l I

~ I I

t l u

Ll

u Li

SURF ACE AND ARCHITECTURAL INVESTIGATIONS OF THE LEON BROWN FARM

AND MENAGERIE, ORLEANS TOWNSHIP, WINNESHIEK COUNTY, row A

Section 16, T99N, RlOW

Prepared for Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission

Courthouse Annex 204 West Broadway

Decorah, Iowa 52101

Prepared by Branden K. Scott

(Principal Investigator)

Bear Creek Archeology, Inc. P.O. Box 347

Cresco, Iowa 52136 David G. Stanley, Director

December 2015

Special Report 5

'PDf

MANAGEMENT SUMMARY

This report presents the results of a surface and architectural investigation at the Leon Brown Farm (96-00761-96-00763) in Orleans Township, Winneshiek County, Iowa. This investigation was completed by Bear Creek Archeology, Inc. of Cresco, Iowa, at the request of the Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission of Decorah, Iowa. Leon Brown was a notable citizen of Winneshiek County and volunteered many years of service to the Winneshiek County Fair Board. Because of his role in shaping the Winneshiek County Fair, the Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission sought to gather background inf01mation on his farm, which also served as a menagerie for a number of years. As Leon Brown was a devoted, compassionate, and influential county citizen, it was decided by the Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission to document aspects of his life and the farm where he lived. This investigation details the known biography of Leon Brown, the history of the farm, the standing extant architectural properties, and architectural resources that have been destroyed. The current farmstead encompasses approximately 6 ha (14.8 ac). There are few plans concerning this property. However, the cement property markers were to be removed and relocated to the Winneshiek County fairgrounds. The removal of the cement property markers was completed in early summer of 2015. Branden K. Scott and Sheri Herold conducted this investigation on May 13, 2015.

Records held at the Winneshiek County Historical Society, plat maps, historic aerial photographs, newspaper clippings, and county property data were used to outline the historic development of the property, devise a biography of Leon Brown, and obtain information on the menagerie. According to these resources, Leon Brown was a semi­professional entertainer, farmer, philanthropist, and menagerie operator. The farm on which he resided was first erected in the 1880s, with most of the existing construction completed in the 1920s. A few of the farm structures/buildings that resided on the property have been removed.

Field methods consisted of locating and documenting extant structures/buildings and identifying those that have been razed. Documentation consisted of photographing each resource, measuring footprints, and documenting architectural attributes. These data were collected to provide a detailed description of the property. The farmstead consists of six buildings (two barns, a machine shed, a chicken coop, a garage, and a hog finishing building), two structures (a privy and a wire grain bin), 10 objects (six comer posts, a fountain, a cistern, a well, and a water trough), and 14 sites (six building foundations, five grain bin foundations, a pump house/windmill, a ruinous barn, and a depression marking the former location of a building/structure). Most of the buildings, structures, objects, and sites are building locations (extant and former) set on poured concrete foundations. Construction of most of these resources likely occurred during the 1920s. One livestock barn and the house foundation were constructed earlier, most likely in the 1880s. There is little evidence at the farm concerning its use as a menagerie, with most buildings and surrounding areas mostly associated with swine/cattle husbandry.

The property has been overshadowed by its use as a fa1m. Most buildings/structures associated with the menagerie are typical farm buildings while others have been removed. The farmstead appears not retain enough integrity as a menagerie to make it eligible for the National Register of Historic Places under Criterion A. Leon Brown, while a wonderful individual of high character, is probably not a significant individual using National Register of Historic Places criteria, therefore, the property is recommended not eligible under Criterion B. The buildings at the farmstead are typical of farmsteads across Iowa and they do not have notable architectural styles. The fmmstead is recommended not eligible under Criterion C. The relocation of the cement property markers to the Winneshiek County fairgrounds seems an appropriate use for the objects because Leon Brown was an avid supporter of the county fair and their relocation to the fairgrounds provides a direct tie between him and his tenure as fair secretary. Their relocation and public display would highlight the contributions that Leon Brown made to Winneshiek County and his dedication to the county fair and would be a lasting memorial of his life.

ii

TABLE OF CONTENTS

MANAGEMENT SUMMARY ........................................................................................... i TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................... iii LIST OF TABLES ............................................................................................................. iv LIST OF FIGURES ........................................................................................................... iv

INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................... 1 FARM LOCATION ............................................................................................................. 2 PROPERTY TYPES AND DEFINITIONS ........................................................................ 2

Building ..................................................................................................................... 2 Structure .................................................................................................................. .. 2 Object ........................................................................................................................ 2 Site ............................................................................................................................. 3 District ....................................................................................................................... 3 Criterion A ................................................................................................................. 3 Criterion B ................................................................................................................. 3 Criterion C ................................................................................................................ 3 Criterion D ................................................................................................................ 3

ENVIRONMENTAL CONTEXT ....................................................................................... 5 LEON BROWN ................................................................................................................... 6 LEON BROWN'S MENAGERIE ....................................................................................... 7 HISTORIC MAPS, AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHS, AND ASSESSOR DATA ..................... 8 POTENTIAL FOR PREHISTORIC ARCHEOLOGICAL SITES ..................................... 9 FIELD INVESTIGATION RESULTS .............................................................................. 10

Buildings ...................................................................................................................... 10 Structures ..................................................................................................................... 11 Objects ......................................................................................................................... 11 Sites .............................................................................................................................. 13

FARM HISTORIC INTEGRITY AND NRHP ELIGIBILITY ......................................... 14 RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS ............................................................ 16 REFERENCES CITED ...................................................................................................... 18 FIGURES ........................................................................................................................... 20 APPENDIX A: Iowa Site Inventory Forms ....................................................................... 81

iii

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1. Soil survey information ........................................................................................ 5 Table 2. Summary of Winneshiek County Assessor data ................................................... 9 Table 3. Property marker locations ................................................................................... 12 Table 4. Grain bin foundation locations ........................................................................... 14 Table 5. Poured concrete foundation locations and infened functions ........................... .14

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1. Physiographic location of the Leon Brown Farm .............................................. 21 Figure 2. Topographic coverage of the Leon Brown Farm .............................................. 22 Figure 3. Soil map of the Leon Brown Farm .................................................................... 23 Figure 4. Lidar image of the Leon Brown Farm ............................................................... 24 Figure 5. Undated photograph of Leon Brown performing magic tricks ......................... 25 Figure 6. Undated photograph of Leon Brown with ventriloquist dummies .................... 26 Figure 7. Leon Brown's 1991 Association of Iowa Fairs Hall of Fame plaque ............... 27 Figure 8. Thank-you letter from the Winneshiek County Society for Crippled

Children and Adults ..................................................................................................... 28 Figure 9. Cow and buffalo at the Leon Brown Farm ........................................................ 29 Figure 10. Children with pheasants at the Leon Brown Farm .......................................... 30 Figure 11. Deer at the Leon Brown Farm ......................................................................... 31 Figure 12. Visitors observing South African wild sheep at the Leon Brown Farm .......... 32 Figure 13. Children with Spider Monkey at the Leon Brown Farm ................................. 33 Figure 14. Leon Brown and children with Spider Monkey at the Leon Brown Farm ...... 34 Figure 15. Weeping Capuchin Monkey at the Leon Brown Farm .................................... 35 Figure 16. Visitor with young gorilla at the Leon Brown Farm ....................................... 36 Figure 17. Leon Brown with Mugs ................................................................................... 37 Figure 18. Mugs at the Leon Brown Farm ........................................................................ 38 Figure 19. Mugs at the Leon Brown Farm ........................................................................ 39 Figure 20. Undated photograph of the fountain at the Leon Brown Farm ...................... .40 Figure 21. Undated photograph of the main entrance to the Leon Brown Farm ............. .41 Figure 22. 1854 map of the Leon Brown Farm ............................................................... .42 Figure 23. 1875 map of the Leon Brown Farm ................................................................ 43 Figure 24. 1886 map of the Leon Brown Farm ................................................................ 44 Figure 25. 1905 map of the Leon Brown Farm ............................................................... .45 Figure 26. 1915 map of the Leon Brown Farm ............................................................... .46 Figure 27. 1940 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm .......................................... .47 Figure 28. 1952 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm .......................................... .48 Figure 29. 1964 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm .......................................... .49 Figure 30. 1971 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 50 Figure 31. 1983 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 51 Figure 32. 1994 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 52

iv

LIST OF FIGURES, continued

Figure 33. 2002 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 53 Figure 34. 2004 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 54 Figure 35. 2005 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 55 Figure 36. 2006 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 56 Figure 37. 2007 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 57 Figure 38. 2008 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 58 Figure 39. 2009 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 59 Figure 40. 2010 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 60 Figure 41. 2011 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 61 Figure 42. 2013 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm ........................................... 62 Figure 43. Winneshiek County Assessor map of the Leon Brown Farm ......................... 63 Figure 44. Scale map of the Leon Brown Farm ................................................................ 64 Figure 45. Overview of the Leon Brown Farm. View to the northwest .......................... 65 Figure 46. Garage/carriage house at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north .............. 66 Figure 47. Garage/carriage house at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west.. ............. 66 Figure 48. Hog finishing building at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north ............. 67 Figure 49. Hog finishing building at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east ............... 67 Figure 50. Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east. .... 68 Figure 51. Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north ... 68 Figure 52. Loft of the three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm.

View to the north ......................................................................................................... 69 Figure 53. Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south ....... 70 Figure 54. Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west.. ...... 70 Figure 55. Loft of the livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm.

View to the north ......................................................................................................... 71 Figure 56. Machine shed at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the southwest .................... 71 Figure 57. Chicken coop at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west ............................. 72 Figure 58. Chicken coop at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south ........................... 72 Figure 59. Privy at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west .......................................... 73 Figure 60. Concrete property marker at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east.. ......... 73 Figure 61. Fountain at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south ................................... 74 Figure 62. Well at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north .......................................... 74 Figure 63. Water trough at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east.. ............................. 75 Figure 64. Former house location at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south ............. 76 Figure 65. Former house location at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west.. ............. 76 Figure 66. House at the Leon Brown Farm prior to demolition.

View to the southwest .................................................................................................. 77 Figure 67. Ruinous barn at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north ............................ 78 Figure 68. Ruinous barn at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east .............................. 78 Figure 69. Pump house/windmill foundation at the Leon Brown Farm.

View to the east. ........................................................................................................... 79 Figure 70. Example of grain bin foundations at the Leon Brown Farm.

View to the north ......................................................................................................... 79

v

LIST OF FIGURES, continued

Figure 71. Depression at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west.. ............................... 80

vi

INTRODUCTION

This report presents the results of a surface and architectural investigation at the Leon Brown Farm (96-00761-96-00763) in Orleans Township, Winneshiek County, Iowa. This investigation was completed by Bear Creek Archeology, Inc. (BCA) of Cresco, Iowa at the request of the Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission of Decorah, Iowa. This investigation was requested to document the known biography of Leon Brown, the history of the farm, the standing architectural properties, and architectural resources that have been removed. The Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission recognized the contributions that Leon Brown made to the county fair and the county culture as a whole and decided that a brief biographical account and description of the farm on which he resided would add to the richness of documented Winneshiek County history. The farm cmTently encompasses approximately 6 ha (14.8 ac). There are few plans concerning this property. However, the cement property markers are to be removed and relocated to the Winneshiek County fairgrounds. The removal of the markers occurred in the early summer of 2015. Branden K. Scott and Sheri Herold conducted this investigation on May 13, 2015.

Background research utilized records held at the Winneshiek County Historical Society, plat maps, historic aerial photographs, newspaper clippings, and county property data. According to these resources, Leon Brown was a semi-professional entertainer, farmer, philanthropist, and menagerie operator. The farm on which he resided was first erected in the 1880s, with most existing construction completed in the 1920s. A few of the farm structures/buildings that resided on the property have been removed.

Field methods consisted of locating and documenting extant structures/buildings and identifying those that have been razed. Documentation consisted of photographing each resource, measuring the footprint, and documenting architectural attributes. These data were collected so that a detailed description of the property could be made. The farmstead consists of six buildings (two barns, a machine shed, a chicken coop, a garage, and a hog finishing building), two structures (a privy and a wire grain bin), 10 objects (six comer posts, a fountain, a cistern, a well, and a water trough), and 14 sites (six building foundations, five grain bin foundations, a pump house/windmill, a ruinous barn, and a depression marking the former location of a building/structure). The former house is identified by one of the six building foundations and is one of two foundations on the property that is not composed solely of poured concrete. Most of the buildings, structures, objects, and sites are building locations (extant and former) set on poured concrete foundations. Construction of these resources likely occurred during the 1920s. One livestock barn and the house foundation were constructed earlier, most likely in the 1880s. There is little evidence at the farm regarding its use as a menagerie, with most buildings and surrounding areas showing an association to swine/cattle husbandry.

1

FARM LOCATION

The Leon Brown Farm (96-00761) is located in the Iowan Surface physiographic region (Prior 1991; Figure 1) within the SEY<!, SEY<!, SEY<!, the EYz, SWY-1, SEY<!, SEY<!, the SEY<!, NWY-1, SEY<!, SEY<!, and the SWY-1, NEY<!, SEY<!, SEY<!, Section 16, T99N, RlOW, Orleans Township, Winneshiek County, Iowa (Figure 2). The property is located at 3105 318th Avenue between Kendallville and Ridgeway. The fann resides on upland landforms cut with minor upland drainages. The farm encompasses approximately 6 ha (14.8 ac). Presently, the only plan concerning this property is the removal of concrete property markers that will be relocated to the Winneshiek County fairgrounds in Decorah.

PROPERTY TYPES AND DEFINITIONS

While the overarching purpose of this document is to provide a history of Leon Brown and his farm, there are standing structures and issues of historical significance that also need addressed. This type of analysis is necessary if the farm on which he lived is subjected to future considerations for national recognition. The National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) has assigned specific names to different types of properties (Andrus and Shrimpton 2002). The NRHP does not recognize skilled or talented individuals or cultural events, but instead focuses on physical properties that are generally fixed in a location (with some exceptions such as ships and aircraft). The properties defined below are those types acknowledged by the NRHP.

Building. A "building", such as a house, barn, church, hotel, or similar construction, is created principally to shelter any form of human activity. "Building" may also be used to refer to a historically and functionally related unit, such as a courthouse and jail, or a house and barn. Buildings eligible for the NRHP must include all their basic structural elements. Parts of buildings, such as interiors, facades, or wings, are not eligible independent of the rest of the existing building. The whole building must be considered, and its significant features must be identified.

Structure. The term "structure" is used to distinguish from buildings and those functional constructions made usually for purposes other than creating human shelter. Structures nominated to the NRHP must include all of the extant basic structural elements. Parts of structures cannot be considered eligible if the whole structure remains extant. Examples include aircraft, bandstands, ships, canals, corncribs, dams, earthworks, gazebos, highways, and silos.

Object. "Object" is used to distinguish from buildings and structures those constructions that are primarily artistic in nature or are relatively small in scale and simply constructed. Although it may be, by nature or design, movable, an object is associated with a specific setting or environment. Small objects not designed for a specific location are normally not eligible. Such works include transportable sculpture, furniture, and other decorative

2

arts that, unlike fixed outdoor sculpture, do not possess association with a specific place. Objects should be in a setting appropriate to their significant historic use, roles, or character. Objects relocated to a museum are inappropriate for listing to the NRHP. Examples of objects include boundary markers, monuments, mileposts, fountains, and sculptures.

Site. A "site" is the location of a significant event, a prehistoric or historic occupation or activity, or a building or structure, whether standing, ruined, or vanished, where the location itself possesses historic, cultural, or archeological value regardless of the value of any existing structure. Examples of sites include battlefields, campsites, cemeteries, designed landscapes, habitation locations, culturally significant natural features, rock carvings, building/structure ruins, shipwrecks, and trails.

District. A "district" possesses a significant concentration, linkage, or continuity of sites, buildings, structures, or objects united historically or aesthetically by plan or physical development. The identity of a district results from the interrelationship of its resources, which can convey a visual sense of the overall historic environment or be an arrangement of historically or functionally related properties. A district can also be a grouping of archeological sites related primarily by their common components. A district can be considered eligible even if all of the components lack individual distinction provided the grouping achieved significance as a whole within its historic context. A district can contain buildings, structures, sites, or objects that do not contribute to the significance of the district. Examples of districts include groups of businesses, canal systems, collections of habitation sites, estates/farms, industrial complexes, rural villages, and residential areas.

The NRHP has developed four criteria to determine if a property is significant and eligible for inclusion. These four criteria are detailed below. These criteria can be applied at the national, state, or local levels. Generally, properties must be at least 50 years old to be considered for the NRHP.

Criterion A. Associated with events that have made a significant contribution to the broad patterns of our history.

Criterion B. Associated with the lives of persons significant in our past.

Criterion C. Embodies the distinctive characteristics of a type, period, or method of construction, or that represents the work of a master, or that possesses high artistic values, or that represent a significant and distinguishable entity whose components may lack individual distinction.

Criterion D. Has yielded, or may be likely to yield, information important in prehistory or history.

Each criterion has different standards to be considered when deciding to nominate a property to the NRHP and a thorough analysis of a given criterion is often warranted.

3

For instance, while a building might be associated with a significant individual it also has to convey a sense of time and place, that is, the significant individual would be able to recognize the property today. Often, placing a property within a broader context will give perspective on its NRHP eligibility.

It is not enough for a property to meet one of the above criteria to be listed to the NRHP. Property integrity must also be addressed. Documentation of integrity should be thorough and not biased one way or the other. It would be disingenuous to only point to the aspects that retain integrity and ignore those that do not (and vice versa). There are seven aspects of integrity: location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, feeling, and association. All seven aspects of integrity must be addressed, however, not all aspects are considered equal, and must be weighed against why a property might be significant in the first place. For instance, a deeply buried archeological site probably does not "feel" like a habitation location, but it still could be eligible under Criterion D. Likewise, materials can be changed in buildings that are associated with general upkeep/maintenance as long as the changes are not significant enough to have changed other applicable aspects of integrity.

Even though a property was the location of something locally special, like a menagerie, it does not necessarily mean that the property is significant under one of the NRHP criterion. Properties that once were special can lack integrity, thus negating a property from NRHP listing. This does not mean that a prope1iy should not receive some special attention. For the cun-ent property, Criteria A and C will be considered. Small, local menageries are rare. In fact, only seven zoos/zoo-related structures are listed to the NRHP nationally. Nearly all of these are associated with large city zoos. The exception is the Trapper Nelson Zoo Historic District at Hobe Sound, Florida, which was a small private zoo occupying approximately 1 ha (2.5 ac; Richardson and Shiver 2006). The absence of these property types could make the Leon Brown farm potentially eligible for the NRHP under Criteria A and C (if there are zoo/menagerie related structures). The property should also be evaluated under Criterion Casa farmstead property. Criterion B is likely not applicable in this case. While Leon Brown seems to have been a nice, caring, compassionate, and eccentric individual, his creation of a menagerie and minor acts conducting ventriloquism and magic do not make him a historically significant individual nor has his contributions as county fair secretary. Criterion D is generally used for archeological properties. This farm will have archeological deposits, but these deposits have not been evaluated. For Criterion D to be applicable, the property would have to yield significant information not available in the historic record. The property will be evaluated for applicable NRHP criteria as part of this investigation, but this is not the sole focus. The primary focus of this research is to gain insights into a farm/menagerie property that provided Winneshiek County residents with recreational opportunities for years and to detail the pertinent details of Leon Brown's life.

4

ENVIRONMENT AL CONTEXT

The farm is located in northeastern Iowa in the Iowan Surface physiographic region (Prior 1991; Figure 1). The Iowan Surface is slightly inclined to gently rolling with long slopes, low topographic relief, and extended views to the horizon. Iowan Surface hillslopes are gradually multi-leveled or stepped surfaces that progress outward to drainage divides (Prior 1991 :68). A well-defined valley edge is generally difficult to distinguish and the drainage networks are well established and have low topographic relief (Prior 1991:69). This physiographic region experienced its last glaciation during the pre-Illinoian period and has since been subjected to episodes of weathering, soil development, loess deposition, and erosion. The erosional surface complex advanced gradually from stream valleys to the adjacent interstream divides, leaving residual concentrations of coarse pebbles, clays, silts, and sands on each developing surface. Fluvial actions, slope wash, and wind deflation eroded these erosional deposits during the same period that loess was deposited on the landscape. Thick loess accumulations occur on undisturbed topographic highs consisting of elongated ridges, isolated oblong hills (pahas), and interstream divides (Prior 1991).

The information presented below was obtained from the Soil Survey of Winneshiek County, Iowa (Camp 2007) and the Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS; 2014). Soils summarized in Table 1 are the types mapped by NRCS that might be encountered at the farm (Figure 3).

Table 1. Soil survey information (Camp 2007; NRCS 2014)

Symbol 444B

512C2

814B

914B

1489B

Series Jacwin loam, 0-2% slopes

Marlean loam, 5-9% slopes,

moderately eroded

Rockton loam, 2-5% slopes

Winneshiek loam, 2-5% slopes

Lawson-Ossian complex,

0-4% slopes

Member/ Landform

Bench

Upland

Upland

Upland

Camp Creek, Roberts Creek, Gunder

Description Nearly level, somewhat poorly drained on treads of structural benches; formed in loamy sediments over weathered shale; native vegetation was tall prairie grasses. Typical profile: Ap-A-Bw-Bk-2BCk-2Cr.

Moderately sloping, well drained on upland shoulders and sideslopes; formed in loamy sediments over loamy material weathered from limestone; native vegetation was tall prairie grasses. Typical profile: Ap-A-Bw-2C.

Gently sloping, well drained on upland summits; formed in loamy sediments over clayey residuum over limestone or dolomite; native vegetation was tall prairie grasses. Typical profile: Ap-A-Btl-Bt2-2Bt3-3R.

Gently sloping, well drained on upland summits; formed in loamy sediments over clayey residuum over limestone or dolomite; native vegetation was tall prairie grasses and deciduous trees. Typical profile: Ap-E-BE-Btl-2Bt2-3R.

Nearly level to gently sloping, somewhat poorly drained in upland drainageways; formed in alluvium under deciduous trees, tall prairie grasses, forms, and water­tolerant grasses. Typical profiles: Lawson: Ap-Al-A2-A3-A4-Cgl-Cg2, Ossian: Ap-A-AB-Bgl-Bg2-Bg3-BCg.

5

Soil survey information indicates that the farm resides principally on relatively flat upland landforms that are cut by an upland drainage. What is documented as a bench is probably a continuation of the upland landform. The topographic map depicts the farmstead on upland landforms cut by an intermittent stream (Figure 2). The intermittent stream flows north for .6 km (.4 mi) and drains into Silver Creek. Silver Creek flows north-northeast to the Upper Iowa River, meeting its confluence east of Kendallville. The highest elevation at the farm is 364.2 m (1,195 ft) and the lowest elevation is 326.1 (1,070 ft) above the National Geodetic Vertical Datum. The lidar image shows the farm on a relatively flat upland landform cut by a small intermittent stream/upland drainage (Figure 4). Alluvial landforms would be confined to upland drainages at the farm.

LEON BROWN

Leon Brown's grandparents, Louis R. and Sarah L. Brown, arrived in Winneshiek County in 1860 (Winneshiek County Historical Society Archives, Decorah, Iowa 2015). Leon Brown was born to H. C. Brown (a.k.a. Fred Brown) and Minnie Stockman on May 2, 1895 on the family farm (Times Plains Dealer 1990). Leon lived most of his life on the family farm, went to school in Winneshiek County, and attended Upper Iowa University. He lived with his parents and eventually took over farm operations.

Leon spent part of his time as a traveling entertainer in the vaudeville style. In addition to being a farmer, Leon was an actor, businessman, ventriloquist, magician, unicycle rider, and juggler (Hart 1978). His acts were generally to a local audience, with common shows at the Decorah Elks Club, local schools, and fairs. He also performed with a troop that traveled the Midwest. The entertainment troop included an orchestra, chorus girls, and other acts (Hart 1978). Leon's acts involved riding a unicycle, performing magic (Figure 5), and ventriloquism (Figure 6). Leon also performed at the WHO Barn Dance show in Des Moines. His ventriloquist dummy, Jerry, was carved by Theodore Mack of Chicago, who also carved Charlie McCarthy, the ventriloquist dummy used by the incomparable Edgar Bergen (unknown newspaper article "Old Dummies Never Die", Winneshiek County Historical Society 1975; W476-18-35). "Jerry" was sold to Grover Ruwe at the 1975 Winneshiek County fair so that the dummy could continue its career. "Jerry" was renamed "Leon Mack Brown" in honor of his original owner.

Leon was also a member of the Elks Lodge, Showman's League of America, and Cresco Congregational Church (Times Plains Dealer 1990). He was the secretary for the Winneshiek County fair for a number of years (26 years according to the Times Plains Dealer 1990; from 1940-1964 according to Lorentzen 2014). His contributions to the county fair and his contacts with entertainers led to his being named to the Association of Iowa Fairs Hall of Fame posthumously in 1991 (Figure 7). Leon took up woodworking in his basement after retiring from the fair and closing the menagerie (Hart 1978). Leon died January 8, 1990.

6

LEON BROWN'S MENAGERIE

Leon Brown always had an affinity for animals, particularly animals that other people would generally not regard as pets. Leon considered exotic pets a hobby, a hobby that started when he was a boy after he tamed a raccoon (Iowa Farm Bureau Spokesman 1954). He then moved on to raise a bear cub, which he sold for $50 when it became too large and aggressive (Iowa Farm Bureau Spokesman 1954). In the 1940s, Leon had a pen with a wolf and four fox (Ahern 1942). He also donated three Japanese deer to the Mayo Park in Rochester, Minnesota, in thanks for the care the hospital gave his father (Ahern 1942). The menagerie was a happenstance of Leon's hobby of animal husbandry. The beginnings of his menagerie began with a few head of deer that he received from the Minnesota Conservation Department (Dubuque Telegraph Herald 1949; Hart 1978). The hobby expanded and Mr. Brown began raising exotic deer, some of which he shipped to zoos, parks, and collectors across the United States (Hart 1978). According to Mr. Brown, "People used to come out here and park along the roads and look in, not wanting to come in because it was private property" (Cedar Rapids Gazette 1955). Mr. Brown opened his farm to the public so that people could enjoy the results of his hobby.

The "Brown Zoo" opened to the public on Sunday, May 15, 1955 (Shane 1955). According to the Decorah Journal (1955a), there were 700 visitors on the first day, with the first arriving at 8:00 a.m. and the last arriving after dark. Even on the first day, Leon Brown donated all of the proceeds (just over $100) from the menagerie to the Winneshiek County Society for Crippled Children and Adults (Decorah Journal 1955a). In his own words, "But I didn't collect these birds and animals to make money so I decided to open up and give the proceeds to Winneshiek County Society for Crippled Children and Adults" (Cedar Rapids Gazette 1955). He continued to donate all of the proceeds to charity throughout the operation of the menagerie (Figure 8). No formal admission price was ever charged and the menagerie had no set hours of operation. The menagerie contained a number of animals throughout its years of operation and supposedly became the largest privately owned menagerie in Iowa, drawing crowds of 300-400 people on some Sundays (Decorah Journal 1955b; Iowa Farm Bureau Spokesman 1954; Shane 1955). Many animals lived at the property during its operation. These animals included wild boars, elk, South African wild sheep, monkeys, chimpanzees, Brahma cattle, Japanese deer, Australian deer, flamingos, macaws, pheasants, emus, alligators, buffalo, Black Fallow deer, Northern deer, and parrots (Shane 1955; Strandberg 1990; Figures 9-12). Domesticated rabbits hopped across the open lawn and there was a peacock enclosure on the side of the house, allowing visitors opportunities for animal interaction (Dubuque Telegraph Herald 1949; Shane 1955).

Of particular note were Mr. Brown's primates. In 1949, he had a spider monkey named Chico that he often dressed in a suit (Dubuque Telegraph Herald 1949). In 1954, he had two Spider Monkeys named Jimmie and Willie (Figures 13 and 14). He also had a Weeping Capuchin Monkey (Figure 15; monkey identifications courtesy of Dr. Jill Pruetz, primatologist). At some point, he also had a young gorilla (Figure 16). Of all of the primates at the menagerie, one stands out. Leon acquired a baby chimpanzee that he

7

named Mugs (Hart 1978; Figures 17-19). Mugs lived in Leon's house, had his own table, and ate dinner from his own dishes. Mugs was trained to ride a bicycle and he became part of a show that was put on at the menagerie. As with all chimpanzees, they grow older and less tame, and Mugs had to be transferred to a larger zoo.

It is unclear when the menagerie officially closed, but the reason is clear. The menagerie became too much of an insurance liability and Leon worried that some of the animals might bite or injure guests. No local company would insure the menagerie and the only company that handled such policies was Lloyd's of London, an inconvenient and costly insurance carrier (Hart 1978). The menagerie was certainly closed by 1978.

Historic photographs of the property depict the animals, visitors at the menagerie, and some aspects of property layout. Historic photographs indicate that the fountain once contained statues of a variety of animals (Figure 20). Additionally, the main entrance had two pillars at the front with elephants on top and a sign that said "MAIN ENTRANCE" that are no longer of the property (Figure 21 ). Large fences partitioned off animal areas and these fences are mostly gone (Figure 11 ). Cages once resided atop concrete foundations with signs identifying animals in the enclosures (Figure 10). Without question, this property looked like a small menagerie when it was in operation.

HISTORIC MAPS, AERIAL PHOTOGRAPHS, AND ASSESSOR DATA

A historical General Land Office (GLO) map (1854; Figure 22) was used to document early historic features and stream locations at the farmstead. The GLO depicts no historic structures at this farm. Four historical plat maps were used to identify documented structures (Anderson and Goodwin 1905; Andreas 1875; Warner and Foote 1886; Webb Publishing Company 1915; Figures 23-26). The Andreas (1875) map depicts no structures at the farm. The Warner and Foote (1886) map depicts a structure at this property. A possible historic structure location is noted on the Anderson and Goodwin (1905) map in the southeastern part of the property. This structure location is replicated on the Webb Publishing Company (1915) map. The maps from 1886, 1905, and 1915 depict the farm much larger than is currently expressed by property records. In 1886 and 1905, the farm occupied the entire east half of Section 16 (Figures 24 and 25). In 1915, the farm was expanded and included the east half as well as the northwest quarter of Section 16 (Figure 26). At its peak, the Brown's farmed approximately 182.1 ha (450 ac).

Aerial photographs from 1940, 1952, 1964, 1971, 1983, 1994, 2002, and 2004-2013 were used to identify historic structure locations at the farm (Figures 27-42). The photograph from 1940 depicts a house, three barns, the machine shed, two garages, three structures that are no longer extant, and possibly a chicken coop (Figure 27). In 1954, the same structures generally appear, but one of the structures in the western portion of the farmstead had been removed (Figure 28). The same pattern is present in 1964 (Figure 29). In 1971, one of the grain bins in the western portion of the property appears to have

8

been removed (Figure 30). This general layout of structures remains unchanged between 1983 and 1994 (Figures 31 and 32). By 2002, one shed in the southern part of the property had been removed (Figure 33). Few changes were made to the property from 2002 through 2013, with the exception of possible grain bin removal. Within the last couple of years, the house on the property succumbed to fire and was destroyed.

Winneshiek County Assessor (2015) data was accessed to determine the ages and types of historic buildings/structures at the farm. Assessor information is summarized in the table below. It should be noted that Winneshiek County Assessor data is occasionally wrong. The Assessor map of the property is presented as Figure 43.

Table 2. Summary of Winneshiek County Assessor data Plot# T}'.Ee Width Length Sguare Feet Year Built AGl Barn-Flat 54 84 4,536 1920

AG3 Barn - Feed and Livestock 32 60 1,920 1920

AG4 Machine or Utility Building 30 60 1,800 1920

AG5 Swine Finish and Farrow (Old Style) 20 40 800 1920

AG8 Swine Finish and Farrow (Old Style) 16 30 480 1920

AG9 Poultry House 16 20 320 2003

Yard extra 1 Shed NIA NIA 288 1920

Yard extra2 Garage NIA NIA 400 1920

This farmstead has been around since at least 1886, suggesting that some buildings might predate 1920. This is particularly true for AG3, the feed and livestock barn. As will be demonstrated below, this barn likely has a construction date in the 1880s. Building AG8, the swine finish and farrow building, is probably plotted in the wrong location on the assessor map, as this structure had very small openings that would allow chickens to exit, but not swine. No building was identified at AG9, the poultry house, as indicated on the assessor map. Assessor data documents standing buildings, taxable buildings, not all potential historic resources that might occur on a given property.

POTENTIAL FOR PREHISTORIC ARCHEOLOGICAL SITES

The area surrounding the Leon Brown farm has received little archeological survey and there are no known sites within a 1.6 km (1 mi) radius. The farm resides along an intermittent stream that feeds Silver Creek. Silver Creek is a perennial stream that feeds the Upper Iowa River. The farm location is unlikely to produce large prehistoric settlements. However, it is in a location that could produce small prehistoric sites such as bivouacs and resource procurement locations. Overall, there is moderate potential for encountering prehistoric archeological sites. Greater potential exists for these resources further north where the intermittent stream has a confluence with Silver Creek.

9

FIELD INVESTIGATION RESULTS

This section is' organized according to resource type at the farmstead (buildings, structures, objects, and sites). The combination of all of these individual properties makes up the farmstead district (Figures 44 and 45). Iowa site inventory numbers were assigned to the standing barns on the property as well as the farmstead as a whole. Inventory numbers were assigned based on recommendations of Don Hirt at the Iowa State Historic Preservation Office and the completed forms are available in Appendix A.

Buildings

The farm contains six standing buildings. From east to west, the first building encountered is a garage/carriage house (Figures 44, 46, and 47). This garage is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,664.7, Northing: 4,804,163.0. The garage measures 6.2 m (20.3 ft; east to west) by 6.1 m (20 ft; north to south). The garage has two stalls, set in a side-opening carriage house style. The garage was constructed using 2 x 4"s set 24" on center. The building is sided with mixed vertical wood lapboard and sheet metal. The roof is steel. There is a small loft over the east half of the garage. The east and west sides have four light, single pane windows. It resides on a poured concrete foundation. The single-gable roof is covered with sheet metal. This garage was likely constructed in the 1920s.

A hog finishing building is present north and slightly west of the garage (Figures 44, 48, and 49). This building is positioned at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,652.0, Northing: 4,804,185.7. The building measures 7.4 m (24.3 ft) north to south and 12.3 m (40.4 ft) east to west. The building rests upon a poured concrete foundation. The foundation supports the 2 x 4" balloon frame covered with lapboard siding. The single-gable roof is covered with sheet metal. There are five small doors on the south side and one small door on the east side that allowed swine to enter/exit the building. This building was likely constructed in the 1920s.

Southwest of the hog finishing building is a three-portal barn (96-00762; Figures 44 and 50-52). The barn is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,628.3, Northing: 4,804,158.9. The barn measures 15.9 m (52.2 ft) east to west and 25.8 m (84.6 ft) north to south. The east and west portals consist of individual livestock pens. The central area consists of additional livestock pens and work areas. The barn was constructed using balloon framing covered with wood siding. The front-gable roof is covered with steel. The east wall has partially collapsed. Roof joists are tied with collar beams. The barn rests atop a poured concrete foundation. This barn was likely constructed in the 1920s.

Another barn is positioned immediately south of barn 96-00762. The southern barn was assigned inventory number 96-00763 (Figures 44 and 53-55). This barn is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,621.9, Northing: 4,804,124.0. This three-portal barn measures 18.9 m (62 ft) east to west by 9.3 m (30.5 ft) north to south. This barn was built with hewn timbers. The framing is covered with wood siding. Framing is tied with

10

square and round nails. The interior of this barn gives the appearance that it was used for larger livestock, such as horses and cattle. The barn rests on a limestone foundation that has been patched with concrete. The single-gable roof was constructed with widely spaced roof joists tied with collar beams. Given the foundation, type of wood used, and the presence of square nails, this barn probably dates to the 1880s. This barn appears to be associated with the original farmstead that resided at this location.

A machine shed is present west of the barns (Figures 44 and 56). The machine shed is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,602.3, Northing: 4,804,127.3. The machine shed rests on a poured concrete foundation. The interior framing was constructed using 2 x 4"s set 32" on center. The building is covered with wood siding. The single-gable roof is covered with steel. The machine shed measures 9.8 m (32.2 ft) east to west by 18.3 m (60 ft) north to south. This building is present on the 1940 aerial photograph and was likely constructed in the 1920s or 1930s.

A chicken coop is present in the southern part of the property (Figures 44, 57, and 58). The chicken coop is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,616.7, Northing: 4,804,102.2. The chicken coop measures 11.7 m (38.4 ft) east to west by 5.9 m (19.4 ft) north to south and rests on a poured concrete foundation. The building has a side-gable roof covered with steel. The balloon framing is covered with wood siding. There is a poultry access door on the north side and ventilation windows are present on the south side. County assessor data suggest that this building was constructed in either 1920 or 2003. This building is present on aerial photographs from 1940 onward; therefore, a 1920s date for construction is reasonable.

Structures

There are two standing structures on the property. The first is a privy that resides behind the garage (Figures 44 and 59). The privy is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,663.2, Northing: 4,804,167.3. The privy measures 1.8 m (5.9 ft; east to west) by 1.9 m (6.2 ft; north to south). The privy was constructed using 2 x 4" wood framing tied together with wood siding. The roof is a single gable covered with sheet metal. The privy rests atop a poured concrete foundation/basin. This structure was likely constructed post-1920. It is difficult to assign this structure a particular date or range because it is small and difficult to make out on aerial photographs. The privy is certainly at this location by 1994.

A wire grain bin is present in the western portion of the property (Figure 44). The wire bin is collapsed. It resides on a poured concrete foundation with a 5 m (16.4 ft) diameter. This bin is located at NAD83; Zone 15; Easting: 578,591.4; Northing: 4,804,132.5. This bin was erected between 1994 and 2002.

Objects

The farm has 10 objects. Six of these objects are property markers. The property markers are located at six locations around the east and south sides of the farm. Two of

11

these markers are present at each of the two driveway entrances. The other two mark comers (Figures 44 and 60). The markers are constructed from poured concrete. The design of all the markers is consistent, a concrete globe atop a rectangular prism base. The markers measure .8 m (2.6 ft) on all four sides and are 1.7 m (5.6 ft) high. The GPS coordinates of each marker are presented below. These markers were probably installed at the same time as the fountain. This period would correspond to the property's use as a menagerie (ca. 1950s). Four of the markers were removed for relocation to the Winneshiek County fairgrounds in the early summer of 2015 (Decorah Journal 2015).

Table 3. Pro2erty marker locations NAD Zone Easting Northing

83 15 578,664.1 4,804,069.3

83 15 578,669.2 4,804,069.4

83 15 578,697.3 4,804,073.2

83 15 578,694.8 4,804,129.2

83 15 578,694.6 4,804,139.7

83 15 578,697.2 4,804,169.3

A poured concrete fountain is located in the eastern part of the property (Figures 44 and 61). The base of this fountain measures 3.9 m (12.8 ft) in diameter. Historic photographs indicate that this fountain was known as the "Eagle Fountain" because of the large concrete eagle that sat at the pinnacle (Figure 20). The fountain also had bear, swan, and flamingo statues (Figure 20). This fountain was likely installed in the 1950s, probably between 1952 (potential absence from aerial photographs) and 1955.

A well was observed in the northern part of the property between the garage and the hog finishing building (Figures 44 and 62). This well is slightly different from general vertical standpipe wells. The well is noted by a concrete cap. The well cap measures approximately 1 m (3.3 ft) in diameter. This well is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,653.1, Northing: 4,804,175.8.

A poured concrete water trough is located near the center of the farmstead between the two standing barns (Figures 44 and 63). This object is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,633.2, Northing: 4,804,135.7. The water trough measures 8.5 m (27.9 ft) north to south and 4.3 m (14.l ft) east to west. It is unclear when this water trough was constructed.

A cistern was noted at the former house location (Figure 44). This cistern was positioned underneath a house addition, indicating that the house was built over it. The cistern is located at approximately NAD83, Zone 15; Easting: 578,660.5, Northing: 4,804,114. This brick-lined cistern has a diameter of approximately 1 m (3.3 ft) and it is approximately 3.7 m (12 ft) deep. The cistern is associated with the original 1880s house.

12

Sites

The farmstead includes 14 features that are considered sites. Sites include poured concrete grain bin pads/foundation, poured concrete foundations, a depression at a former building/structure location, the foundation for a pump house, the house foundation, and a dilapidated barn.

The house on this property has burned to the ground and much of the building material removed. All that remains of the house is the foundation (Figures 44, 64, and 65). The house was irregularly shaped with multiple additions. The house was located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,664.5, Northing: 4,804,116.2. The foundation measures a maximum of 15.6 m (51.2 ft; east to west) by 14.9 m (48.9 ft; north to south). The southeast part of the house was the oldest part of the building based on the foundation. The foundation in this area was constructed using limestone. Additions to the original building led to foundation changes. Later foundation additions were constructed using brick and concrete. The northwestern portion of the house site does not have an excavated foundation. Instead, the northwestern portion of the former house location consists of a poured concrete pad. Framing materials that were left at the site indicate a mixture of round and square nails indicative of multiple construction episodes. A photograph of the house prior to demolition can off er insights into the design of this former house. The photograph depicts a front and side gable house with the front oriented to the east (Figure 66). The house was 1 ~story with double hung windows and a picture window on the first floor of the east side. An addition to the northwest had a single gable. While a second floor was present in the addition, the roof elevation was slightly lower than the older part of the building. Fenestration generally allowed light through two windows in each room. There was limited cross lighting (light coming in from multiple sides) due to constraints caused by the roof form. Builders added an entrance to the basement on the north side. A covered porch was present on the northeast comer of the home.

One barn has fallen down and is considered a site (Figures 44, 67, and 68). The former barn is located at NAD83, Zone 15, Easting: 578,605.9, Northing: 4,804,155.0. This building was a three-portal barn with a gable roof. The gable roof was covered with steel. The barn sat atop a poured concrete foundation. The barn was built using wood balloon framing. The width of the barn was 18 m (59.l ft; east to west). The length of the barn could not be measured with a tape measure. Aerial photographs indicate that the barn had a length of about 18.6 m (61 ft; north to south).

A foundation for a pump house/windmill is present north of the former house location (Figures 44 and 69). The steel framing of the windmill is still present. The pump house, however, was consumed by fire. A picture of the building right after the fire shows a small single gable shed at this location (Figure 66). The foundation of the pump house measured approximately 2.5 m (8.2 ft) square.

The farmstead has five grain bin foundations/pads (Figures 44 and 70). Each of these was formed using poured concrete and has a 5 m (16.4 ft) diameter. One of these

13

foundations is octagonal while the others are round. Bin foundation locations are detailed below.

Table 4. Grain bin foundation locations NAD Zone Easting Northing

83 15 578,655.7 4,804169.6

83 15 578,651.6 4,804,173.5

83 15 578,577.3 4,804,133.3

83 15 578,569.4 4,804,144.9

83 15 578,554.2 4,804,171.0

There are five poured concrete foundations associated with outbuildings and garages. These sites are described further below.

Table 5. Poured concrete foundation locations and inferred functions Potential Dimensions Dimensions function NAD Zone Easting Northing N/S {m} E/W{m}

Outbuilding 83 15 578,676.1 4,804,168.5 2.5 3.1

Outbuilding 83 15 578,673.6 4,804,168.7 3.0 1.3

Outbuilding 83 15 578,641.0 4,804,186.3 7.3 2.2

Outbuilding 83 15 578,626.9 4,804,103.0 9.8 4.2

Garage 83 15 578,661.6 4,804,127.5 3.7 7.4

A depression associated with a former building/structure is present in the northwest part of the farmstead (Figure 71). A building is depicted at this location in 1964 and is gone by 1971. The depression measures approximately 8 m (26.2 ft) in diameter and is roughly circular. This location contained a small outbuilding.

FARM HISTORIC INTEGRITY AND NRHP ELIGIBILITY

The two criteria for NRHP eligibility consideration that are applicable to this property are Criteria A and C. Criterion A is being considered due to the property's relationship to a small-scale, rural menagerie. It is not being considered for the property's use as a farm because these types of resources are very common across the landscape. As a menagerie, there are certain integrity considerations that stand out more than others do. These integrity considerations include design, feeling, and association. These three considerations are given more weight than location, setting, materials, and workmanship. Criterion C is being considered because the resources at the farm might have some architectural significance. Aspects of integrity that will receive greater weight for Criterion C are design, materials, and workmanship. However, as a farm, the buildings have to be representative of a style uncommon to farmsteads or are an excellent example of farmstead architecture to make the property eligible for the NRHP under Criterion C.

14

The location of the prope11y has not changed. Therefore, the farm retains its location integrity.

The design of this property is complex. The only building remaining from the original farmstead is a barn. The house has been destroyed. Therefore, the design does not match the original 1880s layout. As a farm from the early to mid-twentieth century, the design has not changed significantly. The farm buildings are oriented in the same direction and the buildings/structures have about the same appearance as they did when constructed. The major detractions from the twentieth century farmstead design are the lack of a house and the roofs being covered with sheet metal. If viewing the property as a twentieth century farm, the property retains its design integrity. While the farm buildings were present during the property's use as a menagerie, there are some differences. The menagerie would have had a layout allowing for groups of people to move freely through animal display areas. These display areas are gone. No small cages or animal pens are present on the property. The cement pillars are present around the property and these would have given the farm more of a "zoo" feel. The fountain was also a significant aspect of the menagerie design. However, the statues that were present within the fountain have disappeared. As a menagerie, the property does not retain its design integrity.

While the farm resides in the same location, the setting has slightly changed. The rural landscape surrounding the property remains the same. The farm is surrounded by farm fields. Additionally, pastures have remained in the same locations. What differs, however, is the removal of buildings and structures that have affected the local farmstead setting. The farm no longer has a house and small animal enclosures/pens that would have created a menagerie setting at the property. The setting for its use as a farm has altered minimally. With the exception of house removal, the property does retain a farm setting. Overall, the property retains its setting integrity.

Materials associated with the initial farm occupation are few. Materials associated with the farm as it was in the twentieth century are plentiful. There have been few changes to the property during the twentieth century meaning that the buildings are about the same as when they were originally built. Nearly every extant building/structure has a poured concrete foundation and wood framing. The roofs have been updated with steel. The farm retains its materials integrity. When considering the property as a menagerie, materials integrity is mixed. The farm buildings were utilized for the menagerie and they have materials integrity. However, many of the fences and menagerie-related structures are now absent.

The buildings and structures at the farm are typical of the 1920s and later construction and they have been minimally altered (the exception being the steel roofs). The house is no longer available to consider for workmanship. The extant buildings/structures retain their workmanship integrity.

The property feels like a farmstead, even without the house. As a farm, it retains its feeling integrity. The property, however, does not feel like a menagerie. Upon arrival

15

and even after walking around the property it would be unclear that this property was a menagerie without having previous knowledge of the property's history. As a menagerie, the property does not retain its feeling integrity.

This property retains its association with a farm, but farm operations are generally not a significant historic context. There are no buildings/structures directly related to the menagerie function. All of the buildings/structures were utilized for farm activities after the property's use as a menagerie. Essentially, there is little about the property that has a direct link to exotic animal displays. Therefore, this property has little association integrity as it concerns the menagerie.

This farm is not a significant property as it concerns regional agriculture. The significance to broader patterns of history would be derived due to its use as a small, rural menagerie. While the location is good, design, materials, feeling, and association lack integrity. Most importantly, design, feeling, and association lack integrity. This property does not have a menagerie layout, it does not feel like a menagerie, and aspects of the property that would provide direct correlation to menagerie use have been removed or are masked by farm functions. The Leon Brown Farm is recommended not eligible for the NRHP under Criterion A.

The buildings and structures at the Leon Brown Farm are typical of buildings built during the late 1800s and 1920s. These types of buildings are extremely common and there is nothing notable about the architecture even though most of the buildings meet integrity requirements. The Leon Brown Farm and its associated buildings is recommended not eligible for the NRHP under Criterion C

RECOMMENDATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS

This report presented the results of a surface and architectural investigation conducted by BCA at the Leon Brown Farm (96-00761-96-00763) in Orleans Township, Winneshiek County, Iowa, for the Winneshiek Historic Preservation Commission. This investigation was requested to document the known biography of Leon Brown, the history of the farm, the standing architectural properties, and architectural resources that have been removed. Leon Brown was a notable citizen of Winneshiek County and volunteered many years of service to the Winneshiek County Fair Board. Because of his role in shaping the Winneshiek County Fair, the Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission sought to gather background information on his farm, which also served as a menagerie for a number of years. As Leon Brown was a devoted, compassionate, and influential county citizen, it was decided by the Winneshiek County Historic Preservation Commission to document aspects of his life and the farm where he lived. The current farmstead encompasses approximately 6 ha (14.8 ac). It is planned that cement property markers at the farmstead are to be removed and relocated to the Winneshiek County fairgrounds, a task that began in early summer of 2015.

16

Information contained in this report was obtained from records held at the Winneshiek County Historical Society, plat maps, historic aerial photographs, newspaper clippings, county property records, and a reconnaissance survey of the farmstead. According to these resources, Leon Brown was a semi-professional entertainer, farmer, philanthropist, and menagerie operator. The farm on which he resided was first erected in the 1880s, with most existing construction completed in the 1920s. A few of the farm structures/ buildings that resided on the property have been destroyed.

Field methods consisted of locating and documenting extant structures/buildings and identifying those that have been razed. Documentation consisted of photographing each resource, measuring footprints, and documenting architectural attributes. These data were collected so that a detailed description of the property could be made. Presently, the farmstead consists of six buildings (two barns, a machine shed, a chicken coop, a garage, and a hog finishing building), two structures (a privy and a wire grain bin), 10 objects (six corner posts, a fountain, a cistern, a well, and a water trough), and 14 sites (six building foundations, five grain bin foundations, a pump house/windmill, a ruinous barn, and a depression marking the former location of a building/structure). Most of the buildings, structures, objects, and sites are building locations (extant and former) set on poured concrete foundations. Construction of these resources likely occurred during the 1920s. One livestock barn and the house foundation were constructed earlier, most likely in the 1880s. There is little evidence at the farm of its use as a menagerie, with most buildings and surrounding areas showing mostly swine/cattle husbandry.

Leon Brown appears to have been a kind-hearted individual with an overwhelming love for animals. The menagerie was a hobby, and when he noticed the gawkers at his gates, he opened them, took donations, and sent the collected money to care for those in need. He was a selfless man that sought to provide joy for others and strengthen community bonds in Winneshiek County. His character is shown through his menagerie operation, his performances, and his tenure as Secretary of the Winneshiek County Fair Board. While a local philanthropist and nice individual, he would not be considered a significant historical individual as concerns the NRHP. The remains of Leon Brown's legacy are a few buildings at a rural farmstead. There are few indications that this property was used as a menagerie. Instead, most of the buildings appear to be associated with typical farm operations, even though many of the buildings housed exotic animals. The property has lost much of its sense of being a menagerie, the associated buildings are typical of farmsteads throughout Iowa, and they are not architecturally notable. This likely disqualifies the property from listing the NRHP under Criteria A and C. The property was certainly worthy of documentation and the resulting story is a curiosity in the annals of Winneshiek County history. The relocation of the cement markers from his farm to the Winneshiek County fairgrounds seems fitting because of his contributions and lifelong dedication to making the fair an enjoyable experience for all. Moving the markers to the county fairgrounds is an excellent way of memorializing Leon Brown's contributions to the fair and Winneshiek County life, particularly since the farm itself is not historically significant.

17

REFERENCES CITED

Ahem, L. Dale 1942 Roadside Ramblings. Decorah Journal 21 Janua1y. Decorah, Iowa.

Anderson and Goodwin 1905 Standard Atlas of Winneshiek County, Iowa. Anderson and Goodwin Company,

Davenport, Iowa.

Andreas, Alfred T. 1875 Illustrated Historical Atlas of the State of Iowa. Andreas Atlas Company,

Chicago, Illinois.

Andrus, Patrick W., and Rebecca H. Shrimpton 2002 How to Apply the National Register Criteria for Evaluation. National Register

Bulletin 15, National Park Service. Electronic document, www.nps.gov/nr/publications/bulletins/nrb15/, accessed June 11, 2015.

Camp, Leland D. 2007 Soil Survey of Winneshiek County, Iowa. U.S. Department of Agriculture, Soil

Conservation Service. U.S. Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

Cedar Rapids Gazette 1955 Private Zoo Near Decorah. Cedar Rapids Gazette 16 May. Cedar Rapids,

Iowa.

Decorah Journal 1955a More than 700 Persons Visit Brown Zoo Sunday. Decorah Journal 19 May.

Decorah, Iowa.

1955b Leon Brown Shows Unusual Example of Public Spirit. Decorah Journal 12 May. Decorah, Iowa.

2015 Historical Society, Historic Preservation Collaborate with Fairgrounds on Pillar Project. Decorah Journal 2 July. Decorah, Iowa.

Dubuque Telegraph Herald 1949 Winneshiek Man Started with 2 Deer; Now Has Small Zoo on His 400 Acres.

Dubuque Telegraph Herald 4 December. Dubuque, Iowa.

General Land Office (GLO) 1854 Secretary of State Land Survey Records: Description of the Lands on the

Interior Sectional Lines. On file, State Historical Society Library, Iowa City.

18

Hart, Bill 1978 Leon R. Brown: Animal Zoo and Acquaintances Fill Life of Country Boy.

Decorah Journal 7 December:C-5. Decorah, Iowa.

Iowa Farm Bureau Spokesman 1954 Zoo is Hobby for Cresco Farmer. Iowa Farm Bureau Spokesman 2 October.

Lorentzen, Elizabeth 2014 Fairboard Notables. Prepared for the Decorah Historical Sign Project. On file,

Winneshiek County Historical Society, Decorah, Iowa.

Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) 2014 Soil Survey of Winneshiek County, Iowa. U.S. Department of Agriculture,

Washington, DC. Downloaded from http://datagateway.nrcs.usda.gov, July 2014.

Prior, Jean C. 1991 Landforms of Iowa. University of Iowa Press, Iowa City.

Richardson, Barry, and Carl Shiver 2006 National Register of Historic Places Nomination Form for the Trapper Nelson

Zoo Historic District. Submitted by the Bureau of Historic Preservation, Tallahassee, Florida.

Shane, George 1955 Private Zoo is Opening to Aid Crippled. Des Moines Register 17 May. Des

Moines, Iowa.

Strandberg, Sarah 1990 Leon Brown: A Man of Many Talents. Decorah Journal 30 January. Decorah,

Iowa.

Times Plains Dealer 1990 Leon R. Brown Obituary. Times Plains Dealer 17 January. Cresco, Iowa.

Warner, George A., and C. M. Foote 1886 Plat Book of Winneshiek County, Iowa. Warner and Foote, Minneapolis,

Minnesota.

Webb Publishing Company 1915 Atlas and Farm Directory, Township Plats of Winneshiek County, Iowa. Webb

Publishing Company, St. Paul, Minnesota.

Winneshiek County Assessor 2015 Assessor Data. Electronic document, beaconbeta.schneidercorp.com, accessed

June 11, 2015.

19

FIGURES

20

1

I ! \ l

u l l u L!

ll u u

Plain

De Moines Ilobe

0

Miies

20 40 60 80

Kiiometers

0 20 40 60 80 100

100

Figure 1. Physiographic location of the Leon Brown Farm (adapted from Prior [1991:31)).

21

f (

1

1

f I

J !

11

J I

i~

I I J !

) (

l I l ! r 1

} J

u l l u u

Figure 2. Topographic coverage of the Leon Brown Farm.

22

f I

f 1

(

f l f !

f I f I Ll

I ! 1 !

1 !

l l f J

[!

u u u u l J

0 200 ft Nt 1:2400 61 m

Figure 3. Soil map of the Leon Brown Farm (NRCS 2014).

23

f I f I f I f I

!

J I ~

i I

l ! 1 l J

t J

lJ

u u u

Figure 4. Lidar image of the Leon Brown Farm.

24

Figure 5. Undated photograph of Leon Brown performing magic tricks.

25

Figure 6. Undated photograph of Leon Brown with ventriloquist dummies.

26

l f l

u I

11

l I

) l [ J

I l u LJ

u ll•

Figure 7. Leon Brown's 1991 Association of Iowa Fairs Hall of Fame plaque.

27

WINNESHIEK COUNTY

DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL WELFARE COURT HOUSE

MRS. JANICE N. SIVESIND DIRECTOR DECORAH, IOWA

December 2l, 1956

• ff.ir. Leon Brovm Route fi~4 Cresco, Iowa

Dear Leon:

The Board of the Society For Crippled Children and Adults wishes to express our gratitude and thanlts for the contributions to it from your Zoo during the past year. It has been a wonderf'ul thing and has contributed in a large measure to the organization of the Clinic at the West Decorah School which is now '1!_uite well-equipped. I'm sure you know that the Clinic was set up about August l, 1956, and that we were able to hire a Physical Therapist half time. As you have indicated, all of the money from the Zoo has gone into the purchase of equipment

' only, and not for operating expenses.

You realize, of course, that just saying thank you doesn't really begin to express our appreciation for this fine thing you have done. I think it is a monument to your generosity and kindness and will always be remembered~

We would like to show you through the Clinic at the West Side School, and if you happen to be il'\f town some morning during the week I would be happy to take you over and.have iY'irs. Johnson explain the various pieces of e~uipment and their use.

Thank you again for your very fine continuing contribution.

Best wishes for a Merry Christmas and a ;Happy and P-.cosperous New Year.

Sincerely,

WINNESHIEK COUNTY SOCIEI'Y FOR CRIPPLED CHILDREI'l AND ADULTS

PHONE 620

i.~ '\ ~· . ' t , \

r fA..--v·'\...c..w::... I\ . • c-.. ·,x~'.L<_ __ S( Mr~~ Janice 1'1. Sivesind, Hember of · ' e State Board For Crippled

Children and Adults tTM:MJ

Figure 8. Thank-you letter from the Winneshiek County Society for Crippled Children and Adults.

28

Figure 9. Cow and buffalo at the Leon Brown Farm.

29

Figure 10. Children with pheasants at the Leon Brown Farm.

30

f I

I!

11

II l.1

n

u u u

I lJ I

Figure 11. Deer at the Leon Brown Farm.

31

Figure 12. Visitors observing South African wild sheep at the Leon Brown Farm.

32

Figure 13. Children with Spider Monkey at the Leon Brown Farm.

33

Figure 14. Leon Brown and children with Spider Monkey at the Leon Brown Farm.

34

Figure 15. Weeping Capuchin Monkey at the Leon Brown Farm.

35

f I I

f I 11

µ !

I !

lJ l J

u lJ u

Figure 16. Visitor with young gorilla at the Leon Brown Farm.

36

r 1

l

,U

I

J I 11

11

11

~

u u l j Li .

I lJ I

I

Figure 17. Leon Brown with Mugs.

37

l I l

11

11

( I

11

u D u LI

u u Ll

Figure 18. Mugs at the Leon Brown Farm.

38

fl

i I I

r1

~

J I

J I

'I I

11

11

n J j

u LI

. lJ

l j

Figure 19. Mugs at the Leon Brown Farm.

39

Figure 20. Undated photograph of the fountain at the Leon Brown Farm.

40

n 11

n r i I

I I

11

w

! I I : l I

II

l1 n ll u u u u

Figure 21. Undated photograph of the main entrance to the Leon Brown Farm.

41

f 1

f I 11

i~

11

-{ I

11

fl i j

rJ )

u ll u lJ

Leon Brown Farm (96-00761)

Y. /d ':l(j ~

Figure 22. 1854 map of the Leon Brown Farm (GLO).

42

0 -Leon Brown Fann

0 1000 ft Nt

0 1:12000 305 m

I f l I

f I r I

w

l l I I f I l I l ; n l J

lJ u u u

Figure 23. 1875 map of the Leon Brown Farm (Andreas).

43

CJ-Leon Brown Farm

0 1000 ft Nt

0 1:12000 305 m

fl

1

f I I

r 1

fl

u 11

l { l l I l l l1 l j u u u ll

. T. , .. (~/· .0

r)f 011./

•t}

' .If~

~,.,,rr

1

6

I

~ " ...

~ 0 I ... ~

..... ~ •

~ .. ~

..

Leon Brown Farm (96-00761)

---~

' 1. I I

rl 0 "-~ s

~ "' ...... ~

~ .... ~ -. ,. -- ... ~

~

"" ' -,......._

~ I ._

• •

(i (1 1 1·9 l'~'- .J!l1J! l/.J 111"

oo ~~o

• ~ • J t 1 i1 .. t• ~ $ I

~ "' IJli1"1~r.. .. 0 -Leon Brown Fam1

.. , O IOOOft i 0!==::::;:1:~120~00 ~305 m !

Figure 24. 1886 map of the Leon Brown Farm (Warner and Foote).

44

n 1

f 1

f 1

µ 11

l l l !

I I fJ

l l u u u lJ

.!l • .. e. .r·

'l

..

•

,.,. .,,

1-----­.. ,.-- - --· ·-.· •..

·1.1·

"V

" ,_ ~, ~

~ . ~.· .... ~ " • !"iii ....

H.: r ~

. .

. " ·~ , I j -- . ... ... ·,.:. ·6 - ,. ' .... <!

-~ ·~ · 1 - I

I ~ : l.

~

. .. ..... R. II. i

~ . ~~ .. .u ~ ·. • ._,. . .

•

·~ ·i: .,

"" CJ-Leon Brown Farm

0 IOOOft Nl

oc::==/ : ~120::;:00 ~305 m

Figure 25. 1905 map of the Leon Brown Farm (Anderson and Goodwin).

45

fl C .fi.ro~

r I r I I l w

11

11

I !

.. nte ..

u.11' . ••

Leon Brown Farm (96-00761) •

' ..

"' .~t R.H. ~ · urr

I . :i . !!\;. J[\ .

' ~ ~ CJ-Leon;rown Fam1 N

~-' 0 IOOOft l ~ ~ I o 1:12000 30s m

I l ! f I l l lJ

lJ u u

Figure 26. 1915 map of the Leon Brown Farm (Webb Publishing Company).

46

l 1

I

J I

r 1

n w

I j !

l! II u n l u u u u

0 -Leon Brown Fam1

0 200 ft i O /:2400 61 m l

Figure 27. 1940 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

47

fl 1

J !

t

11

µ I

I ! l ! 11

u l.! l [ u ll lJ u

Figure 28. 1952 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

48

I I

f !

~

I

I ! l l 11

I J

Li

lJ

l l lJ

u

Leon Brown Farm (96-00761)

o0c===:::E===:===i200 ft I

1:2400 61 m l

Figure 29. 1964 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

49

fl

l n I 1

I l f I ~

J !

1 [

l I u tJ

LI

u u l J

u

0 -Leon Brown Fam1

0 200 ft i o 1:2400 61m I

Figure 30. 1971 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

50

f I r 1

~

I

(

f I ! I l l n J

u u u l J

Figure 31. 1983 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

51

l 1

l

~

I I 11

l I 11

l lJ

I l lJ lJ u l J

Figure 32. 1994 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

52

f 1

l n f I I

r 1

I ! LJ

!

I l I

11

J

l J

LI

u u u u

Figure 33. 2002 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

53

fl

I f I

II 11

f I ll 1 j

lJ

t I J

Li

u

Figure 34. 2004 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

54

l

11

ll Ll

l I ll u LI

CJ-Leon Brown Farm

0 200 ft

0 1:2400 61 m I Figure 35. 2005 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

55

n n

I ~ I

I : 11

I

l l n ll u u u Li

Figure 36. 2006 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

56

n

1

II

I I ll n l I I j

u u u

0 -Leon Brown Farm

0 200 ft i O 1:2400 61 m l

Figure 37. 2007 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

57

l

f I I l

f J

11

11

l.l n lJ

u u Li

I lJ

Figure 38. 2008 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

58

l

1

f I

I I I 11

11

n Ll

u u Li ~

0 -Leon Brown Farm

0 200 ft i O 1:2400 61 m A

Figure 39. 2009 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

59

l l I

f I r !

~

11

I

1 \

11

I t

u J

u u

Figure 40. 2010 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

60

f I 1

I f I

!

!1 I l I !

1 (

11

l ( l_ I

lJ

u l j u u

0 -Leon Brown Fam1

0 200 ft i O 1:2400 61 m l

Figure 41. 2011 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

61

f I r 1

n f I f I 11

11

I !

11

l! l l l\ u u l1

u li

Figure 42. 2013 aerial photograph of the Leon Brown Farm.

62

N

-r-:: ? AG5

~-2 ""'

[J 318 ~HAVE

~ JT ~ AG 1-FLAT BARN-54MS4

AG 3- FIL BARN· 32x60 AG 4- MACH SHED- 30M60

~ AG9 Yl AG 5- S\./INE FINISH· 20x40

AG8 AG 8- S\./INE FINISH- 16M30 AG 9· POUL TRY-1GM20

Sketch bv 'Pur.:1.cama·o'is~::m.o:.m

Figure 43. Winneshiek County Assessor map of the Leon Brown Farm.

63

r !

I l l I

Li Li

Figure 44. Scale map of the Leon Brown Farm.

64

J

0 -Leon Brown Fann 0 -Building/Structure

o -Potential Building (Not Relocated)

o!====:i;:===:=31so ft 0 1:1800 46m I

fl f l fl

I f I fl I I Li

I ! 11

l ! Figure 45. Overview of the Leon Brown Farm. View to the northwest (5/13/15).

65

1

f I r I

J l

Li u u

Figure 46. Garage/carriage house at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

Figure 47. Garage/carriage house at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

66

l

\ !

11

l l lJ

lJ

J

l1 u

Figure 48. Hog finishing building at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

Figure 49. Hog finishing building at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

67

I

fl f I l I

f I I

w

11

l I

I

ll n j

lJ

Li

1J

LJ

Figure 50. Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

Figure 51. Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

68

f I

l r1

I r I

11

11

J I

J

~

l lJ u u Li

Figure 52. Loft of the three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

69

1

l n

r I I l

w

I

I I

I

11

~

u u u u u

Figure 53. Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15).

Figure 54. Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

70

l

I

I l

I I 11

11

ll u I J

u u

Figure 55. Loft of the livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

-_,.- :....--

Figure 56. Machine shed at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the southwest (5/13/15).

71

n fl f I

I J

u J

lJ Li

LJ

Figure 57. Chicken coop at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

Figure 58. Chicken coop at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15).

72

fl

fl r I

l

f j

w

I I

II

t j

lJ

lJ

Li u

Figure 59. Privy at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

Figure 60. Concrete property marker at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

73

f)

1

f l !

f I l !

u 11

I ! l l l I { J

u lJ u u

Figure 61. Fountain at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15).

Figure 62. Well at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

74

r l l

u I

ll l l l I

u Li Li Li

Figure 63. Water trough at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

75

r I r i f I f l f I f I I I Li

I

I ! l l ! ! l l

l 1

Li

Li Li

u

Figure 64. Former house location at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15).

Figure 65. Former house location at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

76

fl f l f 1

f (

I

f I

I

J 11

I ! ll l !

1.1

n u ll lJ u lJ

Figure 66. House at the Leon Brown Farm prior.to the fire. View to the southwest.

77

n

l r i r I f I l

1 l J I

11

1 l l l u l I lJ

u ll

.,_ . - -....- · · !of·~

····f-;

Figure 67. Ruinous barn at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

Figure 68. Ruinous barn at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

78

n

fl

J I f I

t (

I f

l ! j

Li

Li Li

Figure 69. Pump house/windmill foundation at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

Figure 70. Example of grain bin foundations at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

79

r 1

fl

l f l

fl

l

u f l

I I ! [ Figure 71. Depression at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

JJ

l1

Li l l I

Li

Li 80

APPENDIX A Iowa Site Inventory Forms

81

l . l . '.J

. J

lo,wa Site .. lnventory Form State Historic Preservation Office (July 2014)

State Inventory Number: 96-00761 jg! New D Supplemental 9-Digit SHPO Review & Compliance (R&C) !'lumber: __ 0 Non-extant Year:

Read the Iowa Site lnventoty Form Instructions carefully, to ensure accuracy and completeness before completing this form. The instructions are available on our website: b.JJ.p:/!www.iowahistorv. orq/historic­preserva tionlsta le wide-in ve ntorv-a nd-co! /e ct ions/i owa-site-inve nl ory-f arm. h Im!

• Property Name

A) Historic name: =L=e=or:..:.1.:::;B"-ro,,__w'-'-n'-'-"-F""'a""'rm~------------------------------

B) Other names: =B~ro~w~1~1·~s=Z=o~o-------------------------------~

• Location A) Street address: 3105 318 Avenue B) City or town: Cresco (IXJ Vicinity) County:Winneshiek C) Legal description: Rural: Township Name: Orleans Township No.:99N Range No.:1 OW Section: 1Q Quarter: SE of Quarter: SE Urban: Subdivision: Block(s): __ Lot(s): __

• Classification A) Property category: Check only one

0 Building(s) B) Number of resources (within property):

~ District 0 Site· D Structure D Object

If eligible property, enter number of: Contributin Noncontributin

Buildings Sites Structures Ob'ects Total

C) For properties listed in the National Register: National Register status: 0 Listed 0 De-listed 0 NHL 0 NPS DOE

D) For properties within a historic district: 0 Property contributes to a National Register or local certified historic district.

ff non-eligible property, enter number of:

§ Buildings 14 Sites ~ Structures 10 Ob'ects 32 Total

0 Property contributes to a potential historic district, based on ·professional historic/architectural survey and evaluation . 0 Property does not contribute to the historic district in which it is located.

Historic district name: ~N~A~ ___________ Historic district site inventory number: NA

E) Name of related project report or multiple property study, if applicable: MPD title NA

Historical Architectural Data Base # NA

• Function or Use Enter categories (codes and terms) from the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions

A) Historic functions 8) Current functions

09801: Farmstead 70: Vacant/Not in Use)

> 08F: Outdoor Recreation: Zoo/Menagerie

o Description Enter categories (codes and terms) from the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions

A) Architectural classification 8) Materials

09807: Transverse-Frame/Three Portal Barn Foundation (visible exterior): 10B: Poured concrete

Walls (visible exterior): 02A: Weatherboard

Roof: 05F: Steel

Other: Foundation, 04C: Limestone

.. · J C) Narrative description ~ SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED

.J

l

' l

.:J.

. .J

Site Number: 96-00761 Address: 3105 318th Avenue City:Cresco County: Winneshiek District Number:. NA o Statement of Significance A) Applicable National Register Criteria: Mark your opinion of eligibility after applying relevant National Register criteria Criterion A: Property is associated with significant events. D Yes IZl No D More research recommended Criterion B: Property is associated with the lives of significant persons. D Yes IZl No D More research recommended Criterion C: Property has distinctive architectural characteristics. D Yes 1ZJ No D More research recommended Criterion D: Property yields significant information in archaeology/history. D Yes IZl No D More research recommended

B) Special criteria considerations: Mark any special considerations; leave blank if none DA: Owned by a religious institution or used for religious purposes. D E: A reconstructed building, object, or structure. D B:Hemoved from its original location. D F: f.\ commemorative property. D C: A birthplace or grave. D G: Property less than 50 years of page or D D: A cemetery achieved significance within the past 50 years.

C) Areas of significance Enter categories from instructions

D) Period(s) of significance

F) Significant person E) Significant dates Construction date Complete if Criterion Bis marked above 1880s !ZI check if circa or estimated date Other dates, including renovations 1920s

G) Cultural affiliation H) Architect/Builder Architect Complete if Criterion D is marked above

Builder/contractor

I) Narrative statement of significance !ZI SEE CONTINUA T/ON SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED

• Bibliography !ZI See continuation sheets for the list research sources used in preparing this form

• Geographic. Data Optional UTM references D See continuation sheet for additional UTM or comments "a#J11g· ·· · Northing, N/\Q Zone . Easting· Northing : ·· NAO · ·

~','. 2 ·- ", ., ... ·.·. ~--··-·.-··.·

4·._::···· ~~~_. ·.-_· _>_'· ~.::.-:·:. -· --.· • Form Preparation Name and Title: Branden K. Scott, Principal Investigator Date:06/12/2015 Organization/firm: Bear Creek Archeology, Inc. E-mail: Street address: ~P~O~B~o~x~3~4~7 _____________________ Telephone: 563-547-4545

· City or Town: Cresco State: IA Zip code: 52136

• ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION Submit the following itemswith the completed form A) For all properties, attach the following, as specified in the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions:

1. Map of property's location within the community. 2. Glossy color 4x6 photos labeled on back with property/building name, address, date taken, view shown, and unique photo number. 3. Photo key showing each photo number on a map and/or floor plan, using arrows next top each photo number to indicate the location and directional view of each photograph. 4. Site plan of buildings/structures on site, identifying boundaries, public roads, and building/structure footprints.

· B) For State Historic Tax Credit Part 1 Applications, historic districts and farmsteads, and barns: See lists of special requirements and attachments in the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions.

State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) Use Only Below This Line [[{?1?/§f:ll?O h.a,'sfeviewed the Site Inventory and concurs with above survey.opinion on National Register eligibility: •··. i;i:;'.;/'}', .[}yes ·. ·. D No . D More research recommended · · .· . ·. · •

r~~~mtff~;,~;s;s a locally dos;gnared pcoperly ~ parl ol a lo"llY dos;gnaled dfaITTct

i1 "'h:"~:.·:.; ..... ·.· .. . t~f/f(j authorized signature: ___________________ __;.. __ Date.'

I

l

. l .... , ...

J

J l

· .. J

Iowa Site ~nvrtHiltory form State Historic Preservation Office

Continuation Sheet

Pa e 1

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318111 ,l\venue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiek County Cresco City

The fann contains six standing buildings. From east to west, the first building encountered is a garage/carriage house. The garage measures 6.2 m (20.3 ft; east to west) by 6.1 m (20 ft; north to south). The garage has two stalls, set in a side-opening carriage house style. The garage was constrncted using 2 x 4"s set 24" on center. The building is sided with mixed ve1tical wood lapboard and sheet metal. The roof is steel. There is a small loft over the east half of the garage. The east and west sides have four light, single pane windows. It resides on a poured concrete foundation. The single-gable roof is covered with sheet metal. This garage was likely constructed in the 1920s. A hog finishing building is present north and slightly west of the garage. The building measures 7.4 m (24.3 ft) north to south and 12.3 m (40.4 ft) east to west. The building rests upon a poured concfote foundation. The foundation supports the 2 x 4" balloon frame covered with lapboard siding. The single-gable roof is covered with sheet metal. There are five small doors on the south side and one small door on the east side that allowed swine to enter/exit the building. This building was likely constrncted in the 1920s. Southwest of the hog finishing building is a three-portal barn (Leon Brown Barn 1; 96-00762). The barn measures 15.9 m (52.2 ft) east to west and 25.8 m (84.6 ft) north to south. The east and west p01tals consist of individual livestock pens. The central area consists of additional livestock pens and work areas. The barn was constrncted using balloon framing covered with wood siding. The front-gable roof is covered with steel. The east wall has paitially collapsed. Roof joists are tied with collar beams. The barn rests atop a poured concrete foundation. This barn was likely constructed in the 1920s. Another barn is positioned immediately south of barn 96-00762. The southern barn (Leon Brown Barn 2) was assigned inventory number 96-00763. This three-portal barn measures 18.9 m (62 ft) east to we,st by 9.3 m (30.5 ft) n01th to south. This barn was built with hewn timbers. The balloon framing is covered with wood siding. Framing is tied with square and round nails. The interior of this barn gives the appearance that it was used for larger livestock, such as horses and cattle. The barn rests on a limestone foundation that has been patched with concrete. The single-gable roof was constructed with widely spaced roof joists tied with collar beams. Given the foundation, type of wood used, and the presence of square nails, this barn probably dates to the 1880s. This barn appears to be associated with the original farmstead that resided at this location. A machine shed is present west of the barns. The machine shed rests on a poured concrete foundation. The interior framing was constrncted using 2 x 4"s set 32" on center. The building is covered with wood siding. The single-gable roof is covered with steel. The machine shed measures 9.8 m (32.2 ft) east to west by 18.3 m (60 ft) north to south. This building is present on the 1940 aerial photograph and was likely constructed in the 1920s or 1930s. A chicken coop is present in the southern part of the property. The coop measures 11.7 m (38.4 ft) east to west by 5.9 m (19.4 ft) north to south. The chicken coop rests on a poured concrete foundation. The building has a side-gable roof covered with steel. The balloon framing is covered with wood siding. There is a poultry access door on the north side and ventilation windows are present on the south side. This building is present on aerial photographs from 1940 onward; therefore, a 1920s date for constrnction is reasonable.

There are two standing strnctures on the prope1ty. The first is a privy that resides behind the garage. The privy measures 1.8 m (5.9 ft; east to west) by 1.9 m (6.2 ft; north to south). The privy was constmcted using 2 x 4" · wood framing tied together with wood siding. The roof is a single gable covered with sheet metal. The privy rests atop a poured concrete foundation/basin. This structure was likely constructed post-1920. It is difficult to assign this strncture a particular date or range because it is small and difficult to make out on aerial photographs .

. The privy is ce1tainly at this location by 1994. A wire grain bin is present in the western portion of the property. The wire bin is collapsed. It resides on a poured concrete foundation with a 5 m (16.4 ft) diameter. This bin was erected between 1994 and 2002.

The farm has 10 objects. Six of these objects are prope1ty markers. The property markers are located at six locations around the east and south· sides of the farm. Two of these markers are present at each of the two driveway entrances. The other two mark comers. The markers are constrncted from poured concrete. The design

l

l

. :.i ..

.. · ·i

l

. I

.J

Iowa Site inventory Form State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sheet

Page 2

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number: __ _

Winneshiek County Cresco City

of all the markers is consistent, a concrete globe atop a rectangular prism base. The markers measure .8 m (2.6 ft) on all four sides and they are 1.7 m (5.6 ft) high. These markers were probably installed at the same time as the fountain. This period would con-espond to the prope1ty's use as a menagelie (ca. 1950s). A poured concret(: fountain is located in the eastern pait of the property. The base of this fountain measures 3.9 m (12.8 ft) in diameter. Historic photographs indicate that this fountain was known as the "Eagle Fountain" because of the large concrete eagle that sat at the pinnacle. The fountain also had bear, swan, and flamingo statues. This fountain was likely installed in the 1950s, probably betwee.n 1952 (potential absence from aerial photographs) and 1955. A well was observed in the northern part of the property between the garage and the hog finishing building. The well is noted by a concrete cap. The well cap measures approximately 1 m (3.3 ft) in diameter. A poured concrete water trough is located near the center of the farmstead between the two standing barns. The water trough measures 8.5 m (27.9 ft) north to south and 4.3 m (14.1 ft) east to west. It is unclear when this water trough was constructed. A cistern was noted at the fonner house location. This cistern was positioned underneath a house addition, indicating that the house was built over it. This brick-lined cistern has a diameter of approximately 1 m (3.3 ft) and it is approximately 3.7 m (12 ft) deep. The cistern is associated with the original 1880s house.

The farmstead includes 14 features that are considered sites. Sites include poured concrete grain bin pads/foundation, poured concrete foundations, a depression at a former building/structure location, the foundation for a pump house, the house foundation, and a dilapidated barn. The house on this property has burned to the ground and much of the building material has been removed. All that remains of the house is the foundation. The house was in-egularly shaped with multiple additions. The foundation measures a maximum of 15.6 m (51.2 ft; east to west) by 14.9 m (48.9 ft; north to south). The southeast part of the house was the oldest part of the building based on the foundation. The foundation in this area was constructed using limestone. Additions to the original building led to foundation changes. Later foundation additions were constructed using brick and concrete. The northwestern portion of the house site does not have an excavated foundation. Instead, the northwestern portion of the former house location consists of a poured concrete pad. Framing materials that were left at the site indicate a mixture of round and square nails indicative of multiple construction episodes. A photograph of the house prior to demolition offers insights into the final design. The photograph depicts a front and side gable house with the front oriented to the east. The house was 1 Yi story with double hung windows and a picture window on the first floor of the east site. An addition to the northwest had a single gable. While a second floor was present in the addition, the roof elevation was slightly lower than the older part of the building. Fenestration generally allowed light through two windows in each room. There was limited cross lighting due to constraints from the roof form. Builders added an entrance to the basement on the north side of the building. A covered porch was present on the northeast corner of the home. One barn has fallen down and it is considered a site. This building was a three-portal barn with a gable roof. The gable roof was covered with steel. The barn sat atop a poured concrete foundation. The barn was framed using wood balloon framing. The width of the barn was 18 m (59.1 ft; east to west). The length of the barn could not be measured with a tape measure. Aei;ial photographs indicate that the barn had a length of approximately 18.6 m (61 ft; north to south). A foundation for a pump house/windmill is present north of the fonner house location. The steel framing of the windmill is still present. The pump house, however, was consumed by fire. A picture of the building right after the house fire shows a small single gable shed at this location. The foundation of the pump house measured approximately 2.5 m (8.2 ft) square. The fannstead has five grain bin foundations/pads. Each of these was formed using poured concrete and they have a 5 m (16.4 ft) diameter. One of these foundations is octagonal while the others are round. There are also five poured concrete foundations associated with outbuildings and garages. A depression associated with a former buildmg/structure is present in the northwest part of the farmstead. A building is

.l

·.J

.. !

.J

J .

. J

Iowa Site Inventory Form State Historic Preservation Office

Continuation Sheet

Pa e 3

Leon Brown Farm Name of Properly 3105 318111 Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiek County Cresco City

depicted at this location in 1964 and it is gone by 1971. The depression measures approximately 8 m (26.2 ft) in diameter and is roughly circular. This location contained a small outbuilding.

This farm is not a significant property as it concerns regional agriculture. The significance to broader patterns of . history would be derived due to its use as a small, rural menagerie. While the location is good, design, materials, feeling, and association lack integrity. Most importantly, design, feeling, and association lack integrity. This property does not have a menagerie layout, it does not feel like a menagerie, and aspects of the property that would provide direct correlation to menagerie use have been removed or they are masked by fann functions. The buildings and structures at the Leon Brown Fann are typical of buildings built during the late 1800s and 1920s. These types of buildings are extremely common and there is nothing notable about the architecture even though most of the buildings meet integrity requirements. The Leon Brown Farm and its associated buildings is recommended not eligible for the National Register of Historic Places.

Reference

Scott, Branden K. 2015 Surface and Architectural li1vestigations of the Leon Brown Farm and Menagerie, Orleans Township,

Winneshiek County, Iowa. Special Repo1i 5. Bear Creek Archeology, Inc., Cresco, Iowa.

J

J l

I , .. )

Iowa Site lnventog·y form State Historic: Preservation Office Continuation Sheet

Pa e 4

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshie!<: County Cresco Cily

Topographic coverage of the Leon Brown Farm.

j

j

.. 1

l l

.. · J

.. J

Iowa Site lnrventory Form State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sheet

Pa e 5

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318'h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiel\ County Cresco City

0-Leon Brown Farm 0-Building/Structure

o -Potential Building (Not Relocated)

Scale map of the Leon Brown Farm .

I

I

I

I

I

l l

'.J·

I l

l r

! ! _J

Iowa Site inventory Form State Historic Pres13nrntion Office

Continuation Sheet

Page 6

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318111 Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District !\lumber:

Winneshiek County Cresco City

Overview of the Leon Brown Farm. View to the northwest (5/13/15).

:.J )

l.

)

' J

. • J

Iowa Site lnventm11 Fornn1 State Historic Preservation Office Continuatiaff1 Sheet

Pa e 7

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 3·18111 Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiel\ County Cresco City

Garage/carriage house at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

Garage/carriage house at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15) .

· .. ) · ... ·

1

j

: .J

Iowa Site h11v<erntmlf Form State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sheet

Pa e 8

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318 11

' Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiel< County Cresco City

Hog finishing building at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

Hog finishing building at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

l I

l · 1

·· ...

]

l .. J·

··.. I

l .. J

Iowa Site lnve1n1tory Fonn State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sheet

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Pa e 9

Leon Brown Farm Name of Properiy 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Winneshiel<: County Cresco City

Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15) .

Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

l

l .

l ~l

·. ·. J

. .1

.l

.J .J

J . J

l . J

_J .

Iowa Site lrrvent©ry Form State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sh®et

Pa e 10

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318lh Avenue Address

Site [\lumber: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiek County Cresco Cily

Loft of the three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

l I

l

I )

!

l

.. l

J

l ·· .. J

l ..1

._J

Iowa Site lnventorry form State Historic Preservation Office

Continuatnrn1 ~Hll®®~:

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District f\Jumber:

Pa e 11

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 31811'-Avenue Address

Winneshiel<: County Cresl;O City

Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15).

Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

l

l l l l

.l

.I

. .

l . : ~:! . ·.

l J· J l

· ... l _J

Iowa Site ~nvern~VJulf f'oin1rn State Historic PmservaHon OHice Continuatiof{i] rn11C8l0t(

Pa e 12

Leon Brown Fann Name of Property 3105 3181

" Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winnesl1ielc County Cresco City

Loft of the livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15) .

'

Machine shed at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the southwest (5/13/15).

.. '· . ·1

J

-.l

.. J

J

Iowa Site hnv<BHil~O.Rlf f'on1111 State Historic PreservaiJon Office Continuation §h~1~r[

Pa e 13

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318'h Avenue Address·

Site !\lumber: 96-0076'1 Related District Number:

\J\finneshiel\ County Cresco City

Chicken coop at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

Chicken coop at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15).

j

!

l l J

.... · 1

J J J

.·· .. )

J .. · J

'•·

Iowa Site ~nveu11~m'~f form State Historic Preservation Office

Continuation Sh®®~

Pa e 14

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiel<: County Cresco City

Privy at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15). ·

Concrete piroperty marker at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

l

» > -.' ·1

:: J »

> > -__ -_-·] >

>J

_J

Iowa 'Site ~nv~n11~m]f form State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sh®®tc

Pa e 15

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318'h Avenue Address

Site !\lumber: 96-00761 Related Dist1-ict Number:

Winneslliel\ County Cresco City

Fountain at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15).

Well at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

' l J

: l

' ' J ......

. . l

J ' ... J

'j

Iowa Site lfrllVef(]Jtrn)f IFori·m State Historic Pn:isenration OfficG Continuat001n1 Sh®et

Pa e 16

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 318111 Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

County Cresco City

Water trough at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

I

l.

. · .. l .. ·.·. .j

: . ]

Iowa Site lruv~rr~tory Form State Historic Pr0s0rv<:itkm Ofii<C!G Continuatiorrn ShtBlet

Pa e 17

Leon Brown Farm Name of Properly 3105 3181

h Avenuo Address

Site !\lumber: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshielc County Cresco City

Former house location at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15) .

Former house location at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

l

l L

' ]

··, " ···1 ·

.J J

.. I

l

J

.. .J.

Iowa Site ~nve~1fcori'y [F(!)rrm State Historic Prn!i>enmtkm OtficG

C t • t" OU ~ on mua mril .0iuuee~

Pa e 18

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site !\lumber: 96-00761 Related District [\lumber:

Win11esl1iel;: County Cresco City

House at the Leon Brown Farm prior to the fire. View to the southwest

..

J

· 1 I I

1

l · 1

l l

.. l l ] ·

l

l

J ·

.l

J

Iowa Site lfrllV((3)fill'[ory Form State Historic Preservation Office ContinuaUorn Su11~e[

Pa e 19

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiek County Cresco City

Ruinous barn at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

i.

Ruinous barn at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

I

· .... ·· .. 1·

·1 l

J .. J

; .....

l J

l

. . .J

Iowa. Site h~v~n[rn)f IForrm State Historic Pr0senratfon Offico

Continuatiorni Sha1He~

Page 20

Leon Brown Farm Name of Prope1iy 3105 3181hAvenue Address

Site Number: 96-00761 Related District Number:

Winneshiek County Cresco City

Pump house/windmill foundation at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

Example of grain bin foundations at the Leon Brown Farm. View to tb.e north (5/13/15) .

)

.· ~· j ..

. /· 1

... J · 1

..• I.

. ·.. l

l

J ~

.l

.· 'J .· ,J

Iowa Site ~nvenlcrnry f onrn State Historic Preservai:ion Offic0 Continuation Sh®®li:

Pa e 21

Leon Brown Farm Name of Property 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site f\lurnber: 96~00761 Related District f\Jumber:

\fl/inneslliel<: County Ci"l?.SCO

City

Depression at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15) .

·1

' J

l

Iowa Site Inventory Fonn S.tate Historic Preservation Office (July 2014)

State Inventory l\Jumber: 96-00762 ~ New D Supplemental 9-Digit SHPO Review & Compliance (R8,C) Number: __ D Non-extant Year:

Read the Iowa Site lmren!.rny Form Instructions carefully, to ensure accuracy and completeness before completing this form. The instructions are available on our we/Jsite: h!i1J.l/ww1'.J!:jo1vahiston1corq!hisloric­preservation!state wide-in 1m nl 01J1-a nrf-c;QI I e s:_lj_cm.st0_yy_a-.si{e-in_,1_H nf ory-f orm. h I ml

• Property Name A) Historic name: Leon =B-'-ro=-v'"'""v'-'-n-"B'"""a"'"r'""'"n-'·1 _____________________________ _

• Location A) Street address: 3105 318 Avenue B) City or town:Cresco (IX] Vicinity) County:Winneshiel<: C) Legal description: Rural: Township Name: Orleans Township No. :99N Range No.: 1 OW Section: 16 Quarter: SE of Quarter: SE Urban: Subdivision: Blocl<(s): __ Lot(s): __

• Classification A) Property category: Check only one

(gl Building( s) B) Number of resources (within property):

D District D Site D Structure D .Object

If eligible property, enter number of: Contributin Noncontributin

Buildings Sites Structures Ob'ects Total

C) For properties listed in the National Register: National Register status: D Listed D De-listed D NHL D NPS DOE

D) For properties within a historic district: D Property contributes to a National Register or local certified historic district.

If non-eligible property, enter number of:

1 Buildings Sites Structures Ob'ects

1 Total

D Property contributes to a potential historic district, based on professional historic/architectural survey and evaluation. (gl Property does not contribute to the historic district in which it is located.

Historic district name: Leon Brown Farm Historic district site inventory number: 96-00762

E) Name of related project report or multiple property study, if applicable: MPD title

_NA Historical Architectural Data Base # NA

• Function or Use Enter categories (codes and terms) from the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions

A) Historic functions B) Current functions

09H01: Barn. General Purpose 70: Vacant/Not in Use)

. '

• Description Enter categories (codes and terms) from the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions

A) Architectural classification B) Materials

09B07: Transverse-Frame/Three Portal Barn Foundation (visible exterior): 10B: Poured concrete

Walls (visible exterior): 02A: Weatherboard

Roof: 05F: Steel

Other:

. .! C) Narrative ·description [3'.] SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED

: l

I J \,•

J. :J

. : l . '

Site Number: 96-00762 Address: 3105 318 111 Avenue City: Cresco County: Winneshiek District Number: 96-00762 Leon Brown Farm

• Statement of Significance A) Applicable National Register Crih;iria: Mark your opinion of eligibility after applying relevant National Register criteria Criterion A: Property is associated with significant events. D Yes IS] No D More research recommended Criterion B: Property is associated with the lives of significant persons. D Yes IS! No D fvlore research recommended Criterion C: Property has clislinclive architectural characteristics. D Yes IS! No D More research recommended Criterion D: Property yields significant information in archaeology/history. D Yes IS! No D More research recommended

B) Special criteria considerations: Marie any special considerations; leave blank if none D A: Owned by a religious instilulion or used for religious purvoses. D E: A reconstructed building, object, or structure. D B: Removed from its original location. D F: A commemorative properly. D C: A birthplace or grave. . D G: Proper-ty less than 50 years of page or D D: A cemetery achieved significance within the past 50 years.

C) Areas of significance Enter categories from instructions

E) Significant dates Construction date 1920s [2J check if circa or estimated date Other dates, including renovations

G) Cultural affiliation Complete if Criterion D is marked above

D) Period(s) of significance

F) Significant person Complete if Criterion B is marked above

H) Architect/Builder Architect

Builder/contractor

I) Narrative statement of significance 0 SEE CONTINUATION SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED

• Bibliography 0 See continuation sheets for the list research sources used in preparing this form

• Geographic Data Optional UTM references D See continuation sheet for additional UTM or comments <-- slib1{ Northing NAO . , Zone Easting . Northing NAO .

~····· .... 2

_· .. _··: 4 -·-·-·

• Form Preparation Name and Title: Branden K. Scott, Principal Investigator Date:06/12/2015 Organization/firm: Bear Creel< Archeology, Inc. E-mail: Street address: .._P-=0_,B""'o"""x~3,_4'""'7 ____________________ Telephone: 563-547-4545 City or Town: Cresco State: IA Zip code: 52136 ·

I

• ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION Submit the following items with the completed form A) For all properties, attach the following, as specified in the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions:

1. Map of property's location within the community. 2. Glossy color 4x6 photos labeled on back with property/building name, address, date tal<en, view shown, and unique photo number. 3. Photo key showing each photo number on a map and/or floor plan, using arrows next top each photo number to indicate the location and directional view of each photograph .

. 4. Site plan pf buildings/structures on site, identifying boundaries, public roads, and building/structure footprints. B) For State Historic Tax Credit Part 1 Applications, historic districts and farmsteads, and barns:

See lists of special requirements and attachments in the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions .

State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) Use Only Below This Line LThJf:S.rf PO ~IJ.~{$:f~v;eWed .fh.e Sit~ Inventory and concurs with above survey opinion on National .Register eligibility.~;':. ; ·,-.~.,'>:>·· · ·-(::~.:~:.::;j:~< ... F\\; ::::.;;[}Yes.<: ·.· . .D No . D More research recommended · . ·.· · .•· , ",'.,,V,· ''\;,:'!;,; ;//;;'.''· '[])'his isaJocal/y designated property or part of a locally designated district. .. c: .'}: :~\;~>;,;';<

.

: •. ~~ •. ,'-·.; .. G,·.-.·.:_···,'..·:···6:~ .. ·.~.·.m···.,:·.···.·.· ••• ~_,'m.• .. : .. :·····.·e,.· •. ·:!1··.·.·· t::·,s·:··~? ·,; •:: '<':::' /; , ,:'.:: ·· ·· ··· · ~.;,,\Ui:~t;{:

I

1

I l

<.·( .

.··,r

l

l ... )

'.J

l . · 1

· .. ·

'J ,· .... l.

Iowa Site inventory fonn State Historic Preservation Office

Continuation Sheet

Pa e 1

Leon Brown Barn ·1 Name of Property 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00762 Related District Number: 96-00761

Winneshiel<: County Creo;co City

This barn has a three-portal design. The barn measures 15.9 111 (52.2 ft) east to west and 25.8 m (84.6 ft) north to south. The east and west portals consist of individual livestock pens. The central area consists of additional livestock pens and work areas. The barn was constrncted using balloon framing covered with wood siding. The front-gable roof is covered with steel. The east wall has partially collapsed. Roof joists are tied with collar beams. The barn rests atop a poured concrete foundation. This barn was likely constructed in the 1920s. This barn occurs at a fo1mer menagerie. While it was certainly a part of the farm and menagerie operation, this building is similar to any other barn in the upper Midwest. The construction method was typical of barns constructed in the 1920s. There is no structural evidence that this barn functioned to house exotic animals. The parn is typical of buildings built during the 1920s. These types of buildings are extremely common and there is nothing notable about the architecture of this particular barn. This barn is recommended not eligible for the National Register.·

Reference

Scott, Branden K. 2015 Swface and Architectural Investigations of the Leon Brown Farm and Menagerie, Orleans

Township, Winneshiek County, Iowa. Special Repo1i 5. Bear Creek Archeology, Inc., Cresco, Iowa.

I I

I l

J 'l

1,

[

)

.J

' l

· ... :J.

l

,-l

Iowa Site lnv®ntou11 Forrm State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sh~et

Pa e 2

Leon Brown Barn 1 Name of Property 3105 318'h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00762 Related District Number: 96-00761

Winneslliel\ County Cresco City

Topographic coverage of the Leon Brown Farm.

.. ' ·.· !

·.,J

.l J

J

- J

Iowa Site ~rnventory Fonri State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sheet

Page 3

Leon Brown Barn 1 Name of Property 3105 318'h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00762 Related District Number: 96-00761

Winneslliel\ County Cresco City

0-Leon Brown Fann 0-Building/Structure

o -Potential Building (Not Relocated)

0

Scale map of the Leon Brown Farm.

j'

l.

··,' l , ..

' ' 1

l 1)

·.·_J·

·' ' l ......

.J r

'.J.

' < 1

J

Iowa Site lniv®ll1lt«:»rjf form State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Sheet

Pa e 4

Leon Brown Barn 1 Name of Property 3105 318'i.Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00762 Related District Number: 96-00761

Winnesiliel\ County Cresco City

Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the east (5/13/15).

~·; :..;.... --·..> ---.-.: ........

;;,:, L~~i ··.· Three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

)

j

I

'l .J

,. l . ·-·· .

·. ,' i

J , ! )· ·.

· .. J

•, J

'j

.J

Iowa Site lravenfoiry Form State Historic Preseivatkm Office ContinuatkH111 She~t

Pa e 5

Leon Brown Barn ·1 Name of Prope1iy 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00762 Related District Number: 96-00761

Winneshiek County Cresco City

Loft of the three-portal barn (96-00762) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15).

.. '.··i·· '·•. .

..

··.1

. l ... l

( .. ~· .

l j

I )

l

Iowa Site Inventory Form State Historic Preservation Office (July 2014)

State Inventory Number: 96-00763 ~ New 0 Supplemental 9-Digit SHPO Review & Compliance (R&C) f\lumber: __ 0 Non-extant Year:

Read the Iowa Site lr1vento1y Form lnslructions carnfu!ly, to ensure accuracy and completeness before completing this form. The instructions are available on our website: fJ.1{p:/(www.io1,i~c1/]isJrJ1X.C!Cg!J?j:;;.LQJif..:. preservationlstatewide-inventorv-and-co!/ections/iowa-sile··fnventorv-form.html

• Property Name A) Historic name: Leon Brown Barn 2

B) Other names:

• Location

A) Street address: .::.3_,_10=-5=-=-3-'-'18"--'A'--'-v.:...;e;:,_n""u=e-----------=~----------------B) City or tqwn:Cresco (IZ! Vicinity) County:Winneshiel< C) Legal description: Rural: Township Name: Orleans Township No.:99N Range No.:1 OW Section: 1.§. Quarter: SE of Quarter: SE Urban: Subdivision: Blocl<(s): __ Lot(s): __

• Classification A) Property category: Check only one

t8J Building( s) B) Number of resources {within property):

O District 0 Site 0 Structure 0 Object

ff eligible property, enter number of: Contributin Noncontributin

Buildings Sites Structures Ob'ects Total

C) For properties listed in the National Regis~er: National Register status: D Listed D De-listed D NHL D NPS DOE

D) For properties within a historic district: O Property contributes to a National Register or local certified historic district.

If non-eligible property, enter number of:

1 Buildings Sites Structures Objects

1 Total

O Property contributes to a potential historic district, based on professional historic/architectural survey and evaluation. t8J Property does not contribute to the historic district in which it is located.

Historic district name: Leon Brown Farm Historic district site inventory number: 96-00761

E) Name of related project report or multiple property study, if applicable: MPD title NA

Historical Architectural Data Base # NA

• Function or Use Enter categories (codes and terms) from the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions

A) Historic functions B) Current functions

09H01: Barn. General Purpose 70: Vacant/Not in Use}

• Description Enter categories (codes and terms) from the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions

A) Architectural classification B) Materials

09807: Transverse-Frame/Three Portal Barn Foundation (visible exterior): 04C: Limestone

Walls (visible exterior): OZA: Weatherboard

Roof: 05F: Steel

Other:

C) Narrative description ~ SEE CONTINUA T/ON SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED

J

:1

·r

!J. .. " ·.·J . .

. ...r·

l _J.

•J

Site Number: 96-00763 Address: 3105 3181h Avenue City:Cre_s_c;!:) County: \l\finnE)shiel\ District Number: 9_E)-00761

• Statement of Significance A) Applicable National Register Criteria: Mark your opinion of eligibility after applying relevant National Register criteria Criterion A: Property is associated with significant events. 0 Yes~ No 0 fVlore research recommended Criterion B: Property is associated with the lives of significant persons. 0 Yes~ No D fVlore research recommended Criterion C: Property has distinctive architectural characteristics. 0 Yes~ No 0 fvlore research recommended Criterion D: Property yields significant information in archaeology/histo1y. 0 Yes~ No D fVlor·e r·esearch recommended

B) Special criteria considerations: Marl< any special considerations; leave /Jlani< if none DA: Owned by a religious institution or used for religious purposes. D E: A reconstrncted building, object, or structure. DB: Removed from its original location. 0 F: A commemorative property. 0 C: A birthplace or grave. 0 G: Property less than 50 years of page or 0 D: A cemetery achieved significance within the past 50 years.

C) Areas of significance Enter categories from instructions

E) Significant dates Construction date 1880s [8] check ifcirca or estimated date

. Other dates, including renovations

G) Cultural affiliation Complete If Criterion D is marked above

D) Period(s) of signHicam::e

f) Significant person Complete if Criterion B is marked above

H) Architect/Builder Architect

Builder/contractor

I) Narrative statement of significance ~ SEE CONTINUA T/ON SHEETS, WHICH MUST BE COMPLETED

• Bibliography [8] See continuation sheets for the list research sources used in preparing this form

• Form Preparation

Name and Title: Branden K. Scott, Principal Investigator Date:06/12/2015 Organization/firm: Bear Creel< Archeology, Inc. E-mail: Street address: ,_P...:::Oc..:B=-o=x,,_3=-4-'-'7 ____________________ Telephone: 563-547-4545 City or Town: Cresco State: IA Zip code: 52136

• ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTATION Submit the following items with the completed form

A) For all properties, attach the following, as specified in the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions: 1. Map of property's location within the community. 2. Glossy color 4x6 photos labeled on back with property/building name, address, date taken, view shown, and unique photo number. 3. Photo key showing each photo number on a map and/or floor plan, using arrows next top each photo number to indicate the location and directional view of each photograph. 4. Site plan of buildings/structures on site, identifying boundaries, public roads, and building/structure footprints.

B) For State Historic Tax Credit Part 1 Applications, historic districts and farmsteads, and barns: See lists of special requirements and attachments in the Iowa Site Inventory Form Instructions.

State Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) Use Only Below This Line iTfie:SHPQhas reviewed the Site Inventory and concurs with above survey opinion on National Register eligibility: :,•, · 0 Yes · 0 No D More research recommended ; ; · · . 0 . This is a locally designated property or part of a locally designated district. i'·

t\.:< ',,.: .. :,·. ··.· .: .', :: ... ~SHPO authorized signature: _____________________ _

·.,: -;.:;·;; ·,.

·( _._ ... _ ·:-:·: ." '·>:. ~. Date:

l.

l ' f .

l

J I ·i --·

. . .J

.. l

l J !

.. J

Iowa Site Inventory Form State Historic Preservation Office

Continuation Sh®~t

Pa e 1

Leon Brown Barn 2 Name of Properly 3105 3181

h Avenue Address

Site f\lumber: 96-00763 Related District Number: 96-00761

Winneshiel( County Cresco City

This three-portal barn measures 18.9 rn (62 ft) east to west by 9.3 m (30.5 ft) north to south. This barn was built with hewn timbers. The balloon framing is covered with wood siding. Framing is tied with square and round nails. The interior of this barn gives the appearance that it was used for larger livestock, such as horses and cattle. The barn rests on a limestone foundation that has been patched with concrete. The single-gable roof was constructed with widely spaced roof joists tied with collar beams. Given the foundation, type of wood used, and the presence of square nails, this barn probably dates to the 1880s. This barn appears to be associated with the original farmstead that resided at this location. This barn was part of both a fann and a menagerie. However, the use of this barn for exotic animals is masked by its more common use for commercial livestock. The barn has been altered with new roofing materials and poured concrete and it has a design common to many barns across the upper Midwest. This barn is recommended not eligible for the National Register of Historic Places.

Reference

Scott, Branden K. 2015 Surface and Architectural Investigations of the Leon Brown Farm and Menagerie, Orleans

Township, Winneshiek County, Iowa. Special Report 5. Bear Creek Archeology, Inc., Cresco, Iowa.

J

J .:J

·::-- : .

·.·.·i

. .l

I

.J·

.J ' l

:.J

Iowa Site ~nv®n~orry Forrn1 State Historic Preservation Office Contim .. rn1tkm She®t

Pa e 2

Leon Brown Barn 2 Name of Property 3105 318'11 Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00763 Related District !\lumber: 96-00761

\f\/inneshie!< County Cresco City

Topographic coverage of the Leon Brown Farm.

. · .. i

l

" . J

.J.

J J

J ·. J

. J· j

Iowa Site lruventon1r f«Jrm State Historic Preservation Office Continuation Shteet

Pa e 3

Leon Brown Barn 2 Name of Property 3105 318th Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00763 Related District Number: 96-00761

Winneshieh: County Cresco City

f=i-Leon Brown Fann 0-Building/Structure

o -Potential Building (Not Relocated)

Scale map of the Leon Brown Farm .

,J .... J

. ·i ·. -·

'j l .I

! .\

l

l Iowa Site ~nventm~y f©irm State Historic Preservation OHice Continuation Sh~~[

Site !'lumber: 96-00763 Related District Number: 96-00761

Pa e 4

Leon Brown Barn 2 Name of Property 3105 318111 Avenue Address

Winneshiek County Cresco City

Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the south (5/13/15) .

Livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the west (5/13/15).

J

l .

l · ,. . ·.J ..

j . ·· 1

. J

Iowa Site ~nve1n1tou1f f oirm State Historic Prn$&1'V<011:io111 Office

Continuation Sheet

Pa e 5

Leon Brown Barn 2 Name of Properly 3105 318 11

' Avenue Address

Site Number: 96-00763 Related District Number: 96-00761

\/If in neslliel\ County Cresco City

Loft of the livestock barn (96-00763) at the Leon Brown Farm. View to the north (5/13/15) .