TBen Yagi

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

1/18

PersPectives: international Postgraduate Journal of PhilosoPhy

60

Beyond Subjectivity: Kierkegaards

Self and Heideggers Dasein

Tsutomu B. Yagi

University College Dublin

Abstracti w pp, i Kk

Hi coci th pobm o xitc. I utak th aayi by t

xm w w k m m mptaitio. A it a tmpoa titi, Kikaa a Hi

Dasein mk bj mp

taitio. Thi iv phioophy a w way to ackow th imit o ou it

x m p p .

Howv, I cocu that Kikaa i ti paty co to th mtaphyica

p w existentiellp m

existentialapct. I cot that HiDasein

Kikaa i that th om i uiquy chaacti by th op o

w B.

Keywords: xitc; itu; tmpoaity;Dasein;

Introduction: Against the Tradition

Kikaa a Hi both ca ito qutio th taitioa ia

i phioophy that w ca mo o aquaty uta ouv

. i pp m p ,

thy bi to iht th coct ituatio i which w ouv aom which w away cay out a it tak. I thi pap, I bi by

w Kk h bk w m p

phioophica taitio thouh th otio o xitc (o piit i

Kk). i m x, w mk

m Dasein. i xp w

w Dasein mak th aicai cocptio o itu

mp, i w w xp b Kk

bm pbm. t b w

Kk . h, m mp

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

2/18

61

Beyond suBJectivity:

KIerKegAArds self And HeIdeggers dAseIn

aayi i to motat that Hi aicai byo Kikaa

w Dasein, w m B p p

m w mk w B

.

ex pp mm

bcau uch a ahc tai objctivity, abtactio, a iit

vaiity (a o a a th coitio mai th am). fomaim i thi

, pp , m m

p. i w, b m

cocpt o thoy out o th paticua titi i qutio. Uti th

em, mm m pp

. W , , mm d w m

au that ou c i i ou tat o bi cociou (dcat1985: 127; d 1986: 18, 54). a d, w

m x bj p m b

m. h k

bi (res cogitans) mp , xmp, bk w j

xt thi (res extensa). t m b w d m

m x m m mp w

ic oth xt thi (dcat 1986: 30). A a it ubtac,

whth w po o popty o th oth tmi a what

w . h m m m m b rescogitans res extensa p m . d

xp w m

res cogitans. t w h mm:

W cogito sum dcat ha caim that h wa

putti phioophy o a w a m ooti. But what h

t utmi wh h ba i thi aica way, wa

k B w b res cogitans,

m p meaning of the Being of the sum.(Hi 1962: 46)

dcat omaim tipuat that mi i my a catoy o

pp w m b m . M

mp m d.

K mm

mi by aayi th way th mi cotitut xpic (Kat 1968: 59).

B ppp w xp bj,

w m mk xp pb. i xpo objct i ui u th iua ubjct, a Kat thouht, th it

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

3/18


62

p xp bj -. W

thi uity o cociou, o ca ith bcom awa o o ow

xp b b -. f K, b -

impi havi xpic a coii that a o ow (ibi.: 152-

153). Ba o hi aayi, Kat thu aiv at th tacta uity

o appcptio a th hiht uctio o th mi which uit o

xpic u o ubiti ubjct. Thouh Kat xpoitio i quit

it om that o dcat, h ti maitai th ia that oma

uctio povi itimat kow o u (ibi.: 13-14, 25-26).

Kat pojct wa impy pitmooica ath tha otooica. What

mm b m m pp mode of

investigation b w xp m. t

am oma mo o iquiy, which i abtact a thotica, o thymp m m bj

a tat u jut ik ay oth objct o thi iquiy.

a m d K, m

who I am as an individual b what I am (a huma bi), which

b pp

by thm. Th att qutio ct xitc. Thi i why Hi

commt, I taki ov dcat otooica poitio Kat ma a

m: p Dasein (Hi

1962: 46). W d K p m w cogito -, x p m . t

p b mm

to xitc bcau thy a cotit, it, a tmpoa, a oppo

to oma coitio which a cay, iit, a uiva. Thu to

pp r p w B m

m , , t w x m

ou it o a a pct, -cotai ph (Kikaa 1983:

68). B em w , pp b

w m mm p B.B Kk h b r

w .1 i p b

m , Kk h

-utai coit i a pu cocpt that abtact om ou it

. W p w

jut aoth tity; o itac, wh w ouv biooicay a

bip o thi with two (a i w a o it om quaup

xp mb ). B w

b x w Kk

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

4/18

63



Hi act aait th tm mtaphyic. Th att i mak

about th otu o Bi o th mtaphyica (o oto-thooica)

, mp:

[B]ock ou acc to tho pimoia ouc omw p w

hav b i pat quit uiy aw. I it mak

, mk

pp bk

omthi which w ot v uta. (Hi

1962: 43)

W m -xm x bj. i

p p m k , b b b bw r x, Kk h

ou ou kow o th vy it a tmpoa coitio which w

ouv a. Kikaa a Hi Dasein mk

p

kow (vaiity o kow) to which w mut ook, but th ma

i which w a uiqu iiviua a i a v ito a activity

uch a a qut o kow. Hc thy icopoat i thi puuit

kw pp , w

B. i w m pp pp,

Kikaa a Hi cov i a umb o i momt

w b p x. i

cotxt that I wih to aay a tack th oowi qutio: (i) How i

Dasein, b h, m m

Kikaa?; a (ii) doDasein b p B-

i-th-wo btt tha Kikaa , a Hi tipuat i th

Being and Time (ibi.: 494)? A Kikaa ba th otio

o whi Hi itictivy th chaactii iiviua

Dasein, my aim i thi pap i to bi to th o th cucia ipaity

m b h w Dasein m

Kikaa i pit o thi imiaiti.

I. Self and Dasein

Existence mk p m pp w

w pm p w

kw. i p p kw,

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

5/18


64

m p; Kk p , f p

kw xp situation kw bj in existence

(Kikaa 1968: 75; mphai a). By hiti th ocu away om

r kw w x, Kk, wm

Hi oow, att to ou ituatio which i it a tmpoa.

i The Sickness unto Death, Kikaa (Selv)

a atio which at to it (Kikaa 2004: 43). sic thi

m b, w b p w Kk

itiuih om huma bi. Accoi to Kikaa, huma

bi i a ythi which i a atio btw two [acto]2 (ibi.),

o atativy it i a th atio o two acto which h ca

ythi. O ca h coi th ic i th way Kikaa

m b .A relation between two factors(huma bi) i ot yt a relation which relates to itself(); Kikaa

thu ut om thi that a huma bi i ot yt a (ibi.). Thi

may ou quit cout-ituitiv a mot o u who a huma bi

ao coi ouv a , but hi poit i that a huma bi quai

. hm b

by pych a boy (Kikaa 1980: 85), but i mak by th

thi acto which Kikaa ca piit. I thi way, a poitiv atio

w b , p; ,

w w , to that atio (Kikaa 2004: 43) ith ack o ha vy itt

b m b p.

Kk b The Concept of Anxiety : i

iocc, ma [i.. huma bi] i ot quai a piit but i pychicay

quai i immiat uity with hi atua coitio. Th piit i ma

i ami (Kikaa 1980: 41). W ca thu that Kikaa

o ot quaiy a huma bi who piit uit ativy i iocc

. sp Kk x w mpw

mk w huma bi i a by it o ctio, a Kikaa wit:

Th bi h om o ctio, th i ao

om o h pai to o . With thi ctai

o ctio bi that act o paatio i which

bm w

m m x w

ct upo it. (Kikaa 2004: 85)

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

6/18

65



I thi ma, Kikaa i povii a itio a citia o

existential w m x w m

bi quai a a . To b a uy xiti iiviua i to mak ou ow

x bj k m p . l

p h p x.

i Being and Time, Hi it to ai th qutio o th

mai o Bi (Sein) w - w

ai to coi. Ita o ai i a thotica iquiy, otooy

ha away vov ito th otic aayi o bi (Seinden) w

m ,

, B. o ,

B self-evidentb w m w

B p-p; , B obscureb w k p .

Accoi to Hi, Bi i that which tmi titi a

, b w []

Th Bi o titi i ot it a tity (Hi 1962: 25-26). H

wit wh that W a ab to ap bi [(i.. titi)] a uch,

b, w m k [Being] (Hi 1982:

10).

It i Hi iuity v i aki thi qutio ai th

m B, w m be, bcau a h i i th t, B p w w k b m

that it i uiva a iab. Hi coi that i thi vy

qutio, what i impi a puppo i th tity that ca ai uch

a qutio. That i to ay, th vy qutio va omthi mo tha

th qutio it, amy th iqui. H tho mak th oowi

m:

Thu to wok out th qutio o Bi aquaty, w

mut mak a tityth iquitapat i hi owBi. Th vy aki o thi qutio i a tity mo

Being; m

what i iqui aboutamy, Bi. (Hi 1962:

27)

Thi uiqu tity which ai th qutio o Bi i ot a chai,

k, ; mk B

h Dasein.Dasein

w j m . r b , B, B

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

7/18


66

issue o it (ibi.: 32). Th Bi o a chai i ot a caot b a

. Dasein i a th tity who mo o Bi

p B ; B b

a iu o it.3 Thi -tiaity o th , which Kikaa

p, b existence (Existenz) h,

P commt: To hav a atiohip to Bi ma (accoi to

Kk) x, b m b x. h

ca th Bi o c oDasein xitc (P 1987: 35).

a The essence of Dasein lies in its existence (Hi 1962: 67),

what aow o a mak poib that uiqu atu whichDasein ,

- , x. a , h

t k B w wDasein mp w

, w mp mw, w existence(ibi.: 32). Thi ma that Dasein mp x,

Dasein w m x

(ibi.: 33). A th abov quot hav tipuat, Bi i puppo i

w . B w mk

w w, w mp Dasein

m x, B m w bDasein. f

wDasein w b b w is m

w is not.4 To bi to iht ou it coitio o Bi-i-th-wo

(In-der-Welt-Sein), h Dasein w existentialaaytic.

II. Finitude and Temporality

What itiuih th two thik i thi ptatio ito ou it a

tmpoa coitio, a Kikaa wit, Tmpoaity, itu that

i what it i a about (Kikaa 1983: 49). Whi th oma taitio,

xmpi by thik ik dcat a Kat, ma umou ot to

p , m m pp k

commo quaiti amot a huma bi. dpit havi catoi u

fnite ubtac, dcat i ot uta itu i th pimoia

. sic hi appoach mai iit, hi jumt that w afnite

b mp w infnitely a it ubtac.

lkw, w K mp p b , w

a i a ctai it, hi ppctiv ti mai iit wh h

. s p xp

ou baic tat o itu bcau ki a commo otic chaact ia tak o th iit a o ot accout o ou ituatioa chaact.

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

8/18

67



f w b b ,

,

th i omthi uiqu to ach o u, uch uiqu o ot matt

w m . W m p

ao ook to iiviua who it chaactitic i iat by

piit a xitc. Thi i why Hi aayi o ou vyay

m w m pp b

, b w B---

w. h k w w w w

m x. fmm m m m

w w w

p mk in existence. dm

without accouti o ou xitc i to ta ou it bouay.Ou c i t a omot i xitc a thu i utmi.

i b m x, w

. W m m bj

pp xp b p k.

By i piit, Kikaa ca a o itiuih him om

w p w p

om (ibi.: 7). Hc Kikaa i acti to a citicii tho

w bm . a

p p w w , mbj. sp w b e

bj x bj, w xp

i a hi kow (Kikaa 1968: 75). Hc thi i away

w w m p,

m, w bk. hw, mp

bj bj, Kk w mm m

m m, w w

ubjctivity cotitut th aity (a iaity) o th wo (Hu 1970:

95-100; Kat 1968: 72, 77-78, 130, 153). O th cotay, what i impotato Kikaa i to ackow ou it coitio o th o whom

ach a vy momt i a uiqu ituatio. To ubum thi apct o

bj m m

pbm, w x -bj

m . t p w Kk m px

(Kikaa 1983: 62).

a m , x mp m

w a a it ubtac which ubit thouh tim with a ctai t

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

9/18


68

o quaiti a th taitio ha aum. A phiooph ik dcat

K p, p m w

. W w

actuaity, itity, a ubtatiaity. Caputo aayi o Kikaa

p . Kk mp

w x nous k p

eidos (Caputo 1987: 32). Wh th phiooph t it wo i th

ia that actuaity (pc) i a th i. Jut ik o o ca

a mau who I am without t ackowi th that i away

pk , x m i m mp

m p k res cogitans res extensa. W w x

b b xp b m

w w k, w, . W involved xitc; that i to ay, v th uamta qutio which coc

otooica chaactitic ik who am I a what o it ma to xit

m b p Dasein. i w,

b m bm w . t w

w b - x

o ctio it iat. emphaii th iicac o poa

bj p, Kk w:

[a] m

v, o cic ca ay what th i without aai

tati it quit ay. A thi i th wo o i, that

m w m m kw w

kow, ic h kow who him i [] (Kikaa

1980: 78-79)

i w w w b mk

bj . e -

iiviua t a o o who o i. Thi coctio btw

x bj m xp b Kk

w: i k k

a xiti iiviua (Kikaa 1968: 314). spiit a xitc mak

ou it coitio a w a th -tia uctio. I th itu o

x, w . f bj bm

oca poit. sic w o ot a caot uy attai th iit ppctiv

thouh which w ca obtai compt kow, ou it ppctiv

b b bj mp. i j bj

p, w m m kw m ou it coitio.

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

10/18

69



i x w Dasein,

m w mpm .

fm, - mk w

w w. W w

b w w. ex pj

p w pp b , h ,

ex, , w m p b , b,

tpp byo (Hi 1982: 300). s oDasein -

w . W B Dasein

, w B. t h

w p Dasein: o b w m

[B] Dasein , w

i pciy what tiay chaacti it [Bi] (ibi.: 299). A atact tity, howv, th mai th qutio o how w a to

p B. h w: i b

who o vyayDasein j notth I my (Hi 1962: 150).

B x w w ,Dasein it

iuc a hap by th objct a othDasein

w. i ,Dasein w

. a cp p i pp, bm

away tti ubvt by bi (Caputo 1987: 13).

Pp m p,w b m x b mm

bm. i , m x mm

bw pb pp m, b

btw city a poibiity. I oth wo, w a ot at t pt

b , w b pb

. Kk j

m pb ; , bm

. t x , ; x

mut bcom it, it i a poibiity. (Kikaa 1989: 65-66). To at w ;

m B m w xb

m. a w x, Dasein -

o-it (Sichvorweg) m w b m

(Hi 1962: 279-280). somthi away mai itmiat i

Dasein a ot yt. fo Kikaa a Hi, ou mo o Bi

m b mp pm

pb m mp m . a,

w m -p m mp.5

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

11/18


70

Kikaa ihty pak o ptitio a a owa movmt i

gk w b , w bkw

mm.6 Kk p w w.

i - p x mk w

o pojcti ouv towa a poibiity. I Hi wo, ach

Dasein Being towards a possibility (Sein zu einer Mglichkeit) (ibi.:

305). Caputo at that Th actuaity i tact to th poibiity,

ot tmi, co, pcotai by it (Caputo 1987: 20). Th

qutio ti mai: how ca w btt uta ouv i w a

p p p b w ? i -

b b w w xp ?

a B-w--pb,Daseinexists w pb

pj w . iDasein b m pj w w . a m m,

bDasein x -x

. W bm mp p wDasein

mpb pj . h

pb Dasein p x. t

w w pj w pb

i what Hi ca ath (Tod). J Kk h

p Dasein x w mp

, m pb p w . o x . h pj Dasein

w pb mpb x

a (Hi 1962: 307). Thu accoi to Hi, ath hou ot

b m w m m p

, b Dasein about iabiity to pojct it poibiity.

Dasein mo o Bi i uch that th impoibiity to pojct it poibiity

pb Dasein. a , mp w mp

Dasein w b. o ,

b Dasein pb, b xpBeing-towards-death (Sein zum Tode) (ibi.: 294).7 It i by aticipati

w b p pb Dasein

. s Dasein m

, m b p . i p

b w pp p m

with, Kikaa a Hi hav cti th ocu i th way

w w w w w

B---w.

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

12/18

71



Conclusion: Dasein over Self

W Kk h m p m,

p p. t b Kk w h mk Being and

Time: Kk xp z p pbm x

existentiellpbm [] B existentialpbm w

to him (ibi.: 494; mphai a). Accoi to Hi, thouh

Kk w pbm x,

i co to th existentiellp. a existentiell to a ki o

w p Dasein (otica), wha

existentiale i a ki which ptai to a coc th vy Bi o

Dasein (otooica). I coii th existentialp mk , h Kk b

accout i imit a co to th pci taitio.

W mp Kk B

w pbm x p. i w,

p w B p p w w

pb, m pm w pw w

ha tabih th who atio [o th ] (Kikaa 2004: 43). I

axity o Kikaa ay mat om actuaity a th poibiity

o poibiity, (Kikaa 1980: 42) a h caim, th h caot pak pw w b w m w

b w pb pb.

Th o ctio o which Kikaa pak wi tho o it

b w w m b b

pow which ha tabih ou ow -tia chaact (go).8 fo

Kikaa, th i uamtay th thooica (Kikaa

2004: 111). h b

mai i quiibium a t, but oy, i ati to it, by ati

to that which ha tabih th who atio (ibi.: 44). To b ai,

Kk m w existential

aayi o wh h itiuih axity om a (Kikaa

1980: 42), a Hi imiay o (Hi 1962: 391-394)9, but

w. t pw w b

w w Dasein B--

-w b a m w, Dasein b w into

existence. i x w b b

(ibi.: 321). ra o who thw u ito xitc, w a pimoiaywho w caiy a (acticity) a who w pojct to b (poibiity).

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

13/18


72

t w h m m Kk w

utt: ma ubtac i otspirit as a synthesis of soul and body;

existence (ibi.: 153; mphai a).10 Hi cociouy

w bw p x. W pp

to uctio i th am ma a Hi otio o xitc tu

. t w b w

Kk p w w b p w .

Uik Hi, Kikaa i th ot o i that i ia.

H cay itpt a au that th i a quaitativ uity o th

w b pw w b . o

, Kk m ppp

, . i -

tmi hi amou ph o xitc by which h itiuih x: , , .

Howv, i itiuihi th thooica (iit) om th huma

(it), th iiou ph i pciy a th atio i

w m pw w b

. h, Kk p Fear and Trembling, b w

p pw w b . t

o ctio bak ow wh th o o tabih a it

atio to o thouh o, but ita th i bo go a

tabih a iit atio to go a th about (Kikaa 2004:109; Kikaa 1983: 70). I uch a ma, Kikaa cocty

p w b b . a d p

it, Kikaa oy iv o coht way to t th acto toth

(dyu 1991: 300).

Icoitcy thu ai wh th qutio i what i th bt i to

iv i a to which th aw may b it i to o X, Y, a Z, bcau

m existentialqutio wha th th att i a existentiell

outio.11 Thu v i X, Y, a Z o hp m attai th bt poib

i (existentiell), that ot taat ito vyo wi hav th btpoib i with X, Y, a Z (existential). y

p w Kk b

existentialp pbm x m

mp m b h b pp h w

it (Hi 1962: 494). P iv th oowi mak o thi

p:

Kikaa [o] mo a otica tha a otooica

ituctio; [h] aw ciiv matt i a otica ma,

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

14/18

73



but [h] wou ot hav b ab to aiv at a aquat

otooica cocptuaizatio. [H] tho [i] a

th mo compiy, wh [h pak] with th at

o cocptuaizatio. (P 1987: 31)

i ontical-existentiell

pb w m ,

Kk w p w pw

b . B b bj ,

Kk p j w B pj

w pb w m

pbm x x pw. i

w, m m

pb pj Kk; mp m

to coot a act i th ac th ythi (wo) a bo go. Thi

p w Kk mp b p

mmm, b j b

b .

a, m Kk p

b w w mk

pb. Kk mk

bwDasein m poibiity o maki ciio (existentiell)

Dasein poibiity o maki ciio (existentiale).12

a , Kk existential

w B x. h

existentiell w xp

w p ppp. Kk

w m . t w

bm , b w w w

ci a act i ac o th wo.13 I oth wo, hi coc i

, , p .t w b h

i ca. fo o thi, uch a otooy m to poit a iit ppctiv

b jm, w mp

. M mp, w, w w w

bDasein bb B-w Dasein

Bi-i amot titi. I Hi avoi Kikaa o by

mk bw existentiell existential, b p

x m w. h w:

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

15/18


74

Dasein w m x

m pb : b .

Dasein pb ,

m, w p m . o

pDasein x, w

by taki ho o by cti. Th qutio o xitc

xp x .

(Hi 1962: 33)

t w h, -w bDasein

b, w m

uciatio. Hi mpoy th tm ca (Sorge) a mi

(Jemeinigkeit). Th ooim captu ou poa a cai aity

w w . B Dasein w b mineness,

b , h mk: a m

B, authenticity inauthenticity [] b

Dasein whatov i chaacti by mi (ibi.: 68). Th

m Dasein Bi caot b tmi a tabih ay

p x, b p x Dasein

B bm Dasein.

W h pk Dasein abiity to mak ciio towa

w pb, j m w mp

pb b b

pb pb . t

pb x h.

fm, m p pb Dasein

w w w to be. h

t wm B b

o (ibi.: 171). What i impi th i a ot o cai (Lichtung)

ico (Erschlossenheit) w m

p Dasein i it xitc (ibi.). Jut a Kikaa wtbyo th mtaphyicay-co otio o ubjctivity a aiv at

hi piitua , Hi ovcom v Kikaa piitua

b b p Dasein ca by ou it way o

B---w.

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

16/18

75



References

Caputo, J. d. (1987).Radical Hermeneutics. Bm: i uP.

dcat, r. (1985). The Philosophical Writings of Descartes: Volume1. (J. Cottiham, r. stootho, & d. Muoch, Ta.). Cambi:

cmb uP.

(1986). Meditations on First Philosophy. (J. Cottiham, Ta.).

cmb: cmb uP.

dyu, H. l. (1991).Being-in-the-World. cmb: Mit.

eo, J. W. (1973). Th s i Kikaa Puoym.International

Journal for Philosophy of Religion, 4(4), 218-240.

guio, C. B., (e.). (1993). The Cambridge Companion to Heidegger.

cmb: cmb uP.Hi, M. (1962). Being and Time. (J. Macquai & e. robio,

t.) s f: hp.

(1982). The Basic Problems of Phenomenology. (A. Hotat, Ta.).

Bm: i uP.

(2000).Introduction to Metaphysics. (g. fi & r. Pot, Ta.). nw

h: y uP.

Hu, e. (1970). Crisis of the European Sciences and Transcendental

Phenomenology. (d. Ca, Ta.). evato: nothwt UP.

Kat, I. (1968). Critique of Pure Reason. (n. K. smith, Ta.). loo:st Mati.

Kikaa, s. (1968). Concluding Unscientifc Postscript. (d. f. swo,

t.). P: P uP.

(1980). The Concept of Anxiety. (r. Thomt, Ta. & e.). Picto:

P uP.

(1983).Fear and Trembling/Repetition : Kierkegaards Writings, Vol. 6.

(H. V. Ho & e. H. Ho, Ta. & e.). Picto: Picto UP.

(2004). The Sickness unto Death. (A. Haay, Ta.). loo:

P.

Moa, d. (2000).Introduction to Phenomenology. l: r.

P, O. (1987). Martin Heideggers Path of Thinking. a

h: hm P i.

Wtpha, M. (1996).Becoming a Self. W l, in: P uP.

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

17/18


76

(Endnotes)

1 d f p mm w

w, mk theoreticalappoach a uch (guio 1993:

58).

2 Jut a Aatai Haay mpoy acto ita o tm i hiIntroduction

The Sickness unto Death, i b b m.

3 Uik Kikaa, Hi i coc with th ca o pci ca

huma bi. Th att i ita xamii th existential

which o actuay copo to what w huma bi uiquy hav, but

ay tity that ha th chaactitic tchicay quai o a t what

Dasein. I o ot ma to impy h that Kikaa mpoy th

xpio huma bi i th biooica , but my poit i impy that

th appoach tak by Kikaa a Hi a quit itict. It i caom Kikaa witi that h i oy taki about huma bi. H

thu av o oom o aowi o-huma bi to b quai o what

h ca huma bi a o whth thy atiy th coitio o ot.

t h.

4 h mk K p

pb mp ,

b pm b . t

btw bi a Bi Hi ca th otooica ic (die

ontologische Differenz) (Hi 1982: 17, 319). Thi otooica ic

b B that which makes beings possible. t w B

b w b. f

ut thi wh h wit that Th [Hi] aayi i tacta

K mk pb

u to cout whatv w o cout i th way w mak o th

phoma (guio 1993: 56). But o Hi, th tacta

p bj ; , m b

existential-ctatic tmpoaity o Bi-h (Hi 2000: 20).

5 c mp, M Wp b

Kk h p mp z x. h w bkBecoming a Self,

o Kk, h, d K

wm pb mp , mp z

o th itu o a huma xpic (Wtpha 1996: 18).

6 Kk m h mm

k m B. h bk

pm m w p

pp p. h pp k b

ma o a phomooica tuctio (Destruktion) (Hi 1982: 23).

i b pbm h b p m

7/28/2019 TBen Yagi

18/18

77



w p w , w , m

b pm. h k, xmp, gk m

cot to utai Bi (Hi 2000: 120-122) a thu ut

xp w b

gk. a m h, , b mk bkwmm , m Dasein

i poiti th phomo that i oiia.

7 It i woth oti that Hi coitio o ath wa iuc

by Kikaa, a Moa wit, Iuc by Kikaa, Hi

coi th ctaity o Bi-towa-ath (Sein-zum-Tode) m

(Moa 2000: 240).

8 I am quit awa that o Kikaa, th at to th pow which ha

tabih it i it ow atio to it (Kikaa 2004: 44, 114, 165).

B pm b pw, m

b The Sickness unto Death, b

. fm, p pw

m Fear and Trembling w Kk

xp p x abm.

9 Thi ao i a iuc Kikaa ha ha o Hi, a Moa iicat:

i , w Kk, h p

(Furcht) om axity (Angst) (Moa 2000: 241).

10 c m p, hb d m p p

a uti that Hi i actuay uppoti Kikaa otio o th

piitua (dyu 1991: 299). fom th cotxt, howv, I biv it i h xp m w Kk b

m. t w b p, p w

iicat: But i th s i cociv oy a a way o Bi o thi tity,

thi m tatamout to voatiizi th a co oDasein (Hi

1962: 153).

11 i mp existentiale m pm

th xitti. Thi ai th iu o whth it i iiviua atio to hi

w m pm, pb w B

w w b p . i m ,

Kikaa accout wi caim it pimacy. I ca o th att, Hi

existential pm. f x, i k

existential p

i bb w m

pm.

12 i pk , Kk m pp h

Dasein g, i b m .

13 Joh W. eo mak th oowi mak ai thi poit: ethic a

otooy a ixticaby ik i Kikaa thouht, a w ca tho

pk - k pbm m x(eo 1973: 223).

Documents

TBen Yagi