19
Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 2018 1 Pop-Out Essential Question: How can humans interact ethically with ecosystems? Humans are interacting with environments in increasing amounts. As that happens, humans can change parts of ecosystems, often leading to problems. While scientific discoveries can often give new solutions for problems that were once very difficult to solve, sometimes these scientific discoveries have downfalls that come with their benefits. When a scientific discovery helps some people but negatively impacts an ecosystem, how do we decide what to do? Engage At the end of Unit 1, you learned about how different parts of an ecosystem change when one resource is changed. When it is humans that are making the change, this poses an ethical dilemma. The process of deciding what is right or wrong is known as ethics. Today, you will be applying your own ethics to a number of different situations. 1. Individually, take a couple minutes to read through the imaginary situation below. Bacteria are quickly developing resistance to antibiotics (this means antibiotics can’t kill the bacteria). This makes it harder and harder for scientists to make medicines that help people with certain bacterial infections. One example of a resistant bacteria is MRSA (a type of bacteria that is immune to most antibiotics and is a big cause of hospital deaths). Many medicines are made from plants. A scientist just discovered that a certain type of flower in the Amazonian jungle can make an antibiotic that could help save people with MRSA. To make one dose of the medicine, scientists would need to gather 200 flowers. The flower has important roles within the jungle ecosystem. It is symbiotic with a tree that gives homes to many jungle species. This means the tree and the flower help each other survive. Additionally, the flower provides nectar to three species of birds and gives pollen for many insects. Howler monkeys also need the flowers for food. 2. With your group, discuss the questions below and then use the table to record your opinions. You may be asked to share your ideas in a class discussion. What are benefits of making the medicine?

Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    76

  • Download
    6

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit1:ABalancedBiosphere

Pop-Out:EnvironmentalEthics

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:Howcanhumansinteractethicallywithecosystems?Humansareinteractingwithenvironmentsinincreasingamounts.Asthathappens,humanscanchangepartsofecosystems,oftenleadingtoproblems.Whilescientificdiscoveriescanoftengivenewsolutionsforproblemsthatwereonceverydifficulttosolve,sometimesthesescientificdiscoverieshavedownfallsthatcomewiththeirbenefits.Whenascientificdiscoveryhelpssomepeoplebutnegativelyimpactsanecosystem,howdowedecidewhattodo?EngageAttheendofUnit1,youlearnedabouthowdifferentpartsofanecosystemchangewhenoneresourceischanged.Whenitishumansthataremakingthechange,thisposesanethicaldilemma.Theprocessofdecidingwhatisrightorwrongisknownasethics.Today,youwillbeapplyingyourownethicstoanumberofdifferentsituations.

1. Individually,takeacoupleminutestoreadthroughtheimaginarysituationbelow.Bacteriaarequicklydevelopingresistancetoantibiotics(thismeansantibioticscan’tkillthebacteria).Thismakesitharderandharderforscientiststomakemedicinesthathelppeoplewithcertainbacterialinfections.OneexampleofaresistantbacteriaisMRSA(atypeofbacteriathatisimmunetomostantibioticsandisabigcauseofhospitaldeaths).Manymedicinesaremadefromplants.AscientistjustdiscoveredthatacertaintypeofflowerintheAmazonianjunglecanmakeanantibioticthatcouldhelpsavepeoplewithMRSA.Tomakeonedoseofthemedicine,scientistswouldneedtogather200flowers.Theflowerhasimportantroleswithinthejungleecosystem.Itissymbioticwithatreethatgiveshomestomanyjunglespecies.Thismeansthetreeandtheflowerhelpeachothersurvive.Additionally,theflowerprovidesnectartothreespeciesofbirdsandgivespollenformanyinsects.Howlermonkeysalsoneedtheflowersforfood.

2. Withyourgroup,discussthequestionsbelowandthenusethetabletorecordyouropinions.Youmaybe

askedtoshareyourideasinaclassdiscussion.Whatarebenefitsofmakingthemedicine?

Page 2: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit1:ABalancedBiosphere

Pop-Out:EnvironmentalEthics

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

Whataredownsidesofmakingthemedicine?

Wouldyoumakethemedicine?Whyorwhynot?

ExploreThelastcasewasanimaginarycasetogetyouthinkingaboutcomplicatedethicalsituationscreatedbyscientificdiscoveries.Nowlet’sexploreascenariothathappenedintherealworld.Youalreadylearnedabouthowecosystemsshiftwhenresourceswithintheecosystemincreaseordecrease.KeepthatinmindaswediveintoacaseaboutaproblemcausedwithintheYellowstoneecosystemandwhatscientistsdidtosolveit.

1. Individually,readanarticleandwatchavideoabouttheWolvesinYellowstone.Whilereading:o Usetheannotationstrategiesyourteachergivesyoutohelpyoulearnfromthereading.

2. Withapartner,discussthefollowingquestions.Recordyourresponsesinthetablebelow.

Describethesituation:

o Whywerethewolvesoriginallykilled?

o Whathappenedtotheecosystemwithoutwolves?Why?

o Whathappenedtotheecosystemwhenwolveswerereintroduced?Why?

Page 3: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit1:ABalancedBiosphere

Pop-Out:EnvironmentalEthics

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

Describethepeopleinvolvedinthesituation:

o Whowantedtokillthewolves?Why?

o Whowantedthewolvestostayalive?Why?

Reflectonthesituation:IfyouwerethePresidentoftheUnitedStatesandcoulddecidewhethertoprotectlandowners’rights,protectthewolves,oracombinationofthetwo,whatwouldyoudo?Why?

ExplainPartofwhatmakesthecaseofthewolvesinYellowstonesuchatopicofdebateisthattherearemanydifferentperspectivesonwhatisbestfortheecosystemandthepeoplearoundit.Now,you’llhaveachancetohearyourclassmates’thoughtsandshareyourown.Listencloselyforinstructionsfromyourteacher.Youwillbedoingagroupdiscussion,calledaFishBowl.Asyoulistentotheothergroupdiscuss,takesnotesbelow.

o Remember,ethicalquestionsaretoughbecausetheyhavealotofdifferentperspectives.Berespectfulinlisteningto,andtryingtounderstand,yourclassmates.

Page 4: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit1:ABalancedBiosphere

Pop-Out:EnvironmentalEthics

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 4

ElaborateEventhoughthewolveswerefirstre-introducedin1995,ithassparkedadebatethatcontinuestoday.Allaroundtheworld,peoplearehavingconversationsliketheseabouthowwecanbestsupportecosystems.Onebigissuewehavebeenfacingoverthelastcenturyisinvasivespecies.Invasivespeciesarenewspeciesthatwehavepurposelyoraccidentallyintroducedintoanecosystemthatarenotnativetothatregion.Someofthesespecies“takeover”theirecosystembecausetherearenopredatorsforthemintheirnewecosystem.

1. Workingindividually,readtheZebraMusselCaseStudy.Asyou’rereading,thinkaboutwhatledtotheintroductionofzebramussels,thereasonstoaddressthesituation,andthereasonsagainstaddressingthesituation.Alsothinkaboutwhatyouwoulddotoaddresstheproblem.

2. Usingwhatyoulearned,individuallyanswerthequestionsbelow.Youwillbeaskedtosharethesewithapartnerandtheclasslaterinthepop-out.

Describethesituation:

o Howandwhydidzebramusselsspread?o Whataretheimpactsofthezebramussels

ontheecosystem?

WhatarethepositiveandnegativeaspectsofzebramusselsinCaliforniaecosystems?

Howwouldyouaddresstheproblemscausedbyinvasivespecies?

Page 5: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit1:ABalancedBiosphere

Pop-Out:EnvironmentalEthics

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 5

EvaluateandReflectionYouhaveread,talked,andthoughtalotaboutdifferentperspectivesontheethicsofhowhumansinteractwithecosystems.Nowusewhatyouhavelearnedtowriteanargumentthatanswersthefollowingquestions:Intheseethicalsituations,istheansweralwaysblackandwhite?Shouldwealwayssidewiththeenvironment

oralwayssidewithpeople?Whyorwhynot?Inyourargument,include:

o Aclearstatementofyouropiniononthesequestionso Multipleexamplesfromthescenariosandcasestudiesasevidenceo Aconclusionstatementthatexplainswhyitissometimeschallengingtodecidewhatisethical(rightor

wrong)inscience

Page 6: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit2:MatterMatters

Pop-Out:NaturalResources,Wealth,andFairness

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:Howdonaturalresourcesaffectthewealthofaregionandaretheydistributedfairly?

Alotofwhatyou’relearningthisyearrelatestoEarth’sresources:howtheyaremadebyEarthprocesses,how

theyareusedbyhumans,andhowtheyinteractwithecosystems.AsyouhavelearnedinUnits1and2,naturalresourcesareresourcesthatcomefromtheEarth,suchasoil,water,soil,timber,naturalgas,etc.Giventhat

naturalresourcesaredistributedunevenlyaroundtheglobe,inthispop-out,we’regoingtofocusonsomebig

questions:wholivesintheareaswiththemostnaturalresources?Arethesenaturalresourcesbeingsharedina

waythatisfair?

EngageHaveyouevertraveledoutsideofyourneighborhood?Ifyouhave,youmayhavenoticedthatdifferent

communitieshavedifferentamountsofwealth.Morewealthinanareaoftenleadstomoreprivileges,suchas

accesstogoodschools,updatedcommunityspaces,varietyoffoodchoices,etc.Someareashavealotofwealth,

someareashavelittlewealth,andsomeareashaveamediumamountofwealth.

1. Belowyou’llfindamapandasetoftableswithinformationaboutfivecontinents.Inpartners,usewhat

youknowaboutthecontinentsonEarthtomakeyourbestpredictionsofwhichsetofinformation

describeswhichcontinent.Eachsetofinformationrepresentsonlyonecontinentlisted(excluding

AntarcticaandAustralia).Recordyourideasandexplainwhyinthechartbelow.

Continent IncomePerPerson($)

1 $5,441

2 $1,755

3 $27,242

4 $9,449

5 $49,804

Page 7: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit2:MatterMatters

Pop-Out:NaturalResources,Wealth,andFairness

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

Continent DataSetGuess Explanation

NorthAmerica

SouthAmerica

Africa

Europe

Asia

Withyourpartner,discussthefollowingquestions.Youmaybeaskedtoshareyourresponseswiththeclass.

1. Whatcountryhasthemostwealth(highestincomeperperson)?Whydoyouthinkthisis?

2. Whatcountryhastheleastwealth(lowestincomeperperson)?Whydoyouthinkthisis?

ExploreYouhavejustseenhowdifferentregionscanhavedifferentamountsofwealth.Nowlet’sexploreonereasonwhy

thisisthecase.Inthistask,you’llbeconsideringtwonaturalresources:waterandsoil.Torepresentthequalityof

waterandsoilinanarea,scientistsuseanindicatorcalled“agriculturesuitability.”Explorethedatatoseeifthere

isaconnectionbetweenthecountriesthathavehighagriculturesuitabilityandthecountriesthathavewealth.

1. Asagroup,explorethedataprovidedbyyourteacher.Itincludesanarticle,amap,andawebsite.

Page 8: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit2:MatterMatters

Pop-Out:NaturalResources,Wealth,andFairness

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

2. Asyoulearnfromthedata,answerthequestionsbelow.Youwillusetheinformationyougatherwhen

youcreateacomicstripinthenextsection.

TakealookattheAgricultureSuitabilityMapandtheWealthMap.

o Whatdoyounoticeaboutthecountriesthatcangrowfood?

o Whatdoyounoticeaboutthecountriesthathavewealth?

Thinkaboutbothmaps.Compareandcontrasttheinformationfromthetwomaps.

o Whatissimilarbetweentheinformationonthetwomaps?

o Whatisdifferentbetweentheinformationonthetwomaps?

Doyouthinkthereisaconnectionbetweenacountry’swealthandtheirabilitytogrowfood?Explain.

o Isthisfair?

Page 9: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit2:MatterMatters

Pop-Out:NaturalResources,Wealth,andFairness

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 4

ExplainNowthatyouhaveexploredtheconnectionsbetweentwonaturalresources(waterandsoil)andacountry’s

wealth,itistimetobringyourideastogetherandsharethem.

1. Inpartners,makeacomicstripthatanswersthequestion:Arecountrieswithmorewaterandsoil

wealthier?Yourcomicstripshouldsharewhatyoulearnedfromtheclassdiscussionatthebeginningof

thepop-out,informationfromthedata,andwhatyoutalkedaboutwithyourgroup.Usethenotesyou

tooktohelpyou.Remember,youcanbecreative!Comicsdonotneedtobefunny,buttheycanbe.You

canincluderhymes,color,orananalogytomakeyourcomicstripmoreinteresting.

ElaborateEarth’sdistributionofnaturalresourcesisnottheonlythingthataffectsaccesstoresources.Howpeoplechoose

tosharethemacrosscommunitiesalsoaffectsaccess.Forexample,evenintheheartofcitiesintheUnited

States,wherefoodisplentifulinsomeareas,foodcanbehardtofindinotherareas.Inthiscase,we’reexploring

theconnectionbetweenpovertyandlackofaccesstofood.Afooddesertreferstoanurbanareawhereit’sreallyhardorreallyexpensivetofindfreshnutritiousfood.Let’sconsiderhowfooddesertsappear.

1. Asaclass,watchthevideoaboutfooddesertsinLosAngeles.Then,individuallyrespondtothequestions

below:

EastLosAngeleshasanincomeof$54,242,comparedtothe$132,997incomeinSantaMonica.Compareandcontrastthetwofamilies.Hint:Wheredoeseachfamilylive?Whattypeoffoodispresentineachgrocerystore?

Whydoyoubelievesomepeoplehaveaccesstofoodwhileothersdon’t?

Isthisfair?

Page 10: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit2:MatterMatters

Pop-Out:NaturalResources,Wealth,andFairness

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 5

EvaluateandReflectionIndividually,takesometimetoreadthroughandthinkaboutthequestionsbelow.Providedetailedresponses

usingwhatyoulearnedoverthelastcoupledaysinclass.

1. Isthereaconnectionbetweenlocationofnaturalresourcesandthewealthofthoseregions?Whydoyou

thinkthisis?

2. Isthereaconnectionbetweenthecommunitiesthathavemoneyandtheiraccesstonaturalresources

likefood?Explain.

Page 11: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit3:MimickingNature’sDesign

Pop-Out:HowScienceWorks

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:Inthescientificprocess,howdoesnewevidencedispelmisconceptionsandchangescientificknowledgeovertime?Scienceisaprocesswegothroughinordertolearn.Itteachesusabouttheworldaroundus.SciencetaughtusthattheEarthisround,thatClimateChangeisconnectedtohumans,andthatlivingthingschangeovertime.Butmanypeople(includingscientists)usedtobelievethattheEarthwasflat,thattheworld’schangingclimatewasnotrelatedtopeople,andthatlivingthingsstayedprettymuchthesame.Theseoriginalideaswouldnowbecalledmisconceptions,butatthetime,thesewerethebestideasbasedontheevidencetheyhadavailable.Howdoesthefieldofscienceclaimtoknowsomething?Whatcancausethisknowledgetochangeovertime?Thispop-outwillexplorethewaysciencemakesdiscoveries,bustsmyths,andchangesovertime.Engage

1. Usingwhatyoualreadyknow,individuallyrespondtothequestionsbelow.Wemightnothavetalkedabouttheseinclassbefore,andit’sokayifyoudon’tknowthe“right”answer.Dothebestyoucanbasedonwhatyouknowfromyourlife.

TrueorFalse:

1. _____Plantsbreathe.2. _____Plantsonlydophotosynthesis.3. _____Thingsjustdisappear(likerocksfromamillionyearsago,orasockinthedryer).4. _____Whensomethingchanges,itjustchanges–therearenotdifferenttypesofchanges.5. _____Plantsgeteverythingtheyneedfromthesoil.6. _____Sunlighthelpsplantsgrowbykeepingthemwarm.7. _____Plantsneed“plantfood”toeat.8. _____Allrocksarethesame,andwecan’ttellwheredifferentrockscamefrom.9. _____Whensomeoneburnsalog,thelogsimplydisappears.10. _____Plantsarenotalive.

2. Withyourpartner,shareyourresponses.Ifyouhaveevidenceforwhyyoupickedtrueorfalse,sharethat

withyourpartner.Youmaybeaskedtoshareyourideaswiththeclass.ExploreYouhaveseenhowtherearemanydifferentideasaboutwhatistruewhenthinkingaboutthesciencewehavestudiedinthisunit--matter,thecycleofmatter,andtheflowofenergy.Buthowdidscientistsdiscoverthatthesearemisconceptionsandnotscientifictruths?Let’srollupoursleevesanduseasimilarprocess,butwithanon-scientificexample.Inthistask,youwillreceiveaseriesofchecksthatyouwillexamineinordertouncoverthetruthbehindamystery.

Page 12: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit3:MimickingNature’sDesign

Pop-Out:HowScienceWorks

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

1. Asagroup,listencloselyfortheinstructionsfromyourteacherabouttheactivity.Itisimportanttofollowinstructionsandnotjumpahead.Afteryoureceiveeachsetofchecks,recordyourtentativeexplanationinthetablesbelow.

Checks TentativeExplanationUsingthissetofevidence,whatdoyoubelievehappened?

#1Checks1-4

Claim:Evidence:Reasoning:

Checks TentativeExplanationUsingwhatyouinitiallybelievedandwhatyouhavelearnedfromthenewevidence,whatdo

younowbelievehappened?

#2Checks1-8

Claim:Evidence:

Page 13: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit3:MimickingNature’sDesign

Pop-Out:HowScienceWorks

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

Reasoning:

Checks TentativeExplanationUsingwhatyouinitiallybelievedandwhatyouhavelearnedfromthenewevidence,whatdo

younowbelievehappened?

#3Checks1-12

Claim:Evidence:Reasoning:

ExplainYourgrouphasmadeyourownclaims,evidence,andreasoningaboutwhatyouthinkhappened.Eachcheckgivesyoupiecesofinformation,likeevidencedoesinscience.Theprocessyoudidisverysimilartotheprocessthatscientistsgothrough;Scientistsuseevidencetomaketheirbestguessesaboutwhathappenedorwhatishappening.Asnewevidenceisdiscovered,scientificideascanchangeandoldideasbecomemisconceptions.Thisisscience!

1. Nogrouphasseenallofthechecks,butothergroupshaveseenadifferentcombinationofchecks.Betweenallgroups,yourclasshaslikelyseenalltheevidence.Togetafullpictureofalltheevidence,discussyourexplanationswithothergroups.Youcanuseinformationfromtheconversationstomakeyourfinalconclusionaboutwhathappened.Thisiswhathappensinacommunityofscientists!

Page 14: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit3:MimickingNature’sDesign

Pop-Out:HowScienceWorks

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 4

2. Individually,writeyourfinalscientificexplanationwithevidenceinfullsentencesbelow.Remembertobespecificanduseasmanydetailsaspossibletoexplainyourideas.

FinalScientificExplanation

Claim

Evidence

Reasoning

ElaborateYouhavepracticedyourscientificskillsasyouuseddifferentpiecesofevidencetocreateaclaim.Let’sthinkaboutwhatourexperiencecanteachusaboutthescientificprocess.Withyourgroup,discussandanswerthefollowingquestions.

1. Reflectontheactivityusingthequestionsbelow.o Whatinformationonthecheckswasvaluableinmakingatentativeexplanation?Explain.

Page 15: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit3:MimickingNature’sDesign

Pop-Out:HowScienceWorks

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 5

o Discussspecificplaceswhereyouchangedyourstoryandoldexplanationsbecamemisconceptions.Whydidyouchangeyourstoryinthoseplaces?

o Whichaspectsofyourstoryorexplanationwouldyouwanttogathermoreinformationabout?Whatinformationwouldyouwant?

2. Inscience,weusedifferentdefinitionstoclassifydifferentkindsofideas:○ Ahypothesisisaneducatedguess.○ Atheoryisahypothesisthathasbeentestedbyhundredsofdifferentscientistsandexplains

somethingimportantabouttheworld,likethetheoryofevolution.○ Abeliefisanopinionthatcan’tbescientificallyproven,likeyourspiritualbeliefs.

IntheChecksactivity,

a. Whatwasanexampleofahypothesisyoucreated?

b. Whatcouldbeconsideredatheory?Howisthisdifferentfromahypothesis?

c. Didbeliefscompromiseyourscientificprocess?Ifso,how?

Page 16: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit3:MimickingNature’sDesign

Pop-Out:HowScienceWorks

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 6

EvaluateandReflectionIndividually,takesometimetoreadthroughandthinkaboutthereflectionquestionsbelow.Providedetailedresponsesusingwhatyoulearnedoverthelastcoupledaysinclass.

1. Howdoweuseevidencetodecidewhatishappening?

2. Isitpossibletogetdifferentideasfromthesamepiecesofevidence?

o Howdoesthisleadtomisconceptionsinscience?

o Howdoscientificideaschangeovertime?

Page 17: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit4:SavetheAndes!

Pop-Out:WhoisAtRiskinNaturalHazards?

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 1

Pop-OutEssentialQuestion:Aredifferentgroupsofpeopleaffectedfairlybytheaftermathofnaturalhazards?Naturalhazardsarehappeningmoreandmore–droughts,fires,hurricanes,tsunamis,volcanoes,landslides,avalanches,andearthquakesaretakingplaceacrosstheEarth.Inthisunit,youlearnedthatwecanforecastsomenaturalhazardstohelpreducetheeffectsonhumans.Whennaturalhazardsdotakeplace,thisresultsinInjuries,death,homelessness,lackofaccesstofood,andotherproblemswithgeneralwell-being.Thesepeopleneedhelpfromhumanaidorganizations,likegovernmentagencies,theAmericanRedCross,etc.However,theaidisnotalwaysgivenequallytodifferentgroupsofpeople.At-riskpopulationsarepeoplewhoneedextrasupportincertainsituations.Whothosepeopleareisoftenbasedonsocioeconomicstatus(theamountofmoneyyouhave),age,race,Englishproficiency,andhealthconcerns/physicalability.Inthispop-out,wearegoingtoexplorewhathappensonceanaturalhazardhastakenplacebylookingatwhogetshelpandwhodoesn’tgethelp.We’llaskourselveswhyandconsiderifitisfair.EngageWhenscientistslearnaboutanaturalhazard,theywarncommunitiesinvolved.Theybroadcastwarnings,updates,andhowtoevacuate.IntherecentNorthernCaliforniafires,firefighterswantedeveryoneincertaincommunitiestoevacuate.Almosteveryoneheardthenews,yetsomepeopleweren’tabletoleave.

1. Inpartners,takeacoupleminutestomakepredictionsaboutwhatgroupsofpeopledidn’tmakeitoutoftheirhouses.

Explore

1. Listencarefullytothearticleyourteacherreadsaloud.Then,inpartners,answerthequestionsinthetablebelow.Whowasn’tabletoevacuate

fromthefiresintime?Why?

Page 18: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit4:SavetheAndes!

Pop-Out:WhoisAtRiskinNaturalHazards?

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 2

Whydoesthatpopulationneed

specialsupporttoevacuatefrom

naturalhazards?

Basedonwhatyouknowabout

whythosepeoplecouldn’t

evacuate,doyouthinkthereare

othergroupsofpeoplewho

weren’tabletoescapethefires?

ExplainAsyoulearnedintheunit,scientistsareoftenabletoforecastwhennaturalhazards,likefires,willhitcertainareasandusethisinformationtotellpeoplehowandwhentoevacuate.However,youjustheardinthearticlethatthisinformationdoesnotaffectallpeoplefairly.Firstwithapartnerandthenasaclass,discussthefollowingquestions:

1. Whatat-riskpopulationsdoyouknowareunfairlyaffectedduringfiresandwhy?2. Youknowfromtheintroductionthatthereareotherat-riskpopulationsnotmentionedintheEngage

article.Whichofthesegroupsdoyouthinkmightalsobeaffectedduringfiresandwhy?3. Thereareothernaturalhazards,suchashurricanes,volcaniceruptions,tornadoes,etc.Howdoyouthink

thesegroupsmightbeaffectedduringthesetypesofnaturalhazards?Why?ElaborateThelastarticletalkedabouthowcertaingroupsofpeopleweren’tassafeduringanaturalhazardasothergroups.Nowlet’sexplorewhathappenedtotheentirecityofNewOrleans,LAafterHurricaneKatrinastruck.

1. Paycloseattentiontothephotosyourteachershowsyouandthevideoyourteacherplays.ItshowsthetimelinethatledtoHurricaneKatrinaarrivinginNewOrleans,LA.

2. Individually,readthroughtheHurricaneKatrinaSituation.Whilereading:

o Usetheannotationstrategiesyourteachergivesyoutohelpyoulearnfromthereading.

3. Withyourgroup,discussthefollowingquestions:o Whatgroupsofpeopleweresignificantlyaffectedbythehurricane?o Whatareexamplesofgroupsofotherpeoplewhowerenotdiscussedinthereading?o Explainwhatmadethehurricanesomuchharderforthesepeoplebasedonthesefactors:Age,

HealthConcerns/PhysicalAbility,SocioeconomicStatus(howmuchmoneyyouhave).

Page 19: Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum...Stanford NGSS Integrated Curriculum 7th Grade Science Unit 1: A Balanced Biosphere Pop-Out: Environmental Ethics Student Version Stanford NGSS

StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum7thGradeScienceUnit4:SavetheAndes!

Pop-Out:WhoisAtRiskinNaturalHazards?

StudentVersion StanfordNGSSIntegratedCurriculum2018 3

4. ImaginethatyouhadfamilyorfriendslivinginNewOrleanswhenHurricaneKatrinahit.Usingwhatyouhavelearnedfromthepop-outsofar,individuallywritealettertotheNewOrleansMayor.Yourlettershouldinclude:

o Anoverallstatementexplainingwhatgroupsofpeoplearemorevulnerableinnaturalhazards o Examplesofhowcertaingroupsofpeoplewereimpactedbythehurricane o Ideasforhowtoaddresstheproblemsinthefuture

EvaluateandReflection

Individually,takeafewminutestothinkaboutwhatyoulearnedinthispop-out.Thenreflectonthequestionsbelow.

1. Whichpopulationsareoftenmoreat-riskduringandafternaturalhazards?Why?

2. Inyouropinion,isitfairthatsomepopulationsaremoreimpactedbynaturalhazardsthanothers?