Tisplan Questionnaire Analysis of Results · Tisplan Questionnaire Analysis of Results The TisPlan questionnaire was distributed personally by a team of community volunteers to every

JanetAmos,March2016 1

Tisplan Questionnaire Analysis of Results The TisPlan questionnaire was distributed personally by a team of community volunteers to every household in the Neighbourhood Area of Tisbury and West Tisbury during October 2015.

This was a successful consultation generating a good evidence base for future Neighbourhood Planning decision-making. Although the printing costs were relatively expensive compared with an online survey and the door-to-door collection was time consuming, nevertheless it was clearly the right decision in terms of the methodology adopted. Questionnaire feedback re the age of respondents and the stated requirement for IT and computing courses, indicates that an on-line questionnaire most probably would not have realised such a positive and significant response rate.

There were 671 responses which represented a 47% response rate and statistically is a sufficient response for valid findings.

Over one third of the respondents provided comments and feedback. Again this is statistically significant and indicative of an extremely engaged, informed and interested community with strong opinions. There are clear mandates for action and decision-making. There is an expectation that the information will be shared with those who can influence outcomes. It is important that the NP Steering Group and the Parish councils show how these responses have influenced thinking and future decision making: eg

• The importance of the availability of parking • The lack of interest in the provision of cycle racks and facilities for the use of bicycles • The importance of housing design which should not be left to developers to dictate to the

community

Some elements of the questionnaire generated a huge weight of opinion from the community which will provide good evidence for the development of plan policies and objectives.

NB All reference to ‘Tisbury’ in the following text is shorthand for ‘Tisbury and West Tisbury Neighbourhood Plan Area.’


Results of the questionnaire

Question 1 Numbers of residents per household by age group

101 97

148

182

358368

108

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

Ages0-11 Ages12-18 Ages19-35 Ages36-50 Ages51-65 Ages66-80�Ages81+

Totalnum

berrepo

rted

ineachcategory-Allho

useh

olds

Q1-Howmanypeopleliveinyourhouseholdperagegroup?


Question 2. Length of Residency

Lessthan1year;5%

1-5years;19%

6-10years;14%

11-24years;23%

25+years;39%

Q2 How long have you lived in the Neighbourhood Area?


Question 3. Why do people live in Tisbury and West Tisbury?

Question 4. Future needs for types of housing accommodation

320

242

309 320

126 125

92

173143

60

221

38 37

117

44

85

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

Num

ber o

f res

pons

es

Q3 What brought you to live here?

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

Lowcoststarterhom

e

Shared

owne

rship

Affo

rdablere

nted

-ho

using

Affo

rdablere

nted

-bu

sine

ss

Busine

ss/Com

mercialspace

ReOrem

enta

ccom

mod

aOon

-inde

pend

ent

ReOrem

enta

ccom

mod

aOon

-assisted

living

Smalleraccommod

aOon

Largeraccom

mod

aOon

Manufacturingspace/w

orksho

p

Q4Likelyaccommoda@onrequirementsby2026

Ranking5-verylikely

Ranking4

Ranking3

Ranking2

Ranking1-notatalllikely


16%

8%

17%

3%4%17%

13%

13%

6% 3%

Q4Likelyaccommoda@onrequirementsby2026AnalysisofRank5-verylikely Lowcoststarterhome

Sharedownership

Affordablerented-housing

Affordablerented-business

Business/Commercialspace

ReOrementaccommodaOon-independent

ReOrementaccommodaOon-assistedliving

SmalleraccommodaOon

LargeraccommodaOon

Manufacturingspace/workshop


Question 5. Where should new homes be built by 2026?

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Onbrownfieldsites

Inthehamlets Convertexis@ngcommercial

Ongreenfieldsites Plotsoflandbetweenexis@ng

buildings

Convertredundantagriculturalbuildings

Whereshouldnewhomesbebuiltby2026?

Ranking5-mostpreferred

Ranking4

Ranking3

Ranking2

Ranking1-leastpreferred

50%

5%

13%

2%

11%

19%

Q5Whereshouldnewhomesbebuiltby2026?Ranking5-Mostpreferred

Onbrownfieldsites

Inthehamlets

Convertexis@ngcommercial

Ongreenfieldsites

Plotsoflandbetweenexis@ngbuildings

Convertredundantagriculturalbuildings


Question 6. There are 5 known Brownfield Sites – how would you like to see these sites used if they come forward for re-development?

19%

14%

19%14%

10%

3%

6%

6%

1%0%0%

0%0%0%

2%

1%

0%

1% 0%0%0%0%0%0%

3%

Q6UseofSta@onWorks Housing

Commercial

Parking

Mixed

Affordable

Elderlycare

Employment

Noanswer

Bridgeovertrack

Starterhomes

Tunnel

College

Supermarket

Industrial

SecondplaVorm

Flats

Allotments

Retail

Unsuitable

Wildlife

Community

Childcare

Youthclub

Medical/Clinic

Anything


27%

7%

14%

6%

14%

12%

4%

9%

0%0% 0%0%

0%

0%0%

1%0%

1%

1%0%

3%

0%0%

0%0%

Q6OldMagistrates'Court Housing

Commercial

Parking

Mixed

Affordable

Elderlycare

Employment

Noanswer

Bridgeovertrack

Starterhomes

Tunnel

College

Supermarket

Industrial

SecondplaVorm

Flats

Allotments

Retail

Unsuitable

Wildlife

Community

Childcare

Youthclub

Medical/Clinic

Anything

32%

3%

14%6%

14%

13%

1%6%

0%0%0%0%0%0%0%1%

0% 1%

6%

1% 2%0%0%0%0%Q6LandadjacenttoTrellisHouse Housing

Commercial

Parking

Mixed

Affordable

Elderlycare

Employment

Noanswer

Bridgeovertrack

Starterhomes

Tunnel

College

Supermarket

Industrial

SecondplaVorm

Flats

Allotments

Retail

Unsuitable

Wildlife

Community

Childcare

Youthclub

Medical/Clinic

Anything


49%

9%2%

10%

13%

2% 3%

5%

0%0%0%

0%

0%

0%

0% 0%0%0%

5%

1% 0%0%0%0%0%

Q6WiltsCouncilhighwaysdepot Housing

Commercial

Parking

Mixed

Affordable

Elderlycare

Employment

Noanswer

Bridgeovertrack

Starterhomes

Tunnel

College

Supermarket

Industrial

SecondplaVorm

Flats

Allotments

Retail

Unsuitable

Wildlife

Community

Childcare

Youthclub

Medical/Clinic

Anything

46%

8%1%

11%

12%

3%

2%3%

0%0%0%0%0%0%0%

0%

0%

0%

8%4%

0%0%0%0%0%

Q6Disusedquarry-Tuckingmill Housing

Commercial

Parking

Mixed

Affordable

Elderlycare

Employment

Noanswer

Bridgeovertrack

Starterhomes

Tunnel

College

Supermarket

Industrial

SecondplaVorm

Flats

Allotments

Retail

Unsuitable

Wildlife

Community

Childcare

Youthclub

Medical/Clinic

Anything


Q7 and Q8 Significant ‘Green’ Spaces in the neighbourhood area.

Question 9 Greenfield sites that have already been proposed as potential development sites – are you in favour of the development of these sites for housing?

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

Q7Howimportantisitthattheseareasareprotectedfromdetrimentaldevelopment?

Ranking5-VeryimportantRanking4

Ranking3

Ranking2

Ranking1-leastimportant

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

350

400

NorthofVicarageRoad

Tuckingstones SouthoftheAvenue

ChurchillEstate Tuckingfold,HindonLane

Q9AreyouinfavourofthedevelopmentoftheseGreenfieldsitesforhousing? Ranking5-

Stronglyinfavour

Ranking4

Ranking3

Ranking2

Ranking1-Stronglyagainst


12%

8%

18%

8%

54%

NorthofVicarageRoad

Ranking5-Stronglyinfavour

Ranking4

Ranking3

Ranking2

Ranking1-Stronglyagainst

13%

7%

13%

6%

61%

SouthoftheAvenue

20%

13%

29%

7%

31%

Tuckingstones

19%

13%

23%8%

37%

Tuckingfold,HindonLane17%

10%

22%8%

43%

ChurchillEstate


Question10 Is there anywhere else in the neighbourhood area where development would be appropriate?

This was a free-form question inviting respondents to put forward any other sites which had not yet been proposed. The results have not yet been fully analysed, but several small sites have been proposed for consideration.


Question 11 How important is it that the parish councils should be consulted

re planning issues?

82%

10%

6%

0%2%

Howimportantisitthatparishcouncilsareconsultedinformallybeforeplanningapplica@onsaresubmibed?

Ranking5-Veryimportant

Ranking4

Ranking3

Ranking2

Ranking1-Notatallimportant


Question12 Design of new buildings and their preferred features

21%

3%

3%

17%

21%

1%

8%

8%

11%

7%

Whatlook/featuresshouldnewbuildingshave?Ranking5-mostimportant

InkeepingwithnearbybuildingsSpaceforworkingfromhomeInnova@vedesigns

FeaturestoreduceenergycostsParkingspace

Lectodeveloper

Recrea@onareaforchildrenWalkingdistancetoshops/ameni@esOutsidespace

Garage


Question13. What is the occupation of the household’s main earner?

Question14. How far away from home does the main earner work?

11213 8 10 9 14 2

1121622

2 7 3

49

6 2

158

1 119

231

217

1211511

10

50

100

150

200

250

Agr

icul

ture

A

rchi

tect

A

rt &

cra

ft Av

iatio

n C

ivil

Ser

vice

C

leric

al

Con

stru

ctio

n C

ounc

il E

ngin

eerin

g E

stat

e Fi

nanc

e H

ealth

care

In

sura

nce

Jour

nalis

m/

Pub

lishi

ng

Lega

l M

anag

emen

t M

ilita

ry

Mus

ic

Not

giv

en

Par

t-tim

e R

elig

ion

Ret

ail

Ret

ired

Sci

ence

S

elf-

Stu

dent

Te

achi

ng

Tech

nolo

gy

Tran

spor

t U

nem

ploy

ed

Num

ber o

f Res

pons

es

What is the occupation of the main earner?

24%

15%

30%

31%

Howfarfromhomedoesthemainearnerwork?

Athome

<5miles

6-20miles

>20miles


Question 15. Modes of travel to work

Question16. What would persuade respondents to use alternative forms of transport?

10%

3%1%

55%

4%

23%

2%2%

Howdoesthemainearnertraveltowork?

Walk

Cycle

Motorbike

Car/Van

Carshare

Train

Bus

Other

6%

14%

31%

8%

10%

31%

Whatwouldpersuadeyoutomakemoreuseofalterna@veformsoftransport?

Ranking5-Mostlikely

Vehiclesharingschemes

Improvedfootpaths

Improvedcoordina@onofbuses/trains

Provisionofmorecycleracks

Electriccarchargingpoints

LatertrainsfromSal/Ldn


Questions 17, 19a & 20 Future job opportunities, local skills base and training

4%9%

14%

4%

5%

7%

4%5%2%5%

6%

4%

4%

3%

9%

4%

9%

Whatfuturejobopportuni@eswouldberelevanttoyou?Ranking5-Mostpreferred Agriculturalworking

Training,educaOon,skills,apprenOceshipsHealthandmedicalservicesLeisureindustry

Hospitality

Internet

Manufacturing

Professionalservices

Self-employment

HorOcultural

RuraltradesandcraYs

Sport-related

Music/performingarts

TouristaccommodaOon

Caringservices

Buildingtrades

Retail


0

20

40

60

80

100

120

Num

ber o

f res

pons

es

Q 19a What courses would you like to attend / see provided at the new Campus?


Questions18 and 19 Business and Commercial requirements

6%3%

6%

25%60%

Q19Business/CommercialPremisesRanking5-Verylikely/important

Requirenewbusinesspremises

MakeuseofbusinessincubaOon

OffernewjobsinTisbury

ProximitytorailwaystaOon

Availabilityofhighspeedbroadband


Question 21 Community Priorities for the use of CIL (Community Infrastructure Levy) monies

1%1% 5%4%

13%

6%

6%

3%1%

6%4%9%

6%

8%

3%

9%

7%

8%

WhatprojectsshouldCILmoniesfund?Ranking5-Mostimportant

Communitybicyclescheme

Morecycleracks

Communitytransport

Improveflooddefences

Provisionoffreecarparking

EnergyefficiencyforcommunitybuildingsRenewableenergyini@a@ves

PicnicsitesbyRiverNadder

Touristinforma@oncentre

GrantsforimprovementstocommunitybuildingsEnhancelocalstreetenvironmentConserveandmanagegreenspacesImproveplayparksandrecrea@ongroundsFurtherimprovementstoswimmingpoolPurchaseland/propertyforcommunityinvestmentSupportfacili@esforlocalcommunitygroupsCon@nuedprovisionofpublicconveniencesImprovefootpathsandrightsofway

Documents

Tisplan Questionnaire Analysis of Results · Tisplan Questionnaire Analysis of Results The TisPlan questionnaire was distributed personally by a team of community volunteers to every