;]JR]VK\Q^M+WVLQ\QWVIT[

1V\ZWL]K\QWV+WVLQ\QWVIT[MV\MVKM[ KIVWVQKITTaWN \PMNWZUQN X Y _PQ[S][I_Ia\WI[KMVIZQWLM[KZQJMLJa\PMQZIV\MKMLMV\IVL\PMVUISMIKTIQUIJW]\Q\QV\PMQZKWV[MY]MV\

TIaMZWN XI[\\MV[MUWZXPWTWOaQN 7[_ITLLQLV\SQTT3MVVMLaJMKWUM[QN 7[_ITLPILV\SQTTML3MVVMLa 1\Q[\PI\ILLQ\QWVITTIaMZWN XI[\\MV[MUWZXPWTWOa_PQKPLWM[V\WJ^QW][TaKWV\ZQJ]\MIVIK\]ITXI[\UMIVQVO\PI\Y]Q\MZMTQIJTa[QOVIT[KWVLQ\QWVIT[WN \PM[MKWVLSQVL ;W QV[\MILWN KITTQVO\PMU[]JR]VK\Q^MKWVLQ\QWVIT[ WVMUQOP\KITT\PMUILLQ\QWVITXI[\KWVLQ\QWVIT[

?PQTMW]ZQVQ\QITM`IUXTM[LQLIXXMIZ\W[QOVIT\PI\\PMQZIV\MKMLMV\_I[NIT[MKWVLQ\QWVIT[WN \PM[MKWVLSQVLLWVW\IT_Ia[KIZZa\PM[]OOM[\QWVWN KW]V\MZNIK\]ITQ\a"

1N 2WVM[PIL\ISMVIZ[MVQK PM_W]TLPI^M[PW_VR][\M`IK\Ta\PW[M[aUX\WU[_PQKPPMLWM[QVNIK\[PW_ )VLMZ[WV !

) LWK\WZ_PW]\\MZ[ UQOP\JMXZMXIZML\W][MQ\I[XIZ\WN IVIZO]UMV\\PI\\PMIV\MKMLMV\Q[QVNIK\\Z]M [W\PMKWVLQ\QWVITKW]TLVW\JMKWV^MaQVOKW]V\MZNIK\]ITQ\aI[XIZ\WN Q\[UMIVQVO

+WV^MZ[MTa \PMZMIZM[WUMNWZUITTaQVLQKI\Q^MKWVLQ\QWVIT[\PI\M`XZM[[KW]V\MZNIK\]ITQ\a"

1N PMPI[[WT^ML\PQ[XZWJTMU 1U\PM9]MMVWN -VOTIVL 1N 5M[[Q_IQ\[R][\I[MKWVLTWVOMZ PM[KWZM[WV\PI\XTIa

C1VLQKI\Q^MKW]V\MZNIK\]IT[WN \PMSQVLQV IZMKWUUWVQV[XWZ\[KI[\XTIaJaXTIaKWUUMV\IZa

)TTWN \PMXW[[QJTM_WZTL[[MUIV\QKIXXZWIKPM[IV[_MZ\PQ[KWVKMZVJaKTW[MTa\aQVO\PMQLMV\QKI\QWVWN \PMZMTM^IV\[M\WN XW[[QJTM_WZTL[\WNIK\[QV\PMIK\]IT_WZTL ;\ITVISMZ ! OZW]VL[\PMJI[QKQLMIQV\PM[IUM:IU[Ma

ZMTM^IV\XW[[QJTM_WZTL[_PQKP\PMKWVLQ\QWVIT\PMVZIVOM[W^MZ 1\Q[[PW_V\PI\QN \PMM`XIV[QWVWN \PMUWLITPWZQbWVQ[OW^MZVMLJa\PM[IUM[QUQTIZQ\aWZLMZQVO][MLQV\PM;\ITVISMZ4M_Q[[a[\MU[ \PMIVITa[Q[ZMXTQKI\M[\PM\Z]\PKWVLQ\QWV[WN \PW[M[a[\MU[NWZQ[WTI\MLWZLQ[KW]Z[MQVQ\QITKWVLQ\QWVIT[

! # KN IT[W 0nRMS !! 3ZI\bMZ ! LWM[UISM\PMKWVVMK\QWV# NWZ[WUMZMKMV\LQ[K][[QWV[MM :W\P[KPQTL IVL -OZu+WbQK

3ZI\bMZ\WWS\PMTWOQKIT[\MXIVLIZO]ML\PI\4M_Q[QLMI[PW]TLJMIXXTQML\WITTKWVLQ\QWVITKWV[\Z]K\QWV[ ;PMX]\\PMXWQV\^MZaKWVKQ[MTaQV 3ZI\bMZ ! "

! 0MZbJMZOMZ !! IVL?IZUJZWL ! IZO]MNWZ\PM4QUQ\)[[]UX\QWVI[_MTT 5WZMZMKMV\Ta ?QTTQIU[ JIVL ;_IV[WV PI^MZM^Q[Q\ML\PM\WXQK

1VPQ[IZO]UMV\IOIQV[\\PM4QUQ\)[[]UX\QWV 4M_Q[ILL]KM[KI[M[\PI\[MMU\W[PW_\PI\\PMKTW[MVM[[\W\PMIK\]IT_WZTLKIVOM\I[aUX\W\QKITTaKTW[MZ"

1N \PQ[WVMQVKPTQVM_MZMUWZM\PIVIVQVKPTWVO

.WZIVa_WZTLQV_PQKP\PMTQVMQ[`QVKPM[TWVO \PMZM_QTTJMI_WZTL_PMZM\PMTQVMQ[R][\ITQ\\TMJQ\[PWZ\MZJ]\[\QTTUWZM\PIVIVQVKPTWVO ;W \PMZM_QTTJMVW_WZTL_PMZM\PMTQVMQ[I[KTW[M\WQ\[IK\]ITTMVO\PI[XW[[QJTM_PQTM[\QTTUWZM\PIVIVQVKPTWVO ;\ITVISMZIZO]M[\PI\QVIK\]IT][M VI\]ZITTIVO]IOM_W]TLVW\UISM\PMVMOZIQVMLLQ[\QVK\QWV[VMMLML\W\PZMI\MV\PM4QUQ\)[[]UX\QWVQV[]KPKI[M[

+I[M[ \PI\ \PZW_LW]J\WV \PM=VQY]MVM[[)[[]UX\QWVIZM TM[[ ZMKPMZKPu9]QVM[M`IUXTM!" _QTTLW"

1N *QbM\IVL>MZLQPILJMMVKWUXI\ZQW\[ *QbM\_W]TLPI^MJMMV1\ITQIV 1N *QbM\IVL>MZLQPILJMMVKWUXI\ZQW\[ >MZLQ_W]TLPI^MJMMV.ZMVKP

1N \PM=VQY]MVM[[)[[]UX\QWV_MZMKWZZMK\ M`IK\TaWVMWN IVL _W]TLJM\Z]M *]\\PMaJW\P[MMUL]JQW][

) ^QZ\]MWN \PM=VQY]MVM[[)[[]UX\QWV Q[ \PI\ Q\ ^ITQLI\M[ \PMXZQVKQXTMWN+WVLQ\QWVIT-`KT]LML5QLLTM" MQ\PMZQN X YWZQN X VW\Y ;]ZXZQ[QVOTa \PQ[^ITQLQ\a[MMU[\WXMZ[Q[\M^MVQV\PMXZWJTMUI\QK*QbM\>MZLQKI[M"

-Q\PMZQN *QbM\IVL>MZLQPILJMMVKWUXI\ZQW\[ *QbM\_W]TLPI^MJMMV1\ITQIV WZQN *QbM\IVL>MZLQPILJMMVKWUXI\ZQW\[>MZLQ_W]TLPI^MJMMV.ZMVKP

;\ITVISMZ[]OOM[\[\PI\ IVL IZM[MUIV\QKITTaQVLM\MZUQVI\MJMKI][MQ\Q[QVLM\MZUQVI\M_PQKPZM[WT]\QWVWN \PM[QUQTIZQ\aWZLMZQVOQ[KWV\M`\]ITTa[ITQMV\J]\\PI\ Q[\Z]MVM^MZ\PMTM[[JMKI][MQ\_W]TLJM\Z]M]VLMZIVaZMI[WVIJTMZM[WT]\QWVWN \PMQVLM\MZUQVIKa 0MXZWXW[M[ QUXTMUMV\QVO \PQ[ []OOM[\QWV QVI[]XMZ^IT]I\QWVNZIUM_WZS 3TQVMLQV[\ M`XTWZM[\PQ[N]Z\PMZIVL[PW_[PW_ Q\ KIVUISMOWWLWV \PM []OOM[\QWVJa ^WV.QV\MT 1I\ZQLW] IVL0QOOQVJW\PIU \PI\I+-5^ITQLI\QVO[MUIV\QK[NWZKWVLQ\QWVIT[Q[JMPQVL\PMQV\]Q\Q^MMY]Q^ITMVKMWN XIQZ[WN KWVLQ\QWVIT[]VLMZY]IV\QMZ[KWV\ZI 4M[TQM!# [MMIT[W 0]Q\QVS "

-^MZa[\]LMV\_W]TLPI^MNIQTMLQN PMPILOWWNMLWNN 6W[\]LMV\_W]TLPI^MXI[[MLQN PMPILOWWNMLWNN

;MM *IZSMZ !! IVL ^WV.QV\MT !! NWZLQ[K][[QWV)VW\PMZKWV[MY]MVKMWN UISQVO\PM=VQY]MVM[[)[[]UX\QWV Q[\PI\;\ITVISMZ

KIVVW\\ZMI\ _W]TL IVL UQOP\ I[L]IT[I[XZWXW[MLJa4M_Q[ 1V[\MIL PM[]OOM[\[\PI\ UQOP\ Q[IPQOPMZ][]ITTaMXQ[\MUQKWXMZI\WZ\PI\\ISM[I_PWTMKW]V\MZNIK\]ITQV Q\[ [KWXM )VL \PMMUJMLLML _W]TLKW]V\MZNIK\]IT Q[WN KW]Z[MIVITabMLI[][]IT 0MOQ^M[\PMNWTTW_QVOXIZIXPZI[MZMTI\QWV"

1N 2WPVPILJMMVQV^Q\ML PMUQOP\PI^MKWUM\W\PMXIZ\a! 1\UQOP\JM\PMKI[M\PI\QN 2WPVPILJMMVQV^Q\ML PM_W]TLPI^MKWUM

\W\PMXIZ\a

+WV[QLMZ\PMNWTTW_QVOKWV\ZI[\"

1\[VW\\PMKI[M\PI\2WPVU][\KWUM\W\PMXIZ\a *]\PMUQOP\ 1\[VW\\PMKI[M\PI\2WPV_W]TLPI^MKWUM\W\PMXIZ\aQN PMPILJMMV

QV^Q\ML *]\PMUQOP\PI^M

[PW]TLJMVMIKKWZLQVO\W4M_Q[ Q\[TQSM[IaQVO VW\ITTJ]\[WUM ;\ITVISMZM`XTIQV[Q\[IVWUITa\PQ[_Ia" QV\PMZ[\[MV\MVKM\PM[XMISMZ[Ia[\PI\PMSVW_[\PI\2WPV_W]TLV\PI^MKWUM QV\PM[MKWVL[PM[Ia[\PI\Q\[KWUXI\QJTM_Q\PPMZSVW_TMLOM\PI\PM_W]TLPI^M

4M_Q[PI[IX]ZXWZ\MLKW]V\MZM`IUXTM\W\PQ[IVITa[Q[ ;]XXW[M\PMZMQ[QVNIK\VWXMVVaQVUaXWKSM\ IT\PW]OP1 LWVW\SVW_Q\[QVKM1 LQLVW\TWWS

1N /ZQRX[\ZIXTIaMLPQ[LZ]U[ LM/QMZXTIaMLPQ[]\M 1N /ZQRX[\ZIPILXTIaMLPQ[LZ]U[ LM/QMZ_W]TLPI^MXTIaMLPQ[]\M

IXI[\\QUMJ]\UIaVW\JMIVaUWZM

:MNMZMVKM[)LIU[ -ZVM[\ ?! ;]JR]VK\Q^MIVLQVLQKI\Q^MKWVLQ\QWVIT[ .W]VLI\QWV[WN

4IVO]IOM !!

)LIU[ -ZVM[\ ?!

^WV.QV\MT 3IQ!! *IZMXT]ZIT[ JIZMKWVLQ\QWVIT[ IVL 7VTa 2W]ZVITWN ;MUIV\QK[

^WV.QV\MT 3IQ!!

3I[XMZ ?IT\MZ!! 8ZM[]XXW[Q\QWV[ KWUXW[Q\QWV IVL [QUXTM []JR]VK\Q^M[2W]ZVITWN ;MUIV\QK[ !

3I]NUIVV ;\MNIV +WVLQ\QWVIT\Z]\PIVLN]\]ZMZMNMZMVKM 2W]ZVITWN ;MUIV\QK[

3TQVMLQV[\ 6I\PIV 9]IV\QML KWVLQ\QWVIT[ IVL KWVLQ\QWVIT M`KT]LMLUQLLTM 2W]ZVITWN ;MUIV\QK[ !

3ZI\bMZ )VOMTQSI! ?PI\ U][\ IVL KIV U][\IVLKIVUMIV 4QVO]Q[\QK[IVL8PQTW[WXPa

3ZI\bMZ )VOMTQSI !! +WVLQ\QWVIT VMKM[[Q\a IVL XW[[QJQTQ\a 1V :IQVMZ*q]MZTM =Z[-OTQ)ZVQU^WV;\MKPW_ ML[ ;MUIV\QK[ NZWULQNNMZMV\ XWQV\[ WN^QM_ ;XZQVOMZ

3ZI\bMZ )VOMTQSI! 8IZ\Q\QWVIVLZM^Q[QWV" QOMZML[ +WUXW[Q\QWVITQ\a KWV\M`\IVL[MUIV\QK^IT]M[" -[[Ia[QVPWVW]ZWN -ZVQM4MXWZM ;XZQVOMZ

4M_Q[ ,I^QL! +W]V\MZNIK\]IT[ 7`NWZL" *TIKS_MTT

4M_Q[ ,I^QL! )L^MZJ[WN Y]IV\QKI\QWV 1V-L_IZL3MMVIVML .WZUIT[MUIV\QK[WN VI\]ZITTIVO]IOM +IUJZQLOM=VQ^MZ[Q\a8ZM[[

4M_Q[ ,I^QL! 8ZWJIJQTQ\QM[WN KWVLQ\QWVIT[IVLKWVLQ\QWVITXZWJIJQTQ\QM[

9]QVM ?QTTIZL>IV 7ZUIV! ?WZLIVLWJRMK\ +IUJZQLOM 5)"51< 8ZM[[:M[KPMZ 6QKPWTI[! 0aXW\PM\QKITZMI[WVQVO 6WZ\P0WTTIVL:W\P[KPQTL ,IVQMT ,WQVLQKI\Q^MKWVLQ\QWVIT[M`XZM[[XZWXW[Q\QWV[' .WZ\PKWUQVOQV 6W[

;KP]MTMZ ,I^QL MT\UIV .ZIVS 5ISQVOKW]V\MZNIK\]ITI[[]UX\QWV[ 2W]ZVITWN ;MUIV\QK[!

?IZUJZWL 3MV! ) LMNMV[MWN \PMTQUQ\I[[]UX\QWV 8PQTW[WXPQKIT;\]LQM[

?QTTQIU[ 2:WJMZ\ / +PIVKM[ KW]V\MZNIK\]IT[ IVL[QUQTIZQ\a 8PQTW[WXPaIVL8PMVWUMVWTWOQKIT:M[MIZKP

?QTTQIU[ 2:WJMZ\ /I +PIVKaKW]V\MZNIK\]IT[ ZML]`" :M[XWV[M\W,WLL5[

?QTTQIU[ 2:WJMZ\ /J ,MNMVLQVOKWVLQ\QWVITM`KT]LMLUQLLTM 6W[

C?WZLKW]V\" E

IntroductionThe meaning of subjunctivesNonmonotonicityThe dynamic strict analysisThe Restrictor ViewThe Limit and Uniqueness Assumptions, Conditional Excluded Middle, and MightTense and Aspect