33
Building lifetime relationships with our clients and employees. SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL IMPACT OF LANDFILL MINING ON GROUNDWATER QUALITY May 2017 Speaker: William G. Soukup, P.G.

SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Building lifetime relationships with our clients and employees.

SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL IMPACT OF LANDFILL MINING ON GROUNDWATER QUALITY

May 2017

Speaker:

William G. Soukup, P.G.

Page 2: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Presentation Goals

• Understand Risk

• Reduce Risk

• Manage Risk

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 3: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Advantages of Mining MSW

• Gain landfill space

• Remediation of a

poorly-functioning landfill

• Side Benefits • Recovery of soil for reuse as daily cover

• Optional recovery of metals, combustibles, etc.

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 4: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

MSW operational face

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 5: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Trommel Screen Rotating Drum

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 6: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Trommel Rig

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 7: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Potential Downsides of Landfill Mining

• Time and costs

• Exposure to wastes and landfill gas

• Odors

• Impacts to groundwater quality

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 8: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Typical Mining Sequence

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Limited leachate generation on side slopes

No further leachate generation on bottom

MSW

Natural Formation GW Table

Cap

Page 9: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Factors for Leachate Generation

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Moisture Content (MC): the amount of water per unit volume of waste. (% volume/volume)

10 to 20 %

Field Capacity (FC): the moisture holding capacity of waste under gravity drainage. (% volume/volume)

30 to 40 %

Leachate Generation: occurs when moisture content exceeds field capacity

Page 10: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Example Leachate Generation

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Assumed Waste thickness = 27’

1’ 1’

Waste Volume = 27 ft3 = 1 yd3

35 gallons of recharge = 56 inches of precipitation

Up to 30% of recharge due to “channeling”

Page 11: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Groundwater Model Simulation

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

• 80 acres, 50 feet of waste

• Underlying sand; k=50’/d

• Uniform groundwater horizontal gradient

• Leachate generation rate 48 inches per year

• Steep side slopes

• Non-reactive, conservative solute

• Leachate concentration = 100 m/v units

Page 12: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Groundwater Model Simulations

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Simulated operational factors

1. Mining areas (phases) 2. Sequencing phases 3. Steepness of side slopes 4. Mining rate

Metrics used to evaluate results

1. Maximum concentration beneath excavation 2. Maximum concentration at downgradient boundary 3. Total mass-flux at downgradient boundary

Page 13: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Discharge Boundary

Mined Area

Scale:

48’

38’

40’

42’

44’

46’

0’ 2,000’

Model Domain - Single Phase Scenario

Page 14: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations – Single Phase

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

10 years

40 years 30 years

20 years

100

30

1

50+

Page 15: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations - Single Phase

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Source Area Concentration

Discharge Area Concentration

Normalized Total Mass Flux = 100 mass-units

10-year Mining period

0 10 20 years 30 40 50

Page 16: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Three Phase Scenario

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Discharge Boundary

Mined Area

Scale:

48’

38’

40’

42’

44’

46’

0’ 2,000’

Phase 1

Phase 2

Phase 3

Page 17: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations – 3 Phases

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

3.3 years

30 years 10 years

6.6 years

40+

70+

90+

80+

20+

60+

Page 18: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations - 3 Phases

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

10-year Mining period

Source Area Concentration

Discharge Area Concentration

Normalized Total Mass Flux = 32 mass-units

0 10 20 years 30 40 50

Page 19: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

9 Phases (upgradient sequencing)

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Discharge Boundary

Scale:

48’

38’

40’

42’

44’

46’

0’ 2,000’

1 3 2

5

8

6

7

4

9

Page 20: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations – 9 Phases

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

1.1 years

4.4 years 3.3 years

2.2 years

Page 21: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations - 9 Phases upgradient sequencing

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

10-year Mining period

Source Area Concentration

Discharge Area Concentration

Normalized Total Mass Flux = 11 mass-units

0 10 20 years 30 40 50

Page 22: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

9 Phases (downgradient sequencing)

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Discharge Boundary

Scale:

48’

38’

40’

42’

44’

46’

0’ 2,000’

1 3 2

5

8

6

7

4

9

Page 23: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations – 9 Phases downgradient sequencing

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

10-year Mining period

Source Area Concentration

Discharge Area Concentration

Normalized Total Mass Flux = 10 mass-units

0 10 20 years 30 40 50

Page 24: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Steep Sidewalls

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

6% 6%

88%

Page 25: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Shallow Sidewalls

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

33% 33%

33%

Page 26: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

One Phase 3 Phases 9 PhasesUG

9 PhasesDG

9 PhasesShallowSides

9 Phases15 years

Nor

mal

ized

mas

s un

its

Max Conc.

Max Conc.

Total

12 17 10 11

100

Summary of Model Results

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

32

Page 27: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

In-situ Groundwater Sample Collection

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 28: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Validation Sampling Sequence

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 29: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Conclusions

• The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on:

• Size and duration of the open excavation

• Precipitation rate

• Operational modifications that can reduce impacts include:

• Mining in smaller sub-areas

• Reaching waste bottom more quickly

• Keeping side slopes relatively steep

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 30: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Conclusions

• Groundwater travel time is slow allowing early warning of pending groundwater impacts.

• The pro-active evaluation of potential groundwater impacts (through modeling and validation sampling) is a cost effective means of reducing long-term risks.

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Page 31: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Contact Information

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

William G. Soukup, P.G. Cornerstone Environmental Group, LLC

[email protected]

Phone: (845) 695-0202

Cell: (201) 274-6863

Page 32: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations – 9 Phases Shallow Side slopes

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Source Area Concentration

Normalized Total Mass Flux = 15 mass-units

10-year Mining period

Discharge Area Concentration

0 10 20 years 30 40 50

Page 33: SUSTAINABLE LANDFILLING: EVALUATING THE POTENTIAL … SoukupS.pdf · Conclusions • The impact to groundwater quality from landfill mining depends primarily on: •Size and duration

Predicted Concentrations - 9 Phases 15-year Operation

© 2017 Cornerstone. All rights reserved.

Source Area Concentration

Normalized Total Mass Flux = 12 mass-units

15-year Mining period

Discharge Area Concentration

0 10 20 years 30 40 50