Upload
rkkodi
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
1/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 1
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
Self compacting concrete (SCC), which flows under its own weight and completely
fill the formwork, even in the presence of dense reinforcement, without the need of any
vibration, whilst maintaining homogeneity.
It is highly workable concrete that can flow under its own weight through restricted
sections without segregation and bleeding. Such concrete should have a relatively low yield
value to ensure high flow ability, a moderate viscosity to resist segregation and bleeding, and
must maintain its homogeneity during transportation, placing and curing to ensure adequate
structural performance and long term durability. The successful development of SCC must
ensure a good balance between deformability and stability.
Researchers have set some guidelines for mixture proportioning of SCC, which include
Ø Reducing the volume ratio of aggregate to cementitious material.
Ø Increasing the paste volume and water-cement ratio (w/c).
Ø Carefully controlling the maximum coarse aggregate particle size and total
volume.
Ø Using various superplasticizers /viscosity enhancing admixtures (VEA).
For SCC, it is generally necessary to use superplasticizers in order to obtain high
mobility. Adding a large volume of powdered material or viscosity modifying admixture can
eliminate segregation. The powdered materials that can be added are fly ash, silica fume,
lime stone powder, glass filler and quartzite filler.
Since, self-compactibility is largely affected by the characteristics of materials and
the mix proportions, it becomes necessary to evolve a procedure for mix design of SCC.Okamura and Ozawa have proposed a mix proportioning system for SCC . In this system, the
coarse aggregate and fine aggregate contents are fixed and self-compactibility is to be
achieved by adjusting the water /powder ratio and super plasticizer dosage. The coarse
aggregate content in concrete is generally fixed at 50 percent of the total solid volume, the
fine aggregate content is fixed at 40 percent of the mortar volume and the water /powder ratio
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
2/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 2
is assumed to be 0.9-1.0 by volume depending on the properties of the powder and the super
plasticizer dosage. The required water /powder ratio is determined by conducting a number
of trials. One of the limitations of SCC is that there is no established mix design procedure
yet.
The prototype of self compacting concrete was first completed in 1988 using
materials already on the market as shown in fig.1.1
Fig 1.1 Comparison of mix proportioning between self compacting concrete
and conventional concrete.
The prototype performed satisfactorily with regard to drying and hardening
shrinkage, heat of hydration, denseness after hardening and other properties. This concrete
was named “high performance concrete” and was defined as follows at the three stages of
concrete:
Ø Fresh: self- compactable.
Ø Early age: avoidance of initial defects.
Ø After hardening: protection against external factors.
At almost the same time, high performance concrete was defined as a concrete with
high durability due to a low water cement ratio by professor aitcin et al. (gagne et al 1989).
Since then, the term high performance concrete has been used around the world to refer to
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
3/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 3
high durability concrete. Therefore, the authors have changed the term for the proposed
concrete to self- compacting high performance concrete.
1.1 Development of self compacting concrete
For several years beginning in 1983, the problem of the durability of concrete
structures was a major topic of interest in japan. The creation of durable concrete structures
requires adequate compaction by skilled workers. However, the gradual reduction in the
number of skilled workers in japan’s construction industry has led to a similar reduction in
the quality of construction work. One solution for the achievement of durable concrete
structures independent of the quality of construction work is the employment of self
compacting concrete, which can be compacted into every corner of a formwork, purely by
means of its own weight and without the need for vibrating compaction as shown in fig.1.2.
Fig 1.2 Necessity of self compacting concrete
The necessity of this type of concrete was proposed by okamura in 1986. The studies
to develop self compacting concrete, including a fundamental study on the workability of
concrete has been carried out by ozawa and maekawa at the university of Tokyo (ozawa
1989, okmura 1993 and maekawa 1999).
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
4/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 4
1.2 Advantages of SCC
The use of self-consolidating concrete can yield many advantages over traditionally
placed and compacted concrete.
Ø Saving of costs on machinery, energy, and labors related to consolidation of concrete
by eliminating it during concreting.
Ø High-level of quality control due to more sensitivity of moisture content of
ingredients and compatibility of chemical admixtures.
Ø High-quality finish, which is critical in architectural concrete, precast construction as
well as for cast-in-place concrete construction.
Ø Reduces the need for surface defects remedy (patching).
Ø Increases of the service life the molds/formwork.
Ø Promotes the development of a more rational concrete production.
Ø Industrialized production of concrete.
Ø Covers reinforcement effectively, thereby ensuring better quality of cover for
reinforcement bars.
Ø Reduction in the construction time by accelerating the construction process.
Ø Improves the quality, durability, and reliability of concrete structures due to better
compaction and homogeneity of concrete.
Ø Easily placed in thin-walled elements or elements with limited access.
Ø Ease of placement results in cost savings through reduced equipment and labor
requirement.
Ø Improves working environment at construction sites by reducing noise pollution.
Ø Eliminate noises due to vibration; effective especially at precast concrete products
plants.
Ø Eliminates the need for hearing protection.
Ø Improves working conditions and productivity in construction industry.
Ø It can enable the concrete supplier to provide better consistency in delivering
concrete, thus reduces the need for interventions at the plants or at the job sites.
Ø Provides opportunity for using high-volume of by-product materials such as fly ash,
quarry fines, blast furnace slag, limestone dust, and other similar materials.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
5/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 5
Ø Reduces the workers compensation premium due to the reduction in chances of
accidents.
1.3 Disadvantages of SCC:
Ø More stringent requirements on the selection of materials in comparison with normal
concrete.
Ø More precise measurement and monitoring of the constituent materials. An
uncontrolled variation of even 1% moisture content in the fine aggregate could have
a much bigger impact on the rheology of SCC.
Ø Requires more trial batches at laboratory as well as at ready-mixed concrete plants.
Ø Costlier than conventional concrete based on concrete material cost.
1.4 Applications of Self-Compacting Concrete
Ø To shorten construction period.
Ø To assure compaction in the structure: especially in confined zones where vibrating
compaction is difficult.
Ø To eliminate noise due to vibration: effective especially at concrete products plants.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
6/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 6
Chapter 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
Self-compacting concrete extends the possibility of use of various mineral by- products during manufacturing and with the densification of the matrix, mechanical behavior,
as measured by compressive, tensile and shear strength, is increased. On the other hand, the
use superplasticizers or high range water reducers, improves the stiffening, unwanted air
entrainment and flowing ability of concrete. Practically, all types of constructions are
possible with this concrete. The use of SCC not only shortens the construction period but also
ensures quality and durability of concrete. This non-vibrated concrete allows faster
placement and less finishing time, leading to improved productivity. In the following, a brief
review of the papers found in the literature about self-compacting concrete and some of the
projects carried out with this type of concrete is presented.
Hajime Okamura [1] attempted for a new type of concrete which can be compacted
into every corner of the formwork purely by means of its own weight was proposed by
Okamura. In 1986, he started a research project on the flowing ability and workability of this
special type of concrete, later called self-compacting concrete. The self-compactability of
this concrete can be largely affected by the characteristics of materials and the mix
proportions. In his study, Okamura had fixed the coarse aggregate content to 50% of the solid
volume and the fine aggregate content to 40% of the mortar volume, so that self-
compactability could be achieved easily by adjusting the water cement ratio and
superplasticizer dosage only. A model formwork comprised of two vertical sections (towers)
at each end of a horizontal trough, was used by Professor Okamura to observe how well self-
compacting concrete could flow through obstacles.
Binu Sukumar et. al. [2] found out that self-compacting concrete (SCC) demands
large amount of powder content and fines for its cohesiveness and ability to flow without
bleeding and segregation. In the present investigation, part of this powder is replaced with
high volume fly ash based on a rational mix design method developed by the authors.
Because of high fly ash content, it is essential to study the development of strength at early
ages of curing which may prove to be a significant factor for the removal of formwork. Rate
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
7/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 7
of gain in strength at different periods of curing such as 12 h, 18 h, 1 day, 3 days, 7 days, 21
days and 28 days are studied for various grades of different SCC mixes and suitable relations
have been established for the gain in strength at the early ages in comparison to the
conventional concrete of same grades. Relations have also been formulated for compressive
strength and split tensile strength for different grades of SCC mixes
M.Ramegowda et. al. [3] made an attempt to develop SCC mixes using locally
prepared Rice Husk Ash (RHA) as a supplementary cementitious material. In addition, the
locally available quarry dust (QD) as an alternating material to sand was used. The SCC
mixes so designed were tested for their rheological properties. On obtaining satisfactory
rheological properties, the mixes were tested for their hardened properties, which formed the
basis for assessing the viability of using RHA and QD in the SCC mixes. The results
confirmed the advantage of using RHA, but the limitations of obtaining RHA from a locally
made furnace were also obvious. The local lime burning technology employed for RHA
manufacturing affected the strength development. As the quality of RHA increased, the
amount of water also increased. Replacing more than 10% cement with RHA decreased the
mix strength. This method of obtaining RHA was not suitable for concrete applications.
Tayyeb Akram et. al. [4] worked for the development of conventional concrete, in
which the use of vibrator for compaction is no more required. This property of self
compacting concrete requirements suggested by European federation of national trade
associations representing prohas made its use more attractive all over the world. But its initial
higher supply cost over conventional concrete, has hindered its application to general
construction. Therefore, for producing low cost SCC, it is prudent to look at the alternates to
help reducing the SSC cost. This research is aimed at evaluating the usage of bagasse ash as
viscosity modifying agent in SCC, and to study the relative costs of the materials used in
SCC.
In this research, the main variables are the proportion of bagasse ash, dosage of
superplasticizer for flowability and water/binder ratio. The parameters kept constant are the
amount of cement and water content.
Test results substantiate the feasibility to develop low cost self compacting concrete
using bagasse ash. In the fresh state of concrete, the different mixes of concrete have slump
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
8/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 8
flow in the range of 333 mm to 815 mm, L-box ratio ranging from 0 to 1 and flow time
ranging from 1.8 s to no flow (stucked). Out of twenty five different mixes, five mixes were
found to satisfy the ducers and applicators of specialist building products (EFNARC) guide
for making self compacting concrete. The compressive strengths developed by the self
compacting concrete mixes with bagasse ash at 28 days were comparable to the control
concrete. Cost analysis showed that the cost of ingredients of specific self compacting
concrete mix is 35.63% less than that of control concrete, both having compressive strength
above 34 MPa. Low cost SCC can be made, by incorporating some percentage of bagasse ash
along with the main ingredients of concrete (cement, fine aggregate and coarse aggregate)
and superplasticizer for flowability.
In fresh state, some of the mix results values were out of the EFNARC range and
therefore before casting the concrete, the properties of freshly mixed concrete must be
checked for SCC. The utilization of bagasse ash in SCC solves the problem of its disposal
thus keeping the enviroment free from pollution.
Amir Juma et. al. [5] investigated on self-compacting concrete, also referred to as
self-consolidating concrete, is able to flow and consolidate under its own weight and is de-
aerated almost completely while flowing in the formwork. It is cohesive enough to fill the
spaces of almost any size and shape without segregation or bleeding. This makes SCC
particularly useful wherever placing is difficult, such as in heavily-reinforced concrete
members or in complicated work forms.
The objectives of this research were to make a synergic effect of Rice husk Ash
(RHA) and Sugar cane bagasse ash(SCBA) incorporated in self compaction concrete in order
to increase in strength and a better bonding between aggregate and cement paste, . The mix
design used for making the concrete specimens was based on previous research work from
literature. The water – cement ratios varied from 0.3 to 0.75 while the rest of the componentswere kept the same, except the chemical admixtures, which were adjusted for obtaining the
self- compactability of the concrete.
All SCC mixtures exhibited greater vaules in compressive strength after being tested,
the compressive strength was around 40% greater. In addition, the SCC had a good
rheological properties as per the requirements from European standards from economical
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
9/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 9
point of view the pozzolanic replacements were cheap and sustainable. In the experiments
cement was replaced with 0%, 2.5%, 5% of both blended mixture of rice husk ash and sugar
cane bagasse ash. This was possible due to the use of mineral and chemical admixtures,
which usually improve the bonding between aggregate and cement paste, thus increasing the
strength of concrete.
Dr. R. Sri Ravindrarajah et. al. [6] worked on self-compacting concrete having
enhanced ability to flow is known to have increased segregation and bleeding potential. Any
attempt to increase the stability of fresh concrete (cohesiveness) requires using increase
amount of fine materials in the mixes. This paper reports an investigation into the
development of self-compacting concrete with reduced segregation potential. The self-
compacted concrete mix having satisfied the criterion recognized by the differential height
method is modified in many ways to increase the fine particle content by replacing partially
the fine and coarse aggregates by low-calcium fly ash. The systematic experimental approach
showed that partial replacement of coarse and fine aggregate could produce self-compacting
concrete with low segregation potential as assessed by the V-Funnel test. The paper reports
the results of bleeding test and strength development with age. The results showed that fly
ash could be used successfully in producing self-compacting high-strength concrete with
reduced segregation potential. In addition, fly ash in self-compacting concrete helps to
improve later age strength beyond 28 days.
Shazim Ali Memon et. al. [7] defined Self Compacting Concrete (SCC) by two
primary properties: Deformability and Segregation resistance. Deformability or flowability is
the ability of SCC to flow or deform under its own weight (with or without obstructions).
Segregation resistance or stability is the ability to remain homogeneous while doing so. High
range water reducing admixtures are ut ilized to develop sufficient deformability. At the same
time, segregation resistance is ensured, which is accomplished either by introducing a
chemical viscosity modifying admixture (VMA) or by increasing the amount of fines in the
concrete. These viscosity modifying admixtures are very expensive and the main cause of
increase in the cost of SCC. Therefore, for producing low cost SCC, it is prudent to look at
the alternates to help reducing the SSC cost. This research is aimed at evaluating the usage of
Rice Husk Ash (RHA) as viscosity modifying agent in SCC, and to study the relative costs of
the materials used in SCC.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
10/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 10
In this research, the main variables are the proportion of RHA, dosage of
superplasticizer for flow ability and water/binder ratio. The parameters kept constant are the
amount of cement, water, fine and coarse aggregate contents.
Test results substantiate the feasibility to develop low cost SCC using RHA. In the
fresh state of concrete, the different mixes of concrete have slump flow in the range of 595–
795 mm, L-box ratio ranging from 0 (stucked) to 1 and flow time ranging from 2.2 to 29.3 s.
Out of nine mixes, four mixes were found to satisfy the requirements suggested by European
federation of national trade associations representing producers and applicators of specialist
building products (EFNARC) guide for making SCC. The compressive strengths developed
by the SCC mixes with RHA were comparable to the control concrete. Cost analysis showed
that the cost of ingredients of specific SCC mix is 42.47% less than that of control concrete.
Low cost SCC can be made, by incorporating some percentage of RHA along with the main
ingredients of concrete (cement, fine aggregate and coarse aggregate) and superplasticizer for
flowability. To some extent, the utilization of RHA in SCC solves the problem of its disposal
thus keeping the environment free from pollution. In future research, scientific investigation
should be carried out to endorse the results.
Muhammad Ali Shaikh et. al. [8] stated Self Compacting Concrete as the concrete
requiring a very little or no vibration to fill the form homogeneously. Self Compacting
Concrete (SCC) is defined by two primary properties: Ability to flow or deform under its
own weight (with or without obstructions) and the ability to remain homogeneous while
doing so. Flowability is achieved by utilizing high range water reducing admixtures and
segregation resistance is ensured by introducing a chemical viscosity modifying admixture
(VMA) or increasing the amount of fines in the concrete. The study explores the use of Rice
Husk Ash (RHA) to increase the amount of fines and hence achieve self-compactibility in an
economical way, suitable for Pakistani construction industry.
The study focuses on comparison of fresh properties of SCC containing varying
amounts of RHA with that containing commercially available viscosity modifying admixture.
The comparison is done at different dosages of superplasticizer keeping cement, water,
coarse aggregate, and fine aggregate contents constant.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
11/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 11
Test results substantiate the feasibility to develop low cost SCC using RHA. Cost
analysis showed that the cost of ingredients of specific SCC mix is 42.47 percent less than
that of control concrete.
Asma Abd Elhameed Hussein et. al. [9] showed that Agricultural and industrial by-
products are commonly used in concrete production as cement replacement materials CRMs
or as admixtures to enhance both fresh and hardened properties of concrete as well as to save
the environment from the negative effects caused by their disposal. Sugarcane bagasse ash is
one of the promising CRMs, it is used as a partial replacement of cement for producing
concrete; properties of such concrete depend on the chemical composition, fineness, specific
surface area and burning temperature of SCBA. Approximately 1500 Million tons of
sugarcane are annually produced over all the world which leave about 40-45 % bagasse after
juice crushing for sugar industry giving an average annual production of 675 Million tons of
bagasse as a waste material. This paper presents a review on the uses of sugarcane bagasse
ash in concrete. From review it can be concluded that SCBA can be used as a pozzolanic
material in concrete due to its high silica content.
P. Kolanjinathan et. al. [10] attempted for a highly fluid concrete mixture with no
segregation and can compact under its self weight. The use of SCC is spreading all over the
world, but it is in infant stage in India. SCC requires considerably more fines content as
compared to traditional concrete to achieve self compactability. Looking at the potential of
cementitious constituents in fly ash and availability in abundance in million tonnes as a by
product of the thermal power plant demanding environmental solution, large volumes of fly
ash, partially in substitution for cement and partially as filler, can be employed in SCC. The
concrete grade for the study was chosen as M25 and mix for the normal concrete of this was
designed by IS code method. In self compacting concrete, equivalent mix was chosen as per
literature in reference. Self Compacting Concrete mix with selected superplacticizers and
VMA with 40% fly ash content in total powder content were prepared and their properties in
the fresh state viz, passing ability, filling ability and segregation resistance were studied for
the assessment of the self compactability. Axial load carrying capacity of reinforced concrete
column specimens and reinforced SCC column specimens were studied. Reinforced SCC
columns and RCC columns have similar load-deformation characteristics and strength.
Reinforced SCC columns have better crack control ability than RCC columns.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
12/82
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
13/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 13
the effect of partial replacement of cement with RHA on cement concrete as well as the
addition on natural fibers to from certain percentage of RHA to overcome the decreasing
strength of concrete . It is observed that though the strength of RHA concrete goes on
decreasing after the 12.5% addition of RHA, the composition of 15% RHA + COIR gives
maximum strength results as well as shows the potential to be used as useful material for
different building materials such as wall panels, paving blocks etc.
Ahmed Fathi Mohamed et. al. [14] showed Slump flow is the main characteristic to
investigate the flow ability or deformation of Self-Compacting Concrete (SCC) mix, in fact
this test includes two parameters to study, firstly the horizontal diameter of mix and secondly
the time required for mix to reach the 500 mm diameter. This paper studied the effect of two
different ratio of aggregate on the slump flow test for 10-SCC mix of constant cement
content and different dosage of water and super plasticizer, there is no mineral admixture was
used to develop the SCC mix while the binder was cement only, also the paper showed the
result of compressive strength of SCC mix at early ages. The results showed that the high
slump flow and compressive strength can be obtained with lower amount of coarse aggregate
compared with the higher amount of fine aggregate.
Celso Yoji Kawabata et. al. [15] studied on rice husk ash (RHA) and broiler bed ash
from rice husk (BBA), two agricultural waste materials, have been assessed for use as partialcement replacement materials for application in lightweight concrete. Physical and chemical
characteristics of RHA and BBA were first analyzed. Three similar types of lightweight
concrete were produced, a control type in which the binder was just CEMI cement (CTL) and
two other types with 10% cement replacement with, respectively, RHA and BBA. All types
of similar lightweight concrete were prepared to present the same workability by adjusting
the amount of superplasticizer. Properties of concrete investigated were compressive and
flexural strength at different ages, absorption by capillarity, resistivity and resistance to
chloride ion penetration (CTH method) and accelerated carbonation. Test results obtained for
10% cement replacement level in lightweight concrete indicate that although the addition of
BBA conducted to lower performance in terms of the degradation indicative tests, RHA led
to the enhancement of mechanical properties, especially early strength and also fast ageing
related results, further contributing to sustainable construction with energy saver lightweight
concrete. The use of RHA, a raw material which derives from agro industrial waste, therefore
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
14/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 14
further contributes to sustainability in construction by reducing the clinker consumption in
lightweight concrete without impairment of the general performance of the final product.
Nuntachai Chusilp et. al. [16] studied on Raw bagasse ash collected from the Thai
sugar industry has a high loss on ignition (LOI) of 20%. When ground and ignited at 550 oC
for 45 min, the LOI was reduced to 5%. These high and low LOI of ground bagasse ashes
were blended in the ratios of 1:2 and 2:1 by weight to give ground bagasse ashes with LOIs
of 10% and 15%, respectively. Each of these ground bagasse ashes was used to replace
Portland cement type I at 10%, 20%, 30%, and 40% by weight of binder to cast mortar.
The results showed that the development of compressive strengths of mortars
containing ground bagasse ash with high LOI was slower than that of mortar containing
ground bagasse ash with low LOI. However, at the later age, both types of ground ash
mortars displayed similar compressive strengths. Mortars containing high LOI (_20%) of
ground bagasse ash at 20% and 30% by weight of binder could produce higher compressive
strengths than a control mortar after 28 and 90 days, respectively. Mortar bars containing
ground bagasse ash at 10% showed a greater potential sulfate resistance and displayed a
reduce expansion compared to a control mortar. However, mortar bars containing high LOI
(larger than 10%) of ground bagasse ashes showed greater deterioration from sulfate attack
than the mortar bars containing low LOI (less than 10%) of ground bagasse ashes, especiallyat high replacement levels (30–40%).
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
15/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 15
2.1 Outcome of literature review
From the literature review, we notify certain aspects which we dealt with in our
experimental programme,
Ø Development of SCC mix.
Ø Criterias for self compacting concrete.
Ø Well-known pozzolanas.
Ø Composition of the pozzolanas.
Ø Mechanical properties and durability of Sugarcane Bagasse Ash concrete.
Ø Calcination temperature and method of preparation of SCBA.
Ø Effect of Grinding and Particle Size of SCBA.
Ø Other utilizations of SCBA – As a clinker replacement material to reduce CO2
emission, as viscosity modifying agent and also as light weight aggregates.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
16/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 16
Chapter 3
WORKABILITY REQUIREMENTS OF SCC
Rheology is the science of the deformation and flow of materials. It is a complex
discipline used to understand the workability characteristics of SCC. The two most important
properties of SCC’s rheology are:
Yield stress: The measure of the amount of energy required to make SCC flow. To be
considered SCC, concrete must flow easily under its own weight, so its yield stress must be
very low.
Plastic viscosity: The measure of the resistance of SCC to flow due to internal friction. SCC
must have a high viscosity in order to suspend aggregate particles in a homogenous manner
within the concrete matrix without segregation, excessive bleeding, excessive air migration,
or paste separation.
In summary, SCC must have low-yield stress and high viscosity.
The three important main properties are:
Ø Flowing ability – It should possess the ability to fill all areas and should reach the
nooks and corners into which it is placed. .
Ø Passing ability – Its ability to pass through congested reinforcement without
segregation for the constituent or blocking.
Ø Resistance to segregation – Its ability to retain the coarse components of the mix in
suspension in order to maintain a homogenous material.
A concrete mix can only be classified as Self-compacting Concrete if the requirements
for all three characteristics are fulfilled.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
17/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 17
3.1 Test methods for SCC
Many different test methods have been developed in attempts to characterise the
properties of SCC. So far no single method or combination of methods has achieved
universal approval and most of them have their adherents. Similarly no single method has
been found which characterises all the relevant workability aspects so each mix design
should be tested by more than one test method for the different workability parameters.
Table 3.1 Test methods for SCC
property Test methods
Filling ability 1. Slump flow 2. T50cm slump flow
3. V-funnel 4. Orimet
Passing ability 5. L-box 6. U-box
7. Fill-box
8. J-ring
Segregation
resistance
9. GTM test
10. V-funnel at T5minutes
3.1.1 Slump flow and T50cm test
Introduction:
The slump flow is used to assess the horizontal free flow of SCC in the absence of
obstructions. It was first developed in Japan for use in assessment of underwater concrete.
The test method is based on the test method for determining the slump. The diameter of the
concrete circle is a measure for the filling ability of the concrete.
Assessment of test:
This is a simple, rapid test procedure, though two people are needed if the T50 time is
to be measured. It can be used on site, though the size of the base plate is somewhat unwieldy
and level ground is essential. It is the most commonly used test, and gives a good assessment
of filling ability. It gives no indication of the ability of the concrete to pass between
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
18/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 18
reinforcement without blocking, but may give some indication of resistance to segregation. It
can be argued that the completely free flow, unrestrained by any boundaries, is not
representative of what happens in practice in concrete construction, but the test can be
profitably be used to assess the consistency of supply of ready-mixed concrete to a site from
load to load.
Fig 3.1 Slump flow test apparatus.
Equipments:
The apparatus is shown in figure 3.1.
· Mould in the shape of a truncated cone with the internal dimensions 200 mm diameter
at the base, 100 mm diameter at the top and a height of 300 mm,
· Base plate of a stiff non absorbing material, at least 700mm square, marked with a
circle marking the central location for the slump cone, and a further concentric circle
of 500mm Diameter
· Trowel
· Scoop
· Ruler
· Stopwatch (optional).
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
19/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 19
Procedure:
· About 6 litre of concrete is needed to perform the test, sampled normally.
· Moisten the base plate and inside of slump cone,
· Place base plate on level stable ground and the slumpcone centrally on the base plate
and hold down firmly.
· Fill the cone with the scoop. Do not tamp, simply strike off the concrete level with the
top of the cone with the trowel.
· Remove any surplus concrete from around the base of the cone.
· Raise the cone vertically and allow the concrete to flow out freely.
· Simultaneously, start the stopwatch and record the time taken for the concrete to
reach the 500mm spread circle. (This is the T50 time).
· Measure the final diameter of the concrete in two perpendicular directions.
· Calculate the average of the two measured diameters. (This is the slump flow in mm).
· Note any border of mortar or cement paste without coarse aggregate at the edge of the
pool of concrete.
Interpretation of result:
The higher the slump flow (SF) value, the greater its ability to fill formwork under its
own weight. A value of at least 650mm is required for SCC. There is no generally accepted
advice on what are reasonable tolerances about a specified value, though ± 50mm, as with
the related flow table test, might be appropriate.
The T50 time is a secondary indication of flow. A lower time indicates greater flow
ability. The Brite EuRam research suggested that a time of 3-7 seconds is acceptable for civil
engineering applications, and 2-5 seconds for housing applications. In case of severe
segregation most coarse aggregate will remain in the centre of the pool of concrete and
mortar and cement paste at the concrete periphery. In case of minor segregation a border of mortar without coarse aggregate can occur at the edge of the pool of concrete. If none of
these phenomena appear it is no assurance that segregation will not occur since this is a time
related aspect that can occur after a longer period. Slump cone Flow table units: mm.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
20/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 20
3.1.2 V-Funnel test and V-Funnel test at T5 minutes.
Introduction:
The test was developed in Japan and used by Ozawa et al. The equipment consists of
a V-shaped funnel, shown in Fig.4.3. An alternative type of V-funnel, the O funnel, with a
circular section is also used in Japan. The described V-funnel test is used to determine the
filling ability (flow ability) of the concrete with a maximum aggregate size of 20 mm. The
funnel is filled with about 12 litre of concrete and the time taken for it to flow through the
apparatus measured. After this the funnel can be refilled concrete and left for 5 minutes to
settle. If the concrete shows segregation then the flow time will increase significantly.
Assessment of test:
Though the test is designed to measure flow ability, the result is affected by concrete
properties other than flow. The inverted cone shape will cause any liability of the concrete to
block to be reflected in the result – if, for example there is too much coarse aggregate. High
flow time can also be associated with low deformability due to a high paste viscosity, and
with high inter-particle friction. While the apparatus is simple, the effect of the angle of the
funnel and the wall effect on the flow of concrete is not clear.
Fig 3.2 V– funnel test apparatus
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
21/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 21
Equipment:
· V-funnel
· Bucket ( ±12 litre )
· Trowel
· Scoop
· Stopwatch
Procedure flow time:
· About 12 liters of concrete is needed to perform the test, sampled normally.
· Set the V-funnel on firm ground.
· Moisten the inside surfaces of the funnel.
· Keep the trap door open to allow any surplus water to drain.
· Close the trap door and place a bucket underneath.
· Fill the apparatus completely with concrete without compacting or tamping , simply
strike off the concrete level with the top with the trowel.
· Open within 10 sec after filling the trap door and allow the concrete to flow out under
gravity.
· Start the stopwatch when the trap door is opened, and record the time for the
discharge to complete (the flow time). This is taken to be when light is seen from
above through the funnel.
· The whole test has to be performed within 5 minutes.
Procedure flow time at T5 minutes:
· Do not clean or moisten the inside surfaces of the funnel again.
· Close the trap door and refill the V-funnel immediately after measuring the flow time.
· Place a bucket underneath.
· Fill the apparatus completely with concrete without compacting or tapping, simply
strike off the concrete level with the top with the trowel.
· Open the trap door 5 minutes after the second fill of the funnel and allow the concrete
to flow out under gravity.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
22/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 22
· Simultaneously start the stopwatch when the trap door is opened, and record the time
for the discharge to complete (the flow time at T 5 minutes). This is taken to be when
light is seen from above through the funnel.
Interpretation of result:
This test measures the ease of flow of the concrete; shorter flow times indicate greater
flow ability. For SCC a flow time of 10 seconds is considered appropriate. The inverted cone
shape restricts flow, and prolonged flow times may give some indication of the susceptibility
of the mix to blocking. After 5 minutes of settling, segregation of concrete will show a less
continuous flow with an increase in flow time.
3.1.3 L-Box test
Introduction:
This test, based on a Japanese design for underwater concrete, has been described by
Petersson. The test assesses the flow of the concrete, and also the extent to which it is subject
to blocking by reinforcement. The apparatus is shown in Figure 3.3.
The apparatus consists of a rectangular-section box in the shape of an ‘L’, with a
vertical and horizontal section, separated by a moveable gate, in front of which vertical
lengths of reinforcement bar are fitted. The vertical section is filled with concrete, and then
the gate lifted to let the concrete flow into the horizontal section. When the flow has stopped,
the height of the concrete at the end of the horizontal section is expressed as a proportion of
that remaining in the vertical section (H2/H1in the diagram). It indicates the slope of the
concrete when at rest. This is an indication passing ability, or the degree to which the passage
of concrete through the bars is restricted. The horizontal section of the box can be marked at
200mm and 400mm from the gate and the times taken to reach these points measured. These
are known as the T20 and T40 times and are an indication for the filling ability. The sections
of bar can be of different diameters and spaced at different intervals: in accordance with
normal reinforcement considerations, 3x the maximum aggregate size might be appropriate.
The bars can principally be set at any spacing to impose a more or less severe test of the
passing ability of the concrete.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
23/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 23
Assessment of test:
This is a widely used test, suitable for laboratory, and perhaps site use. It assesses
filling and passing ability of SCC, and serious lack of stability (segregation) can be detected
visually. Segregation may also be detected by subsequently sawing and inspecting sections of
the concrete in the horizontal section. Unfortunately there is no agreement on materials,
dimensions, or reinforcing bar arrangement, so it is difficult to compare test results. There is
no evidence of what effect the wall of the apparatus and the consequent ‘wall effect’ might
have on the concrete flow, but this arrangement does, to some extent, replicate what happens
to concrete on site when it is confined within formwork. Two operators are required if times
are measured, and a degree of operator error is inevitable.
Equipments:
· L box of a stiff non absorbing material
· Trowel
· Scoop
· Stopwatch
Fig.3.3. L-Box test apparatus.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
24/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 24
Procedure:
· About 14 liters of concrete is needed to perform the test, sampled normally.
· Set the apparatus level on firm ground, ensure that the sliding gate can open freely
and then close it.
· Moisten the inside surfaces of the apparatus, remove any surplus water
· Fill the vertical section of the apparatus with the concrete sample.
· Leave it to stand for 1 minute.
· Lift the sliding gate and allow the concrete to flow out into the horizontal section.
· Simultaneously, start the stopwatch and record the times taken for the concrete to
reach the 200 and 400 mm marks.
· When the concrete stops flowing, the distances “H1” and “H2” are measured.
· Calculate H2/H1, the blocking ratio.
· The whole test has to be performed within 5 minutes.
Interpretation of result:
If the concrete flows as freely as water, at rest it will be horizontal, so H2/H1 = 1.
Therefore the nearer this test value, the ‘blocking ratio’, is to unity, the better the flow of the
concrete. The EU research team suggested a minimum acceptable value of 0.8. T20 and T40
times can give some indication of ease of flow, but no suitable values have been generally
agreed. Obvious blocking of coarse aggregate behind the reinforcing bars can be detected
visually.
3.1.4 U-Box test
Introduction:
The test was developed by the Technology Research Centre of the Taisei Corporation
in Japan, Sometimes the apparatus is called a “box-shaped” test. The test is used to measure
the filling ability of self-compacting concrete. The apparatus consists of a vessel that is
divided by a middle wall into two compartments, shown by R1 and R2 in Fig.4.6 An opening
with a sliding gate is fitted between the two sections. Reinforcing bars with nominal
diameters of 13 mm are installed at the gate with centre-to-centre spacing of 50 mm. This
creates a clear spacing of 35 mm between the bars. The left hand section is filled with about
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
25/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 25
20 liter of concrete then the gate lifted and concrete flows upwards into the other section. The
height of the concrete in both sections is measured.
Note: An alternative design of box to this, but built on the same principle is recommended by
the Japan Society of Civil Engineers.
Assessment of test:
This is a simple test to conduct, but the equipment may be difficult to construct. It
provides a good direct assessment of filling ability – this is literally what the concrete has to
do – modified by an unmeasured requirement for passing ability. The 35mm gap between the
sections of reinforcement may be considered too close. The question remains open of what
filling height less than 30 cm. is still acceptable.
Fig. 3.4: U-Box test apparatus.
Equipments:
· U box of a stiff non absorbing material
· Trowel
· Scoop
· Stopwatch
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
26/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 26
Procedure:
· About 20 litre of concrete is needed to perform the test, sampled normally.
· Set the apparatus level on firm ground, ensure that the sliding gate can open freely
and then close it.
· Moisten the inside surfaces of the apparatus, remove any surplus water
· Fill the one compartment of the apparatus with the concrete sample.
· Leave it to stand for 1 minute.
· Lift the sliding gate and allow the concrete to flow out into the other compartment.
· After the concrete has come to rest, measure the height of the concrete in the
compartment that has been filled, in two places and calculate the mean (H1). Measure
also the height in the other compartment (H2)
· Calculate H1 - H2, the filling height.
· The whole test has to be performed within 5 minutes.
Interpretation of result:
If the concrete flows as freely as water, at rest it will be horizontal, so H1 - H2 = 0.
Therefore the nearer this test value, the ‘filling height’, is to zero, the better the flow and
passing ability of the concrete.
Fig.3.5. Detail U-Box apparatus.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
27/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 27
3.1.5 J-Ring test
Introduction:
The principle of the JRing test may be Japanese, but no references are known. The
JRing test itself has been developed at the University of Paisley. The test is used to determine
the passing ability of the concrete. The equipment consists of a rectangular section (30mm x
25mm) open steel ring, drilled vertically with holes to accept threaded sections of
reinforcement bar. These sections of bar can be of different diameters and spaced at different
intervals: in accordance with normal reinforcement considerations, 3x the maximum
aggregate size might be appropriate. The diameter of the ring of vertical bars is 300mm, and
the height 100 mm.
The J-Ring can be used in conjunction with the Slump flow, the Orimet test, or
eventually even the V-funnel. These combinations test the flowing ability and (the
contribution of the J-Ring) the passing ability of the concrete. The Orimet time and/or slump
flow spread are measured as usual to assess flow characteristics. The J-Ring bars can
principally be set at any spacing to impose a more or less severe test of the passing ability of
the concrete. After the test, the difference in height between the concrete inside and that just
outside the JRing is measured. This is an indication of passing ability, or the degree to which
the passage of concrete through the bars is restricted.
Assessment of test:
These combinations of tests are considered to have great potential, though there is no
general view on exactly how results should be interpreted. There are a number of options –
for instance it may be instructive to compare the slump-flow/J Ring spread with the
unrestricted slump-flow: to what extent is it reduced?
Like the slump-flow test, these combinations have the disadvantage of being
unconfined, and therefore do not reflect the way concrete is placed and moves in practice.
The Orimet option has the advantage of being a dynamic test, also reflecting placement in
practice, though it suffers from requiring two operators.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
28/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 28
Equipments:
· Mould, without foot pieces, in the shape of a truncated cone with the internal
dimensions 200 mm diameter at the base, 100 mm diameter at the top and a height of
300 mm.
· Base plate of a stiff non-absorbing material, at least 700mm square, marked with a
circle
· Showing the central location for the slump cone, and a further concentric circle of
500mm diameter.
· Trowel
· Scoop
· Ruler
· J-Ring a rectangular section (30mm x 25mm) open steel ring, drilled vertically with
holes. In the holes can be screwed threaded sections of reinforcement bar (length
100mm, diameter 10mm, spacing 48 +/- 2mm)
Fig 3.6 J-Ring test apparatus
Procedure:
· About 6 litre of concrete is needed to perform the test, sampled normally.
· Moisten the base plate and inside of slump cone,
· Place base-plate on level stable ground.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
29/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 29
· Place the J Ring centrally on the base-plate and the slump-cone centrally inside it and
hold down firmly.
· Fill the cone with the scoop. Do not tamp, simply strike off the concrete level with the
top of the cone with the trowel.
· Remove any surplus concrete from around the base of the cone.
· Raise the cone vertically and allow the concrete to flow out freely.
· Measure the final diameter of the concrete in two perpendicular directions.
· Calculate the average of the two measured diameters (in mm).
· Measure the difference in height between the concrete just inside the bars and that
just outside the bars.
· Calculate the average of the difference in height at four locations (in mm).
· Note any border of mortar or cement paste without coarse aggregate at the edge of the
pool of concrete.
Interpretation of result:
It should be appreciated that although these combinations of tests measure flow and
passing ability, the results are not independent. The measured flow is certainly affected by
the degree to which the concrete movement is blocked by the reinforcing bars. The extent of
blocking is much less affected by the flow characteristics, and we can say that clearly, the
greater the difference in height, the less the passing ability of the concrete. Blocking and/or
segregation can also be detected visually, often more reliably than by calculation.
Note: The results of the J-Ring are influenced by the combination method selected
and results obtained with different combinations will not be comparable.
3.1.6 Fill Box test method
This test is also known as ‘Kajima test’. The test is used to measure the filling ability
of self compacting concrete with a maximum aggregate size of 20 mm. the apparatus consists
of a container (transparent) with a flat and smooth surface. In the container are 35 obstacles
are made of PVC with a diameter of 20mm and a distance centre to centre of 50mm, see
figure. At the top side is a put filling pipe (diameter 100mm height 500mm) with a funnel
(height 100mm). The container is filled with concrete through this filling pipe and difference
in height between two sides of the container is a measure for the filling ability.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
30/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 30
Assessment of test:
This is a test that is difficult to perform on site due to the complex structure of the
apparatus and large weight of the concrete. It gives a good impression of the self compacting
characteristics of the concrete. Even a concrete mix with a high filling ability will perform
poorly if the passing ability and segregation resistance are poor.
Equipment:
· Fill box of a stiff non absorbing material
· Scoop 1.5 to 2 liter
· Ruler
· Stopwatch
Fig.3.7. Picture of fill box empty & filled with concrete
Procedure for Fill box test method:
· About 45 liter of concrete is needed to perform the test, sampled normally.
· Set the apparatus level on firm ground, ensure that the sliding gate can open freely
and then close it.
· Moisten the inside surface of the apparatus, remove any surplus water, fill the
apparatus with the concrete sample.
· Fill the container by adding each 5 seconds one scoop with 1.5 to 2 liters of fresh
concrete into the funnel until the concrete has just covered the first top obstacle.
http://theconstructor.org/concrete/fresh-concrete/803/http://theconstructor.org/concrete/fresh-concrete/803/http://theconstructor.org/concrete/fresh-concrete/803/
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
31/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 31
· Measure after the concrete has come to rest, the height at the side at which the
container has filled on two places and calculate the average (H1). Do this also on
opposite side (H2).
· Calculate the average filling percentage: average filling percentage.
F= [(H1+H2)/2×H1] ×100%.
· The whole has to be performed within 8 minutes.
Interpretation of the result:
If the concrete flows as freely as water, at rest it will be horizontal, so average filling
percentage = 100%. Therefore the nearest this test value, the filling height’, is to be 100%,
the better self compacting characteristics of the concrete.
3.2 Acceptance criteria for SCC
Table 3.2 Acceptance criteria for Self-compacting concrete
Sl no. Methods Unit Typical range of values
Minimum Maximum
1 Slump flow by Abrams cone mm 650 800
2 T50cm slump flow sec 2 5
3 J-ring mm 0 10
4 V-funnel sec 6 12
5 Time increase, V-funnel at T5minutes sec 0 +3
6 L-box (h2/h1) 0.8 1.0
7 U-box (h2-h1) 0 30
8 Fill-box % 90 100
9 GTM Screen stability test % 0 15
10 Orimet sec 0 5
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
32/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 32
Chapter 4
MIX DESIGN
4.1 EFNARC Proposals
4.1.1 Initial mix composition:
In designing the mix it is most useful to consider the relative proportions of the key
components by volume rather than by mass.
Indicative typical ranges of proportions and quantities in order to obtain self-
compactability are given below. Further modifications will be necessary to meet strength and
other performance requirements.
Ø Water/powder ratio by volume of 0.80 to 1.10.
Ø Total powder content - 160 to 240 litres (400-600 kg) per cubic meter.
Ø Coarse aggregate content normally 28 to 35 per cent by volume of the mix.
Ø Water: cement ratio is selected based on requirements in EN 206. Typically water
content does not exceed 200 litre/m3.
Ø The sand content balances the volume of the other constituents.
Generally, it is advisable to design conservatively to ensure that the concrete is
capable of maintaining its specified fresh properties despite anticipated variations in raw
material quality. Some variation in aggregate moisture content should also be expected and
allowed for at mix design stage. Normally, viscosity-modifying admixtures are a useful tool
for compensating for the fluctuations due to any variations of the sand grading and the
moisture content of the aggregates.
4.1.2 Adjustment of the mix:
Laboratory trials should be used to verify properties of the initial mix composition. If
necessary, adjustments to the mix composition should then be made. Once all requirements
are fulfilled, the mix should be tested at full scale at the concrete plant or at site.
In the event that satisfactory performance cannot be obtained, then consideration should
be given to fundamental redesign of the mix. Depending on the apparent problem, the
following courses of action might be appropriate.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
33/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 33
Ø Using additional or different types of filler, (if available).
Ø Modifying the proportions of the sand or the coarse aggregate.
Ø Using a viscosity modifying agent, if not already included in the mix.
Ø Adjusting the dosage of the superplasticizer and/or the viscosity modifying agent.
Ø Using alternative types of superplasticizer (and/or VMA), more compatible with local
materials.
Ø Adjusting the dosage of admixture to modify the water content, and hence the
water/powder ratio.
4.2 Mix Design - M20 Grade
4.2.1 Design Stipulations
1. Characteristic compressive strength : 20Mpa
required in the field at 28-days
2. Maximum size of aggregate : 20mm
3. Degree of workability : 0.9 (compaction factor)
4. Degree of quality control : Good
5. Type of exposure : Severe
4.2.2 Test data of materials
1. Specific gravity of cement : 3.15
2. Compressive strength : Satisfies the requirements of
of cement at 7 days IS269- 1989 .
3. Specific gravities of
Coarse aggregate : 2.70
Fine aggregate : 2.65
4. Grading of aggregates : Conforming to zone II of IS 389-1970.
4.2.3 Target strength for mix proportioning
f 'ck = f ck +1.65s
where,
f 'ck = Target average compressive strength at 28 days,
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
34/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 34
f ck = Characteristic compressive strength at 28 days, and
s = Standard deviation.
From Table 1, standard deviation, s = 4 N/mm2
Therefore, target strength = 20 + 1.65 x 4 = 26.60 N/mm2
.
4.2.4 Selection of water-cement ratio
From Table 5 of IS 456,
Maximum water-cement ratio = 0.55.
Based on experience, adopt water-cement ratio as 0.50.
0.50 < 0.55, hence o.k.
4.2.5 Selection of water and sand content
Selection of water and sand content for 20 mm maximum size aggregate and the sand
confirming to ZONE -II.
For W/C-0.6, C.F-0.8, angular , sand confirming to ZONE-11.
(a). Water content per cubic meter of concrete = 186 l/m3.
(b). Sand content as percentage of total aggregate by absolute volume = 35%.
(c). C.F. = 0.9.
Change in conditions Adjustment required in
water content
Adjustment required in
sand content
For decrease in w/c ratio by (0.6-
0.5) i.e 0.10
0 -2.0%
For increase in compactingfactor (0.9-0.8) i.e 0.10
+3% 0
Total3% -2%
Therefore required sand content as percentage of total aggregate by volume = 35-2.0 = 33%.
Estimated water content for 100 mm slump = 186 + 6 x 186
100
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
35/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 35
= 197.16 liters.
As superplasticizer is used, the slump can be increased.
4.2.6 Calculation of cement content
Water-cement ratio = 0.40
Cement content = 197.16 = 394.32 kg/m3
0.50
From Table 5 of IS 456,
Minimum cement content for 'severe' exposure condition = 320 kg/m3
394.32 kg/m3 > 320 kg/m3, hence o.k.
4.2.7 Determination of coarse and fine aggregates
From IS :10262-1982, Table 3, for the specified maximum size of aggregate of 20
mm, the amount of entrapped air in the wet concrete is 2 percent.
Where ,
V = Absolute volume of fresh concrete, which is equal to gross (m3) minus the volume of
entrapped air.
W = Mass of water (kg) per m3 of concrete.
C = Mass of cement (kg) per m3of concrete.
Sc = Specific gravity of cement.
p = Ratio of fine aggregate to total aggregate by absolute volume.
f a,ca = Total masses of fine aggregate and coarse aggregate (kg) per m3of concrete
respectively,
Sfa,,Sca = Specific gravities of saturated surface dry fine aggregate and coarse aggregate
respectively.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
36/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 36
V = 1 – 2/100
V= 0.98
0.98= [197.16+ (394.32/3.15) + fa/ (0.33×2.65)]×1/1000]
Fine aggregate, f a = 575.12 kg/m3.
0.98= [197.16+ (394.32/3.15) ca/ ((1-0.33)×2.65)×1/1000]
Coarse aggregate, ca = 1189.8 kg/m3
The mix proportion per cubic meter of concrete then becomes
ater cement Fine aggregate Coarse aggregate
197.16 liters 394.32 kg 575.12 kg 1189.80 kg
0.5 1 1.46 3.02
4.2.8 Converting into SCC Proportions:
The normal concrete mix proportions are modified as per EFNARC specifications
and different trail mixes and caste. By considering the fresh properties and harden properties
of the mixes we finally arrived at the SCC mixed proportions as
Cement = 394.32
Fine aggregate = 575.12
Coarse aggregate = 1189.8
Total aggregate (T.A) = 575.12 + 1189.8 = 1764.92
Taking 54% of T.A as F.A
F.A= 1764.92×0.54 = 953.02 Kg/m3
C.A =811.9 kg/m3
The modified proportion is
ater cement Fine aggregate Coarse aggregate
197.16 liters 394.32 kg 953 kg 811.9 kg
0.5 1 2.41 2.05
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
37/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 37
4.3 Mix design – M30 grade
4.3.1 Design stipulation
1. Characteristic compressive strength : 30Mpa
required in the field at 28-days
2. Maximum size of aggregate : 20mm
3. Degree of workability : 0.9 (compaction factor)
4. Degree of quality control : Good
5. Type of exposure : Severe
4.3.2 Test data of materials
1. Specific gravity of cement : 3.15
2. Compressive strength : Satisfies the requirements
of cement at 7 days of IS 269- 1989
3. Specific gravities of
Coarse aggregate : 2.70
Fine aggregate : 2.65
4. Grading of aggregates : Conforming to zone II of IS 389-1970.
4.3.3 Target strength for mix proportioning
f 'ck = f ck +1.65s
where,
f 'ck = target average compressive strength at 28 days,
f ck = characteristic compressive strength at 28 days, and
s = standard deviation.
From Table 1, standard deviation, s = 5 N/mm2
Therefore, target strength = 20 + 1.65 x 5 = 38. 25 N/mm2
4.3.4 Selection of water-cement ratio
From Table 5 of IS 456,
Maximum water-cement ratio = 0.5.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
38/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 38
Based on experience, adopt water-cement ratio as 0.45.
0.45 < 0.5, hence o.k.
4.3.5 Selection of water and sand content
Selection of water and sand content for 20mm maximum size aggregate and the sand
confirming to ZONE -II.
For W/C-0.6, C.F-0.8, angular, sand confirming to ZONE-11.
(a). Water content per cubic meter of concrete = 186 /m3
(b). Sand content as percentage of total aggregate by absolute volume = 35 %
(c). C.F. = 0.9
Change in conditions Adjustment required in
water content
Adjustment required in
sand content
For decrease in w/c ratio by (0.6-
0.5) i.e 0.10
0 -2.0%
For increase in compactingfactor (0.9-0.8) i.e 0.10
+3% 0
Total
3% -2%
Therefore required sand content as percentage of total aggregate by volume = 35-2.0=33%
Estimated water content for 100 mm slump = 186 + 6 x 186
100
= 197.16 litres.
As superplasticizer is used, the slump can be increased.
4.3.6 Calculation of cement content
Water-cement ratio = 0.40
Cement content = 197.16 = 438.13 kg/m3
0.45
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
39/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 39
From Table 5 of IS 456,
Minimum cement content for 'severe' exposure condition = 320 kg/m3
438.13 kg/m3 > 320 kg/m3, hence o.k.
4.3.7 Determination of coarse and fine aggregates
From IS :10262-1982, Table 3, for the specified maximum size of aggregate of 20
mm, the amount of entrapped air in the wet concrete is 2 percent.
Where,
V = absolute volume of fresh concrete, which is equal to gross (m3) minus the volume of
entrapped air.
W = Mass of water (kg) per m3 of concrete.
C = Mass of cement (kg) per m
3
of concrete.Sc = specific gravity of cement.
P = Ratio of fine aggregate to total aggregate by absolute volume.
f a , ca = Total masses of fine aggregate and coarse aggregate (kg) per m3of concrete
respectively.
Sfa ,Sca = Specific gravities of saturated surface dry fine aggregate and coarse aggregate
respectively.
V = 1 – 2/100
V= 0.98
0.98= [197.16+ (438.13/3.15) + fa / (0.33×2.65)]×1/1000]
Fine aggregate, f a = 562.96 kg/m3.
0.98= [197.16+ (438.13/3.15) + ca/ ((1-0.33)×2.65)×1/1000]
Coarse aggregate , ca = 1142.98 kg/m3.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
40/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 40
The mix proportion per cubic meter of concrete then becomes
water cement Fine aggregate Coarse aggregate
197.16 liters 438.13 kg 562.96 kg 1142.98 kg
0.45 1 1.29 2.60
4.3.8 Converting into SCC Proportions
The normal concrete mix proportions are modified as per EFNARC specifications
and different trail mixes and caste. By considering the fresh properties and harden properties
of the mixes we finally arrived at the SCC mixed proportions as
Cement = 438.13
Fine aggregate = 562.96
Coarse aggregate = 1142.98
Total aggregate (T.A) = 562.96 + 1142.98 = 1705.94
Taking 54% of T.A as F.A
F.A= 1705.94×0.54 = 921.2 Kg/m3
C.A =784.74 kg/m3
The modified proportion is
ater cement Fine aggregate Coarse aggregate
197.16 liters 438.13 kg 921.2 kg 784.74 kg
0.5 1 2.41 2.05
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
41/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 41
4.4 SCC proportions with SCBA
Table 4.1 M20 Grade SCC proportions
Mixdesignation
Cementkg/m
3SCBAreplacement
levels kg/m3,
(%)
Quarrydust,
kg/m3
Fineaggregate,
kg/m3
Coarseaggregate,
kg/m3
Water,
kg/m3
M1-0 394.32 0(0)
285.9 667.1 811.9 197.16
M1-5 374.60 19.72(5)
MI-10 354.88 39.44(10)
M1-15 335.16 59.16(15)
M1-20 315.45 78.86(20)
Table 4.2 M30 Grade SCC proportions
Mix
designation
Cement
kg/m3
SCBA
replacement
levels kg/m3,
(%)
Quarry
dust,
kg/m3
Fine
aggregate,
kg/m3
Coarse
aggregate,
kg/m3
Water,
kg/m3
M2-0 438.13 0(0)
276.36 644.84 784.74 197.16
M2-5 416.23 21.9(5)
M2-10 394.33 43.80(10)
M2-15 372.41 65.72(15)
M2-20 350.51 87.62(20)
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
42/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 42
Chapter 5
EXPERIMENTAL PROGRAMME
5.1 Objectives:Ø The aim of this experimental investigation is to incorporate agrowaste i.e Sugarcane
Bagasse Ash in self compacting concrete.
Ø To know the optimum replacement percentage of cement by sugarcane bagasse ash.
Ø Use of waste in a useful manner.
Ø To provide economical construction material.
Ø Provide safeguard to the environment by utilizing waste properly.
5.2 Material properties
5.2.1. Cement:
Ordinary Portland cement of 53 grade from the local market was used and tested for
physical and chemical properties as per IS: 4031 – 1988 and found to be conforming to
various specifications as per IS: 12269-1987.
Fig 5.1 cement
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
43/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 43
1. Specific gravity: 3.15
2. Normal consistency: 30%
3. Initial setting time: 90 min
4. Final setting time: 10 hrs
5. Compressive strength.
· 7 days : 37 N/mm2.
· 14 days : 54 N/mm2.
· 28 days : 70.6 N/mm2.
5.2.2 Fine aggregate: Sand
The aggregate which is passing through 4.75 mm sieve is known as fine aggregate.
Locally available river sand which is free from organic impurities is used sand passing
through 4.75mm sieve and retained on 150 micron IS sieve is used in this investigation. The
physical properties of fine aggregate like specific gravity, bulk density, gradation and
fineness modulus are tested in accordance with IS: 2386-1975.
Fig 5.2 Fine aggregate – Sand
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
44/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 44
Table 5.1 Sieve analysis of fine aggregate
Weight of sand sample taken = 1000g.
I.S.SeiveSize
Weight of
aggregate
retained in gms
Cumulative
Weight retained
in gms
Cumulative %
of weight
retained
% of passing
Remarks
10 mm 0 0 0 100
Zone –II4.75 mm 0 0 0 100
2.36 mm 10 10 1 99
1.18 mm 197.5 207.5 20.75 79.25
600 µ 371.0 578.5 57.85 42.15
300 µ 353.0 931.5 93.15 6.85
150 µ 68.5 1000.0 100.0 0
Fineness modulus of fine aggregate = 272.75/100 = 2.7275 = 2.72
Property Result
Fineness modulus 2.72
Specific gravity 2.648
Bulk density (Kg/m3) 1690
5.2.3 Quarry dust:
This is the powder form of the jelly obtained in the quarry. A by-product from the
crushing process during quarrying activities. Quarry dust as fine aggregate is promising
greater strength, lower permeability and greater density which enable it to provide better
resistance to freeze/thaw cycles and durability in adverse environment. It is obtained from
local crushing plant (bidadi). It is shown in fig. 5.3
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
45/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 45
Fig 5.3 Quarry dust
Property Result
Fineness modulus 2.70
Specific gravity 2.68
Bulk density (Kg/m3) 1790
5.2.4 Coarse aggregate
The crushed coarse aggregate of 20 mm maximum size rounded obtained from the
local crushing plant (bidadi) is used in the present study. The physical properties of coarse
aggregate like specific gravity, bulk density, gradation and fineness modulus are tested in
accordance with IS : 2386-1975.
Fig 5.4 Coarse aggregate - Jelly
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
46/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 46
Table 5.2 Sieve analysis of coarse aggregate
Weight of sand sample taken = 10000g
IS.Sieve
Size
Weight of
Aggregate
retained in gms
Cumulative
weight retained
in gms
Cumulative %
of weight
retained
% of
passing
20mm 0 0 0 100
16mm 1240 1240 12.40 87.60
12.5mm 8260 9500 95.00 5.00
10mm 290 9790 97.90 2.10
8mm 120 9910 99.10 0.8
6.3mm 40 9950 99.50 0.54.75mm 20 9970 99.70 0.3
pan 30 10000 - 0
Fineness modulus of coarse aggregate = 503.6/100 =5.034
Property Result
Fineness modulus 5.03
Specific gravity 2.70
Bulk density (Kg/m3) 1460
5.2.5 Pozzolana: Sugarcane Bagasse Ash
Sugarcane production in India is over 300 million tons/year that cause about 10
million tons of SCBA as un-utilized and waste. The sugarcane bagasse consists of
approximately 50% of cellulose, 25% of hemicellulose and 25% of lignin. Each ton of
sugarcane generates approximately 26% of bagasse (at a moisture content of 50%) and
0.62% of residual ash. The residue after combustion presents a chemical composition
dominates by silicon dioxide (SiO2). In spite of being a material of hard degradation and that
presents few nutrients, the ash is used on the farms as a fertilizer in the sugarcane harvests.
Sugarcane bagasse ash is burnt at the boiler temperatures for the production of electricity .In
this sugarcane bagasse ash was collected during the cleaning operation of a boiler.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
47/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 47
Fig 5.5 Sugarcane bagasse ash
5.2.5.1 Chemical requirements of pozzolana
The material as pozzolona shall conform to the chemical requirements given in Table as
per IS 3812-1981.
Table 5.3 Chemical requirements of a Pozzolana
SL
NOCHARACTERISTIC PARAMETERS REQUIREMENT
1. Silicon dioxide (SiO2) plus aluminium oxide (Al2O3)
plus iron oxide (Fe2O3) percent by mass, Min 70.0
2 Silicon dioxide (SiO2), percent by mass, Min 35.0
3 Magnesium oxide (MgO), percent by mass, Max 5.0
4 Total sulphur as sulphur trioxide (SO3), percent by mass,
Max
2.75
5 Available alkalis as sodium oxide (Na2O), percent by mass,
Max
1.5
6 Loss on ignition, percent by mass, Max 12.0
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
48/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 48
5.2.5.2 Comparative study of Sugarcane Bagasse Ash:
The sugarcane bagasse ash sample which is obtained after burning the dry bagasse for
electricity production at different boiler temperatures is being collected from factories in
mandya district and its chemical compostion is been analysed for the choice of better
sample which satisfy the chemical requirements of a pozzolana.
Sample 1 - collected from Corramandel sugars, maakavalli, K R pete taluk, which is burnt
at boiler temperature of 7500C.
Sample 2 - collected from Mandya sugar limited, mandya taluk which is burnt at boiler
temperature at 7000C.
Sample 3 - collected from Chamundeshwari sugar limited, K M doddi , maddur taluk
which is burnt at boiler of 6000C.
Sample 4 - collected from Pandavapura cooperative sugar limited, pandavapura taluk
which is burnt at boiler of 8000C.
Table 5.4 Composition of SCBA samples
Sl No parameters Sample 1 Sample 2 Sample 3 Sample 4
1 Silica as SiO2 33.20 % 30.36 % 16.35 % 67.80 %
2 Calcium as CaO 1.18 % 3.12 % 4.53 % 1.39 %
3 Iron as Fe2O3 0.14 % 8.14 % 2.84 % 0.18 %
4 Sodium as Na2O 2.69 % 2.68 % 1.98 % 1.36 %
5 Potassium as K 2O 1.20 % 6.58 % 2.76 % 1.66 %
6 Aluminium as Al2O3 0.08 % 0.20 % 12.00 % 0.06 %
7 Magnesium as MgO 0.72 % 2.20 % 2.89 % 0.89 %
8 Loss on Ignition (LOI)
at 9000C
44.56 % 34.62 % 19.81 % 22.12 %
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
49/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 49
Sample 4 collected from pandavapura co-operative sugar limited factory is
being used in this experimental investigation as it has confirmed to the most requirement as a
pozzolona. The chemical composition reveals that SCBA sample from pandavapura sugar
factory can be assigned as class F fly ash type (SiO2+Al2O3+Fe2O3 is greater than 70 %)
exempting the LOI parameter.
The Bagasse ash passing through 150µ IS sieve is used in the experimental work.
Property Result
colour Blackish Grey
Specific gravity 2.04
Bulk density (Kg/m3) 451
5.2.6 Water
As per IS 456:2000, water used for both mixing and curing should be free from
injurious amount of deleterious materials, suspended solids and organic materials. Portable
water (tap water) from municipal water supply network system is generally considered
satisfactory for mixing and curing concrete.
5.2.7 Admixture : Glenium B233
Glenium B233 is an admixture of a new generation based on modified
polycarboxylic ether. The product has been primarily developed for applications in high
performance concrete where the highest durability and performance is required. Glenium
B233 is free of chloride & low alkali. It is compatible with all types of cements.
5.2.7.1 Uses
Ø Production of Rheodynamic concrete.
Ø High performance concrete for durability.
Ø High early and ultimate strength concrete.
Ø High workability without segregation or bleeding.
Ø Precast & Pre-stressed concrete.
Ø Concrete containing pozzolans such as microsilica, GGBFS, PFA including high
volume fly ash concrete.
8/19/2019 Sugarcane Bagasee Ash as a Cement Replacement
50/82
An Experimental Study on Sugarcane Bagasse Ash as a Cement Replacement Material in Self
Compacting Concrete
Dept of Civil Engineering, GCE, Ramanagaram 50
5.2.7.2 Advantages
Ø Elimination of vibration and reduced labour cost in placing.
Ø Marked increase in early & ultimate strengths.
Ø Higher Elastic modulus.
Ø Improved adhesion to reinforcing and stressing steel.
Ø Better resistance to carbonation and other aggressive atmospheric conditions.
Ø Lower permeability-increased durability.
Ø Reduced shrinkage and creep.
5.2.7.3 Description
Glenium B233 has a different chemical structure from the traditional superplasticisers. It
consists of a carboxylic ether polymer with long side chains. At the beginning of the mixing
process it initiates the same electrostatic dispersion mechanism as the traditional
superplasticisers, but the side chains linked to the polymer backbone generates a steric
hindrance which greatly stabilises