48
TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA CAROLYN J HENRY, DVM, MS, DACVIM (ONCOLOGY) UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI COLLEGE OF VETERINARY MEDICINE 1DataConference March 27,2019

TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATACAROLYN J HENRY, DVM, MS, DACVIM (ONCOLOGY)

UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI COLLEGE OF VETERINARY MEDICINE

1DataConference

March 27,2019

Page 2: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 3: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

WHAT CAN COMPANION ANIMAL DATA DO FOR US?

Impact points:

Preventative strategies

Research emphasis

Veterinary curriculum

Market identification

Page 4: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

STRATEGIC DATA MINING

Disease surveillance

Sentinel animals

Machine learning and epidemiology

Outbreak detection and prevention

Page 5: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE

Increased sensitivity

Canary in the coal mine

Shortened life span

Asbestos →Mesothelioma

Asymptomatic exposed

Thai dogs with H5N1 strain of avian flu

Page 6: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

DATA SOURCES

Page 7: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

UNIVERSITY OF WASHINGTON CENTER FOR ONE HEALTH RESEARCH

Page 8: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 9: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 10: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 11: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 12: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 13: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

BANFIELD APPLIED RESEARCH & KNOWLEDGE (BARK)

Data from over 2.5 million dogs and 518,000 cats seen in 2017

State of Pet Health Reports define pet population and disease prevalence

Add in banfield web pic

Page 14: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 15: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 16: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

STRATEGIC DATA MINING

Disease surveillance

Sentinel animals

Machine learning and epidemiology

Outbreak detection and prevention

Breeding programs and genetic discovery

OFA

Page 17: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 18: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 19: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 20: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

STRATEGIC DATA MINING

Disease surveillance

Sentinel animals

Machine learning and epidemiology

Outbreak detection and prevention

Breeding programs and genetic discovery

OFA

Correlates to human disease

Page 21: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

Translational Medicine

21

Cardiomyopathy

Degenerative disc

disease

Lymphoma

Epilepsy

Page 22: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 23: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

18%16%

10%8% 8% 9%

6% 6% 5%

14%

Lymphoma Mast Cell

Tumor

Hemangio-

sarcoma

Osteo-

sarcoma

Mammary Other Soft

Tissue

Sarcoma

Melanoma Oral/Nasal Squamous

Cell

Carcinoma

Other*

Source: Brakke Aug 2002; Burke October 2002; Modiano Lab of the AMC Cancer Research Center; Expert interviews; team analysis

DOG CANCER INCIDENCE

Page 24: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

Translational Medicine

Who is more likely to develop

bone cancer?→

24

Page 25: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

ANNUAL INCIDENCE PER 100,000

65.07.06.0Stomach/Intestines

5.45.07.2Liver and Biliary

1.04.97.9Bone

12.6<1.025.0Melanoma

5.234.790.4Skin (non-melanoma)

HUMANCATDOGTUMORTYPE

Page 26: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

CAUSES OF MORTALITY IN DOGS IN NORTH AMERICA

Breeds with highest proportion of neoplastic disease deaths

Bernese Mountain Dog

Golden Retriever

Scottish Terrier

Bouvier des Flandres

Boxer

Page 27: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

CAUSES OF MORTALITY IN DOGS IN NORTH AMERICA

Breeds with lowest proportion of neoplastic disease deaths

Miniature Pinscher

Miniature Dachshund

Chihuahua

Pekingese

Pomeranian

Page 28: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

REPORTED BREED ASSOCIATIONS WITH CANCER

Golden Retrievers – lymphoma, hemangiosarcoma

Bernese Mtn Dog- malignant histiocytosis; histiocytic sarcoma

Scottish Terriers – bladder cancer

German Shepherd Dogs – hemangiosarcoma; renal cystACa

Greyhounds, Rottweilers, Great Danes – osteosarcoma

Boxers and Pugs – mast cell tumors

Chow Chow – gastric carcinoma

English Springer Spaniel – breast Ca

Page 29: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

GENETIC RESEARCH, TESTING AND BIOREPOSITORIES

Page 30: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 31: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 32: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

STRATEGIC DATA MINING

Disease surveillance

Sentinel animals

Machine learning and epidemiology

Outbreak detection and prevention

Breeding programs and genetic discovery

OFA

Correlates to human disease

Biorepository access

Page 33: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

BIOREPOSITORY ACCESS

Page 34: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

STRATEGIC DATA MINING

Disease surveillance

Sentinel animals

Machine learning and epidemiology

Outbreak detection and prevention

Breeding programs and genetic discovery

OFA

Correlates to human disease

Biorepository access

Clinical trial networks

COHA

COTC - cancer

Regional

Page 35: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 36: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

University of Minnesota

University of California, Davis

Colorado State University

University of Wisconsin

University of Missouri

Auburn University

University of Florida

North Carolina State University

University of Pennsylvania

Cornell University

Tufts University

Ohio State University

Purdue University

Page 37: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

University of Minnesota

University of California, Davis

Colorado State University

University of Wisconsin

University of Missouri

Auburn University

University of Florida

North Carolina State University

University of Pennsylvania

Cornell University

Tufts University

Ohio State University

Purdue University

Page 38: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 39: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 40: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

Translational Medicine

40

The KC Animal Health Corridor represents 56% of the TOTAL

WORLDWIDE animal health, diagnostics and pet food sales.

Page 41: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

MIDWEST CLINICAL TRIALS CENTER

Veterinary School Collaboration

University of Missouri

Kansas State

Oklahoma State

Iowa State

Increased Access to Trials

Trained Coordinator

Screening Patients

Active Sponsor Solicitation

Page 42: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

LIFETIME STUDIES IN DOGS

Page 43: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 44: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

CHALLENGES WITH VETERINARY DATA

Multiple platforms that don’t ‘talk’ to each other

Page 45: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 46: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

CHALLENGES WITH VETERINARY DATA

Multiple platforms that don’t ‘talk’ to each other

Silos

Quality control

Loss to follow-up

Page 47: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed
Page 48: TAKING OWNERSHIP OF OUTCOMES DATA...ANIMAL SENTINELS OF HUMAN DISEASE Increased sensitivity Canary in the coal mine Shortened life span Asbestos →Mesothelioma Asymptomatic exposed

We Can Make a Good Team!