Upload
bintolal
View
225
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
1/58
Name of the Student : Sudheesh U
Student Registration No : BUB0908004
Module Leader at MSRSAS : Prof. B. S. Ajith Kumar
TITLE PAGE
POSTGAD
ENNRNPROGAMMEP
M.S.Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies
Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)New BEL Road, Gnanagangothri Campus, MSR Nagar,Bangalore-560 054
Tel/Fax: 23605539/23601983; website: http://www.msrsas.org
Production Planning & Scheduling
EMM503
Centre Name: Mechanical & Automotive Engineering
Course Name:M.Sc (Engg) in Engg & Mfg M anagement
FULL TIME 2008 BATCH
ASSIGNMENT
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
2/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling ii
DDEECCLLAARRAATTIIOONN
Student Name: Sudheesh U
Reg No: BUB0908004
Course: MSc (Engg) - EMM
Module Code: EMM504
Module Title: Production Planning and Scheduling
Module Leader: Prof. B. S. Ajith Kumar Module Date:
16.03.09
Submission Date:
11.04.09
SUBMISSION ARRANGEMENTS:This assignment must be submitted to Academic Records Office (ARO) by the submission date BEFORE 1730
hours for Full-Time and 1930 hours for Part-Time Evening students.
Extension requests:Extensions can only be granted by the Head of the Department / Course Manager for Postgraduate EngineeringProgrammes. Extensions granted by any other person will not be accepted and hence the assignment will incur apenalty. Extensions MUST be requestedby using the Extension Request Form, which is available with the ARO.
A copy of the extension approval must be attached to the assignment submitted .
PENALTY FOR LATE SUBMISSIONUnless you have submitted proof of Mitigating Circumstances or have been granted an extension, the penalties for alate submission of an assignment shall be as follows:
Up to one week late: Penalty of one grade (5 marks) One-Two weeks late: Penalty of two grades (10 marks) Two-three weeks late: Maximum mark of 40% More than three weeks late: Fail - 0% recorded (F2)All late assignments: must be submitted to Academic Records Office (ARO). It is your responsibility to ensure that the
receipt of a late assignment is recorded in the ARO. If an extension was agreed, the authorization should be submittedto ARO during the submission of assignment.
To ensure assignments are written concisely, the length should be restricted a limit indicated in the assignmentquestions. Assignments greater than this length will incur a penalty of one grade (5 marks). Each participant is
required to retain a copy of the assignment in his or her record in case of any loss.
DECLARATIONThe assignment submitted herewith is a result of my own investigations and that I have conformed to the guidelines
against plagiarism as lay out in the PEPs staff/student Handbook. All sections of the text and results, which have beenobtained from other sources, are fully referenced. I understand that cheating and plagiarism constitute a breach of
University regulations and will be dealt with accordingly.
Signed:
Sudheesh U
Date:
11-04-09
Signature Date Stamp Signature
Module Leader Course Manger
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
3/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling iii
AABBSSTTRRAACCTT
Globalization changed the way the world think and act. It made huge influences in all
the areas. The good and bad affect of these changed the people lifestyle, nations economy. In
last two or three decades the manufacturing and service sectors in the world had considerably
changed. New people came in the picture. Competitions increased between them. Many
companies and nations grow dramatically. But some couldnt survive. The organizations must
concentrate more on internal process and manufacturing related activities to improve the
throughput. Production planning and scheduling is very important to achieve the targets and to
win the market orders.
Planning and scheduling is one of the main activities of a manufacturing firm. Smart
planning reduces the errors, utilizes the resources, and helps to meet the delivery periods. The
PART A deals with a real time situation for planning and scheduling a product through some
operation. Preactor is used as the software tool. Preactor is one of the major production and
advanced planning and scheduling software available. The planning and the interpretation of
the result are carried out in this part.
PART B contains three discussions. The first discussion is based on the personal
policies followed by industries. The differences in the many areas are analyzed to explain the
two personal policies- A stable workforce, varying workforce.
Inventory is stock of material, which can be used for further operations when required.
Manufacturing personnel considers inventory as liability. But the zero inventory may not be
possible, due to the production and market factors. The second discussion in PART B relates
inventory with nine competitive priorities. The tabular column is prepared to match inventory
types and competitive priorities.
The third part of PART B contains five discussions, including an ERP implementation
case study. This part discuss about MPS and shop floor capacity planning, process
synchronization, bottlenecks and buffers, and about level production. These discussions are
very brief to illustrate the ideas.
PART C is a presentation about forecasting methods. The presentation slides are added
with this paper.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
4/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling iv
LLIISSTT OOFF CCOONNTTEENNTTSS
TITLE PAGE................................................................................................................. i
DECLARATION .......................................................................................................... ii
ABSTRACT .................................................................................................................iiiLIST OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................. iv
LIST OF TABLES ....................................................................................................... vi
LIST OF FIGURES .................................................................................................... vii
LIST OF SYMBOLS ................................................................................................. viii
PART A .............................................................................................................. 1
Chapter 1 ...................................................................................................................... 1
1. Scheduling Using PREACTOR Software ........................................................... 1
1.1. Introduction ........................................................................................... 1
1.2. Given Data and Interpretations ............................................................... 1
1.2.1. Requirements ......................................................................................... 21.2.2. Interpretation of the data ........................................................................ 2
1.3. Steps Involved- Flow chart .................................................................... 2
1.4. Results and Discussions ......................................................................... 3
1.5. Conclusion ........................................................................................... 11
PART B ............................................................................................................ 12
Chapter 2 (Question: 1) .............................................................................................. 12
2. Personal Policies................................................................................................. 122.1. Introduction ......................................................................................... 12
2.2. Personal Policies .................................................................................. 12
2.3. Stable Work Force andVarying Workforce ......................................... 132.4. The Two Extreme Policies in Different Areas ...................................... 14
2.4.1. Markets ................................................................................................ 14
2.4.2. Management ........................................................................................ 15
2.4.3. Products ............................................................................................... 16
2.4.4. Financial position................................................................................. 16
2.4.5. Skills ................................................................................................... 17
2.4.6. Costs .................................................................................................... 17
2.4.7. Competition ......................................................................................... 18
2.5. Recommended method of Sales & Operation Plan for each Policy ....... 18
2.5.1. A Comparison ...................................................................................... 19
2.6. Conclusion ........................................................................................... 19
Chapter 3 (Question: 2) .............................................................................................. 20
3. Inventory and Competitive Priorities ............................................................... 203.1. Introduction ......................................................................................... 20
3.2. Inventory ............................................................................................. 20
3.3. Nine Competitive Priorities .................................................................. 20
3.4. Inventory and Competitive Priority ...................................................... 21
3.4.1. Cost ..................................................................................................... 21
3.4.2. Quality ................................................................................................. 21
3.4.3. Time .................................................................................................... 22
3.4.4. Flexibility ............................................................................................ 22
3.5. Comparison ......................................................................................... 23
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
5/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling v
3.6. Zero Inventory ..................................................................................... 23
3.6.1. Inventory is liability, then why to keep inventory? ............................... 24
3.7. Conclusion ........................................................................................... 24
Chapter 5 (Question: 3) .............................................................................................. 26
4. Discussions on Some Topics ............................................................................... 264.1. Introduction ......................................................................................... 26
4.2. MPS and shop-floor capacity planning (Q3: A) .................................... 26
4.2.1. Agility of shop floor............................................................................. 27
4.3. Process Synchronization (Q3: B) ......................................................... 28
4.4. Buffers and bottlenecks (Q3: C) ........................................................... 28
4.5. Advantages of Level Production (Q3: D) ............................................. 29
4.6. ERP Implementation Case Study (Q3: E) ............................................. 30
4.6.1. ERP Implementation at Waltham Forest Borough Council ................... 31
4.6.2. Conclusion ........................................................................................... 31
PART C ............................................................................................................ 33
Chapter 6 .................................................................................................................... 33
5. Presentation on Forecasting .............................................................................. 33
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................... 47
BIBLIOGRAPHY ....................................................................................................... 49
Annexure A ................................................................................................................. 50
Glossary of Terms Used.............................................................................................. 50
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
6/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling vi
LLIISSTT OOFF TTAABBLLEESS
Table 1:1 Data Given for Scheduling .............................................................................. 1
Table 1:2 Operations and Resource details ...................................................................... 1
Table 1:3 The summary of Scheduling in Different Steps ............................................. 10
Table 2:1 Comparison of Chase and Level Production .................................................. 19
Table 3:1 Nine Competitive Priorities ........................................................................... 21
Table 3:2 Inventory and Competitive Priorities ............................................................. 23
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
7/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling vii
LLIISSTT OOFF FFIIGGUURREESS
Figure 1:1 Steps for Planning .......................................................................................... 3
Figure 1:2 Shift Pattern for a Day ................................................................................... 3
Figure 1:3 Resource Groups ........................................................................................... 4
Figure 1:4 Product Database ........................................................................................... 5
Figure 1:5 Forward Scheduling Without Split Batch ....................................................... 6
Figure 1:6 Forward Scheduling With Split Batch ............................................................ 7
Figure 1:7 Forward Scheduling With Rush Order ........................................................... 8
Figure 1:8 Power Cut Data ............................................................................................. 8
Figure 1:9 The Final Scheduling ..................................................................................... 9
Figure 1:10 Final Scheduling with rush order and power cut ........................................... 9
Figure 1:11 Utilization for HMC1 Machine .................................................................. 10
Figure 2:1 Demand for labor in chase production .......................................................... 15
Figure 2:2 Demand for labor in Level production ......................................................... 15
Figure 4:1 MPS and Capacity Planning in MPC............................................................ 27Figure 4:2 Drum-buffer-rope system ............................................................................. 29
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
8/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling viii
LLIISSTT OOFF SSYYMMBBOOLLSS
BOM Bill Of MaterialERP Enterprise Resource Planning
FGI Finished Goods Inventory
MRP Materials Requirement Planning
MRP II Materials Resource Planning
OEE Overall Equipment Effectiveness
PLC Product Life Cycle
PO Purchase Order
RPI Raw Product Inventory
SCM Supply Chain management
TPM Total Productive Maintenance
TQM Total Quality Management
WCM World Class Manufacturing
WIP Work In Process
MPS Master Production Schedule
S&OP Sales and Operations Planning
AOP Annual Operation Plan
MPC Manufacturing Planning and Control
SME Small and Medium Enterprises
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
9/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 1
PART A
CChhaapptteerr 11
1. Scheduling Using PREACTOR Software1.1.Introduction
Meeting customer demand is very critical in todays globalized market. To meet the
customer requirement, a production process must be effectively planned. The production
planning and scheduling is thus a vital criteria to compete in the market. Failing in the delivery
promises will make the firm out of the business.
Preactor is one of the production and advanced planning and scheduling software
developed by Preactor International, United Kingdom. The scheduling is done by finite
capacity scheduling method (1). Finite scheduling systems simulate actual job order starting and
stopping to produce a detailed schedule for each shop order and each machine centre. Finite
schedule explicitly establishes a detailed schedule for each job through each work centre
capacities and the other scheduled jobs (2).
1.2.Given Data and InterpretationsThe data given in the problem are given below. The interpretation of the given data and
the expected output are discussed after that.
Table 1:1 Data Given for Scheduling
Type of Industry Automobile Ancillary Manufacturing Industry
Product High Pressure Housing
Customer ABC India Ltd
Order Number HPH1
Order Quantity 3500 Numbers
Operation Details See Table 1:2
Available Resources See Table 1:2
Working Days 5 days a week (22 Days for April, 2009)Shifts 3 Shifts/Day
Shift Timing Given with Break timings
Table 1:2 Operations and Resource details
Sl.
No.
Operation
Number
Operation
Name
Set Up Time Process Time Resource
Name
Numberof
Resources
RemarksSeconds Minutes
1 10 Operation 1 00 Mins 02 Mins Twin Spindle 1
The machine has twospindles so effective
cycle time is 1min/component
2 20 Operation 2 0.15 Mins 15 Mins HMC 9
3 30 Operation 3 0.30 Mins 03 Mins Hot Spray 3 -Nil-
4 40 Operation 4 0.05 Mins 20 Mins TEM 3 -Nil-
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
10/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 2
5 50 Operation 5 00 Mins 01 Mins Cooling 1
6 60 Operation 6 00 Mins 1.5 Mins Visual Inspection 1
1.2.1. Requirements1. Do the forward scheduling to find out whether the schedule is meeting the customer
due date (i.e., April 30, 2009)
2. Find solution to meet the customer demand.3. Include 200 additional requirement (Dated 20th of April 2009) in the scheduling.4. Also include a 30 minutes power cut from 20th to 25th of April 2009 at 5.00 Hrs
(Issued by electricity supplier).
5. Analyze the schedule and discuss with management about the results.1.2.2.
Interpretation of the data
The process time for twin spindle is given as 2min. As the machine has two spindles,
the process time is considered as 1min.
The forward scheduling must be done with respect to the due date.
The order quantity is large, thus split batching must be required.
Some resources are available in more quantities. All the resources must be utilized to
meet the demand.
Rush order, and power cut may increase the planned days.
1.3.Steps Involved- Flow chart
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
11/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 3
Figure 1:1 Steps for Planning
1.4.Results and DiscussionsStep 1: Shift pattern
Created shift timing for Monday (Figure 1:2). Copied that to all the other days. Then
deleted the non-working days shifts. (From calendar status in maintain database.)
Figure 1:2 Shift Pattern for a Day
Shifts
Breaks
Step 1: Create shift plan
for all the working days.
Step 2: Add resources
Step 3: Add resource
group
Step 4: Create Product
data base
Ste 5: Generate Schedule
Does Plan meet
delivery date?
Ste 6: Do s lit bachin
No
Does Plan meet
delivery date?Yes
Ste 7: Add rush orderDoes Plan meet
delivery date?Yes
Ste 8: Add ower cutDoes Plan meetdelivery date? Yes
Step 9: Analyze the schedule.
Check the machine utilization.
Deliver da s.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
12/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 4
Step 2&3: Resources and Resource Groups
Create resources, and then resource groups (Figure 1:3). Add resources to resource
groups.
Figure 1:3 Resource Groups
Step 4: Product Database
Add product details in Maintain DatabaseProducts. Part number, Operation number,
Operation name are to be entered.
The resource group is to be entered for each operation. While scheduling, Preactorwill
select the resources from resource group accordingly.
Add the setup & Operation times. (inFigure 1:4)
HMC1,
HMC2, HMC9
Resources
ResourceGrou s
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
13/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 5
Figure 1:4 Product Database
Step 5: Schedule Generation
The schedule is generated from the Generate Schedule menu. To generate schedule,
the Customer name (ABC India Ltd), Purchase Order number (HPH1), Order quantity (3500),
are to be entered.
Start Date: 01-04-2009
Delivery Date: 01-04-2009
Select options Forward Scheduling, Due Date, and then ClickAllocate(Figure 1:5)
Resource
For Step: 6
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
14/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 6
Figure 1:5 Forward Scheduling Without Split Batch
The schedule span is of 160 days. That means the planning doesnt meet the schedules.
So adjustments must be made to reduce the time span. Step 6 finds the solution for this.
Step 6: Schedule Generation with Split Batching
From Figure 1:5, it is can be seen that not all the resources are taken for scheduling. For
example, HMC 2 to HMC 9 is not utilized. All the ordered quantities (3500 Nos) are processed
in a single batch. So the large batch makes the problem. To overcome this, the 3500Nos must
split to smaller batches. The batch size be 25Nos.
To make the split batch, the product attributes must be changes to split, and quantity as
25 Nos (seeFigure 1:4). Now the Step 5 needs to be repeated. The result is shown inFigure
1:6.
Resources
Fwd Schedule
Due DateAllocate 160 Days
Late Jobs
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
15/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 7
Figure 1:6 Forward Scheduling With Split Batch
Now the schedule span can meet the delivery schedule. So this can be considered as the
final scheduling. There are some more conditions; they are discussed in next steps.
Step 7: Scheduling with Rush Order
As per the requirement (shown in 1.2.1) there is an additional requirement of 200
Units on 20th of April 2009. This rush order must be added to the present schedule. The
scheduling need to be analyzed for due date.
The rush order also added in the same way as mentioned in Step 5, but with a quantity
of 200Units. The generated schedule is shown inFigure 1:7.
26 Days 16:48
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
16/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 8
Figure 1:7 Forward Scheduling With Rush Order
Now the schedule span can meet the delivery schedule. Now to conclude whether to
accept or reject the additional requirement, the power cut also must be considered in the
schedule. Step 8 Explains.
Step 8: Scheduling with Rush Order and Power Cut
A 30 min power cut is issued by the electricity supplier from 20th
to 25th
of April 2009
at 5.00 Hrs. To add this special situation for all the resources in the specified days, the special
calendar editing is required. There the start time (with date) and end time (with date) is entered.
The efficiency is entered as 0.00% which means it is a break down situation. (Figure 1:8)
Figure 1:8 Power Cut Data
Now the scheduling is to be done, with same steps done before. TheFigure 1:9 shows
the Gantt chart of the schedule. The Figure 1:9 is a enlarged view, and thus showing only some
part of the schedule. The power cut can be seen in the Figure 1:9. The Figure 1:10 shows the
complete scheduling view with performance metrics window.
27 Days 20:11
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
17/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 9
Figure 1:9 The Final Scheduling
Figure 1:10 Final Scheduling with rush order and power cut
The final scheduled time span is 27 Days 22 Hours and 11 Minutes. I.e., the first order
of 3500 and additional order of 200 also can be done within the delivery requirements. The
Table 1:3 shows the summary after every step of the scheduling.
Power Cut
27 Days 22:11
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
18/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 10
Table 1:3 The summary of Scheduling in Different Steps
Sl.
No.
Step Description Scheduled Due Date Schedule Span
1 Step 5Schedule without split
batch08/09/2009; 21:30 160 Days 15:32 Not Ok
2 Step 6Schedule with split
batch27/04/2009; 22:47 26 Days 16:48 Ok
3 Step 7Scheduling with rush
order29/04/2009; 02:10 27 Days 20:11 Ok
4 Step 8Scheduling with rush
order and power cut29/04/2009; 04:10 27 Days 22:11 Ok
The promised delivery date is on 30/04/2009
The Preactorsoftware is having many more features where many types of reports can
be generated from the Report menu in the menu bar. Also machine utilization of individualresources can also be determined. The Figure 1:11 shows the utilization of machines. The
popup window gives complete detail ofHMC1 machine.
Figure 1:11 Utilization for HMC1 Machine
In this scheduling, the idle time of the HMC1 machine 47%. That means the resource is
not utilizing properly. But in many cases the product line will have more than one product and
it will be a small batch production. So at that time the idle time will be very less, as the machine
will be occupied by any of the product.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
19/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 11
1.5.ConclusionProduction planning and scheduling is important in a manufacturing organization for the
effective use of available resources. Many organizations fails to do proper planning and
scheduling of their resources, and thus they falls behind the customer orders. Delivering
products on time with higher quality with minimum cost has become a mandatory requirement
for todays industries. Advanced planning helps organizations to simulate the scheduling, and
there by the planning person can understand the problems well before. This ensures maximum
use of resources, on time delivery, and avoids many problems which normally happens in a
production line.
Preactor is an advanced planning and scheduling software which can be linked to other
softwres like ERP, MES, forecasting, etc. The execution of the planning is equally important as
the planning of production process. To get the best result the organization must have good
interdepartmental communication, motivated and co-operative work force, and strong strategic
goals.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
20/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 12
PART B
CChhaapptteerr 22 ((QQuueessttiioonn:: 11))
2. Personal Policies2.1.IntroductionIt is a competitive world. To be in the business, firms must adopt best practices, and
policies. People are a very important factor for a companys success. A creative workforce can
add more value to its product and services. A skilled and motivated employee is an asset for the
company. Organizations treat employees in different ways. Good or bad, the company will be
affected. So finding a better personal policy; that will suit to the companys working nature,
and can go along with organization behaviour; is important. The selection, implementation, and
execution all are very much vital. This chapter finds out the two extreme policies, followed by
industries. The effect of these policies in different areas in the function is described.
2.2.Personal PoliciesPersonal policies are defined in many ways. It is a set of rules that define the manner in
which an organization deals with a human resources or personnel-related subject. A personnel
policy should reflect good practice, be written down, be communicated across the organization,
and should adapt to changing circumstances(3)
.
People are their most valuable resource. For the higher productivity and to achieve the
organizational goals, a co-operative workforce is required. Job security as well as the flexibility
is important for employee and the employer. When discussing about the two extreme personal
policies, followed by todays manufacturing as we ll as service industries, both gives them
(employer) good and bad effects. Creativity, loyalty, turnaround, motivation, skills, etc are
affected due to the differences in the policies.
Also many factors like shortages of people, unavailability of skilled labor, unskilled
manpower, complex laws, social commitments, average age of the population, union, profits,
flexible work time requirements, outsourcing, cost of replacing a lost worker, etc are make
effect on organizations personal policies (4).There many other factors (opportunities as well as
threats) in the human recourse management. In case of woman employee, the demand for day
care and maternity leave, etc comes.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
21/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 13
2.3.Stable Work ForceandVarying WorkforceA competitive market requires more and more with less, in terms of time, cost, and
recourses. All the modern manufacturing philosophies and techniques are made to achieve the
best with optimum recourses. Human is also comes in the same way. With less number of
manpower, companies strive to achieve more profits. The cell alignments, value stream
mapping (VSM), are implemented for knowing the exact employee requirement in the
production and to make the maximum out of them.
It can say (most of the time) that a stable workforce exist only in government
organizations. The present economic slowdown shows many examples. But most of these
private sector companies were having a stable workforce, which is responsible for work
processes of each stage of the product. Organizations use the creativity of such personnel as and
when required. Organizations never try or act to lose those workers when they dont have
enough work. The present slowdown is an extreme situation, where the companies first give
priority for the existence of the firm. In such situation, many employees are put in trouble. But
in normal situations the employee turnover is the main problem of many organizations, as the
cost of losing a permanent employee will be a bad effect in terms of cost and skill. In Japanese
world-class plants, operators spend more time in the induction process, have longer probation
periods and a lower early drop-out rate (5). The positive as well as the negative effect of this
policy is described in the coming section with respect to manufacturing industries.
When an organization requires more number of persons, the organization need not go
for selecting fulltime employee as it will add more cost to selection process. In such situation
organizations hire workers. It happens when they need varying need for employees. The
situation can be due to a seasonal demand, new trend, special occasions, new product
development, etc. So the companies find the benefits of hiring contingent workers. They are
workers who do not have expectation of regular fulltime employment (4). They can be
- Part time workers
- Temporary workers
- Seasonal workers
- Independent contractors
- Interns
- Co-op students
If available, they have many advantages for the companies. They need less training, and
the companies need not to keep them in a less demand time. In India, after the booming of IT
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
22/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 14
industries, the terms like outsourcing, bench, hiring, etc became popular like in USA, or
European countries.
The employment tenure1 is an important factor which affects different aspects of the
organizations measures. The lower job stability can reduce the productivity. There are many
differences in this context while comparing developed countries and developing countries (6).
When a production company needs to keep the same outputs in every month, regardless
of the fluctuations in the demand, uses a constant-level workforce. This level production
mainly uses inventory to match the demand variations(7)
.
In case of chase production, the production outputs are varied to match the demand. In
this case the output is controlled by changing the workforce size(7)
. The outputs are also
varied by doing overtime, outsourcing, adding shifts, etc.
The following section describes the differences in different areas to describe personal
policies followed by organizations.
2.4.The Two Extreme Policies in Different AreasAs discussed in section 2.3 these extreme policies effects an organizations function.
When labor markets are flexible, structural transformation can occur more rapidly, since both
capital and labor can shift to a newer, higher value added sectors, but world employment
report 2004-05(6) by International Labor Office (UN) finds that the stability of the employment
is positively related to the productivity. Some comments are made on the following subsections
taking account of the two policies followed by companies. All these areas are interrelated and
cant stand alone.
2.4.1. MarketsThe debate on labor market flexibility or rigidity has focused primarily on what types of
labor market institutions, both regulations and policies provide the best environment for
stimulating job growth (8).
Also the fluctuations in the market demand make differences in the companies personal
policies to match the demand of its product. The present slowdown in the global economy can
be illustrated for explaining the market condition and workforce. It is visible that when the
market goes down, the companys reduces their workforce, so that the loss due the inventory of
1Employment tenure is defined as the amount of time that a worker has spent working
for the same employer(8)
.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
23/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 15
the manpower can be avoided. When the market booms again, the organizations recruit
employees to meet the demand.
The Figure 2:1 shows the demand for labor in chase production. When the market
demand is more the company hire employees, and when the demand goes down the lay off the
workforce. TheFigure 2:2 shows the labor demand in level production. A stable workforce is
employed in this case. Lay off doesnt occurs.
Figure 2:1 Demand for labor in chase production (9)
Figure 2:2 Demand for labor in Level production (9)
2.4.2. ManagementThe recruitment of employee is too difficult due to high initial cost, finding
persons who can go in line with organizations culture, and the lack of availability of skilled
labours (4).
In a stable workforce, the management uses the creativity of the employees as and when
required. The employees are involved in each stage of the product. The relation with employee
and the manager is healthier. The morale of the employee will be good. Characteristics, way of
thinking, emotions, attitude and many other factors plays an important role in the success of an
organization. In a stable workforce the management can easily motivate and manage people.
As discussed in section 2.3 part time workers, temporary workers, seasonal workers,
independent contractors, co-op students, etc are comes under the varying workforce. So the
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
24/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 16
relationship between management and the employees will not be matured. The distance
between the employee and management can be observed here.
2.4.3. ProductsThe lifecycle of the product is reducing as the market competition is increasing due
globalization. Introduction of new product at the right time is essential to survive in the
business. Thus the swiftness of new product development and modification in the present
products must be done with the help of the latest technologies. Many organizations make use of
specialized people and consultancies, as those people might be updated for new technological
developments. Employees are hired to balance the production due to the sudden demand in the
existing product, seasonal products etc.
Many of the research and development works done by the organization can have many
commercial importances. A stable workforce can be trusted to give all the works as the morale
of the employee will be more. They will be more familiar with the organization behavior. Such
special situations the organization may require more workforce for a specific task. The
reallocation of employees can be done in such situations.
2.4.4. Financial positionThe financial position of the organizations can be directly related to the productivity.
When the firms do the effective and efficient production, the financial position can be in a
secure position.
Research conducted byPeter Auer(8)
finds a positive and beneficial effect of tenure on
productivity with intermediate levels of tenure exhibiting the greatest returns to productivity,
decreasing but positive returns for extended tenure, and a negative productivity effect from
workers with short tenure. The firms investment in the workers must be useful for the
organizations.
A strong financial position helps organizations to keep a stable work force. They keep
man power as inventory even if there is no or very less work. Otherwise the organization
terminates the employees if there is no work. The present economic slowdown made somany
employees to lose their jobs. Many of them where in bench2 which is a common phenomenon
in the IT industries. But the hard time hit their jobs resulted in losing the jobs.
2Bench: A term used to describe unutilized hands.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
25/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 17
2.4.5. SkillsThe varying work force may be unskilled or skilled. The organization can hire skilled
labors for a particular task for a specific period of time. The advantages of such labors are that
the organization need not give any allowances that are applicable for stable work force. Suchpart time, temporary labors give only short-term advantages as they cant be employed for a
longer period.
The stable work force gives more productivity. The employers can invest in training
them as the firm will be able to pick the rewards for their investment. It will increase the
commitment of the worker. The firm specific training can be given only to a stable workforce.
So the output of such trained personals can have more impact on organizational goals.
2.4.6. CostsProduction planning involves many costs. It can be classified in two categories (10).
1. Quantifiable: Inventory, overtime, subcontracting, and shift premium, recruitment,redundancy, training, and purchasing.
2. Non-quantifiable: Stock outs, loss of orders, low workers morale, inexperiencepersonnel, handling complaints, and loss efficiency.
Many of these quantifiable and non-quantifiable costs are directly related to the stable
or varying workforces. A stable workforce can get more benefits in the non-quantifiable costs.
The temporary or hired workers have so much cost advantages for the organizations.
The stable workforce requires more expenditure while recruiting, they must be paid even if
there is less business, and the cost of dismissal is more.
Today the laws are made very complicated so that the employer cant fire the
employees. The law insist the same consideration to the temporary employees like the
permanent employees. The news points out the Wall Mart reduced their employees and the
justification from the Wall Mart is new labor law which will raise wages and make it more
difficult to lay off employees(11). The laws experience the firms in the increase in their
expenditure.
Still hiring the employee when required will add the cost advantage to the companies.
When the demand goes up, or the research and development going on, or when new product is
under developments, company hires employees from outside. But in a stable work force the
labor cost forecasts can be made easily.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
26/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 18
2.4.7. CompetitionBecoming more competent is the ultimate challenge of the modern organizations. If the
firm cant give better performance they are mercilessly kicked out of the business. People have
a significant role in developing a core competency. The better the group of people are at thefulfilling the demand of the customer, the more competency of the firm
(12). The people in the
firm must be updated with new technology development and techniques of working. A stable
workforce can always be trained to achieve these goals, while comparing to a varying work
force.
Example of a football team can be considered to illustrate this. A good team work can
enhance the success of the team. Also the players must be talented. Some time the team hires
people from other club to play for them. They get special player(s) as it can add more
possibility of winning. Suppose if the new hired player cant be coordinated with the other
players in the team, then the presence of the special player is of no use, rather becomes a
burden. Many times the stable workforce, who is aware or the organization behavior will help
the organizations to develop a competitive advantage in their product in terms of quality,
performance, and timeliness.
2.5.Recommended method of Sales & Operation Plan for each PolicySales and Operations Planning (S&OP) is a set of business processes that helps
companies keep demand and supply in balance (13). S&OP integrates business management
process which synchronizes all the functions of the organization. This process brings sales,
marketing, development, manufacturing, sources, and financial plans together. The plan links
the strategic plans with execution and reviews the performance measures. An effective supply
chain can be enabled by these plans (14) (15).
The S&OP must meet business objectives of profitability, productivity, competitive
customer lead times, etc. The sales and operation plan set ups the production rate. It controls
the inventory levels. It usually takes effort to keep a moderately stable workforce. The
employee levels are thus controlled as per the chase or level productions depending on the
managements objectives.
The method of sales and operation plan can be begin from deciding the basic strategy,
i.e, chase, level or hybrid. The production rate can be determined next. In chase plan the
management can find the amount of over time, subcontracting requirements. In the next stepthe capacity and cost etc can be determined. The cost for regular time, over time,
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
27/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 19
subcontracting, layoff etc can be determined. In the last step the cost of alternative plans can be
considered. Calculating the workforce requirement (size), shortages, expected hiring & firings,
and overtime must be calculated. The total cost of the plans can be compared to select the best
plan. The plans impact on the customer service and human resource issues must be considered
(16).From the internal (strategic objective, financial constrains, capacities, policy) and external
(competitor, demand, raw material availability) inputs must be considered to select the
alternatives.
2.5.1.A ComparisonComparison of Chase and Level production in terms of personnel in both categories are
listed in theTable 2:1
Table 2:1 Comparison of Chase and Level Production (16)+Author
No Comparison Chase Level
1 Level of labor skill required Low High
2 Worker levels and production output Fluctuating Stable
3 Job discretion Low High
4 Compensation rate Low High
5 Working conditions Low Morale High Morale
6 Training required per employee Low High
7 Labor turnover High Low
8 Labor Utilization High Low9 Hire-fire cost High Low
10 Labor Cost Low High
11 Inventory cost Low High
12 Error rate High Low
13 Amount of supervision required High Low
14 Type of budgeting and forecasting required Short-run Long-run
2.6.ConclusionA stable workforce many time benefits the organization. But varying workforce is also
far significant to meet the contingencies. The production type of the organization affects on the
companies personal policies. Realizing the customer requirement, and to meet those
requirement firms must have a skilled workforce. The level of maturity of the organization will
help them to select suitable workforce. Both the personal policies have its own advantages and
disadvantages. Selecting the best suited is critical. The chapter discussed the two different
policies with respect to different measures. The analysis shows that the types of workforce will
affect the organizations performance. So it is very much important to form strategies for the
workforce types.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
28/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 20
CChhaapptteerr 33 ((QQuueessttiioonn:: 22))
3. Inventory and Competitive Priorities3.1.Introduction
Just surviving in the market is not the goal of any organization. The organization must
be able to win the customer order. The competitiveness of a firm depends on the practices they
follow in their process. To become the market leaders the company should be competitive in
the cost, quality, time, and flexibility. These competitive capabilities are affected by many
internal and external factors. The managements vision and decisions to focus on these areas
will contribute to the success in the market.
Inventory is the stock, an important part in any organization. The inventory is closely
related to the competitive priorities of the firm. The following section analyses the relation
between inventory and competitive priorities.
3.2.InventoryInventory can be seen in every operation. In Manufacturing, inventory is the stored
accumulation of material recourses in a transformation system (17). Inventories are kept to meet
the internal or external customer demand. Inventory is manly four types they are buffer
inventory (safety inventory), cycle inventory, anticipation inventory, and pipeline inventory. In
a manufacturing process, inventory is can be classified in to three types.
1) Raw Material Inventory: Materials purchased and stored for production. These arematerial where the manufacturer not added any value. This helps to avoid the production
delaying.
2) Work-in-Process Inventory: Semi-manufactured products. These may be materials duringprocesses, in between workstations or reworked. The WIP inventory helps the production incase of machine breakdown or some work stoppages in one station.
3) Finished Goods Inventory: Completely manufactured products. These are ready forshipment. FGI helps for fast delivery of the product.
3.3.Nine Competitive PrioritiesThe dimensions that a firms production system must possess to support the demands of
the markets that the firm wishes to compete in (18). The nine competitive priorities are listed in
Table 3:1.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
29/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 21
Table 3:1 Nine Competitive Priorities
Competitive
Capabilities Competitive Priorities
Cost 1 Low cost operations
Quality 2 Top quality3 Consistent quality
Time 4 Delivery speed
5 On-time delivery
6 Development Speed
Flexibility 7 Customization
8 Variety
9 Volume Flexibility
The following passages explain each one on them.
3.4.Inventory and Competitive PriorityThe relation is briefed and most commonly applicable inventory and competitive
priority relation is tabled in Table 3:2.
3.4.1.CostThe importance of cost is very much affects the demand of a product. The low cost
increases the demand of the product. To achieve the minimum cost all the operations and
functions related to the product must be matured enough to optimize the cost. Small lot sizeswill decrease the inventory and will improve the process. The Table 3:2 shows the inventory
and competitive priority with respect to types of inventory. Inventory is costly to store, order,
insure, protect so to reduce the cost inventory should be maintained in low levels. But some
cases, eg. The discount level when ordering raw material in bulk can be misunderstands to be a
low cost.
3.4.2.QualityQuality can be divided in to two competitive priorities- top quality and Consistent
quality. Top quality refers to the superior product quality while consistent quality is the
products that meet design specifications.
Quality has many dimensions low-defect rate, product performance, reliability,
certification, and environmental concern. Quality is defined by customers. The quality can be
product quality or process quality. Product quality can be varied with varying customer levels
(like: many times china product refers to a low quality product and the intended customer
requires only that quality). But process quality must be equal for all the product ranges and the
organization must develop competitive quality standards to survive in the market.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
30/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 22
A higher inventory can badly affect the quality. Small batches points to low inventory.
As the batch sizes increases the inventory before and after the machine increases. Large batch
affects the quality. In large batch it is difficult to find out the errors. If the error finds out also it
might be affected the whole batch. As the batch size increases the time for inspection alsoincrease (in many cases).
3.4.3.TimeTime can be divided in to three competitive priorities. The Table 3:2 shows the
inventory and time relation.
3.4.3.1. Delivery speedIt can be referred as lead-time. The time between order receipt and delivery. Many times
higher inventory of raw material refers to faster delivery. For example of Maruti Suzuki Ltd
offers many range of products. Taking example of Swift and Omni; they maintain FGI so the
delivery is fast. But the delivery of swift is more.
3.4.3.2. On Time DeliveryMeeting the delivery promise is utmost important competitiveness in a business. The
organization can meet delivery target by maintaining low inventories too. As the organization
can plan its production to match the delivery requirements. The availability of the raw material
is important.
3.4.3.3. Development SpeedNew product development speed is the time gap from concept to first product in the
production. The higher inventory may not be required as the product would be in introduction
stage. But the customer service must be superior, so that the company may force to keep some
inventories.
3.4.4.FlexibilityCustomers are king in todays market. Knowing changing customer needs and adapting
to it has become a primary requirement for organization. The flexibility in adopting these
changes is important in industries. The flexibility can be three types as explained in next sub
headings. The relation between flexibility and inventory is illustrated in Table 3:2 also.
3.4.4.1. CustomizationCustomization is agility. Satisfying needs of individual customers as in construction.
Due to the low volume, the customization is very risky if not controlled and managed properly.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
31/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 23
The customization requires low inventory. The supply chain must be very strong and co-
operative to achieve the customization.
3.4.4.2. VarietyEfficiently handling many varieties of products is imperative. Many firms do so. Many
fail. In case of General Motors, they owned many brand names and many varieties of products
in each brand name. But this negatively affected their operations and now they stopped some of
their brands.
To keep variety in the product, the organization must keep a very low inventory. But the
common parts and raw materials can be kept as inventory for contingent situation.
3.4.4.3. Volume FlexibilityThe volume flexibility refers to the sudden change in the production capacity of a
product. The ability to react with sudden change in the demand. To meet this the raw material
inventory might be kept high, as the sudden increase in demand cant trigger the raw material
supplier with same pace.
3.5.ComparisonThe comparison is based on the data which suits most manufacturing industries.
Table 3:2 Inventory and Competitive Priorities
Competitive Priorities Raw Material
Inventory
WIP FGI
1 Low cost operations Low Low Low
2 Top quality Low Low Low
3 Consistent quality Low Low Low
4 Delivery speed High Low High
5 On-time delivery High Low High
6 Development Speed Low Low Low
7 Customization Low Low Low
8 Variety High Low Low
9 Volume Flexibility High Low Low
3.6.Zero InventoryInventory is a liability as manufacturing is concerned; even though the traditional
financials consider inventory as asset. The goal of every manufacturing firm is to maintain zero
inventories. Kaizen is practiced in all the organizations for the improvement in every area.
Today world class manufacturing organizations adopt Just-In-Time production system to
eliminate inventory. They use Kanban to control the inventories. But Kanban points to
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
32/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 24
inventory. The best Kanban is NO KANBAN. So the ultimate aim of modern manufacturing
system is to eliminate excess inventories.
Zero inventory is a CONCEPT. Organizations strive to achieve it. Keeping optimum
inventory is required to meet the contingencies. Inventory does not earn interest. Less inventorymaximizes the profitability.
Inventory is costly to
-Store,
-Order,
-Insure,
-Protect
So zero inventory makes the best production system. But an organization cant
completely eliminate the inventory. Inventory should be held to hold enough to run, but not too
much.
There should be proper inventory management system to maintain and to keep the best
size inventories. The inventory management system must control the investments in the
inventory; it should ensure continuous supply of material. Also it should determine ordering
quantity by finding the Economic Order Quantity.
The supply chain must be so much matured and controlled to reduce the problems due
to high inventories. The demand forecasting, planning of the production, production system,
supply chain (suppliers, transportation, distribution, etc), etc makes effects on inventory.
3.6.1.Inventory is liability, then why to keep inventory?All organizations, through modern manufacturing practices, tries to eliminate the
inventory. But optimum inventory is important
- To facilitate smooth production and sales operations- To meet unpredictable changes in demand and supply.- To take advantage of price fluctuations.Too much or too high inventory will lead to more cost or reduction of customers.
3.7.ConclusionGlobalization changed the way the world think and act. It made huge influences in all
the areas. Identifying the competitive priorities required for a particular firm is important for
them to become order winners. For organizations to chug away all the way through todaysmarket, it is mandatory to be further competitive, and should have captivating methods to be
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
33/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 25
unbeaten. All resources must be used effectively and efficiently to get the best outputs.
Inventory is a major factor in competitive priorities. Inventory management must be done to
find out, decide, and to maintain the proper level of inventories. The effective supply chain will
help organization to keep minimum inventory levels.
When there is a difference between rate of supply and demand, inventory exist. The
fluctuation in the demand causes the inventory. In pull production, the inventory is tends to
zero, but the same time the delivery may not be good. Keeping inventory will help for some
industries, while the other will worst affect by higher inventories. Finding the optimum
inventory level and keeping it to best fit to the competitive priorities are important for an
organization to achieve its strategic goals.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
34/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 26
CChhaapptteerr 44 ((QQuueessttiioonn:: 33))
4. Discussions on Some Topics4.1.Introduction
The production planning and control related to every area of operation management,
strategies, supply chain, human resource, and more. The following heading briefly explains
some concepts related to production planning and control.
4.2. MPS and shop-floor capacity planning (Q3: A)The manufacturing planning and control (MPC) repeat business objectives in operations
management terms. The MPC system helps managers to make proper decisions, and to manage
the operations. The Master Production Scheduling (MPS) and Capacity Planning (Both are
explained in next passages) interrelated as shown in the Figure 4:1The MPS included in the
front end system while the material and capacity planning act as the engine of the MPC.
Master Production Scheduling is the most important planning and control schedule. It
forms the main input to the MRP(17)
. The MPS is has developed for production, inventory,
staffing, etc. The manufacturing function gets all the information related to production through
MPS.
The Capacity planning is to ensure the match between capacities available in specific
work centers, Capacity needed to achieve the planned production(2)
. The shop floor capacity
planning controls production process with all the resources involved. MPS is a primary data
source for capacity planning. The Figure 4:1 shows the relation between MPS and Capacity
planning in MPC.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
35/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 27
Figure 4:1 MPS and Capacity Planning in MPC
4.2.1. Agility of shop floorThe requirement of customized products, with minimum cost and higher quality has
becoming the order winning criteria in the market. The concept of agility improves the
competitiveness of the firms. Agility is the ability to thrive in a competitive environment of
continuous and unanticipated change and to respond quickly to rapidly changing markets driven
by customer-based valuing of products and services (DeVor and Mills 1995) (19).
The shop floor will have to respond and accommodate the adjustments in the supply
chain making it an important piece in the competitiveness. So the agility in the shop floor
capacity is important to achieve the organization goals and to survive in the market. To reach
the customized product to the end user, all the functions in the organizations must be
coordinated. The MPS must be able to plan as per the customized requirements.
ProductionPlannin
ResourcePlannin
DemandMana ement
MasterProductionSchedulin
DetailedMaterialPlannin
DetailedCapacityPlannin
Material andCapacity
Plans
VendorS stem
Shop-floorS stems
Front End
Engine
Back End
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
36/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 28
4.3. Process Synchronization (Q3: B)Synchronization means the rapidity of output at each stage in the production process to
ensure the same flow characteristics for each part or product as it progress through each stage
(18). In a pull production system synchronization is attained by balancing of cycle times of
upstream operations with the cycle time of the final assembly.
The upstream operation must work to satisfy the downstream demand. When the
completion time is different for operations, to synchronize the line, all the operation task time
must be adjusted as close as possible to the required cycle time. To achieve this, task grouping
at every operation, work cell, and machining department must be adjusted(7)
. This can be done
by following ways.
a) Adding tasks at operationsb) Sub contracting the tasksc) Moving workforce between stationsd) Time adjustment to perform task.The Takt time of the process must be found. The bottle necks need to be finding out and
must be eliminated. Each stations operation must be equal to the Takt time. The Kanban
system (pull production) is established to trigger the upstream operations. For smooth Kanban
flow, all the operations must be balanced.
In a mixed model production the synchronization is done by identifying the requirement
of each product. Then cycle time of each product is found (available time/requirement). The
Takt time of the line (includes all the product variety) is determined
Takt time = Available Time/Total number of product requirement (Product
1+P2++Pn)
The Takt time is the drumbeat of the process. In every takt, one product will come out
of the line. The sequence of the products in the line is to be determined.
4.4. Buffers and bottlenecks (Q3: C)Bottleneck refers to a low-capacity part of a system that reduces the capacity of the
whole system. Scheduling is the last stage of planning before production. The scheduling is
done to meet the customer due date, minimize the delay, maximize the labor and machine
utilization, minimize WIP. The bottleneck scheduling is a scheduling process based upon the
bottleneck constraint(7)
. The bottle neck scheduling is carried out by DBR (Drum-Buffer-Rope)
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
37/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 29
where the scheduling is planned based on the bottleneck in a process. The Figure 4:2 shows the
DBR representation.
Drum: Bottleneck, beating to set the pace of production for the rest of the system.
Buffer: Inventory placed in front of the bottleneck to ensure it is always kept busy. It
determines output or throughput of the system.
Rope: Communication signal; tells processes upstream when they should begin production.
Figure 4:2 Drum-buffer-rope system (7).
The TOC scheduling procedure includes the following steps.
- Identify bottleneck- Schedule job first whose lead time to bottleneck is less than or equal to bottleneck
processing time.
- Forward schedule bottleneck machine.- Backward schedule other machines to sustain bottleneck schedule.- Transfer in batch sizes smaller than process batch size.Buffers in bottle neck scheduling
Buffers are the excess inventories held between stages of a process to avoid running
short(7)
. The buffers are kept in bottleneck schedule to feed the drum. In a bottleneck
scheduling, constrain resource must not be kept idle. So the buffer supplies to its downstream
operation without interruption. The buffer protects the constraint from all the fluctuations in
demand. Buffer is maintained after the constraint resource to store the WIP after the Drum. The
constraint resource is over worked and keeps an inventory level ahead of bottleneck.
4.5. Advantages of Level Production (Q3: D)Level production maintains a constant level workforce to keep the output approximately
the same every month and, using inventory to absorb monthly fluctuations in demand (7). While
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
38/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 30
chase (non-level production) production varies the production output as needed to match the
demand. This changes the workforce size and uses overtime, outsourcing, extra shifts, etc.
Benefits of Level Production over Non-level production
o Capacity enhancements are not costly due to the constant volume output.o The labor cost will be low because
o No need of hiring of employees.o Less training requirement.o Stable and motivated workforce.
o As the production volume is constant there is less planning required for resource allocation.o The delivery speed will be good as they maintain FGI.o Uniform and constant volume increases the machine utilization.o Scope for process improvement.o Consistent performance of the production system.
4.6. ERP Implementation Case Study (Q3: E)Enterprise Resource Planning is a tool which coordinates and manages resources,
information, and functions of a business. Most of the ERP softwares are adopted best practices
in the industry. ERP helps organization to develop its business and monitors all the functions inan organization. Performance metrics are measures of an organization's activities and
performance. The performance measures can be financial (traditional) or non-financial. Rainer
Feurer and Kazem Chaharbaghi(20) points their views for the need of performance evaluation
as follows
Enable organizations to learn about the internal and external environments of anorganizations
Helps to identify future trends and their implications for the organization. Helps to align operations and supporting objectives for instituting a common purpose.
ERP implementation helps organizations to improve their performances. The case study
briefs the improvements in the performance matrix after the implementation of ERP.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
39/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 31
4.6.1.ERP Implementation at Waltham Forest Borough CouncilReference:http://www.sap.com/uk/about/success/casestudies/walthamforest06.pdf(21)
Waltham Forest Borough3
Council is a public sector company in UK, which provides
services to people and employs 4,300 staffs. It provides local government services, including
education, social services, highways, libraries, environmental services and leisure. The
implementation of ERP in their operations improved their performance- both in financial and
non-financial measures. Those are listed below.
The procurement has been streamlined. The numbers of suppliers were more, as the procurement system was not effective.
Introduction if ERP system benefited to the Council by reducing the number of suppliers.
The improved relation between suppliers improved the performance of the procurementsystem.
The integration of procurement and accounts payable functions has enabled improvedinvoice matching.
The improvements in the cash flow are another indicator of performance of the firm afterthe ERP implementation.
The council could reduce its borrowing by 20 million over 24 months. They reduced the interest payments by improving the cash flow. Authority has seen a dramatic improvement in its Comprehensive Performance Rating
(CPA4).
ERP implementation process helped the Council to standardize their processes. The performance of the employees is improved as everyone follows standards. The co-ordination among all the groups of the organization helped them to improve the
productivity and lead times.
Reduced the inventory cost in supply chain due to improved co-ordination.4.6.2. ConclusionThe ERP implementation improved the productivity, reduced cost of goods and services
and improved transactions. ERP system planning smoothed the whole systems operation, and
improved the enterprise perpetual operating capacity significantly. In the present highly
3A borough is an administrative division of various countries. In principle, the term borough
designates a self-governing township although, in practice, official use of the term varies
widely (22).4 The Comprehensive Performance Assessment (CPA) is the framework which the Audit
Commission uses to measure the performance of all councils(23)
.
http://www.sap.com/uk/about/success/casestudies/walthamforest06.pdfhttp://www.sap.com/uk/about/success/casestudies/walthamforest06.pdfhttp://www.sap.com/uk/about/success/casestudies/walthamforest06.pdfhttp://www.sap.com/uk/about/success/casestudies/walthamforest06.pdf8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
40/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 32
competitive market, enterprise resource integration is very critical. The wrong implementation
of ERP can result in wrong results. So the ERP must be implemented with complete preparation
before the huge investment of money, human, and time. ERP system implementation involves
too many resources and parties and thus it is very time consuming and capital intensive.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
41/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 33
PART C
CChhaapptteerr 55
5. Presentation on Forecasting
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
42/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 34
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
43/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 35
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
44/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 36
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
45/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 37
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
46/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 38
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
47/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 39
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
48/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 40
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
49/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 41
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
50/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 42
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
51/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 43
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
52/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 44
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
53/58
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
54/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 46
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
55/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 47
RREEFFEERREENNCCEESS
1. Production Planning and Scheduling Software-Preactor International. www.preactor.com.
[Online] [Cited: April 6, 2009.] http://www.preactor.com/Home.aspx.
2. Vollman, Berry, Whybark. "Manufacturing Planning and Control Systems". 4th Edition.
s.l. : Irwin McGraw-Hill, 1997. ISBN 0256-13899-0.
3. Unknown. Business Definition for: Personnel Policy. BNET Business Dictionary. [Online]
[Cited: April 3, 2009.] http://dictionary.bnet.com/definition/personnel+policy.html.
4. William G Nickels, James M Mchugh, Susan M Mchugh."Understanding Business". 7th
Edition. New York : McGraw Hill.
5. Mackenzie, Christine. "Working practices in the 1990s- the bottom line". s.l. : MCB
University Press, December 1996, Vols. Volume 14, Number 12/13.www.emeraldinsight.com/10.1108/02632779610152199. ISSN 0263-2772.
6. Office, International Labour."World employment report 2004-05". Geneva : International
Labour Organization, 2005. ISBN 9221148130.
7. Nicholas, John M. "Competitive Manufacturing Management". New York : Tata McGraw-
Hill, 1998. ISBN 007-047415-X
8. Peter Auer, Janine Berg and Ibrahim Coulibaly. "Is a stable workforce good for theeconomy?". s.l. : Employment Analysis and Research Unit Employment Strategy Department,
August 2004, Insights into the Tenure-Productivity Employment Relationship. [Online]http://www.ilo.org/public/english/employment/strat/download/esp15.pdf. ISBN 92-2-116471-3
(web pdf).
9. The Institute for Working Futures Pty Ltd, Planning Strategically. www.marcbowles.co.[Online] 2005. [Cited: April 8, 2009.]
http://www.marcbowles.com/sample_courses/frontline_v5/fmf27/fmf27b.htm.
10. Onwubolu, Godfrey C."Emerging optimization techniques in production planning and
control". s.l. : Imperial College Press, 2002. Link: http://books.google.co.in/books?id=bYfW5-
SgBBoC. ISBN 1860942660.
11. Who Needs a Stable Workforce? Wall Mart Watch. [Online] Nov 5, 2007. [Cited: April 3,
2009.] http://walmartwatch.com/blog/archives/who_needs_a_stable_workforce/.
12. Drejer, Anders. "Illustrating competence development". www.emeraldinsight.com.
[Online] 2001. [Cited: April 4, 2009.] http://www.emeraldinsight.com/Insight.13. Thomas F Wallance, Robort A Stahl.Sales & Operations Planning. 3rd Edition. s.l. :
T.F. Wallace and Company. Link:http://www.tfwallace.com/pages_blocks_v3/images/links/3rdEd1stChp.pdf.
14. Sales and Operations Plan. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. [Online] [Cited: April 3,
2009.] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sales_and_Operations_Plan.
15. Unknown. SALES AND OPERATIONS PLANNING (S&OP).JasperSolutions LLC.[Online] [Cited: April 3, 2009.] http://www.jaspersolutions.net/definitions.htm.
16. Planning. [Online] Augusta State University. [Cited: April 3, 2009.]
http://www.aug.edu/~sbajmg/quan3600/Planning/aggreg%20plng%20rev5.pdf.17. Slack, Nigel. "Operations Management". 2nd Edition. London : Financial Times
Management, 1998. ISBN 0273626884.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
56/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 48
18. Lee J. Krajewski, Larry P. Ritzman. "Operations management: strategy and analysis".
s.l. : Addison-Wesley Pub. Co., 1993. ISBN 0201566303.
19. A Gunasekaran, Y Y Yusuf. Agile manufacturing: a taxonomy of strategic and
technological imperatives. [Online] 2002. [Cited: March 26, 2009.]
http://www.umassd.edu/charlton/birc/am_taxonomy.pdf.20. Chaharbaghi, Rainer Feurer and Kazem. Performance measurement in strategic change.s.l. : MCB University Press,, 1995, Vol. 2. No.2.
http://www.emeraldinsight.com/Insight/viewPDF.jsp?contentType=Article&Filename=html/Ou
tput/Published/EmeraldFullTextArticle/Pdf/1310020205.pdf.
21. ERP Imlimentation at Waltham Forest Borough Council. [Online] 2005. [Cited: April 4,2009.] http://www.sap.com/uk/about/success/casestudies/walthamforest06.pdf.
22. Borough. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. [Online] Wikimedia Foundation, Inc. [Cited:
April 4, 2009.] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Borough.
23. Unknown, Comprehensive Performance Assessment (CPA). [Online]www.birmingham.gov.uk. [Cited: April 4, 2009.]
http://www.birmingham.gov.uk/GenerateContent?CONTENT_ITEM_ID=46768&CONTENT_
ITEM_TYPE=0&MENU_ID=531.
24. Thomas W. Zimmerer, and Roman M. Scarborough.Essential of Entrepreneurshipand Small Business management. 4th Edition. New Delhi : Prentice-Hall Inc., 2005.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
57/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
Production Planning and Scheduling 49
BBIIBBLLIIOOGGRRAAPPHHYY
1) Module Notes of Prof. B.S. Ajith Kumar
2) Vollman, Berry, Whybark.Manufacturing Planning and Control Systems. 4th Edition.s.l. : Irwin McGraw-Hill, 1997. ISBN o256-13899-0.
3) Nicholas, John M. "Competitive Manufacturing Management". New York : Tata McGraw-
Hill, 1998. ISBN 007-047415-X
4) Slack, Nigel. "Operations Management". 2nd Edition. London : Financial Times
Management, 1998. ISBN 0273626884.
5) Lee J. Krajewski, Larry P. Ritzman.Operations management: strategy and analysis.
s.l. : Addison-Wesley Pub. Co., 1993. ISBN 0201566303.
8/9/2019 SUDHEESH Production Planning & Scheduling
58/58
M.S Ramaiah School of Advanced Studies Postgraduate Engineering Programmes (PEPs)
AAnnnneexxuurree AA
Glossary of Terms Used
Core competencies are a unique set of lasting capabilities that a company develops in keyoperational areas that allow it to vault past competitors (24)
CompetitiveAdvantage is the aggregation of factors that gets a small business apart from its
competitors and gives it a unique position with market superior to its competition (24).
Productivity: Productivity in economics refers to metrics and measures of output from
production processes, per unit of input.