The Unity of Imagining - Fabian Dorsch

8/17/2019 The Unity of Imagining - Fabian Dorsch

1/501

I n

t h i s h i g h l y a m b i t i o u s , w i d e r a n g i n g ,

i m m e n s e l y i m p r e s s i v e

a n d g r o u n d - b r e a k i n g

w o r k F a b i a n D o r s c h s u r v e y s j u s t a b o u t e v e r y

a c c o u n t o f t h e i m a g i n a

t i o n t h a t h a s e v e r b e e n

p r o p o s e d . H e i d e n t i f i e

s f i v e c e n t r a l t y p e s o f

i m a g i n i n g t h a t a n y

u n i f y i n g t h e o r y m u s t

a c c o m m o d a t e a n d s e t s h i m s e l f t h e t a s k o f

d e t e r m i n i n g w h e t h e r

a n y t h e o r y o f w h a t

i m a g i n i n g c o n s i s t s i n c o v e r s t h e s e f i v e

p a r a d i g m s . F o c u s s i n g o n w h a t h e t a k e s t o b e t h e

t h r e e m a i n t h e o r i e s , a n d

g i v i n g t h e m e a c h e q u a l

c o n s i d e r a t i o n , h e f a u l t s t h e f i r s t t w o a n d

e m b r a c e s t h e t h i r d .

T h e s c h o l a r s h i p

i s

i m m a c u l a t e , t h e w r i t i n

g c r y s t a l c l e a r a n d t h e

a r g u m e n t a t i o n a l w a y s p o w e r f u l .

M a l c o l m B u d d , F B A ,

E m e r i t u

s G r o t e P r o f e s s o r o f t h e

P h i l o s o

p h y o f M i n d a n d L o g i c ,

U n i v e r s i t y C o l l e g e L o n d o n

D i s t r i b u t e d i n N o r t h

a n d S o u t h A m e r i c a

b y T r a n s a c t i o n B o o k s

I S B N 9 7 8 - 3 - 8 6 8 3 8 - 1 7 4 - 0

o n t

o s

v e r l a g

P h i l o

s o p h i s c h e F o r s c h u n g

P h i l

o s o p h i c a l R e s e a r c h

H e r a u s g e g e b e n v o n / E d i t e d b y

J o h a

n n e s B r a n d l

W o l f g a n g K ü n n e · A n d r e a s K e m m e r l i n g

· M a r k T e x t o r

F a b i a n D o r s c h

T h e U

n i t y o f I m a g i n i n g

F a b i a n D o r s c h T h e U n i t y o f I m a g i n i n g 9

P h R 9

9 7 8 3 8 6 8 3

8 1 7 4 0


2/501

!"#$"% '()*+,

!"# %&'() *+ ,-./'&'&/


3/501

" # $ % & ' & ( # $ ' ) # * + & , ' ) # - . /

" # $ % & ' & ( # $ ) 0 % 1 * ' * 0 , ) #

2*,0-'/*/*3*. 4&. 5 67$8*7 39

:..*' ;,0.7%


4/501

"#$%#& '()*+,

!"# %&'() *+ ,-./'&'&/


5/501

!"#$"%&'()*"+ "-.%'/(0"%- )1#$"2*34 #5 0*3 63102+*3 7(0"%-($#"#$"%0*38

!"# %#&'()"# *+',-.+/0,0/,-'"#1 /,('( '",( 2&0/,)+',-. ,. '"# %#&'()"# *+',-.+/0,0/,-34+2",#5

6#'+,/#6 0,0/,-34+2",) 6+'+ ,( +7+,/+0/# ,. '"# 8.'#4.#' +' "''29::6.0;660;6#

*-4'" +.6

B.,'#6 N,.36->E 84#/+.6E 8)#/+.6E !&41#?E O+/'+E C-4'&3+/ 0?

P+Q#//# @--1( ,'#6

S",'# T4-(( O,//(

U,3"'-D.

R=*T=

R,74+,(-. 2-&4 /+ Y4+.)# #' /+ @#/3,Z

R,04+,4,# C",/-(-2",Z F;[4,.

\E 2/+)# 6# /+ >

DDD;-.'-(7#4/+3;)->

8,((,-. c4-> '"# C&0/,("#4E D,'" '"# #b)#2',-. -c +.? >+'#4,+/ (&22/,#6 (2#),c,)+//? c-4 '"# 2&42-(# -c 0#,.3 #.'#4#6 +.6 #b#)&'#6 -. + )->2&'#4 (?('#>E c-4 #b)/&(,7# &(# -c '"# 2&4)"+(#4 -c '"# D-41

C4,.'#6 -. +),6Kc4## 2+2#4

8 e]GK\Y


6/501

!"#$% '( )'*+%*+,

!"#$%&"' )$*&" +, -+.#".#/ -.

012.+3&"'4"5".#/ ./

0*+1'234+-'* 5

6"1+ 7*% 8 !9% :"+31% "*2 ;"1-%+< '( 0=">-*-*>

0*+1'234+-'* +' 6"1+ 7*% ?@

5 A*-(-%2 B44'3*+, '( 0=">-*-*> ?C

? D%< E%"+31%, '( 0=">-*"+-/% FG-,'2%, HI

@ D%< E%"+31%, '( J%*,'1< 0=">-*-*>, CI

K 0=">-*"+-'* "*2 D*'L$%2>% 55H

H 7+9%1 !9%'1-%, '( 0=">-*-*> 5KI

6"1+ !L' 8 !9% FG-,+%='$'>-4"$ B44'3*+

0*+1'234+-'* +' 6"1+ !L' 5I5

M 7NJ9"3>9*%,,


7/501

/---

6"1+ !91%% 8 !9% P%G%*2%*4< B44'3*+

0*+1'234+-'* +' 6"1+ !91%% ?CHI !9% Q%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$ B44'3*+ ?O5

5R ;-,3"$ 0=">-*-*> B, F.G%1-%*+-"$ 0=">-*-*> @5@

55 F='+-'*"$ 0=">-*-*> B, F.G%1-%*+-"$ 0=">-*-*> @@C

5? J%="*+-4 P%G%*2%*4


8/501

P%+"-$%2 !"#$% '( )'*+%*+,

012.+3&"'4"5".#/ ./

0*+1'234+-'* 5U-V !9% :%%2 ('1 " A*-(-%2 B44'3*+ H

U--V !91%% T"-* !9%'1-%, '( 0=">-*-*> C

U---V 7+9%1 !9%'1-%, '( 0=">-*-*> 55

U-/V !9% J+134+31% '( +9% W''X 5C

6"1+ 7*% 8 !9% :"+31% "*2 ;"1-%+< '( 0=">-*-*>

0*+1'234+-'* +' 6"1+ 7*% ?@

5 A*-(-%2 B44'3*+, '( 0=">-*-*> ?C=>= )3+ !"/%'"7$#$ ?O

=>?> @%A" -".#7$& -$/"/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 @?

U-V J%*,'1< 0=">-*-*> @C

U--V B((%4+-/% 0=">-*-*> K5

U---V 0*+%$$%4+3"$ 0=">-*-*> K?U-/V F.G%1-%*+-"$ 0=">-*-*> KK

U/V 0=">-*"+-/% 61'Y%4+, KM

=>B> C".#$& D8%/+'"/ $.' -+58&"-*"+-/% P-,G',-+-'*, H?

U--V P1%"= Q%G1%,%*+"+-'*, H@

U---V A*3,3"$ '1 6"+9'$'>-4"$ )",%, HK

U-/V E"*4-(3$ F.G%4+"+-'*S B*+-4-G"+-'*S F+4Z HH


9/501

.

? D%< E%"+31%, '( 0=">-*"+-/% FG-,'2%, HI?>=> ;5$4%.$#%A" 0##%#H'" M5

?>?> F+ D8%/#"5%1 @H.1#%+. MO?>B> I","7".1" #+ I"$&%#: C@

@ D%< E%"+31%, '( J%*,'1< 0=">-*-*>, CIB>=> !%5%.%/9"' J%A$1%#: O5

B>?> F+ ;55"'%$1: O@

B>B> ;.'"#"75%.$1: OH

B>E> KH$/%GL*/"7A$#%+.$&%#: OC

B>M> ;55H.%#: #+ D77+7 #97+H49 C%/%'".#%,%1$#%+. IK

B>N> ;.#"&&"1#H$&%#: IM

U-V 6%"4'4X%N, ;-%L IM

U--V J"1+1%N, ;-%L 5RR

U---V 0=">-*"+-/% !9'3>9+ /,Z 0*+%*+-'*[-*[B4+-'* 5R@

U-/V F.G$"*"+'1< 6'L%1 5RM

K 0=">-*"+-'* "*2 D*'L$%2>% 55HE>=> )3+ DN> TP8+.#$."%#:UV 0##".#%+.V $.' T@%&&%.4G;.U 5@O

E>W> J+&H.#$7%."// $.' -+4.%#%A" -+./#7$%.#/ 5K?

H 7+9%1 !9%'1-%, '( 0=">-*-*> 5KIM>=> )9" KH$.#%#$#%A" 011+H.# 5HR

M>?> )9" Q9".+5".$& 011+H.# 5H?

M>B> )9" L.#+&+4%1$& 011+H.# 5HK

M>E> )9" C+'$& 011+H.# 5M5

M>M> )9" 0##%#H'" 011+H.# 5MO

M>N> )9" P8+.#$."%#: 011+H.# 5CM


10/501

.-

6"1+ !L' 8 !9% FG-,+%='$'>-4"$ B44'3*+

0*+1'234+-'* +' 6"1+ !L' 5I5M 7NJ9"3>9*%,,=> 0 67%", P:.+8/%/ 5II

N>?> )9" )97"" C$%. -&$%5/ ?R?

N>B> )9" 074H5".#$#%A" P#7$#"4: ?5@

C 7NJ9"3>9*%,,3=%*+, ??5W>=> )9" 074H5".# ,7+5 L7%4%. ???

U-V J+"*2"12 )'*,+1"-*+, '* )'>*-+-'*, ??@U--V \"X%(3$*%,, ", " E31+9%1 )'*,+1"-*+ ?@?

U---V !9% 71->-* '( 0=">-*-*>, ?K?

W>?> )9" 074H5".# ,7+5 0##".#%+. ?KC

O )1-+-4"$ B,,%,,=%*+ ?H@X>=> )9" D


11/501

.--

5R ;-,3"$ 0=">-*-*> B, F.G%1-%*+-"$ 0=">-*-*> @5@=]>=> C$7#%.U/ 074H5".#^ Q"7/8"1#%A$&."// @5K

=]>?> 0 P"1+.' 074H5".#^ D4+1".#7%1 L7%".#$#%+. @??=]>B> I"8&%"/ #+ L*\"1#%+./ @?H

=]>E> )9" F$#H7" +, D-*-*> B, F.G%1-%*+-"$ 0=">-*-*> @@C==>=> )9" QH__&" +, @%1#%+. @KR

==>?> ̀ $+.U/ 011+H.# +, D5+#%+.$& ;5$4%.%.4 @KM

==>B> C+7$. +. #9" J$7%+H/ @+75/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 @H5

==>E> C+7$.U/ 011+H.# +, D5+#%+.$& ;5$4%.%.4 @HM

==>M> )9" D P"5$.#%1 !"8".'".1: @MM

=?>?> ;5$4%.$#%+. $/ P%5H&$#%+. @MO

=?>B> ;5$4%.$#%+. $/ Q7"#"./" @C@

=?>E> -+.1&H/%+. $.' LH#&++2 @CC

6"1+ E'31 8 !9% B>%*4< B44'3*+

0*+1'234+-'* +' 6"1+ E'31 @O5

5@ 0=">-*"+-/% B>%*4< @OH=B>=> C".#$& A/> 6+'%&: 04".1: @OM

=B>?> )9" F$#H7" +, ;5$4%.$#%A" 04".1: @OC

=B>B> KH$&%,%1$#%+./ @I5

U-V )'*41%+%*%,, @I5

U--V ;'$3*+"1-*%,, @I?

U---V P-1%4+*%,, @IK

=B>E> )9" D//".#%$&%#: +, ;5$4%.$#%A" 04".1: @IM

=B>M> )9" PH*\"1#%+. #+ #9" `%&& 011+H.# KRK

5K T%%+-*> +9% P%,-2%1"+" KRI=E>=> D


12/501

.---

=E>?> D-*"+-/% 69%*'=%*" K5C=E>B> F+.GI"87"/".#$#%+.$&%#:^ #9" -$/" +, ;5$4%."' Q$%./ K?5

=E>E> Q$//%A%#:^ #9" -$/" +, P8+.#$."+H/ ;5$4"/ a )9+H49#/ K?@

)'*4$3,-'* K@5U-V !9% B>%*4< B44'3*+ K@5

U--V !9% FG-,+%='$'>-4"$ "*2 +9% P%G%*2%*4< B44'3*+ K@K

U---V 7+9%1 !9%'1-%, '( 0=">-*-*> K@CU-/V J'=% ^'',% F*2, K@I

6%*&%+47$89: KK@

;.'"< KHH


13/501


14/501

B4X*'L$%2>%=%*+,

0 "= >1"+%(3$ +' +9% ('$$'L-*> Y'31*"$, ('1 G%1=-,,-'* +' 1%G1'234% ="+%1[-"$` D.7$9+.$7 ('1 G"1+, '( =< G"G%1 aF='+-'*"$ 0=">-*-*> "*2 731 Q%[,G'*,%, +' E-4+-'*N U D.7$9+.$7 S /'$Z KMS ?R55b 1%G1-*+%2 #< G%1=-,,-'* '(+9% G3#$-,9%1S A*-/%1,-+"+ B3+c*'=" 2% W"14%$'*"Vb I%A%/#$ '% D/#"#%1$ ('1 G"1+, '( =< G"G%1 a!9% Q%41%"+-/% 0=">-*"+-'*N UQ-/-,+" 2- F,+%+-4"S /'$ZHKS ?R5@b 1%G1-*+%2 #< G%1=-,,-'* '( +9% G3#$-,9%1S Q',%*#%1> d J%$$-%1Vb"*2 Q9%&+/+89%1$& D%2 "*2 G3,9%2 =% (31+9%1 '* +9% +'G-4 +9"* "*9+ =% " $'+"#'3+ +9% G9%*'=%*'$'>-4"$ "GG1'"49 +' +9% =-*2 "*2 +9% -=">-*"+-'*b "*2Q'# e'GX-*,S L9' 9", "$L"


15/501

./-

'( ;"$%*4-" "*2 +9% A*-/%1,-+< '( E1-#'31>ZE-*"$$1"+-+32% +' f'9"**%, W1"*2$S B*21%",

D%==%1$-*>S \'$(>"*> Dh**% "*2 T"1X !%.+'1S ('1 +9%-1 G%1,'*"$ ",,-,+["*4% "*2 %2-+'1-"$ >3-2"*4%b +9% ]1"23"+% J49''$ '( A*-/%1,-+< )'$$%>%^'*2'* "*2 +9% JL-,, :"+-'*"$ J4-%*4% E'3*2"+-'*S ('1 +9%-1 (-*"*4-"$ ,3G[ G'1+ '( =< 1%,%"149b "*2 +' =< ("=-$< "*2 (1-%*2,S ('1 +9%-1 3*4'=G$"-*-*> G"+-%*4% 231-*> +9% $",+


16/501

E'1 F/>%*-"

0*+1'234+-'*


17/501


18/501

0*+1'234+-'*

!9% G1-*4-G"$ "-= '( +9-, ='*'>1"G9 -, +' G1%,%*+ "*2 4'=G"1% +9% ="-*+9%'1-%, '( -=">-*-*> -* " , '1 2"-*-*> G3+ ('1L"12 -* +9% $-+%1"+31%Z !9% #''X +9%1%('1%,%1/%, ", "* -*+1'234+-'* +' +9% ="-* -2%", "*2 G',-+-'*, +9"+ 9"/% #%%* "2['G+%2 L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' -=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"Z W3+ -+ 2'%, ,' -* " ,+1-4+$< G1'#$%=['1-%*+%2 ="**%1S *"=%$< (1'= +9% G%1,G%4+-/% '( +9% G',,-#-$-+< '( G1'/-2-*> "* "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> +9"+ 3*-(-%, -+, 2-((%1%*+ -*4"1*"+-'*,Z B," 4'*,%i3%*4%S +9% 2-,43,,-'* -, '1>"*-,%2 "1'3*2 +9% G',,-#$% ,'314%, '(+9% 3*-+< '( -=">-*-*> "*2 4%*+1%, $%,, '* G"1+-43$"1 G9-$','G9%1, "*2 +9%-1,G%4-(-4 /-%L,Z5

!9% 4'=G"1-,'* '( +9% 4'11%,G'*2-*> G1-*4-G"$ +9%'1-%, '( -=">-*-*> -,5 B*'+9%1 1%",'* ('1 +9-, -, +9"+ 8 L-+9 ,'=% *'+"#$% %.4%G+-'*,S ,349 ", +9% L'1X, #<

e3,,%1$ U?RRMVS J"1+1% U5IKRVS )",%< U5ICMVS \9-+% U5IIRVS 7NJ9"3>9*%,,< U?RRRV"*2 T4]-** U?RRKV 8 ="*< G9-$','G9%1, 9"/% *'+ G1%,%*+%2 (3$$< 2%/%$'G%2 "*2 ('[43,%2 +9%'1-%, '( -=">-*-*>S #3+ -*,+%"2 %=#%22%2 +9%-1 4$"-=, -* 2-,43,,-'*, '('+9%1S '(+%* ='1% >%*%1"$ -,,3%, U,%%S %Z>ZS )'$$-*>L''2 U5I@OVS Q


19/501

? ;.#7+'H1#%+.

'G-*-'*"+%2S '* +9% '+9%1 9"*2S -* ,' ("1 ", " ='1% ,G%4-(-4 >'"$ '( +9% #''X-, +' 2%(%*2 +9% 04".1: 011+H.# '( -=">-*-*> ", +9% #%,+ 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '(

-=">-*-*> "/"-$"#$%Z !9% ="-* 4$"-= '( +9-, +9%'1< -, +9"+ -=">-*-*>, "1%S%,,%*+-"$$< "*2 (3*2"=%*+"$$ +9"+ L% "4+-/%$< "*2 /'$3*+"1-$< 2'Z

B H.%,%"' $11+H.# '( -=">-*-*> -, 49"1"4+%1-,%2 #< +9% ("4+ +9"+ -+ 4"G[+31%, +9% 4'=='* *"+31% '( +9% 4%*+1"$ 4",%, '( -=">-*-*> U%Z>ZS /-,3"$[-,-*>S ,3GG',-*>S '1 2"-*"+-/% =%*+"$ G9%*'=[%*"S *'+"#$< 4'>*-+-/% 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*, U%Z>ZS G%14%G+-'*,S Y32>%=%*+,S '1

=%='1-%,VZ !9% =-*-="$ >'"$ '( "*< +9%'1< -*+%*2%2 ", " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+'( -=">-*-*> ,9'3$2 +9%1%('1% #% +' "49-%/% %.+%*,-'*"$ ", L%$$ ", %.G$"*["+'1< "2%i3"4= 4",%, '( -=">-*"+-/%"*2 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"b "*2 -+ ,9'3$2 4'11%4+$< 2%,41-#% "*2 %.[ G$"-* +9% 2-,+-*4+-/% "*2 (3*2"=%*+"$ *"+31% '( +9% ('1=%1Z B ="-* +9%=% '(+9% 2-,43,,-'* -, +9%1%('1% +9% %$34-2"+-'* '( G1-="1< %."=G$%, '( -=">-*[-*>S "*2 '( L9"+ 2-,+-*>3-,9%, +9%= (1'= '+9%1S *'*[-=">-*"+-/% =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*"Z B*'+9%1 "*2 4$',%$< 1%$"+%2 >3-2-*> -,,3% -, L9%+9%1 -+ -, G',[

,-#$% +' "44'3*+ ('1 +9% ,G%4-(-4 49"1"4+%1 '( +9%,% -=">-*-*>, #< -2%*+-( " ,%+ '( (%"+31%, 2-,+-*4+-/% '( +9%= "*2 1%,G'*,-#$% ('1 +9%-1 -=">-*"+[-/% ,+"+3, U-Z%ZS +9%-1 G1'G%1+< '( #%-*> -*,+"*4%, '( -=">-*-*>VZ !9"+ -,S +9% #''X "221%,,%, +9% -,,3% '( L9%+9%1 -+ -, G',,-#$% +' ,G%4-(< "*2 %$34-2"+%+9-, ,+"+3, -* +%1=, '( -*2-/-23"$$< *%4%,,"1< "*2 Y'-*+$< ,3((-4-%*+ 4'*2-[+-'*, ('1 ,'=%+9-*> +' #% "* -=">-*-*>S "+ $%",+ L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' +9% G"1"2->= 4",%,Z

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`5IK((ZV "*2 '31 ='1"$ %/"$3"+-'* '( "4+-'*, U%Z>ZS f'9*,'* U5II@VV +' +9%"%,+9%+-4 "GG1%4-"+-'* '( "1+L'1X, U%Z>ZS \"$+'* U5IIRV "*2 -+, ="*< ('$[


20/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. @

$'L%1,V "*2 %/%* +9% "4i3-,-+-'* '( X*'L$%2>% "#'3+ +9% %.+%1*"$ L'1$2Z? T'1%'/%1S %/%* L9%* G9-$','G9%1, "221%,, +9% i3%,+-'* '( L9"+ -+

=%"*, ('1 " =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*'* +' #% -=">-*"+-/% U-Z%ZS G',,%,, +9% G1'G[%1+< '( #%-*> "* -=">-*-*>VS +9%< 3,3"$$< 4'*4%*+1"+% %.4$3,-/%$< '* ,G%[4-(-4 ('1=, '( -=">-*-*>S *'+"#$< '* ,%*,'1< '1 /-,3"$ -=">-*-*>,Z@ 0*2%%2S+9% *%>$%4+ '( +9% -,,3% '( L9"+ "$$ -=">-*-*>, 9"/% -* 4'=='* $/ -=">-*[-*>, ="< #% 4$',%$< $-*X%2 +' +9% *%>$%4+ '( *'*[,%*,'1< '1 4'=G$%. X-*2,'( -=">-*-*>Z E-*"$$ "#'3+ +9% -=">-*"+-'* 9"/% *'+"$L" +9%-1 -2%",-*+' " G1'G%1 +9%'1< '( L9"+ -, 2-,+-*4+-/% '( -=">-*-*>,Z

B, " 1%,3$+S =',+ 2-,43,,-'*, '( -=">-*-*>, 9"/% #%%* 4'*4%1*%2 %-+9%1? B$+9'3>9 -=">-*-*>, "1% +9 ,%%)9"G+%1 K ('1 "* 'GG',-*> /-%LVS -+ ,%%=, #%%Z J%%S ('1 -*,+"*4%S +9% 2-,43,,-'*, '*+9'3>9+ %.G%1-=%*+, U%Z>ZS J'1%*,%* U5II?V "*2 ]%*2$%1 U?RRR"VVS +9% $-*X #%+L%%*4'*4%-/"#-$-+< "*2 G',,-#-$-+< U%Z>ZS ]%*2$%1 d e"L+9'1*% U?RR?VVS +9% 1'$% '( =%*[+"$ -=">%1< -* >%'=%+1< U%Z>ZS ]-"i3-*+' U5II?VV "*2 -* 4'3*+%1("4+3"$ 1%",'*-*>U%Z>ZS \-$$-"=,'* U?RROVVS '1 +9% -*/'$/%=%*+ '( /-,3"$-,"+-'* -* =%='1 L9%+9%1 (1'>, 9"/% $-G,S '19'L ="*< L-*2'L, "1% -* '*%N, 'L* 9'3,% U%Z>ZS D',,$L''2 U5I@OV` 49,Z I(ZS J"1+1% U5IKRVS 6%"4'4X% U5IOHVS e'GX-*, U5IIOV`49Z CS "*2S -+ ,%%=,S \-++>%*,+%-* U5IOK4V` /'$Z 00S ,%4Z M@[5KCS +' *"=% Y3,+ " (%L '(+9',% L9' ('43, ='1% '1 $%,, %.4$3,-/%$< '* ,%*,'1< '1 /-,3"$ -=">-*-*>,Z D-*2U?RR5V 2'%, +9% ,"=%` L9-$% ,9% "1>3%, +9"+ "$$ -*,+"*4%, '( a-=">-*-*>N -*/'$/%,%*,'1< -=">%13-,9%, +9% 1%,3$+-*> ,%*,'1< a-=">-*-*>N (1'= -*+%$$%4[+3"$ a,3GG',-+-'*NZ J413+'* U5ICKVS \9-+% U5IIRVS )",%< U?RRRVS 7NJ9"3>9*%,,<

U?RR?VS )311-% d Q"/%*,41'(+ U?RR?V "*2 T4]-** U?RRKV "221%,, #'+9 ,%*,'1< "*2-*+%$$%4+3"$ -=">-*-*>,S #3+ *' %='+-'*"$ -=">-*-*>, U-* 4'*+1",+ +' %='+-'*"$ 1%[,G'*,%, +' -=">-*-*>VS "*2 -=">-*"+-/% G1'Y%4+, '*$< -* G",,-*> "*2 *'+ -* 1%$"+-'* +'+9%-1 4'=='*"$-+< L-+9 -=">-*"+-/% %G-,'2%,Z W%,-2%,S "$+9'3>9 T4]-** 2-,43,,%,/"1-'3, ('1=, '( -=">-*-*>S 9% 2'%, *'+ "-= +' G1'/-2% " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( +9%=Z0*,+%"2S 9% "1>3%, =%1%$< +9"+ +9%< ('1= "* a-=">-*"+-'* ,G%4+13=N L9-49 %.+%*2,(1'= +9% =',+ ,-=G$% "*2 +%=G'1"$$< "*2 4'*4%G+3"$$< G1-'1 -=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"U%Z>ZS +9',% -*/'$/%2 -* ,%*,'1< 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*V +' +9% =',+ 4'=G$%. "*2 2%/%$'G%2'*%, U%Z>ZS +9',% -*/'$/%2 -* 41%"+-/-+


21/501

K ;.#7+'H1#%+.

L-+9 ",G%4+, '( -=">-*-*>, '+9%1 +9"* U+9'3>9 G%19"G, 2%G%*2%*+ '* '1'+9%1L-,% 1%$"+%2 +'V +9%-1 -=">-*"+-/%*%,,S '1 L-+9 +9% -=">-*"+-/%*%,, '(

'*$< 4%1+"-* X-*2, '( -=">-*-*>Z f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` 49Z 5VZ e% ,G%*2,4'*,-2%1"#$% +-=% '* ,G%4-( a" *3=#%1 '( 2-=%*,-'*, "$'*> L9-49 -="[>-*-*>, 4"* /"1'( L9"+ -+ -, +' -=">-*%N U-#-2ZS 5IVZ 0*2%%2S -+ -, 1"+9%1 4'=='* -* 2-,43,[

,-'*, "#'3+ -=">-*-*>, "*2 +9%-1 1'$% -* '31 =%*+"$ $-/%, +' +"X% ('1 >1"*+%2K J%% J413+'* U5ICKV` 49,Z C(ZS )",%< U5ICMVS 7NJ9"3>9*%,,< U?RRRV` 49,Z 55(ZS "*2

T4]-** U?RRKV ('1 4$%"1 %."=G$%,Z W3+ *'*% '( +9%= 2-,43,,%, -=">-*"+-/% G1'Y%4+,U("*+",-%,S 2" a-* '*%N, 9%"2N =->9+ #% "GG$-%2 +' -*+%$$%4+3"$ -=">-*-*> ",L%$$ U,%% J%4+-'* 5?Z@S "*2 Q "*2 -*+%$$%4+3"$ -=">-*-*> -* +%1=, '( +9-*X-*> '( +9% G',[,-#$%S #3+ 2'%, *'+ %.G$-4-+$< 4'**%4+ +9% +L' "*"$-*-*>, ", ,-=3$"+-'*, '( +9%-1 1%,G%4+-/% 4'>*-+-/% 4'3*+%1G"1+,U,%% J%4+-'* 5?Z?S "*2 )311-% d Q"/%*,41'(+ U?RR?V` 55 "*2 KIVS +9%-1 ="-* 4'*4%1*-, L-+9 +9% -*/'$/%=%*+ '( +9% -=">-*"+-'* -* "2'G+-*> " G%1,G%4+-/% '* +9% L'1$22-((%1%*+ (1'= '*%N, 4311%*+ '*%S 1"+9%1 +9"* L-+9 +9% >%*%1"$ *"+31% '( -=">-*-*>U-#-2` O(Z "*2 55VZ


22/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. H

+9"+ -+ -, ,3((-4-%*+$< 4$%"1 L9"+ -+ =%"*, +' -=">-*% ,'=%+9-*> 8 ", -+ -,$-X%L-,% '(+%* ",,3=%2 +9"+ L% 9"/% " >''2 >1",G '(S ,"-*-*> 8 3*2%1,+''2 ", +9% 4$",, '( /-,3"$-,-*>S ,3GG',[-*>S %=G"+9-g-*>S 2" +9% =',+ #",-4 '1 G1-=-+-/% =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*" ="< %.G$"-* L9< -+ 9", #< *' =%"*, #%%* +9%,3#Y%4+ '( G9-$','G9-4"$ -*/%,+->"+-'* +' +9% ,"=% %.+%*+S "*2 L-+9 +9% ,"=%

%.4$3,-/-+-/%* G9%*'=%*'*b L9-$% +9%$"4X '( "*< (31+9%1 %$34-2"+-'* '( +9% *"+31% '( +9-, +%*%1"$$*-(-4"*4% "*2

G1'=-*%*+ G',-+-'* '( -=">-*-*> -* '31 $-/%, "*2 -*+%1"4+-'*, L-+9 %"49'+9%1 "*2 +9% L'1$2 k G1'/-2% ,3((-4-%*+ ='+-/"+-'* ('1 +9% -*/%,+->"+-'* '(+9% G',,-#-$-+< '( " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*>Z 0* G"1+-43$"1S -+ L-$$ #%9%$G(3$ "*2 -$$3=-*"+-*> +' $%"1* ='1% "#'3+ L9"+ -+ =%"*, ('1 "1%G1%,%*+"+-'* +' #% -=">-*"+-/%S "*2 9'L +9-, 1%$"+%, +' '1 -*($3%*4%, +9%/"1-'3, ('1=, '( %*>">%=%*+ '1 G1'Y%4+ -*/'$/-*> -=">-*-*>Z

R%S )9" F""' ,+7 $ b.%,%"' 011+H.# !9% *"+31% "*2 3*-+< '( -=">-*-*> -, '( +9%'1%+-4"$ -*+%1%,+ #'+9 -* -+,%$("*2 -* 1%$"+-'* +' ="*< -=G'1+"*+ ",G%4+, '( '31 $-/%,Z W3+ +9% >%*%1"$ -*[+%1%,+ -*9%1%*+ -* +9% i3%,+-'* '( L9%+9%1 L% 4"* G1'/-2% " 3*-(-%2 +9%'1<'( -=">-*-*> "*2 +9% ,->*-(-4"*+ 1'$% '( -=">-*-*>, -* '31 =%*+"$ $-/%, "1%

H J%%S ('1 -*,+"*4%S +9% ,X%G+-4-,= 8 %.G1%,,%2 -* W322 U5II?VS e'GX-*, U5IIOV` 49Z 5S\'$$9%-= U?RR@V "*2 P'1,49 U?R5?4V 8 "#'3+ +9% %.-,+%*4% '( +9% ,G%4-(-4 ('1= '(-=">-*-*> ,%%-*> +9% 2%G-4+%2S L9-49 \"$+'* 1%(%1, +' -* 9-, "44'3*+ '( G-4+'1-"$ %.[

G%1-%*4% U,%% \"$+'* U5IIRV` 49Z OS "*2 U?RR?VVZ


23/501

M ;.#7+'H1#%+.

*'+ +9% '*$< ='+-/"+-'*, ('1 +9% ,%"149 '( " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+Z !9% %.G%4+"[+-'* +9"+ +9% 4%*+1"$ 4",%, '( -=">-*-*>, ,9"1% " 4'=='* *"+31% "1-,%, "$,'

(1'= +9% *%%2 +' %.G$"-* +L' ("4+, "#'3+ '31 "4+3"$ +1%"+=%*+ '( ,349 1%G[1%,%*+"+-'*,Z

!9% (-1,+ -, ,-=G$< +9"+S %/%* "(+%1 2-,4'3*+-*> +9% $%,, '#/-'3, 4",%,SL% 2' >1'3G +'>%+9%1 " $"1>% /"1-%+< '( =%*+"$ '44311%*4%, -* +9% 4$",, '(-=">-*-*>,S L9-$% %.4$32-*> ="*< '+9%1,Z !93, L% "44%G+ /-,3"$-,-*>S ,3G[ G',-*>S 2"%2 L-+9 (-4+-'*,S %=G"+9-g-*>S "*2 ,' '*S", G"1"2->= -*,+"*4%, '( -=">-*-*>S '1 "+ $%",+ ", %,,%*+-"$$< -*/'$/-*>,349 -*,+"*4%,b #3+ *'+ ,%%-*>S Y32>-*>S 2%$-#%1"+-*>S '1 (%%$-*> "* %='+-'*

'1 2%,-1%Z 0( ,349 -=">-*-*>, 9"2 *'+9-*> -* 4'=='* L-+9 %"49 '+9%1S #3+,9"1%2 (%"+31%, L-+9 +9% *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"S +9-, +%*2%*4< -* 9'LL% 4"+%>'1-,% =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*" L'3$2 #% 1"+9%1 = 4$",,-(-4"[+-'*, "1% ,+"#$%S "*2 +9"+ L% 3,3"$$< 9"/% " >''2 >1",G '( L9%+9%1 8 +9'3>9

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i3'S '1 '( +9% 2">>%1VZ W3+S -* =',+ 4",%,S L% "1% *'+ -* 2'3#+ "#'3+ L9%+9[%1 ,'=% =%*+"$ %G-,'2% -, "* -*,+"*4% '( -=">-*-*>Z !9%,% +91%% ",G%4+, '(+9% ,+"#-$-+< '( '31 1%$%/"*+ 4$",,-(-4"+-'*S +''S ,+1'*>$< ,3>>%,+ +9% %.-,+[%*4% '( " 4%1+"-* X-*2 '( 3*-+< "='*> -=">-*-*>,S +' L9-49 L% (31+9%1='1%9"/% %",< %G-,+%=-4 "44%,,S #3+ L9-49 -, ,+-$$ -* L"*+ '( (31+9%1 %$34-2"+-'*Z


24/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. C

7+9%1L-,%S -+ L'3$2 #% /%1< 2-((-43$+ +' %.G$"-* +9% (-1=*%,, "*2 %",% L-+9L9-49 L% +"X% +9% ,'=%+-=%, /%1< 2-((%1%*+ -*,+"*4%, '( -=">-*-*> +' #% '(

+9% ,"=% X-*2S "*2 L9< -+ -, +9"+ +9%= -*,+"*4%, '( -=">-*-*>,Z

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

1%"$-,+-4 9'G% ('1 " ='1% G',-+-/% +9%'1< '( +9% 4'=='* *"+31% '( -=">-*[-*>, ,9'3$2 '3+L%->9 "*< 2'3#+, "#'3+ +9% G',,-#-$-+< '( " 3*-(-%2 49"1"4[+%1-,"+-'* '( -=">-*-*>Z 0+ -, +93, 1%",'*"#$% +' 2%="*2 (1'= " +9%'1< '(-=">-*-*> +9"+ -+ "44'3*+ ('1 +9% ("4+ +9"+ L% 4$",,-(< " $"1>% /"1-%+< '( G9%[*'=%*" ", -=">-*"+-/%b "*2 +9% ("4+ +9"+ +9-, 4$",,-(-4"+-'* -, *'+ " G31% 4'[-*4-2%*4% '1 4'*/%*+-'*Z B 3*-(-%2 +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> G1'=-,%, +' G1'/-2%,349 "* %.G$"*"+-'* #< +1%"+-*> +9%,% ("4+, ", " 4'*,%i3%*4% '( +9% G1%,[%*4% '( 4%1+"-* (%"+31%, ,9"1%2 %.4$3,-/%$< #< "$$ -=">-*-*>,Z

R%%S )97"" C$%. )9"+7%"/ +, ;5$4%.%.4

!9-, 1"-,%, +9% i3%,+-'* '( L9-49 G1'G',"$, ('1 " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -="[>-*-*> "1% '* '((%1 "*2 ,9'3$2 #% 4'*,-2%1%2Z \9%* $''X-*> "+ +9% +9%'1-%,'( -=">-*-*> G3+ ('1L"12 -* +9% G9-$','G9-4"$ +1"2-+-'*S +91%% ="Y'1 1%431[1-*> +9%=%, 4"* #% -2%*+-(-%2` +9% 1%$"+-'*,9-G U'1 $"4X +9%1%'(V '( -=">-*["+-/% 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*, +' 1%"$-+


25/501

O ;.#7+'H1#%+.

G1-*4-G"$ L"-*-*> ="< #% %$34-2"+%2` -* +%1=, '( +9%-1 -11%$%/"*4% ('1

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

('3*2 -* +9% $-+%1"+31% -2%*+-(< " $"4X '( 4'>*-+-/% 4'*4%1* L-+9 1%"$-+< "*2S%,G%4-"$$-*-*>,Z P-((%1%*+ /%1,-'*, '( +9-, "GG1'"49 ="< /"1< -*9'L +9%< 49"1"4+%1-,% +9% ",,3=%2 $"4X '( 4'>*-+-/% 4'*4%1*ZC

0+ -, 4'*4%-/"#$% +9"+ " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> ="< "$,' #% ('1=3[$"+%2 -* +%1=, '( +9%-1 ,G%4-(-4 -*,->*-(-4"*4% ('1 '31 "4+-/% %*>">%=%*+

M B$+9'3>9 -+ =->9+ #% G',,-#$% +' %*2'1,% " /-%L +9"+ 49"1"4+%1-,%, -=">-*-*>, -*+%1=, '( +9%-1 1%$"+-'*,9-G #'+9 +' 1%"$-+< "*2 +' ">%*4< UL-+9'3+ "$,' +1"4-*> #"4X

'*% 1%$"+-'*,9-G +' +9% '+9%1VS ,349 "* "GG1'"49 +' -=">-*-*> L'3$2 ,%%= +' #% '/%1[4'=G$%.Z B, L-$$ #%4'=% 4$%"1 -* +9% ,3#,%i3%*+ 49"G+%1,S 1%(%1%*4% +' +9% G1%,%*4%"*2 *"+31% '( '*% X-*2 '( 1%$"+-'*,9-G ,3((-4%, +' "44'3*+ ('1 +9% 2-,+-*4+-/% *"+31% '(-=">-*-*> "*2S -( *%4%,,"1


26/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. I

L-+9 +9% L'1$2Z !9% -2%" -, +9"+ -=">-*-*>, 8 -* 4'*+1",+ +'S ," 3, L-+9 -*('1="+-'* "#'3+ '31 1%$%/"*+ %*[/-1'*=%*+S '1 "#'3+ "2%i3"+% =%"*, +' "49-%/% '31 >'"$,VZ e'L%/%1S +9%4$"-= +9"+ -=">-*-*>, $"4X " >3-2-*> 1'$% -* ">%*4< 4"* #% +1"4%2 #"4X +'+9% -2%" +9"+ +9%< $"4X " 4'>*-+-/% 4'*4%1* L-+9 +9% L'1$2` +9%< 4"**'+>3-2% 3, -* "4+-'* #%4"3,% +9%< 2' *'+ G1'/-2% 3, L-+9 X*'L$%2>% "#'3++9% 1%$%/"*+ ",G%4+, '( 1%"$-+< U-Z%ZS +9% %*/-1'*=%*+ "*2 +9% =%"*,VZ !9%-2%" +9"+ -=">-*-*>, 4"**'+ ='/% 3, +' "4+S '* +9% '+9%1 9"*2S -, *'+ '*$<4'*+1'/%1,-"$ U,%% :'+% 5M -* )9"G+%1 5Vb -+ "$,' 2'%, *'+ 2-,+-*>3-,9 +9%=

(1'= ="*< *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"Z e%*4%S -+ -, *'+ /%1< G1'=-,-*> +'('1=3$"+% " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> ,G%4-(-4"$$< -* +%1=, '( +9%-1,%%=-*> 3*-=G'1+"*4% ('1 '31 "4+-'*,b "*2 *'+ /%1< ,31G1-,-*> +9"+ +9%('43, -* +9% $-+%1"+31% '* -=">-*-*> 9", 1"+9%1 #%%* '* +9% "GG"1%*+ $"4X '(4'>*-+-/% 4'*4%1*Z

!9% !"8".'".1: 011+H.# S #< 4'*+1",+S G3+, %=G9",-, '* +9% ",*-+-'*,Z 0+ "1>3%, +9"+ -=">-*"+-/% G9%[*'=%*" "1% 4'*,+-+3+-/%$< 2%G%*2%*+ '* "*2S 9%*4%S 9"/% +' #% %$34-2"+%2

#< 1%(%1%*4% +' +9%-1 4'>*-+-/% 4'3*+%1G"1+,Z \9-$% 4'>*-+-'*, %.-,+ "*2 4"* #% ="2% ,%*,% '( -*2%G%*2%*+$< '( -=">-*-*>,S +9% 'GG',-+% -, ("$,%Z 61'[ G'*%*+, '( +9% P%G%*2%*4< B44'3*+ 2-,">1%% "#'3+ +9% *"+31% '( +9% X-*2'( 2%G%*2%*4< 4'*4%1*%2ZO 69-$','G9%1, -* +9% e3=%"* +1"2-+-'*S ('1 %.["=G$%S ('43, '* +9% -2%" +9"+ -=">-*-*>, 2%G%*2 '* 4'>*-+-'*, -* ,' ("1 ",+9%< 1%G1%,%*+ +9%= UG',,-#$< 23% +' " ,3-+"#$% 4"3,"$ $-*XVZ B*'+9%1 G1'=[-*%*+ "GG1'"49 -, +' ",,3=% +9"+S -* ,'=% ,%*,%S -=">-*-*>, -=-+"+% '1=-=-4 4'>*-+-'*, 8 ('1 -*,+"*4%S -* +9% ,9"G% '( '(([$-*% ,-=3$"+-'* '1 -**%1 G1%+%*,%Z W%,-2%,S -+ -, L-2%$< "44%G+%2 +9"+ +9%1% -, "$,' ,'=% ('1= '( ,%[="*+-4 2%G%*2%*4*-+-'* U-Z%ZS -* G%1[

O e3=% U5C@IV` 5Z5Z5ZM((Z "*2 5Z@ZCZCVS "*2 7NJ9"3>9*%,,< U?RRRV` @M@S %*2'1,% +9%1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$ /%1,-'* '( +9% P%G%*2%*4< B44'3*+ ('1 "$$ ('1=, '( %G-,'2-4 -="[>-*-*>b L9-$% 6%"4'4X% U5IOHV` ??S T"1+-* U?RR5V` ?C@ "*2 U?RR?V` KRKS "*2 P'1,49U?R5R4V "44%G+ +9-, /-%L ('1 ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*>,b "*2 P'1,49 U?R55#V 8 L9-49 -,='1% '1 $%,, -2%*+-4"$ L-+9 )9"G+%1 55 8 ('1 %='+-'*"$ -=">-*-*>,Z )311-% dQ"/%*,41'(+ U?RR?V` KIS "*2 Q


27/501

5R ;.#7+'H1#%+.

4%-/-*>S ,%*,-*>S Y32>-*>S "*2 ,' '*V "*2 2%/%$'G-*> +9% 1%$%/"*+ 1%4'>*-[+-'*"$ "*2 4'*4%G+3"$ 4"G"4-+-%,Z

E-*"$$ +9%=` Y32>%=%*+"$ +9'3>9+, '1 '44311%*+ #%$-%(, +9"+ "1% ('1=%2 -*1%,G'*,% +' %G-,+%=-4 1%",'*,b %G-,'2-4 =%='1-%, +9"+ "1% 2%+%1=-*%2 #<

G",+ %.G%1-%*4%,b G%14%G+-'*, "*2 ,%*,"+-'*, +9"+ "1% 2%+%1=-*%2 #< +9%-1%.+%1*"$ '#Y%4+,b "*2 2%/-"*+$< 4"3,%2 -*,+"*4%, '( +9% %"49 '( +9% G1%4%2[-*> 4'>*-+-/% X-*2, '( %G-,'2%Z B>"-*S 2-,+-*4+ /%1,-'*, '( +9% B>%*4< B4[4'3*+ /"1< -* 9'L %."4+$< +9%< -*2-/-23"+% +9% "4+-/% 49"1"4+%1 2-,+-*4+-/%'( -=">-*-*>,ZI

!9% G"1+-43$"1 /%1,-'*S +9"+ 0 -*+%*2 +' G3+ ('1L"12 -* +9-, #''XS ="-*[+"-*, +9"+ -=">-*-*>, "1% =%*+"$ "4+-'*,S +9"+ "-= "+ +9% "4+-/% "*2 2-1%4+('1="+-'* '( =%*+"$ 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*, L-+9 ,G%4-(-4 4'*+%*+,Z !9% 1%i3-1%[

=%*+ '( 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$ ,G%4-(-4-+< 2%="*2, +9"+ +9% 3*2%1$ ='+-/"[+-'*"$ ,+"+%, U%Z>ZS +1,S 2%,-1%, '1 -*+%*+-'*,V 2%+%1=-*% L9-49 G"1+-43$"1(%"+31%, "1% +' #% 1%G1%,%*+%2 ", #%-*> -*,+"*+-"+%2 #< L9-49 G"1+-43$"1 '#[ Y%4+,b L9-$% +9% 2-1%4+*%,, 1%i3-1%=%*+ -, =%"*+ +' %*,31% +9"+ +9% ='+-/"[+-'*"$ ,+"+%, %*2 3G 2%+%1=-*-*> +9% 4'*+%*+ '( +9% ('1=%2 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*,L-+9'3+ ="X-*> 3,% '( %G-,+%=-4 '1 =%1%$< 4"3,"$ =%49"*-,=, '( 4'*+%*+2%+%1=-*"+-'* k "*2S *'+"#$%*4< B44'3*+ U'1 ,'=%+9-*> /%1< =349 $-X% -+V 9", #%%* %*2'1,%2 #-*-*>, U,%%S ('1 -*,+"*4%S 9-, U5IOK#V` /'$Z 00S ,%4Z M@ "*2 M?Cb ,%% "$,' W322U5IOIV` 5RK((ZVZ


28/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. 55

e'L%/%1S ,-*4% +9% G1%,%*+ #''X -, *'+ '*$< (-*-+% -* -+, $%*>+9S #3+ "$,' G1-="1-$< 4%*+1%2 '* +9% -,,3% '( +9% 3*-+< '( -=">-*-*> "*2 "-=%2 "+ >-/[

-*> " #"$"*4%2 '/%1/-%L '( +9% /"1-'3, "GG1'"49%, +' +9-, -,,3%S +9% 2-,43,[,-'* '( +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+ 9", +' #% 4'*(-*%2 +' 1'3>9$< +9% ,"=% *3=#%1'( G">%, ", +9% +L' '+9%1 ="-* +9%'1-%, U'1S -* +9% 4",% '( +9% P%G%*2%*4<B44'3*+S ", -+, =',+ G1'=-,-*> 8 *"=%$< 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$ 8 /%1,-'*VZ !9-,=%"*,S 3*('1+3*"+%$ -=">%, "*2 +9'3>9+, -* 1%$"+-'* +' -="[>-*"+-/% ">%*43%,,-*>S "*2'+9%1 G1'#$%="+-4 4",%, 8 9"/% +' #% $%(+ ('1 "*'+9%1 '44",-'*Z

R%%%S L#9"7 )9"+7%"/ +, ;5$4%.%.4

0* "22-+-'* +' +9% +91%% G"1+, 2%"$-*> L-+9 +9% ="-* +9%'1-%, '( -=">-*-*>S+9%1% -, " ('31+9 "*2 -*+1'234+'1< G"1+ '( +9% #''X -* L9-49S "='*> '+9%1+9-*>,S 0 #1-%($< 4'*,-2%1 "*2 "1>3% ">"-*,+ $%,, -=G'1+"*+ 4'*+%*2%1, ('1 ","+-,("4+'1< "44'3*+ '( +9% 3*-+< '( -=">-*-*>Z J'=% '( +9%,% "22-+-'*"$/-%L, ,+"1+ (1'= +9% ,"=% 8 '1 "+ $%",+ /%1< ,-=-$"1 8 #",-4 -2%", ", +9% FG-[,+%='$'>-4"$S +9% P%G%*2%*4< '1 +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+Z !9-, -, G"1+ '( +9%

%.G$"*"+-'* '( L9< +9%1% "1% ,'=% 4'*,-2%1"#$% '/%1$"G, -* 4'*/-4+-'*,S"1>3=%*+, "*2 ='+-/"+-'*, "='*> +9% -*2-/-23"$ ="Y'1 "*2 =-*'1 /-%L,ZW3+ +9%,% ,9"1%2 %$%=%*+, 2' *'+ 3*2%1=-*% +9% ("4+ +9"+ +9% /"1-'3, "4[4'3*+, '( -=">-*-*> %.4$32% %"49 '+9%1 ", 3*-(-%2 +9%'1-%, -* ,' ("1 ", +9%<-2%*+-(< 2-((%1%*+ (%"+31%, ", +9% (3*2"=%*+"$ 4'*,+-+3%*+, '( +9% 4'=='**"+31% '( +9% '+9%1L-,% 9%+%1'>%*%'3, ('1=, '( -=">-*-*>,Z

7*% "$+%1*"+-/% G1'G',"$ 8 +9% KH$.#%#$#%A" 011+H.# 8 +"X%, -=">-*"+-/%"*2 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*" +' 2-((%1 ,'$%$< -* 2%>1%% U%Z>ZS " 2-((%1[

%*4% -* /-/"4-+-*-*>, "1% ",,3=%2


29/501

5? ;.#7+'H1#%+.

+' G',,%,, +9% ,"=% %,,%*4% ", +9%-1 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% 4'3*+%1G"1+,Z5R

!9% Q9".+5".$& 011+H.# ",,3=%, +9% =',+ #",-4 2-((%1%*4%, #%+L%%*

-=">-*"+-/% "*2 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*" +' #% G9%*'=%*"$ -* *"+31%`+9"+ -,S +' #% 2-((%1%*4%, -* L9"+ +9% 1%,G%4+-/% %G-,'2%, "1% ,3#Y%4+-/%$<$-X%Z B44'12-*>$-*-*>, +9"+ +9%< -*2%%29$A" " 4%1+"-* X-*2 '( '#Y%4+S "++-+32% '1 '1->-*Z!9% L.#+&+4%1$& 011+H.# S ('1 -*,+"*4%S %$34-2"+%, +9% 2-,+-*4+-/% 49"1"4[

+%1 '( -=">-*-*>, -* +%1=, '( +9% ,G%4-(-4 *"+31% '( +9% -=">-*%2 %*+-+-%,Z!9% 4%*+1"$ -2%" -, +9"+ +9%1% -, " 4"+%>'1-4"$ '*+'$'>-4"$ 2-((%1%*4% #%+L%%*'#Y%4+, L9-49 "1% G%14%-/%2S 1%=%=#%1%2 '1 Y32>%2 +' #% " 4%1+"-* L"< "*2'#Y%4+, L9-49 "1% /-,3"$-,%2 '1 ,3GG',%2 +' #% " 4%1+"-* L"-*%2 "*2 4'>*-,%2 '#Y%4+, 2-((%1 -* +9%-1 + "44'3*+V +9%-1 ='2"$ ,+"+3,Z55

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

5R !9% -2%" +9"+ G%14%G+-'*, "*2 -=">-*-*>, 2-((%1 =%1%$< -* /-/"4-+< -, 4%*+1"$ +'e3=%N, /-%L U,%% J%4+-'* IZ5VZ )'=G"1% "$,' e'GX-*,N U?R55"V "GG1'"49 +' ,%*,'1<=%='1-%,S "44'12-*> +' L9-49 +9%< #%$'*> +' +9% 4$",, '( ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*>, "*22-((%1 =%1%$< 4'*+%.+3"$$< (1'= -+, *'*[=*%='*-4 =%=#%1,Z

55 J'=% '( +9%,% -2%", 4"* #% ('3*2 -* J"1+1% U5IKRV "*2 )",%< U5ICMVS ('1 -*,+"*4%Z5? !9% /-%L G1%,%*+%2 -* \9-+% U5IIRV 4'=%, 4$',% +' +9% T'2"$ B44'3*+S "$+9'3>9

\9-+% G1%,3="#$< 2'%, *'+ -*+%*2 +' 1%,+1-4+ -=">-*-*>, '*$< +' =%1% G',,-#-$-+-%,Z


30/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. 5@

+9-*>, "4+3"$$< "1%S #3+ "#'3+ 9'L +9-*>, =->9+ G',,-#$< #%Z!9% 1%,3$+-*> ='2"$ +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> -,S -* ("4+S *'+9-*> #3+ " ,G%[

4-(-4 /%1,-'* '( +9% 0##%#H'" 011+H.# S "44'12-*> +' L9-49 +9% 2-((%1%*4% #%+L%%* -=">-*"+-/% "*2 4'>*-+-/% %G-,'2%, -, (3*2"=%*+"$$< "++-+32-*"$ZT-*-="$$*-+-/% "++-+32% 8 +9"+ -,S+9% 4'==-+=%*+ +9"+ 1%"$-+< -, Y3,+ $-X% +9%< 1%G1%,%*+ -+ +' #% 8 L9-$% -="[>-*-*>, $"4X -+Z ;%1,-'*, '( +9% B++-+32% B44'3*+ ="< ,+"< *%3+1"$ '* +9% -,[,3% '( L9%+9%1 +9-, =%"*, +9"+ -=">-*-*>, G',,%,, -*,+%"2 " 2-,+-*4+-/%$<-=">-*"+-/% "++-+32%Z e'L%/%1S +9% *%%2 +' 2-,+-*>3-,9 -=">-*"+-/% %G-,['2%, *'+ '*$< (1'= 4'>*-+-/% %G-,'2%,S #3+ "$,' (1'= '+9%1 X-*2, '( %G-,'2%

9", ='/%2 G1'G'*%*+, '( +9% B++-+32% B44'3*+ +' ",,3=% +9"+ -=">-*-*>,"1% *'*[*%3+1"$ ", L%$$S "*2 +' ,G%4-(< +9% 4'==-+=%*+ 2-,+-*4+-/% '( -="[>-*-*>, -* ='1% G',-+-/% +%1=,S ,349 ", #< 1%(%1%*4% +' "* "4+ '( G',-+-*>%*+-+-%, ", *'*[%.-,+%*+S "#,%*+ '1S -*2%%2S *'*["4+3"$Z5@

:%.+ 4'=%, +9% P8+.#$."%#: 011+H.# L9-49 ="-*+"-*, +9"+ -=">-*-*>,2-((%1 (1'= 4'>*-+-'*, -* +9%-1 ,G%4-(-4 '1->-* -* +9% 8 /'$3*+"1< '1 -*/'$3*[+"1< 8 a,G'*+"*%-+ -*4"1*"+-'*S +9% /-%L

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e3,,%1$ U?RRMVS J"1+1% U5IKRV "*2 )",%<U5ICMVZ


31/501

5K ;.#7+'H1#%+.

1%,-,+, "*< "++%=G+, +' #1-*> +9%= 3*2%1 /'$3*+"1< 4'*+1'$Z5K

E-*"$$*-+-/% ,4-%*4%,Z 0* '+9%1 L'12,S G1'G'*%*+, '( +9-, "GG1'"49 ="-*+"-*+9"+ L9"+ -, 2-,+-*4+-/% "#'3+ -=">-*-*>, -, +9"+ +9%< "1% ,3#G%1,'*"$$<('1=%2 -* " ,G%4-"$ L"-*"+-/%N "1%", -* +9% #1"-*S '1 #< =%"*, '( 4%1+"-* a-=">-*"+-/%N L""*2S -( ,'S L9"+ +9%-1 *"+31% -,Z B44'12-*>$*-+-/% ,4-%*4%, "1% 9 +' ('1=3$"+% " ,"+-,("4+'1< 3*-(-%2 +9%'1-*-*> 9", *'+ #%%* '( =349 ,4-[%*+-(-4 -*+%1%,+S "*2 +9"+S 9%*4%S +9% 1%$%/"*+ ,+32-%, 9"/% +,b "*2 G9-$'[

,'G9%1, ="< #% %*>">%2 -* %.G%1-=%*+"$ -*/%,+->"+-'*,Z W3+ G9-$','G9-4"$ =%+9'2'[$'>< -, *'+ -+,%$( %.G%1-=%*+"$ 8 "+ $%",+ *'+ -* +9% ,%*,% '( #%-*> 4'*4%1*%2 L-+9 +9%2%,->*-*> "*2 4"11 '3+ '( 1%G%"+%2 '#,%1/"+-'*, '1 %.G%1-=%*+, L-+9 1%G$-4"#$%1%,3$+,Z !9-, -, +13% %/%* '( +9% ,'[4"$$%2 a%=G-1-4"$N '1 a%.G%1-=%*+"$N G9-$','G9


32/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. 5H

'* G"1+-43$"1 ('1=, '( -=">-*-*>S *'+"#$< /-,3"$-,-*> "*2 #%$-%([$-X% -="[>-*-*>Z5M \9"+ +9-, ="< 1%($%4+ -, +9"+ +9% =%*+"$ 4"+%>'1< '( -=">-*-*> -,

G%19"G, *'+ " /%1< -*+%1%,+-*> 4"+%>'1< L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' +9% ,3#G%1,'*"$$%/%$b L9-$%S ", *'+%2 "#'/%S -+ G$"-*-*>, '* +9% G%1,'*"$ $%/%$ 8 ('1 -*,+"*4%S '*% 4'11%$"+% ('1%"49 '( +9% #",-4, ('1= '( -=">-*-*>Z !9"+ -,S -+ -, 3*4$%"1 L9%+9%1 ,3494'11%$"+%, *%%2 +' ,9"1% " ,4-%*+-(-4"$$< -*+%1%,+-*> (%"+31% -* /-1+3% '(L9-49 +9%< 4'3*+ ", 4'11%$"+%, '( '*% "*2 +9% ,"=% G%1,'*"$ $%/%$ G9%[*'=%*'* U-Z%ZS -=">-*-*>VZ E'1 -*,+"*4%S >1%%* 8 '1S ='1% >%*%1"$$-*-*> +' %=G"+9 8 G"1+$< #",%2 '* +9% L'1X #< :-49'$, d J+-49 U?RR@V 8 "*2 "GG$< -+ +'/"1-'3, G9-$','G9-4"$ G1'#$%=, 8 *"=%$< +9% G1'#$%=, '( %='+-'*"$ 1%,G'*,%, +'(-4+-'* U,%% )9"G+%1 55VS '( -=">-*"+-/% 1%,-,+"*4%S "*2 '( 2-,+-*>3-,9-*> -=">-*-*>(1'= ,3GG',-*> U,%% :'+% 5O -* )9"G+%1 5VZ W< 4'*+1",+S +9% %=G-1-4"$$< -*('1=%22%#"+% "#'3+ +9% *"+31% '( ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*> 9", #%%* $"1>%$< 2'=-*"+%2 #< +9%2-,G3+% #%+L%%* D',,$1'3G%2 +'>%+9%1 -*+%1=, '( +9%-1 2-,G',-+-'*"$ G'L%1 +' #1-*> "#'3+ " 4%1+"-* G"++%1* '( ,+-=3$"+-'* -*


33/501

5M ;.#7+'H1#%+.

+9% *%31'(3*4+-'*"$ 4'11%$"+%, '( -=">-*-*>Z W%,-2%,S +9% G1',G%4+, '( ,%[431-*> " ,"+-,("4+'1< 3*-(-%2 +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> "1% $-X%$< +' 2L-*2$% (31[

+9%1S +9% ='1% 1%='/%2 (1'= +9% G%1,'*"$ $%/%$ "* "44'3*+ #%4'=%,Z 6%1[9"G,S >%*%1"$-+< -, +' #% 9"2 '*$< /%1< 4$',% +' 8 '1S -*2%%2S '*$< "+ 8 +9%$%/%$ '( +9%'1-,-*> "#'3+ G%1,'*,Z

T< ,%4'*2 1%",'* ('1 *'+ (31+9%1 -*/%,+->"+-*> +9% G1',G%4+, '( +9% J3#[ G%1,'*"$ B44'3*+ -, +9"+ -+ -, *'+ 1%"$$< -* 4'=G%+-+-'* L-+9 +9% 3*-(-%2 +9%['1-%, "-=-*> +' 4"G+31% +9% G%1,'*"$ $%/%$ '( -=">-*-*>Z Q"+9%1S +9% +L'X-*2, '( "44'3*+ ,9'3$2 #% ,%%* ", 4'=G$%=%*+-*> %"49 '+9%1Z \9-$% +9% G1%/-'3,$< -*+1'234%2 +9%'1-%, "-= +' 4"G+31% +9% *"+31% '( -=">-*-*> -* 1%[

$"+-'* +' ,3#Y%4+-/%$< "44%,,-#$% (%"+31%, U%Z>ZS 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$-+-*S G",,-/-+*-+-/% ,4-%*4%, 8 9"/% 2-((%1%*+ >'"$, "*2%=G$'< 2-,+-*4+ *'+-'*, '( (3*2"=%*+"$-+ +9"+ ="X%, >''2 ,%*,% '( +9% 3*-+< '( +9% /"1-'3, ('1=, '( -="[>-*-*> '* +9% G%1,'*"$ $%/%$S -+ L'3$2 #% *' 1%",'* +' 1%/-,% '1 >-/% 3G +9-, G9-$','G9-4"$ /-%L +9"+ +9% 4'>*-+-/% ,4-%*4%, L%1% +' 1%/%"$ +9"+ +9%1% "1%

+9% 1%$%/"*+ 'GG'*%*+ G1'4%,,-*> 49"**%$, 8 "*2S 9%*4%S +' #1-*> "#'3+ 4%1+"-* G9%[*'=%*"$$< -*2-/-23"+%2 4'$'31 %.G%1-%*4%,Z e'L%/%1S (1'= +9% G%1,G%4+-/% '( G9 $->9+,31("4%, 1%($%4+S #3+ *'+ '( +9% %.+%*+ +' L9-49 ,31("4%, ,+-=3$"+% +9% 'GG'*%*+ G1'[4%,,-*> ,


34/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. 5C

*' ,->*-(-4"*+ '1 -*+%1%,+-*> 4'=='*"$-+-%, "='*> "$$ +9% 2-((%1%*+ -*[,+"*4%, '( -=">-*-*>Z 0*,+%"2S "*2 -* +9% "#,%*4% '( (31+9%1 1%",'*, +'

i3%,+-'* +9% G9-$','G9-4"$ /-%LS -+ L'3$2 #% ='1% 1%",'*"#$% +' 4'*4$32%+9"+ -=">-*-*>S ", " G%1,'*"$[$%/%$ G9%*'=%*'*S 9", *' ,-*>$% 4'11%$"+% '*+9% ,3#G%1,'*"$ $%/%$Z J-=-$"1$-/%* 3G -( +9%< 4'*+1"2-4+%=G-1-4"$$< L%$$[,3GG'1+%2 /%1,-'*, '( +9% J3#G%1,'*"$ B44'3*+ U-( +9%1%"1% "*-*-*>

+%$$ +9% 4'>*-+-/% ,4-%*4%, L9"+ +' $''X ('1 U%Z>ZS ('1 +9% *%31'(3*4+-'*"$4'11%$"+% '( " G"1+-43$"1 X-*2 '( =%*+"$ ">%*4-4"$S +9% P%G%*2%*4< "*2 +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+Z 0+ 2'%, ,' -* +91%%,+%G,Z

E-1,+S -+ ,G%4-(-%, +9% +L' ="-* 2%,-2%1"+" ('1 "*< 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '(-=">-*-*>` %.+%*,-'*"$ "2%i3"4< "*2 %.G$"*"+'1< G'L%1 U,%% )9"G+%1 5VZB, G"1+ '( +9-, 49"1"4+%1-,"+-'*S 6"1+ 7*% -*/'$/%, " 49"1"4+%1-,"+-'* '( +9%

(-/% 4%*+1"$ ('1=, '( -=">-*-*> +' #% 3*-(-%2` ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*>S "((%4+-/%-=">-*-*>S -*+%$$%4+3"$ -=">-*-*>S %.G%1-%*+-"$ -=">-*-*>S "*2 -=">-*"+-/% G1'Y%4+, U,%% )9"G+%1 5VZ 0+ "$,' -*4$32%, " 2%,41-G+-'* '( +9% ="-* (%"+31%,'( -=">-*"+-/% %G-,'2%, +' #% %.G$"-*%2 8 =',+ *'+"#$< +9%-1 $"4X '( " 4'>[*-+-/% "++-+32% "*2 '( "* %G-,+%=-4 (3*4+-'* 8 "*2S -*2%%2S G1'/-2%, " (-1,++%*+"+-/% 1%",'* ('1 +9% %*2'1,%=%*+ '( +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+S *"=%$< +9"+ -+

5O J%% P'1,49 U?R5R#V "*2 P'1,49 U?R5R"V ('1 " ,-=-$"1 2-/-,-'* '( $"#'31 #%+L%%* G9-$','G9< "*2 +9% %=G-1-4"$ ,4-%*4%, -* +9% 4",% '( 4'$'31, "*2 '( 9"$$34-*"+-'*,S1%,G%4+-/%$


35/501

5O ;.#7+'H1#%+.

G1'=-,%, +9% #%,+ %.G$"*"+-'* '( +9% i3",-['#,%1/"+-'*"$-+< '( ,%*,'1< -="[>-*-*>, U,%% )9"G+%1, ?(ZVZ

J%4'*2S 6"1+ 7*% -, 4'*4%1*%2 L-+9 +9% 1%$"+-'*,9-G #%+L%%* -=">-*-*>"*2 X*'L$%2>%Z 0* G"1+-43$"1S -+ "1>3%, +9"+ 4%1+"-* -*,+"*4%, '( ,%*,'1<-=">-*-*> 4"* 4'*,+-+3+% X*'L$%2>% -* " L"< /%1< ,-=-$"1 +' +9"+ '( G%1[4%G+3"$ %.G%1-%*4%, "*2S -* 1%,G'*,% +' +9-, '#,%1/"+-'*S ",X, -* L9-49,%*,% U-( "*-*-*> $-,+%2 "#'/% U,%% )9"G+%1 HVZ !9% '*$< %.4%G+-'*,

"1% +9% )"3,"$ B44'3*+ "*2 +9% J3#Y%4+-'* +' +9% \-$$ B44'3*+S L9-49 "1% #1-%($< 2-,43,,%2 -* +9% )9"G+%1, I "*2 5@S 1%,G%4+-/%$%2 -*"#-$-+< '( -=">-*[-*>, +' #% 1%$-"#$% '1 1"+-'*"$$< -*+%>1"+%2 L-+9 '31 G-4+31% '( 1%"$-+-*-*>, "*2 1%/%"$, -+, 4'*+-*3-+< L-+9 ='1% 4'*[+%=G'1"1< a*%'[e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


36/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. 5I

'+9%1 +L' ('1=, '( -=">-*-*>Z 6"1+ !91%% 4'*4$32%, L-+9 " *%>"+-/% ",,%,,[=%*+ '( +9% G1',G%4+, '( 2%/-,-*> " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> #< 1%(%1[

%*4% +' +9% -2%" +9"+ -=">-*-*>, ,-=3$"+% '1 '+9%1L-,% -=-+"+% 4'>*-+-'*,U,%% )9"G+%1 5?VZ

!9% (-*"$ 6"1+ E'31 2%/%$'G, "*2 2%(%*2, +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+ '( -="[>-*-*>Z 0+ 2'%, ,'S (-1,+ '( "$$S #< ,G%$$-*> '3+ +9% ="-* +9%,-, '( +9% +9%'13-,9-*> -+ (1'= +9% J3#Y%4+-'* +' +9% \-$$ B44'3*+ "*2 G1%,%*+-*> "*"1>3=%*+ -* ("/'31 '( +9% %*2'1,%=%*+ '( +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+ U,%%)9"G+%1 5@VZ !9% 4%*+1"$ 4$"-= '( +9-, "44'3*+ -, +9"+ -=">-*-*>, "1% +' #%-2%*+-(-%2 L-+9 =%*+"$ "4+-'*, +9"+ 9"/% +9% G31G',% '( G1'234-*> =%*+"$

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

'44311-*> -=">%, "*2 +9'3>9+, U,%% )9"G+%1 5KVZT"*< '( +9% G"1+,S 49"G+%1, "*2 ,%4+-'*, '( +9% #''X "1% ='1% '1 $%,,,%$([4'*+"-*%2 "*2 4"* #% 1%"2 ("-1$< -*2%G%*2%*+$< '( +9% '+9%1,Z F*>">%[=%*+ L-+9 6"1+ !L' "*2 +9% FG-,+%='$'>-4"$ B44'3*+ 1%i3-1%, ="-*$<X*'L$%2>% '( )9"G+%1 5 "*2 J%4+-'*, ?Z5(ZS "$+9'3>9 1%"2-*> "+ $%",+ +9%(-1,+ 9"$( '( )9"G+%1 K L-$$ #% 9%$G(3$ ", L%$$Z 0* "22-+-'*S +9% 1%"2%1 ="<2%4-2% +' ,X-G =',+ '( )9"G+%1 M "*2 "$$ '( )9"G+%1 C -( U,V9% -, *'+ -*+%1[%,+%2 -* +9% 2%+"-$, '( 7NJ9"3>9*%,,-*, L-+9 " #1-%(,3=%*+, '( 7NJ9"3>9*%,,%*4< B44'3*+V G1%,3GG',% %/%* $%,, +9"* 6"1+ !L'S *"=%$< 1%"$$< *'+ =349 ='1% +9"* "4[i3"-*+"*4% L-+9 +9% 4'*+%*+ '( )9"G+%1 5S ", L%$$ ", G%19"G, J%4+-'*, ?Z5(ZZW'+9 )9"G+%1 5R "*2 )9"G+%1 55 8 '* ,%*,'1< "*2 '* %='+-'*"$ -=">-*-*>S1%,G%4+-/%$< 8 4"* #% 1%"2 $"1>%$< '* +9%-1 'L*S L9-49 -, -* G"1+ 23% +' +9%("4+ +9"+ +9%< "1% #",%2 '* G1%/-'3,$< G3#$-,9%2 ="+%1-"$Z J-=-$"1$


37/501

?R ;.#7+'H1#%+.

43,,-'* '( +9% U*%'[Ve3=%"* "GG1'"49 +' -=">-*-*> "*2 -+, 1%Y%4+-'* ", "3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ -* )9"G+%1 I -, 1%$"+-/%$< ,%$([4'*+"-*%2b ", -, +9% 2-,43,[

,-'* '( +9% -2%" +9"+ -=">-*-*>, -=-+"+% 4'>*-+-'*, -* )9"G+%1 5?Z )9"G+%15@ 4'*,+-+3+%, " 1%",'*"#$< (1%%[,+"*2-*> /-*2-4"+-'* '( +9% B>%*4< B4[4'3*+S L-+9 ,'=% "22-+-'*"$ ,3GG'1+ #< )9"G+%1 5KZ W%,-2%,S +9% )9"G+%1,5S ?S @ "*2 H -* 6"1+ 7*% ="< #% 3,%2 ", -*+1'234+'1< 1%"2-*>, +' +9% +'G-4'( -=">-*-*>S >-/%* +9"+ +9%< 9->9$->9+ +9% ="-* ('1=, "*2 (%"+31%, '( -="[>-*-*> "*2 G'1+1"< ="*< '( +9% +9%'1-%, '( -=">-*-*> +' #% ('3*2 -* +9%$-+%1"+31%Z

B$+9'3>9 +9% '3+$''X "*2 ,+134+31% '( +9% #''X -, G1-="1-$< ,-*-*>S -+ "$,' -*4$32%, ,3#,+"*[+-"$ 41-+-4"$ ,+32-%, '( +9% /-%L, '( G"1+-43$"1 G9-$','G9%1,Z !9%,% /-%L, 2'*'+ "$L"-*-*>S '1 '( ,'=% '( -+, ,G%4-(-4 ('1=, U+9% /-%L, '( e3=% "*2 \-+[+>%*,+%-* "1% >''2 %."=G$%,VZ W3+ %/%* -( *'+S +9%< "1% -*('1="+-/% "*2 -*[,+134+-/% L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' +9% "=#-+-'* +' G1'/-2% " 3*-(-%2 +9%'1< '( -="[>-*-*> "*2S ='1% >%*%1"$$-*-*> L'3$2 2%,%1/% ='1% "++%*+-'*Z W3+ -+-, ,'=% 4'=G%*,"+-'* +9"+ =',+ '( 9-, 1%$%/"*+ "*2 -=G'1+"*+ -2%", ,+-$$ 1%[4%-/% 23% "++%*+-'* -* ,' ("1 ", +9%< 4"* #% ('3*2 ">"-* -* +9% e3,,%1$-"*"44'3*+ 2%(%*2%2 #< J"1+1% U5IKRVZ

E-*"$$%, 2%G%*2 '* '1 "$$32% +' 2-,43,,-'*, -* '+9%1 G"1+,S 49"G+%1,S ,%4+-'*,'1 *'+%, '( +9% #''XZ !91'3>9'3+ +9% +%.+S 0 3,% 4"G-+"$ $%++%1, U"*2 *'"##1%/-"+-'*,V +' 2-,+-*>3-,9 +9%,% -*+%1*"$ 41',,[1%(%1%*4%, (1'= %.+%1*"$1%(%1%*4%, +' G"1+-43$"1 %$%=%*+, '1 G'1+-'*, '( 4-+%2 L'1X,Z


38/501

6"1+ 7*%

!9% :"+31% "*2 ;"1-%+< '( 0=">-*-*>


39/501


40/501

0*+1'234+-'* +' 6"1+ 7*%

!9-, 'G%*-*> G"1+ '( +9% #''X 9", +L' ="-* (3*4+-'*,Z E-1,+S -+ -, -*+%*2%2+' G1'/-2% "* '/%1/-%L '( +91%% 2-((%1%*+ +9-*>,` U-V +9% 2-((%1%*+ ('1=, '(-=">-*-*>b U--V +9%-1 ="-* (%"+31%,b "*2 U---V /"1-'3, 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+, '(-=">-*-*> U-Z%ZS +9',% +9"+ 2-((%1 (1'= +9% +91%% ="-* +9%'1-%, +' #% 2-,[43,,%2 $"+%1 '* -* #%-*> $%,, L%$$[2%/%$'G%2S $%,, G$"3,-#$%S '1 $%,, G1'=-*[%*+ -* +9% $-+%1"+31%VZ 0* ,9'1+S -+ -, =%"*+ +' ,%1/% ", "* -*+1'234+-'* +' +9% G9-$','G9< '( -=">-*-*>Z J%4'*2S +9-, G"1+ "$,' "-=, +' ,%+ +9% ,+">% ('1 +9%

1%,+ '( +9% #''XZ 0* G"1+-43$"1S -+, G31G',% -, +' ,G%4-(< +9% ="-* 2%,-2%1"+"('1 " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> "*2 +' 9->9$->9+ ,'=% (%"+31%, '( -="[>-*"+-/% %G-,'2%, +9"+ "1% +' #%4'=% 4134-"$ 231-*> +9% 3G4'=-*> 2-,43,[,-'*,Z

0* +9% (-1,+ 49"G+%1S 0 ,G%$$ '3+ +9% +L' ="-* 2%,-2%1"+" "*2 $-,+ +9% (-/%4%*+1"$ ('1=, '( -=">-*-*>Z !9% *%.+ +L' 49"G+%1, "1% 2%/'+%2 +' " 2%,41-G[+-'* '( +9% ="-* 2-((%1%*4%, #%+L%%* -=">-*"+-/% "*2 4'>*-+-/% %G-,'2%,"*2S -* G"1+-43$"1S +9%-1 ,%*,'1< X-*2,Z 0* )9"G+%1 ?S 0 9->9$->9+ +9% 2-((%1[%*4%, -* "++-+32% "*2 %G-,+%=-4 (3*4+-'* #%+L%%* -=">-*-*>, "*2 4'>*-[+-'*, "*2 "1>3% +9"+ #'+9 ="< 1%(%1 +' ",G%4+, '( 1%"$-+%Z T'1% ,G%4-(-4"$$


41/501

?K )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

i3%,+-'* J"1+1%N, "*2 \-++>%*,+%-*N, 4$"-= +9"+ -=">-*-*>, ,+1-4+$< 2-((%1(1'= 4'>*-+-'*, -* #%-*> 3*-*('1="+-/%Z !9% (-*"$ 49"G+%1 41-+-4"$$< 2-,[

43,,%, ,-. 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+, '( -=">-*-*> +9"+ "1% 8 #'+9 #%4"3,% '( +9%-1 -*[9%1%*+ L%"X*%,,%, "*2 #%4"3,% '( +9%-1 $%,,%1 G'G3$"1-+< -* +9% 1%4%*+ 2%[ #"+%, "#'3+ +9% *"+31% '( -=">-*-*> 8 '( $%,,%1 -=G'1+"*4% +9"* +9% FG-[,+%='$'>-4"$S +9% P%G%*2%*4< "*2 +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+ +' #% 4'*,-2%1%2 -*+9% ,3#,%i3%*+ G"1+,Z !9% ,-. "44'3*+, -* i3%,+-'* "1% +9% l3"*+-+"+-/%S +9%69%*'=%*"$S +9% 7*+'$'>-4"$S +9% T'2"$S +9% B++-+32% "*2 +9% JG'*+"*%-+<B44'3*+Z !9% 2-,43,,-'* '( " ,%/%*+9 =-*'1 /-%L 8 +9% J3#Y%4+-'* +' +9%\-$$ B44'3*+ 8 9", +' L"-+ 3*+-$ J%4+-'* 5@ZHZ

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


42/501

;.#7+'H1#%+. #+ Q$7# L." ?H

>-*"$Z !9% -=">-*"+-/%*%,, '( " =%*+"$ %G-,'2% -, +9%1%('1% -2%*+-4"$ L-+9-+, >%*%1"$ ,+"+3, ", "* -*,+"*4% '( -=">-*-*>S 1"+9%1 +9"* L-+9 " ,G%4-(-4

i3"$-+< '( -+, 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$-+


43/501


44/501

)eB6!FQ 5

A*-(-%2 B44'3*+, '( 0=">-*-*>

E'1 +9% ",,%,,=%*+ '( +9% ="-* 4"*2-2"+%, ('1 " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*[-*>S -+ -, *%4%,,"1< +' ,"< (-1,+ " #-+ ='1% "#'3+ L9"+ -, 1%i3-1%2 '( ,349 "+9%'1-*-*>S "*2 L9-49 2%(-*[-+%$< *'+Z B44'12-*>$-*[-*>Z

0* +9% (-1,+ ,%4+-'*S 0 ,G%4-(< +L' 2%,-2%1"+" ('1 " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -="[>-*-*>` U"V %.+%*,-'*"$ "2%i3"4< L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' "$$ 4%*+1"$ -=">-*"+-/% "*2*'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"b "*2 U#V %.G$"*"+'1< G'L%1 L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' +9%2-,+-*4+-/% *"+31% '( -=">-*-*>,Z !9% ('$$'L-*> ,%4+-'* $-,+, +9% G"1"2->=-*,+"*4%, '( -=">-*-*> "*2 +9%-1 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% 4'3*+%1G"1+,Z 0* G"1+-43[$"1S 0 2%,41-#% (-/% ="-* ('1=, '( -=">-*-*> L9-49 "*< 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ 9",+' 4"G+31%` U-V ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*>,b U--V "((%4+-/% -=">-*-*>,b U---V -*+%$$%4[+3"$ -=">-*-*>,b U-/V %.G%1-%*+-"$ -=">-*-*>,b "*2 U/V -=">-*"+-/% G1'Y%4+,Z0* "22-+-'*S 0 -*+1'234% +9% ="-* %."=G$%, '( *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"S*'+"#$< 4'>*-+-/% ,+"+%, "*2 G1'Y%4+,Z !9% +9-12 "*2 (-*"$ ,%4+-'* #1-%($<2-,43,,%, +9% ,+"+3, '( 3*4$%"1S 4'*+1'/%1,-"$ '1 #'12%1$-*% -*,+"*4%, '( -="[>-*-*> U%Z>ZS 2-,G',-+-'*"$ -=">-*-*>,S '1 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*, ,


45/501

?O )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

=>= )3+ !"/%'"7$#$

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i3%,[+-'* ,9'3$2 4'*+"-* "$$ G1-="1< %."=G$%, '( -=">-*-*>S #3+ *' G1-="1< %.["=G$%, '( *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"Z 0* +9% *%.+ ,%4+-'*S 0 ,G%4-(< -*='1% 2%+"-$ L9-49 =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*" ,9'3$2 #% +"X%* +' #% 4%*+1"$ 4",%, '(

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

-*>Z


46/501

b.%,%"' 011+H.#/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 ?I

J%4'*2S " +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> -, %.G$"*"+'1-$< G'L%1(3$ '*$< -( -+ G1'/-2%, '*% "*2 +9% ,"=% "44'3*+ ('1 "$$ 4%*+1"$ 4",%, '( -=">-*-*>,Z 0*

'+9%1 L'12,S -+ 9", +' #% +13% '( "$$ -=">-*-*>, ('1 +9% ,"=% 1%",'* "*2 -*/-1+3% '( +9% ,"=% ",G%4+, '( +9%-1 *"+31%Z B +9%'1< L9-49 +1"4%, #"4X +9%-=">-*"+-/%*%,, +' ,'=% ,%+ '( (%"+31%, L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' '*% X-*2 '( -=">-*[-*> "*2 +' "*'+9%1 ,%+ '( (%"+31%, L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' " 2-((%1%*+ X-*2 '( -=">-*[-*> -, *'+ 3*-(-%2S ,-*4% -+ 2'%, *'+ 4'*4%1* +9% *"+31% 4'=='* +' "$$ G"1"2->= -*,+"*4%, '( -=">-*-*>S #3+ -*,+%"2 G1'/-2%, +L' -*2%G%*2%*+ "4[4'3*+, ('1 +L' 2-,+-*4+ G9%*'=%*"Z

!9-12S -+ -, 1%i3-1%2 '( " 3*-(-%2 +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> +9"+ -+ -2%*+-(-%, +9%

=',+ #",-4 %,,%*+-"$ (%"+31% U'1 ,%+ '( (%"+31%,V 1%,G'*,-#$% ('1 +9% -=">-*["+-/%*%,, L9-49 +9% 1%,G%4+-/% G9%*'=%*" 9"/% -* 4'=='*Z 0 +9%1%#< +"X%" G1'G%1+< +' #% 7"/8+./%*&" ('1 "*'+9%1 -( "*2 '*$< -( +9% %.%=G$-(-4"+-'*'( +9% (-1,+S "*2 *'+9-*> %$,%S %.G$"-*, +9% %.%=G$-(-4"+-'* '( +9% ,%4'*2 U",L%$$ ", "*< -==%2-"+% 4'*,%i3%*4%, '( +9% %.%=G$-(-4"+-'* '( +9% ,%4'*2VZ0 -*+%*2 +9-, 49"1"4+%1-,"+-'* '( %.G$"*"+'1< 1%,G'*,-#-$-+< +' #% 4'=G"+-#$%L-+9 /"1-'3, =%+"G9%*4% #",% ('1 +9% ,%4'*2b "*2 +9%1% ="< #% '+9%1 'G+-'*,Z e%*4%SL9-49%/%1 (%"+31% %.G$"-*, +9% -=">-*"+-/%*%,, '( +9% 4%*+1"$ 4",%, '( -="[>-*-*>S #3+ -, *'+ %.G$"-*%2 -+,%$( #< " ='1% #",-4 (%"+31%S -, +9% =',+ (3*[2"=%*+"$ (%"+31% L9-49 " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> ,9'3$2 -2%*+-(-*-*> -( -+ -, "#$% +' -2%*+-(< "*2%$34-2"+% "$,' 4%1+"-* (%"+31%, '( -=">-*-*>, L9-49 ,'=% '1 "$$ '( +9%= G',,%,, ", "4'*,%i3%*4% '( +9%-1 -=">-*"+-/%*%,, U%Z>ZS +9%-1 ,G%4-(-4 L"< '( 1%(%11-*> +' 1%"$-+-*-*>Z W3+ ,349 ("-$31% *%%2 *'+ *%4%,,"1-$< 13$% '3+ +9% "44'3*+ 4'*4%1*%2 ", "4"*2-2"+% +9%'1 G1'/-2%, " +9%'1< '( (%"+31%, '( -=">-*[


47/501

@R )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

W3+ -+ L-$$ "$,' #% 9%$G(3$ +' =%*+-'* L9"+ " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*>2'%, *'+ 9"/% +' "49-%/%Z

E-1,+ '( "$$S " 3*-(-%2 +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> *%%2 *'+ -*4$32% +9% 4$"-= +9"+-=">-*-*>, ('1= 8 '1S "$+%1*"+-/%$-*-*>, -,,'=%+9-*> ('1 3, +' 2-,4'/%1 -* *"+31%S '1 ,'=%+9-*> +9"+ -, 2%$-=-+%2 #<'31 G31G',%, '1 #< '31 2-,4'31,% "#'3+ +9% =-*2S ," +9% =',+ #",-4 "*2 aG1-=-+-/%N =%*+"$ G9%[

*'=%*'* U",S "1>3"#$ "*2 #%$-%/-*> "1%V 1%i3-1%, ='1% "1>3[=%*+Z0*2%%2S +9% ="Y'1 /-%L, ,%%= +' #% ,X%G+-4"$ "#'3+ +9-, -2%"Z E'1 %.[

"=G$%S L9-$% +9% B>%*4< B44'3*+ %$34-2"+%, +9% *"+31% '( -=">-*-*>, #<="X-*> 1%(%1%*4% +' +9%-1 -*,+"*+-"+-'* '( +9% *"+31"$ X-*2 $-*X%2 +' #%-*> "U=%*+"$V "4+-'*S -+ -2%*+-(-%, +9% 4$",, '( -=">-*-*>, L-+9 Y3,+ " ,3#,%+ '(+9"+ X-*2 U,%% J%4+-'* 5@Z?VZ@ J-=-$"1$ " $-X%$< (31[+9%1 4"*2-2"+% U,%% J%4+-'* IZKVZ E-*"$$-*"+-/% -* /-1+3% '( 2-((%1%*+ G1'G%1+-%, U,%% J%4+-'* MZ?VZ

0* +9-, 1%,G%4+S 7NJ9"3>9*%,,< L%"X%*, +9% "=#-+-'* '( " 3*-(-%2 +9%'1<'( -=">-*-*> %/%* (31+9%1Z \9-$%S ('1 -*,+"*4%S +9% Q%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$ "*2 +9%B>%*4< B44'3*+ +"X% "$$ -=">-*-*>, +' ,9"1% +9% ,"=% %,,%*4%S "*2 '+9%13*-(-%2 +9%'1-%, ="< %/%* ",,3=% ,349 " ,9"1%2 %,,%*4% +' -*2-/-23"+% "*"+31"$ X-*2S 7NJ9"3>9*%,,< ",,3=%, 2-((%1%*+ ('1=, '( -=">-*-*> +' G',[,%,, 2-((%1%*+ %,,%*4%, +9"+ Y3,+ $%"2 +' +9% ,"=% 4'*,%i3%*4% U-Z%ZS +' +9%

-*>, -*2%G%*2%*+ '( +9%-1 -=">-*"+-/% 49"1"4+%1 U%Z>ZS +9%-1 #%-*> 4'*,4-'3,S '1 +9%-1 #%-*> 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$VZ

@ J%% 7NW1-%* UU?RRCV` 49Z OV ('1 " 2%(%*,% '( +9% 4$"-= +9"+ "4+-'*, ('1= " *"+31"$=%*+"$ X-*2 8 '1 "1% a#",-4 %$%=%*+, '( +9% G,-4"$ 1%G%1+'-1%S =349 ", #%$-%(,"1%N U-#-2` 5@RVZ


48/501

b.%,%"' 011+H.#/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 @5

G',,%,,-'* '( +9% G1'G%1+< '( #%-*> "* -*,+"*4% '( -=">-*-*>VZ B44'12-*>$ +' +9% ,"=% *"+[

31"$ X-*2Z!9%*S " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> *%%2 *'+ #% "#$% +' G1'/-2% "*

"*"$ ,'=% 4'1% *'+-'* '( -=">-*-*>Z 0+ ="< +93, #% 4'*4%1*%2*'+ '*$< L-+9 L9"+ -=">-*-*>, "1% '1 9'L +9%< "1% 4'*,+-+3+%2S #3+ "$,'L-+9 9'L L% ="< 4'*4%-/% '( +9%=Z 0+ -,S 9'L%/%1S 3*1%"$-,+-4 +' %.G%4+ '(" 3*-(-%2 +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> +9"+ -+ 9", +9% "=#-+-'* +' G1'/-2% " (3$$ "*2

,"+-,("4+'1< "*"$-*-*> 8 ", G"1+$< 1%($%4+%2 -* +9% %.-,+%*4%'( #'12%1$-*% '1 '+9%1 3*4$%"1 4",%, U,%% J%4+-'* 5Z@V 8 ,3>>%,+ +9"+ +9-, -,%,G%4-"$$< +9% 4",% L-+9 1%,G%4+ +' 9'L L% 4'=='*$< 4'*4%-/% '( -=">-*[-*>,Z e%*4%S " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> ,9'3$2 *'+ +1< +' "-= "+

G1'/-2-*> " 2%(-*-+-'*"$ "*"$-*-*>,Z !9% 4'1% *'+-'* '( -=">-*-*> G1'/-2%2 #<,349 "* "44'3*+ =->9+ 4'=G1-,% '*$< 4%1+"-* ",G%4+, '( '31 '12-*"1<4'*4%G+ U"*2 =->9+ G%19"G, 2%/-"+% -* '+9%1, (1'= -+VZ

E-*"$$-*-*> *%%2 G1'/-2% *%-+9%1 "* "44'3*+ '(+9% ("43$+< '( -=">-*"+-'* U-( +9%1% -, "*


49/501

@? )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

,+%"2S -+ ="< ,-=G$< 4'*,-,+ -* +9% 4"G"4-+< +' 3,%S -* " 4%1+"-* L"-*-*>ZH J-=-$"1$-*%,'=%+9-*> ="< $%"2 +' " #%++%1 3*2%1,+"*2-*> '( +9% a-=">-*"+-/%*%,,N %.[9-#-+%2 #< 41%"+-/% '1 -*/%*+-/% G%'G$%Z W3+ ">"-*S -+ -, *'+ 4$%"1 L9%+9%1+9%1% -, " G"1+-43$"1$< 4$',% $-*X #%+L%%* -=">-*"+-/%*%,, "*2 -*,+"*4%, '(-=">-*-*>Z B44'12-*>$">% L-+9 +9% +",X Y3,+ '3+$-*%2 8 +' 4$"1-(< L9"+ 0 9"/% -* =-*2L9%* ,G%"X-*> '( a1%G1%,%*+"+-'*,NZ !9"+ " =%*+"$ ,+"+% -, " 1%G1%,%*+"+-'* 8 '1 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$ 8 =%"*, +9"+ -+ -, 2-1%4+%2 "+ '1 "#'3+ 4%1+"-* %*+-+-%,"*2 1%G1%,%*+, +9%= ", #%-*> " G"1+-43$"1 L"9*%,,< UU?RRRV` 49Z 55V G1'/-2%, " >%*%1"$ 2-,43,,-'* '( +9% 1%$"+-'*,9-G

#%+L%%* -=">-*"+-/% 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*, "*2 +9% 4"G"4-+< +' -=">-*%ZM Q%G1%,%*+"+-'*, ="< "$,' 9"/% " 1%(%1%*+S "*2 #% 4'11%4+ 1%$"+-/% +' L9%+9%1 9'L

+9%< 1%G1%,%*+ %*+-+-%, ", #%-*> ,"+-,(-%, " 4%1+"-* ,+"*2"12 '( 4'11%4+*%,, U%Z>ZS +9%1%$%/"*+ ("4+, -* 1%"$-+ +9% -,,3% '( L9%+9%1 "$$ +


50/501

b.%,%"' 011+H.#/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 @@

4'*4%G+3"$ '1 *'*[4'*4%G+3"$S ,%*,'1< '1 -*+%$$%4+3"$SC /-,3"$ '1 "32-+'1-*-*>,S "*2 ="*< '+9%1,Z 0* G"1+-43$"1S -+ 4"G+31%,L9"+ -, 4'=='*$< $"#%$$%2 a-*+%*+-'*"$ ,+"+%,N U,%% e3,,%1$ U5IR5V` G"1+ ;SJ%"1$% U5IO@V` 49Z 5S "*2 )1"*% U?RR5V` 49Z 5VZO W3+ +9% '3+$-*%2 4$",, '(

1%G1%,%*+"+-'*, *%%2 *'+ #% %.9"3,+%2 #< -*+%*+-'*"$ ,+"+%,Z 0+ -, *"+31"$ +'="-*+"-* +9"+ -*+%*+-'*"$-+< -=G$-%, +9% G',,-#-$-+< '( >%*3-*%=-,1%G1%,%*+"+-'*` +9"+ -,S +9% G',,-#-$-+< '( 1%G1%,%*+-*> "* '#Y%4+ -*4'1[1%4+$ -+ "*2 G%19"G, %/%* 1%(%11-*> +' -+ U,%% P1%+[,X% U5IOMVVZ B*2 +9%1% =->9+ #% =%*+"$ 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*, L9-49 2' *'+ "$$'L('1 +9-, G',,-#-$-+< '( %11'1Z !9"+ -,S +9%1% =->9+ #% =%*+"$ ,+"+%, +9"+ "1%"#'3+ 4%1+"-* '#Y%4+, "*2 ",41-#% 4%1+"-* (%"+31%, +' +9%=S #3+ L9-49 4"**'+=-,1%G1%,%*+ '1 =-,1%(%1 "*2S -* +9-, ,%*,%S $"4X -*+%*+-'*"$ 4'*+%*+ U%Z>ZS

G%14%G+-'*,S ", 4'*4%-/%2 #< ,'=% 2-,Y3*4+-/-,+,S ,349 ", T"1+-* U?RR?"V '1!1"/-, U?RRKVVZ!9"+ " =%*+"$ ,+"+% -, " 1%G1%,%*+"+-'* -=G$-%, +9"+ -+ G',,%,,%, " 1+.#".# Z

C T< 4'*+1",+ #%+L%%* /"./+7: "*2 %.#"&&"1#H$& %G-,'2%, -, =%"*+ +' +1"4X +9% #",-42-((%1%*4% -* 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$-+< #%+L%%* G%14%G+-'*, "*2 Y32>%=%*+, U'1 #%$-%(,VS>-/%* +9"+ +9%< ="< #% "#'3+ +9% ,"=% '#Y%4+, "*2 (%"+31%,Z B$+9'3>9 0 L'3$2 $-X% +',+"< *%3+1"$ +'L"12, +9% -,,3% '( L9%+9%1 +9% 2-((%1%*4% -* i3%,+-'* -, '*% '( 2%>1%%'1 '( X-*2S 0 ",,3=% +9"+ +9%1% -, ,'=% 2-,+-*4+-'* +' #% 21"L*S ", -+ 9", #%%* "44%G[+%2 -* +9% +1"2-+-'* "+ $%",+ ,-*4% D"*+Z 0* "22-+-'*S 0 +"X% +9-, 2-((%1%*4% +' #% ='1%

(3*2"=%*+"$ +9"* 8 #3+ G1%,3="#$< '/%1$"GG-*> "*2 G%19"G, %/%* 4'%.+%*,-'*"$L-+9 ,'=% '( 8 +9% /"1-'3, 2-((%1%*4%, +' #% ('3*2 -* +9% ='1% 1%4%*+ $-+%1"+31%SL9-49 9"/% #%%* 49"1"4+%1-,%2 -* +%1=, '( +9% 2-((%1%*4% #%+L%%* 4'*4%G+3"$ "*2*'*[4'*4%G+3"$ U%Z>ZS 6%"4'4X% U5II?V` 49Z ?b )1"*% U5II?VVS 2->-+"$ "*2 "*"$'>3%UP1%+,X% U5IO5V` 49Z MV '1 G1'G',-+-'*"$ "*2 *'*[G1'G',-+-'*"$ U'1 '#Y%4+[2-1%4+%2V1%G1%,%*+"+-'* U7NJ9"3>9*%,,< U?RRRV` 49Z 5RVZ

O T< *'+-'* '( " a1%G1%,%*+"+-'*N -, +93, /%1< 4$',% +' ^'4X%N, *'+-'* '( "* a-2%"NSe3=%N, *'+-'* '( " aG%14%G+-'*NS D"*+N, *'+-'* '( " a1%G1%,%*+"+-'*N U-Z%ZS a;'1,+%$[$3*>NVS '1 e3,,%1$N, *'+-'* '( a-*+%*+-'*"$ "4+NZ 0+ -, G%19"G, $%,, 4$',% +' 4%1+"-* 4'*[+%=G'1"1< 3,%, '( +9% +%1= a1%G1%,%*+"+-'*NS -* G"1+-43$"1 +' +9',% %=G$'


51/501

@K )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

0+, 4'*+%*+ ="< #% +"X%* +' 4'*,-,+ -* L9"+ -+ 1%G1%,%*+,S +9"+ -,S -* +9% 1%G[1%,%*+%2 %*+-+-%, "*2 (%"+31%,Z B44'12-*>$%=%*+ +9"+ -+ 1"-*,S +9%

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

:'LS +9"+ 4%1+"-* X-*2, '( =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*" "1% 4%*+1"$ 4",%, '( -="[>-*"+-/% '1 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"S 1%,G%4+-/%$-*"+-/% 49"1"4+%1 -, *'+ ,3#Y%4+ +' ,%1-'3, 2-,[">1%%=%*+S *%-+9%1 -* 2"-$< 2-,4'31,% *'1 -* G9-$','G9-4"$ 2%#"+%Z 0+ -, -=[ G'1+"*+ +' *'+%S 9'L%/%1S +9"+ L9%+9%1 ,'=%+9-*> -, "* -*,+"*4% '( -=">-*[-*> -, *'+ =%1%$< 8 "*2 G1%,3="#$< *'+ %/%* G1-="1-$< 8 " ="++%1 '( L9%+9[%1 L% $"#%$ -+ ", ,349Z 731 3,% '( +%1=, $-X% a-=">-*-*>N 4"* /"1< >1%"+$%N U'1 '( +9% 1%$"+%2 %.G1%,,-'* a/-,3"$ -=[

">%1-*-*>, 2%G%*2 '* 4'>*-+-'*, -* ,349 " L"< +9"+ +9%< "1%

#'+9 ,-=-$"1 +' "*2 2-((%1%*+ (1'= +9%=V ="< #% +"X%* +' %=#1"4% +9% -2%" +9"+ /-,3["$-,-*> -*/'$/%, -*+%1*"$ aG-4+31%,NZ


52/501

b.%,%"' 011+H.#/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 @H

B*2 +9%< "1% *'+ "$L"-*%2 +9"+N 4"*S -* ,'=%

,-+3"+-'*,S i3%,+-'* +9% -=">-*"+-/% ,X-$$ '( ,'=%'*% U%Z>ZS -* 1%,G'*,% +'9%"1-*> " >1%"+ ,+'1 +31* '( %/%*+,VZ e%*4%S +9% ">1%%=%*+ "#'3+ +9% G"1"2->=, '( -=">-*"+[-/% "*2 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*"S +9"+ 0 9"/% -* =-*2 9%1% "*2 "-= "+S4'*4%1*, +9% *"+31% '( +9% 1%,G%4+-/% =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*"S L9-49 -, +"X%* +' #% $"1>%$< -*2%G%*2%*+$< '( 9'L L% 1%(%1 +' +9%=Z

!9%1% "1% /%1< ="*< =%*+"$ G9%*'=%*" L9-49 "1% 4$%"1$< *'+ -=">-*"+[-/%Z T',+ G1'=-*%*+ "='*> +9%= U%,G%4-"$$< -* 2-,43,,-'*, "#'3+ -=">-*[-*>V "1% 4'>*-+-/% G9%*'=%*"` '* +9% '*% 9"*2S 4'>*-+-/% ,+"+%,S ,349 ", G%14%G+-'*,S Y32>%=%*+,5RS #%$-%(, '1 =%='1-%,b "*2S '* +9% '+9%1 9"*2S4'>*-+-/% G1'Y%4+,S ,349 ", +1 +' 4'=% +' 3*2%1,+"*2 "*'+9%1 G%1,'*S '1(-*2-*> +9% #%,+ "*,L%1 +' +9% =-*2[#'2< G1'#$%=Z 7+9%1 4%*+1"$ 4",%, '(*'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*" "1% 2%,-1%,S %='+-'*,S -*+%*+-'*,S =''2,S -*[4$-*"+-'*,S +9% G1"4+-4"$ G1'Y%4+, '( 2%4-2-*> '* " 4'31,% '( "4+-'*S '1 '(

4"$=-*> '*%,%$( 2'L*S "*2 ,' '*Z B*< +9%'1< '( -=">-*-*> L9-49 4"**'+2-,+-*>3-,9 ,349 4'>*-+-/% "*2 '+9%1 *'*[-=">-*"+-/% G9%*'=%*" (1'=-=">-*"+-/% '*%, ,9'3$2 *'+ 4'3*+ ", G1'/-2-*> " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -="[>-*-*>Z

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


53/501

@M )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

,*'L ,L"$$'L, "*2 =3+%, +9% ,'3*2,S '1 9'L -+ ="X%, " 2-,+-*4+-/% ,'3*2L9%* G1%,,%2 2'L* #< -*S -* 9 +9% 4-+-*% L9"+ 3G 4%1+"-* %.G%1-%*+-"$i3"$-+-%, -* 9+ ="*">% +' ='/% "1'3*2 "*2 X%%G +9% #",-4, '( 2"-$<$-(% 13**-*>Z m'3 ="< -=">-*"+-/%$< +9-*X +91'3>9 2-((%1%*+ 'G+-'*, '(2%"$-*> L-+9 +9% 1"1% "*2 ,31G1-,-*> 4-143=,+"*4%,S "*2 -*-*> +9%,% +9-*>, "#'3+ Q'=% "*2 -+, -*9"#-+"*+,S *'+-* 1%,G'*,% +' =< -*/-+"+-'* +' 2' ,'S #3+ -* 1%,G'*,% +' 1%"2-*> " L'1X '((-4+-'* -* L9-49 " ,4%*% -,S -* ,'=% 2%+"-$S 2%,41-#%2 -* +%1=, ,-=-$"1 +'+9',% 3,%2 "#'/%Z

!9-, 4'=G$%. %."=G$% '( -=">-*"+-/% %*>">%=%*+ '* -*-*> +9"+ 0 4'*,-2%1 +' #% G"1"2->="+-4` U-V ,%*,['1< -=">-*-*>,b U--V "((%4+-/% -=">-*-*>,b U---V -=">-*"+-/% +9'3>9+,b U-/V%.G%1-%*+-"$ -=">-*-*>,b "*2 U/V -=">-*"+-/% G1'Y%4+,Z W%-*> " =%=#%1 '('*% '( +9% (-/% >1'3G, ,9'3$2 *'+ #% +"X%* +' *%4%,,"1-$< %.4$32% #%-*> "=%=#%1 '( "*'+9%1 '*%Z B, L-$$ #%4'=% 4$%"1S -+ -, /%1< $-X%$< +9"+ +9%1% "1%4'*,-2%1"#$% '/%1$"G, #%+L%%* +9% (-/% 2-((%1%*+ +-*-*>Z W3+ +' =


54/501

b.%,%"' 011+H.#/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 @C

=-*2S +9%1% -, *' '#/-'3, 4"*2-2"+% ('1 " (31+9%1 4%*+1"$ + ,'=%+9-*> -* '*%N, =-*2 '1

-=">-*-*> +9% +%.+31% '( "* '#Y%4+ U%Z>ZS ,%% )",%< U5ICMV` K@((Zb 6%"4'4X%U5IOHV` ??b T"1+-* U?RR?"V` KR@VZ \9-$% ('$$'L-*> =< -*,+134+-'*,S "/% L"< +'-*-*>, ="< -*4$32% ='1% +9"* +9% ,%*,['1< 1%G1%,%*+"+-'* '( '#Y%4+, "*2 +9%-1 (%"+31%,Z E'1 "+ $%",+ ,'=% ,%*,'1<-=">-*-*>, ="< "='3*+ +' -=">-*-*> "* %G-,'2% '( G%14%-/-*>S +9"+ -,S9"/% " G%14%G+3"$ %.G%1-%*4% ", G"1+ '( +9%-1 4'*+%*+ U(1'= L9-49 +9%< -*[9%1-+ +9%-1 ,%*,'1< 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$-+3[

55

!9-, -2%" 8 W%1X%$%-"* -* ,G-1-+ 8 -, 2%(%*2%2 #< 6%"4'4X% U5IOHV "*2S "+ $%",+ ('1,'=% 4%*+1"$ 4",%,S -* )9"G+%1 5R '( +9-, #''X "*2 #< T"1+-* U?RR?"V` ,%4Z @ "*2T"1+-* U?RR5V` ,%4Z @S ", L%$$ ", P'1,49 U?R5R4VZ 0+ 4'=%, 3*2%1 "++"4X -* \-$$-"=,U5IMMVS \9-+% U5IIRV` 49,Z 5@[5HS e'GX-*, U5IIOV` 49Z CS :''129'( U?RR?V "*2 )31[1-% d Q"/%*,41'(+ U?RR?V` ,%4Z ?Z?Z :'+% +9"+ -+ ="< ,%%= *"+31"$ +' '*% +' 2%,41-#%/-,3"$-,-*> ", a-=">-*-*> ,%%-*>N L-+9'3+ #%-*> 4'==-++%2 +' +9% 4$"-= +9"+ ,%%-*> -,

G"1+ '( L9"+ -, -=">-*%2 U,%% \'$$9%-= U5IC@V` HHb e'GX-*, U5IIOV` 49Z CVZ W%,-2%,S+9%1% -, "$,' +9% U-*2%G%*2%*+V 2%#"+% "#'3+ L9%+9%1 ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*> 8 '1 %.G%1-[%*+-"$ -=">-*-*>S ('1 +9"+ ="++%1 8 ,'=%+-=%, '1 %/%* "$L"9+ '1 -*+%*+-'*[-*["4+-'*Z !9-, 2%#"+% -, 4$',%$<1%$"+%2 +' +9% i3%,+-'* '( 9'L #%,+ +' 3*2%1,+"*2 +9% a=3$+-G$% 3,% +9%,-,NS "44'12-*>


55/501

@O )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

=%*+, -* ,3GG'1+ '( +9-, 4$"-= -* )9"G+%1 5RZ W3+S ('1 +9% +-=% #%-*>S 0 -*[+%*2 +' ,+"< *%3+1"$ '* +9% G',,-#-$-+< '( *'*[%.G%1-%*+-"$ ,%*,'1< -=">-*[

-*>,S +9"+ -,S '( ,%*,'1< -=">-*"+-/% %G-,'2%, +9"+ 2' *'+ 9"/% G%14%G+-'*,'1 ,-=-$"1 %G-,'2%, ", G"1+ '( +9%-1 4'*+%*+,Z

T"*< 2-,43,,-'*, '( ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*>, 9"/% ('43,%2 '* /-,3"$ -*[,+"*4%, U%Z>ZS ,%% 6%"4'4X% U5IOHVb J"1+1% U5IKRVVS "*2 0 ="-*$< ('$$'L+9%= -* +9"+ 1%,G%4+Z 0*,+"*4%, '( /-,3"$-,-*> " ("4% '1 " $"*2,4"G% +93, (->[31% ", G"1"2->= 4",%, '( ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*>Z 7( 4'31,%S +9%1% "1% -=G'1+"*+2-((%1%*4%, #%+L%%*S ,"-*"+-'*S ", +9%1% "1% -=G'1+"*+ 2-((%1%*4%, #%+L%%* ,%%-*> -+

"*2 9%"1-*> '1 +'349-*> -+ -* 1%"$ $-(%Z W3+ 0 G1%,3=% +9"+ +9%,% 2-((%1%*4%,2' *'+ #%"1 =349 '* +9% -,,3%, $-*X%2 +' +9% G',,-#-$-+< '( ('1=3$"+-*> ","+-,("4+'1< 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*>Z B$,'S -+ -, -*+%1%,+-*> +' ",XL9%+9%1 +9%1% "1% X-*"%,+9%+-4 '1 G1'G1-'4%G+-/% -=">-*-*>,b L9%+9%1 +9%,%"1% ,-=-$"1 -* ,+134+31% +' 4",%, $-X% /-,3"$-,-*>b "*2 L9%+9%1 +9%< "='3*++' -=">-*-*> X-*"%,+9%+-4 '1 G1'G1-'4%G+-/% %.G%1-%*4%,Z W3+ =< 9'G% -,+9"+ +9%< 2' *'+ 2-((%1 -* -=G'1+"*+ 1%,G%4+, (1'= +9% =349 ='1% -*/%,+->["+%2 %."=G$% '( /-,3"$ -=">-*-*>Z J' ("1S +9%1% 2'%, *'+ ,%%= +' #% " >''2

1%",'* +' 2'3#+ +9"+ " 3*-(-%2 "44'3*+ '( -=">-*-*> 4"G"#$% '( 4"G+31-*>/-,3"$ -=">-*-*>, -, "$,' "#$% +' 4"G+31% '+9%1 +-*-*> 8 4'==%*+, L9-49 0 9'G% L-$$ "GG$ U%Z>ZS #< 4$',-*> '*%N, %%Z W3+ L% 4"* "$,' /-,3"$-,% ,'=%+9-*> L9-$% ,%%-*> U",L%$$ ", +9-*X-*> "#'3+V ,'=%+9-*> 4'=G$%+%$< 2-((%1%*+ U,%% \-++>%*,+%-*U5IOK4V` /'$Z 00S ,%4Z MHVZ E'1 %."=G$%S L9-$% L"$X-*> 2'L* +9% ,+1%%+S L%="< /-,3"$-,% +9% ("4% '( " (1-%*2 L9'= L% G$"* +' ,31G1-,% L-+9 ,'=%[+9-*> -* +9% *%"1 (3+31%Z e'L%/%1S +9-, ="< #% ='1% 2-((-43$+ +9"* +9% (-1,+L"< '( /-,3"$-,-*> ,'=%+9-*> U%Z>ZS +9% 1%,3$+ ="< #% $%,, 1-49 -* 2%+"-$ '1-* 2%+%1=-*"4


56/501

b.%,%"' 011+H.#/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 @I

,3((-4-%*+$< ,9-(+ '31 "++%*+-'* (1'= +9% G%14%G+-'* U'1 +9% +9-*X-*>V +' +9%-=">-*-*>Z

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`

\9-$% ,%%-*> "* '#Y%4+S 0 4"**'+ -=">-*% -+Z U\-++>%*,+%-* U5IOK4V` /'$Z 00S,%4Z M@V5@

!9% -2%" -, +9"+ L9%* L% "$1%"2< ,%% +9% :"+-'*"$ ]"$$%1< -* (1'*+ '( 3, L%

5? !9"+ G%14%G+3"$ "*2 -=">-*"+-/% 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*"$ %$%=%*+, 2' *'+ 8 '1 "+ $%",+ *'+ ,'%",-$< 8 =%1>% "$,' 4'*,+-+3+%, " G1'#$%= ('1 -=">-*"+-'*[#",%2 "44'3*+, '( G-4+'1-"$%.G%1-%*4% L9-49 +"X% '31 /-,3"$ "L"1%*%,, '( L9"+ G-4+31%, 2%G-4+ +' #% -=">-*"+[-/% "*2 +' #% =%1>%2 L-+9 '31 G%14%G+3"$ "L"1%*%,, '( +9% 2%G-4+-*> ,31("4%Z E'1 +9%

G1'G'*%*+, '( +9-, /-%L 9"/% G1'#$%=, +' %.G$"-* L9< G%14%G+3"$ "*2 %$%=%*+,=%1>% -* +9% G-4+'1-"$ 4",%S #3+ *'+ -* %."=G$%, $-X% +9% '*% 2-,43,,%2 9%1% U,%%e'GX-*, U5IIOV` @ "*2 P'1,49 U?R5?4VVZ

5@ !9% +1"*,$"+-'* -, =-*%Z !9% '1->-*"$ 1%"2,` a\n91%*2 -49 %-*%* ]%>%*,+"*2 ,%9%SX"** -49 -9* =-1 *-49+ /'1,+%$$%*ZN !9% ,"=% G'-*+ -, ,+1%,,%2 #< T3$$->"* U5IIIV`,%4Z @Z


57/501

KR )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

4"**'+ "$,' /-,3"$-,% -+ "+ +9% ,"=% +-=% U"*2S G1%,3="#$ +' "$,' "*2 ,-=3$+"*%'3,$< ,%%-+ U">"-*S G1%,3="#$< (1'= +9% ,"=% G%1,G%4+-/%VZ B44'12-*> +' '*% G',[,-#$% L"< '( 3*2%1,+"*2-*> +9-, +9%,-,S -+ ,%%=, +' #% +13%` +9% ,%*,'1< 1%G[1%,%*+"+-'* -*/'$/%2 -* ,%%-*> +9% :"+-'*"$ ]"$$%1< 4"**'+ "$,' #% +9% 1%G[1%,%*+"+-'* -*/'$/%2 -* /-,3"$-,-*> +9-, #3-$2-*>b +9% +L' 2' *'+ ,-=G$<,9"1% " +'X%* /-,3"$ 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*Z 0+ ="< "$,' #% +13% -* "*'+9%1-*+%1G1%+"+-'*` -+ ="< #% +9"+ U", "$1%"2< ,3>>%,+%2 "#'/%V /-,3"$-,-*>,'=%+9-*> L9-$% ,%%-*> ,'=%+9-*> %$,% G1%,3GG',%, ,3((-4-%*+ "++%*+-'* +'

+9% +",X '( /-,3"$-,-*>S "*2 +9"+ L% ="< $"4X +9-, 1%i3-1%2 2%>1%% '( "++%*[+-'* L9%* L%S ," -, "+ $%",+ i3%,+-'*"#$%S -( *'+ ("$,%` *"=%$< +9"+L% 4"**'+ ,-=3$+"*%'3,$< 9"/% +L' -*2%G%*2%*+ /-,3"$ %G-,'2%, L-+9 +9%,"=% 4'*+%*+ "*2 G'-*+ '( /-%LS L9%* '*% -, G%14%G+3"$ "*2 +9% '+9%1 -="[>-*"+-/%Z5K 0( L% 4"* /-,3"$-,% " ("4% U'1 "* %$,%V L9-$% $''X-*> "+ +9% :"+-'*"$ ]"$$%1 +' 9"/% '31 G%14%G+-'*Z E'1 -( +9%1% -, "*<

(%"+31% '( /-,3"$-,-*> L9-49 G1%/%*+, -+ 3*2%1 "$$ 4-143=,+"*4%, (1'= '4[4311-*> "+ +9% ,"=% +-=% ", ,%%-*>S -+ ,9'3$2 #%++%1 *'+ 2%G%*2 '* L9"+ -,+9% G"1+-43$"1 4'*+%*+ '( +9% -=">-*"+-/% %G-,'2%Z5H

5K J%% e'GX-*, U?R55"VZ e'GX-*, "$,' '#,%1/%, +9"+ /-,3"$-,-*> ,'=%+9-*> -, -*4'=G"+[-#$% L-+9 ,-=3$+"*%'3,$< /-,3"$$< 1%=%=#%1-*> ,'=%+9-*> U%$,%VS ", L%$$ ", +9"+ L%4"**'+ 9"/% +L' ,-=3$+"*%'3,S #3+ ,%G"1"+% %G-,'2%, '( /-,3"$-,-*> U'1 /-,3"$ 1%4"$$V+9"+ -,S +L' %G-,'2%, +9"+ '4431 "+ +9% ,"=% +-=%S #3+ /-,3"$$< G1%,%*+ +9%-1 '#Y%4+, ",

G"1+ '( 2-,+-*4+ -=">-*%2 ,G"4%, '1 L'1$2,Z e-, %.G$"*"+-'* '( +9%,% '#,%1/%2 ("4+, -,+9"+ /-,3"$ 1%4"$$ -, " ('1= '( /-,3"$-,-*> +9"+ -, 4'*,+1"-*%2 #< +9% 2%+%1=-*"+-'* '(

L9"+ -, /-,3"$$< 1%G1%,%*+%2 #< L9"+ 9", #%%* /-,3"$$< G%14%-/%2 -* +9% G",+Z T< "$[+%1*"+-/% %.G$"*"+-'* -, +9"+ #'+9 /-,3"$-,-*> "*2 /-,3"$ 1%4"$$ -*/'$/% +9% ,"=% X-*2'( %.G%1-%*+-"$ 1%G1%,%*+"+-'* '( /-,3"$ G%14%G+-'* U,%% J%4+-'* IZK "*2 )9"G+%1 5RVZ

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


58/501

b.%,%"' 011+H.#/ +, ;5$4%.%.4 K5

R%%S 0,,"1#%A" ;5$4%.%.4

!9% ,%4'*2 G"1"2->= 4",% '( -=">-*-*>S +9"+ VS '(+%* 4'3G$%2 L-+9 " 1%$"+%2 4'*+%*+Z 5M m'3="< 9"/% -=">-*"+-/%$< (%$+ +9% G$%",31% '( L"$X-*> -* +9% ,*'L "*2 $''X[-*> "+ -+S +9% "**'9+Z

7+9%1 %."=G$%, '( "((%4+-/% -=">-*-*>, "1% +9% -=">-*"+-/% 4'3*+%1G"1+, +' #'2-$< ,%*,"+-'*,S ,349 ", -=">-*%2 '1 -=">-*"+-/%$< (%$+ -+49%, "*2 G"-*,U,%% T"1+-* U?RR?"V` KRM(Z '* +9% ('1=%1VZ \9%+9%1 +9%1% "1% "$,' 2%,-1%[$-X% -=">-*-*>, +9"+ 9"/% '44311%*+ 2%,-1%, ", +9%-1 4'3*+%1G"1+, "*2 2' *'+=%1%$< 4'*,-,+ -* +9% -=">-*"+-/% +9'3>9+ +9"+ '*% 9", " 4%1+"-* 2%,-1% -,='1% 4'*+1'/%1,-"$Z5C

B((%4+-/% -=">-*-*>, "1% 8 "G"1+ (1'= +9%-1 "((%4+-/% 49"1"4+%1 8 *'+ +9"+2-((%1%*+ (1'= ,%*,'1< -=">-*-*>,Z !9-, 4'*4%1*,S -* G"1+-43$"1S +9% -,,3% '(

L9%+9%1 "((%4+-/% -=">-*-*>, "1% "$L"-*-*>, '( "((%4+[-/% %.G%1-%*4%,S '1 L9%+9%1 +9%1% 4"* "$,' 4'*,-,+ -* ,-=G$% -=">-*"+-/%%G-,'2%, L9-49 2' *'+ 9"/% 1%"$ (%%$-*>, '1 %.G%1-%*4%, ", +9%-1 -*+%*+-'*"$'#Y%4+,Z B>"-*S 0 G1%,%*+ ,'=% 4'*,-2%1"+-'*, -* ("/'31 '( +9% -2%" +9"+ "([(%4+-/% -=">-*-*>, "1% -=">-*-*>, '( 1%"$ (%%$-*>, -* )9"G+%1 55Z

0+ -, -=G'1+"*+ +' *'+%S 9'L%/%1S +9"+ '31 1%"$ %='+-'*"$ 1%,G'*,%, +' (-4[+-'*"$ %*+-+-%, "*2 ,-+3"+-'*, U-Z%ZS L9"+ \"$+'* U5IIRV 4"$$, ai3",- %='[

4'3$2 1%"$-,% +9% ,"=% +9 "((%4+-/% %G-,'2%, ="< #% G-4X%2 '3+ #< +9% +%1= a(%%$-*>N U"*2 0 L-$$

,'=%+-=%, 2' +9-,VS -+ -, -=G'1+"*+ +' 9"/% -* =-*2 +9"+ +9-, 2'%, *'+ =%"* +9"+ +9%<4'=G1-,% "$$ G9%*'=%*"$$< %.G%1-%*4%2 '1 4'*,4-'3,$< a(%$+N ,+"+%, U-Z%ZS "$$ =%*+"$%G-,'2%,VZ W%,-2%,S 0 ,+"< *%3+1"$ '* +9% 4'*+%*+ '( "((%4+-/% "*2S %,G%4-"$$%*+-/% U-Z%ZS '( +9%-=G%1"+-/% ('1= aU+'V 2' oNVZ

5C !9% G',+3$"+-'* '( ,349 2%,-1%[$-X% -=">-*-*>, -, 2%(%*2%2 #< ;%$$%="* U?RR?VS )31[1-% U?RR?V "*2 )311-% d Q"/%*,41'(+ U?RR?VZ J%% )"113+9%1, U?RR@VS :-49'$, U?RRK#V"*2 J'$2"+- U?RRMV ('1 >''2 '#Y%4+-'*,Z


59/501

K? )9" F$#H7" $.' J$7%"#: +, ;5$4%.%.4

+-'*,NV "1% *'+ -*,+"*4%, '( "((%4+-/% -=">-*-*>Z 0* G"1+-43$"1S "$+9'3>9+9%,% 1%,G'*,%, "1% #",%2 '* -=">-*-*>,S +9%< "1% *'+ -=">-*"+-/% +9%=[

,%$/%,Z \9%* L% L"+49 " 9'11'1 ='/-% "*2 #%>-* +' (%%$ "(1"-2 "*2 9"/%,'=% 4'11%,G'*2-*> #'2-$< 1%"4+-'*,S +9'3>9+, "*2 -*4$-*"+-'*, +' "4+U+9'3>9 3,3"$$< *'+ +9% ,"=% ", L9%* 4'*(1'*+%2 L-+9 1%"$ 2"*>%1VS '31(%%$-*> '( (%"1 "*2 +9% 1%,G%4+-/% #'2-$< 49"*>%, U%Z>ZS " 1-,-*> 9%"1+#%"+V'1 -*4$-*"+-'*, +' "4+ U%Z>ZS +' 4'/%1 '*%N, %9S +-*"+-/% 1%G1%,%*+"+-'*,Z !9%1% -, " 2%#"+% "#'3+ L9%+9%1,349 ai3",- %='+-'*,N ,9'3$2 4'3*+ ", 1%"$ %='+-'*,Z W3+ -+ ,9'3$2 #% #%-*"+-/%$< (%$+ '*%Z W%,-2%,S ", +9%1%$%/"*+ 2-,43,,-'*, 1%/%"$S "((%4+-/% -=">-*-*>, "1% *'+ *%4%,,"1< ('1 '31%='+-'*"$ %*>">%=%*+ L-+9 (-4+-'*,Z5O

R%%%S ;.#"&&"1#H$& ;5$4%.%.4

m'31 -=">-*-*>, -* +9% %."=G$% "1% "$,' $-X%$< +' 9"/% -*4$32%2 -=">-*"+[

-/% +9'3>9+,S ,349 ", +9% >%*%1"$ ",,3=G+-'* +9"+ Q'=% -, 4'/%1%2 -* ,*'LS'1 99+, "#'3+ +9% G',,-#$% 4'*,%i3%*4%, +9"+ +9-, =->9+9"/% ('1 +9% $-(% '( -+, -*9"#-+"*+,Z J3GG',-*>S -=">-*-*>[+9"+ "*2 ="X-*>[ #%$-%/% L-+9 " G1'G',-+-'*"$ 4'*+%*+ "1% "$,' 4",%, '( -*+%$$%4+3"$ -=">-*[-*>Z5I B$+9'3>9 +9%1% G1%,3="#$< "1% 4",%, -* L9-49 L% %.G%1-%*+-"$$< -="[5O 0 1%+31* +' +9%,% -,,3%, -* )9"G+%1 55Z J%% "$,' \"$+'* U5IIRV

Documents

The Unity of Imagining - Fabian Dorsch