The West From Oriental Ism to Islamophobia Industry

8/2/2019 The West From Oriental Ism to Islamophobia Industry

1/4

The West from Orientalism to Islamophobia Industry: TheMyth of the Threat of Shariah

By Abdelouahed Oulgout

Tinjdad, Morocco, March 22, 2012

As I was readingShariah, the Threat toAmerica, a report published by the Center for

Security Policy in the United States, 2010, I felt a terrible headache because of the manifold

lies and allegations intentionally embedded in the report and served to devilise the

image of Islam and Muslims in the collective mind of the American society, especially the

non-muslims. The report, which is known as the report of Team B II, was described to

be an Exercise in Competitive Analysis; yet a modest critical endeavor of any ordinary

reader would conclude that the report was no analysis in the sense of logical reasoning

and scientific view, but an exercise in competitive misrepresentation of Islam in theAmerican media. What is so ridiculous about this as the reports preface embarks on is

that

This study is the result of months of analysis, discussion and drafting by a group of top security

policy experts concerned with the preeminent totalitarian threat of our time: the legal-political-

military doctrine known within Islam as shariah. It is designed to provide a comprehensive and

articulate second opinion on the official characterizations and assessments of this threat as put

forth by the United States government.

Its funny that those ideological hocks, whom the report refers to as top experts, had to

spend all that time to look into what they had already infused their minds with. And its

evident here that the main thesis of the report is that the Islamic Shariah is the number

one threat endangering the US security, and thus the United States mustrecognize this

enemyboth in its Jihadist and stealth versionand take a defensive strategy against

it. In this way, Newt Gingrichthe 2012 US presidential candidate, whose filmAmerica

At Riskwas produced to convince the American government and the security officials to

name their enemy and stop their nameless war againstterrorismstates, If evil cannot

be called by name, we will not be able to deteror even recognizethreats to our nation.

That is, the United States government should believe that the non-existent threat of

Shariah is real and should be thought of as a devil, so grievous and threatening to theAmerican existence and security.
http://shariahthethreat.org/http://shariahthethreat.org/http://shariahthethreat.org/http://shariahthethreat.org/http://shariahthethreat.org/http://www.centerforsecuritypolicy.org/index.xmlhttp://www.centerforsecuritypolicy.org/index.xmlhttp://www.centerforsecuritypolicy.org/index.xmlhttp://www.centerforsecuritypolicy.org/index.xmlhttp://www.centerforsecuritypolicy.org/index.xmlhttp://shariahthethreat.org/


2/4

This is how the report begins to develop its myths about Shariah. The latter, according to

the report, is the legal-political-military doctrine within Islam. This mythical triangle

reveals the radical ignorance of the broad significance of Shariah in Islam, and it only

demonstrates that these ideological players, who are the very part of the American

Islamophobia network nowadays, are still driven by a power-oriented mentality in whichpower, Edward Said states, is the only language they understand. Misreporting the facts

about Islam is one of the most addictive habits of the modern American Orientalism,

whose role has been to brainwash the mass as well as the government officials and

prompts them to act aggressively and indiscriminately against Muslims, especially those

inside America.

Another lie made by the experts is that Shariahs adherents are making a determined,

sustained, and well-financed effort to impose it on all Muslims and non-Muslims, alike.

Its a pity that they fail to understand that the Islamic belief as far as Shariah is concerned

addresses only those who freely and willingly believe in it. Non-Muslims are not requiredto believe in Allah and his prophet (PBUH); they are not ordered to pray, give zakat, fast

in Ramadan, go to pilgrimage, or eat and drink in our way, marry according to

Shariahetc. Any practice related to their personal affairs is free provided that it doesnt

violate the public morals, order and system in the Muslim society. The only mentioned

Islamic legislation which concerns the non-Muslims within a Muslim community

according to the Shariah doctrine is theJizya, the little amount of money a non-Muslim

inside a Muslim society has to pay annually to the Islamic State to benefit from its civic

and security services. Apart from this, all non-Muslims within an Islamic State have all

freedom to believe in what they want, establish their temples, and practice their religion

and rituals without any kind of aggression, fanaticism, racism, or persecution against

them.

Yet the concept of Shariah as represented in the report leaves out all the details and

components which are first and foremost pertained to the spiritual and civic order of

Muslims. It just picks theJihadbranch and frames it within the circle of threat, terrorism,

and murder, overlooking the fact thatJihadin the Quran and Hadith (the sayings of

Allah and his prophet, which are the basic two sources of Islamic legislation) orders the

Muslims to strive to improve themselves toward righteousness, goodness, and piety. Yes,

it is true that the Islamic Shariah includes a branch related to military Jihad, as anymodern state today has a ministry for security and defense; yet, its utmost goal and

background has never been to enforce others to believe in what they dont, for the Quran

clearly states,

Let there be no compulsion in religion. Truth has been made clear from error. Whoever rejects

false worship and believes in God has grasped the most trustworthy handhold that never breaks.

And God hears and knows all things. (Quran 2:256)

And its Allah also who states,


3/4

And if any one slew a person unless it be for murder or for spreading mischief in the landit

would be as if he slew the whole humanity: and if any one saved a life, it would be as if he saved

the whole humanity. (5:32)

The main goal ofMilitary Jihadin Islam is to protect Muslims, their co-existent non-

Muslims, and theIslamic state from any local or foreign hostility. And when compelled to

engage in wars,Mujahidin must adhere to the numerous obligations and morals in

the Military Jihad doctrine, which determines the honorable reason they should fight

for, the respectful way they should treat the enemy, the prisoners, the wounded, the

women, the children, the elderly, and even the environment. Its a pity that such reports

misread the Islamic history particularly the biography of the prophet Mohammed

(PBUH) and de-contextualize and misinterpret its legislative texts so that the facts fit

their pre-made, politicized, ideological judgments.

Alas, the report goes on reechoing the same rhetoric, painting as many myths as possibleabout Shariah. And on the basis of this myth and false claim, the report ceased the

occasion to attack the Quran, Hadith, Muslim history and scholars, Muslim

Brotherhoodsetc, misrepresenting as more facts as possible, claiming that the so-

called the threat of Shariahis the mainstream doctrine of shariah that constitutes the

threat to the U.S. Constitution and the freedoms it enshrines. The report goes further

quoting John Quincy Adams saying that as the essential principle of [Mohammeds]

faith is the subjugation of others by the sword; it is only by force, that his false doctrines

can be dispelled, and his power annihilated.(Look John Quincy Adams 136 -page series

of essays on Islam).

The report concludes, after two long chapters of fiction and deception, by blaming

America for not yet understanding the nature and credibility of the threat endangering

America, detailing some recommendation to keep it secure and Shariah-free. The report

states:

U.S. policy-makers, financiers, businessmen, judges, journalists, community leaders and the

public at large must be equipped with an accurate understanding of the nature of shariah and the

necessity of keeping America shariah-free.

It is a call for any ideological hock in America to believe that Shariah is a realthreat andto stand by force against this revolutionary ideology to which Muslims are adherents.

In this way, the Islamophobia network and players continue to broadcast their lies about

Islam and Muslims via mass media, leading to a kind of mass deception-just like the

weapons of mass destruction- among Americans. What is worse about this, however, is

that the act of manufacturing fear of Islam has been turning into different forms of

discrimination and physical aggression against Islam and Muslims. Its no wonder,

therefore, to hear news here and there about Quran burning, insulting caricatures about

the prophet of Islam (PBUH), vandalism against mosques and Islamic centers, hijab ban,

and so on and so forth.


4/4

What is so ironical about this, though, is that the perpetual campaigns of Islamophobia

network against Shariah and Muslims have but triggered the collective minds curiosity

and eager all around the West to explore Islam, Shariah, and other misrepresented

concepts; and thus, a widespread movement of conversion to Islam is emerging, not out

of the terrorist attacks of the so-calledJihadists, but because of the individuals personalexperience of Religion and life.

Abdelouahed Oulgout is a Moroccan English teacher, software designer,

English essay and Creative writer, public speaker, and Arabic poet. He got

his BA degree at the faculty of letters, the university of Moulay Ismail,

Meknes. He had been once a member-founder and ex-leader of English

Committee for Dialogue and Communication at the same university. He is

working on different intellectual projects on issues like Orientalism,

Islamophobia, and epistemology. ([email protected])

Documents

The West From Oriental Ism to Islamophobia Industry