14
The University of Western Ontario JitP i B d Joint Pension Board March 12, 2012 Ron Lloyd Managing Partner [email protected] 416-928-5105

The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

The University of Western OntarioJ i t P i B dJoint Pension Board

March 12, 2012Ron Lloyd Managing [email protected]

416-928-5105

Page 2: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Introduction to Romspen

Romspen Continues a 46-Year Track Recordof Successful Mortgage Lending Across Canada

Revelstoke Resort – Revelstoke, British Columbia1 St. Thomas – Yorkville, Toronto Medallion Business Centre – Calgary, Alberta

of Successful Mortgage Lending Across Canada

2Emmanuel Village – Kitchener, OntarioMonterra Subdivision – Cochrane, Alberta Yonge/Dundas Centre – Toronto, Ontario

Page 3: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Romspen Overview

Originated in 1950s• Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm• Loaned money to individuals primarily for home purchases and small commercial buildings in

th t O t isouthwestern Ontario

Founded in 1966• Founders, Sheldon Esbin and Arthur Resnick, both graduates of Osgoode Hall Law School, joined

Spencer Romberg and formally organized the mortgage lending business as Romspen…with a focus on commercial/industrial mortgages

Today• One of the largest non-bank commercial real estate mortgage lenders in Canada• All mortgages are pooled in one fund…with over $800 million invested

Outstanding 10-year track record• Consistent returns: 9.2% to 11.6% (gross) over the past 10 years • Minimal realized losses: < 0.7%

Disciplined investing• Loan-to-value ratio at time of underwriting: approximately 65%• 95% first mortgages• Diversification by size, borrower, geography and property type

3

Active ownership• Managing Partners are collectively the largest non-institutional investors in the Fund

Page 4: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Portfolio Risk Management

We manage our investment risk by closely adhering to the following key lending parameters:

• Canadian, commercial first mortgages to ensure deal control

• Short-term mortgages (< 2 years)

• Loan to value approximately 65% at time of underwriting to create margin of• Loan-to-value approximately 65% at time of underwriting to create margin of safety

• Solid underwriting (rigorous analysis, visit each property, know each borrower)

• Limit of 10% to any single borrower or mortgage

• Diversified portfolio by size, borrower, geography and property type

• Limit number of mortgages (approximately 100 to 125)g g ( pp y )

• Over 95% of mortgages are personally guaranteed

• Fund is not leveraged

4

Page 5: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Mortgage Portfolio Profile

Ontarioterm construction

As of December 31, 2011($763 million)By Type By Geography

41%

17% 33%9%

48%

24%

28%

British ColumbiaOther

Albertapre-development

under 1 year

$10 - $20 million

over $20 million

By MaturityBy Amount

60%

36%

4%

28%18%

31%

23%

$10 $20 million

under $5 million

5

1-2 years> 2 years

under $5 million

$5 - $10 million

Source: Romspen Financial Statements

Page 6: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Annual Historical Performance

Romspen Mortgage PortfolioAnnual Compounded Gross Returns

(2002-2011)

Year Gross return to investors*2002 11.6 %2003 10.7 %2004 10 8 %

Past 3 Yrs: 9.5%

Past 5 Yrs: 10.2%

2004 10.8 %2005 10.9 %2006 11.3 %2007 11.5 %2008 10 9 %

Past 10 Yrs: 10.6%2008 10.9 %2009 9.7 %2010 9.7 %2011 9.2 %

*Results from January 2000 to January 16, 2006 reflect the pool of individually syndicated mortgages. Results from January 16, 2006 to present reflect the Limited Partnership Fund, the successor to the individually syndicated mortgages.

Source: Romspen Analysis 6

Page 7: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Comparative Performance – 10 Year Returns

40%

Romspen Mortgage PortfolioAnnual % Return Comparison

(2002-2011)

20%

30%

0%

10%

% R

etur

n

-20%

-10%

Ann

ual %

Romspen Mortgage Portfolio

91-Day T-Bills

DEX Overall Short Term Bond Index

40%

-30%

Common Stocks (S&P/TSX)

7Source: Bank of Canada, Romspen Analysis

-40%2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011

Years

Page 8: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Investment Environment 2012

“Economic conditions are likely to warrant exceptionally low levels for the y p yFederal funds rate at least through late 2014”

Federal Reserve Open Market CommitteeWashington, January 25, 2012

“The Euro crisis threatens to derail the world economy.”International Monetary FundInternational Monetary FundJanuary 24, 2012

“The U.S. economy may never fully recover.”Mark Carney, Bank of Canada GovernorJanuary 23, 2012

8

Page 9: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Investment Strategy: Past, Present, Future

Single strategy focused on:

• Capital PreservationCapital Preservation

• Absolute Returns

• Consistent Performance

There has been no change in the Fund’s investment philosophy for 46 years.Capital preservation is, and will remain, Romspen’s top priority.

9

Page 10: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Why Romspen

• 46 year track record of successful mortgage investing• 46 year track record of successful mortgage investing

• Top quartile returns [9%+]

• Non-correlated returns

• Low volatile returns

• Simple strategy… No leverage, no hedging, no currency risk

10

Page 11: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Comparative Performance – Risk/Return

Romspen Mortgage PortfolioRisk vs Return

10 Years Ended Dec. 31, 2011

Romspen MortgagePortfolio

10%

12%High Return / Low Risk High Return / High Risk

Common Stocks (S&P/TSX)

6%

8%

% R

etur

n

DEX Overall Short Term Bond Index

T Bills

4%

6%

Ann

ual %

T-Bills

0%

2%

0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25%

Low Return / Low Risk Low Return / High Risk

Risk (Standard Deviation of Annual Returns) - %

Source: Bank of Canada, PriceWaterhouseCoopers Report, Romspen Analysis 11

Page 12: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Convincing Outperformance in a Market Acid Test (2007-2009)

40%

The years 2007-2009 were 3 of the most difficult investment years in the past 50 –Romspen strongly outperformed other major investment vehicles.

32%

30%

Romspen Mortgage Portfolio91-Day T-BillsDEX Overall Short Term Bond Index Common Stocks (S&P/TSX)Top Cdn Mutual Funds¹

18%

10%

20%

ompo

unde

dA

ccum

ulat

edR

etur

n (%

)

Top Cdn Mutual Funds¹

7%

1%0%

10%C A

-1%-3%

-10%

SharpeRatio2 6.2 0.0 1.4 0.1

1 Average performance of the top 180 mutual funds in Canada

Security Return – Risk Free Return

Standard Deviation of Return

2 Sharpe Ratio Formula:[1975]

Calculated from 2007-2009 using annual data (3 data points) with the 91-Day T-bill rate as the risk free rate.12

Source: Statistics Canada, Globe & Mail/Globe Investor, Romspen Analysis

Page 13: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Romspen Team

Managing Partners Years at Romspen

Years in Financial Industry

Experience and Education

Sheldon Esbin 46 46 Spencer Romberg Law Firm; Osgoode Hall (LL.B)

M k Hil 4 28Onex Corporation; P&G; Harvard (MBA); Wilfrid Laurier

Mark Hilson 4 28p ; ; ( );

University (HBBA)

Wesley Roitman 11 11 PSInet; Northern Financial; U of T (B.Sc. - Actuary)

Blake Cassidy 18 20New Era Mortgage; Sandray Property Management; U of T (B Sc); UBC (Real Estate)U of T (B.Sc); UBC (Real Estate)

Ronald Lloyd 2 25Hewitt Associates, President; Gluskin Sheff; Queen’s University (B. Comm Hons, M.IR, CIM)

Arthur Resnick 46 46 Spencer Romberg Law Firm; Osgoode Hall (LL.B)

Robert Shiller 3 26TD Securities; GE Capital; Coopers & Lybrand; McGill (B. Comm)

Key Staff

Arnie Bose 3 12Arthur Andersen; Ernst & Young; Ontario Realty Corporation; U i f W t l (BA M A ) CAUniv. of Waterloo (BA, M.Acc); CA

Bonnie Bowerman 3 21Aetna Canada; Sunlife; Drivers Jonas Canada Ltd.; York University (Hon. B.A., Hons B.A.S, P.L.E.)

Mary Gianfriddo 6 25 GMAC; Canada Life; National Trust

13

Blair Martin 1 30Smart Centres; Barry Lyons; City of Toronto Planning; Ryerson University (Urban Planning)

Joel Mickelson 3 13 Sentinel Hill; Grosvenor Park; U of T (LL.B)

Page 14: The University of Western Ontario JitP i B dJoint Pension ... · • Adjunct business to Spencer Romberg, a Toronto-based real estate law firm • Loaned money to individuals primarily

Primary Contacts

Ron LloydManaging PartnerRon Lloyd is responsible for client relationship management, business development for institutional investors, and strategic marketing initiatives.

Ron has 25 years experience in both the high net worth investment management and corporate pension consulting industries working in both Canada and the United States. Prior to joining Romspen, he was a senior executive at Gluskin Sheff + Associates and the President of Hewitt Associates Canada.

Ron received a Bachelor of Commerce (Honours) and a Masters of Industrial Relations from Queen's University and holds both the Canadian Investment Manager (CIM) and Associate Portfolio Manager designations.

Ron serves on the Board of Directors of Greenwood College School.

Mark HilsonManaging General PartnerMark Hilson oversees the Fund’s overall operation and performance.

Previously, Mark worked at Onex Corporation for 22 years as a Managing Director. Prior to joiningPreviously, Mark worked at Onex Corporation for 22 years as a Managing Director. Prior to joining Onex, Mark was an Associate in the Mergers and Acquisitions Group at Merrill Lynch and a Brand Manager at Procter & Gamble.

Mark received an MBA (George F. Baker Scholar) from the Harvard Graduate School of Business Administration and an Honours Bachelor of Business Administration (Gold Medalist) from WilfridLaurier University.

14

Mark has served on the Board of Directors of McMichael Canadian Art Collection, Shaw Festival, Wilfrid Laurier University, and several Canadian and U.S. public Boards.