The Problem of Search Engines as Essential Facilities (Geoffrey A. Manne)

THE NEXT DIGITAL DECADEESSAYS ON THE FUTURE OF THE INTERNET

Edited by Berin Szoka & Adam Marcus

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

!

THE NEXT DIGITAL DECADE ESSAYS ON THE FUTURE OF THE INTERNET

!Edited by Berin Szoka & Adam Marcus

!

NextDigitalDecade.com

TechFreedom

techfreedom.org Washington, D.C.

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

THE NEXT DIGITAL DECADE: ESSAYS ON THE FUTURE OF THE INTERNET 419

The Problem of Search Engines as Essential Facilities: An Economic & Legal Assessment By Geoffrey A. Manne* !"#$% &'% ()*+,% (&$"% -#..'% /*)% '0#)-"% +01$)#.&$23% 0'40-&#..2% $"*'0% )**$05% &+% $"0%+*$&*+%*/%6+$0)+0$%'0#)-"% 7*)3%8*)0%#--1)#$0.23%9**,.03% $"0%4*.&-2%'-*.5':%;<$0%+*&)% */% $"0% 5#2=% #'% #+% >0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$23?% #+5% +0-0''&$#$&+,% ,*@0)+80+$A8#+5#$05% #--0''B% % C'% *$"0)'% "#@0% +*$053% $"0% ;#'&-% -*+-04$% */% +01$)#.&$2% &+%'0#)-"%&'3%#$%)**$3%/#)-&-#.DE%%F"0%&50#%$"#$%#%'0#)-"%0+,&+03%("&-"%*//0)'%&$'%1'0)'%05&$05% #--0''% $*% $"0% 8*'$% )0.0@#+$% (0;'&$0'% ;#'05% *+% $"0% '0#)-"% 0+,&+0:'%#''0''80+$%*/%$"0%1'0):'%&+$0+$3G%'"*1.5%5*%'*%>+01$)#..2?%&84.&0'%$"#$%$"0%'0#)-"%0+,&+0:'% 0//*)$'% $*% 0+'1)0% )0.0@#+-0% '"*1.5% ;0% -#;&+05% ;2% #+% #.8*'$A.&8&$.0''%)#+,0%*/%#+-&..#)2%-*+-0)+'DH%%%

I0@0)$"0.0''3%4)*4*+0+$'%*/%$"&'%@&0(%"#@0%;0,1+%$*%#551-0%&+-)0#'&+,.2%50$#&.A.#50+% #+5% -*84.0J% #),180+$'% &+% /#@*)% */% $"0&)% 4*'&$&*+'3% #+5% $"0% K1)*40#+%L*88&''&*+% "#'% 0@0+% *40+05% #% /*)8#.% &+@0'$&,#$&*+% &+$*%9**,.0:'% 4)#-$&-0'3%;#'05%.#),0.2%*+%@#)&*1'%-.#&8'%$"#$%&$%"#'%'2'$08#$&-#..2%50+&05%#--0''%$*%&$'%$*4%'0#)-"% )0'1.$'% 7&+% '*80% -#'0'% 4#&5% )0'1.$'3% &+% *$"0)'% *),#+&-% )0'1.$'=% ;2%-*840$&+,%'0)@&-0'3M%0'40-&#..2%@0)$&-#.%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'DN% %F*%82%O+*(.05,03%+*%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%P% KJ0-1$&@0%Q&)0-$*)3%6+$0)+#$&*+#.%L0+$0)%/*)%R#(%S%K-*+*8&-'%#+5%R0-$1)0)%&+%R#(3%R0(&'%

S%L.#)O%R#(%T-"**.D%%!!!"#$!%&'(&%()%*"'*+U%!!!"#&#$*,"%-./#$!/0$&.#)1/+%'00*%123$((%D%

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

G% C%)08#)O#;.0%/0#$3%,&@0+%$"#$%$"&'%&+$0+$%81'$%;0%&+/0))05%/)*8%'&84.03%-*+$0J$A.0''%'0#)-"%$0)8'D%

H% \0)/0-$.2%508*+'$)#$05%;2%])#+O%\#'^1#.0:'%-#..3%0.'0("0)0%&+%$"&'%@*.1803%/*)%&50+$&/2&+,%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'%#'%>0''0+$&#.%-1.$1)#.%#+5%4*.&$&-#.%/#-&.&$&0'3?%$"0)0;2%8#+5#$&+,%&+-*)4*)#$&*+%&+$*%$"0&)%'$)1-$1)0%("#$0@0)%>-1.$1)#.?%#+5%>4*.&$&-#.?%4)0/0)0+-0'%#+2%'1//&-&0+$.2A&+/.10+$&#.%4*.&$&-&#+%7*)%.#(%4)*/0''*)'=%"#440+'%$*%5008%#44)*4)&#$0D%

M% L*840$&+,%'0)@&-0'%&+-.1503%/*)%0J#84.03%_#4`10'$%7!!!"3$5A.%7)"&'3=%7-*840$&+,%(&$"%9**,.0%_#4'=3%a0*"%7!!!";%'4"&'3=%7-*840$&+,%(&$"%Y*1%F1;0=%#+5%b&+,%T"*44&+,%7!!!":8(+"&'3/74'558(+=%7-*840$&+,%(&$"%9**,.0%\)*51-$'=D%

N% a0)$&-#.%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'%#)0%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'%$"#$%/*-1'%*+%#%4#)$&-1.#)%-#$0,*)2%*/ %4)*51-$'3%*)%*+%#%4#)$&-1.#)%$240%*/ %'0#)-"D%%KJ#84.0'%&+-.150%c#2#O%7!!!",$1$,"&'3=%7$)#@0.%'0#)-"=3%

420 CHAPTER 7: IS SEARCH NOW AN “ESSENTIAL FACILITY?”

*+0% "#'% 20$% -.#&805% $"#$% 9**,.0% '"*1.5% *//0)% 14% .&+O'% $*% -*840$&+,% ,0+0)#.%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'%#'%#%)08052%/*)%&$'%40)-0&@05%8#)O0$%/*)0-.*'1)03%;1$%_&-)*'*/$:'%0J40)&0+-0%(&$"%$"0%>b)*('0)%L"*&-0%T-)00+?% &$% %"#'%+*(%#,)005%$*%*//0)%#'%#%-*+'0^10+-0% */% $"0% K1)*40#+% L*88&''&*+:'% '1--0''/1.% -*840$&$&*+% -#'0%#,#&+'$%$"0%-*84#+2%&'%+*$%0+-*1)#,&+,Dd%%F"0'0%8*)0%'140)/&-&#..2%'*4"&'$&-#$05%-.#&8'%#)0% )**$05% &+% $"0%+*$&*+%*/% 6+$0)+0$% '0#)-"%#'% #+%>0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$2?e#%;*$$.0+0-O%.&8&$&+,%0//0-$&@0%-*840$&$&*+D%%%

F"0'0%-.#&8'3%#'%(0..%#'% $"0%8*)0%/1+5#80+$#.%"#)8A$*A-*840$&$*)%-.#&8'3%#)0%5&//&-1.$%$*%'1'$#&+%*+%#+2%0-*+*8&-#..2A)0#'*+#;.0%,)*1+5'D%%F*%1+50)'$#+5%$"&'%)0^1&)0'% '*80% ;#'&-% 1+50)'$#+5&+,% */% $"0% 0-*+*8&-'% */% 0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$&0'3% */%6+$0)+0$% '0#)-"3% #+5%*/% $"0% )0.0@#+$%4)*51-$%8#)O0$'% &+%("&-"% 6+$0)+0$% '0#)-"%*40)#$0'D%

The Basic Law & Economics of Essential Facilities F"0)0% #)0% $(*% (#2'% $*% 50#.% (&$"% #% 4)*;.08#$&-% ;*$$.0+0-Of% % V08*@0% $"0%;*$$.0+0-O% *)% )0,1.#$0% #--0''% $*% &$D% % F"0% .#$$0)% &'% $"0% 8*)0% -*88*+% -*1)'0%#5*4$05% &+% $"0% gDTD% #+5% 0.'0("0)0D% % L*84.0J3% b2h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iid%*/% $"0%8*+'$)*1'%F0.0-*881+&-#$&*+'%C-$=% &+% $"0%gDTD% #)0%4#)#5&,8#$&-%0J#84.0'% */% $"0'0% -*'$.2% 0//0-$'3% #+5% &$% &'% -0)$#&+.2% ^10'$&*+#;.0% ("0$"0)% $"0%5&'0#'0%&'%(*)'0%$"#+%$"0%-1)0Dj%%%

k;@&*1'.23% #+% 0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$2% 81'$% ;0% "88"*1.90D% % K//*)$'% *@0)% $"0% 20#)'% $*%'"*0"*)+%@#)&*1'%8#)O0$'%&+$*%$"&'%-#$0,*)2%"#@0%'*80$&80'%'$)#&+05%-)051.&$23%#'%&$%"#'%@#)&*1'.2%;00+%-.#&805%$"#$%C'40+3%L*.*)#5*%'O&%"&..'3l%.*-#.%@*&-0%8#&.%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

T*1)-0F**.%7!!!"7'.*&%)''#"&'3=%7;1'&+0''%&+41$%'*1)-&+,=3%#+5%]*1+508%7!!!"0'.(-%3"&'3=%7)0$#&.%4)*51-$%'0#)-"%#+5%4)&-0%-*84#)&'*+=D%

d% !""%K1)*40#+%L*88&''&*+3%?"/$/,5@8",$+(5.+"$65,$>2,53"9*$+5*82A",83%4))56//%&"%.*'5$"%./&'35%)8)8'(/&'(7.3%*7/!%:2:*'!7%*72&4'8&%2%("4)3#%7.#'$%#--0''05%Q0-D%l3%GmEm=D%%%

j% k)0+%b)#-"#%#+5%])#+O%\#'^1#.0:'%-#..%/*)%#%>]050)#.%T0#)-"%L*88&''&*+?%8*50.05%*+%$"0%]050)#.%F)#50%L*88&''&*+%&'%&+%/#-$%%#+%"A/,9+"%*/ %$"0%+005%/*)%#%;1)0#1-)#$&-%#44#)#$1'%$*%)0,1.#$0%$"0%/*)-05%#--0''%-#..05%/*)%;2%'0#)-"%+01$)#.&$2%4)*4*+0+$'D%%%!""%k)0+%b)#-"#%#+5%])#+O%\#'^1#.03%B"-",90$!"9,+($C5AA.88.5*D$B9.,*"88#$;++"88#$9*-$;++52*19/.0.14$.*$1("$<9@$56 $!"9,+(3%iH%LkVIKRR%RD%VKaD%EEiH%7Gmml=D%

l% C'40+%W&,".#+5'%TO&&+,%L*)4D%@D%C'40+%TO&&+,%L*D3%jHl%]DG5%ENmi%7Em$"%L&)D%EilM=3%#// :5%*+%*$"0)%,)*1+5'3%MjG%gDTD%NlN%7EilN=D%


'0)@&-0'3i% '*/$% 5)&+O'Em% #+5% 5&)0-$% /)0&,"$% /.&,"$'% ;0$(00+% I0(% Y*)O% #+5% T#+%[1#+EE% 7#8*+,% 8#+2% *$"0)% $"&+,'=% (0)0% 0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$&0'% +0-0''&$#$&+,%8#+5#$05% #--0''% 1+50)% $"0% #+$&$)1'$% .#('DEG% % 6+% $"0'0% #+5% 8#+2% *$"0)% -#'0'3%82)&#5%#.$0)+#$&@0'%$*%$"0%#..0,05.2A8*+*4*.&h05%8#)O0$%0J&'$%#+5%&$%&'%#),1#;.0%$"#$%$"0)0%(#'%+*$"&+,%("#$'*0@0)%>0''0+$&#.?%#;*1$%$"0'0%8#)O0$'D%%

6+% #+$&$)1'$% .&$0)#$1)0% #+5% X1)&'4)150+-03% #% 4.#&+$&//% (*1.5% +005% $*% 4)*@0% $"0%/*..*(&+,% $*% 4)0@#&.% &+% #%8*+*4*.&h#$&*+% -#'0% )**$05% &+% $"0% 0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$&0'%5*-$)&+0f%

ED L*+$)*.%*/%$"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$2%;2%#%8*+*4*.&'$U%%

GD C% -*840$&$*):'% &+#;&.&$2% 4)#-$&-#..2% *)% )0#'*+#;.2% $*% 514.&-#$0% $"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$2U%%

HD F"0%50+&#.%*/%$"0%1'0%*/%$"0%/#-&.&$2%$*%#%-*840$&$*)U%#+5%%

MD F"0%/0#'&;&.&$2%*/%4)*@&5&+,%$"0%/#-&.&$2%$*%-*840$&$*)'DEH%%%

C),1#;.23% '&+-0% $"0% T14)080%L*1)$:'% GmmM%',.*=5% 50-&'&*+3EM% #% 4.#&+$&//%(*1.5%#.'*% +005% $*% 508*+'$)#$0% $"0% #;'0+-0% */% /050)#.% )0,1.#$&*+% ,*@0)+&+,% #--0''D%%F"0% ',.*=5% 50-&'&*+% '&,+&/&-#+$.2% -&)-18'-)&;05% $"0% #)0#% '1;X0-$% $*% 0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'% #),180+$'3% .&8&$&+,% '1-"% -.#&8'% $*% &+'$#+-0'% ("0)03% #'% &+% $"0%;83"*$!=..*&% -#'03% #% -*840$&$*)% )0/1'0'% $*% 50#.% *+% )0#'*+#;.0% $0)8'% (&$"% #+*$"0)%-*840$&$*)%(&$"%("*8%&$%"#'3%&+%/#-$3%50#.$%&+%$"0%4#'$DEN%%%

C%O02%4)*;.08%(&$"%8#+2%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%-#'0'%&'%$"0%+*+A0''0+$&#.&$2%*/%$"0%)0.0@#+$% /#-&.&$2D% %!"&.0% $"0)0% -#+% ;0% +*% 5*1;$% $"#$% $*% 4#)$&-1.#)% -*840$&$*)'3%4#)$&-1.#).2% $"*'0% -*+'$)#&+05% $*% *+.2% *+0% #@0+10% */% #--0''% $*% -*+'180)'% ;2%,0*,)#4"2% *)% +#$1)#.% 8*+*4*.23% #% /#-&.&$2% 8#2% &+5005% '008% 0''0+$&#.3% $"0%$*1-"'$*+0% */% gDTD% #+$&$)1'$% .#(% "#'% .*+,% ;00+% -*+'180)3% +*$% -*840$&$*)3%(0./#)0D%%T*%("&.03%&+50053%C'40+%W&,".#+5'%8#2%"#@0%"#5%5&//&-1.$2%-*840$&+,%(&$"%$"0%C'40+%TO&%L*84#+2%/*)%-*+'180)'%("*%"#5%#.)0#52%-"*'0+%$*%'O&% &+%C'40+3% -*+'180)'% +*+0$"0.0''% "#5% 1+/0$$0)05% #--0''% $*% #% (&50% )#+,0% */%#.$0)+#$&@0%'O&%7#+5%*$"0)%@#-#$&*+=%50'$&+#$&*+'3%'1-"%$"#$%$"0%.&O0.&"**5%*/%$"0%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%i% LFL%L*881+&-#$&*+'%L*)4D%@D%b0..%C$.#+$&-%L*)4D3%jj%]D%T144D%G5%EGM%7QD%_0D%Eiii=D%Em% T1+%Q1+%@D%L*-#AL*.#%L*D3%jMm%]D%T144D%HlE%7QD%_5D%Eiim=D%EE% L0+$1)2%C&)%])0&,"$3%6+-D%@D%C80)&-#+%C&).&+0'3%6+-D3%Nij%]D%T144D%NdM%7TDQDIDYD%EilM=D%EG% ]*)%#%8*)0%-*84.0$0%.&'$%*/ %0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%7#+5%#$$084$05%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'=%-#'0'3%#'%

(0..%#'%#+%&84*)$#+$%$)0#$80+$%*/ %$"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%5*-$)&+0%&+%gT%#+$&$)1'$%.#(3%'00%C;;*$$%bD%R&4'O23%[)D%S%[D%9)0,*)2%T&5#O3%>88"*1.90$B9+.0.1."83%NE%TFCID%RD%VKaD%EElj%7Eiii=D%

EH% _L6%L*88:+'%L*)4D%@D%C80)&-#+%F0.D%S%F0.D%L*D3%jml%]DG5%EmlE%7j$"%L&)D%EilG=D%EM% a0)&h*+%L*88:+'D%@D%R#(%k//&-0'%*/ %L1)$&'%aD%F)&+O*%RR\3%NMm%gDTD%Hil%7GmmM=D%EN% !""3%0D,D3%\W6RR6\%KD%CVKKQC%S%WKVbKVF%WkaKIcC_\3%CIF6FVgTF%RC!%7GmmM%'144D=%#$%EiiD%


8*+*4*.&h#$&*+% */% C'40+:'% 'O&% "&..'% #//0-$&+,% *@0)#..% -*+'180)% (0./#)0% (#'%0''0+$&#..2%+*+A0J&'$0+$DEd%%6+%'1-"%#%-&)-18'$#+-03%'"*1.5%&$%8#$$0)%&/%#%4#)$&-1.#)%-*840$&$*)% &'%"#)805B% % 6'% $"#$%#% /1+-$&*+%*/%#+$&$)1'$A)0.0@#+$%-*+51-$%*+% $"0%4#)$%*/%#+*$"0)%/&)83%*)%#+%1+/*)$1+#$0%'0$%*/%;1'&+0''%50-&'&*+'%*+%$"0%4#)$%*/%$"0%/&)'$%/&)8B%

C'%\"&..&4%C)005#%#+5%W0);0)$%W*@0+O#84%"#@0%/#8*1'.2%'#&5%*/%$"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'% 5*-$)&+03% >n&$o% &'% ;*$"% "#)8/1.% #+5% 1++0-0''#)2% #+5% '"*1.5% ;0%#;#+5*+05D?Ej%C'%#+*$"0)%#+$&$)1'$%0J40)$%"#'%50'-)&;05%&$f%

C$%;*$$*83% #%4.#&+$&//%8#O&+,%#+%0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$&0'%#),180+$% &'% '#2&+,%$"#$% $"0% 50/0+5#+$% "#'% #% @#.1#;.0% /#-&.&$2% $"#$% &$%(*1.5% ;0% 5&//&-1.$% $*%)04)*51-03%#+5%'1,,0'$&+,%$"#$%&'%#%)0#'*+%/*)%#%-*1)$%$*%&+$0)@0+0%#+5%&84*'0%#%'"#)&+,%51$2D%b1$%#$%.0#'$%&+%$"0%@#'$%8#X*)&$2%*/%$"0%-#'0'3%$"0%/#-$% $"#$% $"0%50/0+5#+$%"#'% #%"&,".2%@#.105% /#-&.&$2% &'% #% )0#'*+% $*% ,"E"+1$'"#)&+,3%+*$%$*%,"F2.,"$&$3%'&+-0%/*)-05%'"#)&+,%>8#2%.0''0+%$"0%&+-0+$&@0%/*)% $"0%8*+*4*.&'$3% $"0% )&@#.3% *)%;*$"% $*% &+@0'$% &+% $"*'0% 0-*+*8&-#..2%;0+0/&-&#.%/#-&.&$&0'D?El%%

F"&'%40)0++&#.%4)*;.08e#+$&$)1'$%.#('%;0&+,%1'05%$*%4)*$0-$%-*840$&$*)'%)#$"0)%$"#+%-*+'180)'e.&0'%#$% $"0%"0#)$%*/%-.#&8'%'1))*1+5&+,%6+$0)+0$%'0#)-"%#'%#+%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$2D%

F"0)0%&'%81-"%$&05%14%&+%$"0%#),180+$3%#+5%4)*4*+0+$'%"#@0%*/$0+%;00+%-#)0/1.%$*% #$% .0#'$% ,*% $")*1,"% $"0% 8*$&*+'% */% 5)#(&+,% $"0% )"0$*)&-#.% .&+0% ;#-O% $*%-*+'180)'D%%6+%&$'%/1..0'$%0J4)0''&*+3%&$%&'%-.#&805%$"#$%"#)8%$*%-*840$&$*)'%+*(%(&..%80#+% $"0% #;'0+-0% */% -*840$&$*)'% .#$0)% #+5% $"1'% #+% 1+/0$$0)05%8*+*4*.2%(&$"% $"0% &+$0+$% #+5% 4*(0)% $*% "#)8% -*+'180)'DEi% % 6$% &'% #.'*% */$0+% #),105% $"#$%-*+'180)'% 7&+% $"&'% -#'0% 6+$0)+0$% 1'0)'% '0#)-"&+,% /*)% -0)$#&+% (0;'&$0'% *)% $"0%4)*51-$'%$"02%'0..=%#)0%&+$)&+'&-#..2%"#)805%;2%$"0%1+#@#&.#;&.&$2%*/%#--0''%$*%$"0%&+/*)8#$&*+% -*+$#&+05% &+% '&$0'% $"#$% #)0% 50+&05% #--0''% $*% $"0% '0#)-"% 0+,&+0:'%>0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$2D?Gm%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Ed% F"0%-*1)$'3%"*(0@0)3%5&5%+*$%#,)00D%Ej% HC%CVKKQC%S%WkaKIcC_\3%CIF6FVgTF%RC!%p%jjE-3%#$%EjH%7GmmG=D%El% VD%W0(&$$%\#$03%G"628908$15$H"90$9*-$>88"*1.90$B9+.0.1."83%F0'$&8*+2%T1;8&$$05%$*%Qk[q]FL%

W0#)&+,'%*+%T&+,.0%]&)8%L*+51-$3%[1.D%El3%Gmmd3%979.09/0"$91$4))56//!!!"B.7)8&%"+';/$)*/5.:#8&/4%$*8(+7/78(+#%208*3/-'&7/>C@?DE"4)3%7^1*$&+,%',.*=53%NMm%gDTDD%#$%Mml=D$$%

Ei% !""#$"%&%#%>2,53"9*$C5AA.88.5*$<92*+("8$;*1.1,281$)*7"81.&91.5*$56 $:55&0"3%TKCVLW%IKgFVCR6FYDkV93%I*@D%Hm3%GmEm3%4))56//!!!"7%$*&4(%.)*$#8)1"'*+%7>9**,.0%&'%0J4.*&$&+,%&$'%5*8&+#+-0%*/ %'0#)-"%&+%(#2'%$"#$%'$&/.0%&++*@#$&*+3%'144)0''%-*840$&$&*+3%#+5%0)*50%-*+'180)%-"*&-0D?=D%%_0#+("&.03%-*84.#&+#+$'%"#@0%,*+0%$*%K1)*40%("0)0%#%'"*(&+,%*/ %-*+'180)%"#)8%&'%+*$%+0-0''#)2%$*%4)0@#&.%1+50)%&$'%-*840$&$&*+%.#('D%

Gm% C'%k)0+%b)#-"#%#+5%])#+O%\#'^1#.0%41$%&$3%>T0#)-"%0+,&+0'3%&+%*$"0)%(*)5'3%*/$0+%/1+-$&*+%+*$%#'%80)0%'#$&'/&0)'%*/ %4)050$0)8&+05%4)0/0)0+-0'3%;1$%#'%'"#40)'%*/ %4)0/0)0+-0'3?%B"-",90$!"9,+($C5AA.88.5*3%iH%LkVIKRR%RD%VKaD%#$%EElND%%b)#-"#%#+5%\#'^1#.0%#.'*%-.#&8%$"#$%>_#)O0$%4#)$&-&4#+$'%+005%&+/*)8#$&*+%#;*1$%4)*51-$'%#+5%'0)@&-0'%$*%8#O0%&+/*)805%0-*+*8&-%


F"0%;#'&-%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%-#'0%#,#&+'$%9**,.0%&'%$"#$%&$%-*+$)*.'%#%;*$$.0+0-O%/*)%$"0%6+$0)+0$e&$%&'%$"0%#--0''%4*&+$%/*)%8*'$%-*+'180)'3%#+5%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%*+% 9**,.0% 50$0)8&+0% ("&-"% (0;'&$0'% #)0% '1--0''/1.% #+5% ("&-"% 0+5% 14% &+%*;.&@&*+DGE%%_*)0%4#)$&-1.#).23%&$%&'%#),105%$"#$%9**,.0%"#'%1'05%&$'%-*+$)*.%*@0)%$"&'%;*$$.0+0-O%$*%50+2%#--0''%;2%-*840$&$*)'%$*%9**,.0:'%1'0)'D%%F*%1+50)'$#+5%$"&'%)0^1&)0'%#%;)&0/%5&'-1''&*+%*/%$"0%0-*+*8&-'%)0.0@#+$%$*%6+$0)+0$%T0#)-"%#+5%&$'%)0.0@#+$%8#)O0$D%

The Basic Economics of Internet Search 684.&-&$% &+% -.#&8'% $"#$% 9**,.0% -*+$)*.'% #--0''% $*% #+% 0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$2% &'% $"#$%#--0''%;2%'*80%)0.0@#+$%'0$%*/%-*+'180)'%7*)%-*840$&$*)'=%$*%)0.0@#+$%-*+$0+$%&'%#--0''&;.0% *+.2% 7*)% @&)$1#..2% *+.2=% $")*1,"% 9**,.0D% % 6$% &'% +0-0''#)23% $"0+3% $*%#''0''% ("0$"0)% 9**,.0:'% '0#)-"% )0'1.$'% 4#,0'% #)03% &+% /#-$3% (&$"*1$% '&,+&/&-#+$%-*840$&$&*+%/*)% $"0%0-*+*8&-%#-$&@&$2%#$% $"0&)%"0#)$D% %k/%-*1)'0% $"0%0-*+*8&-%#-$&@&$2%#$%$"0&)%"0#)$%&'%#5@0)$&'&+,DGG%

6$% &'% "#)5% $*% -*+-0&@0% */% 6+$0)+0$% '0#)-"e.0$% #.*+0%9**,.0:'%(0;'&$0e#'% $"0%*+.2% 80#+'% */% )051-&+,% '0#)-"% -*'$'% /*)% 4*$0+$&#.% -*+'180)'% 76+$0)+0$%'0#)-"0)'=% #+5% 4)*'40-$&@0% '0..0)'D% % R0#@&+,% #'&50% $"0% &+-)05&;.0% )#+,0% */%#.$0)+#$&@0%'*1)-0'%$*%$"0%6+$0)+0$%/*)%-*880)-03GH%*//%$"0%$*4%*/%82%"0#53%6%-#+%&8#,&+0%9**,.0:'%-*840$&$*)%(0;'&$0'%/&+5&+,%#--0''%$*%1'0)'%;2%E=%#5@0)$&'&+,%&+%4)&+$%41;.&-#$&*+'%#+5%FaU%G=%1'&+,%'*-&#.%+0$(*)O&+,%'&$0'%$*%4)*8*$0%$"0&)%'&$0'3%H=%;0&+,% .&+O05% $*%;2%*$"0)%(0;'&$0'% &+-.15&+,% '&$0'% '40-&#.&h&+,% &+% )#$&+,%(0;'&$0'3%*+.&+0%8#,#h&+0'3% )0@&0(%'&$0'3%#+5%$"0% .&O0U%M=% &84.080+$&+,%#//&.&#$0%4)*,)#8'%*)%*$"0)%-)0#$&@0%8#)O0$&+,%'-"080'U%N=%41)-"#'&+,%4#&5%#5@0)$&'&+,3%;*$"%&+%9**,.0:'%*(+%4#&5%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'3%#'%(0..%#'%*+%*$"0)3%"0#@&.2A$)#//&-O05%(0;'&$0'U% #+5% d=% '0-1)&+,% #--0''% @&#%9**,.0:'% ,0+0)#.% '0#)-"% -*840$&$*)'% .&O0%Y#"**r% #+5%b&+,D% L*840$&$*)'% 50+&05% #--0''% $*% $"0% $*4% /0(% '0#)-"% )0'1.$'% #$%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%50-&'&*+'D%s%nCo#$$#&+&+,%@&'&;&.&$2%#+5%#--0''%$*%1'0)'%&'%-)&$&-#.%$*%-*840$&$&*+%#+5%-**40)#$&*+%*+.&+0D%%L0+$)#.&h05%-*+$)*.%*)%8#+&41.#$&*+%;2%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'%8#2%'$&/.0%&++*@#$&*+%;2%/&)8'%)0.0,#$05%$*%*;'-1)&$2D?%%)-D%#$%EEjHAjMD%

GE% )-D%#$%EEjH%7>L*+-0+$)#$05%-*+$)*.%*@0)%$"0%/.*(%*/ %&+/*)8#$&*+3%-*14.05%(&$"%$"0%#;&.&$2%$*%8#+&41.#$0%$"&'%/.*(3%8#2%)051-0%0-*+*8&-%0//&-&0+-2%;2%'$&/.&+,%-*840$&$&*+D?=D%

GG$ !""%cKI%CgRKFFC3%9kk9RKQf%FWK%KIQ%k]%FWK%!kVRQ%CT%!K%cIk!%6F%Ed%7Gmmi=%7^1*$&+,%9**,.0%LKk%K)&-%T-"8&5$%#'%'#2&+,3%>!0%#)0%&+%$"0%#5@0)$&'&+,%;1'&+0''?=D%

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q*//.&+0%;1'&+0''%50-&'&*+%/)*8%$"0%"0#.$"2%0//0-$'%*/ %T-"1840$0):'%>40)0++&#.%,#.0%*/ %-)0#$&@0%50'$)1-$&*+D?%[kTK\W%TLWg_\KFKV3%FWK%\VkLKTT%k]%LVKCF6aK%QKTFVgLF6kI%7EiMG=D%


9**,.0:'%'&$0%#)0%'$&..%#;.0%$*%#5@0)$&'0%$"0&)%0J&'$0+-0%#+5%#$$)#-$%1'0)'%$")*1,"%#%(&50%)#+,0%*/%*$"0)%#5@0)$&'&+,%*1$.0$'e0J$)080.2%(&503% &+%/#-$f%C--*)5&+,% $*%*+0% 0'$&8#$0% 9**,.0% (#'% )0'4*+'&;.0% &+% Gmmj% /*)% *+.2% #;*1$% jDNt% */% $"0%(*).5:'%#5@0)$&'&+,DGM%%%

]*)%9**,.0% $*% 4)*/&$% /)*8% &$'% ;1'&+0''e("0$"0)% #'% #%8*+*4*.&'$% *)% +*$e&$%81'$%50.&@0)%14%$*%&$'%#5@0)$&'0)'%#%'0$%*/%1'0)'D%%6+$0)0'$&+,.23%1'0)'%*/%9**,.0:'%,0+0)#.% '0#)-"% 0+,&+0% #)0% 8*'$.2% 1+&+$0)0'$05% &+% $"0% 4#&5% )0'1.$'D% F"02% -.&-O%$")*1,"%$"0%1+4#&5%*)%>*),#+&-?%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%;2%#%(&50%8#),&+%#"0#5%*/%4#&5%)0'1.$'DGN% % F"0)0% &'% $"1'% #+% #'2880$)2D% % k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

b1$%$"0)0%#)0%4)*;.08'%&+"0)0+$%&+%$"0%#8;&,1&$2%*/%'0#)-"%$0)8'%#+5%$"0%#;&.&$2%$*%>,#80%$"0%'2'$08?%$"#$%4)0@0+$%0@0+%$"0%8*'$%'*4"&'$&-#$05%#.,*)&$"8'%/)*8%*//0)&+,%14%40)/0-$%)0.0@#+-0D% %]&)'$3%'0#)-"%$0)8'%#)0%*/$0+%-*+$0J$A.0''3%#+5%#%1'0)% '0#)-"&+,% /*)% >X#,1#)?% 8#2% ;0% '0#)-"&+,% /*)% &+/*)8#$&*+% *+% $"0% -#)%-*84#+23% $"0% *40)#$&+,% '2'$083% $"0% ;&,% -#$3% *)% '*80$"&+,% 0.'0DGd% % C.*+,% #%5&//0)0+$%5&80+'&*+3%#%1'0)%'0#)-"&+,%/*)%>I&O*+%-#80)#?%8&,"$%;0%.**O&+,%$*%/24%#%I&O*+%-#80)#%*)%8&,"$%;0%.**O&+,%/*)%#%3.+12,"%*/%#%I&O*+%-#80)#%$*%4*'$%*+%"&'%;.*,D% %k;@&*1'.2%#5@0)$&'0)'%-#)0%@0)2%81-"%("&-"%*/%$"0'0%1'0)'%-.&-O'%*+%$"0&)%4#&5%)0'1.$D% %C$% $"0%'#80%$&803%8#+2%1+50'&)#;.0%(0;'&$0'% 7'4#8%'&$0'%#+5%$"0%.&O0=%-#+%#+5%5*%$#O0%#5@#+$#,0%*/%4)05&-$#;.0%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%$*%*--142%50'&)#;.0%'0#)-"%)0'1.$%)0#.%0'$#$0%$*%$"0%50$)&80+$%*/%$"0%'0#)-"%0+,&+03%&$'%1'0)'%#+5% &$'% #5@0)$&'0)'D% % K//*)$'% $*% O004% $"0'0% '&$0'% *1$% */% $"0% $*4% )0'1.$'% #+5% $*%0+'1)0% 8#J&818% )0.0@#+-0% /)*8% #8;&,1*1'% '0#)-"% $0)8'% )0^1&)0% #% "*'$% */%#.,*)&$"8%$(0#O'%#+5%0@0+%"18#+%&+$0)@0+$&*+'D%%F"#$%$"0'0%8#2%7&+$0+$&*+#..2%*)%&+#5@0)$0+$.2=%"#)8%'*80%(0;'&$0':%)#+O%&+%-0)$#&+%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%&'%-*+'&'$0+$%(&$"%#%(0..A/1+-$&*+&+,%'0#)-"%4.#$/*)8D%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%GM% !""%K)&-O%T-"*+/0.53%>81.A91"8$I21$)*1",*"1$;-7",1.8.*&$91$JKL$M.00.5*$.*$N%!%#$JOP$M.00.5*$:05/90043%

FKLWLVgILW3%]0;D%Gd3%Gmml3%4))56//)%&4&*.(&4"&'3/>FF@/F>/>?/%7)83$)%795.)98()%*(%)9$-;%*)878(+9$)9>C9:8##8'(98(9.79D<9:8##8'(9+#':$##1/D%%

GN% !""#%"%&%3%I0&.%!#.O0)3%:55&0"$Q,&9*.+$C0.+=$'(,52&($G91"$RC'GS3%gc%TKk%LkITgRFCIF3%_#2%EE3%GmEm3%4))56//!!!"7%'3$-"&'3/GHIJ#'+/+''+#%9'*+$(8&9&#8&,9)4*'.+49*$)%9&)*"4)3#D%%%

Gd% !""%b&..%T.#('O&3%;$<55=$91$:55&0"$T.-39&"$U2",4$G"6.*"A"*183%TKk%bY%FWK%TKC3%C4)D%Gm3%Gmmd3%4))56//!!!"7%':1)4%7%$"&'3/K5LC=DD%%%


9**,.0%*//0)'%&$'%*),#+&-%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%#+5%&$'%*$"0)%'0)@&-0'%#'%#%'*.1$&*+%$*%$"0%$(*A'&505% 4.#$/*)8% 4)*;.08% 80+$&*+05% #;*@0f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n$o"0%#+#.2'&'%*/%0&$"0)%'&50%*/%#%$(*A'&505%4.#$/*)8%&+%&'*.#$&*+%2&0.5'%#%5&'$*)$05%4&-$1)0%*/% $"0% ;1'&+0''D?Gj% %F(*A'&505%8#)O0$% 50/&+&$&*+% &'% -*84.0J3%#+5% .&$$.0% 1+50)'$**5e0'40-&#..2% ;2% +*+A0J40)$'% $")*(&+,% #)*1+5% @#)&*1'%#..0,05%8#)O0$'%&+%("&-"%-*84#+&0'%.&O0%9**,.0%#)0%'#&5%$*%;0%>5*8&+#+$D?%%%

F"0)0% &'%#-$1#..2%'1;'$#+$&#.% )0#'*+%$*%5*1;$% $"0%4)*4)&0$2%*/%#%+#))*(%8#)O0$%50/&+&$&*+%.&8&$05%$*%*+.&+0%'0#)-"%#5@0)$&'&+,DGl%%K@0+%("0)0%$"0)0%#)0%5&//0)0+$%41)4*'0'% /*)% 5&//0)0+$% $240'% */% #5@0)$&'&+,e"%&%$;)#+5% )0-*,+&$&*+% /*)% 5&'4.#2%#5'% #+5% 0//*)$'% $*% '0..% /*)% '0#)-"% #5'% #+5% *$"0)% *1$.0$'% .&O0% -*14*+'e$"&'% &'%80)0.2% #% 5&//0)0+-0% &+% 50,)00D% b*$"% #)0% /1+5#80+$#..2% /*)8'% */% )051-&+,% $"0%-*'$'% */% #% 1'0):'% '0#)-"% /*)% #% 4)*51-$3% #'% (0% "#@0% 1+50)'$**5% '&+-0% 90*),0%T$&,.0):'% '08&+#.% (*)O% *+% $"0% '1;X0-$% &+% Eidl3Gi% #+5% $"0% )0.0@#+$% ^10'$&*+% &'%("0$"0)%$"0%5&//0)0+-0% &'%'&,+&/&-#+$%0+*1,"%$*%)0+50)%50-&'&*+'% &+%*+0%8#)O0$%0''0+$&#..2%1+#//0-$05%;2%50-&'&*+'%*)%4)&-0'%&+%$"0%*$"0)D%%

F"0)0% &'% 0@&50+-0% $"#$% #5@0)$&'0)'% @&0(% *+.&+0% #+5% *//.&+0% #5@0)$&'&+,% #'%'1;'$&$1$0'3%#+5%$"&'%#44.&0'%+*$%*+.2%$*%$)#5&$&*+#.%#5@0)$&'0)'%;1$%#.'*%6+$0)+0$%-*84#+&0'D%%F"1'3%&+%Gmmi3%\04'&%50-&505%+*$%$*%#5@0)$&'0%51)&+,%$"0%GmEm%T140)%b*(.3% &+%*)50)%$*%/*-1'% &+'$0#5%*+%#%4#)$&-1.#)%$240%*/%*+.&+0%-#84#&,+D%>F"&'%20#)% /*)% $"0% /&)'$% $&80% &+% GH% 20#)'3% \04'&%(&..% +*$% "#@0% #5'% &+% $"0% T140)%b*(.%$0.0-#'$%sD% % 6+'$0#5% &$% &'% )05&)0-$&+,% $"0%8&..&*+'% &$% "#'% '40+$% #++1#..2% $*% $"0%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Gj% Q#@&5%TD%K@#+'3%'@5V!.-"-$T9,="1$H"6.*.1.5*#%CbC%TKLF6kI%k]%CIF6FVgTF%RC!3%_CVcKF%

QK]6I6F6kI%6I%CIF6FVgTFf%FWKkVY%CIQ%LCTK%TFgQ6KT%7/*)$"-*8&+,=3%#@#&.#;.0%#$%4))56//77*("&'3/$:7)*$&)LCME?=<C%#$%4D%iD%

Gl% V0#50)'%&+$0)0'$05%&+%#%/1..0)%$)0#$80+$%*/ %$"0%8#)O0$%50/&+&$&*+%^10'$&*+%'1))*1+5&+,%9**,.0%#)0%5&)0-$05%$*(#)5%90*//)02%CD%_#++0%S%[*'"1#%QD%!)&,"$3%:55&0"$9*-$1("$<.A.18$56 $;*1.1,281D$'("$C98"$;&9.*81$1("$C98"$;&9.*81$:55&0"3%HM%WCVaD%[D%RD%S%\gbD%\kR:Y%E%7GmEE=%7/*)$"-*8&+,=3%/)*8%("&-"%81-"%*/ %$"0%5&'-1''&*+%*/ %9**,.0:'%8#)O0$'%#+5%0-*+*8&-'%&+%$"&'%0''#2%&'%5)#(+D%

Gi% 9KkV9K%[kTK\W%TF69RKV3%FWK%kV9CI6uCF6kI%k]%6IQgTFVY%GmE%7g+&@D%*/ %L"&D%\)0''%EilH=%7Eidl=D%


6+$0)+0$D?Hm%C+5%0@0+%9**,.0%&$'0./%#5@0)$&'0'%*//.&+0DHE%%C+*$"0)%'$152%'1,,0'$'%$"#$% $"0)0% &'% &+5005% #% $)#50A*//% ;0$(00+% *+.&+0% #+5%8*)0% $)#5&$&*+#.% $240'% */%#5@0)$&'&+,f% C@&5% 9*.5/#);% #+5% L#$"0)&+0% F1-O0)% "#@0% 508*+'$)#$05% $"#$%5&'4.#2%#5@0)$&'&+,%4)&-&+,%&'%'0+'&$&@0%$*%$"0%#@#&.#;&.&$2%*/%*//.&+0%#.$0)+#$&@0'DHG%%C+5%*/%-*1)'0%-*84#+&0'%"#@0%.&8&$05%#5@0)$&'&+,%;15,0$'3%5&'$)&;1$05%#-)*''%#%;)*#5%)#+,0%*/%805&#%#+5%4)*8*$&*+#.%0//*)$'D%C'%*+0%-*880+$#$*)%+*$0'f%>b2%GmEE%(0;%#5@0)$&'&+,%&+%$"0%g+&$05%T$#$0'%(#'%0J40-$05%$*%-.&8;%$*%'&J$2%;&..&*+%5*..#)'3%*)%EH%40)-0+$%*/%#..%#5%5*..#)'D%F"&'%80#+$%8*)0%5*..#)'%'&4"*+05%/)*8%$)#5&$&*+#.%805&#3%(&$"%$"0%.#),0'$%'.&-0%4)*;#;.2%,*&+,%$*%9**,.0D?HH%%

C5@0)$&'&+,% )0@0+10% *+% $"0% 6+$0)+0$% &'% 5)&@0+% &+&$&#..2% ;2% $"0% '&h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b1$%#--0''%$*%020;#..'%-#+%;0%"#5%/)*8%#%.#),0%)#+,0%*/%#--0''%4*&+$'%#)*1+5%$"0%!0;D%%

T*-&#.% 805&#% '&$0'% .&O0% F(&$$0)% #+5% ]#-0;**O% #)0% $"0)0/*)0% '&,+&/&-#+$% #--0''%4*&+$'3%*--142&+,3%#'%$"02%5*3%#%-*+'&50)#;.0%#8*1+$%*/%6+$0)+0$%>020;#..?%$&80D%F"0%\04'&%50@&#$&*+%*/%#5@0)$&'&+,%)0@0+10%/)*8%$"0%T140)%b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

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Hm% R#))2%QD%!**5#)53%I"38.W8$M.&$:9A/0"D$H.1+(.*&$!23",$M5@0$65,$!5+.90$T"-.9#$CbL%IK!T3%Q0-D%GH3%

Gmmi3%4))56//$:&(%!7"+'"&'3/5*8()K8-LEDF><CDD%HE% !""%Q#++2%T1..&@#+3%:55&0"$I28("8$C(,5A"$M,5@8",$X.9$Y"@8393",$;-83%TKCVLW%KI96IK%RCIQ3%

I*@D%GE3%GmEm3%4))56//7%$*&4%(+8(%#$(-"&'3/+''+#%95.74%79&4*'3%9:*'!7%*9;8$9(%!75$5%*9$-79<??FFD%%

HG% C@&%9*.5/#);%S%L#$"0)&+0%F1-O0)3%!"9,+($>*&.*"$;-7",1.8.*&D$I,.+.*&$;-8$15$C5*1"Z1%id%7IKF%6+'$&$1$0%!*)O&+,%\#40)%I*D%mjAGH3%Gmmj=%979.09/0"$91%4))56//5$5%*7"77*("&'3/7'#M/5$5%*7"&03K$:7)*$&)28-LCF>CD<CN*%&LCN7*&$:7LCFF@D%

HH% cKI%CgRKFFC3%9kk9RKQf%FWK%KIQ%k]%FWK%!kVRQ%CT%!K%cIk!%6F%Ed%7Gmmi=D%HM% Q#@&5%TD%K@#+'3%'("$>+5*5A.+8$56 $1("$Q*0.*"$;-7",1.8.*&$)*-281,43%j%VKaD%k]%IKF!kVc%KLkID%

HNi3%HNiAdm%7Gmml=D%HN$ !""$R#))2%QD%!**5#)53%I"38.W8$M.&$:9A/0"D$H.1+(.*&$!23",$M5@0$65,$!5+.90$T"-.9#$CbL%IK!T3%Q0-D%

GH3%Gmmi3%4))56//$:&(%!7"+'"&'3/5*8()K8-LEDF><CDD%


1'0)'% ,*$% 8*)0% */% $"0&)% &+/*)8#$&*+% $")*1,"% n$"0% ]#-0;**Oo% +0$(*)O3% $"0&)%6+$0)+0$%'0#)-"%0+,&+0%#+5%+#@&,#$*)%8&,"$%;0-*80%]#-0;**O3%+*$%9**,.0D?Hd%

F"0% 14'"*$f% % F*% $"0% 0J$0+$% $"#$% &+-.1'&*+% &+% 9**,.0% '0#)-"% )0'1.$'% &'% #;*1$%>T$&,.0)&#+?% '0#)-"A-*'$% )051-$&*+% /*)%(0;'&$0'% 7#+5% &$% -#+% "#)5.2% ;0% #+2$"&+,%0.'0=3%$"0%)#+,0%*/%#.$0)+#$0%/#-&.&$&0'%/*)%$"&'%/1+-$&*+%&'%+0#).2%.&8&$.0''D%

]&+#..23% 9**,.0% -*840$0'% +*$% *+.2% (&$"% *$"0)% ,0+0)#.% '0#)-"% 0+,&+0'% 7#+5%4*''&;.2% #..% *$"0)% /*)8'% */% #5@0)$&'&+,=% ;1$% #.'*%(&$"% '*A-#..05% @0)$&-#.% '0#)-"%0+,&+0'D% F"0'0% #)0% '0#)-"% 0+,&+0'% #+5% 0A-*880)-0% (0;'&$0'% (&$"% '0#)-"%/1+-$&*+#.&$2% $"#$%'40-&#.&h0'% &+%'40-&/&-%-*+$0+$f%C8#h*+%&+%;**O'3%81'&-3%#+5%*$"0)% -*+'180)% ,**5'U% c#2#O% &+% $)#@0.% '0)@&-0'U% 0b#2% &+% -*+'180)% #1-$&*+'U%!0;_Q% &+% 805&-#.% &+/*)8#$&*+% #+5% 4)*51-$'U% T*1)-0F**.% &+% ;1'&+0''A$*A;1'&+0''%'144.&0'U%Y0.4%&+%.*-#.%;1'&+0''0'3%#+5%8#+2%*$"0)'D%F*%$"0%0J$0+$%$"#$%6+$0)+0$% 1'0)'% ;24#''% 9**,.0% #+5% ;0,&+% $"0&)% '0#)-"0'% #$% *+0% */% $"0'0%'40-&#.&h05%'&$0'%7#'%&'%&+-)0#'&+,.2%$"0%-#'0=3%$"0%@#.10%$*%$"0'0%"0#@&.2A$)#//&-O05%(0;'&$0'%/)*8%#--0''%$*%9**,.0:'%1'0)'%50-)0#'0'DHj%%

L*840$&$&*+%/)*8%@0)$&-#.%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'%&'%&84*)$#+$%;0-#1'0%#5%-.&-OA$")*1,"%)#$0'% .&O0.2%#)0%"&,"0)%("0+%-*+'180)'%#)0%#-$&@0.2%'0#)-"&+,%/*)%'*80$"&+,%$*%;12eX1'$%#'%'0#)-"%#5@0)$&'&+,%$#),0$'%-*+'180)'%("*%0J4)0''%'*80%&+$0)0'$%&+%#%4#)$&-1.#)%'0#)-"%$0)83%$"0%0//0-$%&'%8#,+&/&05%&/%$"0%'0#)-"0)%-#+%;0%&50+$&/&05%#'%#+%&8805&#$0%-*+'180)D%%F"1'%*+.&+0%)0$#&.0)'%.&O0%LQ+*(%$"#$%-#+%0'$#;.&'"%$"0&)% *(+% ;)#+5'% #+5% $"0&)% *(+% +#@&,#$&*+% -"#++0.'Hl% "#@0% #% '&,+&/&-#+$%#5@#+$#,0%&+%5)#(&+,%'0#)-"0)'e#+5%#5@0)$&'0)'e#(#2%/)*8%9**,.0f%F"0%/#-$%$"#$%#%-*+'180)%&'%40)/*)8&+,%#%'0#)-"%*+%#%)0$#&.%'&$0%&$'0./%-*+@02'%&84*)$#+$%#+5% @#.1#;.0% &+/*)8#$&*+% $*% #5@0)$&'0)'% $"#$% &'% +*$% *$"0)(&'0% #@#&.#;.0% /)*8%8*'$% 1+5&//0)0+$&#$05%9**,.0% '0#)-"0'e&$% -0)$#&+.2% &+-)0#'0'% $"0% -"#+-0% $"#$%$"0% '0#)-"0)% &'% '0#)-"&+,% $*% ;12% #% LQ% )#$"0)% $"#+% .0#)+% '*80$"&+,% #;*1$% $"0%'&+,0)D% b0-#1'0% $"&'% >)0#52A$*A;12?% $)#//&-% &'% $"0% 8*'$% @#.1#;.03% $"0)0% &'% #%4*''&;&.&$2% */% $(*% '04#)#$0% '0#)-"% 8#)O0$'3% (&$"% 8*'$% "&,"A@#.10% $)#//&-%;24#''&+,%,0+0)#.A41)4*'0%'0#)-"%0+,&+0'%/*)%4)*51-$%'0#)-"%'&$0'%.&O0%0b#2%#+5%C8#h*+D-*83% #+5% (&$"% 9**,.0% #+5% *$"0)% ,0+0)#.A41)4*'0% '0#)-"% 0+,&+0'%'0)@&+,%4)&8#)&.2%+*+A$#),0$053%.*(0)A@#.10%$)#//&-D%F"0%&84.&-#$&*+%&'%$"#$3%("&.0%0@0+% )0.#$&@0.2% '8#..A'-#.0% -*840$&$&*+% 8#2% 4)0'0+$% #% 4*$0+$&#..2% '&,+&/&-#+$%$")0#$%$*%9**,.0:'%'0#)-"%;1'&+0''3%$"&'%$")0#$%5*0'%+*$%5040+5%*+%.&+O'%$*%$"0'0%'&$0'%/)*8%9**,.0:'%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'D% %C+5%$"1'%$"0'0%-*840$&$*)'%"#@0%#%'$)*+,3%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Hd% cKI%CgRKFFC3%9kk9RKQf%FWK%KIQ%k]%FWK%!kVRQ%CT%!K%cIk!%6F%EjGvjH%7Gmmi=D%Hj% ]*)%0J#84.03%&+%$"0%$"&)$2%5#2'%0+5&+,%*+%]0;)1#)2%GH3%GmEm3%.0''%$"#+%$0+%40)-0+$%*/ %@&'&$'%

$*%0b#2D-*8%*)&,&+#$05%/)*8%#%'0#)-"%0+,&+0D%!""$CRKwC3%"M94%+5A$!.1"$)*653%4))56//!!!"$#%O$"&'3/78)%8(0'/%:$1"&'3D%%

Hl$ !""$Q*++#%RD%W*//8#+%S%F"*8#'%\D%I*@#O#$[5@$15$;+F2.,"$C2815A",8$5*$1("$?"/#$WCVaD%bgTD%VKaD3%_#2v[1+0%Gmmm3%#$%H3%N3%j%%7LQ+*(%(#'%#-^1&)05%;2%C8#h*+D-*8%&+%GmmED=%


&+5040+50+$% &+-0+$&@0% $*% 50@0.*4% 8#)O0$&+,% 4)*,)#8'% *1$'&50% */% 9**,.0:'%'0#)-"%4#,0'e#+5%$"0)0%&'%,**5%)0#'*+%+*$%$*%5041$&h0%9**,.0%&+%$"0%4)*-0''D%

Is Google an Essential Facility? V0-#..% $"#$% $"0% ;#'&-% -.#&8% &'% $"#$% 9**,.0:'% -*840$&$*)'% #)0% /*)0-.*'05% /)*8%#--0''% $*%9**,.0:'% 50'&)#;.0% 70''0+$&#.=%8#)O0$&+,% 4.#$/*)8% #+5% $"0)0;2% '1//0)%'&,+&/&-#+$%"#)8D%%k/%-*1)'0%/)*8%$"0%*1$'0$3%$"&'%"#'%&$%;#-O(#)5'%7#+5%$"&'%&'%#%-*)0%4)*;.08%(&$"%$"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%5*-$)&+0%#'%#%("*.0=D%%%

6/%$"0)0%&'%#%4)*;.083%&$%'"*1.5%;0%$"0%4)*;.08%*/%.&8&$05%#--0''%/4$:55&0"W8$28",8%$*%9**,.0:'%-*840$&$*)'D% %T*80$&80'% $"0%#;'0+-0%*/%#--0''%;2%-*840$&$*)'% $*%-*+'180)'% &'% $"0% '#80% $"&+,% #'% $"0% #;'0+-0% */% #--0''% ;2% -*+'180)'% $*%-*840$&$*)'3%;1$% &$%5040+5'%*+%"*(%(0..% $"0%8#)O0$%"#'%;00+%50/&+05D% %6+%$"0%8*'$% /1+5#80+$#.% '0+'0% 9**,.0% "#'% 4)0-&'0.2% h0)*% -*+$)*.% *@0)% #--0''% ;2%-*+'180)'% 780#+&+,% 1'0)'% ("*% 1'0% 9**,.0% $*% '0#)-"% $"0% 6+$0)+0$=% $*%-*840$&$*)'f% C+2*+0% (&$"% #--0''% $*% #% ;)*('0)% -#+% #--0''% #+2% '&$0% *+% $"0%6+$0)+0$% '&84.2% ;2% $24&+,% &$'% g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f%

F"0%$)&#.%-*1)$:'%50/&+&$&*+%*/%$"0%>4)*51-$?%8#)O0$%0@0+%8*)0%5)#8#$&-#..2% 508*+'$)#$0'% $"#$% &$'% #-$&*+% "#'% ;00+%\)*-)1'$0#+e$"#$%&$%"#'%$#&.*)05%$"0%8#)O0$%$*%$"0%5&80+'&*+'%*/% $"0% 50/0+5#+$'D% 6$% )0-*,+&h0'% $"#$% #% 40)'*+% '00O&+,%4)*$0-$&@0% '0)@&-0'% "#'% 8#+2% #.$0)+#$&@0% '*1)-0'D% 6$% .&'$'%>(#$-"80+3% (#$-"5*,'3% #1$*8#$&-% 4)*4)&0$#)2% '2'$08'%-*+/&+05% $*% *+0% '&$03% 7*/$0+3% ;1$% +*$% #.(#2'3=% #.#)8% '2'$08'%-*++0-$05% (&$"% '*80% .*-#.% 4*.&-0% *)% /&)0% '$#$&*+3% */$0+%1+#--)05&$05% LT\T% n-0+$)#.% '$#$&*+% 4)*$0-$&@0% '0)@&-0'o3% #+5%*/$0+%#--)05&$05%LT\TD?%F"0%-*1)$%/&+5'%$"#$%0@0+%&+%$"0%'#80%-&$2% #% '&+,.0% -1'$*80)% '00O&+,%4)*$0-$&*+% /*)% '0@0)#.%4)08&'0'%8#2%>0J0)-&'0% &$'%*4$&*+?%5&//0)0+$.2%/*)%5&//0)0+$% .*-#$&*+'D%6$%8#2% -"**'0% #--)05&$05% LT\T% /*)% *+0% */% &$'% .*-#$&*+'% #+5% #%5&//0)0+$%$240%*/%'0)@&-0%/*)%#+*$"0)D%


b1$%$"0%-*1)$% &'*.#$0'%/)*8%#..%*/%$"0'0%#.$0)+#$&@0'%*+.2%$"*'0%'0)@&-0'% &+% ("&-"% 50/0+5#+$'% 0+,#,0D% 6$% 0.&8&+#$0'% #..% */% $"0%#.$0)+#$&@0% '*1)-0'% 50'4&$0% &$'% -*+'-&0+$&*1'% 0+180)#$&*+% */%$"08D% 6$'% 50/&+&$&*+% */% $"0% >)0.0@#+$% 8#)O0$?% &'% +*$% 80)0.2%-*+/&+05% $*%>-0+$)#.% '$#$&*+?%4)*$0-$&@0% '0)@&-0'3% ;1$% $*% $"*'0%-0+$)#.% '$#$&*+% 4)*$0-$&@0% '0)@&-0'% ("&-"% #)0% >#--)05&$05?% ;2%&+'1)#+-0%-*84#+&0'D%

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i%

6+%6+$0)+0$%'0#)-"%#'%(0..3%-*84.#&+#+$'% &84.2%#%8#)O0$%;#'05%*+%$"0%/#-$%$"#$%9**,.0%*//0)'%>;0$$0)%^1#.&$2?%#--0''% $*%#% .#),0)%'0$%*/% 6+$0)+0$%1'0)'% $"#+% $"0%82)&#5% 0J&'$&+,%#.$0)+#$&@0'D% %b1$% -.#&8&+,%0''0+$&#.&$2%;#'05%*+%#% -*840$&$*):'%)0.#$&@0%"&,"%^1#.&$2%&'%5004.2%4)*;.08#$&-D%

F"&'% 4*&+$% &'% */% ,)0#$% &84*)$#+-0% &+% #''0''&+,% $"0% 0-*+*8&-'% */% $"0% 0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%5*-$)&+0%,0+0)#..2%#+5%&$'%#44.&-#$&*+%$*%6+$0)+0$%'0#)-"%&+%4#)$&-1.#)D%%6$%&'%-.0#)3%0@0+%1+50)%#%/#&).2%0J4#+'&@0%)0#5&+,%*/%$"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%5*-$)&+03%$"#$%0@0+%#%8*+*4*.&'$%"#'%+*%51$2% $*% '1;'&5&h0% $"0%0//*)$'%*/%#% .0''A0//0-$&@0%)&@#.DMm% %C),1#;.2% $"0%C'40+% TO&&+,% -#'0% '"*1.5% "#@0% ;00+% $*''05% *1$% *+% $"&'%;#'&'D% %C'%#%4)#-$&-#.%8#$$0)3% $"0%C'40+%TO&%L*84#+23%;2%0+$0)&+,% &+$*%#% X*&+$%8#)O0$&+,%#,)0080+$%(&$"%&$'%'8#..0)%)&@#.3%C'40+%W&,".#+5'3%#..*(05%W&,".#+5'%$*% $#O0% #5@#+$#,0% */% &$'% 8#)O05.2% .#),0)% 4)*51-$&@&$2% 7;*$"% &+% 50@0.*4&+,% 'O&%$0))#&+% #+5% #80+&$&0'3% #'% (0..% #'% 8#)O0$&+,% C'40+% #'% #% 'O&% 50'$&+#$&*+=D% % 6$'%'1;'0^10+$%50-&'&*+%$*%5)*4%W&,".#+5'%/)*8%&$'%8#)O0$&+,%4)*,)#8%/*)%/#&.&+,%$*%*//0)%'1//&-&0+$%)0$1)+%*+%&$'%&+@0'$80+$%'"*1.5%"#@0%;00+%1+*;X0-$&*+#;.0DME%%%

T&8&.#).23% $"0% 0J4.&-&$% -.#&8% &+% -#'0'% ;)*1,"$% #,#&+'$% 9**,.0% ;2% &$'% #..0,05.2A/*)0-.*'05% )&@#.'% &'% $"#$% $"0'0% 7)0.#$&@0.2%8&+&'-1.0=% '&$0'% '"*1.5%"#@0% #--0''% $*%9**,.0:'%0//0-$&@0%#+5%&+0J40+'&@0%8#)O0$&+,%$**.D%%b1$%&$%&'%;2%+*%80#+'%-.0#)%$"#$% 9**,.0% 5*0'% *)% '"*1.5% "#@0% $"&'% 51$2% $*% 4)*8*$0% &$'% )&@#.'% 7(&$"*1$%-*840+'#$&*+% $*% 9**,.03% #'% &$% "#440+'=D% % F"&'% &'% 4#)$&-1.#).2% $)10% ("0+3% #'%5&'-1''05%#;*@03%*$"0)%8*50'%*/%#--0''%0J&'$%/*)%-*840$&$*)':%#-$&@&$&0'3%0@0+%&/%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Hi$ N%!%$7%$:,.**"00$C5,3%3%HlM%gDTD%NdH3%NimAiE%7Eidd=%7084"#'&'%#5505=D%%Mm% !""%k.284&#%K^1&4D%R0#'&+,%L*D%@D%!0'$0)+%g+&*+%F0.D%L*D3%jij%]DG5%Hjm%7j$"%L&)D%Eild=D%ME% !""%cK6FW%ID%WYRFkI3%CIF6FVgTF%RC!f%KLkIk_6L%FWKkVY%CIQ%Lk__kI%RC!%

KakRgF6kI%GmNAmd%7GmmH=D%


$"0'0%8*50'%*/%#--0''%#)0%*/%.*(0)%^1#.&$2%*)%"&,"0)%-*'$D%%\#)$&-1.#).2%("0)03%#'%"0)03% $"0%#..0,05%;*$$.0+0-O%#)&'0'%+*$%*1$%*/%#%-*8;&+#$&*+%(&$"%#+*$"0)%/&)8%*)% /&)8'% ;1$% *1$% */% 1+&.#$0)#.% -*+51-$% 7'1--0''% &+% $"0%8#)O0$4.#-0=3% $"0% -.#&8%$"#$%#%'140)&*)%#--0''%4*&+$%#8*+,%8#+2%7&+/0)&*)=%#--0''%4*&+$'%'"*1.5%;0%4)&05%*40+%/*)%$"0%;0+0/&$%*/%&$'%-*840$&$*)'%&'%'40-&*1'D%

6$% &'% (*)$"% +*$&+,% $"#$% #+% #..0,05% 9**,.0% -*840$&$*)3% T*1)-0F**.3% &+% $"0%F)#50L*80$% -*84.#&+$3MG% "#'% 8#50% #% @0)'&*+% */% $"&'% #),180+$3% #..0,&+,% $"#$%9**,.0% *+-0% 0+,#,05% &+% 4)*/&$#;.0% -*880)-0% (&$"% T*1)-0F**.% 7;2% '0..&+,%T*1)-0F**.%#5'%+0J$% $*%9**,.0%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'=%#+5%$"0+%40+#.&h05%T*1)-0F**.%$*% &$'% 79**,.0:'=% 0-*+*8&-% 50$)&80+$DMH% % F"0% '"#40% */% $"&'% #),180+$% &'% #%$)#+'4#)0+$%0//*)$%$*%)08#&+%1+50)%("#$%&'%.0/$%*/%$"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%5*-$)&+0%/*..*(&+,%',.*=5D% % b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

k/% -*1)'0% $"0% #),180+$% $"#$% 9**,.0:'% -*840$&$*)'% #)0% 0//0-$&@0.2% #;'0+$%(&$"*1$% 7,1#)#+$005B=% #--0''% $*% 9**,.0:'% $*4% /0(% '0#)-"% )0'1.$'% 4)*@0'% $**%81-"D%%F"0)0%&'%#%'-#)-&$2%*/%>$*4%/0(%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'3?%#+5%#+2%0//0-$&@0%'0#)-"%0+,&+0%81'$%"#@0% $"0%#;&.&$2% $*%0+'1)0% $"#$% $"*'0%)0'1.$'%#)0% $"0%8*'$% )0.0@#+$%4*''&;.03% #'% (0..% #'% $"#$% $"02% 5*% +*$% @&*.#$0% @#)&*1'% ^1#.&$23% '#/0$23% 8*)#.% *)%*$"0)%'$#+5#)5'%$"#$%$"0%'0#)-"%0+,&+0%-"**'0'%$*%4)*8*$0D% %>]*)-&+,%n*(+0)'%*/% 0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$&0'o% $*% '"#)0% #--0''% 8#2% +*$% 0+"#+-0% -*+'180)% (0./#)0D?MM%%\1)0%>+01$)#.&$2?% &'%+0&$"0)%4*''&;.0%+*)%50'&)#;.03%#+5%$"0%0J-.1'&*+%*/%-0)$#&+%(0;'&$0'%/)*8%$"0'0%-*@0$05%4*'&$&*+'%'"*1.5%;0%500805%1$$0).2%1+40)'1#'&@0%&+%8#O&+,%*1$%0@0+%#%3,.A9$69+."%8*+*4*.&h#$&*+%-#'0%#,#&+'$%#%'0#)-"%0+,&+0D%%%

C+5%&$% &'%+*$%0@0+%$"0%-#'0%$"#$%T*1)-0F**.3%]*1+5083MN%#+5%*$"0)%-*840$&+,%(0;'&$0'%#)0%#;'0+$%/)*8%9**,.0U%&$%&'3%"*(0@0)3%'*80$&80'%$"0%-#'0%$"#$%$"0'0%

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%MG% L*84.#&+$%3%',9-"C5A"1%C5A$<<C$7%$:55&0"#$)*+%3%diH%]D%T144D%G5%Hjm%7TDQDIDYD%Gmmi=%7I*D%

miL&@DEMmm7TWT==D%MH% )-D%p%lD%MM% cK6FW%ID%WYRFkI3%CIF6FVgTF%RC!f%KLkIk_6L%FWKkVY%CIQ%Lk__kI%RC!%KakRgF6kI%

Gml%7GmmH=D%MN% ]*1+508%&'%#%>@0)$&-#.%'0#)-"%#+5%4)&-0%-*84#)&'*+?%'&$0%&+%$"0%gcD%%!""%

!!!"0'.(-%3"&'".,D%%F"0%-*84#+2%&'%#$%$"0%"0#)$%*/ %$"0%>'0#)-"%+01$)#.&$2?%50;#$0%&+%6+$0)+0$%'0#)-"D%%6$%"#'%-)0#$05%#%(0;'&$0%$*%#5@*-#$0%&$'%@&0('%*+%$"0%+01$)#.&$2%&''10%#$%!!!"7%$*&4(%.)*$#8)1"'*+3%#+5%&$'%-.#&8'%#)0%#$%$"0%"0#)$%*/ %$"0%K1)*40#+%L*88&''&*+:'%&+@0'$&,#$&*+%*/ %9**,.0D%%T00%]*1+508:'%5&'-1''&*+%*/ %$"0%Kg%#-$&*+%#+5%&$'%)0.#$&*+'"&4%$*%]*1+508:'%-.#&8'%&+%>2,53"9*$C5AA.88.5*$<92*+("8$;*1.1,281$)*7"81.&91.5*$56 $:55&0"3%TKCVLW%IKgFVCR6FYDkV93%I*@D%Hm3%GmEm3%4))56//!!!"7%$*&4(%.)*$#8)1"'*+D%


'&$0'% 5*% +*$% '"*(%14% &+% $"0% $*4% /0(%*),#+&-% '0#)-"% )0'1.$'% 7#+53% */$0+% #$% $"0%'#80%$&803%9**,.0:'%*(+%-*840$&+,%4)*51-$%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%5*=D%%b1$%&/%#--0''%$*%$"0% $*4% /0(%'0#)-"% )0'1.$'% &'% )0^1&)05% $*% 0+'1)0% $"0% )0^1&'&$0% #--0''% '*1,"$%;2%9**,.0:'% -*840$&$*)'3% $"0% )0.0@#+$% 8#)O0$% "#'% ;00+% +#))*(05% -*+'&50)#;.23%-)0#$&+,%#%'$#+5#)5%$"#$%-#+:$%4*''&;.2%;0%80$3%+*%8#$$0)%"*(%>+01$)#.?%#%'0#)-"%0+,&+0:'%)0'1.$'D%%

_0#+("&.03% &/% ]*1+508%(0)0% $*% 5&'#440#)% /)*8% $"0% /#-0% */% $"0% K#)$"3% ("*3%*$"0)%$"#+%&$'%&+@0'$*)'%#+5%084.*200'%7#+5%40)"#4'%$"0&)%.#+5.*)5'=3%(*1.5%;0%"#)805B%%F"0%&84.&-&$%-.#&8%7&/%#+%#+$&$)1'$%-#'0%&'%$*%;0%8#50=%&'%$"#$%(0;'&$0'%.&O0%]*1+508%#44.2%#%-*+'$)#&+$%*+%9**,.0:'%#;&.&$2%$*%0J$)#-$%8*+*4*.2%)0+$'%74)0'18#;.2% /)*8% #5@0)$&'0)'=D% % b1$% $"&'% &'% #% -1)&*1'% -.#&8% $*% 8#O0% ("&.0%'&81.$#+0*1'.2%#),1&+,%$"#$%9**,.0% &$'0./% &'%8#50%>;0$$0)?%7#'% &+3%'0#)-"0)'%#)0%&+5005%.**O&+,%/*)%]*1+508%&+%'0#)-"0'%/)*8%("&-"%$"0%'&$0%8#2%;0%0J-.1505=%;2%$"0%&+-.1'&*+%*/%]*1+508%&+%&$'%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%7$"1'3%4)0'18#;.23% &+-)0#'&+,%9**,.0:'%#$$)#-$&@0+0''%$*%&$'%1'0)'%#+5%$"1'%&$'%#5@0)$&'0)'=3%("&.0%#.'*%-.#&8&+,%$"#$%]*1+508%(*1.5%-0#'0%$*%0J&'$%(&$"*1$%#--0''%$*%$"0%$*4%/0(%9**,.0%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'D%%%

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e&/3%$"#$%&'3%9**,.0%"#)8'%&$'0./%*)%&$'%#5@0)$&'0)'%;2%&+$0+$&*+#..2%40+#.&h&+,%-*840$&+,%'&$0'%.&O0%]*1+508e$"0+%$"#$%#),180+$%#+5%#+2%0@&50+-0%/*)%&$%&'%#;'0+$%/)*8%$"0%-1))0+$%50;#$0D%%C+53%*/%-*1)'03%&/%9**,.0%&'3%#'%&$%-.#&8'3%#-$1#..2%&84)*@&+,%&$'%4)*51-$%;2%#44.2&+,%^1#.&$#$&@0%50-&'&*+'%$*%508*$0% '&$0'% .&O0% ]*1+508%#+5% *$"0)'% $"#$3%9**,.0% -.#&8'3%80)0.2% )0A41;.&'"%&+/*)8#$&*+% /)*8% 0.'0("0)0% *+% $"0% (0;% (&$"% 4)0-&*1'% .&$$.0% *)&,&+#.% -*+$0+$3%$"0+%9**,.0:'%0//*)$'%'"*1.5%;0%'00+%#'%#%/0#$1)0%#+5%+*$%#%;1,D%

_*)0*@0)3%$"0%0J$0+'&*+%*/%$"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%.*,&-%$*%-*840$&$&*+%;0$(00+%9**,.0% #+5% -*840$&$*)'% .&O0% ]*1+5083% _#4`10'$% *)% c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

6$:'%#%(0&)5%'*)$%*/%-*84.#&+$D%%6$%&'+:$%$"0%'#80%#'%$"0%-.#''&-%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%'*)$%*/%-*84.#&+$%("0)03%$*%'&84.&/23%$"0%*(+0)%*/%#%@0)$&-#..2A&+$0,)#$05%)#&.)*#5%


#+5%)#&.%$)#+'4*)$%-*84#+2%4)0@0+$'%#--0''%;2%*$"0)%$)#+'4*)$%-*84#+&0'%$*%&$'%)#&.)*#5% .&+0D% % 6+'$0#5% $"&'% (*1.5% ;0% .&O0% )#&.)*#5% -*84#+2% C% #),1&+,% $"#$%)#&.)*#5%b%81'$%,&@0%C%#--0''%$*%b:'%$)#-O'%'*%C%-#+%'0..%#--0''%$*%$"*'0%$)#-O'%$*%*$"0)%)#&.%$)#+'4*)$%-*84#+&0'D%%%

b1$%0@0+%$"&'%5*0'+:$%-*84.0$0.2%-#4$1)0%$"0%#15#-&$2%*/%$"0%-*84.#&+$3%;0-#1'0%/*)%$"0%#+#.*,2%$*%"*.53%)#&.)*#5%C%(*1.5%#-$1#..2%;0%#'O&+,%$"0%-*1)$%$*%/*)-0%)#&.)*#5%b%$*%41$%14%#%'&,+%#$%$"0%"0#5%*/%&$'%$)#-O'%#..*(&+,%)#&.)*#5%C%$*%*//0)%$*% $)#&+'% #.)0#52% *+%b:'% )#&.)*#5% $"0% *44*)$1+&$2% $*% X184%*//%b:'% )#&.)*#5% #+5%'$#)$% *@0)% #,#&+% *+% C:'% )#&.)*#5% $"#$% /*..*('% #+*$"0)% )*1$0e;1$% (&$"*1$%O+*(&+,%/*)%'1)0%&/%$"0%)*1$0%&'%;0$$0)%*)%(*)'0%1+$&.%2*1%X184%*+$*%C:'%$)#-O'D%%T*80$"&+,%.&O0%$"#$D%%C,#&+3%&$:'%(0&)5D%%%

C+5% +*$03% */% -*1)'03% $"0% 4)*;.08% $"#$% >#$% $"0% "0#5% */% $"0% $)#-O'?% 7#'% &+%'*80$"&+,% .&O0% >$"0% /&)'$3% '0-*+5% *)% $"&)5% *),#+&-% )0'1.$?=% &'% #% 4)*;.08#$&-%)0^1&)080+$%#'%*+.2%$")00%'&$0'%#$%#+2%,&@0+%$&80%-#+%*--142%$"*'0%'4*$'e;1$%$"0)0% 8#2% ;0%8#+2%8*)0% $"#+% $")00% /&)8'% -*84.#&+&+,% */% 9**,.0:'% -*+51-$%#+5q*)%#//0-$05%;2%$"0%@#,#)&0'%*/%&$'%4)*51-$%50'&,+%50-&'&*+'D%k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

C'%5&'-1''05%#;*@03%'&$0'%.&O0%]*1+508%5*%&+5005%"#@0%#--0''%$*%9**,.0:'%0+5%1'0)'% @&#% #+2% +18;0)% */% O02(*)5'% *+% 9**,.0:'% '&$0D% % F240% >gc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n0''0+$&#.% /#-&.&$&0'o% 5*-$)&+0% &'% $"0% 1+#@#&.#;&.&$2% */% #--0''% $*% $"0%Z0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0':U%("0)0%#--0''%0J&'$'3%$"0%5*-$)&+0%'0)@0'%+*%41)4*'0D?Md%%

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

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Md$ ',.*=53%NMm%gDTD%#$%MEED%


&+'$0#5%#% .&+O%$*%#+*$"0)%'&$0%$"#$%)0^1&)0'%#+*$"0)%'0@0)#.%'$04'%;0/*)0%/&+5&+,%$"0%&+/*)8#$&*+B%

T00+%$"&'%(#23%9**,.0:'%50-&'&*+%$*%4)*8*$0%&$'%*(+%4)&-0%-*84#)&'*+%)0'1.$'%&'%#%'&84.0%4)*51-$%4)&-&+,%#+5%50'&,+%50-&'&*+3%4)*$0-$05%;2%,**5%'0+'0%#+5%$"0%',.*=5%50-&'&*+%7#$% .0#'$% &+% $"0%gDTD=D% %g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e;2%50/&+&$&*+%*/% ,)0#$% @#.10% $*% 1'0)'% 7&+% 0//0-$% .*(0)&+,% $"0% 4)&-0% $*% $"08% */% $"0&)% 4)*51-$%'0#)-"=e$*% 80)&$% 9**,.0:'% &+@0'$80+$3% &$% &'% +0-0''#)2% $"#$% &$'% *(+3% 8*)0A)0.0@#+$% #+5% .0''A0J40+'&@0% )0'1.$'% )0-0&@0% 4)&*)&$2D% % 6/% $"&'% &'% ,0+0)#$&+,%'*80$"&+,%*/%@#.10%/*)%9**,.0%&$%&'%5*&+,%'*%*+.2%&+%$"0%8*'$%'#.1$#)2%/#'"&*+f%;2%*//0)&+,%#55&$&*+#.%)0'*1)-0'%/*)%1'0)'%$*%&84)*@0%$"0&)%>'0#)-"%0J40)&0+-0?%#+5%$"1'%&+51-0%$"08%$*%1'0%9**,.0:'%'0#)-"%0+,&+0D%%F*%)0^1&)0%>+01$)#.&$2?%&+%$"&'% '0$$&+,% &'% $*% &84#&)% $"0% '&$0:'% #;&.&$2% $*% 50'&,+% #+5% 4)&-0% &$'% *(+% 4)*51-$D%%K@0+% $"0%;83"*$ !=..*&% 50-&'&*+% 5&5+:$% ,*% $"#$% /#)3% )0^1&)&+,% #--0''% $*% #% X*&+$%8#)O0$&+,%#))#+,080+$%;1$%+*$%*;.&,#$&+,%C'40+%TO&%L*84#+2%$*%#.$0)%&$'%4)&-0'%/*)%'O&0)'%'00O&+,%$*%#--0''%*+.2%&$'%*(+%'.*40'D%%%

C+5%$"0%'#80%#+#.2'&'%"*.5'%/*)%#''0''80+$'%*/%9**,.0:'%*$"0)%*//0)&+,'%78#4'%#+5%@&50*'3% /*)%0J#84.0=% $"#$%-*840$0%(&$"%*$"0)% '&$0'D% %R**O% /*)% $"0%+0#)0'$%_-Q*+#.5'% &+%9**,.0%#+5%#%9**,.0%_#4%&'%;*1+5%$*%$*4%$"0% .&'$% 7;1$%+*$%;0%$"0%0J-.1'&@0%)0'1.$3%*/%-*1)'0=D%%b1$%("2%'"*1.5%&$%;0%#+2%*$"0)%(#2B%%6+%0//0-$3%("#$%9**,.0%5*0'%&'%,&@0%2*1%$"0%!0;:'%-*+$0+$%&+%#'%#--0''&;.0%#+5%#44)*4)&#$0%#% /*)8%#'% &$% -#+e50'&,+%50-&'&*+'% $"#$3%9**,.0%81'$%;0.&0@03% &+-)0#'0%^1#.&$2%#+5% )051-0% 0//0-$&@0% 4)&-0% /*)% &$'% 1'0)'D% % b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

Conclusion T0#)-"% +01$)#.&$2% #+5% /*)-05% #--0''% $*%9**,.0:'% )0'1.$'% 4#,0'% &'% ;#'05% *+% $"0%4)*4*'&$&*+%$"#$e9**,.0:'%1'0)':%&+$0)0'$'%;0%5#8+05e&/%9**,.0%&'%$"0%0#'&0'$%(#2% -*840$&$*)'% -#+% ,0$% $*% 4*$0+$&#.% 1'0)'3%9**,.0%81'$% 4)*@&50% $"#$% #--0''D%%F"0%0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$&0'%5*-$)&+03%50#.$%#%+0#)A50#$"%;.*(%;2%$"0%T14)080%L*1)$%&+%',.*=53%"#'% .*+,%;00+%*+%$"0%)*40'D% % %6$%'"*1.5%)08#&+%8*)&;1+5%"0)0D% %k+%$"0%*+0%"#+5%9**,.0%5*0'%+*$%4)0-.1503%+*)%5*0'%&$%"#@0%$"0%4*(0)%$*%4)0-.1503%1'0)'% /)*8% #--0''&+,% -*840$&$*)':% '&$0'U% #..% 1'0)'% +005% 5*% &'% $240%>/*1+508D-*8?% &+$*% $"0&)% (0;% ;)*('0)e("&-"% (*)O'% 0@0+% &/% &$:'% 9**,.0:'%


*(+% L")*80% ;)*('0)r% % F*% $"0% 0J$0+$% $"#$% 9**,.0% -#+% #+5% 5*0'% .&8&$%-*840$&$*)':%#--0''% $*% &$'%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%4#,03% &$% &'%+*$%-*+$)*..&+,%#--0''% $*%#+%>0''0+$&#.%/#-&.&$2?%&+%#+2%'0+'0%*$"0)%$"#+%!#.A_#)$%-*+$)*.'%#--0''%$*%&$'%*(+%'$*)0'D%%>9**,.0%'0#)-"%)0'1.$'%,0+0)#$05%;2%&$'%4)*4)&0$#)2%#.,*)&$"8%#+5%/*1+5%*+% &$'%*(+%(0;%4#,0'?%5*%+*$% -*+'$&$1$0% #%8#)O0$% $*%("&-"%#--0''% '"*1.5%;0%/*)-&;.2%,)#+$05%;2%$"0%-*1)$'%*)%.0,&'.#$1)0D%%%

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f%

6+50053%&$%&'%*1)%@&0(%$"#$%&+%.&,"$%*/%$"0%#+$&$)1'$%-.#&8'%#)&'&+,%*1$% */% &++*@#$&@0% -*+$)#-$1#.% #+5% 4)&-&+,% -*+51-$3% #+5% $"0%#44#)0+$% .#-O% */% #+2% -*+-)0$0% 0@&50+-0% */% #+$&-*840$&$&@0%0//0-$'%*)%"#)8%$*%-*840$&$&*+3%#+%0+/*)-080+$%#-$&*+%#,#&+'$%9**,.0% *+% $"0'0% ,)*1+5'% -)0#$0'% '1;'$#+$&#.% )&'O% /*)% #% >/#.'0%4*'&$&@0?% ("&-"% (*1.5% -"&..% &++*@#$&*+% #+5% -*840$&$&*+%-1))0+$.2%4)*@&5&+,%&880+'0%;0+0/&$'%$*%-*+'180)'DMj%

% %

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%Mj% 90*//)02%CD%_#++0%S%[*'"1#%QD%!)&,"$3%:55&0"$9*-$1("$<.A.18$56 $;*1.1,281D$'("$C98"$;&9.*81$1("$

C98"$;&9.*81$:55&0"3%HM%WCVaD%[D%RD%S%\gbD%\kR:Y%#$%dGD%

Documents

The Problem of Search Engines as Essential Facilities (Geoffrey A. Manne)