Star revue march 2015

SOUTH BROOKLYN’S COMMUNITY NEWSPAPER

The Red Hook StarªRevue

MARCH 2015 FREE

A New Vision for Brooklyn Bridge Parkby George Fiala

In case you haven’t noticed, a wa-terfront park has been taking shape just north of the Red Hook Con-tainerport. Brooklyn Bridge Park,

conceived of in the 1980’s and 90’s, and built this century, has not been without controversy.

For much of Brooklyn’s history, the Fulton Ferry piers were a busy hub for loading and unloading cargo ships. By the early 1980’s, that activity had for the most part moved to New Jersey and the Port Authority (PA) together with NYC planned to turn over Piers 1-6 to the private sector for commercial and residential development.

In 1992, the PA, then under the leader-ship of Stanley Brezenoff, was about to sell the piers to developers. It was only community pressure and intervention from the governor’s office that prevent-ed the sale in favor of a park plan that the neighborhood preferred.

Fast forward 23 years and a park has ap-peared, but the housing issue has not gone away. Pierhouses, a project of the Toll Brothers, is currently rising at the north end of the park and already sell-ing some of the most expensive luxury condos in the city. One Brooklyn Bridge Park, a renovation of the former Jehovah’s Witness printing plant, fea-tures condos for as much as $6 million.

Next to One Brooklyn Bridge, RFP’s have been submitted by developers eager to build two additional towers, one of them reaching 37 stories. These towers would also house luxury condo’s, and only a judge’s temporary restraining order is pre-

venting construction from beginning.

On March 3rd, at a meeting of the Brooklyn Bridge Park Community Ad-visory Council, member Roy Sloane presented an alternative vision for Pier 6. His vision is based upon what, in

economics, is called “opportunity cost.” The term refers to what is lost by mak-ing one choice as opposed to another. According to Wikipedia, opportunity cost plays a crucial part in ensuring that scarce resources are used efficiently and are not restricted to financial costs: they also include lost time, pleasure or any other benefit that provides utility.

A grand park entranceAccording to Sloane, his plan would cre-ate a much grander entrance to the park, creating as much as three additional acres of parkland. There is a strong financial reason to not building now as well. Cur-rent trends indicate that the land will be worth much more in decades to come. According to some Wall Street financial analysts, the park has a sufficiently fund-ing base with the current developments to sustain the park and pier for the next 50 years. Holding on to the property for now is a more prudent choice.

Sloane’s presentation was well received. The hope is that it could get a hearing at the next board meeting of the Brooklyn Bridge Park Development Corporation (BBPDC).

Community Board Two divestsIn other business, CAC co-chair Lucy Koteen read aloud a letter to the CAC from the new Community Board 2 (CB 2) chairperson Shirley McCrae.

According to the CAC charter, CB2 is responsible for appointing a co-chair. McCrae’s letter informed the group that CB 2 will no longer do so. It said that “the discourse at and resultant ac-tions of the CAC often appear to be adversarial to the Brooklyn Bridge Park Corporation… it creates a dysfunction-al dynamic that I no longer want the community board to be a party to.”

As the CAC is meant to serve as a con-duit for the community to communicate with the park corporation, similar to the Gowanus Canal Community Advi-sory Group, CAC members were left to wonder who CB2 is meant to represent.

The third major topic discussed at this meeting was the rescinding of a stop-work order given to the Pier House. Views of the Brooklyn Bridge are very important to residents of Brooklyn Heights, especially those who live near or frequent the Brooklyn Promenade. The current not yet completed building

already blocks views.

The BBPDC had always assured the Brooklyn Heights Association that these views would not be disturbed by any construction. Steve Guterman, whose group “Save the View” has col-lected over 5,000 signatures protest-ing the height of the hotel, explained the ins and outs of measuring building height, and encouraged the community, and the CAC, to keep pressure on Toll Brothers to respect the neighborhood’s wishes.

The CAC has an impressive roster, in-

cluding representatives from CB 6, The Atlantic Ave. Betterment Associa-tion, Cobble Hill Association, Dumbo Neighborhood Association, Brooklyn Heights Association, Brooklyn Bridge Park Conservancy and the Brooklyn Bridge Park Defense Fund. At-large members include Anthony Manheim, who has been an active park advocate since the 1980’s.

Yet despite this impressive community representation, the CAC bemoaned the fact that they have trouble being heard by BBBPDC and now CB 2.

Major points of the Alternate Plan:• A major entrance on Atlantic Avenue would help unlock the

economic potential of the Avenue;

• It would bring the park 175 feet closer to the residents;

• It would be a major relief to Brooklyn Heights to have the primary ingress/egress be on a major commercial street and not through residential streets;

• It will eliminate 2,3 or even more lanes of dangerous traffic that park goers must cross;

• The upland of Pier 6 is one of the very few places where trees can be grown in the earth so that they can grow large enough to provide much needed shade;

• It would be more financially prudent to reserve selling this land for as long as possible.

The alternate plan that adds parkland. A version of the current plan.

Long time community leader Roy Sloane making his presentation.(photo by Fiala)

ALSO IN THIS ISSUE:

Page 2 Red Hook Star-Revue www.RedHookStar.com Christmas 2014

The Red Hook StarªRevue

proudly introduces our new website

www.Star-Revue.comFor Editorial, Advertising and Help Wanted Inquiries,

email [email protected], or call 718 624-5568

The Star-Revue is published by Kimberly G. Price & George Fiala

RELIGIOUS SERVICESCATHOLICVisitation Church98 Richards St, (718) 624-1572. Office open Mon-Thursday9 am - 3 pm. Saturday mass 5 pm; Spanish mass at 7 pm. Sunday 10 am English, 12:30 pm Spanish. Community Prayer Tuesday and Thursday, 8 pm. Youth Group Meetings on Friday, 4:30 - 6 pm. Baptisms are held every other month. Please call to arranged for baptisms, communions and weddings. We will visit the sick upon notification.

Saint Paul and Saint Agnes Parish St. Paul’s Church - Rectory & Church Office 234 Congress Street (718) 624-3425 Hours: M - F 830am-12 St. Agnes Church Office 433 Sackett Street, 718-625-1717 Hours: M-F 1pm-430pm Email:[email protected] St. Agnes: Saturday 5pm Vigil Mass Sunday 9 am (English), 11:30am (Spanish) St. Paul’s: Saturday 5pm Vigil Mass Sun-day 8 am & 9:30am (English); 11am (Spanish) Monday & Tuesday 8:30am (St. Paul’s) Wednesday & Thursday 8:30am (St. Agnes) Saturday 8am (St. Paul’s) http://stpaul-stagnes.org/

Sacred Hearts of Jesus and Mary - Saint Stephen Roman Catholic Church125 Summit Street at Hicks Street [email protected] Saturday Vigil Mass 5:30pm Sunday Masses: 10am & 11:45am (Italian/English) Weekdays Masses: Tuesday Through Saturday 8:30am Confessions: Saturdays 4:45pm and by appointment. Baptisms: Every Third Sunday At 1pm. Please call the rectory one month before to make arrangements. Sick Calls: Please call the rectory to arrange for the sacrament of anoint-ing whenever anyone is seriously ill. Marriages: Please call the rectory at least 6 months ahead for an appointment with a priest http://www.sacredhearts-ststephen.com

St. Paul’s Carroll Street 199 Carroll Street Parish Office: 718-625-4126 Sunday Mass at 10 am Weekday Morn-ing Prayer - Mon.-Thurs. at 7:30 am Weekday masses as announced Holy Days as an-nounced (please see the Calendar) Church open for prayer Tues. 6-8pm & Sat. 2-4pm http://stpaulscarrollst.weebly.com/

JewishKane Street Synagogue 236 Kane Street, (near Tompkins Place) 718 875-1550 http://kanestreet.org/ August 29 - 30, Shabbat Shoftim Candle Lighting 7:14 PM Shabbat ends 8:17 PMFriday night services, 6:00 PM Shabbat morning services, 9:15 AM Sunday Morning Services 9:00 AM

Congregation B’nai Avraham/Chabad of Brooklyn Heights117 Remsen St., 718 596 4840 x18 www.bnaiavraham.com, www.heightschabad.com Morning Services: Sunday: 8:45am Monday - Friday: 7:45am Holidays (during the week): 8:45am Saturday: 9:45am Evening Services: Sunday: Shabbat candle lighting time Monday - Thursday: 9:00pm Friday: Winter: 5 minutes before Shabbat candle lighting time Summer: 7:30pm Saturday: Shabbat candle lighting time

If your religious institution isn’t listed here, let us know by emailing [email protected] Thanks!

Community Telephone Numbers:Red Hook Councilman Carlos Menchaca ................. 718 439-9012Red Hook Assemblyman Felix Ortiz ..........................718-492-6334Red Hook State Senator Velmanette Montgomery 718-643-6140Gowanus Councilman Brad Lander ........................... 718 499-1090Park Slope Councilman Steve Levin .......................... 718 875-5200CB6 District Manager Craig Hammerman .............. 718 643-3027

76th Police Precinct, 191 Union StreetMain phone .................................................................718-834-3211Community Affairs ..................................................... 718 834-3207Traffic Safety ............................................................... 718 834-3226

Eileen Dugan Senior Center, 380 Court Street ....... 718 596-1956Miccio Community Center, 110 East 9th Street ..... 718 243-1528 Red Hook East Dev. Office, 62 Mill St. ....................... 718 852-6771Red Hook West Dev. Office, 55 Dwight St. ............... 718 522-3880Brownstone Republicans [email protected]

NYCHA Satellite Police Precinct, 80 Dwight StreetMain Phone ............................................................... (718) 265-7300Community Affairs ................................................... (718) 265-7313Domestic Violence ................................................... (718) 265-7310

Happenings, etc.

WEDNESDAY, MARCH 11Ridgewood Savings Bank Small Business Financial Workshop from 5-7 pm. Benefits, merchant services, banking answers and solutions. 244 Court StreetNYC Department of Environmental Protection discusses flooding, sewage backups, water bills, noise and air and water concerns at 6 pm. Regis-tration begins at 5:30 pm at Brooklyn Borough Hall. Community Room, 209 Joralemon StreetReStore Red Hook invites small business neighbors for cocktails at Ate-lier Roquette at 7 pm. 63 Commerce Street

FRIDAY, MARCH 13Pioneer Works’ group exhibition Under Construction - New Positions in American Photography opening reception from 6-10 pm. 159 Pioneer

SATURDAY, MARCH 14Making Brooklyn Bloom annual conference at Brooklyn Botanic Garden from 10 am-4 pm. Keynote speech and workshop registration begins at 10 am. Advance registration not required. FREE. 150 Eastern Parkway

SUNDAY, MARCH 15Red Hook Pilates Open House from 1-3 pm. Visit the studio, watch dem-os and try out the new Balanced Body Reformer. 414 Van Brunt StreetBrooklyn’s Annual Saint Patrick’s Day Parade at 1 pm. Parade Route: Pros-pect Park West > down 15th Street to 7th Avenue > To Garfield Place > Up Garfield Place to Prospect Park West > Along Prospect Park West to 15th Street. A second parade takes place at Rocky Sullivans at 7 pm following a day of Irish cultural activities.Extreme Kids and Crew’s ALL Abilities Bike Clinic in collaboration with NYC Parks Department from 10 am-1 pm at the Red Hook Rec Center. Each family must bring a bike and a helmet. 155 Bay Street

THURSDAY, MARCH 19Carroll Gardens Association’s Small Business Series workshop Tax Breaks for your Business from 5:30-7:30 pm. RSVP to (718) 243-9301. FREE. 201 Columbia Street. The Gowanus Dredgers annual celebration of programs in Gowanus, Red Hook, Long Island City, Staten Island and the Riverbank State Park Pool. The Dredgers are also looking for carpenters, welders and ma-sons. The Roof of Whole Foods Market from 7-9 pm. 3rd Avenue and 3rd Street.

FRIDAY, MARCH 20Fundraiser of Brooklyn Bridge Rotary Club, in conjunction with Operation Wellness Warrior at McMahon’s Public House from 6:30-9:30 pm. 39 5th Avenue

SATURDAY, MARCH 21Clean & Green: Spring Clean, Plant Propagation Workshop, & Green Roof Rehab at the Gowanus Canal Conservancy’s Nursery and Compost Site, propagate our Spring stock for our nursery, and replenish sedums on our green roof. 11 am-2 pm, 2nd Ave at 5th Street.

PS 15 PTA IS CELEBRATING OUR COMMUNITY SCHOOL!

PS 15 PATRICK F. DALY MAGNET SCHOOL OF THE ARTS

**VENDORS WANTED** **FOOD VENDORS WANTED**Please come out join the

PS 15 PTA SPRING FLEA ON SATURDAY MAY 2ND, 2015 10 AM TO 5 PM

(RAIN DATE MAY 9TH) at the large playground.

Application’s can be requested at:EMAIL: [email protected]

Or 718-330-9280 ext #1251

All monies will go directly to support PTA sponsored school programs at PS 15.

PLEASE SUBMIT ALL APPLICATIONS BY MARCH 31

Red Hook Star-Revue www.star-revue.com March 2015, Page 3

RED HOOKPIZZA RISTORANTE

MARK’S

326 Van Brunt Street (bet. Pioneer & King) Open daily 10 am to 11 pm, Sundays 11 am - 10 pm. Free Delivery Available

(718) 624-0690 (718)624-1628 Fax (718)624-2145

All Credit Cards Accepted ($10 min)

EVERYBODY IN RED HOOK GOES TO

Superfund project on scheduleby George Fiala

Celebrate St. Patrick’s Day with our special green spinach pizza!

(byob & enjoy our comfy dining room)

It’s been a rough winter for meet-ings, as the weather has cancelled quite a few, including the January meeting of the Gowanus Com-

munity Advisory Group (CAG). The CAG serves as a conduit between the community and the EPA and was set up to monitor the Superfund cleanup of the Gowanus Canal.

The January meeting was held February 10 and featured an update of the project from Chief Engineer Christos Tsiamis. The group hadn’t met since November, so there was a lot to tell.

“We are exactly where we want to be - on schedule with the work,” Tsiamis told the audience of CAG members and guests which included representa-tives from public utilities and elected officials.

“Crews are already working in the ca-nal,” continued Tsiamis. He explained that the current work involves test-ing various substrates to help decide the composition of the surface that will cover the bottom of the canal af-ter dredging. That cover will prevent toxic chemicals from leaching upwards and re-contaminate the cleaned water. Tidal currents are also being mapped.

He complimented National Grid as well as local businesses that abut the canal for their cooperation.

Ferrara Brothers, the concrete company that still operates on the Public Place sight, agreed to clear off part of their workspace to accommodate staging op-erations of the testers. A floating dock will be installed which will be used by barges bringing materials.

Tsiamis even brought some good news relating to NYC. The city has been or-dered to build two large holding tanks that will prevent sewage from be-ing flushed into the canal during rain events, as is done currently. Originally, the city was supposed to proved the EPA with the two locations last sum-mer - they now promise to make their final selection by the end of June.

The city has been reticent at first due to the expense and then because of community concerns about having to close Double D park at Degraw Street to place one of the tanks there. Tsiamis said that at recent talks with a whole roomful of city bureaucrats he was told that the decision could come before the end of June. When pressed by someone in the audience, he admitted that it could come a week before - he had no idea, actually.

He explained that when the dredging work finally begins, it will start at the

7th Street Basin and work south. For now, the testing work is being done at the 4th Street Basin, close to Whole Foods. Tsiamis said that was an ideal place to try out the techniques that will be used, as it is far enough from any resi-dences so as not to disturb anyone.

Payment negotiationsBrian Carr, the legal expert on the EPA team, spoke of the money situation. The cost of the cleanup, estimated to be about $500 million, is borne by what are called Potentially Responsible Par-ties (PRPs). Many like to think that taxpayer money is spent by the EPA to clean up toxic sites, but this is un-true. Lawyers for all the PRP’s, which include the City of NY and National Grid, have been haggling over who will pay what - Carr said that he expects ev-erything to be settled by September. A PRP that some may remember is Chem-tura, who operated plants at the end of Court Street. In addition to polluting the Gowanus, the chemical company was also found liable for contaminating the Red Hook ballfields with PCB’s and other toxins.

At the end of the meeting, the CAG voted to admit five new members - all of whom reside in nearby Gowanus Public Housing.

Bridging Gowanus recapThe regular February meeting was held on the 24th. Brad Lander, freshly back from a City Council excursion to Is-rael, presented results from his Bridging Gowanus project.

Bridging Gowanus was a series of pub-lic meetings that followed a stakeholder meeting in which the future of Gowa-nus was discussed. In some ways it re-sembles a 197A plan, except instead of being sponsored by a community board, it is a politically driven plan, shepherd-ed by Pratt Institute.

The work on the plan is complete, and available for viewing at www.bridging-gowanus.com. Lander often speaks of trade-offs - meaning that for the com-munity to ‘get’ something, it might have to give up something.

Some CAG members were critical of the plan. It acknowledges and seems not to challenge new residential devel-opments, saying: “Where new housing is allowed in areas currently zoned for manufacturing, or where increased den-sity might be allowed, developers should be required to include affordable units.”

CAG member Bette Stoltz wondered how existing infrastructure could sup-port an increased population. Lander reminded all that there is currently a

public comment period, that being the appropriate place to air complaints.

Following Lander was John Vetter, an EPA consultant whose specialty is ar-cheology and historic preservation. He came seeking volunteers to serve on a consulting group under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.

That section mandates the Federal Gov-ernment to be mindful of historically significant properties when performing things such as Superfund cleanups or building a federal building.

Vetter cited the bulkheads as a major example of Gowanus Canal history. Some bulkheads go back to the 1850’s, and are historically significant.

The Consulting Party Group would ensure that all bulkheads would be well documented, especially in cases where they will need to be replaced.

The Gowanus CAG meets monthly on the fourth Tuesday of each month. Meetings are usually held at St. Mary’s Star of the Sea, 41 First Street.

Chief Engineer Christos Tsiamis makes a graphic point at the February 10th meeting.

City Councilman Brad Lander recaps the results of the Bridging Gowanus plan before a rapt CAG audience. (photos by George Fiala)

Page 4 Red Hook Star-Revue www.star-revue.com March 2015

A topic that the short-lived Red Hook Coalition attempted to tackle a few years ago was the

many vacant lots that dot Red Hook. As the real estate market has begun to take care of that problem itself, a new problem has taken its place - pile driv-ing.

Since Red Hook is now in a FEMA des-ignated flood zone, most new structures are designed to be elevated - meaning they will be built up and supported by piles driven into the earth. Because of the soil conditions, even houses that won’t be elevated may still use piles for support.

Building is proceeding apace, and ac-cording to Civic Association president John McGettrick, pile driving may like-ly take place at the 23 new townhouses being built on Verona at Van Brunt; 87 Wolcott Street, 15 Luquer Street, 422 Van Brunt and 185 Richards/61 Dike-man.

There are at least two hazards when piles are driven. The driving creates strong vibrations which can damage adjacent buildings. Another side ef-fect is the movement of the earth, es-pecially in soft soil/clay areas, of which Red Hook is one. Soil displacement can undermine neighboring foundations. Many Red Hook homes, being old and having suffered flood damage, are al-ready on shaky ground - more shaking is not helpful.

With all this in mind, McGettrick in-vited two gentlemen from the NYC Buildings Department who were fea-tured at the latest Civic Association meeting on March 3 in the PS 15 audi-torium. Patrick Wehle, Community Af-fairs Director, Department of Buildings [DOB]. This is a position formerly held by Eddie Bautista. He was accompanied by Ben Colombo, from the DOB Com-munity Affairs, who mostly sat next to

Wehle and listened.

Wehle began with a long statement about pile driving. Reading from his iPad, he started by saying that pile driv-ing is an ‘as of right’ activity - meaning that no special permission is required from the Board of Standards and Ap-peals or from City Planning.

He went on to describe two types of pile driving - pounding and auguring. Pounding causes more vibrations but is cheaper than auguring. Auguring refers to piles that are screwed in the ground. Other types of piling include helical and wood piles.

He explained that the building de-partment is concerned with safety, es-

Pile Driving in Red Hook an increasing concernby George Fiala

pecially that of adjacent buildings. A contractor planning to drive piles must notify neighbors ten days in advance, and must work only from 8 am - 6 pm. Driving can be noisy, and a noise miti-gation plan is supposed to be filed with DOB.

Stop work orders can be issued when vi-brations exceed a certain threshold.

Many important questions came up afterwards, which the two gentlemen promised to field. They did their best, but often had no answer, and prom-ised to get back to people following the meeting.

One very interesting case was not about actual pile driving, but rather a metal stamping machine that has been driv-

ing Veronica Vanaria and her neighbors crazy. Vanaria, who has had to com-pletely rebuild her Van Brunt Street home after Sandy, claims that vibra-tions from nearby Gotham Metalworks are both dangerous and greatly impinge on her quality of life.

She has been rebuffed in attempts at dealing with the proprietors, and calls to 311 have not yielded any relief. Wehle jotted the information down and prom-ised to look into it. After the meeting, McGettrick spoke to her as well and said he would put the Civic Association behind her complaint.

Earlier this year, an environmental complaint against a neighborhood roof-

“However, many Red Hook

homeowners are not

wealthy, and are unable

and unwilling to incur a

hefty legal bill.”

er whose smell of burning tar was plagu-ing the neighborhood was dealt with on a community basis, and a solution was found that satisified both the business and its neighbors.

Sue Amendola complained about de-molition taking place on Sullivan Street. She claimed that the noise was so loud it disturbed her from across the street.

Mark Chin commented that he lived near a pile driving site in which the en-tire project was finished in a day. This rush prevented the buildings depart-ment from being able to file a stop order request, since by the time they could act on the complaint, the pile driving was done. Wehle said he had never heard of such a case, but said that DOB can work quickly if need be.

A lawyer who specializes in pile driving cases then addressed the auditorium. He soon got to the crux of the matter. He said that plenty of legal protection ex-ists for buildings adjacent to pile driving activities. Real time vibration equip-ment can monitor the work, with re-sults shared with DOB. However, there

is a cost to the home-owner that could reach thousands of dollars.

Many homes in NY are worth hundreds of thousands and millions of dollars. For those property owners, a few thou-sand is not a big price to pay in order to protect their investment. However, many Red Hook homeowners are not wealthy, and are unable and unwilling to incur a hefty legal bill.

That is a big part of the problem, and one which will stay on the plate of the Civics Association and other local lead-ers in months to come.

PRISTINE COFFEY PARK

Last April, a fence that went up closing Coffey Park surprised many Red Hookers. It turned out that the Parks Depar-ment had a plan to renovate the park paths. At the time they promised that the park would be closed no longer than one year. Eleven months have gone by, and for more days than not there was no evident work performed. This picture, taken through the fence on March 9, shows that nobody has been in the park since the winter snows first covered it. This work could most probably have been finished in a month or two, but NYC contracts give the low bidder a year to complete the job. Most probably it will take more than a year before the park is reopened, and most probably the Parks Depart-ment will blame the weather.

Complaining about vibrations from Go-tham Metal Works.

John McGettrick and the two guests from the Dept of Buildings. (photos by Fiala)

Some major pile driving was done last summer when construction of the BASIS school began. It was far enough away from residential housing to avoid any controversy.


AirBnb is the somewhat contro-versial web service that enables anyone to turn their apartment

into a bed and breakfast, although a meal is not specifically required. An un-expected side effect is the ability to look at a community through the eyes of its visitors.

AirBnB allows the user to scan avail-able listings by neighborhood. On March 6th typing in Red Hook revealed 41 local rentals. Prices ranged from $50 to $500 per night. Each listing comes with a description, photos, availabil-ity and best of all - reviews. A reading through various reviews offers a vision of how we are perceived by the grow-ing number of tourists that frequent the neighborhood.

“Gary,” who rented a room on Beard Street, could be hired by the Red Hook Visitors Bureau, if we had one. He says:

“ Fernando is an excellent host and easy to work with. His place is comfortable and charming. Red Hook is like a small town nestled in New York. Just down the street is Fairway Market, which not only has an incredible food selection, but also has a patio with probably the best and closest view of the Statue of Liberty. It is excel-lent for breakfast before you start your New York day. You can take a 15 minute water taxi ride into Manhattan, which is free on the weekends and only $5 during the week. The restaurants in Red Hook, within a 5 minute walk include Home-town Bar-B-Q which was recently given a stellar review in the New York Times, the farm-to-table Good Fork and Fort Defi-ance with amazing cocktails.

For seafood you have Red Hook Lobster and Brooklyn Crab Shack. Pioneer Works Center for Arts offers cutting-edge ex-hibits and music in a huge refurbished warehouse with a magical sculpture garden out back. Many of the bars and Hometown Bar-B-Q offer live music. Ja-lopy which features blues and bluegrass is a 15 minute walk. For local made whis-key and chocolate on can take a tour and tasting at Widow Jane Whiskey and Cacao Prieto. Steve’s Key Lime Pies is next to Val-entino’s Peer with kayaking and summer movies. Within a 10 minute bike ride (ask Fernando about borrowing a bike) is the

new Brooklyn Bridge Park with stunning views of Manhattan and a carousel.

The bus system in Red Hook connects you easily to the subway. The nuts and bolts: the bed is super comfortable, the shower hot, the neighborhood cool with innovative food spots, little stores and art spaces. I loved my time in Red Hook and staying at Fernando’s “hideaway!”

A top floor apartment that rents for $135 (plus a cleaning fee), had some of the most literate and enthusiastic com-menters:

Debra writes:

“Home/Made is the 1st floor food estab-lishment and it is delicious! Sadly it was not open during the week and we found only one other good coffee place - Baked. Several good restaurants within blocks but particularly enjoyed Grindhaus. Also an amazing grocery store within walking distance with organic products. The com-munity seems to be very tight (Christmas lights strung from our window across to opposite apartment to decorate the street for the season) and trying hard to recover from the damage of Sandy. A won-derfully eclectic neighborhood.”

Melissa gushes with some more Red Hook love:

“Red Hook is an authentic and special place with a good balance between bars/food/shops and actual people doing nor-mal everyday things-- not everywhere in Brooklyn can boast that these days. Don’t let the extra blocks from the subway be a deterrent, it’s not that far and Uber is a great option. Look up Pioneerworks events and exhib-its, it’s right up the street from here, and must see. We didn’t get to eat “down-stairs” because they had a catering event (menu looked delicious though), but we found a wonderful spot close by called Orchard, delicious healthy food at unreal prices (so so cheap)! I would (okay I WILL) stay here again, and I’d highly recommend it to anyone who is looking for a new way to see New York.”

Elisa chimed in:

My husband and I loved staying at this sweet, comfortable apartment because we love Red Hook. It is in the ideal loca-tion for exploring this hip and yet still

grungy neighborhood. There are some excellent restaurants on the same street, as well at the amazing Fairway grocery, next to the water. We highly recommend bringing bikes, as the riding is very scenic and easy. Our host, Lisa was very friendly and set us up with everything we needed to make our stay memorable.

NY State Attorney General Eric Schneiderman recently issued a report that criticized AirBnB for hosting what he called illegal activity. The Times last October reported: “He (Schnei-derman) was careful, however, to speak of “illegal hotels” rather than “illegal rentals.” Airbnb is already too popular to dislodge completely, no matter what the housing laws say. It also delights travelers, who get a cheaper and usually more interesting place to stay.”

AirBnb is also criticized for reducing the number of affordable apartments left in the city for renters. A Daily News op-ed last August writes: “ Airbnb is sending a clear message to city landlords: You can make more money renting your va-

The AirBnB view of Red Hookby George Fiala

Just about all Red Hook apartments are bright and sunny, if you go by the gorgeous photos one can find on AirBnB. You can rent a loftbed in this apartment at the Luggage Factory for $95 per night.

cant units on Airbnb, taking precious units off the market. And Airbnb is ef-fectively encouraging tenants to violate their leases, which could put unsuspect-ing New Yorkers in jeopardy of being evicted.”

While the legality of these rentals is be-ing hashed out, in the meantime it’s a lot of fun to browse through the web-site and see what people think of your neighborhood, not to mention getting to see the insides and backyards of your neighbor’s homes!

This backyard comes with the rental of a one bedroom house for $150 a night or $3300 a month.


Remembering Frances D’Angeloby George Fiala

I believe Frances lived all her 91 years across the street from De Fontes. Hers was the little white house on the corner of Columbia and Luquer.

I only met Frances twice. The first time was at last summer’s Visitation Church street fair. She was a long time support-er of the Church and that day she was selling raffle tickets at a table next to the Amendola sisters.

I was pretty impressed with her energy and her memory and a short time later, I had one of our free-lancers interview her for a story of reminiscences. These are her words:

“Red Hook used to be a big ship town back then. Visitation Church used to have excursions, they’d take us out on a boat around Red Hook. My fam-ily has been going to that church since they came to Red Hook. My grandpar-ents went there. My grandfather move to 353 Columbia street in 1910. I still go to Visitation myself. There’s nobody left there that I know from the old days now. Used to be you knew everyone in the neighborhood. Today, most of my neighbors I don’t even know. These days people come and go. “

“On Sundays in the summer there would be a man with a push-cart selling pretzels, and another selling all kinds of fish. We didn’t have ice cream trucks back then.

Sometimes me and my girlfriends would go to the movie theater and then we would go hide in the bathroom so we could see the same movie over again. Didn’t realize how silly that was back then… but we did it, and we enjoyed ourselves.

Down in Coffey Park and Pier 27 there was a summer program there we used to go to. Then when the Red Hook pool opened we would go there all the time– we’d get there in the early in morning and stay till noon. On some days in the summer my mother and aunt would take us out to Coney Island. We would take the trolley car. It was a nickel for

adults and 3 cents for kids but my mom would tell us in Italian, “Just go under the turnstile, go under!”

Red Hook was a really nice place to grow up. We had nothing, but we had fun. I remember how the neighborhood used to be. I’ve lived in this place my whole life.”

I next met Frances in the fall at the an-nual Luquer Street block festival. That fest still has a Hispanic feel, and loud music was a big part of the day, but Fran-ces didn’t seem to mind at all. I sat with her on a stoop and she told me about her house and the lot next to it. She told me that she sometimes couldn’t get the paper at De Fontes - I’ve made sure I dropped them off faithfully every issue since then.

She had an oxygen tank with her then to help her breathe, but that didn’t stop her from having a good time. She was especially good with the little kids that came by. She told me that she never married, but I think she said that she had nephews and nieces. She seemed to love the children.

A woman came by who said she was a neighbor. She told me how much she loved Frances.

We will both miss her.

Frances at the Visitation street fair last summer. (photo by Fiala)

Hanging out with Buddy we meet the Valentinos

Last week we met Buddy Scotto at the Carroll Gardens Dunkin Donuts. He told us about his new idea, which is lobbying for a new high school on the Public Place lot, which would serve both Carroll Gardens and Red Hook. While there, I was introduced to Phyllis Valentino, mother of Louis Valentino. Louis was the firefighter who died in 1996 in the line of duty. Red Hook’s Valentino Pier is named in his memory. Phyllis is on the right and still lives in the neighborhood.


Andrea McKnight retires after twenty years on the Community Boardby George Fiala

At last month’s CBC 6 meet-ing, the new Chairman, Gary Reilly, announced that after two decades on

the board, Andrea McKnight was retir-ing.

We took the opportunity to visit with Andrea and her husband Jay at their cozy and well appointed home at 495 Columbia Street.

The McKnights grew up in Clinton Hill. I asked Andrea how she became so community minded. “I took part in many voter registrations campaigns back then, working with Shirley Ch-isholm,” she told me. She was also in-volved in tree plantings, working with Hattie Carthan, who formed the Mag-nolia Tree Earth Center. You can still see a beautiful flowering magnolia tree outside their headquarters on Lafayette Avenue.

She moved with Jay, who is a well known professional singer, to Red Hook later on in the 1970’s, “back when ev-erybody in the Red Hook Houses knew each other.” She claims that a loss of this community was what made the Houses a rougher place to live.

The McKnights became community leaders in Red Hook, working with Lou Sones and John McGettrick in the fight against waste transfer facilities, forming the Red Hook Lion’s Club in 1992, and working to bring a savings bank to the neighborhood.

That work was successful, as the McK-nights spearheaded an effort to get 3,000 signatures in favor of bringing the Independence Savings Bank to Lor-raine Street.

After joining the community board, she became involved in the drafting of

the 197A neighborhood plan. “When I came on board, they had not paid much attention to the NYCHA residents in the plan.” With her insistence, the plan evolved to include the total Red Hook community.

McKnight was a member of the Trans-portation and Public Safety Commit-tees. Making sure that bus routes served Red Hook was an important responsi-bility.

Others she worked with included Emma Broughton, Judith Daly, Bea Byrd and Barbara Longobardi. These are all com-munity leaders of the past, and all were vital in leading Red Hook through some rough times.

“It’s important to know what is going on in the community, and to lobby for good outcomes.”

She served as a liaison to CB 6, forward-ing tenant complaints when appropri-ate.

One issue she was involved with re-cently came up when PAVE opened up on Mill Street next to the C-Town. Issues with students and delivery trucks were solved, with the cooperation of the DOT, making sure that the students would remain safe and truck could con-tinue to make deliveries.

John McGettrick remembers that it was Andrea who started and led the Friends of the Red Hook Library for many years.

The McKnights are still active and vi-brant. They continue leading the Lion’s Club. Every Christmas they sponsor a

toy giveaway and sponsor bus trips to faraway places.

Andrea McKnight at her Columbia Street apartment that she shares with husband day and a cute little dog.

The McKnights with the Dinkins.


EVERGREEN LIQUOR STORE INC.718 643-0739

196 Columbia Street, between Sackett & [email protected]

Mon. - Thurs. 11 am - 10:30 pm; Fri & Sat. 11 am - 11:30 pm; Sun. 1 pm - 9 pm

tea and coffee in the am, beer and wine in the pm

517 Court Street, corner West 9th (718) 522-4410www.teaffee.com www.facebook.com/Teaffee

525 COURT STREET (between W. 9th & Garnet)

718 858-8299 Email: [email protected]

FREE DELIVERY Open 7 Days a Week

PHARMACY NOW OPEN!

n Papyrus Greeting cards n Solgar / Windmill vitaminsn Kids toys including Melissa & Doug n Paddywax / Votivo candlesn Mustela / Medela products n Professional haircare productsn Burt’s Bees / Ahava products n And much much more

GARDEN APOTHECARY

Carroll Gardens’ neighborhood pharmacy. All your family’s needs under one roof

481 VAN BRUNT SUITE 8A718 624-5568

www.selectmail.com [email protected]

df df df df df

Brooklyn’s mailing company teams up with Red Hook’s NY Printing & Graphics Our clients have included: St. Ann’s Warehouse, Eastern Athletic Club, BWAC & RHI Services Offered: • Political Mailings• Non-Profit Fundraising

Letters • Postcards • Brochures & Newsletters • First Class & Standard Mail

It’s been an icy winter


Page 12 Red Hook Star-Revue September 2010

I recall when a very young lad around 5 years of age living at 113 Bush Street in 1934-35. It was truly a slum tenement

type building, cold water, and toilets in the hallway. Heat was made by the occupants using wood fires in a cast iron kitchen stove. The people on Bush Street were tough as nails, worked at odd jobs, anything to put together some food for the kids at a time when jobs were unheard of.

The resilience of these people was astonishing, although at my age I hardly noticed it. But today I can look back and see the determina-tion embedded in their faces and in their hearts, not to let their problems overcome them or deter them from striving to survive. True Red Hook-ers, never giving up despite the abys-mal conditions they were forced to endure. Real John Wayne style “True Grit” you might call it.

Not surprisingly, there were no peo-ple from Red Hook living in Hoover City. They were a fiercely proud people who never could surrender their dignity because of hard times.

Bush Street between Clinton and Hicks street was the very last row of houses facing south towards the grain elevator, this imposing structure had been built around the mid 1800s and used for unloading grain ships. This was the major activity on the Red Hook waterfront for over 100 years. Annually, more grain was shipped from Red Hook by sailing vessels as well as steamships during that period than any other place in the world.

Looking south towards the water and the grain elevator structure from Bush Street we view two huge tin lots approximately a double city lot each in size. Both existed as dump-ing grounds for the rest of New York City. As children we would play in both of these lots. There were many truck tires, of the solid rubber type - balloon tires having not been invented at that time. The parallel streets opposite Bush street were first Lorraine Street and then Bay street in that order

As kids, we called them “the tin lots” and played in the abandoned huts built by the occupants of Hoover City. All three streets, Bush – Lor-raine – and Bay streets were bounded by Court Street on the east, and Hicks St. on the west. And therein was the boundary of Red Hook’s Hoover City as I recollect. After Bay Street South, was water, now filled in. This was around 1934/35, so a good deal of the homeless haven was abandoned or evicted, and work opportunities started to increase as

New Deal programs helped boost the Depression economy.

The prime occupants of Hoover City in Red Hook were merchant seamen who lost their positions aboard the ships that came to Brooklyn from various foreign nations. These ship-ping companies could not afford to hire the manpower needed to return home with the cargo so they cut costs by sailing shorthanded. They virtual-ly abandoned hundreds of men every time they set sail, creating a mass of hard working men with no jobs and no place to stay. And even worse, no money. Those who were abandoned chose instead to convert the tin and other waste found in these lots to liv-able housing. If you can call no water or toilet facilities livable. They did so in order to be close to possible sail-ing employment. They were intelli-gent, honest and law abiding people. Some had wives and children, others single, and they all respected each other despite their dire situation. At the beginning of the Great Depres-sion there were many “Hoovervilles” or “Hoover Cities” across the coun-try. In Chicago for instance there were many unemployed stockyard

workers existing in Hoover City type compounds.

I am informed by Mr. Lars Nilsen who heads the Norwegian Immigra-

tion Society, that he has records of nearly 800 Norwegian Seamen who were forced to endure those miser-able conditions of Hoover City in Red Hook because of their lost work in the shipping industry. Most of

Back in the day Section

Hoover City and Red Hook by JJ Burkard

“The prime occupants

of Hoover City in Red

Hook were merchant

seamen who lost their

positions aboard the

ships that came to

Brooklyn from various

foreign nations”

John Burkard is an active 80 year-old local his-torian with a special interest in Fort Defiance and the Red Hook Trail. The Red Hook Star-Revue is pleased to have him join our pages.

where I lived as a young lad.

I nearly forgot to relate a now comi-cal story about when I lived in 113 Bush Street. It was a heck of a cold winter night and everyone was roused from their sleep by a crashing noise in the slum buildings hallway. It seems a squatter on the top floor was cold, so he decided to take an axe and chop up the banister for his firewood to keep him warm. All the regular building occupants banded together and wasted no time in evicting this squatter along with his axe and anything else he wanted to take along, but no firewood. I’m sure those good people would have loved to burn that wood in their stoves, but no one dared touch it.

If there’s a moral to this story, it must be this - when walking the streets of NYC today, if you come across a homeless person covered with news-papers or cardboard to ward off the cold, don’t cringe at the sight, or turn your head and pretend they do not exist. At the very least, look to the heavens and say “There but for the grace of GOD go I.” Or perhaps you can reach in your pocket and come up with a buck or two?

these men had families back home yet no way could they reach them. A Norwegian Church on Summit St did their best to assist these men, and local food merchants donated food. Local churches rendered assistance also, but the Norwegian Salvation Army, and Norwegian Seamen’s In-stitute predominated in their efforts

to render aid and comfort to these abandoned men. Many, if not all of the Norwegians ended up living in Brooklyn permanently and migrated to the Bay Ridge area.

It’s also safe to say nearly everyone looked upon their plight with pity, even the residents of those slums on Bush Street I mentioned earlier

SUBSCRIBe TO THe ReD HOOk STAR-ReVUeWhile most of our circulation is sent for free to residents of Red Hook, the Columbia Street Waterfront area, as well as part of Red Hook, we can also offer mail subscriptions to interested readers in other parts of Brooklyn and the US. The fee for 12 monthly editions is a modest $6.00. Please send payment by check made out to SELECT MaIL.

Please fill out the information below and return with payment to Red Hook Star-Revue, 101 Union Street, Brooklyn, NY 11231.

NaME _____________________________________________________________________________

addRESS ___________________________________________________________________________

CITY_____________________________________STaTE______________ZIP ______________________

Presorted Standard RateUS Postage

PAIDBrooklyn, NY

Permit 84

The Red Hook Star-RevueOctober 2010 FREE The Hook’s Local Newspaper

The Red Hook Star-Revue101 Union StreetBrooklyn, NY 11231

Judge Calabrese at the September 76th Precinct Community Council meeting

Just beyond the BQE and half a block west of Coffey Park, the Red Hook Center For Community Jus-

tice announces itself with a friendly wave of the banner bearing its name. The Center represents what is shaping up to be the most effective form of jus-tice around: deep community involve-ment on the part of the long arm of the law.

As Alex Calabrese, the sole judge pre-siding over this one-room courthouse, explained it, “a community justice kind of approach decides to look at what brought that person to the back door - lets identify that, lets solve that, so that they don’t keep recycling through the system.”

He added that such an approach cre-ates, “a better result for the defendant, but most importantly for the commu-nity, and for the court system.”

Red Hook Court a Model for the Rest of the World

by Eliza Ronalds-Hannon

This Month we expand

our Arts Coverage...

Food!

Music!

Film!

Painting!

Sculpture!

Books!

Thought!

Hanging Out!

12 PAGES OF ARTS COVERAGE INSIDE!!!

The opportunity to break that cycle has proven compelling to courts all over the world - and their represen-tatives have visited the Red Hook Center looking to imitate its model - because to do so would not only im-prove the quality of life for residents, but also save an enormous amount of money currently spent on criminal justice procedure. In a time of tighter and tighter budget cuts, that element is increasingly appealing.

At the Red Hook community court, the judge doesn’t hand down sentences of jail time or probation. Instead, this court seeks to marry criminal justice with community need. “Conditions of release” often consist of job readi-ness training, addiction and/or trauma counseling, and community service.

With this mission, RHCJC arrives at a genuinely productive form of “crimi-nal justice,” rather than an essentially

re t r ibut ive one. For in-stance: In-stead of send-ing a man caught using cocaine to jail, which may very well push his family into poverty, des-peration, and even crime, Judge Cala-

Red Hook’s past, present, and future is inextricably bound to transportation. As politicians

and transport experts consider the best ways to link our neighborhood with the rest of the city, it is important that as residents we inform ourselves of the various options so that we can actively participate in the decision process. This article looks at one par-ticular mode of transportation: the monorail.

Monorail systems are commonly as-sociated with amusement parks and airports – the Walt Disney World

Can a Monorail be the Answer?Liberty International Airport. But the use of monorail systems as urban “peo-ple movers” has been increasing in the United States and in countries around the world, most notably in Japan.

35,000 people ride the Yui Rail ev-ery day in Okinawa, 12,000 ride the Moscow Monorail, and the Seattle Monorail, which was built in 1962 to connect Seattle Center and Westlake Center Mall, boasts a ridership of 1.5 million per year.

The vast majority of “people mover”

Monorail has the highest ridership of any monorail in the country, and just across the Hudson is AirTrain Newark, linking sections of Newark

by Matt Graber

The Roaring 20’s are in style with the Red Hook Ramblers p. 14

The Roaring 20’s are in style with the Red Hook Ramblers p. 14

Krista Dragomer on Joes Boat p. 10

Transportation Study for Red Hook Begins...

brese will send that man to drug treat-ment, and monitor his progress.

Even in an age when diversion pro-grams and drug treatment are some-what available in traditional district courts, several factors distinguish the Red Hook Center. First, it processes

please turn to page 3

please turn to page 5

Bush Clinton Park, where tin shacks used to house unemployed seamen, was taken over by the Park Department in 1934. Hoover Cities were dismantled as the New Deal began.

Editors Note: John passed away last month. He was our first contributor and we re-print here his first column for the Star Revue. It appeared in our September 2010 issue.


Mark’s Corner

BY MARK SHAMES

On February 18, I attended an event at Baruch College about the Implementation of

New York City’s Affordable Housing programs. Much of what was said was a restatement of the plan that is online at a NYC website but the human inter-actions did add texture and there was a preview of certain proposed changes to our zoning code. Such changes will al-low for fuller use of building envelopes to match permitted floor area (FAR) and for the production of more single user and varied types of senior hous-ing units. This is an aggressive and creative plan for new housing given that there is a lack of federal support and that there is no longer a supply of acquisition cost free abandoned or dis-tressed sites as existed during the Koch era.

At the same time I continue to believe that even the current pace isn’t rapid enough to achieve the administra-tion’s stated goal and that goal may still leave us with a reduced number of affordable units citywide. Those I spoke to at this event shared this per-ception. The high demand for market rate housing coupled with very low in-terest rates gives rise, at this moment, to an extraordinary opportunity for the financing and subsidization of af-fordable units. This situation will not last indefinitely and while changed cir-cumstances may stabilize land acquisi-tion costs, the net effect will be that the production of affordable housing units will become even more difficult over time.

An exploration of the changing demo-graphics of the City was a significant part of the presentation, as a guide to what types of units will be needed. This analysis played into the new zoning proposals. The administration projects a City with a larger popula-tion comprised of more and smaller households, a fast growing Hispanic population, a growing Asian popula-tion, a somewhat smaller percentage of African-Americans and an aging Caucasian population. As an aside, my advice for those entering into politics is to learn Spanish and develop a good relationship with the Bronx Borough President.

The other aspect of the presentation that held particular interest for me was the effort being made to reach out to neighborhoods to make the insertion of denser development less painful. This is being done through outreach to community groups and by seeking to coordinate such development with enhanced infrastructure and services and minimal displacement of people and businesses. The panelists were more sanguine than I am about how much resistance to development can be alleviated by these efforts. The ef-fort remains worthwhile even though

there will never be total buy-in. Con-tinuous good faith efforts such as our own locally driven Bridging Gowa-nus process once coordinated with an administration effort will certainly aid in minimizing community angst. For those who have not been follow-ing it, Bridging Gowanus is a process started by Councilman Lander with participation by our other elected officials to develop a plausible con-sensus on local values in reaction to development pressures.

At the Environmental Protec-tion Agency’s Community Advi-sory Group for the Gowanus Canal (CAG) meeting on February 24th we heard a standard rehash of pro-cess complaints and a litany of wishes from the most vocal members in re-action Councilman Lander’s update on the Bridging Gowanus process. While everyone is skeptical of gov-ernment follow through, only the Councilman and the representative of the 5th Avenue Committee, who actually are on the front lines in the creation and maintenance of afford-able housing, spoke of the economic realities that would require all New Yorkers to accept tradeoffs. For ex-ample many people want to see the “Powerhouse” building on the Gowa-nus Canal that is being “re-imagined” as an arts center, landmarked. How-ever, the owner who does have re-spect for the past and who wishes to preserve the essence of the building doesn’t wish to see the building for-mally landmarked. Do we accommo-date this altruist or do we make this already unprofitable endeavor even harder to pull off? This is compara-tively easy compared to other neces-sary tradeoffs.

Many of us believe that real estate in-terests hold too much sway over deci-sions in New York State government but while I share this view, the essen-tial problem in affordability remains the law of supply and demand. In this City, demand has consistently ex-ceeded supply of habitable residences and to add to the degree of difficulty I am told that the cost of non-union construction is now between $230-$260 a square foot. The City’s success is a blessing in nearly all ways, but a curse when it comes to affordability.

What I have never understood is what is meant when we say we are “preserving 120,000 units of afford-able housing?” I would really like to know the bottom line on this. How many currently affordable units are at risk of being lost? Is that number limited to 120,000 units and if they are saved will we then not lose any affordable units? When we build and preserve 200,000 units of affordable housing does that mean there will be

At a recent City Council Trans-portation Committee hear-ing, a bill was introduced to

mandate an agreement between liv-ery bases when one base wishes to use drivers from another base. Passing this bill would protect consumers and small livery bases, like ours, that serve neigh-borhoods not served by taxis and green cabs. Unfortunately, the Taxi and Lim-ousine Commission, the city agency charged with regulating the transpor-tation industry, is on the wrong side of this issue.

At the hearing, the TLC Commissioner stated “some smaller bases do not always have enough business to occupy their affiliated drivers or even enough market power to enter into an agreement with another base that has terms friendly enough for smaller bases to accept them and remain profitable.”

It’s true that we do not always have enough business to occupy drivers, but contrary to the TLC’s interpretation, that’s precisely why our small bases need these base agreements, particularly with the bigger bases.

Bases look to dispatch drivers from oth-er bases because they need additional drivers to fulfill their customer service requests. Base agreements protect our small businesses by helping us maintain our driver pool to service our custom-ers and allow other bases to dispatch our drivers when we don’t have enough work for them, thereby maximizing drivers’ incomes.

Without base agreements, other compa-nies will dispatch our affiliated drivers anytime they want, leaving our custom-ers stranded. The bottom line is that if a base wishes to dispatch to our drivers, then that base should have no problem entering into an agreement with us.

The TLC’s argument about “Market Power” is also baseless! These agree-ments are precisely the mechanism to keep us on equal footing, preventing big bases from taking our drivers whenever they want or need.

All this begs the question: why does the TLC make these arguments? Is it to pro-tect the interest of, and maintain order in the industry? Or is it to make it easier for venture capital companies such as Uber and Lyft to poach our drivers?

I have run a base that services consum-ers in the Brooklyn for more than nine years. Since they entered the market-place, Uber and Lyft have systemati-cally poached our drivers, making it im-possible for us to honor commitments to our customers and protect our small businesses, which are struggling to stay afloat.

So, why should the average person care about this? Because if companies like Uber and Lyft put us out of business, everyone will have to pay their higher prices for car service.

Here’s the truth: for 30 years, the TLC has allowed base agreements to exist. It was only after Lyft and Uber came to the market that the TLC took up the issue of base agreements to the benefit of the app companies and the detriment of our bases and customers.

If the TLC had bothered to consult with us or with the Livery Roundtable, the industry group that represents the in-terest of the livery industry, there may have been a different outcome. But they didn’t. And so that is why it is our hope that the City Council passes the base agreement bill.

Jose Viloria, Owner, Elegante Car Ser-vice, 5911 4th Ave. #1 Brooklyn, NY 11220, 718-972-5555.

Op Ed: Save the Car Services

Outside of Scotto’s Liquor store on Court Street (photo by Fiala)(continued on next page)


EDITORIAL:

The future of our waterfront

a net gain of 80,000 affordable units when we are all said and done or will it be some lesser number? The adminis-tration has indicated on its website that there are affordable unregulated apart-ments left in the City, but it is wishful thinking to believe that such unregu-lated units will remain affordable at the current pace of demand for hous-ing. Even the administration friendly panelists at the forum acknowledged that they no longer know where to tell people moving into the City to look for their first apartment. Neither do I.

Shames(continued from previous page)

For our cover story this week we took a look north at the Brook-lyn Bridge Park. In January, we went south for a story about the

Sunset Park waterfront.

Both these stories have a relevance to Red Hook.

Mark Shames this month speaks of the relentless pressures of the real estate market. This has been an issue ever since the last farms left the five bor-oughs. Except for a period in the 1970’s, New York City’s population has moved ever upwards. City government is now planning for a population of 9 million by 2030.

As New York has long been one of the world’s pre-eminent global cities, a steady influx of foreign money has found its way into the NY market. These days that takes the form of parking money into luxury condos - as a well researched NY Times series recently documented.

As long as the money keeps flowing in - builders will look to accommodate it.

In the meantime, we are still a city of residents, workers and school children. We need schools and parks and places to work. The main role of city government is to keep the city habitable. The alter-native is becoming a Potemkin village of gaudy movie sets and tourist attractions.

A glance at the page 1 representation of two large towers occupying Pier 6, at the foot of Atlantic Avenue, is a por-tent to a continuation of such buildings from Pier 6 through 12 - right through our neighborhood. We’d prefer the alter-native idea, keeping it parkland for the next fifty years, hopefully stemming the condo tide for a while.

The best alternative to open, public space on that waterfront is a working wa-terfront - a vibrant and busier container terminal bringing goods to this part of the Hudson by water. The side benefit of this is less truck traffic - with no ship-ping here, everything would have to be trucked over from Port Elizabeth and Port Newark.

As we don’t trust our city government to give us hundreds of acres of open space with the “trade-off” of residential and commercial development (see Brooklyn Bridge Park), we’re ok with the contain-

erport for now. We’re not quite ready for a Brooklyn version of Miami Beach.

It seems to us that the Cruise Terminal is an opportunity still waiting to happen. For a while, a dedicated group was very upset about the fumes of idling ships. They effectively lobbied our local offi-cials, the Port Authority and Con Edison to create an infrastructure that would al-low the ships to plug into the grid while docked instead of idling on diesel fuel.

The $20 million Shore Power project was eventually put through, and by this summer it will be in operation. However, at the same time that this was happen-ing, the number of ships coming to Red Hook fell by more than half. In addition, nothing was ever done to encourage ship passengers to explore our neighborhoods - they immediately took off to Manhat-tan to spend their day ashore.

We hope that government will see to it that we become an active port of call once diesel fumes are no longer an issue.

We’re not exactly sure how we feel about Estate Four’s plans for the next leg of our waterways - so we asked you, the readers, for your opinion. Last month we pub-lished a page of responses, which turned out to be wildly mixed. It did seem that tourists and real estate interests were very excited, while Red Hook old-timers seemed a bit guarded.

The properties are already bought, and Estate Four will do what they will. We will all be watching and hoping for a successful integration with our existing neighborhood.

John BurkardWe note with sadness the passing of one of our very first contributors.

I started this paper back in the sum-mer of 2010, without really that much knowledge of Red Hook. While I’ve spent much of my life on the outskirts, including Boerum Hill, Windsor Ter-race and Carroll Gardens, I rarely ven-tured across Hamilton Avenue. Actu-ally, I can remember three times. Back in the 1980’s, when smashed car win-dows were a NYC norm, I used to go to Gowanus Glass on Lorraine Street. In the 90’s I headed over to Lillies, on Dwight and Beard, on a couple of oc-casions to hear music. I got lost every time. Another time I read about an an-ti-war exhibit opening at the Kentler on the eve of Desert Storm. I took a strange bus called the 61, to get there.

But in 2010, my other business relocat-ed from Court to Van Brunt and Union and Red Hook came on my radar.

One thing led to another and I eventu-ally realized that Red Hook was much more interesting than I ever thought,

and what was a neighborhood like this doing without a newspaper.

After a first issue which was mostly photos, I had to really start to under-stand what’s going on around here. I also started the paper with the idea that knowing about the past was key to figur-ing out the future, so I started googling Red Hook history.

John had written on the subject for a South Brooklyn blog, and after an in-quiry, he graciously accepted my offer to become the paper’s historian.

I remember chatting with him on pos-sible subjects, and what struck me was his memory of a Red Hook Hooverville during the depression. This was a first-hand memory, as he wrote in the first paragraph of his first column:

“I recall when a very young lad around 5 years of age living at 113 Bush Street in 1934-35.”

He wrote for us for the first two years of the paper, and maintained a once in a while contact afterwards. I asked him last year if he could write about another passion of his - Visitation Church. I kind of wish I had pursued that harder.

That first year, I invited all our con-tributors to a dinner at the Good Fork. I’ll never forget John’s reaction to the menu there. “Can I just get a hamburg-er?” is what he said.


That’s so Brooklyn!

Maram, grabbed my hand and led me over to her favorite photograph hang-ing on the walls of Hope & Anchor. “Eye Am Watching You,” the photo is entitled. She looked up at me and said, “Chocolate eyes!” She pointed at me, and repeated the phrase.

Her teacher, Ms. Julie Cavanagh ex-plained. We both have brown eyes. Maram giggled.

Maram is part of PS 15 Patrick F. Daly Magnet School’s Academics, Careers and Essential Skills (ACES) program for children with special disabilities. She was there with classmates, teach-ers, friends and family to celebrate the completion of a project, as well as the opening of her art exhibit, That’s SO Brooklyn.

The ten students in Maram’s class start-ed with a basic question. “Where do you live, and what’s here that is nowhere else?” They set out in small groups to explore the neighborhood and capture photos of anything they thought de-fined themselves and Brooklyn.

Inspried by exhibit at BMAThe project idea originated out of a cur-rent exhibit at the Brooklyn Museum by Judith Scott (1943-2005). Judith was born with Down syndrome, was mostly deaf and could not speak. She spent 35 years in an institution for people with disabilities.

In 1987, her twin sister, Joyce, moved her to Creative Growth Center in Oak-land California, a studio art program that fosters and serves artists who have developmental and physical disabilities. Judith began sculptural work after being taught specific textile-based processes.

According to the Brooklyn Museum, “For the next seventeen years, until her death, Scott created extraordinary sculptures assembled from found and scavenged materials wrapped and tied in yarn, thread, and other fibers.” Her exhibit will be on display there through March 29.

Ms. Julie took her students on a class trip to see Judith Scott’s exhibit, Bound and Unbound. “This photography in-stallation marries with the ground-breaking art installation [...] and seeks to continue to break down barriers and stereotypes, while furthering the con-versation around self-taught artists and the intersection of disability, creativity, and the disability rights movement,” Ms. Julie said.

PS 15’s ACES students are fully in-cluded in every aspect of school life in a traditional school experience. Their curriculum is adapted from their respec-tive grade levels with a strong emphasis on arts, projects based learning, and ex-periences in the community. Students work towards the same standards as their peers, but with specialized support to make everything accessible. The pro-gram focuses on not only academics, but also career and essential skills to help

students work towards independence, job skills, communication, social skills and mobility.

“Students in PS 15’s ACES classes have intellectual disabilities and have histor-ically been segregated and separated in both school and adult life [...] children and adults with intellectual disabilities deserve the same recognition of their individual gifts as their peers and should have full access to sharing those gifts, maximizing their opportunities,” she justified. “What could be more Brook-lyn than breaking down barriers and stereotypes, and championing the artist in EVERY child?”

Trek through Red HookThe journey of That’s SO Brooklyn began with a trek through Red Hook. From the school’s home base on Sul-livan Street, the students and teachers spent three hours crisscrossing streets and made their way to Valentino Pier. Along the way, they took more than 70 photos of images that can only be found in Brooklyn “through their lens[es].”“I think every student took a picture of the blue chair,” Ms. Julie said. “They

captured images from their school com-munity that inspired their senses and serve as a visual representation of the borough they call home.”

Back in class, all of the photographs were conglomerated and became a part of the entire group’s collection. Instead of giving credit to individual students, every child got to take credit for all of the pictures. Each photo was rated by the class by a simple thumbs-up or thumbs-down majority.

Once photographs had been chosen, the class discussed the each and as-signed a title. “STOP in the Name of LOVE” was another nearly all of the students took. When they discussed what it meant, the kids didn’t know what the “frisking” sticker meant.

Ms. Julie explained the controversial stop and frisk policy to them “in a de-velopmentally appropriate way.” They discussed the importance of respecting police authority, but that some people disagree with the policy.

“I simplified the conversation to what I feel is the important message - that ev-

eryone should treat others with love, no matter who they are,” she said. “They all wanted the STOP big in the name [of the photo,] and I said let’s add more. Someone mentioned love, and I said that reminds me of a song.” They chose to capitalize LOVE to balance the capi-talized STOP.

Ms. Julie, who sometimes stops with other teachers in to Hope & Anchor for lunches on Fridays, asked Pete Ascolese, owner, about the possibility of exhibit-ing the photo essay in his restaurant.

Pete eagerly agreed because wanted to “keep [the project] in the neighbor-hood.” He said he was pleasantly sur-prised by the artistic quality of the work. “With kids, you never know what you’re going to get. I’m impressed.”

Hope & Anchor was involved in the process by selecting the photos in ad-vance. Bar Manager and Art Curator, Candice Sering went to the school and chose which ones would be on display. She decided where each would hang in the restaurant to determine what size each should be.

On the morning of February 24, Hope & Anchor proudly opened their new-est exhibit, That’s SO Brooklyn. Stu-dents, who shared credit for the photo essay with all of classmates, individually presented books they had made about where they live at the art opening.

Through the group project and their own presentations, each child learned about the diverse borough they live in. David talked about the tall apartment building he lives in. Charwin learned about one of her favorite places - Co-ney Island. Ruanny remembered the visit with Ms. Julie and classmates to the Brooklyn Museum. He escorted me to “Blue Chair’” because in Brooklyn, people like to sit down outside.

Restaurant owner Pete’s favorite, “In the Fast Lane” is a scene he sees often - the view of Van Brunt from his store windows. He also likes “Coffee?,” “Blue Chair,” and “Blue Door” as a set because of the complementary colors.

Learning from her studentsEven though Ms. Julie is their teacher, she says she learns so much from her students every day. “Lessons of kind-ness, patience, and love. I learned that perspective is everything - it is the de-termining factor between a striking photo and just a snapshot, but also it got me thinking more broadly about perspective and its impact on our lives-- the way we see ourselves and the way others see us.

“As my students’ teacher I have a role to play in being by their side as they develop and construct their identities, which are not only influenced by their perspective, but by the way others see them. I want everyone they meet to see what I see: able, gifted, talented, loving individuals who have so much to share.”

PS 15 students exhibit at Hope & Anchorby Kimberly Gail Price


That’s SO Brooklyn is a photographic essay completed entirely by ACES students at PS 15 with the guidance of their teachers. The students col-lectively took all photos, ranked their favorites, and named each selected work within class discussions.

The following thirteen pictures will be on display at Red Hook’s Hope & Anchor through the end of March:

“Brooklyn Berries” - Red berries so big, they almost look like tomatoes on the vine.

“The Leaves are Sleeping” - The berries in actual perspective in relation to the size of the tree. The tree is winterly barren, but the berries are thriving.

“In the Fast Lane” - The motion of a skateboarder crossing Van Brunt jux-taposes the idling B61 bus. The image is a direct view from the windows of Hope & Anchor.

“Circles” - Multiple bicycles chained to an iron gate outside of a residential building create various levels of circles.

“Coffee?” - An open rusty drain pipe imbedded in the pavement filled with dark, dank water appears looks like coffee in a stained cup. The cracked lip of the pipe even gives the appearance of a handle.

“Blue Chair” - An aquamarine chair sits on a bespeckled sidewalk against a white contoured wall. The chair is spackled with red and white paint.

“Blue Door” - A navy blue door set inside an aqua colored frame that complements “Blue Chair” is nestled into a dark brown exterior wall.

“Trouble Maker” - A graffiti black and white man in a hoodie sits upon a multi-toned red brick wall cradling a sign that reads, “Art is not a crime.”

“Standing Tall” - Manhattan’s Freedom Tower shoots up into the back-ground sky, while the outer coast of Red Hook plays peek-a-boo in the foreground.

“STOP in the Name of LOVE” - A stop sign tagged with a “frisking” sticker makes a statement that DOT most likely didn’t intend.

“Cruisin’ Past Liberty” - A tug tows a barge, “Blak Slee” across Lady Lib-erty’s waters.

“Writing on the Wall” - Blue graffiti surrounds rusted iron framed iron win-dows, while a MLK quote, “Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice every-where,” is stenciled in a contrasting bright yellow.

“Eye am Watching You” - The top half of a woman’s face depicts dark, thick eyebrows and a straight-on stare. An iconic Red Hook mural, her “choco-late eyes” are watching.


Summer Stage announces 30 artists in 30 daysIn advance of their 30th anniversary, City Parks Foundation’s Summer Stage performing arts festival will announcing the name of one artist performing in the city-wide festival each day beginning Monday, March 9. The full season will be completely revealed by April 8. Art-ists will be broadcast on all three Sum-mer Stage social media sites, where fans can share their response to each artist.

Up-to-date announcements will be posted at SummerStage.org, as well as their Facebook, Twitter and Instagram pages.

SYEP’s InternshipsSummer Youth Employment Program (SYEP) provides New York City youth between the ages of 14-24 with paid summer internships for up to six weeks in July and August. Workshops on job readiness, career exploration, financial literacy, and opportunities for educa-tional and social growth.

Participants are selected via a lottery system to work with community based organizations with in entry level posi-tions. Internships are available in all five boroughs. The deadline to apply for Summer 2015 is April 10, 2015.

Business can also apply to become a SYEP worksite. Businesses that will have positions available can sign up on or before May 16. They are also encour-aged to alert Community Board 6 for help promoting the job openings.

To apply for a summer internship or become a worksite, visit SYEP’s web-site: nyc.gov/html/dycd/html/jobs/syep.shtml

CB6’s Community Service AwardsEvery year, Community Board 6 (CB6) honors youth within the district with Youth Acknowledgement Awards (YAA), as well as the Robert Acito Award for youth Involvement.

YAAs are awarded to youth ages 10-19 who perform group community services or have made outstanding individual contributions in the district.

Robert Acito Awards are named after

the former District Manager who served CB6 from 1980-1993 and demonstrated a strong commitment to the youth of his district. These annual awards are given to an adult who actively contributes to the youth in their community.

Nomination forms are available online at www.brooklyncb6.org/announce-ments.

BGI founder moderates nature panel

Brooklyn Greenway Initiative (BGI) co-founder, Milton Puryear will moder-ate the 2015

St. Paul’s Episcopal Church performanceENSEMBLE COMPANIO, a chamber choir directed by Joseph Gregorio, is proud to announce its performance en-titled ‘Love’s Faces’ at St. Paul’s Episco-pal Church, in the Carroll Gardens on March 21st, 2015 at 8:00 pm. The per-formance is sponsored and coordinated by the Brooklyn Sounds Concert Series.

‘Love’s Faces’ features works by Ar-cadelt, Passereau, Stainer, Duruflé, Lars-Erik Larsson, and a commission by Vince Peterson; arrangements of popu-lar music by The Beatles, Billy Joel, and Randy Newman; and folk music from around the globe. Admission is $20 for the general public and $10 for students / seniors.

Founded in 2011, Ensemble Companio comprises 24 accomplished choral mu-sicians and performs throughout the northeastern United States. Ensem-ble Companio was awarded the 2012 American Prize in choral performance (community division) for its vibrant sound and moving interpretations, and was invited to perform at the 2013 Fall Conference of the Pennsylvania chapter of the American Choral Directors As-sociation. Ensemble Companio derives its name from a late Latin form of “com-panion,” whose etymological meaning is “one with whom one shares bread.” The name reflects the musicians’ belief that sharing in choral music is an essen-tial, nourishing, and healing endeavor akin to the sharing of food. Ensemble Companio’s mission is to build bridges between people through authentic, in-spiring performances of the finest choral music.

Maraschino mysteryIf you’ve been waiting with baited breath for this issue of the Star-Revue to come out so you could get the inside scoop on February’s biggest news story, well, we’re sorry to disappoint you.

You might think that the neighborhood newspaper with offices a few blocks away from Dell’s Maraschino Cherries might be able to come up with some facts that all the other news media missed, but truth is we are as baffled as anyone.

In case you’ve been holed up someplace, here is a summary of the unfor-tunate story.

Operating rather quietly not far from Valentino Pier Park, Dell’s, owned for three generations by the Mondella family, has built up one of the larg-est maraschino cherry operations in the country. Their customers include Chick Fill A, T.G.I. Friday’s and many other large chain stores and res-taurants. Operating out of a warehouse without too many windows, all a passerby might have noticed would be bins of white cherries on their way in, and bins of red cherries on their way out, stacked on the sidewalk until being loaded onto trucks.

On February 19, the factory was raided by a whole host of officials, in-cluding the Brooklyn DA, NYC DEC, NYC DEP (both environmental agencies), and the cops. While inside checking out some environmental complaints ostensibly made by neighbors, they found a secret garden of grass behind a fake wall.

As this discovery was made, Dell’s owner, Arthur Mondella, went to the bathroom and killed himself with a gun he had strapped to his ankle.

This became worldwide news, as the police uncovered a 2500 square feet growing area for marijuana, as well as a bunch of cash, kept hidden by Mondella.

Despite heavy investigative work by the city’s three daily newspapers, as well as television and internet sites such as the Huffington Post, no more of the story has come out.

The business was closed only one day, and the family is cooperating with the DA’s office to try and find out what exactly was the deal.

We figured that if we could get the real story behind the story - the Star-Revue might hit the big time.

Alas, we went to all our local sources, and nobody seems to have any idea about what was going on.

We only found out two things - the guy was paranoid about security - you would be too if you were secretly growing 1200 giant pot plants - and that Michael Buscemi had filed a lot of complaints to the 76th Precinct. He didn’t like the way the workers looked at him, is what we could find out.

If you happen to know the real story - we’d be happy to make you famous. Just call me, George, at 718 624-5568 and we’ll tell your story to the world.

A law enforcement agent outside Dell’s Cherries on the day of the raid.


Star-Revue ClassifiedsPLUMBING

Licensed Electrical ContractorsCommercial • Residential • Industrial

Free Estimates

Violations RemovedAll Types of WiringEmergency Service

Vito Liotine(718) 625-1995(718) 625-0867

[email protected]

137 King StreetBrooklyn, NY 11231Fax: (718) 935-0887

EMERGENCYSERVICE

Home ImprovementSave $ on your electric bill. NRG Home Solar offers free installation if you qualify. Call 888‐685‐0880 or visit nrghomesolar.com. HIC# 1427914, HIC# 5972, Wc24767h12, H11586400000

Junk RemovalMiss clutter and junk. All junks removed from homes, yards, offices,basements, garage and attics. Efficient is our goal. Tel. (718) 775 5925

LegalREAL ESTATE CLOSINGS Buy/Sell. Expd Attorney, Real Estate Broker, ESTATES/CRIMINAL MATTERS Richard H. Lovell, P.C., 10748 Cross Bay, Ozone Park, NY 718 835‐9300. www.LovellLawnewyork.com

Lots & AcreageWATERFRONT LOTS-Virginia’s Eastern Shore. Was 325K Now from $65,000- Community Center/Pool. 1 acre+ lots, Bay & Ocean Access, Great Fishing, Crab-bing, Kayaking. Custom Homes. www.oldemillpointe.com 757-824-0808

House PaintingLawson Painting Service. Interior/ exterior paint-ing , plastering, sheet rock, taping, cement work, Etc. Free estimate Tel. (718) 209-0907

WantedCASH for Coins! Buying ALL Gold & Silver. Also Stamps, Entire Collections, Estates. Travel to your home. Call Marc in NY: 1-800-959-3419

To place an ad in this section call 718 624-5568 or email [email protected].

Rates start at $30 per issue.

No job too big or too small

Toilets, Boilers, Heating, Faucets, Hot Water Heaters,

Pool Heaters.

B & D HEATING507 Court Street 718 625-1396

JABUS BUILDING CORP.Serving Red Hook for over 25 years

Specializing in Construction and Historic Preservation• New construction

• Renovations, additions and extensions • Masonry specialist • Concrete floors/radiant heated • Concrete/bluestone sidewalk repair • Flue linings, chimneys and fireplaces • Demolition and waste removal • Violation removals • Landmark Preservation contractor

Jim & Debbie Buscarello98 Van Dyke Street, Red Hook (718) 852-5364

Fax: (718) 935-1263www.jabusbuildingcorp.com [email protected]

HIC License #0883902 Trade Waste License #1135

Advertise in the Star-Revuefor information call 718 624-5568

or email [email protected]

Jenny belin’s Art

Our friend Jenny, who exhibits locally at the Brooklyn Collective, 212 Columbia Street, sends us this and tells us that the above painting was inspired by the Gold Diggers of 1933. Wikipedia tells us that “Gold Diggers of 1933 is a pre-code Warner Bros. musical film directed by Mervyn LeRoy with songs by Harry Warren (music) and Al Dubin (lyrics), staged and choreographed by Busby Berkeley. It stars Warren William, Joan Blondell, Aline MacMahon, Ruby Keeler and Dick Powell, and features Guy Kibbee, Ned Sparks and Ginger Rogers.In 2003, Gold Diggers of 1933 was selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the Library of Congress as being “culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant”.

Jenny’s website is www.jennybelin.com. The movie is available at Amazon.com


Documents

Star revue march 2015