Upload
dinhtuyen
View
224
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
NiveshakTHE INVESTOR September2016VOLUME IX ISSUE IX
The Telecom War in
India
How Jio will affect the
market
Disclaimer: The views presented are the opinion/work of the individual author and the Finance Club of IIM Shillong bears
no responsibility whatsoever.
F R O M E D I T O R ’ S D E S K
NiveshakVolume IXISSUE IX
September 2016
Faculty Chairman
Prof. P. Saravanan
Aaron Keith Rego
Abhishek Jiaswal
Aditya Kumar Jain
Anisha Khurana
Ankit Singhal
Ankur Kumar
Anoop Prakash
Devansh Sheth
Shreyans Jain
All images, design and artwork are copyright of
IIM Shillong Finance Club
©Finance ClubIndian Institute of Management
Shillong
www.iims-niveshak.com
THE TEAM
Dear Niveshak
The month of September saw the benchmark Sensex falling 557 points or 1.96% rom the start of the month. The month did not see any major economic events or policy announcements by the government. The most talked about topic this month was the new RBI governor who would replace Dr. Raghuram Rajan.This month also the news came that the country’s GDP grew by 7.1% in the irst quarter of this iscal year. This reairmed the India’s position as the fastest growing major-economy in the world. Also on the governance ront, there was some good news. Our Babu-led bureaucracy has inally energised themselves and has started competing among themselves to get the status best performing states. Many states have also hired big consulting irms to help them understand the process of evalua-tion and ind ways to improve their rankings. On policy-ront the government is tak-ing its initiative further and is giving major boost to the Uniied Payment Interface (UPI). There was also one initiative that could be the irst of the million steps needed to revive the inancially-drain Indian Railways (IR). The IR has started the dynamic surge-pricing for ticket booking for some of its premium trains.On magazine ront, this month we have covered HUL for our Equity Research Report. HUL being a behemoth FMCG company provides a wide view of the Indian rural sector economy also. Article of the month talks about talks about the Uniied Payment Interface (UPI). The author talks about why how the UPI is diferent rom Payment Wallet system and who it is another step to make a cashless society. Our cover story talks about the Telecom batle which has started with the launch of Jio at rock-botom price. On the FinGyaan, the author gives views on the GST and how it could help in removing the parallel economy running in the country. FinRewind sec-tion talks about the WorldCom Scandal in the year 2002. While for FinSight we have a topic on the robust BRICS economy. The author illustrates how these ive nations could be the engine of growth for the world economy. On Classroom this time we are explain the concept on Margin Trading.For FinView, this time we have brought the interview of Mr. Tapan Singhel, MD & CEO of Bajaj Allianz. He gives his views on investment philosophy, how we can convert the insurance industry into a pull-based selling model and how IoT can add value to the Insurance industry. Finally, we would like to thank our readers for their immense support and encourage¬ment. You remain our prime motivation factor that keeps our spirits high and gives us the vigour and vitality to keep working hard. We hope you had a great inancial year and wish you the best for the new one. Stay invested Team Niveshak
C O N T E N T S
Niveshak Times
04 The Month That Was
Article of the month
12 Uniied Payment Interface and Its Impact on Payment
Cover Story
24 WorldCom Scandal, 2002
Finsight
28 BRICS - The Fuel to the World’s growth Engine
CLASSROOM
33 Margin Trading
FinGyaan
20 GST Impetus for Indian Econ-omy
FinRewind
16 Telecom Data War
FINVIEW
30 Mr. Tapan Singhel, MD & CEO of Bajaj Allianz
Equity Research Report
10 HUL
MAY 2016
GDP grew by 7.1% in Q1
Indian economy grew by 7.1% in the irst quarter
of this iscal. Though this reairms the India’s
positions as the fastest major economies in the
world, the growth is below expectations. This also
diminishes the hope of achieving 8% growth for
the whole year. Also this growth is also slow than
the 7.9% growth achieved in the Q4 of FY16.
Indian economy needs to grew by 8% consistently
if it needs to create job, reduce poverty and uplift
the life of people. This slow growth might also put
some pressure on the central bank to cut interest
rate in the monetary policy meeting on October
4th. But that hope is also tied to the inlationary
pressure in the economy.
The April – July iscal deicit was registered at 73.7%
of the whole year’s budget which is slightly above
than the last year’s igure of 69.3%.
Sony to Acquire Ten Sports
Sony Pictures Network Limited (SPN) will buy Ten
Sports for INR 2600 crore from Zee Entertainment
Enterprise (ZEE). This would add muscle to the
already large portfolio of SPN.
SPN currently owns channels like Sony Six, Sony
Six HD, Sony ESPN and Sony ESPN HD. By acquiring
Ten Sports it will add channels like Ten 1, Ten 2, ten
3 etc.
ZEE had also acquired Ten Sports from Dubai-
based Abdul Rahman Bukhatir’s Taj Group for INR
500 crore.
Adding Ten Sports channels to its portfolio to
its already diversiied channels will make SPN’s
portfolio quite strong. Also SPN holds broadcasting
right to the Indian Premier League (IPL). The
biggest advantage would come from channels like
WWE (World Wrestling Entertainment).
States Competing to Get the Best Ranking
Competition would even get the babu-culture
moving was little unexpected. But that has actually
happened among the states.
Indian states are competing among themselves
to get the best ranking among themselves.
These ranking are updated continually. As soon
any reform or initiative has been veriied by the
concerned department, the same is fed into the
dashboard. This is done on a real time basis.
To understand the process and to improve their
rankings, states have hired top-notch consultants.
The consulting irms would also help these states
on how they could improve their ranking.
There have been some disagreements about
the method. While some states have questioned
the process of evaluation, DIPP has also raised
question about the reforms initiated by some
states contemplating whether these reforms
should qualify for consideration in the evaluation
process or not.
Moves to Revive Construction Sector
In a major step to boost the economy and take
it to the path of growth trajectory, government
has taken slew of measures that will boost the
construction sector. As this sector is linked to the
heavy-metals industries, revival in construction
sector would have direct efect on the improvement
in other sectors.
Speciically, the government has taken steps to
improve the process of release of funds stuck in
the arbitration process. As per the data release
government agencies, pending claims from
government bodies are the major reason for the
burgeoning debt in the construction sector. These
pending claims account for about 150% of the
total debt.
The government has also given approval to the
100% FDI in the food sector.
Under the steps taken by the government, the
government would pay around 75% of the claim
amount to an escrow account. For faster settlement
the disputes would also be transferred to a new
arbitration process.
Push for Financial Inclusion: UPI to Get Major Boost
In a major push for the inancial inclusion that
would help sort the last mile connectivity problem,
the government has given major push to the
The Niveshak Times
www.iims-niveshak.com
IIM Shillong
Team NIVESHAK
NIVESHAK4T
he
Mon
th T
hat
Was
Uniied Payments Interface (UPI). UPI could rope in
as many as 1015 ecommerce players.
The concept of UPI is almost same as that of the
mobile wallet system Paytm. But there is a slight
diference. While payment apps like Paytm does
not require one to have bank accounts, UPI system
would work with bank account. However the other
functionalities and workings are almost same.
This would act both as advantage as well
disadvantage. While advantage would be in the
form of people would be opening bank accounts
and thus inancial inclusion while this same
advantage couls be its biggest stumbling block
since a large section of people still do not have
proper documents to open bank accounts.
Employees Could Hold Large Share in a Company’s
IPO: SEBI
In order to increase retail participation in the
companies market regulator Security Exchange
Board of India has increased the participation of
employees in the company in which they work.
As per the earlier guidelines, employees could bid
up to INR 2 lakh for their company’s IPO. But with
the revised guidelines, the employees would be
able to invest unto INR 5 lakh in their company.
This has been done to improve the participation
and increase the retail base in the company’s IPO.
In 2010, SEBI had hiked the employee participation
up to INR 2 lakh. But from then there has been
devaluation in rupee. So to ofset that efect of
rising inlation SEBI has taken decision to increase
the limit.
Dynamic Surge Pricing in Railways
Railways has taken a step that would help it mop
up little more cash. It has introduced surge pricing
mechanism for premium trains like Rajdhani,
Satabdi and Duronto.
Under the proposed mechanism, the railways price
would increase with the increase in the number
of the reserved berth. With every 10% reservation
in the birth, the price would increase by 10% of
the base price. Also the maximum price has been
capped to 1.5 times the base price. This means
around 50% of the total seats would be sold at
1.5 times the base price. This would be done only
on the base fare. Other charges like reservation
charges, IRCTC charges etc. would be levied in
addition to the above hiked charges.
Railways oicials said that this would help Indian
Railways mop up around INR 500 crore for this
iscal. Also they contended that when other modes
of transportation have dynamic price mechanism
then why not Railways should have.
The Niveshak Times
www.iims-niveshak.com 5NIVESHAKT
he M
on
th T
hat W
as
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
SEPTEMBER 2016
6C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK6A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
th
MARKET CAP (IN RS. CR)BSE Mkt. Cap 1,10,73,648
CURRENCY RATESINR / 1 USD 66.66
INR / 1 Euro 74.75
INR / 100 Jap. YEN 66.05
INR / 1 Pound Sterling 86.42
INR/ 1 SGD 48.84
POLICY RATESBank Rate 7.00%
Repo rate 6.50%
Reverse Repo rate 6.00%
Market Snapshot
www.iims-niveshak.com
RESERVE
RATIOSCRR 4.00%
SLR 21.00%
LENDING / DEPOSIT
RATESBase rate 9.30%-9.70%
Deposit rate 7.00% - 7.30%
Source: www.bseindia.com
www.nseindia.com
Source: www.bseindia.com
Source: www.bseindia.com
Date as on September 30th
Mark
et S
nap
shot
-2,000
-1,000
0
1,000
2,000
3,000
4,000
27200
27400
27600
27800
28000
28200
28400
28600
28800
29000
29200
01
-09
-20
16
02
-09
-20
16
06
-09
-20
16
07
-09
-20
16
08
-09
-20
16
09
-09
-20
16
12
-09
-20
16
14
-09
-20
16
15
-09
-20
16
16
-09
-20
16
19
-09
-20
16
20
-09
-20
16
21
-09
-20
16
22
-09
-20
16
23
-09
-20
16
26
-09
-20
16
27
-09
-20
16
28
-09
-20
16
29
-09
-20
16
BS
E
FII
, D
II N
et
turn
ov
er
(in
Rs.
Cro
res)
BSE DII FII
-2.50%
-2.00%
-1.50%
-1.00%
-0.50%
0.00%
0.50%
1.00%
1.50%
INR/1 USD Euro/1 USD GBP/1 USD JPY/1 USD SGD/1 USD
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE Of MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
7C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 7A
rticle of th
e Mon
th7
Co
ve
r S
tor
y7
Mark
et Sn
ap
shot
BSEIndex Open Close % change
Sensex 28459.09 27865.96 -2.08
MIDCAP 13236 13167 -0.52
Smallcap 12665 12781 0.91
AUTO 22043 22232 0.85
BANKEX 22683 22046 -2.81
CD 12488 12549 0.48
CG 15195 14582 -4.04
FMCG 8828 8461 -4.61
Healthcare 16144 16181 0.23
IT 10457 10229 -2.18
METAL 9943 9764 -1.80
OIL&GAS 11080 11378 2.68
POWER 2103 1990 -5.40
PSU 7511 7462 -0.65
REALTY 1542 1512 -1.93
TECK 5764 5631 -2.32
www.iims-niveshak.com
Market Snapshot
% CHANGE
Sensex, -2.08%
AUTO, 0.85%
BANKEX, -2.81%
CG, -4.04%
CD, 0.48%
FMCG, -4.16%
Healthcare, 0.23%
IT, -2.18%
METAL, -1.80%
MIDCAP, -0.52%
OIL&GAS, 2.68%
POWER, -5.40%
PSU, -0.65%
REALTY, -1.93%
Smallcap, 0.91%
TECK, -2.32%
1
% Change
Information Technology(10.91%)
Done on 30/6/14
Pharmaceuticals
(9.78%)
Dr Reddy’s Labs
Wg: 3.83%
Gain: 5.77%
Lupin
Wg: 5.95%
Gain : 29.94%
FMCG(21.84%)
BritanniaWg: 7.26%
Gain: 236.36%
Misc. (12.07%)
Amara Raja
Wg: 4.67%
Gain: 45.84%
Titan Company
Wg: 4.26%
Gain: 5.39%
Auto (9.94%)
Tata Motors
Wg: 5.27%
Gain: 26.15%
Infosys
Wg: 3.33%
Gain: 24.76%
HCL Tech.
Wg: 3.84%
Gain : 7.79%
Niveshak Investment Fund
ColgateWg: 5.62%
Gain : 26.70%
TCS
Wg: 3.74%
Gain : -3.91%
HULWg: 4.28%
Gain: 24.57%
Bank (7.05%)
ITCWg: 4.69%
Gain: 4.30%
Chemicals
(9.31%)
Asian Paints
Wg: 9.31%
Gain: 88.38%
HDFC Bank
Wg: 7.05%
Gain: 38.92%
Midcap Stocks (12.55%)
Bharat Forge
Wg: 3.93%
Gain: 3.74%
Kalpataru
Power
Wg: 4.01%
Gain: --2.53%
Natco Pharma
Wg: 4.61%
Gain: 17.67%
Textile
(6.56%)
Page Indus.Wg: 6.56%
Gain : 46.54%
Godrej Consm.
Wg: 7.81%
Gain: 86.44%
Risk Measures:
Standard Deviation : 19.21 (Sensex 9.93)
Sharpe Ratio : 3.34 (Sensex : 3.22)
Cash Remaining: 58,000
Performance EvaluationAs on 30th Sep 2016
Value Scaled to 100
Comments on NIF’s Performance & Way Ahead: The month of September saw
the markets remaining relatively tepid with not much movement in the markets.
The markets saw a bit of volatility due to the Fed meeting initially and later on
the tensions between India and Pakistan saw the market take a nosedive
The coming month will see the focus shift towards the company quarterly results
and the Reserve Bank of India monetary policy meet whose decision on key
interest rates could cause turmoil across the Indian markets.
The top performers during the month in the NIF were Natco Pharma and ITC
which saw a gain of 12% and 8% respectively whereas the laggards were Bharat
Forge and Amara Raja Batteries which fell by nearly 6% and 4% respectively.
95
105
115
125
135
145
155
165
175
185
30-01-2014 18-08-2014 27-02-2015 03-09-2015 16-03-2016 27-Sep-16
Performance of Niveshak
Investment Fund since Inception
Scaled Sensex
Scaled NIF
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
1/9 4/9 7/9 10/9 13/9 16/9 19/9 22/9 25/9 28/9
Sep Performance of Nivehshak
Investment Fund
Scaled Sensex Scaled NIF
Opening Portfolio Value : 10,00,000
Current Portfolio Value : 1681889
Change in Portfolio Value : 68.18%
Change in Sensex : 35.94%
10 NIVESHAKC
ov
er
Sto
ry
10E
qu
ity R
esea
rch
Rep
ort
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
Co
mp
an
y
Ba
ckg
ro
un
d
Bu
sin
ess
De
scrip
tio
n
Co
rp
ora
te
Go
ve
rn
an
ce
Rating Buy
Target Rs. 1114
Current Market price Rs. 868
Target Period 6-7 months
Potential Upside (Annualized) 28% (53%)
Rating Matrix
Gro
wth
D
riv
ers
EQUITY RESEARCH REPORT – Hindustan Unilever Limited Date: 30th September
Ticker (BSE) 500696
Ticker (NSE) HINDUNILVR
Sector FMCG
M- Cap ₹ 191257 Cr.
Basic Information
• Organised sector growth is expected to grow as the share of unorganised market in the FMCG sector fall with increased level of brand consciousness
• Growth in modern retail will augment the growth of organised FMCG sector
• Availability of products has become way more easier as internet and different channels of sales has made the accessibility of desired product to customers more convenient at
required time and place
• Rural consumption has increased, led by a combination of increasing incomes and higher aspiration levels, there is an increased demand for branded products in rural India
• Investment in this sector attracts investors as the FMCG products have demand throughout the year.
Jun - 16’ Mar – 16’ Dec – 15’
Promoter 67.20 67.21 67.21
Public 32.80 32.79 32.79
Others 0.00 0.00 0.00
Total 100.00 100.00 100.00
Shareholding Pattern (As per BSE)
Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL) is an Indian consumer goods company based in Mumbai, Maharashtra. HUL is a subsidiary of Unilever, one of the world’s leading suppliers of fast
moving consumer goods with strong local roots in more than 100 countries across the globe with annual sales of €48.4 billion in 2014. It is owned by Anglo-Dutch Company-Unilever
which owns a 67% controlling share in HUL. HUL's products include foods, beverages, cleaning agents, personal care products, and water purifiers.
HUL’s business falls primarily under 5 segments: Soaps, Detergents and Household Care, Personal Products, Beverages and Packaged foods. The primary sources of revenue for HUL
are Cosmetics (48.87%), Tea (25.92%) and soaps (16.19%). They have several brands such as Lux (Soap), Surf Excel (Detergent), Clinic Plus (Hair Care), Lifebuoy (Soap), etc. of which
the first 3 brands rank in the top 10 of ACNielsen Brand Equity list. A total of 16 brands of HUL feature in the list. The company has 35 brands spanning 20 categories of the FMCG
business & over 16,000 employees. Innovation has always been HUL’s key strengths.
The company has 5 independent directors out of total 9 members in board of directors. It follows
a differential remuneration policy for Non-Executive Directors, with the maximum limit of
remuneration payable to them is Rs 150 lakhs, for the period from 1st April 2013 to 31st March
2018. The Company has adopted the policies in line with new governance requirements
including the Policy on Related Party Transactions, Policy on Material Subsidiaries, CSR Policy and
Whistle Blower Policy.
HUL ER Report
Equity Research report
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
11C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 11E
qu
ity R
esearch
Rep
ort
In
du
stry C
om
pe
titio
n
Co
mp
ara
ble
Va
lu
atio
n
Te
ch
nica
l
An
alysis
Method Value/Share Weight Fair Value
Discounted Cash Flows 1067.13 0.33
963.07Relative Valuation 779.41 0.33
Residual Income Valuation 1042.66 0.33
Valuation Summary
Threat of New Entry – Medium
• Substantial investments are necessary to
achieve growth and economies of scale
Buyer power – High
• Consumers are generally willing to
experiment & brand loyalty is low
Supplier Power – Low
• Large number of suppliers are locally
available
• Raw material can be sourced locally
Threat of Substitutes – High
• Consumer needs are continuously shifting
• Newer products are being rapidly launched
by competitors
Using technical analysis we can estimate a short term target of 910 which is nearly a 5% upside from
current levels as the 50% retracement levels of the downtrend is around that level. The RSI and
MACD also indicates an oversold position and the likelihood of a bounce back is on the cards. In the
long term the stock may find resistance at the 950 level which is its 52 week high and approximately
near our expected target price.
Industry Rivalry
The industry is highly cluttered and there
are lots of companies competing for the
same market
In
du
stry
Fig
ure
We have calculated the stock’s intrinsic value based on a weighted average of DCF, Residual Income
and Relative multiples based valuation. Starting FY17, growth in revenues have been estimated at a
gradually declining rate averaging 15% for the first 5-yr and 3% for the next. Due to the non-cyclical
nature of business, the sensitivity of HUL stock is below 1, indicating a defensive nature with a WACC
of 6.9%. The fundamental value stands at Rs. 963 and given a CMP of Rs. 868 as on 30th Sep, ’16, the
stock is undervalued.
The near term profitability might be impacted by entry of competitors in the market however HUL
continues to enjoy a market leader position in many segments of the FMCG market and will continue
to earn a sizeable margin despite stiff competiton.
BUY: If stock is expected to deliver more than 10% annualized returns over holding period
NEUTRAL: If stock is expected to deliver (-)10% - 10% annualized returns over holding period
SELL: If stock is expected to deliver less than (-)10% annualized returns over holding periodRa
tin
g
De
fin
itio
n
EQUITY RESEARCH REPORT – Hindustan Unilever Limited Date: 30th September
The consumer durables market is expected to reach US$ 12.5 billion in 2015 and US$ 20.6 billion by
2020. Urban markets account for the major share (65 per cent) of total revenues in the consumer
durables sector in India. There is a lot of scope for growth from rural markets with consumption
expected to grow in these areas as penetration of brands increases. Also demand for durables like
refrigerators as well as consumer electronic goods are likely to witness growing demand in the
coming years in the rural markets as the government plans to invest significantly in rural
electrification.
The FMCG sector has grown at an annual average of about 11 per cent over the last decade. The
overall FMCG market is expected to increase at (CAGR) of 14.7 per cent to touch US$ 110.4 billion
during 2012-2020, with the rural FMCG market anticipated to increase at a CAGR of 17.7 per cent to
reach US$ 100 billion during 2012-2025.Food products is the leading segment, accounting for 43 per
cent of the overall market. Personal care (22 per cent) and fabric care (12 per cent) come next in
terms of market share.
SEPTEMBER 2016
12C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK12A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
th121212
IIM UDAIPUR
Siddarth Bhargava & Karan Verma
maintaining the history of inancial transaction. It will further integrate inancial inclusion of Indian society.
UPI is a type of payment system within standard set of Application Programming Interfaces (APIs) to facilitate online immediate payment systems, which leverages on increasing smartphones demand and Internet penetration. Unlike NEFT/RTGS/IMPS, the system is far more structured and standardized across other banks. This system will surely compete against the mobile wallets with much lesser transaction details to be inserted. The architecture of UPI is built on IMPS.
How does it Works?
The system is hassle free and it eiciently
Introduction
As soon as the Uniied payment interface was launched by Reserve bank of India, the speculations have been rife that this shall mark the end of payment wallets in India. The objective of this article is to understand Uniied Payment Interface or UPI and its diferent features along with understanding the impact of UPI on payment wallets.
Uniied Payment Interface (UPI)
With the motto “Power to Empower”, Digital India campaign was launched. National Payments Corporation of India (NPCI) brought this innovative idea of Uniied Payment Interface (UPI) to further digitize India and make it a cashless society. The digital systems help in removing opacity of cash while
Uniied Payment Interface and Its Impact on Payment
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE Of MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
13C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 13A
rticle of th
e Mon
th1313
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE Of MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
13
removes the hectic steps of entering account number, account type, bank name and IFSC code. Once the UPI enabled banks connects the individual to the system, the transaction can be initiated by inserting either of Aadhaar Number, mobile phone number or virtual payment address. The addresses are of two types – global and local. Global address includes Aadhaar, bank account number and mobile number. Local address is a virtual address, which is being provided by banks and resembles similar to email ID (xxx@icicibank).
The process is robust enough to complete transaction on inserting virtual number itself. The authentication by providing MPIN (Mobile Personal Identiication Number) and not OTP (One Time Password) further removes the inconvenience of waiting for the password to lash out. Successful transaction message will prompt up to complete the process. At back end, NPCI will maintain a database of customer’s mobile number, Aadhaar number and bank details. This central mapper (central
repository) will route out payment instructions based on the details. The ABPS (Aadhaar Payment Bridge System) will share this mapper for NACH (National Automated Clearing House) and impart subsidies or direct beneits to the individual.
Key Drivers of UPI
NPCI ideated of implementing UPI in order to simplify and bring down everything on a single payment interface. The key drivers are: -
Simplicity – Receiving and paying payment as smooth as swiping phonebook or making call is the primary motive. An account holder can pay the identiier with the “payment address” (Aadhaar Number, Virtual Payment Address, Mobile Number etc.) and not by illing account/bank details every time. The solution can be initiated from either side, which further eases down the process.
Adoption – Given the projection of Mobile and
NIVESHAK 13
SEPTEMBER 2016
14C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK14A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
th1414
Internet penetration in the upcoming year, the model is scalable. Pilot operations should allow gradual adoption of smartphones and feature phones. The consumer who is not yet using mobile application should also be getting beneited. Interoperability with diferent identiiers should not crash down the solution.
Innovation – The model allows innovations to be done on both side i.e. payee and payer side. Apart from it, the application providers should have advantage of enhancing mobile devices, providing integrated payments across diferent platforms, newer authenticating process which is hassle free etc.
Security – With the increasing cases of phishing, risk scoring etc. in this technological world, an individual always has concern about security of their data. The solution should provide end-to-end robust security and data protection. As per note speciied by NPCI, 1-click 2-factor authentication has been ofered in the solution that can be further improvised.
Cost – In a cost-conscious country like India, the costly product doesn’t long last. As mobile phones are being used for credential capture, virtual payment addresses and third party authentication schemes like Aadhaar, the cost is likely to be driven down for both the acquiring and issuing side.
Diferentiating features
Although we had payment wallets in the existing market, the solution ofers some of the contrasting features to scale it at large.
“Pay by Date” feature is added in the interface, which makes collective request to individual or group for payment on due date. Additionally snoozing option has been provided to pay the request before expiry date to escape from services being blocked.
Multiple recurring payment options with higher credit limit. Unlike payment wallets, the solution provides transaction for higher monetary value i.e. up to one lakh.
NPCI has indicated a charge of 0.50 INR per transaction, which will appear in bank statement as IMPS transaction. AP Hota, CEO & MD NPCI said, “Already a few banks (Yes Bank) out of 29 banks have gone live with UPI to serve their customers. A few other banks are
NIVESHAK
also likely to incorporate this game changing experience for their customers.”
Impact of UPI on Payment wallet
Ever since the launch of UPI by RBI, speculations have been rife that UPI will mark the end of payment wallets in this country. Since none of the banks have actually rolled out or integrated the platform to their existing apps, it’s very early and uninformed speculation to declare sudden deaths of wallets. Even today the number of wallet users in India is much more than the users base of any of the mobile banking app. Although the new interface seems to provide promising results in the future, but the impact on payment wallets is yet to be assessed properly.
As more and more banks integrate their existing apps with UPI, more and more customers are expected to use these apps for cash transfers. Majority of the people opting for these services are expected to be people who frequently transact with. As we understood that the main beneits of payment wallets are limited liability exposure and ease of transactions, the wallets to be impacted the most are the ones with just these value propositions. Wallets will have to evolve themselves to come up with better value propositions to make them more attractive.
Wallets have become main stream today with Paytm alone having more than 122 million users. The main hurdle for the UPI to overcome is cash which due to its iniquitousness, is the most famous medium for transactions. The ticket size of payments through UPI is expected to be not very high and equivalent to that of wallets.
With the growing internet and smartphone penetration, the number of wallet users have increased manifold due to the ease of usage and convenience. With the UPI integration in banking apps, the bank apps will add convenience of wallets but with added advantages of a bank account. The acceptability and ease of usage of banking apps will play a crucial role in deining the future course of UPI and its impact on payment wallets.
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE Of MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
15C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 15A
rticle of th
e Mon
th
But implementation and integration of UPI isn’t that simple with current banking apps. Training staf, upgradation of technology and changing perceptions of the people will include huge investments. Building trust among the consumers may also be a challenge for the banks for using UPIs.
UPI is essentially just an architecture for payments and rather than a competition, may as well act as enhancer of increasing acceptance for payment wallets. Currently most of the wallets either add money via Debit card, internet banking or cashbacks. The irst two modes of loading the money into wallets require a customer to have internet banking or debit card. With the introduction of UPI, this will no longer hold. People with a bank account, using a mobile banking app can transfer funds seamlessly to their wallets.
Since these wallets allow customers to pay to many merchants, the acceptance of bank apps and consequently UPI by the customers is important for the success of UPI architecture. Although the process of transferring money doesn’t require either of the recipient to share his/her account details and hence has a better chance to gain trust of the customers.
The major hindrance for the wallets is the fact that the commission structure is very huge and makes their model diicult to operate, in wafer thin margins. Payments of wallets through net banking or cards include transaction fees of two percent that is usually split between bank and wallet. The wallet gets a share of 0.4-0.5% which makes their business diicult to operate in. Huge transaction charges is another why many merchants, especially the smaller ones haven’t yet moved to online modes of payment. This is where RBI is working with introduction of UPI.
With more than 50 million small registered business, and two million of them paying service tax, wallets have been able to partner with only a fraction of them (30,000). There are still a lot of low hanging fruits in the market up for grab. The acceptance of UPI by these small merchants can go a long way in digitizing the economy and reducing physical cash.
As the economy moves more towards digitization, and with increased acceptance of online modes of payments, and if the wallets decide to evolve themselves into more than just a cash alternate, the UPI can be a game changer for the economy.
The most critical factor for the success of UPI is the seamless integration of it with banking apps and ease of use to increase the usage among the consumers. The technological framework seems to be the only challenge that the banks will have to overcome in order to make UPI a success.
To conclude, it’s too early to declare the death of payment wallets via UPI architecture. Although UPI does provide a plethora of opportunities in the digitization of money transfer in India
With the introduction of UPI, the adoption is highly dependent upon the customer touch point that is the banking apps. The banking apps will have to evolve to be as user friendly and convenient as the payment wallets and their apps are. Although the new customer base will be the one that comes from untapped market or cannibalized from wallet users is yet to be seen.
For wallets this is a technological breakthrough that will disrupt the payment wallets market. The UPI architecture can also provide the wallets an opportunity to tap the untapped market and bring more users to its platform, and at the same time they will have to evolve from just a digital wallet and provide more services to consumers like doorstep pickup of cash, micro-credit, hyper local transactions etc. to make the space more competitive.
But the real winner of the whole new evolved system will be RBI, which will be one step closer to creating a cashless society. At the same time Indian consumers will have the real ease and convenience of carrying any amount of money without the actual cash risk.
SEPTMEBER 2016
16 NIVESHAK
Co
ve
r S
tor
y
population have access to mobile phones. Next big challenge is the internet. Hence, Reliance Jio has invested Rs.15000 crores in laying down the optical ibre network all across India. Charging for SMS and voice will be redundant as many apps provide these facilities for free. Hence, telecom companies see potential customer base in the internet segment.
Reliance JIO Business Model
To target the India’s $50 billion telecommunication industry Reliance Jio has come up with various plans. The underlying rationale behind the business model of Reliance Jio is the more data you use, the cheaper it will be for you. Reliance Jio is promising to provide 1 GB data for as low as 50 rupees and subscription to all reliance Jio apps for free for one year. Another big feature of Reliance Jio plan is the free voice calling. In the
Mukesh Ambani at the Reliance Industries’ 42nd annual general meeting on 1 September’, 2016 made an announcement on Jio, RIL’s telecom venture, including its data tarif plans and the free voice call services across India. The 45 minutes speech resulted in 9800 crores and 2450 crore market capitalization loss for the two telecom giants Airtel and Idea Cellular respectively. The underlying business model of increasing the ‘willingness to pay’ for the customers so that they happily pay little more to get attractive services has triggered the price war with existing telecom operators.
Importance of 4G
Of 1 billion mobile users, only 34% have access to the internet, and only 10% of mobile users use 3G or above. Telecom companies have realised that there is not going to be movement in a voice now as 80% of the Indian
IIM SHILLONG
Ankit Singhal
Telecom Data War
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
17C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK
network providers, free data at night, access to JIO apps they are tempting users to pay more. The target of Reliance Jio is to get Rs 300 from
each customer by the year 2017.
Retaliation from other Telecom Carriers
As of now Reliance Jio has not been commercially rolled out. It will be available from Jan 2017, and then the number portability
year 1995, per call charges was INR 32 per minute but surprisingly after 21 years customer will get “free calls.” Also, they are providing unlimited data at night for 3 hours to attract the customer and eliminating the concept of roaming and SMS charges. Providing unlimited data won’t cost much as they have already laid down the optical ibres, ranging over 2.5 lakh kilometres so that it won’t cost them much. The average monthly revenue per user (ARPU) in India is Rs 150, and they have kept the lowest monthly plan of Rs 149 with all the facilities like SMS, voice calls
and roaming for free. By keeping the lowest monthly plan of 149, they have made sure to
earn at least the current average revenue from each customer. Their other monthly plans for the data users and with attractive facilities like 4G, more data compare to other telecom
SEPTMEBER 2016
18 NIVESHAK
Co
ve
r S
tor
y
option will also be available. So, other telecom operators have three months to make sure that they maintain their customer base or attract new customers with their pricing strategies.
Reliance Jio customers are reporting a huge
number of call drops, and big traic of call volumes is between Reliance Jio and Airtel. Reliance Jio released the live data on call drops its users are experiencing due to Airtel, Vodafone, and Idea not providing enough connectivity.
Airtel: Reliance Jio accused Airtel of ‘anti-competitive behaviour.’ Airtel, in turn, accused reliance Jio of not cooperating to cover up technical issues from Reliance Jio’s side.
Reliance Jio is providing free data, voice calls, and text services for the year 2016. To counterattack this scheme, Airtel has come up with 90 days of 4G service for Airtel 4g customers which is priced at 1495 starting from October 1, 2016.
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
19C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK
Beneits for the customer
Whenever tarif war has unleashed it has always beneited the customer, and the same will happen this time around too. The healthier the competition, better it would be for the customers. Customer will receive better service quality, 4G internet services at afordable prices. Current telecom war will ensure that internet speed will be faster than what has been previously provided by various telecom providers. The charges for roaming, SMS, voice calling won’t be taken from the customer. In the coming months, telecom operators may come up with even better plans to increase or retain the customer base. In the end, the quality of service provided by the telecom operators will decide the winner of this telecom war.
BSNL: BSNL came up with the plan of providing unlimited data for Rs 249 at a download speed of 2 Mbps. Consumers can download 300 GB of data and per Gb price will be less than Rs 1 which is very cheap for the Indian market. But unlike Jio’s ofer that is available for 4G customers, BSNL plan will be open for 2G and 3G customers.
Vodafone: Vodafone and BSNL signed a 2G intra-circle roaming agreement to use each other’s assets and network strength across the country. This strategic partnering will help BSNL in expanding its reach in urban areas and will help Vodafone in expanding its reach in the rural areas.
Vodafone has launched a scheme of ofering 10 GB 4G data at the cost of 1 GB for three months for the new handset (handset which has not used Vodafone sim in last six months).
Vodafone Group has pumped in Rs 47,700 crores of overseas investment into its Indian operation, to reduce the unit’s debt and to prepare for the upcoming auction. The move signals Vodafone’s aggressive intent in the spectrum auction for 4G waves.
Impact on upcoming Spectrum Auction
The aggressive price wars will have an impact on October’s spectrum auction. The mountains of debt along with the aggressive price war may result in $74 billion loss for the government in October’s auction. Some operators have decided to sit out of the auction, and some have decided not to go for certain wavelengths. India was planning its biggest sale of spectrum that can bufering on videos and can speed up download speed for 1 billion plus users in world’s 2nd largest smartphone market. Government generated $18 billion revenue from last year’s auction and $9.8 billion from the auction held in 2014 and this year they were planning to raise $83 billion from the auction. But, companies will spend a fraction of what they have spent in the previous auction to fend of the new market model of Reliance Jio and aggressive price tactics employed by other telecom carriers.
But, Vodafone is looking to spend big in this year’s auction and may spend up to Rs.16300 crores to boost 4G services
20 NIVESHAK2020 NIVESHAK20
SEPTEMBER 2016
and Credit Utilization leading to a complete overhaul of the current indirect tax system. GST will have a strong impact on almost all aspects of business operations, for instance, pricing of products and services, optimization of supply chain, IT, accounting and tax compliance systems. This comprehensive tax will cover all stages right from production to the sale and will be levied only on the value added at each stage of the process.
GST has been commonly accepted around the
world having acknowledgement of more than
GST is the biggest reform in the indirect tax structure of India since the economy began to be opened up 25 years ago. The Constitution Amendment Bill for Goods and Services Tax (GST) passed in the Rajya Sabha on 3 August 2016 will rework the taxation powers of the Centre and states, set up a GST council and roll out the new tax regime from April 2017. With the roll out of GST, a common Indian market will be developed and the cascading efect of tax on the cost of goods and services will be reduced. GST will impact the Tax Structure, Tax Computation, Tax Payment, Compliance
Fin
Gyaan
GST Impetus for Indian Economy
IIT BOMBAY
Vipin Sirohi
21C
ov
er
Sto
ry
21F
inG
yaan
NIVESHAK
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
Reform Measure
• Economic Union of India: Goods
can be easily moved across the country with
difused state boundaries which will encourage businesses to focus on pan-India operations.
• Simpler Tax Structure: By merging all
levies on goods and services, GST acquires
a very simple and transparent character with
less paperwork and reduction in accounting
complexities. A simpler tax regime will make
the manufacturing sector more competitive and
save both money and time.
• Reduced Tax Burden: Under the
present tax structure of India, a company has
to pay multiple taxes to the centre and state
governments, which results in the tax costs for
a business going up by many folds. However,
under GST, the cascading impact of these
multiple taxes will be eliminated.
140 countries and the tax rate is between 15%-
20% in most of the countries.
Taxation under GST
GST shall be levied concurrently by the Centre
(CGST) and the States (SGST). Both CGST
and SGST will be levied on the basis of the
destination principle. Thus, exports would be
exempted from domestic taxation, and tax on
imports would be levied in the same manner
as domestic goods and services. Inter-State
supplies within the country would attract an
Integrated GST (aggregate of CGST and the
SGST of the destination State). All the things
useful for the poor are expected to be kept out of
the tax bracket.
Achievements Expected of GST as a Policy
SEPTEMBER 2016
22C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK22A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
th • Uniform Tax Regime: To attract
industries and drive the economy of the state,
many states ofer complete or partial exemptions from the taxes. However, with only one or two
tax rates across the supply chain, state speciic advantages/disadvantages will be gone, thus
ofering a level playing ield for all stakeholders. • Greater Tax Revenues: A simpler taxation
regime will bring greater compliance thus
leading to increase in the number of tax payers
and in turn tax revenues for the government.
• Competitive Pricing: The total tax
component of any product manufactured in India
is about 25-30% of the cost of the product. After
implementation of GST, the tax paid by the inal consumer will come down in most of the cases
and it will help in boosting consumption, which
is further beneicial to companies. • Push to Exports: India is expected to
climb up the Ease of Doing Business ladder
quickly with a uniformed tax structured. The
competitiveness of Indian goods in international
market will increase with the fall in production
cost in domestic market. This bodes well
for exporters, who compete with global
manufacturers that operate on very diferent cost structures.
• Prepares for Ease of Doing Business:
With a uniformed tax structure under GST,
everyone expects India to better its Ease of
Doing Business ranking quickly. The reduced
tax on the manufacturing and procurements will
help reduce the price for exports and support
make in India campaign by making Indian
goods competitive in the global market. It will
help reduce compliance cost and make the time
taken for refunds shorter. This will thus, have an
overall favourable impact for the exporters in
terms of working capital funds and compliance,
this would indirectly help in boosting exports.
Also, uniformity in tax rates and procedures
will give the much needed conidence to foreign irms that are looking at investing in India. Impact on GDP and Inlation • A study by the National Council of
Applied Economic Research shows that GST
will boost India’s GDP growth by 0.9% to 1.7%.
• Global examples like that of Malaysia
and Canada show that in spite of careful planning,
there has been a spurt in prices following
the introduction of GST. In a research note,
Goldman Sachs, found that Asian countries,
which brought in GST between 1977 and
2015, reported an average increase of 1.1% in
inlation during the year of its implementation. Sachs, based on cross-country evidence and the
evidence from state VAT implementation, also
estimated that if the GST rate was 20% in India,
Fin
Gyaan
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE Of MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
23C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 23A
rticle of th
e Mon
th
retail inlation could rise 0.9% points. Retail food inlation has already built up over the years and in such scenario, any further increase in
inlation is likely to be a burden on the populace. • In July, retail inlation touched a 23-month high of 6.07%; wholesale price
inlation accelerated to 3.55% , the fastest in 23
months, led by rising prices of both food and
non-food articles. However, the Government,
through the FRMB act, is determined to balance
the revenue and deicit of states. For the irst time, by law, the inlation target will be ixed at 4% (+/- 2%).
Roadmap
• A GST Council will be formed within 60
days of the enactment of the Bill consisting of
representatives from the Centre as well as State.
The Council will make recommendations to the
Union and the States on model Goods & Service
tax laws, Place of Supply rules rates including
loor rates with bands of goods & service tax and any other matter relating to GST as the Council
may decide.
• Detailed outline of Joint Committee
constituted by Empowered Committee of the
State Finance Ministers on return and registration
refund, business processes of payment under
GST have been formulated and put in the public
domain for suggestions.
• The draft GST Law was formulated and
put in public domain for suggestions in June
2016.
• GST Network, an IT support of GST,
Fin
Gyaan
which will facilitate tax payment, online
registration and return iling, will be launched.• States will draft their respective GST
Legislations to enable them to implement GST,
which will be in line with the Central GST
Legislation.
Conclusion
In terms of growth, price and current account,
the macroeconomic impact of introduction of
GST will be signiicant. Although there will be a short-term narrow price impact on the larger
economy. However, a larger impact is expected
on the administrative compliance cost of GST
which is expected to increase the tax revenue
from “parallel” or “black” economy. With a
lourishing services sector and a high economic growth trajectory of India, a shift in income-
based tax to consumption-based tax is going
to provide substantial stimulus to source of
revenue.
SEPTEMBER 2016
24C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK24A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
th
It was the June of 2002 when WorldCom, the second largest company in the long-distance telecommunications, admitted to overstating its earnings by more than 3.8 billion USD in 2001 and the irst quarter of 2002. Not only that, later in the year it also announced about manipulating its reserve accounts to the tune of another 3.8 billion USD.
WorldCom began as Long Distance Discount Services Inc. in 1983, in Mississippi. By 1989, the shares of the company were being publicly traded and it had become a public limited corporation as an outcome of being merged with Advantage Companies Inc. In 1985, its name was changed to LDDS WorldCom and the head oice was shifted to Clinton, Mississippi.
The company witnessed rapid growth in the 1990s by making a series of acquisitions that boosted its reported revenues, rising from 154
million USD in the year 1990 to 39.2 billion USD in 2001. This rapid growth resulted in the company being ranked 42 in Fortune 500 list of companies.
The company’s name was changed to MCI WorldCom with the takeover of MCI in 1998, making it the second largest long-distance carrier in the United States. Later in 2000, the company’s name was changed to WorldCom.
Along with WorldCom, there were other telecommunications companies as well which were in inancial trouble, Qwest Communications, Global Crossing, Lucent Technologies, Enron, and Adelphia to name a few. The basic problem with all of these companies lied in the overly optimistic predictions of the market in the 1990s, driven by the internet growth and the dot-com bubble. As a result of this, when these
IIM SHILLONG
Aditya Jain
Fin
Rew
ind
WorldCom Scandal, 2002
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE Of MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
25C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 25A
rticle of th
e Mon
thF
inR
ewin
d
companies faced reduced demand as compared to the expectations of everyone, after the end of the dot-com bubble, their investors sufered major losses.
The market value of WorldCom fell from 150 billion USD in 2000 to 150 million USD in 2002, and the company iled for bankruptcy, admitting to overstating its earnings by classifying revenue expenditure as capital expenditure.
WorldCom paid other companies for using their communication networks (these costs are called line costs), and it classiied these payments as capital expenditure instead of revenue expenditure, reducing its expenses and thereby increasing proits, falsely overstating its earnings.
Line costs consist of access fee and transport charges for WorldCom customers’ messages. As reported, around 3.055 billion USD in 2001 and 797 million USD in 2002 Q1 was classiied under capital expenditure. By doing so, the company was able to spread its current expenses evenly in the coming years, increasing both its net income and assets in 2002.
In July 2002, WorldCom said that there might be a possibility of irregularities existing in its reserve accounts and that it was investigating the same. Reserve accounts are meant to provide a security for predictable events, like future tax liabilities, and the management is not supposed to tamper
with the reserve accounts with the purpose of changing its reported earnings. In August of the same year, WorldCom further admitted to using its reserves in improper ways. They had reduced the reserve accounts to provide credits against the line costs.
The motive of top management behind committing this fraud was pretty clear. After the dot-com bubble had ended, the economy was down in recession and all the telecommunications witnessed a reduction in the demand, including
WorldCom. Revenues were at an all-time low, far below the expectations of the investors; and to top all of this, WorldCom had taken a lot of debt to expand its operations. The market value of WorldCom had plunged and therefore, the management had a powerful motive to conceal bad news by engaging in false accounting practices.
So who discovered the fraud? Cynthia Cooper, the then WorldCom’s internal auditor, found that line costs were being treated as capital expenditure in the May of 2002. This matter was discussed between the auditor, the chief inancial oicer of WorldCom, Scott D. Sullivan, and the company’s controller, David F. Myers. The internal auditing team often worked secretly at night to reveal the fraud.
The head of the audit committee of WorldCom’s Board of Directors, Max Bobbitt, was also informed about the matter by Ms Cooper on or about June 12th. Max Bobbitt sought the intervention of the company’s external auditor, KPMG into the matter (KPMG replaced Arthur Anderson as the external auditor of WorldCom in May 2002).
Soon after the fraud was exposed, the CFO was dismissed from the job, the controller resigned himself, and the company’s previous auditor, Arthur Anderson, immediately withdrew its audit opinion for 2001, stating that it was not notiied about line costs being treated as capital expenditure. The Securities and Exchange Commission of the United States began investigating the matter on June 26, 2002.
In July 2002, Tauzin, chairman of the House Energy and Commerce Committee, announced that the internal documents of the company and the mails exchanged between the executives clearly indicated that the executives knew about the fraud from as early as the summer of 2000.
WorldCom iled for bankruptcy protection under the Chapter 11 on July 21, 2002, making it the largest such iling in the history of United States at the time. The company paid 750 million USD to the SEC in the form of cash and stock by the bankruptcy reorganization agreement.
In the deal concluded between SEC and WorldCom, it was agreed that WorldCom would pay a civil penalty of 2.25 billion USD. Former SEC chairman, Richard C. Breeden, was appointed by Jed Rakof, the then federal judge, to oversee WorldCom’s compliance with
SEPTEMBER 2016
26C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK26A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
thF
inR
ewin
d
the agreement between them and the SEC. Breeden prepared a report, “Restoring Trust” for Rakof. He suggested a lot of corporate governance reforms as part of an efort to “cast the new MCI into what he hoped would become a model of how shareholders should be protected and how companies should be run”.
Some of the Consequences
Even before the announcement in June 2002, the share of WorldCom had fallen from 64.50 USD in 1999 to less than 2 USD per share which further declined to below 1 USD a share after the announcement and then it went down the
drain to a few pennies per share after the news that there were further irregularities in the accounting practices followed by WorldCom.
Many employees of WorldCom who held stock in the company also sufered huge losses. About 32% or 642.3 million USD of WorldCom retirement funds were in company stock at the end of 2000. By 2002, this had fallen to less than 18.7 million USD or 4% of the funds.
The company cut 17,000 employees of from its workforce of 85,000 in 2002.
In the August of 2002, a group was formed by the name of exWorldCom 5100. It consisted of 5100 former employees (who were dismissed on June 28, 2002 before the bankruptcy petition by WorldCom) of the company with the objective of receiving full payment of
severance pay and beneits according to the WorldCom Severance Plan.
Post-Bankruptcy
By the end of 2003, according to the estimates, the value of total assets that had been inlated by the company stood at about 11 billion USD. This resulted in the WorldCom scandal being the largest accounting fraud in the history of America until 2008.
In 2004, with close to 5.7 billion USD in debt and 6 billion USD in cash, WorldCom emerged from the bankruptcy under Chapter 11. Half of the cash was meant to pay the claims
and settlements that were due. Previous bondholders were paid 35.7 cents for every dollar due, that too in the form of bonds and stocks of the newly formed company, MCI Inc. All of the stock of previous shareholders was cancelled, making it completely useless for them.
There were creditors waiting for 2 years for payment, they were yet to be paid; these also included some of the employees who were dismissed during 2002.
In February 2005, Verizon Communications acquired MCI for 7.6 billion USD.
Bernard Ebbers, who was the CEO of WorldCom at the time when the scandal happened, was found guilty of every charge against him and was convicted of fraud, conspiracy, and iling false documents with regulators, on March
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE Of MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
27C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 27A
rticle of th
e Mon
thF
inR
ewin
d
15, 2005. All of this was related to the 11 billion USD accounting scandal. He received a sentence of imprisonment for 25 years. At that time, Ebbers’s age was 63 years. He surrendered himself in September of 2006 to the Federal Bureau of Prisons prison at Oakdale, Louisiana to serve his sentence.
In March 2005, 16 out of 17 former underwriters of WorldCom reached settlements with the investors. Citigroup had settled for an amount of 2.65 billion USD.
In December 2005, an announcement was made by Microsoft that MCI will be joining it by providing “Voice over Internet Protocol” (VoIP) service to Windows Live Messenger users for making telephone calls. This was called MCI Web Calling and it was MCI’s last new product. After the merger with Verizon, this service was renamed as Verizon Web Calling.
Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX)
As a reaction to a slew of corporate scandals, including that of WorldCom, Sarbanes-Oxley Act was passed which is the most sweeping set of new business regulations since the 1930s.
According to the Act, the accuracy of inancial information must be individually certiied by the top management. Additionally, penalties have been made more severe for any fraudulent inancial practice committed. Also, the independence of statutory auditors has been increased.
The Act contains 11 sections which range from telling about the duty of the Board of Directors to the criminal penalty that can be awarded to a person being involved in a fraud. It also requires the SEC to implement rulings on requirements for complying with the law.
The Act was approved by the House by a vote of 423 favouring, 3 opposing, and 8 abstaining, and it was approved by the Senate with a vote of 99 favouring and 1 abstaining. The law was signed into by President George W. Bush who stated that it includes “the most far-reaching reforms of American business practices since the time of Franklin D. Roosevelt. The era of low standards and the false proits is over; no boardroom in America is above or beyond the law”.
There was a perception that there is a need for stricter inancial governance. This resulted in SOX-type regulations being subsequently enacted in Germany, Canada, South Africa,
Australia, France, India, Japan, Israel, Italy, and Turkey.
There has been opposition to the Act as well. Opponents argue that the bill has reduced the international competitive edge of America against foreign inancial service providers by introducing an overly complex regulatory environment in the inancial markets of America.
On the contrary, the proponents consider the bill to be a godsend. They believe that it has improved the conidence that one can display in the trustworthiness of corporate inancial statements.
WorldCom scandal was one of the biggest scandals in history and was among those which resulted in the inception of Sarbanes-Oxley Act which made laws more stringent and made it diicult for the companies to commit such frauds as in the case of WorldCom.
SEPTEMBER 2016
28C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK28A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
thF
insi
gh
t
Introduction
BRICS refers to an acronym given by the Chief Economist, Mr O’Neill, of Goldman Sachs in 2001. It refers to a bunch of emerging economies -Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa. According to him these economies held a lot of potential to become the next superpower because these countries were developing at a rapid pace. These economies also looked attractive to investors because of their expanding middle class and massive development in terms of infrastructure. Added to this these countries also encompass 25% of the world’s land coverage and 40% of the world’s population. Each country was unique in itself it had its own capabilities and strengths. For example- Brazil is blessed with immense natural resources,
agricultural products to be speciic. Russia has huge deposits of oil, natural gas and coal. India’s strength lies in its natural resources as well as its labour force which is skilled and its IT sector. China is a manufacturing hub and is a export driven economy. It has a huge potential for hydropower as well.
From BRIC to BRICS:
South Africa was not a part of BRIC it was added only in 2010. The economists felt that there should be a representation from the African nations because Africa was second largest and most populous continent after Asia. Even though South Africa was smaller than Nigeria it became a part of BRICS because it had abundant natural resources, developed infrastructure and was a business hub. China was the one
TA PAI MANAGEMENT INSTITUTE, MANIPAL
Keerthana Raghavan
BRICS - The Fuel to the World’s
Growth Engine
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
29C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 29C
lassro
om
Fin
sigh
t
that pushed for South Africa’s entry into BRICS because China has a huge stake in South Africa across diverse sectors such as banking, infrastructure, transport and renewable energy. China and South Africa are good trading partners and it is expected in future that China will diversify its investment in South Africa by investing in sectors ranging from biotechnology to IT. South Africa adds strategic value by being a part of BRIC because of its mineral wealth and ofers highly specialised mineral- related professional services.
Expectations when BRICS was created:
The idea was BRICS was that the countries would help each other in facilitating trade and cooperate with each other in trade, investment opportunities and other such areas. Basically it was meant to improve the bond between the emerging counties which was initially weak. The objective was met by holding high proile meetings once in a year to discuss important issues and to improve trade relations. The move was somewhat successful because when Russia was about to be excluded from G20 the BRICS criticised the West for its attempts. It saved Russia from being isolated both economically and politically. Thus, in
this way BRICS grouping has played an important role in international afairs.
One of the initiatives taken by the BRICS member countries was to establish NDB (National Development Bank) for infrastructure funding of the emerging economies. The news of establishment came as a major shock for World Bank and IMF (International Monetary Fund) because they felt that their control over emerging economies was eroding gradually because the now these countries would be self-suicient. NDB was created because of the discriminatory attitude of the West towards countries like India and China. But the initiatives came with a cost. It was feared that China would try to exert its inluence and hence take up more resources than required for funding its needs.
Current scenario/reality of BRICS
The intentions behind grouping a couple of emerging economies was pretty noble but it did not operationalize because each country was too diferent, they did not have the synergy. Each one of them is facing a unique problem right from economic slowdown to steep fall in commodity prices. Ever since the Federal Reserve said that the American economy is doing well,
SEPTEMBER 2016
30C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK30A
rtic
le o
f th
e M
on
thF
insi
gh
t
the investors are pulling out money from emerging economies and shifting it to the developed economies. The other smaller countries like Mexico, Indonesia etc. are expected to do well. The situation is bad in China because it could not sustain its
growth rate of previous decade.
Russia on the other hand is facing its own set of troubles because of its high dependency in its oil and gas sector because exporting oil and gas is its major source of revenue. Hence, steep fall in commodity prices has had a huge negative impact on Russia. The Ukraine Crisis added to its woes and Russia was isolated both politically and economically. When trade relations with other countries are impacted, the growth of the country gets impacted. The Russian central Bank also raised its Interest rates so as to save its falling currency (Ruble).
Brazil is undergoing a political turmoil with the President Dilma Roussef stepping down and there has been a recent scandal linked to state oil and gas irm Petrobas. Economically there is a huge iscal deicit and the economic growth has been at a turtle’s pace. The iscal deicit has arisen due to non-repayment of loans that the government had borrowed from the government banks. The Central Bank of Brazil has not been very eicient in curbing the non-discretionary spending. It is clearly a case wherein a iscal crisis has led to economic crisis. Another reason is slowdown in China and Brazil being the largest exporter was hit the largest. The unemployment levels are high, inlation around 9% and Zika virus that became famous which could potentially have an impact on sales of tickets.
India looks pretty decent compared to others because its economic conditions have improved. Various iscal and monetary
policies have worked well and it is the favourite destination for the investments in the current scenario. Japan and China have also invested in India especially in infrastructure.
The Road Ahead for BRIC Nations:
The greatest lesson from the emergence of the BRICs is that no rise is complete without the triumph of the middle class. The record across these four countries is exceptional, but there is still considerable room for growth. The US should cooperate and work to improve the NDB that was established. The BRICS can be successful if they grow, provide investment opportunities for outside investors, and interact smoothly with International Financial Institutions (IFIs). The BRICS bank can work and cooperate with Asian Development Bank and World Bank. The BRICS face the challenge of containing China’s drive to control institutions that were supposed to give each partner an equal voice during critical decisions. The BRICS will hold a minimum stake of 55 percent in the bank but some analysts say China could increase its hold by bringing in new member countries from its sphere of inluence hence end up getting more say and decision making power. Other than BRICS there are N-11 countries as well that are poised to transform the world economy. US being the world superpower can become a thing of past if the emerging economies (BRICS) work together in a collaborative manner and strive to be the best by working on their major weakness which is corruption and capitalism.
Fin
Gyaan
Fin
Gyaan
31C
ov
er
Sto
ry
31F
inV
iewNIVESHAK
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
condition is moving up. When one has surplus
funds, which is left behind once the disposable
income has satiated all utility buckets, then
one starts thinking about health, life and other
assets, that brings the pull automatically.
The insurance industry has to make it very
convenient for the consumers. Whenever
the need arises, the industry should be at its
tip. Today, the Uber’s and Ola’s are providing
nothing but convenience. They are not
investing in physical assets. The shift for the
insurance industry too, has to be towards
providing convenience to the consumers. The
tipping will happen on its own.
Insurance business is based on relationship
management. We have changed our tagline
to say “Relationship beyond insurance”. In the
industry, claims are not very frequent. The
maximum is in the car segment which is one-
third. For homes, it is one in hundred. For health,
it is one-tenth, which means that 90% people
do not experience insurance beneits. Hence,
they lose charm in insuring. But, we have seen
historically that the year when people remove
the cover, is the year they end up needing it. In
such situations, all their assets get wiped-of.
Hence, the relationship aspect of the insurance
industry is very important. We need to provide
convenience, accessibility and go beyond
claims. For example, in a health product, we are
adding beneits like pharmacy discounts, gym
discounts, spa discounts, wellness tips – these
are the services you usually pay for. So, even
if you don’t have claims, throughout the year
something is beneitting you. In car insurance,
How does Bajaj Allianz go about planning its
investment? What is their security selection
philosophy?
Investment managers make their decisions
based primarily on fundamental research.
One of the things which investment managers
often overlook is the emotional aspect of
the markets. Emotions play a big role in
deciding the stock movements and the overall
behaviour of the market. Most of the time,
we do calculations on how the industry is
performing, where do the valuation ratios
stand. These are important factors which
contribute to 70-80% of the performance but
it’s the human aspect of the market which
often provides the alpha. However, in the long
run, it is extremely diicult to beat the market.
I once had the privilege to interact with Mr.
Warren Bufet and his points of advice were:
• Put your money in which you think
is long term. Invest primarily in non-cyclical
companies which are say recession-proof
• Gauge the sentiments, the strengths
and the management of a company before
investing
In the Indian Insurance industry, currently lot of
transactions happen via push selling initiated
by the insurance company correspondents.
Many people view insurance products as
investment tools and not as vehicles to hedge
against risk. How can we convert the market to
a pull-based selling model?
This would come naturally. When a country’s
economic condition improves, the insurance
penetration goes up. In India, the economic
Mr. Tapan SinghelMD & CEO
Bajaj Allianz
32 NIVESHAK3232 NIVESHAK32
Fin
Gyaan
SEPTEMBER 2016
Talking about the market, what are the kind of
events that create volatility and how can the
market players safeguard against it?
Perception has a big role to play in market
volatility. What exactly is recession – people
unwilling to buy because they are unsure
about their future earnings. When people are
in a positive mood about the economy, the
car sales pick up. So, volatility is caused mostly
by human emotions. A good fund manager
needs to observe the sentiments of the masses
through all possible news vehicles – social
media in particular as it captures the reactions
well. The days of the fund manager reading
only reports and balance sheets are gone.
Today, there are so many online tools available
to analyse the trends of the consumers. It
is important to combine fundamental and
technical research with customer sentiment
analysis in today’s dynamic conditions.
support in new projects and beneiciaries
we have added beneits like replacement of
punctured tyres, batteries etc. and other forms
of road-side assistance.
We have gone much beyond claims as that
is a small segment of the population. The
experience should be beyond claims and
that is how the industry will evolve. The focus
should be on solution-orientation rather than
selling products as such because when you are
pushing something, nobody wants to buy.
With the advent of technology, can Internet
of Things (IoT) add value to the insurance
industry?
IoT has a big role to play in the insurance
industry. If you look at telematics, though
the manufacturers have put it in the car for
analysing the engine damages and issuing
pre-warnings to the customer, the insurance
industry in developed countries has started
making big use of it. Selected insurance
providers can now it this clever device into
your car that measures how well you drive.
By having the device installed in your car, it’s
possible for you to prove that you drive safely.
Your premiums are then based on how safe
and conscientious a driver you are instead of
paying for insurance based on the average
driver.
Look at the wearable devices for health
monitoring. The devices track your physical
training, your itness levels and guide you
on the same. So, IoT and insurance are going
to be heavily integrated. The only challenge
is customer data privacy as the customers
have to give access to their data. This would
help us analyse their trends and customise
our oferings. Now, even this challenge has
softened a bit as the customers are opening up
and the issue of data privacy is being taken care
of due to their habit of going online for most of
their needs. They know that the Google’s and
the Amazon’s of the world already have a lot of
their data. So, the future looks very promising
in terms of IoT.
Fin
Vie
w
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
33C
ov
er
Sto
ry
NIVESHAK 33C
lassro
om
Sir, what is margin trading?
Margin trading allows an investor to
buy more stock and shares than one would
normally be able to with their own money. Efectively, trading on margin is like borrowing money from a
broker to purchase stock. Usually, trading on margin
is carried out through a separate account called a
margin account.
Sir, is there a cost associated with
borrowing?
Yes, it is in essence, a loan from the
broker which carries a ixed rate of interest. Therefore, an investor would enter into margin trading
only if he sees gains which beats the interest costs.
Further, the securities purchased with the borrowed
sum will act as collateral.
But what if the anticipated increase in
price does not take place? Who bears the
loss?
The investor is the risk taker, acting
beyond his normal capacity with a view to enjoy
substantial gains, but at the possible cost of substantial
losses. It is like trading with leverage. Thus, should
there be a decline in price, the efect on the investor is increased due to borrowing additional capital.
Sir, and if the loss is beyond the
capacity of the investor to cover, how does
the broker ensure his interests are covered?
This is where a margin requirement
comes into play. The investor does not use only
borrowed money for trading. Before approaching the
broker for additional money, the investor is required
to deposit an initial investment (set as a percentage
or a minimum amount or a combination of both)
which serves as a capital lock-in. Thus, if the price
of the security falls, the initial investment serves as
a cushion for the lender to ensure that his money is
secure.
With computerization, the margin requirements
is constantly updated at the terminal of the broker.
As stock prices decline, the margin requirements is
updated and if the value of the stock goes below a
predetermined threshold, a margin call is made and an
amount is to be deposited by the investor (borrower) to
make good any unrealized loss. This amount is called
the maintenance margin. If the additional amount is
not deposited, the broker has the right to sell a part of
the stock to cover the requirement.
Are brokerage charges any diferent under margin trading?
No, brokerage and DP charges are
the same and equivalent for normal delivery. Further,
margin trading is not allowed on derivatives.
CLASSROOM
FinFunda
of the
Month
Margin Trading
IIM ShillongAnoop Prakash
3434
W I N N E R S
Article of the MonthPrize - INR 1500/-
Siddarth Bhargava & Karan VermaIIM Udaipur
A N N O U N C E M E N T SALL ARE INVITED
Team Niveshak invites articles from B-Schools all across India. We are looking for
original articles related to inance & economics. Students can also contribute puz-
zles and jokes related to inance & economics. References should be cited wherever
necessary. The best article will be featured as the “Article of the Month” and would
be awarded cash prize of Rs.1500/- along with a certiicate.
Instructions
» Please send your articles before 15th May, 2016 to [email protected]
» The subject line of the mail must be “Article for Niveshak_<Article Title>”
» Do mention your name, institute name and batch with your article
» Please ensure that the entire document has a wordcount between 1500- 2000
» Format: Microsoft WORD File, Font: - Times New Roman, Size: - 12, Line spacing:
1.5
» Please do NOT send PDF iles and kindly stick to the format
» Number of authors is limited to 2 at maximum
» Mention your e-mail id/ blog if you want the readers to contact you for further
discussion
» Also certain entries which could not make the cut to the Niveshak will get ig-
ured on our Blog in the ‘Specials’ section
SUBSCRIBE!!Get your OWN COPY delivered to inbox
Drop a mail at [email protected]
Thanks
Team Niveshak
35
© FINANCE CLUB, INDIAN INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT SHILLONG
COMMENTS/FEEDBACK MAIL TO [email protected]
http://iims-niveshak.com
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED
Finance Club
Indian Institute of Management, Shillong
Mayurbhanj Complex,Nongthymmai
Shillong- 793014