16
The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) Creating spaces for cooperation through multi-level dialogue and capacity building IUCN WATER PROGRAMME – BRIDGE CASE STUDY: THE 3S RIVER BASIN

The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

The 3S River Basin (Cambodia,Lao PDR and Vietnam)Creating spaces for cooperation through multi-level dialogue and capacity building

IUCN WATER PROGRAMME – BRIDGE CASE STUDY: THE 3S RIVER BASIN

Page 2: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

The designation of geographical entities in this case study, and the presentation of the material, do not implythe expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of IUCN or the Swiss Agency for Development andCooperation concerning the legal status of any country, territory, or area, or of its authorities, or concerningthe delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries.

The views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect those of IUCN or the Swiss Agency forDevelopment and Cooperation.

The BRIDGE project is funded by the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation.

Published by: IUCN, Gland, Switzerland

Copyright: © 2013 International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources

Reproduction of this publication for educational or other non-commercial purposes isauthorized without prior written permission from the copyright holder provided thesource is fully acknowledged.

Reproduction of this publication for resale or other commercial purposes is prohibitedwithout prior written permission of the copyright holder.

Citation: MacQuarrie, Patrick R., Welling, Rebecca, Rammont, Lalita and Ganesh Pangare.(2013). The 3S River Basin. Gland, Switzerland: IUCN. 12pp.

Photographs: Cover, p.3, p.6, p.8, p.10, p.11 IUCN/Lalita Rammont

Layout by: Tim Davis, DJEnvironmental, UK

Printed by: UniPrint, Nyon, Switzerland

Available from: IUCN (International Union for Conservation of Nature)IUCN Global Water ProgrammeRue Mauverney 281196 GlandSwitzerlandTel +41 22 999 0000Fax +41 22 999 [email protected]/publications

Page 3: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) 1

THE 3S RIVER BASIN (CAMBODIA, LAO PDR AND VIETNAM)

Creating spaces for cooperation through multi-level dialogueand capacity buildingPatrick R. MacQuarrie, Rebecca Welling, Lalita Rammont and Ganesh Pangare

The Sesan, Sre Pok, and Sekong rivers, referred to as the 3S river basin, are shared by three countries andconstitute a significant part of the Lower Mekong river basin. The BRIDGE project – Building River Dialogue

and Governance – implements water diplomacy in transboundary basins, and is working in the 3S to build andstrengthen water governance capacity.

The 3S river basin contains the only transboundary tributaries of the Mekong covering over 78,650 square kilo-metres. Rapid development of hydropower and mining which has prompted renewed efforts to improve coop-eration, challenged by the fact that the three countries it is shared between have vastly different political andinstitutional arrangements.

As a result of these challenges, BRIDGE uses a combination of facilitating dialogue, information tools, and capac-ity building bringing together and strengthening stakeholders across local, provincial, national, and regional levels.

Experiences in the 3S have illustrated that water diplomacy is a stepwise process that must include a multiplicityof agreements at all levels. In order for cooperation to take shape, space must be created for dialogue andshared learning which can create an environment where joint action across scales can happen. Lao PDR is grad-ually setting up a river basin committee (RBO) on the Sekong catalyzed by stakeholders’ interest in water gov-ernance and IWRM. A crucial point is that water governance depends on combined training and leadershipnetworks that can transmit essential knowledge through non-conventional channels, thereby influencing deci-sions on transboundary management. In the 3S, these networks require advice and technical support brokeredacross scales with support from communication and knowledge products to help improve their effectivenessas agents of change.

Highlighted results

Supporting a process for laying out a roadmap for organising transboundary cooperation in the 3Sbasins and to build needed capacities in key national institutions and stakeholders.

Engaging national and provincial authorities in the process of establishing a national River BasinCommittee for the Sekong in Lao PDR.

Facilitating dialogue with the Cambodian government on a future national Coordination Team forthe Sekong, as a necessary precursor to potential future technical coordination at transboundarylevel.

Identifying and engaging local stakeholders in consultations on the organisation of basinmanagement, supported by training.

Priorities set for a step-wise, country-driven approach to building cooperation in consultations withgovernment, national agencies and civil society in Cambodia and Vietnam on the Sesan and SrePok rivers.

Complementing the Transboundary Initiative led by the Mekong River Commission to establish atransboundary institutions for the Sesan and Sre Pok through support for development of aninformation platform and capacity building.

Page 4: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

2 BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)

The river basins of the Sesan, Sre Pok and Sekong(3S) (3S) spread over approximately 78,650 squarekilometres covering parts of Cambodia (33% of totalbasin area), Lao PDR (29%), and Vietnam (38%). Thesource of the three rivers rests in the Central Highlandsof Vietnam from where the Sekong flows through Lao

THE 3SS RIVER BASIN (CAMBODIA, LAO PDR AND VIETNAM)

PDR before merging with the Sesan and Sre Pok. TheSesan and Sre Pok rivers flow from Vietnam to Cam-bodia where the three rivers merge over a distance ofabout 40 kilometres before forming the confluencewith the main stem of the Mekong River at Stung Trengin Cambodia.

Figure 1. Map of the 3S Basins. Source: Lalita Rammont, IUCN

Page 5: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) 3

migration to the lower parts of the 3S basin. Lao PDRis looking to develop the Sekong basin to contribute tothe economic development of the Sekong Province.

The 3S basin has great potential for agriculture,forestry, hydropower, fisheries, ecotourism and forestryproducts. The aim to improve livelihoods could be lostif basin planning is not conducted with adequate con-sultation with all stakeholders. Hydropower develop-ment is an example of where planning has generallytaken place as mainly a sector-oriented and technol-ogy-driven process focused on profitable outputsrather than sustainable development. The drive forrapid energy production has to a large extent neg-lected the needs of upstream water users and theimpacts of changing flow regimes on downstreamcommunities.

SOCIAL, POLITICAL AND ECONOMIC CONTEXT

Rice planting in Attapeu, Lao PDR.

Agriculture and fisheries are the main sources ofincome for the communities living in the 3S. The

agricultural potential of the area is high and a range ofhigh value cash crops are grown alongside subsis-tence rice paddies. The poorest areas are in theremote mountainous regions, populated by indigenousethnic groups. The livelihoods of these ethnic groupsare based on a mixture of irrigated and rainfed agri-culture and forest products. Increasingly, householdsare supplementing their income through the sale ofhandicrafts for the growing tourism industry.

Vietnam is focusing on economic development of theCentral Highlands in an effort to increase productivityand make the region more economically viable. InCambodia, population pressure in the central andwestern provinces coupled with improved transportinfrastructure in the eastern provinces is driving

Page 6: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

CHALLENGES TO COOPERATION

The need for transboundary cooperation in the 3Sis urgent. Regional development is taking place

rapidly and with the 3S river basin’s high irrigation andhydropower potential, the rivers are expected to playa significant role in the economic growth of the widerregion. The 3S river basin is remote and located farfrom provincial and national capitals making coordina-tion among the three countries difficult. This is furthercompounded by limited basin institution capacities atprovincial and national level. Given that the basin isshared by three countries, each with different politicalsystems and institutional arrangement, there is no one-size-fits-all strategy making good water governancehappen.

Equally challenging is the highly interdependent natureof hydrology and ecosystems in the 3S. River levels,flows and water quality influence the conditions of theLower Mekong, with transboundary impacts bothupstream and downstream of the 3S.

The rivers provide essential resources for the liveli-hoods and subsistence of local people, especiallymarginalised communities, the vulnerable and poor.Uncoordinated development of water resources canhave unpredictable impacts across provincial andnational boundaries. Cooperation over the manage-

ment of water resources provides a means to mitigateand potentially manage the costs for impacted com-munities and countries, but only if the mechanismsfor information sharing, cooperation in basin man-agement, and sharing of the benefits of basin devel-opment are distributed.

Lao PDR has made progress addressing basin man-agement by establishing the first river basin commit-tee (RBC) in 2001, under the now named WaterResources and Environment Administration (WREA).The RBC became functional during the Nam GumRiver Basin Development Project, but due to inade-quate resources and an unclear mandate, progresswas gradual. To increase progress in the establish-ment of RBCs, the Prime Minister in 2010 issued aDecree establishing River Basin Committees the first ofwhich was the Nam Ngum River Basin Committee,designed to operate under the umbrella of the LaoNational Mekong Committee. As part of the Decree,two pilot basins – the Nam Ngum and Nam Theun-Kading – were established, with the Xebangfai,Xebanghieng, Nam Ou and more recently the Sekongin the 3S river basin designated as second priorityRBCs. The primary impediment to implementing theDecree on the Sekong has been national capacity,specifically lack of funding for the project.

4 BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)

Figure 2. BRIDGE in a diversity of transboundary basins around the world.

Page 7: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

BRIDGE ACTIONS, MECHANISMS AND TOOLS

BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) 5

Implementing water diplomacy is not a simpleprocess and BRIDGE incorporates a number ofmechanisms and tools in the 3S. First, it usesdemonstration of how to make cooperation oper-ational in a basin as the basis for confidence andtrust building through shared learning and joint actionon concrete steps in building national and trans-boundary water governance capacity. Second,through learning, BRIDGE uses training and capac-ity building for multiple stakeholders, includingmunicipal and civil society actors as well as high-level national officials, in water governance, interna-tional water law and benefit sharing to improveunderstanding. Third, it facilitates dialogue forconsensus building using demonstration actionsand learning events to catalyse new dialogues ontechnical, development and political matters. Fourth,BRIDGE implements leadership programmes sup-porting the empowerment of champions for trans-boundary water cooperation. Finally, through adviceand support functions, BRIDGE provides guidanceon demand and technical assistance to governmentsand stakeholders, including on effective institutionaland legal frameworks, applications of lessonslearned, and advice and demonstration in trans-boundary hot-spots.

Figure 3. Building River Dialogue and Governance (BRIDGE) strategic process.

Improved water governance through river basininstitutions

At the provincial and national level, as part of demon-strations of cooperation and facilitation of dialogue,BRIDGE supported the formation of the river basinsecretariats for the Sekong River Basin in Lao PDR.Key stakeholders in the Sekong, Sesan, and Sre PokBasins were identified across levels of governance inthe basin. Multi-stakeholder meetings in the SekongRiver Basin were held in Attapeu, Lao PDR and sepa-rately in Stung Treng in Cambodia, with the objectiveto identify and prioritise issues to input into the forma-tion river basin committee on the Sekong.

At the regional level, activities focused on joint effortsbetween Cambodia and Vietnam to produce a scop-ing exercise that would link management plans on theSesan and Sre Pok river basins. Activities have beencoordinated with the ‘Transboundary Cooperation Proj-ect’ led by the Mekong River Commission (MRC) whichfocused on cooperation between Cambodia and Viet-nam on the Sesan and Sre Pok River Basins. Increasedcoordination with the MRC at the regional level has ledto the creation of a National-level Challenges RoadMap for transboundary cooperation.

Page 8: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

been made available through a 3S basin website(www.3sbasin.org) developed and managed byBRIDGE. The site focuses on data and information,linking project documents and 3S basin data toprovincial, national, and regional stakeholders.

Another important knowledge product available on the3S basin website is a situation analysis report withsupport from IUCN Environmental Law Centre (ELC).The report provided a review of institutional arrange-ments, an analysis of domestic legal issues, bilateraltreaties and international agreements relevant to the3S basin. Such analyses have been proven to be cru-cial in understanding the complexities of how to incor-porate multiple layers of water governance in atransboundary institution.

Capacity building and leadership

Capacity building in the 3S is a crucial part of waterdiplomacy. It has focused on four key areas: 1) localtraining on IWRM and water governance, 2) training atthe national level to enhance capacity and coopera-tion, 3) regional training and capacity building throughwater governance and hydro-diplomacy events, and4) development and support of a leadership network.

6 BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)

Hua Khon Waterfall, Lao PDR discharge to Sekong River.

Information and data exchange

A key component of water diplomacy in the 3S is thefacilitation of dialogue and technical exchangesthrough the use of data and information derived fromthe basin. As part of this strategy, a Sekong Basin Pro-file study was developed including water quality sam-pling and analysis and results from field visits on theSekong River Basin. Water quality has been a crucialissue in the Sekong due to the impacts of develop-ment in the area. Therefore, having reliable water qual-ity data is a crucial tool for decision-making providinga basis for negotiation with provincial and national lineagencies. The study also captures the demographic,economic, and political characteristics of the basin,making data and information available for officials andstakeholders. Additionally, a Mekong Factsheet wasproduced that shared important information onBRIDGE activities in the 3S basin translated into Lao,Khmer, and Vietnamese.

Regionally, BRIDGE facilitated coordination withthe Centre for Development and Environment(www.cde.unibe.ch) to source GIS maps for SekongBasin Profile. Cooperation with the two organisationsled to the development of working maps incorporatingGIS layers at provincial and district scales. This has

Page 9: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

BRIDGE ACTIONS, MECHANISMS AND TOOLS

BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) 7

Water Governance training

One of the challenges of river basin management andgood governance is getting the involvement of localsin planning, decision-making, and joint action. As afirst step, BRIDGE developed water governance train-ing packages delivered to Lao PDR, Cambodia, andVietnam participants through “Training of Trainer” work-shops as the first step. Developing the training furtherled to additional workshops in Lao PDR and Cambo-dia with training materials translated into several locallanguages supported by trained facilitators from pre-vious workshops. Participants came from national andprovincial governments, NGOs and the academicsector.

Additionally, specific requests for training on principlesof IWRM have come from local stakeholders from bothLao PDR and Cambodia. Local stakeholders haveshown greater interest in getting involved in water man-agement, thereby increasing their influence on deci-sions made at the national level.

National water governance capacity

The case of Lao PDR is important as the training notonly served to inform and empower stakeholders onthe topics of water governance, international water law,and environmental flows, but also served as a precur-sor for coordinating stakeholder input on river basincommittees in the Sekong – a process supported andled by the government of Lao PDR. The impact oftraining potentially increased momentum and progresstowards formation of the Sekong river basin commit-tee. Later in 2012 and into 2013, Vietnam hasexpressed interest in transboundary cooperation andCambodia is considering a strategy towards greatercooperation and a more coordinated river basin insti-tution in the future.

Regional engagement in hydro-diplomacy

Activity at the regional level revolved around increasedcollaboration with the MRC to coordinate regional leveldialogues, with the Integrated Water Resource Man-agement Project (IWRMP), the Basin Development

Programme (BDP), and the Information and Knowl-edge Management Programme (IKMP). A highlightedevent came with the regional conference on hydro-diplomacy where leaders and stakeholders from theMekong region, came together to share experienceson the meaning and practical uses of hydro-diplomacy.Dignitaries, officials, and stakeholders from across Asiaengaged in dialogue over the practical meanings ofhydro-diplomacy and how to better implement actionson the ground.

Leadership programme

Launched in early 2012, the Leadership programmeassembled a network of champions, or actor ofchange in transboundary cooperation. Its focus was todevelop knowledge and processes of transboundarycooperation with the aim of building a network of keystakeholders in transboundary water governance in the3S river basin. Supported by training workshops,members of the network were empowered to conveyand advocate key information and knowledge on trans-boundary water management to multiple layers of gov-ernment. This provided a means of challenging thestatus quo in a welcoming and productive mannerwhile engaging in meaningful and constructive dialoguewith peers and stakeholders.

Advice and support facilities

Support Facilities have been a key component of theBRIDGE programme in Asia, delivering water gover-nance capacity training packages and Train-the-Trainerworkshops in the basins. Complemented by crucialand timely technical assistance through the Water Lawand Governance Support Platform (www.water-lawandgovernance.org), advice and support facili-ties form the backbone of making water governancework smoothly. Training packages were designed anddelivered to provide a foundation for learning, empow-ering local trainers and supporting the newly formedLeadership Network. Support also was providedthrough knowledge products such as the Water andNature Initiative (WANI) toolkits SHARE and NEGOTI-ATE, which have been translated into Lao, Khmer, andVietnamese.

Page 10: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

BRIDGE ACTIONS, MECHANISMS AND TOOLS

8 BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)

BOX 1. When Capacity Building Builds More than Capacity

When is a capacity building session more than just a capacity building session? Very often, it seems,if it has been organised under the auspices of BRIDGE. As Mark Smith, director of the IUCN GlobalWater Programme, puts it: “Breaking the ice is important. You can look at capacity building as morethan just training.” “The biggest success has been a change in thinking, a change in points of view,”said Lalita Rammont, IUCN project officer in Asia. “I don’t know when people will be ready tocooperate, maybe in five or 10 years, but the seeds have been planted. The people we have invitedto participate in BRIDGE will be part of that change.”

Water Governance Workshop, Saravan Province, Lao PDR, Feb 2013.

Page 11: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

meetings was the government placing greater con-cern on mining activity which having adverse effectson water quality and fisheries.

Another key aspect to cooperation in the 3S is the use,sharing and access of information and knowledge.BRIDGE has played a significant role in this regard bynot only creating and hosting a website on the 3S butproviding support to stakeholders on the use and inter-pretation of information and data. By mobising infor-mation and knowledge, stakeholders and governmentofficials were brought together to discuss areas ofmutual interest in the basin. As part of this strategy, theformation and activities of the Leadership Programmehas contributed to the sharing of information andknowledge through informal interactions with waterprofessionals in their own localities and provinces. Tocomplement the sharing of knowledge locally, BRIDGEhas engaged in a strong partnership with the MekongRiver Commission which is beginning a transboundaryproject on coordination on the Sesan and Sre Pokrivers and is cooperating on data and information shar-ing for the 3S.

Working in the 3S river basin has required stepwiseprogress on water diplomacy, many times encounter-ing significant barriers to cooperation. However, expe-rience illustrates that taking a multi-faceted approachhas yielded the best results. Water diplomacy is amulti-level process and interventions are designed toreach stakeholders at regional, national, provincial, andlocal scales while targeting tangible knowledge, pro-cedural, and relational dimensions of transboundaryriver basin management. This is demonstrated throughreaching out to stakeholders at the regional levelthrough conferences and leadership activities, engag-ing stakeholders at the national level through dialogueon the fundamentals of river basin committees, andtargeting provincial and local-level stakeholders onwater governance training. A key ingredient to makingwater diplomacy work is the ability to provide relevantand timely support to enable interventions to function.In fact, this finding is equally relevant across manyregions that share transboundary basins.

Water governance capacity is a function of soci-ety’s capability to implement effective water

management through policies, laws, institutions, reg-ulations, and compliance mechanisms. Countriesneed to develop each of these components in theirown way – but in all cases, they need to be imple-mented in order to become instruments of effectivewater governance. Traditional diplomacy normallyoccurs at a very high political level, and thus in thewater sector, often leaves crucial stakeholders out ofthe process. In transboundary basins, in particular the3S basin, the issues become more complex due tojurisdictional challenges to implement joint actionsacross boundaries. Water diplomacy is about gainingmulti-stakeholder, multi-level agreements on watermanagement decisions, planning, and actions. There-fore, results from BRIDGE interventions do not nec-essarily originate from one level – they come fromnational, provincial, and local levels and often emergefrom interactions of multiple layers of governance andstakeholder meetings.

As part of Lao PDR’s plan to enhance river basin man-agement, it instituted a Decree to form a number ofnational river basin committees (RBCs) including theSekong as one of its priority basins. BRIDGE sup-ported this by coordinating with the Water Resourcesand Environment Administration from Lao PDR to facil-itate discussions with stakeholders on what the com-ponents of a river basin committee on the Sekong.BRIDGE also worked with Cambodia to facilitate dis-cussions on a National Coordination Team that could,in future, provide a foundation for technical coordina-tion on the Sekong at the transboundary level.

Part of creating spaces for dialogue is understandinghow components of good water governance worktogether and are applied in transboundary basins.With support from BRIDGE, by mid-2012, Lao PDRbecame more and more interested in discussing thefundamental designs for river basin committees onthe Sekong. A key aspect of this intervention is thelinking of local, provincial, and national stakeholdersto make decisions for the benefit of the entire basin.An unexpected development coming out of these

BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) 9

SOLUTIONS AND INTERVENTION RESULTS

Page 12: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

SOLUTIONS AND INTERVENTION RESULTS

10 BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)

BOX 2. Information is Golden on the Sekong River

Lao PDR officials in Vientiane had issued a national Decree on river basin committees, and theSekong basin had been named as a priority. As part of its BRIDGE initiative, IUCN helped identifyand mobilise stakeholders to provide input on the RBO plan. Local and national officials from LaoPDR were brought into the same room at the same time. From that meeting came betterunderstanding and a shared vision. But in countries that share the Sekong, information is oftenscarce, especially information about events and realities in remote areas. “The area is far from themain capitals,” said Ganesh Pangare. Just to reach some parts of the 3S region requires a nearheroic effort, no matter which capital you set out from. Tek Vannara, deputy executive director ofthe NGO Forum on Cambodia, recalls taking “three days to cover 540 kilometres” on the nearlyimpassable roadways of his country’s provinces. Given the difficult geography, “information andknowledge are very important in this region. The right information is very important so that we canbe ready for the next step,” remarked Lalita Rammont, based in Bangkok. An example of this wasone of the major issues that came up in the basin was water pollution. Providing otherwise scarceinformation to somebody in the right place can go a long way. Once information became availableon water conditions in the Sekong, a decision was made to put better controls on water quality andmining.

Gold panning in Attapue, Sekong River, Lao PDR.

Page 13: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

available in local languages. Information products arenot enough – stakeholders need to understand andbe able to use knowledge tools to effect for realchange to take place

Through the procedural dimension, a strategy to informand support national processes, with institutionalstructures, has provided guidance on internationallegal aspects on how water is managed. Examplesinclude support to national and local stakeholders toimplement the legal Decree in Lao PDR to set up riverbasin institutions, or cooperation with the MekongRiver Commission interacting with countries throughthe National Mekong Committees – both dealing withprocedural issues on water management. Experiencein the 3S shows that in the case where water man-agement is a sensitive and political issue, a stepwiseapproach is preferred over large leaps forward. Thiswas illustrated by engaging with national processes inLao PDR to form river basin committees, working withCambodia to create a future platform for technicalcoordination and facilitating interest from Vietnam toengage in BRIDGE processes. The use of water gov-ernance training and advocacy from the LeadershipNetwork can also have a positive impact on bringingstakeholders together, catalysing official transbound-ary cooperation.

Experience in the 3S basin has emphasised theneed for a stepwise multi-level approach to water

diplomacy and transboundary basin management.Given the regional hydropolitical context over devel-opment and a wide range of political arrangements inthe countries sharing the 3S basins, there are signifi-cant challenges for implementing transboundary basinmanagement. Innovative approaches are urgentlyneeded. BRIDGE activities are designed to workaround constraints by facilitating agreements at multi-ple levels, filling the spaces left between stakeholdergroups and different levels of governance.

Successful interventions in the 3S basin have takenthree critical pathways. Through the substantivedimension, they focused on creating and disseminat-ing data, information, and knowledge. A key learning isthat access to information and knowledge is an effec-tive tool for influencing stakeholders and decision-makers. Access, understanding, and dissemination ofinformation is power and directing this power to stake-holders across multiple scales accelerates the rate ofchange in the basin – toward better water governanceand cooperation. For example, the Sekong basin pro-file and 3S website provides data and information toprovincial and local stakeholders. Moreover, to beeffective, information and knowledge needs to be

BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) 11

LESSONS LEARNED GOING FORWARD

Playing at sunset in Attapue on the Sekong river basin, Lao PDR.

Page 14: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

A key strategy, then, is to enhance water diplomacy inthe 3S is to not only support national interests but toengage in regional processes. BRIDGE supported aregional transboundary initiative by charting a roadmap for benefit sharing on transboundary coopera-tion. Due to the need to have national authority overany agreements, a multi-level, multi-stakeholderapproach to getting agreement on key issues wastaken – often filling gaps between local, provincial,national and regional governance mechanisms.

Through the relational dimension, water diplomacy isabout understanding the complex interactionsbetween institutional and political aspects of watermanagement. The role of stakeholders in decision-making is, therefore, dependant on the interests ofstakeholder groups and their power relations in waterinstitutions. At the regional and national levels, BRIDGEhosted several conferences and workshops and as aresult is becoming a known source of knowledge andsupport on issues of environmental flows, water gov-ernance, and international water law.

Through the Leadership Network, BRIDGE has learnedthat change can occur through non-traditional channels

– such as through individuals at work, through virtualnetworks, and at side events at regional conferences.Bottom-up approaches can compliment top-downapproaches – adding new dimensions to water gov-ernance and cooperation in a basin. This was also theapproach in the stakeholder meetings in Lao PDR onriver basin committee emphasising IWRM principlesand participatory approaches to water resources man-agement. A crucial part of a Leadership Network isthus to become an actual bridge for stakeholders,bringing together local, provincial, and national stake-holders – a dynamic that builds relationships acrossgeographic, political, and cultural boundaries.

Taking these lessons forward, BRIDGE in the 3S basinwill focus on a common information platform support-ing water resources management, capacity building ofkey stakeholders specifically in transboundary coop-eration, and utilising information and communicationto enhance cross-sectoral dialogue at the regionallevel. Activities will continue to reinforce interventionstrategies at the national and regional levels in an effortto foster greater cooperation and water governancefor the millions of people relying on water from theSesan, Sre Pok, and Sekong river basins.

12 BRIDGE Case Study – The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)

LESSONS LEARNED GOING FORWARD

“Experience in the 3S has emphasised theneed for a stepwise multi-level approachto water diplomacy and transboundary

basin management.”

Page 15: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

About IUCN

IUCN, International Union for Conservation of Nature, helps the world find pragmaticsolutions to our most pressing environment and development challenges.

IUCN’s work focuses on valuing and conserving nature, ensuring effective andequitable governance of its use, and deploying nature-based solutions to globalchallenges in climate, food and development. IUCN supports scientific research,manages field projects all over the world, and brings governments, NGOs, the UN and companies together to develop policy, laws and best practice.

IUCN is the world’s oldest and largest global environmental organization, with morethan 1,200 government and NGO members and almost 11,000 volunteer experts insome 160 countries. IUCN’s work is supported by over 1,000 staff in 45 offices andhundreds of partners in public, NGO and private sectors around the world.

www.iucn.org

Page 16: The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam)cmsdata.iucn.org/downloads/3s_river_basin.pdf · 2BRIDGE Case Study –The 3S River Basin (Cambodia, Lao PDR and Vietnam) The river

INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR CONSERVATION OF NATURE

WORLD HEADQUARTERSRue Mauverney 281196 Gland, [email protected] +4122 999 0000Fax +41 22 999 0002www.iucn.org/bridgewww.waterandnature.org