63
European Commission Fundamental rights & anti-discrimination The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

  • Upload
    -

  • View
    219

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

Citation preview

Page 1: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

European Commission

Fun

dam

en

tal

rig

hts

& a

nti

-dis

crim

inati

on

T h e S i t u a t i o n o f R o m a i n a n E n l a r g e d

E u r o p e a n U n i o n

Page 2: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

Sales and Subscriptions

Publications for sale produced by the Office for Official Publications of the

European Communities are available from our sales agents throughout the world.

Page 3: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

!

!"#$%&!'(!&)*$)+$,)-($&*$(*

#*.(,/#0$#',)1#(*$'*&)*

#234562789$:$;5<=>4$>??>=@;

!"#$%&'#(%)*+,-.(/*%#$*%#(,0$,/1+,&,#%(,2#

#A@537>8$B522=;;=58

0=@7<95@>97C/787@>4$?5@$#234562789$>8D$%5<=>4$(??>=@;

'8=9$0E

->8A;<@=39$<5234797D$=8$FGGH

Page 4: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

!"#$%&'"(%&)"*+"&((,',*-&)",-+*$.&',*-"*-"'/%"01$*2%&-"3-,*-",4"&5&,)&6)%"*-"'/%"7-'%$-%'8

7'"9&-"6%"&99%44%("'/$*1#/"'/%"01$*2&"4%$5%$":/''2;<<%1$*2&8%18,-'=8

>&'&)*#1,-#"(&'&"9&-"6%"+*1-("&'"'/%"%-("*+"'/,4"216),9&',*-8

!"#$%&'"()*+,--./$+-'(+,--./.01+2"&1./03.'45+'-+36$+7"('8$04+9'%%"4.3.$5:+;<<=

7?@A"BCDEBFDEGEHDC

I"01$*2%&-">*..1-,',%4J"CKKF

L%2$*(19',*-",4"&1'/*$,4%("2$*5,(%("'/%"4*1$9%",4"&9M-*N)%(#%(8

O$,-'%(",-"'/%"3-,'%("P,-#(*."*-"N/,'%"9/)*$,-%D+$%%"2&2%$

!!

>.5/10.%$(

Q/,4"$%2*$'"/&4"6%%-"2$%2&$%("1-(%$"&"4%$5,9%"9*-'$&9'"N,'/"'/%">*..,44,*-"*+"'/%"01$*2%&-"3-,*-8"Q/%

5,%N4"%R2$%44%("/%$%,-"&$%"'/*4%"*+"'/%">*-4*$',1."2$*(19,-#"'/,4"$%2*$'J"&-("(*"-*'"-%9%44&$,)S"$%2$%4%-'

&-S"*++,9,&)"5,%N"*+" '/%">*..,44,*-"&-(" ,-"2&$',91)&$" '/%"T,$%9'*$&'%"U%-%$&)" +*$"0.2)*S.%-'"&-("?*9,&)

!++&,$4J"N/,9/"9*..,44,*-%("'/%"N*$M8"

Q/%">*-4*$',1."2$*(19,-#"'/,4"$%2*$'"9*.2$,4%("V*914">*-41)'&-9S"W'(8J"'/%"01$*2%&-"L*.&"L,#/'4">%-D

'%$J"&-("'/%"01$*2%&-"L*.&"7-+*$.&',*-"X++,9%8

2('?"/3.'4+04?+)(086./+?$5.)4

V*914">*-41)'&-9S"W'(8":NNN8+*914D9*-41)'&-9S89*81M=8

26'3')(086+0/@4'A1$?)$%$435

>*5%$" 2/*'*#$&2/;"Y,$*4)&5" W&9M*J" ?)*5&M,&8" !))" *'/%$" 2/*'*#$&2/4" 6S" M,-(" 2%$.,44,*-" *+" '/%" 01$*2%&-

L*.&"L,#/'4">%-'$%J"@1(&2%4'8"

B/@4'A1$?)$%$435

Q/%">*-4*$',1.".%.6%$4"N*1)("),M%"'*"'/&-M"'/*4%"$%2$%4%-'&',5%4"*+"-&',*-&)"&1'/*$,',%4J"AUX4"&-("L*.&

*$#&-,4&',*-4" '/&'" 9*-'$,61'%(" '*" &-(" 9*..%-'%(" *-" '/,4" $%2*$'J" &-(" 2&$',91)&$)S" '/*4%" +$*." '/%" %)%5%-

Y%.6%$"?'&'%4" &-(" 9&-(,(&'%" 9*1-'$,%4" 4%)%9'%(" +*$".*$%"(%'&,)%(" 4'1(S8" Q/%" 9*1-'$S" $%4%&$9/%$4"N/*

N*$M%(",-"%&9/"*+"'/%4%"Y%.6%$"?'&'%4"&-("9&-(,(&'%"9*1-'$,%4"9&$$,%("*1'"&" )&$#%"5*)1.%"*+"N*$M" ,-"&

4/*$'"2%$,*(J"+*$"N/,9/"'/%">*-4*$',1.".%.6%$4"&$%"#$&'%+1)8"Q/%S"N*1)("&)4*"),M%"'*"'/&-M"'/*4%"2%$4*-4

N/*"&''%-(%("&-("9*-'$,61'%("'*"'/%">*-+%$%-9%"*-"L*.&",-"&-"0-)&$#%("03J"/%)(",-"@$144%)4",-"!2$,)"CKKF

&-("+,-&-9%("6S"'/%"01$*2%&-">*..,44,*-J"N/,9/"9*-'$,61'%("4,#-,+,9&-')S"'*"'/%"(%5%)*2.%-'"*+",(%&4"&-(

2$*2*4&)48"V,-&))SJ"'/%S"N*1)("),M%"'*"&9M-*N)%(#%"'/%"9*..,'.%-'J"9*..%-'4"&-("9*-'$,61',*-4".&(%"6S

5&$,*14" %.2)*S%%4" *+" '/%" 01$*2%&-" >*..,44,*-J" &-(" 2&$',91)&$)S" '/*4%" *+" '/%" T,$%9'*$&'%" U%-%$&)" +*$

0.2)*S.%-'" &-(" ?*9,&)" !++&,$48" T%42,'%" &))" '/%" &6*5%" 9*-'$,61',*-4J" '/%" >*-4*$',1." .%.6%$4" $%.&,-

$%42*-4,6)%"+*$"&-S"%$$*$4"*$".,41-(%$4'&-(,-#4"$%+)%9'%(",-"'/,4"$%2*$'8

7"('8$+>.($/3+.5+0+5$(C./$+3'+6$18+D'"+-.4?+045A$(5+3'+D'"(E"$53.'45+0&'"3+36$+7"('8$04+F4.'4

G($$86'4$+4"%&$(*

<<+H<<+I+J+H+K+L<+LL

FOCUS CONSULTANCY

Page 5: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

!"!#$%&'!()$**+,- .

./(&01234561730 8

9/(,3:;(70(!523<=>(+(?27=@(A7B132C D

E/(%F=(!523<=;0(G3H76C(I2;:=J32K ..

!L<;0470M(;017N47B627:70;1730(032:B(70(!523<= //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////..!$(B367;H(706H5B730(<3H76C(@2;:=J32K //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////.9A5:;0(27MF1B(:30713270M //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////.E!523<=;0(=:<H3C:=01(B12;1=MC ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////.E!$()1256152;H(I504B //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////.OP1F=2(!$(<3H767=B(;04(<23M2;::=B//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////.8!$(=0H;2M=:=01(;04(1F=(27B=(3@(,3:;(;B(;0(;2=;(3@(!$(<3H76C(6306=20 ////////////////////////////////////////////.8P1F=2(!523<=;0(H=M;H(;04(<3H76C(@2;:=J32KB //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////.Q

O/(,3:;(70(R=C()=6132;H(I7=H4B .D

!456;1730 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////.D!:<H3C:=01 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////99A35B70M//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////98A=;H1F6;2=//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////9QS7B<;2;1=(=0T7230:=01;H(7:<;61>(A35B70M(;04(F=;H1F ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////EU)367;H(B=65271CV(7063:=B(;04(4=W1 ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////EUX;6K(3@(<=2B30;H(4365:=01B(;04(B1;1=H=BB0=BB //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////E.Y=04=2(;B<=61B(3@(1F=(B715;1730(3@(,3:; ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////EEG3H767=B(;442=BB70M(%2;T=HH=2(63::50717=B(;04(7047T745;HB //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////E8

8/(G3H76C(#F;HH=0M=B ED

*703271C(2=63M071730 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////EDX;6K(3@(B1;17B176;H(4;1;(30(,3:; //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////ED&0;4=Z5;6C(3@(<3H76C(2=B<30B=//////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////E[#;<;671C(;04(J7HH(;1(H36;H(H=T=H //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////OUG3H767=B(4=127:=01;H(13(1F=(<332(M=0=2;HHC ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////O.,3:;(;04(2=M730;H(4=T=H3<:=01 //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////O9\30N:=:W=2(B1;1=B //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////O9*7M2;01B(;04(2=@5M==B //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////OE&0;66=BB7W7H71C(3@(@50470M //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////OO%F=(\==4(@32(;0(!$(,3:;(&01=M2;1730(S72=617T= //////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////OO

!!!

%+?X!(PI(#P\%!\%)

%F=()715;1730(3@(,3:;(70(;0(!0H;2M=4(!523<=;0($0730

Page 6: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

H8">*-9)14,*-4J"L%9*..%-(&',*-4J"Z&S4"V*$N&$( FH

03")%5%)"$%9*..%-(&',*-4 888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888FHY%.6%$"?'&'%D)%5%)"$%9*..%-(&',*-4 888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888[K>,5,)"4*9,%'S"$%9*..%-(&',*-4 888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888[G

\8"?%)%9'%("@,6),*#$&2/S []

!"

Q/%"?,'1&',*-"*+"L*.&",-"&-"0-)&$#%("01$*2%&-"3-,*-

Page 7: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

!"#$%&'()*+")*+",,&'"#-

./+Q/,4"4'1(S"N&4"9*..,44,*-%("6S"'/%"T,$%9'*$&'%U%-%$&)" +*$" 0.2)*S.%-'" &-(" ?*9,&)" !++&,$4" *+" '/%01$*2%&-">*..,44,*-8"7'4"21$2*4%"/&4"6%%-"'*"6%'D'%$" 1-(%$4'&-(" '/%" 4,'1&',*-" *+" L*.&J" US24S" &-(Q$&5%))%$G 9*..1-,',%4",-"'/%"03DC["&-(",-"N/&'"N&S%R,4',-#" &-(" +1'1$%" 03" &-(" *'/%$" 2*),9,%4" .,#/',.2$*5%"'/&'"4,'1&',*-8 Q/%"$%4%&$9/"N&4"9*..,4D4,*-%(",-"'/%"9*-'%R'"*+"%-)&$#%.%-'J"N/%-"L*.&JUS24S" &-(" Q$&5%))%$" 9*..1-,',%4" 6%9&.%" '/%)&$#%4'"%'/-,9".,-*$,'S"N,'/,-"'/%"03J"&-("*+"&"+&,)1$%*+"%R,4',-#"2*),9,%4"N,'/,-"6*'/"'/%"03DG[":'/%"^*)(_Y%.6%$" ?'&'%4=" &-(" '/%" -%N" Y%.6%$" ?'&'%4" '*&(($%44" &(%`1&'%)S" (,49$,.,-&',*-" &#&,-4'" '/%4%9*..1-,',%4"&-("'*"2$*.*'%"'/%,$"4*9,&)",-9)14,*-8!4"N%))"&4"4'$%44,-#"'/%"%R,4',-#"4,'1&',*-"*+"L*.&JUS24S" &-(" Q$&5%))%$" 9*..1-,',%4" &9$*44" 01$*2%J'/%$%+*$%J" '/,4" $%2*$'"&)4*".&M%4"&"-1.6%$"*+" $%9D*..%-(&',*-4" +*$" 03" ,-4','1',*-4J" Y%.6%$" ?'&'%#*5%$-.%-'4"&-("9,5,)"4*9,%'S"*$#&-,4&',*-4J",-9)1(D,-#"L*.&"*$#&-,4&',*-48

0/+ Q/%" 9*-4*$',1." 9&$$S,-#" *1'" '/%" 4'1(S" /&4),&,4%(" N,'/" 01$*2%&-" >*..,44,*-" 4%$5,9%4'/$*1#/*1'"'/%"9*1$4%"*+"'/%"4'1(S8"Q/%"N*$M"*+"'/%9*-4*$',1." /&4" ,-5*)5%(" 6*'/" '/%" %R%91',*-" *+" &4'&-(&$(,4%(" 2,%9%" *+" $%4%&$9/" ,-" GG" Y%.6%$?'&'%4"&-("CKKF"9&-(,(&'%"9*1-'$,%4C &-("'/%"(%4M4'1(S"*+"%R,4',-#".&'%$,&)4J"4122*$'%("6S"5,4,'4"'*"&),.,'%("-1.6%$"*+"9*1-'$,%4"&-("2$*a%9'4"(%4,#-%('*"&(($%44"L*.&",441%48

1/+Y*$%*5%$J"'/%"01$*2%&-">*..,44,*-"+,-&-9%(&".&a*$"9*-+%$%-9%"*-"'/%"?,'1&',*-"*+"L*.&",-"&-0-)&$#%(" 03" ,-" !2$,)" CKKFJ" /%)(" ,-" @$144%)4" &-(&''%-(%(" 6S" 4*.%" GFK" L*.&" &9',5,4'4J" Y%.6%$?'&'%" &-(" 9&-(,(&'%" 9*1-'$,%4b" #*5%$-.%-'" &-(AUX"$%2$%4%-'&',5%4J"&-("03"&-("*'/%$",-'%$-&',*-D&)" *$#&-,4&',*-" *++,9,&)48" V,-&))SJ" &" 9*.2$%/%-4,5%

9*-41)'&',*-" N,'/" L*.&" *$#&-,4&',*-4" N&4" 1-(%$D'&M%-" 6S" '/%" 01$*2%&-" L*.&" 7-+*$.&',*-" X++,9%:0L7X=J"&"9*-4*$',1.".%.6%$J"&-("'/%"*22*$'1-,'SN&4"#,5%-"'*"Y%.6%$"?'&'%"#*5%$-.%-'4"'*".&M%9*-'$,61',*-4"'*"'/%"($&+'"$%2*$'8

23)*3)%4

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

6*(#"73')

8/+Q/%"W,46*-"01$*2%&-">*1-9,)"/&4"4%'"&"-1.6%$"*+'&$#%'4" ,-" $%)&',*-" '*" %(19&',*-" &-(" '$&,-,-#" +*$&9/,%5%.%-'" 6S" CKGKJ" ),-M%(" ,-" 2&$',91)&$" '*" '/%#%-%$&',*-" *+" &" M-*N)%(#%D6&4%(" 4*9,%'S" &-(" '/%,-9$%&4%" *+" 03" %.2)*S.%-'" $&'%48" Q/%4%" &$%&.6,',*14" '&$#%'4" &-(" '/%,$" ),-M&#%" '*"%.2)*S.%-'$&'/%$"'/&-"'*"4*9,&)"a14',9%"/&4".%&-'"'/&'"'/%$%",491$$%-')S" ),'')%" &-&)S4,4" *+" '/%" ,.2&9'" *+" %(19&',*-2*),9,%4"*-"%'/-,9".,-*$,'S"#$*124J" &-(" 42%9,+,9&))S*-" L*.&8" !)'/*1#/" 4*.%" Y%.6%$" ?'&'%4" (*.*-,'*$" %(19&',*-&)" &9/,%5%.%-'" 6S" %'/-,9" #$*12J'/,4" ,4" -*'" S%'" 9*..*-" &-(" &9/,%5%.%-'" &.*-#L*.&J"US24S"&-("Q$&5%))%$"9*..1-,',%4",4"91$$%-')S5%$S")*N"&9$*44"'/%"03DC[8"Q/,4",4"(1%",-")&$#%"2&$'"'*'/%"4%#$%#&',*-"*+"L*.&-,"&-(".&a*$,'S"2*21)&',*-

!

0c0>3Q7d0"?3YY!Le

Q/%"?,'1&',*-"*+"L*.&",-"&-"0-)&$#%("01$*2%&-"3-,*-

G Q/%"'%$."Q$&5%))%$"$%+)%9'4"'/%"-*.%-9)&'1$%"&(*2'%("6S"5&$,*14"#$*124"9*..*-)S"'/*1#/'"*+"&4"6%,-#"),-M%("'*"US24S"9*.D

.1-,',%4J"N/%'/%$"*$"-*'"'/%S"&$%"*$"N%$%"-*.&(,98"Q/%"'%$.",4"14%("2&$',91)&$)S",-"7$%)&-("&-("'/%"3P8C @1)#&$,&J">f%9/"L%216),9J"V$&-9%J"U$%%9%J"g1-#&$SJ"7$%)&-(J"O*)&-(J"L*.&-,&J"?)*5&M,&J"?2&,-"&-("'/%"3P

Page 8: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

9/,)($%-J" &-(" '/%" +&,)1$%" '*" 2$*5,(%" &(%`1&'%)S" +*$Q$&5%))%$"9/,)($%-8"Z/%$%"L*.&"9/,)($%-"&$%",-9)1(%(N,'/,-".&,-4'$%&." 49/**)4J" '/%4%" &$%" *+'%-" 2**$)S2$*5,(%("+*$J"*$"6%9*.%"^#/%''*,4%(_8

!"#Y%.6%$" ?'&'%" ),+%)*-#" )%&$-,-#" 4'$&'%#,%4" (*-*'J",-")&$#%"2&$'J",(%-',+S"'/%"-%%("+*$"2&$',91)&$"&''%-D',*-" '*" '/%" %(19&',*-" *+" L*.&J"US24S" &-(" Q$&5%))%$9/,)($%-J"&-("&)'/*1#/"&"-1.6%$"*+"01$*2%&-"?*9,&)V1-(" :0?V="2$*a%9'4"&-(" '/%">*..1-,'S"!9',*-"O$*D#$&..%",-"'/%"+,%)("*+"%(19&',*-"&-("5*9&',*-&)"'$&,-D,-#" :?*9$&'%4" &-(" W%*-&$(*" T&" d,-9," 2$*#$&..%4=/&5%" &(($%44%(" L*.&" ,441%4J" '/%4%" /&5%" 6%%-J" 6S'/%,$"(%.&-(D($,5%-"-&'1$%J")&$#%)S"!"#$%& ,-,',&',5%48

$%&'()%$*+

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

-"#V%N"*)("Y%.6%$"?'&'%4",(%-',+S"L*.&J"US24S&-("Q$&5%))%$"9*..1-,',%4"&4"'&$#%'%("#$*124"N,'/,-A&',*-&)" !9',*-" O)&-4" *-" %.2)*S.%-'8" Q/,4" ,4(%42,'%" '/%" +&9'" '/&'" 1-%.2)*S.%-'" $&'%4" &.*-#'/%4%"#$*124"9*-',-1%"'*"6%"&4"/,#/"&4"EKh",-"4*.%-%N"Y%.6%$"?'&'%48"Q/%"01$*2%&-"3-,*-b4"0i3!W,-,',&',5%J" N/,9/" '%4'4" -%N" &22$*&9/%4" '*" &-',D(,4D9$,.,-&',*-"&-(",-9)14,5%-%44"N,'/,-"'/%")&6*1$".&$DM%'J" /&4" +,-&-9%(" &$*1-(" F[" 2$*a%9'4" ,-" '/%" +,$4'$*1-(J" CKKKDCKKFJ"N/%$%"L*.&"9*..1-,',%4"N%$%&.*-#" '/%" 6%-%+,9,&$,%48" !#&,-J" &4" '/%4%" &$%(%.&-(" ($,5%-J" L*.&" ,441%4" /&5%" *+'%-" -*'" 6%%-&(($%44%(" 4S4'%.&',9&))S8" !4" %.2)*S.%-'" ,4" *+'%-'/%" M%S" '*" 2*5%$'S" %$&(,9&',*-" &-(" +1$'/%$" 4*9,&),-9)14,*-J" &-(" &4" L*.&" 1-%.2)*S.%-'" $%.&,-4/,#/J"-&',*-&)"&-("03"2$*#$&..%4"/&5%"S%'"'*".&M%

&-S"N,(%42$%&(" ,.2&9'J" %5%-" ,+" %R&.2)%4" *+" #**(2$&9',9%"(*"%R,4'8

.(/01*234"#g*14,-#",4")%44"(%5%)*2%("&4"&-"&$%&"*+"03"2*),9S&-(" ,4" ,-%),#,6)%" +*$" +,-&-9,-#" 1-(%$" '/%" 01$*2%&-L%#,*-&)"T%5%)*2.%-'"V1-(":0LTV=J"&)'/*1#/"'/%"03L&9%"T,$%9',5%"6&-4"(,49$,.,-&',*-",-"/*14,-#"2$*5,D4,*-"*-"'/%"6&4,4"*+"$&9%"*$"%'/-,9,'S8"Q/%"O/&$%"2$*D#$&..%" /&4" 2$*5,(%(" +,-&-9,-#" +*$" ,-+$&4'$19'1$%,-,',&',5%4" ,-" >%-'$&)" &-(" 0&4'%$-" 01$*2%8" A%5%$'/%D)%44J"'/$*1#/*1'"01$*2%"L*.&J"US24S"&-("Q$&5%))%$4),5%",-"416D4'&-(&$("&99*..*(&',*-"9/&$&9'%$,4%("6S&"^#/%''*,4&',*-_J",-&(%`1&'%",-+$&4'$19'1$%"&-("4%$5D,9%4J"4%#$%#&',*-"+$*."*'/%$"4%'')%.%-'4J"&"/,#/",-9,D(%-9%"*+"(,4%&4%"&-("'/%"'/$%&'"*+"%5,9',*-8""O$*5,4,*-+*$"Q$&5%))%$4",4"*+'%-"-*-D%R,4'%-'"*$",-&(%`1&'%8

56"#0R&.2)%4"*+"#**("2$&9',9%"2*,-'"'*"'/%"-%%(+*$"L*.&",-5*)5%.%-'"&'"&))"4'&#%4"*+"2)&--,-#"&-(%R%91',*-J"'/%"-%%("+*$"(%4%#$%#&',*-"&-("'/%"),-MD&#%"*+"/*14,-#"&-(",-+$&4'$19'1$%",-,',&',5%4"'*"9*.D2)%.%-'&$S"2$*#$&..%4",-"'/%"&$%&"*+"%.2)*S.%-'#%-%$&',*-8

.$7'+.879$#

55"#L&9,&)"&-("%'/-,9"(,49$,.,-&',*-",-"'/%"2$*5,4,*-*+"/%&)'/9&$%",4"%R2),9,')S"2$*/,6,'%(",-"'/%"03"L&9%T,$%9',5%"&-(" '/%"03"T,$%9'*$&'%"U%-%$&)"*+"O16),9g%&)'/" +,-&-9%4" &".*(%4'" >*..1-,'S" !9',*-" O$*D#$&..%",-"'/%"+,%)("*+"216),9"/%&)'/8 7'",4"&)4*",-"'/%2$*9%44" *+" (%5%)*2,-#" 9*..*-" /%&)'/" ,-(,9&'*$4&-(" &9M-*N)%(#%4" '/&'" ^4*9,*D%9*-*.,9" (%'%$.,D-&-'4J",-9)1(,-#".,-*$,'S"&-(".,#$&-'"2*21)&',*-4_[

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

!

Q/%"?,'1&',*-"*+"L*.&",-"&-"0-)&$#%("01$*2%&-"3-,*-

] >*1-9,)"T,$%9',5%"CKKK<F]<0>",.2)%.%-',-#"'/%"2$,-9,2)%"*+"%`1&)"'$%&'.%-'"6%'N%%-"2%$4*-4",$$%42%9',5%"*+"$&9,&)"*$"%'/-,9"*$,D

#,-":216),4/%(",-"Xj"WGEK"*+"GB"j1)S"CKKK=8F >*1-9,)"T,$%9',5%"CKKK<\E<0>"%4'&6),4/,-#"&"#%-%$&)"+$&.%N*$M"+*$"%`1&)"'$%&'.%-'",-"%.2)*S.%-'"&-("*9912&',*-":216),4/%(

,-"Xj"W]K]"*+"C"T%9%.6%$"CKKK=8[ ?%%"k/''2;<<NNN8%1$*2&8%18,-'<9*..</%&)'/l"+*$".*$%"(%'&,)8

Page 9: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

89(00:8/++1*2#100/$0'5;"#%5<=>4$3@597<9=58$;6;972;$><@5;;$#A@537$5?978

>445I$,52>8=$ =8D=J=DA>4;$95$;4=3$9K@5ALK$9K7$;>?796

879M$7=9K7@$D74=N7@>9746$5@$9K@5ALK$87L47<9O$!K7@7$=;

7J=D78<7$ 9K>9$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$27>;A@7;$>@7$>334=7D

95$ ,52>8=$ >334=<>89;$ ?5@$ ;5<=>4$ I74?>@7$ ;A335@9M

IK=47$ 3>@9=<A4>@$ D=??=<A49=7;$ ?><7$ !@>J7447@;O$ ($ <52C

258$ 3@5N472$ 9K@5ALK5A9$ #A@537$ =;$ 9K7$ 4><P$ 5?

>33@53@=>97$ D5<A2789>9=58$ >258L$,52>M$/63;=7;

>8D$!@>J7447@;M$ =8<4AD=8LM$NA9$859$<58?=87D$95M$N=@9K

>8D$ 2>@@=>L7$ <7@9=?=<>97;M$ @7;=D78<7$ 37@2=9;$ >8D

=D789=?=<>9=58$ D5<A2789;O !K=;$ K>;$ 47D$ 95$ ;7J7@7

3@5N472;$=8$><<7;;=8L$;5<=>4$;7@J=<7;M$>8D$=8$;527

<>;7;$K>;$7J78$47D$95$9K7$3K78527858$5?$;9>9747;;C

87;;O$ &8$ @7;37<9$ 5?$ L78D7@M$2>86$ ,52>8=$I5278

?><7$D5AN47$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$<5@@7;358D=8L46$45I

47J74;$5?$><<7;;$95$K7>49KM$7DA<>9=58$>8D$59K7@$;7@JC

=<7;O$/=J78$9K7$@547$5?$I5278$=8$;K>3=8L$9K7$7DA<>C

9=58$ 5?$ 9K7=@$ <K=4D@78M$ 9K=;$ ;=9A>9=58$ =;$ 3>@9=<A4>@46

I5@@6=8LO

8(*8'/01(*0#7*<#9$8(%%$*<7+1(*0

5="#$/#>?@?>"#/=J78$9K7$?>=4A@7$5?$3@7J=5A;$>8D$7Q=;9C

=8L$ 354=<=7;$ 95$ @725J7$ 5@$ ;=L8=?=<>8946$ @7DA<7$ D=;C

<@=2=8>9=58$ >L>=8;9$ ,52>M$ /63;=7;$ >8D$ !@>J7447@;M

>8D$95$3@52597$9K7=@$;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58M$9K7$#'$2A;9

9>P7$9K7$47>D$=8$9>@L79=8L$9K7;7$L@5A3;$I=9K=8$7Q=;9C

=8L$ >8D$ 87I$354=<=7;O$ &9$ =;$ @7<52278D7D$ 9K>9$ 9K7

#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$;K5A4D$7;9>N4=;K$>$<55@D=8>C

9=58$ ;9@A<9A@7$ 58$ ,52>$ =;;A7;$ 95$ 78;A@7$ 9K7

=23@5J7D$<5K7@78<7$>8D$7??=<><6$5?$ =9;$354=<=7;O$ &8

9K7$7J789$9K>9$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$><<739;$9K7$3@5C

35;>4$5?$9K7$#'$*79I5@P$5?$#Q37@9;$=8$+A8D>2789>4

"A2>8$,=LK9;$ 95$ >D539$ >$ ,52>$ &897L@>9=58$0=@7<C

9=J7M$A;=8L$(@9=<47$RE$5?$9K7$(2;97@D>2$!@7>96$>;$>

47L>4$N>;=;M$ 9K78$ 9K7$<55@D=8>9=58$;9@A<9A@7$;K5A4D

N7$ 4=8P7D$ 95$ 9K7$ 7Q7<A9=58$ >8D$ 3@5259=58$ 5?$ 9K7

0=@7<9=J7O$ !K7$ #A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ ;K5A4D$ >4;5

;77P$95$34>6$>$25@7$><9=J7$@547$I=9K=8$7Q=;9=8L$,52>

=8=9=>9=J7;$ 4>A8<K7D$ N6$ 9K7$ B5A8<=4$ 5?$ #A@537M$ 9K7

)%B#$>8D$59K7@;M$>8D$ =8J7;9=L>97$IK>9$ @547$ =9$<>8

34>6$=8$=23@5J=8L$<55@D=8>9=58$>258L$;A<K$N5D=7;O

5A"#!K7$#'$;K5A4D$<589=8A7$95$3@5J=D7$LA=D>8<7

95$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ 58$ 9K7$ <5447<9=58$ 5?$ D>9>$ 58

>;37<9;$5?$@><7$>8D$79K8=<=96$5?$@747J>8<7$95$;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58O$ !K7$ #A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ =;$ ?=8>8<=8L

@7;7>@<K$=895$D>9>$<5447<9=58$3@><9=<7;$74;7IK7@7$=8

9K7$I5@4DM$K>;$7;9>N4=;K7D$>$S5@P=8L$/@5A3$58$79KC

8=<$D>9>$<5447<9=58$>8D$I=44$?=8>8<7$>$<58?7@78<7$58

9K7$=;;A7$>9$9K7$78D$5?$FGGHO

5B"#!K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$;K5A4D$<589=8A7

=9;$7??5@9;$95$258=95@$9K7$9@>8;35;=9=58$5?$9K7$,><7

#TA>4=96$0=@7<9=J7$>8D$9K7$+@>27I5@P$#234562789

0=@7<9=J7$ =895$-72N7@$%9>97$ 4>I;M$>8D$ 9>P7$><9=58

>L>=8;9$ >86$ ;9>97$ 859$ <52346=8L$I=9K$ 9K=;$ @7TA7;9

I=9K=8$>$@7>;58>N47$9=27$37@=5DO

5!"#!K7$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$5?$,52>$;K5A4D$N7$>$?5<A;

5?$354=<6$5?$9K7$#'M$IK=<K$;K5A4D$LA=D7$-72N7@$%9>97;

=8$9K7$;37<=?=<>9=58$5?$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$=8

*>9=58>4$ (<9=58$ 14>8; <5J7@=8L$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58M$ 4=?7C

458L$47>@8=8L$>8D$7234562789M$>8D$3@5J=D7$LA=D>8<7

58$9K7$D7?=8=9=58$5?$>33@53@=>97$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$=8D=<>C

95@;O$ +=8>8<=8L$ =8;9@A2789;M$ =8<4AD=8L$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

%5<=>4$+A8DM$9K7$#A@537>8$,7L=58>4$07J74532789$+A8D

>8D$B522A8=96$(<9=58$1@5L@>227;$ =8$3AN4=<$K7>49KM

7234562789$ >8D$ ;5<=>4$ >??>=@;M$ ;K5A4D$ L=J7$ 7Q34=<=9

@7<5L8=9=58$5?$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$9K7=@$>334=<>9=58

LA=D74=87;O$/A=D74=87;$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ 3@7;7897D$ =8$ >$I>6

9K>9$78<5A@>L7;$9K7$=8J54J72789$5?$,52>$*/);M$>8D

IK7@7$ >33@53@=>97$ >$ 3@535@9=58$ 5?$ ?A8D=8L$2=LK9$ N7

2>D7$>J>=4>N47$?5@$9K7$;9@78L9K78=8L$5?$,52>$5@L>8=;>C

9=58;$I=;K=8L$95$3>@9=<=3>97$=8$<>44;$?5@$3@535;>4;O

5,"#!K7$#'$;K5A4D$>33@5><K$9K7$=23@5J72789$5?

9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$9K@5ALK$N59K$2>=8;9@7>2=8L

>8D$ ;37<=?=<$ 27>;A@7;$ >8D$ ?=8>8<=>4$ >445<>9=58;M

78;A@7$9K>9$=9$=8J54J7;$,52>$@73@7;789>9=J7;$=8$354C

=<6$ ?5@2A4>9=58$ >8D$ 258=95@=8LM$ ;9@78L9K78$ =9;

KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ 258=95@=8L$ >8D$ 3AN4=<=;7$ 9K7$ >89=C

,52>8=$@><=;2O$+=8>446M$=9$;K5A4D$@7<5L8=;7$9K>9$9K7

;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$I=9K=8$ 9K7$#'$ =;$ @74>97D$ 95$ 9K7=@

;=9A>9=58$ =8$ 87=LKN5A@=8L$ ;9>97;M$ >8D$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ #'

?=8>8<7D$7Q97@8>4$@74>9=58;$3@5L@>227;$=8$9K7$>334=C

<>89$<5A89@=7;M$9K7$S7;97@8$U>4P>8;$>8D$9K7$?5@27@

%5J=79$'8=58$ >DD@7;;$ =;;A7;$5?$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D

37@;7<A9=58$>L>=8;9$,52>O

5-"#%?CD?E#FGHG?#>?@?>" (;$859$>44$-72N7@$%9>97;

><<739$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$>;$D=;9=8<9$79KC

8=<$2=85@=9=7;M$9K7=@$@7<5L8=9=58$>;$;A<K$@73@7;789;$>8

7;;789=>4$ ?=@;9$ ;973$ 95$ 9K7$ @725J>4$ 5?$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58

>8D$ 9K7$ 3@5259=58$ 5?$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58O -5@75J7@M

>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ 4>I;$ =8$-72N7@$ %9>97;$ 877D$ 95

@7?47<9$9K7$,><7$#TA>4=96$0=@7<9=J7$>8D$9K7$+@>27I5@P

#234562789$ 0=@7<9=J7M$ >8D$ ?A44$ 9@>8;35;=9=58$ =;

A@L789O V=L=4>8<7$ =;$ >4;5$ @7TA=@7D$ 95$ 78;A@7$ 9K>9

-72N7@$ %9>97;$ @>9=?6$ 1@595<54$ RF$ 95$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

B58J789=58$58$"A2>8$,=LK9;O

54"#&8$<544>N5@>9=58$I=9K$9K7$@747J>89$;7@J=<7;$5?

9K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58M$-72N7@$%9>97;$877D$95

D7J7453$279K5D;$5?$79K8=<$D>9>$<5447<9=58$=8$5@D7@

95$ 258=95@$ 9K7$ 7??7<9;$ 5?$ 9K7=@$ 354=<=7;$ 58$ 79K8=<

!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 10: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

2=85@=9=7;M$>8D$95$9>P7$<5@@7<9=J7$><9=58$>;$@7TA=@7DO

-72N7@$%9>97$*>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8;$877D$95$7Q34=<C

=946$@7<5L8=;7$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$IK7@7$>33@53@=C

>97M$ >8D$-72N7@$%9>97;$877D$ 95$3@55?$ >44$ 354=<=7;

?5@$ 9K7=@$359789=>4$7??7<9;$58$79K8=<$2=85@=9=7;M$>8D

58$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$=8$3>@9=<A4>@O

;6"# *>9=58>4$ (<9=58$ 14>8;$ ?5@$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58

877D$ 95$ @7<5L8=;7$ 7Q34=<=946$ 9K7$ 877D$ ?5@$ ;37<=?=<

27>;A@7;$58$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;M$>8D$95

25J7$ >I>6$ ?@52$ 9>@L79=8L$ ,52>$ 9K@5ALK$ >$ ?@>LC

27897D$ <5447<9=58$ 5?$ =8D=J=DA>4$ 3@5W7<9;O$ &8;97>DM

-72N7@$%9>97;$877D$95$>D539$>8$>33@5><K$9K>9M$=8

>$<5K7@789$2>887@M$3@52597;$9K7$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$5?

,52>$I=9K=8$7Q=;9=8L$354=<=7;O

;5"#+=8>446M$-72N7@$%9>97;$<>8$>;;=;9$=8$9K7$<58;=;C

9789$>8D$?>=@$ 9@7>92789$5?$2=L@>89;$N6$;=L8=8L$A3$95

9K7$<58J789=58;$D@>I8$A3$N6$9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537

>8D$9K7$'8=97D$*>9=58;M$<5234=>8<7$I=9K$IK=<K$I5A4D

=23@5J7$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$IK5$>@7$2=L@>89;O

;;"#8I@I>#FJKI?GL#>?@?>"#,52>$5@L>8=;>9=58;$K>J7

>$@547$95$34>6$=8$>DJ>8<=8L$9K7=@$5I8$I74?>@7$N6$3>@C

9=<=3>9=8L$ =8$ ;5<=79=7;$ 95$ 9K7$ 7Q9789$ 9K76$ >@7$ >N47M

>8D$ <589@=NA9=8L$ 95$ 9K7$ @725J>4$ 5?$ 3@7WAD=<7;$ >8D

;97@759637;O$ !K76$ ;K5A4D$ <58;=D7@$ 3>@9=<=3>9=8L$ =8

;=8L47C=;;A7$45NN6$L@5A3;M$IK=<K$2=LK9$9K78$@7<5LC

8=;7$ 25@7$ <47>@46$ 9K7$ D=;>DJ>89>L7D$ 35;=9=58$ 5?

,52>M$>8D$;K5A4D$25J7$95I>@D;$9K7$<58;54=D>9=58

5?$ D=??7@=8L$ J=7I;$ N79I778$ J>@=5A;$ ,52>M$ /63;6

>8D$ !@>J7447@$ L@5A3;$ =895$ >$ ;=8L47M$ 2>W5@=96$ J5=<7M

I=9K$9K7$5NW7<9=J7$5?$3@7;789=8L$354=<6C2>P7@;$I=9K

<47>@$>8D$A8>2N=LA5A;$3@535;>4;O

;="# ,52>M$ /63;6$ >8D$ !@>J7447@$ 5@L>8=;>9=58;

;K5A4D$ >4;5$ =8J54J7$ 9K72;74J7;$ =8$ 7??5@9;$ 95$ 3@5C

2597$ 79K8=<$258=95@=8L$ >;$ >$27>8;$ 95$ =D789=?6=8L

3@5N472;M$ >@LA=8L$ ?5@$ 9>@L797D$ 354=<=7;$ >8D$ 3@5C

L@>227;M$258=95@=8L$><9=58$>8D$7J>4A>9=8L$=23><9O

)8<7$9K76$>@7$<58J=8<7D$9K>9$8>9=58>4$5@$=897@8>9=58C

>4$>A9K5@=9=7;$D5$859$K>J7$>86$59K7@M$D=;<@=2=8>95@6M

5NW7<9=J7$ =8$ <5447<9=8L$ D>9>M$ 9K78$ 9K76$ ;K5A4D$ >4;5

N7<527$=8J54J7D$=8$>I>@787;;$@>=;=8L$>258L$,52>

>;$95$9K7$J>4A7$5?$D>9>$<5447<9=58$58$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58

27>;A@7;$N6$79K8=<$L@5A3O

;A"# +=8>446M$ 7Q=;9=8L$ #A@537>8$ */);$ >8D$ 9K7=@

879I5@P;$=8J54J7D$=8$KA2>8$@=LK9;M$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>C

9=58$>8D$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$=;;A7;$;K5A4D$<58;=D7@$9K7

;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ >8$ 784>@L7D$ #'$ >8D$ ><9$ 95

=8<4AD7$,52>$@73@7;789>9=J7;$>8D$272N7@;$=8$9K7=@

5@L>8=;>9=58;M$ =8$ 5@D7@$ 95$ 78;A@7$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ 3@7;789

D7L@77$ 5?$ ;5<=>4$ 7Q<4A;=58$ >8D$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ =;

N@5ALK9$95$>8$78DO

!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 11: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

5" !K7$ 0=@7<95@>97$ /787@>4$ ?5@$ #234562789$ >8D

%5<=>4$(??>=@;$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$<589@><9C

7D$9K7$3@5DA<9=58$5?$9K=;$@735@9O$!K7$;9AD6$I>;$?A8DC

7D$ 9K@5ALK$ 9K7$ B522A8=96$ (<9=58$ 1@5L@>227$ 95

<52N>9$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58M$I>;$<>@C

@=7D$ 5A9$ 5J7@$ >$ 37@=5D$ 5?$ RG$2589K;M$ N7L=88=8L$ =8

*5J72N7@$ FGGEM$ >8D$ I>;$ N>;7D$ 58$ 7Q978;=J7

@7;7>@<K$ =8$747J78$<5A89@=7;O !K7$7Q7<A9=58$5?$ 9K7

;9AD6$I>;$>4;5$?><=4=9>97D$N6$9K7$K54D=8L$5?$>$B58?7@C

78<7$58$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$784>@L7D$#'$=8

U@A;;74;$ =8$(3@=4$ FGGHM$ >9$IK=<K$ @73@7;789>9=J7;$5?

,52>$ 5@L>8=;>9=58;$ >8D$ 59K7@$ =897@7;97D$ 3>@9=7;

2>D7$ J>4A>N47$ <589@=NA9=58;$ 95$ 354=<6$ D=;<A;;=58;O

!K7$2>=8$?5<A;$5?$9K7$@735@9$=;$95$=D789=?6$>8D$K=LKC

4=LK9$ 9K7$ =234=<>9=58;$ 5?$ 784>@L72789$ ?5@$ 9K7$ #A@5C

37>8$ '8=58X;$ 354=<=7;$ 58$ >89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D

;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$=8$@74>9=58$95$,52>O$BK>397@$R$=89@5C

DA<7;$ 9K7$ >33@5><K$ 95$ ;9AD6$ 7Q7<A9=58M$ BK>397@$ F

3@7;789;$>$N@=7?$K=;95@6$5?$,52>$I=9K=8$#A@537$>8D

BK>397@$ E$ 5A94=87;$ 9K7$ @747J>89$ 354=<6$ ?@>27I5@P;

I=9K=8$ #A@537O$ BK>397@$ H$ D79>=4;$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?

,52>$=8$>$8A2N7@$5?$P76$;7<95@>4$?=74D;$>8D$BK>397@

Y$D7>4;$I=9K$9K7$354=<6$<K>4478L7;$9K>9$>@7$@>=;7D$N6

9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ #A@537O$ B58<4A;=58;$ >8D

@7<52278D>9=58;$>@7$3@7;7897D$=8$BK>397@$ZM$>8D$>

N=N4=5L@>3K6$3@5J=D7;$?5@$?A@9K7@$@7>D=8LO$+5A@$7Q>2C

347;$ 5?$ L55D$3@><9=<7$ >@7$ 3@7;7897D$ =8$ 97Q9$ N5Q7;O

SK=4;9$ 9K7@7$>@7$>$8A2N7@$5?$3@52=;=8L$87I$ =8=9=>C

9=J7;$9>P=8L$34><7$>9$3@7;789M$9K7@7$>@7$87J7@9K747;;

>$4=2=97D$8A2N7@$5?$3@5J78$7Q>2347;$5?$L55D$3@><C

9=<7$9K>9$2>6$N7$<58?=D78946$<=97D$?5@$@734=<>9=58O

;"# !K7$ <5A89@=7;$ ;747<97D$ ?5@$ 3>@9=<A4>@$ ;9AD6

=8<4AD7D$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ [54D$-72N7@$ %9>97;\$ ]$ =O7OM

9K7$RY$-72N7@$%9>97;$3@7C->6$FGGH$ CC$ >;$I744$ >;

[87I$-72N7@$%9>97;\M$IK=<K$ W5=87D$ 9K7$#A@537>8

'8=58$=8$->6$FGGHO$,7;7>@<K$I>;$>4;5$<>@@=7D$5A9$=8

UA4L>@=>$ >8D$ ,52>8=>M$ N59K$ >334=<>89;$ 95$ W5=8$ 9K7

#'$=8$FGG^O$!>@L797D$@7;7>@<K$I>;$9KA;$A8D7@9>P78

=8$ UA4L>@=>M$ B_7<K$ ,73AN4=<M$ +@>8<7M$ /@77<7M$ "A8C

L>@6M$ &@74>8DM$154>8DM$,52>8=>M$%45J>P=>M$%3>=8$>8D

9K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52OZ &9$=;$><P85I47DL7DM$K5I7J7@M

9K>9$9K7$=;;A7;$@>=;7D$=8$@74>9=58$95$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?

,52>$=8$9K7;7$<5A89@=7;$>@7M$95$>$4>@L7$7Q9789M$<52C

258$95$>425;9$>44$-72N7@$%9>97;O

=" ,7;7>@<K$K>;$7Q>2=87D$>8D$7Q345@7D$ =8$3>@C

9=<A4>@$ 9K7$ 8>9A@7$ 5?$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >L>=8;9$ ,52>M

=D789=?=7D$ 9K7$ ?><95@;$2=4=9>9=8L$ >L>=8;9$ 9K7=@$ ;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58M$>8D$D7;<@=N7D$354=<=7;$>8D$3@><9=<7;$9K>9

D7258;9@>97$ L55D$ >8D$ N7;9$ 3@><9=<7O$ ,7;7>@<K7@;

K>J7$ =D789=?=7D$ >8D$ <523=47D$ 7Q=;9=8L$ D>9>$ 58$ 9K7

;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$;7<95@>4$?=74D;$5?$@747J>8<7$95

#'$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 354=<6M$ >8D$ ;5ALK9$ 95$ =D789=?6

>@7>;$=8$IK=<K$;A<K$D>9>$2>6$N7$2=;;=8LO$!K7$?=8DC

=8L;$K>J7$>9972397D$95$>;;7;;$9K7$<A@@789$;=9A>9=58

=8$@74>9=58$95$9K7$7Q=;9=8L$#'$>8D$D527;9=<$L5J7@8C

2789$354=<=7;$58$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$;5<=>4$=8<4AC

;=58M$I=9K$>33@53@=>97$354=<6$@7<52278D>9=58;O

A"#+5@$9K7$3A@35;7;$5?$9K=;$@735@9M$9K7$97@2;$a,52>a

>8D$ a,52>$>8D$59K7@$ L@5A3;$37@<7=J7D$ >;$ b/63;=7;ba

=8<4AD7$ 37@;58;$ D7;<@=N=8L$ 9K72;74J7;$ >;$ ,52>M

/63;=7;M$!@>J7447@;M$->85A<K7;M$%=89=M$>;$I744$>;$59K7@

97@2;O$&9$=;$95$N7$8597DM$K5I7J7@M$9K>9$L787@>4$A;7$5?

9K7$97@2$,52>$=;$=8$85$I>6$=8978D7D$95$D5I834>6$5@

=L85@7$ 9K7$ L@7>9$ D=J7@;=96$ I=9K=8$ 9K7$ 2>86$ D=??7@789

,52>8=$ L@5A3;$ >8D$ @74>97D$ <522A8=9=7;M$ 85@$ =;$ =9

=8978D7D$95$3@52597$;97@759637;O$0=J7@;=96$I=9K=8$9K7

,52>8=$ <522A8=9=7;$ =;M$ >;$ I=9K$ >44$ <522A8=9=7;M

<52347Q$ >8D$ 2A49=CD=278;=58>4$ >8D$ =8J54J7;

D=??7@78<7;$ 5?$ 4>8LA>L7$ >8D$ D=>47<9M$ K=;95@6M$ <A49A@7M

@74=L=58^ >8D$ ;5<=>4$ <4>;;M$ >8D$ 7DA<>9=58>4$ >8D

!

RO$&*!,)0'B!&)*

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Z &8D=J=DA>4$<5A89@6$@7;7>@<K7@;$=8$9K7$8>27D$<5A89@=7;$K>J7$>334=7D$>$;9>8D>@D=;7D$279K5D545L6M$D7;=L87D$=8$<58;A49>9=58$I=9K

9K7$B522=;;=58M$;5$>;$95$78;A@7$c=d$2>Q=2A2$@74=>N=4=96M$c==d$2>Q=2A2$=8;A4>9=58$?@52$>@N=9@>@6$>8De5@$;ANW7<9=J7$=8?4A78<7$>8D

c===d$2>Q=2A2$<523>@>N=4=96$><@5;;$D>9>$3554;O$,7;7>@<K7@;$K>J7$>4;5$;5ALK9$>$K=LK$D7L@77$5?$<58;A49>9=58$I=9K$L5J7@82789

5??=<=>4;M$7Q37@9;$>8D$272N7@;$5?$<=J=4$;5<=796O

^ ,52>$=8$#A@537$978D$95$N7458L$7=9K7@$95$587$5?$9K7$BK@=;9=>8$<KA@<K7;$5@$c3@7D52=8>8946$=8$9K7$;5A9K7@8$U>4P>8;d$95$N7$-A;4=2O

Page 12: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

5<<A3>9=58>4$ ;9>9A;O$ %527$ <522A8=9=7;$ >8D

=8D=J=DA>4;$ <5J7@7D$ =8$ 9K=;$ ;9AD6$ >@7$ 852>D=<$ N6

<A49A@7M$IK=47$59K7@;$>@7$;7D789>@6O

B"#!K=;$ ;9AD6$A;7;$ 9K7$ 97@2$ a,52>a$ >;$ 9K7$34A@>4

85A8$?5@2M$>;$I744$>;$95$8>27$9K7$L@5A3$>;$>$IK547M

>8D$ a,52>8=a$ >;$ 9K7$>DW7<9=J7M$ =8$ 4=87$I=9K$727@L=8L

>8D$<58J7@L=8L$A;7;O$a,52>8=a$=;$>4;5$A;7D$?5@$9K7$3A@C

35;7;$5?$ 9K=;$ @735@9$>;$9K7$8>27$5?$ 9K7$,52>8=$ 4>8C

LA>L7O$(9$>$8A2N7@$5?$35=89;$ =8$9K=;$;9AD6M$9K7$97@2

a,52>a$5@$a,52>8=a$=;$A;7D$>;$;K5@9K>8D$?5@$9K7$N@5>D

A2N@744>$5?$L@5A3;$>8D$=8D=J=DA>4;O$&8$85$I>6$;K5A4D

9K=;$ <K5=<7$ 5?$ 97@2=8545L6$ N7$ 9>P78$ >;$ >8$ 78D5@;7C

2789$ 5?$ >33@5><K7;$ >=27D$ >9$ K525L78=;=8L$ ,52>

>8D$59K7@$L@5A3;$37@<7=J7D$>;$a/63;=7;a$=8$#A@537$5@

>9$74=2=8>9=8L$9K7$@=<K$D=J7@;=96$>258L$,52>M$/63;=7;M

!@>J7447@;$>8D$59K7@$L@5A3;$37@<7=J7D$>;$a/63;=7;aO

!"#!K7$,52>8=$ 4>8LA>L7$=;$;35P78$N6$2=44=58;$5?

#A@537>8;M$2>P=8L$=9$587$5?$9K7$3@=8<=3>4$2=85@=96$4>8C

LA>L7;$5?$#A@537O$,52>8=$=;$>8$&8D=<$4>8LA>L7M$<45;7C

46$ @74>97D$ 95$25D7@8$"=8D=M$IK=<K$ D7J74537D$ =8$ 9K7

#A@537>8$D=>;35@>$A8D7@$9K7$=8?4A78<7$5?$>$8A2N7@$5?

59K7@$4>8LA>L7;M$25;9$859>N46$U6_>89=87$/@77PO$!K7@7

>@7$2>86$D=>47<9;$5?$,52>8=f >8D$>49K5ALK$=8$9K7$3>;9

9K7@7$ K>J7$ N778$ 7??5@9;$ 95$ D786$ 9K7$ 47L=9=2><6$ 5?

,52>8=$>;$>$4>8LA>L7M$I=9K$;527$;<K54>@;$<4>;;=?6=8L

=9$>;$>$?5@2$5?$W>@L58M$9K7@7$=;$85I$N@5>D$<58;78;A;

>258L$ 4=8LA=;9;$ >;$ 95$ 9K7$ I7>49K$ >8D$ A8=96$ 5?$ 9K7

,52>8=$ 4>8LA>L7O$ &8$>DD=9=58M$;527$,52>8=$L@5A3;

;37>P$59K7@$2=85@=96$ 4>8LA>L7;M$ ;527$5?$IK=<K$>@7

3>@9=<A4>@$ 95$ ,52>$ >8D$ 59K7@$ L@5A3;$ 37@<7=J7D$ >;

a/63;=7;aO$ +5@$ 7Q>2347M$ >$ 4>@L7$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8

"A8L>@6$ >@7$ 8>9=J7$ ;37>P7@;$ 5?$ U7>;KM$ >8$ >@<K>=<

?5@2$5?$,52>8=>8O$->86$!@>J7447@;$=8$9K7$'8=97D$`=8LC

D52$>8D$&@74>8D$;37>P$/>2258M$;5279=27;$@7?7@@7D

95$ >;$ aB>89aM$ >$ 4>8LA>L7$ I=9K$ 2>86$ ,52>8=$ 45>8C

I5@D;M$NA9$859$9K5ALK9$95$N7$>$D=>47<9$5?$,52>8=$=9;74?O

)9K7@$ 858C2>W5@=96$ 4>8LA>L7;$ ;35P78$ N6$ ,52>$ =8

#A@537$=8<4AD7$g78=;<K$>8D$`>45O

,"# (49K5ALK$ 3@7<=;7$ ?=LA@7;$ >@7$ A8>J>=4>N47M

9K7@7$>@7$35;;=N46$5J7@$978$2=44=58$,52>$=8$#A@537

>;$>$IK547M$>$353A4>9=58$2>86$9=27;$9K7$;=_7$5?$9K7

959>4$ 353A4>9=58$ 5?$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ #A@537>8$ '8=58

-72N7@$%9>97;O$!K7$N7;9$7;9=2>97;h 5?$8A2N7@;$5?

,52>$ =8$ 9K7$ RR$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ >8D$ <>8D=D>97

<5A89@=7;$;9AD=7D$?5@$9K=;$@735@9$=8D=<>97$>$@>8L7$5?

N79I778$FO^2$>8D$YOZ2O$(@5A8D$587$>8D$>$K>4?$2=4C

4=58$,52>$W5=87D$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$IK78$9K7$978

87I$-72N7@$%9>97;$><<7D7D$95$9K7$'8=58$=8$->6

FGGHO ,52>$ >@7$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58X;$ 4>@L7;9

2=85@=96$79K8=<$<522A8=96O

-"#%=8<7$ 9K7$ 78D$5?$B522A8=;2$ =8$ 9K7$ ?5@27@

%5J=79$'8=58$>8D$9K7$?>44$5?$B)-#B)*M$=;;A7;$?><C

=8L$ ,52>$ K>J7$ <527$ 95$ N7$ J=7I7D$ >;$ >258L

#A@537b;$ 25;9$ 3@7;;=8L$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ >8D$ ;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58$ 3@=5@=9=7;O$ 0A@=8L$ 9K=;$ 37@=5D$ 5?$ 784>@L7C

2789$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58M$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>

K>;$ @737>97D46$N778$ ;9@7;;7D$>;$ >8$ >@7>$ =8$IK=<K

9K7$ L5J7@82789;$ 5?$ 87I$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ 2A;9

?5<A;$354=<6$>99789=58O$&9$K>D$N778$8597D$9K>9$9K7$;=9C

A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$2>86$ ><<7;;=58$ >8D$ <>8D=D>97

<5A89@=7;$ ?5@$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ @>=;7D$ =;;A7;

A8D7@$ 9K7$ ;5C<>447D [B5378K>L78$ B@=97@=>\M$ IK=<K

;79$;9>8D>@D;$?5@$<5A89@=7;$I=;K=8L$95$ W5=8$9K7$#'O

(258L$ 9K7$ B5378K>L78$ 154=9=<>4$ B@=97@=>$ =;$ 9K7

@7TA=@72789$5?$a;9>N=4=96$5?$=8;9=9A9=58;$LA>@>8977=8L

D725<@><6M$ 9K7$ @A47$ 5?$ 4>IM$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ >8D

@7;37<9$?5@M$>8D$3@597<9=58$5?M$2=85@=9=7;aO

4"#"5I7J7@M$8A27@5A;$>;;7;;2789;$5?$9K7$;=9A>C

9=58$5?$,52>$ =8$N59K$87I$>8D$54D$-72N7@$%9>97;

<47>@46$=44A;9@>97$9K>9$272N7@;$5?$9K7;7$<522A8=9=7;

<589=8A7$ 95$ 7Q37@=78<7$ 2>@P7D$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D

;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58M$>8D$95$78<5A897@$D=??=<A49=7;$=8$L>=8C

=8L$ A8K=8D7@7D$ >8D$ 7TA>4$ ><<7;;$ 95$ 7234562789M

7DA<>9=58M$;5<=>4$;7<A@=96M$K7>49K<>@7M$K5A;=8LM$59K7@

3AN4=<$ ;7@J=<7;$ >8D$ WA;9=<7O$ !K7$ >;;7;;2789;$ >4;5

;K5I$9K>9$2>86$,52>8=$<522A8=9=7;$>@7$A8=TA746

7Q35;7D$95$9K7$?5@<7;$5?$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58O

56"#!K7$ ?A@9K7@$D7J74532789$5?$ >89=CD=;<@=2=8>C

9=58$>8D$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$354=<=7;$>9$9K7$#'$47J74$>8D

=8$-72N7@$%9>97;$I=44M$9K7@7?5@7M$85I$877D$95$9>P7

><<5A89$5?$9K7$3>@9=<A4>@$877D;$5?$9K=;$L@5A3O$!K7;7

D7J74532789;$I=44$N787?=9$?@52M$>8D$=8$>$25@7$?A8C

D>2789>4$I>6$ 9K>8$K=9K7@95$877D$ 95$NA=4D$58M$ <A@C

@789$ ;9@A<9A@7;M$ 3@5L@>227;$ >8D$ =8;9@A2789;M

>258L$IK=<K$ 9K7@7$ >@7$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ 7Q>2347;$ 5?

L55D$3@><9=<7$=8$@7L>@D$95$9K7$;A<<7;;?A4$=897L@>9=58

5?$,52>$<522A8=9=7;O$!K7@7$=;$<58;=D7@>N47$;<537

?5@$ 9K7$3A@35;7?A4$7Q<K>8L7$5?$ 9K7;7$7Q37@=78<7;M

IK=<K$;972$?@52$I5@P$>=27D$>9$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58

>8D$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58M$>;$D7;<@=N7D$4>97@$=8$9K=;$@735@9O

!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

f )8$9K7$,52>8=$ 4>8LA>L7M$;77$7;37<=>446$->9@>;M$i>@58M$!"#$%&'()(*&%+,&-.&/( 0%.1"2,/.&"%M$B>2N@=DL7j$B>2N@=DL7$'8=J7@;=96

1@7;;M$FGGFM$>;$I744$>;M$U>PP7@M$1797@$>8D$"@=;95$`6A<KAP5J$c7DdM$34$.(&-(.45(!"#$%&(6$%+,$+57 ">9?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@DC

;K=@7$1@7;;M$&897@?><7$B5447<9=58M$FGGGO

h )??=<=>4$>8D$A85??=<=>4$7;9=2>97;$>@7$5378$95$=897@3@79>9=58$>8D$D=;3A97M$>8D$85$<58;78;A;$?=LA@7;$7Q=;9O

Page 13: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

5"#!K7$<A@@789$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$#A@537$<>8859$N7

?A446$ A8D7@;955D$ I=9K5A9$ >8$ A8D7@;9>8D=8L$ 5?$ 9K7

K=;95@6$5?$9K7$9@7>92789$5?$,52>$=8$#A@537O$!K7$K=;C

95@6$5?$,52>$=;$859$I744$D5<A27897DM$2>=846$DA7$95

9K7$ ?><9$ 9K>9$ ,52>$ K>J7$ 47?9$ N7K=8D$ ?7I$ I@=9978

@7<5@D;$ @74>97D$ 95$ 9K7=@$ <522A8>4$ 7Q=;978<7O

(49K5ALK$9K7$K=;95@=<>4$5@=L=8;$5?$,52>$K>J7$>9$9=27;

N778$=8$D=;3A97M$=9$=;$85I$4>@L746$>$2>997@$5?$<58;78C

;A;$ CC$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ 58$ 9K7$ ;9@78L9K$ 5?$ 4=8LA=;9=<$ 7J=C

D78<7$CC$9K>9$9K7$,52>8=$375347$>@7$D7;<78D7D$?@52

L@5A3;$ IK5$ 47?9$ 9K7$ &8D=>8$ ;ANC<589=8789$ 95I>@D;

9K7$ 78D$ 5?$ 9K7$ ?=@;9$2=4478=A2$BO#O$ ,52>8=$ L@5A3;

I7@7$ 8597D$ =8$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ 3>@9$ 5?$ 9K7$ U6_>89=87

#23=@7$ N6$ 9K7$ 747J789K$ <789A@6$ >8D$ 3@5N>N46

7897@7D$%3>=8$?@52$*5@9K$(?@=<>$>9$>@5A8D$9K7$;>27

9=27O$(@7>;$45<>97D$=8$IK>9$=;$95D>6$;5A9K7@8$/@77<7

I7@7$8597D$>;$<789@7;$5?$,52>8=$;799472789$=8$9K7

?5A@97789K$>8D$ ?=?97789K$<789A@=7;$>8D$ =9$ =;$ 9K5ALK9

9K>9$,52>$4=J7D$9K@5ALK5A9$9K7$U>4P>8;$N6$9K>9$9=27O

;"#+5445I=8L$>$37@=5D$5?$ @74>9=J7$ 9547@>8<7$ =8$ 9K7

4>97$-=DD47$(L7;M$,52>$I7@7$;ANW7<97D$95$9K7$?=@;9$5?

>$;7@=7;$5?$73=;5D7;$5?$37@;7<A9=58$=8$#A@537O$!K7@7

=;$;527$<58;78;A;$>258L$K=;95@=>8;$9K>9M$3@=5@$95$=9;

458L$D7<4=87$>8D$9K7$73=;5D7;$5?$@73@7;;=58$><<52C

3>86=8L$=9M$9K7$)9952>8$#23=@7$I>;$>$25@7$9547@>89

@7>42$9K>8$BK@=;9=>8$3@7C#84=LK9782789$#A@537$L78C

7@>446MRG >8D$ 9K>9$ 9K=;$ 9547@>8<7$7Q978D7D$ 95$,52>RRO

!K7$ @74>9=J746$ K=LK7@$ 8A2N7@;$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ >@7>;$ 5?

#A@537$ 95D>6M$ IK=<K$ ?5@27@46$ <523@=;7D$ )9952>8

35;;7;;=58;M$ I5A4D$ ;772$ 95$ N7>@$ 5A9$ 9K=;$ <58C

9789=58M$>49K5ALK$)9952>8$>A9K5@=9=7;$>;$>$2>997@$5?

354=<6$D=;<@=2=8>97D$>L>=8;9$858C-A;4=2;M$>8D$7J78

I=9K=8$9K7$-A;4=2$<522A8=96$,52>$>337>@$95$K>J7

N778$3>@9=<A4>@46$D=;<@=2=8>97D$>L>=8;9ORF

="# S=9K=8$ 9K7$ )9952>8$ #23=@7M$ ,52>$ I5A4D

;772$95$K>J7$?>@7D$I5@;9$=8$>@7>;$5?$9K7$#23=@7$<58C

;=D7@7D$@74>9=J7$N><PI>97@;M$;A<K$>;$ =8$>@7>;$95D>6

45<>97D$ =8$ ,52>8=>M$ IK7@7$ 45<>4$ 4>8D5I87@;$ >8D

<47@L6$78;4>J7D$,52>O$1@5?7;;5@$5?$,52>8=$%9AD=7;

0@O$!K52>;$(<958$K>;$<5227897D$5?$,52>8=$K=;95C

@6$ =8$#A@537$=8$9K7$RZ9K$>8D$R^9K$<789A@=7;j$aSK78

,52>8=$375347$ ?@52$#>;97@8$#A@537$2779$,52>8=

375347$ ?@52$*5@9KCS7;97@8$ #A@537$ 95D>6M$ =9$ =;$ 9K7

D7;<78D789;$5?$9K7$;A@J=J5@;$5?$;4>J7@6$2779=8L$9K7

D7;<78D789;$5?$9K7$;A@J=J5@;$5?$L785<=D7Oa

A"#!K7$#84=LK9782789$N@5ALK9$I=9K$ =9$>$;7@=7;$5?

87I$>33@5><K7;$95I>@D$,52>O$&8$9K7$2=DCRf9K$<78C

9A@6M$ 9K7$ ?=@;9$ =8$ >$ ;7@=7;$ 5?$ 7??5@9;$I>;$ A8D7@9>P78

>997239=8L$95$<52374$,52>$95$<58?5@2$95$9K7$85@2;

5?$9K7$I=D7@$;5<=796O$&9$=;$A8<47>@$95$IK>9$7Q9789$9K7;7

7>@46$5@D7@;$I7@7$7J78$5N767D$>9$>$45<>4$47J74M$NA9$=8

9K7$;AN;7TA789$9I5$<789A@=7;$,52>$K>J7$?@7TA78946

N778$@725J7D$?@52$9K7=@$?>2=4=7;$N6$?5@<7$>8D$34><7D

I=9K$858C,52>8=$?>2=4=7;M$5@$34><7D$=8$=8;9=9A9=58;M$=8

>8$7??5@9$95$@=D$9K72$5?$IK>9$K>J7$N778$37@<7=J7D$>;

D7J=>89$9@>=9;M$>8D$95$78D$9K7$<52258$7Q=;978<7$5?

9K7$79K8=<$L@5A3$=9;74?O$!K7$D7J74532789$5?$25D7@8

354=<7$3@><9=<7;$N@5ALK9$I=9K$ =9$ 9K7$D7J74532789$5?

=D7>;$5?$ a/63;6$ <@=27aM$ >8D$I=9K$ =9M$ <523@7K78;=J7

354=<7$@7L=;97@;$5?$,52>ORE

B"#,52>$I7@7$9>@L797D$?5@$@><7CN>;7D$37@;7<AC

9=58$DA@=8L$9K7$"=947@$@7L=27$=8$/7@2>86M$RhEECRhHYM

!

FO$,)-($&*$#',)1#j$($U,&#+$"&%!),i

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RG B523>@>9=J7$;9AD6$5?$9547@>8<7$=8$)9952>8$>8D$BK@=;9=>8$@A47$K>;$N778$3>@9=<A4>@46$7Q978;=J746$7Q>2=87D$I=9K$@7;37<9$95$g7I;O

)8$9K=;$;ANW7<9M$;77$7;37<=>446M$B5K78M$->@P$,O$!"#$%&'%$()$"*&+"#&'%,((-&./$&0$1(&2"&*/$&32##4$&56$(7 1@=8<7958j$1@=8<7958

'8=J7@;=96$1@7;;M$RhhHO

RR &8$RZGH$?5@$=8;9>8<7M$>$D7<@77$?@52$&;9>8NA4$@7?7@@=8L$95$N59K$BK@=;9=>8$>8D$-A;4=2$,52>$5@D7@7D$5??=<7@;$5?$9K7$#23=@7$859$95

[479$c>86587d$K>@>;;$9K7$@><7$=8$TA7;9=58O\

RF )8$,52>$=8$9K7$)9952>8$#23=@7$L787@>446M$;77$->@A;K=>P5J>M$#478>$>8D$1535JM$V7;;74=8O$./$&89:(2$(&2"&*/$&;**,<+"&=<:2%$7

">9?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M$FGGRO

RE %77$ ?5@$7Q>2347$.A<>;;78M$.75M$>26$?"$%-&@2$&8$()/2)/*$&$2"$(&:,42A$242)/$"&;%#"?"6(B$6%2CC$(& 2"&@$?*()/4+"#&DEFFGDHIJM

`k48j$UkK4>A$V7@4>LM$RhhZO

Page 14: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

>8D$ =8$ *>_=C5<<A3=7D$ <5A89@=7;O$ &8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?

<5A89@=7;M$ 9K7$ ,52>8=$ "545<>A;9$ CC$ @7?7@@7D$ 95$ N6

;527$ >;$ 9K7$ a15@@>=25;a$ CC$ I>;$ =234727897D$ N6

N59K$/7@2>8$>A9K5@=9=7;$>;$I744$>;$N6$45<>4$5??=<=>4;O

&8$ ;527$ <5A89@=7;$ =9$ I>;$ =234727897D$ N6$ 9K7

>@2=7;$5?$L5J7@82789;$<544>N5@>9=8L$I=9K$ 9K7$/7@C

2>8C47D$ 7??5@9$ 95$ @7;K>37$ 9K7$ D725L@>3K6$ 5?

#A@537$IK=4;9$=8$59K7@;$9K7$,52>8=$"545<>A;9$I>;

=234727897D$I=9K5A9$/7@2>8$3@5239=8LO$&8$>$8A2C

N7@$ 5?$ >@7>;M$ ;A<K$ >;$ 58$ 9K7$ 97@@=95@6$ 5?$ 95D>6b;

B_7<K$ ,73AN4=<M$ 25;9$ 5?$ 9K7$ ,52>8=$ <522A8=96

I>;$P=447D$DA@=8L$9K7$I>@M$7=9K7@$N6$N7=8L$=897@87D$>9

/7@2>8C@A8$D7>9K$<>23;M$5@$N6$N7=8L$=8<>@<7@>97D

=8$D527;9=<>446$>D2=8=;97@7D$=897@82789$<>23;O

!"# &8$ 9K7$35;9CI>@$37@=5D$ =8$B789@>4$ >8D$#>;97@8

#A@537M$ 7??5@9;$ 95$ ?5@<=N46$ ;79947$,52>M$ >8D$ 95$ 78D

IK>9$I7@7$;778$>;$>89=C;5<=>4$9@>=9;M$I7@7$@7D5AN47DO

!K7$L5J7@82789;$5?$154>8D$>8D$B_7<K5;45J>P=>M$?5@

7Q>2347M$ A8D7@955P$ 7Q978;=J7$ 7??5@9;$ 95$ 78D

852>D=;2$>258L$,52>M$>8D$95$<58J7@9$,52>$95$>

K525L78=;7D$ a3@5479>@=>9aO$ &8978;7$ >;;=2=4>9=58

7??5@9;$A8D7@$;9>97$;5<=>4=;2$3@5DA<7D$N59K$;527$5?

9K7$?=@;9$L787@>9=58;$5?$,52>$=8$9K7$74=97M$>;$I744$>;

?A@9K7@$ K=LK$ 8A2N7@;$ 5?$,52>$ =8$ ;9>97$ =8;9=9A9=58;M

@725J7D$ ?@52$ 9K7=@$ ?>2=4=7;O$ &9;$ 5??=<=>4$ D=;<5A@;7

859I=9K;9>8D=8LM$ 35;9CI>@$ ;9>97$ ;5<=>4=;2$ D=D$ 859

;A<<77D$ =8$ 7@>D=<>9=8L$ @><=;2O$ %527$ L5J7@82789;

A8D7@955P$354=<=7;$5?$<57@<=J7$;97@=4=;>9=58$5?$,52>8=

I5278M$ >8D$ ;<K554=8L$ =8$ 2>86$ <5A89@=7;$ N7<>27

;7L@7L>97DO

,"#!K7$7>@46$35;9CS5@4D$S>@$&&$K=;95@6$5?$,52>$=8

S7;97@8$#A@537$>337>@;$@72>@P>N46$;=2=4>@$95$9K>9$=8

B789@>4$>8D$#>;97@8$#A@537O$&8$*5@I>6M$%I7D78$>8D

%I=9_7@4>8DM$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M$ <58<7@97D$ 7??5@9;$ I7@7

A8D7@9>P78$95$78D$9K7$<522A8>4$7Q=;978<7$5?$,52>

>8D$ @74>97D$ L@5A3;$ 9K@5ALK$ 27>;A@7;$ =8<4AD=8L

?5@<7D$;97@=4=;>9=58$5?$N59K$278$>8D$I5278M$>;$I744

>;$9K@5ALK$9K7$;6;972=<$@725J>4$5?$,52>8=$<K=4D@78

?@52$ ?>2=4=7;$ >8D$ 9K7=@$ 34><72789$ =8$ ;9>97$ <>@7O$ &8

@7<789$ 67>@;M$ 9K7$ %I7D=;K$ >8D$ %I=;;$ L5J7@82789;

!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 15: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

K>J7$ A8D7@9>P78$ >8D$ 2>D7$ 3AN4=<$ <523@7K78;=J7

;9AD=7;$5?$9K7$=;;A7M$>8D$%I7D78$K>;$2>D7$>J>=4>N47

<52378;>9=58$?5@$J=<9=2;O$!K7$=23><9$5?$9K7;7$354=C

<=7;$<589=8A7;$95$N7$?749$ 95D>6M$K5I7J7@M$>8D$,52>

>;$>$L@5A3$;9=44$;A??7@$7Q978;=J7$9@>A2>$>;$>$@7;A49O

-"#!K7$35;9CRhfh$7@>$=8$#A@537$K>;$;778$>8$5A9C

N@7>P$ 5?$ =8978;7$ >89=C,52>8=$ ;789=2789$ =8$ N59K

#>;97@8$ >8D$ S7;97@8$ #A@537O$ &8$ #>;97@8$ #A@537M

L5J7@82789;$ =8$;527$<5A89@=7;$N4>27D$,52>$<54C

47<9=J746$?5@$>$N@7>PD5I8$=8$3AN4=<$5@D7@$5@$?5@$?7>@;

9K>9$ >$ N@7>PD5I8$ =8$ 3AN4=<$ 5@D7@$ I>;$ =22=8789O

%6;972>9=<$37@;7<A9=58$5?$,52>$955P$34><7$=8$<5A8C

9@=7;$=8<4AD=8L$(4N>8=>M$UA4L>@=>M$/7@2>86M$"A8L>@6M

154>8DM$ ,52>8=>M$ ,A;;=>M$ %45J>P=>M$ 'P@>=87$ >8D

iAL5;4>J=>O$,><=;9$25J72789;$K>J7$>4;5$>@=;78$>8D

9>@L797D$,52>$?5@$>99><PO$ &8$;527$<5A89@=7;M$;A<K

>;$ =8$ 9K7$ B_7<K$ ,73AN4=<$ >8D$ %45J>P=>M$ J=5478<7

>L>=8;9$,52>$@72>=8;$>9$>4>@2=8L$47J74;O$&8$L787@>4M

<@=2=8>4$WA;9=<7$>A9K5@=9=7;$K>J7$@7><97D$=8>D7TA>97C

46$ 95$ 9K7$D@>2>9=<$ @=;7$ =8$ @><=>446$259=J>97D$ J=54789

<@=27$>8D$3AN4=<$5??=<=>4;$K>J7$?>=47DM$5@$N778$;45IM

95$<58D728$>89=C,52>8=$J=5478<7O

4"# &8$ S7;97@8$ #A@537M$ >89=C,52>8=$ ;789=2789

K>;$ ?@7TA78946$ N@5P78$ 5A9$ ?5445I=8L$ 9K7$ >@@=J>4$ 5?

,52>$ ?@52$ #>;97@8$ #A@537O$ U74L=A2M$ +=84>8DM

+@>8<7M$ /7@2>86M$ &@74>8DM$ &9>46M$ 9K7$ *79K7@4>8D;M

*5@I>6M$%3>=8M$%I=9_7@4>8D$>8D$9K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52

K>J7$ >44$ ?7>9A@7D$ 73=;5D7;$5?$ 3AN4=<$ 3>8=<M$ ?A7447D

N6$>4>@2=;9$27D=>$@735@9;$5?$a/63;6$=8J>;=58;a$>8D

;=2=4>@O$ !K7;7$27>;A@7;$ K>J7$ ?@7TA78946$ N778$ ?54C

45I7D$N6$@><=>446$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$27>;A@7;$N6$3AN4=<

>A9K5@=9=7;M$5?978$=8<4AD=8L$<5447<9=J7$7Q3A4;=58;ORH

56"# &8$ RhhhM$ 9K7$ ,52>8=$ <522A8=96$ 5?$ #A@537

;A??7@7D$9K7$I5@;9$<>9>;9@53K7$=9$K>;$78DA@7D$;=8<7

S5@4D$S>@$&&$IK78M$?5445I=8L$9K7$78D$5?$*(!)$2=4=C

9>@6$><9=58$=8$9K7$+7D7@>4$,73AN4=<$5?$iAL5;4>J=>$>8D

9K7$I=9KD@>I>4$5?$iAL5;4>J$?5@<7;$?@52$`5;5J5M$79KC

8=<$ (4N>8=>8;$ A8D7@955P$ >$ <>23>=L8$ 5?$ 79K8=<

<47>8;=8L$ >L>=8;9$ ,52>$ >8D$ 59K7@$ 37@;58;$ 37@C

<7=J7D$ 95$ N7$ a/63;=7;aO$ 07;3=97$ ?5A@$ 67>@;$ 5?$ '*

>D2=8=;9@>9=58$=8$`5;5J5M$J=5478<7M$=8<4AD=8L$37@=5DC

=<$ L@78>D7$ >99><P;$ >8D$ 9K7$ @7LA4>@$ D7;9@A<9=58$ 5?

3@537@96M$ K>;$ <589=8A7DO$ !5D>6M$ >8$ 7;9=2>97D$ ?5A@

?=?9K;$ 5?$ 9K7$ 3@7CN52N=8L$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58$ 5?

`5;5J5$ c3@5N>N46$ >@5A8D$ RFGMGGG$ 37@;58;d$ =;$ D=;C

34><7D$I=9K=8$`5;5J5$>8D$=8$@A23$%7@N=>$>8D$-58C

9787L@5M$5@$=;$=8$7Q=47$=8$<5A89@=7;$N5@D7@=8L$`5;5J5

5@$ =8$ 9K7$S7;9O$-5;9$ 4=J7$ =8$ 7Q9@72746$ 355@$ <58D=C

9=58;M$ IK=4;9$ 9K7=@$ >@@=J>4$ =8$ #'$ ;9>97;$ K>;$ @>=;7D

=235@9>89$ =;;A7;$;A@@5A8D=8L$>;64A2$>8D$ =22=L@>C

9=58M$D7>49$I=9K$4>97@$=8$9K=;$@735@9O

55"#&8$9K7$?><7$5?$>$K=;95@6$5?$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D

37@;7<A9=58M$>8D$D7;3=97$<789A@=7;$ =8$#A@537$I=9KC

5A9$ >86$ J=;=N47$ >A95<K9K585A;$ =8;9=9A9=58;M$ ,52>

K>J7$2>=89>=87D$>$D=;9=8<9$=D789=96O$B522A8>4$;54=C

D>@=96$=;$?@7TA78946$>??=@27D$>8D$@7=8?5@<7D$N6$<45;7

7Q978D7D$?>2=46$N58D;O$+>2=46$<747N@>9=58;$?7>9A@7

3@52=878946$ =8$ ;5<=>4$ 3@=5@=9=7;O$ BA49A@>4$ 9@>D=9=58;

>@7$ @7;37<97D$ >8D$ >DK7@7D$ 95$ D=4=L78946M$ >8D$ 2>6

=8<4AD7$3544A9=58$9>N55;$>8DM$=8$;527$<522A8=9=7;M

>A958525A;$;6;972;$5?$ =8D=J=DA>4$>8D$<522A8=96

WA;9=<7O$1544A9=58$9>N55;$>@7$9@>D=9=58>4$I=9K=8$2>86

<A49A@7;$NA9$>@7$>4;5$?@7TA78946$>;;5<=>97D$I=9K$9K7

D7J74532789$5?$ ;9@>97L=7;$N6$2>@L=8>4=;7D$L@5A3;

95$2>=89>=8$=D789=96$>L>=8;9$9K7$?5@<7;$5?$533@7;;=58

>8De5@$ <A49A@>4$ >;;=2=4>9=58O$ (;$ gAD=9K$ )P746$ ;>6;M

[)87$ I>6$ 5?$ @72>=8=8L$ D=??7@789$ =;$ N6$ 3544A9=58

N74=7?;$IK=<K$N59K$7Q3@7;;$>8D$@7=8?5@<7$>8$79K8=<

N5A8D>@6O$!K7$/63;=7;X$N74=7?;$859$5846$<4>;;=?6$9K7

/5@L=5$ c!"!#$"%&d$ >;$ 3544A9=8LM$ NA9$ >4;5$ 5??7@$ 9K7

27>8;$95$@79>=8$>8$=887@$3A@=96O$&?$<7@9>=8$5N;7@J>8<C

7;$>@7$2>=89>=87DM$9K7$/63;=7;$<>8$7897@$/5@L=5$97@C

@=95@6$A8;<>9K7D\ORY

5;"# !K7$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58$ =8$ #A@537$ 95D>6$ =;

7;9=2>97D$ >9$ >@5A8D$ 978$ 2=44=58$ 375347M$ >49K5ALK

;527$ 5N;7@J7@;$ 3A9$ 9K7$ ?=LA@7;$ 7J78$ K=LK7@$ >9

9I74J7$ 2=44=58O$ 1@7<=;7$ D725L@>3K=<$ D>9>$ =;$ 859M

K5I7J7@M$ >J>=4>N47$ DA7$ =8$ 4>@L7$ 3>@9$ 95$ 9K7$ ;9=L2>

>;;5<=>97D$I=9K$ 9K7$,52>8=$ =D789=96$>8D$9K7$ @74A<C

9>8<7$5?$2>86$,52>$95$=D789=?6$9K72;74J7;$>;$;A<K

?5@$5??=<=>4$3A@35;7;M$>8D$ 9K7$ @7?A;>4$5?$2>86$L5JC

7@82789;$95$=8<4AD7$,52>$>;$>$47L=9=2>97$<>97L5@6

?5@$<78;A;$3A@35;7;O 07;3=97$D725L@>3K=<$A8<7@C

9>=89=7;M$9K7@7$=;$4=9947$D5AN9$9K>9$9K7$959>4$8A2N7@$5?

,52>$=8$#A@537$=;$2>86$9=27;$L@7>97@$9K>8$9K7$959>4

353A4>9=58$5?$>$8A2N7@$5?$9K7$-72N7@$%9>97;O

5="#(9$3@7;789M$>89=C,52>8=$;789=2789$=;$3@7;789

=8$ 25;9M$ =?$ 859$ >44M$ #A@537>8$ ;5<=79=7;$ >8D$ =;

7Q9@72746$K=LK$=8$;527$<5A89@=7;O(<<5@D=8L$95$587

@7<789$;A@J76M$^hl$5?$B_7<K;$I5A4D$859$I>89$,52>

!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RH +5@$7Q>2347M$U74L=A2$K>;$@7<78946$N778$?5A8D$=8$J=54>9=58$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B58J789=58$5?$"A2>8$,=LK9;$=8$<5887<9=58$I=9K$9K7

<5447<9=J7$7Q3A4;=58$5?$>$L@5A3$5?$%45J>P$,52>$>8D$&9>46$;79947D$5A9$5?$<5A@9$IK78$>$;=2=4>@$?=8D=8LM$@74>97D$95$9K7$<5447<9=J7

7Q3A4;=58$5?$>$L@5A3$5?$U5;8=>8$,52>M$>337>@7D$=22=8789O

RY )P746M$gAD=9KO$'(&!)*!)+',-.,/0123(0+3/&40--0/+5671*01M$B>2N@=DL7$'8=J7@;=96$1@7;;M$B>2N@=DL7$RhfEM$3O^^O

Page 16: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

>;$ 87=LKN5A@;ORZ ($ 3544$ <58DA<97D$ =8$ RhhF$ N6$ 9K7

(4478;N><K$ 0725;<53=<$ &8;9=9A97$ =8D=<>97D$ 9K>9

ZHl$ 5?$ /7@2>8;$ K>D$ >8$ A8?>J5A@>N47$ 53=8=58$ 5?

,52>$C$>$K=LK7@$37@<789>L7$9K>8$?5@$>86$59K7@$@><=>4M

79K8=<$ 5@$ @74=L=5A;$ L@5A3OR^ ($ ;A@J76$ <58DA<97D$ =8

RhhH$ N6$ 9K7$ #-*&0$ &8;9=9A97$ =8D=<>97D$ 9K>9$ ;527

Zfl$ 5?$ /7@2>8;$ D=D$ 859$ I=;K$ 95$ K>J7$ %=89=$ >8D

,52>$>;$87=LKN5A@;ORf -@O$!@7J5@$1K=44=3;M$9K7$BK>=@

5?$ 9K7$ '8=97D$ `=8LD52b;$ B522=;;=58$ ?5@$ ,><=>4

#TA>4=96$ cB,#dM$ @7<78946$ ;9>97DM$ a(;$ >$ U@=958M$ &$ >2

>;K>27D$ 5?$ 9K7$ I>6$ I7$ 9@7>9$ /63;=7;$ >8D$ !@>JC

7447@;O$ !K=8L;$ 877D$ 95$ <K>8L7$ >8D$ 9K76$ 877D$ 95

<K>8L7$85IaORh

5A" !K7$9@7>92789$5?$,52>$N59K$=8$9K7$#A@537>8

'8=58$>8D$N7658D$=9;$<A@@789$N5@D7@;$K>;$N7<527$>

4=92A;$ 97;9$5?$>$KA2>87$;5<=796O !K7$ 9@7>92789$5?

,52>$ =;$ 95D>6$ >258L$ 9K7$25;9$ 3@7;;=8L$354=9=<>4M

;5<=>4$>8D$KA2>8$@=LK9;$=;;A7;$?><=8L$#A@537O

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RZ %77$$01708.M$<O$RM$,5<8mP$nVM$FhORFOFGGECHOROFGGH

R^ %7J789778$37@<789$K>D$>8$A8?>J5A@>N47$53=8=58$5?$-A;4=2;o$5?$&8D=>8;M$RHlo$5?$LA7;9$I5@P7@;M$RFlo$5?$D>@PC;P=887D$37@;58;M

fl$>8D$5?$g7I;M$^lO$B=97D$=8$/O$->@L>4=9M$9!.*#56716*1%+*!+.(0+:"-*.*;&-+',-.,/0+"<+.(0+=0>0/&-+$07,?-*;+"<+50/%&!6@+9+:&/&--0-

A*.(+9!.*#B0%*.*1%C (<<7;;7D$58$9K7$I7N$>9$K993jee;=<;>OKAW=O><O=4ehL=4>DOK92O

Rf B=97D$=8$0O$%9@>A;;M$[(89=C/63;6=;2$=8$/7@2>8$%5<=796$>8D$.=97@>9A@7\$=8$!7NNA99M$%A;>8M$7DOM$B*!.*+&!>+$"%&@+5671*01+*!+50/#

%&!#B70&8*!)+B";*0.6+&!>+D*.0/&.,/0M$*7I$i5@Pj$U7@LK>K8$U55P;M$RhhfM$3O$fhO

Rh !@>J7447@$!=27;M$&;;A7$RhM$%3@=8L$FGGHM$3ORO

Page 17: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

$3&7*<1*2#7*+1:<10891%1*7+1(*#*(9%0#

1*#$/9(&$

5"# (@LA>N46$ 9K7$ 25;9$ ?A8D>2789>4$ <K>8L7$ =8$ 9K7

'8=58$ @74>9=8L$ 95$ <52N>9=8L$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D

@><=;2$]$=8<4AD=8L$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$@><=;2$>L>=8;9

,52>$]$K>;$N778$9K7$>D539=58$5?$>$;7@=7;$5?$>89=CD=;C

<@=2=8>9=58$ D=@7<9=J7;M$ >D5397D$ 3A@;A>89$ 95$ 9K7

@7J=;7D$(@9=<47$RE$5?$9K7$!@7>96$#;9>N4=;K=8L$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$B522A8=96$c!#Bd$>?97@$=9;$!@7>96$5?$(2;97@D>2

>278D2789;OFG 0=@7<9=J7;$>@7$N=8D=8L$58$>44$3@7CFGGH

#'$-72N7@$%9>97;FR >8D$9@>8;35;=9=58$K>;$>4;5$N778

@7TA=@7D$ 5?$ 87I$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ >8D$ ><<7;;=58

;9>97;O$ 1>@9=<A4>@46$ ;=L8=?=<>89$ ?5@$ ,52>$ =;$ 0=@7<9=J7

FGGGeHEe#B$ a=23472789=8L$ 9K7$ 3@=8<=347$ 5?$ 7TA>4

9@7>92789$N79I778$37@;58;$ =@@7;37<9=J7$5?$ @><=>4$5@

79K8=<$ 5@=L=8a$ c9K7$ a,><7$0=@7<9=J7adO$ (49K5ALK$ ;527

#'$-72N7@$%9>97;$K>D$>4@7>D6$=234727897D$47L=;4>C

9=58$N>88=8L$ @><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$3@=5@$ 95$ 9K7$>D53C

9=58$5?$ 9K7$,><7$0=@7<9=J7M$2>86$D=D$859M$ >8D$7J78

9K5;7$ <5A89@=7;$ I=9K$ 9@>D=9=58;$ 5?$ <52N>9=8L$ @><=>4

D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ 9K@5ALK$ 4>IM$ ?@7TA78946$ K>D$ 859

;7<A@7D$>$N>8$58$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$=8$>44$?=74D;$5?

@747J>8<7$95$#'$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$354=<6O

;"#!K7$,><7$0=@7<9=J7$=89@5DA<7D$47L>4$;9>8D>@D;

9K@5ALK5A9$ 9K7$ '8=58$ >=27D$ >9$ 78D=8L$ D=??7@789=>4

9@7>92789$ N>;7D$ 58$ 9K7$ >@N=9@>@6$ <@=97@=>$ 5?$ @><7$ 5@

79K8=<=96O$&9$3@5J=D7;$D79>=4;$>;$95$9K7$;<537$>8D$<58C

9789$5?$4>I;$N>88=8L$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58M$>8D$<5J7@;

>$I=D7$ @>8L7$5?$>@7>;$IK7@7$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>L>=8;9

,52>$2>6$9>P7$34><7$C$7234562789M$9@>=8=8LM$7DA<>C

9=58M$;5<=>4$3@597<9=58M$><<7;;$95$L55D;$>8D$;7@J=<7;M

>8D$ K5A;=8LO$ !K7$ ,><7$ 0=@7<9=J7$ =8<4AD7;M$ >258L

59K7@$3@5J=;=58;M$N>8;$58$N59K$aD=@7<9a$>8D$a=8D=@7<9a

D=;<@=2=8>9=58MFF 9K7$ @7TA=@72789$ 5?$ 47L>4$ @727D=7;

?5@$ J=<9=2;$ 5?$ @><=>4$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ 9K@5ALK$ aWAD=<=>4

>8De5@$ >D2=8=;9@>9=J7$ 3@5<7DA@7;aM$ ?5@$ 9K7$ 78?5@<7C

2789$ 5?$ >89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ 5N4=L>9=58;$ a>J>=4>N47$ 95

>44aFE >8D$ 9K7$ 3@5J=;=58$ 9K>9$ =8$ <>;7;$ =8$IK=<K$ <52C

34>=8>89;$ a7;9>N4=;KM$N7?5@7$>$<5A@9$5@$59K7@$<5237C

9789$>A9K5@=96M$?><9;$?@52$IK=<K$=9$2>6$N7$3@7;A27D

9K>9$9K7@7$K>;$N778$D=@7<9$5@$=8D=@7<9$D=;<@=2=8>9=58M$=9

;K>44$N7$ ?5@$ 9K7$ @7;358D789$ 95$3@5J7$ 9K>9$ 9K7@7$K>;

!!

EO$!"#$#',)1#(*$1).&Bi$+,(-#S),`

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

FG !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$>D5397D$>$8A2N7@$5?$47L>4$27>;A@7;$IK=<K$K>J7$;=L8=?=<>8946$7Q3>8D7D$9K7$;<537$5?$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58

4>I$=8$#A@537M$859>N46$9K@77$0=@7<9=J7;j$c=d$0=@7<9=J7$FGGGeHEe#B$a=23472789=8L$9K7$3@=8<=347$5?$7TA>4$9@7>92789$N79I778$37@C

;58;$ =@@7;37<9=J7$5?$ @><=>4$5@$79K8=<$5@=L=8a$ ca,><7$0=@7<9=J7ad c==d$0=@7<9=J7$FGGGe^fe#B$ a7;9>N4=;K=8L$>$L787@>4$ ?@>27I5@P$ ?5@

7TA>4$9@7>92789$=8$7234562789$>8D$5<<A3>9=58a$ca#234562789$0=@7<9=J7ad$>8D$c===d$0=@7<9=J7$FGGFe^Ee#B$a58$9K7$=23472789>9=58

5?$9K7$3@=8<=347$5?$7TA>4$9@7>92789$?5@$278$>8D$I5278$>;$@7L>@D;$><<7;;$95$7234562789M$J5<>9=58>4$9@>=8=8L$>8D$3@5259=58M

>8D$I5@P=8L$<58D=9=58;\O$&8$>DD=9=58$95$9K7$0=@7<9=J7;$>D5397D$A8D7@$(@9=<47$REM$>$@7J=;7D$(@9=<47$Fh$5?$9K7$!#B$85I$L=J7;$354=<7

>8D$WAD=<=>4$>A9K5@=9=7;$K7=LK9787D$35I7@;$95$<5C537@>97$58$2>997@;$@74>97D$95M$>258L$59K7@$9K=8L;M$a3@7J789=8L$>8D$<52N>9=8L

@><=;2$>8D$Q7853K5N=>aO

FR SK7@7$-72N7@$%9>97;$K>J7$859$9@>8;35;7D$7472789;$5?$;=2=4>@$D=@7<9=J7;$=8$9K7$3>;9M$9K7$#A@537>8$B5A@9$5?$gA;9=<7$K>;$>334=7D

9K7$3@5J=;=58$>9$=;;A7$D=@7<946O

FF +5@$9K7$3A@35;7;$5?$9K7$#'$0=@7<9=J7M$aD=@7<9$D=;<@=2=8>9=58a$ =;$D7?=87D$>;$K>J=8L$5<<A@@7D$aIK7@7$587$37@;58$=;$9@7>97D$47;;

?>J5A@>N46$9K>8$>859K7@$=;M$K>;$N778$5@$I5A4D$N7$9@7>97D$=8$>$<523>@>N47$;=9A>9=58$58$L@5A8D;$5?$@><=>4$5@$79K8=<$5@=L=8a$c#'

0=@7<9=J7$(@9O$FcFdc>ddM$IK=47$a=8D=@7<9$D=;<@=2=8>9=58a$5<<A@;$aIK7@7$>8$>33>@78946$87A9@>4$3@5J=;=58M$<@=97@=58$5@$3@><9=<7$I5A4D

3A9$37@;58;$5?$>$@><=>4$5@$79K8=<$5@=L=8$>9$>$3>@9=<A4>@$D=;>DJ>89>L7$<523>@7D$I=9K$59K7@$37@;58;M$A847;;$9K>9$3@5J=;=58M$<@=97@=C

58$5@$3@><9=<7$=;$5NW7<9=J746$WA;9=?=7D$N6$>$47L=9=2>97$>=2$>8D$9K7$27>8;$5?$><K=7J=8L$9K>9$>=2$>@7$>33@53@=>97$>8D$87<7;;>@6a

c#'$ 0=@7<9=J7$ (@9O$ FcFdcNddO$ !K7$ ?A44$ 97Q9$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ ,><7$ 0=@7<9=J7$ =;$ >J>=4>N47$ 58$ 9K7$ &897@879

>9jK993jee7A@53>O7AO=89e<522e7234562789p;5<=>4e?A8D>2789>4p@=LK9;e47L=;e47L48p78OK92

FE #'$,><7$0=@7<9=J7$(@9=<47$^cRdO

FH #'$,><7$0=@7<9=J7$(@9=<47$fO

Page 18: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

N778$85$N@7><K$5?$9K7$3@=8<=347$5?$7TA>4$9@7>92789aOFH

!K7$,><7$0=@7<9=J7$ >4;5$ @7TA=@7;$ 9K>9$D527;9=<$ 4>I

=235;7$7??7<9=J7M$3@535@9=58>97$>8D$D=;;A>;=J7$;>8<C

9=58;$?5@$J=54>9=58$5?$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$85@2;O$!K7;7

;K5A4D$=8<4AD7$a9K7$3>62789$5?$<52378;>9=58$95$9K7

J=<9=2aOFY

="#07>D4=87;$?5@$9@>8;35;=9=58$5?$9K7$,><7$0=@7<C

9=J7$=895$D527;9=<$4>I$I7@7$;79$?5@$FGGE$?5@$54D$-72C

N7@$ %9>97;$ >8D$ 9K7$ D>97$ 5?$ ><<7;;=58$ ?5@$ 87I

-72N7@$%9>97;M$>8D$>$8A2N7@$5?$;9>97;$K>J7$>D539C

7D$<523@7K78;=J7$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$4>I;$=8$7??5@9;

95$<52346O$)??=<=>4$>;;7;;2789;$>;$95$IK79K7@$>D539C

7D$4>I;$?A446$<52346$I=9K$#'$LA=D74=87;$>@7$859$679

>J>=4>N47$>8D$=9$2>6$N7$;527$9=27$N7?5@7$=9$ =;$<47>@

IK79K7@$87I46C>D5397D$4>I;$3@5J=D7$9K7$<523@7K78C

;=J7$3@597<9=58;$78J=;>L7DO$&9$=;$87J7@9K747;;$7J=D789

9K>9$9K7$#'$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$D=@7<9=J7;M$>8D$=8$3>@C

9=<A4>@$9K7$,><7$0=@7<9=J7M$<58;9=9A97$>$TA>89A2$47>3

=8$ 3@597<9=58;$ >J>=4>N47$ 95$ =8D=J=DA>4;$ ?@52$ 9K7

7Q9@727$K>@2$5?$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58M$>8D$9K>9$9K7;7

3@597<9=58;$2>6$N7$5?$3@5?5A8D$@747J>8<7$?5@$,52>O

A"#%73>@>9746M$9K7$'8=58$K>;$>4;5$>D5397D$>$B52C

2A8=96$(<9=58$1@5L@>227$95$<52N>9$D=;<@=2=8>9=58

cFGGGCFGGZdM$2>8>L7D$9K@5ALK$9K7$0=@7<95@>97$/78C

7@>4$?5@$#234562789$>8D$%5<=>4$(??>=@;$5?$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$ B522=;;=58O$ !K7$ 1@5L@>227$ =;$ D7;=L87D$ 95

;A335@9$>8D$<523472789$9K7$=23472789>9=58$5?$9K7

0=@7<9=J7;$9K@5ALK$9K7$7Q<K>8L7$5?$=8?5@2>9=58$>8D

7Q37@=78<7$>8D$ 9K7$D=;;72=8>9=58$5?$N7;9$3@><9=<7O

!K7$1@5L@>227$3@52597;$27>;A@7;$95$<52N>9$D=;C

<@=2=8>9=58$N>;7D$58$@><=>4$5@$79K8=<$5@=L=8M$@74=L=58

5@$ N74=7?M$ D=;>N=4=96M$ >L7$ 5@$ ;7QA>4$ 5@=789>9=58O$ !K7

FGGH$ I5@P$ 3@5L@>227$ 5?$ 9K7$ B522A8=96$ (<9=58

1@5L@>227$D7?=87D$7=LK9$3@=5@=96$>@7>;$?5@$9K7$7;9>NC

4=;K2789$ 5?$ 9@>8;8>9=58>4$ ><9=58;O$)87$ 3@=5@=96$I>;

;37<=?=<>446$9>@L797D$>9$,52>$=897L@>9=58$=895$7DA<>C

9=58$>8D$7234562789M$>8D$K>;$47>D$95$9K7$;747<9=58

5?$?5A@$,52>C;37<=?=<$9@>8;8>9=58>4$3>@987@;K=3;$>8D

><9=58;$?5@$9K7$3@73>@>95@6$3K>;7$=8$FGGHM$95$N7$?54C

45I7D$N6$>$FC67>@$=23472789>9=58$37@=5DO

$/#0(817'#1*8'/01(*#&('18)#M97%$N(9O

B" (9$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B5A8<=4;$ =8$ .=;N58$ >8D$ +7=@>

FGGGM$ 9K7$ D7<=;=58$ I>;$ 9>P78$ 95$ 25D7@8=;7$ 9K7

#A@537>8$ %5<=>4$ -5D74M$ N>;7D$ 58$ 9K7$ ;9@>97L6$ 95

N7<527$[9K7$25;9$<52379=9=J7$>8D$D68>2=<$P85I4C

7DL7CN>;7D$7<58526$=8$9K7$I5@4DM$<>3>N47$5?$;A;C

9>=8>N47$ 7<5852=<$ L@5I9K$ I=9K$ 25@7$ >8D$ N7997@

W5N;$>8D$L@7>97@$;5<=>4$<5K7;=58\O

!"# (9$ 9K7$ K7>@9$ 5?$ 9K7$ .=;N58$ >L78D>M$ >;

>33@5J7DM$=;$9K7$L5>4$5?$a25D7@8=;=8L$9K7$#A@537>8

%5<=>4$-5D74$N6$=8J7;9=8L$=8$375347$>8D$NA=4D=8L$>8

><9=J7$ I74?>@7$ ;9>97aO$ !K=;$ =8<4AD7;$ ><9=58$ =8$ 9K7

?=74D;$5?j

q #DA<>9=58$>8D$9@>=8=8L$?5@$ 4=J=8L$>8D$I5@P=8L$ =8

9K7$P85I47DL7$;5<=796o

q -5@7$>8D$N7997@$W5N;$?5@$#A@537j$D7J7453=8L$>8

><9=J7$7234562789$354=<6oFZ

q -5D7@8=;=8L$;5<=>4$3@597<9=58o

q 1@5259=8L$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58O

," S=9K$ @7L>@D$ 95$ 9K7$ 4>997@M$ 9K7$K7>D;$5?$-72N7@

%9>97;$<58J78=8L$>9$9K7$.=;N58$B5A8<=4$<58<4AD7Dj

a!K7$8A2N7@$5?$375347$4=J=8L$N745I$9K7$35J7@96$4=87$>8D$=8

;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58$=8$9K7$'8=58$=;$A8><<739>N47O$r$154=<=7;

?5@$ <52N>9=8L$ ;5<=>4$ 7Q<4A;=58$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ N>;7D$ 58$ >8

5378$279K5D$5?$<55@D=8>9=58$<52N=8=8L$*>9=58>4$(<9=58

14>8;$>8D$>$B522=;;=58$=8=9=>9=J7$?5@$<5537@>9=58$=8$9K=;

?=74D$95$N7$3@7;7897D$N6$gA87$FGGGO

a&8$3>@9=<A4>@M$9K7$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4$=8J=97;$9K7$B5A8<=4$>8D

9K7$B522=;;=58$95j

q 3@52597$>$N7997@$A8D7@;9>8D=8L$5?$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58$r

58$9K7$N>;=;$5?$<5225846$>L@77D$=8D=<>95@;o$9K7$"=LK

.7J74$ S5@P=8L$ 1>@96$ 58$ %5<=>4$ 1@597<9=58$ I=44$ N7

=8J54J7D$=8$7;9>N4=;K=8L$9K7;7$=8D=<>95@;o

q 2>=8;9@7>2$ 9K7$ 3@5259=58$ 5?$ =8<4A;=58$ =8$ -72N7@

%9>97;b$ 7234562789M$ 7DA<>9=58$ >8D$ 9@>=8=8LM$ K7>49K

>8D$ K5A;=8L$ 354=<=7;M$ 9K=;$ N7=8L$ <5234727897D$ >9

B522A8=96$47J74$N6$><9=58$A8D7@$9K7$%9@A<9A@>4$+A8D;

I=9K=8$9K7$3@7;789$NADL79>@6$?@>27I5@Po

q D7J7453$3@=5@=96$><9=58;$>DD@7;;7D$ 95$;37<=?=<$ 9>@L79

L@5A3;$ c?5@$ 7Q>2347$ 2=85@=96$ L@5A3;M$ <K=4D@78M$ 9K7

74D7@46$>8D$9K7$D=;>N47DdM$I=9K$-72N7@$%9>97;$<K55;C

=8L$>258L;9$9K5;7$><9=58;$><<5@D=8L$95$9K7=@$3>@9=<AC

4>@$ ;=9A>9=58;$ >8D$ @735@9=8L$ ;AN;7TA78946$ 58$ 9K7=@

=23472789>9=58OaF^

-" !K7$ .=;N58$B5A8<=4$ >4;5$ >33@5J7D$ >$ 87I$ a5378

279K5D$ 5?$ <55@D=8>9=58a$ =8$ 9K7$ =23472789>9=58$ 5?

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

FY #'$,><7$0=@7<9=J7$(@9=<47$RYO

FZ !K=;$=8<4AD7;$9K7$9>@L79$5?$a@>=;=8L$9K7$7234562789$@>97$?@52$>8$>J7@>L7$5?$ZRl$95D>6$95$>;$<45;7$>;$35;;=N47$95$^Gl$N6$FGRGa

>8D$a=8<@7>;=8L$9K7$8A2N7@$5?$I5278$=8$7234562789$?@52$>8$>J7@>L7$5?$YRl$95D>6$95$25@7$9K>8$ZGl$N6$FGRGOa

F^ 1@7;=D78<6$B58<4A;=58;M$.=;N58$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4M$FE$>8D$FH$->@<K$FGGGM$39;O$EF$>8D$EEO

Page 19: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

#'$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$>8D$@74>97D$L5>4;O$(<<5@D=8L$95

9K7$ 1@7;=D78<6$ B58<4A;=58;$ 5?$ 9K7$ .=;N58$ B5A8<=4

9K=;$=8J54J7Dj

q ?=Q=8L$ LA=D74=87;$ ?5@$ 9K7$ '8=58$ <52N=87D$ I=9K

;37<=?=<$9=279>N47;$?5@$><K=7J=8L$9K7$L5>4;$IK=<K

9K76$;79$=8$9K7$;K5@9M$27D=A2$>8D$458L$97@2;o

q 7;9>N4=;K=8LM$IK7@7$>33@53@=>97M$TA>89=9>9=J7$>8D

TA>4=9>9=J7$ =8D=<>95@;$ >8D$ N78<K2>@P;$ >L>=8;9

9K7$N7;9$=8$9K7$I5@4D$>8D$9>=45@7D$95$9K7$877D;$5?

D=??7@789$-72N7@$%9>97;$>8D$;7<95@;$>;$>$27>8;

5?$<523>@=8L$N7;9$3@><9=<7o

q 9@>8;4>9=8L$ 9K7;7$ #A@537>8$ LA=D74=87;$ =895

8>9=58>4$>8D$@7L=58>4$354=<=7;$N6$;799=8L$;37<=?=<

9>@L79;$ >8D$ >D539=8L$ 27>;A@7;M$ 9>P=8L$ =895

><<5A89$8>9=58>4$>8D$@7L=58>4$D=??7@78<7;o

q 37@=5D=<$258=95@=8LM$7J>4A>9=58$>8D$377@$@7J=7I

5@L>8=;7D$>;$2A9A>4$47>@8=8L$3@5<7;;7;OFf

4" &8$FGGHM$9K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$4>A8<K7D$>$B>44

?5@$1@535;>4;$58$[*>9=58>4$(I>@787;;$,>=;=8L$(<9=58;

58$%5<=>4$&8<4A;=58\M$>=27D$3>@9=<A4>@46$>9$9K5;7$5@L>8C

=;>9=58;$I=9K$>8$><9=J7$=897@7;9$=8$3@5259=8L$9K7$=2347C

2789>9=58$ 5?$ *>9=58>4$ (<9=58$ 14>8;$ >L>=8;9$ 35J7@96

>8D$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58M$>8D$g5=89$&8<4A;=58$-725@>8D>

58$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58M$=8<4AD=8L$8>9=58>4$>8D$45<>4$>A9K5@C

=9=7;M$>8D$*/);O$!K7$3@535;>4;$><<7397D$?5@$?=8>8<=8L

>@7$7Q37<97D$95$;9>@9$=8$9K7$?5A@9K$TA>@97@$5?$FGGHM$>8D

>@7$7Q37<97D$95$K>J7$>8$=23><9$58$3AN4=<$>I>@787;;

5?$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$=;;A7;O

./%7*#912.+0#%(*1+(91*2

56"#&9$=;$7J=D789$9K>9$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$;527

<5A89@=7;$ >33@5><K7;$ >$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ 727@L78<6O

!K7$ #'$ 4><P;$ >8$ 7??7<9=J7$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ 78?5@<7C

2789$N5D6M$>8D$9K7$J><AA2$;5$<@7>97D$47>J7;$2>86

=8D=J=DA>4;$ D>8L7@5A;46$ 7Q35;7D$ 95$ >NA;7O$ !K7

@7<789$D7<=;=58$N6$9K7$#A@537>8$1>@4=>2789$95$@7W7<9

9K7$ 27>;A@7$ 5?$ 35;9C><<7;;=58$ 258=95@=8L$ I=9K

@7;37<9$95$%45J>P=>$K=LK4=LK9;$9K7$877D$95$@7D5AN47

7??5@9;$=8$9K=;$>@7>OFh !K7$#'$;K5A4D$7Q345@7$7Q3>8DC

=8L$ 9K7$35I7@;$5?$587$5@$25@7$N5D=7;$ =8$5@D7@$ 95

78;A@7$7??7<9=J7$ <5234=>8<7$I=9K$ <52258$KA2>8

@=LK9;$;9>8D>@D;M$;A<K$>;$9K5;7$=8<4AD7D$=8$9K7$#'

BK>@97@$58$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;O$,7J=;=9=8L$9K7$2>8C

D>97$5?$ 9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$-58=95@=8L$B789@7$58

,><=;2$ >8D$ n7853K5N=>$ c#'-BdM$ ;558$ 95$ N7$ <58C

J7@97D$ =895$ 9K7$ #'$ "A2>8$ ,=LK9;$ (L78<6M$ I=9K$ >

J=7I$ 95$ 7Q3>8D=8L$ =9;$ 35I7@;$ N7658D$258=95@=8LM

I5A4D$N7$587$35;;=N47$25D7$?5@$;9@78L9K78=8L$#'

KA2>8$@=LK9;$78?5@<72789O ($3@73>@>95@6$><9=58$=8

9K7$ ?5@2$5?$>$B>44$ ?5@$1@535;>4;$ ?5@$ 9K7$;A335@9$5?

87I$ -72N7@$ %9>97$ */);$ 3@5259=8L$ D725<@><6

>8D$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ I=44$ N7$ 4>A8<K7D$ N6$ 9K7$ 0=@7<C

95@>97$/787@>4$?5@$gA;9=<7$>8D$"527$(??>=@;$=8$2=DC

)<95N7@$FGGHO$&9$I=44$N7$9K7$?=@;9$9=27$9K>9$9K7$#B$K>;

>$ ?=8>8<=>4$ =8;9@A2789$ >DD@7;;=8L$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;

I=9K=8$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58O

$/9(&$7*#$%&'()%$*+#0+97+$2)

55" !K7$#A@537>8$#234562789$%9@>97L6$c##%d$I>;

4>A8<K7D$>9$9K7$.AQ72N5A@L$g5N;$%A22=9$=8$Rhh^O

(8$ =897@=2$7J>4A>9=58$ =8$FGGF$ =D789=?=7D$>$8A2N7@

5?$=;;A7;$>8D$<K>4478L7;$?5@$9K7$%9@>97L6M$>8D$@7<C

52278D7D$9K>9$=9$N7$N7997@$>4=L87D$I=9K$9K7$FGGG

.=;N58$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4$ L5>4;$ 5?$ ;A;9>=87D$ 7<5C

852=<$ D7J74532789O$ !K7$ 5@=L=8>4$ ##%$ L5>4$ 5?

@7><K=8L$>8$5J7@>44$^Gl$7234562789$@>97$N6$FGRG

I>;$@7?=87D$95$N@=8L$=8$=897@27D=>97$9>@L79;$5?$Z^l

5J7@>44$ 7234562789$ N6$ FGGYM$ =8<4AD=8L$ Y^l

7234562789$?5@$I5278M$>8D$YGl$?5@$54D7@$I5@PC

7@;$N6$FGRGO$!K7$=897@27D=>97$L5>4;$I=44M$K5I7J7@M

>425;9$ <7@9>=846$ 859$ N7$ 279$ >8D$ 9K5;7$ ?5@$ FGRG

455P$539=2=;9=<$>9$3@7;789O

5;"#!K7$##%$=;$258=95@7D$9K@5ALK$>$;79$5?$>88A>4

*>9=58>4$ (<9=58$ 14>8;$ >8D$ >8$ >88A>4$ g5=89

#234562789$ ,735@9M$ IK=4;9$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B5A8<=4

=;;A7;$ #234562789$ /A=D74=87;$ >8DM$ ;73>@>9746M

,7<52278D>9=58;$95$-72N7@$%9>97;$58$>8$>88A>4

N>;=;O$!K7$FGGH$/A=D74=87;$35=89$5A9$9K7$877D$?5@$>44

-72N7@$ %9>97;$ 95$ 9>P7$ ><9=58$ 95$ [>99@><9$ 25@7

375347$=895$9K7$4>N5A@$2>@P79\$>8D$95$[=8J7;9$25@7

>8D$ 25@7$ 7??7<9=J746$ =8$ KA2>8$ <>3=9>4\O B47>@46M

>49K5ALK$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$ =;$859$ =D789=?=7D$ =8

9K7$ ##%$ >;$ >$ ;37<=?=<$ <K>4478L7M$ 9K7$ 8A2N7@;$ 5?

,52>M$/63;=7;$ >8D$!@>J7447@;$ =8$#A@537M$ >8D$ 9K7=@

J7@6$ 45I$ ?5@2>4$ 7234562789$ @>97$ c;77$BK>397@$ HdM

2>8D>97$ 9K>9M$ =?$ ##%$ 9>@L79;$ >@7$ 95$ N7$ 279M

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Ff 1@7;=D78<6$B58<4A;=58;M$.=;N58$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4M$FE$>8D$FH$->@<K$FGGGM$39O$E^O

Fh %77$#A@537>8$1>@4=>2789M$a,735@9$58$9K7$<523@7K78;=J7$258=95@=8L$@735@9$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$58$9K7$;9>97$5?$3@73>@7DC

87;;$?5@$#'$272N7@;K=3$5?$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$#;958=>M$B63@A;M$.>9J=>M$.=9KA>8=>M$"A8L>@6M$->49>M$154>8DM$%45J78=>$>8D$%45J>C

P=>$ cB)-cFGGEd$Z^Y$C$BYCGYEFeFGGE$C$FGGEeFFGRc&*&ddaM$(YCGRRReFGGHO$ &8$D7N>9=8L$9K7$?=8>4$J7@;=58$5?$9K7$@735@9M$ 9K7$#A@537>8

1>@4=>2789$I>;$>;P7D$95$<58;=D7@M$>258L$59K7@$3@535;>4;M$>$/@778$/@5A3$3@535;>4$95$A8D7@9>P7$35;9C><<7;;=58$258=95@=8L$=8

%45J>P=>M$>;$>$@7;A49$5?$;7@=5A;$KA2>8$@=LK9;$<58<7@8;$I=9K$@7;37<9$95$,52>$=8$9K>9$<5A89@6O$!K7$3@535;>4$I>;$J597D$D5I8O

Page 20: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

3>@9=<A4>@$ >99789=58$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ L=J78$ 95$ 9K7=@

=897L@>9=58$=895$4>N5A@$2>@P79;O

5="# !K7$ FGGH$ 1@535;>4$ ?5@$ ,7<52278D>9=58;M

?5@$ 9K7$ >33@5J>4$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B5A8<=4M$ D5M

=8D77DM$;37<=?=<>446$ @>=;7$ 9K7$ =;;A7$5?$,52>$I=9K=8

9K7$4>N5A@$2>@P79M$2>P=8L$9K7$?5445I=8L$@7<52278C

D>9=58;$95$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<$>8D$95$%45J>P=>j

8P?KQ#9?RSD>IKT [-5@7$7??5@9;$>@7$877D7D$95$=897L@>97

9K7$25;9$JA487@>N47$L@5A3;$=8$9K7$4>N5A@$2>@P79O$!K=;$ =;

3>@9=<A4>@46$877D7D$ =8$ @7L=58;$59K7@$ 9K>8$1@>LA7$>8D$?5@

9K7$,52>$353A4>9=58O\

0>J@HUIHT [!K7$87I$3@=5@=96$L=J78$95$=897L@>9=8L$9K7$,52>

353A4>9=58$877D;$95$N7$@>3=D46$9@>8;4>97D$=895$><9=58O\

5A" &9$ 2>6$ N7$ >@LA7DM$ K5I7J7@M$ 9K>9$ ;A<K$ @7<52C

278D>9=58;$;K5A4D$>3346$95$2>86$5@$25;9$-72N7@

%9>97;M$ IK7@7$ A87234562789$ @>97;$ >258L$ ,52>M

/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$>@7$>4;5$K=LKM$NA9$IK7@7$9K7

=;;A7$K>;$859$N778$>;$3AN4=<46$3@52=8789$>;$=8$9K7

B_7<K$,73AN4=<$>8D$%45J>P=>O

$/#0+9/8+/97'#M/*<0

5B" !I5$<52358789;$5?$9K7$#'$%9@A<9A@>4$+A8D;$>@7

D=@7<946$ @747J>89$ 95$ ,52>$ 353A4>9=58;j$ 9K7$ #A@5C

37>8$,7L=58>4$07J74532789$+A8D$ c#,0+d$ >8D$ 9K7

#A@537>8$%5<=>4$+A8D$c#%+dO !K7$#,0+$=;$9K7$3@=8C

<=3>4$ =8;9@A2789$5?$ @7L=58>4$354=<6M$ =;$2>8>L7D$N6

9K7$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$?5@$,7L=58>4$154=<6$>8D$D=;C

NA@;7D$!FZOFN8$ DA@=8L$ FGGEO$-72N7@$ %9>97$ L5JC

7@82789;$ 3@5J=D7$ <5A897@3>@9$ ?A8D=8LO$ !K7

)NW7<9=J7$R$?A8D=8L$I=8D5I$;A335@9;$9K7$D7J7453C

2789$ 5?$ 9K7$ 47>;9$ ?>J5A@7D$ @7L=58;M$ 9K>9$ =;$ 9K5;7

I=9K$ >$ @7L=58>4$ /01$ 5?$ 47;;$ 9K>8$ ^Yl$ 5?$ 9K7$ #'

>J7@>L7M$ IK=4;9$ 9K7$ )NW7<9=J7$ F$ ?A8D=8L$ I=8D5I

;A335@9;$9K7$<58J7@;=58$5?$@7L=58;$?><=8L$;9@A<9A@C

>4$ D=??=<A49=7;M$ 5?978$ DA7$ 95$ 9K7$ D7<4=87$ 5?$ >$ P76

=8DA;9@6O !K7$ #,0+$ '@N>8$ +A8D$ =;$ >N47$ 95$ ?A8D

A@N>8$@7L787@>9=58$ =8$<5537@>9=58$I=9K$8>9=58>4$5@

45<>4$ >A9K5@=9=7;M$ >8D$ >49K5ALK$ =9$ <>8859$ <A@@78946

?=8>8<7$ K5A;=8L$ =9;74?M$ =9$ <>8$ ;A335@9$ 8>9=58>4

7Q378D=9A@7$58$K5A;=8L$9K@5ALK$2>9<K=8L$;A335@9

95$<523472789>@6$=8?@>;9@A<9A@7O

5!"#!K7$#,0+$=;$859M$K5I7J7@M$>$3A@7$=8?@>;9@A<C

9A@7$ ?A8D$ >;$ ;5279=27;$ =2>L=87DO &8$ ?><9M$ =8?@>C

;9@A<9A@7$><<5A89;$?5@$WA;9$Ffl$5?$7Q378D=9A@7$<52C

3>@7D$95$EGl$?5@$KA2>8$@7;5A@<7$D7J74532789$>8D

HFl$?5@$>=D$95$3@5DA<9=J7$;7<95@;O !K7$+A8D$2>6

9K7@7?5@7$ ?=8>8<7$>$8A2N7@$5?$><9=J=9=7;$5?$ =897@7;9

95$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58;M$ =8<4AD=8L$ N>;=<$ =8?@>;9@A<C

9A@7$?5@$,52>8=$;799472789;M$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$27>;C

A@7;$>8D$4=?7458L$47>@8=8L$?><=4=9=7;O

5,"# !K7$ B5K7;=58$ +A8D$ =;$ >$ <523472789>@6

=8;9@A2789$ D7;=L87D$ ?5@$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ IK5;7

/01$ =;$ 47;;$ 9K>8$ hGl$ 5?$ 9K7$ #'$ >J7@>L7M$ >8D

>49K5ALK$=9$K>;$3@7J=5A;46$<5J7@7D$WA;9$/@77<7M$&@7C

4>8DM$15@9AL>4$>8D$%3>=8$=9$I=44$=8$9K7$FGG^CFGRE$37@=C

5D$ <5J7@$ >44$ RG$ 87I$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ >;$ I744$ >;

/@77<7$>8D$15@9AL>4M$ >8D$I=44$ ?=8>8<7$2A49=C>88A>4

3@5L@>227;$=8$9K7$?=74D;$5?$9@>8;35@9$>8D$9K7$78J=C

@582789O$!K7$ &8;9@A2789$ ?5@$%9@A<9A@>4$154=<=7;$ ?5@

1@7C(<<7;;=58$ c&%1(d$ I>;$ A9=4=;7D$ =8$ 9K7$ RG$ 87I

-72N7@$%9>97;$DA@=8L$9K7$><<7;;=58$37@=5DM$4>@L746

95$=23@5J7$9@>8;35@9$879I5@P;$>8D$?><=4=9=7;O

5-"#!K7$#A@537>8$%5<=>4$+A8D$?=8>8<7;$><9=J=9=7;

>=27D$>9$ =23@5J=8L$ =8J54J72789$ =8$9K7$ 4>N5A@$2>@C

P79M$ =8<4AD=8L$ ;9@7>2;$ 58$ I5278X;$ 3>@9=<=3>9=58M

4=?7458L$47>@8=8LM$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58M$4>N5A@$>D>39>N=4=96

>8D$>8$><9=J7$ 4>N5A@$2>@P79O$!K7$+A8D$K>;$>4@7>D6

N778$ A;7D$ 95$ ?=8>8<7$ ><9=J=9=7;$ 5?$ @747J>8<7$ 95

,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;M$=8<4AD=8L$9K7$*>9=58C

>4$ 1@5L@>227$ ?5@$ 9K7$ %3>8=;K$ ,52>$ B522A8=96

c(BB#0#,dM$ IK=<K$ [=897@$ >4=>\$ 7;9>N4=;K7D$ H^$ ;37C

<=>4=;9$ 7234562789$ 5??=<7;M$ ;7@J=8L$ R^MGGG$ ,52>

>8D$@7;A49=8L$=8$9K7$I5@P$34><72789$5?$RGMGGGM$>8D

;A335@97D$EMZGG$,52>$9K@5ALK$7234562789$@74>97D

9@>=8=8L$3@5L@>227;O$!K7$#%+$3@5J=D7D$!EROY2$5?9K7$!HY2$3@5L@>227$<5;9$c;77$>4;5$!7Q9$U5Q$RdO

54"#!K7$#s'(.$B522A8=96$ &8=9=>9=J7$ =;$ ?=8>8<7D

N6$ 9K7$ #%+$ >8D$ ;77P;$ 95$ 97;9$ 87I$ >33@5><K7;$ 95

?=LK9=8L$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$=87TA>4=9=7;$=8$9K7$723456C

2789$2>@P79M$ 95$ D=;;72=8>97$ L55D$ 3@><9=<7$ >8D$ 95

78;A@7$ ;AN;7TA789$ 2>=8;9@7>2=8LO ($ 8A2N7@$ 5?

3@5W7<9;$ >=27D$ >9$ 9K7$ =8<4A;=58$ 5?$ 2=85@=96$ 79K8=<

<522A8=9=7;$ =8$ 9K7$ I5@P34><7$ K>J7$ N778$ ?=8>8<7D

9K@5ALK$ [D7J74532789$ 3>@987@;K=3;\M$ =8<4AD=8L$ >

8A2N7@$ >=27D$ ;37<=?=<>446$ >9$ ,52>8=$ <522A8=9=7;

>8D$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 9K>9$ N787?=97D$ ,52>8=$ <522A8=9=7;

>258L$59K7@;OEG

;6"#14>88=8L$?5@$9K7$FGG^CFGRE$@5A8D$5?$?A8D=8L

?5@$ 9K7$ #,0+M$ 9K7$ #%+$ >8D$ 9K7$ B5K7;=58$ +A8D$ =;

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

EG +5@$7Q>2347M$9K7$/7@2>8$3@5W7<9$[,52>$A8D$%=89=$DA@<K$%74N;95@L>8=;>9=58$_A$U7;<Kt?9=LA8L$A8D$#Q=;978_;=<K7@A8L\$>8D$9K7

%3>8=;K$[B58;5@<=5$1>478<=>$%5<=>4$3>@>$74$07;>@@5445$.5<>4$D7$1>478<=>\M$N59K$K>J=8L$NADL79;$5?$!F2$5@$25@7O$!K7$ ?=@;9$ =;

L7>@7D$D=@7<946$95$,52>8=$353A4>9=58;M$IK=4;9$9K7$;7<58D$I>;$>=27D$>9$D=;>DJ>89>L7D$I5278M$=8<4AD=8L$,52>8=$I5278O

Page 21: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

<A@@78946$9>P=8L$34><7O$&9$=;$>89=<=3>97D$9K>9$>$959>4$5?

!EEZOEN8$I=44$N7$>J>=4>N47$=8$959>4$?5@$9K7$#'CFYM$ =8>DD=9=58$95$<5A897@3>@9$?A8D=8L$3@5J=D7D$N6$8>9=58>4

L5J7@82789;O$ !K=;$ ;A2$ <5A4D$ 2>P7$ >$ J7@6

;=L8=?=<>89$ D=??7@78<7$ 95$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>M

/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$=8$#A@537$>;$458L$>;$-72N7@

%9>97;$ 34><7$ >$ 3@=5@=96$ 58$ 9K=;$ =;;A7$ >8D$ <522=9

>D7TA>97$<5A897@3>@9$?A8D;O

(+.$9#$/#&('181$0#7*<#&9(297%%$0

;5" )9K7@$ 0=@7<95@>97;$ /787@>4$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

B522=;;=58$ <A@@78946$ K>J7$ 47;;$ >N=4=96$ 95$ ?=8>8<7

27>;A@7;$9K>9$<5A4D$D=@7<946$5@$=8D=@7<946$9><P47$9K7

7??7<9;$ 5?$ @><=;2O *7J7@9K747;;M$ 9K7$ 0=@7<95@>97

/787@>4$?5@$1AN4=<$"7>49K$>8D$B58;A27@$1@597<9=58

D57;$;79$>$K7>49K$;9@>97L6$?5@$9K7$#'M$IK=<K$K>;$9K7

;<537$95$=8<4AD7$7472789;$@74>9=8L$95$9K7$K7>49K$5?

7Q<4AD7D$ <522A8=9=7;M$ =8<4AD=8L$ 9K7$ ,52>$ <52C

2A8=96O !K7$ FGGH$ I5@P$ 3@5L@>227$ 5?$ 9K7$ FGGEC

FGGf$ B522A8=96$ (<9=58$ 1@5L@>227$ =8$ 3AN4=<

K7>49K$D57;$@7<5L8=;7$9K7$35;;=N=4=96$5?$A;=8L$?A8D;

95$ <>@@6$ 5A9$ I5@P$ =8$ 9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?$ [K7>49K$ D797@2=C

8>89;\M$ =8<4AD=8L$ ;5<=5C7<5852=<$ D797@2=8>89;

78<523>;;=8L$[2=85@=96$>8D$2=L@>89$353A4>9=58;\O

!K=;$ >;37<9$ <523@=;7;$ >$ J7@6$ ;2>44$ 3>@9$ 5?$ 9K7

!ZG2$>88A>4$NADL79$?5@$9K7$<5C?=8>8<=8L$5?$K7>49K;7<95@$=8=9=>9=J7;M$K5I7J7@M$>8D$3@5L@>227$5A93A9;

>@7$>;$679$A8<47>@O

;;"# !K7$ 0=@7<95@>97$ /787@>4$ 5?$ #DA<>9=58$ >8D

BA49A@7$K>;$3@7J=5A;46$9>P78$>$3>@9=<A4>@$ =897@7;9$ =8

,52>$ =;;A7;M$ K>J=8L$ =;;A7D$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ D5<AC

2789;$58$9K7$;ANW7<9M$=8<4AD=8L$9K7$Rhfh$,7;54A9=58

[)8$%<K554$ 1@5J=;=58$ ?5@$/63;6$ >8D$ !@>J7447@$ BK=4C

D@78\M$NA9$K>;$679$95$7??7<9$;=L8=?=<>89$<K>8L7$I=9KC

=8$ ,52>$ 7DA<>9=58$ 9K@5ALK$ ;A<K$ D5<A2789;$ 5@

9K@5ALK$=9;$%5<@>97;$&&$>8D$.758>@D5$D>$V=8<=$B52C

2A8=96$ (<9=58$ 1@5L@>227;O$ ($ 4=2=97D$ 8A2N7@$ 5?

;37<=?=<$ 3@5W7<9;$ >=27D$ >9$ 9K7$ 7;9>N4=;K2789$ 5?

9@>8;C8>9=58>4$3>@987@;K=3;$K>J7$3@5DA<7D$;A<<7;;C

?A4$5A9<527;$N6$I>6$5?$D7J7453=8L$>8D$D7258;9@>9C

=8L$ L55D$ 3@><9=<7M$ D7J7453=8L$ =885J>9=J7

>33@5><K7;$9K>9$K>J7$ =8?5@27D$2>=8;9@7>2$354=<6M

3@5J=;=58$>8D$3@><9=<7M$>8D$3AN4=;K=8L$2>86$=8?4A78C

9=>4$ @7;7>@<K$@735@9;eN55P;$>8D$97><K=8L$2>97@=>4;O

)87$;A<K$3@5W7<9M$?=8>8<7D$9K@5ALK$9K7$%5<@>97;$&&

3@5L@>227M$47D$95$9K7$D7J74532789$5?$1>@789$"74D

#DA<>9=58>4$ ,7<5@D;$ ?5@$ 852>D=<$ /63;6$ >8D$ !@>JC

7447@$3A3=4;M$IK=<K$K>;$;AN;7TA78946$N778$>D5397D

>;$354=<6$N6$9K7$073>@92789$?5@$#DA<>9=58$>8D$%P=44;

c0?#%d$=8$#8L4>8DO

$/#$*'792$%$*+#7*<1+.$#910$#(M#9(%7#70#7*

79$7#(M#$/#&('18)#8(*8$9*

;=" !K7$ ->6$ FGGH$ 784>@L72789$ 5?$ 9K7$ #'$ N@=8L;

=235@9>89$ N787?=9;$ 95$ N59K$ 54D$ >8D$ 87I$ -72N7@

%9>97;M$ NA9$ >4;5$ 35;7;$ ;=L8=?=<>89$ <K>4478L7;O

%37<=?=<>446M$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$I=9K=8$87I$-72C

N7@$%9>97;$I>;M$>8D$@72>=8;M$>$<>A;7$?5@$<58<7@8M

L=J78$9K7$7J=D78<7$5?$ @><=;2$>8D$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ =8

7234562789M$ 7DA<>9=58$ >8D$ K7>49K$ <>@7$ 3@5J=;=58M

?>=4A@7;$5?$9K7$<@=2=8>4$WA;9=<7$;6;972;$=8$<>;7;$<58C

<7@8=8L$ ,52>$ >8D$ 73=;5D7;$ 5?$ J=5478<7$ >L>=8;9

,52>O$ (3>@9$ ?@52$ ?A8D>2789>4$ KA2>8=9>@=>8$ >8D

KA2>8$@=LK9;$<58<7@8;M$ 9K7$;=9A>9=58$ =8$2>86$87I

-72N7@$ %9>97;$ 3@=5@$ 95$ ><<7;;=58$ 35=897D$ 95$ 9K7

35;;=N=4=96$5?$?>=4A@7$95$<52346$I=9K$9K7$354=9=<>4$<@=C

97@=>$ ?5@$ #'$272N7@;K=3M$ >;$ ;9>97D$ =8$ 9K7$ B5378C

K>L78$ B@=97@=>M$ >L@77D$ >9$ 9K7$ RhhE$ B5378K>L78

#A@537>8$B5A8<=4O$!K=;$;9>97;$ 9K>9$-72N7@$%9>97;

;K5A4D$[N7$>$;9>N47$D725<@><6M$ @7;37<9=8L$KA2>8

@=LK9;M$9K7$@A47$5?$4>I$>8D$9K7$3@597<9=58$5?$2=85@=C

9=7;O\$+>=4A@7$95$<52346$I=9K$9K7$<@=97@=>$I5A4D$K>J7

W753>@D=;7D$784>@L72789$>9$;=L8=?=<>89$354=9=<>4$<5;9O

;A" &8$5@D7@$ 95$78;A@7$25J72789$ 95I>@D;$ 9K7

<@=97@=>M$9K7$B522=;;=58$;AN2=997D$>88A>4$,7LA4>@

,735@9;$95I>@D$(<<7;;=58$95$9K7$#A@537>8$B5A8C

<=4$?@52$Rhhf$95$FGGEO$!K7;7$@735@9;$D=D$A8D7@4=87

9K7$ =235@9>8<7$ 5?$ D7>4=8L$ I=9K$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;

=;;A7;$<58<7@8=8L$,52>MER >8D$;A335@97D$8>9=58>4

,52>$ 3@5W7<9;$ 9K@5ALK$ 9K7$ 1K>@7$ 3@5L@>227O$ (

;7<58D$ =2379A;$ ?5@$ >DD@7;;=8L$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?

,52>$=8$B789@>4$>8D$#>;97@8$#A@537$I>;$9K7$?4=LK9

5?$,52>$95$S7;97@8$#A@537$95$<4>=2$>;64A2$?@52

37@;7<A9=58O$ !K=;$ 25J72789$ 3@5J=D7D$ >$ 354=9=<>4

=237@>9=J7$=8$7Q=;9=8L$-72N7@$%9>97;$95$3@7;;$?5@

=23@5J72789;$ =8$ 9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$ =8$B789@>4

>8D$#>;97@8$#A@537M$>8D$?5@$27>;A@7;$95$[<52N>9

>;64A2$>NA;7\OEF

;B" +@52$FGGR$95$FGGE$9K7$1K>@7$3@5L@>227$<58C

9@=NA97D$!^^2$95$,52>$3@5W7<9;$=8$9K7$9K78$><<7;;=58>8D$<>8D=D>97$;9>97;M$<5J7@=8L$>$@>8L7$5?$ =8?@>;9@A<C

9A@7M$3AN4=<$>I>@787;;$>8D$;7<95@C;37<=?=<$3@5W7<9;OEE

S74<527$9K5ALK$9K=;$<589@=NA9=58$I>;M$K5I7J7@M$9K7

;<>47$5?$9K7$3@5N472M$>8D$?><9$9K>9$2>86$5?$9K7$=897@C

J789=58;$ I7@7$ 3@5W7<9$ ;37<=?=<M$ 27>8;$ 9K>9$ 2>86

25@7$ @7;5A@<7;$ 877D$ 95$ N7$ <522=997D$ 5J7@$ >$ 458L

37@=5D$5?$9=27$=8$5@D7@$95$2>P7$>$@7>4$=23><9O

;!" B58<4A;=58;$ 5?$ @7<789$ >;;7;;2789$ 5?$ 1K>@7

3@5L@>22=8L$58$,52>$=8<4AD7$9K7$5N;7@J>9=58;$9K>9j

q 1K>@7$ 3@5L@>227;$ <47>@46$ D7258;9@>97D$ 9K>9

7Q=;9=8L$ 354=<=7;$ >8D$ 3@><9=<7;$ =8$ B789@>4$ >8D

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 22: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

#>;97@8$#A@537$I7@7$?>=4=8L$,52>O$!K7$5J7@>44$4><P

5?$J=;=58$>8D$D=@7<9=58$27>8;$9K7@7$I>;$85$<47>@

A8D7@3=88=8L$354=<6$D=@7<9=58$5@$<522=92789O

q (;$ >8$ 5A9<527$ 5?$ #'$ >8D$ 59K7@$ 7Q97@8>4$ 3@7;C

;A@7M$=;;A7;$?><=8L$,52>$K>J7$25J7D$95$>$35;=C

9=58$5?$K=LK7@$3@=5@=96O$(9$9K7$;>27$9=27$=9$K>;$>4;5

N7<527$2A<K$25@7$ 354=9=<>4$ >8D$ 3>@9=;>8M$ >8D

9K7$ 537@>9=58>4$ 78J=@582789$ ;A@@5A8D=8L$ 354=<6

2>P=8L$?5@$,52>$=897L@>9=58$@72>=8;$?@>L=47Ou

q &8$ <A@@789$ ;6;972;$ 9K7@7$ =;$ >$ 4><P$ 5?$ <>3><=96M

A8D7@;9>8D=8L$>8D$3@5?7;;=58>4$7Q37@9=;7$95$D7>4

7??7<9=J746$ I=9K$ 9K7$ <52347Q$ >8D$ 2A49=CD=278C

;=58>4$8>9A@7$5?$9K7$3@5N472O$!K7@7$=;$>$J>;9$L>3

N79I778$9K7$354=<6$47J74M$=8<4AD=8L$3@535@9=58>4C

=96M$>8D$537@>9=58>4$@7>4=96O

;," ,7;7>@<K$A8D7@9>P78$?5@$9K=;$;9AD6$=8D=<>97;$9K>9$=8

>$8A2N7@$5?$>@7>;$9K7;7$<58<4A;=58;$>@7$@747J>89$?5@

,52>$354=<6$=8$2>86$=?$859$>44$5?$9K7$-72N7@$%9>97;O

(+.$9#$/9(&$7*#'$27'#

7*<#&('18)#M97%$N(9O01;-" &8$FGGGM$9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537$53787D$?5@$;=L8>C

9A@7$>$87I$1@595<54$RF$95$9K7$#A@537>8$B58J789=58

58$"A2>8$,=LK9;O$)8<7$=8$7??7<9$CC$>?97@$=9$K>;$N778

@>9=?=7D$N6$978$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537$-72N7@$%9>97;$CC

1@595<54$ RF$ I=44$ 3@5J=D7$ >$ <523@7K78;=J7$ N>8$ 58

D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ =8$ 9K7$7Q7@<=;7$5?$>86$ @=LK9$ ;7<A@7D

N6$4>IO$1@595<54$RF$;=L8=?=<>8946$7Q3>8D;$9K7$3@597<C

9=58;$ >J>=4>N47$ 95$ =8D=J=DA>4;$ A8D7@$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

B58J789=58$ 58$ "A2>8$ ,=LK9;O$ !5$ D>97M$ K5I7J7@M

5846$ 587$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ -72N7@$ %9>97$ cB63@A;d

K>;$@>9=?=7D$1@595<54$RFOEH

;4"# !K7$ B5A8<=4$ 5?$ #A@537b;$ #A@537>8$ %5<=>4

BK>@97@M$ @7<78946$ 7Q3>8D7D$ 95$ ?5@2$ 9K7$ ,7J=;7D

#A@537>8$ %5<=>4$ BK>@97@M$ =8$ 3@=8<=347$ 3@5J=D7;$ 9K7

N>;=;$ ?5@$ ;=L8=?=<>89$3@597<9=58;$5?$ ;5<=>4$ >8D$7<5C

852=<$ @=LK9;O$ !K7$ =8<4A;=58$ 5?$ >$ <5447<9=J7$ <52C

34>=89;$27<K>8=;2$85I$2>P7;$>J>=4>N47$3@5<7DA@7;

9K@5ALK$ IK=<K$ J=54>9=58;$ 5?$ 9K7$ BK>@97@$ <>8$ N7

@7D@7;;7DO$!K=;$27<K>8=;2$955M$K5I7J7@M$=;$A8D7@C

@>9=?=7D$ >8DM$ I=9K$ ;7J7@>4$ 8597I5@9K6$ 7Q<739=58;M

7J78$ 9K5;7$ ;9>97;$IK=<K$K>J7$ @>9=?=7D$ 9K7$,7J=;7D

BK>@97@$K>J7$859$><<7397D$>44$5?$=9;$3@5J=;=58;O

=6" !K7@7$>@7$>$8A2N7@$5?$354=<6$=8=9=>9=J7;$5?$@74C

7J>8<7$ 95$ ,52>$ <A@@78946$ N7=8L$ A8D7@9>P78$ N6

59K7@$=897@8>9=58>4$5@L>8=;>9=58;O$!K7;7$=8<4AD7$9K7

B5A8<=4$ 5?$ #A@537M$ )%B#M$ '*01M$ >8D$ 9K7$ S5@4D

U>8PO$!K7$7Q=;9=8L$4=8P;$>8D$W5=89$=8=9=>9=J7;$N79I778

9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$>8D$59K7@$><95@;$;K5A4D$9K7@7C

?5@7$N7$NA=49$A358O$(8$7Q>2347$5?$>$I5@P=8L$ =8=9=>C

9=J7$N79I778$=897@8>9=58>4$354=<6C2>P=8L$>8D$D585@

>L78<=7;$ =;$ 9K7$ 3@5W7<9$ [,52>$ A8D7@$ 9K7$ %9>N=4=96

1><9\M$IK=<K$9K7$B522=;;=58$ =;$ ?A8D=8L$A8D7@$9K7

#A@537>8$&8=9=>9=J7$?5@$"A2>8$,=LK9;M$>8D$IK7@7$=9

=;$=8$<5537@>9=58$I=9K$9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537$>8D$9K7

)%B#O$ (49K5ALK$ 4=2=97D$ =8$ ;<537M$ >8D$ =8$ 3@><9=<>4

@7;A49;$ 95$ D>97M$ 9K7$ =8=9=>9=J7$ K>;$ <589@=NA97D$ 95$ >

K=LK7@$J=;=N=4=96$5?$,52>$ =;;A7;$58$ 9K7$>L78D>;$5?

;527$L5J7@82789;M$D585@;$>8D$=897@CL5J7@82789>4

5@L>8=;>9=58;O$ &8<@7>;7D$ <5C537@>9=58$ N79I778

D585@;$ I5A4D$ K>J7$ 9K7$ N787?=9$ 5?$ 3554=8L$ 5?

@7;5A@<7;M$>8D$K>;$9K7$359789=>4$5?$=8<@7>;=8L$354=<6

<5K7@78<7O$!K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$9>P7;$3>@9$=8

;7J7@>4$D585@$ =8=9=>9=J7;$>=27D$>9$<5C5@D=8>9=8L$9K7

><9=J=9=7;$ @74>97D$ 95$ 9K7$ =23@5J72789$5?$ 9K7$,52>

;=9A>9=58$>9$9K7$#A@537>8$47J74O$!K7$B522=;;=58$=;

@73@7;7897D$N6$;7J7@>4$0/;$>9$9K7$&8?5@2>4$B589><9

/@5A3$ 5?$ &897@8>9=58>4$ )@L>8=;>9=58$ 58$ ,52>$ >8D

%=89=M$<5C5@L>8=;7D$N6$9K7$)%B#M$>8D$9K7$#'$1@7;=C

D78<6$>4;5$9>P7;$>8$><9=J7$3>@9$I=9K=8$9K7$%977@=8L

B522=9977$ 5?$ 9K7$ ,52>$ &8<4A;=58$07<>D7$ cFGGY$ C

FGRYd$354=9=<>4$=8=9=>9=J7O

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

ER +5@$7Q>2347M$9K7$FGGG$,7LA4>@$,735@9$35=897D$5A9$=8$=9;$;A22>@6$9K>9$[,52>$<589=8A7$95$?><7$I=D7;3@7>D$D=;<@=2=8>9=58O$r&8

25;9$<5A89@=7;$r$27>;A@7;$>8D$3@5L@>227;$K>J7$85I$N778$>D5397DM$;A335@97D$N6$1K>@7$?A8D=8LO\ &8$9K7$<5A89@6C;37<=?=<

(887QM$9K7$@735@9$8597D$?5@$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$?5@$7Q>2347M$9K>9$[;=L8=?=<>89$7??5@9;$K>J7$N778$2>D7rNA9$?A@9K7@$3@5L@7;;$=;

877D7D\M$IK=4;9$=8$,52>8=>$[r9K7$<589=8A7D$K=LK$47J74;$5?$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>@7$>$;7@=5A;$<58<7@8$r>8D$3@5L@7;;$K>;$N778$4=2C

=97D$95$3@5L@>227;$>=27D$>9$=23@5J=8L$><<7;;$95$7DA<>9=58O\

EF 1K@>;7$9>P78$?@52$>$gA46$FGGF$47997@$?@52$9K7$'`$1@=27$-=8=;97@$95$9K7$B_7<K$1@=27$-=8=;97@$>8D$@73@5DA<7D$=8$%5N59P>M$#J>M

cFGGEdM$[,52>8=$-=L@>9=58$=8$9K7$RhhG;j$17@;37<9=J7;$58$068>2=<M$&897@3@79>9=58$>8D$154=<6\M$=8$$"%&!*+B.,>*01M$V54O$RE$&;;A7

FM$33O^hCRFFO

EE &8<4AD=8L$!RZOE2$?5@$"A8L>@6M$!RhOY2$?5@$%45J>P=>$>8D$!RGOZ2$?5@$,52>8=>O$%77$IIIO7A@53>O7AO=89e<522e784>@L72789eD5<;e

3D?eN@5<KA@7p,52>p->6$FGGFO

EH %=Q$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537$-72N7@$%9>97;$=8$959>4$K>J7$@>9=?=7D$1@595<54$RFj$U5;8=>$>8D$"7@_7L5J=8>M$B@5>9=>M$B63@A;M$/75@L=>M$%>8

->@=85M$>8D$%7@N=>$>8D$-589787L@5O

Page 23: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

5" !K7$;<>@<7$@74=>N47$D>9>$9K>9$D57;$7Q=;9$35=89;$95

J7@6$D@>2>9=<$L>3;$N79I778$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>

>8D$858C,52>$9K@5ALK5A9$#A@537$=8$?=74D;$@747J>89

95$ #'$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 354=<6O$ !K=;$ ;7<9=58$ 5?$ 9K7

@735@9$;A22>@=;7;$<58<7@8;$I=9K$@7;37<9$95$9K7$;=9C

A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ ;7<95@>4$ ?=74D;M

=8<4AD=8L$ 7DA<>9=58M$ 7234562789M$ K5A;=8LM$ K7>49K

<>@7$>8D$;5<=>4$>;;=;9>8<7O$&9$>4;5$8597;$=;;A7;$@74>9C

7D$95$L78D7@M$852>D=;2M$>8D$9K7$D=;3>@>97$=23><9

5?$78J=@582789>4$K>@2O

$</87+1(*

;" !K7$.=;N58$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4$K>;$;79$ ?=J7$#A@5C

37>8$N78<K2>@P;$?5@$9K7$=23@5J72789$5?$7DA<>9=58

>8D$9@>=8=8L$;6;972;$=8$#A@537$A3$95$FGRGj

=d$ (8$#'$>J7@>L7$@>97$5?$85$25@7$9K>8$RGl$7>@46

;<K554$47>J7@;$;K5A4D$N7$><K=7J7Do

==d$ !K7$959>4$8A2N7@$5?$L@>DA>97;$ =8$2>9K72>9=<;M

;<=78<7$>8D$ 97<K8545L6$ =8$ 9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58

;K5A4D$ =8<@7>;7$ N6$ >9$ 47>;9$ RYl$ IK=47$ >9$ 9K7

;>27$9=27$9K7$47J74$5?$L78D7@$=2N>4>8<7$;K5A4D

D7<@7>;7o

===d (9$ 47>;9$ fYl$ 5?$ FF$ 67>@$ 54D;$ =8$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

'8=58$;K5A4D$K>J7$<5234797D$A337@$;7<58D>@6

7DA<>9=58o

=Jd !K7$37@<789>L7$5?$RY$67>@C54D$ 45I$><K=7J7@;$ =8

@7>D=8L$ 4=97@><6$ ;K5A4D$ K>J7$ D7<@7>;7D$ N6$ >9

47>;9$FGl$<523>@7D$95$9K7$67>@$FGGGo

Jd$ !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$ >J7@>L7$ 47J74$ 5?$ 3>@9=<=3>C

9=58$ =8$ .=?7458L$ .7>@8=8L$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ >9$ 47>;9

RFOYl$5?$9K7$>DA49$I5@P=8L$>L7$353A4>9=58$cFYC

ZH$>L7$L@5A3dOEY

=" !K7@7$ =;$>$J7@6$ @7>4$ 9K@7>9$ 9K>9$ 9K7$8>9A@7$5?$#'

.=;N58$3@=5@=9=7;$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?$7DA<>9=58M$<52N=87D

I=9K$>$ ?>=4A@7$ 95$D>97$ 95$ =D789=?6$ @><=>4$ ;7L@7L>9=58

>8D$ 59K7@$ ?5@2;$ 5?$ 79K8=<=96CN>;7D$ 7Q<4A;=58$ >;$ >

9K@7>9$95$9K7$@7>4=;>9=58$5?$9K7$.=;N58$L5>4;M$2>6$N7

@7;A49=8L$ =8$ ><9=58;$ 9K>9$ I5@;78$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?

,52>M$>;$I744$>;$59K7@;$45<>97D$58$9K7$2>@L=8;$5?

7DA<>9=58>4$ ;6;972;$ =8$ #A@537O$ &8$ 9K7$ ?=@;9$ 34><7M

=8D=<>95@$ ;6;972;$ D7J74537D$ 95$ 9@><P$ =23472789>C

9=58$5?$ 9K7$.=;N58$>L78D>$?>=4$ 95$ @7L=;97@$D=;3>@>97

=23><9;$ 58$ ,52>$ >8D$ 59K7@$ 79K8=<$ L@5A3;OEZ !K=;

J><AA2$2>6$78<5A@>L7$354=<6C2>P7@;$95$D=;@7L>@D

87L>9=J7M$ @><7C;37<=?=<$ 5A9<527;$ >;$ 9K76$ ;9@=J7$ 95

=23472789$9K7$J7@6$>2N=9=5A;$.=;N58$>L78D>$=8$9K7

?=74D$5?$7DA<>9=58O$%7<58D46M$9K7$K=LK$8A2N7@$5?$.=;C

N58$ 7DA<>9=58$ =8D=<>95@;$ ?5<A;;=8L$ 58$ 2>997@;

>;;5<=>97D$ I=9K$ 74=97$ 7DA<>9=58M$ ;A<K$ >;$ 9K7$ ?5A@

=8D=<>95@;$@74>97D$95$a25N=4=96aM$>L>=8$<52N=87D$I=9K

>8$>N;78<7$5?$7DA<>9=58>4$=8D=<>95@;$9@><P=8L$@><=>4

;7L@7L>9=58M$@><=>4$7Q<4A;=58M$>8D$59K7@$;5<=>446$<5@C

@5;=J7$ 5A9<527;M$ <>8$ ;7@J7$ 95$ A8D7@2=87$ 9K7$ .=;C

N58$ >L78D>$ >8D$ A8D7@<A9$ 9K7$ >N=4=96$ 5?

354=<6C2>P7@;$95$><K=7J7$9>@L79;O

A" !K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$ =8$ 9K7$P76$>@7>$5?$3@=C

2>@6$ 7DA<>9=58$ =;$ J7@6$ I5@@6=8LO$ #,,B$ @7;7>@<K

<58DA<97D$ 58$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ 9K7$ B_7<K

;<K554$;6;972$=8$ 9K7$;<K554$67>@$RhhfCRhhh$D5<AC

27897D$ 7Q9@727$ 47J74;$ 5?$ @><=>4$ ;7L@7L>9=58$ =8

B_7<K$;<K554;OE^ &8978;=J7$@7;7>@<K$I>;$<>@@=7D$5A9

=8$9K7$B_7<K$<=96$5?$);9@>J>O$!K=;$@7J7>47D$9K>9M$DA@C

=8L$9K7$RhhfCRhhh$;<K554$67>@j

q -5@7$9K>8$K>4?$5?$9K7$;9AD789$N5D6$5?$;5C<>447D

a@727D=>4$ ;37<=>4$ ;<K554;a$ ?5@$ 9K7$2789>446$ D=;C

>N47D$I7@7$,52>8=o

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

EY B522=;;=58$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522A8=9=7;M$aB522=;;=58$%9>??$S5@P=8L$1>37@j$1@5L@7;;$!5I>@D;$9K7$B52258$)NW7<9=J7;$=8

#DA<>9=58$>8D$!@>=8=8Lj$&8D=<>95@;$>8D$U78<K2>@P;aM$U@A;;74;M$FROROFGGHM$%#BcFGGHd$^EO

EZ$ !K7$Fh$a&8D=<>95@;$?5@$-58=95@=8L$17@?5@2>8<7$>8D$1@5L@7;;$5?$#DA<>9=58$>8D$!@>=8=8L$%6;972;$=8$#A@537a$<>8$N7$?5A8D$=8$B52C

2=;;=58$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522A8=9=7;M$aB522=;;=58$%9>??$S5@P=8L$1>37@j$1@5L@7;;$!5I>@D;$9K7$B52258$)NW7<9=J7;$=8$#DAC

<>9=58$>8D$!@>=8=8Lj$&8D=<>95@;$>8D$U78<K2>@P;aM$U@A;;74;M$FROROFGGHM$%#B$cFGGHd$^EO

E^ %77$#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@M$($%37<=>4$,727D6j$,52>$>8D$%<K554;$?5@$9K7$-789>446$">8D=<>337D$=8$9K7$B_7<K$,73ANC

4=<M$UAD>37;9M$RhhhO

HO$,)-($&*$`#i$%#B!),(.$+&#.0%

Page 24: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

q -5@7$9K>8$K>4?$5?$9K7$353A4>9=58$5?$,52>8=$<K=4C

D@78$5?$9K7$>L7$5?$2>8D>95@6$;<K554$>9978D>8<7

=8$);9@>J>$I7@7$N7=8L$;<K5547D$=8$@727D=>4$;37C

<=>4$;<K554;o

q (86$L=J78$,52>8=$<K=4D$I>;$25@7$9K>8$F^$9=27;

25@7$ 4=P746$ 9K>8$ >$ 858C,52>8=$ <K=4D$ 95$ N7

;<K5547D$=8$>$@727D=>4$;37<=>4$;<K554O

B" !K7$B_7<K$L5J7@82789$K>;$7;9=2>97D$9K>9M$=8$9K7

<5A89@6$>;$>$IK547M$>33@5Q=2>9746$^Yl$5?$,52>8=

<K=4D@78$5?$3@=2>@6$;<K554$>L7$I7@7$N7=8L$;<K5547D

=8$@727D=>4$;37<=>4$;<K554;O$#,,B$@7;7>@<K$=8$);9@>C

J>$>8D$59K7@$B_7<K$45<>4=9=7;$>4;5$?5A8D$9K>9$IK7@7

,52>8=$ <K=4D@78$ >9978D7D$ 85@2>4$ 3@=2>@6$ ;<K554;M

9K76$I7@7$5J7@IK742=8L46$<58<789@>97D$=8$>$K>8D?A4

5?$;<K554;$I=D746$@7L>@D7D$45<>446$>;$=8?7@=5@$aLK7995a

;<K554;O$ +5445ICA3$ @7;7>@<K$ =8$ FGGE$ =8D=<>97D$ 9K>9

;=8<7$9K7$=8=9=>4$@7;7>@<K$I>;$A8D7@9>P78M$9K5;7$L5JC

7@82789$354=<=7;$>=2=8L$>9$>DD@7;;=8L$9K7$;=9A>9=58

5?$,52>$=8$9K7$;<K554$;6;972$K>D$K>D$4=9947$=23><9

=8$@7DA<=8L$K=LK$47J74;$5?$@><=>4$;7L@7L>9=58O

!"#&;;A7;$>@7$;=2=4>@$=8$%45J>P=>O$0A7$95$9K7$D7>@9K

5?$><<A@>97$D>9>$<58<7@8=8L$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8

9K7$ %45J>P$ ;<K554$ ;6;972M$ 9K7$ #,,B$ <58DA<97D

=8978;=J7$ ?=74D$ @7;7>@<K$ =8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ ;<K554$ D=;C

9@=<9;$=8$%45J>P=>$=8$(A9A28$FGGFM$>=27D$>9$3@5DA<C

=8L$>$25@7$><<A@>97$D7;<@=39=58$5?$ 9K7$7DA<>9=58>4

;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>8=$<K=4D@78O$!K=;$@7;7>@<K$@7J7>47D

9K>9$ DA@=8L$ 9K7$ FGGFeFGGE$ ;<K554$ 67>@M$ 25@7$ 9K>8

K>4?$ 9K7$ ;9AD789;$ 5?$ 2>86$ %45J>P$ ;<K554;$ ?5@$ 9K7

2789>446$D=;>N47DM$85I$@78>27D$[;37<=>4$;<K554;\M

I7@7$ ,52>8=M$ >8D$ =8$ ;527$ ;A<K$ ;37<=>4$ ;<K554;M

040/6+1*!)-0+7,7*-+A&1+$"%&!*O

,"#,52>8=$<K=4D@78$>4;5$?><7$;7@=5A;$3@5N472;$5?

@><=>4$ ;7L@7L>9=58$ =8$ ;<K554=8L$ =8$ "A8L>@6O$ "A8C

L>@6b;$g5=89$ &8<4A;=58$-725@>8DA2$ cag&-adM$ ;=L87D

N6$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ >8D$ 9K7$ "A8L>@=>8

L5J7@82789$ 58$ 07<72N7@$ RfM$ FGGEM$ =235@9>8946

><P85I47DL7;$9K7$3@5N472$5?$@><=>4$;7L@7L>9=58$=8

;<K554=8LM$;9>9=8L$9K>9$a!K7@7$>@7$>33@5Q=2>9746$^GG

;<K554;$ =8$IK=<K$,52>$<K=4D@78$>@7$;7L@7L>97D$ =8

7DA<>9=58$c;9AD6=8L$=8$;73>@>97$<4>;;7;dOaEf

-"#!K7$"A8L>@=>8$-=8=;9@6$5?$#DA<>9=58$K>;M$25@7C

5J7@M$ @7<78946$ >D5397D$25D7;9$ 27>;A@7;$ >=27D$ >9

D7;7L@7L>9=8L$9K7$"A8L>@=>8$7DA<>9=58$;6;972O$!K7

;9>9A95@6$=897L@>9=58$L@>89$D7;<@=N7D$=8$9K7$g&-$?5@2;

3>@9$5?$9K7$3@5<7;;$9K>9$K>;$N778$=8=9=>97D$N6$9K7$-=8C

=;9@6$5?$#DA<>9=58$95$D7;7L@7L>97$;<K554;j

a($ ;9>9A95@6$ =897L@>9=58$ L@>89$ ?=8>8<7D$ N6$ 9K7$ %9>97$ =;

N7=8L$ =89@5DA<7D$cFGGEeFGGH$><>D72=<$67>@d$ 95$3@52597

9K7$ =897L@>9=58$ 5?$ D=;>DJ>89>L7D$ <K=4D@78M$ 7;37<=>446

,52>O$ &8$ 9K7$<>;7$5?$;799472789;$IK7@7$ 9K7$2>W5@=96$5?

9K7$;9AD789;$=8$>$;<K554$>@7$;5<=>446$D=;>DJ>89>L7DM$>;$>

@7;A49$ 5?$ 35J7@96M$ 79K8=<$ N><PL@5A8DM$ D=;>N=4=96$ 5@$ >86

59K7@$<>A;7M$9K7$=897L@>9=58$L@>89$78<5A@>L7;$;5<=>4$=897C

L@>9=58$ N6$ >99@><9=8L$ N7997@C5??$ <K=4D@78$ IK5$ <A@@78946

>9978D$;<K554;$=8$59K7@$;799472789;OaEh

4" &8$UA4L>@=>M$9K7@7$>@7$>4;5$J7@6$;7@=5A;$3@5N472;$5?

@><=>4$;7L@7L>9=58$=8$;<K554=8L$>;$>$@7;A49$=8$3>@9=<AC

4>@$5?$9K7$34><72789$5?$,52>8=$<K=4D@78$=8$;AN;9>8C

D>@D$ ;<K554;$ 45<>97D$ =8$ 5@$ 87>@$ ,52>8=$ TA>@97@;O

!K7;7$ ;<K554;$ >@7$ 9@>D=9=58>446$ P85I8$ >;$ a/63;6

;<K554;a$>8D$L787@>446$5??7@$;AN;9>8D>@D$7DA<>9=58

=8$ 2>97@=>446$ =235J7@=;K7D$ ;A@@5A8D=8L;O$ "7@7M

>49K5ALK$ 9K7$ L5J7@82789$ K>;$ <522=997D$ =9;74?$ 95

D7;7L@7L>9=8L$ 9K7$ ;<K554$ ;6;972M$ D7;7L@7L>9=58

><9=58$95$D>97$K>;$N778$3@=2>@=46$D@=J78$N6$,52>8=

*/);$=8$;527$2A8=<=3>4=9=7;OHG (8$*/)C47D$3@5W7<9

=8$9K7$95I8$5?$V=D=8$K>;$D=;37@;7D$,52>8=$<K=4D@78

?@52$587$;AN;9>8D>@D$LK7995$;<K554$95$>$8A2N7@$5?

2>=8;9@7>2$ 3@=2>@6$ ;<K554;$ 5?$ ;=L8=?=<>8946$ N7997@

TA>4=96O$!K7$3@5W7<9$ =;$8597I5@9K6$ ?5@$ 9K7$7Q978;=J7

47J74;$5?$<58;A49>9=58$I=9K$>44$;9>P7K54D7@;O

56"#)9K7@$ ?5@2;$5?$;7L@7L>97D$;<K554=8L$K>J7

>4;5$N778$8597D$=8$S7;97@8$#A@537O$!K7$FGGG$%7<C

58D$,735@9$58$/7@2>86$N6$9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537b;

#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$>L>=8;9$,><=;2$>8D$&89547@C

>8<7$ c#B,&d$ @7<52278D;$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ L5J7@82789;

;K5A4D$ =8J7;9=L>97$ 9K7$ 5J7@C@73@7;789>9=58$ 5?

2=85@=96$ <K=4D@78$ =8$ [;37<=>4$ ;<K554;$ ?5@$ A8D7@C

><K=7J7@;\$ >8D$ [<5@@7;358D=8L$ A8D7@C@73@7;789>C

9=58$ =8$ =897@27D=>97$ >8D$ L@>22>@$ ;<K554;O\HR

,7;7>@<K$ <58DA<97D$ =8$ FGGE$ N6$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

'8=58$-58=95@=8L$>8D$(DJ5<><6$1@5L@>2$c#'-(1d

5?$ 9K7$)378$%5<=796$ &8;9=9A97M$ =8D=<>97D$ 9K>9$ 5846

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Ef g&-$"A8L>@6$3O$RFO

Eh g&-$"A8L>@6$3O$ERO

HG )8$9K7$7??=<><6$5?$*/)C47D$D7;7L@7L>9=58$=8$UA4L>@=>M$;77$`>87JM$0@O$`@>;;=2=@M$a!K7$+=@;9$%973;j$(8$#J>4A>9=58$5?$9K7$*58CL5JC

7@82789>4$ 07;7L@7L>9=58$ 1@5W7<9;$ =8$ %=Q$ UA4L>@=>8$ B=9=7;j$ (8$ #Q97@8>4$ #J>4A>9=58$ ,735@9$ 95$ 9K7$ )378$ %5<=796$ &8;9=9A97aM

UAD>37;9j$)378$%5<=796$&8;9=9A97M$FGGEO

HR #B,&$,735@9M$3O$RRO

Page 25: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

K>4?$5?$,52>$>8D$%=89=$<K=4D@78$=8$/7@2>86$>9978D

;<K554$ >9$ >44$ >8D$ 5?$ 9K5;7$IK5$D5$ >9978DM$ >$ K=LK

8A2N7@$ CC$ @735@97D46$ A3$ 95$ fGl$ =8$ ;527$ >@7>;$ CC

>9978D$[;37<=>4$;<K554;\OHF

55" &8$%3>=8M$2>86$;9>97$;<K554;M$7;37<=>446$9K5;7

=8$ >@7>;$ I=9K$ 4>@L7$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58;M$ K>J7$ =8

@7<789$ 67>@;$ N7<527$ [LK7995=;7D\O$ &8$ 9K7$ 4>;9$ 978

67>@;M$;527$;<K554;$K>J7$25J7D$?@52$K>J=8L$>@5A8D

EGCHGl$,52>$ ;9AD789;$ 95$ K>J=8L$25@7$ 9K>8$ fGlO

g5;v$B>N>87;MHE >$;5<=545L=;9$>8D$7Q37@9$58$7DA<>C

9=58M$D7;<@=N7;$9K=;$3@5<7;;$=8$9K7$?5445I=8L$97@2;j

=d$ SK78$>$K=LK$8A2N7@$5?$,52>8=$<K=4D@78$7897@$>

L=J78$;<K554$;527$858C,52>8=$?>2=4=7;$@725J7

9K7=@$<K=4D@78$?@52$9K>9$;<K554o

==d$ ($ 4>@L7$ <58<789@>9=58$ 5?$ ;9AD789;$ ?@52$ 45I

;5<=5C7<5852=<$ 47J74;$ >8D$ =44=97@>97$ ?>2=4=7;

2>P7;$ ;<K554;$ 45I7@$ 9K7=@$ ;9>8D>@D;M$ ;5$ 9K>9

;527$858C,52>8=$?>2=4=7;$9>P7$9K7=@$<K=4D@78$95

;<K554;$9K>9$K>J7$[25@7$35;;=N=4=9=7;\o

===d$ !K7$?><9$9K>9$?>2=4=7;$<58<7@87D$>N5A9$9K7=@$<K=4C

D@78X;$ 7DA<>9=58$ 47>J7$ 9K5;7$ ;<K554;$ 2>P7;

9K5;7$ ;<K554;X$ ;9>8D>@D;$ 7J78$ 45I7@M$ >8D$ 9K7

?><9$ 9K>9$ 97><K=8L$ ;9>??$ <K>8L7;$ <58;9>8946

>LL@>J>97;$ 9K=;$ ;=9A>9=58O$ B58;7TA78946M$ 9K7

@72>=8=8L$?>2=4=7;$IK5;7$<K=4D@78$K>D$@72>=87D

=8$ 9K5;7$ ;<K554;$ >8D$ >@7$ <58<7@87D$ >N5A9$ 9K7

;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ 9K7$ 7DA<>9=58>4$ =8;9=9A9=58$ @725J7

9K7=@$ <K=4D@78M$ =8<4AD=8L$ ;527$ ,52>8=$ ?>2=4=7;

IK5$>@7$I5@@=7D$>N5A9$9K7=@$<K=4D@78X;$?A9A@7O

5;" !K=;$ ;=9A>9=58$ K>;$ 47D$ 95$ 9K7$ <45;A@7$ 5?$ ;527

;<K554;O$ &8$ ;527$ <>;7;M$ 9I5$ ;<K554;$ K>J7$ <45;7D

D5I8$<58;7<A9=J746$I=9K=8$>$?7I$67>@;M$>8D$9K7$;9@58L

978D78<6$95$<58<789@>97$,52>$<K=4D@78$=8$5846$>$?7I

;<K554;$=;$7J=D789$?@52$9K7$D>9>$<5447<97D$=8$->D@=Dj

[!K7@7$ >@7$ RYG$ 3@=2>@6$ ;9>97$ ;<K554;$ =8$->D@=DM$ ?=J7$ 5?

IK=<K$L>9K7@$25@7$9K>8$YGl$5?$>44$,52>8=$;9AD789;O !K7

587$ I=9K$ 9K7$ K=LK7;9$ 37@<789>L7$ K>;$ fHl$ cOOOdM&IK=<K

<47>@46$ J=54>97;$ 9K7$ 85@2$ 9K>9$ ;9=3A4>97;$ 9K>9$ A8D7@3@=J=C

47L7D$ ;9AD789;$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ 7TA>446$ D=;9@=NA97D$ =8$ >44

;<K554;O$!K=;$3@5N472$=;$7J78$I5@;7$=8$9K7$<>;7$5?$3@=J>97

;<K554;O$)?$>$959>4$5?$RZYMGGG$3@=2>@6$>8D$;7<58D>@6$;9AC

D789;$=8$3@=J>97$;<K554;M$5846$hhh$>@7$,52>M$K>4?$5?$IK52

>@7$=8$@727D=>4$7DA<>9=58O\HH

5=" ,><=>4$;7L@7L>9=58$=8$7DA<>9=58$=;$>4;5$@735@97D

?@52$+@>8<7M$>49K5ALK$9K7$<52347Q$9@7>92789$5?$79KC

8=<=96$I=9K=8$>$;9@58L$@73AN4=<>8$=D7545L6M$>;$I744$>;

59K7@$?><95@;M$<58;3=@7;$95$@78D7@$D7N>97$58$9K7$;ANC

W7<9$D=??=<A49O$,7;7>@<K7@;$@735@9$J7@6$K=LK$ 47J74;$5?

,52>8=$ >8D$ !@>J7447@$ <K=4D@78$ =8$ a;37<=>4$ 3AN4=<

;<K554;$?5@$<K=4D@78$I=9K$47>@8=8L$5@$>D>39>9=58$D=??=C

<A49=7;a$ >;$I744$ >;$ =8$ =8?5@2>446$ <58;9=9A97D$ a/63;6

<4>;;7;a$=8$5@D=8>@6$;<K554;O$($8A2N7@$5?$9K7;7$>@7

<5235;7D$ >425;9$ 7Q<4A;=J746$ 5?$ /63;6$ <K=4D@78$ ]

7=9K7@$DA7$95$9K7=@$45<>9=58$=8$>8$>@7>$=8$IK=<K$/63;6

<522A8=9=7;$>@7$;73>@>97D$?@52$9K7$@7;9$5?$9K7$353C

A4>9=58M$ 5@$ DA7$ 95$ 9K7$ ?><9$ 9K>9$ 59K7@$ 3>@789;$ K>J7

@725J7D$9K7=@$<K=4D@78$?@52$;A<K$;<K554;O

5A" %<K554=8L$ >A9K5@=9=7;$ =8$ ;527$ <5A89@=7;$ CC

859>N46$0782>@P$ CC$K>J7$ =8$ @7<789$67>@;$D7;=L87D

;<K554=8L$ 3@5J=;=58;$ ?5@$ a,52>8=$ 3A3=4;$IK5$ <>8C

859$N7$<589>=87D$=8$85@2>4$<4>;;7;$5@$;37<=>4$<4>;;C

7;aO$(;=D7$?@52$9K7$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$<K>@><97@$5?$;A<K

;<K554=8L$3@5J=;=58;$>8D$9K7$7259=58>4$K>@2$9K76

2>6$ <>A;7$ 9K7$ <K=4D@78$ =8$ 9K72M$ 9K7@7$ =;$ ?=@2

@7;7>@<K$7J=D78<7$9K>9$9K7$47J74$>8D$TA>4=96$5?$3@5C

J=;=58$ ?5@$ 3A3=4;$ >9978D=8L$ ;7L@7L>97D$ ,52>

;<K554;$ =;$ 2>@P7D46$ =8?7@=5@$ 95$ 9K>9$ ?5@$ 59K7@

L@5A3;OHY

5B" ,7;7>@<K$7J=D78<7$?@52$S>47;$>8D$*5@9K7@8

&@74>8D$=8$9K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52$@7J7>4;$7Q>2347;$5?

;7L@7L>97D$ 7DA<>9=58>4$ 3@5J=;=58$ ?5@$ /63;6$ >8D

!@>J7447@$<K=4D@78O$(49K5ALK$7DA<>9=58>4$354=<6$=8$9K7

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

HF #,,Be#'-(1M$ ag5=89$#'$-58=95@=8L$>8D$(DJ5<><6$1@5L@>2$e$#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@$%K>D5I$,735@9$1@5J=D7D$95$9K7

B522=9977$58$9K7$#4=2=8>9=58$5?$0=;<@=2=8>9=58$(L>=8;9$S5278$B522789=8L$58$9K7$?=?9K$37@=5D=<$@735@9$5?$9K7$+7D7@>4$,73ANC

4=<$5?$/7@2>86$%AN2=997D$A8D7@$(@9=<47$Rf$5?$9K7$'8=97D$*>9=58;$B58J789=58$58$9K7$#4=2=8>9=58$5?$(44$+5@2;$5?$0=;<@=2=8>9=58

>L>=8;9$S5278aM$g>8A>@6$hM$FGGHM$UAD>37;9O

HE B>N>87;$"7@8w8D7_M$g5;vj$[/=9>85;$78$4>$7;<A74>j$A8>$@7>4=D>D$<>2N=>897\$78$!"#$%&'$%()*+O ,*-(.'&"'/(0*.'/&1"2*"(+-*.'(3&$(4+

3('&+&5 c[!K7$,52>$ =8$ ;<K554j$ ($BK>8L=8L$,7>4=96\$ =8$ !" #$%&'$%()*+5"67&/'*/18"9&3&:(+*" ;<" ,;0&" ='72(*.d$ *5O$ FhO$ &8;9=9A95

,52>8xO$U>@<7458>M$FGGGO$3OFZO

HH V=44>@@7>4M$+7@8>8D5$6$S>L2>8M$0>8=74j$/=9>85;$6$D=;<@=2=8><=y8O$'8$7;9AD=5$9@>8;8><=58>4O c!K7$,52>$>8D$0=;<@=2=8>9=58O$(

!@>8;8>9=58>4$%9AD6d$+A8D><=y8$%7<@79>@=>D5$/787@>4$/=9>85O->D@=DM$FGGRO$3OEZO

HY !K7$@7;7>@<K$<>@@=7D$5A9$A8D7@$9K7$,@(g#$1@5L@>227$c,52>$,=LK9;$>8D$(<<7;;$95$gA;9=<7$=8$#A@537d$=8$UA4L>@=>M$<47>@46$=44A;C

9@>97D$9K7;7$D=;<@73>8<=7;$=8$97@2;$5?$L@5;;46$D=??7@789=>4$47J74;$5?$><K=7J72789O$B522=;;=58$E$5?$9K7$(DJ=;5@6$(AD=9$B522=;C

;=58M$%5?=>M$UA4L>@=>$FGGFeEO$,52>8=$U>K9$+5A8D>9=58O

Page 26: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

'`$=;$9K7$5846$;7<95@>4$?=74D$9K>9$;37<=?=<>446$=8<4AD7;

,52>$=8$9K7$3@5<7;;$5?$258=95@=8L$>8D$7J>4A>9=58M

9K7$><K=7J72789$5?$,52>$3A3=4;$=8$;<K554$=;$=8$J7@6

2>@P7D$ <589@>;9$ 95$ 9K7$ ><K=7J72789;$ 5?$ >44$ 59K7@

2=85@=96$79K8=<$L@5A3;OHZ

5!" &8$9K7$?=74D$5?$4=?7458L$47>@8=8LM$9K7@7$=;$<A@@789C

46$>$?>=4A@7$N6$-72N7@$%9>97;$95$=D789=?6$,52>$>;$>

354=<6$ 9>@L79$ L@5A3O$ !KA;M$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M$ D7;3=97$ >

,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58$ 5?$ >9$ 47>;9$ RGGMGGGM$ 2>86$ 5?

IK52$?><7$J7@6$;7@=5A;$3@5N472;$=8$><<7;;=8L$7DAC

<>9=58M$ 9K7$ &9>4=>8$ L5J7@82789M$ =8$ =9;$ 25;9$ @7<789

@735@9$95$9K7$B522=;;=58$58$9K7$=23472789>9=58$5?

4=?7458L$47>@8=8L$;9@>97L=7;M$D=D$859$=D789=?6$,52>$c5@

=8D77D$ >86$ 79K8=<$ L@5A3dM$ ;9>9=8LM$ a!K7$ 27>;A@7;

>DD@7;;7D$95$L@5A3;$>9$@=;P$5?$;5<=>4$>8D$<A49A@>4$2>@C

L=8>4=;>9=58M$<5C?=8>8<7D$N6$9K7$#%+$=8$N59K$9K7$<78C

9@>4$85@9K$>8D$;5A9K7@8$@7L=58;M$=8<4AD7$=897@J789=58;

?5@$2=L@>89;M$5??78D7@;M$9K7$D=;>N47DM$D=;>DJ>89>L7D

L@5A3;$=8$L787@>4M$>8D$I5278OaH^ )9K7@$<5A89@=7;$?>=4C

=8L$95$2>P7$@7?7@78<7$95$,52>$=8$9K7=@$4=?7458L$47>@8C

=8L$ ;9@>97L6$ 3@5L@7;;$ @735@9;$ =8<4AD7$ /7@2>86M

154>8DM$%I7D78$>8D$9K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52OHf

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

HZ 073>@92789$?5@$#DA<>9=58$>8D$%P=44;M$.58D58O$#9K8=<$258=95@=8L$1.(%B$D>9>M$FGGHO$K993jeeIIIOD?7;OL5JOAPe@;L>97I>6e0Ue%+,e

;GGGHHfe=8D7QO;K924O

H^$ #A@537>8$B522=;;=58M$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$#DA<>9=58$>8D$BA49A@7M$a&23472789=8L$.=?7458L$.7>@8=8L$%9@>97L=7;$=8$#A@537j$1@5L@7;;

@735@9$58$9K7$?5445ICA3$95$9K7$FGGF$B5A8<=4$ @7;54A9=58O,7346$ 95$9K7$B522=;;=58$TA7;9=588>=@7M$ &9>46aM$U@A;;74;M$07<72N7@$FGGEM

3ORR^O

Hf$ -72N7@$ %9>97;b$ 3@5L@7;;$ @735@9;$ >@7$ >J>=4>N47$ 58$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ I7N;=97$ >9j$ K993jee7A@53>O7AO=89e<522e

7DA<>9=58e354=<=7;eFGRGe444p78OK924O

%9>@9=8L$=8$9K7$;<K554$67>@$FGGGCFGGRM$,52>8=$<K=4C

D@78$?@52$9K7$*5J$1>9$,52>8=$;799472789$=8$V=D=8M

UA4L>@=>M$ N7L>8$ >9978D=8L$ 858C;7L@7L>97D$ ;<K554;

>;$>$@7;A49$5?$45<>4$>8D$=897@8>9=58>4$858CL5J7@8278C

9>4$ =8=9=>9=J7;O$!K7$[V=D=8$3@5W7<9\M$ 9K7$ ?=@;9$,52>8=C

47D$ ;<K554$ D7;7L@7L>9=58$ =8=9=>9=J7$ =8$ B789@>4$ >8D

#>;97@8$ #A@537M$ N7L>8$IK78$ @5ALK46$ EGG$ ,52>8=

<K=4D@78M$?@52$9K7$>44C,52>8=$;<K554$=8$9K7$*5J$1>9

;799472789$=8$V=D=8M$N7L>8$>9978D=8L$;=Q$2>=8;9@7>2

;<K554;$=8$95I8O$!K7$78@542789$5?$,52>8=$<K=4D@78

=8$ 9K7$2=Q7D$;<K554;$ =8$V=D=8$I>;$3@7<7D7D$N6$>8

=8978;=J7$ >DJ5<><6$ <>23>=L8$ >258L$ 9K7$ 45<>4

,52>8=$>8D$858C,52>8=$<522A8=9=7;M$7DA<>9=58>4

>A9K5@=9=7;$>8D$9K7$45<>4$>D2=8=;9@>9=58O$&8$9K7$FGGGC

FGGE$37@=5DM$9K7$3@5L@>227$K>;$;A<<7;;?A446$=897C

L@>97D$5J7@$ZGG$;9AD789;O

'8D7@$9K7$3@5W7<9M$;9AD789;$>@7$NA;7D$?@52$9K7

;799472789$ 95$ ;<K554$ >8D$N><P$ >8D$ 9K5;7$5?$ 9K72

IK5$877D$95$<>9<K$A3$I=9K$9K7=@$377@;M$@7<7=J7$;A3C

3472789>@6$<4>;;7;$>9$;<K554O$!K7$3@5W7<9$ =8J54J7;

,52>$;A37@J=;5@;$IK5$=897@><9$I=9K$3>@789;$>8D$9K7

;<K554$95$78<5A@>L7$>9978D>8<7O$,73@7;789>9=J7;$5?

9K7$0,)-$5@L>8=;>9=58M$IK=<K$=23472789;$9K7$3@5WC

7<9M$ >@7$ =8$ <58;9>89$ <589><9$I=9K$ 9K7$ ,52>8=$ <K=4C

D@78$>8D$258=95@$9K7=@$=897L@>9=58$=8$9K7$;<K554;O

!K7$;A<<7;;$95$D>97$5?$9K7$3@5L@>2$=;$>99@=NA9C

N47$95$>$8A2N7@$5?$?><95@;O$+=@;9M$ 9K7$,52>8=$<K=4C

D@78$>@7$K>336$95$N7$=8$;<K554;$IK7@7$@7>4$47>@8=8L

9>P7;$ 34><7$ >8D$ 95$ N7$ >258L$ 858C,52>8=$ 377@;O

%7<58DM$ 9K7$ D7;7L@7L>9=58$ 3@5<7;;$ K>;$ N778

5@L>8=;7D$ >8D$ 258=95@7D$ N6$ >$ ,52>8=$ 5@L>8=;>C

9=58M$<@7>9=8L$K=LK$47J74;$5?$9@A;9$58$9K7$3>@9$5?$9K7

,52>8=$3>@789;O$+=8>446M$9K7$;<K554;$K>J7$><<7397D

=8CK5A;7$ ,52>$ ;A37@J=;5@;$ IK5$ 78;A@7$ 9K>9$ 9K7

<K=4D@78$>@7$9@7>97D$7TA>446$>8D$I=9K$@7;37<9O$%=8<7

9K7$3@5W7<9$;9>@97D$=8$V=D=8$=9$K>;$N778$7Q3>8D7D$95

;7J78$25@7$<=9=7;$=8$UA4L>@=>O

!K=;$=8=9=>4$25D74$5?$D7;7L@7L>9=58$;K5A4DM$K5IC

7J7@M$N7$;778$>;$>$;973$ =8$9K7$@=LK9$D=@7<9=58$@>9K7@

9K>8$>8$78D$=8$=9;74?O$.58L7@$97@2$>8D$@5NA;9$258=95@C

=8L$>8D$7J>4A>9=58$>@7$<@=9=<>4$95$78;A@7$9K>9$9K7$TA>4C

=96$5?$9K7$7DA<>9=58>4$7Q37@=78<7$5?$9K7$,52>$3A3=4;

2>9<K7;$9K5;7$><<7397D$;9>8D>@D;$<523>9=N47$I=9K

@><7$7TA>4=96$=8$7DA<>9=58O$!K>9$=;M$9K>9$354=<6$=;$;A;C

9>=8>N47o$ 9K>9$ >D7TA>97$ 47J74;$ 5?$ 9@>=8=8L$ >@7$2>=8C

9>=87Do$9K>9$>9978D>8<7$>8D$><K=7J72789$5A9<527;

>@7$>9$3>@=96$I=9K$9K7$>J7@>L7$?5@$>44$3A3=4;o$9K>9$=8$9K7

=897@7;9;$ 5?$ 7TA>4$ 9@7>92789M$ 858C,52>$ 3A3=4;$ >@7

>4;5$ NA;7D$ 95$ 78;A@7$ >$ @><=>4$ 2=Q$ ><@5;;$ >44$ 9K7

;<K554;$=8$9K7$<522A8=96$>8D$9K>9$78K>8<7D$=8J7;9C

2789$=;$D=@7<97D$95I>@D;$9K7$;<K554;$IK=<K$@72>=8

5378$=8$9K7$,52>$;799472789;O

+$3+#V(3#5"#0KQJJ>#<?F?WE?WHGIJX#IX#VS>WHEIH

Page 27: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

5," !K7$>N5J7$7Q>2347;$3@5J=D7$25@7$9K>8$;A??=C

<=789$7J=D78<7$5?$,52>$7Q<4A;=58$?@52$2>=8;9@7>2

7DA<>9=58M$>8D$><9=58$=;$@7TA=@7D$?@52$N59K$8>9=58>4

L5J7@82789;$>8DM$IK7@7$>33@53@=>97M$9K7$#'O$/=J78

9K7$<789@>4=;7D$8>9A@7$5?$;<K554$;6;972;$=8$#A@537M

8>9=58>4$7DA<>9=58$-=8=;9@=7;$2A;9$47>D$=8$D7;=L8=8L

354=<=7;$9K>9$3@52597$=897L@>97D$7DA<>9=58$?5@$,52>

>8D$=8$78;A@=8L$9K>9$9K=;$=;$?=@246$@5597D$=8$;9@>97L=7;

>=27D$>9$ @><7$7TA>4=96$5A9<527;O$(;$ <58<7@8;$ 9K7

=235@9>89$>@7>$5?$3@=2>@6$>8D$;7<58D>@6$7DA<>9=58M

P76$5NW7<9=J7;$5?$354=<6$;K5A4D$=8<4AD7j

q$ .7L>4$ >8D$>D2=8=;9@>9=J7$ ;9@A<9A@7;$ 9K>9$ ;7<A@7

A8K=8D7@7D$ ><<7;;$ 95$ 2>=8;9@7>2$ 7DA<>9=58>4

5335@9A8=9=7;o

q$ !K7$ 7;9>N4=;K2789$ 5?$ 7??=<=789$ >@@>8L72789;$ 95

>DD@7;;$ >86$ N>@@=7@;$ 95$ @7LA4>@$ ;<K554$ >9978C

D>8<7o

q$ &897L@>9=58$ CC$ 9K>9$ =;M$ ;<K554;$;K5A4D$859$ ;7L@7C

L>97$ >8D$ 9K76$ ;K5A4D$ =8<4AD7$ ><9=J7$ 7472789;

>=27D$>9$<52N>9=8L$7Q=;9=8L$@><=>4$;7L@7L>9=58o

q$ %AN;9>89=>4$ >8D$ <523@7K78;=J7$ ;A335@9$ c>8DM

IK7@7$@747J>89M$?A@9K7@$7DA<>9=58$>8D$@79@>=8=8Ld$95

>44$ 34>67@;$ =8$ 9K7$ 7DA<>9=58$ 3@5<7;;M$ =8<4AD=8L

97><K7@;M$>D2=8=;9@>95@;M$,52>8=$>8D$858C,52>8=

<K=4D@78M$>8D$,52>8=$>8D$858C,52>8=$3>@789;o

q$ %9@58L$7472789;$I=9K=8$9K7$?5@2>4$>8D$=8?5@2>4$<A@C

@=<A4A2$9K>9$3@52597$>89=C@><=;2$>8D$>89=CNA446=8Lo

q$ !K7$ 3@5J=;=58$ 5?$ >44$ 87<7;;>@6$ @7;5A@<7;

@7TA=@7D$95$;7<A@7$@><=>4$7TA>4=96$ =8$7DA<>9=58>4

5A9<527;o

q$ #8K>8<7D$3@7C;<K554$ 7DA<>9=58$ ?5@$ >$2=8=2A2

5?$9I5$67>@;$?5@$>44$,52>8=$<K=4D@78o

q$ )J7@<52=8L$ N>@@=7@;$ N79I778$ ,52>$ >8D$ 858C

,52>$>8D$9K7$3@5259=58$5?$L55D$@><7$@74>9=58;o

q$ 1@5J=D=8L$<A@@=<A4A2$2>97@=>4;$58$9K7$=235@9>89

<589@=NA9=58;$,52>$K>J7$2>D7$95$9K7$;5<=79=7;

5?$#A@537$CC$>8D$=8$3>@9=<A4>@$95$9K7$;5<=796$5?$9K7

=8D=J=DA>4$<5A89@6O$&8$9K7$=897@7;9;$5?$@544=8L$N><P

<A@@78946$K=LK$47J74;$5?$>89=C,52>8=$;789=2789$=8

#A@537M$=9$=;$<@A<=>4$9K>9$9K7;7$2>97@=>4;$N7$A;7D

=8$>44$;<K554;M$859$5846$=8$;<K554;$IK7@7$,52>8=

<K=4D@78$3@7D52=8>97o

q$ 1@5J=D=8L$>D7TA>9746$?5@$<A49A@>4$7DA<>9=58$>N5A9

,52>$]$ =8<4AD=8L$,52>8=$ 4>8LA>L7M$K=;95@6$>8D

<A49A@7$]$?5@$N59K$,52>8=$>8D$858C,52>8=O

5-" +=8>446M$=9$;K5A4D$N7$8597D$9K>9$>$8A2N7@$5?$;9>97;

K>J7$@7<78946$>D5397D$3@><9=<7;$5?$3@5J=D=8L$;<K54>@C

;K=3$?A8D=8L$95$,52>8=$;9AD789;$>9$A8=J7@;=96M$>8D$=8

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 28: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

;527$<>;7;$ ;7<58D>@6C;<K554$ 47J74O$ (9$ 47>;9$ 3>@946

>;$>$@7;A49$5?$9K7;7$354=<=7;M$9K7$8A2N7@$5?$,52>$>9

A8=J7@;=96$K>;$=8<@7>;7D$<58;=D7@>N46$=8$@7<789$67>@;

=8$;527$#'$-72N7@$%9>97;$c3>@9=<A4>@46$=8$;527$5?

9K7$87I$-72N7@$%9>97;dO$!K7;7$>8D$;=2=4>@$354=<=7;

;K5A4D$N7$@734=<>97D$=8$<5A89@=7;$IK7@7$9K76$D5$859

7Q=;9$>8D$N7$?A8D7D$95$9K7$47J74$@7TA=@7DO

54" (9$9K7$#'$47J74M$>8D$859I=9K;9>8D=8L$#'$;ANC

;=D=>@=96$ 3@=8<=347;M$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ #'$ 3@5L@>227;

<47>@46$K>J7$>$D=@7<9$@547$95$34>6$=8$<@7>9=8L$9K7$<58D=C

9=58;$?5@$ =897L@>97D$7DA<>9=58O$ &8$>DD=9=58$95$;799=8L

D>9>$ >8D$ ?@>27I5@P$ <58D=9=58;$ ?5@$ 9K7$ D7;=L8$ 5?

8>9=58>4$354=<6M$>$8A2N7@$5?$'8=58$3@5L@>227;$2>6

N7$ A;7D$ 95$ L787@>97$ ;5<=>4$ <K>8L7$ =8$ 9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?

,52>$7DA<>9=58O$ !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58b;$0=@7<95@>97

/787@>4$ ?5@$#DA<>9=58$>8D$BA49A@7$2>8>L7;$>$I=D7

J>@=796$ 5?$ 3@5L@>227;$ ;A335@9=8L$ <5537@>9=58

N79I778$-72N7@$%9>97;$>8D$<>8D=D>97$<5A89@=7;$=8

9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?$ 7DA<>9=58M$ 9@>=8=8L$ >8D$ 65A9KO$-5;9$ 5?

9K7;7$3@5L@>227;$3@5J=D7$;<537$?5@$3@5W7<9;$>=2=8L

>9$ =23@5J=8L$,52>$7DA<>9=58$>8D$9@>=8=8L$>8DM$<@AC

<=>446M$>;;=;9=8L$I=9K$L5J7@82789$354=<=7;$95$=897L@>97

7DA<>9=58O$+5@$7Q>2347M$9K7$3@5259=58$5?$=897@<A49A@C

>4$7DA<>9=58M$<5A897@=8L$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58$N6$3@5J=D=8L

;A335@9$95$D=;>DJ>89>L7D$L@5A3;M$=;$>$3@=5@=96$5?$9K7

#A@537>8$ '8=58$ B522A8=96$ (<9=58$ 1@5L@>227$ =8

9K7$?=74D$5?$7DA<>9=58$FGGGCGZ$ci5A9K$3@5L@>227dOHh

;6"S=9K=8$9K7$;<537$5?$9K=;$3@5L@>227M$9K7$;9>9C

7D$5NW7<9=J7;$5?$9K7$B5278=A;$(<9=58$c;<K554$7DA<>C

9=58d$ =8<4AD7$ 9K7$ 3@5259=58$ 5?$ =897@<A49A@>4

>I>@787;;$9K@5ALK$9@>8;8>9=58>4$><9=J=9=7;$D7;=L87D

95$?=LK9$@><=;2$>8D$Q7853K5N=>$>8D$=23@5J7$9K7$7DAC

<>9=58$5?$<K=4D@78$5?$2=L@>89$I5@P7@;M$5<<A3>9=58>4

9@>J7447@;M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;O$($@>8L7$5?$9@>8;8>C

9=58>4$3@5W7<9;$58$,52>$7DA<>9=58$>8D$9@>=8=8L$>@7M

5@$K>J7$N778M$;A335@97D$ =8$ @7<789$67>@;$I=9K=8$ 9K7

%5<@>97;$ c;<K554M$ K=LK7@$ >8D$ >DA49$ 7DA<>9=58d$ >8D

.758>@D5$ D>$ V=8<=$ cJ5<>9=58>4$ 9@>=8=8Ld$ B522A8=96

(<9=58$ 1@5L@>227;M$ >;$ I744$ >;$ 9K7$ i5A9K$ 3@5C

L@>227O$,52>C;37<=?=<$9@>8;8>9=58>4$3@5W7<9;$?A8DC

7D$ 95$ D>97$ K>J7$ >DD@7;;7D$ J>@=5A;$ 9K727;$ >8D

>@7>;M$=8<4AD=8L$;<K554$>9978D>8<7$47J74;$>8D$TA>4=96

5?$ 7DA<>9=58M$ =897@<A49A@>4$ 7DA<>9=58$ >8D$ D=>45LA7M

97><K7@$9@>=8=8L$>8D$,52>$27D=>95@;M$>8D$9K7$7DAC

<>9=58>4$877D;$5?$,52>$95$=23@5J7$9K7=@$723456>N=4C

=96$>8D$>N=4=96$95$7897@$5@$@7C7897@$?5@2>4$7DA<>9=58O

;5" !K7$ #'$ K>;$ =8$ 9K7$ 3>;9$ =;;A7D$ @7;54A9=58;

@74>97D$7Q34=<=946$ 95$,52>O &8$RhfhM$ 9K7$B5A8<=4$ 5?

-=8=;97@;$ 5?$ #DA<>9=58$ >D5397D$ ,7;54A9=58$ fheB

RYEeGF$[)8$%<K554$1@5J=;=58$?5@$/63;6$>8D$!@>J7447@

BK=4D@78\O$!K7$Rhfh$,7;54A9=58$I>;$D@>?97D$I=9K$@7?C

7@78<7$ 95$ 9K7$ <=@<A2;9>8<7;$ 5?$ 9K7$ 852>D=<

,52>e/63;6$>8D$!@>J7447@$353A4>9=58$5?$ 9K7$-72C

N7@$%9>97;$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$>9$9K>9$9=27O$&8$9K7

?@>27I5@P$5?$>$87I46$784>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58M$9K7

'8=58$ =8;9=9A9=58;$ ;K5A4D$ @7J=;=9$ #'$ ;9@>97L=7;$ 58

9K7$ 7DA<>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>8=$ <K=4D@78M$ 9>P=8L$ =895

><<5A89$ =8$ 3>@9=<A4>@$ 9K7$ 877D$ ?5@$ 9K5@5ALKCL5=8L

27>;A@7;$95$<52N>9$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$@><=>4

;7L@7L>9=58$=8$9K7$7DA<>9=58>4$;6;972O$!5$9K7$7Q9789

9K>9$ #A@537>8$ %5<=>4$ +A8D;$ >@7$ >4;5$ A;7D$ 95$ <5C

?=8>8<7$ 7DA<>9=58>4$ =8=9=>9=J7;$ =8$ -72N7@$ %9>97;M

9K7$ #%+$ LA=D74=87;$2=LK9$ >4;5$ ;9@7;;$ 9K7$ 877D$ 95

3A@;A7$9K7$=;;A7$5?$,52>M$/63;6$>8D$!@>J7447@$7DAC

<>9=58M$>8D$9K7$877D$95$>DD@7;;$9K7$=;;A7$?@52$3@7C

;<K554$9K@5ALK$95$>DA49$7DA<>9=58O

$%&'()%$*+

;;" (9$ 9K7$.=;N58$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4M$ 9K7$#A@537>8

'8=58$ ;79$ =9;74?$ 9K7$ L5>4$ 5?$ N7<52=8L$ a9K7$ 25;9

<52379=9=J7$>8D$D68>2=<$P85I47DL7CN>;7D$7<585C

26$ =8$ 9K7$I5@4DM$ <>3>N47$5?$ ;A;9>=8>N47$7<5852=<

L@5I9K$I=9K$25@7$>8D$N7997@$W5N;$>8D$L@7>97@$;5<=>4

<5K7;=58aO$!K7$;9@>97L6$I>;$D7;=L87D$95$78>N47$9K7

'8=58$95$@7L>=8$9K7$<58D=9=58;$?5@$?A44$7234562789

>8D$ 95$ ;9@78L9K78$ <5K7;=58$ N6$ FGRGO$ !K7$ B5A8<=4

>4;5$<58;=D7@7D$9K>9$9K7$5J7@>44$>=2$5?$9K7;7$27>;C

A@7;$;K5A4D$N7$95$@>=;7$9K7$5J7@>44$#'$7234562789

@>97$95$^Gl$>8D$95$=8<@7>;7$9K7$8A2N7@$5?$I5278

=8$ 7234562789$ 95$ 25@7$ 9K>8$ ZGl$ N6$ FGRGO$ !K7

%95<PK542$ #A@537>8$ B5A8<=4$ c->@<K$ FGGRd$ >DD7D

9I5$ =897@27D=>97$ >8D$ 587$ >DD=9=58>4$ 9>@L79;j$ 9K7

7234562789$@>97$;K5A4D$N7$@>=;7D$95$Z^l$5J7@>44$N6

FGGYM$Y^l$?5@$I5278$N6$FGGY$>8D$YGl$?5@$54D7@

I5@P7@;$ N6$ FGRGO$ !K7$ U>@<7458>$ B5A8<=4$ c->@<K

FGGFd$<58?=@27D$9K>9$?A44$7234562789$I>;$9K7$5J7@C

>@<K=8L$L5>4$ 5?$ 9K7$#'$>8D$<>447D$ ?5@$ >$ @7=8?5@<7D

#234562789$%9@>97L6$95$A8D7@3=8$9K7$.=;N58$;9@>97C

L6$=8$>8$784>@L7D$#'O

;=" !K7$2>=8$ 9554$ >9$ 9K7$'8=58$ 47J74$ ?5@$ =2347C

2789=8L$ 9K7;7$L5>4;$ =;$ 9K7$#A@537>8$#234562789

%9@>97L6$c##%dOYG `76$7472789;$5?$9K7$##%$=8<4AD7j

""

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Hh 07<=;=58$*5O$RGEReFGGGe#B$5?$RE9K$(3@=4$FGGGO

YG +A@9K7@$ =8?5@2>9=58$ 58$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ #234562789$ %9@>97L6$ =;$ >J>=4>N47$ >9j$ IIIO7A@53>O7AO=89e<522e7234562789p;5<=>4e

7234562789p;9@>97L6e=8D7Qp78OK92O

Page 29: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

q #234562789$ /A=D74=87;j$ ?5445I=8L$ >$ 3@535;>4

?@52$ 9K7$ B522=;;=58M$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B5A8<=4

;K>44$>L@77$7J7@6$67>@$58$>$;7@=7;$5?$LA=D74=87;

;799=8L$5A9$<52258$3@=5@=9=7;$?5@$-72N7@$%9>97

7234562789$354=<=7;o

q *>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8;j$7J7@6$-72N7@$%9>97$;K>44

D@>I$A3$>8$>88A>4$*>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8M$IK=<K

D7;<@=N7;$ K5I$ 9K7;7$ /A=D74=87;$ >@7$ 3A9$ =895

3@><9=<7$8>9=58>446o

q g5=89$#234562789$,735@9j$!K7$B522=;;=58$>8D

9K7$ B5A8<=4$ ;K>44$ W5=8946$ 7Q>2=87$ 7><K$ *>9=58>4

(<9=58$ 14>8$ >8D$ 3@7;789$ >$ g5=89$ #234562789

,735@9O$!K7$B522=;;=58$;K>44$3@7;789$>$87I$3@5C

35;>4$ 95$ @7J=;7$ 9K7$ #234562789$ /A=D74=87;

><<5@D=8L46$?5@$9K7$?5445I=8L$67>@o

q ,7<52278D>9=58;j$ !K7$ B5A8<=4$ 2>6$ D7<=D7M$ N6

TA>4=?=7D$2>W5@=96M$95$=;;A7$<5A89@6C;37<=?=<$,7<52C

278D>9=58;$A358$>$3@535;>4$N6$9K7$B522=;;=58O

;A" 07;3=97$<58;=D7@>N47$7J=D78<7$5?$9K7$35I7@C?A4$@547$5?$@><7$=8$K=8D7@=8L$><<7;;$95$9K7$4>N5A@

2>@P79M$#'$D7<=;=58C2>P7@;$K>J7$859$679$D7J597D

;A??=<=789$ >99789=58$ 95$ 9K7$ 877D$ 95$ 74=2=8>97

A87234562789$>258L$2=85@=96$79K8=<$L@5A3;$>;

>$9>@L79$5?$#'$7234562789$354=<6O

;B" !K7$ @7;A49$ 5?$ 9K7$ #'$859$ 3@5J=D=8L$ ;37<=?=<

LA=D>8<7$ =;$ 7J=D789$ =8$ 9K7$ >N;78<7$ 5?$ ,52>$ >8D

59K7@$L@5A3;$@7L>@D7D$>;$a/63;=7;a$?@52$9K7$*>9=58C

>4$ (<9=58$ 14>8;$ 58$ 7234562789O$ ($ @7J=7I$ 5?$ 9K7

*>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8;$?5@$FGGE$?5@$(A;9@=>M$U74L=A2M

+=84>8DM$ /7@2>86M$ +@>8<7M$ %I7D78M$ %3>=8M$ &@74>8DM

'8=97D$ `=8LD52M$ *79K7@4>8D;M$ >8D$ 15@9AL>4M$ =8D=C

<>97;$9K>9$5?$9K7$<5A89@=7;$4=;97DM$5846$&@74>8D$=8<4ADC

7D$ 2789=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ ca!@>J7447@;a$ =8$ 9K7$ &@74>8D

*>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8$58$7234562789dO

;!" ,52>$>8D$59K7@$L@5A3;$@7L>@D7D$>;$a/63;=7;a

D5M$ K5I7J7@M$ ?><7$ ;=L8=?=<>89$ N>@@=7@;$ =8$ 9K7$ 4>N5A@

2>@P79$>8D$=8$><<7;;=8L$L>=8?A4$7234562789M$>8D$>;

>$ @7;A49$ D=;3@535@9=58>9746$ K=LK7@$ 8A2N7@;$ >@7

A87234567DO$SK7@7$D>9>$58$9K7$34><72789$5?$,52>

58$9K7$4>N5A@$2>@P79$7Q=;9M$J7@6$D=;9A@N=8L$D=;3>@=9=7;

>@7$ >33>@789O$ +5@$ 7Q>2347M5??=<=>4$ D>9>$ ?5@$ 9K7$ E@D

TA>@97@$5?$FGGE$=8D=<>97;$9K>9$>33@5Q=2>9746$f^OYl

5?$ 9K7$ %45J>P$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58$I>;$ A87234567D

DA@=8L$ 9K7$37@=5DM$>;$<523>@7D$I=9K$>8$A8723456C

2789$@>97$5?$RHOFl$?5@$9K7$353A4>9=58$>;$>$IK547O$&8

%3>=8M$K>4?$5?$%3>8=;K$,52>$5?$I5@P=8L$>L7$>@7$7;9=C

2>97D$859$95$K>J7$;9>N47$5@$47L>4$W5N;OYR &8$9K7$B_7<K

,73AN4=<M$ 9K7$ A87234562789$ @>97$ ?5@$ 9K7$ L787@>4

353A4>9=58$I>;$RGOfl$5?$9K7$959>4$I5@P$?5@<7$=8$7>@46

FGGHMYF IK=4;9$ 9K7$ 5??=<=>4$ A87234562789$ @>97$ ?5@

,52>$I>;$7;9=2>97D$95$N7$N79I778$YGl$>8D$fGlOYE

'85??=<=>4$7;9=2>97;M$N>;7D$58$TA>4=?=7D$;5<=545L=<>4

;9AD=7;M$>4;5$=8D=<>97$9K>9$9K7$A87234562789$@>97$?5@

,52>$@>8L7;$N79I778$YGCfGlM$5?$IK=<K$278$<52C

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

+$3+#V(3#;"#9JCH#$CR>JLC?XG#1XIGIHGI@?F#IX#0RHIX

!K7$ (BB#0#,$ 1@5L@>227M$ <5C?=8>8<7D$ N6$ 9K7

#A@537>8$ %5<=>4$ +A8DM$I>;$ =8=9=>97D$ N6$ 9K7$ +A8C

D><=y8$%7<@79>@=>D5$/787@>4$/=9>85$c+%//d$=8$9K7

?@>27I5@P$ 5?$ 9K7$ -A49=C@7L=58>4$ )37@>9=J7$ 1@5C

L@>227$ z+=LK9$ (L>=8;9$ 0=;<@=2=8>9=58X$ =8$ %3>=8O

!K=@9778$ %3>8=;K$ >A958525A;$ @7L=58;$ >8D$25@7

9K>8$ ?5@96$ <=96$ <5A8<=4;$ <544>N5@>97$ =8$ 9K7$ 3@5C

L@>227O$&9;$2>=8$5NW7<9=J7;$>@7$95$3@5J=D7$><<7;;

95$7234562789$?5@$D=;>DJ>89>L7D$L@5A3;$c25;946

,52>d$ 9K@5ALK$>$879I5@P$5?$;37<=>4=;7D$723456C

2789$ 5??=<7;$ 9K>9$ 5??7@$ 9@>=8=8LM$ 27D=>9=58$ >8D

>DJ=;5@6$;7@J=<7;O$(BB#0#,$;9>@97D$=8$FGGG$>8D$=;

DA7$ 95$ ?=8=;K$ =8$FGGZO$!K7@7$>@7$H^$5??=<7;$ =8$HH

2A8=<=3>4=9=7;$>8D$25@7$9K>8$^G$3@=J>97$>8D$3AN4=<

789=9=7;$>@7$9>P=8L$3>@9O$&9;$;9@>97L6$=;$D7;=L87D$95

><K=7J7$9I5$2>W5@$5NW7<9=J7;j

q !K7$D7J74532789$>8D$=23@5J72789$5?$><<7;;

95$7234562789$?5@$,52>

q !K7$3@5259=58$>8D$D7J74532789$5?$87I$W5N;

=8$;7@J=<7$c;d$=8DA;9@=7;O

%=8<7$07<72N7@$FGGE$RZMhZR$375347$K>J7$N778

>;;=;97D$ cZ^l$ I7@7$ ,52>d$ >8D$ hM^HR$ 375347

K>J7$ 7897@7D$ 7234562789O$ !K7$ ;7@J=<7$ ;7<95@

;9>8D;$5A9$]$I=9K$ZZl$5?$>44$<589@><9;$CC$?5445I7D

N6$9K7$=8DA;9@=>4$;7<95@$cR^ldM$<58;9@A<9=58$cRYld

>8D$ >L@=<A49A@7$ cEldO$ (;$ ?>@$ >;$ 9K7$ 478L9K$ 5?

7234562789$ <589@><9;$ =;$ <58<7@87DM$ HYl$ 4>;9

5J7@$E$2589K;$>8D$RGl$5J7@$R$67>@O

!K7$3@5L@>227$K>;$N778$=D789=?=7D$N6$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$%5<=>4$+A8D$>;$>$[<>;7$5?$L55D$3@><9=<7;\$58

9K7$ &897@27D=>97$ #J>4A>9=58$ 5?$ 9K7$ )37@>9=J7$ 1@5C

L@>227$z+=LK9$(L>=8;9$0=;<@=2=8>9=58XO

YR %7<58D$*>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8$?5@$%5<=>4$&8<4A;=58$=8$9K7$`=8LD52$5?$%3>=8O$c(3378D=Q$&O$0=>L85;=;$5?$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$%5<=>4$#Q<4AC

;=58$=8$%3>=8d$-=8=;9@6$5?$.>N5A@$>8D$%5<=>4$(??>=@;M$->D@=DM$FGGEO$3ORHO

YF 1@wJ5M$+7N@A>@6$RGM$FGGHO

YE g5=89$&8<4A;=58$-725@>DA2M$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$FGGEM$3O$ZO

Page 30: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

3@=;7$RGlM$>8D$I5278$<523@=;7$hGlOYH

;," ($ 4>@L7$ 3@535@9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ 9K7$ B_7<K

,73AN4=<$]$>;$74;7IK7@7$]$37@<7=J7$9K7=@$35;=9=58$58

9K7$ 4>N5A@$ 2>@P79$ >;$ D=;>DJ>89>L7D$ N6$ @><=>4$ D=;C

<@=2=8>9=58O$%=Q96C587$37@<789$5?$,52>M$IK78$>;P7D

=?$ 9K76$ K>D$ N778$ @7?A;7D$ 7234562789$ N7<>A;7$ 5?

9K7=@$ 5@=L=8M$ @7;358D7D$ =8$ 9K7$ >??=@2>9=J7O$ &8$ 9I5

?=?9K;$5?$?>2=4=7;M$>9$47>;9$587$5?$9K7$3>@789;$=;$A872C

34567D$>8D$=8$587$9K=@D$5?$?>2=4=7;$587$5?$9K7$3>@789;

=;$9K7$@7<=3=789$5?$>$D=;>N=4=96$378;=58OYY

;-" !K7@7$>@7$<47>@$=8D=<>9=58;$9K>9$@><=>4$D=;<@=2C

=8>9=58$ =;$>$35I7@?A4$ ?5@<7$K=8D7@=8L$ 9K7$><<7;;$5?

,52>$ 95$ 9K7$ 4>N5A@$ 2>@P79O$ +5@$ 7Q>2347M$ 4>N5A@

5??=<7;$ =8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ <5A89@=7;$ K>J7$ ?@7TA78946

@735@97D$ 9K>9$ 7234567@;$ >997239$ 95$ ;AN2=9$ 4=;9=8L;

;9>9=8L$9K>9$a,52>$877D$859$>3346aO$'8?5@9A8>9746M$=8

;527$<>;7;M$4>N5A@$5??=<7;$K>J7$2>@P7D$W5NC;77P7@

4=;9=8L;$?5@$7234567@;$I=9K$9K7$79K8=<=96$5?$ 9K7$37@C

;58$;77P=8L$I5@PM$;A<K$9K>9$359789=>4$7234567@;$<>8

;77$IK5$>@7$a/63;=7;a$c>8D$9K7@7?5@7$859$K=@7$9K72dO

&8$>$8A2N7@$5?$<5A89@=7;M$,52>$K>J7$;A7D$723456C

7@;$?5@$D=;<@=2=8>9=8L$58$@><=>4$L@5A8D;$>8D$859I=9KC

;9>8D=8L$9K7$D=??=<A496$5?$3@5J=8L$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58

?5@$ 9K7$ 3A@35;7;$ 5?$ 47L>4$ ><9=58$ =8$ 9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?

7234562789M$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ 9K7;7$ <>;7;$ K>J7$ N778

@7;54J7D$ =8$ ?>J5A@$ 5?$ 9K7$ 34>=89=??$ >8D$ <5A@9;$ K>J7

;>8<9=587D$ 7234567@;O$ !K7;7$ ;A<<7;;7;$ K>J7$ 859M

K5I7J7@M$ @7DA<7D$I=D7;3@7>D$ @735@9;$5?$ @><=>4$D=;C

<@=2=8>9=58$58$9K7$W5N$2>@P79O$!K7@7$=;$<47>@46$>$877D

95$@7D5AN47$7??5@9;$95$78;A@7$9K7$?A44$=23472789>9=58

5?$7TA>4=96$4>I$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?$7234562789O

;4" #234562789$ 354=<=7;$ >8D$ ;9@>97L=7;$ >9$ 9K7

#'$>8D$-72N7@$%9>97$47J74M$;9>97D$<47>@46M$D=;;72=C

8>97D$I=D746$>8D$258=95@7D$@7LA4>@46M$>@7$>$87<7;C

;>@6$ N>;=;$ ?5@$ 9K7$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 5?$ 2=85@=9=7;M

=8<4AD=8L$,52>O$(33@53@=>97$@7L=58>4$D7J74532789

3@5W7<9;$?5<A;;=8L$58$7234562789$<@7>9=58$>@7$>4;5

@7TA=@7DM$ K5I7J7@M$ 95$ L=J7$ 252789A2$ 95$ 354=<6O

!K=;$=;$3>@9=<A4>@46$;5$=8$>@7>;$IK7@7$,52>8=$A872C

34562789$>8D$35J7@96$3@7J>=4M$>8D$3>@9=<A4>@46$=8$9K7

4=LK9$5?$37@;58>4M$;5<=>4$>8D$7<5852=<$D=;>DJ>89>L7

<>A;7D$N6$458LC97@2$A87234562789O$&8$>@7>;$IK7@7

9K7@7$ =;$ J7@6$ K=LK$ 5@$ 959>4$ A87234562789$ >258L

,52>M$354=<=7;$2A;9$=8<4AD7$7472789;M$>8D$?=8>8<=>4

=8<789=J7;M$ 95$ 78<5A@>L7$ 7234567@;$ 95$ @7<5L8=;7

9K7$ N787?=9;$ 5?$ 723456=8L$ ,52>O$ SK7@7$ ,52>8=

=8D=J=DA>4;$K>J7$N778$A87234567D$?5@$458L$37@=5D;

5?$ 9=27M$ 27>;A@7;$ 2A;9$ =8<4AD7$ 7472789;$ 9K>9

>;;=;9$9K7$9@>8;=9=58$cN><Pd$=895$9K7$I5@P$?5@<7O

=6" !K7$#'$3@5L@>227;$ =89@5DA<7D$ =8$BK>397@

EM$>8D$3@=8<=3>446$9K7$#,0+M$9K7$#%+$>8D$9K7$#s'(.

B522A8=96$ &8=9=>9=J7M$ K>J7$ ?><=4=9>97D$ 3@5W7<9$I5@P

9>@L79=8L$,52>$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?$7234562789$=8$>$8A2C

N7@$ 5?$ -72N7@$ %9>97;O$ ($ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ 9K7;7$ K>J7

N778$ ?=8>8<7D$ 9K@5ALK$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58b;

#s'(.$3@5L@>227M$>8$=8=9=>9=J7$95$3@5J=D7$?A8D=8L

>8D$78<5A@>L72789$?5@$=885J>9=J7$3@5W7<9;$95$?=LK9

D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D$ ;5<=>4$ 7Q<4A;=58$ =8$ 4>N5A@$ 2>@C

P79;O$%=8<7$FGGRM$9K7$#s'(.$3@5L@>227$K>;$?A8DC

7D$ >@5A8D$ HY$ 3@5W7<9;$ IK7@7$ ,52>$ K>J7$ N778

>258L$9K7$N787?=<=>@=7;M$7=9K7@$>;$>$;37<=?=<$9>@L79

L@5A3$ 5@$2>=8;9@7>27D$ >458L;=D7$ 59K7@$ D=;>DJ>8C

9>L7D$L@5A3;$=8$N@5>D7@$3@5L@>227;O$-5;9$5?$9K7

#'$-72N7@$%9>97;M$>8D$N59K$5?$9K7$9I5$<>8D=D>97

<5A89@=7;$ 9K>9$ L>=87D$ ><<7;;$ 95$ 9K7$ #s'(.$ 3@5C

L@>227$=8$FGGFM$K>J7$>9$47>;9$587$5@$9I5$3@5W7<9;

3@5259=8L$ 9K7$ =897L@>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ 9K7$ 4>N5A@

2>@P79O$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ IK7@7$ 85$ ;A<K$ 3@5W7<9;

K>J7$ 679$ N778$ =234727897D$ >@7$0782>@PM$ .AQ72C

N5A@LM$ 9K7$*79K7@4>8D;M$U74L=A2$>8D$+=84>8DO$(4;5

><9=J7$ K>;$ N778$ 9K7$ 0=@7<95@>97$ /787@>4$ ?5@

,7;7>@<K$ >8D$ &885J>9=58M$IK=<K$ K>;$ ?=8>8<7D$ >$ EC

67>@$ @7;7>@<K$3@5W7<9$ cS),`(.)d$ =895$ 9K7$N>@@=7@;

9K>9$7Q<4AD7$,52>$?@52$9K7$#A@537>8$ 4>N5A@$2>@C

P79M$9>P=8L$+@>8<7M$15@9AL>4M$,52>8=>M$%3>=8$>8D$9K7

'`$>;$<>;7$;9AD=7;O$!K7$3@5W7<9$I>;$?=8>8<7D$A8D7@

9K7$Y9K +@>27I5@P$1@5L@>227$cRhhfCFGGFdO

=5" &8$;A22>@6M$7234562789$=;$>258L$9K7$25;9

7;;789=>4$27<K>8=;2;$ ?5@$ ;7<A@=8L$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58O

!K7$537@>9=58$5?$9K7$7234562789$2>@P79$=8$>86$587

;5<=796$3@5J=D7;$>$4=92A;$97;9$5?$=9;$>99=9AD7;$95$@><7

>8D$;5<=>4$WA;9=<7O !K7$@7;7>@<K$K>;$7;9>N4=;K7D$9K>9

9K7@7$ >@7$ ?@7TA78946$ J7@6$ 2>@P7D$ D=??7@78<7;

N79I778$ 9K7$A87234562789$ @>97;$ ?5@$,52>8=$<52C

2A8=9=7;$>8D$59K7@$L@5A3;$I=9K=8$9K7$;>27$;5<=796O

S=D7;3@7>D$ @735@9;$ 5?$ @><=>4$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ =8

7234562789$K>J7$859$ 679$N778$279$I=9K$ >D7TA>97

><9=58$58$9K7$3>@9$5?$L5J7@82789;$>8D$59K7@$>A9K5@=C

9=7;O$1@5W7<9;$95$3@5J=D7$I5@P$95$A87234567D$,52>

K>J7$859$ 679$K>D$>$2>@P7D$ =23><9$58$ 9K7$ 47J74;$5?

?>2=46e<522A8=96$35J7@96$>8D$D7N9M$>8D$=8$2>86$5?

9K7$7Q=;9=8L$,52>C;37<=?=<$7234562789$3@5L@>227;

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

YH V6_PA2$=897@798=<P6<K$J_9>KAj$_3@wJ>M$U@85j$->;>@6P5J>$'8=J7@_=9>M$FGGRO

YY %5A@<7j$%!#-M$,52>8=$<522A8=96$=8$9K7$<=96M$*5J72N7@e$07<72N7@$FGGFM$=8$(8>46_>$;5<=w487$7P5852=<Pv$;=9A><7$@52;Pv

353A4><7$J$B7;Pv$@73AN4=<7$;$8wJ@K6$8>$53>9@$78mM$1@>K>jM$1@>K>j$%5<=5P4ANM$FGGEM$3O$FZGO

Page 31: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

9K7@7$=;$>8$723K>;=;$58$A8;P=447D$2>8A>4$9>;P;$I=9K

2=8=2>4$ 5@$ 85$ 9@>=8=8L$ 5335@9A8=9=7;O$ #234562789

354=<6$=;$>8$A8D7@D7J74537D$;7<95@$=8$>$8A2N7@$5?$9K7

-72N7@$%9>97;$7Q>2=87D$=8$9K=;$;9AD6O

.(/01*2

=;" "5A;=8L$ =;$ <58;=D7@>N46$ 47;;$ D7J74537D$ >;$ >8

>@7>$5?$#A@537>8$'8=58$354=<6$9K>8$59K7@$?=74D;$5?$@74C

7J>8<7$ 95$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58M$ ;A<K$ >;$ 7234562789O

!K7@7$=;$85$;37<=?=<$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$=8$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$'8=58$95$>DD@7;;$K5A;=8L$354=<6$=;;A7;M$K5A;C

=8L$ =;$ 859$ 3@7;78946$ <5J7@7D$ N6$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

,7L=58>4$07J74532789$+A8DM$>8D$9K7@7$=;$@7;=;9>8<7

95$7Q3>8D=8L$#'$<5237978<=7;$=8$9K=;$>@7>M$3>@9=<AC

4>@46$ DA7$ 95$ 9K7$ ?><9$ 9K>9$ K5A;=8L$ =;$ J7@6$ @7;5A@<7C

=8978;=J7O$ !K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ ,><7$ 0=@7<9=J7

7Q34=<=946$ N>8;$ @><=>4$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ =8$ 9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?

K5A;=8LM$K5I7J7@M$>8D$9K7$>D539=58$5?$>$K5A;=8L$=8D=C

<>95@$5@$=8D=<>95@;$A8D7@$9K7$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58$=8D=<>C

95@;$ =;$ A8D7@$ D=;<A;;=58$ I=9K=8$ 9K7$ B522=;;=58$ ]

7Q34=<=9$@7<5L8=9=58$5?$9K7$P76$@547$34>67D$N6$K5A;=8L

=8$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$27>;A@7;O$#Q37@9;$K>J7$8597D$9K>9

IK7@7$ 3@5W7<9;$ K>J7$ N778$ ;A<<7;;?A4M$ K5A;=8L$ K>;

34>67D$>$P76$@547$=8$9K7$=8<4A;=58$5?$,52>$>8D$59K7@

7Q<4AD7D$2=85@=9=7;O$SK78$K5A;=8L$=;$=23@5J7D$95$>

<7@9>=8$ D7L@77M$ 9K7@7$ =;$ ?@7TA78946$ >$ a35=89$ 5?$ 85

@79A@8a$N7658D$IK=<K$=897L@>9=58$3@5<77D;O

==" *7J7@9K747;;M$ =9$ =;$ 5?$ L@>J7$ <58<7@8$ 9K>9

2>86$,52>$9K@5ALK5A9$#A@537$4=J7$=8$;AN;9>8D>@D

5@$ 7Q9@72746$ ;AN;9>8D>@D$ K5A;=8LM$ >8D$ 5?978$ =8

;4A2$LK7995;$5@$;=97$45<>9=58;$<K>@><97@=;7D$N6jYZ

q '8<7@9>=896$5J7@$9K7$5I87@;K=3$5?$4>8D$58$IK=<K

;799472789;$>@7$34><7Do

q ($4><P$5?$;7<A@=96$5?$978A@7$c>8D$I=9K$=9$>$37@2>C

8789$9K@7>9$5?$?5@<7D$7J=<9=58do

q &8>D7TA>97$5@$>N;789$;7I7@>L7M$747<9@=<=96M$4=LK9C

=8L$ >8D$ 359>N47$ I>97@$ ;6;972;M$ >8D$ I>;97

@725J>4M$K7>9M$>8D$9@>8;35@9$;7@J=<7;OY^ &8$;527

7Q9@727$;4A2;M$>44$;A<K$3@5J=;=58;$>@7$4><P=8Lo

q #Q<4A;=58$5@$7Q<7;;=J7$D=;9>8<7$?@52$59K7@$;79C

9472789;M$3AN4=<$;7@J=<7;$;A<K$>;$TA>4=96$;<K554C

=8LM$35;9>4$;7@J=<7;M$K7>49K<>@7$>8D$59K7@$A@N>8

?><=4=9=7;$<@A<=>4$?5@$TA>4=96C5?C4=J=8L$;9>8D>@D;o

q 1@7J>4789$D=;7>;7$>8De5@$9K@7>9;$5?$73=D72=<o

q #Q35;A@7$ 95$ J=54789$354=<7$ @>=D;$>8D$59K7@$ >@N=C

9@>@6$ =89@A;=58;$N>887D$N6$?A8D>2789>4$ =897@8>C

9=58>4$>8D$#A@537>8$KA2>8$@=LK9;$4>I;o

q %7L@7L>9=58$ ?@52$ 59K7@$ <522A8=9=7;$ =8$ >8

=8<@7>;=8L$8A2N7@$5?$;9>97;$c9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<

>8D$ "A8L>@6$ K>J7M$ =235@9>8946M$ ><P85I47DL7D

9K=;$>;$>8$>@7>$5?$<58<7@8dO

=A" "5A;=8L$=;;A7;$?><=8L$,52>$K>J7$>$K=LK$D7L@77

5?$J>@=>N=4=96$><@5;;$<5A89@=7;$>8D$ =8D77D$N79I778

@A@>4M$ A@N>8$ >8D$ ;72=CA@N>8$ 45<>9=58;O$ &8$ ;527

<5A89@=7;M$2>86$,52>$@735@9$9K>9$a9K7$L@5A8D$=;$D=;C

>337>@=8L$ N787>9K$ 5A@$ ?779a$ N7<>A;7$ 5?$ 2>;;=J7

7Q3A4;=58;$5?$,52>$ 9K@5ALK$ ?5@<7D$7J=<9=58;$ ?@52

K5A;=8Le2A8=<=3>4=9=7;M$ >;$ I744$ >;$ N7<>A;7$ 5?$ 9K7

;>47$5?$;5<=>4$K5A;=8L$;95<P;O$+5@<7D$7J=<9=58;$>@7

>4;5$ ?@7TA78946$ @735@97D$ I=9K$ @7;37<9$ 95$ ,52>M

/63;6$ >8D$ !@>J7447@$ ?>2=4=7;$IK5$ @72>=8$ 852>D=<

>8DM$ >;$ >$ <58;7TA78<7$ 5?$ >$ ;K5@9>L7$ 5?$ 5??=<=>4

;=97;M$>@7$?5@<7D$95$<>23$58$A8>A9K5@=;7D$4>8DO

=B" %5<=>4$ K5A;=8L$ ;95<P;$ @735@97D46$ J>@6$ 7Q978C

;=J746$ N79I778$ -72N7@$ %9>97;o$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M$ 9K7

*79K7@4>8D;$ EYlM$ %45J>P=>$ EO^lM$"A8L>@6$ hlM$ >8D

U74L=A2$^lO$!K7@7$=;$>$877D$95$@73478=;K$;5<=>4$K5A;C

=8L$ ;95<P;M$ IK7@7$ 9K7;7$ >@7$ 45IM$ >8D$ 95$ <K7<P$ 9K7

I=D7;3@7>D$ ;>47$ 5?$ ;5<=>4$ K5A;=8L$ ;95<P;$ N6$ 45<>4

>A9K5@=9=7;$ =8$ ;527$<5A89@=7;M$ 859>N46$ =8$ ;527$87I

-72N7@$%9>97;O$!K7$A;7$5?$>@N=9@>@6$<@=97@=>$=8$9K7$>445C

<>9=58$5?$;5<=>4$K5A;=8L$K>;$>4;5$N778$8597DM$>;$K>;

9K7$877D$95$>J5=D$354=<=7;$D=;9=8LA=;K=8L$N79I778$9K7

3A@35@97D$aD7;7@J=8La$>8D$aA8D7;7@J=8La$355@O

=!" !K7@7$ =;$ <A@@78946$ >$ D7N>97$ >;$ 95$ K5I$ 95

>DD@7;;$ 9K7$7Q=;978<7$5?$ ;AN;9>8D>@D$ ;4A2$;79947C

2789;M$I=9K$ =235@9>89$ =8=9=>9=J7;$N7=8L$A8D7@9>P78

N6$)%B#$2=;;=58;$=8$9K7$?5@27@$iAL5;4>J=>M$>;$I744

>;$ N6$ '*$ ">N=9>9$ =8$ =9;$ 3A@;A=9$ 5?$ 9K7$-=44788=A2

07J74532789$/5>4;OYf !K7$#'$1K>@7$3@5L@>227$K>;

=235@9>8946$ 2>D7$ >J>=4>N47$ >$ ;=L8=?=<>89$ 47J74$ 5?

?A8D=8L$ =8$ 9K7$ >@7>$ 5?$ =8?@>;9@A<9A@7$ ?5@$ EG$ ,52>

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

YZ ->86$5?$9K7;7$<=@<A2;9>8<7;$>@7$>4;5$37@9=8789$95$9K7$4=J=8L$<=@<A2;9>8<7;$>8D$45<>9=58;$5?$2>86$,52>$?>2=4=7;$IK5$K>J7$>

852>D=<$4=?7;9647M$;A<K$>;$9K7$;=L8=?=<>89$3@535@9=58$5?$9K7$,52>e/63;6e!@>J7447@$<522A8=9=7;$=8$9K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52O

Y^ #J78$IK7@7$;7@J=<7;$>@7$3@5J=D7DM$9K7;7$>@7$5?978$3@5N472>9=<O$+5@$7Q>2347M$<52258$I>97@$2797@;$K>J7$47D$95$2>;;=J7

I>97@$D7N9$>8D$;AN;7TA789$?5@<7D$7J=<9=58$5?$,52>$=8$"A8L>@6O$&8$UA4L>@=>M$747<9@=<=96$3@5J=D7@;$I=9KD@7I$;7@J=<7;$>?97@

,52>$?>=47D$95$3>6$D7N9;$><<@A=8L$>;$>$@7;A49$5?$<52258$747<9@=<=96$2797@;$?5@$J7@6$4>@L7$8A2N7@;$5?$=8D=J=DA>4;O$S=9KD@>I>4

5?$;7@J=<7;$K>;$47D$95$@=59=8L$N6$,52>$58$;527$5<<>;=58;O

Yf !>@L79$RR$5?$9K7$-=4478=A2$07J74532789$/5>4;$=;$95j$aU6$FGFGM$95$K>J7$><K=7J7D$>$;=L8=?=<>89$=23@5J72789$=8$9K7$4=J7;$5?$>9$47>;9

RGG$2=44=58$;4A2$DI7447@;aO

Page 32: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

;799472789;$?5@$%45J>P=>O$!K7@7$>@7$>4;5$>$8A2N7@$5?

<A@@789$ 3@5W7<9;$ =8$ 9K7$ 54D$ #'$-72N7@$ %9>97;$ >;

I744$>;$=8$9K7$87I$-72N7@$%9>97;$9K>9$2>6$7J789AC

>446$<58;9=9A97$L55D$3@><9=<7M$>49K5ALK$=9$2>6$>;$679

N7$955$7>@46$95$>;;7;;$9K7=@$458LC97@2$=23><9M$L=J78

9K7=@$@7<789$;9>@9=8L$D>97;O

=," &8$>DD@7;;=8L$9K7$=;;A7$5?$;4A2$;799472789;M

9K7@7$7Q=;9;$>$D>8L7@$9K>9$#'$>8D$59K7@$=897@8>9=58>4

?A8D=8L$2>6$N7$N7=8L$A;7D$95$7Q><7@N>97$;3>9=>4$;7LC

@7L>9=58$5?$,52>O$($<58;A49>89$3@5J=D=8L$>8$>;;7;;C

2789$ 5?$ >33@5><K7;$ 95$ ,52>$ K5A;=8L$ =8$ %45J>P=>

8597Dj$a!K7$K5A;=8L$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=;$859$;778$>;

3>@9$5?$9K7$L787@>4$K5A;=8L$354=<6M$NA9$@>9K7@$>;$>$3>@C

9=<A4>@$,52>8=$3@5N472$>8D$9K7@7?5@7$9K7@7$=;$>$978C

D78<6$ 95$ ;54J7$ =9$ =8$ 9K7$ 8>@@5I$ <5897Q9$ 5?$ ,52>

354=<=7;$>8D$3@7?7@>N46$I=9K$ 9K7$ ?=8>8<=>4$>;;=;9>8<7

5?$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58O${OOO|$&8$4>@L7$95I8;$>8D$<=9=7;

=8$3>@9=<A4>@M$=9$<>8$5?978$K>3378$9K>9$,52>$>3346$?5@

;5<=>4$K5A;=8L$>8D$9K76$>@7$859$3@5J=D7D$I=9K$ =9M$5@

9K76$>@7$3@5J=D7D$5846$ =?$ 9K>9$3>@9=<A4>@$2A8=<=3>4=96

K>;$;527$;37<=>4$3@5L@>2$?5@$,52>$K5A;=8LO${OOO|$-6

723=@=<>4$<58<4A;=58$I5A4D$N7$9K>9$,52>$>@7$L=J78

b,52>$ ;5<=>4$ K5A;=8Lb$ >8D$ 9K=;$ L787@>446$ @>D=<>446

N45<P;$>86$=897L@>9=58OaYh$!K7@7$=;$>8$A@L789$877D$=8$>

8A2N7@$ 5?$ <5A89@=7;$ ?5@$ $ =897L@>97D$ >33@5><K7;$ 95

K5A;=8LO$!K=;$877D$=;$3>@9=<A4>@46$3@7;;=8L$>;$?A8D=8L

N7<527;$>J>=4>N47$?5@$,52>$K5A;=8L$3@5W7<9;O

=-" 154=9=<>4$I=44$>9$9K7$8>9=58>4$47J74$>8D$3>@9=<A4>@C

46$ >9$ 9K7$ 45<>4$ 47J74$ =;$ <@A<=>4$ =?$ ,52>M$/63;=7;$ >8D

!@>J7447@;$>@7$ 95$N7$3@5J=D7D$I=9K$>D7TA>97$><<52C

25D>9=58O$&8$9K7$?=74D$5?$K5A;=8LM$9K7$2A8=<=3>4=96$=;

>$P76$><95@O$*>9=58>4$@7LA4>9=58;$>8D$354=<=7;$877D$95

3@5J=D7$ 7Q34=<=9$ LA=D74=87;$ 95$ 9K7$2A8=<=3>4=96$ >;$ 95

9K7=@$5N4=L>9=58;$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?$;5<=>4$K5A;=8L$?5@$2>@C

L=8>4=;7D$L@5A3;M$>8D$=8$3>@9=<A4>@$?5@$,52>M$/63;=7;

>8D$!@>J7447@;M$>8D$ 95$78;A@7$87<7;;>@6$ ?A8D=8L$ ?5@

7J789A>4$4>8D$3A@<K>;7$?@52$3@=J>97$5I87@;O

=4" #J78$=8$<>;7;$IK7@7$9K7$354=9=<>4$I=44$7Q=;9;M

?A8D=8L$=;$J7@6$?@7TA78946$=8;A??=<=789M$5@$7J78$959>446

4><P=8LM$DA7$95$9K7$@7;5A@<7C=8978;=J787;;$5?$K5A;7

<58;9@A<9=58$>8D$@785J>9=58O$(9$9K7$'8=58$47J74$9K7@7

>@7$;9@58L$=237D=2789;$95$9K7$A;7$5?$9K7$#A@537>8

,7L=58>4$ 07J74532789$ +A8D$ ?5@$ K5A;=8LM$ 7J78

9K5ALK$;A<K$?A8D=8L$=;$>J>=4>N47$?5@$<523472789>@6

=8?@>;9@A<9A@7$ ;A<K$ >;$ I>97@$ ;A3346$ >8D$ ;7I>L7

9@7>92789M$>8D$>$@7J=7I$5?$9K=;$354=<6$=;$@7<52278DC

7DO$ !K7$ <A@@789$ @7J=7I$ 5?$ %9@A<9A@>4$ +A8D=8L$ I=44

D7?=87$9K7$7Q9789$>8D$A;7$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$,7L=58>4

07J74532789$+A8D$?5@$ 9K7$37@=5D$FGG^CFGREo$ 9K7@7

=;$>$877D$95$78;A@7$9K>9M$95$9K7$L@7>97;9$7Q9789$35;C

;=N47M$9K7$FGG^CFGRE$?A8D=8L$I=44$>D7TA>9746$>DD@7;;

K5A;=8L$ >8D$ <523472789>@6$ =8?@>;9@A<9A@7$ =;;A7;

?><=8L$ ,52>$ >8D$ 59K7@$ JA487@>N47$ L@5A3;O$ &8$ 9K7

7J789$9K>9$K5A;=8L$=9;74?$<>8859$N7$?A8D7DM$9K7$#,0+

2=LK9$ 7Q>2=87$ I>6;$ =8$ IK=<K$ =9$ <>8$ 3@52597

;<K727;$ IK7@7$ 9K7$ @7<=3=789$ L5J7@82789$ ?A8D;

K5A;=8L$ <58;9@A<9=58$ 5@$ @785J>9=58M$ >8D$ 9K7$ #,0+

?=8>8<7;$<523472789>@6$=8?@>;9@A<9A@7O$';7$5?$;A<K

?A8D;$ ;K5A4D$ <58<789@>97$ 58$ 9K7$ D7;7L@7L>9=58$ 5?

7Q=;9=8L$,52>$<522A8=9=7;$N6$ 9K7$<58;9@A<9=58$5?

><<7;;$ @5>D;$ >8D$ 9K7$ =897L@>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ ;79947C

2789;$ =895$ 7Q=;9=8L$ ;7@J=<7$ 879I5@P;$ ]$ 747<9@=<=96M

I>97@$>8D$I>;97$@725J>4$;7@J=<7;M$?5@$7Q>2347O

A6" &8$ 9K7$ >@7>$ 5?$ 3@5W7<9$ D7;=L8M$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?

35;=9=J7$7Q>2347;$K>J7$N778$8597D$c9K@77$3@5W7<9;

=8$%3>=8$ =8$ 3>@9=<A4>@d$ >49K5ALK$A8?5@9A8>9746$ 9K7@7

>@7$>4;5$>$8A2N7@$5?$N>D$3@><9=<7;$=8$9K=;$>@7>O$!K7

9K@77$35;=9=J7$7Q>2347;$<=97D$=8J54J7$c=d$9K7$<@7>9=58

5?$>8$=897L@>97D$K5A;=8L$3@5W7<9M$I=9K$<58<52=9>89

;5<=>4$;7@J=<7;M$9K@5ALK$9K7$<@7>9=58$5?$>8$=897@27C

D=>@6$ >;;5<=>9=58o$ c==d$ 9K7$ 3@5J=;=58$ N6$ 9K7$ L5J7@8C

2789$ 5?$ ?A8D=8L$ 95$ */);$ 95$ NA6$ K5A;=8L$ >8D

3@5J=D7$<58<52=9>89$;5<=>4$;7@J=<7;$95$,52>8=$?>2C

=4=7;o$ >8D$ c===d$ 9K7$3@5J=;=58$5?$ L5J7@82789$ ?A8D=8L

?5@$9K7$=23@5J72789$5?$,52>8=$K5A;=8L$=8$;=9A$=8$>

@A8CD5I8$>@7>O$&8$9K7$9K=@D$3@5W7<9M$>8$7234562789

<52358789$<5234727897D$?A8D=8L$?5@$K5A;=8L$@78C

5J>9=58O$ !K7$ N787?=<=>4$ 7??7<9;$ 5?$ <52N=8=8L

7234562789$ >8De5@$ ;5<=>4$ >;;=;9>8<7$ <52358789;

I=9K=8$K5A;=8L$3@5W7<9;$K>J7$>4@7>D6$N778$8597DO

A5" U7;9$ 3@><9=<7;$ 58$ K5A;=8L$ ?5@$ ,52>$ =8<4AD7

,52>8=$ =8J54J72789$ =8$ 9K7$ D7;=L8M$ <58;9@A<9=58M

2>=8978>8<7$>8D$2>8>L72789$5?$K5A;=8LO$!K7@7$>@7

25D74;$ >J>=4>N47$ ?5@$ ,52>8=$ <589@54$ 5J7@$ K5A;=8L

9K@5ALK$<522A8=96$2>8>L72789$ ;9@A<9A@7;M$ =8<4ADC

=8L$35I7@C;K>@=8L$>258L$<522A8=96$272N7@;O$!K=;

N7;9$ 3@><9=<7$ ;K5A4D$ >4;5$ N7$ @734=<>97D$ =8$ >44$ 9K5;7

-72N7@$%9>97;$IK7@7$3AN4=<$3@5J=;=58$ =;$877D7D$ =8

9K7$?5@2$5?$5??=<=>4$;=97;$?5@$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>JC

7447@;$IK5$>@7$852>D=<$=8$4=?7;9647O

.$7'+.879$

A;" (<<7;;$95$K7>49K<>@7$?5@2;$>$<5@7$3>@9$5?$9K7$#'

>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >L78D>M$ >;$ @7<5L8=;7D$ N6$ 9K7

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Yh #Q37@9$>;;7;;2789$N6$-@$.><5$)@7>J7<$A8D7@$#,,Be-=4>8$%=27<P>$+5A8D>9=58eB)",#$3@5W7<9$58$K5A;=8L$@=LK9;$?5@

,52>$=8$%45J>P=>O

Page 33: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

7Q34=<=9$ N>8$ 58$ @><=>4$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ =8$ 9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?

K7>49K<>@7$ =8<4AD7D$ =8$ 9K7$ #'$ ,><7$ 0=@7<9=J7O$ !K7

#A@537>8$'8=58$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$5?$1AN4=<$"7>49K

=;$ <A@@78946$ =8$ 9K7$ 3@5<7;;$ 5?$ D7J7453=8L$ <52258

K7>49K$ =8D=<>95@;$ >8D$ =;$ >4;5$ ?A8D=8L$ >$ B522A8=96

(<9=58$1@5L@>227$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?$3AN4=<$K7>49K$cFGGEC

FGGfdO$ !K7$ FGGH$ I5@P$ 34>8$ ;37<=?=7;$ 9K>9$ ;5<=>4

=87TA>4=9=7;M$ L78D7@$2>=8;9@7>2=8L$ >8D$ >L7C@74>97D

>;37<9;$ I=44$ N7$ =897L@>97D$ =895$ 9K7$ 9>;P;$ 5?$ 7><K

S5@P=8L$1>@96M$>8D$=9$=;$;37<=?=7D$=8$3>@9=<A4>@$9K>9$9K7

S5@P=8L$/@5A3$58$K7>49K$D797@2=8>89;$2>6$[=8<4AD7

;5<=5C7<5852=<$D797@2=8>89;M$=8<4AD=8L$2=85@=96$>8D

2=L@>89$353A4>9=58;\O

A=" S=D7;3@7>D$ A8>J>=4>N=4=96$ 5?$ D>9>$ I=9K

@7;37<9$ 95$ 9K7$;9>97$5?$K7>49K$5?$,52>M$>;$I744$>;

9K7=@$34><72789$=8$5@$7Q<4A;=58$?@52$9K7$K7>49K$<>@7

;6;972M$=;$3>@9=<A4>@46$859=<7>N47O$+7I$;9AD=7;$K>J7

N778$ A8D7@9>P78$I=9K$ @7;37<9$ 95$ ><<7;;$ 95$ K7>49K

<>@7$ >8D$ 9K7@7$ =;$ 5335;=9=58$ 58$ 9K7$ 3>@9$ 5?$2>86

K7>49K$3@5?7;;=58>4;$95$79K8=<=96C;37<=?=<$;A@J76;O

AA" SK7@7$D>9>$D57;$7Q=;9M$9K7$3=<9A@7$3@5J=D7D$=;

I5@@6=8LO$ V7@6$ ;7@=5A;$ 3AN4=<$ K7>49K$ @=;P;M$ ;A<K$ >;

9AN7@<A45;=;M$>@7$I=D746$@735@97D$N6$3AN4=<$5??=<=>4;$>;

3@7J>4789$>258L$,52>M$>8D$3>@9=<A4>@46$>258L$,52>

=8$=;54>97D$;4A2$;799472789;MZG NA9$9K7;7$K>J7$95$D>97

859$N778$2>9<K7D$N6$>D7TA>97$@727D=>4$><9=58O$05<C

95@;$%w8<K7_$>8D$05@>D5M$=8$9K7=@$@735@9$58$9K7$%3>8C

=;K$,52>8=$353A4>9=58$?5@$9K7$,)-#',)1#$#A@537>8

3@5L@>227M$ 3@5J=D7$ >$ 4=;9$ 5?$ ;9AD=7;$ 9K>9$ ;K5I$ 9K7

3@7J>478<7$5?$<589>L=5A;$>8D$59K7@$D=;7>;7;j

=d$ K=LK7@$3@7J>478<7$5?$K73>9=9=;$($>258L$,52>8=$

<K=4D@78o

==d$ K=LK7@$ 3@7J>478<7$ 5?$ K73>9=9=;$ U$ c>258L$ 3@7LC

8>89$I5278M$ <K@58=<$ =8?7<9=58$ @>97;$ >@7$ fOHlM

>;$>L>=8;9$ROHl$5?$9K7$L787@>4$353A4>9=58do

===d$ K=LK7@$3@7J>478<7$5?$9AN7@<A45;=;$>8D$>;9K2>O

AB" !K7$ D>9>$ D7?=<=789$ 78J=@582789$ ;A@@5A8D=8L

,52>$<522A8=9=7;$ =8$#A@537M$>8D$IK=<K$K>;$N778

;9@7;;7D$ 9K@5ALK5A9$ 9K=;$ @735@9M$ K>;$>$2>@P7D$ @747C

J>8<7$ =8$ 9K7$ >@7>$ 5?$ ;7QA>446$ 9@>8;2=997D$ D=;7>;7;

c%!0;d$ >8D$ 9K7$ =8<=D78<7$ 5?$ "&Ve(&0%$ =8?7<9=58O$ &9

;K5A4D$N7$8597D$ 9K>9$>44$7Q=;9=8L$7J=D78<7$<58?=@2;

9K7$ =8;A??=<=78<6$ 5?$ ?=@2$ >8D$ <523@7K78;=J7$ D>9>M

>8D$=8$2>86$<>;7;M$=9;$A8@74=>N=4=96$>8D$9K7$@7;7>@<K

4=2=9>9=58;O$ !K7@7$ =;$ 9KA;$ >$ <58;=D7@>N47$ D>8L7@$ =8

<@7>9=8L$ 5@$ <58?=@2=8L$ 87L>9=J7$ ;97@759637;$ >N5A9

,52>$=8$9K7;7$>@7>;$5?$K7=LK9787D$3AN4=<$=897@7;9O

A!" !K7@7$=;$7J=D78<7$9K>9$9K7$;5<=5C7<5852=<$<=@C

<A2;9>8<7;$5?$<522A8=9=7;$K>J7$>$;9@58L$ =8?4A78<7

58$@=;P$?><95@;$>;;5<=>97D$I=9K$%!0;$>8D$"&Ve(&0%O$+5@

9K7;7$@7>;58;M$"&Ve(&0%$K>;$N778$?5A8D$95$D=;3@535@C

9=58>9746$>??7<9$<7@9>=8$2=85@=96$L@5A3;$=8$B789@>4$>8D

#>;97@8$ #A@537MZR >8D$2>86$ ,52>$ <522A8=9=7;$ >@7

7Q9@72746$JA487@>N47O$15J7@96M$A87234562789$>8D$D=;C

<@=2=8>9=58$>@7$3A;K$?><95@;$;>=D$95$N7$@7;358;=N47$?5@

9K7$=8J54J72789$5?$;527$,52>$I5278$>8D$9778>L7@;

=8$9K7$;7Q$=8DA;9@6M$I=9K$=9;$D=;3@535@9=58>97$7Q35;A@7

95$K=LK$@=;P$5?$%!0;$>8D$"&Ve(&0%$=8?7<9=58M$>49K5ALK

9K7@7$=;$85$J7@6$?=@2$D>9>$58$><9A>4$D=;7>;7$=8<=D78<7OZF

.5I$ 47J74;$ 5?$ >I>@787;;$ >8D$ ><<7;;$ 95$ =8?5@2>9=58

>N5A9$ 9K7$D=;7>;7;M$ 9K7=@$ 9@>8;2=;;=58M$37@;58>4$3@5C

97<9=58$>8D$><<7;;$95$9@7>92789$?A@9K7@$7Q><7@N>97$9K7

JA487@>N=4=96$5?$,52>OZE

A," (49K5ALK$ ;527$ @7<789$ =8=9=>9=J7;$ N6$ L5J7@8C

2789;$>8D$*/);$K>J7$;A<<7;;?A446$;9>@97D$95$>DD@7;;

9K7;7$ =;;A7;M$ >8D$ =8$ 3>@9=<A4>@$ 9K7$ 877D$ ?5@$ L@7>97@

3AN4=<$>I>@787;;M$9K7$@7;358;7$95$D>97$=;$859$3@535@C

9=58>4$95$9K7$877D;$>8D$9K7$A@L78<6$5?$9K7$;=9A>9=58O

A-" B>A9=58$ =8$ @74>9=58$ 95$<@7>9=8L$5@$<58?=@2=8L

87L>9=J7$;97@759637;$5?$,52>$=;$7TA>446$=235@9>89$=8

9K7$<58;=D7@>9=58$5?$9K7$=8<=D78<7$5?$D@AL$9@>??=<P=8L

>8D$ A;7O$ (49K5ALK$ ,52>$ >@7$ >;$ 7Q35;7D$ >;$ 59K7@

<522A8=9=7;$95$=8<@7>;=8L$D@AL$A;7M$>DJ7@;7$;5<=5C

7<5852=<$ <=@<A2;9>8<7;M$ ;A<K$ >;$ 9K5;7$ 7Q37@=C

78<7D$N6$,52>M$>@7$>4;5$P85I8$95$34><7$=8D=J=DA>4;

>8D$ <522A8=9=7;$ >9$ @=;PO$ #J=D78<7$I5A4D$ ;772$ 95

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

ZG 154>8Db;$g5=89$&8<4A;=58$-725@>8DA2$>8D$.=9KA>8=>b;$/5J7@82789$1@5L@>227$58$,52>$7Q34=<=946$8597$9AN7@<A45;=;$>;$>$3@5NC

472$>258L$,52>M$>8D$9AN7@<A45;=;$>8D$59K7@$7Q9@727$3AN4=<$K7>49K$@=;P;$>@7$@735@97D46$I=D7;3@7>D$=8$>$8A2N7@$5?$59K7@$<5A8C

9@=7;O$&8$=9;$;7<58D$@735@9$58$.=9KA>8=>M$9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537b;$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$(L>=8;9$,><=;2$>8D$&89547@>8<7$8597;j

a!K7$K7>49K$;=9A>9=58$5?$9K7$272N7@;$5?$9K7$,52>e/63;6$<522A8=9=7;$>4;5$97;9=?=7;$95$9K7=@$L787@>446$D=;>DJ>89>L7D$;=9A>9=58O

%A<K$D=;>DJ>89>L7$=;$4=8P7D$95$;7J7@>4$?><95@;$;A<K$>;$35J7@96$>8D$A8K7>49K6$4=J=8L$<58D=9=58;M$NA9$>4;5$@7?47<9;M$=8$;527$<>;7;M

3@7WAD=<7$58$9K7$3>@9$5?$9K5;7$3@5J=D=8L$9K7$;7@J=<7O

ZR '8=97D$*>9=58;$07J74532789$1@5L@>227M$ !"#$%&%'() *+,)-,.,'&,'/0)123.4M$($,7L=58>4$"A2>8$07J74532789$,735@9$ c'*01dM

U@>9=;4>J>$FGGFM$3OZYO

ZF ,=8L54D$078>M$)@78;97=8$-=9<K744M$S=4P78;$#@=P>$ !5$63)%')3')78.3'&%'()792$.,):);2,3<%'()*+,)=$#,2*0)>0/?,4M$($S5@4D$U>8P

%9AD6O$S>;K=8L958$FGGEO$3OHHO

ZE #'-BM$!;2,3<%'()*+,);322%,2@):)5$63'%)A$6,')3'&)"//,@@)*$)=9B?%/)C,3?*+)>32,4M$#A@537>8$B522A8=9=7;$FGGEO$33OY^CZGO

Page 34: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

;ALL7;9$9K>9$D@AL$>NA;7$=;$58$9K7$@=;7$=8$;527$,52>

<522A8=9=7;M$ >49K5ALK$ @74=>N47$ =8?5@2>9=58$ =;

;<>@<7OZH %527$@7;7>@<K$K>;$3@5J=D7D$7J=D78<7$;ALC

L7;9=8L$9K>9$9K7$25;9$JA487@>N47$>L7$L@5A3;$I=9K=8

,52>$<522A8=9=7;$>@7$hCRZ$67>@$54D$<K=4D@78M$IK5

2>6$N7$>DD=<97D$95$;54J789$>8D$>4<5K54$>NA;7M$>8D

RhCHG$67>@$54D;$IK5$>@7$25@7$ 4=P746$ 95$N7$58$ zK>@D

D@AL;XOZY &9$=;$;ALL7;97D$>4;5$=8$>$8A2N7@$5?$;5A@<7;

9K>9$D@AL$A;>L7$>8D$ 9@>??=<P=8L$2>6$N7$25@7$<52C

258$ =8$ >@7>;$ IK7@7$ <522A8=9=7;$ >@7$ <45;7$ 95

8>9=58>4$ N5>@D7@;O$ !K7$ '*01$ @735@9$ ;9@7;;7;$ 9K7

35;;=N47$ <5887<9=58$ N79I778$ 9K7$ D@AL$ 9@>D7$ >8D

A;7M$>8D$<5227@<=>4$;7Q$I5@POZZ

A4" /=J78$9K7$2>@L=8>4=;>9=58$5?$,52>$<522A8=C

9=7;M$ 9K7=@$;5<=5C7<5852=<$<=@<A2;9>8<7;$>8D$ 9K7=@

355@$ ><<7;;$ 95$ =8?5@2>9=58M$ 7DA<>9=58$ >8D$ 3AN4=<

K7>49K$;9@A<9A@7;M$=9$ =;$<7@9>=8$9K>9$9K76$>@7$3>@9=<AC

4>@46$JA487@>N47$95$D@AL$A;7$>8D$>NA;7$I=9K$J7@6$4=2C

=97D$><<7;;$95$>33@53@=>97$9@7>92789$>8D$>DD=<9=58

;A335@9$>L78<=7;OZ^

B6" &8$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$D>9>$58$9K7$3@7;789$4=?7

7Q37<9>8<6$ 5?$ ,52>$ =;$ 859$ >J>=4>N47O$ "5I7J7@M$ 978

67>@;$ >L5$ 9K7$ 4=?7$ 7Q37<9>8<6$ 5?$ ,52>8=$ 278$ >8D

I5278$I>;$9I74J7$67>@;$;K5@97@$9K>8$>J7@>L7OZf !K7

;9>97$5?$K7>49K$5?$9K7$,52>8=$353A4>9=58$=;$>;;7;;7D

>;$N7=8L$J=;=N46$I5@;7$9K>8$9K>9$5?$9K7$2>W5@=96$353A4>C

9=58$N6$ZhO^l$5?$L787@>4$3@><9=9=587@;OZh ($Rhh^$;9AD6

@7J7>47D$ J7@6$ D=??7@789$ @>97;$ 5?$ =8?7<9=58$ N79I778

,52>$>8D$858C,52>$?5@$>$8A2N7@$5?$D=;7>;7;O^G

B5" &8$%3>=8$=8$Rhh^M$<K=4D$J><<=8>9=58$<>23>=L8;

<>@@=7D$ 5A9$ =8$ J>@=5A;$ ;K>896$ 95I8;$ =8$ V>478<=>$ N6

9*2($;." 2*1" 97+2; D797<97D$ 9K>9$ 87>@46$ HGl$ 5?

,52>8=$<K=4D@78$K>D$859$@7<7=J7D$>86$P=8D$5?$J><<=C

8>9=58$>8D$>33@5Q=2>9746$YGl$K>D$859$N778$?A446$J><C

<=8>97DO^R ($3>7D=>9@=<$;9AD6$A8D7@9>P78$=8$(4=<>897$=8

FGGF$;=2=4>@46$@7J7>47D$J>;9$D=??7@78<7;$=8$J><<=8>9=58

@>97;j$ RfOfl$5?$,52>8=$ <K=4D@78$ >L7D$ F$ 67>@;$ K>D

859$@7<7=J7D$>86$J><<=8>9=58M$IK7@7>;$>44$858C,52>8=

<K=4D@78$K>D$>4@7>D6$N778$J><<=8>97D$>9$9K>9$>L7O^F

B;" %527$<5A89@=7;M$?5@$7Q>2347$154>8D$>8D$%45J>C

P=>M$ >@7$ 85I$ N7L=88=8L$ 95$ 7Q37@=2789$ I=9K$ 25N=47

K7>49K$A8=9;$?5@$=;54>97D$;4A2$;799472789;M$=8$5@D7@$95

D74=J7@$ @AD=2789>@6$ K7>49K$ <>@7$ 58$ >8$ 5<<>;=58>4

N>;=;O$ &8$ %45J>P=>$ 9K7$ 3@5L@>227$ =;$ ?=8>8<7D$ N6

1K>@7O$!K7$/@77P$L5J7@82789$K>;$;9>97D$9K>9$ =9$K>;

@7<78946$A8D7@9>P78$aRZMYfG$2A49=347$J><<=87;a$>258L

,52>$=8$/@77<7O$%A<K$27>;A@7;$>@7$95$N7$<52278DC

7DM$ NA9$ >4;5$ 95$ N7$ @7L>@D7D$ >;$ ;953CL>3M$ >I>=9=8L

<523@7K78;=J7$ 354=<6$ 27>;A@7;$ >=27D$ >9$ ;7<A@=8L

?A44$>8D$A8=237D7D$><<7;;$N6$>44$,52>$95$3@7J789>C

9=J7M$3@=2>@6$>8D$727@L78<6$K7>49K<>@7$;7@J=<7;O

B=" &9$=;$J7@6$I5@@6=8L$9K>9$=8$;527$5?$9K7$<5A8C

9@=7;$ ;9AD=7DM$ 7Q9@727$ >NA;7;$ 5?$ 9K7$ @=LK9$ 5?

=8?5@27D$ <58;789^E K>J7$ N778$ D5<A27897D$ =8

@7<789$67>@;$IK7@7$,52>$>@7$<58<7@87DM$>8D$K>J7

859$679$N778$2>9<K7D$N6$>D7TA>97$<5@@7<9=J7$27>;C

A@7;$N6$3AN4=<$5??=<=>4;O^H #??5@9;$2A;9$N7$@7D5AN47D

95$78;A@7$>$<A49A@7$>8D$@7LA4>@$3@><9=<7$5?$3@5J=D=8L

=8?5@2>9=58$>N5A9$>44$>;37<9;$5?$27D=<>4$<>@7M$27DC

=<>4$9@7>92789M$>8D$3@5<7DA@7;$95$N7$A8D7@9>P78$=8

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

ZH ,=8L54D$078>M$)@78;97=8$-=9<K744M$S=4P78;$#@=P>$ >,;0&"(+"&+"?@)&+2(+3"?7/;)*"A"B/*&C(+3"'%*"D;-*/'8"E8$1*FM$($S5@4D$U>8P

%9AD6O$S>;K=8L958$FGGEO$3OHHO

ZY 1A35@P>$.O$>8D$}>D5@=$}M$>#%*"G*&1'%"='&'7.";<",;0&"(+"G7+3&/8FO$UAD>37;9j$S5@4D$U>8P$,7L=58>4$)??=<7$C$"A8L>@6M$*/)$%9AD=7;$*5OFO

ZZ '8=97D$*>9=58;$07J74532789$1@5L@>227M$ >H-;(2(+3" '%*"I*)*+2*+$8"#/&)FM$($,7L=58>4$"A2>8$07J74532789$,735@9$ c'*01dM

U@>9=;4>J>$FGGFM$3OZZO

Z^ )378$%5<=796$&8;9=9A97$c)%&dM$>I/73.J"H!I="&+2"G&/0",*27$'(;+FO$*7I$i5@P$FGGFOZf g>87<P5Jw$"OM$*7;J>DN5Jw$.OM$`@5A3>$(OM$,A9;<K$gOM$a(99=9AD7;$5?$,52>$153A4>9=58$=8$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<$95$"7>49K$>8D$"7>49K

B>@7aM$47<9A@7$3@7;7897D$>9$9K7$<58?7@78<7$"7>49K$=8$!@>8;=9=58j$#A@537>8$17@;37<9=J7;$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$%5<=796$?5@$"7>49K$>8D

-7D=<>4$ %5<=545L6M$U%($-7D=<>4$ %5<=545L6$/@5A3$ F8D$ g5=89$B58?7@78<7M$ RHCR^$%73972N7@$ FGGGM$'8=J7@;=96$ 5?$ i5@Po$ 1@>K>j

%)B&)`.'U$1AN4=;K=8L$K5A;7M$3O$FFE

Zh *7;J>DN5Jw$.OM$,A9;<K$gOM$`@5A3>$(OM$%5WP>$%OM$a!K7$%9>97$5?$"7>49K$5?$9K7$,52>86$153A4>9=58$=8$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<aM$B789@>4

#A@537>8$g5A@8>4$5?$1AN4=<$"7>49KM$*5O$EM$V54O$f$cg"#-&$J54O$HHdM$(ALA;9$FGGGM$33O$RH^O

^G &N=DO

^R .y37_$UA;9>2>897M$g5>TAm8j$[.>$7Q<4A;=y8$2w;$JA487@>N47j$74$$>4>@2>897$7;9>D5$D7$;>4AD$D7$45;$L=9>85;$2w;$35N@7;\$78 =K=

,&$(.0;5!+<;/0*"&+7&1"LMMN".;O/*"*1"/&$(.0;"*+"?.)&P&"c[!K7$25;9$$JA487@>N47$7Q<4A;=58j$9K7$I5@@6=8L$;9>97$5?$K7>49K$5?$9K7

355@7;9$,52>\$$=8$=K=",&$(.0;5"H++7&1",*);/'"LMMN";+",&$(.0"(+"=)&(+d$#D=95@=>4$&<>@=>M$->D@=DM$FGGRM$3OEG

^F %w8<K7_$%7@@>85M$+Og$79O$>4Oj$[0=?7@78<=>$v98=<>$78$4>$><9=J=D>D$$>;=;978<=>4$D7$A@L78<=>;O$(3@5Q=2><=y8$>$4>$@7>4=D>D$L=9>8>O$H+&1*.

2*"D*2(&'/Q&"LMMLO$85O$YZ$c[#9K8=<$D=??7@78<7;$=8$9K7$>;;=;9>8<7$L=J78$>9$<>;A>49=7;O$(8$>33@5><K$95$9K7$,52>X;$@7>4=96\O$D*2(A

&'/($."&+&1."LMMLdM$58$9K7$&897@879$>9jK993jeeDNOD562>O7;e<L=CN=8eIDN<L=O7Q7eD562>e$2@7J=;9>O?A4497Q9~3=D789�REGFEhHGO

Page 35: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

>$4>8LA>L7$A8D7@;9>8D>N47$95$3>9=789;O$&8$>DD=9=58M

<523@7K78;=J7$ ;>?7LA>@D;$ 58$ 3>9=789;X$ @=LK9;M$ =8

3>@9=<A4>@$?5@$JA487@>N47$L@5A3;$;A<K$>;$,52>M$2A;9

N7$ =89@5DA<7DM$ =8<4AD=8L$ ><<7;;$ 95$ WA;9$ @727D6

IK7@7$;A<K$@=LK9;$>@7$J=54>97DO

BA" !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$<>8$>8D$;K5A4D$3@5J=D7

LA=D>8<7$ 95$-72N7@$%9>97;$ >8D$B>8D=D>97$B5A8C

9@=7;$N6$ =8<4AD=8L$=8$9K7$K7>49K$ =8D=<>95@;$<A@@78946

A8D7@$D7J74532789$ =8D=<>95@;$ @74>97D$ 95$N59K$D=;C

7>;7$ =8<=D78<7$>8D$><<7;;$95$9K7$K7>49K$<>@7$;6;C

972$ N6$ 2>@L=8>4=;7D$ 79K8=<$ L@5A3;O$ /=J78$ 9K7

;37<=?=<$ 3@5N472;$ ?><7D$ N6$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58;M

3>@9=<A4>@46$IK7@7$9K7;7$>@7$=9=87@>89M$>;$I744$>;$9K7

8A2N7@;$5?$,52>$=8$2>86$87I$-72N7@$%9>97;$=8

3>@9=<A4>@M$=9$2>6$N7$>33@53@=>97$95$;37<=?6$9K7$877D

95$D7J7453$=8D=<>95@;$?5@$,52>M$/63;6$>8D$!@>J7447@

L@5A3;O$!K7@7$=;$>4;5$<58;=D7@>N47$;<537$?5@$D7J74C

53=8L$9K7$#'$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58$=8D=<>95@;$95$78<52C

3>;;$ 7Q<4A;=58$ 58$ 79K8=<$ L@5A8D;O$ !K7

D7J74532789$ 5?$ K>@258=;7D$ =8D=<>95@;$ N79I778

9K7$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$?5@$#234562789$>8D$%5<=>4

(??>=@;$>8D$ 9K7$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$ ?5@$"7>49K$>8D

B58;A27@$ 1@597<9=58$ I5A4D$ N7$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ >DJ=;C

>N47$=8$9K=;$>@7>O$'8=58$=8;9=9A9=58;$;K5A4D$>4;5$<58C

9=8A7$95$258=95@$9K7$K7>49K$<>@7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>

=8$-72N7@$%9>97;$IK7@7$c=d$9K7@7$>@7$34>A;=N47$>447C

L>9=58;$9K>9$,52>$K>J7$N778$;ANW7<97D$95$>NA;7;

N6$ K7>49K$ <>@7$ 3@5J=D7@;$ >8D$ c==d$ IK7@7$ 9K7@7$ >@7

<47>@$ =8D=<>9=58;$ 9K>9$ 3@=2>@6$ >8De5@$ 727@L78<6

K7>49K$<>@7$2>6$859$N7$@7><K=8L$;=L8=?=<>89$;7<95@;

5?$9K7$,52>8=$353A4>9=58O

BB" &8$@7;37<9$5?$9K7$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$?5@$1ANC

4=<$"7>49K$B522A8=96$(<9=58$1@5L@>227M$=9$=;$8597D

9K>9$9K7$!YG2$FGGE$NADL79$I>;$RG$9=27;$5J7@;ANC;<@=N7D$>8D$9K>9$9K7@7$=;$?>@$25@7$D72>8D$?5@$K7>49K

;7<95@$ <5C?=8>8<=8L$ 9K>8$ <>8$ N7$ 279$ N6$ 9K7$ 1@5C

L@>227O$ /=J78$ 9K7$ =235@9>8<7$ 5?$ L55D$ K7>49K$ =8

78;A@=8L$ 7<5852=<$ ><9=J=96$ >8D$ 7234562789M$ 9K7

5J7@>@<K=8L$L5>4$5?$ 9K7$'8=58M$ =9$I5A4D$N7$@7>;58C

>N47$ ?5@$ 9K7$ B522=;;=58$ 95$ =8<@7>;7$ 9K=;$ ;A2O

-5@75J7@M$L=J78$9K7$3AN4=<$K7>49K$9K@7>9;$35;7D$N6

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

^E !K7$#A@537>8$BK>@97@$58$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;M$3@5<4>=27D$N6$9K7$$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$58$^$07<72N7@$FGGGM$K>;$>8<K5@7D

9K7$@=LK9$95$?A44$$>8D$=8?5@27D$<58;789$>9$9K7$<5@7$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58O$(@9=<47$E$5?$$9K7$BK>@97@M$58$9K7$@=LK9$95$9K7$=897L@=96

5?$9K7$37@;58M$LA>@>8977;$$9K>9$a=8$9K7$?=74D;$5?$27D=<=87$>8D$N=545L6$=8$3>@9=<A4>@aM$a9K7$?@77$$>8D$=8?5@27D$<58;789$5?$9K7$37@C

;58$<58<7@87Da${OOO|$a2A;9$N7$@7;37<97D$$=8$3>@9=<A4>@aO$

^H (<<5@D=8L$95$#,,B$D5<A2789>9=58$>8D$9K>9$5?$5?$3>@987@$5@L>8=;>9=58;M$,52>8=$I5278$K>J7$N778$<57@<=J746$;97@=4=;7D$=8$@7<789

67>@;$=8$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$"A8L>@6$>8D$%45J>P=>O$.7L>4$<5234>=89;$>@7$<A@@78946$378D=8L$N7?5@7$D527;9=<$>8D$=897@8>9=58>4

<5A@9;$I=9K$@7;37<9$95$<57@<=J7$;97@=4=;>9=58;$=8$"A8L>@6$>8D$%45J>P=>O$&8$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$9K7$#,,B$K>;$3@5J=D7D$=8?5@2>C

9=58$95$9K7$)2NAD;2>8$@74>97D$95$<57@<=J7$;97@=4=;>9=58;O

+$3+#V(3#="#

9JCH#.?H>GQ#%?YIHGJEF#&EJZ?KG[#9JCHXIH"

(49K5ALK$9K7$<58<739$5?$,52>$27D=>95@;$=8$7DAC

<>9=58$ I>;$ ?=@;9$ D7J74537D$ =8$ +@>8<7$ =8$ RhfZC^M

9K7$ 7Q978;=58$ 5?$ 9K7$ <58<739$ 95$ K7>49K<>@7$I>;

=8=9=>97D$=8$,52>8=>O

&8$FGGGM$9K7$>;;5<=>9=58$,52>8=$B,&%%$C$,52>

B789@7$?5@$%5<=>4$&897@J789=58$>8D$%9AD=7;$9@>=87D

K7>49K$ 27D=>95@;$ 95$ 3@5J=D7$ 4=>=;58$ N79I778

,52>$?>2=4=7;$>8D$2>=8;9@7>2$3AN4=<$K7>49K$;7@JC

=<7;O$!K7$I5@P$K>;$N778$3>@9=<A4>@46$7??7<9=J7$ =8

9K7$3@5259=58$5?$<K=4D$J><<=8>9=58$3@5L@>227;M

><<7;;$ 95$ >89=C$ >8D$ 35;9C8>9>4$ <>@7$ ?5@$259K7@;M

>8D$ 7DA<>9=58$ ;A@@5A8D=8L$ =;;A7;$ 5?$ <589@><73C

9=58$ >8D$ ?>2=46$ 34>88=8LO$ (;$ 9K7$ I5@P$ K>;$ 3@5C

L@7;;7DM$9K7$K7>49K$27D=>95@;$K>J7$N7<527$25@7

=8J54J7D$ =8$ 9K7$ =D789=?=<>9=58$ 5?$ ;7@=5A;$ <589>C

L=5A;$ D=;7>;7;$ >8D$ 9K7$ D79>=47D$ @7<5@D=8L$ 5?

;527$>;37<9;$5?$,52>$K7>49K$D>9>O

!K7$I5@P$K>;$N778$;5$7??7<9=J7$=8$7;9>N4=;K=8L

>8D$;9@78L9K78=8L$9K7$><9=J7$ 4=8P;$N79I778$,52>

<522A8=9=7;$ >8D$ 3AN4=<$ K7>49K$ ;7@J=<7;$ 9K>9$ 9K7

;<K727$ I>;$ >D5397D$ =8$ FGGF$ N6$ 9K7$ ,52>8=>8

-=8=;9@6$5?$"7>49K$>8D$+>2=46M$IK=<K$;A335@97D$RZZ

K7>49K$27D=>95@;$=8$EH$3=459$<5A89=7;M$NA9$I=9K$9K7

9@>=8=8L$?A8<9=58$;9=44$3@5J=D7D$N6$,52>8=$B,&%%O$

!K7$8A2N7@;$5?$27D=>95@;$>8D$9K7=@$@7;5A@<7;

>@7$;9=44$25D7;9M$K5I7J7@M$>8D$9K7=@$7??7<9=J787;;$=;

;9=44$D7378D789$58$9K7$<K>@><97@$>8D$TA>4=96$5?$9K7

7Q=;9=8L$3AN4=<$K7>49K$=8?@>;9@A<9A@7M$IK=<K$=;$5?978

I7>PO$-5@75J7@M$IK7@7$ ?>2=46$ =8<527;$>8D$78J=C

@582789>4$<=@<A2;9>8<7;$>@7$355@M$>8D$IK7@7$4=9947

5@$85$><9=58$=;$9>P78$95$>274=5@>97$9K7$;=9A>9=58M$>;

=;$9K7$<>;7$=8$9K7$2>W5@=96$5?$,52>$<522A8=9=7;M

9K78$9K7$TA>4=96$5?$ 4=>=;58M$<522A8=96$K7>49K<>@7M

7DA<>9=58$ >8D$ K7>49K6$ 4=?7;9647$ 3@5259=58$ =;$ ;7@=C

5A;46$A8D7@2=87DO

Page 36: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

9K7$K=LK$ 47J74;$5?$ <589>L=5A;$D=;7>;7$>258L$2>@C

L=8>4=;7D$ L@5A3;M$ >258L$ IK=<K$ ,52>$ L@5A3;$ >@7

3@52=8789M$ >8D$ 9K7$ 0=@7<95@>97$ /787@>4X;$ I=;K$ 95

=23@5J7$ <@5;;CN5@D7@$ <5537@>9=58$ =8$ 9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?

K7>49K<>@7M$=8<@7>;7D$>99789=58$95$9K7$K7>49K$;9>9A;

5?$,52>$=;$?A446$WA;9=?=7DO$!K=;$=;$3>@9=<A4>@46$9K7$<>;7

L=J78$ 9K7$ 353A4>9=58$ 25J72789;$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ FGGH

784>@L72789$K>;$;9=2A4>97DO

<10&797+$#$*\19(*%$*+7'#1%&78+T#

.(/01*2#7*<#.$7'+.

B!" #23=@=<>4$7J=D78<7$?@52$>$8A2N7@$5?$<5A89@=7;

=8D=<>97;$ 9K>9$,52>$;A??7@$D=;3@535@9=58>9746$ ?@52

78J=@582789>4$K>@2;O$+5@$7Q>2347M

q !K7$3@7D52=8>8946$,52>8=$;799472789$5?$.5I7@

"@A;5JM$);9@>J>M$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$=;$45<>97D$5J7@

>$ ?5@27@$ 2=87$ IK=<K$ <589=8A>446$ L787@>97;

279K>87$L>;o$9K7$;799472789$=;$=8$<58;9>89$D>8C

L7@$5?$7Q345D=8Lo

q !K7$,52>8=$ ;799472789$ 5?$ 1>95@><P>M$ ,AD8>86M

%45J>P=>M$ =;$ 45<>97D$58$9K7$L@5A8D;$5?$>$ ?5@27@

27@<A@6$2=87o

q ($ ,52>8=$ ;799472789$ =8$ (;3@536@L5;M$ /@77<7M

WA;9$ 5A9;=D7$ (9K78;M$ =;$ 45<>97D$ 58$ >$ 2A8=<=3>4

DA23O

B," &8$;527$>@7>;M$IK7@7$78J=@582789>4$<58D=9=58;

2>6$ N7$ D>8L7@5A;$ L787@>446M$ 9K76$ >@7$ 3>@9=<A4>@46

<5235A8D7D$I=9K$@7;37<9$95$,52>O$+5@$7Q>2347M$=8

K5A;7;$=8$9K7$95I8$5?$}4>98>M$,52>8=>M$_=8<M$<5337@

>8D$47>D$<58<789@>9=58;$CC$D7@=J=8L$?@52$9K7$9>=4=8L;

5?$>$45<>4$2=87$CC$7Q<77D$9K7$>445I>N47$47J74;$;79$=8

;527$#'$<5A89@=7;$N6$?><95@;$5?$978$5@$25@7O$-5@7C

5J7@M$;527$45<>4$@7LA4>9=58;$@74>97D$95$9K7$78J=@58C

2789$2>6$K>J7$=8D=@7<946$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$7??7<9;O$+5@

7Q>2347M$=8$9K7$<=96$5?$);9@>J>$=8$9K7$B_7<K$,73ANC

4=<M$?77;$?5@$I>;97$@725J>4$>@7$>$?=Q7D$;A2$37@$K7>DM

9>P=8L$85$><<5A89$5?$ =8<527$ 47J74;$5@$ >25A89;$5?

I>;97$L787@>97DO$,52>8=$?>2=4=7;M$IK=<K$978D$95$N7

N59K$4>@L7@$>8D$355@7@M$N7>@$>$D=;3@535@9=58>97$NA@C

D78$5?$45<>4$I>;97$@725J>4$<5;9;O

B-" !K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$0=@7<95@>97$/78C

7@>4$?5@$9K7$#8J=@582789$2>6$K>J7$>$@547$95$34>6$=8

D7?=8=8L$3>8C#'$354=<=7;$ =8$ @7;37<9$5?$ 9K7$78J=@58C

2789$>;$>$D797@2=8>89$5?$K7>49KM$>8D$=8$;A335@9=8L

3@5W7<9;$ >=27D$ >9$ =23@5J=8L$ 9K7$ ;5<=>4$ I74?>@7$ 5?

D=;>DJ>89>L7D$L@5A3;M$=8<4AD=8L$,52>O &8D77DM$9K7

0=@7<95@>97$ /787@>4X;$ Z9K$ #8J=@582789>4$ (<9=58

14>8M$>L@77D$ =8$FGGFM$;79;$ ?5A@$3@=5@=9=7;M$5?$IK=<K

587$=;$9K7$78J=@582789$=8$@74>9=58$95$K7>49K$>8D$9K7

TA>4=96$5?$4=?7O$/@>89;$>@7$L=J78$=8$;A335@9$5?$5@L>8=C

;>9=58;$ 3@535;=8L$ ><<739>N47$ 3@5W7<9;$ >8DM

>49K5ALK$=9$D57;$859$>337>@$9K>9$?=8>8<7$K>;$3@7J=C

5A;46$N778$2>D7$>J>=4>N47$95$,52>8=$L@5A3;M$9K=;$=;

>$35;;=N=4=96$?5@$9K7$?A9A@7O

0(817'#0$8/91+)[#1*8(%$0#7*<#<$V+

B4" &8$9K7$?=74D$5?$;5<=>4$>;;=;9>8<7M$=9$=;$5?$<58<7@8

9K>9M$ #'$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 7??5@9;$ 859I=9K;9>8D=8LM

;527$<5A89@=7;$K>J7$=8$@7<789$67>@;$>278D7D$4>I;

I=9K$ 9K7$ 7??7<9$ 5?$ @725J=8L$ 74=L=N=4=96$ ?5@$ ;5<=>4

>;;=;9>8<7$ ?@52$ ,52>O$ -5;9$ @7<78946M$ =8$ FGGHM

>278D2789;$ 95$ %45J>P$ ;5<=>4$ ;A335@9$ 47L=;4>9=58

@7DA<7D$>;;=;9>8<7$?5@$?>2=4=7;$I=9K$2>86$<K=4D@78M

>$3@5J=;=58$I=D746$K74D$95$N7$9>@L797D$>9$,52>$>8D

587$IK=<K$I=44$I=9K5A9$TA7;9=58$K>J7$=8D=@7<946$D=;C

<@=2=8>95@6$7??7<9;$58$,52>O$&8$>$8A2N7@$5?$<>;7;M

D=@7<9$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>L>=8;9$,52>$K>;$N778$@735@9C

7D$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?$;5<=>4$3@597<9=58O$+5@$7Q>2347M$ =8

,52>8=>$ @7;7>@<K7@;$ K>J7$ D5<A27897D$ 45<>4

>A9K5@=9=7;$ ;9>9=8L$ 9K>9$ 9K76$ >3346$ D=;<@79=58>@6

27>8;$ 97;9;$ ?5@$ 74=L=N=4=96$ ?5@$ ;5<=>4$ N787?=9;$ =8$ >

@><=>446$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$2>887@M$5@$59K7@I=;7$=8D=<>9C

=8L$9K>9$9K76$@7L>@D$,52>$=8$L787@>4$>;$A8D7;7@J=8L

5?$;5<=>4$I74?>@7$;A335@9O^Y

!6" &8$+@>8<7M$>$8A2N7@$5?$Dv3>@972789;$>337>@

95$K>J7$L=J78$>44$?=47;$<58<7@8=8L$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>JC

7447@;$ c=8<4AD=8L$ 9K5;7$IK5$ D5$ 859$ 9@>J74d$ 5J7@$ 95

9K7$;37<=>4$>;;5<=>9=58;$5?$[?@=78D;$5?$9K7$/63;=7;

>8D$!@>J7447@;\O$(;$>$@7;A49M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;

>@7$859$><<7397D$=8$9K7$2A8=<=3>4$5??=<7;M$>8D$K>J7

95$ L5$ 95$ 9K7$ ;37<=?=<$ >;;5<=>9=58;$ D7;=L87D$ [?5@

9K72\O$ &8$ 587$Dv3>@972789M$ ;A2;$>337>@$ 95$ K>J7

N778$@725J7D$?@52$;5<=>4$;A335@9$3>62789;$N>;7D

58$>8$=897@8>4$<K>@9M$IK=<K$3@7;A27D$9K>9$!@>J7447@;

I7@7$I5@P=8L$ =447L>446$ >8D$ 859$ D7<4>@=8L$ 9K7=@$ @7>4

=8<527O$-5@75J7@M$!@>J7447@;$=8$+@>8<7$>@7$=874=L=N47

?5@$<7@9>=8$?5@2;$5?$;5<=>4$>;;=;9>8<7$N7<>A;7$9K7=@

K527;$ >@7$ 859$ a?=Q7DaO$ ->86$ 852>D=<$ ,52>8=M

/63;6$ >8D$ !@>J7447@$ <522A8=9=7;$ =8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?

#A@537>8$'8=58$-72N7@$%9>97;$;A??7@$;=2=4>@$9@7>9C

2789$ >;$>$ @7;A49$5?$K>J=8L$85$ ?=Q7D$5@$37@2>8789

K527$>8D$35;9>4$>DD@7;;O

!5" !K7$4><P$5?$@7<5L8=9=58$5?$9@>D=9=58>4$,52>8=

2>@@=>L7;$=;$>$3@5N472$=8$;527$<5A89@=7;O$!K=;$K>;

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

^Y %77$?5@$7Q>2347M$}558M$&8>M$!"#$%&#'()*+",-#./0(#("1#2345+6#7&)8+6&,##+"#./0("+(9#:35*()+(#("1#'(6&1/"+(M$*7I$i5@Pj$)378

%5<=796$&8;9=9A97M$$FGGRM$33OEFCEHO$

Page 37: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

47D$ 95$ >$ @>8L7$ 5?$ D=;>DJ>89>L7;M$ =8<4AD=8L$ 9K7

=8>N=4=96$95$<5447<9$378;=58;$>8D$95$J=;=9$;35A;7;$=8

3@=;58$5@$=8$K5;3=9>4O

!;" ';A@6$ =;$ >4;5$ I=D7;3@7>D$ =8$ =235J7@=;K7D

<522A8=9=7;$=8$;527$#'$-72N7@$%9>97;M$>8D$A;A@6

K>;$D773787D$9K7$<6<47$5?$35J7@96$5?$2>86$,52>8=

<522A8=9=7;O$ %527$ <522789>95@;$ K>J7$ >@LA7D

9K>9$ A;A@6$ K>;$N7<527$25@7$ ;7J7@7$ @7<78946M$ 9K>9

=897@7;9$@>97;$K>J7$=8<@7>;7D$95$RGGl$5@$25@7M$>8D

9K>9$J=5478<7$5@$9K@7>9;$5?$J=5478<7$=8$9K7$<5897Q9$5?

D7N9$ <5447<9=58$ =;$25@7$ ?@7TA789$ 9K>8$ 3@7J=5A;46O^Z

+5@$ 458L$ 37@=5D;$ 5?$ 9=27M$ A;A@6$I>;$25@7$ 5@$ 47;;

=L85@7D$N6$<@=2=8>4$WA;9=<7$>A9K5@=9=7;M$N7=8L$@7L>@DC

7D$ >;$ >$ ?7>9A@7$5?$,52>8=$ >8D$59K7@$2>@L=8>4=;7D

<522A8=96$4=?7$>8D$9K7@7?5@7$859$>$3@=5@=96$?5@$354=<7

>99789=58O$%45J>P$354=<7$K>J7$ @7<78946$N7LA8$25@7

>LL@7;;=J746$ >@@7;9=8L$ >8D$ ;77P=8L$ 3@5;7<A9=58$ 5?

A;A@7@;M$>8D$9K7@7$=;$;<537$?5@$=8J54J=8L$<522A8=96

;9@78L9K78=8L$ 95$ <52N>9$ A;A@6O$ )87$ ;A<K$ 3@5W7<9

K>;$N778$=234727897D$=8$@7<789$67>@;$=8$9K7$B_7<K

<=96$5?$);9@>J>M$>33>@78946$I=9K$;527$;A<<7;;$c;77

!7Q9$U5Q$HdO

'78O#(M#&$90(*7'#<(8/%$*+0#

7*<#0+7+$'$00*$00

!=" ($;7@=5A;$5N;9><47$95$9K7$7Q7@<=;7$5?$N>;=<$@=LK9;

N6$,52>$9K@5ALK5A9$#A@537M$>;$I744$>;$9K7=@$><<7;;

95$ ;7@J=<7;$ <@A<=>4$ ?5@$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58M$ =;$ >$ 4><P$5?

37@;58>4$ D5<A2789;M$ =8<4AD=8L$ NA9$ 859$ 4=2=97D$ 95

N=@9K$<7@9=?=<>97;M$37@;58>4$=D789=96$D5<A2789;M$45<>4

@7;=D78<7$37@2=9;M$D5<A2789;$@74>97D$95$;9>97C3@5C

J=D7D$K7>49K$=8;A@>8<7$>8D$;5<=>4$I74?>@7M$>8D$3>;;C

35@9;O !K7@7$ >@7$ >4;5$ 3@5N472;$ =8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?

<5A89@=7;$@74>97D$95$9K7$?A8D>2789>4$;9>9A;$5?$=8D=C

J=DA>4;o$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ ,52>$ K>J7$ 859$2>8>L7D$ 95

;7<A@7$ <=9=_78;K=3$ =8$ -72N7@$ %9>97;M$ >8D$ ;527

-72N7@$ %9>97;$ 537@>97$ @7;=D78<7$ 37@2=9$ @7L=27;

IK=<K$ K>J7$ 9K7$ 7??7<9$ 5?$ 37@379A>9=8L$ 9K7$ ;5<=>4

7Q<4A;=58$5?$,52>$>8D$59K7@;O

!A" +5@$7Q>2347M$>$4>@L7$8A2N7@$5?$,52>$=8$%45C

J>P=>$>@7$A8>N47$95$><<7;;$>$@>8L7$5?$N>;=<$;7@J=<C

7;$ <@A<=>4$ 95$ ?A8D>2789>4$ 7<5852=<$ >8D$ ;5<=>4

@=LK9;$N7<>A;7$9K76$4><P$>$@7;=D78<7$37@2=9$ =8$9K7

34><7$5?$ 9K7=@$><9A>4$ @7;=D78<7O$ &8$5@D7@$ 95$;7<A@7

47L>4$37@2>8789$ @7;=D78<7$ =8$>$L=J78$2A8=<=3>4=96M

>8$ =8D=J=DA>4$2A;9$A;A>446$3@5DA<7$>$J>4=D$ =D789=96

D5<A2789M$>;$I744$>;$3>37@;$<58?=@2=8L$9K7$=8D=J=DC

A>4b;$@=LK9$95$A;7$9K7$?4>9$5@$59K7@$K>N=9>N47$@552;M

5@$ 9K7$I@=9978$ >33@5J>4$ 5?$ 9K7$ ?4>9X;$ 5I87@$ 5@$ 3@=C

2>@6$978>89O$0A7$95$9K7$?><9$9K>9$2>86$,52>$4=J7$=8

=8?5@2>4$ ;799472789;$IK7@7$ 9K7;7$ <58D=9=58;$ <>8C

859$N7$279M$>;$I744$>;$DA7$95$>$@>8L7$5?$59K7@$?><C

95@;M$ 2>86$ ,52>$ 7=9K7@$ D5$ 859$ K>J7$ >$ @7;=D78<7

37@2=9$>9$>44M$5@$K>J7$>$@7;=D78<7$37@2=9$5846$=8$9K7=@

95I8$5?$N=@9KO$(;$>$@7;A49M$ 4>@L7$8A2N7@;$5?$,52>

K>J7$ 85$ ><<7;;$ 95$ N>;=<$ 3AN4=<$ ;7@J=<7;M$ 5@$ 5846

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

^Z *5JwPM$`>@74M$a.=<KJ>$W>P5$3@=@5_786$W7JaM$>J>=4>N47$58$9K7$&897@879$>9$IIIO<45J7PJ9=;8=O<_e@52;P7p3@5W7P96e4=<KJ>OK92O

+$3+#V(3#A"#8JCCSXIGL#&EJZ?KG#GJ#8JCDHG#/FSEL"

!K7$B_7<K$5@L>8=;>9=58$.=?7$!5L79K7@$K>;$D7J74C

537D$ ;A<<7;;?A4$ 3@5W7<9;$ @74>97D$ 95$ <52N>9=8L

A;A@6$=8$,52>8=$<522A8=9=7;O$!K7$a,52>$154=<7

(;;=;9>89;$1@5W7<9a$I>;$;9>@97D$=8$5@D7@$95j

q "743$45>8$;K>@P$J=<9=2;$;77P$354=<7$>=D

q 1@73>@7$9K7$354=<7$95$I5@P$3@5?7;;=58>446$I=9K

45>8$;K>@P$J=<9=2;$>258L$9K7$,52>

q U@=DL7$2A9A>4$D=;9@A;9$N79I778$354=<7$>8D

,52>8=$<522A8=9=7;M$>;$I744$>;$95$5378$A3

9K7$354=<7$95$9K7$=D7>$5?$723456=8L$,52>

I=9K=8$9K7$354=<7$?5@<7$

q ,>=;7$9K7$7Q37<9>9=58;$5?$9K7$,52>8=

<522A8=96$?5@$TA>4=96$354=<7$;7@J=<=8LO

!K7$3@5W7<9$N7L>8$?@52$>8$>337>4$=8$%3@=8L$FGGF

I=9K$>$L@5A3$5?$>N5A9$ ?=?96$,52>8=$I5278$IK5

I7@7$<>ALK9$=8$>8$=235J7@=;K=8LM$KA2=4=>9=8L$>8D

J=54789$D7N9$9@>3O$

)?$9K7$?=?96$I5278$IK5$>33@5><K7D$9K7$5@L>8C

=;>9=58$ .=?7$ !5L79K7@$ ?5@$ >;;=;9>8<7$ =8$ <52N>9=8L

A;A@6M$ ?=J7$D7<=D7D$ 95$ ;9>8D$ 95L79K7@$ >L>=8;9$ 9K7

45>8$ ;K>@P;O$ !K=;$ <@7>97D$ >8$ A83@7<7D7897D

<K>8L7$ =8$ 9K7$ <522A8=96O$ !K7$ 45>8$ ;K>@P;$I7@7

<K>4478L7D$ ?5@$ 9K7$ ?=@;9$ 9=27M$ @7;358D7D$ =8=9=>446

I=9K$9K@7>9;M$NA9$4>97@$N7<>27$A8;A@7$>8D$J=5478<7

I>;$>J5=D7DO$!I5$5?$9K7$I5278$<58<7@87D$D7<=DC

7D$ 95$ K743$ 59K7@$ J=<9=2;$ N6$ 3@5J=D=8L$ 9K72$I=9K

3;6<K545L=<>4$>=D$>8D$N6$I5@P=8L$>;$354=<7$>;;=;C

9>89;$?5@$9K=;$*/)O$!K7=@$3AN4=<$K585A@$=;$78;A@7D

N6$ I5@P=8L$ 9@>8;3>@78946$ >8D$ N6$ 859$ =8?5@2=8L

354=<7$IK5$9K7$45>8$;K>@P;$>@7O$!K76$;A335@9$J=<C

9=2;$IK5$I=;K$95$?=47$<5234>=89;$95$9K7$354=<7$<58C

<7@8=8L$A;A@6O$!K7$<522A8=96$37@<7=J7;$9K72$>;

354=<7$>;;=;9>89;$I5@P=8L$?5@$9K7$N787?=9$5?$9K7$J=<C

9=2;M$>8D$859$>;$a354=<7$=8?5@27@;aO

+A@9K7@$=8?5@2>9=58$58$9K7$3@5W7<9$=;$>J>=4>N47

?@52$J_>W7287O;5A_=9=Ä9=;<>4=O<_O

Page 38: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

7Q9@72746$4=2=97D$><<7;;$95$;A<K$;7@J=<7;O

!B" &8$;527$ =8;9>8<7;M$ 45<>4$5??=<=>4;$ =8$%45J>P=>

K>J7$ ;9@A<P$ ,52>$ ?@52$ 9K7$2A8=<=3>4$ @7L=;97@O$ +5@

7Q>2347M$58$gA87$Ff9KM$FGGRM$9K7$45<>4$<5A8<=4$5?$9K7

95I8$ 5?$ .79>85J<7$ >D5397D$ ,7;54A9=58

FReFfOZOFGGRM$a97@2=8>9=8L$9K7$37@2>8789$@7;=D78<7

5?$ 9K7$ <=9=_78;$ 4=J=8L$ =8$ 9K7$ /63;6$ ;799472789

.79>85J<7$ ?@52$(ALA;9$RM$FGGROa$07;3=97$ 9K7$ =897@C

J789=58$5?$ 9K7$%45J>P$/5J7@82789b;$1478=359789=>@6

?5@$,52>$B522A8=9=7;M$>;$I744$>;$@7J=7I$N6$>$3>@4=>C

2789>@6$ <522=9977M$ 9K7$ 45<>4$ <5A8<=4$ @7?A;7D$ 95

;9@=P7$D5I8$9K7$><9O$($<5A@9$;AN;7TA78946$>88A447D

9K7$ ><9M$ NA9$ >;$ 5?$)<95N7@$ FGGEM$ >33@5Q=2>9746$ ZG

,52>$=8$9K7$.79>85J<7$;799472789$4><P7D$37@2>8789

@7;=D78<7$9K7@7M$D7;3=97$9K7$?><9$9K>9$2>86$5?$9K72

I7@7$N5@8$9K7@7O$%=2=4>@$<>;7;$K>J7$5<<A@@7D$=8$9K7

B_7<K$,73AN4=<$>8D$"A8L>@6O

!!" &8$7Q9@727$<>;7;M$,52>$4><P$<=9=_78;K=3M$>8D

9K7$J7@6$I5@@6=8L$3K78527858$5?$;9>9747;;87;;$K>;

>@=;78$>258L$,52>$=8$;527$<5A89@=7;O^^ &8$9K7$<58C

97Q9$ 5?$ 9K7$ N@7>PA3$ 5?$ B_7<K5;45J>P=>$ =8$ RhhEM$ ?5@

7Q>2347M$@>9K7@$9K>8$2>P=8L$B_7<K$<=9=_78;K=3$>J>=4C

>N47$ 95$>44$ ?5@27@$B_7<K5;45J>P$<=9=_78;M$ 9K7$B_7<K

(<9$58$B=9=_78;K=3$>I>@D7D$<=9=_78;K=3$95$9K5;7$IK5

K>D$ B_7<KM$ >;$ 5335;7D$ 95$ %45J>P$ @73AN4=<$ <=9=_78C

;K=3M$>$3@7J=5A;46$27>8=8L47;;$>D2=8=;9@>9=J7$D7;=LC

8>9=58$ 3@5J=D7D$ A8D7@$ >$ RhZh$ 4>IO$ !K5;7$ ?5@27@

B_7<K5;45J>P$<=9=_78;$IK5$K>D$859$N778$>A952>9=C

<>446$>I>@D7D$<=9=_78;K=3$I7@7$789=947D$95$>3346$?5@$=9M

NA9$I7@7$ @7TA=@7D$ 95$2779$ 9K7$ <58D=9=58$ 9K>9$ 9K76

K>D$N778$37@2>8789$@7;=D789;$5?$9K7$B_7<K$,73ANC

4=<$?5@$>9$47>;9$9I5$67>@;$>8D$9K>9$9K76$K>D$859$N778

;78978<7D$?5@$>$<@=27$=8$9K7$3@7J=5A;$?=J7$67>@;O

!," (;$>$@7;A49$5?$9K7$(<9M$9K5A;>8D;$5?$375347

I=9K$%45J>P$@73AN4=<$<=9=_78;K=3$IK5$K>D$4=J7D$>44$5@

25;9$ 5?$ 9K7=@$ 4=J7;$ 58$ 9K7$ 97@@=95@6$ 5?$ 9K7$ B_7<K

,73AN4=<M$ ?5A8D$ 9K72;74J7;$ 5??=<=>446$ =874=L=N47$ ?5@

B_7<K$ <=9=_78;K=3$ 7=9K7@$ >;$ >$ @7;A49$ 5?$ >$ <@=2=8>4

@7<5@D$ 5@$ N7<>A;7$ 9K7=@$ @7>4$ @7;=D78<7$ I>;$ 859

2>9<K7D$N6$ 5??=<=>4$ @7;=D78<7$D5<A2789>9=58O$ !K7

J>;9$2>W5@=96$5?$9K5;7$7Q<4AD7D$?@52$B_7<K$<=9=_78C

;K=3$I7@7$,52>M$>8D$=8D77D$2>86$<5227897D$9K>9

9K7$ 4>I$I>;$D7;=L87D$3@7<=;746$?5@$9K7$3A@35;7$5?

9@6=8L$95$?5@<7$,52>$=8$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<$95$L5$95

%45J>P=>O$ !K7$ I5@;9$ 7472789;$ 5?$ 9K7$ (<9$ I7@7

@725J7D$ 9K@5ALK$ 47L>4$ >278D2789;$ =8$ RhhhM$ NA9

@7;7>@<K7@;$ K>J7$ 8597D$ 9K>9$ =8$ 3@><9=<7$ ><<7;;$ 95

B_7<K$ <=9=_78;K=3$ ?@7TA78946$ @72>=8;$ N45<P7D$ ?5@

,52>M$>8D$9K>9$9K7@7$=;$;9=44$>$@>8L7$5?$<58;7TA789

7??7<9;$=8$P76$>@7>;$5?$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$354=<6$=8<4ADC

=8L$7DA<>9=58M$K5A;=8L$>8D$;5<=>4$>;;=;9>8<7O

!-" %9>9747;;87;;$>8D$4><P$5?$D5<A2789;$>258L

,52>$ K>J7$ 859$ N778$ <58?=87D$ 95$ 87I$ -72N7@

%9>97;O$ &8;9>8<7;$5?$ 9K7$3K78527858$5?$;9>9747;;C

87;;$K>J7$N778$@735@97D$>258L$%=89=$>8D$,52>$=8

/7@2>86$ ;=8<7$S5@4D$S>@$ &&$ A89=4$ @7<789$ 67>@;O^f

-5@75J7@M$ 2>86$ 458LC97@2$ @7;=D789$ ,52>$ =8$ /7@C

2>86$K54D$5846$>$97235@>@6$;9>9A;$<>447D$a9547@>97Da

caDA4DA8LadO$($aDA4DA8La$=;$859$>$@7;=D78<7$37@2=9$]

=9$ =;$ 27@746$ >$ ;953$ 58$ 7Q3A4;=58M$ >8D$ =9$ 2A;9$ N7

@787I7D$ >9$ ?@7TA789$ =897@J>4;M$ =8$ ;527$ =8;9>8<7;

>?97@$5846$;7J7@>4$I77P;O^h$-72N7@;$5?$ 9K7$;>27

?>2=46$>@7$5?978$3@5J=D7D$I=9K$ aDA4DA8La$;9>9A;$ ?5@

D=??7@789$ 37@=5D;$ 5?$ 9=27M$27>8=8L$ 9K>9$ >$ K7>D$ 5?

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

^^ !K7$3@=8<=347$9K>9$;9>9747;;87;;$=;$>8>9K72>$K>;$N778$@737>97D46$$>??=@27D$N6$9K7$=897@8>9=58>4$<522A8=96O$(@9=<47$FH$5?$&897@C

8>9=58>4$$B5J78>89$58$B=J=4$>8D$154=9=<>4$,=LK9;$c&BB1,dM$>DD@7;;=8L$9K7$@=LK9;$$5?$<K=4D@78M$;9=3A4>97;$9K>9$a{7|J7@6$<K=4D$K>;$9K7

@=LK9$95$><TA=@7$>$$8>9=58>4=96Oa$!K7$B58J789=58$5?$9K7$,=LK9;$5?$9K7$BK=4D$cB,Bd$;9>97;$>9$$(@9=<47$^j$a!K7$<K=4D$;K>44$N7$@7L=;97@7D

=227D=>9746$>?97@$N=@9K$>8D$$;K>44$K>J7$9K7$@=LK9$?@52$N=@9K$95$>$8>27M$9K7$@=LK9$95$><TA=@7$>$8>9=58>4=96$>8DM$>;$?>@$>;$35;;=N47M

9K7$@=LK9$95$P85I$>8D$N7$<>@7D$?5@$N6$K=;$5@$K7@$3>@789;${OOO|a$($8A2N7@$5?$=897@8>9=58>4$47L>4$$=8;9@A2789;$>DD@7;;$9K7$=;;A7$5?

;9>9747;;87;;$7Q<4A;=J746O$!K7$B58J789=58$58$9K7$,7DA<9=58$5?$%9>9747;;87;;$=8<4AD7;$>$8A2N7@$5?$3@5J=;=58;$>=2=8L$95$3@7J789

;9>9747;;87;;$>;$>$@7;A49$5?$45;;$5?$8>9=58>4=96$DA7$95$>86$<K>8L7$=8$9K7$37@;58>4$;9>9A;$5?$>8$=8D=J=DA>4O

^f B=9=_78;K=3$4>I;$=8$/7@2>86$I7@7$A89=4$Rhhh$N>;7D$;54746$58$D7;<789$>8D$=8<4AD7D$85$3@5J=;=58$?5@$9K7$><TA=;=9=58$5?$<=9=_78C

;K=3$9K@5ALK$N=@9K$58$/7@2>8$97@@=95@6M$>8D$<>;7;$5?$;9>9747;;87;;$I7@7$@735@97D$@7LA4>@46O

^h ($8A2N7@$5?$=897@8>9=58>4$258=95@=8L$N5D=7;$K>J7$7Q3@7;;7D$<58<7@8;$>9$9K7$9@7>92789$5?$858C<=9=_78;$=8$/7@2>86O$+5@$7Q>2C

347M$9K7$'*$B522=9977$>L>=8;9$#4=2=8>9=58$5?$,><=>4$0=;<@=2=8>9=58$K>;$7Q3@7;;7D$$<58<7@8;$>N5A9$>N;78<7$5?$>86$3@597<9=58

><<5@D7D$95$2*"<&$'; 2=85@=96$L@5A3;$@7;=D789$=8$/7@2>86$?5@$458L$37@=5D;$5?$9=27$c;77$B#,0eBeEEfe(DDORHM$RG$(ALA;9$FGGGdO

!K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537b;$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$>L>=8;9$,><=;2$>8D$&89547@>8<7$c#B,&d$8597D$9K>9$>@5A8D$8=87$37@<789$5?$9K7

789=@7$353A4>9=58$c<O$^MGGGMGGG$37@;58;d$D5$859$K>J7$/7@2>8$<=9=_78;K=3$>8D$<>447D$?5@$@7LA4>@=;>9=58$5?$9K7$;9>9A;$5?$$458LC97@2

?5@7=L8$@7;=D789;$c;77$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537b;$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$>L>=8;9$,><=;2$>8D$&89547@>8<7M$%7<58D$,735@9$58$/7@2>86M

>D5397D$58$RY$07<72N7@$FGGG$>8D$2>D7$3AN4=<$58$E$gA46$FGGRM$3O$hdO

fG -=K5PM$U@=L=997M$R7/S$C"+&$%"T(/3*+2U;5"B;.+(.$%*",;0&<1S$%'1(+3*"(+"B*/1(+M$U7@4=8$FGGRM$3O$^ZO$$

Page 39: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

K5A;7K54D$ 2>6$ N7$ >425;9$ <58;9>8946$ TA7A=8L$ ?5@

@787I>4$5?$9K7$;9>9A;$?5@$J>@=5A;$272N7@;$5?$?>2=C

46OfG$ !K7$ aDA4DA8La$ ;9>9A;$ ?@7TA78946$ =8<4AD7;

@7;9@=<9=58;$ 58$ ?@77D52$ 5?$ 25J72789M$ ><<7;;$ 95

7234562789$>8D$J>@=5A;$?5@2;$5?$;5<=>4$>;;=;9>8<7M

>49K5ALK$3@5J=;=58;$J>@6$?@52$;9>97$cD&!>d$95$;9>97O

!4" !K7@7$>@7$85$3AN4=<46$>J>=4>N47$?=LA@7;$58$9K7

959>4$8A2N7@$5?$,52>$IK5$>@7$=8$35;;7;;=58$5?$aDA4C

DA8La$ ;9>9A;$ =8$ /7@2>86O$ &8$ FGGFM$ 9K7$ 8A2N7@$ 5?

375347$I=9K$[9547@>97D\$;9>9A;$I>;$>@5A8D$FF^MGGGM

5?$IK52$RHZMfEf$K>D$N778$4=J=8L$=8$/7@2>86$?5@$>9

47>;9$?=J7$67>@;$>8D$^fMHf^$?5@$25@7$9K>8$978$67>@;O

&8$2>86$<>;7;M$<K=4D@78$I=9K$[DA4DA8L\$;9>9A;$;37>P

?4A789$/7@2>8$>8D$9K7=@$4>8LA>L7$5?$3@=2>@6$7DA<>C

9=58$=;$/7@2>8O$#Q<4A;=58>@6$3@><9=<7;$I=9K$@7;37<9

95$,52>8=$2=L@>89;$K>J7$>4;5$N778$D5<A27897D$=8

(A;9@=>M$IK=4;9$>$4><P$5?$D5<A2789;$=;$>4;5$>$;7@=5A;

3@5N472$>258L$,52>$=8$/@77<7OfR

,6" #Q<4A;=58>@6$ 5N;9><47;$ <@7>97D$ N6$ 4><P$ 5?

D5<A2789;$<>8$N7$D>A89=8L$>8D$=8$2>86$=8;9>8<7;

9K7$4><P$5?$587$D5<A2789$<>8$47>D$95$>$a<K>=8$@7><C

9=58a$=8$IK=<K$9K7$=8D=J=DA>4$=;$A8>N47$95$;7<A@7$?A@C

9K7@$ D5<A2789;O$ !K=;$ 3@5N472$ =;$ @>@746$ >DD@7;;7D

;6;972>9=<>446$N6$L5J7@82789$354=<6M$ >8D$-72N7@

%9>97$L5J7@82789;$ ;K5A4D$ <>@@6$ 5A9$ >$ [D=;<@=2=8>C

9=58$ 3@55?=8L\$ 5?$ 9K7=@$ <=9=_78;K=3$ 3@5<7DA@7;$ 95

78;A@7$9K>9$9K76$<52346$N59K$I=9K$9K7$#'$3@=8<=347;

5?$ 858CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D$ >@7$I=9K=8$ 9K7$ ;<537$ 5?

=897@8>9=58>4$<58J789=58;$58$9K7$9@7>92789$5?$ 972C

35@>@6$>8D$37@2>8789$@7;=D789;O

2$*<$9#70&$8+0#(M#+.$#01+/7+1(*#(M#9(%7

,5" 17@K>3;$9K7$5846$>@7>$=8$IK=<K$#'$LA=D74=87;$58

D>9>$ <5447<9=58$ >8D$ 9K7$ A;7$ 5?$ =8D=<>95@;$ ><P85I4C

7DL7;$9K7$J>4A7$5?$258=95@=8L$354=<6$=23><9;$58$79KC

8=<$ L@5A3;$ =;$IK7@7$ 9K7;7$ @7TA=@7$ 9K7$ 3@5J=;=58$ 5?

D>9>$ 58$ I5278$ N7458L=8L$ 95$ ;A<K$ L@5A3;O$ !KA;M

IK=4;9$9K7$35;;=N=4=96$5?$<5447<9=8L$354=<6C@74>97D$D>9>

58$79K8=<$L@5A3;$ =;$ @7<5L8=;7D$N6$ 9K7$#'M$ =9$ =;$859

;37<=?=7D$7Q34=<=946$=8$9K7$;>27$I>6$>;$=;$9K7$877D$95

258=95@$L78D7@OfF &9$=;$9K7@7?5@7$=@58=<$9K>9$;9>9=;9=<>4

D>9>$58$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>8=$I5278$=8$9K7$;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58$ ;7<95@>4$ ?=74D;$ =;$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$I7>PO$ !K7;7

4><A8>7$ >@7$ >44$ 9K7$ 25@7$ ;=L8=?=<>89$ N7<>A;7$ 9K7

K>8D?A4$ 5?$ ;9AD=7;$ >J>=4>N47$ D7258;9@>97$ 9K>9

,52>8=$ I5278$ ?><7$ 7J78$ 25@7$ D=??=<A49=7;$ 9K>8

N59K$,52>8=$278$>8D$I5278$5?$9K7$2>W5@=96$<52C

2A8=96$=8$><<7;;=8L$7DA<>9=58M$7234562789M$K7>49K

>8D$59K7@$;7@J=<7;$87<7;;>@6$?5@$?A44$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58O

,;" (<<5@D=8L$ 95$>$8A2N7@$5?$ @735@9;M$ >$ ;=L8=?=C

<>89$ 3@535@9=58$ 5?$ ,52>8=$ I5278$ >@7$ A872C

34567DOfE ($ D=;9A@N=8L$ ?7>9A@7$ =;$ 9K7$ @735@97D$ K=LK

47J74$ 5?$ A87234562789$ >258L$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ JA487@>C

N47$ I5278$ ;A<K$ >;$ ;=8L47$ 259K7@;M$ I=D5I7D

I5278$ >8D$ J=<9=2;$ 5?$ D527;9=<$ J=5478<7OfH &8$ 9K7

>N;78<7$ 5?$ ;A=9>N47$ 7234562789$ 5335@9A8=9=7;M

,52>8=$ I5278$ =8$ ;7J7@>4$ <5A89@=7;$ =8<4AD=8L$ UA4C

L>@=>M$ 9K7$ B_7<K$ ,73AN4=<$ >8D$ %45J>P=>$ K>J7

78L>L7D$=8$3@5;9=9A9=58O$B58<52=9>89$I=9K$9K=;$=;$9K7

3@5N472$5?$ 9@>??=<P=8L$5?$,52>8=$I5278M$ >8$ =;;A7

9K>9$ K>;$ 859$ 679$ @7<7=J7D$ ;A;9>=87D$ =897@7;9$ ?@52

=897@8>9=58>4$ 5@L>8=;>9=58;$ >8D$ 8>9=58>4$ L5J7@8C

2789;O$!K>9$;>=DM$=9$=;$=237@>9=J7$9K>9$>89=C9@>??=<P=8L

27>;A@7;$D5$859$ ?77D$ =895$I=D746CK74D$;97@759637;

>N5A9$,52>8=$<@=2=8>4=96O

,=" +=74D$258=95@=8LM$K5I7J7@M$>4;5$=8D=<>97;$9K>9

,52>8=$I5278$ >@7$ =8$2>86$ =8;9>8<7;$ 9K7$ 3@=2>@6

N@7>DI=887@$=8$>$?>2=46M$5?978$I5@P=8L$>9$9K@77$5@$?5A@

W5N;$=8$9K7$zL@>6X$7<58526$=8$5@D7@$95$;A335@9$?>2=C

4=7;O$ %527$ ;A<K$ ><9=J=9=7;$ =8<4AD7$ D55@C95CD55@$ ;744C

=8LM$ D527;9=<$ I5@PM$ 2>P=8L$ 9@>D=9=58>4$ K>8D=<@>?9;

>8D$ >L@=<A49A@>4$ I5@PO$ #Q<4A;=58$ ?@52$ 9K7$ ?5@2>4

4>N5A@$ 2>@P79$ =;$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ I=D7;3@7>D$ =8$ 34><7;

;A<K$ >;$ 9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<$IK7@7$ >8$ 7Q<4A;=58>@6

<=9=_78;K=3$4>I$<589=8A7;$95$K>J7$87L>9=J7$7??7<9;$58

9K7$ >N=4=96$ 5?$ ,52>$ 95$ ?A446$ 3>@9=<=3>97$ =8$ ;5<=796O

S5278$I5@P=8L$ 3@=2>@=46$ =8$ 9K7$ L@>6$ 7<58526$ >@7

J7@6$?@7TA78946$7Q<4AD7D$?@52$>$@>8L7$5?$3@597<9=58;

;A<K$ >;$ 2>97@8=96$ N787?=9;M$ 378;=58;$ >8D$ 27D=<>4

47>J7M$>8D$9K76$>@7$J7@6$JA487@>N47$95$7Q345=9>9=58O

""

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

fR %77$ #A@537>8$ ,52>$ ,=LK9;$ B7897@$ >8D$ /@77P$ "74;=8P=$-58=95@M$'-0&!*!)+ E70/&.*"!1@+ FG;-,>*!)+ $"%&+ *!+ 5/00;0M$ B5A89@6

,735@9;$%7@=7;$*5O$RFM$$(3@=4$FGGFO

fF +5@$7Q>2347M$L5>4;$5?$#A@537>8$'8=58$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$354=<=7;$$=8<4AD7$9K7$3@5259=58$5?$a9K7$;5<=>4$=897L@>9=58$5?$I5278$>8D

278$>9$$@=;P$5?$?><=8L$37@;=;9789$35J7@96M$?5@$7Q>2347$N7<>A;7$9K76$K>J7$>$$D=;>N=4=96$5@$?0-"!)+."+&+)/",7+0G70/*0!;*!)+7&/.*;#

,-&/+*!.0)/&.*"!++7/"?-0%1Ha$c;77$#A@537>8$'8=58$D5<A2789M$a+=LK9$>L>=8;9$35J7@96$>8D$$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$CC$07?=8=9=58$5?$>33@53@=C

>97$5NW7<9=J7;aM$U@A;;74;M$EG$*5J72N7@$FGGGM$723K>;=;$>DD7DdO

fE %77$?5@$7Q>2347$aV6_PA2$=897@798=<P6<K$J_9>KAj$_3@wJ>aM$U@85j$->;>@6P5J>$'8=J7@_=9>M$FGGFM$3O$HYO

fH 1@7;789>9=58$ N6$ g788=?7@$ !>8>P>$ 58$ 9K7$ ,52>8=$S5278X;$ #234562789 >9$ $ 9K7$S5@4D$ U>8Pe)378$ %5<=796$ &8;9=9A97$ ,52>

S5278X;$+5@A2$UAD>37;9M$gA87$FhM$FGGE$c58$?=47$I=9K$#,,BdO$

Page 40: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

,A" #Q978D=8L$2=<@5C<@7D=9$ 95$I5278$K>;$N778

;778$ >;$ 587$ 35;;=N47$ ;9@>97L6$ ?5@$ =23@5J=8L$ 9K7=@

7<5852=<$ =8D7378D78<7O$ (;$ 9K7$ B522=9977$ 58

#TA>4$ )335@9A8=9=7;$ ?5@$ S5278$ >8D$ -78$ 5?$ 9K7

B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537X;$1>@4=>2789>@6$(;;72N46$8597;

[7Q=;9=8L$2=<@5C?=8>8<7$;<K727;$;K5I$9K>9$I5278

>;$ >$ @A47$ >@7$ N7997@$ 9K>8$ 278$ >9$ @73>6=8L$ 45>8;M

7;37<=>446$ =8$ 9K7$ <5897Q9$ 5?$ ;<K727;$ N>;7D$ 58$ >

L@5A3$5@$58$2A9A>4$;54=D>@=96O$&8$>DD=9=58M$=9$>337>@;

9K>9$45>8;$95$I5278$K>J7$>$L@7>97@$P85<PC58$7??7<9M

>;$I5278$;77$ 95$ =9$ 9K>9$ <K=4D@78$N787?=9$ ?@52$ 9K7

=8<@7>;7$=8$9K7$259K7@X;$=8<527O\fY

,B" (49K5ALK$9K7$[=8<@7>;7D$;<K554=8L$5?$259KC

7@;$K>;$>$27>;A@>N47$=23><9$58$9K7$K7>49K$5?$9K7=@

<K=4D@78M$58$9K7$?A9A@7$;<K554=8L$5?$9K7$<K=4DM$>8D$58

9K7$<K=4Db;$>DA49$3@5DA<9=J=96\MfZ @7;7>@<K$;K5I;$9K>9

2A<K$877D;$95$N7$D587$95$78;A@7$9K7$?A44$>8D$<52C

34797$><<7;;$5?$,52>$L=@4;$95$7DA<>9=58O

,!" +5@$7Q>2347M$=8$9K7$%A95$)@=_>@=$2A8<=3>4=96

=8$ -><7D58=>$ c9K7$ N=LL7;9$ ,52>8=$ <522A8=96$ =8

-><7D58=>dM$ IK=47$ ;<K554$ 3>@9=<=3>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>8=

L=@4;$>8D$N56;$=8$3@=2>@6$;<K554$=;$>425;9$7TA>4$=8

9K7$ 45I7@$ L@>D7;M$ L=@4;$ >@7$ 5N4=L7D$ 95$ K743$ =8$ 9K7

K5A;7$5@$ 95$L79$2>@@=7D$>9$J7@6$65A8L$>L7;$ c?@52

RFCR^$67>@;d$>8DM$>;$>$@7;A49M$5?978$D@53$5A9$=8$9K7

K=LK7@$L@>D7;Of^ -5@75J7@M$[>$,52>8=$L=@4$IK5$4=J7;

=8$ 9K7$ LK7995M$ 4=P7$ K7@$ 3>@789;$ >8D$ L@>8D3>@789;

N7?5@7$ K7@M$ P85I;$ 85$ 59K7@$ 4=?7O$ #J7@6D>6$ ;K7

2779;$375347$IK5$D=D$859$L5$95$;<K554$5@$D=D$859

?=8=;K$>8D$375347$IK5$>@7$A87234567D$5@$37@?5@2

A8;P=447D$ W5N;\Off !KA;M$ =8$ 9K7$ >N;78<7$ 5?$ 35;=9=J7

@547$25D74;$>8D$27895@;M$A8D7@$9K7$I7=LK9$5?$9@>C

D=9=58;$@5597D$=8$3>9@=>@<K6M$<5A347D$I=9K$9K7$N@5>D

=;;A7$5?$ @><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58M$,52>8=$L=@4;$ @72>=8

;7@=5A;46$ K>8D=<>337D$ ?@52$ 3>@9=<=3>9=8L$ ?A446$ =8M

>8D$78W56=8L$9K7$N787?=9;$5?M$7DA<>9=58O$&9$=;$>@LA7D

9K>9$D7;7L@7L>9=58$5?$;<K554;$>8D$=897@><9=58$I=9K

375347$ ?@52$ D=J7@;7$ N><PL@5A8D;$ =;$ 587$ I>6$ 5?

N@7>P=8L$9K=;$<6<47$5?$D=;>DJ>89>L7Ofh

,," &8$ 9K7$ K7>49K<>@7$ >@78>M$ 9K7$ ,)-#',)1#

3@5L@>227$ cRhhfCFGGGdM$ 3@52597D$ N6$!"#$%&'( #)*!+,#& >8D$<5C?A8D7D$N6$ 9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58M$<>@C

@=7D$5A9$9I5$723=@=<>4$;9AD=7;$C$N59K$;5<=545L=<>4$>8D

TA>89=9>9=J7$C$=8$9K@77$5?$9K7$<5A89@=7;$9K>9$3>@9=<=3>9C

7D$=8$9K7$3@5W7<9$c+@>8<7M$%3>=8$>8D$/@77<7dO$!K7$D>9>

58$ 9K7$ K7>49K$ 5?$ ;5<=>446$ 7Q<4AD7D$ ,52>8=$ I5278

;K5I$>$K=LK$8A2N7@$5?$8>9A@>4$>N5@9=58;M$9K7$4><P$5?

<589@><739=58$cZYld$>8D$7Q9@72746$K=LK$@>97;$5?$<K=4D

cFOEYld$>8D$8758>9>4$ cFld$25@9>4=96M$IK=<K$ =;$7=LK9

9=27;$K=LK7@$9K>8$9K>9$5?$9K7$L787@>4$353A4>9=58OhG

,-" ($<@5;;C<A99=8L$9K727$9K>9$K>;$727@L7D$?@52

@7;7>@<K$=8$J>@=5A;$<5A89@=7;$=;$9K7$7Q9789$5?$D=;<@=2C

=8>9=58$ ,52>8=$ I5278$ ?><7$ =8$ ><<7;;=8L$ K7>49K

;7@J=<7;O$ &8$2>86$5?$ 9K7$<5A89@=7;$;A@J767DM$,52>

37@<7=J7$;9@58L$>89=C,52>8=$;789=2789$58$9K7$3>@9$5?

K7>49K$;7@J=<7$3@5J=D7@;M$;5$9K76$D5$859$><<7;;$27DC

=<>4$;7@J=<7;$A847;;$9K7@7$=;$>$4=?7C9K@7>978=8L$727@C

L78<6O$&9$>337>@;$9K>9$9K=;$=;;A7$2>6$K>J7$>$L@7>97@

=23><9$58$,52>8=$I5278$9K>8$58$278O

,4" ,52>8=$ I5278$ >4;5$ 5?978$ ?>44$ J=<9=2$ 95

D527;9=<$J=5478<7O$&9$=;$5846$J7@6$@7<78946$9K>9$L5JC

7@82789;$ =8$ 2>86$ 5?$ 9K7$ <5A89@=7;$ ;9AD=7D$ K>J7

><P85I47DL7D$ 9K7$ 3@5N472$ 5?$ D527;9=<$ J=5478<7

L787@>446O$ +5@$ =8;9>8<7M$ 9K7$ &897@8>9=58>4$ "74;=8P=

+5A8D>9=58$5?$"A2>8$,=LK9;$@7<5@D;$>$4><P$5?$;K74C

97@;$ >8D$ >$ 4><P$5?$ 3@5?7;;=58>4;$ C$ =8<4AD=8L$354=<7M

D5<95@;$>8D$;5<=>4$I5@P7@;$C$9@>=87D$95$D7>4$I=9K$J=<C

9=2;$5?$D527;9=<$J=5478<7$ =8$ 9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<OhR

/=J78$9K7$D=;9@A;9$5?$3AN4=<$5??=<=>4;$>258L$,52>8=

I5278M$ =9$ =;$A84=P746$ 9K>9$7J78$IK7@7$;K7497@;$>@7

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

fY B522=9977$58$#TA>4$)335@9A8=9=7;$?5@$S5278$>8D$-78$[S5278$>8D$2=<@5C45>8;\$3>@>$HRM$HFM$05<O$hZhZ$cRE$+7N@A>@6$FGGEd

>J>=4>N47$>9$$K993jee>;;72N46O<57O=89e05<A2789;eS5@P=8L05<;eD5<GEe#0)BhZhZOK92$c4>;9$J=;=97D$58$(3@=4$F$FGGHdO

fZ -.$#/f^ }>P4=8>$0A@2=;X;$ 3@7;789>9=58$ 58$,52>8=$S5278X;$ #234562789$ >9$ 9K7$S5@4D$U>8Pe)378$%5<=796$ &8;9=9A97$,52>$S5278X;

+5@A2$UAD>37;9M$gA87$FhM$FGGE$c58$?=47$I=9K$#,,BdO

ff `>4=8P>$V>;=47J>X;$3@7;789>9=58$58$,52>8=$S5278X;$#234562789$>9$ 9K7$S5@4D$U>8Pe)378$%5<=796$ &8;9=9A97$,52>$S5278X;

+5@A2$UAD>37;9M$gA87$FhM$FGGE$c58$?=47$I=9K$#,,BdO

fh -.$#/hG .>2>@>M$+>@=Dj$012%%3'(2+4('&$,'()5(6(*2('2,5"(#)(7&7+*25$&,'(8&9:;'$<2,)'(9$<=2,5)'(),('$5+25$&,(#)(<=2,#)()4%*+'$&,(#2,'(5=&$'

72>'(#1?+=&7)/(?'72<,)@(A=2,%)@(B=3%)/ -vD7<=8;$DA$-58D7O$1>@=;M$ Rhhh$>8D$/=4LM$(8>N7447j$C&,,")'(9"#$%2*)'()5( '&%$&D

#"9&<=27E$F+)'G(*)'(7&7+*25$&,'(8&9':;'$<2,)'(9$<=2,5)'(),('$5+25$&,(#)(<=2,#)()4%*+'$&,(#2,'(5=&$'(72>'(#1?+=&7)(D(?'72<,)@

A=2,%)@(B=3%)/(-vD7<=8;$DA$-58D7O$1>@=;M$RhhhO

hR sA597D$ =8$ a,52>8=$S5278$ ?@52$ B789@>4$ >8D$ #>;97@8$ #A@537j$ ($ z+5A@9K$S5@4DXM$ 5@$ #Q37@=78<7$ 5?$ -A49=347$ 0=;<@=2=8>9=58a

c,7?AL77$S5278b;$,7;5A@<7$1@5W7<9M$->@<K$FGGFd$3OhfO

Page 41: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

7;9>N4=;K7DM$ ,52>8=$ I5278$ I=44$ K>J7$ <5234797

><<7;;$95$9K72M$A847;;$;A335@97D$N6$59K7@$35;=9=J7

27>;A@7;O$!K7$#'-B$@735@9$58$9K7$;9>97$5?$,52>8=

I5278X;$K7>49K$@7<52278D;$L@7>97@$<5C5@D=8>9=58

I=9K$,52>8=$I5278X;$*/);$>8D$9@>=8=8L$?5@$K7>49K

27D=>95@;$ >;$ ;527$ 5?$ 9K7$ ;9@>97L=7;$ 9K>9$ L5J7@8C

2789;$<>8$>D539$95$D7>4$I=9K$D527;9=<$J=5478<7OhF

-6" +=8>446M$9K7$;73>@>97$5@$858C9@7>92789$5?$L78C

D7@$ >8D$ @><7$ =8$ 2>86$ ;6;972;$ 5?$ D>9>$ <5447<9=58

A8D7@2=87;$ L5J7@82789>4$ 354=<=7;$ 58$ ,52>O$ /5JC

7@82789$354=<=7;M$5?978$D7J74537D$N6$ @7?7@78<7$ 95

9K7;7$;9>9=;9=<;M$ ?@7TA78946$ ?>=4$ 95$>DD@7;;$9K7$D5AC

N47$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ ?><7D$ N6$,52>8=$I5278O$-5;9

L5J7@82789$ 354=<=7;$ 58$ ,52>$ >@7$ ;=4789$ 58$ 9K7

=;;A7$5?$L78D7@$7TA>4=96M$5@$=8<4AD7$5846$=8>D7TA>97

3@5J=;=58;O$SK7@7$L78D7@$2>997@;$>@7$>DD@7;;7D$=8

354=<=7;M$9K76$>@7$?@7TA78946$<58?=87D$95$=;;A7;$@74>9C

7D$95$2>@@=>L7M$9K7$A;7$5?$<589@><739=58$5@$3>@789>4

@7;358;=N=4=96O$/5J7@82789$ ;9@>97L=7;$ >@7$ 7;;789=>4

95$=23@5J=8L$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>8=$I5278M$K5IC

7J7@M$>8D$L5J7@82789;$;K5A4D$=8<5@35@>97$>$L78D7@

37@;37<9=J7$ =895$ 9K7=@$ ,52>$ ;9@>97L=7;M$ NA=4D=8L

A358$ ><<A@>97$ @7;7>@<K$ IK=<K$ N7997@$ =D789=?=7;

I5278X;$=897@7;9;$>8D$9K7$=;;A7;$9K>9$>??7<9$9K72M

N7658D$9K7$9@>D=9=58>4$@547$5?$2>97@8>4$<>@=8LOhE

&('181$0#7<<9$001*2#+97\$''$9#

8(%%/*1+1$0#7*<#1*<1\1</7'0

-5" &8$<5A89@=7;$IK7@7$,52>$>@7$852>D=<M$ 9K7@7K>J7$5?978$N778$?>=4A@7;$95$3@5J=D7$>D7TA>97$;7@JC

=<7;M$3>@9=<A4>@46$=8$9K7$?=74D;$5?$K5A;=8LM$7DA<>9=58

>8D$K7>49K<>@7O$%527$<5A89@=7;$K>J7$<5235A8DC

7D$9K=;$354=<6$?>=4A@7$N6$>D539=8L$59K7@$354=<=7;$9K>9

K>J7$>$D79@=2789>4$7??7<9O$+5@$7Q>2347M$ =8$&@74>8D

>8D$/@77<7M$9@7;3>;;=8L$=;$>$<@=2=8>4$5??78<7$>8D

852>D=<$,52>$5@$!@>J7447@;$2>6$N7$D=;3@535@9=58C

>9746$>??7<97D$N6$9@7;3>;;$4>I;$N7<>A;7$5?$3>@>4474

?>=4A@7;$95$3@5J=D7$47L>4$K>49=8L$;=97;O$B522789=8L

58$;=2=4>@$3@><9=<7;$=8$9K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52M$#A@5C

37>8$B5A@9$5?$"A2>8$,=LK9;$gADL7$U587445$8597Dj

a"7@7M$I7$>@7$<58?@5897D$I=9K$>$;=9A>9=58$=8$IK=<K

>8$=8D=J=DA>4$I>;$b789@>337Db$=895$N@7>P=8L$9K7$4>I

N7<>A;7$ >$ 3AN4=<$ >A9K5@=96$ I>;$ 3@597<97D$ =8$ =9;

5I8$N@7><KOahH

-;" '8D7@$>$87I$'O`O$FGGH$U=44$c!K7$14>88=8L$>8D

B52378;>9=58$U=44d$ =9$I=44$ N7$ 35;;=N47$ ?5@$ 34>88=8L

>A9K5@=9=7;$ 95$ ;7@J7$ a97235@>@6$ ;953$ 859=<7;a$ ?5@

D7J74532789$9K>9$K>;$85$34>88=8L$<58;789O$!K7@7$=;

3>@9=<A4>@$ <58<7@8$ N7<>A;7$ 9K7@7$ =;$ D5<A2789>@6

7J=D78<7$ 95$ =8D=<>97$ 9K>9$ /63;=7;$ =8$ U@=9>=8$ >@7

@7?A;7D$34>88=8L$37@2=;;=58$?5@$87I$D7J74532789;

?>@$25@7$5?978$9K>8$858C/63;=7;OhY #J78$IK7@7$;=97

3@5J=;=58$ =;$2>D7$>J>=4>N47$ ?5@$852>D=<$<522A8=C

9=7;M$?><=4=9=7;$c7;37<=>446$58$54D7@$;=97;d$>@7$?@7TA789C

46$ =8>D7TA>97$ =8$8A2N7@$>8D$;AN;9>8D>@D$ =8$97@2;

5?$=8?@>;9@A<9A@>4$3@5J=;=58;O$-5@75J7@M$9K7$@7;7>@<K

<58?=@27D$9K>9$=8$;=9A>9=58;$IK7@7$;=97$3@5J=;=58$=;

2>D7$ ?5@$ 852>D=<$ <522A8=9=7;M$ 9K7$ 45<>9=58$ 5?

;=97;$ =;$ ?@7TA78946$ c^Gld$ 58$ 2>@L=8>4$ 4>8DM$ >8D

;527$3AN4=<$;=97;$>@7$=8$359789=>446$D>8L7@5A;$78J=C

@582789;O$)87$;A<K$;=97$=8$I7;9$.58D58$I>;$NA=49

=8$Rh^H$D=@7<946$A8D7@$>$@>=;7D$2595@I>6$<52347QO

-=" ($ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ 37@;58;$ ;A@J767D$ ?5@$ 9K=;

;9AD6$8597D$9K>9$=8$>DD=9=58$95$J=54>9=58;$>8D$;5<=>4

7Q<4A;=58$ ;A??7@7D$ >;$ >$ @7;A49$ 5?$ ?5@<7D$ 7J=<9=58M

9K7$@737>97D$>337>@>8<7$5?$27D=>$>@9=<47;$58$9K7

45<>4$ 7Q3A4;=58$ 5?$ 852>D=<$ ,52>8=$ >8D$ !@>J7447@

L@5A3;$5?978$;=L8=?=<>8946$K7=LK9787D$>89=C,52>8=

;789=2789$>8D$7Q><7@N>97D$>$J=<=5A;$<=@<47$IK7@7C

=8$ 354=<6$ 2>P7@;$ I7@7$ ;AN;7TA78946$ A8>N47$ 95

=23472789$;=97$3@5J=;=58;$ ?5@$852>D=<$,52>$>8D

!@>J7447@;$45<>446O

-A" &8$+@>8<7M$!@>J7447@;$>@7$@7TA=@7D$95$3@5<A@7$>

a9@>J744=8L$37@2=9aM$IK=<K$3>@>D5Q=<>446$ =235;7;$>8

5N4=L>9=58$58$587$79K8=<$L@5A3$?5@$IK>9$=;$>$L787@>4

@=LK9M$ 9K7$ @=LK9$ 95$ ?@77D52$ 5?$ 25J72789O$ +A@9K7@C

25@7M$ 9K7@7$ >@7$ ;527$ <58<7@8;$ 9K>9$ 7J78$ 858C

852>D=<$,52>$2>6$N7$@7TA=@7D$95$3@5<A@7$;A<K$>

37@2=9$=8$;527$>@7>;$>8D$>$8A2N7@$5?$@A47;$@74>9=8L

95$9K7$87<7;;=96$5?$K>J=8L$>$37@2>8789$>DD@7;;$ =8

5@D7@$ 95$J597$3@7<4AD7$2>86$!@>J7447@;$ ?@52$N7=8L

>N47$95$7Q7@<=;7$9K7$@=LK9$95$J597O$V7@6$?7I$5??=<=>446

3@5J=D7D$;=97;$=8$+@>8<7$=8<4AD7$>D7TA>97$3@5J=;=58

5?$I>97@M$747<9@=<=96$>8D$59K7@$N>;=<$;7@J=<7;O$+=8>446M

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

hF #A@537>8$-58=95@=8L$B789@7$58$,><=;2$>8D$n7853K5N=>M$aU@7>P=8L$9K7$U>@@=7@;$C$,52>8=$S5278$>8D$(<<7;;$95$1AN4=<$"7>49K

B>@7aM$V=788>M$FGGEM$33O$ZECZHO

hE !O(25hH %73>@>97$53=8=58$5?$gADL7$U587445M$BK>32>8$JO$!K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52M$(334=<>9=58$85O$F^FEfehYM$gADL2789$58$27@=9;M$Rf$g>8AC

>@6$FGGRO

hY %77$-5@@=;M$,><K74$>8D$.AP7$B472789;M$H'"V%&'"E;.'W"#%*"?$;+;0($.";<"X8).8"&+2"#/&-*11*/"?+$&0)0*+'.M$U@=;954j$!K7$154=<6

1@7;;M$FGGFO

Page 42: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

!@>J7447@;$7Q37@=78<7$5N;9@A<9=58$N7<>A;7$5?$5335C

;=9=58$N6$ 45<>4$ >A9K5@=9=7;$IK78$ 9@6=8L$ 95$3A@<K>;7

4>8DM$>8DM$=?$;A<<7;;?A4M$?@7TA78946$7Q37@=78<7$D=??=C

<A49=7;$ =8$ ;7<A@=8L$ 3@5J=;=58$ 5?$ I>97@M$ 747<9@=<=96M

I>;97$@725J>4$>8D$59K7@$3AN4=<46$3@5J=D7D$;7@J=<7;O

-B# " !K7@7$ =;$ >$D>8L7@$ 9K>9$354=<=7;$ >DD@7;;=8L

852>D=;2$2>6$N7$>334=7D$95$,52>8=$<522A8=9=7;

@7L>@D47;;$5?$IK79K7@$9K76$>@7$852>D=<$5@$859O$+5@

7Q>2347M$>$W5=89$2=8=;97@=>4$D7<=;=58$5?$9K7$-=8=;97@;

?5@$ 9K7$ &897@=5@$ >8D$ 5?$ "7>49K$ 5?$ /@77<7M$ 789=947D

a%>8=9>@6$ 3@5J=;=58$ ?5@$ 9K7$ 5@L>8=;7D$ @745<>9=58$ 5?

I>8D7@=8L$ 852>D;ahZ >8D$3@5J=D=8L$ @7LA4>9=58;$58

;=97$3@5J=;=58;M$K>;$@735@97D46$N778$A;7D$@737>97DC

46$ 95$7Q374$,52>$?@52$2A8=<=3>4=9=7;O$%527$,52>

K>J7$7J78$N778$<@=2=8>446$3@5;7<A97D$?5@$=8?@=8L=8L

9K7$%>8=9>@6$1@5J=;=58Oh^

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

hZ ,7?O$*5O$(YeZhZeFYOHCRROYOfEO

h^ %6;972=<$J=54>9=58;$5?$9K7$@=LK9$95$>D7TA>97$K5A;=8L$?5@$,52>$=;$<A@@78946$9K7$;ANW7<9$5?$>$<5447<9=J7$<5234>=89$>L>=8;9$/@77<7

N6$9K7$#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@$N7?5@7$9K7$#A@537>8$B522=9977$5?$%5<=>4$$,=LK9;$A8D7@$9K7$#A@537>8$%5<=>4$BK>@97@O

Page 43: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

5" !K=;$ ;7<9=58$ 5?$ 9K7$ @735@9$ =D789=?=7;$ 9K727;

727@L=8L$?@52$BK>397@$HM$IK=<K$>@7$?><95@;$=8$7=9K7@

9K7$ ;A<<7;;$ 5?$ 354=<=7;$ >DD@7;;=8L$ ,52>$ =897L@>C

9=58$5@$?><95@;$=8$9K7=@$?>=4A@7O$!K7;7$9K727;$>@7$9K78

A;7D$=8$BK>397@$Z$95$D79>=4$@7<52278D>9=58;$?5@$9K7

>99789=58$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58M$ -72N7@$ %9>97;

>8D$<=J=4$;5<=796$><95@;O

%1*(91+)#9$8(2*1+1(*

;" &;;A7;$5?$2=85@=96$79K8=<$;9>9A;$>8D$ @7<5L8=9=58

5?$ ,52>$ >8D$ 59K7@$ L@5A3;$ 37@<7=J7D$ >;$ a/63;=7;a

<589=8A7$95$<K>4478L7$>$8A2N7@$5?$-72N7@$%9>97;M

=8<4AD=8L$ NA9$ 859$ 87<7;;>@=46$ 4=2=97D$ 95M$ +@>8<7Mhf

/7@2>86Mhh /@77<7MRGG 9K7$*79K7@4>8D;RGR >8D$%45J>C

P=>$>8DM$>;$8597D$>N5J7M$&@74>8DO$#J78$;527$<5A8C

9@=7;$ I=9K$ 7Q978;=J7$ 2=85@=96$ @=LK9;$ 3@597<9=58

;6;972;M$ ;A<K$ >;$"A8L>@6MRGF <589=8A7$ 95$I=9KK54D

<7@9>=8$P76$7472789;$5?$2=85@=96$@=LK9;$IK7@7$,52>

>@7$<58<7@87DO$!K7@7$=;$>$3@7;;=8L$877D$95$3@5J=D7

?A44$@7<5L8=9=58$95$,52>8=$>8D$59K7@$;=2=4>@46$;=9A>9C

7D$2=85@=9=7;$ =8$ >44$ -72N7@$ %9>97;M$ 87I$ >8D$ 54DM

I=9K5A9$>@N=9@>@6$4=2=9>9=58O

'78O#(M#0+7+10+187'#<7+7#(*#9(%73=" !K7@7$=;$>8$>425;9$<5234797$4><P$5?$5??=<=>4M$3ANC

4=<46$>J>=4>N47$>8D$@74=>N47$,52>C;37<=?=<$D>9>$5?$@747C

J>8<7$ 95$#'$;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$>8D$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58

354=<6O$ &8$;527$<5A89@=7;M$ 9K7@7$ =;$>$;=L8=?=<>89$2=;C

<58<739=58$ >258L$ @7;7>@<K7@;M$ >;$ I744$ >;$ 354=<6

2>P7@;$ >8D$L5J7@82789$5??=<=>4;M$ 95$ 9K7$7??7<9$ 9K>9

<5447<9=8L$D>9>$58$,52>M$>8D$59K7@$79K8=<$2=85@=9=7;M

J=54>97;$D>9>$3@597<9=58$4>I;$>8D$I5A4D$9K7@7?5@7$859

N7$ 47L>4ORGE &8$ =9;$D>9>$3@597<9=58$@A47;M$K5I7J7@M$ 9K7

#'$K>;$<58;=;978946$>??=@27D$9K>9$;A<K$@A47;$>3346$95

37@;58>4$D>9>M$859$ 95$>LL@7L>97$D>9>$>N5A9$L@5A3;M

85@$D>9>$D=;>LL@7L>97D$N6$79K8=<=96$5@$59K7@$<@=97@=>ORGH

($ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ =897@8>9=58>4$ 258=95@=8L$ N5D=7;$ K>J7

N59K$L787@>446$<>447D$?5@$9K7$3@5J=;=58$5?$D>9>$58$9K7

;=9A>9=58$5?$I7>P$79K8=<$L@5A3;$>;$I744$>;$@737>97DC

46$<>447D$58$;9>97;$CC$=8<4AD=8L$#A@537>8$'8=58$-72C

N7@$%9>97;$CC$95$3@5J=D7$;9>9=;9=<>4$D>9>$58$9K7$;=9A>9=58

5?$79K8=<$L@5A3;$=8$J>@=5A;$;7<95@>4$?=74D;ORGY

A" (;$ 3>@9$ 5?$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58

3@5<7;;7;$>L@77D$>9$9K7$.=;N58$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4$=8

FGGGM$ L5J7@82789;$ ;K5A4D$3@5J=D7$D>9>$ @74>9=8L$ 95

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

YO$1).&Bi$B"(..#*/#%

hf +@>8<7$D57;$859$47L>446$@7<5L8=;7$9K7$7Q=;978<7$5?$2=85@=9=7;$58$+@78<K$97@@=95@6M$85@$LA>@>8977$>86$2=85@=96$@=LK9;O

hh +5@$9K7$3A@35;7;$5?$2=85@=96$@=LK9;M$/7@2>86$@7<5L8=;7;$5846$a/7@2>8$%=89=$>8D$,52>aM$7Q<4AD=8L$9K7@7?5@7$,52>$5?$?5@7=L8

N=@9K$?@52$2=85@=96$@=LK9;$3@597<9=58;O

RGG /@77<7$K>D$859$@>9=?=7D$9K7$+@>27I5@P$B58J789=58$?5@$9K7$1@597<9=58$5?$*>9=58>4$-=85@=9=7;$>;$5?$+7N@A>@6$FGGHM$>8D$9K7$/@77P

L5J7@82789$K>;$58$>$8A2N7@$5?$@7<789$5<<>;=58;$=8D=<>97D$9K>9$=9$TA7;9=58;$9K7$=D7>$9K>9$/@77<7$=;$>$2A49=<A49A@>4$;5<=796O$+5@

7Q>2347M$;77$c#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$>L>=8;9$,><=;2$>8D$&89547@>8<7$c#B,&dM$=*$;+2",*);/'";+"X/**$*M$B,&$cFGGGd$EFM$(D5397D

58$ RG$ 07<72N7@$ RhhhM$ >J>=4>N47$ >9j$ K993jeeIIIO<57O=89e!e#eKA2>8p@=LK9;e#<@=eRC#B,&eFCB5A89@6CN6C<5A89@6p>33@5><Ke/@77<7eO

!K7$L5J7@82789X;$;9>972789;$<>8$N7$?5A8D$=8$9K7$>887Q$95$9K7$@735@9Od

RGR (;$ 5?$ +7N@A>@6$ FGGHM$*79K7@4>8D;$ K>D$ 859$ 679$ @>9=?=7D$ 9K7$ +@>27I5@P$ B58J789=58$ 58$ 9K7$ 1@597<9=58$ 5?$*>9=58>4$-=85@=9=7;M

D7;3=97$K>J=8L$;=L87D$9K7$B58J789=58$=8$RhhYO

RGF (49K5ALK$"A8L>@6$3@5J=D7;$7Q978;=J7$LA>@>8977;$?5@$c858C2=L@>89d$2=85@=9=7;M$>;$5?$(A9A28$FGGE$"A8L>@6$K>D$?>=47D$95$=8<4AD7

^$5?$=9;$RE$5??=<=>446$@7<5L8=;7D$2=85@=9=7;$c=8<4AD=8L$,52>d$58$4=;9;$5?$@7<5L8=;7D2=85@=9=7;$?5@$9K7$3A@35;7;$5?$9K7$#A@537>8

BK>@97@$58$,7L=58>4$>8D$-=85@=96$.>8LA>L7;O

RGE +5@$7Q>2347M$ =8$ =9;$ @7;358;7$95$9K7$)3=8=58$5?$ 9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537b;$+@>27I5@P$B58J789=58$58$9K7$1@597<9=58$5?$*>9=58>4

-=85@=9=7;$(DJ=;5@6$B522=9977M$9K7$/7@2>8$/5J7@82789$;9>97D$9K>9$a/7@2>86$<5A4D$859$<58;=D7@$<5447<9=8L$>86$;A<K$D>9>$DA7

95$N>;=<$47L>4$<58;=D7@>9=58;a$cB522789;$N6$9K7$+7D7@>4$,73AN4=<$5?$/7@2>86$58$9K7$)3=8=58$5?$9K7$(DJ=;5@6$B522=9977$58$9K7

+@>27I5@P$B58J789=58$?5@$9K7$1@597<9=58$5?$*>9=58>4$-=85@=9=7;M$)3=8=58$58$/7@2>86$cRh9K$gA46$FGGFdM$@7?7@78<7$/V!eB)-e&*+e

)1e&cFGGFdGGfdM$%7<9=58$&&&M$,7$(@9O$EM$8A2N7@$^YO

Page 44: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

978$a3@=2>@6$=8D=<>95@;a$>8D$7=LK9$a;7<58D>@6$=8D=<>C

95@;aORGZ (49K5ALK$D>9>$3@597<9=58$@A47;$;K5A4D$=8$3@=8C

<=347$ >445I$ 9K7$ <5447<9=58$ >8D$ 3AN4=<>9=58$ 5?$ D>9>

D=;>LL@7L>97D$ N6$ 79K8=<=96M$ 3@5J=D7D$ =9$ <>8859$ N7

4=8P7D$ 95$ >86$ 3>@9=<A4>@$ =8D=J=DA>4M$ #'$ D>9>$ ?@>27C

I5@P;$95$D>97$K>J7$859$;37<=?=7D$=8D=<>95@;$5?$;5<=>4

7Q<4A;=58$=23><9;$58$79K8=<$L@5A3;O!KA;M$?5@$7Q>2C

347M$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ 3AN4=<>9=58$ a#A@5C

37>8$ %5<=>4$ %9>9=;9=<;j$ &8<527M$ 15J7@96$ >8D$ %5<=>4

#Q<4A;=58a$=8<4AD7;$85$D>9>$58$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$2=85@C

=96$L@5A3;M$=8<4AD=8L$,52>M$5@$9K7$=23><9$5?$;5<=>446

7Q<4A;=58>@6$?5@<7;$58$;37<=?=<$79K8=<$L@5A3;ORG^ !K7

25@7$@7<789$B522=;;=58$3AN4=<>9=58$a!K7$%5<=>4$%=9C

A>9=58$ =8$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$'8=58$ FGGEaM$ >49K5ALK$ >4;5

3@5J=D=8L$;9>9=;9=<>4$D>9>$58$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58M$=;$;=2=C

4>@46$;=4789$58$2>997@;$@74>97D$95$9K7$=23><9$5?$@><=>4

D=;<@=2=8>9=58ORGf !K7$ %9>9=;9=<>4$ (887Q$ 95$ 9K7$ FGGE

aB522=;;=58$%9>??$S5@P=8L$1>37@$ b0@>?9$g5=89$ &8<4AC

;=58$,735@9baM$>49K5ALK$=8<4AD=8L$D>9>$>8D$a87Ia$=8D=C

<>95@;$ L5=8L$ N7658D$ 9K7$ Rf$ ;5<=>4$ 7Q<4A;=58

=8D=<>95@;$>D5397D$>9$9K7$.>7P78$#A@537>8$B5A8<=4

=8$07<72N7@$FGGRM$4=P7I=;7$=8<4AD7;$85$?@>27I5@P

?5@$9K7$3@5J=;=58$5?$D>9>$N6$79K8=<=96ORGh$!K7$B522=;C

;=58$K>;$ =9;74?$8597D$9K7$877D$95$D7J7453$D>9>$>8D

=8D=<>95@;$=8$9K7$.=;N58$>@7>;ORRG

B" !K7$B522=;;=58$K>;$@>=;7D$9K7$ =;;A7$5?$<54C

47<9=8L$79K8=<=96$D>9>$I=9K$-72N7@$%9>97;M$NA9$I>;

A8>N47$ 95$ <58J=8<7$ 8>9=58>4$ ;9>9=;9=<>4$ 5??=<7;$ 9K>9

9K=;$I>;$87<7;;>@6$>8D$?7>;=N47O$*>9=58>4$;9>9=;9=<>4

5??=<7;$K>J7$9K7@7?5@7$9>P78$J>@=5A;$>33@5><K7;$95

9K7$<5447<9=58$5?$79K8=<=96$D>9>M$I=9K$2>86$=L85@=8L

9K7$=;;A7$IK=4;9$;527$K>J7$9>P78$;973;$95$=23@5J7

9K7$;=9A>9=58O$+5@$7Q>2347M$9K7$'`$)??=<7$5?$*>9=58C

>4$ %9>9=;9=<;$ K>;$ @7<78946$ 3AN4=;K7D$ 9I5$ @747J>89

D5<A2789;j$=";,1+"!+F.(!*;*.6+&!>+I>0!.*.6 >8D$F.(#

!*;+5/",7+B.&.*1.*;1@+9+),*>0+ <"/+ .(0+;"--0;.*"!+&!>

;-&11*<*;&.*"!+ "<+ 0.(!*;*.6+ >&.&HRRR ,7<5L8=;=8L$ 9K7

=;;A7$>;$587$5?$=235@9>8<7M$9K7$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4

5?$#234562789$>8D$%5<=>4$(??>=@;$5?$ 9K7$#A@537>8

B522=;;=58$K>;M$K5I7J7@M$<522=;;=587D$>8$=897@C

8>9=58>4$;9AD6M$D79>=4=8L$D=??7@789$279K5D545L=7;$?5@

9K7$ <5447<9=58$ 5?$ 79K8=<=96$ D>9>M$ IK=<K$ =9$ <>8$ 9K78

;K>@7$I=9K$-72N7@$%9>97;O$+A@9K7@25@7M$=9$K>;$=8=9=C

>97D$ >$S5@P=8L$ /@5A3$ 95$ D=;<A;;$ N>@@=7@;$ 95$ D>9>

<5447<9=58$ 58$ 79K8=<=96$ >9$ >$ #A@537>8$ 47J74$ >8D$ 95

7Q345@7$35;;=N47$I>6;$?5@I>@DO$&8$9K=;$<5897Q9M$9K7

0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$ =;$34>88=8L$>$#A@537>8$<58?7@C

78<7$58$D>9>$<5447<9=58$N6$9K7$78D$5?$FGGHO$(9$9K7

;>27$ 9=27M$ =9$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ 8597D$ 9K>9$ >49K5ALK$ 9K7

B522=;;=58$=9;74?$<5447<9;$D>9>$58$=9;$5I8$723456C

77;X$8>9=58>4=96$>8D$L78D7@M$ =9$;9=44$D57;$859$<5447<9

D>9>$ 58$ =9;$ 79K8=<$ <5235;=9=58$ >8D$ =;$ 9K7@7?5@7

A8>N47$95$3@5J=D7$=8?5@2>9=58$58$9K7$D7L@77$5?$@73C

@7;789>9=58$5?$79K8=<$2=85@=9=7;$>258L$=9;$5I8$;9>??O

!"#-5@75J7@M$>$L787@>4$4><P$5?$;9>9=;9=<>4$D>9>$58

9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?$,52>$ =8$ P76$ ;7<95@>4$ ?=74D;$2>P7;

9K7$D7;=L8M$258=95@=8L$>8D$7J>4A>9=58$5?$354=<6$>8D

3@5L@>227;M$3>@9=<A4>@46$=8$@74>9=58$95$>89=CD=;<@=2=C

8>9=58$>8D$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58M$D=??=<A49$=?$859$=235;;=N47O

!K7$3@5N472;$>;;5<=>97D$I=9K$9K7$4><P$5?$;9>9=;9=<>4

D>9>$58$,52>$>@7$P76$=;;A7;$9K@5ALK5A9$9K=;$@735@9O

!K7@7$=;$>$877D$95$<4>@=?6$9K7$;<537$5?$D>9>$3@597<C

9=58$@7LA4>9=58$>8D$95$723K>;=;7$9K7$877D$95$3@5J=D7

D>9>$D=;>LL@7L>97D$N6$79K8=<=96$c>4I>6;$95$N7$;37<=?C

=<>446$=8<4A;=J7$5?$,52>d$=8$9K7$?=74D;$5?$@747J>8<7$95

;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$354=<6O

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RGH -5;9$@7<78946M$,7LA4>9=58$c#Bd$*5$HYeFGGR$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$$1>@4=>2789$>8D$5?$9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$Rf$07<72N7@$FGGG$a58$9K7$3@597<C

9=58$5?$ =8D=J=DA>4;$I=9K$@7L>@D$95$9K7$3@5<7;;=8L$5?$37@;58>4$D>9>$N6$9K7$B522A8=96$ =8;9=9A9=58;$>8D$N5D=7;$>8D$58$9K7$?@77

25J72789$5?$;A<K$D>9>a$;9>97;j$ac>d$z37@;58>4$D>9>X$;K>44$27>8$>86$=8?5@2>9=58$@74>9=8L$$95$>8$=D789=?=7D$5@$=D789=?=>N47$8>9A@>4

37@;58$K7@7=8>?97@$@7?7@@7D$95$>;$zD>9>$;ANW7<9Xo$>8$=D789=?=>N47$37@;58$=;$587$IK5$<>8$N7$=D789=?=7DM$$D=@7<946$5@$=8D=@7<946M$=8$3>@C

9=<A4>@$N6$@7?7@78<7$95$>8$=D789=?=<>9=58$8A2N7@$5@$95$587$5@$25@7$?><95@;$;37<=?=<$95$K=;$5@$K7@$3K6;=<>4M$3K6;=545L=<>4M$2789>4M

7<5852=<M$<A49A@>4$5@$;5<=>4$=D789=96aO

RGY +5@$>$;A22>@6$5?$;A<K$<>44;$?5@$;9>9=;9=<>4$D>9>M$;77$/54D;958M$g>27;$(OM$a,><7$>8D$#9K8=<$0>9>j$($-=;;=8L$,7;5A@<7$=8$9K7$+=LK9

>L>=8;9$0=;<@=2=8>9=58aM$=8$F.(!*;+J"!*."/*!)+&!>+K&.&+:/".0;.*"!@+3(0+F,/"70&!+'"!.0G.M$UAD>37;9j$B1%$U55P;M$B789@>4$#A@5C

37>8$'8=J7@;=96$1@7;;$CC$&*0)`M$FGGRO

RGZ %77$#A@537>8$'8=58$%5<=>4$1@597<9=58$B522=9977M$a,735@9$58$&8D=<>95@;$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?$35J7@96$>8D$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58aM$)<95N7@

FGGRO

RG^ #A@537>8$B522=;;=58M$#A@5;9>9M$a#A@537>8$%5<=>4$%9>9=;9=<;j$&8<527M$15J7@96$>8D$%5<=>4$#Q<4A;=58aM$079>=47D$!>N47;M$#A@537>8

B522A8=9=7;M$FGGGO

RGf #A@537>8$B522=;;=58M$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$ ?5@$#234562789$>8D$%5<=>4$ $(??>=@;M$ a!K7$%5<=>4$%=9A>9=58$ =8$ 9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58

FGGEaM$)??=<7$?5@$)??=<=>4$1AN4=<>9=58;$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522A8=9=7;M$FGGEO

RGh$$$cB)-cFGGEd^^E$?=8>4d

Page 45: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

,"# )87$ I>6$ 5?$ ;9=2A4>9=8L$ 9K7$ <5447<9=58$ >8D

3AN4=<>9=58$5?$;A<K$D>9>$I5A4D$N7$95$?A@9K7@$;37<=C

?6$9K7$=8D=<>95@;$87<7;;>@6$?5@$9K7$D7J74532789$5?

;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$354=<=7;O$'8D7@$9K7$.=;N58$1@5<7;;M

9K7$3@=2>@6$>8D$;7<58D>@6$=8D=<>95@;M$IK=47$3@5J=DC

=8L$>8$=235@9>89$N>;=;$?@52$IK=<K$95$I5@PM$>@7$859

679$ ?A446$ D7J74537D$ ;5$ >;$ 95$ 3@5J=D7$ 9K7$ D>9>

@7TA=@7D$?5@$>D7TA>97$354=<6C2>P=8LO$(@7>;$=8$877D

5?$74>N5@>9=58$=8<4AD7j

=d$ 7Q3>8;=58$5?$9K7$=8D=<>95@;$95$>44$>@7>;$5?$;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58$354=<6M$;A<K$9K>9$9K7$?5<A;$58$35J7@96

>8D$7234562789$=;$2>9<K7D$N6$;=2=4>@$D79>=4$ =8

>@7>;$ =8<4AD=8L$ 7DA<>9=58M$ K5A;=8LM$ K7>49K<>@7M

;5<=>4$3@597<9=58$>8D$><<7;;$95$WA;9=<7oRRF$

==d$ ;K>@378=8L$ 9K7$7Q=;9=8L$ =8D=<>95@;$>8D$D7J7453C

=8L$87I$=8D=<>95@;$95$N7997@$27>;A@7$9K7$=23><9

5?$ @><=>4$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D$ 59K7@$ 7Q<4A;=58>@6

?5@<7;$>??7<9=8L$79K8=<M$2=85@=96$>8D$59K7@$I7>P

L@5A3;o

===d$ D7J7453=8L$ =8D=<>95@;$ 5?$ 25@7$ @747J>8<7$ 95

,52>M$;A<K$>;$?5@$7Q>2347M$a;7L@7L>9=58$=8D=<7;a

?5@$7DA<>9=58M$K5A;=8L$>8D$K7>49K<>@7M$79<O

-" !K7$ <A@@789$ L>3$ =8$ @><7C;37<=?=<$ ;9>9=;9=<>4$ D>9>

D73@=J7;$354=<6$2>P7@;$5?$>$<47>@$>8D$WA;9=?=>N47$N>;=;

?5@$ ><9=58O$ &9$ >4;5$ D73@=J7;$ 9K7$ 3AN4=<$ 5?$ =235@9>89

=8?5@2>9=58$>N5A9$9K7$;5<=79=7;$=8$IK=<K$#A@537>8;

4=J7M$ >8D$2=LK9$ 478D$ <@7D=N=4=96$ 95$ 9K5;7$IK5$ D786

9K>9$@><7$=;$>$?><95@$=8$3AN4=<$4=?7$5@$9K>9$D=;<@=2=8>C

9=58$7Q=;9;O$0>9>M$3>@9=<A4>@46$IK7@7$;A<K$D>9>$ =8D=C

<>97;$ ;7@=5A;$ D=;3>@=9=7;M$ <>8$ N7$ >258L$ 9K7$ 25;9

35I7@?A4$9554;$>J>=4>N47$?5@$78;A@=8L$354=<6$7??=<><6M

?><=4=9>9=8L$ ;5<=>4$ <K>8L7$ >8D$ LA>@>8977=8L$ @><7

7TA>4=96O$S=9K5A9$;A<K$;9>9=;9=<>4$D>9>M$4=9947$<58<@797

=8?5@2>9=58$7Q=;9;$IK=<K$2=LK9$259=J>97$<K>8L7O

4" &9$ =;$ @7<5L8=;7DM$ K5I7J7@M$ 9K>9$ 9K7@7$ =;$ >4;5$ >

877D$95$@7>;;A@7$;527$79K8=<$L@5A3;$>N5A9$9K7$3A@C

35;7$ 5?$ <5447<9=8L$ D>9>$ >;$ =8$ ;527$ TA>@97@;$ 9K7@7

@72>=8;$>$?7>@$9K>9$;A<K$<5447<9=58$<5A4D$N7$A;7D$>;$>

N>;=;$?5@$?A@9K7@$D=;<@=2=8>9=58O$!KA;M$IK7@7>;$=8$&@7C

4>8D$ !@>J7447@;$ ;A<<7;;?A446$ 45NN=7D$ 9K7$ L5J7@82789

95$=8<4AD7$>$!@>J7447@$<>97L5@6$=8$9K7$8>9=58>4$<78;A;M

>$25J7$9K>9$@7;A497D$=8$5??=<=>4$7;9=2>97;$5?$9K7$8A2C

N7@$ 5?$ !@>J7447@;$ =8$ &@74>8D$ N7=8L$ @>=;7DM$ =8$ %45J>P=>

2=85@=96$79K8=<$L@5A3;M$<58<7@87D$>N5A9$ 9K7$A;7$5?

37@;58>4$ =8?5@2>9=58M$ ;A335@97D$ 9K7$ =89@5DA<9=58$ 5?

(<9O$*5O$HFf$5?$gA46$EM$FGGF$58$1@597<9=58$5?$17@;58>4

0>9>O$!K7$4>I$7;9>N4=;K7;$9K7$)??=<7$?5@$17@;58>4$0>9>

1@597<9=58$ 95$ 3@5J=D7$ >$ K=LK7@$ D7L@77$ 5?$ 3@597<9=58

9K>8$ 3@7J=5A;46$ 95$ 9K7$ ;ANW7<9;$ 5?$ D>9>$ <5447<95@;O

/=J78$9K7$3>@9=>446$;ANW7<9=J7$8>9A@7$5?$79K8=<=96M$<58?=C

D78<7$;K5A4D$N7$NA=49$A3$N6$>445I=8L$79K8=<$2=85@=9=7;

95$ =D789=?6$ 9K72;74J7;M$ @>9K7@$ 9K>8$ K>J7$ 8>9=58>4$ 5@

45<>4$>A9K5@=9=7;$D7?=87$79K8=<=96$>8D$<5447<9$79K8=<=96

D>9>$I=9K5A9$@7?7@78<7$95$9K7$L@5A3;$<58<7@87DM$>8D

95$>445I$><<7;;$95$>44$37@;58>4$D>9>$K74DO

56" &8$;A22>@6M$IK=4;9$ =9$ =;$ @7<5L8=;7D$9K>9$9K7

#A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ =;$ 9>P=8L$ ;973;$ 95$ =23@5J7

9K7$7Q9789$5?$79K8=<=96$D>9>$<5447<9=58$I=9K=8$-72C

N7@$ %9>97;M$ ?A@9K7@$ LA=D>8<7$58$ 9K7$ ;<537$5?$ D>9>

<5447<9=58M$>8D$9K7$279K5D545L=7;$95$N7$7234567DM

=;$@7TA=@7DO$!K=;$;K5A4D$=8<4AD7$9K7$;37<=?=<>9=58$5?

=23><9$ =8D=<>95@;$ @747J>89$ 95$ 79K8=<$ 2=85@=9=7;M

=8<4AD=8L$ ,52>M$ I=9K=8$ ;7<95@;$ @747J>89$ 95$ ;5<=>4

7Q<4A;=58M$>8D$9K7$<544>9=58$5?$79K8=<=96$D>9>$>9$9K7

#'$47J74O$&9$I5A4D$>4;5$N7$K743?A4$=?$9K7$B522=;;=58

;9>@97D$95$258=95@$=9;$5I8$79K8=<$<5235;=9=58$;5$>;

95$?><=4=9>97$<5234=>8<7$I=9K$=9;$5I8$,><7$0=@7<9=J7O

07;3=97$ 9K=;$ @7<52278D>9=58M$ 4><P$ 5?$ D>9>$ ;K5A4D

859$N7$;778$>;$>8$7Q<A;7$?5@$=8><9=58$=8$9K7$D7J74C

532789$5?$,52>C;37<=?=<$354=<=7;$I=9K=8$9K7$#'$>8D

><@5;;$-72N7@$%9>97;O$,>9K7@M$=9$=;$9K>9$<589=8A=8L

7??5@9;$95$=23@5J7$D>9>$;79;$;K5A4D$47>D$95$=8<@7>;C

=8L46$9>@L797D$>8D$7??7<9=J7$354=<=7;O

1*7<$]/78)#(M#&('18)#9$0&(*0$

55" &8$ 9K7$ ?=74D$ 5?$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 354=<6M$ >49K5ALK

9K5;7$ 87I$-72N7@$ %9>97;$ I=9K$ ;=L8=?=<>89$ ,52>8=

353A4>9=58;$ D=D$ 8>27$ ,52>$ 7Q34=<=946$ >;$ >$ 9>@L79

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RRG +5@$7Q>2347M$9K7$aB522=;;=58$%9>??$S5@P=8L$1>37@j$1@5L@7;;$!5I>@D;$9K7$B52258$)NW7<9=J7;$=8$#DA<>9=58$>8D$!@>=8=8Lj$&8D=C

<>95@;$>8D$U78<K2>@P;a$;9>97;j$a&8D=<>95@;$>8D$N78<K2>@P;$>@7$7;;789=>4$?5@$9K7$=23472789>9=58$5?$9K7$5378$279K5D$5?$<5C

5@D=8>9=58$>8D$?5@$9K7$;A<<7;;$5?$9K7$.=;N58$;9@>97L6O$S=9K5A9$J>4=D$>8D$<523>@>N47$D>9>M$-72N7@$%9>97;$I=44$4><P$=8?5@2>9=58

58$K5I$9K7=@$><9=58;$;A335@9$9K7$>99>=82789$5?$9K7$.=;N58$5NW7<9=J7;$N6$FGRGO$"5I7J7@M$9K7@7$=;$>8$A@L789$877D$95$=23@5J7$9K7

;=9A>9=58$=8$5@D7@$95$2>P7$9K7$87<7;;>@6$D>9>$>8D$=8D=<>95@;$>J>=4>N47Oa$c%77$B522=;;=58$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522A8=9=7;M$aB52C

2=;;=58$%9>??$S5@P=8L$1>37@j$1@5L@7;;$!5I>@D;$9K7$B52258$)NW7<9=J7;$=8$#DA<>9=58$>8D$!@>=8=8Lj$&8D=<>95@;$>8D$U78<K2>@P;aM

U@A;;74;M$FROROFGGHM$%#BcFGGHd$^EdO

RRR &9$=;$95$N7$8597DM$K5I7J7@M$9K>9$/63;6e,52>e!@>J7447@$L@5A3;$I7@7$859$=8<4AD7D$=8$9K7$'`$<78;A;$5?$FGGRM$>3>@9$?@52$*5@9K7@8

&@74>8D$IK=<K$=8<4AD7D$>$z!@>J7447@X$<>97L5@6O

RRF %527$5?$9K7;7$>@7>;$>@7$<A@@78946$>DD@7;;7D$N6$9K7$&8D=<>95@;M$NA9$859$95$9K7$47J74$5?$D79>=4$3@5J=D7D$=8$59K7@$>@7>;O

Page 46: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

L@5A3$ ?5@$ 9K7=@$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 354=<=7;M$ =8$ 9K7$ 54D

-72N7@$%9>97;$5846$?=J7$<5A89@=7;$5A9$5?$?=?9778$c+=8C

4>8DM$/@77<7M$&@74>8DM$15@9AL>4$>8D$%3>=8d$K>J7$95$D>97

8>27D$,52>$>;$>$9>@L79$L@5A3$I=9K=8$9K7=@$*>9=58>4

(<9=58$ 14>8;O$ ,52>$ >@7$ 859$ <=97D$ =8$ 9K7$ *>9=58>4

(<9=58$ 14>8;$ 5?$ (A;9@=>M$ U74L=A2M$ 0782>@PM$ +@>8<7M

/7@2>86M$&9>46M$9K7$*79K7@4>8D;M$%I7D78$>8D$9K7$'8=9C

7D$`=8LD52M$>49K5ALK$@735@9;$?@52$>44$5?$9K7;7$<5A8C

9@=7;$=8D=<>97$9K>9$,52>$>@7$=8$877D$5?$9>@L797D$354=<6

><9=58;$>=27D$>9$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$>8D$74=2=8>9=8L$D=;C

<@=2=8>95@6$3@><9=<7;O$-5@75J7@M$;527$L@5A3;$;A??7@C

=8L$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$9@7>92789$>;$a/63;=7;a$5@$;=2=4>@$]

;A<K$>;$!@>J7447@;$=8$9K7$,73AN4=<$5?$&@74>8DRRE ]$>@7$859

679$ ?A446$<5J7@7D$N6$ 9K7$N>8$58$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$ 9@7>9C

2789$58$L@5A8D;$5?$@><7$5@$79K8=<$5@=L=8O

5;" &8$;=9A>9=58;$=8$IK=<K$9K7$877D;$5?$>$2=85@=96

K>J7$N778$=D789=?=7D$<47>@46M$=9$=;$5?978$9K7$<>;7$9K>9

9K7$47J74$5?$354=<6$@7;358;7$=;$=8<58;=;9789$I=9K$9K7

47J74$5?$>;;7;;7D$877DO$+5@$7Q>2347M$ =8$ 9K7$'8=97D

`=8LD52M$ 9K7$ )??=<7$ ?5@$ %9>8D>@D;$ =8$ #DA<>9=58

c)+%!#0dM$3AN4=;K7D$9I5$@735@9;$58$9K7$7DA<>9=58$5?

,52>M$ /63;=7;$ >8D$ !@>J7447@;$ cRhhZ$ >8D$ FGGEd$ =8

IK=<K$=9$I>;$7;9=2>97D$=8$N59K$@735@9;$9K>9$>;$2>86

>;$RFMGGG$;A<K$3A3=4;$I7@7$859$7J78$@7L=;97@7D$I=9K

;<K554;O$(49K5ALK$;527$><9=58;$K>J7$N778$9>P78$?54C

45I=8L$ 9K7$ FGGE$ @735@9M$ 9K7@7$I>;$ 4=9947$ ;=L8=?=<>89

><9=58$?5445I=8L$9K7$RhhZ$@735@9O

5=" SK7@7$ ,52>C;37<=?=<$ 354=<=7;$ 7Q=;9M$ ?7I

K>J7$679$95$D7258;9@>97$DA@>N47$=23><9O$%7J7@>4$5?

9K7$54D$-72N7@$%9>97;$N7L>8$A8D7@9>P=8L$354=<=7;

=8$ 9K7$RhfG;$5@$ 7J78$7>@4=7@O$ &8$ ;527$>@7>;M$ 9K7;7

K>J7$ 6=74D7D$ @7;A49;M$ NA9$ 859$ 87>@46$ 95$ 9K7$ 47J74

@7TA=@7D$A8D7@$<A@@789$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58$ 354=<6O$ &8$ %3>=8M$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M$ D7;3=97$ >

<523@7K78;=J7$354=<6$=8$7??7<9$;=8<7$9K7$4>97$RhfG;M

IK7@7$D>9>$7Q=;9;$c;A<K$>;$37@<789>L7;$5?$,52>$=8

3@=;58;dM$9K7@7$>@7$J7@6$;7@=5A;$<>A;7;$?5@$<58<7@8

9K>9$9K7$354=<6$K>;$859$D74=J7@7D$9K7$@7;A49;$;5ALK9O

5A"-5;9$5?$9K7$<523@7K78;=J7$L5J7@82789$354=C

<=7;$ =8$ 7??7<9$ =8$ B789@>4$ >8D$ #>;97@8$ #A@537$ D>97

?@52$ 85$ 7>@4=7@$ 9K>8$ RhhZ$ c"A8L>@6d$ >8D$ =8$ 25;9

<>;7;$ I7@7$ >D5397D$ 7J78$ 25@7$ @7<78946O$ !5$ D>97

9K76$@72>=8$A8D7@C?A8D7DM$>9$J7@6$3@74=2=8>@6$;9>L7;

5?$ =23472789>9=58M$ >8D$ 5?978$ @7;72N47$ 25@7$ >

278A$5?$D7;=@7D$5A9<527;$9K>8$J=>N47$>8D$@7>4=;9=<

354=<=7;O !K7@7$>4;5$>337>@$A8=J7@;>446$95$N7$;=L8=?=C

<>89$ D7?=<=78<=7;$ =8$ 97@2;$ 5?$ 9>@L79;$ ?5@$ >;;7;;=8L

9K7$;A<<7;;$5?$7Q=;9=8L$354=<=7;o$=9$=;$D=??=<A49$95$;77

95$IK>9$;9>8D>@D;$354=<6$2>P7@;$>;3=@7$=8$9K7$=2347C

2789>9=58$5?$2>86$,52>C@74>97D$354=<=7;O

5B" B58;A49>9=58$I=9K$,52>$>8D$,52>$3>@9=<=3>C

9=58$ =8$ 9K7$ D7;=L8$ >8D$ =23472789>9=58$ 5?$ 354=<=7;

=8978D7D$ 95$N787?=9$ 9K72$ =;$ <A@@78946$ J7@6$25D7;9M

IK7@7$7Q=;9=8L$>9$>44M$>8D$L787@>446$K7;=9>89O$!K=;$;9>C

9A;$ TA5$ =;$ =8$ 859=<7>N47$ <589@>;9$ I=9K$ I744C7;9>NC

4=;K7D$ ;9>8D>@D$ 3@5<7DA@7;$ I=9K$ @7;37<9$ 95$ 59K7@

2=85@=96$ <A49A@>4$ >8D$79K8=<$L@5A3;$ =8$>$8A2N7@$5?

#A@537>8$'8=58$-72N7@$%9>97;O

5!" -5@75J7@M$#'$-72N7@$%9>97;$K>J7$=8$;527

<>;7;$ >D5397D$ 27>;A@7;$ IK=<K$ 74=2=8>97D$ 3@7J=C

5A;$ L>=8;O$ &8$ RhhHM$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M$ '8=97D$ `=8LD52

4>I2>P7@;$@725J7D$9K7$5N4=L>9=58$5?$2A8=<=3>4=9=7;

95$3@5J=D7$K>49=8L$;=97;$?5@$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;M

7??7<9=J746$ 7@5D=8L$ <45;7$ 95$ 9K@77$ D7<>D7;$ 5?

3@5L@7;;$ =8$ 9K7$ >@7>$ 5?$ !@>J7447@$ ><<5225D>9=58M

7DA<>9=58$>8D$59K7@$35;=9=J7$27>;A@7;ORRH

87&781+)#7*<#N1''#7+#'(87'#'$\$'

5," ($ J7@6$ 35I7@?A4$ ?5@<7$ ?5@$ A8D7@2=8=8L$ ;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58$3@5W7<9;$9>@L79=8L$,52>$=;$45<>4$5335;=9=58O

.5<>4$>A9K5@=9=7;$?@7TA78946$A;7$D=;<@79=58>@6$35I7@;

95$ N45<P$ =23472789>9=58$ 5?$ 3@5W7<9;$ >=27D$ >9

=23@5J=8L$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>O$ )87$ 5?$ 9K7

A8;7994=8L$ D7J74532789;$ 5?$ FGGE$ 955P$ 34><7$ =8$ 9K7

%45J>P$J=44>L7$5?$%J=8=>M$IK7@7$=8$->@<K$FGGE$9K7$45<>4

<5A8<=4$D7<=D7D$=8$@7;54A9=58$EHeFGGH$95$a>33@5J7$9K7

97@2=8>9=58$5?$><9=J=9=7;$<A@@78946$N7=8L$<>@@=7D$5A9$=8

9K7$J=44>L7$I=9K$9K7$5@L>8=;>9=58;$">N=9>9$?5@$"A2>8=96

&897@8>9=58>4$ >8D$ 9K7$ B>8>D=>8$ &897@8>9=58>4

07J74532789$ (L78<6Oa$ !K7$ 45<>4$ <5A8<=4$ K>D$ 7>@4=7@

J597D$ ?5@$ <K>8L7;$ 95$ >$ 3@535;7D$ =8?@>;9@A<9A@7

3@5W7<9M$ 9K7$ 8>9A@7$ 5?$ IK=<KM$ =9$ I>;$ >I>@7M$ I5A4D

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RRE )87$<58;7TA78<7$5?$9K7$?>=4A@7$95$@7<5L8=;7$!@>J7447@;$>;$>8$79K8=<$L@5A3$=8$&@74>8D$I5A4D$27>8$9K>9$0=@7<9=J7$FGGGeHEe#BM$9K7

'8=58b;$3@=2>@6$D5<A2789$58$4>I;$N>88=8L$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$I5A4D$859$$<47>@46$>3346$95$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$9@7>92789$5?$!@>JC

7447@;O$!K7$&@=;K$L5J7@82789b;$;9>8<7$58$9K7$=;;A7$=;$=8$<589@>;9$95$9K7$L5J7@82789$5?$9K7$'`M$7Q<739=8L$%<594>8DM$IK7@7$;=2=C

4>@$L@5A3;$>@7$@7<5L8=;7D$?5@$9K7$3A@35;7;$5?$'`$@><7$7TA>4=96$4>IO$1@=2>@6$5N;9><47;$95$9K7$@7<5L8=9=58$5?$!@>J7447@;$=8$&@74>8D

>;$>8$79K8=<$L@5A3$>337>@$95$;972$?@52$D7N>97$>;$95$9K7$5@=L=8;$5?$!@>J7447@;M$TA7;9=58;$5?$5846$9>8L789=>4$@747J>8<7$95$9K7$>334=C

<>9=58$5?$7TA>4=96$4>I$>8D$354=<6O$&@58=<>446M$=8$#8L4>8DM$S>47;$>8D$*5@9K7@8$&@74>8DM$z!@>J7447@;$5?$&@=;K$K7@=9>L7X$>@7$D7?=87D$=8

4>I$>;$>8$79K8=<$L@5A3$<5J7@7D$N6$9K7$,><7$,74>9=58;$(<9;O

RRH B@=2=8>4$gA;9=<7$>8D$1AN4=<$)@D7@$(<9M$RhhHO

Page 47: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

D=;TA>4=?6$ =9$ ?5@$ #'$ ?A8D=8L$ >J>=4>N47$ A8D7@$ >$ 1K>@7

FGGR$3@5W7<9O$S=9K$9K7$9I5$D7<=;=58;M$9K7$45<>4$<5A8<=4

5?$ %J=8=>$ <K5;7$ 95$ @7?A;7$ 5J7@$ >$ 2=44=58$ #A@5$ =8

=8?@>;9@A<9A@7$ >;;=;9>8<7M$ @>9K7@$ 9K>8$ >;;=;9$ =9;$ 45<>4

,52>8=$<522A8=96O$&9$=;$A8<47>@$IK>9$27>;A@7;$<>8

N7$7234567D$95$5J7@<527$45<>4$A8I=44=8L87;;$95$;77P

D7J74532789$ ?A8D=8LM$ >49K5ALK$ =9$ =;$ <47>@$ 9K>9$ =8

<7@9>=8$<5897Q9;M$;A<K$>;$IK7@7$@><=>4$3@7WAD=<7$>8D

;7L@7L>9=58$=;$>9$=;;A7M$9K7@7$=;$>$877D$95$7Q7@<=;7$>44

>J>=4>N47$47L>4$;>8<9=58;O

5-" .5<>4$5??=<=>4;$=8$/@77<7$K>J7$;=2=4>@46$A8D7@C

2=87D$ @7<789$ 7??5@9;$ N6$ 9K7$ /@77P$ L5J7@82789$ 95

=23472789$354=<=7;$58$,52>ORRY &8D77DM$=8?5@2>9=58

<58<7@8=8L$ ><9=58;$ 95$ >;;=;9$ c3@7D52=8>8946$ 5@

7Q<4A;=J746$858C,52>8=d$7>@9KTA>P7$D=;>;97@$J=<9=2;

3@5J=D7D$ =8$ /@77<7b;$ ?=@;9$ *>9=58>4$ (<9=58$ 14>8$ 95

<52N>9$ ;5<=>4$ 7Q<4A;=58$ <589@>;9;$I=9K$ ><9=58;$ N6

/@77P$>A9K5@=9=7;$95$K5A;7$,52>j

a{OOO|RGE$ ;799472789;$I7@7$ ?5@27D$I=9K$ 9@>8;?7@>N47$ 3@7C

?>N$ K5A;7;O$ &8$ 47;;$ 9K>8$ H$2589K;M$ ZMfYH$ ;A<K$ K5A;7;

I7@7$;79$A3O$!K@77$2589K;$>?97@$9K7$7>@9KTA>P7M$85$J=<9=2

5?$9K7$7>@9KTA>P7$4=J7D$A8D7@$>$9789OaRRZ

54" !K7;7$?=LA@7;$>@7$8597I5@9K6$N7<>A;7$9K76$=8D=C

<>97$9K7$<>3>N=4=9=7;$>8D$<>3><=96$5?$9K7$/@77P$3ANC

4=<$ >D2=8=;9@>9=58$ A8D7@$ <58D=9=58;$ 5?$ ;A??=<=789

354=9=<>4$I=44$>8D$N7<>A;7$9K76$3@5J=D7$J7@6$3@7<=;7

D>9>$>;$95$8A2N7@;$5?$K5A;=8L$A8=9;$3@5J=D7D$95$c3@7C

D52=8>8946$ 5@$ 7Q<4A;=J746$ 858C,52>8=d$ 7>@9KTA>P7

J=<9=2;O$ 07;3=97$ 9K7$ 7Q=;978<7$ 5?$ 9I5$ L5J7@82789

354=<=7;$ CC$ N7LA8$ =8$ RhhZ$ >8D$ FGGR$ @7;37<9=J746$ ]

>=27D$>9$=23@5J=8L$9K7$K5A;=8L$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8

/@77<7M$ 85$ ;=2=4>@$ D>9>$ 58$ K5A;=8L$ 3@5J=;=58;$ ?5@

,52>$K>;$ 95$ 9K7$ @7;7>@<K$ 97>2X;$P85I47DL7$N778

3@5J=D7D$N6$9K7$/@77P$L5J7@82789O

;6" ->86$37@;58;$=8J54J7D$D=@7<946$I=9K$L5J7@8C

2789$ 354=<6C2>P7@;$ >8D$ 9K7$ 1K>@7$ 3@5L@>227$ =8

B789@>4$>8D$#>;97@8$#A@537$K>J7$7Q3@7;;7D$;7@=5A;

<58<7@8$>9$9K7$<>3><=96$5?$>A9K5@=9=7;$95$=23472789

#'$ 354=<6$ I744M$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ >;$ ;9@A<9A@>4$ ?A8D=8L

N7<527;$ >J>=4>N47$ ?5445I=8L$ 784>@L72789$ =8$ ->6

FGGHO$!K=;$=;$D7;3=97$9K7$>997239M$=8$"A8L>@6$=8$3>@C

9=<A4>@M$ 95$ ;9@78L9K78$ 9K7$ @73@7;789>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>

45<>446$ 9K@5ALK$ 9K7$ 7;9>N4=;K2789$ 5?$ ,52>$ 45<>4

L5J7@82789;O$&9$=;$5?$<58<7@8$9K>9$>A9K5@=9=7;$=8$9K7

@7L=58$ 2>6$ >9$ 3@7;789$ 4><P$ 9K7$ <>3><=96$ 95$ 9>P7

>DJ>89>L7$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ %5<=>4$ +A8D$ >8D$ 9K7

#A@537>8$,7L=58>4$07J74532789$+A8DM$3>@9=<A4>@46

=8$4=LK9$5?$2>9<K=8L$?A8D=8L$@7TA=@72789;O

&('181$0#<$+91%$*+7'#+(#+.$#&((9#2$*$97'')

;5" %527$ #'$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ K>J7$ A8D7@9>P78

27>;A@7;$ IK=<K$ K>J7$ K>D$ >$ N@5>D46$ D79@=2789>4

=23><9$58$9K7$355@M$>8D$>;$>$@7;A49M$;37<=?=<$=23><9;

58$ 9K7$ D=;3@535@9=58>9746$ 4>@L7$ ;7L2789$ 5?$ 9K7

,52>8=$353A4>9=58$@73@7;7897D$>258L$9K7$355@$>8D

7Q9@72746$355@O$+5@$7Q>2347M$9K7$D@>2>9=<$I7>P78C

=8L$5?$ 9K7$ @=LK9;$5?$ 978>89;$ 9K@5ALK5A9$B789@>4$>8D

#>;97@8$ #A@537M$ >8D$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ =8$ UA4L>@=>M$ 9K7

B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$"A8L>@6M$,52>8=>$>8D$%45J>P=>M$>;

>$ @7;A49$ 5?$ <K>8L7;$ 95$ 9K7$ 47L>4$ ?@>27I5@P$ K>J7

A8D7@<A9$ 354=<6$ 27>;A@7;$ =8$ 59K7@$ >@7>;O$ "A8L>@6

2A;9$;9>8D$K7@7$>;$>8$7Q>2347$5?$I5@;9$3@><9=<7O$&8

->6$FGGGM$>8D$=8$9K7$?><7$5?$<47>@$=8D=<>9=58;$5?$K=LK

47J74;$5?$>89=C,52>8=$K5;9=4=96$>9$45<>4$47J74;M$"A8L>@C

=>8$ 4>I2>P7@;$ >278D7D$ 47L=;4>9=58$ >445I=8L$ 9K7

859>@6$]$>8$72345677$5?$9K7$2A8=<=3>4=96$]$35I7@;$95

5@D7@$ 7J=<9=58;$ I=9K5A9$ >$ <5A@9$ 3@5<7DA@7ORR^ !K7

D7<=;=58$5@D7@=8L$9K7$7J=<9=58$2A;9$N7$=234727897D

I=9K=8$ 7=LK9$ D>6;M$ >8D$ >337>4;$ D5$859$ =8J54J7$ ;A;C

378;=58$5?$9K7$5@D7@O

;;" %=L8=?=<>8946M$ 9K7$ >278D7D$ 4>I$ =8<4AD7;

3@5J=;=58;$ 95$ 3@597<9$ 7J=<97D$ ?A@8=9A@7M$ NA9$ 859

978>89;O$ (49K5ALK$ 9K7$ "A8L>@=>8$ WAD=<=>@6$ K>;

>9972397D$95$>274=5@>97$9K7$=23><9$5?$9K7;7$@A47;$N6

9K7$ A;7$5?$25@>95@=>$ 58$ ?5@<7D$ 7J=<9=58;$ =8$I=897@M

9K7;7$ ;953CL>3$ 27>;A@7;$ K>J7$ 859$ K>D$ >$ DA@>N47

=23><9$ 5J7@>44$ >8D$ ,52>$ K>J7$ N778

D=;3@535@9=58>9746$ ;ANW7<97D$ 95$ ?5@<7D$ 7J=<9=58;ORRf

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RRY +5@$7Q>2347M$-@$#J>8L745;$%=;>2>P=;M$9K7$->65@$5?$*7>$(4=P>@8>;;;5;M$B@797M$I>;$@735@97D$N6$9K7$2>W5@$/@77P$D>=46$87I;3>C

37@$ 5?$F^$g>8A>@6$FGGE$>;$K>J=8L$;9>97Dj$ai5A$<>8859$K>J7$>$/63;6$;799472789$87Q9$95$>$N>;P79N>44$<5A@9M$3>@9$5?$9K7$)4623=<;

FGGH$?><=4=9=7;M$N7<>A;7$/63;=7;$N472=;K$587X;$;78;7$5?$L55D$9>;97$>8DM$=8$>DD=9=58M$9K76$D7>4$=8$D@AL;r$&$D5$859$D786$9K>9$&$D5

859$I>89$9K7$/63;=7;$=8$5A@$>@7>Oa

RRZ -=8=;9@6$5?$.>N5A@$>8D$%5<=>4$%7<A@=96M$-=8=;9@6$5?$"7>49K$>8D$S74?>@7M$-=8=;9@6$5?$&897@=5@M$1AN4=<$(D2=8=;9@>9=58$>8D$07<789@>4C

=_>9=58M$-=8=;9@6$5?$#DA<>9=58$>8D$,74=L=5A;$(??>=@;M$-=8=;9@6$5?$*>9=58>4$#<58526$>8D$+=8>8<7M$T&'(;+&1"H$'(;+"D1&+"<;/"=;$(&1

!+$17.(;+" LMMNALMMYM$ gA87$ FGGRM$ 3OHfM$ >J>=4>N47$ >9j$ K993jee7A@53>O7AO=89e<522e7234562789p;5<=>4e87I;eFGGReWA8e

8>3=8<4FGGR74p78O3D?O

RR^ !K7$"5A;=8L$(<9$RhhEe.nnV&&M$>;$>278D7D$N6$(<9$FGGGen.&O

Page 48: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

(<<5@D=8L$ 95$ 587$ ;9AD6$ 258=95@=8L$ 9K7$ "A8L>@=>8

27D=>$ DA@=8L$ 9K7$ 37@=5D$ g>8A>@6$ RM$ FGGE$ >8D

*5J72N7@$ RM$ FGGEM$ =8$ YY$ 37@<789$ 5?$ 7J=<9=58$ 5@

9K@7>9787D$7J=<9=58$<>;7;$@735@97DM$9K7$J=<9=2;$I7@7

=D789=?=7D$ >;$ ,52>8=M$ >49K5ALK$ ,52>$ ><<5A89$ ?5@

>@5A8D$ Z$ 37@<789$ 5?$ 9K7$ 959>4$ 353A4>9=58$ 5?

"A8L>@6ORRh %5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$=;$859$>$@7>4=;9=<$5NW7<9=J7

A847;;$9K7@7$=;$>8$><@5;;C9K7CN5>@D$<522=92789$95

N@=8L$>N5A9$;6;972=<$<K>8L7$=8$9K7$<A@@789$;6;972;O

9(%7#7*<#9$21(*7'#<$\$'(&%$*+

;=" &8$>$8A2N7@$5?$>@7>;M$7;37<=>446$ =8$B789@>4$>8D

#>;97@8$ #A@537M$ ,52>8=$ =;;A7;$ >@7$ 3>@9=<A4>@46

3@7;;=8L$=8$>@7>;$9>@L797D$?5@$@7L=58>4$D7J74532789O

*5@9K7>;9$"A8L>@6M$<789@>4$>8D$7>;97@8$%45J>P=>$>8D

;5A9K7@8$154>8D$>@7$>44$ >@7>;$ =8$IK=<KM$58$ 9K7$587

K>8DM$ 35J7@96$ =;$ I=D7;3@7>D$ >8D$ =8?@>;9@A<9A@7$ =;

355@M$ >8DM$ 58$ 9K7$ 59K7@$ K>8DM$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58;

>@7$3>@9=<A4>@46$4>@L7O$&8$59K7@$>@7>;M$;A<K$>;$-=;P54<

=8$"A8L>@6$>8D$);9@>J>$=8$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$<A9;

=8$ ;AN;=D=7;$ 95$ K7>J6$ =8DA;9@=7;$ K>J7$ <>A;7D$ 7<5C

852=<$ D7<4=87M$ >8D$ 9K7;7$ >@7>;$ 955$ I5A4D$ N787?=9

?@52$>8$=8J7;92789$>33@5><K$9K>9$7Q34=<=946$=8<4AD7D

>99789=58$95$,52>$=;;A7;O

;A" #'$3@5L@>227;$]$>8D$=8$3>@9=<A4>@$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$,7L=58>4$07J74532789$+A8D$c#,0+d$]$>@7$3>@9=<C

A4>@46$@747J>89$?5@$>DD@7;;=8L$9K7;7$=;;A7;M$3@5J=D7D

;A??=<=789$?A8D=8L$=;$7>@2>@P7D$?5@$,52>$=8<4A;=58$=8

>@7>;$N787?=9=8L$?@52$;A<K$?A8D=8LO$+A@9K7@25@7M$9K7

B522A8=96$ %A335@9$ +@>27I5@P;$ ?5@$ FGGHCFGGZ

>L@77D$I=9K$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<M$"A8L>@6M$154>8D$>8D

%45J>P=>$ @7<5L8=;7$ 9K7$ =235@9>8<7$ 5?$ ,52>$ =;;A7;

>8D$K>J7$>D5397D$;9@>97L=7;$95$<52N>9$,52>$7Q<4AC

;=58O +5@$7Q>2347M$9K7$B%+$?5@$9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<

=8<4AD7;$>$<52358789$>DD@7;;=8L$%5<=>4$ &897L@>9=58

>8D$ #TA>4$)335@9A8=9=7;M$IK=<KM$I=9K$ ;A335@9$ ?@52

#'$;9@A<9A@>4$ ?A8D;M$ K>;$ 9K7$359789=>4$ 95$ <589@=NA97

;=L8=?=<>8946$95$=23@5J=8L$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>O &8

9K7$ <>;7$ 5?$ %45J>P=>M$ 9K7$-=8=;9@6$ ?5@$ B58;9@A<9=58

>8D$ ,7L=58>4$ 07J74532789M$ @7;358;=N47$ ?5@$ 9K7

>D2=8=;9@>9=58$5?$;9@A<9A@>4$?A8D;M$=;$7;9>N4=;K=8L$9K7

B%+$S5@P=8L$ B522=;;=58$ ?5@$ 9K7$ 07J74532789$ 5?

,52>$ B522A8=9=7;$ =8$ 5@D7@$ 95$ 9>P7$ >DJ>89>L7$ 5?

359789=>4$#'$ ?A8D=8LO$!K7$><9=58;$;A335@97D$N6$ 9K7

;9@A<9A@>4$?A8D;M$K5I7J7@M$;A??7@$3>@9=<A4>@46$?@52$9K7

A8>J>=4>N=4=96$5?$79K8=<$D>9>$IK=<K$2>6$=8?4A78<7$9K7

9>@L79=8L$5?$9K7$><9=58;$>8D$9K7=@$7??7<9=J787;;O

;B" *7J7@9K747;;M$ >;$ 8597D$ 7>@4=7@M$ <789@>4$ 354=C

<=7;$ 2>6$ N7$ @78D7@7D$ =87??7<9A>4$ N6$ =8>D7TA>97

<522=92789$>8D$P85I47DL7$>9$45<>4$47J74O !K7@7$=;

9K7$;<537$?5@$A;=8L$;9@A<9A@>4$?A8D;$?5@$9K7$=23@5J7C

2789$ 5?$ <>3><=96$ >9$ 45<>4$ 47J74;$ >8DM$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M

9K7$B_7<K$,73AN4=<$ K>;$ >L@77D$ >$B%+$ <52358789

?5@$ 9K7$ 07J74532789$ 5?$ "A2>8$ ,7;5A@<7;$ I=9K=8

9K7$@7L=58;O$!K7@7$=;$85$@7>;58$IK6$9K=;$<52358789

;K5A4D$859$N7$A;7DM$(+'*/"&1(&M$95$9@>=8$45<>4$L5J7@8C2789$ ;9>??$ 58$ >89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D$ D=J7@;=96

=;;A7;O$ %73>@>97$ NADL79;$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ >445<>97D$ ?5@

9K7$9@>=8=8L$5?$ 45<>4$L5J7@82789$>8D$*/)$;9>??$58

;9@A<9A@>4$?A8D$>334=<>9=58$3@5<7DA@7;O

*(*:%$%V$9#0+7+$0

;!" (49K5ALK$9K=;$@735@9$D7>4;$5846$I=9K$9K7$;=9A>9=58

5?$ ,52>$ =8$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58M$ 9K7$ 4=8P>L7;

N79I778$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58;$ =8$ 9K7$ '8=58$ I=9K

9K5;7$ 5A9;=D7$ =9;$ N5@D7@;M$ >8D$ 9K7$ =8<789=J7;$ 9K>9

7Q=;9$?5@$2=L@>9=58$95$9K7$#'M$27>8$9K>9$#'$354=<=7;

D7;=L87D$ 95$ >DD@7;;$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ 9K7

'8=58$2A;9$>4;5$<58;=D7@$9K7=@$;=9A>9=58$=8$9K7$@7;9

5?$#A@537O$!K=;$=;$3>@9=<A4>@46$9K7$<>;7$IK7@7$9K7$#'

2>8>L7;$3@5L@>227;$95$3@73>@7$;9>97;$?5@$><<7;C

;=58$5@$IK7@7$=9$2>8>L7;$7Q97@8>4$>=D$3@5L@>227;M

N59K$5?$IK=<K$2=LK9$>DD@7;;$,52>8=$=;;A7;O$&8$;A<K

<5A89@=7;$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ 354=<=7;$ =8?4A78<=8L

,52>$ @72>=8$ A8D7@D7J74537D$ >8D$ A8D7@C=2347C

27897DO$)?$3>@9=<A4>@$<58<7@8$>@7$9K7$<5A89@=7;$5?

9K7$?5@27@$iAL5;4>J=>$cI=9K$9K7$7Q<739=58$5?$%45J7C

8=>d$>8D$(4N>8=>$caS7;97@8$U>4P>8;adO

;," (49K5ALK$9K7$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$?5@$#Q97@8>4

,74>9=58;$?=8>8<7;$?=J7$3@5W7<9;$9K>9$9>@L79$,52>$=8

9K7$U>4P>8;$>8D$'P@>=87M$I5@9K$!FOY2M$>8D$;7J782=85@=9=7;$3@5W7<9;$9K>9$=8<4AD7$,52>$N787?=<=>@=7;M

I5@9K$!^OY2M$9K7$;<>47$5?$9K7$3@5N472$=;$;A<K$9K>9>$2A<K$4>@L7@M$2A49=C8>9=58>4$7??5@9$=;$@7TA=@7DO$-5@7

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RRf +5@$>$858C7QK>A;9=J7$4=;9$5?$?5@<7D$7J=<9=58;$<>;7;$D5<A27897D$N6$9K7$#,,B$I=9K$;A335@9$?@52$9K7$*5@I7L=>8$+5@7=L8$-=8=;9@6

>8D$9K7$U@=9=;K$#2N>;;6$=8$UAD>37;9M$;77$aB522789;$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@$c#,,Bd$>8D$9K7$B789@7$58$"5A;=8L

,=LK9;$>8D$#J=<9=58;$ cB)",#d$58$9K7$5<<>;=58$5?$ 9K7$(@9=<47$RZ$,7J=7I$5?$/@77<7M$"A8L>@6$>8D$!A@P76$A8D7@$9K7$#A@537>8

%5<=>4$BK>@97@$;A37@J=;=58$<6<47$nV&&CRaM$07<72N7@$RM$FGGEM$>J>=4>N47$58$9K7$#,,B$&897@879$I7N;=97j$K993jee7@@<O5@Le3AN4=<>9=58;e

=8D=<7;eK5A;=8LO;K924O

RRh 0>9>$ ?@52$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ 1>@4=>2789X;$ B5A89@6$ 1@5?=47$ 58$ "A8L>@6O$ (J>=4>N47$ 58$ 9K7$ &897@879$ >9j$ K993jeeIIIO7A@53>@4O7AO=89e

784>@L72789p87Ie>334=<>89;e3D?eKA8L>@6p3@5?=47p78O3D?O

Page 49: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

7Q978;=J7$<5C?=8>8<=8L$2>6$N7$35;;=N47$=8$9K7$?A9A@7

L=J78$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ >N5J7$ 3@5W7<9;$ >@7$ >D2=8=;97@7D$ =8

<5C537@>9=58$I=9K$9K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537M$)%B#$>8D

#A@537>8$ >8D$ 45<>4$ */);M$ >8D$ 9K7$ 0=@7<95@>97X;

3@5L@>22=8L$?5@$FGGYeFGGZ$=;$7Q37<97D$95$=8<4AD7

>$;9@58L$>89=C@><=;2$>8D$2=85@=96$3@597<9=58$<5235C

8789$=8$9K7$U>4P>8;$>8D$59K7@$<5A89@=7;O

;-" 07;3=97$9K=;$3@7;78<7M$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>

K>;$859$=8$9K7$3>;9$N778$;A??=<=78946$723K>;=;7D$=8

#A@537>8$'8=58$354=<6$?@>27I5@P;O *59$5846$=;$9K7

;=9A>9=58$=8$9K7$S7;97@8$U>4P>8;$<523>@>N47$95$9K>9

=8$B789@>4$ >8D$#>;97@8$#A@537$>;$ ?>@$ >;$,52>$>@7

<58<7@87DM$NA9$,52>$I7@7$79K8=<>446$<47>8;7D$?@52

`5;5J5$N6$79K8=<$(4N>8=>8;$?5445I=8L$9K7$I=9KD@>IC

>4$ 5?$ iAL5;4>J$ 9@553;$ ?@52$ 9K7$ 3@5J=8<7$ >8D$ 9K7

@79A@8$ 5?$ ;7J7@>4$ KA8D@7D$ 9K5A;>8D$ 79K8=<$ (4N>8=C

>8;O$ !5$ D>97M$ D7;3=97$ =8978;7$ 3@7;;A@7$ 95$ 3@5J=D7

;7<A@=96$ =8$ `5;5J5$ ?5@$ ,52>M$ 59K7@;$ @7L>@D7D$ >;

a/63;=7;a$>8D$2=85@=9=7;$L787@>446M$;A<K$9K>9$@79A@8;

2>6$<52278<7M$9K7$>A9K5@=9=7;$K>J7$859$679$2>8C

>L7D$ 95$3@5J=D7$;A<K$;7<A@=96O (<<5@D=8L$ 95$ 45<>4

>A9K5@=9=7;M$85$37@;58$K>;$7J7@$N778$3@5;7<A97D$?5@

>8$>89=C,52>8=$5@$>89=C/63;6$<@=27$=8$`5;5J5M$>8D

=23A8=96$?5@$@><=>446C259=J>97D$J=5478<7$>L>=8;9$37@C

;58;$@7L>@D7D$>;$a/63;=7;a$=;$<A@@78946$<5234797O

;4" !K7@7$>@7$4>@L7$8A2N7@;$5?$D=;34><7D$,52>

c>8D$59K7@;$@7L>@D7D$>;$a/63;=7;ad$4=J=8L$=8$7Q9@727

<58D=9=58;$=8$%7@N=>$>8D$-589787L@5O$!K7@7$>@7$>4;5

2>86$ 9K5A;>8D;$ 5?$ ,52>8=$ @7?AL77;$ =8$ <5A89@=7;

;A<K$ >;$ U5;8=>$ >8D$ "7@_7L5J=8>$ >8D$ -><7D58=>M

D7;3=97$9K7$J7@6$I7>P$<>3><=96$5?$9K5;7$<5A89@=7;$95

3@5J=D7$ 7??7<9=J7$ 3@597<9=58$ 95$ 9K72O$ ,52>8=

@7?AL77;$ ?@52$ `5;5J5$ >@7$ ;<>997@7D$ 9K@5ALK5A9

#A@537$ >8D$ 9K7@7$ >@7$ =8D=<>9=58;$ 9K>9$25@7$ ,52>

>8D$59K7@;$N7458L=8L$ 95$L@5A3;$ @7L>@D7D$>;$ a/63C

;=7;a$ 47>J7M$5?978$9K@5ALK$<4>8D7;9=87$27>8;M$ 9K>8

;9>6O !K7$0>6958$17><7$;799472789M$IK=<K$78D7D

9K7$<58?4=<9$=8$U5;8=>$>8D$"7@_7L5J=8>$>8D$3@5J=D7D

?5@$ 35;9C<58?4=<9$ >D2=8=;9@>9=J7$ >@@>8L72789;M$ K>;

@7;A497D$ =8$ 9K7$;9@A<9A@>4$7Q<4A;=58$5?$,52>M$;=8<7

=9;$3@5J=;=58;$78;K@=87$9@=C3>@9>97$>@@>8L72789;$?5@

9K7$9K@77$I>@@=8L$L@5A3;M$95$9K7$7Q<4A;=58$5?$>44$59KC

7@;O$ +5@$ 9K7;7$ @7>;58;$ >8D$ 59K7@;$ @74>97D$ 95$ 9K7

35;9C<58?4=<9$ ;=9A>9=58M$ ;A=9>N47$ <58D=9=58;$ ;9=44$ CC

<45;7$95$>$D7<>D7$>?97@$9K7$78D$5?$9K7$<58?4=<9$CC$D5

859$7Q=;9$ ?5@$ 9K7$ @79A@8$>8D$ =897L@>9=58$5?$,52>$ =8

U5;8=>$>8D$"7@_7L5J=8>O$!K7@7$>@7$>4;5$;7@=5A;$<58C

<7@8;$@74>97D$95$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>$8A2N7@

5?$<5A89@=7;$5?$9K7$?5@27@$%5J=79$'8=58O

=6" 0A7$95$9K7$3@5Q=2=96$5?$9K7$<5A89@=7;$5?$9K7

S7;97@8$ U>4P>8;$ >8D$ 9K7$ ?5@27@$ %5J=79$ '8=58$ 95

9K7$#'M$>8D$9K7$?><9$5?$?4=LK9$?@52$79K8=<$37@;7<AC

9=58$>8D$7Q9@727$35J7@96M$>;$I744$>;$9K7$;K77@$;=_7

5?$ 9K7$ 7Q<4AD7D$ ,52>8=$ <522A8=9=7;$ =8$ 9K7;7

<5A89@=7;M$9K7$;<>47$5?$?=8>8<=>4$>;;=;9>8<7$>8D$9K7

D7L@77$ 5?$ 354=<6$ >DJ=<7$ 5??7@7D$ N59K$ 877D$ 95$ N7

;AN;9>89=>446$=8<@7>;7DO

%1297*+0#7*<#9$M/2$$0

=6" &9$=;$8597I5@9K6$9K>9$7??5@9;$95$N@=8L$>N5A9$>8$7J7@

<45;7@$ 354=9=<>4$ >8D$ 7<5852=<$ A8=58$ K>J7$ N778

><<523>8=7D$ N6$ 7J7@$ 25@7$ ;9@=8L789$ 27>;A@7;$ =8

-72N7@$ %9>97;$ I=9K$ @7;37<9$ 95$ 9K7$ 9@7>92789$ 5?

2=L@>89;$>8D$@=LK9;$5?$2=L@>89;$>8D$@7?AL77;O$)?$3>@C

9=<A4>@$=23><9$58$,52>8=$<522A8=9=7;$K>J7$N778j

q ,><=>446$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$N5@D7@$354=<=7;$>8D$3@><C

9=<7;$ =8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ c25;9

859>N46$9K7$'8=97D$`=8LD52do

q B5447<9=J7$ 7Q3A4;=58;$ 5?$ ,52>$ N6$ 9K7$ L5J7@8C

2789;$5?$ >$8A2N7@$5?$-72N7@$%9>97;$ c>8D$ ?5@

IK=<K$9I5$L5J7@82789;${U74L=A2$>8D$&9>46|$K>J7

N778$?5A8D$=8$J=54>9=58$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$KA2>8

@=LK9;$ 4>I$ N6$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ B5A@9$ 5?$ "A2>8

,=LK9;M$5@$K>J7$;79947D$5A9$5?$<5A@9$DA7$95$=22=C

8789$?=8D=8L;$5?$J=54>9=58;do

q !K7$7@5;=58$5?$3@597<9=58;$?5@$@7?AL77;O

=5" !K7$ ,52>8=$ 353A4>9=58$ 5?$ ;527$ -72N7@

%9>97;M$;A<K$>;$(A;9@=>M$2>6$N7$<523@=;7D$5?$A3$95

fGl$ 37@;58;$ IK5$ >@7$ 859$ 9K7$ <=9=_78;$ 5?$ >8$ #'

-72N7@$%9>97O$B52258$<5A89@=7;C5?C5@=L=8$?5@$858C

#'$,52>8=$2=L@>89;$=8$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$=8<4AD7

B>8D=D>97$B5A89@=7;$UA4L>@=>M$,52>8=>$>8D$!A@P76M

NA9$ 7;37<=>446$ <5A89@=7;$ IK=<K$ >@7$ 859$ 679$ <>8D=C

D>97;$ ?5@$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ 272N7@;K=3M$ ;A<K$ >;

(4N>8=>M$ -><7D58=>$ >8D$ %7@N=>$ >8D$ -589787L@5M

NA9$ >@7$ =8$ J7@6$ <45;7$ 3@5Q=2=96$ 95$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

'8=58O$!K7$<589=8A7D$?>=4A@7$95$ =897L@>97$;A<K$37@C

;58;M$ IK5$2>6$ N7$ 458LC97@2$ @7;=D789;$ =8$ >$ #A@5C

37>8$ '8=58$ -72N7@$ %9>97M$ L=J7;$ @=;7$ 95

3;6<K545L=<>4$>;$I744$>;$;5<=>4$>8D$7<5852=<$K>@2

95$=8D=J=DA>4;O

=;" +=8>446M$9K7@7$>@7$3@5N472>9=<$?7>9A@7;$95$9K7

#'$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$4>I$?@>27I5@P$>;$=9$@74>97;$95

858C<=9=_78;O$&8$9K7$L787@>4$3@5J=;=58;$5?$9K7$0=@7<C

9=J7M$ >9$ (@9=<47$ EcRdM$ 9K7$ 0=@7<9=J7$ 3@5J=D7;$ 9K>9$ =9;

;<537$5?$>334=<>9=58$;K>44$N7$a>44$37@;58;aO$"5I7J7@M

(@9=<47$ EcFd$ 5?$ 0=@7<9=J7$ FGGGeHEe#B$ ;9>97;j$ a!K=;

0=@7<9=J7$ D57;$ 859$ <5J7@$ D=??7@78<7$ 5?$ 9@7>92789

N>;7D$58$8>9=58>4=96$>8D$=;$I=9K5A9$3@7WAD=<7$95$3@5C

J=;=58;$>8D$<58D=9=58;$@74>9=8L$95$9K7$789@6$=895$>8D

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 50: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

@7;=D78<7$ 5?$ 9K=@DC<5A89@6$ 8>9=58>4;$ >8D$ ;9>9747;;

37@;58;$58$ 9K7$ 97@@=95@6$5?$-72N7@$%9>97;M$>8D$95

>86$9@7>92789$IK=<K$>@=;7;$?@52$9K7$47L>4$;9>9A;$5?

9K7$ 9K=@DC<5A89@6$ 8>9=58>4;$ >8D$ ;9>9747;;$ 37@;58;

<58<7@87DOa$(;$679M$85$N5D6$5?$WA@=;3@AD78<7$7Q=;9;

95$ =8D=<>97$ K5I$ 9K7$ D=;3>@=96$ N79I778$ 9K7$ 3@5J=C

;=58;$5?$(@9=<47$EcRd$>8D$(@9=<47$EcFd$;K5A4D$N7$@7LAC

4>97DO$ !K7$ ?@=<9=58$ N79I778$ 9K7;7$ 9I5$ 3@5J=;=58;

L=J7;$@=;7$95$9K7$<58<7@8$9K>9$=8D=J=DA>4;$2>6$;A??7@

@><=>4$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D$ 859$ K>J7$ >86$ @7<5A@;7$ =?

9K7$D=;<@=2=8>95@$WA;9=?=7;$9K7$><9=58$58$L@5A8D;$9K>9

9K7$ 37@;58$ <58<7@87D$ =;$ >$ 9K=@DC<5A89@6$ 8>9=58>4O

!K7$3@5J=;=58$=;$D=;9=8<946$>9$5DD;$I=9K$=897@8>9=58>4

KA2>8$@=LK9;$4>IORFG

1*788$001V1'1+)#(M#M/*<1*2

==" !K7$7??7<9=J787;;$5?$#'$354=<=7;$D7378D;$=8$J7@6

4>@L7$3>@9$58$9K7$><<7;;=N=4=96$5?$;AN;7TA789$?A8D=8L

>8D$9K7@7$=;$>$I=D7;3@7>D$N74=7?$9K>9M$>9$3@7;789M$#'

?A8D=8L$=;$?@>L27897DM$<52347Q$>8D$=;$J7@6$D=??=<A49

95$><<7;;$3>@9=<A4>@46$ ?5@$<=J=4$;5<=796$><95@;O$-5@7C

5J7@M$ <52347Q=96$ 5?$ ?A8D=8L$ D57;$ 859$ 78<5A@>L7

9@>8;3>@78<6$=8$9K7$>334=<>9=58$?5@M$>8D$A;7$5?M$?A8D;O

&9$K>;$N778$5N;7@J7D$9K>9$1K>@7$K>;$N778$3>@9=<A4>@C

46$ ;A<<7;;?A4$ IK7@7$ 3@5W7<9;$ K>J7$ N778$ D7;=L87D

I=9K$>8$767$95$NA=4D=8L$;9>P7K54D7@$<>3><=96$95$I5@P

A8D7@$ ?A9A@7$ ;9@A<9A@>4$ ?A8D=8L$27<K>8=;2;M$ ?><=4=C

9>9=8L$?A9A@7$><<7;;$95$#'$D=;<@79=58>@6$?A8D;O

+.$#*$$<#M(9#7*#$/#9(%7#

1*+$297+1(*#<19$8+1\$

=A" !K7$ ;<>47$ 5?$ 3@5N472;$ ?><=8L$ ,52>$ K>;$ 47D

@7<78946$ 95$ >$ 3@535;>4$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58

>D539$>$,52>$ &897L@>9=58$0=@7<9=J7O$ &8$ =9;$ a,735@9

58$9K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;$=8$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$'8=58$?5@$FGGEaM$D>97D$g>8A>@6$FGGH$NA9$5846

3AN4=;K7D$58$->6$FZ9KM$FGGHM$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58

*79I5@P$5?$#Q37@9;$=8$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;$@7<52C

278D7D$ 9K7$ >D539=58$ 5?$ >$ a0=@7<9=J7$ ;37<=?=<>446

>=27D$>9$78<5A@>L=8L$ 9K7$ =897L@>9=58$5?$,52>aORFR

!K7$#'$*79I5@P$5?$#Q37@9;$=8$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;

I>;$ 7;9>N4=;K7D$ N6$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$B522=;;=58$ >9

9K7$ @7TA7;9$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ 1>@4=>2789$ >8D

<K>@L7D$I=9K$258=95@=8L$?A8D>2789>4$@=LK9;$=8$9K7

-72N7@$ %9>97;$ >8D$ =8$ 9K7$ '8=58O$ &9$ <523@=;7;

47>D=8L$WA@=;9;$?@52$>44$5?$9K7$#'$-72N7@$%9>97;O

=B" &8$3@7;789=8L$9K7$877D$?5@$;A<K$>$0=@7<9=J7M

9K7$ #'$ *79I5@P$ 5?$ #Q37@9;$ ?=@;9$ 8597;$ 9K>9M$ a!K7

<58<739$5?$A8=J7@;>4$;7@J=<7${OOO|$;K5A4D$=8$3>@9=<A4>@

9>P7$><<5A89$5?$ 9K7$;37<=>4$ ;=9A>9=58$5?$<522A8=C

9=7;$ 4=J=8L$ =8$ <58D=9=58;$ 5?$ ;7L@7L>9=58M$ =;54>97D

?@52$ 9K7$ @7;9$ 5?$ 9K7$ <522A8=96M$ 7;37<=>446$ IK78

45I$ =8<527$ ?5@2;$ >8$5N;9><47$ 95$ 9K7$ A;7$5?$ 3>=D

9@>8;35@9O$!K7$<>;7$5?$ 9K7$,52>$3@7;789;$ =9;74?$ =8

9K5;7$97@2;$=8$;7J7@>4$%9>97;\O

=!" !K7$ #'$ *79I5@P$ 5?$ #Q37@9;X$ @735@9$ <589=8C

A7;j$ a!K7$ 25;9$ =235@9>89$ <589@=NA9=58$ IK=<K$ 9K7

#A@537>8$B522A8=96$<5A4D$2>P7$95$9K7$3@597<9=58

5?$2=85@=9=7;M$ I=9K=8$ 9K7$ ?@>27I5@P$ 5?$ =9;$ 7Q=;9=8L

35I7@;M$I5A4D$N7$9K7$>D539=58$5?$>$0=@7<9=J7$;37<=?C

=<>446$ >=27D$ >9$ 78<5A@>L=8L$ 9K7$ =897L@>9=58$ 5?

,52>\O$!K7$)3=8=58;$5?$9K7$(DJ=;5@6$B522=9977$58

9K7$ +@>27I5@P$ B58J789=58$ ?5@$ 9K7$ 1@597<9=58$ 5?

*>9=58>4$-=85@=9=7;$<>44$ =895$TA7;9=58$9K7$=8>D7TA>C

<6$ 5?$0=@7<9=J7$ FGGGeHEe#B$5?$ Fh$ gA87$ FGGGM$ 7J78

9K5ALK$=9$3@597<9;$9K7$,52>$>L>=8;9$>44$D=;<@=2=8>C

9=58$ 58$ 9K7$ L@5A8D$ 5?$ 272N7@;K=3$ 5?$ >8$ 79K8=<

L@5A3O$079>=47D$@7>;58=8L$?5@$;A<K$>$0=@7<9=J7$I=9KC

=8$ J>@=5A;$ ;7<95@;$ ;A<K$ >;$ 7234562789M$ K5A;=8LM

7DA<>9=58$>8D$K7>49K$?5445I;$I=9K=8$9K7$@735@9O

=," +=8>446M$9K7$#'$*79I5@P$5?$#Q37@9;$8597;$9K>9

#'$ >89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ 4>I$ D57;$ 859M$ >9$ 3@7;789M

<5J7@$ =;;A7;$ @74>97D$ 95$ ><<7;;$ 95$ 37@;58>4$ D5<AC

2789;j$a0=@7<9=J7$FGGGeHEe#B$D57;$859$3@5K=N=9$D=;C

<@=2=8>9=58$ =8$ 9K7$ =;;A=8L$ 5?$ >D2=8=;9@>9=J7

D5<A2789;O$ %A<K$ D5<A2789;M$ K5I7J7@M$ >@7$ 5?978

@7TA=@7D$95$><<7;;$<7@9>=8$;5<=>4$N787?=9;$9K>9$<58C

;9=9A97M$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ ?5@$ 2>@L=8>4=;7D$ 375347;M$ >8

7;;789=>4$ >=D$ 95$ =897L@>9=58O$!K=;$ =;$ >859K7@$ @7>;58

IK6$>$0=@7<9=J7$;37<=?=<>446$>=27D$>9$,52>$=;$=8D=;C

378;>N47O$(@9=<47$RE$#B$?5@2;$9K7$>33@53@=>97$47L>4

N>;=;$?5@$;A<K$>$0=@7<9=J7OaRFF

=-" !K7$>A9K5@;$5?$9K7$3@7;789$@735@9$N74=7J7$9K7@7

=;$ ;A??=<=789$ 7J=D78<7$ 95$ ;A335@9$ 9K7$ <58<4A;=58;$5?

""

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RFG %77M$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M$ !K7$ &897@8>9=58>4$B5J78>89$58$B=J=4$ >8D$154=9=<>4$,=LK9;$ c&BB1,dM!K7$ &897@8>9=58>4$B5J78>89$58$#<5852=<M

%5<=>4$>8D$BA49A@>4$,=LK9;$c&B#%B,d$>8D$!K7$&897@8>9=58>4$B58J789=58$58$9K7$#4=2=8>9=58$5?$(44$+5@2;$5?$,><=>4$0=;<@=2=8>9=58

c&B#,0dO$#><K$5?$9K7;7$;37<=?=7;$9K>9$@=LK9;$>@7$<52258$95$>44$=8D=J=DA>4;$=@@7;37<9=J7$5?M$>258L$59K7@$<@=97@=>M$8>9=58>4=96O

RFR #A@537>8$'8=58$*79I5@P$5?$#Q37@9;$=8$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;M$a,735@9$58$9K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;$=8$9K7$#A@537>8

'8=58$?5@$FGGEaM$U@A;;74;M$g>8A>@6$FGGHM$3O$RGEO$!K7$?A44$97Q9$5?$a,735@9$58$9K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$+A8D>2789>4$,=LK9;$=8$9K7$#A@537>8

'8=58$?5@$FGGEa$=;$>J>=4>N47$58$9K7$&897@879$I7N;=97$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58b;$0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$5?$gA;9=<7$>8D$"527

(??>=@;jK993jee7A@53>O7AO=89e<522eWA;9=<7pK527e=8D7Qp78OK92

Page 51: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

9K7$ #'$ #Q37@9;$ =8$ +A8D>2789>4$ ,=LK9;M$ >8D$ 9K>9

I=9K5A9$;A<K$>$0=@7<9=J7M$ 9K7@7$I=44$859$N7$;A??=<=789

=2379A;$?5@$#'$-72N7@$%9>97;$95$=897L@>97$,52>$>8D

59K7@$ L@5A3;$ @7L>@D7D$ >;$ a/63;=7;aO$ &9$ ;K5A4D$ N7

><P85I47DL7DM$ K5I7J7@M$ 9K>9$ 9K=;$ 3@535;>4$ @>=;7;$ >

8A2N7@$ 5?$ 47L>4$ >8D$ 3@><9=<>4$ TA7;9=58;O$ +=@;946M$ 95

IK>9$ 7Q9789$ <5A4D$ 9K7$ <K>4478L7;$ =D789=?=7D$ N7

>DD@7;;7D$ N6$ N7997@$ =23472789>9=58$ >8D

78?5@<72789$5?$7Q=;9=8L$#A@537>8$>8D$8>9=58>4$ >89=C

D=;<@=2=8>9=58$47L=;4>9=58~$%7<58D46M$=;$=9$D7;=@>N47$95

3@535;7$ 5@$ >D539$ 47L=;4>9=58$ 9>@L79=8L$ 587$ ;37<=?=<

79K8=<$ 2=85@=96$ L@5A3M$ >;$ 5335;7D$ 95$ >$ L787@>4

?@>27I5@P$ ?5@$ 7TA>4$ 9@7>92789$ 9K>9$ 2>6$ N787?=9$ >44

2=85@=9=7;~$ !K=@D46M$ K5I$ ?>@$ =;$ 9K7$#'$ <52379789$ 95

=235;7$ @7TA=@72789;$ ?5@$ 35;=9=J7$ ><9=58M$ 9>P=8L$ =895

><<5A89$ 9K7$ WA@=;3@AD78<7$5?$ 9K7$#A@537>8$B5A@9$5?

gA;9=<7~$%K5A4D$=9$N7$9K>9$47L>4$53=8=58$=;$>L>=8;9$9K7

=;;A=8L$5?$;A<K$>$0=@7<9=J7M$9K7$=8<4A;=58$5?$,52>$I=44

D7378D$ A358$ >$ ;7@=7;$ 5?$ 47;;7@M$ NA9$ =235@9>89M

=8D=J=DA>4$ =8=9=>9=J7;$ 9K>9$ 2>6$ <5447<9=J746M$ K5I7J7@M

K>J7$ >$ ;=2=4>@$ 7??7<9$ 95$ >$ 0=@7<9=J7M$ >8D$ IK=<K$ >@7

D79>=47D$=8$9K7$87Q9$BK>397@O

RFF &N=DOM$33ORGFCRG^O

Page 52: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

5" ($8A2N7@$5?$ @7<52278D>9=58;$>8D$5A94=87;$ ?5@

><9=58$ K>J7$ N778$ =8<4AD7D$ 9K@5ALK5A9$ 9K7$ 97Q9$ 5?

9K=;$ @735@9M$ >8D$>$ ;A22>@6$5?$ 9K7$2>=8$35=89;$ ?5@

><9=58$ ?5445I;$ N745IO$ !K@5ALK5A9M$ =9$ ;K5A4D$ N7

723K>;=;7D$9K>9M$=8$5@D7@$?5@$,52>$95$N7$7??7<9=J7C

46$=8<4AD7D$=8$354=<6M$9>@L797D$=8=9=>9=J7;$>@7$@7TA=@7D

>9$ 9K7$ ;>27$ 9=27$ >;$ 9K7$ =8<4A;=58$5?$,52>$I=9K=8

2>=8;9@7>2$354=<=7;$ =;$ 78<5A@>L7DO$ !K=;$ ;9>8<7$ =;

9>P78$=8$9K7$P85I47DL7$9K>9$2>=8;9@7>2$47L=;4>9=58

>8D$354=<=7;$K>J7$=8$9K7$3>;9$859$>;;=;97D$9K7$;=9A>C

9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ >86$2>97@=>4$ I>6M$ >8D$ 9K>9M$ ?5@$ >

8A2N7@$5?$@7>;58;M$9K7$L@5A3$=;$?@7TA78946$7Q<4ADC

7D$?@52$3@5L@>227;$>8D$3@5W7<9;$D7;=L87D$95$N78C

7?=9$ 2>@L=8>4=;7D$ L@5A3;O$ -5@75J7@M$ >;$ ,52>8=

I5278$ 5?978$ ;A??7@$ ?@52$ D5AN47$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58M

3>@9=<A4>@$ >99789=58$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ 3>=D$ 95$ 9K7$ L78D7@

>;37<9;$5?$354=<6$95$78;A@7$9K>9$3@535;>4;$9>P7$?A44

><<5A89$5?$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>8=$I5278O

$/#'$\$'#9$8(%%$*<7+1(*0#

;"#0G??EHW?" ($P76$<58<4A;=58$5?$9K=;$@7;7>@<K$;9AD6

=;$ 9K>9$ 9K7$#'$;K5A4D$<47>@46$>8D$7Q34=<=946$ =D789=?6

,52>$I=9K=8$ 7Q=;9=8L$ >8D$ <523@7K78;=J7$ >89=CD=;C

<@=2=8>9=58$ >8D$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 354=<=7;M$ >8D$ 859

;=2346$ >;;A27$ 9K>9$ ,52>$ I=44$ N7$ 7??7<9=J746$ <5JC

7@7D$N6$;A<K$354=<=7;O$

=" !K7@7$ =;$ >$ 877D$ ?5@$ 354=<=7;$ 95$ N7$ 7??=<=78946

;977@7D$ N6$ >$ N5D6$ I=9K$ ;A??=<=789$ =8?4A78<7$ >8D

>A9K5@=96$ 95$78;A@7$ 9K>9$#'$D73>@92789;M$-72N7@

%9>97$ L5J7@82789;$ >8D$ 59K7@$ ;9>P7K54D7@;$ 9>P7

D7<=;=J7$ ><9=58$ 95$ 9>@L79$ ,52>$ =897L@>9=58O$ $ !K7

#A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ ;K5A4D$ 9K7@7?5@7$ =23@5J7

9K7$ =897@8>4$ <5K7@78<7$ >8D$ 7??=<><6$ 5?$ =9;$ 354=<=7;

>8D$><9=58$@74>9=8L$95$,52>$N6$7;9>N4=;K=8L$>$;9>8DC

=8L$<5C5@D=8>9=58$L@5A3$58$,52>$354=<6M$?7>9A@=8L$>9

>$ 2=8=2A2$ 272N7@;$ ?@52$ 0/$ #234562789$ >8D

%5<=>4$(??>=@;M$0/$#DA<>9=58$>8D$BA49A@7M$0/$1AN4=<

"7>49KM$ 0/$ #8J=@582789M$ 0/$ gA;9=<7$ >8D$ "527

(??>=@;M$0/$#84>@L72789$>8D$0/$#A@5;9>9M$>;$I744$>;

@73@7;789>9=J7;$ ?@52$@747J>89$ ?A8D=8L$ =8;9@A2789;O

!K7$ B522=;;=58$ ;K5A4D$ <58;=D7@$ ;7@=5A;46$ 9K7

7;9>N4=;K2789$ 5?$ ,52>$ 4=>=;58$ A8=9;$ 5@$ 5??=<7@;

9K@5ALK5A9$9K7$B522=;;=58$95$78;A@7$9K>9$354=<=7;

>@7$ =234727897D$7??7<9=J746$>9$>44$ 47J74;O$!K7$#A@5C

37>8$B522=;;=58$;K5A4D$7Q34=<=946$>DD$B522=;;=58

@7;358;=N=4=96$?5@$,52>$=;;A7;$95$9K7$35@9?54=5$5?$>9

47>;9$587$B522=;;=587@M$IK5$I5A4D$>4;5$3@5J=D7$>

35=89$5?$<589><9$?5@$-#1;$I=9K$@7;358;=N=4=96$?5@M$5@

>8$=897@7;9$=8M$,52>$=897L@>9=58O$$

A" !K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$<5A4D$?A@9K7@$47>D

N6$?><=4=9>9=8L$9K7$7;9>N4=;K2789$5?$>$3>8C#A@537>8

;977@=8L$ L@5A3$ 58$ ,52>$ =;;A7;$ =8J54J=8L$ @747J>89

#'$N5D=7;M$ @747J>89$B5A8<=4$ 5?$#A@537$N5D=7;M$ 9K7

)%B#M$-72N7@$%9>97$L5J7@82789;M$@73@7;789>9=J7;

5?$=8=9=>9=J7;$;A<K$>;$9K7$07<>D7$5?$,52>$&8<4A;=58

>8D$9K7$#A@537>8$,52>$+5@A2M$>;$I744$>;$@73@7;78C

9>9=J7;$5?$@747J>89$<=J=4$;5<=796$5@L>8=;>9=58;$;K5A4D

9K7;7$5@L>8=;>9=58;$<58;=D7@$9K=;$95$N7$A;7?A4O$$%A<K

>$N5D6$2=LK9$2779$@7LA4>@46$95$78;A@7$9K7$<5K7;=58

5?$ ,52>C;37<=?=<$ 354=<=7;$ ><@5;;$ #A@537M$ 95$ W5=8

?5@<7;$58$;37<=?=<$=8=9=>9=J7;$>8D$95$78;A@7$>$@>9=58C

>4$D=J=;=58$5?$7??5@9$>8D$9K7$>J5=D>8<7$5?$DA34=<>9=58O

B" !K7;7$ =8=9=>9=J7;$;K5A4D$><9=J746$3@52597$ 9K7

3>@9=<=3>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$354=<6C2>P=8LM$=23472789>C

9=58$>8D$>;;7;;2789O$(<<5@D=8L46M$9K7$B522=;;=58

;K5A4D$ 2>P7$ 7??5@9;$ 95$ @7<@A=9$ ,52>$ =8$ =9;$ ;9@A<C

9A@7;M$>8D$95$3@5J=D7$9@>=8=8L$?5@$,52>$ =8$#'$2>9C

97@;M$=8<4AD=8L$N6$7;9>N4=;K=8L$9@>=8=8L$3@5L@>227;

D=@7<946$=8;=D7$9K7$#'$=8;9=9A9=58;O$!K=;$2>6$=8<4AD7

=897@8;K=3$3@5L@>227;$I=9K=8$9K7$#A@537>8$B52=;C

;=58$>8D$1>@4=>2789$>;$I744$>;$=8$9K7$0747L>9=58;$5?

9K7$ #A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ =8$ <>8D=D>97$ >8D$ 59K7@

<5A89@=7;M$ >8D$ =8$ >L78<=7;$ ;A<K$ >;$ 9K7$ ?A9A@7

"A2>8$,=LK9;$(L78<6$c>8D$<A@@789$#A@537>8$'8=58

-58=95@=8L$B789@7$58$,><=;2$>8D$n7853K5N=>dO$!K7

2>86$ =897@8>9=58>4$ 5@L>8=;>9=58;$ ?A8D7D$ N6$ 9K7

#A@537>8$ B522=;;=58$ ;K5A4D$ >4;5$ 3@52597$ 9K7

=8<4A;=J7$ K=@=8LM$ 9@>=8=8L$ >8D$ 59K7@$ =8J54J72789$ 5?

,52>O$!K7$L5>4$5?$>44$ =8=9=>9=J7;$>9$#'$ 47J74$;K5A4D

N7$ 95$ 78;A@7$ 9K7$ 7??7<9=J7$ =23472789>9=58$ 5?$ 354=C

<=7;$ >=27D$ >9$ =23@5J=8L$ 9K7$ 2>97@=>4$ >8D$ KA2>8

@=LK9;$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?$ ,52>$ =8$ #A@537M$ =8<4AD=8L$ 9K7

!"

ZO$B)*B.'%&)*%M$,#B)--#*0(!&)*%M$S(i%$+),S(,0$$

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 53: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

-72N7@$%9>97;$ >8D$<5A89@=7;$N7658D$ 9K7$N5@D7@;

5?$9K7$#'O

!" 7XGI:9JCHXI#EHKIFC"# !K=;$@735@9$@7?7@;$=8$J>@=C

5A;$34><7;$95$K=LK$47J74;$5?$>89=C,52>8=$;789=2789

=8$#A@537O$"5;9=4=96$95I>@D;$,52>$K>;$N778$@737>9C

7D46$8597D$>;$>8$5N;9><47$95$;A;9>=8=8L$L5J7@82789

354=<=7;$58$,52>O$#'$ =8;9@A2789;$;K5A4D$N7$A;7D

95$@>=;7$>I>@787;;$5?$9K7$;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$;5<=C

796$>8D$95$NA=4D$>$3>8C#A@537>8$3@5C,52>$<5>4=9=58O

(9$9K7$#'b;$D=;35;>4$>@7$9K7$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D

;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ ><9=58$ 3@5L@>227;O$ U7658D$ 9K=;M

9K7$#'$;K5A4D$<58;=D7@$?5<A;7D$>I>@787;;C@>=;=8L

<>23>=L8;$ >458L$ 9K7$ 4=87;$ 5?$ #A@537>8$ 0>6;$ >8D

#A@537>8$i7>@;$;37<=?=<>446$58$9K7$3@5N472;$5?$>89=C

,52>8=$@><=;2$>8D$9K7$<A@@789$;5<=>4$7Q<4A;=58$<@=C

;=;$ ?><=8L$ ,52>$ =8$ #A@537M$ >;$ I744$ >;$ 58$ 59K7@

@747J>89$9K727;O$

," !K7$ #'$ ;K5A4D$ >4;5$ 78<5A@>L7$ -72N7@

%9>97;M$ <>8D=D>97$ <5A89@=7;$ >8D$ 59K7@$ <5A89@=7;

IK7@7$,52>$4=J7$95$A8D7@9>P7$;A<K$>I>@787;;C@>=;C

=8L$<>23>=L8;O$(N5J7$>44M$=9$=;$=8<A2N789$A358$9K7

354=9=<>4$ 74=97;$ 5?$ #A@537>8$ ;5<=796M$ >9$ 9K7$ 45<>4M

@7L=58>4M$8>9=58>4$>8D$9@>8;C8>9=58>4$ 47J74M$ 95$;37>P

5A9$CC$>8D$95$><9$CC$>L>=8;9$>89=C,52>8=$@><=;2O

-" %JXIGJEIXW#HXGI:2LRFLIFC" #Q=;9=8L$#A@537>8

258=95@=8L$N5D=7;$ ;K5A4D$D7J597$7Q34=<=9$ >99789=58

95$9K7$3@5N472$5?$>89=C/63;6=;2$>;$>$;37<=?=<$?5@2

5?$@><=;2O$!K7@7$=;$>$877D$?5@$74>N5@>9=58$>8D$D5<AC

2789>9=58e@7;7>@<K$=895$9K7$;37<=?=<$?5@2;$9K=;$3K7C

8527858$ 9>P7;M$ >;$ I744$ >;$ 9K7$ 7;9>N4=;K2789$ 5?

@7LA4>@$258=95@=8L$5?$47J74;$5?$>89=C/63;6=;2$=8$3>@C

9=<A4>@$ ;9>97;M$ >;$I744$ >;$ =8$ #A@537$ >;$ >$IK547O$ &8

4=LK9$5?$ 9K7$<A@@789$<@=;=;$5?$>89=C,52>8=$;789=2789

=8$#A@537M$9K7$7;9>N4=;K2789$5?$>$;9>8D=8L$N5D6$95

258=95@$>8D$@735@9$58$D7J74532789;$=8$9K7$?=74D$5?

>89=C/63;6=;2M$95$N7$45<>97D$>9$>$@747J>89$#A@537>8

=8;9=9A9=58M$;K5A4D$N7$;7@=5A;46$<58;=D7@7DO$$

4" 9JCH# IX@J>@?C?XG" !K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58M$ >9

9K7$ !>237@7$ ;A22=9$ =8$ 07<72N7@$ RhhhM$ 723K>C

;=;7D$9K7$877D$?5@$27>;A@7;$95$><K=7J7$?A44$7TA>4=96

5?$5335@9A8=9=7;$?5@$2=85@=9=7;O$!K7$7??7<9=J7$3>@9=<=C

3>9=58$5?$,52>$5ALK9$95$N7$78;A@7D$>9$9K7$7>@4=7;9

;9>L7;$ 5?$ 354=<6$ ?5@2>9=58M$ 3@5L@>227$ D7;=L8M

=23472789>9=58$ >8D$ 7J>4A>9=58O$ (;$ K>;$ N778

;9@7;;7D$ @737>97D46$ N6$ ><95@;$ =8J54J7D$ N59K$ =8

=23472789=8L$>8D$D7J7453=8L$3@5W7<9;$>8D$354=<=7;M

,52>$ =8J54J72789$ >9$ >44$ ;9>L7;$ =;$ P76$ 95$ 9K7$ @7>4

=23><9$>8D$;A;9>=8>N=4=96$5?$=8=9=>9=J7;O$!K7$B522=;C

;=58$<>8$34>6$>$2>W5@$@547$ =8$3@5259=8L$>8D$7;9>NC

4=;K=8L$ <5537@>9=58$ N79I778$ 9K5;7$ 8>9=58>4$ >8D

45<>4$><95@;$=8J54J7D$=8$9K7$D7;=L8$>8D$=23472789>C

9=58$5?$3@5L@>227;$>8D$9K7$N787?=<=>@=7;M$=8<4AD=8L

D=;>DJ>89>L7D$ L@5A3;$25@7$ N@5>D46M$ >8D$ ,52>$ =8

3>@9=<A4>@O$

56" )87$<58D=9=58$?5@$9K7$=8<@7>;7D$=8J54J72789

5?$,52>$=8$N59K$354=<6$>8D$3@5W7<9;$=;$9K7$<>3><=96

5?$ 45<>4$ L@5A3;$ >8D$ 5@L>8=;>9=58;$ 95$ 3>@9=<=3>97

><9=J746O$ !K7@7$ =;$ >8$ A@L789$ 877D$ 95$ 7235I7@

,52>8=$ 5@L>8=;>9=58;$ >8D$ @73@7;789>9=J7;M$ N59K

354=9=<>446$>8D$3@><9=<>446M$ =8$ 9K=;$ ?=74DO$#Q=;9=8L$3@5C

L@>227;$A8D7@M$ ?5@$ 7Q>2347M$ 9K7$#A@537>8$%5<=>4

+A8D$K>J7$9K7$359789=>4$95$=8<4AD7$<52358789;$?5@

9@>=8=8L$ >8D$ 9K7$ 7235I7@2789$ 5?$ ,52>8=$ L@5A3;

>8D$ =8D=J=DA>4;$ =8$5@D7@$ ?5@$ 9K72$95$N7<527$25@7

><9=J7$ =8$ =23472789=8L$ >8D$ ;K>3=8L$ 354=<=7;$ >8D

3@5L@>227;O$ "5I7J7@M$ 95$ D>97M$ J7@6$ ?7I$ 3@5W7<9;

K>J7$2>D7$A;7$5?$9K=;$35;;=N=4=96O$!K7$B522=;;=58

;K5A4D$>4;5$<58;=D7@$9K7$@7LA4>@$>445<>9=58$5?$>$;37C

<=?=<$9@>=8=8L$NADL79$=8$5@D7@$95$3@5J=D7$=8?5@2>9=58

58$#'$354=<=7;$>8D$9K7$#'b;$;9@A<9A@7;$>8D$I5@P=8L

279K5D;$95$9K7$,52>$>8D$59K7@$2=85@=96$@73@7;78C

9>9=J7;O$ (44$ @747J>89$ 3@5W7<9;$ ;K5A4D$ =8<4AD7$ <47>@

LA=D74=87;$?5@$,52>$=8J54J72789O

55"# 0GHGIFGIKH># YHGH" !K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ ;K5A4D

<589=8A7$95$>DD@7;;$>8D$@727D6$9K7$D7?=<=78<=7;$=8$=9;

79K8=<$D>9>$<5447<9=58$?@>27I5@P;M$><@5;;$9K5;7$;7<C

95@;$D7;<@=N7D$>N5J7O$SK=4;9$9K7$>99=9AD7;$5?$-72N7@

%9>97;$ 95$ ;A<K$ <5447<9=58$ J>@=7;M$ >$ <47>@$ ;9>972789

?@52$9K7$B522=;;=58$58$9K7$877D$?5@$;A<K$=8?5@2>C

9=58M$>8D$LA=D>8<7$58$=9;$<5447<9=58M$I5A4D$3@5J=D7$>

2>W5@$ =8<789=J7$ ?5@$-72N7@$%9>97;$ 95$ =23@5J7$ 9K7=@

37@?5@2>8<7$ =8$ 9K=;$ >@7>O$ $ &9$ =;$ @7<5L8=;7D$ 9K>9$ 9K7

=;;A=8L$5?$;A<K$>DJ=<7$I=44$877D$95$>I>=9$9K7$@7;A49;$5?

9K7$ @7;7>@<K$ <A@@78946$ N7=8L$ <>@@=7D$ 5A9$ 58$ =897@8>C

9=58>4$ 85@2;M$ >8D$ 9K7$ J=7I;$ 3@5J=D7D$ N6$ -72N7@

%9>97$@73@7;789>9=J7;$>9$9K7$2779=8L$5?$9K7$S5@P=8L

/@5A3$58$79K8=<$D>9>$<5447<9=58$;<K7DA47D$?5@$9K7$78D

5?$FGGHO$*7J7@9K747;;M$9K7$7Q=;978<7$=8$FGGY$5?$>$3>8C

#A@537>8$ ;9@A<9A@7$ ?5@$ D>9>$ <5447<9=58$ 58$ 79K8=<=96

I5A4D$N7$5?$J7@6$L@7>9$K743O$ $(9$9K7$;>27$9=27M$9K7

B522=;;=58$I=44$I=;K$ 95$7Q>2=87$ =9;$ =897@8>4$3@5<7C

DA@7;$ 58$ 37@;58874$ D>9>$ <5447<9=58$ cL78D7@$ >8D

8>9=58>4=96$D>9>$>@7$<5447<97DM$NA9$859$D>9>$58$79K8=<

5@=L=8d$>8D$58$9K7$@7<@A=92789$95$#'$;9@A<9A@7;$5?$79KC

8=<$2=85@=96$@73@7;789>9=J7;M$=8<4AD=8L$,52>O$

5;"# '?WIF>HGIJX" !K7$ B522=;;=58$ K>;$ >4@7>D6

4>A8<K7D$ =8?@=8L72789$ 3@5<7DA@7;$ >L>=8;9$ >$ 8A2C

N7@$5?$-72N7@$%9>97;$9K>9$K>J7$?>=47D$95$9@>8;35;7

9K7$ ,><7$ 0=@7<9=J7$ >8D$ 9K7$ #234562789$ c?@>27C

I5@Pd$0=@7<9=J7$ =895$ 8>9=58>4$ 4>IO$ !K7$B522=;;=58

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 54: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

;K5A4D$ <589=8A7$ 95$ 9>P7$ 9K7$ >33@53@=>97$ ><9=58$ =8

5@D7@$ 95$ 78;A@7$ 9K>9$ >44$-72N7@$ %9>97;$ 9@>8;35;7

=895$9K7=@$D527;9=<$4>I$>44$7472789;$5?$9K7$0=@7<9=J7O

&8$>;;7;;=8L$?A44$<5234=>8<7$N6$-72N7@$%9>97;$I=9K

9K7$ @7TA=@72789$ 5?$ 9@>8;35;=9=58M$ 9K7$ #A@537>8

B522=;;=58$>8D$59K7@$#'$N5D=7;$;K5A4D$9>P7$ =895

><<5A89$?=@;9$>8D$?5@725;9$9K7$>N=4=96$5?$=8D=J=DA>4;

=8$@7>4=96$95$K>J7$><<7;;$95$WA;9=<7$IK78$9K76$K>J7

;A??7@7D$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58O

5=" !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$ ;K5A4D$ >D539M$I=9K5A9

D74>6M$ <@=2=8>4$ 4>I$ ;9>8D>@D;$ =8$ 9K7$ >@7>$ 5?$ K>97

<@=27;$95$78;A@7$9K>9$@><7$=;$;778$>;$>8$>LL@>J>9=8L

<=@<A2;9>8<7$ A8D7@$ -72N7@$ %9>97$ 4>IO$ !K7$ #'

;K5A4D$>4;5$>278D$5@$<4>@=?6$0=@7<9=J7;$;A<K$9K>9$9K7

>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ ?@>27I5@P$ <47>@46$ >334=7;$ 95$ >44

37@;58;$ @7;=D789$ =8$-72N7@$ %9>97;$ >8D$ D57;$ 859

>@N=9@>@=46$>445I$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$58$L@5A8D;$5?$8>9=58C

>4=96O$ !K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ ;K5A4D$ >4;5$ ;9@78L9K78

9K7$ 47L>4$ ?@>27I5@P$ ?5@$ >DD@7;;=8L$ 9K7$ ;37<=?=<

=23><9$5?$78J=@582789>4$K>@2$58$79K8=<$>8D$2=85@C

=96$L@5A3;M$N6$=8<4AD=8L$=8$9K7$D@>?9$0=@7<9=J7$5?$9K7

#A@537>8$1>@4=>2789$>8D$5?$9K7$B5A8<=4$58$(<<7;;

95$gA;9=<7$=8$#8J=@582789>4$->997@;$CC$>;$I744$>;$=8

@74>97D$ @A47;$>8D$354=<=7;$ CC$7Q34=<=9$ 4=8P>L7;$ 95$ 9K7

#'$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ ?@>27I5@PM$>8D$ =8$3>@9=<A4>@

95$0=@7<9=J7$HEeFGGGO$

5A" !K7@7$=;$>$877D$95$<58;=D7@$9K7$>D539=58$5?

#'$@A47;$3@5K=N=9=8L$79K8=<$>8D$@><=>4$;7L@7L>9=58$=8

9K7$?=74D;$5?M$>9$2=8=2A2M$7DA<>9=58M$K5A;=8L$>8D

K7>49K<>@7O$ !K7$ '8=58$ ;K5A4D$ =8J7;9=L>97$ ?A@9K7@

9K7$ D7J74532789$ 5?$ 47L>4$ 27>;A@7;$ =8$ 9K=;$ >@7>M

3@5J=D=8L$ [=897@$ >4=>\$ D7?=8=9=58;$ >8D$ 2=8=2A2

27>;A@7;$ 95$ <52N>9$ @><=>4$ ;7L@7L>9=58M$ =8<4AD=8L

?5@2>4$258=95@=8L$=8;37<9=58;$>8D$;>8<9=58;O$%527

K>J7$3@535;7D$>$ aD7;7L@7L>9=58$D=@7<9=J7a$<523>C

@>N47$95$9K7$(@9=<47$RE$0=@7<9=J7;$@74>9=8L$95$@><7$>8D

7234562789O$ !K=;$ =D7>$27@=9;$ <45;7@$ ;<@A9=86$ >8D

;K5A4D$N7$9K7$?5<A;$5?$?A@9K7@$@7;7>@<K$>8D$354=<6

=8=9=>9=J7;O$ &8$ >DD=9=58M$ 9K7$ >A9K5@;$ 5?$ 9K=;$ ;9AD6

N74=7J7$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ 3@535;7D$ =D7>$ 5?$ 47L>4$27>;A@7;

N=8D=8L$ 9K7$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ 95$ 9K7$ =897L@>9=58$ 5?

,52>$ D7;7@J7;$ ?A44$ <58;=D7@>9=58M$ >8D$ 9K>9$ 9K7

#A@537>8$ 3AN4=<$ =;$ 5I7D$ >$I744CL@5A8D7D$ D7N>97

58$9K7$;ANW7<9O$%A<K$>$D7N>97$;K5A4D$=D7>446$N7$47D

N6$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$=8;9=9A9=58;M$=8$3>@9=<A4>@$9K7

#A@537>8$B522=;;=58O

5B"# 0JKIH># IXK>SFIJX" %5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ 5?$ ,52>

;K5A4D$ N7$ 9K7$ ?5<A;$ 5?$ ;K5@9CM$27D=A2C$ >8D$ 458LC

97@2$<522=92789$N6$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58M$-72N7@

%9>97$ L5J7@82789;$ >8D$ 59K7@$ ;9>P7K54D7@;O$ !K7

#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$;K5A4D$78<5A@>L7$>44$-72C

N7@$ %9>97;$ 95$ >DD@7;;$,52>M$/63;=7;$ >8De5@$ !@>JC

7447@;$ >;$ >$ 9>@L79$ L@5A3$ ?5@$ 9K7$ 3A@35;7;$ 5?$ 9K7=@

*>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8;$58$%5<=>4$ &8<4A;=58M$ .=?7458L

.7>@8=8LM$ #234562789$ >8D$ 59K7@$ @747J>89$ 354=<6

?@>27I5@P;O$ !K=;$ =;$ <58;=D7@7D$ >$ J>4=D$ >33@5><K

L=J78$ 9K>9M$ 3>@9=<A4>@46$ =8$ 9K7$ 54D$ -72N7@$ %9>97;M

,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$>@7$5?978$5J7@455P7DM

IK=4;9$ 25@7$ J=;=N47$ 5@$ J5<=?7@5A;$ 2=85@=9=7;$ >@7

5?978$25@7$;A<<7;;?A4$=8$=8?4A78<=8L$354=<6O

5!" !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$;K5A4D$7Q34=<=946$4=8P$9K7

A;7$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$%5<=>4$+A8D$95$9K7$.=;N58$>L78C

D>$>8DM$95$9K7$7Q9789$35;;=N47M$;K5A4D$>278D$@A47;

95$37@2=9$9K7$A;7$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$,7L=58>4$07J74C

532789$ +A8D$ ?5@$ 3@5W7<9;$ =8$ 9K7$ ?=74D;$ 5?$ K5A;=8L

>8D$ K7>49K$ >8D$ @74>97D$ =8?@>;9@A<9A@7O$ (9$ 9K7$ J7@6

47>;9M$9K7$#%+$>8D$9K7$#,0+$;K5A4D$@7<5L8=;7$>8D

3AN4=<=;7$ 9K7$<@5;;C<A99=8L$8>9A@7$5?$,52>M$/63;6

>8D$!@>J7447@$=;;A7;M$=8$9K7$;>27$I>6$>;$L78D7@$>8D

D=;>N=4=96$ >@7$ ;5$ @7<5L8=;7DM$ ;5$ 9K>9$ 9K7@7$ =;$ >8

=8<@7>;7D$ 3@5N>N=4=96$ 5?$ ?A8D;$ N7=8L$ A;7D$ ?5@$ 9K7

N787?=9$5?$,52>$353A4>9=58;O$$$%K5A4D$>$3@535;>4$95

=8<4AD7$K5A;=8L$>8D$K7>49K$=8J7;92789;$=8$9K7$#,0+

N7$@7W7<97DM$9K7$+A8D$;K5A4D$7Q>2=87$27<K>8=;2;

IK7@7N6$ =9$ <>8$ <5C?=8>8<7$ <523472789>@6$ =8?@>C

;9@A<9A@7$;A<K$>;$><<7;;$@5>D;$>8D$I>97@$>8D$;7IC

7@>L7$ ;6;972;O$ $ &@@7;37<9=J7$ 5?$ 9K7$ 5A9<527$ 5?

D=;<A;;=58;$ 58$ 9K7$ ;<537$ 5?$ 9K7$ #,0+M$ >99789=58

877D;$95$N7$L=J78$95$9K7$7Q3>8;=58$5?$9K7$0/$1ANC

4=<$"7>49K$B522A8=96$(<9=58$1@5L@>227M$>8D$95$9K7

K7>49K$ 3@5N472;$ 5?$ 2>@L=8>4=;7D$ <522A8=9=7;M

=8<4AD=8L$,52>8=$<522A8=9=7;O

5," ,7;37<9=8L$ 9K7$ 4=2=9;$ 5?$ ;AN;=D=>@=96M$ 9K7

#A@537>8$ '8=58$ ;K5A4D$ 7Q345@7$ I>6;$ =8$ IK=<K

'8=58$ 7DA<>9=58$ 354=<=7;$ >8D$ 3@5L@>22=8L$ <>8

>DD@7;;$9K7$J7@6$;7@=5A;$3@5N472$5?$@><=>4$;7L@7L>C

9=58$ =8$7DA<>9=58$>8D$ 9K7$I=D7;3@7>D$A87TA>4$>8D

=8>D7TA>97$ 47J74$ 5?$ 3@5J=;=58$ ?5@$ ,52>M$ /63;=7;

>8De5@$!@>J7447@;O

5-" #Q37@=78<7$ ?@52$ 1K>@7$ 3@5L@>227;$ ;ALC

L7;9;$9K>9$=8$5@D7@$95$K>J7$>$;A;9>=8>N47$=23><9M$=9$=;

=235@9>89$9K>9$3@5W7<9;$?=8>8<7D$=8$9K7$>@7>$5?$;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58$ >@7$ 859$ ;9>8DC>4587$ =8=9=>9=J7;$I5@P=8L$ =8

=;54>9=58$?@52$9K7$354=<6$78J=@582789M$NA9$@73@7;789

9K7$537@>9=58>4=;>9=58$5?$354=<6O$&8$9K7$<5897Q9$5?$9K7

D7<789@>4=;7D$#%+$c=8<4AD=8L$#s'(.dM$#,0+$>8D$9K7

0=@7<95@>97$/787@>4$5?$1AN4=<$"7>49K$3@5L@>227;M$=9

=;$9K7@7?5@7$7;;789=>4$9K>9$#'$>8D$8>9=58>4$>8D$45<>4

L5J7@82789;$I5@P$95L79K7@$N59K$95$78;A@7$3@5W7<9

9>@L79=8L$>8D$;A;9>=8>N=4=96M$>8D$>4;5$9K7$<5447<9=58

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 55: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

>8D$ D=;;72=8>9=58$ 5?$ @7;A49;$ >8D$ 7Q37@=78<7;$ =8

5@D7@$95$N7$>N47$95$=8?5@2$354=<6$>9$>44$47J74;O$154=<6

D=>45LA7$;K5A4D$9K7@7?5@7$N7$=897L@>97D$>8D$=8<4ADC

7D$=8$9K7$3@5L@>227;$>;$?>@$>;$35;;=N47M$95$78;A@7

9K7$J=;=N=4=96$>8D$3@><9=<>4$=23><9$5?$354=<=7;O$$%37<=?C

=<>446M$ 3@5L@>227$LA=D74=87;$ ;K5A4D$ @7<5L8=;7$ 9K7

2>@L=8>4=;>9=58$5?$,52>8=$353A4>9=58;$>8D$78<5A@C

>L7$ 9K7$ =8<4A;=58$ 5?$ ,52>8=$ <522A8=9=7;$ =8$ ;A<K

3@5L@>227;M$ 859$ 87L47<9=8L$ 9K7$ 877D$ 95$ =8<4AD7

,52>$ =8$ 9K7$ D7;=L8M$ =23472789>9=58$ >8D$ >;;7;;C

2789$5?$;A<K$3@5W7<9;$>8D$354=<=7;O

54"#&J>IKL#CHIXFGE?HCIXW" !K7$97@2$a2>=8;9@7>2C

=8La$K>;$N778$?@7TA78946$2=;A8D7@;955D$>;$>J5=D=8L

;37<=?=<>446$ 9>@L797D$ L@5A3;O$ sA=97$ 9K7$ <589@>@6M

a2>=8;9@7>2=8La$ =8J54J7;$ 78;A@=8L$ 9K>9$ >44$ 354=<=7;

>@7$ 3@55?7D$ =8$ >DJ>8<7$ >8D$ @7LA4>@46$ >;;7;;7D$ =8

3@5L@7;;$ 95$ 78;A@7$ 9K>9$ 9K7=@$ =23><9;$ @7><K$ =D789=C

?=7DM$ 2>@L=8>4=;7D$ L@5A3;$ 95$ >$ 47J74$ >D7TA>97$ 95

877DO$!K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$<>8$>8D$;K5A4D$I5@P$95

?5;97@$354=<6$>33@5><K7;$>9$9K7$'8=58$47J74M$>;$I744

>;$ >9$ 9K7$ 47J74$ 5?$ 9K7$ -72N7@$ %9>97;$ >8D$ 9K7=@

@7L=58;M$78;A@=8L$9K>9$354=<=7;$@7><K$,52>$>8D$59K7@

37@;58;$ @7L>@D7D$>;$ a/63;=7;aORFE (;$B522=;;=587@

?5@$ #234562789$ >8D$ %5<=>4$ (??>=@;$ (88>$ 0=>2>8C

953545A$;9>97D$>9$9K7$UAD>37;9$B58?7@78<7$58$,52>

=8$FGGEM$ aS7$I=44$ 5846$ ;A<<77D$IK78$,52>$ =;;A7;

>@7$N7=8L$9@7>97DM$859$WA;9$I=9K$;37<=?=<$3@5L@>227;

>8D$><9=58;$C$=235@9>89$>;$9K76$>@7$C$NA9$>4;5$>;$3>@9

5?$9K7$?@>27I5@P$5?$#A@537>8$>8D$8>9=58>4$354=<=7;Oa

!K7$ #'$ ;K5A4D$ 78;A@7$ 9K>9$ >44$ 354=<6$ ;9>P7K54D7@;

A8D7@;9>8D$9K7$<58<739$5?$a2>=8;9@7>2=8La$>8D$><9

>D7TA>97$95$9K7$47J74$5?$877D$95$78;A@7$9K>9$>44$354=C

<=7;$=8<4AD7$,52>$2>=8;9@7>2=8L$<52358789;O$

;6"#%JXIGJEIXW#HXY#?@H>SHGIJX"# !K7@7$=;$>$3@7;;C

=8L$877D$95$7J>4A>97$9K7$=23><9$5?$#'$>8D$8>9=58>4

3@5W7<9;$ >8D$ 3@5L@>227;$ 9>@L79=8L$ ,52>O$ %=8<7

IK>9$ 2>997@;$ =;$ <K>8L7$ 58$ 9K7$ L@5A8DM$ 9K7$ @7>4

=23><9$5?$<K>8L7;$=8$>99=9AD7;M$><9=58;$>8D$354=<=7;

877D;$95$N7$>;;7;;7D$=8$>$I>6$9K>9$=;$N59K$<@7D=N47

>8D$A;7?A4$=8$97@2;$5?$=8?5@2=8L$?A@9K7@$354=<6$D7J74C

532789;O$ )846$ >$ ?7I$ #'$ >8D$ 8>9=58>4$ ,52>$ 3@5C

L@>227;$ K>J7$25J7D$ N7658D$ L787@>4$ >;3=@>9=58;

>8D$K>J7$;79$;37<=?=<$>8D$TA>89=?=7D$9>@L79;$95$3@5C

J=D7$>$N>;=;$ ?5@$258=95@=8L$3@5L@7;;O$-5@75J7@M$ =8

2>86$<>;7;M$9K7@7$=;$<58?A;=58$N79I778$258=95@=8L

>8D$7J>4A>9=58M$>8D$9K7$;<537$5?$9K7;7$><9=J=9=7;$=;

7=9K7@$859$D7?=87D$5@$=;$A8<47>@O$$,52>C@74>97D$354=C

<=7;$ >8D$ ;9@>97L=7;$ ;K5A4D$ K>J7$ >$ ;37<=>4$ <K>397@

IK=<K$;37<=?6$9K7$;<537$5?$258=95@=8LM$;A<K$>;o$

q %79$ <47>@$ N78<K2>@P;$ ><<5@D=8L$ 95$ IK=<K$ 95

7J>4A>97$;A<<7;;$5@$4><P$5?$;A<<7;;o

q (445<>97$ ?A8D=8L$ ?5@$ 258=95@=8L$ 3@5W7<9;$ N6

,52>8=$858CL5J7@82789>4$5@L>8=;>9=58;oRFH

q 1@5J=D7$ ;A335@9$ ?5@$ <>3><=96CNA=4D=8L$ 5?$ ,52>

5@L>8=;>9=58;M$;5$9K>9$9K76$I=44$N7$>N47$95$34>6$>8

><9=J7$ @547$ =8$258=95@=8L$ 9K7$ =23472789>9=58$5?

3@5W7<9;$D7;=L87D$95$N787?=9$9K72O

;5" !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$;K5A4D$<58;=D7@$D7J7453=8L

;9>8D>@D;$>8D$LA=D74=87;$><<5@D=8L$95$IK=<K$-72C

N7@$ %9>97;$ ;K5A4D$ >;;7;;$ 9K7$ =23><9$ 5?$ D@>?9$ >8D

7Q=;9=8L$354=<=7;$>8D$4>I;$58$D=;>DJ>89>L7D$L@5A3;M

=8$ 3>@9=<A4>@$ 79K8=<$ L@5A3;O$ %>?7LA>@D;$ ;K5A4D$ N7

=89@5DA<7D$95$78;A@7$9K>9$#'$?A8D=8L$=;$859$A;7D$95

@><=>446$;7L@7L>97$,52>O

;;" .SCHX# EIWQGF# CJXIGJEIXW" B522789=8L

@7<78946$58$ 9K7$;5C<>447D$ aU@5P$,735@9a$ ca,735@9$58

9K7$ <523@7K78;=J7$258=95@=8L$ @735@9$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@5C

37>8$B522=;;=58$58$9K7$;9>97$5?$3@73>@7D87;;$?5@

#'$ 272N7@;K=3$ 5?$ 9K7$ B_7<K$ ,73AN4=<M$ #;958=>M

B63@A;M$ .>9J=>M$ .=9KA>8=>M$ "A8L>@6M$ ->49>M$ 154>8DM

%45J78=>$>8D$%45J>P=>aRFYdM$9K7$#A@537>8$1>@4=>2789b;

B522=9977$58$B=9=_78;b$+@77D52;$>8D$,=LK9;M$gA;C

9=<7$>8D$"527$(??>=@;$;9>97D$9K>9$=9j$aU74=7J7;$9K>9$=8

5@D7@$ 95$ 9><P47$ 9K7$ D7?=<=9$ =8$ WA;9=<7M$ ?@77D52$ >8D

;7<A@=96M$OOO>$<A49A@7$>8D$3@5<7;;$5?$377@$@7J=7I$>8D

2A9A>4$ ;A@J7=44>8<7$ 78<523>;;=8L$ >44$ FY$-72N7@

%9>97;M$=8$IK=<K$9K7$#A@537>8$B522=;;=58$>8D$9K7

#A@537>8$B5A@9$5?$gA;9=<7M$N><P7D$A3$N6$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$ 1>@4=>2789$ >8D$ 9K7$ B5A8<=4M$ I5A4D$ 34>6$ P76

@547;M${=;$@7TA=@7D|a$>8D$a&D789=?=7;$>$877D$95$D7J7453

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

RFE +5@$7Q978;=J7$D=;<A;;=58$5?$2>=8;9@7>2=8LM$;77$a->=8;9@7>2=8L$#TA>4=96$=8$#A@537>8$'8=58$.>I$>8D$154=<6C->P=8LaM$>$@735@9

3@73>@7D$?5@$9K7$#A@537>8$*79I5@P$(L>=8;9$,><=;2$c#*(,d$N6$g5$%K>IM$1@5?7;;5@$5?$#A@537>8$.>IM$'8=J7@;=96$5?$->8<K7;97@

>8D$%78=5@$,7;7>@<K$+7445I$>9$9K7$+7D7@>4$!@A;9M$->@<K$FGGHM$#A@537>8$*79I5@P$(L>=8;9$,><=;2M$gA46$FGGHO

RFH !5$N7$7??7<9=J7M$258=95@=8L$;K5A4D$N7$>;$2A<K$>N5A9$9K7$)/;$*.. 5?$3@73>@=8LM$3@7;789=8L$>8D$A;=8L$>$@735@9$>;$>N5A9$9K7

@735@9$=9;74?O$1@73>@=8L$>8$7??7<9=J7$@735@9$@7TA=@7;$@735@97@;$95$9K=8P$<@=9=<>446M$95$=8J54J7$>8D$95$D@>I$9K7=@$ =8?5@2>9=58$?@52

<522A8=9=7;$>??7<97D$N6$9K7$3@5N472;$N7=8L$258=95@7DM$>8D$95$?5@2A4>97$9K7=@$<@=9=TA7$=8$>$@7>;587D$>8D$37@;A>;=J7$2>887@O

(8D$ 9KA;$ =9$ =;$ 45L=<>4$ 9K>9$ ,52>$ ;K5A4D$ 9>P7$ >$ 47>D=8L$ @547$ =8$ >@9=<A4>9=8L$ >8D$ 9@>8;2=99=8L$ <@=9=TA7;$ 5?$ 9K7$ 3@5L@>227;

D7;=L87D$?5@$9K7=@$N787?=9O

RFY cB)-cFGGEd$Z^Y$C$BY$C$GYEFeFGGE$C$FFGReFGGEc&*&dd

Page 56: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

<523@7K78;=J7$ >8D$A8>2N=LA5A;$#'$ WA;9=<7$ ;9>8C

D>@D;$ I=9K=8$ 9K7$ #'M$ 95L79K7@$ I=9K$ ;6;972>9=<

;<@A9=86$ >8D$ 78?5@<72789$ 27<K>8=;2;$ 95$ 78;A@7

9K7=@$5N;7@J>8<7${OOO|oa

;=" !K7$B522=9977$I789$58$95$;9>97$9K>9$=9M$a%A3C

35@9;$9K7$L5J7@82789;$5?$>44$<5A89@=7;$<58<7@87D$=8

9K7=@$7??5@9;$95$<589=8A7$>$458LC4>;9=8L$>8D$=8978;=J7

354=<6$>DD@7;;=8L$9K7$3@5N472;$5?$2=85@=9=7;$c7;37C

<=>446$ 9K7$ ,52>dM$ >=2=8L$ >9$ 9K7=@$ ;5<=>4$ =897L@>9=58

9K@5ALK$ ><<7;;$ 95$ 7DA<>9=58M$ 7234562789$ >8D

K5A;=8La$ >8D$ a=8;=;9;$ 9K>9$ >44$ 87I$-72N7@$ %9>97;

;K5A4D$ 9>P7$ <>@7$ 9K>9$ 9K7$ #'b;$ >89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58

><TA=;$=;$?A446$9@>8;35;7D$>8D$=234727897D$=8$9K7=@

47L=;4>9=58aO$!K7;7$@7<52278D>9=58;$K>J7$679$95$N7

?A446$ ><97D$ A358O$ !K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ ;K5A4D

7Q345@7$7Q3>8D=8L$9K7$35I7@;$5?$587$5@$25@7$N5DC

=7;$ =8$ 5@D7@$ 95$ 78;A@7$ 7??7<9=J7$ <5234=>8<7$ I=9K

<52258$KA2>8$@=LK9;$;9>8D>@D;O$

;A"# $/# ^IXHXK?# HXY# KI@I># FJKI?GL# ?>IWIDI>IGL" !K7

A;7$5?$;9@A<9A@>4$?A8D;$=8$87I$-72N7@$%9>97;$=;$>

@74>9=J746$ @7<789$ 3K78527858$ >8D$ =9$ >337>@;$ 9K>9

9K7;7$>@7$859$679$N7=8L$?A446$;3789$DA7$95$9K7$?>=4A@7

5?$ L5J7@82789;$ 95$ 3@5J=D7$ >D7TA>97$ 47J74;$ 5?

2>9<K=8L$ ?A8D=8LO$ $ SK=4;9$ 9K=;$ ;=9A>9=58$ 2>6$ I744

=23@5J7$=8$9K7$?A9A@7M$9K7@7$=;$87J7@9K747;;$>$3@7;;C

=8L$877D$95j

q ->P7$I=D746$>J>=4>N47$=8$><<7;;=N47$4>8LA>L7$95

<=J=4$ ;5<=796M$ 9K7$27D=>$ >8D$ 59K7@$ ;9>P7K54D7@;

=8?5@2>9=58$>N5A9$;9@A<9A@>4$?A8D=8LM$IK6$=9$=;$5?

@747J>8<7$95$,52>M$>8D$K5I$=9$<>8$N7$><<7;;7Do

q +5;97@$3@5W7<9;$9K>9$I=44$?><=4=9>97$L@7>97@$=83A9$>9

9K7$D527;9=<$47J74$5?$<=J=4$;5<=796$>8D$59K7@$858C

L5J7@82789>4$;9>P7K54D7@;$=8$9K7$D7;=L8$5?$3@5WC

7<9;$;77P=8L$;9@A<9A@>4$?A8D=8LO

;B" %527$#'$?A8D=8L$95I>@D$<=J=4$;5<=796$=;$7Q<4AC

;=J746$ @7;7@J7D$ ?5@$ =897@8>9=58>4$ aA2N@744>$ 5?

A2N@744>a$5@L>8=;>9=58;M$;A<K$>;$9K7$#A@537>8$*79C

I5@P$(L>=8;9$,><=;2$c#*(,dM$9K7$(89=C15J7@96$*79C

I5@PM$ %5<=>4$ 14>9?5@2M$ 79<O$ S=9K5A9$ 3@7WAD=<7$ 95

9K7;7$5@L>8=;>9=58;M$=9$2>6$2>P7$;78;7$95$?5;97@$>

,52>C;37<=?=<$aA2N@744>$5?$A2N@744>;a$5@L>8=;>9=58O

"5I7J7@M$ >86$27>;A@7$ 95$2>P7$#'$ ?A8D=8L$25@7

><<7;;=N47$ 95$ L@>;;@559;$ 5@L>8=;>9=58;$ I5A4D$ N7

=235@9>89M$ >8D$ 3@=5@$ 95$ 9K7$ 7;9>N4=;K2789$ 5?$ >

,52>C;37<=?=<$ aA2N@744>$ 5?$ A2N@744>;a$ 59K7@$25DC

74;$ >=27D$ >9$ ,52>8=$ <=J=4$ ;5<=796$ =8<4A;=58$ =8$ #'

354=<6$3@5<7;;7;M$;A<K$>;$;A335@9$?5@$;2>447@M$25@7

45<>4=;7D$ 879I5@P;M$ ;K5A4D$ N7$ ;9AD=7D$ <>@7?A446O

'49=2>9746M$ >$ <52N=8>9=58$ 5?$ >33@5><K7;$ 2>6$ N7

I5@9K$<58;=D7@=8LO

;!"#$_G?EXH># E?>HGIJXF" !K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$ =;$>

2>W5@$><95@$=8$9K7$D7J74532789$>8D$9K7$3@5259=58

5?$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ N7658D$ 9K7$ N5@D7@;$ 5?$ 9K7$ #A@5C

37>8$'8=58O$&8$9K7$#A@537>8$'8=58$B>8D=D>97$B5A8C

9@=7;M$ 9K7$S7;97@8$U>4P>8;M$>8D$ =8$9K7$<5A89@=7;$5?

9K7$ ?5@27@$ %5J=79$ '8=58M$ 9K7$ #'$ <>8$ >8D$ ;K5A4D

7Q34=<=946$9>@L79$,52>$>;$>$<52358789$5?$=9;$D7J74C

532789$ >8D$ KA2>8$ @=LK9;$ I5@PO$ +5@$ B>8D=D>97

B5A89@=7;$ 95$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58M$ 9K7$ ;=9A>9=58$ 5?

,52>$;K5A4D$N7$>$P76$<52358789$?5@$>;;7;;=8L$9K7

@7>D=87;;$ 5?$ >86$ L=J78$ <>8D=D>97$ <5A89@6O$ ,52>

@=LK9;$;K5A4D$<58;9=9A97$>$;37<=?=<$7J>4A>9=58$<K>3C

97@$5?$@7LA4>@$@735@9;$95I>@D$><<7;;=58O$ $ &8=9=>9=J7;

;A<K$ >;$ 9K7$ 07<>D7$ 5?$ ,52>$ &8<4A;=58$ 5??7@$ 9K7

359789=>4$95$K>J7$;=L8=?=<>89$ =23><9$ =8$>$8A2N7@$5?

<5A89@=7;o$ 9K7$#'$;K5A4D$34>6$>8$><9=J7$ @547$ =8$ 9K7

07<>D7$>8D$;=2=4>@$=8=9=>9=J7;O

%$%V$9#0+7+$:'$\$'#9$8(%%$*<7+1(*0

;,"# %IXJEIGL# EIWQGF# REJG?KGIJX# HXY# E?KJWXIGIJX"

!K5;7$-72N7@$%9>97;$9K>9$K>J7$859$>4@7>D6$D587$;5

;K5A4D$ @7<5L8=;7$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$>;

>8$ 79K8=<$2=85@=96M$ >8D$ ;K5A4D$I>=J7$ >86$ >@N=9@>@6

<@=97@=>$7Q<4AD=8L$;7L2789;$5?$ 9K7$2=85@=96$ ?5@$ 9K7

3A@35;7;$5?$@7<5L8=9=58O$$#'$-72N7@$%9>97;$;K5A4D

>4;5$@>9=?6$I=9K5A9$D74>6$9K7$+@>27I5@P$B58J789=58

?5@$ 9K7$ 1@597<9=58$ 5?$ *>9=58>4$ -=85@=9=7;$ >8D$ 9K7

BK>@97@$ 58$ ,7L=58>4$ >8D$-=85@=96$ .>8LA>L7;M$ 9I5

;9>8D>@DC;799=8L$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537$=8;9@A2789;O

;-" 7XGI:YIFKEICIXHGIJX# >H "̀ &8$ 9K7$ @74>9=J746

;9@>=LK9?5@I>@D$>@7>$5?$9@>8;35;=9=58$5?$9K7$#'$>89=C

D=;<@=2=8>9=58$D=@7<9=J7;M$ 859$ 5846$ K>J7$2>86$87I

-72N7@$ %9>97;$ 2=;;7D$ D7>D4=87;$ ?5@$ 9@>8;35;=8L

9K7$#'$>89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$2%F+$' =895$D527;9=<$4>IMNA9$2>86$54D$>8D$87I$-72N7@$%9>97;$K>J7M$>;$5?

gA46$FGGHM$ ?>=47D$ 95$ 9@>8;35;7$>44$3@5J=;=58;$5?$ 9K7

D=@7<9=J7;M$>8D$;527$K>J7$859$9@>8;35;7D$>86O$!K=;

;7@=5A;$3@5N472$2A;9$N7$;I=?946$@727D=7DO

;4" (44$-72N7@$%9>97;$;K5A4D$9@>8;35;7$>44$3@5C

J=;=58;$ 5?$ 9K7$ #'$ >89=CD=;<@=2=8>9=58$ D=@7<9=J7;$ >;

TA=<P46$>;$35;;=N47O$&8$9@>8;35;=8L$#'$>89=CD=;<@=2=C

8>9=58$D=@7<9=J7;$=895$D527;9=<$4>IM$-72N7@$%9>97;

;K5A4D$3@5J=D7$;9@58LM$=8D7378D789$>8D$>D7TA>9746

?A8D7D$ 78?5@<72789$ N5D=7;$ =8$ 4=87$I=9K$ 9K7$ 3@5J=C

;=58;$5?$0=@7<9=J7$HEeFGGG$>8D$I=9K$9K7$@7<52278C

D>9=58;$ 5?$ 9K7$ B5A8<=4$ 5?$ #A@537b;$ #A@537>8

B522=;;=58$(L>=8;9$,><=;2$>8D$&89547@>8<7O$-72C

N7@$%9>97;$;K5A4D$>4;5$@>9=?6$1@595<54$RF$95$9K7$#A@5C

37>8$ B58J789=58$ 58$ "A2>8$ ,=LK9;M$ >8D$ ;K5A4D

A8D7@9>P7$<523@7K78;=J7$@7J=7I;$95$78;A@7$9K>9$85

!"

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 57: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

4>I;$5@$@7LA4>9=58;$=8$7??7<9$>9$8>9=58>4M$@7L=58>4$5@

45<>4$47J74$K>J7$=8D=@7<946$D=;<@=2=8>95@6$=23><9;$58

,52>M$/63;=7;$>8De5@$!@>J7447@;O

=6" 9JCH#HW?XKI?FaWJ@?EXC?XG#FGESKGSE?F"#/5J7@8C

2789;$;K5A4D$78;A@7$9K>9$>44$>D2=8=;9@>9=J7$>L78<=7;$C

=8<4AD=8L$-=8=;9@=7;$ >8D$ 59K7@$ 8>9=58>4C$ >8D$ <5A896C

47J74$ =8;9=9A9=58;$>;$I744$ >;$ 45<>4$ >A9K5@=9=7;M$ =8<4AD7

N5D=7;$ <K>@L7D$I=9K$ 78;A@=8L$,52>$ =8<4A;=58O$/5JC

7@82789;$ ;K5A4D$ <58;=D7@$ ;7@=5A;46$ 9K7$ 7;9>N4=;KC

2789$5?$L5J7@82789>4$,52>$(L78<=7;$<K>@L7D$I=9K

78;A@=8L$9K7$7??7<9=J7$=23472789>9=58$5?$;5<=>4$=8<4AC

;=58$354=<=7;$9>@L79=8L$,52>O$(9$2=8=2A2M$2=8=;97@=>4

N5D=7;$A8D7@$9K7$D=@7<9$;A37@J=;=58$5?$1@=27$-=8=;97@;

;K5A4D$N7$@7;358;=N47$?5@$;977@=8L$354=<=7;$>8D$=8=9=>C

9=J7;$5?$J>@=5A;$@747J>89$D73>@92789;O

=5" $GQXIK# <HGH# 8J>>?KGIJX" -72N7@$ %9>97;

;K5A4D$ D7J7453$ 97@9=>@6$ =8D=<>95@;$ 95$ @7L=;97@$ >8D

>;;7;;$9K7$=23><9$5?$@><=>4$D=;<@=2=8>9=58$>8D$59K7@

7Q<4A;=58>@6$ ?5@<7;$ 58$ 3>@9=<A4>@$ 79K8=<$ L@5A3;O

,7;37<9=8L$>44$@747J>89$D>9>$3@597<9=58$4>I;M$-72C

N7@$%9>97;$;K5A4D$L>9K7@$>8D$2>P7$3AN4=<$=8$>$@7>DC

=46$ <523@7K78;=N47$ ?5@2$ ;9>9=;9=<>4$ D>9>$ 58$ 9K7

;=9A>9=58$5?$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8D$!@>J7447@;$>8D$59K7@

I7>P$ L@5A3;$ =8$ ?=74D;$ @747J>89$ 95$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58

354=<6M$=8<4AD=8L$NA9$859$87<7;;>@=46$4=2=97D$95$7DAC

<>9=58M$7234562789M$K7>49K<>@7$>8D$K5A;=8LO

=;" 0JKIH># IXK>SFIJX" ,52>$ c=8<4AD=8L$ !@>J7447@;

>8D$59K7@$L@5A3;$@7L>@D7D$>;$a/63;=7;ad$;K5A4D$N7$>

<47>@46$ 8>27D$3@=5@=96$ L@5A3$I=9K$ >$ ;37<=?=<$ >445<>C

9=58$5?$>88A>4$?A8D=8LM$I=9K=8$9K7$5J7@>44$;5<=>4$=8<4AC

;=58$ 354=<6$ 5?$ 7><K$ -72N7@$ %9>97O$ /5J7@82789;

2A;9$47>D$=8$78;A@=8L$9K>9$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58$>8D$=897C

L@>9=58$354=<=7;$?5@$,52>$>@7$9@>8;4>97D$=895$3@><9=<7O$$

==" *>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8;$;K5A4D$=8<4AD7$;37<=?=<

27>;A@7;$58$,52>M$/63;=7;$>8De5@$!@>J7447@;$A8D7@

>44$@747J>89$;7<95@>4$?=74D$K7>D=8L;M$=8<4AD=8L$NA9$859

4=2=97D$ 95$ 7DA<>9=58M$ 7234562789M$ K7>49K$ <>@7M

K5A;=8L$>8D$;5<=>4$;7@J=<7;$>8D$>;;=;9>8<7O$ &8$ 9K7

87Q9$@5A8D$5?$*>9=58>4$(<9=58$14>8;$95$<52N>9$;5<=>4

7Q<4A;=58M$>44$-72N7@$%9>97;$;K5A4D$<58;=D7@$8>2C

=8L$ ,52>$ c=8<4AD=8L$ /63;=7;M$ !@>J7447@;$ >8D$ 59K7@

L@5A3;d$>;$>$9>@L79$L@5A3$5?$D527;9=<$;5<=>4$ =8<4AC

;=58$354=<6O$

=A" /5J7@82789;$ ;K5A4D$ 25J7$ >I>6$ ?@52$ 9>@C

L79=8L$ ,52>$ 9K@5ALK$ >$ ?@>L27897D$ >8D$ D=;3>@>97

<5447<9=58$5?$=8D=J=DA>4$3@5W7<9;M$4><P=8L$;A;9>=8>N47

=23><9M$>8D$>D539$>8$>33@5><K$IK7@7N6$9K7$;5<=>4

=8<4A;=58$5?$,52>$=;$>$2>=8;9@7>2$5NW7<9=J7$I=9K=8

7Q=;9=8L$354=<=7;O

=B" -72N7@$%9>97;$;K5A4D$;=L8$>8D$@>9=?6$>44$>@9=C

<47;$5?$9K7$,7J=;7D$#A@537>8$%5<=>4$BK>@97@M$=8<4ADC

=8L$9K7$3@5J=;=58;$@74>97D$95$>$<5447<9=J7$<5234>=89;

27<K>8=;2M$ >8D$ 9K7$ #A@537>8$ '8=58$ ;K5A4D

78<5A@>L7$-72N7@$%9>97;$=8$9K=;$D=@7<9=58O

=!" (;$>$P76$27>;A@7$?5@$78;A@=8L$9K7$7??7<9=J7

@7>4=;>9=58$5?$ ;5<=>4$ >8D$7<5852=<$ @=LK9;$N6$,52>

>8D$59K7@;M$>44$#A@537>8$L5J7@82789;$;K5A4D$<K>2C

3=58$ 9K7$ >D539=58$ 5?$ >8$ )39=58>4$ 1@595<54$ 95$ 9K7

&897@8>9=58>4$B5J78>89$58$#<5852=<M$%5<=>4$>8D$BA4C

9A@>4$ ,=LK9;$ 95$ ?><=4=9>97$ =8D=J=DA>4$ >8D$ */)$ <52C

34>=89;$A8D7@$9K7$B5J78>89O

=," &J>IKL# KJQ?E?XK?" &8$ 4=LK9$ 5?$ 9K7$D79@=2789>4

=23><9$>$8A2N7@$5?$354=<6$>8D$4>I$<K>8L7;M$>;$I744

>;$ D7737@$ ;9@A<9A@>4$ <K>8L7;M$ K>J7$ K>D$ =8$ @7<789

67>@;$ 58$ 2>86$ ,52>M$ -72N7@$ %9>97$ L5J7@82789;

>@7$A@L7D$95$A8D7@9>P7$9K5@5ALKCL5=8L$>;;7;;2789;

5?$>44$354=<=7;$@74>97D$95$;5<=>4$=8<4A;=58M$95$D797@2=87j

c=d$IK79K7@$354=<=7;$>@7$;5<=>446$<5@@5;=J7$L787@>446$>8D

c==d$IK79K7@$87L>9=J7$=23><9;$>@7$N7=8L$N5@87$D=;3@5C

35@9=58>9746$N6$,52>O$&8$4=LK9$5?$9K7$=;;A7;$@>=;7D$=8

9K7$N5D6$5?$9K=;$@735@9M$9K7@7$>@7$<47>@46$>$8A2N7@$5?

>@7>;$=8$IK=<K$354=<6$>8D$4>I$>278D2789$>8D$@7?5@2

>@7$>DJ=;>N47$=8$9K7$J7@6$87>@$97@2O

=-" 9IWQGF# J^# CIWEHXGF"#-72N7@$ %9>97$ L5J7@8C

2789;$<>8$N7L=8$95$=23@5J7$9K7$;9>9A;$5?$2=L@>89;

N6$W5=8=8L$9I5$9@7>9=7;$=8$IK5;7$D7J74532789$9K76

><9=J746$3>@9=<=3>97Dj$!K7$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537b;$#A@5C

37>8$ B58J789=58$ 58$ 9K7$ .7L>4$ %9>9A;$ 5?$ -=L@>89

S5@P7@;$>8D$9K7$'8=97D$*>9=58;b$ &897@8>9=58>4$B58C

J789=58$ 58$ 9K7$ 1@597<9=58$ 5?$ 9K7$ ,=LK9;$ 5?$ (44

-=L@>89$S5@P7@;$>8D$-72N7@;$5?$9K7=@$+>2=4=7;O$&8

>DD=9=58M$ %9>97;$ ;K5A4D$ @7J=7I$7Q978;=J746$ 354=<=7;

=8J54J=8L$ N5@D7@$ <@5;;=8L$ >8D$59K7@$ =;;A7;$ @74>97D

95$ 9K7$ N5@D7@M$ =8D=J=DA>4$ 7;9>N4=;K2789$ >8D$ 7Q3A4C

;=58M$ 95$78;A@7$9K>9$ 9K76$<58?5@2$N@5>D46$ 95$#A@5C

37>8$ '8=58$ ;5<=>4$ =8<4A;=58$ L5>4;M$ >;$ I744$ >;$ 95

78;A@7$ 9K>9$ 9K76$>@7$859$ =8?7<97D$N6$D=@7<9$5@$ =8D=C

@7<9$ @><=>4$ D=;<@=2=8>9=58$ 5@$ >@7$ 59K7@I=;7$ =8$ J=54>C

9=58$5?$#A@537b;$<52258$KA2>8$@=LK9;$;9>8D>@D;O$

=4" 1XG?E:7W?XKL#8JJR?EHGIJX"#&8$9K7$?=74D$5?$,52>

=8<4A;=58M$-72N7@$%9>97$L5J7@82789;$2A;9$ 47>D$ =8

354=<6$ =23472789>9=58O$ "5I7J7@M$ 9K76$ ;K5A4D$ <5C

537@>97$25@7$<45;746$I=9K$=897@8>9=58>4$5@L>8=;>9=58;

>8D$<=J=4$;5<=796$34>67@;M$?5@2=8L$3>@987@;K=3;$IK=<K

>@7$D7D=<>97D$95$9K7$3@5259=58$5?$7??7<9=J7$<K>8L7O$

81\1'#0(81$+)#9$8(%%$*<7+1(*0

A6" ,52>$5@L>8=;>9=58;$>4;5$K>J7$>$ @547$ 95$34>6$ =8

>DJ>8<=8L$ 9K7=@$5I8$I74?>@7O$!K=;$ =;$<47>@46$ @7<5LC

8=;7D$=8$9K7$;AN2=;;=58$D>97D$9K7$F8D$gA87$5?$9K7

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 58: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

,52>$*79I5@P$95$9K7$,52>$0>=46$*7I;$<58<7@8=8L

9K7$ 5A9<527;$ 5?$ 9K7$ (3@=4$ FGGH$ B58?7@78<7$ 58

,52>$ =8$ >8$ #84>@L7D$ #'M$ K74D$ =8$ U@A;;74;O$SK=4;9

2>P=8L$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?$ @7<52278D>9=58;$ 95$ 59K7@

N5D=7;M$ 9K7$ *79I5@P$ 8597;$ 9K>9$ a,52>$2A;9$ <58C

9@=NA97$95$9K7$@725J>4$5?$3@7WAD=<7;$>8D$;97@759637;

9K@5ALK$><9=J7$3>@9=<=3>9=58$>8D$<=J=4$ @=LK9;$I5@P$ =8

9K7$;5<=79=7;$=8$IK=<K$9K76$4=J7aO$$!K76$>4;5$8597$9K>9

a,52>$2A;9$@7<5L8=;7$9K>9$859$5846$9K7$2>W5@=96$NA9

9K76$955$>@7$@7;358;=N47$?5@$9K7=@$?A9A@7M$IK=<K$9K76

<>8$>8D$K>J7$95$=8?4A78<7aO$

A5" ,52>$ >@7$ >N47$ 95$ D5$ 9K=;$ =8$ >$ 8A2N7@$ 5?

I>6;O$ !K76$2=LK9$ 3>@9=<=3>97$ =8$ ;=8L47C=;;A7$ 45NN6

L@5A3;M$;A<K$>;$ 9K5;7$3@7;;=8L$ ?5@$ =8<@7>;7D$L78C

D7@$7TA>4=96M$=8$5@D7@$95$35=89$5A9$9K7$D=;<@=2=8>95@6

9@7>92789$@7<7=J7D$N6$,52>$IK=<K$=8$;527$<>;7;M

;A<K$ >;$ 9K>9$ 5?$ ,52>$I5278M$ <58;9=9A97;$ D5AN47

D=;<@=2=8>9=58O$ $ (44$ 955$ 5?978M$ ;A<K$ L@5A3;$ >@7

A8>I>@7$5?$ 9K7$7Q9@72746$2>@L=8>4=;7D$35;=9=58$5?

,52>M$/63;6$ >8D$!@>J7447@$ <522A8=9=7;M$ >8D$2>6

N7$ 3@73>@7D$ 95$ =8<5@35@>97$ 9K7$ ,52>$ <>;7$I=9K=8

9K7=@$45NN6$7??5@9;M$95$2A9A>4$>DJ>89>L7O

A;" ,52>M$ /63;6$ >8D$ !@>J7447@$ 47>D7@;$ 2=LK9

>4;5$3A@;A7M$>;$?>@$>;$=;$35;;=N47M$27>8;$5?$<58;54C

=D>9=8L$ 9K7$D=??7@=8L$ J=7I;$5?$,52>$L@5A3;$ =895$ >

;=8L47M$2>W5@=96$J5=<7M$95$N7$2>D7$P85I8$95$=897@8>C

9=58>4$>8D$8>9=58>4$354=<6C2>P7@;M$IK=4;9$859=8L$9K7

7Q=;978<7$5?$D=;;789=8L$J=7I;O$ $ &9$2>6$N7$ 9K>9$ 9K7

#A@537>8$ ,52>$ +5@A2M$ 7;9>N4=;K7D$ =8$ FGGHM$ <>8

?A4?=4$;A<K$>$@547O$$U59K$=897@L5J7@82789>4$5@L>8=;>C

9=58;$ >8D$ 858C,52>$ */);$ 877D$ 95$ =8978;=?6$ 9K7

?5<A;$58$,52>$ <522A8=9=7;$ =8$ #A@537$ 95$ 78;A@7

9K>9$ ><9=58;$ >8D$ ?A8D=8L$ 3@5L@>227;$ >@7$ I744

=8?5@27DM$>33@53@=>97$95$9K7$877D;$>8D$=8<@7>;=8LC

46$I744$879I5@P7D$95$>J5=D$DA34=<>9=58$>8D$<4>;K7;

5?$=897@7;9O$

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 59: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

(<958M$!K52>;$>8D$/>@6$-A8D6M$7D;OM$,;0&+("E71'7/*"&+2

X8).8"!2*+'('8M$">9?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M

Rhh^O

U>PP7@M$1797@$>8D$`6A<KAP5JM$"@=;95$c7DdM$V%&'"(."'%*",;0&+(

1&+37&3*Z ">9?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M$&897@C

?><7$B5447<9=58M$FGGGO

B>K8M$B4>AD7M$,;0&",(3%'.W",&$*J"[7.'($*"&+2"='/&'*3(*."<;/

?\7&1('8M$*7I$i5@Pj$&0#($1@7;;M$FGGFO

#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@M$E&0)1&+2W",&$(&1"=*3/*3&A

'(;+";<",;0&"(+"!'&18M$UAD>37;9M$FGGGO

#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@M$='&'*";<"!0)7+('8W"G70&+

,(3%'."HO7.*";<",0&"(+",;0&+(&M$UAD>37;9M$FGGRO

#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@M$='(30&'&W"=*3/*3&'*2"=$%;;1A

(+3";<",;0&"(+"E*+'/&1"&+2"?&.'*/+"?7/;)*M$UAD>37;9M$FGGHO

#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@M$#%*"T;+AE;+.'('7*+'.W",(3%'.

I*)/(-&'(;+";<",;0&"(+"D;.'AX*+;$(2*"B;.+(&"&+2"G*/:*3;-A

(+&M$UAD>37;9M$FGGHO

#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@M$#%*"](0('.";<"=;1(2&/('8W",;0&

(+"D;1&+2"H<'*/"N^_^M$UAD>37;9M$FGGFO

#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@M$H"=)*$(&1",*0*28W",;0&

&+2"=$%;;1."<;/"'%*"9*+'&118"G&+2($&))*2"(+"'%*"E:*$%

,*)7O1($M$UAD>37;9M$RhhhO

#A@537>8$,52>$,=LK9;$B7897@$>8D$/@77P$"74;=8P=$-58=95@M

E1*&+(+3"K)*/&'(;+.W"?@$172(+3",;0&"(+"X/**$*M$UAD>37;9

FGGEO

#A@537>8$-58=95@=8L$B789@7$58$,><=;2$>8D$n7853K5N=>M

B/*&C(+3"'%*"B&//(*/.W",;0&+("V;0*+"&+2"H$$*.."';"D7O1($

G*&1'%"E&/*M$V=788>M$FGGEO

#A@537>8$'8=58$(<<7;;=58$-58=95@=8L$1@5L@>2M$9;+(';/(+3

'%*"?`"H$$*..(;+"D/;$*..W"9(+;/('8"D/;'*$'(;+J"E&.*"='72(*.

(+"=*1*$'*2"9*0O*/"='&'*.M$)378$%5<=796$&8;9=9A97j

UAD>37;9$FGGFO

+@>;7@M$%=@$(8LA;M$#%*"X8).(*.M$)Q?5@DM$'`j$U4><PI744$1ANC

4=;K=8LM$RhhFO

/A6M$S=44M$7DO$B*'U**+"D&.'"&+2"a7'7/*W"#%*",;0&";<"E*+'/&1

&+2"?&.'*/+"?7/;)*M$">9?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$">@9?5@D;K=@7

1@7;;M$FGGRO

">8<5<PM$&>8M$V*"H/*"'%*",;0&+("D*;)1*M$B789@7$D7

,7<K7@<K7$!;=L>87;M$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M$&897@C

?><7$B5447<9=58M$FGGFO

"7=8;<K=8PM$-5_7;$+O$A8D$'@;A4>$"72797P$c"LOdM$,;0&5"2&.

7+O*C&++'*"b;1C5"=$%($C.&1"7+2"c71'7/5 S=78j$UkK4>A$V7@4>LM

RhhHO

&J>85J$(O$c7DdM$H-;(2(+3"'%*"I*)*+2*+$8"#/&)J"#%*",;0&"(+

E*+'/&1"&+2"?&.'*/+"?7/;)*J"H",*3(;+&1"G70&+"I*-*1;)A

0*+'",*);/'M$'8=97D$*>9=58;$07J74532789$1@5L@>227M

'*01$,7L=58>4$UA@7>AM$U@>9=;4>J>M$FGGFO

`78@=<PM$058>4D$>8D$/@>99>8$1AQ58M$X8).(*."7+2*/"'%*

=U&.'(C&M$"7@9?5@D;K=@7j$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M

&897@?><7$B5447<9=58M$RhhYO

`78@=<PM$058>4DM$G(.';/($&1"I($'(;+&/8";<"'%*"X8).(*."d,;0&A

+(*.eM$#A@537>8$"=;95@=<>4$0=<9=58>@=7;M$*5$F^M$.58D58j

%<>@7<@5I$1@7;;M$RhhfO

`78@=<PM$058>4D$c7DOdM$!+"'%*"=%&2;U";<"'%*"=U&.'(C&W"'%*

X8).(*."27/(+3"'%*"=*$;+2"V;/12"V&/M$"7@9?5@D;K=@7j$B5447<C

9=58$&897@?><7M$B789@7$D7;$,7<K7@<K7;$!;=L>87;M$'8=J7@;=96$5?

"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M$RhhhO

`7@97;=$/wN5@M$`v_D=$/wN5@M$H"$(3f+8"+g)*..g3"9&38&/;/.:fA

3;+5"2;C70*+'f$(4"g."&2&''f/O$UAD>37;9j$;5<=5C9635M$RhhfO

"!

^O$%#.#B!#0$U&U.&)/,(1"i

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 60: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

.><P5JwM$#478>M$!"#$%&'"()*+,(*+(-$%(*."*./$0(12+3%$0O

1@>K>j$*>P4>D>974;9J=$!@=>D>M$Rhh^M$3AN4=;K7D$=8$#8L4=;K$>;

4(5"'*+(6"7/8(9:(;&<+("*("(=:-*:(>$,"/(&/(?'$2"@&"M$">9C

?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M$&897@?><7$B5447<9=58M

RhhhO

.=vL75=;M$g7>8C1=7@@7M$A$,"B(=:-*&+*B(C#"2+''+#*B(?$D&$EF0'E

.0#"'(6"."B(?$D&$EG$'&.&D"'(6"."M$B5A8<=4$5?$#A@537M$RhhH$c?=@;9

7D=9=58$RhfYdO

.=vL75=;M$g7>8C1=7@@7M$?D1$$'(G#$2&*&$/(<$#(H.1/&D(9&/$#&.&+*8

C1+(=:-*:(G"#"%&I,O$">9?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7

1@7;;M$&897@?><7$B5447<9=58M$RhhfO

.=7L75=;M$g7>8C1=7@@7$>8D$*=<54>7$/K75@LK7O$A$,"J=:-*&+*8

4(H0#$-+"/(9&/$#&.:O$.58D58j$-=85@=96$,=LK9;$/@5A3M$RhhYO

.A<>;;78M$.75M$K&I+0/+#8(6&+(=+*D1&D1.+(+&/+*(-$'&3+&'&D1+/

L#%/0/I*M+I#&<<+*(&/(6+0.*D1'"/%(NOPPENQRSM$`k48j$UkK4>A

V7@4>LM$RhhZO

->@A;K=>P5J>M$#478>$>8D$1535JM$T+**+'&/UC1+(=:-*&+*(&/(.1+

L..$,"/(H,-&#+O$">9?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M

&897@?><7$B5447<9=58M$FGGRO

->9@>;M$i>@58M$A$,"/&8(4(;&/I0&*.&D(V/.#$%0D.&$/M$B>2N@=DL7j

B>2N@=DL7$'8=J7@;=96$1@7;;M$FGGFO

-=K5PM$U@=L=997O$K0#WD@(/"D1(!&#I+/%7$8(X$*/&*D1+(A$,"E

5'WD1.&/I+(&/(X+#'&/OU7@4=8j$-79@5354M$FGGRO

-5@@=;M$,><K74$>8D$.AP7$B472789;M$4.(>1".(F$*.8(C1+(HD$E

/$,&D*($<(=:-*:("/%(C#"2+''+#(H/D",-,+/.*M$U@=;954j$!K7

154=<6$1@7;;M$FGGFO

)@L>8=_>=;>9=58$?5@$%7<A@=96$>8D$B5C537@>9=58$=8$#A@537

c)%B#d$"=LK$B522=;;=587@$58$*>9=58>4$-=85@=9=7;M$A+-$#.

$/(.1+(?&.0".&$/($<(A$,"("/%(?&/.&(&/(.1+(L?FH(4#+"M$!K7

">LA7M$->@<K$FGGGO

,72274M$+@>8_M$6&+(A$,"(A0,Y/&+/*8(T$'@($1/+(Z&/.+#'"/%M

S=78j$1=<A;$V7@4>LM$RhhEO

,=8L54DM$078>M$-=9<K744$(O$)@78;97=8$>8D$#@=P>$>&'@+/BA$,"

&/("/(H[-"/%&/I(H0#$-+8(X#+"@&/I(.1+(G$2+#.:(F:D'+M$S5@4D

U>8PM$FGGEO

A$,"B(=:-*&+*8(C+[.*(V**0+%(M:(V/.+#/".&$/"'(V/*.&.0.&$/*M$">9C

?=74Dj$'8=J7@;=96$5?$"7@9?5@D;K=@7$1@7;;M$&897@?><7$B5447<9=58M

FGGRO

?"2+(.1+(F1&'%#+/B(6+/&+%("(50.0#+\(C1+(A&I1.(.$(H%0D".&$/

$<(A$,"J=:-*:("/%(C#"2+''+#(F1&'%#+/(&/(H0#$-+M$%>J7$9K7

BK=4D@78M$.58D58M$FGGRO

!7NNA99M$%A;>8M$7DOM$?&/.&("/%(A$,"8(=:-*&+*(&/(=+#,"/E?-+"@E

&/I(?$D&+.:("/%(;&.+#".0#+M$*7I$i5@Pj$U7@LK>K8$U55P;M$RhhfO

!58LM$0=>87M$7DOM$=:-*&+*8(4/(V/.+#%&*D&-'&/"#:(A+"%+#M$.58C

D58j$/>@4>8D$1AN4=;K=8LM$RhhfO

S=4472;M$S=2M$V/(?+"#D1($<(.1+(C#0+(=:-*:8(5#$,(H/'&I1.+/E

,+/.(.$(.1+(5&/"'(?$'0.&$/M$15@94>8DM$)@7L58j$+@>8P$B>;;$1ANC

4=;K7@;M$Rhh^O

}=227@2>88M$-=<K>74M$T+#<$'I.B(2+#.#&+M+/B(2+#/&D1.+.U(%&+

/".&$/"'*$D&"'&*.&*D1+(T+#/&D1.0/I*-$'&.&@(I+I+/(?&/.&(0/%

A$,"O$#;;78j$`4>@97Q9$V7@4>LM$RhfhO

}558M$&8>M$L/(.1+(9"#I&/*8(A$,"("/%(G0M'&D(?+#2&D+*(&/

A$,"/&"B(X0'I"#&"("/%(9"D+%$/&"M$*7I$i5@Pj$)378$%5<=796

&8;9=9A97M$FGGRO

"!

!K7$%=9A>9=58$5?$,52>$=8$>8$#84>@L7D$#A@537>8$'8=58

Page 61: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

+Q?#0IGSHGIJX#J^#9JCH#IX#HX#$X>HEW?Y#$SEJR?HX#/XIJX

.AQ72N5A@Lj$)??=<7$?5@$)??=<=>4$1AN4=<>9=58;$5?$9K7$#A@537>8$B522A8=9=7;

FGGHO$Yf$3>L7;O$FR$Q$FhO^$<2O

&%U*$hFCfhHCfRfZCF

"5I$D5$&$;79$>N5A9$5N9>=8=8L$>$3AN4=<>9=58~

)8<7$65A$K>J7$5N9>=87D$9K7$4=;9$5?$;>47;$>L789;M$<589><9$9K7$;>47;$>L789$5?$65A@$<K5=<7$>8D$34><7$65A@$5@D7@O

"5I$D5$&$5N9>=8$9K7$4=;9$5?$;>47;$>L789;~

q$ /5$95$9K7$1AN4=<>9=58;$)??=<7$I7N;=97$K993jee3AN4=<>9=58;O7AO=89e

q$ )@$>3346$?5@$>$3>37@$<536$N6$?>Q$cEYFd$FhFh$HF^Yf

Page 62: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union
Page 63: The Situation of Roma in an Enlarged European Union

KE

-62-0

4-3

89-E

N-C

04

05