28
Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015 Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch FIXED INCOME, CURRENCIES, AND COMMODITES COVERAGE GROUP Bryant Johnson EJ Bernard Harrison Caruthers Jaewoo Jang John Solitario Justin Hsuan Kuno Choi Laura Zhang Sen Lin Nick Bien

Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Stanford Blyth Fund FICCWinter Quarter 2015 Pitch

Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ)

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

FIXED INCOME, CURRENCIES, AND COMMODITES COVERAGE GROUP

Bryant Johnson EJ Bernard Harrison Caruthers Jaewoo Jang John Solitario

Justin Hsuan Kuno Choi Laura Zhang Sen Lin Nick Bien

Page 2: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Pitch Outline

1. VNQ Price History & Metrics Overview

2. ETF Breakdown & Composition3. Macro Catalysts: QE & US Economic

Recovery4. US Real Estate Sector Analysis:

Historical Lows5. Conclusion6. Questions 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 3: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ)

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

VNQ was listed October 1st, 2004 at $51.18 per share. It seeks to track the performance of the MSCI US REIT Index, which represents

around 2/3rds of the US real estate market.

Page 4: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

REITs?A Real Estate Investment Trust (REITs) is a security that sells like a stock on major exchanges and invests in real estate directly, either through properties or mortgages.To qualify as a REIT, a company must1) invest at least 75 percent of its total assets in real estate assets

and cash,2) derive at least 95 percent of its gross income from such real estate

sources and dividends or interest from any source, and3) distribute at least 90 percent of its taxable income to shareholders

annually in the form of dividends.4) Equity REITs v. Mortgage REITs. VNQ is an equity REIT meaning its

earnings mostly comes from rental income as opposed to gains and losses in MBS for MREITs.

Benefits- REITs receive special tax considerations,- Typically offer investors high yields- Highly liquid method of investing in real estate.

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 5: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Stanford Blyth Fund FICC

1. VNQ Overview

Page 6: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

10 Year Historical Performance

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Strong performance against S&P 500 over past decade.

Real Estate most profitable asset class past year (52 wk. +26.5%).

Page 7: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

60 Day Rolling CorrelationVNQ exhibits moderate-to-high correlation with the S&P 500 based on

the past 10 years.

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 8: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Dividend Yield 3.37%

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Given REIT structure VNQ offers high dividend yield.

Offer degree of downside protection in adverse price action.

Page 9: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

VNQ vs. Competitors

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Superior performance with less risk.

KBWY

ROOF

IYR

Page 10: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

SPT: Volatility Statistics

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

10 Year Alpha: 5.02

10 Year Beta: 1.12

10 Year SR: 0.46

5 Year Alpha: 11.13

5 Year Beta: 0.81 5 Year SR: 1.18

3 Year Alpha 10.36

3 Year Beta: 0.98 3 Year SR: 1.20

Benchmarked to MSCI World Index

Page 11: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Stanford Blyth Fund FICC

2. ETF Composition

Page 12: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

ETF Component Weightings

Replicate MSCI REIT Index (2/3rd of US real estate market)

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 13: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

ETF Composition

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Top 10 Holdings (37.5%) (01/31/2015)

Simon Property Group (SPG) 8.4%

Public Storage (PSA) 4.1%

Equity Residential (EQR) 3.9%

Health Care REIT Inc (HCN) 3.6%

ProLogis (PLD) 3.2%

AvalonBay Communities Inc (AVB) 3.1%

Ventas Inc (VTR) 3.1%

HighLand Capital Partners (HCP) 3.0%

Vornado Realty Trust (VNO) 2.9%

Boston Properties (BXP) 2.9%

Others 62.5%

Page 14: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Sample ETF Components

VNQ ETF 47.3 4.47% 3.56

Holdings SectorP/E

Ratio Div. Yield (5

Years)P/B

Ratio

Healthcare Property Investors Inc.

Health Care Industry 21.10 4.20% 1.81

Boston Properties, Inc. Apartments 48.66 5.00% 3.85

Vornado Realty TrustD.C. & NYC Offices and

Retail103.40 2.90% 3.98

Ventas Inc.Senior Housing,

Medical46.61 N/A 2.56

Avalonbay Communities Inc.

Apartments 32.24 3.00% 2.47

Prologis Inc. Industrial 34.60 3.60% 1.57

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Dividend growth as revenue generating investment

Page 15: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Stanford Blyth Fund FICC

3. US Macroeconomic Catalysts

Quantitative Easing here and abroad

Strength of $ on USD denominated asset demand

Jobs growth and recovery prospects

Page 16: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Opportunities Frontier• Labor market strengthening. Jobs market has steadily

recovered since the crisis. Analysts predict that although the housing market has not yet responded decisively to the improvement, there will be significant momentum when demand picks up.

• Lack of attractive yield elsewhere = higher demand for US assets.

• Foreign demand for $ denominated investments will rise, particularly in real estate development projects in coastal luxury markets (i.e. SF, NYC).

Hence,

STRONG JOB GROWTH & SECULAR REAL ESTATE DEMAND02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 17: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Risk Horizon• Rates increase: FRB Federal Funds rate at 0.12% (12-month

consecutive inflation at -0.1% Jan. 2015). Rates increase (the first in almost a decade) expected around mid-year is expected.

• Regulatory barriers: Difficulty of obtaining mortgage loans due to the fallout of the 2008 Financial Crisis.

• Uncertain Economy: Last year, analysts had expected yields on 2-30 year Treasury notes and bonds to increase given a brighter overall U.S. outlook but instead they have fallen from 3.03% at the end of 2014 to 2.112% currently.

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 18: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

“The Goldilocks”

Capital structure of US real estate market with regards to QE increase resilience in real estate

prices.

Moderate rise in rates signal real economic recovery.

Sustained lower rates feed virtuous cycle in asset prices.

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 19: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Stanford Blyth Fund FICC

4. US Real Estate Sector Outlook 2015

Demand outstrips supplyCreditworthiness of sellers

improveConstruction spending increase

Page 20: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

US Real Estate Sector Summary

Post-2008 Crisis left US in housing glut.By 2011-2012 glut becomes shortage as

vacancy rates fall.

VNQ well poised to take advantage of secular growth trends in US commercial and

residential real estate. 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 21: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Housing: Demand > Supply

US Housing vacancies at 20 year lows (Q4 2015 at 7.0% = Q2 1990 levels)

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 22: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Monthly $pending on Construction ↑

Seasonally adjusted construction expenditures at 2004 levels.

In 2014, US Construction Activity +$981 Billion Annual

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 23: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Construction Spending Remains ↓ 10-Year Mark

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

US Census BureauSeasonally Non-Adjusted Residential and Nonresidential Construction

(2005 – 2015)

Page 24: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Number of Distressed Sellers ↓

Pre-crisis lows in property foreclosures and short sales.

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 25: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

While Mortgage Credit Improves…

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 26: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

…Far From Pre-Crisis Highs

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Page 27: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

Cause for Optimism

02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch

Housing starts still below long-run average.As an equity ETF VNQ has much to gain still from rising

demand once consumer credit conditions and construction continue recover to normalcy.

Page 28: Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Winter Quarter 2015 Pitch Vanguard REIT Index Fund (VNQ) 02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter

VNQ Investment Summary

VNQ is a fairly priced investment that stands to benefit from both loose credit conditions

as well as a moderate raise in interest rates.Fundamentals in US residential and

commercial real estate are strong and growing stronger.

Short term horizons: slightly overbought.Possibility of moderate pullback.

Given an investment timeframe of +1~2 years:

Medium to long term prognosis is excellent02/26/2015Stanford Blyth Fund FICC Coverage Group 2015 Winter Quarter Pitch