43

The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

The basis problem(for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Ahmad Farhat

University of Wrocªaw

July 9, 2012

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 2: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Outline

1 Prologue

2 Partial results

3 Open problems

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 3: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Basis problems in combinatorial set theory

An elegant and deep program set forth by Stevo Todorcevic.-S. Todorcevic, Basis problems in combinatorial set theory, Proceedings of the International

Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. II (Berlin, 1998), Doc. Math. 1998, Extra Vol. II, 43�52.

What exactly is at stake here?

Blueprint

Starting out with a class of structures S,1 Recognize the critical members of S.2 Show that a certain list of criticial members is complete.

For instance: linear orders (solved by J.T. Moore), topological spaces(�rst proposed by G. Gruenhage).

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 4: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Basis problems in combinatorial set theory

An elegant and deep program set forth by Stevo Todorcevic.-S. Todorcevic, Basis problems in combinatorial set theory, Proceedings of the International

Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. II (Berlin, 1998), Doc. Math. 1998, Extra Vol. II, 43�52.

What exactly is at stake here?

Blueprint

Starting out with a class of structures S,1 Recognize the critical members of S.2 Show that a certain list of criticial members is complete.

For instance: linear orders (solved by J.T. Moore), topological spaces(�rst proposed by G. Gruenhage).

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 5: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Basis problems in combinatorial set theory

An elegant and deep program set forth by Stevo Todorcevic.-S. Todorcevic, Basis problems in combinatorial set theory, Proceedings of the International

Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. II (Berlin, 1998), Doc. Math. 1998, Extra Vol. II, 43�52.

What exactly is at stake here?

Blueprint

Starting out with a class of structures S,1 Recognize the critical members of S.2 Show that a certain list of criticial members is complete.

For instance: linear orders (solved by J.T. Moore), topological spaces(�rst proposed by G. Gruenhage).

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 6: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Basis problems in combinatorial set theory

An elegant and deep program set forth by Stevo Todorcevic.-S. Todorcevic, Basis problems in combinatorial set theory, Proceedings of the International

Congress of Mathematicians, Vol. II (Berlin, 1998), Doc. Math. 1998, Extra Vol. II, 43�52.

What exactly is at stake here?

Blueprint

Starting out with a class of structures S,1 Recognize the critical members of S.2 Show that a certain list of criticial members is complete.

For instance: linear orders (solved by J.T. Moore), topological spaces(�rst proposed by G. Gruenhage).

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 7: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

The 3-element basis conjecture

For S a class of topological spaces, and �complete� interpreted in termsof topological embedding, a basis for S is then a subclass S0 such thateach member of S contains a homeomorphic copy of a member of S0.Denote by

D(ω1), the discrete space on ω1,

B, an uncountable subspace of the unit interval, and

B × {0}, B considered as a subspace of the split interval.

Cojecture [PFA]

The class of uncountable �rst countable regular spaces has a 3-elementbasis consisting of D(ω1), B and B × {0}.

In other words: each uncountable �rst countable regular space containsan uncountable subspace of the reals with either the metric, theSorgenfrey or the discrete topology.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 8: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

The 3-element basis conjecture

For S a class of topological spaces, and �complete� interpreted in termsof topological embedding, a basis for S is then a subclass S0 such thateach member of S contains a homeomorphic copy of a member of S0.Denote by

D(ω1), the discrete space on ω1,

B, an uncountable subspace of the unit interval, and

B × {0}, B considered as a subspace of the split interval.

Cojecture [PFA]

The class of uncountable �rst countable regular spaces has a 3-elementbasis consisting of D(ω1), B and B × {0}.

In other words: each uncountable �rst countable regular space containsan uncountable subspace of the reals with either the metric, theSorgenfrey or the discrete topology.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 9: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

The 3-element basis conjecture

For S a class of topological spaces, and �complete� interpreted in termsof topological embedding, a basis for S is then a subclass S0 such thateach member of S contains a homeomorphic copy of a member of S0.Denote by

D(ω1), the discrete space on ω1,

B, an uncountable subspace of the unit interval, and

B × {0}, B considered as a subspace of the split interval.

Cojecture [PFA]

The class of uncountable �rst countable regular spaces has a 3-elementbasis consisting of D(ω1), B and B × {0}.

In other words: each uncountable �rst countable regular space containsan uncountable subspace of the reals with either the metric, theSorgenfrey or the discrete topology.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 10: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

The 3-element basis conjecture

For S a class of topological spaces, and �complete� interpreted in termsof topological embedding, a basis for S is then a subclass S0 such thateach member of S contains a homeomorphic copy of a member of S0.Denote by

D(ω1), the discrete space on ω1,

B, an uncountable subspace of the unit interval, and

B × {0}, B considered as a subspace of the split interval.

Cojecture [PFA]

The class of uncountable �rst countable regular spaces has a 3-elementbasis consisting of D(ω1), B and B × {0}.

In other words: each uncountable �rst countable regular space containsan uncountable subspace of the reals with either the metric, theSorgenfrey or the discrete topology.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 11: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Some partial solutions:

Gruenhage con�rmed the basis conjecture for the class ofcometrizable spaces, assuming PFA. Todorcevic later showed thatOCA su�ces.

Todorcevic gave a ZFC positive answer in the class of subspaces ofRosenthal compacta.

Notation: As we will see, continuous at most 2-to-1 maps onto metriccompacta play an important role. A compactum that admits such a mapwill be called a premetric compactum of degree at most 2.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 12: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Some partial solutions:

Gruenhage con�rmed the basis conjecture for the class ofcometrizable spaces, assuming PFA. Todorcevic later showed thatOCA su�ces.

Todorcevic gave a ZFC positive answer in the class of subspaces ofRosenthal compacta.

Notation: As we will see, continuous at most 2-to-1 maps onto metriccompacta play an important role. A compactum that admits such a mapwill be called a premetric compactum of degree at most 2.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 13: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Some partial solutions:

Gruenhage con�rmed the basis conjecture for the class ofcometrizable spaces, assuming PFA. Todorcevic later showed thatOCA su�ces.

Todorcevic gave a ZFC positive answer in the class of subspaces ofRosenthal compacta.

Notation: As we will see, continuous at most 2-to-1 maps onto metriccompacta play an important role. A compactum that admits such a mapwill be called a premetric compactum of degree at most 2.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 14: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Some partial solutions:

Gruenhage con�rmed the basis conjecture for the class ofcometrizable spaces, assuming PFA. Todorcevic later showed thatOCA su�ces.

Todorcevic gave a ZFC positive answer in the class of subspaces ofRosenthal compacta.

Notation: As we will see, continuous at most 2-to-1 maps onto metriccompacta play an important role. A compactum that admits such a mapwill be called a premetric compactum of degree at most 2.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 15: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Outline

1 Prologue

2 Partial results

3 Open problems

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 16: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of monotonically normal compacta

The main tool here is Nikiel's conjecture, proved by M.E. Rudin: aHausdor� space is an image of a compact linearly ordered space i� itis monotonically normal.

A positive answer to the basis conjecture for this class under PFArequires a little patchwork from the literature: results of Eisworth,Gruenhage, and Fremlin.

I have proved that this is true under Souslin's hypothesis.

The critical objects in this setting are, rather expectedly, the splitinterval and duplicate interval. The results exhibit a pleasantparallelism with results from Todorcevic's work �Compact subsets of�rst Baire class�.

Some further results analyze the situation when a monotonicallynormal compactum contains a full copy of the split interval or of theduplicate interval.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 17: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of monotonically normal compacta

The main tool here is Nikiel's conjecture, proved by M.E. Rudin: aHausdor� space is an image of a compact linearly ordered space i� itis monotonically normal.

A positive answer to the basis conjecture for this class under PFArequires a little patchwork from the literature: results of Eisworth,Gruenhage, and Fremlin.

I have proved that this is true under Souslin's hypothesis.

The critical objects in this setting are, rather expectedly, the splitinterval and duplicate interval. The results exhibit a pleasantparallelism with results from Todorcevic's work �Compact subsets of�rst Baire class�.

Some further results analyze the situation when a monotonicallynormal compactum contains a full copy of the split interval or of theduplicate interval.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 18: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of monotonically normal compacta

The main tool here is Nikiel's conjecture, proved by M.E. Rudin: aHausdor� space is an image of a compact linearly ordered space i� itis monotonically normal.

A positive answer to the basis conjecture for this class under PFArequires a little patchwork from the literature: results of Eisworth,Gruenhage, and Fremlin.

I have proved that this is true under Souslin's hypothesis.

The critical objects in this setting are, rather expectedly, the splitinterval and duplicate interval. The results exhibit a pleasantparallelism with results from Todorcevic's work �Compact subsets of�rst Baire class�.

Some further results analyze the situation when a monotonicallynormal compactum contains a full copy of the split interval or of theduplicate interval.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 19: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of monotonically normal compacta

The main tool here is Nikiel's conjecture, proved by M.E. Rudin: aHausdor� space is an image of a compact linearly ordered space i� itis monotonically normal.

A positive answer to the basis conjecture for this class under PFArequires a little patchwork from the literature: results of Eisworth,Gruenhage, and Fremlin.

I have proved that this is true under Souslin's hypothesis.

The critical objects in this setting are, rather expectedly, the splitinterval and duplicate interval. The results exhibit a pleasantparallelism with results from Todorcevic's work �Compact subsets of�rst Baire class�.

Some further results analyze the situation when a monotonicallynormal compactum contains a full copy of the split interval or of theduplicate interval.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 20: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of monotonically normal compacta

The main tool here is Nikiel's conjecture, proved by M.E. Rudin: aHausdor� space is an image of a compact linearly ordered space i� itis monotonically normal.

A positive answer to the basis conjecture for this class under PFArequires a little patchwork from the literature: results of Eisworth,Gruenhage, and Fremlin.

I have proved that this is true under Souslin's hypothesis.

The critical objects in this setting are, rather expectedly, the splitinterval and duplicate interval. The results exhibit a pleasantparallelism with results from Todorcevic's work �Compact subsets of�rst Baire class�.

Some further results analyze the situation when a monotonicallynormal compactum contains a full copy of the split interval or of theduplicate interval.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 21: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of perfectly normal compacta

A space is perfectly normal if it is normal and every closed subset is aGδ-set. Recall that in the setting of compact spaces, HL and perfectnormality coincide.Restricted to the class of subspaces of perfectly normal compacta,Gruenhage observed that the basis conjecture is equivalent, under PFA,to the fundamental conjecture about this class, due to Fremlin.

Fremlin's conjecture

Each perfectly normal compactum is premetric of degree at most 2.

This says that in some sense the only perfectly normal non-metrizablecompacta in ZFC are �relatives" of the split interval.

Fremlin [MM]

Each perfectly normal compactum admits a map to a metric space Mwhose �bers have cardinality two or less on a comeager subset of M.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 22: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of perfectly normal compacta

A space is perfectly normal if it is normal and every closed subset is aGδ-set. Recall that in the setting of compact spaces, HL and perfectnormality coincide.Restricted to the class of subspaces of perfectly normal compacta,Gruenhage observed that the basis conjecture is equivalent, under PFA,to the fundamental conjecture about this class, due to Fremlin.

Fremlin's conjecture

Each perfectly normal compactum is premetric of degree at most 2.

This says that in some sense the only perfectly normal non-metrizablecompacta in ZFC are �relatives" of the split interval.

Fremlin [MM]

Each perfectly normal compactum admits a map to a metric space Mwhose �bers have cardinality two or less on a comeager subset of M.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 23: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of perfectly normal compacta

A space is perfectly normal if it is normal and every closed subset is aGδ-set. Recall that in the setting of compact spaces, HL and perfectnormality coincide.Restricted to the class of subspaces of perfectly normal compacta,Gruenhage observed that the basis conjecture is equivalent, under PFA,to the fundamental conjecture about this class, due to Fremlin.

Fremlin's conjecture

Each perfectly normal compactum is premetric of degree at most 2.

This says that in some sense the only perfectly normal non-metrizablecompacta in ZFC are �relatives" of the split interval.

Fremlin [MM]

Each perfectly normal compactum admits a map to a metric space Mwhose �bers have cardinality two or less on a comeager subset of M.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 24: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of perfectly normal compacta

A space is perfectly normal if it is normal and every closed subset is aGδ-set. Recall that in the setting of compact spaces, HL and perfectnormality coincide.Restricted to the class of subspaces of perfectly normal compacta,Gruenhage observed that the basis conjecture is equivalent, under PFA,to the fundamental conjecture about this class, due to Fremlin.

Fremlin's conjecture

Each perfectly normal compactum is premetric of degree at most 2.

This says that in some sense the only perfectly normal non-metrizablecompacta in ZFC are �relatives" of the split interval.

Fremlin [MM]

Each perfectly normal compactum admits a map to a metric space Mwhose �bers have cardinality two or less on a comeager subset of M.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 25: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Subspaces of perfectly normal compacta

A space is perfectly normal if it is normal and every closed subset is aGδ-set. Recall that in the setting of compact spaces, HL and perfectnormality coincide.Restricted to the class of subspaces of perfectly normal compacta,Gruenhage observed that the basis conjecture is equivalent, under PFA,to the fundamental conjecture about this class, due to Fremlin.

Fremlin's conjecture

Each perfectly normal compactum is premetric of degree at most 2.

This says that in some sense the only perfectly normal non-metrizablecompacta in ZFC are �relatives" of the split interval.

Fremlin [MM]

Each perfectly normal compactum admits a map to a metric space Mwhose �bers have cardinality two or less on a comeager subset of M.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 26: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Aronszajn compacta were recently de�ned by Kunen and Hart.

De�nition

An embedded Aronszajn compactum is a closed subspace X ⊆ [0, 1]ω1

with w(X ) = ℵ1 and χ(X ) = ℵ0 such that for some club C ⊆ ω1: foreach α ∈ C ,Lα := {x ∈ Xα : |(σω1α )−1{x}| > 1} is countable.

For each such X , de�ne T = T (X ) :=⋃{Lα : α ∈ C}, and let / denote

the following order: if α, β ∈ C , α < β, x ∈ Lα and y ∈ Lβ then x / y i�x = πβα(y). (T , /) is then an ℵ1-tree.

De�nition

An Aronszajn compactum is a compact space X such that w(X ) = ℵ1and χ(X ) = ℵ0 and for some Z ⊂ [0, 1]ω1 homeomorphic to X , Z is anembedded Aronszajn compactum.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 27: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Aronszajn compacta were recently de�ned by Kunen and Hart.

De�nition

An embedded Aronszajn compactum is a closed subspace X ⊆ [0, 1]ω1

with w(X ) = ℵ1 and χ(X ) = ℵ0 such that for some club C ⊆ ω1: foreach α ∈ C ,Lα := {x ∈ Xα : |(σω1α )−1{x}| > 1} is countable.

For each such X , de�ne T = T (X ) :=⋃{Lα : α ∈ C}, and let / denote

the following order: if α, β ∈ C , α < β, x ∈ Lα and y ∈ Lβ then x / y i�x = πβα(y). (T , /) is then an ℵ1-tree.

De�nition

An Aronszajn compactum is a compact space X such that w(X ) = ℵ1and χ(X ) = ℵ0 and for some Z ⊂ [0, 1]ω1 homeomorphic to X , Z is anembedded Aronszajn compactum.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 28: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Aronszajn compacta were recently de�ned by Kunen and Hart.

De�nition

An embedded Aronszajn compactum is a closed subspace X ⊆ [0, 1]ω1

with w(X ) = ℵ1 and χ(X ) = ℵ0 such that for some club C ⊆ ω1: foreach α ∈ C ,Lα := {x ∈ Xα : |(σω1α )−1{x}| > 1} is countable.

For each such X , de�ne T = T (X ) :=⋃{Lα : α ∈ C}, and let / denote

the following order: if α, β ∈ C , α < β, x ∈ Lα and y ∈ Lβ then x / y i�x = πβα(y). (T , /) is then an ℵ1-tree.

De�nition

An Aronszajn compactum is a compact space X such that w(X ) = ℵ1and χ(X ) = ℵ0 and for some Z ⊂ [0, 1]ω1 homeomorphic to X , Z is anembedded Aronszajn compactum.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 29: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Aronszajn compacta were recently de�ned by Kunen and Hart.

De�nition

An embedded Aronszajn compactum is a closed subspace X ⊆ [0, 1]ω1

with w(X ) = ℵ1 and χ(X ) = ℵ0 such that for some club C ⊆ ω1: foreach α ∈ C ,Lα := {x ∈ Xα : |(σω1α )−1{x}| > 1} is countable.

For each such X , de�ne T = T (X ) :=⋃{Lα : α ∈ C}, and let / denote

the following order: if α, β ∈ C , α < β, x ∈ Lα and y ∈ Lβ then x / y i�x = πβα(y). (T , /) is then an ℵ1-tree.

De�nition

An Aronszajn compactum is a compact space X such that w(X ) = ℵ1and χ(X ) = ℵ0 and for some Z ⊂ [0, 1]ω1 homeomorphic to X , Z is anembedded Aronszajn compactum.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 30: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Theorem [OCA + MAℵ1 ]

Let X be an HL compact space. Then either X has a quotient which isan Aronszajn compactum, or X is a premetric compactum of degree atmost 2.

Theorem [OCA + MAℵ1 ]

Each perfectly normal compactum admits a map to a metric space Mwhose �bers have cardinality two or less on a cocountable subset of M.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 31: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Theorem [OCA + MAℵ1 ]

Let X be an HL compact space. Then either X has a quotient which isan Aronszajn compactum, or X is a premetric compactum of degree atmost 2.

Theorem [OCA + MAℵ1 ]

Each perfectly normal compactum admits a map to a metric space Mwhose �bers have cardinality two or less on a cocountable subset of M.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 32: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Outline

1 Prologue

2 Partial results

3 Open problems

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 33: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

It is clear that the fundamental analysis concerns Aronszajn trees (likethe case of linear orders). The main open question:

Question

Does there exist in ZFC a HL Aronszajn compactum?Proposed answer: NO.

A negative answer to this question will con�rm the 3-element basisconjecture for perfectly normal compacta. In addition, it will solve aquestion �attributable� (?) to Alexandro�.

Question (Alexandro�)

Does there exist (in ZFC) perfectly normal compacta unrelated to thedouble arrow space?Proposed answer: NO.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 34: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

It is clear that the fundamental analysis concerns Aronszajn trees (likethe case of linear orders). The main open question:

Question

Does there exist in ZFC a HL Aronszajn compactum?Proposed answer: NO.

A negative answer to this question will con�rm the 3-element basisconjecture for perfectly normal compacta. In addition, it will solve aquestion �attributable� (?) to Alexandro�.

Question (Alexandro�)

Does there exist (in ZFC) perfectly normal compacta unrelated to thedouble arrow space?Proposed answer: NO.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 35: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

It is clear that the fundamental analysis concerns Aronszajn trees (likethe case of linear orders). The main open question:

Question

Does there exist in ZFC a HL Aronszajn compactum?Proposed answer: NO.

A negative answer to this question will con�rm the 3-element basisconjecture for perfectly normal compacta. In addition, it will solve aquestion �attributable� (?) to Alexandro�.

Question (Alexandro�)

Does there exist (in ZFC) perfectly normal compacta unrelated to thedouble arrow space?

Proposed answer: NO.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 36: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

It is clear that the fundamental analysis concerns Aronszajn trees (likethe case of linear orders). The main open question:

Question

Does there exist in ZFC a HL Aronszajn compactum?Proposed answer: NO.

A negative answer to this question will con�rm the 3-element basisconjecture for perfectly normal compacta. In addition, it will solve aquestion �attributable� (?) to Alexandro�.

Question (Alexandro�)

Does there exist (in ZFC) perfectly normal compacta unrelated to thedouble arrow space?Proposed answer: NO.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 37: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

It is clear that the fundamental analysis concerns Aronszajn trees (likethe case of linear orders). The main open question:

Question

Does there exist in ZFC a HL Aronszajn compactum?Proposed answer: NO.

A negative answer to this question will con�rm the 3-element basisconjecture for perfectly normal compacta. In addition, it will solve aquestion �attributable� (?) to Alexandro�.

Question (Alexandro�)

Does there exist (in ZFC) perfectly normal compacta unrelated to thedouble arrow space?Proposed answer: NO.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 38: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

This would also solve a host of questions, surveyed in [?]. Prominentamong them are:

Question (M.E. Rudin)

Is every locally connected perfectly normal compactum metrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

Question (Przymusi«ski)

If X × Y is perfectly normal and compact, then is either X or Ymetrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

As mentioned earlier, Gruenhage original work on the basis conjecturestemmed out of his study of (exactly the last two) open problems onperfectly normal compacta.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 39: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

This would also solve a host of questions, surveyed in [?]. Prominentamong them are:

Question (M.E. Rudin)

Is every locally connected perfectly normal compactum metrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

Question (Przymusi«ski)

If X × Y is perfectly normal and compact, then is either X or Ymetrizable?

Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

As mentioned earlier, Gruenhage original work on the basis conjecturestemmed out of his study of (exactly the last two) open problems onperfectly normal compacta.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 40: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

This would also solve a host of questions, surveyed in [?]. Prominentamong them are:

Question (M.E. Rudin)

Is every locally connected perfectly normal compactum metrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

Question (Przymusi«ski)

If X × Y is perfectly normal and compact, then is either X or Ymetrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

As mentioned earlier, Gruenhage original work on the basis conjecturestemmed out of his study of (exactly the last two) open problems onperfectly normal compacta.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 41: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

This would also solve a host of questions, surveyed in [?]. Prominentamong them are:

Question (M.E. Rudin)

Is every locally connected perfectly normal compactum metrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

Question (Przymusi«ski)

If X × Y is perfectly normal and compact, then is either X or Ymetrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

As mentioned earlier, Gruenhage original work on the basis conjecturestemmed out of his study of (exactly the last two) open problems onperfectly normal compacta.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 42: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

This would also solve a host of questions, surveyed in [?]. Prominentamong them are:

Question (M.E. Rudin)

Is every locally connected perfectly normal compactum metrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

Question (Przymusi«ski)

If X × Y is perfectly normal and compact, then is either X or Ymetrizable?Proposed answer: (consistenly) YES.

As mentioned earlier, Gruenhage original work on the basis conjecturestemmed out of his study of (exactly the last two) open problems onperfectly normal compacta.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)

Page 43: The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation ... · Ahmad Farhat University of Wrocªwa July 9, 2012 Ahmad rhataF The basis roblemp (for compacta satisfying high separation

ProloguePartial results

Open problems

Some theorems which shed light on the main problem at hand.

Avraham, Shelah [PFA]

Every two Aronszajn trees are club-isomorphic.

Ahmad Farhat The basis problem (for compacta satisfying high separation axioms)