THE AUTUMN MEETING OF MARSEILLE 26-28 October 2017 … · The representatives of the Association to TEGoVA are: Philippe Conté REV President CEIF-FNAIM Denis Pelouse REV Deputy President

THE AUTUMN MEETING OF

MARSEILLE 26-28 October 2017

HOTEL INTERCONTINENTAL 1 place Daviel - 13002 Marseille

France

FINAL PROGRAMME & AGENDA

ORGANISED BY

Chambre des Experts Immobiliers de France FNAIM

[email protected]

mailto:[email protected]

. TEGoVA Meeting . Final Programme & Agenda . Marseille 26-28 October 2017 . 2

THE ORGANISER

The CEIF-FNAIM, which was created over 40 years ago by founding Chairman Bernard Cochelin, is a

national professional organisation representing real estate valuers.

The CEIF-FNAIM is a non-profit non-governmental organisation representing more than 790

professionals throughout France, all of them members of the National Association of Real Estate

Professionals or FNAIM (Fédération National de l'Immobilier) having more than 12.000 members.

As well as ensuring that the profession's code of ethics is complied with to the full, the Chamber defends

its members' shared valuers, which are centred on professional integrity, know-how, humility and

common sense.

One of the roles of the Chamber is to maintain a high degree of expertise among its members. To this

end, it implements a continuing-training system and hold a large number of seminars each year.

The general meeting, congress and study tour also provide the Chamber with opportunities to pass

professional information on to members.

CEIF is also committed to enabling members to practice the profession in optimal circumstances, which

is why it provides professional third-party insurance cover for peace of mind concerning their civil

liability.

The representatives of the Association to TEGoVA are:

Philippe Conté REV

President CEIF-FNAIM

Denis Pelouse REV

Deputy President CEIF-FNAIM

President of TEGoVA France

Emmanuelle Gauthier MRICS REV

Member of the Board CEIF-FNAIM


BRIEF HISTORY OF MARSEILLE

Facts about Marseille

• With its twenty-six century long experience of exchange, experience and dialogue with the peoples

of the world, Marseille is now opening out to emerging countries without neglecting the age-old ties

that bind it to the Mediterranean basin. Building on its potential for innovation, research and

development and a population of young and qualified people, it benefits from all of the necessary

conditions to ensure the success of companies within an attractive cultural and living environment.

• The city is deeply marked by its past and is constantly digging up the remains of all the cities that

have been built on top of each other over the centuries. It takes the visitor on a journey that begins

with its Greek and Roman origins and leads us past the medieval religious foundations, the 16th

Century fortifications, the rich homes of the 17th and 18th Centuries and the many prestigious

buildings erected in the 19th Century and right up to modern times and the great architectural

achievements of the 21st Century.

• In achieving the title ‘European Capital of Culture’ for 2013, Marseille has established itself as a

cultural destination.

• Beyond culture, Marseille is wagering on its natural environment enhanced by the Calanques National

Park and, in another field all together, on the hosting of major international cultural, economic and

sporting events, for which it has gained experience in recent years from the World Football or Rugby

Cups to the 6th World Water Forum.

• Marseille enjoys a unique geostrategic position within Europe:

• As the first port of France and the Mediterranean and the third largest port in the world for

the oil trade, the “Phocean City” is the established bridgehead of Europe within the

Mediterranean.

• As the second diplomatic seat in France, Marseille has successfully played the hand of

international relations, making its mark as a recognised para-diplomatic centre. A status that

has resulted in the presence of numerous international organisations (Marseille Center for

Mediterranean Integration, UNIDO, World Water Council, World Bank antenna…).

• Over the past fifteen years or so, the urban renewal led by Marseille has been indisputable.


HOTELS & MAIN VENUE

Hotel & Main Vennue

Intercontinental Hotel

The hotel is located in the heart of the city, overlooking the Vieux Port.

Second Option Hotel

Newhotel

The hotel is located opposite the Old Port and at the foot of the famous Canebière, the historical centre of Marseille and next to the Chamber of Commerce.

Location: 10 to 15 minutes walk to main hotel.


FORMAL DINNER

Villa Gaby

285 Corniche Kennedy

http://www.villagaby.org/en/

INFORMAL DINNER

Restaurant La Nautique

Pavillon Flottant, Quai de Rive-Neuve

http://www.lanautique.com/restaurant-societe-nautique-marseille-snm.asp

http://www.villagaby.org/en/

http://www.lanautique.com/restaurant-societe-nautique-marseille-snm.asp


VALUATION CONFERENCE

Palais de la Bourse – 9 la Canebière 13001 Marseille

European Valuation Conference

“Is the Real Estate Valuer the Market Compass?”

Palais de la Bourse Friday 27 October 2017

09:00 – 13:00

GENERAL ASSEMBLY

Intercontinental Hotel


VENUES (summary)

Intercontinental Hotel - Meeting Rooms

▪ EVSB meeting ((Thursday 26 October, 10:00-13.30)

▪ Board meeting (Thursday 26 October, 15:00-19:00)

▪ Other meetings (Friday 27 October, 14:30-18.30)

▪ General Assembly meeting (Saturday 28 October, 09:30-16:00)

▪ Board meeting (Saturday 28 October, 16:00-17:00)

▪ REVASE meeting (Saturday 28 October, 17:00-18:30)

Le Palais de la Bourse

▪ Valuation Conference (Friday 27 October)

Villa Gaby

▪ Formal Dinner (Friday 27 October)

Restaurant La Nautique

▪ Informal Dinner (Saturday 28 October)

PARTNER PROGRAMME

Saturday 28 October 2017

Visit of Marseille: The Old and the New 09:30 – 17:30

Morning

Visit of :

❖ The new Marseille

❖ MUCEM, First major national museum dedicated to the Mediterranean, a place of architecture and heritage

❖ Boulevard du Littoral

❖ The Docks, Historic and emblematic building of the port of Marseille

❖ Lunch at ’Madie les Galinettes’

Afternoon

Visit of :

❖ Le Vieux Panier

❖ La Maison de la Pétanque

❖ Tasting of olive oil


MEETING PROGRAMME

Thursday, 26 October 2017

15:00 - 18:30 Registration of TEGoVA Delegates (hotel main reception)

10:00 – 13:30 EVSB Meeting

(for EVS Board Members only) 15:00 - 19:00 TEGoVA Board Meeting

(for Board Members only) 20:00 - 23:00 TEGoVA Board Dinner (Restaurant Alcyone, Intercontinental Hotel)

(for Board Members, Advisers, Secretariat and Guests) 19:45 Meeting point: lobby of the hotel Dress Code: Jacket & Tie, no badges

Friday, 27 October 2017

08:00 - 13.00

Registration of TEGoVA Delegates (hotel reception)

09:00 - 13:00 European Valuation Conference (please see next page)


EUROPEAN VALUATION CONFERENCE

“Is the Real Estate Valuer the Market Compass?”

Friday 27 October 2017

08:00 - 09:00 Coffee & Registration

09:00 - 09:15 “All roads lead to Marseille: introduction” Philippe Conté REV, President, CEIF FNAIM and Denis Pelouse REV, President, TEGoVA France

09:15 – 09:25 Welcome from the Chairman of TEGoVA Krzysztof Grzesik FRICS IRRV (Hons) REV

09:25 – 09:45 “Marseille : Plus Belle La Vie ?”

Economy, culture, society: what kind of impact on real estate values? Jean-Luc Chauvin, President, Chamber of Commerce and Industry of Marseille Provence and Didier Bertrand, President, FNAIM 13

09:45 - 10:05 “Red Book, Blue Book… Frog’s Book! La Charte de l’Expertise en Evaluation Immobilière” Presentation of the Charte de l’Expertise en Evaluation Immobilière Stéphane Imowicz, Past President, Chart Committtee and Denis François FRICS REV, Immediate Past Chairman of CBRE Valuation France

10:05 - 10:30 “Forever young: initial and executive training” Yvan Auguet, Dean, University of Perpignan Via Domitia Emmanuelle Gauthier MRICS REV, Member of the Board, CEIF FNAIM

10:30 – 11:00 Coffee Break

11:00 - 11:20 “Real estate valuation: jump with or without parachute ?” Karine Gérard, Customer Manager and Nathalie Robert, Deputy Director, Gras Savoye & Galian

11:20 - 11:40 “Client wishes versus the real estate report: who’s the boss ?” Gilles Allard, President, Association of Real Estate Directors

11:40 – 12:00 “La Carte E: the real estate passport” Philippe Conté REV, President, CEIF FNAIM and Denis Pelouse REV, President, TEGoVA France

12:00 - 12:20 Conclusion Romain Grau, Member of Parliament

12:20 - 12:40 Q&A


13:00 - 14:30 Buffet lunch on the premises

14:30 – 15:30 REV, TRV & REVC Contract Signing (Meeting Room) (for AMA, R-AMA and C-AMA delegates who have REV, TRV and REVC Agreements to be signed)

14:30 - 15:30

Recognition Committee Meeting (RC Members only)

15:30 - 16:00 EVQB Meeting

(EVQB Members only) 16:00 - 18:30 EVPMB Meeting

(EVPMB Members only) 20:00 - 23:30

Cocktail & Formal Dinner (TEGoVA delegates, partners / guests)

Venue: Villa Gaby Dress Code: Jacket & Tie, no badge Transport: Private bus

19:30 Meeting point: lobby hotel

Saturday, 28 October 2017

08:30 - 09:30 Registration of TEGoVA Delegates (entrance GA room) 09:30 - 17:30 Parners’ Programme

The old Marseille

09:15 Meeting Point: lobby of the hotel 09:30 - 16:00 TEGoVA General Assembly 11:00 - 11:30 Coffee break 13:00 - 14:30 Lunch Delegates – TEGoVA General Assembly (hotel) 14:30 - 16:00 TEGoVA General Assembly continued

16:00 - 17:00 Board Meeting


17:00 - 18:30 REVASE Meeting (for Project Partners only)

20:00 – 23:00 Informal Dinner

Venue: Restaurant La Nautique Dress Code: Smart casual, no badge Transport: by foot

19:30 Meeting point: lobby of the hotel


TEGoVA General Assembly – Marseille – 28 October 2017

Programme and Agenda

09:30 Meeting opens at the Hotel Intercontinental, naming of Secretary and Scrutineers; roll-call by Secretary of members present and proxies (to be recorded by him in the presence / proxies / voting lists)

I. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES OF THE LAST GENERAL ASSEMBLY No requests for amendments received so far. See t17-16 of 14.06.2017 II. TEGoVA FINANCES Budget for the 2018 Financial Year Jean-François Drouets (AFREXIM), Treasurer, to report See t17-24 of 19.10.2017 III. REV 1. Audit reports regarding ANEVAR and BDVI 2. Assessment report regarding NAVM, UABVS and USOA Roger Messenger (IRRV), Chairman of the Recognition Committee, to report followed by General Assembly vote See t17-26 of 23.10.2017 IV. REVC 1. Audit report regarding ATASA Roger Messenger to report followed by General Assembly vote See t17-27 of 23.10.2017


2. AEV Roger Messenger to report V. TRV

1. Assessment reports regarding NVM, VastgoedPRO and VBO MAKELAAR

Roger Messenger to report followed by General Assembly vote See t17-27 of 23.10.2017 11:00 – 11:30 Coffee break VI. AVMs 1. Dutch law allowing use of AVMs at initiation without valuer involvement for properties

serving as collateral for the mortgage loan – TEGoVA campaign to get the European Commission to investigate incorrect transposition of the Mortgage Credit Directive and infringement of the Capital Requirements Regulation

Krzysztof Grzesik (PFVA) and Michael MacBrien (Secretariat) to report 2. Adaptation of EVS to the regulatory challenges raised by AVMs Introduced by Danijela Ilić (NAVS) and Michael MacBrien See t17-23addendum of 18.10.2017

AVMs vs. Appraisals: A U.S. Perspective

Scott Robinson MAI, SRA, AI-GRS Immediate Past President Appraisal Institute (AI)


The IAAO Approach to AVMs

Randy J. Ripperger, CAE President

International Association of Assessing Officers (IAAO)

VII. EUROPEAN VALUATION STANDARDS BOARD (EVSB) Michael Reinberg (ARE), Chairman of the EVSB, to report on work in progress VIII. EUROPEAN VALUATION PRACTICE AND METHODOLOGY BOARD (EVPMB) Philippe Guillerm (AFREXIM), Chairman of the EVPMB, to report on work in progress other than AVMs IX. TEGoVA MEMBERSHIP CANDIDATURES Upgrades

1. Italy

From Observer to Full Member

➢ ISTITUTO di ESTIMO e VALUTAZIONE (IEV) E-Valuations - Institute of Estimation and Valuation

For approval.


2. Kosovo From Observer to Associate Member

➢ SHOQATES SE VLERESUESVE TE KOSOVES (SHVK) Kosovo Appraisers Association (KAA)

For approval. See t17-25(1) of 19.10.2017 New Members

1. France

➢ UNION DES SYNDICATS DE L’IMMOBILIER (UNIS) National Union of Property Professions (Full Member)

Presentation by Jean-François Trably, Treasurer

2. Bosnia and Herzegovina

➢ UDRUZENJE OVLASCENIH PROCJENJIVACA u BOSNI i HERCEGOVINI (UOPBiH)

Association of Certified Appraisers in Bosnia and Herzegovina (ACABH) (Associate Member)

Presentation by Saša Žižek, member of the Slovenian Institute of Auditors (SIR) in the name of UOPBiH


3. Kosovo

➢ INSTITUTI PËR VLERËSIME DHE STUDIME PRONËSORE (IVSP) Institute for Appraisals and Property Studies (IAPS) (Associate Member)

Presentation by Dritero Kadolli IRRV, Managing Director

4. United States of America

➢ INTERNATIONAL ASSOCIATION of ASSESSING OFFICERS (IAAO) (Observer Member)

Presentation by Ronald D. Worth, CAE, Executive Director See t17-25(2) and t17-25(3) of 19.10.2017

“The REVASE Project”

David Magor OBE IRRV (Hons) Chief Executive

Institute of Revenues Rating and Valuation (IRRV)

X. SPRING 2018 GENERAL MEETING & VALUATION CONFERENCE Estoril (Portugal), 17-19 May 2018, organised by the Associçäo Profissional das Sociedades de Avliaçao (ASAVAL) - Professional Association of Valuation Companies of Portugal Presentation by Engª. Isabel Araújo Ferreira, Member of the Board of ASAVAL


XI. CANDIDATURES FOR HOSTING OF FUTURE GENERAL MEETINGS

Autumn 2018 (18-20 October 2018)

Athens, organised by AVAG (inspection and approval pending)

Spring 2019 (25-27 April 2019)

Vienna, organised by ÖVI (approved)

XII. ANY OTHER BUSINESS

oooooooooooo

13:00 – 14:30 Lunch (hotel) 14:30 – 16:00 General Assembly continued 16:00 – 17:00 TEGoVA Board meeting 17:00 – 18:30 REVASE meeting (for project partners only)

Documents

THE AUTUMN MEETING OF MARSEILLE 26-28 October 2017 … · The representatives of the Association to TEGoVA are: Philippe Conté REV President CEIF-FNAIM Denis Pelouse REV Deputy President