23
The North Texas Skeptics Pathological Science http://www.ntskeptics.org

The North Texas Skeptics

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

The North Texas Skeptics. Pathological Science http://www.ntskeptics.org. Pathological Science. What is pathological science? Irving Langmuir and pathological science Cold fusion The hafnium bomb Sonofusion The studies of Joseph B. Rhine Characteristics of pathological science - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: The North Texas Skeptics

The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Sciencehttp://www.ntskeptics.org

Page 2: The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Science

What is pathological science? Irving Langmuir and pathological science Cold fusion The hafnium bomb Sonofusion The studies of Joseph B. Rhine Characteristics of pathological science Recent history of pathological science

Page 3: The North Texas Skeptics

What is Pathological Science?

Pathological Science is science done—the rules are violated.

The scientist takes ownership of a theory. Feeble or no attempts are made to refute the theory. Contrary evidence is ignored. Problems with the theory are explained away ad hoc. Detractors are defamed or ridiculed. The scientific consensus is viewed as a conspiracy of

orthodoxy. The theory becomes a field of cult science.

Page 4: The North Texas Skeptics

Irving Langmuir

General Electric researcher, Nobel in Chemistry A talk in 1953 related Langmuir’s experiences with

Pathological Science. The complete story was published in Physics Today,

October 1989. Langmuir’s talk involved the following:

The Davis-Barnes effect The incredible story of N-rays The studies of Joseph B. Rhine The Millikan oil drop experiment Characteristics of pathological science Recent history of pathological science

Page 5: The North Texas Skeptics

The Davis-Barnes Experiment

Alpha particles coming from the left are deflected down into the detector at Z. If they combine with electrons in the region of the tube labeled R, then they will not be deflected to Z.

Polonium Alpha Particle Source

Magnetic Field

Undeflected Particles

Deflected Particles

590 Volts (typical)

Alpha Particles Go 8000 to 9000 Miles Per Second.

N

N++

Alpha Particle: Charge is +2.

Page 6: The North Texas Skeptics

The Davis-Barnes Story

Langmuir was invited to observe the effect at Columbia University.

Adjustment by means of crude rheostat Claims made for very fine accuracy Measurement involved counting flashes at the edge of

visibility. Davis was quick to explain away questions about the method. Experimental technique was sloppy—time interval for

counting was uncontrolled. Counts claimed by experimenters could not be replicated by

Langmuir and C. W. Hewlett—Barnes explained the discrepancy was due to a contaminated view screen.

Langmuir debunked the results by making the test blinded.

Page 7: The North Texas Skeptics

Davis-Barnes (Continued)

Barnes excused the result as a gassy tube—the same tube that had been producing good results.

Researchers would not accept Langmuir’s evidence and presented a paper before the NAS.

Barnes excused inconsistent results from “counting bright flashes.”

Davis and Barnes later reported they were not able to reproduce their original data.

In their retraction they never mentioned a gassy tube.

Page 8: The North Texas Skeptics

Davis-Barnes Data Plot

Page 9: The North Texas Skeptics

The Rydberg Constant

Page 10: The North Texas Skeptics

René Blondlot and N-Rays

René Blondlot, French Academy of Sciences, University of Nancy

Blondlot researched x-rays and went on to discover N-rays.

N-rays have peculiar penetrating properties and are viewed in the dark on a calcium sulfide screen.

N-rays penetrate aluminum but not iron, and Blondlot used a large aluminum prism to do N-ray refraction. See the diagram.

Amazing precision was claimed for N-ray spectroscopy.

Measurement required great skill.

Page 11: The North Texas Skeptics

N-Rays

Iron TubeNernst Filament

Slit

Aluminum Prism

Calcium Sulfide Screen

N-Rays

Page 12: The North Texas Skeptics

Robert Wood and N-Rays

Robert W. Wood, physicist at Johns Hopkins University, researcher in infra-red and ultra-violet photography.

Wood went to France to observe the science of N-Rays.

In the dark Wood secretly removed the aluminum prism and put it in his pocket.

Blondlot continued to observe amazing precision. Wood published his findings in Nature, and N-

rays died a quick death. Blondlot’s reputation was shattered.

Page 13: The North Texas Skeptics

Mitogenetic Rays

Page 14: The North Texas Skeptics

The Allison Effect

Page 15: The North Texas Skeptics

Cold Fusion

Stanley Pons and Martin Fleischmann (University of Utah) Announced 23 March 1989 Production of available energy from nuclear fusion without

requiring high temperature, high pressure John Bokris, TAMU Now a field of cult science

Page 16: The North Texas Skeptics

Fusion Basics

+ +

In the real world atomic nuclei are positively charged and repel each other very strongly. Great force is required to bring them into close proximity to obtain fusion.

This is achieved by means of high temperatures and extreme pressures. Quantum tunneling can enable fusion at lower temperatures and pressures.

Page 17: The North Texas Skeptics

Tokamak Fusion

The UT Austin Center for Plasma Fusion embarked on this program to build a Tokamak in 1970. There was no plan to produce power from the experiment.

Artist Tony Bell produced this drawing from design plans.

Page 18: The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Science Characteristics

The maximum effect that is observed is produced by a causative agent of barely detectable intensity, and the magnitude of the effect is substantially independent of the intensity of the cause.

Page 19: The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Science Characteristics

The effect is of a magnitude that remains close to the limit of detectability, or many measurements are necessary bacause of the very low statistical significance of the results.

Page 20: The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Science Characteristics

There are claims of great accuracy.

Page 21: The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Science Characteristics

Fantastic theories contrary to experience are suggested.

Page 22: The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Science Characteristics

Criticisms are met by ad hoc excuses thought up on the spur of the moment.

Page 23: The North Texas Skeptics

Pathological Science Characteristics

The ratio of supporters to critics rises up to somewhere near 50% and then falls gradually to oblivion.