Summary of Tutorial Summary of Tutorial SessionsSessions

T1 T2 T3 T4 T5 T6Total

Attendees61 70 85 33 67 38

Answered Attendees

36 49 46 24 45 30

Answer Percentage

(%)

59 70 54 72 67 78

QuestionnaireQuestionnaire(A) Was the tutorial useful?(B) Was the materials easy to understand?(C) Was the talk easy to understand?(D) Speaker’s expertise

APNOM2002 Tutorial Evaluation Results

0

1

2

3

4

5

T1 T2 T3 T4 T5 T6

Tutorial No.

Po

ints

ABCD

CommentsComments (T1) Trends and QoS issues in VoIP Service by Koichi (T1) Trends and QoS issues in VoIP Service by Koichi

Asatani (3 sheets)Asatani (3 sheets)

Nothing is new. Every Information in this speech is written in journals. Speaker’s English is very poor. Sometimes, it is very difficult to understand his intention.I couldn’t catch up when the presentation touched on the “domain.” I would like to hear more focused story.

Comments Comments (T2) DiffServ-aware-MPLS Networking (T2) DiffServ-aware-MPLS Networking

by Young-Tak Kim (9 sheets)by Young-Tak Kim (9 sheets)

Excellent tutorial. It's a good tutorial to understand corrent tech summary on IP, MPLS, GMPLS with QoS.(+3)It is useful to add glossary at the end of the material.Need a microphone for attendee's comments. Less seats! More Chairs required!2 hours are too long. It should be 90 minutes.Perhaps some less details on DiffServ itself to enhance integration aspects MPLS-DiffServ.

Comments Comments (T3) Quality of Service Control in the Internet by Raouf (T3) Quality of Service Control in the Internet by Raouf

Boutaba (2 sheets)Boutaba (2 sheets)

It focused on policy based NM, but not on QoS in IP networks.The speaker speaks too fast. I can’t understand what he says.

Comments Comments (T4) Wireless Location-based Services: (T4) Wireless Location-based Services: Tech., Applications and Management Tech., Applications and Management

by Graham Chen (3 sheets)by Graham Chen (3 sheets)

Speaking was too fast.excellent tutorial.Nothing New!

Comments Comments (T5) Service Level Management (T5) Service Level Management

by Christian Rad (6 sheets)by Christian Rad (6 sheets)His intention was not delivered many times as his voice was too low and not clear to hear.(+3)He answered only to the questioner not to others.(+2)The slides includes unnecessary information.Too much material and not enough examples. Some of sentences in the tutorial proceedings are very long. It is difficult to understand and see the presentation screen at a glance because screen fonts are too small. (+2)

Comments Comments (T6) IMT-2000 Network, Operation Support Systems a(T6) IMT-2000 Network, Operation Support Systems a

nd Services nd Services by Kouzou Sakae (5 sheets)by Kouzou Sakae (5 sheets)

Video demonstration was very impressive.No new information for me.The presentation material is different from the printed material. There are lots of newly included pages.This tutorial would be designed for post 3G generation, I expected. If it is possible, NTT DoCoMo shows us their strategy for post 3G. We are interested in new services on 3G.