6
170 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 2011 VOL. 35 NO. 2 © 2011 The Authors. ANZJPH © 2011 Public Health Association of Australia The burden of fall-related injury among older persons in New South Wales F all-related injury among older people is a major public health issue which, with the growth of the ageing population, threatens to place significantly increased demands on the public healthcare system. 1-3 Around one in three older people living in the community are estimated to fall each year and many fall more than once. 4-7 In Australia, almost half all fall injuries among older persons resulting in hospital admission occur in the home and a further 22% take place in residential care facilities (RAC). 8 Common injuries sustained following a fall include hip fracture, head injury and other limb fractures. 9 Often older individuals who fall are not able to return to their pre-fall activities. 10 In addition to the injury and the associated pain and disability suffered, falls can also instil a fear of falling, 11 decrease levels of activity, 12 raise levels of anxiety and depression 13 and result in post-traumatic stress disorder, 14 loss of independence 11 and admission to residential care. 9 An injurious fall can therefore have significant personal and economic consequences for the individual and their family. In recent years there have been a number of international studies that have estimated the cost of fall injuries. 15-17 Estimates of the cost of injuries are necessary to guide decision makers in determining funding priorities and to support cost-effectiveness and cost- benefit analyses of the most effective means of preventing injury. To date, there has only been one population- level study conducted in New South Wales (NSW), which estimated the cost of fall- related injury. 18 However, these costs were established in the context of a broader all-age, all-injury study, which included limited cost components and is now quite dated. The study was commissioned by NSW Health to provide comprehensive, up-to-date estimates of the costs associated with fall-related injury to underpin the next iteration of the state falls prevention plan and to provide input for cost-benefit analyses of falls prevention programs. Objective This study aimed to quantify the economic burden of injury associated with unintentional falls in individuals aged 65 years and older, in NSW for the period 1 July 2006 to 30 June 2007 (2006/07), by estimating the total cost of healthcare associated with these injuries. Method There is very little robust information available on the utilisation and costs of health services following a fall, once a patient has Submitted: February 2010 Revision requested: May 2010 Accepted: July 2010 Correspondence to: Dr Wendy Watson, NSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052; e-mail: [email protected] Wendy Watson NSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre, University of New South Wales Angela Clapperton Monash University Accident Research Centre, Victoria Rebecca Mitchell NSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre and Department of Aviation, University of New South Wales Abstract Objective: To develop a comprehensive estimate of the burden of fall-related injury among older people in New South Wales. Methods: Fall injuries in 2006/07 were estimated using information from several datasets and the literature. Healthcare costs were calculated using Australia- Refined–Diagnostic-Related Group costs for hospital episodes of care and average costs for Emergency Department presentations, ambulance transport and residential aged care (RAC). Ratios of the cost of inpatient care relative to other health services, derived from the literature, were used to estimate the costs associated with these services. Results: In 2006/07, in NSW, there were almost 143,000 falls, among older people, resulting in injuries requiring medical treatment. The total cost of healthcare associated with these falls was estimated at $558.5 million. Although accounting for only 6% of the NSW population aged 65 years and older, persons in RAC accounted for 15% of the total cost of falls injury and 21% of hospital inpatient costs. Conclusion and implications: This study demonstrates the extremely high economic cost of falls in older persons and highlights the disproportionate impact of falls in RAC. The study underscores the urgent need for significant investment in fall-injury prevention efforts in both the community and RAC settings. Key words: fall injury, cost, older person, disability, injury burden. Aust NZ J Public Health. 2011;170-5 doi: 10.1111/j.1753-6405.2010.00656.x Environmental Hazards Article

The burden of fall-related injury among older persons in New South Wales

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

170 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 2011 vol. 35 no. 2© 2011 The Authors. ANZJPH © 2011 Public Health Association of Australia

The burden of fall-related injury among

older persons in New South Wales

Fall-related injury among older

people is a major public health issue

which, with the growth of the ageing

population, threatens to place significantly

increased demands on the public healthcare

system.1-3 Around one in three older people

living in the community are estimated to fall

each year and many fall more than once.4-7 In

Australia, almost half all fall injuries among

older persons resulting in hospital admission

occur in the home and a further 22% take

place in residential care facilities (RAC).8

Common injuries sustained following a

fall include hip fracture, head injury and

other limb fractures.9 Often older individuals

who fall are not able to return to their pre-fall

activities.10 In addition to the injury and the

associated pain and disability suffered, falls

can also instil a fear of falling,11 decrease

levels of activity,12 raise levels of anxiety

and depression13 and result in post-traumatic

stress disorder,14 loss of independence11

and admission to residential care.9 An

injurious fall can therefore have significant

personal and economic consequences for the

individual and their family.

In recent years there have been a number of

international studies that have estimated the

cost of fall injuries.15-17 Estimates of the cost

of injuries are necessary to guide decision

makers in determining funding priorities

and to support cost-effectiveness and cost-

benefit analyses of the most effective means

of preventing injury.

To date, there has only been one population-

level study conducted in New South Wales

(NSW), which estimated the cost of fall-

related injury.18 However, these costs were

established in the context of a broader all-age,

all-injury study, which included limited cost

components and is now quite dated. The

study was commissioned by NSW Health to

provide comprehensive, up-to-date estimates

of the costs associated with fall-related

injury to underpin the next iteration of the

state falls prevention plan and to provide

input for cost-benefit analyses of falls

prevention programs.

ObjectiveThis study aimed to quantify the economic

burden of injury associated with unintentional

falls in individuals aged 65 years and older,

in NSW for the period 1 July 2006 to 30 June

2007 (2006/07), by estimating the total cost

of healthcare associated with these injuries.

MethodThere is very little robust information

available on the utilisation and costs of health

services following a fall, once a patient has

Submitted: February 2010 Revision requested: May 2010 Accepted: July 2010Correspondence to:Dr Wendy Watson, NSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre, University of New South Wales, NSW 2052; e-mail: [email protected]

Wendy WatsonNSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre, University of New South Wales

Angela ClappertonMonash University Accident Research Centre, Victoria

Rebecca MitchellNSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre and Department of Aviation, University of New South Wales

Abstract

Objective: To develop a comprehensive

estimate of the burden of fall-related injury

among older people in New South Wales.

Methods: Fall injuries in 2006/07 were

estimated using information from several

datasets and the literature. Healthcare

costs were calculated using Australia-

Refined–Diagnostic-Related Group

costs for hospital episodes of care and

average costs for Emergency Department

presentations, ambulance transport and

residential aged care (RAC). Ratios of

the cost of inpatient care relative to other

health services, derived from the literature,

were used to estimate the costs associated

with these services.

Results: In 2006/07, in NSW, there were

almost 143,000 falls, among older people,

resulting in injuries requiring medical

treatment. The total cost of healthcare

associated with these falls was estimated

at $558.5 million. Although accounting

for only 6% of the NSW population aged

65 years and older, persons in RAC

accounted for 15% of the total cost of falls

injury and 21% of hospital inpatient costs.

Conclusion and implications: This study

demonstrates the extremely high economic

cost of falls in older persons and highlights

the disproportionate impact of falls in

RAC. The study underscores the urgent

need for significant investment in fall-injury

prevention efforts in both the community

and RAC settings.

Key words: fall injury, cost, older person,

disability, injury burden.

Aust NZ J Public Health. 2011;170-5

doi: 10.1111/j.1753-6405.2010.00656.x

Environmental Hazards Article

2011 vol. 35 no. 2 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 171© 2011 The Authors. ANZJPH © 2010 Public Health Association of Australia

been discharged from the emergency department (ED) or hospital.

It is therefore difficult to establish a definitive cost estimate for

injury associated with falls solely using a ‘bottom-up’ health

services utilisation approach. This approach was used where

there was reasonably solid health service utilisation and unit cost

data available, such as for hospital inpatients, ED presentations,

ambulance transport and RAC. However, for other areas of

expenditure the study had to rely on information derived from

the literature.The study takes a societal perspective in that it attempts to

include all costs associated with treatment and care resulting

from a fall-related injury that occurred in 2006/07, irrespective

of who pays or the sector responsible for providing the services.

All costs are expressed in 2006/07 dollars and were assumed to

have occurred within the year following injury. The only exception

was the cost of RAC which, in accordance with data from the

Australian Institute of Health and Welfare19 was assumed to have

been incurred over several years and was discounted accordingly

at 5% per annum in line with current Australian practice.20

Incidence estimationUnintentional fall-related injury for individuals aged 65 years

and over, was estimated using information from several sources

for 2006/07. Three mutually exclusive categories of care were

identified for the purpose of this study:

• Hospital admissions; • EDpresentations(notadmitted); and • Non-hospitaltreatment(includingGeneralPractitioners(GPs)

and allied health professionals). Estimates for each treatment level were made separately for

the two main settings in which older people reside, that is, in the community and in RAC.

The NSWAdmitted Patients Data Collection (APDC)provided information on inpatient admissions from all hospitals in NSW. Unintentional falls were identified using International Classification of Diseases, Version 10, Australian Modification (ICD-10-AM)21 principal external cause codes of a fall (W00-W19) and principal diagnosis codes of an injury (S00-T75 or T79). Episodes of care relating to transfers between hospitals and changes in the service category were excluded.

As it is not possible to consistently identify fall-related

presentations to EDs in existing NSW datasets, Victorian data

were used to establish the ratio of admitted to non-admitted ED

presentations. To establish robust ratios, three years of data (2005,

2006 and 2007) were used. Fall hospitalisations were selected from

the Victorian Admitted Episodes Dataset (VAED) using the same

methoddescribedaboveforNSWAPDCdata.EDpresentations

were selected from the Victorian Emergency Minimum Dataset

(VEMD) if the cause of the ED presentation was recorded as a

fall, if the record was classed as an ‘initial’ visit and if the person

was not admitted. Average annual estimates of admissions and

presentations were calculated by gender and five-year age-group

and the ratios of admissions to presentations determined. These

ratios were then applied to the incident falls admissions derived

from theNSWAPDC to estimate the incident fall-related ED

presentations in NSW.

Datafromthe2009NSWFallsPreventionSurveywereused

to estimate the total number of falls incidents and the number

of these resulting in medical treatment outside the hospital

setting. These were derived by applying the weighted population

proportions from this survey to the estimated 2006/07 population

of older people living in the community (total estimated resident

population22 less the population in RAC19) by gender and five-year

age-groups.

The number of fall injuries in RAC was estimated by calculating

the number of falls per year based on the population in aged care,

in NSW, at 30 June 200719 using proportions derived from the

literature.23 The number of falls requiring medical treatment by

age was estimated using ratios derived from Baranzini et al.24 RAC

fall injuries attended by health professionals (GPs,alliedhealth

or nursing staff) outside the hospital system were calculated by

subtracting the hospital admissions and ED attendances from the

total estimate of fall injuries.

Cost estimationCosts were estimated separately for community and RAC

residents and included all relevant cost components for each of the three levels of care identified above. For example, an ED attendance would include the cost of ED but may also include ambulancetransport,outpatientcare,GPand/orspecialistvisits,allied health services, pharmaceuticals, home nursing and/or domiciliary services.

Inpatient hospital costs for all admitted patients were calculated

using theAustralia-Related–Diagnostic-Related Group (AR-

DRG)codes recorded in theNSWAPDC for each episodeof

care.AverageAR-DRGVersion5.0costswereappliedtoeach

episode of care using data from the NSW Cost of Care Standards

2006/07.25 These costs include all in-hospital medical and allied

health treatment (including the ED cost), nursing, diagnostics and

pharmaceuticals. Adjustments were made for transfers and same-

day episodes in accordance with the methods outlined in the NSW

Cost of Care Standards.25CostsforAR-DRGrehabilitationcodes

Z60A and Z60B were derived from the National Hospital Cost

Data Collection (NHCDC) 2006/07.26 Since no value was provided

by either source for episodes coded Z60C (Rehabilitation – same

day), the average cost for a Tier 2 outpatient rehabilitation clinic

($415) was applied.25

Cases that attended the ED, but were not admitted, were

assigned the average cost of an ED presentation ($380) as defined

in the NSW Cost of Care Standards 2006/07.25 The average cost

of emergency ($528) and non-emergency ($311) ambulance

transport, in 2006/07, was supplied by the Ambulance Service of

NSW. These costs were applied to the estimated number of fall-

related ambulance trips in NSW in 2006/07. This was calculated

by applying the proportion of emergency and non-emergency

trips for presentations and admissions from the VEMD to the

NSWincidentestimates.AlltransfersintheNSWAPDCwere

assumed to involve non-emergency ambulance transport between

hospitals as were patients discharged to nursing homes. Nursing

home residents were assumed to have arrived and departed the

hospital by ambulance.

Environmental Hazards Burden of fall-related injury

172 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 2011 vol. 35 no. 2© 2011 The Authors. ANZJPH © 2011 Public Health Association of Australia

The cost of RAC was calculated by estimating the number of

community fall-related hospital admissions that were discharged

to RAC and applying average costs to each case. The numbers of

persons discharged to respite and permanent RAC following a fall

injury were estimated using proportions derived from tables in

Karmel et al.27 and applying these to the NSW hospital admissions

estimates. The cost of respite and permanent RAC was estimated

using average lengths of stay (by gender and care type) and average

cost per place-day ($142) from the AIHW publication, Residential

aged care in Australia 2006/07: A statistical overview.19

The cost of hospital outpatient services, pharmaceuticals and

GP,specialistandalliedhealthconsultationswasestimatedusing

Australian health expenditures for falls injury in 1993/94.28 The

ratio of the cost for each service category to the total fall-related

inpatient cost was calculated from this study by age-group and

gender. These ratios were then multiplied by the total cost of

fall-related hospital admissions in NSW in 2006/07 to obtain

an estimate of the total cost of each of these health services

for each age group and gender. The cost of outpatient services

was distributed proportionally between admissions and ED

presentations. Costs for pharmaceuticals, GPs, specialists and

allied health professionals were distributed proportionally between

admissions, ED presentations and non-hospital attendances.

The cost of community nursing and domiciliary services

associated with fall injuries occurring among community-dwelling

older people were calculated using the proportional cost of these

services compared to inpatient hospital costs derived by age-group

and gender from Hall and Hendrie and Hendrie et al.29-30 These

proportions were then applied to inpatient costs for community

fall-related injury in older people in NSW in 2006/07. It was

assumed that persons admitted to hospital for treatment would

require a greater proportion of community nursing and domiciliary

services than those who attended other services. Consequently,

half of these costs were assigned to hospital-admitted patients

and the remainder was distributed proportionally between ED

presentations and other medically treated injuries.

ResultsIncidence

In 2006/07, it was estimated that over 251,000 individuals aged

65 years or older (or 27% of the older NSW population) fell at

least once (Table 1). In total, there were an estimated 507,000 falls

and, of these, almost 143,000 (28%) resulted in injuries requiring

some form of medical treatment.

Table 2 presents the estimated number of medically treated falls

by level of treatment required and residential status of the person

who fell. Overall, about 18% of falls-related injuries resulted

in admission to hospital with the majority of treatment (69%)

occurringoutsidethehospitalsetting.PersonsinRAC(5.6%of

the older population) accounted for a disproportionate number of

medically-treated falls injury (30% of the total).

Healthcare costsThe total cost of healthcare associated with fall injuries in older

people in NSW, in 2006/07, was estimated at $558.5 million

(Table 2). Hospital admitted cases accounted for 84.5% of total

costs, ED presentations accounted for 9% and other non-hospital

attendances for 6.5%. Not surprisingly, falls by people living in the

community accounted for the majority of the costs (85%). Women

accounted for 69% of total healthcare costs with women living in

the community accounting for 58% of total costs.

Hospital sector treatment (inpatient, ED and outpatient services)

consumed the majority of costs associated with fall-related injury

among older people accounting for 58% of all treatment costs.

RACaccountedforafurther23%,medicaltreatments(GPsand

specialists) 6% and ambulance transport 4% (Table 3).

People living inRACaccounted for15%of totalhealthcare

costs for fall-related injury despite accounting for only 5.6% of

the population aged 65 years and older. In particular, residents of

aged care account for a disproportionate share of hospital inpatient

costs. While representing only 1 in 18 of the older population,

they account for more than one-fifth (21%) of fall-related hospital

inpatient costs (Table 3).

Table 1: Estimated resident population, number of people who fell and total number of falls by gender and place of residence, persons aged 65 years and older, NSW, 2006/07.

Place of residence by level of care Male Female Persons Number Row % Number Row % Number Row %

CommunityEstimated resident population 402,663 45.8 476,915 54.2 879,578 100

Number of people who fell 97,905 43.4 127,670 56.6 225,575 100

Total number of falls 192,627 45.9 226,596 54.1 419,225 100

Residential aged careEstimated resident population 14,364 27.8 37,390 72.2 51,754 100

Number of people who fell 7,182 27.8 18,695 72.2 25,877 100

Total number of falls 25,528 29.0 62,454 71.0 87,982 100

All NSWEstimated resident population 417,027 44.8 514,305 55.2 931,332 100

Number of people who fell 105,088 41.8 146,365 58.2 251,453 100Total number of falls 218,156 43.0 289,051 57.0 507,207 100

Watson, Clapperton and Mitchell

2011 vol. 35 no. 2 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 173© 2011 The Authors. ANZJPH © 2011 Public Health Association of Australia

Discussion This study highlights the significant cost of fall-related injury

both to the health system and to the community. The total cost of

healthcare associated fall-related injury to NSW in 2006/07 was

estimated at $558.5 million. Although these costs are not all borne

by NSW Health, the estimated cost of falls among older people

in NSW, in 2006/07, was equivalent to almost 5% of the NSW

health budget in that year.31

Despite accounting for only 6% of the NSW population aged

65 years and older, people in RAC are over-represented in the

falls injury data. It is estimated that they account for 15% of the

total healthcare cost of fall injuries and 21% of inpatient costs.

However, the true impact of falls in RAC is likely to be higher

given the data constraints and methodological limitations of the

study described below.

StrengthsThis is the most comprehensive estimate of the population

burden of fall-related injuries in NSW conducted to date. This

study includes the majority of cost components associated with the

medical treatment and care of fall-related injuries for individuals

aged 65 years and older in 2006/07. It is also the first study to

disaggregate the costs of fall-related injuries between those

occurring in the community and those in RAC. Other fall injury

costing studies in the US,2-3 the UK16 and Australia18,30 did not

report separately on the cost of fall injuries in RAC.

LimitationsThe main limitation of this study lies in the lack of

comprehensive health service utilisation data in which falls and

other conditions can be identified. Lack of data on more minor

injuries and inadequacies in existing data meant that a number of

Table 3: Estimated health care costs of all medically treated fall-related injuries by gender, place of residence and level of care, persons aged 65 years and older, NSW, 2006/07.

Place of residence by level of care Male Female Persons Cost $m Column % Cost $m Column % Cost $m Column %

CommunityHospital admissions 124.60 71.8 282.66 73.4 407.26 72.9ED attendances 17.58 10.1 18.80 4.9 36.37 6.5Non-hospital treatments 8.39 4.8 22.28 5.8 30.67 5.5Total community 150.56 86.8 323.74 84.1 474.30 84.9Residential aged careHospital admissions 16.54 9.5 47.90 12.4 64.44 11.6ED attendances 4.14 2.4 9.73 2.5 13.87 2.5Non-hospital treatments 2.28 1.3 3.56 0.9 5.84 1.0Total residential aged care 22.96 13.2 61.19 15.9 84.16 15.1All NSWHospital admissions 141.14 81.3 330.56 85.9 471.70 84.5ED attendances 21.72 12.5 28.53 7.4 50.25 9.0Non-hospital treatments 10.66 6.1 25.85 6.7 36.51 6.5Total NSW 173.52 100.0 384.93 100.0 558.46 100.0

Table 2: Estimated number of falls requiring medical treatment by level of treatment, gender and place of residence, persons aged 65 years and older, NSW, 2006/07.

Place of residence by level of care Male Female Persons Number Column % Number Column % Number Column %

CommunityHospital admissions 6,397 12.4 13,408 14.6 19,805 13.9ED attendances 4,267 8.3 7,211 7.9 11,478 8.0Non-hospital treatments 28,577 55.4 40,579 44.5 69,156 48.4Total community 39,241 76.1 61,198 67.0 100,439 70.3Residential aged care

Hospital admissions 1,401 2.7 4,355 4.8 5,756 4.0ED attendances 1,465 2.9 5,523 6.0 6,988 4.9Non-hospital treatments 9,451 18.3 20,339 22.2 29,790 20.8Total residential aged care 12,317 23.9 30,217 33.0 42,534 29.7All NSWHospital admissions 7,798 15.1 17,763 19.4 25,561 17.9ED attendances 5,732 11.1 12,734 13.9 18,466 12.9Non-hospital treatments 38,028 73.8 60,918 66.7 98,946 69.2Total NSW 51,558 100.0 91,415 100.0 142,973 100.0

Environmental Hazards Burden of fall-related injury

174 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 2011 vol. 35 no. 2© 2011 The Authors. ANZJPH © 2011 Public Health Association of Australia

assumptions had to be made and the researchers had to sometimes

rely on data or literature that was dated.

Even in the NSWAPDC data, there was a large proportion

(around 20%) of ‘unspecified’ place of occurrence codes. Where

the location of the fall was not specified, the case was designated

a community fall and therefore falls in the community have been

over-estimated at the expense of falls in RAC. This will also impact

on the inpatient costs with the cost of community admissions

being over-estimated while the costs associated with RAC will

be under-estimated.

The use of proportions from Victorian data to estimate

the number of ED attendances in NSW was not ideal as the

relationship between the distribution of services in the two states

is unknown. However, the use of Victorian data represents the

best approach available.

The use of self-report data from the 2009 Falls Prevention

Survey may be subject to recall bias as respondents were asked to

report on falls and treatment for fall-related injuries in the previous

12months.However,areviewofcohortstudiesbyGanzetal.32

showed that, in three studies for which data were available, recall

of any fall in the previous year is relatively specific (91–95%)

but somewhat less sensitive (80–89%) than intensive prospective

data collection involving postcards or diaries. In addition, one

Australian study has shown that individuals who suffered an

injurious fall were significantly more likely to recall their falls

than those who were not injured.33

Data on falls in RAC in Australia is limited and hence it was

necessary to rely on a rather dated review to estimate the total

number of falls experienced.23 While more recent data was used

to estimate the ratio of non-injurious to injurious falls,24 this data

was from a single study conducted overseas and as such may not

be representative of the situation in NSW.

There is very little population-level information on health

services utilisation following a fall, once a patient has been

discharged from the ED or hospital. Consequently, approximately

25% of the total treatment cost was estimated using ratios derived

fromMathersandPenm,28 Hall and Hendrie and Hendrie at al.29-30

on the assumption that the ratios of inpatient to other costs have

not changed over time. While this is unlikely and not ideal, there is

very little other information available that would provide reliable

estimates for these components.

The limitations of this study highlight the inadequacies in the

current NSW health data and in the understanding of the patient

journey, beyond the hospital, following a fall. Further work is

needed to address these shortcomings and, in particular, the

standardisation of data collection systems and coding in NSW EDs

is essential to identify injury causes and facilitate the quantification

of less severe injuries from falls and other causes.

ValidationAlthough based on a relatively small sample of 122 community-

dwelling older people, Tiedemann et al.34 included the same cost

components (except for RAC) as the current study in their follow-

up of people who sought medical treatment for a fall-related injury.

By applying the average treatment costs (using 2006 dollars) from

this study to the estimated community fall injury cases in the

current study, it is possible to make a comparison of total costs

between the two. The estimated cost of treatment for falls-related

injury among older people living in the community, in NSW, based

on the average costs from the Tiedemann study, totalled $366

million compared to a total of $346 million (excluding RAC) in

the current study.

While there are limitations around some of the cost estimates in

the current study, the majority of total healthcare costs are based

on reliable incidence estimates and unit cost data. In addition,

the validation using data from the Tiedemann study provides

confidence in the current results since the difference between the

two studies in the estimates derived was only 5.7%.

ImplicationsIn addition to the standard measures of morbidity and mortality,

the provision of information on the estimated cost of fall-related

injury is an essential step in advocating for the need for prevention

strategies in this area. This study provides data to inform the

cost-effective analyses of falls prevention interventions. This

information provided can be used in conjunction with information

on the cost of fall-prevention strategies to aid policy makers and

Table 4: Estimated health care costs of all medically treated fall-related injuries by place of residence and cost component, persons aged 65 years and older, NSW, 2006/07.

Cost component Community RAC NSW Cost $m Column % Cost $m Column % Cost $m Column %

Hospital inpatient 208.14 43.9 54.54 64.8 262.68 47.0

ED and outpatient 51.84 10.9 9.05 10.8 60.90 10.9

Total hospital sector 259.98 54.8 63.59 75.6 323.58 57.9Residential aged care 127.90 27.0 – – 127.90 22.9Medical treatments 28.11 5.9 6.05 7.2 34.16 6.1Pharmaceuticals 7.68 1.6 1.50 1.8 9.19 1.6Allied Health 15.97 3.4 3.09 3.7 19.06 3.4Ambulance 12.12 2.6 9.92 11.8 22.04 3.9Community nursing 9.12 1.9 – – 9.12 1.6Domiciliary services 13.42 2.8 – – 13.43 2.4Total 474.30 100.0 84.15 100.0 558.46 100.0

Watson, Clapperton and Mitchell

2011 vol. 35 no. 2 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 175© 2011 The Authors. ANZJPH © 2011 Public Health Association of Australia

practitioners select the best value countermeasures from the

growing number of proven falls prevention interventions.

Despite its limitations, the study provides the most

comprehensive population-level estimate of the economic cost

of falls among older people in NSW and is the first to attempt

to disaggregate these costs between community and RAC. It

highlights the significant over-representation of residents of aged

care facilities in the data and their disproportionate contribution to

the healthcare costs associated with the treatment of fall injuries.

The study also highlights the considerable cost of these

injuries to the NSW health system and underscores the significant

investment in falls injury prevention necessary, in both the

community and RAC settings, to reduce these costs. While

research has identified a number of effective interventions that

can significantly decrease the incidence of fall-related injuries,

the implementation of fall injury prevention programs at the

population level remains limited. Further efforts are necessary

in NSW to promote these programs and to support their uptake

at the local level.

AcknowledgementsW. Watson and A. Clapperton were supported by the NSW

Health Department. R Mitchell was partially supported by the

NSW Health Department and by an ARC-linkage post-doctoral

fellowship(LP0990057).

This research was undertaken while A. Clapperton was a staff

member at the NSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre

in 2008/09.

The authors wish to acknowledge the Centre for Epidemiology

and Research at the NSW Health Department for providing

access to the Health Outcomes and Information Statistical Toolkit

(HOIST) to obtain data analysed in this study. The HOIST system

refers to a data access, analysis and reporting facility established

and operated by the Centre for Epidemiology and Research,

Population Health Division, NSW Department of Health.The

authors would also like to thank the:

• VictorianInjurySurveillanceUnit forprovidingaggregated

data from the VAED and VEMD;

• NSW Population Health Survey team for the provision of

preliminarydatafromthe2009FallsPreventionSurvey;and

• AmbulanceServiceNSWforprovisionofaverageunitcosts.

References1. Moller J. Projected Costs of fall Related Injury to Older Persons Due to

Demographic Change in Australia. Canberra (AUST): Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing; 2003.

2. RoudsariB,EbelB,CorsoP,MolinariN,KoepsellT.Theacutemedicalcarecosts of fall-related injuries among the US older adults. Injury. 2005;36:1316-22.

3. StevensJ,CorsoP,FinkelsteinE,MillerT.Thecostsoffatalandnon-fatalfallsamong older adults. Inj Prev. 2006;12:290-5.

4. CampbellAJ,BorrieMJ,SpearsGF.Riskfactorsforfallsinacommunity-based prospective study of people 70 years and older. Journal of Gerontology. 1989;44(4):M112-M7.

5. Morris M, Osborne D, Hill K, Kendig H, Lundgren-Lindquist B, Reid J. Predisposingfactorsforoccasionalandmultiplefallsinolderpeoplewholiveat home. Australian Journal of Physiotherapy. 2004;50:153-9.

6. Nevitt MC, Cummings SR, Kidd S, Black D. Risk factors for recurent non-syncopal falls: a prospective study. JAMA. 1989;261:2663-8.

7. TinettiME,SpeechleyM,GinterSF.Riskfactorsforfallsamongelderlypersonsliving in the community. N Engl J Med. 1988;319:1701-7.

8. BradleyC,PointerS.Hospitalisations Due to Falls by Older People, Australia 2005-06. Adelaide (AUST): Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 2008.

9. Tinetti M, Williams C. Falls, injuries due to falls, and the risk of admission to a nursing home. N Engl J Med. 1997;337:1279-84.

10. SattinR.FallsAmongOlderPersons:APublicHealthPerspective.Annu Rev Public Health. 1992;13:489-508.

11. TinettiM,PowellL.Fearoffallingandlowself-efficacy:acauseofdependencein elderly persons. Journal of Gerontology. 1993;48 Suppl:35-8.

12. King M, Tinetti M. Falls in community-dwelling older persons. J Am Geriatr Soc. 1995;43(10):1146-54.

13. Downton J,Andrews K. Postural disturbance and psychological symptomsamongst elderly people living at home. Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 1990;5(2):93-8.

14. Chung M, McKee K, Austin C, Barkby H, Hayley Brown H, Cash S, et al. Posttraumaticstressdisorderinolderpeopleafterafall.Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2009;24(9):955-64.

15. CarrollN,SlattumP,CoxF.Thecostoffallsamongthecommunity-dwellingelderly. J Manag Care Pharm. 2005;11(4):307-16.

16. ScuffhamP,ChaplinS,LegoodR.Incidenceandcostsofunintentionalfallsin older people in the United Kingdom. J Epidemiol Community Health. 2003;57:740-4.

17. StevensJ,CorsoP,FinkelsteinE,MillerT.Thecostsoffatalandnon-fatalfallsamong older adults. Inj Prev. 2006;12:290-5.

18. Potter-ForbesM,AisbettC.Injury Costs! A Validation of the Burden of Injury in NSW, 1998-99. Sydney (AUST): NSW Injury Risk Management Research Centre; 2003.

19. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare. Residential Aged Care in Australia 2006-07: A Statistical Overview. Canberra (AUST): AIHW; 2008.

20. National Health and Medical Research Council. How to Compare the Costs and Benefits: Evaluation of the Economic Evidence. Canberra (AUST): NHMRC; 2001

21. National Centre for Classification in Health. ICD-10-AM. 5th ed. Sydney (AUST): Univesity of Sydney; 2006.

22. Australian Bureau of Statistics. 3201.0 Population by Age and Sex, Australian States and Territories, Jun 2008. Canberra (AUST): ABS; 2008.

23. Department of Health and Aged Care. Insights into the Utilisation of Health Services in Australia Based on Linked Administrative Data. Canberra (AUST): Commonwealth of Australia; 2000.

24. BaranziniF,DiurniM,CecconF,PoloniN,CazzamalliS,CostantiniC,etal.Fall-related injuries in a nursing home setting: is polypharmacy a risk factor? BMC Health Serv Res. 2009;9:228.

25. NSW Department of Health. NSW Costs of Care Standards 2006/2007. Sydney (AUST):StateGovernmentofNewSouthWales;2007.

26. Department of Health and Ageing. National Hospital Cost Data Collection: Hospital Reference Manual Round 11 (2006-07). Canberra (AUST) Commonwealth of Australia; 2007.

27. KarmelR,LloydJ,AndersonP.Movement from Hospital to Residential Aged Care. Canberra (AUST): Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 2008.

28. Mathers C, Penm R. Health System Costs of Injury, Poisoning and Musculoskeletal Disorders in Australia, 1993-94. Canberra (AUST): Australian Institute of Health and Welfare; 1999.

29. Hall SE, Hendrie D. A prospective study of the costs of falls in older people living in the community. Aust N Z J Public Health. 2003;27(3):343-61.

30. HendrieD,HallS,ArenaG,LeggeM.Healthsystemcostsoffallsofolderadults in Western Australia. Aust Health Rev. 2004;28(3):363-73.

31. NSW Department of Health. Annual Report 2006/07. Sydney (AUST): State GovernmentofNewSouthWales;2007.

32. Ganz D, HigashiT, Rubenstein L. Monitoring falls in cohort ctudies ofcommunity-dwelling older people: Effect of the recall interval. J Am Geriatr Soc. 2005;53:2190–4.

33. PeelN.Validatingrecalloffallsbyolderpeople.Accid Anal Prev. 2000;32:371–2.34. Tiedemann A, Murray S, Munro B, Lord S. Hospital and non-hospital costs for

fall-related injury in community-dwelling older people. N S W Public Health Bull. 2008;19(9-10):161-5.

Environmental Hazards Burden of fall-related injury