The Diffrent Bettween Aldarorah and Alhajah

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

بحث دقيق حول الفرق بين الضرورة والحاجة الشرعيتين

Citation preview

  • Gd H GdhQI hGdLJk Y H

    GC MG GC b Gd

    Gd Y Gd H Hq Y Gd GC hQhH dE aA hGd

  • H Gd GdM GdMGd d hGdI hGd Y Sf e hY GB d hU.

    ee``GE GE Y GdL a GC M GC U e Gd Gd j c e GdS,

    GC V GE d Pd GC GC c Gdj Gd GdUI SGAk J Gd hb Gd a eW Gde GC h J Gd JG eQI GC ee JL GE d GE Td Jj GdL

    hJj Gd Gd jC Y: g J HdhQI a M GC h J H?SGAk cf bj W J H Gd ek GC h GE LV, GC h bj GbOj

    J HdO GdjI e GE jQ j Hd GC h JC e HC fGY, GC h GC MGdc hGC S hYO GdQj hGdh GdGF GdaI Y GdaA H

    Gd. e j GC Jj Yb GdL HdhQI GC U eMk C b eGde Gd a Gd Gdj.

    hSC Mh GB - YOGk Y HA - GC GC f cf gG GdV C Y YGf hGC ZQa GC ZGQg hGC U a bf )hc Hd e e he(. hPd M Gd

    Gdd:1. Jj GdhQI:

    - d hGUMk : e fU Gdj hfU GC Ud hGdA.- GC U ehY GdhQI.

    2. Jj GdL:- d hGUMk : e fU Gdj hfU GC Ud hGdA e

    GC e a JR Gd H hH GdhQI.- GC U ehY GdL.

    121

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • 3. f Gdj: GdH Gd hGdGN Gd hGC Ud, eC GTGGC h Gd.

    4. Gd PG Gdb HV GdhQI hGdL.5. GE L Gdh H GdhQI hGdL HAk Y e Pcf e GdA

    hGC Ud hGdj.6. hGC NGk J eUI e bGQG Gd GC hQH dE aA he Gd

    GE Se HI e Gd Y g GdGQG.7. NJ J fF Gd.

    Jj GdhQI dk hGUMk :GdhQI a GU d KK em : Gd Gd GdU Gd j Gd

    hGd GSd GdS hg j GdL, hGd GC Ud.

    GdhQI d:b e Gdj GdhR GC HO a GdeS ehLk HM: )hGVGQ GM

    GE d GdA( hb )GV GE d( GC e )GC ML hGC dC aVo . H GdA( HhD GaL GdA WA C GdA d j d e GdO )hGS GdI( Hd. b

    OQj H Gd:hJ e VI Gd ebk hW Gdi OQ Y e

    GC JC dD Y. ha Mj Y QV Gd Y Qa GC f f Y H Gd. bGH GC K: hgG j e hL GC Mg GC j GE d Gd e Wj GE cG

    Y, b: "hgG H aS j, hGdf GC j GE d Gd dj Qc GC h eD fJg a e a j Hdc dhQI, hgG S a M Gdj hGdhAI GC

    jj Y gG GdL hd jo hjo V GE d GdI GC h Jo i S H aE

    122

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Y Gd e GdhQI Y gG GdL U hd j e cGg GC g Gd d".he Gd gG GdGA GC h Gdj GC h b Gd.

    hbd Ys hLs : }a GVo s Z Hm h YOm | GC a GC o dA GE d GC c Gd heM hVq Y GC e Hd hGC U e GdQ hg Gd.

    )hGdhQI GdL( hj Y GdhQG )cdQhQI hGdQhQ hGdQhQGA(GC NG f GdZJ hGC f a Gd Y GdQhQI:

    GC K GC N VQhQI GC U Gdi Y hb a Gdj GC hGUhb Gd: GdhQI GS dQ GVGQ, J M GdhQI Y cG

    hcG.b: a gG GdhQI hGdI cg GS a GC hd GC j Gd

    cdI hGdhQI K j hg GC jk GdL Gd c j.ha Mj SI j e GdQhQI U GC h Z. GC GE f j d e

    Gd GC jC c e e j Gde e ZGA GC h YA hd d GC j H.)hGdQ( ec )Gd( j e Ph VQ GC Ph V. )J GdhS:

    3/943(.hGE f Pc gG Gd Y Wd d GdQiA Gd Gdj Gd cf hHh

    T Yek e YGe Jh GC bG GdA a e GdhQI. hb j eGd GC jq GE d H GC d Gd hQO a gG Gd dj GdhQI hg

    GM hGdL hGE dA hGd he j MaGk d e Oj jc Gd GC heD f Jg GC h GE cG j GC h L jD GC h GC YGA j Y c g Gdf

    Gd GC TQ GE d GC g Gd hg em J GE d GdI hGd hg Gd Of MdGdA c Si.

    123

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdhQI GUMk :hGdhQI a GU a hJ GE Wb GC Mg: VhQI bi J

    Gdq Si e GSo . hGdf: VhQI Oh Pd hg Gdq Y HdL GE qGC f j Y GdhQI a GS JSk , hZ Gd hJo VhQI

    GC Ud hg: GdhQI Gde Hd, hd GE e Gde e GC h e Gf GE d PdM b a Gdg: "GE GdhQI Y GC b, a J GdhQI fYk jg

    b c Pcf. hb J GdhQI GdA hd J Mk cq k a Gd,H j J a c T cC c Gd hW Gd )hg g GdhQI Gd

    J HdhQI Gd Hd GC N(. hGd Gdd e jJ a GC UHdhQI hd j Gd a GBMO hGC TU hgG cd he a e

    )Gdg: U 249(.hdGC a Jj GC b GdhQI:

    1- GdhQI Gd Hd GC N:Yq a GdW Hd: )adhQI HZ Mq Gk GE d jh Gd g GC h bQ

    hgG j Jh GdG( )GC T hGdF: U16(. hg g GdhQI Gd bY GE e Gde GC f J Mk ck a Gd H j J a c

    T cC c Gd hW Gd c GC S.b a e Gd hg "Ta": )e N e Y GC c Y f eJk GC h

    eVk eak GC h RjOJ GC h W eJ GC h GfY Y Qa GC h N V e GC hQc hd j Mk jC c hhL MGek de GC c(. Gde: GdQOj a Gd Gd

    "ed": )GdhQI g M GdS e Gd GC h TI GdQ( )GdQOj: 2/381(.haq GdQbf a TM GdhQI bFk : )hg N Gd Y Gd Yk GC h

    Xk ( GE q GC f H Pd f Y GdF Y GdSd bd: "hg M GVGQ N

    124

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd GC h N GdV, b dd hGda". )GdQbf: 3/8(.Yq a GdU )M(: "g N GdQ GC h Gd Y Gd GC h H

    GC YA H GC c" )GC M GdGB: 1/591(.b GdW: GVGQ j GC j HE cG e Xd GC h H e e

    hGd Y GdQ e GdA hGdA a e GBj g e U Gd hGdhg Gd GE d Pd, hb e GC c hZ Y GC c g Gdq e. )GdW:

    2/522(.2- GdhQI Hd GSd Gd GdS hGd J GdL:

    b N: "hU b )GC Hh Gd( e GC U GC h GC d H GC h Y T b GE f hGV GC GM c a GdV Y Gd H Gd Gd j e

    GNQ". )GdQbf: 5/781(.he GS GdhQI hjo GO H GdL b GdRQ a Th GZQ GdQ

    Gd: b GH Ya: "RGO GdRQ c e Gd Z eO hVhQI GQJH,hbQ Hd e H GC L hLGR H Gd Gd bQ Mg Gd H

    hM hLGR GdGA d e GM f hJe hLGR ON Gd e bQeA GdS hd a hGd e Gdb GE LYk , a Gd Od Y GE dA e g

    j OY GdhQI d". GH Y Gd a RjOI GdRQ GE T hQO gG"GE T" GH Ya )Gdq G a Gd hGE c He Gd 4/563(. H

    Yq N HdL a g GdC d M b: "hGZ ZQ j dL d j")f GdL hGd(.

    hb fs Gdf a MT Y YQI GdRQ bFk : "hdG Yq GdRQ Y bGdL HdhQI hg GC N e GdL d Gd S" )MT Gdf Y

    GdQbf: 5/08(.

    125

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • he GS` H GdL e Gda UM fj Gd bFk : "fGC hd H e RGO Y e a Y cj heD f S hj e Y RGF Y Pd

    a Re GdhQI. hY e JQ GNU Jj GMQ HC bG" )2/74(.adhQI g GdL, C GVGQ GE PG J d j dd cj S M

    YQI GC H GdA GdGe a GdT Y f Gd.

    3- Gd GC Ud dhQI:dhQI e Kd g Gd GC Ud hfs Y GE e Gde a Gdg a

    Gd Gdd, hb Pcf. hb RGO GC e hVMk Ye b: hg j Gd eGdhQ hj H )GdhQ( J Gd aE GdS d d jOdG e HC jj

    dq Pd VhQI XgI a Gd GE PG GB GE d GdhQI GdGL GE d Gd hGdK b J a Gdj GC GC U GE PG K bGYg a f GE d W J a

    GBMO Gd. )U 329he Hg(.hb GC hV GdW HC f GE Mi Gd Gd Gd JL GE d eU Gdj

    M j: "aC e GdhQj ag GC f H e a b ed Gdj hGdfH GE PG a d J ed Gdf Y GSe H Y aO hJQ ha

    MI ha GC Ni a GdI hGd hGdL HdG Gd" hJ GdWY eGYI GdhQI e Lf GdLO heGYJ e Lf Gd hes dd

    HC U GdOG hGde )aGL: 2/89(.hgG g Gd Gdq Y HdhQ C f e VhQG SS Gdd hHF hGf

    GC MGd M YQI Gda )3/902(.hjq Y HdhQI Hd GE d Gd GdGb a e, a Pd b GdGd

    eKk Y Gd GdS: "hGE hb a eb GdhQI LR GC jD Oi GE dGLO e H GC J b c" )Gda: 3/112(. he b

    126

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gdcf: "GC f GE cf J Gd VhQj b c cf eI aE aGC M g GdK d J, hGdGO HdhQj GC J e GdhQj Gd

    hHd GC J L Gd, d cf d GdS Oh H GC h a MdeU Oh Md". )Gdcf: GE QTO Gd: U 242(.

    hb GdW: "e GdhQj N hg M Gdj hGd hGdhGd hGd" )GdGa: 3/01(.

    hGC e dPG So HdhQI? GE e C f VhQI f MI GdS c J, GC h C GYQg "Gd GE d e Y HdhQI cf eOI d Hd hGM

    H HC Od NQL Y Gd" )GE QTO Gd: U 242(.hb J GC c GC Ud Y GdhQI hGdhQ a GdV GdS GdS

    E K M Hd GdI GE d e Z GYQ GdS HhW, hGC MGd J Y GdF H, cd, GC M eI hg jC J Gd H GE q Y

    Z Gd.hb J GSA e Y c j Y GSO Gdd:

    b GdL: "hGN b ed a GdL jC J OGQ Gd aa GE d a hRfkhjC N e hRfk OQGg hj GC LI Gd. a eI: GC QL GC j Nk .

    hPc GH GdGR hQhG Y Y GH GdS he Pd Y H OjQ hM GHM Y LY e GC U ed, hH b GC H M hGda. hL QhGj

    GdGR Y GdGg e GM H e VhQI GdS GE d GdQGg hJQ Gd GE q aPd GdV e ML GdS GE d GS hGfR Gda dhQ e GC UH

    hNa Y f a GfGO hj GE Z Y Pg GC j hj HhGdhQI Gde J GdQ. GC e Gd a UQ Gd H H hGJ GC e a

    jR hhL QhGj Gd GC f j GC j Hk GC h GE LQI, aE c Hk a

    127

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdV a Gdg, hGE c GE LQI a GE LQI hS hPd Z LF aGdL" )Gd: 4/952(.

    b: hVhQI GdS GdcQI g hcd GdhQI Gde GE f g H GdLGde hd j e c GC H Gdd GC e c gG S e GE K GC M e

    GC L GdhQI Gde HLO jh HhG GdV Gd GC Oi GE d hd c GdHH GdQ.

    hY GS GdhQI a e GdL Hd GC Ud b ed a eC d GdOY GdQg )e eF Gd( ; b ed: c f hjd GC g GdG K

    GC Lf dhQI GdS hC f jh H Uak .a S GH SG QM Gd j: QL ed a GdO Y GdQg d Z

    e GC L GdhQI. )Gdq G: 4/103(.hH Gdj HdhQI d hHdhQI a GU GdA hGC Ud fM GC

    GdhQI GC e jQ Vk he GE q GC gG Gd jh a TJ adhQI eH Gd Gd Y GdW hg c b GC N a TM d

    )Gd( a Gd hGE GN a HdI hGd S ck ek cdVaE s e a GdQ GC bi e e a Gd ek . hgG H GdGWA hg

    Gd GJ e a GC aGO cE f. )jo GL T Gd Y bd(:hf GC d` df N GC b H f`

    JGWD Jc Jd` hGTG Y GdGOhGC Qi GC Gd Y GdhQI hGd hGdL KK e H Gd Gd

    b j eMk d GN YQG Gdj hGdA, adhQI j GC Jo a M GdI Gdi c j GC Jo a M Oh Pd hHdd JJ

    GC M e Y Pd c QGC j.

    128

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GC U ehY M GdhQI:a b Gd Jd: }hb as d e Mo u Y GE s e GVo QJ GE d| )SQI

    GC f 911(b GdU: Pc Gd Jd GdhQI a g GBj hGC W GE HM a H

    dLO GdhQI e Z T h U hg bd Jd: }hb as d e Mo u Y GE s e GVo QJ GE d| )SQI GC f 911( ab Pd hLO GE HM

    HLO GdhQI a c M ho L a. )GC M GdGB dU: 1/741(.hb Jd: }a GV Z Hm h YOm a GE K Y| )GdI 371(. b GH

    Y: "he GV Y" hZ, gG g Gd Gd Y LQ GdAhGdA. hb: e GC c hZ Y GC c g Gde )GdQ GdL H

    Y: 2/17(. hGdU cI HG Gd.hHdb Y bd Jd: }hb as d e Mo u Y GE s e GVo QJ

    GE d|, j GdA e: Gd Gd Pc GdU hg hLO GE HM MhL GdhQI. he GBN hg GE f aq e Gde J GE q GdhQI.

    hgG e j GE d Gd a GSA Y e Y j GC j e Hd GC GdL GE f JN Gd h JN a Gd hGd GC Y.

    Jj GdL:a b GdhR GC HO ehLk HQM:

    )hGdL( GdC QH )( GC eha, hbd Jd: }hdG Y MLk aUhQc| )Za08(. b K: j GC SQ. hY T: hb GC GdL

    Jo Y f GaQ hY GdA Gd j GE d, hb Gd GC H gGd a ahb: GdL GdQ Y Gd Gd, jo Gd j GE d

    Nb hGd N Gd hGd H Gd hGdL GC Gd S hGd

    129

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • j GE d f hGd GC Y e Sd a Gd hZ, K b: bhZ a HC GdL GC Y e Gd hH Hd hGdU GdL hH J

    GC Y GdL Y Gd g J GC h Y GC Y GC h GC N GC h Z PdaC e. b: Uj c T GC GdL e Y Gd hd cd H

    bd hGdL c e eGC hN bd eh c g Xg a j GE de Pc e GdL )cdLA( Hd hGd )h( b )J( GE PG )W( GC

    GdL H GdL hN j j e jL e e, ha GdJ GE d GdA GM GE d hGC QGO ) M( b GdY:

    hGC QV ML H GC Ni cG Gd JV HdGC e GdL a GU a VH: ML Ye b J ed GdhQI hg

    g GdL GC Ud hb Sq g H HdhQI Gde c GC S, hML aNU M eD b J JSk d GdhQI.

    GC hk : GdL Gde )GC Ud(b GE e Gde a Gd GC h: "hGd Gdf e j HdL Gde h

    j GE d M GdhQI, he gG J GE LQI aE f e Y GdL GE dGdc, e GdQ Y J, hV ec H Y S GdQj a ML

    XgI Z Hd e GdhQI GdhV a Gd hZ hd ML Gd b Je GdhQI Gd GdGM e M GE Gda d eG Y J GdL a

    Gd d GBMO Gd VGQ ed J e GdhQI a M GdGM, hbjj GC K Pd a GdQ GdGL GE d Gd Y e j GBMO Hd GE d Gd,

    hgG e j HC M GE jd hGd Pcf eGQ ZV GB". )Gdg 429(.hb GC jk : "hf fi GC fq b J Gd a Y GC e hg GC GE LQI LR

    NQL Y GC b Gd Sg LF a Gd GC h aE eH GdV GdLO

    130

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • HdV Gdh NQ Y GdS GdY a GdhV aE bS GC jHGE q eLOG hd GM Pd a GE LQI d GdL hb Pcf GC GdL

    Gde J ed GdhQI GdU a M GBMO GC TU". )Gdg 139(.hS J GC H Me GdGd e a cH "TA Gd a H Gd

    hGd hed Gd" M b a eV ce Y GdhQI Gd SO GE da e e gG Gd: "hGdL Gde a M ca Gd J ed GdhQI

    GdU a M Gd GdGM" )U 642(.hGE d Lf gG Gd fi GdGd f Ye j Y Gd j "GE f

    hGE hb a eV GdL GC h Gd d J hGE hb a eV GdhQI LRGC jD O GE d GLO e H GC J b c c GC S".

    hb Y GC K J GC H H H GdH Gdd M b a cH Gd)GdYI GdH(: "GYQ GdL a Jj Gd cYQ GdhQI a J

    Gdq " hH GC V ek dd HSA GdV Gd j d GC L Y ede H Gdg Hdg GE d GC L, GC V: "he Pd Mj GdGj hH Gd a

    Y QhD hS Gd Hd GdV Y GC QV ha e GdH KK GC hL: HGdW HdH hGd HdR hGd a Jj Gdd GdHj hJC N GdH

    GE b GC f j d GE PG M LGP Gd" )Gd: 2/097-197(.GE q GC H GdA cH f hGdW fG GdL e ee GC Ud GE d

    GdGY Gd Oh Jj VGH e GC hg H GdM GdUj GC f cM dGF e GC h YV ML j GE HM hcC f j GE d bYI b

    J Y Gd H hGS TC GdhQI Gd Hg GC N a H.hdG aV f GdYI Y GdW d eNk E HGA Gdh GdI H

    GdhQI hGdL.

    131

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • b GdW )GdYI Gde(: GdL J ed GdhQI Ye cf GC hNU. )e GC hd( ehY GE LQI hGdd hGdGd hfg LR Y

    N GdS d a GC hd e hQhO Gd Y ea ehe, ha Gdf eGdd ha Gdd e H Gdj Hdj d GdL GE d Pd. hGdL GE PG Yq

    cf cdhQI he V GdQ LR Y N GdS GE P GdF GE PG H ef d e GC N` e Gd Ojk Y M j` d` M` GdS GE d

    ee` e ja h jD e Nh Gd ek , he e Gd hGE HMGd de hfg hZ Pd. e Gdf J GE fA Hd hjR dL

    h j Gd Y Z Gd C f j GC U GE fA e Gdj bk H GdGOGC ZGV Gd Hd SGA Gdj cE U eV Gd hGd GdK

    he GC c e Gd a OGQ Gd LF dL h j dC c GC j eZ. )GC T hGdF: U 2636(.

    aFI: c GdS e GdW GC jj b Gd a g GdYI hcC f dI eON a d jOg hd GC M GE KJ aC e.

    hYQI GdQc QM Gd Jd: GdL Gde J ed GdhQI GdU aM GBMO GdS, K b: GdL GdU J GdQG. Gf. he PcJ

    GC b GE d GSd GC c, GC GdL J e GdhQI aC e. )GdgHe GC T hGdF: U 121-221(.

    hg GdL Gd Pcg GdW hGH f g ML GC Ud Hd HA MhGSGQ Hh ML d a GBMO GC aGOg hg GdL Y GC Ud

    Gd J Y M b GdW GdL: e j GE d e M GdS hQaGd GdD O a Gdd GE d Gd hGd GdM H Gd hGE PG d JG

    ON Y Gd - Y Gd - Gd hGd hd j GdO Gdba Gdd Gde hg LQj a GdOG hGdOG hGde hGdj

    )GdGa: 2/01-11(.

    132

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • eb Jj GdL ed GdhQI:b GE GdL j GYQg bF e GdhQI H e a GE HM

    Gdq , H GE GC U GC GdhQI hMg J Gdq hGC gG Gd jY GdL c b Gda: "hd j HdL eq GE q a GdhQG"

    )GC : 3/82(. hb Gda: "GdL J C M GC jC N e Z" )fGdL: U77(.

    hGdW f Uq Hd: "GC c Ge a Md GdhQI j Y GC N eGd" )GC T hGdF: U26(; Pd GC GC c Gd a M Gd Jd a hGC N

    e Gd he GdH a M Gd Jd hM GBOe. b GdGa: "hb jL MGd Jd hg ed d GE SW hj e M Gd cj Jd dO GdH

    hGdQ hGd". )Gdh: 1/041-141(. a GdO eq e d Gd hMGdO a j Jj GdL a ed GdhQI HE W.

    hGC c GdA QGC hG GC Gd GdL jJ Y M. b Gda a TMd GdhV: " jR d GC f c d e J GC h ML GYg

    hQJq Y GC M M j YQg TgGk e L" )Gda: 3/702(.hb GH bGe a GdhV a S Mj Y Gdd GdS Gd d j d

    Gd HE H h HYQ e, hgG Y KK Vh: GC Mg ej a eJGdL )hV d GC e(. Gd Gdf e j a eb Gd )hPc d

    GC e( K b: "aG GdH f Nak a GC f jR Gd H e ZGC U aE f d LR Pd c hVk d HdGC hd GM GE d H GdS"

    )QhV GdX: 1/314he Hg(.he b HC K Gd a e GdL T GC J LQj Y GC U Gd

    hbGY e e eOF heU H Ja GC Uk e GC Ud h Odk eGC Od. )GdW "GY": 2/921(; C Gd Gd GE f GC J a

    133

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Hd eGk H g LQ Y GC Ud, hd Jk dN h GNQ GC bGHd HH e GC Ud. )GdGa dW: 4/541(.

    GC e e d b c h a eV GdhQG aE f e f Gdd Gd bY GdGd GC jk : "a e JL GE d M eO a e Gd hGdq

    hGE L hcf e Gdd Gdj Gd JF Ja GdQ a HWhehM he UQ GE d a T" GC MG J GdL Y Gd H GE

    eGJ GC M ehJ hGC Yg Gd heGJ Gd YjI hGC Yg GdG hGdGeGJ. hE j e fj fQO c GdGa GBJ a ahb: )Gd GdO

    hGdK H Gf e Gde GE d GE HM j a GC Y GdJ hH bYIe GE HM GE d Gde j d GC j GC S(. )Gdh dGa: 3/372(

    hV GC e e GdeGd J GE q HC T Gdh hGC Y GdJ, hGdLd e GC Y GdJ, he GC Gd Y j GLH H Gd hGdq ,

    hjO dj a GC Z GC M he Gdj j Y e Gd Zdkhg bGY eha.

    GE q GC Gd GC fG, a Gd dU cd hGd hd Gdj, he GdGd: cdC NP Zk GC h Y aS hgG Gd H J. )Gdhi:

    92/023(.hGd d eh ; a e Jj GdU ; he Gd Jj

    GdSF hGdQGF. aC h GC T e Gdf.hGdH GC T ee GdO, hM GdH C f e d, aE f GC N a H

    eH, hJj GdH GC T e Jj Gd )GH J(. hb GC jk : "GE Jj GdHGC T e Jj GdQ C f X e".

    hGdH eh: aH Gd jh QH GdA, aE Jj gG e Jj

    134

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdU, hJj GBN Jj GdSF hS GdQGF, hdG d j TA e QHGd. )GH Gd "GC Y Gdb": 2/701(.

    hdV e Pc GH Gd fc b GdGa: "GC M Y b: eU hgGd dd hGdS a GC f, hhSF: hg Gd Gd GE d

    hM M e GC a GE d e Jj hJ Z GC f GC N QJ e GdU")Gdh: 2/33(.

    e Pd fQ Jh eGJ Gd hGC GdL JN a f e eJ Y..HE Va GE d GC e bd GH Gd j GC jq H GBN Z Gdj H GdU

    hGdSF H GE GdL JD K M jL f Ha c b GH f:"Gd GC h Gd GE f j a eV f a hGC e e Gd Ha a jR

    Gd Hd, hdG b GC H M he QM Gd He QY MGd Gd hb GE q GC PN". )GC T hGdF: 1/711(. heO ce GC Gd

    jQV GE q HdhQI C f e H GdN hPd a GBN H GdL GdehGdhQI.

    GE GdL Gde JN a Gd GdU dN C GC Kg e hGE cfJN e a GSA e GC U c adN g e T dQ e bS Gdd

    Gdq d GdQ.hb f GdW Y Pd a H a GdN GE P b: "hGC e GdN a T

    dQ T, GSA e GC U c j Gd e GbQ Y eGV GdLa".

    haq GdI GC NI Hd: hcf eGk H Y eV GdL NU e NGUGdN GC jk H e hg GdU H e T e GdL Gdq he T e

    GdN aE TY GdN LF j a Y eV GdL. aE Gdq GE PG

    135

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gf S hL Y GdL GE d GC U e GE J GdI hGE dG Gd.hGdj GE PG bQ Y Gd a GdI d ju bYGk hGE PG bQ Y e GdA d

    j.hcd SF GdN H GdV hGdGV hGdbI,hf Pd e g j

    GdN aE f d HN a M GU C f eh GC jk hGE RG GdQ.aR dE f GC jV hGE d j H ML GE d GbGV hGC jb MF hGE

    c bOQGk Y Y H GC h HSQ Y hGC jQV Hd hGE c bOQGk YGdQI a H GC h HSQ hcd e T. hGdU GC Gdj QGL GE d

    GC U c GHGF. hGdN QGL GE d LF e Y Pd GC U Gd.)GdGa dW: 1/003-303(.

    hGE PG c c GE e Gde hJe je GE d J fU TY -ZGLOj- HdL aE Gdd JSG a HA Gdh GLOj Y GdL

    Gd.b GdG H GC Pc GC fGYk e YO GE LQI Gd jg ed: "hc S

    GH SG QM Gd a g LQ Y gG j H GHGA, h j YeJ aQi GC e eJ GC f JQ dQ. he Gd a T M a h

    S GE OY dd ML. he GC U ed GC f jGY GdL c jGYGdhQj aC LR GdO Y GdQg e cf j e YI e H GdH hGC LR

    JC N Gd a GdGA Gd. GE d GC b: hjo GdQ Gd H H GdH.hPc e GC LH C U H e: b hcd e j GE d GdL jC L GC L

    j d GdQ hd H, b j GE d GC e GE PG GVhG GE d a H d e hjh Gd GE q H aC QL GC q j H HC S GE PG Y e H Pd e jL a GE d

    GC Y GdS h jh Y Hq Gk e cGA Gd a M Gd. hSo S GHSG QM Gd: g JR GdQc a Gda GC j GdQ Y hGM hY

    136

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GBN Gde hJ GdQj H Y f Gd Gd Y? aC L: b GC LRe Pc H GdA, a Y Hd Y GdL GdcQ dhQI hJq Q GdL

    GBN aL GC jR GE TA Gd. hQGC j d a GC Ni b a: hj Pd Ye b ed a GE LRI GC e Gd GdL ".

    hS Y Gd)1(d je HA e Z, b g GE LQI ed hcda GC aG hGdM. hGE f jR Pd Y e j GdS Y GdbI

    hGdGV hM gG Y GH Sj hLY, hY j Gd Y GdS eGC LI Gd dL GdS GE d hY Gd d GC ef hcI Gdf c GYQ

    ed H gG a GE HM JC N GC LI a GdGA Gd a Wj Gd C GC cjA QH ja, a ed gG VhQI GE HM Gdj Hdj adS eh

    dG hGd Gd )Gdq G: 5/093(.hbj e gG Gd e Pg GE d H GC M a eF GE LQI M bdG:

    "hLR GE LQI GdI hGd e GdA, H f d Gdi eG" )GdQGdQ(. Yq GH YHj Hd: bd )e GdA( GC Jk b a c Gd e

    GdGQj d J GE LQI Gd db GE LQI Y GS Gd eO GE q GE PG GC LGC h H e GC QV am jR Jk .

    hGC V GH YHj )J( b a GdJ Nf ha Gd hGdQ j GC LGd he JGVG Y GC a c YI Off cG aG GdG. ha Gdh S

    e GH e Y GC LI GdQ a GC QL GC f HC S H hGE c a GC UaSGk dI Gde hc e gG Z LF aR dL dL GdS GE d

    cN Gd. hY b: QGC j GH Gd` jW` fLk j d c S.)GdT: 5/83(. ha GdQ GdQ: )hj Gd H "GE LQI" d GdGB

    hGd hGE ee hGC PG hj GdC L Y Oa e b(.

    )1( Gd: Nj Gd - b a Gd: g eGV Gd a Gd ha J )GdQ(.

    137

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Yq GH YHj Hd: "b a GdGj: hH ej QM Gd JdGSG GSQ Y J GdGB Gd dQ GdGf a GC eQ Gdj a

    Ge J M GdGB hY Gdi".hPc e e GC a H GdC Nh e ej hg Gd Y N a

    H ed e Pg GE d GE e hUM )MT GH YHj: 5/43-53(.hgG fi GdC Nj e GC J GE ee ed hGC H M jS a Gde e

    GdL GC Mfk e ed eU GE e HAk Y e a e bGY GE ee.hb GM Gd J Gdj H J H Y a eC d GE LQI GC QV hGd

    Hd: aE b GE GH Y LR GE LQI GC QV hGd Lk C L GdL hGC fS e ed d edk GY Gd a Gd hGH Y Y aE GdL

    OGY GE d GE LQI GC QV GdA Gd a T hGE aGOg Y HE LQI eQ GC he d a e GdQ aR ONd a GE LQI c LR Gda ON GC QV

    e Gd Jk a GdbI )Gdhi: 03/132(.ha eg Gda e M UM Gd Y f Gda QM Gd GC

    GC QRG Gd jL Gd dS jR H b b. hH Pc da g GdC d, b Gdh: "hOd e bd GC h hg GC U GC gG GdQ e

    Gdd dYI GM d hGda Hd d GdL" )Gd:9/862(.

    hb GC U GC H GE S GdW gG Gd GdL hGVk GE j a GE WQ GC UdbFk : "he j Y gG GC U bYI GS". hg a eg ed

    GC N H LF a eH Od c. he GdL GE d Jj GSGdS Y GdS, aE e GS d jL GE d eO Phb hJ, hGE f QL

    GE d e Y e b GdQ a Gd a GC e J GC TA GdhV cdF

    138

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd j GdS a GC eGk GE q GC q Pd GC e jD O GE d aG Gd e LGC Ni GC h L eI cd. hcGk e j gG a GC U GdhQ e

    GdL, hGdL e Gd, a GE LGA GdS ek a GdhQ jD OGE d M he a H eGQO a eV Gd hcd a GdL e

    Gd, GC h GdhQ e Gd hg Xg.hd a Gd GC e cI cdV ek aE f QH a GC U C f GdQg HdQg GE d

    GC L, hd GC H d a e Gda hGdS Y GdL, H d H YGC U Gd d a Pd V Y Gd. he H Gdj HU JGk aE f

    H GdW HdH, d GC H d a e Gda hQa Gd Hd GE d Gdp hGdo n i hd Ge ek d hS d GE YGA, c GC QH Gd d Ge a

    GdV e GC U Gda e gG GdL he Gd H Gd hGdA dhL Gda, hb GdI, hGd a Gd Gdj, hUI Gd, hSF

    GdN Gd Y gG Gd, aE M JL GE d GYQ GdB a JGdd GC h OQA GdS Y GdU, M c Gdd Gd j e Pd

    C f d H e GC U gG Gdd Gd C Oi GE d Qa e Gb Pd Gdd eGd, a e GdGL QY Pd GdB GE d GC b he GW Y

    GdQG a GdGh hGdV hGdbI hGE c Gdd Gd j Gd hGC TAe gG Gd cI.

    gG f e GC Od GdGd Y U Gd H GdYI hY H edhGC UH.

    hb b GH GdH a J GS HC f GE jQ J e Gdd Y WjGSA hGdN, dQV e jQV H a H eJ. K L GC bek :

    a J Gdd d cO GC j GE d Gd, hJc GE d Gd cGC L Gd, GC h Jc dE L cE j Gd Y e b Pf H GdV,

    139

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hJc a Gd dg da Gd hGE jQ GdS Y Gd cE LRI GdVGd a GdGW GdI hGE LRI H hU a Gd. hb a GC M GdGB:

    GS Yf hY Gd g Gd HC bi Gdd, ad GE PG GShGdS GE PG GC WO aE edk hGC H M jj J Gd HC Od c e

    Xg GC h e. hj ed GC j Hd, hj GC H M GC j H GdGM e GdH GdGQO H GdS, hjj ek J

    GdS hf Gd. h ji Gda d Gd GE PG K Jk . hgG Gdb g f a eB GC M e Z GbQ Y e Gdd Gd hGdS

    Gd. )GdGa dW: 4/502-902(.hf d J e c GdW a JN GdL a J Y ha

    Gdd j Yek Vk .he Gd GC J GdF GdGQO Y Gd e fGOQ GdQ hj

    a ONd a M Gd. b a eGb GdO:g fOQ a P Gd jN he GC h N j

    hj HdOQ e j Zdk H Gd dQI hbY hdG b H: JRGdH Y Gd hLRg H. hGC U a Pd S GE q a N..

    b Rcj: hL Ye GC f fI hGb a GE K hGC f a M Gd e GE PGdj GE q GE c a N. hGdI a S Gd J. )QGL f GdO:

    1/802he Hg(.hGC LR ed JhI GdF dGB M J hg e d e GdhI

    d.hGE PG b c J GdL hg d e Gd Gd e fU

    hXGg Gd hGdq hZg cE L hGd HY hGdS?

    140

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • b: GE f ji Gd dS GC h GS Gd j Y GdLhPd GC e eh a Gdg Gd hGdd c J Y GdW.

    hGE Gd j Gd Y GC g GdF Gd GC LRg e GC LRg dL aE fhGE cf Jk e Gd a Gd Y bGAI Gd dGB hGd Y bV

    j fk hGd Y H b Gd, aE f Y V a GdF GdUC Mj Gd LA a eV LH Z GdF hg Mj Y, a

    Gd Hd GdQI GdOQI Hd dGh Gdj.hcd aE GSA Gd hg e J Y RjOI e GdQ GdOQI

    Hd d aE f Ye j Y L Gd aE f j HC Ud GdjOI GC h GdjGC h f Pd hY gG fq GH bGe e W N Ye b GE f f a

    Jj GC HU.hb e Pd a eC d GC QRG he GC fGOQ GdQ e a ONd a

    Gd c GC S.

    Kf - GdL GdGd HdhQI Gd hg e H GdS a e GdhQI hGVGQ, GE P

    GdhQI d e, hg c j e GC T a H GC aGO e H, aJS GC W Y Gd GdS )GdL( he d jS Gb Y Gd GC Y:

    GdhQI. hd gG e H GdS hGE f g e H GC Od Gd.hg GdL Gd J GC KGk eGk h Mk OGFk H g cdhQI Jq Q

    HQg hb Pcf ek dd f HNQ g eC d H GdI b Hh UMhTh GSA e Gd, M b N )hU b( GC Hh UM e GC U

    GC h GC d H GC h Y b hGV GC GM c a GdV )d( e Gdj GC hGC Mg c j J J e HF d )GdQbf(.

    141

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hg ML a C f J Mk a a e GM hg T HGC f JR d Gd h JhR e. hgG e j GdL Gd Y

    GdL GC Ud Gd J Mk eGk h j J a GBMO GC aGOg.ad jR d hZ Gd c be, hcd b N a eC d J

    Gd: "hLR d Y S GC e GC N e GE d". he GC e c HGk YGdj jR d GTGA ej GE d e Gd b hUd Gd. b Gd Y

    GH QT: "hGC e GE e H Gd Y bj Y GC e e GdVI aR d GC j e j GE d dQI, d GdV Y GE d GdVI". )Gd:

    4/083(.g g GdL Gd hJ JSk a e GdhQI aq Q HQg hg ML

    T.gG g Gd H GdL GC Ud Gde Gd J H GC M Hd GC h

    GS hGS hH GdL Gd GdU Gd J JSk aGdhQI ; hg e LGk a J GdL hJJ GC M Y.

    hHd fQ hLO fY e GdL GC Mg ML Ye hGC Ni ML NUT.

    hM GE GdL Gd e HdhQI a jo a H Gdh g Ja GdhQI Gdi GC h GdL?

    a eC d GE j H GC bG Y e g Y hb GdA j a GdhQIGd JL Pd. a GdW GE f j Gd GE N H GE J Gd )GC

    GdhQI( aE e GdL hd j Gd GdcQ H Ohf hL Y GH QT)GdQbf: 5/4(.

    142

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • aH QT GC d GdL g HdhQI GE q GC GdhQI Gd J GdL b je H j Pd c a QhGj GH GdS a a Gdj a ea jC N b

    e Gdj. b a GE q Y GdhQI Gd J GC c Gd e GC j a UGAH j cGA hj Y f Gd GE d jC N e OGH j Y,

    hGC T j GC jC N e OGH d H d hGE d J d VhQI )Gd:4/863(.

    Gd PG Gdb:Gd:

    eQ e e U j H Y Gd hVq a GdV hGdQ, hgV GdI hGd V GdO hGC U L e GC h Oa eI. b

    Gdcf: "b GdGQRe: hGdGO Hd Gda Y eO Gd HaGdS Y Gd" )GE QTO Gd: U 242(.

    hH Gd hGdL Y hL, a Jo Gd Y GdL hZg,hcd GdL b J a e Gdd hGS Gd H

    GdLGde a b Gd H Y Gd )C Gd Gde cdhQI GdU()bGY GC M: U 623(.

    hb GH bGe a Gd H GC Pc Gd a M b: "hb fq GC MY GC e T GC j H S d j he GTG GdA a H GBN.

    hQhi Y LGRg cf e d Lk " hH GC Pc GC bG GdjhGdf b: "hGd LGR C f e d e Z VQ dGM e.

    hGd jO Hj Gdd Gd eq I a H HhY hC gG dHU Y Jj h a e GdU aL GE HhD Y GE HM"

    )Gd: 6/634-734(.

    143

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Y Gdi:hg Gdd GC h GdOK Gd J cGk e GdS hjq Q GMGR e )GH YHj:

    GdT 1/013( GC h e J GdL GE d a Y GC MG )c GC SGQ: 3/61(cS Gd hGd J Hdd hGE c QWk Y b GC H jS hg GC U

    Gd H d Gdi )GH YHj: 1/903-013(.hY Gdi cdL ja fk . b GH f: GYQ Y GC H M Hdi

    a eV Gd c a H GBOe aE Gdi a GC Y )GC T hGdF U 48(.Gd:

    Gd J ed GdhQI ha GE aOI GE HM. GC Ji GC GC SG Gd JY Gdq . )GdGF: 6/03(

    Y GMGR:heg UH Gd Y GC e hg a GdOG hZg. b GdSf: c a

    eh a Gd QH SGA c Gd e M GdG GC h e M GC hU GE q e j GdR Y Oak d )HGF GdF: 5/781(.

    hYq Y GdGa HdQ M b: "GdQ j GYQ hGd ja Gd" )Gdh: 3/891(.

    hGC e N a b: " GE Y GMGR e" )GdQbf: 1/71(.hY Y j c e )GC Y j Gf Y H hLO S hg

    Gd( )GdQbf hHT Gdf 1/14(.c e j GMGR e e Y )GH J Gdhi1/295( hY GMGR g

    YQI Y Gd GdM a GdOI GC h Gde.

    144

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd:Gd J H GdL g GdGb a eJ eS. hE j Pd f c

    GdGa a Gdh Y GC b Gd M j ehLk HH Gd HNQe H Y H M Gdd a Jj Gdh e j: )Gd GdGH Y

    H bYJ Gd Gd dOI hGd Gd J(:GY GC Gd GE dG Gd Y GdW j e GSS e OhGY f

    g GC e f eLO a L GC Me M GE HM. K j Z GE HM HHf H GC Y e H. ad H GE hb e je e Gd YOI GC h a

    Gdd GC h a GdOQ cdVA hGd a GdO hGd a GdQ Gdj hGdWIHd a GdO hf Pd, d jD K e je a GdOI HE S h H

    C a Pd f Gd GE d j Gd H je e Gd c GdY KK GC b:

    GC h: e Y GYQ a GE S GC h Gd cd Y GdS GC h GC YAhGda C M g GC eQ g S ed Gdf hGBNI a M g

    GdOI e Gd Y e Pc dGH C Oi dg GC ed.Gdf: e Y Y GYQ a Pd cC Of hL a GC U C J g

    GdOI GC hd e OQA g Gd d GdOI hN Gd.Gdd: e a a j a Gd e GT e hGE H GdGQ

    e N e hg Gdg e eg ed. a Gd e Gd aGdI Y K GdV c e j GdR e c GdGZ hj GdVA a

    Hd dI Y GdA hGdL GE d hGd Y GSd. hH j aGd TjI Gd hN.

    g GC b GdK JO a L GC HG Gd a hL Gd GdK a

    145

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdVA, cd fg a GdI hGd hGC e Hdh hGd Y GdhJb GdF hGd Y MQ GdI hGdC P Hdj GdQOI a Gd GdA

    hGd a GdM hZ Gd hLY Gdf e GSA Gd hZ Pd.hcd GdQ a Gd KK GC b hgG a c GC HG Gd )1/131-231(.

    hH GC d YOI eJ. b: hcd e Gde d e eJ.

    e JN a GdL:GdL hGdQ:

    e GC g Gd Gd JN GdL YO GdQ hJe H GdU GdJ Y GZQ j GdQ dL.

    hfj GC fc GB e g GdQ? hGC U Gd Y hei JC K GdL a GE dAM.

    hGdQ Yq a GdGa HC f: GdA Gd jQ g j GC h . hYq GddHC f: e Yo hLO hLo U.

    hYq GdLf GdQ HC f: e j e Gdb jQ GC j GC h )Gdj(.

    hb: e c d Xg j Gd hHW e. b GC Rg: hjN a HGdQ Gd Gdd Gd j H Gdj )Gd: 3/344(.

    hH GdQ e TYk H Gd dd Jd: }h JC cG GC eGd HHdW| )GdI 2/88(.

    heq HU Gdq . a U e e Mj GC H gjI GC Gd fY H GdI hY H GdQ )T e dh: 11/651(. hGC NL ed a

    146

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdWC eSk Y GC H MR H OjQ Y S H Gd GC Gd f YH GdQ )Gd dL 5/14(.

    Yq GdL Hd "f Y H GdQ j aO he H GdQ hGd GC Ye c a GdQ hZ Y M UQ Gd jU H GdQ aG Gd N

    a Gd e".hGC e j GdQ aE f jD K a aO Y H aE f jO j e Y. hGE f

    j GdA a aO GC Y GdO Na a a e GdQ g g e MGd Gd j Gd GC h e M Gd Gd j, adQ j Hd e

    KK GC hL: e L Gd, hGdV, hGC L )Gd 5/14(. b: hL e PcGdL hZ GC eO hLO GdQ d ek d M j Zdk fTk Y c

    GE Va Gd GE d GdQ g e GE Va GdU GE d Gd. hhU GH ed aGd gG Gd e GE Va HC f e T Gd he d H Gde C

    Gd g Gde hPd U he gG GC Gd hGQO Y H ZQ hd YH a ZQ hGd jQc Gd HGQO GC d.

    hb GdGa: "bYI: GdQ KK GC b: e Y e a Gd cd a GdGAhe Y LGR cC SS GdGQ he a g j Hd GC h d GC h

    Hd Gdf d GC h dhQI GE d c GdF Y Gd hGdfe hfg?a gJ GdYJ j Gd a GdGAI. a` )( ji GE c Gd e

    GC hU M d aR d Gd a hGE SW Hd, hZ jG M GdJd hGC f M Y YO a GdhV Y Gd. h)( ji GC ZQ Gd

    a T GdGAI e GdQ Gd dhQI GdF da Gde Y f hZ jGe GdQ Gd C f b jC J Y GC c U Gd, aC e g GdGQ a

    e GLO hGf GC j GC b dO Gd hbGY aY Y hGd gGdO GE d S GdTO )GdNI dGa: 5/39(.

    147

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hj Gdh: )a( GC U GC H GdQ HW dG Gdj hGdGO e c aZQ Xg j GMGR e )aC e( e JY GE d GdL h j GMGR Y

    cC SS GdGQ hTGA Gde e GM GC Gd hGM GC h GC c hPc GC h GC f hceGC YA GC h fb hcGA GdI a VY d hf Pd aG j H

    HE L.hf GdA GE L GC jk a GC TA ZQg M )e( GC GC eq GC L Y

    U H Gd GdI hGE d j Mg hd H Mg eOGk d j,hGC LG Y LGR GE LQI GdGQ hZg TGk e GC f b j KK jek hb j

    J hYj, hGC LG Y LGR ON Gd HC LI hY LGR Gd e eAGdA HV e GN GC MG GdS a GS GdA GC h e a Gd.

    b GdA eGQ Gd H GdQ hGd e hLO Y e Pcf hg GC f GE PGOY GdL GE d GQJ GdQ h j GMGR Y GE q H GC h c GdQ

    MGk LR Gd hGE q a. hb j GdA a H GdF c Gd GdFhH Gd a S hj GNa ek Y g GdYI, a ji GdQ

    jGk jD K, hH jG eD KGk hGd Sf hJd GC Y )Gd dh:9/852(.

    GC e Gd J Gdj H J aE f bq GdL Hdq I Ye b a Mj YGdGF: "hGdL GdjI ja H GdQ Gd hGdj e Y GC GdI

    Gd dj GE PG YQV e QGL GC H Gdq a GE PG cfGdI e" )Gdhi(.

    GdQ Gd:hGY Gdd GC GdQ GE PG c eak C U LF j dL H e d c

    GdQ GC Uk a Gd a Gd. b GdG: he Gdhf e H GC e hd QVM hT Y QVY hf S ad LF GE PG c GE e Gd GC QVG d

    148

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GBN.. )GH jf( hGd H gG hH Gd jR GC j GE e Gd GC jD J H, GC eC d GC e GdQ a J C f Gf GE d GC U LF. c ed

    a H d TI LGak TGk GC f jR hGC LR cGA fb TGk hGT MH, GC ULGR GTG Gd KGk d jD H - Gf H gG Y bd - hN Gd. hb

    GC T GE GC f Y bd j GdLO M Gdh cdQ hGdd a GdO GE PGb hY GMGR Y f GC SS GdGQ hb Gd hQOGAI HW GdGc hO

    GdGZ hfS K GdV. hGf Hd dH jR e b h c d a H Gd -e GH jf- )GdG MT Y eGg Gd:

    4/563(.hgG Gd hGV a GC ej GC Mg GC GdQ b jR Jk dL hjR e

    Gd hGC GdH jR e b h c.hg fU J MhO JC K GdL a Gd hPd H eJ Gd a

    c a eJ hS cdQ JD K a Hh he c a eJ Y jC K H.he gG Gd JC K GdL eI Y GT Gd Y e Gda hGdh

    a j Gd a GC U MGek hd j dL HAk Y e Y e GdGdQ dh hGda.

    he Pd GC f GC LRhG GE LQI J a W Gda GdC L Y h GdGGdC LI hPd a U Ya Y Gdd H` "GC Y He C Y He".

    hJQ g GdC d e e N ehLk HQM GdQbf: "hLR GC YHe Y MK hf C Y He. GC QGO GC h f Y MK GC h Z. hdG

    M e M c Pd, GE LQI YQj, C f H YV hgG HV,J Gd GC , Jhi Re GC h GN, JK Gd H dBN GC , c

    hHA hZ hKQ a j GJO Gd h Y Gd(. hg GE LQI,

    149

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • he GC GE LQI cd. GC Qcf, hGdc Gdf - GC L- g cd j cfehak bQGk hU " gG c GH Ya )GdG5:/983(.

    hg Gd Gd GY J Y L bQ GC LI hU ; C f b JKQGk a eH Z, hb J MKk a eH GdA C GE Yf eh M

    YQI GdQbf )f GdL(.b GH TS d b GC Y He jek hGC Y He jek a HQj H JL

    GE d M GE LQI d GC LR GH GdS hQGB e Gda )GdG 5/962(.hS Gdj HC S GC j GdL Gde d GC Y N GC j hGC Y N

    GC j a MO RQY hOQS hY )GH QT( C f e Gda a Pd VhQIJ Pd hGE f jR Pd a b hb e GC j hGE GN GC Y )GdG:

    4/814(.b: bd a Pd VhQI GE d GBN eg g GdL c be. hcd fq G

    Y GC )bd Gd J GE PG L Mk hMGek eU HdhVGdd Hd hGdGA( )a GdQbf: 7/97(. bd a eV Gd Y H

    YO Gdb Gd J Mk hMGek , hee GC GdY J Hd HGd hGdG H j a GdA Gd J H Gde hj Z hPd

    C YO Gdh hGda je a fGk d GdQ Gd a GE jY e je a Zg hj a e Gd Gd JY GE d GdL e j a YO

    Gdj Gd.he gG Gd e Pc GH jf a Le hg j H YO Gd: "Gf

    g Gd GC f GE PG bhG GE bd LR C f eh, hGE PG bhG Gdj d j C fej. a Y gG GE PG GH M HGR aC Y fbk hQO Y e Gd,

    GE bhG Gdj d j hd bhG GE bd a Gd hb hL OjQ j

    150

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • SSk GC b HG Gd e SS Gd hN GdjQ Gdb dR" )cGd e GH jf(.

    a g Gd HR GE Y GdL d N e d hd eYk aJ N j H GE Qa heh.

    GdL JL Gd a H GdA:hb fs Gdd Y LGR Gd Hd HK Th: GC JA GE d GdhQI,

    hGC j V TjGk LGk , hGC J f GE d bF jo i H Yk hhQYk .Pc Gdf a MT Y GdQbf Y Gdh )5/421(.

    hf S Y Gd a eGb GdO M b:hPc e V d d GE P PG Y hab b Gf

    H db a eGQ Gd` hd GdQ e d GY`hdGYI Gd Gd` GC h GdGY`I d e S```````

    hcf j GE d Gd```````Q GE c d j a Gd`````QK Gd`h hb J```````` VGk e Gd` H J```````````

    GC U ehY GdL Qa Gd hGd a J e GdhQI a eC d QaGd hg e Y Gd hGd hGdS.

    b GdW )GdC d GdOS(: aE GdQ d j GE d Gd HdhGE Y a hGdd Y Pd GC eQ:

    GC Mg: GdU GdGd Y Pd cd Jd: }hj Y GE Ug hGC ZGd cf Y| )GC YG: 751(. hbd: }QHq h J Y GE UGk c

    M Y Gdj e b| )GdI: 682(. ha Gdj: "b Gd Jd ba" )Mj Qb 081GC NL e Y GH YS, H GE j(. hb LA:

    151

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • } jq Gd fk GE q hS| )GdI 682(. h}jj Gd H Gd h jjH Gd|)GdI 581(. h}he L Y a Gdj e M| )Gd

    87(. h}jj Gd GC j Y hNo GE f V| )GdA 82(. h}ejj Gd d Y e M hd jj do c| )GdFI 6(. ha

    Gdj: "Ho p o Hd Gd" )Gdj GC NL GE e GC M Y GC H GC eeQV Gd Y, Mj Qb 06212Hb e GC fQ(, hMj: "e No u n QS

    Gd H GC ej GE q GNQ GC jg e d j GE Kk " )Gdj GC NL GE e GC MY YF QV Gd Y, Mj Qb 20732Hb e GC fQ(. hGE f b:

    "e d j GE Kk " C J GE K eq a e M c eO J GE d GC T Pde a gG Gd. hd c bUGk d d c ejGk d h Gd

    hd ejGk d hGd hPd HW.hGdf: e K GC jk e ehY GdN hg GC e e H he Y e Oj

    GC e VhQI cN Gd hGd hGd hJh Gde a GVGQ, aE gG f j bk Y e Qa Gd hGdq , hcd eLA e Gd Y

    Gd hGd hGd a Gf Y OhG GC Y. hd c GdQ bUGkd a Gd d c K JN h J )GdGa 2/121-221(.

    adU Gdd Gdc Ye a Gdq HY Gdj hGdS, hGE PG aV GC Qa Gd eO a U Y aE f f e fGR eOI NU e

    Gd e a GC U Qa Gd c GE PG hLf Gd T Y e WGdA hGdI bYGk Y e W Gd, hGd hGd a Gd, hGd H

    GdJ a Gd hGdV hGd, hGd H Gd Y e Gd.hGC W Gd )GE d LF cI LGk j e eY b da Gd aE f

    f H Qa Gd a GC HG c Yk HSGA(. )GdGa:2/992(

    152

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GE L Gdh H GdhQI hGdL:H gG GdV j GC Gd H GdhQI hGdL jL GE d:

    1- Gdj a GC GdhQI a eg Gd GC N TI hV a GdJGdi J Gdq , ha eg GC Ud c j GC M Gd H bG

    GC Oj hGC HG.hGdL e a eJ hS a eg Gd J HdhQI Gd a GE HM

    e V Od hJf eJ a S Gd ha e GC Ud c GC hQY GYQ e hMLk de hGC Oi GYQ GE d Sd hj a GC Uk dO

    eU MO Y bS GC h NL Y bYI c GC h GC Oi GE d GLO eGSMk GC h GSfk .

    2- GC U GdhY a GC GdU Gd HdhQI fU hGV eOIJ Ha M hTI e f NU.

    hGdU Gd JL ehY GdL GE d J Ha Gd H Ye GC Y eJ Gd b hGC b JjGk .

    hgG Gdb H GdhQI hH GdL KH a GdhQI Hd GC Ud)GdhQ( he e, GC GC Gd Gd e GC L Y N GdS

    e HA Y Od GS GC h Gd GdS ha GdhQI HdGd he eb e H GdN Hd GC N hg J M dQ e

    Y Gd GC U.ha GdL H GdL hg Gd GC Ud he e GC GC Gd

    KH H e SGA c eUk ek H cd hGE LQI... GE d GBN, GC heHk GE d GSfk cS dL hGde GC h GSMk cGR JhI

    GdF Y ed.

    153

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hGdL H GdL j a GC J Ye hGC e GdL Gd hgcdhQI Gd C f e H hJS dg hg Ja Gd eD bk H

    GdhQI Hg Gd aE f J e bS Gd Gdf Ujk a JL aaa eD bk hJQc GdL Gd a Gdb d J e a eJ

    Od Gd Gd Ja, aC hd Ja Mk Od b cd Hd GdghGbA hGE TQI hGd hGdS.

    GC e Gdf aE f Ja Mk Od X c Gd hHU Gd Gd a fGOQGdQ c GC S hgG GN a W Gdd Gd JGL c e fTA

    Y GN Gd adq a e GdhQI g eq ci H Gdq ae GdL g eq hS.

    GC e GdhQI H GdhQ Y GC Ud aE f J JC Uk C M eUe GdQ GC h e a Y Wj Gd GdS.

    j Gd H GdhQ hGdL a GC e c e b GdhQj a GC QaeJ e c e b GdL JC Uk hJk , a c e GdhQj e

    M f hOj hf he hY j a GdJ Gd e Gdd GdY hdGaE f e a Z Gdg GdU Y e j Hdd GdS hg ed

    QM Gd Jd hd j e j H cdGd a Gd Hh hGHbGe a GdhV.

    GC e GdL af eJ aE GS a e f c e GdAcdGd a Gd hGH bGe a GdhV.

    hc g Gdh JY GE d GdC e a g GdYI hGE YOI Gd a eb, hGdfG GC f bYI GC Ud hd a hGC GdO hGdh Gd J Y eQI

    Hd acg GE PGk e H Gd hGdC U hd eOI hdG Yq H H

    154

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • Gd hGC GC hd GC Jc e GdhQI GC Ud C f J Mk OGFk hg eGd Gd jb Y J a c aO e GC aGO H j H Hd

    a Gd.hGC Y GC gG Gd g Gd Gf GE e Gde M J Y GdhQI

    GC Ud a Gd Gdd hL e Gd K J Y GE d GdL H aGdJ Gd J hhV H GE LQI hJ Je.

    hgG a QGC g Gd Gd hGE hV bYI a GC M GQJck Y c eGdM M GC HMG HdL Oh GS hOh Gd a Th GS

    hGS, hd jG GE d GC GdL JD K a K Gd Y HC Od bjH J a eJ bj e eGJ Gd a JD K a Jj Gd hGd hGd.

    H GE f JD K a Y V c GC aGO hJhd Gd hGE f JD K a eJGd JU HC f a GC Y OQL Gd a Gd GC eq e

    GdU d cq e GdSF hGdQGF hg ah Ob JR HG Ob.aC hd J GE q GdhQI GdU H JC K GC NI HdL ed ed

    GdhQI hJD K GdL a H Gde hH Gd GC b bI HjM Gd GC GdQ d jO a a Me GdH ce GdQ hGd

    hGdQ adH GC T e g c j GH J.K GE GdL j GC J Gd H GC f j J V GdL GC

    f GC GdQ c GC U LFGk GC h GC H e d Y GC U LFGk , H GE GdLJe e LF a e g Gde C Gd f a j Y GC b

    aE dhD j GE dA d.hGE PG cf GdOG d Y hRG hGM c j GdW ad Gde

    d Y hRG hGM.

    155

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hHNQ aE Gd H GdhQI hH GdL j a K eGJ: eJGdq heJ Gd heJ Gdd. aE GdhQI a GdJ Gdi e Gdq GC h

    e GC g hGdL a eJ eS. hGd Gd J GdhQI Ha g fb j a GC Y OQL Gd C eJ bj GC h C f j GdI a f

    GdU H JGL GdL fk GC Of eJ e Pd C f b j f GdSF.GC e eJ Gdd aE Gdd Gd Ja M GdhQI b j fk Ujk e

    c GC h Sq GC h SGg. GC e Gdd Gd J GE d GdL a a Gdd YV j, GC h bS jO a e GdL, GC h bYI j e.

    e N Gde e g GdGJ Gd j a GdA ha GC PcA aGd H GdhQI H Gd hGC Ud hGdL H GC Ud

    hGd.hY VA gG j GE Y GdL a GdO GdOI j GC j Gd

    c ek Y GdO H j GdO Mk H GC hL Gd c bdG a HGdaA. adO j H GC hL Oh H. hPd GE f j a Y eO h

    j a YI YO GC h ee H aS hH U, a j JGdS HA Y U Gd. hgG e GC S e N Y H GdA

    aG Md GdO GdM HA e Gd hGd j L GE PG c ZQGk jGkek eak GE d GC U LF, WG Pd Gd Y YO eOI H e Y

    H hH e hH LF HYi Gd GdI. hgG c g hGVZ U, h j bd e N eGE GdL H e GC MG.

    156

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • J eUI:a j H Gd GdUI dGE GdL:

    1- ai Gd GC hQhH HC TGA H Gd a OjQ Z Gd:fGC g Gd Hi GC KQ Lk a GdM Gd hg ai Gd

    GC hQhH dE aA hGd Gd HGQ GE HM TGA H Gd a OjQ ZGd JLk dg GC H M he b Hd Gfbk e eGE GdL.

    f Gd a Gd Gd Y H Gdi a GC hQhH ha HO Gd c,hg b GdR Gd Ji HV QH HGS Gd Gdj.

    hb be GE d Gd YI GC hQG a GdV e H eD j heQV bo F YGd, K fb L GC YA eb e, Gf Hg HC Z GC YF

    GE d e j:1. jD c Gd Y e GC L Y GC e e Me GdH hGC f e Gd

    GdH, he GdF Gd JD P H e Gd hQSd, hjD c e bQJ GdeGd GE Se e GC aGF Gd g GdH GdG.

    2. jT Gd GC HA Gd a Gd GC jhG a GE jO GdGF GdYGd T a, e GSYG GE d Pd Sk e )H GdGH( Gd Je

    Gd GE Se, he JC S Tc GE Se JA e g Gd HheI ehQI dQ Gd, hZ Pd.

    3. c jY Gd GE S`e a GC hQhH GC JhV Gd GC hQhH Gdjdj g Gde GE d U ed TYk , e )H Gd( Gd jGO a Gd

    eH GdjOI a GC L, aE gG S d YOGk cGk e Gd jee Y GC SS g Gdj, hg e j H Gd a H GC bQ GC hQhH,

    157

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hb QGC j YOGk e Gd GdH Gdi J ahY d a HOf GdH Jeha Gdj GE Se, c a Gdj hZg. hj d GC jY a

    Pd HE QS fGA GE d g Gd dj Sc e Gd.4. hGE PG d j gG h PG eGk a Gdb GdV, aE Gd a VA GC Od

    hGdGY hGYQG GdY, ji HC Sk e GdA GE d g GdS hg GdVGdH dGA H j GE d Gd d g hGC SJ, H GC j dj H

    GBN j, hGC j g e GC SS, hGC j Y e aF Gd ej e TGF H g GdS, hb GY d a aG Y eJj

    GC SS:

    GdJ GC h:bYI )GdhQG J GdQG( hg bYI e Y eC NPI e fU

    GdGB a N eGV, e bd Jd a SQI GC f: }hb aq d eMq Y GE q e GVQJ GE d| )GBj 911(. he bd Jd a f GdQI

    H Pc eq e GC W: }a GVo s Z Hm h YOm aE QHs ZQ QM|)GBj 541(. he bQ GdA g GC GdL b J ed GdhQI, NU cf

    GC h Ye.hGdL g Gd GE PG d J j Gd a M hGE c j GC j

    H GdhQI Gd j GC j Hhf, hGd Jd Qa Gd Y gGC e HU GdGB c a bd Jd a SQI Gd: }he L Y a

    Gdj e M|)GBj 87(, ha SQI GdFI: }e jj Gd d Y eM|)GBj 6(. hGd Gd ja Y Gd Gd g Gd GdS

    d a eb ha S ha eGa H j Sk Mk .hGE PG c Gd b GY Y bYI GdhQI GC h GdL Gd J ed

    158

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdhQI, aE f d j GdYI GC Ni GdH hGd d, hg GC e GC HdhQI jq Q HQg, a j Jq Gd dQI hfg.

    hGd h T VhQI dO Gd hdC SI Gd, hb Ge Gd HdY YO M b: }hGd L d e HJ Sk | )Gd 08(, hL

    Gd Gd GdGS YGk e YU GdOI GC QH GC h GdK hGdGdC L j c ML Gd, h j HC e, hGE c j Gd

    cGk H ja d Gd hj SG ja GC LJ h j e MGk hGMGk ,he gG j Gd YV dO e gG Gd GE PG c Yd GC h c Va, c

    GC f GE PG c S GC h bq ON GC h Gf YV C jo e H a Gdj.hJ Gd j Gd gG Gd, c GC f j GC jQ Gd bjk e

    Gd hGdc GE Se hGdQS GE Se, hjA aU dYGd GC JQ a ec Y GC JA d ek GE Sek UGk OGN

    Gd Gd, aQ a GC HhD g, hJi QhGH, hjhf Y Gd aX eg GE S hb Gd.

    c GC gG j Gd e GE YGO H hJJ H j ML Gdj hGLYeOG eck d.

    hg GE d Lf g GdL GdOj d e GdL Gde dY GdGdj j GC b NQ OGQ GE S, hg J a J GC MGd Gd,

    M jJ eGg, hjfG GC gk dfA GE d N GC e GC o NL dS, hjhGUQI eb dE S GC e Z Gd, c J a GC jQhG e Gd

    GbOj Y, deG HGL GdYI hjgG a HA Gd Gd, hgGj GC q j Gd j W Y e GC L Oa b GE jQ H hf Y,

    h j aU de e GC h f OYJ.

    159

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GdJ Gdf: )hg e dJ GC h GC SS(g e Pg GE d GC H M hUM e H Gd Gdf - hg Gd H a

    Gdg Gd - hcd S GdQ hGE HGg Gd, hg QhGj Y GC MH M, hQL GH J - a Pc H GdH - e LGR Gde HdH

    - hZ e GdO GdSI - H Gd hZg a Z OGQ GE S.hjL GC N HG Gdg g YI GYQG, e:

    1. GC Gd Z e TYk GC j GC M Gd Gdf hGdd hGdShfg e j Hd Gd a e jD e HE S, C gG d a

    hS, h j Gd fk GE q hS, hJj GdH g e g GC M Gd JHj Gd ha Gdhd hGJg GLY hGbO. hGE f jd

    Gd HE be GC M Gd J aOGk e GC M GdOG hGC M GdehGdhH hGdS he j HdhG hGd hGdL hGdI hGdG

    hZg e GC MG Gd, H d V Y a g GC eQ hd jH GE be Oj a dL Y GC jL GE d GC QV Gd GdGS e hL GE d Pd

    Sk .2. GC Gd GE PG d je H GdO GdSI - he Y GdH - a OGQ Gd,

    SD O Pd Hd GE d GC j GdGe HE S Sk d GbOjk hNQJedk , hGdhV GC GE S jq Gd h j, hjj h j, hj

    h jq , hb GM H YA Gd Y LGR JQj Gd e Z GdHj: "GE S jj h j" GC jj Gd h j, he: "GE S j

    j", hg GE PG d je H GdO Gd jGVf H S GE d GC je j e h jC N eH, a j g GdGf hGdO a j Y e

    eQ h jg a j d e ef, a Gd OGFk hd d Gd, hHGj Gd GC HGk eek edk H GdGe HE S, hGE S j GC HGk GE d GC

    160

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • j Gd HdGe H, hGC jc - a Z OGQ GE S - d Gd jhj e, a M j Y Gd GC j e ee Z Gd a GdH

    a VA GdO GdFI hGd H Yg.he jo e GC eg Gd GE f j Gde HdH a Md GC N GE YA

    C f aFI d a GE YA hg jh Gde HdO GdSI GE qHW GC h: GC j a e d, hGdf: GC j a ZQ h Nf

    d Gd, hg d J Gd d.adG: GC gG Z es , c j Y b e H Gd Gdf a

    Gd Gd, hGE W Gde e YA Gdg, c GC Gd hGE c jGdFI g a Gd GE P H j Gd a Gdj.

    hb GC cq Gd Gdj j a g GdjQ Hd GdT e hHdGS:GC GC b Gd jaf d HQ GC LI Gd jaf dd, H GC Mfk J

    GC b, he gG GC f GE PG Mq e Gde g HdFI e Gd Me Gd e Gee d hC SJ, hg e GdL GC U dE f c jq GdA, hQH

    j Yj S GC h GC c ja GE jQGk Tjk GC h Sjk h j Tk Y M cj a N Yj S - hQH GC b - GC j Gd.

    a d j gG Gde LFGk Y eg GC H M he hGa d LFGk YGd dL Gd J GC Mfk ed GdhQI a GE HM GdQ H.

    h S GC Gd g GE f jD c GdH h jC c, GC g j GdFI h jC NghGC U a Gdj e Y )GC c GdH( c f H GBj GdGB, hGE f M

    GE j SGk dQj c Me GdH d hGdOI Y a e H JjGdSF Jj GdU.

    he Gd GC GC c GdH Gdq jR H, GC e GE jd - H GE YA GdFI- aR dL, hb fq Y Pd GdA hGC LRhG GSGV HdH dL GE PG

    161

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • S a hL GC HG Gd. he GdGY` Gd`I g: GC e M` dGJ jGE q dhQI, he M d GdQj j dL, hGd Gda.

    hJ Y gG GdGQ: f Y HNQ GE f j Gde HE W HdH a OjQZ Gd c g e eg GC H M he b Hd d j a Md

    GdL Gd Gd JhR e a JL e HdL Wk dhGdL HdL Gd fg Y ed. hGE c GJ e UZ H GdG

    hHU a j Hd GC GdL hMg J a GE HM gG Gde.hGd GC GdL J a GE HM GdH hGE f J Gdi Y b GdA

    GdF HG eLk HC U Y T Gd HYQ hg GdL hGd.

    2- bGQ e Gd GE Se: 36)1/7( HC TGA GC S a Tc JeGC Mfk HdH:

    a j H GdO Gd hQO HGQ e Gd GE Se a j HGGdV:

    GE e e Gd GE Se Gd a OhQI eD J GdH HI a GdGdH GdOj e 7-21P GdI 2141g` GdGa 941ej 2991.

    H GE WY Y Gd GdGQOI GE d Gd HU eV "GC SG Gdd"GC S, GNQG, Gd, Hb GF, hH GSY GE d Gdb Gd

    OGQ Md, bQ e j:

    GC hk ` GC S:1- GE S a Gdc:

    GC ( H GC GC U a Gde Gd aE JC S Tc eg PG GC ZGVhGC f ehY GC e LF.

    162

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • ( N a Me GE S a Tc ZV GC SS eq , cdeHdH GC h GE f Gdq e GC h GdLI H.

    ( GC U Me GE S a Tc Je GC Mfk Hdq e cdH hfHdZ e GC GC f GC SS ehY.

    2- Jj eD hd Gdc Gdg GdhOI: ef TYk e GE fA Tc eg PG eD hd ehOI HGC S ed, C Pd

    e de e Gdc hH Gd j GdQ Y je e Gdc.

    Kfk ` Gde Hd hGd hGdD TG a GC SG Gd:1- Gd`: j Gde Hd a GC SG Gd HE Mi GC QH W g:

    Gdj GC hd: GC j Gd M J Gd hJ Gd a Gd e hLOGd GC h GE j e d a e GdF hb. hgG Gd LF TYk Hh

    Gd Gdha.Gdj Gdf: GC j Gd M J Gd hJ Gd a Gd e

    GE ef H g Gd. hgG Gd LF TYk Hh Gd Gdha.Gdj Gdd: GC j Gd Y J S eUa a Gde a eY GC L

    hOa Gd Y Gd hGC j TWk j GC j ak Hd hGd,hgG Gd Z LF dC L Gdd, hj GC jq da Th Gd

    Gdha, aE PG GSa Th Gd LR. hcd jR H Gd GdGI Skb b.

    Gdj GdGH: GC j Gd Y J S eUa a Gdeq a eY GC LhOa Gd Y Gd Oh GC j Gd TWk j GC j Hd

    hGd Gd, H j J H ec. hgG g Gd GC c TYk a

    163

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • GC SG Gd, hgG Gd Z LF GC Uk .hJ Y gG GdGQ Gd HC SG Gdd fi GC Gd JQI d j

    GdL d YQV e Gdd Gd j GYQg e hJQI GYg. a SGd:

    1- GdI )(: GC U Me GE S a Tc Je GC Mfk Hdq e cdHhf HdZ e GC GC f GC SS ehY.

    hHG ji Gd GC GdH J GdL h YI H Hd C Y GdchGC f HYQ Pd hUk WOjk hGd a Pd c ek c GE UH C

    GdH c GC S a eJ e Gd J GE q GdhQI.hc HO GC Jo c )GC U( Gd GC U Gd jQq H E HM GTG

    a g Gdc HYi Gd, hb Hq NC Pd a H GBN.2- bQ Gd GC ef TYk e GE fA Tc eg PG eD hd eOI

    HGC S ed.hGd JhR Y e Gdj Gd Y Gdc aE GC UH hGE cfG

    j GC f eJ HGC S e Gdc aE f e Pd GE f JbhG e GC QH GdchgG GdGQ a Y GYG Hd Gdj hGC U a Gdj GYQ Gdeq

    Gd hGd bQ Pd dL.3- a GdI GC NI e Gdj Gdd bQ Gd GC f ) jR H Gd

    GdGI Sk b b( hd j GdL e GC eg ed hGC hRGY LGRPd e d J Gd Wek .

    g GdGQG J Y Je MQ e eGC GdL, hd H gG j aGE j ej Gde e GdL.

    164

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • HE Va GE d e J a e Gd YO GdQj a bGQG SH hGC cq gGGd a OhQJ GC NI HdjV HQj 52LOi Gdf 1241g,` eYG e j

    e HS HAk Y JC L GdV.hGd j d GC YO GdQj e Gd Gd JN a GdL d hLO

    f a hb GC LR ed JC L GdV a Gd H dK hGE d Zj GC LGd H T Gd hGC LR a GSGQ a GdGA e OGF Gd cdR.

    hGC LR a GC cjA Gd hg cGA e JC L a GdV HL GdS GE d Pdhb f c GH SG Y GdG ha GC ed )GC LR JC N Gd a GdGA

    Gd( )Gd hGE c 5/093(.b N: )GC h a ef d j a GE q cGA M ad( hc ed ji GC

    H GC j K GdGA a Gdf GE d GC L, K QL hb: "b Gb GC cjAGC eG GdS a HC S GC jD Nhg Hd hjHf GdjQ hT" )Gd hGE c:

    5/9393(.b: bd )hjHf( GC : jf YHfk .

    c GC L GS dL hb GC b Gd LGR e GC LGR JC L GdVeg GH Gd QV Gd Y.

    hGC f GC Qi GE Y GdL a e g GdO e d jO a f GE PG K GdLGdI Gd jD O Y GQJH GE d e hM j Gde H Gd Y

    J Pd a GBMO UQg hb TM QGC j a JC L Gdd a H aGdQU Gd GE d Gd GC hQhH dE aA.

    165

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • fF Gd:a gG Gd GdS Ya GdhQI d HC f Gd hGdI hGdL hGC f

    GUMk "GC e GE PG d jJ Gd g GC h bQ Gd" a eg GC NhGC f J Y GdL. hGC f GC Udk Gd Gd j Gda Y VhQG

    GdI Gd e L GdLO he L Gd. hHq GC U ehY GdhQI.hYq a GdL d HC f GaQ GE d GdA hPd g GdC QH hGdC QH g GdL.

    hYq ag GUMk HC f e f Y GdhQI H jD O a GE d e hbhMd GE d S hJ.

    K GE GdL e e g ML Ye Hj hg J Mk eGk hg eH Gd Gd j J a GBMO UQI a GC SSk dS

    hGS.hML NU a J JSk dhQI J M hJQ HQg hGC f

    QN Hd GC N, hPcf GC e dd hfb hV bYI Jj GdL edGdhQI a GdGY Gd hGC NL GC U GC Ud ek e Gdj GE d

    Je.c GC hV GC bYI Jj GdL ed GdhQI d Y GE Wb hGE GdL

    j GC j fGk dhQI Gd hGC GC e Gd Pchg e - hg GC Z- eU a Gd a e c GdL J ed GdhQI a GE q GC f GSA

    e GC U j Gdj c GdhQI GSA e fU J Hdj.he YG g GdQf GdF a jh Jj ed GdhQI eOGk M j bYI

    a b Hq GC f J e c Gd a bjk ce GdU a J edGdhQI a.

    166

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • hGC Tf GE d Jh OQL Gd a Gd hHq GC f JGL fk Hda h JaYeq k a c edd H Ja LF e LFJ hg a Gdd LF J GE d Gd

    H hJ f d j Y GdM hb GC jfg HSGA.c GC Hj GC hLk GC Ni JN a GdL M j Gd a Gd eOGk

    GC h M j GdV e Gd ehak GC h a TF Gdh hGQJ GC h jGd JHk hd eYk , GC h JN GdL eGb Gd d eLk d

    eL Y bF hK Yh.hGC L Gdh Gdgj a GdGJ Gd: eJ Gdq , heJ Gd, heJ

    Gdd.hgG GJ Gd Gdb d H GdhQI hGdL Gd ag a

    GdF Gd.hPcf H Gd e bGQG e Gd GE Se HI JGhM H

    GE bG hGE M Wk dj Gd hGdL hGdJk a Gdd GE d hLO fjC f H GC h GC U j Y. H GC Pcf bGQGk hGMGk d GC hQhH dE aA

    hGd, hY Y g GdGQG Jk eLGk Oh eb b J hJLY S Gd a gG Gd hGC Hj hL ff GdU Gd JGa bGQG

    Gd GC h Jd hJj GdGQG hHU a eC d JC L Gdd. c PdHNQ JQI HdQI Gdj GC h HE TQI Gdj Gd j GC g GNU.

    Gdh:1. e M Gdj: GdhQI TI hV heq J Gdq cd hGd

    hd Gdj he Gd, hGdL: GaQ hf a GC Y e GdhQI.2. GdhQI: GC Od fU hGV, hGdL: GC Od Ye.

    167

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • 3. GdhQI Gd: J GE d f a c Md J a H GE GE P H YSi e GS C Od GC Ni hbGF. hGdL: J GE d f E K GYQg hGC c

    GC e GdcQI cE LQI hGdGV hGdbI eU.4. GdhQI: Ja Gd hZ, hGdL ed g J Gd Y e jGg

    hHU ec Jhd Hd Vk , hb Jd bSk hJ e bYI.5. GdhQI: GC Kg eD b ehO H hGdL Gde GC Kg e.

    6. GdhQI T j H Z Gd hGdL j a JGM a GBMO GC aGOg.

    7. GdhQI QN Hd GC N hGdL Gde d QN HdGC N.

    8. GdhQI Ja fk a eJ Y e S Gd c Ja Z. hGdL Ja fk a eJ Y e eGJ Gd H JN eq e GdSF Oh ee

    GdU.9. GdhQI J GdO Gd j Gd a GC Uk GC h JHk hGdL J Gd

    Gd j a Gd JHk heak .01. GdhQI J Gd hGd hGdL J Gd Gd.

    11. GdhQI J Gd GdO hZ, hGdL J Zdk Gd Z GdOa Gd.

    21. GdhQI J H Oh GBN, hGdL J Gd GC Mfk a SGE Qa heh Oh b Gdj.

    168

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • 31. GdhQI J GE d N, hGdL JL Gd a e GNHh.

    hGC NGk d H Gdh Gd J C h eI H Gdj GC S a J gGdC d GC h Y GC b Hq GdL Gd Gd j Y GdM GC jD eq g

    hGdd Gd j dGQS GC jg. hfb eb Z eb bYIJj GdL ed GdhQI a GdGY Gd e GC f fY GS M

    GE GdOI L a eG Gd GdQI GC J eI Z eI.hGd Sf hJd hd Gda hg GdO H GE d SGA Gd.

    169

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • eGL Gd- GH J, GC H GdS J Gdj GC M H Y Gd, 827g,` e Gdhi, OGQ Gda dY

    hGd, Hh 7931g` ` 8791g.`- GH QT, GC H Gdd e H GC M H e GdW, 595g,` Gd hGd, GE OGQI GE MA GdG

    GE Se, b.- GH Y Gd, Y Gdj Y Gdj, bGY GC M, OGQ Gd, Hh 0041g.`

    - GH YHj, e GC e, 8521g,` MT QO GdQ Y GdQ GdQ, e GdH, GdgI6831g.`

    - GH GdH, GC H H e H Y Gd Gda GC fd, 245g,` Gd, Tc Y Gd,GdgI 6731g.`

    - GH Y, GC H e Y Gd GdQH GdfW, 145g,` Gd GdL, eD S OGQ Gd,GdgI.

    - GH bGe, ea Gdj GC H e Y Gd H GC M H e, 026g,` Gd, e GdgI, GdgI9831g.`

    - GH b GdRj, T Gdj GC H Y Gd e H GC H H, 157g,` GE Y Gdb Y QGdd, e Gd GC Rgj,GdgI 8831g.`

    - GE e Gde, GC H Gdd Y Gd H GC H Y Gd Gdj, Gdg, OGQ GC fQ, GdgI 0041g.`- GdL, GC H Gdd H S H N, 494g,` Gd T eWC GE e ed, OGQ Gd GdH,

    Hh 2331g.`- Gd, GC H Y Gd e H e H Y GdM GdY GdH, 459g,` eGg Gd

    Y e N, OGQ Gd, Hh.- GdQOj, GC H Gdc GC M H e H GC M, 1021g,` Gd Gd Y GC b Gdd GE d

    eg GE e ed, e Gdg GC Rgj, GdgI 6831g.`- Gde, T Gdj e H GC H GdS GC M H MI, 4001g,` fj Gd GE d T

    Gd, e GdH Gd, GdgI 6831g.`- GdQbf, Y Gdb, T Y Gd, OGQ Gd, Hh 8931g.`

    - GdW, L Gdj YGdM H GC H H, 119g,` GC T hGdF a bGY hah aGda, e GdH Gd, GdgI 8731g.`

    - GdW, GC H GE S GE HGg, GdGa, OGQ Gda, Hh.- GdW, GC HGE S GE HGg, GY, OGQ Gd Gd, Hh 8891.

    170

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq

  • - Gdcf, e H Y H e, 0521g,` GE QTO Gd, OGQ Gd GdH, Hh 9141g.`- Gda, f Gdj, T e GdhV, eD S GdSd, GdgI.

    - Gd, S Y Gd, f GdO Y eGb GdO, Uh GE MA GdG, GdgI.- GdGd, GC H Me e H GC M, 505g,` TA Gd, J: M Gd, e GE QTO,

    HGO 6131g.`- GdGa, T Gdj GC H GdS GC M H GE OQj, 486g,` GdNI, OGQ Gd GE Se, Hh.

    - GdGa, T Gdj GC H GdS GC M H GE OQj, 486g,` Gdh, OGQ GE MA Gd GdH, GdgI4431g.`

    - GdW, GC H Y Gd e H GC M GC fQ, 176g,` Gde C M GdGB, OGQ Gd, GdgI6831g.`

    - GdSf, YA Gdj GC H H H eO, 785g,` HGF GdF a JJ GdGF, OGQ GdGdH, GdgI.

    - GdG, GC H Y Gd e H jS H GC H GdS GdQ, 798g,` Gd hGE c MT YGd, OGQ Gd, Hh 2991.

    - Gdh, GC H Rcj e Gdj H T Gda, 676g,` Gd T Gd, OGQ Gd,Hh.

    171

    H : Gd Y Gd H Hq