10
Studies on the wood corrosion on a historic glulam-construction Wolfgang Rug 1 , Gunter Linke 2 , Angelika Lißner 3 ABSTRACT: The exposure to chemically-aggressive media causes a structural modification of wooden members. The related mechanisms are called wood corrosion. The subject of the studies was an approximately 100 year’s old warehouse, which was executed as HETZER-construction and has been used as storage for potassium salt. The assessment of the degree of modification and the evaluation of the strength reduction was the aim of the studies. Test on the strength as well as chemical analyses have been carried out. The results showed a clearly visible modification of the examined material due to the exposure to the salts. This was recognizable by the superficial macroscopic modifications as well as by a reduction in the strength of the material in the periphery of the cross-section. KEYWORDS: wood corrosion, chemically-aggressive media, Otto Hetzer, glulam, Dynstat-method 1 INTRODUCTION 123 The invention of the glued laminated timber by Otto Hetzer in the early 20 th century allowed the building wide-spanning constructions [2]. Amongst others halls in the fertilizer and potassium salt industry were erected by the use of this construction method, which is proven until today by several preserved buildings (see also www.otto-hetzer.de). However, this field of application subjects the building material wood to particular environmental conditions [6]. For example, the production processes as well as stored substances are releasing chemically-aggressive media, which can cause irreversible structural modifications of the wooden members. The modification of the wood due to chemically- aggressive media is not taken into consideration in the static calculations according the currently valid version of the Eurocode 5 [7]. Some suggestions concerning this problem are listed in [6]. Though, the knowledge of the degree of the modification is a significant requirement for static calculations concerning the load bearing capacity. 2 WOOD CORROSION Due to its chemical balance wood has a high resistance against chemically-aggressive media. If the correct environmental conditions are present, the wooden members will be subjected to corrosion [6]. 1 Prof. Dr.-Ing. Wolfgang Rug, Hochschule für nachhaltige Entwicklung, Eberswalde, [email protected] 2 Dipl.-Ing. (FH) Gunter Linke, Hochschule für nachhaltige Entwicklung, Eberswalde, [email protected] 3 Dipl.-Ing. (BA) Angelika Lißner, Ingenieurbüro Rug GmbH, Wittenberge The wood corrosion is a structural damage beginning on the surface, which is caused by chemical and physical reactions. These reactions are caused in particular by strong acidic and strong alkaline media (pH ≤ 2 respectively pH ≥11). If there are salts involved, the cell structure is destroyed by crystallization processes. The lignin and the hemicelluloses are degradated due to hydrolytic splitting. The in the individual case present destructive mechanism is dependent on the type of the impacting media. This fact is a result of numerous investigations on timber constructions additionally stressed due to chemically- aggressive media. The level of the destruction depends on the several aspects. These aspects could also be called a corrosion system, which is depicted in Figure 1. Figure 1: schematic depiction of the wood corrosion

Studies on the wood corrosion on a historic glulam-construction...2016/04/28  · Entwicklung, Eberswalde, [email protected] 3 Dipl.-Ing. (BA) Angelika Lißner, Ingenieurbüro

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Studies on the wood corrosion on a historic glulam-construction

    Wolfgang Rug1, Gunter Linke

    2, Angelika Lißner

    3

    ABSTRACT: The exposure to chemically-aggressive media causes a structural modification of wooden members. The

    related mechanisms are called wood corrosion. The subject of the studies was an approximately 100 year’s old

    warehouse, which was executed as HETZER-construction and has been used as storage for potassium salt. The

    assessment of the degree of modification and the evaluation of the strength reduction was the aim of the studies. Test on

    the strength as well as chemical analyses have been carried out. The results showed a clearly visible modification of the

    examined material due to the exposure to the salts. This was recognizable by the superficial macroscopic modifications

    as well as by a reduction in the strength of the material in the periphery of the cross-section.

    KEYWORDS: wood corrosion, chemically-aggressive media, Otto Hetzer, glulam, Dynstat-method

    1 INTRODUCTION 123

    The invention of the glued laminated timber by Otto

    Hetzer in the early 20th

    century allowed the building

    wide-spanning constructions [2]. Amongst others halls in

    the fertilizer and potassium salt industry were erected by

    the use of this construction method, which is proven

    until today by several preserved buildings (see also

    www.otto-hetzer.de).

    However, this field of application subjects the building

    material wood to particular environmental conditions

    [6]. For example, the production processes as well as

    stored substances are releasing chemically-aggressive

    media, which can cause irreversible structural

    modifications of the wooden members.

    The modification of the wood due to chemically-

    aggressive media is not taken into consideration in the

    static calculations according the currently valid version

    of the Eurocode 5 [7]. Some suggestions concerning this

    problem are listed in [6].

    Though, the knowledge of the degree of the modification

    is a significant requirement for static calculations

    concerning the load bearing capacity.

    2 WOOD CORROSION

    Due to its chemical balance wood has a high resistance

    against chemically-aggressive media. If the correct

    environmental conditions are present, the wooden

    members will be subjected to corrosion [6].

    1 Prof. Dr.-Ing. Wolfgang Rug, Hochschule für nachhaltige

    Entwicklung, Eberswalde, [email protected] 2 Dipl.-Ing. (FH) Gunter Linke, Hochschule für nachhaltige

    Entwicklung, Eberswalde, [email protected] 3 Dipl.-Ing. (BA) Angelika Lißner, Ingenieurbüro Rug GmbH,

    Wittenberge

    The wood corrosion is a structural damage beginning on

    the surface, which is caused by chemical and physical

    reactions. These reactions are caused in particular by

    strong acidic and strong alkaline media (pH ≤ 2

    respectively pH ≥11).

    If there are salts involved, the cell structure is destroyed

    by crystallization processes. The lignin and the

    hemicelluloses are degradated due to hydrolytic splitting.

    The in the individual case present destructive mechanism

    is dependent on the type of the impacting media. This

    fact is a result of numerous investigations on timber

    constructions additionally stressed due to chemically-

    aggressive media.

    The level of the destruction depends on the several

    aspects. These aspects could also be called a corrosion

    system, which is depicted in Figure 1.

    Figure 1: schematic depiction of the wood corrosion

  • On a large amount of the so far observed constructions it

    was determined that the destruction of the wood

    structure is limited to the cross-section near the surface.

    This destruction is visible by a greyish-brown

    discolouration and a fibrous surface structure. In some

    cases the separation of whole strips of wood along the

    annual ring limits was observed. Furthermore, the

    peripherical cross-section shows a reduction of the

    strength as well as an increased density. In the inner

    cross-section there is no such strength reduction.

    Glued laminated timber has a higher resistance

    concerning the wood corrosion as long as large, compact

    members are used and no large shrinkage cracks are

    appearing. Furthermore, the type of glue significantly

    influences the resistance against chemically-aggressive

    media.

    3 SUBJECT AND AIM OF THE STUDY

    The effect of the salts on the load bearing capacity of the

    historic glued laminated timber has been examined in the

    course of material tests [1]. The main focus laid on tests

    with the Dynstat-method as well as on chemical analyses

    concerning the salt content.

    The results of this technical material study should be

    used as basis for future investigations concerning the

    structural stability of existing glued laminated timber

    constructions which are additionally stressed by

    chemically-aggressive media.

    The subject of the study was a warehouse which was

    erected in 1912 by the use of the HETZER-construction

    method. The load-bearing structure of the warehouse

    consisted of eleven parabolic trusses made from glued

    laminated timber according to the patent DRP. 197773

    [5]. The trusses (wood species: spruce) had a double-T

    cross-section (see Figures 2 & 3).

    Figure 2: view on the truss construction; the examined section is marked in red

    After the demolition of the ware house in April 2010

    several parts of the construction have been transferred to

    the University of Applied Sciences, Eberswalde/

    Germany (HNE Eberswalde) to carry out technical

    studies on the wooden members.

    Figure 3: sectional view A-A of the truss construction – 1: top

    chord; 2: web; 3: solid wood bracing; 4: bottom chord (all dimensions in mm)

    The sample material had clearly visible marks of

    corrosion. The surface was greyish-brown discoloured

    and fibrous. The discolouration reached a depth of 20-

    25mm from the surface. Furthermore, the already

    mentioned separation of wooden strips could also be

    found. The Figures 4 and 5 are showing the macroscopic

    appearance of the sample material exemplarily.

    Figure 4: top: fibrous surface structure and greyish

    discolouration as well as salt deposits on the bottom chord;

    bottom: sectional view on a chord and the web (the borders of

    the discolouration are marked in red)

  • Figure 5: discolouration of the peripherical cross-section,

    shown on a bar-shaped sample from a chord lamella (the discoloured area is crosshatched in red)

    4 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

    4.1 SAMPLE EXTRACTION

    The extraction of the samples was limited to an area of a

    length of approx. 1,50m near the support of the truss (see

    Figure 2). The observed part of the truss has shown the

    clearest corrosion marks of all the available truss

    fragments. This can be explained by the direct contact

    between the salt and the wooden members during the

    service life of the warehouse.

    Bar-shaped samples with a cross-section of b/h =

    10/15mm and a length of ℓ = 65mm (web) respectively 205mm (chords) have been extracted from each lamella

    of the chords and the web of the truss. The sample

    extraction included every lamella of the observed truss

    fragment. In total 60 bar-shaped samples have been

    extracted – 30 samples from the cords and 30 samples

    from the web.

    These bar-shaped samples have been cut into

    approximately 4mm thick disc-shaped Dynstat specimen

    along the longitudinal direction of the sample (see Figure

    6). In this way, it was possible to create depth profiles

    which cover the whole length of the samples.

    Figure 6: top: schematic depiction of the specimen cutting;

    bottom: separation of a bar-shaped sample into disc-shaped

    specimen at the example of a sample from a chord lamella

    Each sample from the trusses web was cut into fourteen

    disc-shaped specimens. The samples from the chord

    lamellas were divided into 44 disc-shaped specimens

    each. In total 1740 specimen were cut from the overall

    60 samples as shown below.

    Sample series „chord“:

    30 samples with 44 specimen 1320 specimen

    Sample series „web“:

    30 samples with 14 specimen 420 specimen

    4.2 STRENGTH TESTS WITH THE DYNSTAT-METHOD

    The remaining strength of the material has been

    determined by flexural tests with the Dynstat-method

    according to DIN 53435:1983 [9] respectively. TGL 1-

    204/8:1965 [10]. In the nowadays valid version of the

    test specifications [9] the application of the Dynstat-

    method is restricted for the test of plastic materials.

    Studies [11] have proven the principally applicability of

    this test method for technical studies on wood. This

    applies especially for the material-saving determination

    of the material properties and the development of

    strength profiles along the width respectively the height

    of the cross-section.

    The specimens have been loaded with a continuous rate

    of deformation until a failure occurred. The test setup is

    depicted in Figure 7.

    Figure 7: test setup of the Dynstat-method – 1: specimen; 2:

    rotation axis; 3: bending support (r = 0,5mm); 4: bending blade (r = 0,5mm)

    The test apparatus used is shown in the Figures 8 and 9.

    Figure 8: Dynstat apparatus (type Dys-e 9303)

  • Figure 9: specimen in the test apparatus during the test

    The flexural tests were accompanied by the

    determination of the density according DIN 52182:1976

    [12] and the wood moisture according DIN EN 13183-

    1:2002 [13] by the determination of the dimensions and

    the weight of the conditioned specimen (υ = 20°C and

    φ = 65%) as well as in dry state.

    4.3 CHEMICAL ANALYSIS OF THE SALT CONTENT

    The salt content was determined by the use of the optical

    atom emission spectroscopy with inductive coupled

    plasma (ICP-OES). This analysis method is based on the

    interaction between the elements contained in the

    samples and the electromagnetic radiation emitted by

    them.

    By stimulating a vaporized sample solution, the outer

    electrons of the contained elements are raised to a higher

    energy level. The supplied energy is emitted during the

    relapse of the electrons to their base energy level in the

    form of light. The emitted light has a specific

    wavelength and frequency which is characteristic for a

    specific element (see [14]). By measuring the

    wavelength and the intensity of the emitted light the

    contained elements and their concentration can be

    determined in comparison to given calibration data.

    This chemical analysis was carried out exemplarily on

    one sample from the web and the chords. The samples

    were chosen according to their distinctive strength

    profile. In total 58 specimens have been analyzed

    chemically.

    5 RESULTS AND EVALUATION

    5.1 RESULTS OF THE PHYSICAL-MECHANICAL TEST

    The flexural test have been evaluated according the

    regulations in DIN 53435:1983 [9] and TGL 1-

    204/8:1965 [10]. Accordingly the maximum flexural

    stress equals the bending strength of defect-free wood.

    However, a conversion of the determined strength values

    on the strength of small defect-free specimen in

    accordance with DIN 52186:1978 [12] (bar-shaped

    specimen, test configuration is shown in Figure 9) with

    the help of suitable factors is required.

    Such factors for the conversion of the bending strength

    and the density have been determined in the last years at

    the HNE Eberswalde (see [11]).

    Figure 10: test configuration for the flexural test on bar-

    shaped, defect-free specimen according to DIN 52186:1978 [12]

    The relation between the properties of Dynstat-specimen

    and bar-shaped, defect-free specimen (wood species:

    spruce) is specified in [11] as shown in the following

    Equations (1) and (2):

    - density:

    Dynstat

    DIN52186

    ρρ =

    0.92 (1)

    - bending strength:

    m,Dynstat

    m,DIN52186

    ff =

    0.54 (2)

    where ρDIN52186 = density of bar-shaped, defect-free

    specimen in accordance with DIN 52186, ρDynstat =

    density of Dynstat-specimen, fm,DIN52186 = bending

    strength of bar-shaped, defect-free specimen in

    accordance with DIN 52186, fm,Dynstat = bending strength

    of Dynstat-specimen

    The influence of the wood moisture on the bending

    strength has also been considered by the application of a

    conversion factor. It is specified in [15] that the bending

    strength decreases by 4% if the wood moisture increases

    by one percentage point. This is valid for the increase of

    the wood moisture below the fibre saturation point. The

    equivalent conversion factor can be determined as shown

    in Equation (3):

    fm, Glk = - 0.04 +1 (3)

    Where kfm,ω = conversion factor for the influence of the

    wood moisture on the bending strength, ωGl =

    equilibrium wood moisture in [%] which attunes under

    the predominant climate (here: ωGl =12%), ω = wood

    moisture during the tests [%]

    After the conversion of the test results a statistical

    analysis concerning possible statistical outliers took

    place (test according to GRUBBS, see [22]). In the result

    of this analysis no statistical outliers could be

    determined.

    Furthermore, the distribution of the test results has been

    analyzed by the help of the KOLMOGOROV-

    SMIRNOV-Test (see [22]). It was determined that the

    bending strength as well as the density are approximately

    normal distributed. The actual distribution is positively

    skewed (rate of skewness: density: 0.551; bending

    strength: 0.582). This means that the greater amount of

  • test results is located below the mean value of the

    assumed ideal normal distribution.

    The Figures 11 and 12 are depicting the absolute

    frequency as well as the assumed ideal normal

    distribution of the density and the bending strength of all

    specimens.

    Figure 11: distribution of the density of all specimens

    Figure 12: distribution of the bending strength of all

    specimens

    The results of the statistical analysis of the converted test

    results are listed in Table 1 and Table 2.

    Table 1: results of the statistical analysis of the converted test results – sample series „chord“

    density ρ12 bending

    strength fm

    amount of specimen n 1320 Stk. 1320 Stk.

    minimum xmin 0.31 g/cm³ 23.2 N/mm²

    maximum xmax 0.67 g/cm³ 141.9 N/mm²

    mean value xmean 0.47 g/cm³ 82.1 N/mm²

    standard deviation sx 0.06 g/cm³ 17.1 N/mm²

    variation coefficient vx 12.1% 20.8%

    Table 2: results of the statistical analysis of the converted test results – sample series „web“

    density ρ12 bending

    strength fm

    amount of specimen n 420 Stk. 420 Stk.

    minimum xmin 0.37 g/cm³ 38.3 N/mm²

    maximum xmax 0.68 g/cm³ 164.4 N/mm²

    mean value xmean 0.50 g/cm³ 88.8 N/mm²

    standard deviation sx 0.06 g/cm³ 23.7 N/mm²

    variation coefficient vx 12.0% 26.7%

    The evaluation of the test results was carried out as a

    comparison with the normatively regulated material

    properties of spruce according to DIN 68364:2003 [16].

    In this standard the mean density is given with a value of

    0.46g/cm³ and a variation coefficient of 9.7%. The mean

    bending strength has a value of 80N/mm² and a variation

    coefficient of 14.2%.

    The comparison between the test results and the material

    properties according to DIN 68364:2003 [16] has shown

    that the density of the examined material is slightly

    increased. The mean density is located in the top

    variation range of the normatively regulated density

    (sample series “chord”: 0.47 g/cm³; sample series “web”:

    0.50 g/cm³). The observed increase can be attributed to

    the salt deposit in the peripherical wood structure. The

    comparison of the mean density of the examined

    material and the density according to DIN 68364:2003

    [16] is depicted in Figure 13.

    Figure 13: comparison between the densities of the examined material with the density according DIN 68364:2003[16]

    The bending strength of the examined material is also

    higher than the bending strength according DIN

    68364:2003 [16]. An equivocal explanation for this

    observation could not be found on basis of the studies

    that have been carried out. The comparison of the mean

    bending strength of the examined material and the

    bending strength according DIN 68364:2003 [16] is

    depicted in Figure 14.

  • Figure 14: comparison between the bending strength of the

    examined material with the bending strength according DIN 68364:2003[16]

    The evaluation of the mean values of the bending

    strength has shown that the examined material was

    obviously not affected by the impact of the salts (see

    Figure 14). However, considering the depth profile of the

    bending strength it is clear that the strength in the

    peripherical cross-section is reduced in comparison to

    the inner cross-section (see Figure 15).

    Figure 15: depth profile of the bending strength – sample G1-2 (sample series „chord“)

    5.2 RESULTS OF THE CHEMICAL TEST

    In the result of the chemical analysis mainly potassium

    chloride, sodium chloride and magnesium chloride could

    be determined to be deposed in the wood structure.

    Furthermore, several sulphates in lower concentration

    were detected. The concentration of these sulphates

    equals the amount of sulphates which have to be

    expected in long-term obstructed timber. Therefore, the

    effect of the sulphates on the examined material’s

    properties is neglected.

    The total concentration of the detected chlorides in the

    peripheral cross-section has a value of approximately

    10% (sample series “web”) respectively 13% (sample

    series “chord”). The concentration decreases towards the

    inner cross-section. The analyzed sample from the web

    has a salt concentration of approximately 4-5% in the

    inner cross-section. The concentration of the inner cross-

    section of the sample from the chord was approximately

    1-2%.

    To qualitatively determine the influence of the salt

    deposition on the bending strength a linear correlation

    and regression analysis has been carried out. This

    analysis refers to the entire specimens which have been

    chemically analyzed. The results are depicted in Figure

    16.

    Figure 16: depiction of the relation between the salt concentration and the bending strength

    Figure 15 shows clearly that the bending strength

    decreases with the increasing salt concentration. This is

    also proved by the negative correlation and regression

    coefficients. It should be noted at this point that the

    examined relation is only moderately expressed. The

    correlation coefficient has only a value of -0.485. The

    relatively small sample size of only 58 specimens can be

    seen as the reason for this fact.

    5.3 DETERMINATION OF THE CORROSION LAYER THICKNESS

    The corrosion layer is the peripherical part of the cross-

    section which shows a clearly visible respectively

    measureable alteration due to the influence of the

    chemically-aggressive media. These alterations are

    manifested – as already described above – as a

    macroscopic modification (discolouration, fibrous

    surface structure) as well as a reduction of the material’s

    strength.

    The thickness of this corrosion layer can be determined

    graphically on basis of the results of the technical

    material studies which have been carried out. General

    rules are listed in [17] which are derived from studies on

    timber construction in the potash industry. These rules

    are listed below.

    1) The bending strength in a distance of 14mm from the surface is approximately constant. The mean

    value is depicted as a straight line in this area.

    2) The bending strength beyond this intact inner cross -section (core area) decreases steeply.

    3) The thickness of the corrosion layer results from the intersection of the steeply decreasing strength in

  • the peripherical cross-section and the 75%-line of

    the mean bending strength in the intact inner cross-

    section (core area) plus the half of the specimen’s

    thickness.

    This method was applied exemplarily on the test results

    of on sample of each sample series. These are the same

    samples which were chemically analyzed.

    For the sample from the sample series „chord“, the

    thickness of the corrosion layer equals 13.5mm. The

    sample from the sample series “web” the thickness had a

    value of 11mm.

    The Figure 17 depicts exemplarily the graphically

    determined thickness of the corrosion layer of sample

    G1-2 in comparison to the determined salt concentration.

    Figure 17: graphical determination of the corrosion layer’s thickness according [17] (sample G1-2)

    The Figure 17 reveals that the bending strength in the

    assumed intact inner cross-section is partially lower than

    in the damaged peripherical cross-section. The salt

    concentration in the assumed intact inner cross-section is

    relatively high with values up to 8%.

    The in [17] described method has been derived from test

    on small, defect-free specimen (bar-shaped specimen,

    see Figure 9). Therefore, the unconditional applicability

    of this method on the bending strength of Dynstat-

    specimen is questionable.

    Thus, a second graphical method for the determination

    of the corrosion layer’s thickness was applied. The

    second method uses the 5-percentile value of the bending

    strength of defect-free wood according to DIN

    68364:2003 [16] as reference. Then, the corrosion layer

    is the part of the cross-section in which the test results

    are lower than the reference value.

    With the help of this consideration a corrosion layer’s

    thickness of 5mm (sample series “web”) respectively

    10mm (sample series “chord”) could be determined. The

    Figure 18 depicts exemplarily the graphically determined

    thickness of the corrosion layer of sample G1-2 in

    comparison to the determined salt concentration.

    The corrosion layer’s thickness which was determined in

    comparison to the 5-percentile value of the bending

    strength of defect-free wood according to DIN

    68364:2003 [16] is seen as the decisive thickness.

    Figure 18: graphical determination of the corrosion layer’s thickness (sample G1-2)

    The main reason for this consideration is the nowadays

    valid safety concept for the design of timber

    constructions. This concept uses 5-percentile values as

    the characteristic values for the design. Another reason is

    – as described above – that the in [17] described method

    can only be applied on results of the Dynstat-method

    with restrictions.

    Therefore, the thickness of the circumferential corrosion

    layer of the examined material is declared with values of

    5mm on the web respectively 10mm on the chords (see

    also Figure 19).

    Figure 19: thickness of the corrosion layer

    5.4 COMPARATIVE CALCULATIONS CONCERNING THE STRUCTURAL

    STABILITY

    The knowledge of the thickness of the corrosion layer

    creates the basis for the analysis of the structural stability

    of a timber construction which is affected by the

    influence of chemically aggressive media. A proposal for

    the design of such constructions can be found in [6].

  • According to [6] there are two ways to statically

    calculate such constructions. Both methods are similar to

    the hot-state design according to Eurocode 5 [18]. On the

    one hand, it is possible to calculate with the reduced

    material strength due to the influence of the chemically-

    aggressive media (method 1). On the other hand, the

    cross-section can be reduced by the thickness of the

    circumferential corrosion layer (method 2).

    The comparative calculation concerning the structural

    stability has been carried out by the use of both methods.

    The results of the physical-mechanical and chemical

    tests created the basis of the calculation.

    Method 1: calculation with a reduced material strength

    The modification factor to take account of the influence

    of the chemically-aggressive media kmod,aM was selected

    according to the results of the chemical tests.

    Method 2: calculation with a reduced cross-section

    The cross-section of the glulam trusses has been reduced

    by a value of 5mm. This equals the thickness of the

    corrosion layer which was determined for the web of the

    trusses.

    The results of the comparative calculation revealed that

    the static utilization rate of the glulam trusses under

    consideration of a reduced material strength (method 1,

    kmod,aM = 0.95) equals the utilization rate under

    consideration of a circumferential corrosion layer

    (method 2, d = 5mm).

    The results of the proposed design methods given in [6]

    can be proved by the results of the technical studies

    which were carried out. Therefore, these design methods

    are adequate for the prognostic calculation of the

    structural stability of timber structures under

    consideration of the influence of chemically-aggressive

    media.

    5.5 DETERMINATION OF THE CHARACTERISTIC MATERIAL

    PROPERTIES

    Another initial value for the calculation of the structural

    stability of a timber construction which is affected by

    chemically-aggressive media is the assignment of the

    affected members to the officially approved system of

    strength classes for glued laminated timber members.

    This is achieved by the determination of the

    characteristic material values.

    In this case the characteristic values were determined

    according EN 384:2010 [18]. The test results of all tested

    specimen (sample series “chord” and “web”) have been

    divided into two new groups. The first group included

    the entire specimen from the undamaged cross-section

    (intact inner cross -section). The second group was

    formed by the specimen from the corroded peripherical

    cross-section. The advantage of such a partition is that as

    the actual load bearing capacity of the undamaged cross-

    section can be estimated more accurately.

    The characteristic values of the strength properties are

    determined according EN 384:2010 [18], chapter 5.4 as

    shown below (see Equation 4).

    k 05 S Vf = f k k (4)

    where kf = characteristic value of the strength in

    [N/mm²], 05f = mean value of the 5-percentile values

    which are weighted in proportion to the amount of

    specimen in [N/mm²], Sk = correction factor to consider

    the amount of samples and specimen according to EN

    384:2010 [19], Figure 1, Vk = correction factor to

    consider the low variability of the 5-percintile values of

    machine-graded timber in comparison to visually graded

    timber

    The 5-percentile value f05 is determined as shown in

    Equation 5:

    05 x 95f = f - s t (5)

    where 05f = 5-percentile value of the strength in

    [N/mm²], f = mean value of the strength in [N/mm²],

    xs = standard deviation of the strength in [N/mm²], 95t

    = t-factor of the Student-distribution for 1 - = 95 %

    The characteristic value of the density is determined

    according EN 384:2010 [18], chapter 8 as shown below

    (see Equation 6).

    05,j j

    k

    j

    ρ nρ =

    n (6)

    where kρ = characteristic value of the density in

    [kg/m³], 05, jρ = 5-percentile value of the density of a

    sample in [kg/m³], jn = amount of specimen in one

    sample

    The 5-percentile value ρ05 is determined as shown in Equation 7:

    05ρ = ρ -1,65 s (7)

    where ρ = mean value of the density in [kg/m³], s =

    standard deviation of the density in [kg/m³]

    A characteristic value of the bending strength of

    25.67N/mm² in the corroded peripherical cross-section

    respectively 45.40N/mm² in the intact cross-section was

    derived from the test results. The characteristic density

    equals a value of 413.81kg/m³ in the corroded

    peripherical cross-section respectively 376.23kg/m³ in

    the intact inner cross-section.

    These results are again proving the reduction of the

    material’s strength in the peripherical cross-section in

    comparison to the intact inner cross-section. The density

    in the peripherical cross-section is increased. This fact is

    caused by the deposition of salt in the peripherical cross-

    section as already mentioned above.

  • The characteristic material properties of timber are

    nowadays regulated in the EN 338:2010 [20], Table 1.

    The comparison of the characteristic values of the test

    results with the characteristic values of the strength

    classes in EN 338:2010 [20] allows an assignment of the

    material in the corroded peripherical cross-section to the

    strength class C24. The material in the intact inner cross-

    section can be assigned to the strength class C27

    although the characteristic bending strength is much

    higher than listed in EN 338: 2010 [20], Table 1 (see

    also Table 3).

    Table 3: possible assignment of the examined material to the strength classes of timber according EN 338:2010 [20]

    C2

    4

    per

    iph

    eric

    al

    cro

    ss-s

    ecti

    on

    C2

    7

    inn

    er

    cro

    ss-s

    ecti

    on

    bending

    strength

    fm,k [N/mm²]

    24 25.67 27 45.40

    density

    ρk [kg/m³] 350 413.81 370 376.23

    Following the regulations of EN 14080:2013 [21], Table

    1 it is possible to assign lamellas of the strength class

    C24 to the T-class T14. Lamellas of the strength class

    C27 can be assigned to the T-class T16.

    Since the extraction of the samples included every

    lamella in the cross-section the assignment mentioned

    above can be assumed for the whole cross-section.

    However, this assignment could only be seen as

    orientation since the flexural modulus of elasticity is also

    decisive in order to assign timber to a strength class.

    Furthermore, the characteristic values of the test material

    are derived from test on defect-free wood. The

    transmission of the results to full-scale timber members

    is only possible with the help of an adequate regression

    function. At the moment there is only inadequate

    knowledge for wood affected by chemically-aggressive

    media.

    On basis of the orienting assignment of the examined

    material to the strength and T-classes of timber a

    valuation on the load bearing capacity of the glulam

    timber members is now possible.

    According to EN 14080:2013 [21], Table 3 glulam

    timber which is entirely made of lamellas of the T-class

    T14 can be assigned to the strength class GL24h

    according to EN 14080:2013 [21], Table 5. If the entire

    lamellas are assigned to the T-class T16 the glulam

    timber could be assigned to the strength class GL26h.

    These possible assignments are only valid for modern

    glued laminated timber. Whether this is also valid for

    historic glulam members is questionable at the moment.

    The main causes are the lack of knowledge about the

    historically used glues as well as the fact that historic

    glulam members were produced without finger joints.

    6 CONCLUSIONS

    The results of this study are revealing that the examined

    material was clearly altered due to the salt exposure in

    spite of its high resistance against the effect of

    chemically-aggressive media.

    The chemical analysis has shown that the salts are not

    only deposed in the peripherical cross-section but also in

    its core. The concentration was measured with a value of

    10-13% in the peripherical cross-section respectively 1-

    5% in the core.

    The influence of the chemically-aggressive media is

    amongst others clearly visible by the macroscopic

    alteration of the wood structure near the surface. The

    surface structure of the examined material was fibrous

    and showed a greyish-brown discolouration. This

    discolouration reached a depth of 20-25mm.

    The results of the material test have proven the

    macroscopic alteration of the examined material.

    Although, there is no significant reduction of the

    strength in the inner cross-section there is a significant

    reduction of the strength in the peripherical cross-

    section. The density decreases from the surface towards

    the inner cross-section. This refers to the analyzed salt

    concentration.

    The thickness of the circumferential corrosion layer was

    determined on basis of the examined material’s bending

    strength. Two methods were used – firstly the method

    according to [17] and secondly a comparison between

    the test results and the 5-percentile value of the

    normatively regulated bending strength according to

    DIN 68364:2003 [16]. In the result a thickness of 5mm

    on the web respectively 10mm on the chords was

    determined.

    A comparative calculation according to the method

    described in [6] showed that the prognostic calculated

    load factor (method 1 - calculation with a reduced

    strength) approximates the actual load factor (method 2 -

    calculation with a reduced cross-section).

    The influence of the chemically-aggressive media on the

    material’s properties is not taken into consideration in

    the currently valid timber construction rules so far [7].

    However, this study has shown that this influence has to

    be taken into consideration on existing timber structures.

    The results of this study led to further investigations on

    the influence of the chemically-aggressive media on the

    load bearing capacity of historic glued laminated timber

    constructions. This includes the determination of the

    strength of glulam and solid wood member in full-scale

    as well as a study on the glued joints. These studies will

    be mentioned in future publications.

    ACKNOWLEDGMENT This study was financed by private donations. The

    authors would like to thank the donors for the generous

    support.

    REFERENCES [1] Rug, W., Linke, G.: Untersuchungen zur

    Holzkorrosion an historischem Brettschichtholz.

    Bautechnik 90 (2013), Heft 10, S. 642-650

  • [2] Rug, W.: Innovation im Holzbau – Die Hetzerbauweise (Teil 1). Bautechnik 71 (1994), Heft

    4, S. 213–219.

    [3] Rug, W.: Innovation im Holzbau – Die Hetzerbauweise (Teil 2). Bautechnik 72 (1995), Heft

    4, S. 231–241.

    [4] Rug, W.: 100 Jahre Hetzer-Patent. Bautechnik 83 (2006), Heft 8, S. 533–540.

    [5] DRP. 197773: Gebogener Holz-Bauteil für vereinigte Dach-Pfosten und -Sparren (1906)

    [6] Rug, W.; Lißner, A.: Untersuchungen zur Festigkeit und Tragfähigkeit von Holz unter dem Einfluss

    durch aggressive Medien. Bautechnik 88 (2011),

    Heft 3, S. 177–188.

    [7] DIN EN 1995-1-1:2010 – Eurocode 5: Bemessung und Konstruktion von Holzbauten – Teil 1-1:

    Allgemeines – Allgemeine Regeln und Regeln für

    den Hochbau.

    [8] Linke, G.: Untersuchungen zur Holzkorrosion bei historischem Brettschichtholz. Hochschule für

    nachhaltige Entwicklung (FH), Eberswalde 2011

    (unveröffentlicht – diploma thesis)

    [9] DIN 53435:1983 – Prüfung von Kunststoffen – Biegeversuch und Schlagbiegeversuch an Dynstat-

    Probekörpern

    [10] TGL 1-204/8:1965 – Prüfung von Holz – Bestimmung der Biegefestigkeit und

    Schlagzähigkeit an kleinen proben (Dynstatprüfung)

    [11] Rug, W.; Eichbaum, G.; Linke, G.: Vergleichende Festigkeitsuntersuchungen an Holz mit dem

    Dynstat-Verfahren. In: Holztechnologie 52 (2011) 6,

    S. 34-40

    [12] DIN 52182:1976 – Prüfung von Holz – Bestimmung der Rohdichte

    [13] DIN EN 13183-1:2002 – Feuchtegehalt eines Stückes Schnittholz – Teil 1: Bestimmung durch

    Darrverfahren

    [14] Gey, M. H.: Instrumentelle Analytik und Bioanalytik – Biosubstanzen, Trennmethoden,

    Strukturanalytik, Applikation. Berlin: Springer

    Verlag, 2008

    [15] Niemz, P.: Physik des Holzes und der Holzwerkstoffe. Leinfelden-Echterdingen: DRW-

    Verlag, 1993

    [16] DIN 68364:2003 – Kennwerte von Holzarten – Rohdichte, Elastizitätsmodul und Festigkeiten

    [17] Erler, K.: Bauzustandsanalyse und Beurteilung der Tragfähigkeit von Holzkonstruktionen unter

    besonderer Berücksichtigung der Korrosion von

    Holz. Technische Hochschule Wismar.

    Habilitationsschrift, Wismar: 1988

    [18] DIN EN 1995-1-2:2010 – Eurocode 5: Bemessung und Konstruktion von Holzbauten – Teil 1-2:

    Allgemeine Regeln – Tragwerksbemessung für den

    Brandfall

    [19] DIN EN 384:2010 – Bauholz für tragende Zwecke – Bestimmung charakteristischer Werte für

    mechanische Eigenschaften und Rohdichte

    [20] DIN EN 338:2010 – Bauholz für tragende Zwecke – Festigkeitsklassen

    [21] DIN EN 14080:2013 – Holzbauwerke – Brettschichtholz und Balkenschichtholz –

    Anforderungen

    [22] John, B.: Statistische Verfahren für Technische Meßreihen – Arbeitsbuch für den Ingenieur. Carl

    Hanser Verlag, München – Wien. 1979

    [23] Schwar, A.: Mazeration als Erscheinungsform chemischer Korrosion an verbautem Holz –

    Auslösende Faktoren, Mechanismen, In: Bautechnik

    77 (2000), S. 478-483