St.Josephs Degree & PG College · The topic for the case study was “Foreign direct Investment – A ladder to growth or an excuse to give up - Flipkart Vs. Walmart”. A handout

1

St.Josephs Degree & PG College

Autonomous - Affiliated to Osmania University

Re-accredited by NAAC with ‘A’ Grade with a CGPA of 3.49

King Koti Road, Hyderabad, Telangana

Department of Commerce

CLUB DI COMMERCIO - MIND ABUT COMPETENCIES

(COMMERCE FEST)

Prepared by: Miss.M.Debora

Assistant Professor, Department of Commerce

Mrs.R.Sreelakshmi Mrs.N.Srilatha

Assistant Professor & Convenor of Fest, Head, Department of Commerce

Department of Commerce

Rev.Fr.Dr.Vincent Arokiadas

Principal

2

Commerce education enables the youth to understand and judge the various trends of trade and

business in the modern world. “Club Di Commercio – Mind Abut Competencies”, Inter

Collegiate Commerce Fest” was organized by Department of Commerce, St. Josephs Degree &

PG College on 8th October 2018. The objective of the fest was to provide a new dimension and

platform for the students to showcase their talents to become more innovative and curious

learners and enable them to compete in the modern business and to pace with the modern world.

INAUGURAL SESSION

The Inaugural session commenced at 10.00 am in Jubilee Hall amid cheer and applause. The

Dignitaries were Prof. S.V.Satyanarayana, Chairman, Board of Studies, Faculty of Commerce,

Osmania University, Chief Guest; Mr.Vijay Kiran Agastya, Associate Vice President, Business

Planning Team, Deloitte, Guest of Honour; Rev.Fr.Dr.Vincent Arokiadas, Principal,

Prof.P.L.Vishweshwara Rao, Director and Mrs. N. Srilatha, Head, Department of Commerce.

The inaugural session began with prayer by college choir “Anna Domini”. The Dignitaries were

welcomed and invited on to the dais for lighting of the lamp by the hosts of the session Manas

Vyas and Nidhi Taunk from B.Com final year Honors.

Mrs. N. Srilatha in her welcome address underlined the objective of organizing commerce fest.

She said that the fest will enhance the innovative and managerial skills of students and make

them aware of how to apply theoretical aspects to real life situation. Prof.P.L.Visweshwara Rao

in his address said that Commerce education plays a very important role in the changing business

world. It is the most important key which leads to success in all sectors of economy. Rev. Fr. Dr.

Vincent Arokiadas, Principal in his presidential address highlighted the relevance of conducting

commerce fest. He said that it enables the students to face the market situation, to adapt

themselves to the present circumstances. Moreover, it helps them to meet the global competition.

Mr.Vijay Kiran Agastya, Guest of Honour shared his happiness to be part of the fest and thanked

Department of Commerce for inviting him. In his address he emphasized on 3 do’s which are

enriching skills, developing the habit of reading and participating in competitions and 3 don’ts

are reduce watching movies, TV, and following the interviews of people who do not any provide

value addition. Prof. S.V.Satyanarayana, Chief Guest informed the students to cultivate the habit

3

of reading business newspapers especially the editorials, watch TV channels like CNBC and

participate in sports activities. He also suggested to incorporate Journalism as a subject to B.Com

Students. He congratulated Department of Commerce for organizing second consecutive

commerce fest. The inaugural session came to an end with vote of thanks by Mrs.R.Sreelakshmi,

senior faculty and coordinator of the fest.

Nidhi Taunk & Manas Vyas – Hosts of Inaugural Session

Prayer Song by College Choir “Anna Domini” Dignitaries on the dais

4

Welcoming of Chief Guest and Guest of Honour

Welcoming of Principal and Director

Lighting of Lamp

5

Address by Mrs.N.Srilatha, HOD Address by Rev.Fr.Dr.Vincent Arokiadas, Principal

Address by Chief Guest Address by Guest of Honour

Felicitation of Chief Guest & Guest of Honour

6

Vote of Thanks by Mrs.N.Sreelakshmi, Convenor of Commerce Fest

As part of Commerce Fest, various competitions were conducted. The following

are the details:

KVIZO (Business Quiz)

No. of Participants: 90

No. of Teams: 30

No. of Colleges Participated: 07

After inaugural session, the first competition “Business Quiz” started at 11.30 am in Chapel Hall.

The objective of the event was to encourage students to explore their knowledge in various

disciplines. It comprised of 2 rounds as follows:

Round 1: The first round was “Preliminary Round” where 20 questions were asked and 6 teams

were shortlisted for second round.

Round 2: The second round was “Final Round” where 30 questions were asked

Winners:

S.No Name of the Student Name of the College Prize

1 Abhishek Chakravorthy Aurora Degree & PG College, Hyderabad I

2 Samarth Manda

3 Preethi Sreevastava

4 Syed Omer St.Josephs Degree & PG College, Hyderabad II

5 Ahmed Rehman

6 Faiyaz Ahmed

7

Students participating in Business Quiz)

Students participating in Business Quiz)

Faculty & Student Coordinators for Business Quiz

8

CASO DE ESTUDIO (Case Study)


No. of Teams: 10


The second Competition “Case Study” started at 11.30 am in room No. G10. The objective of the

event was in depth exploration, encourage research and providing practical solution on current

issues. The topic for the case study was “Foreign direct Investment – A ladder to growth or an

excuse to give up - Flipkart Vs. Walmart”. A handout was provided to all the teams about the

details of the case and 60 minutes time was given for preparation. The teams were asked to

discuss and present the case either in writing or through Power Point Presentation. The

Judgement was based on 3 criteria (a).Content (b).Time (c).Presentation.

Judges:

1. Miss.M.Debora

2. Mrs.K.Radha

3. Mrs.J.N.P.P Anantha Lakshmi

4. Mrs.Harshita Singh

Winners:


1 N.Satya Sai Dutt

Indian Institute of Management & Commerce, Hyderabad

I

2 Pranathi Gadse

3 Bharath Reddy

4 Ali Charaniya St.Josephs Degree & PG College, Hyderabad II

5 E.U.Sayuj

6 Kamal Jain St.Josephs Degree & PG College, Hyderabad III

7 Gaurav Bhandari

9

I Prize II Prize III Prize

Students preparing for Case Study

Students preparing for Case Study

10

Students presenting Case Study

Students participating in Case Study

Judges and Student Coordinators of Case Study

11

DISPUTANDUM (Turncoat Debate)



The third competition of the fest “Turncoat Debate” started at 12.00 pm in room No.102. The

objective of the competition was to improve critical thinking analysis and to enhance

communicative competency among the students. It is an individual event where participant is

given a topic. He/she has to speak for/against the topic. After a tap he/she should change his/her

stance. The Judgement was based on 5 criteria (a).Content (b).Communication (c).Spontaneity

(d) Speech (e).Confidence

Judges:

1. Mrs.O.S.Suguna Sheela

2. Mrs.Ch.Padmaja

Winners:


1 T.A.Mayank Little Flower Degree College, Hyderabad I

2 Shaik Zafar Ahmed St.Josephs Degree & PG College, Hyderabad II

3 Mohit Sharma University Post Graduate College, Osmania University,

Secunderabad

III

Students participating in Turncoat Debate

12



Faculty Coordinators for Turncoat

13

IMPROMTU (JAM)



The fourth competition “JAM” started at 1.00 pm in Chapel Hall. The objective of the

competition was to encourage students to think on their feet and to speak out loud without any

hesitation, repetition or deviation. It comprised of 2 rounds as follows:

Round 1: The first round was to recognize the logo of the company or eminent personalities and

to talk about them for one minute

Round 2: The second round was to talk on the given topic for one minute

Judge:

1. Mrs.Aparna Rajhans, Department of Languages

Winners:


1 Pavan Kumar Little Flower Degree College, Hyderabad I

2 Mayank Little Flower Degree College, Hyderabad II

Students participating in JAM

14




15

Faculty Coordinators and Judge for JAM

Student Coordinators for JAM

PLAN DE NEGOCIOS (Business Plan)



The fifth competition of the fest “Business Plan” started at 1.00 pm in Jubilee Hall. The objective

of the competition was to provide a platform for students to present their ideas and to foster their

entrepreneurial skills. Participants need to prepare their own Business Plan (startups) and present

through Power Point Presentation. Each participant was given 15 minutes time to present his/her

Business Plan. Audience was also given opportunity to participate in Question and Answer

Session.

Judge:

1. P.Vasant Vikas

16

Winners:


1 Manasa

Little Flower Degree College, Hyderabad I

2 Deepak Jain Indian Institute of Management & Commerce, Hyderabad II

Students participating in Business Plan


17


Faculty & Student Coordinators of Business Plan

MERCAO OJBECTIVO (Target Market)


No. of Teams: 09


The sixth Competition “Target Market” started at 2.00 pm in room No. 103. The objective of the

event was to provide students a learning experience where they are challenged to combine their

knowledge, research and creativity in developing marketing strategies. It comprised of 2 rounds

as follows:

Round 1: The first round was “Elimination Round” which consisted of 30 questions on logos,

taglines and brand Ambassadors of different companies. 5 teams qualified for second round

18

Round 2: The second round was “Advertising Round” where the teams were shown a video clip

and were asked to create an advertisement. Judgement was based on two criteria (a). Relevance

(b). Creativity

Judges:

1. Mrs.Aarti Samala

2. Mrs. Harshita Singh

Winners:


1 Alan Dennis David

Indian Institute of Management & Commerce, Hyderabad

I

2 Aditya Chigulla Palli

3 Bhargav Chawda

4 Aarushi Gupta

St. Francis Degree & PG College for Women, Hyderabad

II

5 Disha Mundhra

6 Niharika Agarwal

7 Avani Patel

Students participating in Target Market

Students participating in Target Market

19

Faculty & Student Coordinators of Target Market

PUZZLE DI COMMERCIO (Commerce Puzzle)


No. of Teams: 21


The last Competition “Commerce Puzzle” started at 2.00 pm in room No.G13. The objective of

the event was to test student’s knowledge in Commerce. It comprised of 2 rounds as follows:

Round 1: To find out the word from given set of letters in the square box. The words were

related to Commerce and were given in Vertical, Horizontal and Diagonal format.

Round 2: Commerce Crossword puzzle was given with clues for every word.

Winners:


1 Sushmitha Thakur St.Josephs Degree & PG College,

Hyderabad

I

2 Bhavana Anne

3 Umesh Kumar Little Flower Degree College,

Hyderabad

II

4 Andrew Avinash

5 Sai Shashank St.Josephs Degree & PG College,

Hyderabad

III

6 Nidhi Soni

20

Students participating in Commerce Puzzle



21


Faculty and Student Coordinators of Commerce Puzzle

COMMERCE EXHIBITION

The rationale of the economy is undergoing some stern changes and thus the environment is

challenging for one and all. With the advent of technology the reach to the Target Group is

becoming easier day on day. The resources and its skill set too have seen a sea of change. As part

of Commerce fest, Department of Commerce organized Commerce Exhibition on “Recent

Developments in Commerce” at 10.00 am in Josephs Hall. Students from I, II and III year from

all courses actively participated in the exhibition. 12 models/charts were prepared and displayed

on the topics E-Commerce, ways to overcome income and wealth inequality, Economic Times,

Slice Pay: Future of Credit for Students, Online and Offline Marketing, Cash Flow System,

Artificial Intelligence, IKEA, Cashless India and Banking Structure in India.

22

The Chief Guest and Guest of Honour for the Inaugural ceremony of Commerce Fest Prof.

S.V.Satyanarayana, Chairman, Board of Studies, Faculty of Commerce, Osmania University;

Mr.Vijay Kiran Agastya, Associate Vice President, Business Planning Team, Deloitte along with

Rev. Fr. Dr. Vincent Arokiadas, Principal visited the exhibition and applauded the efforts of the

participants. The exhibits put up by the students were extremely informative and eye catching to

the students and visitors.


No. of Teams: 12

Judges:

1. Mrs.M.Kiran Jyothi, Head, Department of Computer Science

2. Mrs.K.Hari Priya, Department of Computer Science

Winners:

S.No Name of the Student Class Model/Chart Prize

1 Syed Mohammed Hussain

Naqvi

B.Com IA

Banking Structure in India

I

2 Deep Jain

3 Melvin Theakstone

4 Arjun Joshi

5 Mamidi Raghavender Rao B.Com IIID Cash Flow System II

6 Mohd Omer Farooq

7 Wasif Mohd Khan

23

I Prize Winners II Prize Winners

Participants explaining to Judges

Participants displaying Models

24

Participants displaying Models

VALEDICTORY CEREMONY

The Valedictory Ceremony of “Club Di Commercio - Mind Abut Competencies”, Inter

Collegiate Commerce Fest was held at 5.00 pm in Jublilee Hall. The Dignitaries were Mrs.

Deepti Reddy, IRS, Deputy Commissioner, NACIN, Hyderabad, Chief Guest; Mr.Srinivasan

Chittaranjan, Executive Vice President, KMV Group, Guest of Honour; Mr.Shujath Bin Ali, CS,

LLM, Senior Director, Parexel International India, Guest of Honour; Rev.Fr.Dr. Vincent

Arokiadas, Principal; Mrs.N.Srilatha, Head, Department of Commerce. The hosts of the session

Simran from B.Com final year Professionals and Mohammed Wajiuddin from B.Com second

year (IFA) welcomed the guests and students for the valedictory ceremony. It began with a

prayer song by college choir “Anna Domini”. Mrs.R.Sreelakshmi, Convenor of Commerce Fest

presented the rappoteur’s report. Rev.Fr.Dr. Vincent Arokiadas, Principal congratulated

Department of Commerce for successfully organizing the fest and also all the students who

participated in the fest.

Mrs. Deepti Reddy, Chief Guest in her address informed the students to spread positiveness and

be joyful. She said that life is bunch of one’s experiences and every action of a person is

manifestation of his/her experiences and emotions. She told them to take calculated risk and be

responsible for decisions taken and also learn from the mistakes committed to bounce back in

life. She also said to take informed choices, be receptive, learn to say sorry whenever required

for saving a relationship which will give you more respect and helps to grow as a person. She

stated that having Patience and patiently believing in something and working towards it will give

25

success. She advised students not to attach happiness to anything or any person, love yourself

and gift yourself as you are your own best friend and also suggested to spend quality time with

family and friends. Mr. Shujath Ali, Guest of Honour shared his personal experience as a student

and said to visualize the subjects instead of thinking as a burden and things becomes easy when

one love doing things. He mentioned that having a professional qualification will help in this

modern world. He said that current generation has a challenge of distractions which needs to be

overcome. He concluded by saying that have passion and goal for life. Mr.Srinivasan, Guest of

Honour said that events like commerce fest will improve interaction, communication and

leadership qualities. He said that as technology is changing, either you disrupt or get disrupted,

be creative to stand in the market and be a lifelong learner. He concluded with a statement “If

god is a creator then you must be co-creator”.

Winners of various competitions were awarded with mementos and certificates by the

Dignitaries. The ceremony came to an end with singing of National Anthem. The fest witnessed

participation of around 300 students from 13 colleges. The Commerce fest was successful in

obtaining rave reviews from the Dignitaries and participants.

Simran and Mohammed Wajiuddin – Hosts of Valedictory Ceremony

26

Prayer Song by College Choir “Anna Domini”

Welcoming of Chief Guest and Guests of Honor

Rappoteur’s report by Convenor of Fest Dignitaries on the dais

27

Introduction of Chief Guest and Guests of Honour

Address by Principal Address by Chief Guest

Address by Guests of Honour

28

Faculty & Students

Head, Department of Commerce Controller of Examinations

Winners awarded with Mementos and Certificates

29




30




31

Overall Championship – Little Flower Degree College

Felicitation of Chief Guest & Guest of Honour

Singing of National Anthem

32

LIST OF COLLEGES PARTICIPATED

1. Indian Institute of Management & Commerce, Khairatabad, Hyderabad

2. Little Flower Degree College, Uppal, Hyderabad

3. Aurora Degree & PG College, Chikkadpally, Hyderabad

4. Badruka College of Commerce and Arts, Kachiguda, Hyderabad

5. St.Anns Degree & PG College for Women, Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad

6. St.Francis College for Women, Begumpet, Hyderabad

7. Sarojini Naidu Vanitha Maha Vidyalya College, Nampally, Hyderabad

8. Pragathi Mahavidyalaya, Koti, Hyderabad

9. Cognizant College of Commerce & Science, Ameerpet, Hyderabad

10. Raja Bahadur Venkata Rama Reddy Women's College, Narayanguda, Hyderabad

11. University Post Graduate College, Osmania University, Secunderabad

12. Madina Degree College, Hyderabad

13. St.Josephs Degree & PG College, King Koti, Hyderabad

FACULTY COORDINATORS FOR COMMERCE FEST

S.No Name of the Event Name of the Faculty

1 Convenor of Commerce Fest Mrs.R.Sreelakshmi

2 Registration Mrs.Ritika Waghray

Mrs. G.Savitha

Mrs. Sarika Verma

3 Hospitality Miss. Mhelsea Mona.M

4 Kvizo (Business Quiz)

Mrs. Shanti Kiran

Mr. T.Krishna

5 Caso De Estudio (Case Study)

Mrs. K.Radha

Mrs.J.N.P.P Anantha Lakshmi

6 Disputandum (Turncoat Debate)

Mrs. O.S.Suguna Sheela

Mrs. Ch.Padmaja

7 Impromtu (JAM)

Mr.S.Bhanu Prakash Sharma

Miss. Rafat Ahmedi

8 Plan De Negocios (Business Plan) Mr.P.Vasant Vikas

9 Mercado Ojbectivo (Target Market)

Mrs. Aarti Samala

Mrs. Harshita Singh

10 Puzzle Di Commercio (Commerce Puzzle) Mrs. Preethi Rathi

33

Miss. P.Namratha

11 Commerce Exhibition Mrs. Mary Vinaya Sheela

Mrs. Bh.Srivatsala

12 Momentos, Prizes and Certificates Mrs. Sumitra Pujari

Mrs.Y.Geethanjali

13 Preparing Report on Commerce Fest Miss. M.Debora

STUDENT CORE COMMITTEE MEMBERS FOR COMMERCE FEST

S.No Name of the Student Class

1 Nidhi Taunk – Student Coordinator B.Com III Honors

2 Mohammed Jalaluddin - Student Coordinator B.Com III Computers

3 B.Aaron Praful Kiran B.Com Generals

4 Mahima Agarwal B.Com Generals

5 Sourabh Sharma B.Com III Computers

6 Simran B.Com III Professionals

7 Mohammed Farhan B.Com III (IFA)

STUDENT COORDINATORS FOR EVENTS

S.No Name of the Event Name of the Student Class

1 Registration Varunika Khandelwal B.Com IIIP

Priyanka Thakur B.Com IIIP

Nikhil Jain B.Com IIH

Mohit Sharma B.Com IIH

2 Hospitality Sonu Reddy B.Com IC

3

Kvizo (Business Quiz)

Mohammed Farhan B.Com III (IF&A)

C.Sushmitha B.Com III (IF&A)

Nathaniel Anthony B.Com III (IF&A)

Syed Naif Ali B.Com III (IF&A)

Apoorv Chitgopekar B.Com II(IF&A)

4 Caso De Estudio (Case Study)

Ankita Saxena B.Com IIIH

Nikita Shukla B.Com IIIH

Nidhi Taunk B.Com IIIH

Syed Naif Ali B.Com III (IF&A)

Manasa Gracy Benjamin B.Com IIH

Radhika Pandey B.Com IIH

5 Disputandum (Turncoat Debate) B.Aaron Praful Kiran B.Com IIIB

34

Simran B.Com IIIP

V.Aakansha B.Com IIH

6 Impromtu (JAM)

Mohammed Wajiuddin B.Com II(IF&A)

Syed Naser Mahmood B.Com II(IF&A)

B.Aaron Praful Kiran B.Com IIIB

7 Plan De Negocios (Business Plan) Abishek Asthana B.Com IIH

V.Enoch Augustine Raj B.Com IIH

Dilshad Raza B.Com IIH

8 Mercado Ojbectivo (Target Market) Manas Vyas B.Com IIIH

Simran B.Com IIIP

Anukesh Baldwa B.Com IIIH

9 Puzzle Di Commercio (Commerce Puzzle)


Murtuza Samdani B.Com IIIH

Rashmitha Thakur B.Com IIIH

Neha Heda B.Com II(IF&A)

Saloni Bhandari B.Com II(IF&A)

10 Commerce Exhibition A.Sahithi B.Com IIIC

Mayank Agarwal B.Com IIIH

Simran B.Com IIIP

C.Yashwanth Yadav B.Com IIIC

K.Sai Kumar B.Com IIIC

G.Sai Krishna Reddy B.Com IIIC

11 Certificate Writing & Prize Distribution Rashmitha Thakur B.Com IIIH


Mohammed Jalaluddin B.Com IIID

Sourab Sharma B.Com IIIC

Riya Baldwa B.Com IIIH

K.Rohitha B.Com IIID

Ankitha Jain B.Com IIID

Renuka Srija Mukka B.Com IIID

Kamal Bohra B.Com III(IF&A)

12 Photographs Kaipa Pankaj Mohan B.Com IIID

Sameer Khan B.Com IIID

Varun Soni B.Com IIC

Taniya K.Dodwani B.Com II(IT)

35

BHOJ-E-JASHN (FOOD FEST)

Entrepreneurship Development Cell of the College organized “Bhoj-e-Jashn – Food Fest” on 8th

October 2018 with a motive to explore entrepreneurial skills of students. It gives them huge

exposure, a deep insight of doing big scale events and is also a learning experience. They can

gain creative and marketing skills which can help them when they graduate and organize events

themselves. The Food Fest was inaugurated by Rev.Fr.Dr. Vincent Arokiadas, Principal at 11.00

am in the college premises. An awesome ambience was created in the campus as it was

beautifully decorated with colourful ribbons.

There was an overwhelming response from 61 students as they put up 27 stalls with 50 mouth

watering delicacies namely Nacho Bhel, Mocktails, Murku Sandwich, Masala Kachori, Cold

Coffee, Onion and Cheese Rings, Pani Puri, Grill Sandwich, Tender Coconut Lollipop, Ice

Creams, Chocolate Fountain, Veg Biryani, Creamy Fruit Salad, Veg Rolls, Dosa, Chat Items,

Kheer, Red Pasta, Oreo Truffle, Oreo Shot, Cup Cakes and Brownies, Milk Shakes, Spaghetti,

Pan Shot etc. Food outlets with a variety of mouthwatering delicious dishes tempted and

attracted each and everyone alike. Participants were judged under different categories such as

(a).Taste (b). Innovation (c). Marketing Strategy (d). Presentation. Rev.Fr. Dr.Vincent Arokia

Das, Principal, distributed prizes to the winners. He lauded the efforts of the students and was

highly appreciative of them. He congratulated the students for their active participation and

commendable presentation. Students were the stars of the event, doing it all, from

conceptualization to execution. The students did an amazing job in all aspects of preparation and

implementation. Relishing and sharing the food ensured that happiness reigned.

Judges

1. Mrs. Ritika Waghray

2. Mrs.G.Savitha

Winners List

S.No Name of the Student Class Awarded for Name of the Cuisine

1 Bharat Reddy

B.Sc (MSC’s) III

year

Best Taste

Kheer and Creamy Fruit

Salad Mohammed Hyder Ali

G.Prashanth

A.Jyoshna Taruna BA(MCJ) II year

2 Farwa Basith

36

Priyanka Jai Kumar

Bhagchandani

B.Com IP Best Innovation Mock Tail and Pan Shot

3 Divesh Kumar Agarwal

B.Com I (IT)

Best Marketing Strategy

Nacho Bhel Kriya Jain

B.Nikitha

Anamika Das

4 Sanjana Goel B.Com I(IT)

Best Presentation

Bread Pizza Ravani Shama Nizar Ali

Alizar Nizar Dosani

Azmeena Kareem Bhimani BA(JPE) I year

Faculty Coordinators

1. Miss.M.Prashanthi, Convenor

2. Mrs.J.N.P.P. Anantha Lakshmi

3. Mrs.Shanti Kiran

4. Mrs.Padmasri

Student Coordinators

S.No Name of the Student Class

1 Ujwal Kumar Dughar B.Com IIID

2 Pranay Jhawar B.Com IIID

3 Tanmai Atul Kamdar B.Com IIID

4 Piyush Agarwal B.Sc (MEC’s) III year

5 Emmanuel Patrick B.Com IIC

Inauguration of Food Fest

37

Address by Principal, Rev.Fr.Dr.Vincent Arokiadas

Students at Stalls

Students at Stalls

38

Students at Stalls

Students at Stalls

Declaration of Winners

39

Prize Winners

Prize Winners

Students and Faculty at Food Fest

40

Documents

St.Josephs Degree & PG College · The topic for the case study was “Foreign direct Investment – A ladder to growth or an excuse to give up - Flipkart Vs. Walmart”. A handout