The privileged few are tightening their grip | Nick Cohen | Comment is free | The Observer

8/11/2019 The privileged few are tightening their grip | Nick Cohen | Comment is free | The Observer

1/5

9/14/14 6:2he privileged few are tightening their grip | Nick Cohen | Comment is free | The Observer

Page ttp://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/13/privileged-few-control-culture-politics-media

Search

'Sleek young beasts' (from left): Sam Claflin, Max Irons and Natalie Dormer in Riot Club. Photograph:

Sportsphoto/Allstar/Blueprint Pictures

Decades back,when the young Judi Dench starred as Juliet, her mother and father

joined the cast. In Act 3 Juliet learns that Romeo has killed her cousin, and cries:

"Where is my father, and my mother?"

"Here we are, darling," shouted her parents from the stalls, "in row H!"

You cannot imagine the parents of today's stars being so gauche. They come from a

The privileged few are tightening their

grip on the artsPolitics, journalism, the arts they are all increasingly controlled

by nice people from wealthy backgrounds. And their niceness is

strangling us

Nick Cohen

The Observer, Saturday 13 September 2014 14.13 EDT
http://www.theguardian.com/ushttp://www.observer.co.uk/http://www.theguardian.com/film/2012/oct/14/judi-dench-interview-skyfallhttp://observer.guardian.co.uk/http://www.theguardian.com/profile/nickcohenhttp://www.theguardian.com/profile/nickcohenhttp://www.theguardian.com/film/2012/oct/14/judi-dench-interview-skyfallhttp://www.observer.co.uk/http://www.theguardian.com/us


2/5



world that is closer to David Cameron's Bullingdon Club than Dench's Quaker roots in

Yorkshire. The forthcomingRiot Club which bears the subtitle "Filthy. Rich. Spoilt.

Rotten" is meant to satirise David Cameron, George Osborne and Boris Johnson's

days at the Buller. Unintentionally it will also satirise itself. To put it as kindly as I can,

the producers did not have to search far to find actors who could give a convincing

impersonation of inherited privilege. Max Irons son of Jeremy, since you asked plays one of the sleek young beasts. Freddie Fox, son of Edward, another. The only

difference between them and the current leadership of the Tory party is that they went

into acting rather than politics. If there is a danger of reading too much into their

slipping into their fathers' shoes, there is also a danger of reading too little. The careers

of Edward and James Fox show there have always been upper-class actors, and I would

not have it any other way. It's just that with Damian Lewis, Benedict Cumberbatch,

Eddie Redmayne and Dominic West, there are so many of them. In arts that boast that

they "celebrate diversity" everyone looks the same.

Dame Judi tells the Observertoday aspiring actors beg her for money to help fund their

training. She worries that acting may become an elite occupation for the children of the

rich, because no one else will be able to meet the costs and take the risks. Ben

Stephenson, the BBC's head of drama, said much the same at the Edinburgh festival but

did not add that television is a racket, too. You cannot get a job in broadcasting unless

you are prepared to work as an intern. In most cases, you cannot work as an intern

unless you have family money to feed and house you.

But then who am I to criticise Stephenson when journalism is as much of a rich kids'

game? Lindsey Macmillan of the Institute of Education found that journalists used to

come from families 6% better off than average, whereas now they come from homes that

are 42% richer. Indeed, British journalists, the supposed tribunes of the people, now

hail from wealthier backgrounds than, er, bankers, an awkward fact that ought to cause

embarrassment all round. I look at my younger self today and wonder if he could

become a journalist on a serious newspaper. My parents were teachers. They were

comfortably off by the standards of 1980s Manchester, but they could never haveafforded to rent me rooms in London and cover my expenses while I went from

internship to internship. They had to look after my sisters as much as anything else.

The hypocrisies of British culture are enough to drive the sane paranoid, but it is not

quite the class conspiracy it seems. To be sure, it is suffocating, narrow and on the edge

of a descent into a mediocre mush. But not a conspiracy for all that. Working-class
http://www.economist.com/news/international/21615612-temporary-unregulated-and-often-unpaid-internship-has-become-routehttp://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/tvandradio/bbc/11053178/Class-a-big-issue-in-arts-says-BBC-drama-boss.htmlhttp://www.theguardian.com/media/bbc


3/5



actors or musicians cannot live on the dole now while they struggle to break through.

The sanctions from the jobcentres whip them into line. If you want to know why British

pop has lost its rough energy, you should blame the Department for Work and Pensions,

not a plot by the record label executives. In any case, tens of thousands of young people

want to work in the arts, television, music and journalism. Why shouldn't their potential

employers, often short of money themselves, take advantage of the laws of supply anddemand?

Those who receive public money have no right to do so. Working- and lower-middle-

class citizens should not have to fund through their taxes and the lottery arts

organisations that deny opportunities to their children. One of the most admirable men

I know is Martin Bright, who threw in a career in journalism to found the Creative

Society, which gives working-class teenagers the same opportunities in the arts that

their middle- and upper-class contemporaries receive. Diversity creates uniformity, he

says, because it ignores class. As a result, projects for women or the ethnic minorities

are colonised by the middle class. The only positive discrimination that works is for arts

organisations to go into jobcentres and find talented young people on the dole who

deserve a break, and too few want to try it.

What applies to artists applies to the audience. The National Endowment for Science,

Technology and the Arts has told recipients of public money that they should at least

think of putting Royal Opera House shows, for example, or National Theatre

productions on the web once their runs are over. The overwhelming majority of peoplewho cannot get to London, and could not afford tickets if they did, would then see the

work their taxes helped pay for. It does no good. The notion that publicly funded art

must be publicly available does not occur to today's generation of cultural bureaucrats.

Expanding the range of British culture is not just an act of social justice, however. When

the arts restrict their gene pool, they restrict their talent pool, too. No Premier League

football club would give contracts only to children with private incomes and expect to

remain in the premier league. The arts, broadcasting, serious journalism and publishing

are coming dangerously close to doing just that, and its class-based culture is becoming

a second-rate culture. British television drama could once boast that it was "the best in

the world". Now the best comes from America and Scandinavia. When Macmillan and

her colleagues at the Institute of Education compared IQs, they found today's younger

cohort of professionals was, on average, slightly dimmer than the previous, poorer

generation.
http://www.nesta.org.uk/http://www.thecreativesociety.co.uk/


4/5



What's this?More from the

Guardian

What is an Indian summer? 08 Sep 2014

So your a pedant? It's nothing to be proud of 11 Sep 2014

Woman arrested over murder of horsewoman Penelope

Davis 11 Sep 2014

In praise of the Sleaford Mods 10 Sep 2014

Don't watch the Ray Rice video. Don't ask why Janay

Palmer married him. Ask why anyone would blame avictim 08 Sep 2014

What's this?More from around

the webPromoted content by Outbrain

The important conversation more families need to have

(Good Neighbors)

How Are U.S. Energy Needs Changing? (The New York

Times: Paid Post)

This New Gmail App is Almost Too Good to Be True

(Evolving SEO)

Ditch your brow pencil and try this! (DermStore)

Questions to Answer Before Migrating to Cloud

(VMware)

Recommended by

In writing this piece, I do not mean to disparage the young, privately educated

journalists I see around me, the sprigs of the Fox and Irons families, the commissioning

editors of the BBC and the staff of the National Theatre and Royal Opera House. They

are all nice people. But there's the rub. They are too fucking nice for Britain's good.

Their niceness is a noose that is strangling our ability to talk to ourselves and to the

world.

Ads by GoogleConstruction experts Ny

All types of site work and masonry Truck and machines for hire per day

www.josephbulfamanteandson.com

SFTWR Prod Launch 07 May

Business Rules on the cloud Compl. plans all week. Also 60% off

www.concentricsys.com

2014 Guardian News and Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.

Get the best of Comment is free

The most shared comment, analysis and editorial

articles delivered every weekday lunchtime.

Sign up for the Comment is free email
https://id.theguardian.com/email/subscribe?emailListId=2313http://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/aclk?sa=L&ai=CPMpQAW0VVMvWGczflgeMooHoCd391uoDha3F4Y4BwI23ARACIIW76A8oAlDJlZ_dBmDJvpaLwKTYD8gBAakCCIpLGjO0UT6oAwGqBLgBT9BzWvBOnJ6ADVhCqPHMyqwV6whECsso7qngZ3JiI4hsWrJ71zeb-a5AiHi1IcSRLD8xw9AnYZRAJUAe2m4L3j2k5sbl_XGVNymcFaY03yyKbReXWAkkeQckiXdnIOZW2WGDr-jmJK9KSwqU_mTdOeY7pez1Pw2VUcW7V3YObMgMBWZB4id5EmVIncRUiwadyE7opJjGxUiBrmNZv1Nex8cnWKLzIMaG6RuP-_avDbbbH03j3TMHO4AHjaOQKA&num=2&sig=AOD64_3HbNYGOU1KZ7A2jVJ9AgT34BhDyQ&client=ca-guardian_js&adurl=http://www.concentricsys.comhttp://googleads.g.doubleclick.net/aclk?sa=L&ai=CPMpQAW0VVMvWGczflgeMooHoCd391uoDha3F4Y4BwI23ARACIIW76A8oAlDJlZ_dBmDJvpaLwKTYD8gBAakCCIpLGjO0UT6oAwGqBLgBT9BzWvBOnJ6ADVhCqPHMyqwV6whECsso7qngZ3JiI4hsWrJ71zeb-a5AiHi1IcSRLD8xw9AnYZRAJUAe2m4L3j2k5sbl_XGVNymcFaY03yyKbReXWAkkeQckiXdnIOZW2WGDr-jmJK9KSwqU_mTdOeY7pez1Pw2VUcW7V3YObMgMBWZB4id5EmVIncRUiwadyE7opJjGxUiBrmNZv1Nex8cnWKLzIMaG6RuP-_avDbbbH03j3TMHO4AHjaOQKA&num=2&sig=AOD64_3HbNYGOU1KZ7A2jVJ9AgT34BhDyQ&client=ca-guardian_js&adurl=http://www.concentricsys.comhttp://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=CCiZbAW0VVMvWGczflgeMooHoCf3wlKUFpaWS0MMBwI23ARABIIW76A8oAlCNveH8B2DJvpaLwKTYD6ABw-DO5APIAQGoAwGqBLgBT9BzWvBNnJ6ADVhCqPHMyqwV6whECsso7qngZ3JiI4hsWrJ71zeb-a5AiHi1IcSRLD8xw9AnYZRAJUAe2m4L3j2k5sbl_XGVNymcFaY03yyKbReXWAkkeQckiXdnIOZW2WGDr-jmJK9KSwqU_mTdOeY7pez1Pw2VUcW7V3YObMgMBWZB4hdAGAJIncRUiwadyE7opJjGxUiBrmNZv1Nex8cnWKLzIMaG6RuP-_avDbbbH03jjX0xDogGAYAHpZ-xGw&num=1&cid=5Gj_9jv3e5yVVxH5NtCzGK0f&sig=AOD64_23BsryIPZDOONBqAf35jQaa-FLsQ&client=ca-guardian_js&adurl=http://josephbulfamanteandson.comhttp://www.googleadservices.com/pagead/aclk?sa=L&ai=CCiZbAW0VVMvWGczflgeMooHoCf3wlKUFpaWS0MMBwI23ARABIIW76A8oAlCNveH8B2DJvpaLwKTYD6ABw-DO5APIAQGoAwGqBLgBT9BzWvBNnJ6ADVhCqPHMyqwV6whECsso7qngZ3JiI4hsWrJ71zeb-a5AiHi1IcSRLD8xw9AnYZRAJUAe2m4L3j2k5sbl_XGVNymcFaY03yyKbReXWAkkeQckiXdnIOZW2WGDr-jmJK9KSwqU_mTdOeY7pez1Pw2VUcW7V3YObMgMBWZB4hdAGAJIncRUiwadyE7opJjGxUiBrmNZv1Nex8cnWKLzIMaG6RuP-_avDbbbH03jjX0xDogGAYAHpZ-xGw&num=1&cid=5Gj_9jv3e5yVVxH5NtCzGK0f&sig=AOD64_23BsryIPZDOONBqAf35jQaa-FLsQ&client=ca-guardian_js&adurl=http://josephbulfamanteandson.comhttps://www.google.com/url?ct=abg&q=https://www.google.com/adsense/support/bin/request.py%3Fcontact%3Dabg_afc%26url%3Dhttp://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/13/privileged-few-control-culture-politics-media%26gl%3DUS%26hl%3Den%26client%3Dca-guardian_js%26hideleadgen%3D1%26ai0%3DCCiZbAW0VVMvWGczflgeMooHoCf3wlKUFpaWS0MMBwI23ARABIIW76A8oAlCNveH8B2DJvpaLwKTYD6ABw-DO5APIAQGoAwGqBLgBT9BzWvBNnJ6ADVhCqPHMyqwV6whECsso7qngZ3JiI4hsWrJ71zeb-a5AiHi1IcSRLD8xw9AnYZRAJUAe2m4L3j2k5sbl_XGVNymcFaY03yyKbReXWAkkeQckiXdnIOZW2WGDr-jmJK9KSwqU_mTdOeY7pez1Pw2VUcW7V3YObMgMBWZB4hdAGAJIncRUiwadyE7opJjGxUiBrmNZv1Nex8cnWKLzIMaG6RuP-_avDbbbH03jjX0xDogGAYAHpZ-xGw%26ai1%3DCPMpQAW0VVMvWGczflgeMooHoCd391uoDha3F4Y4BwI23ARACIIW76A8oAlDJlZ_dBmDJvpaLwKTYD8gBAakCCIpLGjO0UT6oAwGqBLgBT9BzWvBOnJ6ADVhCqPHMyqwV6whECsso7qngZ3JiI4hsWrJ71zeb-a5AiHi1IcSRLD8xw9AnYZRAJUAe2m4L3j2k5sbl_XGVNymcFaY03yyKbReXWAkkeQckiXdnIOZW2WGDr-jmJK9KSwqU_mTdOeY7pez1Pw2VUcW7V3YObMgMBWZB4id5EmVIncRUiwadyE7opJjGxUiBrmNZv1Nex8cnWKLzIMaG6RuP-_avDbbbH03j3TMHO4AHjaOQKA&usg=AFQjCNGAcVaXxXi2MjL6SrMRQfY58F_gzQhttp://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/13/privileged-few-control-culture-politics-media#http://blogs.vmware.com/vcloud/2014/01/clarity-cloud-compliance-security.htmlhttp://www.dermstore.com/lp/2317?utm_term=sb_multi_eye_1http://www.evolvingseo.com/2013/04/20/review-of-yesware-email-tracking/http://paidpost.nytimes.com/chevron/a-complex-flow-of-energy.htmlhttp://goodneighbors.com/post/96357024982/liam1http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/13/privileged-few-control-culture-politics-media#http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2014/sep/08/ray-rice-domestic-violence-video-janay-palmer-victim-blaminghttp://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2014/sep/10/in-praise-of-sleaford-modshttp://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2014/sep/11/penelope-davis-horsewoman-murder-woman-arrestedhttp://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/11/are-you-the-next-pedant-in-chief-prove-ithttp://www.guardian.co.uk/uk-news/from-the-archive-blog/2014/sep/08/indian-summer-archivehttp://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/sep/13/privileged-few-control-culture-politics-media#


5/5



;

Documents

The privileged few are tightening their grip | Nick Cohen | Comment is free | The Observer