1
APRIL MURRAY | MArch | 060279701 [email protected] | Supervisor: Dr. Peter Kelle | School of Architecture, Planning & Landscape This group research project focuses on the study of the risks and vulnerabilies faced by informal selements in Bangkok. The serious flooding of Bangkok in 2011 was used as a way for us to measure and understand community resilience. In order to carry out this research we spent 8 weeks carrying out fieldwork in two case study communies in Bangkok, Thailand. As Yin states the need for case studies grows from the desire to understand complex social phenomena (1989 p.14).The two communes we selected were Khlong Bua Kwan, an urban canal-side selement within the city’s flood defences and Khlong Bung Pai, a rural canal-side selement just outside of the city’s flood defences. RESEARCH AIMS: 1. Invesgate ways that low income canal-side residents use their creavity, experience and knowledge to cope with hazards such as flooding 2. Learn how residents adapted their environment and livelihood in response to extreme 2011 flooding. METHODS Qualitave research was our primary method. We collected our data through spending me in the field and building relaonships with the residents. Throughout our fieldwork we encountered issues of communicaon and the language barrier. This became an unexpected opportunity to be creave with our methods and use the skills we have developed as architecture students, which are atypical of the social science researcher. As well as the tradional verbal interview and focus groups we developed methods of communicaon which involved visual cues and drawings which meant we could communicate directly with the residents rather then indirectly through an interpreter. RESULTS As a group we were very conscious of during our me in the communies was how we could give something back. To show our appreciaon of their involvement and cooperaon we created posters for each community documenng our ‘results’ and what we had learnt from them. This was an opportunity to verify our findings and for addional feedback. The posters were made translang our results into graphics, again to break through the language barrier. This was parcularly relevant to my own research aims as the posters catalogued the physical adaptaons made to their homes. This enabled discussion and encouraging the sharing of resources between communies. CONCLUSION This research has enabled us to gain a beer understanding of the vulnerabilies faced by these informal selements on a day-to-day basis as well as during mes of crisis and disaster. Together as a group we have learnt that the nature of community resilience operates on three levels; the individual, collecve and external. My focus on the relaonship between the canal and the home taught me about resilience on an individual scale. Through the various verbal and visual methods I learnt how they use their creavity to physically adapt their homes (such as raised walkways) to reduce their vulnerability during mes of hardship. UNDERSTANDING COMMUNITY RESILIENCE: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE RESIDENTS AND THE CANAL AND HOW THEY CREATIVELY ADAPT THEIR ENVIRONMENT DURING DISASTER. MY PARTICULAR RESEARCH AIMS WERE ACHIEVED THROUGH: 1. Detailed measured drawing- this enabled thorough observaon and collecon of data regarding the physical elements of the community. 2. Drawings by the residents- understanding their percepons of space. 3. Daily roune diagrams- to understand the effects of flooding on daily domesc life. 4. Photo elicitaon- simple visual communicaon, which can involve all ages. 5. Interviews in the home- the house and its elements became prompts for further conversaon. Learning key words in Thai and gesturing was effecve whilst interviewing in the context of the home. MOVING UPSTAIRS ONCRETE BLOCK PATH RAISING THE FLOOR LEVEL DREDGING My individual research topic within the group was to study the relaonship between the canal and the adjacent houses, in parcular how the residents adapted their houses during the floods. CATALOGUE OF ADAPTATIONS BUA KWAN BUNG PAI PRESENTING OUR RESULTS KHLONG BUA KWAN KHLONG BUNG PAI Studying their vulnerabilies, we learnt that even without disaster the communies’ informal status means they are constantly at risk. An implicaon of our presence as researchers in these previously unstudied communies can assist in raising their profiles, thereby increasing their chance of gaining formal status. This project forms part of ongoing research collaboraon between the Global Urban Research Unit at New- castle University with supervisor Dr. Peter Kelle, and a team led by Dr Rirong Chutaprukorn at Bangkok University. The project involved KMITL University in Bangkok. INTRODUCTION “We humans have an amazing ability to innovate. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the world’s diverse range of handmade or vernacular buildings.” (Reid, 2007 p.6) “Cultures that are prone to frequent recurrent disasters have, in some cases, devel- oped strategies to cope with them or have devised buildings that are resistant to their impact” (Oliver, 2010 p.149) Community Site Plans Focus groups Detailed drawings Drawings by the residents Photo ellicitaon Daily roune diagrams Measured Drawing REFERENCES Oliver, P.(2006) Building to meet needs: cultural issues in vernacular architecture. Oxford: Elsevier Ltd Reid, A. (2010) Buildings without architects: A global guide to everyday architecture. New York: Rizzoli. Yin, R. K.(1989) Case study research: design and methods. London: Sage Publicaons.

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE RESIDENTS AND THE CANAL … · 2018. 10. 21. · annabel ward, april murray, suzanne croft, victoria brown 2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554 codi slum

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE RESIDENTS AND THE CANAL … · 2018. 10. 21. · annabel ward, april murray, suzanne croft, victoria brown 2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554 codi slum

APRIL MURRAY | MArch | 060279701 [email protected] | Supervisor: Dr. Peter Kellett | School of Architecture, Planning & Landscape

This group research project focuses on the study of the risks and vulnerabilities faced by informal settlements in Bangkok. The serious flooding of Bangkok in 2011 was used as a way for us to measure and understand community resilience.

In order to carry out this research we spent 8 weeks carrying out fieldwork in two case study communities in Bangkok, Thailand. As Yin states the need for case studies grows from the desire to understand complex social phenomena (1989 p.14).The two communties we selected were Khlong Bua Kwan, an urban canal-side settlement within the city’s flood defences and Khlong Bung Pai, a rural canal-side settlement just outside of the city’s flood defences.

RESEARCH AIMS:

1. Investigate ways that low income canal-side residents use their creativity, experience and knowledge to cope with hazards such as flooding

2. Learn how residents adapted their environment and livelihood in response to extreme 2011 flooding.

METHODSQualititative research was our primary method. We collected our data through spending time in the field and building relationships with the residents. Throughout our fieldwork we encountered issues of communication and the language barrier. This became an unexpected opportunity to be creative with our methods and use the skills we have developed as architecture students, which are atypical of the social science researcher. As well as the traditional verbal interview and focus groups we developed methods of communication which involved visual cues and drawings which meant we could communicate directly with the residents rather then indirectly through an interpreter.

RESULTS As a group we were very conscious of during our time in the communities was how we could give something back. To show our appreciation of their involvement and cooperation we created posters for each community documenting our ‘results’ and what we had learnt from them. This was an opportunity to verify our findings and for additional feedback. The posters were made translating our results into graphics, again to break through the language barrier. This was particularly relevant to my own research aims as the posters catalogued the physical adaptations made to their homes. This enabled discussion and encouraging the sharing of resources between communities.

CONCLUSION This research has enabled us to gain a better understanding of the vulnerabilities faced by these informal settlements on a day-to-day basis as well as during times of crisis and disaster. Together as a group we have learnt that the nature of community resilience operates on three levels; the individual, collective and external. My focus on the relationship between the canal and the home taught me about resilience on an individual scale. Through the various verbal and visual methods I learnt how they use their creativity to physically adapt their homes (such as raised walkways) to reduce their vulnerability during times of hardship.

UNDERSTANDING COMMUNITY RESILIENCE:

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE RESIDENTS AND THE CANAL AND HOW THEY CREATIVELY ADAPT THEIR ENVIRONMENT DURING DISASTER.

MY PARTICULAR RESEARCH AIMS WERE ACHIEVED THROUGH:

1. Detailed measured drawing- this enabled thorough observation and collection of data regarding the physical elements of the community.

2. Drawings by the residents- understanding their perceptions of space. 3. Daily routine diagrams- to understand the effects of flooding on daily domestic life. 4. Photo elicitation- simple visual communication, which can involve all ages. 5. Interviews in the home- the house and its elements became prompts for further

conversation. Learning key words in Thai and gesturing was effective whilst interviewing in the context of the home.

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP COMMUNITY GATHERINGS

HOW HAS KHLONG BUA KWAN COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY MORE RESILIENT?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUA KWAN?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

MOVING UPSTAIRS CONCRETE BLOCK PATH LIFTING ON CON-CRETE BLOCKS

RAISING THE FLOOR LEVELSANGBAGS BUILDING A BARRIER DREDGING

HOME BASED ENTERPRISES

GARLAND MAKING

LINKS WITH NETWORKS

DETERGENT MAKING

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

NAM OI BAKINGSEWING

SAVINGS SCHEME COMMUNITY CENTRE

SECURE LAND TENURE BECOME MORE SELF SUSTAININGADAPT HOUSINGSHARE KNOWLEDGE

KHLONG BUA KWANคลองบัวขวัญ

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554

CODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NETWORK

CODISTRONGEST TIES?

MOST IMPORTANT?

HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN PART OF THE NETWORK?

SSPCDN

CODI SSPCDN

CODISSPCDN

169

6

น้ําท่วม

CODI

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP DREAM HOUSES

HOW HAS KHLONG BUNG PAI COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY STRONGER?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUNG PAI?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

BUILDING BRIDGES CONCRETE BLOCK PATHCONCRETE LIP ON WATER JARS

MOVING UPSTAIRSUSING BOATS/RAFTS IMPROVISING TOILETS MORE FISHING

GROWING

CHILLIES

VERNACULAR HOUSING

LOTUS

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

PAPAYA PUMPKINSMORNING GLORY

IMPROVISATION SOCIAL SPACES FISHING

IMPROVE NETWORK LINKS ELEVATE CROPS MORE WATERBORNE CROPSUPGRADE PATHSAVINGS SCHEME

KHLONG BUNG PAIคลองไม้ไผ่

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2505 2530 2545 2550 2553 2554 2555

CCODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

PUAE KAM PATTANA

?

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

น้ําท่วม

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP COMMUNITY GATHERINGS

HOW HAS KHLONG BUA KWAN COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY MORE RESILIENT?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUA KWAN?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

MOVING UPSTAIRS CONCRETE BLOCK PATH LIFTING ON CON-CRETE BLOCKS

RAISING THE FLOOR LEVELSANGBAGS BUILDING A BARRIER DREDGING

HOME BASED ENTERPRISES

GARLAND MAKING

LINKS WITH NETWORKS

DETERGENT MAKING

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

NAM OI BAKINGSEWING

SAVINGS SCHEME COMMUNITY CENTRE

SECURE LAND TENURE BECOME MORE SELF SUSTAININGADAPT HOUSINGSHARE KNOWLEDGE

KHLONG BUA KWANคลองบัวขวัญ

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554

CODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NETWORK

CODISTRONGEST TIES?

MOST IMPORTANT?

HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN PART OF THE NETWORK?

SSPCDN

CODI SSPCDN

CODISSPCDN

169

6

น้ําท่วม

CODI

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP COMMUNITY GATHERINGS

HOW HAS KHLONG BUA KWAN COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY MORE RESILIENT?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUA KWAN?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

MOVING UPSTAIRS CONCRETE BLOCK PATH LIFTING ON CON-CRETE BLOCKS

RAISING THE FLOOR LEVELSANGBAGS BUILDING A BARRIER DREDGING

HOME BASED ENTERPRISES

GARLAND MAKING

LINKS WITH NETWORKS

DETERGENT MAKING

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

NAM OI BAKINGSEWING

SAVINGS SCHEME COMMUNITY CENTRE

SECURE LAND TENURE BECOME MORE SELF SUSTAININGADAPT HOUSINGSHARE KNOWLEDGE

KHLONG BUA KWANคลองบัวขวัญ

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554

CODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NETWORK

CODISTRONGEST TIES?

MOST IMPORTANT?

HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN PART OF THE NETWORK?

SSPCDN

CODI SSPCDN

CODISSPCDN

169

6

น้ําท่วม

CODI

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP COMMUNITY GATHERINGS

HOW HAS KHLONG BUA KWAN COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY MORE RESILIENT?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUA KWAN?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

MOVING UPSTAIRS CONCRETE BLOCK PATH LIFTING ON CON-CRETE BLOCKS

RAISING THE FLOOR LEVELSANGBAGS BUILDING A BARRIER DREDGING

HOME BASED ENTERPRISES

GARLAND MAKING

LINKS WITH NETWORKS

DETERGENT MAKING

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

NAM OI BAKINGSEWING

SAVINGS SCHEME COMMUNITY CENTRE

SECURE LAND TENURE BECOME MORE SELF SUSTAININGADAPT HOUSINGSHARE KNOWLEDGE

KHLONG BUA KWANคลองบัวขวัญ

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554

CODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NETWORK

CODISTRONGEST TIES?

MOST IMPORTANT?

HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN PART OF THE NETWORK?

SSPCDN

CODI SSPCDN

CODISSPCDN

169

6

น้ําท่วม

CODI

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP COMMUNITY GATHERINGS

HOW HAS KHLONG BUA KWAN COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY MORE RESILIENT?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUA KWAN?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

MOVING UPSTAIRS CONCRETE BLOCK PATH LIFTING ON CON-CRETE BLOCKS

RAISING THE FLOOR LEVELSANGBAGS BUILDING A BARRIER DREDGING

HOME BASED ENTERPRISES

GARLAND MAKING

LINKS WITH NETWORKS

DETERGENT MAKING

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

NAM OI BAKINGSEWING

SAVINGS SCHEME COMMUNITY CENTRE

SECURE LAND TENURE BECOME MORE SELF SUSTAININGADAPT HOUSINGSHARE KNOWLEDGE

KHLONG BUA KWANคลองบัวขวัญ

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554

CODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NETWORK

CODISTRONGEST TIES?

MOST IMPORTANT?

HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN PART OF THE NETWORK?

SSPCDN

CODI SSPCDN

CODISSPCDN

169

6

น้ําท่วม

CODI

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP COMMUNITY GATHERINGS

HOW HAS KHLONG BUA KWAN COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY MORE RESILIENT?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUA KWAN?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

MOVING UPSTAIRS CONCRETE BLOCK PATH LIFTING ON CON-CRETE BLOCKS

RAISING THE FLOOR LEVELSANGBAGS BUILDING A BARRIER DREDGING

HOME BASED ENTERPRISES

GARLAND MAKING

LINKS WITH NETWORKS

DETERGENT MAKING

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

NAM OI BAKINGSEWING

SAVINGS SCHEME COMMUNITY CENTRE

SECURE LAND TENURE BECOME MORE SELF SUSTAININGADAPT HOUSINGSHARE KNOWLEDGE

KHLONG BUA KWANคลองบัวขวัญ

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554

CODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NETWORK

CODISTRONGEST TIES?

MOST IMPORTANT?

HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN PART OF THE NETWORK?

SSPCDN

CODI SSPCDN

CODISSPCDN

169

6

น้ําท่วม

CODI

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP COMMUNITY GATHERINGS

HOW HAS KHLONG BUA KWAN COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY MORE RESILIENT?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUA KWAN?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

MOVING UPSTAIRS CONCRETE BLOCK PATH LIFTING ON CON-CRETE BLOCKS

RAISING THE FLOOR LEVELSANGBAGS BUILDING A BARRIER DREDGING

HOME BASED ENTERPRISES

GARLAND MAKING

LINKS WITH NETWORKS

DETERGENT MAKING

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

NAM OI BAKINGSEWING

SAVINGS SCHEME COMMUNITY CENTRE

SECURE LAND TENURE BECOME MORE SELF SUSTAININGADAPT HOUSINGSHARE KNOWLEDGE

KHLONG BUA KWANคลองบัวขวัญ

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2515 2520 2530 2535 2538 2547 2554

CODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT NETWORK

CODISTRONGEST TIES?

MOST IMPORTANT?

HOW LONG HAVE YOU BEEN PART OF THE NETWORK?

SSPCDN

CODI SSPCDN

CODISSPCDN

169

6

น้ําท่วม

CODI

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP DREAM HOUSES

HOW HAS KHLONG BUNG PAI COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY STRONGER?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUNG PAI?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

BUILDING BRIDGES CONCRETE BLOCK PATHCONCRETE LIP ON WATER JARS

MOVING UPSTAIRSUSING BOATS/RAFTS IMPROVISING TOILETS MORE FISHING

GROWING

CHILLIES

VERNACULAR HOUSING

LOTUS

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

PAPAYA PUMPKINSMORNING GLORY

IMPROVISATION SOCIAL SPACES FISHING

IMPROVE NETWORK LINKS ELEVATE CROPS MORE WATERBORNE CROPSUPGRADE PATHSAVINGS SCHEME

KHLONG BUNG PAIคลองไม้ไผ่

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2505 2530 2545 2550 2553 2554 2555

CCODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

PUAE KAM PATTANA

?

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

น้ําท่วม

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP DREAM HOUSES

HOW HAS KHLONG BUNG PAI COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY STRONGER?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUNG PAI?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

BUILDING BRIDGES CONCRETE BLOCK PATHCONCRETE LIP ON WATER JARS

MOVING UPSTAIRSUSING BOATS/RAFTS IMPROVISING TOILETS MORE FISHING

GROWING

CHILLIES

VERNACULAR HOUSING

LOTUS

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

PAPAYA PUMPKINSMORNING GLORY

IMPROVISATION SOCIAL SPACES FISHING

IMPROVE NETWORK LINKS ELEVATE CROPS MORE WATERBORNE CROPSUPGRADE PATHSAVINGS SCHEME

KHLONG BUNG PAIคลองไม้ไผ่

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2505 2530 2545 2550 2553 2554 2555

CCODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

PUAE KAM PATTANA

?

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

น้ําท่วม

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP DREAM HOUSES

HOW HAS KHLONG BUNG PAI COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY STRONGER?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUNG PAI?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

BUILDING BRIDGES CONCRETE BLOCK PATHCONCRETE LIP ON WATER JARS

MOVING UPSTAIRSUSING BOATS/RAFTS IMPROVISING TOILETS MORE FISHING

GROWING

CHILLIES

VERNACULAR HOUSING

LOTUS

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

PAPAYA PUMPKINSMORNING GLORY

IMPROVISATION SOCIAL SPACES FISHING

IMPROVE NETWORK LINKS ELEVATE CROPS MORE WATERBORNE CROPSUPGRADE PATHSAVINGS SCHEME

KHLONG BUNG PAIคลองไม้ไผ่

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2505 2530 2545 2550 2553 2554 2555

CCODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

PUAE KAM PATTANA

?

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

น้ําท่วม

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP DREAM HOUSES

HOW HAS KHLONG BUNG PAI COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY STRONGER?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUNG PAI?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

BUILDING BRIDGES CONCRETE BLOCK PATHCONCRETE LIP ON WATER JARS

MOVING UPSTAIRSUSING BOATS/RAFTS IMPROVISING TOILETS MORE FISHING

GROWING

CHILLIES

VERNACULAR HOUSING

LOTUS

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

PAPAYA PUMPKINSMORNING GLORY

IMPROVISATION SOCIAL SPACES FISHING

IMPROVE NETWORK LINKS ELEVATE CROPS MORE WATERBORNE CROPSUPGRADE PATHSAVINGS SCHEME

KHLONG BUNG PAIคลองไม้ไผ่

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2505 2530 2545 2550 2553 2554 2555

CCODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

PUAE KAM PATTANA

?

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

น้ําท่วม

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP DREAM HOUSES

HOW HAS KHLONG BUNG PAI COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY STRONGER?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUNG PAI?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

BUILDING BRIDGES CONCRETE BLOCK PATHCONCRETE LIP ON WATER JARS

MOVING UPSTAIRSUSING BOATS/RAFTS IMPROVISING TOILETS MORE FISHING

GROWING

CHILLIES

VERNACULAR HOUSING

LOTUS

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

PAPAYA PUMPKINSMORNING GLORY

IMPROVISATION SOCIAL SPACES FISHING

IMPROVE NETWORK LINKS ELEVATE CROPS MORE WATERBORNE CROPSUPGRADE PATHSAVINGS SCHEME

KHLONG BUNG PAIคลองไม้ไผ่

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2505 2530 2545 2550 2553 2554 2555

CCODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

PUAE KAM PATTANA

?

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

น้ําท่วม

LINKED RESEARCH- BANGKOK

TIMELINE

WIDER CONTEXT

COMMUNITY MAP DREAM HOUSES

HOW HAS KHLONG BUNG PAI COPED WITH THE FLOODING?

WHAT MAKES THIS COMMUNITY STRONG?

WHAT CAN MAKE THIS COMMUNITY STRONGER?

WHAT DOES ‘COMMUNITY’ MEAN IN KHLONG BUNG PAI?

ADAPTATIONS

WATER LEVELS

BUILDING BRIDGES CONCRETE BLOCK PATHCONCRETE LIP ON WATER JARS

MOVING UPSTAIRSUSING BOATS/RAFTS IMPROVISING TOILETS MORE FISHING

GROWING

CHILLIES

VERNACULAR HOUSING

LOTUS

INTERNAL RELATIONSHIPS

PAPAYA PUMPKINSMORNING GLORY

IMPROVISATION SOCIAL SPACES FISHING

IMPROVE NETWORK LINKS ELEVATE CROPS MORE WATERBORNE CROPSUPGRADE PATHSAVINGS SCHEME

KHLONG BUNG PAIคลองไม้ไผ่

ANNABEL WARD, APRIL MURRAY, SUZANNE CROFT, VICTORIA BROWN

2505 2530 2545 2550 2553 2554 2555

CCODI

SLUM SEA PAAK

PUAE KAM PATTANA

?

ชุมชน

ชุมชน

น้ําท่วม

My individual research topic within the group was to study the relationship between the canal and the adjacent houses, in particular how the residents adapted their houses during the floods.

CATALOGUE OF ADAPTATIONS

BUA

KWAN

BUN

G P

AI

PRESENTING OUR RESULTS

KHLONG BUA KWANKHLONG BUNG PAI

Studying their vulnerabilities, we learnt that even without disaster the communities’ informal status means they are constantly at risk. An implication of our presence as researchers in these previously unstudied communities can assist in raising their profiles, thereby increasing their chance of gaining formal status.

This project forms part of ongoing research collaboration between the Global Urban Research Unit at New-castle University with supervisor Dr. Peter Kellett, and a team led by Dr Rittirong Chutapruttikorn at Bangkok University. The project involved KMITL University in Bangkok.

INTRODUCTION

“We humans have an amazing ability to innovate. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the world’s diverse range of handmade or vernacular buildings.” (Reid, 2007 p.6)

“Cultures that are prone to frequent recurrent disasters have, in some cases, devel-oped strategies to cope with them or have devised buildings that are resistant to their impact” (Oliver, 2010 p.149)

Community Site Plans

Focus groups

Detailed drawings

Drawings by the residents

Photo ellicitation

Daily routine diagrams Measured Drawing

REFERENCESOliver, P.(2006) Building to meet needs: cultural issues in vernacular architecture. Oxford: Elsevier LtdReid, A. (2010) Buildings without architects: A global guide to everyday architecture. New York: Rizzoli. Yin, R. K.(1989) Case study research: design and methods. London: Sage Publications.