St ronmental Prote STRE ET ADDRESS: MAILING ADDRESS 4 … · Dana State Ohio P.O. Colum ments and/ ished in the essing the T ic hearing is rtunity to c it will be is received. erely,

STRE

Lazaru50 W.Colum 1/28 GregTroy2237Luck RE: Dear A draof thlocalpermhttp:mark

Compublprocpubloppopermbeen Sinc

MichPerm Cc:

ET ADDRESS:

us Government C Town St., Suite

mbus, Ohio 43215

/2010

g Ball y Energy, LL79 Pembervkey, OH 434

DRAFT APermit Ty

r Permit Hol

aft of the OAhis draft is tol newspaper

mit has b//www.epa.oked-up copy

DanaStateOhio P.O. Colum

mments and/ished in the

cessing the Tic hearing isortunity to cmit will be isn received.

cerely,

hael W. Ahermit Issuance

U.S. EPAOhio EPA

Center 700

5

C ille Road

443

AIR POLLUType: Renew

der:

AC Chapter o solicit publr, The Sentibeen postohio.gov/dapy of the perm

a Thompson e Implementa

EPA, DAPCBox 1049 mbus, Ohio

/or a requese newspapeTitle IV perms conducted.omment prio

ssued final aIf you have

rn, Manager

e and Data M

A Region 5 -A-NWDO;

St

TION CONTwal

3745-103 Tic commentsnel-Tribune.ted to thpc in Micros

mit or in narra

ation Plan SC

43216-1049

st for a pubr. You will mit will be m. You will thor to the 45after U.S. Eany question

r Management

- Via E-Mail Michigan; I

tate of Ohio Envi

TELE: (614) 64ww

TROL TITLE

Title IV perms. A public . A copy ofhe Divisionoft Word anative format.

Section

9

blic hearing be notified

made after cen be provid

5-day PropoPA review ins, please c

t Section, DA

NotificationIndiana

ironmental Prote

44-3020 FAX: (614) 6ww.epa.ohio.gov

IV ACID RA

mit for the refnotice will af the public n of Air d Adobe Ac Any comm

will be accein writing if

considerationded with a P

osed Title IVis completed

contact Dana

APC

ection Agency

44-3184

AIN PERMIT

ferenced facappear in thenotice and t

Pollution crobat forma

ments must b

epted withina public he

n of commePreliminary PV permit subd and no oba Thompson

CertifieFacilityPermitCounty

T

cility has beee Ohio EPA the draft pe

Control at. Commenbe sent to:

n 30 days oearing is schnts received

Proposed Titbmittal to U.bjections to at (614) 644

ed Mail y ID: 038700t Number: Py: Wood

MAI

Columbus,

en issued. TWeekly Revrmit are enc(DAPC)

nts will be ac

of the date theduled. A d and oral tetle IV permit S. EPA Regthe final iss4-3701.

00377 0104712

LING ADDRESS

P.O. Box 1049OH 43216-1049

The purposeview and theclosed. ThisWeb pageccepted as a

the notice isdecision on

estimony if aand anothe

gion 5. Thesuance have

S:

9 9

e e s e a

s n a

er e e

Wood County

PUBLIC NOTICE

ISSUANCE OF DRAFT AIR POLLUTION Title IV Acid Rain Permit Troy Energy, LLC

Issue Date: 1/28/2010 Permit Number: P0104712 Permit Type: Renewal Permit Description: Renewal of Title IV Acid Rain Permit Facility ID: 0387000377 Facility Location: Troy Energy, LLC 22379 Pemberville Road, Luckey, OH 43443 Facility Description: Fossil Fuel Electric Power Generation Chris Korleski, Director of the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, 50 West Town Street, Columbus Ohio, has issued a draft action of an air pollution control Title IV Acid Rain permit for the facility at the location identified above on the date indicated. Comments concerning this draft action, or a request for a public meeting, must be sent in writing no later than thirty (30) days from the date this notice is published. All comments, questions, requests for permit applications or other pertinent documentation, and correspondence concerning this action must be directed to Donald Waltermeyer at Ohio EPA DAPC, Northwest District Office, 347 North Dunbridge Road or (419)352-8461. The permit can be downloaded from the Web page: www.epa.state.oh.us/dapc

State of Ohio Environmental Protection Agency Division of Air Pollution Control

Draft

Title IV Acid Rain Permit OAC Chapter 3745-103

Troy Energy, LLC

Facility ID: 0387000377 Permit Number: P0104712 Permit Type: Renewal Issued: 1/28/2010 Effective: To be entered upon final issuance Expiration: To be entered upon final issuance


Title IV Acid Rain Permit OAC Chapter 3745-103

Troy Energy, LLC Table of Contents

Authorization ......................................................................................................................................................... 1 A. Standard Terms and Conditions ..................................................................................................................... 2

1. Statement of Basis .................................................................................................................................... 3 2. Permit Application ..................................................................................................................................... 3

B. Emissions Unit Terms and Conditions ............................................................................................................ 4 1. P001 .......................................................................................................................................................... 5 2. P002 .......................................................................................................................................................... 6 3. P003 .......................................................................................................................................................... 7 4. P004 .......................................................................................................................................................... 8

Draft Title IV Acid Rain Permit Permit Number: P0104712

Facility ID: 0387000377 Effective Date: To be entered upon final issuance

Page 1 of 8


Authorization Facility ID: 0387000377 Facility Description: 670 MW Peaking Station Consisting of four Natural Gas/#2 Oil fired turbines and (2)

2,200,000 gallon storage tank. Application Number(s): A0036914 Permit Number: P0104712 Permit Description: Renewal of Title IV Acid Rain Permit Permit Type: Renewal Issue Date: 1/28/2010 Effective Date: To be entered upon final issuance Expiration Date: To be entered upon final issuance This document constitutes issuance of an OAC Chapter 3745-103 Title V permit to:

Troy Energy, LLC 22379 Pemberville Road Luckey, OH 43443

The above named entity is hereby granted a Title IV acid rain permit pursuant to Chapter 3745-103 of the Ohio Administrative Code. This permit shall expire at midnight on the expiration date shown above. You will be sent a notice approximately 6 months prior to the expiration date regarding the renewal of this permit. It is the permittee’s responsibility to renew this permit even if no notice of its expiration is received. If a renewal permit is not issued prior to the expiration date, the permittee may continue to follow the terms and conditions of this permit beyond the expiration date, if a timely renewal application is submitted. A renewal application will be considered timely if it is submitted by the expiration date. This permit is granted subject to the conditions attached hereto. Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

Chris Korleski Director



Page 2 of 8


A. Standard Terms and Conditions



Page 3 of 8


1. Statement of Basis

a) In accordance with Ohio Revised Code Section 3704 and Titles IV and V of the Clean Air Act, the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency issues this permit pursuant to Ohio Administrative Code (OAC) Chapters 3745-103 and 3745-77.

2. Permit Application

a) Attached as part of this permit is the permittee’s Title IV Acid Rain Permit Application (See Appendix A). The application contains additional conditions, terms and limitations that must be met and that are a part of this permit. The application identifies the affected source, affected units, and specifies standard requirements (Permit Requirements, Monitoring Requirements, Sulfur Dioxide Requirements, Nitrogen Oxides Requirements, Excess Emissions Requirements, Record keeping and Reporting Requirements, Liability, and Effect on Other Authorities).



Page 4 of 8


B. Emissions Unit Terms and Conditions



Page 5 of 8


1. P001

ORIS Code: 55348

Acid Rain Program Description:

Unit 1

a) Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) Allowance Allocations

The owners and operators of each source and each affected unit at the sources shall:

(1) Hold allowances, as of the allowance transfer deadline, in the source's compliance account (after deductions under 40 CFR 73.34(c)), not less than the total annual emissions of sulfur dioxide for the previous calendar year from the affected units at the source; and

(2) Comply with the applicable Acid Rain emissions limitations for sulfur dioxide.

b) Nitrogen Oxides (NOx) Requirements

(1) The requirements in this permit are designed to meet Title IV of the Clean Air Act and the corresponding regulations of U.S. EPA and Ohio EPA. This source is also required to meet any applicable requirements of OAC rules 3745-14-01 through 3745-14-12.

c) Comments, Notes, and Justifications

(1) None.



Page 6 of 8


2. P002

ORIS Code: 55348


Unit 2








(1) None.



Page 7 of 8


3. P003

ORIS Code: 55348


Unit 3








(1) None.



Page 8 of 8


4. P004

ORIS Code: 55348


Unit 4








(1) None.

United StatesEnvironmental Protection AgencyAcid Rain Program

OMB No. 2060.0258

Page 1

STEP 1Identify the source byplant name, State, andORIS code.

CanpiBlC8Pm

I Ib c d. e

Unit ID It Unit WillHold

Allowances InAccordancev.;th 40 CFR

72.9(c)(1)

R~PIM

New Units New Units

CanmenceOperatIon Date

MonitorCertification

Deacline

v.1 ~ -~Q~ S~D. 2002v-2 ~. __~@A Sep. 20Q2v.3 ~OO2 Sep. 2002Mar

~

-.i Mar. 2QO2 SeD. 2002v-v-

STEP 2Enter the unit ID # foreach affected unit,and indicate whethera unit is beingrepowered and therepowering plan beingrenewed by entering"yes" or "no" atcolumn c. For newunits, enter therequested informationin columns d and e.

Yes

v.v.Yes

Yes

y~

0 f« eEM:h ri that Is bEing ~. the R8IX1if'9I1ng Ext~kJn Plan form Is 1ooIuded.

STEP 3Check the box if theresponse in column c ofStep 2 is "Yes" for anyunit.

EPA Form 7610-16 (rei. 4-98)S1F ENV595F. 1

For more information, see instructions and refer to 40 CFR 72.30 and 72.31

This submission Is: p New ~ Revised

STEP 4Read the standardrequirements andcertification, enterthe name of thedesignatedrepresentative, andsign and date

Standard Requirements Phase II P~ . Page 2

Permit Reaulrements.

(1) The designated representative of each affected source and ~h affected unit at the source sha!:(i) Submit a complete Acid Ran permit appUcatIoo (Including a compliance plan) under 40 CFR part 72 In acccxdancewith !he deadlines specified in 40 CFR 72.30; and(Ii) Submit In a tllnfjy manner any supJliementai informatloo that the ~ authority determWtes Is n~essay In orderto re-.'iew an Acid Rain permit appiicatlcx1 and issue or deny an Acid Rain permit;

(2) The 11M'8fS and operators cX ~h aff~ted source and each affected unit at the source shall:(I) Operate the unit In compliance with a complete AckJ Rain permit appHcatlon or a superseling Acid Ran permit issuedby the permitting authority; and(II) Have an AckJ RaIn Permit.

Monitorlna Reaulrements.

(1) The attnerS and operators Md, to the extent ~e, designated representative fA each affected source and eachaffected unit at the source shalcomply with the monitoring requirements ~ prC1Jided In 40 CFR part 75-(2) The emissions measurements recorded and reported In accordance with 40 CFR part 75shal be used to determinecompli8\Ce by the unit with the Acid Rain emlssloos limltatioos and emlssloos reducbrequlrem~ts for sulfur <ioxide 51dnitrogen oxides under the Ackt Rain Program.(3) The requirements of 40 CFR part 75 shal not aff~t the responsibility of the ~ and operators to monitor emissionscX ~ pollutants or otheremlssloos characteristics at the unit under other appIcabIe requirements of !he Act and ~provisions cX the operating permit for !he soorce.

Sulfur Dioxide R~uirements.

(1) The ~ers and ~ors of ~h source and ~h affected unit at the soorce $/WI:(I) Hold aI~es, as cX the all<7Nance trmIsf« deacllne, in !he unit's compliance subaccwnt (after deductloos under40 CFR 73.34(c» not less than the total annua emissions of sulfur dioJdde for the previous caendar year from the unit;and(II) Comply with the applicable Acid Rain emissialS Iknitatia1s for sulfur dioJdde.

(2) Each ton cX sulfur dio>dde emitted In ~ess of the AckJ Rain emissions limitations for sulfur dIoJdde shal constitute asepW'ate vidation fA the Act.(3) An affected unit shall be subject to the requirements under paragraph (1) of the sulfur dloJdde requirements as fdlows:

Q) Starting January 1, 2000, an affected unit under 40 CFR 72.6(a)(2); orQI) Starting 00 the later fA JMUary 1, 2000 or !he deadline for monitor certification under 40 CFR part 75, an affected unitunder 40 CFR 72.6(a)(3).

(4) AllaNances shal be held in, deducted f~, or transferred among Allowance Tracking System acCCXJnts in accordancewith the Acid Rain Progran.(5) An aIIaNance shal not be deducted in order to comply with the requirements under paragraph (1) of the sulfur dloJdde~r~ts prior to the calendar year for which the allowance was allocated.(6) An allC1Nance alk)Cated by the Admlnlstrat« under the Acid Rain Program Is a limited authorization to emit sulfur dioJddeIn acC«dance with the Acid Rain Progrwn. No pfO'I'isloo of the AckJ Ran Program, the Acid RaIn permit application, the AcidRain permit, or 51 exemption under 40 CFR 72.7, 72.8 or 72.14 and no pr<Nision of law shall be construed to limit the authorityfA the United States to terminate « limit such authorization.(7) An aI/owa}Ce aIocated by the Administrator under the Acid Rain progran does not constitute a p~ right.

Nitrooen 0Jddes RecaJir~ts. The ~ and operators of the source and each affected 00t at the source shal complywith the applicable Acid Rain emissions Imitation f« nitrogen oxides.

~ Emissions R~ulr~ts.

(1) The designated representative cX an affected unit that hM ~ess emissions m any calendar year shal sutxnit a proposedcXfset plM, as required under 40 CFR pcvt 77.(2) The ~n and ~ators of an affected unit that hM ~ess emissions In any calendar year shal:

Q) Pay wlthwt demand the penalty required, and pay upon demand the Interest 00 thm peraty, as required by 40 CFRpart 77; andQI) Comply with the terms of an approved off~ plan, as required by 40 CFR part 77.

RecorclteENJina ~ ReoortIna R~ulrements.

(1) Unless otherwise pr<Nided, the owners ~ operators fA the source ~ each affected 00t at the source shaA keep 00 siteat !he source ~h fA the fdlC1Ning documents for a period of 5 years from !he date the document Is created. This period maybe extended for cause, at any time prior to the end of 5 years, In writing by !he Administrator « permitting authority:

(i) The certifICate cX repres~tation for the designated representative for the source and each affected unit at the soorceand all documents that demonstrate !he truth of !he statements i1!he certificate fA ~resentatlon, In ~ordance with 40CFR 72.24; prI:7IIided that the cel1ificate and documents shal be retained on site at !he source b9)tond such 5-year perioduntil such documents are superseded because of !he submission of a new certificate of representation c~ng thedesignated representative;(II) AD emissions monitoring information, in ~ordance with 40 CFR part 75, pr<7.Iided that to the extent that 40 CFR part75 ~ f« a 3-year period for recortJ(eeping, the 3-year period shall apply.(1I1)CopIes cX aD reports, compliance cel1lflcations, and ~ submissions and all rec«ds made or required under theAcid Rain Program; and,(Iv) ~es cX all documents used to complete an Acid Rain permit appIicatlcx1 and any other submission under the AcidRan Program or to dema1strate compliance with the requirements of the AckJ Rain Program.

(2) The des9'ated r~resentative of an affected swrce and each aff~ted unit at the source shall submit !he reports andccmpliance certifications required under the Ackt Ran ProgriWn, including those under 40 CFR pcvt 72 subpart I and 40 CFRpart 75.

PlMt N8ne (frcwn Step 1)

Troy Energy,LLCEPA Foon 7810-16 (rw. 4-98)STF~.2

Phase II Permit - p. 3

~.(1) Any person who ~ngly viaates any requirgnent or prohibition of the Acid Rain ProgrIm, a canpiMe AcId Ran permitapplication, 81 Acid Rain permit, or an exemption under 40 CFR 72.7, 72.8, or 72.14, including any requir8n~ for thepayment of any P«JaJty owed to the United States, shall be subject to enforc~ent pursuant to section 113(c) of the Act.(2) Any peI'Son who kn~ngly makes a false, material statgnent in any record,submisslon, or report under the Acid RainPrograms~1 besubjecttocrimin~ enforcgnent pursuant to section 113(c) of the Act s1d 18 U.S.C.1001.(3) No permlt~ ShaileJa:US8 any vioIation« therequirgnents oftheAcidR2MRiProg~thatoocurs~.to the datethat the r~sion takes effect.(4) Each affected source a')d ~h affected unit shall meet the ~r8nents of the Ackj Rain Program.(5) Any prOJislat of the Acid Ran P~ t\at ~ies k> an affected source (~Iudng a prOJislal aA'lic8)le to the designatedrepresentative of an affected source) shaI also apply to the ~ers and ~tors of such source a')d of the affected ooits atthe source.(6) Any ~ of the Acid Ran progrcvn that applies to an aff~ted unit (incluclng a prCNislon appIcabIe to the desiglatedrepresentative of 81 affected unit) shall also apply to the ~ers and operators of such unit. Except as proo.Ijded under 40 CFR72.44 (PhEe II ~gextensioo plans) a'ld40CFR 76.11 (OOx~g plans), arxJ eJa:eptwith re{JWdtothereqUrementsapplicable to units with a canmon stack under 40 CFR part 75 (inducing 40 CFR 75.16, 75.17, a'Id 75.18), the ~ers andoperators a'Id the des9\8ted representative of one affected unit s~1 not be liable for any vtaatIon by 81y other affected unitof MUch they are not owners or operators or the designated representative and that is kx:ated at a source of which they are notowners or operators or the designated representative.(7) E~h viaation of a pr~slon of 40 CFR parts 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77, and 78 by an affected source or affected unit, or by81 ~er or operator or deslSJ'lated representative of such source or unit, ~I be a separate vioIatioo of the Act.

Eff~t 00 Other A~. No p~ion of the Acid RSI P~, 81 Acid Rain permit ~ication, mt Acid Rain permit, or81 exemption ooder 40 CFR 72.7, 72.8, or 72.14 shaM be construed as:

(1) Except as expressly provided in tiUe IV of the Act, exempting or eJa:llKIlng the owners and q>erators and, to the extent~lcable, the designated representative of 81 affected source or aff~ted unit from compliance with any other prC11/Ision ofthe Act, IncI~ the provisions of tiUe I of the Act relating to appIi~e National Ambient Air Quality Standards or StateImpltmentatlon PI81s;(2) Umiting the number of allowances a unit can had; provkled, that the number of allowances held by the unit shall not affectthe source's obligation to comply with any other pr~sions of the Act;

(3) Requiring a Ch81ge of any kind In mty State law regulating electric utility rates 81d charges, affecting any State lawregarding such State regulation, or limiting such State regulation, Including any prudence review requirements under suchState law;

(4) Modifying the Federal PCNIer Act or aff~ting the authority of the Federal Energy Regulatory Cornmlssm under theFederal PCNIer Act; or,(5) Intelferlng with or impairing any program for canpetiUve ~ng for power supply in a State In which such ~~ isestablished.

Certification

I am authorized to make this submission on behalf of the owners and operators of the affected source or affected units forwhich the submlssioo Is made. I certify under penalty of law that I have personaiy e~lned, and am familiar with, thestat~ents and informatioo submitted in this document and all Its attachments. Based on my inquiry of those incividuaIs withprimary responsibility for obtaining the Information, I certify that the statgnents and informatioo are to the best of my ~edgeand belief true, accurate, and canpiete. I ~ aware that there are significant penalties for submitting false statgnents andinformation or omitting required statements and Information, Including the possibility of fine or Imprisonment

EPA Fam 7610-16 (rev. 4-98)S1F EMf59SF.3

Documents

St ronmental Prote STRE ET ADDRESS: MAILING ADDRESS 4 … · Dana State Ohio P.O. Colum ments and/ ished in the essing the T ic hearing is rtunity to c it will be is received. erely,