Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement

8/13/2019 Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement

1/21


2/21

ENGO Submission to Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement Bill 2012 2

C, EG

A

: , .

F A

.

H

(

L FC ).

I FA ,

.

A , FA

.

F , A

,

H A

(HA).


3/21


E G (EG)

F A (FA)

.

: , .

A , ,

.

A . I FA

, . ,

,

L A,

C .

C

,

L C

A .

C. C

C.

C,

.

A ,

,

, ,

.

, .

A , E

20 ,

5000 .

E D 2006

,

. E


4/21


. M C

.

M

; F I., F J M,

F , L E C, M C C C, , B I., F &

D C G, E , ,

B, C, A I.,

, G

(ACF) ,

50 , , ,

. ACF , ,

. I 2012, 35,000

ACF .

()

,

A E.

; ,

, ,

,

.

C . I H L.

, ,

. ,

.

,

, EG

. E

F G. ( )

. I

, . I

.


5/21


F G

FA , H

E C, C .

. EG

, FA

, .

A , FA

.

H

. G

F C

, C B F A A

L ( ),

,

.

I FA

. I

,

.

I , ,

. H

. ,

,

. ;

1999

, .


6/21


.

1991,

F A

. G .

. A

,

.

F A 1991,

. I M 2009,

C C B C G,

. I , ,

. ,

.

, . I

, , ,

.

, ,

:

/

A A

A

A M (AM) D .

D 1980,

AM. A , E

. F


7/21


M F AM

1950.

F F C 1989, CE, G

, . , B

. B , 1991

.

D

, AM .

.

.

.

AM

. AM

.

,

. I

.

FA.

A , FA

,

, .

.

,

,

.

, ,

.

I A F (IGA) .


8/21


FA

. I

,

.

.

, A ,

,

G F C ,

. I

.

A

,

H A (HA).

EG

L C

FA B 2012 (FA B 2012).

EG C 2 FA , ,

A .

A

,

.

.

FA B 2012 A.

H, A

B.

A B

A. G ,

FA, A. D


9/21


B,

.

FA B

. A EG , ,

A.

M FA FA B 2012.

.

,

.

.

C FA ,

,

.

A, ,

.

MAD .

EG .

I

.

F G A,

. I

C ,

G .

FA ,

.

C , . H


10/21


,

. F

, G

.

F EG .

2010 2012, H, L, H,

M, D F, , , D, B . E

. , ,

K ,

.

M,

. ( 2010), K A (J 2011), H A (J 2011),

F I A (A 2011), I

G E (M 2012), D F A

B (J 2012), I A (A 2012), F

A ( 2012) F A B (D

2012).

FA FA B 2012

, . G

, .

,

.

FA,

L C FA B 2012.

, .

A

FA . I

,

.


11/21


.

,

H

, .

,

:

L ;

F ;

F , ,

/ ;

F ;

F (

); ,

F ( ,

)

( ),

.

I A 2011, G F:

, 600 ,

.I , 2011

, ,

.

A G ,

. A I G,

.

E B M

A , D M L

, H AM, C J, D M J, D

M, .

1


12/21


, IG

EG . B

: () ; () H

; () ; () ; () ; () H; ()

C; () ; () E () .

EG

A G ,

(C B D,

H C), C .

.

I EG ,

/ .

EG

. I EG

. 18.

A 2013, A . I ,

.

,

F, , F ,

.

,

, , .

EG

,

, . G

, . I

D L

2http://www.environment.gov.au/land/forests/independent-verification/pubs/ivg_capstone_final1-1.pdf3

http://www.environment.gov.au/land/forests/independent-verification/report.html4http://www.wilderness.org.au/campaigns/forests/DougApsley


13/21


F E A

, , ,

.

,

.

, F A 2012

C

.

D FA,

.

.

M

. EG

,

FA ,

.

EG

. FA B 2012 . I

137,000

. FA B 2012

. C 6 F A

, , ,

.

I 2012, F

201112 109,940 3 HL,

.

5http://au.wiley.com/WileyCDA/WileyTitle/productCd-CON4.html


14/21


I , FA B 2012

571,000

.

, ,

, . FA

,

.

FA . I

571,000 ,

,

, 37,954 C

. C 9

M ,

.

FA,

,

.

,

, FA

.

I 2012, F 12,483 3 . , 84 3

B, 381 2 D, 756 3 H 11,265 3

M.

, C

. B 80

97.5% B FA. M B

I F A

F

FA . H

FA.

6Review of Tasmanian Forest Estate Wood Supply Scenarios. Mark Burgman and Andrew Robinson.

Final Report to the Independent Verification Group, Intergovernmental Agreement, Version 9.9March 7, 2012. http://www.environment.gov.au/land/forests/independent-

verification/pubs/ivg_woodsupply_burgman.pdf


15/21


I , , M, C ,

41,000

FA.

(

400% 4%).

. A B

IG ,

FA,

.

E

, FA

.

,

, C

. C 9 ,

FA ,

.

FA B 2012

. E L C A F

C A , ,

, 80

25 30 .

,

. A ,

, C .

. B

, FA

.

, J


16/21


A, . E

G I G

IGA

,

. EG

,

.

FA

,

,

,

,

.

I

. F

$277

.

$20 1765

.

,

,

.

15,000 32,000 ,

, 13.5%

$2 ( 8%) .

, , . HA

. F , G E, BDA G (2009),

H A:

$700,445,000 ;

7IGA job creation figures, taken from the Department for Regional Australia figures on

economic diversification pending; http://www.regional.gov.au/regional/tasmania/projects.aspx:


17/21


$200,761,000 ;

5131 .

,

. A

CC A

D

, &

,

. A

.

FA FC

,

,

,

.

E C ECE FA FC FC

12 20 .

FC M 2011 FC

. 53.9% FC

A FC

.

A FA 2009 F , 2006, 24

. FA E F C, 2017, 45

.

8Gillespie Economics, BDA Group (2009):Economic Activity of Australias World Heritage

Areas, Department of Environment, Water, Heritage and Arts, Australian Government,Australia.

9

PricewaterhouseCoopers (2007): Sustainable Investments for conservation The businesscase for biodiversity. A study on behalf of the WW F Germany.10FSC Global Market Survey 2011. http://ic.fsc.org/market-information.345.htm


18/21


I

FC

.

F ,

. A

(, ) ( )

,

.

2012

.

/ (

)

,

.

(

) C F I

(CFI)

, , CFI , (

) , A .

CFI A C C

(ACC). A K

D 2012,

, ACC

ACC

A .

I G ACC

F A, :

1. F G

CFI,

CFI F G

CFI

11Tasmanian Forest Carbon Study (May et al 2012), commissioned by the Tasmanian Climate Change

Office; Tasmanian Forests Intergovernmental Agreement:An assessment of its carbon value(Macintosh 2012), commissioned by the Tasmanian Forest Agreement Independent Verification Group12Carbon Credits (Carbon Farming Initiative) Act 2011


19/21


2. G ()

CFI ()

CFI (

)

3. G ,

,

4. F G ( D

I C)

ACC G

5. G

() ACC , ()

ACC

ACC (. L ,

),

.

, F

G D 2012 M G

C F

A G

CFI

.

EG FA .

.

.

, ,

,

.

FA

, ,

. A

A .


20/21


21/21


. ,

.

A : '

: I

, . (G

, C 18 2010)

D 2010, , C,

,

C B F A.

C . I 72

29

.

F A C ( 21

), A , " '

' . (G ,

C 18 2010).

Documents

Submission to the Legislative Council Select Committee on the Tasmanian Forests Agreement