24
THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND DRIVER‟S SPEED PREFERENCES NURUL FARHANA BINTI NASARRUDIN Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the award of the degree of Bachelor Civil Engineering Faculty of Civil Engineering and Earth Resources Universiti Malaysia Pahang JANUARY 2016

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND DRIVER‟S

SPEED PREFERENCES

NURUL FARHANA BINTI NASARRUDIN

Thesis submitted in fulfilment of the requirements

for the award of the degree

of Bachelor Civil Engineering

Faculty of Civil Engineering and Earth Resources

Universiti Malaysia Pahang

JANUARY 2016

Page 2: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

vi

ABSTRACT

Nowadays, road accidents are common issues in the newspapers every day. The number

of road accident cases increases year by year in Malaysia. According to statistics by

Malaysian Institute of Road Safety Research, speeding is the second highest (21%)

factors that contribute to crash. The aim of the study are to determine the speed

preferences of the road users based on the environments of the road, to investigate the

relationship between driver‟s background and driver‟s speed preferences, and to

determine the difference between speed preferred by road users and the actual speed

they used. A set of questionnaire was distributed to 90 respondents in University of

Malaysia Pahang which consist of a variety of questions on gender, age, driving

experience, classes of driving license, daily transportation, occupation, distance of

residence to workplace and estimated driving hour for a day to get the driver‟s speed

preferences. A radar gun was used to obtain the actual speed that road users used. The

study areas are located at Federal Road 2 from KM3 until KM27. The result of this

study showed that male drivers prefer to use higher speed compare to female drivers,

the drivers aged below 50 years old prefer to use higher speed than drivers aged above

50 years old, the drivers who have driving license less than 5 years prefer to use slower

speed, licensee for both classes B2 and D prefer to use higher speed compare to single

license holder which is license B2 or D, car drivers prefer to use higher speed than

motorcycle rider, the drivers with longer distance to workplace prefer to use higher

speed and drivers with longer estimated driving hour will choose the higher speed.

Other than that, the driver‟s speed preferences at each point have been identified where

at point 1 is 80-90 km/hr, point 2 is 60-70 km/hr, and point 3 is 50-60 km/hr and lastly

at point 4 is 80-90 km/hr. The result from cumulative frequency based on speed at 85th

percentiles, point 1 is 55 km/hr, point 2 is 90 km/hr, point 3 is 60 km/hr, and point 4 is

85 km/hr. In conclusion, this finding shows that driver‟s background imposed serious

effects towards driver‟s speed preferences. Further research focusing on driver‟s

background could be proposed in order to minimise contributing of speed as crash

factors.

Page 3: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

vii

ABSTRAK

Pada masa kini, kemalangan jalan raya adalah isu yang kerap terpapar di akhbar setiap

hari. Jumlah kes kemalangan jalan raya di Malaysia meningkat dari tahun ke tahun.

Mengikut statistik oleh Institut Penyelidikan Keselamatan Jalan Raya, memandu laju

adalah faktor kedua tertinggi (21%) yang menyumbang kepada kemalangan. Tujuan

kajian ini adalah untuk menentukan had laju pilihan pengguna jalan raya berdasarkan

persekitaran jalan, untuk mengkaji hubungan antara latar belakang pemandu dan had

laju pilihan pemandu, dan untuk menentukan perbezaan antara had laju pilihan

pengguna jalan raya dan kelajuan sebenar yang mereka gunakan. Satu set borang soal

selidik telah diedarkan kepada 90 responden di Universiti Malaysia Pahang yang terdiri

daripada pelbagai latar belakang pemandu. Senapang radar digunakan untuk

memperoleh kelajuan sebenar yang digunakan oleh pengguna jalan raya. Kawasan

kajian terletak di Jalan Persekutuan 2 dari KM3 hingga KM27. Hasil kajian ini

menunjukkan bahawa pemandu lelaki lebih gemar menggunakan kelajuan yang lebih

tinggi berbanding dengan pemandu wanita, pemandu yang berumur di bawah 50 tahun

lebih gemar menggunakan kelajuan yang lebih tinggi daripada pemandu berusia 50

tahun ke atas, pemandu yang memiliki lesen memandu kurang daripada 5 tahun lebih

gemar meggunakan kelajuan yang lebih perlahan, pemegang lessen bagi kedua-dua

kelas (B2 & D) lebih gemar menggunakan kelajuan yang lebih tinggi berbanding

dengan pemegang lessen tunggal dimana lessen B2 atau D, pemandu kereta memilih

untuk menggunakan kelajuan yang lebih tinggi berbanding penunggang motosikal,

pemandu dengan jarak yang lebih jauh ke tempat kerja lebih suka menggunakan

kelajuan yang lebih tinggi, dan pemandu yang memandu dengan lebih lama memilih

kelajuan yang lebih tinggi. Selain itu, pilihan kelajuan pemandu pada setiap titik telah

dikenal pasti di mana pada titik 1 adalah 80-90 km/jam, titik 2 adalah 60-70 km/jam,

dan titik 3 adalah 50-60 km/jam dan akhir sekali pada titik 4 adalah 80-90 km/jam.

Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan di persentil ke-85, titik 1 adalah 55

km/jam, titik 2 adalah 90 km/jam, titik 3 adalah 60 km/jam, dan titik 4 adalah 85

km/jam. Kesimpulannya, kajian ini menunjukkan bahawa latar belakang pemandu

memberi kesan yang serius terhadap had laju pilihan. Kajian lanjutan yang tertumpu

kepada latar belakang pemandu boleh dicadangkan untuk mengurangkan penglibatan

had laju sebagai faktor kemalangan.

Page 4: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

viii

TABLE OF CONTENT

Page

SUPERVISOR’S DECLARATION ii

STUDENT’S DECLARATION iii

DEDICATION iv

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT v

ABSTRACT vi

ABSTRAK vii

TABLE OF CONTENT viii

LIST OF TABLES xii

LIST OF FIGURE xiv

CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION

1.1 Introduction 1

1.2 Problem Statement 2

1.3 Objectives 3

1.4 Scope of Study 3

1.5 Significance of Study 4

CHAPTER 2 LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 Road Traffic Accident Worldwide 5

2.2 Road Accident in Malaysia 6

2.3 Speed 8

2.3.1 Speed Limit 8

2.3.2 Basic of Speed Limit 10

2.4 Why Do People Speed? 11

2.5 Speed Preferences 12

2.5.1 Factors Influencing Speed Preferences 13

2.6 Driver‟s Background 14

2.6.1 The Driver‟s Gender 15

Page 5: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

ix

2.6.2 The Driver‟s Age 16

2.6.3 Driving Experience 18

2.6.4 Types of Vehicles 19

2.6.5 Types of License 20

CHAPTER 3 METHODOLOGY

3.1 Introduction 22

3.2 Research Flow Chart 22

3.3 Data Collection 24

3.3.1 Data Collection from Questionnaire 24

3.3.3 Data Observed On the Road 24

3.4 Criteria for Selection of Study Area 24

3.5 Development of the Questionnaire 27

3.5.1 Formation of the Questionnaire 28

3.5.1.1 Part A of the Questionnaire 29

3.5.1.2 Part B of the Questionnaire 29

3.6 Respondent Selection 29

3.7 Method to Observe Spot Speed 30

3.8 Procedure to Observe the Spot Speed 30

3.8.1 Factors That Can Affect the Spot Speed Data 30

3.8.2 The Selection of Location to Observe Spot Speed 31

3.8.3 The Time Selection 31

3.9 Data Analysis of Questionnaire 31

3.9.1 Method of Statistic Analysis Using Ms Excel 32

3.9.2 Method of Statistic Analysis Using SPSS 32

3.10 Data Analysis of Spot Speed 33

3.11 Conclusion 34

CHAPTER 4 RESULT AND ANALYSIS

4.1 Introduction 35

4.2 Respondents Background 35

4.3 Speed Preferences of Point 1 43

Page 6: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

x

4.4 Speed Preferences of Point 2 57

4.5 Speed Preferences of Point 3 71

4.6 Speed Preferences of Point 4 85

4.7 Actual Speed by Road Users 99

4.8 Summary 105

CHAPTER 5 DISCUSSION

5.1 Introduction 107

5.2 Speed Preferences of the Road Users Based On 107

The Environment of the Road

5.3 Speed Preferences 108

5.3.1 Speed Preferences Based On Gender 108

5.3.2 Speed Preferences Based On Age 109

5.3.3 Speed Preferences Based On Driving 110

Experience

5.3.4 Speed Preferences Based On Classes 111

Of Driving License

5.3.5 Speed Preferences Based On Daily 112

Transportation

5.3.6 Speed Preferences Based On Occupation 112

5.3.7 Speed Preferences Based On Distance to 113

Workplace

5.3.8 Speed Preferences Based On Estimated 113

Driving Hour for a Day

5.4 The Difference between Speeds Preferred By 114

Road Users and the Actual Speed They Used

CHAPTER 6 CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS

6.1 Introduction 116

6.2 Conclusion 116

6.3 Problem Encountered 117

6.4 Recommendations 118

Page 7: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

xi

REFERENCES 119

APPENDIX

A Sample of Questionnaire 124

Page 8: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

xii

LIST OF TABLES

Table No. Title Page

1.0 Crash contributor‟s factors 2

2.1 General accident data in Malaysia (1995-2012) 6

2.2 Police accident statistic 2009 18

2.3 Types of license in Malaysia 20

4.1 Descriptive gender of road user 35

4.2 Descriptive age of road user 36

4.3 Descriptive driving experience of road user 37

4.4 Descriptive class of driving license of road user 38

4.5 Descriptive daily transportation of road user 39

4.6 Descriptive occupation of road user 40

4.7 Descriptive distance to workplace of road user 41

4.8 Descriptive driving hours of road user 42

4.9 Speed preferences at point 1 of the road users 44

4.10 Speed preferences at point 1 based on gender 45

4.11 Speed preferences at point 1 based on age 47

4.12 Speed preferences at point 1 based on driving experience 48

4.13 Speed preferences at point 1 based on class of driving licence 50

4.14 Speed preferences at point 1 based on daily transportation 51

4.15 Speed preferences at point 1 based on occupation 53

4.16 Speed preferences at point 1 based on distance to work place 54

4.17 Speed preferences at point 1 based on driving hours 56

4.18 Speed preferences at point 2 of the road users 57

4.19 Speed preferences at point 2 based on gender 59

4.20 Speed preferences at point 2 based on age 60

4.21 Speed preferences at point 2 based on driving experience 62

4.22 Speed preferences at point 2 based on class of driving licence 63

4.23 Speed preferences at point 2 based on daily transportation 65

4.24 Speed preferences at point 2 based on occupation 66

4.25 Speed preferences at point 2 based on distances to work place 68

Page 9: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

xiii

4.26 Speed preferences at point 2 based on driving hours 70

4.27 Speed preferences at point 3 of the road users 71

4.28 Speed preferences at point 3 based on gender 73

4.29 Speed preferences at point 3 based on age 74

4.30 Speed preferences at point 3 based on driving experience 76

4.31 Speed preferences at point 3 based on class of driving licence 77

4.32 Speed preferences at point 3 based on daily transportation 79

4.33 Speed preferences at point 3 based on occupation 80

4.34 Speed preferences at point 3 based on distance to work place 82

4.35 Speed preferences at point 3 based on driving hours 84

4.36 Speed preferences at point 4 of the road users 85

4.37 Speed preferences at point 4 based on gender 87

4.38 Speed preferences at point 4 based on age 88

4.39 Speed preferences at point 4 based on driving experience 90

4.40 Speed preferences at point 4 based on class of driving licence 91

4.41 Speed preferences at point 4 based on daily transportation 93

4.42 Speed preferences at point 4 based on occupation 94

4.43 Speed preferences at point 4 based on distance to work place 96

4.44 Speed preferences at point 4 based on driving hours 98

4.45 Actual speed by road users at point 1 99

4.46 Actual speed by road users at point 2 101

4.47 Actual speed by road users at point 3 102

4.48 Actual speed by road users at point 4 104

Page 10: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

xiv

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure No. Title Page

2.1 Road traffic death by type of road user 5

2.2 Factors that contribute to road accident 7

2.3 Malaysian speed limit 9

2.4 Malaysian speed limit for heavy and light vehicle in highway 9

2.5 Statistics of road crash between male and female 16

2.6 Percentage of drivers in speeding-related with driver age 17

2.7 Statistical report road accident Malaysia 19

2.8 Statistic of motorcycles fatality cases 21

3.1 Research flow chart 23

3.2 The road in front of Giant 25

3.3 The area in front of BH Petrol Pump 26

3.4 The area in front of SMK Paya Besar 26

3.5 The area in front of Restaurant Zaman 27

3.7 Microsoft Excel 2010 32

4.1 Descriptive gender of road user 36

4.2 Descriptive age of road user 37

4.3 Descriptive driving experience of road user 38

4.4 Descriptive class of driving license of road user 39

4.5 Descriptive daily transportation of road users 40

4.6 Descriptive occupation of road user 41

4.7 Descriptive distance to workplace of road user 42

4.8 Descriptive driving hours of road user 43

4.9 Speed preferences at point 1 of the road users 44

4.10 Speed preferences at point 1 based on gender 46

4.11 Speed preferences at point 1 based on age 47

4.12 Speed preferences at point 1 based on driving experience 49

4.13 Speed preferences at point 1 based on class of driving licence 50

4.14 Speed preferences at point 1 based on daily transportation 52

4.15 Speed preferences at point 1 based on occupation 53

Page 11: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

xv

4.16 Speed preferences at point 1 based on distance to work place 55

4.17 Speed preferences at point 1 based on driving hours 56

4.18 Speed preferences at point 2 of the road users 58

4.19 Speed preferences at point 2 based on gender 59

4.20 Speed preferences at point 2 based on age 61

4.21 Speed preferences at point 2 based on driving experience 62

4.22 Speed preferences at point 2 based on class of driving licence 64

4.23 Speed preferences at point 2 based on daily transportation 65

4.24 Speed preferences at point 2 based on occupation 67

4.25 Speed preferences at point 2 based on distances to work place 69

4.26 Speed preferences at point 2 based on driving hours 70

4.27 Speed preferences at point 3 of the road users 72

4.28 Speed preferences at point 3 based on gender 73

4.29 Speed preferences at point 3 based on age 75

4.30 Speed preferences at point 3 based on driving experience 76

4.31 Speed preferences at point 3 based on class of driving licence 78

4.32 Speed preferences at point 3 based on daily transportation 79

4.33 Speed preferences at point 3 based on occupation 81

4.34 Speed preferences at point 3 based on distance to work place 83

4.35 Speed preferences at point 3 based on driving hours 84

4.36 Speed preferences at point 4 of the road users 86

4.37 Speed preferences at point 4 based on gender 87

4.38 Speed preferences at point 4 based on age 89

4.39 Speed preferences at point 4 based on driving experience 90

4.40 Speed preferences at point 4 based on class of driving license 92

4.41 Speed preferences at point 4 based on daily transportation 93

4.42 Speed preferences at point 4 based on occupation 95

4.43 Speed preferences at point 4 based on distance to work place 97

4.44 Speed preferences at point 4 based on driving hours 98

4.45 Actual speed by road users at point 1 100

4.46 Average speed of road users at point 1 100

4.47 Actual speed by road users at point 2 101

4.48 Average actual speed by road users at point 2 102

Page 12: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

xvi

4.49 Actual speed by road users at point 3 103

4.50 Average actual speed by road users at point 3 103

4.51 Actual speed by road users at point 4 104

4.52 Average actual speed by road users at point 4 105

Page 13: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

CHAPTER 1

INTRODUCTION

1.1 INRODUCTION

In Malaysia, road is one of the important aspects in transportation sector. The

field of transportation plays a significant role in coordinating all countries‟ development

programme. In fact, the rise in human activities indirectly increases the demand for

various types of vehicles. Simultaneously, the number of vehicles on the road is also

increased and this can be seen from it‟s rapid growth every year.

Transportation is a necessity for human movement that needs to be owned and

being the main basis in one‟s daily life. In this era, an increase in number of vehicles in

Malaysia has directly led to various issues and problems regarding to traffic particularly

in road crashes. Road crashes are one of the major problems of this country involving

various socio-economic aspects. Loss of human life among road users is a big loss in

earnings of human resources in addition to the damage and loss of property.

In Malaysia, speed limit is displayed at road shoulders. The speed limit is

designed based on several factors and it is ranging from 10 km/hr to 110 km/hr. Based

on the explanation by the Minister of Works, the determination of speed limit either on

the road or highway is determined by several factors such as road engineering design,

density of traffic flow and the level of risk of accident. Hence, there are absolutely

certain locations where the speed limit has to be reduced as compared to the rate of the

national speed limit, which is 110 km/hr on highways and 90 km/hr in Federal Road.

Page 14: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

2

However, it is also expected that driver‟s preferences played an important role in

determining speed limit. The driver‟s preferences on the road area will affect the chosen

speed. For example, drivers are believed to use lower speed in the urban area compared

to rural area. This is due to development and existence of buildings in the urban area.

Thus, the driver has to control the movement in accordance with the rules of the road.

Sometimes drivers preferred to speeding and it can contribute to crashes. According to

statistics by Malaysian Institute of Road Safety Research, speeding is the second highest

factor that contributes to car crashes.

Table 1.0: Crash contributor‟s factors

Main crash contributing factors out of the 439 cases Number %

Risky Driving 121 28

Speeding 93 21

Fatigue 70 16

Safety, Health and Environment 38 9

Road Defects 36 8

Driving Under the Influence 24 5

Brake Defects 20 5

Conspicuousness 18 4

Overloading 11 3

Type Defects 14 3

Source: MIROS

Table 1.10 show speeding is the second highest factor that contributes to car

crashes with 21%.

1.2 PROBLEM STATEMENT

The main goal of driving is to reach to a destination. In the decision-making

process to achieve this goal, driver‟s behaviour will play a significant role. These days,

road accidents can be found as common issues in the newspapers and daily news

Page 15: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

3

bulletin. The number of road accident cases increases year by year in Malaysia.

According to statistics by Malaysian Institute of Road Safety Research, speeding is the

second highest factor that contributes to car crashes with 21%.

Sometimes, drivers tend to give minor attention to speed limit signs and also

drive exceeding the speed limit. Excessive limit is defined as exceeding the speed limit

or over the speed limit. It means the drivers drive at inappropriate speed which is not

suitable for prevailing road and traffic conditions. Other than that, some drivers tend to

reduce speed when they are near to the enforcement area and for only a short period of

time. Based on research Ryeng (2011), drivers will reduce their speed when the level of

police enforcement increases. To overcome this problem the speed preferences of the

road users based on environment of the road will be determined and the relationship

between driver‟s background and driver‟s speed preferences will be investigated. The

results of this study would benefit Polis Diraja Malaysia (PDRM) and Jabatan

Pengangkutan Jalan (JPJ). They can use the information from this study to monitor

drivers who are driving beyond the speed limit.

1.3 OBJECTIVES

The objectives of this study are:

1) To determine the speed preferences of the road users based on the environment

of the road.

2) To investigate the relationship between drivers‟ background and driver‟s speed

preferences.

3) To determine the difference between speed preferred by road users and the

actual speed they used.

1.4 SCOPE OF STUDY

i) This study involves University Malaysia Pahang (UMP) community only.

ii) The speed limit data is collected within Gambang Town and Kuantan Town

(Federal Road 2) from KM 3 until KM 27.

Page 16: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

4

iii) The data were obtained during traffic flow in normal condition including peak

hours and at day time.

iv) Weather factors are also considered in the study because the study will not be

conducted during rainy day. It is because it will affect the way of driving.

1.5 SIGNIFICANCE OF STUDY

Since speeding is related with road crashes, the results from this research can be

implemented as indicator for reducing number of road crashes and speeding cases in

Malaysia by Polis Di Raja Malaysia (PDRM) and Jabatan Pengangkutan Jalan (JPJ).

This study also determine the actual speed road users used that have higher risk for

speeding cases based on the statistical analysis.

Page 17: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

CHAPTER 2

LITERATURE REVIEW

2.1 ROAD TRAFFIC ACCIDENT WORLWIDE

Road traffic accident is a vehicles collision whether between vehicles, between

vehicle and pedestrian, vehicle and animal, or a single vehicle by itself overturned on

the road. Road crash can also be defined as an unplanned incident and the incident that

cannot be controlled where the action and response to the object or human until cause

injury (Heinrich et al., 1980). Nowadays, road traffic accident can be classified as

among the leading causes of death. A study by World Health Organization (2004) stated

that road crashes are the second leading cause of death globally. Other than that,

approximately 1.24 million people died on the road in the world each year.

Figure 2.1: Road traffic death by type of road users

Source: WHO

31%

23%

5%

22%

19%

WORLD

Car occupants

Motorized 2-3wheelers

Cyclists

Pedestrians

Other

Page 18: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

6

2.2 ROAD ACCIDENT IN MALAYSIA

In Malaysia, road traffic accident has also becomes a severe problem. According

to the statistic from Malaysian Institute of Road Safety Research (MIROS), the rate of

road accidents occurred in year 2010 is 414,421 accidents. 2 years later in 2012, the rate

of road accidents expanded to 462,423 accidents that increasing by 10.38% from the

previous rate. Other than that, according to statistic of road traffic accident from World

Health Ranking, Malaysia was ranked 20th

in world with 34.5% of road traffic accident.

Table 2.1: General accident data in Malaysia (1995-2012)

Year Population Vehicle

Registered

Vehicle

Involved

Road

Length

Road

Accidents

Road

Casualties

Road

Deaths

Vehicles

Ownership

(Person

per

vehicle)

1995 20,096,700 6,802,375 275,430 62,221 162,491 52,152 5,712 3.0

1996 21,169,000 7,686,684 325,915 64,511 189,109 53,475 6,304 2.8

1997 21,665,600 8,550,469 373,526 66,108 215,632 56,574 6,302 2.5

1998 22,179,500 9,141,357 366,932 66,741 211,037 55,704 5,740 2.4

1999 22,711,900 9,929,951 390,674 67,069 223,166 52,937 5,794 2.3

2000 23,263,600 10,598,804 441,386 68,770 250,429 50,200 6,035 2.2

2001 23,795,300 11,302,545 483,351 74,217 265,175 50,473 5,849 2.1

2002 24,526,500 12,068,144 507,995 74,641 279,711 49,552 5,891 2.0

2003 25,048,300 12,819,248 555,634 79,667 298,653 52,741 6,286 2.0

2004 25,580,000 13,828,889 596,533 71,814 326,815 54,091 6,228 1.8

2005 26,130,000 15,026,660 581,136 71,814 328,264 47,012 6,200 1.7

2006 26,640,000 15,790,732 635,024 72,781 341,252 35,425 6,287 1.7

2007 27,170,000 16,813,943 668,173 73,032 363,319 33,999 6,282 1.6

2008 27,730,000 17,971,901 671,078 73,419 373,071 32,274 6,527 1.5

2009 28,310,000 19,016,782 705,623 100,002 397,330 31,417 6,745 1.5

2010 28,920,000 20,188,565 760,433 111,378 414,421 28,269 6,872 1.4

2011 29,000,000 21,401,269 817,151 127,517 449,040 25,570 6,877 1.4

2012 29,300,000 22,702,221 777,817 127,517 462,423 24,439 6,917 1.3

Source: MIROS

Based on a survey done by MUFORS (Malaysian Unite for Road Safety), 61.1%

of respondents agreed that most of road crash takes place because of driver‟s attitude.

Besides, based on the statistics by Polis Diraja Malaysia (PDRM), they found 85.7% of

road crash happened because of human factor, 10.6% because of road condition and

environmental while the other 3.7% comes from the vehicle itself.

Page 19: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

7

Other than that, based on the research by Transport and Road Research

Laboratory, TRRL (1991), the main factor that contributes to road crash is caused by

human error with 94.75% while 28% of road crash caused by road environment and the

other 8.5% of road crash caused by vehicle itself.

Figure 2.2: Factors that contribute to road accident

Source: TRRL (1991)

Speeding also is the leading killer. The vehicles involved in road crash are the

vehicles driven with higher speed limit as compared to the other vehicles. The

increasing in speed limit can give an effect to the crash that could cause injury (Brown

& Cotton, 2003).

Persekitaran Jalan Raya Pengguna Jalan Raya Kenderaan

28% 94.75% 8.5%

2.5% 65% 2.5%

24% 4.5%

1.25%

0.25%

Page 20: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

8

2.3 SPEED

Speed unit is defined as the rate of movement for vehicles in distance per unit

time. Speed unit normally used as kilometres per hour. Based on research by Roshandeh

et al. (2009) speed is an important consideration that is related to the transportation

safety, time, comfort, convenience and economics.

2.3.1 Speed Limit

Speed limit is the maximum speed that is used on that particular road. Speed

limit is the maximum speed that is permissible and legal where drivers drive along

certain sections of road under the conditions of the road to have a good trip (WHO,

2008). Therefore, all the prescribed speed limit used by drivers on that particular road is

based on the study and research done by highway and transport engineer towards that

area.

In Malaysia, National Speed Limits (Had Laju Kebangsaan) is a set of speed

limits applicable on Malaysian Expressway, federal roads, state roads and municipal

roads. On 1 February 1989, the National Speed Limits was enforced by following

National Speed Limit Orders, 1989 (Perintah Had Laju Kebangsaan, 1989). The drivers

who drive exceeds the speed limit would be compounded up to RM300. As stated by

National Speed Limits (starting from 1989), the speed limit for federal road is 90 km/hr,

60 km/hr for state road and 110 km/hr for highway. Moreover, the speed limit for heavy

vehicles is 80-90 km/hr at highway while 70-80 km/hr at federal and state road.

Nevertheless, Polis Diraja Malaysia had given leniency to the drivers with the added

speed (10 km/hr) from the speed limit on the road before the summons of speed traps

recorded.

Page 21: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

9

Figure 2.3: Malaysian speed limit

Figure 2.4: Malaysian speed limit for heavy and light vehicle in highway

Drivers are obliged to follow minimum and maximum speed limit which have

been set (Texas of Engineering Department of Traffic Division TEDTD, 2005). If the

drivers are not following the speed limit which has been set, the drivers should be

summoned by the authorities.

Page 22: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

10

2.3.2 Basic of Speed Limit

There are 4 types of speed limit which can be enforced on road or highway:

1) Maximum speed limit – the highest speed allowed on the road or highway.

Driving with the exceed of the maximum speed limit will cause the vehicle to

lost control and at the same time trigger road accidents.

2) Minimum speed limit – the lowest speed allowed on the road or highway.

Driving less than the minimum speed limit will likely lead to road accidents

caused by collision with vehicle from the back.

3) Recommended speed limit – the maximum speed recommended for safe driving.

The speed limit is enforced in most of the German Highway since most of the

highway in Germany not set to a maximum speed limit. The drivers are allowed

to drive exceeding the recommended speed limit but in the event of accident, the

driver cannot claim for damages resulting from the accident from the insurance

company respectively.

4) Variable speed limit – the speed limit can be changed according to season,

weather and road conditions. Variable speed limit is usually used in some

countries during winter and at the time, the usual or original speed limit will not

be used temporarily.

It is compulsory for drivers to follow the speed limit that has been set either the

maximum or minimum speed. The speed limit was established to reduce the risk of road

accidents. The speed limit will also be more useful and meaningful if the driver

complies with the stipulated speed limit. (Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices,

MUTCD, 2009)

Page 23: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

11

2.4 WHY DO PEOPLE SPEED?

Various programmes have been implemented by the Government to reduce road

accidents such as “Ops Pacak”, “Ops Sikap” and “Ops Statistik”. But many accidents

are still occurring. According to the Minister of Transportation, Dato‟ Seri Kong Cho

Ha, the situation on the road is very pathetic. This is because the Government has spent

nearly RM 9 billion into various safety campaigns. Reminder “Berhati-hati di Jalan

Raya”, “Patuhi Had Laju”, “Kelajuan Membunuh”, and the slogan “Pandu, Tunggang

dan Jalan dengan Selamat” as well as “Anda Mampu Mengubahnya” stimulates the

mind of road users to be careful while driving on the road. But in reality, road users in

Malaysia are still careless, negligent and forgetful though they are provided richly with

commemorative boards and slogans along the way.

Speeding can be related with driving with excessive speed limit. Speeding is the

main contributor to the crash with 12% from the total crash and 28% from the total fatal

crash (Mosedale et al., 2004). Nowadays speeding is considered as a normal matter on

the road. This is because too many news were exposed by mass media about speeding

car that ended up with crash. An example could be demonstrated by the current news

about the crash between Myvi cars and Pajero sport car. That crash is a result because

the Myvi cars speeding and causes 3 people dead (Fardy Bungga, Harian Metro, Mei

2015).

There are some factors why do people speed, such as they like to drive fast, they

are in bad mood, and they do not realize that they were speeding as well as they were

being selfish and impatient. Based on the research by INRETS (2004), they stated that

the thrill and achievement can be felt by driving fast. Some drivers feel that by driving

fast, they can feel more satisfaction. Usually, young drivers are more likely to speed

because of the age factor. In 2002 at Australia, 80 percent of young drivers died in

motor vehicle crash (Australian Transport Safety Bureau, 2003). Other than that, based

on research by Thoma (1993), drivers could not estimate the proper speed limit when

driving with the inappropriate speed limit and they cannot predict that the risk during

raining can lead to road crash.

Page 24: THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN DRIVER‟S BACKGROUND AND …umpir.ump.edu.my/13057/1/FKASA - NURUL FARHANA NASARRUDIN - CD 6674... · Hasil dari kekerapan kumulatif berdasarkan kelajuan

12

2.5 SPEED PREFERENCES

Speed preferences are speed that drivers prefer to use on the road or highway.

Driver‟s speed preferences or driver‟s speed choice means the driver‟s decision to travel

at a selected rate of motion (Ahie, 2014). In other word, speed preferences are the speed

where the drivers will decide to use for their ride. Driving speed preferences is an

important issue in traffic research (Haglund & Aburg, 2002). It is because the

relationship between greater risks and severe consequences when an accident occurs is

the reason for the need of studying speed preferences. Speed may be further constrained

by the drivers themselves in choosing to drive at any speed they consider safe and

comfortable (Kenallaidis, 1995)

There are a few different reasons for driver‟s speed preferences when driving

such as money saving on fuel, driving safety, driving for fun or casual driving. Other

than that, based on the research by Haglund (2011), speed preferences is one of the

characteristics of driver‟s behaviour. The driver will choose the speed that they find

appropriate during the driving. Higher speed tends to cause accidents because

sometimes the speed choice is not suitable for use. Therefore, the driver‟s judgement

about appropriate speed is important for the speed preferences.

Based on research conducted by Ahie et al. (2015) there is a huge difference

between the speed preferences for the purpose of different driving. The highest speed

could occur when a driver is driving for fun and the lowest speed is chosen when the

goal is for economical purpose. Furthermore, every driver has different speed choice,

such as the case when a driver thought that their usual speed is based on the safe speed

that they believed. For example, a driver would not speed if they find it dangerous in

doing so because their feeling of risk would lead them to be moderate in choosing the

speed. Other drivers also indicated that they usually drive even slower than the speed

that they thought was safe. So, it shows that the usual speed utilized was influenced by

the driver‟s speed choices.