6
Thesis Topic Criteria A thesis is an idea or theory that is expressed as a design statement, a visual representation for which evidence is gathered and discussed logically. One of the most important concerns in choosing a thesis topic is that the topic speaks to an area of current or future demand. A good thesis topic is a general idea that is in need of development, verification or refutation. Your thesis topic should be of interest to you, your advisor, and the research community. If it is not, it may be difficult to stay motivated or to "sell" the idea. When searching for a topic, remember that your thesis should attempt to solve a real problem and should contain solid theoretical work, as well as good results. It should be both connected to existing research and centered on a meaningful topic. Choose a narrow, well-defined topic that branches out in a new direction. Try not to pick a topic that is too out-there, as it will be hard to generate interest in your thesis. Marketability is subject to change, so don't feel obligated to choose a thesis topic that reflects the latest craze in your field. You want a thesis topic that will hook the attention of others, as well as maintain your own attention. Your thesis topic should relate to what you've been studying and should stand up to scrutiny. Remember, part of giving a thesis is having to defend it later. Thesis topics need to be easily manageable given factors such as your geographic area and the resources and facilities available to you. The size of your thesis topic can be tricky; you want it to be manageable but not so narrow that you will be limited while researching. As you develop your thesis topic, always factor in your interests, strengths, and weaknesses. You should also bear in mind the readers' expectations, as well as the assignment restrictions. Try to develop two or three possible topics in case you encounter a lack of supporting information. You don't have to commit to just one idea at the beginning of the process. You can bring your ideas to us, we will help you determine which one is the most promising. Different Types of Thesis’ In doing your thesis, you’re likely to be taking a practical or a theoretical approach, even though both practical and theoretical considerations are of the utmost importance in social science research.. Any useful practical research you carry out requires a sound theoretical basis, and any theoretical study you do needs to link to what’s happening in the world around you. A theoretical study can be mainly abstract with an emphasis on the philosophical, ethical and cultural considerations of the subject, or your subject can be an applied theoretical study with an emphasis on political, social or economic issues, for example. More practical research studies in social science are usually about exploring issues through surveys, action research, observations, case-studies or a review of existing studies. The type of thesis you end up doing depends on the topic you’re researching. The following table gives a few examples of different ways of approaching a topic just to get you thinking: Examples of Practical and Theoretical Approaches to deciding a Thesis topic Concern Method Type of Study Theory/hypothesis Analysis Non-empirical Strategy Analysis Non-empirical with examples Issue Question people Empirical Type of behaviour Observation Empirical

Thesis Topic Selection Guidelines

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Gidelines

Citation preview

Page 1: Thesis Topic Selection Guidelines

Thesis Topic Criteria

A thesis is an idea or theory that is expressed as a design statement, a visual representation for which evidence is

gathered and discussed logically. One of the most important concerns in choosing a thesis topic is that the topic speaks to

an area of current or future demand. A good thesis topic is a general idea that is in need of development, verification or

refutation. Your thesis topic should be of interest to you, your advisor, and the research community. If it is not, it may be

difficult to stay motivated or to "sell" the idea. When searching for a topic, remember that your thesis should attempt to

solve a real problem and should contain solid theoretical work, as well as good results. It should be both connected to

existing research and centered on a meaningful topic.

Choose a narrow, well-defined topic that branches out in a new direction. Try not to pick a topic that is too out-there, as it

will be hard to generate interest in your thesis. Marketability is subject to change, so don't feel obligated to choose a thesis

topic that reflects the latest craze in your field. You want a thesis topic that will hook the attention of others, as well as

maintain your own attention. Your thesis topic should relate to what you've been studying and should stand up to scrutiny.

Remember, part of giving a thesis is having to defend it later. Thesis topics need to be easily manageable given factors

such as your geographic area and the resources and facilities available to you. The size of your thesis topic can be tricky;

you want it to be manageable but not so narrow that you will be limited while researching.

As you develop your thesis topic, always factor in your interests, strengths, and weaknesses. You should also bear in

mind the readers' expectations, as well as the assignment restrictions. Try to develop two or three possible topics in case

you encounter a lack of supporting information. You don't have to commit to just one idea at the beginning of the process.

You can bring your ideas to us, we will help you determine which one is the most promising.

Different Types of Thesis’

In doing your thesis, you’re likely to be taking a practical or a theoretical approach, even though both practical and

theoretical considerations are of the utmost importance in social science research..

Any useful practical research you carry out requires a sound theoretical basis, and any theoretical study you do needs to

link to what’s happening in the world around you. A theoretical study can be mainly abstract with an emphasis on the

philosophical, ethical and cultural considerations of the subject, or your subject can be an applied theoretical study with an

emphasis on political, social or economic issues, for example.

More practical research studies in social science are usually about exploring issues through surveys, action research,

observations, case-studies or a review of existing studies.

The type of thesis you end up doing depends on the topic you’re researching. The following table gives a few examples of

different ways of approaching a topic just to get you thinking:

Examples of Practical and Theoretical Approaches to deciding a Thesis topic

Concern Method Type of Study

Theory/hypothesis Analysis Non-empirical

Strategy Analysis Non-empirical with examples

Issue Question people Empirical

Type of behaviour Observation Empirical

Page 2: Thesis Topic Selection Guidelines

Empirical thesis Empirical: based on, concerned with, or verifiable by observation or experience rather than theory or pure logic. "they provided considerable empirical evidence to support their argument.”

An empirical thesis involves collecting data. For example, to gather the views of patients at a GP’s surgery, volunteers in a

police service, children in a play centre or translators in a refugee centre, you have to find ways of asking the individuals

involved what they think or review what they’re doing. You can collect your data in many ways: from questionnaires and

observations to interviews and focus groups.

Or, you may prefer to collect your data by taking another approach such as looking at and analysing existing data from

new angles, making useful comparisons or drawing interesting parallels.

Even if the focus of your thesis is on using data, don’t forget that you’re still going to need a sound theoretical basis for

your work.

Non-empirical thesis Non Empirical: Not relying directly on data; theory-driven

Making the choice to do a non-empirical thesis shouldn’t be taken lightly. Sustaining an argument over the length of your

whole thesis is a distinct challenge. If you enjoy spending time in the library, reading, thinking and discussing theory, this

is likely to be the right choice for you.

Key theories in your discipline such as feminism or pragmatism can be the basis of an abstract discussion in your thesis.

Subjects such as sociology have this type of theory at their centre and so it’s perfectly valid, for example, to discuss

aspects of the theory of pragmatism as your thesis topic.

Topic-Generation

It can be very helpful to choose a broad subject area at first. As you read and research that subject area, you will narrow

down toward a thesis topic. We will help you narrow it even further if you run into trouble. Organization is key to the entire

thesis process, so get organized early on to reduce your stress levels. As you search for your thesis topic, use the

different materials such as drawings, pictures, mindmaps, piece of literature, notes and papers, for your reference. You

will also find good reading material at our library, start reading! And don't discount your own knowledge - you have studied

hard through the years and have learned a great deal, so apply all of that!

Begin by brainstorming and doing some free-hand doodling and mindmapping to get your brain moving in the right

direction. At this stage, we believe you shouldn't talk to others about your ideas and research your topics on your own to

determine the potential information available. Make an outline to group your ideas and locate the crux of argument or

problem on which you would like to focus. Even if you are not required to do so, it can be beneficial to write up a short

thesis proposal; it can help you define problems, outline possible solutions, and identify evaluation criteria. You can show

the proposal to us for feedback.

Maintaining a log book or journal can be helpful in tracking your ideas for topics. You can keep notes in the journal as you

research possible topics and write down questions to which you would like to find answers. It is important to have an

awareness of ongoing and directly related research. However, don't spend too much time reading and studying some

topic that you don't feel strongly bout and isn't taking you anywhere. Wise decision-making ability is very important in

Page 3: Thesis Topic Selection Guidelines

thesis, as you should be taking your own decisions if the topic/direction is worth researching and spending your precious

time on or not? You might even consider setting up interviews (in person, by telephone or, less effectively, via e-mail) with

people who have researched and written material relevant to your chosen topic. Graduate students do not often give

thought to arranging such interviews, but they can be an effective complement to the research you are conducting. You

can document your interviews that you've used as background to your own work.

Different Areas to choose from:

Mindmap on various levels to get started:

• Personal

Likes, Dislikes, Interests, Things that you want to learn more about/understand, Things that you feel about, etc

• Social

Social issues, problems, responsibilities, Human centered design, etc

• National + Political

Issues, problems you face as a nation, Political/ Government related matters, etc

• International + Global

Things regarding the international world, Involving the entire earth; not limited or provincial in scope, Global issues/

matters, etc

• Cultural

Relating to the arts and manners that a group favors/ Shared knowledge and values of a society, Ethnic issues, etc

Troubleshooting

If you discover that the thesis topic you've chosen is similar to some existing work or a thesis idea that has been in the

past, don't stress out. Carefully judge the material to gain an understanding of what it is that the prior thesis/design project

has accomplished and consider ways your thesis might further develop the topic or might approach the topic from a totally

different perspective. You are likely to find that the former thesis is not the same as the one you are considering after all. If

you discover that another student is working on a thesis on the same topic you've chosen, you should understand and

research on both the topics to get an even better idea of whether your ideas overlap. (Be careful not to give away too

much of your own thinking on the topic as you conduct this discussion.)

Brainstorming Techniques

Kindly read the following, it will help you a lot in how to come up with/approach your topic..

Wearing Six Thinking Hats By Olivier Serrat

Introduction

Routinely, many people think from analytical, critical, logical perspectives, and rarely view the world from

emotional, intuitive, creative, or even purposely negative viewpoints. As a result, their arguments do not make leaps of

imagination, they underestimate resistance to change, or they fail to draw contingency plans.

Lateral thinking is reasoning that offers new ways of looking at problems - coming at them from the side rather than from

the front - to foster change, creativity, and innovation.

One tool of lateral thinking, the Six Thinking Hats technique, was devised by de Bono in 1985 to give groups a means to

reflect together more effectively, one thing at a time.

Six Hats, Six Colors

The Six Thinking Hats technique involves the use of metaphorical hats in discussions. Participants are supposed to put on

hats in turn, possibly more than once but not necessarily all of them, to indicate directions (not descriptions) of thinking.

The color of each is related to a function:

• White hat thinking

Page 4: Thesis Topic Selection Guidelines

Neutral, objective

Focuses on the data and information that are available or needed.

• Red hat thinking

Emotional

Looks at a topic from the point of view of emotions, feelings, and hunches, without having to qualify or justify them.

• Black hat thinking

Sober, serious

Uses experience, logic, judgement, and caution to examine the difficulties and problems associated with a topic and the

feasibility of ideas.

• Yellow hat thinking

Sunny, positive-is concerned with benefits and values.

• Green hat thinking

Growth, fertility

Intimates creative thinking and movement, not judgment, to generate

new ideas and solutions.

• Blue hat thinking

Cool, the sky above: Concentrates on reflection, metacognition (thinking about the thinking required), and the need to

manage the thinking process.

[A blue hat should always be used both at the beginning and at the end of a discussion. What follows it depends on the nature of the topic and emotions

about it. For instance, wearing a red hat next might defuse strong feelings. Discussions to brainstorm problems might adopt blue, white, green, red,

yellow, black, green, and blue hats in sequence. Conversations seeking feedback might follow a blue, black, green, and blue hat pattern.]

See Figure: Six Thinking Hats to understand the framework Wearing Six Thinking Hats

Page 5: Thesis Topic Selection Guidelines

Applications

Pertinent applications for the Six Thinking Hats technique include productivity and communication; product and process

improvement, as well as project management; critical and analytical thinking, problem solving, and decision making; and

creativity training, meeting facilitation, and meeting management. Benefits

The Six Thinking Hats technique provides a common language that works in different cultures. It promotes collaborative

thinking, sharpens focus, facilitates communication, reduces conflict, enables thorough evaluations, improves exploration,

fosters creativity and innovation, saves time, and boosts productivity.

Another Technique Look at the image another technique. Pick up a pencil/pen and a big sheet and jot down everything that comes to your mind. There's no fixed meaning for each symbol, just whatever comes to mind: a plot turn, a character, a setting, an environment, a mood, an object, anything at all.. it's up to you. Rather than generating stories from scratch, it's just for unlocking imaginations by stimulating unpredictable turns of thought! This technique will also be useful when you've chosen your topic and want to have a creative direction within it..

Page 6: Thesis Topic Selection Guidelines

Plus there are a host of other idea/concept generation techniques here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surrealist_techniques