Upload
fores
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
1/36
TheExtremeandFarRightinEuropeLisa Bjurwald
FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
2/36
Abouttheauthor
LisaBjurwaldisafreelancejournalistandauthor.HerreportageontheSwissbanonminarets(Expono4/09)hasbeenawardedtheEuropeanParliamentjournalistprize2010intheSwedishpresscategory.ThisspringshewillreleasethebookEuropesShame:RacistsonAdvance(Nature&Culture).SheismemberoftheeditorialboardoftheantiracistmagazineExpoandhaspreviouslyworkedaseditiorialwriterfortheSwedishdailiesDagensNyheterandSvenskaDagbladet.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
3/36
Contents
Abouttheauthor .................................................................................................................................................2
Contents ..................................................................................................................................................................3
Foreword ................................................................................................................................................................1
Summary.................................................................................................................................................................3
1 Introduction...................................................................................................................................................9
2 ANewPRStrategy...................................................................................................................................10
3 TheMilitantBranch.................................................................................................................................13
4 RacistPartiesinaPositionofPower ...............................................................................................15
5 TheHatredAgainstMuslims ...............................................................................................................19
6 Roma:APeoplePersecuted .................................................................................................................22
7 TheNewAntiSemitism.........................................................................................................................26
8 StrategiesAgainsttheExtremeRight ..............................................................................................28
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
4/36
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
5/36
2
madebyIslamophobesacrossEuropetocollectivelyworkoutstrategiesagainstwhattheyseeastheIslamizationofEurope,inawaythatbringsupstrongmemoriesfromtheconspirationtheoriesofaJewishusurpationofpower.LeadersatthehighestpoliticallevelfromseveralEuropean
countriesmeettosolvetheRomaquestion.AtthesametimeRomaniesaremassevictedincontradictiontoEUlaws,theyaresubjecttomistreatment,arson,shootingsresultingindeath,andlackthesamerightsasothercitizensinmanycountries.Toapproachthesepartiespolicies(triangulationinpoliticallingo)hasineveryEuropeancaseledtolegitimizingthepositionandroleoftheextremists.Thosewhohaveapproachedtheirantiimmigrationrhetorichavewonshortsightedgains,buthavesoonlosttheirsupportandtheend
resulthasbeenastrengtheningoftheextremistparties.Theonlycountermedicineseemstobeestablishingastrongandcoherentcounterimagetothatofthexenophobicparties.Luckilythiscounterimagehassupportinfactsandeconomicreality.OurhopeisnowtocollectcommentsfromourcolleaguesatthinktanksandresearchinstitutesacrossEuropeinordertocollectivelydiscussthefurtherdevelopment,butwehavechosentopublishthisreportalready.
MartindahlCEOFORES
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
6/36
3
SummaryOrganizedracism,oftenmisleadinglyfromanideologicalperspectivecalledtheextremeright,isgainingparliamentarypowerallacrossEurope.Sincethebeginningofthe1980s,thepartieshavegonethroughasuperficialimagetransformation,whiletheyhavekepttheirracistandinmanycasesNaziroots.Theirnew,moreorderly,imagehasgiventhemincreasedrespectbymediaaswellasotherpartiesandtheyhavebeenabletomarchintoboththeEuropeanparliamentandnationalparliaments.ManyoftheracistpartieshavealsobeenabletouniteintheirhatredagainstMuslims.Furthermore,astheyhavegainedparliamentarysuccesses,theestablishedpartieshaveadoptedtheirIslamophobicrhetoric,anddiscriminationofMuslimshasbecomepartofthepoliticalclimate.ThisstudyprovidesanoverviewoftheorganizedracisminEurope.Inthefinalpart,strategiestocombatxenophobicandracistpartiesarepresented.
The Militant BranchMilitantnationalistsconstituteanurgentthreattodemocracy,especiallyinRussiaandHungary.TheRussianskinheadmovementconsistsofapproximately70000peopleandin2009atleast71peoplewerekilledinracistattacks.Jobbik,theantiSemiteandantiZiganistpartythatmadegreatgainsinthisyearselectioninHungary,hasaparamilitarybranch,theHungarianGuards(MagyarGrda).Thisneofascistmovementhasbeenbanned,buthassince
reformedintoaculturalsociety.TheyfindtheirinspirationintheArrowCrossPartyaHungarianmovementfromtheNaziera,andespeciallytheyouthhasbeendrawntotheirnationalistpropaganda.
Racist Parties in a Position of Power
Atpresent(September2010),twonationalistpartiesinEuropearepartoftheirrespectivegovernment:theSwissPeoplesPartyandLegaNordinItaly.IDenmark,theDanishPeoplesPartyisoperatingasasupportparty
tothegovernmentcoalition.XenophobicpartiesarerepresentedinabouthalfofthenationalparliamentsofEurope,aswellasinSwitzerlandand
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
7/36
4
Norway.IntheNetherlands,theFreedomPartyledbyGeertWildersmightbecomepartofagovernmentcoalition.In1999whentheAustrianpartyFPenteredthenationalparliament,the
EUrespondedwithadiplomaticboycott.Now,adecadelater,Europehasbecomeusedtohavingracistpartieswithintheparliamentarysystem.AnumberofpartiesontheextremerightarerepresentedintheEuropeanParliament.40outofthe736MEPscanbeclassifiedasextremerightorxenophobic.Moreover,therehasbeenashiftinthekindofpartiesrepresented,thetrendbeingtowardsmoreextremism.Forexample,LegaNord,theItalianpartypartofthegovernmentcoalition,reactedontheraceriotsinItalyinthebeginningofthisyear,whenAfrican
guestworkerswereassaultedandshotat,bysayingthatItalyhasbeentooslackagainstillegalimmigrants.Jobbikreceived15%ofthevotesintheelectiontotheEuropeanparliamentand16,7percentintheHungarianelection.IntheNetherlands,GeertWilders,whoatpresentstandsprosecutedwithchargesofhatespeechafteramongstotherthingshavingcomparedtheQuranwithHitlersMienKampf,received17percentofthevotes,makinghispartythesecondbiggest.ForthefirsttimeevenBritainisrepresentedbyxenophobesinthe
Europeanparliament,bytheBritishNationalParty(BNP).IntheFrenchregionalelections,FrontNationalmanagedtodoacomebackandreceivedover9percentofthevotes.JobbikhasinitiatedcooperationbetweenseveraloftheracistpartiesinEurope.InOctober2009,anewextremerightalliancewasformedinBudapest,TheAllianceofEuropeanNationalMovements(AENM).TheBNPandtheSwedenDemocratsaresomeofitsmembers.
InSweden,theSwedenDemocrats,apartywithitsrootsinneoNazismandwithseveralmembersstillhavingaffiliationswithNazimovements,hasasubstantialpossibilityofenteringtheparliamentintheelectioninSeptember.
The Hatred Against Muslims
Sincethe9/11terrorattacksin2001andthefollowingattacksinEurope,IslamphobiahasreallyestablisheditselfinEurope.AbanagainstminaretshasbeenpastinSwitzerlandandtheparliamentaryprocessofbanningthe
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
8/36
5
fullcoverveilinpublicspaceshascomerealfarinbothBelgiumandFrance.AccordingtoareportfromtheEUbureauonfundamentalrights(FRA),one
inthreeMuslimshasexperienceddiscrimination.Inanotherreport,fromtheOpenSocietyInstitute,basedoninterviewswithMuslimsinelevencitiesinsevenEuropeancountries,50percentoftherespondentssaidtheyhadexperienceddiscrimination,comparedto9percentofthenonMuslimrespondents.ThetermIslamizationhasbecomewidespreadinEurope.TheideathataMuslimovertakingofpowerconstitutesathreatstronglyresemblesJewsallegedaspirationofglobalpower.AnumberofantiMuslimorganizations
havebeenfounded,amongstothersStopIslamizationofDenmark(SIAD),aDanishorganizationthatnowhasnationalbranchesalloverEurope.InMarsthisyear,hundredsofIslamophobscametogetherinGermanyinordertodiscussantiMuslimstrategies.Thiswasonlyoneexampleofmeetingsandcampaignsorganizedbyracistsandpoliticians.TheinternationalsecretaryoftheSwedenDemocratswasoneoftheparticipantsinGermany.
Roma: the Persecuted People
ParticularlyinEasternandCentralEuropeaswellasItaltytheRomaniesaresubjecttochockinglevelsofviolence,persecutionanddiscrimination.Itincludesshootingsandarsonagainstadultsaswellaschildren.ThousandsofRomafamiliesfleetoCanadaandtheUSinordertoseekasylum.ApproximatelytentotwelvemillionRomaniesliveinEurope.Theirsituationiscomplexanditiswellknownthattheirsocialexclusion
istoacertaindegreearesultofchoice.Astheyhavebeensubjecttopersecutionduringseveralcenturies,thetrustingovernmentprotectionfrome.g.thepoliceisextremelylowamongtheRomaminority65100percenthavestatedthattheylacktrustinthejudicialsystemandactsofprosecutionaccordingtothefirstEUwidestudy.AreasonforthisisthefactthatthepoliceinEasternandCentralEuropehaverepeatedlyrefusedtointerveneincasesofmistreatmentandarson.InotherwordsRomaniesmaybeforcedtoisolatethemselvesforreasonsofsafety.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
9/36
6
PublicauthoritiesinseveralEUcountrieshavewithforcethrownoutRomafamiliesandhavethendemolishedtheircamps,inopencontradictionagainsthumanrightslegislation.InRomaniacertainRomafamilieshavebeenforcedtoliveintinshedsnexttosewerage
plants,inKosovoothershavebeenplacedincampswithhighconcentrationsoflead.MuchattentionhasbeendrawnbythemassexpulsionsofRomanies,inparticularinFrance,duringthelatesummer.Severalthousandshavebeenexpulsed,withoutindividualexaminations,andcontradicttherulesoffreemovementwithintheEU.EvenSwedenhasexpulsedRomaniesthathavesurvivedonbegging,despitethisnotbeinglegal.
RomanieslackrightsthatothercitizensenjoyinseveralEUmemberstates.InBosnia,theyareforbiddenfromrunningforparliamentorthepresidency.InFrancetheyhavetoberegisteredinamunicipalityforatleastthreeyearsinordertovote,whereasitsixmonthssufficesforallotherFrenchcitizens.AntiziganismiswidespreadinEurope.PartiessuchastheHungarianJobbik,BulgarianAtakaandSlovakNationalPartysee
Romaniesassubordinatetoanimals.InHungaryandtheCzechRepublicmistreatmentsandmurderishappeninginawaythatcouldbeseenasapretrialtoapogrom.
The New Anti-Semitism
Againstallodds,Islamists,personsfromtheextremeright,HolocaustdeniersandleftactivistshaveunitedintheirantiSemitism.WithinthemodernantiSemitism,thesameoldstereotype
ofthebloodthirsty,greedyJewisused,withtheonlydifferencethattherhetorichaschanged.SionistsandSionismareusedassynonymswithJewsandanimaginedJewishinfluence,aswellasthestateofIsraelisusedasacodewordforJudaism.Becauseofthis,NaziscanmarchoutsideofsynagoguesincentralStockholmandcryIsraeloutofSweden,despitetherebeingnodoubtwhichminoritytheyareaddressing.AntiSemitisminthesouthernSwedishcityofMalmhasstirredupmuchdebate,eveninternationally.ManyJewshavefeltforcedtoleavethecity.InseveralcountriesAntiSemitistpartieshavewon
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
10/36
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
11/36
8
Eveninothercountries,suchasItaly,whereracistpartieshavebeengivenpoliticalinfluenceandhavebeenmetbyembrace,racismhasspreadquicklyandbeennormalized.ThisisnotariskthatEuropean
countriesshouldtake.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
12/36
9
1 IntroductionThepurposeofthispaperistogiveanoverviewoftheorganizedracisminpresentdayEurope,withafocusontheEUcountries.Thetermorganizedracismisusedtodescribepopulistpartieswithxenophobicideas,aswellasthegroupsandpartiesoften(andrathermisleadingly)termedtheextremeright.Thetermisnotideal,astheextremerightisoftenmoreleftliketheNationalSocialistsofHitlerGermanythanright,asinconservativeorliberalconservative.Infact,theantifascistleftspearheadingthefightagainsttheextremerighthasquitealotincommonwithitsswornenemy.Thetwosidesbothtakeacriticalstanceon,forexample,theEuropeanUnion,capitalism,freetradeandpeacekeepingoperationsabroad.Atthesametime,thehatredagainstMuslimswithinmanyofthexenophobicandantiimmigrantpartieshasstrengthenedtheir(mostlysuperficial)supportforthestateofIsraelandtheJewishpopulationofEurope.Today,thesepartiescanholdmanifestationsonHolocaustRemembranceDay,orevenpayasolemnvisittoAuschwitz.ThishastriggeredreactionsofdisgustwithintheantiSemiticextremeright,whostillregardtheJewsastheirnumberoneenemy.Insomecorners,thehatredagainstJewsissostrongthatextremerightactivistswillevenconsidercollaboratingwithradicalMuslims;seeThenewantiSemitismformoreonthisdevelopment.Therootsoftodaysxenophobicpartiesand/ortheirleadershipcanoftenbetracedtotheextremerightmovement.Somehavecooperatedinthepast,orstillunofficiallydoso,withmoreextremeelements.This,incombinationwithasharedagendaandidenticalargumentsdrivenbyracismandnationalism,meansthattheracistscoveredinthispaperwillbe
sortedunderthesameheadingwhethertheyarewearingbootsorsuits.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
13/36
10
2 A New PR-StrategyTheskinheadmovementofthelate1970sandtheearly1980swasahighlymarginalized,maledominatedmovement,taintedbyalcoholabuseandapenchantforstreetfights.Yetamajorpartoftheextremerightwouldevolveoutoftheskinheadscene.TheperceivedthreatofincreasedimmigrationledtoaresurgenceofracistideasthathadbeentaboosincetheendoftheSecondWorldWar.Apolarizingusandthemworldviewmanagedtoswayatleastafewpercentofthevoters.Soon,inthe1980sand1990s,theracistpopulistsmanywithabackgroundinneoNazigroups,ahandfulwithlesssoiledbackgroundsenteredtheelectoralarena.Some,likeAustriasFreedomPartyunderJorgHaiderandFrontNationalunderJeanMarieLePen,wentontogainpoliticalinfluence.Others,suchastheSwedenDemocrats,weregrowingquietly.The1990swasalsomarkedbydivisionwithinthenewparties.Suddenly,theywereatacrossroads.Thechoice:toremainfaithfultotheirradicalideologyorselloutoraimfortherealpower,dependingonwhomyouasked.TodaysnationalistEuropeanpartiesarefilledwiththosewhochosepathswiththeirbrains,whiletheirheartsstillpoundedforthewhitepowerideology.Thisbecameevidentin,forexample,theradioshowKaliberontheSwedishRadio,which,usinghiddencameras,revealedhowleadingpeoplewithintheSDsangalongwithmodernwhitepowermusicaswellasnationalsocialistfightsongs.Atthedawnofthe21stcentury,the9/11bombingsintheU.S.andthelaterterroristactsonEuropeansoiltriggeredanIslamophobiathatbecametheunifyingfactorfortheparliamentarianfarright.MuslimsandtheallegedislamizationofEuropeappearedastheprimarytarget.ThebynowsuitcladracistsclearedoutatleastthemostvisibleantiSemitismandreplaceditwiththemoresellableIslamophobia.AstronghatredofJewsisstillacentralpartoftheideologyforsomenationalistparties,especiallythosewhoportraytheUnitedStatesasthedevilanddonothesitatetocooperatewithIslamists.ButitcomesasnosurprisethatIslamophobicpartiesareenjoyinggreaterelectoralsuccessintodaysEuropethanantiSemiticones.
Theimagemakeoverisanimportantfactortotakeintoaccountwhen
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
14/36
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
15/36
12
Anincreasedfocusonfamilyissuesandfamilyactivitiesisanimportantcomponentofthemovementsnewstrategy.Whitepowerconcerts,paramilitarytrainingandviolentdemonstrationsareallstillthere.Butthey
aresupplementedwithfamilydays,specialwomensorganizationsandastrongerstanceonclassicconservative(andNationalSocialist)issuessuchasnativity.Bydoingthis,theymanagetoreachthevoterswhowerepreviouslyputoffbythemilitantrhetoric.Thatanincreasingnumberofwomenarejoiningtheextremerightrankshasnotjustledtoasofterimage,buttothecreationofentireextremerightfamilies,wherebothparentsareactiveonthescene.Duringthecourseofthetransformationfromaggressiveskinheadsto
suitedpoliticians,popularresistanceagainstracismhasweakened.Theprominentantiracistmanifestationsofthe1980sand1990s,wheretoppoliticiansqueueduptobeseen,arerareintodaysEurope.ThisisfurtherverifiedbydatafromtheUniversityofGothenburgshowingpeoplesattitudestowardjoiningantiracistorganization.Duringthepasttenyears,thesharestatingwillingnesstodosohasdecreased.1
1 Demker, M. (2008), Lngsamma frskjutningar inom stabila ramar, i Holmberg, S. och Weibull, L. (red.) Skildavrldar, SOM bokserien nr. 44
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
16/36
13
3 The Militant Branch
Alargenumberofextremerightgroupshavepurposelypositionedthemselvesoutsidethedemocraticsystemandhavenodesiretobeacceptedbymainstreamsociety.Militantgroupswhodespisedemocracyandwishtobringdown(oratleastinterferewith)thesysteminaviolentmanner,existinpracticallyeveryEuropeancountry.Thegroupshavelowmembershipfiguresanditisnotunusualfortheiractiviststohavebeenconvictedforviolentcrimessuchasassaultormurder.Theycancooperatewith,orconstituteanationalbranchof,internationalNazinetworkssuchasCombat18orBlood&Honour.InHungaryandRussia,thesituationisratherdifferentfromtherestofEurope.There,themilitantnationalismisathreatagainstdemocracy.About70000activistsarethoughttomakeuptheRussianskinheadmovement.In2009,71peopleweremurderedand333injuredinracistattacks,accordingtotheRussianhumanrightsNGOSovaCenter.Despitethechockingfigures,thisisactuallythefirstdemisetobeobservedinsixyears.Butdifferentkindsofwhitepowerrelatedvandalismincreasedduring2009.InHungary,theantiSemiticandantiRomapartyJobbik,foundedin2003,hasmanagedtogainconsiderablesuccesswithinashortperiodoftime.Intheparliamentaryelectionsin2010,thepartyobtained16,7percentofthevotes,givingthem47seats.Thepartyevenhasaparamilitarywing,theHungarianGuard,whichisstronglyreminiscentontheArrowCrossPartyofthe1940s(moreonthisunderRoma:Apeoplepersecuted).Thesocalledfreenationalistsareanewphenomenon.Theyhavecopiedthenetworkbasedstructureoftheautonomousleftandgatheredinsmaller,independentgroupings,oftenbasedoncityorregion.Inotherwords,theydonotbelongtoanofficialmotherorganizationoranextremerightyouthassociation.Interestinglyenough,Europehasalsoseentheadventofsocalledautonomousnationalists,asortofanarchistNazis.Atdemonstrations,itisalmostimpossibletotellthemapartfromtheautonomouslefttheyproclaimtodespise,asbothsidesdressidenticallyinanarchistinspiredclothingevendowntotheirkeffiyehs.
Eveniftheseantidemocraticgroupsdonotconstituteathreatatthe
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
17/36
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
18/36
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
19/36
16
majorityoftheracistMEPsareeithernonalignedorbelongtotherightwingEuroscepticgroupEuropeofFreedomandDemocracy.IntheEPelectionofJune2009,theextremeandfarrightmadegainsinalmosthalfofthememberstates.Considerablesuccessescouldbenotedin
nolessthan11ofthe27countries.WhilesomehavepointedoutthatracistpartieswerealreadyrepresentedintheEuropeanParliament,andthatsomeevenmadeapoorershowingin2009thaninpreviousyears,afocusonwhichpartiesmadeprogressin2009givesabetterpictureofthesituationthanjustcomparingstatistics.TakeforexampleItaly,oneoftheEuropeancountrieswherethexenophobiaismostworrying.InJanuarythisyear,thecountrywasshakenbyraceriotsasAfricanmigrantworkersintheSoutherncityofRosarno
werebeatenupandshotatbylocals.TheseparatistNorthernLeague,governingthecountryincoalitionwithSilvioBerlusconisPeopleofFreedom,controlstheinteriorministrythroughinteriorministerRobertoMaroni.MaronihaspreviouslytriedtopushthroughanationalracialregisterwithfingerprintsofallItalianRoma.Thistime,hereactedtotheriotsnotwithcondemnation,butbydeclaringthatItalyhashadtoomuchtoleranceagainstillegalimmigrants.LastJune,theNorthernLeagueseriouslyadvancedtheirpositions.The
partyreceivedmorethanthreemillionvotesandincreasedtheirmandatesfromfourtonine,makingthemthelargestextremerightpartyintheEuropeanParliament.Thisachievementisfarmoremeaningfultothexenophobicmovement,onanItalianaswellasaEuropeanlevel,thanthefactthatthealreadymarginalized,neofascistForzaNuovaendedupwithonly0,47percentofthevote(146000votes).TheNorthernLeaguewasalsothepartythatmadethemostgainsintheItalianregionalelectionsinMarchthisyear.Intworegions,theybecamethelargestpartyforthefirsttime:PiedmontandVeneto.
TheDanishPeoplesPartymadeunexpectedgainsinthesummerof2009.PiaKjrsgaardsantiimmigrantpartyincreasedfrombarelysevento15percent,therebydoublingtheirmandatesintheEuropeanParliament.Justafewyearsprior,MortenMesserschmidt,whohasnowtakenupaseatintheEP,wasconvictedforincitementtoracialhatred.In2009,arecord284500DanessenthimtoBrussels.TheantiimmigrantTrueFinnsalsotookthevotersbystorm,goingfrom0,5toalmost10percentofthevote.Over100000FinnselectedpartyleaderTimoSoinitotheEuropean
Parliament.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
20/36
17
TheextremerightpartyJobbik(TheMovementforaBetterHungary),obsessedwiththegypsyquestionandwithclearantiSemiticviews,wonalmost15percentofthevotesandthreeseatsintheEuropeanParliament.AthisfirstsessioninStrasbourgthefollowingmonth,oneofthemembers
worethebannedfascistuniformbelongingtoJobbiksparamilitaryguard.IntheNetherlands,thexenophobicPartyforFreedom(PVV)whoseleaderGeertWildersiscurrentlyfacingchargesforincitementofracialhatredbecamethecountryssecondlargestpartywith17percentofthevote.ThechargeagainstWildersis,amongotherthings,basedonhisequatingIslamwithfascistideologies.Inconsciouslyprovocativestatements,WildershascomparedtheKorantoHitlersMeinKampf.ThechargehasresultedinWildersbecomingamartyramongstneoNazisas
wellaspopulists.AnotheroneoftheEPelectionsbigwinnersisNickGriffin.OveronemillionBritsmadesurethattheextremerightBritishNationalParty(BNP)senthimandanothermembertoBrussels.ItisthefirsttimethattheUnitedKingdomisrepresentedbyanextremerightpartyintheEuropeanParliament.PartyleaderGriffin,withaprominentcareerintheneoNaziNationalFrontonhisresume,isregularlyontheroadinEurope,makingnewcontactsandkeepingupothers.ThecooperationbetweenJobbikand
theBNPhasbeensosuccessfulthatJobbikestablishedanoverseasofficeinLondonin2009auniquemovebyanonBritishextremerightparty.FrancesinfamousFrontNationallostfouroutofitssevenmandatesintheelectiontotheEuropeanParliament.PartyleaderJeanMarieLePenisnowover80yearsoldandissoonexpectedtohandoverthethronetohisdaughterMarine,alsoanMEP.NickGriffinandhisBNPhavebeenquicktoseizethemomentandtrytofillwhattheyperceiveasavoidinthepanEuropeanextremerightleadership.
Butonanationallevel,FrontNationalmadeanunexpectedcomebackinMarch.Afterbeingdownforthecountsincethecatastrophicelectionof2007,thepartywonoverninepercentofthevoteinthisyearsregionalelections.PartoftheirregainedsuccessisprobablyduetoMarinelePenwhohasgiventhepartyofsofterimage.ShehasdissociatedherselffromantiSemitism,playeddowntheextremismandtriedtocamouflageIslamophobiawithfeminismandnationalism.
JobbikhastakenseveralinitiativestopanEuropeancollaborations.InOctober2009,anewextremerightalliancewasforgedinBudapest.The
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
21/36
18
partyfederationAllianceofEuropeanNationalMovements(AENM)consistsofJobbik,theBritishNationalParty,BelgiumsFrontNational,FrancesFrontNational,ItalysFiammaTricoloreandSwedensNationalDemocrats.Afterthefoundingmeeting,theNationalDemocratswrotethat
thepurposeofthefederationistoworkagainstliberalismandglobalismintheWest,withinanEUframework()Themainpurposeofthefederationistocoordinatethefightagainstthemutualenemywhichmanifest(sic)itselfintheinternationalglobalismthreateningthecultureanduniquecharacterofusall.AustriasFreedomParty(FP),somewhatlessradicalthantheAENMparties,isincludedinthemeetingprotocolbuthasnotsignedit,andhasofficiallydeniedthecollaboration.IntheEPelections,FPwon13percent
ofthevote,analmostsevenpercentincrease.Ittakessevenpartiesand25memberstocreateaformalpoliticalgroupintheEuropeanParliament,somethingtheextremeandfarrighthasfailedtodo.In2007,Identity,Tradition,Sovereignty(ITS)brokeupafterAlessandraMussoliniaccusedRomaniansingeneralofbeingcriminal.ThisinfuriatedtheGreaterRomaniaPartytotheextentthattheyleftthegroup,leavingITSwithnotenoughmembers.AlessandraMussoliniisthegrandchildofBenitoMussoliniandwasanMEPuntil2008.SheisnowamemberoftheItalian
parliament(chamberofdeputies).
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
22/36
19
5 The Hatred Against MuslimsMuslimshavebecomethenewJews,claimprominentexpertssuchasAustrianprofessorAntonPelinka3.Islamophobiagainedafootholdafterthe9/11attacksagainstAmericain2001andthesubsequentterroristactsonEuropeansoil.IslamophobiaishereusedasatermforprejudiceagainstanddiscriminationofMuslims,notcriticismagainst(forexample)IslamismortheradicalizationofyoungMuslims.Unfortunately,Islamophobiahasmoreandmorecometoinfecttheseriouspublicdebate.Whatstartedasalegitimateresistanceagainsttheoppressionofwomenhas,incountrieslikeFranceandDenmark,turnedintoafixationonatinyburqawearingminority.Themajoritysoppressionoftheminorityhasalwaysbeenoneofdemocracysweakpoints.RacistpartiesalloverEuropearenowtryingtousethedemocraticsystemtotheiradvantage.InNovember2009,Switzerlandvotedonabanagainsttheconstructionofminarets,thetowersadorningasfewasfourofthecountrysaround200mosques.TheinitiativetothereferendumwastakenbytheEgerkingerCommittee,whichconsistofpoliticiansfromthexenophobicSwissPeoplesParty(SVP),thecountryslargestparty,andalsoofpoliticiansfromasmallevangelicalparty,theFederalDemocraticUnionofSwitzerland(FDU).In2008thecommitteehadamassedthe100000signaturesrequiredforareferendumonachangeoramendmenttotheSwissconstitution.Againsttheodds,thebanonminaretconstructionswasvotedthrough,andSwitzerlandwassharplycriticizedbytheUNandNGOssuchasAmnestyInternational.BytheendofMarsthisyear,Belgiumslowerhouseofparliamentpassedaburqaban.Thelawisexpectedtocomeintoforcethissummer,makingBelgiumthefirstcountryinEuropetobanthewearingoffullcoverageveilsinpublic.Thosewhorefusetocomplyarethreatenedwithjail.TheNationalAssemblyofFrancevotedforabanofthefullcoverveilinpublicspaces.ThelawmustalsobepassedintheSenate.TheGermanantiMuslimmovementistryingtostopislamizationwiththehelpoftheLisbonTreatyandsignaturesfromonemillionEUcitizens.ThetermislamizationhasmadearealbreakthroughinEurope.TheideaofanimminentMuslimtakeoverisreminiscentofthewellknownconspiracy3
Neo-Nazis? No such thing, Primor, Adar, Haaretz 5.3.2010
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
23/36
20
theoriesofZOG4andtheJewsallegedstruggleforworlddomination.EuropeanMuslimsaresubjecttoadisturbingdegreeofdiscrimination.Ina2009surveyofMuslimsin14EUcountries,theEuropeanUnionforAgency
FundamentalRights(FRA)establishedthatoneoutofthreeMuslimshaveexperienceddiscrimination.Elevenpercentoftherespondentshadalsobeenvictimsofaraciallymotivatedcrime.AswithotherminoritygroupssurveyedbytheFRA,anoverwhelmingmajority,79percent,hadchosennottoreporttheirexperiencesofcrimeanddiscriminationtotheauthorities5.AccordingtothereportMuslimsinEurope(December2009)fromtheOpenSocietyInstitute6,whohavetakenacloserlookat11citiesinsevenEuropeancountries,50percentoftheMuslimrespondentssaidthatthey
hadexperienceddiscriminationbecauseoftheirreligioninthepast12months.ThiscanbecomparedtoonlyninepercentofthenonMuslimrespondents.IntheNetherlands,GeertWildersiswaitinginthewingsafterthegovernmentcollapseinFebruary.InthelocalelectionsonMarch4,seenasatestaheadofJunesparliamentaryelections,hisFreedomPartycamefirstinAlmereoutsideAmsterdamandsecondinthecountryspoliticalcapitalTheHague.ThesituationforMuslimsintheNetherlands,wheretheyonly
makeupaboutfivepercentofthepopulation,isaspreviouslymentionedverydifficult.LocalexpertsregardtheantiMuslimrhetoricoftheFreedomPartytobeadirectlycontributingcause.Accordingtoa2009survey,halfofthecountrysMuslimsareconsideringemigration.Athirdstatethattheywoulddefinitelyliketoemigrate7.AspointedoutinthecasewiththeSwissminaretban,theIslamophobesarequicktocopyothercountriessuccessfulstrategies.TheStoptheIslamisationofDenmarkorganization(SIAD)hasthusgrownintothepan
EuropeanmovementStoptheIslamisationofEurope(SIOE).Nationalchapters,fromSwedentoBulgaria,havealsobeenestablished.DuringthecontroversyregardingaMuslimculturalcenteronManhattan,StopIslamizationofAmerica(SIOA)hasfiguredinthemediaonamoreorlessdailybasisbecauseoftheircampaignagainsttheplannedbuilding.
4
Zionist Occupation Government. Zionists and Zionism are extreme right code words for Jews and perceived
Jewish influence.5
fra.europa.eu6
www.soros.org7
Opinion poll ordered by the Dutch program Netwerk. Quoted in Wilders makes half of Dutch Muslims want
to emigrate, Blass, Michael, Radio Netherlands Worldwide 090629 (www.rnw.nl)
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
24/36
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
25/36
22
6 Roma: A People PersecutedTatarszentgyrgyinHungary,February23.AhouseissetonfirewithMolotovcocktails.Ayoungfatherandhis5yearoldsonareshotdeadastheyfleetheirhome.VitkovintheCzechRepublic,April18.Threefamilymembersareinjuredinanarsonattack.Their2yearolddaughtersuffersburnson80percentofherskin.TiszalkinHungary,April22.54yearoldKka,leavingtoworkthenightshift,isshotdeadinfrontofhisfamilyhome.KisltainHungary,August3.Mria,amiddleagedmother,isshotandkilledinherbed.Her13yearolddaughterisseverelywounded.8Thestatisticscoveringbeatings,arsonattacksandmurdersinHungaryandtheCzechRepubliccanbereadasthefirststagesofethniccleansing.Buttheyearwhentheaboveattackstookplaceisnot1939but2009.Roma,previouslycalledgypsies,arefallingvictimtochockinglevelsofviolence,persecutionanddiscriminationinItalyandinEasternandCentralEurope.Now,RomafamiliesfleeEuropebythethousands,seekingasyluminCanadaandtheUnitedStates.YetthesafetyoftheRomaremainsalowpriorityforEurope.TheRomathemselveshaveadifficulttimerousingpublicopinionfortheircause.Thegrouplack,withfewexceptions,representativesatthehigherlevelsofsociety.TheRomaareEuropeslargestethnicminority.ApproximatelytentotwelvemillionRomalivehere,butthefiguresareuncertainandcouldbemuchhigher.AsopposedtoforexamplethewellintegratedJewishpopulation,theRomasituationismorecomplex.Itiswellknownthattheoutsiderstatusistosomedegreeaconsciouschoice.ManyRomaparentshave,forexample,takentheirchildrenoutofschoolbeforetheyhavebeenabletogoontohighereducation.ButcenturiesofantiRomapersecutionsshinealightonthereasonsbehindtheisolation.Inotherwords,Romafamiliesmaywellchoosetoremainseparatedfromtherestofsocietyforsecurityreasons.InEasternand
8
European Roma Rights Centre (ERRC)
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
26/36
23
CentralEurope,thepolicehaverepeatedlyrefusedtocometotherescueatbeatingsandevenarsonattacks.InEUMIDIS,thefirstEUwidereportondiscrimination(2009),6692percentoftheRomastatethattheyhavenotreportedtheirlatestexperienceofdiscriminationtotheauthorities.65100
percentsaystheylacktrustinthejudicialsystemandthelawenforcement9
.Areasonablesuspicioncanactuallybebehindthosehighfigures.AuthoritiesinseveralEUcountrieshaveforcefullyevictedRomafamiliesanddemolishedtheircamps.Thedemolitionshavebeencarriedoutinblatantbreachofhumanrightslaws.Often,thereisnoadvancewarning.InRomania,about75Roma,includingchildren,liveinsimplemetalshacksrightbesideasewagetreatmentplant.Sixyearsago,theywereforcefullymovedinwhatwascynicallycalledatemporarytransfer.Industrialareas
andgarbagedumpsareotherplaceswhereRomafamiliesaredeportedto.Andtheirnewhomesareofteneverythingbuttemporary.Despiterepeatedcriticismfromhumanrightsorganizations,healthyRomachildrenincountriessuchastheCzechRepublicarestillplacedinschoolsforthementallydisabled.InBosnia,RomaandJewsarelegallybarredfromrunningforparliamentandthepresidency.TheRomawhofledpersecutionsinKosovoarecurrentlybeingsentbackfromahostofEUmemberstates,despitethefactthatthesituationhasntimproved.Onthe
contrary,theRomainKosovoarevictimsofhateattacksandareforcedtoliveunderghettolikecircumstances.OneofthosewhohaveexpressedtheirconcernistheCouncilofEuropeCommissionerforHumanRights,ThomasHammarberg,whoatthebeginningofthisyearcondemnedthetransferofRomafamiliesacrosscountryborders.HammarbergisnowdemandingastoptodeportationsofRomatoKosovo.Needlesstosay,theRomaareingravedangerifEuropeleavestheirdestinyinthehandsofantiRomaextremists.HungarianJobbik,BulgarianAtaka
andtheSlovakNationalPartyconsiderRomatobelowerthananimals.Thefirstpartyhas,aspreviouslymentioned,alreadymadetheirentranceinBrussels.JobbiksantiSemitismisexpressedopenlyinwrittenmaterials,inspeechesandatmanifestations.InSeptemberthisyear,thevicepresidentofJobbiksaidtoReutarsthatthepartywantstoplaceRomasinpublicorderzones,someforalifetime.SidebysidewithJobbiksMEPsmarchesthemilitantneofascistsofthepartysparamilitarydivision,theHungarianGuard(MagyarGrda),
9
fra.europa.eu
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
27/36
24
inspiredbytheHungarianArrowCrosspartyoftheNaziera.DespiteabanontheGuard,fewofthemhaveputawaytheirbootsandvestsadornedwithroaringlions.Instead,theGuardhasbeenreestablishedasaculturalassociation.Menandwomenofallageshavejoinedtheirranks,butyouths
seemparticularlyluredbythetoughtalkingnationalistpropaganda.InthebeginningofMarch,anopinionpollshowedthatJobbikwas,forthefirsttimeever,morepopularwithyoungHungariansthantheSocialists.Intheagegroup18to24,Jobbikwaseventwiceaslargeasthepreviousrulingparty10.InItaly,thethreatsagainstRomahaveincreaseddisproportionallysinceSilvioBerlusconisnewgovernmentcametopowerin2008,accordingtothehumanrightsreportSecuritylaItaliana:Fingerprinting,Extreme
ViolenceandHarassmentofRomainItaly.ThereportdescribeshowraciallymotivatedattacksagainstRomaarenolongerisolatedincidentsbutratherastructuralcomponentoftheItalianeverydayreality11.AccordingtoastudypresentedtotheItalianparliamentinFebruary2010,almosthalfofthecountrysyoungmenandwomenarexenophobicorintolerantagainstimmigrants.15percentclaimedtohaveaphobiaagainstRomanians,AlbaniansandRoma.Those15percentweredominatedbywomen12.
InAugust2010FrancecommencedamuchcriticizedmassdeportationofRumanianandBulgarianRomanies.300campsweredemolishedinorderto,accordingtoFrenchpresidentNicolasSarkozy,curbcriminalityandaround1000Romashavebeendeported(September2010).TheeventsthattriggeredthedeportationsstartedwithadeadlyshotbythepoliceofayoungmanbelongingtotheRomaminority,whichleadtoriots.ThedeportationshavemetmassiveprotestsbothfromtheRomanies
themselvesandfrompoliticiansandhumanrightsNGOsaroundtheworld.VivianeReding,TheEUcommissionerforJustice,FundamentalRightsandCitizenship,saidthattheymightcontradictEUlawsoffreemovement,fundamentalrightsandcitizenship.Criticsofthedeportationsarguethattheyareillegalonthegroundsofnotbeingtriedindividually,inadditiontobreakingthelawoffreemovementwithintheEU.InSeptember2010,theEuropeanparliamentpassedaresolutioncallingforFranceandothercountriestoimmediatelyenddeportationsofRomapeople.Amongstother10
Poll reveals Jobbik scores better among young people than Socialists, MTI/Politics.hu, 10030511
From a coalition of human rights groups including the Open Society Institute and the ERRC, 2009. See forexample www.soros.org12
46 percent [of] young Italians xenophobic, AFP 100219
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
28/36
25
things,theparliamentarguedthatsincethedeportationsaregroundedonracetheyareactsofdiscrimination.VoiceshavealsobeenraisedforsanctioningFranceeconomically.
TherearealreadydifferentlawsinplaceforRomainFranceconcerningtherighttovoteinlocalelections.WhileRomapeoplehavetobeenregisteredinthesamemunicipalityduringthreeyearstohavearighttovote,sixmonthsisenoughforallothercitizens.DeportationsofRomanieshavetakenplaceinSwedenaswellduring2010.Thepolicedeportedapproximately50RomabecausetheyearnedtheirlivingthroughbeggingdespiteallEUcitizenshavingarighttostayinanothercountrythreemonthswithoutprovinghowtheymakealiving.Furthermore,beginningisnotillegalinSweden,butthepolicefoundit
dishonest.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
29/36
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
30/36
27
OmarandAhmedRamihavecopiedtheFrenchandcreatedanantiZionistparty.WithincontemporaryantiSemitism,ZionistsandZionismareusedascodewordsforJewsanddelusionsofJewishglobalinfluence.ThestateofIsraelisalsousedasacodedsymbolforanything
Jewish.Thus,ahordeofneoNaziscarryingtorchescanchantIsraeloutofSweden!outsidesynagogues(whichhashappenedinStockholm),withoutbreakingthelawdespitetherebeingnodoubtsastowhichminorityisintended.TheFrenchPartiAntiSionisteisledbycomedianDieudonnMBalaMBala,who,likeAhmedRami,hasbeenconvictedforantiSemitism(inDieudonnscase,forantiSemiticstatements).Oneofthegoalsstatedintheirpartyprogramreads:EradicatingallformsofZionisminthenation.
ThepartyranintheEuropeanParliamentelectioninFrancebutdidntmanagetosecureenoughvotes.ButDieudonnhimselfisverypopularamongFrenchactivistsonthefarleft,aswellaswithradicalizedimmigrantyouths.ThegodfatherofoneofDieudonnsdaughtersisnoneotherthanthegodfatherofFrenchracism,JeanMarieLePenofFrontNational.TheFreedomPartyscandidateinthisyearsAustrianpresidentialelection,BarbaraRosenkranz,istestamenttotheantiSemitismremainingwithinthepopulistpartiesevenifMuslimshavebecometheirpremiertarget.
Rosenkranz,marriedtoamanfrommoreextremenationalistcircles,havepreviouslydefendeddoubtssurroundingtheNazigaschambers.IntheAprilelection,shebecamethesitting(andreelected)presidentHeinzFischersonlychallenger.Despiteharshcsriticism,Rosenkranzsecuredalmost16percentofthevote.TheresulthasbeenmetwithuneaseintheAustrianJewishcommunity.InIsrael,newspapereditorialshaveencouragedJewsinAustriaandHungarytoleavetheirrespectivecountries.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
31/36
28
8 Strategies Against the Extreme RightTheEuropeancountrieshavetrieddifferentstrategiestofacethethreatfromorganizedracism.Insomecountries,xenophobicpartieshavebeenleftoutinthecold,whiletheirantiimmigrantargumentshavebeencopiedinordertowinovervoters.Inotherplaces,exemplarymeasureshavebeentakentoinformthepublicoftheracistshatefulagendaonlytohavetheextremerightdominatethepolls.Manypoliticalpartieslackanysortofstrategyandseemtooperplexedtotakeseriousaction.Anditsnowonder:neitherisolationnoractiveoppositionhasworked.ThisisalsowhattheBertelsmannFoundationinGermanyfoundwhenthey,inagroundbreakingproject,studiedandcomparedstrategiesagainsttheextremerightin11Europeancountries.Nostrategyisuniversalandguaranteedtowork,theyconclude,butsuggestanumberofspecificmeasures.Amongstthoseare:
Showpoliticalresponsibility.Byformingantiracistcommitteesonthehighestpoliticallevels,thepoliticianswillmakeitclearthatdiscriminationandracismareareasofconcern.
Practicepoliticalleadershipandbesuretotaketheinitiativeinthedebate.Politiciansshouldneverforgettoemphasizethepositiveeffectsofadiversifiedsociety.
Racismhastoresultinaredcard.Whenpoliticiansororganizationsdemonstratexenophobicideas,theyhavetobebannedfromimportantpositions.Withoutthissortofzerotolerance,societywillbeinfiltratedby,forexample,Islamophobicideas.
Increaseawarenessofhatecrimesandkeeptrackofinfringementoflaws.Swedenisheldupasagoodexample,buttheSwedishhatecrimelawisactuallyapapertiger.Inotherwords,itisimportantthatthethreatofhatecrimeconvictionsdoesntloseitsteeth.
Themediaplaysakeyrolewhenitcomestoexposingtheagendaofthexenophobes.AsinforexampleFranceandGermany,investigativejournalismfocusingontheextremerightshouldbeencouraged.
TheBertelsmannFoundationisalsofocusingontheneedforinformation.TheEuropeancountriesshouldsharetheirknowledgeaboutthedifferentstrategiesthatexisttocombatthethreat.Perhapsthereisevenaneedfora
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
32/36
29
commonEuropeanstrategy.Inanycase,thethreatmustnotbedismissedasamarginalisedphenomenon,theywarn.Theextremerightmustbekeptunderclosewatch,especiallyasitisassumedthatglobalisationwillmakethemovementgrowevenlarger14.
ProfessorMontserratGuibernauattheUniversityofLondoncomestothesameconclusioninherpaper,Migrationandtheriseoftheradicalright(March2010)15.Init,shecriticizesmainstreampartiesforregardingtheextremerightasabunchoffanatics.Thefactthatnomajorpartyhasneitherbeenabletocalmthepublicsfearsaboutimmigration,orstoptheriseoftheultraright,begsthequestionofwhetherthepartieshavetrulyunderstoodwhatfactorsaredrivingthevotersintothearmsofthexenophobes,writesGuibernau.
Guibernaupresentsthreeelementsthatshouldbeincludedinthepartiesresponsetothechallenge.Firstofall,voterconfidenceinpoliticsmustberestoredbyincreasedtransparencyandlessbureaucracy.Thepartiesalsoneedtoformulateabalancedwayofrelatingtoimmigration,whichneedstobecontrolled,whilestillrespectingthehumanrights.Finally,politiciansshouldacknowledgetheworkingclassesconcernoverthelabormarket,wheretheyoftenfeelincapableofcompetingwithcheaper,foreignlabor(despitestudiesshowingthatthereisnosuchcompetitiononthemarket).
Popular Resistance
Onastrictlymoralnote,itmustbeconsideredbettertofacetheextremerightthantoremainpassive.Astrongantiracistpopularmovementisasignofhealthandasignaltovotersaswellastheextremeright,thatracistopinionsdonotbelongincivilized,diversifiedsocieties.Preventativeactivismisoneofthebestcuresagainstorganizedracism,andthisisalsowhatForeshasconcludedinitspolicypaper2010:1,Localresistanceto
xenophobia.InGreatBritain,theantiracistSearchlightMagazinerunsanationalcampaignagainstracism,HopenotHate.AdoubledeckerbuspaintedahopefulyellowhastouredthecountrytoinformabouttheBritishNationalParty.Searchlighthasmanagedtomobilizethousandsofactivistsandco
14
Bertelsmann Stiftung (red.), Strategies for Combating Right-Wing Extremism in Europe, Gtersloh: Verlag
Bertelsmann Stiftung, 200915
Published by the Policy Network ahead of the conference Migration and the rise of nationalist right-wingparties: confrontation, isolation or engagement in Copenhagen. Can be downloaded from: http://www.policy-
network.net/uploadedFiles/Publications/Publications/Migration and the rise of the far right.pdf.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
33/36
30
operateswithlocalantiBNPgroupsfromNorthtoSouth.TheSwedishantiracistfoundationandmagazineExporunsasimilarcampaign,TheSwedenDemocratsAreWrong,since2008.Basedonabookwiththesamename,Expocampaignsthroughlectures,studycirclesand
Internetactivism.InGermany,itisnotunusualforpeoplefromallwalksoflifetoturnupatantiracistmanifestations.Familieswithyoungchildren,anarchists,gayactivists,priestsfromtheCatholicChurchandothershave,throughtheuseofactivenonviolence,managedtostoptheextremerightsshowofforceandspreadingofpropaganda.OneofthemostimportantdatesintheEuropeanextremerightscalendaristheDresdenMemorialDay,wherethevictimsoftheAlliedbombingsarehonored.Atthisyearsmemorial,10000
Germansformedahumanchain,barringtheneoNazisfrommarchingthroughthecity.
Cordon Sanitaire a Line of Decency
ApoliticalequivalentoftheDresdenresistanceisthesocalledcordonsanitairedrawnupbyBelgianpartiestokeepthexenophobicVlaamsBelangatbay.Thestrategyinvolvesanagreementamongsttheotherpartiesnottocooperatewiththeracistpartyinordertokeepitata
distance.AsimilarlinewasalsodrawnupbythemainstreampartiesinFrancetocounterthethreatfromtheFrontNational(whichiscurrentlymarginalized,muchbecauseofthisstrategy).Oneobviouscriticismwasandstillisthattheapproachisundemocratic.InthecaseofFrance,xenophobicideasalsomanagedtobreakthroughthesanitaryquarantineandentermainstreampolitics.
Supporters and Dealmakers
Someexpertsproposeastrategywheretheestablishedpartiestakeontheareasthattheextremerighttriestoclaimastheirs.Inotherwords,immigration,integrationandIslam.Butthisstrategyisquiteeasytocriticize.InseveralEuropeancountries,attemptstotakebacksuchissueshaveresultedinapoliticaldebateuncomfortablyfixateduponIslamandMuslims.Inreality,theresulthasbeenthattheextremerightissettingtheagenda.NorwaysProgressParty(FrP)isoneexampleofxenophobiaslowlybutsurelybeingnormalized.Today,aftercompromisesanddiscreetsupportfromotherparties,theFrPisNorwayssecondlargestparty.ThequestionEuropespoliticiansneedtoaddressiswhetherthisriskis
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
34/36
31
betterthancooperatingwithxenophobicparties.InDenmark,theDanishPeoplesPartyhastheroleofsupportpartytothegovernmentsincealmostadecade.InthelocalandregionalelectionsofNovember2009,thepartyincreaseditslocalmandatesfrom125to186.Thesuccessfulnormalization
processhasbeenveryfavorabletotheDanishPeoplesParty,whoalsodoubledtheirmandateintheEPelection.ItiseasytoseewhyxenophobicpartiesontheriseregardtheDanishPeoplesPartyastheirrolemodel.
Risky Acceptance
ButtheDanishtoleranceisstillmorevigorousthaninItaly,wheretheNorthernLeagueispartofthegovernment.Moreandmoreoften,Italianpoliticiansrefusetocondemnracialriotsandhatecrimes.Instead,they
shifttheguilttothevictims,sendingadangeroussignaltothepopulationthatethnicandreligiousdiscriminationisacceptableperhapsevendesirable.Italyistheworstcasescenario,anexampleofhowfastracistideascangainafootholdonceyoulettheextremerightinfromthecold.ThequestioniswhetheranyEuropeancountryshouldallowitselftotakethesamerisk.
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
35/36
32
8/7/2019 The Extreme and Far Right in Europe - FORES Policy Paper 2010: 6
36/36
Om FORES
FORES r en ny tankesmedja som vill frndra. Globalisering och klimatfrndring innebr utmaningar som
krver nya stt att se p samhllet. FORES ger debatten nya perspektiv, frimodiga ider och positiv energi.
Vi bygger ntverk av samhllsintresserade och experter. Tillsammans kan vi ta fram tydliga och konkreta
frslag p lsningar fr en hllbar framtid.