31
LegalCrystal - Indian Law Search Engine - www.legalcrystal.com State of Bombay Vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. Court :Supreme Citations :AIR1951SC9! "1951#5$B%&'R()*! +1951,*SCR51 Jud-e : &uer/ea0! &ehr Chand &aha/an0! atan/a2i Sastri0! 3ass and! Saiyid 4aa2 A2i0 JJ 3e6ided %n :195)71*7*) A6ts :Code of Ci8i2 ro6edure "CC#0 19) 7 Se6tions 9 Appe22ant :State of Bombay Respondent : Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. Jud-ement: 4a2 A2i0 J. 1. I ha8e read the /ud-ment prepared by my brother0 &aha/an J.0 and -enera22y a-ree ith his 6on62usions and reasonin-s0 but0 ha8in- re-ard to the importan6e of the points raised0 I ish to add a short /ud-ment of my on. *. ;here are rea22y three <uestions to be de6ided in this appea20 and they are as fo22os : "1# =hether the Bombay City Ci8i2 Court A6t0 19( "A6t >' of 19(#0 is u2tra 8ires the 'e-is2ature of the State of Bombay! "*# =hether in any e8ent Se6tion ( of the abo8e A6t is u2tra 8ires the State 'e-is2ature! and "$# =hether the Bombay ?i-h Court has /urisdi6tion to try the suit. $. ;he first and the third <uestions ha8e been ansered by the ?i-h Court in fa8our of the appe22ant0 and the se6ond <uestion has been ansered in fa8our of the respondents. In this Court0 the appe22ant atta6ed the /ud-ment of the ?i-h Court in so far as it 6on6erns the se6ond <uestion0 hereas the first respondent atta6ed it in so far as it 6on6erns the first and the third <uestions. (. ;he Bombay City Ci8i2 Court A6t purports to 6reate an additiona2 6i8i2 6ourt for @reater Bombay ha8in- /urisdi6tion to try0 re6ei8e and dispose of a22 suits and other pro6eedin-s of a 6i8i2 nature not e6eedin- a 6ertain 8a2ue0 sub/e6t to 6ertain e6eptions hi6h need not be referred to here. It as 6ontended on beha2f of the respondents that the A6t is u2tra 8ires the 'e-is2ature of the State of Bombay0 be6ause it 6onfers /urisdi6tion on the ne 6ourt not on2y in respe6t of matters hi6h the ro8in6ia2 'e-is2ature is 6ompetent to 2e-is2ate upon under 'ist II of the th S6hedu2e to the @o8ernment of India A6t0 19$50 but a2so in re-ard to matters in respe6t of hi6h on2y the Centra2 or 4edera2 'e-is2ature 6an 2e-is2ate under 'ist I "su6h as0 for instan6e0 promissory notes0 hi6h is one of the sub/e6ts mentioned in entry * of 'ist I#. ;o understand this ar-ument0 it is ne6essary to refer to entry 5$ of 'ist I0 entries 1 and * of 'ist II and a2so entry 15 of 'ist III . ;hese entries run as fo22os :7 5. ntry 5$0 'ist I :7 DJurisdi6tion and poers of a22 6ourts e6ept the 4edera2 Court0 ith respe6t to any of the matters in this 'ist......D

State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 1/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 2/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 3/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 4/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 5/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 6/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 7/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 8/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 9/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 10/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 11/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 12/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 13/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 14/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 15/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 16/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 17/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 18/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 19/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 20/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 21/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 22/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 23/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 24/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 25/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 26/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 27/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 28/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 29/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 30/31

8/14/2019 State of Bombay vs. Narothamdas Jethabai and Anr. '

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/state-of-bombay-vs-narothamdas-jethabai-and-anr- 31/31