50
SEC RET//SI//R EL TO USA, FVEY 'i; m ‘wprÿss *>f; iWi W you 2ÿMAN The ART of DECEPTION ”GCHQ" TRAINING FOR A NEW GENERATION OF ONLINE COVERT OPERATIONS SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Training for a new generation of online covert operations GCHQ of UK+USA joint. Source: https://firstlook.org/theintercept/document/2014/02/24/art-deception-training-new-generation-online-covert-operations/

Citation preview

Page 1: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY

'i;m‘wprÿss

*>f; iWi

Wyou

2ÿMANThe ART of DECEPTION

”GCHQ"TRAINING FOR A NEW GENERATION OF ONLINE COVERT OPERATIONS

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 2: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY

HSOCHUMAN SCIENCE OPERATIONS CELL

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 3: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

OnlineHUMINT

StrategicInfluence

JTRIGDisruption

and CNA

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 4: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ANTHROPOLOGY

PSYCHOLOGY

SOCIOLOGY

***b

V

<

).i>-i

*s

ECONOMICS/

V4

\/

\\

HISTORY

BIOLOGYPOLITICAL SCIENCE

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 5: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Culture DeceptionEthnography Influence

ANTHROPOLOGYEthnography Magic

PSYCHOLOGY

SOCIOLOGY

* fA.

Personality

'ÿ'» •

Compliance Trust

\

iElicitationt

s>/

tt

Obedience s

s

ECONOMICS/fk/

/J

Social Networks

i / Belief\x

HISTORYReligion

BIOLOGYPOLITICAL SCIENCE

Key Leader Engagement Neuroscience

Global TrendsEvolutionary Biology

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 6: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

SCIENCE SIGINT

SKILLS SYSTEMS

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 7: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

OnlineHUMINT

StrategicInfluence

JTRIGDisruption

and CNA

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 8: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ti

- '

1

v*i%i

>

s

We want to build Cyber Magicians.

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 9: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ocaaOnline Covert Action

Accreditation

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 10: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ACNO KeySkill Strands

Online

HUMINT

Influence &

Info OpsDisruption & CNA

Magic Techniques & Experiment

lIndividual Psychology Professionalism

Deception

Elegance

Group

Performance Creativity

Global

IntuitionMedia

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 11: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ACNO Key

Skill Strands

Online

HUMINT

Influence &

Info OpsDisruption & CNA

Magic Techniques & Experiment

I Decisions

[Emotional

not rational)

Individual Psychology ProfessionalismTrustBELIEF TrustPersonality (OCEAN)

|1How to

apply

x these

DeceptionRemote Assessment

in Digital Cues Persuasive

TechBehaviour Self 10 PRINCIPLES

OF SCAMS HINDSIGHT& [whoI am? Motives &

exploiting them] BIASInfluence Influence EleganceI nCONFIRMATIONPERSUASION

Hofstede

DimensionsBIAS i

Optimising Deception

ChannelsBuilding

RelationshipsHofstede

Dimensions

i

Group iANCHORING

Interaction

across culturesPrates of Reflection to assess if

weare doing op elÿantlyMirroring /

Mimicry iCONSPIRACY

STORIES

CONFORMITY

/ QBEDIANCEPRIMING

iSocial PenetrationMotives

Roles

Influence/Cascade

DIFFUSION OF

INNOVATION/Theory

Virtual Communities

IPerformance CreativitySocial Identity Theory i f

BrainstormingConstructing experience

in mind of target whichshould be accepted so

they don't realise It

How to act / behaveSocial Proof/Herding etc

NARRATIVE-FtlSelf Presentation

in Cyber context;idtr alternate

AGENTICITV Becoming /Targeting

GroupReducing

PATTERNICI ( Intel

/Analysis/

IntuitionMediaHow to do some of this in

real time so need to

understand what you are

doing in this psychology

Reading from digital tells but

going with performance to

reduce my risk but satisfytnquisition

Financial Ecosystem

of MediaThin Slicing

Design,

Retenti on

& Trust

PROPAGANDA TAA

ADVERTISING

Sell - own - EarnBRANDING

MARKETING

TO USA, FVEYSE&

Page 12: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

ACNO Key

Skill Strands

Online

HUMINT

Influence &

Info Ops

Disruption &

Comp Net Attack

Mental

Health aPsychopathy *

71- 5 USvS3

Decision Making

— RationaleChoice

Crime & punishment

mm [•]% [ÿTag r*iriTi4

Decisions

[Emotional

not rational![ÿXI

Individual Psychology s

( BELIEF Trust FLAMMED

INTERVENTIONPersonality (OCEAN)

1 DeceptionHow to

apply

K these

Remote Assessment

in Digital Cues PersuasiveBehaviour Self 10 PRINCIPLES

OF SCAMS HINDSIGHT& [whoI am? Motives &

exploiting them] BIASInfluence Influence EleganceI CONFIRMATIONPERSUASION

Hofstede

DimensionsBIAS r Optimising Deception

ChannelsBuilding

RelationshipsHofstede

Dimensions

!Group i

ANCHORING/Interaction

across culturesPraces of Reflection to assess if

weare doing op eiÿantlyMirroring /

MimicryCONSPIRACY

STORIES

CONFORMITY

/ QBEDIANCEPRIMING i

!Social PenetrationiMotives

Roles

Influence/Cascade

DIFFUSION OF

INNOVATIONTheory

/Virtual Communities j

Performance CreativityMorality & Ethics Social Identity TheoryBrainstorming

Constructing experience

in mind of target whichshould be accepted so

they don't realise it

How to act / behave !Social Proof/Herding etc

NARRATIVE 1l

4Self Presentation

in Cyber context :>Cyber Culturesacross

Organisations

CCJ/REidtr alternate

AGENTICITV Becoming /Targeting

P !S

Group

Dynamics

Reducing

|-p| GroupEffect iveness

PATTERN 1C Intel

/Analysisj

GlobalLegitimisation ofViolence

IntuitionSOCIAL

NETWORKS ) MediaConstructing

News SystemHowto do some of this in

real time so need to

understand what you are

doing In this psychology

Reading from digital tells but

going with performance to

reduce my risk but satisfyTarget's Inquisition

Financial Ecosystem

of MediaThin Slicing

Design,

Retenti on

& Trust

PROPAGANDA TAA

fias Management

& Legend Building

(decided not to include intraining)

r±iiADVERTISING

Sell - own - EarnBRANDING

MARKETING*TO USA, FVEYSE&

Page 13: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Human Science Learning Pathi

AA Strategic

Influence(1day)

Ai

\A

rA Scams

AndfA

fi r

JHkr

Wj uenceit ! I I

i

PsychologyAnd Cyber -psychology “ Tells* i

Online HUMINTACoreDisruption

{1hour)i

1 Engineering

Fur CNA

(e-learning)

u

rCNA and Disruption

•I HSOCm

i* IVW(Vitwifinwlnuftlllt

ocoo

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 14: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//REL TO USA, FVEY

*ÿ

VI

IIIfV

1

&*I *

1 C, -

*W* I- . i1

V**> w* * L *

* «

•1* EI

41

B*v*

k,

r4r:

•Ifli*< .v*T. Md/

JCKj. _

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 15: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

•If?* V1

.«#

i-4

*

’Ii A

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 16: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Magicians, the military and intelligence

3

fe

*rl

Vr4*

I#

* &L 4.

wa f

ri* rrf.

Vr /A-c

//Hr 4

§

(gJt1w*- 1 *ÿf

1

•Hi**

jiy4

ums

Iff

Jean Robert-Houdin

1856 mission on behalf ofNapoleon III to help quell the

Marabout-led uprising inAlgeria.

Jasper Maskelyne

1940s Camouflage workduring the Second World War.

John Mulholland

1950s CIA work on theapplication of conjuring to‘clandestine activities' .

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 17: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

P— -1- X Jjn . X X r-. ps . p **’ rt

Dissimulation - Hide the realRepackaging DazzlingMasking

~

ttvr

_- -

PH

HB.i IP™” r-n

1-- X

SE* 1

i*j,

jipi

Jmi w]

- ~ ud

J

W

&

i|f f**,iflV|jl

V

.m j *

t **

.V*L/Vij ivÿ.

x->B / ' J \LKPIJ ».»

. '3t

r -l t(V r

i..*'y:Lt* /

'i.w. -J pJ™

_|ÿ

Th

“ SWr"'i1it. ._. #

“IV--Jt

' 'ÿ

£’,1

V *

» rp_!

PuA"Lÿf

jiW- _rS!H-

.

*7i -‘

,

-laW

,fcJ

Mimicking

Simulation

Inventing Decoying

Show the false

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 18: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

The psychological building blocks of deception

Ex net

/

Attention SensemakingPerception Behaviour

1

*/ V

/

Affect

SECRET//SI//RELTO USA, FVEY

Page 19: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 20: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 21: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 22: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 23: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 24: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 25: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 26: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 27: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 28: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 29: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 30: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 31: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 32: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 33: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 34: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 35: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 36: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 37: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 38: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 39: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 40: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 41: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 42: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 43: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 44: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 45: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 46: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 47: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 48: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 49: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint
Page 50: The art of deception training for a new generation of online covert operations gchq of uk usa joint