Upload
others
View
10
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Tissue Sampling & Analysis PlanTechnical Memorandum on Bioaccumulation ModelingSummary and Discussion
Jennifer Sampson
June 25, 2010
008355
Discussion Overview
• Tissue Sampling and Analysis Plan
— Objectives of tissue sampling
— Design and rationale
• Technical Memorandum on Bioaccumulation Modeling
— Analysis of area-wide tissue and sediment data
— Literature review
• Goal of this discussion is to assist in your review of these documents
1
008356
Tissue Sampling and Analysis Plan
2
008357
Objectives of Tissue Sampling
• Human and ecological exposure and risk assessment
— Ingestion exposures for consumers of fish and invertebrates
— Exposures as whole body concentrations for fish and invertebrates
• Development of sediment-tissue relationships to support evaluation of remedial alternatives
— Expand existing datasets to:
» Improve statistical power (with higher sample size)
» Characterize relationship at realistic Site exposures
3
008358
Approach to Tissue Sampling
• Gain representation of the range of exposure levels
— Use of “fish collection areas” on the Site, upstream
— Focus on species with small home ranges, close association with sediment
• Expand on existing datasets
— Samples are to be collected as for the TMDL and TDSHS programs
• Address both human health and ecological risk assessment data needs
— E.g., collect both fillet and whole fish tissue
008359
Overview of Sampling Design
• Fish Collection Areas— Three within the preliminary Site perimeter, one at
upstream background
• Human Health Risk Assessment— Crab edible meat (composites, 5 crabs each)
— Catfish fillet (composites, 3 fish each, skin off)
— Clams (composites to required mass, depurated)
• Ecological Risk Assessment— Clams (Rangia cuneata)
— Whole small fish (Gulf killifish)
— Whole large fish (blue catfish)5
008360
Tissue Design Summary
Number of Tissue
Collection AreasNumber of Samples Analyzed per Area
Total Number of Samples
Within preliminary Site perimeterCatfish Fillet 3 10 30Whole Catfish 3 3 - 4 10Edible Crab Tissue 3 10 30Small Fish 5 2 10Mollusc 5 5 25
Upstream BackgroundCatfish Fillet 1 10 10Whole Catfish 1 6 6
Edible Crab Tissue 1 10 10Small Fish 2 3 6Mollusc 2 5 10
008361
Tissue Sampling Areas: Within Preliminary Site Perimeter
008362
Tissue Sampling Areas: Upstream Background
008363
Large Fish Collection
• Target species: Blue catfish (300-450 mm)
• Capture methods include set lines, gill nets, hook and line, trawls
• Composite sample consisting of 3 fish
— Fillet (skin on)
— Remainder
• All composites will be single species
• Alternate species are defined in the SAP
008364
Small Fish Collection
• Target Species: Gulf killifish (50-80 mm)
• Capture methods include beach seines, fish traps, cast nets
• Composite sample consisting of 10 fish
— Whole body
• Bycatch will be used if enough killifish aren’t found
008365
Bivalve Collection
• Target species: Common rangia
• Capture methods include benthic sediment grab, benthic sledge, shovel/rake
• Clams will be depurated for 24-48 hours prior to processing
• Composite samples
— Number in composite depends on average wet weight to shell length
— All soft tissue and liquids
008366
Crab Collection
• Target species: Blue crab (125-200 mm)
• Capture methods include: crab traps, trawls
• Composite samples consisting of 3-5 crabs
— Number in composite based average wet weight to shell length
— Muscle tissue only
008367
Example Tissue Processing Area
008368
Sample Log-In Procedures
008369
Species Identification/Confirmation
008370
Length and Weight Measurements
008371
Fish Filleting and Dissection
008372
Upstream as Background
18
008373
Upstream as Background: Summary
• Review USEPA 2002 Guidance on Background
— EPA recognizes anthropogenic & natural background
— EPA articulates the relationship between cleanup goals and background
• Uncertainties and data gaps
• Patterns in sediment and source chemistry
• Conceptual framework for bioaccumulation of dioxins and furans
19
008374
CERCLA Guidance on Background (EPA 2002)
• Background refers to constituents or locations that are not influenced by releases from a site, and are usually described as naturally occurring or anthropogenic.
• Naturally occurring – substances present in the environment in forms that have not been influenced by human activity.
• Anthropogenic – natural and human-made substances present in the environment as a result of human activities (not specifically related to the CERCLA site in question).
20
008375
CERCLA Guidance on Background (EPA 2002)
“The CERCLA program normally does not set cleanup levels below anthropogenic background. The reasons for this approach include cost effectiveness, technical practicability, and the potential for recontamination of remediated areas by surrounding areas with elevated background concentrations. ”
21
008376
Upstream Sediments and Sources
008377
Data Gaps: Upstream Tissue
• Summary statistics for the tissue dataset indicate that more information is necessary
23
008378
Data Gaps Include the Upstream Condition
• Available evidence suggests that sediment transport from the impoundments is limited, including upstream transport
— More analysis of upstream transport are planned
• Other dioxin and furan sources occur upstream and regionally, are of interest to the RI/FS, and should be discussed
• Additional information is needed on both sediment and tissue chemistry before upstream can be disqualified as a useful background area
24
008379
Technical Memorandum on Bioaccumulation
Modeling
25
008380
Bioaccumulation Tech Memo Outline
• Background and Purpose
• Review of Available Modeling Methods
• Analysis of Site-specific Data
• Literature Review
• Conceptual Framework
• Conclusion
26
008381
Available Options
• Overly Complex
— PBPK Models
— Food Web Models
• Overly Simple
— Ratios (BSAF, BAF)
• Empirical, Site-specific (MLR)
27
systems-biology.com
http://fl.biology.usgs.gov/coastaleco/Tech-Rept-Pinnacles-2002/chapter_2/results_and_discussion/MMS_2002_034_54a.gif
MLR
Modeled Tissue Result
Mea
sure
d Ti
ssue
Dat
a
BSAF
LOG Sediment
LOG
Tis
sue
008382
Spatial Extent of Tissue Samples
28
008383
Analysis Presented in the Tech Memo
• Analysis of Site-specific data yielded generally poor correlations between sediment or water and tissue
— Univariate (tau-b) correlation coefficients <0.58
— Multivariate regressions explained <58 percent of the variation in the tissue data set
— Correlations were strongest for 2,3,7,8-TCDD/F
— Water-tissue and sediment-tissue correlations were not found for most congeners
• Simultaneous review of the literature showed similar patterns to those observed in HSC fish and crab
29
008384
Sediment vs. Edible Crab Tissue: tau-b
30
008385
Sediment vs. Edible Crab Tissue: MLR
31
008386
Results of Literature Review
• Literature indicates that bioaccumulation of dioxins and furans is unlike bioaccumulation of other organic chemicals
— Limits on uptake, especially larger congeners
— Ability to metabolize and excrete dioxins and furans
• Organisms take up 2,3,7,8-TCDD/F more readily than other dioxin and furan compounds, but can also metabolize and excrete them
• Uptake of OCDD is limited, possibly only in the gut
• Dioxins and furans exhibit little to no biomagnification
32
008387
At Least Four Metabolic Pathways are Described
33
Hu and Bunce 1999
Example of TCDD Metabolism
008388
Catfish
34
008389
Crab
35
008390
Tokyo Bay
36Naito et al. (2003)
008391
Lake Ontario
37Niimi (1996)
San Jacinto
008392
Memorandum Findings
• Relatively high proportions of 2,3,7,8-TCDD/F can occur in tissue throughout the waterway in the absence of elevated concentrations of these congeners in exposure media (sediment and water)
— A conceptual framework is presented
38
008393
Memorandum Findings
• Statistical regression modeling is the most appropriate tool for linking tissue and sediment chemistry
— Empirically based
— Provides a quantitative measure of uncertainty
— Requires minimal assumptions and ancillary data
• Relationships for existing data have low precision
39
008394
References Cited
Hu, K., and N.J. Bunce, 1999. Metabolism of polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and related dioxin-like compounds. J. Toxicol. Environ. Health, Part B 2(2):183–210.
Naito, W., J. Jin, Y-S. Kang, M. Yamamuro, S. Masunaga, and J. Nakanishi, 2003. Dynamics of PCDDs/DFs and coplanar-PCBs in an aquatic food chain of Tokyo Bay. Chemosphere 53:347–362.
Niimi, A.J., 1996. Evaluation of PCBs and PCDD/Fs retention by aquatic organisms. Sci. Tot. Environ. 192:123-150.
40
008395