Upload
others
View
4
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Signe Oksefjell Ebeling 30 October 2014
The secret life of words:
Implications for English language
teaching and learning?
What does hot mean?
She pours the hot water into the sink.
She pours the hot water into the sink.
The case became a hot potato for the government.
Ann bought the hot dog.
Phoebe offered Maggie a cup of hot chocolate.
I'd wear the hot pants -- without the flowers.
Hot off the press.
With the addition of plenty of hot English mustard.
It is a hot topic.
The gardener burst in with Mrs C. hot on his heels.
Nearly seventy acres of magnificent gardens and hot houses.
It was as if she had a hot line to the Devil.
He was a real hot shot.
I followed in hot pursuit.
The same word?
Is this English?
Dear Jonathan,
I hanker for this letter to be good. Like you know, I am not
first rate with English. In Russian my ideas are asserted
abnormally well, but my second tongue is not so premium. I
undertaked to input the things you counseled me to, and I
fatigued the thesaurus you presented me, as you counseled
me to, when my words appeared too petite, or not befitting.
If you are not happy with what I have performed, I command
you to return it back to me. I will persevere to toil on it until
you are appeased. (Alex Perchov in Everything is illuminated by Jonathan Safran Foer)
Dear Jonathan,
I hanker for this letter to be good. Like you know, I am not first
rate with English. In Russian my ideas are asserted abnormally
well, but my second tongue is not so premium. I undertaked to
input the things you counseled me to, and I fatigued the
thesaurus you presented me, as you counseled me to, when my
words appeared too petite, or not befitting. If you are not happy
with what I have performed, I command you to return it back to
me. I will persevere to toil on it until you are appeased.
want – as – very good at – expressed uncommonly – language –
perfect – implement (?) – advised – exhausted – gave – advised –
my vocabulary appeared too small or not appropriate – how I have
performed / what I have done – ask – continue to work – content
Outline
• Vocabulary and phraseology
– The chameleonic nature of words
– The puzzle of native-like selection
• Awareness and insight through exposure to
authentic English
– Corpora
– Corpus exercises
• Implications for English language teaching
and learning?
Vocabulary
• The stock of words in a language
– For language users it is important to know the
meaning of words
– However, this may not be enough:
You shall know a word by the company it keeps! (Firth, 1957:11)
The chameleonic nature of words
• Words that are synonymous in isolation are
not interchangeable in context.
• Synonyms: – Fierce, violent, ferocious
• Fierce + competition, fighting, opposition, eyes, attack
• Violent + crime, clashes, incidents, disorder, behaviour
• Ferocious + attack, attacks, war
Knowing a word thus includes knowing the expressions it
commonly occurs in as well as the meanings that a word
acquires by being associated with others. (Hasselgård, 2012)
Phraseology
• The stock of word combinations in a
language
• Linguistic knowledge encompasses:
– ‘memorized sentences’ (e.g. A friend in need is a friend
indeed)
– ‘lexicalized sentence stems’ (e.g. come to think of …, I
completely forget …)
– ‘phraseological expressions […] less than a
completely specified clause’ (e.g. sausage dog, keep an
eye on)
(Pawley and Syder 1983: 205)
Native-like selection
1. I think this is a very solid statement.
2. … the cosy time in front of the television set.
3. You certainly don't burn a big amount of calories by
doing that. From the Norwegian component of
the International Corpus of Learner English
[P]hraseology is one of the aspects that unmistakably
distinguishes native speakers of a language from L2
learners. (Granger & Bestgen 2014: 229)
How to raise awareness and gain
insight?
• Through exposure to authentic English
– Corpora
– Corpus exercises
Corpus: a body of texts
• representing authentic language use
• put together in a principled way
• computer-readable
• for use in linguistic research
Non-native selection
1. I think this is a very solid statement .
2. … the cosy time in front of the
television set.
3. You certainly don't burn a big amount
of calories by doing that.
The ADJ + NOUN collocations
are variable; the noun selects a
variety of adjectives, but not all!
Adj + statement
clear, full, explicit,
definitive, important,
original, factual, true,
strong cosy + noun
atmosphere, bar, chat,
corner, cottage,
relationship, room a/an ADJ amount
certain, considerable, small,
large, fair, enormous,
substantial, vast,
tremendous, significant,
limited, huge
Available corpora
• British National Corpus (BNC)
http://corpus.byu.edu/bnc/ – a 100-million-word collection of samples of written and spoken language
from a wide range of sources, designed to represent a wide cross-section of
British English from the later part of the 20th century.
• Corpus of Contemporary American English (COCA)
http://corpus.byu.edu/coca/ – the largest freely-available corpus of English and contains more than 450
million words of text, equally divided among spoken, fiction, popular
magazines, newspapers, and academic texts. It includes 20 million words
each year from 1990-2012 and the corpus is also updated regularly.
An example (from Crystal 2009)
I [David Crystal] had a monthly assignment to respond to English
language reader queries for a German teacher magazine, Praxis,
and that brought up [...] questions to do with vocabulary and idiom.
'Would you have marked it wrong?', the column was called. Here's
an example.
The candidate wrote, 'The hotel was fully unknown to me'; the
examiner corrected 'fully' to 'entirely'.
Would I have marked it wrong? Well … would you?
A gut reaction isn't enough. You have to be able to say why. Fully
does sound odd, in this context – but why?
Crystal continues…
You begin by exploring the meaning of the word: it
means 'to the full, completely' – that is, without
deficiency. So it tends to be used with words
expressing something positive … (Crystal 2009: 167)
Moving away from the gut reaction …
The question is…
How can this be implemented in a teaching
situation?
Using COCA
Task (1): Search for change and switch; which of the two
most commonly occurs in the corpus (give an example of
each when they function as verbs)?
Task (2): Which of the two can be found to collocate with
places?
Task (3): According to the corpus results you can use both
change and switch FROM something, but can you both
change and switch BETWEEN something? (Supply your
answer with examples.)
Using COCA (on paper)
Task (1): Search for remember *ing and remember to in
the corpus and give an example of each.
Task (2): Use the search results of the previous question
and give an example of remember NOT followed by a verb.
Task (3): Use the search results of Task (1). Explain the
difference in meaning between remember followed by a
verb ending in -ing and remember followed by the to-
infinitive.
Suggested answer to task 3
When remember is followed by a verb ending in -ing you have a memory of
having done something, i.e. you remember doing something after you have
done it, e.g. I remember asking if it was okay... could be paraphrased as: 'I
have a memory of asking you something', or 'I asked you something and
now I remember doing so'.
When remember is followed by the to-infinitive you remember to do
something before you do it, e.g. Will you remember to give them that
message? can be paraphrased as: Will you remember that you have to give
them the message so that you can do it?
The main difference between the two can be said to be that remember
followed by a verb ending in -ing looks backward in time, while remember
followed by the to-infinitive looks forward in time.
Using COCA (on paper) #2
Task (1): Search for remind * about and remind * of in the corpus,
and give an example of each.
Task (2): How do the two expressions differ in meaning and use?
While "remind someone about" has the meaning of telling
someone not to forget, "remind someone of" has the meaning of
causing someone to think of (something/someone) because of a
resemblance.
Syntactically, however, the two expressions behave similarly by
allowing a pronoun between the verb and preposition.
Using COCA (on paper) #3
Task (1): Search for the adjectives angry, annoyed, and furious; which
prepositions do they precede in the corpus? (Give examples only of
combinations that occur more than once.)
Task (2): Concentrate on angry + preposition combinations; can you
point to any tendencies in the uses of the different prepositions?
Task (3): Do the same tendencies apply to annoyed + preposition and furious
+ preposition?
Task (4): Do the same prepositions combine with the more "positive" adjectives
delighted and pleased? (Give examples.)
While angry about typically refers to something you are angry about, angry at
typically refers to someone you are angry at. Although there are counterexamples
to such a generalisation, these are tendencies shown in the corpus.
Other types of phraseological exercise #1
Fill in the gaps with the collocation that most typically occurs in the corpus.
Other types of phraseological exercise #2
Other types of phraseological exercise #3
Select nouns from the list below
and place them in the blanks
below the prepositions they
typically precede in the corpus:
access, alliance, ban,
congratulations, disregard,
dominion, encounter, jurisdiction,
precedence, provision, quarrel,
recipe, restriction, threat, witness
Conclusion: Implications for English
language teaching and learning?
• To uncover the secret life of words we need
to become familar with their phraseology
– Focus on context
– Focus on authentic English
– Focus on how awareness and knowledge can be
gained
• Hands-on corpus searches
• Purpose-made exercises on paper
Focus on data-driven learning:
“…the attempt to cut out the middleman as far as possible and
to give the learner direct access to the data” (Johns 1991: 30)
Access to collocational patterns gives the learner
the opportunity to discover:
the range of meanings a word can have (e.g. hot)
the range of contexts a word can occur in (e.g. can
you say solid statement?)
grammatical constructions associated with a word
(e.g. remember to vs. remember -ing)
choice of prepositions after verbs and adjectives (e.g
sceptical against/of, angry at vs. angry about?)
... corpus-learner, and indeed corpus-teacher
interaction are not replacements for learner-
learner and teacher-learner interaction, but
should rather be seen as an added value
offered by corpus-aided discovery learning.
(Bernardini 2004: 32)
References Bernardini, S. 2004. Corpora in the classroom: An overview and some reflections
on future developments. In Sinclair, J. (ed.). How to Use Corpora in Language
Teaching. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. 15-36.
Crystal, D. 2009. Just a Phrase I’m Going through: My Life in Language. London:
Routledge.
Granger, S. & Y. Bestgen. 2014. The use of collocations by intermediate vs.
advanced non-native writers: a bigram-based study. International Review of
Applied Linguistics in Language Teaching (IRAL), 52(3), 229-252.
Hasselgård, H. 2012. Vocabulary: Collocations and the corpus. [ˌmægəˈzi:n],
Cappelen Damms tidsskrift for engelsklærere, 02-2012.
Johns, T. 1991. From printout to handout: Grammar and vocabulary teaching in
the context of data-driven learning. In T. Johns & P. King (eds), Classroom
Concordancing. English Language Research Journal 4, 27-46.
Pawley, A. & F.H. Syder. 1983. Two puzzles for linguistic theory: nativelike
selection and nativelike fluency. In S.C. Richards & R.W. Schmidt (eds),
Language and Communication. London/New York: Longman, pp. 191–226.
Safran Foer, Jonathan. 2002. Everything is Illuminated. London: Penguin.