67
Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card (EBSC) Update Morris Brown Janet Harthen Dale Zajac Supplier Relations Supplier Quality Supplier Quality- Warranty [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] June, 2011

Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card

(EBSC) Update

Morris Brown Janet Harthen Dale Zajac

Supplier Relations Supplier Quality Supplier Quality-

Warranty

[email protected] [email protected] [email protected]

June, 2011

Page 2: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Quotes

Logistics

Financial Risk

TS 16949

MMOG/LE

How EBSC is used in sourcing

2

EBSC

Market Share

Fiat

Purchasing

Technology

Bid List Commodity and

Supplier Strategy

Sourcing

Decision

Page 3: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

3

EBSC- 5 Equal Value Drivers (Production) Suppliers

20%

20%

20%

20%

20%

Quality Delivery

Warranty

Partnership

Cost

Bold Value Drivers Have Been

Changed for 2011

20%

20%

20%

20%

20%

2011

Product Dev.

Process

Delivery Quality

Cost Partnership

2010

Page 4: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC 2011 EBSC

4

Benefits:

• Eliminates reconciliation of quarterly

EBSC and monthly detail report

numbers by suppliers and Chrysler

employees

• Corporate sustainability assessment

is a differentiator for Chrysler

• Mouse-over functionality to reveal

descriptions and formulas for

measures

• Better visibility of MOPAR

performance on production

scorecard

Supplier / Commodity Scorecard

Report Parameters

Year: 2011

BU: Production Source Hold: Yes - Commercial

Supplier: 32213 F - WP Chrysler, Inc. Source Restriction: No

Address: 1207 Chrysler Road, Kokomo IN 46901 Financial Risk Rating: High Risk

Commodity: 23BA - Non-Decorative Injection Moldings Service Parts (MOPAR): Yellow

Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Target/Weight

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun - Dec

YTD

Quality (20%) 59% 59% 76% 33% 0% 0%

AQP / NCT Composite 100 64 69 57 53 96 96

100% 64% 69% 57% 53% 96% 96%

Non-Conforming Material - Prod (NC Tickets) 0 8 7 4 5 1 1

52% 58% 76% 70% 94% 94%

Advance Quality Planning 100 100 100 98 98

100% 100% 98% 98%

Forever Requirements Violation (occurrence) 1 1

Containments (Yardholds) (occurrence) 1 1 1

3CPR Level 1 1

3CPR Level 2 1

TS 16949 Certification Y Y Y Y Y Y

Q Hold N N N N Y Y

Delivery (20%) 100% 93% 91% 94% 98% 98%

Delivery Conformance 100 100 100 100 100 100 100

65% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Response Conformance 100 100 92 90 94 96 96

35% 100% 92% 90% 94% 96% 96%

CLS/CLD (occurrence) 1 1 1 1 1 1

MMOG/LE (deduction) Y Y N N N N

Warranty (20%) 70% 68% 82% 82% 85% 85%

Supplier Associated Warranty (C's/1000) 3.69 4.2 4.5 3.91 3.91 3.78 3.78

100% 70% 68% 82% 82% 85% 85%

Cost (20%) 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Annual Combined (000's) $1,250 $57 $79 $256 $646 $656 $656

100% 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Commercial Contribution (000's) $57 $79 $390 $400 $400

Technical Contribution (000's) $256 $256 $256 $256

Idea(s) Submitted N N Y

Partnership (20%) 52% 54% 56% 49% 51% 51%

Purchasing Support 10 8 8 8 5 5 5

50% 80% 80% 80% 50% 50% 50%

Diversity (000's) $580 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $250

25% 8.6% 17.2% 25.9% 34.4% 43.1% 43.1%

Corporate Sustainability 5 2 2 2 3 3 3

25% 40% 40% 40% 60% 60% 60%

Overall 64% 60% 73% 69% 62% 62%

Deduction of points to overall

Delivery Grade each month,

due to not submitting the

MMOG/LE self-assessment

scores by the assigned

deadline. Deduction for no

submission: 15 points for

Direct Ship suppliers, 30

points for a SPD / Module or

PAB supplier.

Page 5: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Quality Enhancements

5

Quality (20%) Target/

Weight Jan Feb Mar YTD

59% 59% 76% 0%

AQP / NCT Composite 100 64 69 57 96

100% 64% 69% 57% 96%

Non-Conforming

Material - Prod (NC

Tickets)

0 8 7 4 1

52% 58% 76% 94%

Advance Quality

Planning

100 100 100 98

100% 100% 98%

Forever Requirements

Violation (occurrence)

1 1

Containments

(Yardholds) (occurrence)

1

3CPR Level 1 1

3CPR Level 2 1

TS 16949 Certification Y Y Y Y

Q Hold N N N Y

• AQP is now

under Quality

• Potential

deductions

have been

added for

3CPR Levels 1

& 2

• TS 16949;

Quality New

Business Hold

included

Aligned with supplier quality bid list

Page 6: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

6

How to Improve Your Quality Score

Take training in the source systems: NCT, CQMS, etc.

Request access to the source systems in the Chrysler Supplier Portal

(Covisint)

Source systems contain the most current information, usually updated

daily, rather than waiting for a monthly update on the scorecard

Look at web sites, especially home pages of applications for updates

Learn how to run reports in source systems

Learn how to run deliverable due reports 30 days in advance

Make sure any parts sourced to your location are your parts

Look at your scorecard frequently. Files are uploaded as received from

source systems (usually over the weekend)

The Quality Value Driver is usually fully loaded by the 3rd week of the

month

Page 7: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Quality Value Driver 2011

7

Page 8: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

AQP/NCT Composite Score

8

Page 9: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC AQP/NCT Composite Score

9

This measurement is a composite of the AQP (Advance Quality

Planning) and NCT (Non Conformance Tracking) measurements

Calculated as ¼ of the AQP value plus ¾ of

the NCT value

Formula: (AQP FFR * 25%) + (NCT FFR *75%)

Example: (60 * 25%) + (80 * 75%)

Page 10: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Advance Quality Planning

AQP

10

Page 11: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

11

Advance Quality Planning (AQP)

The AQP measure is a percentage of required

responses submitted to CQMS before the

appropriate due date

Calculation: # Deliverables Submitted

# Deliverables Due

Target is 100% of responses submitted on time

Cumulative rolling 6 month score

Page 12: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

12

2011 AQP Measurement Business Rules

• If there are no tasks due within the current month, the

score will be null (blank) for the month (not 0%)

• No credit is given for responses entered after the due date

• If a part is incorrectly sourced it will still be included in the

BSC for IRE, AQP and PPAP tasks.

• Please work with the Chrysler buyer to correct any

sourcing issue prior to the month end

• Effective 3/11/2011

• Mandatory tasks that are not approved will be scored in

between Quality Gates

• Task promise dates must be kept current at all times in

order to avoid a negative score

Page 13: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Exemptions from AQP Scoring

13

• AQP and PPAP tasks created in the current

and previous calendar months are exempt

from scoring

• If a Quality Gate date is moved into the current

or previous months, it is exempt from scoring

for AQP and PPAP tasks

• Cancelled parts with an effective out date

occurring in the scoring month are exempt

from scoring (out date = last date the part will be placed on a vehicle)

Page 14: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

AQP IBSC/EBSC Weights and Scoring - Effective January 2011

14

Page 15: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

15

AQP Supplier Reports - Web

Suppliers need to request access to the “AQP Supplier Reports” link

from their Security Administrator. The link is located under the

Applications tab in the Chrysler portal. It will help you understand your

AQP score.

Page 16: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC AQP Supplier Reports - Web

16

5 Reports

Page 17: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

17

AQP Supplier Reports - Web

Page 18: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

AQP Supplier Reports - Web

18

Page 19: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

19

AQP Supplier Reports - Web

Page 20: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Non-Conformance Tracking

NCT

20

Page 21: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

21

Non Conformance Tracking

• Nonconformance Tracking System is source

system

• Cumulative rolling 6 month score

• Non-conforming tickets that change to a

status that is not scored are adjusted in the

current month calculation

Page 22: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

NCT Adjustments

• Adjustments

- Resolved disputed tickets (possible NC quantity or defect code)

- Voided or cancelled tickets

• Defect Codes that do not count against suppliers

- NPNP – Notice of Shipment of Potential Non-

Conforming Parts (pro-active notification)

- NPCO – No Parts Cost Only

- DCC – Directed Consigned Component

- DCNC – Directed Component Non-Conformance

Page 23: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

23

NCT Ticket FFR Calculation

[1-6 * (8-4)/( 4+100)] *100

[1-6 * 4/104] *100

[1-6*.384615]*100

[1-.230769] *100

=.769231*100

= 76.9

= 77 % FFR

T = Target = 4 C= Current = 8

Formula: (1- 6*(C-T)/(T+100) ) *100

Page 24: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

24

Best-in-Class Definition

• NCT uses a Best-In-Class (BIC)

methodology to determine the target for

each 4 digit commodity code.

• Suppliers that ship the same local

commodity code are grouped together and

the best performance is used to determine

the 2011 target for all suppliers that ship that

commodity

Page 25: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Suppliers in

Local code

12AA

Receipts

Those under the

20% floor are

eliminated from

participating in BIC

Suppliers able

to participate

in BIC

Supplier A 500 500 500

Supplier B 660 660 660

Supplier C 25 25

Supplier D 10 10

Supplier E 15 15

Supplier F 85 85 85

Supplier G 32 32

Average 189.57

20% 37.91

25

NCT Ticket Targets - Example

BIC Floor = (average of receipts for local commodity code)*0.20

Page 26: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

26

Target Setting For NC Tickets

NC Tickets Target = 4 x .90 =

3.6

Tickets

12345 Supplier A 6

15542 Supplier B 12

16899 Supplier F 4

12357 Supplier C

12286 Supplier D

65864 Supplier E

58692 Supplier G

Best in Class target for all suppliers in the LCC 4 digit commodity

code 12AA with 10% improvement factor = 3.9 = 4.0

Page 27: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

NCT Rolling 6 Months

27

Page 28: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC NCT Rolling 6 Months

28

Page 29: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC NCT 6 Month Summary

29

Page 30: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

30

NCT Rolling 6 Month Detail

Page 31: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

31

Rolling 6 Month Detail by Part

Page 32: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

32

Ticket Details by Part

Page 33: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

33

NCT Worksheet Inquiry

Page 34: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

34

Quality Metric Deductions

Forever Requirement Violation Containments (Yardholds)

3CPR Level 1 3CPR Level 2

TS 16949 Certification Quality New Business Hold

Page 35: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Deductions from the Composite Score

35

Forever Requirements

Violation

• 10 point deduction per occurrence

• More than 2 occurrences in the scoring

period - Quality Score = Zero

Containments (Yardholds) • 20 point deduction per occurrence

• More than 2 occurrences in the scoring

period - Quality Score = Zero

3CPR (Third Party Containment

and Problem Resolution) - Level 1 • 5 point deduction per month in which

project is open

• More than 2 occurrences in the scoring

period - Quality Score = Zero

3CPR Level 2 • 10 point deduction per occurrence in

which project is open

• More than 1 occurrence in the same

month Quality Score = Zero

TS16949 Certification • No Certification - Quality Score = Zero

• Metric is yet to become activated to

affect scorecard

Quality New Business Hold • NBH - Quality Score = Zero

Page 36: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Forever Requirement Violations

FRV

36

Page 37: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

37

The Forever Requirements

• Proactively communicate with Chrysler and know

when to raise the Red Flag

• Request approval from Chrysler prior to implementing

any anticipated material or process changes

• Request approval from Chrysler prior to implementing

any internal or sub-supplier manufacturing location

changes

• Watch for sub-supplier issues and inform Chrysler of

them

• Notify Chrysler of possible supply/capacity issues

Page 38: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

38

Forever Requirements Violations

Categories

• Processing change

• Change in construction or material

• Implemented prior to Forever Requirements approval

• Parts produced at different / additional locations

• Sub-supplier location change

• Sub-supplier material change

• Tooling capacity change

• Unauthorized tooling transfer

• Unauthorized refurbishment/replacement

• Missed PDR (Production Demonstration Run) & PPAP dates

• Other

Page 39: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

39

Forever Requirements

• Cumulative rolling 6 month score

• 10 point deduction per occurrence from the

overall quality score

• More than 2 occurrences in the scoring

period - Quality Score = Zero

Page 40: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

PRI SQ Responsible Yardholds

40

Page 41: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

41

Yardholds

• Measure of the occurrences of a supplier

responsible containment (yardholds) as

reported by the Chrysler manufacturing

plant via a PRI (Product Related Issue)

• Cumulative rolling 6 month score

• 20 point deduction per occurrence from the

overall quality score

• More than 2 occurrences in the scoring

period - Quality Score = Zero

Page 42: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Third Party Containment & Problem Resolution

3CPR Level 1 3CPR Level 2

[email protected]

42

Page 43: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Third Party Containment & Problem Resolution

43

Level 1

• 3CPR Provider (3CPR-P) sorts Chrysler inventory (pipeline), supplier sorts at

supplier plant.

• 3CPR-P sorts all parts past supplier’s dock and 100% of supplier’s clean

certified shipment (CS)

• Supplier sorts all parts to all plants before shipping until 3CPR-P verifies

supplier’s clean CS

- 5 point deduction per month in which project is open

- More than 2 occurrences in the same month - Quality Score = Zero

Level 2

• 3CPR-P sorts at Supplier’s plant (L2 includes L1 unless L1 waived).

• 3CPR-P sorts all parts past supplier’s dock and all parts to all plants prior to

shipment for 15 to 999 days (project initiator determined length of time) from

supplier’s permanent corrective action (PCA) implementation date.

• Exit clock resets if nonconforming part found after PCA.

- 10 point deduction per occurrence in which project is open

- More than 1 occurrence in the same month – Quality Score = Zero

Page 44: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

44

Are there any sorts that are not counted toward the scorecard?

• If the supplier notifies the 3CPR provider or the plant and requests a

pro-active 3CPR sort, the scorecard is not affected

• A Pro-active sort is identified as such on the project itself

Is there a dispute process of any kind that would affect a 3CPR

point deduction?

• No

• Any discussion would be handled at the time of the sort

Additional information?

Information including a Training and Help section can be found the on

3CPR site available through Covisint

Questions?

Contact [email protected]

Third Party Containment & Problem Resolution

Page 45: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

ISO/TS16949

Mail box: [email protected] Web site: TS16949.extra.chrysler.com

45

Page 46: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC ISO/TS16949

• Certification - Quality Score = Zero

• Metric is yet to become activated to affect scorecard

Chrysler now requires suppliers to provide proof of certification to

ISO/TS16949 and were notified by Chrysler Management

Page 47: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

TS 16949 Certification

47

• Supplier certifications are captured and status is monitored

• Certification scoring is not yet effective

Scoring Plan • When this metric is activated in late July, we will display the

certification status, but NOT have it affect the scorecard for TWO

months to allow suppliers time to see their status and respond

• After two months, a “NO” will result in “0” on the scorecard for Quality,

Suppliers were notified in writing by Chrysler

management in June and September, 2010 regarding

the TS certification requirement

Page 48: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Submit TS 16949 Certification

48

Information Required:

• PDF (only) copy of current certification

• Supplier Manufacturing Location Code (SMLC)

• Contact information

o Name

o Phone

o email address

email to: [email protected]

Page 49: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Quality New Business Hold

NBH

49

Page 50: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Quality New Business Hold

50

• A formal Supplier Quality led process to

restrict supplier manufacturing locations from

quoting on new business opportunities

• Suppliers are notified if they are placed on

NBH

• Suppliers need to meet the established exit

criteria to be taken off NBH

• NBH “Yes” - Quality Score = Zero

Page 51: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Partnership Enhancements

51

Partnership (20%) Target/

Weight Jan Feb Mar YTD

52% 54% 56% 51%

Purchasing Support 10 8 8 8 5

50% 80% 80% 80% 50%

Diversity (000's) $580 $50 $100 $150 $250

25% 8.6% 17.2% 25.9% 43.1%

Corporate Sustainability 5 2 2 2 3

25% 40% 40% 40% 60%

Overall 64% 60% 73% 62%

• Engineering survey has been replaced with corporate

sustainability assessment

• More robust diversity calculation (eliminates directed parts, foreign

operations)

• Partnership score (20% of total EBSC)

• Purchasing Support Survey (10%)

• Corporate Sustainability Assessment (5%)

• Diversity (5%)

Page 52: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

52

Purchasing Support Survey

• Measure for

“Partnership

mindset” of

supplier

management

• Survey provides

10% of score

• Performed 2x per

year

• Assessment by

Lead Director

Page 53: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

53

Purchasing Support Survey

10

X

“Low” ranking results

in F2F meeting:

Benefits both!

Page 54: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

54

Purchasing Support Survey

10

Page 55: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Diversity

55

Diversity: 5%

Purchasing

support: 10%

Sustainability: 5%

Delivery

20 points

Quality

20 points

Cost

20 points

Partnership

20 points

Warranty

20 points

Note: Red rating in diversity negates entire partnership score (20 points)

Purpose: Measure Supplier

Performance to Target

Page 56: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Corporate Responsibility

• Supplier Self-assessment

• Online survey to determine

level of Corporate

Responsibility activity within

supply base

• Will measure all suppliers

regardless of commodity or

APV

• Data collected will be used to

help structure Supply Chain

Sustainability

• Assessment measures:

• Overall Program • Working Conditions • Environmental Management • Ethics & Anti-corruption • Training & Governance

56

Page 57: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Corporate Responsibility

57

Tracking and issue-identification tool

Page 58: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Warranty Enhancements

58

Warranty (20%) Target/

Weight Jan Feb Mar YTD

70% 68% 82% 85%

Supplier Associated Warranty (C's/1000) 3.69 4.2 4.5 3.91 3.78

100% 70% 68% 82% 85%

• Warranty has been moved out from Quality into its own

section

• Warranty weight has been increased to 20%

• Aligned with the new Supplier Associated Warranty

Reduction Program (SAWRP)

Page 59: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Supplier Monthly Measure

59

• Formula to set an FFR >= 80% if supplier does not

deteriorate

• Formula to set FFR =100% if supplier meet/exceeds the

corporate initiative (12% for 2011MY)

Formula to calculate the Fulfillment Rate (FFR)

Formula:

FFR = (Percent Improvement* 1.667) + (80%)

Percent Improvement (“Best of two prior years – Current) / Best of two of the

prior years 1.667 = Improvement factor constant (20%/12%)

Page 60: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Graphical Representation

60

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

FFR

2MIS

3MIS

4MIS

5MIS

6MIS

Dete

rio

rati

on

Improvement

No warranty improvement

Page 61: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

New Measures - Cost

61

Cost (20%) 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Annual Combined (000's) $1,250 $57 $79 $256 $646 $656 $656

100% 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Commercial Contribution (000's) $57 $79 $390 $400 $400

Technical Contribution (000's) $256 $256 $256 $256

Idea(s) Submitted N N Y

Page 62: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Target /

WeightJan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec YTD

Cost (20%) 15% 16% 41% 94% 87% 87%

$1,250 $57 $79 $256 $646 $656 $656

15% 16% 41% 94% 87% 87%

$1,000 $57 $79 $79 $390 $400 $400

15% 16% 13% 57% 53% 53%

$250 $0 $0 $177 $256 $256 $256

0% 0% 28% 37% 34% 34%

RAW SUPPLIER DATA Glide Path YTD Target in CY Savings EBSC Score

Supplier XYZ Target ($000) Factor * May ($000) Credit ($000) as of May

APV - $41,666,667

Total (3.0% APV) 1,250 60% 750 656 87%

Commercial (2.4% APV) 1,000 60% 600 400 53%

Technical (0.6% APV) 250 60% 150 256 34%

Idea(s) Submitted? Indicates if supplier enters ideas in the database each month --- no impact to score

* The following glide path will be used to calculate the cost metric within the EBSC:

Jan - 30%, Feb - 40%, Mar - 50%, Apr - 55%, May - 60%, June - 70%, July - 80%, Aug - 85%, Sept - 90%, Oct - 95%, Nov - 100%, Dec - 100%

Example shown for the month of May

Commercial Contribution = 400 / (1,250 x 0.60) = 53%

Technical Contribution = 256 / (1,250 x 0.60) = 34%

Ideas Submitted? N (No ideas submitted in May)

EBSC Cost Score as of May = 87%

N Y N

Annual Combined (000's)

Commercial Contribution (000's)

N N

Technical Contribution (000's)

Idea(s) Submitted?

New Measures - Cost

62

Page 63: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Delivery (20%) 100% 93% 91% 94% 98% 98%

Delivery Conformance 100 100 100 100 100 100 100

65% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Response Conformance 100 100 92 90 94 96 96

35% 100% 92% 90% 94% 96% 96%

CLS/CLD (occurrence) 1 1 1 1 1 1

MMOG/LE (deduction) Y Y N N N N

New Measures - Delivery

63

• Direct feed from DRIVe at commodity

level

• Potential deductions for CLS/CLD

occurrence and MMOG/LE not being

submitted

Page 64: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Navigating to EBSC

GPSIS MAIN MENU -

Supplier Tools

EBSC

Monthly Detail Report

Other Tools

-MCM

Page 65: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC Navigating to EBSC

Supplier / Commodity Scorecard

Report Parameters

Year: 2011

BU: Production Source Hold: Yes - Commercial

Supplier: 32213 F - WP Chrysler, Inc. Source Restriction: No

Address: 1207 Chrysler Road, Kokomo IN 46901 Financial Risk Rating: High Risk

Commodity: 23BA - Non-Decorative Injection Moldings Service Parts (MOPAR): Yellow

Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Target/Weight

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun - Dec

YTD

Quality (20%) 59% 59% 76% 33% 0% 0%

AQP / NCT Composite 100 64 69 57 53 96 96

100% 64% 69% 57% 53% 96% 96%

Non-Conforming Material - Prod (NC Tickets) 0 8 7 4 5 1 1

52% 58% 76% 70% 94% 94%

Advance Quality Planning 100 100 100 98 98

100% 100% 98% 98%

Forever Requirements Violation (occurrence) 1 1

Containments (Yardholds) (occurrence) 1 1 1

3CPR Level 1 1

3CPR Level 2 1

TS 16949 Certification Y Y Y Y Y Y

Q Hold N N N N Y Y

Delivery (20%) 100% 93% 91% 94% 98% 98%

Delivery Conformance 100 100 100 100 100 100 100

65% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Response Conformance 100 100 92 90 94 96 96

35% 100% 92% 90% 94% 96% 96%

CLS/CLD (occurrence) 1 1 1 1 1 1

MMOG/LE (deduction) Y Y N N N N

Warranty (20%) 70% 68% 82% 82% 85% 85%

Supplier Associated Warranty (C's/1000) 3.69 4.2 4.5 3.91 3.91 3.78 3.78

100% 70% 68% 82% 82% 85% 85%

Cost (20%) 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Annual Combined (000's) $1,250 $57 $79 $256 $646 $656 $656

100% 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Commercial Contribution (000's) $57 $79 $390 $400 $400

Technical Contribution (000's) $256 $256 $256 $256

Idea(s) Submitted N N Y

Partnership (20%) 52% 54% 56% 49% 51% 51%

Purchasing Support 10 8 8 8 5 5 5

50% 80% 80% 80% 50% 50% 50%

Diversity (000's) $580 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $250

25% 8.6% 17.2% 25.9% 34.4% 43.1% 43.1%

Corporate Sustainability 5 2 2 2 3 3 3

25% 40% 40% 40% 60% 60% 60%

Overall 64% 60% 73% 69% 62% 62%

Page 66: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

66

Suggestions & Feedback

For help:

General EBSC Questions: [email protected]

Quality Questions: [email protected]

Warranty Questions: [email protected]

Delivery / Supply Questions:

[email protected].

DSD Questions: [email protected]

Cost Measure Questions: [email protected]

Corporate sustainability: [email protected]

Page 67: Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score … · 18.01.2011 · Supplier Performance Metrics External Balanced Score Card ... Yellow Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

CHRYSLER GROUP LLC

Next Steps

• Supplier Training Week

• 2 Full EBSC training sessions

occurred

• EBSC Webinars are scheduled

for June 23 and July 20

• Phase 1 (Quality & Delivery)

launches in May-Suppliers able

to view in June

• Phase 2 launches in June-

Suppliers able to view in July

• Contact [email protected] or

[email protected]

2011 EBSC Supplier / Commodity Scorecard

Report Parameters

Year: 2011

BU: Production Source Hold: Yes - Commercial

Supplier: 32213 F - WP Chrysler, Inc. Source Restriction: No

Address: 1207 Chrysler Road, Kokomo IN 46901 Financial Risk Rating: High Risk

Commodity: 23BA - Non-Decorative Injection Moldings Service Parts (MOPAR): Yellow

Scorecard Updated Jan 18, 2011

Target/Weight

Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun - Dec

YTD

Quality (20%) 59% 59% 76% 33% 0% 0%

AQP / NCT Composite 100 64 69 57 53 96 96

100% 64% 69% 57% 53% 96% 96%

Non-Conforming Material - Prod (NC Tickets) 0 8 7 4 5 1 1

52% 58% 76% 70% 94% 94%

Advance Quality Planning 100 100 100 98 98

100% 100% 98% 98%

Forever Requirements Violation (occurrence) 1 1

Containments (Yardholds) (occurrence) 1 1 1

3CPR Level 1 1

3CPR Level 2 1

TS 16949 Certification Y Y Y Y Y Y

Q Hold N N N N Y Y

Delivery (20%) 100% 93% 91% 94% 98% 98%

Delivery Conformance 100 100 100 100 100 100 100

65% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100% 100%

Response Conformance 100 100 92 90 94 96 96

35% 100% 92% 90% 94% 96% 96%

CLS/CLD (occurrence) 1 1 1 1 1 1

MMOG/LE (deduction) Y Y N N N N

Warranty (20%) 70% 68% 82% 82% 85% 85%

Supplier Associated Warranty (C's/1000) 3.69 4.2 4.5 3.91 3.91 3.78 3.78

100% 70% 68% 82% 82% 85% 85%

Cost (20%) 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Annual Combined (000's) $1,250 $57 $79 $256 $646 $656 $656

100% 46% 32% 68% 100% 100% 100%

Commercial Contribution (000's) $57 $79 $390 $400 $400

Technical Contribution (000's) $256 $256 $256 $256

Idea(s) Submitted N N Y

Partnership (20%) 52% 54% 56% 49% 51% 51%

Purchasing Support 10 8 8 8 5 5 5

50% 80% 80% 80% 50% 50% 50%

Diversity (000's) $580 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 $250

25% 8.6% 17.2% 25.9% 34.4% 43.1% 43.1%

Corporate Sustainability 5 2 2 2 3 3 3

25% 40% 40% 40% 60% 60% 60%

Overall 64% 60% 73% 69% 62% 62%