77
Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Tackling the search forLepton Flavor Violation

with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip

Stefan RittPaul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Page 2: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 2

Agenda

DRS2DRS2

DRS3DRS3

DRS1DRS1MEG Experiment searchingfor e down to 10-13

MEG Experiment searchingfor e down to 10-13

Page 3: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Motivation

Why should we search for e ?

Page 4: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 4

The Standard Model

Fermions (Matter)

Quarks

uup

ccharm

ttop

ddown

sstrange

bbottom

Lepto

ns

eelectronneutrino

muon

neutrino

tau

neutrino

eelectron

muon

tau

Bosons

photon

Force

carrie

rs

ggluon

WW boson

ZZ boson

Higgs*

boson

*) Yet to be confirmedGeneration I II III

Page 5: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 5

The success of the SM

• The SM has been proven to be extremely successful since 1970’s

• Simplicity (6 quarks explain >40 mesons and baryons)

• Explains all interactions in current accelerator particle physics

• Predicted many particles (most prominent W, Z )

• Limitations of the SM

• Currently contains 19 (+10) free parameters such as particle (neutrino) masses

• Does not explain cosmological observation such as Dark Matter and Matter/Antimatter Asymmetry

CDF

Today’s goal is to look for physics beyond the standard

model

Today’s goal is to look for physics beyond the standard

model

Page 6: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 6

Beyond the SM

Find New PhysicsBeyond the SM

High Energy Frontier

• Produce heavy new particles directly• Heavy particles need large colliders• Complex detectors

High Precision Frontier

• Look for small deviations from SM (g-2) , CKM unitarity

• Look for forbidden decays• Requires high precision at low energy

Page 7: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 7

•Discovery: 1936 in cosmic radiation

•Mass: 105 MeV/c2

•Mean lifetime: 2.2 s

The MuonSeth Neddermeyer

Carl Anderson

e

-

W-e-

e

e

e

e

e ≈ 100%

0.014

< 10-11

led to Lepton Flavor Conservationas “accidental” symmetry

Page 8: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 8

LFV and Neutrino Oscillations

Neutrino Oscillations Neutrino mass e possible even in the SM

W-

ee-

SM

604

4B 10R( )

W

em

m

LFV in the charged sector is forbidden in the Standard Model

LFV in the charged sector is forbidden in the Standard Model

mixing

Page 9: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 9

LFV in SUSY

• While LFV is forbidden in SM, it is possible in SUSY

W-

ee-

e-0~

~e~

SM

604

4B 10R( )

W

em

m

SUSYBR( )e

4

5 2

SUS2

Y

2100 GeV

10 tanem

mm

≈ 10-12

Current experimental limit: BR( e ) < 10-11Current experimental limit: BR( e ) < 10-11

2~~em

Page 10: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 10

History of LFV searches

• Long history dating back to 1947!

• Best present limits:

• 1.2 x 10-11 (MEGA)

• Ti → eTi < 7 x 10-13 (SINDRUM II)

• → eee < 1 x 10-12 (SINDRUM II)

• MEG Experiment aims at 10-13

• Improvements linked to advancein technology

1940 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010

10-1

10-2

10-3

10-4

10-5

10-6

10-7

10-6

10-9

10-10

10-11

10-12

10-13

10-14

10-15

→ e → eA → eee

MEG

SUSY SU(5)

BR( e ) = 10-13

Ti eTi = 4x10-16

BR( eee) = 6x10-16

SUSY SU(5)

BR( e ) = 10-13

Ti eTi = 4x10-16

BR( eee) = 6x10-16

cosmic

stopped

beams

stopped

Page 11: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 11

Current SUSY predictions

“Supersymmetric parameterspace accessible by

LHC”

“Supersymmetric parameterspace accessible by

LHC”

W. Buchmueller, DESY, priv. comm.

current limit

MEG goal

1) J. Hisano et al., Phys. Lett. B391 (1997) 3412) MEGA collaboration, hep-ex/9905013

ft(M)=2.4 >0 Ml=50GeV 1)

tan

Page 12: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Experimental Method

How to detect e ?

Page 13: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 13

Decay topology e

e

e

180º

→ e signal very clean• Eg = Ee = 52.8 MeV• e = 180º• e and in time

52.8 MeV

52.8 MeV

10 20 30 40 50 60 E[MeV]

N

52.8 MeV

10 20 30 40 50 60 Ee[MeV]

N

52.8 MeV

Page 14: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 14

“Accidental” Background

e

e

180º

→ e signal very clean• Eg = Ee = 52.8 MeV• e = 180º• e and in time

e

e

e

e

Annihilationin flight

Background

Good energy resolutionGood spatial resolution

Excellent timing resolutionGood pile-up rejection

Page 15: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 15

Previous Experiments

Exp./Lab

Author Year Ee/Ee

%FWHM

E/E

%FWHM

te

(ns)

e

(mrad)

Inst. Stop rate (s-1)

Duty cycle (%)

Result

SIN (PSI)

A. Van der Schaaf

1977 8.7 9.3 1.4 - (4..6) x 105 100 < 1.0 10-9

TRIUMFP.

Depommier1977 10 8.7 6.7 - 2 x 105 100 < 3.6 10-9

LANLW.W.

Kinnison1979 8.8 8 1.9 37 2.4 x 105 6.4 < 1.7 10-10

Crystal Box

R.D. Bolton 1986 8 8 1.3 87 4 x 105 (6..9) < 4.9 10-11

MEGA M.L. Brooks 1999 1.2 4.5 1.6 17 2.5 x 108 (6..7) < 1.2 10-11

MEG ? ? ? ? ? ? ~ 10-13

How can we achieve a quantum step in detector technology?How can we achieve a quantum step in detector technology?

Page 16: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 16

Collaboration

~70 People (40 FTEs) from five countries

Page 17: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 17

Paul Scherrer Institute

Swiss Light Source

Proton Accelerator

Page 18: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 18

PSI Proton Accelerator

Page 19: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 19

MEG beam line

+

R ~ 1.1x108 +/s at experiment

~ 10.9 mm ~ 10.9 mm

e+

+

Page 20: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 20

Liquid Xenon Calorimeter

• Calorimeter: Measure Energy, Positionand Time through scintillation light only

• Liquid Xenon has high Z and homogeneity

• ~900 l (3t) Xenon with 848 PMTs(quartz window, immersed)

• Cryogenics required: -120°C … -108°

• Extremely high purity necessary:1 ppm H20 absorbs 90% of light

• Currently largest LXe detector in theworld: Lots of pioneering work necessary

Liq. Xe

H.V.

Vacuum

for thermal insulation

Al Honeycombwindow

PMT

Refrigerator

Cooling pipe

Signals

fillerPlastic

1.5m

Page 21: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 21

• Use GEANT to carefully study detector

• Optimize placement of PMTs according to MC results

Page 22: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 22

The complete MEG detector

1m

e+

Liq. Xe Scin tilla tionDetector

Drift Cham ber

Liq. Xe Scin tilla tionDetector

e+

Tim ing Counter

Stopping TargetThin S uperconducting Coil

M uon Beam

Drift Cham ber

Page 23: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 23

Current resolution estimates

Exp./Lab

Author Year Ee/Ee

%FWHM

E/E

%FWHM

te

(ns)

e

(mrad)

Inst. Stop rate (s-1)

Duty cycle (%)

Result

SIN (PSI)

A. Van der Schaaf

1977 8.7 9.3 1.4 - (4..6) x 105 100 < 1.0 10-9

TRIUMFP.

Depommier1977 10 8.7 6.7 - 2 x 105 100 < 3.6 10-9

LANLW.W.

Kinnison1979 8.8 8 1.9 37 2.4 x 105 6.4 < 1.7 10-10

Crystal Box

R.D. Bolton 1986 8 8 1.3 87 4 x 105 (6..9) < 4.9 10-11

MEGA M.L. Brooks 1999 1.2 4.5 1.6 17 2.5 x 108 (6..7) < 1.2 10-11

MEG 2008 0.8 4.3 0.18 18 3 x 107 100 ~ 10-13

Page 24: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 24

MEG Current Status

• Goal: Produce “significant” result before LHC

• R & D phase took longer than anticipated

• Detector has been completed by theend of 2007

• Expected sensitivity in 2008: 2 x 10-12

(current limit: 1 x 10-11)

R&D

199920002001200220032004200520062007200820092010

Engineering

DataTaking

Set-up

http://meg.psi.chhttp://meg.psi.ch

Page 25: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 25

Pile-up in the DC system

• Pile-up can severely degrade the experiment performance ( MEGA Experiment) !

• Traditional electronics cannot detect pile-up

TDC

Amplifier Discriminator Measure Time

Need fullwaveform digitization

> 100 MHz to reject pile-up

Need fullwaveform digitization

> 100 MHz to reject pile-up

Moving average baseline

hit

s

Page 26: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 26

Beam induced background

108 /s produce 108 e+/s produce 108 /s

Cable ductsfor Drift Chamber

Page 27: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 27

Pile-up in the LXe calorimeter

n

E[MeV]50 51 52

e

radiativemuondecay

t

PMTsum

e

(e)2 +

e

51.5 MeV

0.511 MeV

• ’s hitting different parts of LXe can be separated if > 2 PMTs apart (15 cm)

• Timely separated ’s need waveform digitizing > 300 MHz

• If waveform digitizing gives timing <100ps, no TDCs are needed

• ’s hitting different parts of LXe can be separated if > 2 PMTs apart (15 cm)

• Timely separated ’s need waveform digitizing > 300 MHz

• If waveform digitizing gives timing <100ps, no TDCs are needed

~100ns

Page 28: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 28

• Need 500 MHz 12 bit digitization for Drift Chamber system

• Need 2 GHz 12 bit digitization for Xenon Calorimeter + Timing Counters

• Need 3000 Channels

• At affordable price

Requirements summary

Solution: Develop own“Switched Capacitor Array” Chip

Solution: Develop own“Switched Capacitor Array” Chip

Page 29: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 29

The Domino Principle

Shift RegisterClock

IN

Out

“Time stretcher” GHz MHz“Time stretcher” GHz MHz

Waveform stored

Inverter “Domino” ring chain0.2-2 ns

FADC 33 MHz

Keep Domino wave running in a circular fashion and stop by trigger Domino Ring Sampler (DRS)

Keep Domino wave running in a circular fashion and stop by trigger Domino Ring Sampler (DRS)

Page 30: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 30

Switched Capacitor Array

•Cons

• No continuous acquisition

• No precise timing

• External (commercial) FADC needed

•Pros

• High speed (~5 GHz) high resolution (~12 bit equiv.)

• High channel density (12 channels on 5x5 mm2)

• Low power (10 mW / channel)

• Low cost (< 100$ / channel incl. VME board)

t t t t t

Page 31: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 31

Folded Layout

Linear inverter chain causes non-linearity

Page 32: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 32

“Tail Biting”

enable

1 2 3 4

1

2

3

4

speed

Page 33: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 33

Sample readout

0.2 pF 20 pF

DRS1DRS1Tiny signal

TemperatureDependence

~kT

DRS2DRS2I

DRS3DRS3

Page 34: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 34

DRS3

• Fabricated in 0.25 m 1P5M MMC process(UMC), 5 x 5 mm2, radiation hard

• 12 ch. each 1024 bins,6 ch. 2048, …, 1 ch. 12288

• Sampling speed 10 MHz … 5 GHz

• Readout speed 33 MHz, multiplexedor in parallel

• 50 prototypes receivedin July ‘06

CHANNEL 0IN0+IN0-

CHANNEL 1IN1+IN1-

CHANNEL 2IN2+IN2-

CHANNEL 3IN3+IN3-

CHANNEL 4IN4+IN4-

CHANNEL 5IN5+IN5-

CHANNEL 6IN6+IN6-

CHANNEL 7IN7+IN7-

CHANNEL 8IN8+IN8-

CHANNEL 9IN9+IN9-

CHANNEL 10IN10+IN10-

CHANNEL 11

STOP SH IFT REGISTER

READ SHIFT REGISTER

IN11+IN11-

W SRCLKSRIN

W SRO UTSRLO AD

RSRLO AD

WR

ITE

SH

IFT

RE

GIS

TE

R

DENABLEDW R ITEDSPEEDDM ODE

DO MINO WAVE CIR CUIT

DG ND

AGND

DVDD

AVDD

DTAP A0 A1 A2 A3

M UX

EN

AB

LE

M UXOUT /OU T0

OU T1

OU T2

OU T3

OU T4

OU T5

OU T6

OU T7

OU T8

OU T9

OU T10

OU T11

BIAS

RO FS

SSROUT

RSRCLKRSRRST

RSROU T

Page 35: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 35

VME Board3

2 c

han

nels

in

pu

t

General purpose VPC board built at PSIGeneral purpose VPC board built at PSI

40 MHz 12 bit FADC USB adapter

board

USB adapterboard

Page 36: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 36

Bandwidth + Linearity

Readout chain shows excellent linearity from 0.1V … 1.1V @ 33 MHz readout

Analog Bandwidth is currently limited by high resistance of on-chip signal bus, will be increased significantly with DRS4

AM

PL

ITU

E [

dB

]

FREQUENCY [MHz]1 10 100

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6

-5

-4

-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

AM

PL

ITU

E [

dB

]

FREQUENCY [MHz]1 10 100

-10

-9

-8

-7

-6

-5

-4

-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

450 MHz (-3dB)NO

NL

INE

AR

ITY

[m

V]

ANALOG OUTPUT [V]

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2-2

-1

0

1

2

ROFS = 0.95 VBIAS = 0.70 V

NO

NL

INE

AR

ITY

[m

V]

ANALOG OUTPUT [V]

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2-2

-1

0

1

2

ROFS = 0.95 VBIAS = 0.70 V

0.5 mV max.

Page 37: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 37

Signal-to-noise ratio

“Fixed pattern” offset error of 5 mV RMScan be reduced to 0.35 mV by offsetcorrection in FPGA

SNR:

1 V linear range / 0.35 mV = 69 dB (11.5 bits)

“Fixed pattern” offset error of 5 mV RMScan be reduced to 0.35 mV by offsetcorrection in FPGA

SNR:

1 V linear range / 0.35 mV = 69 dB (11.5 bits)

AN

AL

OG

OU

TP

UT

[V

]

BIN NUMBER0 200 400 600 800 1000

0.48

0.49

0.5

0.51

0.52

Crosstalk from trigger signal

OC

CU

RE

NC

E

OUTPUT VOLTAGE [V]0.48 0.49 0.5 0.51 0.520

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

OC

CU

RE

NC

E

OUTPUT VOLTAGE [V]0.48 0.49 0.5 0.51 0.520

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180

200

OffsetCorrection

Page 38: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 38

12 bit resolutionW

AV

EF

OR

M [

V]

TIME [ns]0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

11.5 bits effective resolution <8 bits effective resolution

Page 39: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 39

Sampling speed

PLL

ReferenceClock (1-4 MHz)

Vspeed

~200 psec~200 psec

• Unstabilized jitter: ~70ps / turn

• Temperature coefficient: 500ps / ºC

• Unstabilized jitter: ~70ps / turn

• Temperature coefficient: 500ps / ºC

f SA

MP[G

Hz]

DSPEED [V]0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

30°C

50°C

R. Paoletti, N. Turini, R. Pegna, MAGIC collaborationR. Paoletti, N. Turini, R. Pegna, MAGIC collaboration

Page 40: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 40

How far can we go?

• Maximal sampling speed with current technologies

• DRS4: 5.5 GHz in favor of linearity and flexibility

• 0.250 m technology maximum: 8 GHz

• 0.130 m technology maximum: 15 GHz

• Timing in O(10ps) region is tough

• Sampling has to be close to source (cable effect)

• TDCs can work in this region (vernier method), but what about discriminator?

• Probably only possible with analog sampling

threshold level

firstelectrons

noise timing jitter

Page 41: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 41

Timing Reference

signal

20 MHz Reference clock

PMT hit

Domino stops aftertrigger latency

8 inp

uts

shift registerReference

clock

domino wave

MUX

• Calibrate inter-cell t’s for each chip• 200 ps uncertainty using PLL• 25 ps uncertainty for timing relative to edge

• Calibrate inter-cell t’s for each chip• 200 ps uncertainty using PLL• 25 ps uncertainty for timing relative to edge

Page 42: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 42

What timing can be obtained?

• Detailed studies by G. Varner1) for LAB3 chip

• Bin-by-bin calibration using a 500 MHz sine wave

• Accuracy after calibration: 20 ps

• Detailed studies by G. Varner1) for LAB3 chip

• Bin-by-bin calibration using a 500 MHz sine wave

• Accuracy after calibration: 20 ps

1) G. Varner et al., Nucl.Instrum.Meth. A583, 447 (2007)

1ns

Page 43: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 43

On-chip PLL

PLL

ReferenceClock

fclk = fsamp / 2048

Vspeed

• On-chip PLL should show smaller phase jitter• If <100ps, no clock calibration required

• On-chip PLL should show smaller phase jitter• If <100ps, no clock calibration required

loop

filt

er

DRS4

Simulation:

Page 44: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 44

Comparison with other chipsMATACQ

D. BretonLABRADORG. Varner

DRS3

Bandwidth (-3db) 300 MHz > 1000 MHz 450 MHz

Sampling frequency

1 or 2 GHz 10 MHz … 3.5 GHz

10 MHz … 5 GHz

Full scale range ±0.5 V +0.4 …2.1 V +0.1 … 1.1V

Effective #bits 12 bit 10 bit 12 bit

Sample points 1 x 2520 9 x 256 12 x 1024

Channel per board

4 N/A 32

Digitization 5 MHz N/A 33 MHz

Readout dead time

650 s 150 s 3 s – 370 s

Integral nonlinearity

± 0.1 % ± 0.1 % ± 0.05%

Radiation hard No No Yes (chip)

Board V1729 (CAEN)

- planned (CAEN)

Page 45: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Waveform Analysis

What can we learn from acquired waveforms?

Page 46: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 46

On-line waveform display

click

templatefit

pedestalhisto

848PMTs

“virtual oscilloscope”“virtual oscilloscope”

Page 47: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 47

QT Algorithm

originalwaveform

smoothed anddifferentiated (Difference Of

Samples)Threshold in DOS

Region for pedestal

evaluation

integration area

t• Inspired by H1 Fast Track Trigger (A.

Schnöning, Desy & ETH)

• Difference of Samples (= 1st derivation)

• Hit region defined when DOS is above threshold

• Integration of original signal in hit region

• Pedestal evaluated in region before hit

• Time interpolated using maximum value and two neighbor values in LUT 1ns resolution for 10ns sampling time

• Inspired by H1 Fast Track Trigger (A. Schnöning, Desy & ETH)

• Difference of Samples (= 1st derivation)

• Hit region defined when DOS is above threshold

• Integration of original signal in hit region

• Pedestal evaluated in region before hit

• Time interpolated using maximum value and two neighbor values in LUT 1ns resolution for 10ns sampling time

Page 48: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 48

Pulse shape discrimination

)tt[...]θ.. )tθ(td)/τt(te

/τ)t(te i/τ)t(t

eAV(t)r00

000

CsB

Leading edge Decay time AC-coupling Reflections

Page 49: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 49

-distribution

= 21 ns

= 34 ns

Waveforms can be clearly

distinguished

= 21 ns

= 34 ns

Waveforms can be clearly

distinguished

Page 50: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 50

Coherent noise

i Vi (t)

All PMTs

Pedestal

average

Charge

integration

• Found some coherent low frequency (~MHz) noise

• Energy resolution dramatically improved by properly subtracting the sinusoidal background

• Usage of “dead” channels for baseline estimation

• Found some coherent low frequency (~MHz) noise

• Energy resolution dramatically improved by properly subtracting the sinusoidal background

• Usage of “dead” channels for baseline estimation

Page 51: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 51

Pileup recognition

original

derivative

t = 15ns

E1 E2

T 8ns

T 10ns

T 15ns

T 50ns

T 100ns

21

1

EE

E

MC simulationMC simulation

Rule of thumb: Pileup can be detected if T ~ rise-time of signalsRule of thumb: Pileup can be detected if T ~ rise-time of signals

Page 52: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 52

Crosstalk elimination

Crosstalk removal by subtracting empty channelCrosstalk removal by subtracting empty channel

Hit Hit

subtract

Page 53: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 53

Spurious Noise Problem

• Found “sometimes” a high frequency“ring” on all channels

• 40 MHz, ~20 mV, 1kHz repetition

• Finally identified the liquid xenonpump as the source

• This noise can screw up timingfor rare events

• Without waveform digitizing, thiswould have been very hard todebug

Page 54: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 54

Template Fit

• Determine “standard” PMT pulse by averaging over many events “Template”

• Find hit in waveform

• Shift (“TDC”) and scale (“ADC”)template to hit

• Minimize 2

• Compare fit with waveform

• Repeat if above threshold

• Store ADC & TDC values

Experiment500 MHz sampling

Page 55: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 55

High pass filtering

originalwaveform

template fit

after optimized high pass FIR filter

integrationarea

• Get rid ofbaseline (lowfrequency)noise

• Improveresolutionsignificantly

• Get rid ofbaseline (lowfrequency)noise

• Improveresolutionsignificantly

Page 56: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 56

Lat

ch

Lat

ch

Lat

ch

Lat

ch

Lat

ch

Baseline Subtraction

BaselineSubtraction

Lat

ch

12 bit

100 MHz Clock

-+

<thr

+

-

BaselineRegister

Baselinesubtracted

signal LUT12x12

Calibrated and

linearized signal

Page 57: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 57

Lat

ch

Lat

ch

Lat

ch

Lat

ch

Constant Fraction Discr.

Lat

ch

12 bit

Clock

+

+

MULT

Lat

ch

0

&<0

Delayedsignal

Invertedsignal

Sum

Page 58: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 58

Data Reduction

• Zero suppression: hit if max. value > n x (baseline)

• Readout window: start / width in respect to trigger

• Pile-up flag: Zero-crossings of first derivation

• Re-binning 4:1, 8:1, 16:1

• ADC: Numerical integral of hit over baseline

• TDC: Only simple threshold (usable to recognize accidentals) and time-over-threshold

MEG: Applying to 94% of 100 Hz dataKeeping only 6 Hz of waveformsMEG: Applying to 94% of 100 Hz dataKeeping only 6 Hz of waveforms

TOT

0.5 ns bins 4 ns bins

Page 59: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 59

Huffman encoding

Diff Bin. Code

-1 00

0 01

1 10

2 11

Diff Bin. Code

0 01

1 10

0 01

-1 00

1 10

0 01

0 01

-1 00

0 01

0 01

0

1

-1

2

0.6

0.2

0.2

00.2

0.4

1

0

1

10

11

110

111

20 16

Huffman

110

0

10

111

Huffman

0

10

0

110

10

0

0

110

0

0

-10

-5

0

5

10

15

1

signal

diff

Page 60: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 60

Where to perform waveform analysis?

• Switching from ADC/TDC to ~GHz waveform digitization increases amount of data by ~1000x

• Many algorithms suitable for on-board (FPGA) processing

• Charge integration and time estimation (“QT”)

• Zero-suppression, re-binning, Huffman encoding

• Basic pile-up recognition (zero-crossings of derivative)

• Algorithms for embedded CPUs or PC farms

• Inter-channel cross-talk removal

• Template fit (floating point)

DRS FPGAFrontEndPC

Off-line Analysis

Page 61: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 61

DAQ System Principle

Active Splitter

Drift Chamber Liquid Xenon Calorimeter Timing Counter

WaveformDigitizing

Trigger

TriggerEvent number

Event type

Busy

Rack PC

Rack PC

Rack PC

Rack PC

Rack PC

opticallink

(SIS3100)

Rack PC

Rack PC

Rack PC

Rack PC

Event Builder

Switch

GBit Ethernet

LVDS parallel bus

VME VME

Page 62: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 62

Multi-threading model

VMETransferThread

CalibrationThread

CalibrationThread

CalibrationThread

CalibrationThread

CollectorThread

VME

Round-Robindistribution

Network

Zero-copy ring

buffers

Zero-copy ring

buffers

Page 63: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 63

Optimal rate with 4 calibration threads

Page 64: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 64

DAQ System

• Use waveform digitization (500 MHz/2 GHz) on all channels

• Waveform pre-analysis directly in online cluster (zero suppression, calibration) using multi-threading

• MIDAS DAQ Software

• Data reduction: 900 MB/s 5 MB/s

• Data amount: 100 TB/year

• Use waveform digitization (500 MHz/2 GHz) on all channels

• Waveform pre-analysis directly in online cluster (zero suppression, calibration) using multi-threading

• MIDAS DAQ Software

• Data reduction: 900 MB/s 5 MB/s

• Data amount: 100 TB/year

2000 channelswaveform digitizing

DAQ cluster

Page 65: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Advanced Topics

Reduced dead time, integrated triggering

Page 66: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 66

“Residual charge” problem

R

“Ghost pulse”2% @ 2 GHz

“Ghost pulse”2% @ 2 GHz

After sampling a pulse, some residual charge remains in the capacitors on the next turn and can mimic wrong pulses

After sampling a pulse, some residual charge remains in the capacitors on the next turn and can mimic wrong pulsesSolution: Clear before write

write clearImplemented

in DRS4

Implementedin DRS4

Page 67: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 67

ROI readout mode

readout shift register

Triggerstop

normal trigger stop after latency

Delay

delayed trigger stop

Patent pending!

33 MHz

e.g. 100 samples @ 33 MHz 3 us dead time

(2.5 ns / sample @ 12 channels)

e.g. 100 samples @ 33 MHz 3 us dead time

(2.5 ns / sample @ 12 channels)

Page 68: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 68

Daisy-chaining of channels

Channel 0 – 1024 cells

Channel 1 – 1024 cells

Channel 2 – 1024 cells

Channel 3 – 1024 cells

Channel 4 – 1024 cells

Channel 5 – 1024 cells

Channel 6 – 1024 cells

Channel 7 – 1024 cells

Domino Wave Generation

DRS4 can be partitioned in: 8x1024, 4x2048, 2x4096, 1x8192 cells

DRS4 can be partitioned in: 8x1024, 4x2048, 2x4096, 1x8192 cells

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Page 69: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 69

Interleaved samplingdela

ys

(200p

s/8 =

25ps)

G. Varner et al., Nucl.Instrum.Meth. A583, 447 (2007)G. Varner et al., Nucl.Instrum.Meth. A583, 447 (2007)

5 GSPS * 8 = 40 GSPS

Page 70: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 70

“Almost” Dead time free system

CMC1

CMC232

ch

an

nel

16

ch

an

nel

MUX

VME board

One board is active while other board is read outOne board is active while other board is read out

Page 71: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 71

DRS4 packaging

6 4 -L ea d L Q F P

6 4 -L ea d Q F N

17

64

18

63

19

62

20

61

21

60

22

59

23

58

24

57

25

56

26

55

27

54

28

53

29

52

30

51

31

50

32

49

3316

3415

3514

3613

3712

3811

3910

409

418

427

436

445

454

463

472

481

DRS3TOP VIEW

(N ot to Scale)

PIN 1

DR S3TO P VIEW

(Not to Scale)

PIN 1

P IN C O N F IG U R AT IO N

A 0

A 0

IN8+

IN 8+

A 1

A 1

IN8-

IN 8-A 2

A 2

IN7+

IN 7+A 3A 3

IN7-IN 7-OU T11 OU T 11IN6+IN 6+

OU T10 OU T 1 0IN6- IN 6-

OU T9OU T 9

IN5+IN 5+

OU T8OU T 8

IN5-IN 5-

OU T7

OU T 7

IN4+

IN 4+

OU T6

OU T 6

IN4-

IN 4-

OU T5

OU T 5

IN3+

IN 3+

OU T4

OU T 4

IN3-

IN 3-

OU T3

OU T 3

IN2+

IN 2+

OU T2

OU T 2

IN2-

IN 2-

OU T1

OU T 1

IN1+

IN 1+

IN1-

IN 1-

DG

ND

DV

DD

DTA

P

DS

PE

ED

DW

RIT

E

DE

NA

BL

E

DM

OD

E

RO

FS

IN11

+

IN11

-

IN1

0+

IN1

0-

IN9

+

IN9

-

DV

DD

DG

ND

DG

ND

DV

DD

DTA

PD

SP

EE

DD

WR

ITE

DE

NA

BL

ED

MO

DE

RO

FS

IN11

+IN

11-

IN10

+IN

10-

IN9+

IN9-

DV

DD

DG

ND

M UXOUT/OU T0

MU X O UT/OU T 0

AG

ND

AG

ND

AV

DD

AV

DD

BIA

S

BIA

S

SR

IN

SR

IN

RS

RL

OA

D

RS

RL

OA

D

RS

RC

LK

RS

RC

LK

RS

RO

UT

RS

RO

UT

RS

RR

ST

RS

RR

ST

SS

RL

OA

D

SS

RLO

AD

SS

RO

UT

SS

RO

UT

WS

RC

LK

WS

RC

LK

WS

RO

UT

WS

RO

UT

IN0-

IN0-

IN0+

IN0+

AV

DD

AV

DD

AG

ND

AG

ND

DRS3 DRS4

9 mm

18 mm

5 mm

DRS4flip-chip

Page 72: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 72

New generation of FADCs

• 8 simultaneous flash ADCs on one chip

• Requiredifferentialinput

• DRS4 has beenredesigned withdifferentialoutput

Page 73: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 73

Trigger an DAQ on same board

• Using a multiplexer, input signals can simultaneously digitized at 65 MHz and sampled in the DRS

• FPGA can make local trigger(or global one) and stop DRSupon a trigger

• DRS readout (5 GHz samples)though same 8-channel FADCs

• Multiplexer will be included in DRS4

an

alo

g fro

nt e

nd

DRSFADC12 bit

65 MHzM

UX FPGA

trigger

LVDS

SRAM

DRS4

glo

bal tr

igger

bu

s

No splitter (signal quality!), no dedicated trigger boards, no dedicated scalersNo splitter (signal quality!), no dedicated trigger boards, no dedicated scalers

Page 74: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 74

“Redefinition of DAQ”

Because of the high channel density of the DRS system, it becomes affordable to use waveform digitizing in experiments which today use

ADC/TCDs

Because of the high channel density of the DRS system, it becomes affordable to use waveform digitizing in experiments which today use

ADC/TCDs

Conventional New

AC coupling Baseline subtraction

Const. Fract. Discriminator DOS – Zero crossing

ADC Numerical Integration

TDCBin interpolation (LUT)

Waveform Fitting

Scaler (250 MHz) Scaler (50 MHz)

Oscilloscope Waveform sampling

400 $ / channel 100 $ / channel

TDCDisc.

ADC

Scaler

Scope

FADC

FPGA

CPU

DRS ~GHz

~100MHz

Page 75: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 75

Availability

• DRS4 will become available in larger quantities in summer ’08

• Chip can be obtained from PSI on a “non-profit” basis

• Delivery “as-is”

• Reference design (schematics) from PSI

• Costs ~ 10-15$/channel

• Costs decrease if we find sell more…

• Full VME board can be purchased from CAENprobably end of ’08 with firmware forpeak sensing ADC, QDC, …

• Struck, others, … ?32-channel

65 MHz/12bit digitizer“boosted” by

DRS4 chip to 5 GHz

32-channel 65 MHz/12bit digitizer

“boosted” by DRS4 chip to 5 GHz

Page 76: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 76

Other experiments using DRS

MACE TelescopeIndia

PET scanners

BPM for XFEL@PSI

8 chn.withPGA

Magic Telescope, Canary Islands

Page 77: Tackling the search for Lepton Flavor Violation with GHz waveform digitizing using the DRS chip Stefan Ritt Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland

Feb. 26th, 2008 Fermilab 77

Conclusions

• Switched Capacitor Array techniques has prospects to trigger a quantum step in data acquisition

• The DRS chip has been designed with maximum flexibility and can therefore be used in many applications

• Collaboration on a scientific basis is very welcome

http://midas.psi.ch/drshttp://midas.psi.ch/drs

Datasheets, publications: