25
2015 Alaska RTI Conference Targeted Interventions for Students at Risk Howard S. Muscott, Ed.D, Director New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Supports Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for your am routines by completing the routines, expectations, and scoring on the blank card provided. (5 minutes) Share: Activity 2: Identify one routine from your TCCE card. Think up a scenario where one of your students has earned yellow circle for mostly positive behaviors with some need for reminders. Write down your feedback to the child. (5 minutes) Think: Share: Activity 3: Think of a young child you know who has exhibited challenging behavior. Describe the behavior. Complete a routine analysis. (5 minutes) Think: Behavior Share: Behavior Activity 4: Describe the desired behavior and desired consequences. (5 minutes) Think: Share: Activity 5 (if time permits): Using the planning sheet, identify ideas for a behavior plan in all three categories (antecedents, teaching, consequences) (15 minutes) Think: Antecedents Teaching: Consequences Share: Antecedents Teaching: Consequences 1

Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

  • Upload
    vananh

  • View
    224

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

 2015  Alaska  RTI  Conference  

Targeted Interventions for Students at Risk Howard S. Muscott, Ed.D, Director

New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Supports

Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for your am routines by completing the routines, expectations, and scoring on the blank card provided. (5 minutes) Share: Activity 2: Identify one routine from your TCCE card. Think up a scenario where one of your students has earned yellow circle for mostly positive behaviors with some need for reminders. Write down your feedback to the child. (5 minutes) Think:

Share:

Activity 3: Think of a young child you know who has exhibited challenging behavior. Describe the behavior. Complete a routine analysis. (5 minutes) Think: Behavior

Share: Behavior

Activity 4: Describe the desired behavior and desired consequences. (5 minutes) Think:

Share:

Activity 5 (if time permits): Using the planning sheet, identify ideas for a behavior plan in all three categories (antecedents, teaching, consequences) (15 minutes) Think: Antecedents Teaching: Consequences

Share: Antecedents Teaching: Consequences

1

Page 2: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Support (NH CEBIS) Basic Behavior Support Plan Worksheet for 2015 RTI Conference

Muscott (2014)

1

Student:__________________________________ Program: _______ Class: ______________ Completed by: _____________________________________________________ Date: ______

Features Skill Set Write In Response Describe the Problem Using a Behavior Pathway Identify Desired Behaviors and Student Strengths

1. Define problem behavior in observable and measurable terms. Include frequency or rate.

2. Identify immediate triggering antecedent.

3. Identify the consequences that occur after the problem behavior.

4. Determine if the problem behavior occurs in one or more routines.

Routine 1:

Routine 2:

5. Identify desired behavior for the problem behavior for each problem routine.

Routine 1:

Routine 2:

6. Identify student strengths and interests to inform reinforcement and behavior plan strategies.

2

Page 3: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Support (NH CEBIS) Basic Behavior Support Plan Worksheet for 2015 RTI Conference

Muscott (2014)

2

Feature Skill Set Write In Response

Identify Strategies For Behavior Support Plan (BSP) Develop a Plan to Monitor Progress Develop a Detailed Action Plan to Implement the Plan with Fidelity

7. Identify simple strategies/intervention that will be used to teach student skills the desired skills.

8. Identify what staff will do when the student exhibits the expected behavior(s) to strengthen them. Consider reinforcement strategies that include student’s strengths and interests.

9. Identify what staff will do when the student exhibits the problem behavior(s) to reduce the likelihood the problem behavior will reoccur.

10. Develop specific criteria for success for increasing the desired behaviors and/or decreasing the problem behaviors.

11. Develop a data collection procedure to monitor progress. Include a schedule for assessing progress.

12. Identify who will do what by when.

13. Identify how the plan will be shared with other members of the team, staff and family.

14. Identify any training necessary to support fidelity of implementation.

Adapted from Sugai, (2002) and Sugai, G, Lewis-Palmer, T, & Hagan-Burke, S. (1999-2000). Overview of the functional behavioral assessment process. Exceptionality, 8(3), 149-160.

3

Page 4: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

 

 

 

 

 

Dear  Parents  and  Guardians,  

We  are  introducing  a  new  component  to  the  Black  Bear  Tracks  program  to  help  children  with  behavior.    The  new  technique  is  called  ‘Teacher  Check,  Connect  and  Expect’  (TCCE).    TCCE  is  an  early  response  for  children  not  responding  to  the  Black  Bear  Tracks  program.    TCCE  is  offered  to  provide  extra  help  to  children  who  need  more  support  with  behavior.        TCCE  is  a  procedure  in  which  classroom  teachers  provide  higher  rates  of  positive  feedback,  attention  and  encouragement  by:  greeting  children  at  the  beginning  of  the  day,  “touching-­‐  base”  at  designated  points  during  the  day,  and  working  with  children  to  rate  their  behavior  (‘great  job’,  or  ‘try  again’)  on  a  chart.        The  teacher  will  review  the  chart  with  the  parents/guardian  and  child  at  the  end  of  each  day  and  the  chart  will  be  sent  home.    Parents  can  help  by  providing  children  with  acknowledgement  when  they  have  had  a  good  day  (“I’m  so  proud  of  you!”)  and  providing  extra  encouragement  if  they’ve  had  a  difficult  day  (  “Today  was  hard  for  you,  I  know  you  can  do  better  tomorrow,  everyone  makes  mistakes  sometimes”).        

 

Below  is  an  example  of  the  TCCE  chart.  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

If  you  have  any  questions,  please  talk  with  a  member  of  administration.  

4

Page 5: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

 

Pomerleau, T. M. & Muscott, H.S. (2011). Functional Assessment Checklist for Teachers and Staff in Early Childhood Education Programs - New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Supports at SERESC. Muscott, H.S., & Pomerleau, T. (2008). Behavior Incident Reporting System-NH (BIRS-NH) - New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Supports at SERESC.

 

Routine Analysis of Challenging Behavior in Early Childhood

Adapted from OSEP Technical Assistance Center on PBIS Pomerleau & Muscott (2011)

New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions & Supports at SERESC

Page 1 of 1

updated - 10-26-11

 

 

   

Directions:  List  the  times  and  activities/routines  of  the  child’s  daily  classroom  schedule.  For  each  activity/routine,  circle  the  number  corresponding  to  the  likelihood  that  any  challenging  behaviors  may  occur.  A  score  of  "1"  indicates  low  likelihood  and  a  score  of  "6"  indicates  high  likelihood  that  any  challenging  behaviors  may  occur.  Identify  which  specific  behavior(s)  are  most  likely  to  occur  for  any  rating  of  4,  5  or  6.    A  list  of  common  challenging  behaviors  in  early  childhood  is  found  on  the  back  of  this  form.  

Child's  Name:     Date:     Age:      

Completed  by:     Preschool/Program  Name  :        

Time Activity/Routine Likelihood of Challenging

Behavior Challenging Behavior

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

Low High

1 2 3 4 5 6

5

Page 6: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

 

Pomerleau, T. M. & Muscott, H.S. (2011). Functional Assessment Checklist for Teachers and Staff in Early Childhood Education Programs - New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Supports at SERESC. Muscott, H.S., & Pomerleau, T. (2008). Behavior Incident Reporting System-NH (BIRS-NH) - New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Supports at SERESC.  

Page 1 of 1

updated - 10-26-11

A Project of SERESC  

Challenging Behavior Definitions for Program-wide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports

in Early Childhood Education Programs  

1. Physical  Aggression  –  forceful  physical  actions  directed  towards  adults  or  peers  that  may  result  in  physical  contact  and  injury  (e.g.,  hitting,  kicking,  spitting,  pinching,  and  throwing  objects).        

2. Self-­‐injury  –  physical  actions  directed  towards  oneself,  which  may  result  in  visible  injury  (e.g.,  hitting,  kicking,  scratching,  pinching  oneself).  

 3. Disruption/Tantrum  –  an  outburst  or  action  that  prevents  learning  or  interferes  with  teaching  and  persists  

despite  an  adult’s  request  to  stop  or  attempt  to  provide  support.    4. Inappropriate  Language  –  the  repeated  use  of  words  or  phrases  that  are  typically  unexpected  for  the  

child’s  developmental  age  or  level  (e.g.,  swearing,  profanity,  sexually  explicit)  despite  the  request  of  an  adult  to  stop.    

5. Verbal  Aggression  –  the  use  of  threatening,  offensive  or  intimidating  words  directed  towards  a  peer  or  adult  (e.g.,  screaming,  name-­‐calling,  swearing,  profanity,  threats).      

6. Non-­‐compliance  –  refusal  to  follow  a  reasonable  request,  direction  or  the  established  routine,  which  persists  after  multiple  requests  and  a  reasonable  amount  of  time.    

7. Social  Withdrawal/Isolation  –  non-­‐participation  in  class  activities  or  withdrawal  from  play  or  social  interactions  with  peers  or  adults  that  interferes  with  the  child’s  ability  to  learn  and  interact  with  others  which  is  outside  the  typical  range  of  temperament.      

8. Running  Away  –  the  act  of  leaving  a  designated  area  of  supervision/boundary  of  play  without  permission  and  without  responding  to  the  requests  of  an  adult  to  return.      

9. Property  Damage  –  purposeful  actions  directed  towards  items  or  property  that  may  have  destructive  results  (e.g.,  ripping  of  books,  knocking  over  shelves,  throwing  chairs).    

10.  Unsafe  Behaviors  –  physical  actions  which  may  directly  or  indirectly  result  in  physical  injury  to  self  or  others  that  (a)  persists  despite  an  adult’s  request  to  stop  and  (b)  are  unexpected  based  on  the  developmental  age  and/or  level  of  the  child  (e.g.,  climbing  on  furniture,  running  into  people  or  things,  inappropriate  use  of  materials).  

6

Page 7: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

1

The Functional Assessment Checklist for Early Childhood Education Programs (FACTS-ECE) is an efficient interview process designed to be used by early childhood professionals in developing positive behavior support plans for young children in need of secondary or tertiary level supports. The FACTS-ECE was adapted specifically for early childhood from the Functional Assessment Checklist for Teachers and Staff and the Functional Assessment Interview Form1. The FACTS-ECE is intended to be an efficient strategy for conducting an initial functional behavioral assessment (FBA) and is used to either develop behavior support plans, or guide more comprehensive functional assessment efforts. The checklist provides a guided format for interviewing the caregivers who know the child best (family, teachers, staff, clinicians, etc). The FACTS-ECE can be completed in a short amount of time (5-15 min).

Step #1: Complete Demographic Information Indicate the child’s name and age, the date the assessment information was collected, the name of the person completing the form (the interviewer), and the name(s) of the individuals interviewed (respondents). Step #2: Describe the Child’s Strengths and Interests Begin each assessment with a review of the child’s strengths and interests. First, identify at least three strengths the child possesses (i.e., What is (s)he good at? What does (s)he like to do? Examples include puzzles, self-help skills, helping others, sports, computers, verbal communication, etc.). Next, identify at least three strong interests (s)he has (i.e., What would the (s)he choose to do or play on his/her own? Consider activities or items/toys the (s)he prefers most such as playing with blocks, gross motor games, computer games, board games, music, specific television shows or characters of interest, etc.). This information will be used to inform the acknowledgment/reinforcement component of the behavior support plan. Step #3: Identify the Child’s Challenging Behaviors Identify the specific challenging behaviors the child exhibits that are of most concern or occur on a regular basis. Include behaviors that disrupt the classroom environment, interfere with social development, affect peer or teacher relationships or compromise the child’s safety or the safety of others. Examples from the Behavior Incident Reporting System-NH (BIRS-NH)2 include physical aggression, verbal aggression, self-injury, property damage, disruption/tantrum, non-compliance, social withdrawal/isolation, inappropriate language, running away, and unsafe behaviors. Rank the top 2-3. Provide a brief description of exactly how the child engages in these behaviors (i.e., What the child says or does). 1  Crone,  D.  A.,  Lewis-­‐Palmer,  T.  ,  Carr,  E.  G.,  March,  R.,  Horner,  R.  H.,  Brown,  T.,  &  Todd,  A.  W.  (2011).  The  Functional  Assessment  Checklist  for  Teachers  and  Staff  (FACTS).    Center  on  the  Social  and  Emotional  Foundations  for  Early  Learning  (2010).    Functional  Assessment  Interview  Form  –  Young  Child,  Vanderbilt  University.   2 Muscott, H.S., & Pomerleau, T. (2008). Behavior Incident Reporting System-NH (BIRS-NH). New Hampshire Center for Effective Behavioral Interventions and Supports at SERESC.

How  to  Complete  the  FACTS  –  ECE,  Part  A  

 

Functional  Assessment  Checklist  for  Teachers  and  Staff  in    Early  Childhood  Education  Programs  (FACTS-­‐ECE)  

Adapted  by  Pomerleau  &  Muscott  (2011)  New  Hampshire  Center  for  Effective  Behavioral  Interventions  and  Supports  at  SERESC  

7

Page 8: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

2

Step #4: Identify Where, When and With Whom the Child’s Challenging Behaviors are Most Likely to Occur A. Schedule: List the times that define the child’s daily schedule. B. Activity/Routine: For each time listed, indicate the activity/routine that the child is typically engaged in

during that time (e.g., home morning routine, arrival, free play, circle time/large group activity, centers/workshops, outdoor play, transition, clean up, quiet time/nap, etc.)

C. Likelihood of Challenging Behavior: Use the 1 to 6 scale to indicate (in general) which times/activities/routines are most and least likely to be associated with the challenging behavior(s) of concern. A score of "1" indicates low likelihood, and a score of "6" indicates high likelihood that challenging behaviors will occur.

D. Challenging Behavior: Indicate which specific behavior is most likely to occur in any time/activity/routine that is given a rating of 4, 5 or 6.

E. With Whom: Indicate with whom the child displays the challenging behavior during the selected times/activities/routines (e.g., peer, sibling, parent, step-parent, teacher, assistant teacher, paraprofessional, specialist, bus driver, etc.)

Step #5: Select Routines for Further Assessment Examine each time/activity/routine scored as 4, 5 or 6 in the Table from Step #4. Select between 1 and 3 routines for further analysis. Consider activities that have similar characteristics (i.e., unstructured vs. structured; teacher-directed vs. child-directed) and similar challenging behaviors. For each routine identified as problematic in Step #5, complete a FACTS-ECE, Part B (i.e., If you select three routines for further assessment, you will need to complete three FACTS-ECE, Part B forms to correspond with each routine).

Step #1: Complete Demographic Information Write the child’s name and age, the date that the FACTS-ECE, Part B was completed, the name of the person completing the form (the interviewer), and the name(s) of the individuals interviewed (respondents). Step #2: Identify the Routine(s) for Further Assessment List the routine and challenging behavior(s) identified for further assessment from the final page of the FACTS-ECE, Part A. The FACTS-ECE, Part B collects information about ONE routine only. Use multiple Part B forms if multiple routines are identified. Step #3: Provide Specifics about the Challenging Behavior(s) within the Identified Routine Provide more details about the characteristics of the challenging behavior(s). Specifically describe what the child is likely to say or do when exhibiting the behavior(s), how often it occurs per day, week, or month, how long it lasts when it occurs, and the level of danger or intensity when it occurs (low, moderate, high). Step #4: Identify Events that May Predict the Occurrence of the Challenging Behavior(s) Within each routine identify what related factors such as (a) distant setting events, and (b) immediate antecedents (preceding events) are likely to predict when the challenging behavior(s) will occur. What would you do to make the problem behavior(s) happen in this routine?

How  to  Complete  the  FACTS  –  ECE,  Part  B  

8

Page 9: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

3

Step #5: Indicate What Strategies have been Tried to Prevent/Control the Challenging Behavior(s) In most cases, early childhood staff will have tried some strategies already. List the responses that have been tried, and organize these by (a) attempted strategies to prevent the challenging behavior, (b) attempted consequences to respond to the challenging behavior (or reward alternative behaviors).

Step #6: Identify the Maintaining Consequence and Likely Function of the Challenging Behavior(s) What consequences appear to maintain the challenging behavior? Consider that the child may be trying to get/obtain something they want, or that they may be trying to escape/avoid something they find unpleasant. Identify the most powerful maintaining consequence with a "1", and other possible functions with a "2" or "3." Do not check more than three options. Focus on the consequence that has the greatest impact. Step #7: Build a Behavior Pathway and Summary Statement The behavior pathway and summary statement identify the distant setting events, immediate antecedents (triggers), challenging behaviors, and maintaining consequences. The summary statement is the foundation for building an effective behavior support plan. Build the summary statement from the information in the FACTS-ECE, Part A and FACTS-ECE, Part B (Especially the information in Steps #3, #4, #5 and #6 of the FACTS-ECE, Part B). Step #8: Determine “Level of Confidence” Use the 1-6 scale to define the extent to which the interviewer or the team feels "confident" that the summary statement is accurate. Confidence may be affected by factors such as (a) how often the challenging behavior occurs, (b) how long you have known the child, (c) how consistent the challenging behaviors are, (d) if multiple functions are identified, and (e) if multiple behaviors occur together. If you are confident that the summary statement is accurate enough to design a plan (e.g., a rating of 4, 5 or 6), then start plan development. If you are less confident (e.g., a rating of 1, 2 or 3), then continue the functional behavior assessment by conducting direct observations and collecting more data.

9

Page 10: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

4

Child  Name:  __________________________________    Child’s  Age:  ____Years  ___Months    Interviewer:  ___________________________________   Date  of  Interview:  _______________                    Respondent(s):  __________________________________________________________________      Identify  at  least  3  strengths  and  3  strong  interests  of  the  child:  

Strengths   Interests                Identify  and  rank  the  challenging  behavior(s)  of  most  concern:                        Identify  Where,  When  and  with  Whom  Challenging  Behaviors  are  Most  Likely:  Time   Activity/Routine   Likelihood  

Low                                                        High  Challenging  Behavior(s)   With  Whom?  

       

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

     

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

     

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

     

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

     

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

     

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

     

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

     

   1            2            3            4            5            6  

   

Functional  Assessment  Checklist  for  Teachers  and  Staff  in    Early  Childhood  Education  Programs  (FACTS-­‐ECE,  Part  A)  

Adapted  by  Pomerleau  &  Muscott  (2011)  New  Hampshire  Center  for  Effective  Behavioral  Interventions  and  Supports  at  SERESC  

 

_____Physical Aggression _____Verbal Aggression _____Running away _____Self-injury _____Non-compliance _____Property damage _____Disruption/Tantrum _____Withdrawal _____Inappropriate Language _____Unsafe Behaviors _____Other Describe Challenging Behavior(s): ____________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________________________________________

Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Step 4

10

Page 11: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

5

Select  1-­‐3  routines  for  further  assessment.  Complete  the  FACTS-­‐ECE,  Part  B,  for  EACH  routine  identified  below.  

Routines  Identified  for  Further  Assessment  1.      2.      3.                                                                            

Step 5

11

Page 12: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

6

       Child  Name:  __________________________________    Child’s  Age:  ____Years  ___Months    Interviewer:  ___________________________________   Date  of  Interview:  _______________                    Respondent(s):  __________________________________________________________________      Which  Routine  (pick  1)  from  the  FACTS-­‐ECE,  Part  A  is  being  assessed?  Total  routines:    1      2      3  

Routine/Activity/Context   Challenging  Behavior(s)  

   

 

Fill  in  the  following  details  about  the  challenging  behavior(s)  within  the  identified  routine:     Behavior  

Example:  Withdrawal  

What  the  Child  Says/Does  hides  under  table  in  fetal  position;  refuses  to  speak  or  comply    

How  Often?  2-­‐3  x/day  

How  Long?  20-­‐30  mins  

How  Intense?  Moderate  

1.        

       

2.        

       

3.        

       

 What  events  are  likely  to  predict  that  the  challenging  behavior(s)  will  occur?  

Distant  Setting  Events  (“Slow  Triggers”)   Immediate  Antecedents  (“Fast  Triggers”)  ____Illness                                                              ____Hunger                                      ____Lack  of  sleep                                        ____Medications  ____Home  situation                                  ____Attention  span            ____Lack  of  interest                                ____Sensory  sensitivities                      (boredom)                                            ____High  energy  level                                                              ____Task  too  difficult                          ____Task  too  easy                                                                                                          

____Reprimand/correction              ____Teased  by  peers  ____Structured  activities                    ____Staff    directive  ____Unstructured  times                      ____Transitions                ____Ending  preferred                              ____Task  demand                    activity                                                            ____Length  of  task  ____Change  in  routine                            ____Un-­‐preferred  activity  

Other:   Other:      What  efforts  have  been  used  to  address  the  challenging  behavior(s)  to  date?  

Prevention  Strategies   Response/Consequence  Strategies  ____Schedule  change                                                        ____Pre-­‐corrections  ____Visual  schedule                                                            ____Modify  activities  ____  Visual  directions                                                      ____Teach  new  skill  ____Offer  choices                                                                    ____Designate  seating    ____Reminders                                                                            ____  Warnings/Pre-­‐alerts      ____Increased  attention                                                ____Increased  help  ____Practice  desired  skill/behavior  

____Remove  from  area                                          ____Reprimand  ____Remove  from  activity                              ____Hold/restrain    ____Physical  guidance                                            ____Take  break  ____Loss  of  item/privilege                              ____Thinking  chair  ____Remove  from  classroom                    ____Family  Contact        ____  Extra  rewards  for    positive  behavior  

Other:   Other:  

Functional  Assessment  Checklist  for  Teachers  and  Staff  in    Early  Childhood  Education  Programs  (FACTS-­‐ECE,  Part  B)  

Adapted  by  Pomerleau  &  Muscott  (2011)  New  Hampshire  Center  for  Effective  Behavioral  Interventions  and  Supports  at  SERESC  

Step 2

Step 1

Step 3

Step 4

Step 5

12

Page 13: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

7

What  appears  to  be  the  most  likely  maintaining  consequence  or  function  of  the  child’s  behavior(s)?    Check  up  to  three;  label  “1”  as  the  most  likely  function  and  other  possibilities  with    “2”  or  “3”  

Things  the  child  may  Get/Obtain   Things  the  child  may  Avoid/Escape  ____Peer  attention                                                                            ____Adult  attention  ____Preferred  activity/task                                              ____Desired  item/toy  ____Sensory  stimulation    

____Peer  attention                                                                        ____Adult  attention  ___Un-­‐preferred  activity/task                              ____Undesired  item/object  ____Sensory  Overload  

 Build  a  behavior  pathway  and  summary  statement  by  completing  the  following  information:      

 

                               _________________________  engages  in  _________________________________________________________________                              (Child’s    Name)                                                                                                                          (Challenging  Behavior)      when  _________________________________________________________________  in  order  to  GET  or  AVOID                                                      (Trigger)                                                                                                                                                              (circle  one)    __________________________________________________________________________.    This  behavior  is  more  likely  to  occur                                          (attention/activities/tangibles/sensory)    when  _________________________________________________________________________________________________                                                                                                                          (context/setting  event)    How  confident  are  you  that  the  Summary  of  Behavior  (above)  is  accurate?    Not  very  confident                   Very  confident                            1                                                2                                              3                                              4                                              5                                                6                                                        

Updated  8/31/2011  

Step 6

Step 7

Function/Maintaining Consequence:

Summary Statement/Hypothesis:

Step 8

Specific Routine/Context:

Setting  Events  “Slow  Triggers”  

Antecedents  “Fast  Triggers”  

Challenging  Behavior  

Consequence  

13

Page 14: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

   

 

   

Teacher:__________________ Classroom:_________________

Name:_____________________ Date:______________________

I earned _______ Green Lights

Tomorrow is a new day. I will try again tomorrow. !  

!

14

Page 15: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

Handout 2.7: Social Emotional Teaching StrategiesModule 2

The Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign csefel.uiuc.edu H 2.7(p. 1/5)

Rev. 5/06

Gail E. Joseph, Ph.D. & Phillip S.Strain, Ph.D.

Center on Evidence Based Practicesfor Early Learning

University of Colorado at Denver

As a result of his teachers’ carefulselection of toys, materials, andplay themes, 3 year old Eduardo

now is able to benefit from his activeparticipation in a full range of freeplay activities. Yet, it is still the casethat without this level of planning andsubsequent, ongoing praise, Eduardowould spend most days playing alonewith a particular Tonka truck. On thisday the truck has been retired fromservice due to a broken and nowdangerous part. Visibly upset,Eduardo begins to whimper as histeacher explains the situation with thetruck and promises to get it replacedsoon. She offers Eduardo other playideas and begins to play with othertrucks herself encouraging him to joinin. The disappointment is toooverwhelming, however, and Eduardojust sits passively, shaking his head,No. His teacher next prompts severalof his usual play partners to, “AskEduardo to help with their building.”When asked, Eduardo screams “No,”stomps over their building project andgets a predicable response from hispeers. The teacher intervenes at thispoint to protect Eduardo, his peersand the ongoing program.

Mattie, a 4 year old in a localHead Start classroom is always thefirst to organize fun play when thewater table comes out each Friday.She often talks with great anticipationand excitement (especially onThursday) about what she is going todo at the water table with her friends.

On this Friday, the water table hasbeen borrowed by the class next doorand is not available. When Mattierealizes that the water table is notavailable she seeks out her teacher forhelp. She does this with a clearexpression of frustration anddisappointment. Her teacher explainswhat happened and asks Mattie todescribe how she is feeling. She saysshe is frustrated. Her teacheracknowledges the legitimacy of herfeelings and asks her if she can thinkof what she and her classmates havepracticed when they feel frustrated.With some prompting, Mattie recallsthe plan—takes three deep breaths,tell yourself to calm down, and thinkof some solutions. Mattie and theteacher generate some options at thispoint, including; a) playing with hernext favorite toy; b) asking her bestfriend what she wants to play; and c)pretending to use the water table. Shechooses b, and has a fun freeplay.

As young children gain a betterunderstanding of emotions, theybecome more capable of emotionalregulation. Controlling anger andimpulse is perhaps the most difficulttask of emotional literacy. In real lifesituations that are upsetting,disappointing and frustrating it is atough undertaking to remain calm.Remaining calm in the presence ofadverse situations is not about thesuppression of emotions, but thedynamic engagement of affective,cognitive and behavioral processes.In order to regulate emotions onemust bring into play the rapid andaccurate recognition of physiologicalarousal, the cognitive processrequired to think, for example, “Ineed to calm down” and, the

behavioral pretense of taking a deepbreath and reacting calmly. Childrenwho learn to cope with their emotionsconstructively not only have an easiertime with disappointments,aggravation, and hurt feelings that areso ubiquitous in the lives ofpreschoolers but they also have aneasier time relating to other childrenand adults at home, in school or childcare, and on the playground (NationalResearch Council and Institutes ofMedicine, 2000).

On the other hand, young childrenwho have failed to master the earlyregulatory tasks of learning tomanage interpersonal conflict andcontrol aggressive and disruptiveimpulses are more likely than theirself-regulated peers to display earlyconduct problems. Children withconduct problems and poor impulsecontrol are more likely to be peer-rejected and do more poorly in schoolthan children who are more capableat emotional regulation and problemsolving (Strain, Kerr, Stagg &Lenkner, 1984). Before children caneffectively manage interpersonalconflict, they need to be able torecognize and regulate their ownemotional responses and stress level.Teachers can play a significant role inhelping children learn to control theiranger and impulses and to handledisappointment in appropriate waysby identifying and intervening withchildren who need extra help indeveloping these competencies.Some teaching strategies includemodeling remaining calm; cognitivebehavioral interventions; preparingchildren for disappointing situationsbefore they occur; recognizing andreinforcing when children remain

Helping Young Children Control Angerand Handle Disappointment

15

Page 16: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

calm; and involving parents and othercare providers.

Model remaining calmTeachers can model how to

manage anger and handledisappointment for young children.For example, a teacher can share withher class how she felt angry whensomeone hit her car in the parking lot– but then she decided that feelingmad wasn’t helping her think of goodsolutions – so she took three deepbreaths and thought about somethingrelaxing and then when she felt calmshe thought of some solutions forfixing her car. In addition to recallingincidents when one felt angry butremained in control – teachers canalso model remaining calm asnaturally occurring disappointing,scary, frustrating and difficultsituations happen throughout the day(e.g., a fire drill; being yelled at;having something break, etc.).

Teach children how to controlanger and impulse

While it may be true that childrenoften hear adults telling them to“calm down,” it is very unlikely thatthis simple direction will result in anychanges in children’s affect orbehavior. In some instances this kindof command may even escalate achild’s angry response. Cognitivebehavioral intervention (CBI)strategies can provide children withthe requisite skills to control angerand handle disappointment. CBIsoffer strategies for teachingappropriate replacement skills toangry outbursts and aggression. CBIsengage a relationship betweeninternal cognitive events andbehavioral change through teachingstrategies that guide performance andreduce inappropriate behaviors.Using CBI, teachers can provideyoung children with strategies to

modify their thoughts and promoteself-regulation. With preschooler,many accidents occur in classrooms(e.g., children bumping into oneanother; children knocking overothers’ constructions) and somechildren interpret these accidents aspurposeful, hostile acts. An essentialingredient of CBI is to help childrenreframe and modify their processes inorder to substitute more neutralinterpretations of others’ behaviors.The “turtle technique” is a CBIstrategy that has been usedsuccessfully with preschool andkindergarten age children (Greenberg,Kusche & Quamma, 1995;Webster-Stratton & Hammond, 1997).

The turtle technique was originallydeveloped to teach adults angermanagement skills then wassuccessfully adapted for school agechildren (Robin, Schneider &Dolnick, 1976; Schenider, 1974).Since then, the turtle technique hasbeen adapted and integrated intosocial skills programs for preschoolers(PATHS, Dinosaur School). The basicsteps of the turtle technique are:

Recognizing that you feel angryThinking “stop”Going into your “shell” and taking

three deep breaths and thinkingcalming, coping thoughts, “It was anaccident. I can calm down and thinkof good solutions. I am a goodproblem solver.”

Coming out of your “shell” whencalm and think of some solutions tothe problem.

Teaching the turtle technique toyoung children can happen at largeand small group times. A turtle puppetis helpful and keeps children engagedduring the lesson. The teacher canbegin by introducing the turtle to theclass. After the children get a chanceto say hello and perhaps give a gentlepet, the teacher shares the turtle’sspecial trick for calming down. The

turtle explains a time he got upset inpreschool (selecting an incidentfamiliar to the children is best). Hedemonstrates how he thinks to himself“STOP,” then goes in his shell andtakes three deep breaths. After hetakes three deep breaths, he thinks tohimself “I can be calm and think ofsome solutions to solve my problem.”When he is calm, he comes out of hisshell and is ready to problem solvepeacefully. The teacher can theninvite the children to practice turtle’ssecret. Children can “go in theirshells” as a group and together takethree deep breaths. Then anindividual child can model the “turtletechnique” in front of the class.Practice small group activities caninclude making paper plate turtleswith moveable heads and arms that“go in their shell.” Children can thenrehearse the steps with the paper plateturtle.

Preparing children to handledisappointment

Teachers can help children byrehearsing some strategies to handledisappointment before a potentiallydisappointing incident occurs. Forexample, Elizabeth knows that somechildren will be disappointed becauseshe can only choose one “helper” tofeed the pet goldfish. Before sheannounces who the helper will be shesays to the class, “Remember, I willonly be able to select one fish feedertoday, and that may make some of youfeel disappointed. What can you do ifyou feel disappointed?” The childrentogether snap their finger and say, “Ohwell, maybe next time.” Elizabethsays, “That is right you can say –‘Maybe next time.’” After she selectsthe fish feeder, she reinforces thechildren who remained calm andhandled their disappointment.Similarly, a teacher can prepare asingle child for a disappointing

Handout 2.7: Social Emotional Teaching StrategiesModule 2

The Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign csefel.uiuc.edu H 2.7(p. 2/5)

Rev. 5/06

16

Page 17: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

situation before it occurs. Elizabethknows that Jordan will be disappointedif someone else is on his favoriteswing on the playground. Before theyleave for outside, she pulls Jordanaside and says, “When we go outside,someone else might be on yourfavorite swing. And you might feeldisappointed. But, what can you do tostay calm?” She supports Jordan toremember his “turtle technique” andhelps him think of some solutions suchas asking for a turn, saying please andfinding something else to do while thechild finishes swinging. For addedsupport, because Jordan may notremember when he is in the moment,Elizabeth gives him a small plasticturtle to hold. The turtle promptsJordan to keep calm and think ofsolutions.

Posting pictures of the turtletechnique (see Box 1 ) can remindchildren of the steps to calming down.These can be posted in several placesaround the room. Visual cues can beparticularly helpful for very youngchildren, children who are easilydistracted, and children withcommunication delays. Strategicallyplaced, the visual cues can serve as:a) a permanent reminder forchildren—that is, children don’t haveto remember the steps of the process,b) an efficient prop for teachers suchthat they can simply point to the nextstep and not disrupt the ongoing classactivity with lengthy dialogue, and, c)a clear, concrete way to communicatewith children the specific behavioralsteps for which they are beingreinforced.

Recognize and comment whenchildren remain calm

There are four key features of areinforcement system that are likelyto help strengthen children’smanagement of frustration and anger.First, it must be recognized thatcontrolling one’s emotions andsubsequent behavior is hard work. Assuch, reinforcement needs to befrequent and powerful. As frequencydepends on the occurrence ofbehavior, teachers need to be equallyvigilant about planning as manyopportunities for practice as possible.Teachers may also find that theirimpact is enhanced when they areespecially vigilant to “catch thosechildren being good” who may needthe most support. A second keyfeature is to provide naturallyoccurring, vicarious reinforcementopportunities. For example, theexchanges that adults have with eachother can be planned to achieve thisaim. For example, Elizabeth mightsay, “Wow, Steven you really stayedcalm when your watch broke. I’mproud of you.”

Third, we recommend thatchildren be provided the opportunitiesfor self-reinforcement.

For example, children can chooseamong several favorite items and theycan forecast at the beginning of theday what they would wish to acquirefor managing anger and frustration.Finally, we recommend keepingreinforcers varied and fun. Box 2outlines some favorite ideas toconsider. This system, whenimplemented with a high degree offidelity, sends a clear message toyoung children that handling angerand impulse in constructive andpeaceful ways is greatly valued.

Handout 2.7: Social Emotional Teaching StrategiesModule 2

The Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign csefel.uiuc.edu H 2.7(p. 3/5)

Box 1. The Turtle Technique

The Turtle Technique

Step 1 Step 2

Step 3 Step 4

Rev. 5/06

17

Page 18: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

communication system in which adaily report card is sent home that: a)highlights how children havesuccessfully negotiated a frustratingsituation and b) suggests ways thatfamily members might furtherrecognize and encourage theseaccomplishments. An example homereport is found in Box 3. In this samespirit of regular communication,teachers may also wish to phone hometo report any extraordinary examplesof positive child behavior. For manyfamilies this can be a most welcomechange from the usual events thatoccasion phone calls from serviceproviders.

For families that are interested inmore directed and purposefulintervention in the home, teachersmight choose to share a video ofthemselves modeling strategies,directly teaching a techniques, andreinforcing children for successfullycalming down. Moreover, teachersshould consider the possibility ofarranging opportunities for families toshare with each other the ways theyhave been able to encourage theirchildren’s self-regulation.

ConclusionEmotional regulation is fostered

not only by the interventions andstrategies described in this article, butalso by the confidence and securitythat a warm, responsive relationshipwith a caregiver provides youngchildren. Trusting relationships allowchildren to cope with emotions that,initially without even a feelingvocabulary to describe them orstrategies to regulate them, can beoverwhelming. Moreover this kind oftrusting relationship, by definition,means that children will be moreattuned, attentive, and responsive asadults model appropriate self-regulation and praise examples thatoccur throughout the day.

Strategies like the turtle techniqueand accompanying teaching supportscan clearly offer children thecognitive and behavioral repertoireneeded to be good managers of theirfeelings—particularly thoseoccasioned by frustrating and anger-provoking circumstances. However,for children to be truly competent inthe regulation of their emotions theyoften need additional teaching aimed

Super Turtle Award: Acertificate is given out at the end ofthe day noting how a childcontrolled their anger and impulse.

“Turtle Power” Necklace: Aplastic turtle on a string is awardedto a child who was able to remainclam in an upsetting situation.

“Turtle Token Jar”: Theteacher has a collection of smallplastic turtle counters (or greenpom-poms). Every time the teachercatches a child remaining calm andhandling disappointment – a turtletoken is placed in a clear jar. Whenthe jar is full the class gets to have aturtle celebration.

“Turtle Stack”: Teachers havea supply of construction paper,turtle cut-outs. Each time a child iscaught remaining calm in anupsetting or disappointing situation,the teacher puts a paper turtle on thewall. This turtle can have thechild’s name on it. The next turtleearned is stacked on top of the first,and so on until the criterion isreached. The class then gets to havea turtle party.

“Turtle Tote”: The teacherselects a child who has done aremarkable job of controlling angerand impulse and sends them homewith a stuffed turtle puppet for theevening. The child can then re-tellhow they used the turtle techniqueto their parents.

Box 2: Fun, Reinforcing Activities

Turtle Technique ReinforcingActivities

Handout 2.7: Social Emotional Teaching StrategiesModule 2

The Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign csefel.uiuc.edu H 2.7(p. 4/5)

Involving parentsGiven that there is great variation

in child rearing practices specific toteaching children how to deal withfrustration and anger, it is essentialfor teachers to establish effectivehome-school collaboration. At aminimum we suggest an ongoing

GOOD BEHAVIOR REPORT CARDEric Young

4/10/02Dear Parent:Today Eric did a great job of handling frustration and notgetting angry when we ran out of his favorite cookies at snack.Instead of getting upset, Eric took three deep breaths and wetalked about other good things to eat.

You can help Eric by:Asking him to explain how he calmed downCommenting on what a great job that wasTelling him that you hope he can do that again

when he is frustrated.

Thank you so much,Mr. Phil

Box 3: Sample letter to parents

Rev. 5/06

18

Page 19: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

at helping them build a strategy forgenerating solutions or alternativebehaviors to troubling events.

REFERENCESGreenberg, M. T., Kusche, C. A.,

Cook, E. T., & Quamma, J. P. (1995).Promoting emotional competence inschool-aged children: The effects ofthe PATHS Curriculum. Developmentand Psychopathology, 7, 117-136.

Kusche, C. A., & Greenberg, M. T.(1994) The PATHS Curriculum.Seattle: Developmental Research andPrograms.

Robin, A., Schneider, M., &Dolnick, M. (1976). The turtletechnique: An extended case study ofself-control in the classroom.Psychology in the Schools, 13, 449-453.

Strain, P. S., Kerr, M. M., Stagg, V.& Lenkner, D. (1984). An empiricaldefinition of elementary schooladjustment. Behavior Modification,8, 311-47.

Schneider, M. (1974). Turtletechnique in the classroom. TeachingExceptional Children, 7, 21-24.

Webster-Stratton, C. (1991). Theteachers and children videotapeseries: Dina dinosaur school. Seattle,WA: The Incredible Years.

Webster-Stratton, C., & Hammond,M. (1997). Treating children withearly-onset conduct problems: Acomparison of child and parenttraining interventions. Journal ofConsulting and Clinical Psychology,65(1), 93-109.

Handout 2.7: Social Emotional Teaching StrategiesModule 2

The Center on the Social and Emotional Foundations for Early Learning University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign csefel.uiuc.edu H 2.7(p. 5/5)

Rev. 5/06

19

Page 20: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

PRESCHOOL BEHAVIOR EDUCATION PROGRAM

Adapting the Behavior Education Program for Preschool Settings

ELIZABETH A. STEED, GEORGIA STATE UNIVERSITY

In the past decade, researchers andinterventionists have applied theprinciples of positive behavior

intervention and supports (PBIS) toearly learning environments, such aspreschool classrooms, childcarecenters, and Head Start. Thetranslation of PBIS to early childhoodclassrooms has evolved so that wenow know much more about howvarious strategies need to be adaptedfor young children and early learningcontexts. For example, we know thatpreschool children benefit fromhaving very simply stated classroomrules, that PBIS efforts with youngchildren should involve collaborationwith families, and that somestrategies, such as the use of tokens orexternal reinforcement, may not fitwithin the developmentallyappropriate practice framework earlychildhood teachers use (Stormont,Covington-Smith, & Lewis, 2007).

Research thus far on program-widePBIS has included the implementationof PBIS in Head Start classrooms,childcare centers, and state-fundedpreschool classrooms. These effortshave focused on implementing Tier 1 oruniversal supports for all children(Benedict, Homer, & Squires, 2007;Stormont et al., 2007) and Tier 3 orindividualized interventions forparticular children who exhibitchallenging behavior (Duda, Dunlap,Fox, Lentini, & Clarke, 2004). Very littlework has yet been done on adaptingsecondary or targeted interventions forpreschool classrooms.

The most researched targetedintervention that is used inschoolwide PBIS is the BehaviorEducation Program (BFP; Crone,Homer, & Hawken, 2004). The BFP isa daily check-in and check-out systemin which students receive extraattention for positive social behaviorthroughout their school day. This

extra attention is intended to preventchallenging or disruptive behaviorfor children who require additionalsupport to be successful in school butwho do not require intensiveindividualized interventions. TheBFP's generality makes itcontinuously available for studentswho need it and possible for teachersto start a student on the BEP quickly,once he or she is referred for theintervention. In addition to itsefficiency, the BEP has a growingresearch base to support its use as atargeted intervention (e.g., Fairbanks,Sugai, Guardino, & Lathrop, 2007;Filter et al., 2007).

The BEP involves several corecomponents, including (a) check inwith an appointed adulf at thebeginning of the school day; (b) apoints sheet (daily progress record)with behavioral expectations and ascoring system; (c) repeated check-inswith teachers throughout the day toreceive points and positive feedback;(d) check out with the appointedadult at the end of the day to tallypoints; (e) reinforcement for goalsmet in the form of activities,privileges, and/or preferred items; (f)family involvement with pointssheets sent home each day to besigned and returned to school thenext day wifh the student; (g)frequent evaluation of BEP data bythe PBIS leadership team to reviewprogress toward behavioral goals;and (h) referral of new students to theBEP using data from office disciplinereferrals (Crone et al., 2004).

There are several aspects of theBEP program that must be adaptedfor it to be effectively andappropriately used in the preschoolclassroom (Hawken & Johnston,2007). First, the numeric scoringsystem on the daily progress recordshould be changed to a simplified

graphic system such as the onesuggested by Hawken and Johnstonusing happy, neutral, and sad faces.Second, feedback typically providedto a student on a BEP that occurs atthe end of each academic period maybe given to young children inbetween each change in classroomroutine (e.g., circle time to snack time)in a preschool classroom. Finally,another suggested change involveseliminating the use of tangiblereinforcement in a typical BEPprogram. Early childhood teachersmay prefer to use reinforcement inthe form of activities and privileges(e.g., walk around the school, lineleader for the bus) instead of tangibleitems when a child has attained her orhis behavioral goals. This change maybe a better fit for teachers who usedevelopmentally appropriate practicein their classrooms.

The following case studyprovides an illustration of how amodified version of the BEP, theThumbs Up program, can be used asa targeted intervention in a preschoolsetting. Following this illustration, wedescribe additional potentialmodifications to the BEP that may beappropriate for early childhoodcontexts. Lastly, we discuss potentialfuture directions for research andpractice in adapting the BEP foryoung children.

Case Study

Gregory is new to the EdgewoodPines Early Chikihood Center. Thecenter has four classrooms total: twothat are half-day and two that arefull-day Head Start programs. Undertheir preschool director's guidance,the center is in its 3rd year ofimplementing program-wide PBIS.Edgewood Pines has program-widerules fhat guide teacher and child

F A E E 2 01 1 3 7

20

Page 21: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

PRESCHOOL BEHAVIOR EDUCATION PROGRAM

behavior, which include "listen toothers," "be a good friend," and "be ateam player." Each classroom has arules poster that includes text andvisual pictures of children acting outthe rules. Preschool teachers reviewthe rules with children during circletime with examples and nonexamples,provide opportunities for the childrento practice the rules, and reinforce therules throughout the day whensituations arise. All of the preschoolteachers also use a teaching matrix tofurther translate the rules into routine-based behavioral expectations (seeFigure 1). Other Tier 1 universalsupports that Edgewood Pinesteachers have implemented includethe use of visual schedules, organizedtransitions, and the use of frequentpositive communication with childrenand their families to developencouraging and collaborativerelationships.

After 2 weeks of observingGregory in the preschool classroom,his teachers, Mr. Hughes and Ms.Valencia, have noticed anddocumented that Gregory engages ininappropriate social behaviors, suchas yelling at other children, takingtheir toys, hiding toys and otherchildren's belongings, and crying.He's had an average of 23 instances ofmisbehavior per day, even with theuniversal supports in place. Mr.Hughes and Ms. Valencia try to dobrief rehearsals of the classroom ruleswith Gregory following each instance,but this is taking too much of theirtime away from class instruction. Theydecide to start Gregory on the Tier 2targeted intervention, the Thumbs Upprogram, which is being used withthree other children at EdgewoodPines.

The Thumbs Up programinvolves six key steps. First, Gregorychecks in with the center director, Ms.Wickham (or "Ms. W"; Step 1). Ms.W gives Gregory a blank Thumbs Upsheet and reviews the rules with him(see Figure 2). She asks Gregoryquestions to ensure that he knowswhat is expected of him in each of hisclassroom routines. Ms. W also

reviews Gregory's goal, which is toget more thumbs up than thumbsdown at the end of the day. Ms. Wasks Gregory if he has his Thumbs Upsheet from the previous day. IfGregory has this in his backpack, theyreview it and discuss how he did andwhat changes he might want to makein his behavior today. Ms. W remindsGregory that he will be able to choosea special activity if he has a thumbs-up day.

Next, Gregory takes his ThumbsUp sheet to his classroom and gives itto Ms. Valencia (Step 2). Ms. Valenciauses a timer on her watch to remindher to check in with Gregory rightbefore each change in routine forapproximately 30 s. When she checksin with Gregory, Ms. Valencia circleseither the thumbs-up or thumbs-down picture for the precedingactivity and gives Gregory verbalfeedback about the specific behaviorshe engaged in (Step 3). If Gregoryreceives a thumbs down, Ms.Valencia also reminds Gregory of thebehavioral expectations. At eachfeedback session, Ms. Valencia alsotells or asks Gregory about theclassroom routine that is coming nextand the expectations for that routine.After the last centers of the day, Ms.Valencia gives Gregory his lastthumbs up or thumbs down. Gregorypacks up his backpack with hisbelongings and goes to Ms. W'soffice. Ms. W reviews Gregory'sThumbs Up sheet with him and hashim count all of the thumbs up andthumbs down that are circled (Step 4).She writes the numbers on Gregory'ssheet and then talks to him aboutwhether or not he had an overallthumbs-up or thumbs-down day.

If the majority of his day waspositive, Gregory picks from a choiceboard of special activities that he doesin the last 10 min of school before hismom or grandmother arrive to pickhim up (Step 5). Possible choices onthe choice board are a nature walkwith Ms. W around the school,getting to help Mr. Gonzalez (hisfavorite staff member) dry and stackthe clean lunch trays, or doing Starfall

on Ms. W's computer. All of theactivities on Gregory's choice boardare easily available and based onGregory's preferences and interests. IfGregory does not earn enoughthumbs up for his special activity, hespends the last 10 min of schoolwriting in his journal, reading alibrary book, or sitting and waiting,which are all neutral (neitherespecially positive or punishing) forGregory. Gregory's Thumbs Up sheetis sent home with Gregory's mom orgrandmother with the reminder forthem to review it and return a signedcopy with Gregory the next day (Step6).

After just 1 'A weeks of Gregorybeing on the Thumbs Up program,his preschool teachers have noticedand documented that Gregory isengaging in more rule-followingbehaviors. His disruptive orinappropriate behaviors havedecreased to just one to two instancesof misbehavior per day and noinstances in the past 3 days. Gregoryis excited each day to check in withMs. W at the beginning and end ofthe school day and enjoys earning hisspecial activities for having thumbs-up days. Gregory's family isappreciative of the extra positiveinput that they are now receiving.The sheet also has been influential forfamily members who have startedreminding and reinforcing Gregoryfor listening to others and being ateam player at home. The use of thistargeted intervention appears to haveincreased specific social behaviors forGregory with limited teacher timeand attention. Three months later,Gregory is maintaining goodclassroom behavior and interactingmore positively with his peers. Ms. Whas faded Gregory's reinforcement toa special activity just on Fridays whenhe has a thumbs-up week. Gregory'steachers still enjoy using the targetedintervention and feel like theyprevented a situation in whichGregory's problem behaviors mayhave escalated, warranting a Tier 3intensive and individualizedintervention.

38 BEYOND BEHAVIOR

21

Page 22: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

PRESCHOOL BEHAVIOR EDUCATION PROGRAM

DÛQ

ILU

gÜJ

Q

H

a.3

ters

/Cle

an

cu

tsid

«S

nack

a>

Cir

cl

i

ters

s m

ival

/<

h i

ow d

irect

ions

o

co

••b

"oIlo

w d

ire

1/)

o

w d

irect

ii

_o-5u_

t / )

0

0 .Ec ^0 p

List

en w

fare

CO

C

ectic

ow

dir

Foi

ler

s

_c

)Otl

It

- 0c0

E"

Rai

se

F

ri en

d

1

0CO00

in p

lay

nic

ely

0

>^- 0u'E

pla

yJo

in

-^sh

are

toy

s

</)c

ke t

uX

5S f

ood

ain

ks t

o m

frie

nds

.(-D

E

Sit

on' n

ic(

in p

lay

0

V

• D

"DC0

inds

0

Kee

p m

yto

ys

E0

to

ysel

l

E

Î

laye

r 1

E

00

to

X

Q.

C0

D

"c0

equi

fni

cel'

Fre

at

0

my

man

rU

seat

e

CL

'u

Par

ti

c

ings

bby

• my

thm

y cu

V

'-'Vi

Pac

k up

my

p

0

"5

Put

my

1

m

back

pack

i-0 >c 0to 0

utb

al

a.

oys

E

an u

p

0u

E

1

FALL 20 1 3 9

22

Page 23: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

PRESCHOOL BEHAVIOR EDUCATION PROGRAM

oo

4 0 B E \' o N I) B E H A V I O R

23

Page 24: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

PRESCHOOL BEHAVIOR EDUCATION PROGRAM

Other Preschool BEP Applications

There are alternative ways thatthe BEP may be modified and used asa targeted intervention in earlychildhood settings. For example, thepreschool program may elect to haveteachers provide feedback andattention at regularly timed intervals(e.g., every hour) rather than betweenchanges in classroom routines. Thisalternative may be easier toimplement, as changes in classroomroutines in early childhood settingscan require significant teacherattention to direct all of the childrenthrough the transition. Providingattention at an alternative, but regulartime, such as at the top of the hourwhen signaled by a watch or timer,may be more manageable forpreschool teachers.

Another potential adaptation tothe BEP program for young childrenmay include the use of graphicimages for the child to color in foreach interval of positive behavior,thereby eliminating the use ofnegative graphic images (e.g., sadface, thumbs down) on the BEP dailyprogress record. One possibility forsuch an approach is a Super Star dailyprogress record, in which the childhas a targeted number of stars that heor she is attempting to earn for theday. When the teacher checks in withthe child at the regularly scheduledfeedback session, the child wouldcolor in the star if she or he engagedin positive behavior. A star would notbe colored in if any inappropriatebehavior was exhibited in that timeperiod. This simplified version inwhich only images that are colored inare counted (as opposed to differentfaces or different thumbs) may beeasier for some young children tounderstand and follow.

Finally, as noted in the case studyat Edgewood Pines, most earlychildhood programs make decisionsregarding PBIS implementation at theclassroom level (i.e., among theclassroom teachers), with guidanceand approval from the preschooldirector. For targeted interventions to

be implemented effectively andefficiently program-wide, a PBISleadership team should beestablished that oversees the use of alllevels (universal, targeted, andindividualized) of PBIS interventionsin the center. This leadership teamwould develop the particularstrategies of the BEP to be used in thepreschool program, train teachers onits use, develop data-based decision-making rules for moving children onand off the BEP program, andmonitor and evaluate behavioral datafor children on the BEP program.

Discussion

The BEP is an efficient targetedintervention that may be adapted andused with young children who wouldbenefit from extra teacher attentionand feedback on their socialbehaviors. The case study presentedhighlights how specific features of theBEP may be adapted for a preschool-aged child and the specificorganizational structure of a preschoolsetting. With creative problem solvingand attention to developmentallyappropriate practice, the BEP is anappropriate Tier 2 intervention thatmay be used within an earlychildhood program's PBIS efforts.

Regarding future research intothe modified BEP, the current paucityof literature on targeted interventionsfor young children warrantsbeginning investigations with a singlecase design (e.g., multiple baselinedesign across children or centers).Whether or not an effective, modifiedversion of the BEP can be applied andused in a preschool program is thefirst research question to evaluate. Itmay then be appropriate to askwhether a modified BEP program,such as the Thumbs Up program,may be appropriate for youngchildren in kindergarten or firstgrade. Further research questions andareas for practical applications of theBEP in preschool include whethercertain adaptations (e.g., use of twoversus three choices for feedback) aremore effective than others, methods

to assess young children'sunderstanding of the BEP, andguidelines (e.g., number of behaviorincidents) for making data-baseddecisions about when young childrenmay benefit from the BEP. Research isclearly needed in this area ofprogram-wide PBIS as the fieldmoves forward with implementationof PBIS in increasing numbers ofearly childhood settings.

REFERENCESBenedict, E. A., Horner, R. H., & Squires, J.

K. (2007). Assessment andimplementation of positive behaviorsupport in preschools. Topics in EarlyChildhood Special Education, 27,174-192.

Crone, D. A., Horner, R. H., & Hawken, L.(2004). Responding to problem behaviorin schools: The Behavior EducationProgram, New York: Guilford Press.

Duda, M. A., Dunlap, G., Fox, L., Lentini,R., & Clarke, S. (2004). Anexperimental evaluation of positivebehavior support Ln a communitypreschool program. Topics in EarlyChildliood Special Education, 24,143-156.

Fairbanks, S., Sugai, G., Guardino, D., &Lathrop, M. (2007). Response tointervention: An evaluation of aclassroom system of behaviorsupport for second grade students.Exceptional Children, 73, 288-310.

Eilter, K., McKenna, M., Benedict, E. A.,Homer, R. H., Todd, A. W., & Watson, J.(2007). Check-in/check-out: A post hocevaluation of an efficient secondarylevel intervention for reducing problembehaviors in schools. Education andTreatment of Children, 30,69-84.

Hawken, L., & Johnston, S. (2007).Preventing severe problem behaviorin young children: The BehaviorEducation Program. Journal of Earlyand Intensive Behavior Intervention, 4,599-613.

Stormont, M., CovLngton-Smith, S., &Lewis, T. J. (2007). Teacherimplementation of precorrection andpraise statements in Head Startclassrooms as a component ofprogram-wide positive behavioralsupport. Journal of BehavioralEducation, 16, 280-290.

F A L L 2 0 1 1 4 1

24

Page 25: Tier 2 Interventions PWPBIS Activity Worksheet HMakrti2015.pbworks.com/f/Sunday-Topic 9 PM-Muscott Handout Packet.… · Activity Worksheet Activity 1: Develop a draft TCCE Card for

Copyright of Beyond Behavior is the property of Council for Children with Behavioral Disorders and its content

may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express

written permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.

25