TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT OF BIDS OF …eproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/449_LAB DHQ 2014-15b.pdf · TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT OF BIDS OF ELECTROMEDICAL lAB EQUIPMENTS PURCHAES

TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT OF BIDS OF ELECTROMEDICAL lAB EQUIPMENTS PURCHAES FOR DHQ HOSPITAL GUJRANWALA 2014-15

S/No. Assessment Criteria Sigma

InternationalHOORA Pharma

Meditec

InstrumentsAM sale & service Ali Traders

1Product cirtificate (CE/MHLW/CE/MDD)

for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4

2 Aditional benefit = 2 2

latest incometax paid = 4 4 4 4

Balance sheet = 8 or

Bank statement = 66 6 6

4 Sale refrance to the products = 8 3 0 0

5 Overall reputation to the products = 10 0 0 0

6In one continent = 4 or

In two continents = 6 (Max 10)10 0 10

7 Products specialization = 10 0 0

Repair workshop as per manufacturer = 12 12 0

Spare parts = 8 8

At least 5 technical persons = 10 10 10 10

Each diploma =1 and

Each Bsc Engineer = 2 and

Each Msc engineer = 5 (Max 10)

8 10 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 34 40 0 0

Remarks: Graded Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded

1. PH Analyzer

3

8

9

incompelete offer

make and model is

not propper

mention in their

technical offer no

warrenty and

validity mention in

their technical offer

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

3 years.


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Sigma

InternationalHoora Pharma

Meditec

InstrumentsAM sale & service Ali Traders

1 PH/Blood Gas Ananlyzer (Automatic)

MODEL BG100 348 Easy State Not mention CCA TS

MANUFACTURERConvergent

TechologiesSiemens

Medica

CorporationNova Opti Medical

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Germany Europe USA USA USA

AUTHORIZATION Yes

Quality Cirtificate Yes

Warrenty YesMicro-Processor Controlled micro blood gas/pH measuring system.

Automatic calibration ' Automatic measurement of P02, pH, PC02. Yes

Automatic calculation of base excess, 02 Sat Act HC03 standard HC03 and total

C02. complete with standard and operational accessories, including built n

display and printer. Compatible online UPS. Electrolyte (Na/K/CL/ Hemoglobin). Power

source 220 V 50 Hz AC Imported from EEC. US, JapanYes

RecommendationTechnically

Approved

Techincally Not

Approved.Technically Not

Approved

Technically Not

Approved

Technically Not

Approved

1. PH Analyzer

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a.w

arre

nty

no

t m

en

tio

n.

Inco

mp

ele

te o

ffe

r 3

rd p

arty

dis

trib

uti

on

an

d q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

on

e y

ear

inst

ead

of

3 y

ear

s.

Inco

mp

ele

te o

ffe

r m

ake

an

d m

od

el i

s

no

t p

rop

pe

r m

en

tio

n in

th

eir

tech

nic

al o

ffe

r n

o w

arre

nty

an

d

valid

ity

me

nti

on

in t

he

ir t

ech

nic

al

off

er.

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a.W

arre

nty

no

t m

en

tio

n.



International

Quintex

Medical

Sameer

Enterprises

Su

Enterprises

Scientific

Technical

Corporation

Ali TradersSheikhupura

Surgical

1

Product cirtificate (CE/MHLW/CE/MDD)

for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4

2 Aditional benefit = 2 2 2 2

latest incometax paid = 4 4 4 4 4 4


Bank statement = 66 8 6 7 8

4 Sale refrance to the products = 8 3 5 7 7 6

5 Overall reputation to the products = 10 0 6 0 0


In two continents = 6 (Max 10)10 10 4 10 10


Repair workshop as per manufacturer = 12 12 12 0 0 12

Spare parts = 8 8 8 8 8 8

At least 5 technical persons = 10 10 10 0 10 10

Each diploma =1 and



8 5 3 8 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 72 36 60 70

Remarks: Graded Graded Not Graded Not Graded Graded

2. Water bath

3

8

9

Incomeplet

offer 3rd

party

distribution

one year

warrenty

instead of

three years.

Incomeplet

offer model and

make of quoted

items not

mention.


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Sigma

International

Quintex

Medical

Sameer

Enterprices

Su

Enterprises

Scientific

Technical

Corporation

Ali TradersSheikhupura

Surgical

2 Water Bath

MODEL WNB 29 BW-20H BM-30 Precisdig WSB-30 BM30 Not Mention

MANUFACTURER Memmert Medline Nuve JP Selecta Witage NUVE Not Mention

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Germany UK Turkey Spain Germany Turkey Not Mention

AUTHORIZATION Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No

Quality Cirtificate Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Warrenty 3Y 3Y 2Y 1Y 3Y 1Y

Thermostatic control, temperature upto 100 C+/- 1 C, inner stainless steel, with

thermometer gabelled, cover, time switch . Capacity of 30 liters. 220 V, 50Hz. AC

Complete accessories, imported from EEC. US, Japan

Yes

Offered

model is

having 20

litter capacity

instead of 30

as required

by tender.

Do not fulfill

grading

criteria. Also

the offered

model is not

from USA,

Europe,

Japan

warrenty if

two years

instead of

three years.

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria

quoted

warrenty is

one year

instead of

three years.

Capacity is 12

liters instead

of 20

Country of

origin is korea

instead of

Germany

WITAGE is not

orignal

equipment

manufacturer.

Incomeplet

offer 3rd

party

distribution

one year

warrenty

instead of

three years.

Country of

origin is

turkey that is

not come in

europe.


Approved

Technically

Not

Approved.

Technically

Not

Approved,

Technically

Not

Approved

Technically

Not Approved

Technically

Not

Approved

Technically Not

Approved

Incomeplet

offer model and

make of quoted

items not

mention.

2. Water Bath


S/N

o.Assessment Criteria Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises

Popular

Internatinoal (Pvt)

Ltd.

Scientific Technical

CorporationAli Traders Hospitech Sheikhupura Surgical

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4

2 Aditional benefit = 2 2 2








7 Products specialization = 10 0 0 0




Each diploma =1 and



3 8 5 6 4

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 36 60 75 70 51

Remarks: Not Graded Not Graded Graded Graded Not Graded

3. Centrifuge

Incomeplet offer

model and make of

quoted items not

mention.

Incompelete offer

3rd party distribution

and quoted warrenty

is one year instead of

3 years.

3

8

9


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises

Popular

International


CorporationAli Traders Hospitech healthcare Sheikhupura Surgical

MODEL NF 200 EBA-20 Humax 4K 2420 NV200 Microcen 23

MANUFACTURER NUVE Hettich Human KUBOTA NUVE Ortoalresa

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Turkey Germany Germany Japan Turkey Spain

AUTHORIZATION Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Quality Cirtificate Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Warrenty 2Y 1Y 3Y 3Y 1 year

Speed 5000-6000 rpm. capacity 8x15ml swing out

rotor, built in speedometer, vanable speed

control, lid' locking and braking device, time

switch 0-60 minutes. Standard accessories, 223V. 50

Hz. AC. Imported from EEC. US, Japan

Do not fulfill

assment criteria.

Quoted warrenty is

2years inatesad of

3years.

Also offered model is

not from

USA,Europe, Japan

Did not fulfill

assessment criteria.

Quoted warrenty is

1year inatead of

3years.

Yes4000 rpm instead of

5000

Did not fullfill

assessment criteria.

Quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

three years.Fixed

angle rotor

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically

Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Incomeplet offer

model and make of

quoted items not

mention.

3. Centrifuge

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of 3

years.



InternationalQuintex Medical

Sameer

EnterprisesSU Enterprises

Scientific

Technical

Corporation

Sheikhupura

Surgical

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4













Each diploma =1 and



8 5 3 8 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 72 36 60 70


4. Hot Air Oven

3

8

9

Incomeplet offer

model and make of

quoted items not

mention.


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Sigma

InternationalQuintex Medical

Sameer


Scientific

Technical

Corporation

Sheikhupura

Surgical

MODEL UN75 A3-217-535 FN 55 ED-115 WOF-105

MANUFACTURER Memmert Titanox NUVE Binder WITAGE

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Germany Italy Turkey Germany Germany



Warrenty 3Y 3Y 2Y 1Y 3Y

Thermostatically controlled, temperature range max upto 220 C+/- 2 C -

‘‘ted with thermostat. Thermometer, digital timer, internal stainless

steel, 220 V. 50 Hz AC.

Yes Yes

Do

no

t fu

lfill

ass

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

2ye

ars

inat

esa

d o

f 3

year

s.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t fr

om

USA

,Eu

rop

e, J

apan

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

1ye

ar in

ate

ad o

f 3

year

s.

Co

un

try

of

ori

gin

is k

ore

a in

ste

ad o

f G

erm

any

WIT

AG

E is

no

t o

rign

al e

qu

ipm

en

t m

anu

fact

ure

r.

Comp'ete with standard accessories, capacity 60 liters. Imported from EEC. US .JapanYes Yes


Approved

Technically

Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Inco

me

ple

t o

ffe

r m

od

el a

nd

mak

e o

f q

uo

ted

ite

ms

no

t m

en

tio

n.

4. Hot Air Oven



International

Sameer

Enterprises

SU

Enterprises

Popular

International


Corporation

Hospitech

Healthcare

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4






5 Overall reputation to the products = 10 0 0



7 Products specialization = 10 0

Repair workshop as per manufacturer = 12 12 0 12

Spare parts = 8 8 8 8


Each diploma =1 and



8 8 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 60 70

Lab Items For DHQ Hospital Gujranwala Remarks: Graded Not Graded Graded

3

8

9


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Sigma

International

Sameer

Enterprises

SU

Enterprises

Popular

International


Corporation

Hospitech

Healthcare

5 Roller Mixture

MODEL Movil-Rod RM-500 7000912 HumaRoll ATRL-2 F 406

MANUFACTURER JP Selecta Teknolabo Jp Selecta Human A&E LAB Not Mention

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Spain Italy Spain Germany U.K Not Mention

AUTHORIZATION

Quality Cirtificate

Warrenty

Imported from EEC. US, Japan. Complete accessories

Recommendation:

5. Roller Mixer

May be retender with generalized specifications.



InternationalQuintex Medical Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises

Popular

International


CorporationAli Traders

Hospitech

Healthcare

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4










Repair workshop as per manufacturer = 12 12 0 12



Each diploma =1 and



8 8 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 60 70

Lab Items For DHQ Hospital Gujranwala Remarks: Graded Not Graded Graded

3

8

9

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

3 years.


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sigma

International Quintex Medical Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises

Popular

International


Corporation Ali Traders

Hospitech

Healthcare

6 Vortex Mixture

MODEL Movil-Vib AAH-360115 300-100 ZX3 HumaTwist VM-10 VX 200 MIX 20

MANUFACTURER JP Selecta Medline Teknolabo Velp Human Witage Labnet Falsi Insturment

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Spain UK Italy Italy Germany Germany USA Italy

AUTHORIZATION

Quality Cirtificate

Warrenty

Imported from EEC. US, Japan. Complete

accessoriesMay be retender with generalized specifications.

6. Vortex Mixture


S/No. Assessment Criteria Sigma International Sameer Enterprises SU EnterprisesScientific Technical

CorporationHospitech Sheikhupura Surgical

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4













Each diploma =1 and



8 3 8 6 4

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 36 60 70 51

Lab Items For DHQ Hospital Gujranwala Remarks: Graded Not Graded Not Graded Graded Not Graded

7. LAB Refrigrator

3

8

9

Incomeplet offer

model and make of

quoted items not

mention.


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sigma International Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises


CorporationHospitech Healthcare Sheikhupura Surgical

MODEL LR 440 BLCRF 425W LFF660 AF70V/2 Labor 7002T

MANUFACTURER Evermed Evermed Arctiko Frimed Not Mention

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Italy Italy Denmark Italy Not Mention




For storage of specimens, diagnostic kits, reagents and anti-serum. Temperature

variable. Control panel includes audible alarm, defrost, door & over temperature

indicator lights, digital temperature select dial with adjustable shelves in the hair of

cab-net and roll out baskets with safety cathes in the other half, two double pan

glass dcors with heating :7m, lock and key. S.S. interior, interior light, automatic

safety device to shut down when temperature is below -2 C or

0 to 15 degree C Yes

above +20 C Cap: 15-20 Cuft. Complete unit operatable on 220 V 50 Hz AC.

Imported from EEC. US, Japan. Complete accessories

Yes Yes


Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically

Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Inco

me

ple

t o

ffe

r m

od

el a

nd

mak

e o

f q

uo

ted

ite

ms

no

t m

en

tio

n.

Do

no

t fu

lfill

ass

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

2ye

ars

inat

esa

d o

f 3

year

s.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t fr

om

USA

,Eu

rop

e, J

apan

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

1ye

ar in

ate

ad o

f 3

year

s.

Did

no

t fu

llfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

on

e y

ear

inst

ead

of

thre

e y

ear

s. F

ixe

d a

ngl

e r

oto

r

7. Laboratory Refrigerator/Freezer



InternationalQuintex Medical Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises


Corporation

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4













Each diploma =1 and



8 5 3 8 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 72 36 60 70


3

8

9

8. Electronic Balance


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Sigma

International

Quintex

Medical

Sameer



Corporation

MODEL FA-2204B MD 8104 FA-2004B PA 214 NBL 214E

MANUFACTURERJP Selecta Branded by

ComectaMedline JP Selecta Ohaus ADAM Equp

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Spain UK Spain USA UK




Capscity 40/200 Mg. Sensitivity 0.1 mg, 220 V 50 Hz AC complete ready to use with standard

accessories. Imported from EEC. US, Japan. Yes

Off

er

Sen

siti

vity

is 1

mg

inst

ead

of

0.1

mg

Do

no

t fu

lfill

ass

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

2ye

ars

inat

esa

d o

f 3

year

s.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t fr

om

USA

,Eu

rop

e, J

apan

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

1ye

ar in

ate

ad o

f 3

year

s.

Yes


Approved

Technically Not


Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.Technically

Approved

8. Electronic Balance


S/No. Assessment Criteria Gulf Marketing

International

HOORA

Pharma

Mian

Scientific

Popular

International

Ghrasa

Labartory

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4

2 Aditional benefit = 2 2 2 2 2 2





5 Overall reputation to the products = 10 0 0 0 7 0



7 Products specialization = 10 0 0 0 0 0




Each diploma =1 and



0 10 0 5 2

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 28 36 26 77 36

Remarks: Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded Graded Not Graded

3

8

9

9. Spectrophotometer


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Gulf Marketing

InternationalHoora Pharma Mian Scientific

Popular

International

Ghrasa

Labartory

MODEL Tecno 786 Plus MC15 5V3 Humalyzer 5010V5+

MANUFACTURERaudit

diagnostic

Diasys

DiagnosticERBA Chem Human Robert Riele

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN ireland Europe German Germany Germany



Warrenty 2Y Not Mention 3Y 3Y 3Y

Microprocessor control UV/ Visible wavelength range 200-900 nm banwicth 2-5 nm better 220" V, 50 Hz AC. Imported irom EcC US, Japan. Complete accessories. Compatible online UPS

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria.

Quoted

warrenty is 2Y

instead of 3Y.

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria

warrenty not

mention.

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria.

Yes

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria.

Recommendation

Technically

Not

Approved

Technically

Not

Approved

Technically

Not

Approved

Technically

Approved

Technically

Not

Approved

9. Spectrophotometer


S/No. Assessment Criteria Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises HOORA PharmaScientific Technical

Corporation


Corporation


Corporation

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4 4

2 Aditional benefit = 2 2 2 2 2

latest incometax paid = 4 4 4 4 4 4 4


Bank statement = 66 7 6 8 8 8

4 Sale refrance to the products = 8 7 7 0 6 6 6



In two continents = 6 (Max 10)4 10 0 10 10 10


Repair workshop as per manufacturer = 12 0 0 0 12 12 12


At least 5 technical persons = 10 0 10 10 10 10 10

Each diploma =1 and



3 8 10 6 6 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 36 60 34 70 70 70

Remarks: Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded Graded Graded Graded

3

8

9

10. Dilutor


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Sameer

EnterprisesSU Enterprises Hoora Pharma


Corporation


Corporation


Corporation

MODEL Repette-HW 263-029 Varispenser+ 520.002 520.005 520.05

MANUFACTURER JP Selecta Jencons Eppendrof Socorax Socorax Socorax

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Spain UK Germany Switzerland Switzerland Switzerland

AUTHORIZATION Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes


Warrenty 2Y 1Y No mention 3Y 3Y 3Y

For repetitive dispensing of samples from 0.2-30 ml with wide neck

reservoir Syringe size 10 ml. reservoir 5000 ml. Imported from EEC US, Japan. Complete

sccesscres.

Do

no

t fu

lfill

ass

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

2ye

ars

inat

esa

d o

f 3

year

s.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t fr

om

USA

,Eu

rop

e, J

apan

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a.

Qu

ote

d w

arre

nty

is 1

year

inat

ead

of

3ye

ars.

Did not fulfill

assessment criteria

warrenty not

mention.

0.25 to 2 1 to 5 5 to 50

Recommendation

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not


Approved.

Subject to Sample

evaluation

Subject to Sample

evaluation

Subject to Sample

evaluation

10. Dilutor


S/No. Assessment Criteria Quintex Medical Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises HOORA PharmaPopular Internatinoal

(Pvt) Ltd.



1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4 4













Each diploma =1 and



5 3 8 10 5 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 72 36 60 34 75 70

Remarks: Graded Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded Graded Graded

3

8

9

Incompelete offer 3rd

party distribution and

quoted warrenty is one

year instead of 3 years.

11. Automatic Pipettes


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Quintex Medical

Sameer

Enterprises SU Enterprises Hoora Pharma

Popular

International



MODEL AO-10 .. 5000 Research + fixed & adjs

MANUFACTURER Medline Diamate Ohaus Eppendrof Human Socorax HTL

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN UK UK USA Germany Germany Switzerland Poland



Warrenty 3Y 2Y 1Y Not Mention 3Y 3YAdjustable size 10-100 ul Complete accessories. Imported from EEC ,US , Japan

Yes Yes 10 to 100

Adjustable size 100-500 ul Complete accessories. Yes Yes 100 to 1000Fixed volume 10 ul with tip ejector. Complete accessorie Imported from EEC.

US. Japan. Yes Yes Yes

Fixed volume 20 ul with tip ejector. Complete accessories Imported from; EEC.

US, Japan Yes Yes Yes

Fixed volume 50 ul with tip ejector. Complete accessories Imposed from EEC,

US, Japan Yes Yes Yes

Fixed volume 100 u! with tip ejector. Complete accessories Imported from. EEC

US. Japan Yes Yes Yes

Technically Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Do not fulfill assment

criteria

Technically Not

Approved

Technically Not

ApprovedTechnically Approved Technically Approved

Technically Not

Approved

11. Automatic Pipettes



quoted warrenty is


years.

Did not fulfill

assessment criteria

warrenty not mention.

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

1ye

ar in

ate

ad o

f 3

year

s.

Do

no

t fu

lfill

ass

me

nt

crit

eri

a.

Qu

ote

d w

arre

nty

is 2

year

s

inat

esa

d o

f 3

year

s.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t fr

om

USA

,Eu

rop

e, J

apan



International

Seico Scientific

Traders

Gulf Marketing

InternationalHOORA Pharma

Popular

Internatinoal (Pvt)

Ltd.

Ghrasa Labartory Ghrasa Labartory Ali Traders Ali Traders

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4 4 4


latest incometax paid = 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4


Bank statement = 66 8 8 6 8 6 6

4 Sale refrance to the products = 8 3 5 0 0 7 0 0

5 Overall reputation to the products = 10 0 0 0 0 7 0 0


In two continents = 6 (Max 10)10 4 10 0 10 10 10

7 Products specialization = 10 0 0 0 0 0 0

Repair workshop as per manufacturer = 12 12 0 0 0 12 0 0


At least 5 technical persons = 10 10 10 0 10 10 0 0

Each diploma =1 and



8 10 0 10 5 2 2

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 45 26 34 75 36 36

Remarks: Graded Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded Graded Not Graded Not Graded

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

3 years.

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

3 years.

12. Auto Chemistry

3

8

9


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM

Sigma

InternationalSeico scientific

Gulf Marketing

InternationalHoora Pharma

Popular

InternationalGhrasa Labartory Ghrasa Labartory Ali Traders Ali Traders

MODEL Fully pictus basic accent 300 XL-180 Humaster 200 Alcor Sphera Mocrolab 300 Selecta Pro S

MANUFACTURER BSI diatron pz cormay ERBA Mannhein Human EDIF EDIF

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Italy hungary Poland Germany Germany Italy Italy Neatherland Neatherland

AUTHORIZATION Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Quality Cirtificate Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes

Warrenty 3Y 1Y 2Y Not Mention 3Y 3Y 3Y

Automatic Analyzer Computer controlled,

programmable Complete accessories foe all

chemistries Open System randcmaccess . Display

Monitor, Builtin Printer. The manufacturers must

have a range of standards, reagents about they

must give a surity regarding their availability With

standard operational accessories Power source

220 V. 50 Hz. AC. Compatible online UPS. Import

crom EEC. US, Japan

Yes

Do not fulfill

assment criteria.

Quoted warrenty

is 1Y instaed of 3Y

& UPS not quoted.

Also offered

model is not fully

automatic

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria. Quoted

warrenty is 2Y

instead of 3Y.

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria warrenty

not mention.

Yes

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria.

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria.


Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically

Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

3 years.

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

3 years.

12. Auto Chemistry


S/No. Assessment Criteria Seico Scientific

Traders

Gulf Marketing

International

Popular

Internatinoal (Pvt)

Ltd.

Scientific

Technical

Corporation

AM sale & service Ali Traders Hospitech HOORA Pharma

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4 4

2 Aditional benefit = 2 2 2 2 2 2 2





5 Overall reputation to the products = 10 0 0 7 0 1 0



7 Products specialization = 10 0 0 0 0 0 0


Spare parts = 8 0 8 8 8


Each diploma =1 and



10 0 5 6 4 10

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 47 28 77 70 53 36

Lab Items For DHQ Hospital Gujranwala Remarks: Not Graded Not Graded Graded Graded Not Graded Not Graded

13. Hamatology Analyzer

3

8

9

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty is

one year instead of

3 years.

incompelete offer

make and model is

not propper

mention in their

technical offer no

warrenty and

validity mention in

their technical

offer


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Seico Scientific Gulf Marketing

Popular

International

Scientific

Technical

Corporation

AM sale & service Ali TradersHospitech

HealthcareHOORA Pharma

13 Hematology Anaylizer

MODEL abacus 380 mythic 18 Humacount 60TS Norma Icon Not mention Medonic M SeriesSwelab Alpha

Basic 16PDrew 3

MANUFACTURER diatron orphee s.a Human Norma Icon Not mention Boule Medical Drew Scientific Inc

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN hungary germany Germany Austria Not mention Sweeden Swedan USA

AUTHORIZATION

Quality Cirtificate

Warrenty 1Y 2Y 3Y 3Y Not Mention 1Y Not Mention

Electronic resistence methode atlest RBC, WBC,HCT, MCH, HGB, PLT,

MCV, MCHC parameter with digital display and printer. Sample volume

according to individual design. Compelete accessories. Power source

220V, 50Hz. Compatible onlone UPS imported.

Do not fulfill

assment criteria.

Quoted warrenty

is 1Y instaed of 3Y

& UPS not quoted.

Also offered

model is not fully

automatic

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria. Quoted

warrenty is 2Y

instead of 3Y.

Yes Yes

Inco

mp

ele

te o

ffe

r m

ake

an

d

mo

de

l is

no

t p

rop

pe

r m

en

tio

n in

the

ir t

ech

nic

al o

ffe

r n

o

war

ren

ty a

nd

val

idit

y m

en

tio

n

in t

he

ir t

ech

nic

al o

ffe

r.

Did not fullfill

assessment

criteria. Quoted

warrenty is one

year instead of

three years. Fixed

angle rotor

Did not fulfill

assessment

criteria warrenty

not mention.

RecommendationTechnically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically

Approved

Technically

Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Incompelete offer

3rd party

distribution and

quoted warrenty

is one year instead

of 3 years.

13. Hamatology Analyzer


S/No. Assessment Criteria Sigma InternationalPopular Internatinoal

(Pvt) Ltd.AM sale & service Ali Traders

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4


latest incometax paid = 4 4 4


Bank statement = 66 8

4 Sale refrance to the products = 8 3 7



In two continents = 6 (Max 10)10 10



Spare parts = 8 8 8

At least 5 technical persons = 10 10 10

Each diploma =1 and



8 5

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 75

Remarks: Graded Graded

14. Coagulation Analyzer

3

8

9

incompelete offer make

and model is not

propper mention in

their technical offer no

warrenty and validity

mention in their

technical offer






Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sigma International

Popular

InternationalAM sale & service Ali Traders

MODEL CA4000 Humaclot Duo + Not mention Medonic M Series

MANUFACTURERConvergent

TechnologiesHuman SAS Wienerlab

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Germany Germany France Argentina

AUTHORIZATION Yes Yes

Quality Cirtificate Yes Yes

Warrenty 3Y 3YAutomatic 2 channel, complete with electric pipett,. Random access system. Minimum capacity of 30 cuvettes 3-reagents bottles.. Complete unit ready to use with

standard operational accessories with all test and ratio. Power source 220 V, 50 Hz, AC. Compatible online UPS. Imported from EEC. US, Japan

Yes Yes

Remarks Technically approved Technically approved Technically Not

Approved

Technically Not

Approved

14. Coagulation Analyzer





Incompelete offer

make and model is not

propper mention in

their technical offer no

warrenty and validity

mention in their

technical offer.


S/No. Assessment Criteria Hoora Pharma AM sale & service

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

HOORA Pharma


latest incometax paid = 4


Bank statement = 64

4 Sale refrance to the products = 8 6

5 Overall reputation to the products = 10 0


In two continents = 6 (Max 10)0


Repair workshop as per manufacturer = 12 0

Spare parts = 8 0

At least 5 technical persons = 10

Each diploma =1 and



10

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 24

Remarks: Not Graded

15. URINE STRIP

incompelete offer make and model

is not propper mention in their

technical offer no warrenty and

validity mention in their technical

offer

3

8

9


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Hoora Pharma AM sale & service

MODEL Not mention

MANUFACTURER Uro-Dispckeck 240e Electronika

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN ERBA Mannheim Hungary

AUTHORIZATION Germany

Quality Cirtificate

Warrenty

Imported from EEC. US, Japan. Complete accessories.

Recommendation Technically Not Approved. Technically Not Approved.

15. URINE STRIP

Incompelete offer make and

model is not propper mention in

their technical offer no warrenty

and validity mention in their

technical offer.

Did not fulfill assessment criteria

warrenty not mention.


S/No. Assessment Criteria Sigma International Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises HOORA Pharma HOORA PharmaScientific Technical


1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4 4









7 Products specialization = 10 0 0 0 0




Each diploma =1 and



8 3 8 10 10 6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 36 60 34 34 70

Remarks: Graded Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded Graded

16. Microscope 2Head




quoted warrenty is


years.

3

8

9


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sigma International Sameer Enterprises SU Enterprises Hoora Pharma Hoora Pharma



MODEL B-192 G-302 MCX 100 BB4260 Novex-81.600 LX400 DM 500+2

MANUFACTURER Optika Optima Micros Blue Line EUROMAX Labomed Leica

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Italy Japan Australia Holland Holland USA Germany



Warrenty 3Y 2Y 1Y 3Y 3Y 3Y

Binocular. Quadruple revolving

nosepiece Built in mechanical

stage with coaxial and vernier

scale Abbes two lens condernser

and diaphragm (Moveable),

filter holder. Rack & Pinion,

Standard filters. Coaxial,

coarse & fine focusing

adjustment. Built in

illuminator. Paired Eyepiece:

10X, Arch: Objectives:

Scanning, 10 x, 40 x,. 100 x,

(spring loasded oil immersion).

Carrying case with lock . Dust

cover. Imported from EEC. US.

Japan. Power source 220 V, 50

Hz, AC. Complete accessories.

YesD

o n

ot

fulf

ill a

ssm

en

t cr

ite

ria.

Qu

ote

d w

arre

nty

is 2

year

s in

ate

sad

of

3ye

ars.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t fr

om

USA

,Eu

rop

e, J

apan

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

1ye

ar

inat

ead

of

3ye

ars.

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a w

arre

nty

no

t m

en

tio

n.

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a w

arre

nty

no

t m

en

tio

n.

cou

ntr

y o

f o

rigi

n o

f th

e q

uo

ted

mo

de

l an

d m

ake

r is

Ind

ia in

ste

ad

of

USA

.

RecommendationSubject to

Demostration.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Inco

mp

ele

te o

ffe

r 3

rd p

arty

dis

trib

uti

on

an

d q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

on

e y

ear

inst

ead

of

3 y

ear

s.


Sheikhupura Surgical



Incomeplet offer

model and make of

quoted items not

mention.


Sheikhupura Surgical

Technically Not

Approved.

Inco

me

ple

t o

ffe

r m

od

el a

nd

mak

e o

f q

uo

ted

ite

ms

no

t m

en

tio

n.


S/No. Assessment Criteria Sigma International SU Enterprises Ali Traders Sheikhupura Surgical

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4











Spare parts = 8 8 8


Each diploma =1 and



8 8

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 60

Remarks: Graded Not Graded Not Graded Not Graded

17. Microscope 4 Head

3

8

9

Incomeplet offer model and

make of quoted items not

mention.

Incompelete offer 3rd party

distribution and quoted

warrenty is one year instead of 3

years.


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sigma International SU Enterprises Ali Traders Sheikhupura Surgical

MODEL B193 MCX500 Lilly DM 500+4

MANUFACTURER Optika Micros Leica

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Italy Austria Germany

AUTHORIZATION Yes Yes

Quality Cirtificate Yes Yes

Warrenty 3Y 1Y

Tetranocuar. Quadruple revolving nosepiece Built in mechanical

stage with coaxial and vernier scale Abbes two lens condernser

and diaphragm (Moveable), filter hoider. Rack & Pinion,

Standard filters. Coaxial, coarse & fine focusing adjustment.

Built in illuminator. Paired Eyepiece: 10X, Arch: Objectives:

Scanning, 10 x, 40 x,, 100 x. (spring loasded -oil immersion).

Carrying case with lock . Dust cover. Imported from EEC US.

Japan. Power source 220 V. 50 Hz.AC Complete accessories

Yes

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

1ye

ar in

ate

ad o

f 3

year

s.

Recomendtaion Technically Approved Technically Not Approved Technically Not Approved Technically Not Approved

17. Microscope 4 Head

Incomeplet offer model and

make of quoted items not

mention.

Inco

mp

ele

te o

ffe

r 3

rd p

arty

dis

trib

uti

on

and

qu

ote

d w

arre

nty

is o

ne

ye

ar in

ste

ad

of

3 y

ear

s.


S/No. Assessment Criteria Sigma International Sameer EnterprisesScientific Technical

CorporationHospitech HOORA Pharma

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4 4 4 4









7 Products specialization = 10 0 0 0 0




Each diploma =1 and



8 3 6 4 10

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 67 36 70 51 34

Remarks: Graded Not Graded Graded Not Graded Not Graded

3

8

9

18. Distilation Plant


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sigma International

Sameer

Enterprises


CorporationHospitech Healthcare Hoora Pharma

MODEL L-4B SA-300VL BMS-4CE DIS 4 Plant-15lr

MANUFACTURER JP Select Sturdy BMS Falc Insturment Siemens Water

Technologies

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Spain Japan Canada Italy Ultra Clear



Warrenty 3Y 2Y 2Y 1Y Not Mention

All borosilicate glass, capacity 4 liters with ground glass,

joints, complete. Imported from EEC. US, Japan.

Power source 220 V. 50 Hz AC. Complete accessories.

Yes

Do

no

t fu

lfill

ass

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

2ye

ars

inat

esa

d o

f 3

year

s.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t

fro

m U

SA,E

uro

pe

, Jap

an

Co

un

try

of

ori

gin

is c

anad

a

inst

ead

of

USA

/ E

UR

OP

/

JAP

AN

.

Did

no

t fu

llfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

on

e y

ear

inst

ead

of

thre

e

year

s. F

ixe

d a

ngl

e r

oto

r

Did

no

t fu

lfill

ass

ess

me

nt

crit

eri

a w

arre

nty

no

t

me

nti

on

.


Approved

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

Technically Not

Approved.

18. Distilation Plant


S/No. Assessment Criteria Seico Scientific TradersPopular Internatinoal

(Pvt) Ltd.Ali Traders

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4 4

2 Aditional benefit = 2










Spare parts = 8 0 8


Each diploma =1 and



10 5

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 45 75

Remarks: Not Graded Graded

19. ESR System





3

8

9


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Seico Scientific Popular International Ali Traders

MODEL Vesmatic 20

MANUFACTURER LENA Humased 100mix Diesse Diagnostic

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Linear Human Germany

AUTHORIZATION Spain Germany

Quality Cirtificate

Warrenty 1Y

Imported from EEC. US. Japan. Compete accessories. May be retnder with generalized and broad specifications.

19. ESR System


S/No. Assessment Criteria Scientific Technical Corporation

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4


latest incometax paid = 4 4


Bank statement = 68





7 Products specialization = 10


Spare parts = 8 8

At least 5 technical persons = 10 10

Each diploma =1 and



6

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 70

Remarks: Graded

3

8

9

20. Autoclave Electric and Gas operated


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Scientific Technical Corporation

20 Autoclave Electric

MODEL WAC-47

MANUFACTURER WITAGE

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Germany

AUTHORIZATION Yes


Warrenty 3Y

Vertical type, electrically heated elements, complete with all accessories, rubber liner. Temp range max 127 +/-

2 C. Capacity 40 liters. Power source 220 V, 50 Hz. AC. Imported from EEC. US, Japan. Complete accessories.

Country of origin is korea instead of Germany

WITAGE is not orignal equipment manufacturer.

Recommendation Technically Not Approved

20. Autoclave Electric and Gas operated


S/No. Assessment Criteria Sameer Enterprises

1


for any one =4

any two = 8

4

2 Aditional benefit = 2

latest incometax paid = 4 4


Bank statement = 66







Spare parts = 8 8

At least 5 technical persons = 10 0

Each diploma =1 and



3

Total = 100 (Req 65 %) 36

Remarks: Not Graded

3

8

9

21. Diffrential Counter


Sr.

NONAME OF FIRM Sameer Enterprises

MODEL 7121431

MANUFACTURER JP selecta

COUNTRY OF ORIGIN Spain

AUTHORIZATION Yes


Warrenty 2YDiffererntial counter, microprocessor controlled, 12 channel unit with overlay for differentiating

all types of cells, digital readout on all 12 channels plus the grand total. Power sourcp-220 V^

50 Hz. AC. Imported from EEC. US, Japan. Complete accessories

Recomendation Technically Not Approved.

Do

no

t fu

lfill

ass

me

nt

crit

eri

a. Q

uo

ted

war

ren

ty is

2ye

ars

inat

esa

d o

f 3

year

s.

Als

o o

ffe

red

mo

de

l is

no

t fr

om

USA

,Eu

rop

e,

Jap

an

21. Diffrential Counter

Documents

TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT OF BIDS OF …eproc.punjab.gov.pk/EvaluationReport/449_LAB DHQ 2014-15b.pdf · TECHNICAL EVALUATION REPORT OF BIDS OF ELECTROMEDICAL lAB EQUIPMENTS PURCHAES