The IEA HIA 2009-2020:

ThemesCollaborative RD&D that advances hydrogen science and technology

Hydrogen production

Hydrogen storage

Integrated hydrogen systems

Integration of hydrogen in existing infrastructure

Understanding, Awareness and Acceptance that fosters technology

diffusion and commercialization

Information dissemination

Safety

Outreach

Analysis that positions hydrogen

Technical progress and optimization

Market preparation and deployment

Support in political decision-making

3AN IMPLEMENTING AGREEMENT OF THE INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY

Task PortfolioNR NAME DURATION STATUS

18 Integrated Systems Evaluation 2004‒2009 completed

19 Hydrogen Safety 2004‒2010 completed

21 Biohydrogen 2005‒2010 completed

21 Bioinspired and Biological Hydrogen Production 2010‒2014 completed

22 Fundamental & Applied H2 Storage Materials Development 2006‒2012 completed

23 Small-Scale Reformers for on-Site H2 Supply 2006‒2011 completed

24 Wind Energy and Hydrogen Production (Electrolysis) 2006‒2011 completed

25 High Temperature Production of Hydrogen 2007‒2011 completed

26 Advanced Materials for Waterphotolysis with H2 2008‒2013 completed

27 Near-Term Market Routes to H2 via Co-Gasification with Biomass 2009‒2011 completed

28 Large-Scale Hydrogen Delivery Infrastructure 2010‒2013 ongoing

29 Distributed and Community Hydrogen (DISCO H2) 2011‒2013 ongoing

30 Global Hydrogen Analysis 2010‒2013 ongoing

31 Successor Hydrogen Safety Task 2010‒2013 completed

32 H2 Based Energy Storage 2013‒2016 ongoing

33 Local H2 Supply for Energy Applications 2013‒2016 ongoing

34 BioH2 for Energy & Environment (Successor to Task 21) 2014‒2017 approved

35 Renewable Hydrogen 2014‒2017 approved

36 Life Cycle Sustainability Assessment (LCSA) (Successor Task 30) 2014-2017 approved

37 Safety 2015-2018 approved

38 Power-to-Gas 2015-2018 APPROVED

Marine Sector In Definition

IEA/HIA Task 38

Power-to-Hydrogen and Hydrogen-to-X: System Analysis of techno-economic, legal and regulatory conditions

Paul Lucchese, ExCo Father and Mentor of the Task - CEAAlain Le Duigou - CEA

Christine Mansilla – CEA

CEN-CENELEC WG SFEM Meeting 4 th may 2016

Brussels

IEA – HIA Task 38Power-to-Hydrogen and Hydrogen-to-X: System Analysis of the

techno-economic, legal and regulatory conditions

The “Power-to-hydrogen” concept means that hydrogen is produced via low carbon electricity electrolysis

Electricity supply can be either:• On-Grid• Off-grid• or Hybrid systems

With particular attention devoted to:• Provision of services to the gris• Characterization of hydrogen’s relevance for energy storage.

“Hydrogen-to-X” implies that the hydrogen supply concerns a large portfolio of uses:• Transport/mobility : hydrogen for fuel cells;• Gas grid (“Power to gas”): Mixing with natural gas grid or methanation?;• Industry (refinery, steel, ammonia, synfuels, etc.); • Re-electrification: Fuel cell, Gas turbine.

Scope of the Task 38

IEA – HIA Task 38Power-to-Hydrogen and Hydrogen-to-X: System Analysis of the

techno-economic, legal and regulatory conditions

To provide a comprehensive understanding of the various technical and economic pathways for power-to-hydrogen applications in diverse situations;

To provide a comprehensive assessment of existing legal frameworks;

To provide business developers and policy makers with general guidelines and recommendations that enhance hydrogen system deployment in energy markets.

A final objective will be to develop hydrogen visibility as a key energy carrier for a sustainable and smart energy system, within a 2 or 3 horizon time frame: 2020, 2030 and 2050, for example.

Objectives of the Task 38

IEA – HIA Task 38Power-to-Hydrogen and Hydrogen-to-X: System Analysis of the

techno-economic, legal and regulatory conditions

Four years / two phases

1/General state of the art survey of

-existing portfolio of studies on techno-economic and business cases and smart Analysis

- existing legal framework and macro-economic impacts, including demo/deployment projects;

2/Detailed specific case studies, based on detailed targets

defined during the first phase, together with elaboration of legal and regulatory conditions, policy measures, and general guidelines for business developers and policy makers as well as public and private financial mechanisms and actors.

Inside Task 38: Structure and Task Forces

Subtasks2 Mapping and Review / analysis of existing demo project

3A Review/analysis the existing economic studies on Power-to-Hydrogen

3B Review of different existing legal frameworks, policy measures

4 Systemic approach and macro economic impact analysis

5 Specific case studies

Interfaces with other projects and initiatives: IEA/HIA tasks (36, 33 …), IEA/RETD, IEA secretariat, organisations (EASE, IPHE, NOW, …),

CEN/CENELEC WG

state of the art

Detailedcase studies

Task Forces

Methodology(screening sheets)

DefinitionsTaxonomy

Services to the grid

Data Electrolyzers’data

Common basis for a common work

9

Task 38: major deliverables for phase 1

Reference document (ST1)

Semi annual reports (ST1, with the help of the partners)

Intermediate Report and Data base on state of the art of demonstration projects (ST 2)

Intermediate Report on state of the art of techno-economic studies (ST 3A)

Intermediate Report on state of the art of legal framework (ST 3B)

Intermediate Report on selection of data base and case studies

Global synthesis (ST1 / coordinators and all the partners): short summary and reference to the Intermediate Reports, results of the case studies, guidelines

for business developers, recommendations for policy makers.

10

Subtasks 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022

ST1

ST2

ST3A

ST3B

ST4

ST5

Deliverables

Meetings

Task 38 preliminary timeline

KO meeting

6th month

meeting

Mid-termmeeting

END meeting

Springand Fall

meetings

1 2 3

1 : organization / methodology / common vision of the Task

2 : general state of the art survey

3 : detailed specific cases studies

4 years ?More ?

11

12

Subtask 1 / coordinationManagement team today: Paul Lucchese and 2 co-Operating agents, Alain Le Duigou and Christine Mansilla from CEA laboratory I-tésé: Institute for Technico-economics of Energy Systems (Support contract with French agency

Ademe for at least 18 months)

Organization of the Kick-Off meeting in Paris on January 28th 201630 participants from 13 countries (today ca. 40 people involved)

• To achieve a common vision of the Task objectives and structure• First exchange on participants’ role and subtask leaders• Identify the next steps• Schedule next meeting

Discussions and debates about:- The scope and objectives of the Task (« low carbon », « power » to H2,

H2 to « X », …)- The issues, topics, markets to consider

First arrangement of the SubTasks and Task Forces contributors and leaders

Launching of a « Reference Document » that describes the Task, the organization, and the SubTasks and Task Forces specifications

Participants and possible participants to the Task

FranceGermanyDenmarkSwedenNorwayThe NetherlandsBelgiumRomaniaBulgariaUKSpainAustraliaUSA

ItalyAustriaSwitzerlandJapanKorea ?Canada ?

Non OECD:Argentina ?China ?Participants

today

Possible participants

14

SubTasks: contributors and leadersSubTask Contributors Leader

2 Mapping and Review / analysis of existingdemo project

ICSI, JRC, FCH JU, DGC, SWECO, HA, Hydrogenics, DBI, CEA, IFE ? UCL

3A Review/analyse the existing economicstudies on Power to Hydrogen

CEA, Hydricity, Imperial College, ICSI, DMU, DGC, SWECO, HA, Hydrogenics, Air Liquide, FZJ, Southern Company , IFE ?

FZJ

3B Review of different existing legalframeworks, policy measures

ICSI, Hydrogenics, Southern Company, CEA, BAS JRC

4 Systemic approach and macro economicimpact analysis

Hydricity, Imperial College, ICSI, DMU, JRC, Air Liquide, SWECO ?

5 Specific case studies CEA, Hydricity, Imperial College, ICSI, UCL, HA, Air Liquide, FZJ, Southern Company, SWECO ?

Task Forces: contributors and leadersTask Forces Contributors Leader

M3A Methodology ST 3A CEA, Hydricity, Imperial College, DMU, JRC, SWECO, FZJ FZJ

Def Definitions Hydricity, Imperial College, ISCI, CEA, Engie ?

SG Services to the Grid CEA, DMU, Air Liquide, Clean Horizon ?, AREVAH2Gen ?, ITM ?

D Data Imperial College, JRC, CEA

ED Electrolysers’ Data Imperial College, UCL, Hydrogenics, Areva H2 Gen Air Liquide, IFE ?, JRC ?, ITM ?

UCL

Subtask 3A and 3B / already done

Objective: publish a reference document “labelled” Task 38

Support of Bulgarian Academy of Science : Marin Pandev (in Paris 2 Months late 2015) PhD

Creation and work of a first methodology group (M 3A)Definition of a first methodology sheet for literature review

First list of studies gathered / more than 200 documents today, including focus on native language studies

ST1: Creation (CEA) of a secured Internet sitedocuments, data, minutes, forum, …

- Proposal of a screening sheet as a common analysis grid of the studies to be discussed and agreed upon

- 2 levels analysis grid: quick scan / thorough reading- First Web Seminar in May

CommunicationFirst actions engaged: task summary, participation to the WHEC

WHEC – Dedicated IEA HIA Session

Under the topic "Countries Strategies/Associations/Assessments"

Semi-annual reports, project reportsPublic internet site plannedReviews for publications

Conferences communications

…… and the current presentation !

RE-P2G for non-individual transport

Selection of technologies and policies

18AN IMPLEMENTING AGREEMENT OF THE INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY

Potential Collaborations/Synergies with CEN-

CENELEC Working Group

ST2 Establishment of Data base on Demo project

(world wide)

ST3B : Review of different existing legal frameworks, policy measures

TF « Terminology/Taxonomy »

Others ?

18

20

Backup

21

Participants to the Task, Kick Off meeting attendance

Mary-Rose Valladares mvalladares@ieahia.org IEA HIADenis Thomas dthomas@hydrogenics.com HydrogenicsEverett Anderson eanderson@protononsite.com Proton on siteNoah Meeks ndmeeks@southernco.com Southern CompanyAlain Le Duigou alain.le-duigou@cea.fr CEA

Christine Mansilla christine.mansilla@cea.fr CEABenedicte Champel benedicte.champel@cea.fr CEAPaul Lucchese paul.lucchese@cea.fr CEAMichael Salomon michael.salomon@cleanhorizon.com Clean energyLucas Bertrand lb@itm-power.com ITM

Jean Paul Reich jean-paul.reich@gdfsuez.com ENGIEFabien Aupretre fabien.aupretre@arevah2gen.com AREVA H2GENClaude Heller Claude.heller@airliquide.com Air LiquideLouis Sentis louis.sentis@airliquide.com Air LiquideLuc Bodineau Luc.bodineau@ademe.fr ADEMERobert Dickinson robert.dickinson@hydricity.com.au HydricityMarcel Weeda weeda@ecn.nl ECNMichael Ball Michael.ball@shell.com ShellSheila Samsatli s.samsatli@imperial.ac.uk Imperial CollegeNouri John Samsatli n.samsatli@ic.ac.uk Imperial CollegeMarcus Newborough mn@itm-power.com ITMPierluigi Mancarella p.mancarella@manchester.ac.uk University of Manchester

Mihai Balan mihai.balan@icsi.ro ICIT

Esther Albertin ealbertin@hidrogenoaragon.org FHA

Jesus Simon jsimon@hidrogenoaragon.org FHAMarin Pandev pandeff@cc.bas.bg ; pandeff@gmail.com BASEveline Weidner Eveline.WEIDNER@ec.europa.eu JRC, IPTSNikos Lymberopoulos Nikolaos.Lymperopoulos@fch.europa.eu FCH JUBengt Ridell bengt.ridell@sweco.se Energy Systems, SwecoJoris Proost joris.proost@uclouvain.be UCL LouvainHenry Iskov his@dgc.dk DGCAndreas Reiner Andreas.Reiner@siemens.com SIEMENSMartin Robinius m.robinius@fz-juelich.de FZJAnja Wehling Anja.Wehling@dbi-gut.de DBI Deutche Brennstoff InstituteMartin Kirkengen martin.kirkengen@ife.no IFE

USA

FR

AUSNL

UK

ROESBGEUSEBEDK

D

NOR

22

Coord. ST 1 / CEA

ST 2 / UCL(coord. J Proost)

ICSI (M Balan)JRC (E Weidner)FCH JU (N Lymberopoulos)DGC (H Iskov)SWECO (B Ridell)HA (E Albertin)Hydrogenics (D Thomas)DBI (A Wehling)CEA (A Le Duigou)IFE (M Kirkengen) ?

ST 3A (coord. )

CEA (B Champel)CEA (C Mansilla)Hydricity (R Dickinson)Imperial College (S & N J Samsatli)ICSI (M Balan)DMU (R Gammon)DGC (H Iskov)SWECO (B Ridell)HA (E Albertin, J Simon)Hydrogenics (D Thomas)Air Liquide (S Valentin)FZJ (M Robinius)Southern Company (N Meeks)IFE (M Kirkengen) ?

ST 4(coord. )

Hydricity (R Dickinson)Imperial College (S & N J Samsatli)ICSI (M Balan)DMU (R Gammon)JRC (A Zucker)Air Liquide (J André)SWECO (B Ridell) ?

ST 3B / JRC (coord. E Weidner)

ICSI (M Balan)Hydrogenics (D Thomas)Southern Company (N Meeks)CEA (C Mansilla)BAS (M Pandev) ?

ST5(coord. )

CEA (B Champel)CEA (A Le Duigou)Hydricity (R Dickinson)Imperial College (S & N J Samsatli)ICSI (M Balan)UCL (J Proost)HA (J Simon)Air Liquide (C Heller)FZJ (M Robinius)Southern Company (N Meeks)SWECO (B Ridell) ?

SubTaskscontributorsand leaders

Demo projects

T.E. Studies

Legals and policies

Macro / eco impacts

Case studies

SG – leader ………

CEA (B Champel)CEA (C Mansilla)DMU (R Gammon)Air Liquide (J André)Clean Horizon (M Salomon) ? AREVAH2Gen (F Auprêtre) ?ITM (M Newborough) ?

T – leader …….

Hydricity (R Dickinson)Imperial College (S & N J Samsatli)ISCI (M Balan)CEA (C Mansilla)Engie (J-P Rêche)

M3A – leader M. Robinius

CEA (B Champel)CEA (C Mansilla)Hydricity (R Dickinson)Imperial College (S & N J Samsatli)DMU (R Gammon)JRC (E Weidner)SWECO (B Ridell)FZJ (M Robinius)

D – leader ………

Imperial College (S Samsatli)JRC (E Weidner)CEA (A Le Duigou)

ED – leader ………

Imperial College (S Samsatli)UCL (J Proost)Hydrogenics (D Thomas)Air Liquide (S Valentin)IFE (M Kirkengen) ?JRC (E Weidner) ?ITM (M Newborough) ?

Task Forces contributors and leaders

Services to the Grid

Data

Electrolysers’ Data

Methodology ST 3A

Taxonomy