Standardized Testing (1)

EDU 330: Educational Psychology

Daniel Moos

Standardized testing: Warm-up activity

Think about a time when you took a standardized test (e.g., SAT, ACT) and reflect on the following questions:

1) When you received your score for this test, did you know how to interpret the score?

2) Did you feel as though the test was an accurate assessment?

3) How should standardized tests be used?

4) Is there a place for standardized tests in education? Why or why not?

Validity, continued

Type Description

Content validity

Predictive validity

Construct validity

Ability to appropriately sample the content taught and accurately measure the extent to which students understand the content; i.e. the extent to which test content is consistent with curriculum objectivesAbility to gauge a learner’s future performance; determined by comparing test results with other measures (i.e. GPA)

Logical connection with the area it is designed to measure; determined by professional assessment

Classroom Assessment: Validity & reliability

Statistics and standard scores (1)

Evaluating results of standardized tests through descriptive statistics (Measures of central tendency):

(1) Mean:

Average score

(2) Median:

Middle score in the distribution

(3) Mode:

Most frequent score

(4) Range:

Distance between top and bottom score in distribution

Statistics and standard scores (2)

How should you use mean, median, mode, and range to interpret the results?

70, 80, 80, 80, 90 Mean:

(400/5) = 80 Median:

80 Mode:

80Range:

(90-70) = 20

Statistics and standard scores (3)

How should you use mean, median, mode, and range to interpret the results? (continued)

20, 80, 80, 80, 90 Mean:

(350/5) = 70 Median:

80 Mode:

80Range:

(90-20) = 70

Statistics and standard scores (4)

How should you use mean, median, mode, and range to interpret the results? (continued)

60, 60, 80, 100, 100 Mean:

(400/5) = 80 Median:

80 Mode: 60, 100Range:

(100 – 60) = 40

Statistics and standard scores (5) Standard Deviation (SD):

Statistical measure of spread of scores If data points are close to mean, then SD ≈ 0 If many data points are not close to mean, then SD >

Formula Example on board

Example: Mean of scores is 40 and standard deviation of 4

40 44 48 5228 32 36

50%84% 98% 100%0% 2% 16%

Statistics and standard scores (6)

Evaluating standardized tests through descriptive statistics, continued

Standard Error of Measurement Due to measurement error, scores represent an

approximation of student’s “true” score Example: Dan obtains a score of 54 on a standardized test. If

the standard error of measurement is 3, then the range of Dan’s true score would be 51 to 57.

Normal Distribution: Mean, median and mode are (roughly) equal; scores

distribute themselves symmetrically in a bell-shaped curve

Statistics and standard scores (7) Raw Scores:

What do they really mean? Percentiles (also call Percentile Ranks):

≠ percentages Rankings may not be equal; example:

raw score of 58 = 90th percentile raw score of 56 = 80th percentile Raw score of 54 = 60th percentile

Stanines: Range: 1 to 9 Stanine 5 = center of distribution One Stanine above/below = +/- 0.5 SD Stanine 6 = +0.5 SD; Stanine 4 = -0.5 SD; Stanine 8 = __SD

• Grade equivalents: Compares scores with particular age group (1st digit = grade, 2nd digit = month); Grade equivalent for total reading of 8.4 means __ ?

Statistics and standard scores (8):

Ending Exercises (1)

A superintendent from New Hampshire says:“Standardized testing has its place -- but

standardized testing should only be one piece of the picture of a child's performance or a school/district's performance at a given time. It is essential to educate ourselves and our communities about what standardized testing measures -- and what it does not measure….I like the analogy that standardized testing is a snapshot that is one entry into an album about a child or school”

Ending Exercises (2)

A high school science teacher from Washington, DC says:

“I think they can limit the teaching environment because you end up  teaching to the test.  I think they can ultimately narrow the curriculum….

 They do provide a basis, are consistent because the scorer cannot be biased since there is only one answer (that is, if it is multiple choice!)….

I  have always created my own tests, never have I used a ‘book test’...I  feel this way my students have the opportunity to demonstrate what  they know through short answer, longer essays, etc.”

Ending Exercises (3)

A high school senior from Washington, DC says:

“ I don’t know. I guess they are important, but I don’t think one test can really tell you how good a student I am…or even tell you how much I have learned. I just get real nervous when I take them because they are important, but it is kind of a one shot deal. I don’t think that is very fair.”

Ending Exercises (4)

(1) In your opinion, what are the pros and cons in using student performance on standardized tests to evaluate teachers?

Please reference at least one concept we have talked about today (e.g., functions such as assessments and evaluation; statistical issues such as central tendency, validity)

(2) The correlation between SAT and college grades is .42 (Shepard, 1993). Why do you think there is not a stronger positive relationship between these two?