The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

  • Upload
    fores

  • View
    220

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    1/36

    TheExtremeandFarRightinEuropeLisa Bjurwald

    FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    2/36

    Abouttheauthor

    LisaBjurwaldisafreelancejournalistandauthor.HerreportageontheSwissbanonminarets(Expono4/09)hasbeenawardedtheEuropeanParliamentjournalistprize2010intheSwedishpresscategory.ThisspringshewillreleasethebookEuropesShame:RacistsonAdvance(Nature&Culture).SheismemberoftheeditorialboardoftheantiracistmagazineExpoandhaspreviouslyworkedaseditiorialwriterfortheSwedishdailiesDagensNyheterandSvenskaDagbladet.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    3/36

    Contents

    Abouttheauthor .................................................................................................................................................2

    Contents ..................................................................................................................................................................3

    Foreword ................................................................................................................................................................1

    Summary.................................................................................................................................................................3

    1 Introduction...................................................................................................................................................9

    2 ANewPRStrategy...................................................................................................................................10

    3 TheMilitantBranch.................................................................................................................................13

    4 RacistPartiesinaPositionofPower ...............................................................................................15

    5 TheHatredAgainstMuslims ...............................................................................................................19

    6 Roma:APeoplePersecuted .................................................................................................................22

    7 TheNewAntiSemitism.........................................................................................................................26

    8 StrategiesAgainsttheExtremeRight ..............................................................................................28

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    4/36

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    5/36

    2

    madebyIslamophobesacrossEuropetocollectivelyworkoutstrategiesagainstwhattheyseeastheIslamizationofEurope,inawaythatbringsupstrongmemoriesfromtheconspirationtheoriesofaJewishusurpationofpower.LeadersatthehighestpoliticallevelfromseveralEuropean

    countriesmeettosolvetheRomaquestion.AtthesametimeRomaniesaremassevictedincontradictiontoEUlaws,theyaresubjecttomistreatment,arson,shootingsresultingindeath,andlackthesamerightsasothercitizensinmanycountries.Toapproachthesepartiespolicies(triangulationinpoliticallingo)hasineveryEuropeancaseledtolegitimizingthepositionandroleoftheextremists.Thosewhohaveapproachedtheirantiimmigrationrhetorichavewonshortsightedgains,buthavesoonlosttheirsupportandtheend

    resulthasbeenastrengtheningoftheextremistparties.Theonlycountermedicineseemstobeestablishingastrongandcoherentcounterimagetothatofthexenophobicparties.Luckilythiscounterimagehassupportinfactsandeconomicreality.OurhopeisnowtocollectcommentsfromourcolleaguesatthinktanksandresearchinstitutesacrossEuropeinordertocollectivelydiscussthefurtherdevelopment,butwehavechosentopublishthisreportalready.

    MartindahlCEOFORES

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    6/36

    3

    SummaryOrganizedracism,oftenmisleadinglyfromanideologicalperspectivecalledtheextremeright,isgainingparliamentarypowerallacrossEurope.Sincethebeginningofthe1980s,thepartieshavegonethroughasuperficialimagetransformation,whiletheyhavekepttheirracistandinmanycasesNaziroots.Theirnew,moreorderly,imagehasgiventhemincreasedrespectbymediaaswellasotherpartiesandtheyhavebeenabletomarchintoboththeEuropeanparliamentandnationalparliaments.ManyoftheracistpartieshavealsobeenabletouniteintheirhatredagainstMuslims.Furthermore,astheyhavegainedparliamentarysuccesses,theestablishedpartieshaveadoptedtheirIslamophobicrhetoric,anddiscriminationofMuslimshasbecomepartofthepoliticalclimate.ThisstudyprovidesanoverviewoftheorganizedracisminEurope.Inthefinalpart,strategiestocombatxenophobicandracistpartiesarepresented.

    The Militant BranchMilitantnationalistsconstituteanurgentthreattodemocracy,especiallyinRussiaandHungary.TheRussianskinheadmovementconsistsofapproximately70000peopleandin2009atleast71peoplewerekilledinracistattacks.Jobbik,theantiSemiteandantiZiganistpartythatmadegreatgainsinthisyearselectioninHungary,hasaparamilitarybranch,theHungarianGuards(MagyarGrda).Thisneofascistmovementhasbeenbanned,buthassince

    reformedintoaculturalsociety.TheyfindtheirinspirationintheArrowCrossPartyaHungarianmovementfromtheNaziera,andespeciallytheyouthhasbeendrawntotheirnationalistpropaganda.

    Racist Parties in a Position of Power

    Atpresent(September2010),twonationalistpartiesinEuropearepartoftheirrespectivegovernment:theSwissPeoplesPartyandLegaNordinItaly.IDenmark,theDanishPeoplesPartyisoperatingasasupportparty

    tothegovernmentcoalition.XenophobicpartiesarerepresentedinabouthalfofthenationalparliamentsofEurope,aswellasinSwitzerlandand

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    7/36

    4

    Norway.IntheNetherlands,theFreedomPartyledbyGeertWildersmightbecomepartofagovernmentcoalition.In1999whentheAustrianpartyFPenteredthenationalparliament,the

    EUrespondedwithadiplomaticboycott.Now,adecadelater,Europehasbecomeusedtohavingracistpartieswithintheparliamentarysystem.AnumberofpartiesontheextremerightarerepresentedintheEuropeanParliament.40outofthe736MEPscanbeclassifiedasextremerightorxenophobic.Moreover,therehasbeenashiftinthekindofpartiesrepresented,thetrendbeingtowardsmoreextremism.Forexample,LegaNord,theItalianpartypartofthegovernmentcoalition,reactedontheraceriotsinItalyinthebeginningofthisyear,whenAfrican

    guestworkerswereassaultedandshotat,bysayingthatItalyhasbeentooslackagainstillegalimmigrants.Jobbikreceived15%ofthevotesintheelectiontotheEuropeanparliamentand16,7percentintheHungarianelection.IntheNetherlands,GeertWilders,whoatpresentstandsprosecutedwithchargesofhatespeechafteramongstotherthingshavingcomparedtheQuranwithHitlersMienKampf,received17percentofthevotes,makinghispartythesecondbiggest.ForthefirsttimeevenBritainisrepresentedbyxenophobesinthe

    Europeanparliament,bytheBritishNationalParty(BNP).IntheFrenchregionalelections,FrontNationalmanagedtodoacomebackandreceivedover9percentofthevotes.JobbikhasinitiatedcooperationbetweenseveraloftheracistpartiesinEurope.InOctober2009,anewextremerightalliancewasformedinBudapest,TheAllianceofEuropeanNationalMovements(AENM).TheBNPandtheSwedenDemocratsaresomeofitsmembers.

    InSweden,theSwedenDemocrats,apartywithitsrootsinneoNazismandwithseveralmembersstillhavingaffiliationswithNazimovements,hasasubstantialpossibilityofenteringtheparliamentintheelectioninSeptember.

    The Hatred Against Muslims

    Sincethe9/11terrorattacksin2001andthefollowingattacksinEurope,IslamphobiahasreallyestablisheditselfinEurope.AbanagainstminaretshasbeenpastinSwitzerlandandtheparliamentaryprocessofbanningthe

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    8/36

    5

    fullcoverveilinpublicspaceshascomerealfarinbothBelgiumandFrance.AccordingtoareportfromtheEUbureauonfundamentalrights(FRA),one

    inthreeMuslimshasexperienceddiscrimination.Inanotherreport,fromtheOpenSocietyInstitute,basedoninterviewswithMuslimsinelevencitiesinsevenEuropeancountries,50percentoftherespondentssaidtheyhadexperienceddiscrimination,comparedto9percentofthenonMuslimrespondents.ThetermIslamizationhasbecomewidespreadinEurope.TheideathataMuslimovertakingofpowerconstitutesathreatstronglyresemblesJewsallegedaspirationofglobalpower.AnumberofantiMuslimorganizations

    havebeenfounded,amongstothersStopIslamizationofDenmark(SIAD),aDanishorganizationthatnowhasnationalbranchesalloverEurope.InMarsthisyear,hundredsofIslamophobscametogetherinGermanyinordertodiscussantiMuslimstrategies.Thiswasonlyoneexampleofmeetingsandcampaignsorganizedbyracistsandpoliticians.TheinternationalsecretaryoftheSwedenDemocratswasoneoftheparticipantsinGermany.

    Roma: the Persecuted People

    ParticularlyinEasternandCentralEuropeaswellasItaltytheRomaniesaresubjecttochockinglevelsofviolence,persecutionanddiscrimination.Itincludesshootingsandarsonagainstadultsaswellaschildren.ThousandsofRomafamiliesfleetoCanadaandtheUSinordertoseekasylum.ApproximatelytentotwelvemillionRomaniesliveinEurope.Theirsituationiscomplexanditiswellknownthattheirsocialexclusion

    istoacertaindegreearesultofchoice.Astheyhavebeensubjecttopersecutionduringseveralcenturies,thetrustingovernmentprotectionfrome.g.thepoliceisextremelylowamongtheRomaminority65100percenthavestatedthattheylacktrustinthejudicialsystemandactsofprosecutionaccordingtothefirstEUwidestudy.AreasonforthisisthefactthatthepoliceinEasternandCentralEuropehaverepeatedlyrefusedtointerveneincasesofmistreatmentandarson.InotherwordsRomaniesmaybeforcedtoisolatethemselvesforreasonsofsafety.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    9/36

    6

    PublicauthoritiesinseveralEUcountrieshavewithforcethrownoutRomafamiliesandhavethendemolishedtheircamps,inopencontradictionagainsthumanrightslegislation.InRomaniacertainRomafamilieshavebeenforcedtoliveintinshedsnexttosewerage

    plants,inKosovoothershavebeenplacedincampswithhighconcentrationsoflead.MuchattentionhasbeendrawnbythemassexpulsionsofRomanies,inparticularinFrance,duringthelatesummer.Severalthousandshavebeenexpulsed,withoutindividualexaminations,andcontradicttherulesoffreemovementwithintheEU.EvenSwedenhasexpulsedRomaniesthathavesurvivedonbegging,despitethisnotbeinglegal.

    RomanieslackrightsthatothercitizensenjoyinseveralEUmemberstates.InBosnia,theyareforbiddenfromrunningforparliamentorthepresidency.InFrancetheyhavetoberegisteredinamunicipalityforatleastthreeyearsinordertovote,whereasitsixmonthssufficesforallotherFrenchcitizens.AntiziganismiswidespreadinEurope.PartiessuchastheHungarianJobbik,BulgarianAtakaandSlovakNationalPartysee

    Romaniesassubordinatetoanimals.InHungaryandtheCzechRepublicmistreatmentsandmurderishappeninginawaythatcouldbeseenasapretrialtoapogrom.

    The New Anti-Semitism

    Againstallodds,Islamists,personsfromtheextremeright,HolocaustdeniersandleftactivistshaveunitedintheirantiSemitism.WithinthemodernantiSemitism,thesameoldstereotype

    ofthebloodthirsty,greedyJewisused,withtheonlydifferencethattherhetorichaschanged.SionistsandSionismareusedassynonymswithJewsandanimaginedJewishinfluence,aswellasthestateofIsraelisusedasacodewordforJudaism.Becauseofthis,NaziscanmarchoutsideofsynagoguesincentralStockholmandcryIsraeloutofSweden,despitetherebeingnodoubtwhichminoritytheyareaddressing.AntiSemitisminthesouthernSwedishcityofMalmhasstirredupmuchdebate,eveninternationally.ManyJewshavefeltforcedtoleavethecity.InseveralcountriesAntiSemitistpartieshavewon

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    10/36

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    11/36

    8

    Eveninothercountries,suchasItaly,whereracistpartieshavebeengivenpoliticalinfluenceandhavebeenmetbyembrace,racismhasspreadquicklyandbeennormalized.ThisisnotariskthatEuropean

    countriesshouldtake.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    12/36

    9

    1 IntroductionThepurposeofthispaperistogiveanoverviewoftheorganizedracisminpresentdayEurope,withafocusontheEUcountries.Thetermorganizedracismisusedtodescribepopulistpartieswithxenophobicideas,aswellasthegroupsandpartiesoften(andrathermisleadingly)termedtheextremeright.Thetermisnotideal,astheextremerightisoftenmoreleftliketheNationalSocialistsofHitlerGermanythanright,asinconservativeorliberalconservative.Infact,theantifascistleftspearheadingthefightagainsttheextremerighthasquitealotincommonwithitsswornenemy.Thetwosidesbothtakeacriticalstanceon,forexample,theEuropeanUnion,capitalism,freetradeandpeacekeepingoperationsabroad.Atthesametime,thehatredagainstMuslimswithinmanyofthexenophobicandantiimmigrantpartieshasstrengthenedtheir(mostlysuperficial)supportforthestateofIsraelandtheJewishpopulationofEurope.Today,thesepartiescanholdmanifestationsonHolocaustRemembranceDay,orevenpayasolemnvisittoAuschwitz.ThishastriggeredreactionsofdisgustwithintheantiSemiticextremeright,whostillregardtheJewsastheirnumberoneenemy.Insomecorners,thehatredagainstJewsissostrongthatextremerightactivistswillevenconsidercollaboratingwithradicalMuslims;seeThenewantiSemitismformoreonthisdevelopment.Therootsoftodaysxenophobicpartiesand/ortheirleadershipcanoftenbetracedtotheextremerightmovement.Somehavecooperatedinthepast,orstillunofficiallydoso,withmoreextremeelements.This,incombinationwithasharedagendaandidenticalargumentsdrivenbyracismandnationalism,meansthattheracistscoveredinthispaperwillbe

    sortedunderthesameheadingwhethertheyarewearingbootsorsuits.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    13/36

    10

    2 A New PR-StrategyTheskinheadmovementofthelate1970sandtheearly1980swasahighlymarginalized,maledominatedmovement,taintedbyalcoholabuseandapenchantforstreetfights.Yetamajorpartoftheextremerightwouldevolveoutoftheskinheadscene.TheperceivedthreatofincreasedimmigrationledtoaresurgenceofracistideasthathadbeentaboosincetheendoftheSecondWorldWar.Apolarizingusandthemworldviewmanagedtoswayatleastafewpercentofthevoters.Soon,inthe1980sand1990s,theracistpopulistsmanywithabackgroundinneoNazigroups,ahandfulwithlesssoiledbackgroundsenteredtheelectoralarena.Some,likeAustriasFreedomPartyunderJorgHaiderandFrontNationalunderJeanMarieLePen,wentontogainpoliticalinfluence.Others,suchastheSwedenDemocrats,weregrowingquietly.The1990swasalsomarkedbydivisionwithinthenewparties.Suddenly,theywereatacrossroads.Thechoice:toremainfaithfultotheirradicalideologyorselloutoraimfortherealpower,dependingonwhomyouasked.TodaysnationalistEuropeanpartiesarefilledwiththosewhochosepathswiththeirbrains,whiletheirheartsstillpoundedforthewhitepowerideology.Thisbecameevidentin,forexample,theradioshowKaliberontheSwedishRadio,which,usinghiddencameras,revealedhowleadingpeoplewithintheSDsangalongwithmodernwhitepowermusicaswellasnationalsocialistfightsongs.Atthedawnofthe21stcentury,the9/11bombingsintheU.S.andthelaterterroristactsonEuropeansoiltriggeredanIslamophobiathatbecametheunifyingfactorfortheparliamentarianfarright.MuslimsandtheallegedislamizationofEuropeappearedastheprimarytarget.ThebynowsuitcladracistsclearedoutatleastthemostvisibleantiSemitismandreplaceditwiththemoresellableIslamophobia.AstronghatredofJewsisstillacentralpartoftheideologyforsomenationalistparties,especiallythosewhoportraytheUnitedStatesasthedevilanddonothesitatetocooperatewithIslamists.ButitcomesasnosurprisethatIslamophobicpartiesareenjoyinggreaterelectoralsuccessintodaysEuropethanantiSemiticones.

    Theimagemakeoverisanimportantfactortotakeintoaccountwhen

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    14/36

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    15/36

    12

    Anincreasedfocusonfamilyissuesandfamilyactivitiesisanimportantcomponentofthemovementsnewstrategy.Whitepowerconcerts,paramilitarytrainingandviolentdemonstrationsareallstillthere.Butthey

    aresupplementedwithfamilydays,specialwomensorganizationsandastrongerstanceonclassicconservative(andNationalSocialist)issuessuchasnativity.Bydoingthis,theymanagetoreachthevoterswhowerepreviouslyputoffbythemilitantrhetoric.Thatanincreasingnumberofwomenarejoiningtheextremerightrankshasnotjustledtoasofterimage,buttothecreationofentireextremerightfamilies,wherebothparentsareactiveonthescene.Duringthecourseofthetransformationfromaggressiveskinheadsto

    suitedpoliticians,popularresistanceagainstracismhasweakened.Theprominentantiracistmanifestationsofthe1980sand1990s,wheretoppoliticiansqueueduptobeseen,arerareintodaysEurope.ThisisfurtherverifiedbydatafromtheUniversityofGothenburgshowingpeoplesattitudestowardjoiningantiracistorganization.Duringthepasttenyears,thesharestatingwillingnesstodosohasdecreased.1

    1 Demker, M. (2008), Lngsamma frskjutningar inom stabila ramar, i Holmberg, S. och Weibull, L. (red.) Skildavrldar, SOM bokserien nr. 44

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    16/36

    13

    3 The Militant Branch

    Alargenumberofextremerightgroupshavepurposelypositionedthemselvesoutsidethedemocraticsystemandhavenodesiretobeacceptedbymainstreamsociety.Militantgroupswhodespisedemocracyandwishtobringdown(oratleastinterferewith)thesysteminaviolentmanner,existinpracticallyeveryEuropeancountry.Thegroupshavelowmembershipfiguresanditisnotunusualfortheiractiviststohavebeenconvictedforviolentcrimessuchasassaultormurder.Theycancooperatewith,orconstituteanationalbranchof,internationalNazinetworkssuchasCombat18orBlood&Honour.InHungaryandRussia,thesituationisratherdifferentfromtherestofEurope.There,themilitantnationalismisathreatagainstdemocracy.About70000activistsarethoughttomakeuptheRussianskinheadmovement.In2009,71peopleweremurderedand333injuredinracistattacks,accordingtotheRussianhumanrightsNGOSovaCenter.Despitethechockingfigures,thisisactuallythefirstdemisetobeobservedinsixyears.Butdifferentkindsofwhitepowerrelatedvandalismincreasedduring2009.InHungary,theantiSemiticandantiRomapartyJobbik,foundedin2003,hasmanagedtogainconsiderablesuccesswithinashortperiodoftime.Intheparliamentaryelectionsin2010,thepartyobtained16,7percentofthevotes,givingthem47seats.Thepartyevenhasaparamilitarywing,theHungarianGuard,whichisstronglyreminiscentontheArrowCrossPartyofthe1940s(moreonthisunderRoma:Apeoplepersecuted).Thesocalledfreenationalistsareanewphenomenon.Theyhavecopiedthenetworkbasedstructureoftheautonomousleftandgatheredinsmaller,independentgroupings,oftenbasedoncityorregion.Inotherwords,theydonotbelongtoanofficialmotherorganizationoranextremerightyouthassociation.Interestinglyenough,Europehasalsoseentheadventofsocalledautonomousnationalists,asortofanarchistNazis.Atdemonstrations,itisalmostimpossibletotellthemapartfromtheautonomouslefttheyproclaimtodespise,asbothsidesdressidenticallyinanarchistinspiredclothingevendowntotheirkeffiyehs.

    Eveniftheseantidemocraticgroupsdonotconstituteathreatatthe

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    17/36

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    18/36

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    19/36

    16

    majorityoftheracistMEPsareeithernonalignedorbelongtotherightwingEuroscepticgroupEuropeofFreedomandDemocracy.IntheEPelectionofJune2009,theextremeandfarrightmadegainsinalmosthalfofthememberstates.Considerablesuccessescouldbenotedin

    nolessthan11ofthe27countries.WhilesomehavepointedoutthatracistpartieswerealreadyrepresentedintheEuropeanParliament,andthatsomeevenmadeapoorershowingin2009thaninpreviousyears,afocusonwhichpartiesmadeprogressin2009givesabetterpictureofthesituationthanjustcomparingstatistics.TakeforexampleItaly,oneoftheEuropeancountrieswherethexenophobiaismostworrying.InJanuarythisyear,thecountrywasshakenbyraceriotsasAfricanmigrantworkersintheSoutherncityofRosarno

    werebeatenupandshotatbylocals.TheseparatistNorthernLeague,governingthecountryincoalitionwithSilvioBerlusconisPeopleofFreedom,controlstheinteriorministrythroughinteriorministerRobertoMaroni.MaronihaspreviouslytriedtopushthroughanationalracialregisterwithfingerprintsofallItalianRoma.Thistime,hereactedtotheriotsnotwithcondemnation,butbydeclaringthatItalyhashadtoomuchtoleranceagainstillegalimmigrants.LastJune,theNorthernLeagueseriouslyadvancedtheirpositions.The

    partyreceivedmorethanthreemillionvotesandincreasedtheirmandatesfromfourtonine,makingthemthelargestextremerightpartyintheEuropeanParliament.Thisachievementisfarmoremeaningfultothexenophobicmovement,onanItalianaswellasaEuropeanlevel,thanthefactthatthealreadymarginalized,neofascistForzaNuovaendedupwithonly0,47percentofthevote(146000votes).TheNorthernLeaguewasalsothepartythatmadethemostgainsintheItalianregionalelectionsinMarchthisyear.Intworegions,theybecamethelargestpartyforthefirsttime:PiedmontandVeneto.

    TheDanishPeoplesPartymadeunexpectedgainsinthesummerof2009.PiaKjrsgaardsantiimmigrantpartyincreasedfrombarelysevento15percent,therebydoublingtheirmandatesintheEuropeanParliament.Justafewyearsprior,MortenMesserschmidt,whohasnowtakenupaseatintheEP,wasconvictedforincitementtoracialhatred.In2009,arecord284500DanessenthimtoBrussels.TheantiimmigrantTrueFinnsalsotookthevotersbystorm,goingfrom0,5toalmost10percentofthevote.Over100000FinnselectedpartyleaderTimoSoinitotheEuropean

    Parliament.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    20/36

    17

    TheextremerightpartyJobbik(TheMovementforaBetterHungary),obsessedwiththegypsyquestionandwithclearantiSemiticviews,wonalmost15percentofthevotesandthreeseatsintheEuropeanParliament.AthisfirstsessioninStrasbourgthefollowingmonth,oneofthemembers

    worethebannedfascistuniformbelongingtoJobbiksparamilitaryguard.IntheNetherlands,thexenophobicPartyforFreedom(PVV)whoseleaderGeertWildersiscurrentlyfacingchargesforincitementofracialhatredbecamethecountryssecondlargestpartywith17percentofthevote.ThechargeagainstWildersis,amongotherthings,basedonhisequatingIslamwithfascistideologies.Inconsciouslyprovocativestatements,WildershascomparedtheKorantoHitlersMeinKampf.ThechargehasresultedinWildersbecomingamartyramongstneoNazisas

    wellaspopulists.AnotheroneoftheEPelectionsbigwinnersisNickGriffin.OveronemillionBritsmadesurethattheextremerightBritishNationalParty(BNP)senthimandanothermembertoBrussels.ItisthefirsttimethattheUnitedKingdomisrepresentedbyanextremerightpartyintheEuropeanParliament.PartyleaderGriffin,withaprominentcareerintheneoNaziNationalFrontonhisresume,isregularlyontheroadinEurope,makingnewcontactsandkeepingupothers.ThecooperationbetweenJobbikand

    theBNPhasbeensosuccessfulthatJobbikestablishedanoverseasofficeinLondonin2009auniquemovebyanonBritishextremerightparty.FrancesinfamousFrontNationallostfouroutofitssevenmandatesintheelectiontotheEuropeanParliament.PartyleaderJeanMarieLePenisnowover80yearsoldandissoonexpectedtohandoverthethronetohisdaughterMarine,alsoanMEP.NickGriffinandhisBNPhavebeenquicktoseizethemomentandtrytofillwhattheyperceiveasavoidinthepanEuropeanextremerightleadership.

    Butonanationallevel,FrontNationalmadeanunexpectedcomebackinMarch.Afterbeingdownforthecountsincethecatastrophicelectionof2007,thepartywonoverninepercentofthevoteinthisyearsregionalelections.PartoftheirregainedsuccessisprobablyduetoMarinelePenwhohasgiventhepartyofsofterimage.ShehasdissociatedherselffromantiSemitism,playeddowntheextremismandtriedtocamouflageIslamophobiawithfeminismandnationalism.

    JobbikhastakenseveralinitiativestopanEuropeancollaborations.InOctober2009,anewextremerightalliancewasforgedinBudapest.The

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    21/36

    18

    partyfederationAllianceofEuropeanNationalMovements(AENM)consistsofJobbik,theBritishNationalParty,BelgiumsFrontNational,FrancesFrontNational,ItalysFiammaTricoloreandSwedensNationalDemocrats.Afterthefoundingmeeting,theNationalDemocratswrotethat

    thepurposeofthefederationistoworkagainstliberalismandglobalismintheWest,withinanEUframework()Themainpurposeofthefederationistocoordinatethefightagainstthemutualenemywhichmanifest(sic)itselfintheinternationalglobalismthreateningthecultureanduniquecharacterofusall.AustriasFreedomParty(FP),somewhatlessradicalthantheAENMparties,isincludedinthemeetingprotocolbuthasnotsignedit,andhasofficiallydeniedthecollaboration.IntheEPelections,FPwon13percent

    ofthevote,analmostsevenpercentincrease.Ittakessevenpartiesand25memberstocreateaformalpoliticalgroupintheEuropeanParliament,somethingtheextremeandfarrighthasfailedtodo.In2007,Identity,Tradition,Sovereignty(ITS)brokeupafterAlessandraMussoliniaccusedRomaniansingeneralofbeingcriminal.ThisinfuriatedtheGreaterRomaniaPartytotheextentthattheyleftthegroup,leavingITSwithnotenoughmembers.AlessandraMussoliniisthegrandchildofBenitoMussoliniandwasanMEPuntil2008.SheisnowamemberoftheItalian

    parliament(chamberofdeputies).

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    22/36

    19

    5 The Hatred Against MuslimsMuslimshavebecomethenewJews,claimprominentexpertssuchasAustrianprofessorAntonPelinka3.Islamophobiagainedafootholdafterthe9/11attacksagainstAmericain2001andthesubsequentterroristactsonEuropeansoil.IslamophobiaishereusedasatermforprejudiceagainstanddiscriminationofMuslims,notcriticismagainst(forexample)IslamismortheradicalizationofyoungMuslims.Unfortunately,Islamophobiahasmoreandmorecometoinfecttheseriouspublicdebate.Whatstartedasalegitimateresistanceagainsttheoppressionofwomenhas,incountrieslikeFranceandDenmark,turnedintoafixationonatinyburqawearingminority.Themajoritysoppressionoftheminorityhasalwaysbeenoneofdemocracysweakpoints.RacistpartiesalloverEuropearenowtryingtousethedemocraticsystemtotheiradvantage.InNovember2009,Switzerlandvotedonabanagainsttheconstructionofminarets,thetowersadorningasfewasfourofthecountrysaround200mosques.TheinitiativetothereferendumwastakenbytheEgerkingerCommittee,whichconsistofpoliticiansfromthexenophobicSwissPeoplesParty(SVP),thecountryslargestparty,andalsoofpoliticiansfromasmallevangelicalparty,theFederalDemocraticUnionofSwitzerland(FDU).In2008thecommitteehadamassedthe100000signaturesrequiredforareferendumonachangeoramendmenttotheSwissconstitution.Againsttheodds,thebanonminaretconstructionswasvotedthrough,andSwitzerlandwassharplycriticizedbytheUNandNGOssuchasAmnestyInternational.BytheendofMarsthisyear,Belgiumslowerhouseofparliamentpassedaburqaban.Thelawisexpectedtocomeintoforcethissummer,makingBelgiumthefirstcountryinEuropetobanthewearingoffullcoverageveilsinpublic.Thosewhorefusetocomplyarethreatenedwithjail.TheNationalAssemblyofFrancevotedforabanofthefullcoverveilinpublicspaces.ThelawmustalsobepassedintheSenate.TheGermanantiMuslimmovementistryingtostopislamizationwiththehelpoftheLisbonTreatyandsignaturesfromonemillionEUcitizens.ThetermislamizationhasmadearealbreakthroughinEurope.TheideaofanimminentMuslimtakeoverisreminiscentofthewellknownconspiracy3

    Neo-Nazis? No such thing, Primor, Adar, Haaretz 5.3.2010

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    23/36

    20

    theoriesofZOG4andtheJewsallegedstruggleforworlddomination.EuropeanMuslimsaresubjecttoadisturbingdegreeofdiscrimination.Ina2009surveyofMuslimsin14EUcountries,theEuropeanUnionforAgency

    FundamentalRights(FRA)establishedthatoneoutofthreeMuslimshaveexperienceddiscrimination.Elevenpercentoftherespondentshadalsobeenvictimsofaraciallymotivatedcrime.AswithotherminoritygroupssurveyedbytheFRA,anoverwhelmingmajority,79percent,hadchosennottoreporttheirexperiencesofcrimeanddiscriminationtotheauthorities5.AccordingtothereportMuslimsinEurope(December2009)fromtheOpenSocietyInstitute6,whohavetakenacloserlookat11citiesinsevenEuropeancountries,50percentoftheMuslimrespondentssaidthatthey

    hadexperienceddiscriminationbecauseoftheirreligioninthepast12months.ThiscanbecomparedtoonlyninepercentofthenonMuslimrespondents.IntheNetherlands,GeertWildersiswaitinginthewingsafterthegovernmentcollapseinFebruary.InthelocalelectionsonMarch4,seenasatestaheadofJunesparliamentaryelections,hisFreedomPartycamefirstinAlmereoutsideAmsterdamandsecondinthecountryspoliticalcapitalTheHague.ThesituationforMuslimsintheNetherlands,wheretheyonly

    makeupaboutfivepercentofthepopulation,isaspreviouslymentionedverydifficult.LocalexpertsregardtheantiMuslimrhetoricoftheFreedomPartytobeadirectlycontributingcause.Accordingtoa2009survey,halfofthecountrysMuslimsareconsideringemigration.Athirdstatethattheywoulddefinitelyliketoemigrate7.AspointedoutinthecasewiththeSwissminaretban,theIslamophobesarequicktocopyothercountriessuccessfulstrategies.TheStoptheIslamisationofDenmarkorganization(SIAD)hasthusgrownintothepan

    EuropeanmovementStoptheIslamisationofEurope(SIOE).Nationalchapters,fromSwedentoBulgaria,havealsobeenestablished.DuringthecontroversyregardingaMuslimculturalcenteronManhattan,StopIslamizationofAmerica(SIOA)hasfiguredinthemediaonamoreorlessdailybasisbecauseoftheircampaignagainsttheplannedbuilding.

    4

    Zionist Occupation Government. Zionists and Zionism are extreme right code words for Jews and perceived

    Jewish influence.5

    fra.europa.eu6

    www.soros.org7

    Opinion poll ordered by the Dutch program Netwerk. Quoted in Wilders makes half of Dutch Muslims want

    to emigrate, Blass, Michael, Radio Netherlands Worldwide 090629 (www.rnw.nl)

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    24/36

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    25/36

    22

    6 Roma: A People PersecutedTatarszentgyrgyinHungary,February23.AhouseissetonfirewithMolotovcocktails.Ayoungfatherandhis5yearoldsonareshotdeadastheyfleetheirhome.VitkovintheCzechRepublic,April18.Threefamilymembersareinjuredinanarsonattack.Their2yearolddaughtersuffersburnson80percentofherskin.TiszalkinHungary,April22.54yearoldKka,leavingtoworkthenightshift,isshotdeadinfrontofhisfamilyhome.KisltainHungary,August3.Mria,amiddleagedmother,isshotandkilledinherbed.Her13yearolddaughterisseverelywounded.8Thestatisticscoveringbeatings,arsonattacksandmurdersinHungaryandtheCzechRepubliccanbereadasthefirststagesofethniccleansing.Buttheyearwhentheaboveattackstookplaceisnot1939but2009.Roma,previouslycalledgypsies,arefallingvictimtochockinglevelsofviolence,persecutionanddiscriminationinItalyandinEasternandCentralEurope.Now,RomafamiliesfleeEuropebythethousands,seekingasyluminCanadaandtheUnitedStates.YetthesafetyoftheRomaremainsalowpriorityforEurope.TheRomathemselveshaveadifficulttimerousingpublicopinionfortheircause.Thegrouplack,withfewexceptions,representativesatthehigherlevelsofsociety.TheRomaareEuropeslargestethnicminority.ApproximatelytentotwelvemillionRomalivehere,butthefiguresareuncertainandcouldbemuchhigher.AsopposedtoforexamplethewellintegratedJewishpopulation,theRomasituationismorecomplex.Itiswellknownthattheoutsiderstatusistosomedegreeaconsciouschoice.ManyRomaparentshave,forexample,takentheirchildrenoutofschoolbeforetheyhavebeenabletogoontohighereducation.ButcenturiesofantiRomapersecutionsshinealightonthereasonsbehindtheisolation.Inotherwords,Romafamiliesmaywellchoosetoremainseparatedfromtherestofsocietyforsecurityreasons.InEasternand

    8

    European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC)

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    26/36

    23

    CentralEurope,thepolicehaverepeatedlyrefusedtocometotherescueatbeatingsandevenarsonattacks.InEUMIDIS,thefirstEUwidereportondiscrimination(2009),6692percentoftheRomastatethattheyhavenotreportedtheirlatestexperienceofdiscriminationtotheauthorities.65100

    percentsaystheylacktrustinthejudicialsystemandthelawenforcement9

    .Areasonablesuspicioncanactuallybebehindthosehighfigures.AuthoritiesinseveralEUcountrieshaveforcefullyevictedRomafamiliesanddemolishedtheircamps.Thedemolitionshavebeencarriedoutinblatantbreachofhumanrightslaws.Often,thereisnoadvancewarning.InRomania,about75Roma,includingchildren,liveinsimplemetalshacksrightbesideasewagetreatmentplant.Sixyearsago,theywereforcefullymovedinwhatwascynicallycalledatemporarytransfer.Industrialareas

    andgarbagedumpsareotherplaceswhereRomafamiliesaredeportedto.Andtheirnewhomesareofteneverythingbuttemporary.Despiterepeatedcriticismfromhumanrightsorganizations,healthyRomachildrenincountriessuchastheCzechRepublicarestillplacedinschoolsforthementallydisabled.InBosnia,RomaandJewsarelegallybarredfromrunningforparliamentandthepresidency.TheRomawhofledpersecutionsinKosovoarecurrentlybeingsentbackfromahostofEUmemberstates,despitethefactthatthesituationhasntimproved.Onthe

    contrary,theRomainKosovoarevictimsofhateattacksandareforcedtoliveunderghettolikecircumstances.OneofthosewhohaveexpressedtheirconcernistheCouncilofEuropeCommissionerforHumanRights,ThomasHammarberg,whoatthebeginningofthisyearcondemnedthetransferofRomafamiliesacrosscountryborders.HammarbergisnowdemandingastoptodeportationsofRomatoKosovo.Needlesstosay,theRomaareingravedangerifEuropeleavestheirdestinyinthehandsofantiRomaextremists.HungarianJobbik,BulgarianAtaka

    andtheSlovakNationalPartyconsiderRomatobelowerthananimals.Thefirstpartyhas,aspreviouslymentioned,alreadymadetheirentranceinBrussels.JobbiksantiSemitismisexpressedopenlyinwrittenmaterials,inspeechesandatmanifestations.InSeptemberthisyear,thevicepresidentofJobbiksaidtoReutarsthatthepartywantstoplaceRomasinpublicorderzones,someforalifetime.SidebysidewithJobbiksMEPsmarchesthemilitantneofascistsofthepartysparamilitarydivision,theHungarianGuard(MagyarGrda),

    9

    fra.europa.eu

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    27/36

    24

    inspiredbytheHungarianArrowCrosspartyoftheNaziera.DespiteabanontheGuard,fewofthemhaveputawaytheirbootsandvestsadornedwithroaringlions.Instead,theGuardhasbeenreestablishedasaculturalassociation.Menandwomenofallageshavejoinedtheirranks,butyouths

    seemparticularlyluredbythetoughtalkingnationalistpropaganda.InthebeginningofMarch,anopinionpollshowedthatJobbikwas,forthefirsttimeever,morepopularwithyoungHungariansthantheSocialists.Intheagegroup18to24,Jobbikwaseventwiceaslargeasthepreviousrulingparty10.InItaly,thethreatsagainstRomahaveincreaseddisproportionallysinceSilvioBerlusconisnewgovernmentcametopowerin2008,accordingtothehumanrightsreportSecuritylaItaliana:Fingerprinting,Extreme

    ViolenceandHarassmentofRomainItaly.ThereportdescribeshowraciallymotivatedattacksagainstRomaarenolongerisolatedincidentsbutratherastructuralcomponentoftheItalianeverydayreality11.AccordingtoastudypresentedtotheItalianparliamentinFebruary2010,almosthalfofthecountrysyoungmenandwomenarexenophobicorintolerantagainstimmigrants.15percentclaimedtohaveaphobiaagainstRomanians,AlbaniansandRoma.Those15percentweredominatedbywomen12.

    InAugust2010FrancecommencedamuchcriticizedmassdeportationofRumanianandBulgarianRomanies.300campsweredemolishedinorderto,accordingtoFrenchpresidentNicolasSarkozy,curbcriminalityandaround1000Romashavebeendeported(September2010).TheeventsthattriggeredthedeportationsstartedwithadeadlyshotbythepoliceofayoungmanbelongingtotheRomaminority,whichleadtoriots.ThedeportationshavemetmassiveprotestsbothfromtheRomanies

    themselvesandfrompoliticiansandhumanrightsNGOsaroundtheworld.VivianeReding,TheEUcommissionerforJustice,FundamentalRightsandCitizenship,saidthattheymightcontradictEUlawsoffreemovement,fundamentalrightsandcitizenship.Criticsofthedeportationsarguethattheyareillegalonthegroundsofnotbeingtriedindividually,inadditiontobreakingthelawoffreemovementwithintheEU.InSeptember2010,theEuropeanparliamentpassedaresolutioncallingforFranceandothercountriestoimmediatelyenddeportationsofRomapeople.Amongstother10

    Poll reveals Jobbik scores better among young people than Socialists, MTI/Politics.hu, 10030511

    From a coalition of human rights groups including the Open Society Institute and the ERRC, 2009. See forexample www.soros.org12

    46 percent [of] young Italians xenophobic, AFP 100219

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    28/36

    25

    things,theparliamentarguedthatsincethedeportationsaregroundedonracetheyareactsofdiscrimination.VoiceshavealsobeenraisedforsanctioningFranceeconomically.

    TherearealreadydifferentlawsinplaceforRomainFranceconcerningtherighttovoteinlocalelections.WhileRomapeoplehavetobeenregisteredinthesamemunicipalityduringthreeyearstohavearighttovote,sixmonthsisenoughforallothercitizens.DeportationsofRomanieshavetakenplaceinSwedenaswellduring2010.Thepolicedeportedapproximately50RomabecausetheyearnedtheirlivingthroughbeggingdespiteallEUcitizenshavingarighttostayinanothercountrythreemonthswithoutprovinghowtheymakealiving.Furthermore,beginningisnotillegalinSweden,butthepolicefoundit

    dishonest.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    29/36

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    30/36

    27

    OmarandAhmedRamihavecopiedtheFrenchandcreatedanantiZionistparty.WithincontemporaryantiSemitism,ZionistsandZionismareusedascodewordsforJewsanddelusionsofJewishglobalinfluence.ThestateofIsraelisalsousedasacodedsymbolforanything

    Jewish.Thus,ahordeofneoNaziscarryingtorchescanchantIsraeloutofSweden!outsidesynagogues(whichhashappenedinStockholm),withoutbreakingthelawdespitetherebeingnodoubtsastowhichminorityisintended.TheFrenchPartiAntiSionisteisledbycomedianDieudonnMBalaMBala,who,likeAhmedRami,hasbeenconvictedforantiSemitism(inDieudonnscase,forantiSemiticstatements).Oneofthegoalsstatedintheirpartyprogramreads:EradicatingallformsofZionisminthenation.

    ThepartyranintheEuropeanParliamentelectioninFrancebutdidntmanagetosecureenoughvotes.ButDieudonnhimselfisverypopularamongFrenchactivistsonthefarleft,aswellaswithradicalizedimmigrantyouths.ThegodfatherofoneofDieudonnsdaughtersisnoneotherthanthegodfatherofFrenchracism,JeanMarieLePenofFrontNational.TheFreedomPartyscandidateinthisyearsAustrianpresidentialelection,BarbaraRosenkranz,istestamenttotheantiSemitismremainingwithinthepopulistpartiesevenifMuslimshavebecometheirpremiertarget.

    Rosenkranz,marriedtoamanfrommoreextremenationalistcircles,havepreviouslydefendeddoubtssurroundingtheNazigaschambers.IntheAprilelection,shebecamethesitting(andreelected)presidentHeinzFischersonlychallenger.Despiteharshcsriticism,Rosenkranzsecuredalmost16percentofthevote.TheresulthasbeenmetwithuneaseintheAustrianJewishcommunity.InIsrael,newspapereditorialshaveencouragedJewsinAustriaandHungarytoleavetheirrespectivecountries.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    31/36

    28

    8 Strategies Against the Extreme RightTheEuropeancountrieshavetrieddifferentstrategiestofacethethreatfromorganizedracism.Insomecountries,xenophobicpartieshavebeenleftoutinthecold,whiletheirantiimmigrantargumentshavebeencopiedinordertowinovervoters.Inotherplaces,exemplarymeasureshavebeentakentoinformthepublicoftheracistshatefulagendaonlytohavetheextremerightdominatethepolls.Manypoliticalpartieslackanysortofstrategyandseemtooperplexedtotakeseriousaction.Anditsnowonder:neitherisolationnoractiveoppositionhasworked.ThisisalsowhattheBertelsmannFoundationinGermanyfoundwhenthey,inagroundbreakingproject,studiedandcomparedstrategiesagainsttheextremerightin11Europeancountries.Nostrategyisuniversalandguaranteedtowork,theyconclude,butsuggestanumberofspecificmeasures.Amongstthoseare:

    Showpoliticalresponsibility.Byformingantiracistcommitteesonthehighestpoliticallevels,thepoliticianswillmakeitclearthatdiscriminationandracismareareasofconcern.

    Practicepoliticalleadershipandbesuretotaketheinitiativeinthedebate.Politiciansshouldneverforgettoemphasizethepositiveeffectsofadiversifiedsociety.

    Racismhastoresultinaredcard.Whenpoliticiansororganizationsdemonstratexenophobicideas,theyhavetobebannedfromimportantpositions.Withoutthissortofzerotolerance,societywillbeinfiltratedby,forexample,Islamophobicideas.

    Increaseawarenessofhatecrimesandkeeptrackofinfringementoflaws.Swedenisheldupasagoodexample,buttheSwedishhatecrimelawisactuallyapapertiger.Inotherwords,itisimportantthatthethreatofhatecrimeconvictionsdoesntloseitsteeth.

    Themediaplaysakeyrolewhenitcomestoexposingtheagendaofthexenophobes.AsinforexampleFranceandGermany,investigativejournalismfocusingontheextremerightshouldbeencouraged.

    TheBertelsmannFoundationisalsofocusingontheneedforinformation.TheEuropeancountriesshouldsharetheirknowledgeaboutthedifferentstrategiesthatexisttocombatthethreat.Perhapsthereisevenaneedfora

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    32/36

    29

    commonEuropeanstrategy.Inanycase,thethreatmustnotbedismissedasamarginalisedphenomenon,theywarn.Theextremerightmustbekeptunderclosewatch,especiallyasitisassumedthatglobalisationwillmakethemovementgrowevenlarger14.

    ProfessorMontserratGuibernauattheUniversityofLondoncomestothesameconclusioninherpaper,Migrationandtheriseoftheradicalright(March2010)15.Init,shecriticizesmainstreampartiesforregardingtheextremerightasabunchoffanatics.Thefactthatnomajorpartyhasneitherbeenabletocalmthepublicsfearsaboutimmigration,orstoptheriseoftheultraright,begsthequestionofwhetherthepartieshavetrulyunderstoodwhatfactorsaredrivingthevotersintothearmsofthexenophobes,writesGuibernau.

    Guibernaupresentsthreeelementsthatshouldbeincludedinthepartiesresponsetothechallenge.Firstofall,voterconfidenceinpoliticsmustberestoredbyincreasedtransparencyandlessbureaucracy.Thepartiesalsoneedtoformulateabalancedwayofrelatingtoimmigration,whichneedstobecontrolled,whilestillrespectingthehumanrights.Finally,politiciansshouldacknowledgetheworkingclassesconcernoverthelabormarket,wheretheyoftenfeelincapableofcompetingwithcheaper,foreignlabor(despitestudiesshowingthatthereisnosuchcompetitiononthemarket).

    Popular Resistance

    Onastrictlymoralnote,itmustbeconsideredbettertofacetheextremerightthantoremainpassive.Astrongantiracistpopularmovementisasignofhealthandasignaltovotersaswellastheextremeright,thatracistopinionsdonotbelongincivilized,diversifiedsocieties.Preventativeactivismisoneofthebestcuresagainstorganizedracism,andthisisalsowhatForeshasconcludedinitspolicypaper2010:1,Localresistanceto

    xenophobia.InGreatBritain,theantiracistSearchlightMagazinerunsanationalcampaignagainstracism,HopenotHate.AdoubledeckerbuspaintedahopefulyellowhastouredthecountrytoinformabouttheBritishNationalParty.Searchlighthasmanagedtomobilizethousandsofactivistsandco

    14

    Bertelsmann Stiftung (red.), Strategies for Combating Right-Wing Extremism in Europe, Gtersloh: Verlag

    Bertelsmann Stiftung, 200915

    Published by the Policy Network ahead of the conference Migration and the rise of nationalist right-wingparties: confrontation, isolation or engagement in Copenhagen. Can be downloaded from: http://www.policy-

    network.net/uploadedFiles/Publications/Publications/Migration and the rise of the far right.pdf.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    33/36

    30

    operateswithlocalantiBNPgroupsfromNorthtoSouth.TheSwedishantiracistfoundationandmagazineExporunsasimilarcampaign,TheSwedenDemocratsAreWrong,since2008.Basedonabookwiththesamename,Expocampaignsthroughlectures,studycirclesand

    Internetactivism.InGermany,itisnotunusualforpeoplefromallwalksoflifetoturnupatantiracistmanifestations.Familieswithyoungchildren,anarchists,gayactivists,priestsfromtheCatholicChurchandothershave,throughtheuseofactivenonviolence,managedtostoptheextremerightsshowofforceandspreadingofpropaganda.OneofthemostimportantdatesintheEuropeanextremerightscalendaristheDresdenMemorialDay,wherethevictimsoftheAlliedbombingsarehonored.Atthisyearsmemorial,10000

    Germansformedahumanchain,barringtheneoNazisfrommarchingthroughthecity.

    Cordon Sanitaire a Line of Decency

    ApoliticalequivalentoftheDresdenresistanceisthesocalledcordonsanitairedrawnupbyBelgianpartiestokeepthexenophobicVlaamsBelangatbay.Thestrategyinvolvesanagreementamongsttheotherpartiesnottocooperatewiththeracistpartyinordertokeepitata

    distance.AsimilarlinewasalsodrawnupbythemainstreampartiesinFrancetocounterthethreatfromtheFrontNational(whichiscurrentlymarginalized,muchbecauseofthisstrategy).Oneobviouscriticismwasandstillisthattheapproachisundemocratic.InthecaseofFrance,xenophobicideasalsomanagedtobreakthroughthesanitaryquarantineandentermainstreampolitics.

    Supporters and Dealmakers

    Someexpertsproposeastrategywheretheestablishedpartiestakeontheareasthattheextremerighttriestoclaimastheirs.Inotherwords,immigration,integrationandIslam.Butthisstrategyisquiteeasytocriticize.InseveralEuropeancountries,attemptstotakebacksuchissueshaveresultedinapoliticaldebateuncomfortablyfixateduponIslamandMuslims.Inreality,theresulthasbeenthattheextremerightissettingtheagenda.NorwaysProgressParty(FrP)isoneexampleofxenophobiaslowlybutsurelybeingnormalized.Today,aftercompromisesanddiscreetsupportfromotherparties,theFrPisNorwayssecondlargestparty.ThequestionEuropespoliticiansneedtoaddressiswhetherthisriskis

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    34/36

    31

    betterthancooperatingwithxenophobicparties.InDenmark,theDanishPeoplesPartyhastheroleofsupportpartytothegovernmentsincealmostadecade.InthelocalandregionalelectionsofNovember2009,thepartyincreaseditslocalmandatesfrom125to186.Thesuccessfulnormalization

    processhasbeenveryfavorabletotheDanishPeoplesParty,whoalsodoubledtheirmandateintheEPelection.ItiseasytoseewhyxenophobicpartiesontheriseregardtheDanishPeoplesPartyastheirrolemodel.

    Risky Acceptance

    ButtheDanishtoleranceisstillmorevigorousthaninItaly,wheretheNorthernLeagueispartofthegovernment.Moreandmoreoften,Italianpoliticiansrefusetocondemnracialriotsandhatecrimes.Instead,they

    shifttheguilttothevictims,sendingadangeroussignaltothepopulationthatethnicandreligiousdiscriminationisacceptableperhapsevendesirable.Italyistheworstcasescenario,anexampleofhowfastracistideascangainafootholdonceyoulettheextremerightinfromthecold.ThequestioniswhetheranyEuropeancountryshouldallowitselftotakethesamerisk.

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    35/36

    32

  • 8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6

    36/36

    Om FORES

    FORES r en ny tankesmedja som vill frndra. Globalisering och klimatfrndring innebr utmaningar som

    krver nya stt att se p samhllet. FORES ger debatten nya perspektiv, frimodiga ider och positiv energi.

    Vi bygger ntverk av samhllsintresserade och experter. Tillsammans kan vi ta fram tydliga och konkreta

    frslag p lsningar fr en hllbar framtid.