7
q

sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

VyVV 1((du(M;1

q�s`�{�B�k VtsjkR$R PB� 78sjj 7s��jj$�� _skjBsI

i�{B%��k P�B8 NBb es��Y !�A$�

<kZt�bBt �$8 stI 3�st, �� NZG

=t$%��R$�k BP q�-sR s� V�j$t��Bt� V�j$t��Bt� q�-sR �E(d�

stI

Ns��k W� �{Wsk�

qe�7Vi� 3B�� GB��Y� q�-sR �EddE

qY� ���t��k ��s`�{�B�$�R BP s 11� ,� 8sRR s� �d�; ,8 sj�$�ZI� stI s %�jB{$�k BP ��nd ,8\R

bsR stsjk9�I b$�Y s 8BI$h�I �Y��� I�����TBPTP���IB8 ��{Yt$JZ�� Vt �R�$8s�� BP �Y�

R�s�ts�$Bt }B$t� Y�s�$t� bsR sjRB 8sI�� qY� 8sRR I�}jBk�I st $t4s�sAj�� �Y��� �j�8�t�

I�s� I$R, I�{�j��s�B� �Ys� bsR 8BI�j�I sR s R$t�j� {$�{Zjs� I$R,� ��s$j$t� �Y� }skjBsI�

tB�8sj �B �Y� I$��{�$Bt BP 4$�Y�� y� bsR PBZtI �Ys� �Y� IBbt�st�� I$R�st{� I�{��sR�I stI

�Y� �$8� BP 4$�Y� $t{��sR�I b$�Y $t{��sR�I I�{�j��s�B� s��s� qY� R�s�ts�$BtT}B$t� Y�s�

��stRP�� �s��R b$�Y s I�{�j��s�B� BP RZ^{$�t�jk jBb Asjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t� w1; _s� (�x jA\P�1D

bsR x �B d( }��{�t� �Ys� s �k}${sj Asjj$R�${ ���t��k %�Y${j� b$�Y s Asjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t� BP

d(( jA\P�1 w;�M ,_sD� qY� R�ZIk I$I tB� htI �Ys� R�s��I I�}jBk8�t� BP �Y� I�{�j��s�B�

I$R,R }�B%$I�I stk s��BIkts8${ sI%st�s��R� }s��${Zjs�jk $t %$�b BP �Y� st�${$}s��I

{B8}j�-$�$�R $t%Bj%�I $t I�}jBk$t� RZ{Y s RkR��8� 3$tsjjk� R,$} ��s`�{�B�$�R k$�jI�I Rj$�Y�jk

jBb�� R�s�ts�$BtT}B$t� Y�s� ��stRP�� �Yst �Y� tBtTj$P�$t� {sR�� <Bb�%��� �Y�k 8sk tB�

A� sI%st�s��BZR R$t{� �Y� $t{��sR�I 4$�Y� �$8� bBZjI �-}BR� �Y� I�{�j��s�B� �B s jBt���

}��$BI BP Y�s�$t��

WB8�t{js�Z��

g; ) I�s� {B�^{$�t��z ) �tZIR�t tZ8A��Ne! ) NBb �s��Y B�A$��R� ) Y�s� ��stRP�� �s��p] ) tBR� �sI$ZRC ) {�BRRTR�{�$Btsj s��s BP I�{�j��s�B�J ) %�jB{$�k' ) I�tR$�k

7ZAR{�$}�R

{Bt� ) {Bt�$tZZ8 j$8$�]! ) {$�{Zjs� B�A$� w��� ,8\R� 1E ,P�\RDP8 ) P��� 8Bj�{Zjs� j$8$���P ) ��P���t{�7N ) R�s j�%�j ) P���R���s8

yt��BIZ{�$Bt

q<eie $R ��{�t� $t����R� $t ZR$t� j$�Y�b�$�Y� $t4sT

�sAj� I�{�j��s�B�R PB� ��{B%��$t� R8sjj }skjBsIR�RZ{Y sR Ne! Rs��jj$��R� }jst��s�k Rs8}j� ���Z�t %�Y$T{j�R� RZATB�A$�sj �B{,��R stI Y$�YTsj�$�ZI� R{$�t�$h{ AsjTjBBtR� b$�YBZ� �Y� b�$�Y� }�tsj�k sRRB{$s��I b$�Y ����B

]B}k�$�Y� {s1((d Ak �Y� V8��${st ytR�$�Z�� BP V��BtsZ�${R

stI VR��BtsZ�${R� yt{� Vjj �$�Y�R ��R��%�I�

~i�R�s�{Y VRRB{$s��� ��{Yst${sj stI V��BR}s{� et�$t���$t�

*�}s��8�t�� ��8A�� VyVV�

G_�BP�RRB� stI *$��{�B�� V��BIkts8${R i�R�s�{Y ]�t���� ��T

{Yst${sj stI V��BR}s{� et�$t���$t� *�}s��8�t�� VRRB{$s�� 3�jT

jBb VyVV�

�z${� _��R$I�t�� E��� ]s8} Bb$� BZj�%s�I� 7Z$�� nnd�

�B{,��R stI Y�s� RY$�jIR B� �$j�R� VII$�$Btsjjk� RB8�}skjBsIR 8sk ��JZ$�� s RkR��8 �B s{{B88BIs�� }��T8s�Z�� ��{B%��k� RZ{Y sR $t sAB��$%� jsZt{Y�R� $8}�B}��B�A$�sj $tR���$BtR stI R}s{�{�sP� B}��s�$Btsj Ps$jZ��R BtB�A$��qY� $t{��sR�I }��R�t{� BP 8stt�I R}s{� 4$�Y� $t Ne!

YsR sjRB {sZR�I $t{��sR$t� {Bt{��t B%�� Ys9s�IR }BR�IAk R}s{� B�A$�sj I�A�$R� 7�%��sj {Bt{�}�R Ys%� A��t }�BT}BR�I PB� ��IZ{$t� �Y� Ys9s�IR �Ys� R}s{� B�A$�sj I�A�$R{st }BR� AB�Y $t Ne! stI Bt �Y� ��BZtI� 3B� �-s8T}j�� R}s{� %�Y${j�R $t Ne! ��s{Y$t� �Y� �tI BP �Y�$�8$RR$Bt j$P� {st A� I�TB�A$��I B� }js{�I $t s ��IZ{�Ij$P��$8� B�A$� �B ��IZ{� �Y� }BRR$A$j$�k BP st s{{$I�t�sj{Bjj$R$Bt� qY� js���� s}}�Bs{Y {st A� }��PB�8�I b$�Y{Bt��Bjj�I ���t��k 8st�Z%��R ZR$t� ����BT�B{,��R� bY${Y{st ��TB�A$� �Y� %�Y${j� �B s jBb�� sj�$�ZI� B� {sZR� $� �B���t��� stI AZ�t Z}� <Bb�%��� �Y� t��I �B {s��k sII$T�$Btsj PZ�j �B s{{B8}j$RY RZ{Y 8st�Z%��R b$jj I$8$t$RY�Y� R}s{� %�Y${j�:R 8$RR$Bt� 3Z��Y��� R�ZI$�R Ys%� $tI$T{s��I �Ys� RB8� BP �Y� 8B�� 8sRR$%� {B8}Bt�t�R BP �Y�%�Y${j� 8sk tB� AZ�t Z} {B8}j���jk stI {st ��s{Y �Y�es��Y:R RZ�Ps{� s� jB{s�$BtR �Ys� s�� Ys�I �B }��I${��]Z���t�jk ZtI�� I�%�jB}8�t� $R st sj���ts�� s}T

}�Bs{Y �B R}s{�{�sP� ��{B%��k� qY$R s}}�Bs{Y ZR�R st$t4s�sAj� I�{�j��s�B� RkR��8 �Ys� sjjBbR PB� s }��{$R$Bt��{B%��k BP �Y� �t�$�� %�Y${j� P�B8 B�A$�� qY� h�R� }s��BP �Y$R RkR��8 $t%Bj%�R s js���� j$�Y�b�$�Y� $t4s�sAj�R��Z{�Z�� �Ys� $R I�R$�t�I �B PZt{�$Bt sR s jBb 8sRRTs��s I�s� A�s,� s� Y$�Y sj�$�ZI�� qY� R�{BtI }s�� BP�Y$R RkR��8 $R s {B8}Z���T�Z$I�I }s�sPB$j ��{B%��k I�T%${�� qY� $t4s�sAj� R��Z{�Z�� $R I�}jBk�I $t Ne! �B{sZR� st B�A$�sj %�jB{$�k I�{��sR� �Y�BZ�Y s��BA�s,$t��qY$R I�{��sR� $t B�A$�sj %�jB{$�k ��RZj�R $t s �s}$I B�TA$�sj I�{sk BP �Y� Rs��jj$��� bY${Y $t �Z�t $t$�$s��R s�T8BR}Y��${ ���t��k� qY� $t4s��I R��Z{�Z�� {Bt�$tZ�R �B

d

Page 2: sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

��t��s�� $t{��sR�I I�s� sR �Y� %�Y${j� PsjjR I��}�� $t�B�Y� s�8BR}Y���� V RZ{{�RRPZjjk I�R$�t�I I�s� I�%${�b$jj sjjBb �Y� B%��sjj %�Y${j� �B s{Y$�%� RZARBt${ %�jB{T$�$�R b�jj sAB%� �Y� B}�$8Z8 }s�sPB$j I�}jBk8�t� sj�$T�ZI�� !t{� �Y� I�R$��I %�jB{$�k stI sj�$�ZI� YsR A��ts{Y$�%�I� �Y� $t4s��I R��Z{�Z�� $R ��j�sR�I stI �Y� sZT�BtB8BZR }s�sPB$j $R I�}jBk�I PB� s }��{$R$Bt �Z$I�I hTtsj ��{B%��k� qY$R 8sk sjRB A� �Y� RsP�R� bsk �B ��IZ{�R}s{� B�A$�sj I�A�$R�3B� �-s8}j�� $t �Y� ��{�t� s���8}� BP �Y� iZRR$stT

p��8st yt4s�sAj� i��t��k stI *�R{�t� q�{YtBjB�k %�TY${j�� �Y� RY$�jI $t4s��R P�B8 s d 8 wn�n P�D {B8}s{�}s{,s�� Z} �B d1udE 8 wn�uxn P�D RYB��jk A�PB�� ���tT��k stI �Y�t� $P $� RZ�%$%�R ���t��k� PZt{�$BtR sR s I�s�{Bt� �B �j$I� �Y� }skjBsI As{, �B �s��Y� qY� {Bt{�}�BP ZR$t� $t4s�sAj� I�{�j��s�B�R PB� ��{B%��$t� }skjBsIRP�B8 R}s{� bsR s{�Zsjjk }�B}BR�I $t �Y� js�� d�;(R�d yt�s�jk �-}��$8�t�R� tkjBt }s�s{YZ��R b��� I�}jBk�I s�sj�$�ZI�R $t �-{�RR BP dM( ,8 wE(( ,P�D� qY� }s�s{YZ��Rb��� PBZtI �B }s��$sjjk $t4s�� stI �Y�t {Bjjs}R� {k{j$T{sjjk s� Y$�Y sj�$�ZI�� A�PB�� A�{B8$t� PZjjk $t4s��I s�jBb sj�$�ZI�� qY� BZ��� �I�� BP �Y� }s�s{YZ�� {stB}kbsR PBZtI �B A� 8�j��I� qY$R bsR s���$AZ��I �B �Y�Y$�Y Y�s�$t� �s��R sRRB{$s��I �Y� Y$�Y P���TPsjj %�jB{$�kbY�t �Y� }s�s{YZ�� {Bjjs}R�I� qB }��%�t� {stB}k {BjTjs}R�� st $t4s��I �$t� �B s��$h{$sjjk $t4s�� �Y� {stB}kbsR ZR�I RZ{{�RRPZjjk�1 sR�I Bt �Y$R RZ{{�RRPZj �-}��$T8�t�� $� bsR �YBZ�Y� �Ys� s RZ^{$�t�jk js���� Y$�Y I�s�I�%${� {BZjI A� ZR�I �B I�TB�A$� s Rs��jj$��� yP RZ^T{$�t� I�{�j��s�$Bt B{{Z���I Y$�Y $t �Y� s�8BR}Y���� �Y$RbBZjI R$�t$h{st�jk ��IZ{� s��BIkts8${ Y�s�$t�� <BbT�%��� {sj{Zjs�$BtR $tI${s��I �Ys� �Y� st�${$}s��I 8s-$T8Z8 ���t��k ��8}��s�Z��R Ps� �-{��I �Y� 8�j�$t� }B$t�BP tkjBt� qY$R {Bt{�}� bsR sAstIBt�I $t Ps%B� BP sAjsT�$%� Y�s� RY$�jIR� Vjj R�s��TBPT�Y�Ts�� ��{B%��k RkR��8RZ�$j$9� sAjs�$%� Y�s� RY$�jIR stI Y$�YTR}��I }s�s{YZ��R�B� Y�s� �$j�R stI b$t��I %�Y${j�R PB� htsj ��{B%��k� sjjBP bY${Y {s��k s R�%��� b�$�Y� }�tsj�k�!tjk ��{�t�jk Ys%� sI%st{�R $t 8s���$sjR ��{YtBjB�k

8sI� �Y� {Bt{�}� BP Y$�YTsj�$�ZI� }skjBsI ��{B%��k P�sTR$Aj�� _��j$8$ts�k �R�$8s��R $tI${s�� �Ys� st $t4s�sAj�I�s� I�%${� b$�Y s jBb Asjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t� wPbg;C )1; _s B� (�x jA\P�1D {st B}��s�� b$�Y$t �Y� 8s-$8Z8���t��k ��8}��s�Z��R BP ��{�t� Y$�YT��8}��s�Z�� $t4s�TsAj� 8s���$sjR� 7Z{Y s {Bt{�}� YsR A�t�h�R RZ{Y sR��IZ{�I b�$�Y� {B8}s��I �B sAjs�$%� Y�s� RY$�jIR stI�$j�R� jBb�� �TjBsI$t� Bt ���t��k� stI �Y� �j$8$ts�$Bt BP����BT�B{,��R ZR�I PB� $t$�$s�$t� B�A$�sj I�}s��Z���V {Bt{�}� $R A�$t� I�%�jB}�I bY��� s js��� $t4s�sAj�

I�{�j��s�B� $R I�}jBk�I $t Ne! �B ��{B%�� s }skjBsIP�B8 R}s{�� qY$R {Bt{�}� $R RYBbt R{Y�8s�${sjjk $t3$�� d� y� {BtR$R�R BP �Y��� $t4s�sAj� I�s� }js�� I�{�jT��s�B� I$R,R �Ys� {st A� I�}jBk�I $t R}s{��qY� �bB AsR${ 8��YBIR BP b$�YR�stI$t� ���t��k Y�s�T

$t� s�� sAjs�$Bt RY$�jI$t� stI �sI$s�$%� {BBj$t�� i��tT��k I�%${�R �Ys� $t{B�}B�s�� jBb Asjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t�R�s,� sI%st�s�� BP �sI$s�$Bt {BBj$t� IZ�$t� ���t��k� V�sI$s�$%� 8s���$sj {st b$�YR�stI Y$�Y �B�sj Y�s� jBsIRsR jBt� sR �Y� 8s-$8Z8 Y�s�$t� �s�� IB�R tB� �-{��I�Y� {s}sA$j$�k BP �Y� 8s���$sj� qY� }��8$RR$Aj� Y�s�$t��s�� $R s PZt{�$Bt BP ��8}��s�Z��� �$8� s� ��8}��s�Z��BP �Y� 8s���$sj� �8$RR$%$�k BP �Y� 8s���$sj� stI Y�s� {sT}s{$�k BP �Y� 8s���$sj� 7�s�ts�$Bt }B$t�R Bt �Y� ���t��k

3$�Z�� dU 7{Y�8s�${ BP }skjBsI ��{B%��k {Bt{�}��

R��Z{�Z�� �-}��$�t{� �Y� Y$�Y�R� Y�s�$t� �s��R� 7�s�tsT�$Bt }B$t�R �Ys� Ys%� s js��� �sI$ZR BP {Z�%s�Z�� Y�j} �B��IZ{� jB{sj Y�s�$t� �s��R� yP s ���t��k RkR��8 $R j$�Y��tBZ�Y wjBb 8sRRTs��s �s�$BD �Ys� $� {st A� I�{�j��s��I�B ��js�$%�jk jBb R}��IR� �%�t $P s{��I Bt Ak jBb I�s�PB�{�R� �Y�t �Y� {Bt%�{�$%� Y�s�$t� $R 8$t$8$9�I Ak �8T}jBk$t� RYs}�R b$�Y Y$�YT}��RRZ�� I�s� wAjZt� ABI$�Rb$�Y js��� �sI$$ BP {Z�%s�Z��D� 7Z{Y RYs}�R 8s-$8$9��Y� s8BZt� BP Y�s� I�j$%���I �B �Y� s�8BR}Y��� stI8$t$8$9� �Y� s8BZt� BP Y�s� I�j$%���I �B �Y� I�s� I�T%${� IZ�$t� I�{�j��s�$Bt�qY� sI%st�s�� BP I�}jBk$t� s R�{BtIs�k I�s� ABIk �B

s{Y$�%� s jBb Asjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t� {Bth�Z�s�$Bt $R �Ys�$� RY$P�R s js��� }B��$Bt BP �Y� �B�sj Y�s� jBsI wsR 8Z{YsR M( }��{�t�D sbsk P�B8 �Y� }�$8s�k ABIk� qY� 8s$t}skjBsI R�{�$Bt wRs��jj$��� ��{�D $R sAj� �B 8s,� s ��jTs�$%�jk {BBj ���t��k� N$��j� B� tB ��I�R$�t bBZjI A�t��I�I PB� �Y� }skjBsI IZ� �B �Y� �t�$�� Y�s� jBsI A�T$t� sRRZ8�I Ak �Y� sIITBt ��{B%��k I�%${��qY� {Bt{�}� BP R�s{,$t� R�%��sj I�s� }js��R $t R��$�R

$R R��t sR st �&�{�$%� RBjZ�$Bt �B s{Y$�%$t� �Y� I�R$��IAsjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t�� V {B8A$ts�$Bt BP �bB B� 8B�� $I�tT�${sj I�s� }js��R $t R��$�R $R sII$�$%� b$�Y ��R}�{� �BI�s� {B�^{$�t��n qY$R {BtI$�$Bt YBjIR ��Z� sR jBt� sR�Y� R}s{$t� A��b��t �s{Y I$R, $R RZ^{$�t�� qY� B}T�$8Z8 R}s{$t� A��b��t I�s� }js��R $t R��$�R $R R�%�tI$R, I$s8����R�; qY$R B}�$8Z8 R}s{$t� sjjBbR �Y� I�T�s{Y�I 4Bb �B$t� s�BZtI �Y� h�R� I$R, �B ��s��s{Y }�$B��B �t{BZt���$t� �Y� R�{BtI I$R,� qY� R�{BtI I$R, {st�Y�t ��t��s�� �Y� Rs8� 8s-$8Z8 I�s� {B�^{$�t� BPg; ) d31 �Ys� �Y� h�R� I$R, ��t��s��R� qY� �bB I$R,R{��s�� s {B8A$t�I I�s� {B�^{$�t� BP g; ) 13; PB� �Y�RkR��8� qY� sII$�$Bt BP s �Y$�I I�s� }js�� $t R��$�RA�$t�R �Y� {B8A$t�I �B�sj I�s� {B�^{$�t� �B g; ) n3EPB� �Y� �t�$�� RkR��8�e-s8$ts�$Bt BP s R$t�j�� 4s� I$R, I�s� }js�� s� YkT

}��RBt${ R}��IR PBZtI �Ys� �Y� I�s� {B�^{$�t� %sjZ���8s$tR {BtR�st� s� g; ) d31 PB� i�ktBjIR tZ8A��R���s��� �Yst d((� yt sII$�$Bt� }ZAj$RY�I Is�s AsR�IBt I�s� }js�� ��R�s�{Y RYBbR �Ys� s �bBTI$R, {Bth�ZT�s�$Bt $t R��$�R ��t��s��R s I�s� {B�^{$�t� �b${� �Ys�BP s R$t�j� I$R, wg; ) 13;D PB� i�ktBjIR tZ8A��R d(1stI ���s���� !t� sI%st�s�� BP �Y$R �stI�8 {Bth�Z�sT�$Bt $R �Ys� �s{Y $tI$%$IZsj I$R, {st A� 8sI� R8sjj��sR B}}BR�I �B ZR$t� Bt� R$t�j� I$R, �B 8��� �Y� Asjj$RT�${ {B�^{$�t� ��JZ$��8�t�R� qY$R }�B%$I�R s R$�t$h{st���IZ{�$Bt $t $t4s�sAj� 8s���$sj RZ�Ps{� s��s� stI �YZRs }�B}B��$Btsj ��IZ{�$Bt $t b�$�Y��qY$R }s}�� ��}B��R Bt s }��j$8$ts�k stsjkR$R BP �Y�

1

Page 3: sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

��s`�{�B�k bY�t s R8sjj ��}��R�t�s�$%� }skjBsI BP 11E�M,� wx(( jA8D $R I�TB�A$��I P�B8 st sj�$�ZI� BP �d�;,8 wn(( ,P�D� bY��� $� $R ��s%�j$t� s� ��nd ,8\R w1;,P�\RD� *$&���t� I�{�j��s�B� {Bt{�}�R b��� �-s8$t�I�qY� ��s`�{�B�$�R b��� {B8}s��I b$�Y s �k}${sj V}BjjB{s}RZj� �k}� ���t��k ��s`�{�B�k Ys%$t� s Asjj$R�${ {BT�^{$�t� Pbwg;CD BP ;�M ,_s wd(( jA\P�1D� 7,$}}$t���s`�{�B�$�R b��� sjRB �-s8$t�I sR }s�� BP �Y$R stsjkR$R�

���YBI

q�s`�{�B�$�R BP �Y� ���t��k %�Y${j� b��� {B8}Z��I ZRT$t� �Y� q�s`�{�B�k 7$8Zjs�$Bt stI VtsjkR$R _�B��s8q7V_�x q7V_ RBj%�R PB� }B$t�T8sRR ��s`�{�B�k }�BATj�8R� qY� {BI� sjjBbR �Y� ABIk s��$�ZI� �B A� I�Tht�I stI $t{jZI�R �Y� sA$j$�k �B I�ht� s��BIkts8${ stI}�B}ZjR$Bt 8BI�jR BP s�A$��s�k {B8}j�-$�k� *Z�$t� �Y����t��k }�B{�RR� �Y� s��BIkts8${ }s�s8����R s�� h�R�{Ys�s{���$9�I Ak P��� 8Bj�{Zjs� 4Bb� qY� {BI� �Y�tsjjBbR �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt �B PBjjBb s ��sIZsj ��stR$�$Bt �B{Bt�$tZZ8 4Bb sR �Y� Rs��jj$�� I�R{�tIR $t�B �Y� I�tR��}s��R BP �Y� s�8BR}Y���� qYZR� I�R}$�� A�$t� s �Y���I�����TBPTP���IB8 8BI�j� q7V_ {st ��j$sAjk R$8Zjs����s`�{�B�$�R PB� stk %�Y${j� Ys%$t� }��I${�sAj� ABIk IkTts8${R� y� YsR A��t ZR�I PB� 8stk �k}�R BP s��BR}s{�%�Y${j�R RZ{Y sR s$�{�sP�� �B{,�� ABBR���R� R}s{�{�sP� stI���t��k %�Y${j�R� q7V_ �tsAj�R sR 8stk sR �� ��s`�{T�B�k R��8�t�R �B A� I�ht�I R$t{� s �$%�t 8$RR$Bt }�Bhj�8$�Y� ��JZ$�� s %�Y${j� �B sRRZ8� R�%��sj {Bth�Z�s�$BtRstI �Z$Ist{� R��s���$�R� 3B� �Y$R R�ZIk� q7V_ bsR �ZtBt 7Zt bB�,R�s�$BtR�VR }s�� BP �Y� }BR�T}�B{�RR$t� }�B{�IZ��� s��BIkT

ts8${ I�s� {B�^{$�t�R b��� BA�s$t�I P�B8 s R$8}j��R�$8s�$Bt PZt{�$BtE BP �Y� PB�8U

g; )�zL (3((M

�z L(3(�wg*,P8 �g*,{Bt�D L g* ,{Bt� 3 wdD

yt eJ� wdD� g;,WE ) ;3( stI g;,�Lz0 ) d3d��qY� {Bt%�{�$%� Y�s� ��stRP�� �B �Y� R�s�ts�$BtT}B$t�

sjBt� ��s`�{�B�$�R BP �Y� ���t��k %�Y${j�bsR {sj{Zjs��IZR$t���M

�R� )d�E((

p](3x

w'

'CU

W(3x wJ

Jg5

Wn3dx

3 w1D

qY� �&�{�$%� tBR� �sI$ZR PB� 4s� I$R, bsR �R�$8s��IZR$t�M��

p],�& ) d3EE�;4s�I$R, 3 wnD

3$tsjjk� Y$�Y ��8}��s�Z��R $t Y$�YTR}��I s�8BR}Y��${4$�Y� ��JZ$�� �Ys� �Y� }�B}���$�R A�Y$tI s RYB{, bs%�8ZR� A� BA�s$t�I ZR$t� st �JZ$j$A�$Z8 {Y�8${sjjk ��s{�T$t� s$� 8BI�j $tR��sI BP s {sjB�${sjjk }��P�{� s$� 8BI�j�qY� ��8}��s�Z�� stI I�tR$�k �s�$BR $t �Y� RYB{, jsk��sjBt� RB8� ��s`�{�B�k }B$t�R b��� BA�s$t�I P�B8 �Y���RZj�R BP <ZA��d(�dd �Ys� �$%� �Y� %s�$s�$BtR BP RYB{,��8}��s�Z�� stI I�tR$�k b$�Y %�jB{$�k stI sj�$�ZI��qY� �JZ$j$A�$Z8 {B8}BR$�$Bt BP s$� s� �Y� {B���R}BtI$t���8}��s�Z�� stI I�tR$�k BP �Y� RYB{, jsk�� bsR {B8T}Z��I ZR$t� �Y� ]eV {BI��d1

s� ist��

A� q$8� BP I�R{�t�

3$�Z�� 1U q�s`�{�B�$�R BP }skjBsI ��{B%��k %�Y${j� b$�YI$&���t� I$R, s��sR�

i�RZj�R

7$t�j� *$R,

7B8� R�j�{��I ��RZj�R s�� }��R�t��I Y��� PB� s 11E�M ,�wx(( jA8D %�Y${j� s� �d�; ,8 wn(( ,P�D sj�$�ZI�� s %�TjB{$�k BP ��nd ,8\R w1; ,P�\RD stI s 4$�Y� }s�Y st�j�BP 9��B I��� qY� {sj{Zjs�$BtR b��� IBt� PB� s R$t�j�I$R, b$�Y s��sR BP C��W ) �3n, dM3E, 1�3�, n�31 81

wd((, 1((, n((, ;(( P�1D� 3B� �Y� }��R�t� }��j$8$ts�kstsjkR$R� s R$t�j� I$R, bsR ZR�I �B ��}��R�t� �Y� 8Zj�$T}j�� �stI�8 I$R,R� qY� ��s`�{�B�k BP s }Z��jk Asjj$R�${���t��k %�Y${j� b$�Y s Asjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t� Pbwg;CD )d(( bsR sjRB {B8}Z��I PB� ��t��sj {B88}s�$RBt� qY�$t$�$sj {BtI$�$BtR PB� �Y$R %�Y${j� b��� sRRZ8�I �Y� Rs8�sR �YBR� BP �Y� }skjBsI ��{B%��k %�Y${j��3$�Z�� 1 $R s {B8}s�$RBt BP {sj{Zjs��I ��s`�{�B�$�R

PB� �s{Y I$R, bY$j� 3$�� n RYBbR �Y� %�jB{$�kTsj�$�ZI�8s}R stI %�jB{$�k Y$R�B�$�R� qY� I$R, b$�Y �Y� js���R�s��s YsI �Y� 8BR� s��BIkts8${ I�s� stI� �Y���PB����Y� 8BR� R�%��� $t$�$sj I�{�j��s�$Bt w3$�� nAD� qY�js��� s��BIkts8${ I�s� k$�jI�I �Y� RYB���R� IBbt�st��w3$�� 1sD AZ� sjRB �Y� jBt��R� I�B�A$� �$8� w3$�� 1AD�

n

Page 4: sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

3B� �Y� }Z��jk Asjj$R�${ ���t��k {sR�� �Y� js{, BP s��BIkTts8${ I�s� k$�jI�I �Y� jBt��R� IBbt�st�� AZ� sjRB �Y�RYB���R� I�TB�A$� �$8��qY� ��t�j�� I�R{�t� b$�Y I�{�j��s�B� I$R,R $R �-}�{��I

�B k$�jI jBb�� {Bt%�{�$%� Y�s� ��stRP�� �s��R� qY$R {stA� R��t $t 3$�� ;� qY� 8BR� R�%��� Y�s�$t� $R �t{BZtT����I Ak �Y� R8sjj�R� I$R,� <Bb�%��� PB� sjj �Y� PBZ�I$R,R� �Y� }�s, Y�s�$t� $R Ps� jBb�� �Yst �Y� }Z��jk AsjTj$R�${ ���t��k {sR� s� sABZ� xud( }��{�t� BP �Y� js�����qY� }�s, Y�s�$t� {BtI$�$Bt B{{Z�R �s�jk $t �Y� ��s`�{T�B�k� bY�t �Y� Ikts8${ }��RRZ�� $R R�$jj jBb� *�}jBk$t�$t4s�sAj� s��BIkts8${ I�{�j��s�B�R $t Ne! $R �Y���PB��A�t�h{$sj P�B8 s Y�s� ��stRP�� R�stI}B$t�� <Bb�%����Y$R $R sjRB �Y� 8B8�t� BP �Y� 8BR� R�%��� I�{�j��s�$Bt�qY$R $R {j�s�jk �%$I�t� $t s }jB� BP �Y� �B�sj �TjBsI$t�w3$�� xD� �B��B%��� $� {st A� R��t �Ys� �Y� �TjBsI$t�PB� �Y� PBZ� I$R,R s�� BP R$8$js� 8s�t$�ZI� stI �Y�$�}�s,R s�� tB� R$�t$h{st�jk jBb�� �Yst �Y� Asjj$R�${ ���tT��k {sR�� A�$t� Btjk sABZ� d( }��{�t� jBb�� �Yst �Ys��Y� js����� qY� }�s, jBsI$t� B{{Z�R IZ�$t� s �$8� bY�t�Y� sj�$�ZI� I�{��sR�R �s}$Ijk stI �Y� }skjBsI �t���R�Y� jBb�� s�8BR}Y���� !t� {st {Bt{jZI� �Ys� �Y� }�s,s��BIkts8${ �TjBsI$t� $R tB� R$�t$h{st�jk s&�{��I Ak�Y� ZR� BP $t4s�sAj� I�{�j��s�B�R�

7�s��I *$R, *�}jBk8�t�

qbB {sR�R bY��� �Y� I$R, s��s bsR sA�Z}�jk $t{��sR�I�B� R�s��I� b��� sjRB �-s8$t�I� qY$R bsR IBt� �B R$8ZTjs�� �Y� I$&���t� $t���s{�$BtR BP �Y� I�s� }js��R $t P���8Bj�{Zjs� 4Bb wPBZtI $t Ne!D� stI {Bt�$tZZ8 4Bb�t{BZt����I s� jBb�� ��stR$�$Bt sj�$�ZI�R� yt P��� 8Bj�T{Zjs� 4Bb� �Y� h�R� I$R, $t �Y� I�s� }js�� R��$�R $R �Y�Btjk Bt� ��t��s�$t� stk I�s� �&�{�� <Bb�%��� �Y� I�s�{B�^{$�t� PB� s I$R, $t P��� 8Bj�{Zjs� 4Bb wg; � ;3(D$R PBZtI �B A� 8Z{Y Y$�Y�� �Yst s R$t�j� I$R, $t {BtT�$tZZ8 4Bb� !t{� �Y� I�s� }js�� {Bth�Z�s�$Bt w�Y���I$R,R $t R��$�RD ��s{Y�R �Y� {Bt�$tZZ8 4Bb ��stR$�$Btsj�$�ZI�� sjj �Y��� I$R,R ��t��s�� s {B8A$t�I I�s� {B�PTh{$�t� BP g; � n3E� qY� ��RZj�$t� Asjj$R�${ {B�^{$�t���8s$tR �RR�t�$sjjk �Y� Rs8� �Y�BZ�Y �Y� P��� 8Bj�{ZTjs� 4Bb ���$Bt stI $t�B �Y� {Bt�$tZZ8 4Bb ���$Bt� qY�s��s {Yst�� 8BI�jR �st��I P�B8 ��n �B 1��� 81 wd(( �Bn(( P�1D stI P�B8 d1�; �B n��1 81 wdnn �B ;(( P�1D� qY�s��s {Yst�� bsR sRRZ8�I �B B{{Z� $tR�st�jk s� �Y� ��stTR$�$Bt sj�$�ZI�� qY� ��stR$�$Bt sj�$�ZI�R b��� {YBR�t sREM�E� �E�1 stI Mn�M ,8 w11x� 1x(� 1�x ,P�D� qY� ��RZj�Rs�� RYBbt $t 3$�� Eud( PB� �Y� PB�8�� R{Y�8�� i�RZj�RPB� �Y� js���� R{Y�8� s�� JZsj$�s�$%�jk R$8$js� stI s��tB� }��R�t��I PB� A��%$�k�qY� ��RZj�R $tI${s�� �Ys� �Y� �st��� 4$�Y� �$8� B�

R�s�ts�$Bt }B$t� Y�s�$t� s�� tB� 8Z{Y s&�{��I Ak �Y�R�s��I s��s $t{��sR� s� ��stR$�$Bt sj�$�ZI� {B8}s��I �B�Y� {BtR�st� s��s {sR�� 3B� �-s8}j�� 3$�� � $tI${s��Rs IBbt�st�� BP sABZ� d�x(( ,8 PB� �Y� �Y��� I$R, {BtTh�Z�s�$Bt BP R�s��I I�}jBk8�t� s� ��stR$�$Bt sj�$�ZI��bY$j� �Y� IBbt�st�� PB� s I$R, BP {BtR�st� s��s BP ��n81 wd(( P�1D $R sABZ� d�E(( ,8� 3$tsjjk� �Y� �-���8�jkjs��� /TjBsI$t� $R st s��$Ps{� IZ� �B �Y� RZII�t I�{�j��Ts�$Bt R}�{$h�I $t �Y� R$8Zjs�$Bt 8BI�j� qY$R ��RZj� $R�YZR 8�st$t�j�RR R$t{�� $t }�s{�${�� stk R�s��I ��stR$T�$Bt b$jj I�%�jB} 8B�� ��t�jk� qY��� s}}�s�R �B A� tBsI%��R� ��RZj�R bY�t s 8Zj�$}j� I$R, I�s� }js�� {Bth�T

s� zs�$s�$Bt b$�Y sj�$�ZI�

A� zs�$s�$Bt b$�Y �$8�

3$�Z�� nU i��t��k %�jB{$�$�R� w3B� j���tI� R�� 3$�� 1�D

3$�Z�� ;U ]Bt%�{�$%� Y�s� ��stRP�� �s��R� w3B� j���tI�R�� 3$�� 1�D

;

Page 5: sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

3$�Z�� xU qB�sj �TjBsI$t�R� w3B� j���tI� R�� 3$�� 1�D

3$�Z�� EU ist�� PB� R�s��I I$R, I�}jBk8�t�� C ) �3n�dM3E 81 wd((� n(( P�1D�

Z�s�$Bt $R ZR�I %��RZR s R$t�j� js��� I$R,�

e&�{� BP N$P�

qY� }BRR$A$j$�k BP R,$} }s����t ��s`�{�B�$�R bsR �-s8T$t�I b$�Y �Y� $t��BIZ{�$Bt BP j$P� PB�{�R� qY� {sj{ZjsT�$BtR b��� }��PB�8�I b$�Y gU ) (� (�x� d�( PB� s I$R,BP ��n 81 wd(( P�1D� y� bsR �YBZ�Y� �Ys� j$P� b$jj ��RZj�$t s ��t�j�� ��s`�{�B�k� �YZR ��IZ{$t� }�s, Y�s�$t� stI/TjBsI$t��3$�Z�� dd RYBbR �Ys� j$P� R$�t$h{st�jk $t{��sR�R �Y�

IBbt�st�� BP �Y� ���t��k ��s`�{�B�k� V }�B}B��$Bts��jkjs���� RYs�� BP �Y� I�{�j��s�$Bt B{{Z�R s� s Y$�Y�� sj�$T�ZI� w3$�� d1sD� qY$R sjRB ��RZj�R $t s I�{��sR� $t }�s,Y�s�$t� stI /TjBsI$t� {B8}s��I �B �Y� tBtTj$P�$t� {sR��qY�R� ��RZj�R s�� RYBbt $t 3$�R� d; stI dx�

3$�Z�� �U q�s`�{�B�k PB� R�s��I I$R, I�}jBk8�t�� C )�3n� dM3E 81 wd((� n(( P�1D� w3B� j���tI� R�� 3$�� E�D

s� zs�$s�$Bt b$�Y sj�$�ZI�

A� zs�$s�$Bt b$�Y �$8�

3$�Z�� MU i��t��k PB� R�s��I I$R, I�}jBk8�t�� C )�3n� dM3E 81 wd((� n(( P�1D� w3B� j���tI� R�� 3$�� E�D

x

Page 6: sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

3$�Z�� �U 7�s�ts�$Bt }B$t� Y�s�$t� PB� R�s��I I$R, I�T}jBk8�t�� C ) �3n � dM3E 81 wd(( � n(( P�1D� w3B�j���tI� R�� 3$�� E�D

3$�Z�� d(U �TjBsI$t� PB� R�s��I I$R, I�}jBk8�t�� C )�3n� dM3E 81 wd((� n(( P�1D� w3B� j���tI� R�� 3$�� E�D

3$�Z�� ddU ist�� wR,$} ��s`�{�B�kD�

3$�Z�� d1U q�s`�{�B�k wR,$} ��s`�{�B�kD� w3B� j���tI�R�� 3$�� dd�D

s� zs�$s�$Bt b$�Y sj�$�ZI�

A� zs�$s�$Bt b$�Y �$8�

3$�Z�� dnU i��t��k wR,$} ��s`�{�B�kD� w3B� j���tI� R��3$�� dd�D

E

Page 7: sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB ssI i {B% k P B8 ...arc.uta.edu/publications/cp_files/AIAA 2001-0842.pdf · VyVV 1((du(M;1 sq` { B k VtsjkR$R PB 78sjj 7s jj$ kjB_ssI i {B%

3$�Z�� d;U 7�s�ts�$Bt }B$t� Y�s�$t� wR,$} ��s`�{�B�kD�w3B� j���tI� R�� 3$�� dd�D

]Bt{jZR$BtR

Vt �-}jB�s�B�k R�ZIk bsR 8sI� BP �Y� ���t��k ��s`�{�BT�$�R BP s 11� ,� 8sRR s� �d�; ,8 sj�$�ZI� stI s %�jB{$�kBP ��nd ,8\R b$�Y s 8BI$h�I �Y��� I�����TBPTP���IB8��{Yt$JZ�� qY� 8sRR stI I�{�j��s�B� b��� 8BI�j�I sR sR$t�j� {$�{Zjs� I$R, tB�8sj �B �Y� 4$�Y� I$��{�$Bt� qY�IBbt�st�� I�{��sR�I stI �Y� �$8� BP 4$�Y� $t{��sR�Ib$�Y I�{�j��s�B� s��s� qY� R�s�ts�$BtT}B$t� Y�s� ��stRTP�� �s��R b$�Y I�{�j��s�B�R b��� x �B d( }��{�t� BP �Ys�BP s }Z��jk Asjj$R�${ ���t��k %�Y${j� Ys%$t� s Asjj$R�${ {BT�^{$�t� BP ;�M ,_s wd(( jA\P�1D� �YZR RYBb$t� �Y� sI%stT�s�� BP I�}jBk$t� $t4s�sAj� s��BIkts8${ I�{�j��s�B�R�qY� R�ZIk I$I tB� htI �Ys� �Y� R�s��I I�}jBk8�t� BP�Y� I�{�j��s�B�R ��stR$�$Bt$t� P�B8 P��� 8Bj�{Zjs� 4Bb�B {Bt�$tZZ8 4Bb YsI stk sI%��R� ��RZj�R {B8}s��I�B s R$t�j� js��� I$R, BP {BtR�st� s��s� 3$tsjjk� R,$}��s`�{�B�$�R k$�jI�I Rj$�Y�jk jBb�� R�s�ts�$BtT}B$t� Y�s���stRP�� �Yst �Y� tBtTj$P�$t� {sR�� Z� �Y�k 8sk tB� A�sI%st�s��BZR R$t{� �Y� jBt��� 4$�Y� �$8� bBZjI �-}BR��Y� I�{�j��s�B� �B s jBt��� }��$BI BP Y�s�$t��

V{,tBbj�I��8�t�R

qY$R bB�, bsR }s��jk PZtI�I Ak �Y� =7V3 i�R�s�{YjsAB�s�B�k� �$��jstI V3 � W�b ��-${B� ZtI�� ]BtT��s{� 31�E(dT�MT]T(ddd� qY� sZ�YB�R ��s��PZjjk s{T,tBbj�I�� �Y� sRR$R�st{� BP *�R� q$8B�Yk s���j stI�$,Ys$j psjj$R BP 7stI$s Ws�$Btsj NsAB�s�B�$�R� VjAZTJZ��JZ�� W�b ��-${B� PB� 8s,$t� �Y� q7V_ {BI� s%s$jTsAj��

i�P���t{�R

e�B�jj�� <� <�� �I�� <stIABB, BP VR��BtsZ�${sj et�$t���T$t�� �{p�sbT<$jj� W�b OB�,� d�Ed�

3�ts{,�� q� G�� $-Ak� <� G�� eb$t�� e� p�� Xi�{B%T��k 7kR��8R *�R$�t pZ$I��" V33*NTqiT�MTdxd� V$� 3B�{�3$�Y� *kts8${R NsAB�s�B�k� G_V3 � !<� *�{�8A�� d��M�

3$�Z�� dxU /TjBsI$t� wR,$} ��s`�{�B�kD� w3B� j���tI� R��3$�� dd�D

n<B��t��� 7� 3�� 3jZ$IT*kts8${ *�s�� <B��t�� _ZAj$RY$t���$IjstI _s�,� WF� d�xM�

< ��tI�� i� F�� *�G��R�� F� <�� X*�s� ]Ys�s{���$R�${R BP7�%��sj qbBT BIk 7kR��8R s� q�stRBt${ stI 7Z}��RBt${7}��IR�" iq*Tq*iTEnT;11E� V$� 3B�{� 3$�Y� *kts8${RNsAB�s�B�k� G_V3 � !<� *�{�8A�� d�E;�

x!Z�,s� *� e�� X=R��:R �stZsj PB� �Y� q�s`�{�B�k 7$8ZjsT�$Bt stI VtsjkR$R _�B��s8 wq7V_D�" 7VW* MMTndxM� FZjkd��(�

E s���j� q� F�� Ps{R$8$j� tB�� �B Ns��k �{Wsk� 7stI$s WsT�$Btsj NsAB�s�B�$�R� FZt� dx� d����

�*���s� i� G�� ��8}� W� <� stI i$II�j� 3� i�� XVII�tTIZ8 �B <�s� q�stRP�� �B 7s��jj$�� z�Y${j�R i��t���$t� �Y�V�8BR}Y����" F�� _�B}ZjR$Bt� zBj� 1�� WB� d1� }}� d1xEud1x�� *�{�8A�� d�x��

M ���$t� F� F�� <k}��RBt${ V��B�Y��8BIkts8${R� VyVVeIZ{s�$Bt 7��$�R� VyVV� d��;�

� B$RBt� F� ]� stI ]Z��$RR� <� V�� XVt e-}��$8�t�sj ytT%�R�$�s�$Bt BP jZt� BIk 7�s�ts�$Bt _B$t� z�jB{$�k p�sI$T�t��" Vi7 FBZ�tsj� zBj� 1�� WB� 1� }}� dn(T(dnx� 3�A�Zs�kd�x��

e+<ZA��� _� G�� X<k}��RBt${ 7YB{,T<�s��I 3jBb _s�s8�T���R PB� z�jB{$�$�R �B ;E�((( 3��� }�� 7�{BtI stI Vj�$�ZI�R�B n1n�((( 3����" WV7V qi iTdEn� *�{�8A�� d�En�

eeVtI��RBt� F� *�� <k}��RBt${ stI <$�Y q�8}��s�Z�� psRTIkts8${R� �{p�sbT<$jj� d�M��

e3pB�IBt� 7� stI �{ �$I�� � F�� X]B8}Z��� _�B��s8PB� ]sj{Zjs�$Bt BP ]B8}j�- ]Y�8${sj eJZ$j$A�$Z8 ]B8}BTR$�$BtR stI V}}j${s�$BtR u y� VtsjkR$R�" WV7VTi_Tdndd� !{T�BA�� d��;�