Upload
gegi-f-irong
View
218
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
1/21
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
2/21
The Case of theSpeluncean
Explorers (1949)LON L. FULLER
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
3/21
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
4/21
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
5/21
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
6/21
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
7/21
“Whoever shall willfullytake the life of anothershall be punished todeath.” N.C. S. A. (N.S.) S12 - A
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
8/21
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
9/21
The Case of the SpelunceanExplorers
C. J. Truepenny
J. Foster
J. Tattin
J. !een J. "andy
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
10/21
C. J. Truepenny
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
11/21
C. J. Truepenny
#an ua e of the statute isclear and una$bi uous
%E&'(C) *+r$ ConvictionPropose c e!e"c# to Ch$ef E%ec&t$'e
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
12/21
J. Foster
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
13/21
J. Foster1. #aw of ,ature
2. Case re!o'e fro! eo*raph$ca a"+ora Le*a Or er,. +ost as$c Pr$"c$p e of a ase o"co"tracts
*ssu$in #aw of ,ature $ "otoperate
P&rpos$'e Approach to La
%E&'(C) SET *S('E C-,%(CT(-,
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
14/21
J. Tatting
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
15/21
J. Tatting
Critici/es J. Foster/&est$o"s operation of #aw of,ature/&est$o"s purposive approach $th0!& t$p $c$t# of p&rposes
&t ca"3t accept $ $"* of 45efe" a"ts $th the $'es ost toresc&e the!6
%E&'(CT) ,- %E&'(CT. "E
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
16/21
J. !een
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
17/21
J. !eenCr$t$c$7es C.J. Tr&epe""#3s propose
appea to the Ch$ef E%ec&t$'eSeparat$o" of po ers
+ora $t# as $rre e'a"t $" case
0ud es 1ust apply law 8& $c$a e*$s at$o" as rep&*"a"tP&rpose $s &" "o "
%E&'(CT) S2ST*(, C-,%(CT(-,
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
18/21
J. "andy
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
19/21
J. "andy“3ractical wisdo$” !ore e$*ht tha"a stract theor$es
A stract$o" o" # $"str&!e"ts for CO++ONSENSE
Co&rt act$o" $th$" reasonable accord to!ass se"t$!e"t
456 of public $sh 5efe" a"ts face esserp&"$sh!e"t or re ease
oss$ps of Ch$ef E%ec&t$'e $"c $"e to s&sta$"p&"$sh!e"t
%E&'(CT) C-,%(CT(-, SET *S('E
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
20/21
The Case of the SpelunceanExplorers
C. J. Truepenny
J. Foster
J. Tattin
J. !een J. "andy
8/17/2019 The Speluncean Explorers
21/21
Conviction