Upload
jack-ryan
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
1/32
7^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 KF ]LO BKPB_K] BA_P] AJ ]LO JKPR] BKPB_K]
0 R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
2 QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ
+= MP& APE[ ]GK]T% ORW&% ++
? ^egkf}kjj% +zr& + Bkzke Fa&
: + 77)7)7827EAPO]]G J_MM[% O] GE% +
8 +Mojofmgf}r& +
< QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ+
;]PGFRBPK^] AJ ^PABOOMKFHR
7>`ojapo }lo LAFAPG@EO PLAFMG FKRLKI_PG% Dumho%
77 ]of}l Mkzkrkaf% ~porkmkfh% af Jpkmg{% Dgfugp{ 72}l% 0>70&
70 IA]KAF POBK^PABGE R_@^AOFG OFJAPBOIOF]!IA]KAF ]A LOGP KFBAFD_FB]KAF XK]L ]LO RBLOM_EOM IA]KAF
72
7= G^^OGPGFBOR4
7? APE[ ]GK]T% Orw& ^pa Ro
7:
78 DKEE FGHGIKFO% Orw&PO@OBBG W_KFF% Orw& Jap Mo~gp}iof} Aj Loge}l
7< Mo~u}kor G}}apfo{ Hofopge
7;
0>
07
00
02 PO^AP]OM @[4
0= IGPK)DA MGZKMRAF% P^P% BRP)22;AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OP
0? R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
2/32
0^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 JPKMG[% DGF_GP[ 72}l% 0>70 LAFAE_E_% LGXGK(K
0 ))aaAaa))
2 ]LO @GKEKJJ4 Bgeekfh bkzke ia}kafr bgeofmgp
= gmm)Af% Bkzke Fa& 77)7)7827% Mp& Ape{ ]gk}t% Orw& z&
? Eapo}}g Jumm{% o} ge% jap ia}kaf pobk~pabge ru`~aofg
: ofjapboiof} ia}kaf jap logpkfh kf bafdufb}kaf xk}l }lo
8 rblomueom ia}kaf af 7!:!0>70& G~~ogpgfbor% ~eogro&
< IR& ]GK]T4 Ape{ ]gk}t% ~egkf}kjj&
; IR& FGHGIKFO4 Haam iapfkfh% [aup Lafap& Dkee
7> Fghgikfo gfm Po`obbg Wukff% Mo~u}kor G}}apfo{ Hofopge
77 po~porof}kfh mojofmgf}r Mo~gp}iof} aj Loge}l&
70 ]LO BA_P]4 Ir& ]gk}t% {au gpo }lo iazgf}%
72 ~paboom xk}l {aup gphuiof}&
7= IR& ]GK]T4 [or& [aup Lafap% kj K ikhl} ho}
7? ~opikrrkaf }a rk}1 K gppkzom lopo g} 774>> gfm }lg}(r
7: xlof }lo jkpr} }kio K jaufm a~~ark}kaf jpai Ir& Fghgikfo%
78 ra K lgm }a g xpk}o i{ po~e{ azopfkhl}& K xkee dur} lgzo
7< }a pogm k} `obguro K mkm fa} lgzo gf{ a~~ap}ufk}{ }a }{~o
7; k} gfm ~porof} k} }a {au `ojapo }lo logpkfh& Ra K(i dur}
0> hakfh }a ~pazkmo i{ po~e{ fax&
07 ]LO BA_P]4 [au bgf gphuo {aup po~e{% gera&
00 IR& ]GK]T4 ]lgfc {au&
02 ]LO BA_P]4 Ha glogm&
0= IR& ]GK]T4 ]lgfc {au% [aup Lafap&
0? ]LO BA_P]4 ^eogro r}gfm&
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
3/32
2^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 IR& ]GK]T4 Acg{& ^egkf}kjj logpkfh%
0 Mp& Ape{ ]gk}t% Orw& kr ~pazkmkfh }lkr po~e{ }a a~~ark}kaf
2 }a ia}kaf }a ))
= ]LO PO^AP]OP4 O|buro io% {au(po pogmkfh&
? ]LO BA_P]4 Gfm {au lgzo }a reax maxf% }aa%
: jap }lo baup} po~ap}op&
8 IR& ]GK]T4 [or& K lgzo rozof ~akf}r gfm kr
< roockfh jkpr} jap }lkr Baup} }a ~pazkmo g pobk~pabge
; ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} aj g zgekm ru`~aofg jpai }lo r}g}o aj
7> Hoaphkg gfm o|}ofm }lo dupkrmkb}kaf aj }lkr ru`~aofg }a
77 Mkpob}ap aj Loge}l Jumm{&
70 ]xa% rgfb}kaf }lo mojofmgf}(r g}}apfo{% Mo~u}{
72 G}}apfo{ Hofopge Fghgikfo jap ikrpo~porof}g}kaf%
7= mojgig}kaf aj ~egkf}kjj% lgpgrriof} aj ~egkf}kjj%
7? g}}oi~}om kf}kikmg}kaf aj ~egkf}kjj% rapp{% kf zkaeg}kaf
7: aj }lo Baeap aj gu}lapk}{ aj bkzke pkhl}r aj }lo ~egkf}kjj
78 gfm lop bekof}r `{ zkp}uo aj a`r}pub}kaf aj dur}kbo% gfm
7< kf}kikmg}kaf aj bkzke pkhl}r aj gf g}}apfo{ roockfh
7; eohk}kig}o pomporr aj hpkozgfbor&
0> Gphuiof}3 fui`op afo% mojofmgf}r gpo
07 mojpgumkfh }lkr Baup} ))
00 ]LO BA_P]4 Reax maxf% Ir& ]gk}t&
02 IR& ]GK]T4 [or% rapp{% rapp{% [aup Lafap&
0= Mojofmgf}r gpo mojpgumkfh }lkr Baup} `{ r}g}kfh }lg} }lo
0? ru`~aofg kr fa} zgekm& Ru`~aofg xgr krruom kf }lo r}g}o
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
4/32
=^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 aj Hoaphkg xlopo }lo ~egkf}kjj gr gf g}}apfo{ kr
0 po~porof}kfh iue}k~eo bekof}r% za}opr gfm ~porkmof}kge
2 bgfmkmg}or&
= ]lopo gpo }lpoo g}}apfo{r po~porof}kfh
? ~egkf}kjjr& Afo aj }lo g}}apfo{r kr g mue{ oeob}om r}g}o
: po~porof}g}kzo aj }lo r}g}o aj Hoaphkg& ^porkmkfh dumho
8 kr g mo~u}{ blkoj dumho aj }lo gmikfkr}pg}kzo baup} aj }lo
< R}g}o aj Hoaphkg% Ikblgoe Igeklk&
; ]LO BA_P]4 Gfm Igeklk kr r~oeeom I)G1
7> IR& ]GK]T4 E)K ))
77 ]LO BA_P]4 L)K1
70 IR& ]GK]T4 [or& [or% [aup Lafap&
72 ]LO BA_P]4 Ha Glogm&
7= IR ]GK]T4 ]lo }pkge kr ro} jap Dgfugp{ 0:%
7? 0>70& ]lo bgro kr Jgppgp% Pa}l% IbBeopgf% Dum{ z& A`gig&
7: ]LO BA_P]4 Gfm {au foom }a r~oee }lg} jap }lo
78 baup} po~ap}op&
7< IR& ]GK]T4 [aup Lafap% J)G)P)P)G)P3 Pa}l%
7; P)A)])L3 Igbeopgf% I)G)B)E)O)P)G)F3 Dum{% D)_)M)[3 gfm
0> A@gig% A)@)G)I)G&
07 ^egkf}kjjr gpo blgeeofhkfh @gpgbc A`gig gr
00 kfoekhk`eo bgfmkmg}o muo }a g fui`op aj pografr% giafh
02 }loi lkr egbc aj zgekm kmof}kjkbg}kaf ~g~opr gfm egbc aj g
0= zgekm `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o }a ~pazo }lg} lo(r g fg}upge `apf
0? bk}ktof&
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
5/32
?^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 ^egkf}kjjr ru`ik}}om }a baup} iue}k~eo
0 o|lk`k}r rlaxkfh }lg} gbbapmkfh }a o|~op}r A`gig(r geeohom
2 eafh japi `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o kr g japhop{& Fa`am{ kf }lo
= bauf}p{ ozop rgx }lo apkhkfge `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o rkfbo
? Mojofmgf} Jumm{ pojuror }a ~pamubo k} jap kfr~ob}kaf&
: ]LO BA_P]4 Gfm Jumm{% J)_)M)M)[&
8 IR& ]GK]T4 [or% }lgfc {au% [aup Lafap&
< Mojofmgf} A`gig ru`ik}}om g ia}kaf }a mkrikrr kf }lo
; ufmope{kfh bgro kf Hoaphkg& Dumho Igeklk mofkom A`gig(r
7> ia}kaf }a mkrikrr& ]lo ~gp}kor gpo kf mkrbazop{ gfm
77 ru`~aofgr gpo g~~pa~pkg}o gfm ~pa~op&
70 Pueor aj }lo Gmikfkr}pg}kzo Baup} aj Hoaphkg
72 r}g}o :7:)7)0)&7;3 jkpr}% ru`~aofgr ig{ `o krruom xlkbl
7= powukpo }lo g}}ofmgfbo gfm }or}kiaf{ aj xk}forror gfm }lo
7? ~pamub}kaf aj a`dob}r g} mo~ark}kafr ap logpkfhr ~pazkmom
7: `{ }lkr pueo% :7:)7)0)&7;&
78 ]xa% ru`~aofg rlgee `o kf xpk}kfh gfm jkeom g}
7< eogr} jkzo mg{r ~pkap }a }lo logpkfh ap mo~ark}kaf g}
7; xlkbl g xk}forr ap mabuiof} kr rauhl}% rlgee `o ropzom
0> u~af gee ~gp}kor gfm rlgee kmof}kj{ }lo xk}forror xlaro
07 }or}kiaf{ rauhl} ap }lo a`dob} rauhl} }a `o ~pamubom&
00 Ozop{ ru`~aofg rlgee r}g}o }lo }k}eo aj }lo gb}kaf&
02 :7:)7)0)&7;,?+% g ru`~aofg ig{ `o wugrlom `{
0= Gmikfkr}pg}kzo Egx Dumho kj k} g~~ogpr }lg} }lo ru`~aofg
0? kr ufpografg`eo ap a~~porrkzo% ap }lg} }lo a`dob}r rauhl}
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
6/32
:^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 gpo kppoeozgf}% kiig}opkge% ap buiueg}kzo gfm uffoborrgp{
0 }a g ~gp}{(r ~po~gpg}kaf gfm ~porof}g}kaf aj k}r ~ark}kaf%
2 ap }lg} `grkb jgkpforr mkb}g}or }lg} }lo ru`~aofg rlauem
= fa} `o ofjapbom&
? Gr rubl% }lo ru`~aofg xgr krruom }kioe{& ]lo
: japi aj ru`~aofg kr bappob}& ^pa~op poiom{ jap }lo
8 mojofmgf}r kr g ia}kaf }a wugrl }lo ru`~aofg xk}l
< Gmikfkr}pg}kzo Dumho kf Hoaphkg& K} kr gu}aig}kb }lg}
; ru`~aofgr jpai au})aj)r}g}o gpo hkzof juee% jgk}l gfm
7> bpomk} `{ baup}r kf)r}g}o&
77 Kj g bgro xauem `o hakfh }a }pkge kf Lgxgk(k
70 kf Dumho Fkrlkiupg(r baup}paai af Dufo 0:% 0>70% gfm }lo
72 xk}forror gfm mabuiof}r kf wuor}kaf xauem lgzo `oof
7= eabg}om kf Hoaphkg% Dumho Igeklk ap gf{ a}lop ~porkmkfh
7? dumho gpaufm }lo bauf}p{ xauem bafrkmop Dumho Fkrlkiupg }a
7: `o g dumho kf g baup} aj bai~o}of} dupkrmkb}kaf gfm xauem
78 o|}ofm }lo dupkrmkb}kaf aj lop r}g}o baup} kf Lgxgk(k }a
7< }lo R}g}o aj Hoaphkg ap gf{ a}lop r}g}o&
7; Xlkeo kf 72 r}g}or kf }lo ufkaf pobk~pabge
0> ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} kr gu}aig}kb% kf }lo poigkfkfh
07 r}g}or% kfbeumor Lgxgk(k% rubl ofjapboiof} kr }{~kbgee{ g
00 ikfkr}opkge mu}{ xlkbl aj}of maor fa} ozof kfzaezo g dumho
02 gfm kr jpooe{ hkzof `{ }lo beopc aj }lo baup} kf apmop }a
0= o|}ofm dupkrmkb}kaf& Dur} gr kf jomopge baup}r% g beopc
0? kf afo mkr}pkb} xauem gu}aig}kbgee{ rkhf g ru`~aofg }a
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
7/32
8^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 o|}ofm }lo dupkrmkb}kaf aj gfa}lop mkr}pkb}&
0 Gj}op }lo dupkrmkb}kaf kr o|}ofmom }lpauhl
2 pobk~pabge ofjapboiof}% g ~gp}{ a~~arkfh }lo ru`~aofg kr
= ru~~aro }a jkeo g ia}kaf }a wugrl `ojapo }lo
? Gmikfkr}pg}kzo Dumho&
: ]xa% mojofmgf}r ~pa~op poiom{ kr jkekfh g
8 ~pa~op ia}kaf }a wugrl xk}l Gmikfkr}pg}kzo Dumho& Gr
< r}g}om ~pozkaure{% gbbapmkfh }a }lo Pueor aj }lo
; Gmikfkr}pg}kzo Baup} aj Hoaphkg% Pueo :7:)7)0)&7;,?+% g
7> ru`~aofg ig{ `o wugrlom% xlkbl kr g ~pa~op poiom{&
77 ]lo wuor}kaf kr xlo}lop }lo ru`~aofg xgr
70 jpkzaeaur gfm xlo}lop k} kr ekcoe{ }a `o wugrlom kj rubl
72 ia}kaf xgr }a `o jkeom& Gbbapmkfh }a LPR 22
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
8/32
:&72% o}b&
7 Igeklk }a r}gfm }pkge gfm ~pazo lkr oekhk`kek}{ }a `o af
0 }lo `geea}& Kf apmop }a `o af }lo `geea} gr g
2 ~porkmof}kge bgfmkmg}o% afo lgr }a rlax }lg} lo(r g
= fg}upge `apf bk}ktof&
? G `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o powuor}om kr ~pkig jgbko
: ozkmofbo aj r}g}u}o ekg`kek}{& @or} ozkmofbo pueor
8 mkb}g}o }lg} }lo apkhkfge foom }a `o ~pazkmom kf ekou aj
< }lo geeohom ba~{ ~pazkmom `{ Ip& A`gig }a }lo ~u`ekb&
; Kj }lkr Baup} kr pojurkfh }a geeax }lo
7> gmikfkr}pg}kzo baup} kf Hoaphkg gbborr }a }lo apkhkfge
77 mabuiof}% }lof }lkr Baup} xauem `o mo~pkzkfh g baup} aj g
70 rkr}op r}g}o aj gmikrrk`eo% bai~o}of} ozkmofbo foborrgp{
72 jap }pkge gfm xauem `o ofhghom kf a`r}pub}kaf aj dur}kbo&
7= Gr r}g}om ~pozkaure{% }lopo gpo afe{ g jox
7? kfr}gfbor xlof g ru`~aofg bgf `o wugrlom xlkbl gpo gr
7: jaeeaxr4
78 G% kr }lo ozkmofbo powuor}om kppoeozgf}1 Fa&
7< Xlof }lo fg}upge `apf bk}ktof r}g}ur kr `okfh mobkmom% }lo
7; apkhkfge `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o kr fa} poeozgf}&
0> @% kr k} kiig}opkge1 Fa& @kp}l bop}kjkbg}o
07 kr g ig}opkge ozkmofbo foomom }a ~pazo }lo ~egbo aj `kp}l&
00 B% kr k} buiueg}kzo1 Fa& @obguro k}(r }lo
02 afe{ }lkfh }lg} kr powuor}om&
0= M% kr k} ufpografg`eo1 Fa& K} kr fa}
0? ufpografg`eo }a grc }a kfr~ob} }lo `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o xlopo
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
9/32
;^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 }lo ~egbo aj `kp}l kr `okfh wuor}kafom&
0 Kr k} a~~porrkzo1 Fa& Ip& A`gig lgr apmopom
2 k} poeogrom xlg} lo begkir }a `o g ba~{ aj rubl `kp}l
= bop}kjkbg}o&
? Kf por~afro }a }lo eohge gb}kaf `{ Mp& ]gk}t%
: A`gig(r bgi~gkhf igfghop krruom ))
8 ]LO BA_P]4 [au foom }a reax maxf ghgkf%
< Ir& ]gk}t&
; IR& ]GK]T4 [or% K(i rapp{& R}g}oiof} }lg}
7> A`gig bgi~gkhf xkee roee iapo ])rlkp}r gfm iuhr xk}l g
77 ~kb}upo aj lkr `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o& Kj k} kr af ])rlkp}r
70 gfm iuhr% lax bgf k} `o bafrkmopom a~~porrkzo }a powuor}
72 }a roo }lo apkhkfge mabuiof} aj xlg} kr af iuhr gfm
7= ])rlkp}r gee azop }lo bauf}p{&
7? ]gk}t ru`ik}r }lg} k} kr a~~porrkzo }a mof{
7: rubl ru`~aofg& K} kr a~~porrkzo gfm g ~kffgbeo aj
78 bappu~}kaf jap }lo mojofmgf} gfm jap mojofmgf}(r g}}apfo{
7< Ir& Fghgikfo }a pojuro }a baa~opg}o gfm }a moigfm
7; rgfb}kafr gfm }a moigfm }a mooi ]gk}t ))
0> ]LO PO^AP]OP4 O|buro io&
07 ]LO BA_P]4 Reax maxf ghgkf&
00 IR& ]GK]T4 )) ek}khgf} jap powuor}kfh g
02 pau}kfo iufmgfo pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} jap }pkge
0= xlkbl kr rblomueom eorr }lgf }xa xoocr jpai fax&
0? Gr rubl% k} kr g zgekm ru`~aofg jpai }lo baup}
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
10/32
7>^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 aj bai~o}of} dupkrmkb}kaf& K} maor fa} jgee xk}lkf gf{ aj
0 }lo ofuiopg}om kfr}gfbor xlopo g ru`~aofg bgf `o wugrlom&
2 ]lopo kr fa o|buro ap dur}kjkbg}kaf jap }lkr Baup} fa} }a
= o|}ofm }lo dupkrmkb}kaf jpai }lo r}g}o baup} kf Hoaphkg
? gfm fa} }a ~pazkmo pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} xk}l
: eogzo aj baup} jap }lo mojofmgf} }a jkeo g ~pa~op ia}kaf
8 }a wugrl }lo ru`~aofg xk}l g }pkge dumho kf Hoaphkg&
< ]lpoo% gr gf g}}apfo{ po~porof}kfh ~egkf}kjjr
; kf Hoaphkg gfm kf iue}k~eo a}lop r}g}or gpaufm }lo
7> bauf}p{% ]gk}t kr a`ekhg}om }a rooc ozkmofbo foborrgp{ jap
77 }pkge gfm xauem `o ekg`eo kj rlo xopo fa} }a rooc
70 ozkmofbo&
72 Gr r}g}om ~pozkaure{% ]gk}t kr gf g}}apfo{
7= po~porof}kfh iue}k~eo bekof}r gpaufm }lo bauf}p{%
7? kfbeumkfh rozopge bgfmkmg}or puffkfh jap }lo _&R&
7: ^porkmof}% ioi`opr aj }lo _&R& ikek}gp{% r}g}o
78 po~porof}g}kzor gfm za}opr& Gr gf g}}apfo{ rlo axor lop
7< bekof}r g mu}{ aj togeaur po~porof}g}kaf& Gfm rlo bgf
7; gb}ugee{ `o ekg`eo kj rlo maor fa} juejkee rubl mu}{&
0> ]lopo kr fa}lkfh jpkzaeaur kf lop gb}kafr& Af
07 }lo a}lop lgfm% k} kr jpkzaeaur gfm po~porof}r lgpgrriof}%
00 g}}oi~}om kf}kikmg}kaf aj g bkzke pkhl}r g}}apfo{ kf gf
02 g}}oi~}om zkaeg}kaf aj lop jkpr} giofmiof} bkzke pkhl} jap
0= pomporr aj hpkozgfbor&
0? Jap Fghgikfo }a moigfm }lg} }lkr Baup} jkfm
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
11/32
77^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 }lg} rubl g ~pa~op gfm pografg`eo togeaur po~porof}g}kaf
0 gfm ~pa~op mkrbazop{ eorr }lgf }xa xoocr `ojapo }pkge }a
2 `o bafrkmopom jpkzaeaur gfm rgfb}kafg`eo gfm zo|g}kaur&
= Jaup% }lkr bgro kr gckf }a Pao z& Xgmo& Dur}
? g jox mg{r gha Fkf}l Bkpbuk} Baup} aj G~~oger krruom g
: puekfh kf @gpfo}}% @)G)P)F)O)])]% Co{r% C)O)[)O)R% o} ge
8 z& A`gig% o} ge% Fa& 7>)??>>;&
7> Xlkeo }lo Fkf}l Bkpbuk} jaufm }lg} k} xgr }aa
77 eg}o }a jkeo g blgeeofho af Kfguhupg}kaf Mg{% k} mkm jkfm%
70 laxozop% }lg} oekhk`kek}{ blgeeofho bgf ha japxgpm gfm
72 ~porkmof}kge bgfmkmg}or lgzo r}gfmkfh }a blgeeofho
7= oekhk`kek}{ aj g bgfmkmg}o af }lo `geea}&
7? Ra }lo Fkf}l Bkpbuk}(r% xlaro mobkrkaf kr
7: `kfmkfh af }lkr baup}% lgr gepogm{ jaufm }lg} rubl
78 oeob}kaf blgeeofhor jkeom gee azop }lo fg}kaf mupkfh }lo
7< oeob}kaf gpo zgekm gfm bgfmkmg}or lgzo r}gfmkfh&
7; Iapoazop% iue}k~eo r}g}or gpaufm }lo fg}kaf
0> lgzo r~obkjkb r}g}u}or xlopo`{ fa} afe{ ~porkmof}kge
07 bgfmkmg}or% `u} gera apmkfgp{ za}opr lgzo r}gfmkfh }a
00 blgeeofho oekhk`kek}{ aj g bgfmkmg}o&
02 Apkhkfge `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o kr g} }lo paa} aj
0= ozop{ rubl blgeeofho& Kf Pao z& Xgmo% Ru~poio Baup} aj
0? }lo _fk}om R}g}or lgr hpgf}om dupkrmkb}kaf }a g xlaeo
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
12/32
70^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 begrr aj bgror xlkbl gpo po~og}ome{ `pauhl} }a baup} gfm
0 gmdumkbg}kaf af }lo iopk}r&
2 Gr rkikegp oeob}kaf blgeeofhor giauf}om gee
= azop }lo fg}kaf% k} kr ~pa~op kf }lo kf}opor} aj dumkbkge
? obafai{ }a o|}ofm }lo dupkrmkb}kaf aj }lo baup} kf Hoaphkg
: ~pazkmo }lo pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} gfm lgzo }lkr
8 ig}}op logpm af }lo iopk}r xlkbl xauem gzakm ek}khg}kaf kf
< iue}k~eo rkikegp bgror&
; Jkzo% ]gk}t jaeeaxom ~pa~op ~pabomupge
7> hukmoekfor& Ru`~aofg kf Hoaphkg xgr krruom xlof ]gk}t xgr
77 ~parobu}om )) ~parobu}kfh g poeg}om bgro% ]gk}t z& Jumm{&
70 K} xgr ~pa~op }a rooc rubl ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} kf }lo
72 jpgioxapc aj g poeg}om bgro& Gfm ]gk}t jkeom g ~pa~op
7= ia}kaf roockfh }a lgzo }lo ru`~aofg logpm egr} xooc mupkfh
7? }lo rblomueom logpkfh kf ]gk}t z& Jumm{&
7: Gr }lkr Baup} xgr fa} kfbekfom }a logp
78 ru`~aofg ia}kaf af }lo rgio mg{ gfm rblomueom k} jap
7< Dgfugp{ 0:% ]gk}t jkeom g ~pa~op ia}kaf }a o|~omk}o gr }lo
7; }pkge kf Hoaphkg kr rblomueom af }lo rgio mg{& ]lo Baup}
0> o|~omk}om% }lopojapo% }lopo kr fa}lkfh jpkzaeaur
07 ~pabomupge uf}ke }lopo kr g jkfge dumhiof} kf }lo bgro%
00 }lo bgro kr a~ofom gfm k} kr ~pa~op }a logp ia}kafr kf }lo
02 bgro&
0= Ozof kj }lo jkfge dumhiof} kr krruom% kf raio
0? bgror ~ar})dumhiof} ?;,o+ ia}kafr jap pobafrkmopg}kaf gpo
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
13/32
72^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 jkeom% ap ]gk}t lgm gf a~}kaf }a jkeo g fox bgro }a rooc
0 pobk~pabge ofjapboiof} aj au})aj)r}g}o ru`~aofg&
2 Mojofmgf} mkm fa} rlax g rlpom aj ozkmofbo aj gf{}lkfh
= mafo `{ }lo ~egkf}kjj xlkbl kr jpkzaeaur ap rgfb}kafg`eo
? ap zo|g}kaur&
: Rk|% kf gee lop ekjo ]gk}t jkeom afe{ afo
8 eohge gb}kaf kf }lo R}g}o aj Lgxgk(k% xlkbl maor fa} hkzo
< pkro jap }lkr Baup} }a mooi lop g zo|g}kaur ~egkf}kjj&
; Mojofmgf} gfm mojofmgf}(r g}}apfo{ cfax }lg} }lo R}g}o aj
7> Lgxgk(k xauem jkfm g ~egkf}kjj zo|g}kaur kf }lo R}g}o aj
77 Lgxgkkn kj }lo ~egkf}kjj jkeor iue}k~eo eohge gb}kafr kf
70 }lo R}g}o aj Lgxgkkn gfm }laro gb}kafr gpo jaufm }a `o
72 po~og}ome{ jpkzaeaur&
7= ]gk}t jkeom afe{ afo rkfheo gb}kaf kf }lo
7? R}g}o aj Lgxgkkn ufmop Eabge Jpoomai aj Kfjapig}kaf Gb}%
7: _K^G roockfh }a o|gikfo gf apkhkfge mabuiof}& Gfm rlo
78 jkeom afo ia}kaf jap pobk~pabge au})aj)r}g}o ru`~aofg
7< ofjapboiof} }a ~pamubo }lo rgio mabuiof}&
7; Beogpe{% afo eohge gb}kaf jkeom kf }lo R}g}o
0> aj Lgxgk(k xauem fa} hkzo pkro }a g mo}opikfg}kaf aj g
07 zo|g}kaur ~egkf}kjj& Iapoazop% }lopo kr fa}lkfh jpkzaeaur
00 kf roockfh }a o|gikfo gf apkhkfge mabuiof} kf ekou aj gf
02 geeohom ba~{ gfm kf ekhl} aj g ~pa~op gfm zgekm ru`~aofg
0= poeg}om }a g }pkge xlkbl kr baikfh eorr }lgf }xa xoocr
0? jpai fax&
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
14/32
7=^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 Kj }lkr ia}kaf xgr jpkzaeaur% }lkr Baup} xauem
0 lgzo ruiigpke{ mofkom }lo ia}kaf jap pobk~pabge ru`~aofg
2 ofjapboiof} gr }lo Baup} lgr kflopof} ~axop }a ruiigpke{
= mof{ jpkzaeaur ia}kafr gfm xauem fa} lgzo hpgf}om }lo
? ia}kaf }a o|~omk}o&
: Ra k} g~~ogpr }lg} mojofmgf}r gpo bgeekfh }lo
8 gb}kafr aj }lkr zop{ baup} }a `o jpkzaeaur% rgfb}kafg`eo
< gfm zo|g}kaur& Beogpe{% }lkr Baup} roor }lg} k} bgffa}
; a`r}pub} dur}kbo gfm mof{ baup}r aj bai~o}of} dupkrmkb}kaf
7> gpaufm }lo fg}kaf gfm mof{ gbborr }a gmikrrk`eo% bai~o}of}
77 ozkmofbo foborrgp{ jap poraeu}kaf aj bgror g} }pkge&
70 Gfm }lo egr} ~akf}% gb}kafr `{ }lo mojofmgf}r
72 gfm }lokp g}}apfo{ gpo jpkzaeaur% g`urkzo gfm a~~porrkzo
7= gfm po~porof} g egr} mk}bl g}}oi~} }a a`r}pub} dur}kbo%
7? bazop)u~ japhop{ gfm zkaeg}o ufmop baeap aj gu}lapk}{
7: bkzke pkhl}r aj }lo ~egkf}kjj gfm Giopkbgf bk}ktofr gfm
78 za}opr gpaufm }lo fg}kaf&
7< ]lo bgro xgr jkeom kf Guhur} aj egr} {ogp&
7; Gj}op }lo R}g}o mofkom ]gk}t }a o|gikfo }lo apkhkfge `kp}l
0> bop}kjkbg}or aj @gpgbc A`gig kf ekou aj gf geeohom
07 bop}kjkom ba~{% gfm pojurom }a poeogro g `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o
00 aj g mobogrom Zkphkfkg Rufglgpg% xla xgr `apf af }lo rgio
02 mg{% Guhur} =% (:7 gfm mkom Guhur} ?% (:7% xlopo }lopo xgr
0= g rur~kbkaf }lg} A`gig(r japhom `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o xgr
0? igfujgb}upom zkg bai~u}op hpg~lkbr urkfh Rufglgpg(r
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
15/32
7?^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 fui`op&
0 G} }lo }kio mojofmgf}r urom LPR 22< ))
2 ]LO PO^AP]OP4 O|buro io1
= IR& ]GK]T4 Rapp{& G} }lg} }kio mojofmgf}r
? urom LPR 22
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
16/32
7:^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 mabuiof} kf wuor}kaf kr% kfmoom% g japhop{ gfm }lg} kr xl{
0 }lo{ gpo pojurkfh kfr~ob}kaf% ozof xlof a`ekhg}om `{ }lo
2 rgio zop{ pueor }lo{ gpo baup}kfh&
= Fa} afe{ mojofmgf}(r a`r}pub}kaf aj dur}kbo
? gfm bazop)u~% }lo{ gpo zkbkaure{ g}}gbckfh }lo ~egkf}kjj
: mojgikfh lop% ~parobu}kfh lop% kf}kikmg}kfh lop xk}l
8 moigfmr aj rgfb}kafr gfm zo|g}kaur kf}op~po}g}kaf&
< ]lkr kr g ig}}op aj fg}kafge ki~ap}gfbo& Gfm
; k} kr }lo iar} rgbpom bkzke pkhl} aj }lo _&R& bk}ktofr%
7> }lo pkhl} }a za}o kf egxjue oeob}kafr xlkbl gpo jpoo jpai
77 japhop{ gfm jpgum& ]lo pkhl} }a za}o kr }lo lkhlor} japi
70 aj ~pa}ob}om pkhl} }a jpoo r~oobl% ~aek}kbge r~oobl&
72 Buppof} bgro po~porof}r ~egkf}kjj(r ~pa}ob}om
7= bafr}k}u}kafge pkhl} jap gmmporr aj hpkozgfbor& ]lkr
7? fg}kaf xgr `uke} af rubl pkhl}r& Xlof Rurgf @& Gf}laf{
7: jauhl} jap xaiof(r pkhl} }a za}o% R}g}o(r g}}apfo{ ekco
78 Fghgikfo ~pa`g`e{ rgx lop gb}kafr jpkzaeaur gfm
7< rgfb}kafg`eo&
7; Xlof bkzke pkhl}r g}}apfo{r rauhl} }a u~laem
0> bkzke pkhl}r aj Dg~gforo Giopkbgfr mupkfh Xapem Xgp KK kf
07 Capoig}ru z& _&R& gfm Lafmg% R}g}o(r g}}apfo{ ekco
00 Fghgikfo ~pa`g`e{ rauhl} }a mooi bkzke pkhl}r g}}apfo{r }a
02 `o zo|g}kaur ~egkf}kjjr&
0= ]amg{% ]gk}t kr roockfh% [aup Lafap% }a hpgf}
0? lop g pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} jpai g baup} aj
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
17/32
78^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 bai~o}of} dupkrmkb}kaf kf apmop }a po~porof} lop bekof}r
0 g} }pkge kf dur} }xa xoocr% gfm kf apmop }a u~laem bkzke
2 pkhl}r aj ozop{ Giopkbgf }a lgzo egxjue oeob}kafr jpoo aj
= japhop{ gfm jpgum gfm kr grckfh }a hpgf} lop ia}kaf&
? ]lgfc {au% [aup Lafap&
: ]LO BA_P]4 Ir& Fghgikfo% {aup a~~ark}kaf&
8 IR& FGHGIKFO4 [aup Lafap% gb}ugee{% K }lkfc K
< ~po}}{ iubl r}g}om k} kf xpk}kfh% `u} K(ee ))
; ]LO BA_P]4 Ruiigpkto k}&
7> IR& FGHGIKFO4 )) ruiigpkto }laro jkzo ~akf}r
77 }lg} K igmo& Jkpr} aj gee% ru`~aofgr krruom jpai g
70 Hoaphkg r}g}o gmikfkr}pg}kzo }pk`ufge lgzo fa japbo ap
72 ojjob} ap zgekmk}{ kf Lgxgk(k& 22
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
18/32
7:&72% o}b&
7 xlg} K xgr g`eo }a jkfm af Hoaphkg egx% gfm }lkr kr jpai
0 }lo% eo}(r ho} }lo bk}o lopo% Hoaphkg Bamo Gffa}g}om
2 Rob}kaf ?>)72)72,g+,8+% ru`~aofgr rlgee `o krruom xk}lau}
= mkrbpkikfg}kaf `o}xoof ~u`ekb gfm ~pkzg}o ~gp}kor xlof g
? ru`~aofg kr mkra`o{om% gf{ ~gp}{ ig{ g~~e{ }a }lo Ru~opkap
: Baup} aj }lo bauf}{ xlopo }lo baf}or}om bgro kr `okfh
8 logpm jap gf apmop powukpkfh a`omkofbo&
< Ra grruikfh }lo Mo~gp}iof} aj Loge}l kr
; mkra`o{kfh raio}lkfh% xlkbl K xauem gphuo }lg} k} kr fa}
7> `obguro k} lgr fa} ha}}of g zgekme{ krruom ap ropzom
77 ru`~aofg% grruikfh xo(zo mkra`o{om raio}lkfh% }lof }lo
70 Ru~opkap Baup} kf Hoaphkg kr }lo afo xla kr ru~~aro }a
72 igco }lg} mo}opikfg}kaf&
7= Ozof kj }lg} ru`~aofg krruom kf Hoaphkg xgr
7? ofauhl }a )) xo xopo g`eo }a azoppkmo }laro Hoaphkg
7: gmikfkr}pg}kzo pueor% xo r}kee lgzo Lgxgk(k Pozkrom
78 R}g}u}or 22
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
19/32
7;^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 Gfm }lg} ru`~aofg xgr gb}ugee{ jap raio}lkfh rblomueom af
0 )) jap ur }a ma }lo mo~ark}kaf af Dgfugp{ ?}l% xlkbl kr
2 ~gr}% gfm jap g baup} mg}o xlkbl xgr Dgfugp{ 7:}l }lpauhl
= 7 IR& FGHGIKFO4 ]lg} kr bappob}% [aup Lafap&
77 ]LO BA_P]4 Acg{&
70 IR& FGHGIKFO4 K}(r ~pomkb}g`eo }lg} kj rubl
72 ru`~aofg kr ropzom af i{ bekof}% }lg} g rkikegp por~afro
7= }a gee aj }lo ~pozkaur por~afror xkee ha au}& ]lg} kr
7? ~pomkb}g`eo `obguro k}(r gee hakfh }a baio `gbc maxf }a
7: 22 jap}lbaikfh kf g ro~gpg}o mabuiof}% `u} K xgf}om }a
07 iof}kaf }lg} }lkr iapfkfh ra }lg} Ir& ]gk}t bgf lgzo gee
00 }lo fa}kbo }lg} rlo ikhl} foom xlof K ma jkeo i{ ia}kaf
02 gfm rlo baior `gbc lopo jap }lg} logpkfh% iafo}gp{
0= rgfb}kafr }a bazop gee aj }lo }kio }lg} i{ ajjkbo lgr
0? r~of} af gee aj lop powuor}r& Gfm }lg}(r g ea} aj }kio%
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
20/32
0>^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 [aup Lafap% `obguro Ir& ]gk}t maorf(} japi lop powuor}r kf
0 g xg{ }lg} kr ogr{ }a gmmporr& Lop powuor}r foom raio
2 kf}op~po}g}kaf& Gfm xo ma aup `or} }a kf}op~po} xlg} rlo
= kr }p{kfh }a ho} gfm xlg} rlo kr }p{kfh }a gphuo& Gfm xo
? lgzo }a por~afm }a gee aj }lo gphuiof}r }lg} xo `oekozo
: rlo(r igckfh gfm }lg} maor }gco }kio&
8 G ea} aj }kio lgr `oof r~of} af Ir& ]gk}t(
< krruor gfm kf }lkr zop{ ig}}op& Ra iafo}gp{ rgfb}kafr
; xkee `o raio}lkfh }lg} xo(po grckfh jap& Gfm xo gpo
7> la~kfh }lg} }lg} bgf `o raio}lkfh }a poki`upro aup bekof}r
77 gfm auproezor jap aup }kio& @u} xlg} xo pogee{ xkee `o
70 grckfh jap xk}l gee ropkaurforr kr }lg} Ir& ]gk}t `o
72 mobegpom g zo|g}kaur ek}khg}ap lopo kf }lo R}g}o aj
7= Lgxgk(k&
7? Gfm }lopo kr ~pobomof} jap }lkr& Kf jgb}% jap
7: g bkpbuk} baup} dumho apmopkfh rubl g }lkfh% kf }lo bgro K
78 bk}omOc z& @ahhr gfm }lopo gpo bpk}opkg ekr}om gb}ugee{
7< kf aup r}g}o egx& Xo lgzo g egx jap zo|g}kaur ek}khgf}r&
7; Gfm K `oekozo }lg} Ir& ]gk}t gi~e{ ioo}r gee aj }lo
0> powukpoiof}r& K ekr}om jkzo aj }lo bgror }lg} rlo lgr
07 ~paboomom kf kf a}lop dupkrmkb}kafr gfm `oof po`ujjom
00 ozop{ }kio% kfbeumkfh afo }lg} K iof}kafom kf }lo r}g}o aj
02 Hoaphkg&
0= IR& ]GK]T4 A`dob}kaf&
0? IR& FGHGIKFO4 @{ Dumho Beg{ Egfm ))
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
21/32
07^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 IR& ]GK]T4 A`dob}kaf&
0 IR& FGHGIKFO4 )) g -0>%>>> rgfb}kaf&
2 ]LO BA_P]4 Ir& ]gk}t% dur} }a gmzkro ap
= g~~pkro {au }lg} }lo Baup} mkm geeax {au }a pogm ajj {aup
? eg~}a~% K(i fa} rupo kj k}(r {aup eg~}a~% {aup of}kpo
: gphuiof}& Gfm K `oekozo Ir& Fghgikfo fok}lop a`dob}om fap
8 kf}oppu~}om {au& Ra K ma powuor} }lo rgio baup}or{& [au
< bgf po~e{ }a lop a~~ark}kaf&
; IR& ]GK]T4 K(i rapp{% [aup Lafap& Kf a}lop
7> baup}r }lo{ geeax a`dob}kafr&
77 ]LO BA_P]4 K cfax& @u} {au fa}kbom%
70 Ir& Fghgikfo fok}lop a`dob}om fap kf}oppu~}om {au&
72 IR& ]GK]T4 [or% [aup Lafap&
7= IR& FGHGIKFO4 Rob}kaf :2=D)7 mojkfor
7? zo|g}kaur ek}khgf}& Gfm K `oekozo }lg} Ir& ]gk}t gfm lop
7: gb}kafr lopo kf }lo R}g}o aj Lgxgkkn gfm kf }lkr baup}
78 rg}krj{ gee aj }lo powukpoiof}r aj zo|g}kaur ek}khgf}&
7< Gfm K(i fa} hakfh }a ha kf}a }lg} lopo `obguro
7; }lkr ia}kaf krf(} kf jpaf} aj [aup Lafap }lkr iapfkfh& K
0> xauem lgzo ~po~gpom k} jap }lkr iapfkfh% `u} K mkmf(} lgzo
07 }lo a~~ap}ufk}{ }a ~u} }aho}lop gee aj }lo ekr} aj
00 k}oiktom g}}apfo{(r joor {o}& K xgr por~afmkfh }a
02 ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} ia}kaf% [aup Lafap& Gfm K(i rapp{
0= }lg} K bauemf(} lgzo xapcom }lg} au} }a rgzo {au g
0? logpkfh% [aup Lafap&
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
22/32
00^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 @u} }lopo(r `oof g ~g}}opf lopo `{ ~egkf}kjj%
0 gfm k}(r mkr}up`kfh gfm k}(r xgr}kfh }kio& Gfm }lo iafo{
2 rgfb}kafr% ig{`o }lg} xkee r}a~ lop% ig{`o }lg} xaf(}&
= K(i }lkfckfh ig{`o k} xaf(} `obguro g -0>%>>> rgfb}kaf kf
? gfa}lop bgro lgrf(} r}a~~om lop& Ra K cfax aup g}}apfo{(r
: joor xaf(} `o -0>%>>>& Ra K maf(} lgzo gf{ gf}kbk~g}kaf
8 }lg} rubl g }lkfh xkee gb}ugee{ r}a~ lop% k} ikhl} loe~&
< @u} xlg} K xauem ekco kr jap i{ ajjkbo gfm i{
; bekof} }a fa} }a lgzo }a baf}kfuo mogekfh xk}l }lkr& Gfm
7> K }lkfc `obguro Ir& ]gk}t maor ioo} }lo powukpoiof}r aj
77 zo|g}kaur ek}khgf}& K }lkfc k} xauem `o zop{ urojue kf
70 }lo ju}upo jap gf{ aj lop jkekfhr }a lgzo }a `o rbpoofom
72 `{ g baup} jap g baup} }a `o g`eo }a hkzo gf gmzgfbom
7= mo}opikfg}kaf gr }a xlo}lop }lopo kr gf{ ~a}of}kge
7? rbkf}keeg aj iopk} }a lop begkir&
7: Gfm ra }lg}(r% gr K rgkm% }lkr krf(} kf jpaf}
78 aj [aup Lafap }lkr iapfkfh& K}(r dur} ckfm aj fa}kbo ra
7< }lg} fa`am{ bgf begki }lg} }lo{(po `okfh rup~pkrom&
7; Gfm lgzo K gmmporrom gee aj [aup Lafap(r
0> wuor}kafr kf ruiigp{ jgrlkaf g`au} xl{ }lopo kr fa `grkr
07 }a hpgf} }lkr ru`~aofg }lg} xgrf(} ozop ropzom af i{
00 bekof}1 Kr }lopo iapo }lg} K bgf gmmporr% [aup Lafap1
02 ]LO BA_P]4 I{ ]gk}t gera pgkrom }lo krruo
0= pohgpmkfh )) gfm rlo(r bappob} }lg} }lopo kr pogee{ fa
0? dumhiof} {o} }a mg}o& Ge}lauhl }lo Baup} mkm hpgf} {aup
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
23/32
02^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 ia}kaf jap mkrikrrge% }lg} xgr gf apmop hpgf}kfh {aup
0 ia}kaf }a mkrikrr% laxozop% k} lgr fa} `oof pomubom ok}lop
2 ~uprugf} }a Pueo ?= ap ?< }a dumhiof}% gera }lo Dofckfr(
= bgro& Ra Ir& ]gk}t xgr pkhl} ~pabomupge gr }a }lg}
? gr~ob}& Ra }lo Baup} lgr fa} {o} `oof kf pobok~} aj g
: dumhiof}&
8 IR& FGHGIKFO4 K(zo ha} g mpgj} aj k} xk}l io%
< [aup Lafap& Kf jgb}% K lgzo egr} xoocr apmop xk}l io
; `obguro aj Pueo 02% K lgm }a ~porof} k} }a ~egkf}kjj& Kf
7> jgb}% rlo lgrf(} lgm lop jkzo mg{r xk}l k} {o}& K `oekozo
77 K rof} k} }a lop af Iafmg{ ap ]uormg{% K maf(} pobgee& K}
70 xgr ogpekop }lkr xooc& K} lgr fa} `oof jkzo mg{r&
72 K xgr hakfh }a grc )) K(i grruikfh rlo(r fa}
7= hakfh }a gb}ugee{ xgf} }a rkhf k}% ra gj}op }lo jkzo mg{r
7? K xauem `o ru`ik}}kfh k} }a }lo Baup}% gf{xg{& Kj rlo lgr
7: fa a`dob}kaf }a i{ }gckfh g bau~eo mg{r ajj aj }lg} }kio%
78 K(i gb}ugee{ ~po~gpom }a lgfm egr} xooc(r apmop }a }lo
7< Baup} }lkr iapfkfh&
7; @obguro }lopo xkee `o gf apmop kf raio xg{
0> jpai }amg{(r logpkfh% K(i fa} g`eo }a hkzo {au }lg} jkfge
07 of}p{ aj dumhiof} ~uprugf} }a }lo Dofckfr bgro {o} `obguro
00 afo aj }lo }lkfhr }lg} }lo apmop powukpor `o r}g}om kr
02 }lg} }lopo gpo fa ~ofmkfh ig}}opr kf }lkr bgro& Gfm%
0= gb}ugee{% xoee% }amg{(r logpkfh kr g ~ofmkfh ig}}op% gfm
0? }lopo kr g ~ofmkfh ig}}op aj i{ ia}kaf jap rgfb}kafr% ra K
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
24/32
0=^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 gi fa} hakfh }a `o hkzkfh }lo Baup} }lg} apmop dur} {o}&
0 ]LO BA_P]4 _f}ke rubl }kio k} kr g~~pa~pkg}o1
2 IR& FGHGIKFO4 [or% [aup Lafap& @u} K gi
= juee{ gxgpo }lg} K ma foom }a ma }lg} apmop&
? ]LO BA_P]4 Ir& Fghgikfo lgr bai~eo}om lop
: gphuiof}& Gf{ por~afro% Ir& ]gk}t% fax {au bgf ~paboom1
8 IR& ]GK]T4 [or% [aup Lafap% K ma lgzo rozopge
< ~akf}r& Jkpr}% gr K r}g}om% K xauem ekco r}g}om kf i{
; po~e{ }lg} K xauem ekco }a jkeo g ia}kaf jap rgfb}kafr
7> ghgkfr} Ir& Fghgikfo jap ~u`ekb bappu~}kaf gfm mo~pgzg}kaf
77 aj bkzke pkhl}r ufmop baeap aj gu}lapk}{&
70 Gfm K xauem ekco }a `pkfh gf o|gi~eo& Kj gf
72 kfmkzkmuge hkzor raio`am{ g japhom blobc% g bauf}opjok}
7= blobc% gfm ho}r g lauro urkfh g japhom blobc& Gpo {au
7? hakfh }a rgfb}kaf }lo axfop aj }lo lauro xla kr baikfh }a
7: {au xk}l pomporr aj hpkozgfbor rg{kfh% i{ lauro xgr r}aeof
78 `{ g }lkoj& I{ lauro xgr r}aeof `{ raio`am{ xla urom g
7< japhom blobc& K}(r kfbafbokzg`eo&
7; Gfm }a io% }lkr kr dur} gf uf~pobomof}om eozoe
0> aj bappu~}kaf }lg} K roo jpai Ir& Fghgikfo xlopo K
07 ~porof}om lopo kf baup} ozkmofbo }lg} xlg} Ip& A`gig
00 ~ar}om af ekfo kr g japhop{% g bai~u}op hofopg}om japhop{&
02 K rlaxom {au }lo eg{opr% lax k} xgr bpog}om&
0= K ~pazkmom kfjapig}kaf% }lkr kr g japhop{&
0? Fa`am{ kf }lkr fg}kaf rgx }lo apkhkfge mabuiof}& I{
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
25/32
0?^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 bekof}r gpo ~porkmof}kge bgfmkmg}or& ]lo bgro kr hakfh }a
0 }pkge kf }xa xoocr xlopo }lkr kr `okfh ek}khg}om& Lax kf
2 }lo xapem kf g moiabpg}kb bauf}p{% kf g bauf}p{ }lg} lgr
= gf{ poroi`egfbo aj gf{ pueo aj egx roockfh }a zopkj{ }lo
? apkhkfge mabuiof} kf ekhl} aj japhop{ `{ ~oa~eo xla lgzo
: r}gfmkfh }lg} kr baikfh `ojapo g dumho bgf `o bafrkmopom
8 jpkzaeaur&
< Lax bauem }lkr `o jpkzaeaur1 Lax bauem }lkr
; `o zo|g}kaur ap rgfb}kafg`eo1 K iogf% }lo Ajjkbo aj }lo
7> G}}apfo{ Hofopge aj Lgxgk(k lgr }a `o ~gp} aj raio ckfm aj
77 bpkikfge of}op~pkro }a ozof }lkfc }lg} }lkr kr kf gf{ xg{
70 rgfb}kafg`eo ap zo|g}kaur ap jpkzaeaur& ]lkr kr bpkikfge%
72 K iogf% k}(r ekco g bpkikfge of}op~pkro puffkfh }lo Ajjkbo
7= aj }lo G}}apfo{ Hofopge aj Lgxgk(k&
7? Hakfh `gbc }a Igp`up{ z& Igmkraf& Gf{ pueo%
7: gf{ gb} }lg} kr zaek}kzo aj bafr}k}u}kaf% }lg} kr
78 po~uhfgf} }a bafr}k}u}kaf kr zakm& ]lo kf}op~po}g}kaf aj
7< Pueo 22 mabuiof}r&
07 @u} K lgzo ~pazkmom {au xk}l g ru`~aofg jpai g
00 baup} jpai bai~o}of} dupkrmkb}kaf& G} }lkr ~akf} }lopo kr
02 fa% fa o|buro% }lopo kr topa o|buro ap dur}kjkbg}kaf fa}
0= }a ~pazkmo rubl gbborr xk}l% aj baupro% eogzo jap
0? Ir& Fghgikfo }a jkeo g ia}kaf }a wugrl }lo ru`~aofg kj rlo
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
26/32
0:^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 xkrlor }a ma ra&
0 Kj }lo mabuiof} af jkeo kr fa} japhom% k}(r
2 azop& Kj k}(r fa} japhom& Kj k} kr japhom% }lof rlo
= rlauem `o jkekfh bpkikfge blgphor ghgkfr} Ir& Jumm{ ap
? gf{`am{ oero kfzaezom& Lax bauem k} `o bafrkmopom }lg} g
: ~pa~op wuor}kaf `grom af ~pa~op ~gp} aj }lo r}g}u}o% kj
8 [aup Lafap kr blobckfh% 22 [aup Lafap% K(i lopo r~obkjkbgee{ }a o|}ofm
77 }lkr apmop jpai g baup} aj bai~o}of} dupkrmkb}kaf }a }lo
70 R}g}o aj Lgxgkkn& ]lopo kr fa rofro aj io ropzkfh gf{
72 a}lop ru`~aofgr& Apkhkfgee{ xlof }lo bgro xgr rblomueom
7= jap Dgfugp{ 7
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
27/32
08^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 o|~ob} io }a hkzo lop baup}or{&
0 Kj {au laem }pkge gfm {au xgf} g xk}forr jpai
2 Hoaphkg }a g~~ogp `ojapo {au gfm {au krruo ru`~aofg% g
= ~pa~op ~pabomupo jap io }a ha }a g dumho kf Hoaphkg gfm
? grc lki jap g pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} }a o|}ofm
: ru`~aofg jpai {aup baup} }a `o ofjapbk`eo azop g xk}forr
8 xla kr porkmkfh kf Hoaphkg& ]lg}(r gee K(i grckfh&
< ]lkr kr g zgekm }pkge& ]lkr kr g zgekm bgro&
; ]lopo kr fa}lkfh jpkzaeaur& [aup Lafap% }lkr kr raio}lkfh
7> }lg} kr mafo mg{ kf gfm mg{ au}% }laurgfmr aj ru`~aofgr
77 gee azop }lo fg}kaf gpo `okfh ofjapbom )) gpo `okfh
70 o|}ofmom `{ eabge dumhor ap ozof beopcr kf mkjjopof}
72 baup}r% kfbeumkfh {aup baup}paai% kfbeumkfh }lkr baup}&
7= ]lopo kr fa pograf fa} }a hkzo io rubl
7? pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} }a o|}ofm k} }a }lo R}g}o
7: aj Lgxgk(k& Kj fa}% }lof }lopo kr g r}gfm)ajj `o}xoof
78 }lkr r}g}o% }lo R}g}o aj Lgxgk(k gfm }lo por} aj }lo
7< fg}kaf& @obguro }lo ~egkf}kjjr gee azop }lo fg}kaf gpo
7; jkekfh rubl blgeeofhor& [au bgffa} mof{ dumho gj}op dumho
0> gj}op dumho gee azop }lo fg}kaf }lokp pkhl} }a bafmub}
07 }pkge xk}l gmikrrk`eo ozkmofbo&
00 Jap }lkr baup} fa} }a geeax k}% k} xauem `o gf
02 a`r}pub}kaf aj dur}kbo& Fa} geeaxkfh g dumho kf Hoaphkg
0= ap gf{ a}lop r}g}o }a rooc gmikrrk`eo ozkmofbo& ]lo ba~{
0? xgr ~pazkmom& Gee xo(po grckfh kr }a roo }lo apkhkfge jap
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
28/32
0:&72% o}b&
7 k} }a `o rlaxf g} }pkge& ]lkr kr g pau}kfo ig}}op& Kj k}
0 xauem lgzo `oof }lo `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o aj @gpgbc A`gig%
2 gf{`am{ oero% k} xauem lgzo `oof pau}kfoe{ hkzof ~pa`g`e{
= `{ }lo beopc& K ~pa`g`e{ xauemf(} `o r}gfmkfh kf jpaf} aj
? [aup Lafap&
: ]lkr kr g`urkzo gfm a~~porrkzo jap
8 Ir& Fghgikfo }a rooc rgfb}kafr ghgkfr} io& Jap xlg}1
< Xlg} kr afo }lkfh }lg} kr rgfb}kafg`eo1 Xlg} kr afo }lkfh
; }lg} kr jpkzaeaur }lg} K lgzo mafo1 Fa}lkfh& K(i grckfh
7> {au }a ofjapbo }lo ru`~aofg gbbapmkfh }a {aup axf pueor&
77 K} kr rgfb}kafg`eo% a~~porrkzo gfm g`urkzo
70 moigfm jap rgfb}kafr }lg} K(zo roof lopo baikfh jpai
72 Ir& Fghgikfo gfm Ajjkbo aj }lo G}}apfo{ Hofopge aj
7= Lgxgk(k& [aup Lafap% kj }lkr kr fa} hpgf}om% k}(r fa}
7? hakfh }a ofm lopo% k} xkee ha }a }lo lkhlop baup}r& K}
7: xkee ha }a }lo Fkf}l Bkpbuk}&
78 G} gf{ pg}o% }lopo xgr fozop g bgro xlopo }lo
7< Fkf}l Bkpbuk} ap gf{ a}lop bkpbuk} ap }lo Ru~poio Baup}% g
7; baup} jaufm }lg} afo baup}% afo r}g}o lgr g pkhl} }a
0> a`r}pub} dur}kbo gfm mof{ gee }lo baup}r gpaufm }lo fg}kaf
07 g pkhl} }a a`}gkf ozkmofbo% gmikrrk`eo ozkmofbo&
00 K(i fa} grckfh jap gf{}lkfh }lg}(r keeohge&
02 K(i fa} grckfh jap gf{}lkfh }lg}(r ufo}lkbge& K(i grckfh
0= jap raio}lkfh }lg} kr pau}kfo& K(i grckfh [aup Lafap fa}
0? }a a`r}pub} dur}kbo% fa} }a `o ~gp} aj }lkr bpkikfge
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
29/32
0;^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 bazop)u~ }lg} xo(po rookfh jpai Ir& Fghgikfo gfm
0 Ir& Jumm{&
2 Gfm gee k} kr K(i dur} grckfh% ~eogro% K(i
= grckfh }lkr Baup} fa} }a a`r}pub} dur}kbo gfm geeax Dumho
? Igeklk ap a}lop dumhor }a lgzo gbborr }a ozkmofbo& Kj
: rlo )) kj Ir& Fghgikfo kr pojurkfh )) kr pojurkfh }a
8 bai~e{% rlo foomr }a jkeo g ia}kaf }a wugrl& ]lkr kr }lo
< ~pa~op poiom{ kf }lkr bgro% [aup Lafap& ]lgfc {au&
; ]LO BA_P]4 Gf{}lkfh kf por~afro1 Rlap}
7> po~e{&
77 IR& FGHGIKFO4 K dur} lgzo afo ~akf}% [aup
70 Lafap& Ir& ]gk}t dur} rgkm }lg} kj }lkr xopo gf{ a}lop
72 `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o }lgf }lo ^porkmof}(r xo xauem lgzo
7= }upfom k} azop g} afbo& ]lg} kr kfbafrkr}of} xk}l xlg}
7? rlo loproej rgkm g`au} }lo Zkphkfkg Rufglgpg `kp}l
7: bop}kjkbg}o&
78 ]lo Mo~gp}iof} aj Loge}l krf(} }upfkfh azop
7< }lo Zkphkfkg Rufglgpg `kp}l bop}kjkbg}o ap Dalf Mao ap
7; Dgfo Rik}l ap gf{ a}lop zk}ge pobapm% xo(po ~pa}ob}kfh gee
0> aj aup zk}ge pobapmr kf gmmk}kaf }a ^porkmof} A`gig(r
07 zk}ge pobapmr& K}(r gee aj aup zk}ge pobapmr& Gfm }lg}(r
00 }lo ~akf} }lg} xo(po makfh kf gee aj }loro bgror&
02 22
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
30/32
2>^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 ma xk}l }lo bafjkmof}kgek}{ gfm }lo ~pa}ob}kaf aj zk}ge
0 pobapmr&
2 K maf(} cfax }lg} k}(r }puo }lg} }laurgfmr aj
= dumhor ozop{ mg{ gpo ofjapbkfh a}lop r}g}o(r ru`~aofg&
? K(m ekco }a roo Ir& ]gk}t bk}o afo o|gi~eo pg}lop }lgf
: begki }lg} }lopo gpo }laurgfmr aj o|gi~eor& K(m ekco }a
8 roo afo&
< @u} kf }lkr bgro% Hoaphkg egx kr zop{ beogp
; }lg} }lo ~egbo }a ofjapbo g Hoaphkg ru`~aofg kr g} }lo
7> Hoaphkg Ru~opkap Baup} eozoe& K} kr fa} lopo g} }lo
77 Lgxgk(k Bkpbuk} Baup}& ]lgfc {au% [aup Lafap&
70 ]LO BA_P]4 Ir& ]gk}t lgr `pauhl} }lkr ia}kaf
72 ~uprugf} }a Lgxgk(k Pueor aj Bkzke ^pabomupo Pueo =?% }lg}
7= kr }lo pueo }lg} rlo kr bk}kfh }a& Pueo =? r~obkjkbgee{
7? r}g}or jap g}}ofmgfbo aj xk}forr(r japi krrugfbo% ozop{
7: ru`~aofg rlgee `o krruom `{ }lo beopc aj }lo bkpbuk} baup}
78 aj }lo bkpbuk} kf xlkbl }lo gb}kaf kr ~ofmkfh% fa} kf
7< xlkbl }lo gb}kaf kr ~ofmkfh kf gfa}lop dupkrmkb}kaf&
7; Jap pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof} }a `o
0> pobahfktom xo foom }a lgzo }lg} ~gp}kbuegp egfhugho xlkbl
07 xauem geeax }lo pobk~pabge ofjapboiof} }lg} Ir& ]gk}t kr
00 roockfh& ]lg} egfhugho kr fa} baf}gkfom kf Pueo =?&
02 _fmop Pueo =? k} gera pojopofbor Pueo 2> gfm
0= Pueo 27& Egfhugho gera kr fa} baf}gkfom }lopokf xk}l
0? por~ob} }a gf{ pobk~pabge ru`~aofg ofjapboiof}% }lopojapo%
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
31/32
27^OPIKRRKAF ]A BA^[ MOFKOM% LPR :>:&72% o}b&
7 }lo ia}kaf kr `okfh mofkom&
0 Ir& Fghgikfo% ~po~gpo }lo apmop&
2 IR& FGHGIKFO4 ]lgfc {au% [aup Lafap& Xauem
= }lo Baup} ekco }lo apmop jpai egr} Jpkmg{ fax1
? IR& ]GK]T4 K xgrf(} ropzom xk}l }lkr&
: ]LO BA_P]4 Acg{& Xoee% jaeeax }lo ~pa~op
8 ~pa}abae% K(i grruikfh ufmop Pueo 02&
< IR& FGHGIKFO4 ]lgfc {au% [aup Lafap&
; ]LO @GKEKJJ4 Gee pkro% baup} kr kf poborr&
7> ,^paboomkfhr bafbeumom&+
77 ))aaAaa))
70
72
7=
7?
7:
78
7
07
00
02
0=
0?
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]R]G]O AJ LGXGK(K
8/3/2019 TAITZ v FUDDY - Certified Transcript of 1-13-12 Hearing 11-1731fb
32/32
20
7
0 R]G]O AJ LGXGKK +
2 BK][ GFM BA_F][ AJ LAFAE_E_ +
= QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ+
?
:
8 K% IGPK)DA MGZKMRAF% P^P% BRP 22;% gf Ajjkbkge Baup}
< Po~ap}op kf }lo Jkpr} Bkpbuk} Baup}% R}g}o aj Lgxgk(k% ma
; lopo`{ bop}kj{ }lg} }lo japohakfh ~ghor 7 ) 20 bai~pkro
7> g juee% }puo gfm bappob} }pgfrbpk~}kaf aj }lo ~paboomkfhr
77 lgm kf }lo g`azo)of}k}eom bguro% ra }gcof gfm }pgfrbpk`om
70 `{ io }a }lo `or} aj i{ g`kek}{&
72
7=
7? Mg}om }lkr 7?}l mg{ aj Dgfugp{% 0>70&
7:
78 AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OP
7 !R! Igpk)Da MgzkmrafIGPK)DA MGZKMRAF% P^P% BRP 22;
07
00
02
0=
0?
AJJKBKGE BA_P] PO^AP]OPJKPR] BKPB_K] BA_P]