Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Susan Garvin, CEP, Stock & Option Solutions, Inc.
Linda Hart, Box, Inc.
Joanne Wendler, CEP, Demand Media, Inc.
Alison Wright, Baker & McKenzie LLP
July 25, 2012
Success or Big Mess?: Mistakes and Must-dos on the
Road to IPO
Once upon a time, there was a little company
that wanted to grow really big and strong like it’s
brothers and sisters. To do this, the little
company worked long and hard and decided to
move into the public markets by having an IPO.
Because the little company was stubborn and
proud, it didn’t talk to it’s older and wiser
relatives, but instead, tried to go it alone. It made
many mistakes on the way to the IPO, here are
some of the lessons learned.
3
Devil is in the details
Expect underwriter’s counsel to thoroughly
review all books and records of the company
• Equity compensation plans
• Grant agreements
• Board resolutions granting equity awards
Moral of the Story
• Be prepared for last minute amendments to plan documents that do not comply with legal requirements (Code Section 409A)
• Get good advice upfront to avoid last minute "gotchas"
4
Be careful what you say (someone might be
listening)
Communications before, during and after the IPO process are critical and must be thoroughly vetted for correctness/accuracy/clarity
• Employees
• Investors
Moral of the Story
• Make sure all communications, to everyone, are complete and accurate
• Update communications as needed
• Be as honest as possible
5
A rose by any other name……or not
Not all kinds of equity compensation vehicles (or
underlying equity) are the same
• ADRs
• Options vs. Awards
• Types of transactions allowed
Moral of the Story
• Advance preparation and understanding is critical
• Make sure you have the right players at the table
6
A horse is a horse, of course of course
Unilateral adjustments to equity plan data are not allowed, even pre-IPO. Your data and your backup will be scrutinized.
• ISO/NQ
• International “ISO”
Moral of the Story
• Don’t “correct” data in database without documentation
• If data is changed, make sure approvals/communications are undertaken as well
7
My, what a big nose you have
Securities laws limit the amount of equity compensation a private company
can issue
• Rule 701
• Section 12g, as amended
Moral of the Story
• Understand all the rules/regulations, even if you don’t think they apply to you
• Keep running calculations regarding securities law exemptions (Rule 701, Section 12G)
8
Under Pressure
Creativity which can be utilized prior to IPO may not fit once you are a reporting company – Beware!
• Compensation design and consultants can increase/decrease the ability to administer your plans
• As a publicly traded, reporting company, “unique” does not always allow for good ROI once administrative and communication costs are examined.
Moral of the Story
• “Unique” and “special” can cause compliance and administrative issues
• Think long-term
• Pressure to accept new vehicles/different methods can quell dissent and cause problems
9
Delayed gratification
Employees may be hired, investors found, with a certain time goal for an expected IPO. However, market or company changes can delay that date.
• Managing changed expectations
• Communications
• Employee morale
Moral of the Story
• Have a backup plan
• Don’t promise anything you cannot deliver
10
It’s too quiet in there
All the players in the company and any advisors need
to be kept informed about the status of the project.
• Legal filings
• Communications
• Administration
Moral of the Story
• You can take “quiet” too far
• Missing information can cause problems too
11
You can run but you cannot hide
As part of the IPO process expect to find compliance issues of which you may have been unaware
or thought were immaterial
• Income and employment tax withholding and reporting
• Global compliance issues
Moral of the Story
• Immaterial takes on a whole new meaning when preparing for an IPO
• Make the necessary corrections (or take the risk) and move on
12
Through the Looking Glass
There are many rules and regulations which are not obvious. Make sure you are consulting with authorities in equity compensation when designing and administering your plans. Otherwise, your view may end up distorted and missing some elements.
• Definition of “employee”
• Exempt vs. non-exempt status
• International interpretations• LOA
• Discrimination• Age
• Part-timers
Moral of the Story
• Expertise is critical
• Not everyone “doing” administration is an expert
• It takes a team to make equity compensation work (correctly)
13
The serfs are at the gate
Employees will want to have access to sell their stock as soon as possible. This must be weighed against market concerns, underwriters’ concerns, and administrative concerns.
• Perception of employees selling stock immediately into market
• Employees desire not to lose “profit”, especially if they’ve been burned before
• Administration of plans can take time to set in place
Moral of the Story
• Pressure to allow employees to “cash out” should not be the only consideration
• Administration of plans should be balanced with other issues
• Lock up is negotiable
14
Cheap doesn’t mean free
If your company valuations (and associated grant/exercise pricing) are not audit proof, problems can arise
• Cheap Stock
• Accounting
• Taxation
• Administration
Moral of the Story
• Proper valuations are critical
• Ramp up to IPO
• Tax implications
15
Contact Information
Susan Garvin, CEP
Equity Consultant
Stock & Option Solutions, Inc
910 Campisi Way, Ste 2E
Campbell, CA 95008 USA
Bus: (408) 979-8700
www.sos-team.com
16
Joanne Wendler, CEP
Manager, Stock Administration
Demand Media, Inc.
1299 Ocean Ave , Ste 500
Santa Monica, CA 90401 USA
Bus: (310) 656-6331
Alison Wright
Partner
Baker & McKenzie LLP
Two Embarcadero Center
11th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94111 USA
Bus: (415) 576-3046
Linda Hart
Director, Payroll & Stock Administration
Box, Inc
4440 El Camino Real
Los Altos, CA 94022 USA
17
Appendices
18
Regulatory Information
Securities Law
Securities Act of 1933: regulates the process by which
companies sell stock to the investors
Securities Exchange Act of 1934: regulates the
securities markets and the entities that participant
in those markets
Blue Sky Laws – State securities Laws covering both
Public Company
Definition: A company whose stock is publicly traded
on a recognized stock exchange; subject to
regulation, disclosure and related rules enforced
by the SEC. *
Non-listed companies subject to public company
disclosure rules if Section 12 g of the Exchange Act
is triggered.
*Glossary definition from “Selected Issues in Equity Compensation”
published by the NCEO
Securities Act of 1933
Stock sold by a company to investors must be registered with the SEC
– Form S-1 is used to register shares sold in an IPO– Form S-8 is used to register shares sold pursuant to a
stock plan– Prohibits fraud, misstatements and material omissions
in the– registration statement
Includes a number of registration exemptions– Rule 701 exempts shares sold by a privately held
company through a compensatory arrangement– Shares issued pursuant to an exemption are
considered “restricted securities” and must be resold under an exemption
– Rule 144
Section 12g Basics
The holders of record threshold for triggering Section 12(g) registration for issuers (other than banks and bank holding companies) has been raised from 500 or more persons to either (1) 2,000 or more persons or (2) 500 or more persons who are not accredited investors
In calculating the number of holders of record for purposes of determining whether Section 12(g) registration is required with respect to a class of equity security, issuers (including banks and bank holding companies) may exclude persons who received the securities pursuant to an employee compensation plan in transactions exempted from the registration requirements of Section 5 of the Securities Act
22
Rule 701
• Exempts shares sold by a privately held company through a compensatory arrangement
• Shares are “restricted securities” since not registered
• Shares are freely saleable 90 days after IPO
Rule 701 Basics
Written compensatory benefit plan (or written compensation contract) established by the issuer, its parents, its majority-owned subsidiaries or majority-owned subsidiaries of the issuer's parent
For employees, directors, officers, or consultants and advisors, and their family members who acquire such securities from such persons through gifts or domestic relations orders
Former employees, directors, officers, consultants and advisors only if such persons were employed by or providing services to the issuer at the time the securities were offered
Consultants must be natural person
24
Rule 701 Basics
Amounts that may be sold.
• Offers. Any amount of securities may be offered in reliance on this section. However, for purposes of this section, sales of securities underlying options must be counted as sales on the date of the option grant
• Sales. The aggregate sales price or amount of securities sold in reliance on this section during any consecutive 12-month period must not exceed the greatest of the following:
• $1,000,000;
• 15% of the total assets of the issuer (or of the issuer's parent if the issuer is a wholly-owned subsidiary and the securities represent obligations that the parent fully and unconditionally guarantees), measured at the issuer's most recent annual balance sheet date (if no older than its last fiscal year end); or
• 15% of the outstanding amount of the class of securities being offered and sold in reliance on this section, measured at the issuer's most recent annual balance sheet date (if no older than its last fiscal year end)
25
Rule 144 Basics
Exemption for resale of two types of securities:
– Restricted securities
• shares acquired in unregistered offering
– Control securities
• shares owned by affiliates
– persons considered to be in control of the company
– officers, directors, and principal shareholders
• can be registered or unregistered shares
Rule 144 Basics
• Company must be current in public reporting
• Shares to be resold must have been held for one
year
• Shares resold in three-month period may not
exceed the greater of:
– 1% of the company's outstanding stock
– average trading volume of preceding four weeks
• Shares must be sold through registered stock
broker or market maker
• Form 144 filed with SEC at sale (or prior)
Section 16 Basics
Applies to:– Officers
• CEO and president
• CFO, CAO, and possibly controller
• Vice presidents
• Other persons with significant policy-making function
– Directors
– 10% shareholders
Short-swing profits recovery period– Profits must be returned to company if purchase within less than
six months of sale OR sale within less than six months of purchase
• Highest sale price less the lowest purchase price
– No defenses to application of provision
– Most transactions in stock plans are exempt from this rule
Section 16 Basics
Requires holdings and transactions to be reported to the SEC– Form 3
• Holdings
• File within ten days of becoming an insider
• Often filed by company’s legal counsel with IPO
– Form 4• Non-exempt transactions
• Open market purchases and sales
• Exempt transactions that involve the company
• Grants, exercises, restricted stock purchases, sales of stock to the company
• File within 2 days after the transaction occurs
– Form 5:• Exempt transactions that don’t involve the company
• Gifts, transfers dues to inheritance
• File within 45 days after fiscal year-end
• Year-end statement that no Form 5 is required
Taxation
• US and International
• Different timing, rules, withholding obligations
• Stock Options
• ISO/NQ
• SARs
• Stock Awards
• RS
• RSU
• Performance
Taxation
• Income reporting and tax withholding rules apply
regardless of public/private status
• IRS depository requirement applies regardless of
public/private status
• Section 409A applies regardless of public/private
status
IRS Publication 15, Circular E
“In general, you must deposit federal income tax withheld and both the employer and employee social security and Medicare taxes.”
“$100,000 Next-Day Deposit Rule
If you accumulate $100,000 or more in taxes on any day during a monthly or semiweekly deposit period (see Deposit period on page 21), you must deposit the tax by the next business day, whether you are a monthly or semi-weekly schedule depositor.”
“Accuracy of Deposits Rule
You are required to deposit 100% of your tax liability on or before the deposit due date. However, penalties will not be applied for depositing less than 100% if both of the following conditions are met
Any deposit shortfall does not exceed the greater of $100 or 2% of the amount of taxes otherwise required to be deposited
The deposit shortfall is paid or deposited by the shortfall makeup date as described below.”
32
Code Section 409A Basics
Penalties imposed on employees (not on the
employer); 20% Federal penalty and 20%
California state penalty
Incentive stock options and restricted stock are
exempt from Code Section 409A (but ISOs must
comply with Section 422)
Non-qualified stock options and restricted stock units
must comply with or be exempt from Code
Section 409A
33
Code Section 409A Basics
Non-qualified stock options are exempt if
• Exercise price equal to fair market value on the date of grant (see guidelines for determining fair market value)
• Option on common stock
• Watch out for modifications
Restricted stock units are exempt from Code Section 409A if structured to meet the requirements of the short-term deferral rule – payment made within 2 ½ months following the end of the year (calendar or fiscal) is which the RSU vested
34
Accounting
• Cheap Stock
• SEC determination that the valuation of the company’s stock prior to the IPO was not valid
• Stock was issued at prices below the “true” market value
• SEC reviews prices and methodology
• Usually 12-18 months pre IPO are most scrutinized
• Stock (grants) issued in 6 months prior to IPO are targets if less than the IPO pricing
• Compensation Cost to company
• Disclosures
• IRC Section 409A issues for “discounted” stock
• IRS audit of grants/exercises pre-IPO
Accounting
• Financial Reporting
• Valuation model selection
• Inputs
• Database Reconciliations
• How many databases do you have?
• Are they in sync?
• Can you “prove” your numbers?
Administration
• Stock Plan Administrator
• Tracking software
• Staffing
• New Exercise Types
• Same-Day Sale Programs
• Transfer Agent
• Broker
• Setting up a stock plan department
• Automation
• Systems
• Interfaces
38
Toolbox of IPO Topics
Toolbox for IPO
Securities Law Compliance
– Rule 144
– Rule 701
– Insider Trading Program
– Section 16 compliance
• Form 3
• Ongoing
– Rule 10b5-1 plans
– Form S-8 filing
39
Toolbox for IPO
Shareholder Reconciliation– Company must have a complete and reconciled list of all
shareholders (and option/award holders) prior to IPO• Capitalization Table
– Disclose who owns % of company at IPO
– Usually tracked in legal department (internal or external)
• Certificate/Shareholder Legends
– Securities restrictions (i.e., not registered)
– Affiliate restrictions
– Restricted shares (i.e., exercised but unvested)
– Plan to remove
» Make sure you work with BOTH legal and transfer agent for appropriate opinions
• Equity compensation plans
– Reserves
– Issuance instructions
– Signature authority
– Database audit and documentation
40
Toolbox for IPO
Tools and Partners
– Exchange Agent
– Transfer Agent
– Broker(s)
– Software provider
– Underwriters• Lockup?
• Friends and Family?
– Printers
– Legal counsel
– Payroll
– Automation
41
Toolbox for IPO
Employee Compensation Plans
– Review
• Any modifications needed for publicly traded company
• For example, does plan allow for Cashless/Same Day Sale
– Expand or Replace
– New Vehicles
• RSUs/Performance grants
• ESPP
– Evergreen provisions
– Policy & Procedure Updates
• Do you want to continue to grant ISOs after IPO?
42
Toolbox for IPO
Financial Reports
– Define Team
– Utilize administrative platform functionality where
possible
– Understand methodology of tools
• You have to report to auditors
– Set Processes
• For example, require that FV model inputs are set by financial
team 2 weeks prior to quarter close to allow for valuation and
running of reports.
– Make sure you have the necessary
background/knowledge
43
Toolbox for IPO
Employee Communication and Education
– Prepare ahead and have compliance/accuracy review
– Bring in vendors (brokers) for “how to” sections
– Don’t paint only “rosy” pictures
• Stock does drop
– Be open/honest/specific
– Give lots of examples
– Make education available ongoing/on demand
44
Thank You Sponsors…Thank You Sponsors…