Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Taking the Next Step Team Sauder
Jarl Greve | Nadine Raida | Morten Juhl | Sebastian Kersting
By expanding distribution and initiate production in India Nord-
Lock can gain 1.5 BSEK by 2019
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 2 CBS |
Introducing 2 main initiatives… … will bring you 1.5 BSEK in revenue by 2019
Expand
Distribution in Japan
Initiate
Production in India 694
321
168
318
1501
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
2015 Status quo Korea Japan Total2015 Europe/
America Korea Japan 2019
mSE
K
Re
venue
Nord-Lock has a wide global presence but has mainly focused
on the European region
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 3
Source: Company Material
CBS |
Sales office
Production Plant
Warehouse
… as a result main revenue comes from Europe
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 4
70% 16% 14%
Source: Company Material
CBS |
Competition, limited capacity and decreasing growth in key
markets constitute challenges for Nord-Lock
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 5
Ch
alle
ng
es
Competition
Nord-Lock are facing both internal and external challenges
Capacity Slow Growth
70% utilization 2-3% in mature markets Growing rapidly
Revenue growth has decreased to 10% and limited options for expansion
Source: Company Material
CBS |
… but global opportunities and growth in Asia open up for
Nord-Lock to regain growth
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 6
Op
po
rtu
nit
ies
Low cost production
… but also several opportunities
Global Growth in Asia
Global presence,
regional focus 5-7% in high-end markets In Asia and E. Europe
How can Nord-Lock utilize its capabilities and regain high growth?
Source: Company Material
CBS |
Several options have been explored
7
HIG
H
LOW HIGH
Imp
act
Feasibility
LO
W
IMPACT
Feasibility
Size
Price Sensivity
Growth
Profitability
Organizational fit
Risk
Competition
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
New premium product
Low cost products
B2C segment
Market expansion
CBS |
… but based on feasibility and impact a market expansion is
found to be the best solution
8
HIG
H
LOW HIGH
Imp
act
Feasibility
LO
W
IMPACT
Feasibility
Size
Price Sensivity
Growth
Profitability
Organizational fit
Risk
Competition
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
New premium product
Low cost products
B2C segment
Market expansion
CBS |
Of the countries Nord-lock is active within the Asian
economies have most market potential and growth
9
HIG
H
LOW HIGH
MA
RK
ET
GR
OW
TH
MARKET POTENTIAL
LO
W
PRIORITIZE
MAINTAIN
MARKET POTENTIAL
Profitability
Organisational fit
Current market share
Market size
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Scandi
EU rest
Korea
Japan
China
US/ Ca
DE
CBS |
Due to favorable industries Japan and South Korea should be
the focus for Nord-Lock
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 10
China
9% growth
Automotive, Agriculture
Only present through 3rd party
Japan
5% growth
Transportation, Offshore
Existing sales office
South Korea
7% growth
Transportation, Offshore
Excessive distribution
Source: Company Material
CBS |
Of the countries Nord-lock is active within the Asian
economies have most market potential and growth
11
HIG
H
LOW HIGH
MA
RK
ET
GR
OW
TH
MARKET POTENTIAL
LO
W
PRIORITIZE
MAINTAIN
MARKET POTENTIAL
Profitability
Organisational fit
Current market share
Market size
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Scandi
EU rest
Korea
Japan
China
US/ Ca
DE
CBS |
…and local competitors in Japan and South Korea do not
threaten Nord-Locks position in the market
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 12
Pri
ce
Safety
High Low
Lo
w
Hig
h
Premium Position
High Purchase Price
Long life cycle
Source: Market Line
CBS |
13
Expand Distribution in Japan
CBS |
Nord-lock’s entry strategy must take capabilities, level of
protection and ability to control into account
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 14
Parameter Acquisition Joint Venture Licensing Greenfield
Local
knowledge
NL Capabilities
Protection of
knowhow
Control
CBS |
Nord-lock’s entry strategy must take capabilities, level of
protection and ability to control into account
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 15
Parameter Acquisition Joint Venture Licensing Greenfield
Local
knowledge
NL Capabilities
Protection of
knowhow
Control
CBS |
16
The 4 main Japanese distributers in this segment are all
possible targets
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Financial impact
Company fit
JTEKT
Broad targets
Sanko Techno Co
Mature companies Large targets
Kobayashi Metals
Techno Associe Co
Ease of implementation
CBS |
17
The 4 main Japanese distributers in this segment are all
possible targets
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Financial impact
Company fit
Loyalty Program
Acquire Arriva
Customer Journey Real time
data
Collaborations
Experience
Low er prices
Ease of implementation
1
2
3
4
5
Advantages
Disadvantages
Similarity of
products
Warehouse
facilities
Non-core business
units
High P/E Financial impact
Company fit
Broad targets
Mature companies Large targets
Kobayashi Metals
Ease of implementation
CBS |
Kobayashi’s valuation is based on traded peers and previous
transactions in the industry
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 18
Comparable
peers
Previous
transactions
Kobayashi Metals
Value
EV/EBITDA
EV/EBIT
EV/EBITDA
Implied value 410 million SEK
Avg. Premium
Source: Thomsen Reuter, Bloomberg, Morningstar, Company websites
CBS |
19
Nord-lock must integrate Kobayashi with existing Japanese
offices to achieve synergies within revenue and cost
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Kobayashi Metals
Current Nord-lock sales office Japan
Distribution Warehousing Sales
Secure revenue streams
Process optimization
Cost reduction
Restructure management
Integrate IT systems
Important synergies Key Decisions
CBS |
20
After acquiring Kobayashi Nord-lock should focus on 3 key
areas to ensure successful post-merger integration
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Lock-in
Focus KPI
Employee
satisfaction
Supplier relations
Customer
attrition
Employee
turnover rate
Customer churn
rate
Long term
contracts
CBS |
21
Expand Distribution in Japan
CBS |
22 CBS |
Expand Distribution in Japan
Due to limited capacity expansion of production facilities is needed
23
Based on monetary and human factors the different options
have been explored
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Sweden Eastern
Europe China Japan/Korea India
Investment
Skilled labor
Labor costs
ROI
Risk
Small Large
CBS |
Source: Dezan Shira & Associates
24
India is the best option due to low cost production while still
maintaining a high skill level
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Sweden Eastern
Europe China Japan/Korea India
Investment
Skilled labor
Labor costs
ROI
Risk
Small Large
CBS |
Source: Dezan Shira & Associates
25
IP protection and control are main factors in favor of choosing
WFOE
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Parameter WFOE JV Licensing
IP protection
Quality control
Control
CBS |
26
Nord-Lock should invest in production facilities in Mumbai
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Highly educated and skilled labor force
Two major ports, extensive road network as well as railways
Leading research centers and institutions in energy and offshore
Fair average salary level
Kamathipura – bolt industry manufacturing area
GDP growth of 7.6% in 2015
1
2
3
4
5
6
CBS |
Source: Dezan Shira & Associates
27
Setting up production facilities in Mumbai requires people,
sourcing and an assessment of capacity
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Mumbai People Capacity Sourcing
CBS |
28
In order to set up facility in India people and strong
organizational structure is key
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Research planning
Evaluation of research
Testing
5 people
Customer survey
Cost performance
Supplier performance
5 people
Machinery
Maintenance
Lean
7 people
Production
Equipment
Production planning
22 people
Statistical control
Failure testing
Quality management
5 people
1 executive 5 managers 44 employees
CBS |
Sourcing
29
By initiating production to India Nord-Lock can increase
capacity and utilize local sourcing
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY
Capacity
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
India
Sweden
Transfer of volumes Local sourcing for production
CBS |
Production
Warehouse
Source: Company material, Latour
30
Expand Distribution in Japan
Initiate Production in India
CBS |
Entering into Korea and Japan will give Nord-lock a foothold
in Asia and an option to expand
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 31
Vis
ion
Time
Gaining a foothold in Asia will give
future opportunities for Nord-lock Expand market position in China
Enter into the Indian market
Move entire production to LCC
1
3
2
CBS |
Nord-lock can increase revenue to 1.5 BSEK in 2019
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 32
Assumptions: 12% market share in both
Japan and Korea
Assumptions: 10% & 7% market share in
Korea and Japan, respectively
15% 5-7% 30%
Market
Share
Market
growth
EBIT
margin
Nord-lock can gain more than 300m SEK in
additional revenue in 2019
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
2016 2017 2018 2019
Worst
Base
Best
Worst
CBS |
This suggestion will give Nord-lock not only additional
revenue of up to 485m but sustainable growth markets
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 33
10% growth in status
quo growth
94m in profits in Japan
50m in profits in Korea
Nord-lock can create additional revenue of up to 485m in 2019
694
321
168
318
1501
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
2015 Status quo Korea Japan Total2015 Europe/
America Korea Japan 2019
mSE
K
Re
venue
CBS |
Expanding in Asia involves some important risk factors that
Nord-lock must address beforehand
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 34
Lik
lih
oo
d
Impact
C A
B
High Low
Lo
w
Hig
h Issue
Lack of skilled
labor in Mumbai
Inability to obtain
market share
Loss in home
markets
Mitigation
Implement
quality training
Focus on quality
and branding
Continuous
improvement of
qualty
A
B
C
Issues
CBS |
In order to succeed Nord-Lock must start immediately in
finding land and financial advisory
35
2016 2017 2018
PRODUCTION
FACILITY
ACQUISITION
Must win battles
Acquire distribution chain in
Japan by Q4 2016 1 2 3 Hire skilled labor and managers
for Indian facility by Q1 2018
Acquire land in Kamathipura
for production by Q3 2016
Hire financial advisor
Acquire Kobayashi Metals
Acquire land
Hire employees to manage and work at facility
Build production plant
Post-merger integration
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY CBS |
Currently Nord-Lock has global presence but regional focus
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 36 CBS |
Sales office
Production Plant
Warehouse
Source: Company Material, Company Website
By expanding distribution and production in Asia Nord-Lock
can exploit being a global company
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 37 CBS |
Sales office
Production Plant
Warehouse
Source: Company Material, Company Website
By expanding distribution and initiate production in India Nord-
Lock can gain 1.5 BSEK
EXECUTIVE INSIGHTS SOLUTION IMPACT SUMMARY 38
Introducing 2 main initiatives… … will bring you 1.5 BSEK in revenue by 2019
Expand
Distribution in Japan
Initiate
Production in India 694
321
168
318
1501
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
2015 Status quo Korea Japan Total2015 Europe/
America Korea Japan 2019
mSE
K
Re
venue
CBS |
Questions and Answers Team Suader
Jarl Greve | Nadine Raida | Morten Juhl | Sebastian Kersting
Insights Solution Impact Appendix
2: Executive Summary
3: Worldwide presence
4: Revenue from
geographies
5: Challenges
6: Opportunities
7: Options
8: Chosen option
9: Ranking of countries
10: China, Japan, South
Korea
12: Positioning
15: Entry strategy
17: Choosing Japanese
distributor
18: Kobayashi’s valuation
19: Integrate with existing
offices
20: Post-merger
integration
24: Ranking of countries
for production
25: WFOE, JV or
licensing?
26: Invest in Mumbai
27: What is required in
Mumbai?
28: People needed
29: Capacity and sourcing
31: Foothold in Asia
32: Revenue increase
33: Sustainable growth
markets
34: Risks
35: Implementation
36: Europe focus
37: Enhanced focus
38: Synthesis
41: Key markets
42: Evaluation of Indian
cities
43: Pros and cons of
WHOE, JV and licensing
44: Capacity calculations
45: Risk analysis
46: Geographical
assessment of potential
expansion
47: Distribution companies
in Japan
48: Valuation of
acquisition target
49: Leverage ratio
50: Revenue projections
51: Sensitivity analysis (1)
52: Sensitivity analysis (2)
Key Markets
APPENDIX 41
47% 16% 12%
Germany USA Scandinavia
% of revenue
CBS |
Evaluation of Indian Cities
APPENDIX 42
Mumbai Delhi Bangalore Kolkata
Education
Infrastructure
Leading research
centers
Costs
Economic
Location
CBS |
Pros and cons of investment structures
APPENDIX 43
Structure type Pros Cons
Licensing • Cost effective route to getting a product to
market
• It is a low risk to break into a set market
• Lose control of own product
• Many products do not get licensed
Joint Venture
• Entering industries that by law require a local
partner
• Leveraging a partner’s existing facilities,
workforce, sales/distribution channels
• Split profits
• Less management control than a WFOE
• Technology transfer/IP risks
Wholly Foreign-owned
Enterprise • Greater freedom in business activities
• 100% ownership and management control
• Registered capital requirement
• Lengthy establishment process
CBS |
Capacity Calculations
APPENDIX 44
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
Sweden
Asia % 100% 100% 80% 30% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Europe and North America % 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Asia 103 183 271 138 0 0 0 0 0 0
Europe and North America 694 763 839 923 1015 1066 1120 1176 1234 1296
Total 797 946 1110 1061 1015 1066 1120 1176 1234 1296
% 100% 100% 94% 77% 68% 65% 62% 58% 55% 52%
India
Asia % 0% 0% 20% 70% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
Europe and North America % 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
Asia 0 0 68 321 485 582 699 839 1006 1208
Europe and North America 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Total 0 0 68 321 485 582 699 839 1006 1208
% 0% 0% 6% 23% 32% 35% 38% 42% 45% 48%
Total
Asia 103 183 338 459 485 582 699 839 1006 1208
Europe and North America 694 763 839 923 1015 1066 1120 1176 1234 1296
Total 797 946 1178 1382 1501 1649 1818 2014 2241 2504
Asia % 13% 19% 29% 33% 32% 35% 38% 42% 45% 48%
Europe and North America % 87% 81% 71% 67% 68% 65% 62% 58% 55% 52%
Total 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%
CBS |
Risk analysis
45
Risk
Likelihood
Impact
Strategic importance
Mitigation
Lack of skilled labor in Mumbai
3 5 15 Implement quality training to ensure understanding and awareness of the product.
Inability to obtain market share in Korea and Japan
2 4 8 Focus on understanding customer needs and continually focus on branding NL to high-end
and niche segments
Resistance from owner – Latour Holding Company
1 8 8 Focus on aligning interests and suggest raising debt to lower cost of capital
Loss of revenue in home markets
1 6 6 Maintain high level of product knowledge and differentiation and focus on developing client relationships
Resistance from domestic production facilities
3 1 3 Communicate the internationalization strategy to employees and understand key stakeholder motives
Appendix
Source: Team Sauder analysis
CBS |
Geographical assessment of potential expansion
APPENDIX 46
Country Market Value Share of overall
revenue Growth Market share Customer suitability
Germany 350 47% 7% 14% 2
US/Canada 122 16% 3% 3% 3
Den, Sve and Nor 58 8% 4% 29% 2
Japan 52 7% 5% 3% 3
Korea 51 7% 7% 6% 3
Finland 26 4% 4% 69% 3
Italy 15 2% 3% 4% 1
Spain 14 2% 2% 3% 0
France 14 2% 4% 6% 1
Benelux 14 2% 2% 7% 2
China 13 2% 9% 1% 0
UK 13 2% 3% 3% 1
CBS |
Distribution companies Japan
APPENDIX 47
mJPY Main area Products Suggested investment No. Stores in Japan Market cap.
Kobayashi Metals Distribution Screws Acquisition 8 5461
Sanko Techno Co Develop/manufacturing Anchors Joint venture - 7206
Techno Associe Co Distribution Broad Only fastener product division - 20457
JTEKT Automotive Automotive/Machinery/bearings
Joint venture 3 543766
Source Company website, reports, morningstar and bloomberg
CBS |
Valuation of acquisition target
APPENDIX 48
Multiples EV/EBITDA EV/EBIT
Kobayashi 6,3x 13,7x
Sanko Techno Co 4,0x 4,8x
Techno Associe Co 5,5x 8,6x
JTEKT 4,3x 7,3x
Max 6,3x 13,7x
Mean 5,0x 8,6x
Median 4,9x 8,0x
Min 4,0x 4,8x
Previous transactions EV/EBITDA Premium
Industrials 9,2x 15,2%
Materials 12,9x 16,1%
Mean 11,05x 15,7%
Source : Thomsen Reuters
mJPY Market cap EBITDA EBIT EV/EBITDA EV/EBIT
Kobayashi Metals 5461 864 399 6.3x 13.7x
Sanko Techno Co 7206 1817 1511 4.0x 4.8x
Techno Associe Co 20457 3742 2370 5.5x 8.6x
JTEKT 543766 126632 74155 4.3x 7.3x
Source: Company website, reports, morningstar and bloomberg
CBS |
Cost and Capital for Investment
APPENDIX 49
Latour Holding
Debt 5195
Equity 16080
D/E 32%
Leverage ratio 24%
CBS |
-800
-700
-600
-500
-400
-300
-200
-100
0
2016 2017 2018 2019
Cost of investment 2016 2017 2018 2019
Acquisition 410 50
Production facility 300 200 100 50
Post merger integration 20 20
People 10 10 10
Total 710 260 130 80
Revenue Projections
APPENDIX 50
Base case
mSEK 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Turnover 797 877 964 1061 1167
Status Quo Japan/Korea 103 114 125 138 151
Turnover from Europe/North America 694 763 839 923 1015
Post Turnover 797 946 1071 1250 1404
Operating profit 236 280 317 370 416
EBIT margin 30%
Market size Growth: 7% Korea 5% Japan
Korea 852 912 976 1044 1117
Japan 1742 1830 1921 2017 2118
Market share 6/3% 10/5% 10/7% 12/10% 12/12%
Korea 51 91 98 125 134
Japan 52 91 134 202 254
CBS |
Sensitivity analysis
APPENDIX 51
Best case
mSEK 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Turnover 797 877 964 1061 1167
Status Quo Japan/Korea 103 114 125 138 151
Turnover from Europe/North America 694 763 839 923 1015
Post Turnover 797 946 1178 1382 1501
Operating profit 236 280 349 409 444
EBIT margin 30%
Market size Growth: 7% Korea 5% Japan
Korea 852 912 976 1044 1117
Japan 1742 1830 1921 2017 2118
Market share 6/3% 10/5% 15/10% 15/15% 15/15%
Korea 51 91 146 157 168
Japan 52 91 192 303 318
CBS |
Sensitivity analysis
APPENDIX 52
Worst
mSEK 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Turnover 797 877 964 1061 1167
Status Quo Japan/Korea 103 114 125 138 151
Turnover from Europe/North America 694 763 839 923 1015
Post Turnover 797 918 1052 1169 1275
Operating profit 236 272 311 346 378
EBIT margin 30%
Market size Growth: 7% Korea 5% Japan
Korea 852 912 976 1044 1117
Japan 1742 1830 1921 2017 2118
Market share 6/3% 7/5% 8/7% 10/7% 10/7%
Korea 51 64 78 104 112
Japan 52 91 134 141 148
CBS |