274
8,) '%7) *36 -76%)0 %PER(IVWLS[MX^ .SLR;MPI] 7SRW-RG

The Case For Israel

  • Upload
    diana

  • View
    81

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Arab/Israeli conflict

Citation preview

Page 1: The Case For Israel

8,)�

'%7)�*36�

-76%)0

%PER�(IVWLS[MX

.SLR�;MPI]��7SRW��-RG�

Page 3: The Case For Israel

8,)�

'%7)�*36�

-76%)0

%PER�(IVWLS[MX

.SLR�;MPI]��7SRW��-RG�

Page 4: The Case For Israel

8LMW�FSSO�MW�TVMRXIH�SR�EGMH�JVII�TETIV��

'ST]VMKLX��������F]�%PER�(IVWLS[MX��%PP�VMKLXW�VIWIVZIH

4YFPMWLIH�F]�.SLR�;MPI]��7SRW��-RG���,SFSOIR��2I[�.IVWI]4YFPMWLIH�WMQYPXERISYWP]�MR�'EREHE

(IWMKR�ERH�TVSHYGXMSR�F]�2EZXE�%WWSGMEXIW��-RG�

1ETW�YWIH�F]�TIVQMWWMSR��%XPEW�%VEF�-WVEIPM�'SRJPMGX���XL�)HMXMSR�7MV�1EVXMR�+MPFIVX��4YFPMWLIH�F]6SYXPIHKI���������-7&2��������������4& �ERH�-7&2��������������,& ��4PIEWI�ZMWMX�SYV�[IF�WMXIJSV�JYVXLIV�HIXEMPW�SR�XLI�RI[�IHMXMSR��[[[�XE]PSVERHJVERGMW�GSQ�

2S�TEVX�SJ�XLMW�TYFPMGEXMSR�QE]�FI�VITVSHYGIH��WXSVIH�MR�E�VIXVMIZEP�W]WXIQ��SV�XVERWQMXXIH�MR�ER]�JSVQSV�F]�ER]�QIERW��IPIGXVSRMG��QIGLERMGEP��TLSXSGST]MRK��VIGSVHMRK��WGERRMRK��SV�SXLIV[MWI��I\GITX�EWTIVQMXXIH�YRHIV�7IGXMSR�����SV�����SJ�XLI������9RMXIH�7XEXIW�'ST]VMKLX�%GX��[MXLSYX�IMXLIV�XLI�TVMSV[VMXXIR�TIVQMWWMSR�SJ�XLI�4YFPMWLIV��SV�EYXLSVMEXMSR�XLVSYKL�TE]QIRX�SJ�XLI�ETTVSTVMEXI�TIV�GST]�JIIXS�XLI�'ST]VMKLX�'PIEVERGI�'IRXIV������6SWI[SSH�(VMZI��(ERZIVW��1%������������ �����������JE\

FI�EHHVIWWIH�XS�XLI�4IVQMWWMSRW�(ITEVXQIRX��.SLR�;MPI]��7SRW��-RG�������6MZIV�7XVIIX��,SFSOIR��2.����������� �����������JE\����� �����������IQEMP��TIVQGSSVHMREXSV$[MPI]�GSQ�

0MQMX�SJ�0MEFMPMX]�(MWGPEMQIV�SJ�;EVVERX]��;LMPI�XLI�TYFPMWLIV�ERH�XLI�EYXLSV�LEZI�YWIH�XLIMV�FIWXIJJSVXW�MR�TVITEVMRK�XLMW�FSSO��XLI]�QEOI�RS�VITVIWIRXEXMSRW�SV�[EVVERXMIW�[MXL�VIWTIGX�XS�XLI�EGGYVEG]SV�GSQTPIXIRIWW�SJ�XLI�GSRXIRXW�SJ�XLMW�FSSO�ERH�WTIGMJMGEPP]�HMWGPEMQ�ER]�MQTPMIH�[EVVERXMIW�SJ�QIV�GLERXEFMPMX]�SV�JMXRIWW�JSV�E�TEVXMGYPEV�TYVTSWI��2S�[EVVERX]�QE]�FI�GVIEXIH�SV�I\XIRHIH�F]�WEPIW�VIT�VIWIRXEXMZIW�SV�[VMXXIR�WEPIW�QEXIVMEPW��8LI�EHZMGI�ERH�WXVEXIKMIW�GSRXEMRIH�LIVIMR�QE]�RSX�FI�WYMXEFPIJSV�]SYV�WMXYEXMSR��=SY�WLSYPH�GSRWYPX�[MXL�E�TVSJIWWMSREP�[LIVI�ETTVSTVMEXI��2IMXLIV�XLI�TYFPMWLIV�RSVXLI�EYXLSV�WLEPP�FI�PMEFPI�JSV�ER]�PSWW�SJ�TVSJMX�SV�ER]�SXLIV�GSQQIVGMEP�HEQEKIW��MRGPYHMRK�FYX�RSX�PMQ�MXIH�XS�WTIGMEP��MRGMHIRXEP��GSRWIUYIRXMEP��SV�SXLIV�HEQEKIW�

*SV�KIRIVEP�MRJSVQEXMSR�EFSYX�SYV�SXLIV�TVSHYGXW�ERH�WIVZMGIW��TPIEWI�GSRXEGX�SYV�'YWXSQIV�'EVI(ITEVXQIRX�[MXLMR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�EX����� �����������SYXWMHI�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�EX����� ���������SV�JE\����� ����������

;MPI]�EPWS�TYFPMWLIW�MXW�FSSOW�MR�E�ZEVMIX]�SJ�IPIGXVSRMG�JSVQEXW��7SQI�GSRXIRX�XLEX�ETTIEVW�MR�TVMRX�QE]RSX�FI�EZEMPEFPI�MR�IPIGXVSRMG�FSSOW��*SV�QSVI�MRJSVQEXMSR�EFSYX�;MPI]�TVSHYGXW��ZMWMX�SYV�[IF�WMXI�EX[[[�[MPI]�GSQ�

0MFVEV]�SJ�'SRKVIWW�'EXEPSKMRK�MR�4YFPMGEXMSR�(EXE�

(IVWLS[MX��%PER�1�8LI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP���%PER�(IVWLS[MX�

T��GQ�-RGPYHIW�FMFPMSKVETLMGEP�VIJIVIRGIW�ERH�MRHI\�

-7&2�������������<��GPSXL���EPO��TETIV ���.I[W 4EPIWXMRI ,MWXSV]����.I[W 'SPSRMEXMSR 4EPIWXMRI����6IJYKIIW��

.I[MWL 4EPIWXMRI ,MWXSV]�����>MSRMWXW 4EPIWXMRI ,MWXSV]����-WVEIP,MWXSV]����%VEF�-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX����>MSRMWQ���-��8MXPI�

(7����(�� ���������� ����������

4VMRXIH�MR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�SJ�%QIVMGE

�� � � � � � � � � �

���� �����������SV�SR�XLI�[IF�EX�[[[�GST]VMKLX�GSQ��6IUYIWXW�XS�XLI�4YFPMWLIV�JSV�TIVQMWWMSR�WLSYPH

Page 5: The Case For Israel

8LMW�FSSO�MW�VIWTIGXJYPP]�HIHMGEXIH�XS�Q]�HIEV�JVMIRH�SJRIEVP]�JSVX]�]IEVW��4VSJIWWSV�%LEVSR�&EVEO��XLI�TVIWMHIRXSJ�-WVEIP¬W�7YTVIQI�'SYVX��[LSWI�NYHMGMEP�HIGMWMSRW�QEOIE�FIXXIV�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�ERH�JSV�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�XLER�ER]FSSO�GSYPH�TSWWMFP]�HS�

Page 7: The Case For Israel

%GORS[PIHKQIRXW ZMM

-RXVSHYGXMSR �

��-W�-WVEIP�E�'SPSRMEP��-QTIVMEPMWX�7XEXI# ��

��(MH�)YVSTIER�.I[W�(MWTPEGI�4EPIWXMRMERW# ��

��;EW�XLI�>MSRMWX�1SZIQIRX�E�4PSX�XS�'SPSRMI�

%PP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI# ��

��;EW�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�&MRHMRK�-RXIVREXMSREP�0E[# ��

��;IVI�XLI�.I[W�9R[MPPMRK�XS�7LEVI�4EPIWXMRI# ��

��,EZI�XLI�.I[W�%P[E]W�6INIGXIH�XLI�8[S�7XEXI�7SPYXMSR# ��

��,EZI�XLI�.I[W�)\TPSMXIH�XLI�,SPSGEYWX# ��

��;EW�XLI�9�2��4EVXMXMSR�4PER�9RJEMV�XS�4EPIWXMRMERW# ��

��;IVI�.I[W�E�1MRSVMX]�MR�;LEX�&IGEQI�-WVEIP# ��

���,EW�-WVEIP¬W�:MGXMQMEXMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�&IIR�

XLI�4VMQEV]�'EYWI�SJ�XLI�%VEF§-WVEIPM�'SRJPMGX# ��

���;EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI�)\TERWMSRMWX�

%KKVIWWMSR# ��

���(MH�-WVEIP�'VIEXI�XLI�%VEF�6IJYKII�4VSFPIQ# ��

���(MH�-WVEIP�7XEVX�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV# ��

���;EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�3GGYTEXMSR�[MXLSYX�.YWXMJMGEXMSR# ��

���;EW�XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV�-WVEIP¬W�*EYPX# ���

���,EW�-WVEIP�1EHI�7IVMSYW�)JJSVXW�EX�4IEGI# ���

���;EW�%VEJEX�6MKLX�MR�8YVRMRK�(S[R�XLI�&EVEO§'PMRXSR�

4IEGI�4VSTSWEP# ���

���;L]�,EZI�1SVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�8LER�-WVEIPMW�&IIR�/MPPIH# ���

���(SIW�-WVEIP�8SVXYVI�4EPIWXMRMERW# ���

Z

'328)287

Page 8: The Case For Israel

���,EW�-WVEIP�)RKEKIH�MR�+IRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�4EPIWXMRMER�

'MZMPMERW# ���

���-W�-WVEIP�E�6EGMWX�7XEXI# ���

���-W�XLI�-WVEIPM�3GGYTEXMSR�XLI�'EYWI�SJ�%PP�XLI�4VSFPIQW# ���

���,EW�-WVEIP�(IRMIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�7XEXILSSH# ���

���-W�-WVEIP¬W�4SPMG]�SJ�,SYWI�(IWXVYGXMSR�'SPPIGXMZI�

4YRMWLQIRX# ���

���-W�8EVKIXIH�%WWEWWMREXMSR�SJ�8IVVSVMWX�0IEHIVW�9RPE[JYP# ���

���-W�7IXXPIQIRX�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE�E�1ENSV�&EVVMIV�

XS�4IEGI# ���

���-W�8IVVSVMWQ�1IVIP]�4EVX�SJ�E�']GPI�SJ�:MSPIRGI# ���

���-W�-WVEIP�XLI�4VMQI�,YQER�6MKLXW�:MSPEXSV�MR�XLI�;SVPH# ���

���-W�8LIVI�1SVEP�)UYMZEPIRGI�FIX[IIR�4EPIWXMRMER�

8IVVSVMWXW�ERH�-WVEIPM�6IWTSRWIW# ���

���7LSYPH�9RMZIVWMXMIW�(MZIWX�JVSQ�-WVEIP�ERH�&S]GSXX�-WVEIPM�

7GLSPEVW# ���

���%VI�'VMXMGW�SJ�-WVEIP�%RXM�7IQMXMG# ���

���;L]�(S�7S�1ER]�.I[W�ERH�)ZIR�-WVEIPMW�7MHI�[MXL�

XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW# ���

'SRGPYWMSR��-WVEIP XLI�.I[�EQSRK�2EXMSRW ���

2SXIW ���

-RHI\ ���

ZM '328)287

Page 9: The Case For Israel

-�LEZI�FIIR�[SVOMRK�SR�XLMW�FSSO�WMRGI�������[LIR�-�JMVWX�FIKER�XS�QEOIXLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�SR�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW��MR�XLI�QIHME��ERH�MR�Q]�[VMXMRKW�3ZIV�XLI�]IEVW�-�LEZI�LEH�XLI�EWWMWXERGI SJXIR�XLI�GVMXMGEP�EWWMWXERGISJ�XSS�QER]�GSPPIEKYIW�XS�PMWX�ERH�XLERO��%QSRK�XLSWI�[LS�HIWIVZI�WTI�GMEP�QIRXMSR�EVI�4VSJIWWSV�-V[MR�'SXPIV��RS[�E�QIQFIV�SJ�XLI�'EREHMER4EVPMEQIRX��[MXL�[LSQ�-�LEZI�[SVOIH�SR�WS�QER]�GEYWIW�ERH�TVSNIGXW�.YWXMGIW�%LEVSR�&EVEO�ERH�=MXEO�>EQMV��[LS�LEZI�XEYKLX�QI�WS�QYGL�4VSJIWWSV�+ISVKI�*PIXGLIV��[LS�IHYGEXIW�QI�F]�EVKYMRK�ERH�GLEPPIRKMRK�4VSJIWWSV�%QRSR�6YFMRWXIMR��[MXL�[LSWI�[VMXMRKW�-�RIEVP]�EP[E]W�EKVII�-WVEIP�6MRKIP��[LS�KIRXP]�GSVVIGXW�Q]�QMWTIVGITXMSRW�EFSYX�-WVEIP��ERHKIRIVEXMSRW�SJ�WXYHIRXW�[LS�IHYGEXI�QI�EFSYX�GYVVIRX�QEXXIVW�

-R�[VMXMRK�XLMW�FSSO��-�LEZI�FIRIJMXIH�KVIEXP]�JVSQ�XLI�VIWIEVGL�EWWMW�XERGI�SJ�3[IR�%PXIVQER��1EVE�>YWQER��)VMG�'MXVSR��,SPP]�&IXL�&MPPMRK�XSR��2EXEPMI�,IVWLPEK��ERH�%]IPIX�;IMWW��1]�EWWMWXERX��.ERI�;EKRIV��Q]EKIRX��,IPIR�6IIW��Q]�IHMXSV��,ERE�0ERI��ERH�Q]�XIQTSVEV]�EWWMWXERX�6SFMR�=IS��LEZI�TVSZMHIH�MRZEPYEFPI�EWWMWXERGI�

*SV�TIVGITXMZI�GSQQIRXW�SR�XLI�QERYWGVMTX��-�XLERO�Q]�JVMIRHW&IVREVH�&IGO��.IJJVI]�)TWXIMR��7XIZI�/SWWP]R��%PER�6SXLJIPH��ERH1MGLEIP�ERH�.EGOMI�,EPFVIMGL�

1]�[MJI��'EVSP]R��ERH�Q]�HEYKLXIV��)PPE��MRWTMVIH�QI��HIFEXIH�[MXLQI��ERH�IRGSYVEKIH�QI��1]�WSRW��)PSR�ERH�.EQMR��Q]�RITLI[�%HEQ�Q]�RMIGIW�6ERE�ERH�,ERREL��Q]�FVSXLIV�2EXLER��ERH�Q]�WMWXIV�MR�PE[�1EVMP]R�EPP�QEHI�YWIJYP�WYKKIWXMSRW��[LMGL�-�QYGL�ETTVIGMEXI�

-�EGORS[PIHKI�XLI�TISTPI�SJ�-WVEIP�[LS�LEZI�WEGVMJMGIH�WS�QYGL�MR�XLIMVLMWXSVMG�IJJSVXW�XS�EGLMIZI�TIEGI��TVSWTIVMX]��ERH�HIQSGVEG]�MR�XLI�JEGI�SJWYGL�IRHYVMRK�IRQMX]�ERH�ZMSPIRGI��*MREPP]��-�EGORS[PIHKI�XLI�TIEGIQEO�IVW�ERH�TIEGI�WIIOIVW�SR�FSXL�WMHIW�SJ�XLMW�GSRJPMGX��IWTIGMEPP]�XLSWI�[LSKEZI�XLIMV�PMZIW�WS�XLEX�SXLIVW�QMKLX�PMZI�MR�TIEGI�ERH�WIGYVMX]�

ZMM

%'/23;0)(+1)287

Page 11: The Case For Israel

8LI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�WXERHW�EGGYWIH�MR�XLI�HSGO�SJ�MRXIVRE�XMSREP�NYWXMGI��8LI�GLEVKIW�MRGPYHI�FIMRK�E�GVMQMREP�WXEXI��XLI�TVMQIZMSPEXSV�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW��XLI�QMVVSV�MQEKI�SJ�2EMWQ��ERH�XLI

QSWX�MRXVERWMKIRX�FEVVMIV�XS�TIEGI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX��8LVSYKLSYX�XLI[SVPH��JVSQ�XLI�GLEQFIVW�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�XS�XLI�GEQTYWIW�SJ�YRM�ZIVWMXMIW��-WVEIP�MW�WMRKPIH�SYX�JSV�GSRHIQREXMSR��HMZIWXQIRX��FS]GSXX��ERHHIQSRMEXMSR��-XW�PIEHIVW�EVI�XLVIEXIRIH�[MXL�TVSWIGYXMSR�EW�[EV�GVMQMREPW�-XW�WYTTSVXIVW�EVI�GLEVKIH�[MXL�HYEP�PS]EPX]�ERH�TEVSGLMEPMWQ�8LI�XMQI�LEW�GSQI�JSV�E�TVSEGXMZI�HIJIRWI�SJ�-WVEIP�XS�FI�SJJIVIH�MR�XLI

GSYVX�SJ�TYFPMG�STMRMSR��-R�XLMW�FSSO��-�SJJIV�WYGL�E�HIJIRWI RSX�SJ�IZIV]-WVEIPM�TSPMG]�SV�EGXMSR�FYX�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�FEWMG�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX��XS�TVSXIGX�MXW�GMXM�IRW�JVSQ�XIVVSVMWQ��ERH�XS�HIJIRH�MXW�FSVHIVW�JVSQ�LSWXMPI�IRIQMIW��-�WLS[XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�PSRK�FIIR�[MPPMRK�XS�EGGITX�XLI�OMRH�SJ�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSRXLEX�MW�RS[�SR�XLI�TVSTSWIH�©VSEH�QETª�XS�TIEGI��ERH�XLEX�MX�[EW�XLI�%VEFPIEHIVWLMT�XLEX�TIVWMWXIRXP]�VIJYWIH�XS�EGGITX�ER]�.I[MWL�WXEXI RS�QEXXIVLS[�WQEPPMR�XLSWI�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�[MXL�E�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��-�EPWS�XV]�XSTVIWIRX�E�VIEPMWXMG�TMGXYVI�SJ�-WVEIP��[EVXW�ERH�EPP��EW�E�JPSYVMWLMRK�QYPXMIXLRMGHIQSGVEG]��WMQMPEV�MR�QER]�[E]W�XS�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��XLEX�EJJSVHW�EPP�SJ�MXWGMXMIRW .I[W��1YWPMQW��ERH�'LVMWXMERW JEV�FIXXIV�PMZIW�ERH�STTSVXYRMXMIWXLER�XLSWI�EJJSVHIH�F]�ER]�%VEF�SV�1YWPMQ�REXMSR��1SWX�MQTSVXERX��-�EVKYIXLEX�XLSWI�[LS�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�YRMUYI�GVMXMGMWQ�RSX�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWXGSYRXVMIW�[MXL�JEV�[SVWI�LYQER�VMKLXW�VIGSVHW�EVI�XLIQWIPZIW�KYMPX]�SJ�MRXIV�REXMSREP�FMKSXV]��8LMW�MW�E�WIVMSYW�EGGYWEXMSR�ERH�-�FEGO�MX�YT��0IX�QI�FIGPIEV�XLEX�-�EQ�RSX�GLEVKMRK�EPP�GVMXMGW�SJ�-WVEIP�[MXL�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��-�Q]WIPJLEZI�FIIR�UYMXI�GVMXMGEP�SJ�WTIGMJMG�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW�ERH�EGXMSRW�SZIV�XLI�]IEVW�EW�LEZI�QSWX�-WVEIP�WYTTSVXIVW��ZMVXYEPP]�IZIV]�-WVEIPM�GMXMIR��ERH�QER]%QIVMGER�.I[W��&YX�-�EQ�EPWS�GVMXMGEP�SJ�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW��MRGPYHMRK�Q]�S[R�EW�[IPP�EW�)YVSTIER��%WMER��ERH�1MHHPI�)EWXIVR�GSYRXVMIW��7S�PSRK�EW�GVMXM�GMWQ�MW�GSQTEVEXMZI��GSRXI\XYEP��ERH�JEMV��MX�WLSYPH�FI�IRGSYVEKIH��RSX�HMW�TEVEKIH��&YX�[LIR�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�MW�XLI�SRP]�SRI�GVMXMGMIH�JSV�JEYPXW�XLEXEVI�JEV�[SVWI�EQSRK�SXLIV�REXMSRW��WYGL�GVMXMGMWQ�GVSWWIW�XLI�PMRI�JVSQ�JEMVXS�JSYP��JVSQ�EGGITXEFPI�XS�ERXM�7IQMXMG�8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�SJ�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIWKSX�MX�VMKLX�[LIR�LI�WEMH�

-RXVSHYGXMSR

Page 12: The Case For Israel

©'VMXMGMMRK�-WVEIP�MW�RSX�ERXM�7IQMXMG��ERH�WE]MRK�WS�MW�ZMPI��&YX�WMRKPMRKSYX�-WVEIP�JSV�STTVSFVMYQ�ERH�MRXIVREXMSREP�WERGXMSR SYX�SJ�EPP�TVSTSV�XMSR�XS�ER]�SXLIV�TEVX]�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX MW�ERXM�7IQMXMG��ERH�RSX�WE]MRKWS�MW�HMWLSRIWX�ª�%�KSSH�[SVOMRK�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�MW�XEOMRK�EXVEMX�SV�ER�EGXMSR�XLEX�MW�[MHIWTVIEH��MJ�RSX�YRMZIVWEP��ERH�FPEQMRK�SRP]XLI.I[W�JSV�MX��8LEX�MW�[LEX�,MXPIV�ERH�7XEPMR�HMH��ERH�XLEX�MW�[LEX�JSVQIV,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]�TVIWMHIRX�%��0E[VIRGI�0S[IPP�HMH�MR�XLI�����W�[LIRLI�XVMIH�XS�PMQMX�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�.I[W�EHQMXXIH�XS�,EVZEVH�FIGEYWI�©.I[WGLIEX�ª�;LIR�E�HMWXMRKYMWLIH�EPYQRYW�SFNIGXIH�SR�XLI�KVSYRHW�XLEX�RSR�.I[W�EPWS�GLIEX��0S[IPP�VITPMIH��©=SY¬VI�GLERKMRK�XLI�WYFNIGX��-¬Q�XEPOMRKEFSYX�.I[W�ª�7S��XSS��[LIR�XLSWI�[LS�WMRKPI�SYX�SRP]�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSRJSV�GVMXMGMWQ�EVI�EWOIH�[L]�XLI]�HSR¬X�GVMXMGMI�-WVEIP¬W�IRIQMIW��XLI]VIWTSRH��©=SY¬VI�GLERKMRK�XLI�WYFNIGX��;I¬VI�XEPOMRK�EFSYX�-WVEIP�ª8LMW�FSSO�[MPP�TVSZI�RSX�SRP]�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�MRRSGIRX�SJ�XLI�GLEVKIW

FIMRK�PIZIPIH�EKEMRWX�MX�FYX�XLEX�RS�SXLIV�REXMSR�MR�LMWXSV]�JEGIH�[MXL�GSQ�TEVEFPI�GLEPPIRKIW�LEW�IZIV�EHLIVIH�XS�E�LMKLIV�WXERHEVH�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�FIIR�QSVI�WIRWMXMZI�XS�XLI�WEJIX]�SJ�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW��XVMIH�LEVHIV�XSSTIVEXI�YRHIV�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��SV�FIIR�[MPPMRK�XS�XEOI�QSVI�VMWOW�JSV�TIEGI�8LMW�MW�E�FSPH�GPEMQ��ERH�-�WYTTSVX�MX�[MXL�JEGXW�ERH�JMKYVIW��WSQI�SJ�[LMGL[MPP�WYVTVMWI�XLSWI�[LS�KIX�XLIMV�MRJSVQEXMSR�JVSQ�FMEWIH�WSYVGIW��*SVI\EQTPI��-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�REXMSR�MR�XLI�[SVPH�[LSWI�NYHMGMEV]�EGXMZIP]IRJSVGIW�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�EKEMRWX�MXW�QMPMXEV]�IZIR�HYVMRK�[EVXMQI��-X�MW�XLISRP]�GSYRXV]�MR�QSHIVR�LMWXSV]�XS�LEZI�VIXYVRIH�HMWTYXIH�XIVVMXSV]�GET�XYVIH�MR�E�HIJIRWMZI�[EV�ERH�GVYGMEP�XS�MXW�S[R�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�MR�I\GLERKI�JSVTIEGI��%RH�-WVEIP�LEW�OMPPIH�JI[IV�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�MR�TVSTSVXMSR�XS�XLIRYQFIV�SJ�MXW�S[R�GMZMPMERW�OMPPIH�XLER�ER]�GSYRXV]�IRKEKIH�MR�E�GSQTE�VEFPI�[EV��-�GLEPPIRKI�-WVEIP¬W�EGGYWIVW�XS�TVSHYGI�HEXE�WYTTSVXMRK�XLIMVGPEMQ�XLEX��EW�SRI�EGGYWIV�TYX�MX��-WVEIP�©MW�XLI�TVMQI�I\EQTPI�SJ�LYQERVMKLXW�ZMSPEXSVW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�ª�8LI]�[MPP�FI�YREFPI�XS�HS�WS�;LIR�XLI�FIWX�MW�EGGYWIH�SJ�FIMRK�XLI�[SVWX��XLI�JSGYW�QYWX�WLMJX�XS�XLI

EGGYWIVW��[LS�-�GSRXIRH�QE]�FI�KYMPX]�SJ�FMKSXV]��L]TSGVMW]��SV�EF]WQEPMKRSVERGI�EX�XLI�ZIV]�PIEWX��-X�MW�XLI]�[LS�QYWX�WXERH�MR�XLI�HSGO�SJ�LMW�XSV]��EPSRK�[MXL�SXLIVW�[LS�LEZI�EPWS�WMRKPIH�SYX�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI��XLI.I[MWL�VIPMKMSR��XLI�.I[MWL�GYPXYVI��SV�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�JSV�YRMUYI�ERHYRHIWIVZIH�GSRHIQREXMSR�8LI�TVIQMWI�SJ�XLMW�FSSO�MW�XLEX�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI�-WVEIPM�

ERH�4EPIWXMRMER�GPEMQW�MW�FSXL�MRIZMXEFPI�ERH�HIWMVEFPI��;LEX�TVIGMWI�JSVQXLMW�WSPYXMSR�[MPP�ERH�WLSYPH�YPXMQEXIP]�XEOI�MW��SJ�GSYVWI��WYFNIGX�XSGSRWMHIVEFPI�HMWTYXI EW�IZMHIRGIH�F]�XLI�JEMPYVI�SJ�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�MR�����§�����XS�VIEGL�E�QYXYEPP]�EGGITXEFPI�VIWSPYXMSRERH�F]�XLI�HMWTYXIW�WYVVSYRHMRK�XLI�©VSEH�QETª�SJ�������8LIVI�EVI�VIEPP]SRP]�JSYV�TSWWMFPI�EPXIVREXMZIW�XS�E�.I[MWL�ERH�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�PMZMRK�WMHIF]�WMHI�MR�TIEGI�

� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 13: The Case For Israel

8LI�JMVWX�MW�XLI�TVIJIVVIH�4EPIWXMRMER�WSPYXMSR�HIQERHIH�F]�,EQEW�ERHSXLIVW�[LS�VINIGX�-WVEIP¬W�ZIV]�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX��GSQQSRP]�VIJIVVIH�XS�EW�VINIG�XMSRMWXW ��REQIP]��XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�XSXEP�IPMQMREXMSR�SJ�E�.I[�MWL�WXEXI�ER][LIVI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX��8LI�WIGSRH�MW�TVIJIVVIH�F]�E�WQEPPRYQFIV�SJ�.I[MWL�JYRHEQIRXEPMWXW�ERH�I\TERWMSRMWXW��XLI�TIVQERIRX�ERRI\�EXMSR�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�ERH�XLI�I\TYPWMSR�SV�SGGYTEXMSRSJ�XLI�QMPPMSRW�SJ�%VEFW�[LS�RS[�PMZI�MR�XLIWI�EVIEW��8LI�XLMVH�EPXIVREXMZI[EW�SRGI�TVIJIVVIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��FYX�XLI]�RS�PSRKIV�EGGITX�MX��WSQIOMRH�SJ�JIHIVEXMSR�FIX[IIR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�ERSXLIV�%VEF�WXEXI��M�I���7]VMESV�.SVHER ��8LI�JSYVXL��[LMGL�LEW�EP[E]W�FIIR�E�TVIXI\X�XS�XYVR�-WVEIP�MRXSEHI�JEGXS�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��MW�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�E�WMRKPI�FMREXMSREP�WXEXI�2SRI�SJ�XLIWI�EPXIVREXMZIW�MW�GYVVIRXP]�EGGITXEFPI��%�VIWSPYXMSR�XLEX�VIG�SKRMIW�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�F]�-WVEIPMW�EW�[IPP�EW�4EPIWXMRMERW�MWXLI�SRP]�VIEWSREFPI�TEXL�XS�TIEGI��EPXLSYKL�MX�MW�RSX�[MXLSYX�MXW�S[R�VMWOW�%�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI�%VEF§4EPIWXMRMER§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX�EPWS�WIIQW

XS�FI�E�VEVI�TSMRX�SJ�GSRWIRWYW�MR�[LEX�MW�SXLIV[MWI�ER�MRXVEGXEFPIHMPIQQE��%R]�VIEWSREFPI�GSRWMHIVEXMSR�SJ�LS[�XS�VIWSPZI�XLMW�PSRKWXERHMRKHMWTYXI�TIEGIJYPP]�QYWX�FIKMR�[MXL�XLMW�GSRWIRWYW��1SWX�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�GYV�VIRXP]�EHZSGEXIW�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�ZEWX�QENSVMX]�SJ�%QIV�MGERW��%�WYFWXERXMEP�QENSVMX]�SJ�-WVEIPMW�LEZI�PSRK�EGGITXIH�XLMW�GSQTVSQMWI�-X�MW�RS[�XLI�SJJMGMEP�TSWMXMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�EW�[IPP�EW�XLI)K]TXMER��.SVHERMER��7EYHM�%VEFMER��ERH�1SVSGGER�KSZIVRQIRXW��3RP]�XLII\XVIQMWXW�EQSRK�XLI�-WVEIPMW�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�VINIGXMSR�MWX�WXEXIW�SJ�7]VME��-VER��ERH�0MF]E��GPEMQ�XLEX�XLI�IRXMVI�PERHQEWW�SJ�[LEX�MWRS[�-WVEIP��XLI�;IWX�&ERO��ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�WLSYPH�TIVQERIRXP]�FI�GSR�XVSPPIH�IMXLIV�F]�XLI�-WVEIPMW�EPSRI�SV�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EPSRI�7SQI�EGEHIQMG�STTSRIRXW�SJ�-WVEIP��WYGL�EW�2SEQ�'LSQWO]�ERH

)H[EVH�7EMH��EPWS�VINIGX�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��'LSQWO]�LEW�WEMH��©-HSR¬X�XLMRO�MX¬W�E�KSSH�MHIE�ª�EPXLSYKL�LI�LEW�EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�MX�QE]FI�©XLI�FIWX�SJ�ZEVMSYW�VSXXIR�MHIEW�EVSYRH�ª�'LSQWO]�LEW�PSRK�TVIJIVVIH�ERH�ETTEVIRXP]�WXMPP�TVIJIVW��E�WMRKPI�FMREXMSREP�JIHIVEP�WXEXI�FEWIH�SR�XLIQSHIPW�SJ�0IFERSR�ERH�=YKSWPEZME��8LI�JEGX�XLEX�FSXL�SJ�XLIWI�QSHIPWJEMPIH�QMWIVEFP]�ERH�IRHIH�MR�FPSSH]�JVEXVMGMHI�MW�MKRSVIH�F]�'LSQWO]��JSV[LSQ�XLISV]�MW�QSVI�MQTSVXERX�XLER�I\TIVMIRGI��7EMH�MW�EHEQERXP]STTSWIH�XS�ER]�WSPYXMSR�XLEX�PIEZIW�-WVEIP�MR�I\MWXIRGI�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��©-HSR¬X�Q]WIPJ�FIPMIZI�MR�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��-�FIPMIZI�MR�E�SRI�WXEXI�WSPY�XMSR�ª�,I��EPSRK�[MXL�'LSQWO]��JEZSVW�E�FMREXMSREP�WIGYPEV�WXEXI ERIPMXMWX�ERH�MQTVEGXMGEP�WSPYXMSR�XLEX�[SYPH�LEZI�XS�FI�MQTSWIH�SR�FSXLWMHIW��WMRGI�ZMVXYEPP]�RS�-WVEIPMW�SV�4EPIWXMRMERW�[SYPH�EGGITX�MX��I\GITX�EW�ETPS]�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�SXLIV�WMHI¬W�WXEXI �8SFI�WYVI��XLI�TSPP�RYQFIVW�MR�JEZSV�SJ�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ZEV]�SZIV

XMQI��IWTIGMEPP]�EGGSVHMRK�XS�GMVGYQWXERGI��-R�XMQIW�SJ�ZMSPIRX�GSRJPMGX��QSVI-WVEIPMW�ERH�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VINIGX�GSQTVSQMWI��FYX�QSWX�VIEWSREFPI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 �

Page 14: The Case For Israel

TISTPI�VIEPMI�XLEX�[LEXIZIV�TEVXMGYPEV�MRHMZMHYEPW�[SYPH�LSTI�JSV�MR�XLI�SV]�SV�IZIR�GPEMQ�EW�E�QEXXIV�SJ�+SH�KMZIR�VMKLX��XLI�VIEPMX]�MW�XLEX�RIMXLIVXLI�-WVEIPMW�RSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[MPP�KS�E[E]�SV�EGGITX�E�SRI�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�%GGSVHMRKP]��XLI�MRIZMXEFMPMX] ERH�GSVVIGXRIWW SJ�WSQI�WSVX�SJ�X[S�WXEXIGSQTVSQMWI�MW�E�YWIJYP�FIKMRRMRK�XS�ER]�HMWGYWWMSR�XLEX�WIIOW�E�GSRWXVYG�XMZI�VIWSPYXMSR�SJ�XLMW�HERKIVSYW�ERH�TEMRJYP�GSRJPMGX�%R�EKVIIH�YTSR�WXEVXMRK�TSMRX�MW�IWWIRXMEP��FIGEYWI�IEGL�TEVX]�XS�XLMW

PSRK�HMWTYXI�FIKMRW�XLI�REVVEXMZI�SJ�MXW�GPEMQ�XS�XLI�PERH�EX�E�HMJJIVIRXTSMRX�MR�LMWXSV]��8LMW�WLSYPH�RSX�FI�WYVTVMWMRK��WMRGI�REXMSRW�ERH�TISTPIW[LS�EVI�MR�GSRJPMGX�KIRIVEPP]�WIPIGX�EW�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLIMV�REXMSREP�REV�VEXMZI�E�TSMRX�XLEX�FIWX�WIVZIW�XS�WYTTSVX�XLIMV�GPEMQW�ERH�KVMIZERGIW��;LIRXLI�%QIVMGER�GSPSRMWXW�WSYKLX�WITEVEXMSR�JVSQ�)RKPERH��XLIMV�(IGPEVEXMSRSJ�-RHITIRHIRGI�FIKER�XLI�REVVEXMZI�[MXL�E�LMWXSV]�SJ�©VITIEXIH�MRNYVMIWERH�YWYVTEXMSRWª�GSQQMXXIH�F]�©XLI�TVIWIRX�OMRK�ª�WYGL�EW�©MQTSWMRKXE\IW�SR�YW�[MXLSYX�SYV�GSRWIRXª�ERH�©UYEVXIVMRK�PEVKI�FSHMIW�SJ�EVQIHXVSSTW�EQSRK�YW�ª�8LSWI�[LS�STTSWIH�WITEVEXMSR�FIKER�XLIMV�REVVEXMZI[MXL�XLI�[VSRKW�TIVTIXVEXIH�F]�XLI�GSPSRMWXW��WYGL�EW�XLIMV�VIJYWEP�XS�TE]GIVXEMR�XE\IW�ERH�XLI�TVSZSGEXMSRW�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�&VMXMWL�WSPHMIVW��7MQM�PEVP]��XLI�-WVEIPM�(IGPEVEXMSR�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI�FIKMRW�MXW�REVVEXMZI�[MXL�XLIPERH�SJ�-WVEIP�FIMRK�©XLI�FMVXLTPEGI�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�4ISTPI�ª�[LIVI�XLI]©JMVWX�EXXEMRIH�WXEXILSSH�������ERH�KEZI�XLI�[SVPH�XLI�)XIVREP�&SSO�SJ&SSOW�ª�8LI�SVMKMREP�4EPIWXMRI�2EXMSREP�'LEVXIV�FIKMRW�[MXL�XLI�©>MSRMWXSGGYTEXMSRª�ERH�VINIGXW�ER]�©GPEMQ�SJ�LMWXSVMGEP�SV�WTMVMXYEP�PMROW�FIX[IIRXLI�.I[W�ERH�4EPIWXMRI�ª�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSR¬W�TEVXMXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��ERHXLI�©IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�ª%R]�EXXIQTX�XS�YRVEZIP�XLI�GSQTPI\P]�HMWTYXIH�ERH�YPXMQEXIP]�YRZIVM�

JMEFPI�LMWXSVMGEP�GSRXIRXMSRW�SJ�I\XVIQMWX�-WVEIPMW�ERH�%VEFW�SRP]�TVSHYGIWYRVIEPMWXMG�EVKYQIRXW�SR�FSXL�WMHIW��-X�MW��SJ�GSYVWI��RIGIWWEV]�XS�LEZIWSQI�HIWGVMTXMSR�SJ�XLI�LMWXSV] ERGMIRX�ERH�QSHIVR SJ�XLMW�PERH�ERH�MXWIZIV�GLERKMRK�HIQSKVETLMGW��JSV�RS�VIEWSR�SXLIV�XLER�XS�FIKMR�XS�YRHIV�WXERH�LS[�VIEWSREFPI�TISTPI�GER�HVE[�WYGL�HMEQIXVMGEPP]�STTSWIH�GSR�GPYWMSRW�JVSQ�XLI�WEQI�FEWMG�JEGXW�SR�XLI�KVSYRH��8LI�VIEPMX]��SJ�GSYVWI��MWXLEX�SRP]�WSQI�SJ�XLI�JEGXW�EVI�EKVIIH�YTSR��1YGL�MW�HMWTYXIH�ERHFIPMIZIH�XS�FI�EFWSPYXI�XVYXL�F]�WSQI��[LMPI�SXLIVW�FIPMIZI�XLEX�MXW�STTS�WMXI�MW�IUYEPP]�XVYI�8LMW�HVEQEXMG�HMWTEVMX]�MR�TIVGITXMSR�VIWYPXW�JVSQ�E�RYQFIV�SJ�JEGXSVW�

7SQIXMQIW�MX�MW�E�QEXXIV�SJ�XLI�MRXIVTVIXEXMSR�SJ�ER�EKVIIH�YTSR�IZIRX�*SV�I\EQTPI��EW�[I�[MPP�WII�MR�GLETXIV�����IZIV]SRI�EKVIIW�XLEX�LYRHVIHWSJ�XLSYWERHW�SJ�%VEFW�[LS�SRGI�PMZIH�MR�[LEX�MW�RS[�-WVEIP�RS�PSRKIV�PMZIXLIVI��%PXLSYKL�XLI�TVIGMWI�RYQFIV�MW�MR�HMWTYXI��XLI�QENSV�HMWEKVIIQIRXMW�[LIXLIV�EPP��QSWX��WSQI��SV�RSRI�SJ�XLIWI�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�GLEWIH�SYX�SJ-WVEIP��PIJX�FIGEYWI�%VEF�PIEHIVW�YVKIH�XLIQ�XS��SV�WSQI�GSQFMREXMSR�SJXLIWI�ERH�SXLIV�JEGXSVW��8LIVI�MW�EPWS�HMWEKVIIQIRX�SZIV�LS[�PSRK�QER]�SJ

� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 15: The Case For Israel

XLIWI�VIJYKIIW�LEH�EGXYEPP]�PMZIH�MR�XLI�TPEGIW�XLI]�PIJX��WMRGI�XLI�9RMXIH2EXMSRW�HIJMRIH�E�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKII YRPMOI�ER]�SXLIV�VIJYKII�MR�LMW�XSV] EW�ER]SRI�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�MR�[LEX�FIGEQI�-WVEIP�JSV�SRP]�X[S�]IEVWTVMSV�XS�PIEZMRK�&IGEYWI�MX�MW�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�VIGSRWXVYGX�XLI�TVIGMWI�H]REQMGW�ERH�EXQSW�

TLIVMGW�XLEX�EGGSQTERMIH�XLI������[EV�[EKIH�F]�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�EKEMRWX-WVEIP��XLI�SRI�GSRGPYWMSR�EFSYX�[LMGL�[I�GER�FI�EFWSPYXIP]�GIVXEMR�MW�XLEXRS�SRI�[MPP�IZIV�ORS[ SV�GSRZMRGI�LMW�SV�LIV�STTSRIRXW [LIXLIV�QSWXSJ�XLI�%VEFW�[LS�PIJX�-WVEIP�[IVI�GLEWIH��PIJX�SR�XLIMV�S[R��SV�I\TIVMIRGIHWSQI�GSQFMREXMSR�SJ�JEGXSVW�XLEX�PIH�XLIQ�XS�QSZI�JVSQ�SRI�TPEGI�XSERSXLIV��-WVEIP�LEW�VIGIRXP]�STIRIH�QER]�SJ�MXW�LMWXSVMGEP�EVGLMZIW�XS�WGLSP�EVW��ERH�RI[P]�EZEMPEFPI�MRJSVQEXMSR�LEW�TVSHYGIH�QSVI�MRWMKLXW�ERH�MRXIV�TVIXEXMSRW�FYX�LEW�RSX ERH�[MPP�RIZIV IRH�EPP�HMWEKVIIQIRXW��

7MQMPEVP]��XLI���������7ITLEVHMG�.I[W�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�MR�%VEF�GSYRXVMIWFIJSVI�������QSWX�SJ�[LSQ�IRHIH�YT�MR�-WVEIP��[IVI�IMXLIV�JSVGIH�XSPIEZI��PIJX�SR�XLIMV�S[R��SV�I\TIVMIRGIH�WSQI�GSQFMREXMSR�SJ�JIEV��STTSV�XYRMX]��ERH�VIPMKMSYW�HIWXMR]��%KEMR��XLI�TVIGMWI�H]REQMGW�[MPP�RIZIV�FIORS[R��IWTIGMEPP]�WMRGI�XLI�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW�XLI]�PIJX�HS�RSX�QEMRXEMR��SVVIJYWI�XS�WLEVI��LMWXSVMGEP�VIGSVHW�ERH�EVGLMZIW�)EGL�WMHI�MW�IRXMXPIH�XS�MXW�WIPJ�WIVZMRK�REVVEXMZI�WS�PSRK�EW�MX�VIGSKRMIW

XLEX�SXLIVW�QE]�MRXIVTVIX�XLI�JEGXW�WSQI[LEX�HMJJIVIRXP]��7SQIXMQIW�XLIHMWTYXI�MW�EFSYX�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�XIVQW�VEXLIV�XLER�MRXIVTVIXEXMSR�SJ�JEGXW��*SVI\EQTPI��MX�MW�SJXIR�GPEMQIH�F]�%VEFW�XLEX�-WVEIP�[EW�EPPSGEXIH����TIVGIRXSJ�XLI�PERH�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�SRP]����TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�VIWM�HIRXW�SJ�XLEX�PERH�[IVI�.I[W��-WVEIPMW��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��GSRXIRH�XLEX.I[W�[IVI�E�GPIEV�QENSVMX]�MR�XLI�TEVXWSJ�XLI�PERH�EPPSGEXIH�XS�-WVEIP�[LIRXLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�TEVXMXMSRIH�XLI�HMWTYXIH�PERH��%W�]SY�[MPP�WII��TVIGMWIHIJMRMXMSRW�GER�WSQIXMQIW�REVVS[�HMWTEVMXMIW�%RSXLIV�WXEVXMRK�TSMRX�QYWX�MRGPYHI�WSQI�OMRH�SJ�WXEXYXI�SJ�PMQMXEXMSRW

JSV�ERGMIRX�KVMIZERGIW��.YWX�EW�XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�GER�RS�PSRKIV�VIP]�I\GPY�WMZIP]�SR�XLI�I\TYPWMSR�SJ�XLI�.I[W�JVSQ�XLI�PERH�SJ�-WVEIP�MR�XLI�JMVWX�GIR�XYV]��WS�XSS�XLI�%VEF�GEWI�QYWX�QSZI�FI]SRH�E�VIPMERGI�SR�IZIRXW�XLEXEPPIKIHP]�SGGYVVIH�QSVI�XLER�E�GIRXYV]�EKS��3RI�VIEWSR�JSV�WXEXYXIW�SJPMQMXEXMSRW�MW�XLI�VIGSKRMXMSR�XLEX�EW�XMQI�TEWWIW�MX�FIGSQIW�MRGVIEWMRKP]HMJJMGYPX�XS�VIGSRWXVYGX�XLI�TEWX�[MXL�ER]�HIKVII�SJ�TVIGMWMSR��ERH�TSPMXMGEPQIQSVMIW�LEVHIR�ERH�VITPEGI�XLI�JEGXW��%W�MX�LEW�FIIR�WEMH��©8LIVI�EVIJEGXW�ERH�XLIVI�EVI�XVYI�JEGXW�ª;MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XLI�IZIRXW�TVIGIHMRK�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�MR�������XLI�MRM�

XMEP�MQQMKVEXMSR�SJ�)YVSTIER�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�XS�4EPIWXMRI ��XLIVI�EVI�QSVITSPMXMGEP�ERH�VIPMKMSYW�QIQSVMIW�XLER�XVYI�JEGXW��;I�ORS[�XLEX�XLIVI�LEWEP[E]W�FIIR�E�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR�-WVEIP��TEVXMGYPEVP]�MR�XLI�LSP]�GMXMIW�SJ.IVYWEPIQ��,IFVSR��ERH�7EJEH��ERH�XLEX�XLIVI�LEW�FIIR�E�.I[MWL�TPYVEPMX]SV�QENSVMX]�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�JSV�GIRXYVMIW��;I�ORS[�XLEX�)YVSTIER�.I[W

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 �

Page 16: The Case For Israel

FIKER�XS�QSZI�XS�[LEX�MW�RS[�-WVEIP�MR�WMKRMJMGERX�RYQFIVW�HYVMRK�XLI����W SRP]�WLSVXP]�EJXIV�XLI�XMQI�[LIR�%YWXVEPMERW�SJ�&VMXMWL�HIWGIRXFIKER�XS�HMWTPEGI�%FSVMKMREP�%YWXVEPMERW�ERH�%QIVMGERW�SJ�)YVSTIERHIWGIRX�FIKER�XS�QSZI�MRXS�WSQI�;IWXIVR�PERHW�SVMKMREPP]�TSTYPEXIH�F]2EXMZI�%QIVMGERW�8LI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�HMH�RSX�HMWTPEGI�PSGEP�VIWMHIRXW�F]�GSRUYIWX

SV�JIEV�EW�XLI�%QIVMGERW�ERH�%YWXVEPMERW�HMH��8LI]�PE[JYPP]�ERH�STIRP]FSYKLX�PERH QYGL�SJ�MX�XLSYKLX�XS�FI�RSREVEFPI JVSQ�EFWIRXII�PERH�PSVHW��2S�SRI�[LS�EGGITXW�XLI�PIKMXMQEG]�SJ�%YWXVEPME�FIMRK�ER�)RKPMWL�WTIEOMRK�'LVMWXMER�REXMSR��SV�SJ�;IWXIVR�%QIVMGE�FIMRK�TEVX�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH7XEXIW��GER�UYIWXMSR�XLI�PIKMXMQEG]�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR�[LEX�MW�RS[-WVEIP�JVSQ�XLI�����W�XS�XLI�TVIWIRX��)ZIR�FIJSVI�XLI�9�2��4EVXMXMSR�SJ������MRXIVREXMSREP�XVIEXMIW�ERH�PE[�VIGSKRMIH�XLEX�XLI�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMX]MR�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�XLIVI��EW�E�QEXXIV�©SJ�VMKLX�ª�ERH�ER]�VEXMSREP�HMWGYWWMSR�SJXLI�GSRJPMGX�QYWX�FI�TVIQMWIH�SR�XLI�EWWYQTXMSR�XLEX�XLI�©JYRHEQIRXEPGSRJPMGXª�MW�©SJ�VMKLX�[MXL�VMKLX�ª�7YGL�GSRJPMGXW�EVI�SJXIR�XLI�QSWX�HMJJMGYPXXS�VIWSPZI��WMRGI�IEGL�WMHI�QYWX�FI�TIVWYEHIH�XS�GSQTVSQMWI�[LEX�MXFIPMIZIW�MW�ER�EFWSPYXI�GPEMQ�SJ�VMKLX��8LI�XEWO�FIGSQIW�IZIR�QSVI�HEYRX�MRK�[LIR�WSQI�SR�IEGL�WMHI�WII�XLIMV�GPEMQ�EW�FEWIH�SR�+SH¬W�QERHEXI�-�FIKMR�XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�F]�FVMIJP]�VIZMI[MRK�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI

%VEF§1YWPMQ§.I[MWL�ERH�XLIR�XLI�%VEF§4EPIWXMRMER§1YWPMQ§-WVEIPM�GSR�JPMGX��IQTLEWMMRK�XLI�VIJYWEP�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�XS�EGGITX�E�X[S�WXEXI�SV�X[S�LSQIPERH �WSPYXMSR�MR�������������������ERH�������-�JSGYW�SR-WVEIP¬W�TVEKQEXMG�IJJSVXW�XS�PMZI�MR�TIEGI�[MXLMR�WIGYVI�FSYRHEVMIW�HIWTMXIXLI�VITIEXIH�IJJSVXW�SJ�%VEF�PIEHIVW�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��-�TSMRX�SYX-WVEIP¬W�QMWXEOIW�FYX�EVKYI�XLEX�XLI]�[IVI�KIRIVEPP]�QEHI�MR�E�KSSH�JEMXL�EPXLSYKL�WSQIXMQIW�QMWKYMHIH �IJJSVX�XS�HIJIRH�MXW�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�*MREPP]��-�EVKYI�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�WSYKLX�XS�GSQTP]�[MXL�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�MR�ZMV�XYEPP]�EPP�SJ�MXW�EGXMZMXMIW�(IWTMXI�Q]�S[R�WXVSRK�FIPMIJ�XLEX�XLIVI�QYWX�FI�E�WXEXYXI�SJ�PMQMXEXMSRW

JSV�KVMIZERGIW��QEOMRK�XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�VIUYMVIW�E�FVMIJ�NSYVRI]�MRXS�XLIVIPEXMZIP]�VIGIRX�TEWX��8LMW�MW�WS�FIGEYWI�XLI�GEWI�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�GYVVIRXP]FIMRK�QEHI�SR�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW��MR�XLI�QIHME��ERH�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI[SVPH�VIPMIW�SR�[MPPJYP�HMWXSVXMSRW�SJ�XLI�LMWXSVMGEP�VIGSVH��FIKMRRMRK�[MXLXLI�JMVWX�EVVMZEP�SJ�)YVSTIERW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�RIEV�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�RMRIXIIRXLGIRXYV]�ERH�GSRXMRYMRK�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR��XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRXSJ�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��ERH�XLI�[EVW�FIX[IIR�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�ERH�-WVEIP��ERHGYPQMREXMRK�MR�XLI�SRKSMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�ERH�VIWTSRWIW�XS�MX��8LI�LMWXSVMGEPVIGSVH�QYWX�FI�WIX�WXVEMKLX�WS�EW�XS�LIIH�XLI�TLMPSWSTLIV�7ERXE]ERE¬W[EVRMRK�XLEX�XLSWI�[LS�GERRSX�VIQIQFIV�XLI�TEWX�EVI�GSRHIQRIH�XSVITIEX�MX�)EGL�GLETXIV�SJ�XLI�FSSO�WXEVXW�[MXL�XLI�EGGYWEXMSR�PIZIPIH�EKEMRWX

-WVEIP��UYSXMRK�WTIGMJMG�WSYVGIW��-�VIWTSRH�XS�XLI�EGGYWEXMSR�[MXL�LEVH�JEGXW

� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 17: The Case For Israel

FEGOIH�YT�F]�GVIHMFPI�IZMHIRGI��-R�TVIWIRXMRK�XLI�JEGXW��-�HS�RSX�KIRIVEPP]VIP]�SR�TVS�-WVEIP�WSYVGIW�FYX�TVMQEVMP]�SR�SFNIGXMZI��ERH�WSQIXMQIW�XSIQTLEWMI�XLI�TSMRX��SZIVXP]�ERXM�-WVEIP�WSYVGIW�-�TVSZI�FI]SRH�ER]�WLEHS[�SJ�E�HSYFX�XLEX�E�TIVRMGMSYW�HSYFPI�WXER�

HEVH�LEW�FIIR�ETTPMIH�XS�NYHKMRK�-WVEIP¬W�EGXMSRW��XLEX�IZIR�[LIR�-WVEIP�LEWFIIR�XLI�FIWX�SV�EQSRK�XLI�FIWX�MR�XLI�[SVPH��MX�LEW�SJXIR�FIIR�EGGYWIH�SJFIMRK�XLI�[SVWX�SV�EQSRK�XLI�[SVWX�MR�XLI�[SVPH��-�EPWS�TVSZI�XLEX�XLMWHSYFPI�WXERHEVH�LEW�RSX�SRP]�FIIR�YRJEMV�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�FYX�XLEX�MX�LEWHEQEKIH�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��[SYRHIH�XLI�GVIHMFMPMX]�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�SVKERM�EXMSRW�WYGL�EW�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��ERH�IRGSYVEKIH�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXWXS�GSQQMX�EGXW�SJ�ZMSPIRGI�MR�SVHIV�XS�TVSZSOI�SZIVVIEGXMSR�F]�-WVEIP�ERHWIGYVI�SRI�WMHIH�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�F]�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�-R�XLI�GSRGPYWMSR�XS�XLI�FSSO�-�EVKYI�XLEX�MX�MW�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�YRHIV�

WXERH�XLI�GSRJPMGX�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�[MXLSYX�EGGITXMRK�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEXJVSQ�XLI�ZIV]�FIKMRRMRK�XLI�WXVEXIK]�SJ�XLI�%VEF�PIEHIVWLMT�LEW�FIIR�XSIPMQMREXI�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�ER]�.I[MWL�WXEXI��ERH�MRHIIH�ER]�WYFWXERXMEP�.I[�MWL�TSTYPEXMSR��MR�[LEX�MW�RS[�-WVEIP��)ZIR�4VSJIWWSV�)H[EVH�7EMH��XLI4EPIWXMRMERW¬�QSWX�TVSQMRIRX�EGEHIQMG�GLEQTMSR��LEW�EGORS[PIHKIHXLEX�©XLI�[LSPI�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�REXMSREPMWQ�[EW�FEWIH�SR�HVMZMRK�EPP-WVEIPMW�?F]�[LMGL�LI�QIERW�.I[WA�SYX�ª�8LMW�MW�E�WMQTPI�JEGX�RSX�WYFNIGXXS�VIEWSREFPI�HMWTYXI��8LI�IZMHIRGI�JVSQ�XLI�QSYXLW�ERH�TIRW�SJ�%VEFERH�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�MW�SZIV[LIPQMRK��:EVMSYW�XEGXMGW�LEZI�FIIRIQTPS]IH�XS[EVH�XLMW�IRH��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�QIRHEGMSYW�VI[VMXMRK�SJ�XLI�LMW�XSV]�SJ�XLI�MQQMKVEXMSR�SJ�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�MRXS�4EPIWXMRI��EW�[IPP�EW�XLIHIQSKVETLMG�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��3XLIV�XEGXMGW�LEZI�MRGPYHIHXLI�XEVKIXMRK�SJ�ZYPRIVEFPI�.I[MWL�GMZMPMERW�FIKMRRMRK�MR�XLI�����W��XLI4EPIWXMRMER�WYTTSVX�JSV�,MXPIV�ERH�2EM�KIRSGMHI�MR�XLI�����W�ERH����W��ERH�XLI�ZMSPIRX�STTSWMXMSR�XS�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�TVSTSWIH�F]XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�MR�������XLIR�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�MR�������=IXERSXLIV�XEGXMG�[EW�GVIEXMRK��XLIR�HIPMFIVEXIP]�I\EGIVFEXMRK�ERH�I\TPSMXMRK�XLI�VIJYKII�GVMWMW�*SV�WSQI��XLI�ZIV]�MHIE�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXILSSH�EPSRKWMHI�E�.I[MWL

WXEXI�LEW�MXWIPJ�FIIR�E�XEGXMG E�JMVWX�WXIT XS[EVH�XLI�IPMQMREXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�&IX[IIR������ERH�������ZMVXYEPP]�RS�%VEF�SV�4EPIWXMRMER�WTSOIWTIVWSRGEPPIH�JSV�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��-RWXIEH�XLI]�[ERXIH�XLI�EVIE�XLEX�XLI�6SQERWLEH�HIWMKREXIH�EW�4EPIWXMRI�XS�FI�QIVKIH�MRXS�7]VME�SV�.SVHER��%W�%YRM&I]�%FHYP�,EXM��E�TVSQMRIRX�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIV��XSPH�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSRMR�������©8LIVI�MW�RS�WYGL�GSYRXV]��������4EPIWXMRI�MW�E�XIVQ�XLI�>MSRMWXWMRZIRXIH��������3YV�GSYRXV]�[EW�JSV�GIRXYVMIW�TEVX�SJ�7]VME�ª�%GGSVHMRKP]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VINIGXIH�XLI�MRHITIRHIRX�LSQIPERH�TVSTSWIH�F]�XLI�4IIP'SQQMWWMSR�FIGEYWI�MX�[SYPH�EPWS�LEZI�IRXEMPIH�E�XMR]�.I[MWL�LSQIPERHEPSRKWMHI�MX��8LI�KSEP�LEW�EP[E]W�VIQEMRIH�XLI�WEQI��IPMQMREXMRK�XLI�.I[�MWL�WXEXI�ERH�XVERWJIVVMRK�QSWX�SJ�XLI�.I[W�SYX�SJ�XLI�EVIE�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 �

Page 18: The Case For Israel

%VEF�VIEPMWXW�RS[�VIGSKRMI�XLEX�XLMW�KSEP�MW�YREXXEMREFPI EX�PIEWX�MRXLI�JSVIWIIEFPI�JYXYVI��8LI�LSTI�MW�XLEX�TVEKQEXMWQ�[MPP�TVIZEMP�SZIV�JYR�HEQIRXEPMWQ�ERH�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�ERH�XLIMV�PIEHIVW�[MPP�JMREPP]GSQI�XS�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�XLI�GEWI�JSV�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�MW�WXVIRKXLIRIH�F]XLI�EGGITXERGI�SJ�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��;LIR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[ERX�XLIMV�S[RWXEXI�QSVI�XLER�XLI]�[ERX�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��QSWX�-WVEIPMW�[MPP[IPGSQI�E�TIEGIJYP�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�EW�E�KSSH�RIMKLFSV��8LI�EKVIIQIRXXS�JSPPS[�XLI�©VSEH�QET�ª�ERH�XLI�LERHWLEOIW�ERH�TVSQMWIW�I\GLERKIH�MR%UEFE�SR�.YRI����������VITVIWIRX�WSQI�LSTI�XLEX�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPY�XMSR PSRK�EGGITXIH�F]�-WVEIP [MPP�JMREPP]�FIGSQI�E�VIEPMX]�-�[IPGSQI�ZMKSVSYW�HMWGYWWMSR�EFSYX�XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�-�QEOI�MR�XLMW

FSSO��-RHIIH�-�LSTI�XS�KIRIVEXI�LSRIWX��GSRXI\XYEP�HIFEXI�EFSYX�ER�MWWYIXLEX�LEW�FIGSQI�TSPEVMIH�F]�I\XVIQMWX�EVKYQIRXW��8LIVI�[MPP�WYVIP]�FIHMWEKVIIQIRX�EFSYX�XLI�GSRGPYWMSRW�-�VIEGL�ERH�XLI�MRJIVIRGIW�-�HVE[JVSQ�XLI�LMWXSVMGEP�JEGXW��&YX�XLIVI�GER�FI�RS�VIEWSREFPI�HMWEKVIIQIRXEFSYX�XLI�FEWMG�JEGXW��XLI�)YVSTIER�.I[W�[LS�NSMRIH�XLIMV�7ITLEVHMG�.I[�MWL�GSYWMRW�MR�[LEX�MW�RS[�-WVEIP�EX�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]�LEHER�EFWSPYXI�VMKLX�XS�WIIO�VIJYKI�MR�XLI�PERH�SJ�XLIMV�ERGIWXSVW��XLI]�IWXEF�PMWLIH�F]�XLI�W[IEX�SJ�XLIMV�FVS[W�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�MR�TEVXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRIXLEX�XLI]�JEMVP]�TYVGLEWIH�JVSQ�EFWIRXII�PERHPSVHW��XLI]�HMWTPEGIH�ZIV]�JI[PSGEP�JIPPELMR��%VEFW�[LS�[SVOIH�XLI�PERH ��XLI]�EGGITXIH�TVSTSWEPW�FEWIHSR�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�JSV�E�TEVXMXMSRIH�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�MR�EVIEW�[MXL�E.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��ERH��EX�PIEWX�YRXMP�VIGIRXP]��ZMVXYEPP]�EPP�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH%VEF�PIEHIVW�GEXIKSVMGEPP]�VINIGXIH�ER]�WSPYXMSR�XLEX�MRGPYHIH�E�.I[MWLWXEXI��E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH��SV�.I[MWL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��8LIWI�MRHMWTYXEFPIJEGXW�PEMH�XLI�JSYRHEXMSR�JSV�XLI�GSRJPMGX�XLEX�EGGSQTERMIH�XLI�IWXEFPMWL�QIRX�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�XLEX�GSRXMRYIW�XS�XLMW�HE]��-X�MW�MQTSVXERX�XS�TVIWIRXXLIWI�LMWXSVMGEP�JEGXW�EW�TEVX�SJ�XLI�GYVVIRX�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP��FIGEYWI�HMWXSV�XMSR�SV�SQMWWMSR�SJ�XLI�TEMRJYP�LMWXSV]�MW�E�WXETPI�SJ�XLI�GEWI�SJXIR�QEHIEKEMRWX�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�-�HIGMHIH�XS�[VMXI�XLMW�FSSO�EJXIV�GPSWIP]�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�'EQT

(EZMH§8EFE�TIEGI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�SJ�����§������XLIR�[EXGLMRK�EW�WS�QER]TISTPI�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH�XYVRIH�ZMGMSYWP]�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�[LIR�XLIRIKSXMEXMSRW�JEMPIH�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XYVRIH�SRGI�EKEMR�XS�XIVVSVMWQ��-[EW�PIGXYVMRK�EX�,EMJE�9RMZIVWMX]�MR�-WVEIP�HYVMRK�XLI�WYQQIV�SJ�������WS-�SFWIVZIH�JMVWXLERH�XLI�IRXLYWMEWQ�ERH�ERXMGMTEXMSR�[MXL�[LMGL�WS�QER]-WVEIPMW�E[EMXIH�XLI�SYXGSQI�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW�XLEX�LEH�FIKYR�[MXL�XLI3WPS�%GGSVHW�MR������ERH�ETTIEVIH�SR�XVEGO�XS[EVH�XLI�EGGITXERGI�SJ�EX[S�WXEXI�VIWSPYXMSR��[MXL�-WVEIP�ERH�4EPIWXMRI�JMREPP]�PMZMRK�MR�TIEGI�EJXIVWS�QER]�]IEVW�SJ�ZMSPIRX�GSRJPMGX�%W�XLI�TVSGIWW�QSZIH�XS[EVH�VIWSPYXMSR��4VMQI�1MRMWXIV�)LYH�&EVEO

WLSGOIH�XLI�[SVPH�F]�SJJIVMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ZMVXYEPP]�IZIV]XLMRK�XLI]�LEHFIIR�HIQERHMRK��MRGPYHMRK�E�WXEXI�[MXL�MXW�GETMXEP�MR�.IVYWEPIQ��GSRXVSP�SZIV

� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 19: The Case For Israel

XLI�8IQTPI�1SYRX��E�VIXYVR�SJ�ETTVS\MQEXIP]����TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�;IWX&ERO�ERH�EPP�SJ�XLI�+EE�7XVMT��ERH�E�����FMPPMSR�GSQTIRWEXMSR�TEGOEKIJSV�XLI������VIJYKIIW��,S[�GSYPH�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�TSWWMFP]�VINIGX�XLEX�LMWXSVMGSJJIV#�4VMRGI�&ERHEV�SJ�7EYHM�%VEFME��[LS�[EW�WIVZMRK�EW�ER�MRXIVQIHMEV]EQSRK�XLI�TEVXMIW��YVKIH�%VEJEX�XS�©XEOI�XLMW�HIEP�ª�'SYPH�]SY�IZIV�KIX�©EFIXXIV�HIEPª#�LI�EWOIH��;SYPH�]SY�VEXLIV�RIKSXMEXI�[MXL�7LEVSR#%W�%VEJEXZEGMPPEXIH��&ERHEV�MWWYIH�E�WXIVR�[EVRMRK��©-�LSTI�]SY�VIQIQFIV��WMV��[LEX-�XSPH�]SY��-J�[I�PSWI�XLMW�STTSVXYRMX]��MX�MW�KSMRK�XS�FI�E�GVMQI�ª�

-�[EXGLIH�MR�LSVVSV�EW�%VEJEX�GSQQMXXIH�XLEX�GVMQI�F]�VINIGXMRK�&EVEO¬WSJJIV��[EPOMRK�E[E]�JVSQ�XLI�TIEGI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�[MXLSYX�IZIR�QEOMRK�EGSYRXIVTVSTSWEP��4VMRGI�&ERHEV�[EW�PEXIV�XS�GLEVEGXIVMI�%VEJEX¬W�HIGMWMSREW�©E�GVMQI�EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW MR�JEGX��EKEMRWX�XLI�IRXMVI�VIKMSR�ª�,ILIPH�%VEJEX�TIVWSREPP]�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�EPP�XLI�IRWYMRK�HIEXLW�SJ�-WVEIPMW�ERH4EPIWXMRMERW���4VIWMHIRX�'PMRXSR�EPWS�TPEGIH�XLI�IRXMVI�FPEQI�JSV�XLI�XIV�QMREXMSR�SJ�XLI�TVSGIWW�SR�%VEJEX��EW�HMH�QSWX�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�LEH�TEVXMGM�TEXIH�MR�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW��)ZIR�QER]�)YVSTIERW�[IVI�JYVMSYW�EX�%VEJEX�JSV[EPOMRK�E[E]�JVSQ�XLMW�KIRIVSYW�SJJIV��*MREPP]��MX�PSSOIH�EW�MJ�[SVPH�TYF�PMG�STMRMSR�[EW�WLMJXMRK�E[E]�JVSQ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��[LS�LEH�VINIGXIH�XLIX[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�SRGI�EKEMR��ERH�XS[EVH�XLI�-WVEIPMW��[LS�LEH�TVSTSWIHE�[E]�SYX�SJ�XLI�ZMSPIRX�MQTEWWI�&YX�[MXLMR�E�JI[�WLSVX�QSRXLW��MRXIVREXMSREP�TYFPMG�STMRMSR�LEH�SRGI

EKEMR�WLMJXIH�E[E]�JVSQ�-WVEIP�ERH�FEGO�XS[EVH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��XLMW�XMQI[MXL�E�ZIRKIERGI��7YHHIRP]�-WVEIP�[EW�XLI�TEVMEL��XLI�ZMPPEMR��XLI�EKKVIWWSV�ERH�XLI�HIWXVS]IV�SJ�TIEGI��3R�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW�EGVSWW�XLI�[SVPH��MX[EW�-WVEIP XLI�GSYRXV]�XLEX�LEH�NYWX�SJJIVIH�WS�QYGL XLEX�[EW�XLI�WSPISFNIGX�SJ�HMZIWXQIRX�ERH�FS]GSXX�TIXMXMSRW��,S[�GSYPH�WS�QER]�MRXIPPMKIRXTISTPI�LEZI�JSVKSXXIR�WS�UYMGOP]�[LS�[EW�XS�FPEQI�JSV�XLI�XIVQMREXMSR�SJXLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW#�,S[�GSYPH�XLI�[SVPH�WS�UYMGOP]�XYVR�%VEJEX��XLI�ZMPPEMRSJ�'EQT�(EZMH��MRXS�E�LIVS��[LMPI�XYVRMRK�-WVEIP��[LMGL�LEH�LIVSMGEPP]SJJIVIH�WS�QYGL��MRXS�XLI�ZMPPEMR#�;LEX�LETTIRIH�MR�XLMW�FVMIJ�TIVMSH�XSTVSHYGI�WYGL�E�HVEQEXMG�WLMJX�MR�TYFPMG�TIVGITXMSRW#-�PIEVRIH�XLEX�[LEX�LETTIRIH�[EW�TVIGMWIP]�[LEX�4VMRGI�&ERHEV�LEH

TVIHMGXIH�XS�%VEJEX�[SYPH�LETTIR�MJ�LI�XYVRIH�HS[R�&EVEO¬W�TIEGI�SJJIV�©=SY�LEZI�SRP]�X[S�GLSMGIW��)MXLIV�]SY�XEOI�XLMW�HIEP�SV�[I�KS�XS�[EV�ª%VEJEX�GLSWI�XS�KS�XS�[EV��%GGSVHMRK�XS�LMW�S[R�GSQQYRMGEXMSRW�QMRMWXIV�©8LI�4�%��?4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]A�FIKER�XS�TVITEVI�JSV�XLI�SYXFVIEO�SJ�XLIGYVVIRX�MRXMJEHE�WMRGI�MXW�VIXYVR�JVSQ�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�RIKSXMEXMSRW��F]VIUYIWX�SJ�4VIWMHIRX�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�ª��

8LI�I\GYWI�JSV�XLI�IWGEPEXMSR�SJ�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�[EW�%VMIP�7LEVSR¬WZMWMX�XS�XLI�8IQTPI�1SYRX��&YX�EW�XLI�GSQQYRMGEXMSRW�QMRMWXIV�FSEWXIH�©%VEJEX�������TVIHMGXIH�XLI�SYXFVIEO�SJ�XLI�MRXMJEHE�EW�E�GSQTPIQIRXEV]WXEKI�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WXIEHJEWXRIWW�MR�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW��ERH�RSX�EW�E�WTI�GMJMG�TVSXIWX�EKEMRWX�7LEVSR¬W�ZMWMX�XS�%P�,EVEQ�%P�7LEVMJ�?XLI�8IQTPI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 �

Page 20: The Case For Israel

1SYRXA�ª�-RHIIH��XLI�IWGEPEXMSR�MR�XIVVSVMWQ�LEH�EGXYEPP]�FIKYR�WIZIVEPHE]WFIJSVI7LEVSR¬W�ZMWMX��EW�TEVX�SJ�©XLI�4%¬W�MRWXVYGX?MSRAª�XS�©XLI�TSPMX�MGEP�JSVGIW�ERH�JEGXMSRW�XS�VYR�EPP�QEXIVMEPW�SJ�XLI�MRXMJEHE�ª�-R�SXLIV�[SVHW�MRWXIEH�SJ�WLS[MRK�©WXIEHJEWXRIWW�MR�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRWª�F]�QEOMRK�E�GSYR�XIVTVSTSWEP�XS�&EVEO¬W�KIRIVSYW�SJJIV��%VEJEX�HIGMHIH�XS�QEOI�LMW�GSYR�XIVSJJIV�MR�XLI�JSVQ�SJ�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�ERH�IWGEPEXMRK�ZMSPIRGI��4VMRGI&ERHEV�LEW�GLEVKIH�%VEJEX�[MXL�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�VIWYPXMRK�FPSSHFEXL�©-�LEZI�WXMPP�RSX�VIGSZIVIH�������JVSQ�XLI�QEKRMXYHI�SJ�XLI�QMWWIH�STTSV�XYRMX]�ª�LI�XSPH�E�VITSVXIV��©7M\XIIR�LYRHVIH�4EPIWXMRMERW�HIEH�WS�JEV��%RHWIZIR�LYRHVIH�-WVEIPMW�HIEH��-R�Q]�NYHKQIRX��RSX�SRI�PMJI�SJ�XLIWI�-WVEIPMWERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�HIEH�MW�NYWXMJMIH�ª��

,S[�XLIR�GSYPH�XLI�QER�[LS�[EW�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�XLIWI�EZSMHEFPIHIEXLW��[LS�GLSWI�XS�VINIGX�XLI�&EVEO�TIEGI�TVSTSWEP��ERH�[LS�MRWXVYGXIHLMW�WYFSVHMREXIW�XS�VIWXEVX�XLI�ZMSPIRX�MRXMJEHE�EW�©E�GSQTPIQIRXEV]�WXEKIªXS�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�QEREKI�XS�XYVR�[SVPH�TYFPMG�STMRMSR�WS�UYMGOP]�MRJEZSV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�EKEMRWX�XLI�-WVEIPMW#�-X�[EW�XLMW�HEYRXMRK�UYIW�XMSR�XLEX�GVMIH�SYX�JSV�ER�ERW[IV��ERH�MX�[EW�XLI�JVMKLXIRMRK�ERW[IV�XLEXMQTIPPIH�QI�XS�[VMXI�XLMW�FSSO�8LI�ERW[IV�GSQIW�MR�X[S�TEVXW��8LI�JMVWX�MW�VEXLIV�SFZMSYW��%VEJEX

TPE]IH�XLI�XVMIH�ERH�XVYI�XIVVSVMWQ�GEVH�XLEX�LEH�[SVOIH�JSV�LMQ�WS�QER]XMQIW�SZIV�LMW�PSRK�ERH�XSVXYSYW�GEVIIV�EW�E�XIVVSVMWX�HMTPSQEX��&]�XEVKIX�MRK�-WVEIP¬W�GMZMPMERW GLMPHVIR�SR�WGLSSP�FYWIW��TVIKRERX�[SQIR�MR�WLST�TMRK�QEPPW��XIIREKIVW�EX�E�HMWGSXLIUYI��JEQMPMIW�EX�E�4EWWSZIV�WIHIV�YRMZIVWMX]�WXYHIRXW�MR�E�GEJIXIVME %VEJEX�ORI[�LI�GSYPH�KIX�-WVEIP�XS�SZIV�VIEGX��JMVWX�F]�IPIGXMRK�E�QSVI�LE[OMWL�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�XS�VITPEGI�XLI�HSZMWL)LYH�&EVEO��XLIR�F]�TVSZSOMRK�XLI�QMPMXEV]�XS�XEOI�EGXMSRW�XLEX�[SYPHMRIZMXEFP]�VIWYPX�MR�XLI�HIEXLW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERW��-X�[SVOIH�TIVJIGXP]�EW�MX�LEH�MR�XLI�TEWX��7YHHIRP]�XLI�[SVPH�[EW�WIIMRK�HMWXYVFMRK�MQEKIW�SJ-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�WLSSXMRK�MRXS�GVS[HW��WXSTTMRK�[SQIR�EX�GLIGOTSMRXW��ERHOMPPMRK�GMZMPMERW��%VEJEX�LEH�©QEWXIVIHª�XLI�©LEVWL�EVMXLQIXMG�SJ�TEMR�ª�EWSRI�HMTPSQEX�TYX�MX��©4EPIWXMRMER�GEWYEPXMIW�TPE]�MR�XLIMV�JEZSV��ERH�-WVEIPMGEWYEPXMIW�TPE]�MR�XLIMV�JEZSV��2SR�ZMSPIRGI�HSIWR¬X�TE]�ª��

*SV�QER]��XLI�FEVI�EVMXLQIXMG�[EW�IRSYKL��QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLER-WVEIPMW�[IVI�HIEH��ERH�XLEX�JEGX�EPSRI�TVSZIH�XLEX�-WVEIP�[EW�XLI�ZMPPEMR�-KRSVIH�[EW�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�EPXLSYKL�©SRP]ª�����-WVEIPMW�[IVI�OMPPIH��EW�SJ.YRI����� ��4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�LEH�EXXIQTXIHXS�OMPP�XLSYWERHW�QSVI�ERHLEH�JEMPIH�SRP]�FIGEYWI�-WVEIPM�EYXLSVMXMIW�LEH�XL[EVXIH�©EFSYX����TIVGIRXSJ�XLI�EXXIQTXIHª�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW���-KRSVIH�EPWS�[EW�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�EQSRKXLI�������SV�WS�4EPIWXMRMERW�OMPPIH�[IVI�LYRHVIHW�SJ�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��FSQFQEOIVW��FSQF�XLVS[IVW��XIVVSVMWQ�GSQQERHIVW��ERH�IZIR�EPPIKIH�GSPPEFS�VEXSVW�[LS�[IVI�OMPPIH�F]�SXLIV�4EPIWXMRMERW��;LIR�SRP]�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERWEVI�GSYRXIH��WMKRMJMGERXP]�QSVI�-WVEIPMW�XLER�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH���

-RHIIH��-WVEIP�LEW�OMPPIH�JI[IV�MRRSGIRX�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERW�HYVMRK�XLI

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 21: The Case For Israel

HIGEHIW�MX�LEW�FIIR�JMKLXMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�XLER�ER]�SXLIV�REXMSR�MR�LMWXSV]�JEG�MRK�GSQTEVEFPI�ZMSPIRGI��ERH�XLIWI�XVEKMG�HIEXLW�LEZI�FIIR�XLI�YRMRXIRHIHGSRWIUYIRGIW�SJ�JMKLXMRK�XIVVSVMWQ��VEXLIV�XLER�XLI�SFNIGX�SJ�XLI�ZMSPIRGI�;L]�XLIR�LEZI�WS�QER]�TISTPI�MR�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX] HMTPS�

QEXW��QIHME�TYRHMXW��WXYHIRXW��TSPMXMGMERW��VIPMKMSYW�PIEHIVW JEPPIR�JSV%VEJEX¬W�XVERWTEVIRX�ERH�MQQSVEP�TPS]#�;L]�[IVI�XLI]�RSX�FPEQMRK�%VEJEXJSV�XLI�IWGEPEXMSR�SJ�FPSSHWLIH��EW�4VMRGI�&ERHEV�ERH�SXLIVW�[IVI�HSMRK#;L]�[IVI�XLI]�WS�UYMGO�XS�TPEGI�XLI�FPEQI�SR�-WVEIP#�;L]�[IVI�QSVEP�ERHVIPMKMSYW�PIEHIVW�[LS�SVHMREVMP]�HVI[�E�WLEVT�HMWXMRGXMSR�FIX[IIR�XLSWI[LSTYVTSWIJYPP]XEVKIX�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�ERH�XLSWI�[LS�MREHZIVXIRXP]OMPPGMZMPMERW�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�TVSXIGX�XLIMV�S[R�GMZMPMERW�JEMPMRK�XS�HVE[�XLEXMQTSVXERX�HMWXMRGXMSR�[LIR�MX�GEQI�XS�-WVEIP#�;L]�HMH�XLI]�RSX�YRHIV�WXERH�LS[�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�[EW�QERMTYPEXMRK�ERH�I\TPSMXMRK�XLIEVMXLQIXMG�SJ�HIEXL#�;L]�GSYPH�XLI]�RSX�WII�FI]SRH�XLI�KVSWW�FSH]�GSYRXERH�JSGYW�SR�XLI�GSVVIGX�QSVEP�GEPGYPYW��LS[�QER]�MRRSGIRXTISTPI�[IVIHIPMFIVEXIP]�FIMRK�XEVKIXIH�ERH�OMPPIH�F]�IEGL�WMHI#-R�WIIOMRK�XS�ERW[IV�XLIWI�HMWXYVFMRK�UYIWXMSRW��MX�FIGEQI�GPIEV�XS�QI

XLEX�HEVOIV�JSVGIW�[IVI�EX�TPE]��8LI�HVEQEXMG�ERH�EPQSWX�XSXEP�WLMJX�MR�TYF�PMG�TIVGITXMSRW�SZIV�WS�FVMIJ�E�TIVMSH�SJ�XMQI�GSYPH�RSX�FI�I\TPEMRIH�F]�VIJ�IVIRGI�I\GPYWMZIP]�XS�TVMRGMTPIW�SJ�PSKMG��QSVEPMX]��NYWXMGI IZIR�TSPMXMGW�8LI�ERW[IVW�PE]��EX�PIEWX�MR�TEVX��MR�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXIERH�XLI�©.I[ª�EQSRK�XLI�WXEXIW�SJ�XLI�[SVPH��%�JYPP�YRHIVWXERHMRK�SJ�WSQYGL�SJ�XLI�[SVPH¬W�FMEVVI�VIEGXMSRW�XS�-WVEIP¬W�KIRIVSYW�TIEGI�SJJIV�ERHXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW¬�ZMSPIRX�VIWTSRWI�XS�MX�VIUYMVIW�E�VIGSKRMXMSR�SJ�XLI�[SVPH¬WPSRK�ERH�HMWXYVFMRK�LMWXSV]�SJ�NYHKMRK�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�F]�HMJJIVIRX��ERHJEV�QSVI�HIQERHMRK��WXERHEVHW�7S�XSS�[MXL�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR��7MRGI�WLSVXP]�EJXIV�MXW�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�EW

XLI�[SVPH¬W�JMVWX�QSHIVR�.I[MWL�WXEXI��-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�WYFNIGXIH�XS�E�YRMUYIHSYFPI�WXERHEVH�SJ�NYHKQIRX�ERH�GVMXMGMWQ�JSV�MXW�EGXMSRW�MR�HIJIRHMRKMXWIPJ�EKEMRWX�XLVIEXW�XS�MXW�ZIV]�I\MWXIRGI�ERH�XS�MXW�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR��8LMWFSSO�MW�EFSYX�XLEX�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH FSXL�MXW�YRJEMVRIWW�XS[EVH�-WVEIP�ERH�IZIR�QSVI�MQTSVXERX��MXW�TIVRMGMSYW�IJJIGX�SR�IRGSYVEKMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�F]4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�SXLIVW�-J�XLI�XSRI�SJ�XLMW�FSSO�WSQIXMQIW�WSYRHW�GSRXIRXMSYW��MX�MW�FIGEYWI�XLI

EGGYWEXMSRW�GYVVIRXP]�FIMRK�QEHI�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�EVI�WS�SJXIR�WLVMPP��YRGSQ�TVSQMWMRK��SRI�WMHIH��ERH�I\EKKIVEXIH��©2EM�PMOI�ª�©KIRSGMHEP�ª�©XLITVMQI�I\EQTPI�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXSVW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�ª�ERH�WS�SR��8LIWIJEPWI�GLEVKIW�QYWX�FI�ERW[IVIH�HMVIGXP]�ERH�XVYXLJYPP]�FIJSVI�E�XSRI�SJ�GSQ�TVSQMWI�ERH�QYXYEP�EGORS[PIHKQIRX�SJ�[VSRKHSMRK�GER�FI�VIWXSVIH�ERHXLI�MWWYIW�HIFEXIH�SR�XLIMV�SJXIR�GSQTPI\�QIVMXW�ERH�HIQIVMXW��&YX�EPP�XSSSJXIR��XSHE]¬W�HIFEXI��IWTIGMEPP]�SR�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW��MW�GLEVEGXIVMIH�F]GSRXIRXMSYW�ERH�SRI�WMHIH�EGGYWEXMSRW�QEHI�F]�XLSWI�WIIOMRK�XS�HIQS�RMI�-WVEIP��8LI]�EVI�SJXIR�ERW[IVIH�F]�JEV�QSVI�GERHMH�EGORS[PIHKQIRXW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Diana Boston
Highlight
Diana Boston
Highlight
Page 22: The Case For Israel

SJ�[VSRKHSMRK�F]�HIJIRHIVW�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�E�XSRI�SJ�ETSPSK]�XLEX�SJXIRTERHIVW�XS�XLI�EGGYWIVW�4VSKVIWW�XS[EVH�TIEGI�[MPP�GSQI�SRP]�[LIR�FSXL�WMHIW�EVI�[MPPMRK�XS

EGORS[PIHKI�XLIMV�S[R�[VSRKHSMRK�ERH�FPEQI[SVXLMRIWW�ERH�QSZIFI]SRH�XLI�JMRKIV�TSMRXMRK�TEWX�XS�E�JYXYVI�SJ�QYXYEP�GSQTVSQMWI��%REXQSWTLIVI�GSRHYGMZI�XS�WYGL�GSQTVSQMWI�[MPP�RSX�FI�EGLMIZIH�YRPIWW�XLIEMV�MW�GPIEVIH�SJ�XLI�JEPWI��I\EKKIVEXIH��ERH�SRI�WMHIH�EGGYWEXMSRW�XLEX�RS[TSPPYXI�XLI�HMWGYWWMSR�MR�WS�QER]�WIXXMRKW��8LI�TYVTSWI�SJ�XLMW�FSSO�MW�XSLIPT�GPIEV�XLI�EMV�F]�TVSZMHMRK�HMVIGX�ERH�XVYXLJYP�HIJIRWIW�XS�JEPWI�EGGYWE�XMSRW��8LI�XSRI�SJ�XLIWI�HIJIRWIW�WSQIXMQIW�RIGIWWEVMP]�QMVVSVW�XLI�XSRI�SJXLI�EGGYWEXMSRW��8LI�LEPPQEVO�SJ�Q]�[VMXMRK��WTIEOMRK��ERH�XIEGLMRK�SZIVXLI�]IEVW�LEW�EP[E]W�FIIR�XS�FI�HMVIGX�ERH�RSX�XS�TERHIV�XS��SV�[SVV]�EFSYX�SJJIRHMRK�XLSWI�[LS��SR�XLI�FEWMW�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�FMKSXIH�EGXMSRW�ERH�JEPWIEGGYWEXMSRW��HIWIVZI�XS�FI�SJJIRHIH��-�XV]�XS�JSPPS[�XLEX�TEXL�MR�XLMW�FSSO�3RGI�XLI�EMV�MW�GPIEVIH�SJ�XLI�TSPPYXERXW�SJ�FMKSXV]�ERH�JEPWILSSH��E

QSVI�RYERGIH�HIFEXI�GER�FIKMR�SZIV�WTIGMJMG�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW EW�[IPP�EWWTIGMJMG�4EPIWXMRMER�TSPMGMIW��8LMW�FSSO�MW�RSX�TEVX�SJ�XLEXHIFEXI��EPXLSYKL-�LEZI�Q]�S[R�ZMI[W�SR�QER]�SJ�XLIWI�MWWYIW��7S�PSRK�EW�-WVEIP�WXERHW�WMR�KYPEVP]�ERH�JEPWIP]�EGGYWIH�SJ�FIMRK�XLI�[SVWX�SJJIRHIV��XLI�JMVWX�SFPMKEXMSRSJ�XLSWI�GSQQMXXIH�XS�XVYXL�ERH�JEMVRIWW�MW�XS�HMWTVSZI�XLSWI�EGGYWEXMSRWJMVQP]�ERH�YRIUYMZSGEPP]�-�EQ�JVIUYIRXP]�EWOIH�LS[�-��EW�E�GMZMP�PMFIVXEVMER�ERH�PMFIVEP��GER�WYTTSVX

-WVEIP��8LI�MQTPMGEXMSR�FILMRH�XLI�UYIWXMSR�MW�XLEX�-�QYWX�FI�GSQTVSQMWMRKQ]�TVMRGMTPIW�MR�WYTTSVXMRK�WS�©VITVIWWMZIª�E�VIKMQI��8LI�XVYXL�MW�XLEX�-WYTTSVX�-WVEIP�TVIGMWIP]�FIGEYWI-�EQ�E�GMZMP�PMFIVXEVMER�ERH�E�PMFIVEP��-�EPWSGVMXMGMI�-WVEIP�[LIRIZIV�MXW�TSPMGMIW�ZMSPEXI�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��2SV�HS�-�XV]�XSHIJIRH�IKVIKMSYW�EGXMSRW�F]�-WVEIPMW�SV�XLIMV�EPPMIW��WYGL�EW�XLI������OMPPMRKWF]�MVVIKYPEV�XVSSTW�SJ�GMZMPMERW�EX�(IMV�=EWWMR��XLI������4LEPERKMWX�QEWWEGVISJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�XLI�7EFVE�ERH�7LEXMPPE�VIJYKII�GEQTW��SV�XLI������QEWWQYVHIV�SJ�1YWPMQW�EX�TVE]IV�F]�&EVYGL�+SPHWXIMR��0MOI�ER]�SXLIV�HIQSG�VEG]��-WVEIP�ERH�MXW�PIEHIVW�WLSYPH�FI�GVMXMGMIH�[LIRIZIV�XLIMV�EGXMSRW�JEMP�XSQIIX�EGGITXEFPI�WXERHEVHW��FYX�XLI�GVMXMGMWQ�WLSYPH�FI�TVSTSVXMSREP��GSQ�TEVEXMZI��ERH�GSRXI\XYEP��EW�MX�WLSYPH�FI�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�SXLIV�REXMSRW�EW�[IPP�-�QEOI�XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�FEWIH�SR�PMFIVEP�ERH�GMZMP�PMFIVXEVMER�GSRWMHIV�

EXMSRW��EPXLSYKL�-�FIPMIZI�XLEX�GSRWIVZEXMZIW�WLSYPH�EPWS�WYTTSVX�XLI�.I[MWLWXEXI�FEWIH�SR�GSRWIVZEXMZI�ZEPYIW��-�EQ�RSX�EWOMRK�ER]FSH]�XS�GSQTVSQMWIXLIMV�TVMRGMTPIW��6EXLIV��Q]�VIUYIWX�MW�XLEX�EPP�TISTPI�SJ�KSSH[MPP�WLSYPHWMQTP]�ETTP]�XLI�WEQI�TVMRGMTPIW�SJ�QSVEPMX]�ERH�NYWXMGI�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXISJ�-WVEIP�XLEX�XLI]�HS�XS�SXLIV�WXEXIW�ERH�TISTPIW��-J�XLI]�[SYPH�SRP]�ETTP]E�WMRKPI�WXERHEVH��XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�[SYPH�PEVKIP]�QEOI�MXWIPJ��&YX�WMRGI�WSQER]�TISTPI�MRWMWX�SR�ETTP]MRK�E�QSVI�HIQERHMRK�WXERHEVH�XS�-WVEIP��-RS[�QEOI�XLI�GEWI�XLEX��NYHKIH�F]�ER]�VEXMSREP�WXERHEVH��-WVEIP�HIWIVZIWXLI�WYTTSVX EPXLSYKL�GIVXEMRP]�RSX�XLI�YRGVMXMGEP�WYTTSVX SJ�EPP�TISTPISJ�KSSH[MPP�[LS�ZEPYI�TIEGI��NYWXMGI��JEMVRIWW��ERH�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 23: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP�MW�E�GSPSRMEP��MQTIVMEPMWX��WIXXPIV�WXEXI��GSQTEVEFPI�XS�ETEVXLIMH�7SYXL%JVMGE�

8,)�%''97)67

©?%�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MR�4EPIWXMRIA�GSYPH�SRP]�IQIVKI�EW�XLI�FEWXEVH�GLMPH�SJMQTIVMEPMWX�TS[IVW��ERH�MX�GSYPH�SRP]�GSQI�MRXS�I\MWXIRGI�F]�HMWTPEGMRK�XLIKVIEXIV�TEVX�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR��F]�MRGSVTSVEXMRK�XLIQ�MRXS�ERETEVXLIMH�WXEXI��SV�XLVSYKL�WSQI�GSQFMREXMSR�SJ�XLI�X[S��-R�EHHMXMSR��SRGIGVIEXIH��-WVEIP�GSYPH�SRP]�WYVZMZI�EW�E�QMPMXEVMWX��I\TERWMSRMWX��ERH�LIKI�QSRMG�WXEXI��GSRWXERXP]�EX�[EV�[MXL�MXW�RIMKLFSYVW�ª��1��7LELMH�%PEQ�TVSJIWWSV�SJ�IGSRSQMGW�EX�2SVXLIEWXIVR�9RMZIVWMX]�

©3GGYTMIH�4EPIWXMRI�?[LMGL�MRGPYHIW�EPP�SJ�-WVEIPA�QYWX�FI�HIGSPSRMIH�HIVEGMEPMIH�ERH�VIWXSVIH�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�EW�E�WMRKPI�WSZIVIMKR�WXEXI�-R�TPEMR�)RKPMWL��XLI�>MSRMWX�7XEXI�QYWX�FI�HMWQERXPIH�ª��-QEQ�%GLQIH'EWWMIQ��REXMSREP�GLEMVTIVWSR��-WPEQMG�9RMX]�'SRZMGXMSR��7SYXL�%JVMGE�

8,)�6)%0-8=

-WVEIP�MW�E�WXEXI�GSQTVMWMRK�TVMQEVMP]�VIJYKIIW�ERH�XLIMV�HIWGIRHERXW�I\IVGMW�MRK�XLIMV�VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��&IKMRRMRK�MR�XLI�����W��XLI�.I[W�[LS�QSZIH�XS�[LEX�MW�RS[�-WVEIP�[IVI�VIJYKIIW�IWGETMRK�XLI�STTVIWWMZI

��

-W�-WVEIP�E�'SPSRMEP��-QTIVMEPMWX�7XEXI#

Page 24: The Case For Israel

ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�SJ�GSPSRMEP�)YVSTI�ERH�XLI�1YWPMQ�WXEXIW�SJ�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWXERH�2SVXL�%JVMGE��9RPMOI�GSPSRMEP�WIXXPIVW�WIVZMRK�XLI�I\TERWMSRMWX�GSQ�QIVGMEP�ERH�QMPMXEV]�KSEPW�SJ�MQTIVMEP�REXMSRW�WYGL�EW�+VIEX�&VMXEMR��*VERGI�XLI�2IXLIVPERHW��ERH�7TEMR��XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�IWGETMRK�JVSQ�XLIGSYRXVMIW�XLEX�LEH�STTVIWWIH�XLIQ�JSV�GIRXYVMIW��8LIWI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW[IVI�JEV�QSVI�GSQTEVEFPI�XS�XLI�%QIVMGER�GSPSRMWXW�[LS�LEH�PIJX�)RKPERHFIGEYWI�SJ�VIPMKMSYW�STTVIWWMSR��SV�XLI�)YVSTIERW�[LS�PEXIV�MQQMKVEXIH�XS%QIVMGE �XLER�XLI]�[IVI�XS�IMKLXIIRXL��ERH�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]�)RKPMWLMQTIVMEPMWXW�[LS�GSPSRMIH�-RHME��XLI�*VIRGL�WIXXPIVW�[LS�GSPSRMIH�2SVXL%JVMGE��ERH�XLI�(YXGL�I\TERWMSRMWXW�[LS�GSPSRMIH�-RHSRIWME�

8,)�4633*

8LSWI�[LS�EFWYVHP]�GPEMQ�XLEX�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[LS�MQQMKVEXIH�XS4EPIWXMRI�MR�XLI�PEWX�HIGEHIW�SJ�XLI�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]�[IVI�XLI�©XSSPWª�SJ)YVSTIER�MQTIVMEPMWQ�QYWX�ERW[IV�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�UYIWXMSR��*SV�[LSQ[IVIXLIWI�WSGMEPMWXW�ERH�MHIEPMWXW�[SVOMRK#�;IVI�XLI]�TPERXMRK�XLI�JPEK�SJ�XLILEXIH�GEV�SJ�6YWWME�SV�XLI�ERXM�7IQMXMG�VIKMQIW�SJ�4SPERH�SV�0MXLYERME#8LIWI�VIJYKIIW�[ERXIH�RSXLMRK�XS�HS�[MXL�XLI�GSYRXVMIW�JVSQ�[LMGL�XLI]JPIH�XS�EZSMH�TSKVSQW�ERH�VIPMKMSYW�HMWGVMQMREXMSR��8LI]�GEQI�XS�4EPIW�XMRI�[MXLSYX�ER]�SJ�XLI�[IETSRW�SJ�MQTIVMEPMWQ��8LI]�FVSYKLX�[MXL�XLIQJI[�KYRW�SV�SXLIV�QIERW�SJ�GSRUYIWX��8LIMV�XSSPW�[IVI�VEOIW�ERH�LSIW�8LI�PERH�XLI]�GYPXMZEXIH�[EW�RSX�XEOIR�E[E]�JVSQ�MXW�VMKLXJYP�S[RIVW�F]JSVGI�SV�GSRJMWGEXIH�F]�GSPSRMEP�PE[��-X�[EW�TYVGLEWIH��TVMQEVMP]�JVSQ�EFWIR�XII�PERHPSVHW�ERH�VIEP�IWXEXI�WTIGYPEXSVW��EX�JEMV�SV�SJXIR�I\SVFMXERX�TVMGIW�

%W�1EVXMR�&YFIV��E�WXVSRK�WYTTSVXIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�VMKLXW��SFWIVZIH�MR������©3YV�WIXXPIVW�HS�RSX�GSQI�LIVI�EW�HS�XLI�GSPSRMWXW�JVSQ�XLI�3GGM�HIRX��XS�LEZI�REXMZIW�HS�XLIMV�[SVO�JSV�XLIQ��XLI]�XLIQWIPZIW�WIX�XLIMVWLSYPHIVW�XS�XLI�TPS[�ERH�XLI]�WTIRH�XLIMV�WXVIRKXL�ERH�XLIMV�FPSSH�XSQEOI�XLI�PERH�JVYMXJYP�ª�2SV�[EW�XLI�PERH�XLI]�WSYKLX�XS�GYPXMZEXI�VMGL�MRREXYVEP�VIWSYVGIW�WYGL�EW�SMP�SV�KSPH��SV�WXVEXIKMGEPP]�TSWMXMSRIH�EW�E�XVEHIVSYXI��-X�[EW�E�QEXIVMEPP]�[SVXLPIWW�TMIGI�SJ�VIEP�IWXEXI�MR�E�FEGO[EXIV�SJXLI�[SVPH�[LSWI�WMKRMJMGERGI�XS�.I[W�[EW�VIPMKMSYW��LMWXSVMGEP��ERH�JEQMPMEP�

'PIEVP]�XLIWI�.I[MWL�[SVOIVW�[IVI�RSX�]SYV�X]TMGEP�MQTIVMEPMWXW��8LI][IVI�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�STTVIWWMZI�VIKMQIW�[LS�[IVI�WIIOMRK�XS�FIKMR�RI[PMZIW�MR�E�TPEGI�XLIMV�ERGIWXSVW�LEH�PSRK�EKS�WIXXPIH�ERH�JVSQ�[LMGL�QSWXFYX�RSX�EPP�SJ�XLIQ�LEH�IZIRXYEPP]�FIIR�HVMZIR��1SVISZIV��EW�XLI�&VMXMWLLMWXSVMER�4EYP�.SLRWSR�LEW�HSGYQIRXIH��XLI�GSPSRMEP�TS[IVW�HMH�IZIV]�XLMRK�TSWWMFPI�XS�XL[EVX�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH��©)ZIV]�[LIVI�MR�XLI�;IWX��XLI�JSVIMKR�SJJMGIW��HIJIRWI�QMRMWXVMIW�ERH�FMK�FYWMRIWW[IVI�EKEMRWX�XLI�>MSRMWXW�ª�8LI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[LS�GEQI�XS�PMZI�MR4EPIWXMRI�LEH�XS�SZIVGSQI�8YVOMWL��&VMXMWL��ERH�4ER�%VEF�MQTIVMEPMWQ�MRSVHIV�XS�EGLMIZI�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Diana Boston
Highlight
Diana Boston
Highlight
Page 25: The Case For Israel

8STVSZI�FI]SRH�ER]�VIEWSREFPI�HSYFX�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�RSX�ERH�LEW�RIZIVFIIR�ER�MQTIVMEPMWX�SV�GSPSRMEPMWX�WXEXI��MX�MW�RIGIWWEV]�XS�FVMIJP]�VIGSYRX�XLIIEVP]�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�)YVSTI�[LS�NSMRIH�XLI�QSWXP]7ITLEVHMG�.I[W�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI�JSV�KIRIVEXMSRW��8LI�JMVWX�[EZISJ�MQQMKVEXMSR��SV�%PM]EL�EW�MX�[EW�GEPPIH ��FIKMRRMRK�MR������ERH�IRHMRKMR�������[EW�RSX�ZIV]�HMJJIVIRX�MR�QER]�VIWTIGXW�JVSQ�XLI�JMVWX�PEVKI�WGEPIMQQMKVEXMSR�SJ�)EWXIVR�)YVSTIER�.I[W�XS�%QIVMGE�EX�EFSYX�XLI�WEQI�XMQI�8LMW�[EW�E�XMQI�SJ�QEWWMZI�IQMKVEXMSR�ERH�MQQMKVEXMSR�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI[SVPH��IWTIGMEPP]�JVSQ�XLI�GVS[HIH�GMXMIW�ERH�XS[RW�SJ�)YVSTI��)RSVQSYWTSTYPEXMSR�WLMJXW�XSSO�TPEGI��[MXL�TISTPI�WIXXPMRK�MR�TPEGIW�JEV�E[E]�JVSQXLIMV�FMVXLTPEGIW��-VMWL��-XEPMER��+VIIO��+IVQER��4SPMWL��ERH�.I[MWL�JEQMPMIW�EW�[IPP�EW�'LMRIWI��.ETERIWI��ERH�'EVMFFIER�JEQMPMIW��WSYKLX�FIXXIV�PMZIW�MRXLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��'EREHE��7SYXL�%QIVMGE��%YWXVEPME��ERH�SXLIV�TPEGIW[LIVI�XLI]�GSYPH�[SVO�[MXL�XLIMV�LERHW�ERH�HIZIPST�XLIMV�QMRHW�

%TTVS\MQEXIP]��������)EWXIVR�)YVSTIER�.I[W�MQQMKVEXIH�XS�4EPIWXMRI�EW�GSQTEVIH�XS�RIEVP]�E�QMPPMSR�.I[W�[LS�MQQMKVEXIH�XS�XLI�9RMXIH7XEXIW��1SWX�SJ�XLI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�LEH�RS�VIEPMWXMG�LSTI�SJ�IWXEF�PMWLMRK�E�.I[MWL�REXMSR�MR�4EPIWXMRI��%PXLSYKL�WSQI�.I[MWL�MRXIPPIGXYEPW�WYGL�EW�0IS�4MRWOIV��LEH�EHZSGEXIH�©EYXSIQERGMTEXMSRª�EW�IEVP]�EW������XLIVI�[EW�RS�TSPMXMGEP�QSZIQIRX�EHZSGEXMRK�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�YRXMP�RIEV�XLIIRH�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�MR�������[LIR�8LISHSVI�,IVP�SVKERMIH�XLI�JMVWX>MSRMWX�'SRKVIWW�MR�&EWIP��7[MXIVPERH�

8LI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�TVSHYGIH�E�QERMJIWXS�MR�������MR�[LMGLXLI]�I\TPMGMXP]�VIJIVVIH�XS�XLI�VIGIRX�[EZI�SJ�TSKVSQW�EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�QSVIHMWXERX�EYXSW�HE�JI�XLEX�LEH�XLVIEXIRIH�XS�HIWXVS]�)YVSTIER�.I[V]��8LI]HMH�RSX�RIGIWWEVMP]�[ERX�E�WXEXI�FYX�©E�LSQI�MR�SYV�GSYRXV]�ª�TIVLETW�E©WXEXI�[MXLMR�E�PEVKIV�WXEXI�ª�[LIVI�XLI]�GSYPH�LEZI�XLIMV�©GMZMP�ERH�TSPMXMGEPVMKLXWª�ERH�GSYPH�EPWS�©LIPT�SYV�FVSXLIV�-WLQEIP�MR�XLI�XMQI�SJ�LMW�RIIH�ª

0MOI�XLI�.I[W�[LS�WSYKLX�VIJYKI�MR�%QIVMGE��QSWX�SJ�XLI�.I[W�[LSJMVWX�VIXYVRIH�XS�>MSR�[IVI�WMQTP]�PSSOMRK�JSV�E�TPEGI�XS�PMZI�MR�TIEGI�[MXLSYX�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�ERH�[MXLSYX�TL]WMGEP�XLVIEXW�XS�XLIMV�WYVZMZEP��8LI]GIVXEMRP]�LEH�XLEX�VMKLX��4EPIWXMRI��XLI�PERH�SJ�XLIMV�JSVIFIEVW��WIIQIH�XS�FIER�ETTVSTVMEXI�TPEGI�JSV�WIZIVEP�MQTSVXERX�VIEWSRW��MRGPYHMRK�XLEX�XLIVI�LEWEP[E]W�FIIR�E�WMKRMJMGERX�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�

,MWXSVMERW�FIPMIZI�XLEX�XLI�,IFVI[W�EVVMZIH�MR�TVIWIRX�HE]�-WVEIP�WSQI�XMQI�MR�XLI�WIGSRH�QMPPIRRMYQ�&�'�)�9RHIV�.SWLYE��ERH�PEXIV�/MRK�(EZMHERH�LMW�WYGGIWWSVW��MRHITIRHIRX�,IFVI[�OMRKHSQW�I\MWXIH��©*SV�QSVI�XLERSRI�XLSYWERH�WM\�LYRHVIH�]IEVW�XLI�.I[W�JSVQIH�XLI�QEMR�WIXXPIH�TSTYPE�XMSR�SJ�?[LEX�XLI�6SQERW�PEXIV�GEPPIHA�4EPIWXMRI�ª�EGGSVHMRK�XS�LMWXSVMER1EVXMR�+MPFIVX��%JXIV�GSRUYIWX�F]�XLI�&EF]PSRMERW��4IVWMERW��ERH�+VIIOW�ER�MRHITIRHIRX�.I[MWL�OMRKHSQ�[EW�VIZMZIH�MR�����&�'�)���FYX�6SQI�XSSOIJJIGXMZI�GSRXVSP�MR�XLI�RI\X�GIRXYV]��8LI�6SQERW�WYTTVIWWIH�.I[MWLVIZSPXW�MR����'�)�ERH�����'�)���ERH�.YHIE�[EW�VIREQIH�4EPIWXMRI��MR�SVHIV

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 26: The Case For Israel

��

Page 27: The Case For Israel

XS�HI�.YHEMI�MX��XLI�6SQERW�VIREQIH�MX�EJXIV�XLI�IEVPMIV�GSEWXEP�MRLEFMXERXW�XLI�4LMPMWXMRIW��*VSQ�XLIR�SR��HIWTMXI�VITIEXIH�IJJSVXW�F]�XLI�6SQERW��XLI'VYWEHIVW��ERH�WSQI�1YWPMQW�XS�QEOI�4EPIWXMRI�IQTX]�SJ�.I[W��XLSYWERHWSJ�.I[W�QEREKIH�XS�VIQEMR�MR�MXW�LSP]�GMXMIW��IWTIGMEPP]�.IVYWEPIQ��7EJEH�8MFIVMEW��ERH�,IFVSR��8LIVI�[IVI�EPWS�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMXMIW�MR�+EE�6EJEL��%WLOIPSR��'EIWEVIE��.EJJE��%GVI��ERH�.IVMGLS�

%QSRK�XLI�.I[W�[LS�PMZIH�MR�.IVMGLS�HYVMRK�XLI�WIZIRXL�GIRXYV]�[IVIVIJYKIIW�JVSQ�1YLEQQEH¬W�FPSSH]�QEWWEGVI�SJ�X[S�%VEFMER�.I[MWLXVMFIW��8LI�.I[W�SJ�/LEMFEV�LEH�PMZIH�TIEGIJYPP]�EQSRK�XLIMV�%VEF�RIMKL�FSVW�YRXMP�XLI�TVSTLIX�1YLEQQEH�©ZMWMXIH�YTSR�LMW�FIEXIR�IRIQ]�MRLY�QER�EXVSGMXMIW�ª�QEWWEGVMRK�.I[MWL�QIR��[SQIR��ERH�GLMPHVIR��8LI�.I[WSJ�/LEMFEV�©LEH�TVMHIH�XLIQWIPZIW�SR�XLI�TYVMX]�SJ�XLIMV�JEQMP]�PMJI��RS[XLIMV�[SQIR�ERH�HEYKLXIVW�?XLI�SRIW�[LS�[IVI�WTEVIH�I\IGYXMSRA�[IVIHMWXVMFYXIH�EQSRK�ERH�GEVVMIH�E[E]�F]�XLI�GSRUYIVSVW�ª�8LSWI�.I[W�[LSQEREKIH�XS�IWGETI�XLI�W[SVH�SJ�XLI�TVSTLIX�[IVI�JSVFMHHIR�XS�VIQEMR�SRXLI�%VEF�4IRMRWYPE��TYVWYERX�XS�XLI�TVSTLIX¬W�GSQQERH��©2IZIV�HS�X[SVIPMKMSRW�I\MWX�MR�%VEFME�ª� 1ER]�WIXXPIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI��NSMRMRK�.I[MWLVIJYKIIW�JVSQ�TSWX�6SQER�'LVMWXMER�STTVIWWMSR�

8LI�'VYWEHIVW�QEWWEGVIH�XLSYWERHW�SJ�.I[W�EPSRK�[MXL�1YWPMQW�MR�XLIIPIZIRXL�GIRXYV]��FYX�WSSR�XLIVIEJXIV�.I[W�JVSQ�*VERGI��)RKPERH��ERH�PEXIV7TEMR��0MXLYERME��4SVXYKEP��7MGMP]��7EVHMRME��6LSHIW��ERH�2ETPIW�IWXEFPMWLIHGIRXIVW�SJ�.I[MWL�PIEVRMRK�ERH�GSQQIVGI��*VSQ�XLMW�XMQI�SR��4EPIWXMRI[EW�RIZIV�[MXLSYX�E�WMKRMJMGERX�ERH�[IPP�HSGYQIRXIH�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI��&]XLI�XMQI�XLI�3XXSQER�8YVOW�SGGYTMIH�4EPIWXMRI�MR�������ETTVS\MQEXIP]�������.I[W�PMZIH�MR�XLI�7EJEH�VIKMSR�EPSRI��-R�XLI�WM\XIIRXL�GIRXYV]�EGGSVHMRK�XS�&VMXMWL�VITSVXW��©EW�QER]�EW��������.I[Wª�PMZIH�MR�7EJEH�[LMGL�[EW�©E�GIRXIV�SJ�VEFFMRMGEP�PIEVRMRK�ª��1ER]�QSVI�.I[W�PMZIH�MR.IVYWEPIQ��,IFVSR��%GVI��ERH�SXLIV�PSGEXMSRW��.IVYWEPIQ��MR�JEGX��LEW�LEHE�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]�WMRGI�XLI�JMVWX�TSTYPEXMSR�JMKYVIW�[IVI�KEXLIVIH�MR�XLIRMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]��ERH��EGGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�&VMXMWL�GSRWYP�MR�.IVYWEPIQ��XLI1YWPMQW�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ�©WGEVGIP]�I\GIIH?IHA�SRI�UYEVXIV�SJ�XLI�[LSPI�TST�YPEXMSR�ª��.IVYWEPIQ�[EW�E�TVIHSQMRERXP]�.I[MWL�GMX]�[IPP�FIJSVI�XLI�*MVWX%PM]EL��&]�XLI�QMHHPI�SJ�XLI�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV] XLMVX]�]IEVW�FIJSVI�XLI*MVWX�%PM]EL�SJ�)YVSTIER�.I[W .I[W�EPWS�GSRWXMXYXIH�E�WMKRMJMGERX�TVIW�IRGI��SJXIR�E�TPYVEPMX]�SV�QENSVMX]��MR�7EJEH��8MFIVMEW��ERH�WIZIVEP�SXLIVGMXMIW�ERH�XS[RW���8IP�%ZMZ�LEW�FIIR�E�TVIHSQMRERXP]�.I[MWL�GMX]�WMRGI)YVSTIER�.I[W�JSYRHIH�MX�SR�WERH�HYRIW�MR������

4EPIWXMRI�VIQEMRIH�E�GIRXIV�SJ�.I[MWL�PIEVRMRK��TMIX]��ERH�Q]WXMGMWQXLVSYKLSYX�XLI�EKIW��)YVSTIER�.I[W�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�VIPMKMSYWMRWXMXYXMSRW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�ERH�TVE]IH�HEMP]�JSV�E�VIXYVR�XS�>MSR��[LMGL�[EWSVMKMREPP]�E�VIPMKMSYW��VEXLIV�XLER�E�TSPMXMGEP��XIVQ��LIRGI�MXW�VIGYVVMRKQIRXMSR�MR�'LVMWXMER�WSYVGIW ��%PXLSYKL�QSWX�SJ�XLI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX%PM]EL�[IVI�WIGYPEV�XS�XLI�GSVI��XLI�PSRKMRK�JSV�>MSR�XVERWGIRHIH�XLISPSK]

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 28: The Case For Israel

ERH�[EW�ER�MQTSVXERX�EWTIGX�SJ�.I[MWL�LMWXSV]��.I[W�[LS�PMZIH�SYXWMHI�SJ4EPIWXMRI�[IVI�VIJIVVIH�XS�EW�XLI�HMEWTSVE�SV�XLI�I\MPIW��8LI�.I[MWL�TISTPIRIZIV�EFERHSRIH�XLIMV�GPEMQ�XS�VIXYVR�XS�XLI�PERH�JVSQ�[LMGL�WS�QER]�SJXLIMV�ERGIWXSVW�LEH�FIIR�JSVGMFP]�HVMZIR�

;IPP�FIJSVI�XLI�JMVWX�)YVSTIER�>MSRMWXW�EVVMZIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI��VIPMKMSYWP]MRWTMVIH�TSKVSQW�ERH�SXLIV�JSVQW�SJ�ZMSPIRGI�ZMGXMQMIH�PSGEP�.I[W�[LSWIERGIWXSVW�LEH�GEPPIH�4EPIWXMRI�LSQI�JSV�GIRXYVMIW��(YVMRK�XLI�)K]TXMERSGGYTEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�MR�XLI�����W��XLI�MRHMKIRSYW�.I[W�[IVI�TIVWIGYXIHQIVGMPIWWP]�F]�1YWPMQ�IEPSXW�JSV�RS�VIEWSR�SXLIV�XLER�VIPMKMSYW�FMKSXV]�-R�������.I[MWL�LSQIW�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�©[IVI�WEGOIH�ERH�XLIMV�[SQIR�ZMS�PEXIH�ª��0EXIV�XLEX�]IEV��.I[W�MR�,IFVSR�[IVI�QEWWEGVIH��8LI�&VMXMWL�GSR�WYP��;MPPMEQ�=SYRK��MR�E�VITSVX�XS�XLI�&VMXMWL�*SVIMKR�3JJMGI ���]IEVWFIJSVI�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL TEMRXIH�E�ZMZMH�ERH�GLMPPMRK�TMGXYVI�SJ�XLI�PMJI�SJXLI�.I[W�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ�MR������

-�XLMRO�MX�Q]�HYX]�XS�MRJSVQ�]SY�XLEX�XLIVI�LEW�FIIR�E�4VSGPEQEXMSR

MWWYIH�XLMW�[IIO�F]�XLI�+SZIVRSV�MR�XLI�.I[MWL�UYEVXIV XLEX�RS�.I[�MW

XS�FI�TIVQMXXIH�XS�TVE]�MR�LMW�S[R�LSYWI�YRHIV�TEMR�SJ�FIMRK�WIZIVIP]

TYRMWLIH WYGL�EW�[ERX�XS�TVE]�EVI�XS�KS�MRXS�XLI�7]REKSKYI�������

8LIVI�LEW�EPWS�FIIR�E�TYRMWLQIRX�MRJPMGXIH�SR�E�.I[�ERH�.I[IWW

QSWX�VIZSPXMRK�XS�LYQER�REXYVI��[LMGL�-�XLMRO�MX�MW�Q]�HYX]�XS�VIPEXI�

-R�XLI�IEVP]�TEVX�SJ�XLMW�[IIO��E�,SYWI�[EW�IRXIVIH�MR�XLI�.I[MWL

5YEVXIV��ERH�E�VSFFIV]�[EW�GSQQMXXIH XLI�,SYWI�[EW�MR�UYEVERXMRI

ERH�XLI�KYEVHMER�[EW�E�.I[ LI�[EW�XEOIR�FIJSVI�XLI�+SZIVRSV LI

HIRMIH�LEZMRK�ER]�ORS[PIHKI�SJ�XLI�XLMIJ�SV�XLI�GMVGYQWXERGIW��-R�SVHIV

XS�GSQTIP�LMQ�XS�GSRJIWW��LI�[EW�PEMH�HS[R�ERH�FIEXIR��ERH�EJXIV[EVHW

MQTVMWSRIH��8LI�JSPPS[MRK�HE]�LI�[EW�EKEMR�FVSYKLX�FIJSVI�XLI�+SZIV�

RSV��[LIR�LI�WXMPP�HIGPEVIH�LMW�MRRSGIRGI��,I�[EW�XLIR�FYVRIH�[MXL�E�LSX

MVSR�SZIV�LMW�JEGI��ERH�ZEVMSYW�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�FSH] ERH�FIEXIR�SR�XLI

PS[IV�TEVXW�SJ�LMW�FSH]�XS�XLI�I\XIRX�XLEX�XLI�JPIWL�LYRK�MR�TMIGIW�JVSQ

LMQ��8LI�JSPPS[MRK�HE]�XLI�TSSV�GVIEXYVI�HMIH��,I�[EW�E�]SYRK�.I[�SJ

7EPSRMGE�EFSYX����]IEVW�SJ�EKI [LS�LEH�FIIR�LIVI�FYX�E�ZIV]�WLSVX

XMQI��LI�LEH�SRP]�XLI�[IIO�FIJSVI�FIIR�ETTP]MRK�XS�IRXIV�Q]�WIVZMGI�

%�]SYRK�QER E�.I[ LEZMRK�E�*VIRGL�TEWWTSVX�[EW�EPWS�WYW�

TIGXIH LI�JPIH LMW�GLEVEGXIV�[EW�ORS[R�XS�FI�ER�MRHMJJIVIRX�SRI LMW

QSXLIV��ER�EKIH�[SQER��[EW�XEOIR�YRHIV�WYWTMGMSR�SJ�GSRGIEPMRK�LIV

WSR 7LI�[EW�XMIH�YT�ERH�FIEXIR�MR�XLI�QSWX�FVYXEP�[E]�������

-�QYWX�WE]�-�EQ�WSVV]�ERH�EQ�WYVTVMWIH�XLEX�XLI�+SZIVRSV�GSYPH�LEZI

EGXIH�WS�WEZEKI�E�TEVX JSV�GIVXEMRP]�[LEX�-�LEZI�WIIR�SJ�LMQ��-�WLSYPH

LEZI�XLSYKLX�LMQ�WYTIVMSV�XS�WYGL�[ERXSR�MRLYQERMX] FYX�MX�[EW�E

.I[ [MXLSYX�JVMIRHW�SV�TVSXIGXMSR MX�WIVZIW�[IPP�XS�WLS[��XLEX�MX�MW�RSX

[MXLSYX�VIEWSR�XLEX�XLI�TSSV�.I[��IZIR�MR�XLI�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]��PMZIW

JVSQ�HE]�XS�HE]�MR�XIVVSV�SJ�LMW�PMJI���

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 29: The Case For Israel

��

Page 30: The Case For Israel

2SV�GSYPH�XLI�.I[�WIIO�VIHVIWW��EW�XLI�VITSVX�SFWIVZIH�

0MOI�XLI�QMWIVEFPI�HSK�[MXLSYX�ER�S[RIV�LI�MW�OMGOIH�F]�SRI�FIGEYWI�LI

GVSWWIW�LMW�TEXL��ERH�GYJJIH�F]�ERSXLIV�FIGEYWI�LI�GVMIW�SYX XS�WIIO

VIHVIWW�LI�MW�EJVEMH��PIWX�MX�FVMRK�[SVWI�YTSR�LMQ��LI�XLMROW�MX�FIXXIV�XS

IRHYVI�XLER�XS�PMZI�MR�XLI�I\TIGXEXMSR�SJ�LMW�GSQTPEMRX�FIMRK�VIZIRKIH

YTSR�LMQ���

7IZIVEP�]IEVW�PEXIV��XLI�WEQI�GSRWYP�EXXVMFYXIH�XLI�TPMKLX�SJ�XLI�.I[�MR.IVYWEPIQ�XS�©XLI�FPMRH�LEXVIH�ERH�MKRSVERX�TVINYHMGI�SJ�E�JEREXMGEP�TST�YPEGI�ª�GSYTPIH�[MXL�ER�MREFMPMX]�SJ�XLI�TSZIVX]�WXVMGOIR�.I[MWL�GSQQY�RMX]�XS�HIJIRH�MXWIPJ�IMXLIV�TSPMXMGEPP]�SV�TL]WMGEPP]���8LMW�[EW�LEPJ�E�GIRXYV]FIJSVI�XLI�EHZIRX�SJ�QSHIVR�>MSRMWQ�ERH�XLI�EVVMZEP�SJ�)YVSTIER�.I[W��-X[EW�TYVI�VIPMKMSYW�FMKSXV]�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�E�REXMZI�TSTYPEXMSR�XLEX�LEHPMZIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI�JSV�GIRXYVMIW�ERH�LEH�NYWX�EW�QYGL�VMKLX�XS�FI�XLIVI��ERHXS�FI�XVIEXIH�JEMVP]��EW�ER]�%VEFW�SV�1YWPMQW�

%W�[I�WLEPP�WII��MX�[EW�SRP]�EJXIV�)YVSTIER�.I[W�FIKER�XS�NSMR�XLIMV7ITLEVHMG�GSYWMRW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�XLIWI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�EFPI�XSQSYRX�ER]�OMRH�SJ�HIJIRWI�EKEMRWX�XLI�VIPMKMSYWP]�MRWTMVIH�ZMSPIRGI�XLEXQEHI�PMJI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�WS�HMJJMGYPX��'IVXEMRP]�XLI�MRHMKIRSYW�.I[W�SJ�4EPIW�XMRI��[LS�LEH�EX�PIEWX�EW�QYGL�VMKLX�XS�FI�XLIVI�EW�ER]�1YWPMQ�SV�'LVMWX�MER��[IVI�IRXMXPIH�XS�FI�TVSXIGXIH�EKEMRWX�VIPMKMSYW�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�ERHZMGXMQMEXMSR��ERH�XLIMV�)YVSTIER�GSVIPMKMSRMWXW�LEH�XLI�VMKLX�XS�SJJIVXLIQ�WYGL�TVSXIGXMSR�F]�MRXVSHYGMRK�MRWXMXYXMSRW�SJ�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�

%PXLSYKL�XLI�.I[W�[LS�MQQMKVEXIH�JVSQ�)EWXIVR�)YVSTI�XS�4EPIWXMRI[IVI�WMQMPEV�MR�QER]�[E]W�XS�XLI�.I[W�[LS�GEQI�XS�%QIVMGE�MR�XLEX�FSXLKVSYTW�[IVI�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�)YVSTIER�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�ERH�[IVI�WIIOMRK�RI[PMZIW�MR�E�TPEGI�JVII�JVSQ�SPH�FMKSXVMIW��XLI]�[IVI�HMJJIVIRX�MR�XLEX�WSQI�SJXLSWI�[LS�QSZIH�XS�-WVEIP�LEH�MHISPSKMGEP�VIEWSRW�JSV�XLIMV�GLSMGI�SJ�ERI[�LSQI��[LIVIEW�XLSWI�[LS�GEQI�XS�%QIVMGE�TMGOIH�©XLI�+SPHIRE1IHMREª��XLI�KSPHIR�REXMSR �PEVKIP]�SR�XLI�FEWMW�SJ�TVEGXMGEP�GSRWMHIVE�XMSRW��WYGL�EW�IGSRSQMG�STTSVXYRMX]��TSPMXMGEP�JVIIHSQ��VIPMKMSYW�IUYEPMX]�ERH�JEQMP]�YRMJMGEXMSR �

%QIVMGER�.I[W�QSZIH�MRXS�.I[MWL�RIMKLFSVLSSHW��IWXEFPMWLIH�.I[MWLGSQQYREP�MRWXMXYXMSRW��ERH�GSRXMRYIH�XS�WTIEO�=MHHMWL�EW�XLIMV�GLMPHVIRQEWXIVIH�)RKPMWL��%PXLSYKL�XLI]�I\TIVMIRGIH�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�ERH�I\TPSMXE�XMSR��EW�HMH�SXLIV�MQQMKVERX�KVSYTW��XLI]�IZIRXYEPP]�EWWMQMPEXIH�MRXS�XLIQEMRWXVIEQ�IGSRSQMGEPP]��TSPMXMGEPP]��ERH�IZIR�WSGMEPP]�

8LI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�JSYRH�E�ZIV]�HMJJIVIRX�VIEPMX]�MR�PEXI�RMRI�XIIRXL�GIRXYV]�4EPIWXMRI��8LI]�XSS�IWXEFPMWLIH�XLIMV�S[R�RIMKLFSVLSSHW�FYMPX�XLIMV�S[R�GSQQYREP�MRWXMXYXMSRW��ERH�VIZMZIH�XLI�ERGMIRX�PERKYEKISJ�,IFVI[��&YX�EWWMQMPEXMSR��IZIR�JSV�XLSWI�.I[W�SV�%VEFW�[LS�[ERXIH�MX�[EW�RSX�JIEWMFPI��3VKERMIH�KERKW�SJ�%VEFW�EXXEGOIH�YRTVSXIGXIH�ERH

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 31: The Case For Israel

YREVQIH�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRXW��ERH�IJJSVXW�[IVI�QEHI�XS�TVIZIRX�EHHMXMSREP)YVSTIER�.I[W�JVSQ�WIIOMRK�EW]PYQ�MR�4EPIWXMRI��%PXLSYKL�WSQI�%VEFPIEHIVW�[IPGSQIH�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�ERH�WE[�XLIQ�EW�E�TSXIRXMEP�WSYVGISJ�IQTPS]QIRX�JSV�PSGEP�%VEFW��QER]�[ERXIH�XS�HMWGSYVEKI�ER]�MQQMKVE�XMSR�F]�RSR�1YWPMQW�SV�RSR�%VEFW��9RPMOI�MR�%QIVMGE��[LIVI�.I[MWLMQQMKVERXW�GSYPH�IZIRXYEPP]�PMZI�ERH�[SVO�EPSRKWMHI�RSR�.I[MWL�%QIVM�GERW��MR�4EPIWXMRI�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�LEH�XS�PMZI�MR�WITEVEXI�GSQQYRMXMIWERH�GYPXMZEXI�XLIMV�S[R�PERH��%W�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�[EW�PEXIV�XS�GSR�GPYHI��EWWMQMPEXMSR�[EW�RSX�JIEWMFPI�FIGEYWI�SJ�ERXM�.I[MWL�TVINYHMGI�WXMQ�YPEXIH�F]�1YWPMQ�PIEHIVW�

8LI�MRMXMEP�TLEWI�SJ�XLI�]MWLYZ�©VIXYVRª�SV�©GSQQYRMX]ª �[EW�XLYWQSVI�SJ�ER�MQQMKVEXMSR�SJ�VIJYKIIW�XLER�E�HIXIVQMRIH�TSPMXMGEP�SVREXMSREPMWXMG�QSZIQIRX��EPXLSYKL�XLI�WIIHW�SJ�TSPMXMGEP�>MSRMWQ�[IVI�GIV�XEMRP]�TPERXIH�HYVMRK�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL��ERH�TIVLETW�IZIR�IEVPMIV �F]�XLSWI[LSWI�HIGMWMSR�[EW�QSXMZEXIH��EX�PIEWX�MR�TEVX��F]�E�HIWMVI�XS�VIXYVR�XS>MSR��%X�EFSYX�XLI�XMQI�XLI�JMVWX�[EZI�SJ�)YVSTIER�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[IVIMQQMKVEXMRK�XS�4EPIWXMRI��SXLIV�[EZIW�SJ�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�1YWPMQGSYRXVMIW�WYGL�EW�=IQIR��-VEU��8YVOI]��ERH�2SVXL�%JVMGE�[IVI�EPWS�FIKMR�RMRK�XS�EVVMZI�MR�4EPIWXMRI��8LIWI�%VEF�.I[W�LEH�RS�ORS[PIHKI�SJ�TSPMXMGEP>MSRMWQ��8LI]�[IVI�WMQTP]�VIXYVRMRK�LSQI�XS�IWGETI�TIVWIGYXMSR��LEZMRKPIEVRIH�XLEX�XLI�3XXSQER�)QTMVI�[EW�TIVQMXXMRK��SV�GPSWMRK�MXW�I]IW�XS WSQI�.I[MWL�MQQMKVEXMSR�MRXS�4EPIWXMRI�

&EWIH�SR�XLI�EGXYEP�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[LS�MQQMKVEXIH�XS4EPIWXMRI��XLI�GPEMQ�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�E�GSPSRMEP�SV�MQTIVMEPMWX�WXEXI�MW�WS�JEV�JIXGLIH�XLEX�MX�WMQTP]�WIVZIW�XS�MPPYWXVEXI�LS[�PERKYEKI�MW�[MPPJYPP]�HMWXSVXIHMR�XLI�WIVZMGI�SJ�E�TEVXMWER�EKIRHE�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 32: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�)YVSTIER�.I[W�[LS�GEQI�XS�4EPIWXMRI�HMWTPEGIH�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�LEHPMZIH�XLIVI�JSV�GIRXYVMIW�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LI�.I[W�WXSPI�SYV�PERH��;LEX�IPWI�HS�]SY�[ERX�YW�XS�HS��NYWX�KS�E[E]#ª�1SLEQQEH�%FY�0EMPE��TVSJIWWSV�SJ�GSQTEVEXMZI�VIPMKMSR�EX�%P�%LEV9RMZIVWMX]�MR�'EMVS��MR�XLI�GSRXI\X�SJ�HIJIRHMRK�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�EW�©QEVX]VWª�

©8LI�.I[W�LEXI�XLI�%VEFW��8LI]�LEXI�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�FIGEYWI�XLI�.I[WWXSPI�XLI�PERH�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�4EPIWXMRI��%�XLMIJ�LEXIW�XLI�S[RIV�SJ�XLIVMKLX�ª��©-VEUM�4VIWMHIRX�7E]W�8IP�%ZMZ�&SQFMRK�«.YWX�+VIEX¬��'EFMRIX)RHSVWIW�3MP�)\TSVX�,EPX�ª�VIPIEWIH�.YRI��������

©>MSRMWXW�������GSRGIMZIH�XLIMV�TPER�JSV�E�GSPSRMEP�WIXXPIV�WXEXI�MR�4EPIW�XMRI��EW�XLI]�[IRX�EFSYX�I\IGYXMRK�XLMW�TPER�SR�XLI�FEGOW�SJ�MQTIVMEPMWXTS[IVW [MXL�[EVW��QEWWEGVIW�ERH�IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK ERH��PEXIV��EW�XLI]LEZI�TIVWMWXIH�MR�XLIMV�TPERW�XS�HMWTSWWIWW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�SJ�XLI�PEWX�JVEK�QIRXW�SJ�XLIMV�VMKLXW�ERH�PIKEG]�[LSWI�'EREERMXI�VSSXW�[IVI�QSVIERGMIRX�XLER�-WEMEL��)IOMIP��(EZMH�ERH�1SWIW�ª��1��7LELMH�%PEQ�

��

(MH�)YVSTIER�.I[W�(MWTPEGI�4EPIWXMRMERW#

Page 33: The Case For Israel

©2S[�MR�XLMW�VIWTIGX�-�[ERX�XS�WE]�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI�XLI�MRHMKI�RSYW�TISTPI�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��8LI]�EVI�HIWGIRHERXW�SJ�XLI�7IQMXMG�XVMFIW�XLEXGEQI�ERH�MRLEFMXIH�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVMXSV]�WMRGI�XLSYWERHW�ERH�XLSYWERHW�SJ]IEVW��GIVXEMRP]�PSRK�FIJSVI�%FVELEQ�WIX�JSSX�SR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVMXSV]�������%RH�-�WE]�XLEX�[I�4EPIWXMRMERW��[I�EVI�XLI�HIWGIRHERXW�ERH�MRHMKIRSYWTISTPI�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��������2S[�[I�GSRGIHI�XLEX�XLI�.I[W��XLI�-WVEIPMW�LEZILMWXSVMGEP�VIPEXMSRW�XS�4EPIWXMRI��EPXLSYKL�RSX�EW�PSRK�ERH�RSX�EW�JYRHE�QIRXEP�EW�SYV�VIPEXMSRW�FIMRK�XLI�MRHMKIRSYW�TISTPI�ª��,EMHIV�%FHIP7LEJM��XLIR�LIEH�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TIEGI�XEPOW�HIPIKEXMSR��RS[�ER�MRHI�TIRHIRX�EGXMZMWX�

©7S�XLIVI�EVI�X[S�REXMSREP�KVSYTW�[LMGL�GPEMQ�REXMSREP�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��3RI�KVSYT�MW�XLI�MRHMKIRSYW�TSTYPEXMSR��SV�[LEX¬W�PIJX�SJMX E�PSX�SJ�MX¬W�FIIR�I\TIPPIH�SV�HVMZIR�SYX�SV�JPIH��8LI�SXLIV�KVSYT�MW�XLI.I[MWL�WIXXPIVW�[LS�GEQI�MR��SVMKMREPP]�JVSQ�)YVSTI��PEXIV�JVSQ�SXLIV�TEVXWSJ�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�ERH�WSQI�SXLIV�TPEGIW��7S�XLIVI�EVI�X[S�KVSYTW��XLIMRHMKIRSYW�TSTYPEXMSR�ERH�XLI�MQQMKVERXW�ERH�XLIMV�HIWGIRHERXW�ª��2SEQ'LSQWO]�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�4EPIWXMRI�XS�[LMGL�XLI�)YVSTIER�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�MQQMKVEXIH[EW�ZEWXP]�YRHIVTSTYPEXIH��ERH�XLI�PERH�SRXS�[LMGL�XLI�.I[W�QSZIH�[EW��MRJEGX��FSYKLX�TVMQEVMP]�JVSQ�EFWIRXII�PERHPSVHW�ERH�VIEP�IWXEXI�WTIGYPEXSVW�

-R�EHHMXMSR�XS�4EPIWXMRI�FIMRK�ER�ETTVSTVMEXI�TPEGI�JSV�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIWFIGEYWI�SJ�MXW�GPSWI�GSRRIGXMSR�XS�XLIMV�LMWXSV]�ERH�MHISPSK]��MX�[EW�EPWSWIIR�EW�ETTVSTVMEXI�FIGEYWI�SJ�XLI�HIQSKVETLMGW�SJ�XLI�PERH�XS�[LMGL�XLI][IVI�QSZMRK��SV��MR�XLIMV�[SVH��VIXYVRMRK�

1EVO�8[EMR��[LS�ZMWMXIH�4EPIWXMRI�MR�������SJJIVIH�XLMW�HIWGVMTXMSR�

7XMVVMRK�WGIRIW�������SGGYV�MR�XLI�ZEPPI]�?.IVIIPA�RS�QSVI��8LIVI�MW�RSX�E

WSPMXEV]�ZMPPEKI�XLVSYKLSYX�MXW�[LSPI�I\XIRX RSX�JSV�XLMVX]�QMPIW�MR�IMXLIV

HMVIGXMSR��8LIVI�EVI�X[S�SV�XLVII�WQEPP�GPYWXIVW�SJ�&IHSYMR�XIRXW��FYX�RSX

E�WMRKPI�TIVQERIRX�LEFMXEXMSR��3RI�QE]�VMHI�XIR�QMPIW�LIVIEFSYXW�ERH

RSX�WII�XIR�LYQER�FIMRKW��������'SQI�XS�+EPMPII�JSV�XLEX�������XLIWI�YRTIS�

TPIH�HIWIVXW��XLIWI�VYWX]�QSYRHW�SJ�FEVVIRRIWW��XLEX�RIZIV��RIZIV��RIZIV

HS�WLEOI�XLI�KPEVI�JVSQ�XLIMV�LEVWL�SYXPMRIW��ERH�JEHI�ERH�JEMRX�MRXS

ZEKYI�TIVWTIGXMZI��XLEX�QIPERGLSP]�VYMR�SJ�'ETIVREYQ��XLMW�WXYTMH�ZMPPEKI

SJ�8MFIVMEW��WPYQFIVMRK�YRHIV�MXW�WM\�JYRIVIEP�TEPQW��������;I�VIEGLIH

8EFSV�WEJIP]��������;I�RIZIV�WE[�E�LYQER�FIMRK�SR�XLI�[LSPI�VSYXI�

2EEVIXL�MW�JSVPSVR��������.IVMGLS�XLI�EGGYVWIH�PMIW�MR�E�QSPHIVMRK�VYMR

XSHE]��IZIR�EW�.SWLYE¬W�QMVEGPI�PIJX�MX�QSVI�XLER�XLVII�XLSYWERH�]IEVW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 34: The Case For Israel

EKS��&IXLPILIQ�ERH�&IXLER]��MR�XLIMV�TSZIVX]�ERH�XLIMV�LYQMPMEXMSR��LEZI

RSXLMRK�EFSYX�XLIQ�RS[�XS�VIQMRH�SRI�XLEX�XLI]�SRGI�ORI[�XLI�LMKL

LSRSV�SJ�XLI�7EZMSV¬W�TVIWIRGI��XLI�LEPPS[IH�WTSX�[LIVI�XLI�WLITLIVHW

[EXGLIH�XLIMV�JPSGOW�F]�RMKLX��ERH�[LIVI�XLI�ERKIPW�WERK��©4IEGI�SR

IEVXL��KSSH�[MPP�XS�QIR�ª�MW�YRXIRERXIH�F]�ER]�PMZMRK�GVIEXYVI��������

&IXLWEMHE�ERH�'LSVMR�LEZI�ZERMWLIH�JVSQ�XLI�IEVXL��ERH�XLI�©HIWIVX

TPEGIWª�VSYRH�EFSYX�XLIQ��[LIVI�XLSYWERHW�SJ�QIR�SRGI�PMWXIRIH�XS�XLI

7EZMSV¬W�ZSMGI�ERH�EXI�XLI�QMVEGYPSYW�FVIEH��WPIIT�MR�XLI�LYWL�SJ�E�WSPM�

XYHI�XLEX�MW�MRLEFMXIH�SRP]�F]�FMVHW�SJ�TVI]�ERH�WOYPOMRK�JS\IW��

3XLIV�XVEZIPIVW�VIGSVHIH�WMQMPEV�EGGSYRXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�TVMSV�XS�XLI�EVVMZEP�SJXLI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL��[LS�FIKER�XLI�TVSGIWW�SJ�VIZMXEPMMRK�XLI�PERHERH�MRGVIEWMRK�MXW�TSTYPEXMSR�F]�GVIEXMRK�NSFW�ERH�ER�MRJVEWXVYGXYVI�

8,)�4633*

8LIVI�LEZI�FIIR�X[S�GSQTIXMRK�Q]XLSPSKMIW�EFSYX�4EPIWXMRI�GMVGE������8LI�I\XVIQMWX�.I[MWL�Q]XLSPSK]��PSRK�WMRGI�EFERHSRIH��[EW�XLEX�4EPIWXMRI[EW�©E�PERH�[MXLSYX�TISTPI��JSV�E�TISTPI�[MXLSYX�E�PERH�ª��8LMW�TLVEWI�[EWEGXYEPP]�GSMRIH�F]�XLI�&VMXMWL�PSVH�7LEJXIWFYV]�MR�LMW������QIQSMV� �8LII\XVIQMWX�4EPIWXMRMER�Q]XLSPSK]��[LMGL�LEW�FIGSQI�QSVI�IQFIHHIH�[MXLXMQI��MW�XLEX�MR������XLIVI�[EW�E�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI��WSQI�IZIR�WE]�E�4EPIW�XMRMER�REXMSR�XLEX�[EW�HMWTPEGIH�F]�XLI�>MSRMWX�MRZEWMSR�

8LI�VIEPMX]��EW�YWYEP��PMIW�WSQI[LIVI�MR�FIX[IIR��4EPIWXMRI�[EW�GIVXEMRP]RSX�E�PERH�IQTX]�SJ�EPP�TISTPI��-X�MW�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�VIGSRWXVYGX�XLI�HIQS�KVETLMGW�SJ�XLI�EVIE�[MXL�ER]�HIKVII�SJ�TVIGMWMSR��WMRGI�GIRWYW�HEXE�JSV�XLEXXMQI�TIVMSH�EVI�RSX�VIPMEFPI��ERH�QSWX�EXXIQTXW�EX�VIGSRWXVYGXMSR F]FSXL�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH�-WVEIPM�WSYVGIW WIIQ�XS�LEZI�E�TSPMXMGEP�EKIRHE��&YXVSYKL�IWXMQEXIW�EVI�TSWWMFPI��8LI�IRXMVI�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��HIJMRIHJSV�XLIWI�TYVTSWIW�EW�GYVVIRX�-WVEIP��XLI�;IWX�&ERO��ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT [EW�TVSFEFP]�MR�XLI�RIMKLFSVLSSH�SJ�LEPJ�E�QMPPMSR�EX�XLI�XMQI�SJ�XLI�*MVWX%PM]EL�MR�XLI�IEVP]�����W��8LEX�WEQI�EVIE�XSHE]�WYTTSVXW�E�TSTYPEXMSR�SJQSVI�XLER����QMPPMSR��ERH�MW�GETEFPI�SJ�WYWXEMRMRK�E�JEV�PEVKIV�TSTYPEXMSR�8LI�EVIE�XLEX�[EW�IZIRXYEPP]�TEVXMXMSRIH�MRXS�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�F]�XLI9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�MR������GSRXEMRIH�SRP]�E�JVEGXMSR�SJ�XLEX�RYQFIV��[MXLIWXMQEXIW�ZEV]MRK�FIX[IIR���������ERH����������%W�E�KISKVETLMG�IRXMX]�4EPIWXMRI�LEH�YRGIVXEMR�ERH�IZIV�WLMJXMRK�FSYRHEVMIW��4EPIWXMRI�[EW�RSX�ETSPMXMGEP�IRXMX]�MR�ER]�QIERMRKJYP�WIRWI��9RHIV�3XXSQER�VYPI��[LMGL�TVI�ZEMPIH�FIX[IIR������ERH�������4EPIWXMRI�[EW�HMZMHIH�MRXS�WIZIVEP�HMWXVMGXW�GEPPIHWERNEOW�8LIWIWERNEOW[IVI�TEVX�SJ�EHQMRMWXVEXMZI�YRMXW�GEPPIHZMPE]IXW�8LI�PEVKIWX�TSVXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�TEVX�SJ�XLI�ZMPE]IXSJ�7]VME�ERH[EW�KSZIVRIH�JVSQ�(EQEWGYW�F]�E�TEWLE��XLYW�I\TPEMRMRK�[L]�4EPIWXMRI[EW�GSQQSRP]�VIJIVVIH�XS�EW�WSYXLIVR�7]VME��*SPPS[MRK�E�XIR�]IEV�SGGY�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 35: The Case For Israel

TEXMSR�F]�)K]TX�MR�XLI�����W��4EPIWXMRI�[EW�HMZMHIH�MRXS�XLI�ZMPE]IXSJ&IMVYX��[LMGL�GSZIVIH�0IFERSR�ERH�XLI�RSVXLIVR�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��HS[RXS�[LEX�MW�RS[�8IP�%ZMZ ��ERH�XLI�MRHITIRHIRX�WERNEOSJ�.IVYWEPIQ��[LMGLGSZIVIH�VSYKLP]�JVSQ�.EJJE�XS�.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�WSYXL�XS�+EE�ERH�&I¬IV7LIZE��-X�MW�XLYW�YRGPIEV�[LEX�MX�[SYPH�QIER�XS�WE]�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW[IVI�XLI�TISTPI�[LS�SVMKMREPP]�TSTYPEXIH�XLI�©REXMSRª�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�

*YVXLIVQSVI��EFWIRXII�PERHS[RIVW�S[RIH�QYGL�SJ�XLI�PERH�XLEX�[EWIZIRXYEPP]�TEVXMXMSRIH�MRXS�-WVEIP��%GGSVHMRK�XS�PERH�TYVGLEWI�VIGSVHW�QER]�PMZIH�MR�&IMVYX�SV�(EQEWGYW��ERH�WSQI�[IVI�XE\�GSPPIGXSVW�ERH�QIV�GLERXW�PMZMRK�IPWI[LIVI��8LIWI�PERHPSVHW�[IVI�VIEP�IWXEXI�WTIGYPEXSVW�JVSQJSVIMKR�GSYRXVMIW�[LS�LEH�RS�GSRRIGXMSR�XS�XLI�PERH�ERH�[LS�SJXIRI\TPSMXIH�XLI�PSGEP�[SVOIVW�SV�JIPPELMR��0MOI�VIJYKIIW�MR�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�FSYKLX�PERH��QYGL�SJ�MX�RSREVEFPI��4EPIW�XMRMER�TVSTEKERHMWXW�LEZI�[MPHP]�I\EKKIVEXIH�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�%VEF�JEQMPMIWEGXYEPP]�HMWTPEGIH�F]�.I[MWL�PERH�TYVGLEWIW��&IRR]�1SVVMW�MW�ER�-WVEIPM�LMW�XSVMER�[LSWI�[VMXMRKW�LEZI�FIIR�GVMXMGMIH�F]�WSQI�JSV�XLIMV�©SRI�WMHIH�RIWW�������EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�ª�ERH�LI�MW�JVIUYIRXP]�GMXIH�F]�2SEQ�'LSQWO]�)H[EVH�7EMH��ERH�SXLIV�GVMXMGW�SJ�-WVEIP�EW�EQSRK�XLI�©RI[�LMWXSVMERWª[LS�HS�RSX�TVIWIRX�XLI�©>MSRMWX�PMRI�ª�7EMH�LEW�GLEVEGXIVMIH�1SVVMW��ERHSXLIV�©VIZMWMSRMWX�LMWXSVMERW�ª�EW�LEZMRK�©E�KIRYMRI�[MPP�XS�YRHIVWXERH�XLITEWX�ª�ERH�[LEX�XLI]�WE]�EFSYX�MX�MW�©[MXLSYX�E�HIWMVI�XS�PMI�SV�GSRGIEP�XLITEWXª LMKL�TVEMWI�MRHIIH�JVSQ�SRI�WS�LEVWLP]�GVMXMGEP�SJ�>MSRMWQ��1SVVMWLEW�FIIR�TVEMWIH�F]�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW&SSO�6IZMI[�JSV�LEZMRK�[VMXXIR©XLI�QSWX�WSTLMWXMGEXIH�ERH�RYERGIH�EGGSYRX�SJ�XLI�>MSRMWX§%VEF�GSR�JPMGX�ª�,I�WYQQEVMIW�XLI�LMWXSVMGEP�VIGSVH�EW�JSPPS[W��©,MWXSVMERW�LEZIGSRGPYHIH�XLEX�SRP]�«WIZIVEP�XLSYWERH¬�JEQMPMIW�[IVI�HMWTPEGIH�JSPPS[MRKPERH�WEPIW�XS�.I[W�FIX[IIR�XLI�����W�ERH�XLI�PEXI�����W�ª�8LMW�MW�E�JVEG�XMSR�SJ�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�TISTPI�HMWTPEGIH�F]�XLI�)K]TXMER�GSRWXVYGXMSR�SJXLI�%W[mR�(EQ��XLI�-VEUM�HMWTPEGIQIRX�SJ�XLI�1EVWL�%VEFW��ERH�SXLIVJSVGIH�QSZIQIRXW�F]�%VEF�KSZIVRQIRXW�SJ�JIPPS[�%VEFW�

)ZIR�]IEVW�PEXIV��[LIR�.I[MWL�PERH�TYVGLEWIW�[IVI�MRGVIEWMRK��MX�[EWJSYRH�XLEX�©XLI�UYERXMX]�SJ�%VEF�PERH�SJJIVIH�JSV�WEPI�[EW�JEV�MR�I\GIWW�SJXLI�.I[MWL�EFMPMX]�XS�TYVGLEWI�ª�%�TVSJIWWMSREP�EREP]WMW�SJ�PERH�TYVGLEWIWFIX[IIR������ERH������IWXEFPMWLIH�XLEX�XLVII�UYEVXIVW�SJ�XLI�TPSXW�TYV�GLEWIH�F]�.I[W�[IVI�JVSQ�QIKE�PERHS[RIVW�VEXLIV�XLER�XLSWI�[LS�[SVOIHXLI�WSMP���)ZIR�EW�TVS�4EPIWXMRMER�E�[VMXIV�EW�4VSJIWWSV�6EGLIH�/LEPMHMEGORS[PIHKIW�XLEX�XLIVI�[IVI�GSRWMHIVEFPI�PERH�WEPIW�F]�©EFWIRXII�PERHPSVHW�FSXL�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH�RSR�4EPIWXMRMER �ª�� (EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR��JSVQIVTVMQI�QMRMWXIV�SJ�-WVEIP��MRWXVYGXIH�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�RIZIV�XS�FY]�PERHFIPSRKMRK�XS�PSGEP�©JIPPELW�SV�[SVOIH�F]�XLIQ�ª��-�GLEPPIRKI�ER]SRI�QEO�MRK�XLI�GEWI�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�XS�TVSHYGI�ER]�SFNIGXMZI�HEXE JVSQ�GIRWYWVITSVXW��PERH�XVERWJIV�VIGSVHW��SV�HIQSKVETLMG�VITSVXW XLEX�GSRXVEHMGX�XLMWLMWXSVMGEP�VIEPMX]��2S�SRI�[MPP�FI�EFPI�XS�HS�WS��=IX�XLI�JEPWI�GPEMQ�GSRXMRYIW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 36: The Case For Israel

XS�FI�QEHI�XLEX�XLI�.I[W�WXSPI�XLI�PERH�JVSQ�PSGEP�%VEF�JIPPELMR��%�VIPEXIHGPEMQ��ERH�SRI�XLEX�MW�IUYEPP]�JEPWI��MW�XLEX�XLI�JI[�JIPPELMR�[LS�[IVI�HMW�TPEGIH�[IVI�EPP�PSGEP�%VEFW�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�ERH�[SVOIH�XLI�PERH�©YRMRXIV�VYTXIHP]�JSV������]IEVWª��¨XLEX�XLI]�[IVI�HIWGIRHERXW�SJ�MRHMKIRSYW%VEFW�©[LSWI�'EREERMXI�VSSXW�[IVI�QSVI�ERGMIRX�XLER�-WEMEL��)IOMIP�(EZMH��ERH�1SWIW�ª��

8LIVI�MW�GSRWMHIVEFPI�HMWTYXI�EFSYX�XLI�IXLRMGMX]�SJ�XLI�TISTPI�[LS[SVOIH�XLI�PERH�MR�[LEX�IZIRXYEPP]�FIGEQI�-WVEIP��1ER]�+VIIOW�[LS�JPIH1YWPMQ�VYPI�MR�XLIMV�LSQI�GSYRXV]�LEH�QSZIH�XS�4EPIWXMRI��&]�XLI�QMHHPISJ�XLI�IMKLXIIRXL�GIRXYV]��XLI�FMFPMGEP�TSVX�GMX]�SJ�.EJJE��JVSQ�[LIVI�.SRELFIKER�LMW�JEXIJYP�NSYVRI]��LEH�FIGSQI�E�XS[R�TSTYPEXIH�F]�8YVOW��%VEFW�+VIIOW��%VQIRMERW��ERH�SXLIVW��%�'LVMWXMER�LMWXSVMER�LEW�VITSVXIH�XLEXWIZIVEP�ZMPPEKIW�XLVSYKLSYX�4EPIWXMRI�©EVI�TSTYPEXIH�[LSPP]�F]�WIXXPIVWJVSQ�SXLIV�TSVXMSRW�SJ�XLI�8YVOMWL�)QTMVI�[MXLMR�XLI�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]�8LIVI�EVI�ZMPPEKIW�SJ�&SWRMERW��(VYIW��'MVGEWWMERW�ERH�)K]TXMERW�ª��8LI�����IHMXMSR�SJ�)RG]GPSTEIHME�&VMXERRMGEHIWGVMFIH�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ4EPIWXMRI�EW�GSQTVMWMRK�[MHIP]�HMJJIVMRK�©IXLRSPSKMGEPª�KVSYTW�WTIEOMRK©RS�PIWW�XLER�JMJX]�PERKYEKIW�ª�-X�[EW�HEYRXMRK�XLIVIJSVI�XS�©[VMXI�GSR�GMWIP]ª�EFSYX�©XLI�IXLRSPSK]�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�ª�IWTIGMEPP]�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�MRJPY\SJ�TSTYPEXMSR�JVSQ�)K]TX�©[LMGL�WXMPP�TIVWMWXW�MR�XLI�ZMPPEKIW�ª�-R�EHHMXMSRXS�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W��XLI�SXLIV�IXLRMG�KVSYTW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�EX�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLIRMRIXIIRXL�ERH�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�X[IRXMIXL�GIRXYV]�MRGPYHIH�/YVHW�+IVQER�8IQTPEVW��4IVWMERW��7YHERIWI��%PKIVMERW��7EQEVMXERW��8EXEVW�+ISVKMERW��ERH�QER]�TISTPI�SJ�QM\IH�IXLRMGMXMIW��%W�SRI�WGLSPEV��[VMXMRKMR�������WYQQEVMIH�XLI�WMXYEXMSR��©8LI�JI[�%VEFW�[LS�PMZIH�MR�4EPIWXMRIE�LYRHVIH�]IEVW�EKS��[LIR�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRX�FIKER��[IVI�E�XMR]�VIQRERXSJ�E�ZSPEXMPI�TSTYPEXMSR��[LMGL�LEH�FIIR�MR�GSRWXERX�JPY\��EW�E�VIWYPX�SJYRIRHMRK�GSRJPMGXW�FIX[IIR�PSGEP�XVMFIW�ERH�PSGEP�HIWTSXW��1EPEVME�ERH�HMW�IEWI�LEH�XEOIR�E�LIEZ]�XSPP�SJ�XLI�MRLEFMXERXW�ª��

4VMSV�XS�XLI�EVVMZEP�SJ�XLI�)YVSTIER�.I[W�EX�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI����W��XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�%VEFW��TEVXMGYPEVP]�MR�XLI�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�[EWXS�FI�TEVXMXMSRIH�MRXS�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��[EW�WQEPP�ERH�WLVMROMRK��%R�����GSQQYRMUYr�JVSQ�XLI�&VMXMWL�GSRWYP�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�VITSVXIH�XLEX�©XLIGSYRXV]�MW�MR�E�GSRWMHIVEFPI�HIKVII�IQTX]�SJ�MRLEFMXERXW�ERH�XLIVIJSVI�MXWKVIEXIWX�RIIH�MW�XLEX�SJ�E�FSH]�SJ�TSTYPEXMSR�ª�� -X�EPWS�RSXIH�XLEXEPXLSYKL�XLI�%VEFW�XIRHIH�XS�PIEZI�ERH�RSX�VIXYVR��XLI�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR[EW�QSVI�WXEFPI��©?;AI�LEZI�.I[W�[LS�LEZI�XVEZIPIH�XS�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIWERH�%YWXVEPME�ª�ERH�©MRWXIEH�SJ�VIQEMRMRK�XLIVI��HS�VIXYVR�LMXLIV�ª��*SYV]IEVW�PEXIV��MX�[EW�VITSVXIH�XLEX�©HITSTYPEXMSR�MW�IZIR�RS[�EHZERGMRK�ª��

%RH�JSYV�]IEVW�EJXIV�XLEX��MX�[EW�RSXIH�XLEX�MR�GIVXEMR�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]©PERH�MW�KSMRK�SYX�SJ�GYPXMZEXMSR�ERH�[LSPI�ZMPPEKIW�EVI�VETMHP]�HMWETTIEV�MRK�������ERH�XLI�WXEXMSREV]�TSTYPEXMSR�I\XMVTEXIH�ª��

3XLIV�LMWXSVMERW��HIQSKVETLIVW��ERH�XVEZIPIVW�HIWGVMFIH�XLI�%VEF

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 37: The Case For Israel

TSTYPEXMSR�EW�©HIGVIEWMRK�ª�� ERH�XLI�PERH�EW�©XLMRP]�TSTYPEXIH�ª��

©YRSGGYTMIH�ª�� ©YRMRLEFMXIH�ª�� ERH�©EPQSWX�EFERHSRIH�RS[�ª�8LI4PEMR�SJ�7LEVSR��[LMGL�XLI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�PEXIV�GYPXMZEXIH��[EWHIWGVMFIH�F]�6IZIVIRH�7EQYIP�1ERRMRK�MR������EW�©E�PERH�[MXLSYXMRLEFMXERXWª�XLEX�©QMKLX�WYTTSVX�ER�MQQIRWI�TSTYPEXMSR�ª��

1SVISZIV��XLI�GSRHMXMSRW�SJ�PSGEP�PMJI�FIJSVI�XLI�EVVMZEP�SJ�XLI�)YVSTIER.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�LEVHP]�IRZMEFPI��3RP]�E�XMR]�TVSTSVXMSR�SJ�XLI�TST�YPEXMSR�GSYPH�VIEH�SV�[VMXI���,IEPXL�GEVI�[EW�EFSQMREFPI���MRJERX�QSV�XEPMX]�LMKL��PMJI�I\TIGXERG]�WLSVX��ERH�[EXIV�WGEVGI��� %PP�XLMW�[SYPHMQTVSZI�HVEQEXMGEPP]�EJXIV�XLI�)YVSTIER�.I[W�EVVMZIH�

2SX�WYVTVMWMRKP]��XLI�WQEPP�ERH�HIGVIEWMRK�%VEF§1YWPMQ�TSTYPEXMSR�SJXLI�EVIE�[EW�EPWS�E�XVERWMIRX�ERH�QMKVEXSV]�TSTYPEXMSR��EW�GSRXVEWXIH�[MXLXLI�QSVI�WXEFPI��MJ�WQEPPIV��.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR��8LI�Q]XL�SJ�E�WXEFPI�ERHWIXXPIH�4EPIWXMRMER§%VEF§1YWPMQ�TSTYPEXMSR�XLEX�LEH�PMZIH�MR�ZMPPEKIW�ERH[SVOIH�XLI�PERH�JSV�GIRXYVMIW��SRP]�XS�FI�HMWTPEGIH�F]�XLI�>MSRMWXMRZEHIVW��MW�WMQTP]�MRGSRWMWXIRX�[MXL�XLI�VIGSVHIH�HIQSKVETLMG�HEXEKEXLIVIH�RSX�F]�XLI�.I[W�SV�>MSRMWXW�FYX�VEXLIV�F]�XLI�PSGEP�EYXLSVMXMIWXLIQWIPZIW��.��0��&YVOLEVHX�VITSVXIH�XLEX�EW�IEVP]�EW�MR�XLI�WIGSRH�HIGEHISJ�XLI�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]��©*I[�MRHMZMHYEPW�������HMI�MR�XLI�WEQI�ZMPPEKI�MR[LMGL�XLI]�[IVI�FSVR��*EQMPMIW�EVI�GSRXMRYEPP]�QSZMRK�JVSQ�SRI�TPEGI�XSERSXLIV�������MR�E�JI[�]IEVW�������XLI]�JP]�XS�WSQI�SXLIV�TPEGI��[LIVI�XLI]LEZI�LIEVH�XLEX�XLIMV�FVIXLVIR�EVI�FIXXIV�XVIEXIH�ª��

&]�XLI�QMH�����W SRP]�E�HSIR�]IEVW�EJXIV�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�*MVWX%PM]EL .I[W�[IVI�FIGSQMRK�ER�MQTSVXERX�TEVX�SJ�XLI�IXLRMG�ERH�VIPMKMSYWQM\�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��IWTIGMEPP]�MR�XLI�EVIE�IZIRXYEPP]�TEVXMXMSRIH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH2EXMSRW�JSV�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MR�������%X�XLI�XMQI�SJ�XLI�TEVXMXMSR��XLIVI�[EWE�GPIEV�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]�MR�XLEX�EVIE�����������.I[W�ERH���������%VEFW �%GGSVHMRK�XS�WSQI�HMWTYXIH�EGGSYRXW [LMGL�-�HS�RSX�VIP]�SR�JSV�Q]EVKYQIRX IZIR�EW�IEVP]�EW�XLI�QMH�����W��XLIVI�QE]�LEZI�FIIR�E�TPYVEP�MX]�SJ�.I[W�MR�TEVXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�FIGEQI�XLI�LIEVXPERH�SJ�XLI�.I[MWLEVIE�YRHIV�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR���;MXLSYX�ER]�HSYFX��XLIVI�[EW�EPVIEH]�EWMKRMJMGERX�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR�XLEX�EVIE�FIJSVI�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�X[IR�XMIXL�GIRXYV]�

7SQI�1YWPMQW XLI�RYQFIVW�EVI�YRGIVXEMR LEH�FIIR�EXXVEGXIH�XS�XLIRI[�EVIEW�SJ�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRX�F]�XLI�NSFW�QEHI�EZEMPEFPI�F]�.I[MWL�MQQM�KVEXMSR�ERH�GYPXMZEXMSR�SJ�PERH��%�WXYH]�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRX�SJ�6MWLSR0¬8MSR��JMVWX�IWXEFPMWLIH�MR�������WLS[IH�XLEX�XLI����.I[MWL�JEQMPMIW�XLEXWIXXPIH�XLIVI�LEH�EXXVEGXIH�©QSVI�XLER�����%VEF�JEQMPMIW�ª�QER]�SJ�[LMGL[IVI�&IHSYMR�ERH�)K]TXMER��8LIWI�JEQMPMIW�QSZIH�MRXS�EVIEW�EVSYRH�XLI.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRX�ERH�JSVQIH�E�RI[�%VEF�ZMPPEKI�SR�XLI�WMXI�SJ�©E�JSVWEOIRVYMR�ª��8LI�VITSVX�SFWIVZIH�E�WMQMPEV�TEXXIVR�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�SXLIV�WIXXPI�QIRXW�ERH�ZMPPEKIW�

%PXLSYKL�MX�MW�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�VIGSRWXVYGX�[MXL�ER]�GSRJMHIRGI�XLI�TVIGMWI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 38: The Case For Israel

RYQFIV�SJ�%VEFW§1YWPMQW§4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�JSV�KIRIVEXMSRW�MR[LEX�IZIRXYEPP]�FIGEQI�XLI�.I[MWL�EVIE�YRHIV�XLI�TEVXMXMSR��XLI�RYQFIV�MWJEV�FIPS[�XLEX�GPEMQIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�TSPIQMGMWXW��%GGSVHMRK�XS�SRI�LMWXS�VMER��©EX�PIEWX����SJ�?XLI�1YWPMQW�[LS�PMZIH�MR�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�MR�����A[IVI�RI[GSQIVW�SV�HIWGIRHERXW�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�EVVMZIH�EJXIV�?XLI�)K]TXMERGSRUYIWX�SJ�����A�ª��-R�EHHMXMSR�XS�XLI�)K]TXMER�MRJPY\��XLIVI�[EW�EGSRWMHIVEFPI�MQQMKVEXMSR�SJ�8YVOW��+VIIOW��ERH�%PKIVMERW��1SVISZIV�QER]�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�1YWPMQW�[LS�[IVI�EXXVEGXIH�XS�[IWXIVR�4EPIWXMRIFIX[IIR������ERH������GEQI�JVSQ�IEWXIVR�4EPIWXMRI��XLI�;IWX�ERH�)EWX&EROW�SJ�XLI�.SVHER ��'SQFMRMRK�XLIWI�JMKYVIW�PIEHW�XS�XLI�MRIWGETEFPIGSRGPYWMSR�XLEX�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�[MXL�HIIT�VSSXW�MR�XLI�EVIEW�SJ.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRX EPXLSYKL�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�IWXMQEXI�[MXL�GSRJMHIRGIGSRWXMXYXIW�E�XMR]�JVEGXMSR�SJ�XLI�QSVI�XLER�E�QMPPMSR�4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW[LS�RS[�PMZI�MR�-WVEIP�

8LI�RYQFIV�SJ�1YWPMQW�[LS�PMZIH�MR�XLI�.I[MWL�EVIEW�KVI[�HVEQEXM�GEPP]�EJXIV�XLI�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRXW�FPSWWSQIH�RSX�SRP]�FIGEYWI�QER]�%VEFW[IVI�EXXVEGXIH�XS�XLI�RI[P]�WIXXPIH�EVIEW�ERH�RI[P]�GYPXMZEXIH�PERH�FYX�EPWSFIGEYWI�XLI�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MQTVSZIH�LIEPXL�GEVI��GYX�MRJERX�QSVXEPMX]�ERH�I\TERHIH�EHYPX�PMJI�I\TIGXERG]��%�&VMXMWL�SJJMGMEP�VITSVXIH�MR������XLEX©XLI�KVS[XL�MR�?XLI�RYQFIVW�SJ�%VEF�JIPPELMRA�LEH�FIIR�PEVKIP]�HYI�XS�XLILIEPXL�WIVZMGIW�GSQFEXMRK�QEPEVME��VIHYGMRK�MRJERX�HIEXL�VEXIW��MQTVSZMRK[EXIV�WYTTP]�ERH�WERMXEXMSR�ª��8LIWI�MQTVSZIQIRXW�FIKER�[MXL�QSHIVRLSWTMXEPW�ERH�[EXIV�ERH�WERMXEV]�W]WXIQW�MRXVSHYGIH�MRXS�4EPIWXMRI�F]�XLI.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�)YVSTI�

&IGEYWI�SJ�XLI�EFWIRGI�SJ�TVIGMWI�GIRWYW�SV�PERH�VIGSVHW��RS�SRI�[MPPIZIV�FI�EFPI�XS�VIGSRWXVYGX��[MXL�ER]�HIKVII�SJ�GIVXEMRX]��XLI�TVIGMWI�HIQS�KVETLMGW�SJ�XLI�EVIE�IZIRXYEPP]�EWWMKRIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�F]�XLI�9�2�TEVXMXMSR�SJ������EX�XLI�XMQI�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�)YVSTI�FIKER�XSEVVMZI�XLIVI��&YX�MX�MW�FI]SRH�VIEWSREFPI�HMWTYXI FEWIH�SR�GIRWYW�JMKYVIW�EYXLSVMXEXMZI�VITSVXW��I]I[MXRIWW�EGGSYRXW��ERH�WMQTPI�EVMXLQIXMG XLEX�XLIQ]XL�SJ�HMWTPEGIQIRX�F]�XLI�)YVSTIER�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�SJ�E�PEVKI��WXEFPI�PSRK�XIVQ�1YWPMQ�TSTYPEXMSR�XLEX�LEH�PMZIH�MR�XLEX�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�JSVGIRXYVMIW�MW�HIQSRWXVEFP]�JEPWI��)ZIR�QER]�%VEF�MRXIPPIGXYEPW�EGORS[PIHKIXLI�Q]XLMGEP�REXYVI�SJ�XLMW�GPEMQ��%W�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIV�1YWE�%PEQMWEMH�MR�������©8LI�TISTPI�EVI�MR�KVIEX�RIIH�SJ�E�«Q]XL¬�XS�JMPP�XLIMV�GSR�WGMSYWRIWW�ERH�MQEKMREXMSR�ª��/MRK�%FHYPPEL�SJ�.SVHER�EPWS�VIGSKRMIHXLEX�XLI�WXSV]�SJ�.I[MWL�HMWTPEGIQIRX�SJ�PSGEP�4EPIWXMRMERW�[EW�E�JMGXMSREPSRI��EGORS[PIHKMRK�XLEX�©XLI�%VEFW�EVI�EW�TVSHMKEP�MR�WIPPMRK�XLIMV�PERH�EWXLI]�EVI�MR�������[IITMRK�?EFSYX�MXA�ª��

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 39: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

)ZIR�MJ�XLI�*MVWX�%PM]EL�GER�FI�GLEVEGXIVMIH�EW�ER�MQQMKVEXMSR�SJVIJYKIIW�QIVIP]�WIIOMRK�E�LSQI�MR�4EPIWXMRI��XLI�7IGSRH�%PM]EL�[EW�XLIFIKMRRMRK�SJ�E�>MSRMWX�MQTIVMEPMWX�TPSX�XS�GSPSRMI�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�

8,)�%''97)67

©1]�TVIQMWI�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP�HIZIPSTIH�EW�E�WSGMEP�TSPMX]�SYX�SJ�XLI�>MSRMWXXLIWMW�XLEX�4EPIWXMRI¬W�GSPSRMEXMSR�[EW�XS�FI�EGGSQTPMWLIH�JSV�ERH�F]�.I[WERH�F]�XLI�HMWTPEGIQIRX�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��XLEX�MR�MXW�GSRWGMSYW�ERHHIGPEVIH�MHIE�EFSYX�4EPIWXMRI��>MSRMWQ�EXXIQTXIH�JMVWX�XS�QMRMQMI��XLIRXS�IPMQMREXI��XLIR��EPP�IPWI�JEMPMRK��JMREPP]�XS�WYFNYKEXI�XLI�REXMZIW�EW�E�[E]SJ�KYEVERXIIMRK�XLEX�-WVEIP�[SYPH�RSX�FI�WMQTP]�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�MXW�GMXMIRW�[LMGL�MRGPYHIH�%VEFW��SJ�GSYVWI �FYX�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�XLI�[LSPI�.I[MWL�TIS�TPI��LEZMRK�E�OMRH�SJ�WSZIVIMKRX]�SZIV�PERH�ERH�TISTPIW�XLEX�RS�SXLIV�WXEXITSWWIWWIH�SV�TSWWIWWIW�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�

©?8LI��������.I[W�[LS�PMZIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI�F]�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�7IGSRH%PM]ELA�©[IVI�SZIV[LIPQMRKP]�ERXM�>MSRMWX�ERH�XLIMV�HIWGIRHERXW�WXMPP�EVIYRERMQSYWP]�?SJ�XLEX�ZMI[A�ª��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�

��

;EW�XLI�>MSRMWX�

1SZIQIRX�E�4PSX�XS

'SPSRMI�%PP�SJ

4EPIWXMRI#

Page 40: The Case For Israel

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�7IGSRH�%PM]EL��EPXLSYKL�PEVKIP]�MRWTMVIH�F]�>MSRMWX�MHISPSK]��[EW�EPWSER�MQQMKVEXMSR�JVSQ�TIVWIGYXMSR��ERH�MX�GSRXIQTPEXIH�GSSTIVEXMSR�[MXLPSGEP�1YWPMQW�XS�GVIEXI�FIXXIV�PMZIW�JSV�EPP�VIWMHIRXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�

8,)�4633*

8LI�7IGSRH�%PM]EL������§���� �[EW��MJ�ER]XLMRK��IZIR�QSVI�ER�MQQM�KVEXMSR�SJ�VIJYKIIW�WIIOMRK�EW]PYQ�JVSQ�TIVWIGYXMSR��8LI�LMWXSVMER�&IRR]1SVVMW�[VMXIW��©8LI�?6YWWMERA�TSKVSQW�SJ�����§�����[IVI�E�QENSV�TVI�GMTMXERX�SJ�XLI�7IGSRH�%PM]E�ª�8LIWI�KSZIVRQIRXEPP]�MRWTMVIH�[EZIW�SJZMSPIRGI�[IVI�IZIR�©QSVI�ZMGMSYW�XLER�XLSWI�SJ�XLI�����¬W�ª�8LI�JMVWX�SJXLI�X[IRXMIXL�GIRXYV]�TSKVSQW��SR�4EWWSZIV�SJ������MR�/MWLMRIZ��VIWYPXIHMR�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ����.I[W��XLI�MRNYV]�SJ�LYRHVIHW�QSVI��ERH�XLI�HIWXVYG�XMSR�SJ�������.I[MWL�LSYWIW��WLSTW��ERH�MRWXMXYXMSRW��,YRHVIHW�SJTSKVSQW�JSPPS[IH�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�4EPI�SJ�7IXXPIQIRX��OMPPMRK�ERH�MRNYVMRKXLSYWERHW�SJ�.I[MWL�QIR��[SQIR��ERH�GLMPHVIR��.I[W�GSYPH�RSX�HIJIRHXLIQWIPZIW�[MXLSYX�MRZMXMRK�IZIR�QSVI�VIXVMFYXMSR��8LI�SRP]�STXMSR�[EWXS�FIGSQI�VIJYKIIW��,YRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW�PIJX�JSV�%QIVMGE�ERH�[IWXIVR)YVSTI��8IRW�SJ�XLSYWERHW�WSYKLX�VIJYKI�MR�4EPIWXMRI��1ER]�[IVI�EVHIRX>MSRMWXW��JSPPS[MRK�,IVP¬W�HVIEQ�SJ�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH��3XLIVW�[IVI�WMQ�TP]�VIJYKIIW�[MPPMRK�XS�FIEV�XLI�LEVHWLMTW�SJ�E�PERH�XLI]�LSTIH�XS�XYVR�MRXSE�WSGMEPMWX�TEVEHMWI�

8LI�7IGSRH�%PM]EL��RSX�YRPMOI�XLI�[EZI�SJ�VIJYKIIW�[LS�GEQI�XS%QIVMGE�HYVMRK�XLI�WEQI�TIVMSH��MRGPYHIH�QER]�[SVOMRK�GPEWW�TISTPI�[LSJSVQIH�PEFSV�YRMSRW�ERH�PEFSV�TEVXMIW��8LI]�EPWS�IWXEFPMWLIH�E�,IFVI[TVIWW�ERH�E�WQEPP�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�SVKERMEXMSR�XS�TVSXIGX�XLI�.I[W�JVSQ�XLI%VEF�ZMSPIRGI�XLEX�LEH�ZMGXMQMIH�XLI�IEVPMIV�VIJYKIIW�

-R�������ER�%VEF�[VMXIV��2ENMF�%SYVM��TYFPMWLIH�ER�ERXM�.I[MWLWGVIIH�XLEX�VIZIVFIVEXIH�XLVSYKLSYX�4EPIWXMRI��-X�[EVRIH�SJ�E�WIGVIX�.I[�MWL�TPSX�XS�IWXEFPMWL�E�>MSRMWX�WXEXI�©WXVIXGLMRK�JVSQ�1SYRX�,IVQER�XS�XLI%VEFMER�(IWIVX�ERH�XLI�7YI�'EREP�ª�8LI�]SYRK�(EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR�[SV�VMIH�XLEX�©%SYVM¬W�TYTMPWª�[IVI�©WS[MRK�XLI�WIIH�SJ�LEXVIH�JSV�XLI�.I[W�EXEPP�PIZIPW�SJ�%VEF�WSGMIX]�ª�

1ER]��EPXLSYKL�RSX�EPP��SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�WSYKLX�XS�IWXEFPMWL�KSSHVIPEXMSRW�[MXL�XLIMV�%VEF�RIMKLFSVW��3RI�SJ�XLI�IEVPMIWX�TYFPMGEXMSRW�F]�E>MSRMWX�PMZMRK�MR�-WVEIP�[EW�E�WQEPP�FSSO�F]�=MXLEO�)TWXIMR�IRXMXPIH�8LI,MHHIR�5YIWXMSR�[LMGL�TVSTSWIH�KMZMRK�PSGEP�%VEFW�EGGIWW�XS�.I[MWL�LSW�TMXEPW��WGLSSPW��ERH�PMFVEVMIW��3XLIVW�YVKIH�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�XS�PIEVR%VEFMG�ERH�XS�VIJVEMR�JVSQ�TYVGLEWMRK�ER]�PERH�GSRXEMRMRK�%VEF�ZMPPEKIW�SVLSP]�WMXIW�� &YX�GSRJPMGXW�TIVWMWXIH�EW�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 41: The Case For Israel

MRGVIEWIH��-R�������E�PIEHMRK�%VEF�TIVWSREPMX]�TYFPMWLIH�E�TSIQ�XLEXMRGPYHIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�PMRIW�

.I[W��WSRW�SJ�GPMROMRK�KSPH��WXST�]SYV�HIGIMX�

;IWLEPP�RSX�FI�GLIEXIH�MRXS�FEVXIVMRK�E[E]�SYV�GSYRXV]�

������8LI�.I[W��XLI�[IEOIWX�SJ�EPP�TISTPIW�ERH�XLI�PIEWX�SJ�XLIQ�

%VI�LEKKPMRK�[MXL�YW�JSV�SYV�PERH�

,S[�GER�[I�WPYQFIV�SR#

(IWTMXI�XLIWI�TVSZSGEXMSRW�ERH�GSRXMRYMRK�VIPMKMSYWP]�MRWTMVIH�ZMSPIRGIEKEMRWX�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW��IJJSVXW�TIVWMWXIH�EX�VIEGLMRK�WSQI�VETTVSGLI�QIRX��-R�IEVP]�������E�PIEHMRK�>MSRMWX��2EGLYQ�7SOSPSZ��KEZI�ER�MRXIV�ZMI[�XS�E�'EMVS�RI[WTETIV�YVKMRK�XLI�%VEFW�XS�ZMI[�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�EWJIPPS[�7IQMXIW�©VIXYVRMRK�LSQIª�[LS�GSYPH�LIPT�XLIQ�TVSWTIV�XSKIXLIV�.I[MWL§%VEF�HMEPSKYIW�[IVI�TPERRIH�JSV�XLI�WYQQIV�SJ�������FYX�XLISYXFVIEO�SJ�;SVPH�;EV�-��[LMGL�[EW�XS�LEZI�QSQIRXSYW�GSRWIUYIRGIW�JSVXLI�.I[W�ERH�%VEFW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��TYX�EPP�WYGL�GSSTIVEXMZI�IJJSVXW�SR�LSPH�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 42: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR��[LMGL�GEPPIH�JSV�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�E�©.I[MWLLSQI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�ª�LEW�RS�PIKEP�IJJIGX��WMRGI�MX�[EW�QIVIP]�XLI�STMRMSR�SJXLI�KSZIVRQIRX�SJ�)RKPERH�

8,)�%''97)67

©?8LI�&EPJSYVA�?(AIGPEVEXMSR�[EW�QEHI��E �F]�E�)YVSTIER�TS[IV���F EFSYX�E�RSR�)YVSTIER�XIVVMXSV]���G �MR�E�JPEX�HMWVIKEVH�SJ�FSXL�XLI�TVIWIRGIERH�XLI�[MWLIW�SJ�XLI�REXMZI�QENSVMX]�VIWMHIRX�MR�XLEX�XIVVMXSV]��ERH��H �MXXSSO�XLI�JSVQ�SJ�E�TVSQMWI�EFSYX�XLMW�WEQI�XIVVMXSV]�XS�ERSXLIV�JSVIMKRKVSYT�WS�XLEX�XLMW�JSVIMKR�KVSYT�QMKLX�UYMXI�PMXIVEPP]�QEOIXLMW�XIVVMXSV]�EREXMSREP�LSQI�JSV�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI��������&EPJSYV¬W�WXEXIQIRXW�MR�XLI�HIG�PEVEXMSR�XEOI�JSV�KVERXIH�XLI�LMKLIV�VMKLX�SJ�E�GSPSRMEP�TS[IV�XS�HMWTSWI�SJE�XIVVMXSV]�EW�MX�WE[�JMX�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�

©?-AR�������XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�TVSQMWIH�E�REXMSREP�LSQI�JSV�XLI.I[MWL�TISTPI��9RHIV�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�XLI�HIGPEVEXMSR�[EW�RYPP�ERH�ZSMHWMRGI�4EPIWXMRI�HMH�RSX�FIPSRK�XS�&VMXEMR YRHIV�XLI�TEGX�SJ�XLI�0IEKYI�SJ2EXMSRW�MX�FIPSRKIH�XS�8YVOI]�ª��*EMWEP�&SHM��&VMXMWL�NSYVREPMWX�

��

;EW�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�&MRHMRK-RXIVREXMSREP�0E[#

Page 43: The Case For Israel

8,)�6)%0-8=

%�HI�JEGXS�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�EPVIEH]�I\MWXIH�MR�TEVXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��ERH�MXWVIGSKRMXMSR�F]�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�FIGEQI�E�QEXXIV�SJ�FMRHMRK�MRXIV�REXMSREP�PE[�[LIR�XLI�0IEKYI�SJ�2EXMSRW�QEHI�MX�TEVX�SJ�MXW�QERHEXI�

8,)�4633*

&]�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�*MVWX�;SVPH�;EV��XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�.I[W�PMZMRK�MR�XLIEVIE�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�[EW�XS�FIGSQI�-WVEIP�[EW�WSQI[LIVI�FIX[IIR�������ERH���������)ZIR�FIJSVI�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�SJ�������XLIVI[EW�E�HI�JEGXS�.I[MWL�REXMSREP�LSQI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�GSRWMWXMRK�SJ�WIZIVEPHSIRW�SJ�.I[MWL�QSWLEZMQ�ERH�OMFFYXMQ�MR�[IWXIVR�ERH�RSVXLIEWXIVR4EPIWXMRI��EW�[IPP�EW�MR�.I[MWL�GMXMIW�WYGL�EW�8IP�%ZMZ��.IVYWEPIQ��ERH�7EJEH�8LI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�LEH�IWXEFPMWLIH�XLMW�LSQIPERH�SR�XLIKVSYRH�[MXLSYX�XLI�EWWMWXERGI�SJ�ER]�GSPSRMEP�SV�MQTIVMEPMWX�TS[IVW��8LI]LEH�VIPMIH�SR�XLIMV�S[R�LEVH�[SVO�MR�FYMPHMRK�ER�MRJVEWXVYGXYVI�ERH�GYPXM�ZEXMRK�PERH�XLI]�LEH�PIKEPP]�TYVGLEWIH�

;SVPH�;EV�-�TMXXIH�XLI�&VMXMWL��EQSRK�SXLIVW �EKEMRWX�XLI�+IVQERW�ERHXLI�3XXSQER�)QTMVI��EQSRK�SXLIVW ��8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�IRXIVIH�XLI�[EVSR�XLI�&VMXMWL�WMHI�MR�������ERH�4VIWMHIRX�;SSHVS[�;MPWSR�HIGPEVIH�XLEXXLI�TVMRGMTPI�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�WLSYPH�KSZIVR�ER]�TSWX[EV�VISVKERM�EXMSR�SJ�XIVVMXSVMIW�XLEX�[IVI�JSVQIVP]�GSRXVSPPIH�F]�XLI�3XXSQER

)QTMVI��7YTTSVX�JSV�.I[MWL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�XLSWI�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRIMR�[LMGL�.I[W�GSRWXMXYXIH�E�QENSVMX]�[EW�WIIR�F]�QER]�EW�TEVX�SJ�;MPWSR�MER�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��

%JXIV�EPP��XLIVI�LEH�RIZIV�FIIR�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�MR�XLMW�EVIE��%�.I[MWLLSQIPERH�[SYPH�RSX�FI�GEVZIH�SYX�SJ�E�TVII\MWXMRK�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�-RWXIEH��E�HIGMWMSR�[SYPH�LEZI�XS�FI�QEHI�EFSYX�LS[�XS�EPPSGEXI�E�������WUYEVI�QMPI�EVIE�SJ�PERH�XLEX�LEH�FIIR�GETXYVIH�JVSQ�XLI3XXSQER�)QTMVI�ERH�[EW�TSTYPEXIH�F]�%VEFW��.I[W��ERH�SXLIVW��8LIVI[IVI�JSYV�FEWMG�EPXIVREXMZIW���� �KMZI�EPP�XLI�PERH��IZIR�XLEX�MR�[LMGL�XLI.I[W�[IVI�E�QENSVMX]��XS�WSQI�RI[�%VEF�WXEXI���� �KMZI�EPP�XLI�PERH��IZIRXLI�TEVX�MR�[LMGL�%VEFW�[IVI�XLI�QENSVMX]��XS�XLI�.I[W���� �XYVR�EPP�XLIPERH�SZIV�XS�7]VME��XS�FI�VYPIH�JVSQ�(EQEWGYW��SV��� �HMZMHI�XLI�PERH�JEMVP]FIX[IIR�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�XLI�.I[W�WS�XLEX�IEGL�GSYPH�GVIEXI�E�LSQIPERHFEWIH�SR�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��8LI�PEWX�SJ�XLIWI�STXMSRW�[EW�WIPIGXIH�ERH�XLIHIGMWMSR�[EW�QEHI�XS�EPPSGEXI�E�TSVXMSR�SJ�XLI�PERH�XS�XLI�KVSYT�XLEX�PMZIHXLIVI��[SVOIH�XLI�PERH��ERH�FYMPX�XLI�MRJVEWXVYGXYVI��;LEX�GSYPH�FI�JEMVIVERH�QSVI�MR�XLI�WTMVMX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR#

;MRWXSR�'LYVGLMPP��©E�PMJIPSRK�>MSRMWX�ª�LEH�PSRK�JEZSVIH�.I[MWL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�4EPIWXMRI��%W�JEV�FEGO�EW�������LI�WE[�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRXSJ�©E�WXVSRK��JVII�.I[MWL�WXEXIª�EW�©E�RSXEFPI�WXIT�XS[EVH�E�LEVQSRMMRK

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 44: The Case For Israel

��

Page 45: The Case For Israel

HMWTSWMXMSR�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�EQSRK�MXW�TISTPI�ª�;LIR�&VMXEMR�[EW�JMREPP]�MR�ETSWMXMSR�XS�LIPT�FVMRK�EFSYX�WYGL�E�©LEVQSRMMRK�HMWTSWMXMSR�ª�'LYVGLMPP[EW�IZIR�QSVI�I\TPMGMX�

-X�MW�QERMJIWXP]�VMKLX�XLEX�XLI�WGEXXIVIH�.I[W�WLSYPH�LEZI�E�REXMSREP�GIR�

XIV�ERH�E�REXMSREP�LSQI�ERH�FI�VIYRMXIH�ERH�[LIVI�IPWI�FYX�MR�4EPIWXMRI

[MXL�[LMGL�JSV�������]IEVW�XLI]�LEZI�FIIR�MRXMQEXIP]�ERH�TVSJSYRHP]

EWWSGMEXIH#�;I�XLMRO�MX�[MPP�FI�KSSH�JSV�XLI�[SVPH��KSSH�JSV�XLI�.I[W�

KSSH�JSV�XLI�&VMXMWL�)QTMVI��FYX�EPWS�KSSH�JSV�XLI�%VEFW�[LS�H[IPP�MR

4EPIWXMRI��������8LI]�WLEPP�WLEVI�MR�XLI�FIRIJMXW�ERH�TVSKVIWW�SJ�>MSRMWQ�ª�

-X�WLSYPH�RSX�FI�WYVTVMWMRK��XLIVIJSVI��XLEX�EW�XLI�&VMXMWL�KSZIVRQIRXTPERRIH�JSV�ZMGXSV]�SZIV�XLI�3XXSQER�)QTMVI��MX�ERRSYRGIH�XLVSYKL�E�PIX�XIV�JVSQ�&VMXMWL�*SVIMKR�1MRMWXIV�0SVH�%VXLYV�&EPJSYV�XLEX�©,MW�1ENIWX]¬W+SZIVRQIRX�ZMI[�[MXL�JEZSV�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�MR�4EPIWXMRI�SJ�E�REXMSREPLSQI�JSV�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�ª�-X�EPWS�ERRSYRGIH�XLEX�WYGL�E�LSQI�QYWX�RSX©TVINYHMGI�XLI�GMZMP�ERH�VIPMKMSYW�VMKLXW�SJ�I\MWXMRK�RSR�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMXMIWMR�4EPIWXMRI�ª�-VSRMGEPP]��SRI�SJ�XLI�FMKKIWX�SFNIGXMSRW�QER]�%VEFW�LEH�XSXLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�[EW�XLEX�MX�WIIQIH�XS�VIKEVH�4EPIWXMRI�EW�E�WITEVEXIIRXMX]�VEXLIV�XLER�EW�TEVX�SJ�7]VME��%W�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�[EW�PEXIV�XSSFWIVZI��©8LI�%VEFW�LEH�EP[E]W�VIKEVHIH�4EPIWXMRI�EW�MRGPYHIH�MR�7]VME�ª8LI�PEWX�XLMRK�XLI]�[ERXIH�[EW�E�WITEVEXI�4EPIWXMRI��FIGEYWI�XLI]�VIEPMIHXLEX�E�WITEVEXI�4EPIWXMRI�QIERX�E�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX��YRHIV�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVE�XMSR��QMKLX�MRGPYHI�E�WQEPP�LSQI�JSV�MXW�WYFWXERXMEP�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR�

8LI�*VIRGL�JSVIMKR�QMRMWXIV�LEH�MWWYIH�E�WXEXIQIRX�WMQMPEV�XS�XLI�&EP�JSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�WIZIVEP�QSRXLW�IEVPMIV��HIWGVMFMRK�EW�©E�HIIH�SJ�NYWXMGIERH�SJ�VITEVEXMSRª�XLI�©VIREMWWERGI�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSREPMX]�MR�XLI�PERHJVSQ�[LMGL�XLI�TISTPI�SJ�-WVEIP�[IVI�I\TIPPIH�WS�QER]�GIRXYVMIW�EKS�ª�

8LI�XI\X�SJ�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�LEH�FIIR�WYFQMXXIH�XS�4VIWMHIRX�;MP�WSR�ERH�ETTVSZIH�F]�LMQ�MR�EHZERGI��8LI�*VIRGL�ERH�-XEPMER�KSZIVRQIRXWEPWS�WYFWIUYIRXP]�ETTVSZIH�MX��-R�������4VIWMHIRX�;MPWSR�WXEXIH��©-�EQTIVWYEHIH�XLEX�XLI�%PPMIH�REXMSRW��[MXL�XLI�JYPPIWX�GSRGYVVIRGI�SJ�SYV�S[RKSZIVRQIRX�ERH�TISTPI��EVI�EKVIIH�XLEX�MR�4EPIWXMRI�WLEPP�FI�PEMH�XLI�JSYR�HEXMSRW�SJ�E�.I[MWL�GSQQSR[IEPXL�ª� -R�������XLI�9�7��'SRKVIWWEHSTXIH�E�VIWSPYXMSR�HIGPEVMRK�XLEX�E�©REXMSREP�LSQI�JSV�XLI�.I[MWL�TIS�TPIª�FI�IWXEFPMWLIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI��;MRWXSR�'LYVGLMPP�EPWS�GSRJMVQIH�XLEX�XLI&VMXMWL�KSZIVRQIRX�©GSRXIQTPEXIH�XLI�IZIRXYEP�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�E�.I[MWLWXEXI�ª�ERH�LI�RSXIH�XLEX�XLI�WYFWXERGI�SJ�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�LEHFIIR�VIEJJMVQIH�MR�WIZIVEP�FMRHMRK�QYPXMREXMSREP�XVIEXMIW��EW�[IPP�EW�XLI0IEKYI�SJ�2EXMSRW�QERHEXI�MXWIPJ��ERH�©MW�RSX�WYWGITXMFPI�SJ�GLERKI�ª�-XXLIR�FIGEQI�E�QEXXIV�SJ�FMRHMRK�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�

'LYVGLMPP�EPWS�VIGSKRMIH�XLEX�E�.I[MWL�LSQI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�EPVIEH]I\MWXIH�SR�XLI�KVSYRH�[MXLSYX�ER]�LIPT�JVSQ�XLI�&VMXMWL�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 46: The Case For Israel

(YVMRK�XLI�PEWX�X[S�SV�XLVII�KIRIVEXMSRW�XLI�.I[W�LEZI�VIGVIEXIH�MR�4EPIW�

XMRI�E�GSQQYRMX]��RS[�RYQFIVMRK��������SJ�[LSQ�EFSYX�SRI�JSYVXL�EVI

JEVQIVW�SV�[SVOIVW�YTSR�XLI�PERH��8LMW�GSQQYRMX]�LEW�MXW�S[R�TSPMXMGEP

SVKERW��ER�IPIGXIH�EWWIQFP]�JSV�XLI�HMVIGXMSR�SJ�MXW�HSQIWXMG�GSRGIVRW�

IPIGXIH�GSYRGMPW�MR�XLI�XS[RW��ERH�ER�SVKERMEXMSR�JSV�XLI�GSRXVSP�SJ�MXW

WGLSSPW��-X�LEW�MXW�IPIGXIH�'LMIJ�6EFFMREXI�ERH�6EFFMRMGEP�'SYRGMP�JSV�XLI

HMVIGXMSR�SJ�VIPMKMSYW�EJJEMVW��-XW�FYWMRIWW�MW�GSRHYGXIH�MR�,IFVI[�EW�E�ZIV�

REGYPEV�PERKYEKI��ERH�E�,IFVI[�4VIWW�WIVZIW�MXW�RIIH��-X�LEW�MXW�HMWXMRGXMZI

MRXIPPIGXYEP�PMJI�ERH�HMWTPE]W�GSRWMHIVEFPI�IGSRSQMG�EGXMZMX]��8LMW�GSQQY�

RMX]��XLIR��[MXL�MXW�XS[R�ERH�GSYRXV]�TSTYPEXMSR��MXW�TSPMXMGEP��VIPMKMSYW�ERH

WSGMEP�SVKERMEXMSRW��MXW�S[R�PERKYEKI��MXW�S[R�GYWXSQW��MXW�S[R�PMJI��LEW�MR

JEGX�©REXMSREPª�GLEVEGXIVMWXMGW��;LIR�MX�MW�EWOIH�[LEX�MW�QIERX�F]�XLI�HIZIP�

STQIRX�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�2EXMSREP�,SQI�MR�4EPIWXMRI��MX�QE]�FI�ERW[IVIH�XLEX

MX�MW�RSX�XLI�MQTSWMXMSR�SJ�E�.I[MWL�REXMSREPMX]�YTSR�XLI�MRLEFMXERXW�SJ

4EPIWXMRI�EW�E�[LSPI��FYX�XLI�JYVXLIV�HIZIPSTQIRX�SJ�XLI�I\MWXMRK�.I[MWL

GSQQYRMX]��[MXL�XLI�EWWMWXERGI�SJ�.I[W�MR�SXLIV�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�[SVPH��MR�SVHIV

XLEX�MX�QE]�FIGSQI�E�GIRXIV�MR�[LMGL�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�EW�E�[LSPI�QE]

XEOI��SR�KVSYRHW�SJ�VIPMKMSR�ERH�VEGI��ER�MRXIVIWX�ERH�TVMHI��&YX�MR�SVHIV

XLEX�XLMW�GSQQYRMX]�WLSYPH�LEZI�XLI�FIWX�TVSWTIGX�SJ�JVII�HIZIPSTQIRX�ERH

TVSZMHI�E�JYPP�STTSVXYRMX]�JSV�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�XS�HMWTPE]�MXW�GETEGMXMIW��MX

MW�IWWIRXMEP�XLEX�MX�WLSYPH�ORS[�MX�MW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�EW�SJ�VMKLX�ERH�RSX�SR�

WYJJIVERGI��8LEX�MW�XLI�VIEWSR�[L]�MX�MW�RIGIWWEV]�XLEX�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�E�

.I[MWL�2EXMSREP�,SQI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�WLSYPH�FI�MRXIVREXMSREPP]�KYEVERXIIH�

ERH�XLEX�MX�WLSYPH�FI�JSVQEPP]�VIGSKRMIH�XS�VIWX�YTSR�ERGMIRX�LMWXSVMG

GSRRIGXMSR�

8LMW��XLIR��MW�XLI�MRXIVTVIXEXMSR�[LMGL�,MW�1ENIWX]¬W�+SZIVRQIRX

TPEGI�YTSR�XLI�(IGPEVEXMSR�SJ�������ERH�WS�YRHIVWXSSH��XLI�7IGVIXEV]�SJ

7XEXI�MW�SJ�XLI�STMRMSR�XLEX�MX�HSIW�RSX�GSRXEMR�SV�MQTP]�ER]XLMRK�[LMGL

RIIH�GEYWI�IMXLIV�EPEVQ�XS�XLI�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�SV�HMWET�

TSMRXQIRX�XS�XLI�.I[W���

-RXIVREXMSREP�PE[�VIGSKRMIH�XLEX�XLI�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMX]�[EW�©MR4EPIWXMRI�F]�VMKLXª�ERH�XLEX�IJJSVX�XS�©JEGMPMXEXI�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�XLI.I[MWL�2EXMSREP�,SQI�?F]�MRGVIEWMRK�.I[MWL�MQQMKVEXMSRA�[EW�E�FMRHMRKMRXIVREXMSREP�SFPMKEXMSR�SR�XLI�1ERHEXSV]�ª��8LI�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�PIKEP�WIIHW[IVI�XLYW�WS[R�JSV�E�X[S���SV�XLVII� �WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI�©4EPIWXMRMERTVSFPIQ�ª�8LMW�[EW�E�TIVJIGX�I\EQTPI�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�EX�[SVO�

8LI�.I[W�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�LEH�GIVXEMRP]�IEVRIH�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSRXLVSYKL�XLIMV�W[IEX�ERH�FPSSH��8LI]�LEH�HVEMRIH�XLI�QEPEVME�JMPPIHW[EQTW�SJ�,YPEL�ERH�TPERXIH�SVERKI�KVSZIW�MR�XLIMV�TPEGI��IQTPS]MRKXLSYWERHW�SJ�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W��8LI�.I[MWL�0IKMSR�JSYKLX�EPSRKWMHI�XLI&VMXMWL�%VQ]�XS�HIJIEX�XLI�3XXSQER�%VQ]�ERH�[IPGSQIH�+IRIVEP�)H[EVH%PPIRF]¬W�GETXYVI�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ��&]�GSRXVEWX��QSWX�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 47: The Case For Israel

EW�[IPP�EW�QSWX�%VEFW�MR�KIRIVEP��JSYKLX�SR�XLI�WMHI�SJ�XLI�PSWMRK�3XXSQER)QTMVI��%W�0PS]H�+ISVKI��XLI�&VMXMWL�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV��RSXIH��©1SWX�SJ�XLI�%VEF�VEGIW�JSYKLX�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[EV�JSV�XLI�8YVOMWL�STTVIWWSVW������XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW�?MR�TEVXMGYPEVA�JSYKLX�JSV�8YVOMWL�VYPI�ª��-X�[EW�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�LEH�WMHIH�[MXL�XLI�MQTIVMEPMWX��GSPSRMEPMWX�8YVOMWL�)QTMVIEKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LS�JEZSVIH�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��(IWTMXI�TMGOMRK�XLI�[VSRKWMHI [LMGL�XLI]�HMH�EKEMR�MR�;SVPH�;EV�-- XLI�%VEFW�IQIVKIH�JVSQ�XLI8YVOMWL�HIJIEX�[MXL�WMKRMJMGERX�KEMRW��1SWX�MQTSVXERX��XLI]�KSX����TIVGIRXSJ�4EPIWXMRI�WIX�EWMHI�EW�ER�I\GPYWMZIP]�%VEF�WXEXI��[MXL�RS�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRXTIVQMXXIH��8LMW�PEVKI�EVIE�SJ�IEWXIVR�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�VIREQIH�8VERWNSVHER�

8LI�JMVWX�WXEXI�IWXEFPMWLIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�XLYW�ER�IQMVEXI�[MXL�E�PEVKI4EPIWXMRMER�QENSVMX]��%FHYPPEL��XLI�FVSXLIV�SJ�RIMKLFSVMRK�-VEU¬W�RI[VYPIV��[SYPH�VYPI�MX��1ER]�SJ�XLI�.I[W�[LS�PMZIH�MR�[LEX�FIGEQI�8VERW�NSVHER WSQI�SJ�[LSQ�LEH�PMZIH�XLIVI�JSV�KIRIVEXMSRW LEH�FIIR�JSVGIHXS�PIEZI�FIGEYWI�SJ�ITMWSHMG�SYXFVIEOW�SJ�ZMSPIRGI�ERH��F]�PE[��XLI�JI[VIQEMRMRK�.I[W�[IVI�JSVFMHHIR�JVSQ�PMZMRK�MR�8VERWNSVHER���8LI�RI[P]JSVQIH�OMRKHSQ�SJ�8VERWNSVHER�GSRWMWXIH�SJ�E�PEVKI�XIVVMXSVMEP�I\TERWI[MXL�E�QMRYWGYPI�XSXEP�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ���������TISTPI��QER]�SJ�[LSQ�[IVIXVERWMIRX�&IHSYMRW���8LI�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�8VERWNSVHER�[EW�JEV�WQEPPIV�XLERXLEX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��]IX�RS�.I[W�[IVI�TIVQMXXIH�XS�PMZI�XLIVI�

8LI�VIQEMRMRK�SRI�JMJXL�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�GSYPH�RS[�FI�WLEVIH�SV�HMZMHIHFIX[IIR�MXW�.I[MWL�ERH�%VEF�VIWMHIRXW��%X�PIEWX�XLEX�[EW�XLI�XLISV]��&YX%VEF�STTSWMXMSR�XS�ER].I[MWL�LSQI�MR�ER]TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI XS�ER]�.I[�MWL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�EVIEW�MR�[LMGL�.I[W�[IVI�E�QENSVMX]��GSYTPIH�[MXL%VEF�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�EVIEW�MR�[LMGL�%VEFW�[IVI�E�QENSVMX] XYVRIHMRGVIEWMRKP]�ZMSPIRX�EJXIV�XLI�*MVWX�;SVPH�;EV�ERH�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�8LI�PEWX�XLMRK�QSWX�%VEF�PIEHIVW�[ERXIH�[EW�QYXYEP�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�8LI]�[IVI�WEXMWJMIH�[MXL�XLI�MQTIVMEPMWXMG�HIGMWMSR�XS�GVIEXI�E�,EWLIQMXIIQMVEXI�MR�8VERWNSVHER��ERH�XLI]�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�IUYEPP]�WEXMWJMIH�[MXL�ERMQTIVMEPMWXMG�HIGMWMSR�XS�LERH�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�SZIV�XS�XLI�VYPI�SJ�E�HMWXERX7]VMER�TEWLE ER]XLMRK�XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�IZIR�MR�E�WQEPP�TSVXMSR�SJ�[LEX�[EW�PIJX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�

8LI�STTSWMXMSR�[EW�RSX�SRP]�XS�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH��-RGVIEWMRKP]��%VEFPIEHIVW�FIKER�XS�HIQERH�IPMQMREXMSR�SJ�E�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGIMR�4EPIWXMRI��8LIKSEP�[EW�XS�QEOI�4EPIWXMRI�EW�IQTX]�SJ�.I[W�EW�8VERWNSVHER�LEH�FIGSQI�%W�%VIJ�4EWLE�(ENERE��E�.IVYWEPIQ�RSXEFPI��GERHMHP]�TYX�MX��©-X�MW�MQTSWWM�FPI�JSV�YW�XS�QEOI�ER�YRHIVWXERHMRK�[MXL�?XLI�.I[WA�SV�IZIR�XS�PMZI�[MXLXLIQ��������-R�EPP�XLI�GSYRXVMIW�[LIVI�XLI]�EVI�EX�TVIWIRX�XLI]�EVI�RSX[ERXIH�������FIGEYWI�XLI]�EP[E]W�������WYGO�XLI�FPSSH�SJ�IZIV]FSH]��-J�XLI0IEKYI�SJ�2EXMSRW�[MPP�RSX�PMWXIR�XS�XLI�ETTIEP�SJ�XLI�%VEFW��XLMW�GSYRXV][MPP�FIGSQI�E�VMZIV�SJ�FPSSH�ª��,MW�TVIHMGXMSR�FIGEQI�WIPJ�JYPJMPPMRK�EW�XLI%VEFW�XYVRIH�MRGVIEWMRKP]�XS�FPSSHWLIH�

7SQI�QSHIVEXI�%VEF�PIEHIVW�VIGSKRMIH�XLI�FIRIJMXW�SJ�.I[MWL�WIPJ�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 48: The Case For Israel

HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�4EPIWXMRI��)QMV�*IMWEP��XLI�WSR�SJ�,YWWIMR��WLIVMJ�SJ1IGGE��[LS�VITVIWIRXIH�XLI�%VEF�/MRKHSQ�SJ�,IHNE��WMKRIH�ER�EKVII�QIRX�MR������[MXL�'LEMQ�;IMQERR��[LS�VITVIWIRXIH�XLI�>MSRMWXSVKERMEXMSR��8LMW�EKVIIQIRX�GEPPIH�JSV�XLI�XEOMRK�SJ�EPP�RIGIWWEV]�QIEW�YVIW�XS�©IRGSYVEKI�ERH�WXMQYPEXI�MQQMKVEXMSR�SJ�.I[W�MRXS�4EPIWXMRI�SR�EPEVKI�WGEPI�?MR�SVHIV�XS�EGLMIZIA�GPSWIV�WIXXPIQIRX�ERH�MRXIRWMZI�GYPXMZEXMSRSJ�XLI�PERH�ª�WS�PSRK�EW�©%VEF�TIEWERX�ERH�XIRERX�JEVQIVW�WLEPP�FI�TVS�XIGXIH�MR�XLIMV�VMKLXW��ERH�WLEPP�FI�EWWMWXIH�MR�JSV[EVHMRK�XLIMV�IGSRSQMGHIZIPSTQIRX�ª��-R�E�JSPPS[�YT�PIXXIV�XS�4VSJIWWSV�*IPM\�*VEROJYVXIV��*IMWIPQEHI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�WXEXIQIRXW�

;IJIIP�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W�EVI�GSYWMRW�MR�VEGI��LEZMRK�WYJJIVIH�WMQ�

MPEV�STTVIWWMSRW�EX�XLI�LERHW�SJ�TS[IVW�WXVSRKIV�XLER�XLIQWIPZIW��ERH�F]

E�LETT]�GSMRGMHIRGI�LEZI�FIIR�EFPI�XS�XEOI�XLI�JMVWX�WXIT�XS[EVHW�XLI

EXXEMRQIRX�SJ�XLIMV�REXMSREP�MHIEPW�XSKIXLIV�������

;I%VEFW��IWTIGMEPP]�XLI�IHYGEXIH�EQSRK�YW��PSSO�[MXL�XLI�HIITIWX

W]QTEXL]�SR�XLI�>MSRMWX�QSZIQIRX��3YV�HITYXEXMSR�LIVI�MR�4EVMW�MW�JYPP]

EGUYEMRXIH�[MXL�XLI�TVSTSWEPW�WYFQMXXIH�]IWXIVHE]�F]�XLI�>MSRMWX�3VKE�

RMEXMSR�XS�XLI�4IEGI�'SRJIVIRGI��ERH�[I�VIKEVH�XLIQ�EW�QSHIVEXI�ERH

TVSTIV��;I�[MPP�HS�SYV�FIWX��MR�WS�JEV�EW�[I�EVI�GSRGIVRIH��XS�LIPT�XLIQ

XLVSYKL��[I�[MPP�[MWL�XLI�.I[W�E�QSWX�LIEVX]�[IPGSQI�LSQI��������;I�EVI

[SVOMRK�XSKIXLIV�JSV�E�VIJSVQIH�ERH�VIZMWIH�2IEV�)EWX��ERH�SYV�X[S

QSZIQIRXW�GSQTPIXI�SRI�ERSXLIV��8LI�.I[MWL�QSZIQIRX�MW�REXMSREP�ERH

RSX�MQTIVMEPMWX��3YV�QSZIQIRX�MW�REXMSREP�ERH�RSX�MQTIVMEPMWX��ERH�XLIVI

MW�VSSQ�MR�7]VME�JSV�YW�FSXL��-RHIIH�-�XLMRO�XLEX�RIMXLIV�GER�FI�E�VIEP�WYG�

GIWW�[MXLSYX�XLI�SXLIV���

9RJSVXYREXIP]��XLMW�JEVWMKLXIH�ZMI[�[EW�FPSGOIH�F]�XLI�ZMVYPIRX�ERXM�.I[MWL�FMKSXV]�SJ�XLI�QER�WIPIGXIH�XS�FIGSQI�XLI�PIEHIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRI¬W1YWPMQ�GSQQYRMX]�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 49: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

;LMPI�XLI�%VEFW�[IVI�[MPPMRK�XS�WLEVI�4EPIWXMRI�[MXL�XLI�.I[W��XLI�.I[W[ERXIH�XLI�IRXMVI�GSYRXV]�JSV�XLIQWIPZIW�

8,)�%''97)67

©*VSQ�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�WIVMSYW�>MSRMWX�TPERRMRK�JSV�4EPIWXMRI�������[I�GERRSXI�XLI�MRGVIEWMRK�TVIZEPIRGI�SJ�XLI�MHIE�XLEX�-WVEIP�[EW�XS�FI�FYMPX�SR�XLIVYMRW�SJ�XLI�%VEF�4EPIWXMRI�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�

©?%A�XIVVMXSV]�SRGI�JYPP�SJ�%VEFW�IQIVKIH�JVSQ�E�[EV��E �IWWIRXMEPP]IQTXMIH�SJ�MXW�SVMKMREP�VIWMHIRXW�ERH��F �QEHI�MQTSWWMFPI�JSV�4EPIWXMRMERWXS�VIXYVR�XS��&SXL�XLI�MHISPSKMGEP�ERH�SVKERMEXMSREP�TVITEVEXMSRW�JSV�XLI>MSRMWX�IJJSVX�XS�[MR�4EPIWXMRI��EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�QMPMXEV]�WXVEXIK]�EHSTXIH�IRZMWMSRIH�XEOMRK�SZIV�XIVVMXSV]��ERH�JMPPMRK�MX�[MXL�RI[�MRLEFMXERXW�ª�)H[EVH�7EMH�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�KSEP�SJ�XLI�%VEF�PIEHIVWLMT�[EW�RSX�SRP]�XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRXSJ�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MR�ER]�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�FYX�XS�XVERWJIV�XLI�.I[W�SJ4EPIWXMRI�SYX�SJ�XLIMV�LMWXSVMG�LSQI�ERH�XS�QEOI�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�IQTX]�SJ

;IVI�XLI�.I[W�9R[MPPMRKXS�7LEVI�4EPIWXMRI#

Page 50: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

.I[W��.I[MWL�PIEHIVW��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��[IVI�[MPPMRK�XS�QEOI�TEMRJYPGSQTVSQMWIW�EW�PSRK�EW�XLI]�GSYPH�LEZI�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�MR�XLSWI�EVIEWSJ�4EPIWXMRI�MR�[LMGL�XLI]�[IVI�E�QENSVMX]�

8,)�4633*

7LSVXP]�EJXIV�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�FIGEQI�FMRHMRK�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��WIZ�IVEP�SVKERMIH�TSKVSQW�[IVI�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW��%�'LVMW�XMER�%VEF�IHYGEXSV�HIWGVMFIH�[LEX�LI�SFWIVZIH�MR�[IWXIVR�.IVYWEPIQ�ERHXLI�.I[MWL�UYEVXIV�SJ�XLI�SPH�GMX]�XLEX�LEH�FIIR�.I[MWL�JSV�KIRIVEXMSRW�

?%A�VMSX�FVSOI�SYX��XLI�TISTPI�FIKER�XS�VYR�EFSYX�ERH�WXSRIW�[IVI

XLVS[R�EX�XLI�.I[W��8LI�WLSTW�[IVI�GPSWIH�ERH�XLIVI�[IVI�WGVIEQW�������

-�WE[�E�>MSRMWX�?XLEX�MW��.I[MWL�&VMXMWLA�WSPHMIV�GSZIVIH�MR�HYWX�ERH�FPSSH�

������%JXIV[EVHW��-�WE[�SRI�,IFVSRMXI�ETTVSEGL�E�.I[MWL�WLSIWLMRI�FS]�

[LS�LMH�FILMRH�E�WEGO�MR�SRI�SJ�XLI�?3PH�'MX]A�[EPP¬W�GSVRIVW�RI\X�XS

.EJJE�+EXI��ERH�XEOI�LMW�FS\�ERH�FIEX�LMQ�?XLI�WLSIWLMRI�FS]A�SZIV�XLI

LIEH��,I�WGVIEQIH�ERH�FIKER�XS�VYR��LMW�LIEH�FPIIHMRK�ERH�XLI

,IFVSRMXI�PIJX�LMQ�ERH�VIXYVRIH�XS�XLI�TVSGIWWMSR��������8LI�VMSX

VIEGLIH�MXW�IRMXL��%PP�WLSYXIH��©1YLEQQEH¬W�VIPMKMSR�[EW�FSVR�[MXL

XLI�W[SVH�ª�������-�MQQIHMEXIP]�[EPOIH�XS�XLI�QYRMGMTEP�KEVHIR�������Q]

WSYP�MW�REYWIEXIH�ERH�HITVIWWIH�F]�XLI�QEHRIWW�SJ�LYQEROMRH�ª�

7LSVXP]�XLIVIEJXIV��.I[MWL�[SQIR�[IVI�VETIH�ERH�W]REKSKYIWHIWXVS]IH�MR�E�TSKVSQ�SVKERMIH�F]�E�REXMSREPMWX�KVSYT�GEPPIH�%P�2EHM�%P�%VEFM��%�&VMXMWL�MRZIWXMKEXMSR�GSRGPYHIH��©%PP�XLI�IZMHIRGI�KSIW�XSWLS[�XLEX�XLIWI�EXXEGOW�[IVI�SJ�E�GS[EVHP]�ERH�XVIEGLIVSYW�HIWGVMTXMSR�QSWXP]�EKEMRWX�SPH�QIR��[SQIR�ERH�GLMPHVIR JVIUYIRXP]�MR�XLI�FEGO�ª�

3XLIV�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�XSSO�TPEGI�MR�.EJJE��[LIVI�XLMVXIIR.I[W�[IVI�QYVHIVIH��%�JI[�HE]W�PEXIV��WM\�QSVI�.I[W�[IVI�QYVHIVIH�MR�ERSVERKI�KVSZI��7SSR�XLIVIEJXIV��LYRHVIHW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW�JVSQ8YPOEVQ�EXXEGOIH�XLI�.I[MWL�QSWLEZ�EX�,EHIVE��%XXEGOW�EKEMRWX�ZYPRIVEFPIGMZMPMERW�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�[IVI�FIGSQMRK�XLI�RSVQ�

-R�ER�IJJSVX�XS�GSRXVSP�XLMW�ZMSPIRGI��XLI�&VMXMWL�ETTSMRXIH�,EN�%QMR�EP�,YWWIMRM�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ��XLI�WTMVMXYEP�ERH�IJJIGXMZIP]�TSPMX�MGEP�PIEHIV�SJ�XLI�1YWPMQW�MR�4EPIWXMRI��8LI�LSTI�[EW�XLEX�F]�GIRXVEPMMRKXLI�VIPMKMSYW�ERH�TSPMXMGEP�TS[IV�MR�SRI�QER��[LSQ�XLI�&VMXMWL�XLSYKLXXLI]�GSYPH�GSRXVSP��XLI]�GSYPH�PMQMX�XLI�TEWWMSRW�SJ�XLI�QSF��&YX�XLI]TMGOIH�XLI�[VSRK�QER��,YWWIMRM�[EW�E�ZMVYPIRX�ERXM�7IQMXI� [LSWILEXVIH�SJ�.I[W�[EW�FSXL�VIPMKMSYW�ERH�VEGMEP��,I�[EW�IZIRXYEPP]�XSFIGSQI�E�GPSWI�EPP]�ERH�EHZMWIV�XS�%HSPJ�,MXPIV��ERH�ER�EGXMZI�WYTTSVXIV�SJXLI�©JMREP�WSPYXMSRª XLI�QEWW�QYVHIV�SJ�)YVSTIER�.I[V]��-R�������LIEWOIH�XLI�%\MW�TS[IVW�XS�WIXXPI�XLI�.I[MWL�TVSFPIQ�MR�4EPIWXMRI�MR�EGGSV�

Page 51: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

HERGI�[MXL�XLI�©VEGMEP�MRXIVIWXW�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�EPSRK�PMRIW�WMQMPEV�XSXLSWI�YWIH�XS�WSPZI�XLI�.I[MWL�UYIWXMSR�MR�+IVQER]�ª�,I�YVKIH�,MXPIV�XSI\XIRH�XLI�JMREP�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[LS�LEH�VIEGLIH�4EPIW�XMRI��ERH�LI�EHZMWIH�,MXPIV��MR����� [LIR�MX�[EW�[IPP�ORS[R�[LEX�[EWLETTIRMRK�MR�4SPERH¬W�HIEXL�GEQTW XS�WIRH�XLI�.I[W�XS�©4SPERH��MRSVHIV�XLIVIF]�XS�TVSXIGX�SRIWIPJ�JVSQ�XLIMV�QIREGI�ª�

,YWWIMRM¬W�VEGMWX�LEXVIH�SJ�.I[W�[EW�QERMJIWXIH�IEVP]�MR�LMW�PSRK�GEVIIVEW�KVERH�QYJXM��,I�MRWXMKEXIH�ERXM�.I[MWL�VMSXW�ERH�TVIEGLIH�ERXM�.I[MWLMRGMXIQIRXW��©-XFEL�EP�=ELYHª��OMPP�XLI�.I[W �[EW�XLI�QIWWEKI��EPSRK�[MXL©2EWLVEF�HEQ�EP�=ELYHª��[I�[MPP�HVMRO�XLI�FPSSH�SJ�XLI�.I[W ��8LI�VIWYPX[EW�ER�MRGVIEWI�MR�ERXM�.I[MWL�ZMSPIRGI��%PXLSYKL�XLIVI�LEH�FIIR�IEVPMIVEXXEGOW��IWTIGMEPP]�XLVSYKLSYX�������RS[�XLIWI�EXXEGOW�LEH�XLI�JSVQEPFPIWWMRK�SJ�XLI�SJJMGMEP�PIEHIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRI¬W�1YWPMQW�

8LI�KVERH�QYJXM�EPWS�PIRX�LMW�MQTVMQEXYV�XS�XLI�YR[MPPMRKRIWW�SJ�LMWTISTPI�XS�GSQTVSQMWI��&IJSVI�LMW�EWGIRHERG]�XS�XLI�PIEHIVWLMT�SJ�4EPIW�XMRMER�1YWPMQW��XLIVI�LEH�FIIR�%VEF�ZSMGIW�SJ�GSQTVSQMWI�[MXL�VIKEVH�XSHMZMWMSR�SJ�EYXLSVMX]�SZIV�XLI�PERH�ERH�MXW�TISTPI��*SV�I\EQTPI��SRI�%VEFRI[WTETIV�LEH�[VMXXIR�XLEX�XLI�ORS[R�©IRIVKMIWª�ERH�©PEFSVWª�SJ�XLI.I[MWL�TISTPI�©[SYPH�MQTVSZI�ERH�HIZIPST�XLI�GSYRXV]�XS�XLI�FIRIJMX�SJMXW�%VEF�MRLEFMXERXW�ª��)ZIR�WSQI�[LS�[IVI�GVMXMGEP�SJ�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IG�PEVEXMSR��WYGL�EW�E�KVSYT�SJ�����%VEF�HMKRMXEVMIW�[LS�TIXMXMSRIH�&VMXEMR�MR������[VSXI�XLEX�XLI]�LEH�©EP[E]W�W]QTEXLMIH�TVSJSYRHP]�[MXL�XLI�TIV�WIGYXIH�.I[W�ERH�XLIMV�QMWJSVXYRIW�MR�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW�ª�FYX�XLI]�VIJYWIH�XSFI�VYPIH�F]�XLIWI�.I[W��XLYW�WYKKIWXMRK�XLEX�WSQI�JSVQ�SJ�QYXYEP�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�ER�IUYMXEFP]�TEVXMXMSRIH�4EPIWXMRI�QMKLX�FI�JIEWMFPI���

%PP�XLMW�XEPO�[SYPH�UYMGOP]�IRH�[MXL�XLI�ETTSMRXQIRX�SJ�,YWWIMRM�EWKVERH�QYJXM��;LEX�[SYPH�SXLIV[MWI�LEZI�FIIR�E�TSPMXMGEP�HMWTYXI��WYFNIGX�XSE�TSPMXMGEP�GSQTVSQMWI�VIWSPYXMSR��RS[�FIGEQI�ER�EFWSPYXI�VIPMKMSYW�TVS�LMFMXMSR�XLEX�[EW�RSX�EQIREFPI�XS�ER]�GSQTVSQMWI��EGGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�KVERHQYJXM�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ��MX�[SYPH�ZMSPEXI�-WPEQMG�PE[�JSV�IZIR�SRI�MRGL�SJ�4EPIW�XMRI�XS�FI�GSRXVSPPIH�F]�.I[W��.I[MWL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�EVIEW�[MXL�E�.I[�MWL�QENSVMX] .I[MWL�GMXMIW�ERH�WIXXPIQIRXW�ERH�.I[MWL�LMWXSVMGEP�VSSXW [EWTVSLMFMXIH�F]�-WPEQMG�PE[��EW�,YWWIMRM�I\TSYRHIH�MX��ERH�IZIV]�1YWPMQ�QYWXFI�TVITEVIH�XS�JMKLX�E�LSP]�[EV�XS�TVIZIRX�XLMW�JVSQ�LETTIRMRK��%W�UYMGOP]EW�XLI�X[S���SV�XLVII� �WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�FEWIH�SR�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�ERH�XLIMRXIVREXMSREP�EGGITXERGI�SJ�XLI�TVMRGMTPIW�SJ�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�WIIQIHXS�LSPH�WSQI�TVSQMWI��MX�[EW�XEOIR�SJJ�XLI�XEFPI�F]�,YWWIMRM��%GGSVHMRK�XSXLI�KVERH�QYJXM��XLI�SRP]�WSPYXMSR�[EW�IMXLIV�JSV�XLI�.I[W�XS�FI�HVMZIR�JVSQXLI�PERH�F]�ZMSPIRGI�SV�JSV�E�WQEPP�RYQFIV�SJ�.I[W�XS�VIQEMR�MR�E�1YWPMQPERH�EW�(MQQMWIGSRH�GPEWW�RSRGMXMIRW�WYFNIGX�XS�XLI�EFWSPYXI�GSRXVSP�SJXLI�1YWPMQW���,I�QEHI�MX�IQMRIRXP]�GPIEV�XLEX�MJ�1YWPMQW�IZIV�GSRXVSPPIHEPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��QSWX�SJ�XLI�.I[W�[SYPH�FI�XVERWJIVVIH�SYX���

8LIVI�[IVI��SJ�GSYVWI��.I[W�[LS�[ERXIH�XS�GSRXVSP�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI SV

Page 52: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

EX�PIEWX�XLI����TIVGIRX�XLEX�[EW�PIJX�EJXIV�8VERWNSVHER�[EW�TEVXMXMSRIH�JVSQ[LEX�[EW�SVMKMREPP]�4EPIWXMRI�MRXS�ER�I\GPYWMZIP]�%VEF�WXEXI��&YX�GSQTVS�QMWI�[EW�EP[E]W�WIIR�EW�E�TVEKQEXMG�RIGIWWMX]�F]�XLI�QEMRWXVIEQ�>MSRMWXWERH�XLIMV�PIEHIVWLMT��8LI�VIEPMX]�SJ�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�[MXL�E�.I[MWLQENSVMX]�TSTYPEXMSR�[EW�JEV�QSVI�MQTSVXERX�XLER�XLI�WMI�SJ�XLEX�LSQI�PERH��-RHIIH��WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�[EW�VIEPMWXMG�SRP]�MR�XLSWI�TEVXW�SJ�4EPIW�XMRI�XLEX�[IVI�EPVIEH]�.I[MWL�F]�HIQSKVETLMGW�ERH�F]�XLI�TVIWIRGI�SJ.I[MWL�MRWXMXYXMSRW�SR�XLI�KVSYRH��8LI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�)YVSTI�XSKIXLIV�[MXL�XLI�7ITLEVHMG�.I[W�ERH�XLIMV�HIWGIRHERXW��[IVI�GVIEXMRK�E.I[MWL�LSQI�SRP]�MR�GIVXEMR�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��QEOMRK�XIVVMXSVMEP�GSQ�TVSQMWI�MRIZMXEFPI�ERH�PIEZMRK�VSSQ�JSV�ERSXLIV�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�SR�XLI[IWX�FERO�SJ�XLI�.SVHER�

8LI�HIZIPSTMRK�GPEWL�FIX[IIR�XLI�.I[W�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��PIH�F]�XLI�TVEK�QEXMG�WSGMEPMWX�(EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR��ERH�XLI�1YWPMQW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��PIH�F]�XLIYRGSQTVSQMWMRK�.I[�LEXIV�,EN�%QMR�EP�,YWWIMRM��[EW�RSXSZIV�[LIXLIVXLI�.I[W�SV�XLI�1YWPMQW�[SYPH�GSRXVSP�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�[EW�PIJX�EJXIV8VERWNSVHER�[EW�QEHI�MRXS�ER�I\GPYWMZIP]�%VEF�IQMVEXI��-RWXIEH��MX�[EWVIEPMWXMGEPP]�ZMI[IH [LIXLIV�XLI�VIQEMRHIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�XS�FI�KMZIRI\GPYWMZIP]�XS�XLI�1YWPMQW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�SV�[LIXLIV�MX�[SYPH�FI�JEMVP]HMZMHIH�FIX[IIR�XLI�.I[W�ERH�XLI�1YWPMQW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��IEGL�SJ�[LSQIJJIGXMZIP]�GSRXVSPPIH�GIVXEMR�EVIEW��4YX�ERSXLIV�[E]��XLI�UYIWXMSR�[EW[LIXLIV�XLI�;MPWSR�TVMRGMTPI�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�[SYPH�EPPS[�IEGLKVSYT�XS�GSRXVSP�MXW�S[R�TISTPI�ERH�MXW�S[R�HIWXMR]��8S�XLMW�UYIWXMSR��XLIKVERH�QYJXM�LEH�E�WMQTPI�ERW[IV��RS�JSV�XLI�.I[W��]IW�JSV�XLI�1YWPMQW�

8LI�KVERH�QYJXM¬W�ETTVSEGL�XS�XLI�.I[W�SJ�4EPIWXMRI HIWXVS]�XLIQ�F]JSVGI��JVMKLXIR�XLIQ�MRXS�PIEZMRK�F]�HMVIGXMRK�ZMSPIRGI�EKEMRWX�XLIMV�QSWXZYPRIVEFPI�GMZMPMERW��SV�XVERWJIV�XLIQ�F]�PE[ GYPQMREXIH�MR�XLI�,IFVSRQEWWEGVI�SJ�������8LI�.I[W�SJ�,IFVSR�[IVI�RIMXLIV�EPP�>MSRMWXW�RSV�)YVS�TIER�VIJYKIIW��1ER]�[IVI�VIPMKMSYWP]�SFWIVZERX�7ITLEVHMG��.I[W�[LS�PMZIHMR�,IFVSR�FIGEYWI�SJ�MXW�FMFPMGEP�WMKRMJMGERGI�EW�XLI�FMVXLTPEGI�SJ�.YHEMWQERH�XLI�WIZIVEP�.I[MWL�WIQMREVMIW�ERH�ERGMIRX�W]REKSKYIW�XLEX�[IVI�MR�XLEXLSP]�GMX]�

8LI�,IFVSR�QEWWEGVI�[EW�XLI�GYPQMREXMSR�SJ�E�WIVMIW�SJ�VIPMKMSYWP]MRWTMVIH�QEWWEGVIW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�MRGMXIH�F]�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM��-R�3GXSFIV������XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�SVKERMIH�E�WIVMIW�SJ�TVSZSGEXMSRW�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W[LS�TVE]IH�EX�XLI�;IWXIVR�;EPP��.YHEMWQ¬W�LSPMIWX�WMXI�FIGEYWI�MX�MWFIPMIZIH�XS�FI�XLI�SRP]�VIQRERX�SJ�XLI�7IGSRH�8IQTPI��8LI�QYJXM�SVHIVIHRI[�GSRWXVYGXMSR�©RI\X�XS�ERH�SR�XST�SJ�XLI�[EPPª�[MXL�FVMGOW�SJXIR�JEPPMRKSR�.I[MWL�[SVWLMTIVW��XLI�HVMZMRK�SJ�QYPIW�©XLVSYKL�XLIMV�TVE]MRK�EVIE�SJXIR�HVSTTMRK�I\GVIQIRX�ª�ERH�XLI�XYVRMRK�YT�SJ�XLI�ZSPYQI�SJ�QYI MRW�-WPEQMG�GEPPIVW �HYVMRK�.I[MWL�TVE]IV���8LI�.I[W�TVSXIWXIH�ERH�XIRWMSRWVIQEMRIH�LMKL�JSV�QSRXLW��-R�%YKYWX�������PIEJPIXW�TVITEVIH�F]�XLI�QYJXMMRWXVYGXIH�1YWPMQW�XS�EXXEGO�XLI�.I[W��3RI�WYGL�PIEJPIX�WEMH�XLEX�.I[W�LEH

Page 53: The Case For Israel

©ZMSPEXIH�XLI�LSRSV�SJ�-WPEQª��ERH�LEH�©VETIH�XLI�[SQIR�ERH�QYVHIVIH[MHS[W�ERH�FEFMIW�ª�-X�[EW�E�FPSSH�PMFIP�HIQERHMRK�E�LSP]�[EV�EKEMRWX�XLI.I[W��%�[IPP�SVKERMIH�QSF�FYVRIH�.I[MWL�TVE]IV�FSSOW�EX�XLI�;IWXIVR;EPP�ERH�HIWXVS]IH�RSXIW�SJ�WYTTPMGEXMSR�PIJX�MR�MXW�GVIZMGIW��8LMW�[EW�JSP�PS[IH�F]�EXXEGOW�SR�.I[W�ERH�XLI�FYVRMRK�SJ�.I[MWL�WXSVIW��[MXL�%VEFTSPMGIQIR�NSMRMRK�MR�XLI�EXXEGOW�

3R�%YKYWX�����,IFVSR�[EW�EXXEGOIH��9REVQIH�]IWLMZE�WXYHIRXW�[IVIQYVHIVIH��.I[MWL�LSQIW�[IVI�EXXEGOIH��ERH�XLIMV�SGGYTERXW�[IVI�WPEYKL�XIVIH��7M\X]�.I[W�[IVI�OMPPIH�ERH�XLI�VIQEMRHIV�[IVI�GLEWIH�SYX�SJ�XS[R�8LI�W]REKSKYIW�[IVI�HIWIGVEXIH��*SV�XLI�JMVWX�XMQI�MR�GIRXYVMIW��,IFVSR[EW�QEHI�IQTX]�SJ�.I[W��8LI�KVERH�QYJXM¬W�TSPMG]�SJ�IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK�SJ.I[MWL�MRLEFMXERXW�[EW�FIMRK�MQTPIQIRXIH�[MXL�E�ZIRKIERGI��8LI�&VMXMWLTSPMGI�GLMIJ�SJ�,IFVSR�PEXIV�KEZI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�XIWXMQSR]�

3R�LIEVMRK�WGVIEQW�MR�E�VSSQ��-�[IRX�YT�E�WSVX�SJ�XYRRIP�TEWWEKI�ERH

WE[�ER�%VEF�MR�XLI�EGX�SJ�GYXXMRK�SJJ�E�GLMPH¬W�LIEH�[MXL�E�W[SVH��,I�LEH

EPVIEH]�LMX�LMQ�ERH�[EW�LEZMRK�ERSXLIV�GYX��FYX�SR�WIIMRK�QI��LI�XVMIH�XS

EMQ�XLI�WXVSOI�EX�QI�FYX�QMWWIH��LI�[EW�TVEGXMGEPP]�MR�XLI�QY PI�SJ�Q]

VMJPI��-�WLSX�LMQ�PS[�MR�XLI�KVSMR��&ILMRH�LMQ�[EW�E�.I[MWL�[SQER

WQSXLIVIH�MR�FPSSH�[MXL�E�QER�-�VIGSKRMIH�EW�E?R�%VEFA�TSPMGI�GSRWXE�

FPI�REQIH�-WWE�7LIVMP�JVSQ�.EJJE��������,I�[EW�WXERHMRK�SZIV�XLI�[SQER

[MXL�E�HEKKIV�MR�LMW�LERH��,I�WE[�QI�ERH�FSPXIH�MRXS�E�VSSQ�GPSWI�F]

ERH�XVMIH�XS�WLYX�QI�SYX WLSYXMRK�MR�%VEFMG��©=SYV�,SRSV��-�EQ�E

TSPMGIQER�ª�-�KSX�MRXS�XLI�VSSQ�ERH�WLSX�LMQ���

8LI�VMSXMRK�WSSR�VIEGLIH�7EJEH��[LIVI����.I[W�[IVI�QYVHIVIH�SV�WIVM�SYWP]�MRNYVIH���%HHMXMSREP�QYVHIVW�XSSO�TPEGI�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�.I[MWLEVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��&IJSVI�XLI�SVGLIWXVEXIH�FPSSHWLIH�[EW�SZIV������.I[WLEH�FIIR�QYVHIVIH�ERH�����MRNYVIH���

8LI�&VMXMWL�GSRHIQRIH�©XLI�EXVSGMSYW�EGXW�GSQQMXXIH�F]�FSHMIW�SJVYXLPIWW�ERH�FPSSHXLMVWX]�IZMPHSIVW�ª�8LI]�VEMPIH�EKEMRWX�XLI�©QYVHIVW�TIV�TIXVEXIH�YTSR�HIJIRWIPIWW�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR�������EGGSQ�TERMIH��EW�MR�,IFVSR��F]�EGXW�SJ�YRWTIEOEFPI�WEZEKIV]�ª��8LI]�FPEQIH�XLIQYVHIVW�SR�©VEGMEP�ERMQSWMX]�SR�XLI�TEVX�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�ª��

-R�XV]MRK�XS�HIJIRH�LMQWIPJ�EKEMRWX�GLEVKIW�XLEX�LI�MRGMXIH�XLITSKVSQW��XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�FPEQIH�XLI�ZMGXMQW��'MXMRK�8LI�4VSXSGSPW�SJ�XLI)PHIVW�SJ�>MSR�E�RSXSVMSYW�GEVMWX�JSVKIV]�PSRK�YWIH�F]�ERXM�7IQMXIW �,YWWIMRM�GPEMQIH�XLEX�MX�[EW�XLI�.I[W�[LS�EXXEGOIH�XLI�1YWPMQW�

8LI�&VMXMWL�ORI[�XLEX�XLI�TVIQIHMXEXIH�ZMSPIRGI�[EW�MRWTMVIH�F]�XLIQYJXM�XS�WIRH�E�GPIEV�QIWWEKI�XLEX�IZIR�QSVI�ZMSPIRGI�[SYPH�IRWYI�YRPIWWXLI�&VMXMWL�EKVIIH�XS�GYVXEMP�MQQMKVEXMSR��&YX�MRWXIEH�SJ�VIWTSRHMRK�XS1YWPMQ�ZMSPIRGI�F]�GVEGOMRK�HS[R�SR�MXW�TIVTIXVEXSVW��XLI�&VMXMWL�TYRMWLIHMXW�ZMGXMQW�F]�KMZMRK�XLI�QYJXM�I\EGXP]�[LEX�LI�[EW�WIIOMRK��E�VIHYGXMSR�MR

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 54: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

.I[MWL�MQQMKVEXMSR�ERH�E�WXEXIQIRX�F]�XLI�&VMXMWL�LMKL�GSQQMWWMSRIV�XLEXXLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�[EW�E�©GSPSWWEP�FPYRHIV�ª��-X�[SYPH�RSX�FI�XLI�PEWXXMQI�XLEX�XLI�&VMXMWL�[SYPH�VI[EVH�XLI�GEPGYPEXIH�XIVVSVMWX�ZMSPIRGIHMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�YREVQIH�.I[MWL�GMZMPMERW��-RHIIH��MX�[EW�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJE�TEXXIVR��RIEVP]�IZIV]�XMQI�XLI�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMX]�QEHI�ER]�TVSKVIWW��XLIQYJXM�[SYPH�TPE]�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�GEVH�ERH�QYVHIV�MRRSGIRX�.I[W��8LMW�[SYPHTIVWYEHI�XLI�&VMXMWL�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW�[IVI�©MVVEXMSREPª�ERH�XLEX�XLIMVHIQERHW�QYWX�FI�QIX���%W�[I�[MPP�WII�PEXIV��,YWWIMRM¬W�VIPEXMZI��=EWWIV%VEJEX��[EW�XS�VITIEX�XLMW�TEXXIVR�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XIVVSVMWQ��ERH�XLI�[SVPH[SYPH�VITIEX�MXW�VIWTSRWI�F]�VI[EVHMRK��ERH�XLYW�IRGSYVEKMRK��MX� �0IWW�[EWI\TIGXIH�SJ�XLI�©MVVEXMSREPª�%VEFW�XLER�SJ�XLI�©GMZMPMIHª�.I[W���8LMW�JSVQSJ�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�VEGMWQ VEGMWQ�EKEMRWX�FYX�YPXMQEXIP]�JEZSVEFPI�XS�XLI%VEFW LEW�VIGYVVIH�MR�GYVVIRX�XMQIW� �

8LI�KVERH�QYJXM�GLEVEGXIVMIH�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�.I[MWL�[SQIR��GLMPHVIR�ERH�WXYHIRXW�MR�,IFVSR�EW�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�E�VIZSPX��[LMGL�GSRXMRYIHXLVSYKL�XLI�����W��[MXL�IZIR�KVIEXIV�VI[EVHW�JVSQ�XLI�&VMXMWL��8LI�GYV�XEMPQIRX�SJ�.I[MWL�MQQMKVEXMSR�MRXS�4EPIWXMRI�GSYPH�RSX�LEZI�GSQI�EX�E[SVWI�XMQI�JSV�XLI�.I[W��WMRGI�%HSPJ�,MXPIV�[EW�WSSR�XS�FIGSQI�XLI�J�LVIVSJ�+IVQER]�[MXL�E�TVSKVEQ�XS�VMH�)YVSTI�SJ�MXW�.I[W��IMXLIV�F]�IQMKVEXMSRSV�F]�KIRSGMHI�

Page 55: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�.I[W�LEZI�EP[E]W�VINIGXIH�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��[LIVIEW�XLI�%VEFWLEZI�EGGITXIH�MX�

8,)�%''97)67

©1SWX�MQTSVXERXP]�SJ�EPP��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�HMH�RSX�FIPMIZI��ERH�[IVI�VMKLXRSX�XS�FIPMIZI��XLEX�&IR�+YVMSR�ERH�XLI�SXLIV�PIEHMRK�>MSRMWXW�[SYPH�FIWEXMWJMIH�[MXL��SV�EFMHI�F]��E�GSQTVSQMWI��8LI]�JIEVIH��MR�SXLIV�[SVHW�XLEX�XLI�>MSRMWX�©EGGITXERGIª�SJ�XLI�92�TPER�[EW�HMWMRKIRYSYW��XLEX�XLI>MSRMWX�PIEHIVW�[IVI�EHEQERXP]�FIRX�SR�I\TERHMRK�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�XSMRGPYHI�EPP�SJ�FMFPMGEP�4EPIWXMRI��ERH�XLEX�XLI]�[SYPH�WMQTP]�YWI�E�TEVXMXMSRGSQTVSQMWI�EW�XLI�FEWI�JVSQ�[LMGL�XS�I\TERH�PEXIV�ª��.IVSQI�7PEXIV�VIWIEVGL�WGLSPEV�MR�TSPMXMGEP�WGMIRGI�EX�792=§&YJJEPS�

©;I�QYWX�SRP]�VIGEPP�XLI�VIEP�[SVPH��MR�[LMGL�XLI�403�LEH�FIIR�GEPP�MRK�JSV�RIKSXMEXMSRW�ERH�E�TIEGIJYP�WIXXPIQIRX�[MXL�-WVEIP�JSV�QER]�]IEVW[LMPI�XLI�9�7��ERH�-WVEIP�RIZIV�GSYRXIVIH�[MXL�ER]�«VIEWSREFPI�TISTPIVIEH]�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�¬�NYWX�EW�XLI]�HS�RSX�XSHE]�ª��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�

©-J�]SY�YWI�XLI�XIVQ�?VINIGXMSRMWXA�MR�E�RSR�VEGMWX�WIRWI��[I�MRWXERXP]GSRGPYHI�XLEX�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�PIEHW�XLI�VINIGXMSR�JVSRX�ERH�LEW�JSV�QER]

,EZI�XLI�.I[W�%P[E]W6INIGXIH�XLI�8[S�7XEXI7SPYXMSR#

Page 56: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

]IEVW��ERH�XLEX�FSXL�TSPMXMGEP�KVSYTMRKW�MR�-WVEIP�������EVI�WXVMGX�VINIGXMSRMWXW�ERH�XLMW�MW�GSQTPIXIP]�RSR�GSRXVSZIVWMEP�YT�YRXMP�XLI�QMH���W��������-�XLMROMX�LSPHW�VMKLX�YT�XS�XLI�TVIWIRX�ª��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�

8,)�6)%0-8=

%W�WSSR�EW�TEVXMXMSR�MRXS�X[S�WXEXIW�SV�LSQIPERHW�[EW�TVSTSWIH��XLI�.I[WEGGITXIH�MX�ERH�XLI�%VEFW�VINIGXIH�MX�

8,)�4633*

-R����� MR�XLI�QMHWX�SJ�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�VIZSPX�MRWTMVIH�F]�XLI�KVERH�QYJXMXLI�&VMXMWL�TYFPMWLIH�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�6ITSVX�FEWIH�SR�MXW�MRZIWXMKE�XMSR�SJ�XLI�©GEYWIW�SJ�XLI�HMWXYVFERGIW�ª�-X�PIJX�RS�HSYFX�EFSYX�[LS�[EW�EXJEYPX��©SRI�WMHI�TYX�MXWIPJ��RSX�JSV�XLI�JMVWX�XMQI��MR�XLI�[VSRK�F]�VIWSVXMRKXS�JSVGI��[LIVIEW�XLI�SXLIV�WMHI�TEXMIRXP]�OITX�XLI�PE[�ª�8LI�GSQQMWWMSRVIEPMIH�XLEX�XLI�QYVHIVSYW�ZMSPIRGI�EKEMRWX�GMZMPMERW�XLEX�LEH�FIKYR�MRXLI�����W�LEH�FIIR�HIPMFIVEXIP]�SVHIVIH�F]�XLI�QYJXM�ERH�XLI�%VEF�,MKL'SQQMXXII��-X�EPWS�GSRJMVQIH�XLEX�XLI�.I[W�[LS�LEH�GSQI�XS�4EPIWXMRI[IVI�VIJYKIIW��GEPPMRK�>MSRMWQ�©E�GVIIH�SJ�IWGETIª�JVSQ�XLI�TIVWIGYXMSRWYJJIVIH�F]�XLI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�(MEWTSVE��-R�XLI�FVSEHIWX�WIRWI��MX�WE[�XLITVSFPIQ�EW�©JYRHEQIRXEPP]�E�GSRJPMGX�SJ�VMKLX�[MXL�VMKLXª�XLEX�[EW�VSSXIHHIITP]�MR�XLI�TEWX��%JXIV�VIZMI[MRK�XLI�LMWXSVMG�GPEMQW�SJ�XLI�.I[W�ERH�XLI%VEFW��XLI�GSQQMWWMSR�JSYRH�XLIQ�FSXL�GSQTIPPMRK�

8YVRMRK�XS�XLI�TVIWIRX��XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�JSYRH�XLEX�©XLI�W]QTE�XL]�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW�[MXL�XLIMV�OMRWQIR�MR�7]VME�LEH�FIIR�TPEMRP]WLS[R��������&SXL�TISTPIW�GPYRK�XS�XLI�TVMRGMTPI�XLEX�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�TEVX�SJ7]VME�ERH�WLSYPH�RIZIV�LEZI�FIIR�GYX�SJJ�JVSQ�MX�ª�-X�EPWS�JSYRH�XLEX�MX[SYPH�FI�©[LSPP]�YRVIEWSREFPI�XS�I\TIGXª�XLI�.I[W�XS�EGGITX�QMRSVMX]WXEXYW�MR�E�1YWPMQ�WXEXI��IWTIGMEPP]�WMRGI�XLI]�LEH�IWWIRXMEPP]�GVIEXIH�E.I[MWL�LSQI��[MXL�,IFVI[�RI[WTETIVW��,IFVI[�WGLSSPW�ERH�YRMZIVWMXMIW�E�.I[MWL�LSWTMXEP�W]WXIQ��ER�EGXMZI�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�PEFSV�YRMSR�W]WXIQ��ERH�EPPXLI�SXLIV�EXXVMFYXIW�SJ�WXEXILSSH��8LI�.I[MWL�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�[IVI�QSVIPMOI�ER�SRKSMRK�WXEXI�XLER�[IVI�XLI�%VEF�EVIEW��8IP�%ZMZ�[EW�E�.I[MWLQIXVSTSPMW�[MXL�E�TSTYPEXMSR�I\GIIHMRK����������;IWX�.IVYWEPIQ�LEH�E.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ���������JEV�I\GIIHMRK�XLI�1YWPMQ�TSTYPEXMSR�,EMJE��[MXL�MXW�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ����������[EW�LEPJ�.I[MWL��ERH�QYGL�SJ�XLI�FYWMRIWW�EX�MXW�TSVX�©MW�.I[MWL�FYWMRIWW�ª�0SGEP�HIQSGVEXMG�KSZIVR�QIRXW��EW�[IPP�EW�E�REXMSREP�EKIRG]��JIEXYVIH�RIEVP]�X[IRX]�TSPMXMGEP�TEVXMIW�(IQSGVEG]�LEH�GSQI�XS�4EPIWXMRI��EX�PIEWX�XS�MXW�.I[MWL�EVIEW��7S�LEH�EVXERH�GYPXYVI�

Page 57: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

;MXL�IZIV]�]IEV�XLEX�TEWWIW��XLI�GSRXVEWX�FIX[IIR�XLI�MRXIRWIP]�HIQSGVEXMG

ERH�LMKLP]�SVKERMIH�QSHIVR�GSQQYRMX]�ERH�XLI�SPH�JEWLMSRIH�%VEF

[SVPH�EVSYRH�MX�KVS[W�WLEVTIV��ERH�MR�RSXLMRK�TIVLETW�QSVI�QEVOIHP]

XLER�SR�MXW�GYPXYVEP�WMHI��8LI�PMXIVEV]�SYXTYX�SJ�XLI�2EXMSREP�,SQI�MW�SYX

SJ�EPP�TVSTSVXMSR�XS�MXW�WMI��,IFVI[�XVERWPEXMSRW�LEZI�FIIR�TYFPMWLIH�SJ

XLI�[SVOW�SJ�%VMWXSXPI��(IWGEVXIW��0IMFRMX��*MGLXI��/ERX��&IVKWSR��)MR�

WXIMR�ERH�SXLIV�TLMPSWSTLIVW��ERH�SJ�7LEOIWTIEVI��+SIXLI��,IMRI��&]VSR�

(MGOIRW��XLI�KVIEX�6YWWMER�RSZIPMWXW��ERH�QER]�QSHIVR�[VMXIVW��-R�GVIEXMZI

PMXIVEXYVI�XLI�[SVOW�SJ�&MEPMO��[LS�HMIH�MR�������LEZI�FIIR�XLI�SYXWXERH�

MRK�EGLMIZIQIRX�MR�,IFVI[�TSIXV]�ERH�XLEX�SJ�2ELYQ�7SOSPSZ��[LS�HMIH

MR�������MR�,IFVI[�TVSWI��%�RYQFIV�SJ�,IFVI[�RSZIPW�LEZI�FIIR�[VMXXIR

VIJPIGXMRK�XLI�MRJPYIRGI�SR�XLI�.I[MWL�QMRH�SJ�PMJI�MR�XLI�2EXMSREP�,SQI�

8LI�,IFVI[�4VIWW�LEW�I\TERHIH�XS�JSYV�HEMP]�ERH�XIR�[IIOP]�TETIVW��3J

XLI�JSVQIV��XLI�,E¬EVIXERH�XLI�(EZEVEVI�XLI�QSWX�MRJPYIRXMEP�ERH

QEMRXEMR�E�LMKL�PMXIVEV]�WXERHEVH��8[S�TIVMSHMGEPW�EVI�I\GPYWMZIP]�GSR�

GIVRIH�[MXL�PMXIVEXYVI�ERH�SRI�[MXL�HVEQEXMG�EVX��&YX�TIVLETW�XLI�QSWX

WXVMOMRK�EWTIGX�SJ�XLI�GYPXYVI�SJ�XLI�2EXMSREP�,SQI�MW�MXW�PSZI�SJ�QYWMG��-X

[EW�[LMPI�[I�[IVI�MR�4EPIWXMRI��EW�MX�LETTIRIH��XLEX�7MKRSV�8SWGERMRM�GSR�

HYGXIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRI�7]QTLSR]�3VGLIWXVE��GSQTSWIH�SJ�WSQI����4EPIW�

XMRMER�.I[W��MR�WM\�GSRGIVXW�QEMRP]�HIZSXIH�XS�XLI�[SVOW�SJ�&VELQW�ERH

&IIXLSZIR��3R�IEGL�SGGEWMSR�IZIV]�WIEX�[EW�SGGYTMIH��ERH�MX�MW�RSXI[SV�

XL]�XLEX�SRI�GSRGIVX�[EW�VIWIVZIH�JSV�WSQI�������[SVOTISTPI�EX�ZIV]�PS[

VEXIW�ERH�XLEX�ERSXLIV�������EXXIRHIH�XLI�3VGLIWXVE¬W�JMREP�VILIEVWEP��%PP

MR�EPP��XLI�GYPXYVEP�EGLMIZIQIRX�SJ�XLMW�PMXXPI�GSQQYRMX]�SJ���������TISTPI

MW�SRI�SJ�XLI�QSWX�VIQEVOEFPI�JIEXYVIW�SJ�XLI�2EXMSREP�,SQI�ª�

-R�������XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�VIGSQQIRHIH�E�TEVXMXMSR�TPER�F]�[LMGLXS�VIWSPZI�[LEX�MX�GLEVEGXIVMIH�EW�ER�©MVVITVIWWMFPI�GSRJPMGX�������FIX[IIRX[S�REXMSREP�GSQQYRMXMIW�[MXLMR�XLI�REVVS[�FSYRHW�SJ�SRI�WQEPP�GSYR�XV]�ª�&IGEYWI�SJ�XLI�KIRIVEP�LSWXMPMX]�ERH�LEXVIH�SJ�XLI�.I[W�F]�XLI�1YW�PMQW��©REXMSREP�EWWMQMPEXMSR�FIX[IIR�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W�MW�������VYPIH�SYX�ª��

2SV�GSYPH�XLI�.I[W�FI�I\TIGXIH�XS�EGGITX�1YWPMQ�VYPI�SZIV�XLIQ��IWTI�GMEPP]�WMRGI�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�QEHI�MX�GPIEV�XLEX�QSWX�SJ�XLI�.I[W�[SYPH�FIXVERWJIVVIH�SYX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�MJ�XLI�1YWPMQW�KEMRIH�GSQTPIXI�GSRXVSP���8LI4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�GSRGPYHIH�XLEX�TEVXMXMSR�[EW�XLI�SRP]�NYWX�WSPYXMSR�

1ERMJIWXP]�XLI�TVSFPIQ�GERRSX�FI�WSPZIH�F]�KMZMRK�IMXLIV�XLI�%VEFW�SV�XLI

.I[W�[LEX�XLI]�[ERX��8LI�ERW[IV�XS�XLI�UYIWXMSR�©;LMGL�SJ�XLIQ�MR�XLI

IRH�[MPP�KSZIVR�4EPIWXMRI#ª�QYWX�WYVIP]�FI�©2IMXLIV�ª�;I�HS�RSX�XLMRO

XLEX�ER]�JEMV�QMRHIH�WXEXIWQER�[SYPH�WYTTSWI��RS[�XLEX�XLI�LSTI�SJ�LEV�

QSR]�FIX[IIR�XLI�VEGIW�LEW�TVSZIH�YRXIREFPI��XLEX�&VMXEMR�SYKLX�IMXLIV

XS�LERH�SZIV�XS�%VEF�VYPI���������.I[W�������SV�XLEX�MJ�XLI�.I[W�WLSYPH

Page 58: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

FIGSQI�E�QENSVMX]��E�QMPPMSR�SV�WS�SJ�%VEFW�WLSYPH�FI�LERHIH�SZIV�XS

XLIMV�VYPI��&YX��[LMPI�RIMXLIV�VEGI�GER�NYWXP]�VYPI�EPP�4EPIWXMRI��[I�WII�RS

VIEWSR�[L]��MJ�MX�[IVI�TVEGXMGEFPI��IEGL�VEGI�WLSYPH�RSX�VYPI�TEVX�SJ�MX�

2S�HSYFX�XLI�MHIE�SJ�4EVXMXMSR�EW�E�WSPYXMSR�SJ�XLI�TVSFPIQ�LEW�SJXIR

SGGYVVIH�XS�WXYHIRXW�SJ�MX��SRP]�XS�FI�HMWGEVHIH��8LIVI�EVI�QER]�[LS

[SYPH�LEZI�JIPX�ER�MRWXMRGXMZI�HMWPMOI�XS�GYXXMRK�YT�XLI�,SP]�0ERH��8LI

WIZIVERGI�SJ�8VERWNSVHER��XLI]�[SYPH�LEZI�XLSYKLX��JVSQ�LMWXSVMG�4EPIW�

XMRI�[EW�FEH�IRSYKL��3R�XLEX�TSMRX�[I�[SYPH�WYKKIWX�XLEX�XLIVI�MW�PMXXPI

QSVEP�ZEPYI�MR�QEMRXEMRMRK�XLI�TSPMXMGEP�YRMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�EX�XLI�GSWX�SJ

TIVTIXYEP�LEXVIH��WXVMJI�ERH�FPSSHWLIH��ERH�XLEX�XLIVI�MW�PMXXPI�QSVEP�MRNYV]

MR�HVE[MRK�E�TSPMXMGEP�PMRI�XLVSYKL�4EPIWXMRI�MJ�TIEGI�ERH�KSSH[MPP

FIX[IIR�XLI�TISTPIW�SR�IMXLIV�WMHI�SJ�MX�GER�XLIVIF]�MR�XLI�PSRK�VYR�FI

EXXEMRIH��������4EVXMXMSR�WIIQW�XS�SJJIV�EX�PIEWX�E�GLERGI�SJ�YPXMQEXI�TIEGI�

;IGER�WII�RSRI�MR�ER]�SXLIV�TPER���

8LI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�TPER�TVSTSWIH�E�.I[MWL�LSQI�MR�EVIEW�MR�[LMGLXLIVI�[EW�E�GPIEV�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��HMZMHIH�MRXS�X[S�RSRGSRXMKYSYW�WIG�XMSRW��8LI�RSVXLIVR�TSVXMSR�I\XIRHIH�JVSQ�8IP�%ZMZ�XS�XLI�GYVVIRX�FSVHIV[MXL�0IFERSR��-X�GSRWMWXIH�PEVKIP]�SJ�E����QMPI�[MHI�WXVMT�SJ�PERH�JVSQ�XLI1IHMXIVVERIER�IEWX�XS�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�GSEWXEP�TPEMR��XLIR�E�WSQI[LEX�[MHIVEVIE�JVSQ�,EMJE�XS�XLI�7IE�SJ�+EPMPII��%�WSYXLIVR�TSVXMSR��HMWGSRRIGXIHJVSQ�XLI�RSVXLIVR�SRI�F]�E�&VMXMWL�GSRXVSPPIH�EVIE�XLEX�MRGPYHIH.IVYWEPIQ��[MXL�MXW�QENSVMX]�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR��I\XIRHIH�JVSQ�WSYXL�SJ.EJJE�XS�RSVXL�SJ�+EE�

8LI�TVSTSWIH�%VEF�EVIE�[EW��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��IRXMVIP]�GSRXMKYSYWERH�IRGSQTEWWIH�XLI�IRXMVI�2IKIZ��XLI�;IWX�&ERO��ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT��-X[EW�QER]�XMQIW�PEVKIV�XLER�XLI�TVSTSWIH�.I[MWL�LSQI��8LI�TSTYPEXMSR�SJXLI�TVSTSWIH�.I[MWL�EVIE�[SYPH�LEZI�MRGPYHIH���������.I[W�ERH��������%VEFW��1SVI�XLER��������EHHMXMSREP�.I[W�PMZIH�MR�.IVYWEPIQ��[LMGL�[SYPHLEZI�VIQEMRIH�YRHIV�&VMXMWL�GSRXVSP�

8LI�GSQQMWWMSR�WYKKIWXIH�XLEX�SZIV�XMQI�XLIVI�GSYPH�FI�I\GLERKIW�SJPERH�ERH�TSTYPEXMSR�

?8ALI�.I[W�QE]�[MWL�XS�HMWTSWI�SJ�WSQI�SV�EPP�SJ�XLI�PERHW�RS[�S[RIH

F]�XLIQ�[LMGL�PMI�[MXLMR�XLI�FSYRHEVMIW�SJ�XLI�%VEF�WXEXI��ERH�XLIMV

SGGYTERXW�QE]�[MWL�XS�QSZI�MRXS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��������8LI�%VEFW������

QE]�PMOI[MWI�FI�[MPPMRK�XS�WIPP�XLI�PERH�XLI]�S[R�[MXLMR�XLI�FSYRHEVMIW�SJ

XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�?ERH�QSZI�XS�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIA���

8LI�GSQQMWWMSR�WYQQEVMIH�XLI�EHZERXEKIW�SJ�TEVXMXMSR�JSV�FSXL�WMHIW�

8LI�EHZERXEKIW�XS�XLI�%VEFW�SJ�4EVXMXMSR�SR�XLI�PMRIW�[I�LEZI�TVSTSWIH

QE]�FI�WYQQEVMIH�EW�JSPPS[W�

Page 59: The Case For Israel

��

Page 60: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

-�8LI]�SFXEMR�XLIMV�REXMSREP�MRHITIRHIRGI�ERH�GER�GSSTIVEXI�SR�ER

IUYEP�JSSXMRK�[MXL�XLI�%VEFW�SJ�XLI�RIMKLFSVMRK�GSYRXVMIW�MR�XLI

GEYWI�SJ�%VEF�YRMX]�ERH�TVSKVIWW�

--�8LI]�EVI�JMREPP]�HIPMZIVIH�JVSQ�XLI�JIEV�SJ�FIMRK�©W[EQTIHª�F]�XLI

.I[W�ERH�JVSQ�XLI�TSWWMFMPMX]�SJ�YPXMQEXI�WYFNIGXMSR�XS�.I[MWL�VYPI�

---�-R�TEVXMGYPEV��XLI�JMREP�PMQMXEXMSR�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�2EXMSREP�,SQI

[MXLMR�E�JM\IH�JVSRXMIV�ERH�XLI�IREGXQIRX�SJ�E�RI[�1ERHEXI�JSV�XLI

TVSXIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�,SP]�4PEGIW��WSPIQRP]�KYEVERXIIH�F]�XLI�0IEKYI

SJ�2EXMSRW��VIQSZIW�EPP�ER\MIX]�PIWX�XLI�,SP]�4PEGIW�WLSYPH�IZIV

GSQI�YRHIV�.I[MWL�GSRXVSP�

-:�%W�E�WIX�SJJ�XS�XLI�PSWW�SJ�XIVVMXSV]�XLI�%VEFW�VIKEVH�EW�XLIMVW��XLI

%VEF�7XEXI�[MPP�VIGIMZI�E�WYFZIRXMSR�JVSQ�XLI�.I[MWL�7XEXI��-X�[MPP

EPWS��MR�ZMI[�SJ�XLI�FEGO[EVHRIWW�SJ�8VERW�.SVHER��SFXEMR�E�KVERX�SJ

�����������JVSQ�XLI�&VMXMWL�8VIEWYV]��ERH�MJ�ER�EVVERKIQIRX�GER�FI

QEHI�JSV�XLI�I\GLERKI�SJ�PERH�ERH�TSTYPEXMSR��E�JYVXLIV�KVERX�[MPP

FI�QEHI�JSV�XLI�GSRZIVWMSR��EW�JEV�EW�QE]�TVSZI�TSWWMFPI��SJ�YRGYP�

XMZEFPI�PERH�MR�XLI�%VEF�7XEXI�MRXS�TVSHYGXMZI�PERH�JVSQ�[LMGL�XLI

GYPXMZEXSVW�ERH�XLI�WXEXI�EPMOI�[MPP�TVSJMX�

8LI�EHZERXEKIW�SJ�4EVXMXMSR�XS�XLI�.I[W�QE]�FI�WYQQEVMIH�EW

JSPPS[W�

-�4EVXMXMSR�WIGYVIW�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�2EXMSREP�,SQI

ERH�VIPMIZIW�MX�JVSQ�XLI�TSWWMFMPMX]�SJ�MXW�FIMRK�WYFNIGXIH�MR�XLI

JYXYVI�XS�%VEF�VYPI�

--�4EVXMXMSR�IREFPIW�XLI�.I[W�MR�XLI�JYPPIWX�WIRWI�XS�GEPP�XLIMV�2EXMSREP

,SQI�XLIMV�S[R��JSV�MX�GSRZIVXW�MX�MRXS�E�.I[MWL�7XEXI��-XW�GMXMIRW

[MPP�FI�EFPI�XS�EHQMX�EW�QER]�.I[W�MRXS�MX�EW�XLI]�XLIQWIPZIW�FIPMIZI

GER�FI�EFWSVFIH��8LI]�[MPP�EXXEMR�XLI�TVMQEV]�SFNIGXMZI�SJ�>MSR�

MWQ E�.I[MWL�REXMSR�TPERXIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI��KMZMRK�MXW�REXMSREPW�XLI

WEQI�WXEXYW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�EW�SXLIV�REXMSRW�KMZI�XLIMVW��8LI]�[MPP�GIEWI

EX�PEWX�XS�PMZI�E�©QMRSVMX]�PMJI�ª��

*MREPP]��XLI�GSQQMWWMSR�EPPYHIH�XS�LS[�TEVXMXMSR�[SYPH�LIPT�XLI�VIWGYISJ�)YVSTI¬W�.I[W�JVSQ�2EMWQ�

8SFSXL�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W�4EVXMXMSR�SJJIVW�E�TVSWTIGX ERH�[I�WII�RS�WYGL

TVSWTIGX�MR�ER]�SXLIV�TSPMG] SJ�SFXEMRMRK�XLI�MRIWXMQEFPI�FSSR�SJ�TIEGI�

-X�MW�WYVIP]�[SVXL�WSQI�WEGVMJMGI�SR�FSXL�WMHIW�MJ�XLI�UYEVVIP��[LMGL�XLI

1ERHEXI�WXEVXIH��GSYPH�FI�IRHIH�[MXL�MXW�XIVQMREXMSR��-X�MW�RSX�E�REXYVEP

SV�SPH�WXERHMRK�JIYH��%R�EFPI�%VEF�I\TSRIRX�SJ�XLI�%VEF�GEWI�XSPH�YW�XLEX

XLI�%VEFW�XLVSYKLSYX�XLIMV�LMWXSV]�LEZI�RSX�SRP]�FIIR�JVII�JVSQ�ERXM�

.I[MWL�WIRXMQIRX�FYX�LEZI�EPWS�WLS[R�XLEX�XLI�WTMVMX�SJ�GSQTVSQMWI�MW

Page 61: The Case For Israel

HIITP]�VSSXIH�MR�XLIMV�PMJI��%RH�LI�[IRX�SR�XS�I\TVIWW�LMW�W]QTEXL]�[MXL

XLI�JEXI�SJ�XLI�.I[W�MR�)YVSTI��©8LIVI�MW�RS�HIGIRX�QMRHIH�TIVWSR�ª�LI

WEMH��©[LS�[SYPH�RSX�[ERX�XS�HS�IZIV]XLMRK�LYQERP]�TSWWMFPI�XS�VIPMIZI

XLI�HMWXVIWW�SJ�XLSWI�TIVWSRW�ª�TVSZMHIH�XLEX�MX�[EW�©RSX�EX�XLI�GSWX�SJ

MRJPMGXMRK�E�GSVVIWTSRHMRK�HMWXVIWW�SR�ERSXLIV�TISTPI�ª�'SRWMHIVMRK�[LEX

XLI�TSWWMFMPMX]�SJ�JMRHMRK�E�VIJYKI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�QIERW�XS�QER]�XLSYWERH

WYJJIVMRK�.I[W��[I�GERRSX�FIPMIZI�XLEX�XLI�©HMWXVIWWª�SGGEWMSRIH�F]�

4EVXMXMSR��KVIEX�EW�MX�[SYPH�FI��MW�QSVI�XLER�%VEF�KIRIVSWMX]�GER�FIEV�

%RH�MR�XLMW��EW�MR�WS�QYGL�IPWI�GSRRIGXIH�[MXL�4EPIWXMRI��MX�MW�RSX�SRP]�XLI

TISTPIW�SJ�XLEX�GSYRXV]�XLEX�LEZI�XS�FI�GSRWMHIVIH��8LI�.I[MWL�4VSFPIQ

MW�RSX�XLI�PIEWX�SJ�XLI�QER]�TVSFPIQW��[LMGL�EVI�HMWXYVFMRK�MRXIVREXMSREP

VIPEXMSRW�EX�XLMW�GVMXMGEP�XMQI�ERH�SFWXVYGXMRK�XLI�TEXL�XS�TIEGI�ERH�TVSW�

TIVMX]��-J�XLI�%VEFW�EX�WSQI�WEGVMJMGI�GSYPH�LIPT�XS�WSPZI�XLEX�TVSFPIQ�

XLI]�[SYPH�IEVR�XLI�KVEXMXYHI�RSX�SJ�XLI�.I[W�EPSRI�FYX�SJ�EPP�XLI�;IWX�

IVR�;SVPH���

8LI�.I[W�VIPYGXERXP]�EGGITXIH�XLI�4IIP�TEVXMXMSR�TPER��[LMPI�XLI�%VEFWGEXIKSVMGEPP]�VINIGXIH�MX��HIQERHMRK�XLEX�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�FI�TPEGIH�YRHIV%VEF�GSRXVSP�ERH�XLEX�QSWX�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�FI©XVERWJIVVIHª�SYX�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]��FIGEYWI�©XLMW�GSYRXV]�?GERRSXA�EWWMQMPEXIXLI�.I[W�RS[�MR�XLI�GSYRXV]�ª��8LI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�MQTPMGMXP]�VIGSK�RMIH�XLEX�MX�[EW�RSX�WS�QYGL�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW�[ERXIH�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�EWXLEX�XLI]�HMH�RSX�[ERX�XLI�.I[W�XS�LEZI�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�SV�WSZIVIMKRX]SZIV�XLI�PERH�XLI�.I[W�XLIQWIPZIW�LEH�GYPXMZEXIH�ERH�MR�[LMGL�XLI]�[IVI�EQENSVMX]��%JXIV�EPP��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[ERXIH�XS�FI�TEVX�SJ�7]VME�ERH�FI�VYPIHSZIV�F]�E�HMWXERX�QSREVGL��8LI]�WMQTP]�GSYPH�RSX�EFMHI�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEXXLI�.I[W�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�LEH�GVIEXIH�JSV�XLIQWIPZIW�E�HIQSGVEXMG�LSQIPERHTYVWYERX�XS�XLI�0IEKYI�SJ�2EXMSRW�QERHEXI�ERH�FMRHMRK�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�)ZIR�MJ�XYVRMRK�HS[R�XLI�4IIP�TVSTSWEP�VIWYPXIH�MR�RS�WXEXI�JSV�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW��XLEX�[EW�TVIJIVEFPI�XS�EPPS[MRK�IZIR�E�XMR]��RSRGSRXMKYSYW�WXEXI�JSVXLI�.I[W��;LIR�XLI�&VMXMWL�GSRZIRIH�E�QIIXMRK�FIX[IIR�XLI�TEVXMIW��©XLI%VEFW�[SYPH�RSX�WMX�MR�XLI�WEQI�VSSQ�EW�XLI�.I[W�ª��*YVXLIV��XLI]VIWTSRHIH�XS�XLI�4IIP�TPER�[MXL�QEWWMZI�ZMSPIRGI�HMVIGXIH�EX�.I[MWL�GMZMP�MERW��EW�[IPP�EW�EX�&VMXMWL�TSPMGI�ERH�GMZMP�WIVZERXW�

8LMW�MQTEWWI��VIWYPXMRK�JVSQ�%VEF�VINIGXMSR�SJ�©EPP�EXXIQTXW�XS�KMZI�ER]TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�SZIV�XS�.I[MWL�WSZIVIMKRX]�ª��GSYTPIH�[MXL�%VEF�ZMS�PIRGI��PIH�HMVIGXP]�XS�XLI�&VMXMWL�HIGMWMSR�XS�GYVXEMP�XLI�JPS[�SJ�.I[MWLVIJYKIIW�MRXS�4EPIWXMRI��HIWTMXI�EGORS[PIHKQIRX�MR�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR6ITSVXXLEX�©.I[W�IRXIV�4EPIWXMRI�EW�SJ�VMKLX�ERH�RSX�SR�WYJJIVERGI�ª�ERHXLEX�©.I[MWL�-QQMKVEXMSR�MW�RSX�QIVIP]�WERGXMSRIH�FYX�VIUYMVIH�F]WSPIQR�MRXIVREXMSREP�EKVIIQIRXW�ª��8LI�&VMXMWL�;LMXI�4ETIV�SJ������PMQMXIH�.I[MWL�MQQMKVEXMSR�XS��������SZIV�XLI�RI\X�JMZI�]IEVW��&VMXEMR�LEH�FIGSQI�XLI�FEVVMIV�XS�MRHITIRHIRGI�ERH�WXEXILSSH�JSV�XLI�.I[MWL

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 62: The Case For Israel

GSQQYRMX]�MR�4EPIWXMRI��&VMXMWL�MQTIVMEPMWXMG�KSEPW�RS[�JEZSVIH�XLI�%VEFWSZIV�XLI�.I[W�

%W�1MGLEIP�3VIR�TYX�MX��©8LSYKL�XLI�&VMXMWL�LEH�WXIEHMP]�EFERHSRIHXLIMV�WYTTSVX�JSV�E�.I[MWL�2EXMSREP�,SQI��XLI�LSQI�[EW�EPVIEH]�E�JEGX��ERMRGLSEXI��FYVKISRMRK�WXEXI�ª��&YX�MX�[EW�E�WXEXI�XLEX�[EW�FIMRK�TVIZIRXIHF]�&VMXEMR��EX�XLI�HIQERH�SJ�XLI�%VEFW��JVSQ�STIRMRK�MXW�KEXIW�XS�XLSWIVIJYKIIW�QSWX�MR�RIIH��8LMW�GSMRGMHIH�[MXL�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�,SPS�GEYWX��MR�[LMGL�WM\�QMPPMSR�.I[W�[IVI�QYVHIVIH��,EH�XLI�%VEFW�EGGITXIHXLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�VIGSQQIRHIH�F]�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR��MRWXIEH�SJVIWTSRHMRK�[MXL�ZMSPIRGI��LYRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW TIVLETW�IZIR�E�QMPPMSRSV�QSVI )YVSTIER�.I[W�GSYPH�LEZI�FIIR�WEZIH��WMRGI�XLI�2EM�TVSKVEQ�YT�YRXMP�������GEPPIH�JSV�.I[W�XS�FI�I\TIPPIH�JVSQ�)YVSTI�FYX�RSX�RIGIW�WEVMP]�QYVHIVIH��8LI�©JMREP�WSPYXMSRª�FIGEQI�XLI�WSPYXMSR�SJ�GLSMGI�JSVXLI�2EMW�SRP]�[LIR�MX�FIGEQI�GPIEV�XLEX�XLIVI�[EW�RS[LIVI�JSV�XLI�.I[WSJ�)YVSTI�XS�KS��I\GITX�XS�XLI�KEW�GLEQFIVW�ERH�OMPPMRK�JMIPHW�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 63: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�.I[W�LEZI�I\TPSMXIH�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�XS�KEMR�W]QTEXL]�JSV�E�.I[MWL�WXEXIEX�XLI�I\TIRWI�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��[LS�FIEV�RS�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�,MXPIV¬WKIRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LI�,SPSGEYWX�LEW�TVSZIH�XS�FI�ER�MRHMWTIRWMFPI�MHISPSKMGEP�[IETSR�8LVSYKL�MXW�HITPS]QIRX��SRI�SJ�XLI�[SVPH¬W�QSWX�JSVQMHEFPI�QMPMXEV]TS[IVW��[MXL�ER�LSVVIRHSYW�LYQER�VMKLXW�VIGSVH��LEW�GEWX�MXWIPJ�EW�E�«ZMG�XMQ¬�WXEXI��ERH�XLI�QSWX�WYGGIWWJYP�IXLRMG�KVSYT�MR�XLI�97�LEW�PMOI[MWIEGUYMVIH�ZMGXMQ�WXEXYW��'SRWMHIVEFPI�HMZMHIRHW�EGGVYI�JVSQ�XLMW�WTIGMSYWZMGXMQLSSH MR�TEVXMGYPEV��MQQYRMX]�XS�GVMXMGMWQ��LS[IZIV�NYWXMJMIH�ª�2SVQER�*MROIPWXIMR�

©;LEX�QEOIW�QER]�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�%VEFW�)<86)1)0=�%2+6=�MWXLEX�XLI�QIQSVMIW�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�EVI�FIMRK�I\TPSMXIH�XS�TEMRX�4EPIW�XMRMERW�EW�2EMW��7YGL�HERKIVSYW�GSQTEVMWSR�ERH�TVSTEKERHE�XEGXMGW�EVIGSRXMRYSYWP]�JIH�XS�QER]�-WVEIPM�ERH�.I[MWL�WGLSSP�GLMPHVIR�JVSQ�MRGIT�XMSR��IWTIGMEPP]�YTSR�ZMWMXMRK�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�QYWIYQ�EX�=EH�:EWLIQ��-XWLSYPH�FI�IQTLEWMIH�XLEX�QER]�PMJI�WMI�TMGXYVIW�SJ�EP�,ENN�%QMR�WXERH�MRK�EPSRKWMHI�,MXPIV�EVI�SR�HMWTPE]�EX�=EH�:EWLIQ��NYWX�;IWX�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ

,EZI�XLI�.I[W�)\TPSMXIHXLI�,SPSGEYWX#

Page 64: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

RSX�JEV�JVSQ�(IMV�=EWWMR��-X�MW�L]TSGVMXMGEP�XS�LSPH�4EPIWXMRMERW�VIWTSRWMFPIJSV�XLI�«MPP�JEXIH¬�GLSMGI�SJ�EP�,ENN�%QMR��[LMPI�-WVEIPMW�ERH�.I[W�WXMPP�FPMRHXLIQWIPZIW�XS�XLI�GLSMGIW�WSQI�SJ�XLIMV�PIEHIVW�QEHI�HYVMRK�;;�--�ª�[[[�4EPIWXMRI6IQIQFIVIH�GSQ�VIWTSRHMRK�XS�©-WVEIPM�>MSRMWXW�TVSTE�KERHEª�XLEX�,ENN�%QMR�EP�,YWWIMRM�GSPPEFSVEXIH�[MXL�2EMW�HYVMRK�;;--

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�[MXL�XLI�EGUYMIWGIRGI�SJ�QSWX�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMR�MER�%VEFW�EGXMZIP]�WYTTSVXIH�ERH�EWWMWXIH�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�ERH�2EM�+IV�QER]�ERH�FIEVW�GSRWMHIVEFPI�QSVEP��TSPMXMGEP��ERH�IZIR�PIKEP�GYPTEFMPMX]�JSVXLI�QYVHIV�SJ�QER]�.I[W�

8,)�4633*

7LSVXP]�EJXIV�,MXPIV�GEQI�XS�TS[IV��XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�HIGMHIH�XS�IQYPEXILMQ��,I�MRJSVQIH�XLI�+IVQER�GSRWYP�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�XLEX�©XLI�1YWPMQWMRWMHI�ERH�SYXWMHI�4EPIWXMRI�[IPGSQI�XLI�RI[�VIKMQI�SJ�+IVQER]�ERHLSTI�JSV�XLI�I\XIRWMSR�SJ�XLI�JEWGMWX�ERXM�HIQSGVEXMG��KSZIVRQIRXEP�W]WXIQXS�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW�ª�-R�ER�IJJSVX�XS�FVMRK�MX�XS�LMW�S[R�GSYRXV]��,YWWIMRMSVKERMIH�XLI�©2EM�7GSYXW�ª�FEWIH�SR�XLI�©,MXPIV�=SYXL�ª�8LI�W[EWXMOEFIGEQI�E�[IPGSQI�W]QFSP�EQSRK�QER]�4EPIWXMRMERW�

8LI�QMH��XS�PEXI�����W�[IVI�QEVOIH�F]�%VEF�IJJSVXW�XS�GYVXEMP�MQQM�KVEXMSR�ERH�.I[MWL�IJJSVXW�XS�VIWGYI�EW�QER]�.I[W�EW�TSWWMFPI�JVSQ�,MXPIV¬W)YVSTI��8LIWI�]IEVW�[IVI�EPWS�QEVOIH�F]�IWGEPEXMRK�1YWPMQ�ZMSPIRGISVGLIWXVEXIH�F]�,YWWIMRM�ERH�SXLIV�1YWPMQ�PIEHIVW��-R�������%VEF�XIVVSV�MWQ�XSSO�SR�E�RI[�HMQIRWMSR��-R�XLI�FIKMRRMRK��XLI�XEVKIXW�[IVI�HIJIRWI�PIWW�.I[MWL�GMZMPMERW�MR�LSWTMXEPW��QSZMI�XLIEXIVW��LSQIW��ERH�WXSVIW��8LMW[EW�JSPPS[IH�F]�WXVMOIW�ERH�WLST�GPSWYVIW��XLIR�F]�XLI�FSQFMRK�SJ�&VMXMWLSJJMGIW��8LI�2EM�VIKMQI�MR�+IVQER]�ERH�XLI�-XEPMER�JEWGMWXW�WYTTSVXIH�XLIZMSPIRGI��WIRHMRK�QMPPMSRW�SJ�HSPPEVW�XS�XLI�QYJXM��

8LI�77��YRHIV�XLI�PIEHIVWLMT�SJ�,IMRVMGL�,MQQPIV��TVSZMHIH�FSXLJMRERGMEP�ERH�PSKMWXMGEP�WYTTSVX�JSV�ERXM�7IQMXMG�TSKVSQW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�%HSPJ�)MGLQERR�ZMWMXIH�,YWWIMRM�MR�4EPIWXMRI�ERH�WYFWIUYIRXP]�QEMRXEMRIHVIKYPEV�GSRXEGX�[MXL�LMQ��8LI�WYTTSVX�[EW�QYXYEP��EW�SRI�%VEF�GSQQIR�XEXSV�TYX�MX��©*IIPMRK�XLI�[LMT�SJ�.I[MWL�TVIWWYVI�ERH�MRJPYIRGI��XLI�%VEFWW]QTEXLMI?HA�[MXL�XLI�2EMW�ERH�*EWGMWXW�MR�XLIMV�EKSR]�ERH�XVMEPW�EX�XLILERHW�SJ�.I[MWL�MRXVMKYIW�ERH�MRXIVREXMSREP�JMRERGMEP�TVIWWYVI�ª�8LI�MRMXMEP&VMXMWL�VIWTSRWI�[EW�ETTIEWIQIRX�MR�XLI�JSVQ�SJ�E�VIHYGXMSR�MR�XLI�.I[MWLMQQMKVEXMSR�UYSXE��)ZIRXYEPP]��XLI]�VIWTSRHIH�[MXL�JSVGI��FPS[MRK�YTLSYWIW�EW�TYRMWLQIRX�ERH�HIXIVVIRGI��-R�.EJJE��XLI]�W]WXIQEXMGEPP]HIWXVS]IH�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�SPH�GMX]��FPS[MRK�YT�����LSQIW��

Page 65: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�XLIMV�%VEF�EPPMIW�[IVI�ER]XLMRK�FYX�RIYXVEP�EFSYXXLI�JEXI�SJ�)YVSTIER�.I[V]��8LI�SJJMGMEP�PIEHIV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��,EN%QMR�EP�,YWWIMRM��XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ�[LS�JSVQIH�ER�EPPMERGI[MXL�XLI�2EMW�ERH�IZIRXYEPP]�WTIRX�XLI�[EV�]IEVW�MR�&IVPMR�[MXL�,MXPIV�WIVZMRK�EW�E�GSRWYPXERX�SR�XLI�.I[MWL�UYIWXMSR��[EW�XEOIR�SR�E�XSYV�SJ%YWGL[MX�F]�,MQQPIV�ERH�I\TVIWWIH�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�QEWW�QYVHIV�SJ)YVSTIER�.I[W��,I�EPWS�WSYKLX�XS�©WSPZI�XLI�TVSFPIQW�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�IPI�QIRX�MR�4EPIWXMRI�ERH�SXLIV�%VEF�GSYRXVMIWª�F]�IQTPS]MRK�©XLI�WEQIQIXLSHª�FIMRK�YWIH�©MR�XLI�%\MW�GSYRXVMIW�ª�,I�[SYPH�RSX�FI�WEXMWJMIH[MXL�XLI�.I[MWL�VIWMHIRXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI QER]�SJ�[LSQ�[IVI�HIWGIRHERXWSJ�7ITLEVHMG�.I[W�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�XLIVI�JSV�LYRHVIHW��IZIR�XLSYWERHW��SJ]IEVW VIQEMRMRK�EW�E�QMRSVMX]�MR�E�1YWPMQ�WXEXI��0MOI�,MXPIV��LI�[ERXIHXS�FI�VMH�SJ�©IZIV]�PEWX�.I[�ª�%W�,YWWIMRM�[VSXI�MR�LMW�QIQSMVW�

3YV�JYRHEQIRXEP�GSRHMXMSR�JSV�GSSTIVEXMRK�[MXL�+IVQER]�[EW�E�JVII

LERH�XS�IVEHMGEXI�IZIV]�PEWX�.I[�JVSQ�4EPIWXMRI�ERH�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH��-

EWOIH�,MXPIV�JSV�ER�I\TPMGMX�YRHIVXEOMRK�XS�EPPS[�YW�XS�WSPZI�XLI�.I[MWL

TVSFPIQ�MR�E�QERRIV�FIJMXXMRK�SYV�REXMSREP�ERH�VEGMEP�EWTMVEXMSRW�ERH

EGGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�WGMIRXMJMG�QIXLSHW�MRRSZEXIH�F]�+IVQER]�MR�XLI�LER�

HPMRK�SJ�MXW�.I[W��8LI�ERW[IV�-�KSX�[EW��©8LI�.I[W�EVI�]SYVW�ª�

8LI�QYJXM�[EW�ETTEVIRXP]�TPERRMRK�XS�VIXYVR�XS�4EPIWXMRI�MR�XLI�IZIRXSJ�E�+IVQER�ZMGXSV]�ERH�XS�GSRWXVYGX�E�HIEXL�GEQT�QSHIPIH�EJXIV%YWGL[MX��RIEV�2EFPYW��,YWWIMRM�MRGMXIH�LMW�TVS�2EM�JSPPS[IVW�[MXL�XLI[SVHW�©%VMWI��S�WSRW�SJ�%VEFME��*MKLX�JSV�]SYV�WEGVIH�VMKLXW��7PEYKLXIV.I[W�[LIVIZIV�]SY�JMRH�XLIQ��8LIMV�WTMPPIH�FPSSH�TPIEWIW�%PPEL��SYV�LMW�XSV]�ERH�VIPMKMSR��8LEX�[MPP�WEZI�SYV�LSRSV�ª�-R�������E�+IVQER§%VEFGSQQERHS�YRMX�YRHIV�,YWWIMRM¬W�GSQQERH�TEVEGLYXIH�MRXS�4EPIWXMRI�MRER�IJJSVX�XS�TSMWSR�8IP�%ZMZ¬W�[IPPW�

,YWWIMRM�EPWS�LIPTIH�XS�MRWTMVI�E�TVS�2EM�GSYT�MR�-VEU�ERH�XS�SVKER�MI�XLSYWERHW�SJ�1YWPMQW�MR�XLI�&EPOERW�MRXS�QMPMXEV]�YRMXW�ORS[R�EW,ERHWIPEV�HMZMWMSRW��[LMGL�GEVVMIH�SYX�EXVSGMXMIW�EKEMRWX�=YKSWPEZ�.I[W�7IVFW��ERH�+]TWMIW��%JXIV�E�QIIXMRK�[MXL�,MXPIV��LI�VIGSVHIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRKMR�LMW�HMEV]�

8LI�1YJXM��©8LI�%VEFW�[IVI�+IVQER]¬W�REXYVEP�JVMIRHW��������8LI]�[IVI

XLIVIJSVI�TVITEVIH�XS�GSSTIVEXI�[MXL�+IVQER]�[MXL�EPP�XLIMV�LIEVXW�ERH

WXSSH�VIEH]�XS�TEVXMGMTEXI�MR�E�[EV��RSX�SRP]�RIKEXMZIP]�F]�XLI�GSQQMWWMSR

SJ�EGXW�SJ�WEFSXEKI�ERH�XLI�MRWXMKEXMSR�SJ�VIZSPYXMSRW��FYX�EPWS�TSWMXMZIP]

F]�XLI�JSVQEXMSR�SJ�ER�%VEF�0IKMSR��-R�XLMW�WXVYKKPI��XLI�%VEFW�[IVI�WXVMZ�

MRK�JSV�XLI�MRHITIRHIRGI�ERH�XLI�YRMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��7]VME�ERH�-VEU�

,MXPIV��©+IVQER]�[EW�VIWSPZIH��WXIT�F]�WXIT��XS�EWO�SRI�)YVSTIER

REXMSR�EJXIV�XLI�SXLIV�XS�WSPZI�MXW�.I[MWL�TVSFPIQ��ERH�EX�XLI�TVSTIV�XMQI

Page 66: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

HMVIGX�E�WMQMPEV�ETTIEP�XS�RSR�)YVSTIER�REXMSRW�EW�[IPP��+IVQER]¬W�SFNIG�

XMZI�[SYPH�XLIR�FI�WSPIP]�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�IPIQIRX�VIWMHMRK

MR�XLI�%VEF�WTLIVI�YRHIV�XLI�TVSXIGXMSR�SJ�&VMXMWL�TS[IV��8LI�QSQIRX

XLEX�+IVQER]¬W�XERO�HMZMWMSRW�ERH�EMV�WUYEHVSRW�LEH�QEHI�XLIMV�ETTIEV�

ERGI�WSYXL�SJ�XLI�'EYGEWYW��XLI�TYFPMG�ETTIEP�VIUYIWXIH�F]�XLI�+VERH

1YJXM�GSYPH�KS�SYX�XS�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�ª�

-X�MW�JEMV�XS�GSRGPYHI�XLEX�XLI�SJJMGMEP�PIEHIV�SJ�XLI�1YWPMQW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�,EN�%QMR�EP�,YWWIMRM��[EW�E�JYPP�JPIHKIH�2EM�[EV�GVMQMREP��ERH�LI�[EW�WSHIGPEVIH�EX�2YVIQFIVK��,I�[EW�WSYKLX�F]�=YKSWPEZME�ERH�+VIEX�&VMXEMR�EWE�[EV�GVMQMREP�EJXIV�XLI�[EV��IWGETMRK�XS�)K]TX��[LIVI�LI�[EW�KMZIR�EW]PYQERH�LIPTIH�XS�SVKERMI�QER]�JSVQIV�2EMW�ERH�2EM�W]QTEXLMIVW�EKEMRWX-WVEIP�

-X�MW�EPWS�JEMV�XS�WE]�XLEX�,YWWIMRM¬W�TVS�2EM�W]QTEXLMIW�ERH�WYTTSVX[IVI�[MHIWTVIEH�EQSRK�LMW�4EPIWXMRMER�JSPPS[IVW��[LS�VIKEVHIH�LMQ�EW�ELIVS�IZIR�EJXIV�XLI�[EV�ERH�XLI�HMWGPSWYVI�SJ�LMW�VSPI�MR�2EM�EXVSGMXMIW�%GGSVHMRK�XS�LMW�FMSKVETLIV��©,EN�%QMR¬W�TSTYPEVMX]�EQSRK�XLI�4EPIWXMR�MER�%VEFW�ERH�[MXLMR�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�EGXYEPP]�MRGVIEWIH�QSVI�XLER�IZIV�HYV�MRK�LMW�TIVMSH�[MXL�XLI�2EMW�ª�FIGEYWI�©PEVKI�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�%VEF�[SVPHWLEVIH�XLMW�W]QTEXL]�[MXL�2EM�+IVQER]�HYVMRK�XLI�7IGSRH�;SVPH�;EV�ª2SV�[EW�MX�QIVIP]�E�LEXVIH�SJ�>MSRMWQ�XLEX�ERMQEXIH�XLMW�WYTTSVX�JSV�2EM�MHISPSK]��8LI�KVERH�QYJXM¬W�©LEXVIH�SJ�.I[W�������[EW�JEXLSQPIWW��ERHLI�KEZI�JYPP�ZIRX�XS�MX�HYVMRK�LMW�TIVMSH�SJ�EGXMZMX]�EPSRKWMHI�XLI�2EMW�3GXSFIV�����§1E]����� �ª�,MW�WTIIGLIW�SR�&IVPMR�6EHMS�[IVI�ERXM�7IQMXMG�XS�XLI�GSVI��©/MPP�XLI�.I[W�[LIVIZIV�]SY�JMRH�XLIQ XLMW�TPIEWIW+SH��LMWXSV]�ERH�VIPMKMSR�ª�-R�������XLI�2EXMSREP�4EPIWXMRMER�'SYRGMPIPIGXIH�,YWWIMRM�EW�MXW�TVIWMHIRX��IZIR�XLSYKL�LI�[EW�E�[ERXIH�[EV�GVMQ�MREP�PMZMRK�MR�I\MPI�MR�)K]TX��-RHIIH��,YWWIMRM�MW�WXMPP�VIZIVIH�XSHE]�EQSRKWSQI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EW�E�REXMSREP�LIVS��[LMPI�SXLIVW�XV]�LEVH�XS�IVEWI�LMQJVSQ�4EPIWXMRMER�LMWXSV]��=EWWIV�%VEJEX�JMXW�TPEMRP]�MRXS�XLI�JSVQIV�GEXIKSV]�-R�ER�MRXIVZMI[�GSRHYGXIH�MR������ERH�VITVMRXIH�MR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�HEMP]%P�5YHWSR�%YKYWX����������XLI�GLEMVQER�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]GEPPW�,EN�%QMR�EP�,YWWIMRM�©SYV�LIVS�ª�VIJIVVMRK�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�%VEJEX�EPWS�FSEWXIH�SJ�FIMRK�©SRI�SJ�LMW�XVSSTW�ª�IZIR�XLSYKL�LI�ORI[�LI[EW�©GSRWMHIVIH�ER�EPP]�SJ�2EMW�ª���-J�E�+IVQER�XSHE]�[IVI�XS�GEPP�,MXPIV©SYV�LIVS�ª�LI�[SYPH�ETTVSTVMEXIP]�FI�PEFIPIH�E�RIS�2EM� �)ZIR�4VSJIW�WSV�)H[EVH�7EMH�FIPMIZIW�XLEX�©,ENN�%QMR�EP�,YWWEMRM�VITVIWIRXIH�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%VEF�REXMSREP�GSRWIRWYW��LEH�XLI�FEGOMRK�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERTSPMXMGEP�TEVXMIW�XLEX�JYRGXMSRIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI��ERH�[EW�VIGSKRMIH�MR�WSQIJSVQ�F]�%VEF�KSZIVRQIRXW�EW�XLI�ZSMGI�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�ª��,I[EW�©4EPIWXMRI¬W�REXMSREP�PIEHIVª��[LIR�LI�QEHI�LMW�EPPMERGI�[MXL�,MXPIVERH�TPE]IH�ER�EGXMZI�VSPI�MR�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�

%PXLSYKL�MX�[SYPH�FI�YRJEMV�XS�LSPH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�VIWTSRWMFPI

Page 67: The Case For Israel

JSV�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�)YVSTIER�.I[V]��MXW�SJJMGMEP�PIEHIVWLMT�[EW�GIVXEMRP]�JEVJVSQ�FPEQIPIWW�MR�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��-X�EGXMZIP]�WYTTSVXIH�,MXPIV¬W�JMREP�WSPYXMSREW�[IPP�EW�2EM�ZMGXSV]�SZIV�XLI�%QIVMGERW�ERH�XLIMV�%PPMIW��8LI�KVERH�QYJXMSJ�.IVYWEPIQ�[EW�TIVWSREPP]�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�XLI�GSRGIRXVEXMSR�GEQT�WPEYKL�XIV�SJ�XLSYWERHW�SJ�.I[W��-R�SRI�MRWXERGI��[LIR�LI�PIEVRIH�XLEX�XLI�,YR�KEVMER�KSZIVRQIRX�[EW�TPERRMRK�XS�EPPS[�XLSYWERHW�SJ�GLMPHVIR�XS�IWGETIJVSQ�XLI�2EMW��LI�MRXIVZIRIH�[MXL�)MGLQERR�ERH�HIQERHIH�XLI]�VIZIVWIXLI�TPER��8LI]�HMH�ERH�XLI�GLMPHVIR�[IVI�WIRX�XS�XLI�HIEXL�GEQTW���8LIQYJXM�EPWS�WYTTSVXIH�XLI�2EMW�QMPMXEVMP]��SJJIVMRK�LMW�%VEF�0IKMSR�XS�JMKLXEKEMRWX�XLI�%PPMIW��WS�EW�XS�GSYRXIVEGX�XLI�.I[MWL�&VMKEHI��[LMGL�[EW�JMKLXMRKSR�XLI�WMHI�SJ�XLI�%PPMIW���

-R�PMKLX�SJ�XLI�GPSWI�EWWSGMEXMSR�FIX[IIR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�ERH�2EMWQ�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�����W�ERH�����W��MX�MW�MVSRMG�XLEX�QER]�TVS�4EPIWXMRMER�KVSYTW�LEZI�GLSWIR�XLI�W[EWXMOE�EW�XLI�W]QFSP�[MXL�[LMGLXS�EXXEGO�-WVEIP��.YWX�EW�XLI�2EMW�GEPPIH�XLI�.I[W�GSQQYRMWXWERH�7XEPMRGEPPIH�XLI�.I[W�JEWGMWXW�QER]�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�XLIMV�WYTTSVXIVW FSXL�SRXLI�I\XVIQI�VMKLX�ERH�XLI�I\XVIQI�PIJX RS[�YWI�XLI�[SVH�©2EMª�XS�GLEV�EGXIVMI�-WVEIP��XLI�.I[W��ERH�>MSRMWQ�8LI�.I[W�LEZI�EP[E]W�FIIR�GEYKLXFIX[IIR�XLI�FPEGO�ERH�XLI�VIH��EW�SRI�WGLSPEV�TYX�MX��8LI]�EVI�FEGO�MR�XLIYRGSQJSVXEFPI�TSWMXMSR�SRGI�EKEMR��EW�XLI�I\XVIQI�PIJX�ERH�XLI�I\XVIQIVMKLX�FSXL�WIIO�XS�HIQSRMI�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�F]�JEPWIP]�GSQTEVMRK�MX�XS�ERMHISPSK]�XLEX�TVEGXMGIH�KIRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI E�KIRSGMHI[MHIP]�WYTTSVXIH�ERH�EWWMWXIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�

8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�TSPMGI�GLMIJ��+LEM�.EFEPM��LEW�GSQTEVIH�-WVEIP¬W�JMVWXTVMQI�QMRMWXIV��XLI�7SGMEPMWX�(EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR��XS�XLI�IZMP�QSRWXIV�EKEMRWX[LSQ�LI�JSYKLX��©8LIVI�MW�RS�HMJJIVIRGI�FIX[IIR�,MXPIV�ERH�&IR+YVMSR�ª��3R�XSHE]¬W�GSPPIKI�GEQTYWIW��]SY�GER�SJXIR�LIEV�-WVEIP¬W�TVMQIQMRMWXIV�GSQTEVIH�XS�,MXPIV�[MXL�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�GLERX��©7LEVSR�ERH,MXPIV NYWX�XLI�WEQI XLI�SRP]�HMJJIVIRGI�MW�XLI�REQI�ª�2S�SRI�IZIVGSQTEVIW�7LEVSR�XS��WE]��4MRSGLIX��SV�IZIR�7XEPMR��-X�MW�EP[E]W�,MXPIV�ERH2EMWQ��7MKRW�NY\XETSWMRK�XLI�7XEV�SJ�(EZMH�ERH�XLI�W[EWXMOE�EVI�GSQ�QSRTPEGI��8LIWI�WMKR�GEVVMIVW�EVI��SJ�GSYVWI��HIPMFIVEXIP]�YWMRK�+ISVKI3V[IPP¬W�©XYVRWTIEOª�F]�XV]MRK�XS�EWWSGMEXI�XLI�7XEV�SJ�(EZMH�[MXL�XLIW[EWXMOE��ORS[MRK�LS[�HIITP]�SJJIRWMZI�XLI�W[EWXMOE�MW�XS�.I[W�

7SQI�.I[MWL�KVSYTW�LEZI�GEPPIH�QI�SZIV�XLI�]IEVW�ERH�EWOIH�QI�XS�XV]XS�FER�XLI�YWI�SJ�XLI�W[EWXMOE�MR�EXXEGOW�SR�-WVEIP��7MRGI�-�EQ�STTSWIH�XSGIRWSVWLMT��-�LEZI�EP[E]W�YVKIH�XLIQ�XS�YWI�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�EXXIQTX�XSIUYEXI�-WVEIP�[MXL�2EMWQ�EW�ER�IHYGEXMSREP�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�VIQMRH��XLI[SVPH�SJ�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�4EPIWXMRMER�WYTTSVX�JSV�2EMWQ�ERH�SJ�XLI�JEGXXLEX�2EM�[EV�GVMQMREPW�[IVI�KMZIR�EW]PYQ�MR�)K]TX�ERH�LIPTIH�XLI�)K]TXMER�KSZIVRQIRX�MR�MXW�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMER�XEVKIXW��-J�4EPIW�XMRMER�WYTTSVXIVW�MRWMWX�SR�YWMRK�XLI�W[EWXMOE��XLI]�GIVXEMRP]�GERRSX�GSQ�TPEMR�[LIR�XLMW�W]QFSP�MW�XYVRIH�EKEMRWX�XLIQ�XS�VIQMRH�XLI�[SVPH�SJ

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 68: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

MRHMWTYXEFPI�LMWXSVMGEP�JEGXW�VIKEVHMRK�XLI�VSPI�SJ�XLIMV�VIZIVIH�PIEHIV�MREGXMZIP]�WYTTSVXMRK�,MXPIV¬W�KIRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W�ERH�,MXPIV¬W�JEMPIHEXXIQTX�XS�FVMRK�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�XS�4EPIWXMRI��,MXPIV¬W�TEVXRIV�MR�KIRSGMHIMW�RS[�XLI�©LIVSª�SJ�XLI�GLEMVQER�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��[LMPI�MXWTVMQI�QMRMWXIV�SRGI�XVMIH�XS�©TVSZIª�XLEX�,MXPIV¬W�,SPSGEYWX�EKEMRWX�XLI.I[W�RIZIV�SGGYVVIH��8LEX�MW�XLI�VIEPMX]��ERH�RS�EXXIQTX�XS�XYVR�XLI�ZMGXMQWMRXS�TIVTIXVEXSVW�SV�XLI�ZMPPEMRW�MRXS�LIVSIW�[MPP�GLERKI�LMWXSV]�

+IRIVEPP]��XLSWI�[LS�WYTTSVX�XLI�PSWMRK�WMHI�MR�E�[EV IWTIGMEPP]�E�WMHIWS�IKVIKMSYWP]�IZMP�EW�XLI�2EMW HS�RSX�FIRIJMX�JVSQ�XLI�TSWX[EV�VIGSR�WXVYGXMSR�XLEX�MRIZMXEFP]�JSPPS[W�JVSQ�XLI�WYVVIRHIV�SJ�XLI�PSWMRK�WMHI��1SWX4EPIWXMRMER�1YWPMQW�[IVI�SR�XLI�PSWMRK�WMHI�SJ�;SVPH�;EV�-��[LMPI�XLI�.I[WSJ�4EPIWXMRI�[IVI�SR�XLI�[MRRMRK�WMHI��8LI�.I[MWL�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�&VMXMWL�MR;SVPH�;EV�-��[LMGL�MRGPYHIH�JMKLXMRK�EPSRKWMHI�&VMXMWL�JSVGIW��LIPTIH�IEVRXLIQ�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�SJ�������8LI�.I[MWL�WYTTSVX MRGPYHMRK�XLIQMPMXEV]�WYTTSVX�SJ�XLSYWERHW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�.I[W JSV�XLI�%PPMIW�HYVMRK;SVPH�;EV�--�LIPTIH�XS�IEVR�XLI�9�2��4EVXMXMSR�SJ�������'LYVGLMPPFIPMIZIH�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW�[IVI�©S[IH�������RSXLMRK�MR�E�TSWX[EV�WIXXPIQIRXªFIGEYWI�SJ�XLIMV�[MHIWTVIEH�WYTTSVX�JSV�2EMWQ��;MRWXSR�'LYVGLMPP�LEHGLEVEGXIVMIH�XLI�PIEHIV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EW�©XLI�HIEHPMIWX�IRIQ]�ª��

-R�XLI�ZMI[�SJ�QER]�HIGIRX�TISTPI��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER��ERH�[MHIWTVIEH%VEF �WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�2EMW�WLSYPH�LEZI�HMWUYEPMJMIH�XLIQ�JVSQ�LEZMRKQYGL�SJ�E�WE]�MR�XLI�TSWX[EV�VIEVVERKIQIRXW��QYGL�EW�MX�HMWUYEPMJMIH�XLI7YHIXIR�+IVQERW�JVSQ�LEZMRK�E�ZSMGI�MR�XLIMV�XVERWJIV�JVSQ�XLI�7YHIXIR�PERH�MR�XLI�FSVHIVPERHW�SJ�'IGLSWPSZEOME��[LIVI�XLI]�LEH�PMZIH�JSV�GIR�XYVMIW��XS�XLI�RI[��WQEPPIV�FSVHIVW�SJ�+IVQER]��%W�;MRWXSR�'LYVGLMPP�WEMH�©3J�GSYVWI�XLIVI�QYWX�FI�E�XVERWJIV�ª�HIWTMXI�XLI�SFNIGXMSRW�SJ�XLSWI�FIMRKXVERWJIVVIH�ERH�LMW�S[R�GSRGIVRW�SZIV�MXW�LYQERMXEVMER�MQTPMGEXMSRW���

-RWXIEH��MR�������XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�SJJIVIH�RIEVP]�XLI�WEQI�HIEPXLI]�LEH�VINIGXIH�MR�������[MXL�XLI�I\GITXMSR�SJ�XLI�FEVVIR�2IKIZ �HIWTMXI�XLI�KVIEXIV�RIIH�JSV�E�TPEGI�JSV�XLI�LYRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW�SJ�.I[�MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�XLI�HIEXL�GEQTW�SJ�)YVSTI��%X�XLI�XMQI�SJ�XLI�9�2��TEV�XMXMSR�TPER��E�UYEVXIV�QMPPMSR�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�PMZMRK�MR�HITPSVEFPITVMWSR�GEQTW�MR�XLI�ZIV]�GSYRXV]�XLEX�LEH�QYVHIVIH�XLIMV�TEVIRXW��GLMP�HVIR��ERH�WMFPMRKW��8LI]�GSYPH�RSX�VIXYVR�XS�4SPERH�FIGEYWI�XLI�4SPIWGSRXMRYIH�XS�QYVHIV�.I[W�IZIR�EJXIV�XLI�2EMW�LEH�FIIR�HIJIEXIH��ERH�XLIPEWX�XLMRK�XLI�'SQQYRMWX�PIEHIVW�SJ�4SPERH�[ERXIH�[EW�ER�MRJPY\�SJ�.I[�MWL�VIJYKIIW��2SV�GSYPH�XLI]�FI�I\TIGXIH�XS�VIQEMR�MR�+IVQER]��[LIVI�XLIVIJYKII�GEQTW�[IVI�XIQTSVEVMP]�PSGEXIH�

-QQMKVEXMSR�MRXS�E�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�MR�TEVXMXMSRIH�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�XLISRP]�JIEWMFPI�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ��8LIVI�[EW�EPWS�E�KVS[MRKTVSFPIQ�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW�GSRXEMRMRK�WMKRMJMGERX�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSRW��.I[W�MR�1YWPMQ�GSYRXVMIW�[IVI�EP[E]W�XVIEXIH�EW�WIGSRH�GPEWWRSRGMXMIRW��EX�FIWX �ERH�EW�ETTVSTVMEXI�XEVKIXW�SJ�QEWW�ZMSPIRGI��EX�[SVWX �

Page 69: The Case For Israel

%PXLSYKL�XLI�.I[W�SJ�-WPEQ�[IVI�RIZIV�WYFNIGXIH�XS�ER]XLMRK�PMOI�XLI,SPSGEYWX��XLI]�LEH�PSRK�FIIR�ZMGXMQW�SJ�TSKVSQW�ERH�VIPMKMSYW�HMWGVMQ�MREXMSR�

7SQI�-WPEQMG�KSZIVRQIRXW�LEH�ER�ETEVXLIMH�PMOI�W]WXIQ�YRHIV�[LMGL(LMQQMW E�VIPMKMSYW�GEXIKSV]�XLEX�MRGPYHIW�.I[W�ERH�'LVMWXMERW [IVI�F]�PE[�ERH�XLISPSK]��HIIQIH�MRJIVMSV�ERH�WYFNIGXIH�XS�WITEVEXI�FYXYRIUYEP�VYPIW��(LMQQMW�[IVI��ERH�MR�WSQI�TPEGIW�WXMPP�EVI��FEVVIH�JVSQTYFPMG�SJJMGI��JSVGIH�XS�[IEV�HMWXMRGXMZI�HVIWW��ERH�WYFNIGX�XS�VIWXVMGXMSRW�SRXLI�FYMPHMRK�ERH�QEMRXIRERGI�SJ�W]REKSKYIW�ERH�GLYVGLIW��-X�MW�XVYI�XLEX(LMQQMW�EVI�TIVQMXXIH�XS�TVEGXMGI�XLIMV�VIPMKMSR�ERH�TVIWIVZI�XLIMV�GYP�XYVI��FYX�SRP]�MJ�XLI]�TE]�E�WTIGMEP�NM]E�SV�TSPP�XE\��RSX�VIUYMVIH�SJ�1YW�PMQW��8LI�(LMQQMW�TE]�XLI�XE\�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�TVSXIGXMSR�F]�XLI�WXEXI��%WWYGL��XLI]�EVI�SYXWMHI�XLI�TSPMXMGEP�GSQQYRMX]��7S�MX�MW�RSX�XLEX�XLI�(LMQ�QMW�EVI�WIGSRH�GPEWW�GMXMIRW IWWIRXMEPP]��(LMQQMW�EVI�RSX�GMXMIRW�EX�EPP�)ZIR�MJ�GIVXEMR�1YWPMQ�VIKMQIW�XVIEX�XLIQ�XSPIVEFP]��XLI]�WXMPP�PMZI�PEVKIP]EX�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX¬W�[LMQ��EW�HIWMKREXIH�SYXWMHIVW�

*SPPS[MRK�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�ERH�IWTIGMEPP]�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�1YWPMQ�ERH%VEF�WYTTSVX�JSV�MX��MX�FIGEQI�GPIEV�XLEX�.I[W�GSYPH�RS�PSRKIV�FII\TIGXIH�XS�PMZI�EW�ER�MRJIVMSV�(LMQQM�QMRSVMX]�WYFNIGX�XS�XLI�[LMQWMGEPTVSXIGXMSR�SJ�E�HMWGVMQMREXSV]�QENSVMX]��8LI�.I[W�SJ�-WPEQ�[IVI�VIJYKIIW�MR[EMXMRK��8LI]�[IVI�[EMXMRK�JSV�E�TPEGI�XS�QSZI E�TPEGI�MR�[LMGL�XLI]GSYPH�PMZI�EW�PIKEP�IUYEPW��[MXLSYX�VIKEVH�XS�XLIMV�VIPMKMSR�SV�IXLRMGMX]�-WVEIP�[EW�XLEX�TPEGI��ERH�WLSVXP]�EJXIV�MXW�IWXEFPMWLQIRX��ETTVS\MQEXIP]��������7ITLEVHMG�ERH�1MVELM�.I[W�[IVI�JSVGIH�XS�PIEZI��SV�©GLSWIª�XSPIEZI��TPEGIW�MR�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�XLEX�XLI]�ERH�XLIMV�ERGIWXSVW�LEH�MRLEFMXIHJSV�XLSYWERHW�SJ�]IEVW��%W�[I�[MPP�WII�MR�GLETXIV�����XLI�WMXYEXMSR�SJ�XLSWI7ITLEVHMG�.I[W�[LS�PIJX�XLIMV�ERGMIRX�LSQIPERHW�SYX�SJ�JIEV��GSIVGMSR��SVER�YR[MPPMRKRIWW�XS�PMZI�EW�E�TIVWIGYXIH�QMRSVMX]�[EW��MR�QER]�[E]W��GSQ�TEVEFPI�XS�XLI�WMXYEXMSR�SJ�XLI�%VEF�VIJYKIIW�[LS�PIJX�-WVEIP�JSPPS[MRK�XLIQEWWMZI�%VEF�EXXEGOW�SR�XLI�RI[P]�HIGPEVIH�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

-X�MW�WSQIXMQIW�EVKYIH�XLEX�EPXLSYKL�XLI�.I[MWL�WYVZMZSVW�SJ�XLI�,SPS�GEYWX��[LS�FIGEQI�VIJYKIIW�EX�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�[EV��[IVI�IRXMXPIH�XS�ELSQIPERHWSQI[LIVI�WYGL�E�LSQIPERH�WLSYPH�RSX�LEZI�GSQI�EX�XLII\TIRWI�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�MR�KIRIVEP�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�TEVXMGYPEV��8LI,SPSGEYWX��MX�MW�EVKYIH��[EW�XLI�JEYPX�SJ�XLI�+IVQERW�ERH�SJ�GSYRXVMIWMRGPYHMRK�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�XLEX�VIJYWIH�XS�EGGITX�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ+IVQER]��4SPERH��ERH�%YWXVME��%W�-VERMER�TVIWMHIRX�/LEXEQM�TYX�MX�MR������©-J�2EMW�ERH�*EWGMWXW�MR�XLI�;IWX�GSQQMXXIH�GVMQIW�EKEMRWX�XLI.I[W��[L]�WLSYPH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�TE]�XLI�TVMGI�RS[#�8LSWI�[LS�LEZIGSQQMXXIH�XLI�GVMQIW�?;IWXIVRIVWA�WLSYPH�TE]�XLI�TVMGI�ª��

8LMW�EVKYQIRX�JEMPW�JSV�EX�PIEWX�X[S�VIEWSRW��*MVWX��XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�HMHRSX�GSQI�MRXS�I\MWXIRGI�EX�XLI�I\TIRWI�SJ�IMXLIV�XLI�%VEFW�SV�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW��8LI�EVIE�TEVXMXMSRIH�JSV�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�LEH�E�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]�XLEX

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 70: The Case For Israel

LEH�E�VMKLX�XS�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�ZMW�l�ZMW�XLI�&VMXMWL��ERH�XLI�3XXSQERWFIJSVI�XLIQ ��8LI�PERH�MR�UYIWXMSR�[EW�RIMXLIV�%VEF�RSV�4EPIWXMRMER��-XLEH�TEWWIH�JVSQ�SRI�IQTMVI�XS�ERSXLIV��ERH�XLI�XMQI�LEH�GSQI�JSV�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�F]�XLI�X[S�KVSYTW�XLEX�PMZIH�MR�HMJJIVIRX�TEVXW�SJ�MX��-X�[EWLMWXSVMGEPP]��HIQSKVETLMGEPP]��IGSRSQMGEPP]��ERH�PIKEPP]�FSXLE�.I[MWL�ERHER�%VEF�PERH���8LI�PEWX�MRHITIRHIRX�WXEXI�XS�LEZI�I\MWXIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI�[EWXLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�XLEX�LEH�FIIR�HIWXVS]IH�F]�XLI�6SQERW�MR����'�)�

7IGSRH��XLI�EVKYQIRX�GPSWIW�MXW�I]IW�XS�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�WSQI�%VEF�ERH4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�FSVI�WMKRMJMGERX�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��8LI]WYTTSVXIH�MX��EMHIH�MX��YWIH�MX�XS�XLIMV�EHZERXEKI��ERH�I\TIGXIH�XS�FIRIJMXJVSQ�MX��1SVISZIV��MX�[EW�EW�XLI�HMVIGX�VIWYPX�SJ�%VEF�ERH�4EPIWXMRMER�TVIW�WYVI�XLEX�XLI�KEXIW�SJ�MQQMKVEXMSR�XS�4EPIWXMRI�[IVI�GPSWIH�XS�.I[W�HYVMRKXLI�GVYGMEP�]IEVW�[LIR�LYRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW�SJ�.I[W��TIVLETW�IZIR�QSVI�GSYPH�LEZI�FIIR�WEZIH�MJ�XLI]�LEH�FIIR�TIVQMXXIH�XS�IRXIV�4EPIWXMRI IZIRXLI�XMR]�TSVXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�TVSTSWIH�JSV�E�.I[MWL�LSQI�F]�XLI�4IIP'SQQMWWMSR�MR������

8LI�%VEFW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�FSVI�WYJJMGMIRX�KYMPX�JSV�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�ERHJSV�WYTTSVXMRK�XLI�[VSRK�WMHI�HYVMRK�;SVPH�;EV�--�XS�NYWXMJ]�XLIMV�GSRXVM�FYXMSR��EW�TEVX�SJ�XLI�PSWMRK�WMHI��MR�XLI�VIEVVERKIQIRX�SJ�XIVVMXSV]�ERHHIQSKVETL]�XLEX�MRIZMXEFP]�JSPPS[W�E�GEXEGP]WQMG�[SVPH�GSRJPMGX��.YWX�EW�XLI7YHIXIR�+IVQERW�FSVI�WSQI�SJ�XLI�FYVHIR�SJ�FIMRK�SR�XLI�[VSRK�WMHI��WSXSS�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�NYWXP]�VIUYMVIH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH2EXMSRW�XS�GSRXVMFYXI�XS�E�VIWSPYXMSR�SJ�XLI�TSWX[EV�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�1SVISZIV��EPP�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�HMH�F]�TEVXMXMSRMRK�4EPIWXMRI�[EW�XSKVERX�XLI�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]�MR�XLI�PERH�EVIE�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR E�VMKLX�XLEX�LEW�PSRK�FIIR�ZEPYIH�F]�WYT�TSVXIVW�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�ERH�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW��ERH�E�VMKLX�GPEMQIH�XSHE]�F]4EPIWXMRMERW�SR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�MR�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�

8LI�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�REXMSRW�[IVI�GSQTPIXIP]VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�XLI�WIGSRH�GPEWW��SV�[SVWI �WXEXYW�XLEX�XLIMV�VIPMKMSRW�ERH�TSPMXMGEP�PIEHIVW�LEHMQTSWIH�SR�XLIMV�.I[MWL�QMRSVMXMIW�SZIV�XLI�GIRXYVMIW��8LI�Q]XL�SJ�FIRMKRXVIEXQIRX�F]�XLI�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�[SVPH�SJ�XLIMV�.I[MWL�QMRSVMX]�LEWFIIR�WLEXXIVIH�F]�QSHIVR�WGLSPEVWLMT��8LI�.I[W�[IVI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�ERETEVXLIMH�PMOI�W]WXIQ�GSQTEVEFPI�MR�QER]�VIWTIGXW�XS�XLEX�MRJPMGXIH�SRFPEGO�7SYXL�%JVMGERW�F]�XLI�ETEVXLIMH�KSZIVRQIRX�SJ�TVI�1ERHIPE�7SYXL%JVMGE��-R�EHHMXMSR�XS�XLI�PIKEP�ERH�XLISPSKMGEP�HMWGVMQMREXMSR XLIVIUYMVIQIRX�XS�[IEV�HMWXMRGXMZI�GPSXLMRK��RSX�XS�S[R�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�[IETSRW�ERH�XS�TE]�E�WTIGMEP�XE\ XLI]�[IVI�WYFNIGX�XS�TIVMSHMG�TSKVSQW�ERH�FPSSHPMFIPW��WYGL�EW�MR�(EQEWGYW�MR�������%GGSVHMRK�XS�1SVVMW��XLIVI�[IVI�EPWS

QEWWEGVIW�MR�8IXYER�MR�1SVSGGS�MR�������MR�1EWLLEH�ERH�&EVJYVYWL�MR

4IVWME�MR������ERH�������VIWTIGXMZIP]��ERH��MR�&EKLHEH�MR�������8LI

.I[MWL�UYEVXIV�SJ�*I�[EW�EPQSWX�HIWXVS]IH�MR������F]�E�1YWPMQ�QSF�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 71: The Case For Israel

ERHTVS�2EM�QSFWWPEYKLXIVIH�HSIRW�SJ�.I[W�MR�&EKLHEH�MR������

6ITIEXIHP]��MR�ZEVMSYW�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�-WPEQMG�[SVPH��.I[MWL�GSQQYRMXMIW

GSRXVEV]�XS�XLI�TVSZMWMSRW�SJ�XLI�HLMQQE [IVI�KMZIR�XLI�GLSMGI�SJ�GSR�

ZIVWMSR�SV�HIEXL��9WYEPP]��XLSYKL�RSX�EP[E]W��XLI�MRGMHIRXW�SJ�QEWW

ZMSPIRGI�SGGYVVIH�MR�XLI�ZYPRIVEFPI�I\XVIQMXMIW�SJ�XLI�1YWPMQ�IQTMVI

VEXLIV�XLER�EX�MXW�QSVI�WIPJ�GSRJMHIRX�GSVI��&YX�XLI�YRHIVP]MRK�EXXMXYHI�

XLEX�.I[W�[IVI�MRJMHIPW�ERH�STTSRIRXW�SJ�-WPEQ��ERH�RIGIWWEVMP]�MRJIVMSV�MR

XLI�I]IW�SJ�+SH��TVIZEMPIH�XLVSYKLSYX�1YWPMQ�PERHW�HS[R�XLI�EKIW���

0IWW�PIXLEP�FYX�UYMXI�HIKVEHMRK�[EW�ERSXLIV�[MHIWTVIEH�TVEGXMGI�

3RI�QIEWYVI�ERH�W]QFSP�SJ�.I[MWL�HIKVEHEXMSR�[EW�XLI�GSQQSR�TLI�

RSQIRSR EQSYRXMRK�MR�GIVXEMR�TPEGIW��WYGL�EW�=IQIR�ERH�1SVSGGS��XS

E�PSGEP�GYWXSQ SJ�WXSRI�XLVS[MRK�EX�.I[W�F]�1YWPMQ�GLMPHVIR��%

RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]�;IWXIVR�XVEZIPIV�[VSXI��©-�LEZI�WIIR�E�PMXXPI�JIPPS[�SJ

WM\�]IEVW�SPH��[MXL�E�XVSST�SJ�JEX�XSHHPIVW�SJ�SRP]�XLVII�ERH�JSYV��XIEGLMRK

�XLIQ �XS�XLVS[�WXSRIW�EX�E�.I[��ERH�SRI�PMXXPI�YVGLMR�[SYPH��[MXL�XLI

KVIEXIWX�GSSPRIWW��[EHHPI�YT�XS�XLI�QER�ERH�PMXIVEPP]�WTMX�YTSR�LMW�.I[MWL

KEFEVHMRI��8S�EPP�XLMW�XLI�.I[�MW�SFPMKIH�XS�WYFQMX��MX�[SYPH�FI�QSVI�XLER

LMW�PMJI�[EW�[SVXL�XS�SJJIV�XS�WXVMOI�E�1SLEQQIHER�ª��

3RI�LMWXSVMER�WYQQEVMIH�XLI�LMWXSVMG�XVIEXQIRX�SJ�.I[W�F]�1YWPMQW�EW©GSRXIQTXYSYW�XSPIVERGI�ª��8LI]�[IVI�XVIEXIH�EW�ER�©MRJIVMSV�VEGI�ª��

8LI�JEGX�XLEX�XLIVI�[IVI�RS�-RUYMWMXMSRW�SV�,SPSGEYWXW�SRP]�WLS[W�XLEXQEXXIVW�[IVI�IZIR�[SVWI�MR�'LVMWXMER�)YVSTI��&SXL�XLI�'LVMWXMERW�SJ)YVSTI�ERH�XLI�1YWPMQW�SJ�XLI�%VEF�REXMSRW�XVIEXIH�XLIMV�.I[MWL�QMRSVM�XMIW�WS�LSVVMFP]�XLEX�XLI�RIIH�JSV�.I[MWL�WIPJ�KSZIVRQIRX��MR�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI[MXL�E�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��[LIVI�.I[W�GSYPH�FI�XVIEXIH�EW�IUYEPW�ERH�HIJIRHXLIQWIPZIW�JVSQ�TIVWIGYXMSR��FIGEQI�IZMHIRX�XS�QSWX�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�EX�XLIGPSWI�SJ�XLI�7IGSRH�;SVPH�;EV�

-J�VMKLXW�GSQI�JVSQ�[VSRKW��EW�-�LEZI�EVKYIH�EX�PIRKXL�IPWI[LIVI���

XLIR�XLI�[VSRKWMQTSWIH�SR�.I[MWL�QMRSVMX]�VIWMHIRXW�SJ�1YWPMQ�ERH'LVMWXMER�WXEXIW�HIQSRWXVEXIH�XS�XLI�[SVPH�XLEX�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�LEH�XLIVMKLX�XS�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�E�TPEGI�MR�[LMGL�.I[W�[IVI�E�QENSVMX]��%W;MRWXSR�'LYVGLMPP�LEH�GSVVIGXP]�SFWIVZIH�E�UYEVXIV�SJ�E�GIRXYV]�IEVPMIV�WYGL�E�WXEXI�EPVIEH]�I\MWXIH��MR�JEGX�ERH�MR�PE[��MR�XLSWI�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI[MXL�E�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��.I[MWL�TSPMXMGEP��IGSRSQMG��ERH�GYPXYVEP�MRWXMXY�XMSRW��ERH�E�.I[MWL�EVQ]�XLEX�LEH�JSYKLX�EPSRKWMHI�XLI�ZMGXSVW�MR�;SVPH;EV�- ERH�WYFWIUYIRXP]�MR�;SVPH�;EV�--��%PP�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�HMH�[EWVIGSKRMI�XLI�VIEPMX]�SJ�.I[MWL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�EVIEW�MR�[LMGL�XLI]LEH�IZIV]�VMKLX VIGSKRMIH�F]�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��XVIEXMIW��XLI�0IEKYI�SJ2EXMSRW��ERH�E�QENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW XS�PMZI�ERH�GYPXMZEXI�PERHXLI]�LEH�PE[JYPP]�TYVGLEWIH�JVSQ�EFWIRXII�PERHPSVHW��%W�XLI�0SRHSR�8MQIW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 72: The Case For Israel

IHMXSVMEPMIH�EX�XLI�XMQI��©-X�MW�LEVH�XS�WII�LS[�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH��WXMPP�PIWWXLI�%VEFW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��[MPP�WYJJIV�JVSQ�[LEX�MW�QIVI�VIGSKRMXMSR�SJ�EGGSQ�TPMWLIH�JEGX XLI�TVIWIRGI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�SJ�E�GSQTEGX��[IPP�SVKERMIH��ERHZMVXYEPP]�EYXSRSQSYW�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMX]�ª��

)ZIR�JSV�XLSWI�[LS�VINIGX�ER]�FPEQI[SVXLMRIWW�SR�XLI�TEVX�SJ�4EPIW�XMRMERW�ERH�%VEFW�JSV�XLI�TPMKLX�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�2EMWQ�ERH-WPEQMG�ETEVXLIMH ER�YRXIREFPI�TSWMXMSR�MR�PMKLX�SJ�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�[MHI�WTVIEH�4EPIWXMRMER�WYTTSVX�JSV�2EMWQ XLI�GEWI�JSV�WSQI�EJJMVQEXMZI�EGXMSRJSV�E�TISTPI�[LS�WYJJIVIH�WS�KVMIZSYWP]�EX�XLI�LERHW�SJ�SXLIVW�MW�TS[IVJYP�8LSWI�SJ�YW�[LS�WYTTSVX�EJJMVQEXMZI�EGXMSR�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�%JVMGER�%QIVM�GERW�HS�WS��EX�PIEWX�MR�TEVX��SR�E�XLISV]�SJ�VITEVEXMSR�JSV�TEWX�[VSRKW�%PXLSYKL�SYV�S[R�JSVIFIEVIVW�QE]�FIEV�RSRI�SJ�XLI�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�WPEZ�IV]��WMRGI�XLI]�[IVI�RSX�IZIR�MR�XLI�GSYRXV]��[I�QYWX�EPP�FI�[MPPMRK�XS�WLEVIWSQI�SJ�XLI�FYVHIRW�SJ�VITEVEXMSR��3YV�GLMPHVIR�ERH�KVERHGLMPHVIR�QE]�FIHIRMIH�TPEGIW�MR�XLI�GSPPIKIW�SV�NSFW�SJ�XLIMV�JMVWX�GLSMGI��FIGEYWI�XLIWITPEGIW�EVI�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�HIWGIRHERXW�SJ�WPEZIW�ERH�SXLIV�QMRSVMXMIW��'IV�XEMRP]�XLSWI�[LS�HMVIGXP]�FIRIJMXIH�JVSQ�WPEZIV]�FIEV�E�WTIGMEP�VIWTSRWMFMP�MX]�JSV�QEOMRK�VITEVEXMSRW��NYWX�EW�XLSWI�[LS�FIRIJMXIH�JVSQ�XLI�,SPSGEYWXFIEV�WTIGMEP�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�XS�XLSWI�[LS�[IVI�MXW�ZMGXMQW�

&YX�MR�E�PEVKIV�WIRWI��XLI�IRXMVI�[SVPH�S[IW�XLI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�WPEZIV]��XLI,SPSGEYWX��ERH�SXLIV�LYQERP]�MQTSWIH�KIRSGMHIW�E�WTIGMEP�JSVQ�SJ�EJJMV�QEXMZI�EGXMSR��)ZIR�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�WIIQIH�XS�VIGSKRMI�ER�EJJMV�QEXMZI�EGXMSR�GSQTSRIRX�MR�MXW�HIGMWMSR�XS�VIGSKRMI�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�E.I[MWL�REXMSREP�LSQI�

-X�MW�MQTSWWMFPI��[I�FIPMIZI��JSV�ER]�YRTVINYHMGIH�SFWIVZIV�XS�WII�XLI

2EXMSREP�,SQI�ERH�RSX�[MWL�MX�[IPP��-X�LEW�QIERX�WS�QYGL�JSV�XLI�VIPMIJ

SJ�YRQIVMXIH�WYJJIVMRK��-X�HMWTPE]W�WS�QYGL�IRIVK]�ERH�IRXIVTVMWI�ERH

HIZSXMSR�XS�E�GSQQSR�GEYWI��-R�WS�JEV�EW�&VMXEMR�LEW�LIPTIH�XS[EVHW�MXW

GVIEXMSR��[I�[SYPH�GPEMQ��[MXL�0SVH�&EPJSYV��XLEX�XS�XLEX�I\XIRX��EX�ER]

VEXI��'LVMWXIRHSQ�LEW�WLS[R�MXWIPJ�©RSX�SFPMZMSYW�SJ�EPP�XLI�[VSRK�MX�LEW

HSRI�ª��

8LI�1YWPMQ�[SVPH�XSS�WLSYPH�VIGSKRMI�EPP�XLI�[VSRK�MX�LEW�HSRI�XS�XLI.I[W�MX�LMWXSVMGEPP]�XVIEXIH�EW�WIGSRH�GPEWW�RSRGMXMIRW��(LMQQM �

)ZIR�JSV�XLSWI�[LS�HMH�RSX�FIPMIZI�MR������XLEX�TEVXMXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI[EW�NYWX�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��[LIR�XLI�TEVXMXMSR�MW�ZMI[IH�EW�E�JSVQ�SJ�MRXIV�REXMSREP�EJJMVQEXMZI�EGXMSR�MX�WIIQW�QSVI�XLER�JEMV��*SV�XLSWI�[LS�WYTTSVXEJJMVQEXMZI�EGXMSR�FEWIH�SR�XLI�RIIH�JSV�HMZIVWMX]��E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�GIVXEMRP]EHHW�GSRWMHIVEFPI�HMZIVWMX]�XS�E�[SVPH�[MXL�QSVI�XLER�JSVX]�1YWPMQ�WXEXIWERH�RYQIVSYW�'LVMWXMER��,MRHY�ERH�&YHHLMWX�WXEXIW��%PXLSYKL�XLIVIEPVIEH]�I\MWXW�E�WXEXI�[MXL�E�QENSVMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�.SVHER��E�RI[�4EPIW�XMRMER�WXEXI�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE��KSZIVRIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMERW��[SYPHEPWS�EHH�ER�IPIQIRX�SJ�HMZIVWMX]�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 73: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�9�2��4EVXMXMSR�4PER�SJ������[EW�YRJEMV�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�

8,)�%''97)67

7LEZMX��©;SYPH�]SY�LEZI�EGGITXIH�XLI������4EVXMXMSR�4PER#ª

7EMH��©1]�MRWXMRGX�MW�XS�WE]�RS��-X�[EW�ER�YRJEMV�TPER�FEWIH�SR�XLI�QMRSV�MX]�KIXXMRK�IUYEP�VMKLXW�XS�XLSWI�SJ�XLI�QENSVMX]��4IVLETW�[I�WLSYPHR¬X�LEZIPIJX�MX�XLIVI��4IVLETW�[I�WLSYPH�LEZI�GSQI�YT�[MXL�E�TPER�SJ�SYV�S[R��&YX-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�XLI�4EVXMXMSR�4PER�[EW�YREGGITXEFPI�XS�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�SJ�XLI�XMQI�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�

©?-AR�������XLI�92�TVSTSWIH�E�WSPYXMSR�[LMGL�[EW�EGGITXIH�SRP]�F]SRI�WMHI��XLI�.I[MWL�SRI��%RH��MR�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��YWYEPP]�MJ�]SY�HSR¬X�LEZI�ER�EKVIIQIRX�SJ�FSXL�WMHIW��]SY�HSR¬X�MQTPIQIRX�XLEXWSPYXMSR��8LIVI��XLI�WXSV]�FIKER�XS�XYVR�FEH��8LI�JEGX�MW�XLEX�]SY�JSVGI�XLIWSPYXMSR�SR�E�QENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�TISTPI�PMZMRK�MR�4EPIWXMRI�[LS�STTSWI�XLEXWSPYXMSR��XLIR�]SY�WLSYPHR¬X�FI�WYVTVMWIH�XLEX�XLI]�STTSWIH�MX�IZIR�F]�JSVGI�

©������&YX�[I�HSR¬X�IZIR�LEZI�XLI�VMKLX�XS�WE]�XLI]�[IVI�[VSRK�XS�VIJYWIXLI�TEVXMXMSR��8LI]�ZMI[IH�>MSRMWQ�EW�E�GSPSRMEPMWX�QSZIQIRX��%RH�XLIVIEVI�ZIV]�PMXXPI�VIEWSRW�RSX�XS�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�TSMRX�SJ�ZMI[��.YWX�MQEKMRIXLI�%PKIVMER�REXMSREP�QSZIQIRX�EKVIIMRK�MR�XLI�JMJXMIW�XS�HMZMHI�%PKIVME

;EW�XLI�9�2��4EVXMXMSR

4PER�9RJEMV�XS�

4EPIWXMRMERW#

Page 74: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

MRXS�X[S�WXEXIW��FIX[IIR�XLIQ�ERH�XLI�[LMXI�WIXXPIVW��«PIW�TMIHW�RSMVW¬ �;LS�[SYPH�LEZI�WEMH�XS�XLI�%PKIVMER�PIEHIVWLMT�«(SR¬X�QMWW�XLI�LMWXSVMGGLERGI#¬�ª��-PER�4ETTI��TSPMXMGEP�WGMIRGI�PIGXYVIV�EX�,EMJE�9RMZIVWMX]�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�9�2��TPER�[EW�JEMV�XS�FSXL�WMHIW�ERH�[EW�E�VIJPIGXMSR�SJ�QYXYEP�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�FSXL�JSV�%VEFW�ERH�JSV�.I[W�ERH�MW�RS[�XLI�GSRWIRWYW�SJ[SVPH�STMRMSR�

8,)�4633*

%W�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�GSRGPYHIH�[LIR�MX�TEVXMXMSRIH�4EPIWXMRI�MR�������MXMW�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�FEWI�ER]�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI�TVSFPIQW�SR�XLI�GPEMQIH�©LMW�XSVMGEP�SVMKMRW�SJ�XLI�GSRJPMGXª�SV�©XLI�VMKLXW�ERH�[VSRKWª�EPPIKIH�F]�IEGLWMHI��8LI�©FEWMG�TVIQMWI�YRHIVP]MRKª�TEVXMXMSR�[EW�XLEX�©XLI�GPEMQW�XS4EPIWXMRI�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W��FSXL�TSWWIWWMRK�ZEPMHMX]��EVI�MVVIGSRGMP�EFPI�ª�-X�MW�YWIJYP�XS�UYSXI�JVSQ�XLI�9�2��JMRHMRKW��WMRGI�XLI]�JSVQ�XLIFEWMW�JSV�XLI�GYVVIRX�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSRWIRWYW�VIKEVHMRK�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPY�XMSR�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX�

�� �8LI�FEWMG�TVIQMWI�YRHIVP]MRK�XLI�TEVXMXMSR�TVSTSWEP�MW�XLEX�XLI

GPEMQW�XS�4EPIWXMRI�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W��FSXL�TSWWIWWMRK�ZEPMHMX]��EVI

MVVIGSRGMPEFPI��ERH�XLEX�EQSRK�EPP�XLI�WSPYXMSRW�EHZERGIH��TEVXMXMSR�[MPP

TVSZMHI�XLI�QSWX�VIEPMWXMG�ERH�TVEGXMGEFPI�WIXXPIQIRX��ERH�MW�XLI�QSWX

PMOIP]�XS�EJJSVH�E�[SVOEFPI�FEWMW�JSV�QIIXMRK�MR�TEVX�XLI�GPEMQW�ERH

REXMSREP�EWTMVEXMSRW�SJ�FSXL�TEVXMIW�

�� �-X�MW�E�JEGX�XLEX�FSXL�SJ�XLIWI�TISTPIW�LEZI�XLIMV�LMWXSVMG�VSSXW�MR

4EPIWXMRI��ERH�XLEX�FSXL�QEOI�ZMXEP�GSRXVMFYXMSRW�XS�XLI�IGSRSQMG�ERH

GYPXYVEP�PMJI�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]��8LI�TEVXMXMSR�WSPYXMSR�XEOIW�XLIWI�GSRWMHIVE�

XMSRW�JYPP]�MRXS�EGGSYRX�

�� �8LI�FEWMG�GSRJPMGX�MR�4EPIWXMRI�MW�E�GPEWL�SJ�X[S�MRXIRWI�REXMSR�

EPMWQW��6IKEVHPIWW�SJ�XLI�LMWXSVMGEP�SVMKMRW�SJ�XLI�GSRJPMGX��XLI�VMKLXW�ERH

[VSRKW�SJ�XLI�TVSQMWIW�ERH�GSYRXIV�TVSQMWIW��ERH�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP

MRXIVZIRXMSR�MRGMHIRX�XS�XLI�1ERHEXI��XLIVI�EVI�RS[�MR�4EPIWXMRI�WSQI

��������.I[W�ERH�����������%VEFW�[LS�EVI�HMWWMQMPEV�MR�XLIMV�[E]W�SJ

PMZMRK�ERH��JSV�XLI�XMQI�FIMRK��WITEVEXIH�F]�TSPMXMGEP�MRXIVIWXW�[LMGL�VIR�

HIV�HMJJMGYPX�JYPP�ERH�IJJIGXMZI�TSPMXMGEP�GSSTIVEXMSR�

�� �3RP]�F]�QIERW�SJ�TEVXMXMSR�GER�XLIWI�GSRJPMGXMRK�REXMSREP�EWTMVE�

XMSRW�JMRH�WYFWXERXMEP�I\TVIWWMSR�ERH�UYEPMJ]�FSXL�TISTPIW�XS�XEOI�XLIMV

TPEGIW�EW�MRHITIRHIRX�REXMSRW�MR�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�ERH�MR�XLI

9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�

Page 75: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

%W�WXEXIH�IEVPMIV��XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�MW�XLI�TVIQMWI�SJ�XLMW�FSSO�EW[IPP��-�VINIGX EW�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�HMH�MR�������EW�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRWHMH�MR�������EW�)LYH�&EVEO�HMH�MR�������ERH�EW�QSWX�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�HSIWRS[ XLI�I\XVIQMWX�GPEMQW�SR�FSXL�WMHIW��-�VINIGX�XLI�I\XVIQMWX�.I[MWLGPEMQ�XLEX�©EPP�SJ�+VIEXIV�-WVEIPª�WLSYPH�FI�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��ERH�-�VINIGX�XLII\XVIQMWX�%VEF�GPEMQ�XLEX�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��IZIR�MJ�MX�[IVI�©XLI�WMI�SJ�ETSWXEKI�WXEQT��������LEW�RS�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�ª�

8LI�GYVVIRX�[SVPH[MHI�GSRWIRWYW�WYTTSVXW�XLMW�TVIQMWI��XLEX�XLIVIWLSYPH�FI�X[S�WXEXIW��SRI�.I[MWL�ERH�SRI�4EPIWXMRMER��I\MWXMRK�WMHI�F]�WMHI�8LIVI�MW�RS�GSRWIRWYW�EW�XS�XLI�VIPEXMZI�WMI�ERH�TVIGMWI�FSVHIVW�SJ�XLI�X[SWXEXIW��&YX�XLI�TVMRGMTPI�SJ�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�MW�IZIR�QSVI�EGGITXIHXSHE]�XLER�MX�[EW�MR�������WMRGI�QSWX�%VEF�WXEXIW�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER%YXLSVMX]�WIIQ�XS�EGGITX�MX��EX�PIEWX�[LIR�XEPOMRK�XS�SYXWMHIVW��8LSWI�[LSGYVVIRXP]�VINIGX�MX�MRGPYHI�E�WQEPP�QMRSVMX]�SJ�-WVEIPMW�ERH�%QIVMGER�.I[W�EXXLI�JVMRKI�SJ�-WVEIPM�ERH�.I[MWL�WSGMIX]��4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW�WYGL�EW,EQEW��,IFYPPEL��-WPEQMG�.MLEH��ERH�XLI�4STYPEV�*VSRX�JSV�XLI�0MFIVE�XMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�VINIGXMSRMWX�WXEXIW�SJ�7]VME��-VER��ERH�0MF]E��-R�*IFVYEV]�������8EVMU�%M��XLI�JSVQIV�-VEUM�HITYX]�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�VIJYWIH�IZIR�XS�EGGITX�E�UYIWXMSR�JVSQ�ER�-WVEIPM�NSYVREPMWX�EX�ER�STIRTVIWW�GSRJIVIRGI�MR�6SQI� �&IGEYWI�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�MW�XLI�FIWX�LSTIJSV�TIEGI��MXW�EGGITXERGI�F]�-WVEIP�JMVWX�MR������ERH�XLIR�MR�������GSYTPIH[MXL�MXW�GEXIKSVMGEP�ERH�ZMSPIRX�VINIGXMSR�F]�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW��XLI�4EPIWXMRM�ERW��ERH�ZMVXYEPP]�IZIV]�1YWPMQ�PIEHIV JMVWX�MR������ERH�EKEMR�MR�����MW�E�GIRXVEP�GSQTSRIRX�MR�QEOMRK�XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP��-X�QYWX�FI�ERW[IVIHF]�ER]SRI�WIIOMRK�XS�QEOI�XLI�GEWI�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�

8LI�HIGMWMSR�XS�TEVXMXMSR�4EPIWXMRI EX�PIEWX�XLEX�TSVXMSR�RSX�EPVIEH]EPPSGEXIH�XS�ER�I\GPYWMZIP]�%VEF�IQMVEXI��VIREQIH�8VERWNSVHER�ERH�XLIR.SVHER MRXS�.I[MWL�ERH�%VEF�WXEXIW�[EW�RSX�E�VIJPIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�HMWGVIHMXIHGSPSRMEPMWQ�SV�MQTIVMEPMWQ�SJ�XLI�TEWX��6EXLIV��MX�[EW�EQSRK�XLI�JMVWXI\EQTPIW�SJ�XLI�RI[�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�XLEX�4VIWMHIRX�;SSHVS[�;MPWSRERH�QER]�SXLIV�TVSKVIWWMZIW�LEH�GLEQTMSRIH��7MRGI�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�MRXS�.I[MWL�ERH�%VEF�TSPMXMGEP�YRMXW��QER]�RI[�WXEXIW�LEZIIQIVKIH�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��MRGPYHMRK�WIZIVEP�-WPEQMG�WXEXIW��7SQI��PMOI�4EOMWXER��LEZI�VIWYPXIH�JVSQ�TEVXMXMSRW��=IX�XLI�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]�MR�XLSWI�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�TSVXMSRIHJSV�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MW��EPSRI�EQSRK�RI[P]�HIGPEVIH�WXEXIW��GLEVEGXIVMIH�F]WSQI�IRIQMIW�SJ�-WVEIP�EW�GSPSRMEPMWQ�ERH�MQTIVMEPMWQ��8LMW�MW�RS�QSVIXLER�EVKYQIRX�F]�REQI�GEPPMRK�SV�WPSKERMMRK��IZIR�XLSYKL�RIMXLIV�XLIREQI�RSV�XLI�WPSKER�JMXW�XLI�JEGXW�SV�XLI�LMWXSV]�

8LI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�.SVHER�ERH�XLI�WIPIGXMSR�SJ�MXW�,EWLIQMXI�VYPIV�F]�XLI�&VMXMWL�KSZIVRQIRX�MR������[EWER�EGX�SJ�MQTIVMEPMWQ�ERH�GSPS�RMEPMWQ��-XW�JSVQEP�I\GPYWMSR�SJ�EPP�.I[W�[EW�ER�EGX�SJ�FPEXERX�VEGMWQ��=IX

Page 76: The Case For Israel

XLIWI�GLEVEGXIVMEXMSRW�EVI�VEVIP]�LIEVH�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XLI�MPPIKMXMQEXI�FMVXLGIVXMJMGEXI�SJ�XLEX�REXMSR��8LI�.I[MWL�GPEMQ�XS�KSZIVR�XLI�.I[MWL�EVIE�SJ4EPIWXMRI�EPPSGEXIH�XS�MX�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�MW�GIVXEMRP]�QSVI�GSRWMWXIRX[MXL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�XLER�XLI�,EWLIQMXI�GPEMQW�XS�VYPI�SZIV�XLIQENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�.SVHER��=IX�XLI�WIPIGXMZI�REQI�GEPPIVW�ERH�WPSKERMIVW�EMQ�XLIMV�QMWKYMHIH�VLIXSVMG�SRP]�EX�XLI�.I[MWLWXEXI��8LI�FYVHIR�JEPPW�SR�XLIQ�XS�I\TPEMR�[L]�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 77: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�[EW�IWXEFPMWLIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI��HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�.I[WGSRWXMXYXIH�SRP]�E�QMRSVMX]�SJ�XLI�XSXEP�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�

8,)�%''97)67

©%QIVMGERW�VIGIMZI�QSWX�SJ�XLIMV�MRJSVQEXMSR�VIKEVHMRK�XLI�-WVEIPM�4EPIW�XMRMER�GSRJPMGX�JVSQ�GSVTSVEXI�GSRXVSPPIH��TSPMXMGEPP]�QERMTYPEXIH�QEMR�WXVIEQ�QIHME��*I[�LEZI�XLI�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�WGVYXMRMI�XLI�VIEPMX]�SJ�XLILMWXSV]�XLEX�LEW�VIWYPXIH�MR�XLI�XIRWMSRW�XLEX�I\MWX�MR�XLI�QMH�IEWX��*I[ORS[�XLEX�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI��MR�EPP�PIKMXMQEXI�[E]W��XLI�MRHMKIRSYW�TSTYPE�XMSR�SJ�XLI�EVIE��XLEX�XLI�PERH�RS[�SGGYTMIH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPMW�[EW�S[RIH�F]XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��XLEX�MR����������SJ�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR�[EW�%VEF�ERH�SRP]��.I[MWL��XLEX�MR�������4EPIWXMRMERW�EGGSYRXIH�JSV����SJ�XLI�TSTYPEXMSRIZIR�EW�.I[W�XLVSRKIH�XS�XLI�EVIE�JVSQ�)YVSTI�MR�ER�EXXIQTX�XS�IWGETIXLI�2EMW��XLEX�MR�������XLI�]IEV�XLEX�XLI�92�GVIEXIH�-WVEIP�[MXLSYX�XLIETTVSZEP�SJ�XLI�MRHMKIRSYW�TSTYPEXMSR��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VITVIWIRXIH���ERH�XLI�-WVEIPMW�PIWW�XLER����SJ�XLI�����������[LS�PMZIH�XLIVI�ª��;MPPMEQ%��'SSO��)RKPMWL�TVSJIWWSV�EX�XLI�9RMZIVWMX]�SJ�0E�:IVRI��MR�'EPMJSVRME�

©-R������XLIVI�[IVI���������.I[W�ERH�E�QMPPMSR�XLVII�LYRHVIH�XLSY�WERH�4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW��7S��[LIR�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�HMZMHIH�4EPIWXMRI��XLI

;IVI�.I[W�E�1MRSVMX]�MR;LEX�&IGEQI�-WVEIP#

Page 78: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

.I[W�[IVI�E�QMRSVMX]�����SJ�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR ��8LMW�HMZMWMSR��TVSQSXIH�F]XLI�QEMR�MQTIVMEPMWX�TS[IVW [MXL�WYTTSVX�JVSQ�7XEPMR KEZI����SJ�XLIJIVXMPI�PERH�XS�XLI�>MSRMWX�QSZIQIRX�ª��'IGMPME�8SPIHS��&VEMPMER�NSYVREPMWX�

©-X�MW�[SVXL�RSXMRK�XLEX�IZIR�EJXIV�JMZI�HIGEHIW�SJ�IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK�SGGYTEXMSR��ERH�HMWTSWWIWWMSR�XLI�HIQSKVETLMG�VEXMS�FIX[IIR�4EPIWXMRMERW�����QMPPMSR �ERH�-WVEIPM�.I[W�����§��QMPPMSR �MW�WXMPP�XLI�WEQI�EW�MX�[EW�MR(IGIQFIV�������[LMGL�[EW��ERH�WXMPP�MW ���XS���MR�JEZSV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERTISTPI��,S[IZIV��JSV�-WVEIP�XS�QEMRXEMR�MXW�HIQSGVEXMG�©.I[MWL�7XEXI�ª�ERHEFSZI�EPP�MXW�©.I[MWL�GLEVEGXIV�ª�MX�STXIH�XS�IXLRMGEPP]�GPIERWI����SJ�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�SYX�SJ�XLIMV�LSQIW��JEVQW��FYWMRIWWIW��FSEXW��FEROW��������IXG�ª��[[[�4EPIWXMRI6IQIQFIVIH�GSQ��MR�VIWTSRWI�XS�XLI�©-WVEIPM>MSRMWXW�?WMGA�TVSTEKERHEª�XLEX�©XLI�%VEFW�VINIGXIH�XLI������9�2��TEVXM�XMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��ERH�GSRWIUYIRXP]�EXXEGOIH�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��ERH�PSWX�XLI�����[EVª

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�.I[W�[IVI�E�WYFWXERXMEP�QENSVMX]�MR�XLSWI�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�TEVXMXMSRIHF]�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�JSV�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

8,)�4633*

%HZSGEXIW�SJXIR�TPE]�KEQIW�[MXL�XLI�HIQSKVETLMGW�MR�SVHIV�XS�WYTTSVXXLIMV�EKIRHE�HVMZIR�GSRGPYWMSRW��-R�IWXMQEXMRK�XLI�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ4EPIWXMRI�EX�XLI�XMQI�SJ�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR�SJ�������EHZSGEXIW�SJ�XLI�%VEFGEYWI�WSQIXMQIW�MRGPYHI�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�[LEX�MW�RS[�.SVHER��EW�[IPP�EW[LEX�MW�RS[�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE��-R�EWWIWWMRK�XLI�JEMVRIWW�SJ�XLI�9�2�4EVXMXMSR�4PER�SJ�������[LIR�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�HMZMHIH�4EPIWXMRI��XLIVIPIZERX�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�XLI�EVIE�MW�XLEX�EWWMKRIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWLWXEXI�MR�������)ZIR�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XLEX�TSTYPEXMSR��IWXMQEXIW�ZEV]��FYXXLI�SJJMGMEP�9�2��IWXMQEXI�[EW�XLEX�XLI�PERH�EWWMKRIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXIGSRXEMRIH�ETTVS\MQEXIP]���������.I[W�ERH���������%VEFW��E�RYQFIV�XLEXMRGPYHIH�'LVMWXMERW��&IHSYMRW��(VYI��ERH�SXLIVW �

2S�SRI�HSYFXW�XLEX�LEH�XLIVI�FIIR�E�VIJIVIRHYQ�SR�XLI�MWWYI�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�ERH�WITEVEXMSR��XLI�VIWMHIRXW�SJ�XLI�EVIE�TEVXMXMSRIH�F]�XLI9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�JSV�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�[SYPH�LEZI�ZSXIH�SZIV[LIPQMRKP]�MRJEZSV�SJ�[LEX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�HIGVIIH��-R�XIVQW�SJ�XLI�HMZMWMSR�SJ�PERH�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�VIGIMZIH�WSQI[LEX�QSVI�XLER�XLI�%VEFW��FYX�SRP]�MJ�SRIGSYRXW�JYPP]�XLI�2IKIZ�(IWIVX��[LMGL�[EW�HIIQIH�YRMRLEFMXEFPI�ERHYRGYPXMZEXEFPI��-J�XLI�2IKIZ�MW�I\GPYHIH�SV�WYFWXERXMEPP]�HMWGSYRXIH��XLIYWEFPI�PERH�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�%VEFW�[EW�PEVKIV�XLER�XLEX�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI

Page 79: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

.I[W��1SVISZIV��QYGL�SJ�XLI�PERH�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�[EW�SVMKM�REPP]�W[EQT�ERH�HIWIVX�PERH�XLEX�LEH�FIIR�MVVMKEXIH�ERH�QEHI�JIVXMPI�F].I[MWL�PEFSV�ERH�MRZIWXQIRX��8LI�PERH�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�%VEFW�[EW�EPWS�GSR�XMKYSYW�[MXL�ERH�TVS\MQEXI�XS�8VERWNSVHER��[LSWI�TSTYPEXMSR�LEW�EP[E]WFIIR�TVIHSQMRERXP]�4EPIWXMRMER��EPXLSYKL�E�,EWLIQMXI�QSREVGL]�[EWMQTSWIH�SR�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR�F]�+VIEX�&VMXEMR�

8LI�PERH�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�.I[W�HMH�RSX�MRGPYHI�[IWXIVR�.IVYWEPIQ�[LMGL�LEH�E�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��SV�,IFVSR��X[S�SJ�.YHEMWQ¬W�LSPMIWX�ERHQSWX�LMWXSVMG�GMXMIW��.IVYWEPIQ��[MXL�E�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ����������[EWXS�FI�MRXIVREXMSREPMIH�FYX�GYX�SJJ�JVSQ�XLI�.I[MWL�EVIEW��,IFVSR�[EW�XSFI�TEVX�SJ�XLI�%VEF�WIGXSV��[MXL�RS�.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI��HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX.I[W�LEH�PMZIH�XLIVI�JSV�XLSYWERHW�SJ�]IEVW�YRXMP�4EPIWXMRMER�QEWWEGVIW�SJ.I[MWL�[SQIR��GLMPHVIR��ERH�SPH�QIR�HVSZI�SYX�XLI�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR�MR�����ERH�EKEMR�MR������

&IGEYWI�XLI�PERH�MR�[LMGL�XLI�.I[W�[IVI�XS�PMZI�[EW�HMZMHIH�MRXS�RSR�GSRXMKYSYW�EVIEW�ERH�WITEVEXIH�F]�%VEF�PERH��MX�[SYPH�FI�HMJJMGYPX�XSHIJIRH�MR�XLI�JEGI�SJ�XLI�XLVIEXIRIH�%VEF�EXXEGO��-R�EHHMXMSR�XS�.IVYWEPIQ�7EJEH�[EW�MWSPEXIH��)ZIR�8IP�%ZMZ�GSYPH�IEWMP]�FI�GYX�SJJ�F]�IRIQ]�JSVGIWEX�XLI�REVVS[�[EMWXPMRI�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�EVIE��[LMGL�QIEWYVIH�ETTVS\MQEXIP]��QMPIW�FIX[IIR�XLI�%VEF�EVIE�ERH�XLI�1IHMXIVVERIER�

2IZIVXLIPIWW��-WVEIP�UYMGOP]�EGGITXIH�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR�ERH�WSSRHIGPEVIH�WXEXILSSH��8LI�%VEFW�VINIGXIH�XLI�TEVXMXMSR�ERH�EXXEGOIH�XLI�RI[.I[MWL�WXEXI�JVSQ�XLI�EMV�ERH�XLI�KVSYRH��;LEX�VIQEMRIH�SJ�XLI�TVSTSWIH4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�EJXIV�-WVEIP�VITIPPIH�XLIWI�EXXEGOW�[EW�UYMGOP]�KSFFPIH�YTF]�.SVHER�ERH�)K]TX�

,EH�XLI�%VEFW�EGGITXIH�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR��XLIVI�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�EPEVKI��GSRXMKYSYW�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�EPSRKWMHI�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��8LI�X[S�WXEXIWSPYXMSR�XLEX�MW�RS[�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSRWIRWYW�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�EGLMIZIH[MXLSYX�FPSSHWLIH��7YVIP]�ER]SRI�[LS�RS[�EGGITXW�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSRQYWX�TPEGI�XLI�FPEQI�JSV�MX�RSX�FIMRK�MQTPIQIRXIH�MR�������SV�IZIR�IEV�PMIV�MR����� �SR�XLI�%VEF�ERH�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�[LS�VINIGXIH�E�4EPIWXMR�MER�WXEXI�[LIR�MX�[EW�SJJIVIH�XS�XLIQ���%W�[I�[MPP�WII�MR�GLETXIVW����ERH����E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��[MXL�MXW�GETMXEP�MR�.IVYWEPIQ��[EW�EKEMR�SJJIVIH�EX'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�MR������ERH�EKEMR�VINIGXIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��[LSVIWTSRHIH�XS�XLI�SJJIV�RSX�F]�QEOMRK�ER]�GSYRXIVTVSTSWEP�FYX�F]MRGVIEWMRK�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�

Page 80: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP�MW�XLI�GEYWI�SJ�XLI�%VEF§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LIVI�MW�RS�W]QQIXV]�MR�XLMW�GSRJPMGX��3RI�[SYPH�LEZI�XS�WE]�XLEX��-HIITP]�FIPMIZI�XLEX��8LIVI�MW�E�KYMPX]�WMHI�ERH�XLIVI�EVI�ZMGXMQW��8LI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�EVI�XLI�ZMGXMQW�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�

8,)�6)%0-8=

%VEF�VINIGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�LEW�PSRK�FIIR�XLI�GEYWI�SJ�XLITVSFPIQ�

8,)�4633*

8LI�VITIEXIH�VINIGXMSR�F]�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�0MFIVEXMSR3VKERMEXMSR��XLI�%VEF�[SVPH��ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�SJ�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�SV�LSQIPERH �WSPYXMSR�JVSQ������[LIR�MX�[EW�JMVWX�SJJMGMEPP]�TVSTSWIHYRXMP�VIPEXMZIP]�VIGIRXP]�PMIW�EX�XLI�LIEVX�SJ�XLI�GSRJPMGX��8LI�VIEWSR�JSV�XLIVINIGXMSR�LEW�FIIR�XLEX�QSWX�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�PIEHIVW�GEVIH�QSVI�EFSYXHIR]MRK�XLI�.I[W�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�XLSWI�EVIEW�SJ�4EPIWXMRIMR�[LMGL�XLI]�[IVI�E�QENSVMX]�XLER�MR�I\IVGMWMRK�XLIMV�S[R�VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�

,EW�-WVEIPtW�:MGXMQMEXMSRSJXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�&IIRXLI�4VMQEV]�'EYWI�SJXLI%VEFi-WVEIPM�'SRJPMGX#

��

Page 81: The Case For Israel

HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�XLSWI�EVIEW�[MXL�E�1YWPMQ�QENSVMX]��8LMW�WEH�VIEPMX]�MWHIQSRWXVEXIH�F]�XLI�[SVHW�SJ�WS�QER]�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH�%VEF�PIEHIVW�SZIVE�PSRK�TIVMSH�SJ�XMQI��8LMW�VIEPMX]�MW�FI]SRH�VIEWSREFPI�HMWTYXI��;LIR�XLI4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�UYIWXMSRIH�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�MR�������LI�RSX�SRP]�VIJYWIHXS�EGGITX�ER]�.I[MWL�WIPJ�VYPI��©TSPMXMGEP�TS[IV�ª�SV�©TVMZMPIKI�ª�LI�GEXI�KSVMGEPP]�VIJYWIH�IZIR�XS�©TVSZMHI�KYEVERXIIW�JSV�XLI�WEJIX]�SJ�XLI�.I[MWLTSTYPEXMSR�MR�XLI�IZIRX�SJ�ER�%VEF�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�ª�8LMW�QEHI�MX�GIVXEMR�SJ�GSYVWI��XLEX�XLIVI�[SYPH�FI�RS�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�SV�JIHIVEP�HMZMWMSR�%JXIV�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�GSRGPYHIH�LMW�XIWXMQSR]��XLI�GSQQMXXII�©RSXIHMVSRMGEPP]ª�

;IEVI�RSX�UYIWXMSRMRK�XLI�WMRGIVMX]�SV�XLI�LYQERMX]�SJ�XLI�1YJXM¬W

MRXIRXMSRW�ERH�XLSWI�SJ�LMW�GSPPIEKYIW��FYX�[I�GERRSX�JSVKIX�[LEX

VIGIRXP]�LETTIRIH��HIWTMXI�XVIEX]�TVSZMWMSRW�ERH�I\TPMGMX�EWWYVERGIW��XS

XLI�%WW]VMER�QMRSVMX]�MR�-VEU��RSV�GER�[I�JSVKIX�XLEX�XLI�LEXVIH�SJ�XLI

%VEF�TSPMXMGMERW�JSV�XLI�2EXMSREP�,SQI�LEW�RIZIV�FIIR�GSRGIEPIH�ERH

XLEX�MX�LEH�RS[�TIVQIEXIH�XLI�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�EW�E�[LSPI�ª�

0MXXPI�LEW�GLERKIH�SZIV�XLI�]IEVW��8LI�SJJMGMEP�VEHMS�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER%YXLSVMX]�FVSEHGEWX�E�WIVQSR�SR�%TVMP�����������MR�[LMGL�XLI�JSPPS[MRK[EW�WEMH�

8LI�0ERH�SJ�1YWPMQ�4EPIWXMRI�MW�E�WMRKPI�YRMX�[LMGL�GERRSX�FI�HMZMHIH�

8LIVI�MW�RS�HMJJIVIRGI�FIX[IIR�,EMJE�ERH�7LIGLIQ��2EFPYW ��FIX[IIR

0SH�ERH�6EQEPPEL��ERH�FIX[IIR�.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�2EEVIXL�������XLI�PERH�SJ

4EPIWXMRI�MW�WEGVIH�[EUJ�PERH�JSV�XLI�FIRIJMX�SJ�EPP�1YWPMQW��IEWX�ERH�[IWX�

2S�SRI�LEW�XLI�VMKLX�XS�HMZMHI�MX�SV�KMZI�YT�ER]�SJ�MX��8LI�PMFIVEXMSR�SJ

4EPIWXMRI�MW�SFPMKEXSV]�JSV�EPP�XLI�-WPEQMG�REXMSRW�ERH�RSX�SRP]�JSV�XLI

4EPIWXMRMER�REXMSR��

%RH�MR�������XLI�GLMIJ�NYWXMGI�SJ�XLI�1YWPMQ�8VYWX�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�ETTSMRXIH�F]�=EWWIV�%VEJEX��WEMH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�

©%PP�4EPIWXMRI�MW�-WPEQMG�PERH��������8LI�.I[W�YWYVTIH�MX��������8LIVI�GER�FIRS�GSQTVSQMWI�SR�-WPEQMG�PERH�ª�%�JEX[E�TVSLMFMXW�IZIR�XLI�WEPI�SJ�ER]4EPIWXMRMER�PERH�XS�.I[W��HIGPEVMRK�MX�XS�FI�©ER�EGX�SJ�ETSWXEW]�ERH�VINIG�XMSR�SJ�-WPEQ�ª�%RH�MX�MW�TVSLMFMXIH��EGGSVHMRK�XS�WSQI�-WPEQMG�WGLSPEVW�JSV�.I[W�XS�VYPI�SZIV�1YWPMQW�SV�1YWPMQ�PERH��

-R�VIGIRX�]IEVW��XLI�QEMRWXVIEQ�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�LEW�JMREPP]�WEMHXLSYKL�RSX�[MXLSYX�WSQI�EQFMKYMX]�ERH�FEGOTIHEPMRK XLEX�XLI]�EGGITXXLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�-WVEIP��WS�PSRK�EW�MX�VIXYVRW�XS�FSYRHEVMIW�XLEX�XLI�4EP�IWXMRMERW�LEH�TVIZMSYWP]�VINIGXIH�F]�ZMSPIRGI��&YX�QER]�SXLIV�4EPIWXMRMERERH�%VEF�PIEHIVW�WXMPP�VINIGX�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��8LIWI�MRGPYHI�RSX�SRP]XLI�VINIGXMSRMWX�WXEXIW��WYGL�EW�7]VME��-VER��ERH�0MF]E �ERH�XLI�VINIGXMSRMWX

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 82: The Case For Israel

4EPIWXMRMER�SVKERMEXMSRW��WYGL�EW�,EQEW��,IFYPPEL��ERH�-WPEQMG�.MLEH FYX�EPWS�MQTSVXERX�©QEMRWXVIEQª�ZSMGIW�XLEX�TYVTSVX�XS�WTIEO�JSV�4EPIW�XMRMERW��8LIWI�ZSMGIW�MRGPYHI�4VSJIWWSV�)H[EVH�7EMH�SJ�'SPYQFME�9RMZIV�WMX]��[LS�LEW�XVMIH�XS�TYX�LMW�GEXIKSVMGEP�VINIGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�I\MWXIRGI�MRXIVQW�©TSPMXMGEPP]�EGGITXEFPIª�XS�WIGYPEVMWXW�

8LI�SRP]�VIEWSREFPI�GSYVWI�������MW�XS�VIGSQQIRH�XLEX�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH

XLIMV�WYTTSVXIVW�VIRI[�XLI�WXVYKKPI�EKEMRWX�XLI�JYRHEQIRXEP�TVMRGMTPI

XLEX�VIPIKEXIW�©RSR�.I[Wª�XS�WYFWIVZMIRGI�SR�XLI�PERH�SJ�LMWXSVMGEP�4EPIW�

XMRI��������3RP]�MJ�XLI�MRLIVIRX�GSRXVEHMGXMSR�MW�JEGIH�FIX[IIR�[LEX�MR

IJJIGX�MW�E�XLISGVEXMG�ERH�IXLRMG�I\GPYWMZMWQ�SR�XLI�SRI�LERH�ERH�KIRYMRI

HIQSGVEG]�SR�XLI�SXLIV��GER�XLIVI�FI�ER]�LSTI�JSV�VIGSRGMPMEXMSR�ERH

TIEGI�MR�-WVEIP�4EPIWXMRI��

;LEX�7EMH�JEMPW�XS�QIRXMSR�MW�XLEX�IZIV]�WMRKPI�1YWPMQ�ERH�%VEF�WXEXI�MRGPYHMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��VIPIKEXIW�.I[W�XS�E�TSWMXMSR�XLEX�MW�JEVMRJIVMSV�XS�XLEX�SJ�RSR�.I[W�MR�PEVKIP]�WIGYPEV�-WVEIP��7EMH�EPWS�WYKKIWXW�XLEXXLI�EPXIVREXMZI�XS�-WVEIP�[SYPH�FI�E�©KIRYMRI�HIQSGVEG]�ª�[MXLSYXEGORS[PIHKMRK�XLEX�RS�%VEF�SV�-WPEQMG�WXEXI��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMEREYXLSVMX]��GSQIW�GPSWI�XS�FIMRK�EW�HIQSGVEXMG�EW�-WVEIP��%PXLSYKL�-WVEIP�MWF]�JEV�XLI�PIEWX�XLISGVEXMG�ERH�QSWX�HIQSGVEXMG�WXEXI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWXFSXL�F]�PE[�ERH�F]�TVEGXMGI 7EMH�WMRKPIW�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�GSRHIQREXMSR��EWMJ�MX�[IVI�XLI�SRP]�WXEXI�MR�XLI�VIKMSR�XS�IPIZEXI�SRI�VIPMKMSR�SZIV�ERSXLIV�8LI�FYVHIR�SJ�I\TPEREXMSR�JSV�XLMW�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�JEPPW�WUYEVIP]�SR�LMQ�

6IGIRX�TYFPMG�STMRMSR�TSPPW�XEOIR�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�TSPPMRK�SVKERMEXMSRWEPWS�WLS[�XLEX�E�QENSVMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�HS�RSX�EGGITX�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPY�XMSR��%W�QER]�EW����TIVGIRX�MR�SRI�TSPP�[IVI�MR�JEZSV�SJ�©PMFIVEXMRK�EPP�SJ4EPIWXMRI�ª�)ZIR�=EWWIV�%VEJEX��[LS�PSRK�VINIGXIH�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�XLIR�ETTIEVIH�XS�EGGITX�MX��LEW�WTSOIR�SYX�SJ�FSXL�WMHIW�SJ�LMW�QSYXL�%JXIV�WMKRMRK�XLI�3WPS�%GGSVHW��[LMGL�GSRXIQTPEXIH�ER�IZIRXYEP�X[S�WXEXIWSPYXMSR��%VEJEX�[EW�GEYKLX�QEOMRK�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�WXEXIQIRX�XS�%VEF�PIEH�IVW�MR�7XSGOLSPQ¬W�+VERH�,SXIP�

;ISJ�XLI�403�[MPP�RS[�GSRGIRXVEXI�EPP�SYV�IJJSVXW�SR�WTPMXXMRK�-WVEIP

TW]GLSPSKMGEPP]�MRXS�X[S�GEQTW��������;MXLMR�JMZI�]IEVW��[I�[MPP�LEZI�WM\�XS

WIZIR�QMPPMSR�%VEFW�PMZMRK�SR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�MR�.IVYWEPIQ��%PP�4EPIW�

XMRMER�%VEFW�[MPP�FI�[IPGSQIH�F]�YW��-J�XLI�.I[W�GER�MQTSVX�EPP�OMRHW�SJ

)XLMSTMERW��6YWWMERW��9 FIOW�ERH�9OVEMRMERW�EW�.I[W��[I�GER�MQTSVX�EPP

OMRHW�SJ�%VEFW�XS�YW��������?8LI�403�TPERWA�XS�IPMQMREXI�XLI�7XEXI�SJ�-WVEIP

ERH�IWXEFPMWL�E�TYVIP]�4EPIWXMRMER�7XEXI��;I�[MPP�QEOI�PMJI�YRFIEVEFPI�JSV

XLI�.I[W�F]�TW]GLSPSKMGEP�[EVJEVI�ERH�TSTYPEXMSR�I\TPSWMSR��.I[W�[SR¬X

[ERX�XS�PMZI�EQSRK�YW�%VEFW��

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 83: The Case For Israel

8LMW�[EW�IRXMVIP]�GSRWMWXIRX�[MXL�ZMI[W�I\TVIWWIH�IEVPMIV�F]�%FY�-]EH��SRISJ�%VEJEX¬W�GLMIJ�HITYXMIW��©%GGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�4LEWIH�4PER��[I�[MPP�IWXEFPMWLE�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�SR�ER]�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�XLI�IRIQ]�[MPP�VIXVIEXJVSQ��8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�[MPP�FI�E�WXEKI�MR�SYV�TVSPSRKIH�WXVYKKPI�JSVXLI�PMFIVEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�SR�EPP�SJ�MXW�XIVVMXSVMIW�ª�

;LEXIZIV�XLI�GYVVIRX�ZMI[W�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�%VEFW��XLIVI�GER�FI�RSHMWTYXI�XLEX�YRXMP�VIPEXMZIP]�VIGIRXP]�XLI�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR[EW�ZMVXYEPP]�YRERMQSYW�EQSRK�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�%VEFW��2SV�GER�XLIVI�FIER]�HMWTYXI�XLEX�XLMW�VINIGXMSR��SZIV�WS�QER]�]IEVW�ERH�WS�QER]�QMWWIHSTTSVXYRMXMIW�JSV�GSQTVSQMWI��LEW�GSRXVMFYXIH�KVIEXP]�XS�XLI�FPSSHWLIH�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 84: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI�[EW�ER�I\TERWMSRMWX�EKKVIWWMSR�WXEVXIH�F]-WVEIP�

8,)�%''97)67

©-R�SVHIV�XS�TEMRX�-WVEIP�EW�XLI�ZMGXMQ��XLI�>MSRMWX�REVVEXMZI�GPEMQW�XLEX%VEF�EVQMIW�JVSQ�)K]TX��7]VME�ERH�.SVHER�EXXEGOIH�-WVEIP�XLI�HE]�EJXIV�MX[EW�GVIEXIH�SR�1E]����������?WMGA�©;IVI�XLI�%VEFW�EXXEGOMRK�ER�IWXEFPMWLIH�WXEXI�[MXL�E�LMWXSVMGEP��QSVEP

ERH�PIKEP�VMKLX�XS�4EPIWXMRI��SV�[IVI�XLI]�QIVIP]�HIJIRHMRK�XLIQWIPZIWXLIMV�PERHW��XLIMV�LSQIW��XLIMV�LMWXSVMGEP�VMKLXW EKEMRWX�E�JSVIMKR�SGGYTE�XMSR�WYTTSVXIH�WYGGIWWMZIP]�F]�X[S�MQTIVMEPMWX�TS[IVW��&VMXEMR�ERH�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW#©-R�������XLI�%VEFW�LEH�HSRI�[LEX�-�LEZI�RS�HSYFX�XLI�%QIVMGERW

[SYPH�LEZI�HSRI��XLI]�HIJIRHIH�XLIQWIPZIW�EKEMRWX�ER�EPMIR�MRZEWMSR�ª�1��7LELMH�%PEQ�

8,)�6)%0-8=

-WVEIP�HIJIRHIH�MXWIPJ�EKEMRWX�E�KIRSGMHEP�[EV�SJ�I\XIVQMREXMSR�

;EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ-RHITIRHIRGI)\TERWMSRMWX�%KKVIWWMSR#

��

Page 85: The Case For Israel

8,)�4633*

%W�WSSR�EW�-WVEIP�HIGPEVIH�MXW�MRHITIRHIRGI��)K]TX��.SVHER��7]VME��-VEU��ERH0IFERSR�EXXEGOIH�MX��[MXL�LIPT�JVSQ�7EYHM�%VEFME��=IQIR��ERH�0MF]E��%VEFEVQMIW��[MXL�XLI�LIPT�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW��HIXIVQMRIH�XS�HIWXVS]�XLIRI[�.I[MWL�WXEXI�ERH�I\XIVQMREXI�MXW�TSTYPEXMSR�8LI�JMVWX�EXXEGO�SR�-WVEIP�GEQI�JVSQ�XLI�EMV��)K]TXMER�EMVGVEJX�FSQFIH

-WVEIP¬W�PEVKIWX�GMZMPMER�GIRXIV��XLI�GMX]�SJ�8IP�%ZMZ��%R�%WWSGMEXIH�4VIWWEGGSYRX�SR�1E]�����������HIWGVMFIH�XLI�EXXEGO��©%VEF�4PERIW�,MX�8IP%ZMZ��8MFIVMEW��-RZEHIV�,EQQIVMRK�.I[MWL�3YXTSWXW�ª�%W�[MXL�ZMVXYEPP]IZIV]�TVIZMSYW�%VEF�EXXEGO�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W�WMRGI�XLI�JMVWX�VIJYKIIW�EVVMZIHMR�4EPIWXMRI ERH�IZIR�FIJSVI XLI�XEVKIXW�[IVI�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW��©(MW�TEXGLIW�JVSQ�%VEF�GETMXEPW�WEMH�XLI�MRZEWMSR�EVQMIW�SJ�JMZI�%VEF�REXMSRWLEQQIVIH�E[E]�[MXL�EMV�ERH�EVXMPPIV]�EXXEGOW�EX�SYXP]MRK�.I[MWL�WIXXPI�QIRXW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�ª8LI�EVXMGPI�[IRX�SR�XS�HIWGVMFI�XLI�WLIPPMRK�SJ�.I[MWL�GMZMPMER�LSQIW��©%

.I[MWL�WIXXPIV�[LS�EVVMZIH�MR�,EMJE�KEZI�XLMW�EGGSYRX�SJ�XLI�JMKLXMRK�MR�XLI+EPMPII�EVIE��IRIQ]�TPERIW�EXXEGOIH�%WLHSX�=EEGSZ��%JMOMQ�ERH�)MR�+IK�EW[IPP�EW�8MFIVMEW��)MR�+IK�[EW�TSYRHIH�JVSQ�XLI�XVERW�.SVHER�LMPPW�ª�8LI,EKEREL��XLI�-WVEIPM�GMXMIR�EVQ]��©GPEMQIH�XS�LEZI�OMPPIH�����IRIQ]�WSP�HMIVW�EX�1EPMO]E�SR�XLI�0IFERIWI�FSVHIV�NYWX�MRWMHI�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�ª�

8LI�)K]TXMER�EMV�EXXEGOW�TIVWMWXIH�ERH�GMZMPMERW�[IVI�OMPPIH��IWTIGMEPP]�MRER�EMV�EXXEGO�XLEX�XEVKIXIH�XLI�GIRXVEP�GMZMPMER�FYW�WXEXMSR�MR�8IP�%ZMZ�)JJSVXW�[IVI�EPWS�QEHI�XS�WLIPP�XLI�GMX]�JVSQ�XLI�KVSYRH��8LI�JPIHKPMRK-WVEIPM�EMV�JSVGI�VIWTSRHIH�F]�XEVKIXMRK�QMPMXEV]�MRWXEPPEXMSRW�MR�ERHEVSYRH�%QQER�ERH�(EQEWGYW��OMPPMRK�RS�GMZMPMERW�8LI�TEXXIVR�SJ�TEWX�ERH�JYXYVI�JMKLXMRK�[EW�XLYW�IWXEFPMWLIH��XLI�%VEFW

[SYPH�XEVKIX�WSJX�GMZMPMER�EVIEW GMXMIW��XS[RW��OMFFYXMQ��ERH�QSWLEZMQXV]MRK�XS�OMPP�EW�QER]�GLMPHVIR��[SQIR��IPHIVP]��ERH�SXLIV�YREVQIH�GMZMP�MERW�EW�TSWWMFPI��[LMPI�XLI�-WVEIPMW�[SYPH�VIWTSRH�F]�XEVKIXMRK�WSPHMIVW�QMPMXEV]�IUYMTQIRX��ERH�SXLIV�PE[JYP�XEVKIXW��1MPMXEV]�EXXEGOW�XLEX�XEVKIXGMZMPMERW�EVI�MR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�ERH�XLI�PE[�SJ�[EV��]IX�XLIWILEZI�EP[E]W�FIIR�ERH�GSRXMRYI�XS�FI�XLI�XEVKIXW�SJ�GLSMGI�RSX�SRP]�F]%VEF�XIVVSVMWXW�ERH�KYIVVMPPEW�FYX�EPWS�F]�XLI�VIKYPEV�EVQMIW�SJ�.SVHER�)K]TX��7]VME��ERH�-VEU��8LMW�MW�WMQTP]�LMWXSVMGEP�JEGX��ERH�RS�VIEWSREFPI�QMP�MXEV]�LMWXSVMER�LEW�IZIR�XVMIH�XS�HMWTYXI�MX�%W�[I�WLEPP�WII�MR�GLETXIVW����ERH�����XLI�VIKYPEV�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�LEW�RSX

VIWTSRHIH�F]�XEVKIXMRK�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW��WYGL�EW�%QQER��(EQ�EWGYW��ERH�'EMVS��IZIR�XLSYKL�XLIWI�GMXMIW�LEZI�FIIR�[IPP�[MXLMR�XLI�VERKISJ�-WVEIPM�EMVGVEJX��8LI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]��PMOI�IZIV]�SXLIV�EVQ]�MR�XLI�[SVPH��LEWOMPPIH�GMZMPMERW�[LMPI�EXXEGOMRK�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW��IWTIGMEPP]�WMRGI�XLI�%VEFEVQMIW�ERH�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW�SJXIR�LMHI�ERH�TVSXIGX�XLIMV�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW�F]HIPMFIVEXIP]�WYVVSYRHMRK�XLIQ�[MXL�GMZMPMER�WLMIPHW��-WVEIP��SR�XLI�SXLIV

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 86: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

LERH��LEW�MWSPEXIH�MXW�QMPMXEV]�FEWIW�EW�JEV�EW�TSWWMFPI�JVSQ�MXW�GMZMPMER�TST�YPEXMSR�GIRXIVW��8LIVI�MW��SJ�GSYVWI��ER�IRSVQSYW�HMJJIVIRGI�MR�QSVEPMX]�EW[IPP�EW�PE[�MR�I\TVIWWP]�XEVKIXMRK�GMZMPMERW��EW�XLI�%VEFW�LEZI�PSRK�HSRI��ERHGSPPEXIVEPP]LMXXMRK�GMZMPMERW�[LS�EVI�GPSWI�XS�ETTVSTVMEXI�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXWXLEX�TSWI�E�GSRXMRYMRK�HERKIV��8LI�JSVQIV�MW�E�GVMQI�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]EFWSPYXIP]�TVSLMFMXIH�F]�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��8LI�PEXXIV�MW�TIVQMWWMFPI�YRHIVXLI�PE[W�SJ�[EV�WS�PSRK�EW�XLI�VIWTSRWI�MW�TVSTSVXMSREP�ERH�VIEWSREFPI�ERHIJJSVXW�EVI�QEHI�XS�QMRMQMI�MRIZMXEFPI�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�8LI�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI�[EW�WXEVXIH�F]�XLI�%VEFW��[LSWI

I\TVIWW�EMQ�[EW�KIRSGMHEP��©1YVHIV�XLI�.I[Wª�ERH�©(VMZI�XLI�.I[W�MRXSXLI�WIEª�[IVI�XLI�FEXXPI�GVMIW�SJ�XLI�MRZEHMRK�EVQMIW��8LI�%VEF�0MFIVEXMSR%VQ]�[EW�GSQQERHIH�F]�*E[M�EP�5E[YUNM��[LS�LEH�WEX�SYX�XLI�[EV]IEVW�MR�+IVQER]��FVSEHGEWXMRK�XLI�2EM�QIWWEKI�XS�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�3XLIV�JSVQIV�2EM�STIVEXMZIW�EPWS�TEVXMGMTEXIH�MR�XLMW�[EV�SJ�I\XIVQMREXMSREKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W��QER]�SJ�[LSQ�[IVI�WYVZMZSVW�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��8LI�MRM�XMEP�QIERW�WIPIGXIH�[EW�XLI�XEVKIXMRK�SJ�GMZMPMERW�F]�©QENSV�YVFER�XIVVSVMWXEXXEGOW��TVSFEFP]�QSYRXIH�[MXL�,YWWIMRM¬W�TIVWSREP�FPIWWMRK�ª�8LI�%VEFEVQMIW�EPWS�QEWWEGVIH�GMZMPMERW��IZIR�EJXIV�XLI]�WYVVIRHIVIH�8LI]�VITIEXIHP]ERH�HIPMFIVEXIP]�HVSTTIH�FSQFW�SR�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�RIEVEFWSPYXIP]�RS�PIKMXMQEXI�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW��,YWWIMRM¬W�©GLMIJ�FSQF�QEOIV�*E[M�EP�/EXEF��LEH�PIEVRIH�LMW�GVEJX�MR�ER�77�GSYVWI�MR�2EM�+IVQER]�ª�

8LI�KSEP�[EW�XS�JMRMWL�XLI�NSF�,MXPIV�LEH�WXEVXIH��©8LMW�[MPP�FI�E�[EV�SJI\XIVQMREXMSR�ª� =IX�4VSJIWWSV�)H[EVH�7EMH�MRWMWXW�SR�GEPPMRK�XLI����§�����EXXEGO�SR�-WVEIP�©XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�FMGSQQYREP�[EV�ª�

%X�KVIEX�GSWX�MR�LYQER�PMJI -WVEIP�PSWX���TIVGIRX�SJ�MXW�XSXEP�TSTYPE�XMSR XLI�VEKXEK�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�HIJIEXIH�XLI�MRZEHMRK�%VEF�EVQMIW�ERH�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�EXXEGOIVW��8LI]�[SR�MR�PEVKI�TEVX�FIGEYWI��EW�1SVVMW�EVKYIW��XLIWXEOIW�[IVI�QYGL�KVIEXIV�JSV�XLIQ��8LI]�LEH�XLI�©QSVEPI�FSSWXMRK�WXMQ�YPYWª�SJ�JMKLXMRK�JSV�XLIMV

S[R�LSQI�ERH�JMIPHW��MR�QER]�GEWIW�PMXIVEPP] �ERH�MR�HIJIRWI�SJ�SRI¬W

PSZIH�SRIW��1SVISZIV��EW�HYVMRK�XLI�JMVWX�©GMZMPª�LEPJ�SJ�XLI�[EV��XLI�.I[W

JIPX�XLEX�XLI]�JEGIH�WPEYKLXIV�WLSYPH�XLI]�FI�HIJIEXIH��;MXL�XLI�QIQSV]

SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�WXMPP�JVIWL�MR�XLIMV�QMRHW��XLI�,EKEREL�XVSSTIVW�[IVI

MQFYIH�[MXL�YRPMQMXIH�QSXMZEXMSR��

8LI�%VEF�WSPHMIVW�SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��[IVI�JMKLXMRK�ER�EKKVIWWMZI�[EV��JEVE[E]�JVSQ�LSQI��ERH�JSV�E�WSQI[LEX�©EFWXVEGX�GEYWI�ª�

-R�HIJIEXMRK�XLI�%VEF�EVQMIW��-WVEIP�GETXYVIH�QSVI�PERH�XLER�XLEX�EPPSX�XIH�XS�MX�F]�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR��1YGL�SJ�XLI�RI[P]�GETXYVIH�PERH�LEH�WMK�RMJMGERX�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSRW�ERH�WIXXPIQIRXW��WYGL�EW�MR�[IWXIVR�+EPMPII�8LMW�PERH�LEH�XS�FI�GETXYVIH�MR�SVHIV�XS�EWWYVI�XLI�WEJIX]�SJ�MXW�.I[MWL

Page 87: The Case For Israel

GMZMPMER�VIWMHIRXW��8LI�)K]TXMERW�ERH�.SVHERMERW�EPWS�GETXYVIH�PERH��FYX�JSVRS�VIEWSR�SXLIV�XLER�XS�MRGVIEWI�XLIMV�S[R�XIVVMXSV]�ERH�XS�GSRXVSP�XLIMV4EPIWXMRMER�VIWMHIRXW��-RHIIH��F]�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�[EV��EGGSVHMRK�XS�1SVVMW�XLI�©%VEF�[EV�4PER�GLERKIH�������MRXS�E�QYPXMREXMSREP�PERH�KVEF�JSGYWMRKSR�XLI�%VEF�EVIEW�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]��8LI�IZSPZMRK�%VEF�«TPERW¬�JEMPIH�XS�EWWMKRER]�SJ�XLIWI�[LEXWSIZIV�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�SV�XS�GSRWMHIV�XLIMV�TSPMXMGEPEWTMVEXMSRW�ª�

%�OI]�TEVX�SJ�XLI�%VEF�TPER�[EW�XLI�GSQTPIXI�©QEVKMREPMEXMSRª�SJ�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW���8LI�.SVHERMERW�[ERXIH�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�XLI�)K]TXMERW[ERXIH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT��2IMXLIV�[ERXIH�ER�MRHITIRHIRX�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�2SFSH]�GER�FPEQI�-WVEIP�JSV�XLI�)K]TXMER�ERH�.SVHERMER�HIGMWMSR�XSSGGYT]�XLI�PERHW�EPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�JSV�E�WXEXI�ERH�JSV�HIR]MRKXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�XLSWI�PERHW��8LIWI�EVIMRGSRXVSZIVXMFPI�LMWXSVMGEP�JEGXW�RSX�WYFNIGX�XS�VIEWSREFPI�HMWTYXI�FYX�SQMX�XIH�JVSQ�TVS�4EPIWXMRMER�TWIYHSLMWXSVMIW�SJ�XLI�TIVMSH��8LI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ4EPIWXMRI�F]�.SVHER�ERH�)K]TX�[EW�RIZIV�XLI�WYFNIGX�SJ�9�2��GSRHIQRE�XMSR�SV�IZIR�I\TVIWWMSR�SJ�GSRGIVR�JVSQ�LYQER�VMKLXW�KVSYTW��-RHIIH��MX[EW�RSX�IZIR�[MHIP]�TVSXIWXIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMERW�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 88: The Case For Israel

��

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP�GVIEXIH�XLI�%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�[EW�IWXEFPMWLIH�EW�E�WIXXPIV�GSPSRMEP�TVSNIGX�XLEX�[EWWTSRWSVIH�F]�HMJJIVIRX�GSPSRMEP�TS[IVW�JSV�HMJJIVIRX�VIEWSRW��&IGEYWI�MX[EW�RSX�TSWWMFPI�XS�IWXEFPMWL�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�[MXLSYX�I\TIPPMRKXLI�MRHMKIRSYW�TISTPI�[LS�GSRWXMXYXIH�XLI�QENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR��XLI�����[EV�TVSZMHIH�E�GSZIV�JSV�XLIMV�[MHIWTVIEH�ERH�W]WXIQEXMG�I\TYPWMSR�ª�%QM�&MWLEVE��QIQFIV�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�/RIWWIX�

7LEZMX��©%RH�MR�������HSIW�XLI�QSVEP�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERXVEKIH]�SJ�XLEX�]IEV�PMI�SRP]�[MXL�XLI�.I[W#�(SR¬X�XLI�%VEFW�WLEVI�XLIFPEQI#ª

7EMH��©8LI�[EV�SJ������[EW�E�[EV�SJ�HMWTSWWIWWMSR��;LEX�LETTIRIHXLEX�]IEV�[EW�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�WSGMIX]��XLI�VITPEGIQIRX�SJ�XLEXWSGMIX]�F]�ERSXLIV��ERH�XLI�IZMGXMSR�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�[IVI�GSRWMHIVIH�YRHI�WMVEFPI��8LSWI�[LS�[IVI�MR�XLI�[E]��-X�MW�HMJJMGYPX�JSV�QI�XS�WE]�XLEX�EPPVIWTSRWMFMPMX]�PMIW�[MXL�SRI�WMHI��&YX�XLI�PMSR¬W�WLEVI�SJ�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSVHITSTYPEXMRK�XS[RW�ERH�HIWXVS]MRK�XLIQ�HIJMRMXIP]�PMIW�[MXL�XLI�.I[MWL�>MSRMWXW��=MXLEO�6EFMR�IZMGXIH�XLI��������MRLEFMXERXW�SJ�6EQPI�ERH0]HHE��WS�MX�MW�HMJJMGYPX�JSV�QI�XS�WII�ER]SRI�IPWI�EW�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�

(MH�-WVEIP�'VIEXI�XLI%VEF�6IJYKII�4VSFPIQ#

��

Page 89: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

XLEX��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�SRP]�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�FIMRK�XLIVI�ª��)H[EVH7EMH�

©8LI�-WVEIPMW�IRKEKIH�MR�«IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK�¬�HYVMRK�XLI�����§����;EV�8LI�>MSRMWX�GPEMQ�XLEX�%VEF�PIEHIVW�XSPH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�PIEZI�MW«RSX�FIPMIZIH�F]�ER]SRI��������2S�SRI�IZIR�GPEMQW�XLMW�ER]�QSVI�¬�&IRR]1SVVMW�LEW�WLS[R�XLEX�XLI�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�«[EW�HVMZIR�SYX¬�F]�XLI-WVEIPMW�ª��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�TVSFPIQ�[EW�GVIEXIH�F]�E�[EV�MRMXMEXIH�F]�XLI�%VEFW�

8,)�4633*

8LI�EKKVIWWMZI�[EV�[EKIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�MR������ERH������F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRM�ERW�ERH�XLI�%VEF�EVQMIW�RSX�SRP]�XSSO�PERH�JVSQ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�FYX�EPWSGVIEXIH�XLI�JMVWX�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ��;LMPI�XLI�%VEF�EVQMIW�XVMIH�XS�OMPP�.I[MWLGMZMPMERW�ERH�HMH�MR�JEGX�QEWWEGVI�QER]�[LS�XVMIH�XS�IWGETI��XLI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]EPPS[IH�%VEF�GMZMPMERW�XS�JPII�XS�%VEF�GSRXVSPPIH�EVIEW��*SV�I\EQTPI��[LIRXLI�%VEF�0IKMSR¬W�7M\XL�&EXXEPMSR�GSRUYIVIH�/JEV�)XMSR��XLI]�PIJX�RS�.I[�MWL�VIJYKIIW��8LI�ZMPPEKIVW�WYVVIRHIVIH�ERH�[EPOIH��LERHW�MR�XLI�EMV��MRXS�XLIGIRXIV�SJ�XLI�GSQTSYRH��1SVVMW�VITSVXW�XLEX�XLI�%VEF�WSPHMIVW�WMQTP]�©TVS�GIIHIH�XS�QS[�XLIQ�HS[R�ª�8LI�WSPHMIVW�QEWWEGVIH�����.I[W�����SJ�XLIQ[IVI�[SQIR��8LMW�[EW�TEVX�SJ�E�KIRIVEP�%VEF�TSPMG]��©.I[W�XEOIR�TVMWSRIVHYVMRK�GSRZS]�FEXXPIW�[IVI�KIRIVEPP]�TYX�XS�HIEXL�ERH�SJXIR�QYXMPEXIH�F]XLIMV�GETXSVW�ª�-X�MW�TVIGMWIP]�FIGEYWI�XLI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]��YRPMOI�%VEF�EVQMIW�HMH�RSX�HIPMFIVEXIP]�OMPP�GMZMPMERW�XLEX�XLI�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�EVSWI��

7IZIVEP�HMWXMRGX��EPXLSYKL�SZIVPETTMRK��VIJYKII�TVSFPIQW�[IVI�GVIEXIHF]�XLI�%VEF�EXXEGO�SR�-WVEIP�MR������ERH�������8LI�JMVWX�[EW�GVIEXIHFIX[IIR�(IGIQFIV������ERH�1EVGL������HYVMRK�XLI�EXXEGOW�F]�4EPIW�XMRMERW�MR�XLI�QSRXLW�FIJSVI�XLI�MRZEWMSR�SJ�XLI�4ER�%VEF�EVQMIW��%GGSVH�MRK�XS�&IRR]�1SVVMW��XLI�LMWXSVMER�[LS�MW�UYMXI�GVMXMGEP�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH>MSRMWXW�ERH�ER�I\TIVX�SR�XLI�VIJYKII�MWWYI��©8LI�=MWLYZ�?XLI�.I[W�SJ4EPIWXMRI�[LS�[SYPH�WSSR�FIGSQI�XLI�-WVEIPMWA�[EW�SR�XLI�HIJIRWMZI�ERHYTTIV�ERH�QMHHPI�GPEWW�%VEFW EW�QER]�EW�WIZIRX]�JMZI�XLSYWERH JPIH�ª1SVVMW�HIWGVMFIH�LS[�XLI�JEQMPMIW�XLEX�LEH�XLI�QIERW�XS�QSZI�XS�'EMVS�%QQER��SV�&IMVYX�HMH�WS��I\TIGXMRK�XS�VIXYVR�EW�XLI]�LEH�HSRI�EJXIV�XLIZMSPIRGI�SJ�XLI�PEXI�����W��%QSRK�XLSWI�[LS�PIJX�[IVI�©QER]�SJ�XLI�TSPMX�MGEP�PIEHIVW�ERH�SV�XLIMV�JEQMPMIW�������MRGPYHMRK�QSWX�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�%,'ERH�SJ�XLI�,EMJE�2EXMSREP�'SQQMXXII�ª�8LIWI�RSXEFPIW��EGGSVHMRK�XS1SVVMW�©QE]�LEZI�JIEVIH�E�,YWWIMRM�VYPIH�4EPIWXMRIª�EW�QYGL�EW�XLI]�[SV�VMIH�EFSYX�.I[MWL�HSQMREXMSR�

Page 90: The Case For Israel

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

1SVVMW�TSMRXIH�SYX�XLEX�XLI�.I[MWL�%VEF�GSRJPMGX�[EW�SRP]�TEVX�SJ�E©QSVI�KIRIVEP�FVIEOHS[R�SJ�PE[�ERH�SVHIV�MR�4EPIWXMRI�EJXIV�XLI�92�4EV�XMXMSR�VIWSPYXMSR�ª�4YFPMG�WIVZMGIW�GSPPETWIH�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�[MXLHVE[EP�SJXLI�&VMXMWL�ERH�XLIMV�VITPEGIQIRX�F]�©%VEF�MVVIKYPEVW��[LS�I\XSVXIHQSRI]�JVSQ�TVSWTIVSYW�JEQMPMIW�ERH�SGGEWMSREPP]�EFYWIH�TISTPI�MR�XLIWXVIIXW�ª�

8LI�WIGSRH�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�FIKER�[LIR�XLI�,EKEREL��XLI�SJJMGMEP.I[MWL�EVQ]�SJ�WIPJ�HIJIRWI��FIKER�XS�KEMR�XLI�SJJIRWMZI�FIX[IIR�%TVMP�ERH.YRI�������3RGI�,EMJE�ERH�.EJJE�[IVI�GETXYVIH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPMW��E�HSQMRSIJJIGX�FIKER��[MXL�XLI�JPMKLX�JVSQ�GMXMIW�PIEHMRK�XS�JPMKLX�JVSQ�WYVVSYRHMRKZMPPEKIW��[LMGL�MR�XYVR�PIH�XS�JPMKLX�JVSQ�SXLIV�ZMPPEKIW�

'SRXVEV]�XS�2SEQ�'LSQWO]¬W�GLEVEGXIVMEXMSR�SJ�1SVVMW¬W�GSRGPY�WMSR 'LSQWO]�WE]W�XLEX�1SVVMW�HSIW�RSX�FIPMIZI�XLEX�ER]�%VEF�PIEHIVW©XSPH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�PIEZIª 1SVVMW�EGXYEPP]�WE]W�XLEX�

-R�WSQI�EVIEW�%VEF�GSQQERHIVW�SVHIVIH�XLI�ZMPPEKIVW�XS�IZEGYEXI�XS�GPIEV

XLI�KVSYRH�JSV�QMPMXEV]�TYVTSWIW�SV�XS�TVIZIRX�WYVVIRHIV��1SVI�XLER�LEPJ

E�HSIR�ZMPPEKIW NYWX�RSVXL�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�MR�XLI�0S[IV�+EPMPII [IVI

EFERHSRIH�HYVMRK�XLIWI�QSRXLW�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�WYGL�SVHIVW��)PWI[LIVI��MR

)EWX�.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�MR�QER]�ZMPPEKIW�EVSYRH�XLI�GSYRXV]��XLI�?%VEFA�GSQ�

QERHIVW�SVHIVIH�[SQIR��SPH�TISTPI��ERH�GLMPHVIR�XS�FI�WIRX�E[E]�XS�FI

SYX�SJ�LEVQ¬W�[E]��-RHIIH��TW]GLSPSKMGEP�TVITEVEXMSR�JSV�XLI�VIQSZEP�SJ

HITIRHIRXW�JVSQ�XLI�FEXXPIJMIPH�LEH�FIKYR�MR�����§����[LIR�XLI�%,'

ERH�XLI�%VEF�0IEKYI�LEH�TIVMSHMGEPP]�IRHSVWIH�WYGL�E�QSZI�[LIR�GSR�

XIQTPEXMRK�XLI�JYXYVI�[EV�MR�4EPIWXMRI��

1SVVMW�IWXMQEXIW�XLEX�FIX[IIR�X[S�ERH�XLVII�XLSYWERH�%VEFW�JPIH�XLIMVLSQIW�HYVMRK�XLMW�TLEWI�SJ�XLI�%VEF�MRMXMEXIH�JMKLXMRK�

%KEMR�GSRXVEV]�XS�'LSQWO]¬W�GLEVEGXIVMEXMSR�SJ�1SVVMW¬W�ZMI[W�1SVVMW�RSXIW�XLEX�HYVMRK�XLI�JMVWX�TLEWI�©XLIVI�[EW�RS�>MSRMWX�TSPMG]�XSI\TIP�XLI�%VEFW�SV�MRXMQMHEXI�XLIQ�MRXS�JPMKLX�ª�EPXLSYKL�WSQI�.I[W�[IVIGIVXEMRP]�LETT]�XS�WII�XLIQ�PIEZI��(YVMRK�XLI�WIGSRH�WXEKI�EW�[IPP��©XLIVI[EW�RS�FPEROIX�TSPMG]�SJ�I\TYPWMSR�ª�FYX�XLI�QMPMXEV]�EGXMSRW�SJ�XLI,EKEREL�GIVXEMRP]�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�XLI�JPMKLX��7YGL�JPMKLX�JVSQ�XLI�WGIRIW�SJFEXXPI�SGGYVW�MR�QSWX�[EVW��MJ�XLI�[MRRMRK�WMHI�EPPS[W�MX��VEXLIV�XLER�WIIO�MRK�XS�OMPP�XLSWI�VYRRMRK�E[E]��EW�XLI�%VEFW�HMH��8LIVI�MW�PMXXPI�HSYFX�XLEXMJ�XLI�%VEF�EVQMIW�LEH�GETXYVIH�.I[MWL�GMXMIW��XLI]�[SYPH�RSX�LEZI�EPPS[IHXLI�GMZMPMER�VIJYKIIW�XS�JPII�XS�SXLIV�.I[MWL�GMXMIW��8LI]�[SYPH�LEZI�QEW�WEGVIH�XLIQ�MR�SVHIV�XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�E�.I[MWL�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQMR�XLI�%VEF�WXEXI�XLI]�LSTIH�[SYPH�VIWYPX�JVSQ�ER�%VEF�ZMGXSV]�

8LI�KVERH�QYJXM�HIGPEVIH�©E�LSP]�[EVª�ERH�SVHIVIH�LMW�©1YWPMQFVSXLIVWª�XS�©QYVHIV�XLI�.I[W��1YVHIV�XLIQ�EPP�ª��8LIVI�[IVI�XS�FI�RSWYVZMZSVW�SV�VIJYKIIW��8LI�TSWMXMSR�SJ�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�LEH�EP[E]W�FIIR

Page 91: The Case For Israel

XLEX�ER�%VEF�4EPIWXMRI�GSYPH�RSX�EFWSVF�IZIR���������.I[W���&]������XLI�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR�I\GIIHIH����������)\XIVQMREXMSR��RSX�XLI�GVIEXMSRSJ�E�HMJJMGYPX�VIJYKII�TSTYPEXMSR��[EW�XLI�KSEP�SJ�XLI�%VEF�EXXEGO�SR�.I[�MWL�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSRW��%W�XLI�%VEF�0IEKYI¬W�WIGVIXEV]�KIRIVEP��%FH�EP�%LPQER�% EL�4EWLE��GERHMHP]�TYX�MX��©8LMW�[MPP�FI�E�[EV�SJ�I\XIVQMREXMSRERH�QSQIRXSYW�QEWWEGVI��[LMGL�[MPP�FI�WTSOIR�SJ�PMOI�XLI�1SRKSPMERQEWWEGVIW�ERH�XLI�'VYWEHIW�ª�8LI�KVERH�QYJXM¬W�WTSOIWQER��%LQEH7LYOIMV]��GEPPIH�JSV�©XLI�IPMQMREXMSR�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXIª�[MXL�VIKEVH�XSXLI�KSEP�SJ�XLI�%VEF�EXXEGO��8LIVI�[EW�RS�XEPO�SJ��SV�TPERRMRK�JSV��E�PEVKI.I[MWL�VIJYKII�TSTYPEXMSR�MR�XLI�IZIRX�SJ�ER�%VEF�ZMGXSV]��©-X�HSIW�RSXQEXXIV�LS[�QER]�?.I[WA�XLIVI�EVI��;I�[MPP�W[IIT�XLIQ�MRXS�XLI�WIE�ª�XLI%VEF�0IEKYI¬W�WIGVIXEV]�KIRIVEP�ERRSYRGIH���8LI�.I[W�JYPP]�YRHIVWXSSHXLEX�XLI]�©JEGIH�WPEYKLXIV�WLSYPH�XLI]�FI�HIJIEXIH�ª��

-WVEIP��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��[EW�TVITEVIH�XS�I\XIRH�JYPP�GMXMIRWLMT�XS[LEXIZIV�RYQFIV�SJ�%VEFW�VIQEMRIH�MR�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��%PXLSYKL�QER].I[W�WYVIP]�TVIJIVVIH�E�WQEPPIV��VEXLIV�XLER�E�PEVKIV��%VEF�QMRSVMX]��XLISJJMGMEP�.I[MWL�SVKERMEXMSRW�XSSO�RS�WXITW�XS�EWWYVI�E�VIHYGXMSR�MR�XLI%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�MR�KIRIVEP��EPXLSYKL�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]�GSQQERHIVW�HMHSVHIV�XLI�IZEGYEXMSR�SJ�WIZIVEP�LSWXMPI�XS[RW�XLEX�LEH�WIVZIH�EW�FEWIW�JSV%VEF�MVVIKYPEV�YRMXW��[LMGL�[IVI�TVIZIRXMRK�EGGIWW�XS�XLI�QEMR�VSEH�XS.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�[LMGL�©TVSZIH�E�TIVQERIRX�XLVIEX�FSXL�XS�EPP�RSVXL�WSYXLERH�XS�IEWX�[IWX��8IP�%ZMZ§.IVYWEPIQ �GSQQYRMGEXMSRW�ª��

%PXLSYKL�MX�[EW�RSX�XLI�TSPMG]�SJ�XLI�,EKEREL�XS�IRGSYVEKI�XLI�JPMKLXSJ�PSGEP�%VEFW��XLEX�GIVXEMRP]�WIIQW�XS�LEZI�FIIR�XLI�TSPMG]�SJ�XLI�-VKYR�SV�)XIP ��XLI�TEVEQMPMXEV]�[MRK�SJ�XLI�VIZMWMSRMWX�QSZIQIRX�LIEHIH�F]1IREGLIQ�&IKMR��ERH�0IGLM��SV�XLI�7XIVR�KERK �LIEHIH�F]�=MXLEO7LEQMV��3R�%TVMP����������TEVEQMPMXEV]�YRMXW�JSYKLX�E�HMJJMGYPX�FEXXPI�JSVGSRXVSP�SJ�(IMV�=EWWMR��ER�MQTSVXERX�%VEF�ZMPPEKI�SR�XLI�[E]�XS�.IVYWEPIQ�8LI�FEXXPI�[EW�JMIVGI��[MXL�)XIP�ERH�0IGLM�JSVGIW�PSWMRK�QSVI�XLER�E�UYEV�XIV�SJ�XLIMV�JMKLXIVW��8LI�.I[MWL�JMKLXIVW�[IVI�TMRRIH�HS[R�F]�WRMTIV�JMVIERH�XLVI[�KVIREHIW�XLVSYKL�XLI�[MRHS[W�SJ�QER]�SJ�XLI�LSYWIW�JVSQ[LMGL�XLI�WRMTIVW�[IVI�JMVMRK��1SWX�SJ�XLI�ZMPPEKIVW�IZIRXYEPP]�JPIH��%R)XIP�EVQSVIH�GEV�[MXL�E�PSYHWTIEOIV�HIQERHIH�XLEX�XLI�VIQEMRMRK�ZMP�PEKIVW�PE]�HS[R�XLIMV�EVQW�ERH�PIEZI�XLIMV�LSYWIW��1SVVMW�VITSVXW�XLEX�©XLIXVYGO�KSX�WXYGO�MR�E�HMXGLª��ERH�XLI�QIWWEKI�[EW�RSX�LIEVH��8LI�JMKLXMRKGSRXMRYIH��ERH�[LIR�MX�[EW�SZIV������XS�����%VEFW�[IVI�HIEH���

1ER]�SJ�XLI�HIEH�[IVI�[SQIR��FIGEYWI�%VEF�JMKLXIVW�HVIWWIH�EW[SQIR�ERH�WLSX�-WVEIPMW�XS�[LSQ�XLI]�LEH�©WYVVIRHIVIHª��¨E�XEGXMGIQTPS]IH�F]�WSQI�-VEUMW�MR�������7SQI�GLMPHVIR�ERH�SPH�TISTPI�[IVI�EPWSOMPPIH��%PXLSYKL�XLIVI�[EW�ERH�GSRXMRYIW�XS�FI�GSRWMHIVEFPI�HMWTYXI�WYV�VSYRHMRK�XLI�GMVGYQWXERGIW�SJ�XLIWI�HIEXLW��XLI�IZIRX�[EW�GEPPIH�E�QEW�WEGVI��ERH�EW�[SVH�WTVIEH��MX�GPIEVP]�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�XLI�JPMKLX�SJ�%VEFW�MRWYVVSYRHMRK�ZMPPEKIW��©)ZIV]SRI�LEH�ER�MRXIVIWXª�MR�TYFPMGMMRK�ERH

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 92: The Case For Israel

I\EKKIVEXMRK�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�TISTPI�OMPPIH�ERH�XLI�FVYXEPMX]�SJ�XLI�OMPPMRKW�8LI�%VEF�WMHI�[ERXIH�XS�HMWGVIHMX�XLI�.I[W�F]�EVKYMRK UYMXI�L]TSGVMXM�GEPP]��MR�PMKLX�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�TSPMG]�SZIV�XLI�HIGEHIW�SJ�HIPMFIVEXIP]�QEW�WEGVMRK�GMZMPMERW XLEX�XLI�.I[W�[IVI�[SVWI�XLER�XLI]�[IVI��8LI�&VMXMWLEPWS�[ERXIH�XS�HMWGVIHMX�XLI�.I[W��)XIP�ERH�0IGLM�[ERXIH�XS�©TVSZSOI�XIV�VSV�ERH�JVMKLXIR�%VEFW�MRXS�JPIIMRK�ª�%RH�XLI�,EKEREL�[ERXIH�©XS�XEV�RMWLª�)XIP�ERH�0IGLM���

8LI�,EKEREL�ERH�XLI�.I[MWL�%KIRG] XLI�SJJMGMEP�SVKERW�SJ�XLI�WXEXI�XS�FI MQQIHMEXIP]�GSRHIQRIH�XLI�QEWWEGVI�ERH�XLSWI�[LS�LEH�TEVXMGM�TEXIH�MR�MX��%�JSVQEP�RSXI�SJ�ETSPSK]�ERH�I\TPEREXMSR�[EW�WIRX�XS�/MRK%FHYPPEL��-RHIIH��XLI�(IMV�=EWWMR�QEWWEGVI�GIVXEMRP]�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�XLIGSRXVSZIVWMEP�HIGMWMSR�F]�(EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR -WVEIP¬W�JMVWX�TVMQI�QMRMW�XIV XS�HMWEVQ��F]�JSVGI��XLIWI�TEVEQMPMXEV]�KVSYTW�MR�.YRI�������&YX�XLIIJJIGX�SJ�(IMV�=EWWMR��ERH�XLI�TYFPMGMX]�WYVVSYRHMRK�MX��[EW�GPIEVP]�XS�TVS�ZSOI�IZIR�QSVI�JPMKLX�F]�%VEFW�

7SQI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�EGXYEPP]�GMVGYPEXIH�JEPWI�VYQSVW�XLEX�[SQIRLEH�FIIR�VETIH��;LIR�GSRJVSRXIH�[MXL�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�RS�VETIW�LEH�XEOIRTPEGI��,YWWIMR�/LEPMHM��E�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIV��WEMH��©;I�LEZI�XS�WE]�XLMW��WSXLEX�%VEF�EVQMIW�[MPP�GSQI�XS�PMFIVEXI�YW�JVSQ�XLI�.I[W�ª��,EEQ�2YW�WIMFM��[LS�[EW�E�NSYVREPMWX�EX�XLI�XMQI��XSPH�XLI�&&'�]IEVW�PEXIV�XLEX�XLIHIPMFIVEXI�JEFVMGEXMSR�SJ�XLI�VETI�GLEVKI�©[EW�SYV�FMKKIWX�QMWXEOI�������EWWSSR�EW�XLI]�LIEVH�XLEX�[SQIR�LEH�FIIR�VETIH�EX�(IMV�=EWWMR��4EPIWXMRMERWJPIH�MR�XIVVSV�ª��

(IMV�=EWWMR�WXERHW�SYX�MR�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�%VEF§.I[MWL�GSRJPMGX�MR�4EPIWXMRITVIGMWIP]�FIGEYWI�MX�[EW�WS�YRYWYEP�ERH�WS�SYX�SJ�GLEVEGXIV�JSV�XLI�.I[W��2SWMRKPI�%VEF�QEWWEGVI�SJ�.I[W�LEW�XLEX�WXEXYW��FIGEYWI�XLIVI�EVI�XSS�QER]�XSPMWX��=IX�IZIV]�%VEF�WGLSSPGLMPH�ERH�TVSTEKERHMWX�ORS[W�SJ�ERH�WTIEOW�SJ(IMV�=EWWMR��[LMPI�JI[�IZIV�QIRXMSR�,IFVSR��/JEV�)XMSR��,EHEWWEL�,SW�TMXEP��7EJEH��ERH�XLI�QER]�SXLIV�[IPP�TPERRIH�%VEF�QEWWEGVIW�SJ�.I[W�XSGSQI��I\GITX�[LIR�I\XVIQMWXW�TVSYHP]�XEOI�GVIHMX�JSV�XLIQ�

8LI�%VEFW�VIXEPMEXIH�JSV�XLI�(IMV�=EWWMR�QEWWEGVI�RSX�F]�EXXEGOMRK�XLSWIVIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�TIVTIXVEXMRK�MX )XIP�SV�0IGLM�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW FYXVEXLIV�F]�HIPMFIVEXIP]�GSQQMXXMRK�E�JEV�QSVI�TVIQIHMXEXIH�QEWWEGVI�SJXLIMV�S[R��-R�E�[IPP�TPERRIH�EXXEGO�JSYV�HE]W�EJXIV�(IMV�=EWWMR��%VEF�JSVGIWEQFYWLIH�E�GMZMPMER�GSRZS]�SJ�HSGXSVW��RYVWIW��QIHMGEP�WGLSSP�TVSJIWWSVW�ERH�TEXMIRXW�LIEHIH�XS[EVH�XLI�,EHEWWEL�LSWTMXEP�XS�XVIEX�XLI�WMGO��QYV�HIVMRK�WIZIRX]�SJ�XLIQ��8S�EWWYVI�XLIVI�[IVI�RS�WYVZMZSVW��XLI�%VEFEXXEGOIVW�HSYWIH�XLI�FYWIW�ERH�GEVW�GSRXEMRMRK�XLI�QIHMGEP�TIVWSRRIP�[MXLKEWSPMRI��©WIXXMRK�XLIQ�EPMKLX�ª��

2S�ETSPSKMIW�SV�I\GYWIW�[IVI�SJJIVIH�JSV�XLMW�GEVIJYPP]�TPERRIH�QEW�WEGVI�SJ�QIHMGEP�RSRGSQFEXERXW��-WVEIPM�JSVGIW�HMH�RSX�VIXEPMEXI�JSV�XLI,EHEWWEL�QEWWEGVI�F]�XEVKIXMRK�%VEF�GMZMPMERW�8LI]�[IRX�EJXIV�XLSWIEVQIH�QYVHIVIVW�[LS�LEH�TIVTIXVEXIH�XLI�QEWWEGVI��(IMV�=EWWMR�VIQEMRIH

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 93: The Case For Israel

ER�MWSPEXIH�EPXLSYKL�XVEKMG�ERH�MRI\GYWEFPI�FPIQMWL�SR�-WVEIPM�TEVEQMPMXEV]EGXMSRW�MR�HIJIRWI�SJ�MXW�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR���[LMPI�XLI�HIPMFIVEXI�XEVKIXMRKSJ�GMZMPMERW�VIQEMRIH ERH�WXMPP�VIQEMRW XLI�TSPMG]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXKVSYTW��EW�[IPP�EW�SJ�QER]�%VEF�KSZIVRQIRXW�

%RSXLIV�TLEWI�SJ�XLI�%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�XSSO�TPEGI�[LIR�XLI,EKEREL�[SR�XLI�FEXXPI�JSV�,EMJE�EX�XLI�IRH�SJ�%TVMP�������%GGSVHMRK�XS1SVVMW��©8LI�%VEF�PIEHIVW��TVIJIVVMRK�RSX�XS�WYVVIRHIV��ERRSYRGIH�XLEXXLI]�ERH�XLIMV�GSQQYRMX]�MRXIRHIH�XS�IZEGYEXI�XLI�XS[R��HIWTMXI�E�TPIEF]�XLI�.I[MWL�QE]SV�XLEX�XLI]�WXE]�ª��7MQMPEVP]��MR�.EJJE��XLI�JMIVGI�JMKLXMRK[MXL�QER]�.I[MWL�GEWYEPXMIW�GEYWIH�E�TERMG�EQSRK�XLI�XS[R¬W�%VEF�TSTY�PEXMSR�ERH�QER]�JPIH��1SVVMW�[VMXIW�XLEX�©XLI�FILEZMSV�SJ�.EJJE¬W�%VEF�QMP�MXEV]�EPWS�GSRXVMFYXIH��XLI]�PSSXIH�XLI�IQTX]�LSYWIW�ERH�SGGEWMSREPP]VSFFIH�ERH�EFYWIH�XLI�VIQEMRMRK�MRLEFMXERXW�ª�;LIR�LI�ZMWMXIH�.EJJE�EJXIVXLI�JMKLXMRK�LEH�HMIH�HS[R��(EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR�[VSXI�MR�LMW�HMEV]��©-GSYPHR¬X�YRHIVWXERH��;L]�HMH�XLI�MRLEFMXERXW�������PIEZI#ª��

3J�GSYVWI��.EJJE�VIQEMRIH�ER�%VEF�GMX]��ERH�XSHE]�MXW�TSTYPEXMSRMRGPYHIW�XLSYWERHW�SJ�%VEFW��,EMJE�VIQEMRIH�E�QM\IH�GMX]��[LSWI�GYVVIRXTSTYPEXMSR�EPWS�MRGPYHIW�XLSYWERHW�SJ�%VEFW��7SQI�SXLIV�XS[RW�ERH�ZMPPEKIW�JVSQ�[LMGL�%VEFW�JPIH�VIQEMR�QM\IH�XSHE]��[LMPI�WSQI�LEZI�RSXWIIR�E�VIXYVR�SJ�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSRW��1SVVMW��[LS�MW�LEVWLP]�GVMXMGEP�SJ�XVEHM�XMSREP�-WVEIPM�LMWXSV]�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XLI�VIJYKII�MWWYI��WYQQEVMIW�XLITVSFPIQ�GEYWIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH�4ER�%VEF�EXXEGO��©8LI�4EPIWXMRMER6IJYKII�TVSFPIQ�[EW�FSVR�SJ�[EV��RSX�F]�HIWMKR��������8LI�%VEF�PIEHIVWLMTMRWMHI�ERH�SYXWMHI�4EPIWXMRI�TVSFEFP]�LIPTIH�TVIGMTMXEXI�XLI�I\SHYW�������2S�KYMHMRK�LERH�SV�GIRXVEP�GSRXVSP�MW�IZMHIRX�ª��1SVVMW�WXEXIW�XLEX©?HAYVMRK�XLI�JMVWX�QSRXLW��XLI�JPMKLX�SJ�XLI�QMHHPI�ERH�YTTIV�GPEWWIW�JVSQXLI�XS[RW�TVSZSOIH�PMXXPI�%VEF�MRXIVIWX�ª��

-X�PSSOIH�PMOI�E�VITIEX�SJ�XLI�I\SHYW�XLEX�LEH�XEOIR�TPEGI�HYVMRK�XLIVMSXW�SJ�XLI�PEXI�����W��ERH�XLI�,YWWIMRMW�©[IVI�TVSFEFP]�LETT]�XLEX�QER]SJ�XLIWI�[IEPXL]��3TTSWMXMSR�PMROIH�JEQMPMIW�[IVI�PIEZMRK�ª�� 1SVVMWTSMRXW�SYX�XLEX�©RS�%VEF�KSZIVRQIRX�GPSWIH�MXW�FSVHIVW�SV�SXLIV[MWI�XVMIHXS�WXIQ�XLI�I\SHYW�ª��*MREPP]��1SVVMW�RSXIW�XLEX�XLIWI�VIJYKIIW�[SYPH�

FI�YXMPMIH�HYVMRK�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�]IEVW�F]�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�EW�E�TS[IVJYP

TSPMXMGEP�ERH�TVSTEKERHE�TE[R�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP��8LI�QIQSV]�SV�ZMGEVMSYW

QIQSV]�SJ������ERH�XLI�WYFWIUYIRX�HIGEHIW�SJ�LYQMPMEXMSR�ERH�HITVM�

ZEXMSR�MR�XLI�VIJYKII�GEQTW�[SYPH�YPXMQEXIP]�XYVR�KIRIVEXMSRW�SJ�4EPIW�

XMRMERW�MRXS�TSXIRXMEP�SV�EGXMZI�XIVVSVMWXW�ERH�XLI�©4EPIWXMRMER�TVSFPIQª

MRXS�SRI�SJ�XLI�[SVPH¬W�QSWX�MRXVEGXEFPI���

-R�LMW�TYFPMG�WTIIGLIW��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�QMWGLEVEGXIVMIW�1SVVMW¬WGSRGPYWMSRW�F]�XIPPMRK�LMW�EYHMIRGIW�XLEX�1SVVMW�HSIW�RSX�GPEMQ MRHIIH�'LSQWO]�WE]W�XLEX�RS�SRI�XSHE]�GPEMQW XLEX�%VEF�PIEHIVW�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 94: The Case For Israel

XLI�JPMKLX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW��,I�WE]W��JEPWIP] �XLEX�1SVVMW�TPEGIW�XLI�IRXMVIFPEQI�SR�-WVEIP��XLEX�XLIVI�[IVI�©RIZIV�ER]�WYGL�GEPPWª�F]�%VEF�PIEHIVW�ERH�XLEX�XLMW�WXSV]�[EW�©>MSRMWX�TVSTEKERHEª�XLEX�[EW�©EFERHSRIHEPQSWX����]IEVW�EKSª�ERH�MW�©RSX�FIPMIZIH�F]�ER]SRI�ª��8LI�XVYXL��SJGSYVWI��MW�XLEX�1SVVMW�HSIW�MRHIIH�GSRGPYHI�XLEX�WSQI�©%VEF�GSQQERHIVWSVHIVIH�XLI�ZMPPEKIVW�XS�IZEGYEXIª�ERH�XLEX�XLI�%VEF�0IEKYI�LEH�©TIVMSH�MGEPP]�IRHSVWIH�WYGL�E�QSZI�ª

1SVVMW��PMOI�SXLIV�LMWXSVMERW�ERH�YRPMOI�'LSQWO]��JMRHW�E�WLEVIHVIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�XLI�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�ERH�GSRGPYHIW�XLEXRIMXLIV�WMHI�HIPMFIVEXIP]�GEYWIH�MX�©F]�HIWMKR�ª�FYX�XLEX�©XLI�%VEF�PIEHIV�WLMT�MRWMHI�ERH�SYXWMHI�4EPIWXMRI�LIPTIH�TVIGMTMXEXI�XLI�I\SHYWª E�GSR�GPYWMSR�'LSQWO]�EWWYVIW�LMW�EYHMIRGI�MW�©RSX�FIPMIZIH�F]�ER]SRI�ªIWTIGMEPP]�RSX�1SVVMW��-X�MW�EP[E]W�MQTSVXERX�XS�GLIGO�XLI�WSYVGIW�GMXIH�F]'LSQWO]��IWTIGMEPP]�[LIR�LI�MW�HMWGYWWMRK�-WVEIP�

-R�LMW������QIQSMVW��XLI�JSVQIV�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�SJ�7]VME��/LEPMH�EP�%Q��TPEGIH�XLI�IRXMVI�FPEQI�JSV�XLI�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�SR�XLI�%VEFW�

7MRGI������MX�MW�[I�[LS�HIQERHIH�XLI�VIXYVR�SJ�XLI�VIJYKIIW�������[LMPI

MX�MW�[I�[LS�QEHI�XLIQ�PIEZI��������;I�FVSYKLX�HMWEWXIV�YTSR�������%VEF

VIJYKIIW��F]�MRZMXMRK�XLIQ�ERH�FVMRKMRK�TVIWWYVI�XS�FIEV�YTSR�XLIQ�XS

PIEZI��������;I�LEZI�VIRHIVIH�XLIQ�HMWTSWWIWWIH��������;I�LEZI�EGGYWXSQIH

XLIQ�XS�FIKKMRK��������;I�LEZI�TEVXMGMTEXIH�MR�PS[IVMRK�XLIMV�QSVEP�ERH

WSGMEP�PIZIP��������8LIR�[I�I\TPSMXIH�XLIQ�MR�I\IGYXMRK�GVMQIW�SJ�QYVHIV�

EVWSR��ERH�XLVS[MRK�FSQFW�YTSR�������QIR��[SQIR�ERH�GLMPHVIR EPP�XLMW

MR�XLI�WIVZMGI�SJ�TSPMXMGEP�TYVTSWIW���

)ZIR�1ELQSYH�%FFEW��%FY�1EIR ��XLI�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�SJ�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��LEW�EGGYWIH�XLI�%VEF�EVQMIW�SJ�LEZMRK�EFERHSRIH�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�EJXIV�XLI]�©JSVGIH�XLIQ�XS�IQMKVEXI�ERH�XS�PIEZI�XLIMV�LSQI�PERH�ERH�XLVI[�XLIQ�MRXS�TVMWSRW�WMQMPEV�XS�XLI�KLIXXSW�MR�[LMGL�XLI�.I[WYWIH�XS�PMZI�ª��

3XLIV�WSYVGIW�W]QTEXLIXMG�XS�XLI�%VEF�GEYWI�EKVII��-R�������XLI�%VEF2EXMSREP�'SQQMXXII�SJ�,EMJE�[VSXI�E�QIQSVERHYQ�XS�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�XLEXMRGPYHIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK��©8LI�VIQSZEP�SJ�XLI�%VEF�MRLEFMXERXW�������[EW�ZSP�YRXEV]�ERH�[EW�GEVVMIH�SYX�EX�SYV�VIUYIWX��8LI�%VEF�HIPIKEXMSR�TVSYHP]EWOIH�JSV�XLI�IZEGYEXMSR�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�XLIMV�VIQSZEP�XS�XLI�RIMKLFSVMRK%VEF�GSYRXVMIW��������;I�EVI�ZIV]�KPEH�XS�WXEXI�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW�KYEVHIH�XLIMVLSRSYV�ERH�XVEHMXMSRW�[MXL�TVMHI�ERH�KVIEXRIWW�ª��%RH�E�VIWIEVGL�VITSVXF]�XLI�%VEF�WTSRWSVIH�-RWXMXYXI�JSV�4EPIWXMRI�7XYHMIW�GSRGPYHIH�XLEX�XLIQENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�%VEF�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�RSX�I\TIPPIH�ERH����TIVGIRX�SJ�XLIQ�©PIJX�[MXLSYX�WIIMRK�ER�-WVEIPM�WSPHIV�ª��%X�XLI�ZIV]�PIEWX��XLI�MWWYI�MW�XSS�GSQTPI\�ERH�QYPXMJEGIXIH�JSV�WMQTPI�JMRKIV�TSMRXMRK�MR�SRP]�SRIHMVIGXMSR�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 95: The Case For Israel

8LIVI�MW�WSQI�HMWTYXI�EFSYX�XLI�XSXEP�RYQFIV�SJ�%VEFW�[LS�PIJX�XLIMVGMXMIW��XS[RW��ERH�ZMPPEKIW�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH�%VEF�EXXEGOW�SRXLI�.I[W��8LIVI�MW�IZIR�KVIEXIV�HMWEKVIIQIRX�EFSYX�XLI�TVSTSVXMSR�SJXLSWI�[LS�PIJX�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�EGGSVH��[IVI�GLEWIH��SV�[IVI�XSPH�F]�%VEFPIEHIVW�XS�PIEZI��8LIVI�MW�EPWS�GSRWMHIVEFPI�HMWEKVIIQIRX�SZIV�LS[�PSRKQER]�SJ�XLIWI�VIJYKIIW�LEH�EGXYEPP]�PMZIH�MR�XLI�EVIEW�XLI]�PIJX��%RH�XLIVIMW�PMXXPI�EKVIIQIRX�EFSYX�LS[�QER]�%VEFW�[LS�GYVVIRXP]�GEPP�XLIQWIPZIWVIJYKIIW�SJ�XLI�����§�����[EV�EGXYEPP]�FIPSRK�MR�XLEX�GEXIKSV]�

1SWX�WGLSPEVW�LEZI�TYX�XLI�XSXEP�RYQFIV�SJ�%VEF�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�XLI4EPIWXMRMER§%VEF�EXXEGOW�SJ�����§�����EX�FIX[IIR���������ERH���������8LI�9�2��QIHMEXSV�SR�4EPIWXMRI�GSYRXIH�SRP]����������SJ�[LMGL��������VIUYMVIH�EMH���8LI�SJJMGMEP�-WVEIPM�GSYRX�[EW����������1SVVMW�TYXW�MX�EX���������4EPIWXMRMERW�TYX�MX�EW�LMKL�EW����������;LEXIZIV�XLI�VIEP�JMKYVI[EW��MX�MW�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�WYFHMZMHI�XLEX�XSXEP�JMKYVI�MRXS�ZSPYRXEV]��JSVGIH��SVWSQI�GSQFMREXMSR�SJ�JEGXSVW��%W�1SVVMW�GSRGPYHIW��©8LI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�XLITVSFPIQ�[EW�EPQSWX�MRIZMXEFPI��KMZIR�XLI�KISKVETLMGEP�MRXIVQM\MRK�SJ�XLITSTYPEXMSRW��XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�%VEF§.I[MWL�LSWXMPMX]�WMRGI�������XLI�VINIGXMSRF]�FSXL�WMHIW�SJ�E�FMREXMSREP�?EW�HMWXMRKYMWLIH�JVSQ�E�X[S�WXEXIA�WSPYXMSR�ERH�XLI�HITXL�SJ�%VEF�ERMQSWMX]�XS[EVH�XLI�.I[W�ERH�JIEVW�SJ�GSQMRKYRHIV�.I[MWL�VYPI�ª��4YX�ERSXLIV�[E]��XLI�PEWX�XLMRK�QER]�%VEFW�[ERXIH[EW�XS�VIQEMR�EW�QMRSVMX]�GMXMIRW�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�MR�XLI�ZMP�PEKIW�ERH�LSQIW�XLI]�LEH�PIJX�

8LI�GPEMQIH�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�LEW�RIZIV�GSRXIQTPEXIH�XLIMV�VIXYVR�EW�EQMRSVMX]KVSYT��FEWIH�SR�ER]�TIVWSREP�HIWMVI�XS�PMZI�MR�E�TEVXMGYPEV�ZMPPEKISV�LSYWI�MR�.I[MWL�-WVEIP��8LI�VMKLX�XS�VIXYVR�LEW�EP[E]W�GSRXIQTPEXIHVIXYVRMRK�EW�E�QENSVMX]KVSYT�WS�EW�XS�IPMQMREXI�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�ERH�PMZI�MRE�1YWPMQ�WXEXI��3R�%YKYWX����������)QMPI�+LSYV]��XLI�WIGVIXEV]�SJ�XLI%VEF�,MKLIV�'SQQERH��XSPH�XLI�&IMVYX�8IPIKVETLXLEX�©MX�MW�MRGSRGIMZEFPIXLEX�XLI�VIJYKIIW�WLSYPH�FI�WIRX�FEGO�XS�XLIMV�LSQIW�[LMPI�XLI]�EVI�SGGY�TMIH�F]�XLI�.I[W�������MX�[SYPH�WIVZI�EW�E�JMVWX�WXIT�XS[EVH�XLIMV�VIGSKRMXMSRSJ�-WVEIP�ª��7LSVXP]�XLIVIEJXIV��XLI�JSVIMKR�QMRMWXIV�SJ�)K]TX�EGORS[P�IHKIH�XLEX�©MX�MW�[IPP�ORS[R�ERH�YRHIVWXSSH�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW��MR�HIQERH�MRK�XLI�VIXYVR�SJ�XLI�VIJYKIIW�XS�4EPIWXMRI��QIER�XLIMV�VIXYVR�EW�QEWXIVW�SJXLIMV�LSQIPERH��ERH�RSX�EW�WPEZIW��1SVI�I\TPMGMXP]��XLI]�MRXIRH�XS�ERRMLM�PEXI�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�ª��-R�SXLIV�[SVHW��XLI�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�RSX�TVMQEVMP]E�LYQERMXEVMER�GSRGIVR�FYX�VEXLIV�E�TSPMXMGEP�XEGXMG�HIWMKRIH�XS�TVSHYGIXLI�MRXIRHIH�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP��7YVIP]�RS�SRI�[SYPH�I\TIGX�-WVEIP�XSJEGMPMXEXI�MXW�S[R�TSPMXMGMHI�

%W�XS�LS[�PSRK�XLIWI�VIJYKIIW�LEH�EGXYEPP]�PMZIH�MR�XLI�ZMPPEKIW�ERHXS[RW�XLI]�PIJX��IZIR�1SVVMW�HSGYQIRXW�XLEX�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�©IGSRSQMG�ERHWSGMEP�TVSGIWWIW�XLEX�LEH�FIKYR�MR�XLI�QMH�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYV]�?[IPP�FIJSVIXLI�*MVWX�%PM]ELA�PEVKI�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�VYVEP�TSTYPEXMSR�?LEHA�FIIR�PIJX�PERH�PIWWª�TVMSV�XS�XLI�IZIRXW�SJ�����§�������

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 96: The Case For Israel

-R�GSRWIUYIRGI�XLIVI�[EW�E�GSRWXERX��KVS[MRK�WLMJX�SJ�TSTYPEXMSR�JVSQ

XLI�GSYRXV]WMHI�XS�YVFER�WLERX]XS[RW�ERH�WPYQW��XS�WSQI�HIKVII�XLMW�PIH

XS�FSXL�TL]WMGEP�ERH�TW]GLSPSKMGEP�HMZSVGI�JVSQ�XLI�PERH��?8LI]�EPWSA�PSWX

XLIMV�QIERW�SJ�PMZIPMLSSH��*SV�WSQI��I\MPI�QE]�LEZI�FIGSQI�ER�EXXVEGXMZI

STXMSR��EX�PIEWX�YRXMP�4EPIWXMRI�GEPQIH�HS[R���

8LI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��VIGSKRMMRK�XLEX�QER]�SJ�XLI�VIJYKIIW�LEH�RSXPMZIH�JSV�PSRK�MR�XLI�ZMPPEKIW�XLI]�PIJX��QEHI�E�VIQEVOEFPI�HIGMWMSR�XSGLERKI�XLI�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�VIJYKII SRP]JSV�TYVTSWIW�SJ�HIJMRMRK�[LS�MW�ER%VEFVIJYKIIJVSQ�-WVEIP XS�MRGPYHI�ER]�%VEF�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�MR�-WVEIP�JSVX[S�]IEVWFIJSVI�PIEZMRK���1SVISZIV��ER�%VEF�[EW�GSYRXIH�EW�E�VIJYKII�MJLI�QSZIH�NYWX�E�JI[�QMPIW�JVSQ�SRI�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XS�ERSXLIV IZIR�MJLIVIXYVRIHXS�XLI�ZMPPEKI�MR�[LMGL�LI�LEH�TVIZMSYWP]�PMZIH�ERH�MR�[LMGLLMW�JEQMP]�WXMPP�PMZIH��JVSQ�E�ZMPPEKI�XS�[LMGL�LI�LEH�QSZIH�SRP]�X[S�]IEVWIEVPMIV��-RHIIH�E�WMKRMJMGERX�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKIIW�WMQTP]�QSZIHJVSQ�SRI�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XS�ERSXLIV��7SQI�TVIJIVVIH�XS�PMZI�MR�ER�EVIEGSRXVSPPIH�F]�%VEFW�VEXLIV�XLER�.I[W��NYWX�EW�XLI�.I[W�[LS�LEH�PMZIH�MRGMXMIW�XLEX�GEQI�YRHIV�%VEF�GSRXVSP�GLSWI�XS�QSZI�XS�XLI�-WVEIPM�WMHI�SJ�XLITEVXMXMSR��8LI�.I[W�[LS�QSZIH�E�JI[�QMPIW��IZIR�XLSWI�[LS�LEH�RSGLSMGI �[IVI�RSX�GEPPIH�VIJYKIIW��FYX�XLI�%VEFW�[LS�QSZIH�XLI�WEQI�HMW�XERGI�[IVI��-X�[EW�XLI�QSWX�YRYWYEP�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�VIJYKII�MR�LMWXSV]�

9RPMOI�EPP�SXLIV�VIJYKIIW�[SVPH[MHI��4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKIIW�EVI�XVIEXIH�XSE�WITEVEXI�9�2��EKIRG]��[MXL�E�WITEVEXI�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�VIJYKII�ERH�E�WITEVEXIQMWWMSR��-J�XLI�WXERHEVH�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�VIJYKII��[LMGL�ETTPMIW�XS�EPP�SXLIVVIJYKII�KVSYTW �[IVI�XS�ETTP]�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIW�XMRMER�VIJYKIIW�[SYPH�JEPP�TVIGMTMXSYWP]�

8LI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�,MKL�'SQQMWWMSRIV�JSV�6IJYKIIW��92,'6 ��XLIKIRIVEP�VIJYKII�EKIRG]�XLEX�WIVZIW�VIJYKII�KVSYTW�SXLIV�XLER�XLI�4EPIWXMRM�ERW��MRGPYHIW�MR�MXW�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�VIJYKII�WSQISRI�[LS��� �PIEZIW�SYX�SJ�E©[IPP�JSYRHIH�JIEV�SJ�FIMRK�TIVWIGYXIH�ª��� �MW�©SYXWMHI�XLI�GSYRXV]�SJ�?LMWAREXMSREPMX]�ª�ERH��� �©MW�YREFPI�XS��SV�������YR[MPPMRK�XS�EZEMP�LMQWIPJ�SJ�XLITVSXIGXMSR�SJ�XLEX�GSYRXV]�ª�&YX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�6IPMIJ�ERH�;SVOW%KIRG]��926;% ��XLI�WITEVEXI�EKIRG]�WTIGMJMGEPP]�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKIIW�ETTPMIW�E�JEV�FVSEHIV�WIX�SJ�KYMHIPMRIW��-X�HIJMRIW�4EPIWXMRMERW�EW�VIJYKIIWVIKEVHPIWW�SJ�[LIXLIV�XLI]�PIJX�SYX�SJ�E�©[IPP�JSYRHIH�JIEV�SJ�TIVWIGYXMSRªERH�VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]�[LIVI�XLI]�PMZI��7TIGMJMGEPP]��926;%�HIJMRIWE�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKII�EW�ER]SRI��� �©[LSWI�RSVQEP�TPEGI�SJ�VIWMHIRGI�[EW4EPIWXMRI�FIX[IIR�.YRI������ERH�1E]������ª�ERH��� �©[LS�PSWX�FSXL�XLIMVLSQIW�ERH�QIERW�SJ�PMZIPMLSSH�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�XLI������%VEF§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGXª�VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�XLI�VIEWSR�JSV�PIEZMRK ��4PYW��926;%�HIJMRIW�EW�VIJYKIIW�EPPSJ�XLI�HIWGIRHERXW�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�QIIX�XLIWI�X[S�GVMXIVME���

-R�EHHMXMSR��92,'6�ERH�926;%�LEZI�ZIV]�HMJJIVIRX�QMWWMSRW��8LI92,'6�MW�GLEVKIH�[MXL�JMRHMRK�TIVQERIRX�LSQIW�JSV�VIJYKIIW��926;%

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 97: The Case For Israel

QERHEXI�MW�RSX�GSRGIVRIH�[MXL�TIVQERIRX�WSPYXMSRW�ERH�MW�HIWMKRIH�SRP]XS�QEMRXEMR�ERH�WYTTSVX�4EPIWXMRMERW�[MXLMR�VIJYKII�GEQTW��[LIVI�QER]�SJXLIQ�VIQEMR�XSHE]��;MXL�MXW�FVSEH�VIJYKII�HIJMRMXMSR�ERH�E�QMWWMSR�KIEVIHXS[EVH�HITIRHIRG]��926;%¬W�VIJYKII�GSYRX�LEW�VMWIR�JVSQ�YRHIV�E�QMP�PMSR�MR������XS�SZIV���QMPPMSR��ERH�GSYRXMRK �XSHE]���

8LMW�ETTVSEGL�XS�XLI�VIJYKII�MWWYI�[EW�GEPGYPEXIH�XS�OIIT�MX�JVSQ�FIMRKVIWSPZIH�ERH�XS�EPPS[�MX�XS�JIWXIV�ERH�IZIR�FI�I\EGIVFEXIH��8LI�%VEFVIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�GSYPH�IEWMP]�LEZI�FIIR�WSPZIH�FIX[IIR������ERH�����[LIR�.SVHER�GSRXVSPPIH�ERH�ERRI\IH�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��[LMGL�[EW�ER�YRHIV�TSTYPEXIH�ERH�YRHIVGYPXMZEXIH�EVIE��&YX�MRWXIEH�SJ�MRXIKVEXMRK�XLI�VIJYKIIWMRXS�XLI�VIPMKMSYWP]��PMRKYMWXMGEPP]��ERH�GYPXYVEPP]�MHIRXMGEP�WSGMIX]��XLI]�[IVIWIKVIKEXIH�MRXS�KLIXXSW�GEPPIH�VIJYKII�GEQTW�ERH�QEHI�XS�PMZI�SR�XLI�9�2�HSPI��[LMPI�FIMRK�JIH�TVSTEKERHE�EFSYX�XLIMV�KPSVMSYW�VIXYVR�XS�XLI�ZMPPEKIHS[R�XLI�VSEH�XLEX�LEH�FIIR�XLIMV�LSQI�JSV�EW�PMXXPI�EW�X[S�]IEVW�

%X�EFSYX�XLI�WEQI�XMQI�XLEX���������XS���������%VEFW�FIGEQIVIJYKIIW�JVSQ�-WVEIP��XIRW�SJ�QMPPMSRW�SJ�SXLIV�VIJYKIIW�LEH�FIIR�GVIEXIH�EWXLI�VIWYPX�SJ�;SVPH�;EV�--��-R�ZMVXYEPP]�EPP�SJ�XLSWI�GEWIW��XLI�VIJYKIIW�[IVIHMWTPEGIH�JVSQ�PSGEXMSRW�MR�[LMGL�XLI]�ERH�XLIMV�ERGIWXSVW�LEH�PMZIH�JSVHIGEHIW��WSQIXMQIW�GIRXYVMIW GIVXEMRP]�QSVI�XLER�XLI�X[S�]IEVW�VIUYMVIHJSV�FIMRK�GSRWMHIVIH�E�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKII��*SV�I\EQTPI��XLI�7YHIXIR�+IV�QERW��[LS�[IVI�QSZIH�IR�QEWWI�SYX�SJ�XLI�FSVHIVPERHW�SJ�'IGLSWPSZEOME�LEH�PMZIH�XLIVI�JSV�LYRHVIHW�SJ�]IEVW��8LI�.I[W�SJ�)YVSTI [LEX�VIQEMRIHSJ�XLIQ�EJXIV�XLI�,SPSGEYWX LEH�PMZIH�MR�4SPERH��+IVQER]��'IGLSWPSZE�OME��,YRKEV]��ERH�XLI�7SZMIX�9RMSR�JSV�LYRHVIHW�SJ�]IEVW�

%W�XLI�VIWYPX�SJ�LEZMRK�PMZIH�MR�[LEX�FIGEQI�-WVEIP�JSV�EW�PMXXPI�EW�X[S]IEVW��XLSYWERHW�YTSR�XLSYWERHW�SJ�%VEFW�ERH�XLIMV�HIWGIRHERXW�LEZIFIIR�OITX�MR�VIJYKII�GEQTW�JSV�QSVI�XLER�LEPJ�E�GIRXYV]�XS�FI�YWIH�EWTSPMXMGEP�TE[RW�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�HIQSRMI�ERH�HIWXVS]�-WVEIP��(YVMRK�XLEXWEQI�TIVMSH�SJ�XMQI��QER]�SXLIV�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�LEZI�FIIRWSPZIH�F]�XLI�LSWX�REXMSRW�EGGITXMRK�ERH�MRXIKVEXMRK�XLI�VIJYKII�TSTYPE�XMSR�MRXS�XLIMV�S[R��)\GLERKIW�SJ�TSTYPEXMSR�XSSO�TPEGI�FIX[IIR�WIZIVEPREXMSRW MRGPYHMRK�-RHME�ERH�4EOMWXER��ERH�+VIIGI�ERH�8YVOI] [MXLSYXXLI�RIIH�XS�FYMPH�TIVQERIRX�VIJYKII�GEQTW��%PXLSYKL�XLSWI�I\GLERKIW[IVI�RSX�[MXLSYX�HMJJMGYPXMIW�ERH�WSQI�VIQEMR�GSRXVSZIVWMEP��RSRI�LEW�GVI�EXIH�XLI�OMRH�SJ�IRHYVMRK�TVSFPIQW�GEYWIH�F]�XLI�YR[MPPMRKRIWW�SJ�%VEFWXEXIW�XS�MRXIKVEXI�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�

&IX[IIR������ERH�������XIRW�SJ�QMPPMSRW�SJ�SXLIV�VIJYKIIW�FIGEQITVSHYGXMZI�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLIMV�RI[�WSGMIXMIW��=IX�JSV�XLI�RIEVP]�X[IRX]�]IEVWXLEX�)K]TX�ERH�.SVHER�GSRXVSPPIH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�ERH�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��XLI4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKII�TSTYPEXMSR�VIQEMRIH�MR�GEQTW��KVS[MRK�MR�WMI�ERHHIWTIVEXMSR��)ZIR�/MRK�,YWWIMR�SJ�.SVHER��[LS�GSYPH�LEZI�LIPTIH�WSPZIXLI�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ��EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�XLI�%VEF�REXMSRW�LEZI�YWIH�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKIIW�EW�TE[RW�WMRGI�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�GSRJPMGX��©7MRGI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 98: The Case For Israel

�����%VEF�PIEHIVW�������LEZI�YWIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRI�TISTPI�JSV�WIPJMWL�TSPMXMGEPTYVTSWIW��8LMW�MW�������GVMQMREP�ª��

8LI�SXLIV�QENSV�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�XLEX�EJJIGXIH�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�[EW�XLIGVIEXMSR�SJ�LYRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW�SJ�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�%VEF�ERH�1YW�PMQ�GSYRXVMIW�MR�[LMGL�XLI]�LEH�PMZIH�JSV�LYRHVIHW�SV�WSQIXMQIW�XLSY�WERHW�SJ�]IEVW��IZIR�FIJSVI�XLI�EHZIRX�SJ�-WPEQ��1SLEQQIH�ERH�LMWGSRXIQTSVEVMIW�GVIEXIH�E�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�[LIR�XLI]�FERRIH�.I[W�JVSQ%VEFME��8LIR�EKEMR�EJXIV�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��XLI�WMXYEXMSR�SJ.I[W�MR�QER]�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�GSYRXVMIW�FIGEQI�WS�JVEYKLX�[MXL�VMWO�XLEX�QER]�JIPX�XLI]�LEH�RS�GLSMGI�FYX�XS�PIEZI��-R�XLI�]IEVW�JSPPS[MRK�XLIIWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP��EW�QER]�EW���������WS�GEPPIH�%VEF.I[W�FIGEQI�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�XLI�PERHW�MR�[LMGL�XLI]�LEH�FIIR�FSVR��8LIRYQFIV�SJ�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�%VEF�PERHW�[EW�WPMKLXP]�QSVI�XLER�XLIRYQFIV�SJ�%VEF�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�-WVEIP�

8LIVI�[EW�©ER�I\GLERKI�SJ�TSTYPEXMSRW�ª�[MXL�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�LEZ�MRK�FIIR�JSVGIH�XS�EFERHSR�JEV�QSVI�SJ�XLIMV�TVSTIVX]�ERH�[IEPXL�XLER�XLIVIJYKIIW�PIJX�FILMRH��8LSWI�EFERHSRIH�EWWIXW�MRGPYHIH�PEVKI�LSYWIW��FYWM�RIWWIW��ERH�GEWL��8LI�HMJJIVIRGI�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP�[SVOIH�LEVH��EPXLSYKL�RSXEP[E]W�[MXL�GSQTPIXI�WYGGIWW �XS�MRXIKVEXI�MXW�VIJYKII�TSTYPEXMSR�MRXS�XLIQEMRWXVIEQ��[LMPI�XLI�%VEFW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�IRGSYVEKIH�%VEF�VIJYKIIW�XS�JIW�XIV�F]�OIITMRK�WS�QER]�SJ�XLIQ�MR�GEQTW��[LIVI�QER]�WXMPP�VIQEMR��ERHVIJYWMRK�XS�MRXIKVEXI�XLIQ�MRXS�XLIMV�QSVI�LSQSKIRISYW�TSTYPEXMSRW�8LMW�[EW�HSRI�TYVIP]�XS�XV]�XS�GEWX�HSYFX�SR�-WVEIP¬W�PIKMXMQEG]�HIWTMXI�XLIHIWTIVEXI�RIIH�MR�WSQI�YRHIVTSTYPEXIH�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW��WYGL�EW�7]VME�ERH.SVHER��JSV�QSVI�[SVOIVW�XS�WIVZI�XLI�PEFSV�MRXIRWMZI�IGSRSQMG�RIIHW�SJXLSWI�REXMSRW��)ZIR�EJXIV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�EWWYQIH�GSRXVSP�SZIVEPP�XLI�QENSV�GMXMIW�SR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�MR�+EE��JSPPS[MRK�XLI�MRMXMEPMQTPIQIRXEXMSR�SJ�XLI�3WPS�--�%KVIIQIRX�MR�������RS�WIVMSYW�IJJSVX�[EWQEHI�XS�QSZI�XLI�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�XLI�GEQTW�XS�MRXIKVEXI�XLIQ�MRXS�4EPIW�XMRMER�WSGMIX]��8LI]�VIQEMR�TE[RW�MR�XLI�IJJSVX�XS�JPSSH�-WVEIP�[MXL�E�LSW�XMPI�TSTYPEXMSR�HIWMKRIH�XS�HIWXVS]�MXW�GLEVEGXIV�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

8LIVI�EVI�XLSWI�[LS�EVKYI�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�HMJJIVIRXJVSQ�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�MR�ERSXLIV�VIWTIGX��[LMPI�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVIJSVGIH�XS�JPII�JVSQ�XLIMV�LSQIW��XLI�.I[W�GLSWI�XS�PIEZI�XLIMV�ERGMIRXLSQIPERHW��;I�LEZI�EPVIEH]�WIIR�XLEX�XLI�VIEWSRW�[L]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�PIJXEVI�GSQTPI\�ERH�RSX�EQIREFPI�XS�WYGL�E�WMQTPI��WMRKYPEV�GEYWI��%�FVMIJVIZMI[�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�JPMKLX�JVSQ�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�GSYRXVMIW�HIQSRWXVEXIWE�GSQTEVEFPI�GSQTPI\MX]�ERH�WLS[W�XLEX�XLI�X[S�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQW�EPXLSYKL�ZIV]�HMJJIVIRX�MR�XLIMV�WSPYXMSRW��[IVI�UYMXI�WMQMPEV�MR�XLIMVGEYWIW��3RI�LMWXSVMER�WYQQEVMIH�XLI�WMXYEXMSR�EW�JSPPS[W�

-R�XLI�]IEVW�PIEHMRK�YT�XS�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�-WVEIP��.I[W�MR�QER]�TEVXW

SJ�XLI�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�[SVPH�JEGIH�MRGVIEWMRK�XLVIEXW�XS�XLIMV�WEJIX]��-R

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 99: The Case For Israel

2SZIQFIV�������XLI�LIEH�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMX]�SJ�8VMTSPM��XLI�GET�

MXEP�SJ�0MF]E �HIWGVMFIH�XLI�WGIRI�XLMW�[E]�

©8LI�%VEFW�EXXEGOIH�.I[W�MR�SFIHMIRGI�XS�Q]WXIVMSYW�SVHIVW��8LIMV

SYXFYVWX�SJ�FIWXMEP�ZMSPIRGI�LEW�RS�TPEYWMFPI�QSXMZI��*SV�JMJX]�LSYVW�XLI]

LYRXIH�QIR�HS[R��EXXEGOIH�LSYWIW�ERH�WLSTW��OMPPIH�QIR��[SQIR��SPH

ERH�]SYRK��LSVVMFP]�XSVXYVIH�ERH�HMWQIQFIVIH�.I[W�MWSPEXIH�MR�XLI�MRXI�

VMSV��������-R�SVHIV�XS�GEVV]�SYX�XLI�WPEYKLXIV��XLI�EXXEGOIVW�YWIH�ZEVMSYW

[IETSRW��ORMZIW��HEKKIVW��WXMGOW��GPYFW��MVSR�FEVW��VIZSPZIVW��ERH�IZIR

LERH�KVIREHIW�ª��

;LIR�XLI�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI�FIKER�MR�������XLI�ZMSPIRGI�MRXIRWM�JMIH��-R�%PITTS������LSYWIW�ERH����W]REKSKYIW�[IVI�HIWXVS]IH�MR�ETSKVSQ��ERH����.I[W�[IVI�OMPPIH�MR�%HIR��6MSXW�MR�-VEU�ERH�)K]TX�JSVGIH.I[W�SYX�SJ�XLSWI�GSYRXVMIW��8LI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�[IVI�JSVGIH�SYXF]�JIEV�EW�TSPMXMGEP�ZMSPIRGI�WTMPPIH�SRXS�XLI�WXVIIXW��-R�XLMW�GEWI��MX�[EW�JIHF]�SJJMGMEP�KSZIVRQIRX�MRGMXIQIRX��EW�MR�-VEU��[LIVI�>MSRMWQ�GSYPH�FITYRMWLIH�F]�HIEXL���

7EFVM�.MV]MW��E�JSVQIV�%VEF�-WVEIPM�PE[]IV�[LS�PIJX�-WVEIP�ERH�FIGEQI�EQIQFIV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�2EXMSREP�'SYRGMP��LEW�EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�©XLI.I[W�SJ�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�[IVI�HVMZIR�SYX�SJ�XLIMV�ERGMIRX�LSQIW�?ERHAWLEQIJYPP]�HITSVXIH�EJXIV�XLIMV�TVSTIVX]�LEH�FIIR�GSQQERHIIVIH�������?;ALEX�LETTIRIH�[EW�E�������TSTYPEXMSR�ERH�TVSTIVX]�I\GLERKI��ERH�IEGLTEVX]�QYWX�FIEV�XLI�GSRWIUYIRGIW��������?8ALI�%VEF�WXEXIW�������QYWX�WIXXPIXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�XLIMV�S[R�QMHWX�ERH�WSPZI�XLIMV�TVSFPIQW�ª��-RWXIEH�XLI]�HIPMFIVEXIP]�I\EGIVFEXIH�XLI�TVSFPIQW�

-X�MW�MQTSVXERX�XS�VIGEPP�XLEX�-WVEIP�[EW�RSX�XLI�SRP]�GSYRXV]�XLEX�KEMRIHXIVVMXSV]�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�XLI�JEMPIH�%VEF�EXXEGO��.SVHER�SGGYTMIH MRHIIHERRI\IH XLI�IRXMVI�;IWX�&ERO��[LMPI�)K]TX�SGGYTMIH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�8LIVI�[IVI�RS�VIWSPYXMSRW�HIQERHMRK�ER�IRH�XS�XLIWI�SGGYTEXMSRW�EPXLSYKL�XLI]�[IVI�SJXIR�UYMXI�VITVIWWMZI�ERH�FVYXEP��3RI�SFWIVZIVHIWGVMFIH�+EE�EW�©MR�IJJIGX��E�PEVKI�)K]TXMER�TVMWSR�GEQT�ª��8LI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�HMH�RSX�WIIQ�XS�GEVI�XLEX�XLIMV�PERH��ZMPPEKIW��ERH�GMXMIW�[IVI�FIMRKSGGYTMIH�EW�PSRK�EW�XLI]�[IVI�RSX�SGGYTMIH�F]�.I[W��2SV�[IVI�XLIVI�GSQ�TPEMRXW�XLEX�WSQI�4EPIWXMRMERW IWTIGMEPP]�'LVMWXMERW FIGEQI�VIJYKIIWJVSQ�XLI�.SVHERMER�ERH�)K]TXMER�SGGYTEXMSRW���8LI�VIJYKII�MWWYI�SJ����§�����[EW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�PIJX�YRVIWSPZIH�F]�XLI�%VEFW�EW�E�XEGXMGHIWMKRIH�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�RI[�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

8S�YRHIVWXERH�LS[�HMJJIVIRX�XLI�%VEF§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX�[SYPH�PSSO�MJ�XLI%VEF�[SVPH�MRGPYHMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�1YWPMQW�LEH�EGGITXIH�XLI�X[S�WXEXIWSPYXMSR�[LIR�MX�[EW�JMVWX�TVSTSWIH��SV�IZIR�JSV�]IEVW�XLIVIEJXIV ��[I�QYWXFVMIJP]�VIXYVR�XS�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�6ITSVX�-J�XLI�%VEFW�LEH�EGGITXIH�XLI4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�TEVXMXMSR�TVSTSWEP��XLIVI�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�E�4EPIWXMRMERWXEXI��MR�EHHMXMSR�XS�8VERWNSVHER �MR�QSWX�SJ�[LEX�[EW�PIJX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 100: The Case For Israel

JSPPS[MRK�XLI�TEVXMXMSR�SJ�8VERWNSVHER��8LI�ZEWX�QENSVMX]�SJ�%VEFW�ERH1YWPMQW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�[SYPH�LEZI�PMZIH�YRHIV�4EPIWXMRMER�GSRXVSP��ERH�XLI%VEF�QMRSVMX]�XLEX�PMZIH�MR�XLI�PERH�EPPSXXIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�[SYPH�LEZILEH�XLI�GLSMGI�XS�QSZI�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�SV�VIQEMR�EW�TEVX�SJ�XLI%VEF�QMRSVMX]�MR�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��8LI�WEQI�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�XVYI�JSV�XLI.I[W�[LS�PMZIH�MR�XLI�%VEF�WXEXI�

8LI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�STIR�XS�MQQMKVEXMSR�ERH�GSYPH�LEZIWEZIH�LYRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW��TIVLETW�IZIR�QSVI��)YVSTIER�.I[W�JVSQ�XLI,SPSGEYWX��%PXLSYKL�XLI�EVIE�EPPSXXIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�F]�XLI�4IIP'SQQMWWMSR�[EW�XMR]�MR�GSQTEVMWSR�[MXL�XLEX�EPPSXXIH�XS�XLI�%VEF�WXEXI�ERH�GSQTEVEFP]�IZIR�WQEPPIV�MJ�8VERWNSVHER�MW�MRGPYHIH ��MX�[EW�PEVKIIRSYKL�XS�EFWSVF�QMPPMSRW�SJ�VIJYKIIW��EW�IZMHIRGIH�F]�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�QMP�PMSRW�SJ�TISTPI�PMZI�[MXLMR�XLEX�EVIE�XSHE]�

8LIVI�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�RS�%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�LEH�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIWEGGITXIH�XLI�WYFWIUYIRX�9�2��TEVXMXMSR��&YX�MRWXIEH��LEZMRK�VINIGXIH�.I[�MWL�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�MR�������XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�VINIGXIH�MX�SRGI�EKEMR�MR�����ERH�EXXEGOIH�-WVEIP�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�RI[�.I[MWL�WXEXI�I\XIVQMREXI�MXW�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR��ERH�HVMZI�XLI�.I[W�MRXS�XLI�WIE��8LIREKEMR�MR�������MX�XLVIEXIRIH�-WVEIP�[MXL�HIWXVYGXMSR�ERH�ERRMLMPEXMSR�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 101: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP�WXEVXIH�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV�

8,)�%''97)67

©-R������-WVEIP�WXEVXIH�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV�F]�PEYRGLMRK�ER�EMV�EXXEGO�SR)K]TX��.SVHER��7]VME�ERH�-VEU��-WVEIP�SGGYTMIH�)EWX�.IVYWEPIQ��XLI�;IWX&ERO�ERH�+EE�ERH�����QMPPMSR�%VEFW��QSWXP]�4EPIWXMRMERW��GEQI�YRHIV-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR��1SVI�XLER���������4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�JSVGIH�XS�JPII�-WVEIP�MW�WXMPP�SGGYT]MRK�XLI�XIVVMXSVMIW�ª��)ZE�&NSVIRK��WIGVIXEV]�KIRIVEP�SJ2SV[IKMER�4ISTPI¬W�%MH��ERH�7XIMREV�7SVPMI��WIGVIXEV]�KIRIVEP�SJ�2SV[I�KMER�6IJYKII�'SYRGMP�

8,)�6)%0-8=

%PXLSYKL�-WVEIP�JMVIH�XLI�JMVWX�WLSX�EKEMRWX�)U]TX EPXLSYKL�RSX�EKEMRWX.SVHSR XLI�[EV�[EW�FIKYR�F]�)K]TX¬W�HIGMWMSR�XS�GPSWI�XLI�+YPJ�SJ%UEFE�XS�-WVEIPM�WLMTTMRK�ERH�XS�SVHIV�XLI�VIQSZEP�SJ�9�2��XVSSTW�JVSQXLI�7MREM�

8,)�4633*

%PXLSYKL�-WVEIP�JMVIH�XLI�JMVWX�WLSXW��ZMVXYEPP]�IZIV]SRI�VIGSKRMIW�XLEX)K]TX��7]VME��ERH�.SVHER�WXEVXIH�XLI�[EV��8LI�MPPIKEP�)K]TXMER�HIGMWMSR�XS

��

(MH�-WVEIP�7XEVX�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV#

��

Page 102: The Case For Israel

GPSWI�XLI�7XVEMXW�SJ�8MVER�F]�QMPMXEV]�JSVGI�[EW�VIGSKRMIH�F]�XLI�MRXIV�REXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�XS�FI�ER�EGX�SJ�[EV��%W�)K]TXMER�TVIWMHIRX�2EWWIVLMQWIPJ�FSEWXIH��©;I�ORI[�XLI�GPSWMRK�SJ�XLI�+YPJ�SJ�%UEFE�QIERX�[EV[MXL�-WVEIP�������XLI�SFNIGXMZI�[MPP�FI�-WVEIP¬W�HIWXVYGXMSR�ª�8LI�)K]TXMERGSQQERHIV�SJ�7LEVQ�EP�7LIOL��XLI�TSMRX�SJ�IRXV]�XS�XLI�WXVEMXW�JVSQ[LMGL�XLI�)K]TXMERW�[EVRIH�XLI]�[SYPH�WLSSX�EX�ER]�-WVEIPM�WLMT�XLEX�XVMIHXS�TEWW�XLVSYKL�SR�XLI�[E]�XS�SV�JVSQ�)MPEX��EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�©XLI�GPSW�MRK�SJ�XLI�WXVEMXW�[EW�E�HIGPEVEXMSR�SJ�[EV�ª�,S[IZIV��EGGSVHMRK�XS�2EWWIV�XLI�[EV�[EW�RSX�XS�FI�SZIV�XLI�7XVEMXW�SJ�8MVER�FYX�SZIV�-WVEIP¬W�©I\MW�XIRGI�ª�2SV�[EW�-WVEIP¬W�WYVVIRHIV�GSRXIQTPEXIH��8LMW��PMOI�XLI������[EV�[EW�TPERRIH�XS�FI�E�[EV�SJ�I\XIVQMREXMSR�

(EQEWGYW�6EHMS�MRGMXIH�MXW�PMWXIRIVW��©%VEF�QEWWIW��XLMW�MW�]SYV�HE]�6YWL�XS�XLI�FEXXPIJMIPH��������0IX�XLIQ�ORS[�XLEX�[I�WLEPP�LERK�XLI�PEWXMQTIVMEPMWX�WSPHMIV�[MXL�XLI�IRXVEMPW�SJ�XLI�PEWX�>MSRMWX�ª�,EJM�EP�%WWEHSVHIVIH�LMW�7]VMER�WSPHMIVW�XS�©WXVMOI�XLI�IRIQ]¬W�?GMZMPMERA�WIXXPIQIRXW�XYVR�XLIQ�MRXS�HYWX��TEZI�XLI�%VEF�VSEHW�[MXL�XLI�WOYPPW�SJ�.I[W��7XVMOIXLIQ�[MXLSYX�QIVG]�ª� ,I�GLEVEGXIVMIH�XLI�JSVXLGSQMRK�EXXEGO�SR-WVEIP�EW�©E�FEXXPI�SJ�ERRMLMPEXMSR�ª�8LI�:SMGIW�SJ�XLI�%VEFW�MR�'EMVSI\LSVXIH�MXW�PMWXIRIVW�[MXL�WMQMPEV�MRGMXIQIRXW�XS�WII�XLEX�©-WVEIP�MW�PMUYM�HEXIH�ª�8LI�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�SJ�-VEU�TVIHMGXIH��©8LIVI�[MPP�FI�TVEGXMGEPP]RS�.I[MWL�WYVZMZSVW�ª�'EMVS�[EW�JMPPIH�[MXL�ERXM�7IQMXMG�TSWXIVW�©WLS[MRK%VEF�WSPHMIVW�WLSSXMRK��GVYWLMRK��QERKPMRK��ERH�HMWQIQFIVMRK�FIEVHIH�LSSO�RSWIH�.I[W�ª�

2SV�[EW�XLMW�SRP]�VLIXSVMG��%VEF�EVQMIW�[IVI�QEWWMRK�EPSRK�-WVEIP¬WFSVHIV�TSMWIH�XS�WXVMOI��)K]TXMER�FEXXPI�TPERW�MRGPYHIH�XLI�QEWWEGVI�SJ�XLI8IP�%ZMZ�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR��4EPIWXMRMER�TPERW�MRGPYHIH�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ-WVEIP�©ERH�MXW�MRLEFMXERXW�ª�-WVEIPM�MRXIPPMKIRGI�VITSVXIH�XLEX�XLI�MRZEHMRK)K]TXMER�EVQ]�[EW�IUYMTTIH�[MXL�©GERMWXIVW�SJ�TSMWSR�KEW�ª��8LI�SRP]UYIWXMSR�[EW�[LIXLIV�XLI�%VEF�EVQMIW�[SYPH�FI�EFPI�XS�WXVMOI�XLI�JMVWX�QMP�MXEV]�FPS[��%W�4VMQI�1MRMWXIV�0IZM�)WLOSP�XSPH�LMW�GEFMRIX�SR�1E]����������©8LI�)K]TXMERW�TPER�XS�GPSWI�XLI�WXVEMXW�SV�XS�FSQF�XLI�EXSQMG�VIEG�XSV�MR�(MQSRE��%�KIRIVEP�EXXEGO�[MPP�JSPPS[��%�[EV�[SYPH�IRWYI�MR�[LMGLXLI�JMVWX�JMZI�QMRYXIW�[MPP�FI�HIGMWMZI��8LI�UYIWXMSR�MW�[LS�[MPP�EXXEGO�XLISXLIV¬W�EMVJMIPHW�JMVWX�ª�� %JXIV�I\LEYWXMRK�EPP�HMTPSQEXMG�STXMSRW�� ERHPIEVRMRK�XLEX�)K]TX�[EW�TVITEVMRK�ER�MQQMRIRX�EXXEGO�ERH�LEH�JPS[R�WYV�ZIMPPERGI�JPMKLXW�SZIV�-WVEIPM�XIVVMXSV]��XLI�-WVEIPM�EMV�JSVGI�EXXEGOIH�)K]TXMER�7]VMER��ERH�-VEUM�QMPMXEV]�EMVJMIPHW�SR�XLI�QSVRMRK�SJ�.YRI����������;SYPHER]�VIEWSREFPI�REXMSR�JEGIH�[MXL�GSQTEVEFPI�XLVIEXW�SJ�ERRMLMPEXMSR�LEZIEGXIH�HMJJIVIRXP]#

-WVEIP�HMH�RSX�EXXEGO�.SVHER��LSTMRK�MX�[SYPH�WXE]�SYX�SJ�XLI�[EV��HIWTMXIMXW�XVIEX]�[MXL�)K]TX��-WVEIP�WIRX�WIZIVEP�QIWWEKIW�XS�/MRK�,YWWIMR�TVSQMW�MRK�RSX�XS�EXXEGO�.SVHER�YRPIWW�MX�[EW�EXXEGOIH�JMVWX��-WVEIP�QEHI�MX�GPIEV�XLEXMX�LEH�RS�HIWMKRW�SR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�SV�IZIR�SR�XLI�.I[MWL�5YEVXIV�SJ

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 103: The Case For Israel

.IVYWEPIQ��[MXL�MXW�;IWXIVR�;EPP��YRPIWW�MX�[IVI�XS�FI�EXXEGOIH��-X�[EW�XLI%VEF�PIKMSR�XLEX�MRMXMEXIH�XLI�LSWXMPMXMIW�FIX[IIR�.SVHER�ERH�-WVEIP���

.SVHER�MKRSVIH�-WVEIP¬W�VITIEXIH�TIEGIJYP�SZIVXYVIW�ERH�FIKER�WLIPPMRK.I[MWL�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�MR�ERH�EVSYRH�-WVEIP¬W�QENSV�GMXMIW�ERHWYFYVFW��7M\�XLSYWERH�WLIPPW�[IVI�JMVIH�MRXS�.I[MWL�VIWMHIRXMEP�EVIEW�[SYRHMRK�������GMZMPMERW��QER]�SJ�XLIQ�WIVMSYWP]��8[IRX]�GMZMPMERW�[IVIOMPPIH�ERH�����FYMPHMRKW�[IVI�HEQEKIH��0SRK�8SQ�KYRW�XEVKIXIH�XLI�WYF�YVFW�SJ�8IP�%ZMZ��ERH�.SVHERMER�TPERIW�NSMRIH�7]VMER�ERH�-VEUM�1-+W�MRFSQFMRK�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�MR�GMXMIW��XS[RW��OMFFYXMQ��ERHQSWLEZMQ��(EQEWGYW�6EHMS�TVSYHP]�VITSVXIH��©8LI�7]VMER�%MV�*SVGI�LEWFIKYR�XS�FSQF�-WVEIPM�GMXMIW�ª��-X�[EW�E�VITIEX�SJ�������MR�[LMGL�XLI�%VEFEVQMIW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�ERH�YRPE[JYPP]�XEVKIXIH�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIR�XIVW��[LMPI�XLI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�EXXEGOIH�PIKMXMQEXI�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW�

(IWTMXI�.SVHER¬W�YRTVSZSOIH�EXXEGO�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW��XLI�-WVEIPMEVQ]�HMH�RSX�VIWTSRH��LSTMRK�XLEX�.SVHER�[SYPH�PMQMX�MXW�QMPMXEV]�EGXMSRWXS�E�JI[�STIRMRK�WEPZSW��FYX�EJXIV�.SVHER�WIRX�MXW�EMV�JSVGI�MRXS�XLI�WO]�XSFSQF�XLI�VIWMHIRXMEP�RIMKLFSVLSSHW�SJ�2IXER]E��/JEV�7MVOMR��ERH�/JEV7EFE��XLI�-WVEIPM�EMV�JSVGIW�JMREPP]�EXXEGOIH�.SVHERMER�QMPMXEV]�EMVJMIPHW��8LI-WVEIPMW�XLIR�EGGITXIH�E�GIEWI�JMVI�TVSTSWIH�F]�XLI�9�2��GLMIJ�SFWIVZIV�FYX�XLI�.SVHERMERW�JSYKLX�SR��3RP]�XLIR�HMH�-WVEIP�GETXYVI�XLI�;IWX�&EROERH�XLI�3PH�'MX]�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ TPEMRP]�MR�E�HIJIRWMZI�[EV�EKEMRWX�.SVHERWXEVXIH�F]�.SVHER�EJXIV�-WVEIP�QEHI�MX�GPIEV�MX�[ERXIH�RS�QMPMXEV]�GSRJPMGX[MXL�XLI�,EWLIQMXI�/MRKHSQ�

8LI�7M\�(E]�;EV�GVIEXIH�]IX�ERSXLIV�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ��XLMW�SRI�QYGLIEWMIV�XS�VIWSPZI�MR�XLI�GSRXI\X�SJ�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��8LI���������XS��������VIJYKIIW�[LS�PIJX�+EE�ERH�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�-WVEIPMSGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLSWI�EVIEW�[MPP�WYVIP]�LEZI�E�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�XS�XLSWI�EVIEW

SRGI�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�MW�IWXEFPMWLIH���-X�[MPP�FI�MRXIVIWXMRK�XS�WII�LS[QER]�EGXYEPP]�I\IVGMWI�XLEX�VMKLX��WMRGI�XLI�I\IVGMWI�SJ�XLEX�VMKLX YRPMOIXLI�GPEMQIH�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�XS�-WVEIP [MPP�LEZI�RS�QENSV�TSPMXMGEP�SV�HIQS�KVETLMG�IJJIGX�SR�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI� �1SWX�SJ�XLI�VIJYKIIW�PIJX�SR�XLIMV�S[REGGSVH��8LI�HIJMRMXMZI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI������[EV�F]�1MGLEIP�3VIR�WXEXIW�©*I[�-WVEIPMW�IZIR�GEQI�MR�GSRXEGX�[MXL�GMZMPMERW��QSWX�SJ�[LSQ�LEH�JPIH[MXL�XLI�7]VMER�GSQQERH��[IPP�MR�EHZERGI�SJ�XLI�EXXEGOIVW�ª��

-R�KIRIVEP��XLI�GEWYEPXMIW�EQSRK�GMZMPMERW�©[IVI�VIQEVOEFP]�PS[ª�HYV�MRK�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV�FIGEYWI�-WVEIP�QEHI�WYVI�XLEX�QSWX�SJ�XLI�JMKLXMRK©XSSO�TPEGI�JEV�JVSQ�QENSV�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�ª�3VIR�VITSVXW��-RHIIH��XLIQENSV�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�[IVI�MRJPMGXIH�F]�%VEF�QSFW�SR�MRRSGIRX�.I[MWLGMZMPMERW�MR�%VEF�GMXMIW�XLEX�[IVI�RSX�MRZSPZIH�MR�XLI�JMKLXMRK��3VIR�WYQ�QEVMIW�XLI�WMXYEXMSR�

;MXL�RI[W�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�ZMGXSV]��QSFW�EXXEGOIH�.I[MWL�RIMKLFSVLSSHW�MR

)K]TX��=IQIR��0IFERSR��8YRMWME��ERH�1SVSGGS��FYVRMRK�W]REKSKYIW�ERH

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 104: The Case For Israel

EWWEYPXMRK�VIWMHIRXW��%�TSKVSQ�MR�8VMTSPM��0MF]E��PIJX����.I[W�HIEH�ERH���

MRNYVIH��XLI�WYVZMZSVW�[IVI�LIVHIH�MRXS�HIXIRXMSR�GIRXIVW��3J�)K]TX¬W

������.I[W������[IVI�EVVIWXIH��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�GLMIJ�VEFFMW�SJ�FSXL�'EMVS

ERH�%PI\ERHVME��ERH�XLIMV�TVSTIVX]�WIUYIWXIVIH�F]�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX��8LI

ERGMIRX�GSQQYRMXMIW�SJ�(EQEWGYW�ERH�&EKLHEH�[IVI�TPEGIH�YRHIV�LSYWI

EVVIWX��XLIMV�PIEHIVW�MQTVMWSRIH�ERH�JMRIH��%�XSXEP�SJ�������.I[W�[IVI

I\TIPPIH��QER]�[MXL�QIVIP]�E�WEXGLIP���

8LMW�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�LEW�RIZIV�FIIR�EHHVIWWIH�F]�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREPGSQQYRMX]��8LI�SXLIV�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW��EW�[I�LEZI�WIIR��[IVI�MRJPMGXIHSR�.I[MWL�VIWMHIRXW�SJ�GMXMIW�ERH�XS[RW�XLEX�[IVI�XEVKIXIH�F]�%VEF�QSVXEVWLIPPW��8LI�XMR]�RYQFIV�SJ�%VEF�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�[EW�PS[IV�XLER�MR�ER]GSQTEVEFPI�[EV�MR�QSHIVR�LMWXSV] E�JEGX�RIZIV�QIRXMSRIH�F]�XLSWI�[LSEGGYWI�-WVEIP�SJ�KIRSGMHI�SV�XLI�MRHMWGVMQMREXI�OMPPMRK�SJ�GMZMPMERW��8LIQENSV�MQTEGX�SJ�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV�[EW�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�MXWIPJ�

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 105: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��XLI�+EE�7XVMT��ERH�XLI�+SPER,IMKLXW�JSPPS[MRK�MXW�ZMGXSV]�MR�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV�MW�[MXLSYX�ER]NYWXMJMGEXMSR�

8,)�%''97)67

©?8ALIVI�EVI�X[S�GV]WXEP�GPIEV�JEGXW�XLEX�GER�RSX�FI�SFWGYVIH�F]�TVSTE�KERHE�ERH�FMEW��MR������-WVEIP�IXLRMGEPP]�GPIERWIH�4EPIWXMRI�XS�QEOI�VSSQJSV�MXWIPJ�ERH�EW�E�VIWYPX�XSSO�SZIV����TIV�GIRX�SJ�1ERHEXSV]�4EPIWXMRI��ERH�WIGSRHP]��MR������-WVEIP�MQTSWIH�E�FVYXEP�ERH�GEPPSYW�SGGYTEXMSR�SZIV�XLIVIQEMRMRK����TIV�GIRX�SJ�XLI�PERH��XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�ª�-PER�4ETTI�

©1SWX�SJ�XLI�VIGIRX�OMPPMRK�ERH�HIWXVYGXMSR�?VIJIVVMRK�XS�XLI�ZMSPIRGIWXIQQMRK�JVSQ�XLI�WIGSRH�MRXMJEHEA�LEW�XEOIR�TPEGI�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH+EE��XIVVMXSVMIW�GSRUYIVIH��EPSRK�[MXL�)EWX�.IVYWEPIQ �F]�-WVEIP�MR�XLI�����[EV��9�2��6IWSPYXMSR���� [LMGL�XLI�9�7��ZSXIH�JSV LSPHW�XLEXGSRXMRYIH�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLIWI�XIVVMXSVMIW�MW�MPPIKEP��8LEX�6IWSPYXMSR�TVS�GPEMQW�XLI�«MREHQMWWMFMPMX]�SJ�XLI�EGUYMWMXMSR�SJ�XIVVMXSV]�F]�[EV�¬©&YX�-WVEIP�VIJYWIW�XS�IRH�MXW�SGGYTEXMSR�ª��1E\�)PFEYQ�ERH�,ER]

/LEPMP��GSRXVMFYXMRK�[VMXIVW�XS�;EV�8MQIW�E�TYFPMGEXMSR�©STTSWMRK�XLI�[EVSR�XIVVSVMWQª�

��

;EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�3GGYTEXMSR�[MXLSYX�.YWXMJMGEXMSR#

��

Page 106: The Case For Israel

8,)�6)%0-8=

-WVEIP�[EW�[MPPMRK�XS�XVEHI�PERH�GETXYVIH�MR�E�HIJIRWMZI�[EV�JSV�TIEGI��EW�MXIZIRXYEPP]�HMH�[MXL�XLI�)K]TXMERW�ERH�.SVHERMERW��FYX�RIMXLIV�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�RSV�XLI�7]VMERW�LEZI�FIIR�[MPPMRK�XS�SJJIV�TIEGI�MR�I\GLERKI�JSVPERH��EW�VIUYMVIH�F]�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�6IWSPYXMSR�����

8,)�4633*

%PQSWX�MQQIHMEXIP]�YTSR�TVIZEMPMRK�SZIV�XLI�%VEF�EVQMIW�XLEX�LEHTPIHKIH�ERH�TPERRIH�XS�ERRMLMPEXI�-WVEIP��XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�EKVIIH�XSGSQTP]�[MXL�6IWSPYXMSR�����SJ�XLI�9�2��7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP��[LMGL�JSV�XLIJMVWX�XMQI�MR�LMWXSV]�SVHIVIH�E�REXMSR�XS�VIXYVR�XIVVMXSVMIW�PE[JYPP]�GETXYVIHMR�E�HIJIRWMZI�[EV��&YX�MX�SVHIVIH�XLMW�SRP]�EW�TEVX�SJ�ER�SZIVEPP�TIEGIEKVIIQIRX�VIGSKRMMRK�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�©PMZI�MR�WIGYVMX]�ª�8LMW�MW�[LEX����TVSZMHIH�

?8LI�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMPA��� �%JJMVQWXLEX�XLI�JYPJMPPQIRX�SJ�'LEVXIV�TVMR�

GMTPIW�VIUYMVIW�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�E�NYWX�ERH�PEWXMRK�TIEGI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI

)EWX�[LMGL�WLSYPH�MRGPYHI�XLI�ETTPMGEXMSR�SJ�FSXLSJ�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�TVMR�

GMTPIW���M �;MXLHVE[EP�SJ�-WVEIP�EVQIH�JSVGIW�JVSQ�XIVVMXSVMIWSGGYTMIH�MR

XLI�VIGIRX�GSRJPMGX���MM �8IVQMREXMSR�SJ�EPP�GPEMQW�SV�WXEXIW�SJ�FIPPMKIVIRG]

ERH�VIWTIGX�JSV�ERH�EGORS[PIHKIQIRX�SJ�XLI�WSZIVIMKRX]�XIVVMXSVMEP�MRXIKVMX]

ERH�TSPMXMGEP�MRHITIRHIRGI�SJ�IZIV]WXEXI�MR�XLI�EVIE�ERH�XLIMV�VMKLX�XS�PMZI

MR�TIEGI�[MXLMR�WIGYVI�ERH�VIGSKRMIH�FSYRHEVMIWJVII�JVSQ�XLVIEXW�SV�EGXW

SJ�JSVGI��?IQTLEWMW�EHHIHA

2SXI�XLEX�XLI�VIWSPYXMSR�HSIW�RSX�VIUYMVI�-WVEIPM�[MXLHVE[EP�JVSQ�EPPXLIXIVVMXSVMIW��SRP]�©XIVVMXSVMIW�ª�XLYW�GSRXIQTPEXMRK�WSQI�XIVVMXSVMEPEHNYWXQIRXW�SJ�XLI�OMRH�TVSTSWIH�F]�-WVEIP�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�MR�������-�TPE]IH�E�ZIV]�WQEPP�ERH�MRJSVQEP�GSRWYPXMRK�VSPI�XS�9�7��EQFEW�WEHSV�%VXLYV�+SPHFIVK��[LS�TPE]IH�E�QENSV�VSPI�MR�RIKSXMEXMRK�XLI�VIWS�PYXMSR� �8LI�IPMQMREXMSR�SJ�XLI�HIJMRMXI�EVXMGPI�XLI[EW�ER�I\TPMGMXGSQTVSQMWI�IRKMRIIVIH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�MR�SVHIV�XS�TIVQMX�XLI�VIXIR�XMSR�F]�-WVEIP�SJ�XIVVMXSVMIW�RIGIWWEV]�XS�EWWYVI�WIGYVI�FSYRHEVMIW�-WVEIP�MQQIHMEXIP]�EGGITXIH�XLI�TVMRGMTPIW�SJ�6IWSPYXMSR������%GGSVH�

MRK�XS�1SVVMW��©8LI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�LSTIH�XS�GSRZIVX�MXW�WXYRRMRK�QMP�MXEV]�ZMGXSV]�MRXS�E�TSPMXMGEP�EGLMIZIQIRX��XLI�GSRUYIVIH�XIVVMXSVMIW�GSYPHFI�XVEHIH�JSV�TIEGI�ª�1SWLI�(E]ER��[LS�[EW�XLIR�HIJIRWI�QMRMWXIV��[EWUYSXIH�EW�WE]MRK�XLEX�LI�[EW�©[EMXMRK�JSV�E�XIPITLSRI�GEPP�JVSQ�/MRK�,YW�WIMRª�XS�HMWGYWW�ER�I\GLERKI�SJ�PERH�JSV�TIEGI��8LI�GEPP�HMH�RSX�GSQIYRXMP�QER]�]IEVW�PEXIV��F]�[LMGL�XMQI�,YWWIMR�LEH�VIRSYRGIH�EPP�GPEMQ�XSXLI�;IWX�&ERO�MR�JEZSV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�0MFIVEXMSR�3VKERMEXMSR��3R

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 107: The Case For Israel

.YRI�����������XLI�-WVEIPM�GEFMRIX�HIGMHIH�XLEX�-WVEIP�[SYPH�©KMZI�YT�7MREM�ERH�XLI�+SPER�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�TIEGIª�[MXL�)K]TX�ERH�7]VME��[VMXIW1SVVMW��©;MXLMR�HE]W�FSXL�)K]TX�ERH�7]VME�LEH�VINIGXIH�XLI�SZIVXYVI�ª�

%W�[I�WLEPP�WII��-WVEIP�LEW��MR�JEGX��MQTPIQIRXIH�XLI�STIVEXMZI�TVMRGMTPIWSJ�6IWSPYXMSR�����F]�IZIRXYEPP]�VIXYVRMRK�EPP�XLI�GETXYVIH�XIVVMXSV]�WSYKLXF]�)K]TX�[LIR�)K]TX�XIVQMREXIH�EPP�GPEMQW�SJ�FIPPMKIVIRG]�EKEMRWX�MX��-WVEIPEPWS�VIXYVRIH�PERH�GPEMQIH�F]�.SVHER�EW�TEVX�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�EKVIIQIRX�[MXLXLI�,EWLIQMXI�/MRKHSQ��*MREPP]��MX�SJJIVIH�XS�XYVR�SZIV�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER%YXLSVMX]�RIEVP]�EPP�SJ�XLI�VIQEMRMRK�XIVVMXSV]�GETXYVIH�JVSQ�.SVHER�MRI\GLERKI�JSV�TIEGI��FYX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VINIGXIH�XLMW�SJJIV�QEHI�EX�'EQT(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�EW�VIGIRXP]�EW�������ERH�MRWXIEH�VIWSVXIH�XS�MRGVIEWIHXIVVSVMWQ�8LI�QENSV�%VEF�WXEXIW��EPSRK�[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT��SR�XLI

SXLIV�LERH��GEXIKSVMGEPP]�VINIGXIH�XLI�TVMRGMTPIW�SJ�6IWSPYXMSR�����MR�����FIGEYWI�MX�VIUYMVIH�QEOMRK�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP��[LMGL�XLI]�EHEQERXP]VIJYWIH�XS�HS��%X�E�WYQQMX�MR�/LEVXSYQ��%VEF�PIEHIVW�MWWYIH�XLIMV�RSXS�VMSYW�©XLVII�RS¬Wª�WXEXIQIRX��©2S�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP��RS�RIKSXMEXMSRW�[MXL-WVEIP��RS�VIGSKRMXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�ª�8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VIWTSRHIH�XS�XLI�-WVEIPMTIEGI�SJJIV�FEWIH�SR�MXW�EGGITXERGI�SJ�6IWSPYXMSR�����F]�EHSTXMRK�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�2EXMSREP�'LEVXIV��[LMGL�I\TVIWWP]�HIRMIH�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWXERH�TPIHKIH�XS�GSRXMRYI�©EVQIH�WXVYKKPIª�EW�XLI�SRP]�[E]�XS�PMFIVEXI�EPPSJ�4EPIWXMRI��-X�HIJMRIH�4EPIWXMRI�XS�MRGPYHI�EPP�SJ�-WVEIP��EW�[IPP��ETTEVIRXP]�EW�EPP�SJ�.SVHER ��©4EPIWXMRI��[MXL�XLI�FSYRHEVMIW�MX�LEH�HYVMRK�XLI�&VMXMWL1ERHEXI��MW�ER�MRHMZMWMFPI�XIVVMXSVMEP�YRMX�ª�-R�HIJMERGI�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH2EXMSRW��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�'LEVXIV�HIGPEVIH�XLI�9�2��©TEVXMXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRIMR������ERH�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�?EWA�IRXMVIP]�MPPIKEP�ªFIGEYWI�XLI]�©[IVI�GSRXVEV]�XS�XLI�[MPP�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�ª�%RH�MXVINIGXIH�©EPP�WSPYXMSRW�[LMGL�EVI�WYFWXMXYXIW�JSV�XLI�XSXEP�PMFIVEXMSR�SJ4EPIWXMRIª�XLVSYKL�EVQIH�WXVYKKPI��HIGPEVMRK�>MSRMWQ�ERH�-WVEIP�XS�FIVEGMWX��GSPSRMEP��ERH�JEWGMWX�%R]�TSWWMFMPMX]�SJ�E�X[S�WXEXI�VIWSPYXMSR EPSRK�XLI�PMRIW�TVSTSWIH�F]

XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�MR������SV�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�MR�������ERH�MQQI�HMEXIP]�EGGITXIH�F]�-WVEIP [EW�XLYW�GEXIKSVMGEPP]�VINIGXIH�F]�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW��[LS�HIQERHIH�XSXEP�GSRXVSP�SZIV�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�HIWTMXI�XLIMVFIMRK�SR�XLI�PSWMRK�WMHI�SJ�JSYV�[EVW�SJ�EKKVIWWMSR��;SVPH�;EVW�-�ERH�--�XLI�����§�����[EV�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP��ERH�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV ��%FFE�)FER��XLIJSVIMKR�QMRMWXIV�SJ�-WVEIP��SFWIVZIH�XLEX�XLMW�[EW�©XLI�JMVWX�[EV�MR�LMWXSV][LMGL�LEW�IRHIH�[MXL�XLI�ZMGXSVW�WYMRK�JSV�TIEGI�ERH�XLI�ZERUYMWLIH�GEPP�MRK�JSV�YRGSRHMXMSREP�WYVVIRHIV�ª�-RHIIH��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�HIQERH�MRK�QSVI�XLER�-WVEIP¬W�WYVVIRHIV�EW�E�REXMSR�8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�'LEVXIV�EPWS�HIQERHIH�XLI�XVERWJIVSYX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�SJ

IZIV]�.I[��I\GITX�XLSWI�©.I[W�[LS�LEH�RSVQEPP]�VIWMHIH�MR�4EPIWXMRI�YRXMPXLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�>MSRMWX�MRZEWMSR�ª�-R�XLI�ZMI[�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 108: The Case For Israel

WMRGI�XLI�>MSRMWX�MRZEWMSR�LEH�FIKYR�QER]�]IEVW�IEVPMIV EX�XLI�PEXIWX�MR�����ERH�EX�XLI�IEVPMIWX�MR����� XLMW�JSVQYPEXMSR�[SYPH�VIUYMVI�XLIXVERWJIV�SJ�QMPPMSRW�SJ�.I[W�[LSWI�TEVIRXW�ERH�KVERHTEVIRXW�LEH�PMZIH�MR[LEX�[EW�RS[�-WVEIP�JSV�KIRIVEXMSRW�ERH�MR�QER]�MRWXERGIW�JSV�E�QYGLPSRKIV�XMQI�XLER�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�[SYPH�HMWTPEGI�XLIQ�7MRGI�.SVHER��JVSQ�[LSQ�-WVEIP�LEH�GETXYVIH�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�MR�E

HIJIRWMZI�[EV��WYFWIUYIRXP]�VIRSYRGIH�EPP�GPEMQW�XS�XLEX�XIVVMXSV]�MR�JEZSVSJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��ERH�WMRGI�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�VINIGXIHTIEGI�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��EW�GSRXVEWXIH�[MXL�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�MRGPYHMRK�-WVEIP ��E�WXEPIQEXI�[EW�EWWYVIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�'LEVXIV��8LIVI[EW�RS�IRXMX]�XS�[LMGL�-WVEIP�GSYPH�VIXYVR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�MR�GSQTPMERGI[MXL�6IWSPYXMSR������IZIR�MJ�MX�[IVI�WS�MRGPMRIH��WS�PSRK�EW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERWVIJYWIH�XS�GSQTP]�[MXL�TVMRGMTPI�--�SJ�6IWSPYXMSR�����XLEX�VIUYMVIH�©XIV�QMREXMSR�SJ�EPP�GPEMQW�SV�WXEXIW�SJ�FIPPMKIVIRG]ª�ERH�VIGSKRMXMSR�SJ-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�©WSZIVIMKRX]��XIVVMXSVMEP�MRXIKVMX]�ERH�TSPMXMGEP�MRHITIRH�IRGI�ª�%PSRK�[MXL�QSWX�%VEF�REXMSRW��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VINIGXIH�6IWSPYXMSR�����[LMPI�-WVEIP�EGGITXIH�MX��EW�MX�LEH�XLI�4IIP�6ITSVXERH�XLI�9�2��TEVXM�XMSR��3RGI�EKEMR��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�%VEFW�VINIGXIH�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPY�XMSR��[LMPI�-WVEIP�MRHMGEXIH�E�[MPPMRKRIWW�XS�XEOI�WXITW�XLEX�[SYPH�LEZI�PIHXS�WYGL�E�WSPYXMSR��2SX[MXLWXERHMRK�XLMW�LMWXSVMGEP�VIEPMX]��ERXM�-WVEIP�EGE�HIQMGW�WYGL�EW�2SEQ�'LSQWO]�QMWPIEH�XLIMV�WXYHIRXW�F]�XIPPMRK�XLIQ�XLEX-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�EVI�©VINIGXMSRMWXª�WXEXIW�XLEX�LEZI�EP[E]WSTTSWIH�E�TSPMXMGEP�GSQTVSQMWI��[LMPI�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�ERH�XLI�403�LEZIEGGITXIH�MX��

8LIVI�[IVI��SJ�GSYVWI��YRMPEXIVEP�EGXMSRW�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�GSYPHLEZI��ERH�MR�Q]�ZMI[�WLSYPH�LEZI��XEOIR�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�ZMGXSV]�MR�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV�ERH�XLI�GETXYVI�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT��IZIRXLSYKL�WYGL�YRMPEXIVEP�EGXMSR�[EW�MR�RS�[E]�VIUYMVIH�F]�6IWSPYXMSR����YRPIWW�MX�[EW�EGGSQTERMIH�F]�TIEGI�ERH�VIGSKRMXMSR�JVSQ�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW��-�TSWXTSRI�ER]�HMWGYWWMSR�SJ�XLI�7MREM�EX�XLMW�TSMRX��FIGEYWI�-WVEIP�IZIR�XYEPP]�KEZI�XLEX�XIVVMXSV]�FEGO�XS�)K]TX�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�TIEGI� �-WVEIPGSYPH�LEZI��ERH�WLSYPH�LEZI��MQTPIQIRXIH�XLI�WS�GEPPIH�%PSR�4PER�SVWSQI�ZEVMERX�XLIVISJ��8LI�%PSR�4PER��TVSTSWIH�F]�-WVEIPM�KIRIVEP�=MKEP%PSR��[LS�[EW�XLIR�PEFSV�QMRMWXIV�ERH�E�OI]�EHZMWIV�XS�XLI�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�GSRXIQTPEXIH�-WVEIPM�[MXLHVE[EP�JVSQ�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�SJ�XLI�;IWX&ERO�ERH�JVSQ�EPP�SXLIV�GETXYVIH�XIVVMXSVMIW�I\GITX�JSV�WSQI�YRTSTYPEXIHEVIEW�XLEX�[IVI�HIIQIH�RIGIWWEV]�XS�EWWYVI�-WVEIP¬W�©XIVVMXSVMEP�MRXIKVMX]ª[MXLMR�©WIGYVIª�FSYRHEVMIW��EW�GSRXIQTPEXIH�F]�6IWSPYXMSR������%PSR¬WTPER��YRPMOI�6IWSPYXMSR������HVI[�ER�MQTSVXERX�HMWXMRGXMSR�FIX[IIR�SGGY�T]MRKXIVVMXSV]ERH�SGGYT]MRK�TSTYPEXMSRW�8LI�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�VIWSPYXMSR�JSGYWIH�I\GPYWMZIP]�SR�XIVVMXSVMIW

VEXLIV�XLER�TISTPI��&YX�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�GSQTVMWIW�GMXMIW��XS[RW��ERH�ZMP�PEKIW��EW�[IPP�EW�ZEWX�I\TERWIW�SJ�YRTSTYPEXIH�PERH��8LI�%PSR�4PER�[SYPH

�� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 109: The Case For Israel

LEZI�MQTPIQIRXIH�E�©XIVVMXSVMEP�GSQTVSQMWIª�YRHIV�[LMGL�-WVEIP�[SYPH©VIXEMR�E�WM\§WIZIR�QMPI�HIIT�WXVMT�EPSRK�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�SJ�XLI�.SVHER6MZIVª�EW�E�©WIGYVMX]�FIPX�ª�-X�[SYPH�EPWS�LEZI�QEHI�WSQI�SXLIV�QMRSVFSVHIV�EHNYWXQIRXW�SR�XLI�VSEH�XS�.IVYWEPIQ�WS�EW�RSX�XS�VIXYVR�XS�[LEX%FFE�)FER��E�QENSV�HSZI��LEH�GEPPIH�©XLI�%YWGL[MX�PMRIWª�XLEX�I\TSWIH-WVEIPM�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�XS�KVEZI�VMWOW�%PXLSYKL�MR������-WVEIP�LEH�RS�TIEGI�TEVXRIVW�[LS�[IVI�[MPPMRK�XS

KMZI�TIEGI�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�XIVVMXSV]��MX�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�[MWIV��MR�Q]�ZMI[�JSV�-WVEIP�XS�LEZI�[MXLHVE[R��YRMPEXIVEPP]�MJ�RIGIWWEV]��JVSQ�4EPIWXMRMERTSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�WYGL�EW�2EFPYW��6EQEPPEL��.IVMGLS��,IFVSR��.IRMR�&IXLPILIQ��ERH�8YPOEVQ��[LMPI�QEMRXEMRMRK�GSRXVSP�SZIV�PEVKIP]�YRTSTY�PEXIH�WIGYVMX]�EVIEW��-J�-WVEIP�LEH�XEOIR�XLEX�GSYVWI��MXW�WSPHMIVW�[SYPH�RSXLEZI�FIGSQI�ER�EVQ]�SJ�SGGYTEXMSR�SZIV�TISTPI��8LI�%VEFW�[SYPH�WXMPPGSQTPEMR�XLEX�XLIMV�PERH�[EW�FIMRK�SGGYTMIH��FYX�6IWSPYXMSR�����GSR�XIQTPEXIH�XIVVMXSVMEP�EHNYWXQIRXW�HIWMKRIH�XS�EGLMIZI�WIGYVI�FSVHIVW©JVII�JVSQ�XLVIEXW�SV�EGXW�SJ�[EV�ª�1SVISZIV��XLI�%VEFW�[SYPH�LEZI�GSQ�TPEMRIH�XLEX�XLIMV�PERH�[EW�FIMRK�SGGYTMIH�IZIR�MJ�-WVEIP�XYVRIH�SZIV�IZIV]MRGL�SJ�XIVVMXSV]�GETXYVIH�MR�XLI������[EV�WS�PSRK�EW�-WVEIP�GSRXMRYIH�XSSGGYT]�XLI�.I[MWL�GMX]�SJ�8IP�%ZMZ�SV�ER]�SXLIV�EVIE�SJ�[LEX�LEH�SRGI�FIIR4EPIWXMRI�SV�WSYXLIVR�7]VME�YRHIV�XLI�&VMXMWL�QERHEXI�-RWXIEH�SJ�YRMPEXIVEPP]�[MXLHVE[MRK�JVSQ�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�

-WVEIP�QEMRXEMRIH�GSRXVSP�SZIV�XLI�IRXMVI�;IWX�&ERO��XVIEXMRK�MX�EW�E�FEV�KEMRMRK�GLMT�JSV�TIEGI�[MXL�.SVHER��&YX�.SVHER�LEH�RS�MRXIVIWX�MR�QEOMRKTIEGI�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�E�VIXYVR�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��TIVLETW�FIGEYWI�MX�HMHRSX�[ERX�XS�VIEWWYQI�GSRXVSP�SZIV�QSVI�XLER���������4EPIWXMRMERW��[LSQMKLX�HIWXEFMPMI�E�WLEO]�,EWLIQMXI�VIKMQI��[LMGL�EPVIEH]�LEH�E�QENSVMX]4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�MR�.SVHER�TVSTIV��*SV�[LEXIZIV�VIEWSR��-WVEIPEWWYQIH�GSRXVSP�SZIV�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�JSV����]IEVW JVSQ.YRI������YRXMP�(IGIQFIV�������[LIR�-WVEIP�XYVRIH�XLIWI�GMXMIW�SZIV�XSXLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��TYVWYERX�XS�XLI�3WPS�--�%KVIIQIRX�8LI�X[IRX]�IMKLX�]IEV�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLIWI�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�GSR�

XVMFYXIH�XS�QER]�SJ�XLI�JEGXSVW�XLEX�RS[�QEOI�TIEGI�QSVI�HMJJMGYPX�XSEGLMIZI��8LIVI�MW��LS[IZIV��RS�EWWYVERGI�XLEX�MJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSRGIRXIVW�LEH�RSX�FIIR�SGGYTMIH�F]�-WVEIP��TIEGI�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�EGLMIZIH�WMRGI�XLI�IRHMRK�SJ�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLIWI�GIRXIVW�FIX[IIR������ERH�����HMH�RSX�FVMRK�XLI�VIKMSR�QYGL�GPSWIV�XS�TIEGI��2SV�[EW�XLIVI�TIEGI�FIX[IIR������ERH����� E�TIVMSH�HYVMRK�[LMGL�XLIVI�[EW�RS-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�8LI�SGGYTEXMSR�GIVXEMRP]�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�ER�MRGVIEWI�MR�XLI�RYQFIV�ERH

PIXLEPMX]�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�F]�4EPIWXMRMERW��XLSYKL�XIVVSVMWQ�LEH�FIIRVEQTERX�WMRGI�XLI�����W��ERH�XLI�403��[LMGL�[EW�GSQQMXXIH�XS�XIVVSVMWQEW�XLI�TVMQEV]�QIERW�JSV�PMFIVEXMRK�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��LEH�FIIR�IWXEFPMWLIHFIJSVI�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�FIKER�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ��

Page 110: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV�[EW�-WVEIP¬W�JEYPX�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LI�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�RI[�QMPMXEV]�JPEVI�YT�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�PMIW[LSPP]�ERH�GSQTPIXIP]�[MXL�XLI�8IP�%ZMZ�PIEHIVW��������-WVEIP�GSRXMRYIW�MXWEKKVIWWMSR�WXEVXIH�MR������EKEMRWX�XLI�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW�ª��7SZMIX�KIRIVEPWIGVIXEV]�0ISRMH�-��&VILRIZ��3GXSFIV����������

©3YV�ZMGXSV]�MR�XLI�[EV�WLEXXIVIH�JSVIZIV�XLI�MPPYWMSR�SJ�SYV�RIMKL�FSYVW¬�MRZMRGMFPI�QMPMXEV]�TVS[IWW��;I�LEH�TVSZIR�SYVWIPZIW�XLIMV�IUYEPW�FSXL�MRXIPPIGXYEPP]�ERH�TVEGXMGEPP]��2S�PSRKIV�GSYPH�XLI�VMKLXW�ERH�HYXMIW�SJXLI�%VEFW��ERH�SJ�XLI�MRHMZMHYEP�%VEF��FI�QSGOIH�ERH�HIVMHIH��8LI�3GXS�FIV�;EV�WTIPPIH�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�VEGMWX�XLISV]�SJ�XLI�MRLIVIRX�WYTIVMSVMX]�SJXLI�-WVEIPM�TISTPI�ª��3WEQE�)P�&E��)K]TXMER�REXMSREP�WIGYVMX]�EHZMWIV�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�YRTVSZSOIH�EXXEGO�SR�-WVEIP�[EW�YRNYWXMJMIH�ERH�MR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�XLI9�2��GLEVXIV�

���

;EW�XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV;EV�-WVEIPtW�*EYPX#

��

Page 111: The Case For Israel

8,)�4633*

-R�3GXSFIV�������)K]TX�ERH�7]VME�PEYRGLIH�WYVTVMWI�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPSR�=SQ�/MTTYV��XLI�LSPMIWX�HE]�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�]IEV��8LI�EXXEGOW�EPWS�XSSOTPEGI�HYVMRK�6EQEHER��E�TIVMSH�[LIR�1YWPMQ�PIEHIVW�SJXIR�GPEMQ�ER�EXXEGOSRXLIQ[SYPH�ZMSPEXI�VIPMKMSYW�TVMRGMTPIW�ERH�WLS[�HMWVIWTIGX�JSV�-WPEQ��2SSRI�HMWTYXIW�XLEX�XLI�)K]TXMERW�ERH�7]VMERW��[LS�MRJPMGXIH�GSRWMHIVEFPIGEWYEPXMIW�SR�XLI�-WVEIPMW��WXEVXIH�XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV��8LIMV�KSEP�[EW�XSVIGSZIV�XLI�PERH�PSWX�XS�-WVEIP�JVSQ�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV XLI�[EV�XLI�)K]TXMERWWXEVXIH��HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�XLI�-WVEIPMW�JMVIH�XLI�JMVWX�WLSX��-R�XLI�IRH��XLI)K]TXMERW�EGGSQTPMWLIH�XLEX�KSEP�ERH�VIGSZIVIH�XLI�IRXMVI�7MREM�EJXIV�QEO�MRK�E�GSPH�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP��8LI�7]VMERW�JEMPIH�MR�XLIMV�IJJSVX�XS�VIKEMR�XLI+SPER�,IMKLXW�FIGEYWI�XLI]�VIJYWIH�XS�QEOI�ER]�OMRH�SJ�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP�

-WVEIP�PIEVRIH�WSQI�MQTSVXERX�PIWWSRW�JVSQ�XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV��*MVWXERH�JSVIQSWX��MX�PIEVRIH�LS[�ZYPRIVEFPI�MX�[EW�XS�E�WYVTVMWI�EXXEGO��IZIR[MXL�I\TERHIH�FSVHIVW��-R�TVITEVEXMSR�JSV�MXW�EXXEGO��)K]TX�LEH�SFXEMRIHPEVKI�UYERXMXMIW�SJ�7GYH�QMWWMPIW�XLEX�©GSYPH�VIEGL�-WVEIP¬W�TSTYPEXMSRGIRXIVW�ª�%KEMR��XLI�%VEF�KSEP�[EW�XS�OMPP�EW�QER]�GMZMPMERW�EW�TSWWMFPI�HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�HIPMFIVEXIP]�EXXEGOMRK�GMZMPMER�XEVKIXW�MW�E�[EV�GVMQIERH�E�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��)K]TX¬W�MRMXMEP�EWWEYPX�MRGPYHIH�EREXXIQTX�XS�HVST�FSQFW�SR�8IP�%ZMZ��[LMGL�[EW�TVIZIRXIH�F]�-WVEIPM�EMVJSVGI�MRXIVGITXSVW��

8LI�7]VMER�EXXEGO�EPWS�XEVKIXIH�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMER�WIXXPIQIRXW��ERH�7]VMERXERO�JSVGIW�EPQSWX�WYGGIIHIH�MR�FVIEOMRK�XLVSYKL�-WVEIP¬W�XLMR�HIJIRWI�PMRIXLEX�TVSXIGXIH�MXW�RSVXLIVR�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW��%W�XLI�GSQQERHIV�SJ�XLIYRMX�MR�GLEVKI�SJ�HIJIRHMRK�-WVEIP¬W�RSVXLIVR�XS[RW�ERH�ZMPPEKIW�PEXIV�XSPHXLI�%KVEREX�'SQQMWWMSR�XLEX�[EW�WIX�YT�XS�MRZIWXMKEXI�XLI�RIEV�HMWEWXIV�©8LI�JIIPMRK�[EW�XLEX�XLIVI�[EW�KSMRK�XS�FI�E�LSPSGEYWX�ª�)ZIV]SRI�ORI[[LEX�7]VMER�WSPHMIVW�[SYPH�HS�XS�GETXYVIH�GMZMPMERW��WMRGI�XLI]�LEH�TVIZM�SYWP]�QYVHIVIH�ERH�QYXMPEXIH�GETXYVIH�-WVEIPMW�

3R�XLI�)K]TXMER�JVSRX�EW�[IPP��XLIVI�[EW�E�KIRYMRI�JIEV�SJ�E�KIRSGMHEPVIWYPX��1SWLI�(E]ER��-WVEIP¬W�HIJIRWI�QMRMWXIV��WIRX�E�QIWWEKI�XS�XLIGSQQERHIV�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�EMV�JSVGI�XLEX�©XLI�8LMVH�8IQTPIª LMW�GSHI�JSVXLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP ©MW�MR�HERKIV�ª�(E]ER�WYKKIWXIH�QSFMPMMRK�LMKLWGLSSP�WXYHIRXW�ERH�TISTPI�[LS�[IVI�XSS�SPH�JSV�VIWIVZI�HYX]��

%KEMR�MX�[EW�FVSYKLX�LSQI�XS�-WVEIP�XLEX�MXW�%VEF�IRIQMIW�GSYPH�EJJSVHXS�PSWI�[EV�EJXIV�[EV�[MXL�RS�XLVIEX�XS�XLIMV�I\MWXIRGI�ERH�RS�HERKIV�XSXLIMV�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSRW��&YX�MJ�-WVEIP�PSWX�IZIR�E�WMRKPI�[EV��MX�GSYPH�QIERXLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��E�QEWWEGVI�SJ�MXW�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR��ERH�XLIXVERWJIV�SJ�WYVZMZMRK�VIJYKIIW�SYX�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]��4IVLETW�MX�LEW�FIIR�XLMWVIEPMX]�XLEX�LEW�QSXMZEXIH�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�XS�JMKLX�WS�JMIVGIP]�MR�HIJIRWI�SJXLIMV�GSYRXV]��;LEX�1SVVMW�LEH�WEMH�EFSYX�XLI�QSXMZEXMSRW�ERH�MRGIRXMZIWSJ�-WVEIPM�JMKLXIVW�HYVMRK�XLI�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI�[EW�IUYEPP]�XVYI�HYVMRK

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 112: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV��8LI]�[IVI�JMKLXMRK�©MR�HIJIRWI�SJ�?XLIMVA�PSZIHSRIWª�[LS�©JEGIH�WPEYKLXIV�WLSYPH�XLI]�FI�HIJIEXIH�ª�

-WVEIP�YPXMQEXIP]�TVIZEMPIH�MR�XLI�[EV�FYX�[MXL�IRSVQSYW�GEWYEPXMIW�6IQEVOEFP]��XLI�)K]TXMERW�ERH�XLI�7]VMERW��HIWTMXI�XLIMV�IZIRXYEP�HIJIEX�VIKEVHIH�ERH�WXMPP�VIKEVH�XLI�6EQEHER�;EV��EW�XLI]�GEPP�[LEX�XLI�-WVEIPMWGEPP�XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV �EW�E�ZMGXSV]��-R�E�WTIIGL�SR�3GXSFIV����������)K]TXMER�TVIWMHIRX�%R[EV�7EHEX�XSPH�LMW�TISTPI��©8LI�)K]TXMER�EVQIHJSVGIW�LEZI�EGLMIZIH�E�QMVEGPI�F]�ER]�QMPMXEV]�WXERHEVH��������?8ALIWI�JSVGIWXSSO�XLI�MRMXMEXMZI��WYVTVMWIH�XLI�IRIQ]�ERH�XLVI[�LMQ�SJJ�FEPERGI�ª�)K]TXLEW�©VIWXSVIH�MXW�LSRSV�ª�7MQMPEVP]��4VIWMHIRX�,EJM�EP�%WWEH�XSPH�LMW�TIS�TPI�XLEX�7]VME�LEH�©XVERWJSVQIH�-WVEIP¬W�EKKVIWWMSR��WMRGI��XL�3GXSFIV��XSE�VIXVIEX�SJ�XLI�IRIQ]�JSVGIWª�ERH�©MRJPMGXIH�SR�XLI�IRIQ]�PSWWIW�[LMGLHIITP]�WLSSO�XLI�>MSRMWX�IRXMX]�ª�,I�XSPH�XLI�7]VMER�TISTPI�LS[�XLI�©JIVS�GMSYW�FEXXPIW�[EKIH�F]�SYV�%VEF�JSVGIWª�LEZI�©VIWXSVIH�WIPJ�GSRJMHIRGI�XSXLI�%VEF�MRHMZMHYEP�ª�8SXLMW�HE]��XLI�%VEF�ZMGXSV]�MW�GIPIFVEXIH�MR�)K]TXERH�7]VME��HIWTMXI�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�XLIMV�EVQMIW�[IVI�WEZIH�F]�E�GIEWI�JMVIMQTSWIH�SR�-WVEIP�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�XLI�7SZMIX�9RMSR�

1SVVMW�LEW�HIWGVMFIH�7EHEX¬W�ERH�%WWEH¬W�QSXMZIW�JSV�EXXEGOMRK�-WVEIP�

*SV�FSXL�7EHEX�ERH�%WWEH��XLI�[EV�TVSQMWIH�QENSV�KEMRW��FIKMRRMRK�[MXL

E�VIWXSVEXMSR�SJ�%VEF�TVMHI���%JXIV�XLI�[EV�%VEF�GLVSRMGPIVW�[SYPH�IZIR

WTIEO�SJ�©XLI�VIFMVXLª�SJ�©)K]TXMER�QER�ª �1IVIP]�HEVMRK�XS�KS�XS�[EV

EKEMRWX�XLI�MRZMRGMFPI�-(*�[SYPH�FI�WIIR�EW�TVSJSYRHP]�GSYVEKISYW��[MT�

MRK�SYX�XLI�WLEQI�SJ�������MRHIIH�XLI�WLEQI�SJ�%VEF�LMWXSV]�WMRGI������

[SYPH�FVMRK�FSXL�VIKMQIW�VI[EVHW�MR�XIVQW�SJ�TSTYPEVMX]��PIKMXMQEG]��ERH

PSRKIZMX]��EW�[IPP�EW�PEVKI�GSRXVMFYXMSRW�JVSQ�XLI�SMP�OMRKHSQW���

-WVEIP�PIEVRIH�ERSXLIV�MQTSVXERX�PIWWSR�JVSQ�XLMW�HMWTEVMX]�MR�HIJMRMRKZMGXSV]�MR�[EV��ER]�%VEF�PIEHIV�[LS�GER�MRJPMGX�WIVMSYW�HEQEKI�SR�-WVEIP�MWQSXMZEXIH�XS�HS�WS��IZIR�MJ�LMW�REXMSR�[MPP�YPXMQEXIP]�PSWI�XLI�[EV��8LMW�MWXLI�WEH�VIEPMX]�JSV�E�GSYTPI�SJ�VIEWSRW��*MVWX��XLI�WXEOIW�EVI�JEV�PS[IV�JSV%VEF�GSYRXVMIW�XLEX�PSWI�[EVW�[MXL�-WVEIP��8LI]�QE]�PSWI�WSQI�XIVVMXSV]�[LMGL�XLI]�GER�KIX�FEGO�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�SJJIVMRK�TIEGI �ERH�WSQI�WSP�HMIVW��FYX�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�XLIMV�REXMSR�ERH�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�XLIMV�GMZMPMERW�EVIRSX�EX�WXEOI��7IGSRH��ER]�%VEF�PIEHIV�[LS�LEW�IZIR�XLI�WPMKLXIWX�TSWWMFMP�MX]�SJ�HIJIEXMRK�-WVEIP�[MPP�FI�TVEMWIH�ERH�VI[EVHIH�JSV�XV]MRK��ERH�GSR�HIQRIH��TIVLETW�IZIR�SZIVXLVS[R��JSV�RSX�XV]MRK��8LMW�MW�[L]�MX�MW�WSMQTSVXERX�JSV�XLI�TVIWIVZEXMSR�SJ�TIEGI�XLEX�-WVEIP�VIQEMRW�UYEPMXEXMZIP]WXVSRKIV�QMPMXEVMP]�XLER�EPP�XLI�GSQFMRIH�%VEF�EVQMIW�XLEX�WYVVSYRH�MX��-JXLEX�QMPMXEV]�WYTIVMSVMX]�[IVI�IZIV�XS�FI�PSWX��MX�MW�ZMVXYEPP]�GIVXEMR�XLEX-WVEIP�[SYPH�EKEMR�FI�EXXEGOIH��8LEX�MW�[L]�2IPWSR�1ERHIPE�[EW�[VSRK�MRWYKKIWXMRK�ER]�EREPSK]�FIX[IIR�-WVEIP¬W�HIJIRWMZI�RYGPIEV�TVSKVEQ�ERH-VEU¬W�IJJSVXW�XS�HIZIPST�[IETSRW�SJ�QEWW�HIWXVYGXMSR�JSV�EKKVIWWMZI�YWI�

Page 113: The Case For Israel

8LMW�MW�[LEX�1ERHIPE�WEMH��©&YX�[LEX�[I�ORS[�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�[IETSRWSJ�QEWW�HIWXVYGXMSR��2SFSH]�XEPOW�EFSYX�XLEX��;L]�WLSYPH�XLIVI�FI�SRIWXERHEVH�JSV�SRI�GSYRXV]��IWTIGMEPP]�FIGEYWI�MX�MW�FPEGO��ERH�ERSXLIV�SRIJSV�ERSXLIV�GSYRXV]��-WVEIP��FIGEYWI�MX�MW�[LMXI�ª��

-WVEIP�LEW�LEH�RYGPIEV�[IETSRW�WMRGI�XLI�����W��-X�LEW�RIZIV�YWIH�XLIQ�IZIR�HYVMRK�XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV��-X�LEW�FIIR�WEMH�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�RYGPIEVGETEGMX]�XLEX�MX�[MPP�TVSFEFP]�RIZIV�FI�YWIH�FIGEYWI�MX�GSYPH�SRP]�FI�YWIHXSS�IEVP]�SV�XSS�PEXI��-J�-WVEIP�IZIV�IQTPS]IH�RYGPIEV�[IETSRW�XS�TVIZIRX�EHMWEWXIV��MX�[SYPH�FI�YRMZIVWEPP]�GSRHIQRIH��-J�MX�[EMXIH�XS�YWI�XLIQ�YRXMPEJXIV�E�HMWEWXIV��MX�[SYPH�FI�XSS�PEXI��-WVEIP¬W�RYGPIEV�EVWIREP�MW�XLI�YPXMQEXIHIXIVVIRX�EKEMRWX�E�VEHMGEP�VIKMQI�XLEX�QMKLX�WIIO�XS�TVSHYGI�%VQEKIHHSR�[LMGL�MW�PMXIVEPP]�E�WQEPP�ZMPPEKI�MR�-WVEIP�GEPPIH�1IKKMHS ��8LI�HERKIV�MWXLEX�XLIVI�QE]�FI�WSQI�VEHMGEP�-WPEQMG�PIEHIVW�QSVI�JSGYWIH�SR�XLI�RI\X[SVPH�XLER�XLMW�SRI�[LS�QE]�RSX�FI�HIXIVVIH�IZIR�F]�XLI�TVSWTIGX�SJQYXYEP�RYGPIEV�HIZEWXEXMSR�

7EHEX�EGLMIZIH�FSXL�SJ�LMW�KSEPW�MR�EXXEGOMRK�-WVEIP�SR�=SQ�/MTTYV�SJ������-R�EHHMXMSR�XS�VIWXSVMRK�)K]TXMER�LSRSV��LI�EPWS�VIWXSVIH�XLI�IRXMVI7MREM�XS�)K]TXMER�GSRXVSP��%W�WSSR�EW�7EHEX�GSYVEKISYWP]�MRHMGEXIH�E�[MPP�MRKRIWW�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�XLI�7MREM��XLI�-WVEIPMKSZIVRQIRX��XLIR�YRHIV�XLI�GSRXVSP�SJ�XLI�LE[OMWL�0MOYH�4EVX]�ERH�MXWXSYKL�XEPOMRK�PIEHIV��1IREGLIQ�&IKMR��YTVSSXIH�XLI�.I[MWL�WIXXPIVW�MRXLI�7MREM�ERH�VIXYVRIH�MX��SMP�JMIPHW�ERH�EPP��XS�)K]TX��8LI�HIGMWMSR�XS�QEOITIEGI��IZIR�E�GSPH�TIEGI�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�XLI�WXVEXIKMGEPP]�ERH�QMRIVEPP]ZEPYEFPI�7MREM��QE]�LEZI�GSWX�7EHEX�LMW�PMJI EW�.SVHER¬W�/MRK�%FHYPPEL¬WHIGMWMSR�XS�IZIR�GSRWMHIV�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP�GSWX�LMQ�LMW�PMJI�E�UYEVXIV�GIRXYV]�IEVPMIV��&YX�MX�TEZIH�XLI�[E]�JSV�.SVHER¬W�/MRK�,YWWIMR��%FHYP�PEL¬W�KVERHWSR��XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP�

7MRGI�.SVHER�LEH�VIRSYRGIH�EPP�GPEMQW�XS�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�MR�JEZSV�SJ�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��XLIVI�[EW�RS�PERH�XLEX�-WVEIP�GSYPH�I\GLERKI�JSVTIEGI���%GXYEPP]��-WVEIP�HMH�VIXYVR�E�WQEPP�WXVMT�SJ�EFSYX�����WUYEVI�OMPS�QIXIVW�MR�XLI�%VEZE� �,EH�.SVHER�[ERXIH�E�VIXYVR�XS�XLI�WXEXYW�UYS�FIJSVIXLI������[EV��MX�MW�PMOIP]�-WVEIP�[SYPH�LEZI�[IPGSQIH�WYGL�E�VIXYVR��TIV�LETW�[MXL�WSQI�WQEPP�XIVVMXSVMEP�EHNYWXQIRXW��&YX�XLI�PEWX�XLMRK�.SVHER[ERXIH�MR������[EW�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�QMPPMSRW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLIRPMZMRK�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��IWTIGMEPP]�EJXIV�XLI�EFSVXIH�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMP�[EVPIH�F]�XLI�403�EKEMRWX�/MRK�,YWWIMR�MR������

-WVEIP�VITIEXIHP]�XVMIH�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[MXL�7]VME�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�XIVVM�XSV]�MX�GETXYVIH�HYVMRK�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV��EW�1SVVMW�VITSVXW��©-R�%YKYWX�����E�QENSV�FVIEOXLVSYKL�[EW�EGLMIZIH�[LIR�6EFMR�KEZI�7IGVIXEV]�SJ7XEXI�'LVMWXSTLIV�LMW�«L]TSXLIXMGEP¬�EKVIIQIRX�XS�-WVEIPM�[MXLHVE[EP�JVSQXLI�[LSPI�SJ�XLI�+SPER�,IMKLXW��WLSYPH�7]VME�VIGMTVSGEXI�[MXL�EHIUYEXIWIGYVMX]�EVVERKIQIRXW�ERH�RSVQEPMEXMSR�SJ�VIPEXMSRW�QIEWYVIW��,S[IZIV�XLI�7]VMERW�JEMPIH�XS�VIWTSRH�[MXL�WMQMPEV�PEVKIWWI�ª��

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 114: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

-R�VIGIRX�]IEVW��-WVEIP�LEW�QEHI�RS�WIVMSYW�IJJSVXW�EX�TIEGI�[MXL�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�

8,)�%''97)67

©&]�RS[�MX�LEW�FIGSQI�GPIEV�XLEX��FIGEYWI�;IWXIVR�EYHMIRGIW�EVI�WS�TSSVP]MRJSVQIH��-WVEIPM�TYFPMG�SJJMGMEPW�GER�WE]�ER]XLMRK��MRGPYHMRK�SYX�ERH�SYXPMIW��0EWX�[IIO�E�QENSV�XIPIZMWMSR�HIFEXI�MR�XLI�97�FIX[IIR�4%�1MRMWXIV2EFMP�7LEEXL�ERH�/RIWWIX�7TIEOIV�%ZVELEQ�&YVK�GSRJMVQIH�XLMW�WEH�JEGX��������&YVK�WEX�XLIVI�ERH�FVEIRP]�QERYJEGXYVIH�SRI�JEPWILSSH�EJXIVERSXLIV XLEX�EW�E�HIQSGVEX�ERH�E�TIEGI�PSZIV�LI�[EW�GSRGIVRIH�XLIVI�[EWRS�VIEP�4EPIWXMRMER�TIEGI�GEQT��XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�XV]MRK�IZIV�WS�LEVH�XS�VIQEMRGEPQ�[LMPI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW��IRGSYVEKIH�F]�XLI�%YXLSVMX] �XLVIEXIRIHLMW�HEYKLXIV��RS�PIWW��[MXL�FVYXEP�OMPPMRK��XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�EP[E]W�[ERXIH�TIEGI�������ERH�SR�ERH�SR��%PP�SJ�MX�QEOMRK�XLI�TSMRX��MR�XLI�WX]PI�SJ�GPEWWMGEP�TVST�EKERHE��XS�VITIEX�E�PMI�SJXIR�IRSYKL�MW�XS�FIPMIZI�MX ��XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�ZMGXMQMIHF]�4EPIWXMRMERW��XLEX�MX�[ERXW�TIEGI��ERH�XLEX�MX�MW�[EMXMRK�JSV�4EPIWXMRMERW�XSGEXGL�YT�[MXL�MXW�QEKRERMQMX]�ERH�VIWXVEMRX�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�

©8LI�PSRKIV�XLI�9�7��ERH�-WVEIP�VINIGX�E�TSPMXMGEP�WIXXPIQIRX��XLI�[SVWIMX¬W�KSMRK�XS�FI�ª��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�

���

,EW�-WVEIP�1EHI�7IVMSYW

)JJSVXW�EX�4IEGI#

��

Page 115: The Case For Israel

8,)�6)%0-8=

-WVEIP�LEW�SJJIVIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�IZIV]�VIEWSREFPI�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�QEOITIEGI��FYX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�VINIGXIH�IZIV]�WYGL�SJJIV��QSWX�VIGIRXP]�EX'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�MR�����§�����

8,)�4633*

-WVEIP�HMH�QEREKI�XS�QEOI�WSQI�LEPXMRK�TVSKVIWW�MR�TIEGI�XEPOW�[MXL�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�WXEVXMRK�MR�XLI�IEVP]�����W��)ZIR�FIJSVI�XLEX�XMQI��E�RYQFIVSJ�WIRMSV�*EXEL�JMKYVIW�LEH�FIIR�TVIEGLMRK�E�«X[S�WXEXI¬�WSPYXMSR��FYX�XLIWIMRHMZMHYEPW�LEH�I\TIVMIRGIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR [LEX�+ISVKI�&IVREVH�7LE[LEH�SRGI�GLEVEGXIVMIH�EW�©XLI�YPXMQEXI�JSVQ�SJ�GIRWSVWLMTª EX�XLI�LERHWSJ�SXLIV�4EPIWXMRMERW��*VSQ�MXW�JSYRHMRK�MR�������ERH�IZIR�FIJSVI ��XLI403��ERH�MXW�TVIHIGIWWSVW �LEH�VINIGXIH�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�MR�JEZSV�SJXIVVSVMWQ��XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP��ERH�XLI�XVERWJIV�SYX�SJ�XLI�.I[MWLTSTYPEXMSR�

4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�LEH��LS[IZIV��FIIR�UYMXI�WYGGIWWJYP�MR�FVMRKMRKXLI�KVMIZERGIW�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�XLI�EXXIRXMSR�SJ�XLI�[SVPH��%PXLSYKLXLI�4EPIWXMRMER�HIQERH�JSV�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�XVERWJIV�SJ�MXW.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR EW�EVXMGYPEXIH�MR�MXW�GSZIRERX MW�JEV�PIWW�GSQTIPPMRKJVSQ�E�QSVEP�TIVWTIGXMZI�XLER�XLI�GSQTPEMRXW�SJ�SXLIV�WXEXIPIWW�ERH�SGGY�TMIH�TISTPI��WYGL�EW�XLI�8MFIXERW��XLI�/YVHW��ERH�XLI�&EWUYIW��XLI�403¬WVIWSVX�XS�KPSFEP�XIVVSVMWQ�LEW�PIETJVSKKIH�4EPIWXMRMER�GPEMQW�SZIV�XLI�QSVIGSQTIPPMRK�GPEMQW�SJ�SXLIVW�

&IX[IIR������ERH�������4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�QYVHIVIH�XLSYWERHW�SJMRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW��MRGPYHMRK�MRXIVREXMSREP�XVEZIPIVW��.I[W�EX�TVE]IV�MR�W]RE�KSKYIW�XLVSYKLSYX�)YVSTI��3P]QTMG�EXLPIXIW��RYVWIV]�WGLSSP�GLMPHVIR�HMTPSQEXW��ERH�'LVMWXMER�TMPKVMQW��8LI]�FPI[�YT�EMVTPERIW��TPERXIH�FSQFWMR�WLSTTMRK�QEVOIXW��XLVI[�LERH�KVIREHIW�EX�GLMPHVIR��WIRX�PIXXIV�FSQFW�XSFYWMRIWWTISTPI��ERH�LMNEGOIH�E�GVYMWI�PMRIV��MRGPYHMRK�XLVS[MRK�E�[LIIPGLEMV�FSYRH�TEWWIRKIV�MRXS�XLI�WIE��%PXLSYKL�EPP�SJ�XLIWI�EGXMSRW�GSRWXMXYXI�[EVGVMQIW�ERH�ZMSPEXMSRW�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]ERH�IWTIGMEPP]�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW LEW�VITIEXIHP]�VI[EVHIH�4EPIWXMRMER�XIV�VSVMWQ�F]�EGGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�403�JEV�KVIEXIV�VIGSKRMXMSR�XLER�XLEX�EGGSVHIHXS�SXLIV�WXEXIPIWW�KVSYTW�XLEX�LEZI�RSX�VIWSVXIH�XS�KPSFEP�XIVVSVMWQ�

%W�XLI�GLEVX�XLEX�ETTIEVW�MR�Q]�FSSO�;L]�8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOWZMZMHP]HIQSRWXVEXIW��XLI�QSVI�ZMGMSYW��YRPE[JYP��ERH�PIXLEP�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSV�MWX�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�GMZMPMERW�FIGEQI��XLI�QSVI�HMTPSQEXMG�VIGSKRMXMSR�XLI]LEZI�FIIR�EGGSVHIH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��[LMGL�WMRKPIH�SYX�XLI�403JVSQ�EQSRK�EPP�SXLIV�VITVIWIRXEXMZIW�SJ�WXEXIPIWW�KVSYTW�JSV�WTIGMEP�SFWIVZIVWXEXYW�ERH�SXLIV�HMTPSQEXMG�TVMZMPIKIW��8LMW�[EW�HSRI�EX�E�XMQI�[LIR�XLI403�VINIGXIH�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��VINIGXIH�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�XLI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 116: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

9�2��QIQFIV�REXMSR�-WVEIP��VINIGXIH�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�6IWSPYXMSR�����ERH�HIQERHIH�GSRXVSP�SZIV�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�ERH�XLI�XVERWJIV�SJ�QSWX�.I[WSYX�SJ�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��2S�[SRHIV�XLI�403�QEMRXEMRIH�MXW�GIRXVEPVIPMERGI�SR�XIVVSVMWQ�EW�XLI�[E]�XS�EGLMIZI�MXW�HIQERHW��8IVVSVMWQ�[EW[SVOMRK�JSV�MX�RSX�SRP]�EX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�FYX�EPWS�MR�)YVSTIER�ERHSXLIV�GETMXEPW��MR�XLI�:EXMGER��ERH�EQSRK�WSQI�EGEHIQMGW�ERH�TYFPMG�STMR�MSR�QEOIVW�MR�QER]�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�

&YX�MX�[EW�RSX�[SVOMRK�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�VIKEVH�XS�-WVEIP�SV�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW��8IVVSVMWQ�LEH�SRP]�WXVIRKXLIRIH�XLI�VIWSPZI�SJ�XLIWI�X[SHIQSGVEGMIW�RSX�XS�VI[EVH�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�PIWX�MX�IRGSYV�EKI�QSVI�XS�VIWSVX�XS�XLMW�MQQSVEP�ERH�YRPE[JYP�XEGXMG��(IWTMXI�XLIMVHMTPSQEXMG�KEMRW�EX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�ERH�IPWI[LIVI��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW[IVI�RS�RIEVIV�XS�WXEXILSSH�SV�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR��-J�ER]XLMRK�-WVEIP�[EW�EPPS[MRK�QSVI�WIXXPIQIRXW�SR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�NYWXMJ]MRKXLIQ�SR�WIGYVMX]�KVSYRHW��XLSYKL�XLI�VIEPMX]�[EW�XLEX�QSWX�LEH�PMXXPI�XSHS�[MXL�WIGYVMX]��-RHIIH��MR�XLI�ZMI[�SJ�QSWX�-WVEIPMW��QER]�SJ�XLI�WIXXPI�QIRXW�LEH�ER�EHZIVWI�IJJIGX�SR�-WVEIPM�WIGYVMX]�

8LI�WMXYEXMSR��JSV�FSXL�-WVEIPMW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW��[EW�KVS[MRK�TVSKVIW�WMZIP]�[SVWI��IWTIGMEPP]�EJXIV�XLI�JMVWX�MRXMJEHE�FIKER�MR�XLI�PEXI�����W��VIWYPX�MRK�MR�MRGVIEWIH�ZMSPIRGI�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPMW�ERH�MRGVIEWIH�VIWXVMGXMSRW�SR4EPIWXMRMERW��-WPEQMG�JYRHEQIRXEPMWQ�[EW�KVS[MRK��ERH�,EQEW [LMGL�[EWQSVI�YRGSQTVSQMWMRK�MR�MXW�JYRHEQIRXEPMWX�IEP�FYX�PIWW�GSVVYTX�XLER�XLI403 [EW�MRGVIEWMRK�MXW�MRJPYIRGI�EQSRK�4EPIWXMRMER�1YWPMQW��-XW�GLEVXIV�EHSTXIH�MR�%YKYWX�������MW�IZIR�QSVI�I\XVIQMWX�ERH�SZIVXP]�ERXM�7IQMXMGXLER�XLI�403�GLEVXIV��-X�GEPPW�JSV�XLI�©VIMRWXMXYXMSR�SJ�XLI�1YWPMQ�WXEXIª�MR©IZIV]�MRGL�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�ª�ERH�XLI�VEMWMRK�SJ�XLI�©FERRIV�SJ�%PPELª�SZIV�EPPSJ�4EPIWXMRI��[LMGL�MX�HIWGVMFIH�EW�ER�©-WPEQMG�;EUJ�ª�-X�TVSGPEMQW�XLEX�ER]GSQTVSQMWI��IZIR�MJ�IZIV]�%VEF�ERH�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIV�[IVI�XS�EGGITX�MX�[SYPH�FI�MR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�-WPEQMG�PE[��%PP�TIEGI�MRMXMEXMZIW�SV�©WS�GEPPIHTIEGIJYP�WSPYXMSRW�EVI�GSRXVEV]�XS�XLI�FIPMIJW�SJ�XLI�-WPEQMG�6IWMWXERGI1SZIQIRX�ª�%RH�©VIRSYRGMRK�ER]�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�QIERW�VIRSYRGMRKTEVX�SJ�XLI�VIPMKMSR�ª�-X�TVSGPEMQW�XLEX�RIMXLIV�.I[W�RSV�'LVMWXMERW��[LS�MXGLEVEGXIVMIH�GSPPIGXMZIP]�EW�©XLI�YRFIPMIZIVW�ª�GER�FI�XVYWXIH��ERH�HIGPEVIW�©8LIVI�MW�RS�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TVSFPIQ�I\GITX�F]�.MLEH�ª

8LI�GLEVXIV�XLIR�FIGSQIW�SZIVXP]�ERH�GVYHIP]�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MR�HIWGVMF�MRK�XLI�©2EMWQ�SJ�XLI�.I[Wª�ERH�GPEMQMRK�XLEX�©-WVEIP��F]�ZMVXYI�SJ�MXWFIMRK�.I[MWL�ERH�LEZMRK�E�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSR��HIJMPIH�-WPEQ�ERH�XLI�1YW�PMQW�ª�-X�JEPWIP]�GPEMQW�XLEX�©[LIR�XLI�.I[W�SGGYTMIH�,SP]�.IVYWEPIQ�MR������������XLI]�WLSYXIH�[MXL�NS]��«1YLEQQEH�MW�HIEH��LI�PIJX�HEYKLXIVWFILMRH�¬ª�MQTP]MRK�XLEX�XLI�.I[W�[ERX�XS�VETI�1YWPMQ�[SQIR�ERH�KMVPW��-XXLIR�MRZSOIW�XLI�ERXM�7IQMXMG�GEVMWX�JSVKIV]��8LI�4VSXSGSPW�SJ�XLI�)PHIVW�SJ>MSR�ERH�EVKYIW�XLEX�XLIMV�©TVIWIRX�?GSRHYGXA�MW�XLI�FIWX�TVSSJ�SJ�[LEX�MWWEMH�XLIVI�?MR�XLI�4VSXSGSPWA�ª

Page 117: The Case For Israel

8LI�,EQEW�'LEVXIV�EPWS�FPEQIW�XLI�.I[W�JSV�XLI�*VIRGL�ERH�6YWWMER6IZSPYXMSRW��;SVPH�;EVW�-�ERH�--��ERH�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW©MR�SVHIV�XS�VYPI�SZIV�XLI�[SVPH�ª�'EPPMRK�XLI�EVVMZEP�SJ�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�MR4EPIWXMRI�©XLMW�HIWTMGEFPI�2EM§8EVXEV�MRZEWMSR�ª�XLI�GLEVXIV MR�E�FYVWX�SJMVVEXMSREPMX]�I\GIIHMRK�IZIR�XLEX�[LMGL�GEQI�TVIZMSYWP] GEWXW�WSQI�SJ�XLIFPEQI�SR�©XLI�*VIIQEWSRW��6SXEV]�'PYFW��0MSRW�'PYFW�?ERH�SXLIVA�WIGVIXSVKERMEXMSRW�?[LMGLA�EGX�JSV�XLI�MRXIVIWXW�SJ�>MSRMWQ�ERH�YRHIV�MXW�HMVIG�XMSRW��WXVMZI�XS�HIQSPMWL�WSGMIXMIWª�ERH�XS�HMWXVMFYXI�©HVYKW�ERH�XS\MGW�SJEPP�OMRHW�MR�SVHIV�XS�JEGMPMXEXI�MXW�GSRXVSP�ERH�I\TERWMSR�ª�8LI�GLEVXIV�IRHWF]�HIQERHMRK�XLEX�EPP�1YWPMQW�VIWMWX�XLMW�RI[�'VYWEHI�F]�©.I[W��XLI�QIV�GLERXW�SJ�[EV�ª�EW�XLI]�VIWMWXIH�XLI�'LVMWXMER�'VYWEHIW��(IWGVMFMRK.YHEMWQ�EW�E�©JEPWI�ERH�JEPWMJMIH�JEMXL�ª�MX�GSRJMHIRXP]�TVIHMGXW�ZMGXSV]�SZIVXLI�©2EM�>MSRMWXW�ª�

8LI�,EQEW�'LEVXIV�GSRHIQRIH�)K]TX�JSV�QEOMRK�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP�ERHGSRHIQRIH�XLI�403�JSV�©EHSTXMRK�WIGYPEV�XLSYKLXª�ERH�EHZSGEXMRK�WIGY�PEV�WSPYXMSRW��3RP]�E�TYVIP]�-WPEQMG�WXEXI��[MXL�RS�.I[W��ERH�EPP�'LVMWXMER%VEFW�MR�E�WYFSVHMREXI�WXEXYW��[SYPH�FI�EGGITXEFPI�XS�,EQEW��%�JI[�QSRXLWPEXIV��E�1YWPMQ�&VSXLIVLSSH�TEQTLPIX�GLEVEGXIVMIH�XLI�.I[W�EW�©XLI�HMVX�MIWX�ERH�QIERIWX�SJ�EPP�VEGIW�ª�ERH�,EQEW�LERHFMPPW�GEPPIH�©XLI�.I[W�FVSXL�IVW�SJ�XLI�ETIW��XLI�QYVHIVIVW�SJ�XLI�TVSTLIXW�ª�8LMW�OMRH�SJ�VEGMWX�VLIXSVMGEPWS�TIVQIEXIW�4EPIWXMRMER�WGLSSP�GYVVMGYPE�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH+EE��3RI�LMKL�WGLSSP�I\EQMREXMSR�EWOIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�UYIWXMSR��©)\TPEMRXLI�VIEWSRW�XLEX�QEHI�XLI�)YVSTIERW�TIVWIGYXI�XLI�.I[W�ª�8LI�ERW[IV��EWTVSZMHIH�MR�XLI�WGLSSPFSSO�XI\X��MRGPYHIH�XLI�©JEGXWª�XLEX�.I[W�EVI�©WIPJ�GIRXIVIH�ª�XLEX�XLIMV�8SVEL�TVSQSXIW�©VIPMKMSYW�ERH�VEGMEP�JEREXMGMWQ�?ERHAQEPMGI�XS[EVHW�SXLIV�REXMSRW�ª�XLEX�XLI]�LSPH�©ERXM�'LVMWXMER�FIPMIJWª�ERHGEYWI�©QEWWEGVIW�ª�XLEX�XLI]�GSRXVSP�XLI�©IGSRSQ]�ª�XLEX�XLI]�JIIP�©WYTI�VMSV�ª�EVI�©QSRI]�GLERKIVW�ª�ERH�GVYGMJMIH�.IWYW��8LI�XI\X�EPWS�XIPPW�XLI�WXY�HIRXW�RSX�XS�W]QTEXLMI�[MXL�.I[W�FIGEYWI�©TIVWIGYXMSR�?MWA�HIWMVIH�F]�XLI.I[Wª�WS�XLEX�MX�GER�FI�©I\TPSMXIH�JSV�XLI�VIEPMEXMSR�SJ�QEXIVMEP�������KEMRªERH�XS�LIPT�©>MSRMIª�XLI�.I[W�SJ�XLI�[SVPH��

2SX�WYVTVMWMRKP]��XLI�MRXMJEHE�XSSO�SR�ER�SZIVXP]�ERXM�7IQMXMG�XSRI��EWIZMHIRGIH�F]�XLI�[IIOP]�*VMHE]�WIVQSRW�MR�HIJIRWI�SJ�XLI�ZMSPIRGI�EMVIH�F]XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�QIHME��-X�EPWS�HMVIGXIH�I\XVIQI�ZMSPIRGI�EKEMRWX4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�[IVI�FIPMIZIH�XS�FI�GSSTIVEXMRK�[MXL�-WVEIP��1SVVMW[VMXIW��©&]�XLI�IRH�SJ�������EFSYX�RMRIX]�%VEFW�[LS�LEH�KMZIR�MRXIPPM�KIRGI�XS�XLI�-WVEIPMW�SV�LEH�LIPTIH�WIPP�XLIQ�PERH�LEH�FIIR�OMPPIH��QER]WEZEKIP]�XSVXYVIH�FIJSVI�FIMRK�HMWTEXGLIH�ª�&]�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�MRXMJEHE�MR������EPQSWX�����4EPIWXMRMERW�LEH�FIIR�QYVHIVIH�F]�SXLIV�4EPIWXMRMERWRIEVP]�EW�QER]�EW�LEH�FIIR�OMPPIH�F]�-WVEIPM�HIJIRWI�JSVGIW��-R�ER�MRGVIH�MFPI�HMWTPE]�SJ�GLYXTEL��WSQI�4EPIWXMRMER�WTSOIWQIR�GSYRXIH�XLIWIQYVHIVW�[LIR�TVSZMHMRK�XLI�QIHME�[MXL�E�PMWX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�OMPPIH�HYVMRKXLI�MRXMJEHE���

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 118: The Case For Israel

8LI�MRXMJEHE�TVSFEFP]�TYWLIH�FSXL�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�ERH�XLI403��[LMGL�[EW�PSWMRK�GSRXVSP�SZIV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WXVIIX�XS�QSVI�VEHMGEP-WPEQMG�KVSYTW �XS[EVH�WSQI�OMRH�SJ�VETTVSGLIQIRX��8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIWLEH�FIIR�KIRXP]�TYWLMRK�MR�XLMW�HMVIGXMSR�JSV�WIZIVEP�]IEVW��EW�LEH�WSQI-WVEIPM�HSZIW�

;LIR�XLI�3WPS�TIEGI�TVSGIWW�FIKER�MR�XLI�IEVP]�����W��-WVEIP�[EW�[MPP�MRK�XS�EGGITX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�EW�ER�IUYEP�RIKSXMEXMRK�TEVXRIV�WSPSRK�EW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�[EW�[MPPMRK�XS�EGGITX�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�2IZIV�FIJSVI�MR�LMWXSV]�LEH�XLI�[MRRMRK�WMHI�SJ�HIJIRWMZI�[EVW�FIIR�[MPPMRKXS�RIKSXMEXI�[MXL�XLI�PSWMRK�WMHI�XLEX�LEH�WXEVXIH�XLI�[EVW�FIMRK�XVIEXIH�EWIUYEPW��8S�VIKEVH�XLSWI�[LS�LEZI�MRMXMEXIH�EKKVIWWMZI�[EVW�ERH�PSWX�EW�IUYEPFEVKEMRMRK�TEVXRIVW�MW�XS�IRGSYVEKI�XLI�[EKMRK�SJ�[EV�EW�ER�EHNYRGX�XSRIKSXMEXMSR��8LIVI�QYWX�FI�E�TVMGI�TEMH�JSV�WXEVXMRK�ERH�PSWMRK�[EVW��8LEXTVMGI�MRGPYHIW�E�HMQMRMWLIH�WXEXYW�MR�XLI�TSWX[EV�TIEGI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�

-J�E�TISTPI�EVI�JVII�XS�MRMXMEXI�[EVJEVI��WYI�JSV�TIEGI�[LIR�XLI]�PSWI�XLIR�I\TIGX�XS�FI�XVIEXIH�EX�XLI�RIKSXMEXMRK�XEFPI�EW�XLI�QSVEP�IUYEPW�SJXLSWI�XLI]�EXXEGOIH��XLIVI�[MPP�FI�PMXXPI�HMWMRGIRXMZI�XS�EKKVIWWMSR��;L]�RSXWXEVX�E�[EV#�-J�XLEX�JEMPW��MRMXMEXI�RIKSXMEXMSRW��MRWMWXMRK�SR�TEVMX]�EW�E�GSR�HMXMSR�JSV�RSX�WXEVXMRK�[EV�SRGI�EKEMR��%JXIV�XLI�HIJIEX�SJ�+IVQER]�ERH.ETER�MR�;SVPH�;EV�--��NYWX�MQEKMRI�LS[�XLI�[SVPH�[SYPH�LEZI�VIEGXIH�MJWSQI�+IVQERW�ERH�.ETERIWI�LEH�IQTPS]IH�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�XLI�ZMGXSVM�SYW�TS[IVW��XLIR�HIQERHIH�IUYEP�WXEXYW�EW�FEVKEMRMRK�TEVXRIVW�MR�XLITSWX[EV�RIKSXMEXMSRW�

8VIEXMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EW�IUYEP�RIKSXMEXMRK�TEVXRIVW�VMWOW�WIRHMRK�XLI[VSRK�QIWWEKI�EFSYX�EKKVIWWMZI�[EV��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�WLSYPH�FI�XVIEXIH�EWEKKVIWWSVW�[LS�PSWX��8LI]�WLSYPH�FI�XVIEXIH�JEMVP]�FYX�[MXLSYX�QSVEPGPEMQW�XS�IUYEP�TEVXRIVWLMT�MR�XLI�RIKSXMEXMRK�TVSGIWW��(MWEKVIIQIRXWEFSYX�WIGYVMX]�WLSYPH�FI�VIWSPZIH�EKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LS�WXEVXIH�XLI�[EVW�ERHMR�JEZSV�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�WYGGIWWJYPP]�HIJIRHIH�EKEMRWX�EKKVIWWMSR��(MWTYXIWEFSYX�GSRXVSP�SJ�LSP]�TPEGIW�WLSYPH�EPWS�FI�VIWSPZIH�EKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LSWIMIH�XLIWI�TPEGIW��EW�XLI�%VEFW�HMH�MR�������ERH�HIRMIH�EGGIWW�XS�XLSWIJVSQ�[LSQ�XLI]�[IVI�WIMIH��%KKVIWWSVW�WLSYPH�FI�QEHI�XS�EFWSVFVIJYKIIW�GVIEXIH�F]�XLIMV�EKKVIWWMSR�

-R�XLI�IRH��LS[IZIV��GSQTVSQMWIW�LEZI�XS�FI�VIEGLIH�XS�EWWYVI�TIEGI�ERH�GSQTVSQMWIW�GERRSX�EP[E]W�FI�FEWIH�SR�TYVI�TVMRGMTPI��&YX�EX�PIEWXXLI�TVMRGMTPI�FIMRK�GSQTVSQMWIH�WLSYPH�VIQEMR�GPIEV��ERH�XLEX�TVMRGMTPI�MWXLEX�RS�SRI�WLSYPH�FIRIJMX�JVSQ�LEZMRK�[EKIH�EKKVIWWMZI�[EV�ERH�PSWX�8LI�TVMRGMTEP�VIEWSR�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�EGGSVHIH�IUYEP�WXEXYW�MRXLIWI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�[EW�XLEX�QSWX�-WVEIPMW�[ERX�TIEGI�QSVI�HIWTIVEXIP]�XLERHS�QSWX�4EPIWXMRMERW��4YFPMG�STMRMSR�TSPPW�HIQSRWXVEXI�XLMW�VIEPMX]�FI]SRHER]�HSYFX��1SWX�TSPPW�WLS[�XLEX�ER�SZIV[LIPQMRK�QENSVMX]�SJ�-WVEIPMW[ERX�TIEGI�ERH�[MPP�KMZI�YT�QYGL�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�WIGYVI�MX���[LMPI�EW�QER]EW����TIVGIRX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�[ERX�XIVVSVMWQ�XS�GSRXMRYI�YRXMP�EPP�SJ

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 119: The Case For Israel

4EPIWXMRI�MW�PMFIVEXIH���%GGSVHMRKP]��-WVEIP�LEW�PSRK�FIIR�TVITEVIH�XS�KMZIQSVI�MR�XLI�LSTI�SJ�EGLMIZMRK�E�PEWXMRK�ERH�WIGYVI�TIEGI�

8LMW�EXXMXYHI�MW�WYVIP]�GSQQIRHEFPI��FYX�XLIVI�EVI�IZIR�PEVKIV�MWWYIW�EXWXEOI�XLER�TIEGI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX��3XLIV�REXMSRW�ERH�TISTPI�QYWX�RSX�FI�IRGSYVEKIH�XS�TYVWYI�XLI�EKKVIWWMZI�TEXL�SJ�[EV�ERH�XIVVSVMWQ�XLEXLEW�PIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�FIMRK�KMZIR�IUYEP�WXEXYW�MR�XLI�RIKSXMEXMRKTVSGIWW��-J�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�WYGGIIH�MR�KIXXMRK�IZIV]XLMRK�XLI]�LEZIWSYKLX�F]�XLMW�TEXL��MX�[MPP�SRP]�FI�E�QEXXIV�SJ�XMQI�FIJSVI�SXLIV�REXMSRWERH�TISTPI�[LS�FIPMIZI�XLIQWIPZIW�XS�FI�EKKVMIZIH�[MPP�TYVWYI�EKKVIWWMZI[EVJEVI�ERH�XIVVSVMWQ�EW�E�JMVWX�STXMSR��8LI�[SVPH�[MPP�FI�E�JEV�QSVI�ZMSPIRXERH�HERKIVSYW�TPEGI�MJ�XLEX�MW�XLI�PIWWSR�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM§4EPIWXMRMER�RIKSXM�EXMSRW��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�SJ�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIWLEW�[EVRIH�XLEX�MJXIVVSVMWQ�MW�VI[EVHIH�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX��MX�[MPP�©FI�GSQMRK�XS�E�XLIEXVIRIEV�]SY�ª��

8LI�IRH�VIWYPX�SJ�XLIWI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�LEW�FIIR�ER�SRKSMRK�WXEVX�ERH�WXST�ERH�VIWXEVX�ERH�VIWXST�TVSGIWW�XLEX�LEW�LIPH�QYGL�TVSQMWI�JSPPS[IHF]�QYGL�HMWETTSMRXQIRX�JSV�E�VIWSPYXMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER§-WVEIP��ERHTIVLETW�IZIR�XLI�%VEF§-WVEIP��GSRJPMGX��8LI�3WPS�TIEGI�TVSGIWW�YPXMQEXIP]PIH�XS�ER�IRH�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�GMXMIW��XS[RW��ERH�ZMP�PEKIW��[MXL�E�JI[�I\GITXMSRW ��3R�7ITXIQFIV�����������-WVEIP�ERH�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�WMKRIH�ER�EKVIIQIRX�YRHIV�[LMGL�-WVEIPM�XVSSTW�[IVIXS�[MXLHVE[�JVSQ�QSWX�SJ�XLI�TSTYPEXIH�EVIEW�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH+EE���4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�TSPMGI��RYQFIVMRK���������EWWYQIH�GSRXVSPSZIV�XLIWI�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW��%PXLSYKL�-WVEIP�WXMPP�QEMRXEMRIHGSRXVSP�SZIV�WYFWXERXMEP�EVIEW�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�[MXL�JI[�SV�RS�4EPIWXMRMERVIWMHIRXW��XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�[EW�WYFWXER�XMEPP]�IRHIH�MR�������-X�LEH�PEWXIH�X[IRX]�IMKLX�]IEVW��-WVEIP�HMH�RSX�VISG�GYT]�ER]�SJ�XLIWI�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�YRXMP�������ETTVS\MQEXIP]�E�]IEV�EJXIVER�ITMHIQMG�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�FIKER��ERH�IZIR�XLIR�MX�SRP]VISGGYTMIH�SR�E�XIQTSVEV]�FEWMW�XLSWI�TPEGIW�XLEX�[IVI�FIMRK�YWIH�EWPEYRGLMRK�TEHW�JSV�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW��.IVMGLS��JSV�I\EQTPI��LEW�RSX�FIIRVISGGYTMIH��WMRGI�MX�LEW�RSX�WIVZIH�EW�E�FEWI�JSV�XIVVSVMWQ�

(YVMRK�XLI�RIEVP]�WM\�]IEVW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�GSRXVSP�SZIV�MXW�TSTYPEXMSRGIRXIVW��WSQI�TVSKVIWW�[EW�QEHI�XS[EVH�VIWSPZMRK�SYXWXERHMRK�MWWYIW��8LI�403��EPXLSYKL�RSX�,EQEW�ERH�XLI�SXLIV�VEHMGEP�-WPEQMG�KVSYTW�ETTIEVIH�XS�FI�QSZMRK�XS[EVH�EGGITXMRK�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLI4EPIWXMRMER§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX�

&]�XLI�IEVP]�WYQQIV�SJ�������MX�PSSOIH�EW�MJ�TIEGI�QMKLX�EGXYEPP]�FI�EXLERH��8IVVSVMWQ�LEH�EFEXIH�WSQI[LEX�SZIV�XLI�TVIZMSYW�WIZIVEP�]IEVW��ERHRS[�E�HSZMWL�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�LIEHIH�F]�)LYH�&EVEO�[EW�EGXMZIP]�WIIO�MRK�TIEGI��&MPP�'PMRXSR��WIVZMRK�LMW�PEWX�]IEV�EW�TVIWMHIRX��[EW�HIXIVQMRIHXS�PIEZI�E�PIKEG]�SJ�TIEGI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX��8LI�-WVEIPMW�ERH�XLI�403EKVIIH�XS�QIIX�FIKMRRMRK�.YP]�����������YRHIV�XLI�EYWTMGIW�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 120: The Case For Israel

7XEXIW��-R�XLI�GSYVWI�SJ�XLIWI�QIIXMRKW��[LMGL�PEWXIH�YRXMP�.ERYEV]������&EVEO�WXEVXPIH�XLI�[SVPH�F]�SJJIVMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�RIEVP]�EPP�XLI�XIVVMXSV]XLI]�[IVI�WIIOMRK��&]�XLI�XMQI�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�IRHIH��&EVEO�LEHEGGITXIH�'PMRXSR¬W�IZIR�QSVI�KIRIVSYW�TVSTSWEP�ERH�[EW�SJJIVMRK�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�©FIX[IIR����ERH����TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&EROª�ERH�EPP�SJ�XLI+EE�7XVMT���-R�I\GLERKI�JSV�XLI���XS���TIVGIRX�XLEX�-WVEIP�[SYPH�VIXEMRJSV�WIGYVMX]�TYVTSWIW��MX�[SYPH�GIHI���XS���TIVGIRX�SJ�MXW�PERH�XS�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW��8LMW�[SYPH�TPEMRP]�LEZI�WEXMWJMIH�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�6IWSPYXMSR�����[LMGL�QERHEXIH�VIXYVR�SJ�©XIVVMXSVMIW�ª�RSX�EPP�XIVVMXSVMIW��GETXYVIH�MR-WVEIP¬W�HIJIRWMZI�[EV�[MXL�.SVHER��*I[��MJ�ER]��4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI[SYPHVIQEMR�YRHIV�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�

-R�EHHMXMSR��&EVEO�SJJIVIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�E�WXEXI�[MXL�%VEF�.IVYWEPIQEW�MXW�GETMXEP�ERH�GSQTPIXI�GSRXVSP�SZIV�)EWX�.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�XLI�%VEF�5YEV�XIV�SJ�XLI�3PH�'MX]��EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�IRXMVI�8IQTPI�1SYRX��HIWTMXI�MXW�LMWXSVMGERH�VIPMKMSYW�WMKRMJMGERGI�XS�.I[W��-WVEIP�[SYPH�VIXEMR�GSRXVSP�SZIV�XLI;IWXIVR�;EPP��[LMGL�LEW�RS�WMKRMJMGERGI�JSV�1YWPMQW�

3R�XLI�VIJYKII�MWWYI��-WVEIP�[SYPH�©EGORS[PIHKI�XLI�QSVEP�ERH�QEXI�VMEP�WYJJIVMRK�GEYWIH�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�XLI������[EVERH�XLI�RIIH�XS�EWWMWX�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�MR�EHHVIWWMRK�XLI�TVSF�PIQ�ª��-WVEIP�[SYPH�EGGITX�WSQI�SJ�XLI�VIJYKIIW�SR�LYQERMXEVMER�ERHJEQMP]�YRMJMGEXMSR�KVSYRHW��FYX�QSWX�[SYPH�PMZI�MR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�����FMPPMSR�MR�GSQTIRWEXMSR�[SYPH�FI�EKVIIH�XS�JSV�XLSWI�[LS�HMH�RSXQSZI�XS�-WVEIP��2S�GSQTIRWEXMSR�[EW�SJJIVIH�JSV�XLI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ%VEF�WXEXIW�JSPPS[MRK�XLI������ERH������[EVW��%W�JEV�EW�XLI�.I[MWL�WIXXPI�QIRXW�[IVI�GSRGIVRIH��&EVEO�EKVIIH�XS�XLI�©HMWQERXPMRK�SJ�QSWX�SJ�XLIWIXXPIQIRXW�ERH�XLI�GSRGIRXVEXMSR�SJ�XLI�FYPO�SJ�XLI�WIXXPIVW�MRWMHIª�XLIWQEPP�TIVGIRXEKI�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�XS�FI�ERRI\IH�F]�-WVEIP���

=EWWIV�%VEJEX�VINIGXIH�XLI�&EVEO�TVSTSWEP��QEOMRK�MX�GPIEV�XLEX�LI�[SYPHRIZIV�WYVVIRHIV�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�QSVI�XLER���QMPPMSR�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�VIXYVR�XS-WVEIP�VEXLIV�XLER�PMZI�MR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�[MXL�GSQTIRWEXMSR��8LMW[SYPH��SJ�GSYVWI��UYMGOP]�XYVR�-WVEIP�MRXS�]IX�ERSXLIV�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��MREHHMXMSR�XS�.SVHER�ERH�XLI�RI[�;IWX�&ERO§+EE�7XVMT�WXEXI��8LI�4EPIW�XMRMER�VIJYKII�MWWYI�LEW�EP[E]W�FIIR�E�TPS]�HIWMKRIH�XS�XYVR�-WVEIP�MRXS�E4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��ERH�%VEJEX¬W�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�KIRIVSYW�&EVEO�SJJIVHIQSRWXVEXIH�XLMW�[MXL�PMXXPI�EQFMKYMX]�

-X�MW�SRP]�REXYVEP�XLEX�QSWX�4EPIWXMRMERW�[SYPH�SVHMREVMP]�TVIJIV�XS�PMZIMR�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�YRHIV�4EPIWXMRMER�GSRXVSP�XLER�MR�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�YRHIV-WVEIPM�GSRXVSP XLMW�MW�GIVXEMRP]�[LEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�FIIR�HIQERH�MRK�JSV�]IEVW��&YX�MJ�XLI�KSEP�MW�XS�JPSSH�-WVEIP�[MXL�QMPPMSRW�SJ�%VEFW�MRSVHIV�XS�XYVR�MX�MRXS�ERSXLIV�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��QER]�VIJYKIIW�QMKLXHIGMHI SV�FI�TIVWYEHIH XS�HS�XLIMV�HYX]�ERH�QSZI�XS�-WVEIP��MJ�KMZIRXLEX�GLSMGI��8LI�HSZMWL�-WVEIPM�RI[WTETIV�,E¬EVIXIHMXSVMEPMIH�XLI�JSP�PS[MRK�EJXIV�&EVEO�QEHI�LMW�SJJIV�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 121: The Case For Israel

8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�GSYPH�RSX�EWO�JSV�E�FIXXIV�XMQI�XS�KIX�XLI�FIWX�TSWWMFPI

TIEGI�XVIEX]�XLER�VMKLX�RS[��&YX�XLI]�[ERX�QSVI��������1SVI�XLER�ER]�

XLMRK�IPWI��XLI]�[ERX�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�XS�FI�VIGSKRMIH�ERH�JYPJMPPIH�

8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�[EW�RSX�GEYWIH�F]�-WVEIP��MX�[EW�GEYWIH

F]�%VEF�WXEXIW��[LMGL�LEZI�XVMIH��XMQI�ERH�EKEMR��XS�YWI�FVYXI�JSVGI�XS

[MTI�YW�SJJ�XLI�QET��������

*YPJMPPQIRX�SJ�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�[SYPH�QIER�XLI�IRH�SJ�-WVEIP�EW�E

.I[MWL�WXEXI��ERH�XLYW�-WVEIP�[MPP�RIZIV�EKVII�XS�XLMW�HIQERH�

-J�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�MRGPYHIH�XLI�GPEYWI�SR�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�EW�E

TPS]�MRXIRHIH�WMQTP]�XS�IRLERGI�XLIMV�FEVKEMRMRK�TSWMXMSR��XLI]�[SYPH�FI

[MWI�XS�[MXLHVE[�MX�VMKLX�RS[ FIGEYWI�XMQI�MW�VYRRMRK�SYX��)ZIR�XLI

QSWX�TEXMIRX�WYMXSV�KMZIW�YT�XV]MRK�XS�GETXYVI�E�LEVH�XS�KIX�ZMVKMR��%VEJEX

PSWX�LMW�ZMVKMRMX]�E�PSRK�XMQI�EKS��ERH�[I¬ZI�LEH�MX�[MXL�LMW�KEQI�TPE]MRK

ERH�[MXL�LMW�EVQ�X[MWXMRK�EXXIQTXW�������

-J�XLI]�JEMP�XS�KVEF�LSPH�SJ�XLIWI�SJJIVW�RS[��MRWXIEH�SJ�&EVEO��XLI]¬PP

KIX�7LEVSR���

7SQI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�GSQTPEMRIH�XLEX�XLI�SJJIVIH�PERH�[EW�RSX�EPPGSRXMKYSYW��8LI�+EE�7XVMT��JSV�I\EQTPI��MW�WITEVEXIH�JVSQ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�-WVEIP�SJJIVIH�WSQI�PERH�FVMHKIW�ERH�TIVQERIRX�PIEWMRK�EVVERKIQIRXW��FYXXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�HIQERHIH�GSRXMKYMX]��-X�WLSYPH�FI�VIGEPPIH�XLEX�XLI�PERHSJJIVIH�XS�-WVEIP�MR������F]�XLI�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�ERH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH2EXMSRW�MR������[EW�EPWS�RSRGSRXMKYSYW��-WVEIP�EGGITXIH�XLSWI�SJJIVW�ER]�[E]�

1SVISZIV��WSQI�SJ�XLI�QENSV�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW��WYGL�EW�,EQEW��-WPEQMG.MLEH��ERH�,IFSPPEL��STTSWI�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�VINIGX�XLI�GVI�EXMSR�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�SR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE��8LI]�LEZI�TPIHKIHXS�GSRXMRYI�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP¬W�.I[W�YRXMP�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�MW�PMFIVEXIHERH�RSX�SRI�MRGL�SJ�MX�MW�YRHIV�.I[MWL�GSRXVSP��*SV�XLIQ�QIVI�GSRXMKYMX]MW�MVVIPIZERX��8LI]�[ERX�IZIV]XLMRK�

8LI�VIEP�VIEWSR�[L]�%VEJEX�XYVRIH�HS[R�&EVEO¬W�SJJIV�MW�XLEX�LI�[EWEJVEMH�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP��VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�[LEX�-WVEIP�SJJIVIH��WLSVX�SJIRHMRK�MXW�S[R�I\MWXIRGI��,I�ORI[�XLEX�XLI�VEHMGEP�-WPEQMG�KVSYTW�VITVI�WIRXMRK�E�KVS[MRK�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�VINIGX�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ERH[SYPH�VIKEVH�ER]SRI�[LS�EGGITXIH�MX�EW�E�XVEMXSV��HIWIVZMRK�XLI�HIEXL�XLEXLEH�FIIR�QIXIH�SYX�XS�WS�QER]�SXLIVW JVSQ�%FHYPPEL�XS�7EHEX�XS�QSH�IVEXI�4EPIWXMRMERW [LS�LEH�TVIZMSYWP]�EGGITXIH�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX��-X�[EW�WEJIV�JSV�%VEJEX�XS�JMRH�I\GYWIW�RSX�XS�EGGITX�E�TIEGI�SJJIV�XLER�XSTVSZSOI�XLI�TSXIRXMEPP]�PIXLEP�IRQMX]�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�VINIGX�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XSI\MWX�

8LIVI�EVI�WSQI�[LS�TPEGI�XLI�FPEQI�JSV�XLI�VIRI[EP�SJ�XLI�XIVVSVMWQJSPPS[MRK�XLI�%VEJEX�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�TIEGI�SJJIV�SR�XLI�HIGMWMSR�F]%VMIP�7LEVSR FIJSVI�LI�FIGEQI�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV XS�ZMWMX�XLI�8IQTPI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 122: The Case For Israel

1SYRX�SR�7ITXIQFIV�����������&YX�XLI�IZMHIRGI�TPEMRP]�WLS[W�XLEX�XLIZMSPIRGI�LEH�FIIR�GEVIJYPP]�TPERRIH�[IPP�FIJSVI�7LEVSR¬W�ZMWMX��%W�XLI�GSQ�QYRMGEXMSRW�QMRMWXIV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�GERHMHP]�EGORS[PIHKIH�

8LI�4%�LEH�FIKYR�XS�TVITEVI�JSV�XLI�SYXFVIEO�SJ�XLI�GYVVIRX�-RXMJEHE

WMRGI�XLI�VIXYVR�JVSQ�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�RIKSXMEXMSRW��F]�VIUYIWX�SJ�4VIWM�

HIRX�=EWWIV�%VEJEX��[LS�TVIHMGXIH�XLI�SYXFVIEO�SJ�XLI�-RXMJEHE�EW�E�GSQ�

TPIQIRXEV]�WXEKI�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WXIEHJEWXRIWW�MR�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW��ERH

RSX�EW�E�WTIGMJMG�TVSXIWX�EKEMRWX�?%VMIPA�7LEVSR¬W�ZMWMX�XS�%P�,EVEQ�%P�

5YHWM�?8IQTPI�1SYRXA��������8LI�-RXMJEHE�[EW�RS�WYVTVMWI�JSV�XLI�4EPIW�

XMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT��8LI�PIEHIVWLMT�LEH�MRZIWXIH�EPP�SJ�MXW�IJJSVXW�MR�TSPMXMGEP

ERH�HMTPSQEXMG�GLERRIPW�MR�SVHIV�XS�JM\�XLI�JPE[W�MR�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�ERH

XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW��FYX�XS�RS�EZEMP��-X�IRGSYRXIVIH�-WVEIPM�WXYFFSVRRIWW�ERH

GSRXMRYSYW�VIRYRGMEXMSR�SJ�?4EPIWXMRMERA�VMKLXW��������8LI�4%�MRWXVYGXIH�XLI

TSPMXMGEP�JSVGIW�ERH�JEGXMSRW�XS�VYR�EPP�QEXIVMEPW�SJ�XLI�-RXMJEHE���

8LI�1MXGLIPP�'SQQMWWMSR��LIEHIH�F]�JSVQIV�7IREXI�QENSVMX]�PIEHIV+ISVKI�1MXGLIPPLMQWIPJ�E�HIWGIRHERX�SJ�0IFERIWI�'LVMWXMERW GEQI�XS�EWMQMPEV�GSRGPYWMSR��©8LI�7LEVSR�ZMWMX�HMH�RSX�GEYWI�XLI�%P�%OWE�-RXMJEHE�ª-RHIIH��XLIVI�[IVI�RS�HIEXLW�ERH�JI[�4EPIWXMRMER�MRNYVMIW�SR�XLI�HE]�SJ�XLI7LEVSR�ZMWMX��EPXLSYKL�X[IRX]�IMKLX�-WVEIPM�TSPMGIQIR�[IVI�MRNYVIH�F]�VSGOXLVS[IVW��8LI�HIEXLW�ERH�MRNYVMIW�GEQI�WLSVXP]�EJXIV�ER�SVGLIWXVEXIH�EXXEGOF]�4EPIWXMRMERW�EKEMRWX�.I[W�TVE]MRK�EX�XLI�;IWXIVR�;EPP�

%VMIP�7LEVSR¬W�ZMWMX�XS�XLI�8IQTPI�1SYRX�[EW�RIKSXMEXIH�MR�EHZERGI[MXL�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW��2SRIXLIPIWW��MR�Q]�ZMI[�MX�[EW�E�[VSRK�LIEHIHTVSZSGEXMSR�XLEX�TVSZMHIH�ER�I\GYWI IZIR�E�XVMKKIV JSV�XLI�ZMSPIRGI�FYX�XLI�KYR�LEH�EPVIEH]�FIIR�PSEHIH�MR�ERXMGMTEXMSR�SJ�ER�MRIZMXEFPITVSZSGEXMSR�SJ�WSQI�WSVX�

%�VIEP�TIEGI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�QYWX�FI�EFPI�XS�IRHYVI�XLI�OMRH�SJW]QFSPMG�ZIVFEP�TVSZSGEXMSR�VITVIWIRXIH�F]�%VMIP�7LEVSR¬W�ZMWMX�XS�XLI8IQTPI�1SYRX��%R]�IRHYVMRK�TIEGI�WLSYPH�I\TIGX�XLIWI�OMRHW�SJ�TVSZS�GEXMSRW�SR�FSXL�WMHIW��;LEX�GERRSX�FI�XSPIVEXIH�EVI�ZMSPIRX�VIWTSRWIW�XSXLIWI�TVSZSGEXMSRW��IWTIGMEPP]�MJ�XLI�ZMSPIRGI�MW�SVGLIWXVEXIH�SV�IZIREGGITXIH�EX�XLI�XST�PIZIPW��8LMW�MW�E�QENSV�PIWWSR�XLEX�[EW�QMWYRHIVWXSSHHYVMRK�XLI�FPSSH]�HE]W�JSPPS[MRK�7LEVSR¬W�ZMWMX�

8LI�-WVEIPMW�EVI�TVSZSOIH�HEMP]�F]�WMQMPEV�ZIVFEP�ERH�W]QFSPMG�EGXMSRW�VERKMRK�JVSQ�XLI�XIEGLMRK�SJ�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMEP�ERH�ERXM�.YHEMWQ�MR�WXEXI�VYR4EPIWXMRMER�WGLSSPW�XS�E�TVSZSGEXMZI�ZMWMX�XS�XLI�;IWXIVR�;EPP�F]�%VEF�PIKMW�PEXSVW��8LI�ETTVSTVMEXI�VIWTSRWI�XS�ZIVFEP�ERH�W]QFSPMG�TVSZSGEXMSR�MW�TSPMX�MGEP�TVSXIWX��MRGPYHMRK�HIQSRWXVEXMSRW�ERH�TIVLETW�IZIR�[SVO�WXSTTEKIW��&YXXLVS[MRK�VSGOW�ERH�FSQFW�ERH�WLSSXMRK�KYRW�MW�YXXIVP]�YREGGITXEFPI�ERHWLSYPH�RSX�FI�IRGSYVEKIH�F]�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�

=IX�XLI�[SVPH��MRGPYHMRK�QER]�MR�XLI�QIHME��EGEHIQME��ERH�IZIR�HMTPS�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 123: The Case For Israel

QEG]��WIIQW�XS�EGGITX�4EPIWXMRMER�ZMSPIRGI�EW�GYPXYVEP��3R�XLI�SXLIV�LERH�WSQIXLMRK�HMJJIVIRX�MW�I\TIGXIH�JVSQ�-WVEIPMW��8LMW�MW�GYPXYVEP�VIPEXMZMWQFSVHIVMRK�SR�VEGMWQ��8S�I\TIGX�PIWW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW��VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�XLIMVKVMIZERGIW��MW�XS�HMQMRMWL�XLIMV�LYQERMX]�

8LI�TSMRX�MW�XLEX�TVSZSGEXMSRW�[MPP�SGGYV��IWTIGMEPP]�MR�E�HIQSGVEG][LIVI�7LEVSR��PMOI�ER]�-WVEIPM�GMXMIR��MW�IRXMXPIH�XS�ZMWMX�E�WMXI�STIR�XS�XLITYFPMG�XLEX�MW�LSP]�XS�FSXL�.I[W�ERH�1YWPMQW��8LI�QMRHWIX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERWQYWX�GLERKI�MJ�TIEGI�MW�XS�FIGSQI�E�VIEPMX]��8LI]�QYWX�PIEVR�XLEX�TVSTSV�XMSREPMX]��[LMGL�XLI]�ETTVSTVMEXIP]�HIQERH�JVSQ�XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]��QYWXEPWS�FI�HIQERHIH�SJ�XLIQ�F]�XLIMV�PIEHIVW��:IVFEP�ERH�W]QFSPMG�TVSZSGE�XMSRW�EVI�TEVX�SJ�E�HIQSGVEG]��7LEVSR��MR�LMW�S[R�MREVXJYP�[E]��[EW�QEOMRKE�VIPIZERX�TSMRX��[LIR�XLI�3PH�'MX]�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ�[EW�GSRXVSPPIH�F]�XLI.SVHERMER�KSZIVRQIRX�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�MQEQW��RS�.I[�[EW�EPPS[IH�XSZMWMX�XLI�8IQTPI�1SYRX�SV�XS�TVE]�EX�XLI�;IWXIVR�;EPP��%JXIV�-WVEIPHIJIRHIH�MXWIPJ�JVSQ�.SVHERMER�EXXEGO�HYVMRK�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV�ERH�GET�XYVIH�.IVYWEPIQ��XLI�LSP]�WMXIW�[IVI�STIRIH�XS�EPP�

7LEVSR�[EW�WIIOMRK�XS�HIQSRWXVEXI�XLEX�MJ�XLI�8IQTPI�1SYRX�[IVIVIXYVRIH�XS�4EPIWXMRMER�GSRXVSP��LI�ERH�SXLIV�.I[W�[SYPH�RSX�FI�[IPGSQIXLIVI��8LIVI�QE]�LEZI�FIIR�FIXXIV�[E]W�XS�QEOI�XLEX�TSMRX��FYX�KSZIVR�QIRXW�MR�E�HIQSGVEG]�QE]�RSX�KIRIVEPP]�VIWXVMGX�XLI�QERRIV�F]�[LMGLTSPMXMGEP�TSMRXW�EVI�QEHI�WS�PSRK�EW�MX�MW�RSRZMSPIRX��8S�EPPS[�E�VSGO�XLVS[IV¬W�ZIXS�MW�XS�YRHIVGYX�JVIIHSQ�SJ�I\TVIWWMSR��,EH�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZ�IVRQIRX�TVIZIRXIH�7LEVSR�JVSQ�IRXIVMRK�XLI�8IQTPI�1SYRX��XLEX��XSS�[SYPH�LEZI�[IEOIRIH�XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW�F]�KMZMRK�EQQYRMXMSR�XS�XLI-WVEIPM�I\XVIQI�VMKLX�

;LIR�XLI�X[S�WMHIW�QSZI�FEGO�XS�XLI�RIKSXMEXMRK�XEFPI��XLI]�QYWX�XEOIMRXS�GSRWMHIVEXMSR�XLI�PMOIPMLSSH MRHIIH��XLI�MRIZMXEFMPMX] XLEX�WMQMPEVERH�IZIR�[SVWI�TVSZSGEXMSRW�[MPP�SGGYV�SR�FSXL�WMHIW��2S�TVSZSGEXIYV�[LIXLIV�E�W]QFSPMG�SRI�PMOI�7LEVSR�SV�E�ZMSPIRX�XIVVSVMWX�SR�IMXLIV�WMHI�WLSYPH�FI�EFPI�XS�TYX�ER�IRH�XS�XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW��-X�[MPP�XEOI�[MWI�QMRHWERH�EGGITXMRK�LIEVXW�XS�FYMPH�E�TIEGI�XLEX�GER�IRHYVI�TVSZSGEXMSRW��8LI)K]TXMER§-WVEIPM�TIEGI��EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�.SVHERMER§-WVEIPM�TIEGI��LEZI�FIIREFPI�XS�IRHYVI�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�F]�MRHMZMHYEP�)K]TXMERW�ERH�.SVHERMERWEKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMXMIRW��MRGPYHMRK�GLMPHVIR��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�QYWX�PIEVR�XSIRHYVI�ZIVFEP�ERH�W]QFSPMG�TVSZSGEXMSRW��NYWX�EW�XLI�-WVEIPMW�QYWX�PIEVR�XSVIWTSRH�XS�ZMSPIRGI�MR�E�QERRIV�XLEX�QMRMQMIW�MRNYV]�ERH�IWGEPEXMSR��&YXMRWXIEH��MR�XLI�JEPP�SJ�������XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�HIGMHIH�XS�YWI�XLI�7LEVSR�ZMWMXEW�ER�I\GYWI�XS�EGGIPIVEXI�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�

%W�[I�[MPP�WII�MR�HIXEMP�MR�XLI�RI\X�GLETXIV��XLI�SYXFVIEO�SJ�XIVVSVMWQXLEX�JSPPS[IH�%VEJEX¬W�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�&EVEO�SJJIV�[EW�GEVIJYPP]�©TPERRIHMR�EHZERGI�ª��FIGEYWI�%VEJEX�ORI[�XLEX�F]�TPE]MRK�LMW�XVMIH�ERH�XVYI�XIV�VSVMWQ�GEVH��LI�GSYPH�SRGI�EKEMR�MRJPYIRGI�TYFPMG�ERH�HMTPSQEXMG�STMRMSRMR�LMW�JEZSV��;LIR�%VEJEX�[EPOIH�E[E]�JVSQ�&EVEO¬W�KIRIVSYW�SJJIV��XLI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 124: The Case For Israel

MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�MRMXMEPP]�XYVRIH�EKEMRWX�LMQ�MR�JEZSV�SJ�-WVEIP��&YXEJXIV�XLI�[IPP�TPERRIH�VIWYQTXMSR�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�ERHXLI�IRXMVIP]�TVIHMGXEFPI�-WVEIPM�SZIVVIEGXMSR�XS�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�]SYRKWXIVWERH�JEQMPMIW�MR�TME�TEVPSVW��HMWGSXLIUYIW��ERH�4EWWSZIV�WIHIVW��QYGL�SJ)YVSTIER�TYFPMG�STMRMSR�SRGI�EKEMR�XYVRIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP��

9RHIVWXERHMRK�XLMW�H]REQMG��WSQI�4EPIWXMRMERW�©EPQSWX�[IPGSQIH�XLI�-WVEIPM�EXXEGOW�ª�EGGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW���-X�[EW�TEVX�SJXLIMV�WXVEXIK]�XS�VIKEMR�MRXIVREXMSREP�WYTTSVX��%W�SRI�HMTPSQEX�XSPH�XLI2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�©8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�QEWXIVIH�E�LEVWL�EVMXLQIXMG�SJTEMR��������4EPIWXMRMER�GEWYEPXMIW�TPE]�MR�XLIMV�JEZSV�ERH�-WVEIPM�GEWYEPXMIW�TPE]MR�XLIMV�JEZSV��2SR�ZMSPIRGI�HSIWR¬X�TE]�ª��8IVVSVMWQ�MW�E�XEGXMG�WIPIGXIHF]�IPMXI�PIEHIVW�FIGEYWI�MX�[SVOW��RSX�FIGEYWI�MX�MW�E�HIWTIVEXI�VIEGXMSR�XSSTTVIWWMSR��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�SJ�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIWSFWIVZIH�XLEX

8LI�[SVPH�QYWX�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�RSX�GLSWIR�WYMGMHI

FSQFMRK�SYX�SJ�©HIWTIVEXMSRª�WXIQQMRK�JVSQ�XLI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�

8LEX�MW�E�LYKI�PMI��;L]#�8S�FIKMR�[MXL��E�PSX�SJ�SXLIV�TISTPI�MR�XLI�[SVPH

EVI�HIWTIVEXI��]IX�XLI]�LEZI�RSX�KSRI�EVSYRH�WXVETTMRK�H]REQMXI�XS

XLIQWIPZIW��1SVI�MQTSVXERX��4VIWMHIRX�'PMRXSR�SJJIVIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�E

TIEGI�TPER�XLEX�GSYPH�LEZI�IRHIH�XLIMV�©HIWTIVEXIª�SGGYTEXMSR��ERH

=EWWIV�%VEJEX�[EPOIH�E[E]���

%�WYVZI]�SJ�XLI�VIWIEVGL�SR�[LS�FIGSQIW�E�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�TYXW�XLI�PMIXS�XLI�GPEMQ�XLEX�XIVVSVMWQ�MW�XLI�MRIZMXEFPI�GSRWIUYIRGI�SJ�LSTIPIWWRIWW�TSZIVX]��ERH�HMWIRJVERGLMWIQIRX��©%W�PSKMGEP�EW�XLI�TSZIVX]�FVIIHW�XIVVSVMWQ�EVKYQIRX�QE]�WIIQ��WXYH]�EJXIV�WXYH]�WLS[W�XLEX�WYMGMHIEXXEGOIVW�ERH�XLIMV�WYTTSVXIVW�EVI�VEVIP]�MKRSVERX�SV�MQTSZIVMWLIH�ª�1ER][IVI�VEMWIH�©MR�VIPEXMZIP]�TVSWTIVSYW�GMVGYQWXERGIW��ERH�EXXIRHIH�GSPPIKI�ª3RI�WXYH]�SJ�RIEVP]�����EWTMVMRK�4EPIWXMRMER�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�JSYRH�XLEX©RSRI�[IVI�YRIHYGEXIH��HIWTIVEXIP]�TSSV��WMQTPI�QMRHIH�SV�HITVIWWIH�ª3XLIV�WXYHMIW�JSYRH�XLEX�XLIWI�QEWW�QYVHIVIVW�©[IVI�RSX�MKRSVERX��HIWXM�XYXI�SV�HMWIRJVERGLMWIH�ª�8LI]�LIPH�©RSVQEP��VIWTIGXEFPI�NSFWª�ERHWIIQIH�©XS�FI�IRXMVIP]�RSVQEP�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLIMV�JEQMPMIW�ª�8LI]�HS�RSX©I\TVIWW�LSTIPIWWRIWW�SV�E�WIRWI�SJ�«RSXLMRK�XS�PSWI�¬ª��

(IWTIVEXMSR�QE]�I\TPEMR�LS[�IEW]�MX�LEW�FIIR�JSV�IPMXI�PIEHIVW�XS�TIV�WYEHI�MQTVIWWMSREFPI�]SYRKWXIVW�XS�FIGSQI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��FYX�HIWTIV�EXMSR�EPSRI�MW�RSX�XLI�GSQTPIXI�I\TPEREXMSR�IZIR�JSV�XLEX�JSVQ�SJ4EPIWXMRMER�GLMPH�EFYWI��+PSVMJMGEXMSRW�SJ�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�GSYTPIH�[MXLHILYQERMEXMSR�SJ�LMW�ZMGXMQ�EVI�IWWIRXMEP�GSRXVMFYXMRK�JEGXSVW�XS�[L]GLMPHVIR�EVI�[MPPMRK�XS�FPS[�XLIQWIPZIW�YT��%R�I\EQTPI�SJ�XLI�TSPMXMGEPKPSVMJMGEXMSR�SJ�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRK�MW�XLI�WXEXIQIRX�QEHI�F]�=EWWIV�%VEJEX¬W[MJI��[LS�MW�PMZMRK�MR�PY\YV]�[MXL�LIV�HEYKLXIV�MR�4EVMW��%PXLSYKL�JEV�JVSQHIWTIVEXI��WLI�WEMH�XLEX�WLI�©LEXIWª�-WVEIP�ERH�MJ�WLI�LEH�E�WSR�XLIVI�[SYPH

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 125: The Case For Israel

FI�©RS�KVIEXIV�LSRSVª�XLER�JSV�LMQ�XS�FIGSQI�E�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�[LSOMPPIH�.I[W��7LI�HMH�RSX�WE]�[LIXLIV�WLI�[ERXIH�LIV�HEYKLXIV�XS�FIGSQIE�QEVX]V���

-WPEQMG�VIPMKMSYW�ERH�TSPMXMGEP�PIEHIVW�QEOI�MX�IEWMIV�JSV�XLIWI�WYMGMHEPOMPPIVW�XS�IRKEKI�MR�XLI�QEWW�QYVHIV�SJ�GMZMPMERW�F]�HILYQERMMRK�-WVEIPMWERH�.I[W�MR�XLIMV�WGLSSPW��QSWUYIW��ERH�QIHME��%W�'LEVPIW�/VEYXLEQQIV[VSXI�MR�XLI�;EWLMRKXSR�4SWX�©%VEJEX�LEW�VEMWIH�ER�IRXMVI�KIRIVEXMSRWGLSSPIH�MR�LEXVIH�SJ�XLI�«.YHIS�2EMW�¬ª�8LMW�MRHSGXVMREXMSR�MRGPYHIW©XLI�VE[IWX�MRGMXIQIRX�XS�QYVHIV��EW�MR�XLMW�WIVQSR�F]�%VEJEX�ETTSMRXIHERH�%VEJEX�JYRHIH�%LQEH�%FY�,EPEFM]E�FVSEHGEWX�PMZI�SR�SJJMGMEP�4EPIW�XMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�XIPIZMWMSR�IEVP]�MR�XLI�-RXMJEHE��8LI�WYFNIGX�MW�«XLI.I[W�¬ª��2SXI��RSX�XLI�-WVEIPMW��FYX�XLI�.I[W ��©8LI]�QYWX�FI�FYXGLIVIHERH�OMPPIH��EW�%PPEL�XLI�%PQMKLX]�WEMH��«*MKLX�XLIQ��%PPEL�[MPP�XSVXYVI�XLIQEX�]SYV�LERHW�¬�������,EZI�RS�QIVG]�SR�XLI�.I[W��RS�QEXXIV�[LIVI�XLI]�EVI�MR�ER]�GSYRXV]��*MKLX�XLIQ��[LIVIZIV�]SY�EVI��;LIVIZIV�]SY�QIIX�XLIQ�OMPP�XLIQ�ª��

4EPIWXMRMER�IHYGEXSVW��XSS��MRGMXI�XLIMV�WXYHIRXW�XS�QYVHIV�F]�VEGMWXVLIXSVMG��%R�IRH�SJ�XLI�]IEV�GIVIQSR]�JSV�������OMRHIVKEVXIR�WXYHIRXWVYR�F]�,EQEW�©MRGPYHIH�E�WOMX�F]�GLMPHVIR�XLEX�IRGSYVEKIH�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ.I[W�EW�E�VIPMKMSYW�GSQQERHQIRX�ª��8LMW�GSQFMREXMSR�SJ�VIPMKMSYW��TSPMX�MGEP��ERH�QIHME�QIWWEKIW�LIPTW�I\TPEMR�[L]��EQSRK�XLI�QER]�HIWTIVEXITISTPIW�MR�XLI�[SVPH��SRP]�4EPIWXMRMER�GLMPHVIR�EVI�PMRMRK�YT�XS�GSQQMXWYMGMHI�ERH�LSQMGMHI���

-X�QE]�WIIQ�MVSRMG�XLEX�WS�WSSR�EJXIV�-WVEIP�SJJIVIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERWRIEVP]�IZIV]XLMRK�XLI]�ERH�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�[ERXIH E�4EPIW�XMRMER�WXEXI�[MXL�%VEF�.IVYWEPIQ�EW�MXW�GETMXEP��VIXYVR�SJ�XLI�IRXMVI�+EE7XVMT�ERH�EPQSWX�XLI�IRXMVI�;IWX�&ERO��E�JEMV�ERH�TVEGXMGEP�VIWSPYXMSR�SJ�XLIVIJYKII�MWWYI��ERH�ER�IRH�XS�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRXW MX�MW�RS[�E�TEVMEL�SJ�XLIMRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��)YVSTIER�TYFPMG�STMRMSR��ERH�PEVKI�WIKQIRXW�SJXLI�%QIVMGER�EGEHIQMG�ERH�VIPMKMSYW�PIJX��-WVEIP�LEW�FIGSQI�XLI�SFNIGX�SJHMZIWXMXYVI�ERH�FS]GSXX�GEQTEMKRW�ERH�SXLIV�IJJSVXW�EX�HIQSRMEXMSR�[LMPI�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW [LS�VINIGXIH�XLI�TIEGI�SJJIV�ERH�VIWTSRHIH�[MXLXLI�W]WXIQEXMG�ERH�HIPMFIVEXI�QYVHIV�SJ�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW LEZI�FIGSQI�XLIHEVPMRKW�SJ�XLI�WEQI�KVSYTW�

&YX�MX�MW�RS�MVSR]�EX�EPP��-X�MW�XLI�VIWYPX�SJ�HIPMFIVEXI�GEPGYPEXMSRW�QEHIF]�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�[LS�YRHIVWXERH�LS[�IEW]�MX�MW�XS�TVSZSOI�HIQSG�VEGMIW�MRXS�SZIVVIEGXMSR�F]�QYVHIVMRK�XLIMV�QSWX�ZYPRIVEFPI�GMZMPMERW�*VERGI��)RKPERH��6YWWME��XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��ERH�'EREHE�LEZI�FIIR�WMQM�PEVP]�TVSZSOIH��FYX�SRP]�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�WS�YRJEMVP]�GSRHIQRIH�JSV�MXWIRXMVIP]�YRHIVWXERHEFPI��MJ�WSQIXMQIW�HMWTVSTSVXMSREXI��IJJSVXW�XS�TVSXIGXMXW�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�JVSQ�XIVVSVMWQ��8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�[IPPYRHIVWXERHW�XLI�IEKIVRIWW�SJ�QER]�KVSYTW�XS�GVMXMGMI�JSV�HMZIVWI�VIEWSRWXLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�JSV�EGXMSRW�XLEX�HS�RSX�TVSHYGI�IUYMZEPIRX�GVMXMGMWQ�[LIR

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 126: The Case For Israel

IRKEKIH�MR�F]�SXLIV�REXMSRW�SV�KVSYTW��8LI�VIEWSRW�JSV�XLMW�HSYFPI�WXER�HEVH�PMI�HIIT�[MXLMR�XLI�TW]GLI�ERH�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�WIPIGXMZI�GVMXMGW��FYX�XLIHSYFPI�WXERHEVH�MW�YRHIRMEFPI�ERH�HIQSRWXVEFPI��-X�MW�EPWS�IEKIVP]I\TPSMXIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�

8LI�XVEKIH]�MW�XLEX�F]�ETTP]MRK�XLMW�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH��XLSWI�[LS�EVI�XSSLEVH�SR�-WVEIP��[LMPI�FIMRK�XSS�WSJX�SR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��EGXYEPP]�IRGSYVEKIXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�STX�JSV�XIVVSVMWQ�SZIV�GSQTVSQMWI�ERH�TIEGI��8LI]�XSSWLEVI�WSQI�SJ�XLI�GSQTPMGMX]�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�VIPMERGI�SR�XIVVSVMWQ ERHJSV�XLI�VIWYPXMRK�HIEXLW�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 127: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

%VEJEX�[EW�VMKLX�MR�XYVRMRK�HS[R�XLI�&EVEO§'PMRXSR�TIEGI�TVSTSWEPW�SJ����§������ERH�XLI�JEYPX�JSV�XLI�FVIEOHS[R�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�XEPOW�MW�IMXLIV�EPPSR�XLI�-WVEIPM�WMHI�SV�WLEVIH�F]�&EVEO�ERH�%VEJEX�

8,)�%''97)67

©-R�XLI�[EOI�SJ�XLI�GSPPETWI�SJ�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�7YQQMX�MR�.YP]�������XLIJMRKIV�SJ�FPEQI�[EW�MRWXERXP]�TSMRXIH�EX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�4VIWMHIRX��GLEVKMRKLMQ�[MXL�[MPPJYP�WEFSXEKI�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW�F]�VITYHMEXMRK�)LYH&EVEO¬W�«KIRIVSYW�SJJIV�¬�F]�MRHMVIGXP]�IWTSYWMRK�XLI�PMUYMHEXMSR�SJ�XLI.I[MWL�WXEXI�ERH�XLIR�F]�PEYRGLMRK�E�ZMSPIRX�YTVMWMRK�XS�XLMW�IRH��,I�LEWFIIR�VIZMPIH�EW�ER�YRVITIRXERX�XIVVSVMWX�ERH�ER�MRZIXIVEXI�PMEV��[LS�GSYPHRS�PSRKIV�WYTTVIWW�LMW�XVYI�EMQW��)ZIR�97�4VIWMHIRX�'PMRXSR�ERH�QER]WIPJ�TVSGPEMQIH�WYTTSVXIVW�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�TIEGI�GEQT RYVWMRK�E�HIIT�WIRWISJ�XVYWX�FIXVE]IH NSMRIH�XLI�SVK]�SJ�HIJEQEXMSR�ª��8SR]�/PYK��JSVQIVLIEH�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�HIZIPSTQIRX�EX�%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP�

©8LI�-WVEIPM�+SZIVRQIRX�GEPPIH�SJJ�XLI�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�ª��2SEQ'LSQWO]�

8,)�6)%0-8=

2SX�SRP]�LEZI�4VIWMHIRXW�'PMRXSR�ERH�+ISVKI�;��&YWL�TPEGIH�EPP�SJ�XLIFPEQI�SR�%VEJEX�FYX�WS�LEZI�QER]�SJ�%VEJEX¬W�GPSWIWX�EHZMWIVW��%RH�RS[

���

;EW�%VEJEX�6MKLX�MR8YVRMRK�(S[R�XLI&EVEOi'PMRXSR�4IEGI4VSTSWEP#

��

Page 128: The Case For Israel

IZIR�4VMRGI�&ERHEV�SJ�7EYHM�%VEFME��[LS�TPE]IH�E�GIRXVEP�FI]SRH�XLI�WGIRIW�VSPI�MR�XLI�TIEGI�RIKSXMEXMSRW��LEW�GEPPIH�%VEJEX¬W�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLI&EVEO�SJJIV�©E�GVMQI�EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW MR�JEGX�EKEMRWX�XLI�IRXMVIVIKMSR�ª�4VMRGI�&ERHEV¬W�EWWIWWQIRX�SJ�%VEJEX¬W�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�TVS�TSWEP�ERH�SJ�XLI�VIWYPXMRK�[MHIWTVIEH�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�TVSZMHIWE�GEWI�WXYH]�SJ�LS[�%VEJEX¬W�YWI�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�MW�IRGSYVEKIH�F]�XLI�HSYFPIWXERHEVH�YRHIV�[LMGL�-WVEIP�MW�FPEQIH�JSV�SJJIVMRK�TIEGI�ERH�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�EVI�VI[EVHIH�JSV�VINIGXMRK�TIEGI�

8,)�4633*

:MVXYEPP]�IZIV]SRI�[LS�TPE]IH�ER]�VSPI�MR�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH§8EFE�TIEGITVSGIWW�RS[�TPEGIW�XLI�IRXMVI�FPEQI�JSV�MXW�JEMPYVI�SR�%VEJEX¬W�HIGMWMSR�XSXYVR�HS[R�&EVEO¬W�SJJIV��4VIWMHIRX�'PMRXSR��[LS�[EW�JYVMSYW�EX�%VEJEX�ERHLEW�GEPPIH�LMQ�E�PMEV��LEW�FPEQIH�XLI�JEMPYVI�GSQTPIXIP]�SR�%VEJEX��(IRRMW6SWW��[LS�[EW�XLI�GLMIJ�9�7��RIKSXMEXSV��LEW�WEMH�XLEX�%VEJEX�[EW�YR[MPPMRKXS�EGGITX�ER]�TIEGI�TVSTSWEP��FIGEYWI�JSV�%VEJEX�©XS�IRH�XLI�GSRJPMGX�MW�XS�IRH�LMQWIPJ�ª�8LI�FIWX�TVSSJ�SJ�6SWW¬W�TSMRX�MW�XLEX�%VEJEX�HMH�RSX�IZIR�SJJIV�E�GSYRXIVTVSTSWEP�XS�-WVEIP¬W�SJJIV��,I�WMQTP]�VINIGXIH�MX�ERHSVHIVIH�TVITEVEXMSR�JSV�VIRI[IH�XIVVSVMWQ��4VIWMHIRX�&YWL��EGGSVHMRK�XS8LI�2I[�=SVOIV�EPWS�©TPEGIW�EPP�XLI�FPEQI�JSV�XLI�MRGVIEWI�MR�ZMSPIRGI�SR%VEJEX�ª�

)ZIR�WSQI�SJ�%VEJEX¬W�QSWX�XVYWXIH�EHZMWIVW�ERH�WIRMSV�EWWSGMEXIW�EVIRS[�VIKVIXXMRK�XLI�HIGMWMSR��ERH�%VEJEX�LMQWIPJ�LEW�PIX�MX�FI�ORS[R�XLEX�MJXLI�WEQI�SJJIV�[SYPH�RS[�FI�QEHI��LI�QMKLX�EGGITX�MX EJXIV�ETTVS\M�QEXIP]�������IRXMVIP]�EZSMHEFPI�HIEXLW��3J�GSYVWI��RS�SRI�MR�;EWLMRKXSRSV�MR�-WVEIP�XEOIW�%VEJEX¬W�TVSQMWIW�WIVMSYWP]�EJXIV�LI�PMIH�FSXL�XS�4VIWMHIRX'PMRXSR�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�XS�4VIWMHIRX�+ISVKI�&YWL�[LIR�LI�HIRMIHORS[PIHKI�SJ�XLI�FSEXPSEH�SJ�-VERMER�EVQW�HIWXMRIH�JSV�YWI�F]�4EPIWXMRMERXIVVSVMWXW��HIWTMXI�ER�EHQMWWMSR�F]�XLI�WLMT¬W�GETXEMR�XLEX�LMW�SVHIVW�GEQIHMVIGXP]�JVSQ�%VEJEX��2SV�MW�%VEJEX�XVYWXIH�F]�XLI�QSWX�HSZMWL�QIQFIVW�SJXLI�-WVEIPM�TIEGI�GEQT��QER]�SJ�[LSQ�JIIP�EFWSPYXIP]�FIXVE]IH�F]�LMWVINIGXMSR�SJ�ER�SJJIV�XLEX�XLI]�TVIWWIH�&EVEO�XS�QEOI�ERH�XLEX�XLI]�EWWYVIH&EVEO�XLEX�%VEJEX�[SYPH�EGGITX��8LI]�FPEQI�%VEJEX�JSV�&EVEO¬W�IPIGXSVEPPSWW�XS�7LEVSR�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�VINIGXMSR�SJ�[LEX�QER]�-WVEIPMW�RS[�VIKEVH�EWE�REMZI�ERH�SZIVKIRIVSYW�SJJIV��-J�%VEJEX�[EW�YR[MPPMRK�XS�EGGITX�XLEXSJJIV�XLI]�FIPMIZI�LI�[MPP�FI�YR[MPPMRK�XS�EGGITX�ER]�TIEGI�SJJIV�XLEX�PIEZIW�-WVEIPMR�I\MWXIRGI�-R�E�VIQEVOEFPI�WIVMIW�SJ�MRXIVZMI[W�GSRHYGXIH�F]�)PWE�;EPWL�JSV�8LI

2I[�=SVOIV�4VMRGI�&ERHEV�SJ�7EYHM�%VEFME�LEW�TYFPMGP]�HMWGPSWIH�LMWFILMRH�XLI�WGIRIW�VSPI�MR�XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW�ERH�[LEX�LI�XSPH�%VEJEX��&ER�HEV¬W�HMWGPSWYVIW�KS�[IPP�FI]SRH�ER]XLMRK�TVIZMSYWP]�VIZIEPIH�F]�ER�MRWMHIWSYVGI�XS�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�ERH�TVSZMHI�XLI�FIWX�EZEMPEFPI�IZMHIRGI�SJ�LS[

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 129: The Case For Israel

%VEJEX�TPE]W�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�GEVH�XS�WLMJX�TYFPMG�STMRMSR�RSX�SRP]�MR�XLI�%VEFERH�1YWPMQ�[SVPHW�FYX�MR�XLI�[SVPH�EX�PEVKI�&ERHEV��[LS�LEW�FIIR�E�7EYHM�HMTPSQEX�MR�;EWLMRKXSR�JSV�X[IRX]�]IEVW

ERH�MW�E�LMKL�VEROMRK�QIQFIV�SJ�XLI�VS]EP�JEQMP]��WIVZIH�EW�E�GVYGMEP�MRXIV�QIHMEV]�FIX[IIR�%VEJEX�ERH�XLI�'PMRXSR�EHQMRMWXVEXMSR��,I��PMOI�RIEVP]IZIV]SRI�IPWI��[EW�WYVTVMWIH�EX�&EVEO¬W�©VIQEVOEFPIª�SJJIV�XLEX�KEZI�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�©EFSYX����SJ�XLI�SGGYTMIH�XIVVMXSVMIW�ª�XLI�3PH�'MX]�SJ.IVYWEPIQ�SXLIV�XLER�XLI�.I[MWL�ERH�%VQIRMER�5YEVXIVW��ERH�����FMPPMSRMR�GSQTIRWEXMSR�JSV�XLI�VIJYKIIW��%VEJEX�EWOIH�'VS[R�4VMRGI�%FHYPPEL�XLI�EGXMRK�QSREVGL�SJ�7EYHM�%VEFME��JSV�&ERHEV¬W�LIPT�[MXL�XLI�RIKSXME�XMSRW��&ERHEV�EKVIIH�FYX�XSPH�%FHYPPEL�XLEX�©XLIVI¬W�RSX�QYGL�-�GER�HSYRPIWW�%VEJEX�MW�[MPPMRK�XS�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�XLMW�MW�MX�ª�2S�FIXXIV�SJJIV�JVSQ-WVEIP�[EW�TSWWMFPI�3R�.ERYEV]�������� NYWX�[IIOW�FIJSVI�XLI�IRH�SJ�'PMRXSR¬W�XIVQ

&ERHEV�TMGOIH�%VEJEX�YT�EX�%RHVI[W�%MV�*SVGI�&EWI��[IRX�SZIV�XLI�&EVEOTVSTSWEP��ERH�EWOIH�%VEJEX�[LIXLIV�LI�GSYPH�IZIV�KIX�©E�FIXXIV�HIEP�ª�,IEPWS�TSMRXIHP]�EWOIH�LMQ�[LIXLIV�LI�TVIJIVVIH�XS�HIEP�[MXL�7LEVSR�VEXLIVXLER�&EVEO��%VEJEX�EKVIIH��WMRGI�©&EVEO¬W�RIKSXMEXSVW�EVI�HSZIW�ª�&ERHEVXLIR�VIZMI[IH�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�QMWWIH�STTSVXYRMXMIW�[MXL�%VEJEX��©7MRGI������IZIV]�XMQI�[I¬ZI�LEH�WSQIXLMRK�SR�XLI�XEFPI�[I�WE]�RS��8LIR�[IWE]�]IW��;LIR�[I�WE]�]IW��MX¬W�RSX�SR�XLI�XEFPI�ER]�QSVI��8LIR�[I�LEZI�XSHIEP�[MXL�WSQIXLMRK�PIWW��-WR¬X�MX�EFSYX�XMQI�[I�WE]�]IW#ª�&ERHEV�IQTLE�WMIH�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW�LEH�EP[E]W�XSPH�XLI�%QIVMGERW�XLEX�MJ�©?]ASY�KIX�YW�EHIEP�XLEX¬W�3�/��SR�.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�[I¬VI�KSMRK��XSS�ª�&ERHEV�PEMH�SYX�XLISTXMSRW�XS�%VEJEX��©)MXLIV�]SY�XEOI�XLMW�HIEP�SV�[I�KS�XS�[EV��-J�]SY�XEOIXLMW�HIEP��[I�[MPP�EPP�XLVS[�SYV�[IMKLX�FILMRH�]SY��-J�]SY�HSR¬X�XEOI�XLMWHIEP��HS�]SY�XLMRO�ER]FSH]�[MPP�KS�XS�[EV�JSV�]SY#ª�

7LSVXP]�XLIVIEJXIV��&ERHEV�WXIVRP]�[EVRIH�%VEJEX��©-�LSTI�]SY�VIQIQ�FIV��WMV��[LEX�-�XSPH�]SY��-J�[I�PSWI�XLMW�STTSVXYRMX]��MX�MW�RSX�KSMRK�XS�FI�E�XVEKIH]��MX�MW�KSMRK�XS�FI�E�GVMQI�ª�(IWTMXI�%VEJEX¬W�TVSQMWIW�XLEX�LI[SYPH�XEOI�XLI�HIEP�MJ�7EYHM�%VEFME�ERH�)K]TX�KEZI�LMQ�GSZIV��ERH�HIWTMXI)K]TXMER�ERH�7EYHM�EWWYVERGIW�ERH�&ERHEV¬W�XLVIEXW��%VEJEX�VINIGXIH�XLIHIEP�ERH�JPI[�LSQI�[MXLSYX�SJJIVMRK�ER]�GSYRXIVTVSTSWEPW�SV�EQIRH�QIRXW��%W�XLI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�JEPXIVIH��%VEJEX�SVHIVIH�LMW�XIVVSVMWX�PIEHIVW�XSVEXGLIX�YT�XLI�ZMSPIRGI��,I�LEH�E�TPER�JSV�LS[�XS�XYVR�E�TYFPMG�VIPEXMSRWHMWEWXIV�ERH�E�GVMQI�EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�MRXS�E�TYFPMG�VIPEXMSRWFSRERE��-X�[EW�E�XVMIH�ERH�XVYI�TPER��MX�[SVOIH�IZIR�QSVI�IJJIGXMZIP]�XLMWXMQI�XLER�MX�LEH�MR�XLI�TEWX�&YX�JMVWX��FEGO�XS�4VMRGI�&ERHEV��[LS�[EW�TVMZEXIP]�JYVMSYW�EX�%VEJEX

FIGEYWI�LI�LEH�PMIH�XS�LMQ��,I�[EW��LS[IZIV��RSX�WYVTVMWIH��EW�;EPWLVITSVXW��©&ERHEV�XSPH�EWWSGMEXIW�XLEX�MX�[EW�ER�STIR�WIGVIX�[MXLMR�XLI�%VEF[SVPH�XLEX�%VEJEX�[EW�RSX�XVYXLJYP�ª�-R�TVMZEXI��&ERHEV�FPEQIH�IZIV]XLMRKSR�%VEJEX��©'PMRXSR��XLI�FEWXEVH��VIEPP]�XVMIH�LMW�FIWX�ª�&ERHEV�XSPH�;EPWL

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 130: The Case For Israel

SR�XLI�VIGSVH��8LI�QSWX�GVMXMGEP�SJ�LMW�GSQQIRXW�VIKEVHMRK�%VEJEX�[IVIETTEVIRXP]�QEHI�SJJ�XLI�VIGSVH��EKEMR�EW�VITSVXIH�F]�;EPWL�

&ERHEV�FIPMIZIH�XLEX�%VEJEX¬W�JEMPYVI�XS�EGGITX�XLI�HIEP�MR�.ERYEV]�SJ�����

[EW�E�XVEKMG�QMWXEOI E�GVMQI��VIEPP]��=IX�XS�WE]�WS�TYFPMGP]�[SYPH�HEQEKI

XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�GEYWI�������

&ERHEV�[EW�TEVXMGYPEVP]�ERKV]�[MXL�%VEJEX�FIGEYWI�MJ�LI�TYFPMGP]

HIJIRHIH�&EVEO¬W�EGGSYRX��MX�[SYPH�QEOI�LMQ�WSYRH�PMOI�ER�ETSPSKMWX�JSV

&EVEO�ERH�-WVEIP��©-�[EW�XLIVI��-�[EW�E�[MXRIWW��-�GERRSX�PMI�ª�LI�WEMH

TVMZEXIP]��

&YX�LI�[EW�[MPPMRK�XS�QEOI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�HEQRMRK�WXEXIQIRXW�SR�XLIVIGSVH�

©-�WXMPP�LEZI�RSX�VIGSZIVIH��XS�FI�LSRIWX�[MXL�]SY��MRWMHI��JVSQ�XLI�QEK�

RMXYHI�SJ�XLI�QMWWIH�STTSVXYRMX]�XLEX�.ERYEV]�ª�&ERHEV�XSPH�QI�EX�LMW

LSQI�MR�1G0IER��:MVKMRME��©7M\XIIR�LYRHVIH�4EPIWXMRMERW�HIEH�WS�JEV�

%RH�WIZIR�LYRHVIH�-WVEIPMW�HIEH��-R�Q]�NYHKQIRX��RSX�SRI�PMJI�SJ�XLSWI

-WVEIPMW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�HIEH�MW�NYWXMJMIH�ª�

&YX�XLMW�MW�RSX�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�WXSV]��2S[�[I�KS�FEGO�XS�%VEJEX¬W�KVERHTPER�JSV�KIXXMRK�&ERHEV��XLI�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW��ERH�QSWX�SJ�XLI�VIWX�SJ�XLI[SVPH�FEGO�SR�LMW�WMHI��8LI�TPER�[EW�WMQTPI��WXEVX�QYVHIVMRK�.I[W�EXTVE]IV��-WVEIPM�XIIREKIVW�EX�TME�TEVPSVW�ERH�HMWGSW��TVIKRERX�[SQIR�MRWLSTTMRK�QEPPW��[SVOIVW�XEOMRK�E�JEPEJIP�FVIEO��ERH�YRMZIVWMX]�WXYHIRXW�WMT�TMRK�WSHE�MR�E�WXYHIRX�PSYRKI��=SY�GER�GSYRX�SR�ER�-WVEIPM�SZIVVIEGXMSR�IWTIGMEPP]�EJXIV�]SY�LIPTIH�IPIGX�E�LE[OMWL�KIRIVEP�EW�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV��[LSTVSQMWIH�XS�FI�XSYKL�SR�XIVVSVMWQ��)ZIR�MJ�XLIVI�MW�RS�SZIVVIEGXMSR��XLIVI[MPP�WYVIP]�FI�WSQIVIEGXMSR�XLEX�]SY�GER�GLEVEGXIVMI�EW�ER�SZIVVIEGXMSR�)ZIR�ER�YRHIVVIEGXMSR�XS�XIVVSVMWQ�[MPP�TVSHYGI�WSQI�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�IWTIGMEPP]�MJ�]SY�EVI�GEVIJYP�XS�PSGEXI�]SYV�FSQF�QEOMRK�JEGXSVMIW�EPSRKWMHIOMRHIVKEVXIRW�ERH�XS�YWI�[SQIR��MRGPYHMRK�TVIKRERX�[SQIR �ERH�GLMPHVIREW�LYQER�WLMIPHW��FSQF��ERH�VSGO�XLVS[IVW��ERH�IZIR�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�8LI�TPER�[SVOIH��IZIR�[MXL�&ERHEV��[LS�ORI[�I\EGXP]�[LEX�%VEJEX�[EW

HSMRK��;EPWL�HIWGVMFIW�LS[�XLI�GVS[R�TVMRGI�[EW�[EXGLMRK�XIPIZMWMSR�ERHWE[�ER�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIV�WLSZMRK�E�4EPIWXMRMER�[SQER��8LI�TVMRGI�TLSRIH&ERHEV��©8LMW�MW�MX��8LSWI�FEWXEVHW��)ZIR�[SQIR XLI]¬VI�WXITTMRK�EPPSZIV�XLIQ�ª��

&ERHEV�HIWGVMFIH�XLI�ERKIV�SJ�XLI�TVMRGI��IWTIGMEPP]�EX�XLI�-WVEIPM�TVEG�XMGI�SJ�HIWXVS]MRK�XLI�LSYWIW�SJ�JEQMP]�QIQFIVW�SJ�XIVVSVMWXW��©;I�[SRHIVLS[�XLI�%QIVMGER�TISTPI�[SYPH�LEZI�EGGITXIH�XLI�4VIWMHIRX�SJ�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW�SVHIVMRK�EPP�XLI�1G:IMKL�JEQMP]�LSYWIW�XS�FI�HIWXVS]IH�SVFYVRMRK�XLIMV�JEVQW�ª�LI�WEMH��VIJIVVMRK�XS�XLI�3OPELSQE�'MX]�FSQFIV8MQSXL]�1G:IMKL���

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 131: The Case For Israel

%FHYPPEL�JEMPIH�XS�QIRXMSR�XLEX�1G:IMKL¬W�JEQMP]�HMH�RSX�TVEMWI�XLIMVWSR¬W�EGXMSRW��2SV�HMH�XLI]�EWWMWX�LMQ�ERH�IRGSYVEKI�LMQ�XS�FIGSQI�EQEVX]V��1SVISZIV��LI�[EW�RSX�TEVX�SJ�ER�SRKSMRK�IJJSVX�XLEX�GSRXMRYIW�XSXIVVSVMI�GMZMPMERW�%W�E�VIWYPX�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�VIWTSRWI�XS�XLI�GEPGYPEXIH�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�

%FHYPPEL�SVHIVIH�&ERHEV�XS�QIIX�[MXL�4VIWMHIRX�&YWL��-R�SRI�WYGL�QIIX�MRK��&ERHEV�WLS[IH�&YWL�TLSXSKVETLW�SJ�HIEH�4EPIWXMRMER�GLMPHVIR��,IHMH�RSX�WLS[�&YWL�TLSXSKVETLW�SJ�XLI�QER]�QSVI.I[MWL�GLMPHVIR�[LSLEZI�FIIR�HIPMFIVEXIP]OMPPIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�XLER�4EPIWXMRMER�GLMP�HVIR��WSQI�SJ�XLIQ�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW �[LS�LEZI�FIIR�EGGMHIRXEPP]OMPPIH�F]-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW��&YX�E�TLSXSKVETL�SJ�E�HIEH�GLMPH�MW�GIVXEMR�XS�MRZSOI�W]Q�TEXL]��ERH�EW�;EPWL�VITSVXW��&YWL¬W�©I]IW�WIIQIH�XS�[IPP�YT�ª7MQMPEV�SRI�WMHIH�TMGXYVIW�[IVI�FIMRK�XIPIGEWX�XS�XLI�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ

WXVIIX��GVIEXMRK�XVIQIRHSYW�W]QTEXL]�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�LEXVIHXS[EVH�XLI�-WVEIPMW��[LMGL�[EW�TVIGMWIP]�XLI�KSEP�SJ�XLI�%VEJEX�TPER��8IV�VSVMWQ�[SVOW�FIXXIV�SR�XLI�%VEF�WXVIIX�XLER�RIKSXMEXMSRW��IWTIGMEPP]�MJ�MXTVSHYGIW�XLI�MRXIRHIH�HSYFPI�FIRIJMX��XLI�©GSYVEKISYWª�QEVX]VHSQEGXMSRW�SJ�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�[LS�OMPP�LEXIH�-WVEIPMW��JSPPS[IH�F]�XLI-WVEIPM�VIEGXMSR��[LMGL�TVSZMHIW�RI[�4EPIWXMRMER�QEVX]VW��8LI�IJJIGX�SR�XLI%VEF�WXVIIX�UYMGOP]�XVERWPEXIH�MRXS�TVIWWYVI�SR�%VEF�KSZIVRQIRXW��[LMGLMR�XYVR�TYX�TVIWWYVI�SR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��-R�XLMW�GEWI��&ERHEV�TVIWWIH�XLI%QIVMGERW�XS�GSRXVSP�XLI�-WVEIPMW�©IZIR�MJ�XLI]�HMHR¬X�XVYWX�%VEJEX�ª

-X�HMH�RSX�LIPT�&YWL�MR�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�XLEX�LI�WIIQIH�XS�TPEGI�EPP�XLI

FPEQI�SR�%VEJEX��-R�1E]��'VS[R�4VMRGI�%FHYPPEL�TYFPMGP]�HIGPMRIH�ER

MRZMXEXMSR�XS�XLI�;LMXI�,SYWI��©;I�[ERX�XLIQ�XS�PSSO�EX�XLI�VIEPMX]�ERH

XS�GSRWMHIV�XLIMV�GSRWGMIRGI�ª�LI�WEMH�XS�E�VITSVXIV�JSV�XLI�*MRERGMEP

8MQIW�©(SR¬X�XLI]�WII�[LEX�MW�LETTIRMRK�XS�4EPIWXMRMER�GLMPHVIR�

[SQIR��XLI�IPHIVP] XLI�LYQMPMEXMSR��XLI�LYRKIV#ª��

8LI�VIWYPX�SJ�EPP�XLMW�TVIWWYVI�[EW�E�WXEXIQIRX�F]�4VIWMHIRX�&YWL�MRJEZSV�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI XLI�JMVWX�XMQI�E�9�7��TVIWMHIRX�LEW�SJJMGMEPP]IRHSVWIH�XLMW�SYXGSQI��-�TIVWSREPP]�JEZSV�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMERWXEXI�EW�E�GSRWIUYIRGI�SJ�QEOMRK�FIWX�IJJSVXW�XS�IRH�XIVVSVMWQ��RSX�EW�EVI[EVH�JSV�MRGVIEWMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�EW�E�GEVIJYPP]�GEPGYPEXIH�XEGXMG�XS�EGLMIZIWXEXILSSH��8LI�VIEP�TSMRX�MW�LS[�%VEJEX�QERMTYPEXIW�TYFPMG�STMRMSR�F]XYVRMRK�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�WTMKSX�SJJ�ERH�SR��)ZIR�XLSWI�[LS�ORS[�MRXIPPIGXY�EPP][LEX�%VEJEX�MW�HSMRK PMOI�4VMRGI�&ERHEV ERH�XLEX�LI�MW�IRXMVIP]�XSFPEQI�JSV�XLI�GSPPETWI�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW��EVI�RS[�IQSXMSREPP]GSQTIPPIHXS�WYTTSVX�XLI�©ZMGXMQWª�SJ�-WVEIPM�SZIVVIEGXMSR�XS�XIVVSVMWQ��IZIR�XLSYKLXLI�XIVVSVMWQ�[EW�GEPGYPEXIH�XS�GEYWI�XLMW�VIWTSRWI�ERH�XLI�[SVPH¬W�IQS�XMSREP�VITP]�XS�MX��8IVVSVMWQ�[SVOW��ERH�%VEJEX�I\TPSMXW�XLMW�VIEPMX]�8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�QEHI�E�XVEKMG�QMWXEOI�MR�VINIGXMRK�XLI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 132: The Case For Israel

&EVEO§'PMRXSR�TIEGI�SJJIV�SJ�����§������=IX��QSWX�4EPIWXMRMERW�FPEQI-WVEIP�JSV�XLIMV�S[R�PIEHIV¬W�QMWXEOIW��8LMW�MW�TEVX�SJ�E�PSRK�TEXXIVR��EWHIWGVMFIH�F]�XLI�LMWXSVMER�&IRR]�1SVVMW�MR�ER�EVXMGPI�MR�%TVMP������

?3ARI�SJ�XLI�GLEVEGXIVMWXMGW�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�REXMSREP�QSZIQIRX�LEW

FIIR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW¬�ZMI[�SJ�XLIQWIPZIW�EW�TIVTIXYEP�ZMGXMQW�SJ�SXLIVW

3XXSQER�8YVOW��&VMXMWL�SJJMGMEPW��>MSRMWXW��%QIVMGERW ERH�RIZIV�XS

ETTVIGMEXI�XLEX�XLI]�EVI��EX�PIEWX�MR�PEVKI�TEVX��ZMGXMQW�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�QMW�

XEOIW�ERH�MRMUYMXMIW��-R�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�;IPXERWGLEYYRK��XLI]�RIZIV�WIX�E

JSSX�[VSRK��XLIMV�QMWJSVXYRIW�EVI�EP[E]W�XLI�JEYPX�SJ�SXLIVW��8LI

MRIZMXEFPI�GSVSPPEV]�SJ�XLMW�VIJYWEP�XS�VIGSKRMI�XLIMV�S[R�LMWXSVMGEP�EKIRG]

LEW�FIIR�E�TIVTIXYEP�4EPIWXMRMER�[LMRMRK XLEX��-�JIEV��MW�XLI�ETX�XIVQ

XS�XLI�SYXWMHI�[SVPH�XS�WEZI�XLIQ�JVSQ�[LEX�MW�YWYEPP]�XLIMV�S[R�JEYPX���

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 133: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�JEGX�XLEX�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLER�-WVEIPMW�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�HYVMRK�XLIVIGIRX�WTEXI�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ��7ITXIQFIV������XS�TVIWIRX �TVSZIW�XLEX�-WVEIP¬WVIWTSRWI�MW�[SVWI�XLER�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�

8,)�%''97)67

©-�GER¬X�FIPMIZI�XLEX�EW�E�QER�SJ�XLI�GPSXL��]SY¬VI�RSX�EPEVQIH�F]�XLI�YWISJ�%QIVMGER�EXXEGO�LIPMGSTXIVW��FSQFIVW��XEROW��EXXEGOMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERHIJIRWI�TSPMGI�JSVGI�[MXL�TMWXSPW��[MXL�]SYRK�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��=SY�ORS[�QE]FI�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�HMIH�MR�XLMW�XLER�XLI�-WVEIPMW��%VIR¬X�]SYETTEPPIH�EW�E�QER�SJ�XLI�GPSXL�SJ�XLI�YWI�SJ�%QIVMGER�[IETSRW�XEOMRK�WSQER]�GMZMPMER�PMZIW#ª��&SF�2SZEO��TSPMXMGEP�GSQQIRXEXSV�

©%FFEW�,EQMHIL�WEMH�LI�[EW�YTWIX�F]�QIHME�VITSVXW�XLEX�HITMGX�-WVEIPMWEW�ZMGXMQW�[LIR�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�HMIH�WMRGI�XLI�WIGSRH�MRXMJEHEFIKER�MR�7ITXIQFIV������ª��)VRMI�+EVGME��NSYVREPMWX�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LIVI�EVI�WIZIVEP�MQTSVXERX�VIEWSRW�[L]�XLMW�GSQTEVMWSR�MW�QMWPIEHMRK�8LIWI�MRGPYHI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�4EPIWXMRMERW�GSYRX�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�XLIQ�WIPZIW�EW�ZMGXMQW�ERH�MKRSVI�XLI�PEVKI�RYQFIV�SJ�JSMPIH�ERH�TVIZIRXIH�XIV�VSVMWX�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPMW�

���

;L]�,EZI�1SVI4EPIWXMRMERW�8LER�-WVEIPMW�&IIR�/MPPIH#

��

Page 134: The Case For Israel

8,)�4633*

8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�[MPPJYPP]�XVMIH�XS�OMPP�QER]�QSVI�-WVEIPMW�XLER�XLI]�LEZIWYGGIIHIH�MR�HSMRK��[LIVIEW�XLI�HIEXLW�EXXVMFYXEFPI�XS�-WVEIP�LEZI�QSWXP]FIIR�GEYWIH�EGGMHIRXEPP]�MR�E�PIKMXMQEXI�IJJSVX�XS�XV]�XS�WXST�XIVVSVMWQ��*SVI\EQTPI��HYVMRK�XLI�JMVWX�X[S�QSRXLW�SJ�������XLIVI�[IVI�RS�WYGGIWWJYP�XIV�VSVMWX�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW��8LMW�[EW�RSX�FIGEYWI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIV�VSVMWXW�HMH�RSX�QEOI�GSRWMHIVEFPI�IJJSVXW�XS�GSQQMX�PIXLEP�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�-WVEIPM�EYXLSVMXMIW�TVIZIRXIH�LYRHVIHWSJ�EXXIQTXIH�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�HYVMRKXLEX�XMQI�TIVMSH�EPSRI��%R�EXXIQTXIH�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGO�GEVVMIW�XLI�WEQI�QSVEPGYPTEFMPMX]�EW�E�WYGGIWWJYP�SRI��-J�IEGL�SJ�XLIWI�MRXIRHIH�ERH�[IPP�TPERRIHEXXEGOW�LEH�FIIR�WYGGIWWJYP��TIVLETW�EW�QER]�EW�E�XLSYWERH�-WVEIPM�GMXMIRW[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�HYVMRK�XLIWI�X[S�QSRXLW�SJ�©UYMIXª�ERH�XIRW�SJXLSYWERHW�QSVI�WMRGI�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�VIWYQIH�MR������

-R�SRI�TPERRIH�EXXEGO�EPSRI XLI�XL[EVXIH�FSQFMRK�SJ�XLI�7LEPSQ8S[IVW��-WVEIP¬W�IUYMZEPIRX�SJ�XLI�;SVPH�8VEHI�'IRXIV LYRHVIHW�SJ�GMZMP�MERW�QMKLX�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH��-R�ERSXLIV��XLI�XL[EVXIH�EXXEGO�SR�XLI�4M+PMPSX�KEW�ERH�JYIP�WXSVEKI�JEGMPMX]�MR�8IP�%ZMZ��XLSYWERHW�QSVI�QMKLX�LEZIFIIR�OMPPIH��&IX[IIR�7ITXIQFIV������ERH�%YKYWX������©ETTVS\MQEXIP]�������EXXEGOW�LEZI�FIIR�QEHI�EKEMRWX�XLI�PMJI��TIVWSR�ERH�TVSTIVX]�SJMRRSGIRX�-WVEIPM�GMXMIRW�ERH�VIWMHIRXW��XLI�IPHIVP]��GLMPHVIR��ERH�[SQIR�ª�

1ER]�LEZI�SGGYVVIH�WMRGI��8LSYWERHW�QSVI�[IVI�XL[EVXIH�SV�TVI�ZIRXIH��%�GSRWIVZEXMZI�IWXMQEXI�SJ�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�-WVEIPMW�[LS�QMKLX�LEZIFIIR�OMPPIH�MJ�EPP�SV�QSWX�SJ�XLIWI�EXXIQTXW�LEH�WYGGIIHIH�MW�EX�PIEWX�XIRXMQIW�LMKLIV�XLER�XLI�QSVI�XLER�����[LS�LEZI�EGXYEPP]�FIIR�OMPPIH�

8LI�RYQFIV�SJ�-WVEIPM�GMXMIRW�OMPPIH��EW�GSQTEVIH�[MXL�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ4EPIWXMRMER�GMXMIRW�OMPPIH��EPWS�VIJPIGXW�HMJJIVIRX�TVMSVMXMIW�MR�XLI�EPPSGEXMSRSJ�QIHMGEP�GEVI�XS�XLI�MRNYVIH��-WVEIP�LEW�EPPSGEXIH�ZIV]�WYFWXERXMEPVIWSYVGIW�XS�MXW�QIHMGEP�VIWTSRWI�XS�XIVVSVMWQ��-X�LEW�HIZIPSTIH�E�QIHMGEPWTIGMEPX]�SJ�XVIEXMRK�ZMGXMQW�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�ERH�LEW�QEREKIH�XS�XYVRLYRHVIHW�SJ�[LEX�[SYPH�SXLIV[MWI�LEZI�FIIR�PIXLEP�VIWYPXW�MRXS�ZIV]�WIVM�SYW��SJXIR�TIVQERIRX��FYX�RSRPIXLEP�MRNYVMIW��8LI�RYQFIV�SJ�ZIV]�WIVMSYWP]MRNYVIH�-WVEIPMW�[MXL�TIVQERIRX�HMWEFMPMXMIW�SV�[SYRHW�MW�MR�XLI�XLSYWERHW�1ER]�SJ�XLIWI�ZMGXMQW�[SYPH�LEZI�HMIH�MJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�QIHMGEP�VIWTSRWI�LEHRSX�FIIR�WS�I\XVESVHMREV]�

8LI2I[�=SVO�8MQIWLEW�VITSVXIH��©6IWIEVGL�TYFPMWLIH�XLMW�]IEV?(IGIQFIV�����A�WYKKIWXW�XLEX�XLI�QSWX�WMKRMJMGERX�JEGXSV�MR�OIITMRK�XLILSQMGMHI�VEXI�HS[R�MW�������JEWXIV�EQFYPERGIW�ERH�FIXXIV�GEVI�MR�XLI�IQIV�KIRG]�VSSQ�ª�8LI�VIWIEVGL�GSRGPYHIH��©8LI�QYVHIV�VEXI�MW�FIMRK�EVXMJM�GMEPP]�WYTTVIWWIH�FIGEYWI�XLSYWERHW�SJ�TSXIRXMEP�LSQMGMHI�ZMGXMQW�������EVIRS[�VIGIMZMRK�W[MJX�QIHMGEP�EXXIRXMSR�ERH�WYVZMZMRK�ª�8LI�PIXLEPMX]�VEXI�MWHVSTTMRK�F]�EW�QYGL�EW����TIVGIRX��%WWEMPERXW�©EVIR¬X�ER]�PIWW�QYVHIV�SYW MX¬W�NYWX�KIXXMRK�LEVHIV�XS�OMPP�ª�8LI�WEQI�MW�XVYI�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�XIV�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 135: The Case For Israel

VSVMWXW��XLI]�EVI�RSX�ER]�PIWW�QYVHIVSYW MX¬W�NYWX�KIXXMRK�LEVHIV�JSV�XLIQXS�OMPP�-WVEIPMW�FIGEYWI�SJ�XLI�I\GIPPIRX�QIHMGEP�VIWTSRWI�

-WVEIP¬W�QIHMGEP�VIWTSRWI�XS�XIVVSVMWQ�QYWX�FI�GSRXVEWXIH�[MXL�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�VIWTSRWI��8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�LEW�HIGMHIH�RS�PSRKIV�XSXVERWJIV�[SYRHIH�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�-WVEIPM�LSWTMXEPW��HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX-WVEIPM�LSWTMXEPW�EVI�GSQTPIXIP]�RSRTSPMXMGEP�MR�XLIMV�XVIEXQIRX�SJ�TEXMIRXW�XVMEKMRK�XLIQ�F]�VIJIVIRGI�XS�XLI�WIVMSYWRIWW�SJ�XLIMV�MRNYVMIW�VEXLIV�XLERF]�[LMGL�WMHI�SJ�XLI�GSRJPMGX�XLI]�LETTIR�XS�FI�SR��-WVEIP¬W�LIEPXL�QMRMW�XIV�©LEW�WIZIVEP�XMQIW�SJJIVIH�XS�XVIEX�EPP�4EPIWXMRMERW�[SYRHIH�MR�XLI�GYV�VIRX�-RXMJEHE�EX�-WVEIPM�LSWTMXEPW�ERH�EX�-WVEIP¬W�I\TIRWI�ª�8LI�QMRMWXIVRSXIH�XLEX�©4EPIWXMRMER�QIHMGEP�JEGMPMXMIW�EVI�YREFPI�XS�XVIEX�QER]�SJ�XLI[SYRHIH�EHIUYEXIP]�ª�8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VINIGXIH�XLI�SJJIV��EGGSVHMRK�XS�XLILIEPXL�QMRMWXIV��©FIGEYWI�XLI]�TVIJIV�XLEX�[I�HSR¬X�ORS[�XLI�XVYXL�EFSYXXLI�RYQFIV�SJ�XLIMV�[SYRHIH�ª�;LEXIZIV�XLI�VIEWSRW��XLI�VIEPMX]�MW�XLEXWMKRMJMGERXP]�JI[IV�4EPIWXMRMERW�[SYPH�LEZI�HMIH�SJ�XLIMV�MRNYVMIW�MJ�XLIMVPIEHIVW�LEH�FIIR�[MPPMRK�XS�LEZI�XLIQ�XVIEXIH�F]�-WVEIP¬W�I\GIPPIRX�JMVWXVIWTSRHIVW�VEXLIV�XLER�F]�SJXIR�MRGSQTIXIRX�4EPIWXMRMER�HSGXSVW�ERH�MREH�IUYEXI�4EPIWXMRMER�LSWTMXEPW�

)ZIR�EW�JEV�FEGO�EW�������[LIR�XLIVI�[EW�GSRWMHIVEFP]�PIWW�ZMSPIRGI�4EPIWXMRMER�LSWTMXEP�EHQMRMWXVEXSVW�EPPS[IH�©��MRNYVIH�4EPIWXMRMERW�?XS�HMIAJVSQ�E�PEGO�SJ�FPSSH�[LMPI�FIMRK�WIRX�JVSQ�,IFVSR�XS�1SLEWWIH�,SWTM�XEP�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�F]�EQFYPERGI��8LMW�SGGYVVIH�[LMPI�?-WVEIPA�SJJIVIH�LIPM�GSTXIVW�XS�XVERWTSVX�XLI�MRNYVIH�XS�-WVEIPM�LSWTMXEPW�JSV�JVII�QIHMGEPEXXIRXMSR�ª�%�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�NYWXMGI�ETTSMRXIH�XS�MRZIWXMKEXI�XLMW�XVEKIH]©[EW�JYVMSYWª�[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�EHQMRMWXVEXSVW��HIGPEVMRK�XLEX�LI�HSIWRSX�©YRHIVWXERH�XLI�MHIE�SJ�VIJYWMRK�XS�EGGITX�QIHMGEP�EMH�SR�TSPMXMGEPKVSYRHW�ª�8LI�VIJYWEP�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�XEOI�XLIMV�[SYRHIH�XS�XLI�FIWXEZEMPEFPI�QIHMGEP�JEGMPMX]�LEW�GIVXEMRP]�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�TVI�ZIRXEFPI�4EPIWXMRMER�HIEXLW�

1SVISZIV��HIWTMXI�XLI�IRSVQSYW�TIVWSREP�[IEPXL�EGGYQYPEXIH�F]4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�XLVSYKL�TIVWSREP�GSVVYTXMSR %VEJEX¬W�TIVWSREP�[IEPXLEGGSVHMRK�XS�*SVFIWQEKEMRI�MW�MR�I\GIWW�SJ������QMPPMSR ZIV]�PMXXPIQSRI]�LEW�FIIR�EPPSGEXIH�XS�YTKVEHMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]¬W�TVMQ�MXMZI�IQIVKIRG]�QIHMGMRI�W]WXIQ��8LMW�XSS�LEW�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�XLI�RYQFIVSJ�RSRPIXLEP�[SYRHW�XLEX�LEZI�TVSZIH�JEXEP�

7SQI�4EPIWXMRMER�WTSOIWTIVWSRW�GSYRX�EQSRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�HIEHWSQI�SV�EPP�SJ�XLI�JSPPS[MRK��XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�XLIQWIPZIW��EVQIH�4EPIW�XMRMER�JMKLXIVW��PIEHIVW�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW��MRGPYHMRK�XLSWI�PMOI�XLI�)RKMRIIV�[LS�LEH�STIVEXMSREP�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�FSQF�QEOMRK��XIVVSVMWXW�WLSX�MR�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�[LMPI�TPERXMRK�SV�XLVS[MRK�FSQFW��FSQF�QEOIVW��ERH�XLIMV�RIMKL�FSVW �[LS�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�[LIR�XLI�FSQFW�XLI]�[IVI�QEOMRK�EGGMHIRXEPP]FPI[�YT��GSPPEFSVEXSVW�[LS�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�F]�SXLIV�4EPIWXMRMERW��IZIRTISTPI�[LS�LEZI�HMIH�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�XLI�EFWYVH�ERH�HERKIVSYW�TVEGXMGI�SJ

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 136: The Case For Israel

WLSSXMRK�PMZI�EQQYRMXMSR�MR�XLI�EMV�EX�4EPIWXMRMER�JYRIVEPW�ERH�TVSXIWXW��8LIZIV]�MHIE�XLEX�ER]SRI[SYPH�GSYRX�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�ERH�SXLIV�XIVVSVMWXW�[LSLEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�EW�ZMGXMQWXS�FI�GSQTEVIH�[MXL�XLI�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�[LS[IVI�XLIMV�XEVKIXW�MW�WS�EFWYVH�ERH�MQQSVEP�XLEX�MX�HIJMIW�I\TPEREXMSR�EW�XSLS[�XLI�QIHME�GSYPH�TVIWIRX�XLIWI�JMKYVIW�EW�GSQTEVEXMZI�GEWYEPXMIW�[MXL�EWXVEMKLX�JEGI��=IX�QER]�RI[WTETIVW��ERH�XIPIZMWMSR�ERH�VEHMS�EGGSYRXW��GSR�XMRYI�XS�TVSZMHI�XLIWI�EW]QQIXVMGEP�ERH�FMEWIH�GSQTEVMWSRW�

8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EPWS�GSYRX�MRRSGIRX�TISTPI�GEYKLX�MR�GVSWWJMVIFIX[IIR�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH�-WVEIPM�JMKLXIVW��IZIR�MR�WMXYEXMSRW�[LIVI�MX�GERRSXFI�ORS[R�[LMGL�WMHI�JMVIH�XLI�JEXEP�WLSX��*SV�I\EQTPI��XLI�GLMPH�[LS�[EWJMPQIH�F]�*VIRGL�8:�FIMRK�WLSX�MR�LMW�JEXLIV¬W�EVQW�QE]�[IPP�LEZI�FIIRWLSX�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�KYRQIR��EGGSVHMRK�XS�E�+IVQER�8:�MRZIWXMKEXMZIVITSVX�GSQTEVMRK�XLI�ERKPI�SJ�XLI�FYPPIXW�[MXL�XLI�PSGEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERERH�-WVEIPM�JMKLXIVW��©8LI�I\XIRWMZI�IZMHIRGI�TSMRXW��[MXL�LMKL�TVSFEFMPMX]�XS�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�XLI�-WVEIPMW�HMH�RSX�HS�MX�ª� 1SVISZIV��4EPIWXMRMERWTSOIWTIVWSRW�FPEXERXP]�I\EKKIVEXI�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�ZMGXMQW��EW�XLI]�HMH�JSP�PS[MRK�XLI�JMKLXMRK�MR�.IRMR�MR�������4EPIWXMRMERW�MRMXMEPP]�GPEMQIH�XLEX-WVEIP�LEH�©QEWWEGVIHª�������GMZMPMERW��8LIR�XLI]�VIHYGIH�XLIMV�RYQFIV�XS�����8LI�9�2��WIGVIXEV]�KIRIVEP�JSYRH�XLI�XSXEP�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERWOMPPIH�XS�FI�����QER]�SJ�[LSQ�[IVI�EVQIH�GSQFEXERXW��8LIVI�MW�RSIZMHIRGI�XLEX�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�OMPPIH�IZIR�E�WMRKPI�GMZMPMER�HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�EVQIH�JMKLXIVW�WLSSXMRK�JVSQ�EQSRK�GMZMPMERW�MR�.IRMRERH�FSSF]�XVETTMRK�GMZMPMER�LSQIW�OMPPIH����-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW��8LMW�[MPPJYPI\EKKIVEXMSR�MW�EPP�XSS�X]TMGEP��IZIR�EQSRK�4EPIWXMRMER�EGEHIQMGW��4VSJIW�WSV�)H[EVH�7EMH�LEW�[VMXXIR�XLEX�©LYRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW�?LEZI�FIIRAOMPPIH�������F]�-WVEIP�[MXL�9�7��WYTTSVX�ª��8LMW�MW�WMQTP]�E�PMI��3RI�QSVITSPMXI�GVMXMG�GEPPIH�MX�©E�TVITSWXIVSYW�GPEMQ�ª��

)ZIR�[MXL�EPP�SJ�XLIWI�HMWXSVXMSRW�ERH�I\EKKIVEXMSRW��XLI�EGXYEP�RYQFIVSJ�MRRSGIRX�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERW�OMPPIH�F]�-WVEIPMW�MW�GSRWMHIVEFP]�PS[IV�XLERXLI�RYQFIV�SJ�MRRSGIRX�-WVEIPMW�OMPPIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMERW��8LI�ZEWX�QENSVMX]�SJ4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�[IVI�OMPPIH�[IVI�HMVIGXP]�MRZSPZIH�MR�XIVVSVMWX�EGXMZMX]�8LSWI�[LS�[IVI�RSX�HMVIGXP]�MRZSPZIH�[IVI�OMPPIH�EGGMHIRXEPP]�MR�XLIGSYVWI�SJ�PIKMXMQEXI�QMPMXEV]�EGXMSRW�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWXW��%GGSVHMRK�XS�ERMRXIVREP�EREP]WMW�F]�XLI�-(*��EW�VITSVXIH�MR�XLI�&SWXSR�+PSFIMR�%TVMP������©���TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�RIEVP]�������4EPIWXMRMERW�OMPPIH�F]�-WVEIPM�JSVGIW�WMRGIXLI�YTVMWMRK�FIKER�MR�7ITXIQFIV������[IVI�GMZMPMERW�[MXL�RS�GSRRIGXMSRXS�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSV�ª��8LMW�GSQIW�XS�ETTVS\MQEXIP]�����MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERWOMPPIH�MR�XLI�GSYVWI�SJ�PIKMXMQEXI�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�

-R�Q]�ZMI[�XLMW�RYQFIV�ERH�TVSTSVXMSR�MW�XSS�LMKL�ERH�-WVEIP�QYWXFIEV�WSQI�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�HIEH�ERH�MRNYVIH�4EPIWXMRMERW��&YX�-WVEIP¬WQSVEP�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�XLIWI�EGGMHIRXEP��EPXLSYKL�SJXIR�JSVIWIIEFPI�GEWYEPXMIW�SJ�[EV��MW�MR�RS�[E]�GSQTEVEFPI�XS�XLI�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�SJ�4EPIW�XMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�[LS�LEZI�HIPMFIVEXIP]�XEVKIXIH�IZIV]�WMRKPI�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMER

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 137: The Case For Israel

ZMGXMQ��3J�XLI�QSVI�XLER�����-WVEIPM�HIEXLW��ETTVS\MQEXIP]�����LEZI�FIIRMRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW��QER]�SJ�XLIWI�GLMPHVIR��[SQIR��ERH�XLI�IPHIVP]���)ZIV]WYGL�OMPPMRK�MW�ER�EGX�SJ�JMVWX�HIKVII�QYVHIV��8S�GSQTEVI�XLI�EGGMHIRXEPOMPPMRK�SJ�GMZMPMERW�HYVMRK�PIKMXMQEXI�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ�[MXL�XLIXEVKIXIH�QYVHIV�SJ�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�MW�PMOI�GSQTEVMRK�QIHMGMRI�XS�TSM�WSR��&SXL�GER�VIWYPX�MR�HIEXL��FYX�[MXL�XLI�JSVQIV��MX�MW�E�XVEKMG��MJ�WSQI�XMQIW�JSVIWIIEFPI��WMHI�IJJIGX��[LIVIEW�[MXL�XLI�PEXXIV�MX�MW�XLI�HMVIGXMRXIRHIH�IJJIGX�

8LI�RYQFIV�SJ�-WVEIPM�[SQIR�ERH�GLMPHVIR�OMPPIH�ERH�MRNYVIH�MW�[IPP�MRI\GIWW�SJ�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�[SQIR�ERH�GLMPHVIR�OMPPIH�ERHMRNYVIH EW�QER]�EW�XLVII�XMQIW�QSVI�EGGSVHMRK�XS�SRI�WXYH]���%�TVSQM�RIRX�JIQMRMWX�[VMXIV�LEW�SFWIVZIH�

3R�XLI�-WVEIPM�WMHI�����TIVGIRX�SJ�XLSWI�OMPPIH�[IVI�RSRGSQFEXERXW��QSWX

SJ�[LSQ�[IVI�[SQIR�ERH�KMVPW��-WVEIPM�JIQEPIJEXEPMXMIW�JEV�SYXRYQFIVIH

4EPIWXMRMER�JIQEPIJEXEPMXMIW�F]�IMXLIV���XS���SV���XS�����7S�JEV��-�LEZI

LIEVH�RS�JIQMRMWX�GSQTPEMRXW�EFSYX�XLMW��LEZI�]SY# �-WVEIPM�[SQIR�ERH

KMVPW�GSRWXMXYXIH�EPQSWX����TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�RSRGSQFEXERXW�OMPPIH�F]

4EPIWXMRMERW��3J�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�HIEXLW��SZIV����TIVGIRX�[IVI�QEPI��-R

SXLIV�[SVHW��4EPIWXMRMERW�TYVTSWIJYPP]�[IRX�EJXIV�[SQIR��GLMPHVIR��ERH

SXLIV�YREVQIH�GMZMPMERW�ERH�-WVEIPMW�JSYKLX�EKEMRWX�EVQIH�QEPI�WSPHMIVW

[LS�[IVI�EXXEGOMRK�XLIQ�ª��

)ZIR�[LIR�QIR [LS�EVI�QSVI�PMOIP]�XS�FI�GSQFEXERXW EVI�MRGPYHIH�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�MRRSGIRX-WVEIPMW�OMPPIH�ERH�MRNYVIH�I\GIIHW�XLI�RYQFIV�SJMRRSGIRX�4EPIWXMRMERW�OMPPIH�ERH�MRNYVIH��ERH�XLI�VIEWSRW�WLSYPH�FI�SFZM�SYW�XS�ER]SRI�[LS�FSXLIVW�XS�XLMRO�EFSYX�MX�JSV�IZIR�E�QSQIRX�

8IVVSVMWXW�XV]�IZIV]XLMRK�TSWWMFPI�XS�QE\MQMI�HIEXLW��IZIR�WSQIXMQIWVITSVXIHP]�WSEOMRK�XLI�REMPW�XLI]�YWI�MR�XLIMV�ERXMTIVWSRRIP�FSQFW�MR�VEXTSMWSR�XS�TVIZIRX�GSEKYPEXMSR�SJ�FPSSH��6IGIRXP]��-WVEIPM�HSGXSVW�I\TVIWWIHGSRGIVR�XLEX�XLI�FPSSH�SJ�WSQI�SJ�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��[LMGL�WTPEXXIVW�EPPSZIV�XLI�WGIRI�ERH�MW�XSYGLIH�F]�QIHMGEP�TIVWSRRIP��EW�[IPP�EW�XLIMV�FSRIW�[LMGL�TIRIXVEXI�XLI�FSHMIW�SJ�XLI�ZMGXMQW��QMKLX�GSRXEMR�LITEXMXMW�SV�XLI%-(7�ZMVYW��VEMWMRK�XLI�JIEV�XLEX�XIVVSVMWX�PIEHIVW�GSYPH�FI�XYVRMRK�WYMGMHIFSQFIVW�MRXS�FMSPSKMGEP�[EVJEVI�GEVVMIVW�IMXLIV�F]�MRNIGXMRK�XLIQ�SV�WIPIGX�MRK�GEVVMIVW�EW�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��8LI�JMVWX�WYGL�GEWI�[EW�HSGYQIRXIH�MR�XLI.YP]������MWWYI�SJ�XLI�-WVEIP�1IHMGEP�%WWSGMEXMSR�.SYVREP�(SGXSVW�EX�XLI�,MPPIP�=EJJI�1IHMGEP�'IRXIV�MR�,EHIVE�I\XVEGXIH�FSRI�JVEKQIRXW�JVSQXLI�RIGO��FVIEWX��ERH�KVSMR�SJ�E�[SQER�[LS�LEH�FIIR�XLI�ZMGXMQ�SJ�E�WYM�GMHI�FSQFMRK��8LI�FSRI�JVEKQIRXW�[IVI�WIRX�XS�XLI�-RWXMXYXI�SJ�*SVIRWMG1IHMGMRI�MR�8IP�%ZMZ�ERH�XIWXIH�TSWMXMZI�JSV�LITEXMXMW�&���8LI�EYXLSVW�SJXLI�QIHMGEP�NSYVREP�WEMH��©,YQER�FSRI�JVEKQIRXW��[LMGL�EGX�EW�JSVIMKRFSHMIW�ERH�EVI�SJ�FMSPSKMG�MRJIGXIH�SVMKMR��EVI�E�RI[�GSRGITX�MR�FPEWX

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 138: The Case For Israel

MRNYVMIW�ª��8LI�HSGXSVW�©XLISVMIH�XLEX�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�QMKLX�GEVV]�ERYQFIV�SJ�MRJIGXMSYW�HMWIEWIW�MRGPYHMRK�XLI�LITEXMXMW�WXVEMR��,-:��W]TLMPMW�HIRKYI�JIZIV��'VIYXJIPH�.EGSF�HMWIEWI�SV�QEPEVME�ª��8LISV]�XYVRIH�XSTVEGXMGI�[LIR�XLI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�XLI�,IFVI[�9RMZIVWMX]�GEJIXIVME�FSQFMRK�LEHXS�FI�KMZIR�QEWWMZI�HSWIW�SJ�ERXMFMSXMGW�FIGEYWI�©-WVEIPM�HSGXSVW�LEZIPIEVRIH�XLEX�QER]�SJ�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�EVI�MRJIGXIH�[MXL�HMWIEWIW�VERK�MRK�JVSQ�LITEXMXMW�XS�,-:�ª��

;LIXLIV�XLMW�XYVRW�SYX�XS�FI�ER�MWSPEXIH�WMXYEXMSR�SV�E�KVYIWSQI�IWGE�PEXMSR�MR�XLI�QIXLSHSPSK]�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�VIQEMRW�XS�FI�WIIR��-R�XLI�QIER�XMQI��-WVEIPM�LSWTMXEPW�QYWX�TVITEVI�JSV�XLI�[SVWX�GEWI�WGIREVMS��-WVEIPMQIHMGEP�NSYVREPW�EVI�HMWGYWWMRK�XLIWI�TVSFPIQW��-RHIIH��XLI�IRXMVI�.YP]�����MWWYI�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�1IHMGEP�%WWSGMEXMSR�.SYVREP[EW�HIZSXIH�XS�XLIWYFNIGX�SJ�©8IVVSV�ERH�1IHMGMRI�ª�*MVWX�VIWTSRHIVW�LEZI�FIIR�IUYMTTIH[MXL�XIWX�OMXW��ZEGGMRIW��ERH�ERXMFMSXMGW�XS�GSRJVSRX�XLMW�TSXIRXMEP�RI[�XLVIEX�%RH�MX�[MPP�RSX�FI�IEW]��FIGEYWI�©XIWX�OMXW�EVI�HIWMKRIH�JSV�FPSSH��-X�MW�ZIV]LEVH�XS�XIWX�FSRI��IWTIGMEPP]�JSV�E�JVEKMPI�ZMVYW�PMOI�,-:�ª��1SVISZIV��XLIRI[�HERKIV�VIUYMVIW�XLI�WYVKMGEP�VIQSZEP�SJ�FSRIW�XLEX�GSYPH�SXLIV[MWI�FIPIJX�MR�XLI�ZMGXMQ¬W�FSH]��8IVVSVMWXW�WYGGIIH�[LIRIZIV�XLI]�QEOI�XLI�NSF�SJXLSWI�XV]MRK�XS�WEZI�PMZIW�QSVI�HMJJMGYPX��&]�XLEX�WXERHEVH��XLI�RI[�XLVIEXWTSWIH�F]�MRJIGXIH�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�VITVIWIRX�E�ZMGXSV]�JSV�XIVVSVMWQ�

-R�HMWXMRGX�GSRXVEWX�XS�XLI�QSHYW�STIVERHM�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW XSOMPP�EW�QER]�MRRSGIRX�.I[W�EW�TSWWMFPI�F]�ER]�EZEMPEFPI�QIERW XLI�MRRS�GIRX�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERW�[LS�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�F]�-WVEIPMW�[IVI�RSX�XLIMRXIRHIH�XEVKIXW�SJ�-WVEIPM�GSYRXIVXIVVSVMWQ�IJJSVXW��-WVEIP�XVMIW�XS�YWI�VYF�FIV�FYPPIXW�ERH�SXLIV�[IETSRW�HIWMKRIH�XS�VIHYGI�JEXEPMXMIW��ERH�EMQW�EXXLI�PIKW�[LIRIZIV�TSWWMFPI��;LIR�-WVEIPMW�EGGMHIRXEPP]�OMPP�E�GMZMPMER��XLIVIMW�MRXIVREP�GVMXMGMWQ��FSEVHW�SJ�MRUYMV]��ERH�WSQIXMQIW�IZIR�TYRMWL�QIRX���;LIR�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�QYVHIV�WGLSSPGLMPHVIR��XLIVI�MW�[MHI�WTVIEH�GLIIVMRK�ERH�EHYPEXMSR�SJ�XLI�OMPPIVW��-WVEIP�LEW�RSXLMRK�XS�KEMR�ERHIZIV]XLMRK�XS�PSWI�F]�OMPPMRK�MRRSGIRX�4EPIWXMRMERW��8LI�STTSWMXI�MW�XVYI�JSV4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW��[LS�HIPMFIVEXIP]�XEVKIX�XLI�QSWX�MRRSGIRX�-WVEIPMGMZMPMERW�

&]�HIPMFIVEXIP]�LMHMRK�MR�ERH�STIVEXMRK�SYX�SJ�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIR�XIVW�WYGL�EW�VIJYKII�GEQTW��4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�YWI�XLIMV�S[R�GMZMPMERW�EWWLMIPHW��-X�MW�E�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�XS�YWI�GMZMPMERW�EW�WLMIPHW��ERHYRHIV�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�E�GMZMPMER�[LS�MW�OMPPIH�[LMPI�FIMRK�YWIH�EW�E�WLMIPHMW�GSYRXIH�EW�E�GEWYEPX]�GEYWIH�F]�XLSWI�YWMRK�LMQ�EW�E�WLMIPH��RSX�F]�XLSWI[LS�[IVI�PIKMXMQEXIP]�XV]MRK�XS�EXXEGO�ER�ETTVSTVMEXI�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIX�WYGLEW�ER�EVQIH�XIVVSVMWX��8S�VITIEX�[LEX�E�HMTPSQEX�XSPH�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�©8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�QEWXIVIH�E�LEVWL�EVMXLQIXMG�SJ�TEMR��������4EPIWXMRMERGEWYEPXMIW�TPE]�MR�XLIMV�JEZSV��ERH�-WVEIPM�GEWYEPXMIW�TPE]�MR�XLIMV�JEZSV�ª��

,EQEW�PIEHIV�-WQEMP�,ERM]E�XSPH�XLI�;EWLMRKXSR�4SWX�©4EPIWXMRMERWLEZI�-WVEIPMW�SR�XLI�VYR�RS[�FIGEYWI�XLI]�LEZI�JSYRH�XLIMV�[IEO�WTSX�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 139: The Case For Israel

.I[W�������PSZI�PMJI�QSVI�XLER�SXLIV�TISTPI��ERH�XLI]�TVIJIV�RSX�XS�HMI��7SWYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�EVI�MHIEP�JSV�HIEPMRK�[MXL�XLIQ�ª�8LMW�ZMI[�SJ�PMJI�ERHHIEXL�QE]�FI�©VIEPP]�WMGO�ª�EW�8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�LEW�GLEVEGXIVMIH�MX���FYXMX�MW�TEVX�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWX�EVMXLQIXMG��8LSWI�[LS�QEOI�XLIEVKYQIRX�XLEX�-WVEIP�WLSYPH�FI�GSRHIQRIH�FIGEYWI�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLER-WVEIPMW�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�EGXYEPP]�IRGSYVEKI�XLMW�GVYIP�GEPGYPYW�SJ�HIEXL�

2S�SRI�GPEMQW�XLEX�©%VEFW�ERH�1YWPMQW�LEZI�XIVVSVMWQ�MR�XLIMVKIRIW�ª�EW�)H[EVH�7EMH�EGGYWIW�TVS�-WVEIP�EHZSGEXIW�SJ�FIPMIZMRK���7EMH¬WKIRIXMG�WXVE[�QER�WLSYPH�RSX��LS[IZIV��FPMRH�YW�XS�XLI�WEH�VIEPMX]�XLEXQYGL�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT FSXL�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�VIPMKMSYW LEZIEHSTXIH�XIVVSVMWQ�EW�E�JMVWX�VIGSYVWI�ERH�KPSVMJMIH�MX�EW�TEVX�SJ�XLIMV�GYPXYVIERH�VIPMKMSR���8LI]�EVI�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�MXW�TVSPMJIVEXMSR�

4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�EVI�EPWS�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�XLI�PEVKI�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIW�XMRMER�GLMPHVIR�ERH�]SYRK�EHYPXW�OMPPIH�ERH�MRNYVIH�F]�-WVEIPM�KYRJMVI��-X[EW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�[LS�GLERKIH�XLI�VYPIW�SJ�IRKEKIQIRX�F]�HIPMF�IVEXIP]�YWMRK�GLMPHVIR�ERH�]SYRK�EHYPXW�EW�EKKVIWWMZI�[IETSRW��8LIWI]SYRK�TISTPI WSQI�EW�]SYRK�EW�IPIZIR LEZI�FIIR�VIGVYMXIH�EW�WYMGMHIFSQFIVW��FSQF�XLVS[IVW��ERH�VSGO�XLVS[IVW��7EPEL�7LILEHIL��E�PIEHIV�SJ,EQEW�MR�+EE��WEMH�MR�E�1E]�����������MRXIVZMI[�XLEX�GLMPHVIR�[IVIFIMRK�VIGVYMXIH�MRXS�E�WTIGMEP�FVERGL�SJ�,EQEW��-R�ER�MRXIVZMI[�SR�%P�.EIIVE�XIPIZMWMSR��E�TVSQMRIRX�1YWPMQ�TVSJIWWSV�HIJIRHIH�XLI�YWI�SJ�[LEXLI�GEPPIH�GEPPSYWP]�©XLI�GLMPHVIR�FSQF�ª��

%�TSPP�GSRHYGXIH�F]�-WPEQMG�9RMZIVWMX]�SJ�������]SYRKWXIVW�FIX[IIRXLI�EKIW�SJ���ERH����WLS[IH�XLEX����TIVGIRX�WEMH�XLI]�LEH�TEVXMGMTEXIH�MRERXM�-WVEIP�ZMSPIRGI�ERH����TIVGIRX�I\TVIWWIH�E�HIWMVI�XS�HMI�QEVX]VW��2SXWYVTVMWMRKP]��WSQI�GLMPHVIR�LEZI�FIIR�FPS[R�YT�MR�XLI�TVSGIWW�SJ�HIXS�REXMRK�SV�TPERXMRK�FSQFW��-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�SV�GMZMPMERW�[LS�[IVI�XEVKIXIH�F]XLI�]SYRK�XIVVSVMWXW�LEZI�WLSX�SXLIVW�MR�WIPJ�HIJIRWI��*SV�I\EQTPI��XLI2I[�=SVO�8MQIWSJ�1EVGL����������VITSVXIH��©=SYXLW�XLVI[�WXSRIW�ERHJMVIFSQFW�EX�XVSSTW�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�HE]��%X�SRI�TSMRX��WSPHMIVW�JMVIH�ERHLMX�E�]SYXL�[LS�LEH�XLVS[R�E�JMVIFSQF�ª�EGGSVHMRK�XS�SJJMGMEPW�EX�ER�%VEFLSWTMXEP�MR�+EE���3XLIV�I\EQTPIW�MRGPYHI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�

�3R�.YP]����������X[S�IPIZIR�]IEV�SPHW�[IVI�GEYKLX�XV]MRK�XS�TPERX�EFSQF�RIEV�ER�-WVEIPM�SYXTSWX��ERH�SRI�SJ�XLIQ�WEMH�LI�LSTIH�XSFIGSQI�E�QEVX]V�

�3R�%TVMP�����������XLVII�WXYHIRXW��EKIW�X[IPZI��XLMVXIIR��ERH�JSYV�XIIR��[IVI�OMPPIH�[LMPI�XV]MRK�XS�MRJMPXVEXI�XLI�XS[R�SJ�2MXEVMQ�MRSVHIV�XS�TVIGMTMXEXI�E�WYMGMHI�EXXEGO��8LI]�IEGL�PIJX�E�[MPP�IQTLEWM�MRK�XLIMV�[MWL�XS�HMI�EW�QEVX]VW��8LI�XLVII�HIEH�]SYXLW�EVI�RS[�LIPHYT�EW�I\EQTPIW�SJ�QEVX]VW�

�%JSYVXIIR�]IEV�SPH�[EW�OMPPIH�[LMPI�XV]MRK�XS�IRXIV�ER�-WVEIPM�SYX�TSWX�GEVV]MRK�X[S�TMTI�FSQFW�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 140: The Case For Israel

�%WM\XIIR�]IEV�SPH�[EW�OMPPIH�EW�LI�XLVI[�E�LERH�KVIREHI�EX�-WVEIPMWSPHMIVW�

�%�JMJXIIR�]IEV�SPH�KMVP�[EW�EVVIWXIH�EJXIV�GSRJIWWMRK�XLEX�LIV�YRGPI��EWIRMSV�8ERMQ�STIVEXMZI�MR�&IXLPILIQ��LEH�VIGVYMXIH�LIV�XS�FIGSQIE�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�ERH�WLI�LEH�EKVIIH�XS�VIGVYMX�EHHMXMSREP�KMVPW�JVSQLIV�WGLSSP�

�3R�1EVGL�����������E�WM\XIIR�]IEV�SPH�GEVVMIH�SYX�E�WYMGMHI�FSQF�MRK�EX�E�1EKIR�(EZMH�%HSQ��-WVEIPM�6IH�'VSWW �WXEXMSR��OMPPMRK�WM\-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�ERH�LMQWIPJ�

�%WM\XIIR�]IEV�SPH�LMKL�WGLSSP�WXYHIRX�[EW�EVVIWXIH�SR�LMW�[E]�XSGSQQMXXMRK�E�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRK�SJ�E�GVS[HIH�FYW�EJXIV�LI�ERRSYRGIHMR�JVSRX�SJ�LMW�IRXMVI�GPEWW�XLEX�LI�[SYPH�RSX�FI�VIXYVRMRK�FIGEYWI�LI[EW�FIGSQMRK�E�QEVX]V�

=IX��HIWTMXI�XLIWI�[IPP�HSGYQIRXIH�GEWIW��E�WTSOIWTIVWSR�JSV�%QRIWX]-RXIVREXMSREP�XSPH�E�KEXLIVMRK�EX�XLI�9�2��,YQER�6MKLXW�'SQQMWWMSR�MR�����XLEX�©XS�Q]�ORS[PIHKI��XLIVI�LEW�RIZIV�FIIR�E�4EPIWXMRMER�QMRSVMRZSPZIH�MR�E�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRK�ª��7LI�WLSYPH�XIPP�XLEX�XS�XLI�JEQMPMIW�SJXLI�WM\�-WVEIPMW�QYVHIVIH�F]�XLI�WM\XIIR�]IEV�SPH�4EPIWXMRMER�WYMGMHIFSQFIV�EX�XLI�-WVEIPM�6IH�'VSWW�WXEXMSR�

8LI�9RMZIVWMX]�SJ�'LMGEKS�TLMPSWSTLIV�.IER�&IXLOI�)PWLXEMR��MR�LIVFSSO.YWX�;EV�EKEMRWX�8IVVSV�GSQTEVIW�-WPEQMG�XIVVSVMWX�PIEHIVW�[LS�GPEMQXLEX�©-WPEQMWX�]SYRK�TISTPI�EVI�MR�PSZI�[MXL�HIEXLª�XS�2EM�PIEHIVW�[LSWIRX�©������GLMPHVIR�FIX[IIR�XLI�EKIW�SJ���ERH���ª�XS�RIEV�GIVXEMR�HIEXLMR�XLI�PEWX�HE]W�SJ�XLI�WMIKI�SJ�&IVPMR�

3RP]�JMZI�LYRHVIH�WYVZMZIH��;LEX�[EW�EWXSRMWLMRK�XS�SFWIVZIVW�[EW�XLI

HIXIVQMREXMSR�SJ�XLIWI�GLMPHVIR�XS�©HS�XLIMV�HYX]�YRXMP�XLI]�[IVI�PMXIVEPP]

VIEH]�XS�HVST��8LI]�LEH�FIIR�JIH�SR�PIKIRHW�SJ�LIVSMWQ�JSV�EW�PSRK�EW

XLI]�GSYPH�VIQIQFIV��*SV�XLIQ�XLI�GEPP�XS�«YPXMQEXI�WEGVMJMGI¬�[EW�RS

IQTX]�TLVEWI�ª��

2S�SRI�FPEQIH�XLI�%PPMIH�XVSSTW�JSV�OMPPMRK�XLI�EVQIH�GLMPHVIR�[LS�[IVIXV]MRK�XS�TVIZIRX�XLIQ�JVSQ�GETXYVMRK�&IVPMR�ERH�IRHMRK�XLI�[EV��'MXMRKXLI�[SVO�SJ�XLISPSKMERW�,��6MGLEVH�2MIFYLV�ERH�4EYP�8MPPMGL��)PWLXEMRSJJIVIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�EREP]WMW�

%�[MPPMRKRIWW�XS�WEGVMJMGI�GLMPHVIR�MW�SRI�WMKR�SJ�E�GYPXYVI�SJ�HIEXL��3RI�MW

VIQMRHIH�RSX�SRP]�SJ�XLI�HVMZI�XS[EVH�HIEXL�PEYHIH�F]�FMR�0EHIR�ERH

I\XSPPIH�F]�-WPEQMWX�VEHMGEPW�IZIV][LIVI��FYX�WTIGMJMGEPP]�SJ�LS[�XLSY�

WERHW�SJ�-VERMER�GLMPHVIR�[IVI�XLVS[R�MRXS�XLI�LSVVSV�SJ�XLI�IMKLX�]IEV

[EV�FIX[IIR�-VER�ERH�-VEU�JVSQ������XS�������8LIWI�GLMPHVIR�[IVI�HIG�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 141: The Case For Israel

MQEXIH��WIRX�SYX�EW�LYQER�QMRIW[IITIVW��XLI]�[IVI�IMXLIV�OMPPIH�SYXVMKLX

SV�PIJX�PMQFPIWW�ERH�WGEVVIH��=IX�JEQMPMIW�WTSOI�SJ�XLI�LSRSV�SJ�FIMRK

TEVIRXW�SJ�WYGL�QEVX]VW��'SRXVEWX�XLMW�LMHISYW�[MPP�XS�WEGVMJMGI�GLMPHVIR

[MXL�XLI�IXLMG�SJ�XVEMRMRK�EHYPX�WSPHMIVW�XS�JMKLX�MR�E�QERRIV�XLEX

TVIWIVZIW�EW�QER]�PMZIW�EW�TSWWMFPI��FSXL�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�RYQFIV�ERH�SJ

RSRGSQFEXERXW���

8LI�QSVI�XLEX�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�FVIEO�XLI�XEFSS�EKEMRWX�YWMRK]SYXLW�EW�XIVVSVMWXW��XLI�QSVI�]SYXLW�[MPP�FI�MRNYVIH�ERH�OMPPIH��7YGL�HIPMF�IVEXI�QMWYWI�SJ�GLMPHVIR�MW�ER�I\XVIQI�JSVQ�SJ�GLMPH�EFYWI��ERH�MX�MW�IRXMVIP]XLI�JEYPX�SJ�XLI�EFYWIVW��RSX�XLSWI�[LS�PIKMXMQEXIP]�HIJIRH�XLIQWIPZIWEKEMRWX�JMVI�FSQFIVW�ERH�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�[LS�LETTIR�XS�FI�]SYXLW��%W+SPHE�1IMV��JSVQIV�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�SJ�-WVEIP��SRGI�WEMH��©;I�GER�TIVLETWJSVKMZI�XLIQ�JSV�OMPPMRK�SYV�GLMPHVIR��FYX�[I�GER�RIZIV�JSVKMZI�XLIQ�JSVJSVGMRK�YW�XS�OMPP�XLIMV�GLMPHVIR�ª

8LI�WEQI�MW�XVYI�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�[SQIR��IZIR�TVIKRERX�[SQIR��[LSLEZI�RS[�FIIR�VIGVYMXIH�XS�FIGSQI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��;SQIR�LEZI�GEVVMIHSYX�QSVI�XLER�X[IRX]�WYMGMHI�EXXEGOW�WMRGI�������7SQI�SJ�XLIWI�[SQIRLEZI�FIIR�VIGVYMXIH�F]�XLI�YWI�SJ�IQSXMSREP�ERH�GYPXYVEP�FPEGOQEMP��*SVI\EQTPI��XIVVSVMWX�STIVEXMZIW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�WIHYGIH�%RHEPMF�7YPIMQER��EX[IRX]�SRI�]IEV�SPH�[SQER�JVSQ�&IXLPILIQ��;LIR�WLI�FIGEQI�TVIK�RERX��WLI�[EW�XSPH�XLEX�XLI�SRP]�[E]�XS�EZSMH�XLI�WLEQI�[EW�XS�HMI�E�QEV�X]V¬W�HIEXL��7LI�XLIR�EKVIIH�XS�FPS[�LIVWIPJ�YT�MR�E�.IVYWEPIQ�WLSTTMRKQEVOIX��OMPPMRK�WM\�GMZMPMERW��MRGPYHMRK�X[S�[SVOIVW�JVSQ�'LMRE��%�WMQMPEVI\EQTPI�MW�%]EX�EP�%LVEW��ER�IMKLXIIR�]IEV�SPH�[SQER�JVSQ�(ILEMWM��[LSFPI[�LIVWIPJ�YT�MR�E�WYTIVQEVOIX��OMPPMRK�X[S�GMZMPMERW��EJXIV�LEZMRK�FIIRWIHYGIH�ERH�QEHI�TVIKRERX�

8LMW�QIXLSH�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�EFSVXMSR�MW�E�HIWTMGEFPI�I\EQTPI�SJ�GVIEXMRK�RI[PMJI�MR�SVHIV�XS�KIRIVEXI�HIEXL��8LIVI�EVI�SXLIV�I\EQTPIW�SJ�]SYRK�[SQIRFIMRK�VETIH�MR�SVHIV�XS�XYVR�XLIQ�MRXS�WLEQIH�[SQIR�[LSWI�SRP]�QIERWSJ�VIWXSVMRK�JEQMP]�LSRSV�MW�QEVX]VHSQ��-R�SRI�GEWI��XLI�JEQMP]�PIEVRIH�SJ�XLI�EXXIQTX�F]�8ERMQ�STIVEXMZIW�XS�FPEGOQEMP�XLIMV�HEYKLXIV�ERHWQYKKPIH�LIV�SYX�SJ�&IXLPILIQ��7LI�MW�RS[�PMZMRK�MR�LMHMRK���,EQEW�LEWIZIR�SFXEMRIH�E�PIKEP�VIPMKMSYW�VYPMRK�EFSYX�[LEX�E�JIQEPI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVMW�TIVQMXXIH�XS�[IEV�EW�WLI�KSIW�EFSYX�XLI�FYWMRIWW�SJ�OMPPMRK�.I[MWL�GMZMPMERW�

5YIWXMSR��©1YWX�XLI�JIQEPI�WYMGMHI�WIIOIV�EFSYX�XS�I\IGYXI�ER�STIVEXMSR

HVIWW�MR�EGGSVHERGI�[MXL�7LEVME�?1YWPMQ�VIPMKMSYW�PE[A�ORS[MRK�XLEX�MJ

XLI�STIVEXMSR�MW�XS�FI�MR�ER�-WVEIPM�EVIE�������XLI�[SQER�[MPP�FI�I\TSWIH#ª

%RW[IV��©8LI�UYIWXMSR�SJ�XLI�LMNEF�?[SQER¬W�LIEH�GSZIVMRKA�MW�RSX�STIR

XS�HMWGYWWMSR��8LMW�MW�E�GSQQERHQIRX�ERH�SFPMKEXMSR�E�.MLEH�[EVVMSV�QE]

RSX�JSVKS��%�WIGSRH�TSMRX�MW�XLEX�MR�SYV�WXVIIXW�ERH�GMXMIW�SGGYTMIH�F]�XLI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 142: The Case For Israel

.I[W�?EPP�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�GSRWMHIVIH�«SGGYTMIH¬A��SYV�WMWXIVW�QE]�[EPO�EFSYX

HVIWWIH�MR�XLIMV�7LEVME�GPSXLIW�IZIR�[MXL�ZIMPW�SR�XLIMV�JEGIW�ERH�[IEVMRK

KPSZIW��8LI�XLMVH�TSMRX��ERH�MX�MW�ZIV]�WMKRMJMGERX��MW�XLEX�SYV�WMWXIVW��XLI

.MLEH�[EVVMSVW��GER�HIGIMZI�XLI�.I[W�F]�[IEVMRK�GPSXLIW�SJ�XLI�X]TI�[SVR

F]�XLI�WS�GEPPIH�VIPMKMSYW�.I[MWL�[SQIR�[LMGL�MW�EGGITXEFPI�YRHIV�XLI

7LEVME��3R[EVH�XLI�7LELMH�?(IEXL�JSV�%PPELA�GSRZS]�ª��

%�VIGIRX�VYPMRK�F]�©ER�MRJPYIRXMEP�GPIVMG�FEWIH�MR�5EXEVª�WEMH�XLEX�E4EPIWXMRMER�[SQER�©GSYPH�VIEGL�TEVEHMWI�XLVSYKL�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKWª�ERHXLEX�WLI�GSYPH�VIQSZI�LIV�ZIMPW�ERH�KS�[MXLSYX�E�GLETIVSRI�XS�OMPP�.I[W�FIGEYWI�WLI�MW�KSMRK�XS�©HMI�MR�XLI�GEYWI�SJ�%PPEL��ERH�RSX�XS�WLS[�SJJ�LIVFIEYX]�ª��

%TTVSTVMEXI�VYPIW�SJ�IRKEKIQIRX�VIUYMVI�E�VIWTSRWI�XS�ER]SRI�IRKEKIHMR�TSXIRXMEPP]�PIXLEP�EGXMZMX]�EKEMRWX�XLI�EVQIH�JSVGIW�SV�GMZMPMERW�SJ�EREXMSR��%R�ETX�EREPSK]�MW�XS�XLI�VIGIRX�VIGVYMXQIRX�F]�MRXIVREXMSREP�HVYKWQYKKPIVW�SJ�]SYRK�GLMPHVIR�XS�GEVV]�XLI�HVYKW WSQIXMQIW�MRWMHI�XLIMVFSHMIW�F]�W[EPPS[MRK�GSRHSQW�JMPPIH�[MXL�LIVSMR�ERH�GSGEMRI��%W�E�VIWYPXSJ�XLMW�GLERKI�MR�XLI�EKI�SJ�HVYK�GEVVMIVW��XLI�GYWXSQW�EYXLSVMXMIW�LEZI�LEHXS�FIKMR�WIEVGLMRK�GLMPHVIR��KMZMRK�VMWI�XS�WSQI�GSQTPEMRXW�

&YX�XLI�JEYPX�PMIW�[MXL�XLSWI�[LS�LEZI�HIGMHIH�XS�YWI�GLMPHVIR�EW�HVYKWQYKKPIVW��NYWX�EW�XLI�JEYPX�PMIW�IRXMVIP]�[MXL�XLSWI�[LS�LEZI�HIGMHIH�XS�YWIGLMPHVIR�EW�GEVVMIVW�SJ�HIEHP]�I\TPSWMZIW��%����]IEV�SPH�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�MWNYWX�EW�HERKIVSYW�EW�E����]IEV�SPH��ERH�-WVEIP�LEW�XLI�WEQI�VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�EKEMRWX�FSXL��8LI�SRP]�[E]�XS�IRH�XLI�OMPPMRK�SJ�]SYXLW�ERH[SQIR�F]�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�ERH�TSPMGI�MW�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�WXST�YWMRKXLIQ�EW�XIVVSVMWXW��&YX�XLMW�MW�YRPMOIP]��FIGEYWI�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�PIEHIVW�LEZIQEHI�E�GVYIP�GEPGYPEXMSR��XLIMV�GEYWI�FIRIJMXW�IZIV]�XMQI�ER�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVOMPPW�E�4EPIWXMRMER�GLMPH�SV�[SQER��8LI]�LEZI�IZIR�KSRI�WS�JEV�EW�XS�TPEGIXLIMV�FSQF�QEOMRK�JEGXSVMIW�EHNEGIRX�XS�OMRHIVKEVXIRW�ERH�IPIQIRXEV]WGLSSPW�WS�XLEX�MJ�-WVEIP�[IVI�XS�EXXEGO�XLI�JEGXSVMIW��XLI]�[SYPH�OMPP�GLMP�HVIR��8LI�TPEGIQIRX�SJ�XLIWI�HERKIVSYW�JEGXSVMIW�EPWS�I\TSWIW�XLI�GLMPHVIRXS�XLI�VMWO�SJ�EGGMHIRXEP�HIEXL���

8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�XSS�LEH�XS�GLERKI�MXW�VYPIW�SJ�IRKEKIQIRX�EJXIV�XLI-VEUMW�YWIH�ER�ETTEVIRXP]�TVIKRERX�[SQER�EW�E�XIVVSVMWX��9RMXIH�7XEXIW�WSP�HMIVW�LEH�XS�FIKMR�GLIGOMRK�[SQIR�QSVI�MRXVYWMZIP]�ERH�SGGEWMSREPP]WLSSXMRK�EX�GEVW�XLEX�[IVI�VYRRMRK�GLIGOTSMRXW��8LIWI�EVI�XLI�XVEKMG�FYXYREZSMHEFPI�GSWXW�SJ�TVSXIGXMRK�TISTPI�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ��IWTIGMEPP]�[LIR[SQIR�ERH�GLMPHVIR�EVI�YWIH�EW�LYQER�FSQFW�

8LSWI�[IPP�MRXIRXMSRIH�TISTPI�[LS�PSYHP]�GVMXMGMI�-WVEIP�[LIRIZIV�E4EPIWXMRMER�GLMPH�MW�OMPPIH�MR�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�F]�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�EGXYEPP]�IRGSYV�EKI�XLI�VIGVYMXQIRX�SJ�QSVI�GLMPHVIR�EW�XIVVSVMWXW ERH�ZMGXMQW��4EPIWXMR�MER�TVSTEKERHMWXW�YRHIVWXERH�ERH�I\TPSMX�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�HIGIRX�TISTPIFIGSQI�SYXVEKIH�EX�XLI�OMPPMRK�SJ�E�GLMPH�ERH�SJXIR�HS�RSX�TEYWI�XS�QSZI

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 143: The Case For Israel

XLI�FPEQI�FI]SRH�XLI�WMHI�XLEX�JMVIH�XLI�JEXEP�WLSX�XS[EVH�XLI�WMHI�XLEXHIPMFIVEXIP]�TPEGIH�XLI�GLMPH�MR�LEVQ¬W�[E]�

4EPIWXMRMER�TVSTEKERHMWXW�EPWS�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�XLI]�VIGIMZI�QSVI�FIR�IJMXW�JVSQ�4EPIWXMRMERW�OMPPIH�F]�-WVEIPMW��IZIR�MR�WIPJ�HIJIRWI �XLER�JVSQ4EPIWXMRMERW�OMPPIH�F]�%VEFW��IZIR�MR�GSPH�FPSSH ��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�SJ�XLI2I[�=SVO�8MQIWTYX�MX�XLMW�[E]�

;L]�MW�MX�XLEX�[LIR�,MRHYW�OMPP�LYRHVIHW�SJ�1YWPMQW�MX�IPMGMXW�ER�IQS�

XMSREPP]�QYXIH�LIEHPMRI�MR�XLI�%VEF�QIHME��FYX�[LIR�-WVEIP�OMPPW�E�HSIR

1YWPMQW��MR�E�[EV�MR�[LMGL�1YWPMQW�EVI�EPWS�OMPPMRK�.I[W��MX�IRJPEQIW�XLI

IRXMVI�1YWPMQ�[SVPH#

������8LMW�MW�E�WIVMSYW�MWWYI��-R�VIGIRX�[IIOW��[LIRIZIV�%VEF�1YWPMQW

XSPH�QI�SJ�XLIMV�TEMR�EX�WIIMRK�4EPIWXMRMERW�FVYXEPMIH�F]�-WVEIPMW�SR�XLIMV

8:�WGVIIRW�IZIV]�RMKLX��-�EWOIH�FEGO��©;L]�EVI�]SY�WS�TEMRIH�EFSYX

-WVEIPMW�FVYXEPMMRK�4EPIWXMRMERW��FYX�HSR¬X�WE]�E�[SVH�EFSYX�XLI�FVYXEPMX]

[MXL�[LMGL�7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR�LEW�WRYJJIH�SYX�X[S�KIRIVEXMSRW�SJ�-VEUMW

YWMRK�QYVHIV��JIEV�ERH�TSMWSR�KEW#�-�KSX�RS�KSSH�ERW[IVW�ª��

)ZIR�XLSYKL�QER]�QSVI�%VEFW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�F]�JIP�PS[�%VEFW�XLER�F]�-WVEIPMW��XLI�PSYHIWX�ERH�QSWX�IJJIGXMZI�GSQTPEMRXW�EVMWI[LIR�E�4EPIWXMRMER�MW�OMPPIH�F]�E�.I[��8LMW�XSS�MW�E�JSVQ�SJ�VEGMWQ�

8LIVI�EVI�PSYH�GSQTPEMRXW�EW�[IPP��[LIR�%QIVMGERW�OMPP�%VEF�GMZMPMERW�EW�[I�HMH�MR�%JKLERMWXER�ERH�-VEU��FYX�XLI�WLVMPP�GVMIW�SJ�©KIRSGMHI�ª�©2EMXEGXMGW�ª�ERH�©LSPSGEYWXª�EVI�KIRIVEPP]�VIWIVZIH�JSV�-WVEIP��3R�.YRI����������XLI�%WWSGMEXIH�4VIWW�VIPIEWIH�XLI�JMRHMRKW�SJ�MXW�JMZI�[IIO�MRZIWXMKE�XMSR�MRXS�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�-VEUM�GMZMPMERW�OMPPIH�HYVMRK�XLI�VIGIRX�JMKLXMRK�%JXIV�I\EQMRMRK�LSWTMXEP�ERH�SXLIV�VIGSVHW��MX�GSRGPYHIH�XLEX�©EX�PIEWX������GMZMPMERW�HMIH�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�GSYRXV]��MRGPYHMRK�������MR�&EKL�HEH�ª�8LI�VITSVX�IQTLEWMIH�XLEX�XLI�©GSYRX�MW�WXMPP�JVEKQIRXEV]��ERH�XLIGSQTPIXI�RYQFIV MJ�MX�MW�IZIV�XEPPMIH MW�WYVI�XS�FI�WMKRMJMGERXP]�LMKLIV�ª��

8LI�VIEWSRW�XLIWI�JMKYVIW�EVI�WS�LMKL�JSV�WS�FVMIJ�E�[EV�MW�XLEX�-VEUM�WSP�HMIVW PMOI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW HVIWWIH�EW�[SQIR��LMH�EQSRK�GMZMPMERW�ERH�IZIR�LMH�MR�EQFYPERGIW��XLYW�QEOMRK�MX�HMJJMGYPX�XS�HMWXMRKYMWLFIX[IIR�GSQFEXERXW�ERH�RSRGSQFEXERXW��1ER]�SJ�XLI�-VEUM�GMZMPMERW�LEHFIIR�ZMGXMQW�SJ�7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR¬W�FVYXEP�VIKMQI�ERH�[IVI�RSX��MR�ER]�[E]�WYTTSVXMRK�LMW�EVQ]��1ER]�SJ�XLI�GMZMPMER�ZMGXMQW�EQSRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW[LS�[IVI�OMPPIH�F]�-WVEIPM�XVSSTW�[IVI��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��GSQTPMGMX�MRERH�WYTTSVXMZI�SJ�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW��=IX�XLI�GVMXMGMWQ�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�%QIVMGERXVSSTW�LEW�FIIR�RS[LIVI�RIEV�XLI�PIZIP�SJ�GVMXMGMWQ�HMVIGXIH�EX�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�

&SH]�GSYRXW�EPSRI�HS�RSX�HIXIVQMRI�XLI�QSVEPMX]�SV�PIKEPMX]�SJ�E�QMPM�XEV]�STIVEXMSR��=IX�STTSRIRXW�SJ�-WVEIP�XIRH�XS�JSGYW�SR�XLI�QMWPIEHMRK©JEGXª�XLEX�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLER�-WVEIPMW�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 144: The Case For Israel

���

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIPM�PE[�EYXLSVMIW�XLI�XSVXYVI�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�HIXEMRIIW��ERH�-WVEIPMEYXLSVMXMIW�TIVWMWXIRXP]�IRKEKI�MR�XSVXYVI�

8,)�%''97)67

©?-AX�MW�E�[IPP�HSGYQIRXIH��ERH�IEWMP]�ZIVMJMEFPI�JEGX�XLEX�-WVEIPM�PE[�SJJM�GMEPP]�EYXLSVMIW�XLI�YWI�SJ�XSVXYVI�SR�HIXEMRIIW�ª��.SLR�-LREX��2SVXL%QIVMGER�GSSVHMREXMRK�GSQQMXXII�JSV�2+3W�SR�XLI�UYIWXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�MR�E�WXEXIQIRX�MWWYIH�MR�������RIEVP]�X[S�]IEVW�EJXIVXLI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ-WVEIP�SJJMGMEPP]�SYXPE[IH�EPP�JSVQW�SJ�TL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVI�

8,)�6)%0-8=

-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�[SVPH�[LSWI�NYHMGMEV]�LEW�WUYEVIP]�JEGIHXLI�HMJJMGYPX�MWWYI�SJ�[LIXLIV�MX�MW�IZIV�NYWXMJMIH�XS�IRKEKI�MR�IZIR�E�QSHM�JMIH�JSVQ�SJ�RSRPIXLEP�XSVXYVI EOMR�XS�XLI�XEGXMGW�GYVVIRXP]�FIMRK�YWIH�F]XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�SR�GETXYVIH�EP�5EIHE�TVMWSRIVW MR�SVHIV�XS�SFXEMRMRJSVQEXMSR�HIIQIH�RIGIWWEV]�XS�TVIZIRX�E�XMGOMRK�FSQF�JVSQ�OMPPMRKHSIRW�SJ�GMZMPMERW��3R�7ITXIQFIV����������XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVXHIGMHIH�XLEX�RSX�SRP]�MW�XSVXYVI�EFWSPYXIP]�TVSLMFMXIH�FYX�IZIR�XLI�X]TIW�SJTL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVI�GYVVIRXP]�FIMRK�YWIH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW WPIIT�HITVM�ZEXMSR��JSVGIH�YRGSQJSVXEFPI�TSWMXMSRW��PSYH�QYWMG��WLEOMRK��LSSHW�SZIVXLI�LIEH EVI�TVSLMFMXIH�F]�-WVEIPM�PE[��IZIR�MR�GEWIW�MR�[LMGL�XLI�TVIWWYVI

(SIW�-WVEIP�8SVXYVI

4EPIWXMRMERW#

��

Page 145: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

MW�YWIH�RSX�XS�IPMGMX�E�GSRJIWWMSR�FYX�VEXLIV�XS�IPMGMX�MRJSVQEXMSR�XLEX�GSYPHTVIZIRX�ER�MQQMRIRX�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGO��4VMSV�XS�XLMW�HIGMWMSR��XLI�-WVEIPMWIGYVMX]�WIVZMGIW�HMH�WSQIXMQIW�IQTPS]�TL]WMGEP�QIEWYVIW�WMQMPEV�XS�XLSWIRS[�FIMRK�YWIH�F]�9�7��EYXLSVMXMIW�EKEMRWX�WYWTIGXIH�XIVVSVMWXW�

8LMW�GSRXVEWXW�WLEVTP]�[MXL�XLI�WMXYEXMSR�MR�)K]TX��.SVHER��1SVSGGS�7EYHM�%VEFME��XLI�4LMPMTTMRIW��ERH�SXLIV�1YWPMQ�GSYRXVMIW��[LIVI�XSV�XYVI MRGPYHMRK�XLI�PIXLEP�XSVXYVI�SJ�TYVIP]�TSPMXMGEP�TVMWSRIVW MW�GSQQSRERH�ETTVSZIH�EX�XLI�LMKLIWX�PIZIPW�SJ�KSZIVRQIRX��-X�EPWS�GSRXVEWXWWLEVTP]�[MXL�XLI�WMXYEXMSR�MR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��[LIVI�QSHMJMIH�JSVQW�SJXSVXYVI�XLEX�MRGPYHI�TL]WMGEP�ERH�TW]GLSPSKMGEP�GSQTSRIRXW�EVI�TVEGXMGIHERH�EVI�RSX�IEWMP]�WYFNIGX�XS�NYHMGMEP�VIZMI[��-RHIIH��XLI�PIEHMRK�GEWI�MR�XLI%QIVMGER�GSYVXW�WIIQW�XS�VIKEVH�RSRPIXLEP�XSVXYVI�EW�VIEWSREFPI�ERH�RIG�IWWEV]�[LIR�MXW�TYVTSWI�MW�RSX�XS�IPMGMX�E�GSRJIWWMSR�JSV�YWI�MR�E�TVSWIGYXMSRFYX�VEXLIV�XS�KEMR�MRJSVQEXMSR�XS�WEZI�E�WMRKPI�PMJI��

%�HIFEXI�EFSYX�XLMW�HMJJMGYPX�MWWYI�MW�GYVVIRXP]�YRHIV�[E]�MR�+IVQER]JSPPS[MRK�XLI�XLVIEX�XS�YWI�XSVXYVI�SR�E�OMHRETTIV�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�WEZI�XLI�PMJI�SJ�LMW�ZMGXMQ��3XLIV�GSYRXVMIW��WYGL�EW�*VERGI��TYFPMGP]�GSRHIQR�EPPJSVQW�SJ�XSVXYVI�[LMPI�UYMIXP]�XSPIVEXMRK�WSQI�SJ�MXW�[SVWX�JSVQW��)RKPERHIQTPS]IH�XEGXMGW�WMQMPEV�XS�XLSWI�YWIH�F]�-WVEIP YRGSQJSVXEFPI�TSWMXMSRW�PSYH�QYWMG��LSSHW��ERH�WS�JSVXL [LIR�MRXIVVSKEXMRK�WYWTIGXIH�XIVVSVMWXWMR�2SVXLIVR�-VIPERH��&YX�SRP]�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�WS�VITIEXIHP]�ERH�ZMGMSYWP]GSRHIQRIH�JSV�E�TVEGXMGI�XLEX�XLIMV�GYVVIRX�PE[�HSIW�RSX�IZIR�TIVQMX�

8,)�4633*

8LI�MWWYI�SJ�XSVXYVI��TIVLETW�FIXXIV�XLER�ER]�SXLIV��MPPYWXVEXIW�XLI�L]TS�GVMXMGEP�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�ETTPMIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP��-WVEIP¬W�VIGSVH�SR�XLI�MWWYISJ�XSVXYVI�MW�JEV�FIXXIV�XLER�XLEX�SJ�ER]�SXLIV�1MHHPI�)EWXIVR�SV�ER]�1YW�PMQ�REXMSR��ERH�FIXXIV�XLER�XLEX�SJ�QSWX�HIQSGVEGMIW��MRGPYHMRK�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW��*VERGI��ERH�+IVQER]��FYX�SRP]�-WVEIP�MW�VITIEXIHP]�GSR�HIQRIH�JSV�IRKEKMRK�MR�XSVXYVI��*SV�I\EQTPI��SRI�SJ�XLI�JSYV�MXIQW�GSQ�TVMWMRK�XLI�GSQTPEMRX�ERH�HIQERH�TSVXMSR�SJ�XLI�HMZIWXMXYVI�TIXMXMSR�XLEXMW�GYVVIRXP]�GMVGYPEXMRK�EVSYRH�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW�MRGPYHIW�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�©;I�EPWS�GEPP�SR�?YRMZIVWMXMIWA�XS�HMZIWX�JVSQ�-WVEIP�?YRXMPA�-WVEIP�MW�MR�GSQ�TPMERGI�[MXL�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�'SQQMXXII�%KEMRWX�8SVXYVI�����6ITSVX��[LMGL�VIGSQQIRHW�XLEX�-WVEIP¬W�YWI�SJ�XSVXYVI�FI�IRHIH�ª�8LMWTIXMXMSR�FIKER�GMVGYPEXMRK�MR�������XLVII�]IEVW�EJXIV�XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI'SYVX�VIRHIVIH�MXW�HIGMWMSR�TVSLMFMXMRK�XLI�YWI�SJ�TL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVIW�IZIRWLSVX�SJ�[LEX�QSWX�GSYRXVMIW��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��VIKEVH�EW�XSV�XYVI��8LI�MRXIVVSKEXMSR�XIGLRMUYIW�I\TPMGMXP]�TVSLMFMXIH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM7YTVIQI�'SYVX�MRGPYHI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�

��1EOMRK�XLI�WYWTIGX�©GVSYGL�������SR�XLI�XMT�SJ�LMW�XSIW�JSV�JMZI�QMRYXIMRXIVZEPWª

Page 146: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

��1EOMRK�XLI�WYWTIGX�WMX��LERHGYJJIH�XS�E�PS[�GLEMV�MR�XLI�YRGSQJSVX�EFPI�©7LEFEGL�TSWMXMSRª��©XLI�WYWTIGX�MW�GYJJIH�[MXL�?SRI�LERHATPEGIH�MRWMHI�XLI�KET�FIX[IIR�XLI�GLEMV¬W�WIEX�ERH�FEGO�WYTTSVX�[LMPI�XLI�SXLIV�MW�XMIH�FILMRH�LMQ��EKEMRWX�XLI�GLEMV¬W�FEGO�WYTTSVXª

��'SZIVMRK�XLI�WYWTIGX¬W�LIEH�[MXL�E�©ZIRXMPEXIH�WEGOª

��4PE]MRK�©TS[IVJYPP]�PSYH�QYWMGª

-X�MW�[SVXL�VIEHMRK�XLI�HIGMWMSR�F]�4VSJIWWSV�%LEVSR�&EVEO��XLI�TVIWM�HIRX�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX��[LMGL�MRGPYHIW�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�

8LI�JEGXW�TVIWIRXIH�FIJSVI�XLMW�'SYVX�VIZIEP�XLEX�SRI�LYRHVIH�ERH

X[IRX]�SRI�TISTPI�HMIH�MR�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�FIX[IIR��������XS���������

7IZIR�LYRHVIH�ERH�WIZIR�TISTPI�[IVI�MRNYVIH��%�PEVKI�RYQFIV�SJ�XLSWI

OMPPIH�ERH�MRNYVIH�[IVI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�LEVVS[MRK�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�MR�XLI

LIEVX�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�GMXMIW��1ER]�EXXEGOW MRGPYHMRK�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�

EXXIQTXW�XS�HIXSREXI�GEV�FSQFW��OMHRETTMRKW�SJ�GMXMIRW�ERH�WSPHMIVW�

EXXIQTXW�XS�LMKLNEGO�FYWIW��QYVHIVW��XLI�TPEGMRK�SJ�I\TPSWMZIW��IXG� [IVI

TVIZIRXIH�HYI�XS�XLI�QIEWYVIW�XEOIR�F]�XLI�EYXLSVMXMIW�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV

JMKLXMRK�XLI�EFSZI�HIWGVMFIH�LSWXMPI�XIVVSVMWX�EGXMZMXMIW�SR�E�HEMP]�FEWMW��

?8LI�HIGMWMSR�TVSGIIHW�XS�TVSLMFMX�EPP�JSVQW�SJ�TL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVI��XLIR

WYQQEVMIW�MXW�LSPHMRK�EW�JSPPS[W�A

8LMW�HIGMWMSR�STIRW�[MXL�E�HIWGVMTXMSR�SJ�XLI�HMJJMGYPX�VIEPMX]�MR�[LMGL

-WVEIP�JMRHW�LIVWIPJ�WIGYVMX]�[MWI��;I�WLEPP�GSRGPYHI�XLMW�NYHKQIRX�F]

VIEHHVIWWMRK�XLEX�LEVWL�VIEPMX]��;I�EVI�E[EVI�XLEX�XLMW�HIGMWMSR�HSIW�RSX

IEWI�HIEPMRK�[MXL�XLEX�VIEPMX]��8LMW�MW�XLI�HIWXMR]�SJ�HIQSGVEG]��EW�RSX�EPP

QIERW�EVI�EGGITXEFPI�XS�MX��ERH�RSX�EPP�TVEGXMGIW�IQTPS]IH�F]�MXW�IRIQMIW

EVI�STIR�FIJSVI�MX��%PXLSYKL�E�HIQSGVEG]�QYWX�SJXIR�JMKLX�[MXL�SRI

LERH�XMIH�FILMRH�MXW�FEGO��MX�RSRIXLIPIWW�LEW�XLI�YTTIV�LERH��4VIWIVZMRK

XLI�6YPI�SJ�0E[�ERH�VIGSKRMXMSR�SJ�ER�MRHMZMHYEP¬W�PMFIVX]�GSRWXMXYXIW�ER

MQTSVXERX�GSQTSRIRX�MR�MXW�YRHIVWXERHMRK�SJ�WIGYVMX]��%X�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI

HE]��XLI]�WXVIRKXLIR�MXW�WTMVMX�ERH�MXW�WXVIRKXL�ERH�EPPS[�MX�XS�SZIVGSQI�MXW

HMJJMGYPXMIW�

'SRWIUYIRXP]��MX�MW�HIGMHIH�XLEX�XLI�SVHIV�RMWM�FI�QEHI�EFWSPYXI��EW�[I

HIGPEVI�XLEX�XLI�+77�HSIW�RSX�LEZI�XLI�EYXLSVMX]�XS�©WLEOIª�E�QER��LSPH

LMQ�MR�XLI�©7LEFEGLª�TSWMXMSR�������JSVGI�LMQ�MRXS�E�©JVSK�GVSYGLª�TSWM�

XMSR�ERH�HITVMZI�LMQ�SJ�WPIIT�MR�E�QERRIV�SXLIV�XLER�XLEX�[LMGL�MW�MRLIV�

IRXP]�VIUYMVIH�F]�MRXIVVSKEXMSR��0MOI[MWI��[I�HIGPEVI�XLEX�XLI�©RIGIWWMX]ª

HIJIRWI��JSYRH�MR�XLI�4IREP�0E[��GERRSX�WIVZI�EW�E�FEWMW�SJ�EYXLSVMX]�JSV

XLI�YWI�SJ�XLIWI�MRXIVVSKEXMSR�TVEGXMGIW��SV�JSV�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�HMVIGXMZIW

TIVXEMRMRK�XS�+77�MRZIWXMKEXSVW��EPPS[MRK�XLIQ�XS�IQTPS]�MRXIVVSKEXMSR

TVEGXMGIW�SJ�XLMW�OMRH��

-�ORS[�SJ�RS�SXLIV�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�HIGMWMSR�EGORS[PIHKMRK�XLEX�XLIVIWXVMGXMSRW�MX�MQTSWIW�SR�MRXIVVSKEXMSR�[MPP�EPQSWX�GIVXEMRP]�GSWX�XLI�PMZIW

Page 147: The Case For Israel

SJ�MXW�GMZMPMERW��]IX�RSRIXLIPIWW�TVSLMFMXMRK�XLI�YWI�SJ�IJJIGXMZI�FYX�MRLY�QERI�XEGXMGW�

-R�PMKLX�SJ�XLMW�GSYVEKISYW�HIGMWMSR��MX�MW�MVSRMG�XLEX�MR�1E]������XLI(YXGL�WIGXMSRW�SJ�%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP�TYFPMGP]�STTSWIH�XLI�E[EVHMRK�SJE�LYQER�VMKLXW�TVMI�XS�XLI�EYXLSV�SJ�XLEX��ERH�QER]�SXLIV��LYQER�VMKLXWVYPMRKW�WYTTSVXMRK�4EPIWXMRMER�GPEMQW�SR�XLI�KVSYRH�XLEX�©XLI�-WVEIP7YTVIQI�'SYVX¬W�HIGMWMSRW�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�LYQER�VMKLXW�������LEZI�FIIRHIZEWXEXMRK�ª�%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP�WTIGMJMGEPP]�GPEMQIH�XLEX�©-WVEIP�MW�XLISRP]�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�[SVPH�XS�LEZI�IJJIGXMZIP]�PIKEPMIH�XSVXYVI�ª�-X�WLSYPHRSX�FI�WYVTVMWMRK�XLEX�WS�QER]�LYQER�VMKLXW�EHZSGEXIW�LEZI�PSWX�JEMXL�MR%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP¬W�SFNIGXMZMX]�[LIR�MX�GSQIW�XS�VITSVXMRK�SR�-WVEIP�

'SRXVEWX�XLI�-WVEIP�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�HIGMWMSR�[MXL�E�HIGMWMSR�SJ�XLI�9�7�'SYVX�SJ�%TTIEPW�JSV�XLI�)PIZIRXL�'MVGYMX�MR�E�GEWI�MRZSPZMRK�X[S�OMHRET�TIVW�[LS�[IVI�LSPHMRK�ER�EHYPX�ZMGXMQ�JSV�VERWSQ��3RI�SJ�XLI�OMHRETTIVWGEQI�XS�XLI�JEQMP]�LSQI�SJ�XLI�ZMGXMQ�XS�GSPPIGX�XLI�VERWSQ��ERH�XLITSPMGI�EVVIWXIH�LMQ�ERH�HIQERHIH�XLEX�LI�XIPP�XLIQ�XLI�[LIVIEFSYXW�SJLMW�GSRJIHIVEXI�ERH�XLI�ZMGXMQ��;LIR�LI�VIJYWIH��XLI�TSPMGIH�©GLSOIHªXLI�WYWTIGX�ERH�X[MWXIH�LMW�EVQ�©YRXMP�LI�VIZIEPIH�[LIVI�?XLI�ZMGXMQA�[EWFIMRK�LIPH�ª�3RI�NYHKI�GLEVEGXIVMIH�XLI�TSPMGI�EGXMSR�EW�©VEGO�ERH�TMR�MSR�XIGLRMUYIW�ª�2SRIXLIPIWW��XLI�'SYVX�SJ�%TTIEPW�ETTVSZIH�XLI�EGXMSRWEW�RIGIWWEV]�JSV�©E�KVSYT�SJ�GSRGIVRIH�SJJMGIVW�EGXMRK�MR�E�VIEWSREFPI�QER�RIV�XS�SFXEMR�MRJSVQEXMSR�XLI]�RIIHIH�MR�SVHIV�XS�TVSXIGX�ERSXLIV�MRHM�ZMHYEP�JVSQ�FSHMP]�LEVQ�SV�HIEXL�ª�8LI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ�-WVEIP�[SYPHRSX�LEZI�ETTVSZIH�XLMW�TSPMGI�EGXMSR�IMXLIV�MR�ER�SVHMREV]�GVMQMREP�GEWI�SVMR�E�XIVVSVMWX�TVIZIRXMSR�WMXYEXMSR�

8LI�TVEGXMGI�SYXPE[IH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�[EW�WMQMPEV�FSXL�MROMRH�ERH�HIKVII�XS�XLEX�FIMRK�YWIH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�JSPPS[MRK�7IT�XIQFIV�����������3R�1EVGL����������XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIWVITSVXIH�SRXLI�TEXXIVR�FIMRK�JSPPS[IH�F]�%QIVMGER�MRXIVVSKEXSVW��-X�MRGPYHIW�JSVGMRKHIXEMRIIW�XS�WXERH�REOIH��[MXL�©XLIMV�LERHW�GLEMRIH�XS�XLI�GIMPMRK�ERHXLIMV�JIIX�WLEGOPIH�ª�8LIMV�LIEHW�EVI�GSZIVIH�[MXL�©FPEGO�LSSHWª��XLI]�EVIJSVGIH�©XS�WXERH�SV�ORIIP�MR�YRGSQJSVXEFPI�TSWMXMSRW�MR�I\XVIQI�GSPH�SVLIEX�ª�[LMGL�GER�UYMGOP]�ZEV]�JVSQ�©����XS����HIKVIIW�ª�8LI�HIXEMRIIWEVI�HITVMZIH�SJ�WPIIT��©JIH�ZIV]�PMXXPI�ª�I\TSWIH�XS�HMWSVMIRXMRK�WSYRHW�ERHPMKLXW��ERH��EGGSVHMRK�XS�WSQI�WSYVGIW��©QERLERHPIHª�ERH�©FIEXIR�ª�-RSRI�GEWI�MRZSPZMRK�E�LMKL�VEROMRK�EP�5EIHE�STIVEXMZI��©TEMR�OMPPIVW�[IVI[MXLLIPH�JVSQ�1V��?%FYA�>YFE]HEL��[LS�[EW�WLSX�WIZIVEP�XMQIW�HYVMRKLMW�GETXYVI�ª�

%�;IWXIVR�MRXIPPMKIRGI�SJJMGMEP�HIWGVMFIH�XLIWI�XEGXMGW�EW�©RSX�UYMXI�XSV�XYVI��FYX�EFSYX�EW�GPSWI�EW�]SY�GER�KIX�ª�8LIVI�LEZI�FIIR�EX�PIEWX�X[S�HIEXLWERH�WIZIRXIIR�WYMGMHI�EXXIQTXW�EXXVMFYXIH�XS�XLIWI�MRXIVVSKEXMSR�XEGXMGW�;LIR�-WVEIP�LEW�IQTPS]IH�WMQMPEV�EPXLSYKL�WSQI[LEX�PIWW�I\XVIQI�XEGXMGW�XLI]�[IVI�YRMZIVWEPP]�GLEVEGXIVMIH�EW�XSVXYVI�[MXLSYX�IZIR�RSXMRK�XLEX�XLI]

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 148: The Case For Israel

[IVI�RSRPIXLEP�ERH�HMH�RSX�MRZSPZI�XLI�MRJPMGXMSR�SJ�WYWXEMRIH�TEMR��8LMWMW�[LEX�XLI�9�2��'SQQMXXII�%KEMRWX�8SVXYVI�GSRGPYHIH�MR������

8LI�'SQQMXXII�%KEMRWX�8SVXYVI�XSHE]�GSQTPIXIH�MXW�IMKLXIIRXL�WIW�

WMSR E�X[S�[IIO�WIVMIW�SJ�QIIXMRKW�QEVOIH��EQSRK�SXLIV�XLMRKW��F]�E

WTMVMXIH�HIFEXI�[MXL�-WVEIP�SZIV�+SZIVRQIRX�ETTVSZIH�YWI�HYVMRK�MRXIV�

VSKEXMSRW�SJ�[LEX�MX�XIVQIH�©QSHIVEXI�TL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVIª�MR�IJJSVXW�XS

IPMGMX�MRJSVQEXMSR�XLEX�GSYPH�JSMP�TIRHMRK�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW��8LMW�QSVRMRK

XLI�'SQQMXXII�WEMH�MR�SJJMGMEP�GSRGPYWMSR�XLEX�WYGL�MRXIVVSKEXMSR�QIXL�

SHW�ETTEVIRXP]�MRGPYHIH�VIWXVEMRMRK�MR�ZIV]�TEMRJYP�GSRHMXMSRW��LSPHMRK

YRHIV�WTIGMEP�GSRHMXMSRW��WSYRHMRK�SJ�PSYH�QYWMG�JSV�TVSPSRKIH�TIVMSHW�

WPIIT�HITVMZEXMSR�JSV�PSRK�TIVMSHW��XLVIEXW��MRGPYHMRK�HIEXL�XLVIEXW��ZMS�

PIRX�WLEOMRK��ERH�YWI�SJ�GSPH�EMV�XS�GLMPP ERH�XLEX�MR�XLI�'SQQMXXII¬W

ZMI[��WYGL�QIXLSHW�GSRWXMXYXI�XSVXYVI�EW�HIJMRIH�F]�%VXMGPI���SJ�XLI�'SR�

ZIRXMSR�EKEMRWX�8SVXYVI��IWTIGMEPP]�[LIR�XLI]�[IVI�YWIH�MR�GSQFMREXMSR�

[LMGL�MX�WEMH�ETTIEVIH�XS�FI�XLI�WXERHEVH�GEWI�

-X�GEPPIH��EQSRK�SXLIV�XLMRKW��JSV�-WVEIP�XS�©GIEWI�MQQIHMEXIP]ª�XLI

YWI�SJ�XLSWI�ERH�ER]�SXLIV�MRXIVVSKEXMSR�TVSGIHYVIW�XLEX�ZMSPEXIH�XLI

'SRZIRXMSR��ERH�IQTLEWMIH�XLEX�RS�GMVGYQWXERGIW IZIR�©XLI�XIVVMFPI

HMPIQQE�SJ�XIVVSVMWQª�XLEX�MX�EGORS[PIHKIH�[EW�JEGIH�F]�-WVEIP GSYPH

NYWXMJ]�XSVXYVI�

������1IQFIVW�SJ�E�+SZIVRQIRX�HIPIKEXMSR�ETTIEVMRK�FIJSVI�XLI�'SQ�

QMXXII�GSRXIRH�XLEX�WYGL�QIXLSHW�LEH�LIPTIH�XS�TVIZIRX�WSQI���

TPERRIH�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�SZIV�XLI�PEWX�X[S�]IEVW�ERH�LEH�WEZIH�QER]�GMZMP�

MER�PMZIW��MR�SRI�VIGIRX�GEWI�IREFPMRK�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]¬W�+IRIVEP

7IGYVMX]�7IVZMGI�XS�PSGEXI�E�FSQF��8LI�HIPIKEXMSR�VITIEXIHP]�HIRMIH�XLEX

XLI�TVSGIHYVIW�EQSYRXIH�XS�XSVXYVI���

;LIXLIV�XLI�TVSGIHYVIW�TVIZMSYWP]�YWIH�F]�-WVEIP�ERH�GYVVIRXP]�YWIH�F]XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�HMH�SV�HMH�RSX�GSRWXMXYXI�XSVXYVI��XLI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ-WVEIP�LEW�RS[�SYXPE[IH�XLIQ�

-RXIPPMKIRGI�SJJMGMEPW�©LEZI�EPWS�EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�WSQI�WYWTIGXW�LEZIFIIR�XYVRIH�SZIV�?F]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIWA�XS�WIGYVMX]�WIVZMGIW�MR�GSYRXVMIWORS[R�XS�IQTPS]�XSVXYVI�ª��8LIWI�GSYRXVMIW�MRGPYHI�)K]TX��.SVHER��XLI4LMPMTTMRIW��7EYHM�%VEFME��ERH�1SVSGGS��8YVRMRK�GETXMZIW�SZIV�XS�GSYR�XVMIW�JSV�XLI�TYVTSWI�SJ�LEZMRK�XLIQ�XSVXYVIH�MW�MR�TPEMR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�XLI�����-RXIVREXMSREP�'SRZIRXMSR�%KEMRWX�8SVXYVI��XS�[LMGL�[I��ERH�XLIGSYRXVMIW�XS�[LMGL�[I�EVI�WIRHMRK�XLI�GETXMZIW��EVI�WMKREXSVMIW�

%R�)K]TXMER�KSZIVRQIRX�WTSOIWQER�©FPEQIH�VSKYI�SJJMGIVWª�JSV�ER]EFYWI�MR�LMW�GSYRXV]�ERH�WEMH�©XLIVI�[EW�RS�W]WXIQEXMG�TSPMG]�SJ�XSVXYVI�ª,I�[IRX�SR�XS�EVKYI��©%R]�XIVVSVMWX�[MPP�GPEMQ�XSVXYVI XLEX¬W�XLI�IEWMIWXXLMRK��'PEMQW�SJ�XSVXYVI�EVI�YRMZIVWEP��,YQER�VMKLXW�SVKERMEXMSRW�QEOIXLIMV�PMZMRK�SR�XLIWI�GPEMQW�ª�8LI�WTSOIWQER�[IRX�SR�XS�FVEK�XLEX�)K]TXLEH�©WIX�XLI�QSHIPª�JSV�ERXMXIVVSVMWQ�MRMXMEXMZIW�ERH�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�MW

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 149: The Case For Israel

WIIQMRKP]�©MQMXEX?MRKA�XLI�)K]TXMER�QSHIP�ª�� ;LIR�-WVEIP�XSS�LEWGPEMQIH�XLEX�EPPIKEXMSRW�SJ�XSVXYVI�QEHI�F]�WSQI�HIXEMRIIW�[LS�LEZI�TVS�ZMHIH�MRJSVQEXMSR�QE]�FI�WIPJ�WIVZMRK�ERH�I\EKKIVEXIH��)K]TXMER�ERHSXLIV�EYXLSVMXMIW�LEZI�MRWMWXIH�XLEX�XLI�HIXEMRIIW�QYWX�FI�FIPMIZIH�

8LI;EPP�7XVIIX�.SYVREPVITSVXIH�XLEX�E�9�7��MRXIPPMKIRGI�SJJMGMEP�WEMHXLEX�HIXEMRIIW�[MXL�MQTSVXERX�MRJSVQEXMSR�GSYPH�FI�XVIEXIH�VSYKLP]�

%QSRK�XLI�XIGLRMUYIW��QEOMRK�GETXMZIW�[IEV�FPEGO�LSSHW��JSVGMRK�XLIQ

XS�WXERH�MR�TEMRJYP�©WXVIWW�TSWMXMSRWª�JSV�E�PSRK�XMQI�ERH�WYFNIGXMRK�XLIQ

XS�MRXIVVSKEXMSR�WIWWMSRW�PEWXMRK�EW�PSRK�EW����LSYVW�

9�7��SJJMGMEPW�SZIVWIIMRK�MRXIVVSKEXMSRW�SJ�GETXYVIH�EP�5EIHE�JSVGIW�EX

&EKVEQ�ERH�+YERXEREQS�&E]�2EZEP�&EWI�MR�'YFE�GER�IZIR�EYXLSVMI�©E

PMXXPI�FMX�SJ�WQEGO]�JEGI�ª�E�9�7��MRXIPPMKIRGI�SJJMGMEP�WE]W��©7SQI�EP�5EIHE

NYWX�RIIH�WSQI�I\XVE�IRGSYVEKIQIRX�ª�XLI�SJJMGMEP�WE]W�

©8LIVI¬W�E�VIEWSR�[L]�?1V��1SLEQQIHA�MWR¬X�KSMRK�XS�FI�RIEV�E

TPEGI�[LIVI�LI�LEW�1MVERHE�VMKLXW�SV�XLI�IUYMZEPIRX�SJ�XLIQ�ª�XLI�WIRMSV

JIHIVEP�PE[�IRJSVGIV�WE]W��©,I�[SR¬X�FI�WSQITPEGI�PMOI�7TEMR�SV�+IVQER]

SV�*VERGI��;I¬VI�RSX�YWMRK�XLMW�XS�TVSWIGYXI�LMQ��8LMW�MW�JSV�MRXIPPMKIRGI�

+SH�SRP]�ORS[W�[LEX�XLI]¬VI�KSMRK�XS�HS�[MXL�LMQ��=SY�KS�XS�WSQI

SXLIV�GSYRXV]�XLEX¬PP�PIX�YW�TMWXSP�[LMT�XLMW�KY]�ª������

9�7��EYXLSVMXMIW�LEZI�ER�EHHMXMSREP�MRHYGIQIRX�XS�QEOI�1V�

1SLEQQIH�XEPO��IZIR�MJ�LI�WLEVIW�XLI�WYMGMHEP�GSQQMXQIRX�SJ�XLI�7ITX�

���LMNEGOIVW��©8LI�%QIVMGERW�LEZI�EGGIWW�XS�X[S�SJ�LMW�IPIQIRXEV]�WGLSSP�

EKI�GLMPHVIR�ª�XLI�XST�PE[�IRJSVGIQIRX�SJJMGMEP�WE]W��©8LI�GLMPHVIR�[IVI

GETXYVIH�MR�E�7ITXIQFIV�VEMH�XLEX�RIXXIH�SRI�SJ�1V��1SLEQQIH¬W�XST

GSQVEHIW��6EQ M�&MREPWLMFL�ª��

8LIVI�MW�RS�HSYFX�XLEX�XLIWI�XEGXMGW�[SYPH�FI�TVSLMFMXIH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM7YTVIQI�'SYVX��FYX�XLI�9�7��'SYVX�SJ�%TTIEPW�JSV�XLI�(MWXVMGX�SJ'SPYQFME�VIGIRXP]�VYPIH�XLEX�%QIVMGER�GSYVXW�LEZI�RS�TS[IV�XS�IZIRVIZMI[�XLI�GSRHMXMSRW�MQTSWIH�SR�HIXEMRIIW�MR�+YERXEREQS�SV�SXLIVMRXIVVSKEXMSR�GIRXIVW�SYXWMHI�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW���

=IX�SR�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW�EGVSWW�XLI�[SVPH��RSX�E�[SVH�SJ�GVMXMGMWQ�MWLIEVH�EFSYX�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�YWI�SJ�XSVXYVI�F]�ER]�GSYRXVMIW�SXLIV�XLER-WVEIP��'IVXEMRP]�XLIVI�MW�RS�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�1YWPMQ�GSYRXVMIW�ERH�SXLIV�GSYR�XVMIW�XLEX�XSVXYVI�TSPMXMGEP�HMWWMHIRXW�VSYXMRIP]�[LMPI�JEGMRK�JEV�PIWWIV�XLVIEXWXLER�-WVEIP�JEGIW��8LMW�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�FIKER�EX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��[LIVIJEV�QSVI�XMQI��EXXIRXMSR��ERH�GSRHIQREXMSR�LEZI�FIIR�HMVIGXIH�EX�-WVEIP¬WJSVQIV�YWI�SJ�RSRPIXLEP�TL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVI�XS�IPMGMX�PMJIWEZMRK�MRJSVQEXMSRXLER�EX�PIXLEP�XSVXYVI�GYVVIRXP]�IQTPS]IH�F]�QER]�VIKMQIW��MRGPYHMRK�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��EKEMRWX�QIVI�TSPMXMGEP�STTSRIRXW��HMWWMHIRXW��ERH�GSP�PEFSVEXSVW��8LSWI�[LS�EGGYWI�SRP]�-WVEIP�SJ�YWMRK�XSVXYVI��[MXLSYX�GSR�HIQRMRK�XLI�JEV�QSVI�FVYXEP�ERH�PIWW�NYWXMJMEFPI�TVEGXMGIW�SJ�1MHHPI�)EWXIVRREXMSRW��LEZI�XLI�FYVHIR�SJ�NYWXMJ]MRK�XLIMV�TEPTEFPI�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 150: The Case For Israel

���

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP�MW�KYMPX]�SJ�KIRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�%VEFW�

8,)�%''97)67

©-�[SYPH�PMOI�XS�TVSTSWI�TYFPMGP]�LIVI�MR�+EE��4EPIWXMRI [LIVI�XLI-RXMJEHEL�FIKER�XIR�]IEVW�EKS�EX�XLMW�XMQI XLEX�XLI�4VSZMWMSREP�+SZIVR�QIRX�SJ�XLI�7XEXI�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�ERH�MXW�4VIWMHIRX�MRWXMXYXI�PIKEP�TVSGIIHMRKWEKEMRWX�-WVEIP�FIJSVI�XLI�-RXIVREXMSREP�'SYVX�SJ�.YWXMGI��-'. �MR�8LI,EKYI��XLI�WS�GEPPIH�;SVPH�'SYVX �JSV�ZMSPEXMRK�XLI������'SRZIRXMSR�SRXLI�4VIZIRXMSR�ERH�4YRMWLQIRX�SJ�XLI�'VMQI�SJ�+IRSGMHI��-�EQ�WYVI�[IGER�EPP�EKVII�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�MRHIIH�TIVTIXVEXIH�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GVMQI�SJKIRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�4ISTPI��8LI�TYVTSWI�SJ�XLMW�PE[WYMX�[SYPHFI�XS�HIQSRWXVEXI�XLEX�YRHIRMEFPI�JEGX�XS�XLI�IRXMVI�[SVPH��8LIWI�;SVPH'SYVX�PIKEP�TVSGIIHMRKW�[MPP�TVSZI�XS�XLI�IRXMVI�[SVPH�ERH�XS�EPP�SJ�LMWXSV]XLEX�[LEX�XLI�2EMW�HMH�XS�XLI�.I[W�E�KIRIVEXMSR�EKS�MW�PIKEPP]�WMQMPEV�XS[LEX�XLI�-WVEIPMW�EVI�GYVVIRXP]�HSMRK�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�4ISTPI�XSHE]��KIRS�GMHI��������'IVXEMRP]��4EPIWXMRI�LEW�E�ZEPMH�GPEMQ�XLEX�-WVEIP�ERH�MXW�TVIHIGIW�WSVW�MR�PE[ XLI�>MSRMWX�%KIRGMIW�ERH�*SVGIW LEZI�GSQQMXXIH�KIRSGMHIEKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�4ISTPI�XLEX�EGXYEPP]�WXEVXIH�MR������ERH�LEW�GSR�XMRYIH�ETEGI�YRXMP�XSHE]�MR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�+IRSGMHI�'SRZIRXMSR�%VXMGPI--�E ���F ��ERH��G ��MRXIV�EPME�©*SV�EX�PIEWX�XLI�TEWX�JMJX]�]IEVW��XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�ERH�MXW

,EW�-WVEIP�)RKEKIH�MR+IRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�4EPIWXMRMER�'MZMPMERW#

��

Page 151: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

TVIHIGIWWSVW�MR�PE[ XLI�>MSRMWX�%KIRGMIW�ERH�*SVGIW LEZI�VYXLPIWWP]MQTPIQIRXIH�E�W]WXIQEXMG�ERH�GSQTVILIRWMZI�QMPMXEV]��TSPMXMGEP��ERH�IGS�RSQMG�GEQTEMKR�[MXL�XLI�MRXIRX�XS�HIWXVS]�MR�WYFWXERXMEP�TEVX�XLIREXMSREP��IXLRMGEP�ERH�VEGMEP�KVSYT�ORS[R�EW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�4ISTPI��8LMW>MSRMWX�-WVEIPM�GEQTEMKR�LEW�GSRWMWXIH�SJ�OMPPMRK�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMER�4ISTPI�MR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�+IRSGMHI�'SRZIRXMSR�%VXMGPI�--�E �ª��*VER�GMW�&S]PI��MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�TVSJIWWSV�EX�XLI�9RMZIVWMX]�SJ�-PPMRSMW�TVIWIRXIH�MR�+EE�SR�(IGIQFIV�����������MR�LSRSV�SJ�XLI�XIRXLERRMZIVWEV]�SJ�XLI�JMVWX�MRXMJEHE�

8,)�6)%0-8=

%PP�REXMSRW�QYWX�FI�NYHKIH�MR�GSQTEVMWSR�[MXL�SXLIV�REXMSRW�JEGMRK�GSQ�TEVEFPI�XLVIEXW��'SRXI\X�MW�IWWIRXMEP�XS�ER]�JEMV�IZEPYEXMSR�SJ�E�REXMSR¬WFILEZMSV��.YHKIH�MR�XLMW�QERRIV��-WVEIP¬W�EGXMSR�MR�MXW�[EV�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQERH�I\XIVREP�EXXEGO�VIGIMZIW�VIPEXMZIP]�LMKL�KVEHIW��-RHIIH��RS�SXLIV�REXMSRJEGIH�[MXL�GSQTEVEFPI�XLVIEXW��FSXL�I\XIVREP�ERH�MRXIVREP��LEW�IZIV�FIIRQSVI�TVSXIGXMZI�SJ�IRIQ]�GMZMPMERW��QSVI�[MPPMRK�XS�XEOI�VMWOW�JSV�TIEGI�ERH�QSVI�GSQQMXXIH�XS�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�

8,)�4633*

*SV�XLVII�UYEVXIVW�SJ�E�GIRXYV]��XLI�%VEF§-WVEIPM�[EV�LEW�FIIR�FIX[IIR%VEF�REXMSRW�HIHMGEXIH�XS�KIRSGMHEP�EKKVIWWMSR�EKEMRWX�GMZMPMERW�SR�XLI�SRILERH�ERH�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�HIXIVQMRIH�XS�TVSXIGX�MXW�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�F]XEOMRK�HIJIRWMZI�EGXMSRW�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW�SR�XLI�SXLIVLERH��8LMW�[EV��MR�[LMGL�XLI�%VEF�WMHI�LEW�GSRWMWXIRXP]��MPPIKEPP]��ERHEKKVIWWMZIP]�XEVKIXIH�GMZMPMERW��ERH�XLI�-WVEIPM�WMHI�LEW�GSRWMWXIRXP]��PE[JYPP]�ERH�HIJIRWMZIP]�VIWTSRHIH�F]�EXXEGOMRK�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW��FIKER�MR�����[MXL�XLI�[IPP�TPERRIH�ERH�GEVIJYPP]�GSSVHMREXIH�QEWWEGVI�SJ�WM\X]�.I[MWLGLMPHVIR��[SQIR��SPH�TISTPI��ERH�SXLIV�YREVQIH�GMZMPMER�VIWMHIRXW�SJ�XLIFMFPMGEP�GMX]�SJ�,IFVSR��MR�[LMGL�.I[W�LEH�PMZIH�TIEGIJYPP]�ERH�GSRXMRYEPP]JVSQ�XMQI�MQQIQSVMEP��8LI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�XLMW�GVMQI�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]MRGPYHIH�QER]�.I[W�[LS�[IVI�RSX�>MSRMWXW�SV�WIXXPIVW��8LI������QEWWEGVI[EW�E�LEVFMRKIV�SJ�GMZMPMER�QEWWEGVIW�XS�GSQI QYGL�PMOI�/VMWXEPPREGLXRMRI�]IEVW�PEXIV��[LMGL�TSVXIRHIH�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��-X�[EW�EPWS�XLI�JMVWXMRWXERGI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�SJ�©IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK�ª�EW�EPP�XLI�.I[W�SJ�,IFVSR�[IVIIMXLIV�QYVHIVIH�SV�XVERWJIVVIH�SYX�SJ�XLI�GMX]�MR�[LMGL�.I[W�LEH�PMZIH�JSVQMPPIRRME�4VMSV�XS�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP��HMWWMHIRX�KVSYTW RSX

YRHIV�XLI�GSRXVSP�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�%KIRG]��XLI�TVI�-WVEIP�KSZIVRQIRX �SV�XLI,EKEREL��XLI�TVI�-WVEIP�SJJMGMEP�EVQ] HMH�FPS[�YT�XLI�LIEHUYEVXIVW�SJXLI�&VMXMWL�GSPSRMEP�KSZIVRQIRX�PSGEXIH�MR�E�[MRK�SJ�XLI�/MRK�(EZMH

Page 152: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

,SXIP��OMPPMRK�RMRIX]�SRI�TISTPI��QER]�SJ�[LSQ�[IVI�.I[W�ERH�&VMXMWLGSPSRMEP�SJJMGMEPW��8LI�-VKYR�GPEMQIH�XLEX�[EVRMRKW�LEH�FIIR�GEPPIH�MRFIJSVI�XLI�/MRK�(EZMH�[EW�FPS[R�YT��(MWWMHIRX�KVSYTW�EPWS�OMPPIH�GMZMPMERWEX�(IMV�=EWWMR��WII�GLETXIV��� �ERH�WSQI�SXLIV�PSGEXMSRW��FYX�XLIWI�HIZM�EXMSRW�[IVI�JMVQP]�GSRHIQRIH�F]�XLI�.I[MWL�%KIRG]��%W�WSSR�EW�-WVEIPFIGEQI�E�WXEXI��MXW�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV��(EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR��HMWEVQIH�XLIWI�HMW�WMHIRX�KVSYTW�F]�JSVGI��IZIR�WMROMRK�E�WLMT�PSEHIH�[MXL�[IETSRW�TYVGLEWIHF]�XLI�-VKYR��7M\XIIR�.I[W�[IVI�OMPPIH�F]�,EKEREL�JSVGIW�HYVMRK�XLI�FEX�XPI�SZIV�XLI�%PXEPERE�2S�JYVXLIV�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�[IVI�GSQQMXXIH�F]�XLI-VKYR�SV�0IGLM��&IR�+YVMSR�EPWS�HMWQERXPIH�XLI�4EPQEGL XLI�TIVQE�RIRXP]�QSFMPMIH�GSQQERHS�JSVGI�PS]EP�XS�&IR�+YVMSR¬W�S[R�TEVX] ERHQIVKIH�MX�MRXS�XLI�-(*��[LMGL�[EW�ERH�VIQEMRW�YRHIV�GMZMPMER�GSRXVSP�&IX[IIR������ERH�������4EPIWXMRMER�JIHE]IIR�WTSRWSVIH�F]�)K]TX�ERH

7]VME�QYVHIVIH�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�MR�LYRHVIHW�SJ�GVSWW�FSVHIV�VEMHW��8LIWIQYVHIVW�XSSO�TPEGI�FIJSVI�-WVEIP�SGGYTMIH�ER]�4EPIWXMRMER�PERH�SV�FYMPX�ER]WIXXPIQIRXW�SYXWMHI�SJ�XLI�EVIE�MX�GSRXVSPPIH�TYVWYERX�XS�XLI�9�2��TEVXM�XMSRW�ERH�XLI�GIEWI�JMVI�XLEX�JSPPS[IH�XLI������EXXEGO�EKEMRWX�XLI�RI[P]IWXEFPMWLIH�.I[MWL�WXEXI�-R�XLI������[EV��IZIV]�WMRKPI�%VEF�EVQ] MRGPYHMRK�XLI�)K]TXMER��7]V�

MER��4EPIWXMRMER��.SVHERMER��ERH�-VEUM�EVQMIW XEVKIXIH�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMER�TST�YPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�MR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�XLI�PE[W�SJ�[EV��%W�TVIZMSYWP]�HSGYQIRXIH�7]VMER�EVXMPPIV]�ERH�1-+W�STIRIH�JMVI�SR�-WVEIPM�XS[RW��OMFFYXMQ��ERHQSWLEZMQ��MRGPYHMRK�(IKERME��.SVHER�VEMRIH�������WLIPPW�SR�[IWXIVR.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�XLI�WYFYVFW�SJ�8IP�%ZMZ��[LMPI�MXW�,E[OIV�,YRXIV�JMKLXIVWHVSTTIH�FSQFW�SR�2IXER]E��/JEV�7MVOMR��ERH�/JEV�7EFE��-VEUM�TPERIWWXVEJIH�2ELEPEP��%JYPE��ERH�GMZMPMER�GSQQYRMXMIW�MR�XLI�.IVIIP�:EPPI]�(EQEWGYW�VEHMS�FVEKKIH�XLEX�XLI�7]VMER�EMV�JSVGI�[EW�FSQFMRK�-WVEIPM

GMXMIW��.SVHERMER�JSVGIW�[IVI�MRWXVYGXIH�XS�©HIWXVS]�EPP�FYMPHMRKW�ERH�OMPPIZIV]SRI�TVIWIRX�ª�MRGPYHMRK�GMZMPMERW��MJ�XLI]�GETXYVIH�TSVXMSRW�SJ.IVYWEPIQ��4EPIWXMRMER�FEXXPI�TPERW�MRGPYHIH�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�ERHMXW�MRLEFMXERXW��)K]TXMER�FEXXPI�TPERW�MRGPYHIH�XLI�QEWWEGVI�SJ�8IP�%ZMZ¬WGMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�EW�XLI�JMVWX�WXIT�XS[EVH�©XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�ª4SWXIVW�MR�'EMVS�WLS[IH�©%VEF�WSPHMIVW�WLSSXMRK��GVYWLMRK��WXVERKPMRK�ERHHMWQIQFIVMRK�FIEVHIH��LSSO�RSWIH�.I[W�ª�%W�2EWWIV�TYX�MX��©-J�[EVGSQIW�MX�[MPP�FI�XSXEP�ERH�XLI�SFNIGXMZI�[MPP�FI�-WVEIP¬W�HIWXVYGXMSR�ª�

-R�WLEVT�GSRXVEWX��-WVEIP�HMH�RSX�XEVKIX�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW��EPXLSYKL�MXGIVXEMRP]�LEH�XLI�GETEGMX]�XS�VIXEPMEXI�EKEMRWX�XLI�FSQFMRK�SJ�MXW�GMZMPMERTSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW��-WVEIP�XLVIEXIRIH�XS�FSQF�%QQER�ERH�(EQEWGYW�HYV�MRK�XLI������[EV�MJ�.SVHERMER�ERH�7]VMER�JSVGIW�TIVWMWXIH�MR�FSQFMRK-WVEIPM�GMXMIW��FYX�MX�RIZIV�HMH�WS��-X�FSQFIH�EMV�FEWIW��XERO�GSRZS]W��ERHSXLIV�PIKMXMQEXI�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW��HIWTMXI�MXW�IRIQMIW¬�XEVKIXMRK�SJ�-WVEIPMGMZMPMERW�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�WLSVX�[EV��-R�3VIR¬W�HIJMRMXMZI�EGGSYRX�SJ�XLI�����[EV��LI�GSRGPYHIH�XLEX�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�GEWYEPXMIW�EQSRK�%VEF

Page 153: The Case For Israel

GMZMPMERW�[EW�©VIQEVOEFP]�PS[ª�FIGEYWI�-WVEIP¬W�QMPMXEV]�EGXMSRW�[IVI�GSR�HYGXIH�©JEV�JVSQ�QENSV�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW�ª�

7MRGI�XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI������[EV��XLI�IRXMVI�JSGYW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�EKKVIW�WMSR�LEW�FIIR�SR�GMZMPMERW��FSXL�MRWMHI�-WVEIP�ERH�EVSYRH�XLI�[SVPH��+PSFEPXIVVSVMWQ�FIKER�MR������RSX�EW�E�PEWX�VIWSVX�EKEMRWX�E�PSRK�SGGYTEXMSR�FYXEW�E�JMVWX�VIWSVX VIEPP]�EW�E�GSRXMRYEXMSR�SJ�ER�MPPIKEP�ERH�MQQSVEP�XEGXMGXLEX�LEH�FIIR�GSRXMRYSYWP]�YWIH�F]�XLI�%VEFW�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W�WMRGI�XLIFIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�GSRJPMGX��8EVKIXMRK�GMZMPMERW�[EW�RSX�E�VIWYPX�SJ�XLI�SGGY�TEXMSR��8S�XLI�GSRXVEV]��XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�[EW�XLI�VIWYPX EX�PIEWX�MR�TEVXSJ�E�PSRK�%VEF�LMWXSV]�SJ�QEWWEGVMRK�GMZMPMERW�-J�SGGYTEXMSR�[IVI�XS�NYWXMJ]�XIVVSVMWQ��XLIR�XLI�TSWX§'MZMP�;EV�/Y

/PY\�/PER�ERH�XLI�2MKLX�6MHIVW�[LS�XIVVSVMIH�FPEGOW�HYVMRK�6IGSR�WXVYGXMSR [LMGL�MRGPYHIH�XLI�QMPMXEV]�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLI�HIJIEXIH�'SR�JIHIVEG] [SYPH�FI�WIIR�EW�JVIIHSQ�JMKLXIVW��=IX�XLIWI�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTWLEZI�FIIR�VIPIKEXIH��UYMXI�HIWIVZIHP]��XS�XLI�HYWXFMR�SJ�LMWXSV]�ERH�EVIKPSVMJMIH�SRP]�MR�VEGMWX�JMPQW�PMOI�&MVXL�SJ�E�2EXMSR�1ER]�SJ�XLSWI�[LSQEVGL�MR�WYTTSVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�[SYPH�FI�SYXVEKIH�MJ�&MVXL�SJ�E2EXMSR[IVI�XS�FI�WLS[R�SR�E�GSPPIKI�GEQTYW��SV�MJ�XLI�/PER�[IVI�XS�FIMRZMXIH�XS�VIGVYMX�QIQFIVW��HIWTMXI�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXWLEZI�P]RGLIH�ERH�FPS[R�YT�QSVI�TISTPI MRGPYHMRK�LYRHVIHW�SJ�TISTPISJ�GSPSV� XLER�XLI�/PER�QEREKIH�XS�OMPP�MR�MXW�GIRXYV]�PSRK�VIMKR�SJ�XIV�VSV��8LSWI�[LS�TVEMWIH�ERH�WYTTSVXIH�XLI�QYVHIVIVW�[LS�H]REQMXIH�XLIFPEGO�GLYVGL�MR�[LMGL�JSYV�KMVPW�[IVI�OMPPIH�EVI�RS[�VIKEVHIH�EW�QSVEPQSRWXIVW��=IX�XLSWI��WYGL�EW�XLI�TSIX�8SQ�4EYPMR��[LS�TVEMWI�ERH�WYTTSVXXIVVSVMWXW�[LS�QYVHIV�.I[W�EVI�MRZMXIH�XS�WTIEO�SR�GSPPIKI�GEQTYWIW�EWLSRSVIH�KYIWXW�8SFI�WYVI��4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERW�LEZI�HMIH�MR�XLI�WIZIRX]�XLVII�]IEV�

PSRK�[EV��FYX�XLIMV�RYQFIVW�LEZI�FIIR�MRJMRMXIWMQEP�MR�GSQTEVMWSR�[MXLXLI�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�%VEFW�OMPPIH�F]�.SVHER��7]VME��-VEU��ERH-VER�HYVMRK�XLMW�WEQI�TIVMSH��)ZIR�GSQTEVMRK�MRRSGIRX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERGEWYEPXMIW�[MXL�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�VIZIEPW�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�EGXIH[MXL�VIWXVEMRX��%RH�XLMW�HSIW�RSX�XEOI�MRXS�EGGSYRX�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�QER]�SJXLI�WS�GEPPIH�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERW�[IVI�RSX�WS�MRRSGIRX�LEVFSVIVW�ERH�WYT�TSVXIVW�SJ�XIVVSVMWXW�1SVISZIV��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�HIEXLW�LEZI�VIWYPXIH�TVMQEVMP]�JVSQ�XIVVSVMWXW

LMHMRK�EQSRK�XLIMV�S[R�GMZMPMERW��EW�MR�0IFERSR��[LIVIEW�XLI�-WVEIPMHIEXLW�LEZI�VIWYPXIH�JVSQ�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�FIMRK�WTIGMJMGEPP]�XEVKIXIH�;LIR�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�FIIR�EGGMHIRXEPP]�OMPPIH�MR�E�PIKMXMQEXI�IJJSVX�XSTVIZIRX�XIVVSVMWQ��-WVEIP�LEW�I\TVIWWIH�KIRYMRI�VIKVIX��8LI�QYVHIV�SJMRRSGIRX�-WVEIPMW��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��LEW�KIRIVEXIH�GIPIFVEXMSR�EQSRK4EPIWXMRMERW�-R�������&EVYGL�+SPHWXIMR��E�HIVERKIH�.I[MWL�HSGXSV�JVSQ�,IFVSR�

QEGLMRI�KYRRIH����1YWPMQW�EX�TVE]IV��,MW�JEQMP]�GPEMQIH�XLEX�XLI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 154: The Case For Israel

VITIEXIH�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�.I[W�QEHI�LMQ�WRET��-X�MW�MRXIVIWXMRK�XLEXXLI�WEQI�TISTPI�[LS�LEZI�EP[E]W�GPEMQIH�XLEX�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW ERHXLSWI�[LS�WIRH�XLIQ [IVI�TVSZSOIH�F]�-WVEIPM�VITVIWWMSR�MRXS�XLIMV�QYV�HIVSYW�EGXW�UYMGOP]�VINIGX�XLMW�GPEMQ�[LIR�MX�MW�QEHI�F]�E�.I[MWL�JEQMP]��-RER]�IZIRX��+SPHWXIMR¬W�MRHMZMHYEP�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGO�EKEMRWX�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMP�MERW�[EW�WXVSRKP]�GSRHIQRIH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�ERH�XLI�SZIV�[LIPQMRK�QENSVMX]�SJ�-WVEIPMW�ERH�.I[W�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH��8LMW�MW�MRWLEVT�GSRXVEWX�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�VIEGXMSR�XS�XLIMV�©QEVX]VWª�[LS�FPS[�YTMRRSGIRX�-WVEIPMW�ERH�.I[W��8LIWI�TISTPI�EVI�TVEMWIH�ERH�XLIMV�JEQMPMIW�EVIVI[EVHIH�JSV�XLIMV�[IPP�TPERRIH�GVMQIW�-R�%TVMP�������JSPPS[MRK�LYRHVIHW�SJ�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�XLEX�GYPQM�

REXIH�MR�XLI�4EWWSZIV�WIHIV�QEWWEGVI�SJ�X[IRX]�RMRI�.I[MWL�[SQIR��GLMP�HVIR��ERH�QIR�EX�TVE]IV��XLI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�IRXIVIH�XLI�.IRMR�VIJYKII�GEQT�[LMGL�LEW�FIGSQI�E�FSQF�QEOMRK�JEGXSV]�ERH�XIVVSVMWX�GIRXIV��-RWXIEH�SJFSQFMRK�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW¬�GEQT�JVSQ�XLI�EMV��EW�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�HMH�MR%JKLERMWXER�ERH�EW�6YWWME�HMH�MR�'LIGLR]E��[MXL�PMXXPI�VMWO�XS�XLIMV�S[RWSPHMIVW�FYX�QYGL�XS�GMZMPMERW��-WVEIPM�MRJERXV]QIR�IRXIVIH�XLI�GEQT��KSMRKLSYWI�XS�LSYWI�MR�WIEVGL�SJ�XIVVSVMWXW�ERH�FSQF�QEOMRK�IUYMTQIRX�[LMGL�XLI]�JSYRH��8[IRX]�XLVII�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�ERH�JMJX]�X[S�4EPIWXMRMERW�QER]�SJ�[LSQ�[IVI�GSQFEXERXW��[IVI�OMPPIH��8LMW�MW�RS[�GEPPIH�E�QEW�WEGVI�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�TVSTEKERHMWXW��&]�-WVEIPM�WXERHEVHW�XLI�HIEXLW�SJ�JMJX]�X[S�4EPIWXMRMERW��WSQI�SJ�[LSQ�[IVI�RSX�GSQFEXERXW��[IVI�E�HIZMEXMSRJVSQ�XLI�RSVQ��IZIR�XLSYKL�XLI]�TPEGIH�XLIMV�S[R�WSPHMIVW�EX�VMWO�XS�QMR�MQMI�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW��&YX�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWX�WXERHEVHW�XLI�OMPPMRK�SJ�SRP]�E�JI[�LERHJYPW�SJ�RSRGSQFEXERXW�MW�NYWX�ERSXLIV�EZIVEKIHE]�JSV�XLIMV�XIVVSVMWQ��=IX�XLI�L]TSGVMXMGEP�4EPIWXMRMER�GV]�SJ�E�.IRMR�QEW�WEGVI�TIVWMWXW��ERH�MX�MW�WYTTSVXIH�F]�XLI�LIEH�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW6IJYKII�%KIRG]��926;% ��4IXIV�,ERWSR��E�PSRKXMQI�ETSPSKMWX�JSV��ERHJEGMPMXEXSV�SJ��XIVVSVMWQ��,I�GLEVEGXIVMIH�-WVEIP¬W�EGXMSRW�MR�.IRMR�EW�E©LYQER�VMKLXW�GEXEWXVSTLI�XLEX�LEW�JI[�TEVEPPIPW�MR�VIGIRX�LMWXSV]�ª2SX�SRP]�[EW�.IRMR�RSX�E�QEWWEGVI�SV�ER�YRTEVEPPIH�GEXEWXVSTLI�FYX�MX

MW�VIKEVHIH�F]�QER]�EW�E�QSHIP�SJ�LS[�XS�GSRHYGX�YVFER�[EVJEVI�EKEMRWXXIVVSVMWXW�LMHMRK�EQSRK�GMZMPMERW��%�2I[�=SVO�8MQIWWXSV]�SJ�%TVMP���������VITSVXIH�XLEX�XLI�9�7��QMPMXEV]�LEW�WXYHMIH�-WVEIP¬W�I\TIVMIRGI�©MR�GPSWI�UYEVXIV�JMKLXMRKª�

9RMXIH�7XEXIW�%VQ]�SJJMGMEPW�LEZI�WEMH�XLI]�[IVI�TEVXMGYPEVP]�MRXIVIWXIH�MR

LS[�XLI�-WVEIPM�%VQ]�YWIH�WTIGMEPP]�PSEHIH�XERO�VSYRHW�XS�FPEWX�LSPIW

XLVSYKL�[EPPW��[MXLSYX�GSPPETWMRK�FYMPHMRKW��HYVMRK�JMKLXMRK�PEWX�]IEV�MR

XLI�.IRMR�VIJYKII�GEQT��-R�.IRMR��-WVEIP�EPWS�YWIH�FYPPHSIVW�ERH�[MVI�

KYMHIH�QMWWMPIW�JMVIH�JVSQ�LIPMGSTXIVW�XS�SZIV[LIPQ�EFSYX�����KYRQIR

LSPIH�YT�MRWMHI�XLI�GEQT��

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 155: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

8LI8MQIWWXSV]�UYSXIH�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]�LMWXSVMER�1EVXMR�ZER�'VIZIPHWXEXMRK�XLEX�[LIR�LI�ZMWMXIH�ER�%QIVMGER�QMPMXEV]�GEQT��XLI�1EVMRIW�[IVI©MRXIVIWXIH�MR�[LEX�MX�[SYPH�FI�PMOI�JMKLXMRK�E�KYIVVMPPE�[EV��IWTIGMEPP]YVFER�[EVJEVI�SJ�XLI�OMRH�[I�[IVI�GSRHYGXMRK�MR�.IRMR�ª4VSJIWWSV�ZER�'VIZIPH�JSGYWIH�SR�FYPPHSIVW��LIPMGSTXIVW��ERH�©XLI

QSVEP�ERH�IXLMGEP�TVSFPIQW�XLEX�[IVI�WYVI�XS�GSQIª�JVSQ�JMKLXMRKEQSRK�RSRGSQFEXERXW��

%R�ST�IH�EVXMGPI�MR�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIWSR�%TVMP����������YVKIH�%QIV�MGER�GSQQERHIVW�XS�©XEOI�E�GPSWI�PSSO�EX�XLI�LEVH�PIEVRIH�PIWWSRW�SJ-WVEIP¬W�I\TIVMIRGI�[MXL�YVFER�GSQFEX�ª�FIGEYWI�MX�TVSZMHIH�©E�KSSHQSHIP�JSV�QMPMXEV]�XEGXMGW�ª8LI�TMIGI�[IRX�SR�XS�WE]�

8[IRX]�RMRI�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�[IVI�OMPPIH�MR�XLIWI�FEXXPIW��EPP�FYX�WM\�SJ

XLIQ�MR�XLI�FEXXPI�JSV�XLI�.IRMR�VIJYKII�GEQT��%PXLSYKL�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ

4EPIWXMRMER�HIEXLW�MW��SJ�GSYVWI��LSXP]�HIFEXIH��XLI�-WVEIPM�IWXMQEXI�MW����

OMPPIH�MR�2EFPYW�ERH�.IRMR��'SQTEVIH�[MXL�GEWYEPX]�JMKYVIW�JVSQ�YVFER

GSQFEX�MR�VIGIRX�]IEVW WYGL�EW�XLI�JMKLXMRK�MR�'LIGLR]E��[LIVI�6YWWME¬W

EVQ]�PSWX�EX�PIEWX�������WSPHMIVW�HYVMRK�MXW�JMVWX�EWWEYPX�SR�+VSR] XLIWI

RYQFIVW�EVI�EWXSRMWLMRKP]�PS[��

%�GSZIV�WXSV]�MR�XLI�.YRI������MWWYI�SJ�%XPERXMG�1SRXLP]F]�E�PIEHMRK�XIV�VSVMWX�I\TIVX�JSV�XLI�6ERH�'SVTSVEXMSR�EPWS�JSGYWIH�SR�XLI�©PIWWSRWª%QIVMGE�QYWX�PIEVR�JVSQ�LS[�-WVEIP�HIEPW�[MXL�XIVVSVMWQ�%�PIEH�WXSV]�MR�XLI�©-HIEWª�WIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�&SWXSR�+PSFIEREP]IH�XLI�IXL�

MGEP�XVEMRMRK�VIGIMZIH�F]�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�ERH�GSRGPYHIH��©8LI�-(*�EVQ]SJJIVW�E�QSHIP�JSV�YW�ERH�SXLIV�GSEPMXMSR�JSVGIW�ª�-X�HIWGVMFIH�XLI�-WVEIPMGSRGITX�SJ�©TYVMX]�SJ�EVQW�ª�[LMGL�©VIUYMVIW�XLEX�WSPHMIVW�TYX�XLIMV�S[RPMZIW�EX�WXEOI�MR�SVHIV�XS�EZSMH�LEVQMRK�RSR�GSQFEXERXW�ª�-X�EPWS�VIUYMVIWXLIQ�XS�VIWTSRH�SRP]�[MXL�©TVSTSVXMSREP�JSVGI�ª�8LI�-(*¬W�IXLMGEP�GSHI�[LMGL�MW�©MRGSVTSVEXIH�MRXS�XLI�XVEMRMRK�SJ�EPP�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�ª�[EW�GSQ�TMPIH�©[MXL�XLI�EWWMWXERGI�SJ�WSQI�SJ�XLI�GSYRXV]¬W�PIEHMRK�QSVEP�TLMPSWS�TLIVWª�ERH�©IRNS]W�[MHIWTVIEH�WYTTSVX�EQSRK�ER�SXLIV[MWI�HMZMHIHGMXMIRV]�ª�-X�VIUYMVIW�IZIV]�WSPHMIV�XS�EGX�©SYX�SJ�E�VIGSKRMXMSR�SJ�XLIWYTVIQI�ZEPYI�SJ�LYQER�PMJIª�ERH�GSQQERHW�XLIQ�XS�©HS�EPP�MR�?XLIMVATS[IV�XS�EZSMH�GEYWMRK�LEVQ�XS�?RSRGSQFEXERXW¬A�PMZIW��FSHMIW��HMKRMX]ERH�TVSTIVX]��ERH�VIJVEMR�JVSQ�SFI]MRK�FPEXERXP]�MPPIKEP�SVHIVW�ª3RI�SJ�XLI�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�XIEQ�[LS�HVEJXIH�XLI�GSHI�MW�E�[IPP�

ORS[R�TIEGI�EHZSGEXI��4VSJIWWSV�1SWLI�,EPFIVXEP��[LS�WYTTSVXW�YRM�PEXIVEP�-WVEIPM�[MXLHVE[EP�JVSQ�XLI�XIVVMXSVMIW��,I�VIGSKRMIW�XLEX�XLIWXVEXIK]�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�XLI�VIGIRX�MRXMJEHE�LEW�FIIR�©XS�IVEWI�XLIHMWXMRGXMSR�FIX[IIR�GSQFEXERXW�ERH�RSRGSQFEXERXW�SR�FSXL�WMHIWª�F]XEVKIXMRK�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�ERH�LEZMRK�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�FPIRH�MRXS�XLI

Page 156: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

4EPIWXMRMERGMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR��2SRIXLIPIWW��LI�WIIW�XLI�GLEPPIRKI�XS-WVEIP�EW�HMVIGXMRK�MXW�HIJIRWMZI�QIEWYVIW�©EKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LS�MRWXM�KEXIª�� E�HEYRXMRK�GLEPPIRKI�MRHIIH�[MXL�E�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�XLEXGSRXEMRW�XLSYWERHW�YTSR�XLSYWERHW�SJ�MRWXMKEXSVW��JEGMPMXEXSVW��LEVFSVIVW�ERH�WYTTSVXIVW�-WVEIP�LEW�QIX�XLEX�GLEPPIRKI�FIXXIV�XLER�ER]�REXMSR�XLEX�LEW�JEGIH�GSQ�

TEVEFPI�HERKIVW��%GGSVHMRK�XS�-(*�JMKYVIW�GSQTMPIH�FIX[IIR�7ITXIQFIV�����ERH�1EVGL�������©���TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�RIEVP]�������4EPIWXMRMERW�OMPPIHF]�-WVEIPM�JSVGIW�������[IVI�GMZMPMERW�[MXL�RS�GSRRIGXMSRW�XS�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSV�ª8LMW�MW�E�GSRWMHIVEFP]�PS[IV�VEXMS�SJ�GMZMPMER�HIEXLW�XLER�XLSWI�EGLMIZIH�F]SXLIV�EVQMIW��4VSJIWWSV�1MGLEIP�;EPIV�SJ�4VMRGIXSR�9RMZIVWMX]��E�WXVSRKGVMXMG�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�ERH�XLI�EYXLSV�SJ�XLI������GPEWWMG�.YWX�ERH9RNYWX�;EVW�LEW�RSXIH�XLEX

MR�FEXXPI��XLI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�VIKYPEVP]�EGGITXIH�VMWOW�XS�MXW�S[R�QIR�MR�SVHIV

XS�VIHYGI�XLI�VMWOW�XLEX�MX�TSWIH�SR�XLI�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR��8LI�GSRXVEWX

[MXL�XLI�[E]�XLI�6YWWMERW�JSYKLX�MR�+VSR]��XS�XEOI�XLI�QSWX�VIGIRX

I\EQTPI�SJ�PEVKI�WGEPI�YVFER�[EVJEVI��MW�WXVMOMRK��ERH�XLI�GVYGMEP�QEVO�SJ

XLEX�GSRXVEWX�MW�XLI�ZIV]�WQEPP�RYQFIV�SJ�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�MR�XLI�4EPIW�

XMRMER�GMXMIW�HIWTMXI�XLI�JMIVGIRIWW�SJ�XLI�JMKLXMRK�ª��

8LMW�WMXYEXMSR�EPWS�GSQTEVIW�JEZSVEFP]�[MXL�XLI�[E]�[I�WSQIXMQIW�JSYKLXMR�-VEU��EW�[I�WLEPP�WSSR�WII�8LVII�WXSVMIW�MPPYWXVEXI�XLI�-WVEIPM�GSQQMXQIRX�XS�TVSTSVXMSREPMX]�ERH

XS�EZSMHMRK�YRRIGIWWEV]�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW��8LI�JMVWX�MRZSPZIW�ER�-WVEIPMEXXEGO�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�7EPEL�7LILEHIL��E�PIEHMRK�,EQEW�GSQQERHIV�[LS[EW�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�LYRHVIHW�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�FSQFMRKW��3R�WIZIVEP�SGGEWMSRW�XLI�EVQ]�TEWWIH�YT�STTSVXYRMXMIW�XS�EXXEGO�LMQ�©FIGEYWI�LI�[EW�[MXL�LMW[MJI�SV�GLMPHVIR��)EGL�XMQI�7LILEHIL¬W�PMJI�[EW�WTEVIH��LI�HMVIGXIH�QSVIWYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�ª�-R�SXLIV�[SVHW��-WVEIP�[EW�TVITEVIH�XSVMWO�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�MXW�S[R�GMZMPMERW�MR�SVHIV�XS�WTEVI�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERGMZMPMERW��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�[MJI�SJ�E�QENSV�XIVVSVMWX�8LI�WIGSRH�WXSV]�[EW�VIPEXIH�F]�XLI�GLMIJ�SJ�WXEJJ�SJ�XLI�-(*��1SWLI

=E¬EPSR��-X�MRZSPZIW

ER�MRXIPPMKIRGI�SJJMGIV�[LS�LEW�TVIZIRXIH�XLI�EMV�JSVGI�JVSQ�EXXEGOMRK�E

4EPIWXMRMER�XEVKIX�F]�[MXLLSPHMRK�RIGIWWEV]�MRJSVQEXMSR��8LI�SJJMGIV�LEH

FIPMIZIH��QMWXEOIRP]��XLEX�XLI�STIVEXMSR�[SYPH�TYX�GMZMPMERW�EX�VMWO��©*VSQ

XLI�QSVEP�TSMRX�SJ�ZMI[��LI�HIWIVZIW�E�GSQQIRHEXMSR�ª�GSQQIRXIH

=E¬EPSR��©*VSQ�XLI�STIVEXMSREP�SRI��LI�HIWIVZIH�XS�FI�VIQSZIH�JVSQ�LMW

TSWX�ª�8LI�GLMIJ�SJ�WXEJJ�EHHIH�XLEX�LI�[EW�©TVSYH�XLEX�[I�LEZI�SJJMGIVWª

[LS�XEOI�XLIMV�QSVEP�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�WS�WIVMSYWP]�

Page 157: The Case For Israel

8LI�XLMVH�WXSV]�MRZSPZIW�ER�-WVEIPM�MRJERXV]�SJJMGIV�REQIH�>I¬IZ�[LSHIWGVMFIH

E�X[S�QSRXL�WXEOISYX�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�ZMPPEKI�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��©)ZIV]

RMKLX�XLIVI�[EW�E�WLSSXMRK�JVSQ�XLI�ZMPPEKI��LIEZ]�KYRJMVI��;LIR�]SY�WII

E�TIVWSR�[MXL�E�KYR��XLIVI¬W�RS�UYIWXMSR�[LEX�]SY�LEZI�XS�HS��&YX�[LIR

]SY�WII�RSX�XLVII�SV�JSYV��FYX�VEXLIV����TISTPI��[MXL�E�WMRKPI�VMJPI��[LMGL

QSZIW�EVSYRH��]SY�LEZI�XS�TMGO�]SYV�XEVKIXW�GEVIJYPP]�ª

>I¬IZ�VIGSYRXW�ER�MRGMHIRX�MR�[LMGL�E�GSQVEHI�LEH�LMW�GSQQERHIV¬W

EYXLSVMEXMSR�XS�WLSSX�ER�EVQIH�GSQFEXERX�FIPS[�XLI�ORIIW XS�[SYRH�

RSX�XS�OMPP��8LI�WSPHMIV�WLSX�X[MGI��XLI�WIGSRH�XMQI�EJXIV�XLI�IRIQ]�LEH

JEPPIR�XS�XLI�KVSYRH��ERH�IRHIH�YT�OMPPMRK�E�]SYRK�FS]�[MXL�E�VMJPI�

8LI�WSPHMIV��EGGSVHMRK�XS�>I¬IZ��[EW�©WIRX�XS�NEMP��ERH�XLVS[R�SYX�SJ�LMWYRMXª E�GPEMQ�XLEX�GSYPH�RSX�FI�MRHITIRHIRXP]�GSVVSFSVEXIH�FIGEYWI�SRP]JMVWX�REQIW�[IVI�KMZIR��-X�GER�FI�GSVVSFSVEXIH�XLEX�ZMSPEXMSRW�SJ�XLI�GSHILEZI�FIIR�MRZIWXMKEXIH�ERH�IZIR�TVSWIGYXIH��EPXLSYKL�RSX�MR�PEVKI�RYQ�FIVW��%GGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�&SWXSR�+PSFIEGGSYRX�

>I¬IZ�WE]W�XLEX�FILEZMRK�[MXL�VIWXVEMRX�YRHIV�JMVI�©MW�RSX�E�QMWWMSR�MQTSW�

WMFPI�ª�,I�EHHW��©-J�]SY�LEZI�ER]�WIRWI�SJ�QSVEP�FILEZMSV��ERH�]SY�XLMRO

JSV�E�WIGSRH��XLIVI�WLSYPHR¬X�FI�ER]�TVSFPIQ�WXMGOMRK�XS�XLI�XLMRKW�XLEX

EVI�MR�XLI�GSHI�ª

&YX�RSX�IZIV]SRI�MR�XLI�-(*�XLMROW�MX¬W�XLEX�WMQTPI��)PEEV�7XIVR��E

FVMKEHMIV�KIRIVEP�ERH�GLMIJ�SJ�XLI�-(*�)HYGEXMSR�'SVTW��MW�E[EVI�SJ�XLI

QSVEP�EQFMKYMXMIW�MRLIVIRX�MR�E�WSPHMIV¬W�NSF��©4EVX�SJ�[LEX�XLI�REXMSR

HIQERHW�SJ�YW�ª�LI�WE]W��©MW�E�[MPPMRKRIWW�XS�LEZI�SYV�LIEHW�XSWW�ERH�XYVR

SR�XLI�TMPPS[�WIZIVEP�XMQIW�EX�RMKLX��%RH��MJ�]SY¬VI�PYGO]��MR�XLI�IRH�]SY¬PP

ORS[�XLEX�]SY�HMH�XLI�VMKLX�XLMRK�ª��

8LMW�OMRH�SJ�XSWWMRK�ERH�XYVRMRK�MW�X]TMGEP�SJ�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�[LS�QYWXQEOI�PMJI�ERH�HIEXL�HIGMWMSRW�GSRWXVEMRIH�F]�E�VMKMH�GSHI�SJ�GSRHYGX�8LIMV�HIGMWMSRW�EVI�RSX�EP[E]W�XLI�VMKLX�SRIW��QMWXEOIW�MRIZMXEFP]�SGGYV�MRXLI�JSK�SJ�[EV��IWTIGMEPP]�[LIR�XIVVSVMWXW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�LMHI�FILMRH�GMZMPMERWMR�SVHIV�XS�TVSZSOI�QMWXEOIW�XLEX�EHH�XS�XLI�FSH]�GSYRX E�GSYRX�XLEX�MWGIRXVEP�XS�XLIMV�GVYIP�EVMXLQIXMG�SJ�HIEXL��%PXLSYKL�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�QEOIQMWXEOIW�ERH�SZIVVIEGX�PMOI�WSPHMIVW�MR�IZIV]�EVQ]��EX�PIEWX�XLIVI�MW�ER�IXLMGEP�GSHI�EKEMRWX�[LMGL�XLIMV�EGXMSRW�GER�FI�NYHKIH��4EPIWXMRMER�XIV�VSVMWXW�LEZI�RS�WMQMPEV�GSRWXVEMRXW��8LIMV�SVHIVW�EVI�XS�OMPP�ERH�QEMQ�EWQER]�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�EW�TSWWMFPI��ERH�XLI]�HS�WS�[MXL�IEP�ERH�[MXL�ETVSQMWI�SJ�E�LIEZIRP]�FSYRX]�JSV�IZIV]�.I[MWL�GLMPH�ERH�[SQER�[LS�MWQYVHIVIH�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 158: The Case For Israel

8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�EPWS�LEW�E�GSHI��FYX�MX�MW�JEV�QSVI�KIRIVEP�XLER-WVEIP¬W��IQTLEWMMRK�LSRSV�ERH�XVEHMXMSR��%QIVMGER�WSPHMIVW�GEVV]�©6YPIWSJ�)RKEKIQIRXª�GEVHW�XLEX�MRWXVYGX�XLIQ�XS�WTEVI�GMZMPMER�XEVKIXW�YRPIWWXLI]�QYWX�FI�EXXEGOIH�MR�WIPJ�HIJIRWI���%W�[MXL�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW��XLIWI�GSHIWERH�GEVHW�HS�RSX�VIWSPZI�PMJI�ERH�HIEXL�HIGMWMSRW�XLEX�QYWX�FI�QEHI�MR�XLIQMHWX�SJ�GSQFEX��%�HVEQEXMG�ERH�QSZMRK�FEXXPIJMIPH�EGGSYRX�SJ�XLI�-VEU[EV�F]�4IXIV�1EEW�MR�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW1EKEMRISJ�%TVMP����������HIWGVMFIW�E�WMXYEXMSR�JEGIH�F]�%QIVMGER�QEVMRIW�XLEX�[EW�WMQMPEV�XS�XLSWIJVIUYIRXP]�I\TIVMIRGIH�F]�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW��8[S�%QIVMGER�QEVMRIW�LEH�FIIRWLSX�F]�-VEUMW�JMVMRK�JVSQ�QSZMRK�XVYGOW��8LI�%QIVMGER�GSQQERHIVMRWXVYGXIH�LMW�JSVGIW

XS�JMVI�[EVRMRK�WLSXW�WIZIVEP�LYRHVIH�]EVHW�YT�XLI�VSEH�EX�ER]�ETTVSEGL�

MRK�ZILMGPIW��%W�XLI�LEPJ�HSIR�ZILMGPIW�ETTVSEGLIH��WSQI�WLSXW�[IVI

JMVIH�EX�XLI�KVSYRH�MR�JVSRX�SJ�XLI�GEVW��SXLIVW�[IVI�JMVIH��[MXL�KVIEX�TVI�

GMWMSR��EX�XLIMV�XMVIW�SV�XLIMV�IRKMRI�FPSGOW�������

&YX�WSQI�SJ�XLI�ZILMGPIW�[IVIR¬X�JYPP]�HMWEFPIH�F]�XLI�WRMTIVW��ERH

XLI]�GSRXMRYIH�XS�QSZI�JSV[EVH��;LIR�XLEX�LETTIRIH��XLI�QEVMRIW�VMH�

HPIH�XLI�ZILMGPIW�[MXL�FYPPIXW�YRXMP�XLI]�KVSYRH�XS�E�LEPX�������

8LI�ZILMGPIW��MX�SRP]�PEXIV�FIGEQI�GPIEV��[IVI�JYPP�SJ�-VEUM�GMZMPMERW�

8LIWI�-VEUMW�[IVI�ETTEVIRXP]�XV]MRK�XS�IWGETI�XLI�%QIVMGER�FSQFW�XLEX

[IVI�PERHMRK�FILMRH�XLIQ��JEVXLIV�HS[R�XLI�VSEH��ERH�XS�IWGETI�&EKL�

HEH�MXWIPJ��XLI�VSEH�XLI]�[IVI�SR�MW�E�OI]�VSYXI�SYX�SJ�XLI�GMX]��8LI�GMZMP�

MERW�TVSFEFP]�GSYPHR¬X�WII�XLI�QEVMRIW��[LS�[IVI�[IEVMRK�GEQSYJPEKI

JEXMKYIW�ERH�LEH�XEOIR�YT�KVSYRH�ERH�VSSJXST�TSWMXMSRW�XLEX�[IVI

MRXIRHIH�XS�FI�HMJJMGYPX�JSV�ETTVSEGLMRK�JMKLXIVW�XS�WTSX��������-R�XLI�GLESW�

XLI�GMZMPMERW�[IVI�HVMZMRK�XS[EVH�E�FEXXEPMSR�SJ�QEVMRIW�[LS�LEH�NYWX�PSWX

X[S�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�MR�FEXXPI�XLEX�QSVRMRK�ERH�LEH�FIIR�XSPH�XLEX�WYMGMHI

FSQFIVW�[IVI�LIEHMRK�XLIMV�[E]�

3RI�F]�SRI��GMZMPMERW�[IVI�OMPPIH��7IZIVEP�LYRHVIH�]EVHW�JVSQ�XLI�JSV�

[EVH�QEVMRI�TSWMXMSRW��E�FPYI�QMRMZER�[EW�JMVIH�SR��XLVII�TISTPI�[IVI

OMPPIH��%R�SPH�QER��[EPOMRK�[MXL�E�GERI�SR�XLI�WMHI�SJ�XLI�VSEH��[EW�WLSX

ERH�OMPPIH��?3AZIV�E�WXVIXGL�SJ�EFSYX�����]EVHW�RIEVP]�E�LEPJ�HSIR�ZILM�

GPIW�[IVI�WXSTTIH�F]�KYRJMVI��;LIR�XLI�JMVMRK�WXSTTIH��XLIVI�[IVI�RIEVP]

E�HSIR�GSVTWIW��EPP�FYX�X[S�SJ�[LMGL�LEH�RS�ETTEVIRX�QMPMXEV]�GPSXLMRK

SV�[IETSRW�

%�WUYEH�PIEHIV��EJXIV�XLI�WLSSXMRK�WXSTTIH��WLSYXIH��©1]�QIR

WLS[IH�RS�QIVG]��3YXWXERHMRK�ª

-�GSYRXIH�EX�PIEWX�WM\�ZILMGPIW�XLEX�LEH�FIIR�WLSX�EX��1SWX�SJ�XLIQ

GSRXEMRIH�GSVTWIW�SV�LEH�GSVTWIW�RIEV�XLIQ��8LI�FPYI�ZER��E�/ME��LEH

QSVI�XLER����FYPPIX�LSPIW�MR�MXW�[MRHWLMIPH��8[S�FSHMIW�[IVI�WPYQTIH

SZIV�MR�XLI�JVSRX�WIEXW��XLI]�[IVI�QIR�MR�WXVIIX�GPSXLIW�ERH�LEH�RS

[IETSRW�XLEX�-�GSYPH�WII��-R�XLI�FEGO�WIEX��E�[SQER�MR�E�FPEGO�GLEHSV

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 159: The Case For Israel

LEH�JEPPIR�XS�XLI�JPSSV��WLI�[EW�HIEH��XSS��8LIVI�[EW�RS�ZMWMFPI�GEVKS�MR

XLI�ZER RS�WYMXGEWIW��RS�FSQFW�������

%�NSYVREPMWX�GEQI�YT�ERH�WEMH�XLI�GMZMPMERW�WLSYPH�RSX�LEZI�FIIR�

WLSX�������

©,S[�GER�]SY�XIPP�[LS¬W�[LS#ª�WEMH�'SVTSVEP�:IRXYVE��,I�WTSOI

WLEVTP]��EW�XLSYKL�XV]MRK�XS�GSRXEMR�LMW�JYV]��©=SY�KIX�E�WSPHMIV�MR�E�GEV

[MXL�ER�%/����ERH�GMZMPMERW�MR�XLI�RI\X�GEV��,S[�GER�]SY�XIPP#�=SY�

GER¬X�XIPP�ª

,I�TEYWIH��8LIR�LI�GSRXMRYIH��WXMPP�YTWIX�EX�XLI�WYKKIWXMSR�XLEX�XLI

OMPPMRKW�[IVI�RSX�GSVVIGX�

©3RI�SJ�XLIWI�ZERW�XSSO�SYX�SYV�XERO��'EV�FSQF��;LIR�[I�XIPP�XLIQ

XLI]�LEZI�XS�WXST��XLI]�LEZI�XS�WXST�ª�LI�WEMH��VIJIVVMRK�XS�GMZMPMERW�

©;I¬ZI�KSX�XS�FI�GSRGIVRIH�EFSYX�SYV�WEJIX]��;I�HVSTTIH�TEQTLPIXW

SZIV�XLIWI�TISTPI�[IIOW�ERH�[IIOW�EKS�ERH�XSPH�XLIQ�XS�PIEZI�XLI�GMX]�

=SY�GER¬X�FPEQI�QEVMRIW�JSV�[LEX�LETTIRIH��-X¬W�FYPP��;LEX�EVI�]SY

HSMRK�KIXXMRK�MR�E�XE\M�MR�XLI�QMHHPI�SJ�E�[EV�SRI#

©,EPJ�SJ�XLIQ�PSSO�PMOI�GMZMPMERW�ª�LI�GSRXMRYIH��,I�[EW�VIJIVVMRK�XS

MVVIKYPEV�JSVGIW��©-�QIER��-�LEZI�W]QTEXL]��ERH�XLMW�FVIEOW�Q]�LIEVX��FYX

]SY�GER¬X�XIPP�[LS¬W�[LS��;I¬ZI�HSRI�QSVI�XLER�IRSYKL�XS�LIPT�XLIWI

TISTPI��-�HSR¬X�XLMRO�-�LEZI�IZIV�VIEH�EFSYX�E�[EV�MR�[LMGL�MRRSGIRX�TIS�

TPI�HMHR¬X�HMI��-RRSGIRX�TISTPI�HMI��8LIVI¬W�RSXLMRK�[I�GER�HS�������ª

?8ALI�HIWXVS]IH�GEVW�[IVI�WIZIVEP�LYRHVIH�]EVHW�JVSQ�XLI�QEVMRI

TSWMXMSRW�XLEX�JMVIH�SR�XLIQ��8LI�QEVMRIW�GSYPH�LEZI�[EMXIH�E�FMX�PSRKIV

FIJSVI�JMVMRK��ERH�MJ�XLI]�LEH��TIVLETW�XLI�GEVW�[SYPH�LEZI�WXSTTIH��SV

TIVLETW�XLI�QEVMRIW�[SYPH�LEZI�JMKYVIH�SYX�XLEX�XLI�GEVW�GSRXEMRIH�GSR�

JYWIH�GMZMPMERW��8LI�WRMTIV�ORI[�XLMW��,I�ORI[�XLEX�WSQIXLMRK�XVEKMG�LEH

LETTIRIH�EX�XLI�FVMHKI��%RH�WS��EW�[I�WTSOI�MR�&EKLHEH��LI�WXSTTIH

HIJIRHMRK�XLI�QEVMRIW¬�EGXMSRW�ERH�WXEVXIH�XEPOMRK�EFSYX�XLIMV�MRXIRX��,I

ERH�LMW�JIPPS[�QEVMRIW��LI�WEMH��LEH�RSX�GSQI�XS�-VEU�XS�HVMPP�FYPPIXW�MRXS

[SQIR�ERH�SPH�QIR�[LS�[IVI�NYWX�XV]MRK�XS�JMRH�E�WEJI�TPEGI�������

8LI�GMZMPMERW�[LS�[IVI�OMPPIH E�TVIGMWI�RYQFIV�MW�RSX�ERH�TVSFEFP]

RIZIV�[MPP�FI�EZEMPEFPI�JSV�XLI�XSPP�EX�(M]EPE�FVMHKI��SV�MR�XLI�VIWX�SJ�-VEU

TEMH�XLI�YPXMQEXI�TVMGI��&YX�E�TVMGI�[EW�TEMH��XSS��F]�XLI�QIR�[LS�[IVI

VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�OMPPMRK�XLIQ��*SV�XLIWI�QIR��XLMW�[EW�RSX�E�GPIER�[EV�SJ

WQEVX�FSQFW�ERH�WYVKMGEP�WXVMOIW��-X�[EW�[EV�EW�MX�LEW�EP[E]W�FIIR��[EV�EX

GPSWI�VERKI��[EV�EW�7LIVQER�HIWGVMFIH�MX��FPSSH]�ERH�GVYIP�

%PXLSYKL�QER]�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�[IVI�XVEKMGEPP]�OMPPIH�MR�XLMW�WMRKPI�HE]�FEXXPI TVSFEFP]�QSVI�XLER�MR�XLI�[IIO�PSRK�LSYWI�XS�LSYWI�[EVJEVIMR�.IRMR RS�SRI�GEPPIH�MX�E�QEWWEGVI��-X�[EW�ER�MRGVIEWMRKP]�X]TMGEP�FEXXPIFIX[IIR�E�VIKYPEV�EVQ]�ERH�XIVVSVMWXW�[LS�LMHI�EQSRK�GMZMPMERW��-WVEIP��PMOI%QIVMGE��MW�XV]MRK�XS�JMKLX�XLIWI�FEXXPIW�F]�WXVMOMRK�ER�ETTVSTVMEXI�FEPERGIFIX[IIR�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�ERH�YRHYI�VMWO�XS�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 160: The Case For Israel

-R�EHHMXMSR�XS�XLI�'SHI�SJ�)XLMGW�F]�[LMGL�EPP�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�EVIXVEMRIH��XLI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ�-WVEIPYRMUYI�EQSRK�XLI�[SVPH¬W�NYHMGM�EVMIW I\IVGMWIW�GSRXVSP�SZIV�QMPMXEV]�HIGMWMSRW�XLEX�EVI�GLEPPIRKIH�YRHIVXLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�EW�GVIEXMRK�YRHYI�VMWOW�XS�GMZMPMERW��'SRWMHIV��JSV�I\EQTPI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�GLSMGI�SJ�IZMPW�GSRYRHVYQ�JEGIH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]�[LIRMX�MW�WIIOMRK�XS�ETTVILIRH�ER�EVQIH�XIVVSVMWX�[LS�MW�LSPIH�YT�MR�E�LSQI�-J�XLI�WSPHMIVW�ETTVSEGL�XLI�LSQI�ERH�ORSGO�HS[R�XLI�HSSV��XLI]�VMWOFIMRK�WLSX�F]�XLI�XIVVSVMWX��EW�QER]�WSPHMIVW�LEZI�FIIR��7S�XLI�EVQ]HIZMWIH�E�XEGXMG�GEPPIH�XLI�RIMKLFSV�TVSGIHYVI��TYVWYERX�XS�[LMGL�XLI]�JMVWXHIQERHIH�XLI�WYVVIRHIV�SJ�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�SZIV�E�PSYHWTIEOIV��-J�XLEX�TVS�HYGIH�RS�VIWYPXW��XLI]�WIRX�E�4EPIWXMRMER�RIMKLFSV�XS�XLI�LSYWI�FIEVMRK�EQIWWEKI�XS�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�EWOMRK�LMQ�XS�WYVVIRHIV�%GGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�-(*�XLMW�RIMKLFSV�TVSGIHYVI�[SVOIH�IJJIGXMZIP]�JSV

QSVI�XLER�X[IRX]�]IEVW��WEZMRK�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�QER]�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW��EW�[IPP�EWSJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�[IVI�FIMRK�LIPH�MR�XLI�LSYWI�[MXL�XLI�XIVVSVMWX��-R�XLIWYQQIV�SJ�������XLI�TVSGIHYVI�VIWYPXIH�MR�XLI�JMVWX�GEWYEPX]�SJ�E�4EPIWXMR�MER�QER�REQIH�2MHEP�%FY�1¬/LMWER��[LS�[EW�WLSX�ERH�OMPPIH�F]�E�XIV�VSVMWX�[LS�QMWXSSO�LMQ�JSV�ER�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIV��8LI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�LEH�KMZIR1¬/LMWER�E�FYPPIXTVSSJ�ZIWX��FYX�MX�HMH�RSX�WEZI�LMQ�%W�E�VIWYPX�SJ�XLMW�XVEKIH]��MR�[LMGL�E�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMER�XSSO�E�XIVVSV�

MWX�FYPPIX�MRXIRHIH�JSV�ER�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIV��WIZIVEP�-WVEIPM�VMKLXW�SVKERMEXMSRWFVSYKLX�E�PE[WYMX�WIIOMRK�XS�LEZI�XLI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�IRNSMR�ER]�JYVXLIVYWI�SJ�XLI�RIMKLFSV�TVSGIHYVI��2S�SXLIV�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�MR�XLI�[SVPH[SYPH�IZIR�LIEV�WYGL�E�GEWI��IWTIGMEPP]�RSX�HYVMRK�ER�SRKSMRK�[EV��8LI7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ�-WVEIP�RSX�SRP]�LIEVH�XLI�GEWI�FYX�MWWYIH�XLI�MRNYRGXMSRTVSLMFMXMRK�XLI�-(*�JVSQ�YWMRK�XLMW�TVSGIHYVI�MR�XLI�JYXYVI��IZIR�[LIRXLI�JMIPH�GSQQERHIV�FIPMIZIW�XLEX�MX�TSWIW�PMXXPI�VMWO�XS�XLI�GMZMPMER�ERHGSYPH�WEZI�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�LMW�WSPHMIVW�8LI�TSMRX�MW�RSX�[LIXLIV�XLMW�HIGMWMSR�MW�VMKLX�SV�[VSRK -�TIVWSREPP]

FIPMIZI�MX�MW�VMKLX FYX�VEXLIV�XLEX�XLI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�SVHIVMRKXLI�QMPMXEV]�XS�QEOI�MXW�XMQI�XIWXIH�TVSGIHYVIW�GSQTP]�[MXL�XLI�VYPI�SJPE[��IZIR�MJ�XLEX�QIERW�VMWOMRK�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�MXW�S[R�WSPHMIVW��*VSQ�ER�SFNIG�XMZI�ZMI[�SJ�XLI�JEGXW�MR�GSRXI\X��MX�FIGSQIW�IQMRIRXP]�GPIEV�XLEX�RS�GSYR�XV]�MR�XLI�QSHIVR�LMWXSV]�SJ�[EVJEVI�LEW�FIIR�QSVI�TVSXIGXMZI�SJ�XLIVMKLXW�SJ�MRRSGIRX�RSRGSQFEXERX�IRIQMIW�XLER�-WVEIP��-�GLEPPIRKI�ER]SRIXS�REQI�E�GSYRXV]�XLEX�LEW�JEGIH�GSQTEVEFPI�EXXEGOW�SR�MXW�GMZMPMER�TSTY�PEXMSR�ERH�LEW�VIWTSRHIH�[MXL�QSVI�WSPMGMXYHI�XS[EVH�MXW�IRIQ]�GMZMPMERWEX�WYGL�KVIEX�VMWO�XS�MXW�S[R�WSPHMIVW��'IVXEMRP]�RSX�+VIEX�&VMXEMR�SV�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW��[LMGL�FSQFIH�IRIQ]�GMXMIW��SV�*VERGI��SV�6YWWME��[LMGLHMH�[SVWI�-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�QSHIVR�[EVJEVI�XLEX�LEW

RIZIV�HVSTTIH�FSQFW�MRHMWGVMQMREXIP]�SR�ER�IRIQ]�GMX]�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�OMPPMRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�MR�VIXEPMEXMSR�JSV�XLI�HIPMFIVEXI�FSQFMRK�SJ�MXW�S[R�GMZMP�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 161: The Case For Israel

MERW��)ZIR�[LIR�MX�EXXEGOIH�XLSWI�TEVXW�SJ�&IMVYX�XLEX�[IVI�LSQI�XS�XIV�VSVMWXW��XLI�-WVEIPM�EMV�JSVGI�QEHI�KVIEX�IJJSVXW EPXLSYKL�RSX�EP[E]W�[MXLWYGGIWW XS�EZSMH�YRRIGIWWEV]�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�6IGEPP�XLEX�[LIR�-WVEIP�WSYKLX�XS�TVSXIGX�MXWIPJ�EKEMRWX�&IMVYX�FEWIH

XIVVSVMWQ�MR�������MX�WIRX�MR�E�XIEQ�SJ�WSPHMIVW PIH�F]�XLIR�1ENSV�+IRIVEP)LYH�&EVEO��HVIWWIH�EW�E�[SQER XS�XEVKIX�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW�XLIQWIPZIW�MR�EFYMPHMRK�XLIR�FIMRK�YWIH�EW�XLIMV�FEWI��MRWXIEH�SJ�FSQFMRK�XLI�FYMPHMRKJVSQ�XLI�EMV��[LMGL�[SYPH�LEZI�VIWYPXIH�MR�QER]�QSVI�GEWYEPXMIW��8LMW�MWX]TMGEP�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�©VIXEMP�ª�VEXLIV�XLER�©[LSPIWEPI�ª�ETTVSEGL�XS�XEVKIX�MRK�XIVVSVMWQ��3RI�GER�FI�GVMXMGEP�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�EMV�EXXEGOW�SR�&IMVYX EW�-[EW�ERH�EW�QER]�-WVEIPMW�[IVI FYX�XS�GLEVEGXIVMI�-WVEIP¬W�WIPJ�HIJIRWIEGXMSRW��IZIR�SZIVVIEGXMSRW �EW�KIRSGMHI�ERH�XS�GSQTEVI�XLIQ�XS�2EMEXVSGMXMIW�MW�XS�IRKEKI�MR�E�RSX�WS�WYFXPI�JSVQ�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR��-X�MW�MRXIVIWXMRK�ERH�WMKRMJMGERX�XLEX-WVEIP¬W�IRIQMIW�RIZIV�GSQTEVI�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�XS�1YWWSPMRM¬W�-XEP]��SV7XEPMR¬W�7SZMIX�9RMSR��SV�,MVSLMXS¬W�.ETER SRP]�XS�,MXPIV¬W�2EM�+IV�QER]��8LI�GSQTEVMWSR�MW�SFWGIRI�ERH�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MR�MRXIRX�EW�[IPP�EW�MRIJJIGX�-R�JEGX�-WVEIP�WLSYPH�FI�GSQTEVIH�[MXL�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��MR�XLEX�FSXL

GSYRXVMIW�QEOI�WMKRMJMGERX�IJJSVXW�XS�XVEMR�XLIMV�XVSSTW�XS�EZSMH�GMZMPMERGEWYEPXMIW�ERH�HS�RSX�EP[E]W�WYGGIIH��-R�LIV�FSSO.YWX�;EV�EKEMRWX�8IVVSV�9RMZIVWMX]�SJ�'LMGEKS�TLMPSWSTLIV�.IER�&IXLOI�)PWLXEMR�WLEVTP]�GSRXVEWXWXLI�XVEMRMRK�JMPQW�WLS[R�XS�9�7��WSPHMIVW��WMQMPEV�SRIW�EVI�WLS[R�XS�-WVEIPMWSPHMIVW �[MXL�E�XVEMRMRK�JMPQ�FIMRK�[MHIP]�YWIH�XS�VIGVYMX�-WPEQMG�XIVVSVMWXW�

9�7��QMPMXEV]�XVEMRMRK�JMPQW�MRGPYHI�KIRIVSYW�LIPTMRKW�SJ�©[LEX�[IRX

[VSRKª�MR�ZEVMSYW�STIVEXMSRW��©;VSRKª�VIJIVW�RSX�SRP]�XS�9�7��QMPMXEV]

PSWWIW�FYX�EPWS�XS�STIVEXMSRW�XLEX�PIH�XS�XLI�YRMRXIRXMSREP�PSWW�SJ�GMZMPMER

PMJI��8LIWI�JMPQW�EWO��,S[�GER�WYGL�PSWWIW�FI�TVIZIRXIH�MR�XLI�JYXYVI�MR�E

XLIEXVI�SJ�[EV#�2S�SRI�MW�IRGSYVEKIH��SV�IZIR�EPPS[IH��XS�GEPP�XLI�OMPPMRK

SJ�GMZMPMERW�©+SH¬W�[MPPª�SV��IZIR�[SVWI��ER�EGX�GEVVMIH�SYX�MR�+SH¬W�REQI�

8LI�?-WPEQMG�XIVVSVMWXA�ZMHIS�?[LMGL�MW�©VSYXMRI�JEVIª�MR�QER]�VEHMGEP

QSWUYIW��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�SRI�EXXIRHIH�F]�>EGEVMEW�1SYWWESYM�ERH�6MGLEVH

6IIHA�WLS[W�IRIQMIW�FIMRK�HIGETMXEXIH�[MXL�ORMZIW�EJXIV�XLI]�EVI�HMW�

EVQIH WSQIXLMRK�WXVMGXP]�JSVFMHHIR�F]�XLI�PE[W�SJ�[EV��8LI�JMPQ¬W�REV�

VEXSV�MRXSRIW��©=SY�LEZI�XS�OMPP�MR�XLI�REQI�SJ�%PPEL�YRXMP�]SY�EVI�OMPPIH�

8LIR�]SY�[MPP�[MR�]SYV�TPEGI�JSVIZIV�MR�4EVEHMWI��8LI�[LSPI�-WPEQMG

[SVPH�WLSYPH�VMWI�YT�XS�JMKLX�EPP�XLI�WMGO�YRFIPMIZIVW��8LI�JPEK�SJ�.MLEH

[MPP�FI�JSVIZIV�LIPH�LMKL��3YV�IRIQMIW�EVI�JMKLXMRK�MR�XLI�REQI�SJ�7EXER�

=SY�EVI�JMKLXMRK�MR�XLI�REQI�SJ�+SH�ª

8LI�ZMI[IV�MW�WYFNIGX�XS�©I\GMXIH�WLSYXMRK�EW�XLI�QMPMXERXW�RSXMGI�XLEX

SRI�WSPHMIV�MW�WXMPP�EPMZI��«,I�MW�QSZMRK�¬�GEPPW�SYX�E�JMKLXIV��%�QMPMXERX

GEPQP]�FIRHW�HS[R�ERH�VYRW�E�ORMJI�EGVSWW�XLI�[SYRHIH�GSRWGVMTX¬W

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 162: The Case For Israel

XLVSEX��8LI�MQEKI�SJ�XLI�FPSSH�TYQTMRK�JVSQ�LMW�WIZIVIH�GEVSXMH�EVXIV]

MW�WLS[R�JMZI�XMQIW�HYVMRK�XLI�ZMHIS�ª��

7MRGI�7ITXIQFIV�����ERH�IWTIGMEPP]�HYVMRK�XLI�[EV�EKEMRWX�-VEU��XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW�KSZIVRQIRX�LEW�GSQQMXXIH�ZMVXYEPP]�EPP�SJ�XLI�[VSRKW�JSV[LMGL�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�GSRHIQRIH��-RHIIH��QER]�SJ�XLI�[VSRKW�GSQQMXXIHF]�-WVEIPERH�XLIR�VITPMGEXIH�F]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW [IVI�GSRHIQRIH�F]XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�MXWIPJ�MR�MXW�ERRYEP�7XEXI�(ITEVXQIRX�VITSVXW�SR�LYQERVMKLXW��*SV�I\EQTPI��9�7��WSPHMIVW�WLSX�MRXS�E�GVS[H�SJ�HIQSRWXVEXMRK-VEUMW��OMPPMRK�QSVI�XLER�E�HSIR��MRGPYHMRK�X[S�GLMPHVIR�YRHIV�XLI�EKI�SJ�����3YV�XVSSTW�GPEMQIH��EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�XVSSTW�LEZI�GPEMQIH�MR�WMQMPEV�WMX�YEXMSRW��XLEX�XLI]�[IVI�JMVIH�YTSR�JMVWX�F]�TISTPI�MR�XLI�GVS[H��8LI�%QIV�MGER�KSZIVRQIRX�EPWS�TSMRXIH�SYX��EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�LEW�WMQMPEVP]TSMRXIH�SYX��XLEX�GSQFEX�XVSSTW�EVI�RSX�XVEMRIH�XS�TIVJSVQ�VMSX�GSRXVSPERH�[MPP�SGGEWMSREPP]�SZIVVIEGX�XS�TVSZSGEXMSRW�JVSQ�ER�YRHMJJIVIRXMEXIHGVS[H�SJ�TVSXIWXIVW��VSGO�XLVS[IVW��FSQF�XLVS[IVW��ERH�WLSSXIVW��%QIVM�GER�WSPHMIVW�LEZI�EPWS�FIIR�EGGYWIH�SJ�WLSSXMRK�JMVWX�ERH�EWOMRK�UYIWXMSRWPEXIV�[LIR�XLIMV�GLIGOTSMRXW�EVI�ETTVSEGLIH�F]�YRMHIRXMJMIH�ZILMGPIW�XLEXJEMP�XS�GSQTP]�[MXL�ER�SVHIV�XS�WXST��8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�TSMRXW�XS�WMXYEXMSRWMR�[LMGL�MRHMZMHYEPW�ERH�ZILMGPIW�ETTVSEGLMRK�E�GLIGOTSMRX�LEZI�GEYWIH�XLIHIEXLW�SJ�9�7��WSPHMIVW��%JXIV�ER�ETTEVIRXP]�TVIKRERX�[SQER�FPI[�LIVWIPJYT��OMPPMRK�ERH�MRNYVMRK�%QIVMGERW��SYV�WSPHMIVW�VIWTSRHIH�QSVI�EKKVIW�WMZIP]�XS�WMQMPEV�ETTVSEGLIW��9RMXIH�7XEXIW�EYXLSVMXMIW�LEZI�IRKEKIH�MREHQMRMWXVEXMZI�HIXIRXMSR�SJ�LYRHVIHW�SJ�WYWTIGXIH�XIVVSVMWXW��-WPEQMG�QMPM�XERXW��ERH�SXLIVW�JSV�PSRK�TIVMSHW�SJ�XMQI��%QIVMGER�EYXLSVMXMIW�LEZIIQTPS]IH�TVIWWYVI�XEGXMGW��FSVHIVMRK�SR�RSRPIXLEP�XSVXYVI��MR�ER�IJJSVX�XSIPMGMX�MRJSVQEXMSR�HIIQIH�RIGIWWEV]�XS�TVIZIRX�JYXYVI�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ��&]QEOMRK�XLIWI�GSQTEVMWSRW��-�HS�RSX�QIER�XS�WMRKPI�SYX�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIWJSV�GVMXMGMWQ��EW�WS�QER]�LEZI�HSRI�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�-WVEIP��-RHIIH��FSXL�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�-WVEIP�LEZI�GSRHYGXIH�XLIQWIPZIW�JEV�FIXXIV�XLER�SXLIVGSYRXVMIW�GSRJVSRXMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�ERH�YVFER�[EVJEVI��'SQTEVMWSRW�[MXL�XLI6YWWMERW�MR�'LIGLR]E�ERH�XLI�*VIRGL�MR�%PKIVME�JEZSV�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIWERH�-WVEIP��2SV�HS�-�QIER�XS�WYKKIWX�XLEX�X[S�[VSRKW�QEOI�E�VMKLX��&SXLXLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�-WVEIP�EVI�NYWXP]�GVMXMGMIH�[LIR�XLI]�HS�[VSRK��EW�EVIEPP�SXLIV�REXMSRW��1]�TSMRX�KSIW�FEGO�XS�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]¬W[MPPMRKRIWW MRHIIH��IEKIVRIWW XS�TSVXVE]�-WVEIP�EW�E�YRMUYI�SV�©TVMQIªZMSPEXSV�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW��[LIR�ER]�SFNIGXMZI�GSQTEVEXMZI�EWWIWWQIRX�[MPPTVSZI�XLEX�EPXLSYKL�-WVEIP�LEW�QEHI�QMWXEOIW�ERH�SZIVVIEGXIH��MXW�SZIVEPPVIGSVH�MW�EQSRK�XLI�FIWX�MR�XLI�[SVPH��TIVLETW�XLIFIWX�MR�XLI�[SVPH�[LIRXLI�GMVGYQWXERGIW�XLI]�JEGI�EVI�XEOIR�MRXS�EGGSYRX�4VSJIWWSV�*VERGMW�&S]PI��XLI�%QIVMGER�PE[�TVSJIWWSV�[LS�LEW�FIGSQI�E

WTSOIWTIVWSR�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW��MW�VMKLX�EFSYX�SRI�XLMRK��SRIWMHI�LEW�EXXIQTXIH�KIRSGMHI�HYVMRK�XLI�%VEF§4EPIWXMRMER§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 163: The Case For Israel

8LI�WIPJ�TVSGPEMQIH�%VEF�;EV�SJ�)\XIVQMREXMSR�MR�������XLI�XEVKIXMRK�SJ-WVEIPM�GMXMIW�F]�%VEF�EVQMIW�HYVMRK�XLI�������������ERH������[EVW��ERHXLI�GSRXMRYSYW�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�XLEX�LEZI�OMPPIH�XLSYWERHW�SJ�-WVEIPM��.I[�MWL��ERH�SXLIV�GMZMPMERW�GER�FI�GLEVEGXIVMIH�EW�EXXIQTXIH�KIRSGMHI�-WVEIP¬W�IJJSVXW�XS�TVSXIGX�MXW�GMXMIRW�JVSQ�XLIWI�QEWW�QYVHIVW�F]�EXXEGOMRK%VEF�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW�GER�SRP]�FI�PEFIPIH�EW�KIRSGMHI�F]�E�FMKSX�[MPPMRK�XSIRKEKI�MR�3V[IPPMER�XYVRWTIEO�EKEMRWX�E�TISTPI�XLEX�[EW�XVYP]�ZMGXMQMIHF]�XLI�[SVWX�JSVQ�SJ�KIRSGMHI�4IVLETW�RSXLMRK�QSVI�GER�FI�I\TIGXIH�SJ�4VSJIWWSV�&S]PI��[LS�LEW

PSRK�FIIR�E�SRI�WMHIH�TVSTEKERHMWX�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ��FYX�QSVI�MWGIVXEMRP]�I\TIGXIH�SJ�E�2SFIP�4VMI§[MRRMRK�EYXLSV�WYGL�EW�.SWI�7EVEQEKS�[LS�VIGIRXP]�GLEVEGXIVMIH�-WVEIPM�IJJSVXW�XS�HIJIRH�MXW�GMXMIRW�EKEMRWX�XIV�VSVMWQ�EW�©E�GVMQI�GSQTEVEFPI�XS�%YWGL[MX�ª�;LIR�7EVEQEKS�[EWTVIWWIH�EFSYX�©[LIVI�������XLI�KEW�GLEQFIVWª�EVI��LI�VIWTSRHIH��©2SX�LIVI]IX�ª��8LMW�VIZSPXMRK�GSQQIRX�MW�RSXLMRK�WLSVX�SJ�SFWGIRI��ERH�GER�SRP]FI�I\TPEMRIH�F]�EF]WQEP�MKRSVERGI�SV�E�HIIT�WIEXIH�ERH�MVVEXMSREP�LEXVIHJSV�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��&YX�MKRSVERGI�EPSRI�GERRSX�I\TPEMR�XLI�EPPIKIH©VITSVXMRKª�SJ�E�©NSYVREPMWXª�PMOI�'LVMW�,IHKIW��[LS�GPEMQIH�XS�LEZI�TIV�WSREPP]�SFWIVZIH�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW�©IRXMGI�GLMPHVIR�PMOI�QMGI�MRXS�E�XVET�ERHQYVHIV�XLIQ�JSV�WTSVX�ª��8LMW�WSVX�SJ�VITSVXMRK�FIPSRKW�EPSRKWMHI�XLIVITSVX�XLEX�ETTIEVIH�MR�XLI�7EYHM�RI[WTETIV�%P�6M]EHLSR�1EVGL����������HIWGVMFMRK�XLI�©[IPP�IWXEFPMWLIH�JEGXª�XLEX�XLI�.I[W�YWI�©XLI�FPSSHSJ�'LVMWXMER�ERH�1YWPMQ�GLMPHVIR�YRHIV�XLI�EKI�SJ���ª�XS�©TVITEVI�TEW�XVMIW�JSV�XLIMV�LSPMHE]W�ª��

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 164: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�JEGX�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�[MXL�E�PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�XLEX�IRXMXPIW�.I[WERH�XLIMV�JEQMPMIW�XS�FIGSQI�-WVEIPM�GMXMIRW�SRP]�TVSZIW�XLEX�MX�MW�E�VEGMWXWXEXI�

8,)�%''97)67

©-WVEIP��QSVISZIV��MW�XLI�SRP]�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�[SVPH�XSHE]�XLEX�LEWEHSTXIH��EW�E�QEXXIV�SJ�SJJMGMEP�TSPMG]��XLI�TYVWYMX�SJ�E�GIVXEMR�VEGMEPQEOIYT�SJ�MXW�GMXMIRV]��M�I���QEMRXEMRMRK�E�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��8LMW�TSPMG]��EWMW�[IPP�ORS[R�SYXWMHI�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��MW�SJ�GSYVWI�MR�HMVIGX�ZMSPEXMSRSJ�8LI�-RXIVREXMSREP�'SRZIRXMSR�SR�)PMQMREXMSR�SJ�%PP�*SVQW�SJ�6EGMEP(MWGVMQMREXMSR��[LMGL�I\TPMGMXP]�TVSLMFMXW�«ER]�HMWXMRGXMSR��I\GPYWMSR�VIWXVMGXMSR�SV�TVIJIVIRGI�FEWIH�SR�VEGI��GSPSV��HIWGIRX��SV�REXMSREP�SV�IXL�RMG�SVMKMR�¬ª��%LQIH�&SYMH��TVIWMHIRX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�1IHME�;EXGL�

©-WVEIP¬W�0E[�SJ�6IXYVR�MW�ERSXLIV�VEGMWX�PE[��&]�MX�XLI�WXEXI�QYWXEGGSQQSHEXI�ER]�.I[W�JVSQ�ER][LIVI�MR�XLI�[SVPH�XLEX�QMKLX��EX�ER]XMQI��QMKVEXI�XS�-WVEIP��-J�JSYV�QMPPMSR�.I[W�WYHHIRP]�IQMKVEXI�XS-WVEIP�4EPIWXMRI��XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�[MPP�EGGSQQSHEXI�XLIQ��-R�GSR�XVEWX��JSYV�QMPPMSR�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLEX�[IVI�HMWTSWWIWWIH�SJ�XLIMV�PERH�ERHJSVGIH�MRXS�I\MPI�[LIR�-WVEIP�[EW�JSVQIH�LEZI�RS�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�FIGEYWIMR�)LYH�&EVEO¬W�[SVHW MX�[SYPH�FI�«REXMSREP�WYMGMHI�¬ª��2E¬IIQ�.IIREL�-WPEQMG�%WWSGMEXMSR�JSV�4EPIWXMRI�

���

-W�-WVEIP�E�6EGMWX�7XEXI#��

Page 165: The Case For Israel

©3J�EPP�XLI�HMWGVMQMREXSV]�PE[W�ERH�TVEGXMGIW�SJ�>MSRMWQ��RSRI�GERQEXGL�XLI�-WVEIPM�0E[�SJ�6IXYVR�JSV�MXW�MRIUYMX]��8LMW�PE[�[LMGL�[EWIREGXIH�SR��XL�.YP]������EJJSVHW�XS�IZIV]�QIQFIV�SJ�XLI�«.I[MWL�TISTPI¬FSVR�ER][LIVI�MR�XLI�[SVPH�XLI�VMKLX�XS�MQQMKVEXI�XS�-WVEIP�ERH�FIGSQIE�GMXMIR�YTSR�EVVMZEP��%X�XLI�WEQI�XMQI��MX�HIRMIW�XLMW�VMKLX�XS�4EPIWXMRMER1YWPMQW�ERH�'LVMWXMERW�[LS�[IVI�FSVR�MR�4EPIWXMRI�ERH�I\TIPPIH�HYVMRKXLI�WYGGIWWMZI�[EVW�SJ�SGGYTEXMSR�ª��(V��(EYH�%FHYPPEL��4EPIWXMRMER6IXYVR�'IRXVI�

8,)�6)%0-8=

)ZIV]�SXLIV�WXEXI�MR�XLI�EVIE��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��LEW�ERSJJMGMEPP]�IWXEFPMWLIH�VIPMKMSR��-WPEQ��ERH�HMWGVMQMREXIW�FSXL�MR�PE[�ERH�MRJEGX�EKEMRWX�RSR�1YWPMQW��IWTIGMEPP]�.I[W��-WVEIP��MR�GSRXVEWX��MW�MR�TVEGXMGI�EWIGYPEV�WXEXI�XLEX�MW�VIPMKMSYWP]�ERH�VEGMEPP]�TPYVEPMWXMG�[MXL�JVIIHSQ�SJ�VIPM�KMSR�JSV�EPP��1SVISZIV��WIZIVEP�SXLIV�WXEXIW�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]LEZI�PE[W�SJ�VIXYVR��ERH�.SVHER�LEW�E�PE[�I\TPMGMXP]�TVSLMFMXMRK�.I[W�JVSQFIGSQMRK�GMXMIRW��FYX�SRP]�-WVEIP[LSWI�PE[�KVI[�SYX�SJ�E�LMWXSV]�SJ�.I[WFIMRK�WPEYKLXIVIH�FIGEYWI�RS�SXLIV�WXEXI��SV�4EPIWXMRI�YRHIV�XLI�&VMXMWLQERHEXI��[SYPH�EGGITX�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW MW�GSRHIQRIH�JSV�MXW�PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�

8,)�4633*

%PXLSYKL�-WVEIP�MW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��MX�MW�PEVKIP]�WIGYPEV�ERH�EGGSVHW�GSQTPIXIJVIIHSQ�SJ�VIPMKMSR�XS�1YWPMQW��'LVMWXMERW��ERH�SXLIV�VIPMKMSYW�KVSYTW�8LI�SRP]�VIPMKMSYW�KVSYTW�XLEX�EVI�MR�ER]�[E]�HMWGVMQMREXIH�EKEMRWX�MR-WVEIP�EVI�.I[MWL�KVSYTW�XLEX�HS�RSX�GSRJSVQ�XS�XLI�WXVMGXYVIW�SJ�3VXLSHS\.YHEMWQ��'SRWIVZEXMZI�.I[W��6IJSVQ�.I[W��ERH�WIGYPEV�.I[W�EVI�PIWW�XLERIUYEP�[LIR�MX�GSQIW�XS�MWWYIW�WYGL�EW�QEVVMEKI��GSRZIVWMSR��ERH�KSZIVR�QIRXEPP]�WYTTSVXIH�IHYGEXMSR��4YX�ERSXLIV�[E]��XLIVI�MW�JVIIHSQ�SJVIPM�KMSR�JSV�EPP�MR�-WVEIP��FYX�XLIVI�MW�PIWW�XLER�GSQTPIXI�JVIIHSQ�JVSQVIPMKMSRJSV�RSR�3VXLSHS\�.I[W��-�LEZI�FIIR�PSRK�GVMXMGEP�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVR�QIRX¬W�TSPMG]�XS[EVH�'SRWIVZEXMZI��6IJSVQ��ERH�WIGYPEV�.I[W��EPXLSYKL�-YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�MXW�WSYVGIW�PMI�MR�XLI�UYM\SXMG�REXYVI�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�TSPMXMGEPW]WXIQ��[LMGL�KMZIW�XLI�3VXLSHS\�HMWTVSTSVXMSREXI�TS[IV�FIGEYWI�SJ�XLIRIIH�XS�MRGPYHI�XLIQ�MR�GSEPMXMSRW�SJ�FSXL�XLI�VMKLX�ERH�XLI�PIJX��&YX�IZIR[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�RSR�3VXLSHS\�.I[W��WMKRMJMGERX�TVSKVIWW�LEW�FIIR�QEHI�MRVIGSKRMMRK�XLIMV�VMKLXW�FSXL�XS�TVEGXMGI�E�JSVQ�SJ�.YHEMWQ�HMJJIVIRX�JVSQ3VXLSHS\]�ERH�XS�TVEGXMGI�RS�VIPMKMSR�EX�EPP�(IWTMXI�XLI�MQTIVJIGXMSRW�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX¬W�ETTVSEGL�XS�VIPM�

KMSR��MX�MW�JEV�QSVI�EGGITXMRK�SJ�VIPMKMSYW�TPYVEPMWQ�XLER�ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX��ER]�1YWPMQ�WXEXI�MR�XLI�[SVPH��ERH�QSWX�'LVMWXMER

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 166: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

WXEXIW�XLVSYKLSYX�LMWXSV]��IZIR�XSHE]��8S�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�GVMXMGMWQFIGEYWI�MX�MW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MW�GPIEVP]�E�JSVQ�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�IWTIGMEPP]�[LIR�XLI�GVMXMGMWQ�MW�RSX�GSYTPIH�[MXL�GSQTEVEFPI��SV�QSVIWIZIVI��GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�1YWPMQ�WXEXIW�XLEX�TVEGXMGI�E�JEV�QSVI�HMWGVMQMREXSV]JSVQ�SJ�WXEXI�WTSRWSVIH�VIPMKMSR��)ZIR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��[LMGLLEW�PSRK�EHZSGEXIH�E�WIGYPEV�FMREXMSREP�WXEXI�MR�-WVEIP��GPIEVP]�EW�E�TPS] �ERHLEW�FIIR�I\XVIQIP]�GVMXMGEP�SJ�-WVEIP�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��VIGIRXP]�HIGPEVIH-WPEQ�XS�FI�MXW�SJJMGMEP�ERH�WSPI�WXEXI�VIPMKMSR��-�LEZI�LIEVH�RS�GVMXMGMWQ�SJXLMW�QSZI�F]�XLSWI�[LS�EVI�WS�UYMGO�XS�GSRHIQR�-WVEIP�JSV�ER]�HIZMEXMSRJVSQ�ER�YRVIEPMWXMG�TIVJIGXMSR�XLEX�RS�GSYRXV]�LEW�IZIV�EGLMIZIH�;MXL�VIKEVH�XS�-WVEIP¬W�PE[�SJ�VIXYVR��XLIVI�LEW�FIIR�GSRXMRYMRK�GSR�

XVSZIVW]�EFSYX�[LIXLIV�MX�MW�TVMQEVMP]�E�VIPMKMSYW�PE[��E�JEQMP]�VIYRMJMGEXMSRPE[��E�VIEGXMSR�XS�IXLRMG�HMWGVMQMREXMSR��SV�WSQI�GSQFMREXMSR�SJ�XLIWI�LMW�XSVMGEP�JEGXSVW��1SVI�XLER�ER]�SJ�XLIWI��MX�WLSYPH�FI�ZMI[IH�EW�E�LYQERM�XEVMER�PE[��-X�JSPPS[IH�XLI�MQQMKVEXMSR�[EZIW�HYVMRK�-WVEIP¬W�JMVWX�]IEVW�XLEXFVSYKLX�,SPSGEYWX�WYVZMZSVW�EPSRK�[MXL�VIJYKIIW�JSVGIH�SYX�SJ�%VEF�GSYR�XVMIW��7MRGI�MXW�TEWWEKI��.I[W�LEZI�FIIR�VIWGYIH�JVSQ�XLI�VITVIWWMSR�ERHERXM�7IQMXMWQ�SJ�XLI�'SQQYRMWX�FPSG��JVSQ�©HMWETTIEVERGIWª�YRHIV%VKIRXMRI�HMGXEXSVW��ERH�JVSQ�JEQMRI�MR�)XLMSTME�7SQI�GVMXMGW�SJ�XLI�PE[�GLEVEGXIVMI�MX�EW�©VEGMWX�ª�%WMHI�JVSQ�XLI�SFZM�

SYW�JEPWILSSH�SJ�XLMW�GPEMQ [LMGL�-�[MPP�HMWGYWW�MR�E�QSQIRX XLIWI�GVMX�MGW�EVI�KYMPX]�SJ�XLIMV�YWYEP�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH��-WVEIP�MW�JEV�JVSQ�XLI�SRP]GSYRXV] ERH�JEV�JVSQ�XLI�SRP]�HIQSGVEG] [MXL�GSQTEVEFPI�PE[W��7MRGIXLI�FVIEOYT�SJ�XLI�7SZMIX�9RMSR��6YWWME�LEW�[IPGSQIH�XLSYWERHW�SJ�IXL�RMG�6YWWMERW�JVSQ�XLI�JSVQIV�VITYFPMGW��7MRGI�������QMPPMSRW�SJ�IXLRMG+IVQERW�LEZI�GSQI�XS�+IVQER]�JVSQ�EPP�SZIV�GIRXVEP�ERH�IEWXIVR�)YVSTIERH�XLI�JSVQIV�7SZMIX�9RMSR��*SV�EPQSWX�JMJX]�]IEVW��+IVQER�MQQMKVEXMSRPE[�IZIR�JSPPS[IH�XLI�SJJMGMEP�HIJMRMXMSR�XLEX�©QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�+IVQERTISTPI�EVI�XLSWI�[LS�LEZI�GSQQMXXIH�XLIQWIPZIW�MR�XLIMV�LSQIPERHW�XS+IVQERRIWW��(IYXWGLXYQ ��MR�EW�JEV�EW�XLMW�GSQQMXQIRX�MW�GSRJMVQIH�F]GIVXEMR�JEGXW�WYGL�EW�HIWGIRX��PERKYEKI��YTFVMRKMRK�SV�GYPXYVI�ª�3XLIVWXEXIW��XSS��LEZI�WMQMPEV�PE[W�ERH�WMQMPEV�GSRRIGXMSRW�[MXL�XLIMV�HMEWTSVEW�=IX�SRP]�-WVEIP�MW�EXXEGOIH�EW�VEGMWX�JSV�MXW�RSRVEGMEP�PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�%PXLSYKL�.I[W��ERH�GIVXEMR�SJ�XLIMV�VIPEXMZIW �EVI�IRXMXPIH�XS�GMXMIRWLMT

�WYFNIGX�XS�GIVXEMR�HMWUYEPMJMGEXMSRW�JSV�GVMQMREP�EGXMZMXMIW ��RSR�.I[W�QE]EPWS�WIIO�GMXMIRWLMT��ERH�QER]�LEZI��MR�JEGX��FIIR�[IPGSQIH�F]�-WVEIP�EWJMVWX�GPEWW�GMXMIRW�[MXL�EPP�XLI�VMKLXW�EGGSVHIH�XS�.I[MWL�GMXMIRW��-R�%TVMP������-WVEIP�EMVPMJXIH�QSVI�XLER�����%PFERMER�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�/SWSZS�ERHMRZMXIH�XLIQ�XS�PMZI�MR�/MFFYX�1EEKER�1MGLEIP��8LIWI�RSR�.I[MWLVIJYKIIW�NSMRIH�E�TVIZMSYW�KVSYT�SJ�1YWPMQW�[LS�IWGETIH�JVSQ�XLI�&SWR�MER�'MZMP�;EV�MR�������8LI�VIJYKIIW�[IVI�KMZIR�XLI�GLSMGI�XS�VIQEMR�MR-WVEIP�TIVQERIRXP]�SV�XS�VIXYVR�XS�/SWSZS�EJXIV�XLI�JMKLXMRK��-WVEIP�LEHTVIZMSYWP]�SJJIVIH�EW]PYQ�XS�RSR�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�SXLIV�TEVXW�SJ�XLI

Page 167: The Case For Israel

[SVPH�IQFVSMPIH�MR�GSRJPMGX��1ER]�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�IWGETIH�7SZMIX�VITVIWWMSRF]�IQMKVEXMRK�XS�-WVEIP�[IVI�RSX�.I[MWL��EPXLSYKL�QSWX�[IVI�VIPEXIH�XS.I[W ��8LI�PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�[EW�GPIEVP]�E�VIWTSRWI�XS�LMWXSVMG�HMWGVMQMREXMSRF]�SXLIV�REXMSRW�EKEMRWX�.I[W��-X�MW�WYVIP]�YRHIVWXERHEFPI�[L]�-WVEIP��EWWSSR�EW�MX�FIGEQI�E�WXEXI��VIWTSRHIH�XS�XLEX�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�F]�STIRMRK�MXWHSSVW�XS�IZIV]�.I[��EW�[IPP�EW�XS�SXLIVW�WIIOMRK�VIJYKI�SV�E�FIXXIV�PMJI�8LIVI�MW��MR�JEGX��WSQI�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�EKEMRWX�%VEF�GMXMIRW�SJ�-WVEIP�

1SWX�GERRSX�WIVZI�MR�XLI�EVQ]��FYX�JI[�[SYPH�GLSSWI�XS�JMKLX�EKEMRWX�JIPPS[%VEFW�MJ�KMZIR�XLEX�STXMSR��9RXMP�VIGIRXP]��%VEFW�GSYPH�RSX�FY]�LSQIW�MRGIVXEMR�.I[MWL�EVIEW��NYWX�EW�.I[W�GERRSX�FY]�LSQIW�MR�%VEF�ZMPPEKIW��%�HIGM�WMSR�F]�XLI�-WVEIP�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�MR������VYPIH�XLEX�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX�QE]RSX�EPPSGEXI�PERH�FEWIH�SR�VIPMKMSR�SV�IXLRMGMX]�ERH�QE]�RSX�TVIZIRX�%VEFGMXMIRW�JVSQ�PMZMRK�[LIVIZIV�XLI]�GLSSWI��©8LI�TVMRGMTPI�SJ�IUYEPMX]�TVS�LMFMXW�XLI�WXEXI�JVSQ�HMWXMRKYMWLMRK�FIX[IIR�MXW�GMXMIRW�SR�XLI�FEWMW�SJ�VIPM�KMSR�SV�REXMSREPMX]�ª�'LMIJ�.YWXMGI�%LEVSR�&EVEO�[VSXI��©8LI�TVMRGMTPI�EPWSETTPMIW�XS�XLI�EPPSGEXMSR�SJ�WXEXI�PERH��������8LI�.I[MWL�GLEVEGXIV�SJ�XLI�WXEXIHSIW�RSX�TIVQMX�-WVEIP�XS�HMWGVMQMREXI�FIX[IIR�MXW�GMXMIRW�ª�-X�MW�JEMV�XS�WE]XLEX�-WVEIP��PIH�F]�MXW�TVSKVIWWMZI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX��MW�QEOMRK�GSRWMHIVEFPITVSKVIWW�MR�IPMQMREXMRK�XLI�ZIWXMKIW�SJ�ERXM�%VEF�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�XLEX�[IVIPEVKIP]�E�TVSHYGX�SJ�XLI�VIJYWEP�SJ�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�XS�EGGITX�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��-XMW�EPWS�JEMV�XS�WE]�XLEX�HIWTMXI�WSQI�PMRKIVMRK�MRIUYEPMXMIW��XLIVI�MW�JEV�PIWW�HMW�GVMQMREXMSR�MR�-WVEIP�XLER�MR�ER]�1MHHPI�)EWXIVR��%VEF��SV�1YWPMQ�REXMSR�8LI�QSWX�TVMQMXMZI�ETEVXLIMH�EKEMRWX�RSR�1YWPMQW�MW�WXMPP�STIRP]�TVEG�

XMGIH�MR�WSQI�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW��1SVISZIV��.SVHER�LEW�E�PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�XLEXI\TPMGMXP]�HIRMIW�GMXMIRWLMT�XS�EPP�.I[W��IZIR�XLSWI�[LS�PMZIH�XLIVI�JSV�KIR�IVEXMSRW��-XW�PE[W�TVSZMHI�XLEX�GMXMIRWLMT�MW�STIR�©XS�ER]�TIVWSR�[LS�[EWRSX�.I[MWLª�ERH�[LS�QIIXW�GIVXEMR�SXLIV�GVMXIVME��7EYHM�%VEFME�WMQMPEVP]FEWIW�IPMKMFMPMX]�SR�VIPMKMSYW�EJJMPMEXMSR��+IVQER]�PSRK�LEH�E�PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�EW�HS�'LMRE�ERH�QER]�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW��=IX�SRP]�-WVEIP��[LMGL�LEW�GMXMIRWSJ�ZMVXYEPP]�IZIV]�VIPMKMSR��IXLRMGMX]��VEGI��ERH�REXMSREP�SVMKMR��MW�GLEVEG�XIVMIH�F]�MXW�IRIQMIW�EW�VEGMWX�SV�ETEVXLIMH�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 168: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�MW�XLI�PSRKIWX�ERH�QSWX�FVYXEP�MR�QSHIVR�LMWXSV]�

8,)�%''97)67

©%P�2EOFE�?XLI�SVMKMREP�WMRA�MW�XLI�PEVKIWX��QSWX�GEVIJYPP]�TPERRIH�ERHPSRKIWX�IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK�STIVEXMSR�MR�QSHIVR�LMWXSV]��8LI�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ����XS[RW�ERH�ZMPPEKIW�LEZI�FIIR�I\TIPPIH�MR�������VIQSZMRK����TIV�GIRXSJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�XLI�PERH�XLEX�FIGEQI�-WVEIP��8LSWI�[LS�HMH�RSX�WYJ�JIV�XLMW�JEXI�MR�XLI�VIQEMRMRK�TEVX�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�EVI�RS[�MR�XLI�KVMT�SJ�XLIQSWX�FVYXEP��PSRKIWX�ERH�SRP]�SGGYTEXMSR�MR�XLI�[SVPH�ª��7EPQER�%FY7MXXE�

©8LI�PMJI�SJ�XLI�SVHMREV]�4EPIWXMRMER�LEW�FIIR�SRI�PSRK�NSYVRI]�SJ�QMW�IV]�ERH�LYQMPMEXMSR��'SPSRMIH��HMWTSWWIWWIH��SGGYTMIH�ERH�GSPPIGXMZIP]TYRMWLIH�ERH�IRHYVMRK�IXLRSGMHI�ERH�WXEVZEXMSR�ERH�JYVXLIV�VSFFIH�SJXLIMV�LSQIW�ERH�PERH�JSV�E�GVMQI�GSQQMXXIH�F]�)YVSTIERW�EKEMRWX�.I[W���]IEVW�EKS��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�RS�PSRKIV�GEVI�[LEX�XLI�;IWX��SV�XLI�%VEFW�JSVXLEX�QEXXIV��XLMRO��7YJJIVMRK�YRHIV�XLI�FVYXEP�-WVEIPM�VIKMQI�ERH�YRHIV�XLIPSRKIWX�QMPMXEV]�SGGYTEXMSR�MR�VIGIRX�LMWXSV]��XLI]�LEZI��VIPYGXERXP]�VIWSVXIH�XS�XLI�©QEVX]VHSQ�STIVEXMSRª MR�VIEGXMSR�XS�GSRXMRYIH�-WVEIPMVITVIWWMSR�ERH�GEVREKI�ª��%VXMGPI�EX�[[[�QIHMEVIZMI[RIX�GSQ��MR�VIEGXMSRXS�E�TLSXSKVETL�WLS[MRK�E�4EPIWXMRMER�FEF]�HVIWWIH�EW�E�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�

���

-W�XLI�-WVEIPM�3GGYTEXMSRXLI�'EYWI�SJ%PP�XLI4VSFPIQW#

��

Page 169: The Case For Israel

8,)�6)%0-8=

3XLIV�SGGYTEXMSRW��WYGL�EW�XLI�'LMRIWI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�8MFIX��LEZI�FIIRPSRKIV�ERH�PIWW�NYWXMJMIH��ERH�-WVEIP�IRHIH�MXW�SGGYTEXMSR�MR�������SRP]VIXYVRMRK�XS�WSQIEVIEW�XS�TVIZIRX�XIVVSVMWQ��-X�LEW�EKEMR�SJJIVIH�XS�IRHXLI�SGGYTEXMSR�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�FIWX�IJJSVXW�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�EYXLSVMXMIW�XSIRH�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�

8,)�4633*

%W�TVIZMSYWP]�HSGYQIRXIH��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�FIIR�SJJIVIH�E�LSQIPERHSR�XLVII�WITEVEXI�SGGEWMSRW MR�������������ERH�����§���� ERH�IEGLXMQI�LEZI�VINIGXIH�XLI�SJJIV�ERH�VIWTSRHIH�[MXL�MRGVIEWIH�XIVVSVMWQ��-X�MWUYMXI�VIQEVOEFPI�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�SJJIVIH�ER]XLMRK�EJXIV�XLI�7IG�SRH�;SVPH�;EV��GSRWMHIVMRK�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�XLIMV�PIEHIVWLMT�EGXMZIP]�WMHIH[MXL�XLI�PSWMRK�2EMW��7YTTSVXMRK�XLI�PSWMRK�WMHI�KIRIVEPP]�HSIW�RSX�VIWYPXMR�SJJIVW�SJ�WXEXILSSH��8LI�.I[W�KSX�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�JSV�WYTTSVX�MRK�XLI�VMKLX�WMHI�MR�;SVPH�;EV�-��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�KSX�E�KIRIVSYW�SJJIV�SJTEVXMXMSR�EJXIV�WMHMRK�[MXL�,MXPIV�

-�ORS[�SJ�RS�WMXYEXMSR�MR�LMWXSV]�[LIVI�E�WXEXI�LEW�X[MGI�VINIGXIH�KIR�IVSYW�SJJIVW�SJ�WXEXILSSH��VIWTSRHIH�[MXL�XLI�QEWWEGVMRK�SJ�GMZMPMERW��XLIRFIIR�VI[EVHIH�JSV�MXW�VINIGXMSRMWQ�ERH�GVMQIW�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]�F]�WXMPPERSXLIV�SJJIV�SJ�WXEXILSSH��-R�������XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�EKEMR�SJJIVIHWXEXILSSH��XLMW�XMQI�UYMXI�YRHIVWXERHEFP]�[MXL�E�VIHYGXMSR�MR�XIVVMXSV]�FYX[MXL�RS�VIHYGXMSR�MR�GSRXVSP�SZIV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR��*SV�XLI�XLMVHXMQI��4EPIWXMRMERW�VIWTSRHIH�[MXL�ZMSPIRGI�

&]�ER]�WXERHEVH�SJ�QSVEPMX]�ERH�NYWXMGI��XLI�GEWI�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�MRHI�TIRHIRGI�ERH�WXEXILSSH�MW�JEV�[IEOIV�XLER�XLI�GEWI�JSV�XLI�MRHITIRHIRGIERH�WXEXILSSH�SJ�RYQIVSYW�SXLIV�TISTPI�WIIOMRK�EYXSRSQ]�SZIV�XLIMVPMZIW��8LI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�8MFIX�F]�'LMRE�LEW�FIIR�PSRKIV�ERH�QSVI�FVYXEPERH�PIWW�NYWXMJMIH�F]�TVSXIGXMZI�SV�QMPMXEV]�GSRWMHIVEXMSRW��ERH�XLIVI�EVIQER]�QSVI�8MFIXERW�XLER�XLIVI�EVI�4EPIWXMRMERW��1SVISZIV��XLIVI�I\MWXW�RSSXLIV�WXEXI�[MXL�E�QENSVMX]�8MFIXER�TSTYPEXMSR��[LIVIEW�XLI�.SVHERMERTSTYPEXMSR�MW�EX�PIEWX�X[S�XLMVHW�4EPIWXMRMER��8LI�'LMRIWI�KSZIVRQIRX�LEWFYMPX�JEV�QSVI�WIXXPIQIRXW�MR�8MFIX�XLER�-WVEIP�LEW�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH+EE��;LMPI�.I[MWL�WIXXPIVW�GSRWXMXYXI�E�XMR]�QMRSVMX]�MR�4EPIWXMRMER�EVIEW�XLI�'LMRIWI�LEZI�JPSSHIH�8MFIX�[MXL�WS�QER]�IXLRMG�'LMRIWI�XLEX8MFIXERW�LEZI�FIGSQI�E�QMRSVMX]�MR�XLIMV�S[R�PERH�

3RI�TSPMG]�LEW�FIGSQI�MRGVIEWMRKP]�TVSQMRIRX�ERH�QE]�TVSZI�XS�FI�XLI

QSWX�IJJIGXMZI�SZIV�XMQI��XLI�TSPMG]�SJ�TSTYPEXMSR�XVERWJIV�SJ�'LMRIWI�GMX�

MIRW�MRXS�8MFIX��4STYPEXMSR�XVERWJIV�LEW�QEHI�8MFIXERW�E�QMRSVMX]�MR

8MFIX��LEW�HEQEKIH�XLI�8MFIXER�IRZMVSRQIRX�ERH�JEGMPMXEXIH�LYQER

VMKLXW�EFYWIW��

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 170: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

8LI�(EPEM�0EQE�WYQQEVMIH�XLI�WMXYEXMSR�MR������

%JXIV����]IEVW�SJ�'LMRIWI�VYPI��8MFIX�WIIQW�RS�GPSWIV�XS�JVIIHSQ�

%PXLSYKL�LYQER�VMKLXW�ETTIEPW�LEZI�LEH�PMXXPI�IJJIGX�XLYW�JEV��XLIWI

ETTIEPW�[MPP�RS�HSYFX�GSRXMRYI�XS�FI�QEHI��XLMW�QE]�IZIRXYEPP]�LIPT�XLI

8MFIXERW�MR�XLIMV�JMKLX�JSV�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�ERH�ER�IRH�XS�TSTYPEXMSR

XVERWJIVW��������-R������EPSRI�XLIVI�LEZI�FIIR�WM\�ORS[R�GEWIW�SJ�HIEXLW

VIWYPXMRK�JVSQ�XSVXYVI�ERH�EFYWI��%YXLSVMXMIW�LEZI�I\TIPPIH�E�XSXEP�SJ

������QSROW�ERH�RYRW�JVSQ�XLIMV�QSREWXIVMIW�ERH�RYRRIVMIW��������8LIVI

EVI�����ORS[R�ERH�HSGYQIRXIH�8MFIXER�TSPMXMGEP�TVMWSRIVW��������

7MRGI�������E�XSXEP�SJ��������QSROW�ERH�RYRW�LEZI�FIIR�I\TIPPIH�������

)ZIR�XSHE]�XLI�TVIWIRX�]SYRK�VIMRGEVREXI�4ERGLIR�0EQE�MW�YRHIV�ZMVXYEP

LSYWI�EVVIWX��QEOMRK�LMQ�XLI�]SYRKIWX�TSPMXMGEP�TVMWSRIV�MR�XLI�[SVPH��-

EQ�HIITP]�GSRGIVRIH�EFSYX�XLMW��

%�VIGIRX�EVXMGPI�MR�ER�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�VIZMI[�EHHIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�

8LI�VMKLXW�HIRMIH�XS�XLI�8MFIXERW�MRGPYHI�����0MJI��PMFIVX]�ERH�WIGYVMX]

LEZI�FIIR�ZMSPEXIH�����*SVGIH�PEFSYV�LEW�FIIR�MRJPMGXIH�SR�XLI�8MFIXERW�

���8SVXYVI�ERH�GVYIP�ERH�HIKVEHMRK�XVIEXQIRX�LEZI�FIIR�MRJPMGXIH��

���6MKLXW�SJ�LSQI�ERH�TVMZEG]�LEZI�FIIR�ZMSPEXIH�����*VIIHSQ�SJ�QSZI�

QIRX�[MXLMR�E�WXEXI��ERH�XLI�VMKLX�XS�PIEZI�ERH�VIXYVR�XS�8MFIX�LEZI�FIIR

HIRMIH�����1EVVMEKIW�LEZI�FIIR�JSVGIH�YTSR�YR[MPPMRK�TEVXMIW�����4VST�

IVX]�VMKLXW�LEZI�FIIR�EVFMXVEVMP]�ZMSPEXIH�����*VIIHSQ�SJ�VIPMKMSR�ERH�[SV�

WLMT�LEZI�FIIR�W]WXIQEXMGEPP]�HIRMIH�����*VIIHSQ�SJ�XLI�I\TVIWWMSR�ERH

GSQQYRMGEXMSR�SJ�MHIEW�MW�XSXEPP]�PEGOMRK������*VIIHSQ�SJ�EWWSGMEXMSR�

MW�HIRMIH������8LI�VMKLX�XS�VITVIWIRXEXMZI�KSZIVRQIRX�MW�HIRMIH�����

8LIVI�MW�E�[ERXSR�HMWVIKEVH�JSV�XLI�IGSRSQMG�VMKLXW�SJ�QER�MR�VIPEXMSR�XS

LMW�GSYRXV]¬W�VIWSYVGIW������8LI�VMKLX�XS�E�JVII�GLSMGI�SJ�IQTPS]QIRX�MW

HIRMIH������'SRHMXMSRW�SJ�PEFSYV�HS�RSX�GSRJSVQ�XS�QMRMQYQ�WXERHEVHW

MR�VIWTIGX�SJ�VIWX�ERH�PMQMXEXMSRW�SJ�LSYVW������8LI�VMKLX�XS�ER�EHIUYEXI

WXERHEVH�SJ�PMZMRK�MW�HIRMIH������8LI�VMKLX�XS�E�PMFIVEP�ERH�IJJMGMIRX��RSR�

HMWGVMQMREXSV]�IHYGEXMSREP�W]WXIQ�MW�HIRMIH������8LI�VMKLX�XS�TEVXMGMTEXI

MR�XLI�GYPXYVEP�PMJI�SJ�XLI�GSQQYRMX]�MW�HIRMIH������8LI�PMQMXEXMSRW

MQTSWIH�SR�XLI�VMKLXW�SJ�XLI�8MFIXERW�JEV�I\GIIH�ER]�[LMGL�EVI�VIEWSR�

EFP]�VIJIVEFPI�XS�XLI�VIUYMVIQIRXW�SJ�TYFPMG�QSVEPMX]��TYFPMG�SVHIV�ERH

XLI�[IPJEVI�SJ�WSGMIX]��

(IWTMXI�XLMW�LSVVIRHSYW�VIGSVH��XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�LEW�RIZIV�GSR�HIQRIH�'LMRE�SV�VIGSKRMIH�XLI�VMKLXW�SJ�8MFIXERW�XS�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�8SXLI�GSRXVEV]��XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�VI[EVHIH�'LMRE�[MXL�XLI�����3P]QTMGW��ERH�JI[�[LS�HIQERH�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXILSSH�EVI�IZIV�LIEVHSR�XLI�JEV�QSVI�GSQTIPPMRK�MWWYI�SJ�8MFIXER�MRHITIRHIRGI��;L]#�8LI

Page 171: The Case For Israel

WEQI�UYIWXMSR�GER�FI�EWOIH�EFSYX�XLI�/YVHW��XLI�%VQIRMERW�MR�8YVOI]�XLI�'LIGLIRW��XLI�&EWUYIW��ERH�HSIRW�SJ�SXLIV�WXEXIPIWW�KVSYTW��RSRI�SJ[LMGL�LEZI�SFWIVZIV�WXEXYW�EX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�SV�VIGSKRMXMSR�F]�WSQER]�WXEXIW�SV�VIPMKMSYW�KVSYTW�EW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�HS��1SVISZIV��RSRI�SJXLIWI�SXLIV�KVSYTW�LEZI�FIIR�SJJIVIH�WXEXILSSH�ERH�LEZI�VINIGXIH�MX�SRQYPXMTPI�SGGEWMSRW�

-WVEIP�LEW�SJJIVIH�WXEXILSSH�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�E�GSQ�QMXQIRX�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�XS�QEOI�MXW�FIWX�IJJSVXW�XS�IRH�XIV�VSVMWQ��ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�VIWTSRWI�LEW�FIIR�ER�IWGEPEXMSR�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[MPP�IZIRXYEPP]�LEZI�E�WXEXI��FYX�MX�WLSYPH�RSX�GSQI�EW�EVI[EVH�JSV�XIVVSVMWQ�

-�LEZI�WXVSRKP]�STTSWIH�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�TSTYPEXMSR�GIR�XIVW�WMRGI�������FYX�-WVEIP¬W�EGXMSRW�LEZI�FIIR�JEV�QSVI�NYWXMJMIH�QMPMXEVMP]�PIKEPP]��ERH�QSVEPP]�XLER�SXLIV�PSRKIV�SGGYTEXMSRW�XLEX�LEZI�RSX�FIIR�XLISFNIGX�SJ�RIEVP]�EW�QYGL�GSRHIQREXMSR��1SVISZIV��XLI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�YRPMOI�ER]�SJ�XLI�SXLIV�GYVVIRX�SGGYTEXMSRW��LEW�FVSYKLX�GSRWMHIVEFPI�HMZ�MHIRHW�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��MRGPYHMRK�WMKRMJMGERX�MQTVSZIQIRXW�MR�PSRKIZMX]�LIEPXL�GEVI��ERH�IHYGEXMSR��-X�LEW�EPWS�FVSYKLX�EFSYX�E�VIHYGXMSR�MR�MRJERXQSVXEPMX]��&IX[IIR������ERH�������[LIR�-WVEIP�[EW�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�LIEPXLERH�QIHMGEP�WIVZMGIW��QSVI�XLER����TIVGIRX�SJ�MRJERXW�ERH�WGLSSPGLMPHVIR[IVI�MQQYRMIH��XLIVI�[EW�ER�MRGVIEWI�MR�GSRXVSP�SJ�GLMPHLSSH�GSRXEKMSYWHMWIEWIW��ERH�XLI�MRJERX�QSVXEPMX]�VEXI�HIGPMRIH�JVSQ�����XS�����HIEXLW�TIV������PMZI�FMVXLW�MR�XLI�]IEVW�HYVMRK�[LMGL�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE�[IVISGGYTMIH�F]�.SVHER�ERH�)K]TX�XS����XS����HIEXLW�TIV�������PMZI�FMVXLW�F]XLI�IRH�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�MR�������-VSRMGEPP]��FIMRK�SGGYTMIH�F]-WVEIPMW�EW�HMWXMRKYMWLIH�JVSQ�.SVHERMERW�ERH�)K]TXMERW�EPWS�TVSQSXIH4EPIWXMRMER�REXMSREPMWQ��2SRI�SJ�XLIWI�HMZMHIRHW�EPSRI�SV�MR�GSQFMREXMSRNYWXMJ]�ER�YR[ERXIH�SGGYTEXMSR��FYX�XLI]�HS�TPEGI�E�FYVHIR�SJ�NYWXMJMGEXMSRSR�XLSWI�[LS�GSRHIQR�SRP]XLI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�[MXLSYX�IZIR�I\TVIWW�MRK�GSRGIVR�JSV�SXLIV�JEV�QSVI�FVYXEP�ERH�PIWW�NYWXMJMIH�SGGYTEXMSRW�

2SV�[SYPH�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�RIGIWWEVMP]�IRH�MJ�-WVEIP�KEZI�FEGOIZIV]�MRGL�SJ�PERH�MX�SGGYTMIH�MR�HIJIRHMRK�MXWIPJ�EKEMRWX�.SVHERMER�ERH)K]TXMER�EKKVIWWMSR�MR�������-R�XLI�JMVWX�TPEGI��4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�TVI�GIHIH�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�EW�XLI�XEGXMG�SJ�GLSMGI��&IKMRRMRK�MR�XLI�����W��XIV�VSVMWX�EXXEGOW�XEVKIXIH�.I[W >MSRMWXW�ERH�RSR�>MSRMWXW�EPMOI��8IVVSVMWQKSX�[SVWI�MR�XLI�����W�ERH�GSRXMRYIH�EJXIV�-WVEIP�FIGEQI�E�WXEXI�FYXFIJSVI�MX�SGGYTMIH�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE��&IX[IIR������ERH������RIEVP]�E�XLSYWERH�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�[IVI�OMPPIH�F]�JIHE]IIR�MR�GVSWW�FSVHIVEXXEGOW��%QSRK�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�GSRHYGXIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERWFIJSVIXLI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE�7XVMT�[IVI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�QEWW�QYVHIV�SJ�IPIZIR�FYW�TEWWIRKIVW�VIXYVRMRK�JVSQ�ZEGEXMSR�MR�)MPEXMR�������XLI�XIVVSVMWXW�JMVWX�OMPPIH�XLI�HVMZIV�ERH�XLIR�FSEVHIH�XLI�FYW�ERHWLSX�IEGL�TEWWIRKIV ��ERH�XLI������WLSSXMRK�SJ�GLMPHVIR�ERH�XIIREKIVW�MR

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 172: The Case For Israel

E�W]REKSKYI��MR�[LMGL�JSYV�[IVI�OMPPIH�ERH�JMZI�[SYRHIH��8LMW�PEXXIVEXXEGO�[EW�WMQMPEV�XS�XLI�/Y�/PY\�/PER�FSQFMRK�SJ�E�FPEGO�GLYVGL�MR%PEFEQE�MR�[LMGL�JSYV�GLMPHVIR�[IVI�OMPPIH�

,EQEW��,IFSPPEL��ERH�SXLIV�VINIGXMSRMWX�KVSYTW�LEZI�ZS[IH�XS�GSR�XMRYI�XIVVSVMWQ�IZIR�MJ�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�[IVI�XS�IRH��%�VIGIRX�TSPP�XEOIR�EX2ENEL�9RMZIVWMX]�MR�2EFPYW�JSYRH�XLEX�©���SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�WYVZI]IH�[IVIMR�JEZSV�SJ�GSRXMRYMRK�XIVVSV�EXXEGOWª�ERH�©�����[IVI�MR�JEZSV�SJ�«PMFIV�EXMRK�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�¬ª�-J�XIVVSVMWQ�WYGGIIHW�MR�WIGYVMRK�E�4EPIWXMRMERWXEXI�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT��[L]�WLSYPH�MX�RSX�GSRXMRYI�XSFI�YWIH�XS�WIGYVI�[LEX�XLI�ZEWX�QENSVMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�WE]�XLI]�[ERX#�%W8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�TYX�MX�MR�E�GSPYQR�WLSVXP]�EJXIV�XLI�TSPP�

4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�YWI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�XS�FPS[�YT�-WVEIPMW�EX�E�4EWWSZIV

QIEP�ERH�XLIR�HIGPEVI�©.YWX�IRH�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�ERH�IZIV]XLMRK�[MPP�FI

JMRIª�EVI�RSX�FIPMIZEFPI��2S�-WVEIPM�MR�LMW�VMKLX�QMRH�[SYPH�XVYWX�=EWWIV

%VEJEX��[LS�LEW�YWIH�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�[LIR�MX�WYMXIH�LMW�TYVTSWIW��RSX�XS

HS�XLI�WEQI�XLMRK�MJ�LI�KSX�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�FEGO�ERH�WSQI�SJ�LMW�TISTPI

WXEVXIH�HIQERHMRK�8IP�%ZMZ��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�GERRSX�]IX�FI�XVYWXIH�XS

GSRXVSP�XLIWI�EVIEW�SR�XLIMV�S[R�MJ�-WVEIP�[MXLHVE[W��

*VMIHQER�GSRGPYHIH�[MXL�E�VLIXSVMGEP�UYIWXMSR�XLEX�EPP�RSR�-WVEIPMW�WLSYPH�EWO�XLIQWIPZIW��©;SYPH�]SY�XVYWX�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�XS�TSPMGI�]SYVRIMKLFSVLSSH#ª�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 173: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP�LEW�HIRMIH�WXEXILSSH�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI��[LS�HIWIVZI�WXEXI�LSSH�QSVI�XLER�ER]�SXLIV�WXEXIPIWW�ERH�SGGYTMIH�KVSYT�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LI�EMQW�SJ�-WVEIP�EVI�GPIEV��JSV��EW�>MSRMWX�ERH�-WVEIPM�PIEHIVW�LEZI�FIIRWE]MRK�GERHMHP]�JSV�WIZIVEP�KIRIVEXMSRW��4EPIWXMRMER�REXMSREP�GPEMQW�EVI�RIM�XLIV�EHQMWWMFPI�RSV�ZEPMH��������;MXL�-WVEIP��XLI�9�7��LEW�VIWSPYXIP]�STTSWIHXLI�MHIE�SJ�REXMSREP�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�ERH�'LVMWXSTLIV,MXGLIRW�

©;L]�EVIR¬X�)YVSTIERW�EW�W]QTEXLIXMG�[MXL�XLI�8MFIXERW��'LIGLIRW�SV/YVHW�EW�XLI]�EVI�[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW#

©8LMW�MW�ERSXLIV�TIVZIVWI�PETWI��FIGEYWI�[IVI�XLI�;IWX�XS�HS�JSV�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�[LEX�MX�HMH�JSV�XLI�-VEUM�/YVHW��=EWWIV�%VEJEX�[SYPH�FI�E�ZIV]LETT]�QER�MRHIIH��&IWMHIW��RIMXLIV�HSIW�7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR�RSV�XLI�'LMRIWI'SQQYRMWX�4EVX]�GSQI�XS�;IWXIVR�GETMXEPW�IZIV]�SXLIV�QSRXL�FIKKMRK�YWMRK�FPEGOQEMP�[SYPH�FI�QSVI�EGGYVEXI �JSV�JYRHW�XS�WYFWMHMI�XLIMVQEGLMRIW�SJ�STTVIWWMSR�ERH�HMWTSWWIWWMSR�EKEMRWX�/YVHW�ERH�8MFIXERW�

©&YX�IZIR�MJ�XLMW�EVKYQIRX�[IVI�ZEPMH��ERH�XLI�;IWX�[EW�WMPIRX�EFSYXXLI�GVMQIW�EKEMRWX�SXLIV�STTVIWWIH�TISTPIW��HSIW�XLMW�QEOI�[LEX�-WVEIPHSIW�PIWW�SJ�E�GVMQI#

���

,EW�-WVEIP�(IRMIH�XLI

4EPIWXMRMERW�7XEXILSSH#

��

Page 174: The Case For Israel

©8LIVI�MW�E�TEVEHS\MGEP�MRZMXEXMSR�XS�MQQSVEPMX]�MRLIVIRX�MR�XLMW�TIVZIVWIPSKMG��7YTTSVXIVW�SJ�-WVEIP�EGORS[PIHKI�XLEX�-WVEIPM�WSGMIX]�MW�IRKEKIH�MR�ERMQQSVEP�IRHIEZSV�XS�WYFNYKEXI��HMWTSWWIWW�ERH�STTVIWW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�8LI]�ORS[�XLEX�[LEX�XLI]�EVI�HSMRK�MW�MQQSVEP�ERH�MPPIKEP��ERH�XLI]�LEZIGLSWIR�XS�FI�PIH�F]�E�RSXSVMSYW�[EV�GVMQMREP�[LS�LEW�QEHI�RS�WIGVIX�SJ�LMWMRXIRXMSR�XS�YWI�SRP]�ZMSPIRGI�XS�MQTSWI�LMW�[MPP�SR�E�GETXMZI�TSTYPEXMSR�

©;LIR�XLIWI�WMQTPI�JEGXW�EVI�TSMRXIH�SYX��WYTTSVXIVW�SJ�-WVEIP�GV]«VEGMWQ�¬�'VMXMGMMRK�XLIWI�GVMQIW�FIGSQIW�TIVZIVWI�VEGMWQ��[LMPI�EGUYM�IWGMRK�MR�XLIQ��IZIR�HIJIRHMRK�XLIQ��FIGSQIW�XLI�GSVVIGX�EXXMXYHI�-QQSVEPMX]�XYVRW�MRXS�QSVEP�VIGXMXYHI��ERH�XLI�[LSPI�[SVPH�FIGSQIW�XLI«YRHIV[SVPH�¬�E�JVEXIVRMX]�SJ�GVMQI�ERH�MR�GVMQI�ª��%FHIP[ELEF�IP�%JJIRHM��7IRMSV�6IWIEVGL�*IPPS[��'IRXIV�JSV�XLI�7XYH]�SJ�(IQSGVEG]��9RM�ZIVWMX]�SJ�;IWXQMRWXIV�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�RIZIV�WSYKLX�WXEXILSSH�[LIR�XLI]�[IVI�SGGYTMIH�F]�.SV�HER�ERH�)K]TX��,MWXSVMGEPP]�XLI]�[ERXIH�XS�FI�TEVX�SJ�7]VME��8LI�GPEMQ�SJ4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXILSSH�FIKER�EW�E�XEGXMG�XS�IPMQMREXI�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�SJ-WVEIP��1SVISZIV��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�GPEMQ�XS�WXEXILSSH�ERH�MRHITIRHIRGI�MWRS�WXVSRKIV��ERH�MR�WSQI�GEWIW�JEV�[IEOIV��XLER�XLI�GPEMQW�SJ�XLI8MFIXERW��XLI�/YVHW��XLI�&EWUYIW��XLI�'LIGLIRW��XLI�8YVOMWL�%VQIRMERW�ERH�SXLIV�WXEXIPIWW�KVSYTW�

=IX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�GPEMQ�LEW�FIIR�PIETJVSKKIH�SZIV�SXLIV�QSVI�GSQ�TIPPMRK�GPEMQW�JSV�SRI�QENSV�VIEWSR��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�EXXVEGXIH�[SVPH�[MHI�EXXIRXMSR�F]�QYVHIVMRK�XLSYWERHW�SJ�MRRSGIRX�TISTPI��[LIVIEW�XLI8MFIXERW�LEZI�RIZIV�VIWSVXIH�XS�XIVVSVMWQ��ERH�XLI�SXLIV�KVSYTW�LEZIIQTPS]IH�SRP]�ITMWSHMG�PSGEP�XIVVSVMWQ��[LMGL�LEW�RSX�FIIR�VI[EVHIH�F]XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�MR�XLI�[E]�XLEX�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�LEW�FIIRWS�VMGLP]�VI[EVHIH��8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�WYGGIWW�MR�FVMRKMRK�XLIMV�GEYWI�XS�XLIEXXIRXMSR�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�LEW�RSX��LS[IZIV��FVSYKLX�XLIQ�E�WXEXI��FIGEYWIRIMXLIV�-WVEIP�RSV�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�LEW�FIIR�[MPPMRK�XS�VI[EVH�XIVVSVMWQ�MRXLI�[E]�XLEX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��XLI�)YVSTIER�'SQQYRMX]��XLI�:EXMGER�ERH�SXLIVW�LEZI�

8,)�4633*

3R�XLI�QIVMXW��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�GEYWI�MW�JEV�[IEOIV�XLER�XLEX�SJ�QER]�SXLIVWXEXIPIWW�TISTPI��;L]�XLIR�HSIW�XLI�I\XVIQI�PIJX��TEVXMGYPEVP]�XLI�)YVSTIERPIJX��EPSRK�[MXL�XLI�I\XVIQI�VMKLX��GLEQTMSR�XLI�GEYWI�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LMPI�PEVKIP]�MKRSVMRK�XLI�JEV�QSVI�QIVMXSVMSYW�GEYWIW�SJ�XLI�8MFIXERW��XLI/YVHW��ERH�SXLIV�WXEXIPIWW�TISTPIW#�&]�ER]�SFNIGXMZI�WXERHEVH�SJ�QSVEPMX]�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 175: The Case For Israel

XLI�GPEMQW�SJ�XLI�8MFIXERW�ERH�/YVHW XS�JSGYW�SR�SRP]�X[S�WXEXIPIWWKVSYTW EVI�JEV�QSVI�GSQTIPPMRK�XLER�XLI�GPEMQW�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�8LIVI�EVI�QER]�QSVI�WXEXIPIWW�8MFIXERW�ERH�/YVHW�XLER�XLIVI�EVI�WXEXIPIWW4EPIWXMRMERW��8LI�8MFIXERW�ERH�XLI�/YVHW�LEZI�FIIR�XVIEXIH�JEV�QSVI�FVY�XEPP]�F]�XLIMV�SGGYTMIVW�XLER�LEZI�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��8LIVI�MW�EPVIEH]�SRIWXEXI�[LIVI�E�QENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR�MW�4EPIWXMRMER��[LIVIEW�RIMXLIV�XLI8MFIXERW�RSV�XLI�/YVHW�LEZI�ER]�WXEXI�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�

8LI�8MFIXERW�LEZI�IQTPS]IH�SRP]�PE[JYP�ERH�PIKMXMQEXI�QIERW�SJ�WIIO�MRK�VIHVIWW��ERH�XLI�/YVHW�LEZI�VIPMIH�TVMQEVMP]�SR�WYGL�QIERW��[LIVIEWJVSQ�XLI�ZIV]�FIKMRRMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�IQTPS]IH�GVMQIW�EKEMRWXLYQERMX]��XEVKIXMRK�XLI�QSWX�ZYPRIVEFPI�SJ�GMZMPMERW��8LI�8MFIXERW�ERH�XLI/YVHW�LEZI�EP[E]W�WSYKLX�MRHITIRHIRGI�ERH�WXEXILSSH��[LIVIEW�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�LEZI�LEH�QER]�STTSVXYRMXMIW�XS�EGLMIZI�WXEXILSSH��FIKMRRMRK�[MXLXLI4IIP�6ITSVX�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR��XLI�.SVHERMER�ERH�)K]TXMER�SGGYTE�XMSRW��ERH�XLI�SJJIVW�QEHI�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERWRIZIV�WSYKLX�WXEXILSSH��I\GITX�EW�E�XEGXMG�XS�HIWXVS]�-WVEIP�

8LI�GPEMQW�SJ�XLI�/YVHW�ERH�XLI�8MFIXERW�YRHIV�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�EVIJEV�WYTIVMSV�XS�XLSWI�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�WYTTSVXIH�XLIPSWMRK�WMHI�MR�IZIV]�[EV�SJ�XLI�X[IRXMIXL�GIRXYV]��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�*MVWX�;SVPH;EV�XLI�7IGSRH�;SVPH�;EV��XLI�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI��ERH�XLI+YPJ�;EV��[LIVIEW�XLI�8MFIXERW�ERH�XLI�/YVHW�LEZI�RSX�EPMKRIH�XLIQ�WIPZIW�[MXL�XLI�IZMPW�SJ�2EMWQ��XIVVSVMWQ��ERH�7EHHEQMWQ��%�QENSVMX]�SJ4EPIWXMRMERW�WYTTSVX�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�E�9�2��QIQFIV�WXEXI��[LIVIEW�RIM�XLIV�XLI�8MFIXERW�RSV�XLI�/YVHW�WIIO�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�ER]�WXEXI�

=IX�HIWTMXI�XLI�WMKRMJMGERXP]�QSVI�GSQTIPPMRK�GPEMQW�F]�XLI�8MFIXERWERH�XLI�/YVHW��RIMXLIV�KVSYT�LEW�IZIV�VIGIMZIH�ER]�VIGSKRMXMSR�JVSQ�XLI9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��XLI�)YVSTIER�GSQQYRMX]��XLI�:EXMGER��SV�ER]�SXLIV�SJJM�GMEP�FSH]��1SVISZIV��MRXIPPIGXYEPW�SJ�XLI�I\XVIQI�VMKLX�ERH�XLI�I\XVIQI�PIJXLEZI�PEVKIP]�MKRSVIH�XLIMV�GEYWIW��%�LIEZ]�FYVHIR�JEPPW�YTSR�XLSWI�WIPIGXMZIQSVEPMWXW�[LS�GLEQTMSR�E�[IEOIV�GEYWI�[LMPI�RIKPIGXMRK�WXVSRKIV�SRIW�

4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�FIIR�HIRMIH�WXEXILSSH�F]�XLIMV�S[R�PIEHIVW��[LSLEZI�VINIGXIH XMQI�EJXIV�XMQI SJJIVW�XLEX�[SYPH�LEZI�PIH�XS�WXEXILSSH�8LI�LMWXSVMER�&IRR]�1SVVMW�[VMXIW�SJ�XLI�©MRWXMRGXMZI�VINIGXMSRMWQ�XLEX�[EWPMOI�E�HEVO�XLVIEH�XLVSYKL�4EPIWXMRMER�LMWXSV]�ª�-WVEIP�LEW�WXSSH�VIEH]ERH�WXERHW�VIEH]�XSHE] XS�SJJIV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�WXEXILSSH��MR�I\GLERKIJSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]¬W�QEOMRK�KIRYMRI�FIWX�IJJSVXW�XS�WXST�XIVVSV�MWQ�F]�XLSWI�4EPIWXMRMER�KVSYTW�GSQQMXXIH�XS�GSRXMRYMRK�XLIMV�GVMQIWEKEMRWX�LYQERMX]�YRXMP�-WVEIP�MW�HIWXVS]IH��8LEX�MW�E�TIVJIGXP]�VIEWSREFPIGSRHMXMSR�XLEX�ER]�HIQSGVEXMG�REXMSR��JEGIH�[MXL�GSQTEVEFPI�HERKIVW�[SYPH�HIQERH�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 176: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�-WVEIPM�TSPMG]�SJ�LSYWI�HIWXVYGXMSR�MW�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�TVSLMFMXIHF]�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LI�HIQSPMXMSR�SJ�?IQTX]A�LSYWIW�F]�-WVEIPM�XEROW�MR�XLI�6EJEL�6IJYKII'EQT�MW�RSX�QYGL�HMJJIVIRX�JVSQ�XLI�WGIRI�SJ�XLI�;SVPH�8VEHI�'IRXIV�?MR[LMGL�QSVI�XLER�������TISTPI�[IVI�OMPPIHA�[LMGL�[EW�HIWXVS]IH�F]�XLIXIVVSVMWXW�[LSQ�[I�LEZI�EKVIIH�LIVI�XS�GSQFEX�ERH�IPMQMREXI�

©8LI�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�«MW�TVEGXMGMRK�E�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�MR�RSX�HIRSYRG�MRK�-WVEIPM�EGXMSRW¬�[LMPI�«HIRSYRGMRK�XLI�TIVTIXVEXSVW�SJ�XLI�7ITXIQFIV��XL�HIWXVYGXMSR�¬ª��7XEXIQIRX�F]�XLI�7]VMER�VITVIWIRXEXMZI�XS�XLI�7IGYVMX]'SYRGMP�

8,)�6)%0-8=

;LIXLIV�MX�MW�[MWI�SV�YR[MWI��XLI�-WVEIPM�TSPMG]�SJ�HIQSPMWLMRK�LSYWIW�XLEX[IVI�YWIH�XS�JEGMPMXEXI�XIVVSVMWQ�SV�S[RIH�F]�TISTPI�[LS�EWWMWXIH�XIVVSV�MWXW�MW�ER�IGSRSQMG�TIREPX]�JSV�GSQTPMGMX]�[MXL�QYVHIV��-X�MW�RSX�TEVXMGY�PEVP]�IJJIGXMZI��WMRGI�XLI�LSYWIW�EVI�VIFYMPX�[MXL�QSRI]�TVSZMHIH�F]W]QTEXLMIVW��FYX�WS�PSRK�EW�MX�MW�PMQMXIH�XS�LSYWIW�XLEX�EVI�S[RIH�F]

���

-W�-WVEIPtW�4SPMG]�SJ,SYWI�(IWXVYGXMSR�'SPPIGXMZI�4YRMWLQIRX#

��

Page 177: The Case For Israel

EGGIWWSVMIW�XS�XIVVSVMWQ�MX�MW�RSX�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX��1SVISZIV��XLI�GSR�GITX�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]�JSV�XIVVSVMWQ�XLEX�MW�[MHIP]�WYTTSVXIH�F]XLI�ZEWX�QENSVMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�XLIMV�PIEHIVWLMT�MW�IRXMVIP]�GSRWMWXIRX[MXL�PE[�ERH�QSVEPMX]�

8,)�4633*

8IVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�MW��SJ�GSYVWI��XLI�YPXMQEXI�JSVQ�SJ�GSP�PIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX��)ZIV]�-WVEIPMVIKEVHPIWW�SJ�LMW�SV�LIV�WYTTSVX�JSV�SVSTTSWMXMSR�XS�TEVXMGYPEV�KSZIVRQIRXEP�TSPMGMIW MW�XEVKIXIH�JSV�HIEXL�NYWXJSV�FIMRK�-WVEIPMW�SV�.I[W��=IX�XLSWI�[LS�WYTTSVX�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQGSQTPEMR�QSWX�PSYHP]�[LIR�E�LSQI�YWIH�F]�E�XIVVSVMWX�MW�HIWXVS]IH�EW�ERIGSRSQMG�HIXIVVIRX�EKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LS�LEVFSV�XIVVSVMWXW�

&IGEYWI�SJ�XLI�MQTSWWMFMPMX]�SJ�HIXIVVMRK�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW�XLIQWIPZIW��IWTI�GMEPP]�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��MX�MW�MQTSVXERX�XS�HMVIGX�HIXIVVIRGI�EX�XLSWI�[LS�WIRHXLIQ��XLSWI�[LS�JEGMPMXEXI�XLIMV�EGXMSRW��ERH�XLSWI�[LS�GER�LEZI�WSQI�MRJPY�IRGI�SZIV�XLIQ��;LIRIZIV�E�HIXIVVIRX�MW�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�ER]SRI�SXLIV�XLERXLI�MQQIHMEXIP]�GYPTEFPI�EGXSV��MX�GER�FI�HIIQIH�E�JSVQ�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�TYR�MWLQIRX��%PXLSYKL�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�MW�TVSLMFMXIH�F]�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�MX�MW�[MHIP]�TVEGXMGIH�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH��MRGPYHMRK�F]�XLI�QSWX�HIQS�GVEXMG�ERH�PMFIVX]�QMRHIH�GSYRXVMIW��-RHIIH��RS�W]WXIQ�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREPHIXIVVIRGI�GER�FI�IJJIGXMZI�[MXLSYX�WSQI�VIPMERGI�SR�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�)ZIV]�XMQI�SRI�REXMSR�VIXEPMEXIW�EKEMRWX�ERSXLIV��MX�GSPPIGXMZIP]�TYRMWLIW�GMX�MIRW�SJ�XLEX�GSYRXV]��8LI�%QIVMGER�ERH�&VMXMWL�FSQFMRKW�SJ�+IVQER�GMXMIWTYRMWLIH�XLI�VIWMHIRXW�SJ�XLSWI�GMXMIW��8LI�EXSQMG�FSQFMRKW�SJ�,MVSWLMQEERH�2EKEWEOM�OMPPIH�XLSYWERHW�SJ�MRRSGIRX�.ETERIWI�JSV�XLI�GVMQIW�SJ�XLIMVPIEHIVW��8LI�FSQFMRK�SJ�QMPMXEV]�XEVKIXW�MRIZMXEFP]�OMPPW�GMZMPMERW�

&I]SRH�XLI�OMPPMRK�ERH�[SYRHMRK�SJ�RSRGYPTEFPI�MRHMZMHYEPW��XLIVI�MWGSPPIGXMZI�IGSRSQMG�TYRMWLQIRX��WYGL�EW�9�2��ETTVSZIH�WERGXMSRW�ERH�XLIFEROVYTXMRK�SJ�ER�IRIQ]�REXMSR¬W�IGSRSQ]��[LMGL�MW�E�GSQQSR�[IETSRSJ�FSXL�LSX�ERH�GSPH�[EVW��2EXMSRW�XLEX�[EKI�EKKVIWWMZI�[EV�ERH�EVIHIJIEXIH�SJXIR�PSWI�XIVVMXSV]��ERH�WYGL�E�PSWW�QE]�[IPP�TYRMWL�MRRSGIRX�VIW�MHIRXW�SJ�XLEX�XIVVMXSV]��1ER]�IXLRMG�+IVQERW��WSQI�SJ�[LSQ�HMH�RSX�WYT�TSVX�,MXPIV��[IVI�JSVGIH�XS�VIPSGEXI�JSPPS[MRK�+IVQER]¬W�HIJIEX�MR�;SVPH;EV�--��'SPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�MW�E�QEXXIV�SJ�HIKVII��[MXL�XLI�2EM�GSR�GITX�SJ�7MTTIRLEJX XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�OMR�SV�XS[RWJSPO EX�SRI�IRH�SJ�XLIGSRXMRYYQ�ERH�IGSRSQMG�GSRWIUYIRGIW�SJ�EKKVIWWMSR�EX�XLI�SXLIV��'EPPMRKWSQIXLMRK�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�MW�SJXIR�E�TSPMXMGEP�SV�TYFPMG�VIPEXMSRW�XEG�XMG�GEPGYPEXIH�XS�GSRJYWI�VEXLIV�XLER�XS�GPEVMJ]��8LIVI�MW�QYGL�[VSRK�[MXLGIVXEMR�X]TIW�ERH�HIKVIIW�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX��&YX�XLIVI�MW�PMXXPI[VSRK ERH�SJXIR�WSQIXLMRK�ZIV]�VMKLX EFSYX�WSQI�OMRHW�SJ�GSPPIGXMZIEGGSYRXEFMPMX]�JSV�XLI�EGXMSRW�SJ�PIEHIVW�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 178: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

*SV�I\EQTPI��MX�[EW�VMKLX�JSV�XLI�IRXMVI�+IVQER�TISTPI�XS�WYJJIV�JSV[LEX�XLIMV�IPIGXIH�PIEHIV�LEH�YRPIEWLIH�SR�XLI�[SVPH��8LI�JI[�+IVQERW[LS�JSYKLX�EKEMRWX�,MXPIV�WLSYPH�LEZI�FIIR�VI[EVHIH��FYX�XLI�ZEWX�QENSV�MX]�SJ�+IVQERW�WLSYPH�LEZI�FIIR�LIPH�EGGSYRXEFPI�JSV�XLIMV�GSQTPMGMX][MXL�IZMP��-R�E�TIVJIGX�[SVPH��XLI�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�MQTSWIHMR�HMVIGX�TVSTSVXMSR�XS�TIVWSREP�GSQTPMGMX]��[MXL�XLSWI�QSWX�HMVIGXP]MRZSPZIH�FIMRK�MQTVMWSRIH�ERH�XLSWI�PIWW�HMVIGXP]�MRZSPZIH�FIMRK�QEHI�XSWYJJIV�IGSRSQMG�HITVMZEXMSR��8LI�+IVQER�TISTPI�[IVI�TVSQMWIH�XLEX�XLI][SYPH�FIRIJMX�JVSQ�E�2EM�ZMGXSV]��[LMGL�MW�TEVX�SJ�XLI�VIEWSR�WS�QER]WYTTSVXIH�,MXPIV��8LIVIJSVI��MX�[EW�NYWX�JSV�XLIQ�XS�WYJJIV�JVSQ�E�2EMHIJIEX��IZIR�XLSYKL�WSQI�EQSRK�XLI�WYJJIVIVW�[IVI�PIWW�GYPTEFPI�XLER�SXL�IVW��8LEX�MW�TEVX�SJ�[LEX�MX�QIERW�XS�FI�E�REXMSR�SV�E�TISTPI��8LSWI�[LSWXEVX�[EVW�ERH�PSWI�XLIQ�SJXIR�FVMRK�WYJJIVMRK�XS�XLIMV�TISTPI��8LEX�MWVSYKL�NYWXMGI��-X�MW�EPWS�E�HIXIVVIRX�XS�YRNYWX�[EVW�

%TTP]MRK�XLMW�TVMRGMTPI�XS�XIVVSVMWQ��MX�MW�RSX�YRNYWX�XS�QEOI�XLI�GEYWIMXWIPJ�WYJJIV�JSV�XIVVSVMWX�EGXMSRW�GSQQMXXIH�SR�MXW�FILEPJ��IWTIGMEPP]�MJ�XLIVI�MW[MHIWTVIEH�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�[MXLMR�XLI�GEYWI��'SRWMHIV��JSV�I\EQ�TPI��E�KVSYT�SJ�I\XVIQMWX�ERXMEFSVXMSRMWXW��WSQI�SJ�[LSWI�QIQFIVW�QYVHIVEFSVXMSR�HSGXSVW��FPS[�YT�EFSVXMSR�GPMRMGW��ERH�XLVIEXIR�TVIKRERX�[SQIRWIIOMRK�EFSVXMSRW��-X�[SYPH�FI�EFWYVH�XS�VI[EVH�XLIMV�XIVVSVMWQ�F]�VIWXVMGX�MRK�E�[SQER¬W�VMKLX�XS�GLSSWI�EFSVXMSR��-X�[SYPH�FI�NYWXMJMIH�XS�WIX�FEGOXLIMV�GEYWI�MJ�XLI]�TIVWMWXIH�MR�SV�MRGVIEWIH�XLIMV�XIVVSVMWQ��IWTIGMEPP]�MJ�XLIXIVVSVMWQ�[IVI�[MHIP]�WYTTSVXIH�F]�VERO�ERH�JMPI�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�KVSYT�

-R�XLMW�GSRXI\X��VIGEPP�XLI������TSPP�HIWGVMFIH�IEVPMIV�XLEX�JSYRH����TIV�GIRX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�WYTTSVXIH�GSRXMRYMRK�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW��7MRGI�XLIWI�WYT�TSVXIVW�LSTI�ERH�I\TIGX�XS�FIRIJMX�GSPPIGXMZIP]�JVSQ�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ��MX�MW�NYWX�EPFIMX�MQTIVJIGXP]�NYWX �XS�LSPH�XLI�GEYWI�GSPPIGXMZIP]�EGGSYRXEFPI�JSV�XLIQYVHIVSYW�EGXW�TIVTIXVEXIH�MR�MXW�REQI�ERH�YRHIV�MXW�YPXMQEXI�GSRXVSP��-JXLMW�FIRMKR�JSVQ�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]�GER�IJJIGXMZIP]�WEZI�MRRSGIRXPMZIW�F]�HIXIVVMRK�XIVVSVMWQ��XLI�FEPERGI�SJ�NYWXMGI�[IMKLW�MR�MXW�JEZSV�

8LI�OMRH�SJ�WYMGMHI�XIVVSVMWQ�TVEGXMGIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMERW QEWW�QYVHIV�SJTIVJIGXP]�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�[MXL�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�PSKMWXMGEP��JMRERGMEP��VIPM�KMSYW��TSPMXMGEP��ERH�IQSXMSREP�WYTTSVX�SJ�E�PEVKI�QENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�GMZMPMERTSTYPEXMSR GLEPPIRKIW�YW�XS�VIXLMRO�XLI�GPEWWMG�FVMKLX�PMRI�HMWXMRGXMSRFIX[IIR�GSQFEXERXW�ERH�RSRGSQFEXERXW��8LMW�PMRI��[LMGL�PMIW�EX�XLI�GSVI�SJXLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�SJ�[EV��LEW�FIIR�I\TPSMXIH�MR�XLI�MRXIVIWX�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�LEZI�PIEVRIH�LS[�XS�YWI�GMZMPMERW�EW�FSXL�W[SVHW�ERHWLMIPHW��XLI]�XEVKIX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW��XLIR�LMHI�FILMRH�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERW[LIR�XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]�GSQIW�EJXIV�XLIQ��8LI]�YWI�RSRGSQFEXERXW�EWWLMIPHW�JSV�GSQFEXERXW��8LI]�HIPMFIVEXIP]�TPEGI�XLIMV�FSQF�QEOMRK�JEGXSVMIWEHNEGIRX�XS�WGLSSPW��LSWTMXEPW��ERH�SXLIV�GMZMPMER�FYMPHMRKW�

8LI�VIWYPX�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP�QYWX�GLSSWI�FIX[IIR�IQTPS]MRK�[LSPIWEPI�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�XEGXMGW�WYGL�EW�EMV�WXVMOIW�XLEX�VMWO�OMPPMRK�PEVKI�RYQFIVW�SJ

Page 179: The Case For Israel

RSRGSQFEXERXW�EQSRK�[LSQ�XLI�GSQFEXERXW�EVI�LMHMRK�ERH�IQTPS]MRKVIXEMP�XEGXMGW�WYGL�EW�LSYWI�XS�LSYWI�GSQFEX�XLEX�VMWO�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�-WVEIPMWSPHMIVW��EW�XLI]�HMH�MR�.IRMR��8LIVI�MW�RS�TVIGMWI�JSVQYPE�JSV�GEPGYPEXMRKXLI�ETTVSTVMEXI�GSQFEXERX�RSRGSQFEXERX�VEXMS�IZIR�MR�GSRZIRXMSREP[EVJEVI�

%�QSVEP�REXMSR�QYWX�FI�TVITEVIH�XS�TPEGI�WSQISJ�MXW�S[R�WSPHMIVW�EXVMWO�XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�GSPPEXIVEP�OMPPMRK�SJ�IRIQ]�GMZMPMERW��FYX�MX�RIIH�RSX�VMWOXLI�PMZIW�SJ�QER]SJ�MXW�S[R�GSQFEXERXW�XS�EGLMIZI�XLMW�WEPYXEV]�EMQ��8LITVSTIV�QSVEP�VEXMS�WLSYPH�HITIRH��EX�PIEWX�MR�TEVX��SR�XLI�GSQTPMGMX]�SJ�XLIRSRGSQFEXERXW��-J�QER]�SJ�XLIQ�[MPPMRKP]�EPPS[�GSQFEXERXW�XS�LMHIEQSRK�XLIQ��MJ�XLI]�TVSZMHI�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�GSQFEXERXW��MJ�XLI]�QEOIQEVX]VW�SJ�XLI�QYVHIVIVW��XLIMV�S[R�GSQTPMGMX]�MRGVIEWIW�ERH�XLI]�QSZIGPSWIV�XS�GSQFEXERX�WXEXYW�SR�[LEX�LEW�FIGSQI�E�GSRXMRYYQ�VEXLIV�XLER�EFVMKLX�PMRI�WITEVEXMRK�GMZMPMERW�JVSQ�GSQFEXERXW��%R�EVQ]�SJ�PMFIVEXMSR[LSWI�TYVTSWI�MW�XS�VIWGYI�RSRGSRWIRXMRK�GMXMIRW�JVSQ�LYQER�VMKLXWEFYWIW�GSQQMXXIH�EKEMRWX�XLIQF]�XLIMV�YRIPIGXIH�PIEHIVWWLSYPH�IQTPS]�EHMJJIVIRX�QSVEP�VEXMS�XLER�XLEX�YWIH�F]�ER�EVQ]�JMKLXMRK�EKEMRWX�E�QM\IHKVSYT�SJ�GMZMPMERW�ERH�GSQFEXERXW�[LS�QYXYEPP]�WYTTSVX�IEGL�SXLIV�MRGSQQMXXMRK�GVMQIW�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]�

,S[�JEV�XLIR�EPSRK�XLI�GSRXMRYYQ�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]�[SYPH�MXFI�NYWX�XS�QSZI�MR�SVHIV�XS�GSQFEX�XIVVSVMWQ#�'IVXEMRP]�RSX�XS�XLI�TSMRX�SJHIPMFIVEXIP]�XEVKIXMRK�GSQTPIXIP]�MRRSGIRX�TISTPI�JSV�QYVHIV��-RHIIH��XLEXMW�TVIGMWIP]�[LEX�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW�HS��&YX�IGSRSQMG�WERGXMSRW�MQTSWIH�SR�WYT�TSVXIVW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�EVI�JEMV�ERH�QE]�FI�IJJIGXMZI��)ZIR�MJ�WSQI�TISTPI�[LSHS�RSX�WYTTSVX�XIVVSVMWQ�JIIP�WSQI�IGSRSQMG�MQTEGX��MX�WIIQW�E�WQEPPQSVEP�TVMGI�XS�TE]�JSV�WEZMRK�QER]�MRRSGIRX�PMZIW��IWTIGMEPP]�WMRGI�XLSWI[LS�WYTTSVX�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW�I\TIGX�XS�VIET�XLI�FIRIJMXW�SJ�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�

;LIRIZIV�GSPPIGXMZI�IGSRSQMG�TYRMWLQIRX�MW�MQTSWIH�SR�XLSWI�[LSWYTTSVX�XIVVSVMWQ��-�EQ�EP[E]W�JPEFFIVKEWXIH�XS�LIEV�XLI�TVSXIWXEXMSRWQEHI�MR�LMKL�QSVEP�HYHKISR�F]�XLSWI�[LS�XLIQWIPZIW�WYTTSVX�PIXLEP�XIV�VSVMWQ��WYGL�EW�=EWWIV�%VEJEX��)UYEPP]�L]TSGVMXMGEP�EVI�XLSWI�EGEHIQMGW�[LSWYTTSVX�XLI�FS]GSXXMRK�SJ�IZIV]�.I[MWL�-WVEIPM�WGLSPEV��VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�XLIMVMRHMZMHYEP�ZMI[W�SJ�-WVEIPM�TSPMG]��XLIR�GSQTPEMR�EFSYX�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWL�QIRX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�EVI�XLIQWIPZIW�GSQTPMGMX�MR�XIVVSVMWQ��%�FS]GSXXSJ�EPP�-WVEIPM�WGLSPEVW�ERH�HMZIWXQIRX�JVSQ�EPP�GSQTERMIW�XLEX�HS�FYWMRIWW[MXL�-WVEIP�EVI��SJ�GSYVWI��EGXW�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�

8LI�HIFEXI�SZIV�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�EVI�GSQTPMGMX�MRXIVVSVMWQ�VIQMRHW�QI�SJ�XLI�MRJEQSYW�*EPP�6MZIV�VETI�GEWI��JMGXMSREPMIH�MRXLI�JMPQ�8LI�%GGYWIH ��MR�[LMGL�XLIVI�[IVI�WIZIVEP�GEXIKSVMIW�SJ�QSVEPP]ERH�PIKEPP]�GSQTPMGMX�MRHMZMHYEPW��XLSWI�[LS�EGXYEPP]�VETIH�XLI�[SQER�XLSWI�[LS�LIPH�LIV�HS[R��XLSWI�[LS�FPSGOIH�LIV�IWGETI�VSYXI��XLSWI�[LSGLIIVIH�ERH�IRGSYVEKIH�XLI�VETMWXW��ERH�XLSWI�[LS�GSYPH�LEZI�GEPPIH�XLITSPMGI�FYX�HMH�RSX��2S�VEXMSREP�TIVWSR�[SYPH�WYKKIWX�XLEX�ER]�SJ�XLIWI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 180: The Case For Israel

TISTPI�[IVI�IRXMVIP]�JVII�SJ�QSVEP�KYMPX��EPXLSYKL�VIEWSREFPI�TISTPI�QMKLXHMWEKVII�EFSYX�XLI�PIKEP�KYMPX�SJ�XLSWI�MR�XLI�PEWX�X[S�GEXIKSVMIW��8LISFNIGXMSR�XS�MQTSWMRK�PIKEP�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�SR�TISTPI�MR�XLIWI�X[S�GEXI�KSVMIW�[SYPH�FI�HMQMRMWLIH�MJ�XLI�SRP]�WERGXMSR�EKEMRWX�XLIQ�[IVI�IGS�RSQMG E�JMRI��WE]��SV�GMZMP�PMEFMPMX]��8LIMV�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]�JSV�VETI�MW�WYVIP]�EQEXXIV�SJ�HIKVII��EW�MW�XLI�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]�JSV�XIVVSVMWQ�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�GLIIVXLI�XIVVSVMWXW��QEOI�QEVX]VW�SJ�XLIQ��IRGSYVEKI�XLIMV�S[R�GLMPHVIR�XSFIGSQI�XIVVSVMWXW��SV�I\TIGX�XS�FIRIJMX�JVSQ�XIVVSVMWQ��8LIVI�MW�RSXLMRKQSVEPP]�[VSRK�[MXL�LSPHMRK�WYGL�GSQTPMGMXSVW�EGGSYRXEFPI�WS�PSRK�EW�XLIGSRWIUYIRGIW�MQTSWIH�SR�XLIQ�EVI�TVSTSVXMSREP�XS�XLIMV�GSQTPMGMX]�

8LI�9�7��PIH�IGSRSQMG�WERGXMSRW�EKEMRWX�-VEU��0MF]E��ERH�'YFE�EVI�GSP�PIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRXW�MQTSWIH�SR�PEVKI�TSTYPEXMSRW�JSV�XLI�HIIHW�SJ�XLIMVPIEHIVW��7S�[IVI�XLI�WERGXMSRW�ERH�FS]GSXXW�MQTSWIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�F]�XLI%VEF�0IEKYI��-WVEIP¬W�TSPMG]�SJ�HIQSPMWLMRK�XLI�LSQIW�SJ�XIVVSVMWXW�SVXLSWI�[LS�LEVFSV�XLIQ�MW�E�WSJX�JSVQ�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�HMVIGXIHEKEMRWX�XLI�TVSTIVX]�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�EVI�HIIQIH�WSQI[LEX�GSQTPMGMX��8LEXMX�SGGEWMSREPP]�LEW�ER�MQTEGX�SR�MRRSGIRX�TISTPI�HIXVEGXW�JVSQ�MXW�QSVEPTYVMX]��FYX�XS�E�GSRWMHIVEFP]�PIWWIV�HIKVII�XLER�[MHIWTVIEH�IGSRSQMG�WERG�XMSRW�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�IRXMVI�REXMSRW��=IX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�LEW�WYT�TSVXIH�WYGL�IGSRSQMG�WERGXMSRW�IZIR�EW�MX�LEW�GSRHIQRIH�-WVEIP¬W�TSPMG]SR�TYRMWLMRK�XLSWI�[LS�EWWMWX�XIVVSVMWXW�

8LI�9�7��TSPMG]�SJ�GSRJMWGEXMRK�GEVW��FSEXW��EMVTPERIW��ERH�LSQIW�YWIHXS�JEGMPMXEXI�XLI�HVYK�XVEHI�MW�EPWS�E�JSVQ�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]HIWMKRIH�XS�HIXIV�TISTPI�JVSQ�EPPS[MRK�XLIMV�TVSTIVX]�XS�FI�YWIH�F]�HVYKWQYKKPIVW��-X�QE]�[IPP�FI�E�UYIWXMSREFPI�TSPMG]��FYX�MX�LEW�RSX�MRGYVVIH�XLIOMRH�SJ�GSRHIQREXMSR�XS�[LMGL�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�WYFNIGXIH�JSV�XEOMRK�JEV�PIWWUYIWXMSREFPI�EGXMSRW�XS�TVSXIGX�EKEMRWX�E�JEV�QSVI�WIVMSYW�IZMP�

-WVEIP�IQTXMIW�XLI�LSQIW��SJ�GSYVWI��FIJSVI�FYPPHSMRK�XLIQ��FYX�SR�EGSYTPI�SJ�SGGEWMSRW�TISTPI�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH��MRGPYHMRK�E�TVSXIWXIV�[LSXLVI[�LIVWIPJ�MR�JVSRX�SJ�XLI�FYPPHSIV�ERH�[EW�ETTEVIRXP]�RSX�WIIR�F]�MXWSTIVEXSV��%PXLSYKL�WLI�[EW�GLEVEGXIVMIH�F]�XLI�QIHME�EW�E�TIEGIEGXMZMWX MQTP]MRK�XLEX�WLI�[EW�E�RSRTEVXMWER�WYTTSVXIV�SJ�TIEGI RSXLMRKGSYPH�FI�JEVXLIV�JVSQ�XLI�XVYXL��7LI�FIPSRKIH�XS�E�VEHMGEP�TVS�4EPIWXMRMERKVSYT�SJ�IEPSXW WSQI�JVSQ�XLI�I\XVIQI�PIJX��SXLIVW�JVSQ�XLI�I\XVIQIVEGMWX�©VMKLX�[MRKª� [LS�EVI�SRI�WMHIH�WYTTSVXIVW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSV�MWQ��1IQFIVW�SJ�XLI�-RXIVREXMSREP�7SPMHEVMX]�1SZIQIRX�EVI�XEYKLX�XS�©FIWIRWMXMZIª�XS�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��FIGEYWI�©XLI]�EVI�KMZMRK�XLIMV�PMZIW�JSV�XLIMVPERH�ERH�XLIMV�TISTPI�ª�8LI]�EVI�HMVIGXIH�©XS�GSRWYPX�[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRM�ERWª�FIJSVI�XLI]�HS�ER]XLMRK��8LI]�WIVZI�EW�LYQER�WLMIPHW��[SVOMRKGPSWIP]�[MXL�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW�ERH�TVSXIGXMRK�SRP]4EPIWXMRMERWJVSQ�-WVEIPM�WSPHMIVW��8LI]�LEZI�RIZIV�SJJIVIH�XS�WIVZI�EW�WLMIPHW�TVSXIGXMRK-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�EKEMRWX�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ��8LI]�HS�RSX�WYTTSVX�TIEGI�

-RWXIEH��XLIWI�IEPSXW�EHZSGEXI�XLI�ZMGXSV]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�SZIV

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 181: The Case For Israel

-WVEIPM�WIPJ�HIJIRWI��8LI]�VIGIMZI�©JYRHW�JVSQ�FSXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSV�MX]�ERH�,EQEW��ERH�7LEHM�7YOM]E��E�WIRMSV�QIQFIV�SJ�-WPEQMG�.MLEH�MR.IRMR�[LS�[EW�MRZSPZIH�MR�XLI�TPERRMRK�SJ�WIZIVEP�XL[EVXIH�WYMGMHI�FSQF�MRK�EXXEGOW�[EW�EVVIWXIH�F]�-�(�*��XVSSTW�[LMPI�LMHMRK�MR�XLI�SJJMGIW�SJ�XLI-RXIVREXMSREP�7SPMHEVMX]�1SZIQIRXª�MR�1EVGL�������%RH�MR�%TVMP�����X[S�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�JVSQ�)RKPERH�LMH�EQSRK�XLI�KVSYT��IZIR�EXXIRHMRKE�WIVZMGI�GSRHYGXIH�F]�MX��NYWX�HE]W�FIJSVI�SRI�SJ�XLIQ�FPI[�LMQWIPJ�YTEPSRK�[MXL�XLVII�-WVEIPMW��8LI�©WSPMHEVMX]ª�KVSYT�XLIR�GSRHIQRIH�-WVEIPJSV�MXW�VIWTSRWI�XS�XLI�QYVHIVW�

8LI�QIHME�WLSYPH�WXST�VIJIVVMRK�XS�XLIWI�TISTPI�EW�TIEGI�EGXMZMWXW�ERHWLSYPH�GEPP�XLIQ�[LEX�XLI]�EVI��EGXMZI�WYTTSVXIVW�ERH�JEGMPMXEXSVW�SJ�4EPIW�XMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ��2IZIVXLIPIWW��XLIVI�MW�RS�I\GYWI�JSV�XLI�OMRH�SJ�RIKPM�KIRGI�F]�XLSWI�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�LSYWI�HIQSPMXMSRW�XLEX�VIWYPXIH�MR�XLIHIEXL�SJ�XLI�IEPSX��FYX�EFWIRX�TL]WMGEP�LEVQ�XS�MRHMZMHYEPW��XLI�IGSRSQMGWERGXMSR�SJ�LSQI�HIWXVYGXMSR�MW�IRXMVIP]�QSVEP�MJ�MX�MW�PMQMXIH�XS�XLSWI�[LSFIEV�WSQI�QSVEP�GSQTPMGMX]�MR�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�XLEX�MW�WSYKLX�XS�FI�HIXIVVIH�

8LI�QENSV�TVSFPIQ�[MXL�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�LSYWIW�MRZSPZIH�MR�XIVVSV�MWQ�MW�RSX�[MXL�MXW�QSVEPMX]��%�RSRPIXLEP�ETTVSEGL�PMOI�XLMW�MW�EQSRK�XLIQSWX�QSVEP�ERH�GEPMFVEXIH�VIWTSRWIW�XS�XIVVSVMWQ JEV�QSVI�WS�XLER�QEW�WMZI�QMPMXEV]�VIXEPMEXMSR��[LMGL�MRIZMXEFP]�TVSHYGIW�GSPPEXIVEP�HIEXLW�SJ�RSR�GSQFEXERXW��IWTIGMEPP]�[LIR�GSQFEXERXW�FPIRH�MR�[MXL�RSRGSQFEXERXWERH�[LIR�RSRGSQFEXERG]�MW�SJXIR�E�QEXXIV�SJ�HIKVII ��8LI�TVSFPIQ�[MXLHIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�LSYWIW�MW�XLEX�MX�TPE]W�TSSVP]�SR�XIPIZMWMSR��-RHIIH��MR�WSQI1YWPMQ�GSYRXVMIW�ZMI[IVW�EVI�PIH�XS�FIPMIZI�XLEX�XLI�LSYWIW�EVI�HIWXVS]IH[MXL�TISTPI�WXMPP�MR�XLIQ�

)ZIR�[LIR�MX�MW�GPIEV�XLEX�RS�SRI�MW�MRWMHI��XLI�MRIZMXEFPI�TMGXYVI�SJ�XLIGV]MRK�[SQER�FIQSERMRK�XLI�PSWW�SJ�LIV�LSQI�GVIEXIW�W]QTEXL]��IZIR�MJXLEX�WEQI�[SQER�[EW�]IWXIVHE]�IRGSYVEKMRK�LIV�WSR�XS�FIGSQI�E�QEVX]VERH�XSQSVVS[�[MPP�FI�GLIIVMRK�EX�XLI�RI[W�SJ�ER�-WVEIPM�VIWXEYVERX�FIMRKFPS[R�YT�[MXL�E�HSIR�XIIREKIVW�MRWMHI���-J�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW�[SYPH�EKVII�XSKMZI�EHZERGI�[EVRMRK�XLEX�XLI]�[IVI�KSMRK�XS�FPS[�YT�E�FYMPHMRK��XLI�[E]XLI�-WVEIPMW�HS��XLIR�XLIVI�QMKLX�FI�WSQI�EVKYQIRX�JSV�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRG]�

,SYWI�HIWXVYGXMSR�MW�EPWS�MRIJJIGXMZI�FIGEYWI�,EQEW�GSRXMRYIW�XS�TE]TISTPI�[LSWI�LSYWIW�EVI�HIWXVS]IH�IRSYKL�QSRI]�XS�FYMPH�E�FMKKIVLSYWI���7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR�LEH�ERRSYRGIH�MR�%TVMP������XLEX�LI�[SYPH�TE]XLI�JEQMP]�SJ�ER]�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�[LS�OMPPIH�.I[W���������MR�GEWL��FYXXLEX�WXVIEQ�SJ�TE]QIRX�IRHIH�EJXIV�LI�[EW�XSTTPIH� �9RHIV�9�7��PE[��ER]�SRI�[LS�EKVIIW�MR�EHZERGI�XS�TE]�XLI�JEQMP]�SJ�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�MW�E�GSR�WTMVEXSV�MR�XIVVSVMWQ�ERH�QYVHIV�

8LI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�QYWX�GSQI�XS�EGGITX�XLI�NYWXMGI�SJ�HMVIGX�MRK�TVSTSVXMSREXI��RSRPIXLEP�HIXIVVIRXW�EKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LS�WYTTSVX�ERHFIRIJMX�JVSQ�XIVVSVMWQ��VEXLIV�XLER�XLVIEXIRMRK�QIERMRKPIWW�WERGXMSRWEKEMRWX�XLI�WYMGMHI�XIVVSVMWXW�XLIQWIPZIW��8LMW�MW�FSXL�JEMV�ERH�TSXIRXMEPP]

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 182: The Case For Israel

IJJIGXMZI�EW�E�HIXIVVIRX�EKEMRWX�QER]�X]TIW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ��IWTIGMEPP]�XLSWIXLEX�VIP]�SR�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��8LI�%WWSGMEXIH�4VIWWVITSVXIH�SR�1E]����������XLEX�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LSWI�LSYWIW�[IVI�HIWXVS]IH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]LEZI�I\TVIWWIH�ERKIV�EX�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�[LS�XLI]�WE]�MRZMXIH�EXXEGOF]�JMVMRK�VSGOIXW�JVSQ�XLIMV�XS[R��%GGSVHMRK�XS�1SLEQQIH�>EERIIR��SRISJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�JEVQIVW��©?8LI�XIVVSVMWXWA�GPEMQ�XLI]�EVI�LIVSIW�?FYXXLI]A�FVSYKLX�YW�SRP]�HIWXVYGXMSR�ERH�QEHI�YW�LSQIPIWW��8LI]�YWIH�SYVJEVQW��SYV�LSYWIW�ERH�SYV�GLMPHVIR�������XS�LMHI�ª�

%W�[I�[MPP�WII�MR�GLETXIV�����XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�VIGIRXP]�VYPIHXLEX�SRP]�TISTPI�HMVIGXP]�MRZSPZIH�MR�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�QE]�FI�QSZIH�JVSQSRI�TEVX�SJ�XLI�SGGYTMIH�XIVVMXSVMIW�XS�ERSXLIV�TEVX��8LMW�MQTSVXERX�HIGMWMSR[MPP�WYVIP]�FI�GMXIH�EW�E�TVIGIHIRX�JSV�XLSWI�EVKYMRK�XLEX�LSYWI�HIWXVYGXMSRQE]�FI�YWIH�SRP]�EKEMRWX�TISTPI�[LS�EVI�GSQTPMGMX�MR�XIVVSVMWQ�

-R�E�HIXEMPIH�EREP]WMW�SJ�-WVEIPM�VIWTSRWIW�XS�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW��XLI�2I[=SVO�8MQIWGSRGPYHIH�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEH�EGLMIZIH�GSRWMHIVEFPI�WYGGIWW�MRWXIQQMRK�QER]�EXXEGOW FYX�EX�E�GSWX��-X�HIWGVMFIH�SRI�GEWI�MR�[LMGL�EQER�REQIH�%PM�%NSYVM�LEH�HMWTEXGLIH�X[S�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�[LS�LEH�OMPPIHJMZI�GMZMPMERW��8LI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�FPI[�YT�%NSYVM¬W�JEQMP]�LSQI�ERH�GLEVKIHLMW�WMWXIV�[MXL�©WI[MRK�FSQF�FIPXW�JSV�XLI�EXXEGOIVWª�ERH�LMW�FVSXLIV�[MXLEWWMWXMRK�XLI�QYVHIVIVW��8LIR�XLI]�WLSX�%PM�%NSYVM�LMQWIPJ�[LMPI�LI�[EWXV]MRK�XS�IWGETI��,I�[EW�E�QIQFIV�SJ�XLI�%P�%OWE�1EVX]VW�&VMKEHI��[LMGLWTIGMEPMIW�MR�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRK�

4EPIWXMRMERW ���XS����TIVGIRX�SJ�[LSQ�WXMPP�WYTTSVX�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRK�EGGSVHMRK�XS�STMRMSR�TSPPW�GMXIH�F]�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIWSR�%TVMP�������� LEZI�GVMXMGMIH�XLIWI�XEGXMGW��EPXLSYKL�©XLI�QMPMXERXW�XLIQWIPZIWGSRGIHI�XLEX�XLI�QIEWYVIW�LEZI�QEHI�MX�LEVHIV�XS�WXEKI�EXXEGOW�ª�8LI%NSYVM�LSQI�©LEW�FIIR�PEVKIP]�VIFYMPX�ª�8LI�PMZIW�SJ�LMW�ZMGXMQW�GERRSX�FIVIFYMPX��;LMPI�GMZMP�PMFIVXEVMERW�QE]�HMWEKVII�EFSYX�[LIXLIV�XLI�QIEWYVIWXEOIR�F]�-WVEIP�EVI�SV�EVI�RSX�I\GIWWMZI��RS�VIEWSREFPI�TIVWSR�SJ�KSSH[MPPGER�TPEYWMFP]�GPEMQ�XLI]�GSRWXMXYXI�KVSWW�ZMSPEXMSRW�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�SV�EVIMR�ER]�[E]�GSQTEVEFPI�XS�XLI�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�XLI]�EVI�XV]MRK�XS�TVI�ZIRX SV�XS�2EM�XEGXMGW��SV�IZIR�XS�XLI�XEGXMGW�GYVVIRXP]�FIMRK�YWIH�F]�XLIQSWX�©TVSKVIWWMZIª�%VEF�VIKMQIW��WYGL�EW�.SVHER�SV�)K]TX��8LI]�EVI��MRJEGX��GSQTEVEFPI�XS�QIEWYVIW�XEOIR�F]�SXLIV�HIQSGVEGMIW�WYGL�EW�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�+VIEX�&VMXEMR�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 183: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�-WVEIPM�TSPMG]�SJ�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�PIEHIVW�MW�QYVHIVTVSLMFMXIH�F]�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�

8,)�%''97)67

©%WWEWWMREXMSRW�LEZI�FIIR�TEVX�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�WIGYVMX]�TSPMG]�JSV�QER]�]IEVW�-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�HIQSGVEXMG�GSYRXV]�[LMGL�VIKEVHW�WYGL�QIEWYVIW�EW�EPIKMXMQEXI�GSYVWI�SJ�EGXMSR��8LMW�TSPMG]�MW�TEXIRXP]�MPPIKEP��EGGSVHMRK�XSFSXL�-WVEIPM�ERH�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��E�TSPMG]�[LSWI�MQTPIQIRXEXMSR�MRZSPZIWE�LMKL�VMWO�SJ�LYVXMRK�F]WXERHIVW�ERH�JVSQ�[LMGL�XLIVI�MW�RS�XYVRMRK�FEGOIZIR�MJ�IVVSVW�EVI�YRGSZIVIH�EJXIV�XLI�JEGX��-WVEIP�QYWX�GIEWI�EWWEWWMREXMRK4EPIWXMRMERW�MQQIHMEXIP]�ª��=EIP�7XIMR�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�LYQER�VMKLXW�SVKERM�EXMSR�&¬8WIPIQ�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8EVKIXMRK�XLI�QMPMXEV]�PIEHIVW�SJ�ER�IRIQ]�HYVMRK�LSWXMPMXMIW�MW�TIVJIGXP]TVSTIV�YRHIV�XLI�PE[W�SJ�[EV��[LMGL�MW�[LEX�-WVEIP EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�9RMXIH7XEXIW�ERH�SXLIV�HIQSGVEGMIW LEW�HSRI�

8,)�4633*

-R�SRI�WIRWI��XLI�TSPEV�STTSWMXI�SJ�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�MW�XEVKIXIH�EWWEW�WMREXMSR��8LMW�XEGXMG�WIIOW�XS�TVIZIRX�JYXYVI�XIVVSVMWQ�F]�MRGETEGMXEXMRK

���

-W�8EVKIXIH�%WWEWWMREXMSRSJ8IVVSVMWX�0IEHIVW9RPE[JYP#

��

Page 184: The Case For Israel

XLSWI�[LS�EVI�TPERRMRK�XS�GEVV]�MX�SYX�FYX�EVI�FI]SRH�XLI�VIEGL�SJ�SXLIVQIXLSHW�SJ�MRGETEGMXEXMSR��WYGL�EW�EVVIWX��8]VERRMGEP�VIKMQIW�LEZI�[MHIP]IQTPS]IH�ER�I\XVIQI�JSVQ�SJ�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�EKEMRWX�TIVGIMZIHIRIQMIW�EX�LSQI�ERH�EFVSEH��,MXPIV�LEH�LMW�VMZEPW�QYVHIVIH�[MXLMQTYRMX]��7XEPMR�XSSO�LMW�GEQTEMKR�SJ�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�EVSYRH�XLI[SVPH��IZIR�XS�1I\MGS��[LIVI�LMW�STIVEXMZIW�QYVHIVIH�0ISR�8VSXWO]�

8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�LEW�GIVXEMRP]�XVMIH�XS�EWWEWWMREXI�JSVIMKR�PIEHIVW�SZIVXLI�]IEVW��-XW�LMX�PMWX�LEW�MRGPYHIH�*MHIP�'EWXVS��EW�[IPP�EW�4EXVMGI0YQYQFE��1YEQQEV�IP�5EHHEJM��ERH�7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR��%PXLSYKL�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW�HMH�RSX�HMVIGXP]�QYVHIV�7EPZEHSV�%PPIRHI�SV�2KS�(MRL(MIQ��MX�GIVXEMRP]�TPE]IH�ER�EGXMZI�VSPI�MR�LIPTMRK�SXLIVW�XS�HMWTEXGL�XLIQ�6IGIRXP]��MX�EKEMR�XEVKIXIH�7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR��LMW�GLMPHVIR��ERH�LMW�KIRIVEPW�ERH�LEW�TYX�FSYRXMIW�SR�XLI�LIEHW�SJ�3WEQE�FMR�0EHIR�ERH�1YPPEL1SLEQQEH�3QEV��3XLIV�HIQSGVEXMG�REXMSRW�LEZI�EPWS�KMZIR�XLIMV�EKIRXWE�©PMGIRWI�XS�OMPPª�MR�I\XVIQI�WMXYEXMSRW�

8EVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR��PMOI�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX��STIVEXIW�EPSRK�E�GSR�XMRYYQ��%X�XLI�LEVH�IRH�MW�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�XEVKIXMRK�SJ�EPP�TIVGIMZIH�TSPMX�MGEP�STTSRIRXW��EW�,MXPIV�ERH�7XEPMR�TVEGXMGIH�MX��%X�XLI�WSJX�IRH�MW�[LEX�XLI9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�-WVEIP�GYVVIRXP]�HS��XEVKIXMRK�WTIGMJMG�XIVVSVMWX�PIEHIVW[LS�EVI�EGXMZIP]�MRZSPZIH�MR�TPERRMRK�SV�GSSVHMREXMRK�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�ERH[LS�GERRSX�FI�EVVIWXIH��%R�I\EQTPI�SJ�WYGL�E�XEVKIX�[EW�=ILM]E�%]EWL�ORS[R�EW�©XLI�)RKMRIIV�ª�XLI�GLMIJ�FSQF�QEOIV�JSV�,EQEW��[LSQ�-WVEIPMEKIRXW�OMPPIH�MR�.ERYEV]������F]�TPEGMRK�I\TPSWMZIW�MR�LMW�QSFMPI�TLSRI�%RSXLIV�I\EQTPI�[EW�XLI�%TVMP������-WVEIPM�VSGOIX�EXXEGO�SR�E�GEV�XLEXOMPPIH�XLI�PIEHIV�SJ�-WPEQMG�.MLEH��1ELVSYH�>EXQI��,MW�SVKERMEXMSR�MWWYIHE�WXEXIQIRX�©GSRHIQRMRK�XLI�OMPPMRKª�FYX�FSEWXMRK�XLEX�©XLI�QEVX]V�[EWXLI�IRKMRIIV�SJ�FSQFW�ERH�I\TPSWMZI�FIPXW�XLEX�OMPPIH�XIRW�ERH�[SYRHIHLYRHVIHW�SJ�>MSRMWX�SGGYTMIVW�ª�QIERMRK�.I[MWL�GLMPHVIR�ERH�SXLIV�GMZMP�MERW��2S�SRI�IPWI�[EW�OMPPIH�MR�XLI�EXXEGO�SR�>EXQI�

8LI�ZMGI�SJ�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�MW�XLEX�XLSWI�[LS�EYXLSVMI�XLI�LMXEVI�TVSWIGYXSV��NYHKI��ERH�NYV] ERH�XLIVI�MW�RS�ETTIEP��-R�-WVEIP��XLI�HIGM�WMSR�VIKEVHMRK�[LS�MW�ER�ETTVSTVMEXI�XEVKIX�MW�KIRIVEPP]�QEHI�F]�LMKL�VEROMRK�KSZIVRQIRX�SJJMGMEPW�[MXL�TSPMXMGEP�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]��8LI�ZMVXYI�SJXEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR��MJ�XLI�XEVKIXW�EVI�TMGOIH�GEVIJYPP]�ERH�GSRWIVZEXMZIP]�MW�TVIGMWIP]�XLEX�MX�MW�XEVKIXIH�ERH�XIRHW�XS�EZSMH�GSPPEXIVEP�HEQEKI�ERH�GSP�PIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX��%PFIVX�'EQYW¬W�©NYWX�EWWEWWMRª�[EW�IQTPS]MRK�XEVKIXIHEWWEWWMREXMSR�EKEMRWX�ER�IZMP�[VSRKHSIV��ERH�LI�VIJYWIH�XS�TVSGIIH�MR�XLIJEGI�SJ�GSPPIGXMZIP]��SV�GSPPEXIVEPP] �TYRMWLMRK�XLI�IZMPHSIV¬W�]SYRK�RMIGIERH�RITLI[��)ZIR�[LIVI�XLIVI�EVI�GSPPEXIVEP�ZMGXMQW��XLIVI�EVI�JI[IV�SJXLIQ�XLER�MR�X]TMGEP�QMPMXEV]�VITVMWEPW�

9RHIV�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�ERH�XLI�PE[W�SJ�[EV��MX�MW�IRXMVIP]�PIKEP�XS�XEVKIXERH�OMPP�ER�IRIQ]�GSQFEXERX�[LS�LEW�RSX�WYVVIRHIVIH��4EPIWXMRMER�XIV�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 185: The Case For Israel

VSVMWXW [LIXLIV�XLI]�EVI�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�XLIQWIPZIW��XLSWI�[LSVIGVYMX�XLIQ��XLSWI�MR�GLEVKI�SJ�XLI�STIVEXMSR��SV�GSQQERHIVW�SJ�XIVVSVMWXKVSYTW EVI�YRHSYFXIHP]�IRIQ]�GSQFEXERXW��VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�[LIXLIV�XLI][IEV�SJJMGMEP�YRMJSVQW�SV�XLVII�TMIGI�WYMXW��-X�MW�PE[JYP�XS�OMPP�ER�IRIQ]GSQFEXERX�IZIR�[LIR�LI�MW�WPIITMRK��EW�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�XVMIH�XS�HS�[MXL7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR��WS�PSRK�EW�LI�LEW�RSX�WYVVIRHIVIH��2SV�RIIH�LI�FI�KMZIRER�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�WYVVIRHIV��,I�QYWX�XEOI�XLI�MRMXMEXMZI��SXLIV[MWI�XLIWSPHMIV�SR�XLI�SXLIV�WMHI�[MPP�VMWO�FIMRK�JMVIH�YTSR��8LI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRXKIRIVEPP]�XEVKIXW�SRP]�XIVVSVMWXW��RSX�TSPMXMGEP�PIEHIVW��EW�IZMHIRGIH�F]�XLIJEGX�XLEX�MX�LEW�VITIEXIHP]�TVSXIGXIH�XLI�PMJI�SJ�=EWWIV�%VEJEX��[LS�MW�FSXL�ETSPMXMGEP�PIEHIV�ERH�E�XIVVSVMWX��-WVEIP�LEW�EPWS�ERRSYRGIH�XLEX�MX�[MPP�WXSTXEVKIXMRK�,EQEW�XIVVSVMWXW�MJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�[SYPH�WXEVX�EVVIWX�MRK�XLIQ�

8LI�OI]�MWWYI�MR�IZEPYEXMRK�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�MW�[LIXLIV�XLI�XEV�KIXMRK�MW�WYJJMGMIRXP]�JSGYWIH�SR�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�[MXLSYX�YRHYP]�VMWOMRK�XLIPMZIW�SJ�MRRSGIRX��ERH�WSQIXMQIW�RSX�WS�MRRSGIRX �GMZMPMERW��*SV�I\EQTPI�[LIR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�XEVKIXIH�5EIH�7EPMQ�7MRER�%P�,EVIXLM EP5EIHE¬W�XST�QER�MR�=IQIR JSV�EWWEWWMREXMSR�MR�=IQIR��MX�FPI[�YT�XLI�GEVMR�[LMGL�LI�[EW�XVEZIPMRK��OMPPMRK�LMQ�ERH�SXLIV�SGGYTERXW�SJ�XLI�GEV��8LISRP]�VIEP�UYIWXMSR�[EW�[LIXLIV�XLSWI�SGGYTERXW�[IVI�XLIQWIPZIW�ETTVS�TVMEXI�XEVKIXW��7MQMPEVP]��[LIR�-WVEIP�FSQFIH�E�XIVVSVMWX�LIEHUYEVXIVW�MR+EE��XEVKIXMRK�1SLEQQIH�(IMJ��E�PIEHMRK�,EQEW�XIVVSVMWX��XLI�ETTVS�TVMEXI�GVMXMGMWQ MR�[LMGL�-�NSMRIH [EW�XLEX�XLI�EGXMSR�[EW�RSX�WYJJM�GMIRXP]�XEVKIXIH��MR�PMKLX�SJ�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�WIZIVEP�MRRSGIRX�F]WXERHIVW�[IVIOMPPIH�SV�MRNYVIH��1ER]�-WVEIPMW�WLEVIH�Q]�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�XLEX�TEVXMGYPEV�EWWEW�WMREXMSR��ERH�XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]�EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�XLI�MRXIPPMKIRGI�SR[LMGL�XLEX�EGXMSR�[EW�FEWIH�[EW�JPE[IH��;LIR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�XEVKIXIH7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR�ERH�MR�XLI�TVSGIWW�OMPPIH�QER]�GMZMPMERW��XLI�MWWYI�[EW�XLIWEQI�

-�FIPMIZI�XLEX�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�WLSYPH�SRP]�FI�YWIH�EW�E�PEWXVIGSYVWI�[LIR�XLIVI�MW�RS�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�EVVIWX�SV�ETTVILIRH�XLI�QYV�HIVIV��EPXLSYKL�XLMW�MW�RSX�VIUYMVIH�F]�XLI�PE[�SJ�[EV�MJ�XLI�QYVHIVIV�MW�EGSQFEXERX ��[LIR�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�MW�MRZSPZIH�MR�SRKSMRK�QYVHIVSYW�EGXMZM�XMIW��ERH�[LIR�XLI�EWWEWWMREXMSR�GER�FI�HSRI�[MXLSYX�YRHYI�VMWO�XS�MRRS�GIRX�F]WXERHIVW��4VSTSVXMSREPMX]�MW�XLI�OI]�XS�ER]�QMPMXEV]�EGXMSR��ERHXEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�WLSYPH�FI�NYHKIH�YRHIV�XLEX�VYFVMG��9RHIV�ER]�VIE�WSREFPI�WXERHEVH��-WVEIPM�TSPMG]�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSRW�SJ©XMGOMRK�FSQF�XIVVSVMWXWª�HSIW�RSX�HIWIVZI�XLI�OMRH�SJ�GSRHIQREXMSR�MX�MWVIGIMZMRK��IWTIGMEPP]�MR�GSQTEVMWSR�[MXL�SXLIV�REXMSRW�ERH�KVSYTW�[LSWIPIKEP�EGXMSRW�EVI�JEV�PIWW�TVSTSVXMSREXI�XS�XLI�HERKIVW�XLI]�JEGI�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 186: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRXW�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE�EVI�XLI�QENSV�FEVVMIV�XSTIEGI�

8,)�%''97)67

©;L]�MW�MX�WS�LEVH�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX#�8LI�KVIEXIWX�FEVVMIVMW�XLI�-WVEIPM�WIXXPIQIRXW XLIWI�EVI�FSXL�XLI�QSXMZEXMSR�ERH�IRKMRI�SJ�XLI-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVMXSVMIW��8LVII�HIGEHIW�SJ�SFNIG�XMSRW�JVSQ�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�)YVSTI�LEZI�EGLMIZIH�RSXLMRK��8LIVETMH�I\TERWMSR�SJ�-WVEIPM�WIXXPIQIRXW EPP�MPPIKEP LEW�YRHIVQMRIH�4EPIW�XMRMER�EXXIQTXW�EX�REXMSR�FYMPHMRK��-J�XLI]�GSRXMRYI�XS�WTVIEH��XLI]�[MPPIRH�XLI�-WVEIP�XLEX�MXW�JSYRHIVW�IRZMWMSRIH�ª��1EV[ER�&MWLEVE��TVSJIWWSV�SJMRXIVREXMSREP�VIPEXMSRW�EX�XLI�%QIVMGER�9RMZIVWMX]�MR�4EVMW�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�%VEFW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�VIJYWIH�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�FIJSVI�XLIVI�[EW�E�WMR�KPI�WIXXPIQIRX��ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VIJYWIH�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[LIR�)LYH&EVEO�SJJIVIH�XS�IRH�XLI�WIXXPIQIRXW��1SVISZIV��[LIR�)K]TX�SJJIVIH�XSQEOI�TIEGI��XLI�7MREM�WIXXPIQIRXW�[IVI�RSX�E�FEVVMIV��XLI]�[IVI�MQQIHM�EXIP]�YTVSSXIH��%PXLSYKL�-�EQ�TIVWSREPP]�STTSWIH�XS�XLI�WIXXPIQIRXW��-�HS

���

-W�7IXXPIQIRX�MR�XLI�;IWX&ERO�ERH�+EE�E�1ENSV&EVVMIV�XS�4IEGI#

��

Page 187: The Case For Israel

RSX�FIPMIZI�XLEX�XLI]�EVI�XLI�VIEP�FEVVMIV�XS�TIEGI��8LI�VIEP�FEVVMIV�LEW�FIIRXLI�YR[MPPMRKRIWW�SJ�QER]�4EPIWXMRMERW��ERH�QER]�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXKVSYTW�ERH�REXMSRW��XS�EGGITX�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MR�ER]�TEVX�SJ4EPIWXMRI��-J�XLIWI�KVSYTW�[SYPH�EGGITX�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��XLI�WIXXPI�QIRXW�[SYPH�FI�YTVSSXIH��[MXL�WSQI�XIVVMXSVMEP�EHNYWXQIRXW �

%�VIGIRX�TSPP�WLS[IH�XLEX�E�PEVKI�RYQFIV�SJ�XLI�WIXXPIVW�XLIQWIPZIW[SYPH�FI�[MPPMRK�XS�EFERHSR�XLIMV�LSQIW�MJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[IVI�XS�EKVIIXS�TIEGI��%RH�4VMQI�1MRMWXIV�%VMIP�7LEVSR�ERRSYRGIH�MR�%TVMP������XLEX-WVEIP�[SYPH�FI�[MPPMRK�XS�QEOI�©TEMRJYP�GSRGIWWMSRWª�VIKEVHMRK�XLI�WIX�XPIQIRXW�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�TIEGI�[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��©-�ORS[�XLEX�[I�[MPPLEZI�XS�TEVX�[MXL�WSQI�SJ�XLIWI�TPEGIW��%W�E�.I[�XLMW�EKSRMIW�QI��&YX�-LEZI�HIGMHIH�XS�QEOI�IZIV]�IJJSVX�XS�VIEGL�E�WIXXPIQIRX�ª�

)ZIR�EJXIV�]IEVW�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�QYVHIVW��EGGSVHMRK�XS�TSPPW�XEOIR�MR�PEXI%TVMP�������XLI�-WVEIPM�TYFPMG�WYTTSVXW�XLI�%QIVMGER��ERH�)YVSTIER�WTSRWSVIH�©VSEH�QETª�[LMGL�VIUYMVIW�-WVEIP�XS�QEOI�WMKRMJMGERX�GSRGIW�WMSRW�ERH�GSRXIQTPEXIW�XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�F]�������

8,)�4633*

*VSQ�E�TYVIP]�PIKEP�ERH�QSVEP�TSMRX�SJ�ZMI[��XLIVI�MW�RS�KSSH�VIEWSR�[L]ERGMIRX�.I[MWL�GMXMIW�PMOI�,IFVSR�WLSYPH�FI�.YHIRVIMR��8LI�.I[W�[LS�[IVIJSVGIH�SYX�SJ�,IFVSR�F]�VIPMKMSYWP]�MRWTMVIH�QEWWEGVIW�ERH�XLIMV�HIWGIR�HERXW�WLSYPH�LEZI�XLI�WEQI�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�SV�GSQTIRWEXMSR�EW�XLI�%VEFVIJYKIIW�EVI�GPEMQMRK��1SVISZIV��XLI�VIXYVR�SJ�E�JI[�XLSYWERH�.I[W�XS,IFVSR�[SYPH�RSX�EJJIGX�XLI�HIQSKVETLMGW�SJ�XLEX�%VEF�GSRXVSPPIH�EVIE�[LIVIEW�XLI�VIXYVR�XS�-WVEIP�SJ�XLI�QMPPMSRW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�GPEMQVIJYKII�WXEXYW�[SYPH�UYMGOP]�XYVR�-WVEIP�MRXS�E�XLMVH�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�

2IZIVXLIPIWW��JSV�TVEKQEXMG�VIEWSRW��XLIWI�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ,IFVSR�ERH�SXLIV�.I[MWL�EVIEW�MR�XLI�FMFPMGEP�TVSZMRGIW�SJ�.YHIE�ERH7EQEVME�WLSYPH�FI�HIRMIH�XLIMV�VMKLX�XS�VIXYVR�MR�XLI�MRXIVIWXW�SJ�TIEGI�ERHGSQTVSQMWI��%�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�TVIWYTTSWIW�SRI�WXEXI�[MXL�E�TVIHSQM�RERXP]�.I[MWL�GLEVEGXIV�ERH�TSTYPEXMSR�ERH�ERSXLIV�WXEXI�[MXL�E�TVIHSQ�MRERXP]�4EPIWXMRMER�GLEVEGXIV�ERH�TSTYPEXMSR��-R�ER�MHIEP�[SVPH��.I[WWLSYPH�FI�EFPI�XS�PMZI�EW�E�QMRSVMX]�MR�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��NYWX�EW�4EPIWXMRM�ERW�LEZI�PMZIH�EW�E�QMRSVMX]�MR�-WVEIP�WMRGI�MXW�IWXEFPMWLQIRX��8LI�[SVPH�[IPMZI�MR�MW��LS[IZIV��JEV�JVSQ�MHIEP��ERH�MJ�XLI�TVMGI�SJ�TIEGI�MW�E�.YHIRVIMR4EPIWXMRI��EPSRK�[MXL�E�.YHIRVIMR�.SVHER ��MX�MW�E�TVMGI�[SVXL�TE]MRK FYXMX�MW�E�TVMGI��ERH�XLI�[SVPH�WLSYPH�VIGSKRMI�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�[MPPMRK�XS�TE]�MXJSV�TIEGI�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 188: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP¬W�TSPMG]�SJ�EKKVIWWMZI�VIXEPMEXMSR�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ MRGPYHMRK�EWWEW�WMREXMSR��LSQI�HIWXVYGXMSR��FSQFMRKW�XLEX�OMPP�GMZMPMERW��ERH�VISGGYT]MRK

4EPIWXMRMER�GMXMIW�ERH�VIJYKII�GEQTW TVSQSXIW�E�G]GPI�SJ�ZMSPIRGI�

8,)�%''97)67

©;LEX�-WVEIP�MW�HSMRK�MW�MRGVIEWMRK�XLI�EQSYRX�SJ�LEXVIH�XS[EVH�-WVEIPMW��ERH

QEOMRK�MX�QYGL�IEWMIV�JSV�GMZMPMERW�XS�FI�VIGVYMXIH�EW�QMPMXERXW�[LS�[SYPH[MPPMRKP]�KMZI�XLIMV�PMZIW�XS�GEYWI�WSQI�WSVX�SJ�HEQEKI�XS�-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�MRRS�GIRX�.I[W�[LS�VITVIWIRX�MX�ª��%WL�4YPGMJIV��GSPYQRMWX��=IPPS[XMQIW�SVK�

8,)�6)%0-8=

;LMPI�VIEWSREFPI�TISTPI�QMKLX�HMWEKVII�EFSYX�XLI�IJJIGXMZIRIWW�SJ�EWTIGXWSJ�-WVEIPM�GSYRXIVXIVVSVMWQ�XEGXMGW��XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQGPIEVP]�WLS[W�XLEX�XIVVSVMWQ�MRGVIEWIW�[LIRIZIV�-WVEIP�SJJIVW�TIEGI�SV�MWMRZSPZIH�MR�ER�IPIGXMSR�MR�[LMGL�E�HSZMWL�GERHMHEXI�MW�VYRRMRK��8IVVSVMWQLEW�FIIR�YWIH�EW�E�HIPMFIVEXI�XEGXMG�XS�HIVEMP�ER]�QSZIQIRX�XS[EVH�TIEGI

ERH�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��*SV�I\EQTPI��SR�XLI�ZIV]�HE]�1ELQSYH�%FFEW[EW�W[SVR�MR�EW�XLI�4VMQI�1MRMWXIV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��ERH�NYWXLSYVW�FIJSVI�XLI�TIEGI�VSEHQET�[EW�XS�FI�YRZIMPIH��E�4EPIWXMRMER�WYMGMHI

���

-W�8IVVSVMWQ�1IVIP]�4EVXSJE�']GPI�SJ:MSPIRGI#

��

Page 189: The Case For Israel

FSQFIV�WIX�SJJ�E�HIEHP]�I\TPSWMSR�EX�E�GEJr�RIEV�XLI�9�7��IQFEWW]�MR�8IP%ZMZ��6EHMGEP�4EPIWXMRMER�KVSYTW�XSSO�GVIHMX�JSV�XLI�QYVHIVW�ERH�WEMH�XLEXXLI]�[SYPH�GSRXMRYI�[MXL�XLIMV�XIVVSVMWQ�MR�SVHIV�XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�TIEGI

TPER��[LMGL�GSRXIQTPEXIW�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR��JVSQ�WYGGIIHMRK��%W�XLI2I[�=SVO�8MQIWIHMXSVMEPMIH�

-X�[EW�LEVHP]�E�GSMRGMHIRGI�XLEX�XLI�I\TPSWMSR�GEQI�NYWX�EJXIV�XLI�RI[

4EPIWXMRMER�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�HIPMZIVIH�ER�MREYKYVEP�WTIIGL�HIGV]MRK�XIV�

VSVMWQ��8LI�I\XVIQMWXW�FILMRH�XLI�8IP�%ZMZ�EXXEGO�[IVI�YRHSYFXIHP]�EMQ�

MRK�XLIMV�ZMSPIRGI�EX�XLIMV�S[R�PIEHIVWLMT�EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�-WVEIPMW��8LI]

GERRSX�FI�EPPS[IH�XS�WYGGIIH��8LIVI�[MPP�FI�IRSVQSYW�SFWXEGPIW�XS

TIEGI��%PP�XLSWI�MRZSPZIH -WVEIPMW��4EPIWXMRMERW��%QIVMGERW�ERH�)YVS�

TIERW QYWX�FI�TVITEVIH�XS�WLS[�HIXIVQMREXMSR��GSYVEKI��ERH�IRIVK]�

8LI�XIVVMFPI�EXXEGO�]IWXIVHE]�[MPP�FI�SRP]�XLI�JMVWX�XIWX��

8LIVI�MW�RSXLMRK�-WVEIP�GER�HS�XS�WXST�XIVVSVMWQ�SXLIV�XLER�XEOMRKEGXMSRW�XS�TVIZIRX�HIXIVQMRIH�XIVVSVMWXW�JVSQ�WYGGIIHMRK��%�G]GPI�SJ�ZMS�PIRGI�TVIWYTTSWIW�XLEX�SRI�WMHI�GER�ZSPYRXEVMP]�WXST�XLI�G]GPI�MJ�MX�WMQTP]HSIW�RSX�VIWTSRH�XS�XLI�SXLIV�WMHI¬W�ZMSPIRGI��)\TIVMIRGI�WLS[W�XLEX�[LIR-WVEIP�HMH�RSX�VIWTSRH�JMVQP]�XS�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ��QSVI�XIVVSVMWQ�JSPPS[IH��ERH�[LIR�-WVEIP�XSSO�ETTVSTVMEXI�QMPMXEV]�WXITW��XLI�RYQFIV�ERH

WIZIVMX]�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�[IVI�VIHYGIH�

8,)�4633*

8LI�EWWYQTXMSR�YRHIVP]MRK�XLI�G]GPI�SJ�ZMSPIRGI�EVKYQIRX�MW�XLEX�XIVVSV�

MWQ�MW�ER�IQSXMSREPP]�QSXMZEXIH�EGX�SJ�VIZIRKI�IRKEKIH�MR�F]�JVYWXVEXIHMRHMZMHYEPW�[LS�LEZI�RS�SXLIV�VIGSYVWI��8LI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX-WVEIP�YRHIVGYXW�XLMW�EWWYQTXMSR�ERH�TVSZIW�XLEX�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�MW�EVEXMSREP�XEGXMG�WIPIGXIH�F]�PIEHIVW�FIGEYWI�MX�LEW�TVSZIR�IJJIGXMZI�

-X�QE]�FI�IEWMIV�XS�VIGVYMXWYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�JVSQ�E�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�JVYW�XVEXIH�MRHMZMHYEPW�WIIOMRK�VIZIRKI��FYX�MRHMZMHYEP�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�ERH

SXLIV�XIVVSVMWXW�HS�RSX�WIRH�XLIQWIPZIW�SR�QMWWMSRW�SJ�HIEXL��8LI]�EVIWIRX�F]�IPMXI�PIEHIVW�[LS�EVI�QEOMRK�E�VEXMSREP�GEPGYPEXMSR�FEWIH�SR�GSWXWERH�FIRIJMXW��8LI�GSWXW�EVI�UYMXI�PS[��WMRGI�XLI�VEHMGEP�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTWFIRIJMX�JVSQ�IZIV]�HIEXL�SJ�FSXL�-WVEIPMW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERWEVI�XVIEXIH�EW�QEVX]VW�ERH�XLIMV�JEQMPMIW�EVI�LSRSVIH�ERH�TEMH�LERHWSQIP]�

3RI�SJ�XLI�KSEPW�SJ�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW�MW�XS�TVSZSOI�ER�SZIVVIEGXMSR�F]�XLI

-WVEIPMW�WS�EW�XS�KIRIVEXI�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�XIVVSVMWXW¬�GEYWI��8LMW�[EW�GIVXEMRP]XLI�QSXMZEXMRK�GSRWMHIVEXMSR�MR�XLI�[IPP�TPERRIH�IWGEPEXMSR�SJ�WYMGMHIFSQFMRK�JSPPS[MRK�%VEJEX¬W�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLI�&EVEO§'PMRXSR�SJJIVW�EX�'EQT(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�MR�����§������8LI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��[LMGL�[EW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 190: The Case For Israel

XYVRMRK�EKEMRWX�%VEJEX�JSV�VINIGXMRK�XLIWI�VIEWSREFPI�SJJIVW��UYMGOP]�XYVRIHEKEMRWX�-WVEIP�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�-WVEIPM�VIWTSRWI�XS�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�

%RSXLIV�KSEP TEVXMGYPEVP]�SJ�XLI�VEHMGEP�VINIGXMSRMWXW�PMOI�,EQEW MW�XS

HVMZI�XLI�-WVEIPM�IPIGXSVEXI�XS�XLI�VMKLX�WS�EW�XS�VIHYGI�XLI�TVSWTIGXW�JSV�ERIKSXMEXIH�TIEGI�XLEX�[SYPH�PIEZI�-WVEIP�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��8LMW�[EW�GIV�XEMRP]�ER�MQTSVXERX�IJJIGX�SJ�XLI�IWGEPEXIH�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW��[LMGLLIPTIH�EWWYVI�XLI�IPIGXMSR�SJ�7LEVSR��QYGL�XS�XLI�WEXMWJEGXMSR�SJ�,EQEWERH�SXLIVW�[LS�VINIGX�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�

%�XLMVH�KSEP�MW�XS�OMPP�EW�QER]�-WVEIPMW�EW�TSWWMFPI�ERH�XS�XV]�XS�JVMKLXIR

-WVEIP�MRXS�WYFQMWWMSR��%�JSYVXL�KSEP�MW�XS�WEXMWJ]�XLI�%VEF�WXVIIX��[LMGL�LEWXSS�SJXIR�FIIR�XEYKLX�MR�XLI�GPEWWVSSQW��MR�XLI�QSWUYIW��ERH�MR�XLI�QIHMEXLEX�XLI�WTMPPMRK�SJ�.I[MWL�FPSSH�MW�ER�SFPMKEXMSR��3RP]�XLI�JMVWX�SJ�XLIWIKSEPW�QMKLX�FI�MRJPYIRGIH�F]�QSVI�QSHIVEXI�-WVEIPM�VIWTSRWIW��FYX�EX�ELMKL�TVMGI��-WVEIP�WLSYPH�FI�QSHIVEXI�ERH�TVSTSVXMSREXI�MR�MXW�VIWTSRWI�XSXIVVSVMWQ�FIGEYWI�XLEX�MW�XLI�VMKLX�XLMRK�XS�HS��&YX�XS�FIPMIZI�XLEX�-WVEIPM

QSHIVEXMSR�[SYPH�WMKRMJMGERXP]�VIHYGI�XIVVSVMWQ�MW�XS�JEPWIP]�EWWYQI�XLEXXIVVSVMWQ�MW�TEVX�SJ�E�G]GPI�SJ�ZMSPIRGI�VEXLIV�XLER�E�XEGXMG�SJ�JMVWX�GLSMGIXLEX�LEW�[SVOIH�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 191: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP�MW�©XLI�TVMQI�I\EQTPI�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXSVW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�ª�

8,)�%''97)67

©8LI�;SVPH�'SRJIVIRGI�%KEMRWX�6EGMWQ�[EW�TVIGIHIH�F]�JSYV�6IKMSREP'SRJIVIRGIW�[LSWI�XEWO�MX�[EW�XS�HVEJX�E�GSQTSWMXI�(IGPEVEXMSR�EKEMRWX6EGMWQ�ERH�E�4PER�SJ�%GXMSR��-WVEIP�[EW�I\GPYHIH�JVSQ�XLI�PEWX�SJ�XLIVIKMSREP�GSRJIVIRGIW�MR�8ILIVER��[LMGL�MWWYIH�XLI�QSWX�WGYVVMPSYW�MRHMGX�QIRX�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�WMRGI�XLI�7IGSRH�;SVPH�;EV��8LIVI�[IVI�WIZIR�GSQ�TSRIRXW�XS�XLI�«MRHMGXQIRX¬�

�3GGYTEXMSR�MW�E�GVMQI�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]��E�RI[�JSVQ�SJ�%TEVXLIMH��EXLVIEX�XS�MRXIVREXMSREP�TIEGI�ERH�WIGYVMX]�

�-WVEIP�MW�MR�IWWIRGI�ER�%TEVXLIMH�7XEXI�

�-WVEIP�MW�E�QIXE§,YQER�6MKLXW�ZMSPEXSV��MR�E�[SVPH�MR�[LMGL�LYQERVMKLXW�GSRWXMXYXIW�E�RI[�WIGYPEV�VIPMKMSR��-WVEIP�FIGSQIW�XLI�RI[«%RXM�'LVMWX¬�SJ�SYV�XMQI �

�-WVEIP�MW�XLI�TIVTIXVEXSV�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�GVMQIW [EV�GVMQIW��GVMQIWEKEMRWX�LYQERMX]��KIRSGMHI LIRGI�XLI�VMKLX�XS�«EVQIH�WXVYKKPI¬ERH�«VIWMWXERGI¬�EKEMRWX�XLMW�«GVMQMREP¬�WXEXI�

�-WVEIP��EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI �MW�ER�«SVMKMREP�WMR¬�IWXEFPMWLIH�XLVSYKL«IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK¬�SJ�1ERHEXSV]�%VEF�4EPIWXMRI�

���

-W�-WVEIP�XLI�4VMQI,YQER�6MKLXW�:MSPEXSVMR�XLI�;SVPH#

��

Page 192: The Case For Israel

�8LI�VIJIVIRGI�XS�«LSPSGEYWXW¬�MW��MR�XLI�TPYVEP�ERH�MR�PS[IVGEWI��[MXL-WVEIP�ER�I\EQTPI�SJ�E�«LSPSGEYWX¬�EKEMRWX�%VEFW�

�>MSRMWQ�MW�HIGPEVIH�XS�FI�RSX�SRP]�E�JSVQ�SJ�6EGMWQ��FYX�>MSRMWQMXWIPJ�[EW�HIGPEVIH�XS�FI�«ERXMWIQMXMG�¬ª��4VSJIWWSV�-V[MR�'SXPIV�HIWGVMFMRK�XLI�EGGYWEXMSRW�

©)ZIV]�HE]�SJ�XLI�92�'SQQMWWMSR�SR�,YQER�6MKLXW¬�WM\�[IIO�WIW�WMSR��[LMGL�LEW�RS[�JMRMWLIH�MXW�WIGSRH�[IIO��FIKMRW�[MXL�E�ZMSPEXMSR�SJXLI�92�'LEVXIV¬W�QSWX�FEWMG�TVMRGMTPI�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�VIPEXMSRW��«XLIIUYEPMX]�SJ�EPP�REXMSRW�PEVKI�ERH�WQEPP�¬�3RI�92�QIQFIV�MW�PIJX�WXERHMRK�MRXLI�LEPPW�IZIV]�QSVRMRK�JVSQ���XS����E�Q��[LMPI�EPP�SXLIV�92�QIQFIVWERH�SFWIVZIVW��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX] �QIIX�MR�TVMZEXI�WXVEXIKMGERH�MRJSVQEXMSR�WLEVMRK�WIWWMSRW�MR�IEGL�SJ�XLI�JMZI�92�VIKMSREP�KVSYTW�8LEX�GSYRXV]�MW�-WVEIP��8LMW�MW�ETEVXLIMH�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW§WX]PI��������%W�JSV�XLIWYFWXERXMZI�EWWEYPX�SR�-WVEIP��[LMGL�XLMW�]IEV�FIKER�8LYVWHE]��XLI�'SQ�QMWWMSR�VIGSVH�SZIV����]IEVW�WTIEOW�JSV�MXWIPJ�

�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�XLI�SRP]�WXEXI�WYFNIGX�XS�ER�IRXMVI�EKIRHE�MXIQ�IZIV]]IEV�

�8LI�'SQQMWWMSR�SR�,YQER�6MKLXW�LEW�WTIRX�QSVI�XMQI�SR�-WVEIPXLER�ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]�

�;LMPI����TIVGIRX�SJ�MXW�XSXEP�WYFWXERXMZI�QIIXMRK�LEW�FIIR�SR�-WVEIPEPSRI�����TIVGIRX�SJ�MXW�XMQI�LEW�FIIR�WTIRX�SR�EPP�SXLIV�92�WXEXIWGSQFMRIH�

����TIVGIRX�SJ�MXW�GSYRXV]�WTIGMJMG�VIWSPYXMSRW�GVMXMGEP�SJ�E�WXEXI�LEZIFIIR�SR�-WVEIP�EPSRI�

©8LI�VIEP�HSYFPI�WXERHEVHW#�2S�VIWSPYXMSR�MR�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�GSQ�QMWWMSR�LEW�IZIV�FIIR�TEWWIH�SR�WXEXIW�WYGL�EW�7]VME��'LMRE��7EYHM�%VEFMESV�>MQFEF[I�

©8LI�JEYPX�MW�RSX�XLEX�SJ�XLI�ZMGXMQW��[LS�SZIV�XLI�]IEVW�LEZI�GSQ�TPEMRIH�XS�XLI�92�F]�XLI�XLSYWERHW�EFSYX�KVSWW�ERH�W]WXIQEXMG�LYQERVMKLXW�EFYWIW�MR�GSYRXVMIW�WYGL�EW�&ELVEMR��'LEH��0MFIVME��1EPE[M��1EPM�4EOMWXER��7EYHM�%VEFME��7]VME��9RMXIH�%VEF�)QMVEXIW��=IQIR�ERH�>MQ�FEF[I��&YX�IZIV]�]IEV��XLI�GSQQMWWMSR�LSPHW�GPSWIH�HSSV�QIIXMRKW XLIJMVWX�SRI�LIPH�*VMHE] MR�[LMGL�MX�FYVMIW�XLIWI�GSQTPEMRXW�ERH�VIJYWIW�XSWYFNIGX�WYGL�WXEXIW�XS�XLI�TYFPMG�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�VIWSPYXMSRW�

©'SQQMWWMSR�HIFEXIW�SR�XLI�-WVEIP�EKIRHE�MXIQ�I\TPEMR�E�PSX��3R8LYVWHE]��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�VITVIWIRXEXMZI��2EFMP�6EQPE[M��[LSQ�XLI0MF]ER�GLEMV�GEPPW�«,MW�)\GIPPIRG]��XLI�HMWXMRKYMWLIH�%QFEWWEHSV�SJ�4EPIW�XMRI¬ ��WEMH�

«8LI�[SVPH�GSRHIQRIH�XLI�SPH�2EMWQ�MR�XLI�TEWX�������HYVMRK�XLI�7IG�SRH�;SVPH�;EV��������8LI�[SVPH�EPWS�GSRHIQRIH�>MSRMWX�-WVEIP�JSV�XLI�WEQI

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 193: The Case For Israel

GVMQMREP�GVMQIW�MX�LEW�FIIR�TIVTIXVEXMRK�EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI������JSV�SZIV����]IEVW�RS[��WXEVXMRK�������MR�������������?8ALI�[SVPH�������LEW�RSX]IX�IPMQMREXIH�XLI�2I[�>MSRMWX�2EMWQ�ERH�©-WVEIP�[EW�GVIEXIH�XLVSYKLGVMQIW�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]�MX�TIVTIXVEXIH�ERH�[LMGL�GSRXMRYI�XSHE]�ª¬ª�%RRI�&E]IJWO]��HIWGVMFMRK�XLI�EGGYWEXMSRW�

8,)�6)%0-8=

-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�REXMSR�MR�XLI�1MHIEWX�XLEX�STIVEXIW�YRHIV�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�-XW�VIGSVH�SR�LYQER�VMKLXW�GSQTEVIW�JEZSVEFP]�XS�XLEX�SJ�ER]�GSYRXV]�MRXLI�[SVPH�XLEX�LEW�JEGIH�GSQTEVEFPI�HERKIVW��-XW�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�MW�EQSRKXLI�FIWX�MR�XLI�[SVPH��ERH�MX�LEW�VITIEXIHP]�SZIVVYPIH�XLI�EVQ]�ERH�XLIKSZIVRQIRX�ERH�QEHI�XLIQ�STIVEXI�YRHIV�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��-WVEIP�LEWEQSRK�XLI�FIWX�VIGSVHW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XLI�VMKLXW�SJ�[SQIR�KE]W��XLI�TL]WMGEPP]�ERH�QIRXEPP]�GLEPPIRKIH��ERH�WS�SR��-X�EPWS�LEW�JVII�HSQ�SJ�WTIIGL��TVIWW��HMWWIRX��EWWSGMEXMSR��ERH�VIPMKMSR�

8LI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��WLS[W�RS�VIWTIGX�JSVLYQER�VMKLXW��-X�XSVXYVIW�ERH�OMPPW�EPPIKIH�GSPPEFSVEXSVW�[MXLSYX�IZIR�EWIQFPERGI�SJ�HYI�TVSGIWW��-X�XSPIVEXIW�PMXXPI�HMWWIRX�ERH�MX�MW�MRXSPIVERX�SJEPXIVREXMZI�PMJIWX]PIW��4EPIWXMRMER�TVSTEKERHMWXW�MRZSOI�©LYQER�VMKLXWªQIVIP]�EW�E�XEGXMG�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�

8,)�4633*

*EGIH�[MXL�GSQTEVEFPI�HERKIVW�FSXL�MRXIVREP�ERH�I\XIVREP��RS�REXMSR�MRLMWXSV]�LEW�IZIV�XVMIH�WS�LEVH�XS�VIUYMVI�MXW�QMPMXEV]�XS�STIVEXI�[MXLMR�XLIVYPI�SJ�PE[��8LI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX��F]�EPP�EGGSYRXW�SRI�SJ�XLI�JMRIWX�MRXLI�[SVPH��LEW�TPE]IH�E�JEV�KVIEXIV�VSPI�MR�GSRXVSPPMRK�XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]XLER�ER]�GSYVX�MR�LMWXSV]�LEW�IZIV�TPE]IH�MR�XLI�GSRHYGX�SJ�QMPMXEV]�EJJEMVW�MRGPYHMRK�MR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��%PXLSYKL�SFZMSYWP]�WIRWMXMZI�XS�XLI�RIIHJSV�WIGYVMX]��XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�LEW�VITIEXIHP]�IRNSMRIH�XLI�-WVEIPMKSZIVRQIRX�ERH�MXW�QMPMXEV]�JVSQ�YRHIVXEOMRK�EGXMSRW�MR�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�XLILMKLIWX�WXERHEVHW�SJ�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�

-R�ZMVXYEPP]�IZIV]�SXLIV�HIQSGVEG]��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��XLIGSYVXW�EVI�I\XVIQIP]�PMQMXIH�MR�XLIMV�EFMPMX]�XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�QMPMXEV]�JVSQXEOMRK�[LEXIZIV�EGXMSR�MX�HIIQW�RIGIWWEV]�XS�TVIWIVZI�REXMSREP�WIGYVMX]��%WXLI2I[�=SVO�8MQIWVITSVXIH��©3RI�SJ�XLI�QSWX�YRYWYEP�EWTIGXW�SJ�-WVEIPMPE[�MW�XLI�VETMH�EGGIWW�XLEX�TIXMXMSRIVW��MRGPYHMRK�4EPIWXMRMERW��GER�KEMR�XS-WVEIP¬W�LMKLIWX�GSYVX��-R�%TVMP�������HYVMRK�XLI�JMIVGIWX�JMKLXMRK�SJ�XLIGYVVIRX�GSRJPMGX��MR�XLI�.IRMR�VIJYKII�GEQT�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��XLI�LMKLGSYVX�[EW�VIGIMZMRK�ERH�VYPMRK�SR�TIXMXMSRW�EPQSWX�HEMP]�ª�

4VSJIWWSV�=MXLEO�>EQMV��E�JSVQIV�.YWXMGI�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI'SYVX�[MXL�©E�VITYXEXMSR�EW�E�WXVSRK�EHZSGEXI�SJ�GMZMP�VMKLXW�ª�WEMH�XLEX�LI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 194: The Case For Israel

HMH�RSX�ORS[�SJ�©ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]�[LIVI�GMZMPMER�GSYVXW�LEH�WYGL�FVSEHNYVMWHMGXMSR�XS�VIZMI[�QMPMXEV]�EGXMSRW�ª�)ZIR�6ENM�7SYVERM��XLI�HMVIGXSV�SJXLI�4EPIWXMRMER�'IRXIV�JSV�,YQER�6MKLXW�MR�+EE�ERH�E�WXVMHIRX�GVMXMG�SJ�-WVEIP��WE]W�XLEX�LI�VIQEMRW�©GSRWXERXP]�EQEIH�F]�XLI�LMKL�WXERHEVHW�SJXLI�PIKEP�W]WXIQW�ª�

8LI�QSHIVR�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX��YRHIV�XLI�PIEHIVWLMT�SJ�MXW�TVIWM�HIRX��4VSJIWWSV�%LEVSR�&EVEO��LEW�XEOIR�ER�EGXMZMWX�VSPI�MR�WXVMOMRK�XLIETTVSTVMEXI�FEPERGI�FIX[IIR�WIGYVMX]�ERH�PMFIVX]��-X�LEW�TVSXIGXIH�XLIVMKLXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW��RSRGSQFEXERXW��TVMWSRIVW�SJ�[EV��ERH�SXLIVW��SJXIREX�GSRWMHIVEFPI�VMWO�XS�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�ERH�WSPHMIVW�

8LI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�LEW�FIIR�XLI�SRP]�LMKL�GSYVX�XS�HMVIGXP]XEOI�SR�XLI�MWWYI�SJ�ETTP]MRK�TL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVI��RSRPIXLEP�XSVXYVI �XS�GET�XYVIH�XIVVSVMWXW�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�WIGYVI�MRJSVQEXMSR�RIGIWWEV]�XS�TVIZIRXSRKSMRK�XIVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW��2SX[MXLWXERHMRK�MXW�VIGSKRMXMSR�XLEX�WYGLI\XVIQI�QIEWYVIW�QE]�EX�WYGL�XMQIW�WEZI�PMZIW��MX�LEW�TVSLMFMXIH�XLIMV�YWI�XLIVIF]�EGORS[PIHKMRK�XLEX�-WVEIP�QYWX�JMKLX�XLI�[EV�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ©[MXL�SRI�LERH�XMIH�FILMRH�MXW�FEGO�ª�FIGEYWI�XLEX�MW�[LEX�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[VIUYMVIW��-X�LEW�TVSLMFMXIH�XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]�JVSQ�EXXEGOMRK�EQFYPERGIW�HIWTMXI�MXW�VIGSKRMXMSR�XLEX�EQFYPERGIW�EVI�SJXIR�YWIH�XS�XVERWTSVX�I\TPS�WMZIW�ERH�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW��

;IWII�JMX�XS�IQTLEWMI�XLEX�SYV�GSQFEX�JSVGIW�EVI�SFPMKIH�XS�EFMHI�F]�XLI

LYQERMXEVMER�VYPIW�VIKEVHMRK�GEVI�JSV�XLI�[SYRHIH��XLI�MPP��ERH�XLI�FSHMIW

SJ�XLI�HIGIEWIH��8LI�EFYWI�GSQQMXXIH�F]�?4EPIWXMRMERA�QIHMGEP�TIVWSRRIP

MR�LSWTMXEPW�ERH�MR�EQFYPERGIW�SFPMKIW�XLI�-�(�*��XS�EGX�MR�SVHIV�XS�EZSMH

WYGL�EGXMZMXMIW��FYX�HSIW�RSX��MR�ERH�SJ�MXWIPJ��QEOI�W[IITMRK�FVIEGL�SJ

LYQERMXEVMER�VYPIW�TIVQMWWMFPI��%RH�MRHIIH��XLMW�MW�XLI�HIGPEVIH�TSWMXMSR�SJ

XLI�7XEXI��8LMW�TSWMXMSR�MW�ETTVSTVMEXI�RSX�SRP]�EW�JEV�EW�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[�

SR�[LMGL�XLI�4IXMXMSRIVW�FEWIH�XLIMV�EVKYQIRX��MW�GSRGIVRIH��FYX�EPWS�MR

PMKLX�SJ�XLI�ZEPYIW�SJ�XLI�7XEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�EW�E�.I[MWL�ERH�HIQSGVEXMG�WXEXI�

8LI�-�(�*��WLEPP�SRGI�EKEMR�VIQMRH�XLI�GSQFEX�JSVGIW��HS[R�XS�XLI

PIZIP�SJ�XLI�WMRKPI�WSPHMIV�MR�XLI�JMIPH��SJ�XLMW�GSQQMXQIRX�SJ�SYV�JSVGIW�

FEWIH�SR�PE[�ERH�QSVEPMX] ERH�EGGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�7XEXI��IZIR�SR�YXMPMX]

XLVSYKL�GSRGVIXI�MRWXVYGXMSRW�[LMGL�[MPP�TVIZIRX��XS�XLI�I\XIRX�TSWWMFPI�

ERH�IZIR�MR�WIZIVI�WMXYEXMSRW��EGXMZMXMIW�[LMGL�EVI�RSX�MR�PMRI�[MXL�XLI�VYPIW

SJ�LYQERMXEVMER�EMH��

*SPPS[MRK�XLEX�HIGMWMSR��4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�GSRXMRYIH�XS�YWI�EQFY�PERGIW��8LI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�SR�1E]�����������VITSVXIH�E�GEWI�MR�[LMGL©E�[SYPH�FI�FSQFIV�LMH�XLVII�XMQIW�MR�ER�EQFYPERGI�MR�E�FMH�XS�KIX�TEWX-WVEIPM�XVSSTW��������,I�XLIR�NSMRIH�JSVGIW�[MXL�E����]IEV�SPH�[SQER��EQSXLIV�SJ�XLVII��[LS�WXVETTIH�E�FSQF�XS�LIV�GLIWX�ERH�EGGSQTERMIH�LMQSR�E�XE\M�VMHI�ª

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 195: The Case For Israel

8LI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�LEW�TVSLMFMXIH�-WVEIP�JVSQ�LSPHMRK�TVMWSR�IVW�EW�©FEVKEMRMRK�GLMTWª�JSV�XLI�I\GLERKI�SJ�TVMWSRIVW�MPPIKEPP]�FIMRK�LIPHF]�MXW�IRIQMIW��

3R�7ITXIQFIV����������XLI�GSYVX�HIGMHIH�E�GEWI�MR�[LMGL�XLI�-WVEIPMQMPMXEV]�SVHIVIH�XLI�I\TYPWMSR�SJ�XLI�WMWXIV�ERH�FVSXLIV�SJ�E�XIVVSVMWX�[LSLEH�SVKERMIH�WIZIVEP�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW��8LI]�[IVI�I\TIPPIH�JVSQ�XLI;IWX�&ERO�JSV�E�TIVMSH�SJ�X[S�]IEVW�ERH�QSZIH�XS�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�SR�XLIFEWMW�SJ�E�JMRHMRK�XLEX�XLI�WMWXIV�LEH�WI[R�I\TPSWMZI�FIPXW�ERH�XLI�FVSXLIVWIVZIH�EW�E�©PSSO�SYX�[LIR�LMW�FVSXLIV�ERH�QIQFIVW�SJ�LMW�KVSYT�QSZIHX[S�I\TPSWMZI�GLEVKIW�JVSQ�SRI�TPEGI�XS�ERSXLIV�ª��8LI�GSYVX�VYPIH�XLEXXLI�I\TYPWMSR�SVHIV��[LMGL�GSRWXMXYXIH�E�XIQTSVEV]�©EWWMKRQIRX�SJ�VIWM�HIRGIª�[MXLMR�XLI�SGGYTMIH�XIVVMXSVMIW�VEXLIV�XLER�E�XVERWJIV�SYX�SJ�XLI�XIV�VMXSVMIW��[EW�ZEPMH�SRP]�MJ�©XLI�TIVWSR�LMQWIPJ�?[LS�MW�FIMRK�I\TIPPIHATVIWIRXW�E�VIEP�HERKIVª�

3RI�GERRSX�EWWMKR�XLI�VIWMHIRGI�SJ�ER�MRRSGIRX�VIPEXMZI�[LS�HSIW�RSX

TVIWIRX�E�HERKIV��IZIR�MJ�MX�MW�TVSZIH�XLEX�EWWMKRMRK�LMW�VIWMHIRGI�QE]

HIXIV�SXLIVW�JVSQ�GEVV]MRK�SYX�XIVVSVMWXW�EGXW��3RI�GERRSX�EWWMKR�XLI�VIW�

MHIRGI�SJ�WSQISRI�[LS�RS�PSRKIV�TVIWIRXW�E�HERKIV��%WWMKRMRK�WSQI�

SRI¬W�TPEGI�SJ�VIWMHIRGI�QE]�FI�HSRI�SRP]�SR�XLI�FEWMW�SJ�GPIEV�ERH

GSRZMRGMRK�EHQMRMWXVEXMZI�IZMHIRGI��-X�QYWX�FI�TVSTSVXMSREXI���

-R�E�GSQTERMSR�GEWI��XLI�GSYVX�VIZIVWIH�XLI�I\TYPWMSR�SVHIV�

-X�[EW�LS[IZIV�HIGMHIH�XLEX�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�XLI�TIXMXMSRIV�%FIH�%PREWWIV

1YWXEJE�%LQIH�%WMHE XLI�FVSXLIV�SJ�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�2EWWIV�%�(MR

%WMHE XLI�QIEWYVI�SJ�EWWMKRIH�VIWMHIRGI�GSYPH�RSX�FI�EHSTXIH��8LI�VIE�

WSR�JSV�XLMW�[EW�XLEX�IZIR�XLSYKL�MX�[EW�TVSZIH�XLEX�XLMW�TIXMXMSRIV�ORI[

SJ�XLI�HIIHW�SJ�LMW�XIVVSVMWX�FVSXLIV��LMW�MRZSPZIQIRX�EQSYRXIH�QIVIP]�XS

PIRHMRK�LMW�FVSXLIV�E�GEV�ERH�KMZMRK�LMQ�GPIER�GPSXLIW�ERH�JSSH�EX�LMW

LSQI��ERH�RS�GSRRIGXMSR�LEH�FIIR�IWXEFPMWLIH�FIX[IIR�XLI�TIXMXMSRIV¬W

EGXW�ERH�XLI�XIVVSVMWX�EGXMZMX]�SJ�XLI�FVSXLIV��-X�[EW�XLIVIJSVI�LIPH�XLEX

XLIVI�[EW�ER�MREHIUYEXI�FEWMW�JSV�HIXIVQMRMRK�XLI�TIXMXMSRIV�XS�FI�WYJJM�

GMIRXP]�HERKIVSYW�JSV�LMW�VIWMHIRGI�XS�FI�EWWMKRIH���

-R�MXW�GSRGPYWMSR��XLI�GSYVX�QEHI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�SFWIVZEXMSR�

8LI�7XEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�YRHIVKSMRK�E�HMJJMGYPX�TIVMSH��8IVVSV�MW�LYVXMRK�MXW

VIWMHIRXW��,YQER�PMJI�MW�XVEQTPIH�YTSR��,YRHVIHW�LEZI�FIIR�OMPPIH�

8LSYWERHW�LEZI�FIIR�MRNYVIH��8LI�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSR�MR�.YHEIE�ERH

7EQEVME�ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�MW�EPWS�WYJJIVMRK�YRFIEVEFP]��%PP�SJ�XLMW�MW

FIGEYWI�SJ�EGXW�SJ�QYVHIV��OMPPMRK�ERH�HIWXVYGXMSR�TIVTIXVEXIH�F]�XIVVSV�

MWXW��������8LI�7XEXI�MW�HSMRK�EPP�XLEX�MX�GER�MR�SVHIV�XS�TVSXIGX�MXW�GMXMIRW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 196: The Case For Israel

ERH�IRWYVI�XLI�WIGYVMX]�SJ�XLI�VIKMSR��8LIWI�QIEWYVIW�EVI�PMQMXIH��8LI

VIWXVMGXMSRW�EVI��JMVWX�ERH�JSVIQSWX��QMPMXEV]�STIVEXMSREP�SRIW��-X�MW�HMJJMGYPX

XS�JMKLX�EKEMRWX�TIVWSRW�[LS�EVI�TVITEVIH�XS�XYVR�XLIQWIPZIW�MRXS�PMZMRK

FSQFW��8LIWI�VIWXVMGXMSRW�EVI�EPWS�RSVQEXMZI��8LI�7XEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�E�

JVIIHSQ�WIIOMRK�HIQSGVEG]��-X�MW�E�HIJIRWMZI�HIQSGVEG]�EGXMRK�[MXLMR�XLI

JVEQI[SVO�SJ�MXW�VMKLX�XS�WIPJ�HIJIRGI E�VMKLX�VIGSKRMIH�F]�XLI�GLEVXIV

SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��������?2ASX�IZIV]�IJJIGXMZI�QIEWYVI�MW�EPWS�E�PE[JYP

QIEWYVI��������-RHIIH��XLI�TSWMXMSR�SJ�XLI�7XEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�E�HMJJMGYPX�SRI�

%PWS�SYV�VSPI�EW�NYHKIW�MW�RSX�IEW]��;I�EVI�HSMRK�EPP�[I�GER�XS�FEPERGI

TVSTIVP]�FIX[IIR�LYQER�VMKLXW�ERH�XLI�WIGYVMX]�SJ�XLI�EVIE��-R�XLMW�FEP�

ERGI��LYQER�VMKLXW�GERRSX�VIGIMZI�GSQTPIXI�TVSXIGXMSR��EW�MJ�XLIVI�[IVI

RS�XIVVSV��ERH�7XEXI�WIGYVMX]�GERRSX�VIGIMZI�GSQTPIXI�TVSXIGXMSR��EW�MJ

XLIVI�[IVI�RS�LYQER�VMKLXW��%�HIPMGEXI�ERH�WIRWMXMZI�FEPERGI�MW�VIUYMVIH�

8LMW�MW�XLI�TVMGI�SJ�HIQSGVEG]��-X�MW�I\TIRWMZI��FYX�[SVXL[LMPI��-X

WXVIRKXLIRW�XLI�7XEXI��-X�TVSZMHIW�E�VIEWSR�JSV�MXW�WXVYKKPI���

8LI�IRXMVI�XI\X�SJ�XLMW�HIGMWMSR��[LMGL�MW�EZEMPEFPI�SR�XLI�;IF���WLSYPHFI�VIUYMVIH�VIEHMRK�JSV�XLSWI�[LS�GPEMQ�XLEX�-WVEIP�HSIW�RSX�GSQTP]�[MXLXLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�

-X�MW�JEMV�XS�WE]�XLEX�EPXLSYKL�-WVEIPM�EGXMSRW�MR�GSQFEXMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�LEZIFIIR�JEV�JVSQ�TIVJIGX��-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�MR�KVIEXIV�GSQTPMERGI�[MXL�XLI�VYPISJ�PE[�XLER�ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]�JEGMRK�GSQTEVEFPI�HERKIVW��-R�GSRXVEWX�XS-WVEIP��XLI�)K]TXMERW��XLI�.SVHERMERW��ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�VSYXMRIP]�XSVXYVIWYWTIGXW�ERH�HS�RSX�PMQMX�XLIMV�XSVXYVI�XS�RSRPIXLEP�ETTPMGEXMSRW��-R������XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�MX�XSVXYVIH�E�WYWTIGXIH�GSP�PEFSVEXSV�MR�SVHIV�XS�KIX�LMQ�XS�MRGVMQMREXI�LMW�EYRX��[LS�[EW�XLIR�WLSX[MXLSYX�ER]�WIQFPERGI�SJ�E�XVMEP���.SVHER�LEW�RSX�SRP]�XSVXYVIH�WYWTIGXIHXIVVSVMWXW�FYX�EPWS�XLIMV�VIPEXMZIW�MR�ER�IJJSVX�XS�PSSWIR�XLI�XSRKYIW�SJ�YRGS�STIVEXMZI�XIVVSVMWXW�

-X�MW�MRXIVIWXMRK�XS�VIGEPP�XLEX�[LIR�XLI�'LMRIWI�KSZIVRQIRX�OMPPIHHIQSRWXVEXSVW�EX�8MERERQIR�7UYEVI�MR�������XLI�JMVWX�TIVWSR�XS�GSRKVEX�YPEXI�.MERK�>IQMR�JSV�TYXXMRK�HS[R�XLI�HIQSRWXVEXMSR�[EW�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�WTIEOMRK�SR�FILEPJ�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI��8LMW�MW�[LEX�LI�[VSXI�

3R�FILEPJ�SJ�XLI�%VEF�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI��XLIMV�PIEHIVWLMT�ERH�Q]WIPJ��

-�������XEOI�XLMW�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�I\TVIWW�I\XVIQI�KVEXMJMGEXMSR�XLEX�]SY�[IVI

EFPI�XS�VIWXSVI�RSVQEP�SVHIV�EJXIV�XLI�VIGIRX�MRGMHIRXW�MR�4ISTPI¬W�'LMRE�

-�[MWL�]SY��GPSWI�JVMIRHW��QSVI�TVSKVIWW�MR�]SYV�IRHIEZSYV�XS�EGLMIZI�XLI

LSTIW��KSEPW��EWTMVEXMSRW��WXEFMPMX]�ERH�WIGYVMX]�SJ�SYV�JVMIRHW��XLI�'LMRIWI

TISTPI���

8LI�WEQI�4EPIWXMRMER�TVSTEKERHMWXW�[LS�WS�PSYHP]�ERH�L]TSGVMXMGEPP]GSQTPEMR�[LIRIZIV�-WVEIP�HIZMEXIW�IZIR�SRI�MSXE�JVSQ�LYQER�VMKLXW�TIV�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 197: The Case For Israel

JIGXMSR�EVI�UYMGO�XS�TVEMWI�ERH�WYTTSVX�IZIV]�X]VERRMGEP�HIWXVS]IV�SJLYQER�VMKLXW��VERKMRK�JVSQ�7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR�XS�1YEQQEV�/LEHEJM�XS*MHIP�'EWXVS�

0MOI�IZIV]�SXLIV�REXMSR��-WVEIP�LEW�QEHI�QMWXEOIW�MR�SZIVVIEGXMRK�XSXIVVSVMWQ�ERH�SXLIV�XLVIEXW�XS�MXW�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR��-X�MW�JEV�JVSQ�TIVJIGX�FYX�E�GSQTEVEXMZI�ERH�GSRXI\XYEP�EWWIWWQIRX�SJ�MXW�EGXMSRW�HIQSRWXVEXIWXLEX�MX�HIWIVZIW�XS�FI�WMRKPIH�SYX�JSV�TVEMWI��RSX�GVMXMGMWQ��JSV�MXW�IJJSVXW�XSGSQFEX�XIVVSVMWQ�[MXLMR�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�ERH�[MXL�WIRWMXMZMX]�XS�XLI�VMKLXWSJ�MRRSGIRX�RSRGSQFEXERXW�

-R�E������WTIIGL��.YWXMGI�;MPPMEQ�&VIRRER��TIVLETW�XLI�QSWX�GMZMPPMFIVXEVMER�NYWXMGI�MR�9�7��7YTVIQI�'SYVX�LMWXSV]��QEHI�XLI�JSPPS[MRKSFWIVZEXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�IJJSVXW�XS�FEPERGI�WIGYVMX]�ERH�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�

-X�QE]�[IPP�FI�-WVEIP��RSX�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��XLEX�TVSZMHIW�XLI�FIWX�LSTI

JSV�FYMPHMRK�E�NYVMWTVYHIRGI�XLEX�GER�TVSXIGX�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�EKEMRWX�XLI

HIQERHW�SJ�REXMSREP�WIGYVMX]��*SV�MX�MW�-WVEIP�XLEX�LEW�FIIR�JEGMRK�VIEP�ERH

WIVMSYW�XLVIEXW�XS�MXW�WIGYVMX]�JSV�XLI�PEWX�JSVX]�]IEVW�ERH�WIIQW�HIWXMRIH�XS

GSRXMRYI�JEGMRK�WYGL�XLVIEXW�MR�XLI�JSVIWIIEFPI�JYXYVI��8LI�WXVYKKPI�XS

IWXEFPMWL�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�EKEMRWX�XLI�FEGOHVST�SJ�XLIWI�WIGYVMX]�XLVIEXW�

[LMPI�HMJJMGYPX��TVSQMWIW�XS�FYMPH�FYP[EVOW�SJ�PMFIVX]�XLEX�GER�IRHYVI�XLI

JIEVW�ERH�JVIR]�SJ�WYHHIR�HERKIV FYP[EVOW�XS�LIPT�KYEVERXII�XLEX�E

REXMSR�JMKLXMRK�JSV�MXW�WYVZMZEP�HSIW�RSX�WEGVMJMGI�XLSWI�REXMSREP�ZEPYIW�XLEX

QEOI�XLI�JMKLX�[SVXL[LMPI��������8LI�REXMSRW�SJ�XLI�[SVPH��JEGIH�[MXL�WYH�

HIR�XLVIEXW�XS�XLIMV�S[R�WIGYVMX]��[MPP�PSSO�XS�-WVEIP¬W�I\TIVMIRGI�MR�LER�

HPMRK�MXW�GSRXMRYMRK�WIGYVMX]�GVMWMW��ERH�QE]�[IPP�JMRH�MR�XLEX�I\TIVMIRGI

XLEX�I\TIVXMWI�XS�VINIGX�WIGYVMX]�GPEMQW�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�I\TSWIH�EW�FEWIPIWW

ERH�XLI�GSYVEKI�XS�TVIWIVZI�XLI�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�TVIWIVZIH

[MXLSYX�HIXVMQIRX�XS�MXW�WIGYVMX]�������

-�?[SYPH�RSXA�FI�WYVTVMWIH�MJ�MR�XLI�JYXYVI�XLI�TVSXIGXMSRW�KIRIVEPP]

EJJSVHIH�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�HYVMRK�XMQIW�SJ�[SVPH�HERKIV�S[IH�QYGL�XS�XLI

PIWWSRW�-WVEIP�PIEVRW�MR�MXW�WXVYKKPI�XS�TVIWIVZI�WMQYPXERISYWP]�XLI�PMFIVXMIW

SJ�MXW�GMXMIRW�ERH�XLI�WIGYVMX]�SJ�MXW�REXMSR��*SV�MR�XLMW�GVYGMFPI�SJ�HERKIV

PMIW�XLI�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�JSVKI�E�[SVPH[MHI�NYVMWTVYHIRGI�SJ�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW

XLEX�GER�[MXLWXERH�XLI�XYVFYPIRGIW�SJ�[EV�ERH�GVMWMW��-R�XLMW�[E]��EHZIVWMX]

QE]�]IX�FI�XLI�LERHQEMHIR�SJ�PMFIVX]���

;LIR�E�WXYHIRX�PIEHIV�PMOI�XLI�SRI�UYSXIH�EX�XLI�FIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLMW�GLET�XIV�HIGPEVIW�-WVEIP�XS�FI�XLI�TVMQI�LYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXSV�MR�XLI�[SVPH��LI�SVWLI�MW�KYMPX]�IMXLIV�SJ�EF]WQEP�MKRSVERGI�SV�QEPMKRERX�FMKSXV]��-R�IMXLIV�GEWI�LI�MW�MR�ZIV]�PEVKI��EPXLSYKL�RSX�ZIV]�KSSH��GSQTER]��1SWX�VIEWSREFPI�TIS�TPI�[SYPH�VEXLIV�FI�PIGXYVIH�EFSYX�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�ERH�LYQER�VMKLXW�F]�.YW�XMGI�;MPPMEQ�&VIRRER�XLER�F]�)VMG�6IMGLIRFIVKIV��=EWWIV�%VEJEX��SV�XLI�9�2�'SQQMWWMSR�SR�,YQER�6MKLXW�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 198: The Case For Israel

-J�XLIVI�MW�ER]�VIQEMRMRK�HSYFX�EFSYX�XLI�WYTIVMSVMX]�SJ�-WVEIPM�HIQSG�VEG]�ERH�GSQQMXQIRX�XS�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�MR�GSQTEVMWSR�XS�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�REXMSRW��ERH�IZIR�QSWX�;IWXIVR�REXMSRW��PIX�MX�FI�VIWSPZIH�F]�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�XLIQWIPZIW��[LS�EVI�JEQMPMEV�[MXL�-WVEIP¬W�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�NYHMGMEPMRWXMXYXMSRW��/LEPMP�7LMOEOM��E�4EPIWXMRMER�TSPMXMGEP�WGMIRXMWX�[LS�LEW�FIIRTSPPMRK�4EPIWXMRMERW�WMRGI������EFSYX�©[LEX�KSZIVRQIRXW�XLI]�EHQMVI�ªJSYRH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�

)ZIV]�]IEV�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�XLI�XST�TIVJSVQIV��EX�XMQIW�VIGIMZMRK�QSVI

XLER����TIVGIRX�ETTVSZEP��8LI�%QIVMGER�W]WXIQ�LEW�FIIR�XLI�RI\X�FIWX�

JSPPS[IH�F]�XLI�*VIRGL�ERH�XLIR��HMWXERXP]�XVEMPMRK��XLI�.SVHERMER�ERH

)K]TXMER�

-R�MXW�IEVP]�HE]W��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�LIPH�JSYVXL�TPEGI��[MXL

EFSYX����TIVGIRX�ETTVSZEP��2S[��MX�MW�HIEH�PEWX��YRHIV����TIVGIRX�

'SVVYTXMSR��QMWQEREKIQIRX�ERH�XLI�WXEKREXMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER

TVIHMGEQIRX�LEZI�XYVRIH�XLI�GYPXYVI�SJ�GVMXMGMWQ�EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER

VYPIVW���

8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�[IVI�TSPPIH�[SYPH�EPWS�PMOI�XS�WII�E�GSRWXMXYXMSRXLEX�[SYPH�©WYFWXERXMEPP]�WXVIRKXLIR�ERH�TVSXIGX�XLI�NYHMGMEV]�?[LMGLA�MWRS[�XLI�[IEOIWX�IPIQIRX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�KSZIVRERGI�ª�8LMW�XSS�MW�QSHIPIHSR�XLI�-WVEIPM�NYHMGMEV]��2SX�WYVTVMWMRKP]��%VEJEX�©TVIJIVW�E�[IEO�NYHMGMEV]�ª1SWX�HMGXEXSVW�HS�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 199: The Case For Israel

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LIVI�MW�E�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRGI�FIX[IIR�XLSWI�[LS�HIPMFIVEXIP]XEVKIX�MRRS�GIRX�GLMPHVIR��[SQIR��XLI�IPHIVP]��ERH�SXLIV�GMZMPMERW�ERH�XLSWI�[LS�MREH�ZIVXIRXP]OMPP�GMZMPMERW�MR�XLI�TVSGIWW�SJ�XV]MRK�XS�TVIZIRX�JYVXLIV�XIVVSVMWXEXXEGOW�

8,)�%''97)67

©7YMGMHI�FSQFIVW�EVI�XIVVSVMWXW��ERH�WS�EVI�XLI�JEV�[SVWI�-WVEIPM�GVMQIW�XLEX[I�?XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIWA�GEVV]�SYX�ª��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�

©/MPPMRK�XLI�*YXYVI��'LMPHVIR�MR�XLI�0MRI�SJ�*MVI�E�RI[�VITSVX�MWWYIHXSHE]�F]�%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP��HIXEMPW�XLI�[E]�MR�[LMGL�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH-WVEIPM�GLMPHVIR�LEZI�FIIR�XEVKIXIH�MR�ER�YRTVIGIHIRXIH�QERRIV�WMRGI�XLIFIKMRRMRK�SJ�XLI�GYVVIRX�MRXMJEHE�©«'LMPHVIR�EVI�MRGVIEWMRKP]�FIEVMRK�XLI�FVYRX�SJ�XLMW�GSRJPMGX��&SXL�XLI

-WVEIPM�(IJIRWI�*SVGI��-(* �ERH�4EPIWXMRMER�EVQIH�KVSYTW�WLS[�ER�YXXIVHMWVIKEVH�JSV�XLI�PMZIW�SJ�GLMPHVIR�ERH�SXLIV�GMZMPMERW�¬�%QRIWX]�-RXIVRE�XMSREP�WEMH�XSHE]�«6IWTIGX�JSV�LYQER�PMJI�QYWX�FI�VIWXSVIH��3RP]�E�RI[�QMRHWIX�EQSRK

-WVEIPMW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�GER�TVIZIRX�XLI�OMPPMRK�SJ�QSVI�GLMPHVIR�¬©8LI�MQTYRMX]�IRNS]IH�F]�QIQFIVW�SJ�XLI�-(*�ERH�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER

KVSYTW�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�OMPPMRK�GLMPHVIR�LEW�RS�HSYFX�LIPTIH�GVIEXI�E

���

-W�8LIVI�1SVEP�)UYMZEPIRGI�FIX[IIR4EPIWXMRMER�8IVVSVMWXW�ERH�-WVEIPM�6IWTSRWIW#

��

Page 200: The Case For Israel

WMXYEXMSR�[LIVI�XLI�VMKLX�XS�PMJI�SJ�GLMPHVIR�ERH�GMZMPMERW�SR�XLI�SXLIV�WMHILEW�PMXXPI�SV�RS�ZEPYI�©«)RSYKL�SJ�YREGGITXEFPI�VIEWSRW�ERH�I\GYWIW��&SXL�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZ�

IVRQIRX�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�QYWX�EGX�W[MJXP]�ERH�JMVQP]�XS�MRZIW�XMKEXI�XLI�OMPPMRK�SJ�IEGL�ERH�IZIV]�GLMPH�ERH�IRWYVI�XLEX�EPP�XLSWIVIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�WYGL�GVMQIW�EVI�FVSYKLX�XS�NYWXMGI�¬�XLI�SVKERMEXMSRWXEXIH�ª��%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP�4VIWW�6IPIEWI�

©?4STI�.SLR�4EYP�--�LEW�MWWYIH�ERA�YRIUYMZSGEP�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�8IV�VSVMWQ��JVSQ�[LEXIZIV�WMHI�MX�QE]�GSQI�ª�

©;I�GSRHIQR�IUYEPP]�������FSXL�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW�������ERH�XLI�ZMS�PIRGI�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�ª��2EXMSREP�'SYRGMP�SJ�'LYVGLIW�HIPIKEXMSRXS�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�

©4EPIWXMRMERW�[MPP�EVKYI�XLEX�XLI�ZMSPIRGI�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�3GGYTEXMSR�MW�JEVKVIEXIV��ERH�XLEX�XLI�HEMP]�GSQFMREXMSR�SJ�XSVXYVI��LSYWI�HIQSPMXMSRW�LYQMPMEXMRK�WIEVGLIW��XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSRW��ERH�XLI�WMIKI�SJ�XS[RW�ERHZMPPEKIW�MW�JEV�[SVWI�XLER�ER]XLMRK�I\TIVMIRGIH�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM�TSTYPEXMSR�8LI]�QE]�FI�VMKLX�ª��6EFFM�1MGLEIP�0IVRIV�

8,)�6)%0-8=

)ZIV]�VIEWSREFPI�WGLSSP�SJ�TLMPSWSTL]��XLISPSK]��NYVMWTVYHIRGI��ERH�GSQ�QSR�WIRWI�HMWXMRKYMWLIW�FIX[IIR�HIPMFIVEXIP]�XEVKIXMRK�GMZMPMERW�ERH�MREH�ZIVXIRXP]�OMPPMRK�GMZMPMERW�[LMPI�XEVKIXMRK�XIVVSVMWXW�[LS�LMHI�EQSRK�XLIQ�

8,)�4633*

8IVVSVMWX�EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPMW�ERH�.I[W�LEZI�MRGPYHIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�XEVKIXW�

�%RYVWIV]�WGLSSP�MR�[LMGL�IMKLXIIR�GLMPHVIR�ERH�XIEGLIVW�[IVIQEGLMRI�KYRRIH�XS�HIEXL

�%R�IPIQIRXEV]�WGLSSP�MR�[LMGL�X[IRX]�WIZIR�GLMPHVIR�ERH�XIEGLIVW[IVI�OMPPIH

�%.I[MWL�GSQQYRMX]�GIRXIV�MR�[LMGL�IMKLX]�WM\�GMZMPMERW�[IVI�OMPPIH

�%8YVOMWL�W]REKSKYI�MR�[LMGL�X[IRX]�WIZIR�.I[W�EX�TVE]IV�[IVIOMPPIH

�%7[MWW�EMVPMRIV�LIEHIH�XS�-WVEIP�MR�[LMGL�EPP�JSVX]�WIZIR�GMZMPMER�TEW�WIRKIVW�[IVI�OMPPIH

�%TEWWIRKIV�XIVQMREP�EX�0SH�%MVTSVX�MR�[LMGL�X[IRX]�WIZIR�GMZMPMERW�QSWXP]�'LVMWXMER�TMPKVMQW��[IVI�OMPPIH

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 201: The Case For Israel

�%4EWWSZIV�WIHIV�MR�[LMGL�X[IRX]�RMRI�.I[W�[IVI�OMPPIH

�%HMWGSXLIUYI�JSV�XIIREKIVW�MR�[LMGL�X[IRX]�SRI�QSWXP]�6YWWMER.I[W�[IVI�OMPPIH

�%,IFVI[�9RMZIVWMX]�GEJIXIVME�MR�[LMGL�RMRI�TISTPI�[IVI�OMPPIH

�%R�EMVTPERI�JMPPIH�[MXL�-WVEIPM�XSYVMWXW�VIXYVRMRK�JVSQ�E�'LERYOELZEGEXMSR�MR�/IR]E

3RP]�XLI�PEWX�SJ�XLIWI�EXXEGOW�JEMPIH��8LMW�XEVKIXIH�QYVHIV�SJ�GLMPHVIR�XLI�IPHIVP]��ERH�SXLIV�ZYPRIVEFPI�GMXMIRW�MW�YXXIVP]�[MXLSYX�ER]�QSVEP�NYW�XMJMGEXMSR��%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP�LEW�HIGPEVIH�WYGL�XIVVSVMWX�EGXW�XS�FI©GVMQIW�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]�ª�1ER]�XIVVSVMWX�EGXW�EVI�RSX�IZIR�HMVIGXIHEKEMRWX�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW YRNYWXMJMIH�EW�XLEX�MW FYX�EVI�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX.I[W�[LS�PMZI�SYXWMHI�SJ�-WVEIP��VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�XLIMV�ZMI[W�EFSYX�-WVEIP��8LMWMW�ERXM�7IQMXMG�LEXI�ZMSPIRGI��TYVI�ERH�WMQTPI�;LIR�XLI�/PY�/PY\�/PER�TIVTIXVEXIH�WMQMPEV�SYXVEKISYW�EXXEGOW�

EPXLSYKL�SR�E�JEV�WQEPPIV�WGEPI��XLIVI�[EW�YRMZIVWEP�GSRHIQREXMSR��2S�SRIGSRHIQRIH�IUYEPP]�XLI�HIPMFIVEXI�FSQFMRKW�F]�XLI�/PER�ERH�XLI�SGGE�WMSREP�SZIVVIEGXMSRW�F]�XLI�*&-��=IX�XLIVI�EVI�XLSWI�[LS�WIIO�XS�NYWXMJ]�XLIGYVVIRX�ERXM�.I[MWL�SYXVEKIW�EW�XLI�[SVO�SJ�JVIIHSQ�JMKLXIVW��8LI�VIEPMX]�MWXLEX�VMKLX�[MRK�I\XVIQMWXW�ERH�-WPEQMG�QMPMXERXW�EVI�[SVOMRK�XSKIXLIV�MR+IVQER]�ERH�SXLIV�)YVSTIER�GSYRXVMIW�XS�WTVIEH�©ZMSPIRX�ERXM�7IQMXMWQSR�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW�ª�2IS�2EMW�LEZI�EPWS�GSSTIVEXIH�[MXL�-WPEQMGXIVVSVMWXW�MR�%VKIRXMRE�XS�TIVTIXVEXI�ERXM�.I[MWL�ZMSPIRGI�8LI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�ERH�SXLIV�KIRSGMHIW�HMH�RSX�XEOI

VIZIRKI�F]�OMPPMRK�MRRSGIRX�GLMPHVIR��IZIR�XLI�GLMPHVIR�SJ�EGXYEP�TIVTIXVE�XSVW�SJ�XLI�KIRSGMHIW��=IX�-WVEIP¬W�IRIQMIW JVSQ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�XLI-VERMERW�XS�XLI�RIS�2EM�KVSYTW�XLEX�LEZI�[SVOIH�MR�GSPPEFSVEXMSR�[MXLXLIQ LEZI�RSX�LIWMXEXIH�XS�XEVKIX�GLMPHVIR�SV�ER]SRI�IPWI��.I[�SV�RSR�.I[��%RH�QER]�MR�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�MRWMWX�SR�HIWGVMFMRK-WVEIP¬W�EXXIQTXW�XS�TVIZIRX�XLIWI�SYXVEKIW�EW�QSVEPP]�IUYMZEPIRX�XS�XLISYXVEKIW�XLIQWIPZIW��%QSRK�XLI�[SVWX�SJJIRHIVW�EVI�GIVXEMR�VIPMKMSYW�PIEH�IVW�[LS�WLSYPH�ORS[�FIXXIV�ERH�[LSWI�S[R�XLISPSKMIW�QEOI�E�GVYGMEP�HMW�XMRGXMSR�FIX[IIR�HIPMFIVEXIP]�MRXIRHIH�GSRWIUYIRGIW��WYGL�EW�XEVKIXMRKGLMPHVIR��ERH�YRMRXIRHIH�GSRWIUYIRGIW��IZIR�[LIR�XLI]�GEYWI�XLI�EGGM�HIRXEP�HIEXL�SJ�E�GLMPH�MR�XLI�TVSGIWW�SJ�XEVKIXMRK�E�HERKIVSYW�XIVVSVMWX�8LI2I[�'EXLSPMG�)RG]GPSTIHMEHIJMRIW�XLI�TVMRGMTPI�SJ�©HSYFPI�IJJIGXª�EW©E�VYPI�SJ�GSRHYGX�JVIUYIRXP]�YWIH�MR�QSVEP�XLISPSK]�XS�HIXIVQMRI�[LIRE�TIVWSR�QE]�PE[JYPP]�TIVJSVQ�ER�EGXMSR�JVSQ�[LMGL�X[S�IJJIGXW�[MPP�JSP�PS[��SRI�FEH��ERH�XLI�SXLIV�KSSH�ª�-X�XLIR�KMZIW�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�I\EQTPI�[LMGL�TIVJIGXP]�HIWGVMFIW�-WVEIP¬W�TSPMG]�SJ�JMKLXMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�

-R�QSHIVR�[EVJEVI�XLI�TVMRGMTPI�SJ�XLI�HSYFPI�IJJIGX�MW�JVIUYIRXP]�ETTPM�

GEFPI��8LYW��MR�[EKMRK�E�NYWX�[EV�E�REXMSR�QE]�PEYRGL�ER�EMV�EXXEGO�SR

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 202: The Case For Israel

ER�MQTSVXERX�QMPMXEV]�SFNIGXMZI�SJ�XLI�IRIQ]�IZIR�XLSYKL�E�GSQTEVEXMZIP]

WQEPP�RYQFIV�SJ�RSRGSQFEXERXW�EVI�OMPPIH��8LMW�IZMP�IJJIGX�GER�FI�GSQTIR�

WEXIH�JSV�F]�XLI�KVIEX�FIRIJMX�KEMRIH�XLVSYKL�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�XLI�XEVKIX�

8LMW�[SYPH�RSX�FI�XVYI�MJ�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�RSRGSQFEXERXW�WPEMR�MR�XLI

EXXEGO�[IVI�SYX�SJ�TVSTSVXMSR�XS�XLI�FIRIJMXW�KEMRIH��������*YVXLIVQSVI��MJ

XLI�HMVIGX�TYVTSWI�SJ�XLI�EXXEGO�[IVI�XS�OMPP�E�PEVKI�RYQFIV�SJ�RSRGSQ�

FEXERXW�WS�XLEX�XLI�QSVEPI�SJ�XLI�IRIQ]�[SYPH�FI�FVSOIR�HS[R�ERH�XLI]

[SYPH�WYI�JSV�TIEGI��XLI�EXXEGO�[SYPH�FI�WMRJYP��������-X�[SYPH�FI�E�GEWI�SJ

XLI�YWI�SJ�E�FEH�QIERW�XS�SFXEMR�E�KSSH�IRH�

%W�XLI�TLMPSWSTLIV�.IER�&IXLOI�)PWLXEMR�LEW�TSMRXIHP]�SFWIVZIH�MR�VIEGXMSRXS�XLI�GPEMQ�SJ�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRGI�F]�WSQI�GPIVK]QIR�ERH�XLISPSKMERW��

-J�[I�GSYPH�RSX�HMWXMRKYMWL�FIX[IIR�ER�EGGMHIRXEP�HIEXL�VIWYPXMRK�JVSQ�E

GEV�EGGMHIRX�ERH�ER�MRXIRXMSREP�QYVHIV��SYV�GVMQMREP�NYWXMGI�W]WXIQ�[SYPH

JEPP�ETEVX��%RH�MJ�[I�GERRSX�HMWXMRKYMWL�XLI�OMPPMRK�SJ�GSQFEXERXW�JVSQ�XLI

MRXIRHIH�XEVKIXMRK�SJ�TIEGIEFPI�GMZMPMERW��[I�PMZI�MR�E�[SVPH�SJ�QSVEP

RMLMPMWQ��-R�WYGL�E�[SVPH��IZIV]XLMRK�VIHYGIW�XS�XLI�WEQI�WLEHI�SJ�KVE]

ERH�[I�GERRSX�QEOI�HMWXMRGXMSRW�XLEX�LIPT�YW�XEOI�SYV�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�QSVEP

FIEVMRKW��

8LMW�JEMPYVI�XS�YRHIVWXERH SV�[SVWI��XS�YRHIVWXERH�FYX�RSX�XSEGORS[PIHKI XLI�JYRHEQIRXEP�HMJJIVIRGI�FIX[IIR�HIPMFIVEXIP]�XEVKIXMRKGMZMPMERW�ERH�EGGMHIRXEPP]�OMPPMRK�GMZMPMERW�MR�XLI�GSYVWI�SJ�WIPJ�HIJIRWIVIJPIGXW�QSVEP�SFXYWIRIWW�EX�FIWX�ERH�SYXVMKLX�FMKSXV]�EX�[SVWX��-X�EPWSIRGSYVEKIW�XLSWI�[LS�HIPMFIVEXIP]�IQTPS]�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�GMZMPMERW�EW�EQIERW�XS[EVH�EGLMIZMRK�©QSVEP�IUYEPMX]ª�[MXL�XLIMV�QSVI�LYQERI�IRIQMIWMR�XLI�GSYVX�SJ�TYFPMG�STMRMSR��8LI�GVYIP�MVSR]�MW�XLEX�JSV�WSQI�FMKSXW-WVEIP�MW�RSX�IZIRVIKEVHIH�EW�XLI�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRX�SJ�MXW�XIVVSVMWX�IRIQMIW�2SEQ�'LSQWO]��JSV�I\EQTPI��VIKEVHW�-WVEIPM�ERH�%QIVMGER�GSYRXIVXIV�VSVMWQ�EGXMSRW�EW�JEV�[SVWI�XLER�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�MXWIPJ�8LI�EVKYQIRX�-�EQ�QEOMRK�MW�RSX�XLEX�X[S�[VSRKW�QEOI�E�VMKLX��-X�MW

EP[E]W�TSWWMFPI�XS�JMRH�[VSRKW�SR�EPP�WMHIW��8LI�EVKYQIRX ERH�MX�MW�EREVKYQIRX�GIRXVEP�XS�GMZMPMEXMSR�ERH�NYWXMGI MW�XLEX�XLI�GSRGITX�SJ�[VSRKWMW�RSX�EP[E]W�E�QEXXIV�SJ�HIKVII��XLIVI�EVI�UYEPMXEXMZI�HMJJIVIRGIW�FIX[IIRYRMRXIRHIH[VSRKW�ERH�TYVTSWIJYP[VSRKW��8[S�HIEH�GMZMPMERW�EVI�RSXQSVEPP]�IUYMZEPIRX�MJ�SRI�[EW�XEVKIXIH�JSV�QYVHIV��ERH�XLI�HIEXL�SJ�XLISXLIV�[EW�XLI�YRJSVXYREXI�GSRWIUYIRGI�SJ�FIWX�IJJSVXW��MRGPYHMRK�VMWOW�XSSRI¬W�S[R�WSPHMIVW��XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�GMZMPMERW��&SXL�EVI�[VSRKW�NYWX�EW�XLI�HIEXL�SJ�X[S�LSWTMXEP�TEXMIRXW�JVSQ�SZIVHSWIW�SJ�E�GERGIV�XVIEXMRK�HVYK�EVI�[VSRKW��&YX�ER]SRI�[LS�GERRSX��SV�[MPP�RSX��HMWXMRKYMWLFIX[IIR�E�GEWI�[LIVI�E�FPEGO�TEXMIRX�[EW�HIPMFIVEXIP]�SZIVHSWIH�F]�E�VEGMWX

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 203: The Case For Israel

RYVWI�ERH�ERSXLIV�GEWI�[LIVI�XLI�TEXMIRX�HMIH�EJXIV�GSRWIRXMRK�XS�EKKVIW�WMZI�GERGIV�XLIVET]�XLEX�LI�ORI[�GEVVMIH�E�LMKL�VMWO�SJ�HIEXL�MW�IMXLIVQSVEPP]�FPMRH�SV�[MPPJYPP]�FMKSXIH��)ZIV]FSH]YRHIVWXERHW�XLMW�HMJJIVIRGI�ERH�IZIV]SRI�FIPMIZIW�MR�MX�MR�SXLIV�GSRXI\XW�&YX�[LIR�MX�GSQIW�XS�-WVEIP�WMQTPI�MRXIPPMKIRGI�ERH�FEWMG�QSVEPMX]�EVI�WYWTIRHIH�F]�WSQI�[LS�MRWMWXSR�ETTP]MRK�E�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�)ZIR�MJ�-WVEIP�MW�TVSTIVP]�GVMXMGMIH�JSV�SZIVVIEGXMRK�MR�TEVXMGYPEV�GEWIW�F]

TPEGMRK�GMZMPMERW�EX�VMWO��XLIVI�MW�WXMPP�RS�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRGI�FIX[IIRI\TPSHMRK�ER�ERXMTIVWSRRIP�FSQF�QEHI�SJ�REMPW�WSEOIH�MR�VEX�TSMWSR[LSWI�WSPI�TYVTSWI�MW�XS�QE\MQMI�GMZMPMER�HIEXLW�ERH�MRNYVMIW��SR�XLI�SRILERH��ERH�XEVKIXMRK�XIVVSVMWXW�YRHIV�GMVGYQWXERGIW�MR�[LMGL�MX�MW�PMOIP]�XLEXWSQI�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�QE]�HMI��SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH��&SXL�EVI�[VSRK��FYXXLI�JSVQIV�MW�JEV��JEV�QSVI�QSVEPP]�GYPTEFPI�XLER�XLI�PEXXIV��FIGEYWI�SJ�XLIHMJJIVMRK�TYVTSWIW��2S�GMZMPMIH�WSGMIX]�VIKEVHW�TVIQIHMXEXIH�JMVWX�HIKVIIQYVHIV�EW�QSVEPP]�IUYMZEPIRX�XS�RIKPMKIRX�LSQMGMHI��8LMW�MW�XVYI�SJ�XLI&MFPI��XLI�/SVER��ERH�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[ I\GITX�ETTEVIRXP]�[LIR�MX�GSQIWXS�-WVEIP��[LIVI�PSRKWXERHMRK�HMWXMRGXMSRW�ERH�YRMZIVWEPP]�EGGITXIH�VYPIW�SJQSVEPMX]�WIIQ�XS�FI�JSVKSXXIR�-X�MW�MQTSVXERX�JSV�WSQI�TISTPI�XS�FIPMIZI�XLEX�EPP�QSVEPMX]�MW�VIPEXMZI�

ERH�XLIVI�MW�RS�EFWSPYXI�IZMP�MR�XLI�[SVPH��8LMW�MW�IWTIGMEPP]�XVYI�SJ�TISTPI[LS�GEQI�SJ�EKI�EJXIV�XLI�,MXPIV§7XEPMR�IVE��)ZIR�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�HIEXL�SJXLSWI�X[S�TIVJIGXP]�IZMP�QSRWXIVW��XLIVI�[IVI�SXLIVW�[LS�[IVI�TYVI�IZMP�WYGL�EW�4SP�4SX�ERH�-HM�%QMR��&YX�XLI]�PMZIH�MR�HMWXERX�PERHW�ERH�[IVI�RSXTEVX�SJ�XLI�HEMP]�GSRWGMSYWRIWW�SJ�QSWX�%QIVMGERW�EW�,MXPIV�ERH�7XEPMR[IVI��8LI�:MIXREQ�;EV�[EW�WIIR�F]�QER]�EW�E�GPEWL�FIX[IIR�QSVEPP]IUYMZEPIRX�EKKVIWWSVW��*MHIP�'EWXVS�[EW�ZMI[IH�F]�QER]�SR�XLI�PIJX�EW�LEZ�MRK�HSRI�WSQI�KSSH�ERH�WSQI�FEH�=IX�XLIVI�MW�XVYI�IZMP�MR�XLI�[SVPH��ERH�XLI�HIPMFIVEXI�XEVKIXMRK�SJ�GLMP�

HVIR��[SQIR��ERH�SPH�TISTPI�FEWIH�SR�XLIMV�IXLRMGMX]�SV�REXMSREP�SVMKMR�MWTYVI�IZMP��[MXL�EFWSPYXIP]�RS�NYWXMJMGEXMSR��8S�JEMP�XS�EGORS[PIHKI�WYGL�XIV�VSVMWQ�EW�TYVI�IZMP�MRZMXIW�VIPEXMZMWQ�EFSYX�IZIV]XLMRK��-J�MX�MW�TIVQMWWMFPI�XSXEVKIX�FEFMIW�ERH�WGLSSPGLMPHVIR�NYWX�FIGEYWI�XLI]�EVI�.I[MWL��MW�XLIVI�ER]�XLMRK�XLEX�MW�FI]SRH�XLI�TEPI�SJ�EGGITXEFMPMX]#�-R�8LI�&VSXLIVW�/EVEQESZ�*]SHSV�(SWXS]IZWO]�TSWIH�XLMW�UYIWXMSR�MR�XLI�JEQSYW�HMEPSKYI�EFSYX�VIP�EXMZMWQ�FIX[IIR�-ZER�ERH�%P]SWLE�

-ZER��©-QEKMRI�XLEX�]SY�EVI�GVIEXMRK�E�JEFVMG�SJ�LYQER�HIWXMR]�[MXL�XLI

SFNIGX�SJ�QEOMRK�QIR�LETT]�MR�XLI�IRH��KMZMRK�XLIQ�TIEGI�EX�PIEWX��FYX

XLEX�MX�[EW�IWWIRXMEP�ERH�MRIZMXEFPI�XS�XSVXYVI�XS�HIEXL�SRP]�SRI�XMR]�GVIE�

XYVI XLEX�FEF]�FIEXMRK�MXW�FVIEWX�[MXL�MXW�JMWX��JSV�MRWXERGI ERH�XS�JSYRH

XLEX�IHMJMGI�SR�MXW�YREZIRKIH�XIEVW��[SYPH�]SY�GSRWIRX�XS�FI�XLI�EVGLMXIGX

SJ�XLSWI�GSRHMXMSRW#�8IPP�QI��ERH�XIPP�XLI�XVYXL�ª�%P]SWLE�VITPMIH�[MXLSYX

LIWMXEXMSR��©2S��-�[SYPHR¬X�GSRWIRX�ª

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 204: The Case For Israel

6IQIQFIV�XLEX�,MXPIV�ERH�7XEPMR�FSXL�GPEMQIH�NYWXMJMGEXMSRW�JSV�XLIMVTSPMGMIW�SJ�QEWW�QYVHIV�ERH�LEH�PEVKI�JSPPS[MRKW�XLEX�MRGPYHIH�MRXIPPIGXY�EPW��TVSJIWWMSREPW��ERH�EVXMWXW��=IX�[I�RS[�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�RSXLMRK�GSYPHTSWWMFP]�NYWXMJ]�XLI�ERRMLMPEXMSR�SJ�XIRW�SJ�QMPPMSRW�SJ�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�EPXLSYKL�WSQI�4EPIWXMRMER�ERH�%VEF�PIEHIVW�WXMPP�FIQSER�XLI�JEGX�XLEX,MXPIV�HMH�RSX�GSQTPIXI�XLI�NSF�;L]�XLIR�EVI�HIGIRX�TISTPI�XSHE]�EJVEMH�XS�GEPP�IZMP�F]�MXW�REQI#�;L]

HS�WS�QER]�MRWMWX�SR�JMRHMRK�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRGI#�%RH�[L]�HS�WS�QER]TISTPI�HIWGVMFI�XLI�[SVWX�SJ�IZMPW XLI�HIPMFIVEXI�XEVKIXMRK�SJ�GLMPHVIR[MXL�TSWMXMZI�WSYRHMRK�XIVQW�PMOI�©JVIIHSQ�JMKLXMRK�ª�[LMPI�HIWGVMFMRKVIEWSREFPI�IJJSVXW�XS�TVIZIRX�XLIWI�2EM�PMOI�IZMPW�EW�2EMWQ�MXWIPJ#�2SEQ'LSQWO]�PMOIW�XS�VIQMRH�LMW�EYHMIRGIW�XLEX�,MXPIV�ERH�7XEPMR�FSXLGPEMQIH�XLEX�XLIMV�KIRSGMHI�[EW�VIEPP]�ERXMXIVVSVMWQ��EW�MJ�XS�WYKKIWX�XLEXIZIV]XLMRK�PEFIPIH�ERXMXIVVSVMWQ JVSQ�XLI�FYMPHMRK�SJ�HIEXL�GEQTW�MR[LMGL�E�QMPPMSR�GLMPHVIR�[IVI�KEWWIH�XS�XLI�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�SJ�E�WMR�KPI�XIVVSVMWX�GSQQERHIV MW�QSVEPP]�IUYMZEPIRX�8LI�HE]�EJXIV�4VIWMHIRX�&YWL�FVSYKLX�-WVEIPM�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�7LEVSR�ERH

4EPIWXMRMER�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�%FFEW�XSKIXLIV�EX�%UEFE��,EQEW�PIEHIV�-WQEMP%FY�7LEREF�ZS[IH�XS�GSRXMRYI�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW��EJXIV�GSQTPEMRMRKFMXXIVP]�XLEX�%FFEW�LEH�EGORS[PIHKIH�XLEX�.I[W�LEH�WYJJIVIH�XLVSYKLSYXLMWXSV]��©,I�WTSOI�EFSYX�-WVEIPM�WYJJIVMRK�EW�MJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�GSQQMXXIH�XLI,SPSGEYWX�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W��[LMPI�MR�XVYXL�MX�MW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�EVIFIMRK�WYFNIGX�XS�ER�-WVEIPM�LSPSGEYWX�ª�8LMW�LMWXSVMGEP�MKRSVERGI�SV�WIPJ�HIGITXMSR�EFSYX�XLI�EGXYEP�VSPI�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�MR�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�GSYTPIH�[MXL�MQQSVEP�GSQTEVMWSRW�FIX[IIR�2EM�HIEXL�GEQTW�ERH�-WVEIPMWIPJ�HIJIRWI�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ��LEW�MXWIPJ�FIGSQI�E�FEVVMIV�XS�TIEGI�8LI�TSPMXMGEP�EREPSKYI�XS�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRGI�MW�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW��-X

QMKLX�JSPPS[�JVSQ�XLI�JEPWI�TVIQMWI�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�-WVEIPMW�EVIIUYEPP]�EX�JEYPX�JSV�XLI�FVIEOHS[R�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�TVSGIWW�ERH�XLI�IWGEPEXMRKZMSPIRGI��XLEX�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�WLSYPH�FI�IZIR�LERHIH�MR�HIEP�MRK�[MXL�FSXL�WMHIW��&YX�MX�EPWS�JSPPS[W�JVSQ�XLI�YRHMWTYXIH�JEGX�XLEX4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�EVI�FPEQI[SVXL]�JSV�XLIMV�VITIEXIH�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLIX[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ERH�JSV�XLI�VIWYPXMRK�IWGEPEXMSR�SJ�ZMSPIRGI��XLEX�XLI�X[SWMHIW�WLSYPH�RSX�FI�XVIEXIH�MR�ER�IZIR�LERHIH�QERRIV��8S�VI[EVH�VINIG�XMSR�ERH�ZMSPIRGI�[MXL�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�MW�XS�IRGSYVEKI�WYGL�GSRHYGX�8LIVI�QYWX�FI�E�LMKL�TVMGI�TEMH�F]�XLSWI�[LS�VINIGX�TIEGI�MR�JEZSV�SJ�ZMS�PIRGI��EW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�WMRGI�XLI�����W��8LIVI�QYWX�FI�E�FIRIJMX�JSVXLSWI�[LS�[IVI�[MPPMRK�XS�EGGITX�E�TIEGIJYP�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�MR������������ERH�����§������EW�-WVEIP�[EW�1SVISZIV��XLIVI�QYWX�FI�E�TVMGI�TEMH�F]�XLSWI�[LS�WXEVX�EKKVIWWMZI

[EVW�SJ�ERRMLMPEXMSR�ERH�I\XIVQMREXMSR��EW�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERJMKLXIVW�LEZI�VITIEXIHP]�HSRI��%RH�XLIVI�WLSYPH�FI�E�FIRIJMX�JSV�XLSWI[LS�WYGGIWWJYPP]�HIJIRH�XLIMV�GMZMPMER�TSTYPEXMSR�EKEMRWX�WYGL�EKKVIWWMZI

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 205: The Case For Israel

[EVW��%R]�SXLIV�ETTVSEGL�[MPP�IRGSYVEKI�XLI�[EKMRK�SJ�EKKVIWWMZI�[EVW�8LIVI�QYWX�EPWS�FI�E�TVMGI�TEMH�F]�XLSWI�[LS�LEZI�VITIEXIHP]�EPPMIH

XLIQWIPZIW�[MXL��ERH�EGXMZIP]�WYTTSVXIH��XLI�[SVWX�WSVXW�SJ�IZMP��VERKMRKJVSQ�2EMWQ�XS�7EHHEQMWQ��7MQMPEVP]��XLSWI�[LS�WYTTSVX�XLI�[MRRMRKWMHIW�SJ�NYWX�[EVW�LEZI�XVEHMXMSREPP]�FIIR�VI[EVHIH�[MXL�JEZSVEFPI�XVIEX�QIRX�8LI�GSRGITX�SJ�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�WIIQW�FIRMKR��EPQSWX�QSVEP��%W�

E�TISTPI�GSQQMXXIH�XS�IUYEPMX]��%QIVMGERW�KIRIVEPP]�WYTTSVX�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW��;I�[SYPH�GIVXEMRP]�I\TIGX�MX�JVSQ�ER�YQTMVI�SV�E�VIJIVII�EXEWTSVXMRK�IZIRX��;I�HIQERH�MX�SJ�SYV�KSZIVRQIRX�MR�XLI�XVIEXQIRX�SJTISTPI�SJ�HMJJIVIRX�VEGIW��VIPMKMSRW��KIRHIVW��ERH�WI\YEP�SVMIRXEXMSRW��&YXIZIR�LERHIHRIWW�MW�RSX�EYXSQEXMGEPP]�E�HIWMVEFPI�GVMXIVMSR�JSV�HIEPMRK�[MXLREXMSRW�ERH�KVSYTW�XLEX�LEZI�FILEZIH�UYMXI�HMJJIVIRXP] WSQI�JEV�FIXXIVXLER�SXLIVW EW�NYHKIH�F]�YRMZIVWEPP]�EGGITXIH�QSVEP�GVMXIVME��2S�SRII\TIGXIH�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�JSV�XLI�+IVQERW�ERH�XLI�.ETERIWI�JSPPS[MRKXLI�7IGSRH�;SVPH�;EV��ERH�RS�SRI�I\TIGXIH�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�[LIR�XLI.YWXMGI�(ITEVXQIRX�GSRJVSRXIH�XLI�/Y�/PY\�/PER��1SWX�VIPIZERXP]��RSSRI�I\TIGXW�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�FIX[IIR�3WEQE�FMR�0EHIR¬W�EP�5EIHE�ERHXLSWI�[LS�EVI�WIIOMRK�XS�HIWXVS]�LMW�GETEGMX]�XS�MRJPMGX�JYVXLIV�LEVQ�SRMRRSGIRX�TISTPI��;I�WLSYPH�JEZSV�XLSWI�[LS�WIIO�TIEGI�SZIV�XLSWI�[LSLEZI�WLS[R�E�TVIJIVIRGI�JSV�[EV��;I�WLSYPH�JEZSV�XLSWI�[LS�EVI�RSX�WIIO�MRK�XS�HIWXVS]�E�9�2��QIQFIV�WXEXI�SZIV�XLSWI�[LS�EVI�7LMJXMRK�JVSQ�XLI�XLISVIXMGEP�XS�XLI�TVEGXMGEP��IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�MW�VEVIP]

IZIR��8LSWI�[LS�EHZSGEXI�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�FIX[IIR�-WVEIP�ERH�MXW�IRI�QMIW�KIRIVEPP]�JEZSV�E�WXVSRK�XMPX�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�MR�JEZSV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�'IVXEMRP]�XLEX�LEW�PSRK�FIIR�XVYI�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��[LMGL�XEPOW�XLIXEPO�SJ�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�FYX�ZSXIW�XLI�ZSXI�SJ�E�WXVSRK�FMEW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPERH�E�TVIJIVIRGI�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��RSX�SRP]�SZIV�-WVEIP�FYX�EPWS�SZIV�EPPSXLIV�SGGYTMIH�ERH�WXEXIPIWW�TISTPI��8LI�WEQI�LEW�FIIR�XVYI�SJ�QSWX)YVSTIER�ERH�%WMER�GSYRXVMIW�)ZIR�%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP�LEW�JEMPIH�XLI�XIWX�SJ�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�F]

JEPWIP]�GPEMQMRK�XLEX�RS�4EPIWXMRMER�QMRSV�LEW�IZIV�FIIR�MRZSPZIH�MR�E�WYM�GMHI�FSQFMRK�ERH�XLEX�XLI�-WVEIPM�%VQ]�©XEVKIXWª�MRRSGIRX�4EPIWXMRMERGLMPHVIR��8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��[LMGL�LEW�KIRIVEPP]�FIIR�IZIR�LERHIH�MRJEGX��EW�FIX[IIR�-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��MW�[MHIP]�TIVGIMZIH�EW�FIMRKYRJEMVP]�JEZSVEFPI�XS�-WVEIP��[LIVIEW�XLSWI�[LS�EVI�MR�JEGX�YRJEMVP]�JEZSV�EFPI�XS�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI�[MHIP]�TIVGIMZIH�EW�IZIR�LERHIH��8LI�9RMXIH7XEXIW�LEW�ZSXIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�EX�XLI�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�SR�QER]�SGGEWMSRW�WSQIXMQIW�QSWX�VIKVIXXEFP]��EW�[LIR�MX�GSRHIQRIH�-WVEIP�JSV�HIWXVS]MRK-VEU¬W�RYGPIEV�VIEGXSV ER�EGXMSR�JSV�[LMGL�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�MW�RS[�UYMXIKVEXIJYP��1ER]�REXMSRW�XLEX�GPEMQ�XS�FI�IZIR�LERHIH�LEZI�EPQSWX�RIZIVZSXIH�XS�GSRHIQR�4EPIWXMRMER�EGXMSRW�)ZIR�XLI�JEPWI�EVKYQIRX�SZIV�[L]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�©XMPXWª�XS[EVH

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 206: The Case For Israel

-WVEIP�[LMPI�XLI�VIWX�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�MW�IZIR�LERHIH�MW�SJXIR�XMRKIH�[MXL�ERSX�WS�WYFXPI�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��©8LI�.I[W�GSRXVSP�%QIVMGE�ª�MX�MW�GPEMQIH�ERH�XLEX�MW�[L]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�MW�WS�TVS�-WVEIP��3RI�VEVIP]�LIEVW�GSQ�TEVEFPI�GSQTPEMRXW�EFSYX�1YWPMQ�SV�SMP�MRJPYIRGIW�SR�*VIRGL�TSPMG]�%QIVMGERW��[LIXLIV�.I[MWL�SV�RSR�.I[MWL��[LS�WYTTSVX�-WVEIP�FIGEYWIXLI]�FIPMIZI�XLEX�MW�XLI�FIWX�TSPMG]�JSV�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�LEZI�E�TIVJIGXVMKLX�XS�XV]��F]�HIQSGVEXMG�QIERW��XS�MRJPYIRGI�9�7��TSPMG]��IWTIGMEPP][LIR�WS�QYGL�SJ�XLI�VIWX�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�MW�WS�SRI�WMHIHP]�ERXM�-WVEIP��EWVIJPIGXIH�F]�XLI�SRI�WMHIH�ZSXMRK�VIWYPXW�EX�XLI�9�2��ERH�SXLIV�MRXIVRE�XMSREP�FSHMIW�-J�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW�MW�IZIV�XS�FI�EGLMIZIH�[MXLMR�XLI�IRXMVI�MRXIVRE�

XMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��MX�[MPP�SRP]�LETTIR�MJ�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�HSIW�RSX�WIIO�XSIQYPEXI�)YVSTIER�GSRGITXMSRW�SJ�IZIR�LERHIHRIWW��-J�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW[IVI�IZIV�XS�FIGSQI�EW�IZIR�LERHIH�EW�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�LEWFIIR��MX�[SYPH�WYVIP]�IRGSYVEKI�GSRXMRYMRK�EKKVIWWMSR�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[MWLWXEXI��-X�[SYPH�EPWS�FI�QSVEPP]�[VSRK��)ZIR�LERHIHRIWW�XS[EVH�XLSWI[LSWI�EGXMSRW�EVI�RSX�QSVEPP]�IUYMZEPIRX�MW�ER�MQQSVEP�ERH�HERKIVSYWJSVQ�SJ�EVXMJMGMEP�W]QQIXV]�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 207: The Case For Israel

���

8,)�%''97%8-32

-WVEIP¬W�EGXMSRW��QSVI�XLER�XLSWI�SJ�ER]�SXLIV�REXMSR��[EVVERX�HMZIWXQIRXERH�FS]GSXX�

8,)�%''97)67

©;I�XLI�YRHIVWMKRIH�������GEPP�SR�1-8�ERH�,EVZEVH�XS�HMZIWX�JVSQ�-WVEIP�ª�2SEQ�'LSQWO]��WMKRMRK�E�TIXMXMSR�JSV�HMZIWXQIRX

©(MZIWXQIRX�MW�[VSRK�MR�TVMRGMTPI�������©(MZIWXQIRX�MW�«YRTVMRGMTPIH¬�ERH�«MX�[SYPH�FI�PSZIH�F]�%PER�(IV�

WLS[MX��0E[VIRGI�7YQQIVW�ERH�1EVX]�4IVIX�[LS�EVI�HIPMKLXIH�XS�LEZIQSVI�EXVSGMXMIW�ERH�ZMSPIRGI�EKEMRWX�4EPIWXMRMERW�¬�8LIWI�QIR�EVI�«I\XVIQ�MWXW�[LS�[ERX�XS�QE\MQMI�9�7�§-WVEIPM�EXVSGMXMIW�ERH�GVMQIW�¬ª��2SEQ'LSQWO]�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LIWI�GEQTEMKRW�XS�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�HIQSRMEXMSR�EVI�MQQSVEP�FMKSXIH��ERH�FEWIH�SR�QMWMRJSVQEXMSR�8LI�GEQTEMKR�GYVVIRXP]�FIMRK�[EKIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�SR�GSPPIKI�ERH

7LSYPH�9RMZIVWMXMIW(MZIWX�JVSQ�-WVEIP�ERH&S]GSXX�-WVEIPM�7GLSPEVW#

��

Page 208: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH�MW�JYIPIH�F]�MKRSVERGI��FMKSXV]�ERH�G]RMGMWQ��0IH�F]�IJJSVXW�EX�,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��XLI�1EWWEGLYWIXXW-RWXMXYXI�SJ�8IGLRSPSK]��ERH�SXLIV�WGLSSPW�XS�IRH�YRMZIVWMX]�MRZIWXQIRX�MR-WVEIP�ERH�XS�FS]GSXX�-WVEIPM�WTIEOIVW�ERH�EGEHIQMGW��XLMW�GEQTEMKR�WIIOW�XSHIPIKMXMQMI�ERH�MWSPEXI�-WVEIP�EW�E�TEVMEL�WXEXI��8LI�GEQTEMKR�EPWS�WIIOW�XSGSRZI]�XS�GSPPIKI�WXYHIRXW�XLI�JEPWI�RSXMSR�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�EQSRK�XLI�[SVWXLYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXSVW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�ERH�MW�KYMPX]�SJ�KIRSGMHI��XSVXYVI�VEGMWQ��IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK��ERH�2EM�XEGXMGW��[LIVIEW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERHXLIMV�%VEF�WYTTSVXIVW�EVI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�-WVEIPM�EKKVIWWMSR�%PXLSYKL�MX�MW�YRPMOIP]�XLEX�HMZIWXMXYVI�[MPP�FI�MQTPIQIRXIH�SR�XLIWI

GEQTYWIW��XLI�KSEP�SJ�XLI�GEQTEMKR�MW�WMQMPEV�XS��ERH�KVS[W�SYX�SJ��TVIZM�SYW�EXXIQTXW�XS�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP�F]�IUYEXMRK�>MSRMWQ�[MXL�VEGMWQ�ERH�F]GSQTP]MRK�[MXL�XLI�RS[�HMWGVIHMXIH�ERH�MPPIKEP�%VEF�FS]GSXX�SJ�-WVEIPM�ERH.I[MWL�KSSHW�

8,)�4633*

8LI�MRXIPPIGXYEP�KSHJEXLIV�SJ�XLMW�GEQTEMKR�MW�RSRI�SXLIV�XLER�2SEQ'LSQWO]��[LS�LEW�GEPPIH�JSV�XLI�EFSPMXMSR�SJ�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�XLIWYFWXMXYXMSR�SJ�E�©WIGYPEV�FMREXMSREP�WXEXIª�FEWIH�SR�XLI�QSHIPW�SJ0IFERSR�ERH�=YKSWPEZME��'LSQWO]�LEW�EPWS�HIJIRHIH�XLI�JMRHMRKW�SJ�XLIRSXSVMSYW�ERXM�7IQMXI�ERH�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMIV�6SFIVX�*EYVMWWSR��[LS�GPEMQWXLEX�XLI�.I[W�[IVI�VIWTSRWMFPI�JSV�;SVPH�;EV�--�ERH�XLEX�RS�.I[W�[IVIKEWWIH�EX�HIEXL�GEQTW��'LSQWO]�LEW�WEMH�XLEX�LI�WE[�©RS�LMRX�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MQTPMGEXMSRW�MR�*EYVMWWSR¬W�[SVO�ª�MRGPYHMRK�LMW�HIRMEP�SJ�XLI�,SPS�GEYWX��[LMGL�'LSQWO]�GPEMQW�MW�FEWIH�SR�©I\XIRWMZI�LMWXSVMGEP�VIWIEVGL�ª'LSQWO]�[IRX�WS�JEV�EW�XS�[VMXI�ER�MRXVSHYGXMSR�XS�SRI�SJ�*EYVMWWSR¬W

ERXM�7IQMXMG�FSSOW��%PXLSYKL�LI�WIIW�RS�LMRX�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�MR�FPEQMRK;SVPH�;EV�--�SR�XLI�.I[W�ERH�MR�HIR]MRK�XLEX�.I[W�[IVI�KEWWIH�MR�HIEXLGEQTW��'LSQWO]�MW�UYMGO�XS�EGGYWI�SJ�VEGMWQ�XLSWI�[LS�HIJIRH�-WVEIP¬WVMKLX�XS�HIJIRH�MXWIPJ�JVSQ�XIVVSVMWQ��'LSQWO]�MW�NSMRIH�MR�LMW�MKRSFPITIXMXMSR�F]�WSQI�[LS�[SYPH�XEOI�XLI�QSRI]�RS[�MRZIWXIH�MR�XLI1MHIEWX¬W�SRP]�HIQSGVEG]�ERH�LEZI�MX�WIRX�XS�0MF]E��7]VME��'YFE��XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��ERH�SXLIVW�[LS�WYTTSVX�ERH�JMRERGI�XIVVSVMWQ��8LI]EVI�E�QSXPI]�EWWSVXQIRX�SJ�ORII�NIVO�ERXM�>MSRMWXW��VEFMH�ERXM�%QIVMGERW�VEHMGEP�PIJXMWXW�WYGL�EW�XLI�7TEVXEGYW�0IEKYI��[LMGL�EPWS�HIJIRHW�XLI©VMKLXª�SJ�2SVXL�/SVIE�XS�HIZIPST�ERH�WIPP�RYGPIEV�[IETSRW ��ERH�IZIRWSQI�SJ�'LSQWO]¬W�JSVQIV�WXYHIRXW�[LS�RS[�XIEGL�MR�-WVEIP�-X�WLSYPH�RSX�FI�WYVTVMWMRK�XLEX�XLI�TIXMXMSR�LEW�KEVRIVIH�WS�PMXXPI�WYT�

TSVX�EQSRK�QSVI�VIWTIGXEFPI�ERH�I\TIVMIRGIH�LYQER�VMKLXW�EHZSGEXIW�WMRGI�XLIVI�MW�RS�MRXIPPIGXYEPP]�SV�QSVEPP]�HIJIRWMFPI�GEWI�JSV�WMRKPMRK�SYX-WVEIP�JSV�HMZIWXMXYVI��9RMZIVWMXMIW�MRZIWX�MR�E�[MHI�EVVE]�SJ�GSQTERMIW�XLEX

Page 209: The Case For Israel

LEZI�STIVEXMSRW�MR�GSYRXVMIW�EPP�SZIV�XLI�[SVPH��MRGPYHMRK�QER]�XLEX�W]W�XIQEXMGEPP]�ZMSPEXI�XLI�LYQER�VMKLXW�SJ�QMPPMSRW�SJ�TISTPI��%RH�XLIWI�SXLIVGSYRXVMIW�EVI�RSX�HIJIRHMRK�XLIQWIPZIW�EKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LS�[SYPH�HIWXVS]XLIQ�ERH�XEVKIX�XLIMV�GMZMPMERW��=IX�XLMW�TIXMXMSR�JSGYWIW�SRP]�SR�XLI�.I[MWLWXEXI��XS�XLI�I\GPYWMSR�SJ�EPP�SXLIVW��MRGPYHMRK�XLSWI�[LMGL�F]�ER]�VIEWSR�EFPI�WXERHEVH�EVI�EGXYEPP]�EQSRK�XLI�[SVWX�ZMSPEXSVW�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�%W�ER�EHZSGEXI��XIEGLIV��ERH�WXYHIRX�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�JSV�EPQSWX�JSVX]

]IEVW��-�JIIP�GSRJMHIRX�MR�EWWIVXMRK�XLEX�-WVEIP¬W�VIGSVH�SR�LYQER�VMKLXW�MWEQSRK�XLI�FIWX�MR�XLI�[SVPH��IWTIGMEPP]�EQSRK�REXMSRW�XLEX�LEZI�GSR�JVSRXIH�GSQTEVEFPI�XLVIEXW��-WVEIP�LEW�XLI�SRP]�MRHITIRHIRX�NYHMGMEV]�MRXLI�IRXMVI�1MHHPI�)EWX�ERH�SRI�SJ�XLI�QSWX�LMKLP]�VIKEVHIH�WYTVIQIGSYVXW�MR�XLI�[SVPH��-X�MW�XLI�SRP]�GSYVX�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�JVSQ�[LMGL�ER%VEF�SV�E�1YWPMQ�GER�I\TIGX�NYWXMGI��EW�QER]�LEZI�MR�[MRRMRK�HSIRW�SJZMGXSVMIW�EKEMRWX�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX��XLI�-WVEIPM�QMPMXEV]��ERH�-WVEIPM�GMX�MIRW��8LIVI�MW�RS�QSVI�MQTSVXERX�GSQTSRIRX�MR�XLI�TVSXIGXMSR�SJ�LYQERVMKLXW�ERH�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�XLER�ER�MRHITIRHIRX�NYHMGMEV]�[MPPMRK�XS�WXERH�YTXS�MXW�S[R�KSZIVRQIRX��-�GLEPPIRKI�XLI�TVSTSRIRXW�SJ�HMZIWXMXYVI�XS�REQIE�GSYVX�MR�ER]�SXLIV�%VEF�SV�1YWPMQ�GSYRXV]�XLEX�MW�GSQTEVEFPI�XS�XLI-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�XVYI�HIQSGVEG]�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�ERH�XLI�SRP]�GSYR�

XV]�XLEX�LEW�ZMVXYEPP]�YRPMQMXIH�JVIIHSQ�SJ�WTIIGL��-XW�QIHME�EVI�KIRIVEPP]ZIV]�GVMXMGEP�SJ�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX��%R]�TIVWSR�MR�-WVEIP [LIXLIV�.I[MWL�1YWPMQ��SV�'LVMWXMER GER�GVMXMGMI�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�ERH�MXW�PIEHIVW�2S�GMXMIR�SJ�ER]�SXLIV�1MHIEWXIVR�SV�1YWPMQ�WXEXI�GER�HS�XLEX�[MXLSYXJIEV�SJ�MQTVMWSRQIRX�SV�HIEXL��2SV�GER�4EPIWXMRMERW�STIRP]�GVMXMGMI�XLIMVPIEHIVW�[MXLSYX�JIEV�SJ�VITVMWEP��%W�%VEJEX�JEQSYWP]�XLVIEXIRIH�XLI�QE]SVSJ�&IXLPILIQ��EJXIV�XLI�QE]SV�LEH�TVSTSWIH�E�XVYGI�XLEX�[SYPH�LEZILEPXIH�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ��©;LSIZIV�XLMROW�SJ�WXSTTMRK�XLI�-RXMJEHEFIJSVI�MX�EGLMIZIW�MXW�KSEP��-�[MPP�KMZI�LMQ����FYPPIXW�MR�XLI�GLIWX�ª�%VEJEXJMVWX�HIRMIH�IZIV�QEOMRK�WYGL�E�WXEXIQIRX��ERH�XLIR�[LIR�SYV�7XEXI(ITEVXQIRX�TVSHYGIH�E�XETI�VIGSVHMRK��%VEJEX�HIRMIH�MX�[EW�E�XLVIEX�*MREPP]��[LIR�%VEF�XVERWPEXSVW�WEMH�MX�GSYPH�LEZI�RS�SXLIV�QIERMRK��%VEJEXHIRMIH�XLEX�MX�[EW�HMVIGXIH�EX�XLI�QE]SV�FYX�VEXLIV�EX�LMQWIPJ��©-�WEMH�XLEXMJ�-�XVMIH�XS�WXST�XLI�MRXMJEHE��XLI�WQEPP�FS]�[LS�MW�WXERHMRK�FIWMHI�QI[SYPH�WLSSX�QI�ª�8LI�QE]SV�SJ�&IXLPILIQ�LEH�RS�HMJJMGYPX]�YRHIV�WXERHMRK�I\EGXP]�[LEX�%VEJEX�[EW�WE]MRK��LI�MQQIHMEXIP]�[MXLHVI[�LMW�TVS�TSWEP�JSV�E�XVYGI��3RI�[EK�VIGIRXP]�TYX�MX�XLMW�[E]��GMXMIRW�SJ�-WVEIP�ERHXLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�LEZI�I\EGXP]�XLI�WEQI�VMKLX�SJ�JVII�WTIIGL XLI]QE]�FSXL�GVMXMGMI�%VMIP�7LEVSR�ERH�TVEMWI�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�%W�TVIZMSYWP]�HSGYQIRXIH��-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�[SVPH�XLEX

LEW�STIRP]�GSRJVSRXIH�XLI�HMJJMGYPX�MWWYI�SJ�XLI�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�SJ�XLI�XMGOMRK�FSQF�XIVVSVMWX��VYPMRK�XLEX�HIWTMXI�XLI�TSXIRXMEP�FIRIJMXW�SJ�IQTPS]MRKTL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVI��WYGL�TVIWWYVI�MW�RS[�MPPIKEP��&VYXEP�XSVXYVI��MRGPYHMRK

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 210: The Case For Israel

PIXLEP�XSVXYVI��MW�GSQQSRTPEGI�MR�IZIV]�SXLIV�1MHIEWXIVR�ERH�1YWPMQGSYRXV]��-RHIIH��XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�WSQIXMQIW�WIRHW�WYWTIGXW�XS�)K]TX�.SVHER��ERH�XLI�4LMPMTTMRIW�TVIGMWIP]�FIGEYWI�MX�ORS[W�XLEX�XLI]�[MPP�FIXSVXYVIH�MR�XLSWI�GSYRXVMIW�8LIVI�MW�QSVI�KIRHIV��VIPMKMSYW��WI\YEP�SVMIRXEXMSR��ERH�IXLRMG�IUYEPMX]

MR�-WVEIP�XLIR�MR�ER]�SXLIV�1MHIEWXIVR�SV�1YWPMQ�GSYRXV]��8LI�VMKLXW�SJ[SQIR��KE]W��ERH�SXLIVW�EVI�JEV�QSVI�JYPP]�VIGSKRMIH�ERH�MQTPIQIRXIHMR�-WVEIP�XLER�ER][LIVI�MR�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH��8LI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�HSIW�RSX�HMW�GVMQMREXI�EKEMRWX�KE]W��EW�IZIR�XLI�9�7��%VQ]�HSIW��ERH�XLI�-WVEIPM�/RIW�WIX�RS[�MRGPYHIW�ER�STIRP]�KE]�QIQFIV���=IX�WMKRW�LEZI�FIIR�WIIR�EXERXM�-WVEIP�HIQSRWXVEXMSRW�VIEHMRK�©5YIIVW�JSV�4EPIWXMRI�ª�HIWTMXI�XLI�VIEP�MX]�XLEX�MJ�ER]SRI�[IVI�XS�HMWTPE]�WYGL�E�WMKR�MR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�LI�[SYPH�VMWO�FIMRK�OMPPIH��-RHIIH��KE]�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�[IVI�XSVXYVIHFIGEYWI�SJ�XLIMV�WI\YEP�SVMIRXEXMSR�LEZI�WSYKLX�EW]PYQ�MR�-WVEIP� �-WVEIPM%VEFW�WMX�MR�XLI�/RIWWIX��WIVZI�SR�XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX��ERH�LEZIXLIMV�S[R�RI[WTETIVW��8LI�PMWX�GSYPH�KS�SR�ERH�SR��ERH�F]�IZIV]�WMRKPIWXERHEVH�-WVEIP�[SYPH�WYVTEWW�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW�EKEMRWX�[LMGL�RS�HMZIWXMXYVITIXMXMSR�LEW�FIIR�HMVIGXIH��8S�FI�WYVI��-WVEIP�MW�JEV�JVSQ�TIVJIGX��-�LEZIFIIR�GVMXMGEP�SJ�WSQI�SJ�MXW�TSPMGMIW��FYX�XLIVI�EVI�QIGLERMWQW�[MXLMR�-WVEIPJSV�MQTVSZMRK�MXW�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW�ERH�LYQER�VMKLXW�VIGSVH��8LIWI�QIGLE�RMWQW�HS�RSX�I\MWX�MR�SXLIV�1MHIEWXIVR�ERH�1YWPMQ�REXMSRW�)ZIR�[LIR�NYHKIH�EKEMRWX�)YVSTIER�REXMSRW��-WVEIP¬W�LYQER�VMKLXW

VIGSVH�HSIW�ZIV]�[IPP��-X�MW�JEV�FIXXIV�XLER�XLEX�SJ�*VERGI�SR�ZMVXYEPP]�ER]GVMXIVMSR��IZIR�MJ�SRI�JSVKIXW�EFSYX�XLI�%PKIVMER�;EV��MR�[LMGL�XLI�*VIRGLXSVXYVIH�ERH�QYVHIVIH�XLSYWERHW�SJ�TISTPI��-X�MW�EX�PIEWX�EW�KSSH�EW�XLI&VMXMWL�VIGSVH�MR�HIEPMRK�[MXL�XIVVSVMWQ�MR�2SVXLIVR�-VIPERH�ERH�XLI�9�7�VIGSVH�SJ�HIEPMRK�[MXL�EP�5EIHE�XIVVSVMWQ��8LI�-WVEIPM�PIKEP�W]WXIQ�MW�JEVWYTIVMSV�XS�XLSWI�SJ�-XEP]��7TEMR��ERH�QER]�SXLIV�)YVSTIER�GSYRXVMIW��ERHEX�PIEWX�EW�KSSH�EW�XLI�W]WXIQ�MR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�8LIVI�EVI��SJ�GSYVWI��HMJJMGYPX�MWWYIW�XS�FI�VIWSPZIH�FIX[IIR�-WVEIP�ERH

XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��8LIWI�MRGPYHI�XLI�WIXXPIQIRXW��XLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�SJ�4EPIW�XMRMER�WIPJ�KSZIVRERGI��ERH�XLI�TVIZIRXMSR�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ��8LIWI�MWWYIW�[MPPVIUYMVI�GSQTVSQMWI�SR�EPP�WMHIW��%R]�%QIVMGER�WLSYPH�GIVXEMRP]�JIIP�JVIIXS�GVMXMGMI�-WVEIP��EW�[IPP�EW�ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�[SVPH�[LSWI�VIGSVHSR�LYQER�VMKLXW�MW�RSX�TIVJIGX��&YX�XS�WMRKPI�SYX�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIPEW�MJ�MX�[IVI�XLI�[SVWX�LYQER�VMKLXW�SJJIRHIV�MW�FMKSXV]�TYVI�ERH�WMQTPI�ERH�XLSWI�[LS�WMKR�XLI�'LSQWO]�MRWTMVIH�TIXMXMSR�WLSYPH�FI�EWLEQIH�SJXLIQWIPZIW�ERH�WLEQIH�F]�SXLIVW�-�LEZI�SJJIVIH�ER�EPXIVREXMZI�XS�WMRKPMRK�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�HMZIWXMXYVI��0IX

YRMZIVWMXMIW�MRZIWX�XLIMV�JYRHW�MR�XLI�SVHIVSJ�XLI�LYQER�VMKLXW�VIGSVHW�SJXLI�ZEVMSYW�GSYRXVMIW��-J�XLEX�[IVI�XS�FI�HSRI��MRZIWXQIRX�MR�-WVEIP�[SYPHMRGVIEWI�HVEQEXMGEPP]��[LMPI�MRZIWXQIRXW�MR�7EYHM�%VEFME��)K]TX��.SVHER�XLI�4LMPMTTMRIW��-RHSRIWME��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��ERH�QSWX�SXLIV

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 211: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

GSYRXVMIW�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�[SYPH�HIGVIEWI�HVEQEXMGEPP]��%R�EPXIVREXMZI�[SYPHFI�XS�MRZIWX�MR�XLI�SVHIV�SJ�XLI�TIVQMXXIH�HIKVII�SJ�MRXIVREPGVMXMGMWQ�SJXLI�REXMSR¬W�LYQER�VMKLXW�VIGSVH��8LI�XLISV]�FILMRH�XLMW�ZEVMEXMSR�MW�XLEXHMZIWXMXYVI��[LMGL�MW�ER�I\XIVREPTVIWWYVI��MW�QSWX�RIIHIH�JSV�GSYRXVMIW�XLEXXSPIVEXI�RS�MRXIVREPTVIWWYVIW�JSV�GLERKI��9RHIV�XLMW�ETTVSEGL��MRZIWXQIRXMR�-WVEIP�[SYPH�EPWS�WO]VSGOIX�-R�E�XEPO�EX�XLI�GEQTYW�1IQSVMEP�'LYVGL�MR�������,EVZEVH¬W�TVIWM�

HIRX��0E[VIRGI�7YQQIVW��GSRHIQRIH�XLI�HMZIWXMXYVI�GEQTEMKR�ERHSXLIV�IJJSVXW�EX�WMRKPMRK�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�GSRWMHIVEXMSR��,I�FIKER�LMW�XEPO�F]VIQMRHMRK�LMW�EYHMIRGI�SJ�©WSQI�SJ�XLI�KPSFEP�IZIRXW�SJ�XLI�PEWX�]IEVª�

�8LIVI�LEZI�FIIR�W]REKSKYI�FYVRMRKW��TL]WMGEP�EWWEYPXW�SR�.I[W��SV�XLI

TEMRXMRK�SJ�W[EWXMOEW�SR�.I[MWL�QIQSVMEPW�MR�IZIV]�GSYRXV]�MR�)YVSTI�

3FWIVZIVW�MR�QER]�GSYRXVMIW�LEZI�TSMRXIH�XS�XLI�[SVWX�SYXFVIEO�SJ

EXXEGOW�EKEMRWX�XLI�.I[W�WMRGI�XLI�7IGSRH�;SVPH�;EV�

�'ERHMHEXIW�[LS�HIRMIH�XLI�WMKRMJMGERGI�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�VIEGLIH�XLI

VYRSJJ�WXEKI�SJ�IPIGXMSRW�JSV�XLI�REXMSR¬W�LMKLIWX�SJJMGI�MR�*VERGI�ERH

(IRQEVO��7XEXI�WTSRWSVIH�XIPIZMWMSR�WXEXMSRW�MR�QER]�REXMSRW�SJ�XLI

[SVPH�WTI[�ERXM�>MSRMWX�TVSTEKERHE�

�8LI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW¬§WTSRWSVIH�;SVPH�'SRJIVIRGI�SR�6EGMWQ [LMPI

JEMPMRK�XS�QIRXMSR�LYQER�VMKLXW�EFYWIW�MR�'LMRE��6[ERHE��SV�ER]TPEGI

MR�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH WTSOI�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�TSPMGMIW�TVMSV�XS�VIGIRX�WXVYKKPIW

YRHIV�XLI�&EVEO�KSZIVRQIRX�EW�GSRWXMXYXMRK�IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK�ERH

GVMQIW�EKEMRWX�LYQERMX]��8LI�2+3�HIGPEVEXMSR�EX�XLI�WEQI�GSRJIVIRGI

[EW�IZIR�QSVI�ZMVYPIRX�

7YQQIVW�XLIR�HMWGYWWIH�MWWYIW�GPSWIV�XS�LSQI�

3J�GSYVWI�EGEHIQMG�GSQQYRMXMIW�WLSYPH�FI�ERH�EP[E]W�[MPP�FI�TPEGIW�XLEX

EPPS[�ER]�ZMI[TSMRX�XS�FI�I\TVIWWIH��%RH�GIVXEMRP]�XLIVI�MW�QYGL�XS�FI

HIFEXIH�EFSYX�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�ERH�QYGL�MR�-WVEIP¬W�JSVIMKR�ERH�HIJIRWI

TSPMG]�XLEX�GER�FI�ERH�WLSYPH�FI�ZMKSVSYWP]�GLEPPIRKIH�

&YX�[LIVI�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�ERH�ZMI[W�XLEX�EVI�TVSJSYRHP]�ERXM�-WVEIPM

LEZI�XVEHMXMSREPP]�FIIR�XLI�TVMQEV]�TVIWIVZI�SJ�TSSVP]�IHYGEXIH�VMKLX�

[MRK�TSTYPMWXW��TVSJSYRHP]�ERXM�-WVEIP�ZMI[W�EVI�MRGVIEWMRKP]�JMRHMRK�WYT�

TSVX�MR�TVSKVIWWMZI�MRXIPPIGXYEP�GSQQYRMXMIW��7IVMSYW�ERH�XLSYKLXJYP

TISTPI�EVI�EHZSGEXMRK�ERH�XEOMRK�EGXMSRW�XLEX�EVI�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MR�XLIMV

IJJIGX�MJ�RSX�XLIMV�MRXIRX�

7YQQIVW�KEZI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�I\EQTPIW�

�,YRHVIHW�SJ�)YVSTIER�EGEHIQMGW�LEZI�GEPPIH�JSV�ER�IRH�XS�WYTTSVX�JSV

-WVEIPM�VIWIEVGLIVW��XLSYKL�RSX�JSV�ER�IRH�XS�WYTTSVX�JSV�VIWIEVGLIVW

JVSQ�ER]�SXLIV�REXMSR�

Page 212: The Case For Israel

�-WVEIPM�WGLSPEVW�XLMW�TEWX�WTVMRK�[IVI�JSVGIH�SJJ�XLI�FSEVH�SJ�ER�MRXIV�

REXMSREP�PMXIVEXYVI�NSYVREP�

�%X�XLI�WEQI�VEPPMIW�[LIVI�TVSXIWXIVW��QER]�SJ�XLIQ�YRMZIVWMX]�WXYHIRXW�

GSRHIQR�XLI�-1*�ERH�KPSFEP�GETMXEPMWQ�ERH�VEMWI�UYIWXMSRW�EFSYX

KPSFEPMEXMSR��MX�MW�FIGSQMRK�MRGVIEWMRKP]�GSQQSR�XS�EPWS�PEWL�SYX�EX

-WVEIP��-RHIIH��EX�XLI�ERXM�-1*�VEPPMIW�PEWX�WTVMRK��GLERXW�[IVI�LIEVH

IUYEXMRK�,MXPIV�ERH�7LEVSR�

�)ZIRXW�XS�VEMWI�JYRHW�JSV�SVKERMEXMSRW�SJ�UYIWXMSREFPI�TSPMXMGEP�TVSZI�

RERGI�XLEX�MR�WSQI�GEWIW�[IVI�PEXIV�JSYRH�XS�WYTTSVX�XIVVSVMWQ�LEZI

FIIR�LIPH�F]�WXYHIRX�SVKERMEXMSRW�SR�XLMW�ERH�SXLIV�GEQTYWIW�[MXL�EX

PIEWX�QSHIWX�WYGGIWW�ERH�ZIV]�PMXXPI�GVMXMGMWQ�

�%RH�WSQI�LIVI�EX�,EVZEVH�ERH�WSQI�EX�YRMZIVWMXMIW�EGVSWW�XLI�GSYRXV]

LEZI�GEPPIH�JSV�XLI�9RMZIVWMX]�XS�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP�EQSRK�EPP�REXMSRW�EW

XLI�PSRI�GSYRXV]�[LIVI�MX�MW�MRETTVSTVMEXI�JSV�ER]�TEVX�SJ�XLI�YRMZIV�

WMX]¬W�IRHS[QIRX�XS�FI�MRZIWXIH��-�LEWXIR�XS�WE]�XLI�9RMZIVWMX]�LEW�GEX�

IKSVMGEPP]�VINIGXIH�XLMW�WYKKIWXMSR�

*MREPP]��7YQQIVW�HIJIRHIH�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�ER]SRI�XS�GVMXMGMI�-WVEIP�ERH�ER]SXLIV�REXMSR�SV�MRWXMXYXMSR�

;I�WLSYPH�EP[E]W�VIWTIGX�XLI�EGEHIQMG�JVIIHSQ�SJ�IZIV]SRI�XS�XEOI�ER]

TSWMXMSR��;I�WLSYPH�EPWS�VIGEPP�XLEX�EGEHIQMG�JVIIHSQ�HSIW�RSX�MRGPYHI

JVIIHSQ�JVSQ�GVMXMGMWQ��8LI�SRP]�ERXMHSXI�XS�HERKIVSYW�MHIEW�MW�WXVSRK

EPXIVREXMZIW�ZMKSVSYWP]�EHZSGEXIH��-�LEZI�EP[E]W�XLVSYKLSYX�Q]�PMJI�FIIR

TYX�SJJ�F]�XLSWI�[LS�LIEVH�XLI�WSYRH�SJ�FVIEOMRK�KPEWW�MR�IZIV]�MRWYPX�SV

WPMKLX��ERH�GSRNYVIH�YT�MQEKIW�SJ�,MXPIV¬W�/VMWXEPPREGLX�EX�ER]�HMWEKVII�

QIRX�[MXL�-WVEIP��7YGL�ZMI[W�LEZI�EP[E]W�WIIQIH�XS�QI�EPEVQMWX�MJ�RSX

WPMKLXP]�L]WXIVMGEP��&YX�-�LEZI�XS�WE]�XLEX�[LMPI�XLI]�WXMPP�WIIQ�XS�QI

YR[EVVERXIH��XLI]�WIIQ�VEXLIV�PIWW�EPEVQMWX�MR�XLI�[SVPH�SJ�XSHE]�XLER

XLI]�HMH�E�]IEV�EKS�

8LMW�FEPERGIH�TVIWIRXEXMSR�PIH�XS�2SEQ�'LSQWO]�MRGPYHMRK�7YQQIVWMR�XLI�GEXIKSV]�SJ�©I\XVIQMWXW�[LS�[ERX�XS�QE\MQMI�9�7��-WVEIPM�EXVSGMXMIWERH�GVMQIW�ª�-X�EPWS�PIH�&VMXMWL�NSYVREPMWX�6SFIVX�*MWO�XS�EGGYWI�7YQ�QIVW [LS�LI�HIWGVMFIH�EW�©XLI�.I[MWL�TVIWMHIRX�SJ�,EVZEVHª SJ�TEV�XMGMTEXMRK�MR�E�©ZMGMSYW�GEQTEMKR�SJ�WPERHIV�?EKEMRWXA�ER]SRI�[LS�HEVIW�XSGVMXMGMI�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW�ª�

-�[VSXI�E�GSPYQR�MR�WYTTSVX�SJ�4VIWMHIRX�7YQQIVW��MR�[LMGL�-�GLEP�PIRKIH�E�LSYWIQEWXIV�EX�,EVZEVH�[LS�LEH�WMKRIH�XLI�TIXMXMSR�XS�E�HIFEXI�

-R�Q]����]IEVW�SJ�XIEGLMRK�EX�,07��-�HSR¬X�VIGEPP�IZIV�[VMXMRK�MR�TVEMWI�SJ

ER]�EGXMSR�F]�E�,EVZEVH�4VIWMHIRX��FYX�XLMW�XMQI�-�QYWX�GSRKVEXYPEXI

4VIWMHIRX�0E[VIRGI�7YQQIVW�JSV�LMW�[MPPMRKRIWW�XS�WE]�SYX�PSYH�[LEX

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 213: The Case For Israel

QER]�SJ�YW�MR�XLI�,EVZEVH�GSQQYRMX]�LEZI�PSRK�FIPMIZIH��REQIP]��XLEX

WMRKPMRK�SYX�-WVEIP��EQSRK�EPP�XLI�GSYRXVMIW�MR�XLI�[SVPH��JSV�HMZIWXQIRX�

MW�ER�EGXMSR�[LMGL�MW�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MR�IJJIGX��MJ�RSX�MR�MRXIRX�

9RMZIVWMXMIW�WLSYPH�IRGSYVEKI�[MHIWTVIEH�HIFEXI�ERH�HMWGYWWMSR

EFSYX�HMZMWMZI�ERH�GSRXVSZIVWMEP�MWWYIW��%�LSYWIQEWXIV�[LS�TIVIQTXSVMP]

WMKRW�E�TIXMXMSR�ERH�XLIR�LMHIW�FILMRH�©SXLIV�TVMSVMXMIWª�HSIW�RSX�WIVZI

XLI�MRXIVIWXW�SJ�HMEPSKYI�ERH�IHYGEXMSR��-�LSTI�XLEX�?LIA�[MPP�EGGITX�Q]

GLEPPIRKI��ERH�XLEX�MJ�?LI�HSIWA�RSX��-�[MPP�FI�MRZMXIH�F]�?LMWA�WXYHIRXW�XS

LIPT�JMPP�XLI�IHYGEXMSREP�KET�PIJX�F]�XLI�GS[EVHMGI�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�LEZI

WMKRIH�XLMW�TIXMXMSR�ERH�VIJYWI�XS�HIJIRH�XLIMV�EGXMSRW�MR�TYFPMG�HIFEXI�

,MW�WXYHIRXW�HMH�MRZMXI�QI�FYX�LI�VIJYWIH�XS�TEVXMGMTEXI�MR�ER]�HIFEXI�SVHMWGYWWMSR��ERH�-�©HIFEXIHª�ER�IQTX]�GLEMV�[MXL�E�GST]�SJ�XLI�TIXMXMSR�MRJVSRX�SJ�LMW�WXYHIRXW�EX�;MRXLVST�,SYWI�4VIWMHIRX�0II�&SPPMRKIV�SJ�'SPYQFME�9RMZIVWMX]�EPWS�HIRSYRGIH�XLI

HMZIWXQIRX�TIXMXMSR��VIWTSRHMRK�XS�XLSWI�[LS�GSQTEVIH�MX�XS�WMQMPEV�TIXM�XMSRW�EKEMRWX�7SYXL�%JVMGER�ETEVXLIMH��LI�GLEVEGXIVMIH�XLI�EREPSK]�XS-WVEIP�EW�©FSXL�KVSXIWUYI�ERH�SJJIRWMZI�ª�8LVII�LYRHVIH�SXLIV�GSPPIKI�ERHYRMZIVWMX]�TVIWMHIRXW�I\TVIWWIH�GSRGIVR�SZIV�MRXMQMHEXMSR�ERH�LEXVIHHMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�.I[MWL�WYTTSVXIVW�SJ�-WVEIP�SR�QER]�GEQTYWIW��-�[VSXI�XLIJSPPS[MRK�MR�WYTTSVX�SJ�XLIMV�WXEXIQIRX�

8LIVI�EVI�WSQI�[LS�EVKYI�XLEX�XLI�4VIWMHIRXW¬�EH�[MPP�GLMPP�GEQTYW

HIFEXI��5YMXI�XLI�STTSWMXI�MW�XVYI��8LI�EH��EPSRK�[MXL�,EVZEVH�4VIWMHIRX

0E[VIRGI�7YQQIVW¬�WXEXIQIRX�XLEX�XLI�HMZIWXMXYVI�GEQTEMKR�MW�ERXM�

7IQMXMG�MR�MXW�IJJIGX��LEW�WXMQYPEXIH�LIEPXL]�HIFEXI�

4VIWMHIRX�7YQQIVW�[IRX�SYX�SJ�LMW�[E]�XS�QEOI�MX�GPIEV�XLEX�GVMXMGMWQ

SJ�-WVEIP�MW�RSX�ERXM�7IQMXMG��IMXLIV�MR�MRXIRX�SV�IJJIGX��2S�SRI�-�ORS[�MW

WIIOMRK�XS�WXMJPI�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�SV�SJ�XLI�GYVVIRX�KSZIVRQIRX��SV�XS

GLMPP�WYTTSVX�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXILSSH�ERH�LYQER�VMKLXW�

;LEXMWXLI�IUYMZEPIRX�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�MW�XLI�WMRKPMRK�SYX�SJ�XLI�.I[�

MWL�REXMSR�JSV�HMZIWXQIRX��FS]GSXX��9�2��GSRHIQREXMSR�SV�SXLIV�WERG�

XMSRW��MR�JEGI�SJ��ERH�HIWTMXI�MXW�JEV�FIXXIV�VIGSVH�SR�LYQER�VMKLXW�XLER

ER]�SXLIV�REXMSR�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�ERH�QSWX�SXLIV�REXMSRW�MR�XLI�[SVPH�

-X�MW�GIVXEMRP]�TSWWMFPI�XLEX�WSQI�[LS�LEZI�WMKRIH�XLI�HMZIWXMXYVI�SV

FS]GSXX�TIXMXMSRW�HS�RSX�FIPMIZI�XLEX�XLIMV�EGXMSRW�EVI�ERXM�7IQMXMG��8LI]

QE]�FI�MKRSVERX�SJ�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�XLI]�EVI�FIMRK�YWIH�F]�IRIQMIW�SJ

-WVEIP�[LS�[SYPH�HIPIKMXMQEXI�ERH�MWSPEXI�XLI�[SVPH¬W�SRP]�.I[MWL

REXMSR��8LI�VIGIRX�GEQTEMKRW�JSV�HMZIWXMXYVI�ERH�FS]GSXX�KVS[�SYX�SJ

X[S�IEVPMIV�GEQTEMKRW�XLEX�[IVI�YRHSYFXIHP]�QSXMZEXIH�F]�E�HIWMVI�XS

HIWXVS]�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��8LI�JMVWX�[EW�XLI�%VEF�FS]GSXX��[LMGL�PEWXIH�JSV

QER]�]IEVW�ERH�[EW�JMREPP]�HIJIEXIH��8LI�WIGSRH�[EW�XLI�RS[�HMWGVIHMXIH

9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�VIWSPYXMSR�IUYEXMRK�>MSRMWQ�[MXL�VEGMWQ��8LI�GYVVIRX

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 214: The Case For Israel

IJJSVXW�XS�IUYEXI�-WVEIP�[MXL�XLI�ETEVXLIMH�VIKMQI�SJ�7SYXL�%JVMGE�[MPP�EPWS

JEMP��FIGEYWI�XLI�EREPSK]�MW�HIQSRWXVEFP]�JEPWI��8LI�KSEP�SJ�XLMW�GEQTEMKR

MW�RSX�EGXYEPP]�XS�EGLMIZI�HMZIWXMXYVI��FYX�VEXLIV�XS�QMWIHYGEXI�]SYRK�ERH

MQTVIWWMSREFPI�GSPPIKI�WXYHIRXW�MRXS�FIPMIZMRK�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�EQSRK�XLI

[SVWX�LYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXSVW�MR�XLI�[SVPH��HIWTMXI�MXW�KIRIVEPP]�WYTIVF

VIGSVH�SR�LYQER�VMKLXW�ERH�MXW�KVIEX�GSRGIVR�JSV�QMRMQMMRK�GMZMPMER

GEWYEPXMIW�F]�I\TSWMRK�MXW�S[R�WSPHMIVW�XS�XLI�VMWOW�SJ�HSSV�XS�HSSV

©VIXEMPª�JMKLXMRK��VEXLIV�XLER�©[LSPIWEPIª�FSQFMRK�SJ�XLI�OMRH�HSRI�F]

QER]�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW��MRGPYHMRK�SYV�S[R��8LI�JEGX�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]

GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�[MXL�JVIIHSQ�SJ�I\TVIWWMSR��ER�MRHITIRHIRX

NYHMGMEV]��E�GSQQMXQIRX�XS�XLI�IUYEPMX]�SJ�[SQIR�ERH�KE]W�EVI�EPP

MKRSVIH�MR�XLMW�IJJSVX�XS�MWSPEXI�-WVEIP��-KRSVERGI�QE]�FI�E�HIJIRWI�XS�FMK�

SXV]��FYX�MX�LEW�RS�TPEGI�SR�E�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYW�

8LI�MQQSVEP�GEQTEMKR�SR�GEQTYWIW�EKEMRWX�.I[W�[LS�WYTTSVX�-WVEIP

QYWX�FI�GSQFEXIH�MR�XLI�QEVOIXTPEGI�SJ�MHIEW��8LI�4VIWMHIRXW¬�PIXXIV�MW

ER�MQTSVXERX�GSQTSRIRX�SJ�XLMW�WXVYKKPI�EKEMRWX�FMKSXV]��8SS�QER]�KSSH

TISTPI�EVI�VIQEMRMRK�WMPIRX�MR�XLI�JEGI�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��-X�MW�XMQI�XS

WXERH�YT�ERH�FI�GSYRXIH�

-X�[EW�GPIEV�JVSQ�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�XLI�ERXM�-WVEIPHMZIWXQIRX�TIXMXMSR�XLEX�RS�QENSV�%QIVMGER�YRMZIVWMX]�[SYPH�WIVMSYWP]GSRWMHIV�HMZIWXMRK�JVSQ�-WVEIP��8LSWI�[LS�MRMXMEXIH�XLI�HMZIWXQIRX�GEQ�TEMKR�[IVI��SJ�GSYVWI��E[EVI�SJ�XLMW�VIEPMX]��%GXYEP�HMZIWXQIRX�[EW�RSX�XLIKSEP�SJ�XLI�GEQTEMKR��-XW�KSEP�[EW�XS�QMWIHYGEXI�ERH�QMWMRJSVQ�WXYHIRXWEVSYRH�XLI�[SVPH�EFSYX�-WVEIP¬W�LYQER�VMKLXW�VIGSVH��%JXIVQSWX�SJ�XLIWMKREXYVIW�LEH�EPVIEH]�FIIR�WIGYVIH��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�ZMVXYEPP]�EHQMXXIHXLMW�[LIR�LI�XSPH�E�,EVZEVH�EYHMIRGI�XLEX�EPXLSYKL�LI�LEH�WMKRIHMRHIIH�WTIEVLIEHIH XLI�ERXM�-WVEIP�HMZIWXQIRX�TIXMXMSR��LI�[EW�EGXYEPP]STTSWIHXS�HMZIWXQIRX�JVSQ�-WVEIP��'LSQWO]�WEMH��©-�EQ�STTSWIH�ERH�LEZIFIIR�STTSWIH�JSV�QER]�]IEVW��MR�JEGX��-¬ZI�TVSFEFP]�FIIR�XLI�PIEHMRKSTTSRIRX�JSV�]IEVW�SJ�XLI�GEQTEMKR�JSV�HMZIWXQIRX�JVSQ�-WVEIP�ERH�SJ�XLIGEQTEMKR�EFSYX�EGEHIQMG�FS]GSXXW�ª�,I�EPWS�HIGPEVIH�MX�XS�FI�©[VSRK�MRTVMRGMTPIª�ERH�©YRTVMRGMTPIH�ª�

;LIR�EWOIH�[L]�LI�WMKRIH�XLI�HMZIWXQIRX�TIXMXMSR�MR�ZMI[�SJ�LMW�TVMR�GMTPIH�STTSWMXMSR�XS�HMZIWXQIRX��XLI�VIRS[RIH�PMRKYMWX�I\TPEMRIH��©2SSRI�[LS�WMKRW�E�TIXMXMSR�MW�I\TIGXIH�XS�ETTVSZI�SJ�IZIV]�[SVH��IZIR�SJPEVKI�TEVXW��MJ�XLI�QEMR�XLVYWX�MW�ETTVSTVMEXI�ERH�WYJJMGMIRXP]�MQTSVXERX�ª�

&YX��SJ�GSYVWI��HMZIWXQIRX�MW�XLI�QEMR�XLVYWX�SJ�XLI�TIXMXMSR EX�PIEWX�XSQER]�[LS�EKVIIH�XS�WMKR�MX��&YX�RSX�XS�'LSQWO]��[LSWI�WIGVIX�EKIRHEXLI�HIPIKMXMQEXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�XLVSYKL�XLI�WTVIEH�SJ�HMWMRJSVQEXMSR LI�HMHRSX�WLEVI�[MXL�XLI�WMKREXSVMIW��,I�OITX�LMW�STTSWMXMSR�WIGVIX�JVSQ�QSWX�SJXLI�WMKREXSVMIW�YRXMP�EJXIV�XLIMV�WMKREXYVIW�LEH�FIIR�SFXEMRIH�%PXLSYKL�'LSQWO]�IZIRXYEPP]�GLEVEGXIVMIH�XLI�GEPP�JSV�HMZIWXQIRX�EW

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 215: The Case For Israel

©E�FMK�QMWXEOI�ª�LI�[SYPH�RSX EW�WSQI�TVSJIWWSVW�LEZI�RS[�HSRIVIQSZI�LMW�MRJPYIRXMEP�REQI�JVSQ�MX��WMRGI�LI�FIPMIZIW�XLEX�MXW�WYFWXERXMZIHIQERHW�EVI�ZEPMH��&YX�EVI�XLI]#�%�GPSWI�PSSO�EX�XLI�HIQERHW�XLIQWIPZIWHIQSRWXVEXIW�XLEX�XLI]�EVI�FSKYW�SR�XLIMV�JEGI IZIR�[MXLSYX�ER]�GSQ�TEVMWSR�[MXL�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIW�8LI�TIXMXMSR�HIQERHW�XLEX�-WVEIP�GSQTP]�[MXL�9�2��6IWSPYXMSR�����

XLI9�2��'SQQMXXII�%KEMRWX�8SVXYVI������6ITSVX�XLI�*SYVXL�+IRIZE'SRZIRXMSR��ERH�9�2��6IWSPYXMSR�����[MXL�VIWTIGX�XS�XLI�VMKLXW�SJVIJYKIIW��%TTEVIRXP]��QSWX�SJ�XLI�WMKREXSVMIW�SJ�XLMW�TIXMXMSR��[LMGLMRGPYHIH�����,EVZEVH�ERH�1-8�JEGYPX]�QIQFIVW�EX�PEWX�GSYRX��EVIYRE[EVI�SJ�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�EPVIEH]GSQTPMIH�[MXL�SV�LEW�SJJIVIH�XSGSQTP]�[MXL�IEGL�SJ�XLIWI�GSRHMXMSRW�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�6IWSPYXMSR������SRI�SJ�[LSWI�HVEJXWQIR�[EW�XLI�ZIV]

PMFIVEP�.YWXMGI�%VXLYV�+SPHFIVK��JSV�[LSQ�-�LEH�WIVZIH�EW�E�PE[�GPIVO �HSIW�RSX�GEPP�SR�-WVEIP�XS�KMZI�FEGO�EPPSJ�XLI�XIVVMXSVMIW�GETXYVIH�HYVMRKXLI�HIJIRWMZI�[EV�SJ�������8LI�GSQTVSQMWI�EKVIIH�XS�F]�XLI�7IGYVMX]'SYRGMP�[EW�XLEX�-WVEIP�[SYPH�KMZI�FEGO�©XIVVMXSVMIWª QIERMRK�QSWX�FYXRSX�EPPMR�I\GLERKI�JSV�GSQTPIXI�XIVQMREXMSR�SJ�EPP�GPEMQW�SV�WXEXIW�SJ�FIP�PMKIVIRG]�F]�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW��%�VIWSPYXMSR�TYX�JSV[EVH�F]�XLI�7SZMIX�9RMSRERH�MXW�GPMIRX�WXEXIW�GEPPMRK�JSV�-WVEIP�XS�[MXLHVE[�JVSQ�EPP�XLI�XIVVMXSVMIW[EW�RSX�EHSTXIH�&SXL�.YWXMGI�+SPHFIVK�ERH�0SVH�'EVVMRKXSR�SJ�&VMXEMR��XLI�TVMQEV]

HVEJXIVW�SJ�XLI�VIWSPYXMSR�XLEX�[EW�EGGITXIH��LEZI�WXEXIH�YREQFMKYSYWP]XLEX�MX�HMH�RSX�GSRXIQTPEXI�[MXLHVE[EP�JVSQ�©EPP�XLI�XIVVMXSVMIW�ª�VIGSK�RMMRK��EW�0SVH�'EVVMRKXSR�TYX�MX��©MX�[SYPH�LEZI�FIIR�[VSRK�XS�HIQERHXLEX�-WVEIP�VIXYVR�XS�MXW�TSWMXMSRW�SJ�.YRI����������FIGEYWI�XLIWI�TSWMXMSRW[IVI�YRHIWMVEFPI�ERH�EVXMJMGMEP�ª�8LI�SRP]�X[S�GSYRXVMIW�XLEX�LEZI�QIX�XLIGSRHMXMSR�JSV�E�VIXYVR�SJ�GETXYVIH�XIVVMXSVMIW REQIP]�E�GSQTPIXI�XIVQM�REXMSR�SJ�FIPPMKIVIRG]�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP EVI�)K]TX�ERH�.SVHER�%W�TVIZMSYWP]�HSGYQIRXIH��-WVEIP�VIXYVRIH�IZIV]�MRGL�SJ�PERH�WSYKLX�F]

)K]TX�[LIR�)K]TX�VIRSYRGIH�FIPPMKIVIRG]��ERH�.SVHER�LEW�EFERHSRIHEPQSWX�EPP�SJ�XLI�GPEMQW�XS�PERH�RS[�SGGYTMIH�F]�-WVEIP��8LI�WQEPP�EVIE�XLEX[EW�GPEMQIH�F]�.SVHER�[EW�VIXYVRIH�EW�WSSR�EW�MX�QEHI�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP�ERH�E�XMR]�EVIE�MR�HMWTYXI�FIX[IIR�)K]TX�ERH�-WVEIP�[EW�WYFQMXXIH�XS�EVFM�XVEXMSR�ERH�-WVEIP�XYVRIH�MX�SZIV�XS�)K]TX�[LIR�XLI�EVFMXVEXSV�VYPIH�MRJEZSV�SJ�)K]TX�1SVISZIV��MR�XLI�]IEV�������EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE��-WVEIP�SJJIVIH�XS

KMZI�YT�FIX[IIR����TIVGIRX�ERH����TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�HMWTYXIH�PERH�SR�XLI;IWX�&ERO�ERH�EPP�SJ�XLI�+EE�7XVMT�ERH�XS�EGGITX�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��8LEXSJJIV��XSKIXLIV�[MXL�XLI�VIXYVR�SJ�XLI�XIVVMXSVMIW�XS�)K]TX�ERH�.SVHER�[SYPH�LEZI�PIJX�-WVEIP�MR�TSWWIWWMSR�SJ�E�XMR]�TIVGIRXEKI�SJ�XLI�PERHVIJIVVIH�XS�F]�6IWSPYXMSR������SXLIV�XLER�XLI�+SPER�,IMKLXW��[LMGL�-WVEIP�LEW�SJJIVIH�XS�VIXYVR�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�TIEGI�[MXL�7]VME ��-X�WYVIP]

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 216: The Case For Israel

GSRWXMXYXIH�JYPP�GSQTPMERGI�[MXL�XLI�PERKYEKI�SJ�6IWSPYXMSR�����SR�XLITEVX�SJ�-WVEIP��&YX�XLIVI�LEW�FIIR�RS�GSQTPMERGI�[MXL�6IWSPYXMSR�����F]XLI�VINIGXMSRMWX�%VEF�WXEXIW�ERH�SVKERMEXMSRW��[LMGL�GSRXMRYI�XS�LSPHWXEXIW�SJ�FIPPMKIVIRG]�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP��=IX�XLI�HMZIWXMXYVI�TIXMXMSR�MQTSWIW�RSGSRHMXMSRW�SR�XLIWI�WXEXIW��QER]�SJ�[LMGL�EPWS�VIGIMZI�9�7��JSVIMKR�EMH�ERHMRZIWXQIRXW�JVSQ�,EVZEVH�ERH�SXLIV�YRMZIVWMXMIW�8LI�WIGSRH�HIQERH�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP�IRH�XLI�YWI�SJ�©PIKEP�XSVXYVI�ª�EW�SYX�

PMRIH�MR�XLI�9�2��'SQQMXXII�%KEMRWX�8SVXYVI������6ITSVX�8LI�[VMXIVW�SJXLMW�GSRHMXMSR�EVI�IMXLIV�MKRSVERX�SV�QIRHEGMSYW��%W�TVIZMSYWP]�HSGY�QIRXIH��X[S�]IEVW�FIJSVI�XLI�TIXMXMSR�[EW�GMVGYPEXIH�XLI�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI'SYVX�SYXPE[IH�XLI�YWI�SJ�EPP�TL]WMGEP�TVIWWYVI�MR�IPMGMXMRK�MRJSVQEXMSRJVSQ�TSXIRXMEP�XIVVSVMWXW��-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SRP]�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�XSLEZI�EFSPMWLIH�ER]�OMRH�SJ�XSVXYVI��MR�JEGX�EW�[IPP�EW�MR�PE[��.SVHER�ERH)K]TX��FSXL�SJ�[LMGL�VIGIMZI�WYFWXERXMEP�9�7��EMH�ERH�MRZIWXQIRX��STIRP]TVEGXMGI�XSVXYVI�SJ�XLI�QSWX�ZMSPIRX�ERH�PIXLEP�REXYVI��=IX�XLI�HMZIWXMXYVITIXMXMSR�HIQERHW�XLEX�SRP]�-WVEIP�WXST�HSMRK�WSQIXLMRK�XLEX�MX�LEWEPVIEH]�WXSTTIH�HSMRK�[MXLSYX�QEOMRK�ER]�HIQERHW�SR�GSYRXVMIW�XLEXGSRXMRYI�XS�IRKEKI�MR�XSVXYVI��8LIVI�EVI�WGSVIW�SJ�GSYRXVMIW�[MXL�[SVWIVIGSVHW��;L]�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP#�8LI�ERW[IV�MW�SFZMSYW�XS�ER]�[LS�EVI�RSXEJVEMH�XS�EWO�UYIWXMSRW�[MXL�YRTPIEWERX�ERW[IVW�%RSXLIV�GSRHMXMSR�PEMH�SYX�MR�XLI�HMZIWXMXYVI�TIXMXMSR�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP

EGORS[PIHKI�MR�TVMRGMTPI�XLEX�VIJYKIIW�FI�EPPS[IH�XS�VIXYVR�XS�XLIMV�JSV�QIV�PERHW��SV�IPWI�FI�GSQTIRWEXIH�JSV�XLIMV�PSWWIW��XS�GSQTP]�[MXL�9�2�6IWSPYXMSR������%X�FSXL�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE��-WVEIP�SJJIVIH�XLISTXMSR�JSV�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�FI�GSQTIRWEXIH�JSV�XLIMV�PSWWIW��ERH�XLI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�VINIGXIH�MX��1SVISZIV��RS�%VEF�WXEXI�LEW�]IX�SJJIVIH�GSQTIRWEXMSRXS�XLI�LYRHVIHW�SJ�XLSYWERHW�SJ�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�[LS�[IVI�JSVGIH�XS�JPIIGSYRXVMIW�XLI]�ERH�XLIMV�JEQMPMIW�LEH�PMZIH�MR�JSV�LYRHVIHW�SJ�]IEVW�EJXIV%VEF�GSYRXVMIW�HIGPEVIH�[EV�SR�-WVEIP�MR�������=IX�XLI�TIXMXMSR�HIQERHWRSXLMRK�SJ�XLIWI�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW�8LI�JMREP�GSRHMXMSR��XLI�GIWWEXMSR�SJ�FYMPHMRK�RI[�WIXXPIQIRXW�ERH�XLI

HMWQERXPMRK�SJ�I\MWXMRK�WIXXPIQIRXW��MW�ER�MWWYI�XLEX�HIITP]�HMZMHIW�-WVEIPMW�%�QENSVMX]�SJ�-WVEIPMW�EKVII�XLEX�RS�RI[�WIXXPIQIRXW�WLSYPH�FI�FYMPX�ERHXLEX�QSWX�SJ�XLI�I\MWXMRK�WIXXPIQIRXW�WLSYPH�FI�ZEGEXIH�EW�TEVX�SJ�ER�SZIV�EPP�TIEGI�MR�XLI�EVIE��)ZIR�E�WMKRMJMGERX�RYQFIV�SJ�XLI�WIXXPIVW�LEZI�RS[I\TVIWWIH�E�[MPPMRKRIWW�XS�PIEZI�XLIMV�LSQIW�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�TIEGI��&YX�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�VIJYWIH�XS�EGGITX�TIEGI�SJJIVW�QEHI�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZ�IVRQIRX��1ER]�QSHIVEXI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EKVII�XLEX�%VEJEX¬W�VINIGXMSR�SJ�XLITIEGI�SJJIV�QEHI�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�EX�8EFE�[EW�E�XEGXMGEP�QMWXEOI�ERHXLEX�XLI�VIWYQTXMSR�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�MW�QSVEPP]�MRHIJIRWMFPI�)ZIR�4VMRGI�&ERHEV�SJ�7EYHM�%VEFME��E�WXVSRK�WYTTSVXIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER

VMKLXW�[LS�[EW�HMVIGXP]�MRZSPZIH�MR�XLI�JEMPIH�RIKSXMEXMSRW��LEW�EGORS[P�IHKIH�XLEX�%VEJEX¬W�VIJYWEP�XS�EGGITX�&EVEO¬W�KIRIVSYW�SJJIV�[EW�©E�GVMQI

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 217: The Case For Israel

EKEMRWX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERWª MR�JEGX��©EKEMRWX�XLI�IRXMVI�VIKMSR�ª�4VMRGI�&ER�HEV��[LS�LEW�WEMH�XLEX�%VEJEX�©PMIH�XS�LMQª�ERH�XLEX�MX�MW�©ER�STIR�WIGVIX[MXLMR�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH�XLEX�%VEJEX�[EW�RSX�XVYXLJYP�ª�LEW�TPEGIH�VIWTSRWM�FMPMX]�WUYEVIP]�SR�%VEJEX�JSV�XLI�HIEXL�SJ�XLI�©������4EPIWXMRMERW�������ERH����-WVEIPMW�ª�%W�LI�TYX�MX�MR�ER�MRXIVZMI[�[MXL�8LI�2I[�=SVOIV�©-R�Q]NYHKQIRX�RSX�SRI�PMJI�SJ�XLIWI�-WVEIPMW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�HIEH�MW�NYWXMJMIH�ª4VMRGI�&ERHEV�WE[�%VEJEX¬W�VINIGXMSR�EW�TEVX�SJ�E�LEPJ�GIRXYV]�PSRK�TEX�

XIVR��©7MRGI�������IZIV]�XMQI�[I¬ZI�LEH�WSQIXLMRK�SR�XLI�XEFPI��[I�WE]RS��8LIR�[I�WE]�]IW��;LIR�[I�WE]�]IW��MX¬W�RSX�SR�XLI�XEFPI�ER]�QSVI�8LIR�[I�LEZI�XS�HIEP�[MXL�WSQIXLMRK�PIWW��-WR¬X�MX�EFSYX�XMQI�[I�WEMH]IW#ª��%FFE�)FER�QEHI�E�WMQMPEV�TSMRX�[LIR�LI�WEMH��©8LI�4EPIWXMRMERWLEZI�RIZIV�QMWWIH�ER�STTSVXYRMX]�XS�QMWW�ER�STTSVXYRMX]�ª�ERH�©XLI]�GER¬XWIIQ�XS�XEOI�]IW�JSV�ER�ERW[IV�ª�=IX�HIWTMXI�XLI�EGORS[PIHKQIRX�F]�QER]TISTPI�SR�EPP�WMHIW�SJ�XLI�GSRJPMGX�XLEX�XLI�FPEQI�JSV�VINIGXMRK�&EVEO¬W�TIEGISJJIV�PMIW�IRXMVIP]�EX�XLI�JIIX�SJ�%VEJEX��XLI�SRI�WMHIH�HMZIWXMXYVI�TIXMXMSRJEYPXW�SRP]�-WVEIP�;LIR�-�WTSOI�XS�XLI�WXYHIRXW�EX�,EVZEVH¬W�;MRXLVST�,SYWI XLI

LSYWI�[LSWI�QEWXIV�LEH�WMKRIH�XLI�,EVZEVH�1-8�HMZIWXMXYVI�TIXMXMSRQER]�SJ�XLI�WXYHIRXW�WIIQIH�YRE[EVI�SJ�XLIWI�JEGXW�EFSYX�-WVEIP¬W�GSQ�TPMERGI��-�WYWTIGX�XLEX�QER]�SJ�XLI�WMKREXSVMIW�SJ�XLI�TIXMXMSR�EVI�EPWSMKRSVERX�SJ�XLI�GSQTPI\�VIEPMXMIW�YRHIVP]MRK�XLI�GSRXMRYMRK�LSWXMPMXMIW�MRXLI�1MHHPI�)EWX��&YX�MXW�HVEJXIVW�EVI�RSX��8LI]�WIX�SYX�UYMXI�HIPMFIVEXIP]�XSQMWMRJSVQ��QMWIHYGEXI��ERH�QMWHMVIGX�XLIMV�S[R�WXYHIRXW E�TEVXMGYPEVP]REWX]�JSVQ�SJ�IHYGEXMSREP�QEPTVEGXMGI�%R]�QSVEP�TIVWSR�[LS�MW�E[EVI�SJ�XLI�XVYI�JEGXW�[SYPH�RSX�WMKR�E�TIXM�

XMSR�WMRKPMRK�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�HMZIWXMXYVI��8LSWI�[LS�WMKRIH�MX�EVI�IMXLIVQMWMRJSVQIH�SV�QEPMKRERX��8LIVI�MW�RS�XLMVH�EPXIVREXMZI�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 218: The Case For Israel

���

8,)�%''97%8-32

%R]SRI�[LS�GVMXMGMIW�-WVEIP�MW�EYXSQEXMGEPP]�EGGYWIH�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�XLIVIF]�WXMJPMRK�PIKMXMQEXI�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�XLEX�GSYRXV]¬W�KSZIVRQIRX�ERHTSPMGMIW�

8,)�%''97)67

©-X¬W�XLI�GPEWWMG�>MSRMWX�TPS]�XS�HIJEQI�TISTPI�F]�MHIRXMJ]MRK�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ-WVEIP�[MXL�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�

©?8ALI�KSZIVRQIRX�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�TPEGIH�SR�E�TIHIWXEP��ERH�XS�GVMXMGMI�MXMW�XS�FI�MQQIHMEXIP]�HYFFIH�ERXM�7IQMXMG�ª��%VGLFMWLST�(IWQSRH�8YXY�

8,)�6)%0-8=

-�LEZI�RIZIV�LIEVH�E�QIVI�GVMXMG�SJ�-WVEIP�GEPPIH�ERXM�7IQMXMG�

8,)�4633*

8]VERXW�YRHIVWXSSH�XLEX�MJ�]SY�VITIEX�E�FMK�PMI�SJXIR�IRSYKL�TISTPI�[SYPHFIKMR�XS�FIPMIZI�MX��8LI�FMK�PMI�XLEX�MW�FIMRK�VITIEXIH�EPP�EVSYRH�XLI�9RMXIH7XEXIW��IWTIGMEPP]�SR�GSPPIKI�ERH�YRMZIVWMX]�GEQTYWIW��MW�XLEX�ER]SRI�[LS�MWGVMXMGEP�SJ�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW�SV�XLI�7LEVSR�KSZIVRQIRX�[MPP�EYXSQEXMGEPP]�FI

%VI�'VMXMGW�SJ-WVEIP

%RXM�7IQMXMG#

��

Page 219: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

PEFIPIH�ER�ERXM�7IQMXI��-X�[SYPH�FI�XIVVMFPI�MJ�XLMW�[IVI�XVYI��WMRGI�GVMXMGMWQSJ�-WVEIP�MW�MQTSVXERX��EW�MW�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�ER]�MQTIVJIGX�HIQSGVEG]��&YX�XLIVIEPMX]�MW�XLEX�MR�XLI�QER]�]IEVW�XLEX�-�LEZI�FIIR�WTIEOMRK�EFSYX�XLI%VEF§-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX��-�LEZI�RIZIV�LIEVH�ER]SRI�EGXYEPP]�PEFIP�E�QIVI�GVMXMGSJ�-WVEIP�SV�7LEVSR�EW�ERXM�7IQMXMG��2SV�LEZI�-�IZIV�LIEVH�QIVI�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ-WVEIP�HIWGVMFIH�EW�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�

=IX�XLI�FMK�PMI�TIVWMWXW��7YWERREL�,IWLIP��E�TVSJIWWSV�SJ�.I[MWL�WXYHMIWEX�(EVXQSYXL��LEW�QEHI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�GLEVKI��©;I�SJXIR�LIEV�XLEX�GVMXM�GMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�IUYMZEPIRX�XS�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�ª�1MGLEIP�0IVRIV��XLI�IHMXSVSJ8MOOYR�LEW�QEHI�E�WMQMPEV�GLEVKI��7S�LEW�2SEQ�'LSQWO]��1SWXVIGIRXP]��E�PIEHMRK�TVSJIWWSV�EX�,EVZEVH��4EYP�,ERWSR�SJ�XLI�(MZMRMX]7GLSSP��LEW�QEHI�XLMW�GLEVKI��-�LIVIF]�GLEPPIRKI�ER]SRI�[LS�GPEMQW�XLEXQIVI�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�SJXIR�PEFIPIH�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�XS�HSGYQIRX�XLEXWIVMSYW�GLEVKI�F]�TVSZMHMRK�EGXYEP�UYSXEXMSRW��MR�GSRXI\X��[MXL�XLI�WSYVGISJ�XLI�WXEXIQIRXW�MHIRXMJMIH��-�EQ�RSX�XEPOMRK�EFSYX�XLI�SGGEWMSREP�OSSO[LS�[VMXIW�ER�ERSR]QSYW�TSWXGEVH�SV�I�QEMP��-�EQ�XEPOMRK�EFSYX�QEMR�WXVIEQ�WYTTSVXIVW�SJ�-WVEIP�[LS��MX�MW�GPEMQIH��LEZI�SJXIR�IUYEXIH�QIVIGVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�[MXL�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�

7YVIP]�XLEX�MW�RSX�[LEX�,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]�TVIWMHIRX�0E[VIRGI�7YQ�QIVW�HMH�[LIR�LI�WEMH�XLEX�©XLIVI�MW�QYGL�XS�FI�HIFEXIH�EFSYX�XLI�1MH�HPI�)EWX�ERH�QYGL�MR�-WVEIP¬W�JSVIMKR�ERH�HIJIRWI�TSPMG]�XLEX�GER�FI�ERHWLSYPH�FI�ZMKSVSYWP]�GLEPPIRKIH�ª�2SV�MW�MX�[LEX�8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�SJXLI2I[�=SVO�8MQIWHMH�[LIR�LI�[VSXI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK��©'VMXMGMMRK�-WVEIP�MWRSX�ERXM�7IQMXMG��ERH�WE]MRK�WS�MW�ZMPI��&YX�WMRKPMRK�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�STTVS�FVMYQ�ERH�MRXIVREXMSREP�WERGXMSR SYX�SJ�EPP�TVSTSVXMSR�XS�ER]�SXLIV�TEVX]MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX MW�ERXM�7IQMXMG��ERH�RSX�WE]MRK�WS�MW�HMWLSRIWX�ª�

7YVIP]�MX�MW�RSX�[LEX�-�LEZI�HSRI�[LIR�-�LEZI�[IPGSQIH�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ-WVEIP��[LMPI�EGGYWMRK�SJ�FMKSXV]�XLSWI�[LS�[SYPH�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV�IGS�RSQMG�GETMXEP�TYRMWLQIRX��HIWTMXI�XLI�VIEPMX]�XLEX�-WVEIP¬W�LYQER�VMKLXWVIGSVH�MW�JEV�FIXXIV�XLER�XLEX�SJ�ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]�MR�XLI�VIKMSR�ERH�EX�PIEWXEW�KSSH�EW�XLEX�SJ�ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]�XLEX�LEW�JEGIH�GSQTEVEFPI�HERKIVW��-LEZI�SJXIR�Q]WIPJ�FIIR�GVMXMGEP�SJ�TEVXMGYPEV�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW��IWTIGMEPP]�[MXLVIKEVH�XS�WIXXPIQIRXW��=IX�-�LEZI�RIZIV�FIIR�EGGYWIH�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��RSVLEZI�-WVEIP¬W�QER]�GVMXMGW�[MXLMR�XLI�-WVEIPM�QIHME�

-RHIIH��XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX¬W�LEVWLIWX�WYFWXERXMZI�GVMXMGW�EVI�-WVEIPMW�FSXL�MRWMHI�ERH�SYXWMHI�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX ERH�WSQIXMQIW�IZIR�MR�XLI�GEF�MRIX�MXWIPJ��2S�SRI�LEW�IZIV�GEPPIH�XLIQ�ERXM�7IQMXMG��8LI�SRI�TVSQMRIRXTIVWSR�-�EQ�E[EVI�SJ�[LS�IUYEXIH�ERXM�>MSRMWQ�[MXL�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�[EW1EVXMR�0YXLIV�/MRK�.V���[LS�VIWTSRHIH�XS�E�UYIWXMSR�TSWIH�F]�E�WXYHIRX[LS�EXXEGOIH�>MSRMWQ�F]�XIPPMRK�XLI�WXYHIRX�XLEX�EXXEGOW�SR�>MSRMWXW�[IVISJXIR�E�IYTLIQMWQ�JSV�EXXEGOMRK�.I[W��©=SY¬VI�XEPOMRK�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�ª�

&YX�/MRK¬W�WXEXIQIRX�[EW�QEHI�RSX�MR�XLI�GSRXI\X�SJ�GVMXMGMMRK�-WVEIPMTSPMGMIW�FYX�VEXLIV�JVSQ�E�KIRIVEP�EXXEGO�SR�>MSRMWQ�ERH�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�XLI

Page 220: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

.I[MWL�WXEXI�XS�I\MWX��/MRK�FIPMIZIH�WXVSRKP]�XLEX�EPP�KSSH�TISTPI�QYWX©TVSXIGX�MXW�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�ª�EW�'SRKVIWWQER�.SLR�0I[MW��SRI�SJ�/MRK¬W�OI]EWWMWXERXW��VIGIRXP]�VIGEPPIH��

3R�1EVGL�����������PIWW�XLER�X[S�[IIOW�FIJSVI�LMW�XVEKMG�HIEXL��LI�WTSOI

SYX�[MXL�GPEVMX]�ERH�HMVIGXRIWW�WXEXMRK��©TIEGI�JSV�-WVEIP�QIERW�WIGYVMX]�

ERH�[I�QYWX�WXERH�[MXL�EPP�SYV�QMKLX�XS�TVSXIGX�MXW�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX��MXW�XIV�

VMXSVMEP�MRXIKVMX]��-�WII�-WVEIP�EW�SRI�SJ�XLI�KVIEX�SYXTSWXW�SJ�HIQSGVEG]�MR

XLI�[SVPH��ERH�E�QEVZIPSYW�I\EQTPI�SJ�[LEX�GER�FI�HSRI��LS[�HIWIVX

PERH�GER�FI�XVERWJSVQIH�MRXS�ER�SEWMW�SJ�FVSXLIVLSSH�ERH�HIQSGVEG]�

4IEGI�JSV�-WVEIP�QIERW�WIGYVMX]�ERH�XLEX�WIGYVMX]�QYWX�FI�E�VIEPMX]�ª�

(YVMRK�XLI�VIGIRX�9�2��'SRJIVIRGI�SR�6EGMWQ�LIPH�MR�(YVFER��7SYXL

%JVMGE��[I�[IVI�EPP�WLSGOIH�F]�XLI�EXXEGOW�SR�.I[W��-WVEIP�ERH�>MSRMWQ�

8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�SJ�%QIVMGE�WXSSH�YT�EKEMRWX�XLIWI�ZMGMSYW�EXXEGOW��

3RGI�EKEMR��XLI�[SVHW�SJ�/MRK�VER�XLVSYKL�Q]�QIQSV]��©-�WSPIQRP]

TPIHKI�XS�HS�Q]�YXQSWX�XS�YTLSPH�XLI�JEMV�REQI�SJ�XLI�.I[W FIGEYWI

FMKSXV]�MR�ER]�JSVQ�MW�ER�EJJVSRX�XS�YW�EPP�ª�

-X�MW�MQTSVXERX�XS�YRHIVWXERH�XLEX�EPXLSYKL�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�MW�RSX�F]MXWIPJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��XLIVI�EVI�GIVXEMR�OMRHW�SJ�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�XLEX�EVIGPIEVP]�ERXM�7IQMXMG��IZIR�MJ�XLI�[SVH�.I[MW�RIZIV�QIRXMSRIH��%R�SFZMSYWMRWXERGI�MW�%QMVM�&EVEOE�GPEMQMRK�MR�LMW�TSIQ�XLEX�-WVEIP�ERH�7LEVSR�ORI[EFSYX�XLI�EXXEGO�SR�XLI�;SVPH�8VEHI�'IRXIV�FIJSVI�MX�LETTIRIH�ERH[EVRIH�������-WVEIPMW�XS�WXE]�E[E]��'ER�ER]SRI�HSYFX�XLEX�XLMW�ZEVMEXMSRSR�XLI�FPSSH�PMFIP�MW�ERXM�7IQMXMG�XS�XLI�GSVI#�'ER�ER]SRI�HMWTYXI�XLEXXLSWI�[LS�XEVKIX�.I[W�JSV�TL]WMGEP�EXXEGO [LIXLIV�MR�*VERGI��+IVQER]�SV�6YWWME EVI�IRKEKMRK�MR�ERXM�7IQMXMG�EGXMSRW#

4VSJIWWSV�-V[MR�'SXPIV��E�PIEHMRK�WGLSPEV�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW��LEW�MHIRXMJMIHXLI�JSPPS[MRK�RMRI�WIXW�SJ�[LEX�LI�GEPPW�©RI[�ERXM�7IQMXMWQª��

�+IRSGMHEP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�8LI�TYFPMG�GEPPW�JSV�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�.I[MWL�4ISTPI��)\EQTPIW�EVI��

8LI�'SZIRERXW�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW�PMOI�,EQEW�XLEX�GSQQMX�XLIQ�WIPZIW�XS�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�.I[MWL�4ISTPI

6IPMKMSYW�PIKEP�VYPMRKW��JEX[EW XLEX�GEPP�JSV�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIPERH�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI

7XEXI�MRGMXIH�GEPPW�JSV�KIRSGMHI��I�K���XLI�-VERMER�XLVIEX�XS�ERRMLMPEXI-WVEIP

�4SPMXMGEP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ

8LI�HIRMEP�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI¬W�VMKLX�XS�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR8LI�HI�PIKMXMQMEXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�EW�E�WXEXI8LI�EXXVMFYXMSR�XS�-WVEIP�SJ�EPP�XLI�[SVPH¬W�IZMPW -WVEIP�EW�XLI�©TSM�

WSRIV�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�[IPPWª

Page 221: The Case For Israel

�-HISPSKMGEP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ �[LMGL�WYVTEWWIW�XLI�>MSRMWQ�!�6EGMWQVLIXSVMG �XS�©2EMJ]ª�-WVEIP

�8LISPSKMGEP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�8LI�GSRZIVKIRGI�SJ�-WPEQMG�ERXM�7IQMXMWQERH�'LVMWXMER�©VITPEGIQIRXª�XLISPSK]��HVE[MRK�SR�GPEWWMGEP�LEXVIH�SJ.I[W

�'YPXYVEP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�8LI�QrPERKI�SJ�EXXMXYHIW��WIRXMQIRXW��ERHHMWGSYVWI�SJ�©JEWLMSREFPIª�WEPSR�MRXIPPIGXYEPW

�)GSRSQMG�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�[LMGL�KSIW�FI]SRH�XLI�%VEF�FS]GSXX�SJ-WVEIP�XS�MRGPYHI�I\XVE�XIVVMXSVMEP�ETTPMGEXMSR�SJ�VIWXVMGXMZI�GSZIRERXWEKEMRWX�GSYRXVMIW�XVEHMRK�[MXL�-WVEIP

�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMEP

�6EGMWX�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�.I[W

�(IRMEP�XS�-WVEIP�SJ�IUYEPMX]�FIJSVI�XLI�PE[�MR�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�EVIRE�8LI�WMRKPMRK�SYX�SJ�-WVEIP�JSV�HMJJIVIRXMEP�ERH�HMWGVMQMREXSV]�XVIEX�QIRX�MR�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�EVIRE

;LIXLIV�SV�RSX�SRI�EGGITXW�IEGL�SJ�XLIWI�WIXW��XLIVI�GER�FI�PMXXPI�HSYFX�XLEXWSQI�SJ�XLIWI�QYWX�FI�MRGPYHIH�MR�ER]�GSQTVILIRWMZI�GEXEPSK�SJ�FMKSXV]�

'IVXEMRP]��HIR]MRK�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��SV�FPEQMRK�MX�SR�©XLI�.I[W�ª�[LMGLLEW�FIIR�E�WXETPI�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�I\XVIQMWX�VLIXSVMG��GSRWXMXYXIW�FMKSXV]�)ZIR�XLI�©TVSKVIWWMZIª�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�[VSXIE�FSSO�HIR]MRK�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��[LMGL�LI�RS[�ETTEVIRXP]�VIKVIXW��%RH�XLIXLIQIW�SJ�SYXVMKLX�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMEP�ERH�FPEQMRK�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�SR�XLI.I[W�EVI�TIVZEWMZI�MR�XLI�*VMHE]�WIVQSRW�XLEX�EVI�XIPIGEWX�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMR�MER�%YXLSVMX]��-X�MW�RSX�WYVTVMWMRK�XLEX�X[S�SJ�XLI�MWWYIW�XLEX�YRMXI�XLII\XVIQMWXW�SR�XLI�JEV�VMKLX�ERH�XLI�JEV�PIJX�EVI�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMEP�ERH�YR[E�ZIVMRK�WYTTSVX�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ��-X�QMKLX�FI�HMJJMGYPX�XS�MQEKMRIX[S�QSVI�HMJJIVIRX�TISTPI�[MXL�QSVI�HMJJIVIRX�[SVPHZMI[W�XLER�4EXVMGO&YGLERER��XLI�TEPISGSRWIVZEXMZI��ERH�2SEQ�'LSQWO]��XLI�VEHMGEP�PIJXEREVGLMWX��=IX�XLI]�FSXL�WXVSRKP]�WYTTSVX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�LEXI�-WVEIP�8LI]�EPWS�LEZI�FSXL�JPMVXIH�[MXL�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMEP��EW�LEZI�QER]�4EPIWXMR�MER�ERH�%VEF�PIEHIVW�

4EX�&YGLERER�LEW�I\TVIWWIH�HSYFXW�EFSYX�[LIXLIV�.I[W�[IVI�KEWWIH�EX8VIFPMROE��,MW�©IZMHIRGIª�[EW�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�ZMKRIXXI��©-R����������OMHW�XVETTIH�����JIIX�YRHIVKVSYRH�MR�E�;EWLMRKXSR��(�'��XYRRIP�[LMPI�X[SPSGSQSXMZIW�WTI[IH�HMIWIP�I\LEYWX�MRXS�XLI�GEV��IQIVKIH�YRLEVQIH�EJXIV���QMRYXIW�ª�%R�EVXMGPI�MR�XLI�2I[�6ITYFPMGTSMRXIH�SYX�XLEX�©QYGL�SJXLI�QEXIVMEP�SR�[LMGL�&YGLERER�FEWIW�LMW�GSPYQRW�?EFSYX�XLI�,SPSGEYWXAMW�WIRX�XS�LMQ�F]�TVS�2EM��ERH�ERXM�7IQMXMG�GVEROW�ª�%WOIH�[LIVI�LI�KSXXLI�MRJSVQEXMSR�EFSYX�8VIFPMROE��LI�VITPMIH��©7SQIFSH]�WIRX�MX�XS�QI�ª8LI�EVXMGPI�GSRGPYHIW�XLEX�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMIVW�ORS[�©XLI]�GER�I\TIGX�ELIEVMRK�JVSQ�&YGLERER�ª��

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 222: The Case For Israel

&YGLERER¬W�WYTTSVX�JSV�2EM�[EV�GVMQMREPW��WYGL�EW�/PEYW�&EVFMI�ERH/EVP�0MRREW��ERH�JSV�XLI�EFSPMXMSR�SJ�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX�SJJMGI�XLEX�MRZIWXM�KEXIW�XLIQ��PIH�JSVQIV�.YWXMGI�(ITEVXQIRX�SJJMGMEP�%PER�6]ER�XS�GSQQIRXXLEX�©KVIEX�RYQFIVW�SJ�TISTPI�EVI�EWOMRK�XLIQWIPZIW��;L]�MW�4EX�&YGLERERWS�MR�PSZI�[MXL�2EM�[EV�GVMQMREPW#ª��

2SEQ�'LSQWO]¬W�JPMVXEXMSR�[MXL�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMEP�MW�IZIR�WXVERKIV�&YGLERER�MW�WMQTP]�E�GPEWWMG�ERXM�7IQMXI��EW�QER]�SJ�LMW�JIPPS[�GSRWIVZE�XMZIW�RS[�EGORS[PIHKI��&YX�'LSQWO]�MW�E�.I[�[LSWI�TEVIRXW�[IVI,IFVI[�XIEGLIVW��,I�[IRX�XS�XLI�WEQI�,IFVI[�WTIEOMRK�GEQT�XLEX�-�HMHERH�[EW�EGXYEPP]�E�QIQFIV�SJ�E�PIJX�[MRK�TVS�-WVEIP�KVSYT�HYVMRK�LMW]SYXL��&YX�XLI�TYFPMWLIH�VIGSVH�WTIEOW�JSV�MXWIPJ�

8LI�WXSV]�FIKMRW�[MXL�E�WXVERKI�*VIRGLQER�REQIH�6SFIVX�*EYVMWWSR�*EYVMWWSR��[LS�[EW�ER�SFWGYVI�PIGXYVIV�SR�*VIRGL�PMXIVEXYVI�EX�XLI�9RM�ZIVWMX]�SJ�0]SR��[VSXI�E�FSSO�ERH�KEZI�XEPOW�MR�[LMGL�LI�QSGOIH�,SPS�GEYWX�ZMGXMQW�ERH�WYVZMZSVW�EW�TIVTIXVEXSVW�SJ�E�LSE\��8LI�,SPSGEYWX�EGGSVHMRK�XS�*EYVMWWSR��RIZIV�XSSO�TPEGI��8LI�,MXPIV�KEW�GLEQFIVW�RIZIVI\MWXIH��8LI�.I[W�FIEV�VIWTSRWMFMPMX]�JSV�;SVPH�;EV�--��,MXPIV�EGXIH�VIE�WSREFP]�ERH�MR�WIPJ�HIJIRWI�[LIR�LI�VSYRHIH�YT�XLI�.I[W�ERH�TYX�XLIQ�MRPEFSV�GEQTW��RSX�HIEXL�GEQTW��8LI�©QEWWMZI�PMIª�EFSYX�KIRSGMHI�[EW�EHIPMFIVEXI�GSRGSGXMSR�FIKYR�F]�%QIVMGER�>MSRMWXW MR�GSRXI\X�LI�SFZM�SYWP]�QIERW�.I[W��8LI�TVMRGMTEP�FIRIJMGMEV]�SJ�XLMW�LSE\�MW�-WVEIP��[LMGLLEW�IRGSYVEKIH�XLMW�©IRSVQSYW�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�JMRERGMEP�JVEYH�ª�8LI�TVMRGM�TEP�ZMGXMQW�SJ�XLMW�JVEYH�LEZI�FIIR�XLI�+IVQER�TISTPI�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERTISTPI��*EYVMWWSR�EPWS�GEPPIH�XLI�HMEV]�SJ�%RRI�*VERO�E�JSVKIV]���

2SX�WYVTVMWMRKP]��EW�WSSR�EW�*EYVMWWSR¬W�GVEGOTSX�XSQI�[EW�TYFPMWLIH��MX[EW�WIMIH�YTSR�F]�.I[�LEXIVW�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH��-R�XLI�9RMXIH7XEXIW��XLI�RSXSVMSYW�0MFIVX]�0SFF]��[LMGL�HMWXVMFYXIW�8LI�4VSXSGSPW�SJ�XLI)PHIVW�SJ�>MSRERH�SXLIV�ERXM�7IQMXMG�FIWX�WIPPIVW��XVERWPEXIH�XLI�QSWX�LEXI�JYP�TSVXMSRW�SJ�XLI�[SVO�ERH�HMWXVMFYXIH�XLIQ�[MHIP]�[MXLMR�MXW�RIX[SVO�XSYXMRK�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�*EYVMWWSR�[EW�E�TVSJIWWSV��,MW�ZMHISXETIH�WTIIGLIW[IVI�HMWXVMFYXIH�JSV�YWI�EX�RIS�2EM�KEXLIVMRKW��-�WIRX�JSV�SRI�WYGL�ZMHISERH�[EXGLIH�*EYVMWWSR�WQMPI�[LIR�HIWGVMFMRK�XLI�©EPPIKIH�ZMGXMQWª�SJ�XLI©RSRI\MWXIRXª�KEW�GLEQFIVW��,MW�RIS�2EM�EYHMIRGI�PEYKLIH�EW�LIQSGOIH�XLI�XIWXMQSR]�SJ�WYVZMZSV�I]I[MXRIWWIW�

*SPPS[MRK�XLI�TYFPMGEXMSR�SJ�*EYVMWWSR¬W�FSSO��XLI�9RMZIVWMX]�SJ�0]SRWYWTIRHIH�LMQ�JSV�E�WIQIWXIV��GPEMQMRK�XLEX�MX�GSYPH�RSX�KYEVERXII�LMWWEJIX]��8LMW�HIGMWMSR��YRHIVWXERHEFPI�EW�MX�QE]�LEZI�FIIR�GSRWMHIVMRK�XLIJEGX�XLEX�0]SR�WYJJIVIH�KVIEXP]�HYVMRK�XLI�2EM�SGGYTEXMSR��[EW�MQTVSTIVERH�JSSPMWL��%�XIEGLIV�LEW�XLI�VMKLX�XS�FI�TVSXIGXIH�IZIR�JSV�IWTSYWMRKMHMSXMG�ZMI[W�

'LSQWO]�[EW�EWOIH�XS�NSMR�MR�TVSXIWXMRK�*EYVMWWSR¬W�WYWTIRWMSR��-�EQWYVI�XLEX�LI�[IPGSQIH�XLI�STTSVXYRMX]��FIGEYWI�*EYVMWWSR¬W�[VMXMRKW�ERHWTIIGLIW�EVI�WXVMHIRXP]�ERXM�>MSRMWX�EW�[IPP�EW�ERXM�7IQMXMG��-RHIIH��4VSJIWWSV

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 223: The Case For Israel

'LSQWO]�LEW�LMQWIPJ�QEHI�WXEXIQIRXW�EFSYX�>MSRMWX�I\TPSMXEXMSR�SJ�XLIXVEKIH]�SJ�;SVPH�;EV�--�XLEX�EVI�RSX��MR�Q]�ZMI[��WS�HMJJIVIRX�JVSQ�WSQI�SJXLSWI�SJ�*EYVMWWSR��,I�LEW�EPWS�GSQTEVIH�-WVEIP�[MXL�2EM�+IVQER]�

'LSQWO]�HIJIRHIH�*EYVMWWSR�RSX�SRP]�SR�XLI�MWWYI�SJ�JVII�WTIIGL�FYXEPWS�SR�XLI�QIVMXWSJ�LMW�WGLSPEVWLMT�ERH�GLEVEGXIV��,I�WMKRIH�E�TIXMXMSRXLEX�GLEVEGXIVMIH�*EYVMWWSR¬W�JEPWMJMGEXMSRW�SJ�LMWXSV]�EW�©JMRHMRKWª�ERHWEMH�XLEX�XLI]�[IVI�FEWIH�SR�©I\XIRWMZI�LMWXSVMGEP�VIWIEVGL�ª�� ,EH'LSQWO]�FSXLIVIH�XS�GLIGO�SR�*EYVMWWSR¬W�LMWXSVMGEP�VIWIEVGL��LI�[SYPHLEZI�JSYRH�MX�XS�FI�JEOIH���

8LIVI�[EW�RS�I\XIRWMZI�LMWXSVMGEP�VIWIEVGL��-RWXIEH��XLIVI�[EW�XLI�JVEYH�YPIRX�QERYJEGXYVMRK�SJ�JEPWI�ERXMLMWXSV]��-X�[EW�XLI�OMRH�SJ�HIGITXMSR�JSV[LMGL�TVSJIWWSVW�EVI�VMKLXP]�JMVIH RSX�FIGEYWI�XLIMV�ZMI[W�EVI�GSRXVSZIV�WMEP�FYX�FIGEYWI�XLI]�EVI�ZMSPEXMRK�XLI�QSWX�FEWMG�GERSRW�SJ�LMWXSVMGEPWGLSPEVWLMT��=IX�'LSQWO]�[EW�TVITEVIH�XS�PIRH�LMW�EGEHIQMG�PIKMXMQEG]�XS*EYVMWWSR¬W�©I\XIRWMZI�LMWXSVMGEP�VIWIEVGL�ª�2S[��RSX�SRP]�[EW�XLI�,SPS�GEYWX�©HMWTVSZIHª�F]�E�TVSJIWWSV�FYX�XLI�TVSJIWWSV¬W�VIWIEVGL�ERH�JMRHMRKW[IVI�GIVXMJMIH�F]�ERSXLIV�TVSJIWWSV XLMW�SRI�JVSQ�1-8�

'LSQWO]�[IRX�IZIR�JYVXLIV��%JXIV�WMKRMRK�XLI�TIXMXMSR��LI�[VSXI�ERIWWE]�XLEX�LI�EPPS[IH�XS�FI�YWIH�EW�E�JSVI[SVH�XS�*EYVMWWSR¬W�RI\X�FSSOEFSYX�LMW�GEVIIV�EW�E�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMIV��-R�XLMW�FSSO��*EYVMWWSR�EKEMR�GEPPWXLI�KEW�GLEQFIVW�E�PMI�ERH�VITIEXW�LMW�GPEMQW�EFSYX�XLI�LSE\�SJ�XLI�,SPS�GEYWX��'LSQWO]��MR�LMW�JSVI[SVH��JIMKRW�MKRSVERGI�SJ�*EYVMWWSR¬W�[SVO ª-HS�RSX�ORS[�LMW�[SVO�ZIV]�[IPPª FYX�GSRGPYHIW�XLEX�*EYVMWWSR¬W�EVKY�QIRXW�EVI�RSX�ERXM�7IQMXMG�ERH�XLEX�*EYVMWWSR�LMQWIPJ�MW�RIMXLIV�ER�ERXM�7IQMXI�RSV�E�2EM�FYX�VEXLIV�©E�WSVX�SJ�VIPEXMZIP]�ETSPMXMGEP�PMFIVEP�ª��

%�JI[�]IEVW�PEXIV��EJXIV�MX�FIGEQI�YRQMWXEOEFP]�GPIEV�XLEX�*EYVMWWSR�[EWGSRWGMSYWP]�PIRHMRK�LMW�REQI�XS�EPP�WSVXW�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMG�ERH�RIS�2EMKVSYTW��'LSQWO]�VITIEXIH�LMW�GLEVEGXIV�VIJIVIRGI��©-�WII�RS�ERXM�7IQMXMGMQTPMGEXMSRW�MR�HIRMEP�SJ�XLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�KEW�GLEQFIVW��SV�IZIR�HIRMEP�SJXLI�,SPSGEYWX��2SV�[SYPH�XLIVI�FI�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MQTPMGEXMSRW��TIV�WI�MR�XLIGPEMQ�XLEX�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��[LIXLIV�SRI�FIPMIZIW�MX�XSSO�TPEGI�SV�RSX �MWFIMRK�I\TPSMXIH��ZMGMSYWP]�WS��F]�ETSPSKMWXW�JSV�-WVEIPM�VITVIWWMSR�ERH�ZMS�PIRGI��-�WII�RS�LMRX�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MQTPMGEXMSRW�MR�*EYVMWWSR¬W�[SVO�ª��

-�WMQTP]�GERRSX�YRHIVWXERH�LS[�E�.I[�[LS�[EW�LMQWIPJ�EPMZI�HYVMRKXLI�,SPSGEYWX�ERH�[LS�GEPPW�ZMVXYEPP]�ER]XLMRK�[MXL�[LMGL�LI�HMWEKVIIW©VEGMWQª�GER�JEMP�XS�WII�IZIR�E�LMRX�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�MR�XLI�[SVO�SJ�E�QER[LS�HIWGVMFIW�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�EW�E�©LSE\ª�ERH�©JVEYHª�TIVTIXVEXIH�F]�.I[W�2SV�GER�-�YRHIVWXERH�LS[�E�.I[�GSYPH�WE]�[MXL�VIJIVIRGI�XS�XLI�,SPS�GEYWX��©[LIXLIV�SRI�FIPMIZIW�MX�XSSO�TPEGI�SV�RSXª XLYW�WYKKIWXMRK�XLEXVIEWSREFPI�TISTPI�GSYPH�FIPMIZI�IMXLIV�XLEX�MX�HMH�SV�HMH�RSX�XEOI�TPEGI�

-�GEQI�EGVSWW�XLMW�WXEXIQIRX�MR�E�&SWXSR�+PSFIEVXMGPI�XLEX�GLEVEGXIVMIH'LSQWO]�EW�E�HIJIRHIV�SJ�YRHIVHSKW�ERH�[VSXI�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�PIXXIV�XS�XLIIHMXSV�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 224: The Case For Israel

;LMPI�WSQI�QE]�VIKEVH�'LSQWO]�EW�ER�IQMRIRX�PMRKYMWX��LI�HSIW�RSX

YRHIVWXERH�XLI�QSWX�SFZMSYW�QIERMRK�SJ�[SVHW�MR�GSRXI\X��8S�JEMP�XS

WII�ER]�©LMRX�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MQTPMGEXMSRWª�MR�*EYVMWWSR¬W�GSPPIGXMZI�GSR�

HIQREXMSR�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�EW�PMEVW�MW�XS�FI�IMXLIV�E�JSSP�SV�E�OREZI�

*EMPYVI�XS�VIGSKRMI�XLI�ERXM�7IQMXMG�MQTPMGEXMSRW�SJ�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMEP�

MW�PMOI�WE]MRK�XLIVI�[SYPH�FI�RS�VEGMWX�MQTPMGEXMSRW�MR�E�GPEMQ�XLEX�

&PEGOW�IRNS]IH�WPEZIV]��SV�RS�WI\MWX�MQTPMGEXMSRW�MR�E�WXEXIQIRX�XLEX

[SQIR�[ERX�XS�FI�VETIH��8LI�,SPSGEYWX�MW�XLI�GIRXVEP�LMWXSVMGEP�IZIRX

SJ�QSHIVR�.I[MWL�LMWXSV]��)JJSVXW�XS�HIR]�SV�QMRMQMI�MX�EVI�XLI�GYVVIRX�

XSSPW�SJ�XLI�ERXM�7IQMXI�ERH�RIS�2EM��2SX�WYVTVMWMRK��FSXL�*EYVMWWSR

ERH�'LSQWO]�EVI�JVIUYIRXP]�UYSXIH�[MXL�ETTVSZEP�F]�XLSWI�LEXI�

QSRKIVW�

'LSQWO]¬W�EGXMSRW�MR�HIJIRHMRK�XLI�WYFWXERGI�SJ�*EYVMWWSR¬W�FMKSXIH

VIQEVOW�EKEMRWX�ZEPMH�GLEVKIW�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ EW�HMWXMRKYMWLIH�JVSQ

HIJIRHMRK�*EYVMWWSR¬W�VMKLXXS�TYFPMWL�WYGL�TIVRMGMSYW�HVMZIP HMWUYEPMJ]

'LSQWO]�JVSQ�FIMRK�GSRWMHIVIH�ER�LSRSVEFPI�HIJIRHIV�SJ�XLI�©YRHIV�

HSK�ª�8LI�ZMGXMQW�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��RSX�MXW�HIJIRHIVW�SV�HIRMIVW��EVI�XLI

YRHIVHSKW���

'LSQWO]�VIWTSRHIH�F]�EVKYMRK�XLEX�*EYVMWWSR�[EW�ER�ERXM�>MSRMWXVEXLIV�XLER�ER�ERXM�7IQMXI�FIGEYWI�LI�HIRSYRGIH�©>MSRMWX�PMIW�ª�,IGLEVKIH�XLEX�©(IVWLS[MX¬W�IEW]�XVERWPEXMSR�SJ�«>MSRMWX¬�XS�«.I[MWL¬�MW�MPPI�KMXMQEXI�ª�ERH�XLEX��©MR�JEGX��MX�MW�E�WXERHEVH�KEQFMX�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXIW�ª��

*SPPS[MRK�XLMW�I\GLERKI��-�GLEPPIRKIH�'LSQWO]�XS�E�TYFPMG�HIFEXI�SRXLI�MWWYI�SJ�[LIXLIV�MX�MW�ERXM�7IQMXMG�SV�ERXM�.I[MWL�XS�HIR]�XLI�,SPS�GEYWX��8LMW�[EW�LMW�ERW[IV��©-X�MW�WS�SFZMSYW�XLEX�XLIVI�MW�RS�TSMRX�MRHIFEXMRK�MX�FIGEYWI�RSFSH]FIPMIZIW�XLIVI�MW�ER�ERXM�7IQMXMG�GSRRSXEXMSR�XSXLI�HIRMEP�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWXª��IQTLEWMW�EHHIH ���8LEX�ERW[IV��[LMGL�WYK�KIWXW�XLI�TIVZIVWI�[SVPH�'LSQWO]�PMZIW�MR��WTIEOW�JSV�MXWIPJ�

3RI�MW�PIJX�XS�WTIGYPEXI�EFSYX�'LSQWO]¬W�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�TW]GLSPSKMGEPQSXMZIW�JSV�FIGSQMRK�WS�IQFVSMPIH�MR�XLI�WYFWXERXMZI�HIJIRWI�SJ�E�RIS�2EM�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMIV��8LI�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW§JVII�WTIIGL�VEXMSREPI�HSIW�RSX[SVO�JSV�'LSQWO]��GMZMP�PMFIVXEVMERW�[LS�HIJIRH�XLI�JVII�WTIIGL�SJ�RIS�2EMW�HS�RSX�KIX�MRXS�FIH�[MXL�XLIQ�F]�PIKMXMQEXMRK�XLIMV�JMRHMRKW�EW�LEZ�MRK�FIIR�FEWIH�SR�©I\XIRWMZI�LMWXSVMGEP�VIWIEVGLª�ERH�F]�HIJIRHMRK�XLIQEKEMRWX�[IPP�HSGYQIRXIH�GLEVKIW�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��1SVISZIV��TVSZMHMRK�EJSVI[SVH�JSV�E�FSSO�MW�NSMRMRK[MXL�XLI�EYXLSV�ERH�TYFPMWLIV�MR�ER�IJJSVXXS�WIPP�XLI�FSSO��-X�MW�MRXIRHIH�RSX�QIVIP]�XS�PIEZI�XLI�QEVOIXTPEGI�SJ�MHIEWSTIR��-X�MW�MRXIRHIH�XS�MRJPYIRGI�XLEX�QEVOIXTPEGI�WYFWXERXMZIP]�MR�JEZSV�SJXLI�EYXLSV¬W�MHIEW�

4EYP�0��&IVQER��[VMXMRK�JSV�XLI�:MPPEKI�:SMGI�KSX�MX�I\EGXP]�VMKLX�©'LSQWO]¬W�ZMI[�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�MW�TSWMXMZIP]�[MPH��,MW�HIJMRMXMSR�MW�WSREVVS[��RIMXLIV�XLI�4VSXSGSPW�SJ�XLI�)PHIVW�SJ�>MSRRSV�XLI�RS�,SPSGEYWX

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 225: The Case For Israel

HIPYWMSR�JMX�MRXS�MX��������-�EQ�EJVEMH�XLEX�LMW�TVIWIRX�VIQEVOW�SR�ERXM�7IQM�XMWQ�ERH�>MSRMWX�PMIW�HMWUYEPMJ]�LMQ�JVSQ�IZIV�FIMRK�XEOIR�WIVMSYWP]�SR�QEX�XIVW�TIVXEMRMRK�XS�.I[W�ª��

=IX�'LSQWO]��HIWTMXI�LMW�PSRK�XVEGO�VIGSVH�SJ�QIRHEGMX]�EFSYX�-WVEIPERH�LMW�TIVZIVWI�ZMI[W�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��GSRXMRYIW�XS�FI�XEOIR�UYMXI�WIVM�SYWP]�SR�QEXXIVW�TIVXEMRMRK�XS�.I[W�F]�PIKMSRW�SJ�WXYHIRXW�ERH�TVSJIWWSVWEVSYRH�XLI�[SVPH��,I�LEW�IZIR�XEYKLX�E�GSYVWI�XLEX�MRGPYHIW�XLMW�WYFNIGXEX�,EVZEVH¬W�/IRRIH]�7GLSSP�SJ�+SZIVRQIRX�HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�LI�MW�EPMRKYMWX�[MXL�RS�TVSJIWWMSREP�GVIHIRXMEPW�MR�XLMW�EVIE��SXLIV�XLER�LMW�SRI�WMHIH�STMRMSRW�

8LI�'LSQWO]§*EYVMWWSR�ITMWSHI�MPPYWXVEXIW�WSQI�MQTSVXERX�MWWYIWHMWGYWWIH�MR�XLMW�FSSO��'LSQWO]¬W�FMEVVI�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ EHIJMRMXMSR�XLEX�I\GPYHIW�HIRMEP�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�ERH�XLI�GPEMQ�XLEX�MX�MW�E>MSRMWX�LSE\ VIQMRHW�YW�LS[�ERXM�>MSRMWQ�SJXIR�TVSZMHIW�E�GSZIV�JSVERXM�7IQMXMWQ��;LIR�*EYVMWWSR�WE]W�XLEX�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�MW�E�LSE\�TIVTI�XVEXIH�F]�>MSRMWXW��LI�QIERW�.I[W��1ER]�RSR�>MSRMWX�.I[W�MR�XLI�9RMXIH7XEXIW�ERH�IPWI[LIVI�LEZI�FIIR�MRZSPZIH�MR�,SPSGEYWX�IHYGEXMSR�ERHQIQSVMEPMEXMSR��*EYVMWWSR�ERH�'LSQWO]�HIJIRH�ER]�EGGYWEXMSR�PIZIPIHEKEMRWX�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�EW�PSRK�EW�XLI�EGGYWIV�YWIW�XLI�VMKLX�GSHI�[SVH�>MSRMWXW�&YX�XLIWI�EGGYWEXMSRW�IEWMP]�XVERWPEXI�JVSQ�©>MSRMWXª�XS�©.I[�ª©6IZMWMSRMWXª�LMWXSVMERW�PMOI�*EYVMWWSR�EVI�VIKYPEVP]�GMXIH�F]�VEHMGEP�MQEQW[LS�TVIEGL�LEXVIH�SJ�.I[W�MR�XLI�[IIOP]�WIVQSRW��*SV�I\EQTPI��7LIMOL-FVELMQ�1EHLM [LS��[LIR�LI�MW�RSX�GEPPMRK�XLI�.I[W�©HSROI]Wª�ERHHIQERHMRK�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP��MW�E�PIGXYVIV�SR�IGSPSK]�EX�%P�%UWE9RMZIVWMX]�MR�+EE HIPMZIVIH�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�©LMWXSVMGEPª�EREP]WMW�MR�7IT�XIQFIV�������©3RI�SJ�XLI�.I[W¬�IZMP�HIIHW�MW�[LEX�LEW�GSQI�XS�FI�GEPPIH«8LI�,SPSGEYWX¬�XLEX�MW�XLI�WPEYKLXIV�SJ�XLI�.I[W�F]�2EMWQ��,S[IZIV�6IZMWMSRMWX�?LMWXSVMERWA�LEZI�TVSZIR�XLEX�XLMW�GVMQI��GEVVMIH�SYX�EKEMRWXWSQI�SJ�XLI�.I[W��[EW�TPERRIH�F]�XLI�.I[W¬�PIEHIVW��ERH�[EW�TEVX�SJ�XLIMVTSPMG]�ª��

8LMW�WIVQSR [LMGL�'LSQWO]�[SYPH�RSX�VIKEVH�EW�ERXM�7IQMXMG [EWXIPIGEWX�SR�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�8IPIZMWMSR��EW�[EW�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�WIVQSR�HIPMZIVIH�F]�(V��%LQEH�%FY�,EPEFM]E��[LS�[EW�ER�SJJMGMEP�QIQFIV�SJ�XLI*EX[E�'SYRGMP��ETTSMRXIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�

,EZI�RS�QIVG]�SR�XLI�.I[W��RS�QEXXIV�[LIVI�XLI]�EVI��MR�ER]�GSYRXV]�

*MKLX�XLIQ��[LIVIZIV�]SY�EVI��;LIVIZIV�]SY�QIIX�XLIQ��OMPP�XLIQ�

;LIVIZIV�]SY�EVI��OMPP�XLSWI�.I[W�ERH�XLSWI�%QIVMGERW�[LS�EVI�PMOI

XLIQ ERH�XLSWI�[LS�WXERH�F]�XLIQ XLI]�EVI�EPP�MR�SRI�XVIRGL�

EKEMRWX�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�XLI�1YWPMQW FIGEYWI�XLI]�IWXEFPMWLIH�-WVEIP�LIVI�

MR�XLI�FIEXMRK�LIEVX�SJ�XLI�%VEF�[SVPH��MR�4EPIWXMRI��8LI]�GVIEXIH�MX�XS�

FI�XLI�SYXTSWX�SJ�XLIMV�GMZMPMEXMSR ERH�XLI�ZERKYEVH�SJ�XLIMV�EVQ]��ERH

XS�FI�XLI�W[SVH�SJ�XLI�;IWX�ERH�XLI�GVYWEHIVW��LERKMRK�SZIV�XLI�RIGOW�SJ

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 226: The Case For Israel

XLI�QSRSXLIMWXW��XLI�1YWPMQW�MR�XLIWI�PERHW��8LI]�[ERXIH�XLI�.I[W�XS�FI

XLIMV�WTIEVLIEH�ª��

)ZIR�XLSWI�[LS�FIPMIZI�XLEX�WMRKPMRK�SYX�>MSRMWXW�SV�XLI�>MSRMWX�WXEXIJSV�GVMXMGMWQ�MW�RSX�ERXM�7IQMXMG�QYWX�WYVIP]�EGORS[PIHKI�XLEX�XLIVI�MW�E�HMJ�JIVIRGI�FIX[IIR�QIVI�GVMXMGMWQSJ�-WVEIP�ERH�WMRKPMRK�MX�SYXJSV�YRMUYIWERGXMSRW�WYGL�EW�HMZIWXMXYVI�SV�FS]GSXX��-X�MW�XVYI�XLEX�XLSWI�[LS�EHZSGEXIXLI�PEXXIV�LEZI�FIIR�EGGYWIH�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��FYX�MX�MW�JEPWI�XLEX�XLSWI�[LSJMX�MRXS�XLI�JSVQIV�GEXIKSV]�LEZI�FIIR�WS�PEFIPIH��=IX�XLI�VIGIRX�FMK�PMIPYQTW�XLIWI�HMWXMRGX�GEXIKSVMIW�XSKIXLIV��8LI�XMQI�LEW�GSQI�JSV�XLSWI�[LSEVI�WTVIEHMRK�XLMW�FMK�PMI�IMXLIV�XS�TYX�YT�F]�HSGYQIRXMRK�XLIMV�GLEVKI�SVXS�WXST�QMWPIEHMRK�XLI�TYFPMG�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 227: The Case For Israel

���

8,)�%''97%8-32

8LI�JEGX�XLEX�WS�QER]�-WVEIPMW�ERH�.I[W�WYTTSVX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WMHI�ERH�WSJI[�4EPIWXMRMERW��%VEFW��ERH�1YWPMQW�WYTTSVX�XLI�-WVEIPM�WMHI�MW�IZMHIRGIXLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�WMHI�MW�VMKLX�

8,)�%''97)67

©?*ASPPS[MRK�MR�XLI�PMRI�SJ�.YHEL�1EKRYW��XLI�KVIEX�GVMXMGEP�IJJSVXW�SJ�RSR�SV�ERXM�>MSRMWX�.I[W�PMOI�)PQIV�&IVKIV��-WVEIP�7LELEO��2SEQ�'LSQWO]�1E\MRI�6SHMRWSR��0MZME�6SOEGL��-�*��7XSRI��QER]�SJ�XLIQ�WTSRWSVIH�SVHMVIGXP]�IRGSYVEKIH�F]�%VEF�IJJSVXW�MR�XLI�;IWX��?TVSHYGIH�QEXIVMEPA�JSV�IZIV�HMWQMWWMRK�XLI�Q]XL�SJ�>MSRMWX�MRRSGIRGI�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�ERH'LVMWXSTLIV�,MXGLIRW�

©7SQI�SJ�XLI�]SYRK�-WVEIPM�VIZMWMSRMWX�LMWXSVMERW�������?8SQ�7IKIZ��&IRR]1SVVMW��ERH�WS�SRA�EVI�>MSRMWXW��FYX�XLIMV�[SVO�MW�HSRI�[MXL�E�KIRYMRI�[MPPXS�YRHIVWXERH�XLI�TEWX��[LEX�XLI]�WE]�EFSYX�XLI�LSVVSVW�SJ�������XLI]�WE]STIRP]�[MXLSYX�E�HIWMVI�XS�PMI�SV�GSRGIEP�XLI�TEWX��8LIMV�GSYRXIVTEVXW�MRXLI�IWXEFPMWLQIRX�WXMPP�STIVEXI�[MXL�XLI�SPH�WGVYTPIW�ª��)H[EVH�7EMH�ERH'LVMWXSTLIV�,MXGLIRW�

©>MSRMWQ�MW�ERXM�7IQMXMG�FIGEYWI�MX�IWWIRXMEPMIW�.I[W��1ER]�.I[W�HSRSX�WYTTSVX�-WVEIPM�STTVIWWMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI�ª��%QIV�>ELV�

;L]�(S�7S�1ER]�.I[WERH�)ZIR�-WVEIPMW�7MHI[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW#

��

Page 228: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

9RMZIVWMX]�SJ�1MGLMKER�PE[�WXYHIRX��EX�E�TERIP�HMWGYWWMSR�WTSRWSVIH�F]1MGLMKER¬W�TVS�4EPIWXMRMER�WXYHIRX�KVSYT�

©8LI�XVYI�.I[W�VIQEMR�JEMXLJYP�XS�.I[MWL�FIPMIJ�ERH�EVI�RSX�GSRXEQM�REXIH�[MXL�>MSRMWQ��8LI�XVYI�.I[W�EVI�EKEMRWX�HMWTSWWIWWMRK�XLI�%VEFW�SJXLIMV�PERH�ERH�LSQIW��%GGSVHMRK�XS�XLI�8SVEL��XLI�PERH�WLSYPH�FIVIXYVRIH�XS�XLIQ�ª��;IFWMXI�SJ�2IXYVIM�/EVXE�97%��XLI�YPXVE�SVXLSHS\ERXM�>MSRMWX�WIGX�

8,)�6)%0-8=

8LI�VIEPMX]�MW�XLEX�GSQTPIXI�JVIIHSQ�SJ�MRJSVQEXMSR�ERH�JVIIHSQ�SJWTIIGL�EQSRK�-WVEIPMW�ERH�.I[W�EPPS[W�JSV�XLI�[MHIWX�EVVE]�SJ�ZMI[W�XS�FITVIWIRXIH��[LIVIEW�ZMVXYEPP]�XSXEP�GSRXVSP�SZIV�MRJSVQEXMSR�XS�QSWX�VIWM�HIRXW�SJ�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�WXEXIW��GSYTPIH�[MXL�I\XVIQI�WERGXMSRW�JSVI\TVIWWMRK�HMWWIRXMRK�ZMI[W��QEOIW�ER]�VIEPMWXMG�GSQTEVMWSR�MQTSWWMFPI�

8,)�4633*

-WVEIPMW�ERH�.I[W�LEZI�RS�PMQMXEXMSRW�SR�VIGIMZMRK�ZMI[W�VIKEVHMRK�XLI-WVEIPM§4EPIWXMRMER�HMWTYXI��8LI]�GER�[EXGL�%VEF�ERH�-WPEQMG�XIPIZMWMSRTVSKVEQW��VIEH�XLI�QSWX�ZMVYPIRX�ERXM�>MSRMWX�QEXIVMEP��ERH�I\TVIWW�ER]ZMI[W�XLI]�[MWL�SR�XLI�GSRJPMGX��1SVISZIV��.I[W�ERH�-WVEIPMW�LEZI�XVEHM�XMSREPP]�LIPH�XLI�[MHIWX�EVVE]�SJ�ZMI[W�VERKMRK�JVSQ�TSPMXMGEP�ERH�VIPMKMSYWERXM�>MSRMWQ�XS�QIWWMERMG�GSRGITXW�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

8LI�QIHME�XIRHW�XS�IQTLEWMI�HMWWIRXMRK�VEXLIV�XLER�QEMRWXVIEQZMI[W��*SV�I\EQTPI��XLI�����XS�����-WVEIPM�VIWIVZMWXW�[LS�VIJYWIH�XS�WIVZIMR�XLI�XIVVMXSVMIW�GSRWXMXYXIH�PIWW�XLER���TIVGIRX�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�HMH�WIVZIERH�E�JEV�WQEPPIV�RYQFIV�XLER�XLSWI�[LS�[IVI�EFSZI�XLI�EKI�SJ�WIVZMGIERH�MRWMWXIH�SR�ZSPYRXIIVMRK�XS�HIJIRH�-WVEIP��=IX�XLI�QIHME��JSV�YRHIV�WXERHEFPI�VIEWSRW��TEMH�JEV�QSVI�EXXIRXMSR�XS�XLI�HMWWMHIRXW�XLER�XS�XLSWIMR�XLI�QEMRWXVIEQ�

1SVISZIV��QER]�.I[MWL�SVKERMEXMSRW�MR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��ER\MSYW�XSLIEV�XLI�[MHIWX�VERKI�SJ�ZMI[W��[IPGSQIH�XLI�HMWWIRXIVW�ERH�KEZI�XLIQ�EJYPP�LIEVMRK��8LI�%QIVMGER�ERH�)YVSTIER�QIHME�KIRIVEPP]�XIRH�XS�TVIWIRXXLI�ZMI[W�SJ�EVXMGYPEXI�-WVEIPMW��WYGL�EW�%QSW�3 �ERH�=SWWM�&IMPMR�EW�[IPP�EWPIEHIVW�SJ�TIEGI�RS[�ERH�&¬8WIPIQ��[LS�XIRH�XS�FI�UYMXI�GVMXMGEP�SJ�GYVVIRX-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW��%PXLSYKL�QSWX�SJ�XLIWI�-WVEIPM�GVMXMGW�XLIQWIPZIW�VIQEMR>MSRMWXW�ERH�WYTTSVX�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�ERH�XS�HIJIRHMXWIPJ�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWXW�F]�TVSTSVXMSREP�QIERW��XLIMV�GVMXMGMWQW [IPP�YRHIV�WXSSH[MXLMR-WVEIP EVI�QMWYWIH�SYXWMHI�SJ�-WVEIP�F]�XLSWI�[LS�[SYPHHIPIKMXMQMI�ERH�HIWXVS]�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

Page 229: The Case For Israel

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

8LMW�GSRXVEWXW�WLEVTP]�[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER��%VEF��ERH�1YWPMQ�ETTVSEGLXS�HMWWIRX��)ZIR�XLI�QSWX�QMRMQEP�SJ�HMWWIRXMRK�ZSMGIW�EVI�MQTVMWSRIH�ERHSJXIR�I\IGYXIH���6IGEPP�XLI�JEX[E�EKEMRWX�7EPQER�6YWLHMI� �1SVISZIV�QER]�4EPIWXMRMERW��%VEFW��ERH�1YWPMQW�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH�EVI�HIRMIHEGGIWW�XS�MRJSVQEXMSR�XLEX�GSYPH�MRJPYIRGI�XLIMV�TIVWTIGXMZIW�MR�JEZSV�SJ-WVEIP��*SV�I\EQTPI��XLI]�EVI�WLS[R�VITIEXIH�MQEKIW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�GMZMPMERWFIMRK�OMPPIH�[MXLSYX�FIMRK�WLS[R�XLI�QERKPIH�FSHMIW�SJ�.I[MWL�FEFMIW�[SQIR��ERH�XLI�IPHIVP]��8LI]�EVI�WLS[R�TMGXYVIW�SJ�LSYWIW�FIMRKHIWXVS]IH�[MXLSYX�FIMRK�XSPH�XLEX�XLI]�[IVI�IQTXMIH�SJ�VIWMHIRXW�TVMSV�XSXLI�FYPPHSIVW�EVVMZMRK��8LIVI�MW�EFWSPYXIP]�RS�GSQTEVMWSR�FIX[IIR�XLIJVII�JPS[�SJ�MRJSVQEXMSR�EQSRK�.I[W�ERH�-WVEIPMW�SR�XLI�SRI�LERH��ERHEQSRK�4EPIWXMRMERW��1YWPMQW��ERH�%VEFW�SR�XLI�SXLIV�LERH�

1SVISZIV��.I[W�ERH�-WVEIPMW�LEZI�XVEHMXMSREPP]�MRGPYHIH�WSQI�I\XVIQMWXWSR�ZMVXYEPP]�IZIV]�MWWYI��8LIVI�MW�ER�SPH�NSOI�EFSYX�X[S�-WVEIPMW�FIMRKJSYRH�SR�E�HIWIVX�MWPERH�EJXIV�LEZMRK�FIIR�WXVERHIH�JSV�JMZI�]IEVW��8LI�JMVWXXLMRK�XLI]�VITSVXIH�XS�XLIMV�VIWGYIVW�[EW�XLEX�XLI]�LEH�JSVQIH�WIZIR�TSPMX�MGEP�TEVXMIW�FIX[IIR�XLIQ��8LI�-WVEIPM�TSTYPEXMSR�XSHE]�MRGPYHIW�QIWWMERMGERXM�>MSRMWXW��7XEPMRMWXW��1ESMWXW��8VSXWO]MXIW��SRI�[SVPHIVW��JPEX�)EVXLFIPMIZIVW��,SPSGEYWX�HIRMIVW��ERH�SXLIV�GSRGIMZEFPI ERH�WSQI�MRGSR�GIMZEFPI ZMI[W�

-�VIGEPP�E�GSRZIVWEXMSR�[MXL�E�TVSQMRIRX�-WVEIPM�PE[]IV�[LS�LEW�HIZSXIHLIV�PMJI�RSX�SRP]�XS�HIJIRHMRK�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�MR�GSYVX�FYX�XS�WYT�TSVXMRK�XLIMV�GEYWI�MR�XLI�TSPMXMGEP�EVIRE�ERH�FIJVMIRHMRK�XLIQ�TIVWSREPP]�7LI�MW�E�ZMVYPIRX�ERXM�>MSRMWX�ERH�ER�EGXMZI�QIQFIV�SJ�XLI�7XEPMRMWX�[MRK�SJXLI�'SQQYRMWX�TEVX]��;LIR�-�EWOIH�LIV�LS[�WLI�GSYPH�FI�E�7XEPMRMWX��LIVERW[IV�[EW�WMQTPI�ERH�QSZMRK��MJ�YPXMQEXIP]�YRGSRZMRGMRK��©7XEPMR�WEZIHQI�ERH�Q]�JEQMP]�JVSQ�,MXPIV��-�GSYPH�RIZIV�JSVKIX�XLEX�ª��-�VIKVIX�RSXLEZMRK�XLSYKLX�XS�EWO�LIV�LS[�WLI�GSYPH�WYTTSVX�ERH�FIJVMIRH�TISTPI[LS�HIR]�SV�QMRMQMI�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�MR�[LMGL�WS�QER]�SJ�LIV�S[R�JEQ�MP]�[IVI�QYVHIVIH� �-R�EHHMXMSR�XS�XLIWI�HMWWMHIRX�.I[MWL�ZMI[W��QSVI�XLERE�QMPPMSR�1YWPMQW�ERH�%VEFW�EVI�GMXMIRW�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�LEZI�GSQTPIXI�JVII�HSQ�SJ�MRJSVQEXMSR�ERH�I\TVIWWMSR�

4VMSV�XS�XLI�GSPPETWI�SJ�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�TIEGI�XEPOW��XLIVI[EW�JEV�QSVI�HMWEKVIIQIRX�EQSRK�-WVEIPM�HSZIW�EFSYX�[LIXLIV�%VEJEX�[EWE�VIEP�TIEGI�TEVXRIV�ERH�[LIXLIV�4EPIWXMRMER�TIEGI�IJJSVXW�[IVI�WIVMSYW�2S[��EPXLSYKL�XLIVI�MW�WXMPP�ER�EGXMZI�TIEGI�GEQT��XLIVI�EVI�ZIV]�JI[-WVEIPMW�[LS�TPEGI�ER]�JEMXL�MR�%VEJEX¬W�[MPPMRKRIWW�SV�EFMPMX]�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�%W�=SVEQ�/MRYMO��SRI�SJ�XLI�JSYRHIVW�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�TIEGI�QSZIQIRX��TYXMX��©7MRGI�XLI�JEMPYVI�SJ�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�XEPOW��[LIR�XLI�XVYXL�GEQI�SYX�-¬ZI�LEH�XS�JEGI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�XLI�%VEFW�WMQTP]�HSR¬X�EGGITX�-WVEIP�FIMRKLIVI��?3YV�TIEGIA�TEVXRIV�MW�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFIV�ª�8LI�JEGX�XLEX�WS�QER]EVI�RS[�STXMQMWXMG�EFSYX�XLI�ETTSMRXQIRX�SJ�E�RI[�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�HIWTMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�%FY�1EIR�[VSXI�E�FSSO�HIR]MRK�XLI�,SPSGEYWX��MW

Page 230: The Case For Israel

E�XIWXEQIRX�XS�XLI�TIVWIZIVERGI�SJ�XLI�TIEGI�GEQT��EW�[IPP�EW�XS�XLI�TEYGMX]SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�[MXL�EGGITXEFPI�ZMI[W�

1ER]�-WVEIPMW�EVI�WS�ER\MSYW�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�XLEX�WSQI�EVI�[MPPMRK�XS�HMW�XSVX�XLI�LMWXSV]�ERH�HIR]�GPIEV�JEGXW�[LIR�XLI�LMWXSV]�ERH�XLI�JEGXW�WIIQ�XSQEOI�MX�QSVI�HMJJMGYPX�XS�QEOI�TIEGI��*SV�I\EQTPI��[LIR�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�[EWGEYKLX�KMZMRK�E�WIGVIX�FVMIJMRK�XS�%VEF�PIEHIVW�MR�[LMGL�LI�VIZIEPIH�LMWXVYI�TPER�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��QER]�-WVEIPMW�VIJYWIH�XS�FIPMIZI�XLIWXSV]��1ER]�-WVEIPM�TIEGI�EHZSGEXIW�EVI�EPWS�[MPPMRK�XS�EGGITX�VIZMWMSRMWX�ERH�SJXIR�JEPWI��LMWXSVMGEP�EGGSYRXW�XLEX�TVSHYGI�E�QSVI�©IZIR�LERHIHªREVVEXMZI�SJ�XLI�TEWX��FIGEYWI�XLI]�FIPMIZI�XLEX�WYGL�E�REVVEXMZI��EW�GSR�XVEWXIH�[MXL�XLI�EGXYEP�LMWXSV]��MW�QSVI�GSRHYGMZI�XS�TIEGI�

*MREPP]��XLIVI�MW�E�WSQI[LEX�MVVEXMSREP�FYX�LMWXSVMGEPP]�EGGYVEXI�JEGXSVXLEX�GSRXVMFYXIW�XS�XLI�HMWTEVMX]�FIX[IIR�.I[MWL�ERH�-WVEIPM�HMWWIRX��SR�XLISRI�LERH��ERH�XLI�PEGO�XLIVISJ�SR�XLI�SXLIV�WMHI��8LIVI�LEW�EP[E]W�FIIR�EWQEPP�IPIQIRX�[MXLMR�XLI�.I[MWL�GSQQYRMX]�XLEX�JSV�PEVKIP]�MRI\TPMGEFPIVIEWSRW�LEW�FIIR�L]TIVGVMXMGEP�SJ�IZIV]XLMRK�EWWSGMEXIH�[MXL�.YHEMWQ��.I[W�SV�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXIW��/EVP�1EV\��2SEQ�'LSQWO]��ERH�2SVQER�*MROIPWXIMRGSQI�IEWMP]�XS�QMRH��8LI�VIEWSRW�JSV�XLMW�PMI�QSVI�MR�XLI�VIEPQ�SJ�7MK�QYRH�*VIYH�ERH�.IER�4EYP�7EVXVI�XLER�MR�XLI�VIEPQ�SJ�TSPMXMGEP�SV�QIHMEHMWGSYVWI��&YX�MX�LEW�FIIR�E�WEH�VIEPMX]�SZIV�XMQI�

-�HS�RSX�QIER�XS�WYKKIWX�F]�XLMW�SFWIVZEXMSR�XLEX�EPP�ERXM�>MSRMWXW�ERH-WVEIP�FEWLIVW�EVI�WIPJ�LEXMRK�.I[W��4ISTPI�GER�FI�[VSRK�SR�XLI�QIVMXW[MXLSYX�VIUYMVMRK�ER]�TW]GLSPSKMGEP�I\TPEREXMSR��&YX�XLI�VIEPMX]�MW�XLEXXLIVI�EVI�WSQI�.I[W�[LS�HIWTMWI�ER]XLMRK�.I[MWL��VERKMRK�JVSQ�XLIMV�VIPM�KMSR��XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��XS�MRHMZMHYEPW�[LS�EVI�©XSS�.I[MWL�ª�8S�VIGSK�RMI�XLI�EGGYVEG]�SJ�XLMW�IQTMVMGEP�SFWIVZEXMSR�MW�RSX�RIGIWWEVMP]�XSYRHIVGYX�XLI�MQTSVXERGI�SJ�HIEPMRK�[MXL�ERXM�>MSRMWX�ERH�ERXM�-WVEIPEVKYQIRXW�SR�XLIMV�QIVMXW�ERH�HIQIVMXW��-X�MW�XS�SJJIV�E�TEVXMEP�I\TPEREXMSRJSV�[LEX�WIIQW�WS�MRGSRKVYSYW�XS�WSQI REQIP]��XLI�JIVSGMSYW��WSQI�XMQIW�IZIR�NS]SYW��ERH��EW�XLI�JIQMRMWX�[VMXIV�4L]PPMW�'LIWPIV�LEW�TYX�MX�©IVSXMG�ªREXYVI�SJ�ORII�NIVO�-WVEIP�FEWLMRK�SR�FILEPJ�SJ�WSQI�.I[W��

8LIVI�EVI�EPWS�WSQI�.I[W�JSV�[LSQ�-WVEIP¬W�KVS[MRK�YRTSTYPEVMX]EQSRK�XLI�VEHMGEP�PIJX�MW�WSQIXLMRK�SJ�ER�IQFEVVEWWQIRX��8LIWI�.I[W�[ERXXS�FI�PMOIH�F]�XLSWI�[LSWI�TSPMXMGW�XLI]�WYTTSVX�SR�SXLIV�MWWYIW��%GGSVH�MRKP]�XLI]�XIRH�XS�HMWXERGI�XLIQWIPZIW�JVSQ�-WVEIP�ERH�SJXIR�WYTTSVX�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�WMHI�[MXLSYX�QYGL�XLSYKLX�EFSYX�XLI�QIVMXW�SJ�XLI�GEWI�3TTSWMRK�-WVEIP�ERH�WYTTSVXMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MW��JSV�WSQI�.I[W��E�[E]�SJIWXEFPMWLMRK�XLIMV�PIJX�[MRK�GVIHIRXMEPW�ERH�TVSZMRK�XLEX�XLIMV�TSPMXMGEP�GSV�VIGXRIWW�XVYQTW�ER]�IXLRMG�WSPMHEVMX]��8LMW�TLIRSQIRSR�GVIEXIW�E�QYPXM�TPMIV�IJJIGX�XLEX�VIWYPXW�MR�WSQI�.I[W�[LS�TVIZMSYWP]�WYTTSVXIH�-WVEIP�RS[EFERHSRMRK�XLEX�WYTTSVX�EW�QSVI�ERH�QSVI�VEHMGEP�PIJXMWXW�XEOI�YT�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�GEYWI�EW�TEVX�SJ�XLIMV�EKIRHE�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 231: The Case For Israel

%�VIPEXIH�TLIRSQIRSR�LEW�WIIR�WSQI�.I[W��IWTIGMEPP]�MR�)YVSTI��EFER�HSRMRK�XLIMV�WYTTSVX�SJ�-WVEIP�FIGEYWI�SJ�JIEV��-R�������JSPPS[MRK�MXW�WTIGXEGYPEV�ZMGXSV]�MR�XLI�7M\�(E]�;EV��-WVEIP�[EW�WIIR�EW�E�WSYVGI�SJ�TVS�XIGXMSR�JSV�.I[W�EVSYRH�XLI�[SVPH��%QIVMGER�ERH�)YVSTIER�.I[W��FEWOMRKZMGEVMSYWP]�MR�-WVEIP¬W�ZMGXSV]��I\TIVMIRGIH�E�RI[�TVMHI�MR�FIMRK�.I[W�8SHE]�-WVEIP�MW�WIIR�F]�QER]�)YVSTIER�.I[W�EW�E�WSYVGI�SJ�HERKIV��FIGEYWIERXM�>MSRMWQ�LEW�FIGSQI�XLI�GYVVIRX�NYWXMJMGEXMSR�SV�I\GYWI�JSV�ZMSPIRGIEKEMRWX�.I[W��8LMW�LEW�VIWYPXIH�MR�WSQI�JEMV�[IEXLIV�WYTTSVXIVW�SJ�-WVEIPEFERHSRMRK�XLIMV�WYTTSVX�HYVMRK�HMJJMGYPX�XMQIW�

-X�MW�E�JYRHEQIRXEP�JEPPEG]�XS�GSRGPYHI�XLEX�SRI�WMHI�SJ�E�HMWTYXI�QYWXFI�VMKLX�MJ�WSQI�TISTPI�[LS�EVI�IXLRMGEPP]�MHIRXMJMIH�[MXL�XLEXWMHI�WYTTSVXXLISXLIV�WMHI�*SV�I\EQTPI��XLI�JEGX�XLEX�XLIVI�MW�E�LERHJYP�SJ�.I[MWL�,SPS�GEYWX�HIRMIVW EW�[IPP�EW�WSQI�TVSQMRIRX�.I[W��PMOI�2SEQ�'LSQWO]��[LSEVI�TVITEVIH�XS�IRHSVWI�XLI�©I\XIRWMZI�VIWIEVGLª�HSRI�F]�E�,SPSGEYWXHIRMIV HSIW�RSX�QIER�XLEX�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�HMH�RSX�SGGYV��2SV�HSIW�XLIJEGX�XLEX�WSQI�-XEPMER�.I[W�WYTTSVXIH�1YWWSPMRM�MR�XLI�IEVP]�����W�TVSZIXLEX�JEWGMWQ�[EW�VMKLX��=IX�E�WXETPI�SJ�TVS�4EPIWXMRMER�TVSTEKERHE�MW�XLIEVKYQIRX�XLEX�MW�WXVYGXYVIH�EW�JSPPS[W��©7II��IZIR�E�.I[�PMOI�?JMPP�MR�XLIREQIA�FIPMIZIW�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�[VSRK�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI�VMKLX�EFSYX�?JMPPMR�XLI�MWWYIA�ª�8LMW�©EVKYQIRX�F]�IXLRMG�EHQMWWMSRª�MW�FSXL�PSKMGEPP]�ERHIQTMVMGEPP]�JEPPEGMSYW�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 232: The Case For Israel

-R�SVHIV�XS�EWWIWW�XLI�WXEXYW�SJ�-WVEIP�MR�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��MXQE]�FI�YWIJYP�XS�PSSO�EX�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX¬W�SRP]�HIQSGVEG]�EW�©XLI�.I[ªEQSRK�REXMSRW��4VMZEXIP]�EHQMVIH�JSV�MXW�TMSRIIVMRK�WTMVMX��MRXIPPMKIRGI�

EKKVIWWMZIRIWW��ERH�XIREGMX]��XLI�7XEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�TYFPMGP]�GSRHIQRIHEW�VEGMWX��QMPMXERX��\IRSTLSFMG��YRGSQTVSQMWMRK��EYXLSVMXEVMER��ERH�WXMJJ�RIGOIH��(YVMRK�MXW�GIRXYV]�ERH�E�UYEVXIV§PSRK�WXVYKKPI�JSV�REXMSRLSSH�ERHWYVZMZEP�JSPPS[MRK�QMPPIRRME�SJ�JSVGIH�HMWTIVWMSR�ERH�I\MPI��XLI�QSHIVRTVIWXEXI�ERH�7XEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�JEV�JVSQ�TIVJIGX�MR�MXW�EHLIVIRGI�XS�MXWS[R�TVSJIWWIH�IPIZEXIH�ZEPYIW�ERH�XLSWI�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��LYQERVMKLXW��ERH�GMZMP�PMFIVXMIW��HIWGVMFIH�GSPPIGXMZIP]�EW�©XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[ª �

&YX��EW�WXEXIH�EX�XLI�SYXWIX��MX�MW�XLI�XLIWMW�SJ�XLMW�FSSO�XLEX�RS�REXMSR�MRXLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�XLEX�LEW�JEGIH�GSQTEVEFPI�XLVIEXW�XS�MXW�WYVZMZEPFSXL�I\XIVREP�ERH�MRXIVREPLEW�IZIV�QEHI�KVIEXIV�IJJSVXW�EX��ERH�LEW�IZIVGSQI�GPSWIV�XS��EGLMIZMRK�XLI�LMKL�RSVQW�SJ�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��=IX�RS�GMZMPMIHREXMSR�MR�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�[SVPH��MRGPYHMRK�XSXEPMXEVMER�ERH�EYXLSVMXEVMERVIKMQIW��LEW�IZIV�FIIR�EW�VITIEXIHP]��YRJEMVP]��ERH�L]TSGVMXMGEPP]�GSR�HIQRIH�ERH�GVMXMGMIH�F]�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�EW�-WVEIP�LEW�FIIRSZIV�XLI�]IEVW��8LI�RIX�VIWYPX�MW�XLEX�XLI�KYPJFIX[IIR�-WVEIP¬W�EGXYEPVIGSVHSJ�GSQTPMERGI�[MXL�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�ERH�MXW�TIVGIMZIHVIGSVH�SJ�GSQTPMERGI[MXL�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�MW�KVIEXIV�XLER�JSV�ER]�SXLIV�REXMSR�MR�LMWXSV]�

-�GLEPPIRKI�ER]SRI�XS�HMWTYXI�XLMW�GSRGPYWMSR�F]�REQMRK�ERSXLIV�GSYR�XV]�MR�[LMGL�XLI�KYPJ�MW�IUYEP�SV�KVIEXIV��2SRI�IZIR�GSQIW�GPSWI��EPXLSYKLJSV�WSQI�%QIVMGE�FEWLIVW�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�QE]�FI�E�HMWXERX�WIGSRH�XS

���

'SRGPYWMSR

-WVEIPhXLI�.I[�EQSRK2EXMSRW

Page 233: The Case For Israel

-WVEIP��8LI�YRHIVP]MRK�VIEWSR�JSV�XLMW�QMWPIEHMRK�KYPJ�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP¬W�MQTIV�JIGXMSRW ERH�XLIVI�EVI�QER] LEZI�FIIR�KVIEXP]�I\EKKIVEXIH�F]�PEVKIWIKQIRXW�SJ�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��XLI�QIHME��XLI�EGEHIQ]��ERHTYFPMG�STMRMSR��[LMPI�XLI�GSQTEVEXMZI�MQTIVJIGXMSRW�SJ�SXLIV�GSYRXVMIWLEZI�FIIR�QMRMQMIH�

-R�XLI�MRXIVIWXW�SJ�JEMVRIWW�ERH�TIEGI��XLI�[SVPH�QYWX�GSQI�XS�WII�-WVEIPMR�E�VIEPMWXMG�[E]��-X�QYWX�WXST�PSSOMRK�SRP]�JSV�MQTIVJIGXMSRW��ERH�XLIRQEKRMJ]MRK�XLIQ�EPP�SYX�SJ�TVSTSVXMSR�FSXL�XS�-WVEIP¬W�S[R�TSWMXMZIEGGSQTPMWLQIRXW�ERH�XS�XLI�MQTIVJIGXMSRW�SJ�SXLIV�REXMSRW�

-WVEIP�MW�E�XMR]�REXMSR��[MXL�JI[�REXYVEP�VIWSYVGIW�ERH�PMXXPI�REXYVEP[IEPXL��XLEX�LEW�LEH�XS�HIZSXI�ER�IRSVQSYW�TIVGIRXEKI�SJ�MXW�KVSWWREXMSREP�TVSHYGX�XS�HIJIRHMRK�MXWIPJ�EKEMRWX�I\XIVREP�ERH�MRXIVREP�IRIQMIW�=IX�MX�LEW�RSX�SRP]�GVIEXIH�E�KSSH�PMJI�JSV�MXW�.I[MWL�GMXMIRW��MX�LEW�LIPTIHMXW�%VEF�GMXMIRW�PMZI�FIXXIV�PMZIW EW�QIEWYVIH�F]�MRGSQI��LIEPXL�PSRKIZMX]��ERH�SXLIV�EGGITXIH�GVMXIVME XLER�XLI�%VEFW�SJ�ER]�RIMKLFSVMRKGSYRXVMIW��-X�WLSYPH�RSX�FI�WYVTVMWMRK�XLEX�E�TSPP�SJ�XLI�%VEF�-WVEIPM�VIWM�HIRXW�SJ�9QQ�IP�*ELQ�GSRHYGXIH�F]�XLI�%VEF�-WVEIPM�[IIOP]�TETIV�/YP%P�%VEFMR������WLS[IH�E�WXVMOMRK����TIVGIRX�STTSWIH�XS�MRGPYHMRK�XLIMVGMX]�MR�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��8LI�VIEWSR�KMZIR�F]�E�QENSVMX]�SJ�XLSWI�STTSWIH[EW�XLEX�XLI]�[ERXIH�XS�VIQEMR�YRHIV�HIQSGVEXMG�VYPI�ERH�XLI]�IRNS]IH�EKSSH�UYEPMX]�SJ�PMJI��%PXLSYKL�XLIVI�MW�QYGL�XS�FI�GVMXMGMIH��ERH�TVSKVIWWXS�FI�QEHI��MR�XLI�IGSRSQMG�MRIUYEPMX]�FIX[IIR�.I[W�ERH�%VEFW�PMZMRK�MR-WVEIP��XLI�[SVPH�WLSYPH�EGORS[PIHKI�XLI�FIRIJMXW�XLEX�XLI�HIQSGVEXMG�WXEXISJ�-WVEIP�FVMRKW�XS�XLI�%VEFW�PMZMRK�ERH�[SVOMRK�[MXLMR�MXW�FSVHIVW�

3TTSRIRXW�SJ�-WVEIP�XIRH�XS�IQTLEWMI�XLI�HMWTEVMX]�FIX[IIR�-WVEIPM%VEFW�ERH�.I[W��[LMPI�LEVHP]�QIRXMSRMRK�LS[�QYGL�FIXXIV�-WVEIPM�%VEFWJEVI�XLER�XLIMV�GSYRXIVTEVXW�MR�XLI�%VEF�WXEXIW��-R�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH)YVSTI�RI[WTETIVW�VSYXMRIP]�GMXI�XLI�JEGX�XLEX�-WVEIPM�%VEFW�LEZI�XLI�PS[�IWX�EZIVEKI�JEQMP]�MRGSQI�SJ�ER]�IXLRMG�KVSYT�MR�-WVEIP��EW�[IPP�EW�XLI�LMKL�IWX�MRJERX�QSVXEPMX]�VEXI��EW�HS�QMRSVMX]�KVSYTW�MR�QSWX�GSYRXVMIW�MRGPYHMRK�SYV�S[R ��*I[�TSMRX�SYX��LS[IZIV��XLEX�%VEF�JEQMPMIW�XIRH�XSFI�QYGL�PEVKIV�HIWTMXIXLI�MRJERX�QSVXEPMX]�VEXI��SV�XLEX�[SQIR�EVI�HMW�GSYVEKIH�JVSQ�[SVOMRK�MR�XLI�%VEF�GSQQYRMX] JEGXW�XLEX�I\TPEMR�WSQISJ�XLI�HMWGVITERGMIW��)ZIR�XLI�ZIV]�GVMXMGEP�KVSYT�7MOOY]��[LMGL�QSRMXSVWGMZMG�IUYEPMX]�EQSRK�.I[W�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW��EGORS[PIHKIW�XLEX�XLIVI�LEZIFIIR�KSSH�JEMXL�IJJSVXW�SR�XLI�TEVX�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�XS�MQTVSZI%VEF�MRJVEWXVYGXYVI�ERH�IHYGEXMSREP�MRWXMXYXMSRW��

-WVEIP¬W�LIEPXL�GEVI�W]WXIQ�EPWS�H[EVJW�XLEX�SJ�MXW�RIMKLFSVW��XS�XLI�FIR�IJMX�SJ�EPP�MXW�GMXMIRW��-WVEIP�LEW�REXMSREP�LIEPXL�MRWYVERGI��[LMGL�KYEVERXIIWLIEPXL�GEVI�XS�EPP�SJ�MXW�GMXMIRW��VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�VEGI�SV�VIPMKMSR��%GGIWW�XS�WYGLGEVI�LEW�LIPTIH�XS�VEMWI�XLI�PMJI�I\TIGXERG]�SJ�-WVEIPM�%VEFW�XS�[IPP�EFSZIXLEX�SJ�%VEF�RIMKLFSVW��ERH�XS�HVMZI�XLIMV�MRJERX�QSVXEPMX]�VEXIW�XS�[IPPFIPS[��%PXLSYKL�PMJI�I\TIGXERG]�MW�WSQI[LEX�PS[IV�JSV�-WVEIPM�4EPIWXMRMERW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 234: The Case For Israel

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

XLER�JSV�-WVEIPM�.I[W WIZIRX]�WIZIR�]IEVW�JSV�[SQIR�ERH�WIZIRX]�JSYV�JSVQIR�VEXLIV�XLER�IMKLX]�ERH�WIZIRX]�WM\�VIWTIGXMZIP]� MX�MW�WXMPP�[IPP�EFSZIXLEX�SJ�7]VME��[LMGL�MW�SRP]�MR�XLI�YTTIV�WM\XMIW�JSV�FSXL��

7]VME�MW�E�VIWSYVGI�VMGL�GSYRXV]��FYX�PMOI�-VEU��MXW�[IEPXL�LEW�FIIR�YWIHXS�PMRI�MXW�PIEHIVW¬�TSGOIXW�VEXLIV�XLER�SR�REXMSREP�LIEPXL��%VEJEX�MW�RS[SRI�SJ�XLI�VMGLIWX�QIR�MR�XLI�[SVPH��FYX�PMXXPI�SJ�LMW�I\XSVXIH�FSYRX]�MWWTIRX�SR�LSWTMXEPW�SV�LIEPXL�GEVI��-X�MW�YRJEMV�XS�GVMXMGMI�-WVEIP�JSV�MXW�PEGO�SJ�TIVJIGX�TEVMX]�[LMPI�RSX�GVMXMGMMRK�XLIWI�SXLIV�PIEHIVW�JSV�XLIMV�GSQTPIXIPEGO�SJ�IJJSVX��-R�XVYXL��-WVEIPM�LIEPXL�GEVI�LEW�PMOIP]�WEZIH�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERPMZIW�XLER�XLI�GEVI�EZEMPEFPI�MR�QER]�SJ�XLI�RIMKLFSVMRK�GSYRXVMIW�GSQ�FMRIH�

8LI�-WVEIPM�IGSRSQ]�EPWS�GVIEXIW�LIEPXL�FIRIJMXW�FI]SRH�MXW�FSVHIVW�-WVEIP�LEW�FIGSQI�E�[SVPH�PIEHIV�MR�FMSXIGLRSPSK]��[MXL�-WVEIPM�GSQTERMIWPIEHMRK�XLI�[E]�MR�IPIQIRXW�SJ�GERGIV�ERH�EYXSMQQYRI�HMWIEWI�VIWIEVGL�8LIVI�EVI�RS[�SZIV�����FMSXIGL�GSQTERMIW�MR�-WVEIP��[MXL�LYRHVIHW�SJQMPPMSRW�SJ�TVMZEXI�HSPPEVW�MRZIWXIH��TVSZMHMRK�XLSYWERHW�SJ�NSFW�ERH�LYR�HVIHW�SJ�LIEPXL�MQTVSZMRK�TVSHYGXW ���TIVGIRX�SJ�[LMGL�EVI�JSV�I\TSVX��

;MXL�GPSWI�XMIW�XS�-WVEIP¬W�JPSYVMWLMRK�VIWIEVGL�YRMZIVWMXMIW�ERH�IHYGEXMSREPW]WXIQ��EW�[IPP�EW�WYTTSVX�JVSQ�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX��-WVEIPM�FMSXIGL�LEWFIGSQI�MRHYWXV]�PIEHMRK��TVSZMHMRK�EHZERGIW�MR�VIWIEVGL�SR�4EVOMRWSR¬WERH�%PLIMQIV¬W��QYPXMTPI�WGPIVSWMW��ERH�SXLIV�HMWIEWIW�XLEX�EVI�XLI�GEYWI�SJKVIEX�WYJJIVMRK��2S[��XVEKMGEPP]��MX�LEW�FIGSQI�XLI�[SVPH¬W�PIEHIV�MR�XLIQIHMGEP�XVIEXQIRX�SJ�MRNYVMIW�GEYWIH�F]�XIVVSVMWQ��-WVEIPM�GSQTERMIW�ERH-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�VIWIEVGL�HSPPEVW�EVI�WEZMRK�PMZIW�FSXL�MR�-WVEIP�ERHEFVSEH��ERH�XLI�WEQI�WMQTP]�GERRSX�FI�WEMH�SJ�ER]�SXLIV�GSYRXV]�MR�XLIVIKMSR�HIWTMXI�XLIMV�QYGL�KVIEXIV�WLEVI�SJ�REXYVEP�VIWSYVGIW��8LEX�-WVEIPWLSYPH�FI�WS�ZMPPEMRMIH�JSV�MXW�MRIUYEPMXMIW MRIUYEPMXMIW�XLEX�TPEKYI�IZIV]GSYRXV] HIWTMXI�MXW�HMWTVSTSVXMSREXIP]�PEVKI�GSRXVMFYXMSRW�MR�LIEPXL�GEVI�WMQTP]�WLS[W�XLEX�ER�YRJEMV�ZMI[�MW�XEOIR�SJ�XLI�VIEP�FIRIJMXW�XLEX�XLI�-WVEIPMIGSRSQ]�ERH�LIEPXL�GEVI�W]WXIQ�TVSZMHI��FSXL�MR�-WVEIP�ERH�EVSYRH�XLI[SVPH�

)ZIR�EWMHI�JVSQ�QIHMGMRI��-WVEIPM�VIWIEVGL�SR�QER]�WYFNIGXW��VERKMRKJVSQ�GSQTYXIV�XIGLRSPSK]�XS�EVGLISPSK]��MW�EQSRK�XLI�QSWX�VIWTIGXIH�MRXLI�[SVPH�

8LI�TSMRX�XLEX�MW�SJXIR�MKRSVIH�MW�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�FIGSQI XLVSYKLLEVH�[SVO��MRKIRYMX]��ERH�QSWX�SJ�EPP��HIHMGEXMSR�XS�JVIIHSQ�ERH�XLI�VYPISJ�PE[ E�JPSYVMWLMRK�ERH�HMZIVWI�HIQSGVEG]�[MXL�E�FYWXPMRK�IGSRSQ]��EZMFVERX�ERH�GVMXMGEP�QIHME��E�GVIEXMZI�EVXMWXMG�GYPXYVI��ERH�E�GSQQMXQIRX�XSIUYEPMX]�FEWIH�SR�KIRHIV��WI\YEP�SVMIRXEXMSR��ERH�VEGI��3XLIV�GSYRXVMIW�MRXLI�VIKMSR��[LMGL�LEZI�QSVI�REXYVEP�VIWSYVGIW�ERH�GSQTEVEFPI�EQSYRXW�SJJSVIMKR�EMH��LEZI�JEMPIH�XS�XVERWPEXI�XLIWI�EWWIXW�MRXS�FIRIJMXW�XS�XLIMVTISTPI��1SVISZIV��XLI�VIPEXMZIP]�WXVSRK�-WVEIPM�IGSRSQ]�QEXIVMEPP]GSRXVMFYXIW�XS�XLI�[IPP�FIMRK�SJ�EPP-WVEIPMW��VIKEVHPIWW�SJ�XLIMV�VIPMKMSR�

Page 235: The Case For Israel

IXLRMGMX]��SV�VEGI��ERH�XLI�KET�FIX[IIR�.I[MWL�ERH�RSR�.I[MWL�-WVEIPMW�[MPPWYVIP]�GPSWI�IZIR�JYVXLIV�MJ�TIEGI�MW�EGLMIZIH�

4VSJIWWSV�%QRSR�6YFIRWXIMR E�WXVSRK�WYTTSVXIV�SJ�E�TIEGIJYP�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ERH�E�JVIUYIRX�GVMXMG�SJ�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX�TSPMGMIW [IPPWYQQEVMIH�-WVEIP¬W�EGLMIZIQIRXW�SR�MXW�JMJX]�JMJXL�FMVXLHE]�

-WVEIP�GER�PSSO�FEGO[EVHW�[MXL�XVIQIRHSYW�TVMHI��1MRYXI�MR�WMI��RSX

QYGL�FMKKIV�XLER�E�WPMZIV�SJ�1IHMXIVVERIER�GSEWXPMRI��MX�LEW�[MXLWXSSH

GSRXMRYMRK�%VEF�SRWPEYKLXW��[EVW��FS]GSXX�ERH�XIVVSVMWQ��MX�LEW�XYVRIH

MXWIPJ�JVSQ�E�TSSV��VYVEP�GSYRXV]�XS�ER�MRHYWXVMEP�ERH�TSWX�MRHYWXVMEP�TS[�

IVLSYWI��HIWTMXI�XLI�PSRK�VSEH�ELIEH��ERH�XLI�RIIH�JSV�JYVXLIV�MRXIKVE�

XMSR��MX�LEW�VIHYGIH�WSGMEP��IHYGEXMSREP�ERH�LIEPXL�KETW�FIX[IIR�MXW

ZEVMSYW�GSQTSRIRXW��MRGPYHMRK�KETW�FIX[IIR�%VEFW�ERH�.I[W��7SQI�SJ�MXW

EGLMIZIQIRXW�EVI�YRTVIGIHIRXIH��-WVEIPM�%VEFW�LEZI�E�LMKLIV�PMJI�

I\TIGXERG]�XLER�QSWX�)YVSTIER�[LMXIW��MXW�HIQSGVEG]�JYRGXMSRW��MRWMHI

-WVEIP�TVSTIV��MR�XMQIW�SJ�KVIEX�REXMSREP�IQIVKIRG]��MX�FSEWXW�SJ�XLI�QSWX

EGXMZMWXW�ERH�MRXIVZIRXMSRMWX�GSYVXW�MR�XLI�[SVPH��[LS�HS�RSX�JIEV�XS�XVIEH

[LIVI�SXLIV�GSYVXW�WLYR�MRXIVZIRXMSR��MX�LEW�QEMRXEMRIH�JVIIHSQ�SJ�XLI

TVIWW�MR�XMQI�SJ�[EV��MX�WXERHW�SYX�EW�E�WMRKYPEV�HIQSGVEXMG��JMVWX�[SVPH

MWPERH�MR�E�WIE�SJ�%VEF�ERH�1SWPIQ�TSZIVX]�ERH�FEGO[EVHRIWW�

=IX��XLIWI�VIEPMXMIW�EVI�SJXIR�MKRSVIH�SV�HMWXSVXIH�MR�E�HIPMFIVEXI�IJJSVX�XSHIQSRMI�-WVEIP�

-�GER�IEWMP]�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�XLI�SMP�MRXIVIWXW�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�QMKLX�WIIO�XSHMWXSVX�XLI�JEGXW�MR�SVHIV�XS�JEZSV�XLI�%VEFW��[LS�GSRXVSP�QYGL�SJ�XLI[SVPH¬W�SMP�ERH�KEW�VIWIVZIW��SZIV�XLI�-WVEIPMW��[LS�KEZI�FEGO�XLI�SRP]�SMPJMIPHW�XLI]�LEH�MR�SVHIV�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[MXL�)K]TX��-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]-WPEQMG�JYRHEQIRXEPMWXW�JEZSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��[LS�LEZI�TVSQMWIH�XSIWXEFPMWL�ER�-WPEQMG�WXEXI��SZIV�XLI�-WVEIPMW��[LS�LEZI�E�PEVKIP]�WIGYPEV�.I[�MWL�HIQSGVEG]��-�GER�IZIR�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�ERXM�7IQMXIW��PMOI�4EX�&YGLERERERH�(EZMH�(YOI��JEZSV�XLI�VEHMGEP��ERXM�'LVMWXMER��ERH�ERXM�%QIVMGER4EPIWXMRMERW��[LSQ�XLI]�[SYPH�SVHMREVMP]�HIWTMWI�MJ�XLI]�[IVI�JMKLXMRK�ER]�SRI�IPWI�FYX�XLI�.I[W��-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�WI\MWXW��LSQSTLSFIW��ERHVEGMWXW�[SYPH�JEZSV�XLSWI�[LS�HMWGVMQMREXI�EKEMRWX�[SQIR��KE]W��ERH�RSR�1YWPMQW��SZIV�XLI�-WVEIPMW��[LS�EVI�GSQQMXXIH�XS�IUYEPMX]�

-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�XLSWI�[LS�HS�RSX�ZEPYI�LYQER�PMJI�JEZSV�KVSYTW[LS�TVSQSXI�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRK�ERH�XLI�QYVHIV�SJ�GMZMPMERW��SZIV�-WVEIP�[LMGL�ZEPYIW�IZIV]�LYQER�PMJI��-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�XLSWI�[LS�HS�RSXGEVI�EFSYX�GLMPHVIR�JEZSV�XIVVSVMWXW��[LS�EFYWI�XLIMV�S[R�GLMPHVIR�F]�XYVR�MRK�XLIQ�MRXS�WYMGMHI�FSQFIVW�ERH�TPEGMRK�XLIMV�FSQF�JEGXSVMIW�RI\X�XSOMRHIVKEVXIRW��ERH�[LS�EFYWI�XLI�GLMPHVIR�SJ�SXLIVW�F]�XEVKIXMRK�XLIQ�JSVXIVVSVMWQ��SZIV�-WVEIPMW��[LS�XV]�XS�OIIT�GLMPHVIR�E[E]�JVSQ�GSQFEX�

-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�XLI�I\XVIQI�VEHMGEP�PIJX��[LMGL�JEZSVW�MRWXEFMPMX]

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 236: The Case For Israel

SZIV�WXEFMPMX]��[SYPH�JEZSV�XLI�VEHMGEP�HIWXEFMPMMRK�MQTEGX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERXIVVSVMWQ�SZIV�XLI�WXEFMPMX]�SJ�-WVEIP��-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�WSQI�[LS�LEXIXLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��JVIIHSQ��ERH�HIQSGVEG]�JEZSV�XLSWI�[LS�LEZI�WMHIH[MXL�%QIVMGE¬W�IRIQMIW XLI�/EMWIV��,MXPIV��7XEPMR��7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR��ERH3WEQE�FMR�0EHIR SZIV�SRI�SJ�%QIVMGE¬W�QSWX�PS]EP�ERH�ZEPYEFPI�HIQS�GVEXMG�EPPMIW�

-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�XLI�RIS�JEWGMWX�VMKLX��[LMGL�FIQSERW�,MXPIV¬W�JEMP�YVI�XS�GSQTPIXI�LMW�KIRSGMHI��[SYPH�JEZSV�XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP��-�GERYRHIVWXERH�[L]�XLSWI�[LS�FIPMIZI�XLEX�GSRJPMGX�WLSYPH�FI�VIWSPZIH�F]�ZMS�PIRGI�VEXLIV�XLER�F]�RIKSXMEXMSRW�[SYPH�JEZSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIV��[LS[EPOIH�E[E]�JVSQ�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�[MXLSYX�SJJIVMRK�ER]�TIEGI�TVS�TSWEP�ERH�VIRI[IH�XLI�ZMSPIRGI��SZIV�-WVEIP��[LMGL�LEW�EP[E]W�FIIR�[MPPMRKXS�RIKSXMEXI�ERH�EGGITX�GSQTVSQMWI��-�GER�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�EPP�SJ�XLIWI[SYPH�JEZSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�GEYWI�SZIV�XLI�-WVEIPM�GEYWI�

&YX�-�GERRSX�JSV�XLI�PMJI�SJ�QI�YRHIVWXERH�[L]�TIEGI�PSZMRK�TISTPIGSQQMXXIH�XS�IUYEPMX]�ERH�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�WLSYPH�JEZSV�XLI�WMHI�XLEXVINIGXW�EPP�XLI�ZEPYIW�XLI]�LSPH�HIEV�ERH�STTSWI�XLI�WMHI�XLEX�TVSQSXIWXLIWI�ZEPYIW��;LEX�XLIR�I\TPEMRW�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRM�ERW�ERH�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�STTSWMXMSR�XS�-WVEIP#�-�EQ�RSX��F]�EWOMRK�XLMW�UYIW�XMSR��MRGPYHMRK�GSRWXVYGXMZI�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�SV�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�PIKMXMQEXIEWTMVEXMSRW�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TISTPI��[LS�LEZI�WYJJIVIH�KVIEXP]��EPXLSYKLQSWXP]�EX�XLI�LERHW�SJ�XLIMV�S[R�HIWXVYGXMZI�PIEHIVWLMT�ERH�XLIMV�I\TPSMXE�XMSR�F]�SXLIV�%VEF�REXMSRW�

2SV�EQ�-�VIJIVVMRK�XS�VIEWSREFPI�STTSWMXMSR�XS�ER]�TEVXMGYPEV�TVMQIQMRMWXIV��KSZIVRQIRX��TEVX]��SV�TSPMG]�SJ�-WVEIP��1ER]�WYTTSVXIVW�SJ�-WVEIPSTTSWI IZIR�WXVSRKP]�STTSWI TEVXMGYPEV�EWTIGXW�SJ�-WVEIP�EX�E�KMZIR�XMQI�EW�-�HS��-�EQ�EWOMRK�EFSYX�WSQIXLMRK�UYEPMXEXMZIP]�HMJJIVIRX��E�ZMWGIVEP�HMW�PMOI WSQIXMQIW�LEXVIH SJ�-WVEIP��GSYTPIH�[MXL�YRGVMXMGEP�WYTTSVX�SJ�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�GEYWI��IZIR�F]�XLSWI��WYGL�EW�WSQI�5YEOIVW �[LS�[SYPH�RSV�QEPP]�FI�ETTEPPIH�F]�XIVVSVMWQ��XLSWI��WYGL�EW�WSQI�TVS�%QIVMGER�TEXVMSXW [LS�[SYPH�RSVQEPP]�FI�SYXVEKIH�EX�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�4EPIWXMRMER�WYTTSVX�JSV%QIVMGE¬W�IRIQMIW��XLSWI��PMOI�WSQI�JIQMRMWXW �[LS�[SYPH�YWYEPP]�VEMPEKEMRWX�XLI�WI\MWX�TVEGXMGIW�SJ�QER]�4EPIWXMRMERW��XLSWI��PMOI�WSQI�GMZMP�PMF�IVXEVMERW �[LS�[SYPH�RIZIV�XSPIVEXI�XLI�PE[PIWWRIWW�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMEREYXLSVMX]��XLSWI��PMOI�WSQI�PIJXMWXW �[LS�[SYPH�RSVQEPP]�FI�STTSWIH�XS�XLIJMRERGMEP�GSVVYTXMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�ERH�XLIMV�I\TPSMXEXMSR�SJ4EPIWXMRMER�[SVOIVW��ERH�XLSWI��PMOI�WSQI�MRXIVREXMSREPMWXW �[LS�[SYPHRIZIV�NYWXMJ]�XLI�GPEMQ�SJ�QER]�4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�HIWXVS]�E�QIQFIV�REXMSR�SJXLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�ERH�XS�XEVKIX�RSRGSQFEXERXW�JSV�XIVVSVMWQ�

;LIR�MX�GSQIW�XS�STTSWMXMSR�XS�-WVEIP�ERH�WYTTSVX�JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERGEYWI��GSRWMWXIRG]�WIIQW�XS�FI�JSVKSXXIR��8LI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MW�WYM�KIRIVMW�-XMW�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�I\TPEMR�XLI�EXXMXYHIW�SJ�QER]�SXLIV[MWI�VEXMSREP�TISTPIERH�MRWXMXYXMSRW�F]�VIJIVIRGI�XS�TVMRGMTPIW�SJ�VEXMSREPMX]��QSVEPMX]��SV

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 237: The Case For Israel

GSRWMWXIRG]��%PP�SJ�XLIWI�WIIQ�XS�JP]�SYX�XLI�[MRHS[�[LIR�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXIMW�FIMRK�HMWGYWWIH�

:EVMSYW�I\TPEREXMSRW�LEZI�FIIR�SJJIVIH�JSV�XLMW�ERSQEP]��*MVWX��KSSHTISTPI�JEZSV�XLI�YRHIVHSK��ERH�XLI�WXEXIPIWW�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI�XLI�YRHIV�HSKW�MR�XLIMV�WXVYKKPI�EKEMRWX�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�F]�XLI�TS[IVJYP�-WVEIPM�WXEXI�7IGSRH��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI�TISTPI�SJ�GSPSV��[LMPI�XLI�-WVEIPMW�EVI�[LMXI)YVSTIERW��8LMVH��-WVEIP�MW�E�XSSP�SJ�XLI�MQTIVMEPMWX�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��[LMPIXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI�E�XLMVH�[SVPH�TISTPI��*SYVXL��KSSH�TISTPI�LEZI�GSQIXS�I\TIGX�QSVI�SJ�XLI�.I[W�XLER�XLI]�HS�SJ�XLI�%VEFW��*MJXL��HIGIRX�TIS�TPI�ORS[�XLEX�XLI]�GERRSX�MRJPYIRGI�%VEF�FILEZMSV��FYX�XLI]�GER�MRJPYIRGIXLI�FILEZMSV�SJ�-WVEIP��)EGL�SJ�XLIWI�EVKYQIRXW VIEPP]�VEXMSREPMEXMSR MWHIQSRWXVEFP]�JEPWI�ERH�WSQI�WQEGO�SJ�FPEXERX�VEGMWQ�

:MI[IH�JVSQ�XLI�KPSFEP�TIVWTIGXMZI��-WVEIP��EW�XLI�[SVPH¬W�SRP]�.I[MWLREXMSR��MW�GPIEVP]�XLI�YRHIVHSK��8LI�4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�XLI�[MHIWTVIEH�WYT�TSVX�SJ�E�FMPPMSR�1YWPMQW��%HH�XS�XLEX�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��XLI�)YVSTIERGSQQYRMX]��XLI�XLMVH�[SVPH��XLI�:EXMGER��QER]�MRJPYIRXMEP�EGEHIQMGW��XLIMRXIVREXMSREP�PIJX��XLI�JEV�VMKLX��ERH�QER]�4VSXIWXERX�GLYVGLIW��8LI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�LEZI�JEV�QSVI�WYTTSVX�XLER�XLI�8MFIXERW��XLI�/YVHW��XLI�%VQIRMERW�XLI�'LIGLIRW��ERH�SXLIV�VIEP�YRHIVHSKW��1SVISZIV��XLI�REXMSRW�XLEX�EVISTTVIWWMRK�XLIWI�SXLIV�YRHIVHSK�KVSYTW 'LMRE��8YVOI]��ERH�6YWWME EVIJEV�QSVI�TS[IVJYP�XLER�XMR]�-WVEIP�[MXL�XLI�TSTYPEXMSR�SJ�ETTVS\MQEXIP]�����QMPPMSR�.I[W�ERH������QMPPMSR�%VEFW��=IX�XLIWI�SXLIV�©YRHIVHSKWªVIGIMZI�PMXXPI�WYTTSVX�JVSQ�XLSWI�[LS�GLEQTMSR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�

-WVEIP�MW�XLI�YRHIVHSK�MR�]IX�ERSXLIV��IZIR�QSVI�HERKIVSYW��[E]��-XGERRSX�EJJSVH�XS�PSWI�IZIR�E�WMRKPI�[EV�[MXLSYX�I\TSWMRK�MXW�TSTYPEXMSR�XSKIRSGMHI�ERH�MXW�REXMSRLSSH�XS�TSPMXMGMHI��;EVW�[EKIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�EVI[EVW�SJ�I\XIVQMREXMSR�XLEX�XEVKIX�MXW�GMXMIW�ERH�TSTYPEXMSR�GIRXIVW��-XW�IRI�QMIW�EVI�WIIOMRK�MXW�XSXEP�HIWXVYGXMSR�

-WVEIP��MR�GSRXVEWX��EZSMHW�XEVKIXMRK�GMXMIW�ERH�GMZMPMERW�ERH�HSIW�RSX�WIIOXLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�ER]�RIMKLFSVMRK�WXEXI��8LI�WXEOIW�EVI�JEV�KVIEXIV�JSV-WVEIP�XLER�JSV�ER]�SJ�MXW�IRIQMIW��ERH�HIWTMXI�MXW�GYVVIRX�QMPMXEV]WXVIRKXL [LMGL�MW�EFWSPYXIP]�RIGIWWEV]�EW�E�HIXIVVIRX�EKEMRWX�IRIQ]EKKVIWWMSRW -WVEIP�MW�GPIEVP]�XLI�YRHIVHSK�SZIV�XLI�PSRK�XIVQ�SJ�LMWXSV]�8LI�YRHIVHSK�VEXMSREPI�JSV�WYTTSVXMRK�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MW�WLSVX�WMKLXIHERH�MRGSRWMWXIRX�[MXL�XLI�PEGO�SJ�WYTTSVX�JSV�VIEP�YRHIVHSKW�

;MXL�VIKEVH�XS�WYTTSVX�JSV�TISTPI�SJ�GSPSV��-WVEIP�MW�XVYP]�E�REXMSR�SJGSPSV��-X�LEW�SRI�SJ�XLI�QSWX�HMZIVWI�TSTYPEXMSRW�MR�XLI�[SVPH��MRGPYHMRKFPEGO�%JVMGERW�JVSQ�)XLMSTME��FVS[R�%JVMGERW�ERH�%WMERW�JVSQ�2SVXL%JVMGE��=IQIR��)K]TX��-VEU��ERH�1SVSGGS��.I[W�JVSQ�'IRXVEP�%WME��6YWWME�ERH�XLI�'EYGEWYW��ERH�JEQMPMIW�JVSQ�6SQERME��0EXMR�%QIVMGE��ERH�XLI�JSV�QIV�=YKSWPEZME��2IPWSR�1ERHIPE�[EW�WMQTP]�[VSRK�[LIR�LI�HIWGVMFIH-WVEIP�EW�E�©[LMXIª�REXMSR�EW�GSRXVEWXIH�[MXL�-VEU��[LMGL�LI�GEPPIH�E©FPEGOª�REXMSR�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 238: The Case For Israel

%W�JEV�EW�-WVEIP�FIMRK�E�XSSP�SJ�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��XLEX�MW�WMQTP]�JEPWI��-XMW�ER�EPP]��&SXL�GSYRXVMIW�EVI�HIQSGVEGMIW�JMKLXMRK�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ��-WVEIPMW�EPWS�ER�MRHITIRHIRX�REXMSR�TYVWYMRK�MXW�S[R�WIPJ�MRXIVIWX��-X�[EW�IWXEF�PMWLIH�[MXL�XLI�WYTTSVX�SJ�XLI�7SZMIX�9RMSR��[LMGL�SVMKMREPP]�VIGSKRMIHMX�FIGEYWI�SJ�MXW�WSGMEPMWX�VSSXW��-X�EPPMIH�MXWIPJ�[MXL�)RKPERH�ERH�*VERGI[LIR�)K]TX�REXMSREPMIH�XLI�7YI�'EREP��-X�LEW�EWWMWXIH�FPEGO�%JVMGERREXMSRW�[MXL�MXW�XIGLRMGEP�I\TIVXMWI�ERH�SXLIV�JSVQW�SJ�EMH�

8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�LEW�SJXIR�STTSWIH�-WVEIP¬W�TSPMGMIW��EW�MR�XLI�7YIQEXXIV�ERH�[LIR�MX�GSYPH�LEZI�HIWXVS]IH�XLI�IRGMVGPIH�)K]TXMER�EVQ]�MR������8LI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�WYTTSVXIH�-WVEIP¬W�IJJSVXW�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[MXL�XLI4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�����§������ERH�4VIWMHIRX�&MPP�'PMRXSR�PEMH�XLI�IRXMVIFPEQI�JSV�XLI�GSPPETWI�SJ�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�EX�XLIJIIX�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��[LIVI�MX�FIPSRKW��8LI�GPSWI�FYX�MRHITIRHIRX�VIPE�XMSRWLMT�FIX[IIR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�-WVEIPFEWIH�SR�QYXYEP�TVMRGMTPIWSJ�HIQSGVEG]��IUYEPMX]��ERH�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[ MW�ER�EVKYQIRX�JSV�WYTTSVXMRK-WVEIP��RSX�JSV�ETTP]MRK�E�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�SJ�GSRHIQREXMSR�EKEMRWX�MX�I\GITX�JSV�XLSWI�[LS�LEXI�IZIV]XLMRK�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�WXERHW�JSV��PMOI2SEQ�'LSQWO]��[LS�FIPMIZIW�XLEX�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�MW�XLI�PIEHIV�SJ�XLIVIEP�©%\MW�SJ�)ZMP�ª�2SX�WYVTVMWMRKP]��'LSQWO]¬W�©%\MW�SJ�)ZMPª�EPWSMRGPYHIW�-WVEIP�ERH�8YVOI]�� ERH�I\GPYHIW�0MF]E��-VER��'YFE��2SVXL/SVIE��ERH�IZIR�7EHHEQ�,YWWIMR¬W�-VEU�

8LI�EVKYQIRX�XLEX�QSVI�WLSYPH�FI�I\TIGXIH�SJ�XLI�.I[W�ERH�PIWW�SJ�XLI%VEFW��ERH�XLEX�XLI�©VEXMSREPª�-WVEIPMW�EVI�QSVI�WYFNIGX�XS�TVIWWYVI�XLERXLI�©MVVEXMSREPª�4EPIWXMRMERW��MW�TVMQMXMZI�VEGMWQ��-X�EPWS�GVIEXIW�WIPJ�JYPJMPP�MRK�TVSTLIGMIW�F]�I\TIGXMRK�XLI�%VEFW�XS�EGX�MVVEXMSREPP]��%R�-WVEIPM�QE]�FIIRXMXPIH�XS�I\TIGX�QSVI�SJ�-WVEIP��NYWX�EW�ER�%QIVMGER�QE]�FI�IRXMXPIH�XSI\TIGX�QSVI�SJ�LMW�S[R�GSYRXV]�ERH�E�4EPIWXMRMER�XS�I\TIGX�QSVI�SJ�LMWS[R�TISTPI��&YX�RS�SYXWMHIV�MW�IRXMXPIH�XS�I\TIGX�QSVI�SJ�SRI�TISTPI�XLERERSXLIV��)ZIR�E�.I[�[LS�LEW�GLSWIR�RSX�XS�FIGSQI�ER�-WVEIPM�GMXMIR�ERHXS�WYJJIV�MXW�FYVHIRW�ERH�VMWOW�MW�RSX�IRXMXPIH��MR�Q]�ZMI[��XS�ETTP]�E�HSY�FPI�WXERHEVH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�ERH�RSX�XS�SXLIV�WXEXIW�

'IVXEMRP]��RS�SRI�WLSYPH�I\TIGX�PIWW�SJ�[IPP�IHYGEXIH��[IEPXL]��ERHEHZERXEKIH�4EPIWXMRMERW��PMOI�%VEJEX �SV�%VEFW��PMOI�FMR�0EHIR �XLER�SJ�XLIMV.I[MWL�GSYRXIVTEVXW��2SV�MW�MX�XVYI�XLEX�%QIVMGERW�WLSYPH�FI�EFPI�XSHIQERH�QSVI�JVSQ�-WVEIP�XLER�JVSQ�MXW�%VEF�RIMKLFSVW�FIGEYWI�-WVEIP�MW�XLIVIGMTMIRX�SJ�E�PEVKI�EQSYRX�SJ�JMRERGMEP�EMH�JVSQ�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��7YGL�ERETTVSEGL�[SYPHXYVR�-WVEIP�MRXS�ER�%QIVMGER�TYTTIX��[LMGL�MX�MW�RSX�

-WVEIP��QSVI�XLER�ER]�%VEF�REXMSR��IEVRWMXW�JMRERGMEP�EWWMWXERGI�F]TVSZMHMRK�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�[MXL�MRZEPYEFPI�MRXIPPMKIRGI�MRJSVQEXMSR�XIGLRSPSKMGEP�EHZMGI��ERH�E�HIQSGVEXMG�TVIWIRGI�MR�XLI�1MHIEWX��)K]TX�.SVHER��8YVOI]��ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��[LMGL�XSKIXLIV�VIGIMZI�EMHGSQTEVEFPI�XS�XLEX�VIGIMZIH�F]�-WVEIP��TVSZMHI�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�PMXXPI�MRVIXYVR��8LI]�VIGIMZI�JSVIMKR�EMH�MR�PEVKI�TEVX�XS�FSPWXIV�VIKMQIW�XLEX�EVI�MR

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 239: The Case For Israel

HERKIV�SJ�MRXIVREP�MRWYVVIGXMSRW��-WVEIP��EW�E�HIQSGVEG]��LEW�RS�WYGL�RIIH�8LI�FIRMKR�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�EVKYQIRX�MW�ER�I\XVIQIP]�HERKIVSYW�SRIFSVHIVMRK�SR�VEGMWQ�ERH�IRGSYVEKMRK�JYVXLIV�ZMSPIRGI�

-J�XLI�TVIZMSYW�VEXMSREPMEXMSRW�EVI�VINIGXIH��[LEX�IPWI�VIQEMRW�XSI\TPEMR�XLI�MVVEXMSREP�LEXVIH�WS�SJXIR�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�SFZM�SYW�HMWTEVMX]�FIX[IIR�VIEPMX]�ERH�TIVGITXMSR�XLEX�I\MWXW�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS-WVEIP#�3RI�SFZMSYW�ERH�HMWXYVFMRK�I\TPEREXMSR�MW�XLI�PMRKIVMRK�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�MR�QER]�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��[LMGL�GEVVMIW�SZIVJVSQ�©XLI�.I[ª�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR��%�WIGSRH�MW�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERQSZIQIRX�LEW�QEHI�E�GSRGIVXIH�ERH�WSQI[LEX�WYGGIWWJYP�IJJSVX�XS�HIQS�RMI�-WVEIP�F]�I\EKKIVEXMRK�MXW�MQTIVJIGXMSRW�MR�LYQER�VMKLXW��%�XLMVH�MWXLEX�-WVEIPM�STTSRIRXW�SJ�XLI�KSZIVRQIRX�MR�TS[IV TEWX�ERH�TVIWIRXLEZI�MRXIVREXMSREPMIH�HSQIWXMG�STTSWMXMSR�F]�LMKLPMKLXMRK�XLI�MQTIVJIG�XMSRW�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�ERH�FVSEHGEWXMRK�XLIQ�EFVSEH��XLYW�GSRJMVQMRK�MRXLI�QMRHW�SJ�QER]�XLI�I\EKKIVEXMSRW�QEHI�F]�-WVEIP¬W�IRIQMIW�

%�JSYVXL�I\TPEREXMSR�MW�XLEX�IZIR�JVMIRHW�SJ�-WVEIPHSQIWXMG�ERH�I\XIV�REPWIIQ�XS�I\TIGX�QSVI�SJ�-WVEIP�MR�XIVQW�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW�FIGEYWI�MX�MWXLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��%�JMJXL�MW�XLEX�IZIR�WSQI�TISTPI�SJ�KSSH[MPP�IRNS]�WXMGO�MRK�MX�XS�XLI�.I[W��[LS�XLI]�FIPMIZI�LEZI�EP[E]W�GPEMQIH�WSQI�QSVEP�WYTI�VMSVMX]��[LIR�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�FILEZIW�PMOI�SXLIV�WXEXIW��8LSQEW�*VMIHQERWEMH��©8LI�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�GSQMRK�SYX�SJ�)YVSTI�XSHE]�WYKKIWXW�XLEX�HIITHS[R�)YVSTIERW�[ERX�1V��7LEVSR�XS�GSQQMX�E�QEWWEGVI�EKEMRWX�4EPIW�XMRMERW��SV�XLI]�[ERX�XS�HIWGVMFI�[LEX�LI�HMH�MR�.IRMR�EW�E�QEWWEGVI��WS�XLEXXLI�)YVSTIERW�GER�JMREPP]�KIX�XLI�KYMPX�SJ�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�SJJ�XLIMV�FEGOW�ERHEVI�EFPI�XS�WLSYX��«0SSO�EX�XLIWI�.I[W��XLI]¬VI�[SVWI�XLER�[I�[IVI�¬ª�

%�WM\XL�I\TPEREXMSR�MW�XLEX�WSQI�RSR�.I[W�[LS�LEZI�FIGSQI�EGGYW�XSQIH�XS�WIIMRK�ERH�W]QTEXLMMRK�[MXL�.I[W�EW�LIPTPIWW�ZMGXMQW�LEZI�HMJ�JMGYPX]�EGGITXMRK�XLI�MQEKI�SJ�XLI�WXVSRK�.I[MWL�WXEXI�[MXL�XLI�QMPMXEV]GETEGMX]�XS�JMKLX�FEGO��&YX�[LEXIZIV�XLI�I\TPEREXMSRW ERH�RSRI�SJ�XLIQEPSRI�SV�MR�GSQFMREXMSR�FIKMR�XS�NYWXMJ]�XLI�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH MX�MW�IWWIR�XMEP�XS�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�XLEX�XLMW�KYPJ�FI�VIEWWIWWIH�

(YVMRK�XLI�JMVWX������]IEVW�SJ�XLI�'SQQSR�)VE��XLI�WSYP�SJ�ER]�KMZIRGMX]��REXMSR��GYPXYVI��SV�VIPMKMSR�GSYPH�FI�JEMVP]�EWWIWWIH�F]�XLI�[E]�MXVIKEVHIH�ERH�XVIEXIH�MXW�.I[MWL�RIMKLFSVW��8SHE]��XLI�WSYP�SJ�XLI�MRXIVRE�XMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�GER�FI�JEMVP]�EWWIWWIH�F]�XLI�[E]�MR�[LMGL�MX�XVIEXW�XLI.I[�EQSRK�REXMSRW��.YHKIH�F]�XLMW�WXERHEVH��XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�JEMPW�QMW�IVEFP]��EW�HS�QER]�SJ�XLI�KVIEX�REXMSRW�SJ�)YVSTI��%WME��%JVMGE��ERH�7SYXL%QIVMGE��-RHIIH��MJ�XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�[IVI�YPXMQEXIP]�XS�JEMP��EW�XLI0IEKYI�SJ�2EXMSRW�HMH��MX�QE]�[IPP�FI�EW�XLI�VIWYPX�SJ�PSWMRK�MXW�QSVEPEYXLSVMX]�SZIV�-WVEIP�

;LIR�XLI�+IRIVEP�%WWIQFP]�ZSXIH�XS�HIGPEVI�>MSRMWQ�E�JSVQ�SJVEGMWQ��MX�FIGEQI�GSQTPMGMX�MR�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�ERH�WYJJIVIH�ER�IRSVQSYW�PSWWSJ�TVIWXMKI�ERH�WYTTSVX�MR�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERH�WSQI�SXLIV�TEVXW�SJ�XLI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 240: The Case For Israel

[SVPH��EPXLSYKL�RSX�MR�SXLIVW ��;LIR�XLI�9�2��'SRJIVIRGI�SR�;SQIR�MR1I\MGS�'MX]�MR�������ERH�MR�'STIRLEKIR�MR�������HIZSXIH�QSVI�XMQI�ERHIRIVK]�XS�GSRHIQRMRK�>MSRMWQ�XLER�WI\MWQ��MX�FIGEQI�E�GVYIP�NSOI��;LIRXLI�9�2��'SRJIVIRGI�SR�6EGMWQ�MR�(YVFER�FIGEQI��MR�XLI�[SVHW�SJ�'ERE�HMER�4EVPMEQIRX�QIQFIV�ERH�LYQER�VMKLXW�WGLSPEV�-V[MR�'SXPIV��©E�VEGMWXGSRJIVIRGI�EKEMRWX�.I[W��MX�FIGEQI�E�QIKETLSRI�JSV�FMKSXV]�

1SVI�XLER�XLI�GVIHMFMPMX]�SJ�XLI�+IRIVEP�%WWIQFP]�SV�XLI�IRXMVI�9RMXIH2EXMSRW�MW�TYX�EX�VMWO�F]�XLI�YRJEMV�XVIEXQIRX�EGGSVHIH�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��8LI-RXIVREXMSREP�'VMQMREP�'SYVX�[MPP�JEMP�MJ�MX�GERRSX�FI�XVYWXIH�XS�FI�IZIR�LERHIH�XS[EVH�-WVEIPMW��IZIR�MJ�MX�MW�JEMV�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�SXLIVW��7SYXLIVRGSYVXW�HYVMRK�.MQ�'VS[�ERH�7SYXL�%JVMGER�GSYVXW�HYVMRK�ETEVXLIMH�[IVISJXIR�JEMV�MR�GEWIW�FIX[IIR�[LMXI�PMXMKERXW��FYX�XLI]�GSYPH�RSX�FI�XVYWXIH�XSHS�NYWXMGI�FIX[IIR�FPEGO�ERH�[LMXI�PMXMKERXW��8LI�WEQI�LEW�KIRIVEPP]�FIIRXLI�GEWI�[MXL�VIKEVH�XS�MRXIVREXMSREP�SVKERMEXMSRW�[LIR�-WVEIP�MW�MRZSPZIH�)ZIR�%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREPER�SXLIV[MWI�[SRHIVJYP�SVKERMEXMSR��[LMGL-�WYTTSVX LEW�GSRXVMFYXIH�XS�XLI�JEPWI�GSQTEVMWSRW�FIX[IIR�-WVEIP�ERH�SYX�PE[�REXMSRW�XLEX�HS�RSX�VIWTIGX�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��8LI�;SVPH�,IEPXL�3VKERM�EXMSR��[MXLSYX�LIEVMRK�ER]�IZMHIRGI��SRGI�GSRHIQRIH�-WVEIP�JSV�TVSZMHMRKTSSV�LIEPXL�GEVI�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��HIWTMXI�XLI�HVEQEXMG�MRGVIEWI�MR�PMJII\TIGXERG]�ERH�HIGVIEWI�MR�MRJERX�QSVXEPMX]��%�QIHMGEP�XIEQ�[EW�XLIR�WIRXXS�MRZIWXMKEXI��8LI�XIEQ��GSQTSWIH�SJ�HSGXSVW�JVSQ�6SQERME��-RHSRIWME�ERH�7IRIKEP��GSRGPYHIH�XLEX�©XLI�QIHMGEP�GEVI�MR�XLI�%VEF�XIVVMXSVMIW�SGGY�TMIH�F]�-WVEIP�LEW�WLS[R�WPS[�FYX�WXIEH]�MQTVSZIQIRX�MR�XLI�RMRI�]IEVWWMRGI�XLI������[EV�ª�;LIR�XLMW�JEZSVEFPI�I\TIVX�VITSVX�[EW�VIGIMZIH��XLI;SVPH�,IEPXL�3VKERMEXMSR�ZSXIH����XS�����[MXL����EFWXIRXMSRW��RSX�XSEGGITX�MX��WMRGI�MX�HMH�RSX�GSRJSVQ�XS�MXW�TSPMXMGEP�EKIRHE���

-R�(IGIQFIV�������XLI�GSRXVEGXMRK�TEVXMIW�SJ�XLI�+IRIZE�'SRZIRXMSR

GSRZIRIH�JSV�XLI�JMVWX�XMQI ERH�XLI]�HMH�MX�XS�GVMXMGMI�-WVEIP��8LMW�[EW

XLI�SRP]�XMQI�MR����]IEVW�XLEX�ER]�REXMSR�[EW�GSRHIQRIH��7MQMPEVP]�XLI

92�'SQQMWWMSR�SR�,YQER�6MKLXW�LEW�VITIEXIHP]�WMRKPIH�SYX�-WVEIP�JSV

HMWGVMQMREXSV]�XVIEXQIRX�[LMPI�MKRSVMRK�XLI�VIEP�LYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXSVW���

6SYXMRI�TYFPMG�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�JSV�EGXMSRW�XLEX�VEVIP]�MRGYVGSRHIQREXMSR�[LIR�YRHIVXEOIR�F]�SXLIV�REXMSRW�MW�SRP]�SRI�QERMJIWXE�XMSR�SJ�XLMW�TIVZEWMZI�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH��%�WMQTPI�XIWX�SJ�XLMW�TVSTSWMXMSR[SYPH�FI�XS�MQEKMRI�ER�I\XVEXIVVIWXVMEP�QIWWIRKIV�WIRX�XS�)EVXL�XS�EWWIWWXLI�VIPEXMZI�GSQTPMERGI�SJ�XLMW�TPERIX¬W�REXMSRW�XS�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��-J�XLIQIWWIRKIV�[IVI�XS�PMQMX�LMW�VIZMI[�XS�9�2��VIWSPYXMSRW�ERH�XLI�VIGSVH�SJMRXIVREXMSREP�GSRHIQREXMSRW�SZIV�XLI�TEWX�XLMVH�SJ�E�GIRXYV]��LI�[SYPHVITSVX�FEGO�XS�LMW�WYTIVZMWSVW�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�XLI�SYXPE[�REXMSR�SJ�XLI�IEVXL[MXL�XLI�[SVWX�VIGSVH�SJ�GSQTPMERGI�[MXL�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�

8LI�I\XVEXIVVIWXVMEP�QIWWIRKIV�[SYPH�VITSVX�XLEX�XLMW�TEVMEL�EQSRK

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 241: The Case For Israel

REXMSRW�LEW�FIIR�GSRHIQRIH�JSV�[EKMRK�EKKVIWWMZI�[EV��JSV�GETXYVMRK�ERHOIITMRK�XIVVMXSV]�SJ�SXLIV�REXMSRW��JSV�HMWTSWWIWWMRK�GMXMIRW�SJ�XLIMVLSQIW��JSV�HIWXVS]MRK�XLI�LSQIW�SJ�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW��JSV�XSVXYVMRK�TVMW�SRIVW��JSV�GSRHYGXMRK�WIGVIX�XVMEPW��JSV�MQTVMWSRMRK�TISTPI�[MXLSYX�XVMEP��JSVFSQFMRK�GMZMPMER�XEVKIXW��JSV�IRJSVGMRK�VIPMKMSYW�ERH�KIRHIV�HMWGVMQMRE�XMSR��ERH�JSV�E�LSWX�SJ�SXLIV�ZMSPEXMSRW�SJ�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��&IMRK�E�WSTLMW�XMGEXIH�QIWWIRKIV��SYV�I\XVEXIVVIWXVMEP�[SYPH�PSSO�RSX�SRP]�EX�XLI�LMWXSV]SJ�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�FYX�EPWS�EX�XLI�GSQTEVEXMZILMWXSV]�SJ�GSRHIQ�REXMSRW�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�SXLIVREXMSRW��7YGL�GSQTEVEXMZI�EWWIWWQIRX�[SYPHSRP]�GSRJMVQ�LMW�GSRGPYWMSR�XLEX�-WVEIP�[EW�XLI�TPERIX¬W�[SVWX�SJJIRHIV�MRXIVQW�SJ�XLI�WIVMSYWRIWW�SJ�XLI�SJJIRWIW��XLIMV�TIVWYEWMZIRIWW��ERH�XLIMVVIGMHMZMWQ��,I�[SYPH�PIEVR�PMXXPI�JVSQ�WXYH]MRK�9�2��VIWSPYXMSRW�EFSYX�XLILYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXMSRW�SJ�'LMRE��'YFE��)K]TX��.SVHER��%PKIVME��&IPEVYW�XLI�4LMPMTTMRIW��ERH�SXLIV�REXMSRW�XLEX�LEZI�E�QYGL�TSSVIV�VIGSVH�SJ�GSQ�TPMERGI�[MXL�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�XLER�-WVEIP�

8LI�I\XVEXIVVIWXVMEP�QIWWIRKIV�MW�FYX�E�JMKQIRX�SJ�E�PE[�TVSJIWWSV¬WMQEKMREXMSR��&YX�XLMW�WEQI�PE[�TVSJIWWSV�LEW�XVEZIPIH�XLI�VIEP�[SVPH�PIG�XYVMRK�ERH�WTIEOMRK�EFSYX�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�XS�YRMZIVWMX]�ERH�SXLIV�EYHM�IRGIW�SJ�]SYRK�IEVXLPMRKW�JVSQ�2I[�>IEPERH�XS�7SYXL�%JVMGE��JVSQ�'LMREXS�6YWWME��JVSQ�%YWXVEPME�XS�+IVQER]��JVSQ�'EREHE�XS�4SPERH��JVSQ�-XEP]XS�2SV[E]��ERH�IZIV]�QENSV�GMX]�MR�2SVXL�%QIVMGE��1]�VITSVX�SJ�XLI�TIV�GITXMSRWSJ�QER]�]SYRK��LMKLP]�IHYGEXIH�QIR�ERH�[SQIR�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI[SVPH�[SYPH�RSX�FI�ZIV]�HMJJIVIRX�JVSQ�XLI�GSRGPYWMSRW�VIEGLIH�F]�XLII\XVEXIVVIWXVMEP�QIWWIRKIV�

%PXLSYKL�QSWX�]SYRK�IEVXLPMRKW�VIEPMI�XLEX�LYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXMSRWEVI�RSX�YRMUYI�XS�-WVEIPXLI]�LEZI�LIEVH�EFSYX�-VER��-VEU��0MF]E��%PKIVME�'LMRE��2SVXL�/SVIE��ERH�SXLIV�JPEKVERX�ERH�TIVWMWXIRX�ZMSPEXSVW QER]FIPMIZI�XLEX�-WVEIP�MW�EQSRKXLI�[SVWX�SJJIRHIVW��8LMW�TIVGITXMSR��EW�-�LEZIHIQSRWXVEXIH��MW�RSX�SRP]�YRJEMV�ERH�HERKIVSYW�XS�-WVEIP�FYX�MW�HIWXVYGXMZISJ�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�MXWIPJ��[LMGL�GERRSX�WYVZMZI�MR�XLI�EFWIRGI�SJ�E�WMRKPIWXERHEVH�JEMVP]�ETTPMIH�XS�EPP�REXMSRW��;LIR�©LYQER�VMKLXWª�FIGSQIW�E�XEG�XMG��WIPIGXMZIP]�ERH�WYGGIWWJYPP]�MRZSOIH�F]�XLI�[SVWX�ZMSPEXSVW�EKEMRWX�XLSWI[LS�QEOI�WIVMSYW�IJJSVXW�XS�GSQTP]�[MXL�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��LYQER�VMKLXW�PSWIEPP�SFNIGXMZI�QIERMRK�ERH�XLIMV�GSRXMRYIH�YXMPMX]�MR�XLI�SRKSMRK�WXVYKKPIJSV�MRXIVREXMSREP�NYWXMGI�FIGSQIW�HMPYXIH�

)ZIR�WSQI�I\TIVMIRGIH�HMTPSQEXW�IZIRXYEPP]�JEPP�JSV�XLI�FMK�PMI�[LIR�MXMW�VITIEXIH�SJXIR�IRSYKL��9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�7IGVIXEV]�+IRIVEP�/SJM�%RRERLEW�©VIQEVOIH�XLEX�MX�GERRSX�FI�XLEX�XLI�IRXMVI�[SVPH�MW�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP��]IX-WVEIP�MW�VMKLX�ª��&YX�ER]SRI�[LS�VIQIQFIVW�XLI�©FPSSH�PMFIPª��XLI�GPEMQXLEX�.I[W�VMXYEPP]�QYVHIV�'LVMWXMER�GLMPHVIR�ERH�YWI�XLIMV�FPSSH�XS�QEOIQEXEL �SV�XLI�4VSXSGSPW�SJ�XLI�)PHIVW�SJ�>MSR�XLI�'EVMWX�JSVKIV] �[MPPYRHIVWXERH�XLEX�QMPPMSRW�SJ�TISTPI�GER�FIPMIZI�E�XSXEPP]�JEPWI�EGGYWEXMSR�

8LI�KVIEX�QSVEP�MWWYI�JEGMRK�XLI�[SVPH�EX�XLI�HE[R�SJ�XLMW�QMPPIRRMYQ�MW

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 242: The Case For Israel

[LIXLIV�-WVEIP¬W�EXXIQTX�XS�TVSXIGX�MXWIPJ�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ�[MPP�VIWYPX�MR�EQEWWMZI�MRGVIEWI�MR�[SVPH[MHI�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWXXLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MXWIPJ��MXW�WYTTSVXIVW��ERH�.I[W�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH��8[SMRHMWTYXEFPI�TVSTSWMXMSRW�EVI��� �XLEX�-WVEIP¬W�GYVVIRX�IJJSVXW�XS�TVSXIGX�MXWMRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW�EKEMRWX�XLSWI�[LS�[SYPH�QYVHIV�GLMPHVIR��[SQIR��XLIIPHIVP]��ERH�SXLIVW�MW�RS�[SVWI ERH�MR�QER]�VIWTIGXW�MW�GSRWMHIVEFP]�FIXXIV XLER�TVSXIGXMZI�IJJSVXW�XEOIR�F]�SXLIV�HIQSGVEGMIW�XLEX�LEZI�JEGIHJEV�PIWW�ZMVYPIRX�XLVIEXW��ERH��� �XLEX�RS�SXLIV�GSYRXV] [LIXLIV�'EXLSPMG�4VSXIWXERX��1YWPMQ��SV�[MXLSYX�VIPMKMSR LEW�JEGIH�XLI�OMRH�SJ�GSRHIQ�REXMSR�XLEX�-WVEIP�ERH�MXW�WYTTSVXIVW�LEZI�IRGSYRXIVIH��TEVXMGYPEVP]�WMRGI=EWWIV�%VEJEX�[EPOIH�E[E]�JVSQ�-WVEIP¬W�TIEGI�SJJIVW�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH8EFE�ERH�HVEQEXMGEPP]�MRGVIEWIH�XLI�GEQTEMKR�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�-WVEIPMGMZMPMERW�

%W�QER]�SFNIGXMZI�GSQQIRXEXSVW�LEZI�SFWIVZIH��RSX�WMRGI�XLI�LSVVMFPIHE]W�SJ�XLI�PEXI�����W�ERH�IEVP]�����W�LEW�XLI�[SVPH�I\TIVMIRGIH�WS�TIV�ZIVWI�ERH�WYWXEMRIH�ER�SYXTSYVMRK�SJ�TVMQMXMZI�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��%RHVI[�7YP�PMZER��[LS�[VSXI�I\XIRWMZIP]�JSV�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1EKEMRI�TYX�MX�XLMW[E]�NYWX�FIJSVI�XLI�[EV�EKEMRWX�-VEU�

%QIVMGE¬W�ERXM�[EV�QSZIQIRX��WXMPP�TYR]�ERH�WXVYKKPMRK��MW�WLS[MRK�WMKRW

SJ�FIMRK�LMNEGOIH�F]�SRI�SJ�XLI�SPHIWX�ERH�HEVOIWX�TVINYHMGIW�XLIVI�MW�

4IVLETW�MX�[EW�MRIZMXEFPI��8LI�GSRJPMGX�EKEMRWX�-WPEQS�JEWGMWQ�SFZMSYWP]

GMVGPIW�FEGO�XS�XLI�UYIWXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP��*EREXMGEP�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��EW�FEH�SV

IZIR�[SVWI�XLER�,MXPIV¬W��MW�RS[�E�GYPXYVEP�RSVQ�EGVSWW�QYGL�SJ�XLI�

1MHHPI�)EWX��-X¬W�XLI�EGVMH�KPYI�XLEX�YRMXIW�7EHHEQ��%VEJEX��%P�5EIHE�

,IFSPPEL��-VER�ERH�XLI�7EYHMW���

8LI�[VMXIV�3VMERE�*EPPEGM�LEW�WXEXIH�MX�IZIR�QSVI�HVEQEXMGEPP]��©-�JMRHMX�WLEQIJYP�ERH�WII�MR�EPP�XLMW�XLI�VMWI�SJ�E�RI[�JEWGMWQ��E�RI[�2EMWQ��%JEWGMWQ��E�2EMWQ��XLEX�MW�QYGL�QSVI�KVMQ�ERH�VIZSPXMRK�FIGEYWI�MX�MW�GSR�HYGXIH�ERH�RSYVMWLIH�F]�XLSWI�[LS�L]TSGVMXMGEPP]�TSWI�EW�HS�KSSHIVW?ERHA�TVSKVIWWMZIW�ª��

%W�[MXL�QSWX�TVIZMSYW�SYXFVIEOW�SJ�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ��WSQI�LEZI�WSYKLXXS�FPEQI�MX�SR�XLI�ZMGXMQW��©-X¬W�XLI�.I[W¬�JEYPX�ª�[VSXI�(SWXS]IZWO]�MR�LMWRSXSVMSYW�EVXMGPI�SR�XLI�.I[MWL�UYIWXMSR�MR�������8LI�KVIEX�6YWWMER�[VMXIVEVKYIH�XLEX�XLI�LEXVIH�SJ�.I[W�©QYWX�LEZI�WXIQQIH�JVSQ�WSQIXLMRK�ª%RH�MRWXIEH�SJ�PSSOMRK�JSV�XLI�WSYVGIW�[MXLMR�XLI�LEXIVW��LI�PSSOIH�XS�XLIEGXMSRW�SJ�XLI�LEXIH�ERH�HIGPEVIH�XLEX�©XLI�.I[�LMQWIPJ�MW�KYMPX]�ª�,I�GSR�XMRYIH��©8LI�.I[��[LIVIZIV�LI�LEW�WIXXPIH��LEW�������LYQMPMEXIH�ERHHIFEYGLIH�XLI�TISTPI�ª�%GGSVHMRK�XS�(SWXS]IZWO]��MX�[EW�XLI�.I[W�[LS©VYMRIHª�XLI�0MXLYERMERW�©[MXL�ZSHOE�ª�ERH�MX�MW�XLI�.I[W�[LS�[MPP�VI�IRWPEZI�XLI�©QMPPMSRW�SJ�PMFIVEXIH�2IKVSIWª�MR�XLI�%QIVMGER�7SYXL��©8LIRIKVSIW�LEZI�RS[�FIIR�PMFIVEXIH�JVSQ�XLIMV�WPEZI�S[RIVW��FYX�������XLEX�[MPP

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 243: The Case For Israel

RSX�PEWX�FIGEYWI�XLI�.I[W��SJ�[LSQ�XLIVI�EVI�WS�QER]�MR�XLI�[SVPH��[MPPNYQT�EX�XLMW�RI[�PMXXPI�ZMGXMQ�ª��

(SWXS]IZWO]¬W�ZMI[W�SJ�XLI�[SVPH[MHI�.I[MWL�GSRWTMVEG]�EVI�RSX�QYGLHMJJIVIRX�JVSQ�XLI�ZMI[W�I\TVIWWIH�F]�,MXPIV�MR�1IMR�/EQTJSV�MR�XLI'EVMWX�JSVKIV]�8LI�4VSXSGSPW�SJ�XLI�)PHIVW�SJ�>MSR�-R�(SWXS]IZWO]¬WFMEVVI�[SVPH�©XLI�.I[W�EVI�VIMKRMRK�IZIV][LIVI�SZIV�WXSGO�I\GLERKIW�ª©XLI]�GSRXVSP�GETMXEP�ª�©XLI]�EVI�XLI�QEWXIVW�SJ�GVIHMX�ª�©XLI]�EVI�EPWS�XLIQEWXIVW�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�TSPMXMGW�ª�ERH�©[LEX�MW�KSMRK�XS�LETTIR�MR�XLIJYXYVI�MW�ORS[R�XS�XLI�.I[W�XLIQWIPZIW�ª�,I�TVIHMGXIH�XLEX�©XLIMV�VIMKR�XLIMV�GSQTPIXI�VIMKR�MW�ETTVSEGLMRK�ª��,I�FIPMIZIH�XLEX�©.YHEMWQ�ERH�XLI.I[MWL�MHIEª�MW�©GPEWTMRK�XLI�[LSPI�[SVPH�MRWXIEH�SJ�'LVMWXMERMX]�ª��,MWGSRWTMVEG]�XLISV]�[EW�FEWIH�SR�XLI�JSPPS[MRK�PSKMG��,I�JSYRH�MX�©MQTSW�WMFPI�XS�GSRGIMZI�SJ�E�.I[�[MXLSYX�+SH�ª�VIJYWMRK�XS�FIPMIZI�©MR�XLI�I\MW�XIRGI�SJ�EXLIMWXW�IZIR�EQSRK�XLI�IHYGEXIH�.I[W�ª�,I�FIPMIZIH�XLEX�XLI.I[W�©EPP�SJ�XLIQ FSXL�XLI�PS[IWX�=MHHMWLIV�ERH�XLI�LMKLIWX�ERH�QSWXPIEVRIH�SRI XLI�TLMPSWSTLIV�ERH�XLI�GEFEPMWX�VEFFM EPP�FIPMIZI�XLEX�XLIQIWWMEL�[MPP�EKEMR�YRMXI�XLIQ�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�ERH�[MPP�FVMRK�F]�LMW�W[SVH�EPPREXMSRW�XS�XLIMV�JIIX�ª�,I�EPWS�FIPMIZIH�XLEX�©XLMW�MW�XLI�VIEWSR�XLEX�XLISZIV[LIPQMRK�QENSVMX]�SJ�XLI�.I[W�LEZI�E�TVIHMPIGXMSR�FYX�JSV�SRI�TVS�JIWWMSR XLI�XVEHI�MR�KSPH�ª�;LIR�XLI�QIWWMEL�GSQIW��EGGSVHMRK�XS�(SW�XS]IZWO]��©MX�[MPP�FI�IEWMIV�?JSV�XLI�.I[WA�XS�GEVV]�?XLI�KSPHA�E[E]�ª��

(SWXS]IZWO]�GSYPH�RSX�I\TPEMR�[L]�XLI�.I[W�[SYPH�[ERX�XS�GEVV]�XLI�KSPHE[E]�[LIR�XLI]�EPVIEH]�EVI�©VIMKRMRK�MR�)YVSTI��EVI�HMVIGXMRK�XLIVI�EXPIEWX�XLI�WXSGO�I\GLERKIW�ERH�XLIVIJSVI�TSPMXMGW��HSQIWXMG�EJJEMVW��ERH�XLIQSVEPMX]�SJ�XLI�WXEXIW�ª��

2SV�[EW�(SWXS]IZWO]¬W�FMKSXV]�HMVIGXIH�SRP]�EX�.YHEMWQ�MR�XLI�EFWXVEGX�,I�HIIQIH�MX�©HMJJMGYPX�XS�JMRH�ER]XLMRK�QSVI�MVVMXEFPI�������XLER�XLI�IHY�GEXIH�.I[�ª��

-X�MW�UYMXI�VIQEVOEFPI�XLEX�E�QER�SJ�(SWXSIZWO]¬W�FVMPPMERGI�ERH�MRWMKLXMR�WS�QER]�EVIEW�GSYPH�LEZI�LEVFSVIH�WYGL�TVMQMXMZI�JERXEWMIW�EFSYX�XLI.I[W��-X�QYWX�FI�VIGEPPIH��LS[IZIV��XLEX�(SWXS]IZWO]¬W�JEQI�MW�FEWIH�SR�LMWJMGXMSR�[VMXMRKW�ERH�RSX�SR�LMW�RSRJMGXMSR�VERXMRKW��0MOI�QER]�ERXM�7IQMXIWXLVSYKLSYX�LMWXSV]��ERH�IZIR�XSHE]��(SWXS]IZWO]�HMWGPEMQIH�ER]�E�TVMSVMERXM�.I[MWL�JIIPMRKW��WE]MRK�MX�MW�©XLI�.I[�LMQWIPJ�[LS�MW�VIWTSRWMFPIª�JSV�EPPXLI�LEXVIH�HMVIGXIH�EKEMRWX�LMQ��8LIWI�ZMI[W�[IVI�IGLSIH�F]�,MXPIV��7XEPMR�'EVHMREP�+PIQT��ERH�SXLIV�RSXSVMSYW�ERXM�7IQMXIW�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�EKIW��

2S[�XLI�GPEMQ�MW��©-X¬W�XLI�-WVEIPMW¬�JEYPX�ª�SV�©-X¬W�7LEVSR¬W�JEYPX�ª�&YXXLI�JEGXW�RS�QSVI�WYTTSVX�XLMW�EGGYWEXMSR�XLER�(SWXS]IZWO]¬W�VIEWSRMRK�

%R�MRXIVIWXMRK�TSMRX�SJ�GSQTEVMWSR�QMKLX�FI�XLI�FIWX��GIVXEMRP]�XLI;IWXIVR�[SVPH¬W�JEZSVMXI��%VEF§1YWPMQ�REXMSR��.SVHER��%�GVIEXMSR�SJ&VMXMWL�MQTIVMEPMWQ��.SVHER�SGGYTMIH�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�JSV�X[IRX]�]IEVW��-XERRI\IH�MX��MQTSWIH�IQIVKIRG]�QEVXMEP�PE[W�SR�MXW�VIWMHIRXW��ERH�I\GPYHIHEPP�.I[W�JVSQ�MX��-R�7ITXIQFIV�������/MRK�,YWWIMR�SJ�.SVHER�OMPPIH�ERH

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 244: The Case For Israel

MRNYVIH�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�MR�SRI�QSRXL�XLER�-WVEIP�LEW�HYVMRK�XLVII�]IEVWSJ�VIWTSRHMRK�XS�XLI�WYMGMHI�FSQFMRK�MRXMJEHE���8SVXYVI��IWTIGMEPP]�SJ4EPIWXMRMERW��MW�VEQTERX�MR�.SVHER�ERH�LEW�FIIR�HIZIPSTIH�MRXS�E�JMRI�EVX�2SX�SRP]�EVI�WYWTIGXIH�XIVVSVMWXW�XSVXYVIH�FYX�WS�EVI�XLIMV�VIPEXMZIW��8LI]LEZI�WS�TIVJIGXIH�XLI�XIGLRMUYI�XLEX�SYV�'-%�LEW�GSQI�XS�VIP]�SR�XLIQ�EPSRK�[MXL�)K]TX�ERH�XLI�4LMPMTTMRIW��)ZIV]XLMRK�FEH�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEW�HSRIXS�4EPIWXMRMERW��.SVHER�LEW�HSRI�JEV�[SVWI��%RH�]IX�XLIVI�EVI�RS�HMZIWX�QIRX�SV�FS]GSXX�GEQTEMKRW�HMVIGXIH�EX�XLEX�OMRKHSQ��SRP]�EKEMRWX�XLIHIQSGVEG]�XS�MXW�[IWX�

%W�E�GMZMP�PMFIVXEVMER�ERH�LYQER�VMKLXW�EHZSGEXI��-�TIVWSREPP]�HMWETTVSZISJ�QER]�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�GSQTVSQMWIW�[MXL�TIVJIGXMSR�MR�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��EW�-�HS[MXL�Q]�S[R�GSYRXV]¬W�MQTIVJIGXMSRW��;IVI�-�ER�-WVEIPM�GMXMIR��-�[SYPH�FIGEQTEMKRMRK�JSV�GLERKIW�ERH�MQTVSZIQIRXW�MR�-WVEIP��&YX�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREPGSQQYRMX] YRPMOI�-WVEIPM�GMXMIRW LEW�RS�VMKLX�XS�WMRKPI�SYX�-WVEIP�JSVGVMXMGMWQ�EW�XLI�[SVWX�SJJIRHIV�[LIR�XLEX�FIPIEKYIVIH�REXMSR�MW�EQSRK�XLIQSWX�GSQQMXXIH�XS�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[��*SV�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�XSEGGYWI�-WVEIP�SJ�FIMRK�XLI�[SVWX�SV�EQSRK�XLI�[SVWX�ZMSPEXSVW�SJ�XLI�VYPI�SJPE[�MW�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�IUYMZEPIRX�SJ�XLI�SPH�ERXM�7IQMXMG�FPSSH�PMFIP��8SHIQSRWXVEXI�LS[�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]¬W�YRJEMV�XVIEXQIRX�SJ�-WVEIPMW�MXWIPJ�E�FEVVMIV�XS�TIEGI��PIX�QI�TSWI�ER�MQTSVXERX�[LEX�MJUYIWXMSR�

;LEX�MJ�-WVEIP�[IVI�XS�EGGIHI�XS�IZIV]�HIQERH�FIMRK�QEHI�F]�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��XLI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��ERH�XLI�)YVSTIER�'SQQYRMX]#;LEX�MJ��EJXIV�XEOMRK�EPP�SJ�XLI�WXITW�HIQERHIH�SJ�MX��XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX�MXWGMZMPMERW�GSRXMRYIH��IZIR�IWGEPEXIH#�;LEX�[SYPH�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQ�QYRMX]�XLIR�I\TIGX�-WVEIP�XS�HS#�;LEX�[SYPH�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]HS#�;LEX�GSYPH�-WVEIP�GSYRX�SR�MX�XS�HS#

8LIWI�EVI�XLI�UYIWXMSRW�FIMRK�EWOIH�F]�QSHIVEXI�-WVEIPMW�ERH�XLIMV%QIVMGER�WYTTSVXIVW�[LS�GVEZI�TIEGI��8LI]�EVI�TEVXMGYPEVP]�XVSYFPMRKUYIWXMSRW�MR�PMKLX�SJ�LS[�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�VIWTSRHIH�EJXIV)LYH�&EVEO�SJJIVIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�RIEVP]�EPP�SJ�XLIMV�[MWL�PMWX�ERH�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�VIWTSRHIH�F]�IWGEPEXMRK�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ�

8LI�WXERHEVH�ERW[IV�FIMRK�SJJIVIH�XSHE]�MW�XLEX�ER]�TIEGI�[SYPH��SJGSYVWI��FI�GSRHMXMSREP�SR�KSSH�JEMXL�IJJSVXW�F]�XLI�RI[P]�GVIEXIH�4EPIW�XMRMER�WXEXI�XS�IRH�XLI�XIVVSVMWQ��&YX�VIGIRX�TYFPMG�STMRMSR�TSPPW�XEOIR�F]4EPIWXMRMERW�XLIQWIPZIW�WLS[�XLEX�E�WMKRMJMGERX�QENSVMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERWJEZSV�E�GSRXMRYEXMSR�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�YRXMP�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��[LMGL�MRGPYHIW-WVEIP��MW�PMFIVEXIH��8S�FI�WYVI��MX�MW�TSWWMFPI�XLEX�XLIWI�JMKYVIW�EVI�MRJPEXIHF]�XLI�GYVVIRX�ZMSPIRGI�ERH�[SYPH�HMQMRMWL�MJ�VIEP�TIEGI�[IVI�EGLMIZIH�

&YX�MX�MW�TSWWMFPI�XLEX�XLI�STTSWMXI�QE]�FI�XVYI��MJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�MWEGLMIZIH�F]�XIVVSVMWQ SV�MJ�XLEX�TIVGITXMSR�I\MWXW�EQSRK�QSWX�4EPIWXMRM�ERW XLIR�QER]�[MPP�YVKI�ER�IWGEPEXMSR�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�XS�EGLMIZI�XLI�YPXM�QEXI�KSEP�SJ�QER]�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�KVSYTW��MRGPYHMRK�,EQEW�,IFYPPEL��-WPEQMG�.MLEH��ERH�IZIR�IPIQIRXW�[MXLMR�XLI�*EXEL�QSZIQIRX�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 245: The Case For Israel

8LIVI�MW�TVIGIHIRX�JSV�XLMW�PEXXIV�WGIREVMS��[LIR�-WVEIP�PIJX�WSYXLIVR0IFERSR�EW�E�VIWYPX�SJ�MRGVIEWMRK�,IFSPPEL�XIVVSVMWQ��WIZIVEP�4EPIWXMRMERKVSYTW�GEPPIH�JSV�ER�MRGVIEWI�MR�XIVVSVMWQ��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER�WYQQEVMIHXLMW�TIVWTIGXMZI�EW�JSPPS[W��©)ZIV�WMRGI�XLI�YRMPEXIVEP�-WVEIPM�[MXLHVE[EPJVSQ�0IFERSR��4EPIWXMRMERW�LEZI�[EXGLIH�XSS�QYGL�,IFYPPEL�8:�JVSQ0IFERSR��[LMGL�LEH�TIHHPIH�XLI�RSXMSR�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEH�FIGSQI�NYWX�E�FMK�WSJX�7MPMGSR�:EPPI]��ERH�XLEX�XLIVIJSVI��[MXL�IRSYKL�WYMGMHI�FSQFW��XLI.I[W�GSYPH�FI�JSVGIH�JVSQ�4EPIWXMRI��NYWX�EW�XLI]�LEH�FIIR�JVSQ�7SYXL0IFERSR�ª��

+MZIR�XLI�I\TVIWWIH�KSEP�SJ�XLIWI�MRGVIEWMRKP]�TSTYPEV�VEHMGEP�KVSYTW�XLSWI�[LS�YVKI�XLI�IZIRXYEP�GVIEXMSR�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��EW�-�HS��GERRSXMKRSVI�XLI�VIEPMWXMG�TSWWMFMPMX]�XLEX�WYGL�E�WXEXI�QMKLX�[IPP�GSRXMRYI�XS�WYT�TSVX��IRGSYVEKI��SV�EX�XLI�ZIV]�PIEWX�XSPIVEXI�GSRXMRYMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�EKEMRWX-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW�MR�ER�IJJSVX��JYXMPI�EW�MX�QMKLX�FI��XS�QEOI�XLI�-WVEIPMW�KMZIYT�ERH�EFERHSR�XLIMV�LEVH�IEVRIH�WXEXI��;LIR�-WVEIP�HIGPEVIH�WXEXILSSHMR�������SRI�SJ�XLI�JMVWX�EGXMSRW�XEOIR�F]�MXW�RI[�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV��(EZMH&IR�+YVMSR��[EW�XS�EXXEGO�ERH�WMRO�E�WLMT�PSEHIH�[MXL�[IETSRW�HIWXMRIHJSV�1IREGLIQ�&IKMR¬W�TEVEQMPMXEV]�KVSYT��XLI�-VKYR��©%�WXEXI�QYWX�LEZIE�XSXEP�QSRSTSP]�SR�MXW�YWI�SJ�JSVGI�ª�LI�HIGPEVIH��ERH�EPP�TEVEQMPMXEV]KVSYTW�[IVI�JSVGMFP]�HMWFERHIH��(SIW�ER]SRI�VIEPP]�FIPMIZI�XLEX�=EWWIV%VEJEX��SV�ER]�TSTYPEVP]�IPIGXIH�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIV��[SYPH�WLS[�WYGLGSYVEKI�EKEMRWX�LMW�S[R�GSRWXMXYIRXW#�%VEJEX¬W�TIVWSREP�MRZSPZIQIRX�MR�ERH�HIRMEP�SJ �XLI�WLMTQIRX�SJ�XIVVSVMWX�[IETSRW�JVSQ�-VER�MR������GIVXEMRP]�VEMWIW�WSQI�UYIWXMSRW�EFSYX�LMW�VIPMEFMPMX]�MR�IRHMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�

%R]�SFNIGXMZI�SFWIVZIV�SJ�XLI�1MHIEWX�WMXYEXMSR�QYWX�EGORS[PIHKI�XLIWMKRMJMGERX�TVSFEFMPMX]�XLEX�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�GSYPH�WIVZI�EW�E�PEYRGLMRKTEH�JSV�VIRI[IH�XIVVSVMWQ ERH�[SVWI��9RXMP�ERH�YRPIWW�XLEX�JVMKLXIRMRKWGIREVMS�MW�EHHVIWWIH��[MXL�GSRGVIXI�KYEVERXIIW�JVSQ�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW�ERHXLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��MX�[MPP�FI�QSVI�HMJJMGYPX�JSV�E�TSPMXMGEP�GSR�WIRWYW�XS�FI�VIEGLIH�MR�-WVEIP�MR�JEZSV�SJ�WYGL�E�WXEXI�

-X�MW�RSX�IRSYKL�XS�WE]�XLEX�-WVEIP�VIXEMRW�XLI�VMKLX�XS�HIJIRH�MXWIPJ�ERHXS�VIXEPMEXI�EKEMRWX�XIVVSVMWQ��FIGEYWI�[LIR�-WVEIP�LEW�HSRI�WS�MR�XLI�TEWX�MX�LEW�FIIR�GSRHIQRIH�F]�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�ERH�XLI�9RMXIH2EXMSRW��7YGL�GSRHIQREXMSR�[SYPH�SRP]�KVS[�WXVSRKIV�MJ�-WVEIP�[IVI�XSEXXEGO�E�RI[P]�JSVQIH�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�XLEX�[EW�KMZMRK�PMT�WIVZMGI�XS�WXST�TMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�FYX�[EW�WIGVIXP]�WYTTSVXMRK�MX��SV�IZIR�NYWX�GPSWMRK�MXW�I]IWXS�MX��8LI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�GSYPH�RSX�FI�GSYRXIH�SR��EW�IZMHIRGIH�F]926;%¬W�VIJYWEP�XS�HS�ER]XLMRK�EFSYX�XIVVSVMWQ�XLEX�MW�STIRP]�TPERRIHERH�SVKERMIH�MR�MXW�VIJYKII�GEQTW��3RP]�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��[MXL�XLIGSSTIVEXMSR�SJ�SXLIV�REXMSRW��GSYPH�TVSZMHI�XLI�RIIHIH�KYEVERXIIW��&YXPMXXPI�XLSYKLX�MW�GYVVIRXP]�FIMRK�KMZIR�XS�IPMQMREXMRK�XLMW�TVIWWMRK�[LEX�MJFEVVMIV�XS�TIEGI�FIGEYWI�WS�QYGL�EXXIRXMSR�MW�FIMRK�JSGYWIH�SR�FPEQMRK-WVEIP�JSV�XLI�GYVVIRX�MQTEWWI�

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 246: The Case For Israel

-J�XLI�SRP]�GSRWIUYIRGI�SJ�GSRHIQRMRK�-WVEIP�HMWTVSTSVXMSREXIP]�XS�MXWJEYPXW�[IVI�XS�FI�YRJEMVRIWW�XS[EVH�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��XLEX�[SYPH�FI�FEHIRSYKL�GSRWMHIVMRK�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�XS[EVH�.I[W�ERH�.I[MWLMRWXMXYXMSRW�SZIV�XLI�QMPPIRRME��FYX�XLI�GSRWIUYIRGIW�EVI�JEV�QSVI�WIZIVI�8LI�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�ETTPMIH�XS�-WVEIP�IRHERKIVW�XLI�VYPI�SJ�PE[�ERH�XLIGVIHMFMPMX]�SJ�MRXIVREXMSREP�MRWXMXYXMSRW��8LI�HMWTVSTSVXMSREXI��WSQIXMQIWIZIR�I\GPYWMZI��JSGYW�SR�-WVEIP¬W�MQTIVJIGXMSRW�KMZIW�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREPGSQQYRMX]�E�VIEH]�I\GYWI�XS�MKRSVI�JEV�QSVI�WIVMSYW�ERH�WYWXEMRIH�ZMSPE�XMSRW�SJ�LYQER�VMKLXW��-X�EPWS�IRGSYVEKIW�XLSWI�[LS�HIPMFIVEXIP]�IRKEKI�MRZMSPIRGI�MR�SVHIV�XS�TVSZSOI�ER�-WVEIPM�VIEGXMSR�XLEX�XLI]�ORS[�[MPP�VIWYPXMR�HMWTVSTSVXMSREXI�ERH�I\GIWWMZI�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�

*MREPP]��ERH�TIVLETW�QSWX�WYFXP]��XLI�GEGSTLSR]�SJ�YRVIEWSREFPI��HSYFPI�WXERHEVH��I\XVIQMWX�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�HVS[RW�SYX�XLI�VIE�WSREFPI��GSQTEVEXMZI��ERH�GSRXI\XYEP�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�TEVXMGYPEV�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW�KSZIVRQIRXW��ERH�EGXMSRW��;LIR�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�MW�WS�YRJEMVP]�GVMXMGMIH�WSQI�SJ�MXW�WYTTSVXIVW IZIR�XLSWI�[LS�[SYPH�RSVQEPP]�FI�GVMXMGEP�SJ�TEV�XMGYPEV�EGXMSRW XIRH�XS�FIGSQI�HIJIRWMZI�FIGEYWI�XLI]�VIEPMI�XLEXEHHMRK�XS�XLI�GVMXMGMWQ�SRP]�PIRHW�WYTTSVX�XS�MQTVSTIV�IJJSVXW�XS�HIQS�RMI�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��8LI�IRH�VIWYPX�MW�XLEX�XLSWI�[LS�EXXEGO�-WVEIP�YRJEMVP]QEOI�MX�QSVI�HMJJMGYPX�XS�GVMXMGMI�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW�JEMVP]��ERH�XLI]�WSQIXMQIWHMWGSYVEKI�-WVEIP�JVSQ�EGGITXMRK�VIEWSREFPI�GVMXMGMWQ�ERH�EGXMRK�SR�MX�8LI]�EPWS�GSRXVMFYXI�MRHMVIGXP]�FYX�TEPTEFP]�XS�XLI�ZMSPIRGI�XLEX�TPEKYIWIJJSVXW�XS�FVMRK�EFSYX�E�NYWX�ERH�PEWXMRK�TIEGI�

%W�E�WXVSRK�WYTTSVXIV�SJ�JVIIHSQ�SJ�WTIIGL�ERH�E�PMJIPSRK�TVEGXMXMSRIVSJ�JVIIHSQ�XS�GVMXMGMI��-�[SYPH�GIVXEMRP]�RIZIV�XV]�XS�TVIZIRX�XLI�I\TVIW�WMSR�SJ�ER]�ZMI[W�VIKEVHMRK�-WVEIP��FYX�-�EQ�EPWS�E�WXVSRK�FIPMIZIV�MR�XLIVIEPMX]�XLEX�[SVHW�QEXXIV�ERH�XLEX�YRVIEWSRIH�GSRHIQREXMSR�GER�WSQI�XMQIW�GSQI�[MXL�E�LIEZ]�TVMGI��8LI�WIPIGXMZI�ERH�YRNYWX�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIPGEVVMIW�[MXL�MX�ER�IWTIGMEPP]�LIEZ]�TVMGI�QIEWYVIH�MR�PMZIW�ERH�PMQFW��*SVWSQI�IRIQMIW�SJ�-WVEIP��XLMW�VMWO�MW�[SVXL[LMPI MRHIIH��MX�MW�WTIGMJMGEPP]GEPGYPEXIH�XS�TVSHYGI�ZMSPIRX�VIWYPXW��&YX�JSV�QER]�TISTPI�SJ�KSSH[MPPXLIVI�MW�ER�YRE[EVIRIWW�XLEX�XLI�ZIV]�YRJEMVRIWW�SJ�XLI�GSRHIQREXMSRHMVIGXIH�WMRKYPEVP]�XS[EVH�-WVEIP�GSRXVMFYXIW�XS�VIWYPXW�SJ�[LMGL�XLI][SYPH�WYVIP]�HMWETTVSZI�

-R�WYQ��XLIVIJSVI��XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�MW�WXVSRK�MRHIIH��IWTIGMEPP]�[LIRZMI[IH�GSQTEVEXMZIP]�ERH�GSRXI\XYEPP]��FYX�IZIR�[LIR�NYHKIH�EKEMRWX�ER]VIEWSREFPI�SFNIGXMZI�WXERHEVHW��-WVEIP�MW�E�WQEPP�HIQSGVEG]�WYVVSYRHIH�F]LSWXMPI�IRIQMIW�ERH�FEXXPMRK�JSV�MXW�ZIV]�WYVZMZEP��-X�MW�JMKLXMRK�E�QER]�TVSRKIH�[EV�EKEMRWX�IRIQMIW�FSXL�[MXLMR�MXW�FSVHIVW�ERH�SYXWMHI�XLIQ��EW[IPP�EW�EKEMRWX�LSWXMPI�REXMSRW�ERH�KVSYTW�WIIOMRK�XS�HIPIKMXMQEXI�MX�[MXLMRXLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��-XW�EGXMSRW�MR�HIJIRWI�SJ�MXW�GMXMIRW�ERH�MXWREXMSRLSSH�LEZI�FIIR�JEV�JVSQ�TIVJIGX�SZIV�XLI�]IEVW��-X�LEW�QEHI�QMW�XEOIW��MX�LEW�SZIVEGXIH��ERH�MX�LEW�WSQIXMQIW�PEGOIH�KIRIVSWMX]�XS[EVH�MXW

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 247: The Case For Israel

IRIQMIW��&YX�XLI�WEQI��ERH�[SVWI��GER�FI�WEMH�SJ�QSWX�SXLIV�HIQSGVEGMIW�;LEX�GERRSX�FI�WEMH�SJ�SXLIV�HIQSGVEGMIW�MW�XLEX�ER]�LEZI�FILEZIH�FIX�

XIV QSVI�PE[JYPP]��QSVI�KIRIVSYWP] [LIR�JEGIH�[MXL�IUYMZEPIRX�XLVIEXWXS�MXW�GMXMIRW�ERH�XS�MXW�WYVZMZEP��;LIRIZIV�-WVEIP�SV�ER]�REXMSR�HIZMEXIWJVSQ�TIVJIGXMSR��MX�WLSYPH�FI�GVMXMGMIH�F]�MXW�S[R�GMXMIRW�ERH�F]�SYXWMHIVW�&YX�RS�REXMSR ERH�GIVXEMRP]�RS�REXMSR�[LSWI�TISTPI�LEZI�LMWXSVMGEPP]FIIR�WYFNIGX�XS�WS�QYGL�TVINYHMGI��TIVWIGYXMSR��ERH�HMWGVMQMREXMSRWLSYPH�FI�WYFNIGXIH�XS�XLI�OMRH�SJ�HSYFPI�WXERHEVH��YRMUYI�GSRHIQREXMSRXS�[LMGL�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�MW�RS[�FIMRK�YRJEMVP]�WYFNIGXIH�

&IJSVI�-�XYVR�XS�TVSTSWEPW�JSV�E�JYXYVI�TIEGI��PIX�QI�HMVIGXP]�EHHVIWW�XLIKVS[MRK�RYQFIV�SJ�WXYHIRXW�ERH�]SYRK�TISTPI�[LS�EVI�NSMRMRK�XLI�PIKMSRSJ�FMKSXW�[LS�GER�WII�RS�VMKLX�SR�XLI�WMHI�SJ�-WVEIP�ERH�RS�[VSRK�SR�XLIWMHI�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�WIIO�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�ERH�XVERWJIV�MXW�.I[MWLTSTYPEXMSR��=SY�EVI�SR�XLI�[VSRK�WMHI�SJ�LMWXSV]��=SY�EVI�SR�XLI�[VSRKWMHI�SJ�QSVEPMX]�ERH�NYWXMGI��=SY�LEZI��TIVLETW�MREHZIVXIRXP]��NSMRIH�LERHW[MXL�JSVGIW�SJ�IZMP�XLEX�LEZI�JSV�QMPPIRRME�MQTSWIH�E�HSYFPI�WXERHEVHEKEMRWX�IZIV]XLMRK�.I[MWL�

=SY�EVI�SR�XLI�WMHI�SJ�XLSWI�[LS�WYTTSVXIH�,MXPIV¬W�,SPSGEYWX�ERHRS[�HIR]�XLEX�MX�SGGYVVIH��=SY�EVI�EWWMWXMRK�XLSWI�[LS�EVI�SRGI�EKEMR�XEV�KIXMRK�FEFMIW��GLMPHVIR��[SQIR��ERH�XLI�IPHIVP]�NYWX�FIGEYWI�XLI]�EVI�.I[�MWL��=SY�EVI�MR�ZIV]�FEH�GSQTER]��2SV�GER�]SY�GSRXMRYI�XS�LMHI�FILMRHGPEMQW�SJ�MKRSVERGI��FIGEYWI�XLI�JEGXW�EVI�WS�IEWMP]�EZEMPEFPI�XS�ER]SRI�[LS[ERXW�XS�XLMRO�JSV�LMQWIPJ�SV�LIVWIPJ�

-J�XVEKIH]�[IVI�SRGI�EKEMR�XS�FIJEPP�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI��SV�XLI�.I[MWLREXMSR�MR�[LMGL�QSVI�XLER���QMPPMSR�SJ�XLIQ�QEOI�XLIMV�LSQI��LMWXSV][MPP�NYHKI�]SY�LEVWLP]��EW�MX�LEW�]SYV�MHISPSKMGEP�TVIHIGIWWSVW��8LMRO�JSV]SYVWIPJ��0IEVR�XLI�JEGXW��0MWXIR�XS�EPP�WMHIW��%RH�MJ�]SY�EVI�E�TIVWSR�SJKSSH[MPP��-�EQ�GSRJMHIRX�XLEX�]SY�[MPP�RS�PSRKIV�WII�XLMW�GSQTPI\�MWWYI�EWSRI�WMHIHP]�ERXM�-WVEIP��=SY�S[I�MX�XS�]SYVWIPJ�ERH�XS�LMWXSV]�RSX�XS�VIQEMRGSQTPMGMX�[MXL�E�RI[�ZEVMERX�SR�XLI�[SVPH¬W�SPHIWX�TVINYHMGI�

8,)�'%7)�*36�4)%')��2)')77%6=�*-678�78)47

-WVEIP¬W�FIWX�GLERGI�JSV�TIEGI�MW�XS�VIQEMR�WXVSRK�QMPMXEVMP]�[LMPI�EPWS�LIPT�MRK�XS�WXVIRKXLIR�XLI�LERHW�SJ�XLSWI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�XVYP]�FIPMIZI�MR�E�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR XLSWI�[LS�[SYPH�FI�WEXMWJMIH�[MXL�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�PMZMRKWMHI�F]�WMHI�[MXL�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�RSX�QIVIP]�EW�E�XIQTSVEV]�XEGXMG�FYX�EW�ERIRHYVMRK�WSPYXMSR�XS�XLMW�GIRXYV]�PSRK�TVSFPIQ��%PXLSYKL�GYVVIRX�TSPPWWYKKIWX�XLEX�QSWX�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�QER]�%VEFW�EVSYRH�XLI�[SVPH�WII�E�4EPIW�XMRMER�WXEXI�EW�E�XEGXMGEP�JMVWX�WXIT�XS[EVH�XLI�IZIRXYEP�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�XLI�FIWX�LSTI�JSV�TIEGI�MW�XLEX�XMQI�ERH�TVSKVIWW�[MPP�GLERKI�XLIWI�RYQFIVW�

8LIVI�[MPP�EP[E]W�FI�WSQI�[LS�STTSWI�-WVEIP¬W�ZIV]�I\MWXIRGI�ERH�[LSEVI�TVITEVIH�XS�FPS[�XLIQWIPZIW�YT��EPSRK�[MXL�-WVEIPM�GMZMPMERW��XS

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 248: The Case For Israel

EGLMIZI�XLEX�YRVIEPMWXMG�KSEP��%PP�XIVVSVMWQ�[MPP�RSX�GSQI�XS�ER�IRH RS[SV�IZIV IZIR�MJ�-WVEIP�[IVI�XS�HS�IZIV]XLMRK�MR�MXW�TS[IV�XS�LIPT�IWXEFPMWLE�WXVSRK�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��-WVEIP��PMOI�XLI�9RMXIH�7XEXIW��[MPP�TVSFEFP]�LEZIXS�PMZI�[MXL�E�GIVXEMR�EQSYRX�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ�SZIV�MXW�PMJIXMQI��NYWX�EW�%JVMGER%QIVMGERW�LEH�XS�IRHYVI�/Y�/PY\�/PER�ZMSPIRGI�JSV�QER]�]IEVW��&YX�XLI/PER�MW�JMREPP]�HIEH��SV�EX�PIEWX�SR�PMJI�WYTTSVX �ERH�TIVLETW�WSQIHE]�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�[MPP�EPWS�HMI�E�FIPEXIH�HIEXL��=IX�MX�[MPP�FI�E�WPS[HIEXL�FIGEYWI�MX�IRNS]W�QSVI�WYTTSVX�EQSRK�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�-WPEQMGI\XVIQMWXW�XLER�/PER�ZMSPIRGI�IZIV�IRNS]IH�EQSRK�%QIVMGER�VEGMWXW�

8LI�GSQTPIXI�XIVQMREXMSR�SJ�EPP�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWQ�WLSYPH�RSX�FI�ETVIVIUYMWMXI�XS�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�EPSRKWMHI�E�WIGYVI�-WVEIP�8SMQTSWI�WYGL�E�GSRHMXMSR�[SYPH�FI�XS�KMZI�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW�E�ZIXS�SZIVTVSKVIWW�XS[EVH�TIEGI E�ZIXS�XLI]�[SYPH�I\IVGMWI�[MXL�ZMSPIRGI��EW�XLI]LEZI�MR�XLI�TEWX�[LIR�TVSKVIWW�[EW�FIMRK�QEHI��&YX�E�XSXEP�ERH�LSRIWXIJJSVX�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��ERH�XLSWI�KVSYTW�ERH�MRHMZMHYEPW�SZIV[LMGL�MX�I\IVGMWIW�HI�JEGXS�GSRXVSP��XS�WXST�EPP�XIVVSVMWQ�QYWX�FI�ER�YRGSR�HMXMSREP�TVIVIUYMWMXI�XS�WXEXILSSH��%�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�QYWX�WIIO�XS�QEMR�XEMR�ER�EFWSPYXI�QSRSTSP]�SZIV�QMPMXEV]��TEVEQMPMXEV]��KYIVVMPPE��ERHXIVVSVMWX�ZMSPIRGI��EW�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�HMH�MR������[LIR�MX�JSVGMFP]�ERH�TIV�QERIRXP]�HMWEVQIH�)XIP�ERH�0IGLM��)ZIR�FIJSVI�MX�FIGSQIW�E�WXEXI��XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�QYWX�WLS[�XLEX�MX�MW�[MPPMRK�ERH�EFPI�XS�HMWEVQ�EPPXIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW��ERH�IWTIGMEPP]�XLSWI WYGL�EW�XLI�8ERMQ�ERH�%P�%UWE1EVX]VW�&VMKEHI XLEX�VIKEVH�XLIQWIPZIW�EW�TEVX�SJ�XLI�*EXEL�QSZIQIRX�7YVIP]��XLIVI�GER�FI�RS�WIVMSYW�GSRWMHIVEXMSR�SJ�WXEXILSSH�MJ�XLI�4EPIWXMR�MER�%YXLSVMX]�GSRXMRYIW�XS�MQTSVX�MPPIKEP�[IETSRW�JSV�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW�EW�MXHMH�MR�.ERYEV]�������[LIR�XLI�/EVMRI�%[EW�GEYKLX�ERH�MXW�GETXEMREHQMXXIH�XLEX�LI�[EW�FVMRKMRK�MR�[IETSRW�F]�SVHIV�SJ�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�

'VIEXMRK�E�WXVSRK�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�RI\X�XS�E�WXVSRK�-WVEIP�[MPP�VIUYMVI4EPIWXMRMERW�XS�KMZI�YT�XLIMV�YRVIEPMWXMG�HVIEQ�ERH�-WVEIP¬W�HVIEHIH�RMKLX�QEVI�SJ�WIZIVEP�QMPPMSR�TISTPI�VIXYVRMRK�XS�-WVEIP�[LS�GPEMQ�XS�FIVIJYKIIW�JVSQ�-WVEIP��8LMW�WS�GEPPIH�4EPIWXMRMER�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR��QSVI�XLERER]�-WVEIPM�EGXMSR��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�QMWKYMHIH�GSRXMRYIH�SGGYTEXMSR�ERH�XLI[VSRK�LIEHIH�I\TERWMSR�SJ�WIXXPIQIRXW��MW�XLI�QENSVFEVVMIV�XS�E�TIVQE�RIRX�TIEGI�FIX[IIR�-WVEIPMW�ERH�4EPIWXMRMERW�

*I[�4EPIWXMRMERW�EGXYEPP]�[ERX�XS�VIXYVR�XS�-WVEIP�XS�FIGSQI�TEVX�SJ�ER%VEF�QMRSVMX]�PMZMRK�MR�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��YRPIWW�XLI]�EVI�JIEVJYP�SJ�E�1YW�PMQ§4EPIWXMRMER�X]VERR] ���1SWX�[SYPH�WYVIP]�TVIJIV�XS�PMZI�EW�TEVX�SJ�E1YWPMQ�QENSVMX]�MR�ER�IGSRSQMGEPP]�ZMEFPI�ERH�TSPMXMGEPP]�HIQSGVEXMG4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��%W�EVKYIH�IEVPMIV��E�GPEMQIH�VMKLX�XS�VIXYVR�LEW�EP[E]WFIIR�E�XEGXMG�HIWMKRIH�XS�W[EQT�-WVEIP�[MXL�QMPPMSRW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�WS�EWXS�XYVR�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�MRXS�E�XLMVH�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�ERH�]IX�ERSXLIV�SJXLI�RYQIVSYW�-WPEQMG�WXEXIW�

%W�E�VIWSPYXMSR�TEWWIH�F]�XLI�VIJYKII�GSRJIVIRGI�EX�,SQW��7]VME��QEHI

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 249: The Case For Israel

GPIEV�MR�������©%R]�HMWGYWWMSR�EMQIH�EX�E�WSPYXMSR�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�TVSF�PIQ�[LMGL�[MPP�RSX�FI�FEWIH�SR�IRWYVMRK�XLI�VIJYKIIW¬�VMKLX�XS�ERRMLMPEXI-WVEIP�[MPP�FI�VIKEVHIH�EW�E�HIWIGVEXMSR�SJ�XLI�%VEF�TISTPI�ERH�ER�EGX�SJXVIEWSR�ª��-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�QYWX�FI�HIIQIH�F]�XLIMRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]�ERH�QYWX�FI�GSRGIHIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEH�IVWLMT�XS�XVYQT�ER]�GPEMQIH�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�

2SV�[SYPH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�FI�KMZMRK�YT�E�VIEP�VMKLX��2S�SXLIV�VIJYKIIKVSYT�MR�LMWXSV] GIVXEMRP]�RSRI�GVIEXIH�F]�XLI�OMRH�SJ�GSQTPI\�JSVGIWXLEX�PIH�ER�IUYMZEPIRX�RYQFIV�SJ�%VEFW�XS�PIEZI�-WVEIP�ERH�.I[W�XS�PIEZI%VEF�GSYRXVMIW LEW�IZIV�FIIR�KMZIR�ER�EGXYEP�VMKLX�XS�VIXYVR�XLEX�LEH�XLIIJJIGX��MJ�RSX�XLI�MRXIRX��SJ�GLERKMRK�XLI�GLEVEGXIV�ERH�REXYVI�SJ�XLI�GSYR�XV]�XLEX�XLI]�PIJX��

1SVISZIV��XLI�ZEWX�QENSVMX]�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�RS[�GPEMQ�XLI�VMKLX�XSVIXYVR�XS�-WVEIP�LEZI�RIZIV�PMXIVEPP]�WIX�JSSX�MR�-WVEIP��8LI]��XLIMV�GLMPHVIR�ERH�SJXIR�XLIMV�KVERHGLMPHVIR�[IVI�FSVR�MR�VIJYKII�GEQTW�HIPMFIVEXIP]IWXEFPMWLIH�F]�-WVEIP¬W�IRIQMIW�XS�TIVTIXYEXI�ERH�I\TERH�E�VIJYKII�TVSF�PIQ�HIWMKRIH�XS�HIWXVS]�-WVEIP��%QSRK�XLI�JI[�[LS�EGXYEPP]�PIJX�QSVIXLER�LEPJ�E�GIRXYV]�EKS�ERH�[LS�EVI�WXMPP�EPMZI��QER]�PMZIH�MR�-WVEIP�JSV�SRP]E�JI[�]IEVW��6IGEPP�XLEX�XLI�HIJMRMXMSR�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKII��YRPMOI�XLEXSJ�ER]�SXLIV�VIJYKII�MR�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�XLI�[SVPH��MW�WSQISRI�[LS�PMZIH�MR-WVEIP�JSV�SRP]�X[S�]IEVWERH�PIJX�JSV�ER]�VIEWSR�[LEXWSIZIV��MRGPYHMRK�IGS�RSQMG�GSRZIRMIRGI��JEQMP]�VIYRMJMGEXMSR��LEXVIH�SJ�.I[MWL�RIMKLFSVW��SVXEGXMGEP�HIGMWMSRW�QEHI�F]�%VEF�PIEHIVW��8LMW�MW�SRI�SJ�XLI�[IEOIWX�VIJYKIIGPEMQW�MR�LMWXSV]��]IX�MX�MW�XLI�SRI�XLEX�LEW�KSXXIR�XLI�WXVSRKIWX�WYTTSVXJVSQ�XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��%KEMR��XLI�KYPJ�FIX[IIR�VIEPMX]�ERHTIVGITXMSR�MW�YRTVIGIHIRXIH��TIVLETW�FIGEYWI�XLI�REXMSR�EGGYWIH�SJ�GVI�EXMRK�XLMW�I\EKKIVEXIH�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�MW�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�

8LI�XMQI�LEW�GSQI MRHIIH�XLI�XMQI�MW�PSRK�SZIVHYI XS�TYX�ER�IRH�XSXLMW�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�GLEVEHI�F]�WS�GEPPIH�%VEF�VIJYKIIW��)ZIR�2SEQ�'LSQ�WO]�LEW�YVKIH�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�XS�WXST�TERHIVMRK�XS�XLIMV�JSPPS[IVW�F]TVSQMWMRK�XLIQ�E�VMKLX�XS�VIXYVR�XLEX�XLI]�LEZI�RS�TSWWMFMPMX]�SJ�WIGYVMRK���

9RXMP�XLI�[SVPH�EGORS[PIHKIW�XLEX�XLI�%VEF�VIJYWEP�XS�EGGITX�XLI�I\MWXIRGISJ�-WVEIP�JSPPS[MRK�XLI�9�2��TEVXMXMSR�GVIEXIH�ER�I\GLERKI�SJ�TSTYPEXMSRXLEX�QYWX�RS[�FI�HIIQIH�XS�FI�TIVQERIRX��XLIVI�[MPP�FI�RS�TVSWTIGX�SJTIEGI�FIX[IIR�XLI�%VEFW�ERH�-WVEIP��&YX�EW�WSSR�EW�XLI�[SVPH�VIGSKRMIW-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�GSRXMRYI�XS�I\MWX�ERH�XLVMZI�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��[MXLSYX�XLIXLVIEX�SJ�QMPPMSRW�SJ�LSWXMPI�VIJYKIIW�VIXYVRMRK�XS�HIWXVS]�MX��XLI�TVSWTIGXWJSV�TIEGI�[MPP�MRGVIEWI�HVEQEXMGEPP]�

4VSJIWWSV�1MGLEIP�;EPXIV�SJ�4VMRGIXSR¬W�-RWXMXYXI�JSV�%HZERGIH�7XYH�MIW�LEW�EVKYIH�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[MPP�RIZIV�EGLMIZI�WXEXILSSH�YRPIWW�XLI]KMZI�YT�XLI�VMKLX�XS�VIXYVR�ERH�XS�HIQSKVETLMGEPP]�HIWXVS]�-WVEIP�EW�E�.I[�MWL�WXEXI��,I�LEW�EPWS�GSVVIGXP]�SFWIVZIH�XLEX�JI[��MJ�ER]��4EPIWXMRMER�PIEH�IVW�LEZI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 250: The Case For Israel

FIIR�VIEH]�XS�EVKYI�XLEX�KMZMRK�YT�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�MW�XLI�RIGIWWEV]

TVMGI�SJ�WXEXILSSH��8LEX�WIIQW�XS�QI�XLI�VMKLX�TSWMXMSR��WMRGI�XLI�GPEMQ�XS

VIXYVR�IJJIGXMZIP]�VISTIRW�XLI�����§�����GSRJPMGX��[LMGL�MW�RSX�E�LIPTJYP

XLMRK�XS�HS�QSVI�XLER�LEPJ�E�GIRXYV]�PEXIV��%PP�XLI�SXLIV�VIJYKIIW�JVSQ�XLI

]IEVW�MQQIHMEXIP]�EJXIV�;SVPH�;EV�8[S��JVSQ�'IRXVEP�)YVSTI�XS�7SYXLIEWX

%WME��LEZI�FIIR�WYGGIWWJYPP]�VIWIXXPIH��4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI�WXMPP�MR�GEQTW

FIGEYWI�E�HIGMWMSR�[EW�QEHI��F]�XLIMV�S[R�PIEHIVW�ERH�F]�XLI�EHNEGIRX

%VEF�WXEXIW��XS�OIIT�XLIQ�XLIVI�XLMW�[EW�E�[E]�SJ�MRWMWXMRK�XLEX�-WVEIP¬W

MRHITIRHIRGI�[EV�[EW�RSX�]IX�SZIV��8SHE]��LS[IZIV��MJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�EVI

XS�[MR�XLIMV�S[R�MRHITIRHIRGI�[EV��XLI]�QYWX�EGORS[PIHKI�XLEX�-WVEIP¬W�MW

EPVIEH]�[SR��4IVLETW�WSQI�RYQFIV�SJ�VIJYKIIW�[MPP�VIXYVR�XS�-WVEIP��WSQI

KVIEXIV�RYQFIV�XS�4EPIWXMRI��LS[�QER]�[MPP�HITIRH�SR�XLI�TEGI�SJ

MRZIWXQIRX�ERH�IGSRSQMG�HIZIPSTQIRX ��8LI�VIWX�QYWX�JMREPP]�FI�VIWIXXPIH�

-X�MW�XMQI�XS�EHHVIWW�XLIMV�EGXYEP�QMWIV]�VEXLIV�XLER�XLIMV�W]QFSPMG�GPEMQW�

8LIVI�[MPP�GSRXMRYI�XS�FI�E�4EPIWXMRMER�HMEWTSVE��NYWX�EW�XLIVI�GSRXMRYIW�XS

FI�E�.I[MWL�HMEWTSVE��%�GPIEV�WXEXIQIRX�F]�%VEJEX�EGORS[PIHKMRK�XLMW�WMQ�

TPI�XVYXL�[SYPH�VITVIWIRX�E�FMK�WXIT�XS[EVH�YRHIGPEVMRK�XLI�JMVWX�[EV���

2SX�SRP]�LEW�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�VIJYWIH�XS�XEOI�XLMW�WXIT��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER%YXLSVMX]�VIGIRXP]�XSSO�E�KMERX�WXIT�FEGO[EVH�F]�MRGPYHMRK�XLI�VMKLX�SJVIXYVR�MR�XLIMV�RI[�GSRWXMXYXMSR�ERH�MRWMWXMRK�XLEX�MX�VIQEMR�SR�XLI�XEFPI�EWTEVX�SJ�XLI�©VSEH�QET�ª�1SVISZIV��EPXLSYKL�XLI�RI[�4EPIWXMRMER�TVMQIQMRMWXIV�LEW�VIGSKRMIH�-WVEIP¬W�©VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�ª�LI�LEW�XLYW�JEV�VIJYWIH�ER%QIVMGER�VIUYIWX��QEHI�EW�VIGIRXP]�EW�.YRI����������XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER%YXLSVMX]�VIGSKRMI�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�©WTIGMJMGEPP]�EW�E�.I[MWL�7XEXI�ª��

8LMW�VIJYWEP�TVIWIVZIW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�GPEMQ�XLEX�-WVEIP�WLSYPH�EPPS[�QMPPMSRWSJ�%VEF�VIJYKIIW�XS�©VIXYVRª�ERH�XS�XYVR�-WVEIP�MRXS�ERSXLIV�WXEXI�[MXL�E4EPIWXMRMER�QENSVMX]��-X�MW�XLI�LSTI�SJ�QSWX�-WVEIPMW�XLEX�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[MPPIZIRXYEPP]�HVST�XLMW�YRVIEPMWXMG�HIQERH��WMRGI�MX�[EW�%VEJEX¬W�VIJYWEP�XS�HSWS�XLEX�HSSQIH�XLI�IEVPMIV�TIEGI�RIKSXMEXMSRW�MR�����§�����

4VIWMHIRX�,SWRM�1YFEVEO�XSSO�E�TSWMXMZI�JMVWX�WXIT�MR�XLMW�HMVIGXMSR�F]HIGPEVMRK�XLEX�©XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�HIQERH�JSV�XLI�«VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR¬�MW�XSXEPP]YRVIEPMWXMG�ERH�[SYPH�LEZI�XS�FI�WSPZIH�F]�QIERW�SJ�JMRERGMEP�GSQTIRWEXMSRERH�VIWIXXPIQIRX�MR�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW�ª��8LMW��SJ�GSYVWI��MW�TVIGMWIP]�[LEX�[EWSJJIVIH�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE E�����FMPPMSR�GSQTIRWEXMSR�TEGOEKITPYW�ER�EGORS[PIHKQIRX�SJ�©[VSRKWª�HSRI�XS�XLI�VIJYKIIW��ERH�XLI�VMKLXSJ�WSQI�VIJYKIIW�XS�VIXYVR�XS�-WVEIP�&YX�%VEJEX�[EPOIH�E[E]��GPEMQMRK�XLEX&EVEO¬W�SJJIV�[SYPH�RSX�VIWSPZI�XLI�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ��%R]�LSTI�SJ�EGLMIZ�MRK�E�VIEP�TIEGI�[MPP�FI�HEWLIH�YRPIWW�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMT�KMZIW�YT�XLMWTVIXI\XYEP�©VMKLX�SJ�VIXYVR�ª�[LMGL�MW�RSXLMRK�PIWW�XLER�E�ZIMPIH�©VMKLXª�XSHIWXVS]�-WVEIP�F]�HIQSKVETLMG��VEXLIV�XLER�F]�XIVVSVMWXMG��QIERW�

8LI�1YWPMQ�[SVPH�QYWX�EPWS�KMZI�YT�MXW�GLEYZMRMWXMG�ERH�VEGMWX�GPEMQ�XLEXXLI�I\MWXIRGI�SJ�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��RS�QEXXIV�LS[�WQEPP��SR�©WEGVIH�1YWPMQ

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 251: The Case For Israel

PERHª�MW�E�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�-WPEQMG�PE[��8LMW�EFWYVH�ERH�WIPJ�WIVZMRK�GPEMQ��JMVWXQEHI�F]�XLI�ERXM�7IQMXMG�KVERH�QYJXM�MR�XLI�����W�ERH�GSRXMRYSYWP]VITIEXIH�WMRGI�XLIR�MR�4EPIWXMRMER�GLEVXIVW��GSRWXMXYXMSRW��ERH�WIVQSRW�QYWX�FI�GEXIKSVMGEPP]�ERH�TYFPMGP]�VINIGXIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVWLMTSRGI�ERH�JSV�EPP�RSX�EW�E�XEGXMG�FYX�EW�E�VIGSKRMXMSR�XLEX�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�LEWEW�QYGL�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�MR�XLI�EVIE�EW�HSIW�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI�

)XLER�&VSRRIV��[LS�GSZIVIH�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�JVSQ������XS������ERHMW�RS[�ER�IHMXSVMEP�TEKI�IHMXSV�JSV�XLI�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�VIGIRXP]�XSPH�SJ�ERMRXIVZMI[�[MXL�XLI�PEXI�/MRK�,YWWIMR�SJ�.SVHER�XLEX�WLS[W�LS[�HIITP]�XLISTTSWMXMSR�XS�-WVEIP¬W�PIKMXMQEG]�MW�MRKVEMRIH�IZIR�EQSRK�XLI�QSWX�QSH�IVEXI�SJ�%VEF�PIEHIVW�

-�SRGI�EWOIH�/MRK�,YWWIMR�������[LIXLIV�LI�GSRWMHIVIH�>MSRMWQ�PIKMXM�

QEXI��(MH�LI�EGGITX�XLEX�XLIVI�[EW�ER]�LMWXSVMGEP�FEWMW�XS�XLI�.I[W¬�GPEMQ

XS�E�TSVXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�EW�XLIMV�LSQIPERH#�,I�PSSOIH�EX�QI�EW�MJ�-�[IVI

JVSQ�1EVW�ERH�HYGOIH�XLI�UYIWXMSR��4IVLETW�F]�XLI�XMQI�SJ�LMW�HIEXL�MR

�����LI�LEH�WSJXIRIH�LMW�ZMI[��&YX�LMW�VIEGXMSR�WXMPP�I\IQTPMJMIW�XLEX�SJ

XLI�ZEWX�QENSVMX]�SJ�%VEFW�XSHE]�ª��

&VSRRIV�EPWS�VITSVXW�XLEX�7EIF�)VIOEX��E�©QSHIVEXIª�4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIV�ERRSYRGIH�HYVMRK�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�RIKSXMEXMSRW�MR������XLEX�MX�MW�XLI1YWPMQ�TSWMXMSR�XLEX�©XLIVI�RIZIV�[EW�E�.I[MWL�8IQTPIª�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�HIWTMXI�RIEV�YRERMQMX]�EQSRK�LMWXSVMERW�ERH�EVGLISPSKMWXW�XLEX�XLI�LSPMIWXWMXI�MR�.IVYWEPIQ�[EW�SR�XLI�8IQTPI�1SYRX��8LMW�JEPWMJMGEXMSR�SJ�LMWXSV]�MWTEVX�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�IJJSVX�XS�HMWTYXI�ER]�LMWXSVMGEP�GPEMQW�F]�.I[W�RSX�SRP]XS�.IVYWEPIQ�FYX�XS�ER]�TEVX�SJ�-WVEIP�

8LI�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�REXMSRW�SJ�XLI�[SVPH�QYWX�EPWS�GSQI�XS�EGGITXRSX�SRP]�-WVEIP¬W�GSRXMRYIH�I\MWXIRGI�EW�E�JEGX�FYX�EPWS�MXW�VMKLXXS�I\MWX�EWE�.I[MWL�WXEXI�MR�WEJIX]�ERH�WIGYVMX]��8LI�XLVIEXW�SJ�KIRSGMHI�ERH�TSPMXMGMHIXLEX�EVI�GSRXMRYEPP]�QEHI�MR�QER]�UYEVXIVW�QYWX�IRH�SRGI�ERH�JSV�EPP�%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�PIEHIVW�QYWX�XIPP�XLIMV�TISTPI�XLEX�-WVEIP�[MPP�RSX�FIEXXEGOIH�FIGEYWI�MX�LEW�XLI�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�TIVQERIRXP]��RSX�FIGEYWI�MX�MW�XEG�XMGEPP]�MREHZMWEFPI�XS�HS�WS�©EX�XLMW�XMQIª ERH�XLIWI�WXEXIQIRXW�QYWX�FIQEHI�ERH�VITIEXIH�MR�%VEFMG�XS�XLIMV�TISTPI��RSX�SRP]�MR�)RKPMWL�ERH*VIRGL�XS�HMTPSQEXW�

-WVEIP¬W�TIVQERIRX�WIGYVMX]�QYWX�FI�EWWYVIH�EKEMRWX�IRIQMIW�FSXL�I\XIV�REP�ERH�MRXIVREP��9RXMP�ERH�YRPIWW�XLEX�SGGYVW��-WVEIP�QYWX�GSRXMRYI�XSQEMRXEMR�E�UYEPMXEXMZI�QMPMXEV]�WYTIVMSVMX]�SZIV�XLI�GSQFMRIH�EVQIHJSVGIW�SJ�MXW�TSXIRXMEP�IRIQMIW�EW�XLI�FIWX�EWWYVERGI�SJ�TIEGI�MR�XLI�VIKMSR�WMRGI�-WVEIP�GER�GSYRX�SR�RS�SRI�IPWI�XS�EWWYVI�MXW�WYVZMZEP�

-WVEIP��MR�XYVR��QYWX�KMZI�YT�ER]�GPEMQ��EW�MX�SJJIVIH�XS�HS�EX�'EQT(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�MR�������SZIV�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�XLI�+EE�7XVMT��WYFNIGXSRP]�XS�XLI�OMRH�SJ�WQEPP�XIVVMXSVMEP�EHNYWXQIRXW�GSRXIQTPEXIH�F]�9�2��6IW�SPYXMSR�����XS�EWWYVI�MXW�WIGYVMX]��-X�QYWX�EPWS�IRH�XLI�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRXW�MR

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 252: The Case For Israel

XLI�+EE�7XVMT�ERH�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�LIEVX�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO��EPXLSYKL��SZIVXMQI��.I[W�WLSYPH�FI�JVII�XS�PMZI�WEJIP]�ER][LIVI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�EW�4EPIWXMRM�ERW�GER��ERH�HS��PMZI�MR�-WVEIP��3R�1E]�����������-WVEIPM�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV%VMIP�7LEVSR�ERRSYRGIH�XLEX�©?XALI�QSQIRX�LEW�EVVMZIH�XS�HMZMHI�XLMWXVEGX�SJ�PERH�FIX[IIR�YW�ERH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ª��,MW�KSZIVRQIRX�ZSXIH�XSEGGITX�XLI�VSEH�QET��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�GVIEXMSR�SJ�E�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXI��2S[�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�QYWX�HIQSRWXVEXI�MXW�HIXIVQMREXMSR�XS�HMWQERXPI�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWX�SVKERMEXMSRW��ERH�XS�QEOI�FIWX�IJJSVXW�XS�TVIZIRX�JYV�XLIV�EGXW�SJ�XIVVSVMWQ��-X�VIQEMRW�XS�FI�WIIR�[LIXLIV�MXW�GYVVIRX�PIEHIVWLEZI�XLI�GSYVEKI�ERH�TS[IV�XS�MQTPIQIRX�XLIMV�SFPMKEXMSRW�YRHIV�XLIVSEH�QET�

-R�ER�MQTSVXERX�EVXMGPI�MR�(MWWIRX�MR�XLI�JEPP�SJ�������4VSJIWWSV�;EPIVTSMRXIH�SYX�XLEX�JSYV�[EVW�EVI�FIMRK�JSYKLX�WMQYPXERISYWP]�

8LI�JMVWX�MW�E�4EPIWXMRMER�[EV�XS�HIWXVS]�XLI�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP�

8LI�WIGSRH�MW�E�4EPIWXMRMER�[EV�XS�GVIEXI�ER�MRHITIRHIRX�WXEXI�EPSRKWMHI

-WVEIP��IRHMRK�XLI�SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE�

8LI�XLMVH�MW�ER�-WVEIPM�[EV�JSV�XLI�WIGYVMX]�SJ�-WVEIP�[MXLMR�XLI������

FSVHIVW�

8LI�JSYVXL�MW�ER�-WVEIPM�[EV�JSV�+VIEXIV�-WVEIP��JSV�XLI�WIXXPIQIRXW�ERH�XLI

SGGYTMIH�XIVVMXSVMIW���

;EPIV�XLIR�EVKYIH�XLEX�JSV�QSWX�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLI�[EV�JSV�-WVEIP¬WHIWXVYGXMSR�WIIQW�XS�LEZI�TVMSVMX]�SZIV�XLI�[EV�JSV�4EPIWXMRMER�WXEXILSSHEPSRKWMHI�-WVEIP��,MW�TVSSJ�MW�XLEX�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�©WXEXILSSHGSYPH�LEZI�FIIR�EGLMIZIH�[MXLSYX�ER]�[EV�EX�EPP�ª�=IX�MX�[EW�XYVRIH�HS[RFIGEYWI�MX�PIJX�-WVEIP�MRXEGX�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI��*SV�QSWX�-WVEIPMW��SR�XLI�SXLIVLERH��XLI�©HIJIRWMZI�[EV�JSV�-WVEIP¬W�WIGYVMX]ª�XEOIW�TVMSVMX]�SZIV�ER]�[EVJSV�©KVIEXIV�-WVEIP�ª�8LI�TVSSJ�MW�XLEX�ER�-WVEIPM�KSZIVRQIRX��EPQSWX�GIV�XEMRP]�WYTTSVXIH�F]�E�QENSVMX]�SJ�MXW�TSTYPEXMSR��[EW�TVITEVIH�XS�IRH�XLISGGYTEXMSR�ERH�HMWQERXPI�XLI�WIXXPIQIRXW�MR�I\GLERKI�JSV�VIEP�TIEGI�ERHWIGYVMX]��=IX�%VEJEX�[EPOIH�E[E]�JVSQ�&EVEO¬W�TVSTSWEP�[MXLSYX�SJJIVMRK�EGSYRXIVTVSTSWEP�

*SV�TIEGI�XS�FIGSQI�E�VIEPMX]��XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�WYTTSVX�XLI�KSEP�SJXLI�JMVWX�[EV XLI�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIPQYWX�FIGSQI�GSRZMRGIH�XLEX�MX�MWRSX�SRP]�MQTSWWMFPI�XS�EGLMIZI��MX�MW�EPWS�[VSRK��%RH�XLI�-WVEIPMW�[LS�WYT�TSVX�XLI�JSYVXL�[EV JSV�E�TIVQERIRX�SGGYTEXMSR�ERH�ER�I\XIRWMZI�RIX�[SVO�SJ�WIXXPIQIRXW QYWX�FIGSQI�GSRZMRGIH�SJ�XLI�WEQI�XLMRK��8LITVSFPIQ�MW�XLEX�XLIVI�EVI�QER]�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�[LS�FIPMIZI�MR�XLI�JMVWX[EV�XLER�XLIVI�EVI�-WVEIPMW�[LS�FIPMIZI�MR�XLI�JSYVXL�[EV��ERH�XLIWI�4EPIW�XMRMERW�EVI�JEV�QSVI�[MPPMRK�XS�YWI�XIVVSVMWX�ZMSPIRGI�MR�E�JYXMPI�FYX�HIEHP]IJJSVX�XS�EGLMIZI�XLIMV�MKRSFPI�KSEP�SJ�HIWXVS]MRK�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 253: The Case For Israel

8LI�QSWX�MQTSVXERX�ERH�IRHYVMRK�WXITW�XS[EVH�TIEGI�EVI�XLYW�EXXMXY�HMREP��4EPIWXMRMER�PIEHIVW�QYWX�WXST�XIEGLMRK�XLIMV�GLMPHVIR�XS�LEXI�.I[WERH�-WVEIPMW��QYWX�WXST�TYFPMWLMRK�QETW�XLEX�IPMQMREXI�-WVEIP��ERH�QYWXWXST�QMWPIEHMRK�XLI�©VIJYKIIWª�MRXS�FIPMIZMRK�XLEX�XLI]�[MPP�WSQIHE]VIXYVR�XS�XLIMV�LSQIW�MR�E�1YWPMQ�-WVEIP��-WVEIPM�PIEHIVW�QYWX�WXSTIRGSYVEKMRK�WIXXPIQIRXW�ERH�QYWX�HMWGSYVEKI�XLSWI�[LS�LEVFSV�XLI�MPPY�WMSR�SJ�E�KVIEXIV�-WVEIP�XLEX�MRGPYHIW�PEVKI�TSVXMSRW�SJ�.YHIE�ERH�7EQEVME�.I[MWL�FMFPMGEP�GPEMQW�QYWX�FI�EFERHSRIH�MR�XLI�REQI�SJ�TVEKQEXMG�GSQ�TVSQMWI��NYWX�EW�-WPEQMG�/SVERMG�GPEMQW�QYWX�FI�WYVVIRHIVIH��1SWX�MQTSV�XERX��XLI�MRXIVREXMSREP�GSQQYRMX]��XLI�EGEHIQMG�PIJX��VIPMKMSYW�PIEHIVW��ERHTISTPI�SJ�KSSH[MPP�XLVSYKLSYX�XLI�[SVPH�QYWX�WXST�XV]MRK�XS�HIQSRMIERH�HIPMKMXMQEXI�XLI�.I[MWL�REXMSR�JSV�MXW�VIEWSREFPI�IJJSVXW�XS�TVSXIGX�MXWTSTYPEXMSR�[LMPI�WIIOMRK�TEVXRIVW�JSV�TIEGI��8LMW�YRXLMROMRK�ERH�SRI�WMHIH�GSRHIQREXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�LEW�MXWIPJ�FIGSQI�E�WMKRMJMGERX�FEVVMIV�XSTIEGI�

%�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�SJ�XLI�OMRH�TVSTSWIH�F]�JSVQIV�9�7��TVIWMHIRX�&MPP'PMRXSR�ERH�JSVQIV�-WVEIPM�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�)LYH�&EVEO��ERH�RS[�ETTEV�IRXP]�EGGITXIH�F]�4VMQI�1MRMWXIVW�%VMIP�7LEVSR�ERH�1ELQIH�%FFEW��%FY1EIR ��LSPHW�IRSVQSYW�TVSQMWI�JSV�FSXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�ERH�XLI-WVEIPMW�SJ�E�HIQSGVEXMG��IGSRSQMGEPP]�ZMEFPI�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�TSWIW�RS�HERKIVXS�-WVEIP¬W�WIGYVMX]��(IQSGVEGMIW�HS�RSX�KIRIVEPP]�KS�XS�[EV�EKEMRWX�IEGLSXLIV��ERH�IGSRSQMGEPP]�ZMEFPI�HIQSGVEGMIW�LEZI�VIEP�MRGIRXMZIW�XS�WIXXPIXLIMV�HMJJIVIRGIW�TIEGIJYPP]�ERH�XS�TVIZIRX�XIVVSVMWX�KVSYTW�JVSQ�STIVEXMRK[MXLMR�XLIMV�FSVHIVW��&]�EFERHSRMRK�YRVIEPMWXMG�GPEMQW�ERH�VIGSKRMMRKIEGL�SXLIV¬W�VMKLX�XS�PMZI�MR�TIEGI��-WVEIP�ERH�4EPIWXMRI�GER�FIGSQI�FIEGSRWSJ�IRPMKLXIRQIRX��TVSKVIWW��ERH�LSTI�MR�ER�MRGVIEWMRKP]�HERKIVSYW�[SVPH�

-�[VMXI�XLIWI�GPSWMRK�TEVEKVETLW�MR�E�WTMVMX�SJ�GEYXMSYW�STXMQMWQ��LEZMRKNYWX�[EXGLIH�-WVEIP¬W�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�%VMIP�7LEVSR��XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSV�MX]¬W�TVMQI�QMRMWXIV�1ELQSYH�%FFEW��.SVHER¬W�/MRK�%FHYPPEL�ERH�SYVS[R�4VIWMHIRX�+ISVKI�;��&YWL�WLEOI�LERHW�ERH�WTIEO�[SVHW�SJ�TIEGI�ERHVIGSRGMPMEXMSR�EX�%UEFE��&YX�LERHWLEOIW�EPSRI�[MPP�RSX�FVMRK�TIEGI��RSV[SVHW�VIGSRGMPMEXMSR�EJXIV�WS�QER]�HIGEHIW�SJ�FPSSHWLIH��(MJJMGYPX�ERHPSRK�XIVQ�EGXMSRW�SR�XLI�KVSYRH�[MPP�FI�RIIHIH�XS�FYMPH�QYXYEP�GSRJM�HIRGI�

3R�XLI�ZIV]�HE]�SJ�XLI�%UEFE�WYQQMX��4EPIWXMRMER�I\XVIQMWXW�ZS[IH�XSGSRXMRYI�XLI�ZMSPIRGI��EW�=EWWIV�%VEJEX�GSQTPEMRIH�XLEX�-WVEIP�LEH�SJJIVIH©RSXLMRK�XERKMFPI�ª�)ZIR�1ELQSYH�%FFEW�WIIQIH�XS�FI�TVIWIVZMRK�XLISTXMSR�SJ�HIWXVS]MRK�-WVEIP�HIQSKVETLMGEPP]�F]�VIJYWMRK�XS�EGORS[PIHKI�MXWVMKLX�XS�I\MWX�EW�E�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

3R�XLI�WEQI�HE]��WSQI�.I[MWL�WIXXPIVW�JVSQ�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�VEPPMIH�MRSTTSWMXMSR�XS�XLI�TIEGI�IJJSVXW��GEVV]MRK�WMKRW�GPEMQMRK�XLEX�©1V��&YWL¬WVSEH�QET�MW�SR�E�GSPPMWMSR�GSYVWI�[MXL�XLI�GVIEXSV¬W�VSEH�QET�ª�8LI�KSSHRI[W�MW�XLEX�ER�SZIV[LIPQMRK�QENSVMX]�SJ�-WVEIPMW��MRGPYHMRK�E�GSRWMHIVEFPI

8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0 ���

Page 254: The Case For Israel

RYQFIV�SJ�WIXXPIVW��WIIQ�TVITEVIH�XS�MQTPIQIRX�XLI�VSEH�QET��WS�PSRK�EWXLI�VSEH�PIEHW�XS�ER�IRHYVMRK�TIEGI�ERH�E�KIRYMRI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSRSRI�[MXL�E�.I[MWL�QENSVMX]��XLI�SXLIV�[MXL�ER�%VEF�QENSVMX]��%�GSRWMHIV�EFPI�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�EPWS�WIIQ�VIEH]�XS�GSQTVSQMWI�MR�XLIMRXIVIWXW�SJ�TIEGI�

-J�E�TIEGIJYP�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�[IVI�JMREPP]�XS�FIGSQI�VIEPMX]��MX�[SYPHFI�E�FPIWWMRK�JSV�EPP��&YX�MX�[SYPH�EPWS�LEZI�XVEKMG�SZIVXSRIW��WMRGI�XLMWIQMRIRXP]�VIEWSREFPI�ERH�JEMV�WSPYXMSR�GSYPH�LEZI�FIIR�EGLMIZIH�PSRK�EKSMJ�XLI�%VEF�PIEHIVWLMT��LEH�RSX�VINIGXIH�XLI�4IIP�6ITSVX�XLI�9�2��TEVXM�XMSR��ERH�XLI�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�TVSTSWEPW��7S�QER]�PMZIW�[IVI�[EWXIH�F]WS�VITIEXIH�ER�YR[MPPMRKRIWW�SR�XLI�TEVX�SJ�WS�QER]�%VEF�PIEHIVW�XS�VIG�SKRMI�XLI�VMKLX�SJ�XLI�.I[MWL�TISTPI�TIEGIJYPP]�XS�IWXEFPMWL�E�WQEPP�.I[MWLWXEXI�MR�XLSWI�TEVXW�SJ�XLI�ERGMIRX�.I[MWL�LSQIPERH�XLEX�XLI]�LEH�GYPXM�ZEXIH�ERH�SR�[LMGL�XLI]�GSRWXMXYXIH�E�GPIEV�QENSVMX]��8S�EZSMH�XLI�FPSSH]TEWX�FIGSQMRK�TVSPSKYI�]IX�EKEMR��[I�QYWX�PIEVR�JVSQ�XLI�XVEKMG�QMWXEOIWXLEX�RIIHPIWWP]�XSSO�EPP�XLIWI�PMZIW�

-�RS[�VIWX�XLI�GEWI�JSV�-WVEIP�XLEX�-�QEOI�MR�XLMW�FSSO��-�VIEPMI��LS[�IZIV��XLEX�XLI�HIJIRWI�GER�RIZIV�VIWX�[LIR�MX�GSQIW�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI��2SQEXXIV�[LEX�WXITW�-WVEIP�XEOIW�XS[EVH�TIEGI�ERH�XLI�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�XLIVI�[MPP�EP[E]W�FI�WSQI�JSV�[LSQ�RSXLMRK�WLSVX�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�HIWXVYGXMSR[MPP�WYJJMGI��*SV�XLEX�VIEWSR��-WVEIP¬W�FIWX�HIJIRWI�QYWX�VIQEMR�MXW�HIXIV�QMREXMSR�XS�WYVZMZI�ERH�MXW�EFMPMX]�XS�HIJIRH�MXW�GMXMIRW�EKEMRWX�XLSWIIEPSXW WSQI�EVQIH�[MXL�FSQFW��SXLIVW�[MXL�FMKSXV] [LS�GERRSXEFMHI�XLI�VIEPMX]�SJ�E�WXVSRK�MRHITIRHIRX�ERH�HIQSGVEXMG�.I[MWL�WXEXI�

��� 8,)�'%7)�*36�-76%)0

Page 255: The Case For Israel

-RXVSHYGXMSR��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER��©'EQTYW�,]TSGVMW]�ª

2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��3GXSFIV������������7II�GLETXIV����MR�XLMW�FSSO���7II�GLETXIV����MR�XLMW�FSSO���'LSQWO]¬W�TVIJIVIRGI�JSV�E�JIHIVEP�QSHIP

©EPSRK�=YKSWPEZ�PMRIWª�MW�EVXMGYPEXIH�MR1MHHPI�)EWX�-PPYWMSRW�3\JSVH��6S[QER�0MXXPIJMIPH������ ��TT�����§�����,MW�YWI�SJ0IFERSR�EW�E�QSHIP�GSQIW�JVSQ�E�HIFEXI[MXL�QI�MR������

��%XPERXMG�9RFSYRH�SRPMRI�TYFPMGEXMSR�SJ%XPERXMG�1SRXLP] ��-RXIVZMI[�SJ�7EMH�F],EVV]�&PSSQ��7ITXIQFIV�����������[[[�XLIEXPERXMG�GSQ�YRFSYRH�MRXIVZMI[W�FE�������LXQ�

��7II�&IRR]�1SVVMW��6MKLXISYW�:MGXMQW��2I[=SVO��:MRXEKI�&SSOW������ ��T��\MZ�

��7II�GLETXIV���MR�XLMW�FSSO���%XPERXMG�9RFSYRH�7ITXIQFIV������������7II�GLETXIV����MR�XLMW�FSSO�

���7II�GLETXIV����MR�XLMW�FSSO����7II�GLETXIVW����ERH����MR�XLMW�FSSO����7II�GLETXIV����MR�XLMW�FSSO����.EQIW�&IRRIX��©%VEJEX¬W�)HKI��:MSPIRGI�ERH

8MQI�SR�,MW�7MHI�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1EVGL���������

���&VYGI�,SJJQER��©8LI�0SKMG�SJ�7YMGMHI�8IV�VSVMWQ�ª%XPERXMG�1SRXLP]��.YRI�������T�����

���7II�GLETXIV����MR�XLMW�FSSO�

',%48)6��

-W�-WVEIP�E�'SPSRMEP��-QTIVMEPMWX�7XEXI#��©;LEX�;IRX�;VSRK#ª�%P�%LVEQ�;IIOP]

�)K]TX ��(IGIQFIV���§����������%PP�GMXIWXS%P�%LVEQ�;IIOP]EZEMPEFPI�EX�LXXT���[IIOP]�ELVEQ�SVK�IK�

��6EHMS������1E]�������������&YFIV�XS�+ERHLM��UYSXIH�MR�%VXLYV

,IVXFIVK�8LI�>MSRMWX�-HIE�4LMPEHIPTLME�.I[MWL�4YFPMGEXMSR�7SGMIX]������ ��T������

��4EYP�.SLRWSR��1SHIVR�8MQIW��8LI�;SVPHJVSQ�XLI�8[IRXMIW�XS�XLI�2MRIXMIW�2I[�=SVO�,EVTIV��6S[������ ��T������

��8LI��������.I[W�[LS�WSYKLX�VIJYKI�MR4EPIWXMRI�GSRWXMXYXIH�VSYKLP]���TIVGIRX�SJXLI�I\MWXMRK�TSTYPEXMSR��8LI�QMPPMSR�.I[W[LS�WSYKLX�VIJYKI�MR�%QIVMGE�GSRWXMXYXIH

ETTVS\MQEXIP]���TIVGIRX�SJ�XLI�I\MWXMRKTSTYPEXMSR�

��1EVXMR�+MPFIVX��8LI�6SYXPIHKI�%XPEW�SJ�XLI%VEF�-WVEIPM�'SRJPMGX���XL�)HMXMSR��0SRHSR�6SYXPIHKI�8E]PSV�*VERGMW�+VSYT������ ��T����

��'PE]XSR�1MPIW�0ILQERR��©4EPIWXMRI�ª�LXXT���[[[�YWH�IHY�IVT�4EPIWXMRI�LMWXSV]��LXQ�

��=MXGLEO�&IR�>ZM��8LI�)\MPIH�ERH�XLI6IHIIQIH�4LMPEHIPTLME��.I[MWL�4YFPMGEXMSR7SGMIX]������ ��TT����§���

��7LIMOL�%FH�%PPEL�%P�1IWLEH��©.I[W¬�%XXM�XYHIW�XS[EVH�-WPEQ�ERH�1YWPMQW�MR�XLI*MVWX�-WPEQMG�)6)�ª�UYSXIH�MR�(��*��+VIIR�IH��%VEF�8LISPSKMERW�SR�.I[W�ERH�-WVEIP�+IRIZE��)HMXMSRW�HI�P¬%ZIRMV������ �

���4EPIWXMRI�6S]EP�'SQQMWWMSR�6ITSVX��4IIP6ITSVX �0SRHSR��,MW�1ENIWX]¬W�7XEXMSREV]3JJMGI������ ��TT����§���

���.EQIW�*MRR�XS�)EVP�SJ�'PEVIRHSR��.ERYEV]��������

���.EQIW�*MRR�XS�:MWGSYRX�4EPQIVWXSR��2SZ�IQFIV���������

���.EGSF�HI�,EEW��,MWXSV]�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�2I[=SVO��1EGQMPPER������ ��T������UYSXMRKGSRXIQTSVERISYW�PIXXIV�

���;Q��8��=SYRK�XS�'SPSRIP�4EXVMGO�'EQT�FIPP��1E]����������

���;Q��8��=SYRK�XS�:MWGSYRX�4EPQIVWXSR�1E]����������

���;Q��8��=SYRK�XS�:MWGSYRX�'ERRMRK��.ERY�EV]����������

',%48)6��

(MH�)YVSTIER�.I[W�(MWTPEGI�4EPIWXMRMERW#��/IRRIXL�6��8MQQIVQER��©8ST�)K]TXMER

'PIVMG�.YWXMJMIW�8IVVSVMWQ�ª�-RWMKLX�SR�XLI2I[W�2SZIQFIV����������

��©%�'SPSRMMRK�4VSNIGX�&YMPX�SR�0MIW�ª'SYRXIV4YRGL�[[[�GSYRXIVTYRGL�SVK �%TVMP����������

��'IRXIV�JSV�4SPMG]�%REP]WMW�SR�4EPIWXMRIPYRGLISR�EHHVIWW��7XEXI�(ITEVXQIRX�FVMIJ�MRK��*IHIVEP�2I[W�7IVZMGI��.ERYEV]���������

��-RXIVZMI[�[MXL�(EZMH�&EVWEQMER�SJ�%PXIVRE�XMZI�6EHMS��©-WVEIP��XLI�,SPSGEYWX��ERH�%RXM�7IQMXIW�ª�3GXSFIV�����������MR�2SEQ'LSQWO]��'LVSRMGPIW�SJ�(MWWIRX�1SRVSI�1I���'SQQSR�'SYVEKI�4VIWW������ �

���

238)7

Page 256: The Case For Israel

��1EVO�8[EMR��8LI�-RRSGIRXW�%FVSEH�2I[=SVO��3\JSVH�9RMZIVWMX]�4VIWW������ ��TT�������������������§����

��)JVEMQ�/EVWL��*EFVMGEXMRK�-WVEIPM�,MWXSV]�XLI�©2I[�,MWXSVMERWª�0SRHSR��*VERO�'EWW����� ��TT���§��

��)XLER�&VSRRIV��&SSO�6IZMI[��2I[�=SVO8MQIW�2SZIQFIV�����������7MRGI�%VEJEX[EPOIH�E[E]�JVSQ�XLI�&EVEO�'PMRXSR�TIEGISJJIVW�EX�'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�8EFE�MR����§������1SVVMW�LEW�[VMXXIR�QSVI�GVMXM�GEPP]�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW��[LMPI�WXMPP�GVMXMGM�MRK�QER]�-WVEIPM�TSPMGMIW��EGXMSRW��ERHHIGMWMSRW��7II�&IRR]�1SVVMW��©8LI�6INIG�XMSR�ª2I[�6ITYFPMG��%TVMP���§���������

��1SVVMW��T��������5YSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T������

���%FVELEQ�+VERSXX��8LI�0ERH�7]WXIQ�MR4EPIWXMRI��,MWXSV]�ERH�7XVYGXYVI�0SRHSR�)]VI��7TSXXMW[SSHI������ ��T������

���)H[EVH�7EMH�ERH�'LVMWXSTLIV�,MXGLIRW��IHW��&PEQMRK�XLI�:MGXMQW��0SRHSR��:IVWS������ �

���7LEFXEM�8IZIXL��(EZMH�&IR�+YVMSR�ERH�XLI4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW�2I[�=SVO��3\JSVH�9RM�ZIVWMX]�4VIWW������ ��T�����

���.EQEP�,YWWIMRM��*IFVYEV]����������UYSXIHMR�%VMIL�%ZRIVM��8LI�'PEMQ�SJ�(MWTSWWIWWMSR�2I[�&VYRW[MGO��8VERWEGXMSR�&SSOW����� ��T�����

���1��7LELMH�%PEQ��©%�'SPSRMMRK�&YMPX�SR0MIW�ª'SYRXIVTYRGL�[[[�GSYRXIVTYRGL�SVK��%TVMP����������

���.EQIW�4EVOIW��;LSWI�0ERH#�%�,MWXSV]�SJ�XLI4ISTPIW�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�2I[�=SVO��8ETPMRKIV����� ��T������

���%ZRIVM��T�������.EQIW�*MRR�XS�XLI�)EVP�SJ�'PEVIRHSR��7IT�

XIQFIV�������������-FMH����.��&��*SVW]XL��%�*I[�1SRXLW�MR�XLI�)EWX

�5YIFIG��.��0SZIPP������ ��T���������,��&��8VMWXVEQ��8LI�0ERH�SJ�-WVEIP��%�.SYV�

REP�SJ�8VEZIPW�MR�4EPIWXMRI�0SRHSR��7SGMIX]JSV�4VSQSXMRK�'LVMWXMER�/RS[PIHKI����� ��T������

���7EQYIP�&EVXPIXX��*VSQ�)K]TX�XS�4EPIWXMRI�2I[�=SVO��,EVTIV������ ��T�������'MXIH�MR*VIH�+SXXLIMP��©8LI�4STYPEXMSR�SJ�4EPIW�XMRI��'MVGE������ª�1MHHPI�)EWXIVR�7XYHMIW�ZSP������RS�����3GXSFIV������

���)H[EVH�;MPWSR��-R�7GVMTXYVI�0ERHW�2I[=SVO��'��7GVMFRIV¬W������ ��T�������'MXIH�MR+SXXLIMP�

���;��%PPIR��8LI�(IEH�7IE��%�2I[�6SYXI�XS-RHME�0SRHSR������ ��T������'MXIH�MR+SXXLIMP�

���;MPPMEQ�8LSQWSR��8LI�0ERH�ERH�XLI�&SSO�2I[�=SVO��,EVTIV�&VSW������� ��T������'MXIH�MR�+SXXLIMP�

���6IZIVIRH�7EQYIP�1ERRMRK��8LSWI�,SP]*MIPHW�0SRHSR��8LI�6IPMKMSYW�8VEGX�7SGM�IX]������ ��TT����§���

���6SHIVMG�,��(EZMWSR��6IJSVQ�MR�XLI3XXSQER�)QTMVI��4VMRGIXSR��4VMRGIXSR9RMZIVWMX]�4VIWW������ �T������GMXMRK�E�1YW�PMQ�[VMXIV�MR������

���1SVVMW��T�������-FMH����.SLR�0I[MW�&YVGOLEVHX��8VEZIPW�MR�7]VME

ERH�XLI�,SP]�0ERH��2I[�=SVO��%17�4VIWW����� ��T������

���7II�GLETXIV���MR�XLMW�FSSO����8LI�VIWIEVGL�SJ�E�*VIRGL�KISKVETLIV��:MXEP

'YMRGX�EVI�VIPMIH�SR�JSV�XLMW�GSRGPYWMSR��7II.SER�4IXIVW��*VSQ�8MQI�-QQIQSVMEP��'LM�GEKS��./%4�4YFPMGEXMSRW������ ��4IXIVW¬WGSRGPYWMSRW�ERH�HEXE�LEZI�FIIR�GLEPPIRKIH�7II�7EMH�ERH�,MXGLIRW��T������-�HS�RSX�MRER]�[E]�VIP]�SR�XLIQ�MR�XLMW�FSSO�

���%��(VY]ERS[��/IXEZMQ�0IXSPHSX�,MFFEX>M]]SR�:I�=MWLWLYZ�)VI�=MWVE¬IP�;VMXMRKWSR�XLI�LMWXSV]�SJ�,MFFEX�>M]]SR�ERH�XLI�WIX�XPIQIRX�SJ�XLI�PERH�SJ�-WVEIP ��3HIWWE��8IP%ZMZ������������������ ��ZSP�����TT����§���

���)VRWX�*VEROIRWXIMR��.YWXMGI�JSV�Q]�4ISTPI�0SRHSR��2MGLSPWSR��;EXWSR������ ��T������

���6ITSVX�F]�,MW�&VMXERRMG�1ENIWX]¬W�+SZIVR�QIRX�XS�XLI�'SYRGMP�SJ�XLI�0IEKYI�SJ�2EXMSRWSR�XLI�%HQMRMWXVEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�ERH8VERW�.SVHER�JSV�XLI�=IEV�������'SPSRMEP�2S������TT�����§����

���5YSXIH�MR�4IXIVW��T��������/MRK�%FHYPPEL�SJ�.SVHER��1]�1IQSMVW�'SQ�

TPIXIH�,EVSPH�;��+PMHHIR��XVERW���0SRHSR�0SRKQER������ ��TT����§���

',%48)6��

;EW�XLI�>MSRMWX�1SZIQIRX�E�4PSX�XS'SPSRMI�%PP�SJ4EPIWXMRI#��8LI�5YIWXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�2I[�=SVO��:MR�

XEKI�&SSOW�������IH� ��T�������0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV����

������ZMHISXETI ���1SVVMW��T�������-FMH���-FMH���T�������-FMH���-FMH���-FMH���TT����§���

',%48)6��

;EW�XLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�&MRHMRK-RXIVREXMSREP�0E[#��8LI�5YIWXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI��2I[�=SVO��:MR�

XEKI�&SSOW�������IH� ��TT����§���

��� 238)7

Page 257: The Case For Israel

��©;L]�;I¬VI�SR�XLI�7MHI�SJ�.YWXMGI�ª�7YR�HE]�1EMP�%YWXVEPME ��%TVMP���������

��1SVVMW��T�������-FMH���T�������-FMH���-FMH���T�������-FMH���T�������4IIP�6ITSVX�T��������-FMH��T�����

���-FMH��T��������-FMH��T��������5YSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T��������.SVHERMER�REXMSREPMX]�PE[��%VXMGPI���� �SJ

0E[�2S�����ERH�3JJMGMEP�+EIXXI�RS�������*IFVYEV]����������

���4IIP�6ITSVX�T���������5YSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T��������;EPXIV�0EUYIYV�ERH�&EVV]�6YFMR��8LI

-WVEIP�%VEF�6IEHIV��XL�)HMXMSR��2I[=SVO��4IRKYMR������ ��T�����

���-FMH�

',%48)6��

;IVI�XLI�.I[W�9R[MPPMRK�XS�7LEVI�4EPIWXMRI#��8LI�5YIWXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�TT����§�����-FMH���T��������1SVVMW��T�������-FMH���T�������5YSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T�������1SVVMW��T���������-�YWI�ERXM�7IQMXMWQ�MR�MXW�SVMKMREP�QIERMRK

EW�LEXVIH�SJ�.I[W�MR�TEVXMGYPEV��RSX�7IQMXIWMR�KIRIVEP�

��5YSXIH�MR�4IXIVW��T�������0IXXIV�JVSQ�,YWWIMRM�XS�XLI�1MRMWXIV�JSV

*SVIMKR�%JJEMVW�SJ�,YRKEV]��.YRI�������������1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T��������7II�XIWXMQSR]�UYSXIH�MR4IIP�6ITSVX��T���������-FMH����1SVVMW��T���������-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������4IIP�6ITSVX�T��������1SVVMW��T�������%W�MJ�XS�WYKKIWX�WSQI�QSVEP

IUYMZEPIRGI��1SVVMW�VITSVXW�XLEX�����%VEFW[IVI�OMPPIH��&YX�QSWX�[IVI�EVQIH�TIVTIXVE�XSVW�OMPPIH�F]�XLI�TSPMGI��RSX�YREVQIH�MRRSGIRX�GMZMPMERW��WII�4IIP�6ITSVX�T�����

���1SVVMW��UYSXMRK�7MV�.SLR�'LERGIPPSV��T���������4IIP�6ITSVX�T��������;LEXIZIV�XLI�LMKL�GSQQMWWMSRIV��[LS�[EW

ER�SZIVX�ERXM�>MSRMWX��QE]�LEZI�XLSYKLX�SJXLI�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR��MX�[EW�EX�XLMW�XMQIFMRHMRK�MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[��[LMGL�GSYPH�RSXYRMPEXIVEPP]�FI�EFVSKEXIH�F]�XLI�&VMXMWL�IZIR�XLSYKL�XLI]�LEH�MRMXMEXIH�MX��

',%48)6��

,EZI�XLI�.I[W�%P[E]W�6INIGXIH�XLI�8[S�7XEXI�7SPYXMSR#��©'ER�>MSRMWQ�&I�6IGSRGMPIH�[MXL�.YWXMGI

JSV�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW#ª�8MOOYR�.YP]§%YKYWX�����

��©1MHHPI�)EWX�(MTPSQEG]��'SRXMRYMXMIW�ERH'LERKI�ª>QEKEMRI��(IGIQFIV������EZEMPEFPI�EX�[[[�QEK�SVK�GLSQWO]��PEWXZMWMXIH�1EVGL��������� �

��0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV���������

��4IIP�6ITSVX�T�������-FMH���TT�����§������-FMH���T�������-FMH���T�������-FMH���TT�����§������-FMH���T������

���-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������-FMH���TT�����§�������-FMH���T���������-FMH���TT�����§�������-FMH���T���������-FMH���T�������UYIWXMSR�XS�XLI�KVERH�QYJXM�ERH

LMW�ERW[IV����-ER�&MGOIVXSR�ERH�'EVPE�/PEYWRIV��%�'SR�

GMWI�,MWXSV]�SJ�XLI�%VEF�-WVEIPM�'SRJPMGX�9TTIV�7EHHPI�6MZIV��2�.���4VIRXMGI�,EPP����� ��T�����

���-FMH�����4IIP�6ITSVX�T���������1MGLEIP�3VIR��7M\�(E]W�SJ�;EV�3\JSVH�

3\JSVH�9RMZIVWMX]�4VIWW������ ��T�����

',%48)6��

,EZI�XLI�.I[W�)\TPSMXIH�XLI�,SPSGEYWX#��2SVQER�+��*MROIPWXIMR��8LI�,SPSGEYWX

-RHYWXV]��6IJPIGXMSRW�SJ�XLI�)\TPSMXEXMSR�SJ.I[MWL�7YJJIVMRK�0SRHSR��:IVWS������ �

��5YSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T��������1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T��������5YSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T��������1SVVMW��TT�������������7EVEL�,SRMK��©*MIRHMWL�,]TSGVMW]�--��8LI

1ER�JVSQ�/PSTWXSGO�7X��ª�.IVYWEPIQ�4SWX�%TVMP���������

��+IVQER]��%YW[nVXMKIW�%QX���(SGYQIRXW�SR+IVQER�*SVIMKR�4SPMG]������§������JVSQ�XLI%VGLMZIW�SJ�XLI�+IVQER�*SVIMKR�1MRMWXV]�WIVMIW�(��ZSP��<---��RS��������;EWLMRKXSR�(�'���9�7��+SZIVRQIRX�4VMRXMRK�3JJMGI����� ��TT�����§�����'MXIH�EX�[[[�TW]GL�YTIRR�IHY�bJNKMP�QYJXMLMXPIV�LXQ�

��7II�>ZM�)PTIPIK��8LI�+VERH�1YJXM��0SR�HSR��*VERO�'EWW������ ��T������

238)7 ���

Page 258: The Case For Israel

���-XEQEV�1EVGYW��©2EM�%PPI]��,ENN�%QIR�%P,YWWIMRM�-W�%VEJEX¬W�«,IVS�¬�ª�4EPIWXMRMER1IHME� ;EXGL�� [[[�TQ[�SVK�MP�RI[�FYPPIXMRW��������LXQP�

���7EMH�ERH�,MXGLIRW��T����������-FMH����1SVVMW��T���������-FMH���T���������4%�RI[WTETIV��%P�,E]EX�%P�.EHIIHE�7IT�

XIQFIV������������)PTIPIK��T���������1EVXMR�+MPFIVX��;MRWXSR�7��'LYVGLMPP�ZSP�

:--��0SRHSR��,IMRIQERR������ ��TT��������

���©«(MEPSKYI�SJ�'MZMPMEXMSRW�7IIOW�-RXIV�REXMSREP�(IQSGVEG]�¬�7XEXIW�4VIWMHIRX/LEXEQM�8ILVER��*IFVYEV]����������ªJVSQ�XLI�[IFWMXI�SJ�XLI�-RXIVREXMSREP�'IRXVI�JSV�(MEPSKYI�EQSRK�'MZMPMEXMSRW�[[[�HMEPSKYIGIRXVI�SVK�RI[WCHIXEMP���LXQ�

���1SVVMW��T��������-FMH����)PMI�/IHSYVMI��UYSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T�������1SVVMW��T��������%PER�(IVWLS[MX��7LSYXMRK�*MVI�'MZMP�0MF�

IVXMIW�MR�E�8YVFYPIRX�%KI�&SWXSR��0MXXPI�&VS[R������ ��TT����§���

���0SRHSR�8MQIW�(IGIQFIV������������4IIP�6ITSVX�T������

',%48)6��

;EW�XLI�9�2��4EVXMXMSR�4PER�9RJEMV�XS�4EPIWXMRMERW#��-R�ER�MRXIVZMI[�MR�,E¬EVIX[MXL�NSYVREPMWX

%VM�7LEZMX��©1]�6MKLX�SJ�6IXYVR�ª�%YKYWX���������

��-R�ER�MRXIVZMI[�[MXL�&IPKMER�NSYVREPMWX�&EY�HSMR�0SSW��©%R�-RXIVZMI[�SJ�-PER�4ETTI�ª0I�7SMV�&IPKMYQ ��2SZIQFIV����������

��*EMWEP�&SHM��©-WVEIP�7YVIP]�,EW�2S�6MKLX�XS)\MWX�ª8LI�+YEVHMER�.ERYEV]���������8LMW�ZMI[�MW�EPWS�VIJPIGXIH�MR�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER2EXMSREP�'SZIRERX�SJ������

��7II�GLETXIV���MR�XLMW�FSSO�

',%48)6��

;IVI�.I[W�E�1MRSVMX]�MR�;LEX�&IGEQI�-WVEIP#��©%�;SVPH�;MHI�-RXMJEHE#�;L]#ª�'SYRXIV�

4YRGL�[[[�GSYRXIVTYRGL�SVK�GSSO�����LXQP��PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP�������� �

��©-WVEIP��*MZI�(IGEHIW�SJ�4MPPEKI�ERH�)XLRMG'PIERWMRK�ª�1EV\MWQ�%PMZI�;IFWMXI��[[[�QEV\MWQEPMZI�SVK�MWVEIPJMZI��LXQP��PEWX�ZMW�MXIH�%TVMP�������� �

��8LI�WEQI�[SYPH�FI�XVYI�SJ�XLI�4IIP�'SQ�QMWWMSR�TVSTSWEP��2SVQER�+��*MROIPWXIMR�

ER�ERXM�>MSRMWX�TSPIQMGMWX��EVKYIW�XLEX�©XLISRP]�KIVQERI�HIQSKVETLMG�GSQTEVMWSRWEVI�FIX[IIR�XLI�%VEF�ERH�.I[MWL�TSTYPE�XMSRW�MR�EPP�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�ERH��EVKYEFP]�FIX[IIR�XLI�%VEF�ERH�.I[MWL�TSTYPEXMSRW�MRXLI�VIKMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�XLEX�PEXIV�FIGEQI-WVEIP�ª�IQTLEWMW�EHHIH �7EMH�ERH�,MXGLIRWEX�T������8LMW�MW�JEPWI��*SV�TYVTSWIW�SJ�EWWIWW�MRK�XLI�JEMVRIWW�SJ�XLI�9�2��4EVXMXMSR�MR������XLI�VIPIZERX�GSQTEVMWSR�MW�FIX[IIR.I[MWL�ERH�%VEF�TSTYPEXMSRW�MR�XLI�EVIEEPPSGEXIH�XS�XLI�.I[MWL�WXEXI�F]�XLEX�TEVXMXMSR�8LI�JEGX�XLEX�-WVEIP�KEMRIH�QSVI�XIVVMXSV]EJXIV�FIMRK�EXXEGOIHF]�%VEF�EVQMIW�ERH4EPIWXMRMER�JMKLXIVW�MW�RSX�VIPIZERX�XS�XLIJEMVRIWW�SJ�XLI�SVMKMREP�TEVXMXMSR�TPER��

',%48)6���

,EW�-WVEIPtW�:MGXMQMEXMSR�SJXLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�&IIR�XLI�4VMQEV]�'EYWI�SJXLI�%VEFi-WVEIPM�'SRJPMGX#��-RXIVZMI[�MR�,E¬EVIX[MXL�%VM�7LEZMX��©1]

6MKLX�XS�6IXYVR�ª�%YKYWX������������)PTIPIK��TT����§�����7IVQSR�FVSEHGEWX�SR�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]

6EHMS��%TVMP�����������VIPIEWIH�MR�E�VITSVXJVSQ�XLI�-WVEIPM�4VMQI�1MRMWXIV¬W�3JJMGIERH�GMXIH�MR�XLI�&SWXSR�+PSFI�.YRI���������

��5YSXIH�MR�2MWWMQ�6EXPEZ�/EX��©.SWITL¬W-RLIVMXERGI�ª2EXMSREP�6IZMI[�%YKYWX���������ERH�'LEVPIW�%��6EHMR��©7EGVIH�7MXIW'EYKLX�MR�,MWXSVMG�'SRJPMGX�ª�&SWXSR�+PSFI�.YRI����������

��7II�GLETXIV����SJ�XLMW�FSSO���©*MJX]�=IEVW�SJ�(MWTSWWIWWMSR�ª�%P�%LVEQ

;IIOP]�1E]��§�����������2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1E]������������%W�UYSXIH�F]�=IHMH]E�%XPEW��©%VEJEX¬W�7IGVIX

%KIRHE�MW�XS�;IEV�-WVEIPMW�3YX�ª�-RWMKLXSR�XLI�2I[W��%TVMP����������T������8LI�MRGM�HIRX�[EW�SVMKMREPP]�VITSVXIH�F]�XLI�2SV[I�KMER�HEMP]�(EKIR ERH�[MHIP]�UYSXIHXLIVIEJXIV�

��%W�UYSXIH�F]�7IREXSV�;EVVIR�6YHQER��EX�ELIEVMRK�SJ�XLI�'SQQIVGI��.YWXMGI��7XEXI�ERH�.YHMGMEV]�7YFGSQQMXXII�SJ�XLI�7IREXI%TTVSTVMEXMSRW�'SQQMXXII��%TVMP����������

',%48)6���

;EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ-RHITIRHIRGI)\TERWMSRMWX�%KKVIWWMSR#��©>MSRMWX�8LIWIW�ERH�%RXM�8LIWIW�ª�8LI

4EPIWXMRI�'LVSRMGPI�2SZIQFIV����������[[[�TEPIWXMRIGLVSRMGPI�GSQ�EVXMGPI�TLT#WXSV]!������������������PEWX�ZMWMXIH%TVMP�������� �

��� 238)7

Page 259: The Case For Israel

��%WWSGMEXIH�4VIWW�VITSVX�TYFPMWLIH�MR�8LI1SVRMRK�'EPP�%PPIRXS[R��4E���1E]���������

��1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���-FMH���T��������7EMH�ERH�,MXGLIRW��T��������1SVVMW���T��������-FMH���-FMH���T������

���-FMH���TT�����§����

',%48)6���

(MH�-WVEIP�'VIEXI�XLI�%VEF�6IJYKII�4VSFPIQ#��©'EPPMRK�E�7TEHI�E�7TEHI�ª�%P�%LVEQ

;IIOP]�7ITXIQFIV��§�����������-R�ER�MRXIVZMI[�MR�,E¬EVIX[MXL�%VM�7LEZMX�

©1]�6MKLX�XS�6IXYVR�ª�%YKYWX������������0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV����

�������1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T��������%W�[I�[MPP�WII��XLI�VEVI�MRWXERGIW�MR�[LMGL

%VEF�GMZMPMERW�LEZI�FIIR�XEVKIXIH�[IVI�TIV�TIXVEXIH�RSX�F]�XLI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]�FYX�F]MVVIKYPEVW�ERH�TEVEQMPMXEV]�KVSYTW�XLEX�[IVITYX�SYX�SJ�FYWMRIWW�SRGI�XLI�-WVEIPM�EVQ]EWWYQIH�GSRXVSP�SZIV�XLI�HIJIRWI�SJ�-WVEIP�

��1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T��������-FMH�

���0EVV]�'SPPMRW�ERH�(SQMRMUYI�0ETMIVVI��3�.IVYWEPIQ�2I[�=SVO��7MQSR��7GLYWXIV����� ��T������

���4IIP�6ITSVX�T���������1SVVMW��T���������-FMH���T���������1EVXMR�+MPFIVX��-WVEIP��%�,MWXSV]�2I[

=SVO��;MPPMEQ�1SVVS[�ERH�'S������� ��T�����

���1SVVMW��T���������-FMH���T�������3VMKMREP�VITSVXW�TPEGIH�XLI

RYQFIV�SJ�HIEH�EW�LMKL�EW������FYX�XLMWRYQFIV�[EW��MX�XYVRIH�SYX��ER�I\EKKIVEXMSR�

���7II�9VM�1MPWXIMR��,MWXSV]�SJ�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ-RHITIRHIRGI�ZSP��-:�IH��F]�%PER�7EGOW�0ERLEQ��1H���9RMZIVWMX]�4VIWW�SJ�%QIVMGE����� ��T������

���1SVVMW��T���������&&'�6ITSVX��-WVEIP�ERH�XLI�%VEFW��8LI���

=IEV�'SRJPMGX����-FMH����1SVVMW��T���������8LIVI�[IVI�SXLIV�ITMWSHIW�MRZSPZMRK�MRHM�

ZMHYEPW�ERH�TEVEQMPMXEV]�KVSYTW�MR�[LMGLGPEMQW�SJ�QEWWEGVI�[IVI�QEHI��FYX�RSRI�SJXLI�WGEPI�ERH�WIVMSYWRIWW�SJ�(IMV�=EWWMR�

���1SVVMW��T���������-FMH���T���������&IRR]�1SVVMW��8LI�&MVXL�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER

6IJYKII�4VSFPIQ �8LI�&MVXL �'EQFVMHKI�'EQFVMHKI�9RMZIVWMX]�4VIWW������ ��TT����§����

���-FMH���T���������-FMH����-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV����

��������5YSXIH�MR�4IXIVW��T��������©%FY�1EIR�'LEVKIW�XLEX�XLI�%VEF�7XEXIW

%VI�XLI�'EYWI�SJ�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�6IJYKII4VSFPIQ�ª�;EPP�7XVIIX�.SYVREP�.YRI��������

���4IXIV�(SHH��6MZIV�;MXLSYX�&VMHKIW��&IMVYX�-RWXMXYXI�JSV�4EPIWXMRI�7XYHMIW������ ��T�����EW�UYSXIH�MR�4IXIVW��T������R�����

���'MXIH�MR�4IXIVW��T��������+IRIVEP�%WWIQFP]�SJJMGMEP�VIGSVHW���VH�WIW�

WMSR��WYTTPIQIRX�RS������%���� ��4EVMW�������T�����

���1SVVMW��T���������5YSXIH�MR�4IXIVW��T��������5YSXIH�MR�4IXIVW��T��������1SVVMW��T���������-FMH����6YXL�0ETMHSXL��©0IKEP�%WTIGXW�SJ�XLI�4EPIW�

XMRMER�6IJYKII�5YIWXMSR�ª�.IVYWEPIQ�'IR�XIV�JSV�4YFPMG�%JJEMVW��RS����������)PYP������[[[�NGTE�SVK�NP�ZT����LXQ�

���7II�[[[�YRLGV�GL��3JJMGI�SJ�XLI�,MKL'SQQMWWMSRIV�JSV�,YQER�6MKLXW �ERH[[[�YR�SVK�YRV[E�MRHI\�LXQP��9RMXIH2EXMSRW�6IPMIJ�ERH�;SVOW�%KIRG] �

���)VMO�7GLIGXIV��©(MZMHIH�6IWTSRWMFMPMXMIW�8LI�9�2��ERH�XLI�6IJYKIIW�ª�8LI�.IVY�WEPIQ�6ITSVX�.ERYEV]�����������92,'6�©;LS�-W�E�6IJYKII#ª�EZEMPEFPI�EX[[[�YRLGV�SVK��PEWX�ZMWMXIH�1EVGL�������� ��GMXMRK�XLI������'SRZIRXMSR�6IPEX�MRK�XS�XLI�7XEXYW�SJ�6IJYKIIW��926;%�©;LS�-W�E�4EPIWXMRMER�6IJYKII#ª�EZEMPEFPI�EX[[[�YR�SVK��YRV[E�VIJYKIIW�TP�LXQ��PEWXZMWMXIH�1EVGL��������� �

���%WWSGMEXIH�4VIWW�MRXIVZMI[�[MXL�/MRK�,YW�WIMR�SJ�.SVHER��.ERYEV]�������UYSXIH�MR4IXIVW��T�����

���(EZMH�+��0MXXQER��©8LI�*SVKSXXIR6IJYKIIW�ª2EXMSREP�6IZMI[�(IGIQFIV��������

���,S[EVH�7EGLEV��%�,MWXSV]�SJ�-WVEIP�2I[=SVO��/RSTJ������ ��TT�����§����

����5YSXIH�MR�4IXIVW��TT����§������(ERMIP�(SVSR��©4EPIWXMRMER�0MIW�ERH�;IWX�

IVR�'SQTPMGMX]�ª�2EXMSREP�6IZMI[��%YKYWX���������

238)7 ���

Page 260: The Case For Israel

���&IVREVH�'ETPER��©1YWPMQW�%PWS�8EVKIXIH.IVYWEPIQ¬W�'LVMWXMERW�ª6MGLQSRH�4SWX�(MWTEXGL�.YRI����������

',%48)6���

(MH�-WVEIP�7XEVX�XLI�7M\i(E]�;EV#��©-RXIVREXMSREP�'SQQYRMX]�&EVKEMRW�[MXL

6MKLXW�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�ª�%JXIRTSWXIR�2SV�[IKMER�HEMP] ��TSWXIH�SR�XLI�[IF�WMXI�SJ7TIGXVII�QEKEMRI��[[[�WTIGXVIMRI�SVK�[EV�4EPIWXMRI��PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP�������� �

��3VIR��T�������-FMH���T�������1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T��������5YSXIH�MR�3VIR��T��������1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T��������3VIR��T�����

���-FMH���T��������-FMH���T��������-FMH���T��������-FMH���TT�����§�������-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������-FMH���TT�����§����

',%48)6���

;EW�XLI�-WVEIPM�3GGYTEXMSR�[MXLSYX�.YWXMJMGEXMSR#��-R�E�PIXXIV�HIJIRHMRK�XLI�ERXM�-WVEIP�HSGY�

QIRXEV]�SJ�&VMXMWL�NSYVREPMWX�.SLR�4MPKIV�©0IXXIV��*EYPXPIWW�*MPQ�ª�8LI�-RHITIRHIRX�&VMXEMR ��7ITXIQFIV����������

��©;EV�SR�8IVVSVMWQ�SV�-PPIKEP�3GGYTEXMSR#ª;EV�8MQIW�2I[WTETIV�[[[�[EV�XMQIW�SVK�THJ�TEPIWXMRI�������THJ��PEWX�ZMWMXIH%TVMP�������� �

��9�2��7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP��6IWSPYXMSR�����2SZIQFIV����������

��1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���-FMH���-FMH���%FFE�)FER��%FFE�)FER�2I[�=SVO��6ER�

HSQ�,SYWI������ ��T��������0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV����

�����

',%48)6���

;EW�XLI�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV�-WVEIPtW�*EYPX#��0EUYIYV�ERH�6YFMR��T��������©8LI�7TMVMX�SJ�3GXSFIV�ª�%P�%LVEQ�;IIOP]

�)K]TX ��3GXSFIV��§�����������1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T������

��5YSXIH�MR�1SVVMW��T��������1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T��������5YSXIH�MR�0EUYIYV�ERH�6YFMR��T��������-FMH���T������

���1SVVMW��T���������8SQ�1EWPERH��©2IPWSR�1ERHIPE��8LI

9�7�%��-W�E�8LVIEX�XS�;SVPH�4IEGI�ª2I[W[IIO�7ITXIQFIV����������

���1SVVMW��T������

',%48)6���

,EW�-WVEIP�1EHI�7IVMSYW�)JJSVXW�EX�4IEGI#��©-WVEIP�7LEVTIRW�-XW�%\I�ª�'SYRXIV4YRGL�

.YP]�����������[[[�GSYRXIVTYRGL�SVK�WEMHE\I�LXQP���PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP�������� �

��0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV���������

��1SVVMW��T��������0EUYIYV�ERH�6YFMR��TT�����§������1SVVMW��TT�����§������6ITSVX��.I[W��-WVEIP�ERH�4IEGI�MR�4EPIWXMRMER

7GLSSP�8I\XFSSOW�[[[�IHYQI�SVK�VITSVXW�����LXQ�

��7II�-XQEV�1EVGYW��©4EPIWXMRI�1IHME�;EXGL6ITSVX�����ª�.YP]����������EZEMPEFPI�EX[[[�TQ[�SVK�MP�VITSVX����LXQP�

��1SVVMW��T��������-FMH���T������

���©-R������XLI�-WVEIPMW�OMPPIH�JI[IV�4EPIWXMRM�ERW EFSYX���� XLER�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�HMHXLIQWIPZIW EFSYX�����ª�7II�1SVVMW��T������

���)TLVEMQ�=EEV�ERH�8EQEV�,IQVERR��©4IEGI-RHI\��1SWX�-WVEIPMW�7YTTSVX�%XXEGO�SR-VEU�ª,E¬EVIX��1EVGL���������

���8LSQEW�*VMIHQER��2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��1EVGL����������

���7IVKI�7GLQIQERR��©1MHIEWX�8YVQSMP��8LI8EPOW�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1EVGL����������

���8LSQEW�*VMIHQER��©8LI�,EVH�8VYXL�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��%TVMP���������

���©'PMRXSR�1MRYXIW�ª�,E¬EVIX�(IGIQFIV���������

���-FMH����&IRR]�1SVVMW��©'EQT�(EZMH�ERH�%JXIV��%R

)\GLERKI���� �%R�-RXIVZMI[�[MXL�)LYH&EVEO�ª2I[�=SVO�6IZMI[�SJ�&SSOW�.YRI���������

���0EUYIYV�ERH�6YFMR��TT�����§�������%PER�(IVWLS[MX��;L]�8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOW

�2I[�,EZIR��'SRR���=EPI�9RMZIVWMX]�4VIWW����� ��T������/LEPIH�%FY�8SEQIL��©,S[XLI�;EV�&IKER�ª�.IVYWEPIQ�4SWX�7ITXIQFIV���������

���+YEVHMER�0SRHSR ��.ERYEV]�������������.SIP�&VMROPI]��%TVMP������������5YSXIH�MR�;L]�8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOW�T�����

��� 238)7

Page 261: The Case For Israel

���2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�UYSXIH�MR�;L]�8IVVSVMWQ;SVOW�TT����§���

���7GSXX�%XVER��©;LS�;ERXW�XS�FI�E�1EVX]V�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1E]����������T��%���

���;L]�8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOW�T��������-FMH��T��������-FMH����-FMH�

',%48)6���

;EW�%VEJEX�6MKLX�MR�8YVRMRK�(S[R�XLI&EVEOi'PMRXSR�4IEGI�4VSTSWEP#��©8LI�-RJIVREP�7GETIKSEX�ª�7ITXIQFIV����

������[[[�QMHIEWX[IF�SVK�MRJIVREPWGETI�KSEX�LXQP�

��0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV���������

��1��/SRHVEGOI��©4S[IPP�7LSYPH�8IPP�%VEJEX�«-X¬W�2S[�SV�2IZIV�¬ª6SPP�'EPP�%TVMP���������

��)PWE�;EPWL��©8LI�4VMRGI�ª�8LI�2I[�=SVOIV�1EVGL�����������T�����

��.EQIW�&IRRIX��©7OMTTIV�8MIW�'EVKS�XS%VEJEX¬W�+VSYT�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�.ERYEV]��������

��8LI�UYSXI�MW�;EPWL¬W�HIWGVMTXMSR�SJ�[LEX&ERHEV�[EW�WLS[R�F]�XLI�%QIVMGER�RIKS�XMEXSVW�

��8LI�2I[�=SVOIV�1EVGL�����������T�������-FMH���TT�����������-FMH���T�����

���-FMH����-FMH���T��������-FMH���T��������&IRR]�1SVVMW��©6INIGXMSR�ª�8LI�2I[

6ITYFPMG�%TVMP���§����������T�����

',%48)6���

;L]�,EZI�1SVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�8LER�-WVEIPMW�&IIR�/MPPIH#��3R�'22¬W�'VSWWJMVI�%TVMP����������MR

VIWTSRWI�XS�GSQQIRXW�QEHI�F]�6IZ��.IVV]*EP[IPP�

��©1MHIEWX�4IEGI�:MWMSRW�7LEVIH�ª�8LI�.SYV�REP�2I[W��;IWXGLIWXIV�'SYRX]��2�=� �1EVGL����������UYSXMRK�%FFEW�,EQMHIL�GSGLEMVQER�SJ�XLI�2I[�=SVO§2I[�.IVWI]FVERGL�SJ�XLI�%P�%[HE�4EPIWXMRI�6MKLX�XS6IXYVR�'SEPMXMSR�

��%NYVM�Z��-�(�*��'SQQERHIV��,'.��-WVEIPM7YTVIQI�'SYVX ����������7ITXIQFIV��������

��&VYGI�,SJJQER��©8LI�0SKMG�SJ�7YMGMHI8IVVSVMWQ�ª%XPERXMG�1SRXLP]��.YRI������T�����

��©8LI�%QFYPERGI§,SQMGMHI�8LISV]�ª�2I[

=SVO�8MQIW�1EKEMRI�(IGIQFIV����������T�����

��.IVYWEPIQ�4SWX�%TVMP������������.IVYWEPIQ�4SWX�1E]������������'LMGEKS�8VMFYRI�%TVMP�����������)PPMW�7LYQER��+IVQER�8:��©1SLEQIH�%�

(YVE�0MOIP]�/MPPIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�+YRJMVI�ª7II�EPWS��.EQIW�*EPPS[W��©;LS�7LSX1SLEQQIH�%P�(YVE�ª�%XPERXMG�1SRXLP]�.YRI�������T�����

���5YSXIH�MR�.IER�)PWLXEMR��.YWX�;EV�EKEMRWX8IVVSV�2I[�=SVO��&EWMG�&SSOW������ �T�����

���-FMH����(EZMH�*��+VIIR��©*MKLXMRK�F]�XLI�&SSO�ª

&SWXSR�+PSFI�%TVMP�������������-FMH��-(*�9THEXI��.YRI�������������(ER�6EHPEYIV��-'8�%WWSGMEXI��©8LI�«%P�

%UWE�-RXMJEHE¬��%R�)RKMRIIVIH�8VEKIH]�ª.YRI�����������YTHEXIH�.ERYEV]�������� �[[[�MGX�SVK�MP��©-R�EFWSPYXI�XIVQW��IZIRXLSYKL�QSVI�4EPIWXMRMERW�XLER�-WVEIPMW�LEZIFIIR�OMPPIH�SZIVEPP��-WVEIPM�JIQEPI�JEXEPMXMIWLEZI�JEV�SYXRYQFIVIH�4EPIWXMRMER�JIQEPIJEXEPMXMIW���-J�[I�MRGPYHI�EPP�VIPMEFPI�VITSVXWSJ�[SQIR�ERH�KMVPW�OMPPIH�MR�XLI�GSRJPMGX�XLI�VEXMS�MW�����-WVEIPM�JIQEPIW�GSQTEVIH�XS���4EPIWXMRMER�JIQEPIW E�VEXMS�SJ�EPQSWX����XS����-J�[I�VIWXVMGX�XLI�GSQTEVMWSR�XSRSRGSQFEXERX�-WVEIPM�JIQEPIW�OMPPIH�F]�4EPIW�XMRMERW�ERH�RSRGSQFEXERX�4EPIWXMRMER�JIQEPIWOMPPIH�F]�-WVEIP��XLI�HMJJIVIRGI�MW�IZIR�QSVIHVEQEXMG�����4EPIWXMRMERW�GSQTEVIH�XS����-WVEIPMW��E�VEXMS�SJ�XLVII�XS�SRI�ª

���4L]PPMW�'LIWPIV��8LI�2I[�%RXM�7IQMXMWQ�.SLR�;MPI]��7SRW��EHZERGI�TVSSJ ��T������

���/EVIR�&MVGLEVH��©,IT�&�'EWI�1EOIW�7YM�GMHI�&SQFIVW�ER�-RJIGXMSR�6MWO�ª�1IHMGEP4SWX�1EG0IER�,YRXIV�0XH���7ITXIQFIV���������

���-FMH����-FMH����1MGLEIP�0IHIIR��©,IFVI[�9�7YVZMZSV��%R

-RXIVZMI[�[MXL�)PMEH�1SVIL�ª�2EXMSREP6IZMI[SRPMRI��%YKYWX���������

���©,ITEXMXMW�7TVIEH�:ME�7YMGMHI�&SQFIVW�ª8LI�7XVEMXW�8MQIW�7MRKETSVI ��.YP]���������

���©-WVEIPM�WSPHMIV�KMZIR����HE]W�MR�NEMP�JSVOMPPMRK�4EPIWXMRMER�FS]�ª�(IYXWLI�4VIWWI�%KIRXYV�*IFVYEV]����������

���.EQIW�&IRRIX��©%VEJEX¬W�)HKI��:MSPIRGI�ERH�8MQI��SR�,MW�7MHI�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1EVGL����������

���8LSQEW�*VMIHQER��©7YMGMHEP�0MIW�ª�2I[=SVO�8MQIW��1EVGL����������

���7EMH�ERH�,MXGLIRW��T���������©,EXI�+SIW�,MKL�8IGL�ª�*VSRXPMRIQEKE�

MRI��;MRXIV�������T����

238)7 ���

Page 262: The Case For Israel

���©-WVEIP�/MPPW�E�8ST�,EQEW�0IEHIV�ª�2I[=SVO�8MQIW�1EVGL���������

���%RRI�&E]IJWO]��©,YQER�6MKLXW�+VSYTW,EZI�0IWW�8LER�2SFPI�%KIRHEW�ª�'LMGEKS7YR�8MQIW�%TVMP����������8LMW�WXEXIQIRX�MWUYMXI�VIQEVOEFPI�GSRWMHIVMRK�XLI�TYFPMGP]EZEMPEFPI�HSGYQIRXEXMSR MRGPYHMRK�WTIGMJMGREQIW�ERH�HEXIW SJ�XLI�QER]�XIVVSVMWX�EGXWGSQQMXXIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�EHSPIWGIRXW�ERHGLMPHVIR��7II�.IVIQ]�'SSOI��©7GLSSP�8VEMRW7YMGMHI�&SQFIVW�ª&&'�2I[W��.YP]����������.YWXYW�6IIH�;IMRIV��©4EPIWXMRMER'LMPHVIR�ERH�XLI�'YPX�SJ�1EVX]VHSQ�ª,EVZEVH�-WVEIP�6IZMI[��7YQQIV������©4EVXMGMTEXMSR�SJ�'LMPHVIR�ERH�8IIREKIVW�MR8IVVSVMWX�%GXMZMX]�HYVMRK�XLI�«%P�%UWE¬-RXMJEHE�ª�[[[�QJE�KSZ�MP�

���)PWLXEMR��T�������UYSXMRK�+IVLEVHX�6IQTIP�,MXPIV¬W�'LMPHVIR��'LETIP�,MPP��9RMZIVWMX]�SJ2SVXL�'EVSPMRE�4VIWW������ ��TT�����O������

���)PWLXEMR��T���������-WVEIPM�7IGYVMX]�*SVGIW��©&PEGOQEMPMRK

=SYRK�;SQIR�MRXS�7YMGMHI�8IVVSVMWQ�ª-WVEIPM�1MRMWXV]�SJ�*SVIMKR�%JJEMVW�6ITSVX�*IFVYEV]�����������[[[�QJE�KSZ�MP�QJE�KS�EWT#1*%,�R�E��

���-XQEV�1EVGYW��&YPPIXMR�I�QEMP�JSV�4EPIWXMR�MER�1IHME�;EXGL�(IGIQFIV���������

���.EQIW�&IRRIX��©8LI�1MHIEWX�8YVQSMP�/MPPIV�SJ����,S[���8SSO�XLI�4EXL�SJ�7YMGMHI&SQFIVW�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1E]����������

���7XEXIQIRXW�QEHI�F]�7PEMQ�,EKE��E�WIRMSV,EQEW�STIVEXMZI��ERH�%LQIH�1SYKLVEFM��E8ERMQ�STIVEXMZI��1E]�����������

���8LSQEW�0��*VMIHQER��©8LI�'SVI�SJ�1YWPMQ6EKI�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1EVGL���������UYSXIH�MR�;L]�8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOW�TT����§���

���%XPERXE�.SYVREP�'SRWXMXYXMSR��[[[�ENG�GSQ�RI[W�GSRXIRX�RI[W��������MVEUHIEH�LXQP��PEWX�ZMWMXIH�.YRI����������

',%48)6���

(SIW�-WVEIP�8SVXYVI�4EPIWXMRMERW#��©9RMRXIVIWXMRK�8IVVSVMWQ�ERH�-RWMKRMJM�

GERX�3TTVIWWMSR�ª�%PP�8LMRKW�2I[�[[[�WGQGEREHE�SVK�EXR�EXR���EXR���CT���LXQP�

��0ISR�Z��;EMR[VMKLX� ����*��H��������§�������XL�'MV������ ��UYSXIH�MR�;L]8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOW��T��������7II�EPWS�'LEZI�Z�1EVXMRI �WPMT�STMRMSR��9�7��7YTVIQI'SYVX��2S��������� ��3R�1E]����������XLI�9�7��7YTVIQI�'SYVX��MR�E�WLEVTP]HMZMHIH�HIGMWMSR��VYPIH�XLEX�XLI�EGX�SJ�XSV�XYVMRK�E�WYWTIGX�MR�SVHIV�XS�SFXEMR�E�WXEXI�QIRX�MW�RSX��MR�MXWIPJ��E�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�XLITVMZMPIKI�EKEMRWX�WIPJ�MRGVMQMREXMSR�EJJSVHIHF]�XLI��XL�%QIRHQIRX�YRPIWW�XLI�WXEXI�

QIRX�MW�XLIR�EHQMXXIH�EKEMRWX�XLI�WYWTIGX�MRE�GVMQMREP�GEWI���8LI�EGX�SJ�XSVXYVMRK�QE]�LS[IZIV��GSRWXMXYXI�E�ZMSPEXMSR�SJ�HYITVSGIWW�MR�I\XVIQI�GEWIW�

��6MGLEVH�&IVRWXIMR��©/MHRETTMRK�,EW�+IV�QERW�(IFEXMRK�4SPMGI�8SVXYVI�ª�2I[�=SVO8MQIW�%TVMP����������

��4YFPMG�'SQQMXXII�EKEMRWX�8SVXYVI�Z��7XEXI�SJ-WVEIP�,'.��-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX ���������.YP]����������

��-FMH���%HVM�/IQTW��HMVIGXSV��(YXGL�7IGXMSR�SJ

%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP �XS�(V��1EVMS7SEVIW��MR�TVSXIWX�SJ�E[EVHMRK�XLI�©.YWXMGMSIR�IP�1YRHSª�TVMI�XS�%LEVSR�&EVEO��

��0ISR�Z��;EMR[VMKLX�����*��H�EX����§������6E]QSRH�&SRRIV��IX�EP���©5YIWXMSRMRK�8IV�

VSV�7YWTIGXW�MR�E�(EVO�ERH�7YVVIEP�;SVPH�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��1EVGL���������

��3RI�TIVWSR�HMIH�JSPPS[MRK�WLEOMRK��FYX�ERMRHITIRHIRX�MRZIWXMKEXMSR�EXXVMFYXIH�LMWHIEXL�XS�ER�YRORS[R�TVII\MWXMRK�QIHMGEPGSRHMXMSR��7II�4YFPMG�'SQQMXXII�%KEMRWX8SVXYVI�,'.��-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX ���������

���©'SQQMXXII�EKEMRWX�8SVXYVI�'SRGPYHIW)MKLXIIRXL�7IWWMSR�+IRIZE�����%TVMP§�1E]�ª������9�2��4VIWW�6IPIEWI�,6������

���6E]QSRH�&SRRIV��2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��1EVGL��������

���-FMH����.IWW�&VEZMR�ERH�+EV]�*MIPHW��©,S[�(S

-RXIVVSKEXSVW�1EOI�8IVVSVMWXW�8EPO�ª�;EPP7XVIIX�.SYVREP��1EVGL���������

���%P�3HEL�Z��9RMXIH�7XEXIW�����*��H���������� �

',%48)6���

,EW�-WVEIP�)RKEKIH�MR�+IRSGMHI�EKEMRWX�4EPIWXMRMER�'MZMPMERW#��4SWXIH�F]�GSYVXIW]�SJ�&S]PI�EX�[[[��

QIHMEQSRMXSVW�RIX�JVERGMW��LXQP��&S]PIKSIW�SR�XS�WIX�SYX�E�JYPP�WGEPI��WXIT�F]�WXITTPER�SJ�EGXMSR�JSV�XLI�©WXEXI�SJ�4EPIWXMRIª�XSFVMRK�XLI�WYMX��8S�Q]�ORS[PIHKI��MX�[EW�EPPXEPO�ERH�RS�PE[WYMX�[EW�IZIV�FVSYKLX�

��3VIR��T�������-FMH���T�������-FMH���T��������'PIS�2SIP��XLI�%QIVMGER�HMTPSQEX�QYV�

HIVIH�MR�1EVGL�������[EW�XLI�LMKLIWX�VEROMRK�HMTPSQEX�SJ�GSPSV�MR�XLI�%QIVMGER*SVIMKR�7IVZMGI��7SQI�SJ�XLI�����QEVMRIWOMPPIH�F]�4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�MR�&IMVYX[IVI�FPEGO��7IZIVEP�SJ�XLI�EMVPMRI�TEWWIRKIVWOMPPIH�MR�XLI�RYQIVSYW�EXXEGOW�SR�EMVPMRIWERH�XIVQMREPW�[IVI�FPEGO��EW�[IVI�WIZIVEP�SJXLI�.I[W�QYVHIVIH�MR�-WVEIP�

��� 238)7

Page 263: The Case For Israel

��.EQIW�&IRRIX��©%�2EXMSR�EX�;EV��4EVEPPIPW�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��%TVMP���������

��-FMH���=MKEP�,IROMR��©8LI�&IWX�;E]�MRXS�&EKL�

HEH�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�%TVMP�����������(EZMH�&��+VIIR��©*MKLXMRK�F]�XLI�&SSO�ª

&SWXSR�+PSFI�%TVMP�������������-FMH����1MGLEIP�;EPIV��©8LI�*SYV�;EVW�SJ

-WVEIP�4EPIWXMRI�ª(MWWIRX�*EPP���������+VIIR��&SWXSR�+PSFI�%TVMP�������������.EWGLE�,SJJQER��©8LI�+SSH�7SPHMIV�ª

&SWXSR�+PSFI�%TVMP�������������)PWLXEMR��TT����§������2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�%TVMP�������������*SV[EVH�1E]�������������'LVMW�,IHKIW��©%�+EE�(MEV]�ª�,EVTIV¬W

1SRXLP]�3GXSFIV���������(V��9QE]E�%LQEH�EP�.EPELQE��%P�6M]HL�

UYSXIH�EX�1MHHPI�)EWX�1IHME�6IWIEVGL-RWXMXYXI��1)16- ��7TIGMEP�(MWTEXGL7IVMIW��1EVGL�����������RS�������LXXT���QIQVM�SVK�

',%48)6���

-W�-WVEIP�E�6EGMWX�7XEXI#��%LQIH�&SYMH��©8LI�6MKLX�SJ�6IXYVR

-WVEIP�ERH�4EPIWXMRI�ª�1IHME�1SRMXSVW�2IX�[SVO� [[[�QIHMEQSRMXSVW�RIX�FSYMH��LXQP�

��2E¬IIQ�.IIREL��©>MSRMWQ�MW�E�XLISV]�SJ�IXL�RMG�GPIERWMRK�ERH�VEGMWQ�ª�-WPEQMG�%WWSGMEXMSRJSV�4EPIWXMRI�[[[�MET�SVK�MSRMWQ��LXQ�

��(V��(EYH�%FHYPPEL��©8LI�6MKLX�SJ�6IXYVR�MRXLI�>MSRMWX�4SPMXMGEP�(MWGSYVWI�ª�PIGXYVI�JSV*VMIRHW�SJ�%P�%UWE�%ZEMPEFPI�EX�[[[�EUWE�SVK�YO�NSYVREPW�ZSP�MWW��HMWGSYVWI�LXQP�

��.EQIW�&IRRIX��©0IXXIV�JVSQ�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�%VEF�7LS[TMIGI#�'SYPH�-X�&I�XLI�;IWX&ERO#ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�%TVMP���������

��6YYH�/SSTQERW��©+IVQER]�ERH�-XW�-QQM�KVERXW��%R�%QFMZEPIRX�6IPEXMSRWLMT�ª�.SYV�REP�SJ�)XLRMG�ERH�1MKVEXMSR�7XYHMIW�3GXSFIV��������

��%KIRGI�*VERGI�4VIWWI��©-WVEIP�%MVPMJXW�/SWSZS6IJYKIIW�SR�)ZI�SJ�,SPSGEYWX�1IQSVMEP(E]�ª�%TVMP����������

��5EHER�Z��-WVEIP�0ERHW�%HQMRMWXVEXMSR��,'.�-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX ����������1EVGL��������

��8LI�SJJMGMEP�[IFWMXI�SJ�8LI�(EZMH�4VSNIGXWLS[W�I\EQTPIW�SJ�HMWGVMQMREXMSR�EKEMRWX©(LMQQMª�SJ�QER]�HMJJIVIRX�IXLRMG�ERH�VIPM�KMSYW�TIVWYEWMSRW�MR�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW��MRGPYHMRK'LVMWXMERW�ERH�&ELEMW��-X�EPWS�JIEXYVIW�E�TMGXYVISJ�E�LMKL[E]�WMKR�MR�7EYHM�%VEFME�[MXL�SRI�PERI�JSV�©1YWPMQW�3RP]�ª�7II�[[[�HEZMHTVSNIGX�SVK�WII�GSRRIGXXLIHSXW�LXQ�

��%VXMGPI����� �SJ�.SVHERMER�REXMSREPMX]�PE[�0E[�RYQFIV�������� ��SJJMGMEP�+EIXXI�2S�������*IFVYEV]�����������VITVMRXIH�MR�9VM(EZMW�'MXMIRWLMT�ERH�XLI�7XEXI��6IEHMRK�9�/���-XLEGE�4VIWW������ ��T�����

',%48)6���

-W�XLI�-WVEIPM�3GGYTEXMSR�XLI�'EYWI�SJ%PPXLI�4VSFPIQW#��7EPQSR�%FY�7MXXE��©8LI�6MKLX�SJ�6IXYVR�-W

%PMZI�ERH�;IPP�ª�4STYPEV�*VSRX�JSV�XLI�0MF�IVEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�[[[�TJPT�TEP�SVK�VMKLX�LXQP��4YFPMWLIH�MR�8LI�.SVHER�8MQIW�

��©&EF]�&SQFIV�4MGXYVI�+IRIVEXIW�-RXIRWI*IEV�ª�1IHME�6IZMI[�2IX[SVO��[[[�QIHM�EVIZMI[�RIX�GSQ�&EF]��&SQFIV��TMG�XYVI��KIRIVEXIW��MRXIRWI��JIEV�LXQ�PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP��������� ��

��.SLR�7��,EPP��©'LMRIWI�4STYPEXMSR�8VERWJIVMR�8MFIX�ª���'EVHSS�.��-RX¬P��'SQT��0���������� �

��-FMH���6IKMRE�1��'PEVO��©'LMRE¬W�9RPE[JYP�'SR�

XVSP�SZIV�8MFIX��8LI�8MFIXER�4ISTPI¬W�)RXM�XPIQIRX�XS�7IPJ�(IXIVQMREXMSR�ª����-RH�-RX¬P��'SQT��0��6IZ���������� �

��©,IEPXL�7IVZMGIW�(IZIPSTQIRX�MR�.YHIE§7EQEVME�ERH�+EE������§�����ª�-WVEIPM+SZIVRQIRX� [IFWMXI��[[[�QJE�KSZ�MP�QJE�KS�EWT#1*%,�F ���������PEWX�ZMW�MXIH�%TVMP��������� �

��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER��2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1EVGL���������

��-FMH���2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��1EVGL�����������UYSXIH

MR;L]�8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOW�T������

',%48)6���

,EW�-WVEIP�(IRMIH�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW�7XEXILSSH#��7EMH�ERH�,MXGLIRW��T��������©%VEF�;SVH�0SSOW�XLI�3XLIV�;E]�EW�

6EGI�&EWIH�,EXVIHW�8EVKIX�-X�SR�8[S*VSRXW�ª�(EMP]�7XEV�0IFERSR ��EZEMPEFPI�EX0IFERSR�;MVI��[[[�PIFERSR[MVI�GSQ��������������(7�EWT��TSWXIH�.YRI�������� �

��&IRR]�1SVVMW��2I[�6ITYFPMG�%TVMP���§���������T�����

',%48)6���

-W�-WVEIPtW�4SPMG]�SJ,SYWI�(IWXVYGXMSR'SPPIGXMZI�4YRMWLQIRX#��7XEXIQIRX�SJ�7]VMER�VITVIWIRXEXMZI�XS�XLI�7I�

GYVMX]�'SYRGMP��8LMW�[EW�XLI�JMVWX�WXEXIQIRX

238)7 ���

Page 264: The Case For Israel

F]�XLI�VITVIWIRXEXMZI�WMRGI�7]VME�EWWYQIHSRI�SJ�XLI�JMJXIIR�WIEXW�SR�XLI�7IGYVMX]'SYRGMP��-WVEIP�LEW�FIIR�I\GPYHIH�JVSQ�WMX�XMRK�SR�XLI�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�

��7IPJ�HIWGVMTXMSR�F]�(ERR]�;EVVIR��[LSTVSYHP]�FSEWXIH�SJ�GSQMRK�JVSQ�XLI�©QSWXVEGMWX�XS[R�MR�XLI�9�/�ª�ERH�[ERXMRK�XS©KS�FEGO�ERH�XIPP�Q]�XS[R�[LEX�-�HMW�GSZIV�ª�,E¬EVIX�(IGIQFIV����������

��.SIP�0I]HIR��©-RMXMEP�-(*�6ITSVX��7LSX�4EPIW�XMRMER�%GXMZMWX�1E]�,EZI�*MVIH�*MVWX�ª.IVYWEPIQ�4SWX�%TVMP����������

��;EVVIR�,SKI��©&VMXEMR�,SPHW��XL�4IVWSR�MR8IP�%ZMZ�&PEWX�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1E]��������

��-FVELMQ�&EVEO��©4VSXIWXIVW�MR�+EE�8S[R&PEQI�4EPIWXMRMER�1MPMXERXW�JSV�-RGYVWMSR�ª%WWSGMEXIH�4VIWW��1E]����������

��+VIK�1]VI��©-WVEIP�7XIQW�7YMGMHI�&SQFMRKW�FYX�EX�E�'SWX�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��%TVMP��������

��-FMH�

',%48)6���

-W�8EVKIXIH�%WWEWWMREXMSR�SJ8IVVSVMWX0IEHIVW�9RPE[JYP#��=EIP�7XIMR��©-WVEIP¬W�%WWEWWMREXMSR�4SPMG]�

)\XVE�.YHMGMEP�)\IGYXMSRW�ª� &¬8WIPIQ�.ERYEV]�������EZEMPEFPI�EX�[[[�FXWIPIQ�SVK�

��-FVELMQ�&EVEO��%WWSGMEXIH�4VIWW��1E]���������

',%48)6���

-W�7IXXPIQIRX�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�ERH�+EE�E�1ENSV�&EVVMIV�XS�4IEGI#��1EV[ER�&MWLEVE��©;IWX�&ERO�7IXXPIQIRXW

3FWXVYGX�4IEGI��-WVEIP¬W�)QTMVI�7XEXI�&YMPH�MRK�ª0I�1SRHI�(MTPSQEXMUYI�.YRI������EZEMPEFPI�EX�LXXT���PSKSWSRPMRI�LSQI�MKG�SVK�FMWLEVE�LXQ�

��.EQIW�&IRRIX��©1MHIEWX�7MHIW�1ERIYZIV�)\TIGXMRK�4IEGI�)JJSVX�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�%TVMP����������

��*SV[EVH�1E]���������

',%48)6���

-W�8IVVSVMWQ�1IVIP]�4EVX�SJE�']GPI�SJ:MSPIRGI#��%WL�4YPGMJIV��©8LI�']GPI�SJ�:MSPIRGI�&IKMRW

%KEMR�ª=IPPS[XMQIW�SVK�[[[�]IPPS[XMQIW�SVK�EVXMGPI�TLT#WMH!������

��©1MHIEWX�,STI�1IIXW�-XW�)RIQ]�ª�2I[�=SVO8MQIW�%TVMP����������

',%48)6���

-W�-WVEIP�XLI�4VMQI�,YQER�6MKLXW�:MSPEXSV�MR�XLI�;SVPH#��)VMG�6IMGLIRFIVKIV��WTSOIWQER�JSV�7XY�

HIRXW�%PPMIH�JSV�*VIIHSQ�ERH�)UYEPMX]��ETVS�4EPIWXMRMER�KVSYT�EX�XLI�9RMZIVWMX]�SJ1MGLMKER��EX�XLI�ERXM�-WVEIP�HMZIWXQIRX�GSR�JIVIRGI�LSWXIH�F]�LMW�SVKERMEXMSR�MR�3GXS�FIV�������(ERMIP�8VIMQER��©7XYHIRXW�6ET-WVEIP�EX�(MZIWXQIRX�4EVPI]�ª�*SV[EVH�3GXSFIV�����������EPWS�UYSXIH�F]�2EX,IRXSJJ��3T��)H���©-WVEIP�EX�7XEOI�SR�9�7�'EQTYWIW��7XYHIRXW�ERH�*EGYPX]�'EPP�JSV(MZIWXQIRX�ª;EWLMRKXSR�8MQIW�2SZIQFIV�������� �

��4VSJIWWSV�-V[MR�'SXPIV��©&I]SRH�(YVFER�8LI�'SRJIVIRGI�%KEMRWX�6EGMWQ�8LEX&IGEQI�E�6EGMWX�'SRJIVIRGI�%KEMRWX�.I[W�ª+PSFEP�.I[MWL�%KIRHE��[[[�NEJM�SVK�MP�EKIRHE������IRKPMWL�[O�������EWT��PEWXZMWMXIH�%TVMP��������� �

��%RRI�&E]IJWO]��©%X�9�2���-WVEIP�&EWLMRK�-W%P[E]W�XLI�*MVWX�4VMSVMX]�ª�'LMGEKS�7YR8MQIW�1EVGL����������

��+VIK�1]VI��©8VMEP�SJ�4EPIWXMRMER�0IEHIV*SGYWIW�%XXIRXMSR�SR�-WVEIPM�'SYVXW��2I[=SVO�8MQIW�1E]���������

��-FMH���-FMH���7YTVIQI�'SYVX�.YWXMGI�(SVMX�&IMRMWGL�

©8LI�6SPI�SJ�XLI�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ�-WVEIPMR�8MQIW�SJ�)QIVKIRG]�ª�+PSFIW�2SZIQFIV���������

��4L]WMGMERW�JSV�,YQER�6MKLXW�Z��'SQQERHIVSJ�-�(�*��*SVGIW�MR�XLI�;IWX�&ERO�,'.���������%TVMP���������

��(ER�-IRFIVK��IX�EP���©7YTVIQI�'SYVX3VHIVW�0IFERIWI�*VIIH��1-%¬W�7PEQ�«7IPJ�(IWXVYGXMZI�.YHMGMEP�7]WXIQ�¬�ª�.IVYWEPIQ4SWX��%TVMP����������

���%NYVM��,'.��-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX ��������

���©-WVEIPM�7YTVIQI�'SYVX�(IGMWMSR�SR�(ITSV�XEXMSR�SJ�*EQMP]�1IQFIVW�SJ�8IVVSVMWXW�ª.I[MWL�:MVXYEP�0MFVEV]��%QIVMGER�-WVEIP'SSTIVEXMZI�)RXIVTVMWI��[[[�YW�MWVEIP�SVK�NWSYVGI�8IVVSVMWQ�WGXHIG�LXQP��7ITXIQ�FIV����������PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP�������� �

���-FMH����-FMH����7II�[[[�GSYVX�KSZ�MP����/LEPIH�%FY�8SEQIL��©����7YWTIGXIH�'SP�

PEFSVEXSVW�,IPH�MR�4�%��.EMPW�ª�.IVYWEPIQ�4SWX�%YKYWX������������7II�EPWS��7IVKI�7GLIQERR�©*SV�%VEF�-RJSVQIVW��(IEXL��JSV�XLI�)\IGY�XMSRIVW��.YWXMGI�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�7ITXIQFIV���������HIWGVMFMRK�XLI�I\IGYXMSR�SJ�XLI

��� 238)7

Page 265: The Case For Israel

[SQIR�SJ�ER�IRXMVI�JEQMP]�SR�WYWTMGMSR�SJFIMRK�GSPPEFSVEXSVW�[MXL�-WVEIP�

���©4EVPMEQIRXEV]�(IFEXIW������ª�4EVPMEQIRXSJ�-VIPERH��[[[�MVPKSZ�MI�HIFEXIW������HIG�WIGX��LXQ��(IGIQFIV�����������PEWXZMWMXIH�%TVMP�������� �

���.YWXMGI�;MPPMEQ�.��&VIRRER�.V���©8LI�5YIWXXS�(IZIPST�E�.YVMWTVYHIRGI�SJ�'MZMP�0MFIV�XMIW�MR�8MQIW�SJ�7IGYVMX]�'VMWMW�ª�PIGXYVI�,IFVI[�9RMZIVWMX]�0E[�7GLSSP��EZEMP�EFPIEX�[[[�FVIRRERGIRXIV�SVK�VIWSYVGIW�HS[RPSEHW�REXMSRCWIGYVMX]CFVIRRER�THJ�

���.EQIW�&IRRIX��©0IXXIV�*VSQ�XLI�1MHHPI)EWX�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�%TVMP���������

',%48)6���

-W�8LIVI�1SVEP�)UYMZEPIRGI�FIX[IIR4EPIWXMRMER�8IVVSVMWXW�ERH�-WVEIPM�6IWTSRWIW#��0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV����

�������©-WVEIP�3GGYTMIH�8IVVMXSVMIW�4EPIWXMRMER

%YXLSVMX]��/MPPMRK�'LMPHVIR�9RHIV�7GVYXMR]EX�92�ª�[[[�EQRIWX]�SVK�EY�GLMPHVIR�OMPPMRKJYXYVI�LXQP��7ITXIQFIV����������PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP��������� �

��7XEXIQIRX�SJ�XLI�,SP]�7II��%TVMP����������EZEMPEFPI�EX�[[[�ZEXMGER�ZE�

��©&]�1]�7TMVMX��;LEX�;MPP�1EOI�JSV�4IEGI�MRXLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�ª�WXEXIQIRX�SJ�2EXMSREP'SYRGMP�SJ�'LYVGLIW�HIPIKEXMSR�XS�XLI�1MH�HPI�)EWX��EZEMPEFPI�EX�[[[�RGGGYWE�SVK�RGGQMHHPIIEWXHIPIKEXMSR�WXEXIQIRX�LXQP�

��©7XEXI�SJ�XLI�7TMVMXª�EHHVIWW�KMZIR�EX�XLIJSYRHMRK�GSRJIVIRGI�SJ�XLI�8MOOYR�'SQ�QYRMX]�

��4IXIV�*MRR��©+IVQER]�%RRSYRGIW�&ER�SR-WPEQMG�)\XVIQMWX�+VSYT�ª�;EWLMRKXSR�4SWX�.ERYEV]����������

��)PWLXEMR��T�������&SWXSR�+PSFI��.YRI����������T��%���

',%48)6���

7LSYPH�9RMZIVWMXMIW�(MZIWX�JVSQ�-WVEIP�ERH�&S]GSXX�-WVEIPM�7GLSPEVW#��0IGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]��2SZIQFIV����

�������'SRKVIWWMSREP�6IGSVH��7IREXI��*IFVYEV]���

������7�������)PEMRI�7GMSPMRS��©9�7��7E]W�-X�,EW�%VEJEX

8LVIEX�SR�8ETI�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��.ERYEV]���������

��-FMH���6SFIVX�*MWO��©,S[�XS�7LYX�9T�=SYV�'VMXMGW

[MXL�E�7MRKPI�;SVH�ª�8LI�-RHITIRHIRX�3GXSFIV����������

��(EZMH�;IMRJIPH��©'LSQWO]¬W�+MJX�ª�,EV�ZEVH�'VMQWSR�(IGIQFIV����������

��'LSQWO]��PIGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]�2SZIQFIV����������

��;IMRJIPH�,EVZEVH�'VMQWSR��(IGIQFIV���������

��©2SX�.YWX�7IQERXMGW�ª�)HMXSVMEP��3VPERHS7IRXMRIP�%YKYWX���������

���8LI�2I[�=SVOIV��1EVGL�����������TT���§���

',%48)6���

%VI�'VMXMGW�SJ-WVEIP�%RXM�7IQMXMG#��8LSQEW�&EVXPIXX��©%�7YVKI�SJ�%RXM�7IQM�

XMWQ�SV�1G'EVXL]MWQ#ª�8LI�'LVSRMGPI�SJ,MKLIV�)HYGEXMSR�ZSP������3GXSFIV��������

��©%TEVXLIMH�MR�XLI�,SP]�0ERH�ª�+YEVHMER�%TVMP����������

��0E[VIRGI�7YQQIVW��WTIIGL�EX�1IQSVMEP'LYVGL��'EQFVMHKI��1EWWEGLYWIXXW��7IT�XIQFIV����������

��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER��©'EQTYW�,]TSGVMW]�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�3GXSFIV����������

��7I]QSYV�1EVXMR�0MTWIX��©8LI�7SGMEPMWQ�SJ*SSPW XLI�0IJX��XLI�.I[W��ERH�-WVEIP�ª)RGSYRXIV��(IGIQFIV�������T�����

��6ITVIWIRXEXMZI�.SLR�0I[MW��©�«-�,EZI�E(VIEQ¬�JSV�4IEGI�MR�XLI�1MHHPI�)EWX�ª�7ER*VERGMWGS�'LVSRMGPI��.ERYEV]����������

��4VSJIWWSV�-V[MR�'SXPIV��©&I]SRH�(YVFER�ª+PSFEP�.I[MWL�%KIRHE��[[[�NEJM�SVK�MP�EKIRHE������IRKPMWL�[O�������EWT�

��7II��I�K���1)16-�7ITXIQFIV����������RS������

��4EXVMGO�&YGLERER��©(MZMHMRK�0MRI�ª�2I[=SVO�4SWX��1EVGL�����������&YGLERER��EWYWYEP��LEH�LMW�JEGXW�[VSRK��8LI�.I[W�SJ�8VIFPMROE�[IVI�QYVHIVIH�F]�ZEVMSYW�QIXL�SHW�SJ�KEWWMRK��MRGPYHMRK�XLI�YWI�SJ�I\LEYWXJYIPW�ERH�>]OPSR�&��&YGLERER¬W�©JEGXWªEFSYX�XLI�,SPSGEYWX�X]TMGEPP]�GSQI�JVSQGVEGOTSX�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMIVW�

���.EGSF�;IMWFIVK��©8LI�,IVIWMIW�SJ�4EX&YGLERER�ª2I[�6ITYFPMG�3GXSFIV����������T�����

���4LMPMT�7LIRSR��©;EWLMRKXSR�8EPO��8LI&YGLERER�%KKVEZEXMSR�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�*IFVYEV]����������

���6SFIVX�*EYVMWWSR��1IQSMVI�IR�(IJIRWI�4EVMW��0E�:MIMPPI�8EYTI������ �

���4EYP�0��&IVQER��©+EW�'LEQFIV�+EQIW�'VEGOTSX�,MWXSV]�ERH�XLI�6MKLX�XS�0MI�ª:MPPEKI�:SMGI�.YRI���§����������T�����

���*SV�I\EQTPI��*EYVMWWSR�VIPMIW�SR�ER�IRXV]HEXIH�3GXSFIV�����������JVSQ�XLI�HMEV]�SJ77�HSGXSV�.SLERR�4EYP�/VIQIV�[VMXXIR�HYV�MRK�XLI�XLVII�QSRXLW�LI�WTIRX�MR�%YWGL[MXMR�������%R�IQMRIRX�WGLSPEV�GLIGOIH�*EY�VMWWSR¬W�YWI�SJ�XLI�IRXV]�ERH�HIQSRWXVEXIH

238)7 ���

Page 266: The Case For Israel

XLEX�*EYVMWWSR¬W�VIWIEVGL�[EW�IRXMVIP]�TLSR]�8LI�HMEV]�IRXV]�VIEH��©8LMW�7YRHE]�QSVR�MRK�MR�GSPH�ERH�LYQMH�[IEXLIV�-�[EW�TVIW�IRX�EX�XLI���XL�WTIGMEP�EGXMSR��(YXGL �%XVSGMSYW�WGIRIW�[MXL�XLVII�[SQIR�[LSFIKKIH�YW�XS�PIX�XLIQ�PMZI�ª

*EYVMWWSR�GSRGPYHIW�XLEX�XLMW�TEWWEKITVSZIW��� �XLEX�E�©WTIGMEP�EGXMSRª�[EW�RSXL�MRK�QSVI�XLER�XLI�WSVXMRK�SYX�F]�HSGXSVW�SJXLI�WMGO�JVSQ�XLI�LIEPXL]�HYVMRK�E�X]TLYWITMHIQMG���� �XLEX�XLI�©EXVSGMSYW�WGIRIWª[IVI�©I\IGYXMSRW�SJ�TIVWSRW�[LS�LEH�FIIRGSRHIQRIH�XS�HIEXL��I\IGYXMSRW�JSV�[LMGLXLI�HSGXSV�[EW�SFPMKIH�XS�FI�TVIWIRXª���� XLEX�©EQSRK�XLI�GSRHIQRIH�[IVI�XLVII[SQIR�[LS�LEH�GSQI�MR�E�GSRZS]�JVSQ,SPPERH�?[LSA�[IVI�WLSXª��� �XLEX�XLIVI[IVI�RS�KEW�GLEQFIVW�WMRGI�XLI�[SQIR[IVI�WLSX�ERH�RSX�KEWWIH��IQTLEWMW�EHHIH �

%�*VIRGL�WGLSPEV�REQIH�+ISVKI�;IPPIVWEREP]IH�XLMW�HMEV]�IRXV]�ERH�XLI�WYVVSYRH�MRK�HSGYQIRXEXMSR�JSV�0I�1SRHI�,I�HMHEGXYEP�LMWXSVMGEP�VIWIEVGL��GLIGOMRK�XLI%YWGL[MX�EVGLMZIW�JSV�XLI�HEXI�SJ�XLI�HMEV]IRXV] E�WMQTPI�QEXXIV��,I�JSYRH�XLEX������(YXGL�.I[W�EVVMZIH�EX�%YWGL[MX�SR3GXSFIV�����������3J�XLIWI��������[IVIMQQIHMEXIP]�WIRX�XS�XLI�KEW�GLEQFIVW��8LIVIQEMRMRK�����TISTPI��EPP�[SQIR��[IVIFVSYKLX�MRXS�XLI�GEQT��XLI�XLVII�[SQIR[LS�[IVI�XLI�WYFNIGX�SJ�XLI�/VIQIV�HMEV]QYWX�LEZI�FIIR�EQSRK�XLIQ��8LI�XLVII[SQIR�[IVI��MR�JEGX��WLSX��EW�*EYVMWWSRGSRGPYHIW��&YX�XLI�JEGX�RS[�ETTIEVW�LIVI�MR/VIQIV¬W�HMEV]��,S[�HMH�*EYVMWWSR�PIEVR�MX#4VSJIWWSV�;IPPIVW�[EW�EFPI�XS�JMRH�XLIERW[IV�[MXL�WSQI�WMQTPI�VIWIEVGL��,IGLIGOIH�(V��/VIQIV¬W�XIWXMQSR]�EX�E�4SPMWL[EV�GVMQIW�XVMEP��8LMW�MW�[LEX�/VIQIV�WEMH�EXXLI�XVMEP��©8LVII�(YXGL�[SQIR�HMH�RSX[ERX�XS�KS�MRXS�XLI�KEW�GLEQFIVERH�FIKKIHXS�LEZI�XLIMV�PMZIW�WTEVIH��8LI]�[IVI�]SYRK[SQIR�MR�KSSH�LIEPXL�FYX�MR�WTMXI�SJ�XLEX�XLIMV�TVE]IV�[EW�RSX�KVERXIH�ERH�XLI�77[LS�[IVI�TEVXMGMTEXMRK�MR�XLI�EGXMSR�WLSXXLIQ�SR�XLI�WTSXª��IQTLEWMW�EHHIH �

*EYVMWWSR��[LS�WEMH�LI�LEH�VIWIEVGLIHXLI�XVMEP��ORI[�XLEX�LMW�S[R�WSYVGI��(V��/VI�QIV��LEH�XIWXMJMIH�XLEX�XLI�KEW�GLEQFIVW�HMHI\MWX��=IX�LI�HIPMFIVEXIP]�SQMXXIH�XLEX�GVY�GMEP�MXIQ�JVSQ�LMW�FSSO�[LMPI�MRGPYHMRK�XLIJEGX�XLEX�XLI�[SQIR�[IVI�WLSX��*EYVMWWSREPWS�ORI[�XLEX�XLI�XLVII�[SQIR�[IVI�MRKSSH�LIEPXL��=IX�LI�PIH�LMW�VIEHIVW�XSFIPMIZI�XLEX�(V��/VIQIV�LEH�WEMH�XLI]�[IVIWIPIGXIH�SR�QIHMGEP�KVSYRHW�HYVMRK�ER�ITM�HIQMG��*MREPP]��*EYVMWWSR�WXEXIW�XLEX�XLSWI[LS�[IVI�WLSX�LEH�FIIR�©GSRHIQRIH�XS

HIEXL�ª�=IX�LI�ORI[�XLI]�[IVI�WLSX�F]�XLI77�JSV�VIJYWMRK�XS�IRXIV�XLI�KEW�GLEQFIVW��

���&VMER�1SVXSR��©8LI�'YPXYVI�SJ�8IVVSV�MWQ�ª2EXMSR�ZSP�������RS������1E]���������T������

���;��(��6YFMRWXIMR��©'LSQWO]�ERH�XLI�2IS�2EMW�ª 5YEHVERX�%YWXVEPME ��3GXSFIV������T�����

���%PER�1��(IVWLS[MX��©'LSQWO]�(IJIRHW:MGMSYW�0MI�EW�*VII�7TIIGL�ª�&SWXSR�+PSFI�.YRI�����������T�����

���2SEQ�'LSQWO]��©6MKLX�XS�7TIEO�8VER�WGIRHW�'SRXIRX�SJ�7TIIGL�ª�&SWXSR�+PSFI�.YP]����������T�����

���7GSX�0ILMKL��©1IR�SJ�0IXXIVW�ª�&SWXSR4LSIRM\�.YRI���§����������T�����

���4EYP�0��&IVQER��©6ITP]�XS�'LSQWO]�ª�:MP�PEKI�:SMGI�.YP]��§���������T�����

���1)16-�7ITXIQFIV�����������RS���������4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]�8IPIZMWMSR��3GXSFIV

���������

',%48)6���

;L]�(S�7S�1ER]�.I[W�ERH�)ZIR�-WVEIPMW�7MHI�[MXL�XLI�4EPIWXMRMERW#��7EMH�ERH�,MXGLIRW��T�������-FMH���T������6ITSVXIH�F]�'LVMW�%QSW��©%GXMZMWXW�9VKI

6IETTVEMWEP�SJ�1MHHPI�)EWX�'SRJPMGX�ª1MGLMKER�(EMP]��2SZIQFIV����������

��[[[�ROYWE�SVK�EFSYXYW�MRHI\�GJQ��PEWXZMWMXIH�1E]�������� �

��*SV[EVH�2SZIQFIV����������

'SRGPYWMSR��-WVEIPhXLI�.I[�EQSRK�2EXMSRW��%RHVIE�0IZMR��©-WVEIPM�%VEF�6MKLXW�ERH

;VSRKW�ª3R�'%1)6%�GSPYQR��*IFVYEV]���������

��©8LI�[EKI�KETW�FIX[IIR�.I[W�ERH�%VEFW�MR-WVEIP�EVI�ZIV]�WMQMPEV�XS�XLSWI�FIX[IIR[LMXIW�ERH�FPEGOW�MR�XLI�9�7��ª�%QRSR6YFIRWXIMR��©.I[MWL�4VSJIWWMSRW��%VEF�4VS�JIWWMSRW�ª�,EEVIXHEMP]�GSQ��%TVMP����������8LI�EVXMGPI�KSIW�SR�XS�WLS[�XLEX©IXLRMG�FEWIH�MRGSQI�HMWTEVMXMIW�I\MWX�IZIRMR�GPEWWMG�[IPJEVI�WXEXIWª�WYGL�EW�,SPPERH�

��7II�XLI�7MOOY]�6ITSVX�����§������T����[[[�WMOOY]�SVK�MP�VITSVX�7MOOY]��6ITSVX�������HSG�

��-WVEIPM�'IRXVEP�&YVIEY�SJ�7XEXMWXMGW��[[[�GFW�KSZ�MP�

��7XIZIR�4PEYX��©8LI�'SPPETWMRK�7]VMER�)GSR�SQ]�ª�1MHHPI�)EWX�5YEVXIVP]�ZSP��:-��RS����7ITXIQFIV�������

��;IF�WMXI�SJ�XLI�-WVEIPM�*SVIMKR�1MRMWXV]�[[[�MWVIEP�QJE�KSZ�MP�

��� 238)7

Page 267: The Case For Israel

��2SEQ�'LSQWO]��WTIIGL�XS�1MHHPI�)EWX'LMPHVIR¬W�%PPMERGI��7ER�*VERGMWGS��1EVGL���� ������ [[[�QEK�SVK�GSRXIRX�1MHIEWX�GLSQWO]QIGEXEPO�GJQ�

��8LSQEW�*VMIHQER��©2MRI�;EVW�8SS�1ER]�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�1E]����������

��4VSJIWWSV�-V[MR�'SXPIV��©&I]SRH�(YVFER�ª+PSFEP�.I[MWL�%KIRHE��[[[�NEJM�SVK�MP�EKIRHE������IRKPMWL�[O�������EWT�

���.YPMERE�4MPSR��©8LI�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW¬�'EQ�TEMKR�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP�ª�,IVMXEKI�*SYRHEXMSR6ITSVX��.YRI����������

���'SXPIV��©&I]SRH�(YVFER�ª���-FMH����4SWXIH�SR�%RHVI[�7YPPMZER¬W�TIVWSREP�[IF�

WMXI�EX�[[[�ERHVI[WYPPMZER�GSQ�QEMRCEVXMGPI�TLT#EVXRYQ!���������

���3VMERE�*EPPEGM��©3VMERE�*EPPEGM�SR�%RXM�7IQMXMWQ�ª4ERSVEQE�%TVMP����������

���*��1��(SWXS]IZWO]��8LI�(MEV]�SJ�E�;VMXIV�&SVMW�&VEWSP�XVERW���7EPX�0EOI�'MX]��4IVI�KVMRI�7QMXL�&SSOW������ ��TT�����§����

���-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������-FMH���T���������)WXMQEXIW�ZEV]�EW�XS�XLI�RYQFIV�SJ�4EPIW�

XMRMERW�OMPPIH�HYVMRK�©&PEGO�7ITXIQFIV�ª[MXL�WSQI�IWXMQEXIW�EW�LMKL�EW��������3RI�(E]�MR�7ITXIQFIV��7SR]�4MGXYVIW�[[[�WSR]TMGXYVIW�GSQ�GPEWWMGW�SRIHE]

�LXQP�FPEGOWITX��PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP�������� ��[LMPI�SXLIVW�GMXI�XLI�JMKYVI�SJ�������©7SQI�/I]�(EXIW�MR�XLI�-WVEIPM�4EPIWXMRMER'SRJPMGX�ª�[[[�YQMGL�IHY�bMMRIX�GQIREW�WXYH]YRMXW�MWVEIPM�TEPIWXMRMERCGSRJPMGX�WXY�HIRXOI]HEXIW�LXQP��PEWX�ZMWMXIH�%TVMP�������� �

���8LSQEW�0��*VMIHQER��©6IIPMRK�FYX�6IEH]�ª2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�%TVMP����������

���7II�TSPP�GSRHYGXIH�F]�XLI�4EPIWXMRMER�'IR�XIV�JSV�4SPMG]�ERH�6IWIEVGL�EX�&IVIMX�9RM�ZIVWMX]��VIJIVVIH�XS�MR�.I[MWL�;IIO�%TVMP����������T�����

���&IMVYX�EP�2EWWE��.YP]�������������'LSQWO]��PIGXYVI��,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]�

2SZIQFIV�������������1MGLEIP�;EPIV��©8LI�*SYV�;EVW�SJ

-WVEIP�4EPIWXMRI�ª(MWWIRX�*EPP���������.EQIW�&IRRIX��©9�7��7XEXIQIRXW�+YMHI�XLI

8EPOW�SR�XLI�1MHIEWX�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�.YRI���������

���.IVYWEPIQ�4SWX��.ERYEV]�������������6IZMI[�SJ�7LEXXIVIH�(VIEQWF]�'LEVPIW

)RHIVPMR�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW�&SSO�6IZMI[�1E]����������T�����

���.EQIW�&IRRIX��©8LI�1MHIEWX�8YVQSMP�.IVYWEPIQ��-WVEIP�%TTVSZIW�&YWL¬W�6SEHQETXS�2I[�4EPIWXMRI�ª�2I[�=SVO�8MQIW��1E]���������

���;EPIV��©8LI�*SYV�;EVW�SJ�-WVEIP�4EPIW�XMRI�ª

238)7 ���

Page 268: The Case For Israel

���

-2()<

%FFEW��1ELQSYH��%FY�1EIR ���������§������

%FHYP�,EXM��%YRM�&I]���%FHYPPEL��(EYH�����%FHYPPEL��'VS[R�4VMRGI�SJ�7EYHM�%VEFME �

��������§��%FHYPPEL��/MRK�SJ�.SVHER ��������������%FY�,EPEFM]E��%LQEH�����§��EGGYWIVW�SJ�-WVEIP���%JJIRHM��%FHIP[ELEF�IP������EJJMVQEXMZI�EGXMSR����%KVEREX�'SQQMWWMSR�����%LPQER�% EL�4EWLE��%FH�EP�����%P�%OWE�-RXMJEHE�����%PEQ��1��7LELMH������������%PEQM��1YWE����%P�2EHM�%P�%VEFM����%PSR�4PER����§��%QRIWX]�-RXIVREXMSREP���������������ERXM�7IQMXMWQ

ERH�GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�.I[W���§������§��JEREXMGEP�����§��*EYVMWWSR�ERH�����MR�,EQEW�'LEVXIV�����ERH�MRXMJEHE�����RMRI�WIXW�SJ�©RI[�ª����§��

%VEF�,MKL�'SQQMXXII����%VEF�0MFIVEXMSR�%VQ]����%VEF�4EPIWXMRMER�-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX

GEYWI�SJ�������§��WSPYXMSRW�XS���§�

%VEF�VIJYKIIW���§�����§��%VEF�;EV�SJ�)\XIVQMREXMSR�������7II�EPWS;EV

SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI��-WVEIPM%VEFW

ERH�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR����§��HMWTPEGIQIRX�SJ�F]�)YVSTIER�.I[W�������§��,SPSGEYWX�ERH����§����������ERH�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI����§��.I[MWL��������§�������QSHIVEXIW����§�������[EV�EKEMRWX�-WVEIP���TIEGI�SJJIVW�VIJYWIH�F]�����§��ERH�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�TEVXMXMSR�TPER����§���

��§��ERH�4LEWIH�4PER�JSV�PMFIVEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�

��§��TSPMG]�SJ�OMPPMRK�EPP�.I[W�������������§����

���

ERH�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ����§��VINIGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP¬W�VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�����������

�������§��ERH�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR����WXVEXIK]�XS�IPMQMREXI�.I[W���9�2��4EVXMXMSR�4PER�VINIGXIH�F]����

%VEJEX��=EWWIVERH�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW��������

�����������������§�������§���JIEV�SJ�QEOMRK�TIEGI�����,YWWIMRM�GEPPIH�©LIVSª�F]����-WVEIP¬W�HIGMWMSR�RSX�XS�XEVKIX�����EJXIV�3WPS�%GGSVHW����XIVVSVMWQ�ERH�������������ERH�8MERERQIR�7UYEVI�����[IEO�NYHMGMEV]�TVIJIVVIH�F]�����[IEPXL�SJ����������

EVX�ERH�GYPXYVI�MR�-WVEIP����§�������%WWEH��,EJM�EP����������EWWEWWMREXMSRW��XEVKIXIH�����§��©EYXSIQERGMTEXMSR�ª���%]EWL��=ILM]E�����%M��8EVMU����%Q��/LEPMH�EP�����%SYVM��2ENMF����

&EPJSYV��%VXLYV����&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR����§��&ERHEV��4VMRGI�SJ�7EYHM�%VEFME ��������

���§�������§���&EVEO��%LEVSR�����&EVEO��)LYH���§����������§�������§��������

��������&EVEO�'PMRXSR�TIEGI�TVSTSWEPW��7II'EQT

(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW&E]IJWO]��%RRI�����&IKMR��1IREGLIQ���������&IR�+YVMSR��(EZMH�������������������������

��������FMREXMSREP�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR���§�&MWLEVE��1EV[ER�����&SYMH��%LQIH�����&NSVIRK��)ZE����&SHM��*EMWEP����&SPPMRKIV��0II�����&S]PI��*VERGMW����������&VIRRER��;MPPMEQ�����&VILRIZ��0ISRMH�-������

Page 269: The Case For Israel

&VMXEMRERH�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR��������GYVXEMPQIRX�SJ�.I[MWL�MQQMKVEXMSR�MRXS

4EPIWXMRI�F]����§������§��ERH�,IFVSR�QEWWEGVIW����TEVXMXMSR�TPER�SJ���������§��

&VMXMWL�;LMXI�4ETIV�SJ���������&VSRRIV��)XLER�����§��&VSXLIVW�/EVEQESZ��8LI�(SWXS]IZWO] �����&¬8WIPIQ����������&YFIV��1EVXMR����&YGLERER��4EX�����§��&YVOLEVHX��.��0�����&YWL��+ISVKI�;���������������������

'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW������§�����������§�������§�������§���

'EQYW��%PFIVX�����'EWWMIQ��-QEQ�%GLQIH����GLMPHVIR�EW�XIVVSVMWXW�����§��'LMRE��SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�8MFIX�F]�����§��������

���§��'LSQWO]��2SEQ

EFSPMXMSR�SJ�WXEXI�SJ�-WVEIP��GEPP�JSV�����%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ������������§��'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�����GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�����HMZIWXQIRX�JVSQ�-WVEIP��GEQTEMKR���������ERH�,SPSGEYWX�HIRMIV�*EYVMWWSR�����§��-WVEIP�ERH�9�7��EW�VINIGXMSRMWXW����§�������

���.I[W�EW�WIXXPIVW�MR�4EPIWXRI����EW�©RI[�LMWXSVMER�ª���VINIGXMSR�SJ�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR���XIVVSVMWQ�����>MSRMWX�MQTIVMEPMWQ����

'LVMWXSTLIV��;EVVIR�����'LYVGLMPP��;MRWXSR��������§������GMZMPMERW��XEVKIXMRK�ERH�OMPPMRK�SJ���

%VEF�TSPMG]�SJ���������§��EJXIV�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR����EJXIV�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�

��§�������§�������§��GLMPHVIR����������GSPPEXIVEPP]�LMXXMRK�ZIVWYW����EW�GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�����EX�(IMV�=EWWER����§��I\EQTPIW�SJ�����§��F]�,YWWIMRM����MR�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI����§��-WVEIP¬W�EZSMHERGI�SJ����������§��4EPIWXMRMER�XIVVSVMWXW�ERH�����§��������§��ERH�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ����MR�7M\�(E]�;EV���������§��9�7��TSPMG]�GSRGIVRMRK�����§��EW�[EV�GVMQI�����MR�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV����������

'PMRXSR��&MPP��������§����������������������

GSPPIGXMZI�EGGSYRXEFMPMX]��������������������GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�����§��GSPSRMEPMWQ��EGGYWEXMSRW�SJ����§��GSQTVSQMWI��������������������'SSO��;MPPMEQ�%�����'SXPIV��-V[MR����������§��'VYWEHIVW��������

(ENERE��%VIJ�4EWLE����(EQEWGYW�6EHMS�������������(E]ER��1SWLI��ERH�6IWSPYXMSR��������(IMV�=EWWER�QEWWEGVI����§�������HIQSGVEG]��-WVEIP�EW����������������§��HIXIVVIRGI����������(LMQQMW��������HMEWTSVE��I\MPIW ��������HMWTPEGIQIRX�SJ�%VEFW�F]�)YVSTIER�.I[W����

��§��HMZIWXQIRX�JVSQ�-WVEIP�F]�YRMZIVWMXMIW�

���§���(SWXS]IZWO]��*]SHSV����������§��©HSYFPI�IJJIGX�ª����

IGSRSQMG�WERGXMSRW���������������)K]TX

ERH�%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ����ERH�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR��������ERH�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI����2EM�[EV�GVMQMREPW�KMZIR�EW]PYQ�MR����SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�F]����ERH�7M\�(E]�;EV����§�������XSVXYVI�TSPMGMIW�MR�����ERH�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR���ERH�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV�����§���

)MGLQERR��%HSPJ��������)PFEYQ��1E\����)P�&E��3WEQE�����)PWLXEMR��.IER�&IXLOI����������§�������)TWXIMR��=MXLEO����)WLOSP����IXLRMG�GPIERWMRK�SJ�.I[W���������)XIP����)YVSTIER�.I[MWL�MQQMKVERXW�XS�4EPIWXMRI���§��

��§��������������§����7II�EPWS*MVWX%PM]EL

GYVXEMPQIRX�SJ����§������§��HMWTPEGIQIRX�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�F]�������§��,SPSGEYWX�ERH������������PERH�TYVGLEWIW�F]����§��ERH�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�TEVXMXMSR����§��WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�SJ����

I\TERWMSRMWXW���I\XVIQMWXW�������������������§�������§��

*EPPEGM��3VMERE�����JEWGMWXW����*EYVMWWSR��6SFIVX����������§��JIHIVEXMSR�WSPYXMSR����

-2()< ���

Page 270: The Case For Israel

*IMWEP��)QMV����JIPPELMR�������§��©JMREP�WSPYXMSR��©�����������*MROIPWXIMR��2SVQER����*MVWX�%PM]EL���§������������§������§��JSVIMKR�EMH�����*VEROJYVXIV��*IPM\����JVIIHSQ�SJ�WTIIGL��MR�-WVEIP����������*VMIHQER��8LSQEW�����������������������JYRHEQIRXEPMWXW�������������

+EVGME��)VRMI�����+EE�7XVMT���������������������§�������KE]W�����KIRSGMHI�����������������§�������+ISVKI��0PS]H����+IVQERW��GSPPIGXMZI�TYRMWLQIRX�SJ����������+LSYV]��)QMPI����+MPFIVX��1EVXMR����+SPER�,IMKLXW��������������+SPHFIVK��%VXLYV����©+SPHIR�1IHMRE�ª���+SPHWXIMR��&EVYGL�����§��KVERH�QYJXM�SJ�.IVYWEPIQ��7II,YWWIMRM+YPJ�SJ�%UEFE��������

,EHEWWEL�,SWTMXEP�EXXEGO����,EKEREL�EVQ]����������������,EMJE��������,EPFIVXEP��1SWLI�����,EQEW

GLEVXIV�����§���JYRHEQIRXEPMWX�IEP�SJ�����ERH�LSYWI�HIQSPMXMSRW�F]�-WVEIP�����EW�VINIGXMSRMWXW�������XEVKIXMRK�SJ�����ERH�XIVVSVMWQ�����§������������

,ERM]E��-WQEMP�����§��,ERWSR��4IXIV�����,EVZEVH�1-8�HMZIWXMXYVI�TIXMXMSR�����§���,EVZEVH�9RMZIVWMX]���LIEPXL�GEVI�������������§������������§��,IFVI[�OMRKHSQW��MRHITIRHIRX����,IFVSR������������������������,IFVSR�QEWWEGVI����§�������,IVP��8LISHSVI��������,IWLIP��7YWERREL�����,IFYPPEL��������,MHHIR�5YIWXMSR��8LI�)TWXIMR ����,MQQPIV��,IMRVMGL����LMWXSV]��HMWTEVEXI�TIVGITXMSRW�SJ���§����,MXGLIRW��'LVMWXSTLIV�����,MXPIV��%HSPJ�������§���������������,SPSGEYWX

%VEF�ERH�1YWPMQ�WYTTSVX�SJ����§����������ERH�GYVXEMPQIRX�SJ�.I[MWL�MQQMKVEXMSR�JVSQ

)YVSTI����HIRMEP�SJ����������§��

,YWWIMRM�ERH����§��.I[W�EGGYWIH�SJ�I\TPSMXMRK����§��WYVZMZSVW����

LSP]�GMXMIW���������������,SP]�4PEGIW��QERHEXI�XS�TVSXIGX����LSQIPERH�WSPYXMSR��7IIX[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSRLSYWI�HIWXVYGXMSR��-WVEIP¬W�TSPMG]�SJ�����§���

��������§��LYQER�VMKLXW��-WVEIP¬W�VIGSVH�SR��������§���

�������������,YWWIMR��7EHHEQ����������,YWWIMR��/MRK�SJ�.SVHER ����§��������

���§�������§��,YWWIMRM���,EN�%QMR�EP�

&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR�ERH����LEXVIH�SJ�.I[W�F]��������,IFVSR�QEWWEGVI�ERH����,MXPIV��2EMW��ERH����§����������ERH�-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI����WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�ERH������������XIVVSVMWQ�MRGMXIH�F]����§��ERH�[EV�SJ�����§��������§��

-(*��7II-WVEIPM�(IJIRWI�*SVGI-LREX��.SLR�����MQTIVMEPMWQ��EGGYWEXMSRW�SJ����§����������§��MRXIVREXMSREP�PE[W�����§��-RXIVREXMSREP�7SPMHEVMX]�1SZIQIRX�����MRXIVVSKEXMSR�XIGLRMUYIW�����§��MRXMJEHE��EJXIV�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�

�%P�%OWE�-RXMJEHE ���§������������§��MRXMJEHE��JMVWX����������-VER��EW�VINIGXMSRMWX�WXEXI�������-VEU

TVS�2EM�GSYT�MR����ERH�7M\�(E]�;EV��������[EV�EKEMRWX�����

-VKYR��)XIP ����-WPEQ��EW�IWXEFPMWLIH�VIPMKMSR����������-WPEQMG�.MLEH����-WVEIP

EGLMIZIQIRXW�SJ�����§��EGXYEP�ZIVWYW�TIVGIMZIH�VIGSVH�����§��EVX�ERH�GYPXYVI�MR����§�������EX�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW���§��'SHI�SJ�)XLMGW�JSV�QMPMXEV]���������������EW�HIQSGVEG]��������§��HIQSRMEXMSR�SJ����������§�������§���

���§��HMWGVMQMREXMSR�MR�����HMZIWXQIRX�JVSQ��GEPP�JSV�����§HSYFPI�WXERHEVH�EKEMRWX�����������������

��������IGSRSQMG�WXVIRKXL�SJ�����§��.IVYWEPIQ�GETXYVIH�F]����EW�©.I[ª�EQSRK�REXMSRW���������SGGYTEXMSR�F]����§������������§�������4EPIWXMRMER�%VEFW�MR����

��� -2()<

Page 271: The Case For Israel

TISTPI�SJ�GSPSV�MR�����TYFPMG�STMRMSR�EKEMRWX�������§��������

���§�������§��VEGMWQ�EGGYWEXMSR�����§��EW�VIJYKII�WXEXI����§��VIPMKMSYW�TPYVEPMWQ�MR�����§��VMKLX�XS�I\MWX�����VYPI�SJ�PE[��GSQTPMERGI�[MXL�����7YTVIQI�'SYVX�SJ����������§�������������

��������§�������9�2��4EVXMXMSR�4PER�EGGITXIH�F]����;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI����§������;IWX�&ERO�SGGYTMIH�F]��������§��

-WVEIP�(IGPEVEXMSR�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI���-WVEIPM�(IJIRWI�*SVGI��������������������§��-WVEIPM�4EPIWXMRMER�GSRJPMGX��7II%VEF�4EPIWXMR�

MER�-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX-WPEQMG�9RMX]�'SRZIRXMSR����-]EH��%FY����§��

.EFEPM��+LEM����

.EJJEEXXEGOW�SR�.I[W�MR����FEXXPI�EX����MR�IMKLXIIRXL�ERH�RMRIXIIRXL�GIRXYVMIW����.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR��������TSTYPEXMSR�SJ����

.IIREL��2E¬IIQ�����

.IRMR�QEWWEGVI�����§��

.IVMGLS��.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR��������

.IVYWEPIQ����������������������

.I[MWL�WXEXI������������������§����7II�EPWS-WVEIP

.I[WJVSQ�%VEF�GSYRXVMIW��������§��'VYWEHIVW¬�TIVWIGYXMSR�SJ��������HMWWIRX�EQSRK�����§��LSQI�MR�4EPIWXMRI�JSV����§��MQQMKVERXW�XS�4EPIWXMRI��7II)YVSTIER�.I[�

MWL�MQQMKVERXW�XS�4EPIWXMRI��*MVWX�%PM]EL�7IGSRH�%PM]EL

1YWPMQW¬�TIVWIGYXMSR�SJ��������§������§��MR�4EPIWXMRI��LMWXSV]�SJ����������§������§��ERH�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�TEVXMXMSR�TPER�����

��§��6SQERW¬�TIVWIGYXMSR�SJ����6YWWME¬W�TIVWIGYXMSR�SJ����7ITLEVHMG��������������WXVEXIK]�XS�IPMQMREXI���

.MV]MW��7EFVM����

.SLRWSR��4EYP����

.SVHERERH�%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ����§��I\GPYWMSR�SJ�.I[W�F]���������,EWLIQMXI�VYPI�SJ����§��ERH�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR��������PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�MR�����SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�4EPIWXMRI�F]����ERH�7M\�(E]�;EV��������§�������

XSVXYVI�ERH�OMPPMRK�F]�����§��X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ERH���;IWX�&ERO�GSRXVSPPIH�F]���������

.YHIE��VIREQIH�4EPIWXMRI��������

.YWX�ERH�9RNYWX�;EVW��;EPIV �����

.YWX�;EV�EKEMRWX�8IVVSV��)PWLXEMR ���������§��

/EXEF��*E[M�EP�����/LEMFEV��.I[W�SJ����/LEPMHM��,YWWIMR����/LEPMHM��6EGLIH����/LEPMP��,ER]����/LEXEM��-VERMER�TVIWMHIRX ����/MRK�(EZMH�,SXIP�FSQFMRK�����§��/MRK�.V���1EVXMR�0YXLIV�����§��/PYK��8SR]�����

0EMPE��1SLEQQEH�%FY����PE[�SJ�VIXYVR�����§���0IEKYI�SJ�2EXMSRW����0IFERSR���0IGLM��7XIVR�KERK ����0IVRIV��1MGLEIP����������0I[MW��.SLR�����0MFIVX]�0SFF]�����0MF]E��EW�VINIGXMSRMWX�WXEXI�������0MGLYH�4EVX]�����0S[IPP��%��0E[VIRGI���

1EEW��4IXIV�����§��1EHLM��-FVELMQ�����1ERHIPE��2IPWSR�����§��������1ERRMRK��7EQYIP����QMPMXEV]�WYTIVMSVMX]��-WVEIP¬W�RIIH�JSV������

���§���1MXGLIPP�'SQQMWWMSR�����1SLEQQIH��������QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRGI��FIX[IIR�XIVVSVMWXW�ERH

-WVEIPM�VIWTSRWIW�����§��1SVSGGS��X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ERH���1SVVMW��&IRR]

%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ����������������§�����§��

-WVEIPM�;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI��������1YWPMQ�ZMSPIRGI�EKEMRWX�.I[W����§��EW�©RI[�LMWXSVMER�ª���4EPIWXMRMERW¬�ZMGXMQ�QIRXEPMX]�����6IWSPYXMSR��������7IGSRH�%PM]EL����[EV�SJ������ERH�������������=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV�����

QYJXM��KVERH��7II,YWWIMRM1YLEQQEH�7II1SLEQQIH1YWPMQW

HMWGVMQMREXMSR�SJ�RSR�1YWPMQW�F]����������,SPSGEYWX�ERH����§����������,YWWIMRM�EW�PIEHIV�SJ����

-2()< ���

Page 272: The Case For Israel

1YWPMQW�GSRXMRYIH TIVWIGYXMSR�SJ�.I[W�F]�������§������§��

2EWWIV��+EQEP�%FHIP����§�������2EMW��������§��������7II�EPWS�,MXPIV��,SPS�

GEYWX©2EM�7GSYXW�ª���2IKIZ�(IWIVX����RIS�2EMW����������©2S�TIEGI�[MXL�-WVEIP��RS�RIKSXMEXMSRW�[MXL

-WVEIP��RS�VIGSKRMXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�ª���2SZEO��&SF�����RYGPIEV�[IETSRW��MR�-WVEIP�����2YWWIMFM��,EEQ����

SMP�MRXIVIWXW�����SRI�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR���3VIR��1MGLEIP��������§�������§��3WPS�TIEGI�TVSGIWW���������3WPS�--�%KVIIQIRX�SJ������������������3XXSQER�)QTMVI��������������������

4EPIWXMRIERH�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�����

���HIQSKVETLMGW�SJ����§��������������§��IXLRMGMX]�MR����§������ERH�*MVWX�%PM]EL����§��LMWXSV]�SJ�GPEMQW�XS���§�ERH�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR�������������.I[MWL�QENSVMX]�MR�EVIEW�SJ�����������������

������§��.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR����������§������§���

��§������PERH�TYVGLEWIW�F]�.I[W����§��PMZMRK�GSRHMXMSRW�MR�����������������QIHMGEP�VIWTSRWI�XS�XIVVSVMWQ�F]�����RSR�.I[MWL�MQQMKVERXW�XS����YRHIV�3XXSQER�VYPI����TIEGI�SJJIVW�VINIGXIH�F]�����§�������§���

���§���4LEPERKMWX�QEWWEGVI�SJ���������4LEWIH�4PER�JSV�PMFIVEXMSR�SJ����§��TSWX�;SVPH�;EV�-�VISVKERMEXMSR�SJ����WLMJXMRK�FSYRHEVMIW�SJ����§��WXEXILSSH���§�����������§�������������

��������§��©XEOISZIVª�F]�.I[W�SJ����§��9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�TEVXMXMSRMRK�SJ��7II9RMXIH

2EXMSRW�4EVXMXMSR�4PER�SJ�����ZMGXMQ�QIRXEPMX]�SJ�����

4EPIWXMRI�0MFIVEXMSR�3VKERMEXMSR��403 ���§�����������§��������

4EPIWXMRI�2EXMSREP�'LEVXIV���4EPIWXMRI6IQIQFIVIH�GSQ��������4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]

ERH�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW���+EE�GMXMIW�GSRXVSPPIH�F]����

LYQER�VMKLXW�ZMSPEXMSRW�F]�����-WPEQ�EW�IWXEFPMWLIH�VIPMKMSR�SJ����������ERH�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR����VINIGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�F]����X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ERH���;IWX�&ERO�GSRXVSPPIH�F]��������

4EPIWXMRMER�2EXMSREP�'LEVXIV����§��4EPIWXMRMER�-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX��7II%VEF�4EPIWXMR�

MER�-WVEIPM�GSRJPMGX4EPIWXMRMER�VIJYKIIW���§���7II�EPWS%VEF

VIJYKIIW4EPIWXMRMERW

HMWTPEGIH�F]�)YVSTIER�.I[W�������§��,MXPIV�ERH�2EMW�WYTTSVXIH�F]�������§���

��§��©QEVKMREPMEXMSRª�SJ����XIVVSVMWQ�WYTTSVXIH�F]����������[EV�JSV�HIWXVYGXMSR�SJ�-WVEIP�����

4ETTI��-PER��������TEVXMXMSR�TPERW

4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR����§��9RMXIH�2EXMSRW��7II9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�4EVXM�

XMSR�4PER4EYPMR��8SQ�����TIEGI

FEVVMIV�XS�����§��GSQTVSQMWI�ERH����IRHMRK�XIVVSVMWQ�RIIHIH�JSV�����JMVWX�WXITW�XS�����§��-WVEIP¬W�IJJSVXW�EX�����§��ERH�.I[MWL�WIXXPIQIRXW�����§��4EPIWXMRMER�GLERKI�RIIHIH�JSV�����TVSZSGEXMSRW�ERH�����§��©VSEH�QETª�XS�������������WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR�ERH���

4IIP�'SQQMWWMSRERH�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR��������ERH�,YWWIMRM����TEVXMXMSR�TPER����§��ZMSPIRX�STTSWMXMSR�XS���

4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�6ITSVX����§������§�������4LEPERKMWX�QEWWEGVI�SJ���������4MRWOIV��0IS����4PEMR�SJ�7LEVSR����TSKVSQW��������������������TSPP�XE\IW����TSTYPEXMSR�ERH�TVSTIVX]�I\GLERKIW����TVSTSVXMSREPMX]�����§��4VSXSGSPW�SJ�XLI�)PHIVW�SJ�>MSR��8LI�����������

���4YPGMJIV��%WL�����

5E[YUNM��*E[M�EP�����

VEGMWQ��-WVEIP�EGGYWIH�SJ�����§�������§��6EJEL��.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR��������6EQEHER��=SQ�/MTTYV �;EV�����§���6EQPE[M��2EFMP�����§��

��� -2()<

Page 273: The Case For Israel

VIJYKIIW�7II%VEF�VIJYKIIW��)YVSTIER�.I[MWLMQQMKVERXW�XS�4EPIWXMRI��*MVWX�%PM]EL��7IG�SRH�%PM]EL

ERH�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW�����GYVXEMPQIRX�SJ�.I[MWL����§������§��-WVEIP�EW�WXEXI�SJ����§��ERH�7M\�(E]�;EV����§��

VINIGXMSRMWXW����������§����������§��VIPMKMSYW�TPYVEPMWQ��MR�-WVEIP�����§��VITEVEXMSR����6IWSPYXMSR�����SJ�9�2��7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�

��§������������VIXYVR��PE[�SJ�����VIXYVR��VMKLX�SJ����������������������������VMKLX�SJ�WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��7IIWIPJ�HIXIVQMRE�

XMSR��VMKLX�SJ6MWLSR��0¬8MSR����©VSEH�QETª�SJ������������������6SQER�GSRUYIWX����§��6SWW��(IRRMW�����6YFIRWXIMR��%QRMR�����VYPI�SJ�PE[��������6YWWMER�TSKVSQW����

7EHEX��%R[EV����������7EJEH�������������������7EMH��)H[EVH

%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ����§��&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR����GVMXMGMWQ�SJ�-WVEIP�����IPMQMREXMSR�SJ�-WVEIPMW���,YWWIMRM�EW�©ZSMGI�SJ�4EPIWXMRMERW�ª���-WVEIP¬W�TIEGI�IJJSVXW�����.I[MWL�HMWWMHIRXW�����SR�©RI[�LMWXSVMERW�ª���4EPIWXMRMERW�EW�ZMGXMQW�SJ�GSRJPMGX����VINIGXMSR�SJ�X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR���§�����9�2��4EVXMXMSR�4PER����[EV�SJ�����§������������>MSRMWX�MQTIVMEPMWQ��������

WERNEOW�HMWXVMGXW ����§��7EYHM�%VEFME��X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR�ERH���WGLSPEVW��-WVEIPM��FS]GSXX�SJ�����§���7IGSRH�%PM]EL����§��WIGYPEV�WXEXI��FMREXMSREP���§�7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�6IWSPYXMSR��������§��������

���WIPJ�HIXIVQMREXMSR��VMKLX�SJ

ERH�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR������������'LYVGLMPP�ERH����,YWWIMRM�ERH��������EQSRK�.I[MWL�VIJYKIIW�ERH�HIWGIRHERXW��

������QYXYEP����TIEGI�ERH���ERH�9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�TEVXMXMSR��������

7LEJM��,EMHIV�%FHIP����7LEQMV��=MXLEO����

7LEVSR��%VMIP���§���������������§��������������������������

7LILEHIL��7EPEL����������7LMOEOM��/LEPMP�����7LYOIMV]��%LQEH����7MXXE��7EPQER�%FY�����7M\�(E]�;EV����§������§�������§��7PEXIV��.IVSQI����7SOSPSZ��2EGLYQ����7SVPMI��7XIMREV����7SYVERM��6ENM�����WTIIGL�ERH�MRJSVQEXMSR��JVIIHSQ�SJ�MR�-WVEIP�

��������7XEPMR������������7XEV�SJ�(EZMH����7XIVR��)PEEV�����7XVEMXW�SJ�8MVER��������WXEXYXI�SJ�PMQMXEXMSRW�JSV�KVMIZERGIW������WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW���§�������§�������§���

��������§�������§�������7YPPMZER��%RHVI[�����7YQQIVW��0E[VIRGI�����§��������W[EWXMOE����7]VME

ERH�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR���������-WVEIP¬W�EXXIQTXW�XS�QEOI�TIEGI�[MXL�����EW�VINIGXMSRMWX�WXEXI�������ERH�7M\�(E]�;EV�������������ERH�=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV�����§���

8IP�%ZMZ����������������8IQTPI�1SYRX���§�������§�������XIVVSVMWQ��7II�EPWSGMZMPMERW��XEVKIXMRK�ERH

OMPPMRK�SJ��WYMGMHI�FSQFMRKW%VEJEX�ERH��������EXXEGOW�TVIZIRXIH�F]�-WVEIP�����§��������

���EJXIV�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW����

�§�������§�������F]�GLMPHVIR�ERH�]SYRK�EHYPXW�����§��ERH�G]GPI�SJ�ZMSPIRGI�����§��HIXIVVIRGI�SJ���������������§��IRHMRK�SJ�����KSEPW�SJ�����§��LMWXSV]�SJ�����§��,YWWIMRM�ERH����§��-WPEQMG�XVEMRMRK�QIXLSHW�����§��ERH�-WVEIPM�SGGYTEXMSR����-WVEIP¬W�VIXEPMEXMSR�EKEMRWX�����§�������§��QIHMGEP�VIWTSRWI�XS�����§��QIXLSHW�SJ�����§��ERH�QSVEP�IUYMZEPIRGI�����§��F]�RIS�2EMW�����4EPIWXMRMER�ZIVWYW�-WVEIPM�HIEXLW�HYI�XS�

���§��TIEGI�SJJIVW�ERH�MRGVIEWI�MR�����§��403�ERH���������§��������ERH�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSR�����§��

-2()< ���

Page 274: The Case For Israel

XIVVSVMWQ�GSRXMRYIH F]�[SQIR�����[SVPH�����

8MFIVMEW��.I[MWL�TVIWIRGI�MR��������8MFIX��SGGYTEXMSR�SJ�F]�'LMRE�����§��������

���§��8SPIHS��'IGMPME����XSVXYVI�����§�����������������§���8VERWNSVHER���������7II�EPWS.SVHER8YVOMWL�VYPI����8[EMR��1EVO����§��X[S�WXEXI�WSPYXMSR���§������

GSRWIRWYW�JSV��������IJJIGXW�SJ���������.I[W�EGGYWIH�SJ�VINIGXMRK����§��VINIGXMSR�SJ����������§����������§������WXEVXMRK�TSMRXW������ERH�9�2��4EVXMXMSR�4PER����§������

9RMXIH�2EXMSRW%VEF�VIJYKII�TVSFPIQ�ERH�������§��'SQQMWWMSR�SR�,YQER�6MKLXW�����§��'SQQMXXII�%KEMRWX�8SVXYVI����������§��,MKL�'SQQMWWMSR�JSV�6IJYKIIW����§��6IPMIJ�ERH�;SVOW��6IJYKII �%KIRG]����§���

��������7IGYVMX]�'SYRGMP�6IWSPYXMSR��������§���

��������9RMXIH�2EXMSRW�4EVXMXMSR�4PER�SJ������������

������������������§��9RMXIH�7XEXIW

ERH�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR����ERH�GMZMPMER�GEWYEPXMIW�����§��IZIRLERHIHRIWW�MR�1MHHPI�)EWX�����§��-WVEIP¬W�VIPEXMSRWLMT�[MXL�����§�������§��ERH�XEVKIXIH�EWWEWWMREXMSRW����������ERH�XSVXYVI��������������������§��������

���§���ERH�;SVPH�;EV�-����

YRMZIVWMXMIW��GEPP�XS�FS]GSXX�-WVEIPM�WGLSPEVW�MR����§���

ZMPE]IXW�EHQMRMWXVEXMZI�YRMXW ����§��ZMSPIRGI�7II�EPWSGMZMPMERW��XEVKIXMRK�ERH�OMPPMRK

SJ��TSKVSQW��XIVVSVMWQEJXIV�&EPJSYV�(IGPEVEXMSR������������EJXIV�'EQT�(EZMH�8EFE�RIKSXMEXMSRW����

�§�������§��G]GPI�SJ�����§��SJ�MRXMJEHE�����EJXIV�4IIP�'SQQMWWMSR�TEVXMXMSR�TPER����

:SMGIW�SJ�XLI�%VEFW����

;EPWL��)PWE�����§��;EPIV��1MGLEIP����������§�������[EV��PE[W�SJ�����§��;EV�SJ�-RHITIRHIRGI��-WVEIPM����§������[EV�SJ������ERH���������§��;IMQERR��'LEMQ����;IWX�&ERO

%PSR�4PER�JSV����§��ERRI\EXMSR�SJ�������&EVEO¬W�SJJIV�SJ�����JIHIVEXMSR�[MXL�%VEF�WXEXI���-WVEIPM�WIXXPIQIRXW�SR���������������§��.SVHER¬W�GSRXVSP�SJ����ERH�4EPIWXMRMER�%YXLSVMX]��������

;IWX�.IVYWEPIQ��������;IWXIVR�;EPP���������;L]�8IVVSVMWQ�;SVOW�(IVWLS[MX �����;MPWSR��;SSHVS[������������;SSHLIEH�'SQQMWWMSR����;SVPH�'SRJIVIRGI�%KEMRWX�6EGMWQ�����§��;SVPH�;EV�-��������;SVPH�;EV�--��VIJYKIIW�SJ����

=E¬EPSR��1SWLI�����§��=SQ�/MTTYV�;EV�����§���=YKSWPEZME���

>EERIIR��1SLEQQIH�����>ELV��%QIV�����>EQMV��=MXLEO�����§��>EXQI��1ELVSYH�����>MSR��PSRKMRK�JSV����§������>MSRMWQ��������§��>MSRMWX�'SRKVIWW��JMVWX����>MSRMWXW����

��� -2()<