94
The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box: From Cells to Galaxies Using Super-Computers Diego Muñoz Michael Long Amanda Peters Randles Thursday, October 25, 12

The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box:From Cells to Galaxies Using Super-Computers

Diego Muñoz Michael Long

Amanda Peters Randles

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 2: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 3: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 4: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 5: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 6: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 7: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 8: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box:From Cells to Galaxies Using Supercomputers

Part I 14 Billion Years of History told by 10 Billion

Particles: A Simulated Universe

Diego Muñoz Harvard-Smithsonian Center for AstrophysicsDepartment of Astronomy, Harvard University

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 9: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Computational power Computational methods

Image source: www.clker.com, Public Domain

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 10: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Computational power Computational methods

Image source: www.clker.com, Public Domain

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 11: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Computational power Computational methods

Larger, faster computers Better, more efficient techniquesand approximations

Image source: www.clker.com, Public Domain

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 12: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Sir Isaac Newton, portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller

GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself.

However, it was not understood until Isaac Newton’s Principia Matematica (1687). The term originates from the Latin gravitas, which means weight.

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 13: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Sir Isaac Newton, portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller

GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself.

However, it was not understood until Isaac Newton’s Principia Matematica (1687). The term originates from the Latin gravitas, which means weight.

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 14: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

"The Blue Marble" photograph of Earth, taken from Apollo 17. Source: Wikipedia

Image credit: NASA / JPL-Caltech / R. Hurt. Source: Wikipedia

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 15: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

GravityAsteroid Discovery 1980-2010. Credit: Scott Manley

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 16: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Whi

rlpoo

l Gal

axy/

M51

a . A

utho

r: N

AS

A an

d E

urop

ean

Spa

ce A

genc

y

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 17: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity at Cosmic Scales

HST Image of NGC 4414 /Image source: wikimedia commons

A galaxy...

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 18: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity at Cosmic Scales

HST Image of NGC 4414 /Image source: wikimedia commons

1000000000000000000 kmor 1 quintillion km

A galaxy...

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 19: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity at Cosmic Scales

HST Image of NGC 4414 /Image source: wikimedia commons

A galaxy...

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 20: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity at Cosmic Scales

Burrell Schmidt telescope image of the Virgo cluster. Credit Chris Mihos et al.using the /Image source: wikimedia commons

A cluster of galaxies...

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 21: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity at Cosmic Scales

Burrell Schmidt telescope image of the Virgo cluster. Credit Chris Mihos et al.using the /Image source: wikimedia commons

100000000000000000000 kmor 100 quintillion km

A cluster of galaxies...

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 22: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 23: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

6 sextillion km

0.7 sextillion km

0.15 sextillion km

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 24: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Sir Isaac Newton, portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller

Newton postulated, the the gravitational force between two bodies of masses m1 and m2 has a magnitude of

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 25: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Sir Isaac Newton, portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller

Newton postulated, the the gravitational force between two bodies of masses m1 and m2 has a magnitude of

m1 m2

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 26: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Sir Isaac Newton, portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller

Newton postulated, the the gravitational force between two bodies of masses m1 and m2 has a magnitude of

m1 m2

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 27: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Sir Isaac Newton, portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller

Newton postulated, the the gravitational force between two bodies of masses m1 and m2 has a magnitude of

m1 m2 r

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 28: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Sir Isaac Newton, portrait by Sir Godfrey Kneller

Newton postulated, the the gravitational force between two bodies of masses m1 and m2 has a magnitude of

m1 m2 r

where r is the distance between the bodies and G is the universal gravitational constant.

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 29: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Image license: Stock photo, photo.xchng Image ID: 909780

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 30: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Image license: Stock photo, photo.xchng Image ID: 909780

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 31: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Image license: Stock photo, photo.xchng Image ID: 909780

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 32: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Image license: Stock photo, photo.xchng Image ID: 909780

Earth

Moon

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 33: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Image license: Stock photo, photo.xchng Image ID: 909780

Earth

Moon

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 34: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Image license: Stock photo, photo.xchng Image ID: 909780

Earth

Moon

m1

m2

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 35: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity

Image license: Stock photo, photo.xchng Image ID: 909780

Earth

Moon

m1

m2

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 36: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Questions?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 37: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 38: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

a “particle”

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 39: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 40: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

2

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 41: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 42: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

3

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 43: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 44: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

4

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 45: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

4

4

5

6

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 46: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

4

4

5

6

5

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 47: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

4

4

5

6

5

8 79

10

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 48: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

4

4

5

6

5

8 79

10

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 49: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

4

4

5

6

5

8 79

10for N particles:

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 50: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

1

21

23

3

4

4

5

6

5

8 79

10

Gravitational systems require an enormous amount of operations

for N particles:

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 51: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Human Brain versus Computer

Thinking Man by Rodin

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 52: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Human Brain versus Computer

Thinking Man by Rodin

1 second per operationfor operations

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 53: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Human Brain versus Computer

Thinking Man by Rodin

(10 billion)2/2 seconds to calculate gravity for a Galaxy = 1 trillion years

1 second per operationfor operations

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 54: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

• Computers help us perform large numbers of operations

• Super-computers allow us to carry the operations out simultaneously

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 55: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

• Computers help us perform large numbers of operations

• Super-computers allow us to carry the operations out simultaneously

• Super-computers allow us to calculate approximate solutions in an efficient manner.

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 56: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

• Computers help us perform large numbers of operations

• Super-computers allow us to carry the operations out simultaneously

• Super-computers allow us to calculate approximate solutions in an efficient manner.

CAN WE CALCULATE GRAVITY APPROXIMATELY?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 57: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 58: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

5 = x +3

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 59: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

5 = x +3x = 2

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 60: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 61: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 62: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 63: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 64: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 65: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 66: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1? 1 = 1/2

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 67: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1? 1 = 1/2

0 1

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 68: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1? 1 = 1/2

0 10.5

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 69: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1? 1 = 1/2

0 1

x = 0.5?

0.5

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 70: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1? 1 = 1/2

0 1

x = 0.5? 0.5 = 0.707...

0.5

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 71: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1? 1 = 1/2

0 1

x = 0.5? 0.5 = 0.707... x = 0.6411?

0.5

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 72: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

x = 1 2x

x = 0? 0 = 1x = 1? 1 = 1/2

0 1

x = 0.5? 0.5 = 0.707... x = 0.6411? 0.6411 0.64122...

0.5

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 73: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

Image credit:http://www.shiftingstates.com

until it is “good enough”...

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 74: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Why Computers?

0.6411857445049 8598448620048211482366656282095719110...

x =

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 75: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

What is “Good Enough”?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 76: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

What is “Good Enough”?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 77: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

What is “Good Enough”?

In physics: the fine structure constant is known within 10 significant figures. Its relative standard of uncertainty is 0.32 parts per billion

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 78: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

What is “Good Enough”?

In physics: the fine structure constant is known within 10 significant figures. Its relative standard of uncertainty is 0.32 parts per billion

In astronomy: The mass of the Milky Way is known only within a 50% error: 1.0 - 1.5 billion times the mass of the Sun

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 79: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Questions?

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 80: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity in Astrophysics

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 81: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity in Astrophysics

Images: HST publicly released images, hubblesite.org/newscenter

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 82: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity in Astrophysics

Images: HST publicly released images, hubblesite.org/newscenter

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 83: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Gravity in Astrophysics

Images: HST publicly released images, hubblesite.org/newscenter

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 84: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

http://openclipart.orgoffice.microsoft.com/en-us/images/

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 85: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 86: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Calculating Gravitational Forces with Supercomputers

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 87: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

...this is called domain decomposition

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 88: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

(Mihos & Hernquist 1996)Credit: NASA, ESA, and F. Summers (STScI) 2008

Simulation Data: Chris Mihos (Case Western Reserve University) and Lars Hernquist (Harvard University)

http://hubblesite.org/newscenter/archive/releases/2008/16/video/d/

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 89: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

credit: Philip Hopkins, UC Berkeley Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 90: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

The Universe in a Box:

What is the shape of the Universe??

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 91: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Sloan Digital Sky Survey http://www.sdss.org

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 92: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Aquarius Simulation -- Virgo Consortium

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 93: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12

Page 94: The Universe in a (Pretty Big) Box · 2013. 4. 14. · Kneller GRAVITY is one of the fundamental forces of the Universe, that is, it originates with the universe itself. However,

Thursday, October 25, 12